{"case_name": "case_102", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_103", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' dates of birth and places of residence are given in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "At the material time, the first applicant was a chairman of the Sumgait city branch of the opposition party Musavat.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "At the material time, the fourth applicant was a deputy chairman of the Goychay district branch of the opposition party Musavat.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "At the material time, the third applicant was a member of the opposition party the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "At the material time, the second applicant was a member of the Coordination Council of an opposition group İctimai Palata.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "According to the applicants, they participated in a number of peaceful demonstrations organised by the opposition.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The number of opposition demonstrations increased in 2011.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The tendency of increasing opposition demonstrations continued into the years following 2011.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "A demonstration was held on 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "A demonstration was held on 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "A demonstration was held on 20 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The second applicant attended the demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The first applicant attended the demonstration of 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The third applicant attended the demonstration of 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the first applicant, he also intended to participate in the demonstration of 20 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Prior to the demonstration of 2 April 2011, on 18 March 2011, the organisers gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Prior to the demonstration of 17 April 2011, on 11 April 2011, the organisers gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Prior to the demonstration of 20 October 2012, on 15 October 2012, the organisers gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) refused to authorise the demonstrations at the places indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) proposed a different location on the outskirts of Baku — the grounds of a driving school situated in the 20th residential area of the Sabail District — as an alternative venue for the demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The organisers decided to hold the demonstrations as originally planned, notwithstanding the Baku City Executive Authority's refusal to authorise the demonstrations at the places indicated.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the applicants, the demonstrations were intended to be peaceful and were conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The participants in the demonstrations were demanding democratic reforms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The participants in the demonstrations were demanding free and fair elections.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The participants in the demonstrations were protesting against impediments on freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The fourth applicant was one of the organisers of a rally planned by several opposition parties.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The rally organised by several opposition parties was planned to be held on 18 October 2011 in Goychay.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The fourth applicant intended to participate in the rally planned for 18 October 2011 in Goychay.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the fourth applicant, on 9 October 2011, he and the other organisers gave notice of the rally of 18 October 2011 to the Goychay District Executive Authority (the GDEA).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The information about the rally of 18 October 2011 was sent to the Goychay District Executive Authority (the GDEA) by post.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The fourth applicant's home address was indicated (for reference) as the address of the sender in the notice sent to the Goychay District Executive Authority (the GDEA).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the fourth applicant, the rally planned for 18 October 2011 in Goychay was intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to the fourth applicant, the purpose of the rally planned for 18 October 2011 in Goychay was to mark the twentieth anniversary of the Independence Day of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the fourth applicant, the purpose of the rally planned for 18 October 2011 in Goychay was to honour the memory of those buried in the Cemetery of Martyrs in the town of Goychay.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "It appears that the rally planned for 18 October 2011 in Goychay eventually did not take place.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The second applicant attended the demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The first applicant attended the demonstration of 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The third applicant attended the demonstration of 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The police began to disperse the demonstration of 2 April 2011 as soon as the protesters began to gather.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The police began to disperse the demonstration of 17 April 2011 as soon as the protesters began to gather.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The circumstances related to the dispersal of the demonstration of 2 April 2011, the second applicant's arrest and custody, and subsequent administrative proceedings against the second applicant are similar to those in Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The circumstances related to the dispersal of the demonstration of 17 April 2011, the first and third applicants' arrests and custody, and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first and third applicants are similar to those in Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Further details regarding the first, second and third applicants' arrests, custody and administrative proceedings are given in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The circumstances of the fourth applicant's arrest on 15 October 2011, custody and subsequent administrative proceedings against the fourth applicant are similar to those in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (nos. 67360/11 and 2 others, 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The circumstances of the first applicant's arrest on 20 October 2012, custody and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant are similar to those in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (nos. 67360/11 and 2 others, 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Further details regarding the fourth and first applicants' arrests on 15 October 2011 and 20 October 2012 respectively, their custody and administrative proceedings are given in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to the first applicant, after being arrested during the dispersal of the demonstration of 17 April 2011 and brought to a police station, he was subjected to ill-treatment by the deputy chief of the Nasimi District Police Office, police officer S.N.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "According to the third applicant, after being arrested during the dispersal of the demonstration of 17 April 2011 and brought to a police station, he was subjected to ill-treatment by the deputy chief of the Nasimi District Police Office, police officer S.N.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The first applicant submitted to the Court a photograph allegedly taken after his police custody in which he is shown with a bruise on his forehead.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The first applicant submitted to the Court a photograph allegedly taken before his police custody in which he is shown without any bruising on his forehead.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The third applicant submitted to the Court a medical report dated 18 April 2011 confirming that he had a broken rib.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "According to the third applicant, the medical report of 18 April 2011 was issued when he was taken to a hospital after his trial, before he was placed in a detention facility to serve his sentence.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The third applicant submitted to the Court a photograph in which he is shown with bruises on his body.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The first and third applicants raised their ill-treatment complaints during the administrative proceedings following their arrest on 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In their appeals against the first-instance court's decisions, the first and third applicants complained to the Baku Court of Appeal that they had been ill-treated during their police custody.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "In their appeals against the first-instance court's decisions, the first and third applicants requested the Baku Court of Appeal to order a forensic examination of their injuries.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In their appeals against the first-instance court's decisions, the first and third applicants requested the Baku Court of Appeal to question particular witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "In their appeals against the first-instance court's decisions, the first and third applicants requested the Baku Court of Appeal to obtain the review of the medical records drawn up at their check-in to the detention facility where they had served their sentence.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 21 April 2011, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the first applicant's appeal and upheld the decision of the first-instance court (see Appendix).", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 4 May 2011, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the third applicant's appeal and upheld the decision of the first-instance court (see Appendix).", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal disregarded the first and third applicants' ill-treatment complaints and their requests related to those complaints.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On an unspecified date, the first and third applicants lodged a complaint before the General Prosecutor's Office of Azerbaijan asking it to conduct an investigation into the alleged ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On unspecified dates, the first and third applicants were summoned to the Nasimi District prosecutor's office and questioned in connection with their complaint of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 23 May 2011, investigator M.H. adopted a decision refusing to open criminal proceedings into allegations of ill-treatment in respect of the third applicant.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 2 July 2011, investigator M.H. adopted a decision refusing to open criminal proceedings into allegations of ill-treatment in respect of the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "According to the first and third applicants, for a certain period of time neither they nor their lawyer were informed about any actions taken by the authorities to investigate their ill-treatment complaints.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "According to the first and third applicants, only in January 2012, after making enquiries about the outcome of the investigation, did they manage to obtain copies of investigator M.H.'s decisions of 23 May 2011 and 2 July 2011 refusing to open criminal proceedings into allegations of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The first and third applicants did not lodge a complaint with a supervising court against investigator M.H.'s decisions refusing to open criminal proceedings into allegations of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The first and third applicants' allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Law no. 135-IVQD of 31 May 2011 introduced amendments to the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 (the CAO), which entered into force on 1 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "After the amendments introduced by Law no. 135-IVQD of 31 May 2011, Article 410.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 provided that a copy of the administrative offence report shall be given to an individual who is subject to the administrative offence proceedings or to a representative of a legal entity.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "After the amendments introduced by Law no. 135-IVQD of 31 May 2011, Article 410.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 provided that an aggrieved person in administrative offence proceedings has the right to a copy of the administrative offence report.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "A summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, relevant provisions concerning freedom of assembly, the organisation and holding of public assemblies, and relevant extracts from international documents and press releases can be found in the judgment in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (nos. 67360/11 and 2 others, 11 February 2016, §§ 56-77).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "A summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, relevant provisions concerning freedom of assembly, the organisation and holding of public assemblies, and relevant extracts from international documents and press releases can also be found in the judgment in Ibrahimov and Others v. Azerbaijan (nos. 69234/11 and 2 others, §§ 44-59, 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F022", "F027", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F044", "F045"], "interference": ["F039", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F044", "F045"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F004", "F005", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F039", "F040", "F044", "F045"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F009", "F010", "F022", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F039"], "interference": ["F039", "F040", "F044", "F045"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F023", "F039", "F040", "F044", "F045"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F009", "F010", "F022", "F023", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F044", "F045"]}} {"case_name": "case_104", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1982.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "At the material time the applicant was a member of an opposition party called Musavat.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant attempted to participate in a demonstration organised by the opposition on 20 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Prior to the assembly of 20 October 2012, on 15 October 2012, the organisers gave notice to the relevant authority, the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) refused to authorise the holding of the demonstration at the place indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) proposed a different location for the demonstration on the outskirts of Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Despite the Baku City Executive Authority's refusal to authorise the demonstration at the originally indicated place, the organisers decided to hold the demonstration as planned.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstration of 20 October 2012 was intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstration of 20 October 2012 was conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The participants in the demonstration of 20 October 2012 were demanding democratic reforms in the country.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant had intended to attend the demonstration of 20 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant and a few others attempted to march from the headquarters of the Musavat party to the place where the assembly of 20 October 2012 was being held.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Shortly after the applicant's attempt to march to the assembly on 20 October 2012, he was arrested and taken to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the applicant, he was arrested on 20 October 2012 by people in plain clothes.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 6 May 2014 the applicant participated in an assembly that took place near the Baku Court of Serious Crimes.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The assembly of 6 May 2014 near the Baku Court of Serious Crimes was held in support of members of an opposition group called Nida, who were being tried on that day.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 6 May 2014 the courtroom of the Baku Court of Serious Crimes was full, so some people were waiting outside the court for the outcome of the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "When the Baku Court of Serious Crimes announced its judgment on 6 May 2014, those who had gathered outside began to protest against the judgment, which they considered unfair.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The protest outside the Baku Court of Serious Crimes on 6 May 2014 was brief, spontaneous and peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "As soon as the protesters outside the Baku Court of Serious Crimes on 6 May 2014 started chanting slogans, police officers and people in plain clothes began to forcibly disperse the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant was arrested during the dispersal operation of the assembly outside the Baku Court of Serious Crimes on 6 May 2014.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "After his arrest on 6 May 2014, the applicant was taken to a police station, where he was kept overnight.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "In both cases (20 October 2012 and 6 May 2014), on the day of the applicant's arrest, an administrative-offence report (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) was issued in respect of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "In the first case (20 October 2012), the administrative-offence report stated that by deliberately failing to comply with a lawful order of the police, the applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "In the second case (6 May 2014), the applicant was charged with an administrative offence under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO), which concerns participation in a public assembly that had not been organised in accordance with the law.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with copies of the administrative-offence reports in his case files in either case.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with other documents in his case files in either case.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "In both cases (20 October 2012 and 6 May 2014), the applicant was not given access to a lawyer after his arrest or while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "In the second case (6 May 2014), according to a document drawn up by a police officer and an order dated 6 May 2014, a State-funded lawyer (Mr S.A.) was instructed to assist the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "In the first case, the applicant was brought before the Binagadi District Court on 20 October 2012, the day of his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "In the second case, the applicant was brought before the Nasimi District Court on 7 May 2014, the day following his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing before the court in both cases (before the Binagadi District Court on 20 October 2012 and before the Nasimi District Court on 7 May 2014) was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the applicant, members of the public, including human rights defenders and journalists, were not allowed to attend the hearings in either case, even though the court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearing to the public.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "According to the applicant, in neither case was he given an opportunity to hire a lawyer of his own choice for the first-instance court hearings.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "In both cases (before the Binagadi District Court on 20 October 2012 and before the Nasimi District Court on 7 May 2014), State-funded lawyers were appointed to assist the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "In the second case (before the Nasimi District Court on 7 May 2014), the State-funded lawyer appointed to assist the applicant was Mr S.A., the same lawyer who had been instructed to assist the applicant in accordance with the document of 6 May 2014 drawn up by a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the records of the court hearings in both cases, in their oral submissions the State-funded lawyers briefly stated that the applicant was not guilty.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the records of the court hearings in both cases, in their oral submissions the State-funded lawyers asked the respective court to discontinue the case.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "In both cases, the only witnesses questioned during the court hearing were police officers who, according to the official records, had arrested the applicant or prepared an administrative-offence report on him.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The police officer witnesses in both cases testified that the applicant had staged an unauthorised protest.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "In both cases, the first-instance court found that the applicant had failed to stop participating in an unauthorised protest.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "By a decision of 20 October 2012, the Binagadi District Court convicted the applicant under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) and sentenced him to ten days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "By a decision of 7 May 2014, the Nasimi District Court convicted the applicant under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) and sentenced him to fifteen days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On unspecified dates the applicant lodged appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal against his convictions in both cases.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In his appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant argued that his convictions were in violation of his rights because the assemblies in which he had participated or attempted to participate had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In his appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal in the second case (6 May 2014), the applicant additionally argued that the assembly had been spontaneous.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "In his appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant complained that his arrests had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In his appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant complained that the hearings before the respective first-instance courts had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In both cases, the applicant was assisted before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 29 October 2012, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal in the first case and upheld the decision of the Binagadi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 16 May 2014, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal in the second case and upheld the decision of the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "At the time of both of the applicant's arrests (20 October 2012 and 6 May 2014), under Article 5 § IV of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, no prior written notification was required for spontaneous assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 20 October 2012, Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (CAO) provided that any breach of the rules, set forth under the legislation, on the organisation and holding of assemblies, demonstrations, protests, marches and pickets shall be punishable by a reprimand or a fine of seven to thirteen manats (AZN).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 20 October 2012, Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (CAO) provided that deliberate failure by an individual to comply with a lawful order of a police officer or military serviceman carrying out their duties to protect public order shall be punishable by a fine of twenty to twenty-five manats (AZN) or, if that sanction is inadequate in the circumstances of the case and taking into account the character of the offender, by administrative detention for a term of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 entered into force on 1 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced new wording to Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) concerning breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Under the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, participation in an assembly organised in breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies became explicitly punishable under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced for the first time a punishment in the form of administrative detention of up to fifteen days under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced community service as a new form of punishment under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 increased the fine for breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies, fixing the amounts as follows: between AZN 300 and 600 for participants of an assembly; between AZN 1,500 and 3,000 for individuals who organise an assembly; between AZN 3,000 and 6,000 for persons in charge (vəzifəli şəxslər) who organise an assembly; and between AZN 15,000 and 30,000 for legal entities involved in the organisation of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Law no. 651-IVQD of 14 May 2013 entered into force on 5 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Law no. 651-IVQD of 14 May 2013 increased the administrative-detention sentence set out in Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) to up to two months.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Law no. 457-IVQD of 2 November 2012 entered into force on 29 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Law no. 457-IVQD of 2 November 2012 increased the fine in Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) to AZN 200.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Law no. 651-IVQD of 14 May 2013 increased the administrative-detention sentence in Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) to up to one month.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, titled 'The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan', stated that there is no political dialogue with the opposition parties outside parliament in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about the restrictive climate for the activities of the extra-parliamentary opposition in Azerbaijan, which complains about limitations imposed on freedom of expression and freedom of assembly and the lack of access to the public media.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the establishment of an inclusive political system and a truly competitive and unrestrictive political environment in Azerbaijan requires full implementation of basic freedoms, including freedom of expression, freedom of assembly and freedom of association.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed deep concern about the situation regarding basic freedoms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about recently adopted amendments to the Criminal Code and the Administrative Code of Azerbaijan, which increased penalties for the organisers of, and participants in, 'unauthorised' gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that, considering the authorities' ongoing blanket ban on protests in the Baku city centre, the amendments to the Criminal Code and the Administrative Code of Azerbaijan are likely to have a further negative impact on freedom of assembly and freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about the restrictive use of certain articles of the Criminal Code of Azerbaijan, in particular Articles 221 and 233, against participants in peaceful, albeit unauthorised, demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 was authored by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "In the Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe expressed deep concern about recent amendments to the Law on Freedom of Assembly, the Criminal Code and the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan, which further erode the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "In the Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe stated that the sanctions which can now be imposed in Azerbaijan, coupled with the fact that local authorities have not authorised a single rally in Baku city centre in recent years, clearly have a chilling effect on the organisation of or participation in demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "In the Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe expressed the view that participants in peaceful assemblies should not be sanctioned for the mere fact of being present at and actively participating in the demonstration in question, provided they do not do anything illegal, violent or obscene in the course of it.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "In the Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe urged the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure that no disproportionate sanction, which would undermine the fundamental right to peaceful assembly, is imposed.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "A summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, the relevant provisions concerning the organisation and holding of public assemblies, and the relevant extracts of international documents can be found in the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, paragraphs 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["national_security", "public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F012", "F013", "F043", "F016", "F022", "F044", "F009", "F010", "F020"], "interference": ["F014", "F021", "F022", "F043", "F044"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F006", "F007", "F054", "F055", "F025", "F043", "F005", "F006", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F053"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F009", "F010", "F011", "F020", "F021", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F003", "F071", "F072", "F076"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F016", "F009", "F010", "F020"], "interference": ["F014", "F021", "F022", "F043", "F044"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F005", "F006", "F025", "F053", "F019", "F020"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F009", "F010", "F020", "F021", "F042", "F043", "F044"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F009", "F010", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F053", "F005"]}} {"case_name": "case_106", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_107", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_108", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The present case concerns the first applicant's static demonstration in November 2009.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The present case concerns the first applicant's prosecution for an administrative offence related to his static demonstration in November 2009.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The present case concerns the interception of the applicants' telephone communications.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The Government were initially represented by Mr G. Matyushkin, Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr M. Galperin, Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Government were latterly represented by Mr M. Vinogradov, Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights, as successor to Mr M. Galperin in that office.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Between 2005 and 2012 the applicants worked for the Gelendzhik Human Rights Centre.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The first applicant was a registered private entrepreneur.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Among their various activities, the applicants were involved in locating unlawfully constructed buildings in the town of Gelendzhik and reporting them to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "In the absence of an adequate response from the authorities, the applicants would initiate various proceedings before the civil or commercial courts.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicants also had recourse to other actions, such as demonstrations (see also Achilov and Others v. Russia [Committee], nos. 10780/07 and 54004/07, 9 June 2020).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On an unspecified date the second applicant was arrested on suspicion of a criminal offence.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 55674/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The first applicant submitted a notice to the Gelendzhik municipality notifying them of his intention to hold a static demonstration on 26 November 2009 near the town office of the Federal Security Service (FSB).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 55674/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The notice submitted by the first applicant to the Gelendzhik municipality specified that the event's goal was to draw the public's attention to the allegedly unlawful arrest of the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 55674/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 23 November 2009, referring to section 12 § 2 of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) and Article 294 of the Criminal Code, the Gelendzhik municipality issued a warning document to the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 55674/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The warning document issued by the Gelendzhik municipality on 23 November 2009 invited the first applicant to abstain from holding the planned demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 55674/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The warning document issued by the Gelendzhik municipality on 23 November 2009 indicated that if the demonstration were to be held, the first applicant and participants might be held liable.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 55674/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 26 November 2009 the first applicant held the demonstration as planned.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 55674/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "By a judgment of 15 December 2009, a justice of the peace convicted the first applicant under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 55674/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The justice of the peace sentenced the first applicant to a fine of 2,000 Russian roubles (approximately 45 euros at the time).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 55674/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The justice of the peace held that the first applicant had committed a breach of public order on account of his failure to abstain from holding the demonstration despite the lawful warning document issued by the Gelendzhik municipality.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 55674/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The justice of the peace stated that the first applicant's actions amounted to 'putting pressure on justice in relation to a specific criminal case'.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 55674/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 20 January 2010 the Gelendzhik Town Court of the Krasnodar Region upheld the judgment of 15 December 2009 convicting the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 55674/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Gelendzhik Town Court of the Krasnodar Region stated that the goal of the first applicant's demonstration amounted to indirect interference with the administration of justice in the criminal case against Mr Ivanov.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 55674/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "By two decisions of 3 October 2011, an unspecified judge of Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk authorised the tapping of the applicants' conversations on three mobile telephone numbers.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The authorisation for tapping the applicants' conversations on three mobile telephone numbers was granted from 3 October 2011 for 180 days.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The decision of 3 October 2011 in respect of the second applicant mentioned that, according to information held by the FSB office of the Krasnodar Region, the second applicant was the subject of investigative file no. 543 (дело оперативного учета).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The decision of 3 October 2011 in respect of the second applicant mentioned that data obtained in respect of him indicated that he had been involved in the organisation of an extremist community, which is an offence under Article 282.1 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 20 February 2012 the applicants were arrested in relation to unrelated criminal proceedings concerning fraud charges under Article 159 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 18 April 2012 the court extended the first applicant's detention.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 16 May 2012 the appeal court heard representations from the prosecutor and upheld the extension of the first applicant's detention.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicants learnt about the tapping of their telephone communications in June 2012 when they studied the material in the case file concerning the criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The criminal case file did not contain the decisions of 3 October 2011 authorising the tapping of the applicants' telephone communications.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 8 October 2012 the Krasnodar Regional Court declassified the decisions of 3 October 2011 authorising the tapping of the applicants' telephone communications.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "During the trial, the prosecutor submitted two documents that appeared to be excerpts from the decisions of 3 October 2011 authorising the tapping of the applicants' telephone communications.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The two documents submitted by the prosecutor during the trial did not bear the name of the authorising judge or the official seal of the authorising court.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "At a court hearing on 27 November 2012 the prosecutor requested the trial court to require the FSB to submit the decisions of 3 October 2011 authorising the tapping of the applicants' telephone communications.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 27 November 2012 the FSB submitted photocopies of the decisions of 3 October 2011 authorising the tapping of the applicants' telephone communications.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The photocopies of the decisions of 3 October 2011 submitted by the FSB on 27 November 2012 had not been signed by a judge and did not bear the official seal of the authorising court.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The photocopies of the decisions of 3 October 2011 submitted by the FSB on 27 November 2012 bore the seal of the FSB office.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "By a judgment of 30 April 2013, the Town Court convicted the applicants as charged.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "In its judgment of 30 April 2013, the Town Court held that the interception of the applicants' communications had been lawful and thus the records could be relied on as evidence.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "In its judgment of 30 April 2013, the Town Court held that no circumstance was identified for rejecting the records of intercepted communications as inadmissible evidence.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "In its judgment of 30 April 2013, the Town Court rejected the defendants' argument that the records of the intercepted telephone communications should not be used in evidence because during the preliminary investigation the investigator did not receive court decisions authorising the interception.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In its judgment of 30 April 2013, the Town Court rejected the defendants' argument that the records of the intercepted telephone communications should not be used in evidence because the court decisions did not bear the seal of the authorising court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Town Court noted in its judgment of 30 April 2013 that authorities carrying out operational-search activities rely on the Operational-Search Activities Act and the Instruction of 17 April 2007 on providing the operational-search activities results to an enquirer, an investigator, a prosecutor or a court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Town Court noted in its judgment of 30 April 2013 that under section 13 of the Instruction of 17 April 2007, operational-search activities results arising from the interception of telephone communications should be accompanied by a copy of the related court decisions authorising the operational-search activities.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 27 November 2012 the trial court admitted to the file copies of court decisions nos. 706 and 707 dated 3 October 2011 authorising the tapping of the applicants' telephone communications.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Town Court noted in its judgment of 30 April 2013 that an authorised official certified the copies of court decisions nos. 706 and 707 and apposed an appropriate seal.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Town Court held in its judgment of 30 April 2013 that the court decisions were requested and admitted to the file in compliance with Articles 271 and 286 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, section 11 of the Operational-Search Activities Act and paragraphs 11 and 21 of the Instruction of 17 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Town Court held in its judgment of 30 April 2013 that the fact that court decisions nos. 706 and 707 were not handed over to the investigator during the investigation does not tarnish the operational-search activities results.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 13 August 2013 the Krasnodar Regional Court upheld the judgment of 30 April 2013 convicting the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "It appears that in 2015 a request for a review in cassation of the applicants' conviction was dismissed.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "A. Interception of telephone communications"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In February 2013 the FSB informed the second applicant that, pursuant to section 5 of the Operational-Search Activities Act, the second applicant had not at that time acquired the right to have access to the information received in the framework of file no. 543.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "B. The second applicant's enquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The FSB informed the second applicant in February 2013 that he had not acquired the right to access information in file no. 543 because he was not a person whose guilt had not been established in the relevant procedure (by way of a refusal to institute criminal proceedings or to discontinue such proceedings for lack of evidence that a crime had been committed or corpus delicti).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "B. The second applicant's enquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The FSB informed the second applicant in February 2013 that within the measures taken for the purposes of file no. 543, the FSB received information indicating that the second applicant, Mr Achilov, and two others had committed crimes under Article 159 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "B. The second applicant's enquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The FSB informed the second applicant in February 2013 that the relevant material from file no. 543 was transferred to the investigating authority in order to take a decision on whether or not to institute criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "B. The second applicant's enquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The FSB informed the second applicant in February 2013 that criminal proceedings were instituted on 21 February 2012.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "B. The second applicant's enquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The FSB informed the second applicant in February 2013 that it had no other information indicating that the second applicant had committed other offences, for instance under Article 282.1 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "B. The second applicant's enquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "By a letter of 18 November 2013, the President of the Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk informed the second applicant that the court had no information in relation to any operational-search activities in respect of him on the part of FSB officers.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "B. The second applicant's enquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 27 July 2015 the Judiciary Department of the Supreme Court of Russia informed the second applicant that pursuant to paragraph 12.5 of the Instruction on case processing in a district court (adopted by the Judiciary Department of the Supreme Court of Russia in its Decree no. 36 of 29 April 2003), copies of court decisions issued by a court must be certified with the signature of the judge presiding in the relevant case.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "B. The second applicant's enquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Judiciary Department of the Supreme Court of Russia informed the second applicant on 27 July 2015 that if certification by the presiding judge is not possible, copies of court decisions must be certified by the signature of the (deputy) president of the court or another authorised member of personnel, such as a court clerk.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "B. The second applicant's enquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Judiciary Department of the Supreme Court of Russia informed the second applicant on 27 July 2015 that copies of court decisions must bear the official seal of the court.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "B. The second applicant's enquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Judiciary Department of the Supreme Court of Russia informed the second applicant on 27 July 2015 that in order to certify compliance of the copy with the original court decision, it must be stamped 'Copy verified' and the court's seal must appear on the last sheet of the court decision.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "B. The second applicant's enquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 24 August 2015 the FSB's regional office gave a reply similar to that of the Judiciary Department of the Supreme Court of Russia, concluding that the FSB's regional office had no authority to certify copies of court decisions.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "B. The second applicant's enquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 13 July 2016 the FSB's regional office informed one of the applicants' co-defendants that the originals of court decisions nos. 706 and 707 of 3 October 2011 had been kept in file no. 543.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "B. The second applicant's enquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The FSB's regional office informed one of the applicants' co-defendants on 13 July 2016 that in October 2013 file no. 543 had been disposed of, as it no longer had any practical, scientific or historical value.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "B. The second applicant's enquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Between February 2012 and August 2013 the applicants were kept, for varying consecutive periods of time, in the temporary detention centre in Gelendzhik.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Between February 2012 and August 2013 the applicants were kept, for varying consecutive periods of time, in remand centre no. 23/3 in the town of Novorossiysk.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The applicants were held in the temporary detention centre in Gelendzhik or in remand centre no. 23/3 in Novorossiysk because criminal proceedings against them were pending in Gelendzhik.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 54271/12", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Pursuant to Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), a public event may be held in any convenient location, provided that it does not create a risk of building collapse or any other risks to the safety of the participants (section 8 § 1).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Under section 12 § 2 of Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), if the information contained in the notification or other factors give reason to believe that the aims of the public event or the manner of its conduct are contrary to the Constitution, the Criminal Code or the Code of Administrative Offences, the competent regional or municipal authority must warn the organisers in writing that they may be held liable for any unlawful actions, in accordance with the procedure prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "For a summary of the relevant provisions of Federal Law no. 144-FZ of 12 August 1995 (the Operational-Search Activities Act), see Zubkov and Others v. Russia, nos. 29431/05 and 2 others, §§ 43-55, 7 November 2017.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERCEPTION OF TELEPHONE COMMUNICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Under section 9 of Federal Law no. 144-FZ of 12 August 1995 (the Operational-Search Activities Act), a court decision authorising an operational-search activity (such as the interception of telephone communications) must be certified with a seal and handed over to the requesting authority.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERCEPTION OF TELEPHONE COMMUNICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Under section 9 of Federal Law no. 144-FZ of 12 August 1995 (the Operational-Search Activities Act), the administration of the courts must ensure the protection of the data contained in the documents submitted by the requesting authority.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERCEPTION OF TELEPHONE COMMUNICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Under section 12 of Federal Law no. 144-FZ of 12 August 1995 (the Operational-Search Activities Act), a court decision authorising an operational-search activity and the material submitted for making such an order are both kept only by the authority carrying out the operational-search activity.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERCEPTION OF TELEPHONE COMMUNICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "According to the Constitutional Court of Russia, in decision no. 460-O-O of 15 July 2008 (unpublished), operational-search activities results may be used in evidence in criminal proceedings only after a court decision authorising the operational-search activity or a copy of such a decision has been admitted to the criminal case file.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERCEPTION OF TELEPHONE COMMUNICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "According to the Constitutional Court of Russia, in decision no. 1585-O-O of 17 November 2011 (unpublished), section 12 of Federal Law no. 144-FZ of 12 August 1995 (the Operational-Search Activities Act) did not prohibit the defendant having access to the court decision or receiving a copy of the court decision authorising an operational-search activity, and thus did not impede the right to seek judicial review of such a court decision.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERCEPTION OF TELEPHONE COMMUNICATIONS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F024", "F002"], "interference": ["F002", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F072", "F073"], "legitimate_aim": ["F013", "F016", "F017", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025"], "necessity": ["F016", "F017", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F013", "F014", "F015", "F019"], "interference": ["F016", "F017", "F018", "F020"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F016", "F022", "F023", "F025"], "necessity": ["F016", "F022", "F023", "F025"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F014", "F016", "F019", "F020", "F022", "F025"]}} {"case_name": "case_110", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1944.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Lefkoşa, in northern Cyprus, in the area known as the \"Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus\" (\"TRNC\").", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The application concerns the killing of the applicant's husband, Mr Kutlu Adalı, by unknown persons.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant made serious allegations about the involvement of Turkish and/or \"TRNC\" agents in the murder of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant complained of the inadequacy of the investigation launched by the \"TRNC\" authorities into the death of Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant contended that her husband, Mr Kutlu Adalı, had received death threats on several occasions because of his articles and political opinions.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant complained that following the death of her husband she had been subjected to continuing practices of harassment, intimidation and discrimination by the \"TRNC\" authorities.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "In connection with her complaints of harassment, intimidation and discrimination, the applicant referred to several specific incidents.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Government denied all allegations concerning the murder of Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Government maintained that the \"TRNC\" authorities had immediately commenced an investigation into the death of Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Government maintained that the \"TRNC\" authorities had conducted a thorough investigation into the death of Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Government acknowledged that the perpetrators of the crime of killing Kutlu Adalı had not yet been identified.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Government rejected the applicant's allegations of harassment.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Government submitted that the applicant's allegations of harassment were mere speculation.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The facts surrounding the killing of the applicant's husband, Mr Kutlu Adalı, and the alleged practices of harassment, intimidation and discrimination by the \"TRNC\" authorities are disputed between the parties.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The facts as submitted by the applicant are set out in Section 1 of the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The facts as submitted by the Government are contained in Section 2 of the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "A summary of the documents submitted by the parties is to be found in the Annex to the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The witness evidence taken by the Court's Delegates at hearings conducted in Strasbourg and Nicosia is summarised in Part B of the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant's husband, Mr Kutlu Adalı, was a Turkish Cypriot writer and journalist.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı was known for having written and published articles strongly criticising the policies and practices of the Turkish Government and the authorities of the \"TRNC\".", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı had always claimed that Cyprus should not be divided.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı had always claimed that Turkish and Greek Cypriots should live in a united republic based on a pluralist democratic system.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Apart from his writing and journalism, Mr Kutlu Adalı had held various civil service posts in the past.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Between 1961 and 1972 Mr Kutlu Adalı was employed as the private secretary to Mr Rauf Denktaş.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Mr Rauf Denktaş later became the President of the \"TRNC\".", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "In 1972 Mr Kutlu Adalı's salary was suspended because he had wished to write an article about policies of Mr Denktaş with which he disagreed.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "At the time of the salary suspension, Mr Rauf Denktaş wanted Mr Kutlu Adalı to work for a radio station called Bayrak (Flag), which was under the control of the Turkish Resistance Movement.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı refused to work for the Bayrak (Flag) radio station.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı was imprisoned without any charge or trial for one week because of his refusal to work for the Bayrak (Flag) radio station.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "After his release from imprisonment, Mr Kutlu Adalı started to work for the Bayrak radio station in order for his salary to be restored.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "In 1974 Mr Kutlu Adalı was appointed to the post of Head of the Identity Cards Section of the Department for the Registration of the Population.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "In December 1979 Mr Kutlu Adalı was suspended from his post.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı was reinstated in 1986.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "When reinstated in 1986, Mr Kutlu Adalı was given the post of adviser in the Tourist Office of the \"TRNC\".", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı's career as a civil servant ended in 1987, when he was compelled to take early retirement at the age of 50.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "During his public service and after his retirement, Mr Kutlu Adalı continued his career as a writer and journalist.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Initially, Mr Kutlu Adalı wrote under a pseudonym, Kerem Atlı, because it was dangerous for him to express his political views about a unified Cyprus using his real name.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "In 1981 Mr Kutlu Adalı started using his real name in his writing.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "For the last seven years before his death, Mr Kutlu Adalı wrote regularly for Yenidüzen, a left-wing newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicant and her husband received various threats intended to deter Mr Kutlu Adalı from continuing to express his opinions.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Between January 1980 and July 1996, unknown persons subjected Mr Kutlu Adalı to various forms of harassment.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı's house was attacked with machine guns.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı received frequent threatening phone calls.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Unknown people entered Mr Kutlu Adalı's house looking for copies of his articles, in order to be able to start criminal proceedings against him, as he was writing his articles under a pseudonym.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 17 March 1996 the Yenidüzen newspaper printed an article by Kutlu Adalı about an incident in which thieves had broken into a tomb in the monastery of St Barnabas and stolen various objects of cultural significance.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In his article of 17 March 1996, Mr Kutlu Adalı had written that the licence plates and the colour of the thieves' cars had been noted, and the licence plates had been traced as belonging to two members of the Civil Defence Organisation.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "After the publication of the article about the St Barnabas monastery theft, the editor of the Yenidüzen newspaper received a threatening phone call from the head of the Civil Defence Organisation.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "After the publication of the article about the St Barnabas monastery theft, Mr Kutlu Adalı began to receive frequent threatening phone calls.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 4 July 1996 the Yenidüzen newspaper published an article by Mr Kutlu Adalı which strongly criticised the \"Mother Country-Child Country\" policy of the Government of Turkey and of the \"TRNC\".", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 6 July 1996, at around 11.35 p.m., the applicant's husband, Mr Kutlu Adalı, was shot and killed in front of his house in the \"TRNC\" by unknown persons.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The applicant was in Istanbul on the night when her husband, Mr Kutlu Adalı, was killed.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "When the applicant had telephoned her husband at about 11.15 p.m. on 6 July 1996, he had told her that \"they\" had been threatening him.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The \"TRNC\" authorities refused to show the applicant her husband's body.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The applicant was told by the doctor in charge of the mortuary, Dr İsmail Bundak, that no post mortem had been carried out, although the body had been X-rayed.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The applicant was never allowed to see the X-rays of her husband's body.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicant was informed for the first time that a post mortem had been carried out in the Government's observations of 1 April 1999, and a copy of the post-mortem report was provided at that time.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicant attempted to investigate her husband's death herself.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicant found out from her neighbours that shortly before her husband's death, a black car had been parked in the street.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The black car parked in the street shortly before Mr Kutlu Adalı's death was of the same model as the car driven by Altay Sayıl, a retired police officer who had become friendly with the family in the last months of Mr Kutlu Adalı's life.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Retired police officer Altay Sayıl did not appear for ten days following the death of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicant's neighbours told her that around the time her husband had been shot they had heard him begging his killers for his life.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The applicant's neighbours told her that they had heard a man saying that Mr Kutlu Adalı deserved to die.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The applicant's neighbours informed her that the electric lighting in the street outside the applicant's home had gone out at about 10.30 p.m. on the night of the killing, causing the area to be in darkness.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The electric lighting in the street outside the applicant's home had not been switched on again until shortly after Mr Kutlu Adalı had been shot.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The applicant learned from her neighbours that within only a few minutes of the shooting about twelve military cars had arrived and had sealed off the area.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The applicant learned from her neighbours that the \"special teams\" of police officers had threatened the neighbours with guns to force them to go back inside their houses.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 8 July 1996 the pro-\"TRNC\" government newspaper Kıbrıs reported that it had received a statement from a fascist group calling itself the Turkish Revenge Brigade, claiming that it had killed Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "According to the applicant, the Turkish Revenge Brigade is linked to the so-called \"Grey Wolves\", the youth movement of the Turkish Nationalist Movement Party.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "According to the applicant, the \"Grey Wolves\" have close and long-standing links with members of the Turkish armed forces, the Turkish police, the Turkish National Intelligence Service (MIT), the Turkish paramilitary apparatus, Turkish ministers and the Turkish mafia.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Three days after Mr Kutlu Adalı was killed, the applicant's family received a telephone call from an anonymous female caller who gave the names of two individuals she said were responsible for Mr Kutlu Adalı's murder: a Mr Hüseyin Demirci and a man whose first name was Orhan.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The applicant informed the police about the anonymous phone call naming Mr Hüseyin Demirci and a man named Orhan as responsible for Mr Kutlu Adalı's murder.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The police refused to start an investigation based on the anonymous phone call, stating that the woman caller was known for making false allegations to the police.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The applicant discovered that Mr Hüseyin Demirci was a member of the \"Grey Wolves\" and of the Civil Defence Organisation and that the security forces were paying him.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The applicant discovered that the man named Orhan mentioned in the anonymous phone call was a colonel in the Turkish armed forces on the island.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 14 July 1996 the applicant's children arranged a meeting with the President of the \"TRNC\".", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "At the meeting on 14 July 1996, the applicant's children requested the President of the \"TRNC\" to take steps to ensure that effective action was taken to find their father's killer.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "At the meeting on 14 July 1996, the President of the \"TRNC\" promised to take effective action to find Mr Kutlu Adalı's killer.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "On 18 July 1996 the applicant requested President Denktaş that the status of martyr be awarded to Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 9 September 1996 the applicant's request that the status of martyr be awarded to Kutlu Adalı was rejected.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "There have been repeated allegations in the press that a man called Abdullah Çatlı, an extreme right-wing activist linked with the \"Grey Wolves\" and allegedly instructed by some Turkish officials to kill people suspected of being PKK members, was involved in the death of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "According to the applicant's personal information, Abdullah Çatlı had arrived in the \"TRNC\" at the beginning of July 1996 under a false identity.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The applicant contends that in November 1996 she received an invitation from southern Cyprus to receive an award in her husband's name.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The day before the meeting in southern Cyprus, the applicant received a phone call from an official in the \"TRNC Ministry of Foreign Affairs\".", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Being scared by the phone call from the \"TRNC Ministry of Foreign Affairs\" official, the applicant decided not to attend the meeting in southern Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "In December 1996 the applicant went to see the security forces' commander, Mr Hasan Peker Günal, and complained that the security forces were not investigating her husband's death properly.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "On 5 March 1997 the Yenidüzen newspaper published a letter signed by the head of the \"Grey Wolves\", which contained a threat that left-wing journalists and writers would be killed like Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The applicant gave copies of the article containing the threat from the head of the \"Grey Wolves\" to the police to investigate, but she did not receive any response.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "On 26 June 1997 the applicant wrote to the security forces' commander, Mr Hasan Peker Günal, pointing out that nearly one year had passed since her husband's assassination and that the perpetrators had not yet been found.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The applicant did not receive any concrete information in reply to her letter of 26 June 1997 to the security forces' commander, Mr Hasan Peker Günal.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Plain-clothes policemen have constantly been following the applicant and her daughter.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The applicant's and her daughter's phones had been tapped and their correspondence monitored.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The applicant and her daughter received anonymous phone calls.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The applicant's telephone and fax line has been disconnected from time to time.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The applicant submits that she received very few letters of condolence following her husband's death.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The applicant maintains that the water supply of her house has been cut on several occasions and she does not believe that this was due to technical faults as alleged by the Council Water Department.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The \"TRNC\" regime refused to register an association called the \"Kutlu Adalı Foundation\", whose aims include the furthering of the ideas of Kutlu Adalı regarding peace, democracy, human rights and freedom.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The applicant requested permission from the authorities to keep her husband's press card that entitled her to certain privileges, such as discounts for air fares.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The applicant's request to keep her husband's press card was rejected.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 20 June 1997 the public authorities prevented the applicant and her daughter from attending a meeting organised by a radio station in southern Cyprus, by not giving them permission to cross over to the southern part of Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On the anniversary of Kutlu Adalı's death the applicant organised a ceremony to commemorate her husband.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "On the day of the commemoration ceremony for Kutlu Adalı, the municipality brought in digging machines to dig up the road just under the applicant's street.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "A picture of Kutlu Adalı, which was displayed in the applicant's garden, was stolen.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On 10 August 1997 the applicant heard three gunshots outside her home.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Before the applicant left for England, a real-estate agent came to meet her daughter and told her to sell their house and accept any offer he would make to buy it.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The applicant believes that the real-estate agent was sent by the \"TRNC\" authorities to persuade her to leave the country.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The applicant contends that following her application to the European Court of Human Rights, her daughter was dismissed from her post in a bank.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The applicant contends that although her daughter was ranked 15th among 68 candidates in the examination to become a civil servant, she was not given a post.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The applicant's representatives informed the Court on 21 January 2000 that on 15 December 1999 the applicant had a meeting with Professor Bakır Çağlar about her application before the Court.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Professor Bakır Çağlar is a former agent of the Turkish Government in cases before the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "According to the applicant's representatives, Professor Bakır Çağlar allegedly told the applicant that she might be assassinated if she won her case before the Court.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "According to the applicant's representatives, Professor Bakır Çağlar allegedly told the applicant that her daughter's scholarship would be discontinued.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The applicant submitted in her oral evidence to the Court's Delegates that Professor Bakır Çağlar had asked about the details of the case and told her that he could win the case for her since, according to him, her lawyers were not very good.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The applicant considered Professor Bakır Çağlar to be connected to the authorities of the \"TRNC\" or of Turkey and therefore did not want to hand her case over to him.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "1. Facts as submitted by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Government submit that at the time when Kutlu Adalı was employed as the private secretary of President Denktaş, he requested the President's support to evade military service.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(a) Events preceding the murder of Kutlu Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Government submit that Mr Kutlu Adalı's request to evade military service was rejected and he had to do his military service, which consisted of a short period of basic training and a remaining period of office work performed at the Bayrak radio station.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(a) Events preceding the murder of Kutlu Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Government submit that when Mr Kutlu Adalı completed his military service, he was appointed as the Director of Registration.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(a) Events preceding the murder of Kutlu Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The Government submit that in December 1979 Mr Kutlu Adalı was removed from his post by an instrument signed by the minister responsible, the Prime Minister and the Head of State pursuant to Article 93 of the Constitution of the Turkish Federated State of Cyprus, and was appointed to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Defence and Tourism as an adviser.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(a) Events preceding the murder of Kutlu Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The Government submit that Mr Kutlu Adalı initiated proceedings in the High Administrative Court and requested the annulment of his removal from his post.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(a) Events preceding the murder of Kutlu Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The Government submit that the courts accepted Mr Kutlu Adalı's arguments and he was reinstated in his post in 1983.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(a) Events preceding the murder of Kutlu Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Government maintain that Mr Kutlu Adalı pursued his career as a writer and a newspaper journalist while he was in the public service.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(a) Events preceding the murder of Kutlu Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Government maintain that Mr Kutlu Adalı used to write under the pseudonym of \"Kerem Atlı\" not because it was dangerous for him to express his political views, but because there was a legal provision that civil servants should not be involved in daily politics and should act impartially.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(a) Events preceding the murder of Kutlu Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Government maintain that the vast majority of Turkish Cypriots did not agree with the views expressed by Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(a) Events preceding the murder of Kutlu Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The Government submit that on 6 July 1996 at 11.40 p.m. a tip-off was received at the communications section of the Lefkoşa Police Headquarters on telephone no. 155 from an unidentified caller, stating that there had been a murder at the point where Ardıç Street crosses Akasya Street.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Following the tip-off, two Land Rovers belonging to the special unit (çevik birlik) of the nearby Yenişehir police station, attached to the Lefkoşa Police Headquarters, came to the scene of the incident within a short time.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Land Rovers from the Yenişehir police station were followed by police vehicles bringing Criminal Investigation Department personnel from the Yenişehir and Lefkoşa Police Stations.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The immediate area of the incident and the surrounding area were cordoned off by police officers who started to work in order to identify the culprits.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The Government underline the fact that all the vehicles used by the police and those by the Turkish Cypriot security forces are of a similar type and colour.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Early in the morning of 7 July 1996, at 3 a.m., police officers brought a doctor from the Nicosia (Lefkoşa) State Hospital to the scene of the incident.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The doctor who examined Mr Kutlu Adalı's body established that Mr Adalı had died at the scene of the incident as a result of two bullet wounds in the areas of his left temple and left shoulder.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "A photographic fingerprinting officer took photographs of the scene of the incident where Mr Kutlu Adalı was killed.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "A sketch map of the scene of the incident indicated the positions of the empty cartridges found at the scene of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı's body was sent to the Nicosia State Hospital morgue for the purposes of an autopsy.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı's corpse was shown to his brother-in-law by police officers at the Nicosia State Hospital morgue.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "On 7 July 1996 police officers drew up a list of residents, including the applicant's neighbours, in the Akasya and Ardıç streets.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "On 7 July 1996 statements were taken from thirty-three persons as to their knowledge about the incident of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Following the autopsy carried out by Dr İsmail Bundak on 7 July 1996, the cause of Mr Kutlu Adalı's death was identified as dismemberment of the internal organs, internal haemorrhage and subdural bleeding at the head as a result of the wounds sustained by being shot with a firearm.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "After the autopsy, the blue-coloured shirt, striped T-shirt, pair of slippers and pair of glasses which Mr Kutlu Adalı was wearing were taken as evidence.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Between 8 and 31 July 1996 twenty-six further statements were taken from potential witnesses, including members of the applicant's family, in connection with the investigation into Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The investigation report of 13 July 1996 indicated persons who were not at home on the night of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing and their whereabouts at that time.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "On 17 July 1996 the Deputy to the Head of Security Forces Command in Lefkoşa sent a bloodied T-shirt and a shirt belonging to Mr Kutlu Adalı to the State Laboratory for an analysis of the blood.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "On 18 July 1996 an article appeared in the newspaper Milliyet under the headline \"The murderer was someone he knew\", alleging that a few days before the murder, a Timur Ali from the Nationalist Thought Association had made statements in the Birlik newspaper such as \"Kutlu Adalı must be destroyed like a dog by the council\".", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "On 18 July 1996 statements were taken by police officers from Ali Tekman, a columnist who used the pen-name \"Timur Ali\".", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Ali Tekman, in his statements, denied that he had made allegations about Kutlu Adalı and claimed that he had never written for the Birlik newspaper and that he was not a member of the Nationalist Thought Association.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The authorities investigated the applicant's allegations that at the time her husband was killed the street lights at the scene of the incident and in the vicinity were switched off.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Subsequent to enquiries made by Mr Ali Horoz, an equipment engineer at the Turkish Cyprus Electricity Company, it was established that the electricity for the street lights at the place of the incident and in the nearby Akasya, Akalan, Bağarası, Söğüt and Altınova Streets was provided by the \"Sıdıka Çatozlu\" power supply and not from the power supply of the Civil Defence Organisation as alleged by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "After statements had been taken from residents in the area, it was established that there had not been a power cut on the night of Mr Kutlu Adalı's murder.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "It was further established that even if the power supply in the courtyard of the Civil Defence Headquarters had been interfered with, it would not have been possible to switch off the street lights at the scene of the incident or in the streets in the vicinity.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "A ballistic examination was carried out on 14 used cartridges found at the scene of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The ballistics report of 6 August 1996 stated that the 14 used cartridges were 9-mm Parabellum-type cartridges that had been fired from one single gun at close range.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "The ballistics report of 6 August 1996 noted that the cartridges and the bullet cores were not linked to any other cartridges or bullet cores that had hitherto been found within the territory of the \"TRNC\" or recorded in the files on murders by unknown assailants.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "On 15 October 1996 the applicant submitted a petition to the Telephone Directorate in Nicosia, stating that she and her family had been disturbed by calls made from a certain number.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "At the applicant's request, a tapping device was put on to the applicant's telephone line (no. 2274089).", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "On 12 November 1996 a call was received from telephone number 2271851, and the authorities found out that the number belonged to a certain Mr Cahit Hüray, whose telephone line was then cut off.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "Following a request made by a person named B.K., Mr Cahit Hüray's telephone was reconnected on payment of a certain amount of money.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The owner of the telephone line, Mr Cahit Hüray, sent a complaint to the Telephone Directorate on 18 November 1996 stating that he had never dialled the applicant's number and requesting an inquiry to be made into the disturbance.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "On 22 November 1996, an assistant police inspector took statements from the head of the technical section at the Telephone Directorate to clarify the matter of the call from Mr Cahit Hüray's telephone number to the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "On 4 March 1998 the police assistant inspector in charge of the investigation into Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing, Ahmet Soyalan, concluded his report on the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "In his concluding remarks, police assistant inspector Ahmet Soyalan stated that it had not been possible to identify the murderer(s) of Mr Kutlu Adalı and that he could not therefore reach a positive result for the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "On 29 April 1998 the case of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing was referred to the Attorney-General of the \"TRNC\".", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "On 1 July 1998 the Attorney-General's office advised that the matter of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing should be referred to a coroner for an inquest.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "On 31 July 1998 the Nicosia Police Chief informed the Nicosia Coroner of the results of the investigation into the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The Nicosia Police Chief transmitted to the Nicosia Coroner the full investigation file containing the statements of the witnesses and the investigating officer's report.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The hearing before the coroner in Lefkoşa commenced on 20 October 1998.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "Following statements from witnesses, the coroner's hearing was concluded on 11 December 1998 with the delivery of the verdict.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The coroner found that Kutlu Adalı had been shot dead on 6 July 1996 by unidentified person(s), and that his death had been caused by organ dismemberment, internal haemorrhage and subdural haemorrhage in the head.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The coroner stated that the murderer(s) of Kutlu Adalı could not be identified and declared the case closed.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(b) Investigation into the killing of Mr Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The Government maintain that the allegation about the involvement of Abdullah Çatlı in the killing of Kutlu Adalı is no more than speculation.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The Government submit that according to \"TRNC\" records, Abdullah Çatlı's last visit to the \"TRNC\" had been between 26 April 1996 and 1 May 1996.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The Government emphasise that Abdullah Çatlı was not in the \"TRNC\" on 6 July 1996, when Kutlu Adalı was killed.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The Government explain that public opinion was supportive of the loss of the applicant's husband, Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "Public statements were made by the President, the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly, the Prime Minister and political party leaders of the \"TRNC\", condemning the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı and calling for the assailants to be found.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı's name was assigned to the street where he lived by the Lefkoşa Municipal Council.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "The Government maintain that most of the applicant's allegations of harassment following her husband's death are highly exaggerated.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "The Government note that the applicant herself asked for protection from the \"TRNC\" authorities and was told that she was already under the protection of plain-clothes policemen.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "The Government submit that in order to register a foundation in the name of Kutlu Adalı, an application should be made to the competent court and a court order should be obtained.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "On 2 April 1998 the Nicosia Family Court ordered the registration of the Kutlu Adalı Foundation after the applicant and eight other persons followed the correct procedure.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "The Government submit that crossings of the Green Line to and from the Ledra Palace Gate between the \"TRNC\" and southern Cyprus are regulated by the rules and regulations of the \"TRNC\" and are subject to restrictions due to security precautions.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "The Government submit that the \"TRNC\" authorities have the right to suspend permission to cross the border at the Ledra Palace Gate.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "The Government submit that the St Barnabas incident which occurred in March 1996 was a security operation.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "The Government submit that there was no damage to the icons or to the archaeology museum at St Barnabas.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "The Government submit that upon receipt of intelligence reports to the effect that illegal arms had been hidden in the tomb at St Barnabas, the security forces conducted an operation there.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "The Government state that the Civil Defence Organisation was not involved in the St Barnabas incident.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "The Government explain that pursuant to Law No. 7/1974 providing for aid to families of martyrs and victims of events, a martyr denotes a person who lost his life in the performance of duties assigned to him by lawful orders, in the protection of the rights of the \"TRNC\" in the struggle against illegal acts.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "The Government contend that the applicant's daughter was dismissed from her post in the Erbank on account of disorderly conduct on 12 October 1998.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "The application was communicated to the Government on 26 December 1998, which was after the dismissal of the applicant's daughter on 12 October 1998.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "The Government contend that the dismissal of the applicant's daughter from the Erbank cannot be attributed to the authorities because it occurred before the communication of the application.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "The Government state that the applicant's daughter had ranked 52nd (not 15th as alleged by the applicant) amongst 68 candidates in the examination to become a civil servant.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "The result of the civil servant examination in which the applicant's daughter participated was published in the Official Gazette dated 23 September 1998.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The facts", "2. Facts as submitted by the Government", "(c) The Government's observations in response to the applicant's allegations"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "The facts of the case being in dispute between the parties, the Court conducted an investigation with the assistance of the parties.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "Four delegates of the Court took oral evidence from the applicant on 8 October 2002.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "Six further witnesses were heard by the Court's Delegates on 23 and 24 June 2003 in Lefkoşa, Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "Mrs İlkay Adalı was born in 1944.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "Prior to the events in question, Mr Kutlu Adalı's writing led to his being prosecuted by the authorities on one occasion.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "On 15 August 1981 police officers searched the applicant's house because her husband had allegedly insulted President Denktaş in an article.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "The search warrant for the search of the applicant's house on 15 August 1981 was signed by Emin Okur, a judge in Kyrenia.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "The authorities wanted to find out the identity of the author of the article \"Minaredeki Deli\" (the mad on the minaret) and whether it was Kutlu Adalı who was using the name Kerem Atlı.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "The prosecution of Mr Kutlu Adalı in connection with the article \"Minaredeki Deli\" was subsequently discontinued for lack of evidence.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "None of the books and articles written by Mr Kutlu Adalı were ever seized or confiscated.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "No further incidents occurred until after Mr Kutlu Adalı's article on the St Barnabas monastery was published in Yenidüzen on 17 March 1996.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "On the day of publication of the St Barnabas article on 17 March 1996, the head of the Civil Defence Organisation, Galip Mendi, telephoned the Yenidüzen newspaper and made threats, which were indirectly aimed at Mr Kutlu Adalı because he was the author of the article.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "Following the St Barnabas incident, Galip Mendi was removed from his post as head of the Civil Defence Organisation.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "Galip Mendi left Cyprus two days before the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı and returned two years later.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "Galip Mendi was currently in charge of the security services at the time of the applicant's oral evidence.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F205", "text": "The Civil Defence Organisation was an organisation initially established in order to help the people and to assist them in defending themselves in the event of disasters such as a fire or the outbreak of war.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F206", "text": "People who were no longer eligible on grounds of age belonged to the Civil Defence Organisation and were called into service if there was an emergency.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F207", "text": "A commander belonging to the military stood at the head of the Civil Defence Organisation.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F208", "text": "The applicant did not accept that the Civil Defence Organisation was a civil organisation; she was of the opinion that it was a special and secret organisation attached to the Prime Minister.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F209", "text": "Whilst in his post as Director General of Population Issues, Mr Kutlu Adalı had been a senior manager within the Civil Defence Organisation.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F210", "text": "The applicant only learned about Mr Kutlu Adalı's role in the Civil Defence Organisation after her husband's death, when amongst his papers she found the 1975 decision of the Council of Ministers appointing him.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F211", "text": "Erhan Arıklı, a member of the Nationalist Thought Association, wrote to Yenidüzen threatening Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F212", "text": "Erhan Arıklı had an article entitled \"The Red Disease\" published in the pro-Government newspaper Birlik in which he wrote, using the pseudonym Timur Ali, that leftist people should be shot like stray dogs by municipal officials.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F213", "text": "In her interview with the Milliyet newspaper, the applicant said that in \"The Red Disease\", Mr Arıklı had written that her husband should be put down like a dog, which was how she had interpreted the article.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F214", "text": "In December 1996, when the applicant was going through her husband's papers, she discovered a letter dated 1990, written to her husband by the fascist Nationalist Thought Association and signed by Mr Arıklı, whose contents she perceived as threatening.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F215", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı received many anonymous letters saying that he would be killed in a week's time, and threatening telephone calls.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F216", "text": "As Mr Kutlu Adalı was a very proud person, he did not report the threats to the police, although he did mention them in an article of 23 April 1996.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F217", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı did not try to have the threatening telephone calls traced.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F218", "text": "On 6 July 1996, the day of her husband's killing, the applicant was in Istanbul to celebrate their daughter's birthday.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F219", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı had not accompanied the applicant and their daughter to Istanbul for financial reasons.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F220", "text": "The applicant spoke to her husband by telephone at 11.15 p.m. on 6 July 1996, fifteen minutes before he was killed.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F221", "text": "After her husband's death, the applicant was unable to see his body, although her brother-in-law did see the body.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F222", "text": "Being of the firm belief that her husband had been assassinated by Government agents, the applicant herself conducted an investigation and handed the results, in the form of a written statement, to the police chief Mehmet Özdamar.", "source_paragraph": 85, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F223", "text": "The applicant was not given a copy of the written statement she handed to police chief Mehmet Özdamar.", "source_paragraph": 85, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F224", "text": "Ayşe Mehta told the applicant that she had seen a black Murat car driving rapidly to the Civil Defence Organisation headquarters on the day of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F225", "text": "Ms Ayşe Mehta lived on Şehit Ecvet Yusuf Street, which ran parallel to the street where the applicant and her husband were living and was also the street where the Civil Defence Organisation was based.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F226", "text": "None of the inhabitants of Şehit Ecvet Yusuf Street were interviewed by the police in connection with Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F227", "text": "The police said that the inhabitants of Şehit Ecvet Yusuf Street had not been at home when the incident had occurred, but the applicant stated this was not true.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F228", "text": "Neighbour Arzu Çağın mentioned a dark red Şahin car in connection with the night of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 87, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F229", "text": "Neighbour Ali Rıza Kırçay mentioned a dark-coloured car in connection with the night of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 87, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F230", "text": "Based on the statements of her neighbours, the applicant formed the opinion that the car seen near the scene of the killing had been a black Murat, although she acknowledged that it might also have been a Şahin since Şahin and Murat cars looked the same.", "source_paragraph": 88, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F231", "text": "Ms Ayşe Mehta told the applicant that the two lamp-posts on Ardıç Street, around the applicant's house, had been switched off at 10.30 p.m. on the night of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 89, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F232", "text": "Ms Ayşe Mehta did not see when the lamp-posts came back on, but noticed that they were on after the murder.", "source_paragraph": 89, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F233", "text": "The applicant stated that the switching off of only the lights around her house was something that used to and continued to happen quite frequently.", "source_paragraph": 89, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F234", "text": "A sibling of the applicant explained to her that the lights were switched off by removing the fuse from the fuse-box in an individual lamppost.", "source_paragraph": 89, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F235", "text": "Two neighbours who were Turkish students living in the basement of the building next door refused to speak to the applicant and left Cyprus three days after the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 90, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F236", "text": "The two Turkish student neighbours did give a statement to the police.", "source_paragraph": 90, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F237", "text": "Erinç Aydınova, a fourteen-year-old child of a neighbour, was one of the first persons to find the body of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 91, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F238", "text": "Erinç Aydınova was so afraid that he had still not spoken to the applicant about the incident.", "source_paragraph": 91, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F239", "text": "Erinç Aydınova had made a statement to the police, but it was not complete: the boy did not tell the police that he had seen a car passing at great speed.", "source_paragraph": 91, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F240", "text": "The applicant's daughter found out from Erinç Aydınova that he had seen a car passing at great speed, as she used to take him to school.", "source_paragraph": 91, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F241", "text": "Feri Khan and her mother lived across from the applicant's house, were at home on the night of the murder, saw a black Murat car without licence plates and heard shots, but the police had never asked them for statements.", "source_paragraph": 92, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F242", "text": "According to the police, Feri Khan and her mother had not been at home on the night of Mr Kutlu Adalı's murder.", "source_paragraph": 92, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F243", "text": "Following the murder, the applicant found a packet of dried nuts bought from the shop of Ziya Kasaboğlu in her house.", "source_paragraph": 93, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F244", "text": "Mr Ziya Kasaboğlu told the applicant that her husband had bought the nuts and that he had been killed afterwards, and that it was because of this that he had been the one who had informed the family of the murder by telephoning the father-in-law of the applicant's sister.", "source_paragraph": 93, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F245", "text": "Mr Ziya Kasaboğlu was a plain-clothes policeman and the father-in-law of the applicant's sister was his superior.", "source_paragraph": 93, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F246", "text": "After Mr Kutlu Adalı died, Mr Ziya Kasaboğlu closed up his shop and moved to the village of İnönü.", "source_paragraph": 93, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F247", "text": "The applicant believed that Mr Ziya Kasaboğlu was involved in the incident because he did not come to speak to her and the police did not take a statement from him.", "source_paragraph": 93, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F248", "text": "The applicant asked the authorities to take a statement from Mr Ziya Kasaboğlu, but to no avail, first making this request at a secret meeting in December 1996 with Hasan Peker Günal, commander of the security forces, and Attila Sav, the chief of police, which took place in the latter's office.", "source_paragraph": 93, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F249", "text": "Altay Sayıl was a friend of Mr Kutlu Adalı; they met about fifteen years before Mr Kutlu Adalı's death and would occasionally meet to pursue cultural activities.", "source_paragraph": 94, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F250", "text": "Two to three years before the murder, the friendship between Altay Sayıl and Mr Kutlu Adalı intensified, with Mr Sayıl often coming to visit and bringing classified documents, for example about the police, which Mr Kutlu Adalı used in his articles.", "source_paragraph": 94, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F251", "text": "As a result of articles written by Mr Kutlu Adalı based on classified documents provided by Altay Sayıl, the head of the security forces was removed from his post after those articles were published.", "source_paragraph": 94, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F252", "text": "Two nights before the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı, Altay Sayıl came to the applicant's house in a black Murat car, which he said belonged to a friend.", "source_paragraph": 94, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F253", "text": "Apart from the applicant's mother, Altay Sayıl and his wife were the only persons who knew that the applicant was going to Istanbul on the night of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 94, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F254", "text": "The applicant suspected that Altay Sayıl was working for the intelligence services and that he had been using her husband.", "source_paragraph": 95, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F255", "text": "On the first night when the applicant was questioned, police chief Mehmet Özdamar told her that Altay Sayıl was a good person and insinuated that Mr Sayıl had nothing to do with the murder.", "source_paragraph": 95, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F256", "text": "The applicant did not tell police chief Mehmet Özdamar about Mr Sayıl handing documents to her husband, but she did mention it in an article in Aktüel.", "source_paragraph": 95, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F257", "text": "Altay Sayıl did not come to the applicant's house for ten days after the murder; and then he only came because the applicant asked him to.", "source_paragraph": 96, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F258", "text": "On the occasion when Altay Sayıl came to the applicant's house after the murder, he denied having brought a booklet to Mr Kutlu Adalı on the night of the murder.", "source_paragraph": 96, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F259", "text": "The booklet, which had been left in front of Mr Kutlu Adalı's office, contained photographs of two journalists who had been assassinated in 1962, with a photocopied picture of Mr Kutlu Adalı superimposed on it.", "source_paragraph": 96, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F260", "text": "Months later, the applicant found the photograph from which the copy had been made upside down in an album amongst her husband's books.", "source_paragraph": 96, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F261", "text": "The applicant found out that a letter saying that certain journalists had been killed had been photocopied at a shop where Altay Sayıl's brother was working.", "source_paragraph": 96, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F262", "text": "Shortly after Mr Kutlu Adalı had been killed, a large number of police officers went into the applicant's house, ostensibly to guarantee the security of the house because, according to them, they found the door open and the television switched on.", "source_paragraph": 97, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F263", "text": "The police officers who entered the applicant's house turned everything upside down and it took the applicant and her family two years to restore order amongst her husband's books and papers.", "source_paragraph": 97, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F264", "text": "The police officers who entered the applicant's house were accompanied by the muhtar, Tahsin Ali Rıza.", "source_paragraph": 97, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F265", "text": "The muhtar Tahsin Ali Rıza was never questioned by the police.", "source_paragraph": 97, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F266", "text": "Both Mr Hüseyin Demirci and Orhan Ceylan, who was a colonel, brought a court action against the applicant because of an article that had appeared in Milliyet, which is how the applicant found out about Orhan's surname.", "source_paragraph": 98, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F267", "text": "The police never took a statement from Orhan Ceylan, although Mr Hüseyin Demirci was interviewed by them.", "source_paragraph": 98, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F268", "text": "A statement was not taken from Mustafa Asilhan, who had dinner with Mr Hüseyin Demirci on the evening of the murder according to the latter's statement.", "source_paragraph": 98, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F269", "text": "Mustafa Asilhan was an adviser to the commander of the security forces at the time of the applicant's oral evidence.", "source_paragraph": 98, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F270", "text": "The applicant later found out that Mr Hüseyin Demirci had been injured in an incident when his car had been shot at.", "source_paragraph": 99, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F271", "text": "When Mr Hüseyin Demirci was taken to hospital by local people after his car was shot at, he shouted that an attempt had been made to kill him because he had killed Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 99, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F272", "text": "The local people who heard Mr Hüseyin Demirci's statement at the hospital informed the police, but were told to forget about it.", "source_paragraph": 99, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F273", "text": "Mr Hüseyin Demirci was subsequently taken to a military hospital in Turkey where all his expenses were paid.", "source_paragraph": 99, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F274", "text": "Upon his return to Cyprus, Mr Hüseyin Demirci became the private secretary of Mr Galip Mendi.", "source_paragraph": 99, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F275", "text": "Following the murder, the applicant spoke to Dr İsmail Bundak, who told her that no post mortem had been carried out but that her husband's body had been X-rayed.", "source_paragraph": 100, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F276", "text": "The applicant was unable to find out whether a post mortem had been carried out until, after she had lodged her application with the former Commission, she obtained a copy of the post mortem report together with the Government's observations.", "source_paragraph": 100, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F277", "text": "Dr İsmail Bundak did not give the applicant the death certificate, in which the cause of death was stated as internal bleeding, until about one month after the incident.", "source_paragraph": 100, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F278", "text": "The applicant's allegation that Abdullah Çatlı was involved in her husband's murder was not just based on newspaper reports.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F279", "text": "In 1997 the applicant had a meeting with Fikri Sağlar, a member of the Turkish Parliament and chairman of the Turkish Susurluk committee.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F280", "text": "In 1998 and in 2001 the Parliament of the \"TRNC\" established its own Susurluk investigation committee, suspecting that there was a connection between Abdullah Çatlı and the murder of Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F281", "text": "The applicant made statements to the \"TRNC\" Susurluk investigation committees but did not have transcripts of her statements.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F282", "text": "The \"TRNC\" Susurluk investigation committees came to the conclusion that Abdullah Çatlı had visited Cyprus, using false identities, on many occasions and that around the time of Mr Kutlu Adalı's murder he had been staying at the Jasmine Court hotel, with his expenses being paid by the army.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F283", "text": "When Abdullah Çatlı died in a car accident in November 1996, an Uzi was retrieved from the car.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F284", "text": "It is the applicant's opinion that the Uzi retrieved from Abdullah Çatlı's car, which had gone missing from the Turkish police, was the weapon with which her husband had been shot.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F285", "text": "Although the roads in the vicinity of the applicant's house were very quickly closed off by the military after the shooting of her husband, the roads in the outlying area, and especially those leading to the airport, were not.", "source_paragraph": 102, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F286", "text": "A taxi driver told the applicant that he had taken Abdullah Çatlı to the airport directly after the murder of Mr Kutlu Adalı had been committed.", "source_paragraph": 102, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F287", "text": "The applicant believed that Altay Sayıl, Ziya Kasaboğlu, Hüseyin Demirci and Abdullah Çatlı were Government agents who had acted collectively and as a team and had killed her husband.", "source_paragraph": 103, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F288", "text": "The applicant did not accept that Mr Kutlu Adalı might have been killed by a private individual who was angered at his writings.", "source_paragraph": 103, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F289", "text": "At the secret meeting with Hasan Peker Günal and Attila Sav in December 1996, the applicant informed them of her suspicions about Altay Sayıl, Ziya Kasaboğlu, Hüseyin Demirci and Abdullah Çatlı.", "source_paragraph": 103, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F290", "text": "At the December 1996 meeting, Hasan Peker Günal said that he had never heard the name of Altay Sayıl before but that he would follow it up.", "source_paragraph": 103, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F291", "text": "The applicant was of the opinion that the security forces were opposed to an effective investigation being carried out into the killing of her husband.", "source_paragraph": 104, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F292", "text": "Shortly after the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı, Refik Öztümen, who was in charge of the judicial investigation, wanted to meet with the applicant at her sister-in-law's house, but the applicant refused because she was afraid at that time.", "source_paragraph": 104, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F293", "text": "Refik Öztümen told the applicant's sister-in-law that he had been given instructions by the security forces not to conduct the investigation effectively and that the applicant should not follow it up either.", "source_paragraph": 104, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F294", "text": "The applicant had been subjected to constant harassment after the death of her husband, including receiving threatening telephone calls.", "source_paragraph": 105, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F295", "text": "When the applicant informed the police about threatening telephone calls in 1996, they managed to trace a call to one Cahit Hüray who lived two streets away.", "source_paragraph": 105, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F296", "text": "The applicant knew that Cahit Hüray belonged to the Civil Defence Organisation.", "source_paragraph": 105, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F297", "text": "Mr Cahit Hüray was let off after paying a miserly fine, and the threatening telephone calls continued.", "source_paragraph": 105, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F298", "text": "The applicant bought an indicator to show the number of incoming telephone calls.", "source_paragraph": 105, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F299", "text": "The applicant received a telephone call from a man calling himself Ali who said that he was coming over to determine her fate; she informed the police as the indicator had shown the number that had been used, but the police did nothing.", "source_paragraph": 105, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F300", "text": "One evening, as the applicant was returning home after a meeting and stopped off at a neighbour's, she was told that there was somebody walking around in her garden; it turned out to be a neighbour who was near the water tank and did not explain what he was doing there.", "source_paragraph": 106, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F301", "text": "The applicant's sister-in-law, a chemist, advised the applicant to change the water in the water tank, which they did.", "source_paragraph": 106, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F302", "text": "The next day after the water tank incident, the applicant found that her dog was dead, with its ribs and one of its legs broken.", "source_paragraph": 106, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F303", "text": "The veterinary surgeon who conducted the autopsy on the applicant's dog said that the dog had not been run over by a car, because of a lack of tyre marks on the place where it was found, and that the dog had been severely tortured elsewhere and then taken to the applicant's garden.", "source_paragraph": 106, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F304", "text": "The applicant's water and electricity were regularly cut off.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F305", "text": "Mail addressed to the applicant was either not delivered or was opened.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F306", "text": "The applicant's telephone calls were monitored.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F307", "text": "The applicant's complaints to the police, both orally and in writing, about the harassment she experienced led to nothing.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F308", "text": "The application to establish the Adalı Foundation, which sixty democratic organisations wanted to set up in order to continue Kutlu Adalı's work, was initially refused.", "source_paragraph": 108, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F309", "text": "The registration fee for the Adalı Foundation was increased fivefold and the applicant sold a plot of land to raise the money.", "source_paragraph": 108, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F310", "text": "The charter of the Adalı Foundation had to be changed; for example, the phrase \"democratic activities\" was replaced by \"cultural activities\".", "source_paragraph": 108, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F311", "text": "On 15 December 1999 the applicant met with Professor Bakır Çağlar, after he had asked her to send him the details of the case.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F312", "text": "Professor Bakır Çağlar became cross when the documents which the applicant showed him did not include the agreements which she had concluded with her lawyers.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F313", "text": "Professor Bakır Çağlar told the applicant that her lawyers were not very good and that he could win the case for her.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F314", "text": "The applicant considered Professor Bakır Çağlar to be connected to the authorities of the \"TRNC\" or of Turkey and therefore did not want to hand her case over to him.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F315", "text": "In July 1996, the applicant's daughter was told she would get a job in the public sector but this did not materialise.", "source_paragraph": 110, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F316", "text": "The applicant's daughter found a job in a bank, but her contract of employment was terminated from one day to the next, allegedly for disciplinary reasons.", "source_paragraph": 110, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F317", "text": "The applicant contends that her daughter's dismissal from the bank was in reality because the applicant had lodged an application with the Court.", "source_paragraph": 110, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F318", "text": "The applicant's daughter was standing as a candidate for a party different from the party for which the owner of the bank was standing as a candidate.", "source_paragraph": 110, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F319", "text": "The applicant's daughter wrote to, and subsequently met, President Denktaş about her dismissal from the bank.", "source_paragraph": 110, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F320", "text": "President Denktaş wrote out a cheque for the equivalent of two months' wages and told the applicant's daughter to go home.", "source_paragraph": 110, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F321", "text": "The applicant's daughter's scholarship had recently been discontinued at the time of the applicant's oral evidence.", "source_paragraph": 110, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F322", "text": "On 19 August 2001 the applicant met with President Denktaş at the presidential palace.", "source_paragraph": 111, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F323", "text": "At the presidential palace on 19 August 2001, the applicant met a man with the first name Tansel, who was the son-in-law of the police commander Erdem Demirbağ.", "source_paragraph": 111, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F324", "text": "Tansel told the applicant that unless she withdrew her application to the European Court of Human Rights she would be arrested.", "source_paragraph": 111, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "1. İlkay Adalı"]}, {"fact_id": "F325", "text": "Witness Ahmet Soyalan was born in 1962.", "source_paragraph": 112, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F326", "text": "In 1996 Ahmet Soyalan was an assistant inspector at the judicial branch of the Lefkoşa police headquarters.", "source_paragraph": 112, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F327", "text": "Mr Mehmet Özdamar, who was Ahmet Soyalan's superior, was the head of the judicial branch, attached to the general police headquarters.", "source_paragraph": 112, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F328", "text": "Mr Refik Öztümen was the chief of Yenişehir police station.", "source_paragraph": 112, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F329", "text": "In an investigation, the local police station would report to the judicial branch and the judicial branch would report to the head of the judicial branch.", "source_paragraph": 112, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F330", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan was responsible for the investigation into the killing of Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F331", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan started his investigation into the killing of Kutlu Adalı at 9 a.m. on 7 July 1996.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F332", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan had known Mr Kutlu Adalı by name from the articles he wrote for Yenidüzen, but had never met him.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F333", "text": "Although it was possible that Mr Kutlu Adalı had been killed because of his activities as a journalist, Ahmet Soyalan also looked into Mr Adalı's personal life and his personality as part of the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F334", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan had not been on duty on the evening of 6 July 1996 and did not go to the scene of the crime that night.", "source_paragraph": 114, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F335", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan was only informed of the murder of Mr Kutlu Adalı the following morning and received a short briefing from Mr Refik Öztümen as to what had been done the previous night.", "source_paragraph": 114, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F336", "text": "Chief Inspector Eybil Efendi and his colleagues from the rapid response unit had been the first police officers to arrive at the scene of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 115, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F337", "text": "Chief Inspector Eybil Efendi and his colleagues from the rapid response unit heard shots whilst out on patrol duty and went to the location of the incident.", "source_paragraph": 115, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F338", "text": "Chief Inspector Eybil Efendi informed the general police headquarters about the incident.", "source_paragraph": 115, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F339", "text": "Upon hearing the shots, local people also alerted the police switchboard.", "source_paragraph": 115, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F340", "text": "Not long after the first responders arrived, Mr Mehmet Özdamar, Mr Refik Öztümen, assistant chief of police Yusuf Özkum, police sergeant Mustafa Eğmez, as well as officers working at the judicial branch and the Yenişehir police station, arrived at the site of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 115, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F341", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan did not consider it necessary to take a statement from Chief Inspector Eybil Efendi initially because he had been briefed by Mr Refik Öztümen, who had arrived at the scene so soon after Mr Efendi that the latter would not have seen anything different.", "source_paragraph": 116, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F342", "text": "In 2002, Ahmet Soyalan took a statement from Chief Inspector Eybil Efendi in order to show that, contrary to what the applicant alleged, no military vehicles were present at the scene and that the vehicles of the rapid response unit resembled military vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 116, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F343", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan was told by Mr Refik Öztümen that after the discovery of Mr Kutlu Adalı's body, police had entered the applicant's house, together with the muhtar, in order to check if any of the family members were at home and if they were safe, and also to see if any clues about the murder could be found there.", "source_paragraph": 117, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F344", "text": "The door of the applicant's house was open, the television was switched on and a table and chairs were on the veranda when police entered after the discovery of Mr Kutlu Adalı's body.", "source_paragraph": 117, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F345", "text": "Nothing untoward was found in the applicant's house; no search as such was carried out, merely a visual inspection.", "source_paragraph": 117, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F346", "text": "It was not considered necessary to take a statement from the muhtar, as no evidence was found in the house and nothing untoward happened.", "source_paragraph": 117, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F347", "text": "No fingerprint examination was carried out at the applicant's house, given that the incident had taken place outside the house and the interior of the house was thus not a crime scene.", "source_paragraph": 117, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F348", "text": "The applicant said that when she had spoken to her husband by telephone at 11 p.m. on 6 July 1996, her husband had told her that he had not received any visitors.", "source_paragraph": 117, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F349", "text": "One or two neighbours stated that when they had passed the applicant's house around 8 p.m. on 6 July 1996, there had been no one in there.", "source_paragraph": 117, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F350", "text": "From the statements taken by Mr Refik Öztümen and his colleagues directly after the incident, it appeared that a dark-coloured car with many lights at the rear had been seen near the scene of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 118, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F351", "text": "The make or registration of the dark-coloured car seen near the scene of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing was not known, and no one had mentioned to Ahmet Soyalan that it had been a Murat car.", "source_paragraph": 118, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F352", "text": "A search was carried out on the night of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing but the vehicle, which had left the scene at high speed, was not found.", "source_paragraph": 118, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F353", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan spoke to Arzu Çağın the day after her initial statement had been taken by one of his colleagues; she said that she did not know what make or colour the car was.", "source_paragraph": 118, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F354", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan did not draw up a written report of Arzu Çağın's second statement, given that it did not contain any positive indications.", "source_paragraph": 118, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F355", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan disputed that at the inquest, Ms Arzu Çağın had given evidence to the effect that the car was Bordeaux red and that it might have been a Şahin.", "source_paragraph": 118, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F356", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan started his investigation on the morning after the incident by taking statements from the people living in the area of the scene of the crime, with this work having already commenced the previous evening.", "source_paragraph": 119, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F357", "text": "Statements were taken from all persons who had been at home at the time of the incident, regardless of whether or not they had any information to offer.", "source_paragraph": 119, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F358", "text": "It was the local police officers, who knew the area and its inhabitants well, who established who had been at home and who had not on the night of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 119, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F359", "text": "Since no statement was taken from Feri Khan and her mother, Ahmet Soyalan concluded they must have been out when the offence had taken place.", "source_paragraph": 119, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F360", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan knew nothing about the applicant asking Hasan Peker Günal, commander of the security forces, to have Feri Khan and her mother interviewed.", "source_paragraph": 119, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F361", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan took the applicant's statement on the evening of 7 July 1996, after she had returned from Turkey.", "source_paragraph": 120, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F362", "text": "The applicant expressed to Ahmet Soyalan her opinion that the killing of her husband was connected to the articles he had written about the St Barnabas incident and that the head of the Civil Defence Organisation, Mr Galip Mendi, had been annoyed by these articles and had telephoned Yenidüzen making threats against her husband.", "source_paragraph": 120, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F363", "text": "The applicant persistently claimed to Ahmet Soyalan that the murder had been arranged by the administration of the Civil Defence Organisation and that she held the head of that organisation responsible.", "source_paragraph": 120, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F364", "text": "Not even the smallest piece of evidence could be found to support the allegation that the Civil Defence Organisation was involved in Mr Kutlu Adalı's murder, and for that reason no statements were taken from the head or other persons belonging to the Civil Defence Organisation.", "source_paragraph": 120, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F365", "text": "A statement could not be taken from Mr Galip Mendi because he had gone abroad; Mr Mendi returned in 2001 as the commander of the security forces.", "source_paragraph": 120, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F366", "text": "The applicant alleged that on the night of the murder the street lighting in Ardıç Street, where she lived, had been switched off at the transformer substation in the Civil Defence Organisation.", "source_paragraph": 121, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F367", "text": "The matter of the street lighting was examined and it was established through the taking of statements that the street lights had been on on the night of Mr Kutlu Adalı's murder.", "source_paragraph": 121, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F368", "text": "It was further established that power for the lighting in Ardıç Street was supplied from a different substation than the one in the Civil Defence Organisation.", "source_paragraph": 121, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F369", "text": "In her statement to Ahmet Soyalan, the applicant mentioned Ahmet Cavit An, according to whom Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing was a politically motivated murder.", "source_paragraph": 122, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F370", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan went to see Ahmet Cavit An, once at his house and once at the clinic where he worked, but Mr Cavit An was unable to provide any useful information as to the secret cells allegedly involved in the murder.", "source_paragraph": 122, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F371", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan had not heard that the applicant had been refused permission to see her husband's body.", "source_paragraph": 123, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F372", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan was not given any instructions to the effect that, because the applicant had given critical newspaper interviews, he should not give her a copy of the post mortem and ballistic reports.", "source_paragraph": 123, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F373", "text": "In order to obtain a copy of documents such as the post mortem and ballistic reports, permission from the Attorney-General's office was required.", "source_paragraph": 123, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F374", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan took two statements from Altay Sayıl in connection with the investigation into Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F375", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan first interviewed Altay Sayıl because he had been informed that Mr Sayıl was a close friend of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F376", "text": "In the light of articles that subsequently appeared in newspapers, Ahmet Soyalan felt the need to take a more in-depth statement from Altay Sayıl.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F377", "text": "Altay Sayıl attended the mevlit (religious ceremony) held at the applicant's house three days after the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F378", "text": "Altay Sayıl did not go to the applicant's house subsequently because of the allegations which the applicant had made against him.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F379", "text": "The weapon used to kill Mr Kutlu Adalı could not be identified; a number of spent cartridges were found at the site from which it could be established that they had been fired by a 9 mm firearm, but the make of the weapon remained unknown.", "source_paragraph": 125, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F380", "text": "Ballistic tests were carried out both in Turkey and in the \"TRNC\" to see if the bullets used to kill Mr Kutlu Adalı had been fired by a weapon known to the authorities, but to no avail.", "source_paragraph": 125, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F381", "text": "The ballistic tests included comparisons of sample cartridges held in the archives of the \"TRNC\" of all the weapons registered in the names of persons in the \"TRNC\", such as the weapon belonging to Mr Orhan Ceylan.", "source_paragraph": 125, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F382", "text": "Two of the spent cartridges from the scene of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing were kept in the archives in Turkey.", "source_paragraph": 126, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F383", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan assumed that the Turkish authorities had examined whether the spent cartridges had been fired by the Uzi found in the car in which Abdullah Çatlı had died in Susurluk in November 1996, but he had not been informed of any result.", "source_paragraph": 126, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F384", "text": "The investigation showed that Abdullah Çatlı had not been in the \"TRNC\" at the time of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing, as there were no records of him entering the \"TRNC\" at the relevant time under any of the identities which Mr Çatlı was known to have used.", "source_paragraph": 126, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F385", "text": "Abdullah Çatlı had visited the island of Cyprus under the name of Mehmet Özbay in June 1994 and in April/May 1996.", "source_paragraph": 126, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F386", "text": "It was not possible to enter the \"TRNC\" without an entry record being made by the immigration authorities.", "source_paragraph": 126, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F387", "text": "The applicant did not inform Ahmet Soyalan or any other police officers that she had received an anonymous telephone call from a woman alleging that Mr Hüseyin Demirci and a man with the first name Orhan had been involved in the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 127, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F388", "text": "Some time after the incident, a woman who could not be identified telephoned Mr Yusuf Özkum, the then head of the judicial branch, and gave him the name of Hüseyin Demirci.", "source_paragraph": 127, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F389", "text": "Mr Yusuf Özkum passed the name of Hüseyin Demirci on to Mr Mehmet Özdamar, who proceeded to take Mr Demirci's statement.", "source_paragraph": 127, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F390", "text": "On the evening of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing, Mr Hüseyin Demirci had dinner with Mustafa Asilhan, the then assistant chief of police, in Gemikonağı.", "source_paragraph": 128, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F391", "text": "Although no statement was taken from Mustafa Asilhan at the time, Mr Mehmet Özdamar spoke to Mr Asilhan about the matter, and Mr Asilhan said that Police Officer Muharrem Göç had seen the two men having dinner.", "source_paragraph": 128, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F392", "text": "Police Officer Muharrem Göç subsequently confirmed in a statement to Mr Mehmet Özdamar that he had seen Mr Hüseyin Demirci and Mustafa Asilhan having dinner on the evening of 6 July 1996.", "source_paragraph": 128, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F393", "text": "Mustafa Asilhan himself confirmed that he had had dinner with Mr Hüseyin Demirci on 6 July 1996 when his statement was taken in 2002.", "source_paragraph": 128, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F394", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan did not consider it likely that Mr Hüseyin Demirci could have been involved in the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı after he had left the restaurant because such an assassination required preparation.", "source_paragraph": 129, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F395", "text": "Mr Hüseyin Demirci said that he had gone straight home after dropping off Mustafa Asilhan, and as Mr Mehmet Özdamar had not formed the opinion that Mr Demirci was speaking anything other than the truth, this matter was not examined further.", "source_paragraph": 129, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F396", "text": "According to Ahmet Soyalan, Mr Hüseyin Demirci was a self-employed ironmonger who had no relations with the police or the security forces.", "source_paragraph": 130, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F397", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan checked to see whether Mr Hüseyin Demirci had a criminal record as there was an allegation that he had been acquitted on a murder charge, but there was no information that he had ever committed any criminal offence.", "source_paragraph": 130, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F398", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan examined whether Mr Hüseyin Demirci had been admitted to hospital with burns, as alleged by the applicant, and established that Mr Demirci had spent three days in hospital in February 1997 for broken ribs.", "source_paragraph": 131, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F399", "text": "Mr Hüseyin Demirci was not asked about his hospital stay because it did not coincide with the murder of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 131, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F400", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan stated that had the incident alleged by the applicant really occurred — namely that Mr Hüseyin Demirci opened fire inside the hospital, saying \"I killed Kutlu Adalı\" — it would have been reported to the police.", "source_paragraph": 131, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F401", "text": "The information reported to the police was only connected to Mr Hüseyin Demirci and did not mention Orhan Ceylan.", "source_paragraph": 132, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F402", "text": "At some point there was a report in the press to the effect that Orhan Ceylan had committed the murder of Mr Kutlu Adalı along with Mr Hüseyin Demirci.", "source_paragraph": 132, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F403", "text": "Orhan Ceylan's statement was not taken at the time of the initial investigation given that Mr Hüseyin Demirci's whereabouts on the evening of the murder had already been established and it was thus known that Mr Demirci had not been in contact with Mr Ceylan that night.", "source_paragraph": 132, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F404", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan took a statement from Orhan Ceylan on 18 October 2002, only because his name had come up in the application to the Court, as there was not a shred of evidence or any indication that he had been involved in the killing.", "source_paragraph": 133, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F405", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan took a statement from Ziya Kasapoğlu on 21 October 2002, because his name was mentioned in the application to the Court.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F406", "text": "Prior to taking the statement on 21 October 2002, Ahmet Soyalan was not aware that Ziya Kasapoğlu might possess information relating to the incident, as Mr Kasapoğlu's shop was in Şehit Ecvet Yusuf Street, far from the scene of the crime.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F407", "text": "Ziya Kasapoğlu told Ahmet Soyalan that Mr Kutlu Adalı had come to his shop at 11 p.m. on the night of the killing to buy some dried fruit and nuts, as he used to do from time to time.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F408", "text": "Ziya Kasapoğlu told Ahmet Soyalan that he had not telephoned anybody to inform the applicant's family of the death of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F409", "text": "Ziya Kasapoğlu further stated that he had not received any telephone calls from the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F410", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan was requested by the Agent of the respondent Government, Professor Necatigil, to carry out an investigation in connection with the allegations made by the applicant to the Court.", "source_paragraph": 135, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F411", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan received no specific instructions from Professor Necatigil, only a document containing the applicant's allegations.", "source_paragraph": 135, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F412", "text": "Apart from taking statements from a number of persons, Ahmet Soyalan also took photographs of a Murat, a Şahin and a Fiat car so that they could be compared.", "source_paragraph": 136, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F413", "text": "Ahmet Soyalan investigated the applicant's claim that Mr Hüseyin Demirci's azure blue car had been repainted black, and it was established that the car's colour was its original blue.", "source_paragraph": 136, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "2. Ahmet Soyalan"]}, {"fact_id": "F414", "text": "Witness Mehmet Özdamar was born in 1953.", "source_paragraph": 137, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F415", "text": "At the time of the oral evidence hearing, Mehmet Özdamar was the chief of police in Güzelyurt.", "source_paragraph": 137, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F416", "text": "At the time of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing, Mehmet Özdamar was the head of the judicial branch at the Police Headquarters in Lefkoşa (Nicosia).", "source_paragraph": 137, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F417", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar supervised the investigation into the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı and was the supervisor of Ahmet Soyalan and Refik Öztümen.", "source_paragraph": 137, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F418", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar was informed about the incident by the switchboard and arrived at the scene of the incident within ten or fifteen minutes.", "source_paragraph": 137, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F419", "text": "When Mehmet Özdamar arrived at the scene of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing, Mr Refik Öztümen and Mr Yusuf Özkum were already at the scene of the crime.", "source_paragraph": 137, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F420", "text": "The officers marked and numbered the empty cartridges and cordoned the area off with a view to preventing unauthorised persons from walking around the scene of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 137, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F421", "text": "A sketch-map of the scene of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing was drawn up and a team was set up in order to take testimonies from people nearby.", "source_paragraph": 137, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F422", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar entered Mr Kutlu Adalı's house three or four hours after the incident, along with Refik Öztümen, a close relative of the deceased and the local muhtar.", "source_paragraph": 138, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F423", "text": "The door of Mr Kutlu Adalı's house was open and the TV was on when Mehmet Özdamar entered.", "source_paragraph": 138, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F424", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar and those with him looked for a document, an item or anything that could have been the cause of the incident but did not remove any object.", "source_paragraph": 138, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F425", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı's office was in disorder and there were a large number of books which were piled up or arranged in boxes.", "source_paragraph": 138, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F426", "text": "Refik Öztümen told Mehmet Özdamar that he had entered the house for a very short time in order to check whether there was anybody in.", "source_paragraph": 138, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F427", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar did not consider it necessary to look for fingerprints in the applicant's house since the incident had happened in the street and not in the house.", "source_paragraph": 139, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F428", "text": "According to the statements given by the deceased's next door neighbour, Mr Ali Rıza Kırçay, the deceased was sitting on the terrace by himself and watching television before he was killed.", "source_paragraph": 139, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F429", "text": "On the basis of Mr Ali Rıza Kırçay's statement, Mehmet Özdamar excluded the possibility that Mr Kutlu Adalı could have been sitting with some other persons on the terrace.", "source_paragraph": 139, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F430", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar identified a glass, a bottle and an ashtray in a photograph shown to him of the scene.", "source_paragraph": 139, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F431", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar knew the deceased by sight and through his articles in an opposition newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 140, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F432", "text": "When investigating the murder of Mr Kutlu Adalı, every aspect of the case was considered, including whether it was a political crime or one related to Mr Adalı's activities as a journalist, but there was no evidence significant enough to lead to any of these conclusions.", "source_paragraph": 140, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F433", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar was informed about the applicant's allegation that the head of the Civil Defence Organisation had made threats against Mr Kutlu Adalı personally or against the Yenidüzen newspaper because of an article concerning the St Barnabas incident.", "source_paragraph": 140, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F434", "text": "The prosecuting authorities did not verify the allegation about the Civil Defence Organisation's head making threats since the applicant could not name anyone and she had constantly made similar inconsistent allegations.", "source_paragraph": 140, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F435", "text": "As an example of the applicant's inconsistent allegations, Mehmet Özdamar referred to the applicant's statements in which she had described Altay Sayıl as a close friend of her husband who visited their home every day, and had then complained to the authorities that she suspected Mr Sayıl of involvement in the murder.", "source_paragraph": 140, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F436", "text": "Following the receipt of an anonymous telephone call alleging that a person named Hüseyin Demirci and another person described as Colonel Orhan were involved in the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı, the prosecuting authorities found Mr Demirci and took statements from him.", "source_paragraph": 141, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F437", "text": "It was established that Mr Hüseyin Demirci had been outside Lefkoşa on the night of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing, having been at a dinner in the Güzelyurt area in the company of Mustafa Asilhan, who was the first assistant of the Chief of Police, and Muharrem Göç, a police inspector.", "source_paragraph": 141, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F438", "text": "Mustafa Asilhan confirmed to Mehmet Özdamar that he had been out for dinner with Mr Hüseyin Demirci on the night of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 141, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F439", "text": "A statement was also taken from Muharrem Göç confirming the dinner between Mr Hüseyin Demirci and Mustafa Asilhan.", "source_paragraph": 141, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F440", "text": "The anonymous caller who named Hüseyin Demirci was a lady who could not be identified.", "source_paragraph": 141, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F441", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar denied having told the applicant that the anonymous caller was a crazy woman who had often made such allegations to the police.", "source_paragraph": 141, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F442", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar knew Altay Sayıl from the time they had enrolled to the police academy and had attended the same course.", "source_paragraph": 142, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F443", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar denied having told the applicant that Altay Sayıl was a very good person and that he had nothing to do with the killing.", "source_paragraph": 142, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F444", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar stated that he had never spoken to the applicant about Altay Sayıl.", "source_paragraph": 142, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F445", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar stated that he had never taken a statement from the applicant in relation to Kutlu Adalı and the applicant had never approached him to be supplied with a copy of such a statement.", "source_paragraph": 142, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F446", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar stressed that no security commander had been dismissed or forced to relinquish his post for any reason, contrary to the applicant's allegation that the chief of the security forces had been removed from his post because of the articles written by Mr Kutlu Adalı on the basis of documents supplied by Altay Sayıl.", "source_paragraph": 142, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F447", "text": "Regarding a tip-off to Yusuf Özkum, who was then the Chief of Police, about Mr Hüseyin Demirci, Mehmet Özdamar stated that they had had no chance to investigate the woman caller since she had not given her name and had asked her identity to be kept secret.", "source_paragraph": 143, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F448", "text": "On 8 July 1996 the pro-Government newspaper Kıbrıs reported that it had received a statement from a fascist group called the Turkish Revenge Brigade claiming responsibility for the murder of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 144, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F449", "text": "No investigation was conducted into the Turkish Revenge Brigade's claim of responsibility as such an organisation did not exist in the \"TRNC\" and the investigating authorities considered that the allegation had been made as a ploy designed to cause confusion.", "source_paragraph": 144, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F450", "text": "The applicant had never asked Mehmet Özdamar to supply her with a copy of the autopsy report.", "source_paragraph": 145, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F451", "text": "Documents contained in the investigation file were confidential; only the investigating officer and his superiors as well as the Attorney-General's office could have access to them.", "source_paragraph": 145, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F452", "text": "Mehmet Özdamar was not involved in the subsequent investigation that followed from 15 October 2002.", "source_paragraph": 145, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "3. Mehmet Özdamar"]}, {"fact_id": "F453", "text": "Witness Refik Öztümen was born in 1953.", "source_paragraph": 146, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F454", "text": "At the time of the oral evidence hearing, Refik Öztümen was working at the judicial branch attached to the \"TRNC\" General Police Headquarters.", "source_paragraph": 146, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F455", "text": "At the time of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing, Refik Öztümen was the chief of Yenişehir police station, attached to the Lefkoşa police headquarters.", "source_paragraph": 146, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F456", "text": "Refik Öztümen was informed about the incident at 11.40 p.m. at the station and sent the sergeant on duty to the scene of the incident together with a team.", "source_paragraph": 147, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F457", "text": "Refik Öztümen asked for a doctor from the local hospital to be sent to the scene of the incident.", "source_paragraph": 147, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F458", "text": "Refik Öztümen went to the scene of the crime along with a police officer and arrived there at 11.45 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 147, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F459", "text": "Refik Öztümen saw the deceased, Mr Kutlu Adalı, lying on the ground 55 metres from the door of his house in Ardıç Street.", "source_paragraph": 147, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F460", "text": "Refik Öztümen checked the deceased and took his pulse.", "source_paragraph": 147, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F461", "text": "Refik Öztümen called out \"Anybody in?\" at the applicant's house; the door was open and the television was on, and there was nobody in the house.", "source_paragraph": 147, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F462", "text": "Refik Öztümen learned from the neighbour waiting outside that Mr Kutlu Adalı's family was abroad.", "source_paragraph": 147, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F463", "text": "At around 3 or 3.30 a.m. Refik Öztümen entered the applicant's house along with the muhtar, Yusuf Özkum, Mehmet Özdamar and the brother-in-law of the deceased.", "source_paragraph": 147, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F464", "text": "Refik Öztümen and those with him looked for a clue that could have shed light on the incident but could not find anything.", "source_paragraph": 147, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F465", "text": "There was one plastic chair and one table on the terrace of the applicant's house, giving the impression that Mr Kutlu Adalı had been sitting on the terrace just before he was killed in the street.", "source_paragraph": 147, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F466", "text": "Refik Öztümen and those with him did not consider taking fingerprints on account of the fact that the incident had taken place outside the house.", "source_paragraph": 147, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F467", "text": "There was nothing on the terrace of the applicant's house; no glasses and bottles or any trace indicating that cigarettes had been smoked.", "source_paragraph": 147, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F468", "text": "The officers assigned by Refik Öztümen visited the families living in the close vicinity and further away from the scene of the incident and noted their names, interviewing those who were at home at the time of the incident.", "source_paragraph": 148, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F469", "text": "The officers also went to the home of the Khan family of Pakistani origin and established that the family was not at home.", "source_paragraph": 148, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F470", "text": "Refik Öztümen rang the bell of the Khan family the next day and the following evening but to no avail.", "source_paragraph": 148, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F471", "text": "The Khan family's neighbour, Ali Rıza Bey (Kırçay), told Refik Öztümen that the Khan family was not in.", "source_paragraph": 148, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F472", "text": "The police officers guarded the applicant's house until she arrived from abroad.", "source_paragraph": 148, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F473", "text": "Apart from the cartridges found at the scene of the incident, the applicant and the officers in charge conducted a search along the whole street with a view to finding anything that might have been left by the assailants, but could not find anything.", "source_paragraph": 149, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F474", "text": "The cartridges found at the scene of Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing were first examined against those in the \"TRNC\" and no matches could be found, then they were sent to a forensic laboratory in Ankara, but no positive result had been obtained about the weapon which could have discharged them.", "source_paragraph": 149, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F475", "text": "The weapon found in the possession of Abdullah Çatlı following his death was also put through a forensic test in connection with the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı, and the result was negative.", "source_paragraph": 149, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F476", "text": "Refik Öztümen denied that he was related to the applicant, but remarked that his brother's daughter had married the applicant's sister-in-law.", "source_paragraph": 150, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F477", "text": "Refik Öztümen stated that he had never met or spoken to the applicant prior to the impugned incident.", "source_paragraph": 150, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F478", "text": "Refik Öztümen rejected the applicant's allegation that he had told her sister-in-law that the security forces had given him instructions not to follow the investigation effectively.", "source_paragraph": 150, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F479", "text": "Refik Öztümen stressed that the applicant had never asked him to take statements from Mr Ziya Kasapoğlu.", "source_paragraph": 150, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F480", "text": "Refik Öztümen denied the applicant's assertion that he had asked to meet her at her sister-in-law's house.", "source_paragraph": 150, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F481", "text": "Refik Öztümen maintained that he had met the applicant at least ten times at her house following her husband's death and had also spoken to her in connection with the damaged tyre incident and other problems.", "source_paragraph": 150, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F482", "text": "Refik Öztümen led the investigation carried out in October 2002.", "source_paragraph": 151, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F483", "text": "In 1996 Mr İsmail Koşman was the commander of the security forces; in August of the same year he was replaced by Hasan Peker Günal.", "source_paragraph": 151, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F484", "text": "No investigation was carried out into the role of the Civil Defence Organisation in Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing since no allegation involving the responsibility of the Civil Defence Organisation was communicated to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 151, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F485", "text": "The Ministry of National Education investigated the St Barnabas incident and concluded that the Civil Defence Organisation had conducted an exercise.", "source_paragraph": 151, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F486", "text": "The applicant had never made an allegation in relation to Orhan Ceylan in the course of her talks or meetings with Refik Öztümen.", "source_paragraph": 152, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F487", "text": "The distance between Gemikonağı and Lefkoşa was approximately 55-60 kilometres, in other words approximately an hour's distance.", "source_paragraph": 152, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "4. Refik Öztümen"]}, {"fact_id": "F488", "text": "Witness Hasan Peker Günal was born in 1948.", "source_paragraph": 153, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F489", "text": "At the time of the oral evidence hearing, Hasan Peker Günal was a retired major-general.", "source_paragraph": 153, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F490", "text": "In July 1996 Hasan Peker Günal was the commander of a commando brigade in south-east Anatolia in Turkey.", "source_paragraph": 153, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F491", "text": "Between 19 August 1996 and 15 August 1998 Hasan Peker Günal served as the commander of the security forces in the \"TRNC\".", "source_paragraph": 153, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F492", "text": "Subsequent to his arrival on the island, Hasan Peker Günal learned about the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı through articles in the press.", "source_paragraph": 153, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F493", "text": "In view of the allegations that the Turkish armed forces had been involved in the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı, Hasan Peker Günal asked the General Police Headquarters to brief him about the event.", "source_paragraph": 153, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F494", "text": "At the end of August or early September 1996, Mr Atilla Sav and his delegation briefed Hasan Peker Günal about the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı and the current state of the investigation at the office of the Chief of Police.", "source_paragraph": 153, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F495", "text": "According to the Constitution of the \"TRNC\", the police were under the authority of the commander of the security forces in the administrative field, and in the judicial field operated under the supervision of the chief prosecutor's office.", "source_paragraph": 153, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F496", "text": "The commander of the security forces was responsible to the Prime Minister of the \"TRNC\".", "source_paragraph": 153, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F497", "text": "The applicant wrote a letter to Hasan Peker Günal complaining about the conduct of the investigation into her husband's killing.", "source_paragraph": 154, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F498", "text": "Hasan Peker Günal told the applicant through the police liaison officer that he was unable to intervene in a judicial affair but, if she wished, he could meet her.", "source_paragraph": 154, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F499", "text": "A meeting was held on 12 December 1996 at the office of the chief of police, Mr Atilla Sav, attended by Mr Atilla Sav, the applicant, her daughter, Hasan Peker Günal and a few other police officers who were involved in the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 154, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F500", "text": "During the meeting on 12 December 1996, the applicant was given all relevant information about the investigation into her husband's killing.", "source_paragraph": 154, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F501", "text": "Hasan Peker Günal asked the investigators to take all necessary measures to find the perpetrators of the murder so that they could save the honour of the \"TRNC\" and that of the security forces whose involvement in the event was in question.", "source_paragraph": 154, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F502", "text": "At the meeting on 12 December 1996, the applicant stated that she had been threatened several times and that she had been receiving anonymous calls, but at no stage did she ask for protection.", "source_paragraph": 154, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F503", "text": "Hasan Peker Günal denied having told the applicant that she had already been protected by plain-clothes police officers.", "source_paragraph": 155, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F504", "text": "At the meeting on 12 December 1996, the applicant did not make an allegation in relation to the Civil Defence Organisation.", "source_paragraph": 155, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F505", "text": "Hasan Peker Günal denied that he had pointed at the cars outside through the window of the meeting room and had told the applicant that they were there to protect her, stating that the room was a small office where you could not look out and see a car outside.", "source_paragraph": 155, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F506", "text": "The meeting on 12 December 1996 was not a secret one and was reported in the press.", "source_paragraph": 155, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F507", "text": "Hasan Peker Günal spoke to the applicant on other occasions and once met her concerning her late husband's entitlements for the period of his military service.", "source_paragraph": 156, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F508", "text": "Hasan Peker Günal was informed about developments in the investigation into Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing in the course of monthly coordination meetings.", "source_paragraph": 156, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F509", "text": "Hasan Peker Günal told the police force to examine even the slightest suspicion and made it clear that if they wanted to investigate anything connected with the armed forces or any members of the armed forces he would not obstruct it.", "source_paragraph": 156, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F510", "text": "There was not the slightest indication of any member of the security forces being involved in the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 156, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F511", "text": "According to Hasan Peker Günal, there was no political motive behind the murder of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 156, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F512", "text": "Hasan Peker Günal had not heard any allegations about Colonel Orhan Ceylan.", "source_paragraph": 157, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F513", "text": "During Hasan Peker Günal's term of office in the \"TRNC\", no one under his command was ever the subject of an investigation.", "source_paragraph": 157, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F514", "text": "Hasan Peker Günal noted that the Civil Defence Organisation was not a unit under the authority of the security forces but was responsible to the Prime Minister.", "source_paragraph": 157, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "5. Hasan Peker Günal"]}, {"fact_id": "F515", "text": "Witness Atilla Sav was born in 1938.", "source_paragraph": 158, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F516", "text": "Atilla Sav is a former police chief who retired on 4 May 1998.", "source_paragraph": 158, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F517", "text": "In July 1996 Atilla Sav was the Chief of Police in the \"TRNC\".", "source_paragraph": 158, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F518", "text": "Atilla Sav learned about the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı whilst he was at an engagement party.", "source_paragraph": 159, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F519", "text": "Atilla Sav arrived at the scene of the incident almost an hour and a half after the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 159, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F520", "text": "When Atilla Sav arrived at the scene, the police had already secured the house and barred the public from entering.", "source_paragraph": 159, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F521", "text": "Atilla Sav stayed at the crime scene for half an hour and entered the Adalı family's house along with other officers, not noticing anything out of the ordinary.", "source_paragraph": 159, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F522", "text": "Atilla Sav knew Mr Kutlu Adalı by name and knew that he was a journalist who wrote articles in the Yenidüzen critical of the Government, but had not seen him before.", "source_paragraph": 159, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F523", "text": "Atilla Sav was regularly informed by the officers about developments in the investigation into Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing.", "source_paragraph": 159, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F524", "text": "On 12 December 1996 a meeting was held in Atilla Sav's office with the applicant, her daughter, Hasan Peker Günal and Mehmet Özdamar, who was then the chief of the forensic police.", "source_paragraph": 160, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F525", "text": "The meeting on 12 December 1996 was held at the request of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 160, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F526", "text": "At the meeting on 12 December 1996, the applicant gave all relevant information to the participants about the incident and complained that she had been receiving anonymous phone calls during which she had been threatened.", "source_paragraph": 160, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F527", "text": "At the meeting on 12 December 1996, the applicant was advised to apply to the telecommunications department to have her line monitored.", "source_paragraph": 160, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F528", "text": "At the meeting on 12 December 1996, the applicant raised her suspicion about Mr Hüseyin Demirci and was told that statements from Mr Demirci had been taken by the police.", "source_paragraph": 160, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F529", "text": "Atilla Sav stated that he had known Mr Ziya Kasapoğlu since 1956 and also knew Altay Sayıl as a police officer who was now retired.", "source_paragraph": 161, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F530", "text": "Atilla Sav did not remember whether Altay Sayıl and Ziya Kasapoğlu's names had been mentioned during the meeting on 12 December 1996.", "source_paragraph": 161, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F531", "text": "Atilla Sav did not know or remember the applicant's allegations about Colonel Orhan Ceylan or the Civil Defence Organisation.", "source_paragraph": 161, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F532", "text": "Atilla Sav did not remember whether any notes had been taken as regards the applicant's statements or allegations at the meeting on 12 December 1996.", "source_paragraph": 161, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F533", "text": "Atilla Sav did not need to intervene in the investigation in any way since there were no deficiencies and it was being conducted according to its normal course.", "source_paragraph": 162, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F534", "text": "The applicant had not told Atilla Sav about her suspicion concerning the involvement of the Civil Defence Organisation in the killing of her husband.", "source_paragraph": 162, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F535", "text": "Atilla Sav pointed out that it would have been inappropriate to qualify the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı as politically motivated before concluding the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 162, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F536", "text": "When the police had completed the investigation, the files had been given to the chief prosecutor who had supervised the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 162, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F537", "text": "Atilla Sav remarked that only the materials which were considered to be part of the evidence had been retained, and that Mr Kutlu Adalı's glasses could have been considered as irrelevant in respect of the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 162, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F538", "text": "Atilla Sav stressed that during the meeting on 12 December 1996, the commander of the security forces had not pointed at cars outside the building telling the applicant that they were protecting her, noting that the office did not have a window overlooking the car park.", "source_paragraph": 162, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "6. Atilla Sav"]}, {"fact_id": "F539", "text": "Witness Galip Mendi was born in 1951.", "source_paragraph": 163, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F540", "text": "At the time of the oral evidence hearing, Galip Mendi was the Field Operations Deputy Chief-of-Staff in the Turkish armed forces.", "source_paragraph": 163, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F541", "text": "Galip Mendi was the head of the Civil Defence Organisation between August 1994 and July 1996.", "source_paragraph": 163, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F542", "text": "Galip Mendi served as the commander of the \"TRNC\" security forces between 2000 and 2002.", "source_paragraph": 163, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F543", "text": "According to \"TRNC\" legislation, the head of the Civil Defence Organisation can be any person, whether a civilian or a military person, provided that that person is a Turkish national.", "source_paragraph": 164, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F544", "text": "Given that the post of head of the Civil Defence Organisation requires expertise and that the \"TRNC\" is a newly established state, the heads of the Civil Defence Organisation are appointed from among the members of the Turkish armed forces.", "source_paragraph": 164, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F545", "text": "The Civil Defence Organisation is a humanitarian rescue organisation which protects institutions and organisations as well as the life and property of the civilian population during wartime or in the event of natural disasters such as floods and earthquakes.", "source_paragraph": 165, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F546", "text": "The Civil Defence Organisation does not have any military functions; its officers do not wear uniform and do not possess arms.", "source_paragraph": 165, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F547", "text": "In certain rescue operations, in cases of fire or floods, officers of the Civil Defence Organisation wear special clothing.", "source_paragraph": 165, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F548", "text": "There is no organisational link between the Turkish armed forces and the Civil Defence Organisation, the latter being directly under the authority of the Prime Minister's office.", "source_paragraph": 165, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F549", "text": "In certain cases, such as floods, fire or war, the Civil Defence Organisation cooperates with the military in the performance of its tasks.", "source_paragraph": 165, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F550", "text": "Galip Mendi stated that the Civil Defence Organisation is not a secret organisation or an intelligence agency as alleged by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 165, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F551", "text": "Galip Mendi did not know Mr Kutlu Adalı personally but used to read his articles published in the Yenidüzen newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 166, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F552", "text": "Galip Mendi knew that the applicant had worked in the civil defence people's army and held a post in Girne (Kyrenia) People's Army.", "source_paragraph": 166, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F553", "text": "Mr and Ms Adalı were given certificates for their services at a ceremony organised in Girne, which was the only occasion on which Galip Mendi had met them.", "source_paragraph": 166, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F554", "text": "Mr Kutlu Adalı had represented the Ministry of Culture in the Civil Defence Committee between 1978 and 1980.", "source_paragraph": 166, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F555", "text": "Galip Mendi denied that the Civil Defence Organisation could have been involved in the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 167, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F556", "text": "Galip Mendi noted that he had not been involved in the investigation into Mr Kutlu Adalı's killing and that the oral evidence hearing was the first time he had been questioned about it.", "source_paragraph": 167, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F557", "text": "Galip Mendi was aware of the allegations that the Civil Defence Organisation had been involved in the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı, but stated that neither he nor the Civil Defence Organisation had a problem with Mr Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 167, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F558", "text": "Galip Mendi did not deem it necessary to carry out an investigation within the Civil Defence Organisation as he considered that the allegations were totally unfounded.", "source_paragraph": 167, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F559", "text": "Galip Mendi's term of office as head of the Civil Defence Organisation ended a month after the incident and he left the island in August 1996.", "source_paragraph": 168, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F560", "text": "On his return to Turkey, Galip Mendi reported to his superiors that neither he nor any other person in the Civil Defence Organisation had been involved in the murder of Mr Kutlu Adalı.", "source_paragraph": 168, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F561", "text": "Galip Mendi averred that the St Barnabas incident had in no way been connected with the Civil Defence Organisation; it was an anti-terrorist operation carried out by the peace forces command at the time.", "source_paragraph": 169, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F562", "text": "The allegations that the Civil Defence Organisation was involved in the St Barnabas incident stemmed from the fact that Galip Mendi's organisation had allocated a civilian car to the peace forces, who wore official uniforms, for an operation conducted against the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 169, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F563", "text": "Apart from the allocation of a car, the Civil Defence Organisation had not intervened in any activity connected with the St Barnabas incident.", "source_paragraph": 169, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F564", "text": "There were many newspaper articles on the St Barnabas incident and the alleged involvement of the Civil Defence Organisation, some of which were written by Mr Kutlu Adalı in Yenidüzen.", "source_paragraph": 170, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F565", "text": "Galip Mendi did not call on any newspaper to refute the allegations about the Civil Defence Organisation's involvement in the St Barnabas incident, but instructed his colleagues in the press department to telephone the newspaper and tell them that the organisation had not been involved.", "source_paragraph": 170, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F566", "text": "One of Galip Mendi's colleagues conveyed the message to the Yenidüzen newspaper, possibly to the editor-in-chief, in appropriate language and reported back to him that it had been well received.", "source_paragraph": 170, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F567", "text": "Galip Mendi met Hüseyin Demirci in one of the training courses on civil defence services, just as he met many other local people.", "source_paragraph": 171, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F568", "text": "Galip Mendi denied the applicant's allegation that Mr Hüseyin Demirci was his adviser.", "source_paragraph": 171, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F569", "text": "Galip Mendi stated that he had known Orhan Ceylan as a renowned officer who was now retired after a career of heroic service, but was not acquainted with him.", "source_paragraph": 171, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F570", "text": "Galip Mendi denied the applicant's allegation that he had left the island two days before the killing of Mr Kutlu Adalı, namely on 4 July 1996, and stressed that he had left the island in the second week of August 1996 subsequent to the end of his term of office.", "source_paragraph": 172, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F571", "text": "When asked about the allegations made by Mr Kutlu Adalı in his column in the 23 March 1996 edition of Yenidüzen in relation to the St Barnabas incident, Galip Mendi contested the allegations and stated that it had been an anti-terrorist operation, for which he had provided a white Renault Toros car.", "source_paragraph": 172, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F572", "text": "Galip Mendi stated that he had not reacted to a television programme on Show TV during which allegations had been made by the editor of Yenidüzen to the effect that he had made a threatening call to the newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 173, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F573", "text": "Galip Mendi explained that it was not possible to react to the allegations without obtaining the authorisation of the General Staff of the Turkish armed forces.", "source_paragraph": 173, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}, {"fact_id": "F574", "text": "As regards an article published in the Afrika newspaper which referred to Mustafa Asilhan as Galip Mendi's adviser who had allegedly said that it would have been better had they not written about the involvement of the Civil Defence Organisation, Galip Mendi stressed that Mr Asilhan had never been an adviser to him and that the allegations were untrue.", "source_paragraph": 174, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Oral evidence", "7. Galip Mendi"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F100"], "interference": ["F100", "F178", "F179"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F100", "F178", "F179"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F100"], "interference": ["F100", "F178", "F179"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F100", "F178", "F179"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F100", "F178", "F179"]}} {"case_name": "case_111", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention and its Protocol.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_112", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1982.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "At the material time, the applicant was deputy chairman of the Youth Committee of an opposition party called Musavat.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held on 2 April 2011 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held on 20 October 2012 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 18 March 2011, the organisers of the 2 April 2011 demonstration, who were members of the opposition, gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority of the planned assembly.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 15 October 2012, the organisers of the 20 October 2012 demonstration, who were members of the opposition, gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority of the planned assembly.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority refused to authorise the demonstrations at the places indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority proposed a different location for the demonstrations on the outskirts of Baku, specifically the yard of a driving school situated in the 20th habitable area of the Sabail District.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The organisers decided to hold the demonstrations in the centre of Baku, notwithstanding the Baku City Executive Authority's refusal to authorise the demonstrations at the places indicated.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstrations were intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstrations were conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The participants in the demonstrations were demanding free and fair elections in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The participants in the demonstrations were demanding democratic reforms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant attended the demonstration on 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicant attended the demonstration on 20 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Shortly after the demonstration on 2 April 2011 had begun, the police started to disperse those who had gathered.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Shortly after the demonstration on 20 October 2012 had begun, the police started to disperse those who had gathered.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant was arrested during the dispersal operation at the demonstration on 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant was arrested during the dispersal operation at the demonstration on 20 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "After his arrest at the demonstration on 2 April 2011, the applicant was taken to a police station where he was questioned.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "After his arrest at the demonstration on 20 October 2012, the applicant was taken to a police station where he was questioned.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the applicant, at the demonstration on 20 October 2012 he was arrested by people in plain clothes.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 2 April 2011, the day of the applicant's arrest, an administrative offence report was issued against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 20 October 2012, the day of the applicant's arrest, an administrative offence report was issued against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The administrative offence report issued on 2 April 2011 stated that by deliberately failing to comply with a lawful order of the police, the applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The administrative offence report issued on 20 October 2012 stated that by deliberately failing to comply with a lawful order of the police, the applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "In the first case (arrest on 2 April 2011), the applicant refused to sign the administrative offence report.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with copies of the administrative offence reports from his case files.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with other documents from his case files.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "In the first case (arrest on 2 April 2011), the applicant was not given access to a lawyer after his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "In the first case (arrest on 2 April 2011), the applicant was not given access to a lawyer while he was in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "In the second case (arrest on 20 October 2012), the applicant was not given access to a lawyer after his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "In the second case (arrest on 20 October 2012), the applicant was not given access to a lawyer while he was in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 2 April 2011, the day of his arrest in the first case, the applicant was brought before the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 20 October 2012, the day of his arrest in the second case, the applicant was brought before the Binagadi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing before the court in the first case was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing before the court in the second case was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Members of the public, including human rights defenders and journalists, were not allowed inside the courtroom at the hearing in the first case.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Members of the public, including human rights defenders and journalists, were not allowed inside the courtroom at the hearing in the second case.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "At the hearing in the first case, the court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearing to the public.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "At the hearing in the second case, the court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearing to the public.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the applicant, in the first case he was not given an opportunity to appoint a lawyer of his own choosing.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the applicant, in the second case he was not given an opportunity to appoint a lawyer of his own choosing.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "At the hearing in the first case before the Nasimi District Court, the applicant was not represented by a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to documents submitted by the Government, the applicant refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer at the hearing in the first case.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to documents submitted by the Government, the applicant decided to defend himself in person at the hearing in the first case.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "At the hearing in the second case before the Binagadi District Court, a State-funded lawyer was invited to assist the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "According to the transcript of the court hearing in the second case, the State-funded lawyer made oral submissions in which he briefly asked the court to impose on the applicant a light punishment in view of the applicant's young age.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The only witness questioned during the court hearing in the first case was a police officer who, according to official records, had arrested the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The police officer questioned at the hearing in the first case testified that the applicant had staged an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "At the hearing in the second case, the court did not question any witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "In the first case, the Nasimi District Court found that the applicant had failed to stop participating in an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In the second case, the Binagadi District Court found that the applicant had failed to stop participating in an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "By a decision of 2 April 2011, the Nasimi District Court convicted the applicant under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "By a decision of 2 April 2011, the Nasimi District Court sentenced the applicant to seven days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "By a decision of 20 October 2012, the Binagadi District Court convicted the applicant under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "By a decision of 20 October 2012, the Binagadi District Court sentenced the applicant to ten days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On unspecified dates, the applicant lodged appeals with the Baku Court of Appeal against his conviction in the first case.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On unspecified dates, the applicant lodged appeals with the Baku Court of Appeal against his conviction in the second case.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "In his appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant argued that his convictions were in violation of his rights because the demonstrations in which he had participated or attempted to participate had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "In his appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant complained that his arrests had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In his appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant complained that the hearings before the respective first-instance courts had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "In the first case, the applicant was represented before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer of his own choosing.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "In the second case, the applicant was represented before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer of his own choosing.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 11 April 2011, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal in the first case and upheld the decision of the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 29 October 2012, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal in the second case and upheld the decision of the Binagadi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 2 April 2011, Article 410.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 provided that an individual who is subject to administrative offence proceedings or a representative of a legal entity shall be given an opportunity to familiarise himself with the administrative offence report.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 2 April 2011, Article 410.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 provided that an individual who is subject to administrative offence proceedings or a representative of a legal entity has the right to a copy of the administrative offence report.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "A summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, relevant provisions concerning the organisation and holding of public assemblies, and relevant extracts of international documents can be found in the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, paragraphs 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F011", "F012", "F015", "F016", "F019"], "interference": ["F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F055", "F056", "F057", "F058"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F026", "F027", "F008", "F009", "F070"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F017", "F018", "F053", "F054", "F055", "F057"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F011", "F012", "F015", "F016", "F019"], "interference": ["F017", "F019", "F055", "F056"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F026", "F008", "F070"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F006", "F011", "F012", "F017", "F055"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F006", "F008", "F011", "F012", "F015", "F017", "F019", "F055", "F056", "F070"]}} {"case_name": "case_113", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and their representatives and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained under Article 11 of the Convention of the disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under Article 6 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_116", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1980.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1979.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The first applicant lives in Hatay.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The second applicant lives in Urfa.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 3 May 1998, Kenan Mak, a student at the Abant İzzet Baysal University in Bolu, was killed in an attack.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "After 3 May 1998, on 3 May of every subsequent year, students at the Abant İzzet Baysal University in Bolu have held a meeting to mark the anniversary of the killing of Kenan Mak.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 3 May 2002, the two applicants were studying at the Abant İzzet Baysal University in Bolu.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 3 May 2002, the two applicants attended the remembrance meeting at the Abant İzzet Baysal University in Bolu.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 2 May 2002 (the day before the meeting), the chancellor of the Abant İzzet Baysal University in Bolu indicated his approval of the meeting taking place in the canteen of the university.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to a report drawn up by gendarmes responsible for the security of the Abant İzzet Baysal University in Bolu, seventy to eighty 'left wing students' wearing photographs of Kenan Mak gathered in the university's canteen on 3 May 2002.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The students then proceeded from the university's canteen to the university's garden on 3 May 2002.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "In the university's garden, the students were met by gendarme Captain F.Y.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Captain F.Y. told the students that their gathering was in breach of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) because they were not holding it in the designated place, namely the canteen.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Captain F.Y. asked the students to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Captain F.Y. warned the students that 'otherwise force would be used' to disperse them.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Instead of dispersing, the students displayed a banner stating 'down with fascism, Kenan Mak is immortal'.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The students chanted slogans such as 'shoulder to shoulder against fascism'.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The students started walking towards the chancellor's offices of the Abant İzzet Baysal University in Bolu.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The gendarmes present in the vicinity used force and dispersed the students.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The two applicants and seven other students were arrested by the gendarmes.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "During the scuffle, Captain F.Y.'s little finger was injured by the students.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "During the scuffle, a gendarme's leg was injured by the students.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicants were questioned on 3 May 2002 by gendarme officers.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicants stated during questioning on 3 May 2002 that they were aware that prior permission had been sought and granted for the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 3 May 2002, the applicants were examined by a doctor.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicants did not complain about any ill-treatment during the medical examination on 3 May 2002.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The doctor did not observe any injuries on the applicants' bodies during the medical examination on 3 May 2002.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "After the medical examination, the applicants were sent to the prosecutor's office.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The prosecutor's office ordered the release of the applicants on 3 May 2002.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 28 May 2002, the gendarme whose leg was injured during the incident informed the prosecutor that the name of the student who injured him was C.G.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 5 July 2002, the Bolu prosecutor filed an indictment with the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Bolu prosecutor accused the applicants and the remaining seven students of breaching the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Bolu prosecutor stated in his indictment that the applicants and C.G. had punched and kicked gendarme Captain F.Y.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Bolu prosecutor stated in his indictment that the applicants and C.G. had punched and kicked a gendarme.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "In the course of the criminal proceedings, the applicants rejected the allegations of the use of force by them.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "In the course of the criminal proceedings, the applicants accepted that they had taken part in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Captain F.Y. was not heard directly by the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Captain F.Y. was questioned by a court in another city, pursuant to a letter rogatory sent to that court by the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 6 May 2003, the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance convicted the applicants of having taken part in an illegal demonstration, on the basis of statements given by eyewitnesses, gendarmes, and video footage of the incident.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 6 May 2003, the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance convicted the applicants of having used force when the gathering was being dispersed by the gendarmes, in breach of section 32 § 3 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the judgment of 6 May 2003, in addition to Captain F.Y. and the gendarme with the injured leg, four other gendarmes had also apparently been injured by the applicants and their fellow student C.G.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance sentenced the applicants to two years and six months' imprisonment on 6 May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The applicants appealed against the judgment of 6 May 2003 of the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "In their appeals, the applicants argued that there had been insufficient evidence to warrant their conviction.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "In their appeals, the applicants argued that they had not been given the opportunity to examine the video footage.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In their appeals, the applicants referred to their constitutional right to take part in, inter alia, peaceful demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In their appeals, the applicants drew the Court of Cassation's attention to the fact that similar gatherings had been organised in the past to commemorate Kenan Mak's death and that there had never been any problems caused by those gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 9 March 2006, the Court of Cassation upheld the judgment of the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance in respect of the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicants asked the prosecutor at the Court of Cassation to apply to the Court of Cassation for rectification of the decision of 9 March 2006.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In their letter to the prosecutor at the Court of Cassation, the applicants pointed out that none of the injured gendarmes had accused them of inflicting their injuries.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The prosecutor at the Court of Cassation accepted the applicants' request for rectification.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 31 July 2006, the prosecutor at the Court of Cassation applied to the Court of Cassation's president for rectification of the decision of 9 March 2006.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "In his application for rectification, the prosecutor noted that none of the injured gendarmes had named the applicants as the persons responsible for their injuries.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In his application for rectification, the prosecutor referred to Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In his application for rectification, the prosecutor argued that university grounds could not be regarded as public places within the meaning of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "In his application for rectification, the prosecutor argued that the applicants' and their fellow students' actions could not therefore be regarded to be in breach of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In his application for rectification, the prosecutor argued that the students' failure to hold their meeting in a place other than the one for which permission had been granted could only be regarded as a disciplinary issue to be dealt with by the university administration and not by courts of law.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "In his application for rectification, the prosecutor noted that the disturbance in the demonstration had been caused by the gendarmes' intervention.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "In his application for rectification, the prosecutor noted that the reports drawn up by the gendarmes who had taken part in the operation had not made any mention of physical resistance by the students.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "In his application for rectification, the prosecutor noted that the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance had not examined the video footage.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "In his application for rectification, the prosecutor noted that the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance had not asked the injured gendarmes to identify the persons responsible for their injuries.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "In his application for rectification, the prosecutor argued that the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance's decision to convict the applicants under section 32 § 3 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) had not been in accordance with applicable law and procedure.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In its decision of 10 October 2006, the Grand Chamber of the Court of Cassation's Criminal Division observed that the transcripts of one of the hearings held by the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance did not bear the signature of the court's clerk.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 10 October 2006, the Grand Chamber of the Court of Cassation's Criminal Division quashed the decision convicting the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Grand Chamber of the Court of Cassation's Criminal Division deemed it unnecessary to examine the points raised by the prosecutor in his application for rectification.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "A retrial began before the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance following the quashing of the conviction.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance rendered its retrial decision on 24 October 2007.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Having examined the video footage, the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance observed that eleven and a half minutes had elapsed between the beginning of the gathering and its dispersal by the gendarmes.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance noted that neither the applicants nor any of the other participants in the demonstration had used force against the gendarmes.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Nevertheless, the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance considered that the applicants and the other students had taken part in an unauthorised meeting and had thus acted in breach of section 32 §1 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "According to the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance, the gathering had been unlawful because it had not been organised in the canteen but rather had taken place outside.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance sentenced the applicants to one year and three months' imprisonment on 24 October 2007.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The sentence of one year and three months' imprisonment imposed on the applicants on 24 October 2007 was suspended.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The applicants appealed against the retrial decision of 24 October 2007 of the Bolu Criminal Court of First Instance.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The appeal proceedings against the retrial decision of 24 October 2007 are still pending before the Court of Cassation.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 9 December 2002, on account of his participation in the demonstration of 3 May 2002, the Abant İzzet Baysal University in Bolu imposed a disciplinary sanction on the first applicant Ali Akgöl.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 9 December 2002, the Abant İzzet Baysal University in Bolu expelled the first applicant Ali Akgöl from the university for two semesters.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The university's decision to expel the first applicant Ali Akgöl was not quashed by the administrative courts until 2004.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The university's decision to expel the first applicant Ali Akgöl was enforced, and the first applicant's graduation from the university was delayed for one year.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The first applicant Ali Akgöl completed his studies at the Abant İzzet Baysal University in Bolu and started working as a teacher.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 22 August 2006, the Ministry of Education dismissed the first applicant Ali Akgöl from his post as a teacher on account of his attendance at the demonstration of 3 May 2002.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The first applicant Ali Akgöl was reinstated in his post as a teacher in July 2007, following the quashing of his conviction by the Court of Cassation on 10 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "At the material time, section 10 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) required that, in order for a meeting to take place, the governor's office or authorities of the district in which the demonstration is planned must be informed, during opening hours and at least seventy-two hours prior to the meeting, by a notice containing the signature of all the members of the organising board.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Section 22 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) prohibits demonstrations and processions on public streets, in parks, places of worship and buildings in which public services are based.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Section 22 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) requires that demonstrations organised in public squares must comply with security instructions and not disrupt individuals' movement or public transport.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Section 24 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) provides that demonstrations and processions which do not comply with the provisions of that law will be dispersed by force on the order of the governor's office and after the demonstrators have been warned.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Section 32 § 1 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) provides that unarmed persons taking part in an unlawful meeting or procession who, instead of dispersing of their own motion after having been warned or ordered to do so and who thus have to be forcefully dispersed by government forces, are liable to be sentenced to a term of imprisonment of between one and three years.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Section 32 § 2 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) provides that, unless their action breaches another criminal law provision which stipulates a more severe punishment, persons who resort to violence or making threats while being dispersed, or who resist the attempts to disperse them, are liable to be sentenced to a term of imprisonment of between three and five years.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F005", "F008", "F010", "F016", "F017", "F020", "F036", "F068", "F069", "F070", "F072"], "interference": ["F019", "F020", "F031", "F032", "F036", "F066", "F070", "F072", "F075"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F087", "F088"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F005", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F016", "F017", "F068", "F069", "F070", "F072"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F008", "F010", "F016", "F017", "F036", "F069"], "interference": ["F019", "F020", "F075"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F087"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F009", "F011", "F068", "F069", "F070"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F019", "F068", "F069", "F070", "F009", "F011"]}} {"case_name": "case_118", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "On the dates indicated in the appended table, the applicants participated in political demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants were arrested at the venue of the political demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants were subsequently convicted of an administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants' details are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Government were represented by Mr G. Matyushkin, Representative of the Russian Federation at the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr A. Fedorov, Head of the Office of the Representative of the Russian Federation at the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr M. Galperin, Representative of the Russian Federation at the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On the dates indicated in the appended table, the applicants participated in political demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicants were apprehended at the venue of the political demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicants were transferred to police stations in Moscow after being apprehended.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Relevant administrative records were drawn up at the police stations in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The administrative offence records were based on the reports and explanations of the police officers who had arrested the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Akhunov, was released several hours after being apprehended.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Nemuchinskiy, remained in detention until the court hearing the next day.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On the dates stipulated in the appended table, the applicants were convicted under the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Akhunov, was convicted under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences, which concerns violating the established procedure for the conduct of a public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Akhunov, was ordered to pay a fine of 10,000 Russian roubles.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Nemuchinskiy, was convicted under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, which concerns refusal to obey the lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Nemuchinskiy, was sentenced to administrative imprisonment of fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The domestic courts relied on the administrative records and the reports and explanations of the police officers when convicting the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The domestic courts considered it unlawful that the applicants had shouted slogans during the demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The domestic courts considered it unlawful that the applicants had participated in a public assembly in respect of which no advance notification had been submitted to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic law can be found in Navalnyy v. Russia [GC] (nos. 29580/12 and 4 others, §§ 46-47, 15 November 2018).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The domestic legal provisions governing administrative transfer (escorting) and detention are set out in the case of Butkevich v. Russia (no. 5865/07, §§ 33-36, 13 February 2018).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to Article 31.9 of the Code of Administrative Offences, if a decision imposing an administrative punishment is not enforced within two years from its entry into force, it can no longer be executed.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to Article 31.9 of the Code of Administrative Offences, the time when enforcement of a decision imposing an administrative punishment is suspended or stayed is excluded from the two-year enforcement period.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002", "F009", "F010"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F010", "F011", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F018", "F020"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002", "F003", "F009", "F010", "F016", "F017", "F019", "F022", "F023"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F001"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002", "F003", "F022", "F023"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F001", "F002", "F003", "F022", "F023"]}} {"case_name": "case_120", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of the ban on holding lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) public assemblies imposed by the domestic authorities.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of the discriminatory manner in which the domestic authorities treated their applications for holding lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) public assembly events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_121", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The facts of the cases, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "In 2009-14, the applicants lodged notices of LGBT public assemblies as indicated in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "In each instance, the local authorities refused to approve the dates proposed by the applicants for the LGBT public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "In each instance, the local authorities refused to approve the locations proposed by the applicants for the LGBT public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants challenged the local authorities' refusal decisions in the domestic courts under Chapter 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The domestic courts upheld the decisions of the local authorities refusing to approve the dates and locations of the LGBT public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "In every case, the judicial decisions were taken after the respective dates of the originally proposed assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The dates of the authorities' refusals are indicated in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The dates of the final domestic decisions are indicated in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The relevant domestic law and practice is set out in Lashmankin and Others v. Russia, application nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, paragraphs 216-88, judgment of 7 February 2017.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The relevant international and comparative material is set out in Lashmankin and Others v. Russia, application nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, paragraphs 313-24, judgment of 7 February 2017.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The relevant domestic law and practice is also set out in Alekseyev v. Russia, application nos. 4916/07 and 2 others, paragraphs 49-52, judgment of 21 October 2010.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004", "F005", "F007"], "interference": ["F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F003", "F004", "F012"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F003", "F004", "F012"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003", "F004", "F012"]}} {"case_name": "case_122", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1977.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant is a gay rights activist.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "In 2006 the applicant, together with other individuals, organised a march to draw public attention to discrimination against the gay and lesbian minority in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The march organised in 2006 aimed to promote respect for human rights and freedoms.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The march organised in 2006 aimed to call for tolerance on the part of the Russian authorities and the public at large towards the gay and lesbian minority.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The march in 2006 was entitled 'Pride March'.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "In subsequent years the march was entitled 'Gay Pride'.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The march was named to replicate similar events held by homosexual communities in big cities worldwide.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The date chosen for the march was 27 May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The date of 27 May 2006 was chosen to celebrate the anniversary of the abolition of criminal liability in Russia for homosexual acts.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 16 February 2006 the Interfax news agency published a statement by Mr Tsoy, the press secretary of the mayor of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Mr Tsoy, the press secretary of the mayor of Moscow, stated that the government of Moscow would not even consider allowing the gay parade to be held.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Interfax quoted Mr Tsoy as saying that the mayor of Moscow, Mr Luzhkov, had firmly declared that the government of the capital city would not allow a gay parade to be held in any form, whether openly or disguised as a human rights demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Mr Tsoy stated that any attempt to hold any unauthorised action would be severely repressed.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 22 February 2006 Interfax quoted the mayor of Moscow as having said, on a different occasion, that if he received a request to hold a gay parade in Moscow he would impose a ban on it.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The mayor of Moscow stated he would ban a gay parade because he did not want to stir up society, which is ill-disposed to such occurrences of life.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The mayor of Moscow stated that he himself considered homosexuality 'unnatural', though he tried to treat everything that happens in human society with tolerance.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 17 March 2006 the first deputy to the mayor of Moscow wrote to the mayor of Moscow about the imminent campaign to hold a gay parade in Moscow in May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The first deputy to the mayor of Moscow considered that allowing the gay parade event would be contrary to health and morals.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The first deputy to the mayor of Moscow considered that allowing the gay parade event would be against the will of numerous petitioners who had protested against the idea of promoting homosexuality.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The first deputy to the mayor of Moscow noted that the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (the Assemblies Act) did not provide for the possibility of banning the gay parade event.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The first deputy to the mayor of Moscow stated that the authorities could suggest changing the venue or time of the gay parade event.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The first deputy to the mayor of Moscow stated that if the gay parade event turned out to be a real public threat, it could be interrupted.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The first deputy to the mayor of Moscow requested the mayor's agreement on developing an effective action plan for the prevention of any actions – public or otherwise – aimed at promoting or holding a gay parade or festival.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 24 March 2006 the mayor of Moscow instructed his first deputy, five other officials of his office and all prefects of Moscow to take effective measures for the prevention and deterrence of any gay-oriented public or mass actions in the capital city.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The mayor of Moscow called for action proposals based on the legislative and regulatory framework regarding the prevention of gay-oriented public or mass actions.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The mayor of Moscow demanded an active mass-media campaign and social commercials with the use of petitions brought by individuals and religious organisations regarding the prevention of gay-oriented public or mass actions.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 15 May 2006 the organisers of the Pride March submitted a notice to the mayor of Moscow stating the date, time and route of the intended march.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The intended march was to take place between 3 p.m. and 5 p.m. on 27 May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The intended march had an estimated number of about 2,000 participants.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The intended march route was from the Moscow Post Office along Myasnitskaya Street to Lubyanskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The organisers of the Pride March undertook to cooperate with the law-enforcement authorities in ensuring safety and respect for public order by the participants.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The organisers of the Pride March undertook to comply with regulations on restriction of noise levels when using loudspeakers and sound equipment.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 18 May 2006 the Department for Liaison with Security Authorities of the Moscow Government informed the applicant of the mayor's decision to refuse permission to hold the march.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The mayor of Moscow refused permission to hold the Pride March on grounds of public order, for the prevention of riots and the protection of health, morals and the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Department for Liaison with Security Authorities of the Moscow Government stated that numerous petitions had been brought against the march by representatives of legislative and executive State bodies, religious denominations, Cossack elders and other individuals.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Department for Liaison with Security Authorities of the Moscow Government stated that the march was likely to cause a negative reaction and protests against the participants, which could turn into civil disorder and mass riots.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Having received the refusal of permission for the Pride March, the organisers submitted a notice with a view to holding another event on the same date and time as the march for which permission had been refused.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The organisers informed the prefect of their intention to hold a picket in the park at Lubyanskaya Square on 27 May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 19 May 2006 the applicant challenged before a court the mayor's decision of 18 May 2006 refusing permission to hold the Pride March.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 23 May 2006 the deputy prefect of the Moscow Central Administrative Circuit refused permission to hold the picket at Lubyanskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The deputy prefect of the Moscow Central Administrative Circuit refused permission to hold the picket on the same grounds as those given for the refusal to hold the Pride March.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 26 May 2006 Interfax quoted the mayor of Moscow as saying in an interview to the radio station Russian Radio that no gay parade would be allowed in Moscow under any circumstances, as long as he was the city mayor.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The mayor of Moscow stated that all three major religious faiths – the Church, the Mosque and the Synagogue – were against the gay parade.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The mayor of Moscow stated that the gay parade was absolutely unacceptable in Moscow and in Russia, unlike in some Western countries more progressive in that sphere.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The mayor of Moscow stated: 'That's the way morals work. If somebody deviates from the normal principles [in accordance with which] sexual and gender life is organised, this should not be demonstrated in public and anyone potentially unstable should not be invited.'", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The mayor of Moscow stated that 99.9% of the population of Moscow supported the ban on the gay parade.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 26 May 2006 the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow dismissed the applicant's complaint against the mayor's decision refusing permission to hold the Pride March.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow referred to provisions of the Assemblies Act concerning the authorities responsible for ensuring the safety of events (sections 12 and 14), who were entitled to suggest changing the time or venue, or both, of a proposed event on safety grounds (section 12).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow noted that a public event could be held at any suitable venue unless it threatened to cause the collapse of buildings or constructions or entailed safety risks for its participants (section 8 of the Assemblies Act).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow noted the organisers' right to hold the event at the venue and time indicated in the notice to the authorities, or at the venue and time agreed with the authorities if they had suggested a change (section 5 of the Assemblies Act).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow stated that it was prohibited to hold the event if the notice had not been submitted on time or if the organisers had failed to agree to a change of venue or time proposed by the authorities (section 5 of the Assemblies Act).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow noted that the organisers, officials or other individuals were prohibited from interfering with the expression of opinion by the participants in the public event unless they breached public order or contravened the format of the event (section 18 of the Assemblies Act).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow concluded that the authorities could ban a public event on safety grounds and that it was for the organisers to submit a notice suggesting a change of venue and time for consideration by the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow considered that the refusal to hold the Pride March had legitimate grounds and that the applicant's right to hold assemblies and other public events had not been breached.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicant lodged an appeal against the Tverskoy District Court judgment of 26 May 2006, relying on section 12 of the Assemblies Act, which imposed an obligation on the authorities, and not the organisers, to make a reasoned proposal to change the venue or the time of the event as indicated in the notice.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicant challenged the finding that the ban on the Pride March was justified on safety grounds, claiming that concerns for safety could have been addressed by providing protection to those taking part in the event.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 27 May 2006 the applicant and several other persons participated in a conference celebrating the International Day Against Homophobia.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "At the conference celebrating the International Day Against Homophobia on 27 May 2006, the applicant and several other persons announced their intention to gather in the Aleksandrovskiy Garden to lay flowers at the war memorial, the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier, allegedly to commemorate the victims of fascism, including gay and lesbian victims.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "At the conference celebrating the International Day Against Homophobia on 27 May 2006, the applicant and several other persons announced their intention to hold a fifteen-minute picket at the Moscow mayor's office to protest against the ban on the march and the picketing.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Later on 27 May 2006 the applicant and about fifteen other persons arrived at the Aleksandrovskiy Garden to find the gates closed, with police patrolling the access.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "According to the applicant, there were about 150 policemen from the special riot squad (OMON) at the Aleksandrovskiy Garden on 27 May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "According to the applicant, there were about a hundred individuals protesting against the flower-laying event planned by the applicant and his fellow participants at the Aleksandrovskiy Garden on 27 May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicant was arrested on 27 May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The applicant was taken to the police station to be charged with the administrative offence of breaching the conditions for holding a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "In the meantime on 27 May 2006, other participants in the flower-laying event proceeded towards the Moscow mayor's office, with protesters pursuing and attacking them.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Several persons reportedly sustained slight injuries during the attacks by protesters on 27 May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "According to the applicant, the special riot squad (OMON) arrested about one hundred persons involved in attacking those taking part in the flower-laying event on 27 May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The applicant submitted a report by the International Lesbian and Gay Association on the events of 27 May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The applicant submitted a report by Human Rights Watch on the events of 27 May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The reports by the International Lesbian and Gay Association and Human Rights Watch corroborated the applicant's account of the events of 27 May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 31 May 2006 Interfax quoted the mayor of Moscow as saying in a television interview: 'Those gays trying to lay flowers at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier ... it is a provocation. It was a desecration of a holy place.'", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The mayor of Moscow reiterated the condemnation of the flower-laying action on behalf of the public at large in a television interview quoted by Interfax on 31 May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 16 June 2006 the applicant challenged before a court the prefect's decision of 23 May 2006 refusing to allow the picketing at Lubyanskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 22 August 2006 the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow dismissed the applicant's complaint against the prefect's decision refusing to allow the picketing, finding that the ban had been justified on safety grounds.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The applicant appealed against the Taganskiy District Court judgment of 22 August 2006.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 19 September 2006 the Moscow City Court examined the appeal against the Tverskoy District Court judgment of 26 May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "On 19 September 2006 the Moscow City Court upheld the first-instance judgment of 26 May 2006 as lawful and justified in the circumstances.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 28 November 2006 the Moscow City Court examined the appeal against the Taganskiy District Court judgment of 22 August 2006.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 28 November 2006 the Moscow City Court dismissed the appeal against the Taganskiy District Court judgment of 22 August 2006 on essentially the same grounds.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "In 2007 the applicant, together with other individuals, decided to organise a march similar to the one attempted in 2006.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "On 15 May 2007 the organisers submitted a notice to the mayor of Moscow stating the date, time and route of the intended march and its purpose, all of which were identical to the march proposed in 2006.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The estimated number of participants for the 2007 march was 5,100.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 16 May 2007 the Department for Liaison with Security Authorities of the Moscow Government informed the applicant that permission to hold the 2007 march had been refused on the grounds of potential breaches of public order and violence against the participants, with reference to the events of the previous year.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The organisers were warned that holding the 2007 march without permission would render them liable.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Having received the refusal of permission for the 2007 march, the organisers submitted a notice with a view to holding other events on the same date and time as the march for which permission had been refused.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The organisers informed the prefect of the Moscow Central Administrative Circuit of their intention to hold a picket in front of the Moscow mayor's office at Tverskaya Square on 27 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The organisers informed the prefect of the Moscow Central Administrative Circuit of their intention to hold a picket in Novopushkinskiy Park on 27 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 23 May 2007 the organisers were informed that the prefect had refused permission to hold the picket at Tverskaya Square on grounds of public order, prevention of riots and protection of health, morals and the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "On 23 May 2007 the organisers were informed that the prefect had refused permission to hold the picket in Novopushkinskiy Park on grounds of public order, prevention of riots and protection of health, morals and the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The organisers were warned that they would be held liable for holding any unauthorised picketing on 27 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "On 26 May 2007 the applicant and several other persons announced at the annual 'LGBT Rights are Human Rights' conference that they would meet the following day in front of the Moscow mayor's office to file a petition together in protest against the ban on the march and the picketing.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "On 27 May 2007 the applicant and about twenty other individuals were stopped by the police as they attempted to approach the Moscow mayor's office.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "On 27 May 2007 the applicant and two other men were detained at the police station for twenty-four hours on charges of having committed the administrative offence of disobeying a lawful order from the police.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "On 9 June 2007 the applicant was found guilty of the administrative offence of disobeying a lawful order from the police and had to pay a fine of 1,000 roubles.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The decision finding the applicant guilty of the administrative offence of disobeying a lawful order from the police was upheld by the Tverskoy District Court on 21 August 2007.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 30 May 2007 the applicant challenged before a court the decision of 16 May 2007 by the mayor of Moscow refusing permission to hold the 2007 march.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The applicant alleged that under the Assemblies Act, the authorities were not entitled to ban public events, but could only propose changing their time and location, which in the present case they had not done.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The applicant argued that official disapproval of the purpose of a public event was not by itself a sufficient ground, in a democratic society, for a ban.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On 26 June 2007 the applicant challenged before a court the prefect's decision of 23 May 2007 refusing permission for the picketing.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "On 24 August 2007 the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow dismissed the complaint concerning the ban on the picketing planned for 27 May 2007, finding that the ban had been justified on safety grounds.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Taganskiy District Court judgment of 24 August 2007 was upheld on 8 November 2007 by the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On 4 September 2007 the Tverskoy District Court dismissed the applicant's claim against the ban on the 2007 march, upholding the grounds for the ban and confirming the lawfulness of the authorities' acts.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court judgment of 4 September 2007 was upheld on 6 December 2007 by the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Pride March and picketing on 27 May 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "In 2008 the applicant, together with other individuals, decided to organise several marches similar to the ones attempted in 2006 and 2007.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "On 18 April 2008 the organisers submitted a notice to the mayor of Moscow stating the date, time and route of ten intended marches to be held on 1 and 2 May 2008 in central Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "On 24 April 2008 the Department for Liaison with Security Authorities of the Moscow Government informed the applicant that permission to hold all ten marches planned for 1 and 2 May 2008 had been refused on the grounds of potential breaches of public order and violence against the participants.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "On 22 April 2008 the organisers submitted a notice with a view to holding a further fifteen marches from 3 to 5 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "On 28 April 2008 the Department for Liaison with Security Authorities of the Moscow Government informed the applicant that permission to hold the fifteen marches planned from 3 to 5 May 2008 had been refused on the same grounds as the previous refusals.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The applicant submitted applications dated 25 and 28 April 2008 for 30 marches in total, which were refused on 5 May 2008 on the same grounds as previous refusals.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The applicant submitted an application dated 30 April 2008 for 20 marches, which was refused on 7 May 2008 on the same grounds as previous refusals.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The applicant submitted an application dated 5 May 2008 for 20 marches, which was refused on 8 May 2008 on the same grounds as previous refusals.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The applicant submitted an application dated 8 May 2008 for 15 marches, which was refused on 13 May 2008 on the same grounds as previous refusals.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The applicant submitted an application dated 12 May 2008 for 15 marches, which was refused on 16 May 2008 on the same grounds as previous refusals.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The applicant submitted an application dated 15 May 2008 for 15 marches, which was refused on 21 May 2008 on the same grounds as previous refusals.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The applicant submitted an application dated 19 May 2008 for 15 marches, which was refused on 23 May 2008 on the same grounds as previous refusals.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "On 16 May 2008 the applicant gave notice to the President of Russia of his intention to hold a march in the Aleksandrovskiy Garden on 31 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The applicant received no reply to the notice given to the President of Russia on 16 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "From 28 April 2008 to 17 June 2008 the applicant brought several court actions challenging the decisions by the mayor of Moscow refusing permission to hold the marches.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court joined the applicant's court actions challenging the decisions by the mayor of Moscow refusing permission to hold the marches.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "On 17 September 2008 the Tverskoy District Court dismissed the applicant's claim, upholding the grounds for the bans on the marches and confirming the lawfulness of the authorities' acts.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court judgment of 17 September 2008 was upheld on 2 December 2008 by the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The applicant attempted to organise picketing to call for criminal charges to be brought against the mayor of Moscow for hindering the holding of public events.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The picket intended to be held on 17 May 2008 was prohibited on 13 May 2008 on the same grounds as those given for the previous events.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The decision prohibiting the picket intended for 17 May 2008 was reviewed and upheld by the Taganskiy District Court on 22 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The decision prohibiting the picket intended for 17 May 2008 was upheld on appeal by the Moscow City Court on 14 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "On 1 June 2008 the applicant, in a group of twenty individuals, held a picket on Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street for about ten minutes.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Pride Marches in May 2008 and picketing in May and June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Article 30 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation provides that everyone has the right to freedom of association.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Article 55 § 3 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation provides that rights and freedoms may be restricted by federal laws for the protection of constitutional principles, public morals, health and the rights and lawful interests of others, and to ensure the defence and security of the State.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Section 5(3)(i) of the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004, the Assemblies Act) provides that the organiser of a public event has the right to hold meetings, demonstrations, marches and pickets at the venues and time specified in the notice on holding the public event or as altered by agreement with the executive authority of the subject of the Russian Federation or the municipal body.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Section 5(3)(v) of the Assemblies Act provides that the organiser of a public event has the right, in holding assemblies, meetings, demonstrations and marches, to use sound-amplifying technical devices with a level of sound corresponding to the standards and norms established in the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Section 5(4)(i) of the Assemblies Act provides that the organiser of the public event must submit to the executive authority of the subject of the Russian Federation or the municipal body a notice on holding the public event in accordance with the procedure prescribed by section 7 of the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Section 5(4)(ii) of the Assemblies Act provides that the organiser of the public event must, no later than three days prior to the holding of the public event, notify in writing the executive authority of the subject of the Russian Federation or the municipal body of the acceptance or non-acceptance of its proposal to alter the venue and/or time of the public event as specified in the notice of the event.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Section 5(4)(iii) of the Assemblies Act provides that the organiser of the public event must ensure compliance with the conditions for holding the public event as specified in the notice of the event or with any conditions that have been altered as a result of an agreement reached with the executive authority of the subject of the Russian Federation or the municipal body.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Section 5(4)(iv) of the Assemblies Act provides that the organiser of the public event must require the participants in the public event to observe public order and comply with the conditions for holding the public event, and that persons who fail to comply with the lawful requirements of the organiser may be expelled from the venue.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Section 5(4)(v) of the Assemblies Act provides that the organiser of the public event must ensure, within their competence, public order and the safety of citizens when holding the public event and, in instances specified by the Assemblies Act, perform this obligation jointly with the authorised representative of the executive authority of the subject of the Russian Federation or the municipal body and the authorised representative of the Ministry of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Section 5(5) of the Assemblies Act provides that the organiser of the public event shall have no right to hold it if the notice on holding the public event has not been submitted in due time or no agreement has been reached with the executive authority of the subject of the Russian Federation or the municipal body on their reasoned proposal as to the alteration of the venue and/or time of the public event.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Section 8 of the Assemblies Act provides that a public event may be held at any venue suitable for holding the event if its conduct does not create a threat of the collapse of buildings or structures or other threats to the safety of the participants in the public event.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Section 8 of the Assemblies Act provides that conditions governing bans or restrictions on holding a public event at particular venues may be specified by federal laws.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Section 12(1)(ii) of the Assemblies Act provides that the executive authority of the subject of the Russian Federation or the municipal body, upon receiving notice of the public event, must inform the organiser of the public event, within three days of receipt of the notice, of a reasoned proposal to alter the venue and/or time of the public event, as well as of any proposal for the organiser to bring the aims, form or other conditions for holding the event into line with the requirements of the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Section 12(1)(iii) of the Assemblies Act provides that the executive authority of the subject of the Russian Federation or the municipal body must designate, depending on the form of the public event and the number of participants, an authorised representative to assist the event organisers in conducting the event in accordance with the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Section 12(1)(v) of the Assemblies Act provides that the executive authority of the subject of the Russian Federation or the municipal body must ensure, within its competence and jointly with the organiser of the public event and the authorised representative of the Ministry of the Interior, public order and safety of citizens while holding the event and, if necessary, provide them with urgent medical aid.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Section 14(3)(i) of the Assemblies Act provides that the authorised representative of the Ministry of the Interior must facilitate the conduct of the public event.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Section 14(3)(ii) of the Assemblies Act provides that the authorised representative of the Ministry of the Interior must ensure, jointly with the organiser of the public event and the executive authority of the subject of the Russian Federation or the municipal body, public order and safety of citizens and compliance with the law while holding the public event.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Section 18(1) of the Assemblies Act provides that the organiser of the public event, officials or other individuals may not prevent the participants in the event from expressing their opinion in a manner that does not breach public order or the conditions for holding the public event.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe to member States on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity, paragraph 13, provides that member states should take appropriate measures to ensure that the right to freedom of expression can be effectively enjoyed, without discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity, including with respect to the freedom to receive and impart information on subjects dealing with sexual orientation or gender identity.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT COUNCIL OF EUROPE DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe to member States, paragraph 14, provides that member states should take appropriate measures at national, regional and local levels to ensure that the right to freedom of peaceful assembly can be effectively enjoyed, without discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT COUNCIL OF EUROPE DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe to member States, paragraph 15, provides that member states should ensure that law enforcement authorities take appropriate measures to protect participants in peaceful demonstrations in favour of the human rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender persons from any attempts to unlawfully disrupt or inhibit the effective enjoyment of their right to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT COUNCIL OF EUROPE DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe to member States, paragraph 16, provides that member states should take appropriate measures to prevent restrictions on the effective enjoyment of the rights to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly resulting from the abuse of legal or administrative provisions, for example on grounds of public health, public morality and public order.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT COUNCIL OF EUROPE DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "On 6 June 2006 the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights issued a press release.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT COUNCIL OF EUROPE DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "In a statement given in St Petersburg on 5 June 2006, Commissioner Hammarberg stressed that the rights to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly belong to all people and that the authorities have a duty to protect peaceful demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT COUNCIL OF EUROPE DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights expressed regret that his statement had been misrepresented by the news agency RIA Novosti in a report dated 5 June 2006 at 13:33.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT COUNCIL OF EUROPE DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "protection_of_morals"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F029", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F083", "F107", "F035", "F036", "F042", "F043", "F065", "F066", "F085", "F090", "F091", "F094", "F095", "F096", "F108", "F110"], "interference": ["F035", "F036", "F042", "F043", "F065", "F066", "F085", "F090", "F091", "F094", "F095", "F096", "F108", "F110", "F111", "F112", "F113", "F114", "F115", "F116", "F117", "F125"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F022", "F036", "F043", "F085", "F090", "F091", "F108", "F130", "F139", "F140", "F141"], "legitimate_aim": ["F013", "F014", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F022", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F064", "F069", "F073", "F074", "F085", "F090", "F091", "F130", "F139", "F140", "F141"], "necessity": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F013", "F014", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F026", "F029", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F064", "F065", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F073", "F074", "F083", "F085", "F090", "F091", "F107", "F108", "F110", "F111", "F112", "F113", "F114", "F115", "F116", "F117", "F147", "F148", "F149", "F150"], "positive_obligation": ["F036", "F037", "F038", "F064", "F065", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F085", "F090", "F091"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F005", "F006"], "interference": ["F035", "F036", "F065", "F066", "F085", "F090", "F091", "F095", "F096", "F108"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F022", "F036", "F139", "F141"], "legitimate_aim": ["F013", "F014", "F016", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F044", "F046", "F047", "F064", "F085", "F090", "F091"], "necessity": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F013", "F014", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F026", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F044", "F046", "F047", "F064", "F065", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F085", "F090", "F091", "F108", "F147", "F148", "F149", "F150"], "positive_obligation": ["F036", "F037", "F038", "F064", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F085", "F090", "F091"]}, "list3": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F013", "F014", "F016", "F022", "F026", "F035", "F036", "F044", "F046", "F047", "F064", "F065", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F085", "F090", "F091", "F108"]}} {"case_name": "case_123", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' dates of birth and places of residence are given in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants were opposition-oriented activists.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "At the material time, the first applicant was a member of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan, one of the opposition parties.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The first applicant participated in a number of peaceful demonstrations organised by the opposition.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On several occasions, the first applicant was arrested for participating in peaceful demonstrations organised by the opposition.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On several occasions, the first applicant was convicted for participating in peaceful demonstrations organised by the opposition.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 12 October 2013, an opposition group called İctimai Palata held a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The demonstration held by İctimai Palata on 12 October 2013 was authorised by the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), the relevant authority.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The demonstration held by İctimai Palata on 12 October 2013 was held in the Mahsul stadium, a place proposed by the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The demonstration held by İctimai Palata on 12 October 2013 was intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The demonstration held by İctimai Palata on 12 October 2013 was conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The participants in the demonstration of 12 October 2013 were protesting against alleged irregularities and fraud during the presidential elections of 9 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "All three applicants participated in the demonstration held by İctimai Palata on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "After the end of the demonstration of 12 October 2013, the applicants were arrested at the entrance to a nearby metro station called Inshaatchilar.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The circumstances of the applicants' arrests are similar to those in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (application nos. 67360/11 and 2 others, judgment of 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The circumstances of the applicants' custody are similar to those in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (application nos. 67360/11 and 2 others, judgment of 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The circumstances of the subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants are similar to those in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (application nos. 67360/11 and 2 others, judgment of 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The circumstances of the applicants' arrests are similar to those in Huseynov and Others v. Azerbaijan (Committee, application nos. 34262/14 and 5 others, judgment of 24 November 2016).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The circumstances of the applicants' custody are similar to those in Huseynov and Others v. Azerbaijan (Committee, application nos. 34262/14 and 5 others, judgment of 24 November 2016).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The circumstances of the subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants are similar to those in Huseynov and Others v. Azerbaijan (Committee, application nos. 34262/14 and 5 others, judgment of 24 November 2016).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Further details regarding the circumstances of the applicants' arrests, custody, and subsequent administrative proceedings are given in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Law no. 135-IVQD of 31 May 2011 introduced amendments to the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Law no. 135-IVQD of 31 May 2011 entered into force on 1 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "After the amendments introduced by Law no. 135-IVQD of 31 May 2011, Article 410.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 provided that a copy of the administrative offence report shall be given to an individual who is subject to the administrative offence proceedings or to a representative of a legal entity.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "After the amendments introduced by Law no. 135-IVQD of 31 May 2011, Article 410.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 provided that an aggrieved person in administrative offence proceedings has the right to a copy of the administrative offence report.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "A summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings is contained in the judgment in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (application nos. 67360/11 and 2 others, judgment of 11 February 2016), at paragraphs 56-77.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "A summary of relevant provisions concerning freedom of assembly, the organisation and holding of public assemblies is contained in the judgment in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (application nos. 67360/11 and 2 others, judgment of 11 February 2016), at paragraphs 56-77.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "Relevant extracts from international documents and press releases are contained in the judgment in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (application nos. 67360/11 and 2 others, judgment of 11 February 2016), at paragraphs 56-77.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "A summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings is contained in the judgment in Huseynov and Others v. Azerbaijan (Committee, application nos. 34262/14 and 5 others, judgment of 24 November 2016), at paragraphs 32-36.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "A summary of relevant provisions concerning freedom of assembly, the organisation and holding of public assemblies is contained in the judgment in Huseynov and Others v. Azerbaijan (Committee, application nos. 34262/14 and 5 others, judgment of 24 November 2016), at paragraphs 32-36.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Relevant extracts from international documents and press releases are contained in the judgment in Huseynov and Others v. Azerbaijan (Committee, application nos. 34262/14 and 5 others, judgment of 24 November 2016), at paragraphs 32-36.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F007", "F008", "F010", "F011", "F013", "F014"], "interference": ["F013", "F014", "F017", "F020"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F007", "F008", "F011", "F013"], "interference": ["F013", "F014"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F014", "F017", "F020"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F008", "F011", "F013", "F014", "F017", "F020"]}} {"case_name": "case_125", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1948.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Ashtarak, Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "In 2003 a presidential election was held in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The first round of the 2003 Armenian presidential election took place on 19 February 2003.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The second round of the 2003 Armenian presidential election took place on 5 March 2003.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant acted as an authorised election assistant (վստահված անձ) for the main opposition candidate in the 2003 Armenian presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Following the first and second rounds of the 2003 Armenian presidential election, a series of protest rallies were organised in Yerevan by the opposition parties.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 21 February 2003 the applicant participated in a demonstration held in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 22 February 2003 two police officers went to the applicant's flat.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 22 February 2003 two police officers took the applicant to the Central District Police Department of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "At the Central District Police Department of Yerevan, an administrative case was initiated against the applicant on account of his participation in the demonstration of 21 February 2003.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 22 February 2003, several hours after being taken to the Central District Police Department of Yerevan, the applicant was taken to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan (Երևան քաղաքի Կենտրոն և Նորք-Մարաշ համայնքների առաջին ատյանի դատարան).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "At the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan, the applicant was brought before Judge H.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Judge H. conducted a brief hearing in the applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Judge H. sentenced the applicant under Article 180.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (Վարչական իրավախախտումների վերաբերյալ ՀՀ օրենսգիրք – \"the CAO\") to 15 days of administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Judge H. found that on 21 February 2003 the applicant participated together with a group of people in an unauthorised demonstration in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant was taken to a detention facility following his sentencing.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant alleged that he had been visited in the detention facility several days after his detention began by a Red Cross representative.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant alleged that the Red Cross representative who visited him in the detention facility had brought him a letter from his wife.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant alleged that he was not allowed to reply to the letter from his wife that was brought to him in the detention facility by the Red Cross representative.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant alleged that, on an unspecified date, his wife had verbally requested the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan to review its decision sentencing the applicant to 15 days of administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant's wife was notified by a letter of 25 February 2003 that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan had no competence to review its decision sentencing the applicant to 15 days of administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 27 February 2003 the applicant's lawyer lodged an application with the General Prosecutor (ՀՀ գլխավոր դատախազ) requesting the General Prosecutor to initiate an appeal against the decision of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan sentencing the applicant to 15 days of administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant's lawyer had apparently received by mistake a copy of a decision taken in respect of a person convicted in a different administrative case, identified as H.A.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant's lawyer argued that the applicant had been unlawfully found guilty under Article 180.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO) by a decision taken in respect of another person, H.A.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant's lawyer argued that the applicant had been unlawfully deprived of his liberty by a decision taken in respect of another person, H.A.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 1 March 2003 the President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal (ՀՀ քրեական և զինվորական գործերով վերաքննիչ դատարանի նախագահ) reviewed the applicant's conviction.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal found that the applicant, according to the decision of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan, was subjected to administrative detention for the violation of the prescribed rules for organising and holding assemblies, demonstrations, street marches and rallies.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal found that on 21 February 2003 the applicant participated in an unauthorised demonstration and street march, during which he violated public order.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal found, having reviewed the applicant's appeal and the materials concerning the administrative offence, that the penalty imposed on the applicant must be changed.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal changed the applicant's penalty to an administrative fine of 1,000 Armenian drams (AMD), which was approximately 1.5 euros (EUR) at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal ordered the applicant's release from detention.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 1 March 2003 the applicant was released from detention after having served approximately seven days of his 15-day sentence.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "By a letter of 4 March 2003 the General Prosecutor's Office (ՀՀ գլխավոր դատախազություն) informed the applicant's lawyer that, on the basis of the applicant's appeal, the penalty had been changed by decision of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "By a letter of 4 March 2003 the General Prosecutor's Office (ՀՀ գլխավոր դատախազություն) informed the applicant's lawyer that the applicant had been released by decision of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "A summary of the relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings is contained in the judgment in the case of Galstyan v. Armenia (no. 26986/03, § 26, 15 November 2007).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "A summary of the relevant legislation invoked by the parties in connection with Article 180.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO) is contained in the judgment in the case of Mkrtchyan v. Armenia (no. 6562/03, §§ 20-28, 11 January 2007).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F008", "F016", "F029"], "interference": ["F027", "F031"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F015", "F028", "F029", "F031", "F037"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F008"], "interference": ["F027", "F031"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F028", "F031", "F037"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F008", "F028", "F031", "F037"]}} {"case_name": "case_126", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1933.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Limassol.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant claimed that in 1952, when she was 19 years old, she had permanently settled in Famagusta (northern Cyprus).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant got married in Famagusta (northern Cyprus).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant had two sons in Famagusta (northern Cyprus).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant had her home in Famagusta (northern Cyprus).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant had other immovable property in Famagusta (northern Cyprus).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant produced an 'affirmation of ownership of Turkish-occupied immovable property' issued by the Republic of Cyprus to substantiate her claim to ownership.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "According to the affirmation of ownership of Turkish-occupied immovable property issued by the Republic of Cyprus, the applicant's property is located at Famagusta, Chrysi Akti, plot no. 778, block C, sheet/plan 33/21.1.IV.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicant's property at Famagusta, Chrysi Akti, plot no. 778, block C, sheet/plan 33/21.1.IV is described as buildings with house, yard and shop on ground floor and house on the first floor.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The use of the applicant's property at Famagusta, Chrysi Akti, plot no. 778, block C, sheet/plan 33/21.1.IV is described as residence.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The area of each of the houses at the applicant's property at Famagusta, Chrysi Akti, plot no. 778, block C, sheet/plan 33/21.1.IV is 115 m².", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant's share in the property at Famagusta, Chrysi Akti, plot no. 778, block C, sheet/plan 33/21.1.IV is three-quarters (¾).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant submitted that the property at Famagusta, Chrysi Akti, plot no. 778, block C, sheet/plan 33/21.1.IV had been transferred to her by way of gift from her husband, Mr Andreas Papis, on 28 June 2000 (Declaration of transfer no. D-971).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Mr Andreas Papis had acquired the property at Famagusta, Chrysi Akti, plot no. 778, block C, sheet/plan 33/21.1.IV on 8 July 1994 by way of gift (Declaration of transfer no. D-1044) from his mother.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Mr Andreas Papis's mother had become the owner of the whole property at Famagusta, Chrysi Akti, plot no. 778, block C, sheet/plan 33/21.1.IV in 1971.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant produced a copy of Declaration of transfer no. D-971 and Declaration of transfer no. D-1044.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant claimed to have a 'possession' within the meaning of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention with regard to property at Kato Dherynia, provisional no. 19, D/959.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The property at Kato Dherynia, provisional no. 19, D/959 is described as a building site under subdivision.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant's share in the property at Kato Dherynia, provisional no. 19, D/959 is the whole.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant declared that she had entered into a contract to purchase the site at Kato Dherynia, provisional no. 19, D/959 on 24 December 1971.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant paid the purchase price for the site at Kato Dherynia, provisional no. 19, D/959 in monthly instalments.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The sale price for the site at Kato Dherynia, provisional no. 19, D/959 was CYP 2,750 (approximately EUR 4,613).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant gave a lump-sum of CYP 200 (approximately EUR 341) as an advance payment for the site at Kato Dherynia, provisional no. 19, D/959.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The remaining sum of CYP 2,550 for the site at Kato Dherynia, provisional no. 19, D/959 was to be paid as follows: CYP 500 on 31 January 1972, plus 48 monthly instalments of not less than CYP 45 (approximately EUR 76).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "All the instalments for the site at Kato Dherynia, provisional no. 19, D/959 had been paid off, with the final instalment being paid on 2 July 1974.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "In accordance with the contract for the site at Kato Dherynia, provisional no. 19, D/959, the transfer was to be effected on payment of the full sale price.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant's title to the land at Kato Dherynia, provisional no. 19, D/959 was not registered owing to the Turkish intervention.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant produced the contract of sale for the site at Kato Dherynia, provisional no. 19, D/959.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicant produced copies of the receipts of payment for the site at Kato Dherynia, provisional no. 19, D/959.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant submitted that since the 1974 Turkish intervention she had been deprived of her property rights, since her property was located in the area under the occupation and control of the Turkish military authorities.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant made an attempt to return to her home and property on 19 July 1989 but was not allowed to do so by the Turkish military authorities.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Turkish military authorities prevented the applicant from having access to and using her house and properties.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 19 July 1989, the applicant joined an anti-Turkish demonstration in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicants in the Chrysostomos and Papachrysostomou v. Turkey case also took part in the anti-Turkish demonstration in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicant in the Loizidou v. Turkey case also took part in the anti-Turkish demonstration in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant before the Nicosia District Court on 4 August 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant before the Nicosia District Court on 4 August 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was held on the fifteenth anniversary of the Turkish intervention in Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant before the Nicosia District Court on 4 August 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was held in support of the missing persons and to protest against human rights violations.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicant and other women had gathered in the Ayios Georgios church, where a service was in progress.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "While the applicant was in the Ayios Georgios chapel, she heard cries coming from outside.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "While the applicant was in the Ayios Georgios chapel, she saw Turkish policemen entering the church, indiscriminately grasping women, beating them and pulling them out.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "A Turkish policeman seized the applicant by one hand and twisted the other hand backwards.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "A Turkish policeman pushed the applicant out of the Ayios Georgios church.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "A Turkish policeman hit the applicant fiercely with a baton and with his knee in the lower part of her head and on the back of her neck as well as on other parts of her body.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicant felt electricity passing through her body and realised that the baton used by the Turkish policeman was electric.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant and other women were forcefully dragged into the area controlled by the authorities of the 'Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus' (the 'TRNC').", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant was arrested and taken by bus to the so-called 'Pavlides Garage'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "During the journey to the 'Pavlides Garage', the applicant was subjected to assaults, beatings and gestures of a sexual nature by the officers who had detained her.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The crowd outside the 'Pavlides Garage' was swearing, shouting abuse and threats and throwing stones at the garage, some of which came through the roof.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Some of the Turkish policemen at the 'Pavlides Garage' threatened to open the doors and let the crowd lynch the detainees.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "At the 'Pavlides Garage' there were two UN men who merely acted as observers.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "One of the women detainees, Mrs Vrahimi (application no. 16078/90), was seriously beaten at the 'Pavlides Garage'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "At about midnight the applicant was interrogated at the 'Pavlides Garage'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The applicant's interrogation at the 'Pavlides Garage' took place in Greek.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The applicant lied when asked for details concerning the members of her family during the interrogation at the 'Pavlides Garage'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicant was told to sign a statement in Turkish at the 'Pavlides Garage' but did not do so as she did not understand Turkish.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicant considered that signing the statement in Turkish would have been tantamount to recognising the 'TRNC'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On the morning of 20 July 1989 the applicant was given some food and water at the 'Pavlides Garage'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On the morning of 20 July 1989 the applicant was taken to court where she was remanded in custody for forty-eight hours.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "At the hearing on 20 July 1989, an interpreter explained the procedure to the accused.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicant understood that she was accused of having violated the borders of the 'TRNC'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The applicant was subsequently transferred to a prison outside Nicosia, where she was kept in a cell with another two women.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "At the prison outside Nicosia, there were not enough mattresses and the applicant and the other detainees in her cell took turns to lie down.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicant could not sleep at the prison outside Nicosia due to the severe pain from the blows she had received.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "During the night at the prison outside Nicosia, the applicant and the other detainees were harassed by the guards and told that the long-term prisoners would rape them.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The toilets and showers at the prison outside Nicosia were filthy and had no doors so the guards could see the detainees bathing.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Essential means of hygiene were lacking at the prison outside Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "At night at the prison outside Nicosia, the guards continually picked out individual detainees for checks.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "At around midnight on 21 July 1989, the applicant was taken to court.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "At the court hearing around midnight on 21 July 1989, the applicant had no legal representation.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "At the court hearing around midnight on 21 July 1989, the quality of the interpretation was poor; the applicant felt that the interpreter was not translating all of what was being said.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "At the court hearing around midnight on 21 July 1989, the judge asked whether the accused wanted legal representation.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "At the court hearing around midnight on 21 July 1989, the accused replied that they would only accept as defence counsel a lawyer registered with the bar association of the Republic of Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "As a result of refusing to accept a lawyer not registered with the bar association of the Republic of Cyprus, the accused were not assisted by a lawyer at the court hearing around midnight on 21 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "At the court hearing around midnight on 21 July 1989, one of the accused spoke on behalf of the others.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "At the court hearing around midnight on 21 July 1989, some prosecution witnesses were interrogated.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "At the court hearing around midnight on 21 July 1989, prosecution witnesses lied about the basic facts surrounding the demonstration and the circumstances of the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "At the court hearing around midnight on 21 July 1989, the accused tried to protest against the prosecution witnesses' false testimony.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "At the court hearing around midnight on 21 July 1989, the accused were told to stay quiet if they did not want to be handed over to the vociferous crowd that had gathered outside the courtroom.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "At around midnight on 22 July 1989, the court sentenced the applicant to three days' imprisonment and to a fine of CYP 50 (approximately EUR 85).", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The court imposed five additional days in prison on the applicant in default of payment of the fine of CYP 50 within 24 hours.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "After sentencing around midnight on 22 July 1989, the applicant was brought back to prison where she was given some personal hygiene items that had been sent by the Red Cross.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On 24 July 1989 the applicant was released from prison.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "At the time of her release on 24 July 1989, the applicant was examined by UN doctors, who took some notes.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "After her release on 24 July 1989, the applicant was transferred to southern Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "On 28 July 1989, the applicant made a statement to Limassol police.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "On 28 July 1989, the applicant was examined by a Government doctor at Limassol Hospital.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The applicant produced a medical report issued on 28 July 1989 by Dr. Charalambos Michael, a medical officer.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "According to the medical report of Dr. Charalambos Michael dated 28 July 1989, at approximately 23.00 hours on 28 July 1989 he was requested by the Limassol District Police to examine Mrs Despo Andreou Papi from Famagusta, presently living at 16 Chrysanthou Mylona Street in Limassol.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "According to the medical report of Dr. Charalambos Michael dated 28 July 1989, Mrs Despo Andreou Papi alleged that on 19 July 1989 she was hit (kicks, fists and use of police baton) on various parts of her body by Turkish pseudo-policemen in the area of Ayios Kassianos in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "According to the medical report of Dr. Charalambos Michael dated 28 July 1989, the examination found multiple and extensive bruises on various parts of the applicant's body, particularly obvious and serious in the areas of the right buttock and the posterior surface of the left hip.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "According to the medical report of Dr. Charalambos Michael dated 28 July 1989, the examination found haematoma and swelling on the applicant's left elbow joint.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "According to the medical report of Dr. Charalambos Michael dated 28 July 1989, the examination found pain at various parts of the applicant's body, particularly in the region of the ribs (both sides), the neck, the left elbow, both buttocks, the coccyx and the waist.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "According to the medical report of Dr. Charalambos Michael dated 28 July 1989, an X-ray examination was requested.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The applicant alleged that she continued to suffer from the effects of the beatings inflicted on her.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant had participated in a violent demonstration with the aim of enflaming anti-Turkish sentiment.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators, supported by the Greek-Cypriot administration, were demanding that the 'Green Line' in Nicosia should be dismantled.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Government alleged that some demonstrators carried Greek flags, clubs, knives and wire-cutters.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators were acting in a provocative manner and shouting abuse.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators were warned in Greek and English that unless they dispersed they would be arrested in accordance with the laws of the 'TRNC'.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was arrested by the Turkish-Cypriot police after crossing the UN buffer zone and entering the area under Turkish-Cypriot control.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Government alleged that the Turkish-Cypriot police intervened in the face of the manifest inability of the Greek-Cypriot authorities and the UN Force in Cyprus to contain the incursion and its possible consequences.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Government alleged that no force was used against demonstrators who did not intrude into the 'TRNC' border area.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Government alleged that in the case of demonstrators who were arrested for violating the border, no more force was used than was reasonably necessary in the circumstances in order to arrest and detain the persons concerned.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The Government alleged that no one was ill-treated.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Government alleged that it was possible that some of the demonstrators had hurt themselves in the confusion or in attempting to scale barbed wire or other fencing.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Government alleged that had the Turkish police, or anyone else, assaulted or beaten any of the demonstrators, the UN Secretary General would no doubt have referred to this in his report to the Security Council.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was charged, tried, found guilty and sentenced to a short term of imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant pleaded not guilty but did not give evidence and declined to use the available judicial remedies.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was asked if she required assistance from a lawyer registered in the 'TRNC', but refused and did not ask for legal representation.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Government alleged that interpretation services were provided at the trial by qualified interpreters.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Government alleged that all the proceedings were translated into Greek.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989 on the UN operations in Cyprus, the UN Secretary General stated that in the evening of 19 July 1989, some 1,000 Greek Cypriot demonstrators, mostly women, forced their way into the UN buffer zone in the Ayios Kassianos area of Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "According to the UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989, the demonstrators broke through a wire barrier maintained by UNFICYP and destroyed an UNFICYP observation post.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "According to the UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989, the demonstrators broke through the line formed by UNFICYP soldiers and entered a former school complex where UNFICYP reinforcements regrouped to prevent them from proceeding further.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "According to the UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989, a short while later Turkish-Cypriot police and security forces elements forced their way into the area and apprehended 111 persons, 101 of them women.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "According to the UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989, the Ayios Kassianos school complex is situated in the UN buffer zone, but the Turkish forces claim it to be on their side of the cease-fire line.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "According to the UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989, under working arrangements with UNFICYP, the Turkish-Cypriot security forces had patrolled the Ayios Kassianos school grounds for several years within specific restrictions, and this patrolling had ceased altogether as part of the unmanning agreement implemented the previous May.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "According to the UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989, in the afternoon of 21 July 1989, some 300 Greek Cypriots gathered at the main entrance to the UN protected area in Nicosia to protest the continuing detention by the Turkish-Cypriot authorities of those apprehended at Ayios Kassianos.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "According to the UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989, the number of demonstrators at the main entrance to the UN protected area in Nicosia fluctuated between 200 and 2,000 and they blocked all UN traffic through this entrance until 30 July 1989, when the Turkish-Cypriot authorities released the last two detainees.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "According to the UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989, the events of 19 July 1989 created considerable tension in the island and intensive efforts were made, both at the UN headquarters and at Nicosia, to contain and resolve the situation.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "According to the UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989, on 21 July 1989 the UN Secretary General expressed his concern at the events that had taken place and stressed that it was vital that all parties keep in mind the purpose of the UN buffer zone as well as their responsibility to ensure that that area was not violated.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "According to the UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989, the UN Secretary General urged the Turkish-Cypriot authorities to release without delay all those who had been detained.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "According to the UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989, on 24 July 1989 the President of the Security Council announced that he had conveyed to the representatives of all the parties, on behalf of the members of the Council, the Council's deep concern at the tense situation created by the incidents of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "According to the UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989, the President of the Security Council stressed the need strictly to respect the UN buffer zone and appealed for the immediate release of all persons still detained.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "According to the UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989, the President of the Security Council asked all concerned to show maximum restraint and to take urgent steps that would bring about a relaxation of tension and contribute to the creation of an atmosphere favourable to the negotiations.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The applicant produced 21 photographs taken at different times during the demonstration on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Photographs 1 to 7 produced by the applicant were intended to show that, notwithstanding the deployment of the Turkish-Cypriot police, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "In photographs 8 to 10 produced by the applicant, members of the Turkish-Cypriot police are seen breaking up the UNFICYP cordon.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The final set of photographs produced by the applicant shows members of the Turkish-Cypriot police using force to arrest some of the women demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code defines an unlawful assembly as occurring where five or more persons assemble with intent to commit an offence, or, being assembled with intent to carry out some common purpose, conduct themselves in such a manner as to cause persons in the neighbourhood to fear that the persons so assembled will commit a breach of the peace, or will by such assembly needlessly and without any reasonable occasion provoke other persons to commit a breach of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that it is immaterial that the original assembly was lawful if, being assembled, the persons conduct themselves with a common purpose in such a manner as to cause persons in the neighbourhood to fear a breach of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that when an unlawful assembly has begun to execute the purpose for which it assembled by a breach of the peace and to the terror of the public, the assembly is called a riot and the persons assembled are said to be riotously assembled.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "According to section 71 of the Cypriot Criminal Code, any person who takes part in an unlawful assembly is guilty of a misdemeanour and liable to imprisonment for one year.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Section 80 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that any person who carries in public without lawful occasion any offensive arm or weapon in such a manner as to cause terror to any person is guilty of a misdemeanour and is liable to imprisonment for two years, and his arms or weapons shall be forfeited.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "According to section 82 of the Cypriot Criminal Code, it is an offence to carry a knife outside the home.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Chapter 155, section 14(1)(b) of the Cypriot Criminal Procedure Law states that any officer may, without warrant, arrest any person who commits in his presence any offence punishable with imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Police officers' powers of arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Chapter 155, section 14(1)(c) of the Cypriot Criminal Procedure Law states that any officer may, without warrant, arrest any person who obstructs a police officer while in the execution of his duty.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Police officers' powers of arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Section 9 of Law No. 5/72 states that any person who enters a prohibited military area without authorisation, or by stealth, or fraudulently, shall be tried by a military court in accordance with the Military Offences Act, and those found guilty shall be punished.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Subsection 12(1) of the Aliens and Immigration Law states that no person shall enter or leave the Colony except through an approved port.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Subsection 12(5) of the Aliens and Immigration Law states that any person who contravenes or fails to observe any of the provisions of subsections (1), (2), (3) or (4) of section 12 shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months or to a fine not exceeding one hundred pounds or to both such imprisonment and fine.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": false, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["national_security", "public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F034", "F040", "F047", "F048", "F114", "F115", "F116"], "interference": ["F034", "F040", "F047", "F048"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F132", "F133", "F134", "F135", "F138", "F139", "F140", "F141", "F142"], "legitimate_aim": ["F114", "F115", "F116", "F117", "F118"], "necessity": ["F114", "F115", "F116", "F117", "F118"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F034", "F040", "F114", "F115", "F116"], "interference": ["F034", "F047", "F048"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F132", "F135", "F138", "F140"], "legitimate_aim": ["F114", "F115", "F116", "F118"], "necessity": ["F114", "F115", "F116", "F118"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F034", "F048", "F114", "F115", "F116", "F118", "F132", "F135", "F138"]}} {"case_name": "case_127", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some of the applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_129", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants either owned businesses at Voronezh municipal market and rented the market pitches for their businesses.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "Some of the applicants worked as vendors for businesses at Voronezh municipal market.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "In August 2007 the title to the plot of land on which Voronezh municipal market was located was transferred from the town to a municipal enterprise.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "In August 2007 the title to the plot of land on which Voronezh municipal market was located was transferred from a municipal enterprise to a private company.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The private company that acquired the title to the plot of land on which Voronezh municipal market was located intended to demolish the market and build a shopping centre.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "In 2008 and 2009 court proceedings were ongoing between the prosecutor's office and the municipal enterprise in relation to the plot of land on which Voronezh municipal market was located.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicants and some other people (several dozen in total) disagreed with the course of action of demolishing Voronezh municipal market and building a shopping centre, which would adversely affect their businesses and employment.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicants and some other people (several dozen in total) decided to remain on the Voronezh municipal market premises permanently, doing 'night shifts'.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "According to the applicants, on an unspecified date and in a specified manner, the entrepreneurs notified the town administration of their intention to 'constantly do night shifts at the market until the matters relating to the legality of the land's transfer and the demolition of the market were settled'.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The entrepreneurs started their 'night shifts' at Voronezh municipal market on an unspecified date.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 6 August 2009 the police told the entrepreneurs who had gathered at Voronezh municipal market to leave the premises.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Some entrepreneurs refused to comply with the police order to leave Voronezh municipal market premises in the absence of any court order.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Some entrepreneurs argued that, under their rent contracts, they had a right to remain at Voronezh municipal market.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 7 August 2009 Mr Annenkov was arrested at Voronezh municipal market.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 7 August 2009 Mr Khripunov was arrested at Voronezh municipal market.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 7 August 2009 Mr Khavantsev was arrested at Voronezh municipal market.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 7 August 2009 Mr Finskiy was arrested at Voronezh municipal market.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 7 August 2009 Ms Suprunova was arrested at Voronezh municipal market.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 7 August 2009 Ms Zakharova was arrested at Voronezh municipal market.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 7 August 2009 Ms Guseva was arrested at Voronezh municipal market.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov were accused of an offence under Article 19.3 of the Federal Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO), which punished disobeying or resisting the lawful order of a public official.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov were assisted by counsel before the trial court.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov pleaded not guilty before the trial court.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov denied that they had disobeyed or resisted any specific lawful orders from the police, or that they had otherwise breached the public order or endangered public safety.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "By a judgment of 7 August 2009 a justice of the peace convicted Mr Finskiy of an offence under Article 19.3 of the Federal Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The justice of the peace sentenced Mr Finskiy to five days' administrative detention by judgment of 7 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The justice of the peace held that Mr Finskiy violated the procedure for organising and managing a gathering (собрание).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The justice of the peace held that Mr Finskiy disobeyed a lawful order issued by police officers in relation to their duties to ensure public order and safety.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The justice of the peace held that Mr Finskiy obstructed police officers' exercise of their duties to ensure public order and safety.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The justice of the peace found that Mr Finskiy's guilt was confirmed by the record of the administrative offence, a complaint and written statements issued by the market director, written reports by police officers, and statements from witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 7 August 2009 Mr Khripunov was sentenced to five days' administrative detention by a justice of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The justice of the peace held that Mr Khripunov violated the procedure for organising and managing a gathering.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The justice of the peace held that Mr Khripunov disobeyed a lawful order issued by police officers in relation to their duties to ensure public order and safety.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The justice of the peace held that Mr Khripunov obstructed police officers' exercise of their duties to ensure public order and safety.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "A witness identified as N. stated before the justice of the peace that on 7 August 2009 a group of entrepreneurs were doing night shifts to prevent the demolition of the market building, that police officers arrived and started to grab people and take them to the police station, and that Mr Khripunov was grabbed by the police but did not show any resistance during this procedure.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The justice of the peace adopted a critical stance in relation to the testimony of witness N., who was Mr Khripunov's acquaintance and colleague, because this testimony was refuted by the bulk of the other evidence, namely the officers' written reports made in their official capacity.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "A judgment apparently in similar terms to those issued in respect of Mr Finskiy and Mr Khripunov was issued in respect of Mr Khavantsev.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Mr Khavantsev was sentenced to ten days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "As required under the Federal Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO), Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov started to serve their sentences of administrative detention immediately following the trial judgments in their cases.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov appealed to the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh against their convictions.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "Mr Khripunov argued before the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh that the trial court had not made a proper assessment of the testimonies of eyewitnesses.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Mr Khripunov and Mr Finskiy argued before the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh that they had taken part in a 'gathering', and the Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets (the Public Events Act) did not require that prior notice be given to the competent public authority for this type of public event.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Mr Khripunov and Mr Finskiy argued before the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh that, in breach of the Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets (the Public Events Act), no written requirement to cease any unlawful conduct had been issued to them or the other entrepreneurs.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Mr Khripunov and Mr Finskiy argued before the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh that the penalty of administrative detention had been disproportionate.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Mr Finskiy argued before the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh that he had been present on the market premises in the early morning of 7 August 2009 because he had been performing a 'duty'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Mr Finskiy argued before the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh that, having heard some noise, he had gone out of the building and had seen other entrepreneurs being arrested.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Mr Finskiy argued before the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh that he had started to film the events on his camera but had then been ordered to delete the video and had been arrested.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh examined a written statement from M., the new executive director of Voronezh municipal market, in the appeal proceedings concerning Mr Finskiy.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "M., the new executive director of Voronezh municipal market, stated that he had arrived at the marketplace but could not get into the office building because a number of entrepreneurs were blocking the entrance by holding hands or linking their arms.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "M., the new executive director of Voronezh municipal market, stated that following a request by him for assistance, the police had ordered the entrepreneurs to stop their activity.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "M., the new executive director of Voronezh municipal market, stated that the entrepreneurs, including Mr Finskiy, had not complied with the police order to stop their activity.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh examined written statements from witnesses B., Ma. and L. in the appeal proceedings concerning Mr Finskiy and Mr Khripunov.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Witnesses B., Ma. and L. stated that while passing through Voronezh municipal market on the morning of 7 August 2009, they had seen a group of some fifty people shouting slogans and calling for people in the town and regional administrations to be dismissed, as well as calling for the violation of public order.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Witnesses B., Ma. and L. stated that the police had told the group of people to stop, but they had not complied with that order.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Witnesses B., Ma. and L. stated that the police had repeated the warning to the most active participant, and after he had failed to comply, he had been taken to a police car while grabbing the officers' uniforms and trying to run away.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Officers S., Y. and F. submitted written reports stating that on 6 August 2009, noting the blocking of the entrance to the office building at Voronezh municipal market, they had ordered the people present to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Officers S., Y. and F. submitted written reports stating that on 7 August 2009 they again ordered the people present at Voronezh municipal market to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Officers S., Y. and F. submitted written reports stating that approaching Mr Finskiy, whom they identified as one of the most active participants, they had ordered him to stop, and after he had refused, they had taken him to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh heard Ms D. in the appeal proceedings, who stated that Mr Finskiy had been trying to film the ongoing events when the police had taken him away and that he had not shown any resistance.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 13 August 2009 the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh upheld the judgment of 7 August 2009 in respect of Mr Finskiy.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh stated it had no reason to doubt the testimonies of police officers and witnesses L., B. and Ma. because they were not previously acquainted with Mr Finskiy or other entrepreneurs and had no reason to give false testimony against him.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh dismissed the argument that witnesses L., B. and Ma. could not be eyewitnesses since the market was surrounded by a wall, finding that their testimonies indicated they had effectively passed through the marketplace.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh dismissed the argument that the police had acted unlawfully in relation to the entrepreneurs' presence at a gathering requiring no prior authorisation, finding that the police had acted lawfully with the aim of ensuring public order and public safety because the entrepreneurs were blocking access to the market for employees and had not reacted to lawful orders from the police to stop these actions.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh adopted a critical attitude in respect of the testimony of Ms D., finding that she had tried to help her colleague Mr Finskiy avoid responsibility for the offence and that her testimony was refuted by the other evidence.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "By a decision of 13 August 2009 the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh upheld the judgment in respect of Mr Khripunov.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Witness P. stated before the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh that on 7 August 2009 people in plain clothes and the police arrived at Voronezh municipal market and, following orders from the chief officer of the Sovetskiy police station, started to arrest entrepreneurs without explaining the reasons for such arrests, and that Mr Khripunov was arrested while showing no resistance or disobedience to any specific orders.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh found that the record of the administrative offence against Mr Khripunov stated that after his violation of the procedure for organising and managing public events, while being arrested, he disobeyed the lawful order of a police officer, grabbed his uniform and tried to escape.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh found that written statements from three passers-by confirmed that some fifty people were chanting slogans and calling for the dismissal of the mayor and the governor and for violations of the public order, that despite the police's order to stop, the entrepreneurs refused, and that Mr Khripunov, who appeared particularly active, did not respond to a further order to stop, resisted while being placed in the police car, and threatened the officers with violence and prosecution.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh found that officers' written statements confirmed that having approached Mr Khripunov as one of the most active men, they warned him against committing offences but he did not react and refused to stop, and was thus arrested and taken to the police station (the officers' reports mistakenly referred to him as 'Finskiy').", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh dismissed the defence's argument that Mr Khripunov had lawfully participated in a gathering requiring no prior authorisation, finding that the police's actions were lawful and aimed to secure public order and public safety since the entrepreneurs were blocking the market employees' access to the building.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh adopted a critical attitude in respect of the testimony of witness P., who was Mr Khripunov's colleague, finding that P.'s testimony was refuted by the bulk of the other evidence.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "An appeal decision in similar terms to those issued in respect of Mr Finskiy and Mr Khripunov was issued in respect of Mr Khavantsev by the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "In late September 2009 Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov learnt that court decisions in respect of certain other participants in the same events had been quashed on appeal in September 2009.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 8 October 2009 Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov lodged applications under Article 30.12 of the Federal Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO) for review of the final judgments in respect of them.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 20 November 2009 the Deputy President of the Voronezh Regional Court upheld the lower courts' decisions in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Deputy President of the Voronezh Regional Court dismissed the defence's argument that the lower courts' judges had omitted to specify the type of public event in which the defendants had participated, the relevant regulations on such public events, and the specific details concerning the police's orders to the defendants, stating that it had been established by the justice of the peace that the impugned event was a 'gathering'.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Proceedings in respect of Mr Finskiy, Mr Khavantsev and Mr Khripunov"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "By judgments of 7 August 2009 the female defendants in the proceedings (Ms Suprunova, Ms Zakharova and Ms Guseva) and Mr Annenkov were fined.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 2 September 2009 the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh set aside the judgment of 7 August 2009 in respect of Mr Annenkov.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "On 8 September 2009 the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh set aside the judgment of 7 August 2009 in respect of one or more of the female defendants.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 10 September 2009 the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh set aside the judgment of 7 August 2009 in respect of one or more of the female defendants.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh held in respect of Mr Annenkov that neither the record of the administrative offence nor the judgment contained references to specific circumstances or actions relating to the corpus delicti of the imputed offence of disobeying the lawful order of a police officer, and in particular neither document specified what order was given to Mr Annenkov which was then not complied with, and the judgment did not indicate that Mr Annenkov had disobeyed a lawful order issued by a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh held in respect of Ms Guseva that the record of the administrative offence did not specify what type of public event was being held, which procedure was violated, or what orders relating to maintaining public order during a public event were not complied with by Ms Guseva.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh held in respect of Ms Suprunova that the record of the administrative offence did not indicate what type of public event was being held, which applicable procedure Ms Suprunova allegedly violated, what orders relating to maintaining public order during such an event were issued to Ms Suprunova by the police, or which of those orders was not complied with.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh held in respect of Ms Zakharova that neither the record of the administrative offence nor the first-instance judgment referred to specific facts and actions forming part of the offence imputed to Ms Zakharova of disobeying the lawful order of a police officer, or the specific order given to her which she failed to comply with, and the record did not specify what Ms Zakharova's violation of the procedure concerning the organisation and management of demonstrations, meetings and gatherings was, or what type of event was being held.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh ordered the return of the case files concerning Mr Annenkov, Ms Suprunova, Ms Zakharova and Ms Guseva to the relevant justice of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The justice of the peace returned the case files concerning Mr Annenkov, Ms Suprunova, Ms Zakharova and Ms Guseva to the police station, apparently for the documents to be amended or the administrative-offence records to be redrafted.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The case files concerning Mr Annenkov, Ms Suprunova, Ms Zakharova and Ms Guseva were not resubmitted for a retrial.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events on 7 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "At 5.30 a.m. on 10 August 2009 the police arrested some twenty people at Voronezh municipal market.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Among those arrested at 5.30 a.m. on 10 August 2009 at Voronezh municipal market were applicants Mr Buzov, Ms Garkavets, Ms Zhuravleva, Ms Khavantseva and Ms Suprunova.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 10 August 2009 a justice of the peace examined a case against Mr Buzov.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The justice of the peace heard Ms Khr., who stated that a group of people had impeded security guards as they tried to re-establish access to the market building, and that the police had then arrived and had taken some people to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "During the hearing before the justice of the peace on 10 August 2009, Mr Buzov, who was assisted by counsel, first sought to have some other witnesses and police officers examined in open court.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "According to the Government, Mr Buzov then withdrew his application to have other witnesses and police officers examined in open court.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "By a judgment of 10 August 2009 Mr Buzov was convicted of an offence under Article 19.3 of the Federal Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Mr Buzov was sentenced to ten days' administrative detention by the justice of the peace by judgment of 10 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The justice of the peace found that Mr Buzov disobeyed the police officers and did not comply with lawful orders to stop violating public order.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The justice of the peace found that Mr Buzov's guilt was confirmed by the administrative-offence record, the police officers' reports and the written testimonies of witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "According to the Government, Mr Buzov did not serve his sentence of ten days' administrative detention, as he was taken to the cardiology unit of a local hospital on the evening of 10 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Mr Buzov appealed to the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh against his conviction of 10 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh held a hearing on 13 August 2009 in respect of Mr Buzov's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh heard Mr Buzov's lawyer at the hearing on 13 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh heard Ms Yef. at the hearing on 13 August 2009, who stated that she had seen Mr Buzov making a video recording while surrounded by security guards who had torn his clothes, that colleagues had managed to get him out of the security guards' grasp, that the police had then arrived and started to push certain entrepreneurs aside, that one of the security guards had given an order to arrest Mr Buzov, and that Mr Buzov had not disobeyed any orders and had not resisted arrest.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "By a decision of 13 August 2009 the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh upheld the judgment of 10 August 2009 in respect of Mr Buzov.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "In late September 2009 Mr Buzov and his counsel Ms Gnezdilova learnt that court decisions in respect of certain other participants in the events on 10 August 2009 and 7 August 2009 had been quashed on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Mr Buzov and his counsel Ms Gnezdilova thought they had a reasonable prospect of success in seeking a further review of the court decisions of 10 and 13 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "In early October 2009 Mr Buzov and his counsel Ms Gnezdilova lodged an application for review of the court decisions of 10 and 13 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Mr Buzov and his counsel Ms Gnezdilova argued in their application for review that the lower courts had not specified what specific order Mr Buzov had disobeyed or whether such an order was lawful under Russian law.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Mr Buzov and his counsel Ms Gnezdilova argued in their application for review that the courts had not heard any officers or eyewitnesses who had witnessed the impugned reprehensible conduct on the part of Mr Buzov.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Mr Buzov and his counsel Ms Gnezdilova argued in their application for review that the courts had not specified any particular actions on Mr Buzov's part which constituted a breach of public order.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "On 20 November 2009 the Deputy President of the Voronezh Regional Court upheld the lower courts' decisions in respect of Mr Buzov.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Deputy President of the Voronezh Regional Court held that Mr Buzov was part of the group of people who impeded market officials as they tried to gain access to their office building, that guards from a private security company intervened and a fight ensued between them and some participants, that these participants did not respond to orders from police officers, and that the officers required Mr Buzov, who was one of the most active participants, to cease his unlawful conduct, but he did not respond to this order, and was thereafter taken to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "1. Mr Buzov"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "On 10 August 2009 a justice of the peace sentenced several female defendants (Ms Garkavets, Ms Zhuravleva and Ms Khavantseva) to a fine.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "On 8 September 2009 the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh heard appeals from the female defendants sentenced on 10 August 2009 and set aside the judgments against them.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh held in respect of Ms Zhuravleva that the record of the administrative offence did not specify which requests relating to public order were addressed to Ms Zhuravleva and were not complied with, or which actions of Ms Zhuravleva such requests related to, and that the deficiencies of the record made it impossible to establish Ms Zhuravleva's liability for an administrative offence, and the record must be returned to the police.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh held in respect of Ms Khavantseva and Ms Garkavets that neither the record of the administrative offence nor the justice of the peace's judgment specified how each defendant violated public order, or which specific order was given by the police in this connection but not complied with by her.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The case files concerning the female defendants sentenced on 10 August 2009 were returned to the police for the documents to be amended.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The case files concerning the female defendants sentenced on 10 August 2009 were not resubmitted to the relevant justice of the peace for a retrial.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events on 10 August 2009 and related proceedings", "2. Other applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "On 10 August 2009 Ms Shatalova (Mr Annenkov's wife and also an applicant in the present case) lodged a criminal complaint with the Sovetskiy Investigations Unit.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Ms Shatalova alleged that Officer Ku., a senior officer at the Sovetskiy police station, had subjected her elderly husband Mr Annenkov to ill-treatment on 7 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Ms Shatalova sought the institution of criminal proceedings against Officer Ku.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Ms Shatalova stated that at her request, Mr Annenkov had arrived at Voronezh municipal market in the early morning of 7 August 2009, where she had been doing 'night shifts' with others, in order to bring her some warm clothes.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Ms Shatalova stated that Officer Ku. had struck a blow to Mr Annenkov's chest, causing him to fall to the ground and sustain a head injury as he hit his head against the corner of a table.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Mr Annenkov was examined on 7 August 2009 by a neurosurgeon, a traumatology specialist and a therapist.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The medical examination of Mr Annenkov on 7 August 2009 concluded that he had a contused wound on his head measuring 6 cm by 0.3 cm by 0.5 cm.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The medical examination of Mr Annenkov on 7 August 2009 concluded that he had some swelling on his upper right arm and some other injuries (this part of the certificate is not legible).", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The applicants' lawyer alleged before the Court that Mr Annenkov had sustained a rib fracture, and maintained this assertion following communication of the case to the Government.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Government did not comment on the applicants' lawyer's assertion that Mr Annenkov had sustained a rib fracture.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Unspecified officials carried out an inquiry between 10 and 18 August 2009 into whether any police officers had committed the offence of abuse of power under Article 286 of the Criminal Code, defined at the time as 'actions manifestly outside the scope of official duties, causing a significant violation of one's rights or legitimate interests'.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Ms Suprunova, Ms Zakharova and Ms Guseva sought medical assistance on 8 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Ms Suprunova was diagnosed with concussion and soft-tissue bruises on her head and right arm.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Ms Zakharova was diagnosed with soft-tissue bruises on her head and right shoulder.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Ms Guseva was examined by a forensic expert who concluded that she had bruises on the front upper part of her right arm measuring 2.5 cm by 2 cm and 2.4 cm by 1.9 cm, and a smaller bruise on the inner part of her right arm.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Ms Guseva was examined by a forensic expert who concluded that she had abrasions on her right and left hip measuring 9 cm by 8.5 cm and 8 cm by 7.5 cm respectively.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Ms Guseva was examined by a forensic expert who concluded that she had abrasions on her right and left ankle joints measuring 6 cm by 3 cm and 2 cm by 1.3 cm respectively.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "On an unspecified date Ms Suprunova, Ms Zakharova and Ms Guseva were heard in the context of the pre-investigation inquiry regarding Mr Annenkov.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Ms Zakharova stated that she had arrived at Voronezh municipal market early on the morning of 7 August 2009 and had seen a police officer dragging Ms Guseva.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Ms Zakharova stated that she had protested to Officer Ku., who had then pushed her, causing her to fall to the ground and hit her shoulder and the back of her head against wooden objects on the ground.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Ms Suprunova stated that Officer Ku. had ordered 'Take this one' and had started to pull her hair and hands, but other entrepreneurs had tried to shield her.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Ms Guseva stated that she had tried to shield Ms Suprunova from Officer Ku., who was pulling Ms Suprunova's hair.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Ms Guseva stated that Officer Ku. and Officer Kh. had pushed Ms Guseva against a wall, causing her to fall to the ground and lose consciousness.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Ms Guseva stated that she had then been dragged along the ground by her hands, and had been kicked in the back by one of the officers as she was placed in the police car.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Ms Yef., the applicants' colleague, made a written statement that in the early morning of 7 August 2009 some thirty people had been at Voronezh municipal market.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Ms Yef. stated that upon being alerted to the arrival of the police, she had gone out and seen some sixteen police officers, including Officer Ku., a senior officer, who was giving orders and indicating that the officers should 'Take this one' or something similar.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Ms Yef. stated that she had seen an officer twisting Ms Suprunova's arms and Ms Guseva being dragged along the ground.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Ms Yef. stated that she had seen Mr Annenkov ask Officer Ku. 'What are you doing?', and that Officer Ku. had suddenly hit Mr Annenkov in the chest, causing Mr Annenkov to fall to the ground and hit against the top of a table, and that Mr Annenkov had fainted.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Ms Yef. stated that Officer Ku. had then kicked Mr Annenkov on the leg and ordered 'Take this one'.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Officer Ku. made a written statement during the inquiry that on 6 August 2009 the police station received information that in the early morning of 7 August a group of three hundred people might take violent action in order to take possession of Voronezh municipal market.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Officer Ku. stated that at 5.45 a.m. on 7 August 2009 some thirty officers under his supervision arrived at Voronezh municipal market to prevent disorder and unlawful actions.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "Officer Ku. stated that the officers saw some twenty people outside the building who were holding a meeting, chanting slogans and shouting about the regional prosecutor and the governor.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "Officer Ku. stated that the entrepreneurs had previously been issued with warnings against unlawful actions on their part.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "Officer Ku. stated that some five women suddenly started to shout and call for help, grabbing the officers' uniforms.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "Officer Ku. stated that the officers arrested some thirteen people, including the most active perpetrators, and that all of them resisted during the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "Officer Ku. stated that the officers did use physical force against some people, namely sambo fighting techniques such as twisting hands behind backs, and that none of the officers, including himself, inflicted any blows.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "On 19 August 2009 an investigator issued a decision refusing to institute criminal proceedings against police officers, referring to the statements of several officers including Officer Ku., and the testimonies of Mr Annenkov, Ms Shatalova, Ms Zakharova and Ms Suprunova.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The refusal to institute criminal proceedings issued on 19 August 2009 was overruled for unspecified reasons and the inquiry was resumed.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "Written statements were obtained from some other participants in the gathering at Voronezh municipal market as part of the resumed inquiry.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "Officer Kh. was heard during the resumed inquiry and confirmed Officer Ku.'s earlier statement.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "On 7 September 2009 the investigator issued a new refusal to institute criminal proceedings against Officer Ku., Officer Kh. or other officers.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The investigator concluded on 7 September 2009 that no sufficient and objective data could be gathered during the inquiry to show that any police officers had committed any criminal offence.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The investigator concluded on 7 September 2009 that the grievances presented in the complaints were refuted by the testimonies from the officers.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The investigator concluded on 7 September 2009 that injuries could have been sustained during the arrest procedure owing to the resistance displayed to the police officers, such resistance later being confirmed by the prosecution for the administrative offences.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The investigator concluded on 7 September 2009 that in view of the important and irremediable inconsistencies in various testimonies, there was no possibility of drawing a truthful conclusion regarding the commission of a criminal offence by Officer Ku., Officer Kh. or others.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "A new refusal to prosecute was issued on 1 October 2009 for unspecified reasons.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The refusal to prosecute of 1 October 2009 was overruled on 7 October 2009 by the deputy director of the District Investigations Department.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The deputy director of the District Investigations Department indicated on 7 October 2009 that it was necessary to assess the available court decisions regarding administrative offences concerning the events on 7 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The deputy director of the District Investigations Department indicated on 7 October 2009 that it was necessary to identify and interview people who had been kept with the arrested people at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The deputy director of the District Investigations Department indicated on 7 October 2009 that it was necessary to identify and interview all police officers who had been present at the station and had compiled administrative-offence files against the arrested entrepreneurs.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The deputy director of the District Investigations Department indicated on 7 October 2009 that it was necessary to identify and interview all the officers who had been on duty on 7 August 2009 and had been present at Voronezh municipal market.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "Four applicants (Mr Annenkov, Ms Suprunova, Ms Guseva and Ms Zakharova) sought judicial review in respect of the refusal to prosecute dated 1 October 2009.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "At a hearing on 19 October 2009, Mr Annenkov, Ms Suprunova, Ms Guseva and Ms Zakharova learnt that the refusal to prosecute of 1 October 2009 had already been overruled.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The judicial review case brought by Mr Annenkov, Ms Suprunova, Ms Guseva and Ms Zakharova in respect of the refusal to prosecute of 1 October 2009 was discontinued.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "A new refusal to prosecute was issued on 9 November 2009.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "On 22 December 2009 the Regional Investigations Department set aside the refusal to prosecute of 9 November 2009.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "The Regional Investigations Department set aside the refusal of 9 November 2009 because it contained an insufficient assessment of the factual circumstances, no plausible explanation for the applicants' injuries, and no assessment of the legality of the police's actions.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "Being unaware of the Regional Investigations Department's decision of 22 December 2009, one of the applicants sought judicial review of the refusal to prosecute dated 9 November 2009.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "On 9 November 2010 the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh discontinued the judicial review proceedings concerning the refusal to prosecute of 9 November 2009 because the supervising authority had overruled the impugned refusal decision.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "According to the Government, a new refusal to prosecute was issued on 19 June 2012.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "The refusal to prosecute of 19 June 2012 was overruled on 5 October 2012 by the district prosecutor's office.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "After the refusal to prosecute of 19 June 2012 was overruled, a criminal case was opened under Article 286 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "Apparently, Mr Annenkov and Ms Suprunova at least were interviewed again by an investigator following the opening of the criminal case under Article 286 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "Mr Annenkov had a formal confrontation procedure with an unspecified witness who had allegedly seen Mr Annenkov stumble and fall to the ground by himself on 7 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Alleged excessive use of force on 7 August 2009 and the related proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "At the material time, Article 19.3 § 1 of the Federal Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO) punished with a fine or administrative detention the following behaviour: disobeying the lawful order of a police officer, a military officer or a detention facility staff member in relation to the fulfilment of their official duties aimed at securing public order and public safety.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Prosecution of administrative offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "At the material time, Article 19.3 § 1 of the Federal Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO) also punished with a fine or administrative detention resisting the fulfilment of such duties by police officers, military officers or detention facility staff members.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Prosecution of administrative offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "Pursuant to Article 3.9 of the Federal Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO), the penalty of administrative detention cannot be imposed for an administrative offence committed by a pregnant woman, a woman with children, a person below the age of majority, a person with a Category 1 or Category 2 disability, military personnel, or individuals in some other categories.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Prosecution of administrative offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "In its decision no. 195-O of 13 June 2006 the Constitutional Court of Russia considered that the legislator was empowered to provide for different types of penalty depending on whether the same administrative offence was committed by a man or a woman, with the aim of protecting the health and social well-being of a woman who was a mother.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Prosecution of administrative offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "The penalty of administrative detention under the Federal Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO) could only be imposed by a court and only in exceptional circumstances, when a less intrusive penalty such as a fine would not be appropriate.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Prosecution of administrative offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "In a case involving a male defendant under the Federal Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO), a judge should take into consideration whether the defendant was the sole parent taking care of his child or children.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Prosecution of administrative offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "For a summary of the domestic law and practice in relation to the review of final judgments issued by courts of general jurisdiction under the Federal Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO) prior to and after legislative changes in December 2008 and August 2014, see Smadikov v. Russia (dec.), no. 10810/15, §§ 8-30, 31 January 2017, and Orlovskaya Iskra v. Russia, no. 42911/08, §§ 29-32, 21 February 2017.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Prosecution of administrative offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "The Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets, no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), provides that a public event is an open, peaceful event accessible to all, organised at the initiative of citizens of the Russian Federation, political parties, other public associations, or religious associations.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Regulation of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "The Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets, no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), provides that the aims of a public event are to express or develop opinions freely and to voice demands on issues related to political, economic, social or cultural life in the country, as well as issues related to foreign policy (section 2(1) of the Public Events Act).", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Regulation of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "The Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets, no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), defines a 'gathering' (собрание) as an assembly of citizens in a specially designated or arranged location for the purpose of the collective discussion of socially important issues (section 2(2) of the Public Events Act).", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Regulation of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "The Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets, no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), defines a 'meeting' (митинг) as a mass assembly of citizens at a certain location with the aim of publicly expressing an opinion on topical, mainly social or political issues (section 2(3) of the Public Events Act).", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Regulation of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "The Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets, no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), defines a 'demonstration' (демонстрация) as an organised expression of public opinion by a group of citizens with the use, while advancing, of placards, banners and other means of visual expression (section 2(4) of the Public Events Act).", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Regulation of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "The Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets, no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), defines a 'march' (шествие) as a procession of citizens along a predetermined route with the aim of attracting attention to certain problems (section 2(5) of the Public Events Act).", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Regulation of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "The Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets, no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), defines a 'picket' (пикетирование) as a form of public expression of opinion which does not involve movement or the use of loudspeaker equipment, where one or more citizens with placards, banners and other means of visual expression station themselves near the target object of the picket (section 2(6) of the Public Events Act).", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Regulation of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "Under the Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets, no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), an organiser of a public event, except for a gathering and a picket held by one person, must notify the competent authority (section 7(1) of the Public Events Act).", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Regulation of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "It appears that only a solo picket was not subject to the requirement of prior notification under the Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets (the Public Events Act), as indicated by decisions nos. 4a-4310/2015 and 7-14096/2015 of the Moscow City Court dated 11 November and 22 December 2015 respectively.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Regulation of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "Certain courts considered that both a gathering and a solo picket were not subject to the prior notification requirement under the Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets (the Public Events Act), as indicated by decision no. 4a-427/2015 of the Samara Regional Court dated 4 June 2015.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Regulation of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "The Police Act 1991 (Federal Law no. 1026-I of 18 April 1991) authorised police officers to use physical force, including combat fighting techniques, to stop crimes being committed, apprehend offenders, and overcome resistance to lawful orders, if less intrusive means had not allowed the officers to fulfil their functions (section 13 of the Police Act 1991).", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Use of force by the police"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "Under the Police Act 1991 (Federal Law no. 1026-I of 18 April 1991), everyone was required to comply with the lawful order of a police officer, and failure to comply with such an order, or obstruction in relation to such an order, would result in the person concerned incurring legal liability.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Use of force by the police"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "Under the Police Act 1991 (Federal Law no. 1026-I of 18 April 1991), police officers could not be held responsible for pecuniary or non-pecuniary damage or damage to health caused by the use of physical force if the damage was proportionate to the resistance of the person concerned (section 23 of the Police Act 1991).", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Use of force by the police"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "Under the Police Act 1991 (Federal Law no. 1026-I of 18 April 1991), when using physical force, a police officer was required to strive to limit any damage caused to the person concerned, bearing in mind the nature and degree of the danger posed by the offence and the danger posed by the person concerned, as well as his or her resistance (section 12 of the Police Act 1991).", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Use of force by the police"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "Under the Police Act 1991 (Federal Law no. 1026-I of 18 April 1991), when using physical force, a police officer was required to ensure an injured person's access to medical assistance (section 12 of the Police Act 1991).", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Use of force by the police"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "Under the Police Act 1991 (Federal Law no. 1026-I of 18 April 1991), the use of force in the context of exceeding authority, constituting abuse of power, could entail legal liability.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Use of force by the police"]}, {"fact_id": "F205", "text": "Under the Police Act 1991 (Federal Law no. 1026-I of 18 April 1991), a police officer could rely on the provisions of the Criminal Code relating to self-defence, causing damage during the arrest of a person who had committed a crime, and extreme necessity (section 24 of the Police Act 1991).", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Use of force by the police"]}, {"fact_id": "F206", "text": "Article 39 § 1 of the Criminal Code of Russia provides that the harming of legally protected interests in a state of extreme necessity, that is, for the purpose of removing a direct danger to a person or his rights, to the rights of other persons, or to the legally protected interests of society or the State, shall not be deemed to be a crime if this danger could not be removed by other means and if there was no exceeding the limits of extreme necessity.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Use of force by the police"]}, {"fact_id": "F207", "text": "Article 39 § 2 of the Criminal Code of Russia provides that the infliction of harm that clearly does not correspond to the nature and the degree of danger threatened, nor to the circumstances under which the danger was removed, when equal or more considerable harm was caused to the legally protected interests than the harm averted, shall be deemed to exceed extreme necessity, and such exceeding of authority shall involve criminal liability only in cases of intended infliction of harm.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Use of force by the police"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F007", "F008", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F027", "F032", "F035", "F055", "F066", "F067", "F088", "F089", "F091", "F102", "F111", "F191"], "interference": ["F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F025", "F026", "F031", "F038", "F060", "F065", "F072", "F077", "F094", "F095", "F103"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F025", "F026", "F030", "F031", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F041", "F042", "F060", "F061", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F066", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F070", "F071", "F072", "F075", "F076", "F091", "F094", "F095", "F096", "F097", "F102", "F103", "F107", "F108", "F109", "F110", "F111", "F122", "F123", "F124", "F129", "F130", "F131", "F132", "F133", "F134", "F136", "F137", "F138", "F139", "F140", "F141", "F153", "F159", "F160", "F161", "F162", "F174", "F191", "F196", "F198"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F008", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F027", "F035", "F067", "F089", "F102", "F111"], "interference": ["F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F025", "F026", "F031", "F038", "F077", "F094", "F095"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F026", "F031", "F036", "F038", "F063", "F064", "F067", "F070", "F071", "F076", "F095", "F096", "F102", "F111", "F122", "F124", "F130", "F131", "F132", "F133", "F134", "F174", "F191", "F196"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F008", "F014", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F026", "F031", "F038", "F067", "F071", "F076", "F089", "F095", "F096", "F111", "F122", "F124", "F130", "F131", "F132", "F174", "F196"]}} {"case_name": "case_130", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_131", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1952.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1966.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1947.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The first, second and third applicants live in Washington (Tyne and Wear).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The fourth applicant is an environmental group set up by the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The fourth applicant is based in Washington (Tyne and Wear).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The new town centre of Washington is known as 'the Galleries'.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Galleries is located within an area owned by Postel Properties Limited ('Postel'), a private company.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Galleries was originally built by the Washington Development Corporation ('the Corporation'), a body set up by the government of the United Kingdom pursuant to an Act of Parliament to build the 'new' centre.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Galleries was sold to Postel Properties Limited on 30 December 1987.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Galleries, as owned by Postel Properties Limited at the relevant time, comprised a shopping mall with two hypermarkets and major shops.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Galleries, as owned by Postel Properties Limited at the relevant time, comprised surrounding car parks with spaces for approximately 3,000 cars.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Galleries, as owned by Postel Properties Limited at the relevant time, comprised walkways.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Public services were available in the vicinity of the Galleries.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The freehold of the careers' office within or near the Galleries was owned by the Council.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The freehold of the public library within or near the Galleries was owned by the Council.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The social services office within or near the Galleries was leased to the Council by the Secretary of State.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The health centre within or near the Galleries was leased to the Council by the Secretary of State.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The freehold of the police station within or near the Galleries was held on behalf of Northumbria Police Authority.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "There was a post office within the Galleries.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The offices of the housing department within the Galleries were leased to the Council by Postel Properties Limited.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Around September 1997, the Council gave outline planning permission to the City of Sunderland College to build on a part of Princess Anne Park in Washington known as the Arena.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Arena is the only playing field in the vicinity of Washington town centre which is available for use by the local community.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The first to third applicants, together with other concerned residents, formed the fourth applicant to campaign against the City of Sunderland College's proposal to build on the Arena.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The first to third applicants, together with other concerned residents, formed the fourth applicant to persuade the Council not to grant the City of Sunderland College permission to build on the Arena.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On or around 14 March 1998, the first applicant, together with her husband and son, set up two stands at the entrance of the shopping mall in the Galleries.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The stands set up by the first applicant on or around 14 March 1998 displayed posters alerting the public to the likely loss of the open space known as the Arena.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The stands set up by the first applicant on or around 14 March 1998 were used to seek signatures to present to the Council on behalf of Washington First Forum.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Security guards employed by Postel Properties Limited would not let the first applicant or her assistants continue to collect signatures on any land or premises owned by Postel Properties Limited.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicants had to remove their stands from the Galleries.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicants had to stop collecting signatures at the Galleries.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "In March 1998, the manager of one of the hypermarkets in the Galleries gave the applicants permission to set up stands within that store.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The permission granted by the manager of one of the hypermarkets in March 1998 allowed the applicants to transmit their message and to collect signatures, albeit from a reduced number of people.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "In April 1998, the manager of one of the hypermarkets in the Galleries did not grant the applicants permission to collect signatures for a further petition.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 10 April 1998, the third applicant, as acting chair of Washington First Forum, wrote to the manager of the Galleries asking for permission to set up a stand and to canvass views from the public either inside the mall itself or in the adjacent car parks.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The third applicant offered to pay to be allowed to set up a stand and canvass views in the Galleries or adjacent car parks.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "In his reply of 14 April 1998, the manager of the Galleries refused the third applicant access to the Galleries and adjacent car parks.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "In his letter of 14 April 1998, the manager of the Galleries stated that the Galleries is unique in that although it is the Town Centre, it is also privately owned.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "In his letter of 14 April 1998, the manager of the Galleries stated that the owner's stance on all political and religious issues is one of strict neutrality and that he was charged with applying this philosophy.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "In his letter of 14 April 1998, the manager of the Galleries stated that he was obliged to refuse permission for Washington First Forum to carry out a petition within the Galleries or the adjacent car parks.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 19 April 1998, the third applicant wrote again to the manager of the Galleries asking him to reconsider his decision to refuse access.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The third applicant's letter of 19 April 1998 to the manager of the Galleries remained unanswered.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The fourth applicant continued to try to reach the public by setting up stands by the roadside on public footpaths.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The fourth applicant continued to try to reach the public by going to the old town centre at Concord.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The old town centre at Concord is visited by a much smaller number of Washington residents than the Galleries.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The deadline for letters of representation to the Council regarding the building works on the Arena was 1 May 1998.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 30 April 1998, the applicants submitted 3,200 letters of representation they had obtained to the Council.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The fourth applicant produced a list of associations and others which were given permission to carry out collections, set up stands and displays within the Galleries.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Salvation Army was given permission to carry out a collection before Christmas within the Galleries.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Local school choirs were given permission to carry out carol-singing and a collection before Christmas within the Galleries.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Stop Smoking Campaign was given permission to set up an advertising display and hand out nicotine patches within the Galleries.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Blood Transfusion Service was given permission to carry out a blood collection within the Galleries.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Royal British Legion was given permission to carry out a collection for Armistice Day within the Galleries.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Various photographers were given permission to carry out advertising and taking of photographs within the Galleries.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "British Gas was given permission to set up a staffed advertising display within the Galleries.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "From 31 January to 6 March 2001, Sunderland Council ran a consultation campaign under the banner 'Your Council, Your Choice'.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The 'Your Council, Your Choice' campaign informed local residents of three leadership choices for the future of Sunderland Council.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Sunderland Council was allowed to use the Galleries for the 'Your Council, Your Choice' consultation campaign.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The 'Your Council, Your Choice' campaign was a statutory consultation exercise carried out under section 25 of the Local Government Act 2000.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Section 25 of the Local Government Act 2000 required local authorities to draw up proposals for the operation of 'executive arrangements' and consult local electors before sending them to the Secretary of State.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Some 8,500 people were reported as having responded to the 'Your Council, Your Choice' survey.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "At common law, a private property owner may in certain circumstances be presumed to have extended an implied invitation to members of the public to come onto his land for lawful purposes.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "At common law, the implied invitation to members of the public to enter private property applies to commercial premises such as shops, theatres and restaurants.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "At common law, there is a presumption that a house owner authorises people to come up the path to his front door to deliver letters or newspapers or for political canvassing.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "At common law, any implied invitation to members of the public to enter private property may be revoked at will.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "At common law, a private person's ability to eject people from his land is generally unfettered and he does not have to justify his conduct or comply with any test of reasonableness.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "In CIN Properties Ltd v. Rawlins ([1995] 2 EGLR 130), the applicants were young men who were barred from a shopping centre in Wellingborough by the private company owner CIN Properties Ltd on the basis that their behaviour was a nuisance.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "In CIN Properties Ltd v. Rawlins ([1995] 2 EGLR 130), the Court of Appeal held that CIN Properties Ltd had the right to determine any licence which the applicants might have had to enter the shopping centre in Wellingborough.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "In CIN Properties Ltd v. Rawlins ([1995] 2 EGLR 130), Lord Phillips found that the local authority had not entered into any walkways agreement with CIN Properties Ltd within the meaning of section 18(1) of the Highways Act 1971 (later replaced by section 35 of the Highways Act 1980) which would have dedicated the walkways or footpaths as public rights of way.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "In CIN Properties Ltd v. Rawlins ([1995] 2 EGLR 130), Lord Phillips found that a walkways agreement within the meaning of section 18(1) of the Highways Act 1971 would have given the local council the power to issue by-laws regulating the use of those rights of way.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "In CIN Properties Ltd v. Rawlins ([1995] 2 EGLR 130), Lord Phillips found there was no basis for finding an equitable licence in favour of the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "In CIN Properties Ltd v. Rawlins ([1995] 2 EGLR 130), Lord Phillips considered case-law from North America concerning the applicants' arguments for the finding of some kind of public right.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "In Uston v. Resorts International Inc. (1982) N.J. 445A.2d 370, the Supreme Court of New Jersey laid down as a general proposition that when property owners open their premises to the general public in pursuit of their own property interests, they have no right to exclude people unreasonably but have a duty not to act in an arbitrary or discriminatory manner towards persons who come on their premises.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "In CIN Properties Ltd v. Rawlins ([1995] 2 EGLR 130), Lord Phillips noted that the decision in Uston v. Resorts International Inc. (1982) N.J. 445A.2d 370 was based upon a previous decision of the Supreme Court of New Jersey in State v. Schmid (1980) N.J. 423A 2d 615, which clearly turned upon the constitutional freedoms of the First Amendment to the United States Federal Constitution.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "In CIN Properties Ltd v. Rawlins ([1995] 2 EGLR 130), Lord Phillips stated that the general proposition from Uston v. Resorts International Inc. has no application in English law.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "In Harrison v. Carswell (1975) 62 D.L.R. 3d 68, the Supreme Court of Canada considered the right of an employee of a tenant in a shopping centre to picket her employer in the centre against the wishes of the owner of the centre.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "In Harrison v. Carswell (1975) 62 D.L.R. 3d 68, the majority of the Supreme Court of Canada held that the employee had no right to picket her employer in the shopping centre and that the owner of the centre had sufficient control or possession of the common areas to enable it to invoke the remedy of trespass.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "In Harrison v. Carswell (1975) 62 D.L.R. 3d 68, Laskin C.J.C. in a strong dissenting judgment held that since a shopping centre was freely accessible to the public, the public did not enter under a revocable licence subject only to the owner's whim.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "In his dissenting judgment in Harrison v. Carswell (1975) 62 D.L.R. 3d 68, Laskin C.J.C. stated that members of the public visiting a shopping centre are privileged visitors whose privilege is revocable only upon misbehaviour or by reason of unlawful activity.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "In CIN Properties Ltd v. Rawlins ([1995] 2 EGLR 130), Lord Phillips accepted that courts may have to be ready to adapt the law to new social facts where necessary.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "In CIN Properties Ltd v. Rawlins ([1995] 2 EGLR 130), Lord Phillips held that there was no necessity for courts to adapt the law where Parliament had already made adequate provision for the new social facts in question, as it had by section 18 of the Highways Act 1971 and section 35 of the Highways Act 1980.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "In CIN Properties Ltd v. Rawlins ([1995] 2 EGLR 130), Lord Phillips held that where Parliament has legislated and the Council, as representing the public, chooses not to invoke the statutory machinery, it is not for the courts to intervene.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "In CIN Properties Ltd v. Rawlins ([1995] 2 EGLR 130), Lord Phillips allowed the appeal on the basis that CIN Properties Ltd had the right, subject only to the issue under section 20 of the Race Relations Act 1976, to determine any licence the applicants may have had to enter the shopping centre.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The parties referred to case-law from the United States and Canada in the proceedings before the Court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The First Amendment to the United States Federal Constitution protects freedom of speech and peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The United States Supreme Court has accepted a general right of access to certain types of public places, such as streets and parks, known as 'public fora', for the exercise of free speech (Hague v. Committee for Industrial Organisation, 307 U.S. 496 (1939)).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "In Marsh v. Alabama (326 U.S. 501, 66 S.Ct. 276, 90 L.Ed. 265 (1946)), the United States Supreme Court held that a privately owned corporate town having all the characteristics of other municipalities was subject to the First Amendment rights of free speech and peaceable assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The United States Supreme Court has found that the First Amendment to the United States Federal Constitution does not require access to privately owned properties, such as shopping centres, on the basis that there has to be 'State action' (a degree of State involvement) for the amendment to apply (see, for example, Hudgens v. NLRB, 424 U.S. 507 (1976)).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "In Lloyd Corp. v. Tanner (47 U.S. 551, 92 S.Ct. 2219, 33 L.Ed. 2d 131 (1972)), the United States Supreme Court held that the First Amendment to the United States Federal Constitution does not prevent a private shopping-centre owner from prohibiting distribution on its premises of leaflets unrelated to its own operations.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "In Pruneyard Shopping Center v. Robbins (447 U.S. 74, 64 L.Ed. 2d 741, 100 S.Ct. 2035 (1980)), the United States Supreme Court held that State constitutional provisions could adopt more expansive liberties than the United States Federal Constitution to permit individuals reasonably to exercise free speech and petition rights on the property of a privately owned shopping centre to which the public was invited.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "In Pruneyard Shopping Center v. Robbins (447 U.S. 74, 64 L.Ed. 2d 741, 100 S.Ct. 2035 (1980)), the United States Supreme Court held that permitting individuals to exercise free speech and petition rights on privately owned shopping centre property did not violate the property rights of the shopping-centre owner so long as any restriction did not amount to taking without compensation or contravene any other federal constitutional provisions.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Some United States State courts have found that a right of access to shopping centres could be derived from provisions in their State constitutions according to which individuals could initiate legislation by gathering a certain number of signatures in a petition (see, for example, Batchelder v. Allied Stores Int'l, N.E. 2d 590 (Massachusetts, 1983); Lloyd Corp. v. Whiffen, 849 P. 2d 446, 453-54 (Oregon, 1993); Southcenter Joint Venture v. National Democratic Policy Comm., 780 P. 2d 1282 (Washington, 1989)).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Some United States State courts have found that a right of access to shopping centres could be derived from provisions in their State constitutions according to which individuals could stand for office by gathering a certain number of signatures.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "In Bock v. Westminster Mall Co., 819 P. 2d 55 (Colorado, 1991), the court found State obligations arising because the shopping centre was a State actor due to financial participation of public authorities in its development and the active presence of government agencies in the common areas.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "In Jamestown v. Beneda, 477 N.W. 2d 830 (North Dakota, 1991), the court found State obligations arising because the shopping centre was owned by a public body, although leased to a private developer.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "In State v. Shack, 277 A. 2d 369 (New Jersey, 1971), the court ruled that under New Jersey property law, ownership of real property did not include the right to bar access to governmental services available to migrant workers, in that case a publicly funded non-profit lawyer attempting to advise migrant workers.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "In Uston v. Resorts International, 445 A. 2d 370 (New Jersey, 1982), a New Jersey case concerning casinos, the court held that when property owners open their premises to the general public in pursuit of their own property interests they have no right to exclude people unreasonably, although it was acknowledged that the private law of most States did not require a right of reasonable access to privately owned property (p. 374).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "In Streetwatch v. National Railroad Passenger Corp., 875 F. Supp. 1055 (Southern District of New York, 1995), the court considered the ejection of homeless people from a railway station.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "In Arizona, the court ruled in Fiesta Mall Venture v. Mecham Recall Comm., 767 P. 2d 719 (Court of Appeals, 1989) that free speech provisions in the Arizona State constitution did not apply to privately owned shopping centres.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "In Connecticut, the court ruled in Cologne v. Westfarms Assocs, 469 A. 2d 1201 (1984) that free speech provisions in the Connecticut State constitution did not apply to privately owned shopping centres.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "In Georgia, the court ruled in Citizens for Ethical Gov't v. Gwinnet Place Assoc., 392 S.E. 2d 8 (1990) that free speech provisions in the Georgia State constitution did not apply to privately owned shopping centres.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "In Michigan, the court ruled in Woodland v. Michigan Citizens Lobby, 378 N.W. 2d 337 (1985) that free speech provisions in the Michigan State constitution did not apply to privately owned shopping centres.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "In Minnesota, the court ruled in State of Minnesota v. Wicklund et al., 7 April 1998 (Court of Appeals) that free speech provisions in the Minnesota State constitution did not apply to privately owned shopping centres.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "In North Carolina, the court ruled in State of North Carolina v. Felmet, 273 S.E. 2d 708 (1981) that free speech provisions in the North Carolina State constitution did not apply to privately owned shopping centres.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "In Ohio, the court ruled in Eastwood Mall v. Slanco, 626 N.E. 2d 59 (1994) that free speech provisions in the Ohio State constitution did not apply to privately owned shopping centres.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "In Pennsylvania, the court ruled in Western Pa Socialist Workers 1982 Campaign v. Connecticut Gen. Life Ins. Co., 515 A. 2d 1331 (1986) that free speech provisions in the Pennsylvania State constitution did not apply to privately owned shopping centres.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "In South Carolina, the court ruled in Charleston Joint Venture v. McPherson, 417 S.E. 2d 544 (1992) that free speech provisions in the South Carolina State constitution did not apply to privately owned shopping centres.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "In Washington State, the court ruled in Southcenter Joint Venture v. National Democratic Policy Comm., 780 P. 2d 1282 (Washington, 1989) that free speech provisions in the Washington State constitution did not apply to privately owned shopping centres.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "In Wisconsin, the court ruled in Jacobs v. Major, 407 N.W. 2d 832 (1987) that free speech provisions in the Wisconsin State constitution did not apply to privately owned shopping centres.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "A. The United States"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Prior to the entry into force of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, the Canadian Supreme Court had taken the view that the owner of a shopping centre could exclude protesters (Harrison v. Carswell, 62 D.L.R. 3d 68 (1975)).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "B. Canada"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "After the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms entered into force, a lower court held that the right to free speech applied in privately owned shopping centres (R. v. Layton, 38 C.C.C. 3d 550 (1986) (Provincial Court, Judicial District of York, Ontario)).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "B. Canada"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "An individual judge of the Canadian Supreme Court, McLachlin J, expressed the view obiter in Committee for Cth of Can. v. Canada [1991] 1 SCR 139, 228 that the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms does not confer a right to use private property as a forum of expression.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. CASES FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS", "B. Canada"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": false, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "interference": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F035"], "interference": ["F008", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F040"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": ["F008", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F047", "F062", "F065", "F066"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F024", "F026", "F028", "F035"], "interference": ["F008", "F029", "F037"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": ["F008", "F029", "F037", "F043", "F044", "F047", "F062", "F065", "F066"]}, "list3": ["F008", "F029", "F037", "F043", "F044", "F047", "F062", "F065", "F066"]}} {"case_name": "case_132", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_133", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Aristov) was born in 1986.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Aristov) lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The second applicant (Mr Gromov) was born in 1983.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The second applicant (Mr Gromov) lives in Moscow Region.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 7-65, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 7-33, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The parties' submissions on the circumstances directly relevant to the present cases are set out below.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 6 May 2012 a public demonstration entitled the 'March of Millions' was held in central Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration on 6 May 2012 was held to protest against the allegedly rigged presidential elections.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration on 6 May 2012 had been approved by the Moscow city authorities in the form of a march followed by a meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The approved demonstration on 6 May 2012 was supposed to end at 7.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The march on 6 May 2012 was peaceful and held without any disruptions.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "When the marchers arrived at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, it became apparent that barriers installed by the police had narrowed the entrance to the meeting venue.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The barriers installed by the police at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 allegedly restricted the space allocated for the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "To control the crowd at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, a police cordon forced the protestors to remain within the barriers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "There were numerous clashes between the police and protesters at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police ordered that the meeting at Bolotnaya Square finish early.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police began to disperse the participants of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "It took the police about two hours to clear the protestors from Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Aristov) and the second applicant (Mr Gromov) took part in the demonstration on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Aristov) and the second applicant (Mr Gromov) were arrested at the venue of the demonstration on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "After their arrest, the first applicant (Mr Aristov) and the second applicant (Mr Gromov) were brought to police stations where they were charged with administrative offences.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "After an overnight detention, the first applicant (Mr Aristov) and the second applicant (Mr Gromov) were brought before the justices of the peace and convicted as charged.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the first applicant (Mr Aristov), during the demonstration on 6 May 2012 he stood at the intersection of Malyy Kamennyy Bridge and Bolotnaya Embankment and filmed the event.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the first applicant (Mr Aristov), at 6 p.m. on 6 May 2012 he was picked out of the crowd and apprehended by the police.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the first applicant (Mr Aristov), he did not cause any disorder at the time of his apprehension on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the first applicant (Mr Aristov), he did not resist the police officers who arrested him on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the first applicant (Mr Aristov), the police officers who arrested him on 6 May 2012 gave no orders during his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the Government, the first applicant (Mr Aristov) was arrested at 6 p.m. on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the Government, the first applicant (Mr Aristov) was arrested because he had participated in breaking the police cordon at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the Government, the first applicant (Mr Aristov) was arrested because he had disregarded police orders to cease his actions at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "At 7.20 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the first applicant (Mr Aristov) was brought to Basmannyy district police station in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "At Basmannyy district police station, an on-duty officer drew up a record of the first applicant's (Mr Aristov's) administrative escort for the purpose of compiling an administrative file.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The record of administrative arrest of the first applicant (Mr Aristov) indicated that he had been arrested at 7.20 p.m. at Basmannyy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The record of administrative arrest of the first applicant (Mr Aristov) indicated that he was released on 7 May 2012 at 9.20 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "An on-duty officer at Basmannyy district police station drew up an administrative-offence record against the first applicant (Mr Aristov) on the basis of reports and explanatory notes by police officers P. and Ch., who had arrested the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The reports and explanatory notes by police officers P. and Ch. regarding the first applicant (Mr Aristov) were drawn up using an identical template.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The reports and explanatory notes by police officers P. and Ch. regarding the first applicant (Mr Aristov) contained no individualised information except the police officers' personal information and the applicant's name.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Aristov) was accused of having disobeyed a lawful order of the police, an offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The administrative-offence record against the first applicant (Mr Aristov) reiterated the police reports, stating that the applicant, acting as part of a group of 15,000 citizens, took part in an authorised meeting.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The administrative-offence record against the first applicant (Mr Aristov) stated that the applicant chanted slogans 'Russia without Putin', 'Putin is a thief', and 'United Russia is a party of crooks and thieves'.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The administrative-offence record against the first applicant (Mr Aristov) stated that during the event the participants broke the police cordon and tried to enter Red Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The administrative-offence record against the first applicant (Mr Aristov) stated that the applicant did not react to the multiple lawful demands of Officers P. and Ch. to stop breaking the police cordon and continued his unlawful acts, in breach of Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 7 May 2012 the first applicant (Mr Aristov) was brought before the Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Before the Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow, the first applicant (Mr Aristov) insisted that he had not broken the police cordon and had been arrested by the police with no warnings or orders.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Aristov) applied to have the two police officers who had arrested him examined as witnesses before the Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow rejected the first applicant's (Mr Aristov's) application to have the two arresting police officers examined as witnesses, in order to expedite the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow questioned two witnesses for the defence in the case of the first applicant (Mr Aristov).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow examined a video recording submitted by the first applicant's (Mr Aristov's) representative.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On the basis of the police officers' reports and explanations and the records of the administrative escorting and arrest, the Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow established that the first applicant (Mr Aristov) had committed an administrative offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, as described in the administrative-offence record.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow dismissed as unreliable the testimony of defence witnesses, who stated that the first applicant (Mr Aristov) had not chanted any slogans in their presence and had not participated in breaking the cordon.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow dismissed the video recording submitted by the first applicant (Mr Aristov) on the grounds that it showed the background of the events in question rather than the applicant's arrest.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow dismissed the video recording submitted by the first applicant (Mr Aristov) on the additional grounds that it did not contain any sound and could not therefore prove whether the applicant had chanted any slogans or not.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow sentenced the first applicant (Mr Aristov) to twenty-four hours' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 22 May 2012 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow examined the first applicant's (Mr Aristov's) appeal against the judgment of 7 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow, the first applicant (Mr Aristov) repeated his application to summon and question the two police officers who had arrested him on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow rejected the first applicant's (Mr Aristov's) application to summon and question the two arresting police officers owing to the applicant's failure to name those officers.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow, the first applicant (Mr Aristov) insisted that he had not chanted any slogans and had not participated in breaking the police cordon.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow questioned two defence witnesses who confirmed the first applicant's (Mr Aristov's) account of events but stated that they had not observed his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow dismissed the testimony of the two defence witnesses as unreliable because both witnesses were the first applicant's (Mr Aristov's) friends.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Relying on the reports and written statements of the police officers, the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow upheld the first-instance judgment convicting the first applicant (Mr Aristov) of an administrative offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Aristov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "According to the second applicant (Mr Gromov), on 6 May 2012 at 4 p.m. he came to Bolotnaya Square to participate in the authorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "According to the second applicant (Mr Gromov), he could not leave the venue of the demonstration on 6 May 2012 because all the ways out of Bolotnaya Square had been cordoned off by the police.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "According to the second applicant (Mr Gromov), he stood in the crowd at Bolotnaya Square waiting for further information about the demonstration from its organisers.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "According to the second applicant (Mr Gromov), around 7.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 he saw State Duma Deputy Ponomarev with a megaphone and came closer to listen to him together with ten other participants.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "According to the second applicant (Mr Gromov), at that moment a few police officers ran out of the cordon and arrested State Duma Deputy Ponomarev and everyone around him, including the second applicant (Mr Gromov).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "According to the Government, the second applicant (Mr Gromov) was arrested at 8.10 p.m. on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "According to the Government, the second applicant (Mr Gromov) was arrested because he was participating in breaking the police cordon at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "According to the Government, the second applicant (Mr Gromov) was arrested because he had disregarded the police order to cease breaking the police cordon and to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "At 9 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the second applicant (Mr Gromov) was brought to Veshnyaki district police station in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "At Veshnyaki district police station, an on-duty officer drew up a record of the second applicant's (Mr Gromov's) administrative escort at 9.10 p.m. on 6 May 2012 for the purpose of compiling an administrative-offence record.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "At 9.20 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the second applicant (Mr Gromov) was administratively arrested at Veshnyaki district police station.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "According to the record of the second applicant's (Mr Gromov's) administrative arrest, he was released on 7 May 2012 at 10.50 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The second applicant (Mr Gromov) was accused of having disobeyed a lawful order of the police, an offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The administrative-offence record against the second applicant (Mr Gromov) contained a printed template stating that the police repeatedly announced through a loudhailer lawful demands to stop the march but the applicant, acting as part of a group of citizens, broke the police cordon.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The administrative-offence record against the second applicant (Mr Gromov) stated that the applicant did not react to multiple demands to cease these actions and disperse, and continued his unlawful acts, thereby attracting the attention of the public and mass media.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The administrative-offence record against the second applicant (Mr Gromov) stated that the applicant tried to cause confusion among the public (создать суматоху среди граждан), thereby demonstrating his refusal to obey the lawful orders of the police officers and precluding them from fulfilling their service duties, in breach of Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The administrative case file of the second applicant (Mr Gromov) contained two hand-written reports by police officers D. and S., who had arrested the second applicant on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The hand-written reports by police officers D. and S. repeated the description of the second applicant's (Mr Gromov's) acts contained in the administrative-offence record.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 7 May 2012 the second applicant (Mr Gromov) was brought before the Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow adjourned the case of the second applicant (Mr Gromov) to 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 15 May 2012 the Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow decided to transfer the case of the second applicant (Mr Gromov) owing to the lack of jurisdiction.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "On 14 August 2012 the Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 114 of the Luberetskiy Court District of Moscow Region examined the charges against the second applicant (Mr Gromov).", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Upon the second applicant's (Mr Gromov's) application, the Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 114 of the Luberetskiy Court District of Moscow Region questioned the applicant's sister, who was an eyewitness to his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The second applicant's (Mr Gromov's) sister confirmed his account of events — that he had come closer to listen to State Duma Deputy Ponomarev and was arrested along with those around the deputy — but the Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 114 of the Luberetskiy Court District of Moscow Region dismissed her statements as unreliable evidence.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 114 of the Luberetskiy Court District of Moscow Region questioned Officers D. and S., who stated that after the end of the demonstration, at around 8 p.m. on 6 May 2012, the second applicant (Mr Gromov), acting as part of a group of citizens, had broken the police cordon and begun the march towards Red Square.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Officers D. and S. stated that as the second applicant (Mr Gromov) had not reacted to multiple demands to stop, he had been arrested together with other participants following a radio communication order.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "On the basis of the police officers' statements and reports, the Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 114 of the Luberetskiy Court District of Moscow Region found the second applicant (Mr Gromov) guilty under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Court Circuit no. 114 of the Luberetskiy Court District of Moscow Region sentenced the second applicant (Mr Gromov) to a fine of 700 Russian roubles (approximately 18 euros at the time).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The second applicant (Mr Gromov) appealed against the judgment of 14 August 2012, pointing out that he had been arrested by riot squad officers rather than by Officers D. and S.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "On 24 September 2012 the Lyuberetskiy Town Court of the Moscow Region examined the second applicant's (Mr Gromov's) appeal against the judgment of 14 August 2012.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Lyuberetskiy Town Court of the Moscow Region upheld the judgment of 14 August 2012 convicting the second applicant (Mr Gromov) under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Lyuberetskiy Town Court of the Moscow Region dismissed the second applicant's (Mr Gromov's) allegations that he had been arrested by riot squad officers rather than by Officers D. and S.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Lyuberetskiy Town Court of the Moscow Region considered that the statements of Officers D. and S. about the second applicant's (Mr Gromov's) failure to obey their lawful demands to stop marching after the end of the event had been trustworthy.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, detention and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Mr Gromov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law applicable to the present cases, see Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 77-79, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F008", "F010", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F020", "F024", "F026", "F027", "F030", "F031", "F041", "F045", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F068"], "interference": ["F017", "F018", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F054", "F089"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F016", "F018", "F030", "F031", "F039", "F054", "F068", "F069", "F074", "F089"], "necessity": ["F011", "F017", "F019", "F028", "F030", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F045", "F047", "F050", "F054", "F057", "F067", "F075", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F088", "F089", "F092"], "positive_obligation": ["F005", "F013", "F014", "F015"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F008", "F010", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F020", "F026", "F041", "F065"], "interference": ["F017", "F021", "F023"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F039", "F074"], "necessity": ["F019", "F037", "F038", "F041", "F047", "F050", "F054", "F067", "F085", "F086", "F089"], "positive_obligation": ["F013", "F014", "F015"]}, "list3": ["F020", "F013", "F015", "F021", "F023", "F037", "F038", "F041", "F047", "F085", "F019", "F067", "F054"]}} {"case_name": "case_134", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_135", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1959.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr V. Grigoryan of the European Human Rights Advocacy Centre (EHRAC) based in London.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr P. Leach of the European Human Rights Advocacy Centre (EHRAC) based in London.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant was represented by Ms J. Gavron of the European Human Rights Advocacy Centre (EHRAC) based in London.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant was represented by Ms J. Evans of the European Human Rights Advocacy Centre (EHRAC) based in London.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr L. Simonyan, a lawyer practising in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr G. Kostanyan.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr Y. Kirakosyan, Representative of the Republic of Armenia to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 19 February 2008 a presidential election was held in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the then Prime Minister, Mr Serzh Sargsyan, representing the ruling party.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the main opposition candidate, Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Immediately after the announcement of the preliminary results of the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election, Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan called on his supporters to gather at Freedom Square in central Yerevan in order to protest against alleged irregularities in the election process.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan announced that the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election had not been free and fair.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "From 20 February 2008 onwards, nationwide daily protest rallies were held by Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan's supporters.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The main meeting place of Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan's supporters during the post-election protest rallies was Freedom Square and the surrounding park in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The rallies at Freedom Square attracted at times tens of thousands of people.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Several hundred demonstrators stayed at Freedom Square around the clock, having set up a camp.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant was a known political figure and a former minister of foreign affairs.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant acted as the head of Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan's pre-election campaign.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant was actively involved in the post-election protests following the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant regularly attended the demonstrations held at Freedom Square in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant gave speeches at the demonstrations held at Freedom Square in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant and the group of opposition supporters whom he had joined had conspired to usurp State power.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Government alleged that the assembly at Freedom Square had pursued the aim of usurping State power by discrediting the presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The Government alleged that the assembly at Freedom Square had pursued the aim of usurping State power by creating illusions of public discontent and revolt.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Government alleged that the assembly at Freedom Square had pursued the aim of usurping State power by destabilising the internal political situation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 24 February 2008 the Central Election Commission of Armenia announced that Mr Serzh Sargsyan had won the 19 February 2008 presidential election with around 52% of all votes cast.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 24 February 2008 the Central Election Commission of Armenia announced that Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan had received around 21% of votes in the 19 February 2008 presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 29 February 2008 the protest rallies at Freedom Square were still in full swing.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 1 March 2008, at some point around 6-7 a.m., a police operation was conducted at Freedom Square in Yerevan where several hundred demonstrators were camping.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant alleged that the aim of the police operation on 1 March 2008 at Freedom Square had been forcibly to terminate the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The applicant alleged that a large police force had violently attacked the demonstrators at Freedom Square with rubber batons and electric shock devices, without any prior warning.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant alleged that the police attack on demonstrators at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008 forced the demonstrators to flee the square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Government contested the applicant's allegations regarding the police operation at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Government claimed that the reason for the police operation at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008 had been to verify information obtained on the previous day by the Armenian Police and National Security Service, according to which a large number of weapons were to be distributed to the protesters to incite provocative actions and riots in Yerevan on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Government claimed that when police officers tried to carry out the verification task at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008, about 800 to 900 armed demonstrators attacked them.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Government claimed that as a result of the attack by demonstrators at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008, numerous police officers had been injured.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 1 March 2008 a criminal case was instituted under several Articles of the Armenian Criminal Code in connection with the events at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The criminal case instituted on 1 March 2008 in connection with the events at Freedom Square included charges of organising and holding an unlawful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The criminal case instituted on 1 March 2008 in connection with the events at Freedom Square included charges of incitement to disobedience of police orders to terminate the unlawful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The criminal case instituted on 1 March 2008 in connection with the events at Freedom Square included charges of illegal possession of arms and ammunition.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The criminal case instituted on 1 March 2008 in connection with the events at Freedom Square included charges of life-threatening assaults on police officers.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The decision to institute criminal proceedings on 1 March 2008 stated that after the announcement of the preliminary results of the 19 February 2008 presidential election, Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan organised and held mass public events at Yerevan's Freedom Square in violation of the procedure prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The decision to institute criminal proceedings on 1 March 2008 stated that members of parliament K.S. and S.M. organised and held mass public events at Yerevan's Freedom Square in violation of the procedure prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The decision to institute criminal proceedings on 1 March 2008 stated that the chief editor of Haykakan Zhamanak daily newspaper, N.P., organised and held mass public events at Yerevan's Freedom Square in violation of the procedure prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The decision to institute criminal proceedings on 1 March 2008 stated that the organisers and participants made calls inciting disobedience of decisions ordering an end to the events held in violation of the procedure prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The decision to institute criminal proceedings on 1 March 2008 stated that a number of participants in the mass events illegally possessed and carried illegally obtained arms and ammunition.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The decision to institute criminal proceedings on 1 March 2008 stated that on 1 March 2008 at around 6 a.m., when the police took measures aimed at forcibly ending the public events held in violation of the procedure prescribed by law in compliance with the requirements of section 14 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the organisers and participants committed a life- and health-threatening assault on police officers with clubs, metal rods and other adapted objects.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The decision to institute criminal proceedings on 1 March 2008 stated that the assault on police officers caused the police officers injuries of varied severity.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "After Freedom Square was cleared of demonstrators on 1 March 2008, some demonstrators relocated to the area near the French Embassy, the Yerevan Mayor's Office and the Myasnikyan monument, situated about 1.7-2 km from Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The demonstrators who relocated near the French Embassy, the Yerevan Mayor's Office and the Myasnikyan monument on 1 March 2008 were joined by thousands of others who poured into the streets of Yerevan in response to the events of the early morning.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The applicant was present in the area near the French Embassy, the Yerevan Mayor's Office and the Myasnikyan monument on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Rallies continued near the French Embassy, the Yerevan Mayor's Office and the Myasnikyan monument, as well as in a number of adjacent streets including Grigor Lusavorich, Mashtots, Leo and Paronyan streets, until the early morning of 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Tensions gradually escalated during the rallies on 1-2 March 2008, resulting in clashes between some protesters and law enforcement officers.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "As a result of the events of 1-2 March 2008 in Yerevan, ten persons died, including eight civilians.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "As a result of the events of 1-2 March 2008 in Yerevan, numerous persons were injured.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "As a result of the events of 1-2 March 2008 in Yerevan, public and private property was damaged.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "A state of emergency was declared by the outgoing President of Armenia following the events of 1-2 March 2008 in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Government alleged that the disorder which took place in Yerevan on 1 and 2 March 2008 had been incited and organised by the applicant in conspiracy with several other active opposition supporters.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicant contested the Government's allegation that the disorder which took place in Yerevan on 1 and 2 March 2008 had been incited and organised by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 2 March 2008 another criminal case was instituted under, inter alia, Article 225 § 3 of the Armenian Criminal Code (organising mass disorder involving murder) in connection with the events of 1 and 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The decision to institute the criminal case on 2 March 2008 stated that Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan, the candidate running for president at the 19 February 2008 presidential election, and his followers and supporters, including members of parliament K.S. and S.M., the chief editor of Haykakan Zhamanak daily newspaper N.P., and others, not willing to concede defeat at the election, organised mass disorder involving murders, violence, massacre, arson, destruction of property and armed resistance to public officials, with the use of firearms, explosives and other adapted objects, from 1 March 2008 in the area of the Yerevan Mayor's Office and central streets.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The decision to institute the criminal case on 2 March 2008 stated that the aim of the organisers was to cast doubt on the 19 February 2008 presidential election, instil distrust towards the results among large segments of the population, create illusions of public discontent and revolt, and discredit the election and the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 2 March 2008 the two criminal cases (instituted on 1 March 2008 and 2 March 2008) were joined and examined under criminal case no. 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 10 March 2008 the applicant was arrested by officers of the National Security Service on suspicion of usurpation of State power.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 10 March 2008 the applicant was questioned as a suspect.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 10 March 2008 the applicant refused to testify when questioned as a suspect.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 10 March 2008 the applicant stated that his prosecution was politically motivated.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 12 March 2008 the applicant was charged under Article 225 § 3 of the Armenian Criminal Code within the scope of criminal case no. 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 12 March 2008 the applicant was charged under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (usurpation of State power) within the scope of criminal case no. 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The charging decision of 12 March 2008 stated that after the 19 February 2008 presidential election, the applicant joined the group of supporters of Levon Ter-Petrosyan and, having conspired with them to usurp State power in violation of the constitutional order, actively participated in carrying out activities for that purpose.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The charging decision of 12 March 2008 stated that the applicant's activities included discrediting the pre-election process and the conduct of the election, instilling distrust towards the results among large segments of the population, creating illusions of public discontent and revolt, and organising and holding unlawful demonstrations aimed at destabilising the internal political situation.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The charging decision of 12 March 2008 stated that the applicant, three other members of parliament and a number of other opposition supporters incited and organised mass disorder which took place in Yerevan on 1 and 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The charging decision of 12 March 2008 stated that the mass disorder in Yerevan on 1 and 2 March 2008 involved mass violence, massacre, arson, destruction and damage of public and private property, armed resistance to public officials and murder.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 12 March 2008 a court ordered the applicant's pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 1 December 2008 the prosecutor approved the bill of indictment against the applicant and six other opposition leaders, commonly known as the 'Case of Seven'.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The criminal case against the applicant and six other opposition leaders (the 'Case of Seven') had been disjoined from criminal case no. 62202608 before being transferred for trial.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 1 December 2008 the criminal case against the applicant and six other opposition leaders (the 'Case of Seven') was transferred for trial.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 31 March 2009 the prosecutor replaced the charge against the applicant under Article 225 § 3 of the Armenian Criminal Code with a charge under Article 225 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 31 March 2009 the prosecutor dropped the charge against the applicant under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The prosecutor dropped the charge under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code on the ground that on 24 March 2009 Article 225 § 3 of the Armenian Criminal Code had been repealed.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The prosecutor dropped the charge under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code on the ground that Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code had been amended and could not be applied retroactively.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 1 April 2009 the cases against the applicant and one of the co-accused, S.S., were disjoined into separate proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On 22 June 2009 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found the applicant guilty under Article 225 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code of organising mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "On 22 June 2009 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan sentenced the applicant to five years in prison.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "On 22 June 2009 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan applied an amnesty and freed the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that Serzh Sargsyan won the presidential election held on 19 February 2008.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant and S.S., together with a group of people, starting from 20 February 2008 carried out organisational activities for the purpose of creating discontent in society towards the conduct and results of the 19 February 2008 presidential election and preparing the crowd gathered at Freedom Square for use of violence and disobedience.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant and S.S. spread false information about the assembly at Freedom Square being authorised by the municipal authorities, about around 500,000 people attending it, about the election result being rigged, and about presidential candidate Levon Ter-Petrosyan winning 60% of the votes cast.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant and S.S. provided participants of the assembly at Freedom Square with household items and money in order to ensure the constant presence of people at the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that rods, clubs, armature, petrol bombs, metal constructions used as missile weapons, firearms and ammunition were distributed to a group of participants of the assembly at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that on 29 February 2008 intelligence information was received by the Armenian Police and the National Security Service that a group of persons intended to instigate mass disorder in Yerevan on 1 March 2008 through provocations and that a large quantity of clubs, metal rods, explosive substances, firearms and grenades were to be distributed among the participants of the assembly at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that in the early morning of 1 March 2008 the police tried to discover illegal items at Freedom Square and to prevent their use, for the purpose of verifying intelligence information regarding the illegal turnover of firearms, ammunition, explosive substances, explosive devices and various objects adapted to cause physical injuries for the purpose of instigating mass disorder in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant and his co-thinkers were informed in advance about the police operation at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that as a result of the police operation on 1 March 2008, some objects brought for the purpose of mass disorder, including firearms and ammunition, were discovered at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that after the police operation at Freedom Square, participants of the assembly, led by the applicant, S.S. and others, moved and gathered in the area adjacent to the Myasnikyan monument in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that at around 11 a.m. on 1 March 2008 the participants of the mass disorder blocked Grigor Lusavorich street by placing trolleybuses along the carriageway, after which they attacked the police officers upholding public order.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the participants of the mass disorder beat a number of police officers on several occasions.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the participants of the mass disorder armed themselves with objects including stones, rods and sticks, as well as explosive substances, explosive devices, firearms and Molotov cocktails which had been prepared beforehand and brought to the area of the mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that Molotov cocktails were filled with flammable liquid immediately behind the platform at the Myasnikyan monument and in the nearby park.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant and S.S., together with a group of others, arranged and managed the activities of other organisers and participants of the mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that S.S., together with a group of others, regularly circulated among the participants of the mass disorder and organised their activities aimed at building barricades and showing armed resistance to the police.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that S.S., being in the epicentre of the mass disorder, regularly updated the applicant regarding the ongoing massacre, arson and the deliberate destruction, damage and looting of property, carrying out new orders received from the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan proceeded to describe the damage caused by the unrest in its judgment of 22 June 2009.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "On 21 July 2009 the applicant lodged an appeal against the judgment of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan of 22 June 2009, raising numerous arguments including that the charge against him was trumped up and politically motivated.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "On 31 July 2009 the Criminal Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal against the judgment of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan of 22 June 2009.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "On 28 August 2009 the applicant lodged an appeal on points of law against the judgment of the Criminal Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "On 10 September 2009 the Court of Cassation declared the applicant's appeal on points of law inadmissible for lack of merit.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The relevant provisions of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003) are set out in Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia (no. 49020/08, §§ 44-46, 15 October 2020).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code (2003)"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The relevant extracts of the Armenian Ombudsman's Ad Hoc Public Report regarding the 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events are set out in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (no. 23086/08, § 124, 20 September 2018).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "B. Ad Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The relevant extracts of the Armenian Ombudsman's Ad Hoc Public Report regarding the 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events are set out in Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia (no. 49020/08, § 49, 15 October 2020).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "B. Ad Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "In its Resolutions regarding the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election and the events that followed, the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) condemned the arrest and continuing detention of scores of persons, including more than 100 opposition supporters and three members of parliament.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) condemned the arrest and continuing detention of persons on seemingly artificial and politically motivated charges, especially those under Articles 225 and 300 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The relevant extracts of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) Resolutions and other relevant international materials regarding the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election and subsequent events are set out in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (no. 23086/08, §§ 125-34, 20 September 2018) and Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia (no. 49020/08, §§ 51-57, 15 October 2020).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F037", "F052", "F056", "F086", "F087", "F093", "F094", "F095", "F097"], "interference": ["F022", "F023", "F024", "F086", "F087", "F088"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F032", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F052", "F053", "F056", "F067", "F071", "F072", "F086", "F087", "F090", "F091", "F092", "F093", "F094", "F095", "F097", "F103", "F104", "F105", "F114", "F115"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F016", "F017", "F018", "F021", "F023", "F024", "F031", "F032", "F037", "F093", "F095", "F097"], "interference": ["F023", "F024", "F086", "F087"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F032", "F034", "F035", "F052", "F053", "F056", "F090", "F091", "F092", "F093", "F095", "F097", "F103", "F105", "F114", "F115"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F023", "F024", "F086", "F087", "F090", "F091", "F092", "F103", "F052", "F053", "F056", "F032", "F034", "F035", "F114", "F115"]}} {"case_name": "case_137", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Asainov) was born in 1968.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Asainov) lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) was born in 1975.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) lives in Mashabei Sadeh, Israel.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 7-65, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 7-33, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 6 May 2012 a public demonstration entitled the 'March of Millions' was held in central Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration on 6 May 2012 was held to protest against the allegedly rigged presidential elections.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration on 6 May 2012 had been approved by the Moscow city authorities in the form of a march followed by a meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The approved meeting at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 was supposed to end at 7.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The march on 6 May 2012 was peaceful and held without any disruptions.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "When the marchers arrived at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, it transpired that barriers installed by the police had narrowed the entrance to the meeting venue, allegedly restricting the space allocated for the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "To control the crowd at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, a police cordon forced the protestors to remain within the barriers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "There were numerous clashes between the police and protesters at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police ordered that the meeting at Bolotnaya Square finish early and began to disperse the participants.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "It took the police about two hours to clear the protestors from Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicants (Mr Asainov and Ms Sibiryak) took part in the demonstration on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicants (Mr Asainov and Ms Sibiryak) were arrested at the venue of the demonstration on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "After their arrest, the applicants (Mr Asainov and Ms Sibiryak) were taken to police stations.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "At the police stations, the applicants (Mr Asainov and Ms Sibiryak) were charged with administrative offences.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicants (Mr Asainov and Ms Sibiryak) were convicted of administrative offences as charged by the justices of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the first applicant (Mr Asainov), on 6 May 2012 he had arrived at Bolotnaya Square to take part in the peaceful demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the first applicant (Mr Asainov), around 8.55 p.m. on 6 May 2012 he had been arrested outside the venue of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the first applicant (Mr Asainov), before his arrest on 6 May 2012 he had not committed any breach of public order or other offences.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the first applicant (Mr Asainov), before his arrest on 6 May 2012 he had not received any orders from the police.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the Government, the first applicant (Mr Asainov), as a participant in the authorised demonstration on 6 May 2012, had broken through the police cordon and tried to pass to Red Square.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the Government, the first applicant (Mr Asainov) had ignored the police orders to cease his actions of breaking through the police cordon on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the Government, the first applicant (Mr Asainov) had actively resisted the police officers while being taken to the police van on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "At 8.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the first applicant (Mr Asainov) was brought to the Fili-Davydkovo district police station in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "At the Fili-Davydkovo district police station, an on-duty officer drew up a record of the first applicant's (Mr Asainov's) administrative escorting for the purpose of compiling an administrative file.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The administrative arrest record for the first applicant (Mr Asainov) indicated that he had been arrested at 8.30 p.m. at the Fili-Davydkovo district police station on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The administrative arrest record for the first applicant (Mr Asainov) indicated that he had been released at 11.05 p.m. on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "A duty officer at the Fili-Davydkovo district police station drew up an administrative offence record in respect of the first applicant (Mr Asainov).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The administrative offence record stated that on 6 May 2012 at 8.30 p.m. at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow the first applicant (Mr Asainov) took part in an authorised meeting.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The administrative offence record stated that the first applicant (Mr Asainov) broke through the police cordon and tried to enter Red Square, pushing police officers away.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The administrative offence record stated that the first applicant (Mr Asainov) did not react to the multiple lawful demands of the police to cease these actions and actively resisted while being taken to the police van.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The administrative offence record stated that the first applicant's (Mr Asainov's) conduct was in breach of Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, demonstrating his refusal to obey the lawful orders of the police officers and preventing them from fulfilling their service duties.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 29 May 2012 the Justice of the Peace of circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow examined the administrative charges against the first applicant (Mr Asainov) in his presence.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On the basis of the statements of two police officers, the Justice of the Peace of circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow established that the first applicant (Mr Asainov) had committed an administrative offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, as described in the administrative offence record.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Asainov) was sentenced by the Justice of the Peace of circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow to a fine of 500 Russian roubles (about EUR 12 at the time).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Asainov) appealed against the judgment of the Justice of the Peace to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 7 June 2012 the first applicant's (Mr Asainov's) wife, who had been an eye-witness to the events of 6 May 2012, submitted written statements to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the first applicant's (Mr Asainov's) wife, she had come to take part in the authorised demonstration at Bolotnaya Square with her husband on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the first applicant's (Mr Asainov's) wife, she and her husband passed Yakimanka Street together with other participants of the demonstration on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the first applicant's (Mr Asainov's) wife, when they approached Malyy Kamennyy Bridge the march stopped on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to the first applicant's (Mr Asainov's) wife, after standing and waiting for some time they decided to cease their participation in the demonstration on 6 May 2012 but could not leave the venue and remained at the pavement.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to the first applicant's (Mr Asainov's) wife, around 8.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police told them to proceed to the metro station, which they did.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "According to the first applicant's (Mr Asainov's) wife, on the way to the metro station at 8.55 p.m. on 6 May 2012 her husband was arrested by police officers who gave no orders and was taken to the police van.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "According to the first applicant's (Mr Asainov's) wife, after her husband's arrest she went to the Fili-Davydkovo police station to wait for his release.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 16 July 2012 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow examined and partly granted the first applicant's (Mr Asainov's) request to exclude the written statements of the police officers as inadmissible evidence.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow summoned the police officers to be examined at the hearing as witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 2 August 2012 the hearing at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow was adjourned to 23 August 2012.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The first applicant's (Mr Asainov's) request to be represented by one more lawyer was granted by the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Asainov) and his lawyer were duly summoned to the hearing scheduled for 23 August 2012 at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 22 August 2012 the first applicant (Mr Asainov) sent a telegram to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow asking to adjourn the hearing on the grounds that he was away from Moscow for family reasons.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 23 August 2012 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held a hearing in the absence of the first applicant (Mr Asainov) and his lawyers.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow mentioned at the 23 August 2012 hearing that none of the first applicant (Mr Asainov) or his lawyers had lodged a request to adjourn the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "At the 23 August 2012 hearing, the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow questioned two police officers.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The two police officers questioned at the 23 August 2012 hearing stated that the first applicant (Mr Asainov), together with other participants of the demonstration, had pushed through the police cordon and tried to approach the Kremlin.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The two police officers questioned at the 23 August 2012 hearing stated that the first applicant (Mr Asainov) had pushed the police officers away.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The two police officers questioned at the 23 August 2012 hearing stated that the first applicant (Mr Asainov) had thrown stones, glass bottles and smoke bombs.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The two police officers questioned at the 23 August 2012 hearing stated that the first applicant (Mr Asainov) had disregarded multiple demands by the police to cease his actions.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The two police officers questioned at the 23 August 2012 hearing stated that the first applicant (Mr Asainov) had resisted arrest.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The appeal decision of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow of 23 August 2012 did not mention the eye-witness statement submitted by the first applicant's (Mr Asainov's) wife.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Relying on the testimony of the two police officers, the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow upheld the first-instance judgment convicting the first applicant (Mr Asainov) of an administrative offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "1. The first applicant (Mr Asainov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak), she arrived at Oktyabrskaya metro station at 4 p.m. on 6 May 2012 to take part in the peaceful demonstration at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak), she passed Yakimanka Street with other participants of the demonstration on 6 May 2012, but on approaching Bolotnaya Square found the entrance blocked.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak), around 6.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police started to break the crowd up into groups and push them.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak), two police officers grabbed her hands and pushed her towards the police van on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak), she did not breach public order and had not taken part in any acts of violence prior to her arrest on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak), at around 9.05 p.m. on 6 May 2012 she was brought to Khoroshevskiy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak), after the police drew up an administrative offence record at Khoroshevskiy district police station, she was released at around 1.40 a.m. on 7 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "According to the Government, the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) was arrested at 7.15 p.m. on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square because she had been participating in breaking through the police cordon.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "According to the Government, the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) had disregarded the police order to cease breaking through the police cordon and to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "According to the Government, the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) was taken to the police station at 8.10 p.m. on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "According to the Government, the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) was released at 10.35 p.m. on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The logbook of persons brought to the Khoroshevskiy district police station indicated that the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) was taken there at 7.50 p.m. on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The logbook of persons brought to the Khoroshevskiy district police station indicated that the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) was released at 10.35 p.m. on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The administrative file for the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) contained no record of her being escorted to the Khoroshevskiy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The record of administrative arrest for the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak), compiled at 8.20 p.m. on 6 May 2012, indicated that she had been taken to the Khoroshevskiy district police station at 8.10 p.m. and released later on the same day.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) was accused of having disobeyed a lawful police order, which was an offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The administrative offence record for the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) stated that on 6 May 2012 at 7.15 p.m. she took part in an authorised meeting at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The administrative offence record for the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) stated that she broke through the police cordon and tried to approach the Kremlin.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The administrative offence record for the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) stated that she did not react to the multiple lawful demands of the police officers to cease these actions, thereby preventing them from fulfilling their service duties, in breach of Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The administrative case-file for the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) contained a police officer's report which was drawn up on a template.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The police officer's report in the second applicant's (Ms Sibiryak's) administrative case-file contained no individualised information except the police officer's and the applicant's personal data.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The police officer's report in the second applicant's (Ms Sibiryak's) administrative case-file substantially repeated the description of the applicant's acts contained in the administrative offence record.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The police officer's report in the second applicant's (Ms Sibiryak's) administrative case-file added that the applicant had thrown stones at the police, lit fireworks and resisted arrest.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "On 30 May 2012 the Justice of the Peace of Circuit Court no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow examined the administrative charges against the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) was not present at the 30 May 2012 hearing before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit Court no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow, even though she had been summoned to attend.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "On the basis of the police officer's report, the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) was found guilty under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences by the Justice of the Peace of Circuit Court no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) was sentenced by the Justice of the Peace of Circuit Court no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of Moscow to a fine of 500 Russian roubles (about EUR 12 at the time).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "On 13 November 2012 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow examined the second applicant's (Ms Sibiryak's) appeal in her presence.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "On 13 November 2012 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow upheld the first-instance judgment convicting the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) of an administrative offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The second applicant's (Ms Sibiryak's) request to have the police officers who had arrested her examined at the 13 November 2012 hearing before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow was dismissed.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "At the second applicant's (Ms Sibiryak's) request, the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow examined a witness of defence at the 13 November 2012 hearing.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The defence witness at the 13 November 2012 hearing stated that the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) had not participated in breaking through the police cordon and had not committed any unlawful acts.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow dismissed the defence witness's statements as unreliable evidence on the grounds that he was the second applicant's (Ms Sibiryak's) friend.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow considered that the second applicant (Ms Sibiryak) had been duly summoned to the first-instance hearing by telephone but had failed to appear or to lodge a request for its adjournment.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 15 April 2013 the Deputy President of the Moscow City Court examined the second applicant's (Ms Sibiryak's) administrative case in supervisory review proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On 15 April 2013 the Deputy President of the Moscow City Court upheld the earlier judicial decisions in the second applicant's (Ms Sibiryak's) administrative case.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest and conviction for administrative offences", "2. The second applicant (Ms Sibiryak)"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic law is set out in Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 77-79, ECHR 2016 (extracts)).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F009", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F017", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F066", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F070"], "interference": ["F015", "F018", "F020", "F021"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F014", "F015", "F020", "F037", "F081", "F084"], "necessity": ["F016", "F018", "F021", "F035", "F039", "F040", "F064", "F065", "F083", "F091", "F092", "F094", "F095", "F097", "F098"], "positive_obligation": ["F005", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F007", "F009", "F012", "F013", "F017", "F024", "F070"], "interference": ["F015", "F018", "F021"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F020"], "necessity": ["F021", "F039", "F064", "F065", "F091", "F095", "F097", "F098"], "positive_obligation": ["F012", "F013", "F015"]}, "list3": ["F007", "F009", "F012", "F017", "F018", "F021", "F064", "F065", "F095", "F097", "F098"]}} {"case_name": "case_138", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1965.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant works as a cook.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "In February-March 2003 a presidential election took place in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Following the February-March 2003 presidential election in Armenia, the applicant participated in a series of rallies of protest organised in Yerevan by the opposition parties.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 7 April 2003 at 5 p.m. a demonstration was held in the centre of Yerevan on the occasion of Mother's Day.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The demonstration of 7 April 2003 took place on the Mashtots Avenue next to the Research Institute of Ancient Manuscripts (Մատենադարան).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The demonstration of 7 April 2003 appears to have been of a political nature.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "During the demonstration of 7 April 2003, criticism of the Government and of the conduct of the presidential election was voiced.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicant alleged that traffic was suspended by the traffic police on the relevant stretch of the Mashtots Avenue prior to the commencement of the demonstration of 7 April 2003 in order to facilitate its conduct.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Government did not dispute the applicant's allegation that traffic was suspended by the traffic police on the relevant stretch of the Mashtots Avenue prior to the commencement of the demonstration of 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant took part in the demonstration of 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant took part in the march that followed the demonstration of 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the applicant, at around 6 p.m. on 7 April 2003 she went to work.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the applicant, after work at around 9 p.m. on 7 April 2003 the applicant went home.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the applicant, on her way home on 7 April 2003 she was approached by three men in civilian clothes who, without presenting themselves, started dragging her to a nearby car.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the applicant, the three men who approached her on 7 April 2003 twisted her arms, punched her and pushed her into the car.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the applicant, she screamed and tried to resist when the three men in civilian clothes attempted to drag her to a nearby car on 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant was taken to the Central District Police Station of Yerevan (ՀՀ ոստիկանության Երևան քաղաքի կենտրոնական բաժին).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "At the Central District Police Station of Yerevan, the applicant found out that she had been arrested for having participated in the demonstration of 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "At the Central District Police Station of Yerevan, the arresting police officers drew up a record of the applicant's arrest (արձանագրություն բերման ենթարկելու մասին).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The record of the applicant's arrest stated that the applicant had been \"arrested at 7.30 p.m. at 12 Khorhurdneri Street for violating public order\".", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant alleged that the time of her apprehension was not correctly recorded in the arrest record.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant alleged that in reality she was arrested at 9 p.m. on 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "One of the arresting police officers reported to the Head of the Central District Police Station of Yerevan (ՀՀ ոստիկանության Երևան քաղաքի կենտրոնական բաժնի պետ) that the applicant was brought to the Central District Police Station for having participated on 7 April 2003 in an unauthorised march headed from the Research Institute of Ancient Manuscripts (Մատենադարան) to the Constitutional Court and violated public order.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant was subjected to a search at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan following her arrest on 7 April 2003, during which no illegal items were found.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "A record of the search of the applicant was drawn up following the search on 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The police officers questioned the applicant following her arrest on 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant made a written statement (արձանագրություն բացատրություն վերցնելու մասին) in which she gave details of her participation in the demonstration of 7 April 2003 and the following march.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "In her written statement of 7 April 2003, the applicant stated that the street traffic was obstructed when the march headed towards the building of the Constitutional Court.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "In her written statement of 7 April 2003, the applicant stated that she was in the front line holding the Armenian flag and screaming \"justice\".", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant alleged that her written statement of 7 April 2003 was made under pressure and was dictated to her by the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant alleged that while most of her written statement of 7 April 2003 was true, the part concerning the obstruction of traffic did not correspond to reality since the traffic had been beforehand suspended by the traffic police.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The police officers drew up a record of an administrative offence (վարչական իրավախախտման արձանագրություն) in which it was stated that the applicant had \"participated in a march and violated public order\" on 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant's actions on 7 April 2003 were qualified under Article 172 of the Code of Administrative Offences (Վարչական իրավախախտումների վերաբերյալ ՀՀ օրենսգիրք – \"the CAO\") as minor hooliganism.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The record of an administrative offence relating to the events of 7 April 2003 was signed by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant put her signature in the section of the record of an administrative offence of 7 April 2003 certifying that she had been made aware of her rights under Article 267 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "In the section of the record of an administrative offence of 7 April 2003 marked as \"other information relevant for the determination of the case\", the applicant added \"I do not wish to have a lawyer\".", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicant alleged that she was forced to sign the record of an administrative offence and other documents prepared by the police officers on 7 April 2003 under threat of violence.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicant alleged that the police officers persuaded her to refuse a lawyer on 7 April 2003 by insisting that a lawyer's involvement would not help and would only be detrimental to her case.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 7 April 2003 at around 12 midnight the applicant was taken to Judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan (Երևան քաղաքի Կենտրոն և Նորք-Մարաշ համայնքների առաջին ատյանի դատարան), who examined the case.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Government contested the applicant's allegation that she was forced to sign documents under threat of violence on 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant was kept at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan for two hours on 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant was taken to Judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan at 9.30 p.m. on 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the Government, the police officers explained to the applicant her right to have a lawyer on 7 April 2003 and advised her to avail herself of this right, which she did not wish to do.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to the Government, the record of an administrative offence of 7 April 2003 was signed by the applicant voluntarily and without any objections.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant failed to initiate any actions aimed at the defence of her rights on 7 April 2003, such as lodging motions or availing herself of other procedural rights guaranteed by Article 267 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO), despite having been made aware of them.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The materials of the applicant's administrative case arising from the events of 7 April 2003 were transmitted by the police to Judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan for examination.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The materials of the applicant's administrative case arising from the events of 7 April 2003 contained the following documents: (1) the record of an administrative offence; (2) the police report; (3) the record of the applicant's arrest; (4) the record of the search of the applicant; and (5) the applicant's written statement.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "All documents in the applicant's administrative case arising from the events of 7 April 2003 were signed by the applicant except the police report.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan, after a brief hearing, sentenced the applicant under Article 172 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) to an administrative fine of 1500 Armenian drams (approximately EUR 2.4 at the material time) in relation to the events of 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Judge M.'s entire finding in relation to the events of 7 April 2003 stated: \"On 7 April 2003 between 4 p.m. and 6 p.m. ... on the Mashtots Avenue [the applicant], together with a group of people, obstructed street traffic, violated public order by making a loud noise, and incited other participants of the demonstration to do the same...\"", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing of 7 April 2003, drawn up in calligraphic handwriting, the hearing was held in public with the participation of the judge, a clerk and the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing of 7 April 2003, the judge explained the applicant's rights to her and informed her of the possibility to challenge the judge and the clerk.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing of 7 April 2003, the applicant did not wish to lodge any challenges.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing of 7 April 2003, the applicant stated that she was aware of her rights and did not wish to have a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing of 7 April 2003, the judge read out the motion submitted by the police, seeking to impose administrative liability on the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing of 7 April 2003, the applicant submitted that at 4.30 p.m. she had participated in a march which had taken place in the Central District of Yerevan, during which they had obstructed the traffic and invited other people to join them.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing of 7 April 2003, no questions were put to the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing of 7 April 2003, the judge read out and examined the materials prepared by the police.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing of 7 April 2003, having familiarised herself with the materials, the applicant accepted that she had signed the record of an administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing of 7 April 2003, the judge departed to the deliberation room, after which he returned and announced the decision.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The applicant alleged, and the Government did not explicitly dispute, that the record of the court hearing of 7 April 2003 was a fake and was drafted at some point after the hearing in order to create an appearance of lawfulness.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The applicant alleged that in reality there was no clerk present at the court hearing of 7 April 2003 and the hearing was not being recorded.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicant alleged that the court hearing of 7 April 2003 lasted not more than five minutes and was conducted in Judge M.'s office.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The applicant alleged that, contrary to what the record stated, only Judge M., the applicant and the accompanying police officer were present at the court hearing of 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The applicant alleged that the accompanying police officer at the court hearing of 7 April 2003 did not participate in the hearing and his functions were limited only to bringing the applicant before the judge.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The applicant alleged that at the court hearing of 7 April 2003, Judge M. neither explained her rights nor asked whether she wanted to have a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The applicant alleged that at the court hearing of 7 April 2003, the materials of the case file were not read out and she was not allowed to make any oral submissions.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The applicant alleged that at the court hearing of 7 April 2003, no evidence was taken or examined.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The applicant alleged that at the court hearing of 7 April 2003, Judge M. prepared the decision solely on the basis of the materials prepared by the police.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The applicant alleged that at the court hearing of 7 April 2003, Judge M. threatened the applicant with imminent detention if she did not refrain from further participation in demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 8 April 2003 the applicant complained to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Prosecutor (Կենտրոն և Նորք-Մարաշ համայնքների դատախազ) about the events of 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "In her complaint of 8 April 2003 to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Prosecutor, the applicant submitted that she had been arrested on false accusations.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "In her complaint of 8 April 2003 to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Prosecutor, the applicant submitted that the police officers had drafted a document and forced her to sign it without reading it.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "In her complaint of 8 April 2003 to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Prosecutor, the applicant submitted that at about 12.30 a.m. she had been brought before a judge who had sentenced her to a fine without any examination of the case.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "In her complaint of 8 April 2003 to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Prosecutor, the applicant submitted that she had sustained an injury to her wrist in the course of the arrest on 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "In her complaint of 8 April 2003 to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Prosecutor, the applicant sought to undergo an official medical examination and to have criminal proceedings instituted against the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The applicant alleged that in reply to her complaint of 8 April 2003 she was asked to appear in two days.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "It appears that the applicant did not pursue her complaint of 8 April 2003 to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Prosecutor any further.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 7 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 9 April 2003 at 12 noon another demonstration was organised in the same area (next to the Research Institute of Ancient Manuscripts on the Mashtots Avenue in Yerevan) by the opposition parties.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The demonstration of 9 April 2003 was followed by a march towards the Government building where the inauguration ceremony of the elected President was taking place.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The applicant was in the front line of the march of 9 April 2003, holding the Armenian flag.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "According to the applicant, the march of 9 April 2003 was blocked at the very beginning of the Mashtots Avenue by special forces.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "According to the applicant, since the demonstrators insisted on continuing their march on 9 April 2003, the special forces started to disperse the demonstration with rubber clubs.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "According to the applicant, she was ordered by a police officer on 9 April 2003 to hand over the flag.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "According to the applicant, she refused to hand over the flag on 9 April 2003, after which she was beaten and taken to a police car.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "At around 2.30 p.m. on 9 April 2003 the applicant was brought to the Central District Police Station of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The arresting police officers drew up a record of the applicant's arrest on 9 April 2003 in which it was stated that she had been \"arrested for having violated public order during the march of 9 April 2003\".", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "One of the arresting police officers reported to the Head of the Central District Police Station of Yerevan that during the march of 9 April 2003 after the demonstration next to the Research Institute of Ancient Manuscripts (Մատենադարան) he noticed one citizen who was violating public order: waving a flag while walking on the driveway, obstructing the regular traffic of public transport, creating an emergency situation, randomly hitting passers-by who were not taking part in the demonstration with the long flagpole, and inciting others to follow her example.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The applicant was subjected to a search at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan following her arrest on 9 April 2003, during which no illegal items were found.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "A record of the search of the applicant was drawn up following the search on 9 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The police officers questioned the applicant following her arrest on 9 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "A statement was taken from the applicant on 9 April 2003, although this time it was not written by the applicant herself.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "According to the statement taken on 9 April 2003, when the special forces blocked the march, the applicant who was in the frontline started to demand to pass through.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "According to the statement taken on 9 April 2003, the special forces ignored the applicant's demands and ordered her to leave.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "According to the statement taken on 9 April 2003, the applicant started to shout and hit the people standing behind her with the flagpole so that they would pay attention and also start to demand to pass through, after which she got arrested.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "According to the statement taken on 9 April 2003, the applicant admitted that the Mashtots Avenue was blocked because of the march.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The police officers drew up a record of an administrative offence on 9 April 2003 in which it was stated that the applicant had \"made a loud noise with a group of people, and randomly insulted and hit passers-by in the Central District\".", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The applicant's actions on 9 April 2003 were qualified under Article 172 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) as minor hooliganism.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "All documents relating to the applicant's arrest on 9 April 2003, including the record of an administrative offence, were signed by the applicant with the exception of the police report.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The applicant put her signature in the section of the record of an administrative offence of 9 April 2003 certifying that she had been made aware of her rights under Article 267 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "In the section of the record of an administrative offence of 9 April 2003 marked as \"other information relevant for the determination of the case\", the applicant added \"I do not wish to have a lawyer in administrative proceedings\".", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The applicant initially submitted that she had refused to sign any documents during her arrest of 9 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "In a later submission, the applicant claimed that due to the injuries and stress suffered during the apprehension on 9 April 2003 she could hardly stand and was in a difficult physical and psychological condition.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The applicant claimed that as a result of her difficult physical and psychological condition on 9 April 2003, she signed the record of an administrative offence unconsciously and without first familiarising herself with it.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The applicant claimed that she later did not even remember that she had signed any documents on 9 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The applicant refused a lawyer on 9 April 2003 for the same reasons as on 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "At 11 p.m. on 9 April 2003 the applicant was taken to Judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan, who examined the case.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Government contested the applicant's allegation regarding the circumstances of her stay at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan on 9 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant was kept at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan for two hours on 9 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant was taken to Judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan at around 5 p.m. on 9 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "According to the Government, the circumstances of the applicant's stay at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan on 9 April 2003 were similar to those of 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The materials of the applicant's administrative case arising from the events of 9 April 2003 were transmitted by the police to Judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan for examination.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The materials of the applicant's administrative case arising from the events of 9 April 2003 contained the following documents: (1) the record of an administrative offence; (2) the police report; (3) the record of the applicant's arrest; (4) the record of the search of the applicant; and (5) the applicant's written statement.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "All documents in the applicant's administrative case arising from the events of 9 April 2003 were signed by the applicant except the police report.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan sentenced the applicant under Article 172 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) to five days of administrative detention in relation to the events of 9 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Judge M.'s entire finding in relation to the events of 9 April 2003 stated: \"On 9 April 2003 between 11 a.m. and 1 p.m. in the Central District of Yerevan [the applicant], swearing loudly and hitting passers-by, obstructed street traffic and violated public order.\"", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "In deciding on the administrative penalty for the events of 9 April 2003, Judge M. took into account as an aggravating circumstance the repetition of the anti-social behaviour of 7 April 2003, i.e. re-commission of a similar offence within one year.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "In deciding on the administrative penalty for the events of 9 April 2003, Judge M. took into account as an aggravating circumstance that the offence was committed by a group of people.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The decision of Judge M. relating to the events of 9 April 2003 indicated that the applicant had no dependants.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The record of the court hearing of 9 April 2003 is almost identical in wording to the record of the court hearing of 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing of 9 April 2003, the applicant added in her submissions that she and other demonstrators had incited passers-by to participate in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing of 9 April 2003, the applicant added in her submissions that they had arguments with a few passers-by and there were also some swear words used, since some of the passers-by tried to mock her.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing of 9 April 2003, the applicant added in her submissions that she touched the passers-by with the flagpole accidentally.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The applicant alleged, and the Government did not explicitly dispute, that the court hearing of 9 April 2003 was in reality conducted in the same manner as the court hearing of 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The applicant alleged that at the court hearing of 9 April 2003, Judge M. asked the applicant: \"if you promise in writing that from now on you will not participate in demonstrations and marches any more, I will fine you and let you go home, otherwise I will detain you\".", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The applicant replied to Judge M. at the court hearing of 9 April 2003 that she had participated and would continue to participate in demonstrations, because she had not violated any laws and nobody had the right to prohibit her from enjoying her constitutional rights.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Judge M. pronounced the sentence of five days of administrative detention at the court hearing of 9 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Following the sentence pronounced by Judge M. on 9 April 2003, the applicant was taken to a detention centre where she served her sentence.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "On 15 April 2003 the applicant applied to a local human rights NGO called February 22nd («Փետրվարի 22» իրավապաշտպան կազմակերպություն), complaining about the events of 7 and 9 April 2003 and seeking its assistance.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "In her application of 15 April 2003 to the NGO February 22nd, the applicant submitted that on 7 April 2003 the police officers had prepared some documents and forced her to sign them without even familiarising herself with them first.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "On 18 April 2003 the NGO February 22nd complained to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Prosecutor (Կենտրոն և Նորք-Մարաշ համայնքների դատախազ) on behalf of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "By a letter of 12 May 2003 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Prosecutor (Կենտրոն և Նորք-Մարաշ համայնքների դատախազ) informed the NGO February 22nd that the decisions of 7 and 9 April 2003 had been well-founded and there were no grounds for appeal.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 9 April 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic provisions and international documents and reports applicable to this case can be found in the judgment in the case of Galstyan v. Armenia (no. 26986/03, §§ 25-32, 15 November 2007).", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F035", "F051", "F052", "F081", "F083", "F090", "F099", "F117", "F118", "F122", "F126", "F135"], "interference": ["F051", "F052", "F117", "F118"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F035", "F051", "F100", "F117"], "legitimate_aim": ["F034", "F035", "F052", "F090", "F099", "F100", "F118"], "necessity": ["F006", "F007", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F052", "F081", "F083", "F090", "F099", "F117", "F118", "F119", "F122", "F126"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F052", "F081", "F083", "F090", "F099", "F118", "F122", "F126"], "interference": ["F051", "F117"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F035", "F100"], "legitimate_aim": ["F052", "F099", "F118"], "necessity": ["F010", "F011", "F012", "F052", "F090", "F099", "F117", "F118", "F119", "F122", "F126"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F006", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F051", "F052", "F081", "F083", "F090", "F099", "F117", "F118", "F119", "F122", "F126"]}} {"case_name": "case_139", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The public assemblies in question were manifestations for fair elections to the Moscow City Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The manifestations for fair elections to the Moscow City Parliament took place in summer 2019 in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_141", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1963.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant claimed that his home had been in Trypimeni, a village in the District of Farmagusta in northern Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant had lived in Trypimeni with his parents and six siblings.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant's parents ran a grocery store in Trypimeni.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant's family home in Trypimeni was a house with a yard covering an area of 532 square metres.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant's family home in Trypimeni was registered under plot no. 81, sheet/plan 13/40.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant's family home in Trypimeni was owned by the applicant's father.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 7 September 1999, the applicant's father transferred ownership of the house in Trypimeni to Mr Georgios Asproftas (the applicant's brother) by way of gift.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Since the 1974 Turkish intervention, the applicant has been deprived of his home in Trypimeni, which was located in the area under the occupation and control of the Turkish military authorities.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Turkish military authorities prevented the applicant from having access to and from using the house in Trypimeni.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 19 July 1989, the applicant joined an anti-Turkish demonstration in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicants in the Chrysostomos and Papachrysostomou v. Turkey case also took part in the demonstration of 19 July 1989 in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant in the Loizidou v. Turkey case also took part in the demonstration of 19 July 1989 in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant before the Nicosia District Court on 4 January 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant before the Nicosia District Court on 4 January 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was held on the fifteenth anniversary of the Turkish intervention in Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant before the Nicosia District Court on 4 January 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was held in support of the missing persons and to protest against human rights violations.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant joined the demonstration of 19 July 1989 as a reporter for the newspaper Exormisis.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "During the demonstration of 19 July 1989, dozens of armed Turkish policemen and soldiers moved towards the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "During the demonstration of 19 July 1989, the UN peacekeeping cordon broke up and vanished.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "During the demonstration of 19 July 1989, Turkish forces started to beat some women demonstrators with batons, to kick them and drag them by the arms, legs and hair.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "While the applicant was trying to help some of the women demonstrators, he was grabbed and beaten by Turkish policemen.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant was hit in the face and other parts of the body by Turkish policemen during the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant was taken at gunpoint together with others who had also been arrested during the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant's photographic equipment was seized despite him showing his press card during the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant was led to a bus through an angry crowd of 200-300 civilians who shouted abuse and threats at him.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "As the applicant was walking without police protection, the crowd had an opportunity to rush at him, and he was dragged and beaten until two policemen came and accompanied him onto the bus.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant was transported to the so-called \"Pavlides Garage\", where a body search was carried out and all his personal effects were taken.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "At the so-called \"Pavlides Garage\", the crowd outside was shouting and throwing stones, some of which came through the roof.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "While at the so-called \"Pavlides Garage\", the applicant saw a policeman in civilian clothes who told him \"Turkey will kill you\".", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Sometime around midnight at the so-called \"Pavlides Garage\", the applicant was interrogated by an officer who spoke perfect Greek.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant did not give wholly accurate answers to some of the questions during the interrogation, preferring to lie about some of the detail.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The interrogating officer started a political discussion and tried to convey his own ideas to the applicant in a very friendly and diplomatic manner.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The applicant refused to sign a statement written in Turkish, as he considered it would have been tantamount to recognising the \"Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus\" (the \"TRNC\").", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "When one of the women detainees (Mrs Vrahimi, application no. 16078/90) was beaten at the so-called \"Pavlides Garage\", all the other prisoners remained silent, fearing for their fate.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "At around 2.30 a.m. on 20 July 1989, the applicant and some other men were ordered onto a police bus.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant was taken to the Seray Police Station, where, after a body search, he was held in a cell that was filthy, dirty and dark.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "During his stay in the cell at the Seray Police Station, the applicant heard the screams of other demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "At around 2.00 p.m. on 20 July 1989, the applicant was given back his personal effects and taken to court together with seven other prisoners.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "No proper translation was provided at the court hearing on 20 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "At the court hearing on 20 July 1989, a policeman acted as translator but translated only part of what the judge and the witnesses said.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "At the court hearing on 20 July 1989, the accused explained why they were taking part in the demonstration and in what capacity.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The applicant was remanded in custody for two days following the court hearing on 20 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant was taken to Ortakeuy Prison, where all his personal effects were removed again.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "At Ortakeuy Prison, the applicant was put with other men in a dormitory block.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "An hour after being placed in the dormitory block at Ortakeuy Prison, the applicant was blindfolded and led to another area of the prison.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "At Ortakeuy Prison, the applicant was interrogated by four or five army officers who could not speak any Greek, with a translator present.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The interrogation at Ortakeuy Prison touched on political and military subjects.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "After the interrogation at Ortakeuy Prison, the applicant was taken to another room to talk to a television anchorman.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 21 July 1989, the applicant was again taken to court together with nine other people.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "At the court hearing on 21 July 1989, the applicant had no legal representation.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "At the court hearing on 21 July 1989, no proper interpretation was provided, and the interpreter had difficulties in translating some of the words and was occasionally helped by the television anchorman.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "At the court hearing on 21 July 1989, one of the accused (the Bishop of Kitium) spoke on behalf of the others and said they would only accept as defence counsel a Greek-Cypriot or a UN lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "At the court hearing on 21 July 1989, the trial judge replied that she could only appoint a lawyer registered with the \"TRNC\" bar association.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "At the court hearing on 21 July 1989, the accused pleaded \"not guilty\" and stated that they did not recognise the legitimacy of the \"TRNC\" and of its tribunals.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "At the court hearing on 21 July 1989, four witnesses were called by the prosecution.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "At the court hearing on 21 July 1989, the Bishop of Kitium put some questions to the first prosecution witness, but those considered of a political character were ruled inadmissible by the trial judge.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "At the court hearing on 21 July 1989, the Bishop of Kitium made the following statement: \"since cross-examining the pseudo-witnesses of your pseudo-court may be regarded as indicating that we recognise the procedure, we say that we have nothing else to say and we shall not cross-examine any other pseudo-witness\".", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "From the point of the Bishop of Kitium's statement at the court hearing on 21 July 1989, the accused did not participate in the procedure.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "After the trial hearing on 21 July 1989, the applicant and his co-accused were taken back to prison and their pictures were taken.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 22 July 1989, the applicant was taken to court again.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 22 July 1989, a baying crowd gathered outside the courtroom.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 22 July 1989, the applicant was sentenced to three days' imprisonment and a fine of 50 Cypriot pounds (CYP) – approximately 85 euros (EUR).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The sentence imposed on the applicant on 22 July 1989 included five additional days in prison in default of payment of the fine within 24 hours.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 22 July 1989, there was an angry crowd in the court area shouting, swearing and making obscene gestures at the applicant and the other detainees.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The applicant was detained in Ortakeuy Prison from 24 until 28 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "During his detention in Ortakeuy Prison from 24 until 28 July 1989, the applicant refused to eat anything in order to protest against the prison director's refusal to give to the Bishop of Kitium the church vestments and holy vessels, which had been sent in order to allow the Bishop to celebrate mass.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 26 July 1989, the applicant was locked in an isolation cell at Ortakeuy Prison as punishment for refusing food.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The isolation cell at Ortakeuy Prison in which the applicant was placed on 26 July 1989 was extremely small and unbearably hot (40-60°C).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 28 July 1989, the applicant was released in front of journalists and television cameras.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 28 July 1989, the applicant was handed over to UN soldiers at the last Turkish sentry box and transported back to the southern part of Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "In support of his claim of ill-treatment, the applicant produced five medical certificates.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "A certificate issued on 16 December 2002 by Dr. Andreas G. Constantinides, consultant surgeon at the Evangelistria Medical Centre in Nicosia, stated that Mr Tasos Asproftas (the applicant) is suffering from osteoarthritis of the cervical cord and that Dr. Constantinides recommended he stay at home and undergo physiotherapy from 17 December until 28 December 2002.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "A certificate issued on an unspecified date by Dr. S.C. Sergiou, orthopaedic surgeon in Larnaka, stated that Mr Tasos Asproftas (the applicant) is suffering from cervical disc disease and is unable to work from 3 January 2003 until 12 January 2003.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "A certificate issued on 9 January 2003 by the medical and public health services – X-rays department – of the Republic of Cyprus stated that Mr Tasos Asproftas (the applicant) had a rear central hernia of the disc, rear lateral right osteophyte in the area of chronic hernia of the disc A4-A5, rear lateral left osteophyte in the area of chronic hernia in discs A5-A6 and A6-A7, straight cervical spine due to muscles' spasm, and stenosis of the middle sections of the spinal cord A4-A5 and A5-A6.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "A certificate issued on an unspecified date by Dr. Nicos Chr. Spanos, neurosurgeon in Nicosia, recommended that Mr Asproftas (the applicant) be granted sick leave from 13 January 2003 until 31 January 2003 for investigation and treatment of the cervical middle spinal disc.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "A certificate issued on 7 February 2003 by Dr. Nicolas C. Christodoulou, specialist in physical medicine and rehabilitation sport medicine in Limassol, diagnosed Mr Asproftas (the applicant) with severe left cervicobranchial syndrome (radiculitis C7) and instructed approximately 12 sessions of physiotherapy including interferential current, short wave diathermy, and mild cervical massage.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The applicant alleged that his health problems (osteoarthritis of the cervical cord, cervical disc disease, and related conditions) were the result of the savage blows he had received from Turkish policemen, soldiers and civilians in July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant had participated in a violent demonstration with the aim of inflaming anti-Turkish sentiment.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators, supported by the Greek-Cypriot administration, were demanding that the \"Green Line\" in Nicosia should be dismantled.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Government alleged that some demonstrators carried Greek flags, clubs, knives and wire-cutters.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators were acting in a provocative manner and shouting abuse.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators were warned in Greek and English that unless they dispersed they would be arrested in accordance with the laws of the \"TRNC\".", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was arrested by the Turkish-Cypriot police after crossing the UN buffer zone and entering the area under Turkish-Cypriot control.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Government alleged that the Turkish-Cypriot police intervened in the face of the manifest inability of the Greek-Cypriot authorities and the UN Force in Cyprus to contain the incursion and its possible consequences.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Government alleged that no force was used against demonstrators who did not intrude into the \"TRNC\" border area.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Government alleged that in the case of demonstrators who were arrested for violating the border, no more force was used than was reasonably necessary in the circumstances in order to arrest and detain the persons concerned.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Government alleged that no one was ill-treated during the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Government alleged that it was possible that some of the demonstrators had hurt themselves in the confusion or in attempting to scale barbed wire or other fencing.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Government alleged that had the Turkish police, or anyone else, assaulted or beaten any of the demonstrators, the UN Secretary General would no doubt have referred to this in his report to the Security Council.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was charged, tried, found guilty and sentenced to a short term of imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant pleaded not guilty but did not give evidence and declined to use the available judicial remedies.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was asked if he required assistance from a lawyer registered in the \"TRNC\", but refused and did not ask for legal representation.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Government alleged that interpretation services were provided at the trial by qualified interpreters and that all the proceedings were translated into Greek.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989 on the UN operations in Cyprus, the UN Secretary General stated that in the evening of 19 July 1989, some 1,000 Greek Cypriot demonstrators, mostly women, forced their way into the UN buffer zone in the Ayios Kassianos area of Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989, the UN Secretary General stated that the demonstrators broke through a wire barrier maintained by UNFICYP and destroyed an UNFICYP observation post.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989, the UN Secretary General stated that the demonstrators broke through the line formed by UNFICYP soldiers and entered a former school complex where UNFICYP reinforcements regrouped to prevent them from proceeding further.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989, the UN Secretary General stated that a short while later, Turkish-Cypriot police and security forces elements forced their way into the area and apprehended 111 persons, 101 of them women.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989, the UN Secretary General stated that the Ayios Kassianos school complex is situated in the UN buffer zone, but that the Turkish forces claim it to be on their side of the cease-fire line.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989, the UN Secretary General stated that under working arrangements with UNFICYP, the Turkish-Cypriot security forces had patrolled the Ayios Kassianos school grounds for several years within specific restrictions, and that this patrolling ceased altogether as part of the unmanning agreement implemented in May 1989.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989, the UN Secretary General stated that in the afternoon of 21 July 1989, some 300 Greek Cypriots gathered at the main entrance to the UN protected area in Nicosia to protest the continuing detention by the Turkish-Cypriot authorities of those apprehended at Ayios Kassianos.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989, the UN Secretary General stated that the number of demonstrators at the main entrance to the UN protected area in Nicosia fluctuated between 200 and 2,000, and that they blocked all UN traffic through this entrance until 30 July 1989, when the Turkish-Cypriot authorities released the last two detainees.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989, the UN Secretary General stated that the events created considerable tension in the island and that intensive efforts were made, both at the UN headquarters and at Nicosia, to contain and resolve the situation.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989, the UN Secretary General stated that on 21 July 1989, he expressed his concern at the events and stressed that it was vital that all parties keep in mind the purpose of the UN buffer zone as well as their responsibility to ensure that that area was not violated.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989, the UN Secretary General stated that he urged the Turkish-Cypriot authorities to release without delay all those who had been detained.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989, the UN Secretary General stated that on 24 July 1989, the President of the Security Council announced that he had conveyed to the representatives of all the parties, on behalf of the members of the Council, the Council's deep concern at the tense situation created by the incidents of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989, the UN Secretary General stated that the President of the Security Council stressed the need strictly to respect the UN buffer zone and appealed for the immediate release of all persons still detained, and asked all concerned to show maximum restraint and to take urgent steps to bring about a relaxation of tension and contribute to the creation of an atmosphere favourable to the negotiations.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The applicant produced 21 photographs taken at different times during the demonstration on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Photographs 1 to 7 produced by the applicant were intended to show that, notwithstanding the deployment of the Turkish-Cypriot police, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "In photographs 8 to 10 produced by the applicant, members of the Turkish-Cypriot police are seen breaking up the UNFICYP cordon during the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The final set of photographs produced by the applicant show members of the Turkish-Cypriot police using force to arrest some of the women demonstrators during the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The English translation of the \"TRNC\" Nicosia District Court's judgment of 22 July 1989 indicates that the applicant, together with 9 other men, was charged with entering \"TRNC\" territory without permission, contrary to sections 2, 8 and 9 of Law no. 5/72.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. The documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The English translation of the \"TRNC\" Nicosia District Court's judgment of 22 July 1989 indicates that the applicant, together with 9 other men, was charged with entering \"TRNC\" territory other than through an approved port, contrary to subsections 12(1) and (5) of the Aliens and Immigration Law.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. The documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The \"TRNC\" Nicosia District Court's judgment of 22 July 1989 was given in the presence of the accused and of an interpreter.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. The documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The \"TRNC\" Nicosia District Court noted that the accused did not accept the charges against them and stated that they did not wish to use the services of a lawyer registered in the \"TRNC\".", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. The documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The \"TRNC\" Nicosia District Court noted that the public prosecutor called five witnesses, whose statements were translated into Greek for the accused's benefit.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. The documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The \"TRNC\" Nicosia District Court noted that the witnesses (mainly police officers on duty at the time of the demonstration) declared that the accused had illegally entered the \"TRNC\" territory, shouted abuse at the Turkish-Cypriot forces and resisted arrest by pulling and pushing.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. The documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The \"TRNC\" Nicosia District Court noted that knives and other cutting objects had been found in the bags of some of the demonstrators who had been arrested.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. The documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The \"TRNC\" Nicosia District Court noted that the applicant stated that he was a journalist, that he had been arrested while he was following the demonstration even though the peacekeeping forces had given him permission to do so.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. The documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The \"TRNC\" Nicosia District Court noted that the accused had been told that they could cross-examine witnesses in turn and, if they so wished, choose one of their number to cross-examine the witnesses on behalf of all the accused, but that they had not done so; one of the accused had put a few questions to one of the prosecution witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. The documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Before the \"TRNC\" Nicosia District Court passed sentence, the Bishop of Kitium, speaking on behalf of all the accused, made a statement saying that their struggle was peaceful, that their aim was to encourage Greek and Turkish-Cypriots to live together in peace, that they carried no weapons and that they had asked for UN protection.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. The documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The \"TRNC\" Nicosia District Court, relying on statements by the prosecution witnesses which had not been undermined by the statements made by some of the accused, concluded that the accused had crossed the borders of the \"TRNC\" at an unapproved entry point and without permission and had resisted by various means the UN and Turkish forces which had tried to stop them.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. The documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The \"TRNC\" Nicosia District Court found that the prosecution had proved its case beyond reasonable doubt and that the accused were guilty on both counts.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. The documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "In deciding on the sentence, the \"TRNC\" Nicosia District Court took into account the seriousness of the offence and the fact that the accused had shown no remorse and continued to deny the validity of the \"TRNC\".", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. The documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code defines an unlawful assembly as five or more persons assembled with intent to commit an offence, or, being assembled with intent to carry out some common purpose, conducting themselves in such a manner as to cause persons in the neighbourhood to fear that the persons so assembled will commit a breach of the peace, or will by such assembly needlessly and without any reasonable occasion provoke other persons to commit a breach of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that it is immaterial that the original assembling was lawful if, being assembled, the persons conduct themselves with a common purpose in such a manner as to cause fear of a breach of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that when an unlawful assembly has begun to execute the purpose for which it assembled by a breach of the peace and to the terror of the public, the assembly is called a riot and the persons assembled are said to be riotously assembled.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "According to section 71 of the Cypriot Criminal Code, any person who takes part in an unlawful assembly is guilty of a misdemeanour and liable to imprisonment for one year.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Section 80 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that any person who carries in public without lawful occasion any offensive arm or weapon in such a manner as to cause terror to any person is guilty of a misdemeanour, liable to imprisonment for two years, and his arm or weapons shall be forfeited.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "According to section 82 of the Cypriot Criminal Code, it is an offence to carry a knife outside the home.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Chapter 155, section 14(1)(b) of the Cypriot Criminal Procedure Law states that any police officer may, without warrant, arrest any person who commits in his presence any offence punishable with imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Police officers' powers of arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Chapter 155, section 14(1)(c) of the Cypriot Criminal Procedure Law states that any police officer may, without warrant, arrest any person who obstructs a police officer while in the execution of his duty.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Police officers' powers of arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Section 9 of Law No. 5/72 states that any person who enters a prohibited military area without authorization, or by stealth, or fraudulently, shall be tried by a military court in accordance with the Military Offences Act, and those found guilty shall be punished.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Subsection 12(1) of the Aliens and Immigration Law states that no person shall enter or leave the Colony except through an approved port.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Subsection 12(5) of the Aliens and Immigration Law states that any person who contravenes or fails to observe any of the provisions of subsections (1), (2), (3) or (4) of section 12 shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months or to a fine not exceeding one hundred pounds or to both such imprisonment and fine.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": false, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["national_security", "public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F012", "F013", "F014"], "interference": ["F024", "F039", "F063", "F084", "F098"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F112", "F113", "F125", "F126", "F127", "F128", "F131", "F132", "F133", "F134", "F135"], "legitimate_aim": ["F095", "F096", "F097", "F117", "F118", "F122"], "necessity": ["F095", "F096", "F097", "F098", "F099", "F112", "F113", "F117", "F122"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F012"], "interference": ["F024", "F098"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F128", "F131", "F112", "F134"], "legitimate_aim": ["F095", "F096", "F097"], "necessity": ["F095", "F096", "F097", "F117", "F099"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F012", "F024", "F095", "F096", "F097", "F117", "F128", "F131"]}} {"case_name": "case_149", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants in a protest against the Russian military attack on Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The protest against the Russian military attack on Ukraine was held on 27 February 2022 in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention in addition to their complaint about disproportionate measures.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_150", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_152", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' dates of birth and places of residence are given in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "At the material time the first applicant was a member of the youth committee of an opposition party called the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan (Azərbaycan Xalq Cəbhəsi Partiyası – the PFPA).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "At the material time the second applicant was a chairman of a youth organisation called Azad Genclik.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Both applicants participated in a number of unauthorised peaceful demonstrations organised by the opposition.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "In the course of many of those unauthorised peaceful demonstrations, both applicants were arrested and convicted.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The first applicant was arrested during demonstrations on 15 May 2010.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The first applicant was arrested during demonstrations on 19 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The first applicant was arrested during demonstrations on 31 July 2010.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The number of opposition demonstrations increased in 2011.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The tendency of increasing opposition demonstrations continued into the years following 2011.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "A demonstration was held on 11 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "A demonstration was held on 20 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "A demonstration was held on 17 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The second applicant attended the demonstration of 11 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The second applicant attended the demonstration of 20 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The first applicant attended the demonstration of 20 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The first applicant attended the demonstration of 17 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the first applicant, he also intended to participate in the demonstration of 11 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the first applicant, he was actively promoting public participation in the assembly of 11 March 2011 on online social networks.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "It appears that the organisers of the demonstration of 11 March 2011 gave no proper prior notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Information about the demonstration of 11 March 2011 was disseminated through Facebook or the press.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Prior to the demonstration of 20 October 2012, on 15 October 2012 the organisers gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Prior to the demonstration of 17 November 2012, on 12 November 2012 the organisers gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) refused to authorise the demonstration of 20 October 2012 at the site indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) proposed another location for the demonstration of 20 October 2012, namely the grounds of a driving school situated in the 20th habitable area of the Sabail District on the outskirts of Baku.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) refused to authorise the demonstration of 17 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) noted in general terms that the assembly of 17 November 2012 would not be in accordance with the Law on Freedom of Assembly.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) noted that the square where the organisers proposed to hold the assembly of 17 November 2012 was a designated public leisure area.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) noted that the assembly of 17 November 2012 itself would be impractical.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The organisers decided to hold the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October 2012, and 17 November 2012 as planned, despite the refusals by the Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the applicants, the demonstrations were intended to be peaceful and were conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The participants in the demonstrations were demanding democratic reforms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The participants in the demonstrations were demanding free and fair elections.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The participants in the demonstrations were protesting against impediments on freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 4 March 2011 the first applicant was arrested.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 4 March 2011 the first applicant was brought to police station no. 22 of the Nasimi district police office.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the official records, the first applicant was arrested because at around 11.20 a.m. on 4 March 2011, in front of the National Bank in Baku, he had disobeyed a lawful order of the police to stop speaking loudly on a mobile phone.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the official records, the first applicant had disobeyed a lawful order of the police to stop using foul language in front of the National Bank in Baku on 4 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the official records, the first applicant swore at the police officers at the time of his arrest on 4 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the official records, the first applicant tried to run away when being arrested on 4 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The first applicant contested the official version of his arrest on 4 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The first applicant stated that he had been arrested in an Internet café by three persons in plain clothes who had failed to present themselves or give reasons for the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The first applicant stated that the three persons who arrested him had taken his belongings from the Internet café, including his mobile phone.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The first applicant stated that he had been pushed into an unmarked car after his arrest on 4 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The first applicant stated that in the unmarked car, one of the persons who had arrested him presented himself as a police officer and showed a police badge.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The first applicant stated that the other two persons who arrested him presented themselves as agents of the Ministry of National Security, without showing any supporting document.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The first applicant stated that he had been told that his arrest on 4 March 2011 had been in connection with the demonstration of 11 March 2011 and another protest planned to be held on 12 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "At police station no. 22 of the Nasimi district police office, an administrative-offence report (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) was issued in respect of the first applicant, setting out the charges against him.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The administrative-offence report stated that the first applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (failure to comply with a lawful order of a police officer).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "According to the first applicant, he was never served with a copy of the administrative-offence report or with other documents from his case file following his arrest on 4 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "According to the first applicant, he was not given access to a lawyer after his arrest on 4 March 2011 or while he was in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "1. Administrative arrest of the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 4 March 2011, the day of his arrest, the first applicant was brought before the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Nasimi District Court adopted a decision on the merits of the first applicant's case on 4 March 2011, the same day he was brought before it.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "According to the first applicant, he was not given an opportunity to appoint a lawyer of his own choosing at the hearing before the Nasimi District Court on 4 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "A State-funded lawyer (Mr O.A.) was appointed to assist the first applicant at the hearing before the Nasimi District Court on 4 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "According to the transcript of the Nasimi District Court's hearing on 4 March 2011, the State-funded lawyer Mr O.A. did not make any oral or written submissions on behalf of the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In his statement before the Nasimi District Court, the first applicant contested the police officers' version of events and argued that he had been arrested unlawfully.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Nasimi District Court disregarded the first applicant's statement as non-reliable.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "At the Nasimi District Court hearing on 4 March 2011, only the police officers who, according to the official records, had arrested the first applicant were questioned as witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "At the Nasimi District Court hearing on 4 March 2011, the police officer who issued the administrative-offence report in respect of the first applicant was also questioned as a witness.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "In their statements at the Nasimi District Court hearing, the police officers reiterated the official version of the reasons for the first applicant's arrest on 4 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Nasimi District Court found that the first applicant had committed the administrative offence of failure to comply with a lawful order of a police officer under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Nasimi District Court convicted the first applicant under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences and sentenced him to ten days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "According to the first applicant, until 6 March 2011 his whereabouts were unknown to his family and friends.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Only on 7 March 2011 was a lawyer hired by the first applicant's family able to meet the first applicant and to learn the details of his arrest, detention and the court proceedings against him.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On an unspecified date the first applicant lodged an appeal with the Baku Court of Appeal, presenting his version of the events surrounding his arrest on 4 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "In his appeal to the Baku Court of Appeal, the first applicant argued that he had been arrested in connection with the demonstration scheduled for 11 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "In his appeal to the Baku Court of Appeal, the first applicant complained that the hearing before the Nasimi District Court had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The first applicant applied to the Baku Court of Appeal to have his mobile-phone call records examined in respect of the date and time of the alleged administrative offence on 4 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The first applicant was represented before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer of his own choosing in the proceedings related to his arrest on 4 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 19 March 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the first applicant's appeal against the Nasimi District Court's decision of 4 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 19 March 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the Nasimi District Court, stating that the conclusions reached by that court had been correct.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal did not address the first applicant's request to have his mobile-phone call records examined in respect of the date and time of the alleged administrative offence on 4 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 4 March 2011 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the first applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The demonstration of 11 March 2011 was attended by the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "1. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The demonstration of 20 October 2012 was attended by both the first applicant and the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "1. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The demonstration of 17 November 2012 was attended by the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "1. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "All three demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October 2012, and 17 November 2012 were dispersed as soon as the protesters began to gather.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "1. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Both applicants were arrested during the dispersal operations of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October 2012, and 17 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "1. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "After each arrest during the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October 2012, and 17 November 2012, both applicants were taken to police station no. 9 of the Sabail district police office.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "1. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "According to the applicants, during the dispersal of the demonstration of 20 October 2012 they were arrested by individuals in plain clothes.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "1. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "According to the applicants, during the dispersal of the demonstration of 17 November 2012 they were arrested by individuals in plain clothes.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "1. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On the day of each of the applicants' respective arrests during the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October 2012, and 17 November 2012, administrative-offence reports were issued in respect of them.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "1. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "In each case following the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October 2012, and 17 November 2012, the applicants were charged with an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (failure to comply with a lawful order of a police officer).", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "1. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Following their arrest on 20 October 2012, the applicants were additionally charged under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences (violation of rules on holding public assemblies).", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "1. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "According to the applicants, they were never served with a copy of the administrative-offence reports or with other documents from their case files following their arrests during the demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "1. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "According to the applicants, they were not given access to a lawyer after their arrests during the demonstrations or while they were in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "1. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The first applicant was brought before the Sabail District Court on 20 October 2012, the day of his arrest during the demonstration of that date.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The first applicant was brought before the Sabail District Court on 17 November 2012, the day of his arrest during the demonstration of that date.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The second applicant was brought before the Sabail District Court on 11 March 2011, the day of his arrest during the demonstration of that date.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The second applicant was brought before the Sabail District Court on 20 October 2012, the day of his arrest during the demonstration of that date.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "According to the applicants, the respective hearings before the Sabail District Court were very brief.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "According to the applicants, members of the public were not allowed inside the courtroom during the hearings before the Sabail District Court, even though the court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearings to the public.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "According to the applicants, they were not given an opportunity to appoint lawyers of their own choosing at the hearings before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "A State-funded lawyer was appointed to defend each of the applicants at each hearing before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "According to the transcript of the Sabail District Court hearing of 11 March 2011, the State-funded lawyer for the second applicant (Mr V.M.) briefly asked the court in his oral submissions to consider the young age of the second applicant and his sincere regret for having committed the administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "None of the material submitted to the Court contains any record showing that at the hearing of 20 October 2012 the State-funded lawyer for the second applicant (Mr K.B.) made any oral or written submissions on behalf of the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "None of the material submitted to the Court contains any record showing that at the hearing of 17 November 2012 the State-funded lawyer for the first applicant (Mr Z.A.) made any oral or written submissions on behalf of the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "According to a statement (ərizə) signed by the first applicant, he refused the assistance of the State-funded lawyer at the Sabail District Court hearing of 20 October 2012 and decided to defend himself in person.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The only witnesses questioned during the Sabail District Court hearing of 11 March 2011 concerning the second applicant were police officers who, according to official records, had arrested him.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "At the Sabail District Court hearing of 11 March 2011, the police officers testified that together with some other people the second applicant had attempted to hold an unlawful demonstration and continued to protest despite the order to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "During the Sabail District Court hearing of 20 October 2012, the court did not question any witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "During the Sabail District Court hearing of 17 November 2012, the court did not question any witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "In each case the Sabail District Court found that the applicants had failed to stop participating in an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Sabail District Court convicted the applicants under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (failure to comply with a lawful order of a police officer) in each case related to the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October 2012, and 17 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "In the proceedings related to his participation in the demonstration of 20 October 2012, the second applicant was also convicted by the Sabail District Court under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences (violation of rules on holding public assemblies).", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The applicants were sentenced to various periods of administrative detention as set out in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "On unspecified dates the applicants lodged appeals with the Baku Court of Appeal, arguing that their convictions had been in violation of their rights because the protest in which they had participated had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "In their appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicants complained that their arrests had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "In their appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicants complained that the hearings before the Sabail District Court had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The applicants asked the Baku Court of Appeal to quash the Sabail District Court's decisions in their respective cases.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The first applicant was assisted by a lawyer of his own choosing in each case before the Baku Court of Appeal related to the demonstrations of 20 October 2012 and 17 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The second applicant was assisted by a lawyer of his own choosing during the Baku Court of Appeal proceedings related to his participation in the demonstration of 20 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The second applicant was not represented by a lawyer during the Baku Court of Appeal proceedings related to his participation in the demonstration of 11 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "On various dates the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants' appeals against the Sabail District Court's decisions and upheld those decisions, as set out in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Dispersal of the demonstrations of 11 March 2011, 20 October and 17 November 2012 and subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "After the amendments introduced by Law no. 135-IVQD of 31 May 2011, which entered into force on 1 July 2011, Article 410.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 provided that a copy of the administrative offence report shall be given to an individual who is subject to the administrative offence proceedings or to a representative of a legal entity.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "After the amendments introduced by Law no. 135-IVQD of 31 May 2011, which entered into force on 1 July 2011, Article 410.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 provided that an aggrieved person in administrative offence proceedings has the right to a copy of the administrative offence report.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "A summary of the relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings in Azerbaijan is contained in the judgment in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (nos. 67360/11, 67964/11 and 69379/11, §§ 67-77, 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "A summary of the relevant provisions concerning freedom of assembly and the organisation and holding of public assemblies in Azerbaijan is contained in the judgment in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (nos. 67360/11, 67964/11 and 69379/11, §§ 67-77, 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Relevant extracts from international documents and press releases are contained in the judgment in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (nos. 67360/11, 67964/11 and 69379/11, §§ 67-77, 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "A summary of the relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings in Azerbaijan is also contained in the judgment in Ibrahimov and Others v. Azerbaijan (nos. 69234/11, 69252/11 and 69335/11, §§ 44-59, 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "A summary of the relevant provisions concerning freedom of assembly and the organisation and holding of public assemblies in Azerbaijan is also contained in the judgment in Ibrahimov and Others v. Azerbaijan (nos. 69234/11, 69252/11 and 69335/11, §§ 44-59, 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Relevant extracts from international documents and press releases are also contained in the judgment in Ibrahimov and Others v. Azerbaijan (nos. 69234/11, 69252/11 and 69335/11, §§ 44-59, 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F002", "F004", "F018", "F019", "F031", "F074", "F075", "F076"], "interference": ["F035", "F037", "F038", "F041", "F042", "F047", "F057", "F058", "F059", "F061", "F062", "F063", "F071", "F072", "F073", "F077", "F078", "F083", "F104", "F106", "F002", "F004", "F005", "F018", "F019"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F030", "F083", "F084", "F103", "F104", "F031"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F022", "F023", "F024", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F031", "F077", "F103", "F104", "F035", "F037", "F038", "F041", "F042", "F047", "F057", "F058", "F059", "F061", "F071", "F072", "F073", "F063"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F004", "F018", "F019", "F031"], "interference": ["F035", "F047", "F063", "F058", "F059", "F072", "F073", "F077", "F078", "F104", "F106"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F024", "F026", "F027", "F083", "F103", "F104"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F022", "F023", "F031", "F077", "F027", "F103", "F104", "F035", "F058", "F072"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F004", "F018", "F031", "F035", "F047", "F058", "F063", "F072", "F022", "F023", "F027", "F077", "F104", "F106"]}} {"case_name": "case_153", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The present case concerns the allegedly unjustified interference with the applicants' right to freedom of assembly on account of the dispersal of an unauthorised peaceful protest.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants alleged, relying on Article 6 of the Convention, that their rights were breached by the domestic authorities.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants alleged, relying on Article 10 of the Convention, that their rights were breached by the domestic authorities.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants alleged, relying on Article 11 of the Convention, that their rights were breached by the domestic authorities.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 4 and 5 March 2012, the mass media broadcast information to the effect that two persons arrested on allegedly political grounds had been subjected to ill-treatment while in custody.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants, together with a number of other persons, gathered at around 3 p.m. on 6 March 2012 near the metro station Elmlar Akademiyasi in Baku to protest against the alleged ill-treatment of two persons arrested on allegedly political grounds.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicants and other protesters attempted to march towards the Ministry of Internal Affairs on 6 March 2012.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The protest on 6 March 2012 near the metro station Elmlar Akademiyasi in Baku was spontaneous and peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The attempt by the applicants and other protesters to stage a march towards the Ministry of Internal Affairs was stopped by police officers, who began to disperse the protesters.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The police arrested seventeen protesters, including the applicants, on 6 March 2012.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The seventeen arrested protesters, including the applicants, were taken to the Yasamal District Police Office.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "At the Yasamal District Police Office, administrative-offence reports (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) were drawn up in respect of the arrested protesters, including the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 6 March 2012, the first applicant was brought before the Yasamal District Court.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Yasamal District Court convicted the first applicant under Article 296 (minor hooliganism) of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Yasamal District Court sentenced the first applicant to a fine in the amount of 50 Azerbaijani manats (AZN), approximately 40 euros (EUR) at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The administrative-offence reports in respect of the second applicant stated that the second applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 298 (violation of the rules on holding public gatherings) of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The administrative-offence reports in respect of the third applicant stated that the third applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 298 (violation of the rules on holding public gatherings) of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The police ordered the second applicant to pay a fine in the amount of 10 Azerbaijani manats (AZN), approximately 8 euros (EUR) at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The police ordered the third applicant to pay a fine in the amount of 10 Azerbaijani manats (AZN), approximately 8 euros (EUR) at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The second applicant was released after payment of the fine of 10 Azerbaijani manats (AZN).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The third applicant was released after payment of the fine of 10 Azerbaijani manats (AZN).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 19 March 2012, the applicants lodged a complaint with the Baku Administrative Economic Court against the Yasamal District Police Office.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "In their complaint to the Baku Administrative Economic Court, the applicants argued that the protest in which they had participated had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "In their complaint to the Baku Administrative Economic Court, the applicants argued that the police officers' interference with the protest had been unlawful and inadequate.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 27 July 2012, the Baku Administrative Economic Court dismissed the applicants' complaints as unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 28 September 2012, the applicants lodged an appeal with the Baku Court of Appeal, reiterating their previous complaints against the Yasamal District Police Office.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 13 November 2012, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants' appeal.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 13 November 2012, the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the Baku Administrative Economic Court's judgment of 27 July 2012, finding it justified.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 24 December 2012, the third applicant lodged a cassation appeal complaining that the dispersal of the protest had violated his right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 24 December 2012, the third applicant lodged a cassation appeal complaining that the dispersal of the protest had violated his right to freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 24 December 2012, the third applicant lodged a cassation appeal complaining that the hearing before the Baku Court of Appeal had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "By a decision of 13 March 2013, the Supreme Court dismissed the third applicant's cassation appeal.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "By a decision of 13 March 2013, the Supreme Court upheld the Baku Court of Appeal's judgment of 13 November 2012, finding it justified.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The applicants complained, relying on Article 6 of the Convention, that the domestic proceedings had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicants complained, relying on Article 10 of the Convention, that the dispersal of the protest by the police had been in breach of their right to freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicants complained, relying on Article 11 of the Convention, that the dispersal of the protest by the police had been in breach of their right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F008", "F010", "F017", "F019"], "interference": ["F006", "F009", "F010", "F017", "F019", "F021"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F005", "F006", "F008", "F017", "F019", "F025", "F027", "F028", "F032", "F033"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F008"], "interference": ["F006", "F009", "F017", "F019"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F005", "F006", "F008", "F017", "F025", "F032"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F005", "F006", "F008", "F009", "F017", "F019", "F032"]}} {"case_name": "case_154", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained under Article 11 of the Convention of the prohibition on holding peaceful assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained under Article 11 of the Convention of restrictions on the location of public events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants complained under Article 11 of the Convention of restrictions on the time of conduct of public events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants complained under Article 11 of the Convention of restrictions on the manner of conduct of public events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants raised complaints under Article 13 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004", "F005"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004", "F005"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F002", "F003", "F004", "F005"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F004", "F005"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F002"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_155", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention and the Protocols thereto.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_156", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "On 6 March 2006 the applicants were taken into police custody.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants were taken into police custody on suspicion of aiding and abetting the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) was classified as an illegal armed organisation.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 7 March 2006 the applicants were brought before a judge at the Ankara Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants were mainly questioned about their participation in a number of demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants were questioned about various CDs, documents, books and periodicals that had allegedly been found by the police in their homes.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicants denied the veracity of the allegations that they had acted in support of an illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "All the applicants accepted that they had participated in legally organised demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicants denied having chanted illegal slogans or slogans in favour of an illegal organisation during the demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicants claimed that the material found in their homes had not been illegal.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Necla Çomak claimed that the documents found in her home were related to a legal association, namely the Working Women's Association (Emekçi Kadınlar Derneği).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 7 March 2006 the Ankara Assize Court ordered the detention of Levent Çakır.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 7 March 2006 the Ankara Assize Court ordered the detention of Deniz Bakır.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 7 March 2006 the Ankara Assize Court ordered the detention of Alihan Alhan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 7 March 2006 the Ankara Assize Court ordered the detention of Necla Çomak.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 7 March 2006 the Ankara Assize Court ordered the detention of Metin Kürekçi.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 7 March 2006 the Ankara Assize Court ordered the detention of Latife Canan Kaplan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 7 March 2006 the Ankara Assize Court ordered the detention of Uğur Güdük.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The other applicants (those not named in the detention order of 7 March 2006) were released on 7 March 2006.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 22 March 2006 the Ankara public prosecutor filed an indictment with the Ankara Assize Court against the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "In the indictment, the Ankara public prosecutor noted that the applicants had participated in a demonstration organised by trade unions and non-governmental organisations held on 17 December 2005 with the authorisation of the governor's office.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "In the indictment, the Ankara public prosecutor noted that the applicants had participated in a demonstration organised by trade unions and non-governmental organisations held on 19 February 2006 with the authorisation of the governor's office.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "In the indictment, the Ankara public prosecutor noted, on the basis of video footage provided by the police, that the applicants had carried banners on behalf of the ESP (the Socialist Platform of the Oppressed).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "In the indictment, the Ankara public prosecutor noted, on the basis of video footage provided by the police, that the applicants had carried banners on behalf of the SGD (Socialist Youth Association).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to information on the Internet, the ESP (the Socialist Platform of the Oppressed) and the SGD (Socialist Youth Association) were connected to the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicants were charged with membership of an illegal organisation under Article 220 § 7 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicants were charged with membership of an illegal organisation under Article 314 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 18 May 2006 the Ankara Assize Court held the first hearing in the case.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "At the hearing on 18 May 2006, the applicants conceded before the Ankara Assize Court that they had participated in the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "At the hearing on 18 May 2006, the applicants conceded before the Ankara Assize Court that they had participated in the demonstration of 19 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "At the hearing on 18 May 2006, the applicants stressed that the demonstrations of 17 December 2005 and 19 February 2006 had been legal.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "At the hearing on 18 May 2006, the applicants maintained that none of the documents, periodicals, books and CDs found in their homes was illegal.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "At the hearing on 18 May 2006, the applicants stated that they did not accept the content of the search-and-seizure reports prepared after the searches conducted in their homes, as those reports had not been drafted in their presence.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "During the hearing held on 22 June 2006, Latife Canan Kaplan was released pending trial.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "During the hearing held on 22 June 2006, Uğur Güdük was released pending trial.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "During the hearing held on 22 June 2006, Levent Çakır was released pending trial.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Between 18 May 2006 and 17 January 2007 the Ankara Assize Court held nine hearings in the case.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 17 January 2007 the Ankara Assize Court convicted Deniz Bakır of membership of a terrorist organisation under Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), on the basis of Articles 220 § 7 and 314 § 3 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 17 January 2007 the Ankara Assize Court convicted Metin Kürekçi of membership of a terrorist organisation under Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), on the basis of Articles 220 § 7 and 314 § 3 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 17 January 2007 the Ankara Assize Court convicted Necla Çomak of membership of a terrorist organisation under Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), on the basis of Articles 220 § 7 and 314 § 3 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 17 January 2007 the Ankara Assize Court convicted Alihan Alhan of membership of a terrorist organisation under Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), on the basis of Articles 220 § 7 and 314 § 3 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Metin Kürekçi was sentenced to six years and three months' imprisonment by the Ankara Assize Court on 17 January 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Necla Çomak was sentenced to six years and three months' imprisonment by the Ankara Assize Court on 17 January 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Alihan Alhan was sentenced to six years and three months' imprisonment by the Ankara Assize Court on 17 January 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Deniz Bakır was sentenced to seven years and six months' imprisonment by the Ankara Assize Court on 17 January 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The remaining applicants (other than Deniz Bakır, Metin Kürekçi, Necla Çomak and Alihan Alhan) were convicted on 17 January 2007 of disseminating propaganda in favour of a terrorist organisation under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The remaining applicants convicted of disseminating propaganda in favour of a terrorist organisation were each sentenced to one year and eight months' imprisonment by the Ankara Assize Court on 17 January 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 27 September 2007 the Court of Cassation quashed the Ankara Assize Court's judgment of 17 January 2007.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Court of Cassation quashed the judgment on the ground that the applicants had not had an opportunity to submit their defence submissions in relation to the classification by the Ankara Assize Court of their acts under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (Prevention of Terrorism Act).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Between 6 February and 22 October 2008 the Ankara Assize Court held seven more hearings in the case.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 22 October 2008 the Ankara Assize Court issued a judgment containing the same conclusions and sentences as in its judgment of 17 January 2007.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 22 October 2008 the Ankara Assize Court ordered the release of Metin Kürekçi, taking into account the period of time he had spent in detention and the length of the sentence imposed on him.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 22 October 2008 the Ankara Assize Court ordered the release of Necla Çomak, taking into account the period of time she had spent in detention and the length of the sentence imposed on her.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 22 October 2008 the Ankara Assize Court ordered the release of Alihan Alhan, taking into account the period of time he had spent in detention and the length of the sentence imposed on him.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In its judgment, the Ankara Assize Court noted that although the ESP (Socialist Platform of the Oppressed) and the SGD (Socialist Youth Association) were legal entities, their activities were in line with those of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court observed that members of the ESP (Socialist Platform of the Oppressed) and SGD (Socialist Youth Association) regarded members of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) who had been killed by the security forces as 'martyrs' and had organised commemorative ceremonies for them.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court observed that members of the ESP (Socialist Platform of the Oppressed) and SGD (Socialist Youth Association) regarded members of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) who had died during hunger strikes as 'martyrs' and had organised commemorative ceremonies for them.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court observed that the declarations issued by the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) on the Internet were consistent with the aims of the ESP (Socialist Platform of the Oppressed) and the SGD (Socialist Youth Association).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court considered that the ESP (Socialist Platform of the Oppressed) and the SGD (Socialist Youth Association) appeared in the legal domain on behalf of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) and had an organic relationship with it.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found it established, on the basis of the conduct of members of the ESP (Socialist Platform of the Oppressed) and the SGD (Socialist Youth Association) and having regard to the documents found in the accused's homes, that ESP and SGD members were carrying out activities in line with the strategies of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found it established that ESP (Socialist Platform of the Oppressed) and SGD (Socialist Youth Association) members had been holding legally authorised demonstrations in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) on the pretext of exercising their democratic rights.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that all the applicants except Selçuk Mart had participated in the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court observed that Selçuk Mart had attended the demonstration of 19 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found it established that the applicants had chanted the slogan 'M-L-K-P' during the demonstration held on 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found it established that the applicants had chanted the slogan 'Yaşasın partimiz MLKP' ('Long live our Party, MLKP') during the demonstration held on 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found it established that the applicants had chanted the slogan 'Devrimin zaferi, biji MLKP' ('Victory to the revolution, long live the MLKP') during the demonstration held on 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found it established that the applicants had chanted the slogan 'İşçiler partiye, MLKP'ye' ('Workers join the party, join the MLKP') during the demonstration held on 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found it established that Necla Çomak had chanted the slogan 'Yaşasın 1. Kürdistan konferansı' ('Long live the first Conference of Kurdistan') during the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found it established that Uğur Güdük had chanted the slogan 'Yaşasın 1. Kürdistan konferansı' ('Long live the first Conference of Kurdistan') during the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Selçuk Mart had chanted the slogan 'Dısa dısa serhildan MLKP Kürdistan' ('Rise up again and again, MLKP Kurdistan') during the demonstration of 19 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Metin Kürekçi had been wearing clothes with 'ESP' (Socialist Platform of the Oppressed) on them during the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Metin Kürekçi had been carrying pennants with 'ESP' (Socialist Platform of the Oppressed) on them during the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Mehmet Ali Tosun had been wearing clothes with 'ESP' (Socialist Platform of the Oppressed) on them during the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Mehmet Ali Tosun had been carrying pennants with 'ESP' (Socialist Platform of the Oppressed) on them during the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Uğur Güdük had been wearing clothes with 'SGD' (Socialist Youth Association) on them during the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Uğur Güdük had been wearing hats with 'SGD' (Socialist Youth Association) on them during the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Selçuk Mart had been wearing clothes with 'SGD' (Socialist Youth Association) on them during the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Selçuk Mart had been wearing hats with 'SGD' (Socialist Youth Association) on them during the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Serdar Kır had had a red ribbon attached to his arm during the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Necla Çomak had had a red ribbon attached to her arm during the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Necla Çomak had incited the crowd to chant slogans during the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found it established that Levent Çakır had given a clenched-fist salute during the demonstration of 17 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Metin Kürekçi had been taken into police custody in the past on account of his participation in various public meetings.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Alihan Alhan had been taken into police custody in the past on account of his participation in various public meetings.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Deniz Bakır had been taken into police custody in the past on account of his participation in various public meetings.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "There were several police records in respect of Necla Çomak.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Alihan Alhan had previously been remanded in custody.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Deniz Bakır had previously been remanded in custody.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that books which had previously been the subject of seizure orders had been found in the home of Metin Kürekçi.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that books which had previously been the subject of seizure orders had been found in the home of Necla Çomak.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that books which had previously been the subject of seizure orders had been found in the home of Filiz Uluçelebi.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that books which had previously been the subject of seizure orders had been found in the home of Mehmet Ali Tosun.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Metin Kürekçi had also had written material regarding the ESP (Socialist Platform of the Oppressed) and SGD (Socialist Youth Association).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Necla Çomak had been in possession of notes on the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Necla Çomak had been in possession of leaflets which belonged to the ESP (Socialist Platform of the Oppressed).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court concluded that Metin Kürekçi should be convicted as a member of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) because he had aided that illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court concluded that Necla Çomak should be convicted as a member of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) because she had aided that illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court concluded that Alihan Alhan should be convicted as a member of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) because he had aided that illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court concluded that Deniz Bakır should be convicted as a member of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) because he had aided that illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found it established that Metin Kürekçi, Necla Çomak, Alihan Alhan and Deniz Bakır had directed crowds during demonstrations in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found it established that Metin Kürekçi, Necla Çomak, Alihan Alhan and Deniz Bakır had incited people to chant slogans in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found it established that Metin Kürekçi, Necla Çomak, Alihan Alhan and Deniz Bakır had carried banners in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found it established that Metin Kürekçi, Necla Çomak, Alihan Alhan and Deniz Bakır had prepared organisational documents in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found it established that Metin Kürekçi, Necla Çomak, Alihan Alhan and Deniz Bakır had previously been involved in activities in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court considered that the acts of Metin Kürekçi, Necla Çomak, Alihan Alhan and Deniz Bakır represented continuity and diversity, and that they had an organic relationship with the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court held that Metin Kürekçi, Necla Çomak, Alihan Alhan and Deniz Bakır had aided the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) by acting and directing other people to act 'in a manner planned by' that organisation.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court convicted Metin Kürekçi, Necla Çomak, Alihan Alhan and Deniz Bakır under Articles 220 § 7 and 314 §§ 2 and 3 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Levent Çakır had chanted slogans and carried banners and flags in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) during the demonstrations of 17 December 2005 or 19 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Uğur Güdük had chanted slogans and carried banners and flags in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) during the demonstrations of 17 December 2005 or 19 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Latife Canan Kaplan had chanted slogans and carried banners and flags in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) during the demonstrations of 17 December 2005 or 19 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Serdar Kır had chanted slogans and carried banners and flags in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) during the demonstrations of 17 December 2005 or 19 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Selçuk Mart had chanted slogans and carried banners and flags in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) during the demonstrations of 17 December 2005 or 19 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Mehmet Ali Tosun had chanted slogans and carried banners and flags in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) during the demonstrations of 17 December 2005 or 19 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Filiz Uluçelebi had chanted slogans and carried banners and flags in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) during the demonstrations of 17 December 2005 or 19 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Mesut Açıkalın had chanted slogans and carried banners and flags in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) during the demonstrations of 17 December 2005 or 19 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court noted that Levent Çakır, Uğur Güdük, Latife Canan Kaplan, Serdar Kır, Selçuk Mart, Mehmet Ali Tosun, Filiz Uluçelebi and Mesut Açıkalın had been in possession of banned books and documents in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Ankara Assize Court found that the acts of Levent Çakır, Uğur Güdük, Latife Canan Kaplan, Serdar Kır, Selçuk Mart, Mehmet Ali Tosun, Filiz Uluçelebi and Mesut Açıkalın had constituted propaganda in favour of the MLKP (Marxist-Leninist Communist Party) and thereby propaganda inciting people to commit violence or other methods of terrorism.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Levent Çakır, Uğur Güdük, Latife Canan Kaplan, Serdar Kır, Selçuk Mart, Mehmet Ali Tosun, Filiz Uluçelebi and Mesut Açıkalın were convicted pursuant to section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (Prevention of Terrorism Act).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "On 24 December 2009 the Court of Cassation upheld the Ankara Assize Court's judgment of 22 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "On various dates between 10 March 2009 and 12 July 2012 all the applicants except Necla Çomak served the prison sentences imposed on them.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "On 5 July 2012 Law no. 6352 entered into force.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "On 2 November 2012 the Ankara Assize Court revised its judgment of 22 October 2008 pursuant to Law no. 6352 in respect of Metin Kürekçi, Alihan Alhan, Deniz Bakır, Necla Çomak, Levent Çakır, Serdar Kır, Selçuk Mart and Filiz Uluçelebi.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Law no. 6352 had entered into force on 5 July 2012.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "On 2 November 2012 the Ankara Assize Court decided to reduce the sentences imposed on Metin Kürekçi pursuant to Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), on the basis of Articles 220 § 7 and 314 § 3 of the same Code, to two years and one month's imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "On 2 November 2012 the Ankara Assize Court decided to reduce the sentences imposed on Alihan Alhan pursuant to Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), on the basis of Articles 220 § 7 and 314 § 3 of the same Code, to two years and one month's imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "On 2 November 2012 the Ankara Assize Court decided to reduce the sentences imposed on Deniz Bakır pursuant to Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), on the basis of Articles 220 § 7 and 314 § 3 of the same Code, to two years and one month's imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "On 2 November 2012 the Ankara Assize Court decided to reduce the sentences imposed on Necla Çomak pursuant to Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), on the basis of Articles 220 § 7 and 314 § 3 of the same Code, to two years and one month's imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "On 2 November 2012 the Ankara Assize Court decided to suspend the execution of the sentence imposed on Levent Çakır under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (Prevention of Terrorism Act), in accordance with provisional section 1 of Law no. 6352.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "On 2 November 2012 the Ankara Assize Court decided to suspend the execution of the sentence imposed on Serdar Kır under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (Prevention of Terrorism Act), in accordance with provisional section 1 of Law no. 6352.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "On 2 November 2012 the Ankara Assize Court decided to suspend the execution of the sentence imposed on Selçuk Mart under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (Prevention of Terrorism Act), in accordance with provisional section 1 of Law no. 6352.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "On 2 November 2012 the Ankara Assize Court decided to suspend the execution of the sentence imposed on Filiz Uluçelebi under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (Prevention of Terrorism Act), in accordance with provisional section 1 of Law no. 6352.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The suspension of the sentences of Levent Çakır, Serdar Kır, Selçuk Mart and Filiz Uluçelebi was for a period of three years, on condition that they did not commit an offence when expressing ideas and opinions through the medium of the press or other media, or by any other means.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "On 1 April 2005 Law no. 5237 (the Turkish Criminal Code) entered into force.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 1 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who establishes or directs an organisation for the purpose of criminal activity shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between two and six years, provided that the structure of the organisation, the number of members and the quantity of equipment and supplies are sufficient to commit the intended crimes.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who becomes a member of an organisation established for the purpose of criminal activity shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between one and three years.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 3 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that if the organisation is armed, the sentences stated in Article 220 §§ 1 and 2 shall be increased by between one quarter and one half.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 4 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that any crime committed within the framework of the organisation's activities shall be punished separately.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 5 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that the heads of a criminal organisation shall also be sentenced as perpetrators of all crimes committed within the framework of the organisation's activities.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 6 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who commits a crime on behalf of an illegal organisation, even if he is not a member of that organisation, shall also be punished for being a member of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 7 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who aids an illegal organisation knowingly and willingly, even if he does not belong to the hierarchical structure of the organisation, shall be punished as a member of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 8 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who spreads propaganda for the organisation or its objectives shall be punished by a term of imprisonment of between one and three years, and if the crime is committed through the press or other media, the sentence shall be increased by one half.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article 220 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) were amended by Law no. 6352, which entered into force on 2 July 2012.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "As amended by Law no. 6352, Article 220 § 6 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who commits a crime on behalf of an illegal organisation, even if he is not a member of that organisation, shall also be punished for being a member of the organisation, and the penalty to be imposed for membership may be reduced by up to half.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "As amended by Law no. 6352, Article 220 § 7 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who aids an illegal organisation knowingly and willingly, even if he does not belong to the hierarchical structure of the organisation, shall be punished as a member of the organisation, and the penalty to be imposed for membership may be reduced by up to two thirds, depending on the nature of the assistance.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Article 314 § 1 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who forms an armed organisation to commit the crimes listed in the fourth and fifth sections of the relevant chapter, or commands such an organisation, shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between ten and fifteen years.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who becomes a member of an armed organisation mentioned in Article 314 § 1 shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between five and ten years.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Article 314 § 3 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that other provisions relating to the crime of establishing an organisation for the purpose of criminal activity are also applicable to the crime of membership of an armed organisation under Article 314.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Between 7 August 2003 and 18 July 2006, section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (Prevention of Terrorism Act) provided that any person who assists members of terrorist organisations or who disseminates propaganda inciting others to violence or other methods of terrorism shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of one to five years and a judicial fine of five million liras to one billion liras.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "The first sentence of section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (Prevention of Terrorism Act) was amended by Law no. 5532, which entered into force on 18 July 2006, to read: 'Any person who disseminates propaganda in favour of a terrorist organisation shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of one to five years.'", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The first sentence of section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (Prevention of Terrorism Act) was amended on 30 April 2013 by Law no. 6459 to read: 'Any person who disseminates propaganda in favour of a terrorist organisation by justifying, praising or encouraging the use of methods constituting coercion, violence or threats shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of one to five years.'", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "At its 106th plenary session, held on 11 and 12 March 2016, the Venice Commission (European Commission for Democracy through Law) adopted an Opinion on Articles 216, 299, 301 and 314 of the Penal Code of Turkey (CDL-AD(2016)002).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission noted that the Turkish Penal Code does not contain a definition of an armed organisation or an armed group.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "In its judgment E. 2006/10-253 K. 2007/80 of 3 April 2007, the General Criminal Board of the Court of Cassation of Turkey listed the main criteria that a criminal organisation for the purposes of Article 220 of the Turkish Penal Code should display, including: the group must have at least three members; there must be a tight or loose hierarchical connection between members; an 'abstract link' between members is not sufficient; members must have a common intention to commit crimes; the group must present continuity in time; and the structure, number of members, tools and equipment must be sufficient for the commission of the envisaged crimes.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission noted that the Court of Cassation of Turkey developed the criterion of 'membership' in an armed organisation by examining different acts of the suspect, taking account of their 'continuity, diversity and intensity' in order to determine whether those acts prove an 'organic relationship' with the organisation or whether the acts may be considered as committed knowingly and wilfully within the 'hierarchical structure' of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission noted that if an 'organic relationship' with the organisation cannot be proven on the basis of acts attributed to the defendant which do not present any 'continuity, diversity or intensity', the paragraphs on 'aiding and abetting an armed organisation' or 'committing crime on behalf of an armed organisation' under Article 220 of the Turkish Penal Code may be applied.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission noted that according to non-governmental sources, in the application of Article 314 of the Turkish Penal Code, domestic courts in many cases decide on the membership of a person in an armed organisation on the basis of very weak evidence, raising questions as to the 'foreseeability' of the application of Article 314.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "Amnesty International, in its 2013 Report on Turkey, considered that conduct which is not in itself criminal, such as activity related to the exercise of the rights to freedom of assembly, association and expression, is considered as evidence of membership of defendants in an armed organisation by Turkish courts.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "Amnesty International's 2013 Report on Turkey stated that individuals have been prosecuted for membership of a terrorist organisation on charges relating solely to their engagement in peaceful and, in themselves, lawful pro-Kurdish activities.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission noted that in the case of Yılmaz and Kılıç v. Turkey (application no. 68514/01), the European Court of Human Rights considered that where the only evidence which led to the criminal conviction of the applicants under Article 169 of the former Turkish Penal Code was forms of expression (statements by the applicants, content of the slogans they shouted during a public demonstration), it should be concluded that there was an interference with the applicants' right to freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission noted that the European Court of Human Rights applied the same principle in the case of Gül and Others v. Turkey (application no. 4870/02) and held that the criminal conviction of the applicants on the basis of Article 169 of the former Turkish Penal Code constituted an interference with their right to freedom of expression, since the only evidence used against them was the content of the slogans they shouted during a public demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission stated that conviction on the basis of weak evidence in the application of Article 314 of the Turkish Penal Code may create problems in the field of Article 7 of the Convention, since that provision embodies the principle that the criminal law must not be extensively construed to an accused's detriment, for instance by analogy.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission stated that any allegation of membership of an armed organisation must be established with convincing evidence and beyond any reasonable doubt.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission recommended that the established criteria in the case law of the Court of Cassation of Turkey — that acts attributed to a defendant should show 'in their continuity, diversity and intensity' an 'organic relationship' to an organisation, or prove that the defendant acted knowingly and willingly within the 'hierarchical structure' of the organisation — should be applied strictly.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission stated that the expression of an opinion in its different forms should not be the only evidence before domestic courts to decide on the membership of a defendant in an armed organisation.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission noted that paragraph 3 of Article 314 of the Turkish Penal Code provides that all other provisions related to the crime of establishing an organization to commit a crime will be applied in conjunction with Article 314.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission noted that in many recent judgments of the Court of Cassation of Turkey, Article 314 of the Turkish Penal Code was applied in conjunction with paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article 220, on the basis of the reference made in Article 314(3) to 'other provisions' related to forming a criminal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission noted that in a judgment of 4 March 2008, the General Criminal Board of the Court of Cassation of Turkey held that acts such as participating in a public demonstration following a general call from pro-PKK media outlets, making a victory sign and shouting slogans to support the leader of a terrorist organisation, and clashing with the security forces, are considered crimes committed on behalf of the terrorist organisation, and that the defendant was convicted as a member of a criminal organisation under Article 220 § 6 applied in conjunction with Article 314 of the Turkish Penal Code, although membership in an armed organisation was not established.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission noted that in a judgment of 24 March 2011, the 9th Chamber of the Court of Cassation of Turkey held that participation in an illegal public demonstration following a general call of an armed organisation on its Internet site, covering one's face during a demonstration, and shouting slogans in support of the armed organisation were considered as committing crimes on behalf of an armed organisation, and the defendant was convicted as a member of an armed organisation under Article 220(6) in conjunction with Article 314 of the Turkish Penal Code, although his membership was not proven.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission noted that Article 220(7) of the Turkish Penal Code, concerning aiding and abetting an organisation knowingly and willingly, was applied in the Nedim Şener case, where the applicant was prosecuted under Article 314(3) in conjunction with Article 220(7) for having contributed, at the request of suspected members of a criminal organisation, to the preparation of books criticising the actions of the government.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission noted that in a judgment of 4 June 2012 of the Court of Cassation of Turkey, the preparation of a declaration stating 'If it is a crime to refer to Öcalan as Mr. Öcalan, I hereby commit this crime and I denounce myself' and the collection of signatures for this declaration, in the framework of a campaign instigated by a terrorist organisation on its internet sites, was considered as 'knowingly and willingly aiding the criminal organisation'.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission noted that a new paragraph was added to Article 7 of the Anti-Terror Law no. 3713 by an amendment of 11 April 2013, providing that those who committed the crime of propaganda in support of a terrorist organisation under Article 7(2), the crime under Article 6(2) of printing and disseminating declarations by terrorist organisations, or the crime under Article 28(1) of the Public Demonstrations Law no. 2911 of participating in an unlawful demonstration, shall not be sentenced separately under Article 220(6) of the Turkish Penal Code.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission welcomed the amendment introduced to Article 7 of the Anti-Terror Law no. 3713, which excluded the above-mentioned crimes from the scope of application of Article 220(6) of the Turkish Penal Code.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission considered that the scope of the amendment to Article 7 of the Anti-Terror Law no. 3713 is rather limited and does not provide for sufficient protection to the exercise of freedom of expression and assembly, in particular because the amendment excluded the mentioned crimes only from the scope of Article 220(6) but not from Article 220(7) of the Turkish Penal Code.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission recommended that the sentence 'although he is not a member of that organisation, shall also be sentenced for the offence of being a member of that organisation' in paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article 220 of the Turkish Penal Code be repealed.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "In its Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002, the Venice Commission recommended that, should the sentence in paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article 220 of the Turkish Penal Code be maintained, the Turkish authorities should consider limiting the application of Article 220 in conjunction with Article 314 to cases which do not involve the exercise of the rights to freedom of expression and assembly.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "In a report published on 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2), Mr Thomas Hammarberg, the former Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, reported on a visit to Turkey between 10 and 14 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "1. Report of 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2)"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated in his report of 10 January 2012 that any allegation of terrorist activity must be established with convincing evidence and beyond any reasonable doubt.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "1. Report of 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2)"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated in his report of 10 January 2012 that violence or the threat to use violence is an essential component of an act of terrorism, and that restrictions of human rights in the fight against terrorism must be defined as precisely as possible and be necessary and proportionate to the aim pursued.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "1. Report of 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2)"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated in his report of 10 January 2012 that the provisions contained in the Turkish anti-terror legislation and Article 220 of the Turkish Criminal Code allow for a very wide margin of appreciation, in particular in cases where membership in a terrorist organisation has not been proven and when an act or statement may be deemed to coincide with the aims or instructions of a terrorist organisation.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "1. Report of 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2)"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "Mr Thomas Hammarberg encouraged the Turkish authorities in his report of 10 January 2012 to reflect on and address concerns about the wide margin of appreciation in Turkish anti-terror legislation and Article 220 of the Turkish Criminal Code through legislative measures and/or case-law.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "1. Report of 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2)"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "In a memorandum on freedom of expression and media freedom in Turkey (CommDH(2017)5), published on 15 February 2017, Mr Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, reported on a visit to Turkey between 6 and 14 April 2016.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "2. Memorandum of 15 February 2017 ((CommDH(2017)5))"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "Mr Nils Muižnieks, in his memorandum CommDH(2017)5 of 15 February 2017, stressed the need for a complete overhaul of the Turkish Criminal Code, including Article 220 §§ 6 and 7 and Article 314.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "2. Memorandum of 15 February 2017 ((CommDH(2017)5))"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "Mr Nils Muižnieks, in his memorandum CommDH(2017)5 of 15 February 2017, considered that the overhaul of the Turkish Criminal Code should take full account of the European Court of Human Rights' case-law and the opinion of the Venice Commission (CDL-AD(2016)002).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "2. Memorandum of 15 February 2017 ((CommDH(2017)5))"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "On 1 November 2010 Human Rights Watch published a report entitled 'Protesting as a Terrorist Offence / The Arbitrary Use of Terrorism Laws to Prosecute and Incarcerate Demonstrators in Turkey'.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 was seventy-five pages long and mainly concerned trials and convictions of demonstrators in Turkey under Laws nos. 5237, 2911 and 3713.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 stated that many hundreds of people in Turkey face prosecution, or are serving substantial sentences for terrorism convictions, where their 'crime' was to engage in peaceful protest, or to throw stones or burn a tire at a protest.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 stated that legal amendments since 2005, along with case law since 2008, have allowed courts in Turkey to convict demonstrators under the harshest terrorism laws, by invoking two articles of the Turkish Penal Code in combination with the Anti-Terror Law.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 stated that Article 220 of the Turkish Penal Code (Law no. 5237) has been most commonly used to punish criminal gangs, but courts have also applied it to those deemed to be associated with armed political organizations.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 stated that Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code has in some cases been applied to leftist demonstrators who have been punished as 'members' of armed organizations for 'knowingly and willingly aiding' them without providing any material assistance.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 stated that Turkish Penal Code Articles 220/6 and 220/7 are so vaguely worded and lacking in clarity about what is prohibited as to offer an individual no indication of how to regulate or limit conduct.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 recommended that the Turkish Government urgently amend Turkish Penal Code Article 220 and repeal Articles 220/6 and 220/7, which are vague, lack legal clarity and specificity, and are therefore subject to arbitrary application.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 recommended that a review board be set up to examine all cases concluded under Articles 220/6 and 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code for compliance with international human rights law obligations, with a view to quashing sentences under Turkish Penal Code Articles 314/2 and 314/3 in connection with Articles 220/6 and 220/7.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "On 27 March 2013 Amnesty International published a report entitled 'Turkey: Decriminalize Dissent / Time to deliver on the Right to Freedom of Expression'.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 27 March 2013 stated that Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code criminalises assisting a terrorist organisation and is a self-standing offence that does not require the commission of a further criminal act.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 27 March 2013 stated that Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code allows for the sentencing of those convicted under it as though they were members of the organisation they are found to have assisted.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 27 March 2013 stated that Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code is often used to prosecute conduct protected by the rights to freedom of expression, association and assembly.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 27 March 2013 stated that the choice of prosecutors to prosecute under Article 220/6 or Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code often appears arbitrary, with similar behaviour sometimes prosecuted under one, sometimes under the other, and sometimes under Article 314 directly.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 27 March 2013 stated that when prosecutors seek to convict a person under Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code, they often do not provide evidence demonstrating a link to a terrorist organisation, nor do they attempt to prove that the accused was engaged in any criminal offence or in aiding and abetting, other than supposedly assisting the proscribed organisation.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 27 March 2013 stated that no inference should be drawn from someone undertaking a lawful act, such as participating in a peaceful demonstration, even if such acts benefit, through lawful means, goals shared by a terrorist organisation.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 27 March 2013 urged the Turkish government to adopt guidelines for prosecutors on the application of Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code that set out clear criteria for when assisting an armed group can be criminalized, including the requirement that such assistance must either in and of itself be a recognizable criminal offence, or be directly linked to the planning or commission of one.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental organisations' reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["national_security", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F008", "F021", "F022", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F062", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F066", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F070", "F071", "F072", "F073", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F077", "F078", "F079", "F080", "F082", "F117", "F118"], "interference": ["F038", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F051", "F119", "F132"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F021", "F022", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F051", "F055", "F059", "F062", "F064", "F065", "F066", "F067", "F071", "F072", "F079", "F080", "F096", "F097", "F098", "F099", "F100", "F101", "F102", "F105", "F107", "F119", "F139", "F140", "F145", "F146", "F147", "F154", "F167", "F168"], "legitimate_aim": ["F003"], "necessity": ["F008", "F021", "F022", "F031", "F047", "F064", "F065", "F066", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F070", "F071", "F072", "F073", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F077", "F078", "F079", "F080", "F082", "F117", "F118"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F008", "F021", "F022", "F062", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F066", "F067", "F082"], "interference": ["F038", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F119", "F132"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F021", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F051", "F062", "F105", "F107", "F119", "F139", "F140", "F146", "F167", "F168"], "legitimate_aim": ["F003"], "necessity": ["F021", "F022", "F047", "F064", "F065", "F066", "F067", "F070", "F071", "F072", "F073", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F077", "F078", "F079", "F080", "F082", "F117", "F118"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F021", "F022", "F062", "F063", "F140", "F167", "F051", "F107", "F118", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F047", "F064", "F065", "F066", "F067", "F071", "F072", "F079", "F080", "F117", "F119"]}} {"case_name": "case_157", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1967 and lives in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1979 and lives in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1971 and lives in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The fourth applicant was born in 1963 and lives in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The fifth applicant was born in 1979 and lives in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The sixth applicant was born in 1973 and lives in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The seventh applicant was born in 1972 and lives in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Intelligence reports were received indicating that on 5 August 2000 a group of demonstrators would gather in İstiklal Street in Istanbul to read a press declaration and block the tram line to protest against F-type prisons.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Upon receipt of those intelligence reports, police officers were deployed in the İstiklal Street area in Istanbul on 5 August 2000.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Upon receipt of those intelligence reports, members of the 'Rapid Intervention Force' (çevik kuvvet) were deployed in the İstiklal Street area in Istanbul on 5 August 2000.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "At noon on 5 August 2000, the applicants, together with thirty-nine others, gathered in İstiklal Street in Istanbul to make a press declaration to protest against F-type prisons.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The police asked the group gathered in İstiklal Street on 5 August 2000 to disperse and to end the gathering.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The police informed the group gathered in İstiklal Street on 5 August 2000 that the demonstration was unlawful since no advance notice had been submitted to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The demonstrators refused to obey the police order to disperse on 5 August 2000.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The demonstrators attempted to march along İstiklal Street on 5 August 2000, chanting slogans and reading out a press declaration.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "At about 12.30 p.m. on 5 August 2000, the police dispersed the group gathered in İstiklal Street, allegedly by using truncheons and tear-gas.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicants were arrested on 5 August 2000 along with thirty-nine other persons.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant Sema Gül was subsequently taken to the Taksim Hospital following the events of 5 August 2000.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant Semiha Kırkoç was subsequently taken to the Taksim Hospital following the events of 5 August 2000.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The doctor who examined the applicant Sema Gül noted: 'There are bruises on both arms and a swelling on the left foot.'", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The doctor who examined the applicant Semiha Kırkoç noted: 'There is a 4 cm long laceration on the left parietal region.'", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "There were no medical reports in respect of the remaining applicants (i.e., those other than Sema Gül and Semiha Kırkoç).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The incident report dated 5 August 2000 stated that the security forces had to use force to disperse the group because the group refused to obey the warnings.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The incident report dated 5 August 2000 indicated that one police officer was wounded during the incident.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Following the events of 5 August 2000, the applicants were taken to Beyoğlu central police directorate, where they were kept for one day.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Following the events of 5 August 2000, the applicants were taken to Karaköy police station, where they were kept for one day.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The day after their arrest (6 August 2000), the applicants were released upon the order of the Beyoğlu public prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On an unspecified date, the applicants filed a petition with the Beyoğlu public prosecutor against the police officers who had carried out the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "In their petition to the Beyoğlu public prosecutor, the applicants complained of the unlawfulness of their arrest by the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "In their petition to the Beyoğlu public prosecutor, the applicants complained of the excessive use of force by the police officers during and after the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 5 January 2001, the Beyoğlu public prosecutor issued a decision of non-prosecution in respect of the police officers who had been on duty at the relevant time on 5 August 2000.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "In his decision of 5 January 2001, the Beyoğlu public prosecutor considered that the force used by the security forces was in line with Article 16 of Law No. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "In his decision of 5 January 2001, the Beyoğlu public prosecutor considered that the force used by the security forces had not been excessive.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "In his decision of 5 January 2001, the Beyoğlu public prosecutor opined that the injuries sustained by the complainants had been caused by the use of force which was proportionate.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicants filed an objection against the Beyoğlu public prosecutor's decision of non-prosecution dated 5 January 2001.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 25 June 2001, the Istanbul Assize Court dismissed the applicants' objection against the Beyoğlu public prosecutor's decision of non-prosecution.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 14 August 2000, the Beyoğlu public prosecutor filed a bill of indictment with the Beyoğlu Criminal Court against the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Beyoğlu public prosecutor accused the applicants under Article 28 § 1 of Law No. 2911 (Assemblies and Marches Act) of taking part in an illegal demonstration without prior authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Beyoğlu public prosecutor accused the applicants under Article 28 § 1 of Law No. 2911 (Assemblies and Marches Act) of not dispersing despite the police officers' warning.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 19 September 2005, the Beyoğlu Criminal Court acquitted the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Beyoğlu Criminal Court held that making a press statement was a constitutional right and that prior authorisation was not needed to exercise this right.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Beyoğlu Criminal Court observed that it was not certain that the warning given to the accused to disperse could be heard by all the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Beyoğlu Criminal Court concluded that the accused had used their constitutional rights and, consequently, had not committed any offence.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Article 34 of the Turkish Constitution provides that everyone has the right to hold unarmed and peaceful meetings and demonstration marches without prior permission.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Constitutional guarantees"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Article 34 of the Turkish Constitution provides that the formalities, conditions, and procedures governing the exercise of the right to hold meetings and demonstration marches shall be prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Constitutional guarantees"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "At the material time, section 10 of the Assemblies and Marches Act (Law No. 2911) required that, in order for a meeting to take place, the governor's office or authorities of the district in which the demonstration was planned must be informed, during opening hours and at least seventy-two hours prior to the meeting, by a notice containing the signature of all the members of the organising board.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Demonstrations Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Section 22 of the Assemblies and Marches Act (Law No. 2911) prohibited demonstrations and processions on public streets, in parks, places of worship, and buildings in which public services were based.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Demonstrations Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "Section 22 of the Assemblies and Marches Act (Law No. 2911) required that demonstrations organised in public squares comply with security instructions and not disrupt individuals' movement or public transport.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Demonstrations Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Section 24 of the Assemblies and Marches Act (Law No. 2911) provided that demonstrations and processions which did not comply with the provisions of that law would be dispersed by force on the order of the governor's office and after the demonstrators had been warned.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Demonstrations Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Article 16 of Law No. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that the police may use firearms in the event of self-defence.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Law No. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Article 16(h) of Law No. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that the police may use firearms if a person or a group resists the police and prevents them from carrying out their duties or if there is an attack against the police.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Law No. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Additional Article 6 (dated 16 June 1985) of Law No. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that in cases of resistance by persons whose arrest is necessary or by groups whose dispersal is necessary, or of their threatening to attack or carrying out an attack, the police may use violence to subdue these actions.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Law No. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Additional Article 6 (dated 16 June 1985) of Law No. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that use of violence refers to the use of bodily force, physical force and all types of weapons specified in the law, and that it gradually increases according to the nature and level of resistance and attack in such a way as to restore calm.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Law No. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Additional Article 6 (dated 16 June 1985) of Law No. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that in cases of intervention by group forces, the extent of the use of force and the equipment and instruments to be used are determined by the commander of the intervening force.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Law No. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F008", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F023"], "interference": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F016", "F017", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F040"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F013", "F046", "F047", "F048"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F023", "F044", "F046"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F011", "F015", "F023"], "interference": ["F016", "F017", "F037", "F040"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F046", "F047"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F044", "F046"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F008", "F011", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F037", "F040", "F046", "F047"]}} {"case_name": "case_158", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of nationwide protests in support of the jailed opposition leader, Aleksey Navalnyy.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of nationwide protests in support of the jailed opposition leader, Aleksey Navalnyy.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention, in addition to their complaints about disproportionate measures.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_159", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1990.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 7-65, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 7-33, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The parties' submissions on the circumstances directly relevant to the present case are set out below.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 6 May 2012 a public demonstration entitled the 'March of Millions' was held in central Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration on 6 May 2012 was held to protest against the allegedly rigged presidential elections.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration on 6 May 2012 had been approved by the Moscow city authorities in the form of a march followed by a meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The approved meeting at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 was supposed to end at 7.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The march on 6 May 2012 was peaceful and held without any disruptions.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "When the marchers arrived at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, it became apparent that barriers installed by the police had narrowed the entrance to the meeting venue.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The barriers installed by the police at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 allegedly restricted the space allocated for the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "To control the crowd at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, the police cordon forced the protestors to remain within the barriers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "There were numerous clashes between the police and protestors at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police ordered the meeting at Bolotnaya Square to finish early.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police began to disperse the participants of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "It took the police about two hours to clear Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the Moscow city department of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation opened criminal proceedings to investigate suspected acts of mass disorder under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the Moscow city department of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation opened criminal proceedings to investigate suspected violence against the police under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 18 May 2012 the criminal case file was transferred from the Moscow city department to the headquarters of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation for further investigation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 28 May 2012 a criminal investigation was launched into the offence of organising acts of mass disorder under Article 212 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 28 May 2012 the two criminal cases (concerning mass disorder and organising mass disorder) were joined into a single case.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "At the time of his arrest the applicant was working as an artist.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the applicant, on 6 May 2012 he arrived at Kaluzhskaya Square to take part in the 'March of Millions' march.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the applicant, on 6 May 2012 he walked down Yakimanka Street to Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the applicant, on 6 May 2012 he passed the metal detectors at Bolotnaya Square and joined other protestors in front of the stage, where a rock group was performing.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicant, sometime after 6 p.m. on 6 May 2012 he walked towards Malyy Kamenyy Bridge but discovered that movement in that direction had been blocked by a police cordon.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the applicant, after finding the route to Malyy Kamenyy Bridge blocked, he walked back and stayed in the general area of Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the applicant, at around 7.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 groups of police officers started pushing into the crowd, forcing it apart by using their truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the applicant, protestors at Bolotnaya Square were surrounded and squeezed together by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the applicant, at some point he realised that he was facing the police line and that the police were using excessive force to arrest protestors.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the applicant, he was both angered and scared by the actions of the police and actively resisted.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant was eventually seized by four police officers and escorted to a police car, which took him to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 14 May 2012 the Justice of the Peace of the 100th Court Circuit of the Yakimanka District of Moscow found the applicant guilty of non-compliance with a lawful order by a police officer, an offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of the 100th Court Circuit of the Yakimanka District of Moscow established that after the meeting at Bolotnaya Square the applicant had shouted anti-government slogans, ignoring the lawful demands of the police to cease those acts.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of the 100th Court Circuit of the Yakimanka District of Moscow established that the applicant had thrown objects at the police officers, including stones, flagpoles, empty plastic bottles, and pieces of asphalt.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of the 100th Court Circuit of the Yakimanka District of Moscow established that the applicant had refused to proceed to the police van.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant was sentenced by the Justice of the Peace of the 100th Court Circuit of the Yakimanka District of Moscow to detention of twenty-four hours for the administrative offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "After his release from the twenty-four-hour administrative detention, the applicant continued to live at his usual address and pursue his customary activities.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 28 May 2012 the applicant's flat was searched.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 28 May 2012 the applicant was detained on suspicion of participation in acts of mass disorder on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 28 May 2012 the applicant was detained on suspicion of committing violent acts against the police on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 30 May 2012 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow ordered that the applicant be placed in pre-trial detention until 6 July 2012.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its order of 30 May 2012, referred to the gravity of the charges against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its order of 30 May 2012, stated that if the applicant was at liberty he could co-ordinate his position with accomplices whose identities were still being established by the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its order of 30 May 2012, pointed out that the applicant had forcefully resisted the police officers during his arrest, which had led to them using force and handcuffs against him.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its order of 30 May 2012, relied on information obtained from undercover sources that the applicant had connections with football fans and groups of anarchists.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant denied having connections with football fans and groups of anarchists and challenged the use of information from undisclosed sources in the detention proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its order of 30 May 2012, concluded that there were sufficient reasons to believe that the applicant was likely to abscond, continue his criminal activity, threaten witnesses, destroy evidence or otherwise obstruct the course of the criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its order of 30 May 2012, dismissed a request from the applicant for an alternative preventive measure.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its order of 30 May 2012, found that the applicant's release was not required on health grounds.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 4 June 2012 the applicant lodged an appeal against the detention order of 30 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 27 June 2012 the Moscow City Court dismissed the applicant's appeal against the detention order of 30 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 5 June 2012 charges were brought against the applicant under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (participation in acts of mass disorder accompanied by violence).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 5 June 2012 charges were brought against the applicant under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (use of violence against a public official).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The applicant was accused of active resistance to police officers on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicant was accused of participation in a group assault on a police officer whereby the applicant had allegedly pulled a protective helmet off the officer's head.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicant was accused of participation in a group assault on a police officer whereby the applicant had allegedly punched and kicked the officer on the head and body.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 4 July 2012 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow examined an application from the investigator for an extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "At the hearing on 4 July 2012, the applicant argued that he had no criminal record, was in work, and had a permanent residence in Moscow where he lived with his family.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "At the hearing on 4 July 2012, the applicant denied any involvement with football fans or anarchists.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "At the hearing on 4 July 2012, the applicant asked for the preventive measure to be changed to house arrest.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 4 July 2012 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow granted the investigator's application and extended the applicant's pre-trial detention until 6 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its extension order of 4 July 2012, relied on the gravity of the charges and information on the applicant's character, which gave it sufficient grounds to presume that he might reoffend, threaten witnesses and other participants of the criminal proceedings, destroy evidence or otherwise obstruct the proper administration of justice.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 12 July 2012 the applicant lodged an appeal against the extension order of 4 July 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 6 August 2012 the Moscow City Court dismissed the applicant's appeal against the extension order of 4 July 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 31 October 2012 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow examined a new application for an extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 31 October 2012 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow extended the applicant's pre-trial detention until 6 March 2013, referring to the gravity of the charges and the complexity of the criminal investigation.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 13 November 2012 the applicant lodged an appeal against the extension order of 31 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 3 December 2012 the Moscow City Court dismissed the applicant's appeal against the extension order of 31 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 16 November 2012 the charges against the applicant were updated.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "In the updated charges of 16 November 2012, the classification of the offences against the applicant remained unchanged.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "In the updated charges of 16 November 2012, it was specified that the applicant had struck the police officer once on the head.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "In the updated charges of 16 November 2012, it was specified that the applicant had kicked the police officer once on the body while the officer was lying on the ground.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 1 March 2013 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow authorised a further extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention until 28 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its extension order of 1 March 2013, relied on the gravity of the charges and the need to allow the defendants sufficient time to read the investigation case file.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 10 April 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the Basmannyy District Court's extension order of 1 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 23 April 2013 the Moscow City Court granted an extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention until 6 July 2013.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Moscow City Court, in its extension order of 23 April 2013, noted that even though the applicant and his lawyer had already finished reading the case file, other defendants had not.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Moscow City Court, in its extension order of 23 April 2013, reiterated the grounds given in the previous extension orders and stated that the circumstances justifying the detention order had not changed.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 30 May 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the extension order of 23 April 2013.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 24 May 2013 the applicant's criminal case was transferred to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow for the determination of criminal charges.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "On 6 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow granted another extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention until 24 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The extension order of 6 June 2013 by the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow concerned eleven defendants.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow, in its extension order of 6 June 2013, based its decision on the gravity of the charges, the finding that 'the reasons which initially warranted the detention have not changed', and that 'no other measures of restraint would secure the aims and goals of the judicial proceedings'.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On 2 July 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court's extension order of 6 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "On 19 November 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow granted another extension of pre-trial detention in respect of nine defendants, including the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow, in its extension order of 19 November 2013, ordered the detention of the nine defendants including the applicant until 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow, in its extension order of 19 November 2013, based its decision on the gravity of the charges and the nature of the offences imputable to the defendants.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 17 December 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court's extension order of 19 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "On 6 June 2013 court proceedings began in hearing room no. 338 at the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "At the end of July 2013 the court proceedings moved to hearing room no. 635 at the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The defendants, including the applicant, were held in glass cabins in hearing room no. 338 and hearing room no. 635 at the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "From mid-September 2013 to the end of 2013 the hearings continued at the Nikulinskiy District Court of Moscow in hearing room no. 303.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "In January and February 2014 the hearings took place at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow in hearing room no. 410.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Hearing room no. 303 at the Nikulinskiy District Court of Moscow and hearing room no. 410 at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow were equipped with metal cages in which nine defendants (seven from 19 December 2013), including the applicant, sat during the hearings.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "For a detailed description of the conditions in the hearing rooms used during the proceedings, see Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 74-77, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 6 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow began a preliminary hearing in a criminal case against ten participants in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The ten defendants in the criminal case before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow were charged with participation in acts of mass disorder and committing acts of violence against police officers.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 18 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow began the trial on the merits.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On an unidentified date during the trial, Police Officer K., the alleged victim of the applicant's assault, was examined as a witness.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "Police Officer K. testified that he had been carrying out an order to split the crowd up when someone had pulled at his bullet-proof vest.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "Police Officer K. testified that he had fallen to the ground and someone had hit him several times and had taken off his anti-riot helmet.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "Police Officer K. testified that other police officers had picked him up to take him away from the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Police Officer K. testified that as a result of his fall and the blows, he had sustained injuries.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Police Officer V.K. testified that the applicant had kicked an unidentified police officer.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Three police officers, examined as witnesses during the trial, stated that the applicant had resisted arrest by planting his feet firmly on the ground and attempting to escape.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Three police officers, examined as witnesses during the trial, stated that the applicant had uttered obscenities to the police officers and shouted at them.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "On 21 February 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found the applicant guilty as charged under Article 212 § 2 and Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that between 4 p.m. and 8 p.m. on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square, unidentified persons called those present to move outside the agreed meeting venue and to defy the lawful orders of the police.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that the unidentified persons called those present at Bolotnaya Square to use violence, which led to mass disorder accompanied by the use of violence against public officials in connection with the performance of their duties and the destruction of property.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that on 6 May 2012 at 5 p.m. at the latest, the defendants acquired the criminal intent to participate in mass disorder and to use violence against police officers.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that participants of the acts of mass disorder threw chunks of tarmac, stones, sticks and other objects at the police, which hit them on various parts of their body.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant used violence against Police Officer K. which did not endanger his life or health.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that between 5.10 p.m. and 8.20 p.m. on 6 May 2012, unidentified participants of acts of mass disorder intentionally seized Police Officer K. by his uniform and knocked him down.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant, together with other unidentified participants of acts of mass disorder, tore off Police Officer K.'s anti-riot helmet.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant punched Police Officer K.'s head at least once and kicked Police Officer K. on the body at least once when the latter was lying on the ground.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The applicant pleaded not guilty at trial and testified that he wanted to see why the meeting was not starting and went to Malyy Kamennyy Bridge where he saw the police cordon.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The applicant testified that around 7.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 he saw police officers starting to beat people with truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The applicant testified that at some point he found himself in the first line and saw the police officers harshly arresting and beating people who tried to evade the blows.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The applicant testified that he was hit several times on the shoulder and the head, which led to dizziness.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The applicant testified that he was scared, felt that his life was in danger, and while in a state of fury moved towards a police officer who happened to be Police Officer K., and then moved his leg towards the police officer who was getting up.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The applicant testified that he did not see who knocked Police Officer K. down.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The applicant testified that he did not know whether his hand reached the target but supposed that he was able to touch the bullet-proof vest.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The applicant testified that he definitely did not touch Police Officer K. with his leg and that he caused him no harm.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The applicant testified that a few minutes later he was taken out of the crowd and beaten, his T-shirt was torn, and then four police officers seized him and dragged him along the tarmac to the police vehicle.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The applicant insisted at trial that he caused no injuries to the police officer and that his actions, provoked by panic, were taken in response to the events occurring around him.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow considered the defendants' arguments that they were protecting somebody from the police officers or happened to be victims of the police's use of force as farfetched and aimed at the mitigation of their responsibility.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow noted that no medical document which could prove the presence of injuries on the applicant's body was provided to the court.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to three years and seven months' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The applicant's sentence of three years and seven months' imprisonment was calculated on the basis of a three-year prison term under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, partly concurrent with a term of one year and eight months under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The applicant's pre-trial detention counted towards his prison sentence.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The applicant appealed against the judgment of 21 February 2014 of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant contested the classification of the crimes under Article 212 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant contested the classification of the crimes under Article 318 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant insisted that he had been a victim of unlawful police action.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant insisted that his involvement in using violence against the police officer had not been proven.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "On 20 June 2014 the Moscow City Court upheld the first-instance judgment of 21 February 2014 of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Article 212 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the organisation of mass disorder, accompanied by violence, riot, arson, destruction of property, the use of firearms, explosives and explosive devices, as well as armed resistance to a public official, shall be punishable by four to ten years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that participation in the types of mass disorder provided for by Article 212 § 1 shall be punishable by three to eight years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Article 212 § 3 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the instigation of the acts of mass disorder provided for by Article 212 § 1, or the instigation of participation in such acts, or the instigation of violence against citizens, shall be punishable by a restriction of liberty for up to two years, or community service for up to two years, or deprivation of liberty for the same term.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the use of violence which does not endanger life or health, or the threat to use such violence against a public official or his relatives in connection with the performance of his or her duties, shall be punishable by a fine of up to 200,000 roubles or an equivalent of the convicted person's wages for 18 months, or community service for up to five years, or up to five years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law provisions governing pre-trial detention and for the practice of the domestic courts in such matters, see Zherebin v. Russia (no. 51445/09, §§ 16-25, 24 March 2016).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F010", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F112", "F114", "F117", "F119", "F120", "F122"], "interference": ["F109", "F130", "F131"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F139", "F140", "F141", "F142", "F054", "F055"], "legitimate_aim": ["F054", "F055"], "necessity": ["F008", "F010", "F014", "F018", "F019", "F073", "F074", "F084", "F098", "F099", "F109", "F112", "F114", "F115", "F117", "F118", "F119", "F120", "F122", "F127", "F128", "F129", "F130", "F131", "F136"], "positive_obligation": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F008", "F024", "F026", "F010", "F119", "F120", "F122"], "interference": ["F109", "F130"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F140", "F142"], "legitimate_aim": ["F054", "F055"], "necessity": ["F008", "F010", "F073", "F074", "F112", "F114", "F117", "F119", "F122", "F128", "F130", "F131"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F008", "F010", "F073", "F074", "F114", "F117", "F119", "F122", "F128", "F130", "F131"]}} {"case_name": "case_160", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1960.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in the town of Chekhov in the Moscow region.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant is the pastor of the \"Christ's Grace\" Church of Evangelical Christians (Церковь евангельских христиан \"Благодать Христова\").", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 9 September 2002, the applicant applied to the Chekhov Town Council for permission to hold a service in public.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant requested permission to hold the public service between 11 a.m. and 1 p.m. on 22 or 29 September 2002.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 20 September 2002, the deputy head of the Chekhov Town Council refused the applicant's request for permission to hold a public service.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The deputy head of the Chekhov Town Council stated that the Chekhov Town Council had on many occasions informed the applicant that it was not possible to hold services in public areas in the town (squares, streets, parks, etc.).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant was advised by the Chekhov Town Council to hold services and other religious rites at the registered seat of the \"Christ's Grace\" Church of Evangelical Christians or on other premises owned or used by the church members.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 26 September 2002, the applicant challenged the Chekhov Town Council's refusal of permission before a court.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicant alleged violations of the right to freedom of religion in his court challenge.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant alleged violations of the right to freedom of assembly in his court challenge.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 11 October 2002, the Chekhov Town Court of the Moscow Region examined the applicant's claim.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Chekhov Town Court of the Moscow Region dismissed the applicant's claim on 11 October 2002.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Chekhov Town Court of the Moscow Region found that, pursuant to domestic law, public worship and other religious rites were subject to authorisation by a municipal authority.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Chekhov Town Court of the Moscow Region ruled that the Chekhov Town Council's refusal was lawful because it was justified.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Chekhov Town Court of the Moscow Region ruled that the \"Christ's Grace\" Church of Evangelical Christians practices a religion different from the religion professed by the majority of the local residents.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Chekhov Town Court of the Moscow Region noted that in the Chekhov district there are more than twenty religious organisations of different denominations.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Chekhov Town Court of the Moscow Region ruled that a service of worship in a public area held by one religious organisation may lead to discontent of individuals of other denominations and public disorder.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Chekhov Town Court of the Moscow Region ruled that the acts of the Chekhov Town Council could not be deemed to impair the rights of the \"Christ's Grace\" Church of Evangelical Christians because they did not prevent the church from holding services in religious buildings or on other premises intended for that purpose.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant appealed against the judgment of the Chekhov Town Court of the Moscow Region of 11 October 2002.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 4 November 2002, the Moscow Regional Court upheld the judgment of the Chekhov Town Court of the Moscow Region of 11 October 2002.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Freedom of Conscience and Religious Associations Act (no. 125-FZ of 26 September 1997) provided that services and other religious rites and ceremonies in public were to be performed in accordance with the procedure established for assemblies, marches and demonstrations (section 16 of the Act).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 was in force at the material time pursuant to Presidential Decree no. 524 of 25 May 1992.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 provided that organisers of an assembly were to serve written notice on the municipal authorities no later than ten days before the planned assembly (section 2 of the Decree).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 provided that the municipal authority was to give its response no later than five days before the planned assembly (section 3 of the Decree).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 provided that an assembly could be banned if its purpose was contrary to the Constitution or threatened public order or the security of citizens.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F016", "F018"], "interference": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F008"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F023", "F026", "F006"], "legitimate_aim": ["F026", "F018"], "necessity": ["F016", "F018", "F017", "F006", "F007", "F015"], "positive_obligation": ["F006", "F007"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F005"], "interference": ["F004", "F006"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F023", "F026"], "legitimate_aim": ["F018", "F026"], "necessity": ["F016", "F018", "F006", "F007", "F015"], "positive_obligation": ["F006", "F007"]}, "list3": ["F004", "F006", "F007", "F016", "F018", "F023", "F026"]}} {"case_name": "case_161", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_162", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1967.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Gyumri.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr K. Tumanyan, a lawyer practising in Vanadzor.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr E. Marukyan, a lawyer practising in Vanadzor.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr G. Kostanyan.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr Y. Kirakosyan, Representative of the Republic of Armenia before the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant is a journalist.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant is a political activist.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicant is the chairman of a journalists' club based in Gyumri.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Gyumri is the second largest city in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 19 February 2008 a presidential election was held in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "After the announcement of the preliminary results of the 19 February 2008 presidential election, the main opposition candidate, Mr Ter-Petrosyan, called on his supporters to gather at Freedom Square in central Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Mr Ter-Petrosyan called on his supporters to gather at Freedom Square in central Yerevan in order to protest against the irregularities which had allegedly occurred in the election process.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Mr Ter-Petrosyan announced that the 19 February 2008 presidential election had not been free and fair.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "From 20 February 2008 onwards, nationwide daily protest rallies were held by thousands of Mr Ter-Petrosyan's supporters.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The main meeting place of Mr Ter-Petrosyan's supporters during the protest rallies from 20 February 2008 onwards was Freedom Square and the surrounding park in central Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Several hundred demonstrators stayed around the clock at Freedom Square and the surrounding park, having set up a camp.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 1 March 2008 in the early morning a police operation was conducted on Freedom Square in Yerevan where several hundred demonstrators were camping.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "As a result of the police operation on 1 March 2008, Freedom Square was cleared of all the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Later on 1 March 2008 the situation in Yerevan escalated and rallies continued throughout the city until the early morning of 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The rallies on 1 March 2008 involved clashes between some protesters and law enforcement officers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The events of 1 March 2008 resulted in ten deaths, including eight civilians.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The events of 1 March 2008 resulted in numerous injured persons.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The events of 1 March 2008 resulted in destruction of private and public property.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 1 March 2008 the incumbent President of Armenia issued a decree declaring a state of emergency in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The state of emergency declared by the President of Armenia on 1 March 2008 was for a period of twenty days.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The state of emergency declared on 1 March 2008 included a prohibition on holding meetings, rallies, demonstrations, marches and other mass events in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE EVENTS FOLLOWING THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE DECLARATION OF A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN YEREVAN"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 2 March 2008 at around 12.30 p.m. the applicant arrived at Theatre Square in central Gyumri.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 2 March 2008 the applicant tried to enter Theatre Square in central Gyumri in order to hold a protest.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 2 March 2008 the applicant was refused entry to Theatre Square by police officers who were stationed there for the purpose of preventing any demonstrations from taking place.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "It is alleged that the applicant started calling on people who were present at Theatre Square to gather and to hold a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "Police officers ordered the applicant to leave Theatre Square and to stop inciting others to assemble.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The applicant did not obey the police officers' orders to leave Theatre Square and to stop inciting others to assemble.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant was taken to a police station after disobeying the police officers' orders at Theatre Square on 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "At the police station an administrative case was initiated against the applicant under Article 182 of the Code of Administrative Offences for disobeying the lawful orders of the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "A record of an administrative offence was drawn up against the applicant at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "A statement was taken from the applicant at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicant was released from the police station after a record of an administrative offence was drawn up and a statement was taken from him.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 5 March 2008 the police lodged a claim with the Administrative Court seeking to subject the applicant to a penalty under Article 182 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The police stated in their claim that the applicant had called on others to hold a demonstration at Theatre Square in Gyumri.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The police stated in their claim that the applicant had refused to obey the lawful orders of the police officers, who had been stationed at Theatre Square for the purpose of preventing the conduct of unauthorised demonstrations, to stop his actions and to leave.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The police noted in their claim that the Gyumri Mayor's Office had not been duly notified of the demonstration at Theatre Square on 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The police noted in their claim that no authorisation had been obtained to hold the demonstration at Theatre Square on 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 24 March 2008 the applicant lodged a counter-claim against the police.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In his counter-claim, the applicant argued that the police had failed to substantiate the factual basis of their claim, namely the fact that he had called on others to hold a rally.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In his counter-claim, the applicant insisted that he had not intended to organise a rally and that there had not been any rally at Theatre Square at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "In his counter-claim, the applicant argued that the act of calling on people was not an act prohibited and therefore punishable by law.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In his counter-claim, the applicant argued that no evidence had been produced to show that more than 100 people had gathered at or in the vicinity of Theatre Square at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In his counter-claim, the applicant argued that the allegation that he had called on others to hold a rally without prior notification was unsubstantiated, since the law did not require prior notification if fewer than 100 people took part in a rally.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "In his counter-claim, the applicant argued that the police orders addressed to him could not be considered lawful.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On an unspecified date the police lodged a written response to the applicant's counter-claim, seeking to dismiss it as unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The police claimed in their written response that well-known facts were not liable to be proved.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The police asserted that well-known facts included the fact that a tense situation had been created in Armenia after the tragic events of 1 March 2008, which threatened national security and public safety.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The police asserted in their written response that the day before the incident on 2 March 2008, an unauthorised rally had been held on Theatre Square in Gyumri, at which the time and place of the next rally had been announced.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The police asserted in their written response that at the unauthorised rally held the day before the incident, it had been announced that the applicant, who was known to be an active rally participant, would make a speech at Theatre Square.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The police asserted in their written response that it was not by chance that the applicant had appeared at Theatre Square on 2 March 2008, as he was not just an accidental passer-by.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The police asserted in their written response that the administrative case against the applicant was therefore justified.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 31 March 2008 the applicant lodged his objections to the police's written response, contesting the factual allegations made by the police.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 10 June 2008 the Administrative Court granted the police claim against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 10 June 2008 the Administrative Court dismissed the applicant's counter-claim against the police.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 10 June 2008 the Administrative Court subjected the applicant to an administrative fine under Article 182 of the Code of Administrative Offences in the amount of 50,000 Armenian Drams (approximately 110 euros at the material time) for disobeying the lawful orders of the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Administrative Court held that on 2 March 2008 at around 12 noon police officers of the Gyumri Police Station were performing their duties at Gyumri's Theatre Square and its surroundings for the purpose of prohibiting the conduct of a demonstration in respect of which no notification had been made in accordance with the procedure prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Administrative Court found, referring to the requirements of Section 10 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, that there had been no legal basis for holding a demonstration at Theatre Square in Gyumri on 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Administrative Court found that on 2 March 2008 at around 12.30 p.m. the applicant arrived at Theatre Square in Gyumri and wanted to enter the square, but was prevented and ordered to leave that area and not to call on people to gather and hold an event, which he disobeyed.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Administrative Court made reference to Sections 2, 12, 22 and 38 of the Police Act (2001).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Administrative Court held that mass public events may be held only after notification in writing to the competent authority, in this case the Head of the Gyumri Community, in accordance with the requirements of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Administrative Court held that no notification of a mass public event on 2 March 2008 had been submitted to the Head of the Gyumri Community.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Administrative Court noted that the President of Armenia, by Decree no. NH-35-N of 1 March 2008, declared a state of emergency in Yerevan starting from 1 March 2008 for a period of twenty days for the purpose of preventing the threat to the constitutional order of the country and protecting the rights and lawful interests of the population.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Administrative Court found that the conduct of a mass public event in Gyumri, the second largest city of the country, could have endangered the protection of public order and public health, particularly when no notification to hold such an event had been submitted in accordance with the prescribed procedure.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Administrative Court found that the police applied certain restrictions on gathering and holding events on Gyumri's Theatre Square pursuant to Article 43 of the Constitution of Armenia and the Police Act (2001).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Administrative Court concluded that the orders given to the applicant, which he had disobeyed, had been lawful.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 8 September 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal on points of law against the Administrative Court's judgment of 10 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "In his appeal on points of law, the applicant argued that the Administrative Court, by subjecting him to a fine, had violated his rights under Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "In his appeal on points of law, the applicant argued that the Administrative Court's judgment did not explain why his right to hold a rally and to participate in it was subject to a restriction.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 2 October 2008 the Court of Cassation declared the applicant's appeal on points of law inadmissible for lack of merit.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Article 43 of the Constitution of Armenia, as in force at the material time, permitted restrictions on the right to freedom of peaceful assembly under the conditions of being prescribed by law and necessary in a democratic society for the protection of national security and public order, the prevention of crimes, the protection of public health and morals, or the protection of constitutional rights and freedoms, honour and good reputation of others.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. The Constitution (2005-2015)"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Article 182 of the Code of Administrative Offences, as in force at the material time, provided that disobeying a lawful order of a military serviceman or a police officer issued in the performance of his duties of preserving public order and of ensuring public safety would result in a fine in the amount of 50 times the fixed minimum wage.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences (1986)"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "According to Section 2 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011), the concept of a public event includes peaceful assemblies, rallies, marches (parades) and demonstrations (including sit-ins).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "According to Section 2 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011), 'mass public events' are defined as public events which have 100 or more participants.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "According to Section 2 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011), 'non-mass public events' are defined as public events which have fewer than 100 participants.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Section 10 §§ 1, 2 and 4 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that, except for cases when a non-mass public event spontaneously turns into a mass public event, mass public events may be held only after notifying the competent authority in writing.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Section 10 §§ 1, 2 and 4 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that everyone has the right to hold non-mass public events without notifying the competent authority and without violating public order.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Section 2 of the Police Act (2001) provides that the objectives of the police include the prevention of crimes and the protection of public order and public safety.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "D. The Police Act (2001)"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Section 12 of the Police Act (2001) provides that the police are obliged to ensure the protection of public order in the streets, squares, parks, railway stations, airports, polling stations and other public spaces, as well as during court hearings upon a court's request.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "D. The Police Act (2001)"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "According to Section 22 of the Police Act (2001), when protecting public order, the police are entitled to restrict or ban temporarily the traffic and the pedestrian flow.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "D. The Police Act (2001)"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "According to Section 22 of the Police Act (2001), when protecting public order, the police are entitled to oblige people to remain in specific spaces, facilities, streets or roads for the protection of their life, health or property or for the conduct of investigative or operative-search measures, and must immediately inform their superiors about this.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "D. The Police Act (2001)"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Section 38 of the Police Act (2001) provides that every citizen and public official is obliged to obey lawful orders of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "D. The Police Act (2001)"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Section 38 of the Police Act (2001) provides that failure to obey lawful orders of a police officer or actions obstructing the performance of a police officer's duties result in liability in accordance with the procedure prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "D. The Police Act (2001)"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman carried out a comprehensive and in-depth analysis of the post-election events in Armenia following the 19 February 2008 presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "E. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Ad-Hoc Public Report found that though the state of emergency was declared only in the City of Yerevan, some restrictions specified in the Decree declaring a state of emergency were effectively applied in other towns of Armenia as well, including the restriction of the freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "E. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Relevant extracts from the Armenian Ombudsman's Ad-Hoc Public Report on the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments were quoted in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia, no. 23086/08, § 124, 20 September 2018.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "E. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Relevant extracts from the Armenian Ombudsman's Ad-Hoc Public Report on the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments were quoted in Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia, no. 49020/08, § 49, 15 October 2020.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "E. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Relevant Council of Europe and other international materials concerning the presidential election of 19 February 2008 and the events of 1 March 2008 are referenced in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia, no. 23086/08, §§ 125-134.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Relevant Council of Europe and other international materials concerning the presidential election of 19 February 2008 and the events of 1 March 2008 are referenced in Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia, no. 49020/08, §§ 50-57.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008), produced by the co-rapporteurs of the PACE Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe (the Monitoring Committee), stated that although the state of emergency was formally only declared in Yerevan, a large number of provisions, especially those related to the media and the activities of political parties and NGOs, had a nationwide application.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE): Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008)"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008) stated that a number of broadcasters stopped operating, either by their own decision or forced by the national security service.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE): Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008)"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008) stated that a number of news websites were taken offline after intervention by the national security service.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE): Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008)"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008) stated that restrictions on rallies and demonstrations were not limited to Yerevan alone, but also applied to other major cities in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE): Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008)"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Report by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008 (CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008) stated that a number of restrictions enacted by the state of emergency affected the whole country and were not limited to the boundaries of the capital.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Report by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008 (CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008)"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Report by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008 (CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008) stated that restrictions on rallies and demonstrations had been applied also outside of the capital, in other major cities of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Report by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008 (CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008)"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "Armenia's Ministry of Foreign Affairs transmitted a Note verbale dated 2 March 2008 containing a notice of derogation to the Permanent Representation of Armenia to the Council of Europe.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "III. NOTICE OF DEROGATION OF 2 MARCH 2008 MADE BY ARMENIA TO THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Note verbale containing Armenia's notice of derogation was registered by the Secretariat General of the Council of Europe on 4 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "III. NOTICE OF DEROGATION OF 2 MARCH 2008 MADE BY ARMENIA TO THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Note verbale from Armenia's Ministry of Foreign Affairs was addressed to Mr Terry Davis, Secretary General of the Council of Europe.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "III. NOTICE OF DEROGATION OF 2 MARCH 2008 MADE BY ARMENIA TO THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Note verbale from Armenia's Ministry of Foreign Affairs transmitted the Decree of the President of the Republic of Armenia on Declaration of State of Emergency in Yerevan, Armenia, pursuant to Article 15 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "III. NOTICE OF DEROGATION OF 2 MARCH 2008 MADE BY ARMENIA TO THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The Decree of the President of the Republic of Armenia on Declaration of a State of Emergency (No. NH-35-N) was issued on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "III. NOTICE OF DEROGATION OF 2 MARCH 2008 MADE BY ARMENIA TO THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Decree of the President of the Republic of Armenia No. NH-35-N declared a state of emergency in Yerevan from 1 March 2008 for 20 days, in order to prevent the threat of danger to the constitutional order in the Republic of Armenia and to protect the rights and lawful interests of the population, guided by point 14 of Article 55 and point 6 of Article 117 of the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "III. NOTICE OF DEROGATION OF 2 MARCH 2008 MADE BY ARMENIA TO THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Decree of the President of the Republic of Armenia No. NH-35-N established as a temporary limitation in the area under state of emergency the banning of meetings, rallies, demonstrations, marches and other mass events.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "III. NOTICE OF DEROGATION OF 2 MARCH 2008 MADE BY ARMENIA TO THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The Decree of the President of the Republic of Armenia No. NH-35-N came into force from the moment of its announcement.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "III. NOTICE OF DEROGATION OF 2 MARCH 2008 MADE BY ARMENIA TO THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F046", "F047", "F065", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025"], "interference": ["F031", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F062"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F063", "F064", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F070"], "necessity": ["F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F049", "F050", "F063", "F064", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F070", "F080", "F081", "F082", "F083"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F030", "F032", "F065", "F022", "F023"], "interference": ["F031", "F033", "F035", "F062"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F080", "F082", "F083", "F064", "F067", "F068", "F026", "F022", "F023", "F031", "F063", "F070"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F030", "F031", "F062", "F080", "F082", "F083", "F026", "F022", "F063", "F070"]}} {"case_name": "case_165", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The application concerns the conviction of the applicant under Articles 220 § 6 and 314 of the Turkish Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant was convicted on account of his participation in a demonstration held in Batman on 13 December 2009.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to six years and three months' imprisonment under Articles 220 § 6 and 314 of the Turkish Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant complains of a violation of his rights guaranteed by Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 13 December 2009 the applicant was taken into police custody.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 16 December 2009 the applicant was placed in pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant was placed in pre-trial detention on 16 December 2009 on suspicion of belonging to an illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 13 January 2010 the Batman public prosecutor issued an indictment charging the applicant with committing offenses in the name of an illegal organisation without being a member of it, under section 23(b) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 13 January 2010 the Batman public prosecutor issued an indictment charging the applicant with resisting the security forces by way of throwing stones, under section 33(c) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The charges in the indictment of 13 January 2010 were based on acts the applicant allegedly committed during demonstrations which took place on 12 and 13 December 2009.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 8 June 2010 the Diyarbakır Assize Court convicted the applicant of committing offenses in the name of an illegal organisation without being a member of it pursuant to Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code, on the basis of Articles 220 § 6 and 314 § 3 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court sentenced the applicant to six years and three months' imprisonment on 8 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found that there was no evidence in the case file in support of the allegation that the applicant threw stones at the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court concluded that the applicant's conduct constituted the offence prescribed by Section 32 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court sentenced the applicant to a total of one year and three months' imprisonment in respect of the Section 32 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) offence.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court decided to suspend the pronouncement of the judgment in respect of the Section 32 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) offence.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court convicted the applicant of membership of an illegal organisation on the basis that he was considered to have committed a crime on behalf of an illegal organisation and acted in breach of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court established that the applicant had taken part in the demonstration of 13 December 2009.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The demonstration of 13 December 2009 was allegedly organised by the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party, an illegal armed organisation).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court established that the applicant had been part of a group of demonstrators who chanted slogans in favour of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court established that the applicant had been part of a group of demonstrators who chanted slogans in favour of Abdullah Öcalan, the leader of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court acquitted the applicant of the charges regarding his participation in the demonstration of 12 December 2009.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court acquitted the applicant of the charges regarding throwing stones at police officers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 20 April 2011 the Court of Cassation upheld the judgment of the Diyarbakır Assize Court of 8 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 5 July 2012 Law no. 6352 entered into force.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Law no. 6352 amended various laws with a view to suspending proceedings and sentences given in cases concerning crimes committed through the press and media and similar expressions of opinions.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant submitted a request to benefit from Law no. 6352.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 2 August 2012 the Diyarbakır Assize Court, hearing the applicant's request to benefit from Law no. 6352, decided to reduce the sentence imposed on the applicant by half, taking into account the amendment made by Law no. 6352 to Article 220 § 6 of the Turkish Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 2 August 2012 the Diyarbakır Assize Court finally sentenced the applicant to imprisonment for a period of three years, one month and fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F005", "F006", "F011", "F018"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F005", "F006", "F011"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F001", "F011"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F018"], "interference": ["F002", "F011"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F001", "F011"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F018", "F002", "F011"]}} {"case_name": "case_166", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' dates of birth and places of residence are given in the appendix.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "At the material time some of the applicants held positions in opposition political parties or groups.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held on 31 July 2010 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held on 2 April 2011 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held on 17 April 2011 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 23 July 2010, the organisers of the 31 July 2010 demonstration, consisting of several members of the opposition, gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 18 March 2011, the organisers of the 2 April 2011 demonstration, consisting of several members of the opposition, gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 11 April 2011, the organisers of the 17 April 2011 demonstration, consisting of several members of the opposition, gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) refused to authorise the holding of the demonstration of 31 July 2010 at the places indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) proposed three alternative locations on the outskirts of Baku for the 31 July 2010 demonstration: a stadium in the Binagadi District, a square in the proximity of Zigh road in the Khatai District, and a yard of a driving school situated in the 20th residential area of the Sabail District.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) noted that the squares in one of which the organisers proposed to hold the 31 July 2010 assembly were designated for public leisure.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) noted that the other places proposed by the organisers for the 31 July 2010 demonstration were areas with heavy traffic.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) refused to authorise the holding of the demonstration of 2 April 2011 at the places indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) refused to authorise the holding of the demonstration of 17 April 2011 at the places indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "For both the 2 April 2011 and 17 April 2011 demonstrations, the Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) proposed a different location on the outskirts of Baku, namely the yard of a driving school situated in the 20th residential area of the Sabail District.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) noted that the places proposed by the organisers for the 2 April 2011 and 17 April 2011 demonstrations were areas with heavy traffic.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The organisers decided to hold the demonstrations in the centre of Baku, notwithstanding the Baku City Executive Authority's refusals to authorise the proposed locations.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the applicants, the demonstrations were intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the applicants, the demonstrations were conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The participants in the demonstrations were demanding free and fair elections in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The participants in the demonstrations were demanding democratic reforms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Participants in the demonstration of 17 April 2011 were also protesting against impediments to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Each applicant attended one of the demonstrations (as specified in the appendix).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Shortly after the demonstrations had begun, the police started to disperse them.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the official records, all the applicants were arrested during the dispersal operations.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the official records, all the applicants were taken to various police stations following their arrests.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicant in application no. 67351/11, he was arrested by people in plain clothes.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicants were questioned at the respective police stations.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On the day of the applicants' arrests, administrative offence reports (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) were issued in respect of each of the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The administrative offence reports stated that by deliberately failing to comply with lawful police orders, the applicants had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Some of the applicants refused to sign the respective administrative offence reports.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to most of the applicants in applications nos. 57737/11, 67351/11, 67977/11, 69411/11 and 69421/11, they were never served with copies of the administrative offence reports.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to most of the applicants in applications nos. 57737/11, 67351/11, 67977/11, 69411/11 and 69421/11, they were never served with other documents in their case files.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the applicant in application no. 57737/11, he obtained a copy of the administrative offence report several months after the administrative proceedings against him had ended.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "None of the applicants was given access to a lawyer after the arrest or while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. \"Administrative\" arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Each applicant was brought before a first-instance court on the day of the arrest or the following day.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to most of the applicants, the hearing before the court in each case was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "In some of the cases, members of the public were not allowed to attend the court hearings, even though the court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearing to the public.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to all the applicants, they were not given an opportunity to hire lawyers of their own choice.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "State-funded lawyers were appointed to represent most of the applicants before the first-instance courts.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicant in application no. 74609/10 was not assisted by a lawyer before the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicant in application no. 57737/11 was not assisted by a lawyer before the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The records of the respective court hearings show that the applicant in application no. 74609/10 refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and decided to defend himself in person.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The records of the respective court hearings show that the applicant in application no. 57737/11 refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and decided to defend himself in person.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The record of the hearing in the case of the applicant in application no. 69411/11 shows that the State-funded lawyer, in his oral submissions, briefly asked the court to be merciful and adopt a lenient decision.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In the case of the applicant in application no. 67351/11, the State-funded lawyer did not make any oral or written submissions before the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In the case of the applicant in application no. 67977/11, the State-funded lawyer did not make any oral or written submissions before the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "None of the material submitted to the Court in application no. 69421/11 contains any record showing that the State-funded lawyer, Ms R.N., made any oral or written submissions before the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The only witnesses questioned during the respective court hearings were the police officers who, according to the official records, had arrested the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In the case of the applicant in application no. 67977/11, a police officer who had issued the administrative offence report was also questioned as a witness.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "All the police officers questioned as witnesses testified that the applicants had staged unauthorised demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In application no. 67351/11, the court did not question any witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The respective first-instance courts found that the applicants had failed to stop participating in unauthorised demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The respective first-instance courts convicted the applicants under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The respective first-instance courts sentenced the applicants to periods of administrative detention ranging from seven to fifteen days, as specified in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On various dates, the applicants lodged appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal, arguing that their convictions were in violation of their rights because the demonstrations in which they had participated or attempted to participate had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicants complained before the Baku Court of Appeal that their arrests had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicants complained before the Baku Court of Appeal that the hearings before the respective first-instance courts had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicants asked the Baku Court of Appeal to quash the first-instance courts' decisions in their respective cases.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Most of the applicants were assisted before the Baku Court of Appeal by lawyers of their own choice.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The applicant in application no. 57737/11 was not represented by a lawyer before the Baku Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On various dates, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants' appeals and upheld the decisions of the respective first-instance courts, as specified in the appendix.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "According to the applicant in application no. 57737/11, on 28 February 2011, following his complaints about the authorities' failure to serve him with the relevant documents, the Sabail District Court sent him a copy of the administrative offence report issued in respect of him.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "According to the applicant in application no. 57737/11, on 28 February 2011, the Sabail District Court sent him the first-instance court's decision of 31 July 2010.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "According to the applicant in application no. 57737/11, on 28 February 2011, the Sabail District Court sent him the Baku Court of Appeal's decision of 20 August 2010.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "According to the applicant in application no. 69411/11, he received the Baku Court of Appeal's decision of 13 April 2011 on 15 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "According to the applicant in application no. 69411/11, he received the Baku Court of Appeal's decision of 13 April 2011 only after having complained about the court's failure to serve him with that decision.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "At the time of the applicants' arrests, Article 410.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 provided that an individual who is subject to administrative offence proceedings shall be given an opportunity to familiarise themselves with the administrative offence report.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "At the time of the applicants' arrests, Article 410.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 provided that an individual who is subject to administrative offence proceedings has the right to a copy of the administrative offence report.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "At the time of the applicants' arrests, Article 437.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 provided that a copy of a decision delivered on the basis of an appeal or a protest against a decision in an administrative offence case shall be given to the individual with respect to whom the decision was adopted within three days of its adoption.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "At the time of the applicants' arrests, Article 437.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 provided that a copy of a decision delivered on the basis of an appeal or a protest against a decision sentencing an individual to administrative detention shall be given to that individual on the day of its adoption.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "A summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, the relevant provisions concerning the organisation and holding of public assemblies, and the relevant extracts of international documents can be found in the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, paragraphs 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F054"], "interference": ["F024", "F025", "F054", "F055"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F009", "F013", "F014", "F030", "F053", "F054", "F072"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F018", "F019", "F023", "F024", "F053", "F054"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F017", "F018", "F019", "F023", "F024"], "interference": ["F024", "F054", "F055"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F013", "F030", "F072"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F007", "F018", "F019", "F024", "F053", "F054"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F007", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F023", "F024", "F054", "F055"]}} {"case_name": "case_167", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1962.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "At the material time, the applicant was deputy chairperson of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan was one of the main opposition parties in Azerbaijan at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 17 April 2011, the applicant participated in a demonstration organised by the opposition in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 26 January 2013, the applicant participated in a demonstration organised by the opposition in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 11 April 2011, the organisers of the demonstration of 17 April 2011 gave notice of the demonstration to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "No prior notice was given to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) by the organisers of the demonstration of 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Information about the demonstration of 26 January 2013 was disseminated through Facebook or the press.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) refused to authorise the demonstration of 17 April 2011 at the place indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) proposed a different location for the demonstration of 17 April 2011, namely the yard of a driving school situated in the 20th residential area of the Sabail District, on the outskirts of Baku.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) noted that the place proposed by the organisers for the demonstration of 17 April 2011 was in an area with heavy traffic.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The organisers decided to hold the demonstrations in the centre of Baku, notwithstanding the Baku City Executive Authority's refusal to authorise the demonstration of 17 April 2011 at the proposed location.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstrations of 17 April 2011 and 26 January 2013 were intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstrations of 17 April 2011 and 26 January 2013 were conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the applicant, the participants of the demonstration of 17 April 2011 were demanding free and fair elections and democratic reforms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the applicant, the participants of the demonstration of 17 April 2011 were protesting about impediments to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the applicant, the participants of the demonstration of 26 January 2013 were condemning the use of force by the police against participants of previous demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant attended the demonstration of 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant attended the demonstration of 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Shortly after the demonstration of 17 April 2011 had begun, the police started to disperse it.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Shortly after the demonstration of 26 January 2013 had begun, the police started to disperse it.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant was arrested during the dispersal operation of the demonstration of 17 April 2011 and taken to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant was arrested during the dispersal operation of the demonstration of 26 January 2013 and taken to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the applicant, during her arrest on 17 April 2011, several police officers twisted her arms behind her back.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the applicant, during her arrest on 17 April 2011, several police officers held her head down.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicant, during her arrest on 17 April 2011, several police officers forced her to move with her arms twisted behind her back and her head held down for 20-25 metres in the direction of a police car.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the applicant, as a result of the treatment during her arrest on 17 April 2011, the muscles in her neck, arms, back and other parts of her body hurt.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the applicant, at the police station following her arrest on 17 April 2011, she was kept handcuffed.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicant submitted to the Court a photograph allegedly taken at the time of her arrest on 17 April 2011, showing the applicant with both arms twisted behind her back by two police officers and with her body bent as a result of that restraint.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On the day of the applicant's arrest on 17 April 2011, an administrative offence report (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) was issued in respect of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On the day of the applicant's arrest on 26 January 2013, an administrative offence report (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) was issued in respect of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The administrative offence report issued on 17 April 2011 stated that by deliberately failing to comply with a lawful order from the police, the applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "In the second case (arrest of 26 January 2013), the applicant was charged with an administrative offence under Article 298.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, which concerns breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies by an assembly organiser.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "According to the applicant, she was never served with copies of the administrative offence reports from her case files in either the first case (17 April 2011) or the second case (26 January 2013).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to the applicant, she was never served with other documents from her case files in either the first case (17 April 2011) or the second case (26 January 2013).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the applicant, in neither the first case (17 April 2011) nor the second case (26 January 2013) was she given access to a lawyer after her arrest or while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "In the first case, the applicant was brought before the Nasimi District Court on 18 April 2011, the day following her arrest on 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "In the second case, the applicant was brought before the Sabail District Court on 26 January 2013, the day of her arrest.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing before the court in the first case (17 April 2011) was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing before the court in the second case (26 January 2013) was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to the applicant, in the second case (26 January 2013), members of the public were not allowed inside the courtroom, even though the court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearing to the public.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the applicant, in neither the first case (17 April 2011) nor the second case (26 January 2013) was she given an opportunity to hire a lawyer of her own choice.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "State-funded lawyers were appointed to assist the applicant in both the first case (17 April 2011) and the second case (26 January 2013).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The records of the court hearings in both the first case (17 April 2011) and the second case (26 January 2013) show that in their oral submissions the State-funded lawyers briefly stated that the applicant was not guilty.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The records of the court hearings in both the first case (17 April 2011) and the second case (26 January 2013) show that in their oral submissions the State-funded lawyers asked the respective court to discontinue the case.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In both the first case (17 April 2011) and the second case (26 January 2013), the courts questioned only the police officers who, according to the official records, had arrested the applicant or issued an administrative offence report in respect of her.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The police officers testified that the applicant had attempted to stage an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In the second case (26 January 2013), the police officers also testified that the applicant had incited others to participate in an unauthorised assembly.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In the first case (17 April 2011), the first-instance court found that the applicant had participated or attempted to participate in an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "In the second case (26 January 2013), the court found that the applicant had incited people to participate in an unlawful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In the second case (26 January 2013), the court found that the applicant had violated the rules on organising and holding assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "By a decision of 18 April 2011, the first-instance court in the first case convicted the applicant under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "By a decision of 18 April 2011, the first-instance court in the first case sentenced the applicant to five days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "By a decision of 26 January 2013, the court in the second case convicted the applicant under Article 298.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "By a decision of 26 January 2013, the court in the second case sentenced the applicant to a fine of 2,000 Azerbaijani manats (AZN).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On unspecified dates, the applicant lodged appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal in both the first case (17 April 2011) and the second case (26 January 2013).", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "In her appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant argued that her convictions were in violation of her rights because the demonstrations in which she had participated had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "In her appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant complained that her arrests had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "In her appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant complained that the hearings before the respective first-instance courts had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "In the first case (17 April 2011), the applicant requested the Baku Court of Appeal to order a forensic examination of the injuries she had allegedly sustained during her arrest.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal disregarded the applicant's request to order a forensic examination of the injuries she had allegedly sustained during her arrest on 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal disregarded the applicant's request to examine video recordings of her arrest on 17 April 2011 made by some journalists.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal disregarded the applicant's request to question the police officers appearing in the video recordings of her arrest on 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal disregarded the applicant's request to demand the medical record issued in respect of the applicant in the detention facility where she had served her administrative detention following her arrest on 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "In the first case (17 April 2011), the applicant was assisted before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer of her own choice.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "In the second case (26 January 2013), the applicant was not represented by a lawyer before the Baku Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 22 April 2011, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal in the first case and upheld the decision of the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 6 February 2013, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal in the second case and upheld the decision of the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On an unspecified date, the applicant lodged a complaint before the General Prosecutor's Office asking it to conduct an investigation into ill-treatment allegedly committed by the police during her arrest on 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's allegation of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "By a letter of 25 May 2011, the General Prosecutor's Office informed the applicant's lawyer that the applicant's complaint of ill-treatment had been forwarded to the Baku City prosecutor's office for examination.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's allegation of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The letter of 25 May 2011 from the General Prosecutor's Office instructed the Baku City prosecutor's office to inform the applicant's lawyer about the results of the examination of the complaint.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's allegation of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On an unspecified date, the applicant was summoned to the Nasimi District prosecutor's office and questioned in connection with her complaint of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's allegation of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "According to the applicant, neither she nor her lawyer was informed about any actions taken by the authorities to investigate her complaint of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's allegation of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "According to the applicant, it was only after making enquiries about the outcome of the investigation, in January 2012, that the applicant managed to obtain a copy of an investigator's decision of 16 June 2011 refusing to open a criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's allegation of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The applicant did not lodge a complaint with a court against the investigator's decision of 16 June 2011 refusing to open a criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's allegation of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "At the time of both of the applicant's arrests (17 April 2011 and 26 January 2013), under Article 5 § IV of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, no prior written notification was required for spontaneous assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 17 April 2011, Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 provided that any breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies, demonstrations, protests, marches and pickets shall be punishable by a reprimand or a fine of seven to thirteen Azerbaijani manats (AZN).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 17 April 2011, Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 provided that deliberate failure by an individual to comply with a lawful order of a police officer or military serviceman carrying out their duties to protect public order shall be punishable by a fine of twenty to twenty-five Azerbaijani manats (AZN) or, if that sanction is inadequate in the circumstances of the case and taking into account the character of the offender, by administrative detention for a term of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 17 April 2011, Article 410.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 provided that an individual who is subject to administrative offence proceedings shall be given an opportunity to familiarise themselves with the administrative offence report.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 17 April 2011, Article 410.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 provided that an individual who is subject to administrative offence proceedings has the right to a copy of the administrative offence report.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 entered into force on 1 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced new wording to Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences concerning breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Under the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, participation in an assembly organised in breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies became explicitly punishable under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced for the first time a punishment in the form of administrative detention of up to fifteen days for breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced community service as a new form of punishment for breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 increased the fine for breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies, fixing the amounts as follows: between AZN 300 and 600 for participants of an assembly; between AZN 1,500 and 3,000 for individuals who organise an assembly; between AZN 3,000 and 6,000 for persons in charge (vəzifəli şəxslər) who organise an assembly; and between AZN 15,000 and 30,000 for legal entities involved in the organisation of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Law no. 457-IVQD of 2 November 2012 entered into force on 29 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Law no. 457-IVQD of 2 November 2012 increased the fine set out in Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences to AZN 200.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "According to presidential Order (sərəncam) no. 1866 of 1 December 2011, which was in force until 1 September 2013, the minimum wage in Azerbaijan was AZN 93.5.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, titled 'The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan', stated that there is no political dialogue with the opposition parties outside parliament in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the Parliamentary Assembly is concerned by the restrictive climate for the activities of the extra-parliamentary opposition in Azerbaijan, which complains about limitations imposed on freedom of expression and freedom of assembly and the lack of access to the public media.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the establishment of an inclusive political system and a truly competitive and unrestrictive political environment requires full implementation of basic freedoms, including freedom of expression, freedom of assembly and freedom of association.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the situation in Azerbaijan regarding basic freedoms is preoccupying and expressed deep concern in that regard.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that recently adopted amendments to the Criminal Code and the Administrative Code of Azerbaijan, which increased penalties for the organisers of and participants in 'unauthorised' gatherings, raise concern.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that, considering the authorities' ongoing blanket ban on protests in the Baku city centre, the amendments increasing penalties for organisers of and participants in 'unauthorised' gatherings are likely to have a further negative impact on freedom of assembly and freedom of expression in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the restrictive use of certain articles of the Criminal Code of Azerbaijan, in particular Articles 221 and 233, against participants in peaceful, albeit unauthorised, demonstrations, is a matter of concern.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 was produced by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 stated that the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe is deeply concerned by the recent amendments to the Law on Freedom of Assembly, the Criminal Code and the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan, which further erode the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 stated that the sanctions which can now be imposed in Azerbaijan, coupled with the fact that local authorities have not authorised a single rally in Baku city centre in recent years, clearly have a chilling effect on the organisation of or participation in demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 stated that the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe is of the view that participants in peaceful assemblies should not be sanctioned for the mere fact of being present at and actively participating in the demonstration in question, provided they do not do anything illegal, violent or obscene in the course of it.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 stated that the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe urges the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure that no disproportionate sanction, which would undermine the fundamental right to peaceful assembly, is imposed.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "A summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, relevant provisions concerning the organisation and holding of public assemblies, and relevant extracts of international documents can be found in the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, paragraphs 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["national_security", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F005", "F006", "F014", "F015", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024"], "interference": ["F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F053", "F054", "F055", "F056"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F013", "F033", "F053", "F077", "F079"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F007", "F014", "F015", "F021", "F022", "F053", "F054", "F055", "F056", "F087", "F090", "F095", "F096", "F100"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F005", "F006", "F014", "F015", "F019", "F020"], "interference": ["F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F053", "F055"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F007", "F008", "F033", "F077", "F079"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F007", "F014", "F015", "F021", "F022", "F053", "F054", "F055", "F056", "F090"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F005", "F006", "F007", "F014", "F015", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F053", "F054", "F055", "F056", "F090"]}} {"case_name": "case_169", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1988.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The opposition planned to hold a demonstration on 12 January 2013 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The opposition planned to hold a demonstration on 26 January 2013 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "No prior notice was given to the Baku City Executive Authority by the organisers of the demonstration planned for 12 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "No prior notice was given to the Baku City Executive Authority by the organisers of the demonstration planned for 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority was the relevant authority to receive prior notice of demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Information about the demonstrations was disseminated through Facebook or the press.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstrations were intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstrations were conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "According to the applicant, the participants in the demonstration of 12 January 2013 were drawing the public's attention to the deaths of soldiers in the army.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "According to the applicant, the participants in the demonstration of 26 January 2013 were condemning the use of force by the police against those who had participated in previous demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant attended the demonstration of 12 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant attended the demonstration of 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Shortly after the demonstration of 12 January 2013 had begun, the police started to disperse the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Shortly after the demonstration of 26 January 2013 had begun, the police started to disperse the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant was arrested during the dispersal operation of the demonstration of 12 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant was arrested during the dispersal operation of the demonstration of 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Following his arrest on 12 January 2013, the applicant was taken to a police station where he was questioned.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Following his arrest on 26 January 2013, the applicant was taken to a police station where he was questioned.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On the day of the applicant's arrest on 12 January 2013, an administrative-offence report (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) was issued in respect of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On the day of the applicant's arrest on 26 January 2013, an administrative-offence report (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) was issued in respect of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The administrative-offence report issued on 12 January 2013 stated that the applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences (participation in a public assembly that had not been organised in accordance with the law).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The administrative-offence report issued on 26 January 2013 stated that the applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences (participation in a public assembly that had not been organised in accordance with the law).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with a copy of the administrative-offence report relating to his arrest on 12 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with a copy of the administrative-offence report relating to his arrest on 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with other documents in his case file relating to his arrest on 12 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with other documents in his case file relating to his arrest on 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the applicant, he was not given access to a lawyer after his arrest on 12 January 2013 or while in police custody following that arrest.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the applicant, he was not given access to a lawyer after his arrest on 26 January 2013 or while in police custody following that arrest.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "A statement (ərizə) was written by the applicant on 12 January 2013 at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The statement written by the applicant on 12 January 2013 at the police station was submitted to the Court by the Government.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The statement written by the applicant on 12 January 2013 at the police station showed that the applicant had declared that he would defend himself in person in the first case.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "A statement was written by the applicant on 26 January 2013 at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The statement written by the applicant on 26 January 2013 at the police station was submitted to the Court by the Government.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The statement written by the applicant on 26 January 2013 at the police station showed that the applicant had declared that he did not need a lawyer because of his financial situation in the second case.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "In the first case (arrest of 12 January 2013), after having been held for a few hours in police custody, the applicant was released.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "In the first case (arrest of 12 January 2013), the applicant's release was subject to an undertaking to reappear at the police station on 14 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "In the first case (arrest of 12 January 2013), the applicant was brought before the Nasimi District Court on 14 January 2013, the day he reappeared at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "In the second case (arrest of 26 January 2013), the applicant was brought before the Nasimi District Court on 26 January 2013, the day of his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing before the Nasimi District Court in the first case was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing before the Nasimi District Court in the second case was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the applicant, members of the public were not allowed to attend the hearing in the first case before the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the applicant, members of the public were not allowed to attend the hearing in the second case before the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the applicant, the Nasimi District Court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearing to the public in either case.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to the applicant, in the first case he was not given an opportunity to hire a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to the applicant, in the second case he was not given an opportunity to hire a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "A statement was signed by the applicant on 14 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The statement signed by the applicant on 14 January 2013 was submitted to the Court by the Government.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The statement signed by the applicant on 14 January 2013 showed that the applicant had declared that he did not need legal assistance and would defend himself in person in the first case.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "At the court hearing in the second case before the Nasimi District Court, a State-funded lawyer was appointed to assist the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The record of the court hearing in the second case before the Nasimi District Court shows that the State-funded lawyer made oral submissions.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "In his oral submissions at the second case hearing, the State-funded lawyer briefly stated that there had been elements of the administrative offence in the applicant's actions.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In his oral submissions at the second case hearing, the State-funded lawyer asked the Nasimi District Court to adopt a fair decision.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In the first case, the Nasimi District Court questioned police officers who had participated in the dispersal operation of 12 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "In the first case, the Nasimi District Court questioned police officers who had prepared the administrative-offence report against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In the second case, the Nasimi District Court questioned police officers who had participated in the dispersal operation of 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "In the second case, the Nasimi District Court questioned police officers who had prepared the administrative-offence report against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The police officers testified that the applicant had staged an unauthorised demonstration in the first case.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The police officers testified that the applicant had staged an unauthorised demonstration in the second case.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "In the first case, the Nasimi District Court found that the applicant had participated in an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "In the second case, the Nasimi District Court found that the applicant had participated in an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "By decision of 14 January 2013, the Nasimi District Court convicted the applicant under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences in the first case.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "By decision of 26 January 2013, the Nasimi District Court convicted the applicant under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences in the second case.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "In the first case, the Nasimi District Court sentenced the applicant to a fine of 500 Azerbaijani manats (AZN).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "In the second case, the Nasimi District Court sentenced the applicant to a fine of AZN 400.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On unspecified dates the applicant lodged appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal against his conviction in the first case.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On unspecified dates the applicant lodged appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal against his conviction in the second case.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "In his appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant argued that his convictions were in violation of his rights because the demonstrations in which he had participated had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "In his appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant complained that his arrests had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "In his appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant complained that the hearings before the respective first-instance courts had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "In the first case, the applicant was not represented before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "At the appellate court hearing in the second case before the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant was represented by the same State-funded lawyer who had represented him before the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "In the first case, on 25 January 2013, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal and upheld the decision of the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "In the second case, on 6 February 2013, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal and upheld the decision of the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "At the time of both of the applicant's arrests, under Article 5 § IV of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, no prior written notification was required for spontaneous assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Before the amendments introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, which entered into force on 1 January 2013, any breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies was punishable under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 by a reprimand or a fine of AZN 7 to 13.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 entered into force on 1 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "Both of the applicant's arrests occurred after the amendments introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 were enacted.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrests, Article 298.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that any breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies, demonstrations, protests, marches and pickets by an organiser of an assembly who is an individual shall be punished by a fine of AZN 1,500 to 3,000; or, depending on the circumstances of the case and the personality of the perpetrator of the offence, by community service for 200 to 240 hours or administrative detention for up to 15 days.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrests, Article 298.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that a person in charge shall be punished by a fine of AZN 3,000 to 6,000.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrests, Article 298.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that a legal entity shall be punished by a fine of AZN 15,000 to 30,000.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrests, Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that participation in an assembly, a demonstration, a protest, a march or a picket which was not organised in accordance with the rules set forth under the legislation shall be punishable by a fine of AZN 300 to 600; or, depending on the circumstances of the case and the personality of the perpetrator of the offence, by community service for 160 to 200 hours or administrative detention for up to 15 days.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Note to Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that if there are elements of a crime in actions proscribed under Articles 298.1 and 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences, the perpetrator of those actions bears criminal responsibility under the relevant Articles of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "According to presidential Order (sərəncam) no. 1866 of 1 December 2011, the minimum wage in Azerbaijan was AZN 93.5.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Presidential Order no. 1866 of 1 December 2011 was in force until 1 September 2013.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, titled 'The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan', stated that there is no political dialogue with the opposition parties outside parliament in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about the restrictive climate for the activities of the extra-parliamentary opposition in Azerbaijan, which complains about limitations imposed on freedom of expression and freedom of assembly and the lack of access to the public media.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the establishment of an inclusive political system and a truly competitive and unrestrictive political environment requires full implementation of basic freedoms, including freedom of expression, freedom of assembly and freedom of association.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed deep concern about the situation regarding basic freedoms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about recently adopted amendments to the Criminal Code and the Administrative Code of Azerbaijan, which increased penalties for the organisers of, and participants in, 'unauthorised' gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that, considering the authorities' ongoing blanket ban on protests in the Baku city centre, the amendments to the Criminal Code and the Administrative Code are likely to have a further negative impact on freedom of assembly and freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about the restrictive use of certain articles of the Criminal Code of Azerbaijan, in particular Articles 221 and 233, against participants in peaceful, albeit unauthorised, demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Nils Muižnieks was the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe at the time of Report CommDH(2013)14.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Nils Muižnieks visited Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Report CommDH(2013)14 by Nils Muižnieks, Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, was issued on 6 August 2013 following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Report CommDH(2013)14 stated that the Commissioner is deeply concerned by the recent amendments to the Law on Freedom of Assembly, the Criminal Code and the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan, which further erode the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Report CommDH(2013)14 stated that the sanctions which can now be imposed, coupled with the fact that local authorities have not authorised a single rally in Baku city centre in recent years, clearly have a chilling effect on the organisation of or participation in demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Report CommDH(2013)14 stated that the Commissioner is of the view that participants in peaceful assemblies should not be sanctioned for the mere fact of being present at and actively participating in the demonstration in question, provided they do not do anything illegal, violent or obscene in the course of it.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "Report CommDH(2013)14 stated that the Commissioner urges the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure that no disproportionate sanction, which would undermine the fundamental right to peaceful assembly, is imposed.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, relevant provisions concerning the organisation and holding of public assemblies, and relevant extracts of international documents are summarised in the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, paragraphs 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied", "aims": ["national_security", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F005", "F006", "F007", "F013", "F014", "F017", "F018", "F063", "F064", "F009", "F010"], "interference": ["F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F063", "F064", "F083", "F091", "F092", "F098"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F005", "F006", "F007", "F076", "F011"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F101", "F015", "F016", "F009", "F010", "F061", "F062", "F063", "F064", "F017", "F018", "F083", "F091", "F092", "F098"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F013", "F014", "F009", "F010"], "interference": ["F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F063", "F064"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F005", "F006", "F076", "F011"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F009", "F010", "F015", "F016", "F063", "F064", "F083", "F092"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F013", "F014", "F009", "F010", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F063", "F064", "F076", "F083"]}} {"case_name": "case_170", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The public assemblies in question were manifestations for fair elections to the Mosgorduma (Moscow City Duma).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention in addition to their complaint about disproportionate measures.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_171", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants are a group of individuals and the Foundation for Equality.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The first applicant is a member of the executive committee of the Foundation for Equality and is empowered to act on its behalf in the present case.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants wished to hold an assembly (a march) in Warsaw within the framework of Equality Days organised by the Foundation for Equality, planned for 10-12 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The purpose of the planned march in Warsaw was to alert public opinion to the issue of discrimination against minorities – sexual, national, ethnic and religious – and also against women and disabled persons.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 10 May 2005 the organisers held a meeting with the Director of the Safety and Crisis Management Unit of Warsaw City Council.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "During the meeting on 10 May 2005 between the organisers and the Director of the Safety and Crisis Management Unit of Warsaw City Council, an initial agreement was reached as to the itinerary of the planned march.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 11 May 2005 Mr Bączkowski obtained an instruction of the Warsaw Mayor's Office on requirements which organisers of public assemblies have to comply with under the Road Traffic Act, applicable should the assembly be regarded as an 'event' (impreza) within the meaning of Article 65 of the Road Traffic Act.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 12 May 2005 the organisers applied to the City Council Road Traffic Office for permission to organise the march.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The itinerary of the planned march would lead from the Parliament buildings (Sejm) to Assembly Square (Plac Defilad) in the centre of Warsaw.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 3 June 2005 the Traffic Officer, acting on behalf of the Mayor of Warsaw, refused permission for the march.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Traffic Officer's refusal of permission for the march on 3 June 2005 was based on the organisers' failure to submit a 'traffic organisation plan' ('projekt organizacji ruchu') within the meaning of Article 65(a) of the Road Traffic Act.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Traffic Officer alleged that the organisers had been ordered to submit a 'traffic organisation plan' ('projekt organizacji ruchu') prior to the refusal of 3 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 3 June 2005 the applicants informed the Mayor of Warsaw about stationary assemblies they intended to hold on 11 June 2005 in seven different squares in Warsaw.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Four of the seven planned stationary assemblies on 11 June 2005 were intended to protest about discrimination against various minorities and to support actions of groups and organisations combating discrimination.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Three of the seven planned stationary assemblies on 11 June 2005 were intended to protest about discrimination against women.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 9 June 2005 the Mayor of Warsaw issued decisions banning the stationary assemblies to be organised by Mr Bączkowski, Mr Biedroń, Mr Kliszczyński, Ms Kostrzewa, Mr Szypuła, and Mr N. (who is not an applicant).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Mr Bączkowski, Mr Biedroń, Mr Kliszczyński, Ms Kostrzewa, Mr Szypuła, and Mr N. are active in various non-governmental organisations acting for the benefit of persons of homosexual orientation.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In his decision of 9 June 2005 banning the stationary assemblies, the Mayor of Warsaw relied on the argument that assemblies held under the provisions of the 1990 Assemblies Act (Ustawa o zgromadzeniach) had to be organised away from roads used for road traffic.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "In his decision of 9 June 2005, the Mayor of Warsaw stated that if assemblies were to use roads, more stringent requirements applied.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The organisers of the stationary assemblies wished to use cars carrying loudspeakers.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The organisers had failed to indicate where and how the cars carrying loudspeakers would park during the assemblies so as not to disturb traffic.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The organisers had failed to indicate how the movement of persons and cars between the assembly sites would be organised.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "A number of requests had been submitted to organise other assemblies on 11 June 2005, the tenor of which ran counter to the ideas and intentions of the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Mayor of Warsaw refused permission for the applicants' stationary assemblies in part to avoid possible violent clashes between participants in the various demonstrations planned for 11 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 9 June 2005 the municipal authorities, acting on the Mayor of Warsaw's behalf, allowed the three planned stationary assemblies concerning discrimination against women to be held as requested by the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 9 June 2005 the municipal authorities, acting on the Mayor of Warsaw's behalf, permitted six other demonstrations to be held on 11 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The six other demonstrations permitted on 9 June 2005 to be held on 11 June 2005 had the following themes: 'For more stringent measures against persons convicted of paedophilia', 'Against any legislative work on the law on partnerships', 'Against propaganda for partnerships', 'Education in Christian values, a guarantee of a moral society', 'Christians respecting God's and nature's laws are citizens of the first rank', and 'Against adoption of children by homosexual couples'.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Preparation of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 11 June 2005, despite the decision of 3 June 2005 refusing permission, the march took place.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Meetings held on 11 June 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The march on 11 June 2005 followed the itinerary as planned in the original request of 12 May 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Meetings held on 11 June 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The march on 11 June 2005 was attended by approximately 3,000 people.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Meetings held on 11 June 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The march on 11 June 2005 was protected by the police.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Meetings held on 11 June 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 11 June 2005, nine stationary assemblies were held in addition to the march, under permission granted by the Mayor of Warsaw on 9 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Meetings held on 11 June 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 28 June 2005 the applicant Foundation for Equality appealed to the Local Government Appeals Board against the decision of 3 June 2005 refusing permission for the march.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "a) The march"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "In its appeal of 28 June 2005, the applicant Foundation for Equality argued that the requirement to submit a 'traffic organisation plan' lacked any legal basis.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "a) The march"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "In its appeal of 28 June 2005, the applicant Foundation for Equality argued that the applicants had never been requested to submit a 'traffic organisation plan' prior to the refusal of 3 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "a) The march"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "In its appeal of 28 June 2005, the applicant Foundation for Equality argued that the decision of 3 June 2005 amounted to an unwarranted restriction of freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "a) The march"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "In its appeal of 28 June 2005, the applicant Foundation for Equality argued that the decision of 3 June 2005 had been dictated by ideological reasons incompatible with the tenets of democracy.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "a) The march"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 22 August 2005 the Local Government Appeals Board quashed the decision of 3 June 2005 refusing permission for the march, finding that it was unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "a) The march"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Local Government Appeals Board observed that under the applicable provisions of administrative procedure the authorities were obliged to ensure that parties to administrative proceedings had an opportunity of effectively participating in them.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "a) The march"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Local Government Appeals Board found that the obligation to ensure effective participation in administrative proceedings had not been respected in the applicant Foundation for Equality's case, in that the case file contained no evidence that the applicant Foundation for Equality had been informed of its procedural right to have access to the case file.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "a) The march"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Local Government Appeals Board found that the first-instance authority's decision of 3 June 2005 referred to the absence of a traffic organisation plan in the case file, but that the case file contained no mention that the organisers had been obliged to submit such a plan.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "a) The march"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Local Government Appeals Board found that the document on the procedure for obtaining permission to organise an event which was served on the organisers contained no information on the obligation to submit a traffic organisation plan.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "a) The march"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Local Government Appeals Board noted that the organisers' request concerned a march to be held on 11 June 2005 and that the appeal was received by the Board's Office together with the case file on 28 June 2005, by which date the proceedings had already become devoid of purpose.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "a) The march"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 10 June 2005 the applicants appealed to the Mazowsze Governor against the Mayor of Warsaw's refusals of 9 June 2005 of permission to hold several of the planned stationary assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "In their appeal of 10 June 2005, the applicants argued that the assemblies were to be entirely peaceful and that banning them breached their freedom of assembly guaranteed by the Constitution.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In their appeal of 10 June 2005, the applicants submitted that the assemblies did not pose any threat to either public order or morals.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In their appeal of 10 June 2005, the applicants contested the argument relied on in the Mayor of Warsaw's decision that they were required to submit a document on the planned itinerary between the places where the assemblies were to be held.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "In their appeal of 10 June 2005, the applicants argued that they only intended to organise stationary assemblies, not any movement of persons between them, and that they should not be held responsible for the organisation or supervision of such movement.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 17 June 2005 the Mazowsze Governor quashed the Mayor of Warsaw's refusals of 9 June 2005 of authorisation to hold the stationary assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Mazowsze Governor observed that the Mayor of Warsaw's decisions of 9 June 2005 breached the law in that the parties had been served only with copies of the decisions, not with originals as required by the law on administrative procedure.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Mazowsze Governor noted that the Mayor of Warsaw had informed the media of his decisions of 9 June 2005 before they had been served on the applicants, which was manifestly in breach of the principles of administrative procedure.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Mazowsze Governor observed that the 1990 Assemblies Act was a guarantee of freedom of assembly in respect of both the organisation of and participation in assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Mazowsze Governor observed that the Constitution clearly guaranteed freedom of assembly, not a right, and that it was not for the State to create a right to assembly; its obligation was limited to ensuring that assemblies were held peacefully.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Mazowsze Governor observed that the applicable law did not provide for any permit for the holding of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Mazowsze Governor noted that the requirement to submit a permit to occupy a part of the road, based on the provisions of the Road Traffic Act, lacked any legal basis in the provisions of the 1990 Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Mazowsze Governor noted that the Mayor of Warsaw had assumed that the demonstration would occupy a part of the road, but had failed to take any steps to clarify whether this had really been the organisers' intention, which he was obliged to do by law.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Mazowsze Governor observed that a decision banning an assembly had to be regarded as a method of last resort because it radically restricted freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Mazowsze Governor observed that the principle of proportionality required that any restriction of constitutionally protected freedoms be permitted only in so far as it was dictated by the concrete circumstances of a particular case.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Mazowsze Governor noted that the Mayor of Warsaw's reliance on the threat of violence between the demonstrations organised by the applicants and the counter-demonstrations planned by other persons and organisations for 11 June 2005 could not be countenanced.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Mazowsze Governor stated that the Mayor of Warsaw's reliance on the threat of violence was tantamount to the administration endorsing the intentions of organisations which clearly and deliberately intended to breach public order.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Mazowsze Governor stated that protecting the freedom of expression guaranteed by the 1990 Assemblies Act should be an essential task of the public powers.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Mazowsze Governor discontinued the proceedings concerning the stationary assemblies as they had become devoid of purpose, the assemblies having taken place on 11 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Appeal proceedings", "b) The assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In an interview published in 'Gazeta Wyborcza' on 20 May 2005, E. Siedlecka asked the Mayor of Warsaw whether the organisers of the march had written anything in their application indicating a danger to life or limb or a major danger to property, as required under the Assemblies Act for a restriction of freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Translation of an interview with the Mayor of Warsaw published in \"Gazeta Wyborcza\" on 20 May 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "In the interview published in 'Gazeta Wyborcza' on 20 May 2005, the Mayor of Warsaw stated that he had not read the organisers' application.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Translation of an interview with the Mayor of Warsaw published in \"Gazeta Wyborcza\" on 20 May 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "In the interview published in 'Gazeta Wyborcza' on 20 May 2005, the Mayor of Warsaw stated that he would ban the demonstration regardless of what the organisers had written in their application.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Translation of an interview with the Mayor of Warsaw published in \"Gazeta Wyborcza\" on 20 May 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "In the interview published in 'Gazeta Wyborcza' on 20 May 2005, the Mayor of Warsaw stated that he was not for discrimination on the ground of sexual orientation, for example by ruining people's professional careers, but that there would be no public propaganda about homosexuality.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Translation of an interview with the Mayor of Warsaw published in \"Gazeta Wyborcza\" on 20 May 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "In the interview published in 'Gazeta Wyborcza' on 20 May 2005, E. Siedlecka stated that the Mayor of Warsaw was engaging in discrimination by making it impossible for people to use their freedom only because of their particular sexual orientation.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Translation of an interview with the Mayor of Warsaw published in \"Gazeta Wyborcza\" on 20 May 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "In the interview published in 'Gazeta Wyborcza' on 20 May 2005, the Mayor of Warsaw stated that he did not forbid the organisers to demonstrate if they wanted to demonstrate as citizens, not as homosexuals.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Translation of an interview with the Mayor of Warsaw published in \"Gazeta Wyborcza\" on 20 May 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "In the interview published in 'Gazeta Wyborcza' on 20 May 2005, E. Siedlecka suggested that, as in the previous year, the Mazowsze Governor would quash the Mayor of Warsaw's prohibition, and that if the organisers appealed to the administrative court they would win because preventive restrictions on freedom of assembly are unlawful, but that the appeal proceedings would last some time and the date for which the march was planned would pass.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Translation of an interview with the Mayor of Warsaw published in \"Gazeta Wyborcza\" on 20 May 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "In the interview published in 'Gazeta Wyborcza' on 20 May 2005, the Mayor of Warsaw stated that he would not let himself be persuaded to give permission for such a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Translation of an interview with the Mayor of Warsaw published in \"Gazeta Wyborcza\" on 20 May 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "In the interview published in 'Gazeta Wyborcza' on 20 May 2005, the Mayor of Warsaw stated that in his view propaganda about homosexuality was not the same as exercising one's freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Translation of an interview with the Mayor of Warsaw published in \"Gazeta Wyborcza\" on 20 May 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Article 57 of the Polish Constitution provides that freedom of peaceful assembly and participation in such assemblies shall be ensured to everyone, and that limitations upon such freedoms may be imposed by statute.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "1. Relevant provisions of the Constitution"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Article 79 § 1 of the Polish Constitution entered into force on 17 October 1997.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "1. Relevant provisions of the Constitution"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Article 79 § 1 of the Polish Constitution provides that everyone whose constitutional freedoms or rights have been infringed shall have the right to appeal to the Constitutional Court for a judgment on the conformity with the Constitution of a statute or other normative act on the basis of which a court or an administrative authority has issued a final decision on his freedoms or rights or on his obligations specified in the Constitution, in accordance with principles specified by statute.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "1. Relevant provisions of the Constitution"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Article 190 § 1 of the Polish Constitution provides that judgments of the Constitutional Court shall be universally binding and final.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "1. Relevant provisions of the Constitution"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Article 190 § 2 of the Polish Constitution provides that judgments of the Constitutional Court shall be published without delay.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "1. Relevant provisions of the Constitution"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Article 190 § 3 of the Polish Constitution provides that a judgment of the Constitutional Court shall take effect from the day of its publication, but that the Constitutional Court may specify another date for the end of the binding force of a normative act, with such time-limit not exceeding 18 months in relation to a statute or 12 months in relation to any other normative act.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "1. Relevant provisions of the Constitution"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Pursuant to section 1 of the 1990 Assemblies Act, everyone has the right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "2. The Assemblies Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "Under section 1 of the 1990 Assemblies Act, a gathering of at least fifteen persons, called in order to participate in a public debate or to express an opinion on a given issue, is to be regarded as an assembly within the meaning of the Act.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "2. The Assemblies Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "Under section 2 of the 1990 Assemblies Act, freedom of assembly can be restricted only by statute and where it is necessary for the protection of national security or public safety, for the protection of health or morals, or for the protection of the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "2. The Assemblies Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Under the 1990 Assemblies Act, all decisions concerning the exercise of freedom of assembly must be taken by the local authorities in the municipality where the assembly is to be held.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "2. The Assemblies Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Under the 1990 Assemblies Act, decisions concerning the exercise of freedom of assembly can be appealed against to the Governor.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "2. The Assemblies Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Under section 3 of the 1990 Assemblies Act, the municipality must be informed by the organisers of the intention to hold a public gathering in the open air for an indeterminate number of persons.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "2. The Assemblies Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Under section 7 of the 1990 Assemblies Act, information about a planned public gathering must be submitted to the municipality not earlier than thirty days before the planned date of the demonstration and not later than three days before it.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "2. The Assemblies Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Under section 7 of the 1990 Assemblies Act, the information submitted to the municipality must include the names and addresses of the organisers, the aim and programme of the demonstration, its place, date and time, and information about the itinerary if the demonstration is intended to proceed from one place to another.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "2. The Assemblies Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Pursuant to section 8 of the 1990 Assemblies Act, the municipality shall refuse permission for a demonstration if its purpose is in breach of the 1990 Assemblies Act itself or of provisions of the Criminal Code, or if the demonstration might entail a danger to life or limb, or a major danger to property.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "2. The Assemblies Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Under the 1990 Assemblies Act, a first-instance refusal of permission to hold a demonstration must be served on the organisers within three days of the date on which the relevant request was submitted and not later than three days before the planned date of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "2. The Assemblies Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Under the 1990 Assemblies Act, an appeal against a first-instance refusal of permission to hold a demonstration must be lodged within three days of the date of its service.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "2. The Assemblies Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Under the 1990 Assemblies Act, the lodging of an appeal against a refusal of permission to hold a demonstration does not have a suspensive effect on the refusal.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "2. The Assemblies Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Under the 1990 Assemblies Act, a decision given by the appellate authority must be served on the organisers within three days of the date on which the appeal was submitted.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "2. The Assemblies Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Under section 65 of the Road Traffic Act of 1997, as amended in 2003, the organisers of sporting events, contests, assemblies and other events which may obstruct road traffic are obliged to obtain permission for the organisation of such assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "3. The Road Traffic Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Under section 65 read together with section 65(a) of the Road Traffic Act of 1997, as amended in 2003, organisers of events which may obstruct road traffic are obliged to comply with various administrative obligations specified in a list contained in section 65(a), numbering nineteen items, including the obligation to submit a traffic organisation plan to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "3. The Road Traffic Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The provisions of sections 65 and 65(a) of the Road Traffic Act of 1997, as amended in 2003, were repealed as a result of the judgment of the Constitutional Court of 18 January 2006.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "3. The Road Traffic Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "In its judgment of 18 January 2006, the Constitutional Court examined a request submitted by the Ombudsman to determine whether the requirements imposed on organisers of public events by the provisions of the Road Traffic Act were compatible with the Constitution in so far as they impinged on freedom of assembly, or whether they amounted to an excessive limitation of that freedom.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "4. Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 18 January 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Constitutional Court observed that the essence of the constitutional problem was whether the requirements imposed by section 65 of the Road Traffic Act were compatible with freedom of expression as formulated by the Constitution and developed by the 1990 Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "4. Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 18 January 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Constitutional Court noted that the 1990 Assemblies Act was based on the premise that the exercise of freedom of assembly did not require any authorisations or licences issued by the State.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "4. Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 18 January 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Constitutional Court noted that freedom of assembly being a freedom meant the State was obliged to refrain from hindering its exercise and to ensure that it was enjoyed by various groups despite the fact that their views might not be shared by the majority.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "4. Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 18 January 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Constitutional Court observed that the 1990 Assemblies Act provided for a system based on nothing more than the registration of the proposed assembly.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "4. Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 18 January 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Constitutional Court observed that when the legislature enacted the Road Traffic Act, it incorporated various administrative requirements which were difficult to comply with into the procedure created for the organisation of sporting events, contests and assemblies, thus replacing the registration system by a system based on permission.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "4. Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 18 January 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Constitutional Court observed that the Road Traffic Act placed assemblies within the meaning of the 1990 Assemblies Act on a par with events of a commercial character or organised for entertainment purposes.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "4. Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 18 January 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Constitutional Court found that placing assemblies on a par with commercial or entertainment events was incompatible with the special position that freedom of expression occupied in a democratic society and rendered nugatory the special place that assemblies had in the legal system under the Constitution and the 1990 Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "4. Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 18 January 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Constitutional Court noted that the list of requirements imposed by the Road Traffic Act contained as many as nineteen sundry administrative obligations.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "4. Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 18 January 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Constitutional Court found that the restrictions on freedom of assembly imposed by the Road Traffic Act were in breach of the requirement of proportionality applicable to all restrictions imposed on the rights guaranteed by the Constitution.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "4. Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 18 January 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Constitutional Court concluded in its judgment of 18 January 2006 that section 65 of the Road Traffic Act was incompatible with the Constitution in so far as it applied to assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "4. Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 18 January 2006"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F013", "F010", "F016", "F028", "F032", "F030"], "interference": ["F010", "F016", "F028", "F032", "F023", "F024", "F038", "F049"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F038", "F041", "F042", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F055", "F056", "F094", "F103", "F104", "F093", "F077"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": ["F004", "F014", "F017"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F013", "F028", "F032"], "interference": ["F010", "F016", "F028", "F038", "F049"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F038", "F041", "F049", "F055", "F103", "F104", "F093"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": ["F004", "F017"]}, "list3": ["F010", "F016", "F028", "F038", "F041", "F049", "F055", "F103", "F104"]}} {"case_name": "case_172", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_175", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant (Ms Belan) was born in 1961.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) was born in 1949.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The first applicant (Ms Belan) lives in Rostov-on-Don.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) lives in Rostov-on-Don.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 3 September 2012 the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) and Ms T. notified the local authority of their intention to hold a public assembly from 4 to 5 p.m. on 15 September 2012 in Sovetov Square in Rostov-on-Don.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) and Ms T. indicated that the assembly would otherwise be held in front of the Lenin monument at the entrance to Gorkiy Park.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The first applicant (Ms Belan) intended to take part in the public event planned for 15 September 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 5 September 2012 the local authority suggested that the public event should instead be held from 9.30 to 10.30 a.m. in the square in front of the City Library.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 6 September 2012 the event organisers dismissed the local authority's suggestion of holding the event in the square in front of the City Library as unsuitable for the purposes of their assembly.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 12 September 2012 the local authority insisted on their suggestion of holding the event in the square in front of the City Library.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 12 September 2012 the local authority refused to make another suggestion for an alternative venue because large-scale festive events were due to take place in Rostov-on-Don on 15 September 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Ms T. withdrew her request to hold the planned public event.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Belan), she decided to stage a solo picket (одиночный пикет) on 15 September 2012 from 2 to 3 p.m. at the entrance to Gorkiy Park.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Belan), she chose the format of a solo picket because it did not require her to give prior notification to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Belan), at around 2.10 p.m. on 15 September 2012, shortly after she had started her solo picket, she was approached by police officers who ordered her to stop the picket.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Belan), the police officers issued her with a formal warning for a violation of public order.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Belan), one of the police officers asked a passer-by, Mr Z., to hold her banner so that she could sign the formal warning.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The events of 15 September 2012 involving the first applicant (Ms Belan) were recorded on video.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Belan), at around 2.20 p.m. on 15 September 2012 the first applicant (Ms Belan) and Mr Z. were arrested and taken to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Belan), she remained at the police station from 2.30 to 6 p.m. on 15 September 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Belan), she was then allowed to leave the police station.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya), from 1.30 to 2.45 p.m. on 15 September 2012 she staged a solo demonstration on a street corner opposite Gorkiy Park to protest against construction laws.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya), on her way back home on 15 September 2012 she walked through Gorkiy Park and at around 3 p.m. saw a man holding a banner.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya), she approached the man to read the banner, which read \"I will not give up my freedom of choice, which is granted by God and the Constitution!\".", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya), she was immediately approached by a police officer who ordered her to show her own banner, but she refused.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya), at 3.05 p.m. on 15 September 2012 she was taken to a police station, where she saw the first applicant (Ms Belan).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya), she spent five hours at the police station on 15 September 2012, including two hours waiting outside for a copy of the record.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the relevant records, the first applicant (Ms Belan) was taken to the police station at 5.20 p.m. on 15 September 2012 for the purpose of compiling an administrative-offence record.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the relevant records, the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) was taken to the police station at 4.45 p.m. on 15 September 2012 for the purpose of compiling an administrative-offence record.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The police station logbook indicated that the first applicant (Ms Belan) had been brought to the police station at 4.20 p.m. on 15 September 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The police station logbook indicated that the first applicant (Ms Belan) had been released from the police station at 6.30 p.m. on 15 September 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The police station logbook indicated that the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) had been brought to the police station at 4.45 p.m. on 15 September 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The police station logbook indicated that the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) had been released from the police station at 6.45 p.m. on 15 September 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "At the police station, the first applicant (Ms Belan) was accused of organising and holding a public event without giving prior notification to the authorities, in breach of Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "At the police station, the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) was accused of organising and holding a public event without giving prior notification to the authorities, in breach of Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The administrative-offence record indicated that the first applicant (Ms Belan) had held a public event at 3.45 p.m. near the Lenin monument at the entrance to Gorkiy Park.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The administrative-offence record indicated that the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) had held a public event at 3.10 p.m. near the Lenin monument at the entrance to Gorkiy Park.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The administrative case files contained handwritten reports by the two police officers who had arrested the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Both police officers' handwritten reports contained descriptions of the applicants' acts substantially similar to those contained in the administrative-offence records.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' escorting to the police station and retention there"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On an unspecified date the administrative case against the first applicant (Ms Belan) was transferred to a justice of the peace of Circuit no. 2 of the Leninskiy District of Rostov-on-Don.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The justice of the peace of Circuit no. 2 of the Leninskiy District of Rostov-on-Don held several hearings in the administrative case against the first applicant (Ms Belan).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The first applicant (Ms Belan) attended the hearings before the justice of the peace and was assisted by a representative, though it is unclear whether that person was a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 25 September 2012 the justice of the peace of Circuit no. 2 of the Leninskiy District of Rostov-on-Don held a hearing in the administrative case against the first applicant (Ms Belan) and heard various witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "At the hearing on 25 September 2012, witness Ms O. stated that she had seen the first applicant (Ms Belan) standing in front of the entrance to Gorkiy Park with a banner.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "At the hearing on 25 September 2012, witness Ms O. stated that a man and a woman had also been standing on that square with banners.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "At the hearing on 25 September 2012, witness Mr P. testified that he had wanted to join the picket at Gorkiy Park.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "At the hearing on 25 September 2012, witness Mr Z. stated that he had happened to be standing close to the first applicant (Ms Belan) and had taken her banner at the request of the police so that she could sign some papers.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "At the hearing on 25 September 2012, the justice of the peace dismissed an application by the defence seeking to admit two photographs and a video-recording (apparently showing the events of 15 September 2012) into evidence.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The justice of the peace stated that it was unclear who had captured the footage and that the photographs and video-recording contained no indication of when and where they had been taken.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "At the defence's request, the justice of the peace ordered the city police department to release the footage of two street cameras.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 4 October 2012 the deputy chief of the city police department replied that the footage from one street camera had been saved and invited the justice of the peace to provide an electronic storage device onto which it could be copied.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 18 October 2012 the acting head of the duty unit of the city police department informed the justice of the peace that the street camera footage could not be released because it had not been archived owing to a failure of the archiving system.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 18 October 2012 the acting head of the duty unit of the city police department informed the justice of the peace that the street camera footage could not be released because those city cameras had not been working.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The justice of the peace summoned police officer A., who had arrested the first applicant (Ms Belan), for questioning.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "At a hearing on 7 November 2012, police officer A. stated that after receiving information from Sh., the chief of police station no. 4, he had arrived at Gorkiy Park.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "At the hearing on 7 November 2012, police officer A. stated that at Gorkiy Park he had seen a group of people, including Mr Z., in possession of banners, without having given any prior notification of their public event.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "At the hearing on 7 November 2012, police officer A. stated that he remembered arresting Ms Belan (the first applicant), though he could not remember her face.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "At the hearing on 7 November 2012, police officer A. stated that on 15 September 2012 officers from the regional bureau of forensic examinations within the regional police department had taken photographs of what appeared to be a public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 7 November 2012 the justice of the peace allowed the examination of videos submitted by officers of police station no. 4 containing two clips relating to the events on 15 September 2012.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "One of the two video clips showed the first applicant (Ms Belan) with a banner.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The other video clip showed the first applicant (Ms Belan) reading a piece of paper and Mr Z. standing close to her and holding a banner above his head.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The justice of the peace later declared the two video clips submitted by officers of police station no. 4 inadmissible evidence.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The justice of the peace granted a request by the defence for the regional bureau of forensic examinations to provide the photographs taken on 15 September 2012.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The hearing before the justice of the peace was then adjourned.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 12 November 2012 the chief of the city police department replied to the request for photographs, indicating that no photographs or video recordings had been taken on 15 September 2012 in front of the entrance to Gorkiy Park.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "It is unclear whether the regional bureau of forensic examinations was within the purview of the chief of the city police department.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 9 November 2012 the justice of the peace of Circuit no. 2 of the Leninskiy District of Rostov-on-Don convicted the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) in separate proceedings dealing with the same events of 15 September 2012.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 13 November 2012 the justice of the peace of Circuit no. 2 of the Leninskiy District of Rostov-on-Don convicted the first applicant (Ms Belan) under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The justice of the peace issued the first applicant (Ms Belan) with a fine of 20,000 Russian roubles (approximately EUR 497 at the time).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The justice of the peace based its findings on the statements of witnesses Ms O., Mr P. and Mr Z. and police officer A.'s testimony.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The justice of the peace found it established that on 15 September 2012 a group of people with banners had held a public event in front of the entrance to Gorkiy Park without having given prior notification to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The justice of the peace found it established that the first applicant (Ms Belan) had participated in the public event held on 15 September 2012 in front of the entrance to Gorkiy Park.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The first applicant (Ms Belan) lodged an appeal with the Leninskiy District Court of Rostov-on-Don against the conviction of 13 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "In her appeal, the first applicant (Ms Belan) argued that the Public Events Act conferred on the regional authorities the power to determine the minimum distance between solo demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "In her appeal, the first applicant (Ms Belan) argued that as no minimum distance between solo demonstrations had been specified in the Rostov region, there was no legal justification for not treating people standing at even a short distance from each other as solo demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "In her appeal, the first applicant (Ms Belan) argued that there was no legal justification for treating people standing at even a short distance from each other as a public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "It appears that the Leninskiy District Court of Rostov-on-Don heard further evidence from witness Ms O. on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On appeal, witness Ms O. stated that around 3 p.m. on 15 September 2012 she had approached the Lenin monument with the intention of expressing her views on the situation in the country.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "On appeal, witness Ms O. stated that she had seen the first applicant (Ms Belan) standing alone with a banner close to the Lenin monument.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On appeal, witness Ms O. stated that she had positioned herself at a distance from the first applicant (Ms Belan), closer to the city administration building.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On appeal, witness Ms O. stated that the first applicant (Ms Belan) had been approached by two police officers and had handed over her banner to a passer-by while signing a document, before being taken away.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On appeal, witness Ms O. stated that she had also seen two other people standing with banners at a distance.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "It appears that the Leninskiy District Court of Rostov-on-Don watched a video-recording at the first applicant's (Ms Belan's) request on appeal, although its origin is unclear.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "It is unclear whether the video-recording watched by the Leninskiy District Court of Rostov-on-Don on appeal was one of the videos sought to be admitted into evidence at the trial before the justice of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 3 December 2012 the Leninskiy District Court of Rostov-on-Don dismissed the first applicant's (Ms Belan's) appeal against the conviction of 13 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Rostov-on-Don dismissed Ms O.'s testimony as unconvincing and complicit, noting that she had participated in the same event and was an acquaintance of the first applicant (Ms Belan).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Rostov-on-Don observed that the video-recording examined at the hearing showed the first applicant (Ms Belan) holding a banner and also showed different people.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Rostov-on-Don observed that the video-recording was done without zoom so it was not possible to conclude whether the first applicant (Ms Belan) was holding a demonstration alone or whether there were other participants.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Rostov-on-Don observed that other people had earlier been convicted of the same offence at the same time and place, which refuted the first applicant's (Ms Belan's) argument about her solo demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 4 December 2012 the first applicant (Ms Belan) lodged a complaint with the Rostov regional prosecutor's office, seeking the institution of criminal proceedings against the police officers under Articles 149 and 286 of the Criminal Code (unlawful impediment to a public assembly and abuse of powers).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The first applicant (Ms Belan) alleged in her complaint that the termination of her solo demonstration and her arrest by the police had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "By a letter of 9 January 2013 the Rostov regional prosecutor's office replied to the first applicant (Ms Belan) that the decisions of 13 November and 3 December 2012 were not amenable to appeal.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "On 28 December 2012 the justice of the peace of Circuit no. 2 of the Leninskiy District of Rostov-on-Don granted permission to the first applicant (Ms Belan) to pay the administrative fine of 20,000 Russian roubles in three instalments.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "On 6 March 2013 the deputy president of the Rostov Regional Court upheld the decisions of 13 November and 3 December 2012 in the case of the first applicant (Ms Belan).", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "On 20 May 2013 the deputy president of the Rostov Regional Court upheld the decisions of 13 November and 3 December 2012 in the case of the first applicant (Ms Belan).", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The first applicant (Ms Belan) did not apply for a further review of the court decisions before the Supreme Court of Russia.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. The first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "On 9 November 2012 the justice of the peace of Circuit no. 2 of the Leninskiy District of Rostov-on-Don convicted the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) under Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences for holding a public assembly without giving prior notice to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The justice of the peace heard several witnesses in the case of the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya), including two defence witnesses and the two police officers who had arrested her.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Officer Sh., the chief of police station no. 4, stated that there had initially been four solo demonstrators but they had later started to gather together.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "Officer Sh. stated that the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) had been walking amongst the demonstrators and had put down her banner when she had been told by the police that she was conducting herself in an unlawful manner.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Officer Sh. stated that subsequently the four demonstrators had positioned themselves in pairs.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The justice of the peace found that the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) had held a group public event together with three other participants.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The justice of the peace concluded that in the circumstances of the case it was appropriate to issue the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) with the minimum statutory fine of 20,000 Russian roubles.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) appealed against the conviction of 9 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "On 6 December 2012 the Leninskiy District Court of Rostov-on-Don examined the second applicant's (Ms Sviderskaya's) appeal and upheld the earlier judgment of 9 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "On 10 December 2012 the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) lodged a complaint with the Rostov regional prosecutor's office, similar to that lodged by the first applicant (Ms Belan).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) alleged in her complaint that she had been placed under administrative arrest, which had been unlawful because no written record of it had been made by the police.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "On 9 January 2013 the Rostov regional prosecutor's office replied to the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) that the decisions of 9 November and 6 December 2012 were not amenable to appeal.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "By a decision of 26 December 2012 the justice of the peace allowed the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) to pay the administrative fine in three monthly instalments: two instalments of 7,000 Russian roubles and one of 6,000 Russian roubles.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The arrangement of three monthly instalments was the best possible solution available under Article 31.5 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The justice of the peace took note of the fact that the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) received an old-age pension of 5,561 Russian roubles (approximately EUR 138 at the time) per month.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "It was not specified whether the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) had any income other than her old-age pension.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) applied for a supervisory review of the decisions of 9 November and 6 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "In her application for supervisory review, the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) argued, inter alia, that she was in a precarious financial situation.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) asked for the fine to be reduced to below the statutory minimum, in accordance with a ruling of the Russian Constitutional Court made on 14 February 2013.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "On 6 March 2013 the deputy president of the Rostov Regional Court upheld the judgments of 9 November and 6 December 2012 in the case of the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya), stating in particular that the amount of fine was within the scope of the statutory requirement.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "On 29 May 2013 the deputy president of the Rostov Regional Court upheld the judgments of 9 November and 6 December 2012 in the case of the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya), stating in particular that the amount of fine was within the scope of the statutory requirement.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "On 10 January 2014 the Supreme Court of Russia upheld the judgments of 9 November and 6 December 2012 in the case of the second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya).", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. The second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "A summary of domestic law and practice concerning regulations relating to the conduct of public events, liability for breaches committed in their course, and administrative escorting and arrest can be found in Lashmankin and Others v. Russia (nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, §§ 216-312, 7 February 2017).", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "A summary of domestic law and practice concerning regulations relating to the conduct of public events, liability for breaches committed in their course, and administrative escorting and arrest can be found in Novikova and Others v. Russia (nos. 25501/07 and 4 others, §§ 47-85, 26 April 2016).", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "In the Rostov region, Regional Law no. 146-3C of 27 September 2004 complements the federal regulations on public gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "In December 2012 Regional Law no. 146-3C of 27 September 2004 was amended to provide that the distance between solo demonstrations should be at least fifty metres (section 2).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Section 26 of the Prosecutors Act (Federal Law no. 2202-1 of 17 January 1992) provides that prosecutors supervise the observance of human rights and freedoms by State authorities and private bodies.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Under section 27 § 1 of the Prosecutors Act (Federal Law no. 2202-1 of 17 January 1992), prosecutors may examine and review complaints and requests containing information concerning alleged violations of individual rights and freedoms.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Under section 27 § 1 of the Prosecutors Act (Federal Law no. 2202-1 of 17 January 1992), prosecutors may explain the avenues of protection for individual rights and freedoms.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Under section 27 § 1 of the Prosecutors Act (Federal Law no. 2202-1 of 17 January 1992), prosecutors may issue warnings about the unacceptability of violations and bring those who have violated the law to account.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Under section 27 § 2 of the Prosecutors Act (Federal Law no. 2202-1 of 17 January 1992), if a prosecutor has grounds to suspect that a crime has been committed, he or she can take measures to ensure that the perpetrators are prosecuted in accordance with the law.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Under section 28 of the Prosecutors Act (Federal Law no. 2202-1 of 17 January 1992), a prosecutor or a deputy prosecutor may complain about acts violating individual rights to the competent authority which issued such an act or to the court.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F071", "F072", "F102", "F097", "F041", "F043", "F067", "F098", "F013", "F022"], "interference": ["F015", "F019", "F025", "F026", "F068", "F069", "F097", "F103"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F121", "F122"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F013", "F022", "F071", "F072", "F102", "F068", "F069", "F097", "F103", "F015", "F019", "F025", "F026"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F071", "F072", "F102"], "interference": ["F019", "F026", "F068", "F069", "F097", "F103"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F122"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F015", "F019", "F025", "F026", "F069", "F071", "F102", "F103"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F015", "F019", "F025", "F026", "F069", "F071", "F102", "F103", "F122"]}} {"case_name": "case_176", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_179", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_180", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1992.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was represented by Ms K. Mikhaylova, a lawyer practising in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The Government were represented by Mr M. Galperin, the Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 27 September 2013 a group of LGBTI rights activists informed the St Petersburg authorities of their intention to hold a meeting to mark Coming Out Day (an annual LGBTI awareness day).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PUBLIC EVENT TO MARK COMING OUT DAY"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The meeting to mark Coming Out Day was planned to take place from 2 p.m. until 3.30 p.m. on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PUBLIC EVENT TO MARK COMING OUT DAY"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The meeting to mark Coming Out Day was planned to be held at the Field of Mars (Марсово поле), a large square in the city centre of St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PUBLIC EVENT TO MARK COMING OUT DAY"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "About 150 people were expected to attend the Coming Out Day meeting on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PUBLIC EVENT TO MARK COMING OUT DAY"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The organisers of the Coming Out Day meeting mentioned that some participants would arrive at 1.30 p.m. on 12 October 2013 to prepare for the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PUBLIC EVENT TO MARK COMING OUT DAY"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 30 September 2013 the St Petersburg authorities forwarded information about the upcoming Coming Out Day meeting to the police (ГУ МВД Российской Федерации по г. Санкт-Петербургу и Ленинградской области).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PUBLIC EVENT TO MARK COMING OUT DAY"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 30 September 2013 the St Petersburg authorities reminded the organisers of the Coming Out Day meeting that they would be held liable under domestic law for inciting hatred and enmity on account of ethnicity, language, origin and religious beliefs.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PUBLIC EVENT TO MARK COMING OUT DAY"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 30 September 2013 the St Petersburg authorities reminded the organisers of the Coming Out Day meeting that they would be held liable under domestic law for promoting 'non-traditional' sexual relationships to minors.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PUBLIC EVENT TO MARK COMING OUT DAY"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The police deployed around 540 police officers, including officers from special-purpose units, to ensure public order during the Coming Out Day meeting on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PUBLIC EVENT TO MARK COMING OUT DAY"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The enhanced security deployment of approximately 540 police officers was ordered in the light of anticipated clashes with counter-demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PUBLIC EVENT TO MARK COMING OUT DAY"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "There is no information about any other prior arrangements made by the authorities in connection with the Coming Out Day meeting on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PUBLIC EVENT TO MARK COMING OUT DAY"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "At 11.30 a.m. on 12 October 2013 police officers arrived at the Field of Mars in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "It does not appear that any crowd barriers were installed at the Field of Mars on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "It does not appear that the police erected any kind of perimeter fence for the demonstrators at the Field of Mars on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "At about 1 p.m. on 12 October 2013 the applicant arrived at the Field of Mars to take part in the preparation of the Coming Out Day meeting.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the applicant, the Coming Out Day participants (about twenty or thirty people) were unable to gather at the Field of Mars because the place was blocked by more than 100 aggressive counter-demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the applicant, many of the counter-demonstrators were in national costumes and armed with whips (нагайка).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the applicant, the counter-demonstrators insulted the participants in the Coming Out Day meeting.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the applicant, the counter-demonstrators pushed and punched the participants in the Coming Out Day meeting.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the applicant, the counter-demonstrators surrounded the Coming Out Day participants, including the applicant, and followed them.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the applicant, the Coming Out Day participants asked for help from the police officers present at the Field of Mars, but the police officers did not react.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicant, the police officers at the Field of Mars stepped in only when counter-demonstrators insulted the police officers personally.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the applicant, the police officers arrested several counter-demonstrators, took them to a police bus parked nearby, and then released them.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the applicant, the released counter-demonstrators continued their verbal attacks and physical pressure on the LGBTI activists present at the Field of Mars.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "At 1.55 p.m. on 12 October 2013 police officers surrounded a group of twelve demonstrators, including the applicant, Mr D.G., Mr D.M., Ms N.I., Ms E.M., Ms S.L. and Ms Y.T.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The police officers stated that the group of twelve demonstrators, including the applicant, had breached public order by using foul language in a public place.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The police officers ordered the group of twelve demonstrators, including the applicant, to proceed to a police bus.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The police officers took the group of twelve demonstrators, including the applicant, to central police station no. 28 in St Petersburg (28 отдел полиции УМВД России по центральному району г. Санкт-Петербургу).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The police officers referred to the transfer procedure set out in Article 27.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences as the legal basis for taking the demonstrators to central police station no. 28 in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Government submitted that in total, ninety-three people had been arrested during the public event on 12 October 2013 on account of their disorderly conduct.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Government submitted that the ninety-three people arrested during the public event on 12 October 2013 were taken to three police stations and then released.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant argued that the police officers had taken only participants in the Coming Out Day meeting to various police stations on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE APPLICANT'S ATTEMPT TO TAKE PART IN THE MEETING AND HER ARREST"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant was detained at central police station no. 28 in St Petersburg under Article 27.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences from 2.30 p.m. to around 6.30 p.m. on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the applicant, at around 6 p.m. on 12 October 2013 police officers started drawing up administrative-arrest, administrative-escort and administrative-offence records.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The administrative-arrest record stated that the applicant had been detained at 1.55 p.m. on 12 October 2013 on account of her disorderly conduct, an offence proscribed by Article 20.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The administrative-arrest record stated that the applicant had been taken to the police station to ensure the 'prompt and proper examination of her case'.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The administrative-offence record specified that the grounds of the applicant's arrest were that she had used foul language during the public meeting and had ignored warnings given by police officers to refrain from doing so.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The applicant signed the administrative-arrest record and the administrative-offence record, noting her disagreement with them.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant's administrative case was transmitted to the Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg terminated the administrative proceedings against the applicant on 8 November 2013 for lack of evidence of her guilt.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The police brought charges of disorderly misconduct (use of foul language) against Mr D.G., Mr D.M., Ms N.I., Ms E.M., Ms S.L. and Ms Y.T.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST OTHER PARTICIPANTS OF THE PUBLIC EVENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg terminated the administrative proceedings against Mr D.G. for lack of evidence of his guilt on a date in November or December 2013.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST OTHER PARTICIPANTS OF THE PUBLIC EVENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg terminated the administrative proceedings against Mr D.M. for lack of evidence of his guilt on a date in November or December 2013.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST OTHER PARTICIPANTS OF THE PUBLIC EVENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg terminated the administrative proceedings against Ms E.M. for lack of evidence of her guilt on a date in November or December 2013.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST OTHER PARTICIPANTS OF THE PUBLIC EVENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg terminated the administrative proceedings against Ms S.L. for lack of evidence of her guilt on a date in November or December 2013.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST OTHER PARTICIPANTS OF THE PUBLIC EVENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg terminated the administrative proceedings against Ms Y.T. for lack of evidence of her guilt on a date in November or December 2013.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST OTHER PARTICIPANTS OF THE PUBLIC EVENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 9 January 2014 the Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg found Ms N.I. guilty of disorderly misconduct (use of foul language).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST OTHER PARTICIPANTS OF THE PUBLIC EVENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Ms N.I. appealed against the Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg's decision of 9 January 2014 finding her guilty.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST OTHER PARTICIPANTS OF THE PUBLIC EVENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 6 March 2014 the St Petersburg City Court quashed the Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg's decision of 9 January 2014 finding Ms N.I. guilty.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST OTHER PARTICIPANTS OF THE PUBLIC EVENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court found on 6 March 2014 that the police had failed to substantiate the charges of disorderly misconduct against Ms N.I. and terminated the proceedings against her.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST OTHER PARTICIPANTS OF THE PUBLIC EVENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 12 February 2014 the applicant lodged a civil claim with the Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg against the St Petersburg and Leningrad Region Main Department of the Russian Ministry of the Interior (Главное управление МВД России по г. Санкт-Петербургу и Ленинградской области).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 12 February 2014 the applicant lodged a civil claim with the Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg against the Central District of St Petersburg Department of the Russian Ministry of the Interior (УМВД России по Центральному району г. Санкт-Петербурга).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 12 February 2014 the applicant lodged a civil claim with the Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg against the chief of central police station no. 28 in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 12 February 2014 the applicant lodged a civil claim with the Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg against two police officers involved in her transfer to central police station no. 28 in St Petersburg and her detention there.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "In her civil claim of 12 February 2014, the applicant challenged the lawfulness of her arrest and detention at central police station no. 28 in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On an unspecified date after 12 February 2014, the applicant extended her civil claim, alleging that the authorities had failed to ensure the personal safety of the participants in the public meeting of 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 17 February 2014 the Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg rejected the applicant's civil claim on procedural grounds, without examining it on the merits.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The applicant appealed against the Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg's decision of 17 February 2014 rejecting her civil claim on procedural grounds.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 14 July 2014 the St Petersburg City Court quashed the Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg's decision of 17 February 2014 rejecting the applicant's civil claim on procedural grounds.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 23 October 2014 the Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg examined the merits of the applicant's civil claim and dismissed it.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg noted on 23 October 2014 that the applicant had failed to comply with the three-month statutory time-limit for appealing against the police's actions.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg stated on 23 October 2014 that the applicant's civil claim was in any event ill-founded.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Relying on a video recording of the event of 12 October 2013, the Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg established that the police had interfered with the public gathering because of the conflict between the demonstrators and counter-demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg found on 23 October 2014 that the applicant had been one of the active participants in the conflict between demonstrators and counter-demonstrators on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg concluded on 23 October 2014 that the applicant's arrest had been lawful.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg was not convinced by witness evidence stating that the applicant herself had not breached public order, because the witnesses belonged to the same group of demonstrators as the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg concluded on 23 October 2014 that the applicant's detention had been lawful, as its duration had not exceeded forty-eight hours, the maximum length of administrative detention provided by Article 27.5 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg found on 23 October 2014 that the applicant's allegation regarding the authorities' failure to ensure the personal safety of the demonstrators had been unsubstantiated by evidence.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg noted on 23 October 2014 that about 550 police officers had been deployed by the authorities during the Coming Out Day meeting on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg noted on 23 October 2014 that no harm had been caused to the applicant during the Coming Out Day meeting on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 31 December 2014 the applicant appealed against the Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg's judgment of 23 October 2014 to the St Petersburg City Court.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "In her appeal of 31 December 2014, the applicant complained that her arrest had not pursued a legitimate aim and had been arbitrary.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "In her appeal of 31 December 2014, the applicant alleged that the authorities had failed to comply with their positive obligations under the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "In her appeal of 31 December 2014, the applicant alleged that instead of ensuring the participants' freedom of expression, the police officers had arrested them.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "In her appeal of 31 December 2014, the applicant alleged that no counter-demonstrators had been detained during the Coming Out Day meeting on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "In her appeal of 31 December 2014, the applicant alleged that the selective approach of arresting only Coming Out Day participants and not counter-demonstrators had been discriminatory.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 11 March 2015 the St Petersburg City Court upheld the Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg's judgment of 23 October 2014 on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court concluded on 11 March 2015 that the applicant's arrest had been lawful.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court considered on 11 March 2015 that the applicant's arrest was an interim measure taken to facilitate subsequent administrative proceedings for the use of foul language.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court found on 11 March 2015 that at the time of the event, given the tension between the participants of the assembly and counter-demonstrators, the police officers had been unable to identify the people who had used offensive language and to immediately draft the administrative-offence records.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court found on 11 March 2015 that the police officers had therefore had to take the arrested people to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court found on 11 March 2015 that the fact that the administrative proceedings against the applicant had subsequently been terminated had not invalidated the lawfulness of her arrest.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court noted on 11 March 2015 that the applicant's civil claim had been lodged belatedly.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "On 2 September 2015 the applicant lodged a cassation appeal challenging the Vasileostrovskiy District Court of St Petersburg's judgment of 23 October 2014 and the St Petersburg City Court's appeal decision of 11 March 2015.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 25 September 2015 the St Petersburg City Court dismissed the applicant's cassation appeal, upholding the findings of the lower-instance courts.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "On an unspecified date after 25 September 2015, the applicant lodged a cassation appeal with the Supreme Court of Russia challenging the lower courts' decisions.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "On 20 February 2016 the Supreme Court of Russia declined to entertain the applicant's cassation appeal.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "It appears that the applicant did not receive a written version of the Supreme Court of Russia's decision of 20 February 2016.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Subsequently, the applicant requested the Supreme Court of Russia to provide her with a copy of its decision of 20 February 2016.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "By a letter of 23 May 2019, the Supreme Court of Russia informed the applicant that the case file had been destroyed owing to the expiration of the statutory period for its storage.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. CIVIL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST POLICE AUTHORITIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The relevant provisions of the Code of Administrative Offences, including Article 27.2 ('Transfer procedure') and Article 27.3 ('Administrative detention'), are summarised in Navalnyy and Yashin v. Russia (no. 76204/11, § 44, 4 December 2014).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "For other relevant material on the legal framework, see Lashmankin and Others v. Russia (nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, §§ 216-17, 218-19 and 231-42, 7 February 2017).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 31 March 2010, at the 1081st meeting of Ministers' Deputies, the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe adopted Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe provides that member states should take appropriate measures at national, regional and local levels to ensure that the right to freedom of peaceful assembly, as enshrined in Article 11 of the Convention, can be effectively enjoyed without discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe provides that member states should ensure that law enforcement authorities take appropriate measures to protect participants in peaceful demonstrations in favour of the human rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender persons from any attempts to unlawfully disrupt or inhibit the effective enjoyment of their right to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) were prepared by the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) in consultation with the European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission) of the Council of Europe.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that states have a positive duty to facilitate and protect the exercise of the right to freedom of peaceful assembly, which should be reflected in the legislative framework and relevant law enforcement regulations and practices.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that the duty to facilitate assemblies includes a duty to facilitate assemblies at the organiser's preferred location and within 'sight and sound' of the intended audience.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that the duty to protect involves the protection of assembly organizers and participants from third party individuals or groups who seek to undermine their right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that discrimination based on grounds such as sexual orientation, gender, and gender identity should be prohibited.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that law enforcement agencies should adopt a human rights-based approach to all aspects of the planning, preparation and policing of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that a human rights-based approach to policing assemblies should be based on four key principles: (1) knowledge of the groups involved; (2) a commitment to facilitating assemblies; (3) recognition of the value and importance of voluntary communication at all stages of the assembly process; and (4) acknowledgment of the diversity of participants in assemblies and the need to differentiate between them in active policing.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that law enforcement agencies should not use force at assemblies unless strictly unavoidable, and that force should only be applied to the minimum extent necessary, following the principles of restraint, proportionality, and minimization of damage and the preservation of life.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that law enforcement should as far as possible avoid the use of containment or mass arrests of participants at an assembly, as such indiscriminate measures may amount to an arbitrary deprivation of liberty under international human rights law.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that state authorities must protect the organizers and participants of peaceful assemblies that espouse controversial or unpopular views from hostile opposition, and shall protect peaceful assemblies from any person or group that intentionally seeks to limit or destroy the rights of others to assemble.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that potential disorder arising from hostility directed against those participating in a peaceful assembly must not be used to justify disproportionate restrictions on the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that an assembly may be prohibited as a last resort measure when the risk of violent counter-demonstrations may not otherwise be prevented or mitigated, and that the principle of proportionality must always be respected.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that the state has the duty to ensure that counter-demonstrators do not constitute an undue and serious interference with the main event's ability to convey its message.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that the state should take positive measures to facilitate assemblies associated with individuals and groups that have historically faced discrimination, or are otherwise marginalized or at risk.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that law enforcement officials must differentiate between peaceful and non-peaceful participants, since only those who themselves take part in violence forfeit the legal guarantee of their right to assemble, and that state intervention should target individual wrongdoers rather than all participants more generally.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The 2019 Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017) provide that if a dispute arises during the course of an assembly, communication between the organizer and the competent state authorities may be an appropriate means by which to reach an acceptable resolution, and that where voluntary dialogue is not possible, the relevant law enforcement bodies must still ensure that their actions are aimed at de-escalating tensions.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "In a report entitled 'License to Harm: Violence and Harassment against LGBT People and Activists in Russia' published in December 2014, the NGO Human Rights Watch stated that since at least the mid-2000s, Russian authorities had refused to tolerate most public events in support of LGBT rights and equality.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "In the December 2014 report 'License to Harm: Violence and Harassment against LGBT People and Activists in Russia', Human Rights Watch stated that homophobic counter-demonstrators had violently disrupted many public events in support of LGBT rights and equality in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "In the December 2014 report 'License to Harm: Violence and Harassment against LGBT People and Activists in Russia', Human Rights Watch stated that the vast majority of people it interviewed who had been involved in such events said that the frequency of attacks had risen over the previous two years.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "In the December 2014 report 'License to Harm: Violence and Harassment against LGBT People and Activists in Russia', Human Rights Watch stated that in 2013 anti-gay activists had attacked virtually every LGBT equality event of which Human Rights Watch were aware.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "In the December 2014 report 'License to Harm: Violence and Harassment against LGBT People and Activists in Russia', Human Rights Watch described how anti-gay counter-protesters routinely harassed LGBT activists and their supporters during public events, used offensive homophobic slurs, or threatened them with physical violence.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "In the December 2014 report 'License to Harm: Violence and Harassment against LGBT People and Activists in Russia', Human Rights Watch stated that in five out of seven cases documented in the report, police had not taken adequate measures to prevent and stop the harassment and attacks.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "One of the five cases in which police had not taken adequate measures to prevent and stop harassment and attacks, as documented in the December 2014 Human Rights Watch report 'License to Harm: Violence and Harassment against LGBT People and Activists in Russia', concerned the public meeting of 12 October 2013 in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "A Human Rights Watch researcher observed the Coming Out Day rally organized by LGBT activists on 12 October 2013 at the Field of Mars in central St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch researcher's observations, after about a dozen LGBT activists arrived at the Field of Mars for the Coming Out Day rally on 12 October 2013, a crowd of at least five times as many anti-gay counter-protesters harassed and attacked them.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch researcher's observations, some of the counter-protesters at the Field of Mars on 12 October 2013 were dressed as priests with religious accessories; others were in military uniforms and camouflage outfits.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch researcher's observations, the counter-protesters at the Field of Mars on 12 October 2013 yelled that gays were 'abnormal' and that there was no place for them in St Petersburg, and blocked access for LGBT activists to the protest venue.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch researcher's observations, after several attempts to reach the venue at the Field of Mars on 12 October 2013, the LGBT activists were unable to start the Coming Out Day event.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch researcher's observations, the LGBT activists told the police at the Field of Mars on 12 October 2013 that they were effectively barred from reaching the event venue.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch researcher's observations, the police at the Field of Mars on 12 October 2013, who numbered several dozen ordinary police officers and many riot police, did not take adequate measures to ensure access to the venue and prevent harassment and attacks by anti-gay counter-protesters.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch researcher's observations, the police at the Field of Mars on 12 October 2013 began detaining counter-protesters only when several of them started insulting police officers for not stopping the LGBT rally.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch researcher's observations, a few LGBT activists were also detained at the Field of Mars on 12 October 2013 but were released after several hours.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch researcher's observations, the initial charges against the detained LGBT activists of organizing and participating in an unsanctioned public event were eventually dropped.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F030", "F031", "F033", "F045"], "interference": ["F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F026", "F027", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F034", "F040", "F042", "F045", "F047", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F055"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F031", "F045"], "positive_obligation": ["F006", "F014", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F023", "F024", "F026", "F027", "F030", "F065", "F067", "F073", "F082", "F117", "F118", "F120", "F121", "F123", "F124", "F127", "F128"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F020", "F045"], "interference": ["F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F021", "F023", "F024", "F026", "F027", "F030", "F033"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F034", "F045"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F031", "F045"], "positive_obligation": ["F014", "F016", "F018", "F019", "F021", "F023", "F024", "F026", "F027", "F117", "F118", "F120"]}, "list3": ["F016", "F018", "F019", "F021", "F023", "F024", "F026", "F027", "F030", "F045", "F117", "F118"]}} {"case_name": "case_181", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1968.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1950.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1944.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The fourth applicant was born in 1949.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The fifth applicant was born in 1973.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The sixth applicant was born in 1953.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The seventh applicant was born in 1956.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The eighth applicant was born in 1958.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The ninth applicant was born in 1955.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The tenth applicant was born in 1965.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicants live in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "In November 2005 the Moscow city administration authorised a public gathering called 'the Right March'.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The 'Right March' was organised by a number of non-governmental organisations including the Movement against Illegal Immigration and the Eurasian Youth Movement.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The declared aim of the 'Right March' was to commemorate the liberation of Moscow from occupation.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The declared aim of the 'Right March' included expressing the participants' dissatisfaction with the flow of immigration into Russia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The 'Right March' included a parade from the Chistiye Prudy underground station down to Slavyanskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "A demonstration was held at Slavyanskaya Square as part of the 'Right March'.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The 'Right March' event lasted for some two and a half hours, according to the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The 'Right March' attracted several thousand people, according to the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Reportedly, a number of 'Right March' participants shouted 'Russia for Russians, Moscow for Moscovites!'", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Reportedly, a number of 'Right March' participants displayed banners with the slogan 'Let's clean the unwelcome guests out of the city!'", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Reportedly, a number of 'Right March' participants displayed banners with the slogan 'Chechens, the war is over. It's time to go home!'", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Reportedly, a number of 'Right March' participants displayed banners with the slogan 'Russia belongs to us!'", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Following the 'Right March', a 'steering committee for an anti-fascist march' was formed.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The 'steering committee for an anti-fascist march' included representatives of various human rights organisations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "It was decided to hold a public gathering on 27 November 2005 to mark opposition to the values proclaimed by the 'Right March'.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The planned public gathering on 27 November 2005 was intended to progress through several streets in central Moscow to Tverskaya Square (near the Moscow mayor's office).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The planned public gathering on 27 November 2005 was intended to include a demonstration at Tverskaya Square (near the Moscow mayor's office).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 23 November 2005 the Moscow city administration stated that it would give permission only for the demonstration, not the march.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Moscow city administration wanted the demonstration to be held in Tverskaya Zastava Square instead of Tverskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Moscow city administration wanted the demonstration to last one hour instead of two hours.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The organisers of the planned anti-fascist march did not challenge in court the conditions imposed by the Moscow mayor's office.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The organisers of the planned anti-fascist march withdrew their application to hold the march as planned.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The organisers withdrew their application apparently considering that the modified conditions would work against the aims they sought to achieve by holding a public gathering.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The organisers opted to picket Tverskaya Square on 27 November 2005 from 2 p.m. to 4 p.m. next to the Dolgorukiy monument.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The organisers expected that up to fifty people would join the picket (пикетирование) at Tverskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "At the picket at Tverskaya Square, the organisers intended to express their disagreement with the Moscow mayor's office as to the location of the previously planned march and demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The new picket event at Tverskaya Square was apparently no longer meant to be a direct reply to the 'Right March'.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 23 November 2005 thirteen persons gave notice of the picket event to the district authority.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "One of the thirteen persons who gave notice of the picket event on 23 November 2005 was Mr Orlov, one of the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "Notice of the picket event was given to the district authority in order to comply with the Public Gatherings Act.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "In a letter of 24 November 2005, the district authority suggested that the picket event be held in Tverskaya Zastava Square instead of Tverskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "In its letter of 24 November 2005, the district authority suggested the picket event run from 2 p.m. to 3 p.m. instead of 2 p.m. to 4 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The district authority's letter of 24 November 2005 referred to the 'security of the participants' as a reason for the suggested change of venue and timing.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The district authority's letter of 24 November 2005 referred to the need to avoid causing obstruction to pedestrians and vehicles as a reason for the suggested change of venue and timing.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The district authority explained in its letter of 24 November 2005 that under a 1998 order the area around the Dolgorukiy monument was restricted to service vehicles of the Moscow mayor's office.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The organisers of the new picket event sent a letter expressing their disagreement with the district authority's decision regarding the change of venue and timing.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 24 November 2005, the organisers informed the Moscow mayor's office that they were no longer intending to hold a march and a demonstration as initially planned.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The organisers informed the Moscow mayor's office of their decision in view of the mayor's reply of 23 November 2005.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Prior to 27 November 2005, the organisers did not challenge in court the conditions imposed on the picket event by the district authority.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Despite the position of the district authority, the organisers decided to hold a public gathering in Tverskaya Square on 27 November 2005 at 2 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The special security squad proceeded to arrest some participants at the public gathering in Tverskaya Square on 27 November 2005.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The special security squad allegedly did not give participants time or opportunity to disperse after a verbal order to do so before making arrests.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The applicants, along with fifty other people, were taken to the Tverskoy police station following the public gathering on 27 November 2005.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The applicants and fifty other people remained at the Tverskoy police station until 7 p.m. on 27 November 2005.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "While at the Tverskoy police station, various records were compiled, including administrative offence records.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The \"Right March\" and the counter-march and demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 29 November 2005 the Justice of the Peace delivered judgments finding some of the applicants guilty of a breach of the procedures for public gatherings under Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 30 November 2005 the Justice of the Peace delivered judgments finding some of the applicants guilty of a breach of the procedures for public gatherings under Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicants found guilty were ordered to pay a fine of 1,000 Russian roubles (RUB), except for the ninth applicant.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The ninth applicant was ordered to pay a fine of 500 Russian roubles (RUB).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Justice of the Peace referred to the district authority's letter of 24 November 2005 in concluding that the public gathering was unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Justice of the Peace held that under the Public Gatherings Act, a picket means an expression by one person or several people of his or their opinion in public, by way of displaying posters, banners and other means of visual propaganda, without movement or use of sound-amplifying technical means.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Justice of the Peace held that a right to hold public gatherings entails a corresponding duty of the public authorities.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Justice of the Peace held that representatives of the relevant public authorities should be appointed to ensure the lawfulness of the event, public safety and public security.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Justice of the Peace held that rules should be laid down for the event to enable event participants and public officers to fulfil their obligations and duties.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Justice of the Peace found that despite police orders, the event participants refused to stop the picket and thus committed a premeditated administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Justice of the Peace found that it had not been established that the first applicant acted as one of the event organisers.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Justice of the Peace found that the first applicant's actions disclosed a violation of the procedures for public gatherings because he participated in a picket in a venue which had not been assigned for this purpose.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Justice of the Peace noted that the first applicant intended to take part in a public event and to express his opinion in relation to issues of general and political interest.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Justice of the Peace found that the first applicant, failing to respect circumstances significant for the event and the police orders, refused to stop the picket.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Justice of the Peace made similar findings in respect of the other applicants, except for Mr Orlov.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Justice of the Peace found in respect of Mr Orlov that the circumstances of the case and Mr Orlov's actions disclosed a violation of the procedure for a picket because no proper notification had been made to the competent public authority in relation to the picket.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The applicants appealed against the Justice of the Peace's judgments.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "By separate appeal decisions taken between 22 February and 10 April 2006, the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow upheld the decisions taken by the Justice of the Peace.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "In separate proceedings, Mr Orlov and another person sought to challenge the position taken by the district authority in its letter of 24 November 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "In a judgment of 30 March 2006, the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow cited the relevant legislative provisions and concluded that the circumstances of the case did not disclose any violation of those provisions.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 3 October 2006, the Moscow City Court endorsed the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow's conclusion of 30 March 2006 on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings before the national courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Under Article 31 of the Russian Constitution, citizens have a right of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Russian Constitution"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "Under Article 55 § 3 of the Russian Constitution, the right of peaceful assembly can be limited by a federal statute in so far as it is necessary to protect the constitutional regime, morals, health or rights or interests of others.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Russian Constitution"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "Under sections 5 and 7 of the 2004 Public Gatherings Act in force at the relevant time, the organiser of a public event (except for an event involving one person) was required to inform the competent authority of the event at least ten days in advance.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The 2004 Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Under sections 5 and 7 of the 2004 Public Gatherings Act in force at the relevant time, the organiser of a picket (пикетирование) was required to inform the competent authority at least three days in advance.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The 2004 Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Under sections 5 and 7 of the 2004 Public Gatherings Act, the organiser was required to indicate the purpose of the event, its form, the venue and the itinerary, as well as the date, timing and approximate number of participants.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The 2004 Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Under the 2004 Public Gatherings Act, the competent authority was required to notify the organiser if it had a reasoned proposal for another venue and/or timing for the event.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The 2004 Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Under the 2004 Public Gatherings Act, the organiser was required to inform the competent authority whether he or she refused or accepted the suggested new venue and/or timing.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The 2004 Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Under section 5 § 5 of the 2004 Public Gatherings Act, the event could not take place if the event organiser and the competent authority had not approved the alternative proposal.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The 2004 Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Under section 16 of the 2004 Public Gatherings Act, a public event could be stopped if there was a real threat to life or physical integrity of persons or property.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The 2004 Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Under section 16 of the 2004 Public Gatherings Act, a public event could be stopped if the event participants had acted unlawfully.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The 2004 Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Under section 16 of the 2004 Public Gatherings Act, a public event could be stopped if the event organiser had knowingly breached the requirements of the 2004 Public Gatherings Act as regards the conduct of the event.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The 2004 Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Under section 17 of the 2004 Public Gatherings Act, the representative of the public authority present at the event could order the event organiser to put an end to the event in circumstances justifying stoppage.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The 2004 Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Under section 17 of the 2004 Public Gatherings Act, the public authority representative was required to explain the reasons for the order to stop the event and provide time for compliance.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The 2004 Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Under section 17 of the 2004 Public Gatherings Act, if the organiser had not complied with the order to stop the event, the public official could issue the same order to the participants.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The 2004 Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Under section 17 of the 2004 Public Gatherings Act, if both the organiser and participants failed to comply with the order to stop the event, the police was to take appropriate measures to stop the event.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The 2004 Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Under section 8 of the 2004 Public Gatherings Act, a public event could not be held in zones close to dangerous industrial objects, the residences of the President of the Russian Federation, court buildings or prisons.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The 2004 Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001, a violation of the procedure concerning a public gathering is punishable by a fine.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "By order no. 1471-RP of 30 December 1998, the Moscow city mayor introduced regulations concerning city-hall parking areas for service vehicles, including on Tverskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Other legal acts"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Moscow city mayor's order no. 1471-RP of 30 December 1998 provided for approximately eighty service vehicle parking spaces on Tverskaya Square during weekdays, not Sundays or public holidays.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Other legal acts"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": false, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others", "public_safety"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F026", "F035", "F037", "F051", "F054", "F055", "F057", "F058", "F068"], "interference": ["F051", "F052", "F053", "F054", "F055", "F056", "F057", "F058", "F059", "F060", "F083", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F087", "F088", "F094"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F080", "F081", "F083", "F084", "F085", "F094"], "legitimate_aim": ["F044", "F045", "F061", "F074"], "necessity": ["F030", "F039", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F045", "F047", "F050", "F051", "F057", "F058", "F059", "F060", "F061", "F074", "F085"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F026", "F035", "F051", "F054"], "interference": ["F052", "F053", "F054", "F055", "F057", "F058", "F059", "F085", "F094"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F083", "F085", "F094"], "legitimate_aim": ["F044", "F045"], "necessity": ["F039", "F042", "F043", "F045", "F047", "F050", "F051", "F059", "F060", "F085"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F042", "F043", "F045", "F047", "F050", "F051", "F085", "F039", "F059"]}} {"case_name": "case_182", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_184", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_186", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of nationwide protests in support of the jailed opposition leader, Aleksey Navalnyy.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of nationwide protests in support of the jailed opposition leader, Aleksey Navalnyy.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_187", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1955.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 29 October 2003, the applicant attempted to participate in a demonstration in the form of a press conference held on Istiklal Street in the Beyoğlu district of Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 29 October 2003, at approximately 4.10 p.m., the applicant was arrested by police officers on Istiklal Street in the Beyoğlu district of Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 29 October 2003, approximately 50 to 60 other participants in the demonstration were arrested together with the applicant by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant alleged that the police officers had used disproportionate force to disperse the crowd and to arrest the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Government claimed that the demonstrators had resisted the police and had refused to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Following her arrest on 29 October 2003, the applicant was taken to hospital for a medical examination.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The doctor who examined the applicant at the hospital reported that there were no signs of injury on the applicant's body.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The doctor who examined the applicant at the hospital noted that the applicant complained of pain in her right upper arm.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 29 October 2003, at 7.30 p.m., the applicant was questioned by the Beyoğlu public prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant informed the Beyoğlu public prosecutor that she had been subjected to ill-treatment by the police, who had used disproportionate force during her arrest.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant claimed before the Beyoğlu public prosecutor that she had attended the meeting organised by a group called the Peace Mothers' Initiative as the President of the Istanbul Human Rights Association.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant claimed before the Beyoğlu public prosecutor that she had been arrested by the police for no reason.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant stated before the Beyoğlu public prosecutor that she had merely exercised her legal rights.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicant stated before the Beyoğlu public prosecutor that she had not breached the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant was released from police custody on 29 October 2003, after being questioned by the Beyoğlu public prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police during a demonstration in Istanbul"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 6 November 2003, the applicant lodged a complaint with the Beyoğlu public prosecutor against the police officers who had been involved in the incident of 29 October 2003 and had arrested her.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "In her complaint of 6 November 2003, the applicant complained of the unlawfulness of her arrest by the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "In her complaint of 6 November 2003, the applicant complained of the excessive use of force by the police officers during her arrest.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 6 November 2003, the applicant was referred to the Istanbul branch of the Forensic Medical Institute by the Beyoğlu public prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The doctor at the Istanbul branch of the Forensic Medical Institute who examined the applicant noted a 2 x 6 cm ecchymosis on the back of her left leg.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The doctor at the Istanbul branch of the Forensic Medical Institute concluded that the injury rendered the applicant unfit for work for five days.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The doctor at the Istanbul branch of the Forensic Medical Institute noted that the applicant was suffering from pain in her right shoulder and right arm.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 12 November 2004, the Beyoğlu public prosecutor issued a decision not to prosecute the police officers who had been on duty at the press conference of 29 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Beyoğlu public prosecutor relied on the incident report prepared by the police officers in issuing the decision not to prosecute.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The Beyoğlu public prosecutor noted that the demonstrators had gathered illegally without obtaining permission and had disturbed public order by blocking the pedestrian zone and tramway.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Beyoğlu public prosecutor noted that, despite warnings by the police, the demonstrators had refused to disperse, and the police had therefore been obliged to use some degree of force to disperse them and restore public order.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Beyoğlu public prosecutor considered that the force used by the security forces had been in line with section 24 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) and had been justified in the circumstances.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "In the Beyoğlu public prosecutor's opinion, the applicant's injuries were the result of a proportionate use of force which did not amount to ill-treatment or abuse of authority.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 23 December 2004, the applicant lodged an appeal with the Istanbul Assize Court against the Beyoğlu public prosecutor's decision of 12 November 2004 not to prosecute the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "In her appeal, the applicant claimed that on 29 October 2003 police officers had beaten her during her arrest, causing injuries rendering her unfit for work for five days, as corroborated by the medical report from the hospital.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "In her appeal, the applicant alleged that the participants had not blocked the tramway or pedestrian traffic.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "In her appeal, the applicant asked the Istanbul Assize Court to order the prosecuting authorities to bring charges against the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 30 December 2004, the Istanbul Assize Court dismissed the applicant's appeal against the Beyoğlu public prosecutor's decision not to prosecute the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court dismissed the applicant's appeal having regard to the content of the file and the reasons given by the Beyoğlu public prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court's decision of 30 December 2004 was served on the applicant on 16 February 2005.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the police officers"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 7 November 2003, the Beyoğlu public prosecutor brought charges against thirteen demonstrators, including the applicant, for violation of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "In her defence submissions before the court, the applicant claimed that, in participating in the demonstration, she had merely been exercising her democratic rights.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "In a judgment dated 19 December 2006, the Beyoğlu Assize Court acquitted the applicant and her co-accused of the charges of violating the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Beyoğlu Assize Court held that there was no convincing evidence indicating with sufficient certainty that the accused committed the alleged offence of breaching the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Beyoğlu Assize Court noted from the incident report that the security forces took measures following an intelligence report that the Peace Mothers' Initiative, Gök-Der, Tuad and Yakay-Der associations were to hold a demonstration in front of the post office in the Galatasaray district.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Beyoğlu Assize Court noted that after the demonstrators gathered, the chair of the association Yakay-Der stated that they would stage a sit-in in front of the Galatasaray post office.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Beyoğlu Assize Court noted that following a police warning that the meeting was unlawful, the demonstrators told the police that they would make a press statement and then disperse.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Beyoğlu Assize Court noted that the police teams did not release the group and continued to keep them within a circle.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Beyoğlu Assize Court noted that the police arrested the demonstrators without giving a proper warning that could be heard by everyone, and that no evidence was provided to substantiate the assertion that a warning was given.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Beyoğlu Assize Court held that no evidence was adduced to indicate that the accused committed the alleged offence in contravention of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) and that their action went beyond the exercise of their democratic rights.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Beyoğlu Assize Court held that the actions of the accused were merely an exercise of their democratic rights to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The relevant domestic law applicable to the case can be found in the case of Nurettin Aldemir and Others v. Turkey (application nos. 32124/02, 32126/02, 32129/02, 32132/02, 32133/02, 32137/02 and 32138/02, §§ 20-23, 18 December 2007).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F040", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F047", "F048"], "interference": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F045", "F046"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F038", "F049"], "legitimate_aim": ["F027", "F028"], "necessity": ["F003", "F040", "F041", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F048"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F005", "F044", "F047", "F048"], "interference": ["F004", "F045", "F046"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F038", "F049"], "legitimate_aim": ["F027"], "necessity": ["F040", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F048"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F004", "F040", "F046", "F047", "F048"]}} {"case_name": "case_188", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants in protests against the Russian invasion of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The protests against the Russian invasion of Ukraine occurred in various parts of Moscow on 6 March 2022.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention in addition to their complaint about disproportionate measures.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_190", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The present case concerns the applicant's prosecution in relation to his participation in peaceful assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The Government were initially represented by Mr M. Galperin, former Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The Government were later represented by Mr M. Vinogradov, successor to Mr M. Galperin as Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 4 December 2011 the applicant took part in a rally in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The rally on 4 December 2011 in St Petersburg was a protest against the alleged fraud committed during the election to the State Duma on the same day.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Before the Court the applicant referred to a video accessible at an Internet video hosting service relating to the rally on 4 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The video relating to the rally on 4 December 2011 appeared to show that rally from different angles and at different moments.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The video relating to the rally on 4 December 2011 showed a police officer speaking through a loudspeaker and indicating that the rally had not received official approval from the competent authority.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The police officer shown in the video indicated that the rally was therefore in breach of the Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets, no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The police officer shown in the video indicated that participants' actions could amount to an administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The police officer shown in the video asked the journalists who were present at the venue of the rally not to impede the police in carrying out their duties.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The text of the police officer's announcement was repeated, in nearly identical terms, several times in the video relating to the rally on 4 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant was arrested following the rally on 4 December 2011 and taken to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant was released on 5 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 7 February 2012 a justice of the peace sentenced the applicant to a fine of 700 Russian roubles (approximately 18 euros) for an offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 7 February 2012 a justice of the peace sentenced the applicant to a fine of 700 Russian roubles (approximately 18 euros) for an offence under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On both charges arising from the 4 December 2011 rally, the justice of the peace held that the public event in the form of a meeting (митинг) had not been notified to the competent authority in breach of section 5 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On both charges arising from the 4 December 2011 rally, the justice of the peace held that the public event in the form of a meeting (митинг) had not been notified to the competent authority in breach of sub-paragraph 2 of paragraph 3 of section 6 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On both charges arising from the 4 December 2011 rally, the justice of the peace held that the police had informed the participants of the breach several times and had instructed them to stop the meeting and to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant appealed his convictions arising from the 4 December 2011 rally before the Kirovo-Chepetskiy District Court of the Kirov Region.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "In his appeal before the Kirovo-Chepetskiy District Court of the Kirov Region, the applicant argued that there had been no evidence that he personally (rather than the event itself or other people) had not complied with the statutory obligation to respect the 'public order' under sub-paragraph 2 of paragraph 3 of section 6 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant was notified of the appeal hearing before the Kirovo-Chepetskiy District Court of the Kirov Region but decided not to participate in it.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 26 March 2012 the Kirovo-Chepetskiy District Court of the Kirov Region upheld the trial judgments relating to the 4 December 2011 rally.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant received copies of the appeal decisions relating to the 4 December 2011 rally on an unspecified date.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 25 May 2012 the applicant sought review under Article 30.12 of the Code of Administrative Offences in respect of his conviction under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences arising from the 4 December 2011 rally.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 14 August 2012 the applicant sought review under Article 30.12 of the Code of Administrative Offences in respect of his conviction under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences arising from the 4 December 2011 rally.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 22 June 2012 the Deputy President of the Kirov Regional Court confirmed the applicant's conviction under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences on review.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 6 September 2012 the Deputy President of the Kirov Regional Court confirmed the applicant's conviction under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences on review.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Deputy President of the Kirov Regional Court stated that it was not 'possible' in a Code of Administrative Offences case to ascertain whether the police had acted lawfully.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PROTEST RALLY ON 4 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 6 December 2011 the applicant took part in another protest rally relating to the recent election to the State Duma.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The protest rally on 6 December 2011 was held at around 7.30 p.m. on a weekday near one of the entrances to a metro station.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "Before the Court the applicant referred to a video accessible at an Internet video hosting service relating to the rally on 6 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The content of the video relating to the rally on 6 December 2011 was similar to the video relating to the rally on 4 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The police arrested a number of people, including the applicant, at the rally on 6 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The police compiled an offence report in respect of the applicant following the rally on 6 December 2011, indicating that the rally in the form of a meeting was in breach of section 6 § 3 (2) of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The offence report compiled following the rally on 6 December 2011 indicated that Officer A. and other officers had made several warnings to the participants, specifying the breach of section 6 § 3 (2) of the Public Events Act and instructing them to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The offence report compiled following the rally on 6 December 2011 indicated that the applicant had not complied with the order to disperse and thereby committed an offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 7 December 2011 a justice of the peace sentenced the applicant to eleven days of detention for the offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences arising from the rally on 6 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 12 March 2012 the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of St Petersburg heard the applicant and upheld the judgment of 7 December 2011 in substance.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Kuybyshevskiy District Court of St Petersburg stated that the meeting on 6 December 2011 had been held next to an entrance to a metro station during the time when the passenger traffic had been intense.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Kuybyshevskiy District Court of St Petersburg stated that in view of the political nature of the event on 6 December 2011 entailing expressions of discontent and the large number of demonstrators, there had been a 'real threat to other people'.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 16 March 2012 the applicant sought review of the court decisions relating to the rally on 6 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 10 April 2012 the St Petersburg City Court upheld the court decisions relating to the rally on 6 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 17 August 2012 the Supreme Court of Russia upheld the court decisions relating to the rally on 6 December 2011 on the second review.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROTEST RALLY ON 6 DECEMBER 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 26 November 2012 the applicant and several other people staged a 'performance' aimed at 'reviving' the Russian Constitution.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The 'performance' on 26 November 2012 consisted of a coffin filled with brochures containing the text of the Russian Constitution, and a speech.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "During the 'performance' on 26 November 2012 the applicant held a poster saying 'Let us resurrect the Constitution'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "During the 'performance' on 26 November 2012 the applicant uttered several slogans including 'Follow your own laws', 'Stop the police state' and 'We need a different Russia'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The police were present during the 'performance' on 26 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "After the 'performance' on 26 November 2012 ended, the applicant was arrested and taken to the local police station.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 17 December 2012 a justice of the peace sentenced the applicant to a fine of 15,000 Russian roubles (approximately 373 euros) under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences in relation to the 'performance' on 26 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The justice of the peace considered that the 'performance' on 26 November 2012 amounted to a 'public event' regulated under the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The justice of the peace considered that the 'performance' on 26 November 2012 had not been notified to the competent authority and 'had been in breach of section 6 of the Public Events Act'.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The justice of the peace considered that the applicant had taken part in the unlawful 'performance' on 26 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The applicant appealed his conviction arising from the 'performance' on 26 November 2012, arguing that a lawful conviction under paragraph 5 of Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences required proof that as a participant he had breached the obligations or bans listed in section 6 §§ 3 and 4 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicant argued in his appeal that neither the offence report nor the trial judgment described or held against him any failure to comply with any ban or obligation under section 6 §§ 3 and 4 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 6 June 2014 the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of St Petersburg upheld the judgment relating to the 'performance' on 26 November 2012 in a summary manner.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicant sought review of the court decisions relating to the 'performance' on 26 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "In his application for review of the court decisions relating to the 'performance' on 26 November 2012, the applicant reiterated his arguments concerning the interpretation and application of section 6 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 9 September 2014 the St Petersburg City Court upheld the court decisions relating to the 'performance' on 26 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court held on 9 September 2014 that it was established that the applicant had held a poster and had distributed leaflets during the 'performance' on 26 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court held on 9 September 2014 that by holding a poster and distributing leaflets the applicant had taken part in a 'public event' which had not been notified to the competent authority.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 26 NOVEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 31 December 2012 the applicant took part in a rally at which the police were present.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PROTEST RALLY ON 31 DECEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicant was arrested during the rally on 31 December 2012, allegedly prior to hearing any specific order from the police and, a fortiori, prior to disobeying any such order.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PROTEST RALLY ON 31 DECEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "By a judgment issued on 1 January 2013 the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of St Petersburg sentenced the applicant to a fine of 700 Russian roubles (approximately 17 euros) under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences in relation to the rally on 31 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PROTEST RALLY ON 31 DECEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "By a separate judgment issued on 1 January 2013 the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of St Petersburg sentenced the applicant to a fine of 20,000 Russian roubles (approximately 497 euros) under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences in relation to the rally on 31 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PROTEST RALLY ON 31 DECEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Kuybyshevskiy District Court of St Petersburg held in relation to the charge under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences arising from the rally on 31 December 2012 that a police officer had informed the participants that the event had not been notified and 'had explained the consequences of taking part in such an event'.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PROTEST RALLY ON 31 DECEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 31 January 2013 the St Petersburg City Court held an appeal hearing in relation to the convictions arising from the rally on 31 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PROTEST RALLY ON 31 DECEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The applicant was present at the appeal hearing on 31 January 2013 before the St Petersburg City Court.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PROTEST RALLY ON 31 DECEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "At the closure of the appeal hearing on 31 January 2013 the St Petersburg City Court delivered the operative part of the appeal decisions upholding the trial judgments relating to the rally on 31 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PROTEST RALLY ON 31 DECEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "It appears that the applicant received the texts of the appeal decisions relating to the rally on 31 December 2012 on 21 February 2013.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PROTEST RALLY ON 31 DECEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court held in relation to the charge under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences arising from the rally on 31 December 2012 that the participants 'had been publicly notified by a police officer about the violation of the law'.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PROTEST RALLY ON 31 DECEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 12 April 2013 the Deputy President of the St Petersburg City Court confirmed the court decisions relating to the rally on 31 December 2012 on review.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PROTEST RALLY ON 31 DECEMBER 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 5 April 2013 the applicant took part in a public assembly together with fewer than twenty people near the building of the St Petersburg Administration of the Bank of Russia.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "It appears that the public assembly on 5 April 2013 was aimed at carrying the message that the Russian Government needed to prevent the removal of State-owned enterprises' revenues to offshore jurisdictions.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "According to the applicant, when the public assembly on 5 April 2013 was about to end, the police arrived and arrested him and some other participants.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "With reference to a video recording, the applicant was sentenced to a fine of 1,000 Russian roubles (approximately 21 euros) under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences for disobedience to a lawful police order to disperse, despite a repeated order from the police, in relation to the assembly on 5 April 2013.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "On appeal in relation to the assembly on 5 April 2013, the St Petersburg City Court watched the video recording and concluded that a police officer had once pronounced a phrase that the event had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court concluded on appeal that the video recording relating to the assembly on 5 April 2013 did not confirm that the police officer had made any repeated statements or orders to cease participation in the event.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court noted on appeal that the police officer had not been examined at the trial as regards the relevant circumstances of the assembly on 5 April 2013.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court quashed the conviction under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences arising from the assembly on 5 April 2013.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Following the quashing of the conviction, the first-instance court returned the case relating to the assembly on 5 April 2013 to the police.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The proceedings relating to the assembly on 5 April 2013 under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences were not pursued after the case was returned to the police.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 10 June 2013 the Nevskiy District Court of St Petersburg convicted the applicant under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences for organising and holding the public event on 5 April 2013 that had not been notified to the competent authority.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On 20 August 2013 the St Petersburg City Court upheld the judgment of 10 June 2013 relating to the assembly on 5 April 2013.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court held on 20 August 2013 that it was irrelevant for the offence under paragraph 2 of Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences whether the police had ordered a dispersal.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The applicant sought review of the court decisions relating to the assembly on 5 April 2013 under Article 30.12 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "In his application for review of the court decisions relating to the assembly on 5 April 2013, the applicant argued, referring to the video recording, that the police had only announced once their position on the legality of the event while making no specific order to disperse, and even less repeating any such order.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 21 November 2013 the Deputy President of the St Petersburg City Court reclassified the case relating to the assembly on 5 April 2013 under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Deputy President of the St Petersburg City Court held on 21 November 2013 that a participant's obligations as provided by law are not related to the fact whether that person took part in a public event which was or was not approved by the executive authority.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Deputy President of the St Petersburg City Court held on 21 November 2013 that irrespective of whether a public event was approved, a participant is required to comply with the obligations and bans provided for by the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Deputy President of the St Petersburg City Court held on 21 November 2013 that the applicant had participated in a public event in the form of a meeting on 5 April 2013 which had not been approved by the competent authority, and was therefore a participant rather than the organiser of that event.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Deputy President of the St Petersburg City Court held on 21 November 2013 that by participating in the meeting on 5 April 2013 and after being informed by the police that it was being held in breach of the notification requirement under the Public Events Act, the applicant did not comply with the lawful order from the police to stop the meeting and to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Deputy President of the St Petersburg City Court held on 21 November 2013 that the applicant had violated the obligations imposed on him as a participant of a public event, namely the obligation to comply with all lawful instructions from the police, and that his actions should be classified under paragraph 5 of Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Deputy President of the St Petersburg City Court sentenced the applicant on 21 November 2013 to a fine of 20,000 Russian roubles (approximately 450 euros at the time) in relation to the assembly on 5 April 2013.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Deputy President of the St Petersburg City Court noted on 21 November 2013 that the applicant had previously been prosecuted for similar offences.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 11 March 2014 the Supreme Court of Russia upheld the judgment of 21 November 2013 relating to the assembly on 5 April 2013.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Supreme Court of Russia confirmed on 11 March 2014, inter alia, that a participant's statutory obligations under section 6 § 3 of the Public Events Act applied both to notified and non-notified public events.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. RALLY ON 5 APRIL 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 27 June 2013 the applicant and five others came in front of the building of the local office of the Federal Migration Service in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On 27 June 2013 one of the group put a ladder to the wall of the Federal Migration Service building in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "On 27 June 2013 the applicant and another person climbed by a ladder onto the balcony at the first floor of the Federal Migration Service building in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "On the balcony of the Federal Migration Service building on 27 June 2013 the applicant and another person shouted the slogans 'FMS in Dushanbe' and 'Freedom to the people'.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On the balcony of the Federal Migration Service building on 27 June 2013 the applicant and another person unfolded a red flag with a white circle with a picture of a grenade.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The red flag with a white circle with a picture of a grenade unfolded on 27 June 2013 was apparently related to The Other Russia, a non-registered political party.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "A migration officer opened the balcony door of the Federal Migration Service building and invited the applicant and the other person to enter inside, and they complied.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Federal Migration Service office called the police following the 'performance' on 27 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Police officers arrived at the Federal Migration Service building and took the applicant to the local police station following the 'performance' on 27 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "An offence report was compiled accusing the applicant of an offence under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences following the 'performance' on 27 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The police considered that the 'performance' on 27 June 2013 amounted to an assembly regulated by the Public Events Act and thus required a prior notification to the St Petersburg city administration, but no such notification had been submitted.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "On 8 October 2013 the Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg convicted the applicant under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences and sentenced him to a fine of 20,000 Russian roubles (approximately 456 euros) in relation to the 'performance' on 27 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg considered that the 'performance' on 27 June 2013 concerned criticism of the legislation on migration and amounted to a 'public event' regulated by the Public Events Act, specifically a group static demonstration (a 'picketing').", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg considered that the applicant was the organiser of the 'performance' on 27 June 2013 and that he had not notified it to the competent authority in breach of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The applicant appealed the judgment of 8 October 2013 relating to the 'performance' on 27 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "On 19 December 2013 the St Petersburg City Court considered that the applicant had participated in the demonstration on 27 June 2013 and had not been its organiser.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "On 19 December 2013 the St Petersburg City Court reclassified the charge relating to the 'performance' on 27 June 2013 under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences and upheld the fine of 20,000 Russian roubles.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court held on 19 December 2013 that Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences only concerns an organiser of a public event who violated section 5 § 5 of the Public Events Act prohibiting running a public event without notifying a public authority.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court held on 19 December 2013 that a participant's action or inaction during a public event should be classified under paragraph 5 of Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court held on 19 December 2013 that since the applicant had participated in the static demonstration on 27 June 2013 which had not been notified to the competent authority, he had acted as a participant rather than the organiser of that demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court noted on 19 December 2013 that the applicant had already been convicted of similar offences in 2012 and 2013 and decided that the fine of 20,000 Russian roubles was appropriate.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The applicant had not been present at the appeal hearing on 19 December 2013 before the St Petersburg City Court relating to the 'performance' on 27 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The text of the appeal decision of 19 December 2013 relating to the 'performance' on 27 June 2013 was dispatched to the applicant on 31 January 2014.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. \"PERFORMANCE\" ON 27 JUNE 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law, the Court referred to Lashmankin and Others v. Russia (nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, §§ 216-312, 7 February 2017) and Navalnyy v. Russia ([GC], nos. 29580/12 and 4 others, §§ 43-48, 15 November 2018).", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The provisions of domestic law directly relevant to the present case are set out in the relevant legal framework section of the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets, no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act) provides that the organiser of a public event must notify the executive or municipal authority of the event pursuant to sections 5 and 7 of the Act.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Section 6 § 3 of the Public Events Act provides that during a public event participants must comply with all lawful instructions given by the event organiser, the persons designated by the organiser, the designated representative of the executive authority of the constituency of the Russian Federation or the municipality, or by law enforcement officers.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Section 6 § 3 of the Public Events Act provides that during a public event participants must respect the public order (общественный порядок) and the programme of the public event.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Section 6 § 3 of the Public Events Act provides that during a public event participants must comply with regulations aimed at ensuring transport safety and traffic security where vehicles are used for the public event.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation considered in decision no. 3089-O of 26 November 2018 that where during a public event a participant uses symbols or other elements of visual support which are prohibited by Russian law, this may amount to a breach of the obligation to respect the 'public order' under paragraph 3 of section 6 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "In June 2012 section 6 § 4 was added to the Public Events Act, providing that public event participants are not allowed to cover their face, including by way of using masks or other objects specially designed to impede a person's identification.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Section 6 § 4 of the Public Events Act, added in June 2012, provides that public event participants are not allowed to be in possession of arms or objects used as such, beer or beverages produced from it.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Section 6 § 4 of the Public Events Act, added in June 2012, provides that public event participants are not allowed to be in a state of alcoholic intoxication at the venue of the public event.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Pursuant to section 16 of the Public Events Act, the grounds for ending a public event shall be the emergence of a genuine threat to citizens' lives or health, and to the possessions of physical or legal persons.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Pursuant to section 16 of the Public Events Act, the grounds for ending a public event shall include commission by the participants of unlawful acts or a deliberate breach by the organiser of the rules for the conduct of public events established by the Act.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Pursuant to section 16 of the Public Events Act, since 2012 the grounds for ending a public event include non-compliance by the organisers with the obligations set out in section 5 of the Act.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Section 17 of the Public Events Act provides that if it is decided to end the public event, the representative of the executive or municipal authority shall give an order to the organiser of the public event to end the public event, having explained the reasons for its termination, and within twenty-four hours shall issue this order in writing and serve it on the organiser.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Section 17 of the Public Events Act provides that the representative of the executive or municipal authority shall set the time for compliance with the order to end the public event.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Section 17 of the Public Events Act provides that if the organiser does not comply with the order to end the public event, the representative of the executive or municipal authority shall directly address the participants of the public event and set an additional time for compliance with the order to end the public event.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Section 17 of the Public Events Act provides that in the event of non-compliance with the order to end the public event, the police shall take the necessary measures to end the public event.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Section 17 of the Public Events Act provides that the procedure for ending a public event shall not apply in the event of mass disorder, mob violence, arson, or other situations requiring urgent action.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. PUBLIC EVENTS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided at the relevant time that disobedience to a lawful order or request made by a police officer, a military officer or a detention facility officer in connection with the exercise of duties relating to securing public order and public safety was punishable with a fine of 500 to 1,000 Russian roubles or administrative detention for up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided at the relevant time that resistance to a police officer, military officer or detention facility officer in the exercise of their official duties was punishable with a fine of 500 to 1,000 Russian roubles or administrative detention for up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided, prior to June 2012, that violation of the rules for running a public event was punishable by a fine of 1,000 to 2,000 Russian roubles as regards organisers.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided, prior to June 2012, that violation of the rules for running a public event was punishable by a fine of 500 to 1,000 Russian roubles for participants.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Since June 2012 Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences was amended to contain a new paragraph 5 concerning participants, providing that violation by a participant in a public event of the rules for running a public event was punishable with a fine of from 10,000 to 20,000 Russian roubles or up to forty hours of community work.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "On 26 June 2018 the Plenary of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation adopted the Resolution 'On certain questions arising during judicial examination of administrative cases and cases on administrative offences related to the application of the legislation on public events'.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation's Resolution of 26 June 2018 provided guidelines indicating that the violation by a participant in a public event of the established procedure for running a public event — constituting an offence under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences — is only established where the demonstrator did not comply with one of the obligations and prohibitions incumbent on demonstrators under section 6 §§ 3 and 4 of the Public Events Act, including the obligation to comply with all legal orders made by the police, military officers or National Guard officers.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation's Resolution of 26 June 2018 provided guidelines indicating that the failure by a participant in a public event to comply with lawful orders or instructions of the police was to be classified under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences, which was in these circumstances to be regarded as a lex specialis in relation to Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (§ 33 of the Resolution).", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "In Ruling no. 19-P of 17 May 2021 the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation held that the constitutional right of peaceful assembly implies a real opportunity — through organising and participating in public events regulated under the Public Events Act — to influence the activities of public authorities by way of maintaining a civilised dialogue between civic society and the State.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation held in Ruling no. 19-P of 17 May 2021 that the constitutional right of peaceful assembly does not exclude the protest nature of public events or criticism directed at specific acts or actions on the part of public authorities or at their policies.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "The Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation held in Ruling no. 19-P of 17 May 2021 that the authorities' reaction to public events should be neutral and — irrespective of political, cultural or other views expressed by organisers or demonstrators — should be aimed at facilitating the lawful exercise of freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation held in Ruling no. 19-P of 17 May 2021 that legislative, regulatory or other measures on the part of public authorities should not unjustifiably restrict the constitutional right of peaceful assembly, and that restrictions should be based on the principles of necessity and proportionality, with due regard to the presumption in favour of the organisers' and demonstrators' willingness to maintain the peaceful nature of the event.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation held in Ruling no. 19-P of 17 May 2021 that Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences, which uses a 'blanket reference' technique, should be interpreted and applied with reference to the contents of the relevant legislation and regulations, and that it is precisely their breach — specifically as regards the notification procedure for public events — that constitutes an element of the administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Section 13 § 1 (1) and (7) of the Police Act (Federal Law no. 3-FZ of 7 February 2011) provides that outside the context of public events being held lawfully, the police is authorised to make an oral order requiring citizens to disperse or to go to another location where the amassing of people poses a threat to their lives or health, the lives or health of other citizens, possessions, or interferes with the work of organisations or impedes the traffic of vehicles or pedestrians.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "III. POLICE ACT 2011"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F005", "F006", "F031", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F049", "F064", "F075", "F100", "F101", "F102", "F103", "F104", "F001", "F032", "F036", "F038", "F067", "F068", "F073", "F093", "F115", "F018", "F019", "F054", "F094", "F110", "F116", "F119"], "interference": ["F016", "F017", "F039", "F067", "F096", "F018", "F019", "F036", "F054", "F068", "F094", "F110"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F126", "F127", "F145", "F147", "F154"], "legitimate_aim": ["F125", "F126", "F127"], "necessity": ["F005", "F006", "F031", "F014", "F035", "F039", "F024", "F030", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F044", "F032", "F064", "F067", "F068", "F073", "F065", "F145", "F074", "F079", "F080", "F082", "F090", "F094", "F095", "F096", "F053", "F054", "F058", "F063", "F112", "F113", "F018", "F019", "F110", "F116", "F119", "F106", "F107", "F108"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F001", "F005", "F006", "F031", "F046", "F064", "F075", "F100", "F102", "F093", "F115", "F036", "F068"], "interference": ["F016", "F017", "F039", "F067", "F096"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F126", "F145", "F147", "F154"], "legitimate_aim": ["F125", "F126"], "necessity": ["F005", "F006", "F031", "F024", "F030", "F036", "F039", "F065", "F068", "F073", "F067", "F096", "F145", "F018", "F054", "F094", "F110", "F116", "F079", "F080", "F082", "F090", "F106", "F108", "F053", "F063", "F112"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F001", "F005", "F006", "F031", "F064", "F075", "F018", "F030", "F036", "F065", "F068", "F079", "F080", "F082", "F090", "F039", "F067", "F145"]}} {"case_name": "case_191", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants raised complaints other than disproportionate measures under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003"], "interference": ["F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003"], "interference": ["F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_192", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_194", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_195", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_196", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention and its Protocols.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_197", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "All of the applicants, except for the applicant in application no. 51989/21, also raised other complaints under the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_198", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some of the applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_199", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant's details and information relevant to the application are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant complained of the lack of impartiality of the tribunal in view of the absence of the prosecuting party in administrative-offence proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant raised other complaints under the provisions of Protocol No. 7.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F003"], "interference": ["F001", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F001"], "interference": ["F001"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F001"]}} {"case_name": "case_200", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1975.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1953.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1969.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The fourth applicant was born in 1981.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The first applicant lives in Pepeni.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The second applicant lives in Chișinău.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The third applicant lives in Ungheni.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The fourth applicant lives in Chișinău.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "All four applicants are members of Hyde Park, a Chișinău-based non-governmental organisation.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 27 March 2008 the first applicant participated in a public gathering in the Stefan cel Mare park in Chișinău on the occasion of the anniversary of the 1918 reunification of Bessarabia with Romania.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 27 March 2008 the fourth applicant participated in a public gathering in the Stefan cel Mare park in Chișinău on the occasion of the anniversary of the 1918 reunification of Bessarabia with Romania.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The demonstration held on 27 March 2008 in the Stefan cel Mare park in Chișinău had been authorised by the Chișinău Municipality.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "At approximately 11.30 a.m. on 27 March 2008 the first and fourth applicants were arrested.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "After their arrest on 27 March 2008, the first and fourth applicants were taken to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "At the police station on 27 March 2008, the first and fourth applicants were charged with resisting arrest.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "At the police station on 27 March 2008, the first and fourth applicants were charged with insulting police officers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "In a video filmed by the applicants, one of the police officers can be seen requesting identity papers from one of the participants in the demonstration of 27 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In the video filmed by the applicants, after an identity card was presented to the police officer, one of the police officers ordered the applicants to follow him to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "In the video filmed by the applicants, the applicants complied with the police officer's order to follow him to the police station without any resistance.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The first and fourth applicants were released several hours after their arrest on 27 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 26 May 2008 the Buiucani District Court finally acquitted the applicants of all charges arising from the events of 27 March 2008 in view of a lack of evidence against them.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Buiucani District Court found that the accusations made against the applicants in connection with the events of 27 March 2008 were groundless as they were not confirmed by any of the witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On an unspecified date one of the applicants lodged a criminal complaint against the police officers who had arrested the applicants on 27 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 30 May 2008 the criminal complaint lodged against the police officers who had arrested the applicants on 27 March 2008 was dismissed as manifestly ill-founded.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 27 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 22 April 2008 a new Assemblies Act entered into force under which no authorisation was needed for spontaneous gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 22 April 2008 a new Assemblies Act entered into force under which no authorisation was needed for gatherings with a limited number of participants.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 22 April 2008, at approximately 10.40 a.m., the first applicant organised a demonstration in front of the residence of the President of Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 22 April 2008, at approximately 10.40 a.m., the second applicant organised a demonstration in front of the residence of the President of Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 22 April 2008, at approximately 10.40 a.m., the fourth applicant organised a demonstration in front of the residence of the President of Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the applicants, the intended purpose of the demonstration on 22 April 2008 in front of the residence of the President of Moldova was to express their joy at the entering into force of the new Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the applicants, the intended purpose of the demonstration on 22 April 2008 in front of the residence of the President of Moldova was to encourage the people to assemble freely.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "After a short time during the demonstration on 22 April 2008, the first, second and fourth applicants were approached by several police officers who ordered them to leave.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The first, second and fourth applicants refused to leave when ordered to do so by police officers on 22 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The first, second and fourth applicants argued that according to the new Assemblies Act they had a right to protest peacefully without any authorisation on 22 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The first, second and fourth applicants were arrested during the demonstration on 22 April 2008 in front of the residence of the President of Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "After their arrest on 22 April 2008, the first, second and fourth applicants were taken to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The first, second and fourth applicants were held at the police station for several hours following their arrest on 22 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The first, second and fourth applicants were charged with the offence of holding an unauthorised demonstration following their arrest on 22 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The first, second and fourth applicants were charged with the offence of resisting arrest following their arrest on 22 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The first, second and fourth applicants were charged with the offence of insulting police officers following their arrest on 22 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 8 May 2008 the Buiucani District Court acquitted the first, second and fourth applicants of all charges arising from the events of 22 April 2008 in view of a lack of incriminating evidence against them.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Buiucani District Court found that the first, second and fourth applicants had a legal right to protest in front of the residence of the President of Moldova without any authorisation on 22 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Buiucani District Court found that the charges concerning resisting police officers brought against the first, second and fourth applicants in connection with the events of 22 April 2008 were groundless.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Buiucani District Court found that the charges concerning insulting police officers brought against the first, second and fourth applicants in connection with the events of 22 April 2008 were groundless.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On an unspecified date the applicants lodged a criminal complaint against the police officers who had arrested them on 22 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The criminal complaint lodged against the police officers who had arrested the applicants on 22 April 2008 was dismissed as manifestly ill-founded.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 22 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 30 April 2008 the National Television company organised a celebration on the occasion of its fiftieth anniversary.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "O.B., a member of Hyde Park who is not an applicant in this case, attempted to protest against censorship at National Television on 30 April 2008 in front of the concert hall in which the National Television fiftieth anniversary celebration was taking place.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "O.B. was draped in a banner bearing the inscription '50 years of lies' during the protest on 30 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "O.B. was accompanied by the first applicant during the protest on 30 April 2008 in front of the concert hall.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "O.B. was accompanied by the second applicant during the protest on 30 April 2008 in front of the concert hall.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "O.B. was accompanied by the third applicant during the protest on 30 April 2008 in front of the concert hall.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "One of the first, second or third applicants was filming the event on 30 April 2008 in front of the concert hall.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "After approaching the concert hall on 30 April 2008, O.B. was approached by a group of police officers who surrounded him and ordered him to vacate the premises of the concert hall.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "O.B. and the first, second and third applicants entered into a verbal clash with the police officers on 30 April 2008 and refused to leave the concert hall premises.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "O.B. and the first, second and third applicants argued on 30 April 2008 that they had the right to protest and that the actions of the police were unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "After several minutes of dispute on 30 April 2008, O.B. was physically attacked by a person in plain clothes.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "O.B. and the first, second and third applicants requested the assistance of the police on 30 April 2008 following the physical attack on O.B.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "O.B. and the first, second and third applicants shouted on 30 April 2008 that the attack on O.B. had been provoked by the police.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "O.B. and the first, second and third applicants were immediately arrested on 30 April 2008 and taken to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "O.B. and the first, second and third applicants were charged with the offence of holding an unauthorised demonstration following their arrest on 30 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "O.B. and the first, second and third applicants were charged with the offence of resisting arrest following their arrest on 30 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "O.B. and the first, second and third applicants were charged with the offence of insulting police officers following their arrest on 30 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "O.B. and the first, second and third applicants were released several hours after their arrest on 30 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 18 June 2008 all the applicants and O.B. were finally acquitted by the Chișinău Court of Appeal of all charges arising from the events of 30 April 2008 in view of a lack of incriminating evidence against them.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Chișinău Court of Appeal reached its acquittal decision on 18 June 2008 after viewing the video of the event of 30 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Chișinău Court of Appeal concluded that the applicants' demonstration on 30 April 2008 had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Chișinău Court of Appeal concluded that the applicants had been attacked by another individual during the events of 30 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On an unspecified date the applicants lodged a criminal complaint against the police officers who had arrested them on 30 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The criminal complaint lodged against the police officers who had arrested the applicants on 30 April 2008 was dismissed as manifestly ill-founded.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 30 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "In December 2008 the Government of Moldova decided to celebrate Christmas exclusively on 7 January, according to the old religious calendar.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "In December 2008 the Government of Moldova decided to have a Christmas tree installed in the central square of Chișinău only in the last few days of December so as to bypass the celebration of Christmas on 25 December by the adherents of the new religious calendar.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "In spite of the central Government's decision, the Chișinău local government, which was represented by a political majority different from that of the central Government, decided to install a Christmas tree in the middle of December 2008.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Chișinău local government decided to organise celebrations on the occasion of the Christmas celebrated on 25 December according to the new religious calendar.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 16 December 2008 a truck transporting the Chișinău municipality's Christmas tree was stopped by the police.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 16 December 2008 the Chișinău municipality's Christmas tree was confiscated by the police.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "In the morning of 18 December 2008 a group of Hyde Park members, including the first and second applicants, attempted to organise a protest demonstration in front of the Ministry of Internal Affairs in order to express their concern about the actions of the police regarding the Christmas tree.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 18 December 2008 the first applicant was arrested on the street while walking towards the building of the Ministry of Internal Affairs carrying a small Christmas tree.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "After his arrest on 18 December 2008, the first applicant was taken to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The first applicant was charged with the offence of organising an unauthorised demonstration following his arrest on 18 December 2008.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The first applicant was released several hours after his arrest on 18 December 2008.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 18 December 2008 the second applicant was near a trolleybus stop when a group of six plain-clothes police officers forced him into a trolleybus.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The six plain-clothes police officers cornered the second applicant in the trolleybus on 18 December 2008 and, in spite of his protests, released him only approximately eight minutes and several stops later.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The applicants submitted a video of the events involving the second applicant on 18 December 2008.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 18 December 2008 the first applicant was acquitted in view of a lack of incriminating evidence against him in connection with the events of that date.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On an unspecified date the first and second applicants lodged a criminal complaint against the police officers in connection with the events of 18 December 2008.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "On 2 February 2009 the criminal complaint lodged by the first and second applicants against the police officers in connection with the events of 18 December 2008 was dismissed as manifestly ill-founded.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The events of 18 December 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "On 3 February 2009 the first applicant organised a protest demonstration in front of the Prosecutor General's Office together with approximately twenty participants who are not applicants in this case.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The events of 3 February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The aim of the demonstration on 3 February 2009 in front of the Prosecutor General's Office was to denounce the inaction of the Prosecutor General's Office in connection with abuses by the police.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The events of 3 February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Several minutes after the beginning of the demonstration on 3 February 2009, the protesters were attacked by seven men wearing masks.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The events of 3 February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The seven masked attackers started to beat up the protesters during the demonstration on 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The events of 3 February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The seven masked attackers sprayed the protesters with tear gas during the demonstration on 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The events of 3 February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The protesters defended themselves during the attack on 3 February 2009 and managed to immobilise two of the attackers.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The events of 3 February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "One of the attackers on 3 February 2009 admitted to having been paid 1,000 Moldovan lei by an unknown person to participate in the attack.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The events of 3 February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "A police unit patrolling nearby did not intervene to put an end to the clash between the protesters and the attackers on 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The events of 3 February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The protesters called the police on 3 February 2009 and requested the assistance of the police officers who were guarding the Prosecutor General's Office, but to no avail.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The events of 3 February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "According to the applicants, the organisers of the demonstration of 3 February 2009 lodged a criminal complaint with the Prosecutor General's Office; however, no action was taken.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The events of 3 February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The applicants were unable to present proof that they had lodged a criminal complaint with the Prosecutor General's Office in connection with the events of 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The events of 3 February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The applicants argued that the relevant documents proving the lodging of the criminal complaint had been seized by the police on the occasion of an unlawful search of Hyde Park's premises.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The events of 3 February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Government disputed that the applicants had complained to the Prosecutor General's Office in respect of the events of 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The events of 3 February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Article 32(1) of the Constitution of the Republic of Moldova guarantees each citizen freedom of thought and of opinion, as well as freedom of expression in public through words, images or other available means.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "Article 32(2) of the Constitution of the Republic of Moldova provides that freedom of expression shall not be prejudicial to the honour or dignity of others or the right of others to have their own opinion.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "Article 32(3) of the Constitution of the Republic of Moldova provides that the law prohibits and punishes the calling into question and defamation of the State and the nation, calls to war and aggression, national, racial or religious hatred, and incitement to discrimination, territorial separatism, or public violence, as well as any other expression which endangers the constitutional order.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "Article 40 of the Constitution of the Republic of Moldova provides that all meetings, demonstrations, rallies, processions or any other assemblies are free, but they may be organised and take place only peacefully and without the use of weapons.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Section 6(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be conducted peacefully, without any sort of weapons, and the protection of participants and the environment must be ensured, without impeding the normal use of public highways, road traffic or the operation of businesses, and without degenerating into acts of violence capable of endangering public order or the physical integrity or life of persons or their property.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Section 7 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be suspended in circumstances including: denial and defamation of the State and of the people; incitement to war or aggression and incitement to hatred on ethnic, racial or religious grounds; incitement to discrimination, territorial separatism or public violence; and acts that undermine the constitutional order.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Section 8(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies may be conducted in squares, streets, parks and other public places in cities, towns and villages, and also in public buildings.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Section 8(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct an assembly in the buildings of public authorities, local authorities, prosecutors' offices, courts or companies with armed security.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Section 8(3)(a) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct assemblies within fifty metres of the Parliament building, the residence of the President of Moldova, the seat of the Government, the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Section 8(3)(b) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct assemblies within twenty-five metres of the buildings of the central administrative authority, the local public authorities, courts, prosecutors' offices, police stations, prisons and social rehabilitation institutions, military installations, railway stations, airports, hospitals, companies which use dangerous equipment and machines, and diplomatic institutions.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Section 8(4) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that free access to the premises of the institutions listed in section 8(3) shall be guaranteed.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Section 8(5) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local public authorities may, if the organisers agree, establish places or buildings for permanent assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Section 11(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that not later than fifteen days prior to the date of the assembly, the organiser shall submit a notification to the Municipal Council.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate: the name of the organiser and the aim of the assembly; the date, starting time and finishing time; the location and access and return routes; the manner in which the assembly is to take place; the approximate number of participants; the persons responsible for the proper conduct of the assembly; and the services the organiser asks the Municipal Council to provide.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Section 11(3) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that if the situation so requires, the Municipal Council may alter certain aspects of the prior notification with the agreement of the organiser of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Section 12(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall be examined by the local government of the town or village at the latest five days before the date of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Section 12(6) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local authorities may reject an application to hold an assembly only if, after consulting the police, they have obtained convincing evidence that the provisions of sections 6 and 7 will be breached with serious consequences for society.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Section 14(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that a decision rejecting an application to hold an assembly shall be reasoned and presented in writing, containing reasons for the refusal to issue the authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Section 15(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the organiser of the assembly may challenge the refusal in the administrative courts.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Section 19 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that participants in the assembly are required to respect the Act and other laws referred to therein, to respect the instructions of the organiser of the assembly and decisions of the municipality or police, and to leave the assembly if asked by the organiser, the municipality or the police.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "On 22 February 2008 the Parliament of Moldova adopted a new Assemblies Act under which no authorisation was needed for the holding of demonstrations with less than fifty participants.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Article 166(1) of the Criminal Code of Moldova provides that illegal deprivation of liberty, other than kidnapping, shall be punishable by 120-240 hours of community work or imprisonment for up to two years.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Article 166(2) of the Criminal Code of Moldova provides that the same offence of illegal deprivation of liberty committed against two or more persons or by two or more persons shall be punishable by imprisonment for three to eight years.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Article 184(1) of the Criminal Code of Moldova provides that violation of the right to freedom of assembly by way of the illegal hindering of a demonstration, rally or act of protest, or the preventing of persons from taking part in them, when committed by an official, by two or more persons, or accompanied by acts of violence which do not pose a danger to life or health, shall be punishable by a fine of four to eight thousand Moldovan lei or by community work of 180-240 hours, or by imprisonment for up to two years.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Article 174 § 1(2) of the Code of Administrative Offences, in force at the material time, provides that the organisation and holding of an assembly without prior notification of the Municipal Council or without authorisation from the Council, or in breach of the conditions concerning the conduct of meetings indicated in the authorisation, shall be punishable by a fine imposed on the organisers in an amount equal to between MDL 500 and 1,000.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Article 174 § 1(4) of the Code of Administrative Offences, in force at the material time, provides that active participation in an unauthorised assembly shall be punishable by a fine in an amount between MDL 200 and 300.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Article 174 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences, in force at the material time, provides that resisting a police officer in the exercise of his or her duties of ensuring public order and the fight against crime shall be punishable by a fine of up to MDL 300 or detention for up to thirty days.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Article 174 § 6 of the Code of Administrative Offences, in force at the material time, provides that insulting police officers in the exercise of their duties shall be punishable by a fine of up to MDL 200 or imprisonment for up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Article 249 of the Code of Administrative Offences provides that persons who disobey in bad faith the lawful orders of police officers, or resist or insult police officers, may be detained until their case is examined by a court.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The relevant provisions of Law no. 1545 (1998) on compensation for damage caused by the illegal acts of the criminal investigation organs, prosecution and courts have been set out in the Court's judgment in Sarban v. Moldova, no. 3456/05, § 54, 4 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "In the case of Belicevecen v. the Ministry of Finance (no. 2ra-1171/07, 4 July 2007) the Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova found that a person could claim damages on the basis of Law no. 1545 (1998) only if he or she had been fully acquitted of all the charges against him or her.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "In the case of Belicevecen v. the Ministry of Finance (no. 2ra-1171/07, 4 July 2007), since Mr Belicevecen had been found guilty in respect of one of the charges brought against him, the Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova found he could not claim any damages under Law no. 1545 (1998).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F012", "F025", "F026", "F042", "F121", "F019", "F067", "F043", "F044", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F053", "F066", "F084", "F021", "F022", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F065", "F067", "F085"], "interference": ["F013", "F035", "F060", "F078", "F082"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F012", "F021", "F022", "F025", "F026", "F041", "F042", "F065", "F067", "F085", "F121"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F012", "F025", "F026", "F121", "F042", "F067", "F021", "F041", "F065", "F085"], "interference": ["F013", "F035", "F060", "F078", "F082"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F012", "F025", "F121", "F042", "F067", "F021", "F041", "F065", "F085"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F013", "F035", "F060", "F078", "F012", "F025", "F121", "F042", "F021", "F041", "F065", "F085", "F067"]}} {"case_name": "case_201", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1975.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Pepeni.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant is a journalist.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant is a member of Hyde Park, an unincorporated non-governmental organisation from Chișinău.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Hyde Park lobbies, inter alia, for freedom of expression and the right to peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Hyde Park organised a demonstration on 8 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Following the demonstration organised by Hyde Park on 8 May 2008, the applicant's brother was arrested and placed in detention.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant's brother is also a member of Hyde Park.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant was unable to trace his brother for two days after his brother's arrest.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicant decided to go on hunger strike because he was unable to trace his brother for two days.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 10 May 2008 at 10 a.m., the applicant stood outside the Government building in Chișinău's main square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 10 May 2008 at 10 a.m., the applicant positioned a placard with the inscription \"Hunger strike for rights\" outside the Government building in Chișinău's main square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 10 May 2008 at 10 a.m., the applicant started a silent protest outside the Government building in Chișinău's main square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Shortly after the applicant began his silent protest on 10 May 2008, police officers approached him.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Some of the police officers who approached the applicant asked him questions.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Some of the police officers who approached the applicant filmed him.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "At approximately 10.45 a.m. on 10 May 2008, the applicant was approached by two persons wearing plain clothes.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In a video filmed by the applicant, one of the two plain-clothed persons can be seen ordering the applicant to stop filming.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant refused the order to stop filming and stated that he is a journalist on hunger strike.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant asked the two plain-clothed persons for identification.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "One of the two plain-clothed persons hit the applicant, apparently in the hand holding the camera.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "One of the two plain-clothed persons threatened the applicant in rude terms with violence if he did not stop filming.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant backed away while insisting that he had the right to film.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant asked for the identity of the person who had hit him.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The person who hit the applicant identified himself as C.A., Commander of the Special Forces police regiment \"Scut\".", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "C.A. stated that he only wanted to talk with the applicant and insisted that the applicant stop filming.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant asked C.A. why he did not want to talk with the camera on.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "C.A. retorted that he was not an actor to be filmed.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant asked C.A. for identification documents.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "At the moment the applicant asked C.A. for identification documents, the applicant received another blow from C.A.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant continued to back away while being followed by the second plain-clothed police officer.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The second plain-clothed police officer appeared to forcefully put an end to the applicant's filming.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The video filmed by the applicant resumes for several seconds showing what appears to be a police van taking the applicant away from the scene of the event.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "In a video filmed by the police from another angle, the scene with the two plain-clothed police officers and the applicant can be seen from a distance.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "In the police video, the camera approaches when the second plain-clothed police officer forcefully puts an end to the applicant's filming.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The second plain-clothed police officer seized the applicant by his clothes and hands.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant asked the second plain-clothed police officer not to use force and insisted that he had the right to protest.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The second plain-clothed police officer retorted that by protesting the applicant was breaching the rights of other persons.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Two uniformed police officers approached and apprehended the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The two uniformed police officers took the applicant to a police van without any resistance from the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicant arrived at the police station at approximately 11 a.m. on 10 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicant's personal effects were taken away at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The applicant was questioned for approximately two hours at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the applicant, he insisted on being informed of the reasons for his arrest at the police station, but to no avail.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant was detained for forty-eight hours in solitary confinement in a cell without windows.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The temperature in the applicant's cell was approximately fourteen degrees centigrade.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant was wearing light clothes during his detention.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "There was a concrete bed in the applicant's cell, covered with wooden boards but without any bedding.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "There were no sanitary facilities in the applicant's cell.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The applicant had to ask the guards to be taken to a toilet.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The guards reacted to the applicant's request to be taken to a toilet only one or two hours later, when he screamed out loud in order to be heard by their superiors.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The only water the applicant had to drink during his detention was water from the sink in the toilet.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Throughout his detention the applicant was given no food.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Nobody was allowed to visit the applicant throughout his detention.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The applicant's cell was lit with a low-energy bulb which was on continuously, with no possibility to switch it off.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "After twelve hours of detention the applicant felt unwell.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicant's request for a doctor during his detention was ignored.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Only the next morning after the applicant felt unwell was a doctor called.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicant was taken by ambulance to a hospital.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The doctors at the hospital diagnosed the applicant with nephrolithiasis (kidney stones).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The doctors at the hospital diagnosed the applicant with renal colic (extremely sharp and severe pain caused by a renal stone blocking the ureter).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The doctors at the hospital decided to hospitalise the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The police officer accompanying the applicant to the hospital refused to allow the applicant to be hospitalised.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 12 May 2008 at 11 a.m., the applicant was taken to the Buiucani District Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "At the Buiucani District Court on 12 May 2008, the applicant learned that he had been charged with the offence of insulting police officers.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "At the Buiucani District Court on 12 May 2008, the applicant learned that he had been charged with the offence of resisting arrest.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The police accused the applicant of calling them \"rats\", \"cowards\" and \"Voronin's dogs\" when they peacefully approached him.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "At the end of the hearing on 12 May 2008, at 3 p.m., the applicant was released.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "After his release, the applicant had no money or mobile telephone.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "After his release, the applicant had to walk to the police station to pick up his belongings without laces on his shoes and without a belt.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "At the police station, the applicant discovered that the memory of his video camera (approximately forty-five minutes of film) had been erased.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The applicant sealed his video camera in the presence of two witnesses who signed a document attesting to the sealing.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The police officer responsible for the storage of the applicant's belongings refused to sign the document attesting to the sealing of the video camera.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On the same day the applicant picked up his belongings, the applicant took his video camera to an expert.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The expert succeeded in recovering 7-10% of the contents of the erased memory of the applicant's video camera, including the images described in the video of the applicant's encounter with the plain-clothed police officers.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 15 May 2008, the applicant lodged a criminal complaint with the Prosecutor's Office, complaining about the actions of the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "In his criminal complaint, the applicant complained that the police officers had physically and verbally aggressed him.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "In his criminal complaint, the applicant complained that the police officers had dispersed a peaceful protest held in accordance with the law.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "In his criminal complaint, the applicant complained that the police officers had unlawfully deprived him of his liberty for forty-eight hours.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "In his criminal complaint, the applicant complained that the police officers had unlawfully searched him.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "In his criminal complaint, the applicant complained that the police officers had seized his possessions.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "In his criminal complaint, the applicant complained that the police officers had erased the memory of his video camera.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The applicant complained that the police officers had breached several provisions of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On 26 May 2008, the criminal complaint lodged by the applicant was dismissed by the Prosecutor's Office.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The applicant appealed against the dismissal of his criminal complaint.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant added that he had been held in inhuman and degrading conditions.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant added that he had not been provided with appropriate medical assistance.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The video of the applicant's verbal and physical abuse in front of the Government building became the subject matter of a media scandal.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Several television stations reported on the event of the applicant's verbal and physical abuse in front of the Government building and broadcast the video footage.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 28 May 2008, the Minister of Internal Affairs formally admonished two police officers, C.A. and V.O.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The applicant was accused by the Minister of Internal Affairs of having provoked the police officers by insulting them and resisting arrest.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The applicant was described by the Minister of Internal Affairs as someone with a systematic tendency to disturb public order.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Without any explanations, C.A. and V.O. received an admonishment for breaching several rules of police conduct, in particular unprofessional conduct, dishonesty and failure to identify themselves.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "On 5 June 2008, the Buiucani District Court delivered its judgment acquitting the applicant of all charges.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Buiucani District Court examined the videos of the applicant's encounter with the police and his arrest of 10 May 2008 before delivering its judgment.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Buiucani District Court heard witnesses before delivering its judgment of 5 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Buiucani District Court found that the accusations against the applicant were false.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Buiucani District Court found that the applicant had not insulted the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Buiucani District Court found that the applicant had not resisted arrest.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 15 June 2008, the Chișinău Prosecutor's Office dismissed the applicant's appeal on the ground that the police officers' behaviour did not disclose an offence.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Chișinău Prosecutor's Office noted that the applicant had insulted the police officers by calling them \"rats\", \"cowards\" and \"Voronin's dogs\".", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Chișinău Prosecutor's Office noted that the two police officers who had physically and verbally assaulted the applicant had been admonished for their behaviour.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The applicant lodged an appeal on points of law against the Chișinău Prosecutor's Office's decision of 15 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On 2 July 2008, the Buiucani District Court dismissed the applicant's appeal against the Chișinău Prosecutor's Office's decision of 15 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "According to Law No. 26 of 22 February 2008, in force at the time of the events, no authorisation is needed to hold a peaceful demonstration with fewer than fifty participants.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "According to Article 308 of the Criminal Code of Moldova, unlawful arrest or detention is punishable with up to two years' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "According to Article 184 of the Criminal Code of Moldova, breach of the right to peaceful assembly by a public official is punishable with a fine, community service or up to two years' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "According to Article 328 of the Criminal Code of Moldova, abuse of authority accompanied by acts of violence is punishable with up to ten years' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "According to Article 249 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Moldova, persons who disobey in bad faith the lawful orders of police officers, or resist or insult police officers, may be detained until their case is examined by a court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F105", "F023", "F037", "F040", "F097", "F098", "F099"], "interference": ["F039", "F040", "F041", "F045"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F105", "F019", "F023", "F037", "F040", "F098", "F099", "F106", "F107", "F108"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F013", "F105", "F040", "F098", "F099"], "interference": ["F039", "F040"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F013", "F105", "F019", "F040", "F098", "F099"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F013", "F105", "F039", "F040", "F098", "F099"]}} {"case_name": "case_203", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1969.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Diósd.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 4 July 2002 the applicant organised a demonstration aimed at forcing the authorities to preserve the ballot papers of the 2002 legislative elections with a view to a potential recounting.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The Government submitted that the ballot papers were bound for statutory destruction on 20 July 2002 as per section 5(3) of Decree no. 48/2001 (XII. 29.) BM on the Procedural Time-limits for the Legislative Elections of 7/21 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "In the applicant's view, the relevant law could be understood — and was by many — to the effect that the ballot papers could be destroyed as early as 7 July 2002.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 2 July 2002, Parliament had decided not to put on the agenda a bill for the amendment of the 90-day statutory preservation period of the ballot papers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The demonstration organised by the applicant on 4 July 2002 had not been announced to the police.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The demonstration organised by the applicant on 4 July 2002 consisted of completely blocking all six lanes of Erzsébet Bridge, a centrally situated bridge over the Danube, by parking six cars across it with their doors locked.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The demonstration on 4 July 2002 started at about 8.20 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The demonstrators, including the applicant, refused to comply with the police's order to remove the vehicles and leave Erzsébet Bridge.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Apart from ambulances, no vehicles could pass the blockade on Erzsébet Bridge on 4 July 2002.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "By 9.00 a.m. on 4 July 2002 a crowd had gathered at Erzsébet Bridge and the situation evolved into a massive traffic jam all over Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "At about 11.00 a.m. on 4 July 2002 the cars blocking Erzsébet Bridge were finally towed away by the police.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Traffic flow on Erzsébet Bridge resumed at about 12 noon on 4 July 2002.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 5 July 2002 the Pest Central District Court imposed a regulatory fine of 50,000 Hungarian forints on the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Pest Central District Court held that the applicant, by not complying with the police's instruction to leave the site of the demonstration, had committed the regulatory offence of disorderly conduct within the meaning of section 142(1c) of Act no. LXIX on Regulatory Offences.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "International observers, in particular the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), found that the 2002 parliamentary elections in Hungary had been conducted in a manner consistent with international standards.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) found that the Hungarian electoral system had provided the basis for a generally transparent, accountable, free, fair and equal process in the 2002 parliamentary elections.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Hungarian media widely covered the events of 4 July 2002.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "In an official communiqué, the President of the Republic of Hungary condemned the incident of 4 July 2002, declaring it illegal.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The President of the Republic of Hungary underlined that Hungary was a stable parliamentary democracy where human rights were observed and where even critical views should be voiced in a lawful manner.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 2 September 2002 the Budapest XI District Police Department fined the applicant for a parking offence consisting of his parking his car in the middle of Erzsébet Bridge on 4 July 2002, necessitating its being towed away.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On appeal, on 15 May 2003 the Buda Central District Court reduced the parking fine imposed on the applicant to 5,000 Hungarian forints.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Criminal proceedings were subsequently instituted against the applicant and his accomplices in connection with the events of 4 July 2002.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 16 June 2008 the applicant was convicted of 'disturbance of public works' within the meaning of section 260(1) of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Pest Central District Court dismissed the defendants' arguments that they had been exercising their freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The Pest Central District Court made reference to the European Court of Human Rights' judgment in the case of Bukta and Others v. Hungary (no. 25691/04, ECHR 2007-III).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Pest Central District Court held that the applicant's action on 4 July 2002 could not be regarded as a spontaneous and prompt response to an event, as the court was satisfied that the statutory date for ballot paper destruction was 20 July 2002 as per Decree no. 48/2001.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Pest Central District Court held that the applicant's action on 4 July 2002 was not lawful, as it had contravened the Highway Code and disturbed the functioning of 'public works'.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Pest Central District Court observed that the demonstration on 4 July 2002 had caused traffic to become paralysed all over Budapest for several hours.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Pest Central District Court observed that the demonstration on 4 July 2002 disturbed the running of 29 bus lines in respect of 642 scheduled individual bus trips, concerning approximately 23,000 passengers.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to 30 days of community work by the Pest Central District Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 26 November 2008 the Budapest Regional Court upheld the Pest Central District Court's judgment convicting the applicant of disturbance of public works.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court noted that 'the message of the judgment is not that non-notified assemblies cannot be peaceful; the message is that an assembly, notified or non-notified, is not peaceful where, by its very manner, it constitutes unlawful conduct.'", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court referred to section 2(3) of Act no. III of 1989 on the Right of Assembly, according to which 'the exercise of the right of assembly may not constitute an offence, or instigation thereto, or violate the rights and freedoms of others'.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court quoted the European Court of Human Rights' judgment in the case of Ezelin v. France (26 April 1991, Series A no. 202), establishing that 'in peaceful assemblies the protection provided under Article 11 of the Convention shall be ensured for the participants as long as they do not commit any reprehensible act on such an occasion'.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court held that 'it directly follows from the case law of the Constitutional Court and the European Court of Human Rights that the peaceful or non-peaceful nature of an assembly does not depend on whether a participant broke or smashed an asset or applied violence against a property.'", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court held that an assembly may be rendered non-peaceful by passive conduct.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court held that the accused parties' conduct, which in its outward appearance seemed to be peaceful, was rendered non-peaceful by its causal result — the major disturbance of road traffic — and was thereby not protected under the law.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 3 December 2009 the Supreme Court of Hungary dismissed the defendants' petition for review of the judgment convicting the applicant of disturbance of public works.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Supreme Court of Hungary added to the reasoning of the lower courts that 'criminal law rules cannot be excluded or restricted by invoking the right of assembly; the exercise of the right of assembly shall not be exempt from compliance with criminal law restrictions.'", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Supreme Court of Hungary's decision of 3 December 2009 was served on the applicant on 18 January 2010.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Particular circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Section 260(1) of the Criminal Code, as in force at the relevant time, provided that any person who interferes with the functioning of public works to a considerable extent by damaging their equipment, cables or interfering with them in any other way, is guilty of a felony punishable by imprisonment of up to five years.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Section 260(4) of the Criminal Code, as in force at the relevant time, provided that for the purposes of section 260, 'public works' shall mean public utilities, public transportation operations, telecommunications networks, as well as plants producing war materials, energy or basic materials designed for industrial use.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Section 1 of Act no. V of 1991 on Certain Amnesty Measures provided that in connection with the road blockades paralysing the country's life from 25 to 28 October 1990, no criminal proceedings shall be instituted or conducted for the disturbance of public works under section 260 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The relevant domestic law on freedom of assembly, in particular Article 62 of the Hungarian Constitution and Act no. III of 1989 on the Right of Assembly, is outlined in paragraphs 19 and 20 of the European Court of Human Rights' judgment in Éva Molnár v. Hungary (no. 10346/05, 7 October 2008).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": false, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F025", "F033", "F039"], "interference": ["F025", "F032", "F033", "F040"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F043", "F045"], "legitimate_aim": ["F008", "F011", "F012", "F030", "F031"], "necessity": ["F004", "F006", "F009", "F010", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F034", "F036", "F037", "F041"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F008", "F010"], "interference": ["F025", "F032", "F040"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F043", "F045"], "legitimate_aim": ["F008", "F012", "F031"], "necessity": ["F004", "F009", "F010", "F012", "F013", "F025", "F027", "F028", "F030", "F032", "F036"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F004", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F012", "F013", "F025", "F028", "F030", "F032"]}} {"case_name": "case_204", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention or Protocols to the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_205", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants are Hungarian nationals.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1943.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1945.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1951.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants live in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 1 December 2002 the Romanian Prime Minister made an official visit to Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 1 December 2002 the Romanian Prime Minister gave a reception in Budapest on the occasion of Romania's national day.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Romania's national day commemorates the 1918 Gyulafehérvár National Assembly.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The 1918 Gyulafehérvár National Assembly was the occasion when the transfer of hitherto Hungarian Transylvania to Romania was declared.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Hungarian Prime Minister decided to attend the reception given by the Romanian Prime Minister on 1 December 2002.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Hungarian Prime Minister made his intention to attend the reception public the day before the event, i.e. on 30 November 2002.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicants were of the opinion that the Hungarian Prime Minister should refrain from attending the reception given by the Romanian Prime Minister on 1 December 2002.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicants considered the Gyulafehérvár National Assembly to have negative significance in Hungarian history.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicants decided to organise a demonstration in front of the Hotel Kempinski in Budapest where the reception was to be held.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicants did not inform the police of their intention to organise a demonstration in front of the Hotel Kempinski in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "In the afternoon of 1 December 2002, approximately 150 people assembled in front of the Hotel Kempinski in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicants were among the approximately 150 people who assembled in front of the Hotel Kempinski in Budapest on 1 December 2002.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The police were present at the assembly in front of the Hotel Kempinski in Budapest on 1 December 2002.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "There was a loud noise during the assembly in front of the Hotel Kempinski in Budapest on 1 December 2002.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The police decided to disband the assembly in front of the Hotel Kempinski in Budapest, considering that it constituted a risk to the security of the reception.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The police forced the demonstrators back to a park next to the Hotel Kempinski in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "After being forced to the park next to the Hotel Kempinski, the demonstrators dispersed after a while.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 16 December 2002 the applicants sought judicial review of the action of the police before the Pest Central District Court.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicants requested the Pest Central District Court to declare the police action of disbanding the assembly on 1 December 2002 unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicants asserted before the Pest Central District Court that the demonstration on 1 December 2002 had been totally peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicants asserted before the Pest Central District Court that the only aim of the demonstration on 1 December 2002 had been to express their opinion.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicants pointed out that it had obviously been impossible to inform the police about the assembly three days in advance, as required by Law no. III of 1989 on the right of assembly (the Assembly Act), because the Hungarian Prime Minister had only announced his intention to attend the reception the day before the event.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 6 February 2003 the Pest Central District Court dismissed the applicants' action seeking judicial review of the police action of disbanding the assembly on 1 December 2002.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Pest Central District Court noted that the demonstration on 1 December 2002 had been disbanded after a minor detonation was heard.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Pest Central District Court noted that the three-day time-limit for informing the police of a planned assembly could not possibly be observed if the demonstration had its roots in an event that had occurred less than three days beforehand.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Pest Central District Court was of the view that the possible shortcomings of Law no. III of 1989 on the right of assembly (the Assembly Act) could not be remedied by the courts.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Pest Central District Court held that the duty to inform the police about assemblies applied to every type of demonstration, including spontaneous ones.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Pest Central District Court noted that there might be a need for more precise and sophisticated regulations in respect of spontaneous assemblies but said that this was a task for the legislator, not the courts.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Pest Central District Court found that the duty to inform the police in advance about assemblies held in public served to protect the public interest and the rights of others, namely the free flow of traffic and the right to freedom of movement.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Pest Central District Court observed that the organisers of the demonstration on 1 December 2002 had not even attempted to notify the police.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Pest Central District Court stated that under the relevant provisions of Hungarian domestic law in force, the fact that an assembly is peaceful is not by itself enough to dispense with the duty to inform the police.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Pest Central District Court stated that it had not dealt with the issue of whether or not the assembly on 1 December 2002 was peaceful, since the lack of notification made it illegal per se.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Pest Central District Court stated that the police had dissolved the assembly on 1 December 2002 lawfully, pursuant to section 14(1) of Law no. III of 1989 on the right of assembly (the Assembly Act).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicants appealed against the Pest Central District Court's decision of 6 February 2003.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 16 October 2003 the Budapest Regional Court upheld the first-instance decision of the Pest Central District Court of 6 February 2003.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court amended part of the Pest Central District Court's reasoning by omitting the remarks concerning the possible shortcomings of the relevant domestic law.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court referred, inter alia, to the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights and to decision no. 55/2001 (XI. 29.) of the Hungarian Constitutional Court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court found that in the application of the relevant domestic law, there is no exemption from the duty of notification and therefore no difference between 'notified' assemblies and 'spontaneous' ones, the latter being unlawful owing to the failure to respect the duty of notification.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court found that the restrictions imposed on the applicants were necessary and proportionate.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicants lodged a petition for review with the Hungarian Supreme Court.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 24 February 2004 the Hungarian Supreme Court dismissed the applicants' petition for review without examining its merits.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Hungarian Supreme Court dismissed the applicants' petition for review because it was incompatible ratione materiae with the relevant provisions of the Hungarian Code of Civil Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Article 62 of the Hungarian Constitution guarantees the right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Article 62 of the Hungarian Constitution secures the free exercise of the right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Section 6 of Law no. III of 1989 on the right of assembly (the Assembly Act) requires the police to be informed of an assembly at least three days before the date of the event.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Section 14(1) of Law no. III of 1989 on the right of assembly (the Assembly Act) requires the police to disband any assemblies held without prior notification.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Section 14(3) of Law no. III of 1989 on the right of assembly (the Assembly Act) provides that if an assembly is dissolved its participants may seek judicial review within fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F017", "F018", "F020", "F026", "F038"], "interference": ["F021", "F022", "F023"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F051", "F052", "F039"], "legitimate_aim": ["F051", "F052", "F035"], "necessity": ["F007", "F008", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F020", "F021", "F026", "F028", "F033", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F044", "F051"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F017", "F018", "F020", "F026", "F038"], "interference": ["F021", "F022"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F051", "F052"], "legitimate_aim": ["F051", "F035"], "necessity": ["F012", "F051", "F016", "F020", "F038", "F044"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F012", "F051", "F052", "F016", "F038", "F020", "F044"]}} {"case_name": "case_209", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of the lack of impartiality of the tribunal in view of the absence of the prosecuting party in administrative-offence proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention, in addition to their complaint about the lack of impartiality of the tribunal.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001"], "interference": ["F001"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F001"], "interference": ["F001"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F001"]}} {"case_name": "case_210", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant, the Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia (Центр обществ сознания Кришны в России), is a centralised religious organisation.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia was established under Russian law on religious associations in 1992.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia has its registered office in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Frolov, was born in 1975.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Mr Frolov lives in the Moscow Region.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants were represented before the Court by Mr V. Borisov, vice-president of the Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicants were represented before the Court by Mr S. Minenkov, a lawyer practising in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Government were initially represented by Mr M. Galperin, former Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Government were later represented by Mr M. Vinogradov, successor to Mr M. Galperin as Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 15 September 2008 the Orthodox news agency Russkaya Liniya published an interview with A.M., a member of Orthodox clergy.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "A. Interview with an Orthodox priest"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "In the interview published by Russkaya Liniya on 15 September 2008, A.M. was quoted as saying that the Krishna Society was a 'demonically oriented religion'.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "A. Interview with an Orthodox priest"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "In the interview published by Russkaya Liniya on 15 September 2008, A.M. was quoted as saying that the Krishna Society 'profoundly affected the personality' of its followers.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "A. Interview with an Orthodox priest"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 23 September 2008 the Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia sent a letter of complaint to the St Petersburg office of the media regulator, seeking a declaration that A.M.'s allegations constituted extremist speech.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "A. Interview with an Orthodox priest"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 28 January 2009 the media regulator replied to the Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia that their experts had found no indications of racial, ethnic or religious hatred in A.M.'s statements.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "A. Interview with an Orthodox priest"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia unsuccessfully appealed to the head of the media regulator following the regulator's reply of 28 January 2009.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "A. Interview with an Orthodox priest"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia filed an application for judicial review following the unsuccessful appeal to the head of the media regulator.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "A. Interview with an Orthodox priest"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 10 November 2009 the Taganskiy District Court in Moscow held that, in so far as the media regulator had acted within its mandate and in accordance with the law, there had been no breach of the Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia's rights.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "A. Interview with an Orthodox priest"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 30 November 2010 the Moscow City Court upheld the Taganskiy District Court's decision of 10 November 2009.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "A. Interview with an Orthodox priest"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 1 November 2008 the official website of the Governor and Government of the Ulyanovsk Region announced that the project 'Beware: cults!' (Осторожно – секты!) was moving forward.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The chief objective of the project 'Beware: cults!' was stated to be the 'prevention of negative activities of destructive religious groups in the region'.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The project 'Beware: cults!' had begun in April 2008 with a conference co-organised by the Government of the Ulyanovsk Region and the Ulyanovsk State University.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "An action plan adopted at the conference co-organised by the Government of the Ulyanovsk Region and the Ulyanovsk State University had included the setting-up of an anti-cult hot line.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "An action plan adopted at the conference co-organised by the Government of the Ulyanovsk Region and the Ulyanovsk State University had included the organisation of roundtables and seminars with the participation of youth organisations, ministers of 'traditional denominations', authorities, educators and members of the public.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "An educational seminar titled 'Adverse effects of cults on the minds of children and youth' had been held on 31 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "At the educational seminar held on 31 October 2008, vice-principals of secondary schools, teaching staff, and religious ministers had discussed the religious situation in the Ulyanovsk Region.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "At the educational seminar held on 31 October 2008, teaching staff had been given pamphlets, posters and brochures to be distributed among their students.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The brochure 'Watch out for cults!' (Будьте внимательны: секты!) had been compiled in the framework of the project 'Beware: cults!' by experts of the Government of the Ulyanovsk Region together with staff of the Ulyanovsk State University.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The first deputy chief of staff of the Government of the Ulyanovsk Region was quoted as saying: 'the Government attaches particular importance to ... the protection of the population from the influence of totalitarian cults'.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "An electronic version of the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' was published on the Ulyanovsk regional Government's website.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The cover page of the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' listed 'Government of the Ulyanovsk Region' and 'Ulyanovsk State University' at the top, followed by the names of three authors.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The second page of the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' stated that the methodical recommendations had been compiled on the basis of works by prominent Russian and international religious scholars.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The second page of the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' stated that the methodical recommendations were addressed to administrators of educational institutions and officials in charge of education in the matter of destructive activities of totalitarian cults in the Ulyanovsk Region.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The second page of the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' stated that it was published by decision of the Government of the Ulyanovsk Region.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Chapter 2 of the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' provided an overview of 'non-traditional religious movements active in the Ulyanovsk Region', including Jehovah's Witnesses, Mormons, Unification Church of Rev. Moon, Scientology, and Krishna Society.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The section on the Krishna Society in the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' described members of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness as 'flamboyant groups of mostly young people dressed in white and yellow garments who sing unintelligible hymns to the beat of drums and other musical instruments'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The section on the Krishna Society in the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' described the International Society for Krishna Consciousness as a 'totalitarian cult'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The section on the Krishna Society in the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' described the life of the founder of the Krishna Societies, the precepts of the faith, rituals and dietary restrictions.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The section on the Krishna Society in the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' stated that 'the goals of Krishnaites are frequently rather materialistic: they seek to obtain money by all means'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The section on the Krishna Society in the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' stated that Krishnaites 'beg for money in the street, they sell their literature; in some countries, they have been caught stealing or selling drugs'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The section on the Krishna Society in the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' stated that money obtained by Krishnaites 'goes to the leaders of the cult who keep a close watch on that activity'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The section on the Krishna Society in the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' concluded that 'this religious movement is highly destructive for our society'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The section on the Krishna Society in the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' stated that the Krishna movement 'has no genetic, historic or geographic connection to our people' and is 'a peculiar spiritual culture of the East'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The section on the Krishna Society in the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' stated that 'zombification and psychological manipulation of our youth constitute a serious threat to our future'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 11 November 2008 the Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia complained to the Prosecutor General that the Government of the Ulyanovsk Region's anti-cult project discriminated against the Krishna movement by portraying it as a 'totalitarian cult'.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The complaint to the Prosecutor General dated 11 November 2008 was accompanied by a printout of the news from the official website of the Governor and Government of the Ulyanovsk Region.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The complaint to the Prosecutor General dated 11 November 2008 was accompanied by a copy of the brochure 'Watch out for cults!'.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The complaint to the Prosecutor General dated 11 November 2008 was accompanied by a detailed analysis of untrue or misleading allegations in the brochure 'Watch out for cults!'.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The complaint to the Prosecutor General was forwarded to the Ulyanovsk regional prosecutor's office.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 29 December 2008 the Ulyanovsk regional prosecutor's office replied that the State authorities had carried out the project 'Beware: cults!' within their legal authority.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 29 December 2008 the Ulyanovsk regional prosecutor's office replied that the primary objective of the project 'Beware: cults!' had been to discuss matters relating to an interfaith dialogue and build the best possible framework for a relationship between the State and religious organisations.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 29 December 2008 the Ulyanovsk regional prosecutor's office replied that the brochure 'Watch out for cults!' had been developed by staff of the Ulyanovsk State University and presented a variety of views on the activities of 'non-traditional religious organisations'.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 29 December 2008 the Ulyanovsk regional prosecutor's office advised the Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia that if they believed their rights had been violated, they should apply to a court for protection.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Further hierarchical appeals by the Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia following the Ulyanovsk regional prosecutor's office reply elicited similar responses.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia turned to a court for substantive review of the prosecutors' decisions after further hierarchical appeals elicited similar responses.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 27 October 2010 the Tverskoy District Court in Moscow held that the prosecutors had considered all the matters which the Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia had complained about and gave sufficient responses.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court in Moscow held on 27 October 2010 that the Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia's disagreement with the contents of the prosecutors' responses did not constitute a sufficient reason to impugn them.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 16 March 2011 the Moscow City Court upheld the Tverskoy District Court's judgment of 27 October 2010 on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOSTILE STATEMENTS ABOUT THE KRISHNA MOVEMENT", "B. Ulyanovsk Government's \"anti-cult\" project"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 1 April 2013 Mr Frolov submitted a notification to the prefecture of the Severo-Vostochnyy District in Moscow, stating his intention to hold, on 13 April 2013, a 'meeting to promote the teaching of Vaishnavism and a healthy lifestyle based on spiritual values', with up to fifteen people participating.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 2 April 2013 the prefecture of the Severo-Vostochnyy District in Moscow rejected Mr Frolov's notification on the grounds that 'the stated purpose – promoting the teaching of Vaishnavism – does not correspond to section 2(1) of the Public Events Act (Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004)'.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "In his application for judicial review, Mr Frolov contended that the prefecture's refusal had had no basis in law.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "In his application for judicial review, Mr Frolov contended that section 16(5) of the Religions Act (Law no. 125-FZ of 26 September 1997) established that religious assemblies outside religious buildings were to be held in accordance with the Public Events Act (Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In his application for judicial review, Mr Frolov contended that the Public Events Act (Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) governed the procedure for organising public events without imposing any specific purposes.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "In his application for judicial review, Mr Frolov contended that section 1(2) of the Public Events Act (Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) expressly provided for a possibility of holding religious events.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "In his application for judicial review, Mr Frolov contended that the authorities had not specified the nature of the alleged contradiction between the stated purpose of the meeting and section 2(1) of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "In his application for judicial review, Mr Frolov contended that the refusal had breached his rights to freedom of expression, assembly and religion.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 12 August 2013 the Meshchanskiy District Court in Moscow pronounced the prefecture's refusal of Mr Frolov's first notification to have been lawful and justified.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Meshchanskiy District Court in Moscow found on 12 August 2013 that the promotion of the teaching of Vaishnavism did not correspond to the purposes of a public event listed in section 2(1) of the Public Events Act (Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 16 January 2014 the Moscow City Court dismissed Mr Frolov's appeal against the Meshchanskiy District Court's decision of 12 August 2013.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Moscow City Court found on 16 January 2014 that 'the missionary activities, of which Mr Frolov had informed the prefecture, did not correspond to the lawful purposes of a public event'.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Moscow City Court found on 16 January 2014 that Mr Frolov's missionary activities were 'incompatible with the respect for the religious beliefs of others'.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Moscow City Court found on 16 January 2014 that 'the rejection of the notification of a public event was therefore lawful'.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Moscow City Court added on 16 January 2014 that the refusal did not restrict Mr Frolov's right to freedom of religion because he could promote the teaching of Vaishnavism 'by other lawful means and methods'.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "A. First notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 8 April 2013 Mr Frolov submitted a second notification to the prefecture of the Severo-Vostochnyy District in Moscow, stating his intention to hold, on 20 April 2013, a meeting to promote the teaching of Vaishnavism.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "B. Second notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 10 April 2013 the prefecture of the Severo-Vostochnyy District in Moscow rejected Mr Frolov's second notification on the grounds that the promotion of Vaishnavism did not correspond to the purposes of a public event in section 2(1) of the Public Events Act (Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "B. Second notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 10 April 2013 the prefecture of the Severo-Vostochnyy District in Moscow rejected Mr Frolov's second notification on the grounds that the Religions Act (Law no. 125-FZ of 26 September 1997) did not mention a 'meeting' as a form of religious event.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "B. Second notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Mr Frolov sent a letter of objection to the prefecture of the Severo-Vostochnyy District in Moscow following the rejection of his second notification, to which he received no reply.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "B. Second notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 20 April 2013 a few participants gathered at the designated location of the religious event planned by Mr Frolov.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "B. Second notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "On 20 April 2013 a police officer told the participants who had gathered at the designated location of Mr Frolov's religious event to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "B. Second notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 11 June 2013 the Ostankinskiy District Court in Moscow dismissed Mr Frolov's application for judicial review of the rejection of his second notification.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "B. Second notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Ostankinskiy District Court in Moscow found on 11 June 2013 that the prefecture had not actually refused to allow the public event to proceed but merely informed Mr Frolov that its stated purpose had been inconsistent with the law.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "B. Second notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 20 August 2013 the Moscow City Court dismissed Mr Frolov's appeal against the Ostankinskiy District Court's decision of 11 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "B. Second notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Moscow City Court held on 20 August 2013 that neither the Religions Act (Law no. 125-FZ of 26 September 1997) nor the Public Events Act (Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) made provision for holding a 'public event of a religious nature in the form of a meeting'.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "B. Second notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Moscow City Court held on 20 August 2013 that religious events could take the form of a service of worship, rite or ceremony, and that a 'meeting', 'as the term was generally applied', was none of them.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "B. Second notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Moscow City Court held on 20 August 2013 that it was 'evident' that 'promoting the teaching of Vaishnavism' was not 'a service of worship, a rite or a ceremony'.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "B. Second notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Moscow City Court held on 20 August 2013 that promoting the teaching of Vaishnavism fell outside the concept of a 'public event' in so far as it did not involve 'free expression and shaping of opinions [or] making demands on issues related to political, economic, social or cultural life'.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. Mr FROLOV'S ATTEMPTS TO HOLD A RELIGIOUS MEETING FOR THE PROMOTION OF THE TEACHING OF VAISHNAVISM", "B. Second notification to hold a religious meeting"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Programme of Comprehensive Measures for Crime Prevention in the Ulyanovsk Region in 2006-2010 was approved by Ulyanovsk Regional Law no. 100-ZO of 4 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. CRIME PREVENTION PROGRAMME OF THE ULYANOVSK GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Programme of Comprehensive Measures for Crime Prevention in the Ulyanovsk Region in 2006-2010 provided that the Regional Council for Religions and Ethnicities and the regional offices of the Ministry of the Interior and the Federal Security Service would co-operate with municipal authorities in matters relating to 'the activities of foreign missionaries and non-traditional religious associations which pose a security risk for the life and health of citizens'.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. CRIME PREVENTION PROGRAMME OF THE ULYANOVSK GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Point 5.3 of Annex 1 to the Programme of Comprehensive Measures for Crime Prevention in the Ulyanovsk Region in 2006-2010 listed 'the prevention of extremism and the termination of cultist activities' as objectives of the co-operation between the Regional Council for Religions and Ethnicities, the regional offices of the Ministry of the Interior and the Federal Security Service, and municipal authorities.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. CRIME PREVENTION PROGRAMME OF THE ULYANOVSK GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Religions Act (Law no. 125-FZ of 26 September 1997) established that private services of worship, religious rites and ceremonies could be conducted without hindrance in religious buildings or other premises made available to religious organisations for that purpose (section 16, subsection 2).", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PROCEDURE FOR CONDUCTING PUBLIC EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Religions Act (Law no. 125-FZ of 26 September 1997) established special rules for holding services in hospitals and on military grounds (section 16, subsections 3 and 4).", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PROCEDURE FOR CONDUCTING PUBLIC EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Religions Act (Law no. 125-FZ of 26 September 1997) established that in cases other than those covered by section 16 subsections 2, 3 and 4, public services of worship, religious rites and ceremonies were to be conducted in accordance with the procedure established for conducting meetings, marches and demonstrations (section 16, subsection 5).", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PROCEDURE FOR CONDUCTING PUBLIC EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Section 1(2) of the Public Events Act (Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) establishes that the conduct of 'religious rites and ceremonies' is governed by the Religions Act (Law no. 125-FZ of 26 September 1997).", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PROCEDURE FOR CONDUCTING PUBLIC EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Section 2(1) of the Public Events Act (Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) defines a 'public event' as 'an open, peaceful and publicly accessible event which is conducted in the form of an assembly, meeting, demonstration, march or picket or in various combinations of these forms, at the initiative of Russian nationals, political parties, public associations or religious associations'.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PROCEDURE FOR CONDUCTING PUBLIC EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Section 2(1) of the Public Events Act (Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) defines the purposes of a public event as 'free expression and shaping of opinions or making demands on various issues related to political, economic, social or cultural life in the country or its foreign policy'.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PROCEDURE FOR CONDUCTING PUBLIC EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Subsections 2 to 6 of section 2 of the Public Events Act (Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) describe various types of public events.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PROCEDURE FOR CONDUCTING PUBLIC EVENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F059", "F074", "F078", "F079", "F092", "F094", "F095"], "interference": ["F060", "F067", "F069", "F070", "F071", "F072", "F075", "F076", "F079", "F080", "F082", "F083"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F060", "F068", "F070", "F075", "F076", "F083", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F092", "F094", "F095", "F096"], "legitimate_aim": ["F060", "F071", "F075"], "necessity": ["F059", "F060", "F070", "F071", "F075", "F078", "F079"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F059", "F074", "F078", "F092"], "interference": ["F060", "F075", "F076", "F079"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F068", "F070", "F083", "F084", "F092", "F094", "F095"], "legitimate_aim": ["F071"], "necessity": ["F059", "F060", "F071", "F078", "F079"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F059", "F060", "F068", "F070", "F071", "F075", "F078", "F079", "F083", "F092", "F094", "F095"]}} {"case_name": "case_212", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_213", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1972.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Kharkiv.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr Y. Borysenko, a lawyer practising in Kharkiv.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The Government were represented by their acting Agent, Ms O. Davydchuk, of the Ministry of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The facts of the case may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 11 August 2012 the applicant informed the local police in Kharkiv of his intention to hold a peaceful assembly under the banner of 'Ukraine for fair elections'.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant's intended assembly was planned to run from 12 August 2012 onwards for an indefinite period of time.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant's intended assembly was planned to be held in Shevchenko Park in Kharkiv city centre.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The local police in Kharkiv transmitted the applicant's notice of intended assembly to the Kharkiv City Council.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "There is no information as to whether the applicant actually attempted to hold the demonstration on 12 August 2012 as he declared to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 13 August 2012 the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council decided that the assembly that the applicant planned to hold should not be permitted.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 13 August 2012 the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council requested the local court to prohibit the applicant's planned assembly.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 13 August 2012 the Kharkiv District Administrative Court allowed the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council's request and prohibited the applicant's planned assembly.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Kharkiv District Administrative Court noted that the matters under examination were regulated by the Temporary Regulations on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Kharkiv.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Kharkiv District Administrative Court noted that the Temporary Regulations on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Kharkiv were binding under section 73 of the Local Self-Government in Ukraine Act.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Kharkiv District Administrative Court noted that the procedure set out in the Temporary Regulations on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Kharkiv for the examination by the local authorities of the applicant's notification had been observed.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Kharkiv District Administrative Court based its decision to ban the assembly on the ground that the notice sent by the applicant did not provide clear details of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Kharkiv District Administrative Court based its decision to ban the assembly on the ground that the notice had not been sent a reasonable time in advance, noting that it was dated 11 August 2012 and had been received by the Kharkiv City Council on 13 August 2012, whereas the assembly had been scheduled for 12 August 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Kharkiv District Administrative Court based its decision to ban the assembly on the ground that the applicant planned to hold an assembly for an indefinite period of time.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Kharkiv District Administrative Court based its decision to ban the assembly on the ground that the applicant had chosen the city centre as the location for the assembly, not far from areas with significant levels of road traffic.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Kharkiv District Administrative Court based its decision to ban the assembly on the ground that the proposed location of the assembly was a place where the people of Kharkiv liked to rest and take part in leisure activities.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Kharkiv District Administrative Court noted that 'there was no evidence to prove that the assembly was not contrary to the interests of the inhabitants of Kharkiv'.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Kharkiv District Administrative Court noted that the assembly could pose a risk to the health and life of the inhabitants of Kharkiv, as well as their right to move about safely in the city.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Kharkiv District Administrative Court stated that 'the material in the case file [did] not demonstrate that there [was] no possibility of a violation of the rights and freedoms of people [not participating in the assembly]'.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 17 September 2012 the Kharkiv Administrative Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal against the prohibition of the planned assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Kharkiv Administrative Court of Appeal noted that the time and place of the applicant's planned assembly coincided with the time and place of the Honey Fair and the Flower Show, which were to take place from 14 to 23 August 2012 in Shevchenko Park.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The Kharkiv Administrative Court of Appeal noted that the holding of the applicant's assembly at the same time and place as the Honey Fair and the Flower Show could lead to a breach of public order and a threat to safety, because the applicant's assembly could spontaneously be joined by an unknown number of people.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Kharkiv Administrative Court of Appeal noted that if the applicant's assembly were spontaneously joined by additional people, the number of participants would increase and the assembly would become unmanageable, all of which would hinder the movement of people and vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 15 November 2012 the Higher Administrative Court rejected a request by the applicant for leave to appeal on points of law.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that citizens have the right to assemble peacefully without arms and to hold meetings, rallies, marches and demonstrations, after notifying the executive authorities and bodies of local self-government beforehand.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that restrictions on the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly may be established by a court in accordance with the law, in the interests of national security and public order only, for the purpose of preventing disturbances or crimes, protecting the health of the population, or protecting the rights and freedoms of other persons.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Article 92 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that human and citizens' rights and freedoms, the guarantees of these rights and freedoms, and the main duties of the citizen shall be determined exclusively by the laws of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "Article 182 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Justice, 2005, as worded at the material time, provides that bodies of executive power and bodies of local self-government, immediately upon receipt of notification of the holding of gatherings, meetings, rallies, demonstrations and so on, shall be entitled to bring a claim in the local Circuit Administrative Court seeking to ban such events or otherwise restrict the right to peaceful assembly concerning the place or time of their holding.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Administrative Justice, 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "Article 182 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Justice, 2005, as worded at the material time, provides that a claim received on the date of the events or thereafter shall be left unexamined.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Administrative Justice, 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Article 182 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Justice, 2005, as worded at the material time, provides that the court shall immediately notify the claimant and the organiser(s) of the gatherings, meetings, rallies, demonstrations or other peaceful assemblies about the opening of the proceedings, and the date, time and place of examination of the case.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Administrative Justice, 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Article 182 § 4 of the Code of Administrative Justice, 2005, as worded at the material time, provides that the administrative case concerning the restriction of the right to peaceful assembly shall be decided by the court within three days after the opening of the proceedings, or immediately where the proceedings are opened less than three days prior to the holding of the events in question.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Administrative Justice, 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Article 182 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Justice, 2005, as worded at the material time, provides that the court shall allow the claimant's claims in the interests of national security and public order where it establishes that the holding of gatherings, meetings, rallies, demonstrations or other assemblies may create a real risk of disturbances or crime, or endanger the health of the population or the rights and freedoms of other people, and that in its ruling the court shall indicate the manner in which the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly is to be restricted.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Administrative Justice, 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Article 182 § 6 of the Code of Administrative Justice, 2005, as worded at the material time, provides that the ruling of the court in cases concerning the restriction of the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly shall be enforced immediately.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Administrative Justice, 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Article 182 § 7 of the Code of Administrative Justice, 2005, as worded at the material time, provides that copies of the court's ruling shall be handed out immediately to the parties to the proceedings, or sent to them if they were not present during the delivery of the decision.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Administrative Justice, 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Article 183 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Justice, 2005, as worded at the material time, provides that the organiser(s) of gatherings, meetings, rallies, demonstrations or other peaceful assemblies shall be entitled to apply to the administrative court for the locality where the events are planned to be held with a claim for the removal of restrictions on the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly by the bodies of executive power or of local self-government that were notified of the holding of such events.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Administrative Justice, 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "Article 183 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Justice, 2005, as worded at the material time, provides that the court shall immediately notify the claimant and the defendant of the opening of the proceedings, and the date, time and place of examination of the case.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Administrative Justice, 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Article 183 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Justice, 2005, as worded at the material time, provides that an administrative case concerning the removal of restrictions on the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly shall be decided by the court within three days after the opening of proceedings, or immediately where the proceedings are opened less than three days prior to the holding of the events in question or on the date that they are held.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Administrative Justice, 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Article 183 § 4 of the Code of Administrative Justice, 2005, as worded at the material time, provides that the ruling of the court in an administrative case concerning the removal of restrictions on the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly shall be enforced immediately.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Administrative Justice, 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Article 183 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Justice, 2005, as worded at the material time, provides that copies of the court's ruling shall be handed out immediately to the parties to the proceedings or sent to them if they were not present during the delivery of the decision.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Administrative Justice, 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Section 38(1)(b)(3) of the Local Self-Government in Ukraine Act, 1997, provides that the executive bodies of city councils shall have delegated powers for resolving, in accordance with the law, issues concerning the holding of meetings, rallies, marches and demonstrations, or sports, entertainment and other mass events, and for securing public safety and order during the holding of such events.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Local Self-Government in Ukraine Act, 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Section 59 § 6 of the Local Self-Government in Ukraine Act, 1997, provides that the Executive Committee of the city council shall take decisions within the limits of its powers, that such decisions shall be taken at its meetings by a majority vote from the general composition of the executive committee, and shall be signed by the mayor.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Local Self-Government in Ukraine Act, 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Section 73 § 1 of the Local Self-Government in Ukraine Act, 1997, provides that acts of the council, mayor, or the executive committee of the city council which are adopted within the limits of the powers granted to them shall be binding on all executive authorities located in the relevant territory, associations of citizens, enterprises, institutions and organisations, and officials, as well as citizens permanently or temporarily residing in the relevant territory.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Local Self-Government in Ukraine Act, 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 introduced the procedure for organising peaceful gatherings in the city of Kharkiv.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 on approval of the Temporary Regulations on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Kharkiv (hereinafter \"Decision no. 543\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 was adopted on the basis of section 38 and section 59 § 6 of the Local Self-Government in Ukraine Act, 1997.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 on approval of the Temporary Regulations on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Kharkiv (hereinafter \"Decision no. 543\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Temporary Regulations approved by Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 state in their General Provisions that they had been drawn up in accordance with the Convention, the Local Self-Government in Ukraine Act, the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR, the decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001 in a case regarding timely notification of a peaceful assembly, and the Code of Administrative Justice.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 on approval of the Temporary Regulations on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Kharkiv (hereinafter \"Decision no. 543\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Under the Temporary Regulations approved by Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007, freedom of assembly could be restricted by a court in the interests of national security and public safety, for considerations of public health, for the prevention of crime and disorder, and for the protection of the rights of others.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 on approval of the Temporary Regulations on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Kharkiv (hereinafter \"Decision no. 543\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Under the Temporary Regulations approved by Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007, notification of the intended event was to be submitted in writing and in good time, that is, not less than ten days prior to the planned date of holding the event.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 on approval of the Temporary Regulations on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Kharkiv (hereinafter \"Decision no. 543\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Temporary Regulations approved by Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 provided that the holding of mass gatherings within parks and other recreational areas was not permitted, except in one particular park, namely Molodizhnyi.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 on approval of the Temporary Regulations on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Kharkiv (hereinafter \"Decision no. 543\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Temporary Regulations approved by Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 provided that the simultaneous holding of any mass gatherings in a location where other mass events had been authorised was not permitted.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 on approval of the Temporary Regulations on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Kharkiv (hereinafter \"Decision no. 543\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Temporary Regulations approved by Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 provided that the holding of any demonstrations and pickets directly in front of the offices of institutions and organisations where this would interfere with the work of those institutions and organisations or would impede members of the public from visiting them was not permitted.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 on approval of the Temporary Regulations on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Kharkiv (hereinafter \"Decision no. 543\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Temporary Regulations approved by Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 provided that the holding of mass gatherings prior to 8 a.m. or after 10 p.m. was not permitted.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Decision no. 543 of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council of 6 June 2007 on approval of the Temporary Regulations on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Kharkiv (hereinafter \"Decision no. 543\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In its decision of 19 April 2001 in a case regarding the timely notification of a peaceful assembly, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine noted that the Ministry of the Interior of Ukraine had applied to the Constitutional Court of Ukraine for an official interpretation of the provisions of Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine regarding timely notification to executive authorities or bodies of local self-government of planned meetings, rallies, marches or demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "In its decision of 19 April 2001, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine noted that the current legislation of Ukraine does not provide for a specific time-limit within which the executive authorities or bodies of local self-government are to be notified about planned meetings, rallies, marches or demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "In its decision of 19 April 2001, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine held that the provisions of the first part of Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine on timely notification to the executive authorities or bodies of local self-government of planned meetings, rallies, marches or demonstrations shall be understood to mean that where the organisers of such peaceful gatherings are planning to hold such an event, they must inform the above-mentioned authorities in advance, that is, within a reasonable time prior to the date of the planned event.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "In its decision of 19 April 2001, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine held that the time-limits for notification should not restrict the right of citizens under Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine, but should serve as a guarantee of this right and at the same time should provide the relevant executive authorities or bodies of local self-government with an opportunity to take measures to ensure that citizens may freely hold meetings, rallies, marches and demonstrations and to protect public order and the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "In its decision of 19 April 2001, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine held that specifying the exact deadlines for timely notification with regard to the particularities of different forms of peaceful assembly, the number of participants, the venue, and the time of the event is a matter for legislative regulation.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Other relevant domestic law and practice are summarised in Vyerentsov v. Ukraine, no. 20372/11, 11 April 2013, paragraphs 25-40.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Other relevant domestic law and practice"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 20 December 2012 the United Nations Human Rights Council published the Report of the Working Group on the Universal Periodic Review in respect of Ukraine (UN Doc. A/HRC/22/7).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Human Rights Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "In the Report of the Working Group on the Universal Periodic Review in respect of Ukraine (UN Doc. A/HRC/22/7), one of the recommendations made to Ukraine was to implement a law on freedom of assembly that complies with applicable standards under Article 21 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which recognises the right of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Human Rights Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "In its Resolution 2116 (2016) on the urgent need to prevent human rights violations during peaceful protests, dated 27 May 2016, the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe noted that it was worried about the lack of legislation on freedom of assembly in certain countries, including Ukraine, where there is no legislation with respect to a procedure for holding demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Between 2006 and 2011 the European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission), together with the Office for Democratic Institution and Human Rights of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE/ODIHR), issued four joint opinions on the draft legislation of Ukraine on freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. The Venice Commission and the OSCE/ODIHR"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "None of the draft laws on freedom of assembly submitted to the Venice Commission and the OSCE/ODIHR for assessment between 2006 and 2011 was eventually passed.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. The Venice Commission and the OSCE/ODIHR"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "In October 2016 the Venice Commission adopted a Joint Opinion with the Directorate of Human Rights of the Directorate General of Human Rights and Rule of Law of the Council of Europe and the OSCE/ODIHR on two draft laws of Ukraine on guarantees for freedom of peaceful assembly (no. 854/2016).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. The Venice Commission and the OSCE/ODIHR"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The October 2016 Joint Opinion noted that the Venice Commission, the Directorate of Human Rights of the Directorate General of Human Rights and Rule of Law of the Council of Europe, and the OSCE/ODIHR delegation learned during their most recent visit in Kyiv that civil society appeared to be divided on the need to adopt specific legislation on the right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. The Venice Commission and the OSCE/ODIHR"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The October 2016 Joint Opinion noted that supporters of the 'no-law approach' claimed that civil society in Ukraine is still too weak to control the Verkhovna Rada and feared that if specific legislation were adopted, the Verkhovna Rada could introduce negative amendments into the specific law during possible future political crises.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. The Venice Commission and the OSCE/ODIHR"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The October 2016 Joint Opinion noted that supporters of the 'no-law approach' considered that a safer method would be to amend the existing legislation in order to introduce regulations on freedom of assembly and to adopt some secondary legislation in this field.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. The Venice Commission and the OSCE/ODIHR"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The October 2016 Joint Opinion noted that others asserted that the adoption of a specific law on public assemblies would provide greater clarity and precision regarding the obligations of the State in this field, the grounds for restriction, and the procedures to be followed.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. The Venice Commission and the OSCE/ODIHR"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The October 2016 Joint Opinion noted that in the absence of clear legislative regulations on freedom of assembly, local authorities in Ukraine have issued specific and widely varying local rules in order to regulate the exercise of the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. The Venice Commission and the OSCE/ODIHR"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The October 2016 Joint Opinion noted that according to certain civil society organisations, regulation of the right to freedom of assembly by local decisions is a widespread practice in Ukraine, which would contradict Article 92 of the Constitution of Ukraine, which provides that human and citizens' rights and freedoms are determined exclusively by the laws of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. The Venice Commission and the OSCE/ODIHR"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Other international materials are cited and/or summarised in Vyerentsov v. Ukraine, no. 20372/11, 11 April 2013, paragraphs 41-43.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "D. Other international materials"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F010", "F011", "F013"], "interference": ["F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F025", "F029"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F014", "F015", "F016", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F045", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F054", "F058", "F061", "F062", "F065", "F067", "F073", "F074"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F008"], "interference": ["F010", "F013"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F014", "F015", "F016", "F022", "F030", "F032", "F045", "F048", "F049", "F053", "F067"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F006", "F010", "F013", "F030", "F032", "F067", "F048", "F045", "F014", "F015", "F022"]}} {"case_name": "case_214", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants live in Kharkiv.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "According to the applicants, in the period from 20 May to 6 July 2010 they participated in protest activities against a road-construction project in Gorky Park (Парк ім. Горького) in Kharkiv.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "According to the applicants, the protest activities in Gorky Park included obstructing tree-felling work.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "One issue raised in connection with the Gorky Park events is whether alleged verbal and physical harassment on the part of the personnel involved in the road-construction project against all the applicants breached their right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "One issue raised in connection with the Gorky Park events is whether the arrest and conviction of the first six applicants for refusal to obey orders to leave the construction site breached their freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Regarding the arrest and conviction issue, the first five applicants were arrested together, forming one sub-group.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Regarding the arrest and conviction issue, the sixth applicant was arrested on a different date from the first five applicants, forming a separate sub-group.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "One issue raised in connection with the Gorky Park events is whether the proceedings against the first and second applicants for failure to obey the police order to leave the construction site were fair in view of the applicants' absence from the appeal hearings.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "One issue raised in connection with the Gorky Park events is whether the third, seventh and ninth applicants were subjected to inhuman or degrading treatment by the personnel involved in the road-construction project.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "One issue raised in connection with the Gorky Park events is whether, if the third, seventh and ninth applicants were subjected to inhuman or degrading treatment, there was a failure to protect them from such treatment and to investigate it effectively.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 23 June 2004 the Kharkiv City Council adopted a document entitled General Urban Development Plan until 2026.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The General Urban Development Plan until 2026 had been drafted by the State Academic Institute for Urban Planning \"Dipromisto\" (the Urban Planning Institute).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "A public consultation on the General Urban Development Plan until 2026 had been held in 2003.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 20 September 2007 the Kharkiv Municipal Construction Department (Департамент будівництва та шляхового господарства Харківської міської ради) published in the Kharkivsky Kuryer newspaper information about its plan to build a road from Sumska Street to Novgorodska Street through Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Kharkiv Municipal Construction Department's publication of 20 September 2007 in the Kharkivsky Kuryer newspaper invited public comments on the planned road construction.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 10 September 2008 the Kharkiv City Council allocated land for the road construction to the Kharkiv Municipal Construction Department.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 14 March 2008 the State Academic Institute for Urban Planning \"Dipromisto\" (the Urban Planning Institute) approved the plan submitted by the Kharkiv Municipal Urban Planning Department (Департамент містобудування, архітектури та земельних відносин) envisaging construction of a road through Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The plan approved by the Urban Planning Institute on 14 March 2008 also envisaged modification of the General Urban Development Plan until 2026 in respect of the road through Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 25 January or February 2009 the Kharkiv City Council approved the overall plan for the prospective road construction, including the road through Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 27 April 2010 a commission of municipal officials examined the trees which had to be felled in order to allow the road construction in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The commission of municipal officials drew up a detailed list of the trees to be felled, including their varieties, ages, diameters and state of health.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 18 May 2010 the Kharkiv Regional Environmental Protection Department approved the list of trees to be felled in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 7 May 2010 the Kharkiv Municipal Construction Department published a notice about the planned construction of the road in Gorky Park in Ekologiya Syogodni (Environment Today), a newspaper published by the Kharkiv Regional Environmental Inspectorate.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The notice published on 7 May 2010 contained an indication of where the road would be sited and stated that it would be 1,283 metres long and 16 metres wide, with a footpath and a bicycle path.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The notice published on 7 May 2010 stated that in the process of road construction, 503 trees would be destroyed but that 75 trees and 35 bushes would be replanted along the road.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The notice published on 7 May 2010 solicited public comment and provided the Kharkiv Municipal Construction Department's postal address for that purpose.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 17 May 2010 the Kharkiv Municipal Construction Department sent letters to the regional environmental protection authorities explaining that the purpose of the road construction was to relieve the problem of increasing traffic in central Kharkiv.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Kharkiv Municipal Construction Department's letters of 17 May 2010 explained that the road would link two radial roads and thus circumvent the city centre.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 19 May 2010 the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council (the municipality's executive authority) authorised the felling of 503 trees in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 11 or 19 May 2010 the Kharkiv Municipal Construction Department entered into a contract with private company P., engaging the latter as the main contractor for the road construction project (the Main Contractor).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 19 May 2010 the Main Contractor signed an agreement with a private company to perform preparatory works for the road construction.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 19 May 2010 the Main Contractor subcontracted municipal company K. to do the tree-felling on the construction site in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "Municipal company K. in turn engaged another municipal company as its own subcontractor for the tree-felling work (hereinafter the subcontractors).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 26 May 2010 the Regional Architecture and Construction Inspectorate (Інспекція державного архітектурно-будівельного контролю у Харківській області) issued to the Kharkiv Municipal Construction Department a permit to carry out preparatory work for the road construction.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Approval of the road-construction project in Gorky Park, public consultations and preparation for its implementation"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 13 or 19 May 2010 the Main Contractor signed an agreement for the provision of security guard services with the local authority-owned company Municipal Guard (Munitsipalna okhorona; Комунальне підприємство «Муніципальна охорона» – hereinafter MG).", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Under the agreement between the Main Contractor and Municipal Guard (MG), MG undertook to provide services consisting of guarding the road construction site in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "MG held a licence authorising it to provide commercial security guard services, issued on 2 February 2010 by the Ministry of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 19 May 2010 the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council sent a letter to the chief of the Kharkiv city police referring to its decision of the same date authorising the felling of trees.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council's letter of 19 May 2010 asked the chief of the Kharkiv city police to dispatch police officers to the construction site as from 20 May 2010 to ensure public order.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 19 May 2010 Kharkiv city police approved an action plan for ensuring public safety during the tree-felling work in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the Kharkiv city police action plan of 19 May 2010, twenty-seven active officers were assigned for ensuring public order and safety at the construction site daily from 20 May 2010.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to the Kharkiv city police action plan of 19 May 2010, a number of officers were to be kept in reserve at the local police station in case of need.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Kharkiv city police action plan of 19 May 2010 mentioned that the tree felling could potentially generate picketing, demonstrations and other unexpected action by opponents of the construction project.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 21 May 2010 the Main Contractor signed an agreement for the provision of security guard services with private security company P-4 (приватне підприємство «Охоронне агентство «Р-4») (hereinafter PS).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The subject of the agreement between the Main Contractor and private security company PS was the provision of security guard services for the purpose of preventing third parties from entering the road construction site in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The security guard services provided by private security company PS were to be provided as from 28 May 2010.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Private security company PS held a licence authorising it to provide commercial security guard services, issued on 11 April 2007 by the Ministry of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 25 May 2010 the Main Contractor asked the chief of the Kharkiv city police to send police units to the construction site at 7 a.m. on 26 May 2010 to prevent third parties from infiltrating the construction site.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 29 May 2010 the Main Contractor asked the chief of police of the then Dzerzhinsky (presently Shevchenkivsky) District, where Gorky Park is located, to ensure public order on the construction site.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Main Contractor's request of 29 May 2010 referred to an incident the previous day in which, according to the company, unidentified people had interfered with the construction work, shouted profanities at the workers and tried to provoke a fight.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Private security and law-enforcement planning measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Tree felling commenced on 20 May 2010 in Gorky Park, attracting a number of individuals who protested against it, including, according to the applicants, the applicants themselves.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "According to the applicants, there were hundreds of protesters at Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "No formal notification of the protest had been sent to the municipal authorities.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The protesters alleged, inter alia, that the tree felling in Gorky Park was unjustified and not duly authorised, and demanded proof of its legality.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Some protesters actively attempted to interfere with the tree-felling work in Gorky Park by climbing trees with the help of climbing equipment and attaching themselves to the trees to be felled.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Some protesters interfered with work to be carried out by machinery by placing themselves in front of it.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Notwithstanding the protests, the tree-felling and construction work in Gorky Park proceeded.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, in response to the protesters' actions the security guards attempted to drive them away by pushing them back beyond the boundaries of the construction area.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "In some instances, clashes took place between security guards and protesters in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On at least fifteen occasions ambulances were called to the Gorky Park construction site during the protest events.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The police officers deployed at the Gorky Park construction site allegedly remained largely passive in the face of the clashes between security guards and protesters.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The bulk of the protest activity in Gorky Park was brought to an end on 2 June 2010 and most of the protesters left the site on that day.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Some protesters apparently continued to picket the Gorky Park construction site until about mid-August 2010.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The sixth applicant was arrested on 6 July 2010 in connection with continued protest activity at the Gorky Park construction site.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Video and photographic evidence of the events of 20 May to 2 June 2010 in Gorky Park was provided by the applicants to the Court.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "At the time of examination of the case by the Court, similar video evidence of the Gorky Park events was also publicly available online.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Certain video material was examined in the course of the domestic proceedings but was not provided to the Court.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Court stated it would rely on the evidence provided to the extent that it does not contradict the domestic authorities' findings and, in particular, to the extent that it disproves the applicants' own allegations.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. General description of the events in Gorky Park"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Material for 20 May 2010 consists of a news report by the Kharkiv local television channel ATN concerning the events in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The ATN news report for 20 May 2010 shows workers felling trees, apparently unobstructed, with no sign of any protesters.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The ATN news report narrator stated that the tree-felling work for the road construction was advancing rapidly and that the project dated from 2007 but was attracting opposition from academics, environmentalists and city residents.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The ATN news report showed archive footage of what appears to be a demonstration in front of a public building with flags and the slogan 'Dobkin [Kharkiv mayor at the time], do not destroy the park'.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The ATN news report narrator stated that protests had not prevented the city authorities from pushing ahead with the road construction project.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The ATN news report showed the head of the Kharkiv Municipal Construction Department explaining the need for the new road in the city's traffic scheme at what appears to be a public meeting of city authorities.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The ATN news report showed footage marked '17 September 2007' of the then-mayor of Kharkiv speaking at what appears to be a press conference about the sources of financing for the road construction project.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Mr Sh., a representative of Pechenigy NGO, expressed concern in the ATN news report that more trees would be felled than authorised.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Mr K., a representative of the NGO My Kharkivyany, stated in the ATN news report that he had not been shown the permits for tree felling, in particular the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council's decision of 19 May 2010.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The acting mayor of Kharkiv was shown in the ATN news report at a public meeting of the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council saying that the road construction project had all the necessary permits and the NGOs had been informed.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The ATN news report narrator stated that civil activists had complained to the police of illegal tree felling and intended to appeal to the prosecutor's office and the courts.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "Material for 22 May 2010 shows an area in Gorky Park that had been cleared of some trees, with protesters seen standing by two trees and hugging them.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Material for 23 May 2010 shows tree-felling work in Gorky Park with a number of individuals standing by, and an individual being taken away by the police.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Material for 23 May 2010 shows three individuals surrounding a tree and facing the police, with one of them saying 'Welcome to the picnic'.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Material for 24 May 2010 shows tree-felling work in Gorky Park with police and individuals who appear to be protesters surrounding loggers holding chainsaws.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Material for 24 May 2010 shows a logger starting to cut down a tree with a chainsaw, at which moment an individual in civilian clothing puts his foot on the tree trunk at the level where the logger is attempting to cut, causing the worker to walk away.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Material for 25 May 2010 shows a large number of police officers standing in lines blocking protesters' access to certain areas where tree felling is ongoing, or pulling individual protesters away from the trees while protesters attempt to cling to them.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Material for 25 May 2010 shows protesters being pushed, pulled and escorted away from the felling area and released.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Material for 25 May 2010 shows police pushing back some protesters who appear to be trying to get closer to the area where a tall tree is being cut down.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Material for 25 May 2010 shows a worker starting to cut a tree with a chainsaw, making a short pause, after which a protester comes along and hugs the tree, preventing the worker from proceeding.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Events of 20-25 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The applicants alleged a number of attacks on them and other protesters by the security guards and loggers in the period from 20 May to 2 June 2010 in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "According to the applicants, on 27 May 2010 the ninth applicant was beaten by unidentified men in orange vests.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "1. Incident of 27 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "An ambulance was called following the alleged beating of the ninth applicant on 27 May 2010 and the ninth applicant was taken to hospital.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "1. Incident of 27 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The ninth applicant was diagnosed at hospital as having sustained injuries to the soft tissue of the head and face and was treated as an outpatient.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "1. Incident of 27 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "On 27 May 2010 the ninth applicant lodged a complaint with the district police, alleging that he had been assaulted in the course of the Gorky Park events near the children's railway.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "1. Incident of 27 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Video and photographic material for 27 May 2010 shows a person introducing himself as the head of the Kharkiv Municipal Construction Department, surrounded apparently by some other officials including a police officer, arguing with protesters.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "1. Incident of 27 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Video material for 27 May 2010 shows a group of protesters confronting a bulldozer near railway tracks, attempting to sit down on its blade, and surrounding the blade to block the bulldozer.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "1. Incident of 27 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Video material for 27 May 2010 shows a group of individuals in orange vests and a group in civilian clothing confronting and pushing each other in a chaotic fashion around an excavator.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "1. Incident of 27 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Video material for 27 May 2010 shows several individuals in civilian clothing on what appears to be the protesters' side recording the events with cameras.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "1. Incident of 27 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Photographs for 27 May 2010 reproduce what appear to be some aspects of the same scenes, and red-and-white warning tape is seen on some photographs for the first time.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "1. Incident of 27 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "According to the applicants, on 31 May 2010 the seventh applicant was assaulted by men in black wearing Municipal Guard (MG) badges in response to her protests about the beating of another protester.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "2. Incident of 31 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "According to the seventh applicant, police officers who were standing nearby on 31 May 2010 observed the assault on her without reacting to her cries for help.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "2. Incident of 31 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On 31 May 2010 the seventh applicant was taken to hospital by ambulance.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "2. Incident of 31 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The seventh applicant was diagnosed at hospital on 31 May 2010 as suffering from stress-related hypertension and soft tissue contusions in the lumbar area.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "2. Incident of 31 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The seventh applicant stayed in hospital on 31 May 2010 from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "2. Incident of 31 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On 1 June 2010 the seventh applicant complained to the head of the Dzerzhinsky District police that on 31 May 2010 she had been hit in the back by Municipal Guard (MG) staff.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "2. Incident of 31 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Video and photographic material for 31 May 2010 shows a tumultuous scene with men in black with badges confronting a large group of individuals in civilian clothing, pulling some protesters away from an area they are attempting to protect, and then forming an elbow-to-elbow line blocking access.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "2. Incident of 31 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Video material for 31 May 2010 shows individuals in civilian clothing on the protesters' side filming the events, with shouts of 'Police!' and 'Call an ambulance!'", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "2. Incident of 31 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Video material for 31 May 2010 shows a woman (apparently the seventh applicant) lying on the ground surrounded by the crowd, after which an ambulance team arrives and takes her away.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "2. Incident of 31 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Photographs for 31 May 2010 show individuals apparently protesters sitting in groups around trees marked with slogans, men in black clothing with badges confronting individuals in civilian clothing and pushing them away, and a man in black facing what appears to be a group of protesters sitting on the ground and holding onto a tree.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "2. Incident of 31 May 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "According to the applicants, on 2 June 2010 men in black with Municipal Guard (MG) badges and loggers were attempting to clear the Gorky Park construction site of protesters.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "3. Incident of 2 June 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "According to the applicants, on 2 June 2010 the third applicant was closely approached by two loggers, subsequently identified as A. and K., employees of one of the subcontractors.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "3. Incident of 2 June 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "According to the applicants, on 2 June 2010 loggers A. and K. threatened the third applicant and a group of other protesters with working chainsaws, and one of them nearly injured the third applicant.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "3. Incident of 2 June 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Government alleged that on 2 June 2010 it was the protesters who had attacked the workers, trying to take away the chainsaws, so that the workers had had to retreat to avoid injuries.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "3. Incident of 2 June 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "In their statements in the course of the domestic investigation, as summarised in the decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010, loggers A. and K. stated that on 2 June 2010, on arriving at the designated felling area in Gorky Park, they had observed men in black and protesters.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "3. Incident of 2 June 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Loggers A. and K. stated that the protesters had started insulting the workers and the men in black, then started to push A. and K., grabbing their arms and trying to seize their chainsaws.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "3. Incident of 2 June 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Loggers A. and K. stated that in order to prevent people from approaching, they had switched on the chainsaws, but the protesters had started approaching and in order not to injure them, A. and K. had had to step back, holding the chainsaws in front of them.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "3. Incident of 2 June 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Video material for 2 June 2010 shows a tumultuous scene involving dozens of individuals, with men in black attempting to push the protesters away from the trees and the protesters attempting to hold their ground and push back, while several police officers observe.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "3. Incident of 2 June 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Video material for 2 June 2010 shows two workers starting their chainsaws some distance away from the main altercation.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "3. Incident of 2 June 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Video material for 2 June 2010 shows an individual identified as the third applicant approaching closely and confronting one of the workers with running chainsaws, raising and spreading his arms, with several other individuals also closely approaching the worker.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "3. Incident of 2 June 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Video material for 2 June 2010 shows the worker stepping back while holding the chainsaw close and waving it in horizontal semi-circles in front of him.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "3. Incident of 2 June 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Video material for 2 June 2010 shows a group of individuals in camouflage and in black intervening and interposing themselves in a line between the workers and the protesters.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Alleged attacks on the applicants and other protesters", "3. Incident of 2 June 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "On 28 May 2010 the first to fifth, the eighth and the tenth applicants, among other protesters, were arrested and taken to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "At the police station on 28 May 2010, charges of malicious insubordination in the face of lawful demands of a police officer were drawn up against the first to fifth, the eighth and the tenth applicants.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "According to the offence reports drawn up on 28 May 2010, the arrested applicants had repeatedly refused to abide by police officers' instructions to leave the construction site and resisted the officers' efforts to remove them, in particular by dragging their feet and attempting to break free and to remain on the site.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "It appears that the first to fifth, the eighth and the tenth applicants were released shortly after the offence reports had been drawn up on 28 May 2010.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "On various dates the offence reports drawn up on 28 May 2010 against the arrested applicants were examined by the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "During the hearings before the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court, the applicants pleaded not guilty.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The applicants submitted to the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court that on the morning of 28 May 2010 they had been in Gorky Park along with some other protesters to express their dissatisfaction with the tree felling.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The applicants submitted that the construction site had no boundary markers and they had believed that they were lawfully in a public open space.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The applicants submitted that about 100 police officers had been standing nearby and had never asked the protesters to leave the area.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The applicants submitted that a number of men in black with Municipal Guard (MG) badges had surrounded the protesters and started pressing them into a tight circle.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The applicants submitted that police officers had then approached and, instead of responding to the protesters' cries for help, had taken some of the protesters, including the applicants, out of the crowd one by one and escorted them to the police station, without any demands or explanations.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The applicants submitted that they had followed the police officers without offering any resistance.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Video and photographic material for 28 May 2010 shows an individual in civilian clothing leading a group of several dozen men in black and other clothing with badges approaching a group of protesters within a zone marked off with warning tape standing by what appears to be a railroad crossing.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Video material for 28 May 2010 shows the individual in civilian clothing repeating several times 'Please leave the construction site', receiving the response 'This is a park, not a construction site'.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Video material for 28 May 2010 shows the people with badges lining up elbow-to-elbow and starting to push the protesters away from the railroad crossing towards the periphery of the marked-off area, with protesters resisting and shouting 'Police!' and 'The park is ours!'", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Video material for 28 May 2010 shows a large group of police officers arriving, upon which the protesters start chanting 'Police with the people!'", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Video material for 28 May 2010 shows that by the time the police arrived, the protesters had been moved away from the railroad crossing and were surrounded by the people with badges in a tight circle, but were still within the marked-off area.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Video material for 28 May 2010 shows the police officer in charge exchanging inaudible words with a person who appears to be one of the surrounded protesters, appearing to say 'Do you wish to leave [the territory]?', and then saying to the other officers 'To the police station!'", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Video material for 28 May 2010 shows police officers prising individuals from the group and leading them away from the marked-off area, with several seen dragging their feet and arguing.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Video material for 28 May 2010 shows that eventually the area previously occupied by the protesters was cleared and an excavator moved through it.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "In his statement to the police the first applicant said that at 7.30 a.m. on 28 May 2010 he had been in Gorky Park with his bicycle, had been grabbed by people with Municipal Guard (MG) badges and then handed over to the police.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "In his statement to the police the second applicant said that at 7.20 a.m. on 28 May 2010 he had been in Gorky Park near the railway crossing, had seen a crowd and come closer to find out what was going on, and had been unaware that construction work was being conducted there.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "The second applicant stated to the police that individuals with Municipal Guard (MG) badges had pushed him and others away from the railway crossing and encircled them, after which police officers had come and dragged him out of the circle and to the police station, and that he had not heard any warnings to leave the site.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "On 28 May 2010 the cases against the first and second applicants were sent to court.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The first and second applicants requested that the hearings in their cases be postponed as they needed time to appoint a lawyer, and they appointed a lawyer on 28 May 2010.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The second applicant's administrative-offence case file contains two versions of the report drawn up by arresting officers concerning the circumstances of his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The first version of the arresting officers' report states that the second applicant was taken to the police station because he had been protesting at the construction site in Gorky Park, thus putting his life at risk and interfering with the construction work.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The second version of the arresting officers' report states that the second applicant had been present at the construction site in Gorky Park, had refused to leave despite repeated warnings from police officers, and had struggled when police officers had attempted to escort him out of the area.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "On 31 May 2010 the first and second applicants' lawyer asked the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court to admit to the file and examine a video recording of the events of 28 May 2010.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "On 9 June 2010 the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court held a hearing at which it heard the police officers, who supported the charges and the account of events set out in the offence reports.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "At the hearing on 9 June 2010 the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court also heard the first and second applicants and some witnesses, and examined the video recording submitted by the applicants' lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The first applicant stated at the hearing on 9 June 2010 that on the morning of 28 May 2010 he had been cycling through Gorky Park on his way to work, had seen many people where trees were being felled and had gone closer.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The first applicant stated that there had been red-and-white tape but he had not realised that the area in question was a construction site.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "The first applicant stated that people with Municipal Guard (MG) badges had tried to push him and others away from the railway crossing and had surrounded them, after which he had been taken away by police officers who had not addressed any orders to him personally.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The second applicant stated at the hearing on 9 June 2010 that on the morning of 28 May 2010 he had gone to Gorky Park to look at the events surrounding the tree felling, that there had been a lot of people there, and that there had been red-and-white tape but he had not understood that it was a construction site and that his presence there could be dangerous.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The second applicant described the subsequent events on 28 May 2010 in terms close to those used by the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "At the close of the hearing on 9 June 2010 the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court convicted the first and second applicants as charged and sentenced them to fifteen days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court stated that, in view of the examined evidence including that submitted by the defence, it was convinced that the first and second applicants were guilty as charged.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court stated that the video recording submitted by the applicants' lawyer had not exculpated the first and second applicants since it had pauses and did not show certain witnesses, and therefore could not be regarded as a complete record of the events.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court stated that having examined the circumstances of the case and the character of the first and second applicants, it was convinced that a punishment less severe than detention would not be adequate.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court's decision convicting the first and second applicants was enforced immediately and the applicants were taken into custody.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court's judgments were served on the first and second applicants.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "On 10 June 2010 the first and second applicants' lawyer appealed to the Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal against the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court's judgments.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The first and second applicants' lawyer argued on appeal that the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court had failed to set out its analysis of the evidence which had led it to the conclusion that the applicants were guilty, and had thus failed adequately to reason its judgments.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The first and second applicants' lawyer argued on appeal that under the Code of Administrative Offences administrative detention could only be applied in exceptional cases, and that the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court had failed to explain the exceptional nature of the applicants' cases which would justify the severity of the punishment imposed.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "On 14 June 2010 the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court notified the first and second applicants' lawyer and the applicants (through the detention centre) that their cases were being sent to the Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "According to a note in the domestic files, at 5 p.m. on 17 June 2010 a clerk from the Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal informed the first and second applicants' lawyer that court hearings in their cases would be held at 2 p.m. and 2.20 p.m. the following day respectively.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "On 17 June 2010 the first and second applicants' lawyer studied the case files.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "On 18 June 2010 the Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal heard the appeals of the first and second applicants in their absence but in the presence of their lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "On 18 June 2010 the Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal upheld the conviction of the first and second applicants.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal found that the case-file material showed that the police officers had acted lawfully in directing the first and second applicants to leave the construction site.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "The Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal found that the construction work was being conducted on the basis of valid permits and the appellants had failed to show otherwise.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "The Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal concluded that the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court had not had sufficient grounds to impose the maximum punishment on the first and second applicants, having failed to sufficiently take into account the circumstances of the cases and the applicants' personal characteristics.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "The Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal reduced the first and second applicants' sentence from fifteen days to nine days' detention.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "On 18 June 2010 the Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal's decision became final and the first and second applicants were released.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(a) The first and second applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "In the course of the hearing before the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court, the third applicant stated that he had indeed been in Gorky Park, had not heard any orders to leave the site from the police officers but had heard it from a person in civilian clothing, and had been dragged from the circle by police officers who had taken him to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(b) The third and fourth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "On 14 June 2010 the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court, having heard the police officers, the third and fourth applicants and some witnesses, convicted the third and fourth applicants as charged.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(b) The third and fourth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "The Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court sentenced the third applicant to a fine of 136 Ukrainian hryvnias (UAH), at the time the equivalent of about 14 euros (EUR).", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(b) The third and fourth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "The Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court sentenced the fourth applicant to a fine of 170 Ukrainian hryvnias (UAH), at the time the equivalent of about 17 euros (EUR).", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(b) The third and fourth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "The third and fourth applicants appealed against the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court's judgments.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(b) The third and fourth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "In his appeal the third applicant argued that he could not be held liable for failure to comply with the order of the police since he had had the right to be present in Gorky Park and the order to leave it had been without legal basis.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(b) The third and fourth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "The fourth applicant argued on appeal that police officers had not issued any order to leave the construction site.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(b) The third and fourth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "On 27 July 2010 the Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal upheld the judgment in the third applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(b) The third and fourth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "On 11 August 2010 the Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal upheld the judgment in the fourth applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(b) The third and fourth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "On 23 June 2010 the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court, having heard the police officers, the fifth applicant and some witnesses, convicted the fifth applicant as charged and fined him 170 Ukrainian hryvnias (UAH), at the time the equivalent of about 17 euros (EUR).", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(c) The fifth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "On 27 July 2010 the Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal quashed the fifth applicant's conviction by a final decision and discontinued the proceedings against the fifth applicant under Article 22 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1984.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(c) The fifth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "The Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal found that the trial court had correctly established the facts concerning the fifth applicant's guilt, but that its judgment lacked reasoning as to the degree of dangerousness of the applicant's conduct and his personal characteristics.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(c) The fifth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "The Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal found it established that the fifth applicant's registered residence was in Kharkiv, that he was employed and that his actions had not caused prejudice to the public interest or to individuals.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(c) The fifth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "The Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal found that the delinquent element in the fifth applicant's conduct had been so insignificant that an oral reprimand would have sufficed under Article 22 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1984, and proceeded to issue the reprimand.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(c) The fifth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "On 8 June 2010 the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court discontinued proceedings against the eighth applicant.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(d) The eighth and tenth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "On 12 July 2010 the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court discontinued proceedings against the tenth applicant.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(d) The eighth and tenth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "In its judgment concerning the eighth applicant, the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court noted that his explanations were consistent with a private video recording of the events submitted by him, and that there were inconsistencies between various police reports in the case file and a lack of evidence that the officers had duly instructed him to leave.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(d) The eighth and tenth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "Concerning the tenth applicant, the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court likewise pointed to inconsistencies between various police reports in the case file and the lack of evidence that the officers had duly instructed him to leave.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "1. Arrest of certain applicants on 28 May 2010 and subsequent proceedings", "(d) The eighth and tenth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "On 6 July 2010 the sixth applicant was arrested and charged with malicious insubordination in the face of orders given by police officers to leave the construction site in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "On 7 July 2010 the sixth applicant's case was heard by the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court, at which the police officers supported the charges.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "At the hearing on 7 July 2010 the sixth applicant acknowledged that he had been sitting on the ground in the construction area, protesting against the tree felling, which he considered unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "The sixth applicant acknowledged that he had refused to comply with the police officers' requests to leave the construction site, to the point where they had had to drag him away by the arms with his legs dragging on the ground.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "The sixth applicant admitted that he had told the police officers that he would return to the construction site as soon as he could.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "Witnesses at the hearing on 7 July 2010 gave testimony to the same effect as the sixth applicant's account, with one adding that the applicant had also tried to break away from the police.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "On 7 July 2010 the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court convicted the sixth applicant as charged and sentenced him to ten days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "In justifying the sanction imposed on the sixth applicant, the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court stated that it had taken into account the nature of the offence and its specific circumstances, the applicant's personal characteristics, the fact that he had no employment, the absence of aggravating or attenuating circumstances, and the need to re-educate the offender and to prevent new offences.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "The Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court considered that the use of sanctions less severe than imprisonment would be insufficient and that administrative detention needed to be imposed on the sixth applicant, but not for the maximum duration provided for in the law.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "The sixth applicant started to serve his sentence immediately after the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court's judgment of 7 July 2010.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "The sixth applicant's lawyer lodged an appeal against the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court's judgment, arguing that the court had failed to set out its analysis of the evidence which had led it to the conclusion that the applicant was guilty, and had thus failed adequately to reason its judgment.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F205", "text": "The sixth applicant's lawyer argued on appeal that under the Code of Administrative Offences administrative detention could only be applied in exceptional cases, and that the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court had failed to explain the exceptional nature of the applicant's case which would justify the severity of the punishment imposed.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F206", "text": "The sixth applicant's lawyer requested that the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court's judgment be quashed and the proceedings in the case discontinued.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F207", "text": "On 15 September 2010 the Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal held a hearing at which it heard the sixth applicant and his lawyer and examined, at the request of the defence, an additional witness.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F208", "text": "On 15 September 2010 the Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal upheld the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court's judgment convicting the sixth applicant.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F209", "text": "The Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal concluded that the evidence, notably the sixth applicant's own explanations in court, fully supported the finding of the applicant's guilt.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F210", "text": "The Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal found no indication of illegality in the police order to leave the construction site, in particular because the sixth applicant had not submitted any evidence of any challenge having been lodged concerning the police actions or the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council's decision of 19 May 2010 authorising the tree felling.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F211", "text": "The Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal stated it was in no position to reduce the sixth applicant's sentence, since neither the applicant nor his lawyer had asked the court to modify the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court's judgment in respect of the sentence, but had rather insisted only on the applicant's innocence.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. Arrest of and proceedings against certain applicants", "2. Arrest of the sixth applicant on 6 July 2010 and subsequent proceedings against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F212", "text": "On 2 June 2010 the ninth applicant informed the chief of the Kharkiv city police that, in protest against the destruction of trees in Gorky Park, the Kharkiv regional council would be picketed daily from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. and until further notice by the Zelenyi Front association (объединение Зеленый фронт), which the ninth applicant represented.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Events subsequent to the Gorky Park protests"]}, {"fact_id": "F213", "text": "On 14 June 2010 the Kharkiv Regional Environmental Protection Inspectorate informed the Kharkiv Municipal Construction Department that it had failed to obtain an environmental impact assessment for the road construction project from the Inspectorate.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Events subsequent to the Gorky Park protests"]}, {"fact_id": "F214", "text": "On 17 June 2010 the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council ordered that 1,006 trees be planted in city parks to compensate for the trees felled in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Events subsequent to the Gorky Park protests"]}, {"fact_id": "F215", "text": "On 2 July 2010 the Kharkiv Regional Environmental Protection Department issued a positive environmental impact assessment (висновок державної екологічної експертизи) of the road construction project.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Events subsequent to the Gorky Park protests"]}, {"fact_id": "F216", "text": "On various dates the protesters, including some of the applicants, complained to the law-enforcement authorities that they had been assaulted by unidentified loggers and men in black clothing with Municipal Guard (MG) badges.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F217", "text": "The protesters' complaints to law-enforcement authorities also alleged that the police officers stationed nearby had done nothing to protect them during the Gorky Park events.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F218", "text": "The protesters' complaints were investigated by the Kharkiv city prosecutor's office.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F219", "text": "On or around 3 June 2010 two television companies sent to the Kharkiv city prosecutor's office, at its request, their video recordings of the events in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F220", "text": "On 3 June 2010 the assistant prosecutor of Kharkiv questioned Mr Kl., director of Municipal Guard (MG), and the heads of four departments of that company about the presence and acts of the guards in the area.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F221", "text": "Mr Kl. and the heads of four departments of Municipal Guard (MG) stated that there had been nobody from the company present in the area except them.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F222", "text": "Mr Kl. and the heads of four departments of Municipal Guard (MG) stated that there had been a lot of men in black with MG badges who were not in fact the company's employees, and that on 28 May 2010, after having been rebuked by Mr Kl., those individuals had taken the badges off.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F223", "text": "On 3 June 2010 the chief of the Kharkiv police sent to the Kharkiv city prosecutor a report summarising the law-enforcement measures taken in the course of the protests in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F224", "text": "The police chief's report of 3 June 2010 stated that Sh. and K., the heads of the NGOs Pechenigy and My Kharkivyany, had taken part in the protests.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F225", "text": "The police chief's report of 3 June 2010 stated that the police had invited the protesters to submit an official notification of their protest action as required by Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine, but the protesters had responded that they were not organising any assembly or action but were rather present in the park as ordinary citizens.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F226", "text": "The police chief's report of 3 June 2010 stated that police officers had been deployed in full force as envisaged by the law-enforcement plan, that is twenty-seven officers on site daily from 20 May to 2 June 2010, except for 23, 29 and 30 May 2010 when two officers had been deployed.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F227", "text": "The police chief's report of 3 June 2010 stated that the construction site had been marked off with tape on 28 May 2010.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F228", "text": "The police chief's report of 3 June 2010 stated that the picketing of the construction site had been discontinued at 9.45 a.m. on 2 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F229", "text": "The Kharkiv city prosecutor's office questioned a number of police officers, employees of subcontractor companies, and journalists in the course of its investigation.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F230", "text": "The Kharkiv city prosecutor's office examined video evidence of the Gorky Park events provided by the protesters.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F231", "text": "The Kharkiv city prosecutor's office solicited information from the local hospital concerning reports of injuries sustained in the course of the events in Gorky Park.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F232", "text": "On 17 and 18 June 2010 the Kharkiv city prosecutor's office questioned twenty employees of private security company PS.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F233", "text": "The twenty PS employees stated that they had not assaulted the protesters, had not deployed any special gear but had indeed pushed the protesters away from the construction site.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F234", "text": "On 24 June 2010 the Kharkiv city prosecutor's office decided not to institute any criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F235", "text": "On 4 August 2010 the Kharkiv regional prosecutor's office overruled the Kharkiv city prosecutor's office decision of 24 June 2010 not to institute criminal proceedings and ordered a further inquiry.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "1. Investigation by the prosecutor's office"]}, {"fact_id": "F236", "text": "Following an additional round of pre-investigation enquiries, on 9 August 2010 the Kharkiv city prosecutor's office decided not to institute criminal proceedings against loggers A. and K., managers of the Main Contractor and subcontractor companies, Municipal Guard (MG), the Kharkiv City Council or its executive authorities, including the Kharkiv Municipal Construction Department, for lack of constituent elements of a crime in their actions.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F237", "text": "The decision of 9 August 2010 stated that it was the result of an investigation conducted in response to a large number of complaints in connection with the Gorky Park events, including from several members of parliament, a member of the regional council, the Pechenigy NGO, a number of journalists and a number of protesters, including the applicants' then representative Mr Bushchenko, and the seventh and ninth applicants.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F238", "text": "The decision of 9 August 2010 referred to the rulings of the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court of 26 May and 14 July 2010 in a case brought by a certain Ms Y. against the Executive Committee of the Kharkiv City Council concerning the construction project as being at the origin of the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F239", "text": "The decision of 9 August 2010 stated that in the course of the investigation more than a hundred people had been questioned, including protesters, police officers, employees of the Main Contractor and subcontractors, and Municipal Guard (MG) staff.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F240", "text": "The Kharkiv city prosecutor's office had also examined photographs and video recordings of the Gorky Park events, including those provided by news outlets, complainants and NGOs.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F241", "text": "The decision of 9 August 2010 described the events of 28 May 2010 as follows: at around 7 a.m. the Main Contractor's staff had marked the boundaries of the construction site with tape and Municipal Guard (MG) staff had taken up the duties of guarding it.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F242", "text": "According to the decision of 9 August 2010, the Municipal Guard (MG) staff had asked individuals who were within the perimeter to leave the area in order to avoid the risk of trauma from the construction equipment, and when they refused, the Main Contractor's management had appealed to the police for help in removing those individuals from the construction site.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F243", "text": "According to the decision of 9 August 2010, some protesters had then been arrested as they had refused to leave the construction site on 28 May 2010.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F244", "text": "Private security company PS staff had provided guard services on the Gorky Park construction site from 28 May to 2 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F245", "text": "When questioned, the private security company PS guards stated that they had avoided any conflict with the protesters and had not assaulted them, despite provocative behaviour on the part of the latter.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F246", "text": "The Kharkiv city prosecutor's office concluded in the decision of 9 August 2010 that no criminal-law provision had been breached in the course of issuance of approvals for the road construction project, tree removal, the construction work or interactions with the protesters.", "source_paragraph": 85, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F247", "text": "The Kharkiv city prosecutor's office concluded in the decision of 9 August 2010 that loggers A. and K. had not committed any offence, for the reasons set out in the Government's version of the events of 2 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 85, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F248", "text": "According to the applicants, notwithstanding their persistent efforts and requests submitted on 17 February, 5 July, 9 August and 12 September 2011, they had been unable to obtain a copy of the decision of 9 August 2010.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F249", "text": "The applicants submitted a copy of a letter from the Kharkiv city prosecutor's office of 19 August 2011, which stated that in response to Mr Bushchenko's request of 5 July 2011 a copy of the decision of 9 August 2010 had been sent to him on 26 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F250", "text": "On 4 October 2011 Mr Bushchenko wrote to the Kharkiv city prosecutor's office again, stating that in fact a copy of the decision of 9 August 2010 had not been enclosed with the authorities' previous letters.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F251", "text": "On 10 October 2011 the Kharkiv city prosecutor's office sent Mr Bushchenko another copy of the decision of 9 August 2010.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F252", "text": "The applicants allege that Mr Bushchenko finally received a copy of the decision of 9 August 2010 for the first time on 19 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F253", "text": "On 25 October 2011 the applicants appealed against the decision of 9 August 2010.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F254", "text": "According to the applicants, on 25 November 2011 the Kharkiv Kyivsky District Court dismissed their appeal against the decision of 9 August 2010.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F255", "text": "On 2 April 2012 the applicants appealed against the Kharkiv Kyivsky District Court's decision of 25 November 2011, and they have not informed the Court of any further developments.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "2. Decision not to institute criminal proceedings of 9 August 2010 and subsequent appeals"]}, {"fact_id": "F256", "text": "On 13 August 2010 the police refused to institute criminal proceedings in connection with the seventh applicant's complaint of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 87, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "3. Police investigation concerning the seventh and ninth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F257", "text": "On 20 March 2012 the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court quashed the police decision of 13 August 2010 on the grounds that the requirements of the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 concerning pre-investigation enquiries had not been complied with and the seventh applicant's allegations had not been verified.", "source_paragraph": 87, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "3. Police investigation concerning the seventh and ninth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F258", "text": "The applicants submitted a copy of a letter from their lawyer to the district police dated 3 October 2014, stating that after the Kharkiv Dzerzhinsky District Court's decision of 20 March 2012, the seventh applicant had not been informed about any further progress in the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 87, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "3. Police investigation concerning the seventh and ninth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F259", "text": "According to the Government, the Kharkiv city prosecutor's office investigated possible official involvement in the alleged attacks on the seventh and ninth applicants and, having found no such involvement, forwarded the material to the police to investigate the possibility that bodily injuries may have been inflicted by private parties.", "source_paragraph": 88, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "3. Police investigation concerning the seventh and ninth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F260", "text": "On 20 August 2010 the police decided not to institute criminal proceedings in respect of possible bodily injuries inflicted on the seventh and ninth applicants by private parties.", "source_paragraph": 88, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "3. Police investigation concerning the seventh and ninth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F261", "text": "In their response of 15 November 2011 to the Government's observations, the applicants alleged that they had learned about the decision of 20 August 2010 only from those observations and had never been provided with a copy.", "source_paragraph": 88, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "3. Police investigation concerning the seventh and ninth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F262", "text": "The applicants submitted copies of letters addressed to the Kharkiv city prosecutor's office and to the city and district police chiefs in which they had asked to be provided with a copy of the decision of 20 August 2010, and enclosed postal receipts showing that those letters had been delivered on 9 and 10 November 2010.", "source_paragraph": 88, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "3. Police investigation concerning the seventh and ninth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F263", "text": "In their comments of 1 March 2012 concerning the applicants' observations of 15 November 2011, the Government commented on a number of factual matters raised by the applicants but not on the applicants' alleged inability to obtain a copy of the decision of 20 August 2010.", "source_paragraph": 88, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "3. Police investigation concerning the seventh and ninth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F264", "text": "On 31 July 2014, in response to the Court's request for further observations, the Government informed the Court that material concerning enquiries into the seventh and ninth applicants' allegations of ill-treatment had been destroyed due to the expiry of the time-limit for their preservation.", "source_paragraph": 89, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "3. Police investigation concerning the seventh and ninth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F265", "text": "The Government provided a statement documenting the destruction of the material concerning enquiries into the seventh and ninth applicants' allegations of ill-treatment, dated 9 September 2013.", "source_paragraph": 89, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "3. Police investigation concerning the seventh and ninth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F266", "text": "In November 2010 a number of protesters, including all the applicants, lodged an action with the Kharkiv Circuit Administrative Court, complaining that the police had failed to protect them against assaults during their peaceful protest against the tree felling, in particular on 28 and 31 May and 1 and 2 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 90, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "4. Administrative court proceedings concerning the police's failure to protect the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F267", "text": "According to the Government, in the course of the trial before the Kharkiv Circuit Administrative Court, the seventh applicant was examined by a representative of the police and stated that she could not say with certitude who had hit her on 31 May 2010 and only supposed that it had been a person in black.", "source_paragraph": 90, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "4. Administrative court proceedings concerning the police's failure to protect the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F268", "text": "On 24 May 2011 the Kharkiv Circuit Administrative Court rejected the applicants' claim that the police had failed to protect them against assaults during their protest.", "source_paragraph": 91, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "4. Administrative court proceedings concerning the police's failure to protect the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F269", "text": "On 9 December 2011 the Kharkiv Administrative Court of Appeal upheld the Kharkiv Circuit Administrative Court's decision of 24 May 2011.", "source_paragraph": 91, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "4. Administrative court proceedings concerning the police's failure to protect the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F270", "text": "On 26 June 2014 the High Administrative Court allowed an appeal lodged by the applicants and remitted the case to the Kharkiv Circuit Administrative Court for re-examination on the grounds that the lower courts' examination of the facts had been incomplete.", "source_paragraph": 91, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "4. Administrative court proceedings concerning the police's failure to protect the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F271", "text": "The High Administrative Court found that the lower courts had failed, in particular, to establish whether attacks on the protesters had really taken place, the list of the officers present, and whether the protesters had appealed for help.", "source_paragraph": 91, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "4. Administrative court proceedings concerning the police's failure to protect the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F272", "text": "As of 8 October 2014, the date of the last communication from the applicants on this point, the applicants' claim concerning the police's failure to protect them was pending before the Kharkiv Circuit Administrative Court.", "source_paragraph": 92, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "H. Domestic proceedings concerning the events in the park", "4. Administrative court proceedings concerning the police's failure to protect the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F273", "text": "Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that citizens have the right to assemble peacefully without arms and to hold meetings, rallies, processions and demonstrations, upon notifying in advance the bodies of executive power or bodies of local self-government.", "source_paragraph": 93, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Constitution of 1996"]}, {"fact_id": "F274", "text": "Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that restrictions on the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly may be established by a court in accordance with the law and only in the interests of national security and public order, with the purpose of preventing disturbances or crimes, protecting the health of the population, or protecting the rights and freedoms of other persons.", "source_paragraph": 93, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Constitution of 1996"]}, {"fact_id": "F275", "text": "Article 40 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that everyone has the right to file individual or collective petitions, or to personally appeal to bodies of state power, bodies of local self-government, and to the officials and officers of these bodies, that are obliged to consider the petitions and to provide a substantiated reply within the term established by law.", "source_paragraph": 93, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Constitution of 1996"]}, {"fact_id": "F276", "text": "In its decision of 19 April 2001 the Constitutional Court of Ukraine provided an official interpretation of Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine, in response to an application for abstract interpretation lodged by the Ministry of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 94, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Constitution of 1996"]}, {"fact_id": "F277", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Ukraine stated in its decision of 19 April 2001 that deadlines for advance notification of meetings, rallies, marches and demonstrations must be reasonable, and that during the advance notification period the authorities have to take preparatory actions to ensure that there are no obstacles to the event and to maintain public order and the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 94, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Constitution of 1996"]}, {"fact_id": "F278", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Ukraine stated in its decision of 19 April 2001 that the period of advance notification must be sufficient for executive or local government authorities to determine whether holding such events complies with the law and, if necessary, to apply to a court under paragraph 2 of Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine to resolve any matters in dispute.", "source_paragraph": 94, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Constitution of 1996"]}, {"fact_id": "F279", "text": "Article 22 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 provides that in the case of an offence of minor importance the offender could be relieved of liability with a reprimand.", "source_paragraph": 95, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F280", "text": "Article 32 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 provides that administrative detention for up to fifteen days may be applied by courts only in exceptional cases for certain administrative offences.", "source_paragraph": 96, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F281", "text": "Article 33 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 requires the sentencing authority, in determining a sentence, to take into account the nature of the offence in question, the degree of culpability of the person concerned and his or her financial situation, and any attenuating and aggravating circumstances.", "source_paragraph": 96, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F282", "text": "Article 185 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 provides that malicious disobedience in the face of a lawful order or demand by a police officer who is carrying out his official duties shall be punished by a fine of between 136 and 255 Ukrainian hryvnias (UAH), or by withholding 20% of earnings; or, in the event that in the particular circumstances of the case and with regard to the offender's character these measures are found to be insufficient, by administrative detention of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 97, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F283", "text": "Article 185-1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 provides that a breach of the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations shall be punishable by a reprimand or by a fine, and that the same actions committed within a year of the application of administrative penalties or by the organiser shall be punishable by a fine, or by correctional labour of one to two months with a deduction of 20% of earnings, or by administrative detention of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 97, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F284", "text": "Under Article 294 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1984, the parties to administrative-offence proceedings have the right to appeal against court judgments within ten days of their delivery, and such an appeal is to be submitted through the court of first instance.", "source_paragraph": 98, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F285", "text": "Under Article 294 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1984, the court of first instance must, within three days, refer the appeal together with the case file to a court of appeal, which has twenty days to examine the case.", "source_paragraph": 98, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F286", "text": "Under Article 294 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1984, the court of appeal must notify the parties about the hearing not later than three days before the hearing, and the failure of parties to appear does not prevent the court from examining the case, except where a good reason is shown for their failure to appear or the court has no information that the party failing to appear has been duly notified.", "source_paragraph": 98, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F287", "text": "Under Article 294 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1984, the appellate court's examination is limited to matters raised in the appeal, unless the court discovers another breach of substantive or procedural law, and the court has the power to examine new evidence if a good reason has been shown for non-production of such evidence before the first-instance court or the first-instance court rejected such evidence without sufficient grounds.", "source_paragraph": 98, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F288", "text": "Under Article 294 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1984, the court of appeal has powers to reject the appeal, to quash the first-instance court's judgment and discontinue the proceedings or quash the judgment and adopt a new judgment, or to amend the judgment, but cannot impose a sentence more severe than that imposed at first instance, and the appellate court's decision is final and not amenable to any further appeal.", "source_paragraph": 98, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F289", "text": "Article 297-1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 provides that a judgment in an administrative-offence case can be reviewed in the event of a finding by an international judicial body, whose jurisdiction Ukraine has accepted, of a violation by Ukraine of its international obligations during the judicial examination of the case.", "source_paragraph": 99, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Offences of 1984 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F290", "text": "Article 182 of the Code of Administrative Justice of 2005 provides that immediately upon receipt of a notification concerning the organisation of meetings, rallies, processions, demonstrations, etc., executive authorities and bodies of local self-government shall have the right to apply to a circuit administrative court with an action seeking to prohibit these events or otherwise restrict the right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 100, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Justice of 2005 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F291", "text": "Article 182 of the Code of Administrative Justice of 2005 provides that an action received on the date on which the aforementioned events take place or thereafter shall be left without examination.", "source_paragraph": 100, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Justice of 2005 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F292", "text": "At the material time the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 provided for a procedure known as pre-investigation enquiries, which resulted in a decision either not to institute criminal proceedings or to institute them, in which case a fully-fledged criminal investigation was to be conducted.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F293", "text": "Article 97 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 required a prosecutor, investigator, body of inquiry or judge to accept allegations or notifications of crimes and, upon receipt, to adopt within three days one of the following decisions: to institute criminal proceedings, to refuse to institute criminal proceedings, or to remit the application for examination in accordance with the rules of jurisdiction.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F294", "text": "Article 97 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 provided that before instituting criminal proceedings, the prosecutor, investigator or body of inquiry shall conduct an inquiry if necessary to verify information contained in an allegation or notification of a crime, to be completed within ten days by means of collecting explanations from individual citizens or officials or by obtaining necessary documents.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F295", "text": "Article 99 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 provided that where there are no grounds to institute criminal proceedings, a prosecutor, investigator, body of inquiry or judge shall issue a decision refusing to institute criminal proceedings and shall inform the individuals and organisations with an interest in the matter of such a decision.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F296", "text": "Article 99-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 provided that a decision by an investigator or body of inquiry refusing to institute criminal proceedings may be appealed against to the relevant prosecutor, and if that decision was taken by a prosecutor, it may be appealed against to a higher prosecutor, within seven days of the date of receipt of a copy of the decision.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F297", "text": "Article 236-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 provided that an appeal against a decision refusing to institute criminal proceedings shall be lodged with the relevant court by the person whose interests are concerned or his/her representative within seven days of notification of the decision by the prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F298", "text": "Other relevant provisions concerning pre-investigation enquiries under the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 can be found in the judgment in the case of Kaverzin v. Ukraine (no. 23893/03, § 45, 15 May 2012).", "source_paragraph": 102, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F299", "text": "The Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 was in force at the material time and was repealed with effect from 19 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 103, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure of 1960 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F300", "text": "The Citizens' Petitions Act of 1996 contains rules concerning petitions, guarantees for those lodging them and regulates the procedure for their examination.", "source_paragraph": 104, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "E. Citizens' Petitions Act of 1996 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F301", "text": "The Citizens' Petitions Act of 1996 provides for the right of citizens and other persons lawfully present in Ukraine to address petitions to State and municipal bodies on matters of concern, including alleged breaches of the law.", "source_paragraph": 104, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "E. Citizens' Petitions Act of 1996 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F302", "text": "The Citizens' Petitions Act of 1996 imposes on State and municipal bodies an obligation to examine petitions in an impartial manner, respond and take remedial action if warranted, with a time-limit for response of normally one month, which can be shortened where the citizen so requests and the circumstances so warrant.", "source_paragraph": 104, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "E. Citizens' Petitions Act of 1996 (as amended)"]}, {"fact_id": "F303", "text": "Section 9 of the Licensing Act of 2000, in force at the relevant time, required a licence for services associated with guarding State-owned and other property and for personal protection services.", "source_paragraph": 105, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "F. Rules concerning security guards"]}, {"fact_id": "F304", "text": "Section 6 of the Licensing Act of 2000 required the authorities issuing licences for respective activities to enact the rules regulating the activities in the relevant field.", "source_paragraph": 105, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "F. Rules concerning security guards"]}, {"fact_id": "F305", "text": "In the field of security guard services, licensing rules were enacted by Order no. 505 of the Ministry of the Interior of 1 December 2009, entitled Licensing Rules for Business Operations Involving Security Services to Guard Property and Individuals (Ліцензійні умови провадження господарської діяльності з надання послуг з охорони власності та громадян), and were in force at the relevant time.", "source_paragraph": 105, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "F. Rules concerning security guards"]}, {"fact_id": "F306", "text": "Rule 1.3 of the Licensing Rules for Business Operations Involving Security Services to Guard Property and Individuals defined 'guarded entity' as either individuals or property belonging to individuals and public or private legal entities.", "source_paragraph": 106, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "F. Rules concerning security guards"]}, {"fact_id": "F307", "text": "Rule 1.4.1 of the Licensing Rules for Business Operations Involving Security Services to Guard Property and Individuals provided that security measures performed by security guards include control over persons' access to the guarded entity, their movement within its territory and leaving it.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "F. Rules concerning security guards"]}, {"fact_id": "F308", "text": "Rule 1.4.2 of the Licensing Rules for Business Operations Involving Security Services to Guard Property and Individuals provided that physical security measures are actions directly aimed at detecting, preventing and stopping intrusions into the guarded entity unauthorised by the owner and the presence of persons unauthorised within the guarded entity.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "F. Rules concerning security guards"]}, {"fact_id": "F309", "text": "Rule 1.4.3 of the Licensing Rules for Business Operations Involving Security Services to Guard Property and Individuals provided that rapid response measures are urgent actions, starting from those minimally required, in connection with any unlawful acts against the guarded entities or events and circumstances causing or capable of causing pecuniary damage to the owners or posing an obvious threat to the personal safety of individuals, the personnel of the guarded entity, or other individuals and guards.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "F. Rules concerning security guards"]}, {"fact_id": "F310", "text": "Rule 2.1.2 of the Licensing Rules for Business Operations Involving Security Services to Guard Property and Individuals required licensed entities to ensure that their guards wore insignia showing that they belonged to a specific licensed entity, to be approved by the licensed entity and notified to the Ministry of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 108, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "F. Rules concerning security guards"]}, {"fact_id": "F311", "text": "Rule 2.2.3 of the Licensing Rules for Business Operations Involving Security Services to Guard Property and Individuals required the licensed entity to notify the police without delay of any attempted unlawful actions against the guarded entity, discovery of theft or any other offences, and to take steps to restrict the access of third parties to the scene of the event until the arrival of the police.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "F. Rules concerning security guards"]}, {"fact_id": "F312", "text": "Section 12(1)(3) of the Guarding Activity Act of 2012 authorises security guards to prevent people from accessing a guarded entity or to apprehend those who have entered it or are trying to leave it in breach of established rules, and in the latter case requires guards to notify the police without delay.", "source_paragraph": 110, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "F. Rules concerning security guards"]}, {"fact_id": "F313", "text": "At the relevant time, section 28(3) of the Populated Localities Development Act of 2005 provided that the removal of trees had to be carried out in accordance with the procedure set forth by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine (Cabinet of Ministers Resolution no. 1045 of 1 August 2006).", "source_paragraph": 111, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "G. Rules governing tree removal and construction site safety"]}, {"fact_id": "F314", "text": "Cabinet of Ministers Resolution no. 1045 of 1 August 2006 stipulated that trees could be removed within the framework of implementation of urban development plans but that their removal required a decision by the executive authority of the municipality and an order, and that before any decision could be issued, the trees had to be examined by a commission appointed by the municipal authorities.", "source_paragraph": 111, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "G. Rules governing tree removal and construction site safety"]}, {"fact_id": "F315", "text": "At the material time, safety rules for construction were contained in Construction Norms and Rules (СНиП) III-4-80 Safety Rules for Construction, enacted by Order no. 82 of the USSR State Committee on Construction of 9 June 1980, which continued to be applicable in Ukraine on the basis of Resolution of the Ukrainian Parliament of 12 September 1991 on temporary application of legislative acts of the Soviet Union.", "source_paragraph": 112, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "G. Rules governing tree removal and construction site safety"]}, {"fact_id": "F316", "text": "Rule 1.16 of Construction Norms and Rules III-4-80 prohibited access of unauthorised persons to construction sites.", "source_paragraph": 112, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "G. Rules governing tree removal and construction site safety"]}, {"fact_id": "F317", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly were developed by the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe and by the Venice Commission, and adopted by the Venice Commission at its 83rd Plenary Session on 4 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F318", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly define an assembly as the intentional and temporary presence of a number of individuals in a public place for a common expressive purpose, and state that all types of peaceful assembly deserve protection.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F319", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly provide that the policing of assemblies must be guided by the human rights principles of legality, necessity, proportionality and non-discrimination, and that the State has a positive duty to take reasonable and appropriate measures to enable peaceful assemblies to take place without participants fearing physical violence.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F320", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly provide that law enforcement officials must protect participants of a peaceful assembly from any person or group that attempts to disrupt or inhibit it in any way.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F321", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly state that they apply to assemblies held in public places that everyone has an equal right to use, including public parks, squares, streets, roads, avenues, sidewalks, pavements and footpaths, and that the state should always seek to facilitate public assemblies at the organizers' preferred location where this is a public place ordinarily accessible to the public.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F322", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly state that the term 'peaceful' should be interpreted to include conduct that may annoy or give offence to persons opposed to the ideas being promoted, and even conduct that temporarily hinders, impedes or obstructs the activities of third parties, and that assemblies involving purely passive resistance should be characterized as peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F323", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly provide that law enforcement agencies should be proactive in engaging with assembly organizers, that officers should seek to send clear messages that inform crowd expectations and reduce the potential for conflict escalation, and that there should be a nominated point of contact within the law enforcement agency whom protesters can contact before or during an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F324", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly provide that law enforcement officers should allow time for people in a crowd to respond as individuals to the situation they face, including any warnings or directions given to them.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F325", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly provide that if dispersal is deemed necessary, the assembly organiser and participants should be clearly and audibly informed prior to any intervention by law enforcement personnel, and should be given reasonable time to disperse voluntarily, and only if participants then fail to disperse may law enforcement officials intervene further.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F326", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly provide that law-enforcement officials should be liable for any failure to fulfil their positive obligations to protect and facilitate the right to freedom of peaceful assembly, and that liability should also extend to private agencies or individuals acting on behalf of the state.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F327", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly provide that if the force used is not authorized by law or more force was used than necessary, law-enforcement officers should face civil and/or criminal liability, as well as disciplinary action, and that relevant law-enforcement personnel should also be held liable for failing to intervene where such intervention may have prevented other officers from using excessive force.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F328", "text": "In their joint report on the proper management of assemblies issued in 2016 (A/HRC/31/66), the United Nations Special Rapporteurs on the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association and on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions stated that open dialogue between authorities and assembly organizers before, during and after an assembly enables a protective and facilitative approach, helping to defuse tension and prevent escalation.", "source_paragraph": 114, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations Special Rapporteurs"]}, {"fact_id": "F329", "text": "The United Nations Special Rapporteurs' joint report A/HRC/31/66 stated that law enforcement agencies and officials should take all reasonable steps to communicate with assembly organizers and/or participants regarding the policing operation and any safety or security measures, and that law enforcement officials must be trained on the possible impact of any indirect communication that may be perceived as intimidation.", "source_paragraph": 114, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations Special Rapporteurs"]}, {"fact_id": "F330", "text": "The United Nations Special Rapporteurs' joint report A/HRC/31/66 stated that only governmental authorities or high-ranking officers with sufficient and accurate information should have the authority to order dispersal, and that if dispersal is deemed necessary, the assembly and participants should be clearly and audibly informed and given reasonable time to disperse voluntarily before law enforcement officials intervene further.", "source_paragraph": 114, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations Special Rapporteurs"]}, {"fact_id": "F331", "text": "The United Nations Special Rapporteurs' joint report A/HRC/31/66 stated that a clear and transparent command structure must be established to minimize the risk of violence or the use of force, and that law enforcement officials must be clearly and individually identifiable, for example by displaying a nameplate or number.", "source_paragraph": 114, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations Special Rapporteurs"]}, {"fact_id": "F332", "text": "The United Nations Special Rapporteurs' joint report A/HRC/31/66 stated that civilian private security services should not perform policing-type functions in relation to assemblies, but where this occurs, such services must respect and protect human rights and should comply with the highest voluntary standards of conduct.", "source_paragraph": 114, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations Special Rapporteurs"]}, {"fact_id": "F333", "text": "In his report on the right to life and the use of force by private security providers in law-enforcement contexts issued in 2016 (A/HRC/32/39), the United Nations Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions stated that where States choose to devolve some of their responsibilities for the provision of security to private entities, those actions are attributable to the State, and at least the same restrictions apply to private security providers operating in such a context as would apply to State law enforcement personnel.", "source_paragraph": 115, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations Special Rapporteurs"]}, {"fact_id": "F334", "text": "The United Nations Special Rapporteur's report A/HRC/32/39 stated that the responsibility to plan an appropriate operational response to an emerging situation applies as clearly to private security providers as it does to State law enforcement, and that in the case of private security providers there exists an additional potential precautionary step, namely to call upon the State's law enforcement personnel.", "source_paragraph": 115, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations Special Rapporteurs"]}, {"fact_id": "F335", "text": "The United Nations Special Rapporteur's report A/HRC/32/39 stated that in circumstances where private security providers resort to force having turned down an opportunity to defer to the State's police, their full compliance with the requirements of precaution would be called into question.", "source_paragraph": 115, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations Special Rapporteurs"]}, {"fact_id": "F336", "text": "The United Nations Special Rapporteur's report A/HRC/32/39 stated that in contexts such as mass labour protests or disputes or other mass gatherings taking place on or around private property, the police should be called in whenever uncertainties exist with regard to private and public interests, especially concerning the use of force.", "source_paragraph": 115, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations Special Rapporteurs"]}, {"fact_id": "F337", "text": "The United Nations Special Rapporteur's report A/HRC/32/39 stated that States must impose on private security providers and their personnel a duty of precaution concerning recruitment, training, equipment, planning, command and control, and reporting, and that in circumstances likely to require the use of force, private security personnel have a responsibility to inform State law enforcement and to follow any instructions given.", "source_paragraph": 115, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations Special Rapporteurs"]}, {"fact_id": "F338", "text": "The International Code of Conduct for Private Security Service Providers of 9 November 2010 was drawn up as part of a multi-stakeholder initiative in the international private security sector and has been signed by a number of security companies.", "source_paragraph": 116, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. International Code of Conduct for Private Security Service Providers"]}, {"fact_id": "F339", "text": "The International Code of Conduct for Private Security Service Providers of 9 November 2010 sets out a commitment that signatory companies, to the extent consistent with reasonable security requirements and the safety of civilians, their personnel and clients, will require all personnel to be individually identifiable whenever they are carrying out activities in discharge of their contractual responsibilities.", "source_paragraph": 116, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. International Code of Conduct for Private Security Service Providers"]}, {"fact_id": "F340", "text": "On 17 June 2010 Amnesty International's Director for Europe and Central Asia wrote to the Prosecutor General of Ukraine describing the background to the events in Gorky Park and calling on the Prosecutor General to take a number of steps for the protection of the Gorky Park protesters.", "source_paragraph": 117, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "D. Amnesty International's intervention"]}, {"fact_id": "F341", "text": "Amnesty International's letter of 17 June 2010 stated that at about 6 a.m. on 28 May 2010 a large number of Municipal Guard security guards started to break up the human chain formed by the demonstrators in Gorky Park, and were joined after a few minutes by police officers who then detained 10-12 people and took them to the Dzerzhinsky district police station.", "source_paragraph": 117, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "D. Amnesty International's intervention"]}, {"fact_id": "F342", "text": "Amnesty International's letter of 17 June 2010 stated that Andrei Yevarnitsky and Denis Chernega were charged and subsequently sentenced to 15 days' detention on 9 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 117, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "D. Amnesty International's intervention"]}, {"fact_id": "F343", "text": "Amnesty International's letter of 17 June 2010 stated that witnesses reported that at no point during the events of 28 May 2010 did the police officers make any requests or demands to the demonstrators that might have resulted in the charges against Andrei Yevarnitsky and Denis Chernega.", "source_paragraph": 117, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "D. Amnesty International's intervention"]}, {"fact_id": "F344", "text": "Amnesty International's letter of 17 June 2010 stated that Andrei Yevarnitsky and Denis Chernega appeared to have been sentenced to a punishment amounting to imprisonment for the peaceful exercise of their rights to freedom of assembly and expression, and that the organisation considered them to be prisoners of conscience.", "source_paragraph": 117, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "D. Amnesty International's intervention"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["protection_of_health", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F051", "F054", "F121", "F133", "F134", "F135", "F137", "F139", "F123", "F147", "F122", "F340", "F341", "F342", "F343", "F344", "F196", "F197"], "interference": ["F121", "F133", "F135", "F137", "F139", "F186", "F189", "F177", "F178", "F179", "F185", "F200", "F035", "F036", "F044", "F045", "F058", "F059", "F105", "F108", "F040", "F041", "F061", "F100", "F226"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F282", "F273", "F274", "F276", "F277", "F278", "F290", "F291", "F053", "F055", "F056"], "legitimate_aim": ["F315", "F316", "F083", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F087", "F088", "F011", "F016", "F019", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033"], "necessity": ["F133", "F134", "F135", "F136", "F137", "F138", "F139", "F190", "F191", "F192", "F193", "F157", "F158", "F159", "F160", "F167", "F169", "F170", "F173", "F174", "F175", "F178", "F179", "F185", "F055", "F056", "F083", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F087", "F088", "F122", "F123", "F196", "F197", "F198", "F199", "F200", "F064", "F194", "F204", "F205", "F206", "F208", "F211"], "positive_obligation": ["F038", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F043", "F048", "F049", "F051", "F057", "F058", "F059", "F061", "F095", "F096", "F100", "F105", "F108", "F220", "F221", "F222", "F226", "F234", "F236", "F044", "F305", "F306", "F307", "F308", "F309", "F311"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F051", "F002", "F121", "F133", "F147", "F122", "F123"], "interference": ["F121", "F139", "F177", "F185", "F200", "F061", "F058", "F100"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F282", "F053", "F273", "F274", "F278", "F290", "F291"], "legitimate_aim": ["F315", "F316", "F083", "F085", "F030"], "necessity": ["F133", "F134", "F137", "F138", "F190", "F192", "F157", "F160", "F173", "F174", "F167", "F123", "F178", "F179", "F185", "F196", "F197", "F198", "F200", "F211"], "positive_obligation": ["F040", "F041", "F048", "F061", "F100", "F305", "F307", "F308", "F309", "F311", "F058", "F059", "F220", "F222", "F234", "F044"]}, "list3": ["F133", "F137", "F138", "F157", "F160", "F173", "F174", "F167", "F190", "F192", "F123", "F178", "F179", "F185", "F196", "F197", "F198", "F200", "F211", "F040", "F048", "F061", "F100", "F307", "F309", "F311", "F058", "F059", "F222", "F234"]}} {"case_name": "case_217", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some of the applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_218", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The present case primarily concerns the applicant's complaint that his arrest at a demonstration had amounted to an interference with his rights to freedom of expression and freedom of assembly, in breach of Articles 10 and 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The present case primarily concerns the applicant's complaint that the imposition of a custodial sanction in respect of administrative offences had amounted to an interference with his rights to freedom of expression and freedom of assembly, in breach of Articles 10 and 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was born in 1980.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant lives in Tbilisi.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant was represented before the Court by Mr I. Chitashvili, a lawyer practising in Tbilisi.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr B. Dzamashvili, of the Ministry of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant is a civil society activist.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant has been a member of the Georgian Labour Party since 2019.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the applicant, fourteen sets of administrative-offence proceedings were instituted against him throughout the course of his activism, including the one at the heart of the present application.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 29 November 2019 a demonstration was held in front of the National Parliamentary Library of Georgia.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The demonstration on 29 November 2019 was part of a series of protests about the Parliament of Georgia's failure to adopt amendments to the Constitution of Georgia meant to facilitate the transition of the parliamentary electoral system from a 'mixed-member' system to one of proportional representation (see Makarashvili and Others v. Georgia, nos. 23158/20 and 2 others, §§ 5-6, 1 September 2022).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The demonstration on 29 November 2019 was attended by opposition politicians, civil society activists and ordinary citizens.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The location of the demonstration on 29 November 2019 in front of the National Parliamentary Library of Georgia was apparently chosen because the Minister of Justice had been scheduled to give a speech there.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The exact number of participants in the demonstration on 29 November 2019 remains unclear.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Video material relating to the demonstration on 29 November 2019 shows a couple of hundred individuals gathered at the site.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Video material relating to the demonstration on 29 November 2019 shows a large number of police officers gathered at the site.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Minister of Justice entered the National Parliamentary Library of Georgia with the help of a police cordon on 29 November 2019.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Video coverage of the demonstration on 29 November 2019 shows that the demonstrators attempted several times to break through the police cordon and force their way to the entrance of the National Parliamentary Library of Georgia while the Minister of Justice was there.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Video coverage of the demonstration on 29 November 2019 shows that the pavement and narrow road leading to the entrance of the National Parliamentary Library of Georgia were largely occupied by people who had gathered at the demonstration, including police officers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Footage from the demonstration on 29 November 2019 shows the police telling the demonstrators that their actions were contrary to the law and that they could not block the entrance to the National Parliamentary Library of Georgia or the road.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Footage from the demonstration on 29 November 2019 shows some demonstrators yelling inaudible phrases at the police officers while the officers remained calm.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Six individuals, including the applicant, were arrested on 29 November 2019 on various grounds.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "It does not appear that the demonstration on 29 November 2019 was dispersed.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "At some point during the demonstration on 29 November 2019, the applicant turned towards the police officers, allegedly in response to the police calls to clear the road, holding beans in his hand and shouting loudly that beans used to be 'gruel for slaves'.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the case file, the applicant then threw the beans at the police officers, crying out 'slave gruel for the police'.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The video footage available in the case file shows that the applicant was arrested immediately after throwing beans at the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant's arrest took place at 11.45 a.m. on 29 November 2019.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant was escorted to the Tbilisi police station for having allegedly committed offences under Article 166 of the Code of Administrative Offences (disorderly conduct/minor hooliganism).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicant was escorted to the Tbilisi police station for having allegedly committed offences under Article 173 of the Code of Administrative Offences (disobeying lawful orders of a law-enforcement officer/insulting a law-enforcement officer).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the administrative-offence report, the applicant had blocked the road on 29 November 2019.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the administrative-offence report, the applicant had breached public order on 29 November 2019.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to the administrative-offence report, the applicant had resisted the police on 29 November 2019.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the administrative-offence report, the applicant had insulted the police officers on 29 November 2019.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "According to the administrative-offence report, the applicant had disobeyed the lawful orders of the police officers on 29 November 2019.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The administrative-arrest report indicated Articles 166 and 173 of the Code of Administrative Offences as the provisions relevant to the applicant's arrest.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The administrative-arrest report stated that on 29 November 2019 the applicant (Lasha Chkhartishvili) blocked the road beside the Public Library located on Purtseladze Street in Tbilisi.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The administrative-arrest report stated that the applicant insulted and harassed members of the public.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The administrative-arrest report stated that despite multiple instructions to stop, the applicant continued in defiance of the law and after the police had ordered him to desist he became more aggressive and threw dried beans at the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The administrative-arrest report stated that the applicant insulted the police officers and called them slaves.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The administrative-arrest report stated that the applicant was arrested for minor hooliganism and disobeying police orders.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICANT'S ARREST AND DETENTION"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 29 November 2019 the applicant was brought before the Tbilisi City Court.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The trial before the Tbilisi City Court started at 3.32 p.m. on 29 November 2019.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "At the outset of the trial before the Tbilisi City Court, the parties were warned that they must observe order and comply with judicial instructions.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "At the outset of the trial before the Tbilisi City Court, the parties were warned that contempt of court would entail sanctions.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicant requested the recusal of the judge presiding over his administrative-offence case at the Tbilisi City Court.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant stated that it was always that judge who presided over administrative-offence cases relating to arrests at demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant stated that his case had been scheduled for immediate consideration while older administrative-offence cases had still been pending.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicant expressed the opinion that the judge was biased and must have been following instructions coming from outside the courtroom.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The judge responded that the applicant's recusal request was unsubstantiated as it did not demonstrate the existence of any grounds provided for by the law for his recusal.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The judge stated that he was on duty that day, which had been the reason for the applicant's case having been assigned to him.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "While the judge was speaking, the applicant interrupted in a louder voice, repeating that all politically sensitive cases had been assigned to that judge.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The judge asked the applicant to calm down, to show respect towards the court and to allow the case to proceed.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The applicant responded that he was calm and that it was the judge who had to worry because he would be held accountable before the law for all the politically motivated prosecutions.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The judge explained that he was not interested in any political party, to which the applicant responded: 'we can see that'.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The judge asked the applicant to calm down, warning that failing to do so would result in his removal from the courtroom and the trial proceeding without his attendance or participation.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicant repeated that the judge would be held accountable before the law.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicant received a fine of 300 Georgian laris (approximately 120 euros) for the offence of contempt of court.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicant was notified that the contempt of court fine decision could be appealed against.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The applicant continued, in a calm voice, to accuse the judge of wrongdoing, interrupting him.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The applicant was warned that continued disorderly conduct would result in his removal from the courtroom.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicant replied 'remove me, no problem' and made some inaudible remark.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The judge ordered the applicant's removal from the courtroom.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "In response to the judge's order for removal, the applicant started yelling that 'slaves' of B.I. (the chairman of Georgian Dream, a political party that at the time in question held an absolute majority in Parliament), like the judge in question, would end up in prison.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicant was removed from the courtroom.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "After the applicant's removal from the courtroom, the judge stated that, unlike the other cases the applicant had referred to, the applicant's case had involved the element of administrative arrest, rendering the consideration of the case a matter of urgent priority.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The judge continued to hear the administrative-offence case in the applicant's absence.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The applicant's defence lawyer requested that the trial be adjourned, stating that she needed time to familiarise herself with the administrative case file and to collect the evidence.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The applicant's defence lawyer stated that she had not been able to meet with the applicant prior to the trial.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The applicant's defence lawyer alleged that the police had concealed the applicant's whereabouts until his eventual transfer to the courtroom.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The judge granted the adjournment request and adjourned the hearing for three hours and ten minutes.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "In response to the complaint that the police had obstructed the lawyer's attempts to meet with the applicant, the lawyer was told that a separate complaint should have been lodged if she believed that the authorities had committed any unlawful actions.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Once the hearing resumed, the applicant's defence lawyer requested that the applicant be questioned as a witness, since she had not had time to consult him.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Once the hearing resumed, the applicant's defence lawyer requested that the trial be postponed again, as she needed additional time to obtain some video recordings in respect of the events complained of.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Once the hearing resumed, the applicant's defence lawyer requested that the applicant be released from detention.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The applicant's defence lawyer complained that the police had exceeded their powers during the applicant's arrest.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The trial judge rejected the application for the applicant to be questioned as a witness, reasoning that the applicant's own behaviour had caused his removal from the courtroom after unheeded warnings and that his appearance as a witness was not justified in such circumstances.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "As regards the video evidence which the applicant's defence lawyer had sought to obtain, the trial judge noted that this material had been widely disseminated by the media and the lawyer was free to show those recordings to the court in addition to the material already available in the case file, without the need for further adjournment.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The trial judge noted that the applicant's detention meant that the conduct of the trial had to be especially expeditious, and another adjournment was therefore not considered necessary.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "During the hearing before the trial court, the author of the administrative-offence report stated that the applicant had a history of committing administrative offences and disobeying police orders.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "During the hearing before the trial court, it was noted that on at least two previous occasions — in 2008 and 2014 — the applicant had been ordered to pay administrative fines.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The author of the administrative-offence report requested, in view of the applicant's history of administrative offences, that the trial court apply a stricter sanction as a deterrent for the future.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The applicant's representative contested the officer's submission regarding the applicant's history of administrative offences as unsubstantiated, unclear and irrelevant.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On 29 November 2019 the Tbilisi City Court acquitted the applicant of any offence under Article 166 of the Code of Administrative Offences (disorderly conduct/minor hooliganism).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 29 November 2019 the Tbilisi City Court found the applicant guilty of insulting law-enforcement officers and disobeying their lawful orders, in breach of Article 173 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court sentenced the applicant to eight days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court's judgment was based on the administrative-offence and arrest reports of 29 November 2019.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court's judgment was based on internal reports of the police.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court's judgment was based on a document entitled 'information regarding the accused', reflecting the fact that the applicant had been charged with administrative offences in the past.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court's judgment was based on the parties' submissions.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court's judgment was based on witness statements, including the officers' explanation that beans had been thrown in their faces.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court's judgment was based on the video footage relating to the applicant's arrest.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court articulated the view that statements of police officers would, in principle, be sufficient to shift the burden of proof onto a person accused of committing an administrative offence, because of the expertise of the police and the fact that they carried out their professional duties in line with the domestic legislation.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court noted that statements by persons alleged to have breached administrative rules and regulations could not, unless supported by other evidence, be regarded as constituting irrefutable evidence in respect of determining the circumstances of a case, given that the individuals in question were interested parties and that information provided by them could be aimed at covering up an offence and avoiding sanctions.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court established that the case file material confirmed that the applicant showed disobedience towards the lawful demands of the police and insulted the police officers, conduct falling within the scope of Article 173 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court found that there was no evidence which could incontrovertibly confirm the commission of conduct contrary to Article 166 of the Code of Administrative Offences; namely, the facts of cursing at the site of a public gathering and of a breach of public order had not been established.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court noted that on 29 November 2019 a demonstration was being held along the site of the public library in Tbilisi, on Purtseladze Street, and that police officers were ensuring the peaceful conduct of the demonstration and the implementation of the constitutionally guaranteed rights of citizens.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court found that the police officers were enforcing security, protecting the rights of the participants in the demonstration and ensuring citizens' constitutionally guaranteed right to freely move along Rustaveli Avenue and the adjacent streets, which constituted sufficient grounds for the officers to implement appropriate measures provided for by law.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court found that the evidence, the parties' explanations and the video material confirmed the police officers' instructions and the applicant's disobedience to such instructions, as well as the fact of his insulting the officers.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court found that the law-enforcement authority called on the applicant to leave the road and that request was left unheeded.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court found that the law-enforcement authorities gave instructions to preserve order and that the instructions were lawful and aimed at achieving the legitimate goal of safeguarding individuals and public order.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court found that calling the police officers 'slaves' amounted to behaviour which insulted and degraded the honour and dignity of the police officers and constituted a sufficient basis for the applicant's actions to fall within the scope of Article 173 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court referred to the Freedom of Speech Act, which accepts and protects the freedoms of speech and expression as eternal and supreme human values, while section 8 of the same Act provides for grounds for limiting these freedoms only if such limitations are provided for by law in a clear and foreseeable manner and when the advantage achieved by a limitation exceeds the damage inflicted by it.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court found that the evidence, the parties' submissions and the video material confirmed that the applicant called the police officers 'slaves' and threw beans at them, stating that it had been gruel for slaves.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court noted that section 48(3) of the Police Act provides that insulting the honour and dignity of police officers who are on duty will incur liability under Georgian legislation.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court noted that Article 173 of the Code of Administrative Offences expressly defines liability for disobeying the lawful orders of police officers on duty, verbally insulting them and/or carrying out insulting actions towards them.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court considered that actions insulting the dignity of police officers — calling them 'slaves' and throwing beans at them while noting that beans used to be gruel for slaves — cannot be considered a form of protest.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court referred to section 111(1) of the Assemblies and Demonstrations Act, which authorises the police to clear the road in the event of the partial or full blocking of a road by the participants in an assembly or a demonstration if the number of the participants allows the holding of those events without blocking the road.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court found that a need to block the road had not been demonstrated in the present case and accordingly the applicant did not have a right to occupy it, and the police officers' repeated requests to have the road cleared to allow cars to circulate were lawful but not complied with.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "As regards the sanction of the eight-day custodial sentence imposed on the applicant, the Tbilisi City Court cited Articles 33 and 35 of the Code of Administrative Offences and reasoned that 'in view of the applicant's personality and the degree of seriousness of his actions', the imposition of a fine or a verbal reprimand would not ensure the attainment of the objectives of punishment.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "On 1 December 2019 the applicant lodged an appeal against the Tbilisi City Court's decision.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant complained that the trial court had relied exclusively on the police officers' account and that any doubt should have benefited him, according to the principles applicable in criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant stated that it remained unclear what lawful orders he had disobeyed.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant noted that in circumstances where the trial court had acquitted him of the charge under Article 166 of the Code of Administrative Offences, his arrest and conviction for the breach of Article 173 of the Code of Administrative Offences had been devoid of justification.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant submitted that it had been the police who had blocked the road and that he physically could not have blocked it.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant submitted that he had not insulted the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant stated that he had been unable to meet with his lawyer before the court hearing despite the lawyer's attempt to secure a meeting through the bailiff of the court, though no evidence appears to have been presented on that account.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The applicant did not complain about his removal from the courtroom in his appeal.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "On 2 December 2019 the Tbilisi Court of Appeal issued a final decision rejecting the applicant's appeal as inadmissible.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The final decision of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal was served on the applicant on 19 December 2019.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Tbilisi Court of Appeal found that the parties to the proceedings had been given the opportunity to argue their case and the trial court had correctly assessed all the relevant evidence.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Tbilisi Court of Appeal upheld the lower court's findings, stating that the applicant had not adduced any evidence or referred to newly discovered circumstances surrounding his administrative-offence case which would have warranted the re-examination of his case on the merits.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE-OFFENCE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Section 9(3) of the Assemblies and Demonstrations Act provides that the blocking of entrances to buildings during an assembly or a demonstration shall be prohibited.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. ASSEMBLIES AND DEMONSTRATIONS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Section 11(2)(e) of the Assemblies and Demonstrations Act provides that it is prohibited to deliberately obstruct traffic.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. ASSEMBLIES AND DEMONSTRATIONS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Section 111 of the Assemblies and Demonstrations Act provides that in the event of participants in a demonstration partially or completely blocking a road used by cars, the police have the right to decide to clear the road and/or restore the movement of vehicles if blocking the road 'is not made necessary by the number of participants in an assembly or a demonstration'.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. ASSEMBLIES AND DEMONSTRATIONS ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Article 33 of the Code of Administrative Offences provides that the nature of the offence, the personalities of the offenders, the degree of blame to be ascribed to the offenders, their financial status and any extenuating and aggravating circumstances are to be taken into account at the sentencing stage.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Article 35 §§ 1 and 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences lists, among the possible aggravating circumstances to be taken into account at the sentencing stage, 'the continuation of unlawful conduct in the face of demands by authorised officials to cease'.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Article 35 §§ 1 and 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences lists, among the possible aggravating circumstances to be taken into account at the sentencing stage, 'the commission of a similar offence during the year following conviction for an administrative offence or the commission of an offence by an individual who had previously been convicted of a crime'.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Article 166 of the Code of Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time, defined disorderly conduct ('minor hooliganism') as 'swearing and cursing in a public place, causing harassment of a person by means of insults, or other similar actions that disturb public order and peace'.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Article 166 of the Code of Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time, provided that disorderly conduct ('minor hooliganism') was punishable by a fine and/or up to fifteen days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Article 173 of the Code of Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time, provided that 'disobeying a lawful instruction or order issued by a law-enforcement officer on duty or insulting the latter' was punishable by a fine of a minimum of 1,000 Georgian laris and a maximum of 4,000 Georgian laris, or up to fifteen days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENCES"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F016", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F008", "F009"], "interference": ["F027", "F028", "F085", "F086"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F131", "F085"], "legitimate_aim": ["F025", "F026", "F031", "F035", "F098", "F101"], "necessity": ["F012", "F013", "F016", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F008", "F009", "F080", "F081", "F082", "F089", "F085", "F086", "F110", "F121", "F122", "F128", "F102"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F016", "F024", "F025", "F026"], "interference": ["F027", "F085", "F086"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F131", "F085"], "legitimate_aim": ["F025", "F026", "F031"], "necessity": ["F012", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F008", "F009", "F081", "F086", "F110", "F128", "F121", "F122"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F012", "F025", "F026", "F024", "F086", "F081", "F110", "F128", "F122"]}} {"case_name": "case_219", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) is a political party in the Republic of Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) was represented in Parliament at the time of the events.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) was in opposition at the time of the events.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 3 December 2003, the applicant party applied to the Chișinău Municipal Council for an authorisation to hold a protest demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant party requested to hold the protest demonstration in the Square of the Great National Assembly, in front of the Government's building.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant party requested to hold the protest demonstration on 25 January 2004.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "According to the application, the organisers intended to express views on the functioning of the democratic institutions in Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "According to the application, the organisers intended to express views on the respect for human rights.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "According to the application, the organisers intended to express views on the Moldo-Russian conflict in Transdniestria.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 20 January 2004, the Chișinău Municipal Council rejected the applicant party's request to hold a protest demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Chișinău Municipal Council rejected the applicant party's request on the ground that it had convincing evidence that during the meeting there would be calls to a war of aggression, ethnic hatred and public violence.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant party challenged the Chișinău Municipal Council's refusal to authorise the demonstration in court.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant party argued, inter alia, that the reasons relied upon by the Chișinău Municipal Council for refusing the authorisation were entirely baseless.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 23 January 2004, the Chișinău Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant party's action challenging the Chișinău Municipal Council's refusal to authorise the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Chișinău Court of Appeal found that the Chișinău Municipal Council's refusal to authorise the Christian Democratic People's Party's demonstration was justified.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Chișinău Court of Appeal found that leaflets disseminated by the applicant party contained the slogan 'Down with Voronin's totalitarian regime'.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Chișinău Court of Appeal found that leaflets disseminated by the applicant party contained the slogan 'Down with Putin's occupation regime'.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the Chișinău Court of Appeal, the slogan 'Down with Voronin's totalitarian regime' constituted a call to a violent overthrow of the constitutional regime.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the Chișinău Court of Appeal, the slogan 'Down with Putin's occupation regime' constituted a call to hatred towards the Russian people.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Chișinău Court of Appeal recalled that during a previous demonstration organised by the applicant party, the protesters burned a picture of the President of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Chișinău Court of Appeal recalled that during a previous demonstration organised by the applicant party, the protesters burned a Russian flag.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The previous demonstration referred to by the Chișinău Court of Appeal was organised by the applicant party to protest against the presence of the Russian military in Transdniestria.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant party appealed against the Chișinău Court of Appeal's decision of 23 January 2004 dismissing its action.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant party argued, inter alia, that the slogans 'Down with Voronin's totalitarian regime' and 'Down with Putin's occupation regime' could not have reasonably been interpreted as a call to a violent overthrow of the Government.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant party argued, inter alia, that the slogans 'Down with Voronin's totalitarian regime' and 'Down with Putin's occupation regime' could not have reasonably been interpreted as a call to ethnic hatred.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant party argued that the refusal to authorise the meeting constituted a breach of its rights guaranteed by Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant party argued that the refusal to authorise the meeting constituted a breach of its rights guaranteed by Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 21 April 2004, the Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova dismissed the applicant party's appeal against the Chișinău Court of Appeal's decision.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova confirmed the judgment of the Chișinău Court of Appeal dated 23 January 2004.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Section 6(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be conducted peacefully, without any sort of weapons.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Section 6(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall ensure the protection of participants and the environment.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Section 6(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall not impede the normal use of public highways, road traffic and the operation of economic undertakings.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "Section 6(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall not degenerate into acts of violence capable of endangering the public order and the physical integrity and life of persons or their property.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "Section 7(a) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be suspended in circumstances involving denial and defamation of the State and of the people.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Section 7(b) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be suspended in circumstances involving incitement to war or aggression and incitement to hatred on ethnic, racial or religious grounds.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Section 7(c) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be suspended in circumstances involving incitement to discrimination, territorial separatism or public violence.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Section 7(d) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be suspended in circumstances involving acts that undermine the constitutional order.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Section 8(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies may be conducted in squares, streets, parks and other public places in cities, towns and villages, and also in public buildings.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Section 8(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it is forbidden to conduct an assembly in the buildings of the public authorities, the local authorities, prosecutors' offices, the courts or companies with armed security.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Section 8(3)(a) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it is forbidden to conduct assemblies within fifty metres of the parliament building, the residence of the president of Moldova, the seat of the government, the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "Section 8(3)(b) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it is forbidden to conduct assemblies within twenty-five metres of the buildings of the central administrative authority, the local public authorities, courts, prosecutors' offices, police stations, prisons and social rehabilitation institutions, military installations, railway stations, airports, hospitals, companies which use dangerous equipment and machines, and diplomatic institutions.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Section 8(4) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that free access to the premises of the institutions listed in Section 8(3) shall be guaranteed.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Section 8(5) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local public authorities may, if the organisers agree, establish places or buildings for permanent assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Section 11(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that not later than fifteen days prior to the date of the assembly, the organiser shall submit a notification to the Municipal Council.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the name of the organiser and the aim of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the date, starting time and finishing time of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the location of the assembly and the access and return routes.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the manner in which the assembly is to take place.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the approximate number of participants.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the persons who are to ensure and answer for the sound conduct of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the services which the organiser of the assembly asks the Municipal Council to provide.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Section 11(3) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that if the situation so requires, the Municipal Council may alter certain aspects of the prior notification with the agreement of the organiser of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Section 12(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall be examined by the local government of the town or village at the latest five days before the date of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Section 12(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that when the prior notification is considered at an ordinary or extraordinary meeting of the Municipal Council, the discussion shall deal with the form, timetable, location and other conditions for the conduct of the assembly, and the decision taken shall take account of the specific situation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Section 12(6) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local authorities can reject an application to hold an assembly only if, after having consulted the police, they have obtained convincing evidence that the provisions of Sections 6 and 7 of the Assemblies Act will be breached with serious consequences for society.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Section 14(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that a decision rejecting the application for holding an assembly shall be reasoned and presented in writing, and shall contain reasons for refusing to issue the authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Section 15(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the organiser of the assembly can challenge in the administrative courts the refusal of the local government.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["national_security", "prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F006", "F010", "F016", "F017", "F020", "F021"], "interference": ["F004", "F006", "F010"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F011", "F055", "F056"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002", "F003", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F011", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022"], "positive_obligation": ["F011"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F016", "F017", "F020", "F021"], "interference": ["F004", "F010"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F011", "F055"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F011", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022"], "positive_obligation": ["F011"]}, "list3": ["F002", "F003", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021"]}} {"case_name": "case_220", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant party, the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP), is a parliamentary political party in the Republic of Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) was in opposition at the time of the events described in the case.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Towards the end of 2001, the Moldovan government made public its intention to make the study of the Russian language compulsory in schools for children aged seven and over.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. The background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The Moldovan government's initiative to make Russian language study compulsory prompted vehement criticism from the opposition.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. The background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Moldovan government's initiative to make Russian language study compulsory generated a heated public debate.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. The background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 26 December 2001, the parliamentary group of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) informed Chișinău Municipal Council of its intention to hold a meeting with its supporters on 9 January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. The background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The meeting planned by the CDPP parliamentary group for 9 January 2002 was to be held in Great National Assembly Square, in front of the government buildings.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. The background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The CDPP parliamentary group stated that the meeting planned for 9 January 2002 would relate to the introduction of the compulsory study of Russian in schools.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. The background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The CDPP parliamentary group relied on section 22 of the Status of Members of Parliament Act of 7 April 1994, arguing that it did not require members of parliament to obtain prior authorisation for meetings with their supporters.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. The background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "By a decision of 3 January 2002, Chișinău Municipal Council classified the gathering to be held on 9 January 2002 as a 'demonstration' within the meaning of sections 4, 8, 12 and 13 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. The decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "By a decision of 3 January 2002, Chișinău Municipal Council authorised the parliamentary group of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) to hold the gathering on 9 January 2002 in National Opera Square rather than Great National Assembly Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. The decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Chișinău Municipal Council's decision of 3 January 2002 did not give any reasons for the change of location from Great National Assembly Square to National Opera Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. The decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 23 January 2002, Chișinău Municipal Council addressed a letter to the Ministry of Justice informing it that there was a discrepancy between the provisions of the Status of Members of Parliament Act and those of the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. The decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "In its letter of 23 January 2002, Chișinău Municipal Council informed the Ministry of Justice that it did not know which of the two Acts — the Status of Members of Parliament Act or the Assemblies Act — to apply.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. The decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "In its letter of 23 January 2002, Chișinău Municipal Council stated that a number of reputable lawyers supported the idea that CDPP members of parliament had the right to hold meetings with their supporters in Great National Assembly Square without obtaining prior authorisation, in accordance with sections 22 and 23 of the Status of Members of Parliament Act.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. The decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "In its letter of 23 January 2002, Chișinău Municipal Council cited the opinion of an ombudsman who considered that, since section 23 of the Status of Members of Parliament Act proclaimed the right of members of parliament to raise demands on the spot for action to remedy a breach of the law, the CDPP members of parliament were entitled to raise their demands for the cessation of the alleged breaches concerning the introduction of compulsory Russian lessons in front of the government building.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. The decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The ombudsman's opinion noted that the government building also housed the Ministry of Education, which was relevant to the CDPP members of parliament's right to raise demands there.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. The decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In its letter of 23 January 2002, Chișinău Municipal Council requested the Ministry of Justice to ask Parliament for an official interpretation of the legislation in question.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. The decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 26 January 2002, Chișinău Municipal Council issued a decision noting that the provisions of domestic legislation were contradictory in respect of the demonstrations organised by the CDPP and that the opinions of legal experts were contradictory.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. The decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "In its decision of 26 January 2002, Chișinău Municipal Council stated that it had formally requested the Ministry of Justice to ask Parliament for an official and urgent interpretation of the relevant legislation.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. The decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "In its decision of 26 January 2002, Chișinău Municipal Council suspended its decision of 3 January 2002 until Parliament had given its official interpretation of the relevant legislation.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. The decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 9 January 2002, the parliamentary group of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) held a gathering in Great National Assembly Square, in front of government headquarters.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. The gatherings held by the CDPP members of parliament"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The parliamentary group of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) also held gatherings on 11, 13, 15, 16 and 17 January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. The gatherings held by the CDPP members of parliament"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) informed Chișinău Municipal Council in advance of each gathering held in January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. The gatherings held by the CDPP members of parliament"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) did not seek authorisation in accordance with the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 for the gatherings held in January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. The gatherings held by the CDPP members of parliament"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 14 January 2002, the Ministry of Justice issued an official warning to the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) in accordance with section 27 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act of 17 September 1991.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "In its warning of 14 January 2002, the Ministry of Justice stated that the CDPP had breached the provisions of section 6 of the Assemblies Act by organising demonstrations in Great National Assembly Square on 9, 10, 11 and 13 January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "In its warning of 14 January 2002, the Ministry of Justice stated that the CDPP had organised demonstrations in Great National Assembly Square notwithstanding that the authorisation issued by Chișinău Municipal Council only gave permission for a demonstration on 9 January 2002 in National Opera Square.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "In its warning of 14 January 2002, the Ministry of Justice called for an immediate halt to the gatherings, which it considered to be illegal and unconstitutional.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "In its warning of 14 January 2002, the Ministry of Justice claimed that the gatherings were not meetings with voters within the meaning of the Status of Members of Parliament Act, but demonstrations falling under the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "In its warning of 14 January 2002, the Ministry of Justice asked the CDPP for a written explanation within three days.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "In its warning of 14 January 2002, the Ministry of Justice warned the CDPP that if it failed to comply with the warning, the Ministry would impose a temporary ban (suspendarea activităţii) on the party's activities in accordance with section 29 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 17 January 2002, the President of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) wrote a letter to the Ministry of Justice stating that the gatherings had not been organised by the CDPP but by members of its parliamentary group, and that it was therefore the members concerned who were liable, and not the party.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "In his letter of 17 January 2002, the President of the CDPP relied on section 22 of the Status of Members of Parliament Act, arguing that it was a very specific Act applicable to meetings between members of parliament and voters, while the Assemblies Act was general in nature.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "In his letter of 17 January 2002, the President of the CDPP submitted that the threatened ban on the party's activities would amount to a political measure taken by the Communist Party in order to repress the opposition.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 18 January 2002, the Ministry of Justice issued a decision imposing a one-month ban on the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s activities, in accordance with section 29 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act of 17 September 1991.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The one-month ban on the CDPP's activities imposed on 18 January 2002 was based on the organisation by the CDPP of unauthorised demonstrations on 9, 10, 11, 13, 15, 16 and 17 January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Ministry of Justice dismissed the CDPP leader's argument that the party could not be held liable for the gatherings organised by its parliamentary group.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "In its decision of 18 January 2002, the Ministry of Justice stated that the gatherings organised by the CDPP on 9, 10, 11, 13, 15, 16 and 17 January 2002 had in fact been demonstrations and marches and therefore fell within the scope of the Assemblies Act rather than the Status of Members of Parliament Act.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the Ministry of Justice's decision of 18 January 2002, the CDPP had breached the provisions of sections 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 11 of the Assemblies Act by not obtaining prior authorisation from Chișinău Municipal Council to stage demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the Ministry of Justice's decision of 18 January 2002, the CDPP had breached the provisions of sections 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 11 of the Assemblies Act by blocking the public highway.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to the Ministry of Justice's decision of 18 January 2002, the participation of minors in the CDPP demonstrations had been in breach of Article 15 of the International Convention on the Rights of the Child of 20 November 1989.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the Ministry of Justice's decision of 18 January 2002, the participation of minors in the CDPP demonstrations had been in breach of section 13(3) of the Protection of Children Act of 15 December 1994.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the Ministry of Justice's decision of 18 January 2002, the participation of minors in the CDPP demonstrations had been in breach of section 56(g) of the Education Act of 21 July 1995.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the Ministry of Justice's decision of 18 January 2002, the CDPP's actions disclosed a violation of sections 27 and 29 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act of 17 September 1991.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to the Ministry of Justice's decision of 18 January 2002, the CDPP's actions disclosed a violation of section 15(1) and (2) of the Status of Members of Parliament Act of 7 April 1994.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to the Ministry of Justice's decision of 18 January 2002, the CDPP's actions disclosed a violation of Article 32 of the Constitution of the Republic of Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "According to the Ministry of Justice's decision of 18 January 2002, the use of the slogan 'I'd rather be dead than a communist' (Mai bine mort decât comunist) could be interpreted as a call to public violence and an act undermining the legal and constitutional order.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 24 January 2002, the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) challenged the Ministry of Justice's decision of 18 January 2002 imposing a one-month ban on its activities.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In its challenge of 24 January 2002, the CDPP argued, inter alia, that the gatherings had been meetings with voters within the meaning of the Status of Members of Parliament Act, and not assemblies falling within the scope of the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 8 February 2002, the Ministry of Justice issued a decision lifting the temporary ban imposed on the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s activities.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In its decision of 8 February 2002, the Ministry of Justice stressed that the CDPP had breached all the laws mentioned in the decision of 18 January 2002 and that the temporary ban had been necessary and justified.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Ministry of Justice lifted the temporary ban on the CDPP's activities following an inquiry by the Secretary General of the Council of Europe under Article 52 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Ministry of Justice lifted the temporary ban on the CDPP's activities having regard to the forthcoming local elections.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Ministry of Justice's decision of 8 February 2002 lifting the temporary ban did not set aside the decision of 18 January 2002 imposing the ban.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 7 March 2002, the Court of Appeal of the Republic of Moldova found in favour of the Ministry of Justice and ruled that the Ministry of Justice's decision of 18 January 2002 imposing a one-month ban on the CDPP's activities had been lawful.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 7 March 2002, the Court of Appeal dismissed the CDPP's argument that the party could not be held liable for the actions of its members, namely its parliamentary group.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 7 March 2002, the Court of Appeal found that the gatherings organised by the CDPP had in fact been demonstrations, meetings and marches which fell under the provisions of the Assemblies Act, and not meetings with voters.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 7 March 2002, the Court of Appeal found that even assuming the gatherings had been intended as meetings with voters, they had gradually taken on the nature of demonstrations and, accordingly, the CDPP needed authorisation in order to organise them.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 7 March 2002, the Court of Appeal stated that as a result of the CDPP demonstrations, the public transport company had suffered losses of 12,133 Moldovan lei (MDL), equivalent to approximately 1,050 euros (EUR) at the time.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 7 March 2002, the Court of Appeal found that the participation of minors in the CDPP demonstrations had been in breach of the International Convention on the Rights of the Child of 20 November 1989, the Protection of Children Act of 15 December 1994 and the Education Act of 21 July 1995.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) lodged an appeal against the Court of Appeal's decision of 7 March 2002 with the Supreme Court of Justice of the Republic of Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In its appeal to the Supreme Court of Justice, the CDPP relied, inter alia, on Articles 10 and 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 17 May 2002, a panel of the Supreme Court of Justice of the Republic of Moldova delivered its judgment dismissing the appeal lodged by the CDPP against the Court of Appeal's decision of 7 March 2002.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "In its judgment of 17 May 2002, the Supreme Court of Justice endorsed the arguments of the Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "In its judgment of 17 May 2002, the Supreme Court of Justice found that since the demonstrations organised by the CDPP had been illegal, the sanction imposed on it had not been disproportionate.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "In its judgment of 17 May 2002, the Supreme Court of Justice stated that in any event the Ministry of Justice's decision of 18 January 2002 had not had any negative effects on the CDPP since it had not been enforced, the CDPP's accounts had not been frozen and the party could continue its activities unhindered.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. The proceedings challenging the ban on the party's activities, and the lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Ministry of Justice did not reply to Chișinău Municipal Council's request of 23 January 2002 for interpretation of the law.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. The proceedings by the government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Ministry of Justice did not address any request to Parliament for an official interpretation of the legislation, as requested by Chișinău Municipal Council on 23 January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. The proceedings by the government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 21 February 2002, the government of the Republic of Moldova lodged an application with the Supreme Court of Justice asking it, inter alia, to declare the demonstrations organised by the CDPP illegal and to order their cessation.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. The proceedings by the government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 25 February 2002, the Supreme Court of Justice ruled in favour of the government and declared the CDPP gatherings illegal.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. The proceedings by the government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "In its ruling of 25 February 2002, the Supreme Court of Justice stated that even if the CDPP had the initial intention of holding meetings with its supporters, those meetings later took on the character of demonstrations, marches, processions and picketing, which fall under the provisions of the Assemblies Act, and that the leaders of the CDPP were therefore required to comply with the provisions of the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. The proceedings by the government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) appealed against the Supreme Court of Justice's ruling of 25 February 2002.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. The proceedings by the government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 15 March 2002, the Supreme Court of Justice dismissed the CDPP's appeal against the ruling of 25 February 2002.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. The proceedings by the government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice's judgment of 25 February 2002 declaring the CDPP gatherings illegal became final on 15 March 2002.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. The proceedings by the government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "In the course of the present proceedings before the Court, the Government submitted a video with images of gatherings held by CDPP deputies on 15, 16, 17 and 18 January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. The video submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The gatherings shown in the video submitted by the Government were held in Great National Assembly Square, in a pedestrian area, in front of the government buildings.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. The video submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The participants in the gatherings shown in the video appeared to number several hundred and included people of different ages varying from schoolchildren to pensioners.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. The video submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "According to the time displayed on the video images, the gatherings commenced at around 1 p.m. and lasted for about two hours.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. The video submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "During the gatherings shown in the video, different personalities made speeches critical of the ruling Communist Party, the government and its policy.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. The video submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "It appears from the video submitted by the Government that traffic was not disrupted as a result of the gatherings held on 15, 16, 17 and 18 January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. The video submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "No signs of violence can be seen in the video submitted by the Government of the gatherings held on 15, 16, 17 and 18 January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. The video submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "'The Layabout's Anthem' (Imnul Golanilor — a song that originated in the 1990 Bucharest student demonstrations) was played frequently at the gatherings shown in the video.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. The video submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The chorus of 'The Layabout's Anthem' (Imnul Golanilor) included the following lines: 'I'd rather be a slacker than a traitor (Mai bine haimana, decât trădător) / I'd rather be a hooligan than a dictator (Mai bine huligan, decât dictator) / I'd rather be a layabout than an activist (Mai bine golan, decât activist) / I'd rather be dead than a communist (Mai bine mort, decât comunist).'", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. The video submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Article 32(3) of the Constitution of the Republic of Moldova provides that denial and defamation of the State and of the people, incitement to war of aggression, incitement to hatred on ethnic, racial or religious grounds, incitement to discrimination, territorial separatism or public violence, as well as other acts undermining the constitutional order shall be forbidden and shall be punishable under the law.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Section 15(1) of the Status of Members of Parliament Act of 7 April 1994 provides that members of parliament shall be obliged strictly to observe the Constitution, the laws and the rules of morality and ethics.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Section 15(2) of the Status of Members of Parliament Act of 7 April 1994 provides that members of parliament shall have a duty to be dependable and to contribute by their own example to the consolidation of State discipline, the fulfilment of civil obligations, the protection of human rights and the observance of the law.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Section 15(3) of the Status of Members of Parliament Act of 7 April 1994 provides that alleged breaches of the rules of ethics by members of parliament shall be examined by the Parliamentary Commission on Legal Affairs, Appointments and Immunity.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Section 22(3) of the Status of Members of Parliament Act of 7 April 1994 (as originally enacted) provides that local authorities shall provide members of parliament with all necessary assistance for the organisation of their work with voters and shall place premises at their disposal for meetings with voters.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 26 July 2002, section 22(3) of the Status of Members of Parliament Act of 7 April 1994 was amended to provide that local authorities shall provide members of parliament with the necessary assistance for the organisation of their work with voters, shall ensure access to buildings or other public places, provide equipment and any necessary information, and inform voters in good time about the place and time of meetings with members of parliament.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "On 26 July 2002, a new section 22(1) was introduced into the Status of Members of Parliament Act of 7 April 1994, providing that members of parliament shall have the right to organise demonstrations, meetings, processions and other peaceful gatherings in accordance with the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Section 23(1) of the Status of Members of Parliament Act of 7 April 1994 provides that members of parliament, in their capacity as representatives of the supreme legislative power, shall have the right to raise demands on the spot for action to remedy a breach of the law.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Section 5 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies may be conducted only after the organisers have notified the local council.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Section 6(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be conducted peacefully, without any sort of weapons, and shall ensure the protection of participants and the environment, without impeding the normal use of public highways, road traffic and the operation of economic undertakings and without degenerating into acts of violence capable of endangering the public order and the physical integrity and life of persons or their property.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "On 26 July 2002, a new section 6(2) was added to the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995, providing that teachers or other school staff members shall not involve students in unauthorised assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Section 7 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be suspended in circumstances including: denial and defamation of the State and of the people; incitement to war of aggression and incitement to hatred on ethnic, racial or religious grounds; incitement to discrimination, territorial separatism or public violence; and acts that undermine the constitutional order.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Section 8(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies may be conducted in squares, streets, parks and other public places in cities, towns and villages, and also in public buildings.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Section 8(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct an assembly in the buildings of the public authorities, the local authorities, prosecutors' offices, the courts or companies with armed security.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Section 8(3)(a) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct assemblies within fifty metres of the parliament building, the residence of the President of Moldova, the seat of the government, the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "Section 8(3)(b) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct assemblies within twenty-five metres of the buildings of the central administrative authority, the local public authorities, courts, prosecutors' offices, police stations, prisons and social rehabilitation institutions, military installations, railway stations, airports, hospitals, companies which use dangerous equipment and machines, and diplomatic institutions.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Section 8(4) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that free access to the premises of the institutions listed in section 8(3) shall be guaranteed.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "Section 8(5) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local public authorities may, if the organisers agree, establish places or buildings for permanent assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "Section 9 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the date and time of the assembly shall be agreed by the organiser and the local council of the city, town or village.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "Section 11(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that not later than fifteen days prior to the date of the assembly, the organiser shall submit a notification to the Municipal Council.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate: the name of the organiser and the aim of the assembly; the date, starting time and finishing time; the location and the access and return routes; the manner in which the assembly is to take place; the approximate number of participants; the persons who are to ensure and answer for the sound conduct of the assembly; and the services the organiser asks the Municipal Council to provide.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Section 11(3) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that if the situation so requires, the Municipal Council may alter certain aspects of the prior notification with the agreement of the organiser of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Section 12(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that when the prior notification is considered at an ordinary or extraordinary meeting of the Municipal Council, the discussion shall deal with the form, timetable, location and other conditions for the conduct of the assembly and the decision taken shall take account of the specific situation.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Section 27 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act of 17 September 1991 provides that in the event that breaches of the statute or of the law are discovered in the activities of a party or a socio-political organisation, the Ministry of Justice shall warn its leaders in writing, requesting that the breaches be remedied within a fixed time-limit.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Section 29 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act of 17 September 1991 (as originally enacted) provides that the Ministry of Justice shall impose a temporary ban on the activities of a party or socio-political organisation which breaches the provisions of the Constitution or those of the Act, or does not comply with a warning.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "On 21 November 2003, section 29 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act of 17 September 1991 was amended to provide that the Ministry of Justice shall impose a temporary ban on the activities of a party or socio-political organisation which breaches the provisions of the Constitution, and shall inform the party's leadership in writing of the breaches and set a time-limit for remedying them.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The amended section 29 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act (as amended on 21 November 2003) provides that during electoral campaigns the activities of parties and other socio-political organisations may be suspended only by the Supreme Court of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The amended section 29 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act (as amended on 21 November 2003) provides that during the temporary ban, it shall be forbidden for the party to use the mass media, to disseminate propaganda and publicity, to carry out bank transactions or other operations in respect of its assets and to participate in elections.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The amended section 29 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act (as amended on 21 November 2003) provides that once all the breaches of the law have been remedied, the party shall inform the Ministry of Justice, which shall lift the temporary ban within five days.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The amended section 29 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act (as amended on 21 November 2003) provides that the activities of the party or other socio-political organisation may be suspended for a period of up to six months, and if the breaches of the law are not remedied, for a period of one year.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Article 15(1) of the International Convention on the Rights of the Child of 20 November 1989 provides that States Parties recognise the rights of the child to freedom of association and to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Article 15(2) of the International Convention on the Rights of the Child of 20 November 1989 provides that no restrictions may be placed on the exercise of children's rights to freedom of association and peaceful assembly other than those imposed in conformity with the law and which are necessary in a democratic society in the interests of national security or public safety, public order (ordre public), the protection of public health or morals or the protection of the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Section 13(1) of the Protection of Children Act of 15 December 1994 provides that children shall have the right to membership of non-governmental organisations in accordance with the law.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Section 13(2) of the Protection of Children Act of 15 December 1994 provides that the State must provide children's non-governmental organisations with financial support, place premises at their disposal and provide them with fiscal incentives.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Section 13(3) of the Protection of Children Act of 15 December 1994 provides that the involvement of children in politics and their membership of political parties shall be forbidden.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Section 56(g) of the Education Act of 21 July 1995 provides that it shall be the duty of teachers not to involve children in street actions (meetings, demonstrations, picketing, etc.).", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Article 174(1)(2) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 29 March 1985 provides that the organisation and holding of an assembly without prior notification to the Municipal Council or without authorisation from the Council, or in breach of the conditions concerning the conduct of meetings indicated in the authorisation, shall be punishable by a fine imposed on the organisers (leaders) of the assembly in an amount equal to between ten and twenty-five times the minimum monthly wage.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Article 174(1)(4) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 29 March 1985 provides that active participation in an assembly organised without prior notification or authorisation shall be punishable by a fine of between 180 and 450 Moldovan lei (MDL).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "On 26 July 2002, a new provision (Article 174(1)(7)) was added to the Code of Administrative Offences of 29 March 1985, providing that the involvement of children in unauthorised assemblies shall be punishable by a fine of between 180 and 360 Moldovan lei (MDL).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F074", "F075", "F076", "F082", "F080", "F083", "F084"], "interference": ["F036"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F026", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F031", "F036", "F037", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F048"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002", "F003", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F013", "F014", "F019", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F036", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F048", "F054", "F061", "F077", "F078", "F080", "F082", "F083", "F084", "F122"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F074", "F076", "F082"], "interference": ["F036"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F026", "F027", "F036", "F048"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002", "F003", "F005", "F013", "F019", "F021", "F036", "F048", "F054", "F077", "F078", "F082", "F083", "F084", "F122"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F001", "F002", "F003", "F005", "F013", "F019", "F021", "F036", "F054", "F077", "F078", "F082", "F083", "F084", "F122"]}} {"case_name": "case_222", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1927.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant claimed that until 1974 she had been permanently residing in a house she owned at 33, 28th October Street, Kyrenia, northern Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant owned a garden at Kazafani, in the District of Kyrenia.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant owned three fields with trees at Karmi, in the locality known as 'Horteri Chomatovounos', in the District of Kyrenia.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "According to the applicant, her house at 33, 28th October Street, Kyrenia had a surface-area of 190 square metres.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "According to the applicant, her house at 33, 28th October Street, Kyrenia contained three large drawing rooms.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "According to the applicant, her house at 33, 28th October Street, Kyrenia contained a spacious dining room and kitchen.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "According to the applicant, her house at 33, 28th October Street, Kyrenia contained four bedrooms.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the applicant, her house at 33, 28th October Street, Kyrenia contained two bathrooms.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "According to the applicant, her house at 33, 28th October Street, Kyrenia contained a storeroom and verandas.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "According to the applicant, her house at 33, 28th October Street, Kyrenia was surrounded by a 753 square metre garden.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "According to the applicant, her house at 33, 28th October Street, Kyrenia was furnished mainly with period antiques and luxury items.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "In support of her claim to ownership, the applicant produced copies of certificates of ownership of Turkish-occupied immovable properties issued by the Republic of Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the certificates of ownership produced by the applicant, one of her properties was registered as: Kyrenia/Pano Kyrenia, plot no. 45, sheet/plan 12/21.1.12, registration no. C1703, house with garden.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the certificates of ownership produced by the applicant, one of her properties was registered as: Kyrenia/Kazafani, plot no. 95/1/1, sheet/plan 12/22W2, garden/orchard; area: 2,351 square metres.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the certificates of ownership produced by the applicant, one of her properties was registered as: Kyrenia/Karmi, plot no. 222, sheet/plan 12/27E2, field; area: 3,138 square metres.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the certificates of ownership produced by the applicant, one of her properties was registered as: Kyrenia/Karmi, plot no. 282, sheet/plan 12/27E2, field; area: 1,650 square metres.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the certificates of ownership produced by the applicant, one of her properties was registered as: Kyrenia/Karmi, plot no. 291/1, sheet/plan 12/27E2, field; area: 2,264 square metres.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Since the 1974 Turkish intervention, the applicant has been deprived of her properties located in the area under the occupation and control of the Turkish military authorities.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Turkish military authorities prevented the applicant from having access to and using her properties in the area under their occupation and control.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOUSE AND PROPERTIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 19 July 1989, the applicant joined an anti-Turkish demonstration in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicants in the Chrysostomos and Papachrysostomou v. Turkey cases also took part in the anti-Turkish demonstration in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant in the Loizidou v. Turkey case also took part in the anti-Turkish demonstration in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant at Nicosia District Court on 10 April 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant at Nicosia District Court on 10 April 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was held on the fifteenth anniversary of the Turkish intervention in Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant at Nicosia District Court on 10 April 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was held in support of the missing persons and to protest against human-rights violations.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant at Nicosia District Court on 10 April 2000, the applicant and other women had planned to gather in the grounds of the Ayios Kassianos School and to stage a sit-in in protest against the occupation of the northern part of Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant at Nicosia District Court on 10 April 2000, the applicant and other women asked the Bishop of Kitium to conduct a service in the St. George's Chapel, which was located near the Ayios Kassianos School.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "When the applicant arrived at the Ayios Kassianos School grounds, the grounds were filled with a group of mostly young women who were singing.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant stood near a water tank at the Ayios Kassianos School grounds.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant noticed the presence of UN soldiers at the Ayios Kassianos School grounds.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant noticed the presence of Turkish policemen armed with batons at the Ayios Kassianos School grounds.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The UN officers invited the demonstrators at the Ayios Kassianos School grounds to leave the premises.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Within a matter of seconds of the UN officers' invitation to leave, Turkish policemen rushed towards the demonstrators at the Ayios Kassianos School grounds.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Some of the women demonstrators at the Ayios Kassianos School grounds were grabbed by their clothes and hit with guns and batons by Turkish policemen.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant was hit and pushed by Turkish policemen at the Ayios Kassianos School grounds.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant received what she described as a 'terrible blow in the right leg beneath the tibia'.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicant stated that she had been hit with a sharp object, namely a bayonet wielded by a Turkish soldier.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicant's leg started to bleed profusely after she was struck.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicant felt herself drifting into unconsciousness after being struck.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicant shouted: 'Help, help, please, I am losing my leg'.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Some demonstrators put the applicant on a stretcher after she was struck.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant was taken by ambulance to Nicosia General Hospital after being struck at the Ayios Kassianos School grounds.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "At Nicosia General Hospital, the applicant's wound was stitched internally and externally.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicant was told to take ten days' absolute rest following treatment at Nicosia General Hospital.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "For the six months following the demonstration of 19 July 1989, the applicant suffered considerable pain in her leg.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "Following the demonstration of 19 July 1989, the applicant could not walk or put weight on her leg and was forced to use crutches.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicant experienced pain in her leg with changes in the weather following the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The applicant continued to have problems climbing stairs following the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The scar on the applicant's leg from the injury sustained on 19 July 1989 remained visible.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Three witnesses who saw the wound being inflicted on the applicant on 19 July 1989 — two friends and the editor of a local newspaper — had already died by the time of the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "An affidavit sworn by a witness, Mrs Olga Nicolaidou, corroborated the applicant's version of events regarding the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In support of her claim of ill-treatment, the applicant produced a medical certificate issued on 27 March 2000 by Doctor Stelios Georgiou, a specialist orthopaedic surgeon practising in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 27 March 2000 by Doctor Stelios Georgiou stated that the applicant was injured on 19 July 1989 by Turks following an attack on women near Ayios Kassianos in Nicosia at the Ayios Kassianos Primary School.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 27 March 2000 by Doctor Stelios Georgiou recorded that the applicant sustained an injury to the right lower limb of the upper third of the tibia with an open wound about 9 centimetres long.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 27 March 2000 by Doctor Stelios Georgiou stated that the applicant's wound was caused with a sharp object.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 27 March 2000 by Doctor Stelios Georgiou recorded that treatment of the applicant included surgical cleaning of the wound.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 27 March 2000 by Doctor Stelios Georgiou recorded that treatment of the applicant included stitching up of the wound.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 27 March 2000 by Doctor Stelios Georgiou recorded that treatment of the applicant included pharmaceutical treatment.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 27 March 2000 by Doctor Stelios Georgiou recorded that treatment of the applicant included regular dressing of the wound.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 27 March 2000 by Doctor Stelios Georgiou recorded that treatment of the applicant included complete rest in bed for ten days with the leg supported by pillows.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 27 March 2000 by Doctor Stelios Georgiou recorded that the stitches were removed ten days after the applicant's treatment.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 27 March 2000 by Doctor Stelios Georgiou recorded that the applicant was required to walk with crutches for one month.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 27 March 2000 by Doctor Stelios Georgiou recorded that the applicant's present condition included an evident ugly scar of about 9 centimetres in the upper third of the tibia, transversal.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 27 March 2000 by Doctor Stelios Georgiou recorded that the applicant's present condition included loss of feeling in the area of the wound.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant had participated in a violent demonstration with the aim of inflaming anti-Turkish sentiment.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators were supported by the Greek-Cypriot administration and were demanding that the 'Green Line' in Nicosia should be dismantled.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Government alleged that some demonstrators carried Greek flags, clubs, knives and wire-cutters.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators were acting in a provocative manner and shouting abuse.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators were warned in Greek and English that unless they dispersed they would be arrested in accordance with the laws of the 'Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus' ('TRNC').", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was arrested by the Turkish-Cypriot police after crossing the UN buffer zone and entering the area under Turkish-Cypriot control.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Government alleged that the Turkish-Cypriot police intervened in the face of the manifest inability of the Greek-Cypriot authorities and the UN Force in Cyprus to contain the incursion and its possible consequences.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Government alleged that no force was used against demonstrators who did not intrude into the 'TRNC' border area.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Government alleged that in the case of demonstrators who were arrested for violating the border, no more force was used than was reasonably necessary in the circumstances in order to arrest and detain the persons concerned.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Government alleged that no one was ill-treated during the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Government alleged that it was possible that some of the demonstrators had hurt themselves in the confusion or in attempting to scale barbed wire or other fencing.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Government alleged that had the Turkish police, or anyone else, assaulted or beaten any of the demonstrators, the UN Secretary General would no doubt have referred to this in his report to the Security Council.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989 on UN operations in Cyprus, the UN Secretary General stated that a serious situation arose in July 1989 as a result of a demonstration by Greek Cypriots in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 stated that in the evening of 19 July 1989, some 1,000 Greek Cypriot demonstrators, mostly women, forced their way into the UN buffer zone in the Ayios Kassianos area of Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 stated that the demonstrators broke through a wire barrier maintained by the UN Force in Cyprus (UNFICYP) and destroyed a UNFICYP observation post.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 stated that the demonstrators broke through the line formed by UNFICYP soldiers and entered a former school complex where UNFICYP reinforcements regrouped to prevent them from proceeding further.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 stated that Turkish-Cypriot police and security forces elements forced their way into the Ayios Kassianos area and apprehended 111 persons, 101 of them women.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 stated that the Ayios Kassianos school complex is situated in the UN buffer zone, but that the Turkish forces claim it to be on their side of the cease-fire line.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 stated that under working arrangements with UNFICYP, the Turkish-Cypriot security forces had patrolled the Ayios Kassianos school grounds for several years within specific restrictions, and that this patrolling had ceased altogether as part of an unmanning agreement implemented in May 1989.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 stated that in the afternoon of 21 July 1989, some 300 Greek Cypriots gathered at the main entrance to the UN protected area in Nicosia to protest the continuing detention by the Turkish-Cypriot authorities of those apprehended at Ayios Kassianos.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 stated that the number of demonstrators at the main entrance to the UN protected area in Nicosia fluctuated between 200 and 2,000 and that they blocked all UN traffic through that entrance until 30 July 1989, when the Turkish-Cypriot authorities released the last two detainees.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 stated that the events of 19 July 1989 created considerable tension in Cyprus and that intensive efforts were made, both at UN headquarters and at Nicosia, to contain and resolve the situation.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 stated that on 21 July 1989, the UN Secretary General expressed his concern at the events that had taken place and stressed that it was vital that all parties keep in mind the purpose of the UN buffer zone as well as their responsibility to ensure that that area was not violated.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 stated that on 21 July 1989, the UN Secretary General urged the Turkish-Cypriot authorities to release without delay all those who had been detained.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 stated that on 24 July 1989, the President of the Security Council announced that he had conveyed to the representatives of all the parties, on behalf of the members of the Council, the Council's deep concern at the tense situation created by the incidents of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 stated that the President of the Security Council stressed the need strictly to respect the UN buffer zone and appealed for the immediate release of all persons still detained, and asked all concerned to show maximum restraint and to take urgent steps to bring about a relaxation of tension.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code defines an unlawful assembly as occurring where five or more persons assemble with intent to commit an offence, or, being assembled with intent to carry out some common purpose, conduct themselves in such a manner as to cause persons in the neighbourhood to fear that the persons so assembled will commit a breach of the peace or will by such assembly needlessly and without any reasonable occasion provoke other persons to commit a breach of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that it is immaterial that the original assembly was lawful if, being assembled, the persons conduct themselves with a common purpose in such a manner as to cause persons in the neighbourhood to fear a breach of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that when an unlawful assembly has begun to execute its purpose by a breach of the peace and to the terror of the public, the assembly is called a riot and the persons assembled are said to be riotously assembled.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "According to section 71 of the Cypriot Criminal Code, any person who takes part in an unlawful assembly is guilty of a misdemeanour and liable to imprisonment for one year.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Section 80 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that any person who carries in public without lawful occasion any offensive arm or weapon in such a manner as to cause terror to any person is guilty of a misdemeanour and is liable to imprisonment for two years, and his arms or weapons shall be forfeited.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "According to section 82 of the Cypriot Criminal Code, it is an offence to carry a knife outside the home.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Chapter 155, section 14(1)(b) of the Cypriot Criminal Procedure Law states that any police officer may, without warrant, arrest any person who commits in his presence any offence punishable with imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Police officers' powers of arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "Chapter 155, section 14(1)(c) of the Cypriot Criminal Procedure Law states that any police officer may, without warrant, arrest any person who obstructs a police officer while in the execution of his duty.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Police officers' powers of arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Section 9 of Law No. 5/72 states that any person who enters a prohibited military area without authorization, or by stealth, or fraudulently, shall be tried by a military court in accordance with the Military Offences Act, and those found guilty shall be punished.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "Subsection 12(1) of the Aliens and Immigration Law states that no person shall enter or leave the Colony except through an approved port.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "Subsection 12(5) of the Aliens and Immigration Law states that any person who contravenes or fails to observe any of the provisions of subsections (1), (2), (3) or (4) of section 12 shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months or to a fine not exceeding one hundred pounds or to both such imprisonment and fine.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": false, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["national_security", "public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F022", "F030", "F033", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F080", "F081", "F082"], "interference": ["F022", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F083"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F093", "F094", "F095", "F096", "F099", "F100", "F101", "F102", "F103"], "legitimate_aim": ["F080", "F081", "F082", "F083"], "necessity": ["F080", "F081", "F082", "F083", "F084", "F101", "F102", "F103"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F022", "F080", "F081", "F082"], "interference": ["F022", "F035", "F083"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F093", "F096", "F099"], "legitimate_aim": ["F080", "F081"], "necessity": ["F080", "F081", "F082", "F084"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F022", "F080", "F081", "F082", "F083", "F084", "F093", "F096", "F099"]}} {"case_name": "case_223", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1968.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Stryzhavka.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 12 September 2006 the applicant submitted a written notice to the mayor of Vinnytsia informing him that the Chumatskyy Shlyakh civic youth association intended to hold a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "According to the Government, the officially registered chairman of the Chumatskyy Shlyakh civic youth association at the material time was a certain Igor Viktorovyh Chumak.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant was not the chairman of the Chumatskyy Shlyakh civic youth association at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant could not even be a member of the Chumatskyy Shlyakh civic youth association because, according to the Association's charter, membership was open only to persons under the age of twenty-eight.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "According to the Government, at the time of the relevant events the applicant was older than twenty-eight years of age and therefore ineligible for membership of the Chumatskyy Shlyakh civic youth association.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 13 September 2006 the mayor's office of Vinnytsia forwarded the applicant's notice of the demonstration to the police.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 13 September 2006 the mayor's office of Vinnytsia requested that the police maintain public order during the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 14 September 2006 the Chumatskyy Shlyakh civic youth association started the picket as intended.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "According to the applicant, several other local groups joined the picket action on 14 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "According to the applicant, two small camping tents measuring 2 by 2 metres were erected by the walls of the regional authority building on a 15-metre wide street.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "According to the applicant, the two small camping tents were erected for the purpose of storing handout materials and displaying the protesters' slogans.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 15 September 2006 the executive committee of Vinnytsia City Council instituted administrative proceedings seeking to restrict or prohibit the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 15 September 2006 the Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia received the administrative claim lodged by the executive committee of Vinnytsia City Council.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Later on 15 September 2006 the Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia allowed the claim of the executive committee of Vinnytsia City Council.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia decided that the case file contained sufficient evidence that the protesters had behaved inappropriately.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia found that the executive committee of Vinnytsia City Council did not and could not have known about a possible breach of public order by the participants of the event, which resulted in missing the time-limit for lodging a court action as required by paragraph 1 of Article 182 of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia reset the procedural time-limit for lodging the administrative action.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia found that the participants in the event installed small architectural edifices on the pavement.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia found that during the event the participants acted arrogantly, thus offending other citizens.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia found that the participants obstructed the passage of pedestrians along Soborna street.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia found that the participants endangered road users.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia found that the alleged breaches of public order were confirmed by complaints from individuals identified as Y.S. and V.Ch.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia noted that in the notice of the event it was stated that the event would be held indefinitely.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia noted that the number of protesters was not defined in the notice and could gradually increase.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia found that at any time during the picket of indeterminate length it could not be excluded that those taking part might repeatedly breach public order.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia noted that the picket may potentially encroach upon the rights and freedoms of other local residents.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia held to prohibit the Chumatskyy Shlyakh civic youth association and other persons taking part in the action from organising and carrying out peaceful assemblies in the streets and squares of Vinnytsia.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia held to prohibit the Chumatskyy Shlyakh civic youth association and other persons taking part in the action from installing small architectural edifices in Vinnytsia.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia ordered the Chumatskyy Shlyakh civic youth association and other persons taking part in the action to dismantle the small architectural edifices installed in the square in front of the regional administration building.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia allowed immediate enforcement of its court ruling of 15 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "At 9 p.m. on 15 September 2006 the protesters were dispersed by the police.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 29 September 2006 the local registry office informed the applicant that V.Ch. and Y.S. were not registered as residents at the addresses indicated by them in their complaints lodged with the police.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 8 October 2006 the applicant lodged an appeal against the judgment of the Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia of 15 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicant signed the appeal against the judgment of 15 September 2006 as the Chumatskyy Shlyakh civic youth association's chairman.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant submitted that under Article 182 of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine, a plaintiff's action could not be examined when it had been lodged out of time.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant submitted that the Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia's factual conclusions had been devoid of an evidentiary basis.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant submitted that there was no evidence that the protesters had breached the law, apart from the complaints by V.Ch. and Y.S., who had given false home addresses and thus could not be identified.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant complained that the Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia had rejected his request that V.Ch. and Y.S. be located and summoned.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant complained that the Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia had rejected his request that police officers present at the site of the picket be summoned for questioning concerning the alleged breaches of the law by the protesters.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant complained that the Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia had refused his request that relevant police reports documenting the purported breaches of the law be produced.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant complained that the Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia had refused his request that an inspection of the picket site be carried out with a view to determining whether the tents erected by the activists could count as 'architectural structures' and whether there had been any obstruction of traffic or pedestrians.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant complained that the sanction imposed by the Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia — a total and permanent ban on the Chumatskyy Shlyakh civic youth association organising peaceful assemblies in Vinnytsia — had been arbitrary and disproportionate.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 22 November 2006 the Vinnytsia Regional Court of Appeal examined the applicant's appeal against the judgment of the Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia of 15 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Vinnytsia Regional Court of Appeal decided that, in view of the short notice of the intention to hold a picket and the indefinite period during which the participants planned to continue their demonstration, the administrative action lodged by the executive committee of Vinnytsia City Council could be accepted for examination.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Vinnytsia Regional Court of Appeal agreed with the Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia's findings of fact.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Vinnytsia Regional Court of Appeal found that by installing the tents, the protesters had breached section 16 of the Populated Localities Development Act of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Vinnytsia Regional Court of Appeal found that by installing the tents, the protesters had breached section 18 of the Automobile Roads Act of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Vinnytsia Regional Court of Appeal found that the sanction imposed on the protesters by the Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia had been disproportionate.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Vinnytsia Regional Court of Appeal noted that the Constitution of Ukraine generally allowed peaceful assemblies, which could therefore not be prohibited in a blanket manner.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Vinnytsia Regional Court of Appeal found that the Constitution of Ukraine did not envisage a form of assembly such as the 'picketing' of administrative buildings with the installation on the streets of small architectural structures.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Vinnytsia Regional Court of Appeal found that the term 'peaceful assemblies' in the operative part of the Leninskiy District Court in Vinnytsia's judgment had to be substituted with the term 'pickets'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Vinnytsia Regional Court of Appeal rejected the applicant's remaining arguments as unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 1 April 2009 the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine dismissed an appeal on points of law lodged by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that citizens have the right to assemble peacefully without arms and to hold meetings, rallies, processions and demonstrations, upon notifying in advance the bodies of executive power or bodies of local self-government.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Constitution of Ukraine of 1996"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that restrictions on the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly may be established by a court in accordance with the law and only in the interests of national security and public order, with the purpose of preventing disturbances or crimes, protecting the health of the population, or protecting the rights and freedoms of other persons.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Constitution of Ukraine of 1996"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Article 8(1) of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine (as worded at the material time) provides that when considering a case, a court shall be governed by the principle of the rule of law, which provides that a human being and his or her rights and freedoms shall be the highest social value and shall determine the essence and orientation of the activity of the State.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Justice of 6 July 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Article 8(2) of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine (as worded at the material time) provides that a court shall apply the principle of the rule of law by taking into account the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Justice of 6 July 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Article 8(3) of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine (as worded at the material time) provides that the right to appeal to an administrative court for the protection of human rights and freedoms based directly on a reference to the Constitution of Ukraine shall be possible.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Justice of 6 July 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Article 8(4) of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine (as worded at the material time) provides that a court may not refuse to examine and resolve an administrative case on the grounds that the legislation applicable to the dispute is incomplete, unclear, incoherent, or lacking.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Justice of 6 July 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Article 11(1) of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine (as worded at the material time) provides that the consideration and resolution of cases in the administrative courts shall take place on the basis of adversarial proceedings, the evidence submitted by the parties and their ability to prove its cogency before the court.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Justice of 6 July 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Article 11(2) of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine (as worded at the material time) provides that the court shall consider administrative cases exclusively following the lodging of an action in accordance with the Code and may not exceed the scope of the complaints, except where necessary for the comprehensive protection of the rights, freedoms and interests of the parties or third persons.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Justice of 6 July 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Article 11(3) of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine (as worded at the material time) provides that each person who seeks judicial protection may dispose of his or her claim at his or her discretion, except in the circumstances determined in the Code.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Justice of 6 July 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Article 11(4) of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine (as worded at the material time) provides that the court shall use the measures provided for in law which are necessary for the establishment of all the circumstances of the case, including by determining and ordering the production of evidence on its own initiative.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Justice of 6 July 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Article 11(5) of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine (as worded at the material time) provides that the court shall, on its own initiative, invite the parties to the proceedings to submit evidence or order the production of evidence which, in its view, is lacking.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Justice of 6 July 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Article 182(1) of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine (as worded at the material time) provides that immediately upon receipt of a notification concerning the organisation of meetings, rallies, processions, demonstrations, etc., the executive authorities and bodies of local self-government shall have the right to apply to the District Administrative Court of the respective locality with an action seeking to prohibit these events or otherwise restrict the right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Justice of 6 July 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Article 182(2) of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine (as worded at the material time) provides that an action received on the date on which the aforementioned events take place or thereafter shall be left without examination.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Justice of 6 July 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Article 182(5) of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine (as worded at the material time) provides that the court shall allow the plaintiff's claims in the interests of national security and public order where it establishes that carrying out the meetings, rallies, processions, demonstrations or other assemblies may create an imminent risk of disturbances or crimes, or endanger the health of the population or the rights and freedoms of other people, and that in its ruling the court shall indicate the manner in which the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly is to be restricted.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Justice of 6 July 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Article 182(6) of the Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine (as worded at the material time) provides that the ruling of the court in respect of cases concerning restriction of the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly shall be enforced immediately.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Administrative Justice of 6 July 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Section 16(5) of the Populated Localities Development Act of Ukraine (Law no. 2807-IV of 6 September 2005) proscribed the installation in public areas of objects for external advertisement, commercial stalls, pavilions, kiosks, and so on without authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Other relevant provisions of domestic law and relevant case-law"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Section 18 of the Automobile Roads Act of Ukraine (Law no. 2862-IV of 8 September 2005) proscribed the placement of any objects, constructions, erections or their parts within the boundaries of the so-called 'red lines of the street', delimiting the width of the street.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Other relevant provisions of domestic law and relevant case-law"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F010", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F026", "F029", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F053"], "interference": ["F016", "F029", "F032", "F033", "F053", "F055"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F010", "F015", "F017", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F047", "F053", "F054", "F067", "F068", "F071", "F072"], "legitimate_aim": ["F021", "F022", "F023", "F027", "F028"], "necessity": ["F003", "F010", "F017", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F026", "F027", "F029", "F033", "F034", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F047", "F053", "F054"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F010", "F024", "F034", "F036"], "interference": ["F029", "F033", "F053"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F010", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F047", "F053", "F054", "F067", "F068", "F071", "F072"], "legitimate_aim": ["F021", "F022", "F023", "F027"], "necessity": ["F003", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F027", "F029", "F033", "F034", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F047", "F053", "F054"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F010", "F024", "F029", "F033", "F034", "F040", "F041", "F043", "F047", "F053", "F054", "F067", "F068"]}} {"case_name": "case_229", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_230", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was a member of a group of aliens without residence permits.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant was a spokeswoman for a group of aliens without residence permits.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "In 1996, the group of aliens without residence permits decided to take collective action to draw attention to the difficulties they were having in obtaining a review of their immigration status in France.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The campaign of the group of aliens without residence permits received widespread coverage in the press.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The campaign of the group of aliens without residence permits culminated with the occupation of St Bernard's Church in Paris on 28 June 1996.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The group that occupied St Bernard's Church in Paris on 28 June 1996 numbered approximately two hundred illegal immigrants.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Most of the approximately two hundred illegal immigrants who occupied St Bernard's Church in Paris on 28 June 1996 were of African origin.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Ten men within the group occupying St Bernard's Church decided to go on hunger strike.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant's daughter joined the applicant as one of the occupiers of St Bernard's Church in Paris.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The movement occupying St Bernard's Church was known as the 'St Bernard sans papiers' movement.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The 'St Bernard sans papiers' movement was supported by several human-rights organisations.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Some activists from the human-rights organisations supporting the 'St Bernard sans papiers' movement decided to sleep on the premises of St Bernard's Church in a show of solidarity with the occupiers' predicament.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 22 August 1996, the Paris Commissioner of Police signed an order for the total evacuation of St Bernard's Church in Paris.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The evacuation order for St Bernard's Church was made on the ground that the occupation of the premises was unrelated to religious worship.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The evacuation order for St Bernard's Church was made on the ground that there had been a marked deterioration in the already unsatisfactory sanitary conditions at the church.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The evacuation order for St Bernard's Church was made on the ground that padlocks had been placed on the church exits.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The evacuation order for St Bernard's Church was made on the ground that there were serious sanitary, health, peace, security and public-order risks.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The director of the Paris Mobile Emergency Medical Service (SAMU) was given responsibility on 17 July 1996 for ensuring day-to-day care of the hunger strikers at St Bernard's Church.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The parish priest of St Bernard's Church was reminded of the health hazards to which the occupants were exposed by the precarious living conditions and of the need to allow unrestricted access to the emergency services.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The World Doctors (Médecins du Monde) organisation offered continuous medical assistance in St Bernard's Church.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The World Doctors (Médecins du Monde) organisation made public alarming information on the very serious consequences of the hunger strike for the health of the hunger strikers at the expiration of the medically critical period of forty days.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 12 August 1996, the ten hunger strikers at St Bernard's Church were evacuated on the basis of Article 223-6 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, solely in order for the men to be given appropriate medical check-ups in hospitals in Paris.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The ten hunger strikers returned to St Bernard's Church of their own accord after being evacuated on 12 August 1996.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Upon returning to St Bernard's Church, the ten hunger strikers immediately declared their intention to pursue their hunger strike action.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Since 28 June 1996, there had been a marked deterioration in the already unsatisfactory sanitary conditions at St Bernard's Church, the available sanitary equipment being totally inadequate for the long-term use of the premises as a collective shelter.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The number of people present on the premises of St Bernard's Church grew considerably during the last few days before the evacuation order, leading to incidents in the immediate vicinity and notably on the public highway.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The incidents in the vicinity of St Bernard's Church created a risk of behaviour that may result in public order disturbances.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The various movements concerned with the occupation of St Bernard's Church erected barriers on the public highway, across rue Saint-Bruno at the junctions with rue Saint-Luc and rue Jérôme l'Ermite.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The barriers erected on the public highway near St Bernard's Church obstructed the highway, hindering the passage of ordinary traffic and of emergency vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The church doors and various exits of St Bernard's Church were kept closed, and in some cases padlocked, to enable a filter system to be operated at the only remaining entrance that was permanently accessible.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "A barricade formed of barriers chained together was placed between the enclosure railings and the north entrance to the chancel of St Bernard's Church.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The installations at St Bernard's Church (closed/padlocked doors and barricade) constituted a major hazard should an emergency evacuation of the persons present inside the building become necessary.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The activities and movements at St Bernard's Church were totally unrelated to religious worship, which was the exclusive use to which the public building could be put under the law of 9 December 1905.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the evacuation order, the situation at St Bernard's Church represented a serious sanitary, health, peace, public-security and public-order risk.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The morning following the signing of the evacuation order (23 August 1996), the police carried out the evacuation of St Bernard's Church.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Police officers arrived at St Bernard's Church at 6.30 a.m. on 23 August 1996.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Police officers set up a checkpoint at the exit of St Bernard's Church to verify whether the aliens evacuated from the church had documentation authorising them to stay and circulate in French territory.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The checkpoint at St Bernard's Church was set up on the basis of Article 78-2, subparagraphs 1 and 3, of the Code of Criminal Procedure and Article 8, subparagraphs 2 and 3, of the Ordinance of 2 November 1945.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The police entered St Bernard's Church at 7.56 a.m. on 23 August 1996.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "All the occupants of St Bernard's Church were stopped and questioned by police during the evacuation on 23 August 1996.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "White occupants of St Bernard's Church were immediately released by police during the evacuation on 23 August 1996.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Police assembled all the dark-skinned occupants of St Bernard's Church, apart from those on hunger strike, and sent them by coach to an aliens' detention centre at Vincennes.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Orders were made for the detention and deportation of almost all of the dark-skinned occupants sent to the aliens' detention centre at Vincennes.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "More than a hundred of the occupants detained following the evacuation of St Bernard's Church were subsequently released by the courts on account of certain irregularities on the part of the police.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The police irregularities following the evacuation of St Bernard's Church even extended to making false reports regarding the stopping and questioning procedure.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "At 8.20 a.m. on 23 August 1996, a police officer asked the applicant, as she was leaving St Bernard's Church, for documentary evidence that she had leave to stay in France.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant was unable to produce documentary evidence that she had leave to stay in France when asked by the police officer at 8.20 a.m. on 23 August 1996.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant had attended the Paris Police Commissioner's Office on 5 June 1996.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 17 July 1996, the applicant was refused leave to remain in France on the ground that she did not satisfy any of the conditions laid down by the Ordinance of 2 November 1945 for the issue of a residence permit.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 17 July 1996, the applicant was refused leave to remain in France on the ground that there were no personal or family reasons justifying her being granted leave to remain on humanitarian grounds.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The applicant had been invited to leave French territory within one month after receipt of notification of the Paris Commissioner of Police's decision of 17 July 1996 refusing her leave to remain.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "At 9.55 a.m. on 23 August 1996, the applicant was taken into custody and informed of her rights pursuant to Articles 63-2 and 63-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The custody measure against the applicant was deemed to have taken effect at 7.56 a.m. on 23 August 1996, when she was stopped.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The applicant refused to speak throughout her period in custody on 23 August 1996.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "At 8.15 p.m. on 23 August 1996, the Senior Deputy Public Prosecutor at the Eighth Division of the Paris Public Prosecutor's Office instructed the police officers to bring the applicant before him, with the case file as it stood.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "At 1.30 p.m. on 24 August 1996, the applicant appeared before the Paris Criminal Court under the 'immediate summary trial' procedure.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicant was accused before the Paris Criminal Court of having entered and stayed in France without being in possession of the documents or visas required by the rules.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Paris Criminal Court sentenced the applicant to two months' imprisonment, suspended.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Paris Criminal Court held that the occupation of a place of worship over a period of several weeks in order to contest immigration status and create a movement in their favour in itself constituted an emergency justifying the administrative authority's decision to expel the occupants.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Paris Criminal Court held that the presence in St Bernard's Church of several hundred people for a period of several weeks, claiming through public statements or spokespersons to be aliens without residence permits or papers, constituted grounds for suspecting that those concerned had committed offences under the immigration rules such that the verification of their identity pursuant to Article 78-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure was justified.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Paris Criminal Court held that, since a large number of people were stopped at the same time and refused to disclose their identities, the police were not able to carry out an immediate identity check.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Paris Criminal Court held that the fact that the identity check was not carried out when the occupants were first stopped, but within a reasonable period thereafter given the practical contingencies inherent in an operation of that size, did not render the proceedings defective.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Paris Criminal Court held that, regard being had to the large number of persons stopped and the circumstances in which the operation was conducted, the applicant was notified of her rights within a reasonable time.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 23 January 1997, the Paris Court of Appeal, on appeal by the applicant, upheld the sentence of two months' imprisonment, suspended, imposed by the Paris Criminal Court.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 23 January 1997, the Paris Court of Appeal added an order excluding the applicant from French territory for three years.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Paris Court of Appeal held that the occupation of a place of worship by approximately three hundred individuals over several weeks, in order to create a movement in their favour and to contest their immigration status, constituted an emergency that justified the administrative authority making an expulsion order without making a prior application to the courts.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Paris Court of Appeal held that the occupiers of St Bernard's Church continued their hunger strike for almost forty days and the living conditions of those concerned continued to deteriorate.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Paris Court of Appeal held that the scale of the demonstrations over several weeks, with barriers being used to obstruct the highway and hinder the passage of vehicles, constituted a risk for security, sanitation, the health of the hunger strikers and public order that justified urgent measures being taken to put an end to the disturbances.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 4 June 1998, the Court of Cassation dismissed the applicant's appeal on points of law.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "In the proceedings before the courts below, Madjiguène Cissé (the applicant), a Senegalese national, was accused of illegally entering and staying in France.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "In the proceedings before the courts below, the applicant duly challenged the lawfulness of the order issued by the Paris Commissioner of Police, without a prior court order, for the evacuation of St Bernard's Church.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Court of Cassation held that even if the applicant had proved that the evacuation order issued by the Paris Commissioner of Police was unlawful, it would have had no bearing on the outcome of the criminal proceedings against her.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Article 111-5 of the French Criminal Code provides that criminal courts shall have jurisdiction to interpret general or individual administrative decisions or regulations and to determine their lawfulness if the outcome of criminal proceedings pending before them depends on their so doing.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Article 78-2, subparagraph 1, of the French Code of Criminal Procedure provides that senior police officers and ordinary police officers acting on the orders of senior police officers who are accountable for their actions may invite any person to prove his or her identity by any means if there are grounds for suspecting that he or she has committed or attempted to commit an offence.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Article 78-2, subparagraph 1, of the French Code of Criminal Procedure provides that senior police officers and ordinary police officers acting on the orders of senior police officers who are accountable for their actions may invite any person to prove his or her identity by any means if there are grounds for suspecting that he or she is preparing to commit a serious crime (crime) or other major offence (délit), may be able to provide information that will assist in the investigation of a serious crime or other major offence, or is wanted by a judicial authority.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Article L. 2512-13 of the General Code of the Territorial Authorities provides that in the City of Paris the Commissioner of Police shall have the powers and prerogatives conferred on him by the Ordinance of the Consuls of 12 Messidor, Year VIII, determining the functions of the Paris Commissioner of Police, by the amendments made thereto, and by Articles L. 2512-7, L. 2512-14 and L. 2512-17.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Article L. 2512-13 of the General Code of the Territorial Authorities provides that in the circumstances set out in the General Code of the Territorial Authorities and the Public Health Code, the Mayor of Paris shall be responsible for ensuring that public highways in the city are kept clean and tidy, for maintaining order at fairs and markets and, subject to the opinion of the Commissioner of Police, for all grants of parking permits to small traders and of permits or licences for erecting stalls on the public highway.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Article L. 2512-13 of the General Code of the Territorial Authorities provides that the Mayor of Paris shall be responsible for ensuring the preservation of State property incorporated into the public property of the City of Paris, and that the power of substitution conferred on the State in the département shall be exercised, in Paris, by the Commissioner of Police.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "Section I, Article 1 of the Ordinance of the Consuls of 12 Messidor, Year VIII provides that the Commissioner of Police of Paris shall perform the functions set out therein under the immediate authority of the ministers and shall communicate directly with them about the matters for which their departments have responsibility.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "Section I, Article 2 of the Ordinance of the Consuls of 12 Messidor, Year VIII provides that the Commissioner of Police of Paris may republish the administrative rules and regulations and issue orders to ensure that they are complied with.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Section III, Article 21 of the Ordinance of the Consuls of 12 Messidor, Year VIII provides that the Commissioner of Police of Paris shall have responsibility for all matters concerning minor highways, save that an appeal will lie against his or her decisions to the Minister of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Section III, Article 22 of the Ordinance of the Consuls of 12 Messidor, Year VIII provides that the Commissioner of Police of Paris shall secure liberty and security on the public highway and shall have responsibility for preventing criminal damage to the public highway, for lighting, for ensuring that residents comply with their obligation to keep the area in front of their houses swept, and for arranging for squares and the perimeters of public gardens and buildings to be swept at the city's expense.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Article 1 of the Law of 30 June 1881 on Public Meetings provides that anyone may attend public meetings and that public meetings may be held without prior permission subject to compliance with the conditions laid down in the following articles.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Article 6 of the Law of 30 June 1881 on Public Meetings provides that meetings may not be held on the public highway.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Article 8 of the Law of 30 June 1881 on Public Meetings provides that every meeting shall have a board of at least three people, which shall be responsible for maintaining order, preventing any breach of the law, ensuring that the meeting retains the character ascribed to it in the declaration, and prohibiting any speech that is contrary to public order or morals or containing any incitement to commit a serious crime (crime) or other major offence (délit).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Article 9 of the Law of 30 June 1881 on Public Meetings provides that the right to terminate a meeting shall not be exercised by the authority's representative unless he or she is called upon to do so by the board or unless clashes or patently illegal acts occur.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Article 10 of the Law of 30 June 1881 on Public Meetings provides that any breach of the provisions of that Law shall be punishable by the penalties laid down for summary offences, without prejudice to any proceedings that may be instituted in respect of any serious crime or other major offence that may have been committed at the meetings.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Section 25 of the Law of 9 December 1905 on the Separation of Church and State provides that assemblies for the purposes of worship in premises belonging to or placed at the disposal of a religious association shall be open to the public, shall be exempted from the requirements of section 8 of the Law of 30 June 1881, but shall remain under the supervision of the authorities in the interests of public order, and may not take place until a declaration has been made identifying the premises where they will be held.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Section 26 of the Law of 9 December 1905 on the Separation of Church and State provides that it is prohibited to hold a public meeting in premises habitually used as a place of worship.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Section 32 of the Law of 9 December 1905 on the Separation of Church and State provides that anyone who prevents, delays or interrupts religious ceremonies by causing disturbances or disorder in the premises used for such ceremonies shall be liable to the same penalties.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Section 35 of the Law of 9 December 1905 on the Separation of Church and State provides that a minister of religion guilty of making a speech or posting or distributing notices publicly in a place of worship that contain direct incitement to resist compliance with the law or the lawful acts of public authorities or are aimed at stirring up or rousing one group of citizens against the others shall be liable to two years' imprisonment, without prejudice to the penalties for complicity if the incitement is followed by sedition, revolt or civil war.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": false, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F003", "F005"], "interference": ["F001", "F003", "F005", "F013", "F035"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F076", "F088"], "legitimate_aim": ["F005", "F013", "F014", "F033", "F049", "F050", "F051"], "necessity": ["F005", "F008", "F013", "F021", "F025", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F044", "F045"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F001", "F003", "F005"], "interference": ["F013", "F035"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F076", "F088"], "legitimate_aim": ["F013", "F014", "F033"], "necessity": ["F005", "F008", "F013", "F021", "F025", "F035", "F044"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F005", "F008", "F013", "F021", "F025", "F035", "F044", "F088"]}} {"case_name": "case_237", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The present applications concern the applicants' arrests in relation to their intention to participate in peaceful demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The present applications concern administrative proceedings against the applicants in relation to their intention to participate in peaceful demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants alleged that their arrest had been an unlawful interference with their right to freedom of assembly under Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants alleged that their conviction had been an unlawful interference with their right to freedom of assembly under Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants alleged that their arrest had been contrary to the guarantees of Article 5 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants alleged that their arrest had been contrary to the guarantees of Article 6 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicants alleged that their conviction had been contrary to the guarantees of Article 5 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicants alleged that their conviction had been contrary to the guarantees of Article 6 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Some applicants raised complaints under Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicants were represented by Mr R. Mustafazade, a lawyer based in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicants were represented by Mr A. Mustafayev, a lawyer based in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr Ç. Əsgərov.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The circumstances relating to the applicants' arrest and custody are similar to those in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (application nos. 67360/11 and 2 others, paragraphs 5-55, judgment of 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The circumstances relating to the subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants are similar to those in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (application nos. 67360/11 and 2 others, paragraphs 5-55, judgment of 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The circumstances relating to the applicants' arrest and custody are similar to those in Huseynov and Others v. Azerbaijan (application nos. 34262/14 and 5 others, paragraphs 4-30, judgment of 24 November 2016).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The circumstances relating to the subsequent administrative proceedings against the applicants are similar to those in Huseynov and Others v. Azerbaijan (application nos. 34262/14 and 5 others, paragraphs 4-30, judgment of 24 November 2016).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicants were opposition-oriented activists.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicants intended to participate in peaceful demonstrations planned for 8 April 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicants intended to participate in peaceful demonstrations planned for 22 April 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicants were arrested on various dates while distributing leaflets inviting people to participate in the authorised demonstration of 8 April 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicants were arrested on various dates while distributing leaflets inviting people to participate in the authorised demonstration of 22 April 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicants were subsequently convicted under the Code of Administrative Offences to various administrative detention terms.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Further information concerning the applications is set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021"], "interference": ["F001", "F002", "F003", "F004", "F020", "F021", "F022"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F020", "F021", "F022"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F018", "F019", "F020", "F021"], "interference": ["F020", "F021", "F022"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F020", "F021", "F022"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016"]}} {"case_name": "case_238", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_239", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F001", "F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_240", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the location of public events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the time of conduct of public events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the manner of conduct of public events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Some applicants also raised complaints under Article 6 of the Convention, as set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Some applicants also raised complaints under Article 13 of the Convention, as set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003", "F004"]}} {"case_name": "case_242", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_243", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "On 29 April 2008 the applicants jointly notified the Beyoğlu district governor that they would be gathering before the Taksim Atatürk memorial on 1 May 2008 at 1 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants notified the Beyoğlu district governor that the purpose of the gathering was to celebrate Labour Day.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants notified the Beyoğlu district governor that the purpose of the gathering was to commemorate their friends who had lost their lives during the demonstrations of 1 May 1977.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 30 April 2008 the Beyoğlu district governor authorised a gathering at the Taksim Atatürk memorial for representatives of trade unions only.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Beyoğlu district governor specifically indicated that a demonstration on a larger scale at the Taksim Atatürk memorial was not authorised.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Minister of the Interior issued a press statement declaring that the authorities were in possession of intelligence reports which precluded them from authorising any demonstration in Taksim Square, for security reasons.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Government's spokesman issued a press statement declaring that the authorities were in possession of intelligence reports which precluded them from authorising any demonstration in Taksim Square, for security reasons.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Istanbul Governor's office issued a press statement declaring that the authorities were in possession of intelligence reports which precluded them from authorising any demonstration in Taksim Square, for security reasons.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The authorities held that any demonstration held in Taksim Square on 1 May 2008 would be unlawful and unconstitutional on account of possible provocations and disruption of traffic and public order.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The authorities stated that they were going to shut down certain schools in the nearby districts of Taksim Square on 1 May 2008 as a security measure.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The authorities stated that they were going to stop the operation of ferries and subways on 1 May 2008 as a security measure.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The authorities stated that they were going to block the roads leading to Taksim Square on 1 May 2008 as a security measure.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The authorities stated that they were going to deploy extra police on 1 May 2008 as a security measure.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "As alternative locations for the demonstration, the Istanbul Governor's office indicated four other squares: two on the European side and two on the Anatolian side of Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 30 April 2008 the first applicant lodged a complaint against the Governor of Istanbul with the Istanbul public prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The first applicant accused the Governor of Istanbul of denying the trade unions their right to assembly in a discriminatory manner.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The first applicant complained that there was no justification for denying trade unions access to Taksim Square on Labour Day, when the same location was available for other large-scale demonstrations and celebrations.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The complaint lodged by the first applicant against the Governor of Istanbul was assigned investigation number 2008/20905.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "At approximately 6 a.m. on 1 May 2008, members of the Confederation of Progressive Trade Unions of Turkey (DİSK) and the Confederation of Public Employees' Trade Unions (KESK) began gathering in front of the DİSK headquarters located in the district of Şişli for Labour Day celebrations.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "At around 6.30 a.m. on 1 May 2008, the police asked the group gathered in front of the DİSK headquarters in Şişli to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The police warned the group gathered in front of the DİSK headquarters in Şişli that they were acting in violation of the Assemblies and Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The members of the group refused to disperse, arguing that they were merely waiting in front of the DİSK headquarters, which was a pedestrian area, and that they were not violating the Assemblies and Marches Act (Law no. 2911) in any way.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The police proceeded to disperse the group gathered in front of the DİSK headquarters in Şişli by spraying them with pressurised water, paint and tear gas, both inside and outside the DİSK building.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Similar police interventions occurred over the next couple of hours after 6.30 a.m. on 1 May 2008 with increasing intensity.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Some of the demonstrators were injured as a result of the use of force by the police on 1 May 2008 in the district of Şişli.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "While injured demonstrators were trying to reach the nearby Şişli Etfal Hospital for medical care, they were chased by the police.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "While injured demonstrators were trying to reach Şişli Etfal Hospital for medical care, they were subjected to gas attacks even within the hospital premises.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "Some members of the DİSK were arrested on 1 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "At approximately 10.30 a.m. on 1 May 2008, the group of demonstrators broke up of its own accord to forestall any further violence.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 2 May 2008 the Chief of Şişli Etfal Hospital gave a statement to the police.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Chief of Şişli Etfal Hospital stated that on 1 May 2008 around 20-30 demonstrators had entered the hospital and opened a banner.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Chief of Şişli Etfal Hospital stated that police officers had entered the Şişli Etfal Hospital premises in pursuit of the demonstrators and used a gas bomb in the hospital's garden to neutralise the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Chief of Şişli Etfal Hospital stated that one of the police officers had mistakenly sat on a gas bomb and exploded it in the police car parked at the entrance of the Emergency Service of Şişli Etfal Hospital.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Chief of Şişli Etfal Hospital stated that as a result of the gas bomb explosion in the police car, staff working in the Emergency Service of Şişli Etfal Hospital as well as some of the patients had been affected.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Chief of Şişli Etfal Hospital stated that the gas bomb was not deliberately thrown in the hospital building.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On an unspecified date after 1 May 2008, the director of the DİSK, along with other persons, lodged a complaint with the Istanbul public prosecutor against various authorities, including the office of the Prime Minister, the Minister of the Interior, the Minister of Justice, the Istanbul Governor's office, the Head of the Istanbul Security Directorate and the police officers involved in the incidents of 1 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The director of the DİSK and other persons accused the aforementioned authorities of breach of the right to freedom of assembly and a disproportionate use of force (investigation no. 2008/59361).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On an unspecified date, the Istanbul public prosecutor issued a decision of lack of jurisdiction in connection with the complaint lodged against the Istanbul Governor and the Head of Istanbul Security Directorate.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The case file concerning the complaint against the Istanbul Governor and the Head of Istanbul Security Directorate was transferred to the Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Cassation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Pursuant to the terms of Law no. 4483, the public prosecutor at the Court of Cassation sought authorisation from the Minister of the Interior to prosecute the Istanbul Governor and the Head of Istanbul Security Directorate.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On an unspecified date, the Minister of the Interior refused to authorise the prosecution of the Istanbul Governor and the Head of Istanbul Security Directorate.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 8 April 2009 the public prosecutor at the Court of Cassation decided not to proceed with the case against the Istanbul Governor and the Head of Istanbul Security Directorate.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The decision of 8 April 2009 not to proceed with the case was notified to the applicants' lawyer on 16 April 2009.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicants' appeal lodged against the decision of 8 April 2009 not to proceed with the case was dismissed by the Supreme Administrative Court.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Supreme Administrative Court held that pursuant to domestic legislation, no appeal was possible against the decision of 8 April 2009 not to proceed with the case.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 1 February 2009 the Istanbul public prosecutor delivered a decision of non-prosecution regarding the complaint lodged against the Prime Minister, the Minister of the Interior, and the Minister of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Istanbul public prosecutor held that pursuant to the Turkish Constitution, the Prime Minister, the Minister of the Interior, and the Minister of Justice could not be held liable for their actions in the course of their duties.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The decision of non-prosecution dated 1 February 2009 was served on the applicants' lawyer on 24 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicants' appeal against the decision of non-prosecution dated 1 February 2009 was rejected on 22 May 2009 by the Sincan Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Sincan Assize Court held that no objection could be lodged against the decision of the Istanbul public prosecutor dated 1 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 5 May 2008 the representative of the first applicant handed to the Şişli public prosecutor an undetonated gas bomb belonging to the police force.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The undetonated gas bomb handed to the Şişli public prosecutor had been found inside the DİSK headquarters following the events of 1 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 19 June 2008, upon a complaint lodged by the Istanbul Governor's office, the Beyoğlu public prosecutor questioned the director of the DİSK in relation to the events that took place on 1 May 2008 (investigation no. 2008/9241).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "No prosecution was initiated against the applicants in relation to the events of 1 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Article 34 of the Turkish Constitution provides that everyone has the right to hold unarmed and peaceful meetings and demonstration marches without prior permission.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Article 34 of the Turkish Constitution provides that the formalities, conditions, and procedures governing the exercise of the right to hold meetings and demonstration marches shall be prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Section 22 of the Assemblies and Marches Act (Law no. 2911) prohibits demonstrations and processions on public streets, in parks, places of worship and buildings in which public services are based.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Demonstrations Act (Law no. 2911)"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Section 22 of the Assemblies and Marches Act (Law no. 2911) provides that demonstrations organised in public squares have to comply with security instructions and not disrupt individuals' movements or public transport.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Demonstrations Act (Law no. 2911)"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Section 24 of the Assemblies and Marches Act (Law no. 2911) provides that demonstrations and processions which do not comply with the provisions of that law will be dispersed by force on the order of the governor's office and after the demonstrators are warned.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Demonstrations Act (Law no. 2911)"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F019", "F022", "F054"], "interference": ["F023", "F024", "F029"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F057", "F058", "F059"], "legitimate_aim": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F009"], "necessity": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F019", "F020", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F029", "F031", "F032", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F054"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F019", "F022", "F054"], "interference": ["F023", "F029"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F057", "F059"], "legitimate_aim": ["F009"], "necessity": ["F019", "F020", "F022", "F023", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F029", "F031", "F032", "F041", "F042", "F054"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F019", "F020", "F023", "F025", "F027", "F029", "F032", "F041", "F054"]}} {"case_name": "case_244", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant is a Cypriot national of Turkish origin.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant was born in 1950.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant is a paediatrician.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant resides in Nicosia, north of the \"green line\".", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant is a critic of the Turkish-Cypriot authorities.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant is a critic of the Turkish military presence in the northern part of Cyprus, which he defines as \"occupation\".", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant is the \"Turkish-Cypriot coordinator\" of the Movement for an Independent and Federal Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Movement for an Independent and Federal Cyprus is an unregistered association of Turkish and Greek Cypriots.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Movement for an Independent and Federal Cyprus was founded in 1989 in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Movement for an Independent and Federal Cyprus has a Turkish-Cypriot coordinating committee in the northern part of Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Movement for an Independent and Federal Cyprus has a Greek-Cypriot coordinating committee in the southern part of Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The purpose of the Movement for an Independent and Federal Cyprus is to develop close relations between the two communities (Turkish-Cypriot and Greek-Cypriot).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Movement for an Independent and Federal Cyprus organises bi-communal meetings of a political, cultural, medical or social character.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant is normally unable to obtain a permit from the Turkish and Turkish-Cypriot authorities to visit the \"buffer-zone\".", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant is normally unable to obtain a permit from the Turkish and Turkish-Cypriot authorities to visit the southern part of Cyprus in order to participate in various bi-communal meetings.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Between 8 March 1992 and 14 April 1998 (the date of the Commission's admissibility decision), only 6 out of 46 requests by the applicant for permits to visit the \"buffer-zone\" or the southern part of Cyprus were granted.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Between 18 April 1998 and 16 October 1999, two permit requests by the applicant were refused by the Turkish and Turkish-Cypriot authorities.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Of the two permit requests refused between 18 April 1998 and 16 October 1999, one was subsequently granted.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "One of the refused permit requests concerned a UNFICYP (United Nations Peacekeeping Force in Cyprus) Spring Fair at Nicosia International Airport in May 1992.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "One of the refused permit requests concerned a bi-communal medical seminar organised by the UNHCR (United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees) in June 1992.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "One of the refused permit requests concerned a meeting of the coordinating committee for the Movement for an Independent and Federal Cyprus at the Ledra Palace in October 1992.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "One of the refused permit requests concerned a meeting for the reorganisation of the coordinating committee of the Movement for an Independent and Federal Cyprus in April 1994.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "One of the refused permit requests concerned a meeting for the reorganisation of the coordinating committee of the Movement for an Independent and Federal Cyprus in July 1994.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "One of the refused permit requests concerned a seminar on cardiology organised by the UNHCR (United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees) in June 1994.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "One of the refused permit requests concerned a general meeting of the New Cyprus Association in December 1997.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "A number of the refused permit requests concerned receptions organised by the German embassy in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "In May 1992, the Turkish and Turkish-Cypriot authorities refused to allow Greek Cypriots to attend a meeting organised by the applicant in the northern part of Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant claimed that the Council of Ministers of the \"Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus\" (the \"TRNC\") had adopted a decision prohibiting him from contacting Greek Cypriots.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Reference to the Council of Ministers of the \"TRNC\" decision prohibiting the applicant from contacting Greek Cypriots was allegedly made in a letter dated 3 February 1992 from the Health Minister of the \"TRNC\" to the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The letter dated 3 February 1992 from the Health Minister of the \"TRNC\" to the applicant stated: \"According to the information our Ministry has received, you were informed by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Defence orally and this has been a decision of the government and we have nothing to add in our capacity as the Ministry.\"", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 7 May 1992, the applicant wrote to the Prime Minister of the \"TRNC\" requesting to be informed of the content of the Council of Ministers' decision referred to in the Health Minister's letter of 3 February 1992.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant received no reply from the Prime Minister of the \"TRNC\" to his letter of 7 May 1992.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 29 May 1992, the applicant sent a letter of protest to the Foreign Minister of Turkey.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The applicant's letter of protest of 29 May 1992 to the Foreign Minister of Turkey remained unanswered.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 18 May 1994, the Directorate of Consular and Minority Affairs of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Defence of the \"TRNC\" informed the applicant that the permission requested by the applicant's letter of 19 April 1994 was refused for security reasons, in the public interest, and because the applicant had made propaganda against the State.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 24 May 1994, the applicant wrote to the Deputy Prime Minister of the \"TRNC\" asking whether the previous decision of the Council of Ministers was still in force, since he was not allowed to visit the buffer-zone or cross over into Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant received no answer from the Deputy Prime Minister of the \"TRNC\" to his letter of 24 May 1994.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 19 July 1994, the applicant sent a reminder to the Deputy Prime Minister of the \"TRNC\" regarding his letter of 24 May 1994.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicant's reminder of 19 July 1994 to the Deputy Prime Minister of the \"TRNC\" also remained unanswered.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicant claimed that in an article published in a newspaper on 18 March 1996, the former Deputy Prime Minister of the \"TRNC\" (to whom the applicant had sent the letters of 24 May 1994 and 19 July 1994) stated that when he had held the position of Deputy Prime Minister he had requested an explanation from the Prime Minister of the \"TRNC\" regarding the refusal of permits to the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicant claimed that in the newspaper article of 18 March 1996, the former Deputy Prime Minister of the \"TRNC\" stated that when he had held the position of Deputy Prime Minister he had requested an explanation from the President of the \"TRNC\" regarding the refusal of permits to the applicant, but had not received an answer.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F013", "F012", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F015", "F016"], "interference": ["F016", "F015", "F014", "F005"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F041"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F013", "F015", "F016"], "interference": ["F015", "F016"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F030", "F032", "F035", "F037"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F013", "F015", "F016", "F030", "F032", "F035"]}} {"case_name": "case_245", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_246", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_247", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1965.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1965.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1967.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The fourth applicant was born in 1948.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "At the material time, all four applicants lived in Novorossiysk.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants were human rights activists.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicants had participated since 2003 in the work of a charity and human rights organisation called FRODO in the Krasnodar Region.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "FRODO's goal was to combat intolerance of and discrimination against ethnic minorities in the Krasnodar Region.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "One of FRODO's key activities was the organisation of a game of 'tolerant football' with the participation of children belonging to different ethnic groups in Novorossiysk.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "In 2006 the second applicant received an email from Mr S.G., a former Russian citizen residing in Germany.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Mr S.G. expressed his interest in the concept of 'tolerant football' in his email to the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Mr S.G. asked to meet the second applicant to discuss the concept of 'tolerant football'.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The second applicant and Mr S.G. met on 23 January 2007 at 11 a.m. in the local art school (referred to as 'the Art School').", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The director of the Art School, Mr V.S., had been a member of FRODO since its foundation.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Mr V.S. proposed the use of the Art School's premises for the meeting because FRODO had no offices.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The other meeting attendees on 23 January 2007 included six members of FRODO (including the applicants), Mr S.G. and Mr R.K. from Germany, an interpreter, and three university students.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "In total, there were twelve participants at the meeting on 23 January 2007 at the Art School.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "At around 1 p.m. on 23 January 2007, about fifteen police officers and representatives of the migration service entered the meeting room at the Art School.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "When the police officers and migration service representatives entered the meeting room, they found the meeting participants having tea and cake.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the applicants, a further twenty armed police officers surrounded the Art School building on 23 January 2007.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Government contested the applicants' claim that twenty armed police officers surrounded the Art School building as unconfirmed.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The police officers requested those present in the meeting room to show their identity documents.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Those present in the meeting room showed their identity documents to the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The police officers demanded an explanation as regards the event taking place at the Art School on 23 January 2007.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The members of FRODO refused to give any explanation to the police officers on the grounds that no charges had been brought against them.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The police officers remained in the meeting room at the Art School until officials from the Department of Culture arrived.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The police officers remained in the meeting room at the Art School until officials from the Department of Cooperation with Public Organisations and Monitoring of Migration of Novorossiysk arrived.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The officials from the Department of Culture and the Department of Cooperation with Public Organisations and Monitoring of Migration of Novorossiysk requested the participants to leave the meeting room on the grounds that no notification of a public event had been sent to the Department of Culture.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The meeting participants refused to leave the meeting room on the grounds that their meeting was not public and therefore did not require notification.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "A few minutes later, the director of the Art School informed the participants that a lesson was about to start in the meeting room.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The meeting participants left the meeting room at the Art School after the director informed them that a lesson was about to start.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 30 January 2007, the justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk examined an administrative case brought against the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk held that the meeting in the Art School on 23 January 2007 had been a gathering — a public event aimed at expressing opinions on various issues.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk held that the organiser of the gathering at the Art School should have notified the regional authorities of the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk found the first applicant guilty of participation in an unauthorised public event, an offence under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk sentenced the first applicant to a fine of 500 Russian roubles (RUB).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 12 March 2007, the Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk upheld the judgment of the justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk convicting the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 2 February 2007, the justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk examined administrative cases brought against the second and the third applicants.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk held that the second applicant had organised a public event, namely a gathering of ten participants, without notifying the regional authorities.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk held that the third applicant had organised a public event, namely a gathering of ten participants, without notifying the regional authorities.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk found the second applicant guilty under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences and sentenced the second applicant to a fine of RUB 2,000.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk found the third applicant guilty under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences and sentenced the third applicant to a fine of RUB 2,000.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 20 February 2007, the Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk examined the appeal lodged by the second applicant, inter alia on the grounds that the gathering had been a private one.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 2 March 2007, the Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk examined the appeal lodged by the third applicant, inter alia on the grounds that the gathering had been a private one.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk upheld the first-instance court's finding that the gathering on 23 January 2007 had been a public event subject to the requirement of notification of the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk reclassified the second applicant's offence as falling under Article 20.2 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, reducing the fine to RUB 1,000 in respect of the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk reclassified the third applicant's offence as falling under Article 20.2 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, reducing the fine to RUB 1,500 in respect of the third applicant.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 9 February 2007, the justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk examined an administrative case brought against the fourth applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk dismissed the claims that the gathering at the Art School on 23 January 2007 was a private meeting in the administrative case against the fourth applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk found the fourth applicant guilty of participation in an unauthorised public event under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 81st judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk sentenced the fourth applicant to a fine of RUB 1,000.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 2 March 2007, the Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk upheld on appeal the judgment convicting the fourth applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On an unidentified date, the first deputy prosecutor for the Krasnodar Region filed a request for a supervisory review of the administrative cases against the second, third and fourth applicants.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 9 July 2007, the Acting President of the Krasnodar Regional Court examined the administrative case against the fourth applicant in supervisory review proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Acting President of the Krasnodar Regional Court upheld the judgment of 9 February 2007 convicting the fourth applicant as lawful and well-founded.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Acting President of the Krasnodar Regional Court upheld the appeal decision of 2 March 2007 in the fourth applicant's case as lawful and well-founded.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 3 August 2007, the Deputy President of the Krasnodar Regional Court conducted the supervisory review in the second and third applicants' cases.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Deputy President of the Krasnodar Regional Court quashed the judgment of 2 February 2007 in the second and third applicants' cases on the grounds that section 7 of the Public Events Act exempted the gatherings from the notification requirement.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Deputy President of the Krasnodar Regional Court quashed the decision of 20 February 2007 in the second applicant's case on the grounds that section 7 of the Public Events Act exempted the gatherings from the notification requirement.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Deputy President of the Krasnodar Regional Court quashed the decision of 2 March 2007 in the third applicant's case on the grounds that section 7 of the Public Events Act exempted the gatherings from the notification requirement.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The administrative cases of the second and third applicants were remitted for a fresh examination by the first-instance court following the supervisory review decision of 3 August 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 12 September 2007, the justice of the peace of the 80th judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk examined the administrative charges against the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 14 September 2007, the justice of the peace of the 80th judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk examined the administrative charges against the third applicant.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 80th judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk terminated the administrative proceedings against the second applicant on the grounds that the gathering had been conducted in a proper venue — 'a specially designated or arranged location' — in accordance with section 2 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 80th judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk terminated the administrative proceedings against the third applicant on the grounds that the gathering had been conducted in a proper venue — 'a specially designated or arranged location' — in accordance with section 2 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 80th judicial circuit of the Central District of Novorossiysk found that the gathering had not been subject to notification in accordance with section 7 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The second and third applicants sued the town administration of Novorossiysk and the Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation for damages.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The second and third applicants claimed that the police intervention during their private gathering on 23 January 2007 had been unlawful, intimidating and disruptive.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The second and third applicants claimed that their subsequent administrative convictions had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The second and third applicants claimed that despite the termination of the administrative case they had not been reimbursed for the administrative fines they had incurred in those proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The second and third applicants claimed that despite the termination of the administrative case they had not been reimbursed for the legal costs they had incurred in those proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 25 December 2007, the Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk rejected the second and third applicants' claim for damages.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk found that the police had acted lawfully and within their powers in order to verify a report of an unauthorised entry onto the Art School's premises.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk found that, in accordance with the local administration's directives and in order to combat terrorism, schools had to notify any planned events.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk found that the applicants had not been arrested or removed from the Art School's premises during the police check on 23 January 2007.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk found that the applicants could have continued their meeting elsewhere after the police check on 23 January 2007.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk found that no damage had been caused by the police check on 23 January 2007.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk found that the fines imposed on the second and third applicants had been cancelled by a previous judicial decision, which was not subject to review in the proceedings before it.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk found no grounds to make an award in respect of the second and third applicants' legal costs incurred in the terminated administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 19 February 2008, the Krasnodar Regional Court upheld on appeal the judgment of 25 December 2007 of the Oktyabrskiy District Court of Novorossiysk rejecting the second and third applicants' claim for damages.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Article 20.2 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001, as in force at the material time, provided that breaches of the established procedure for the organisation of public gatherings, meetings, demonstrations, marches or pickets shall be punishable by an administrative fine of between ten and twenty times the minimum wage, for the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001, as in force at the material time, provided that breaches of the established procedure for the conduct of public gatherings, meetings, demonstrations, marches or pickets shall be punishable by an administrative fine of, for the organisers, between ten and twenty times the minimum wage, and, for the participants, between five and ten times the minimum wage.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The relevant provisions of the Public Events Act are set out in Navalnyy v. Russia ([GC], nos. 29580/12 and 4 others, § 45, 15 November 2018) and in the cases cited in paragraph 43 of that judgment.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Section 2(1) of the Public Events Act defined a public event as an open, peaceful action accessible to all, held in the form of a gathering, a meeting, a demonstration, a march, or a picket or in various combinations of these forms, organised at the initiative of citizens of the Russian Federation, political parties, other public associations, or religious associations, including events held with the use of vehicles, with the aim of the free expression and formation of opinions, and to put forward demands on issues of political, economic, social and cultural life in the country, as well as issues of foreign policy.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Section 2(2) of the Public Events Act defined a gathering as an assembly of citizens in a specially designated or arranged location for the purpose of collective discussion of socially important issues.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Section 7 of the Public Events Act provided that notification of a public event (except for a gathering and a picket held by a solo participant) must be filed in writing by its organiser with the executive or municipal authority no earlier than fifteen days and no later than ten days before the date of the public event.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Section 8(1) of the Public Events Act provided that a public event may be held in any convenient location, provided that it does not create a risk of building collapse or any other risks to the safety of the participants, and that the access of participants to certain locations may be banned or restricted in the circumstances specified by federal laws.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F013", "F016", "F017", "F019", "F025", "F029", "F031"], "interference": ["F018", "F024", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F030", "F031"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F019", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F033", "F034", "F058", "F059", "F060", "F073", "F074", "F086"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F013", "F016", "F017", "F019"], "interference": ["F018", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F031"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F019", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F058", "F074", "F086"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F013", "F017", "F019", "F018", "F028", "F031", "F058", "F086", "F074"]}} {"case_name": "case_251", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' personal details are set out in the appendix.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants were represented by Mr M. Erbil, a lawyer practising in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants were represented by Mrs N. Selçuk, a lawyer practising in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr Hacı Ali Açıkgül.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Mr Hacı Ali Açıkgül held the position of Head of the Department of Human Rights of the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Turkey.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 18 November 2003 at around 10.50 a.m. a group of twenty-three individuals, including the applicants, entered the corridor of the third floor of the Sultanahmet Courthouse in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The corridor of the third floor of the Sultanahmet Courthouse in Istanbul was where the registries and hearing rooms of several courts were located.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "When the group of twenty-three individuals entered the corridor of the third floor of the Sultanahmet Courthouse, some civilians and court officials were present in the same corridor.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The group of twenty-three individuals began chanting the slogan \"End the Isolation\" (\"Tecride Son\").", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The group of twenty-three individuals began chanting the slogan \"No to invasion\" (\"İşgale Hayır\").", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The group of twenty-three individuals began chanting the slogan \"Close İmralı Prison\" (\"İmralı Cezaevi Kapatılsın\").", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The group of twenty-three individuals began chanting the slogan \"We have not surrendered and we will not surrender\" (\"Teslim olmadık olmayacağız\").", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The group of twenty-three individuals began chanting the slogan \"Salute, salute a thousand salutes to İmralı\" (\"Selam, Selam, İmralıya Bin Selam\").", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The group of twenty-three individuals began chanting the slogan \"Freedom to Öcalan\" (\"Öcalan'a Özgürlük\").", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The group of twenty-three individuals began chanting the slogan \"The messenger of peace is in İmralı\" (\"Barış elçisi İmralı'da\").", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Subsequently, some members of the group closed the door to the corridor of the third floor of the Sultanahmet Courthouse.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Some members of the group locked themselves in the corridor of the third floor of the Sultanahmet Courthouse by toppling metal cupboards behind the door.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Members of the group hung a large banner from one of the windows of the corridor of the third floor of the Sultanahmet Courthouse.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Members of the group threw leaflets outside from the corridor of the third floor of the Sultanahmet Courthouse.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The banner read: \"A democratic solution to the Kurdish problem; İmralı Prison must be shut down\" (\"Kürt sorununa demokratik çözüm, İmralı Cezaevi kapatılsın\").", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The banner also read: \"Youth Initiative for Social Peace\" (\"Toplumsal Barış için Gençlik Girişimi\").", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The leaflets thrown from the corridor contained critical remarks concerning the policies of the governing Justice and Development Party.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicants later submitted to the Istanbul Assize Court (the trial court) that they had locked themselves in the corridor.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicants later submitted to the Istanbul Assize Court (the trial court) that they had originally planned to make a press statement in front of the Sultanahmet Courthouse, but that they had entered the building owing to the rain.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicants submitted to the Istanbul Assize Court (the trial court) that they had attempted to go outside again to make the press statement, but that certain civilians had attacked them with a view to lynching them, forcing them to seek shelter in the closest corridor.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicants submitted to the Istanbul Assize Court (the trial court) that the door of the corridor had been shut behind them and that, as the door had only had one handle, they had not been able to open it from the corridor.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to witness statements, the protesters warned other individuals present in the corridor and inside the offices that they were going to stage a protest but that there was no need to be afraid.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Some witnesses locked themselves in the hearing rooms during the protest by blocking the entrances to those rooms.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Some witnesses locked themselves in the registries during the protest by blocking the entrances to those rooms.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Witnesses mainly reported hearing repetitive slogans being chanted outside in the corridor of the third floor of the Sultanahmet Courthouse.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Witnesses reported that they had come to no harm during the protest.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The incident report of 18 November 2003 drawn up by the Deputy Public Prosecutor of Istanbul indicated that no material damage had been caused in the corridor or to its furniture.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The protesters, including the applicants, continued their actions for about an hour until the police broke in and arrested them.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "According to the Government's version of events, the protesters resisted the police officers during their arrest by locking arms.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to the Government's version of events, the police used tear gas to disperse the protesters because the protesters had resisted by locking arms.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicants contested the Government's version of events, arguing that they had surrendered to the police but that they had nevertheless been beaten at the time of their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Following their arrest, the applicants were first taken to Haseki Hospital.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Following their arrest, the applicants were examined by the Forensic Medicine Institute.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the medical reports added to the case file, all of the applicants, except for Mehmet Şahin, Özgür Tan and Mahmut Cengiz, presented signs of physical trauma, either at the beginning or at the end of their custody.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The medical reports drawn up in respect of the applicant Ekrem Can at the beginning of his time in police custody did not note any signs of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The medical reports drawn up in respect of the applicant Fikret Avras at the beginning of his time in police custody did not note any signs of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The medical reports compiled at the end of the applicant Ekrem Can's time in police custody concluded that he had been unfit for work for a period of one day.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The medical reports compiled at the end of the applicant Fikret Avras's time in police custody concluded that he had been unfit for work for a period of one day.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Between 18 and 22 November 2003, the applicants were held in police custody on terrorism-related charges.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Between 18 and 22 November 2003, the applicants were interviewed by the Anti-Terrorism branch of the Istanbul Security Directorate.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to some documents in the case file, most of the applicants met their lawyer before giving statements to the police.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "According to some documents in the case file, most of the applicants met their lawyer after giving statements to the police.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "According to forms bearing the signature of each applicant (save for the applicant Mehmet Şahin), the applicants chose to give their statements without the presence of a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The forms bearing the applicants' signatures indicated that each applicant had been informed of his rights under Article 135 of the former Code of Criminal Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The forms bearing the applicants' signatures indicated that a copy of a form explaining their rights had been handed to each applicant.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The forms bearing the applicants' signatures did not bear the time at which they had been signed, but the dates were recorded by hand.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The applicant Mehmet Şahin was the only applicant who requested the assistance of a lawyer during the taking of his statement by the police.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "A certain A.P., who is not one of the applicants, also appears to have requested the assistance of a lawyer during the taking of his statement by the police.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The applicant Mehmet Şahin was interviewed in the presence of a lawyer and remained silent before the police.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "A.P. was interviewed in the presence of a lawyer and remained silent before the police.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The officers involved in the questioning of the applicant Mehmet Şahin and A.P. were not the same as those involved in the questioning of the other applicants.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicant Kerim Taştan exercised his right to remain silent without requesting the assistance of a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The rest of the applicants (other than Mehmet Şahin, A.P. and Kerim Taştan) gave statements to the police between 19 and 21 November 2003, in the absence of a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The statements of the applicants were transcribed on printed forms, the first page of which indicated inter alia that they were suspected of acting on behalf of the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan), an illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The first page of the printed forms used for the applicants' statements included a printed message stating inter alia that the person being questioned had the right to remain silent and the right to choose a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On each of the applicants' forms, the box entitled \"No lawyer sought\" was marked with a printed \"X\", indicating that all the applicants refused legal assistance.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "According to the police statement records, all the applicants except for one also stated that they did not wish to have a lawyer or to remain silent.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The applicant Fikret Avras met a lawyer on 19 November 2003 at 10.35 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicant Fikret Avras met a different lawyer on 21 November 2003 at 9.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The applicant Ekrem Can met a lawyer on 19 November 2003 at 11.20 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The applicants, except for Kerim Taştan and Mehmet Şahin (who did not give statements to the police), acknowledged having wilfully participated in the protest at the Sultanahmet Courthouse on 18 November 2003, pursuant to decisions made by the council of the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Many of the applicants acknowledged having taken part in other protests organised in support of the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 21 November 2003 the applicants Ekrem Can and Fikret Avras participated in an identity parade conducted with photographs (fotoğraftan teşhis).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The applicants Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras and Mahmut Cengiz were taken to certain locations for a reconstruction of the events in question (yer gösterme) on 21 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "During the reconstruction of events (yer gösterme), the applicants Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras and Mahmut Cengiz were not assisted by a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "During the reconstruction of events (yer gösterme), the applicants Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras and Mahmut Cengiz acknowledged having been involved in throwing Molotov cocktails at police vehicles on different occasions.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "During the reconstruction of events (yer gösterme), the applicants Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras and Mahmut Cengiz acknowledged having been involved in throwing stones at public buses on different occasions.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "During the reconstruction of events (yer gösterme), the applicants Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras and Mahmut Cengiz acknowledged having been involved in attacking a bank on different occasions.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The case file contains a copy of a handwritten record (tutanak) stating that on 18 November 2003 lawyer Suat Eren was assigned to represent the defendant Ekrem Can by the Istanbul Bar Association.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The first handwritten record (tutanak) stated that during a meeting held on 19 November 2003 at 11.34 a.m. at the Anti-Terrorism branch of the Istanbul Security Directorate, the defendant Ekrem Can stated that he would not give statements to the police.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The first handwritten record (tutanak) stated that during a meeting held on 19 November 2003 at 11.34 a.m. at the Anti-Terrorism branch of the Istanbul Security Directorate, the defendant Ekrem Can stated that he would not attend any investigative acts without a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The first handwritten record (tutanak) stated that during a meeting held on 19 November 2003 at 11.34 a.m. at the Anti-Terrorism branch of the Istanbul Security Directorate, the defendant Ekrem Can stated that he would exercise his right to remain silent.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The first handwritten record (tutanak) was prepared and signed by lawyer Suat Eren and Ekrem Can together on 19 November 2003 at 11.40 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The first handwritten record (tutanak) noted that despite the record of Ekrem Can's stated intentions, there exists a statement record showing that statements were taken from Ekrem Can.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The case file contains a copy of a second handwritten record (tutanak) stating that on 18 November 2003 lawyer Suat Eren was assigned by the Bar Association to represent the defendant Ekrem Can.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The second handwritten record (tutanak) stated that on 20 November 2003 at 9 p.m. lawyer Suat Eren attempted to hold a meeting with the defendant Ekrem Can on the premises of the Anti-Terrorism branch of the Istanbul police headquarters.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The second handwritten record (tutanak) stated that lawyer Suat Eren was prevented from meeting Ekrem Can on the basis that Ekrem Can was not present on the premises because he had been taken outside for the reconstruction of events.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The second handwritten record (tutanak) stated that lawyer Suat Eren had previously been prevented from holding meetings with clients using similar excuses.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The second handwritten record (tutanak) was signed by lawyer Suat Eren and lawyer Sami Almaz and was drawn up on 20 November 2003 at 9 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "At the end of their period in police custody on 22 November 2003, the applicants were taken to the Forensic Medicine Institute for medical examination.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "At the end of their period in police custody on 22 November 2003, it was found that the applicant Ekrem Can bore marks of physical trauma on different parts of his body that were not life-threatening.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "At the end of their period in police custody on 22 November 2003, it was found that the applicant Fikret Avras bore marks of physical trauma on different parts of his body that were not life-threatening.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "At the end of their period in police custody on 22 November 2003, it was found that the applicant Şenol Akyaz bore marks of physical trauma on different parts of his body that were not life-threatening.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "At the end of their period in police custody on 22 November 2003, it was found that the applicant Ahmet Işık bore marks of physical trauma on different parts of his body that were not life-threatening.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "At the end of their period in police custody on 22 November 2003, it was found that the applicant Güven Öztürk bore marks of physical trauma on different parts of his body that were not life-threatening.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "At the end of their period in police custody on 22 November 2003, it was found that the applicant Kerim Taştan bore marks of physical trauma on different parts of his body that were not life-threatening.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "At the end of their period in police custody on 22 November 2003, it was found that the applicant Muhlis Doğan bore marks of physical trauma on different parts of his body that were not life-threatening.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "At the end of their period in police custody on 22 November 2003, it was found that the applicant Yavuz Oğur bore marks of physical trauma on different parts of his body that were not life-threatening.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "At the end of their period in police custody on 22 November 2003, it was found that the applicant Esat Gezer bore marks of physical trauma on different parts of his body that were not life-threatening.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "At the end of their period in police custody on 22 November 2003, it was found that the applicant Abdulkerim Doğan bore marks of physical trauma on different parts of his body that were not life-threatening.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Medical reports drawn up in respect of the applicant Ekrem Can at the end of his custody indicated that he was unfit for work for one day, even though the medical reports compiled at the beginning of his custody indicated no such finding.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Medical reports drawn up in respect of the applicant Fikret Avras at the end of his custody indicated that he was unfit for work for one day, even though the medical reports compiled at the beginning of his custody indicated no such finding.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "On 22 November 2003 the applicants gave statements to the public prosecutor in the presence of their lawyers.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "All the applicants, except for the applicant Muhlis Doğan, contested the version of events to which they had confessed when being interviewed by the police, when giving statements to the public prosecutor on 22 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "All the applicants, except for the applicant Muhlis Doğan, contested the additional offences to which they had confessed when being interviewed by the police, when giving statements to the public prosecutor on 22 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The applicant Fikret Avras denied the accuracy of the records concerning the reconstruction of events when giving statements to the public prosecutor on 22 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The applicant Mahmut Cengiz denied the accuracy of the records concerning the reconstruction of events when giving statements to the public prosecutor on 22 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The applicants mainly stated to the public prosecutor on 22 November 2003 that they had agreed to take part in a peaceful protest concerning the \"Kurdish problem\".", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The applicants mainly stated to the public prosecutor on 22 November 2003 that they had locked themselves in the corridor of the third floor of the Sultanahmet Courthouse for fear of being forcibly dispersed by the police.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The lawyer of the applicant Ekrem Can informed the public prosecutor on 22 November 2003 that he had not been allowed to be present at the police interviews of his client or the reconstruction of events.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The lawyer of the applicant Fikret Avras informed the public prosecutor on 22 November 2003 that he had not been allowed to be present at the police interviews of his client or the reconstruction of events.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The lawyer of the applicant Yavuz Oğur informed the public prosecutor on 22 November 2003 that he had not been allowed to be present at the police interviews of his client or the reconstruction of events.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The lawyer of the applicant Osman Taşdemir informed the public prosecutor on 22 November 2003 that he had not been allowed to be present at the police interviews of his client or the reconstruction of events.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Subsequently on 22 November 2003, the applicants were questioned by a judge of the Istanbul State Security Court.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The applicants gave similar accounts of the event to the judge of the Istanbul State Security Court as those that they had given to the public prosecutor, affirming that they had had the intention of taking part in the making of a press statement in front of or inside the Sultanahmet Courthouse.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "As in his statements to the public prosecutor, the applicant Ekrem Can denied his affiliation with the group when questioned by the judge of the Istanbul State Security Court.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The lawyer of the applicant Fikret Avras requested the judge of the Istanbul State Security Court to bear in mind the fact that he had not been allowed to be present during the taking of statements by the police from his client or during the reconstruction of events.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "At the end of the questioning on 22 November 2003, the judge of the Istanbul State Security Court placed all the applicants in pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "On 10 December 2003 the Istanbul public prosecutor filed a bill of indictment against the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Istanbul public prosecutor charged the applicant Ekrem Can with membership of a terrorist organisation under Article 168 of the former Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Istanbul public prosecutor charged the applicant Fikret Avras with membership of a terrorist organisation under Article 168 of the former Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The Istanbul public prosecutor charged the applicant Mahmut Cengiz with membership of a terrorist organisation under Article 168 of the former Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The Istanbul public prosecutor charged the applicant Şenol Akyaz with membership of a terrorist organisation under Article 168 of the former Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The Istanbul public prosecutor charged the applicants Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras, Mahmut Cengiz and Şenol Akyaz with possessing and using explosive materials under Article 264 § 6 in fine of the former Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Istanbul public prosecutor charged the rest of the applicants (other than Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras, Mahmut Cengiz and Şenol Akyaz) with aiding and abetting a terrorist organisation under Article 169 of the former Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Istanbul public prosecutor charged all the applicants with \"interrupting public services through coercion, distortion or the commission of unlawful acts\" under Article 188 § 5 in fine of the former Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "At a hearing held on 19 April 2004, the applicants gave evidence to the Istanbul Assize Court (the trial court).", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The applicant Ekrem Can reiterated at the hearing on 19 April 2004 the statements that he had given to the public prosecutor, asserting that he had become caught up in the protest by mere accident.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The applicant Ekrem Can denied any affiliation with the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan) at the hearing on 19 April 2004.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The applicant Ekrem Can denied the charges against him at the hearing on 19 April 2004.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The applicant Mahmut Cengiz acknowledged at the hearing on 19 April 2004 that the applicants had planned to make a press statement in front of the Sultanahmet Courthouse regarding the fact that Abdullah Öcalan was being held in isolation in İmralı Prison.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The applicant Mahmut Cengiz stated at the hearing on 19 April 2004 that the applicants had gone inside the Sultanahmet Courthouse building owing to the rain.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The applicant Mahmut Cengiz maintained at the hearing on 19 April 2004 that the police had kept him awake over the course of the three days that he had been held in custody.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The applicant Mahmut Cengiz maintained at the hearing on 19 April 2004 that the police had forced him into signing certain documents, owing to the refusal of the police to allow him to see his lawyer despite his repeated requests.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The applicant Fikret Avras gave a similar version of events to that of Mahmut Cengiz at the hearing on 19 April 2004.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The applicant Fikret Avras submitted at the hearing on 19 April 2004 that he had been deprived of sleep during his time in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The applicant Fikret Avras submitted at the hearing on 19 April 2004 that police officers had slapped him every time that he had replied to their questions with a \"no\".", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The applicant Fikret Avras noted at the hearing on 19 April 2004 that he, Ekrem Can and Mahmut Cengiz had been taken to certain locations by car during the reconstruction of events.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The applicant Fikret Avras noted at the hearing on 19 April 2004 that one of the police officers had forcibly ejected him from the police vehicle and had then forced him — squeezing his arm — to admit while being recorded on video to committing crimes.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The rest of the applicants stated at the hearing on 19 April 2004 that they had planned to peacefully make a press statement in front of the Sultanahmet Courthouse.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "All the applicants, except for the applicants Mehmet Şahin and Kerim Taştan (who had not given statements to the police), retracted the statements that they had given to the police at the hearing on 19 April 2004.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The rest of the applicants stated to the Istanbul Assize Court (the trial court) at the hearing on 19 April 2004 that they had been subjected to pressure or ill-treated while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "At the hearing on 19 April 2004, the applicants' lawyers submitted to the Istanbul Assize Court (the trial court) that the incident had in fact comprised no more than the making of a simple press statement.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "At the hearing on 19 April 2004, the applicants' lawyers submitted to the Istanbul Assize Court (the trial court) that the applicants should not have been charged with terrorism-related offences.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "At the hearing on 19 April 2004, the applicants' lawyers submitted to the Istanbul Assize Court (the trial court) that even though they had been present at the police station during the time that the applicants had been held in custody, they had never been called by the police to take part in the interviews of their clients.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "At a hearing held on 1 November 2004, a number of witnesses gave evidence before the Istanbul Assize Court (the trial court).", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Witness M.A.İ. stated that he had been waiting his turn to attend a hearing before a court at the Sultanahmet Courthouse when a noisy quarrel had broken out in the corridor.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Witness M.A.İ. stated that after the clamour in the corridor had escalated, the judge had discontinued the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Witness M.A.İ. stated that the people in the hearing room had moved some cabinets behind the hearing room's door in order to securely block the entrance.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Witness M.A.İ. stated that he and others had been confined in the hearing room for a further forty-five minutes.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Witness M.A.İ. stated that the tear gas used to disperse the group had affected the people in the hearing room.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Witness M.A.İ. stated that the judge had postponed the rest of the proceedings scheduled for that day as a result of the incident.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "Witness G.İ., a clerk working for a court at the Sultanahmet Courthouse, attested that at around 10 a.m. on 18 November 2003 two individuals had come into the registry of that court, stating that they would give a statement in the corridor and would not harm anyone.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "Witness G.İ. stated that the group had first chanted PKK-related slogans and the name of Abdullah Öcalan.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "Witness G.İ. stated that she and the other people who had barricaded themselves into the hearing room had then unblocked the door and left the office after about an hour.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "Witness G.İ. stated that she had not identified any damage in the corridor after the incident.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "At the hearing held on 1 August 2005, the Istanbul Assize Court (the trial court) ordered the release of the applicants, except for the applicants Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras, Mahmut Cengiz and Şenol Akyaz.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "On 26 December 2006 the Istanbul Assize Court delivered its judgment in the case.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court found that the applicants had chanted certain slogans, waved a banner from the windows, and closed the door to the corridor, preventing officials from entering by placing metal cupboards behind the door to form a barricade, thereby trapping the lawyers and the court personnel and hampering them in the performance of their duties.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court found all the applicants guilty under Article 113 § 1 of the Criminal Code of \"interrupting public services through coercion, distortion or the commission of unlawful acts\".", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court sentenced each of the applicants to one year and eight months' imprisonment under Article 113 § 1 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court found all the applicants, except for Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras, Mahmut Cengiz and Şenol Akyaz, guilty under Article 169 of the former Criminal Code of aiding and abetting an armed gang.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court sentenced each of the applicants convicted under Article 169 of the former Criminal Code to three years and nine months' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court found the applicants Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras, Mahmut Cengiz and Şenol Akyaz guilty of membership of an armed terrorist organisation under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court sentenced the applicants Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras, Mahmut Cengiz and Şenol Akyaz each to six years and three months' imprisonment under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The conviction of the applicants Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras, Mahmut Cengiz and Şenol Akyaz under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code was based on their actions within the Sultanahmet Courthouse and on certain other activities.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The other activities relied upon for the conviction of Şenol Akyaz under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code included procuring new members for the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan), which had been proved by the statements he had made during the police interviews and the reconstruction of events.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The other activities relied upon for the conviction of Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras and Mahmut Cengiz under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code included throwing Molotov cocktails, which had been proved by the statements they had made during the police interviews and the reconstruction of events.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court convicted the applicant Ekrem Can on two counts of possessing explosive materials under Article 174 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court convicted the applicant Ekrem Can on two counts of using explosive materials under Article 170 § 1 (c) of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court sentenced the applicant Ekrem Can to an additional term of eight years and four months' imprisonment and a judicial fine for the offences of possessing and using explosive materials.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court convicted the applicant Mahmut Cengiz of possessing and using explosive materials under Articles 174 and 170 § 1 (c) of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court convicted the applicant Fikret Avras of possessing and using explosive materials under Articles 174 and 170 § 1 (c) of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court sentenced the applicant Mahmut Cengiz to four years and two months' imprisonment and a judicial fine for possessing and using explosive materials.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court sentenced the applicant Fikret Avras to four years and two months' imprisonment and a judicial fine for possessing and using explosive materials.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "On 18 March 2009, following an appeal by the applicants, the Court of Cassation partially upheld and partially quashed the Istanbul Assize Court's judgment.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "The Court of Cassation upheld the convictions of the applicants Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras, Mahmut Cengiz and Şenol Akyaz under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "The Court of Cassation upheld the convictions of the applicants Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras and Mahmut Cengiz under Article 174 § 1 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "The Court of Cassation upheld the convictions of the rest of the applicants under Article 169 of the former Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "The Court of Cassation quashed the convictions of all the applicants under Article 113 § 1 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "The Court of Cassation quashed the convictions of the applicants Ekrem Can, Fikret Avras and Mahmut Cengiz for using explosive materials under Article 170 § 1 (c) of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "Following the Court of Cassation's partial quashing, the case file was remitted to the Istanbul Assize Court (the trial court) in respect of the convictions that were quashed.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "On 3 February 2010 the applicants lodged their application with the Court while the proceedings were still pending before the Istanbul Assize Court (the trial court).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "On 30 June 2010 the Istanbul Assize Court once again convicted all the applicants under Article 113 § 1 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "On 30 June 2010 the Istanbul Assize Court sentenced each of the applicants to one year and eight months' imprisonment under Article 113 § 1 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "On 30 June 2010 the Istanbul Assize Court convicted the applicant Ekrem Can on two counts of using explosive materials under Article 170 § 1 (c) of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "On 30 June 2010 the Istanbul Assize Court sentenced the applicant Ekrem Can to ten months' imprisonment under Article 170 § 1 (c) of the Criminal Code for using explosive materials.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "On 30 June 2010 the Istanbul Assize Court convicted the applicant Fikret Avras under Article 170 § 1 (c) of the Criminal Code for throwing Molotov cocktails.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "On 30 June 2010 the Istanbul Assize Court convicted the applicant Mahmut Cengiz under Article 170 § 1 (c) of the Criminal Code for throwing Molotov cocktails.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "On 30 June 2010 the Istanbul Assize Court sentenced the applicant Fikret Avras to five months' imprisonment under Article 170 § 1 (c) of the Criminal Code for throwing Molotov cocktails.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "On 30 June 2010 the Istanbul Assize Court sentenced the applicant Mahmut Cengiz to five months' imprisonment under Article 170 § 1 (c) of the Criminal Code for throwing Molotov cocktails.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "On 2 April 2012 the Court of Cassation upheld the Istanbul Assize Court's judgment of 30 June 2010 in so far as it concerned the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "The relevant domestic law as in force at the material time, as well as the case-law of the Constitutional Court regarding the issue of waiver of the right to a lawyer, may be found in Ruşen Bayar v. Turkey (no. 25253/08, §§ 41-46, 19 February 2019).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "Article 113 § 1 of the Criminal Code provided that where the activities of a public institution are prevented by the use of violence or threats or by any other unlawful act, a penalty of imprisonment for a term of two to five years shall be imposed.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "Article 170 § 1 (c) of the Criminal Code provided that any person who acts in such a way that is capable of creating panic, fear or anxiety among the public or of endangering the life, health or property of the public by firing weapons or using explosives shall be sentenced to a penalty of imprisonment for a term of six months to three years.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F007", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F019", "F020", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F036", "F045", "F059", "F071", "F072", "F073", "F074", "F080", "F083", "F009", "F114", "F115", "F146", "F147", "F149", "F151", "F152", "F156", "F157", "F180", "F181"], "interference": ["F034", "F045", "F114", "F115", "F156", "F157", "F180", "F181"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F156", "F180", "F190"], "legitimate_aim": ["F007", "F008", "F009", "F017", "F018", "F029", "F030", "F034", "F144", "F146", "F148", "F151"], "necessity": ["F032", "F033", "F034", "F114", "F144", "F148", "F152", "F153", "F157", "F181"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F007", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F019", "F020", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F059", "F071", "F149"], "interference": ["F034", "F114", "F156", "F157", "F180", "F181"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F190", "F180"], "legitimate_aim": ["F008", "F017", "F018", "F029", "F030", "F144", "F148"], "necessity": ["F032", "F033", "F114", "F153", "F157", "F181"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F028", "F032", "F033", "F017", "F018", "F034", "F114", "F153", "F157", "F181", "F190", "F180"]}} {"case_name": "case_254", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1979.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Kazan.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 2 March 2017, Aleksey Navalnyy published on YouTube a documentary entitled \"Don't Call Him Dimon\".", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The documentary \"Don't Call Him Dimon\" denounced Prime Minister Mr Medvedev for alleged corruption.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Aleksey Navalnyy called on his supporters to protest on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Mr Navalnyy's followers in many towns notified the local authorities of their intention to hold public assemblies against corruption on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "In the majority of cases, the local authorities refused to allow the public assemblies against corruption planned for 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "According to media reports, between 32,000 and 93,000 people in ninety-seven towns took part in the country-wide anti-corruption protest on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Between 1,666 and 1,805 people were arrested and convicted of administrative offences in connection with the country-wide anti-corruption protest on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 14 March 2017, in response to the call by Mr Navalnyy to protest against corruption, the applicant notified the Kazan Town Administration of her intention to hold a meeting from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The meeting notified by the applicant on 14 March 2017 was expected to be attended by 150 people.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant proposed three alternative sites for the Kazan Town Administration to choose from for the meeting planned for 26 March 2017, including a specially designated location for holding public events in Krylya Sovetov Park.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The aim of the meeting notified by the applicant on 14 March 2017 was to protest against corruption and to demand Mr Medvedev's resignation.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 16 March 2017, the Kazan Town Administration refused to approve the meeting notified by the applicant on 14 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Kazan Town Administration's refusal of 16 March 2017 was based on the claim that other (unspecified) public events were scheduled at the locations chosen by the applicant at the same time.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicant challenged the Kazan Town Administration's refusal of 16 March 2017 before the Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 17 March 2017, the applicant and Mr B. notified the Kazan Town Administration of their intention to hold a \"picket\" (пикетирование) against corruption from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In the notification of 17 March 2017, the applicant proposed four alternative sites for the Kazan Town Administration to choose from for the \"picket\".", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 21 March 2017, the Kazan Town Administration refused to approve the \"picket\" notified on 17 March 2017, claiming that other (unspecified) public events were scheduled at the locations chosen by the applicant at the same time.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 21 March 2017, the Kazan Town Administration proposed another venue for the \"picket\" notified on 17 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 22 March 2017, the applicant accepted the venue proposed by the Kazan Town Administration for the \"picket\".", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 23 March 2017, the applicant published a message on VKontakte criticising the Kazan Town Administration for its decision not to allow the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "In the VKontakte message of 23 March 2017, the applicant stated that the Kazan Town Administration's decision of 16 March 2017 had been unlawful because the town administration had not proposed alternative locations for the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "In the VKontakte message of 23 March 2017, the applicant claimed that the Kazan Town Administration could not refuse to allow the meeting in Krylya Sovetov Park because it was a specially designated location for public events.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "In the VKontakte message of 23 March 2017, the applicant stated that if another event was scheduled at Krylya Sovetov Park, the Kazan Town Administration had to propose another time for the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "In the VKontakte message of 23 March 2017, the applicant stated that Krylya Sovetov Park was very large and there was enough space for several simultaneous events.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "In the VKontakte message of 23 March 2017, the applicant stated that the Kazan Town Administration's decision of 16 March 2017 had been challenged before a court and that the proceedings were still pending.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "In the VKontakte message of 23 March 2017, the applicant stated that people were entitled to assemble peacefully and that it had therefore been decided to hold a meeting in Krylya Sovetov Park at 2 p.m. on 26 March 2017 to protest against corruption.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The VKontakte message of 23 March 2017 ended with the following call: \"Invite your friends to join the group. We demand answers in the streets of Kazan! The meeting point is near the main entrance to Krylya Sovetov Park in Kopylova street, underground station Aviastroitelnaya.\"", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 24 March 2017, the Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan allowed the applicant's claim against the Kazan Town Administration's decision of 16 March 2017 in part.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan found that the regional branch of the \"United Russia\" party had earlier notified the Kazan Town Administration of its intention to hold public events from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. on 26 March 2017 at all three locations chosen by the applicant and at two other sites.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan found that in the circumstances where the regional branch of the \"United Russia\" party had notified the Kazan Town Administration of events at the same locations, the town administration was required to provide the applicant with well-reasoned proposals for changing the location or time of her intended meeting.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan found that the Kazan Town Administration had not made any well-reasoned proposals for changing the location or time of the applicant's intended meeting.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan found that the Kazan Town Administration's failure to propose an alternative location or time for the applicant's event had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 24 March 2017, the Kazan department of internal affairs warned the applicant that if she held a public event at one of the locations indicated in her notifications of 14 and 17 March 2017, she would be held liable.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 26 March 2017, the applicant held a meeting at the specially designated location for public events in Krylya Sovetov Park.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the applicant, about 1,500 people attended the meeting held in Krylya Sovetov Park on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the applicant, the meeting held in Krylya Sovetov Park on 26 March 2017 lasted for about one hour and twenty minutes.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the Government, about 400 people participated in the meeting held in Krylya Sovetov Park on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the Government, during the meeting in Krylya Sovetov Park on 26 March 2017, the police used loudspeakers to order the participants to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the applicant, no announcements were made through loudspeakers during the meeting in Krylya Sovetov Park on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to the applicant, a police officer approached her during the meeting in Krylya Sovetov Park on 26 March 2017 and demanded that she stop the unlawful public event.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the applicant, she replied to the police officer's demand by referring to the Vakhitovskiy District Court's decision of 24 March 2017 and stating that the meeting was lawful.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the applicant, no further action was taken by the police until the end of the meeting in Krylya Sovetov Park on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's notification of a public event in Kazan"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant was arrested on her way home after the meeting in Krylya Sovetov Park at about 4.20 p.m. on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "After her arrest on 26 March 2017, the applicant was taken to a nearby police station.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The police immediately drew up a report stating that the applicant had been escorted to the police station so that a report on an administrative offence could be drawn up.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "An arrest record drawn up at the same time as the escort report stated that the applicant had been arrested \"in connection with an administrative offence [sic.] under Articles 20.2 § 2 [and] 19.3 § 1 [of the Code of Administrative Offences] for examination of the case\".", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "At 6 p.m. on 26 March 2017, the police drew up a report on an administrative offence under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In the report under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences, the police noted that the applicant had organised an unauthorised public event.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "In the report under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences, the police noted that the applicant had published a message on VKontakte calling for participation in the meeting in Krylya Sovetov Park on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In the report under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences, the police noted that the applicant had held a meeting from 2 to 3 p.m. on 26 March 2017 in which about 400 people had participated.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "In the report under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences, the police noted that the applicant had notified the Kazan Town Administration of her intention to hold a meeting in Krylya Sovetov Park but that the town administration had refused to allow the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In the report under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences, the police noted that the applicant had been allowed to hold a \"picket\" at another location.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In the report under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences, the police stated that by holding an unauthorised meeting in Krylya Sovetov Park, the applicant had breached the requirements of section 4 paragraphs 4 and 5 of the Public Assemblies Act and had thereby committed an offence under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "At 6 p.m. on 26 March 2017, the police also drew up a report on an administrative offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The report on the administrative offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences repeated verbatim the report on the administrative offence under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The report on the administrative offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences added that the applicant had been warned by the Kazan department of internal affairs that she would be held liable if she went ahead with a public event at a location which had not been approved by the Kazan Town Administration.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The report on the administrative offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences stated that the applicant had held the meeting in Krylya Sovetov Park at 2 p.m. on 26 March 2017 despite the warning from the Kazan department of internal affairs.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The report on the administrative offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences stated that the police had ordered the applicant to stop the meeting but she had not taken any actions to comply with that order, and that the meeting had lasted until about 3 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The report on the administrative offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences stated that the applicant had disobeyed a lawful order of the police and had thereby committed an offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicant was released from the police station at 8.35 p.m. on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 27 March 2017, the Aviastroitelnyy District Court of Kazan, in two separate judgments, found the applicant guilty of offences under Articles 19.3 and 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Aviastroitelnyy District Court of Kazan found that the applicant had organised an unauthorised public event, including by publishing a message on VKontakte calling for participation.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Aviastroitelnyy District Court of Kazan found that the applicant had refused to obey a lawful order given by the police to stop the unauthorised public event.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Aviastroitelnyy District Court of Kazan noted that the applicant had notified the Kazan Town Administration of her intention to hold a meeting in Krylya Sovetov Park but that the town administration had refused to allow the meeting and had proposed that she hold a \"picket\" at another location.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Aviastroitelnyy District Court of Kazan noted that the applicant had been warned by the Kazan department of internal affairs that she would be held liable if she went ahead with the public event at locations which had not been approved by the Kazan Town Administration.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Aviastroitelnyy District Court of Kazan noted that the applicant had held the meeting in Krylya Sovetov Park despite the warning from the Kazan department of internal affairs.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Aviastroitelnyy District Court of Kazan noted that the police had ordered the applicant to stop the meeting but she had not complied with that order.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Aviastroitelnyy District Court of Kazan did not reply to the applicant's argument that the Kazan Town Administration's decision of 16 March 2017 refusing to approve the meeting had been annulled on judicial review and that the meeting had therefore to be considered as authorised and lawful, and the police's order to stop it unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Aviastroitelnyy District Court of Kazan sentenced the applicant to a fine of 1,000 Russian roubles under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Aviastroitelnyy District Court of Kazan sentenced the applicant to twenty hours of community work under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The applicant appealed against the judgments of 27 March 2017 of the Aviastroitelnyy District Court of Kazan.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "In her appeal, the applicant reiterated her argument that the meeting organised by her had been duly notified and therefore lawful, and that the police's order to stop it had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "In her appeal, the applicant referred to the decision of 24 March 2017 by the Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan declaring unlawful the Kazan Town Administration's decision of 16 March 2017 refusing to approve the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "In her appeal, the applicant submitted that under Article 227 § 8 of the Code of Administrative Procedure, the Vakhitovskiy District Court's decision of 24 March 2017 was subject to immediate enforcement.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "In her appeal, the applicant referred to a Constitutional Court ruling of 14 February 2013 that a public event was considered to be approved not only after receipt by the organiser of the local authorities' express approval, but also if the local authorities had not provided the organiser with a well-reasoned proposal for a change of location or time of the event within the statutory time-limit.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "In her appeal, the applicant argued that the public event had not created any risk to people's lives or health or to the property of persons or legal entities.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "In her appeal, the applicant argued that the participants had not committed any unlawful acts or breached the procedure for the conduct of public events established by the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "In her appeal, the applicant argued that there had been no lawful grounds to stop the public event.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 17 May 2017, the Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic upheld both judgments of 27 March 2017 of the Aviastroitelnyy District Court of Kazan on appeal, finding them lawful, well reasoned and justified.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic held that the applicant's and her counsel's arguments that she was innocent and had been unlawfully charged under Articles 19.3 and 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences were unsubstantiated and based on an incorrect interpretation of the applicable legal provisions and an incorrect assessment of the facts.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic held that the evidence cumulatively showed that the applicant had disobeyed a lawful order by a police officer who was fulfilling his duty to safeguard public order and ensure public safety.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic concluded that the organiser of the public event had not fully complied with the procedure for organising and holding public events, which rendered the public event unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic held that the judicial decision finding the Kazan Town Administration's failure to act unlawful did not amount to an unconditional approval of the location and time of the public event and did not exempt the organiser from fulfilling the obligations imposed by the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic held that the judicial decision finding the Kazan Town Administration's failure to act unlawful did not transform an unauthorised public event into an authorised one.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic held that the police officer acted within the powers provided by law with the aim of fulfilling his duty to ensure public safety and order, and that his order to stop the public event addressed to its organiser could be considered lawful in accordance with the Police Act.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic held that the argument that the public event was to be considered as approved if the local authorities had not provided the organiser with a well-reasoned proposal for a change of location or time within the statutory time-limit was invalid in the present case.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic found that the aim of the public event indicated in the notification (against corruption and for Prime Minister Medvedev's resignation) differed from the real aim of the public event and the aim declared during preliminary campaigning for that event.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic noted that on 23 March 2017 the applicant had published on her VKontakte personal page campaigning material about the forthcoming public event at 2 p.m. on 26 March 2017 in Krylya Sovetov Park, which stated: \"26 March is a nationwide protest day against corruption by Russian high-ranking officials. #whereisDimon#lookforDimon. Friends, we have the right to assemble peacefully, to discuss. It has therefore been decided to hold the meeting in Krylya Sovetov Park ...\".", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "On 12 July 2017, the Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan found the applicant guilty of an offence under Article 20.2 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan noted that the applicant had given oral submissions and had pleaded not guilty at the hearing on 12 July 2017.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan found that on 23 March 2017 the applicant had published a message on VKontakte calling for participation in a meeting to be held on 26 March 2017 in Krylya Sovetov Park, despite the fact that the Kazan Town Administration had refused to approve that meeting and had suggested that the applicant should hold a \"picket\" at another location.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan found that the applicant had campaigned for participation in the public event before it had been approved by the competent regional or municipal authorities, contrary to the applicable law.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan ordered the applicant to pay a fine of 10,000 Russian roubles for the offence under Article 20.2 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "On 9 August 2017, the Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic upheld the judgment of 12 July 2017 of the Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan on appeal, finding that it had been lawful, well reasoned and justified.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic held that section 10 § 1 of the Public Events Act expressly prohibited organisers from campaigning for participation in a public event before it had been approved by the competent local authorities.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic held that the applicant had breached the prohibition in section 10 § 1 of the Public Events Act against campaigning for participation in a public event before it had been approved by the competent local authorities.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "In its judgment of 9 August 2017, the Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic repeated verbatim the parts of its judgment of 17 May 2017 relating to the applicant's guilt.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The applicant attended the hearing of 9 August 2017 before the Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic and made oral submissions.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest and the administrative-offence proceedings against her"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On 12 September 2017, the Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan dismissed the applicant's claim in respect of non-pecuniary damage caused by the Kazan Town Administration's unlawful failure to propose alternative locations for the meeting of 26 March 2017, as established by the judgment of 24 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan found that the applicant had not proved that she had suffered non-pecuniary damage as a result of the Kazan Town Administration's failure to propose alternative locations for the meeting of 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "On 14 December 2017, the Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic upheld the Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan's judgment of 12 September 2017 on appeal, finding that it had been lawful, well reasoned and justified.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic added that on 21 March 2017 the Kazan Town Administration had proposed an alternative location for the public event planned by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Tatarstan Republic found that the applicant had not substantiated her argument that the Kazan Town Administration's proposal of 21 March 2017 concerned another public event.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "For a summary of the domestic provisions on the procedure for the notification and conduct of public events, on relevant judicial review procedures and on the liability for breaches committed in the course of public events, see Lashmankin and Others v. Russia, nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, § 216-312, 7 February 2017.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The applicable domestic provisions on public events have since been interpreted by the Russian Supreme Court in Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 deals with the application of legislation governing public events during judicial examination of administrative complaints and administrative-offence cases.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that a refusal to approve a public event, its location or time or the manner in which it is to be conducted may be challenged before a court either by the event organiser or by a person appointed by the organiser to fulfil certain organisational tasks (point 2).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that when examining administrative complaints about refusals to approve public events, courts must examine whether the interference by a public authority with the right to freedom of public assembly was lawful, necessary and proportionate to a legitimate aim (point 9).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that courts must examine all the grounds advanced by the public authority and all the evidence submitted by it, and assess whether the reasons for the interference were relevant and sufficient (point 9).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that courts must verify whether the proposal to change the location or time of a public event or the manner of conducting it was made within the three-day statutory time-limit (point 10).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that failure to comply with the three-day statutory time-limit for proposing a change of location or time means that the public event must be considered to be approved by default (point 10).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that courts must take into account that a proposal to change the location or time of a public event or the manner of conducting it must not be arbitrary or unreasoned, and must mention specific facts showing that public interest considerations make it manifestly impossible to hold the public event at the chosen location or time (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that valid public interest considerations for changing the location or time of a public event may include: normal functioning of essential public utilities, social and transport infrastructure and communications; maintenance of public order and safety of citizens; disruption of pedestrians or traffic or of citizens' access to residential premises or to social or transport facilities; and other similar considerations (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that inconvenience caused to citizens by a public event or an assumption by the authorities that there might be a risk of such inconvenience may not in themselves be considered valid reasons for changing the location or time of a public event (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that a necessity to temporarily divert pedestrians or traffic may not be considered a valid reason for changing the location or time of a public event, provided that it is possible to ensure that the traffic and the conduct of everyone involved in the event will comply with the established rules and will not lead to traffic accidents (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that disruption of pedestrians or traffic or a risk of disruption of essential public utility services may be considered valid reasons for proposing to change the location or time of a public event, provided that holding the public event will breach traffic or public transport safety requirements or limit citizens' access to residential premises or public facilities, irrespective of measures taken by the public authority to ensure compliance with such requirements (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that the public authority must submit to the court evidence of specific facts making it impossible to hold the public event at the chosen location or time, and that courts may not take into account any circumstances which were not mentioned in the proposal to change the location or time of the public event (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that courts should take into account that the public authority must suggest a specific alternative location and time for the public event compatible with its purposes and its social and political significance (point 13).", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that if approval was denied because it was prohibited to hold public events at the chosen location, the public authority may suggest an alternative location for that event (point 13).", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that the organiser must reply in writing, stating whether he or she accepts the proposed alternative location and/or time, no later than three days before the planned date of the event, and may also propose another location or time for approval (point 13).", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that if the organiser wants to change the date of the event, he must submit a new notification (point 13).", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that public events held at private premises with unrestricted public access (such as shopping malls) must be notified to the public authority, and the organiser must enclose with the notification the consent to the public event signed by the premises' owner (points 8 and 14).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that it is not necessary to notify a public event planned at a specially designated location for public events, provided that the number of participants does not exceed the number permitted for each such location by regional law (point 15).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that the organiser of a public event at a specially designated location must ensure the safety of participants and must make enquiries about any other events planned at the same location at the same time, to make sure that the maximum capacity of the location will not be exceeded (point 15).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that the fact that the organiser informed the public authority about the intended public event will be taken into account if he or she is held liable for failure to ensure public order and safety (point 15).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that the public authority may propose a change of location or time of a public event to be held at a specially designated location and not requiring notification only if another public event has been scheduled to take place at the same location and time and either (i) the number of participants of the two simultaneous events will exceed the maximum capacity of the location, or (ii) it will not be possible to ensure the peaceful character of the simultaneous events by applying security arrangements habitually used at public events with a comparable number of participants (point 15).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that a cultural event, a fair or some other mass event not falling under the Public Events Act, scheduled to take place at the same specially designated location at the same time, may not in itself serve as lawful grounds for proposing to change the location or time of a public event (point 16).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that a cultural event, a fair or other mass event not falling under the Public Events Act may serve as lawful grounds for proposing to change the location or time of a public event only if information about that mass event was duly published and it will not be possible to ensure safety at the two events if they are held simultaneously (point 16).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that if a court allowed the administrative complaint before the planned date of the public event, it may require the public authority not to impede the public event at the location and time chosen by the organisers (point 20).", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that if the public authority has submitted evidence showing that new grounds objectively preventing holding the public event at the chosen location or time arose after the contested decision, the court may require that the public authority re-examine the issue of the event's location, time or the manner in which it is to be conducted within a certain time-limit (point 20).", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F036", "F010", "F037", "F039"], "interference": ["F014", "F045", "F063", "F071", "F072"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F014", "F015", "F033", "F034", "F063", "F070", "F085", "F086", "F106"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F036", "F063", "F071", "F072", "F034", "F014"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F036"], "interference": ["F014", "F045", "F063"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F034", "F063", "F070", "F085"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F034", "F072"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F036", "F034", "F014", "F063", "F045", "F085"]}} {"case_name": "case_255", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1979.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant is a person with a Category 2 disability.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant is an independent journalist.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant is the chairman of the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety (IRFS), a non-governmental organisation specialising in the protection of journalists' rights.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant worked as a reporter for the news agency Turan Information Agency.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 14 June 2008 a group called the 'Che Guevara Fan Club' held a gathering at a private café in Baku to celebrate the eightieth anniversary of the birth of Che Guevara.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The café where the gathering was held on 14 June 2008 was located in the basement of a building in the city centre of Baku.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "There were about twenty-five attendees at the gathering held by the 'Che Guevara Fan Club' on 14 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicant attended the gathering held by the 'Che Guevara Fan Club' on 14 June 2008, accompanied by two colleagues from the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety (IRFS), R.A. and M.H.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The gathering held by the 'Che Guevara Fan Club' on 14 June 2008 began at noon.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Approximately thirty minutes after the gathering began on 14 June 2008, about thirty police officers entered the café.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Some of the police officers who entered the café on 14 June 2008 were in police uniform and others were in plain clothes.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The police officers who entered the café on 14 June 2008 suspended the gathering and announced that they were going to take the attendees to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant identified himself to the police officers, informing them that he was a journalist and the chairman of the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety (IRFS).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicant had with him his identity card and the card confirming that he was the chairman of the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety (IRFS) at the time of the police intervention on 14 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant asked the police officers to identify themselves and to release his arrested colleagues on 14 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant informed the Turan Information Agency by telephone about the police intervention on 14 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "In response to the applicant's actions, one of the police officers, who was apparently in charge of the intervention on 14 June 2008, ordered other police officers to take the applicant to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the applicant, he was taken to a police car by four police officers on 14 June 2008, who used force against him.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the applicant, the four police officers who took him to the police car on 14 June 2008 punched and kicked him in the stomach.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant relied on written eyewitness statements from R.A. dated 23 June 2008 and M.H. dated 24 June 2008 in support of his version of events.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "R.A. and M.H. confirmed in their written eyewitness statements that the applicant had informed the police officers that he was a journalist and the chairman of the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety (IRFS) before asking the police officers to release them.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "R.A. and M.H. confirmed in their written eyewitness statements that a police officer had instructed other police officers to arrest the applicant and that those officers had used force against him while taking him to a police car.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "After his arrival at the police station on 14 June 2008, the applicant was separated from the others who had been arrested and was taken to the office of the Deputy Head of Nasimi District Police Station no. 22, A.K.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Four police officers entered the room of the Deputy Head of Nasimi District Police Station no. 22, A.K., and threatened the applicant in the presence of A.K. on 14 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicant, one of the police officers in the room of the Deputy Head of Nasimi District Police Station no. 22, O.A., shouted at the applicant and took out his gun on 14 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the applicant, police officer O.A. hit his gun on the table and shouted 'I can eliminate you', 'I can arrest you', 'I can send you to jail' on 14 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the applicant, police officer O.A. pushed down the applicant's head by pressing on the back of his neck so that his head hit the table on 14 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicant warned police officer O.A. that he was a person with a Category 2 disability and that his health was fragile.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the applicant, police officer O.A. struck the applicant in the neck with his elbow on 14 June 2008, as a result of which the applicant lost consciousness.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant relied on the written eyewitness statements from R.A. and M.H. in support of his version of events regarding what occurred at Nasimi District Police Station no. 22.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "R.A. submitted in his witness statement that, when he was in the corridor of the police station, the applicant was taken to the office of the Deputy Head of Nasimi District Police Station no. 22.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "R.A. submitted in his witness statement that he heard someone shouting at the applicant 'I can eliminate you', 'I can send you to jail' while the applicant was in the office of the Deputy Head of Nasimi District Police Station no. 22.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "When the applicant regained consciousness on 14 June 2008, he asked the police officers to call an ambulance because he did not feel well.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The police officers allegedly refused to call an ambulance for the applicant but took him out of the room at Nasimi District Police Station no. 22.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant's colleagues saw him in the corridor of the police station and asked other members of the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety (IRFS) to call an ambulance.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant's colleagues informed the media about the applicant's alleged ill-treatment by the police.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Some journalists, human rights defenders and youth movement activists who had been informed of the arrest of the applicant and his colleagues began gathering in front of Nasimi District Police Station no. 22.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "At around 4 p.m. on 14 June 2008, two police officers accompanied the applicant to the door leading out of the police station.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicant was able to take only a few steps after leaving Nasimi District Police Station no. 22 and then again lost consciousness.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicant relied on written eyewitness statements from I.A. (journalist), R.H. (civil society activist) and M.A. (director of the Turan Information Agency), who were present in front of the police station at the time the applicant was brought out.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "I.A., R.H. and M.A. stated in their witness statements that when the applicant was taken out of the police station he was unconscious and was taken by an ambulance, which was called by them, to hospital.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "At 5.20 p.m. on 14 June 2008 the applicant was admitted to hospital with the diagnosis of traumatic brain injury and contusion of the soft tissues around the nape of his neck.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant remained in the intensive care unit of the hospital for four days following his admission on 14 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicant was released from hospital on 25 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The events of 14 June 2008 attracted significant public and media interest both inside Azerbaijan and internationally.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "A number of human rights organisations, including Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, expressed concern over the applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police following the events of 14 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International asked the domestic Azerbaijani authorities to conduct an effective investigation into the incident of 14 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "1. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "According to the Government, on 14 June 2008 the police intervened in the gathering at the café on the basis of a complaint from people living in the neighbourhood of the café, who complained about noise and the behaviour of those attending.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "2. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant and other attendees who were unable to produce their identity cards were taken to the police station but were released once their identity had been established.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "2. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "According to the Government, during his stay at the police station on 14 June 2008 the applicant was not ill-treated by the police.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 June 2008", "2. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "A criminal inquiry was launched by Nasimi District Police Station no. 22 in connection with information about the applicant's admission to the Clinical Medical Centre with injuries.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 15 June 2008 the applicant was questioned in hospital by an investigator from Nasimi District Police Station no. 22.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The applicant described in detail to the investigator the circumstances of his arrest and detention by the police on 14 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The applicant stated to the investigator that on 14 June 2008 he had attended the gathering commemorating the eightieth anniversary of the birth of Che Guevara, which had been interrupted by a police intervention.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicant stated to the investigator that when he protested about the arrest of his journalist colleagues on the orders of the police officer apparently in charge of the intervention, four police officers forcibly took him to a police car.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicant stated to the investigator that following his arrival at Nasimi District Police Station no. 22, he was taken to the room of the Deputy Head of the police station.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicant stated to the investigator that other police officers were also in the room of the Deputy Head of Nasimi District Police Station no. 22 and one of them, who was wearing black sunglasses, began insulting him and then threatening him, took out his gun and shouted at him.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The applicant stated to the investigator that the same police officer who was wearing black sunglasses struck him in the neck, as a result of which he lost consciousness, and that the police officers then took him out of the room.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 17 June 2008, while the criminal inquiry was still pending, the spokesman for the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Azerbaijan, E.Z., gave an interview to the Turan Information Agency concerning the applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment by the police.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The spokesman for the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Azerbaijan, E.Z., stated in the interview that the statements made to the media by the applicant, Emin Huseynov, alleging that he was subjected to duress by the police were not true.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The spokesman for the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Azerbaijan, E.Z., stated that even the allegations published in the media were contradictory.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The spokesman for the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Azerbaijan, E.Z., stated that on 14 June 2008 a group of people held an unauthorised gathering at a café and the police requested the interruption of the unauthorised gathering.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The spokesman for the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Azerbaijan, E.Z., stated that twenty people were taken to Nasimi District Police Station no. 22 in order to establish their identity and to conduct the relevant explanatory interviews (izahat işləri), and that they were all released following the explanatory interviews.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The spokesman for the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Azerbaijan, E.Z., stated that Emin Huseynov said he did not feel well at the police station and an ambulance was called immediately.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The spokesman for the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Azerbaijan, E.Z., stated that it was established during the medical examination that Emin Huseynov's health problem was related to his previous diseases and that he had lost consciousness because his blood pressure reached 190.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "According to the applicant, he was examined by a forensic expert in hospital on 18 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The forensic report dated 23 June 2008 states that the examination began on 15 June 2008 and ended on 20 June 2008, without specifying the exact date of the applicant's examination by the forensic expert in hospital.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The forensic report of 23 June 2008 recorded that the applicant, Emin Huseynov, stated during the inquiry that on 14 June 2008 a person he did not know had struck him in the neck in Nasimi District Police Station no. 22.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The forensic examination of the applicant was carried out in the resuscitation and intensive care unit of the Clinical Medical Centre of the Baku City Main Health Department in the presence of the lawyer Rashid Hajili.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "According to the applicant as recorded in the forensic report, at approximately 12.30 p.m. to 1 p.m. on 14 June 2008 during an event dedicated to the eightieth anniversary of the birth of Che Guevara in café Alaturka, plain clothes persons took him and other attendees to Nasimi District Police Station no. 22.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "According to the applicant as recorded in the forensic report, he was struck in his head at the time of being taken from café Alaturka and later at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The forensic report of 23 June 2008 found that no injuries or objective signs of injury (bruise, abrasion, wound, swelling, etc.) were noticed on the body of the applicant, Emin Huseynov.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The forensic report of 23 June 2008 found that the applicant's medical record no. 5190 from the Clinical Medical Centre of the Baku City Main Health Department showed that at 5.20 p.m. on 14 June 2008 the applicant, aged 29, was admitted to the resuscitation and intensive care unit with the diagnosis of traumatic brain injury and contusion of the soft tissues around the nape of the neck.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The forensic report of 23 June 2008 recorded that the applicant's general state upon admission to hospital was serious, with blood pressure of 190/120 mm Hg and heart pulse of 120 per minute, and that his conscious awareness was impaired to the point of deafness.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The forensic report of 23 June 2008 recorded that no injury was noticed on the applicant's skin upon admission to hospital and that the diagnosis was neurological reaction (nevrotik reaksiya).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The forensic report of 23 June 2008 recorded that on 15 June 2008 there was no pathological change in side projected X-ray examinations of the side and neck vertebras of the cranium of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The forensic report of 23 June 2008 recorded that the cerebral computed tomography opinion dated 17 June 2008 found that intraparenchymal traumatic pathological changes were not observed in the applicant, Emin Huseynov.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The forensic report of 23 June 2008 recorded that the computed tomography examination of 17 June 2008 revealed no pathological change in the neck area and no traumatic change in the neck part of the vertebral column of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The forensic report of 23 June 2008 recorded that the ultrasound examination of 17 June 2008 revealed no liquid in the abdomen and no hematoma in the parenchymal organs of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The forensic report of 23 June 2008 recorded that the applicant's illness was related to extended osteochondrosis of the vertebral column, numerous disc protrusions in the back and neck areas (C 4-5, C 5-6, C 6-7, L 3-4, L 5, S 1), chronic dyscirculatory encephalopathy and vestibulopathy.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The forensic report of 23 June 2008 concluded that the applicant's in-patient treatment was related to his previous diseases — extended osteochondrosis of the vertebral column, numerous disc protrusions in the back and neck areas (C 4-5, C 5-6, C 6-7, L 3-4, L 5, S 1), chronic dyscirculatory encephalopathy and vestibulopathy.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The forensic report of 23 June 2008 was prepared by forensic expert C.A.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The applicant was not provided with a copy of the forensic report dated 23 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On 25 June 2008 Nasimi District Police Station no. 22 issued an explanation (arayış) concerning the police intervention of 14 June 2008, signed by the Head of Nasimi District Police Station no. 22, M.T.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The explanation issued by Nasimi District Police Station no. 22 on 25 June 2008 stated that on 14 June 2008, at around 1 p.m., police officers from the Baku City Police Office took measures to identify persons gathered at café 'Alaturka' in the basement of building no. 6 at 28 May Street in Baku, and twenty-two of them were taken to Nasimi District Police Station no. 22.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The explanation issued by Nasimi District Police Station no. 22 on 25 June 2008 stated that after the individuals arrived at Nasimi District Police Station no. 22 at 1.55 p.m., they were registered in the 'apprehended persons' registration log' (gətirilmiş şəxslərin qeydiyyat kitabı) and were released at 4.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The explanation issued by Nasimi District Police Station no. 22 on 25 June 2008 stated that statements were taken from nine of the twenty-two individuals in order to establish the purpose of their gathering.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The explanation issued by Nasimi District Police Station no. 22 on 25 June 2008 stated that the individuals' identity was established and they were released following a 'prophylactic conversation' (profilaktik söhbət).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The explanation issued by Nasimi District Police Station no. 22 on 25 June 2008 stated that Huseynov Emin Rafik oglu, who presented a document stating that he was the chairman of the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety (IRFS), was among the persons apprehended.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "By a decision of 27 June 2008, the investigator refused to institute criminal proceedings, finding that there was no evidence that the applicant had been ill-treated by the police.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The investigator's decision of 27 June 2008 noted that the applicant was admitted to the Clinical Medical Centre with the diagnosis of neurological reaction at 5.20 p.m. on 14 June 2008, as established during the examination of the patients' reception log.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The investigator's decision of 27 June 2008 relied on forensic report no. 143/TM of 23 June 2008, which found no injuries or objective signs of injury on the applicant's body and concluded that the applicant's in-patient treatment was related to his previous diseases.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The investigator's decision of 27 June 2008 concluded that no criminal act had been established and that it was appropriate to refuse to institute criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The applicant was not informed of the decision of 27 June 2008 concerning the investigator's refusal to institute criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal inquiry"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "On 16 March 2009 the applicant lodged a criminal complaint with the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "In his criminal complaint to the Nasimi District Court, the applicant, relying on Articles 3, 5, 10 and 11 of the Convention, complained that he had been ill-treated by the police during his arrest and whilst in police custody, and that the domestic authorities had failed to conduct an effective investigation in this respect.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "In his criminal complaint to the Nasimi District Court, the applicant complained that he had been unlawfully deprived of his liberty and that the police intervention of 14 June 2008 had been unlawful and had constituted an unjustified interference with his rights to freedom of expression and assembly.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "In his criminal complaint to the Nasimi District Court, the applicant pointed out that the investigator had questioned neither the police officers who had been involved in the alleged ill-treatment nor the other witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The applicant stated in his criminal complaint that he had not learned about the existence of the investigator's decision of 27 June 2008 until 3 March 2009.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The applicant stated in his criminal complaint that he had never been provided with a copy of the forensic report dated 23 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "On 31 March 2009 the Nasimi District Court dismissed the applicant's criminal complaint, finding the investigator's decision of 27 June 2008 lawful.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Nasimi District Court's decision of 31 March 2009 was silent as to the applicant's particular complaints.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Nasimi District Court's decision of 31 March 2009 noted that the applicant was admitted to the Clinical Medical Centre with the diagnosis of neurological reaction at 5.20 p.m. on 14 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The Nasimi District Court's decision of 31 March 2009 noted that the forensic report found no injuries or objective signs of injury on the applicant's body and that the applicant's in-patient treatment was related to previous diseases he had suffered.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Nasimi District Court's decision of 31 March 2009 found that the investigator had taken all necessary steps in carrying out a preliminary examination in compliance with Article 207 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and had adopted a justified and lawful decision on refusal to institute criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "On 6 April 2009 the applicant appealed against the Nasimi District Court's decision of 31 March 2009, reiterating his previous complaints.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "In his appeal of 6 April 2009, the applicant complained that the investigator had not arranged an identity parade including police officer O.A.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "In his appeal of 6 April 2009, the applicant complained that the investigator had not questioned the police officers involved in his arrest and detention, and in particular the Deputy Head of Nasimi District Police Station no. 22 in whose room and in whose presence he had allegedly been ill-treated.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "In his appeal of 6 April 2009, the applicant complained that the investigator had failed to obtain video recordings from security cameras situated in Nasimi District Police Station no. 22.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "In his appeal of 6 April 2009, the applicant disputed the conclusions of the forensic report dated 23 June 2008, pointing out that he had not been provided with a copy of it.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "On 27 April 2009 the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the Nasimi District Court's decision of 31 March 2009.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "1. The criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The applicant lodged a civil action against the Nasimi District Police Office, asking for compensation.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "In his civil action against the Nasimi District Police Office, the applicant, relying on Articles 3, 5, 10 and 11 of the Convention, complained that he had been ill-treated by the police, that he had been arrested and taken to the police station unlawfully, and that the police intervention in the gathering had constituted an unlawful interference with his rights to freedom of expression and assembly.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "In support of his civil claim, the applicant relied on written eyewitness statements from R.A. and M.H., who stated that police officers had used force against the applicant during his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "R.A. and M.H. stated in their written eyewitness statements submitted in the civil proceedings that when the applicant was in the room of the Deputy Head of Nasimi District Police Station no. 22, they had heard someone shouting at the applicant 'I can eliminate you', 'I can send you to jail'.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "R.A. and M.H. stated in their written eyewitness statements submitted in the civil proceedings that when the applicant had been taken out of the room of the Deputy Head of Nasimi District Police Station no. 22, he did not feel well.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "On 25 July 2008 the Nasimi District Court refused to admit the applicant's civil action, finding that it did not comply with the procedural requirements for lodging a complaint.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "On 2 September 2008 the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the Nasimi District Court's decision of 25 July 2008 refusing to admit the applicant's civil action.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "On 17 November 2008 the Supreme Court of Azerbaijan quashed the Baku Court of Appeal's decision of 2 September 2008 and remitted the case to the lower courts for a new examination.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "On 17 June 2009 the Nasimi District Court, having examined the applicant's civil action on the merits, decided to dismiss it.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Nasimi District Court's judgment of 17 June 2009 found that the applicant had been taken to the police station because he had not had his identity card on him.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The Nasimi District Court's judgment of 17 June 2009 found that the police intervention had been lawful, since the gathering at the café in the city centre disturbed other people present.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The Nasimi District Court's judgment of 17 June 2009 found that it had not been established that the applicant had been ill-treated by the police.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Nasimi District Court's judgment of 17 June 2009 noted that an investigator from Nasimi District Police Station no. 22 had examined the fact that the applicant had sustained injuries and had decided to refuse to institute criminal proceedings because no criminal act had been established, and that this decision had not been challenged.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Nasimi District Court's judgment of 17 June 2009 found on the basis of witness statements that the applicant had been taken to Nasimi District Police Station no. 22 because he had not had his identity card on him, that he had been detained for a certain period of time, and that he had been released following the establishment of his identity.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The Nasimi District Court's judgment of 17 June 2009 found that the applicant had previously sustained brain injury and regularly underwent medical treatment in Azerbaijan and abroad for a long period of time, and that unexpected health problems had previously been observed in his case.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Nasimi District Court's judgment of 17 June 2009 found that the fact that the applicant had felt unwell after having been brought to the police station was not related to any duress but to his previous illness.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The Nasimi District Court's judgment of 17 June 2009 found that it was not established that the applicant had sustained a bodily injury or been subjected to physical violence, beaten or been under duress at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "On 3 August 2009 the applicant appealed against the Nasimi District Court's judgment of 17 June 2009, reiterating his previous complaints.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "On 14 October 2009 the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal against the Nasimi District Court's judgment of 17 June 2009.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "On 7 May 2010 the Supreme Court of Azerbaijan upheld the lower courts' judgments in the civil proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Remedies used by the applicant", "2. The civil proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Article 46 (III) of the Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan provides that no one shall be subjected to torture or ill-treatment and no one shall be subjected to degrading treatment or punishment.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Article 49 of the Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan provides that everyone has the right to freely assemble together with others.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Article 49 of the Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan provides that everyone has the right, upon notification to relevant Government bodies in advance, to assemble peacefully with others, without arms, and to hold rallies, meetings, demonstrations, street marches and pickets.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Article 207 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of Azerbaijan provides the rules concerning the examination of information about committed criminal offences by the investigating authorities.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCrP\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "In accordance with Article 207 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of Azerbaijan, an investigator or the prosecutor in charge of the case, after the examination of information about the commission of a criminal offence, should adopt a decision instituting criminal proceedings, refusing to institute criminal proceedings, or transferring the information to the relevant investigating authority or the court in case of private criminal prosecution.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCrP\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "In accordance with Article 212.2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of Azerbaijan, any person providing information about a committed or planned criminal offence should be provided within twenty-four hours with a copy of the investigator's decision concerning refusal to institute criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCrP\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Article 4.1 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 of Azerbaijan, as in force at the material time, provided that the right to hold gatherings in places which are in private ownership is not regulated by that Law.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Article 7 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 of Azerbaijan provides that any restriction on freedom of assembly may be put in place only by law and for the purposes of protecting interests necessary in a democratic society, including: protection of the interests of public and state security; preventing the disturbance of public order; prevention of disorder or crime; protection of the health of the population; protection of morals; and protection of the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Article 14 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 of Azerbaijan sets out the powers and duties of the police in connection with the holding of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "According to Article 14.I.3 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 of Azerbaijan, the police have the right to suspend an assembly, if necessary, when the conduct of the assembly does not satisfy the conditions provided in the prior written notification.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Article 14.II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 of Azerbaijan provides that the police have the right to inform organisers of and participants in an assembly of its suspension and dispersal, to order organisers and participants to use all available means for suspension of the assembly and dispersal of participants, to warn organisers and participants that force will be used if an order to suspend the assembly is not executed, and to use appropriate force to ensure the suspension of the assembly and the dispersal of the participants.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Article 14.6 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 of Azerbaijan provides that use of physical force or special equipment by the police should in all circumstances be proportional to the danger in question.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The Venice Commission (European Commission for Democracy through Law) issued Opinion no. 384/2006 (CDL-AD (2006)034) on the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 of Azerbaijan on 25 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The Venice Commission Opinion no. 384/2006 stated that Article 4.1 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 of Azerbaijan, which provides that peaceful assemblies in places in private ownership shall not be regulated by the Law, is positive in that assemblies on private property are exempted from any notification requirement as well as from all other requirements provided for in the Law.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The Venice Commission Opinion no. 384/2006 stated that Article 4.1 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 of Azerbaijan shall not be interpreted as prohibiting spontaneous assemblies on private property, and that if the assembly is peaceful it should be allowed.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENT"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F140"], "interference": ["F012", "F013", "F014", "F019", "F087"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F050", "F061", "F064", "F065", "F086", "F087", "F089", "F140", "F141", "F142"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F007", "F010", "F140"], "interference": ["F014", "F087"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F050", "F064", "F065", "F087", "F089", "F140"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F007", "F014", "F050", "F064", "F087", "F140"]}} {"case_name": "case_258", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1954.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Engelskirchen, Germany.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 7 April 2002 (first round) legislative elections took place in Hungary.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 21 April 2002 (second round) legislative elections took place in Hungary.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The coalition which had governed Hungary from 1998 had been in charge of organising the April 2002 legislative elections.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The coalition which had governed Hungary from 1998 lost their majority in the April 2002 legislative elections.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The official results of the April 2002 elections were established by the local and regional electoral commissions following the second round.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "After the courts had ruled on certain complaints concerning the legality and outcome of the voting procedure, on 4 May 2002 the National Election Committee made a public statement in the Official Gazette.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the National Election Committee's public statement in the Official Gazette on 4 May 2002, the result of the April 2002 elections had become final.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The final results of the April 2002 elections were virtually identical to the results of the exit poll carried out on the day of the second round (21 April 2002), as had been the case in previous Hungarian elections.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The final results of the April 2002 elections were virtually identical to the preliminary results announced by the National Election Committee on the evening of 21 April 2002, as had been the case in previous Hungarian elections.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Views were subsequently voiced in certain sections of the media that the April 2002 elections had been \"rigged\".", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "International observers, in particular the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), found that the April 2002 parliamentary elections in Hungary had been conducted in a manner consistent with international standards.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) found that the Hungarian election system had provided the basis for a generally transparent, accountable, free, fair and equal process in the April 2002 parliamentary elections.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "A period of two months elapsed after the April 2002 elections during which a new government was formed in a coalition of the ex-opposition parties.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The new coalition government of ex-opposition parties took up its functions on 27 May 2002.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On the morning of Thursday, 4 July 2002, several hundred demonstrators started to protest against the statutory destruction of the ballots from the April 2002 elections, which was scheduled for 20 to 22 July 2002.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On the morning of 4 July 2002, the demonstrators blocked the centrally located Erzsébet Bridge in Budapest with their cars.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The objective of the demonstrators who blocked Erzsébet Bridge on 4 July 2002 was to force a recount of the April 2002 election votes.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The demonstrators who blocked Erzsébet Bridge on 4 July 2002 brought traffic to a complete standstill.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The demonstrators who blocked Erzsébet Bridge on 4 July 2002 had not given prior notice of their gathering to the police, as required by Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly (the Assembly Act).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The demonstration at Erzsébet Bridge on the morning of 4 July 2002 was dispersed after several hours.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Shortly after the dispersal of the Erzsébet Bridge demonstration, at around 1 p.m. on 4 July 2002, more demonstrators assembled at Kossuth Square in front of the Parliament building in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The demonstrators who assembled at Kossuth Square at around 1 p.m. on 4 July 2002 did so without any prior notification to the police.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The demonstrators at Kossuth Square on 4 July 2002 demanded a recount of the April 2002 election votes.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The demonstrators at Kossuth Square on 4 July 2002 expressed their support for the participants in the morning's events at Erzsébet Bridge.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the applicant's submissions of 14 February 2005 and the Government's observations, the demonstrators at Kossuth Square on 4 July 2002 had been at the Erzsébet Bridge and then relocated to Kossuth Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "In her submissions of 23 December 2007, the applicant stated that the demonstrators at Kossuth Square on 4 July 2002 had merely been supporters of those who had blocked the Erzsébet Bridge, rather than the same individuals.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Having learnt of the events at Kossuth Square from the news, the applicant joined the demonstration at Kossuth Square at around 7 p.m. on 4 July 2002.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "By the time the applicant joined the demonstration at Kossuth Square at around 7 p.m. on 4 July 2002, traffic and public transport — including the circulation of trams and trolley-buses — had become seriously disrupted in the area of Kossuth Square.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The estimated number of demonstrators at Kossuth Square on 4 July 2002 ranged from several hundred to two or three thousand.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The police initially attempted to allow the circulation of traffic to continue during the Kossuth Square demonstration on 4 July 2002.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The police eventually had to close some streets nearby Kossuth Square during the demonstration on 4 July 2002.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Faced with an unmanageable situation, the police broke up the Kossuth Square demonstration at about 9 p.m. on 4 July 2002 without using any force.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicant participated in the Kossuth Square demonstration on 4 July 2002 until it was dispersed at about 9 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Hungarian media reported in detail on the events of 4 July 2002, and the affair was the leading news in the country.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "In an official communiqué, the President of the Republic of Hungary condemned the events of 4 July 2002, declaring them illegal.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "In his official communiqué, the President of the Republic of Hungary underlined that Hungary was a stable parliamentary democracy where human rights were observed and where even critical views should be voiced in a lawful manner.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicant sought judicial review of the actions of the police before the Budapest Central District Court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicant asserted before the Budapest Central District Court that the dispersal of the Kossuth Square demonstration on 4 July 2002 had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 1 October 2003 the Budapest Central District Court dismissed the applicant's claim.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Budapest Central District Court established that the duty to inform the police about planned assemblies was applicable to every type of demonstration, including spontaneous ones.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant did not deny that the Kossuth Square demonstration on 4 July 2002 had not been notified to the police, as required by section 14 of Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly (the Assembly Act).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Budapest Central District Court found that, since the Kossuth Square demonstration had not been notified to the police as required by section 14 of the Assembly Act, the police had not had any other choice but to break it up.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Budapest Central District Court found that the duty to inform the police in advance about assemblies held in public served the protection of the public interest and the rights of others, namely the prevention of disorder and the undisturbed circulation of traffic.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Budapest Central District Court concluded that the measures taken by the police in dispersing the Kossuth Square demonstration on 4 July 2002 had been in compliance with the law.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant appealed against the Budapest Central District Court's decision of 1 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 13 July 2004 the Budapest Regional Court upheld the first-instance decision of the Budapest Central District Court dismissing the applicant's claim.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court's judgment of 13 July 2004 was served on the applicant's lawyer on 31 August 2004.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Article 62 of the Constitution of the Republic of Hungary (Act no. 20 of 1949 as amended) provides: \"The Republic of Hungary acknowledges the right to peaceful assembly and secures its free exercise.\"", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law", "1. The Constitution of the Republic of Hungary"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Section 2(3) of Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly (the Assembly Act) provides that the exercise of freedom of assembly shall not constitute a crime or an incitement to crime, and moreover, it should not result in the infringement of the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law", "2. Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Section 6 of Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly (the Assembly Act) provides that the organisation of an event held in the public domain shall be notified to the competent police headquarters according to the place of the event, and in Budapest to the Budapest Police Headquarters, three days prior to the planned date of the event, and that the obligation to notify the police lies with the organiser of the event.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law", "2. Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Section 8(1) of Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly (the Assembly Act), as in force at the relevant time, provides that if the holding of an event subject to prior notification seriously endangers the proper functioning of the representative bodies or courts, or results in a disproportionate hindrance of the circulation of traffic, the police may ban the holding of the event at the place or time indicated in the notification, within 48 hours from the receipt of the notification by the authority.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law", "2. Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Section 9(1) of Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly (the Assembly Act) provides that no appeal shall lie against the decision of the police, but the organiser may seek judicial review of the administrative decision within three days of its notification.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law", "2. Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Section 14(1) of Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly (the Assembly Act), as in force at the relevant time, provides that the police shall disperse an event if the exercise of the right to freedom of assembly contravenes section 2(3) of the Assembly Act, or if the participants appear at the event in possession of arms, or if an event subject to prior notification is held without notification, or despite a decision banning the event.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law", "2. Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Section 14(3) of Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly (the Assembly Act), as in force at the relevant time, provides that if an event is dispersed, the participants may seek judicial review within fifteen days with a view to the establishment of the illegality of the dispersal.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law", "2. Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": false, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F030", "F035", "F025"], "interference": ["F035", "F036"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F056", "F044", "F053", "F054", "F055"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F009", "F010", "F016", "F019", "F021", "F022", "F027", "F026", "F024", "F030", "F035", "F025", "F033", "F031", "F034"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F030", "F035", "F025"], "interference": ["F035", "F036"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F056", "F044", "F053", "F055"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F009", "F010", "F019", "F022", "F027", "F024", "F030", "F035", "F025", "F031"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F010", "F019", "F022", "F027", "F024", "F035", "F025", "F055", "F056"]}} {"case_name": "case_260", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "Mr Roland Ezelin is a French national.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "Mr Roland Ezelin lives at Basse-Terre, Guadeloupe.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Mr Roland Ezelin practises as a lawyer (avocat).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 12 February 1983, a number of Guadeloupe independence movements and trade unions held a public demonstration at Basse-Terre.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The public demonstration on 12 February 1983 was held to protest against two court decisions whereby prison sentences and fines were imposed on three militants for criminal damage to public buildings.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant, Mr Roland Ezelin, was Vice-Chairman of the Trade Union of the Guadeloupe Bar at the time of the demonstration on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant took part in the public demonstration at Basse-Terre on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant carried a placard during the public demonstration at Basse-Terre on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Chief Superintendent of the Basse-Terre police drew up a report on 12 February 1983 concerning the demonstration held that day.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Chief Superintendent of the Basse-Terre police sent the report on the demonstration to the local public prosecutor on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Chief Superintendent's report had eleven appendices.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The demonstration on 12 February 1983 was held by various independence movements in the Champ d'Arbaud, Basse-Terre, from 9 a.m. onwards.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The demonstration on 12 February 1983 took the form of a procession through the streets of Basse-Terre.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Demonstrators set off at 10.30 a.m. on 12 February 1983 and marched through the streets of Basse-Terre chanting slogans hostile to the police and the judiciary.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "During the procession on 12 February 1983, graffiti were daubed in paint on various buildings, in particular the Institut d'émission d'Outre-mer, known as the 'Central Treasury'.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "A group of 450–500 people which had left the Champ d'Arbaud joined another group of 500 people at the rue Schoelcher, forming a compact group of about a thousand people.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The procession on 12 February 1983 was headed by leaders who announced over loudspeakers the slogans to be chanted.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Roland Thesauros of the University of West Indies-Guiana was recognised among the leaders of the demonstration on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Luc Reinette, leader of the MPGI (Popular Movement for an Independent Guadeloupe) and a former member of the GLA who came out of prison after 10 May 1981, was recognised among the leaders of the demonstration on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Max Safrano, presumed head of the ALN (National Liberation Army), against whom criminal charges had been brought and who had been released from Basse-Terre Prison the previous day, was recognised among the leaders of the demonstration on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Fernand Curier of the UTS/UGTG Trade Union, recently sentenced on 1 February 1983 by the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal to 15 days' imprisonment and a fine of 10,000 francs, was recognised among the leaders of the demonstration on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The sister of Joseph Samson, who had been given the same sentence on 7 February 1983 by the Basse-Terre Criminal Court, was recognised among the leaders of the demonstration on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Rosan Mounien, a member of the UTA/UGTG Trade Union, was recognised among the leaders of the demonstration on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Marc-Antoine, convicted by the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal on 7 September 1983 along with Alexander and others, known to be particularly fanatical and determined extremists, was recognised among the leaders of the demonstration on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "At ten past eleven on 12 February 1983, the demonstrators reached the Basse-Terre police station and assembled in front of it.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Two leaders from outside the district, unknown to the police officers present, addressed the demonstrators assembled in front of the Basse-Terre police station on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The speakers at the Basse-Terre police station on 12 February 1983 spoke in Creole and urged the police officers to move up and join the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "During the demonstration on 12 February 1983, there was a violent tirade against Police Officer Beaugendre, who was accused of betrayal, after which the crowd rhythmically chanted 'BEAUGENDRE-MAKO! UN JOU OU KE PAYE' (One day you will pay).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Among the demonstrators identified at the Basse-Terre police station on 12 February 1983 were Roland Thesauros, Luc Reinette, Max Safrano, Fernand Curier, Rosan Mounien, Rupaire, Marc-Antoine, Samson's family, Dr Corentin, and Mr Ezelin (a barrister).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Dr Corentin and Mr Ezelin displayed a banner with the words 'LAWYERS - DOCTORS' during the demonstration on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The majority of demonstrators on 12 February 1983, including the most worked up and aggressive ones, were people from outside Basse-Terre, most of them from Grande-Terre island.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The demonstrators left the Basse-Terre police station at about 11.30 a.m. on 12 February 1983 and headed in the direction of the Law Courts and the council building.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Chief Constable abandoned the idea of blocking the lower end of the boulevard Félix-Eboué with a police line because the demonstrators' numerical superiority was too great.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The procession on 12 February 1983 went along the boulevard Félix-Eboué and eventually reached the Champ d'Arbaud, where it dispersed after making two lengthy halts.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "During the demonstration on 12 February 1983, the procession made a lengthy halt in front of the Law Courts in order to insult the judges.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "During the demonstration on 12 February 1983, the procession made a lengthy halt outside the prison in order to demonstrate solidarity with the imprisoned militants.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "After the demonstrators had passed on 12 February 1983, it was found that they had painted offensive and insulting graffiti in green, red and black on the walls of administrative buildings.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The investigation immediately undertaken after the demonstration on 12 February 1983 failed to identify those responsible for defacing the buildings.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to information received, most of the graffiti on 12 February 1983 were the work of girls who were not from Basse-Terre.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "One of the girls responsible for the graffiti on 12 February 1983 was claimed to be a teacher from Pointe-à-Pitre, but this could not be positively established.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The intelligence service (Renseignements généraux) confirmed that the persons responsible for the graffiti on 12 February 1983 were among the demonstrators who arrived by coach from Pointe-à-Pitre, but did not know their identities.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "A judicial investigation was commenced on 21 February 1983 into the commission by a person or persons unknown of offences of criminal damage to public buildings and insulting the judiciary.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The judicial investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 24 February 1983, the Principal Public Prosecutor at the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal wrote to the Chairman of the Guadeloupe Bar enclosing a photocopy of a police report of 21 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The judicial investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Principal Public Prosecutor's letter of 24 February 1983 stated that Mr Ezelin, of the Guadeloupe Bar, had taken part in a public demonstration against the judiciary in circumstances likely to entail criminal liability under Article 226 of the French Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The judicial investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Principal Public Prosecutor's letter of 24 February 1983 asked the Chairman of the Guadeloupe Bar to provide his opinion of the case after hearing Mr Ezelin's explanations.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The judicial investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In a letter of 14 March 1983, the Chairman of the Guadeloupe Bar informed the Principal Public Prosecutor of the outcome of his investigations into Mr Ezelin's conduct.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The judicial investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Chairman of the Guadeloupe Bar's letter of 14 March 1983 stated that Mr Ezelin had not been carrying a banner with another person but had been carrying a placard on his own bearing the words 'Trade Union of the Guadeloupe Bar against the Security and Freedom Act'.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The judicial investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Chairman of the Guadeloupe Bar's letter of 14 March 1983 stated that no act, gesture or words insulting to the judiciary could be attributed to Mr Ezelin.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The judicial investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Chairman of the Guadeloupe Bar's letter of 14 March 1983 stated that Mr Ezelin's participation in the demonstration had been confined to protesting at the use of the 'Security and Freedom' Act.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The judicial investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Chairman of the Guadeloupe Bar concluded in his letter of 14 March 1983 that, even assuming the worst as regards Mr Ezelin, the Chief Superintendent's report did not accuse him of any insulting gesture, act or words.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The judicial investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Chairman of the Guadeloupe Bar concluded in his letter of 14 March 1983 that Mr Ezelin could not have incurred any liability under Article 226 of the French Criminal Code in exercising his right to join a demonstration which had not been prohibited, carrying a placard with the words 'Trade Union of the Guadeloupe Bar against the Security and Freedom Act'.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The judicial investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "After a postponement, the applicant was summoned to appear before the investigating judge on 25 April 1983 in order to give evidence as a witness.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The judicial investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "At the interview before the investigating judge on 25 April 1983, the applicant stated that he had nothing to say on the matter.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The judicial investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 19 May 1983, the judicial investigation ended with a discharge order on the ground that no evidence had been obtained which would make it possible to identify those responsible for the graffiti or for the insulting or threatening words uttered during the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The judicial investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 1 June 1983, the Principal Public Prosecutor sent the Chairman of the Guadeloupe Bar a complaint against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Principal Public Prosecutor's complaint of 1 June 1983 was brought under Article 113 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972 regulating the profession of avocat.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Principal Public Prosecutor's complaint of 1 June 1983 stated that the aim of the demonstration on 12 February 1983 was to protest against two court decisions: the first given on 1 February 1983 by the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal against Fernand Curier, and the second given on 7 February 1983 by the Basse-Terre tribunal de grande instance against Gérard Quidal and Joseph Samson, who were charged with offences of criminal damage to public buildings.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Principal Public Prosecutor's complaint of 1 June 1983 stated that during the demonstration on 12 February 1983, a number of particularly offensive graffiti were daubed in paint on the walls of the Law Courts calling one of the judges who had taken part in one of the decisions a fascist and calling all the judges 'MAKO' (pimps).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Principal Public Prosecutor's complaint of 1 June 1983 stated that the demonstrators chanted death threats on numerous occasions against police officers who witnessed the events.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Principal Public Prosecutor's complaint of 1 June 1983 stated that the Basse-Terre investigating judge opened an investigation into the commission by a person or persons unknown of offences of criminal damage to public buildings, insulting the judiciary and aiding and abetting.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Principal Public Prosecutor's complaint of 1 June 1983 stated that all persons reported as having taken part in the demonstration were interviewed and stated either that they had not seen anyone paint the graffiti or that they did not know who the people responsible were.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Principal Public Prosecutor's complaint of 1 June 1983 stated that only Roland Ezelin refused to answer the questions put by the investigating judge.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Principal Public Prosecutor's complaint of 1 June 1983 stated that the date of Mr Ezelin's examination as a witness had been delayed for more than a month in order to suit his convenience.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Principal Public Prosecutor's complaint of 1 June 1983 expressed the view that Mr Ezelin, who was acquainted with the purpose of the demonstration, wanted by taking part in it to associate himself with a political organisation's criticisms of the judiciary in Guadeloupe, and that neither the death threats nor the insulting graffiti directed against judges surprised or shocked him as a barrister.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Principal Public Prosecutor's complaint of 1 June 1983 stated that Mr Ezelin's refusal to reply to the investigating judge as a witness displayed an attitude of contempt for justice.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Principal Public Prosecutor's complaint of 1 June 1983 alleged a breach under Article 106 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972 and requested that disciplinary proceedings be brought against Mr Ezelin before the Bar Council.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "At a disciplinary hearing held under Article 104 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972, the Guadeloupe Bar Council adopted a decision on 25 July 1983.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Bar Council's decision of 25 July 1983 noted that the Chairman of the Guadeloupe Bar had given an opinion dated 14 March 1983 as to the first series of charges against Mr Ezelin.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Bar Council's decision of 25 July 1983 found that Mr Ezelin took part in the demonstration in response to a call by the Trade Union of the Guadeloupe Bar, of which he was one of the leaders, in order to protest against the use of the direct-committal procedure and the continuation in force of the so-called Security and Freedom Act, which had since been repealed.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Bar Council's decision of 25 July 1983 found that it did not appear from the judicial investigation that Mr Ezelin committed a breach of Article 106 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972 in connection with taking part in the demonstration, and that no disciplinary sanction could consequently be imposed on him for that conduct.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Bar Council's decision of 25 July 1983 noted that the judicial investigation had been brought to an end with a discharge order that had become final.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Bar Council's decision of 25 July 1983 found that Mr Ezelin's refusal to make a statement to the investigating judge was prompted by anxieties based on Article 105 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure and a concern to comply with Article 89 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972, as some of the persons summoned by the investigating judge had previously consulted him as a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Bar Council's decision of 25 July 1983 noted that in a letter of 24 February 1983 the Principal Public Prosecutor had informed the Chairman of the Guadeloupe Bar that Mr Ezelin had taken part in a public demonstration against the judiciary in circumstances likely to entail criminal liability under Article 226 of the French Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Bar Council's decision of 25 July 1983 found that Mr Ezelin, having been informed of the charge under Article 226 of the French Criminal Code, was justified in relying on the provisions of Article 105 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Bar Council's decision of 25 July 1983 found that Mr Ezelin's refusal to make a statement could not be regarded as contempt for justice and the judiciary.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Bar Council's decision of 25 July 1983 noted that if Mr Ezelin's refusal had been deemed sufficiently serious to amount to obstructing the normal course of proceedings, the investigating judge would not have failed to avail himself of the provisions of Article 109 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, nor the prosecution to make the appropriate applications before the discharge order was made.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Bar Council's decision of 25 July 1983 decided that there was no occasion to impose any disciplinary sanction on Mr Roland Ezelin on account of the matters referred to it by the Principal Public Prosecutor on 1 June 1983.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Bar Council's decision of 25 July 1983 recommended that the Chairman of the Guadeloupe Bar remind both Mr Ezelin and the whole of the Bar of the traditional rules of good behaviour and sound judgment in all activities in which their status as avocats may be involved.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "1. The decision of the Bar Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Principal Public Prosecutor appealed to the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal against the Bar Council's decision of 25 July 1983.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "At the hearing before the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal, the Principal Public Prosecutor asked the Court to impose on the applicant the disciplinary penalty of a warning.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 12 December 1983, the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal reversed the Bar Council's decision of 25 July 1983.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 12 December 1983, the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal imposed the disciplinary penalty of a reprimand on Mr Ezelin, a heavier penalty than a warning.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 found it established that on 12 February 1983 Mr Ezelin took part in a demonstration in the streets of Basse-Terre.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 found that the acknowledged purpose of the demonstration on 12 February 1983, organised by the independence movements in the département, was to protest noisily against the recent sentences of three militants to 15 days' imprisonment and a fine of FRF 10,000 for damage to administrative buildings.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 found that it was not alleged that Mr Ezelin took part in the demonstration any more actively than by his constant presence and by carrying a placard.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 noted that a judicial investigation was opened into the commission by a person or persons unknown of offences of damage to public buildings, insulting the judiciary and aiding and abetting, and that Mr Ezelin was summoned as a witness by the investigating judge.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "When examined as a witness by the investigating judge, Mr Ezelin, after taking the oath, stated 'I have nothing to say on the matter' in response to all questions, including the question of whether he was present at the demonstration on 12 February 1983 and whether he saw anybody painting anything on the walls of various buildings.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 found that Mr Ezelin, avocat at the Court of Appeal and member of the Bar Council, participated in the whole of the demonstration on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 found that during the demonstration on 12 February 1983, serious threats were continually made against a police constable and insults uttered against various other persons, including a judge of the Court of Appeal, a well-known regional figure and the judiciary as a whole.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 found that the walls of the Law Courts and of the département council building were covered with particularly offensive and insulting graffiti directed against the same persons during the demonstration on 12 February 1983.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 found that Mr Ezelin, who formed part of the procession notably when it halted in front of the police station, the Law Courts and the prison, could not have failed to see the insulting and offensive graffiti being painted in very large letters on all the walls of the Law Courts and of the council building, and could not have failed to hear the threats and insults directed against the same people.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 found that Mr Ezelin was at the demonstration in his capacity as an avocat, since he carried a placard announcing his profession, and at no time did he dissociate himself from the demonstrators' offensive and insulting acts or leave the procession.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 found that Mr Ezelin's conduct could not be justified by personal beliefs or trade-union instructions and amounted to a breach of discretion under Article 106 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 found that Mr Ezelin, when examined as a witness by the investigating judge, refused to give evidence about matters of which he had knowledge, without giving any reason.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 found that Mr Ezelin contravened the provisions of Article 109, third paragraph, of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, which are binding on all citizens and of whose requirements he could not, as a lawyer, be unaware.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 found that Mr Ezelin, having contravened a statutory provision and shown a lack of discretion, rendered himself liable to the disciplinary sanctions listed in Article 107 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 noted the unanimously favourable opinion of Mr Ezelin's professional conduct and considered that the penalty should be a reprimand.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 set aside the decision taken on 25 July 1983 by the Council of the Bar of the département of Guadeloupe at the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal sitting as a disciplinary board.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983 sentenced Mr Ezelin to the disciplinary penalty of a reprimand and awarded costs against him.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "2. The Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The applicant appealed on points of law against the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 December 1983.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "3. The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The applicant argued in his appeal on points of law that the disciplinary sanction imposed on him infringed Articles 10 and 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "3. The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "On 19 June 1985, the Court of Cassation (First Civil Division) delivered a judgment dismissing the applicant's appeal on points of law.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "3. The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985 stated that the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal did not hold Mr Ezelin liable in virtue of a collective responsibility for criminal offences committed by other demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "3. The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985 stated that the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal had found that during the demonstration, whose purpose was to protest noisily against recent criminal sentences, insults had been uttered and offensive graffiti daubed on all the walls of the Law Courts, directed against the judiciary as a whole and against a judge of the Court of Appeal by name and a well-known figure in the département who practised as a barrister.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "3. The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985 stated that the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal had found that Mr Ezelin, who was at the demonstration as an avocat and had heard the threats and insults and seen the offensive graffiti daubed on the walls of the Law Courts, did not at any time express his disapproval of these excesses or leave the procession in order to dissociate himself from these criminal acts.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "3. The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985 held that the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal was entitled to infer from Mr Ezelin's behaviour that it was a breach of discretion amounting to a disciplinary offence.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "3. The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985 stated that Article 109 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure lays a duty on any person heard as a witness to give evidence, and that by Article 106 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972, any infringement of statutes or regulations constitutes a disciplinary offence, irrespective of the investigating judge's power to fine a witness who refuses to give evidence.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "3. The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985 stated that the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal had found that in reply to the questions put by the investigating judge, including the question 'Were you present at the demonstration in the streets of Basse-Terre on 12 February 1983?', Mr Ezelin said merely 'I have nothing to say on the matter', and gave no reason to explain this attitude.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "3. The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985 held that the Basse-Terre Court of Appeal was entitled to infer that Mr Ezelin, who had refused to give evidence without justifying his refusal on the basis of Article 105 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure or of professional confidentiality, had committed a breach of the law and of discretion vis-à-vis the investigating judge amounting to a disciplinary offence.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The disciplinary proceedings against the applicant", "3. The Court of Cassation's judgment of 19 June 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Article 226, first paragraph of the French Criminal Code provides that anyone who by his acts or by means of the written or spoken word has publicly attempted to bring discredit on any action or decision taken by a court, in a manner likely to impair the authority or independence of the judiciary, shall be liable to imprisonment for not less than one month and not more than six months and a fine of not less than 500 francs and not more than 90,000 francs, or to only one of these two penalties.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. General provisions", "1. The Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Article 105 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure provides that an investigating judge in charge of an investigation and judges and senior police officers (officiers de police judiciaire) acting on judicial warrants shall not, with the intention of preventing the exercise of the rights of the defence, examine as witnesses persons against whom there is substantial, consistent evidence of guilt.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. General provisions", "2. The Code of Criminal Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Article 109 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure provides that anyone summoned to be examined as a witness shall be required to appear, to take the oath and to give evidence, subject to the provisions of Article 378 of the French Criminal Code concerning the duty of professional confidentiality.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. General provisions", "2. The Code of Criminal Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Article 109 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure provides that if a witness fails to appear, the investigating judge may, on an application by the public prosecutor, have the witness brought before him by the police and impose on him a fine of not less than 2,500 francs and not more than 5,000 francs.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. General provisions", "2. The Code of Criminal Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Article 109 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure provides that if a witness subsequently appears, he may, if he apologises and provides an explanation, be excused the penalty by the investigating judge, after the public prosecutor has made submissions.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. General provisions", "2. The Code of Criminal Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Article 109 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure provides that the same penalty may, on an application by the prosecutor, be imposed on a witness who, although he has appeared, refuses to take the oath and to give evidence.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. General provisions", "2. The Code of Criminal Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Article 89 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972 regulating the profession of avocat provides that an avocat must not, in any matter, make any disclosure in breach of professional confidentiality, and must in particular respect the confidentiality of judicial investigations in criminal matters by refraining from communicating any information from the file and from publishing letters or other documents concerning a current investigation.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Provisions relating specifically to avocats", "1. The Decree of 9 June 1972 \"regulating the profession of avocat, implementing the Act of 31 December 1971 reforming certain court and legal professions\""]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Article 104 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972 regulating the profession of avocat provides that the Bar Council sitting as a disciplinary board shall proceed against and punish offences and misconduct by an avocat or a former avocat where at the material time he was entered on a Bar roll, list of trainees or list of honorary avocats.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Provisions relating specifically to avocats", "1. The Decree of 9 June 1972 \"regulating the profession of avocat, implementing the Act of 31 December 1971 reforming certain court and legal professions\""]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Article 106 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972 regulating the profession of avocat provides that any contravention of statutes or regulations, infringement of professional rules or breach of integrity, honour or discretion, even relating to non-professional matters, shall render the avocat responsible liable to the disciplinary sanctions listed in Article 107.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Provisions relating specifically to avocats", "1. The Decree of 9 June 1972 \"regulating the profession of avocat, implementing the Act of 31 December 1971 reforming certain court and legal professions\""]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Article 107 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972 regulating the profession of avocat provides that the disciplinary penalties shall be: a warning; a reprimand; suspension for a period not exceeding three years; striking off the roll of avocats or list of trainees or withdrawal of honorary status.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Provisions relating specifically to avocats", "1. The Decree of 9 June 1972 \"regulating the profession of avocat, implementing the Act of 31 December 1971 reforming certain court and legal professions\""]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Article 107 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972 provides that a warning, a reprimand and suspension may, if so provided in the decision imposing the disciplinary penalty, entail loss of membership of the Bar Council for a period not exceeding ten years.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Provisions relating specifically to avocats", "1. The Decree of 9 June 1972 \"regulating the profession of avocat, implementing the Act of 31 December 1971 reforming certain court and legal professions\""]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Article 107 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972 provides that the Bar Council may further order, as an ancillary penalty, that any disciplinary penalty shall be publicly displayed on the Bar's premises.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Provisions relating specifically to avocats", "1. The Decree of 9 June 1972 \"regulating the profession of avocat, implementing the Act of 31 December 1971 reforming certain court and legal professions\""]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Article 113 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972 provides that the Chairman of the Bar, either on his own initiative or on an application from the Principal Public Prosecutor or on a complaint by any party affected, shall inquire into the conduct of the avocat concerned and shall then either discontinue the proceedings or refer the matter to the Bar Council.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Provisions relating specifically to avocats", "1. The Decree of 9 June 1972 \"regulating the profession of avocat, implementing the Act of 31 December 1971 reforming certain court and legal professions\""]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Article 113 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972 provides that if the Chairman of the Bar has received a complaint, he shall inform the complainant, and if the facts were reported to him by the Principal Public Prosecutor, he shall notify the latter.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Provisions relating specifically to avocats", "1. The Decree of 9 June 1972 \"regulating the profession of avocat, implementing the Act of 31 December 1971 reforming certain court and legal professions\""]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Avocats are bound by the oath they take when entering upon their duties.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Provisions relating specifically to avocats", "2. The Act of 15 June 1982 \"on the procedure applicable in the event of professional misconduct by an avocat at a court hearing\""]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Section 1 of the Act of 15 June 1982 on the procedure applicable in the event of professional misconduct by an avocat at a court hearing provides that the wording of the avocat's oath is: 'I swear, as an avocat, to defend and counsel in a dignified, conscientious, independent and humane manner.'", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Provisions relating specifically to avocats", "2. The Act of 15 June 1982 \"on the procedure applicable in the event of professional misconduct by an avocat at a court hearing\""]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Before the Act of 15 June 1982 came into force, the avocat's oath was worded as follows under Article 23 of Decree no. 72-468 of 9 June 1972: 'I swear, as an avocat, to defend and counsel in a dignified, conscientious, independent and humane manner, with respect for the courts, the public authorities and the rules of the Bar, and neither to say nor to publish anything contrary to statute, regulations, morals, the security of the State, or public order.'", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Provisions relating specifically to avocats", "2. The Act of 15 June 1982 \"on the procedure applicable in the event of professional misconduct by an avocat at a court hearing\""]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "An avocat who took the oath before the Act of 15 June 1982 came into force is deemed to have taken it in its current form.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Provisions relating specifically to avocats", "2. The Act of 15 June 1982 \"on the procedure applicable in the event of professional misconduct by an avocat at a court hearing\""]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "In a judgment of 9 June 1964, the Court of Cassation (First Civil Division) held that the avocat's oath also bound him in all circumstances not to deviate from the respect due to the courts and to the public authorities.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Provisions relating specifically to avocats", "2. The Act of 15 June 1982 \"on the procedure applicable in the event of professional misconduct by an avocat at a court hearing\""]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "In a judgment of 30 June 1965 (Criminal Division, Bouvier), the Court of Cassation held that an avocat, while being entitled to protest at any infringement of the rights of the defence, must refrain from any expression which would reflect on the honour or discretion of a judge.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["AS TO THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Provisions relating specifically to avocats", "2. The Act of 15 June 1982 \"on the procedure applicable in the event of professional misconduct by an avocat at a court hearing\""]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "In his application of 16 October 1985 to the European Commission of Human Rights (application no. 11800/85), Mr Ezelin relied on Articles 10 and 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE COMMISSION"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "In his application of 16 October 1985, Mr Ezelin submitted that the disciplinary sanction imposed on him seriously interfered with his freedom of expression and of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE COMMISSION"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The European Commission of Human Rights declared the application no. 11800/85 admissible on 13 March 1989.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE COMMISSION"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "In its report of 14 December 1989 made under Article 31 of the Convention, the European Commission of Human Rights expressed the opinion that there had been a breach of Article 11 of the Convention, by fifteen votes to six.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE COMMISSION"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "In its report of 14 December 1989, the European Commission of Human Rights expressed the opinion unanimously that no separate issue arose under Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE COMMISSION"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The full text of the European Commission of Human Rights' opinion and of the dissenting opinion contained in the report of 14 December 1989 is reproduced as an annex to the Court's judgment.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE COMMISSION"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F007", "F009", "F012", "F013", "F048", "F050", "F085", "F092", "F093", "F105"], "interference": ["F082", "F092", "F099", "F105"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F118", "F128", "F129"], "legitimate_aim": ["F064", "F092", "F093", "F105"], "necessity": ["F003", "F004", "F007", "F082", "F085", "F092", "F099", "F119", "F120"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F007", "F085", "F092"], "interference": ["F092", "F099", "F105"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F118", "F128"], "legitimate_aim": ["F092", "F093"], "necessity": ["F003", "F082", "F085", "F092", "F099", "F119"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F004", "F007", "F085", "F092", "F099", "F118", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_263", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The case concerns restrictions of the applicant's rights to take part in a public event, under Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant planned to hold a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 27 March 2009, the applicant, together with two other picket organisers, resubmitted their notification specifying that, according to the National Centre for Radiology of the Ministry of Health and Social Development of the Russian Federation, about 70% of Russians over forty years old have haemorrhoids, which is one of the most common human diseases.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 27 March 2009, the Deputy Prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow again refused to authorise the picket.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Deputy Prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow noted that the statistics provided by the applicant and the two other picket organisers were not in line with the relevant data from the Ministry of Health and Social Development of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The picket organisers were invited once again to remedy the shortcomings in their notification and to resubmit it.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The picket organisers decided to cancel the event that they had planned.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 7 April 2009, the applicant lodged a complaint with the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow regarding the refusals of the Deputy Prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow of 19 March 2009 and 27 March 2009.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant argued that Russian law did not permit a blanket ban on the holding of peaceful assemblies as long as the purpose of the assembly in question was in conformity with constitutional values.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 11 June 2009, the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow rejected the applicant's complaint.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Taganskiy District Court of Moscow referred to the definition of a public event as specified by section 2(1) of the Public Events Act (no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Under section 2(1) of the Public Events Act (no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004), a public event was one which aimed to express or develop opinions freely and to voice demands on issues related to political, economic, social or cultural life in the country, or issues related to foreign policy.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Taganskiy District Court of Moscow held that since the picket at issue did not pursue any aims related to expressing or developing opinions freely or voicing demands on issues related to political, economic, social or cultural life in the country, or issues related to foreign policy, the refusals to authorise it had been lawful.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 8 October 2009, the Moscow City Court upheld the judgment of the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow of 11 June 2009 on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Relying on Article 11 of the Convention, the applicant complained that the local authorities' decisions refusing to approve her picket had violated her right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Relying on Article 13 of the Convention, the applicant contended that she had not had at her disposal any procedure which would have allowed her to obtain an enforceable decision prior to the date of the planned picket.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004", "F013"], "interference": ["F004", "F007", "F011", "F012", "F013"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F004", "F011", "F012", "F013"], "legitimate_aim": ["F004", "F005", "F013", "F014"], "necessity": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F013", "F014"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F013"], "interference": ["F004", "F013"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F004", "F011", "F012", "F013"], "legitimate_aim": ["F004", "F005", "F013"], "necessity": ["F003", "F013"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F004", "F013"]}} {"case_name": "case_265", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The application concerns the alleged violation of Article 10 of the Convention on account of the applicant's conviction for disseminating propaganda in favour of the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan) through his participation in actions carried out during a demonstration organised by a political party.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The application concerns the alleged violation of Article 11 of the Convention on account of the applicant's conviction for disseminating propaganda in favour of the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan) through his participation in actions carried out during a demonstration organised by a political party.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The application pertains to the alleged unfairness of criminal proceedings against the applicant on account of the domestic courts' failure to deliver a reasoned judgment in respect of his convictions.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant's convictions were based on his having participated in a demonstration and incited other people to throw stones at the police.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The application pertains to an alleged breach of the principle of equality of arms owing to the allegedly deficient manner in which evidence was admitted and assessed during the trial.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 15 December 2009, a local branch of the Party for a Democratic Society (Demokratik Toplum Partisi – the DTP) organised a demonstration in Muş.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The demonstration organised by the local branch of the Party for a Democratic Society (DTP) on 15 December 2009 in Muş was held to protest about the dissolution of the party by the Constitutional Court.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "After a group of people had gathered near a building of the district branch of the Party for a Democratic Society (DTP), a person started firing into the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The shooting into the crowd near the district branch of the Party for a Democratic Society (DTP) resulted in the deaths of two people.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The shooting into the crowd near the district branch of the Party for a Democratic Society (DTP) resulted in injuries to several people.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "After the shooting incident, the gathering became violent and demonstrators started throwing Molotov cocktails at buildings, police officers and police vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "After the shooting incident, the gathering became violent and demonstrators started throwing stones at buildings, police officers and police vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "A police report dated 18 December 2009 indicated that video footage recorded by police officers showed that the applicant had been one of the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "A police report dated 18 December 2009 indicated that video footage recorded by police officers showed that the applicant had directed a group of people with his hand, inciting them to throw stones at the police.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "In his statements to the police, the applicant denied the accusations against him.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "In his statements to the police, the applicant stated that he was a local council officer.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "In his statements to the police, the applicant stated that he had gone out of the council building to see what was going on.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In his statements to the police, the applicant stated that he had raised his arm to tell the group not to throw stones.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "An expert report concerning the video footage indicated that the applicant had been in the group throwing stones.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "An expert report concerning the video footage indicated that the applicant had raised his right hand.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "An expert report concerning the video footage indicated that the applicant had pointed his index finger at the police officers who had been recording videos.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "An expert report concerning the video footage indicated that the applicant had not thrown stones.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "An expert report concerning the video footage indicated that the applicant had not chanted any slogans.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Throughout the criminal proceedings, the applicant admitted that the person in the video footage had been him.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant stated during the criminal proceedings that he had raised his hand as a reaction to those throwing stones, since he had felt nervous.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant stated during the criminal proceedings that he had tried to help the security forces.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant stated during the criminal proceedings that he had run away because the demonstrators had been throwing stones.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant stated during the criminal proceedings that he had returned to his workplace following the dispersal of the demonstrators by the police.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On multiple occasions the applicant had asked the trial court to hear three witnesses, including a police officer, in support of his defence.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The trial court refused on multiple occasions to hear the three witnesses, including a police officer, that the applicant had requested in support of his defence.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 17 September 2010 the trial court sentenced the applicant to six years and three months' imprisonment for committing an offence on behalf of an armed terrorist organisation without being a member of the organisation, contrary to Article 220 § 6 taken in conjunction with Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The trial court's sentence for committing an offence on behalf of an armed terrorist organisation without being a member was based on the grounds that the applicant had taken part in a demonstration in response to general calls issued by the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 17 September 2010 the trial court sentenced the applicant to ten months' imprisonment for disseminating propaganda in support of the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan), contrary to section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 17 September 2010 the trial court sentenced the applicant to ten months' imprisonment for using force to obstruct a public officer in the execution of his duties, contrary to Article 265 of the Turkish Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The trial court stated in its reasoning that the demonstrators had gathered around the district branch of the Party for a Democratic Society (DTP) for a press conference organised by the DTP to protest against the Constitutional Court's decision dissolving the party.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The trial court found that the demonstration on 15 December 2009 had been organised in response to general calls issued by the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The trial court found that following intensive calls for action on websites known to carry news reports in favour of the terrorist organisation PKK/KONGRA-GEL, on 15 December 2009 at around 10.30 a.m., a press conference was organised in front of the 700. Yıl Mosque in the Bulanık district by the former Bulanık district organisation of the Party for a Democratic Society (DTP), in protest against the Constitutional Court's decision dissolving the party.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The trial court found that a group of approximately 1,000 people gathered around the Party for a Democratic Society (DTP) building and started an illegal march on İnönü Street, Mareşal Fevzi Çakmak Street and Şehit Üsteğmen Suat İshakoğlu Street with stones in their hands.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The trial court found that the marching group carried placards depicting Abdullah Öcalan, who is in prison for the offence of committing acts aimed at bringing about the secession of some territories under the sovereignty of the Republic of Türkiye from the State administration.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The trial court found that the marching group unfurled flags of the so-called KCK (Kürdistan Demokratik Topluluğu – Kurdistan Democratic Community) and the so-called YDGM (Yurtsever Demokratik Gençlik Meclisi – Patriotic Democratic Youth Assembly).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The trial court found that the marching group shouted slogans including 'PKK Revenge', 'Long Live Leader Apo', 'A tooth for a tooth, blood for blood, we're with you Öcalan', 'Again and again revolt, our leader Öcalan', 'A thousand greetings to İmralı', 'PKK is the people, the people are here', 'Bulanık plain, the home of the Apoists', and 'Who are we, we are Apoists'.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The trial court found that the group caused damage by throwing stones and setting fire to workplaces, particularly T.C. Ziraat Bank, Halkbank, and a shop called 'Mardin Manifatura'.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The trial court found that the group actively resisted by throwing stones and bottles at the security officers who were trying to impede them.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The trial court found that five security officers were injured by stones and bottles during the incidents in the Bulanık district.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The trial court found that the applicant directed the group which had gathered in the centre of the Bulanık district in response to calls by the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan), using as an excuse the Constitutional Court's decision dissolving the Party for a Democratic Society (DTP).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The trial court found that the applicant's police statement — that he had not thrown stones at the police officers, had not provoked anybody, and that no one near him had thrown stones at the security forces — was not credible in light of the video footage.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The trial court found from the video footage that the applicant, standing next to people heading towards the police panzer, raised his right hand into the air and pointed at the security forces with his index finger.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The trial court found from the video footage that the demonstrators threw stones at the security forces, after which gas bombs were thrown and the demonstrators started to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The trial court found that the group which the applicant had directed with his hand threw stones at the police panzer and the security forces.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The trial court found that the applicant's testimony to the public prosecutor — that he was raising his arm to tell the group not to throw stones — was not credible in the context of the video footage.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The trial court found that a general call by the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan) was consolidated through material published and calls issued by the organisation's media outlets, and that such a call does not need to be made to a specific person.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The trial court found that the demonstrations on 15 December 2009 took place with the knowledge of and at the request of the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan) and were carried out on behalf of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The trial court found that by taking part in an unauthorised demonstration which started following calls on Internet sites affiliated to the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan), the applicant participated in demonstrations carried out on behalf of the organisation, constituting a violation of Article 314 § 2 taken in conjunction with Article 314 § 3 and Article 220 § 6 of the Turkish Criminal Code (no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The trial court found, consistently with the decision of the 9th Criminal Division of the Court of Cassation dated 28 February 2008 (numbered E.2007/13527 K.2008/1265), that the applicant's actions in participating in the illegal demonstration and being part of the group shouting slogans in favour of the leader of the armed organisation and attacking the security forces with stones and Molotov cocktails constituted disseminating propaganda in favour of a terrorist organisation in such a way as to encourage the use of violence or other terrorist methods, under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The trial court found it necessary to punish the applicant pursuant to Article 265 § 1 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) because the applicant, together with the group in which he had been involved, attacked the security forces who were intervening in the incidents in order to prevent their intervention and to obstruct them in carrying out their duties.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 7 March 2011 the Court of Cassation upheld the trial court's judgment of 17 September 2010.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 5 July 2012 Law no. 6352 entered into force, amending various laws with a view to reducing and suspending sentences given in relation to several offences including the ones of which the applicant was convicted.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Following the entry into force of Law no. 6352, the trial court suspended the pronouncement of the judgment in so far as it concerned the offence of obstructing the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Following the entry into force of Law no. 6352, the trial court suspended the execution of the applicant's sentence for disseminating propaganda in support of the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Following the entry into force of Law no. 6352, the trial court reduced the applicant's sentence to three years, one month and fifteen days' imprisonment for committing an offence on behalf of an armed terrorist organisation of which he was not a member.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The judgment in the applicant's case became final on 22 December 2015.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["national_security", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F033", "F004", "F014", "F045", "F049"], "interference": ["F033", "F002"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F033"], "legitimate_aim": ["F033", "F036", "F052"], "necessity": ["F004", "F033", "F054", "F056", "F059"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F004"], "interference": ["F033"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F033"], "legitimate_aim": ["F033"], "necessity": ["F033", "F054", "F056", "F059"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F006", "F004", "F033", "F054", "F056"]}} {"case_name": "case_267", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_268", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1962.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the applicant was arrested during the dispersal of a political rally at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant was detained at the police station for at least thirty-six hours pending administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "In the administrative proceedings, the applicant was found guilty of failure to obey lawful police orders, an offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to fifteen days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 23 April 2012 five individuals (Mr I. Bakirov, Mr S. Davidis, Ms Y. Lukyanova, Ms N. Mityushkina and Mr S. Udaltsov) submitted notice of a public demonstration to the mayor of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The planned march had an estimated 5,000 participants.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The planned march was to begin at 4 p.m. on 6 May 2012 from Triumfalnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The planned march was to be followed by a meeting at Manezhnaya Square, which was to end at 8 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The aim of the demonstration was to protest against abuses and falsifications in the course of the elections to the State Duma and of the President of the Russian Federation, and to demand fair elections, respect for human rights, the rule of law and the international obligations of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 26 April 2012 the Head of the Moscow Department of Regional Security, Mr A. Mayorov, informed the organisers that the requested route could not be allocated because of preparations for the Victory Day parade on 9 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Moscow Department of Regional Security proposed that the organisers hold the march between Luzhniki Street and Frunzenskaya Embankment.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 27 April 2012 the organisers declined the proposal to hold the march between Luzhniki Street and Frunzenskaya Embankment.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 27 April 2012 the organisers requested an alternative route from Kaluzhskaya Square, down Bolshaya Yakimanka Street and Bolshaya Polyanka Street, followed by a meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The march was to begin at 4 p.m. and the meeting was to finish by 7.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The number of participants for the alternative route proposal was indicated as 5,000.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 3 May 2012 the Moscow Department of Regional Security approved the alternative route from Kaluzhskaya Square, down Bolshaya Yakimanka Street and Bolshaya Polyanka Street, followed by a meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Moscow Department of Regional Security noted that the organisers had provided a detailed plan of the proposed events when approving the alternative route.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 3 May 2012 the Moscow Department of Regional Security informed the Chief of the Moscow Department of the Interior, Mr V. Kolokoltsev, that a different group of organisers had submitted notification of another public event – a meeting at Manezhnaya Square – which the Moscow authorities had rejected.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The organisers of the rejected meeting at Manezhnaya Square had expressed their intention to proceed in defiance of the ban and to occupy the square from 6 to 10 May 2012, ready to resist the police if necessary.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Moscow Department of Regional Security requested the Moscow Department of the Interior to safeguard public order in Moscow in light of the threatened unauthorised occupation of Manezhnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "At 8 p.m. on 4 May 2012 the First Deputy Head of the Moscow Department of Regional Security, Mr V. Oleynik, held a working meeting with the organisers of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square to discuss security issues.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Deputy Chief of the Public Order Directorate of the Moscow Department of the Interior, Police Colonel D. Deynichenko, took part in the working meeting on 4 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "At the working meeting on 4 May 2012, the organisers stated that the turnout could significantly exceed the expected 5,000 participants.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "At the working meeting on 4 May 2012, the organisers were warned that exceeding the number originally declared would be unacceptable.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicant, during the working meeting on 4 May 2012 the organisers and the authorities agreed that, since there was insufficient time for an on-the-spot reconnaissance, the assembly layout and the security arrangements would be identical to the previous public event organised by the same group of opposition activists on 4 February 2012.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 4 February 2012, the previous public event had proceeded with a march down Yakimanka Street followed by a meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 4 February 2012, the venue of the meeting had included the park at Bolotnaya Square (in some documents referred to as 'Repin Park') and the Bolotnaya Embankment.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 4 May 2012 the deputy mayor of Moscow, Mr A. Gorbenko, instructed the Tsentralnyy district prefect to assist the organisers in maintaining public order and security during the event.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 4 May 2012 the deputy mayor of Moscow, Mr A. Gorbenko, ordered the Moscow Department of Regional Security to inform the organisers that their assembly notice had been accepted and to monitor its implementation.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Other public agencies were assigned the duties of street cleaning, traffic control and ensuring the presence of ambulances at the site of the assembly on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 5 May 2012 the Moscow Department of Regional Security requested the Moscow City Prosecutor's Office to issue a warning to the organisers against exceeding the notified number of participants.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 5 May 2012 the Moscow Department of Regional Security requested the Moscow City Prosecutor's Office to issue a warning to the organisers against erecting camping tents at the meeting venue, an intention allegedly expressed by the organisers at the working meeting.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Moscow Department of Regional Security referred to information found on the Internet that the demonstrators would go to Manezhnaya Square after the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 5 May 2012 the Tsentralnyy district prosecutor's office issued a warning to two of the organisers, Mr S. Davidis and Mr S. Udaltsov, against exceeding the notified number of participants and against erecting camping tents at the meeting venue.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 5 May 2012 the Moscow Department of the Interior published on its website official information concerning the forthcoming demonstration on 6 May 2012, including a map.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The map published by the Moscow Department of the Interior on 5 May 2012 indicated the route of the march, the traffic restrictions and an access plan to Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The map published by the Moscow Department of the Interior on 5 May 2012 delineated the area allotted to the meeting, which included the park at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The map published by the Moscow Department of the Interior on 5 May 2012 marked access to the meeting through the park at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 5 May 2012 the Police Chief of the Moscow Department of the Interior, Police Major-General V. Golovanov, adopted a plan for safeguarding public order in Moscow on 6 May 2012 (the security plan).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The security plan was a ninety-nine-page internal document which had not been disclosed to the public or to the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The security plan provided for security measures in Moscow city centre in view of the forthcoming authorised demonstration at Bolotnaya Square and anticipated attempts by other opposition groups to hold unauthorised public gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The security plan set up operational headquarters to implement the security measures.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Thirty-two high-ranking police officers, including eight major-generals, two military commanders and one emergency-relief official, were appointed to the operational headquarters.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Deputy Police Chief of the Moscow Department of the Interior, Police Major-General V. Kozlov, was appointed as head of the operational headquarters.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Chief of the Special-Purpose Operational Centre of the Moscow Department of the Interior, Police Major-General V. Khaustov, was appointed as deputy head of the operational headquarters.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Deputy Chief of the Public Order Directorate of the Moscow Department of the Interior, Police Colonel D. Deynichenko, was appointed as deputy head of the operational headquarters.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The security plan provided for an 8,094-strong crowd-control taskforce, comprising police and military, to police the designated security areas and to prevent unauthorised public gatherings and terrorist attacks.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The main contingent of the security plan was the police squad charged with cordon and riot-control duties in accordance with a structured and detailed action plan for each operational unit.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The security plan provided for a 785-strong police unit assigned to operational posts across the city centre, with responsibility for apprehending offenders, escorting them to police stations and drawing up administrative-offence reports.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The 785-strong police unit was instructed to prepare templates for the administrative-offence reports and to have at least forty printed copies of them at every police station.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The security plan provided for a 350-strong police unit for intercepting and apprehending organisers and instigators of unauthorised gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The 350-strong police unit had to be equipped with full protection gear and police batons.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Each unit in the security plan had to ensure effective radio communication within the chain of command.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Units were instructed to keep loudspeakers, metal detectors, handcuffs, fire extinguishers and wire clippers in the police vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The security plan set out in detail the allocation and deployment of police vehicles, police buses, interception and monitoring vehicles and equipment, dog-handling teams, fire-fighting and rescue equipment, ambulances and a helicopter.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The security plan made provision for a 1,815-strong reserve unit equipped with gas masks, aerosol grenades (Дрейф), flash grenades (Заря-2), bang grenades (Факел and Факел-C), a 40-mm hand-held grenade launcher (Гвоздь 6Г-30), and a 43-mm hand-held grenade launcher (ГМ-94).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The 1,815-strong reserve unit was also equipped with tubeless pistols (ПБ-4СП) with 23-mm rubber bullets and propelling cartridges, and rifles (KC-23).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Two water-cannon vehicles were ordered to be on standby, ready to be used against persistent offenders.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "All units were instructed to be vigilant and thorough in detecting and eliminating security threats and to be polite and tactful in their conduct vis-à-vis citizens, engaging in lawful dialogue with them without responding to provocations.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "If faced with an unauthorised gathering, units were instructed to give a warning through a loudspeaker, to arrest the most active participants and to record video-footage of those incidents.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Police chiefs were instructed to place plain-clothes officers among the protesters in order to monitor the threat of violence and terrorist attacks within the crowd and to take measures, where appropriate, to prevent and mitigate the damage and to pursue the perpetrators.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Chief of the Tsentralnyy district of Moscow Department of the Interior, Police Major-General V. Paukov, was required to prepare, together with the organisers, the text of the public announcement to be made if the situation deteriorated.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The head of the press communication service of the Moscow Department of the Interior, Internal Service Lieutenant-Colonel Y. Alekseyeva, was in charge of communication with the press.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The head of the Department for Liaison with Civil Society of the Moscow Department of the Interior, Internal Service Colonel V. Biryukov, had to ensure coordination with the representatives of public organisations and coordination and information flow with other services of the Moscow Department of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The units assigned to police the march and the meeting belonged to Zone no. 8, covering Kaluzhskaya Square, Bolotnaya Square and the adjacent territory.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The zone commander of Zone no. 8 was the Chief of the Riot Police of the Moscow Department of the Interior, Police Colonel P. Smirnov.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Police Colonels P. Saprykin, Y. Zdorenko, A. Kuznetsov, V. Yermakov, A. Kasatkin, A. Dvoynos, Police Lieutenant-Colonel A. Tsukernik, Police Captain R. Bautdinov and Internal Service Lieutenant-Colonel D. Bystrikov were appointed as deputy commanders of Zone no. 8.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The units assigned to Zone no. 8 comprised 2,400 riot police officers, of whom 1,158 were on duty at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The units assigned to Zone no. 8 were instructed to search the demonstrators to prevent them from taking camping tents to the site of the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The units assigned to Zone no. 8 were instructed to obstruct access to Bolshoy Kamennyy Bridge, diverting the marchers to Bolotnaya Embankment, the site of the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The adjacent park at Bolotnaya Square had to be cordoned off under the security plan.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The only entrance to Bolotnaya Embankment – from Malyy Kamennyy Bridge – had to be equipped with fourteen metal detectors, which were to be removed just before the march approached the site of the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "An exception was made for the organisers and the technical staff, who were allowed access behind the stage through two additional metal detectors.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Further arrangements were made for access of the press to the meeting venue.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The command of Zone no. 8, in particular Police Colonels Smirnov and Saprykin, were under orders to meet the organisers in person at the beginning of the event to remind them of their responsibilities and to have them sign an undertaking.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The organisers were to undertake to ensure the lawful and safe conduct of the event, and to refrain from any calls for forced change of the constitutional order and from hate speech and propaganda in favour of violence or war.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The organisers were to undertake to be present at the venue until the end of the assembly and the departure of the participants.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "A video-recording of the briefing and the signing of the undertaking had to be made.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "1. The planning of the assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "At approximately 1.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the organisers were allowed access to Bolotnaya Square to set up the stage and sound equipment.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The police searched the vehicles delivering the equipment and seized three tents found amid the gear.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The police arrested several people for bringing the tents to Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The installation of the stage and sound equipment was delayed due to the police searches and arrests.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "During the time of the equipment installation, communication between the organisers setting up the stage and those leading the march was sporadic.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "At the beginning of the march, Police Colonel A. Makhonin met the organisers at Kaluzhskaya Square to clarify any outstanding organisational matters and to have them sign the undertaking to ensure public order during the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Police Colonel A. Makhonin specifically asked Mr S. Udaltsov to ensure that no tents were placed on Bolotnaya Square and that the participants complied with the limits on the place and time allocated for the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The organisers gave their assurances that no tents would be placed on Bolotnaya Square and that participants would comply with the limits on the place and time allocated for the assembly, and signed the undertaking.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The march began at 4.30 p.m. at Kaluzhskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The march proceeded down Yakimanka Street peacefully and without disruption.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The turnout at the march exceeded expectations, but there is no consensus as to the exact numbers.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The official estimate was that there were 8,000 participants in the march.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The organisers considered that there had been about 25,000 participants in the march.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The media reported different numbers of participants, some significantly exceeding the official and organisers' estimates.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "At approximately 5 p.m. the march approached Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The leaders of the march found that the layout of the meeting and the placement of the police cordon did not correspond to what they had anticipated.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Unlike on 4 February 2012, the park at Bolotnaya Square was excluded from the meeting venue on 6 May 2012, which was limited to Bolotnaya Embankment.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "A cordon of riot police in full protection gear barred access to the park at Bolotnaya Square and continued along the whole perimeter of the meeting area, channelling the demonstration to Bolotnaya Embankment.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Further down Bolotnaya Embankment there was a row of metal detectors at the entrance to the meeting venue.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "By approximately 5 p.m. on 6 May 2012, the stage had been erected at the far end of Bolotnaya Embankment and a considerable number of people had already accumulated in front of it.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Faced with the police cordon and unable to access the park, the leaders of the march – Mr S. Udaltsov, Mr A. Navalnyy, Mr B. Nemtsov and Mr I. Yashin – stopped and demanded that the police open access to the park.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "According to the protesters, they were taken aback by the alteration of the expected layout and demanded that the police officers at the cordon move the cordon back to allow sufficient space for the protesters to pass and to assemble for the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "According to the official version, the protesters were not interested in proceeding to the meeting venue; they stopped because they had either intended to break the cordon in order to proceed towards Bolshoy Kamennyy Bridge and then to the Kremlin, or to stir up the crowd to incite disorder.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The cordon officers did not enter into any discussion with the protest leaders and no senior officer was delegated to negotiate.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "After around fifteen minutes of attempting to engage with the cordon officers, at 5.16 p.m. the four leaders (Mr S. Udaltsov, Mr A. Navalnyy, Mr B. Nemtsov and Mr I. Yashin) announced that they were going on a 'sit-down strike' and sat on the ground.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The people behind the four leaders stopped, although some people continued to go past them towards the stage.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The leaders of the sit-in called on other demonstrators to follow their example and sit down, but only a few of their entourage did so (between approximately twenty and fifty people in total).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Between 5.20 p.m. and 5.45 p.m. two State Duma deputies, Mr G. Gudkov and Mr D. Gudkov, contacted unidentified senior police officers to negotiate the enlargement of the restricted area by moving the police cordon behind the park along the lines expected by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Mr V. Lukin, the Ombudsman of the Russian Federation, at the request of Police Colonel V. Biryukov, attempted to convince the leaders of the sit-in to resume the procession and to head towards the meeting venue at Bolotnaya Embankment, where the stage had been set up.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "During the period between 5.20 p.m. and 5.45 p.m., no senior police officers or municipal officials came to the site of the sit-down protest, and there was no direct communication between the authorities and the leaders of the sit-in.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "At 5.40 p.m. one of the meeting participants announced from the stage that the leaders were calling on the demonstrators to support their protest.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Some people waiting in front of the stage headed back to Malyy Kamennyy Bridge, either to support the sit-down protest or to leave the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The area in front of the stage almost emptied after the announcement at 5.40 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "At 5.43 p.m. the media reported that Mr S. Udaltsov had demanded that the protesters be given airtime on Russia's main television channels, that the presidential inauguration of Mr Putin be cancelled and that new elections be called.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "At 5.50 p.m. the crowd around the sit-down protest built up, which caused some congestion, and the leaders abandoned the protest and headed towards the stage, followed by the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "At 5.55 p.m. the media reported that the police authorities were regarding the sit-down strike as a provocation of mass disorder and were considering prosecuting those responsible for it.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "At approximately 5.55 p.m. a commotion arose near the police cordon at the place vacated by the sit-down protest, and the police cordon was broken in several places.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "A crowd of around a hundred people spilled over to the empty space beyond the cordon after it was broken.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Within seconds the police restored the cordon, which was reinforced by additional riot police.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Those who found themselves outside the cordon wandered around, uncertain what to do next.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Several people were apprehended, others were pushed back inside the cordon, and some continued to loiter outside or walked towards the park.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The police cordon began to push the crowd into the restricted area and advanced by several metres, pressing it inwards.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "At 6 p.m. Police Colonel A. Makhonin told Ms N. Mityushkina to make an announcement from the stage that the meeting was over.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Ms N. Mityushkina made the announcement from the stage that the meeting was over, but apparently her message was not heard by most of the demonstrators or the media reporters broadcasting from the spot.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The live television footage provided by the parties contained no mention of Ms N. Mityushkina's announcement that the meeting was over.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "At approximately 6 p.m. a Molotov cocktail was launched from the crowd at the corner of Malyy Kamennyy Bridge over the restored police cordon.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Molotov cocktail landed outside the cordon and the trousers of a passer-by caught fire.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The fire caused by the Molotov cocktail was promptly extinguished by the police.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "At 6.15 p.m., at the corner of Malyy Kamennyy Bridge, the riot police began breaking into the demonstration to split the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Running in tight formations, the riot police pushed the crowd apart, arrested some people, confronted others and formed new cordons to isolate sections of the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Some protesters held up metal barriers and aligned them so as to resist the police, threw various objects at the police, shouted and chanted 'Shame!' and other slogans.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Whenever the police apprehended anyone from among the protesters, other protesters attempted to pull them back.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The police applied combat techniques and used truncheons during the dispersal at 6.15 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "At 6.20 p.m. Mr S. Udaltsov climbed onto the stage at the opposite end of the square to address the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "At 6.20 p.m. many people were assembled in front of the stage, but the sound equipment had been disconnected.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Mr S. Udaltsov took a loudspeaker and addressed the crowd, calling for an indefinite protest action and stating that they would not leave until their comrades had been released, until the inauguration had been cancelled and until they were given airtime on the central television channels.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "At 6.21 p.m. several police officers arrested Mr S. Udaltsov and took him away from the stage.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Mr A. Navalnyy attempted to go up onto the stage, but he was also arrested at the stairs and taken away.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "As Mr A. Navalnyy was pushed out by the police officers he turned to the crowd shouting 'Nobody leave!'", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "At 6.25 p.m. the police arrested Mr B. Nemtsov, who had also attempted to address people from the stage.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "At Malyy Kamennyy Bridge the police continued dividing the crowd and began pushing some sections away from the venue.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Through the loudspeakers the police requested that the participants leave for the metro station.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "The dispersal of the demonstration continued for at least another hour until the venue was fully cleared of all protesters.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "2. Dispersal of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "On 6 May 2012 Police Colonel D. Deynichenko drew up a report summarising the security measures taken on that day in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The report by Police Colonel D. Deynichenko stated that the march, in which around 8,000 people had participated, had begun at 4.15 p.m. and had followed the route to Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The report by Police Colonel D. Deynichenko listed the groups and organisations represented at the march, the number of participants in each group, the number and colours of their flags and the number and content of their banners.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "According to Police Colonel D. Deynichenko's report, at 5.04 p.m. the organised procession arrived at the police cordon and expressed the intention to proceed straight to Bolshoy Kamennyy Bridge and to Borovitskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "According to Police Colonel D. Deynichenko's report, the leaders at the head of the procession – Mr S. Udaltsov, Mr B. Nemtsov and Mr A. Navalnyy – called on the marchers through the loudspeaker not to move, and together with some thirty protesters sat on the ground.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "According to Police Colonel D. Deynichenko's report, the police repeatedly warned those sitting on the ground against holding an unauthorised public gathering and required them to proceed to the venue of the meeting or to leave.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "According to Police Colonel D. Deynichenko's report, two State Duma deputies (Mr G. Gudkov and Mr D. Gudkov), the Ombudsman of the Russian Federation (Mr V. Lukin), and a member of the Civic Chamber (Mr N. Svanidze) talked to those sitting on the ground, but they did not react and continued chanting slogans.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "According to Police Colonel D. Deynichenko's report, from 5.58 p.m. to 7 p.m. persons on Malyy Kamennyy Bridge and Bolotnaya Embankment made attempts to break the cordon, and threw empty glass bottles, fireworks, chunks of tarmac and portable metal barriers at the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "According to Police Colonel D. Deynichenko's report, at 6 p.m. one of the organisers, Ms N. Mityushkina, went on the stage and declared the meeting over.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "According to Police Colonel D. Deynichenko's report, at 6.20 p.m. Mr S. Udaltsov went on the stage and called on the people to take part in an indefinite protest action.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "According to Police Colonel D. Deynichenko's report, at 7 p.m. a group of around twenty individuals including Ms N. Mityushkina attempted to put up three one-person camping tents on Bolotnaya Embankment.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "According to Police Colonel D. Deynichenko's report, from 6 p.m. to 9 p.m. necessary measures were taken to push citizens away from Malyy Kamennyy Bridge, Bolotnaya Embankment and Bolotnaya Street and to arrest those who resisted the most, during which twenty-eight police officers and military servicemen sustained injuries of various gravity, four of whom were hospitalised.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "According to Police Colonel D. Deynichenko's report, in total 656 people were detained in Moscow to prevent public disorder and unauthorised demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "According to Police Colonel D. Deynichenko's report, the total number of troops deployed for public order and security duties in Moscow was 12,759 servicemen, including 7,609 police officers, 100 traffic police officers, 4,650 military servicemen and 400 members of voluntary brigades.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation opened a criminal investigation into suspected offences of mass disorder and violent acts against the police under Article 212 § 2 and Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "On 28 May 2012 an investigation was launched into the criminal offence of organising mass disorder under Article 212 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "On 28 May 2012 the two criminal cases concerning the events of 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square were joined.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "On 22 June 2012 the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation set up a group of twenty-seven investigators and put them in charge of the criminal file concerning the events of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "On an unspecified date, two human-rights activists filed a request with the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation to open a criminal investigation into the conduct of the police during the events of 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square, complaining in particular of the suppression of a lawful public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "On an unspecified date, forty-four human rights activists and members of non-governmental organisations filed a petition calling for the curbing of repression against those who had been arrested and prosecuted in relation to the events of 6 May 2012 and denying that mass riots had taken place at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "On 13 August 2012, following an enquiry from the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation regarding publication of the maps of the assembly of 6 May 2012, the Moscow Department of the Interior replied that on 5 May 2012 it had published on its official website a notice on 'Safeguarding public order in Moscow during the public events on 6 May'.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The Moscow Department of the Interior stated that the notice published on 5 May 2012 included information on the route, the map of traffic restrictions and information concerning the location of the socio-political events, the security measures and the warning against any unlawful acts during the events.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The decision to publish the notice on 5 May 2012 was taken by the head of the Department on Liaison with the Mass Media of the Moscow Department of the Interior with the aim of ensuring the security of citizens and media representatives planning to take part in the event.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The Moscow Department of the Interior stated that the pictures contained in the notice were schematic and showed the approximate route of the march as well as the reference place of the meeting – 'Bolotnaya Square' – indicated in the security plan.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "On 4 May 2012 a working meeting took place at the Moscow Department of Regional Security with participants from among the organisers and the Moscow Department of the Interior, where they discussed the arrangements for the march, the placement of metal detectors, the stage set-up and other organisational matters.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "After the working meeting on 4 May 2012, the Moscow Department of the Interior prepared a security plan and map providing for the park at Bolotnaya Square to be cordoned off with metal barriers and for the participants in the meeting to be accommodated on the road at Bolotnaya Embankment.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The security plan and security maps were prepared at extremely short notice (during the night of 4-5 May 2012 and the day of 5 May 2012) and were approved on 5 May 2012 by senior officials at the Moscow Department of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The Moscow Department of the Interior did not discuss the security maps and security plan with the organisers, as those documents were for internal use showing the placement of the police forces and setting out their tasks.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "On an unspecified date, eight prominent international non-governmental organisations set up an international expert commission to evaluate the events at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 (the Expert Commission).", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "The Expert Commission comprised six international experts whose objective was to provide an independent fact-finding and legal assessment of the circumstances in which the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square had been dispersed.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "In 2013 the Expert Commission produced a fifty-three-page report containing the chronology and an assessment of the events of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "The Expert Commission's work was based on evidence from the official investigation, reports and statements made by the relevant authorities, information from public investigations and observations gathered by human rights defenders, journalists and others, and reports by observers and journalists, witness testimony and video materials.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "The Expert Commission developed a questionnaire that it distributed to the city administration of Moscow, the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation, police authorities in Moscow, the Ombudsman of the Russian Federation and event organisers.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "The Expert Commission did not receive replies from the city administration of Moscow, police authorities or the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "The Expert Commission's analysis was based on information from open sources, including materials presented by the event organisers, observers and non-governmental organisations, materials from public investigations and information provided by defence attorneys engaged in the so-called 'Bolotnaya case'.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "The experts analysed more than 50 hours of video-records and 200 documents related to the Bolotnaya events.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "The Expert Commission members met organisers, participants and observers of the events and attended several court hearings of the Bolotnaya case.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "The Expert Commission noted that the Moscow Department of Regional Security announced on 4 May 2012 that the event would follow a similar route to the previous rally on 4 February 2012.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "The Expert Commission noted that the official notification of approval for the 6 May 2012 assembly was issued on 4 May 2012 – just two days before the beginning of the event.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "The Expert Commission noted that on 4 May 2012 the Moscow Department of the Interior published a plan on its website indicating that all of Bolotnaya Square, including the public gardens, would be given over to the rally, while Bolshoy Kamennyy Bridge would be closed to vehicles but would remain open to pedestrians.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "The Expert Commission noted that the procedure of opening all of Bolotnaya Square including the public gardens was the same procedure the authorities had adopted for the two previous rallies on Bolotnaya Square on 10 December 2011 and 4 February 2012.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "The Expert Commission noted that on the evening of 5 May 2012 the police cordoned off the public gardens at Bolotnaya Square, according to Police Colonel Y. Zdorenko, in order to prevent the participants from setting up camp and from other illegal acts.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "The Expert Commission noted that the authorities received information that the protesters might attempt to establish a protest camp at the site, causing them to decide that the rally should be confined to only the Bolotnaya waterfront area – a much smaller area than had been originally allocated for the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "The Expert Commission noted that the police did not inform the organisers of the changes they had decided upon, and the organisers only became aware of the police-imposed changes to the event when they arrived at the site on the afternoon of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "The Expert Commission noted that the City Council of Moscow did not send out a written announcement that a special representative from the city authorities would be present at the event.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "The Expert Commission noted that the chairman of the Moscow local department of the Ministry of the Interior, Mr V. Kolokoltsev, did not issue any special orders on sending a special representative of the Ministry to the event.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "The Expert Commission noted that the organisers requested twelve hours to set up a stage and sound equipment for the rally, but on the morning of 6 May 2012 the authorities only allocated six hours of advance access.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "The Expert Commission noted that at 1.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police did not allow vehicles with stage equipment onto the site until they had been searched, and the searches revealed a small number of tents, resulting in the detention of a number of people.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "The Expert Commission noted that the police finally allowed the truck with the stage equipment onto Bolotnaya Square at 2.50 p.m. on 6 May 2012, just 70 minutes before the march was due to begin.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that as the march approached Bolotnaya Square, demonstrators found that a police cordon was blocking off most of the square, leaving only a narrow stretch along the waterfront for the rally.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that the police established a triple cordon of officers on Bolshoy Kamennyy Bridge, which prevented any movement in the direction of the Kremlin.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that the first cordon was positioned close to the junction of Malyy Kamennyy Bridge and the Bolotnaya waterfront, comprising students from the Police College and officers of the Patrol Guard Service without any protective equipment.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that behind the first cordon were two rows of OMON riot police, a line of voluntary citizen patrol ('druzhinniki'), and another cordon of OMON, with a number of water cannons visible between the second and third cordons.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "The Expert Commission's report contained two photographs comparing the police cordon on 4 February 2012 (a thin line of police officers without protection gear) and the one on 6 May 2012 (multiple ranks of riot police with full protection gear backed up by heavy vehicles).", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that by 5.15 p.m. the majority of the march was immobile, and a number of leaders including Mr S. Udaltsov, Mr A. Navalnyy and Mr I. Yashin encouraged demonstrators to sit down on the road in front of the 'Udarnik' cinema facing the police cordon.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that an estimated 50-200 people joined the sit-down protest, and the leaders stressed the need to maintain a peaceful protest and appealed to demonstrators to remain calm.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that at 5.42 p.m. the chief of the Moscow Department of the Interior issued a statement characterising the organisers' refusal to proceed to the agreed place of the rally as creating a real threat of a jam and trauma for participants, and announcing that an inquiry commission was working on the spot to document actions related to appeals to commit mass public disorder.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that some demonstrators tried to pass through the police cordon to leave the area, but the police refused to let them through and directed them to go back through the crowd to Bolshaya Polyanka Street, even though this was practically impossible.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that the police used loudspeakers to inform demonstrators of the rally location and asked participants to pass directly to Bolotnaya Square, but given the poor quality of the sound equipment, only those nearest the police could hear this information.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that from the moment difficulties first arose for demonstrators attempting to cross Malyy Kamennyy Bridge, demonstrators made repeated attempts to negotiate with the police over moving their cordons to allow protesters onto Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that Mr D. Oreshkin, a member of the Presidential Human Rights Council, and State Duma deputy Mr G. Gudkov tried to talk to the police authorities at around 5.30 p.m., but there was no response.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F205", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that at 7.00 p.m. State Duma deputy Mr I. Ponomarev tried to stop violence during the clashes on the embankment by speaking to the authorities, but he did not get a positive response.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F206", "text": "The Expert Commission's report quoted organiser Ms N. Mityushkina as stating that she tried unsuccessfully to find the responsible people in the Ministry of the Interior to solve organisational problems, and that only at 6.00-6.30 p.m. did a senior police officer approach her and tell her that the authorities had suspended the demonstration and ask her to announce from the stage that the event was over.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F207", "text": "The Expert Commission's report quoted organiser Mr I. Bakirov as stating that a police officer in a colonel's uniform contacted him only once, and that later when clashes with the police erupted he could not find anyone with whom to communicate and cooperate.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F208", "text": "The Expert Commission's report quoted organiser Mr S. Davidis as stating that he personally did not meet nor have time to get into contact with the authorities regarding the fences set up around the perimeter of the rally, and that he only saw OMON officers who behaved aggressively and were not predisposed to get into a conversation.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F209", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that at 5.55 p.m. as people tried to move through the narrow gap between the police cordon and the waterfront, the police line moved two steps forward, further pressing the crowd, which generated a counter response from the crowd, and in several places the police cordon broke.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F210", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that it was impossible to determine whether the breaking of the cordon was the result of conscious action by sections of the crowd or if the police cordon simply broke due to the pressure from such a large number of people.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F211", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that just after the breaking of the police cordon at approximately 6.00 p.m., a single Molotov cocktail was thrown from the crowd, landed behind the police ranks and ignited the trousers of a 74-year-old demonstrator who had passed through the cordon, and the police used their fire extinguishers to put out the fire.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F212", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that at 6.10 p.m. Mr S. Udaltsov, Mr A. Navalnyy and Mr B. Nemtsov managed to walk from the Udarnik cinema to the stage at the waterfront followed by a large number of people, and that OMON officers then detained Mr S. Udaltsov on stage and shortly afterwards detained Mr B. Nemtsov and Mr A. Navalnyy as well.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F213", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that in the two hours between 6 p.m. and 8 p.m. there does not appear to have been any clear reason for the police decision to advance other than to divide the crowd up into smaller sections, and that there is little evidence that demonstrators initiated the violence.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F214", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that at around 6.20 p.m. the police announced that the rally was cancelled and asked protesters to disperse, but the announcement was not loud enough to reach the majority of the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F215", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that at the same time as the dispersal announcement, Police Colonel V. Biryukov, head of the Moscow Department of the Interior's press service, told a group of human rights defenders that the demonstrators could continue to Bolotnaya Square to take part in the rally.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F216", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that by 6.30 p.m. the crowd at the corner of Malyy Kamennyy Bridge and the waterfront was cut in two.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F217", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that around 6.54 p.m. the police cordon that acted as a barrier along the waterfront near Luzhkov Bridge was removed, and demonstrators were able to move freely along the Bolotnaya waterfront.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F218", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that approximately 15 minutes after 6.54 p.m., some 200 police officers in protective equipment began pushing protesters in the direction of Lavrushinsky Lane and back along the Bolotnaya waterfront from Luzhkov Bridge towards the Udarnik cinema.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F219", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that at around 7.47 p.m. authorities created a corridor to allow demonstrators to leave the Bolotnaya area.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F220", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that at 7.53 p.m. a group of OMON officers appeared from the bushes of Bolotnaya Gardens and divided those demonstrators that remained on the square.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F221", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that at 8.08 p.m. the last groups of people slowly left the waterfront along a corridor formed by the policemen.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F222", "text": "The Expert Commission's report stated that between 9.00 and 10.00 p.m. around two thousand demonstrators moved along Bolshaya Ordynka Street chanting slogans and OMON officers began to detain people and actively disperse the column.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F223", "text": "On 20 March 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy branch of the Investigative Committee dismissed ten individual complaints and two official enquiries made in relation to the allegedly unlawful acts of the police in dispersing the rally on 6 May 2012, including excessive use of force and arbitrary arrests.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F224", "text": "The two official enquiries dismissed on 20 March 2013 were made by Mr I. Ponomarev, a deputy of the State Duma, and Mr A. Babushkin, President of the Public Supervisory Committee of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F225", "text": "The Investigative Committee interviewed one of the ten individuals who had lodged the complaints and four police officers deployed in the cordon around Bolotnaya Square, including squadron and regiment commanders.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F226", "text": "The police officers stated that they had been acting under orders to maintain public safety and to identify and arrest the most active instigators of unrest, and that only those resisting the demands of the police had been arrested and no force had been used unnecessarily.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F227", "text": "The police officers stated that when the police had had to intervene, they had used combat manoeuvres and truncheons but not tear gas or other exceptional means of restraint.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F228", "text": "Squadron Commander S. explained that he had been deployed in the sector adjacent to the stage and that there had been no incidents or disorder in that sector and no one had been arrested.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F229", "text": "The decision of 20 March 2013 listed thirteen other internal inquiries carried out following individual complaints and medical reports; in six cases the allegations of abuse had been found to be unsubstantiated and in seven cases the police conduct had been found to be lawful.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F230", "text": "The Investigative Committee found on 20 March 2013 that after the organisers had decided to call a sit-down protest they provoked mass disorder, during which the participants threw various objects at the police, causing injuries to some of them, and that the police officers detained those participating in the mass disorder with justifiable use of force.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F231", "text": "The Investigative Committee refused on 20 March 2013 to institute criminal proceedings against the police officers for the absence of corpus delicti.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F232", "text": "On 24 May 2013 the first criminal case against twelve individuals suspected of participation in mass disorder was transferred to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow for the determination of criminal charges (the first Bolotnaya case).", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F233", "text": "On 2 December 2013 Mr A. Navalnyy gave testimony as a witness in the first Bolotnaya case before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F234", "text": "Mr A. Navalnyy testified that the political organisers and the formal organisers all had a clear idea that the march would follow the same route as the one that had taken place on 4 February 2012, as confirmed by the Moscow mayor's office.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F235", "text": "Mr A. Navalnyy testified that two days beforehand maps showing where people would assemble and the route of the march were published on the official news website RiaNovosti and on the police website 'Petrovka, 38'.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F236", "text": "Mr A. Navalnyy testified that when the march approached the venue of the meeting, they saw that the map showing where people would assemble on the square had been essentially altered, with the park at Bolotnaya Square, taking up approximately 80% of the square, barred and cordoned off.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F237", "text": "Mr A. Navalnyy testified that since the cordon did not correspond to the map, the column stopped and the event organisers and the people who came just waited for the police to remove the wrong cordon and for the police chiefs to reply as to what had changed.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F238", "text": "Mr A. Navalnyy testified that to show visually that they were not going anywhere, the leaders sat on the ground, and that the first line of the police cordon was composed of 20-year-old conscripts and with a thousand people pressing on it the cordon broke.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F239", "text": "Mr A. Navalnyy testified that no authorities were present on the spot and it was impossible to understand who was in command, and that State Duma deputies present on the spot tried to act as negotiators but said that nobody wanted to come up to them.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F240", "text": "Mr A. Navalnyy testified that when he was in the detention facility he lodged a complaint concerning the hindrance of a peaceful public event with the Moscow Department of the Interior, setting out arguments that officials of the Moscow Department of the Interior had deliberately provoked the crowd to panic so that they could later make claims regarding mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F241", "text": "On 2 December 2013 Mr S. Davidis gave testimony as a witness in the first Bolotnaya case before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F242", "text": "Mr S. Davidis testified that the negotiations with the mayor's office were very difficult this time and that it was only on 4 May 2012 that the organisers received the written agreement, with practically twenty-four hours' notice.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F243", "text": "Mr S. Davidis testified that the organisers could not bring the vehicles carrying the stage to the square before 1 p.m. on 6 May 2012 and only had three hours to put up the stage.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F244", "text": "Mr S. Davidis testified that at the working meeting on 4 May 2012, because there was no time for an on-site reconnaissance, at Mr D. Deynichenko's suggestion it was stated that in organising the event they would follow the example of the assembly held on 4 February 2012.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F245", "text": "Mr S. Davidis testified that the only thing noted at the working meeting was that the stage would be a bit closer to the park at Bolotnaya Square, at the corner of the square, because originally it had been declared that there would be 5,000 participants.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F246", "text": "Mr S. Davidis testified that when he called Mr D. Deynichenko the following day, Mr Deynichenko told him that he had had a map drawn up by the Department of the Interior and that Mr S. Udaltsov could come during the day to see it, but Mr Deynichenko postponed the meeting several times and then no longer answered the phone.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F247", "text": "Mr S. Davidis testified that the closure of the park was not discussed at the working meeting on 4 May 2012, and that it was expressly stated that everything except the position of the stage would be the same as on 4 February 2012.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F248", "text": "Mr S. Davidis testified that the official website of the Moscow Department of the Interior published the map on which it was shown, just as agreed and just as on 4 February 2012, that the border of the meeting venue was outlined at the far end of the park and not the near one, and that all agreements were breached.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F249", "text": "Mr S. Davidis testified that when the emergency occurred he called Mr S. Udaltsov to tell him that the police were trying to terminate the meeting, but Mr Udaltsov replied that they were already heading to the stage and had ended the sit-in protest.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F250", "text": "Mr S. Davidis testified that the police officers did not answer phone calls and he did not manage to find anyone in charge of the police.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F251", "text": "On 5 December 2013 Mr B. Nemtsov gave testimony as a witness in the first Bolotnaya case before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F252", "text": "Mr B. Nemtsov testified that on the website of the Moscow Department of the Interior a map was posted showing that the park of Bolotnaya Square should have been open, but it turned out to be closed.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F253", "text": "Mr B. Nemtsov testified that on 4 February 2012 there was an authorised event where all of Bolotnaya Square was open with no cordons on Bolshoy Kamennyy Bridge, and they were sure that on 6 May 2012 it would be exactly the same, but the police had blocked Bolotnaya Square leaving a very narrow passage for the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F254", "text": "Mr B. Nemtsov testified that they sat on the ground to show the police that they were not going to storm the Kremlin and Bolshoy Kamennyy Bridge, and that State Duma deputy Mr G. Gudkov offered to be an intermediary in the negotiations between the protesters and the police but his attempts to negotiate came to nothing.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F255", "text": "Mr B. Nemtsov testified that when he arrived at the stage the microphones had all been switched off, Mr A. Navalnyy and Mr S. Udaltsov had been arrested just before him, and within a few minutes of taking a megaphone and addressing the people the police apprehended him.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F256", "text": "Mr B. Nemtsov testified that the demonstration took place just one day before Mr Putin's inauguration and that the fact that the authorities had breached the agreement and closed off the square proved that there were political orders.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F257", "text": "On 18 December 2013 Ms N. Mirza, the head of the Ombudsman's secretariat, gave testimony as a witness in the first Bolotnaya case before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F258", "text": "Ms N. Mirza testified that on 6 May 2012 she was present as an observer and that unlike the usual events held at Bolotnaya Square, the park was cordoned off.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F259", "text": "Ms N. Mirza testified that Police Colonel V. Biryukov called and asked her and the Ombudsman to return urgently to Malyy Kamennyy Bridge where protesters had sat down on the ground, and that the Ombudsman tried to persuade these people to stand up and go and conduct the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F260", "text": "Ms N. Mirza testified that the second riot police cordon, which had stood between Bolshoy Kamennyy Bridge and Malyy Kamennyy Bridge, apparently approached the crowd, therefore the pressure built up from both sides.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F261", "text": "Ms N. Mirza testified that she tried to leave the congested area and showed her observer's badge but the riot police would not listen to her and continued to press, without reacting.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F262", "text": "Ms N. Mirza testified that Police Colonel V. Biryukov told her that he could do nothing, that he was not in charge of the riot police and that the riot police reported to the federal police.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F263", "text": "Ms N. Mirza testified that as she was later told by Police Colonel V. Biryukov, the protesters had sat down on the ground because the passage had been narrowed down, and she confirmed that the passage was much narrower than usual and there were metal detectors which were not supposed to be there.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F264", "text": "Ms N. Mirza testified that after the cordon had already been broken and the arrests had begun, she heard through a megaphone that the meeting was over and that people should disperse.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F265", "text": "On 23 December 2013 Mr N. Svanidze, a member of the Civic Chamber of the Russian Federation, gave testimony as a witness in the first Bolotnaya case before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F266", "text": "Mr N. Svanidze testified that on 6 May 2012 he was present as an observer and that when everybody headed towards the narrow bottleneck at the embankment it created a jam, several dozen people sat on the ground, and the cordon moved towards them.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F267", "text": "Mr N. Svanidze testified that he asked why the passage would not be opened, but Police Colonel V. Biryukov kept turning his face away and would not answer, and Mr Svanidze understood that there was no point talking to him as he was not in command.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F268", "text": "Mr N. Svanidze testified that neither the Ombudsman nor anyone else was able to get the passage widened despite requesting it.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F269", "text": "Mr N. Svanidze testified that there were no calls to move towards the Kremlin during the event.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F270", "text": "Mr N. Svanidze testified that he was convinced that the meeting had been authorised at Bolotnaya Square and the park at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F271", "text": "On 23 December 2013 Mr Vasilyev, a staff member at the Ombudsman's office, gave testimony as a witness in the first Bolotnaya case before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F272", "text": "Mr Vasilyev testified that on 6 May 2012 he was present as an observer and that on that day they gathered at the press centre of the Moscow Department of the Interior, were given maps, instructions on how to behave, and the list of public observers.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F273", "text": "Mr Vasilyev testified that the Ombudsman asked the protesters sitting on the ground why they were not going to the meeting venue, and after they got up and headed on, congestion occurred.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F274", "text": "Mr Vasilyev testified that the Ombudsman told Police Colonel V. Biryukov to let the cordon be moved back so that people could pass, but Police Colonel V. Biryukov told him that it was outside his powers and that he did not know in whose powers it was, at which point the police began breaking the crowd up.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F275", "text": "On 21 February 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow delivered a judgment in the first Bolotnaya case finding eight individuals guilty of participation in mass disorder and of violent acts against police officers during the public assembly on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F276", "text": "The eight individuals found guilty in the first Bolotnaya case received prison sentences of between two and a half and four years; one of them was released on parole.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F277", "text": "Three co-defendants in the first Bolotnaya case had previously been pardoned under the Amnesty Act and a fourth had his case disjoined from the main proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F278", "text": "On 22 May 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy branch of the Investigative Committee dismissed five complaints by individuals who had sustained injuries on 6 May 2012, allegedly through the excessive use of force by the police.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F279", "text": "The five complaints dismissed on 22 May 2014 had originally been a part of the criminal investigation file concerning the mass disorder at Bolotnaya Square, but were subsequently disjoined from it.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F280", "text": "During the investigation of the mass-disorder case, confrontations were conducted between those who had lodged complaints (in the capacity of the accused in the criminal case) and the police officers accused of violence (in the capacity of victims in the criminal case).", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F281", "text": "The Investigative Committee found on 22 May 2014 that in suppressing attempts to break the police cordon, the police officers acted in coordination and concert, without applying physical force or special means of restraint, except that the work of the officers charged with apprehending offenders did involve physical force and special means of restraint in so far as necessary against those resisting.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F282", "text": "The Investigative Committee found on 22 May 2014 that the police officers justifiably used physical force to apprehend the participants in the mass disorder, and also special means of restraint in relation to some of them who attempted to resist.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F283", "text": "On 20 June 2014 the Moscow City Court upheld the judgment of 21 February 2014 in the first Bolotnaya case, having slightly reduced the prison sentences for two of the defendants.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F284", "text": "On 24 July 2014 the Moscow City Court found Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev guilty of organising mass disorder on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F285", "text": "The witness Mr D. Deynichenko testified in the proceedings against Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev that on 4 May 2012 he had taken part in a working meeting at the Moscow Department of Regional Security, and that all necessary agreements were reached with the organisers concerning the order of the march and meeting, the movement of the procession, the stage set-up, access to the meeting venue, barriers and the exit from the stage.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F286", "text": "The witness Mr D. Deynichenko testified that the question of using the park at Bolotnaya Square was not raised at the working meeting because the declared number of participants was 5,000, whereas over 20,000 people could be accommodated in the open area of the square and the embankment.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F287", "text": "The witness Mr D. Deynichenko testified that it had been discussed with the organisers how the cordon would be placed from Malyy Kamennyy Bridge to the park of Bolotnaya Square, so the organisers knew of the cordon in advance.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F288", "text": "The witness Mr D. Deynichenko testified that he had known that at the beginning of the march the event organisers, including Mr S. Udaltsov, had discussed between them that they were not going to turn towards the meeting venue but would stop and try to break the cordon to proceed to Bolshoy Kamennyy Bridge.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F289", "text": "The witness N. Sharapov testified that Mr S. Udaltsov had known the route of the march and had not raised a question regarding opening up the park at Bolotnaya Square, and that the park had been opened up previously as an exception on only one occasion, on 4 February 2012, because it was winter, it was snowing and the declared number of participants had significantly exceeded 5,000.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F290", "text": "According to the statement of the Moscow City Security Department, the meeting venue at Bolotnaya Embankment could accommodate 26,660 people.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F291", "text": "The Moscow City Court in the proceedings against Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev found that no official map had been adopted with the organisers and that the published map had been based on Mr S. Udaltsov's own interview with journalists.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F292", "text": "The witness Mr A. Makhonin testified that on 5 May 2012 he received the security plan, and that before the start of the march he personally met the event organisers Mr S. Udaltsov, Ms N. Mityushkina and Mr S. Davidis and explained to them the order of the meeting and the march, warned against the breach of public order, and asked Mr S. Udaltsov regarding the intention to proceed towards the Kremlin and to cause mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F293", "text": "The witness Mr A. Makhonin testified that Mr S. Udaltsov had assured him that there would be no breaches of order at the event and that they had no intention to approach the Kremlin.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F294", "text": "The witness Mr A. Makhonin testified that he arrived at Bolotnaya Square after the mass disorder had already begun, and that after the mass disorder began he tried calling Mr S. Udaltsov on the phone but there was no reply.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F295", "text": "The witness Mr A. Makhonin testified that Ms N. Mityushkina, at his request, announced the end of the meeting, and the police opened additional exits for those willing to leave and repeated through a loudspeaker the announcement of the end of the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F296", "text": "The witness Police Colonel Y. Zdorenko testified that following information received from undercover sources concerning the possible setting-up of a camp site, at around 9 p.m. on 5 May 2012 he arrived at Bolotnaya Square and organised a search of the area including the park, and the park was cordoned off and guarded.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F297", "text": "The witness Police Colonel Y. Zdorenko testified that if necessary, at the decision of the operational headquarters, the venue allocated for the meeting could have been significantly extended by opening up the park at Bolotnaya Square, but there had been no need for that given that there were no more than 2,500-3,000 persons on Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F298", "text": "The witness M. Volondina testified that before the beginning of the march, police information came through from undercover sources that the event organisers intended to encircle the Kremlin holding hands to prevent the inauguration of the Russian President.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F299", "text": "The witness Y. Vanyukhin testified that on 6 May 2012 at around 6 p.m. Mr S. Udaltsov, while on the way to the stage, told people around him that they were going to set up camp.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F300", "text": "The witness Ms N. Mirza testified in the proceedings against Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev that Police Colonel V. Biryukov had asked her and the Ombudsman to come to Malyy Kamennyy Bridge where some of the protesters, including Mr B. Nemtsov and Mr S. Udaltsov, had not turned right towards the stage but had gone straight to the cordon, where they had begun a sit-in protest on the pretext that access to the park of Bolotnaya Square had been closed and cordoned off.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F301", "text": "The witness Mr A. Babushkin testified in the proceedings against Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev that after the first confrontations between the protesters and the police had begun, the police announced through a loudspeaker that the meeting was cancelled and invited citizens to leave.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F302", "text": "The witness Mr I. Ponomarev testified in the proceedings against Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev that the police cordon had been placed differently from the cordon placed for the similar march on 4 February 2012, and that he proposed to Mr S. Udaltsov that the cordon be pushed back so that the police would go back a few steps and widen access to Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F303", "text": "The witnesses Mr I. Yashin and Mr B. Nemtsov testified in the proceedings against Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev that during the steering committee meeting the question of setting up tents during the public event had not been discussed, and that while Mr G. Gudkov and Mr D. Gudkov were negotiating with the police the crowd built up and suddenly the police began moving forward, the protesters resisted and the cordon broke.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F304", "text": "The witness Mr G. Gudkov, deputy of the State Duma, testified in the proceedings against Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev that at the request of the organisers he had taken part in the negotiations with the police on moving the cordon back and opening up access to the park at Bolotnaya Square, and that he had reached an agreement with the officers of the Moscow Department of the Interior that the cordon would be moved back, but those who had called for a sit-in, including Mr S. Udaltsov, refused to go to the offices of the Moscow Department of the Interior to sign the necessary documents.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F305", "text": "The witness Mr D. Gudkov, deputy of the State Duma, testified in the proceedings against Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev that together with Mr G. Gudkov he had conducted negotiations with the police and an agreement had been reached that the cordon at Malyy Kamennyy Bridge would be moved back and access to the park would be opened up, but at that point some young men in hoodies among the protesters began pushing citizens onto the cordon, after which the cordon broke, the police began the arrests and mass disorder ensued.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F306", "text": "The Moscow City Court in the proceedings against Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev rejected testimonies to the effect that it was the police who had begun moving towards the protesters who were peacefully sitting on the ground and thus provoked the breaking of the cordon, and found that it was the protesters who began pushing against the cordon, causing the crowd to panic, which eventually led to the breaking of the cordon and the ensuing mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F307", "text": "The Moscow City Court in the proceedings against Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev found that the location of the sit-in was outside the venue approved by the Moscow authorities for the public event.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F308", "text": "The Moscow City Court in the proceedings against Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev found that there are no grounds to consider the closure of access to the park of Bolotnaya Square and the placement of a guiding police cordon at the foot of Malyy Kamennyy Bridge to be a provocation, since it was only to indicate the direction and it did not obstruct access to the meeting venue at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F309", "text": "The Moscow City Court in the proceedings against Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev found that the mass disorder organised by Mr S. Udaltsov and others led to the destabilisation of public order and peace in a public place during the conduct of a public event, put a large number of people in danger, and led to considerable psychological tension in the vicinity of Bolotnaya Square in Moscow, accompanied by violence against the police and the destruction of property.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F310", "text": "The Moscow City Court sentenced Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev to four and a half years' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F311", "text": "On 18 March 2015 the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation upheld the judgment of 24 July 2014 convicting Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev, with a number of amendments.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F312", "text": "On 18 August 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow examined another Bolotnaya case and found four individuals guilty of participating in mass disorder and committing violent acts against police officers during the demonstration on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F313", "text": "The four individuals found guilty in the second Bolotnaya case received prison sentences of between two and a half and three and a half years; one of them was released on parole.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F314", "text": "The judgment of 18 August 2014 in the second Bolotnaya case was upheld by the Moscow City Court on 27 November 2014.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012", "3. The reports of the events of 6 May 2012 and the investigation of the \"mass disorder\" case"]}, {"fact_id": "F315", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the applicant arrived at Bolotnaya Square at around 6 p.m. to take part in the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F316", "text": "The applicant stood in front of the stage on Bolotnaya Embankment, within the area designated as the meeting venue.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F317", "text": "According to the applicant, between 6 p.m. and 7 p.m. the area around him remained peaceful, although there was general confusion.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F318", "text": "The applicant claimed that he had not heard any announcement of the termination of the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F319", "text": "The applicant claimed that he had heard the police orders made through a megaphone to disperse, but in the general commotion he was unable to leave immediately and remained within the authorised meeting area until 7 p.m., when he was arbitrarily arrested by the police dispersing the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F320", "text": "The applicant denied that he had received any warning or orders before being arrested.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F321", "text": "The police apprehended the applicant and took him to a police van, where he waited for an hour before it left Bolotnaya Square for the police station.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F322", "text": "According to the applicant, there was no traffic at Bolotnaya Square at the time of his arrest; it was still suspended.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F323", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant was arrested at 8.30 p.m. at Bolotnaya Square because he was obstructing the traffic and had disregarded the police order to move away.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F324", "text": "At 9.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the applicant was taken to the Krasnoselskiy district police station in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F325", "text": "At the Krasnoselskiy district police station an on-duty officer drew up a statement on an administrative offence on the basis of a report by Police Officer Y., who had allegedly arrested the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F326", "text": "Police Officer Y.'s report contained a handwritten statement that on 6 May 2012 at 9.30 p.m., at 5/16 Bolotnaya Square, together with Police Lieutenant A., he arrested the applicant (Mr Frumkin).", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F327", "text": "The rest of Police Officer Y.'s report was a printed template stating that the applicant, acting in a group of citizens, took part in an authorised meeting, went out onto the road and thus obstructed the traffic, did not react to the multiple demands of the police to vacate the road, thereby disobeying a lawful order of the police, who were fulfilling their service duty of maintaining public order and ensuring safety, and thereby committed an administrative offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F328", "text": "The statement on the administrative offence contained an identical text to the printed template but indicated that the applicant had been arrested at 8.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F329", "text": "The applicant was charged with obstructing traffic and disobeying lawful police orders, an offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F330", "text": "The applicant's administrative detention was ordered with reference to Article 27.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F331", "text": "The 'reasons' section of the administrative detention order remained blank.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F332", "text": "At 2 p.m. on 7 May 2012 the applicant was taken to court, but his case was not examined.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F333", "text": "Having spent the day in a transit van without food or drink, at 11.55 p.m. on 7 May 2012 the applicant was taken back to the cell at the Krasnoselskiy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F334", "text": "A new order for the applicant's administrative detention was issued on 7 May 2012, indicating that he had been detained 'for the purpose of drawing up the administrative material'.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F335", "text": "At 8 a.m. on 8 May 2012 the applicant was brought before the Justice of the Peace of circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka district, who examined the charges.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F336", "text": "The applicant requested that the case be adjourned on the grounds that he was unfit to stand trial after the detention; this request was rejected in order to expedite the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F337", "text": "The applicant requested that the hearing be opened to the public; this request was rejected in order to expedite the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F338", "text": "The applicant requested that two police officers be examined as witnesses; this request was rejected in order to expedite the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F339", "text": "A further request by the applicant for the examination of several eyewitnesses was partly refused and partly granted, and three witnesses for the defence were examined.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F340", "text": "On the basis of the report written by Police Officer Y., the Justice of the Peace of circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka district established that at 8.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the applicant had been walking along the road at Bolotnaya Square and obstructing the traffic, and that he had then disobeyed lawful police orders to vacate the venue.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F341", "text": "The Justice of the Peace rejected as unreliable two eyewitnesses' testimonies to the effect that the police had not given the applicant any orders or warnings before arresting him.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F342", "text": "The applicant was found guilty of disobeying lawful police orders and was sentenced under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation to fifteen days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F343", "text": "On 11 May 2012 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow examined an appeal lodged by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F344", "text": "At the applicant's request the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow examined Ms S. as a witness on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F345", "text": "Ms S. testified that at 7.46 p.m. on 6 May 2012 she had been looking for her son when she saw the applicant in a police van and spoke to him.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F346", "text": "Ms S. testified that at 9.03 p.m. on 6 May 2012 she had been at Bolotnaya Square; the site had been fully cordoned off and the traffic had not resumed.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F347", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow rejected the applicant's argument that the police report and the police statement were inconsistent as regards the time of his arrest, finding that the correct interpretation was that the time of arrest had been 8.30 p.m. and the detention at the police station 9.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F348", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow dismissed the video-recording submitted by the applicant on the ground that it did not contain the date and the time of the incident, but found that the applicant's guilt had been proved by other evidence.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F349", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow upheld the first-instance judgment convicting the applicant of disobeying lawful police orders.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F350", "text": "On 11 January 2013 the Deputy President of the Moscow City Court examined the applicant's administrative case in supervisory-review proceedings and upheld the earlier judicial decisions.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F351", "text": "The Federal Law on assemblies, meetings, demonstrations, marches and pickets (no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004, the Public Events Act) required that notification of a public event be filed by its organiser in writing with the executive body of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation or the municipal authorities no earlier than fifteen days and no later than ten days prior to the scheduled date of the event.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F352", "text": "Section 8 of the Public Events Act provided that a public event may be held at any venue suitable for the purposes of the event, provided that it does not create a risk of the collapse of buildings or structures or any other threats to the safety of the participants.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F353", "text": "Section 12(1)(iii) of the Public Events Act required the executive body of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation or the municipal authorities, upon receipt of the notification of a public event, to appoint an authorised representative to assist the event organisers in conducting the event in accordance with the law, with the appointment to be formally made by a written decision sent to the event organiser prior to the scheduled date of the event.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F354", "text": "Section 12(1)(iv) of the Public Events Act required the executive body of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation or the municipal authorities to inform the organiser of the public event of the maximum capacity of the territory or venue where the public event is to be held.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F355", "text": "Section 12(1)(v) of the Public Events Act required the executive body of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation or the municipal authorities to ensure, within its competence and jointly with the organiser and the authorised representative of the Ministry of the Interior, public order and the safety of citizens during the public event and, if necessary, to provide them with urgent medical aid.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F356", "text": "Section 12(2) of the Public Events Act required the executive body of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation or the municipal authorities to immediately notify the organiser of the public event by issuing a reasoned written warning if the information in the notification gave grounds to suppose that the aims or conduct of the planned event did not comply with the Constitution of the Russian Federation or were in breach of prohibitions established by administrative or criminal legislation.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F357", "text": "Section 13(1) of the Public Events Act provided that the representative of the executive body of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation or the municipal authorities had the right to require the organiser of a public event to comply with the conditions for holding the event and to decide on the suspension or termination of the public event.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F358", "text": "Section 13(2) of the Public Events Act required the representative of the executive body of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation or the municipal authorities to be present at the public event, to assist the event organiser in the conduct of the public event, and to ensure, jointly with the organiser and the authorised representative of the Ministry of the Interior, public order and the safety of citizens and compliance with the law during the event.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F359", "text": "Section 14(1) of the Public Events Act required the chief of the department of the interior in charge of the territory or venue where the public event is intended to be held to appoint an authorised representative of the Ministry of the Interior to assist the event organiser in maintaining public order and the safety of citizens, with the appointment to be formally made by a written decision.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F360", "text": "Section 14(2) of the Public Events Act provided that the authorised representative of the Ministry of the Interior had the right to require the organiser to announce the closure of access to the event if the maximum capacity of the venue is exceeded, to require the organiser and participants to comply with the conditions for holding the event, and at the request of the event organiser to remove any citizens disobeying the organiser's lawful orders.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F361", "text": "Section 14(3) of the Public Events Act required the authorised representative of the Ministry of the Interior to facilitate the conduct of the public event and to ensure, jointly with the organiser and the executive body, public order and the safety of citizens and compliance with the law during the public event.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F362", "text": "Section 15 of the Public Events Act provided that if during the holding of a public event there occurs, through the fault of the participants, a breach of lawful order which does not entail a risk to the life or health of the participants, the representative of the executive body may require the event organiser to remedy the breach, and if the breach is not remedied the public event shall be terminated in accordance with section 17 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F363", "text": "Section 16 of the Public Events Act provided that a public event may be terminated if the event has created a real danger for the life and health of citizens or for the possessions of individuals or legal persons, or if the participants have committed unlawful acts and the organisers have deliberately breached the provisions of the Public Events Act relating to the conditions for holding the event.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F364", "text": "Section 17(1) of the Public Events Act provided that in the event that a decision to terminate a public event is taken, the authorised representative of the executive body shall order the event organiser to terminate the public event giving the justification, determine a time-limit for compliance, and if the organiser does not comply, address the participants directly and allow additional time for compliance.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F365", "text": "Section 17(2) of the Public Events Act provided that in the event of non-compliance with the order to terminate a public event, the police shall take all necessary measures to terminate the event.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F366", "text": "Section 17(3) of the Public Events Act provided that the procedure for termination set out in section 17(1) shall not apply if mass disorder, riots, arson attacks or other emergency situations occur, in which case the termination shall be carried out in accordance with the legislation of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F367", "text": "Article 212 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provided that the organisation of mass disorder accompanied by violence, riots, arson, destruction of property, use of firearms, explosives and explosive devices, as well as by armed resistance to a public official, shall be punishable by four to ten years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F368", "text": "Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provided that participation in mass disorder as provided for in Article 212 § 1 shall be punishable by three to eight years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F369", "text": "Article 212 § 3 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provided that the instigation of mass disorder or the instigation of participation in it, or the instigation of violence against citizens, shall be punishable by restriction of liberty for up to two years, or community work for up to two years, or deprivation of liberty for the same term.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F370", "text": "Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provided that the use of violence not endangering life or health, or the threat to use such violence, against a public official or his or her relatives in connection with the performance of his or her duties shall be punishable by a fine of up to 200,000 Russian roubles or the equivalent of the convicted person's wages for eighteen months, or community work for up to five years, or up to five years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F371", "text": "Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation provided that failure to obey a lawful order or demand of a police officer in connection with the performance of the officer's official duties relating to maintaining public order and security, or impeding the officer's performance of his or her official duties, shall be punishable by a fine of between RUB 500 and RUB 1,000 or by administrative detention for up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F372", "text": "Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation provided that breaches of the established procedure for the organisation of public gatherings, meetings, demonstrations, marches or pickets shall be punishable by an administrative fine of between ten and twenty times the minimum wage payable by the organisers, and breaches of the established procedure for the conduct of such events shall be punishable by a fine of between RUB 1,000 and RUB 2,000 for the organisers and between RUB 500 and RUB 1,000 for the participants.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F373", "text": "Article 27.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation provided that the escorting or transfer by force of an individual for the purpose of drawing up an administrative-offence report shall be carried out as quickly as possible and shall be recorded in an escort-operation report, an administrative-offence report or an administrative-detention report.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F374", "text": "Article 27.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation provided that administrative detention or short-term restriction of an individual's liberty may be applied in exceptional cases if necessary for the prompt and proper examination of the alleged administrative offence or to secure the enforcement of any penalty imposed, and that where the detained person so requests, his or her family, the administrative department at the person's place of work or study and his or her defence counsel shall be informed of his or her whereabouts.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F375", "text": "Article 27.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation provided that administrative detention shall be recorded in a report, and that if the detained person so requests, he or she shall be given a copy of the administrative-detention report.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F376", "text": "Article 27.5 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation provided that the duration of administrative detention shall not exceed three hours, except in the cases set out in paragraphs 2 and 3 of that Article.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F377", "text": "Article 27.5 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation provided that persons subject to administrative proceedings concerning offences punishable, among other administrative sanctions, by administrative detention may be subject to administrative detention for up to forty-eight hours.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F378", "text": "Article 27.5 § 4 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation provided that the term of administrative detention shall be calculated from the time when a person escorted in accordance with Article 27.2 is taken to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F379", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly adopted by the Venice Commission at its 83rd Plenary Session (Venice, 4 June 2010) provided that an assembly should be deemed peaceful if its organisers have professed peaceful intentions and the conduct of the assembly is non-violent, and that the term 'peaceful' should be interpreted to include conduct that may annoy or give offence, and even conduct that temporarily hinders, impedes or obstructs the activities of third parties.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F380", "text": "The Venice Commission Guidelines recommended that wherever possible, and especially in the case of large assemblies or assemblies on controversial issues, the organiser should discuss with the law enforcement officials the security and public safety measures prior to the event.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F381", "text": "The Venice Commission Guidelines provided that the policing of assemblies must be guided by the human rights principles of legality, necessity, proportionality and non-discrimination, and that the State has a positive duty to take reasonable and appropriate measures to enable peaceful assemblies to take place without participants fearing physical violence.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F382", "text": "The Venice Commission Guidelines provided that if a standoff or other dispute arises during the course of an assembly, negotiation or mediated dialogue may be an appropriate means of trying to reach an acceptable resolution.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F383", "text": "The Venice Commission Guidelines provided that any prior restrictions should be formalised in writing and communicated to the organiser of the event within a reasonable timeframe, and that the relevant authorities must ensure that any restrictions imposed during an event are in full conformity with the law.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F384", "text": "The Venice Commission Guidelines provided that resort to hate speech by participants in an assembly does not of itself necessarily justify the dispersal of the event, and law enforcement officials should take measures only against the particular individuals involved.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F385", "text": "The Venice Commission Guidelines provided that no additional restrictions should be imposed by law enforcement personnel during an assembly unless absolutely necessary in light of demonstrably changed circumstances, and that the detention of participants during an assembly should meet a high threshold and should be used only in the most pressing situations when failure to detain would result in the commission of serious criminal offences.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F386", "text": "The Venice Commission Guidelines provided that the regulatory authority should fairly and objectively assess all available information to determine whether the organisers and participants of a notified assembly are likely to conduct the event in a peaceful manner, and should ensure that any relevant concerns raised are communicated to the event organiser with an opportunity to respond.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F387", "text": "The Venice Commission Guidelines provided that any restrictions placed on an assembly should be communicated in writing to the event organiser with a brief explanation of the reason for each restriction, and that such decisions should be communicated within a reasonable timeframe sufficiently far in advance to allow judicial appeal before the notified date of the event.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F388", "text": "The Venice Commission Guidelines provided that governments must ensure that law enforcement officials receive adequate training in the policing of public assemblies, including soft skills such as negotiation and mediation.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F389", "text": "The Venice Commission Guidelines provided that law enforcement agencies should be proactive in engaging with assembly organizers, that there should be a nominated point of contact within the law enforcement agency whom protesters can contact before or during an assembly, and that the policing operation should be characterized by a policy of 'no surprises'.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F390", "text": "The Venice Commission Guidelines provided that law enforcement officials should differentiate between peaceful and non-peaceful participants, and that neither isolated incidents of sporadic violence nor the violent acts of some participants are themselves sufficient grounds to impose sweeping restrictions on peaceful participants in an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F391", "text": "The Venice Commission Guidelines provided that so long as assemblies remain peaceful, they should not be dispersed by law enforcement officials, and that dispersal of assemblies should be a measure of last resort.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F392", "text": "The Venice Commission Guidelines provided that dispersal should not occur unless law enforcement officials have taken all reasonable measures to facilitate and protect the assembly from harm and unless there is an imminent threat of violence.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F393", "text": "The Venice Commission Guidelines provided that if dispersal is deemed necessary, the assembly organiser and participants should be clearly and audibly informed prior to any intervention by law enforcement personnel, and participants should be given reasonable time to disperse voluntarily before law enforcement officials intervene further.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F018", "F023", "F041", "F043", "F049", "F050", "F067", "F070", "F105", "F107", "F115", "F117", "F123", "F126", "F129", "F137", "F138", "F140", "F228", "F315", "F316", "F317", "F319", "F329", "F342"], "interference": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F041", "F049", "F070", "F073", "F098", "F123", "F124", "F137", "F138", "F140", "F295", "F315", "F316", "F319", "F323", "F324", "F342"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F123", "F362", "F366"], "legitimate_aim": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F033", "F034", "F071", "F073", "F296", "F342"], "necessity": ["F003", "F004", "F006", "F115", "F117", "F123", "F126", "F129", "F156", "F228", "F315", "F316", "F317", "F319", "F322", "F327", "F329", "F342"], "positive_obligation": ["F027", "F028", "F029", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F042", "F065", "F066", "F096", "F097", "F098", "F104", "F105", "F107", "F109", "F110", "F169", "F171", "F262", "F274", "F294"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F018", "F023", "F107", "F228", "F315", "F316", "F317", "F319", "F329"], "interference": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F098", "F123", "F315", "F342"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F123", "F362", "F366"], "legitimate_aim": ["F033", "F034", "F073", "F296"], "necessity": ["F117", "F123", "F156", "F228", "F316", "F317", "F319", "F322", "F329", "F342"], "positive_obligation": ["F027", "F029", "F039", "F040", "F042", "F066", "F096", "F097", "F098", "F104", "F107", "F110", "F169", "F171", "F274", "F294"]}, "list3": ["F029", "F039", "F042", "F097", "F098", "F104", "F110", "F274", "F294", "F315", "F316", "F317", "F319", "F322", "F342", "F156"]}} {"case_name": "case_269", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_270", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1953.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The opposition group Ictimai Palata was planning a demonstration to be held on 19 June 2011 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 9 June 2011, the organisers of the demonstration — consisting of several members of Ictimai Palata — gave prior notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The prior notice given to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) on 9 June 2011 informed it of the date, time, place and purpose of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "According to the notice, the assembly was scheduled to take place from 5 p.m. to 7 p.m. on 19 June 2011 at the square in front of the Narimanov Cinema in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) refused to authorise the holding of the demonstration at the place indicated by the organisers (the square in front of the Narimanov Cinema in Baku).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) proposed another location on the outskirts of Baku as an alternative to the place indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Despite the Baku City Executive Authority's refusal, the organisers decided to hold the demonstration in one of the central areas of Baku, namely near the Puppet Theatre on Seaside Boulevard.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstration was intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstration was conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The participants of the demonstration were demanding free and fair elections.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The participants of the demonstration were demanding democratic reforms.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The participants of the demonstration were demanding freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The participants of the demonstration were demanding the release of persons arrested during some previous demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicant attended the demonstration near the Puppet Theatre on Seaside Boulevard on 19 June 2011.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Shortly after the demonstration had started, the police started to disperse it.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant was arrested at around 6.10 p.m. on 19 June 2011 during the dispersal operation.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant claimed that he had been arrested and taken to a police car by plain-clothed persons.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the official records, the applicant was arrested by police officers Z.H. and J.M.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant was taken to police station No. 9 of the Sabail District Police Office.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Police officers Z.H. and J.M. submitted a report (raport) to a superior police officer stating that at around 6.10 p.m. they were on duty when Mammadov Gafgaz Suleyman oglu, whose identity was established later, was attempting to hold an unlawful demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Police officers Z.H. and J.M. stated in their report (raport) that they demanded that the applicant (Mammadov Gafgaz Suleyman oglu) stop his illegal actions.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Police officers Z.H. and J.M. stated in their report (raport) that the applicant deliberately disobeyed their demand and continued his actions.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Police officers Z.H. and J.M. stated in their report (raport) that for the reason of the applicant's deliberate disobedience they brought him to police station No. 9 of the Sabail District Police Office.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the applicant, he was questioned at police station No. 9 of the Sabail District Police Office after his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "At 6.50 p.m. on 19 June 2011, an administrative-offence report (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) was issued by police officer H.H. in respect of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The administrative-offence report stated that by deliberately failing to comply with the lawful order of the police during the demonstration, the applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant refused to sign the administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The administrative-offence report contained a pre-printed text declaring that the arrested person was familiarised with the report, the reasons for his or her arrest, and his or her rights under Articles 371, 400.2, 401.1.6, and 401.1.7 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) of the Republic of Azerbaijan were explained.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Subsequently, police officer H.H. prepared an administrative-arrest report (inzibati qaydada tutma haqqında protokol).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The administrative-arrest report prepared by police officer H.H. stated that the applicant was subjected to administrative arrest at 8 p.m. on 19 June 2011.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The administrative-arrest report stated that the applicant's administrative arrest was carried out in order to ensure issuance of an administrative-offence report, to ensure a correct and timely examination of the case, and to ensure the execution of decisions, in accordance with Articles 396.1.2 and 398 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with a copy of the administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with other documents in his case file.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to the applicant, he was not given access to a lawyer after his arrest or while he was kept in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2011 and the applicant's \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 20 June 2011, the day after his arrest, the applicant was brought before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the applicant, he refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and insisted on hiring a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the applicant, the judge disregarded his request to hire a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the applicant, his representation by the State-funded lawyer was ineffective and of a formalistic nature.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing before the Sabail District Court was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to the applicant, members of the public, including human rights defenders and journalists, were not allowed to attend the hearing before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Sabail District Court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearing to the public.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant stated before the Sabail District Court that he was not guilty of disobeying a lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant stated before the Sabail District Court that he had participated in the demonstration because he had a constitutional right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to the record of the hearing provided by the Government, the judge asked the applicant whether the police officers, before arresting him, had issued a relevant notice about dispersal of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to the record of the hearing provided by the Government, the applicant answered that there were a lot of police officers and they were demanding that the demonstrators disperse.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "According to the record of the hearing provided by the Government, the applicant stated that the police's demand to disperse was not lawful because the demonstrators were exercising their right.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "According to the record of the hearing provided by the Government, the applicant stated that instead of calling on the demonstrators to disperse, the responsibility of the police should have been to ensure their security.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The only witness questioned during the court hearing before the Sabail District Court was police officer Z.H.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Police officer Z.H. testified that at around 6.10 p.m. on 19 June 2011 he noticed that the applicant, together with a group of other people, was attempting to hold an unauthorised demonstration by shouting out slogans.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Police officer Z.H. testified that he asked the applicant and the group of people to observe silence.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Police officer Z.H. testified that the applicant continued his actions, disobeying the police officers' requests.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "According to the record of the hearing before the Sabail District Court, the State-funded lawyer stated that the applicant was not guilty.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "According to the record of the hearing before the Sabail District Court, the State-funded lawyer asked the court to take into consideration the applicant's age and the fact that he had children.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Sabail District Court found that the applicant had failed to stop participating in the unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Sabail District Court convicted the applicant under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Sabail District Court sentenced the applicant to five days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicant lodged an appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal arguing that his conviction was in violation of his rights because the demonstration in which he had participated had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The applicant complained before the Baku Court of Appeal that his arrest had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The applicant complained before the Baku Court of Appeal that the hearing before the Sabail District Court had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicant urged the Baku Court of Appeal to quash the Sabail District Court's decision.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The applicant was represented before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 24 June 2011, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 24 June 2011, the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the Sabail District Court, stating that its findings had been correct.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Article 49 of the 1995 Constitution of Azerbaijan provides that everyone has the right, having notified respective governmental bodies in advance, to assemble with other people peacefully and without arms, to organise meetings, demonstrations, protests and marches, and to stage pickets.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. 1995 Constitution"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Under Article 5 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, advance written notification is required in order to agree upon the place and time of an assembly and upon the route of a march, with the purpose of enabling the relevant local executive authority to take necessary measures.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Under Article 5 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, the notification must be done in writing five days before the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Article 8 §§ IV and V of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides the relevant local executive authority with broad powers to issue relevant orders so as to prohibit a public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Article 8 § VI of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides the relevant local executive authority with broad powers to issue relevant orders so as to stop a public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Article 9 §§ II and VII of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides the relevant local executive authority with broad powers to restrict or change the place, route and/or time of a public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Article 9 § VI of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides the relevant local executive authority with broad powers to designate specific areas for public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "At the material time, Article 14 § I(2) of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that police authorities have the power, when necessary, to stop an assembly which has not been notified to the authorities beforehand, save for spontaneous assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "At the material time, Article 14 § I(4) of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that police authorities have the power to apprehend and remove from the place where an event is being held persons who came carrying weapons, rocks, pieces of wood and glass, clubs that may pose a threat to people's life and safety or damage property, as well as explosives, flammables, or radioactive materials.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "At the material time, Article 14 § II(2) of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that police authorities have the power to order the organisers and participants of an assembly to use all available opportunities to stop the assembly and to disperse, with regard to the execution of orders specified under Article 8 §§ V and VI of that Law.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "At the material time, Article 14 § II(3) of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that police authorities have the power to warn organisers and participants that physical force or exceptional measures will be used against them if the order to stop the assembly and to disperse is not complied with.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "At the material time, Article 14 § II(4) of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that police authorities have the power to use physical force or exceptional measures in order to stop an assembly and disperse participants, in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "At the material time, Article 14 § II(5) of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that police authorities have the power to apprehend persons not complying with the order to stop an assembly and disperse.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "At the material time, Article 14 § VI of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the use of physical force or exceptional measures by police officers in all circumstances must be proportionate to an existing threat.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "At the material time, Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) of 2000 provided that any breach of the rules, set forth under the legislation, on the organisation and holding of assemblies, demonstrations, protests, marches and pickets shall be punishable by a reprimand or a fine of seven to thirteen manats (AZN).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "At the material time, Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) of 2000 provided that deliberate failure by an individual to comply with the lawful order of a police officer or military serviceman carrying out their duties to protect public order shall be punishable by a fine of twenty to twenty-five manats (AZN) or, if that sanction is inadequate in the circumstances of the case and taking into account the character of the offender, by administrative detention for a term of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "At the material time, Article 376.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) of 2000 provided that if it is impossible for the lawyer chosen by the person against whom administrative-offence proceedings are being carried out to attend, a judge shall appoint a lawyer for that person, in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "At the material time, Article 376.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) of 2000 provided that if a person subjected to an administrative arrest has no possibility to hire a lawyer due to his or her financial situation, his or her legal assistance shall be funded by the State, and in this case a lawyer may not refuse to carry out his or her duties.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "At the material time, Article 396.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) of 2000 provided that an authorised official may use measures to secure administrative-offence proceedings, including administrative arrest (Article 396.1.2), in order to prevent administrative offences, to establish the identity of a person, to draw up an administrative-offence report if this cannot be done at the place of the administrative offence and if the drawing up of a report is important, to ensure the correct and timely examination of administrative-offence cases, and to ensure the implementation of decisions in administrative-offence cases.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "At the material time, Article 398.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) of 2000 provided that administrative arrest, that is the short-term restriction of an individual's liberty, may be applied in exceptional circumstances when deemed necessary for ensuring the correct and timely examination of an administrative-offence case or for the implementation of a decision in an administrative-offence case, except for instances set out in legislation.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "At the material time, Article 410.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) of 2000 provided that a copy of the administrative-offence report shall be given to an individual who is subject to the administrative-offence proceedings or to a representative of a legal entity.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "At the material time, Article 414.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) of 2000 provided that a report concerning an administrative offence punishable by administrative detention shall be sent to a judge for examination immediately after it has been drawn up.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "At the material time, Article 422.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) of 2000 provided that cases concerning an administrative offence punishable by administrative detention shall be examined on the day of receipt by the court of an administrative-offence report, and cases against persons subjected to administrative arrest shall be examined at the latest within 48 hours of their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Under Article 368 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) of 2000, a public prosecutor has a right to participate in administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Chapter 28 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) of 2000 enumerates the participants of administrative proceedings and their rights and obligations.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Chapter 28 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) of 2000 does not mention the prosecution — a police officer, public prosecutor or any other public official representing the prosecution — as a participant of the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, in document CommDH(2011)33 dated 29 September 2011, noted that his attention was drawn to the wave of arrests of activists and political opponents in connection with protests held in Baku in March and April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "According to information received by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, the protests held in Baku in March and April 2011 were sometimes dispersed with excessive force, and the work of journalists was hindered.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe noted that the organisers of protests in Baku in March and April 2011 were denied permission to demonstrate in a central square and other places in the city centre in Baku, and were instead authorised to hold a demonstration in the outskirts of the city.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe noted that several persons were detained on grounds of violating public order in connection with protests held in Baku in March and April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe noted that six opposition activists were sentenced on 25 August 2011 for participating in actions causing disturbance of public order, following trials whose conformity with human rights standards has been called into question.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, in document CommDH(2011)33 dated 29 September 2011, criticised the method of curbing the impact of a demonstration by allowing it to take place only at another time and at a less central location, thereby diminishing significantly the visibility of the rally and its message to the general public.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, in document CommDH(2011)33 dated 29 September 2011, urged the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure that the right to freedom of peaceful assembly is fully guaranteed in Azerbaijan, in accordance with the Court's case-law.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "In the Report CommDH(2013)14 dated 6 August 2013, Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe Nils Muižnieks noted that the issue of limitations imposed on freedom of assembly had regularly been raised by local and international observers in recent years.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 noted that the most frequent problems encountered in Azerbaijan include the banning of demonstrations in central and easily accessible locations and the use of force to disperse demonstrations which still go ahead, leading to arrests and, in some cases, harsh sentences.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 called on the Azerbaijani authorities to adopt effective measures to prevent the use of force against peaceful protestors by law enforcement officials.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 reiterated the recommendation of the 2010 Report, inviting the Azerbaijani authorities to reform the existing system of internal disciplinary investigations of police ill-treatment and to introduce an independent police complaints body.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 noted that Azerbaijan amended its Law on Freedom of Assembly in 2008, following two opinions adopted by the Council of Europe Venice Commission.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 noted that while the Law on Freedom of Assembly is in line with international standards, undue restrictions of the right to freedom of peaceful assembly are widely reported in practice.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 noted that the problems with freedom of assembly in Azerbaijan mainly stem from the interpretation of Article 5 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, which provides for a notification procedure before convening an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 noted that in 2006, the Venice Commission welcomed the confirmation by representatives of the Government that the requirement in the Law on Freedom of Assembly was for notification and not for a prior permission to hold the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 noted that in 2006, the Venice Commission noted that other provisions of the Law on Freedom of Assembly could, as they currently stood, encourage the competent authorities to issue a blanket prohibition as soon as the notification process proves incomplete.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 noted that in 2007, the Venice Commission added that a system of notification is in itself admissible so long as it is only meant to help the authorities cope more easily with the practical problems involved with the holding of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 noted that in 2007, the Venice Commission stressed that it is important that assemblies can be held with a presumption of legality so as to avoid any chilling effect on organisers and participants.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 noted that the Azerbaijani authorities confirmed that the legislation does not require permission for rallies, but the authorities appear to have interpreted it as requiring such permission, and a system of authorisation has in practice replaced the system of notification.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 noted that peaceful protesters have been effectively banned from demonstrating in central Baku since 2006, despite advanced notification of the assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 noted that several requests by the political opposition or civil society to hold demonstrations were allegedly denied or, when allowed, organisers were obliged to have them in areas very remote from the city centre of Baku.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 expressed concern about the way the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 is currently being implemented in Azerbaijan and called on the authorities to assess the functioning of that law.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 called on the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure that no authorisation is required for the holding of public demonstrations and that the system of notification is applied in accordance with European standards.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 welcomed the announced publication by the Azerbaijani authorities of a list of locations where demonstrations will be made possible, and called for these to include adequate locations in the centre of Baku and other cities.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 stated that the authorities should seek to facilitate and protect public assemblies at the organisers' preferred location, given the need for tolerance in a democratic society.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 noted a concern relating to the reported non-implementation of due process standards in proceedings brought against participants in unauthorised demonstrations in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 stated that participants in peaceful assemblies should not be sanctioned for the mere fact of being present at and actively participating in the demonstration in question, provided they do not do anything illegal, violent or obscene in the course of it.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 urged the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure that no disproportionate sanction, which would undermine the fundamental right to peaceful assembly, is imposed.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 called on the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure the full respect of fair trial guarantees for protesters.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report 'Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent' (2013) noted that the Baku municipal authorities have implemented a blanket ban on all opposition demonstrations in the city center since early 2006.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report 'Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent' (2013) noted that the authorities have broken up unsanctioned demonstrations — often with violence — and have arrested and imprisoned peaceful protestors, organizers, and participants.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report 'Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent' (2013) noted that the misdemeanor trials of those charged for involvement in unsanctioned protests are perfunctory.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report 'Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent' (2013) noted that while the constitution of Azerbaijan stipulates that groups may peacefully assemble after simply notifying the relevant government body in advance, in practice authorities require that gatherings obtain a permit issued by local municipalities.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report 'Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent' (2013) noted that municipal authorities have effectively banned all forms of peaceful protest from the center of Baku and instead force all demonstrations into designated zones on the outskirts of the city.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report 'Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent' (2013) stated that such a blanket ban on freedom of assembly in the central areas of Baku violates Azerbaijan's international obligations to respect freedom of assembly and expression.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report 'Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent' (2013) noted that for several years police have dispersed, at times violently, peaceful protests in Baku's center.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report 'Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent' (2013) noted that in the days before and during the Eurovision Song Contest held in Baku in May 2012, police broke up several protests in the city's center and briefly detained dozens of peaceful demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report 'Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent' (2013) noted that in 2011, when activists inspired by the uprisings in the Middle East and North Africa launched protests in Azerbaijan, the government responded by arresting hundreds of protesters, activists, and journalists.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report 'Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent' (2013) noted that several protesters in Azerbaijan in 2011 were convicted of public order offences and imprisoned for up to three years.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report 'Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent' (2013) noted that the Azerbaijani authorities regularly use administrative or misdemeanor charges to lock up people for organizing or participating in unsanctioned rallies, then prosecuting and convicting them in perfunctory trials.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F016", "F017", "F056", "F057", "F058"], "interference": ["F007", "F009", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F028", "F056", "F057", "F058"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F007", "F017", "F028", "F056", "F057", "F066", "F067", "F069", "F070", "F071", "F072", "F081", "F104", "F105", "F110", "F111", "F124"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F004", "F005", "F007", "F010", "F011", "F016", "F017", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F027", "F028", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F056", "F057", "F058", "F064", "F065", "F066", "F067", "F080", "F081"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F016", "F017", "F056"], "interference": ["F017", "F018", "F056", "F057"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F007", "F028", "F066", "F069", "F070", "F081", "F110", "F111"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F004", "F007", "F010", "F011", "F017", "F022", "F023", "F056", "F057", "F058", "F065", "F066", "F080", "F081"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F004", "F007", "F010", "F011", "F017", "F018", "F056", "F057", "F058", "F066", "F080", "F081"]}} {"case_name": "case_271", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of nationwide protests in support of the jailed opposition leader, Aleksey Navalnyy.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of nationwide protests in support of the jailed opposition leader, Aleksey Navalnyy.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_272", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of unlawful detention (deprivation of liberty).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F003"], "interference": ["F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003"], "interference": ["F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_273", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_274", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1958.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "In 2003 a presidential election was held in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The first round of the 2003 Armenian presidential election took place on 19 February 2003.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant acted as an authorised election assistant (վստահված անձ) for the main opposition candidate in the 2003 Armenian presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The second round of the 2003 Armenian presidential election took place on 5 March 2003.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "At the second round of the 2003 Armenian presidential election, the applicant was a member of one of the district election commissions.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Following the 2003 Armenian presidential election, the applicant participated in a series of rallies of protest organised in Yerevan by the opposition parties.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant alleged, and the Government did not dispute, that at the beginning of April 2003 police officers of the Central District Police Station of Yerevan (ՀՀ ոստիկանության Երևան քաղաքի կենտրոնական բաժին) came to the applicant's home while he was absent.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Having found out that police officers had come to his home, the applicant went to the Central District Police Station of Yerevan to inquire about the reasons for their visit.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "At the Central District Police Station of Yerevan, the Deputy Head ordered the applicant to stop participating in the demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 7 April 2003 at 17h00 a demonstration was held in the centre of Yerevan on the occasion of Mother's Day.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The demonstration of 7 April 2003 took place on the Mashtots Avenue next to the Research Institute of Ancient Manuscripts (Մատենադարան).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The demonstration of 7 April 2003 appears to have been of a political nature, and criticism of the Government and of the conduct of the 2003 Armenian presidential election was voiced at it.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant alleged, and the Government did not dispute, that the demonstration of 7 April 2003 was organised by women.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicant alleged, and the Government did not dispute, that the demonstration of 7 April 2003 was attended by about 30,000 people, the majority of whom were female.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Traffic was suspended by the traffic police on the relevant stretch of Mashtots Avenue prior to the commencement of the demonstration of 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant did not as such participate in the demonstration of 7 April 2003, since most men, including himself, were observing it from a distance, standing on both sides of Mashtots Avenue.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The task of the men observing the demonstration of 7 April 2003 from a distance, including the applicant, was to encourage the women and to prevent possible provocations.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the applicant, at around 17h30 on 7 April 2003 he went home.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the applicant, on his way home on 7 April 2003, about 100-150 metres away from the site of the demonstration, he was approached by two persons in civilian clothes who showed police identity papers.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the applicant, the two persons in civilian clothes who approached him on 7 April 2003 took him to the Central District Police Station of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "At the Central District Police Station of Yerevan, the arresting police officers drew up a record of the applicant's arrest (արձանագրությաւն բերման ենթարկելու մասին).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The record of the applicant's arrest stated that the applicant had been 'arrested at around 17h30 on the Mashtots Avenue for obstructing traffic and behaving in an anti-social way at a demonstration'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "One of the arresting police officers reported to the Head of the Central District Police Station of Yerevan (ՀՀ ոստիկանության Երևան քաղաքի կենտրոնական բաժնի պետ) that on 7 April 2003 the officers were on duty at the Mashtots Avenue, where a demonstration was being held and a great number of people were gathered.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "One of the arresting police officers reported to the Head of the Central District Police Station of Yerevan that while on duty on 7 April 2003 they noticed one person who was obstructing traffic, behaving in an anti-social way and inciting others to follow his example.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "One of the arresting police officers reported to the Head of the Central District Police Station of Yerevan that the person observed obstructing traffic and behaving in an anti-social way on 7 April 2003 was brought to the Central District Police Station of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant was subjected to a search at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan during which no illegal items were found.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "A record of the search of the applicant was drawn up at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The police officers questioned the applicant at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant made a written statement (արձանագրություն բացատրություն վերցնելու մասին) in which he submitted that he had participated in a demonstration three days before 7 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "In his written statement, the applicant submitted that having found out about the demonstration of 7 April 2003, he had also gone there.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "In his written statement, the applicant submitted that he was aware of a demonstration to be held in two days and that he would participate in it.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "In his written statement, the applicant added that he had not violated, and would not violate, any laws during the demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant's first written statement was torn up by the police officers, who said that there was a pencil mark and asked the applicant to write a new one.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "When the applicant wrote a new written statement with similar content, the police officers stopped him at the point when he was about to write about not having committed any offences during the demonstrations and said that what he had written was enough.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The police officers drew up a record of an administrative offence (վարչական իրավախախտման արձանագրություն) stating that the applicant had 'participated in a demonstration, during which he violated public order'.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant's actions were qualified under Article 172 of the Code of Administrative Offences (Վարչական իրավախախտումների վերաբերյալ ՀՀ օրենսգիրք) as minor hooliganism.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The record of an administrative offence was signed by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicant put his signature in the section of the record of an administrative offence certifying that he was made aware of his rights under Article 267 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicant put his signature in the section of the record of an administrative offence marked as 'other information relevant for the determination of the case', where he also added 'I do not wish to have a lawyer'.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicant alleged that he had initially refused to sign the record of an administrative offence and requested a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The applicant alleged that his initial refusal to sign the record of an administrative offence and his request for a lawyer was the reason why he was kept at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan for the following five and a half hours.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant alleged that during the period he was kept at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan, the police officers were persistently trying to convince him to sign the record of an administrative offence and to refuse a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant alleged that the police officers told him it was unnecessary to have a lawyer and spend money for such a minor case.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicant alleged that the police officers told him the case had been already pre-decided by their superiors, so a lawyer would only harm rather than help, and that he may end up spending quite some time at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan because of that.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant alleged that the police officers told him that if he signed the record of an administrative offence and refused a lawyer, he would be immediately taken to a court, where at worst a small fine would be imposed and he would be released.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant alleged that he finally succumbed and agreed to sign the record of an administrative offence and to refuse a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 7 April 2003 at 23h00 the applicant was taken to judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan (Երևան քաղաքի Կենտրոն և Նորք-Մարաշ համայնքների առաջին ատյանի դատարան), who examined the case.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Government contested the applicant's allegation that he was kept at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan for five and a half hours under pressure to sign the record of an administrative offence and refuse a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant was kept at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan for two hours and taken to judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan at 19h30.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "According to the Government, during the period the applicant was kept at the Central District Police Station of Yerevan, the police officers explained to the applicant his right to have a lawyer and advised him to avail himself of this right, which he did not wish to do.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "According to the Government, the record of an administrative offence was signed by the applicant voluntarily and without any objections.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant failed to initiate any actions aimed at the defence of his rights, such as lodging motions or availing himself of other procedural rights guaranteed by Article 267 of the Code of Administrative Offences, despite having been made aware of them.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The materials of the applicant's administrative case transmitted by the police to judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan for examination contained the record of an administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The materials of the applicant's administrative case transmitted by the police to judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan for examination contained the police report.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The materials of the applicant's administrative case transmitted by the police to judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan for examination contained the record of the applicant's arrest.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The materials of the applicant's administrative case transmitted by the police to judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan for examination contained the record of the applicant's search.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The materials of the applicant's administrative case transmitted by the police to judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan for examination contained the applicant's written statement.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "All documents in the applicant's administrative case materials were signed by the applicant except the police report.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan, after a brief hearing, sentenced the applicant under Article 172 of the Code of Administrative Offences to three days of administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The judge's entire finding in the applicant's case amounted to the following sentence: 'On 7 April 2003 at around 17h00 ... on the Mashtots Avenue [the applicant], together with a group of people, obstructed street traffic, violated public order by making a loud noise, and incited other participants of the demonstration to do the same...'", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The decision of judge M. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan stated that it was subject to review by the Chairman of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal (ՀՀ քրեական և զինվորական գործերով վերաքննիչ դատարանի նախագահ).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing — drawn up in calligraphic handwriting — the hearing in the applicant's case was held in public with the participation of the judge, a clerk and the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing, the judge explained the applicant's rights to him and informed him of the possibility to challenge the judge and the clerk.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing, the applicant did not wish to lodge any challenges.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing, the applicant stated that he was aware of his rights and did not wish to have a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing, the judge read out the motion submitted by the police, seeking to impose administrative liability on the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing, the applicant stated that he, together with a group of unknown people, had blocked the traffic on the Mashtots Avenue.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing, the applicant said that he blocked traffic because it was a demonstration and everybody else was doing the same.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing, the applicant said he made noise since everybody else was making noise, but he did not push anybody.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing, no questions were put to the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing, the judge read out and examined the materials prepared by the police.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing, having familiarised himself with the materials prepared by the police, the applicant accepted that he had signed the record of an administrative offence but objected to being subjected to administrative liability since the incriminated acts had been committed also by others.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "According to the record of the court hearing, the judge departed to the deliberation room, after which he returned and announced the decision.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The time of the hearing in the applicant's case was not recorded in the record of the court hearing.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The applicant alleged, and the Government did not explicitly dispute, that the record of the court hearing was a fake and was drafted at some point after the hearing in order to create an appearance of lawfulness.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The applicant alleged that in reality there was no clerk at the hearing and the hearing was not being recorded.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The applicant alleged that the hearing lasted only about five minutes and was conducted in judge M.'s office.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The applicant alleged that, contrary to what the record of the court hearing stated, only judge M., the applicant and the accompanying police officer were present at the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The applicant alleged that the accompanying police officer did not as such participate in the hearing and his functions were limited only to bringing the applicant before judge M.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The applicant alleged that judge M. listed the materials prepared by the police and asked the applicant 'what do you want?', to which the applicant replied 'Justice and lawfulness'.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The applicant alleged that judge M. continued reading through the materials and said 'since you have three children and have not been guilt-stained in the past, I will impose a mild sentence of three days of detention'.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The applicant alleged that in reply he tried to present the circumstances of the case, petitioned judge M. to summon some witnesses and requested a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The applicant alleged that judge M. listened silently to the applicant, signed some papers and let the applicant go, after which the applicant was taken to a detention centre where he served his sentence.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On 14 April 2003 the applicant applied to a local human rights NGO called 'February 22nd' («Փետրվարի 22» իրավապաշտպան կազմակերպություն), complaining in detail about the events of 7 April 2003 and seeking its assistance.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The applicant submitted to the NGO 'February 22nd', inter alia, that the police officers had prompted him to sign a document refusing a lawyer, persuading him that a lawyer was not necessary in his case.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "On 28 April 2003 the NGO 'February 22nd' complained to the General Prosecutor (ՀՀ գլխավոր դատախազ) on behalf of the applicant, seeking to institute criminal proceedings against the police officers and judge M.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "By a letter of 27 May 2003 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Prosecutor (Կենտրոն և Նորք-Մարաշ համայնքների դատախազ) informed the NGO 'February 22nd' that the decision of 7 April 2003 had been well-founded and there were no grounds for lodging a protest.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Article 24 of the Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005) provides that everyone has the right to express his opinion.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005)"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Article 24 of the Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005) provides that it is prohibited to force anyone to give up or change his opinion.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005)"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Article 24 of the Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005) provides that everyone has the right to freedom of expression, including the freedom to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any information medium regardless of frontiers.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005)"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Article 26 of the Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005) provides that citizens have the right to hold peaceful assemblies, rallies, processions and demonstrations without carrying arms.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005)"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Article 39 of the Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005) provides that everyone has the right to have his violated rights restored, as well as, in the determination of a charge against him, the right to a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal with a respect for equality of arms.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005)"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Article 40 of the Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005) provides that everyone has the right to legal assistance, and that in cases prescribed by law legal assistance is provided free of charge.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005)"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Article 40 of the Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005) provides that everyone has the right to have a defence counsel from the moment of his arrest, detention or accusation.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005)"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Article 44 of the Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005) provides that no restrictions may be placed on the exercise of the rights and freedoms guaranteed under Articles 23-27 of the Constitution other than such as are prescribed by law and are necessary in the interests of national security or public safety, for the protection of public order, health or morals, or for the protection of the rights, freedoms, honour and reputation of others.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005)"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Article 94 of the Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005) provides that the guarantor of independence of the judicial authorities is the President of Armenia, who presides over the Council of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005)"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Following the amendments of 2005, Article 94 of the Constitution of Armenia provides that the independence of the courts is guaranteed by the Constitution and by law.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005)"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "Following the amendments of 2005, Article 94.1 of the Constitution of Armenia provides that the Council of Justice is composed of nine judges elected for a period of five years by secret ballot at the general meeting of judges of Armenia, and of four legal scholars, two appointed by the President of Armenia and two by the National Assembly, with meetings presided over by the President of the Court of Cassation who does not have the right to vote.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005)"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Article 95 of the Constitution of Armenia of 1995 provides that the Council of Justice, upon the proposal of the Minister of Justice, shall prepare and submit for the President's approval the annual lists of professional fitness and career development of judges on the basis of which appointments are made.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005)"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "Article 96 of the Constitution of Armenia of 1995 provides that a judge is irremovable and shall stay in his post until the age of 65.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005)"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "Article 97 of the Constitution of Armenia of 1995 provides that in administering justice, a judge is independent and obeys only the law.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of Armenia of 1995 (prior to the amendments introduced in 2005)"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "Article 9 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that a person shall be liable to an administrative penalty for offences envisaged by the Code, if these offences by their nature do not attract a criminal penalty in accordance with the law.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Article 22 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that an administrative penalty is a form of liability imposed in order to educate the person who has committed an administrative offence to uphold the laws and to respect the rules of socialist way of life, as well as to deter the offender and others from committing new offences.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Article 23 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that administrative penalties that may be imposed include, inter alia, a fine, correctional labour, and administrative detention; the provisions concerning correctional labour and administrative detention are no longer in force as of 16 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Article 31 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 (no longer in force as of 16 December 2005) provides that administrative detention is prescribed and imposed only in exceptional cases for certain types of administrative offences for a period not exceeding fifteen days, and is imposed by a court (a judge).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Article 172 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 (no longer in force as of 16 December 2005) defines minor hooliganism as obscene swearing at a person or an offensive annoyance of a person in a public place and other similar actions which disturb public order and peace of citizens, and prescribes a fine, correctional labour, or administrative detention not exceeding 15 days.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Article 223 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that judges of first instance courts examine cases concerning administrative offences envisaged by, inter alia, Article 172 of the Code.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Article 249 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that cases on administrative offences are examined in public.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Article 250 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that the public prosecutor who monitors the enforcement of laws in the context of proceedings on administrative cases is entitled to institute administrative proceedings, familiarise himself with the materials of the case, scrutinise the lawfulness of actions of the authorities in the course of the administrative proceedings, participate in the examination of the case, and lodge motions and make conclusions in respect of questions arising during the examination of the case.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Article 251 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that evidence in an administrative case consists of any facts on the basis of which the authorities establish the existence or absence of an administrative offence and the guilt of a particular person, as well as other circumstances decisive for the proper outcome of the case.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Article 251 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that such facts are established by the record of an administrative offence, the statement of the person against whom administrative proceedings are brought, testimonies of the victim and witnesses, expert opinions, exhibits, the record of seizure of objects and documents, as well as by other documents.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Article 254 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that the record of an administrative offence shall be drawn up by an authorised official.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Article 255 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that the record of an administrative offence shall contain the date and location when and where it was drafted, the post and name of the person drafting it, information concerning the offender, the location, time and essence of the administrative offence, the legal act prescribing a penalty for the offence committed, names and addresses of witnesses and victims if any, the explanation of the offender, and other information necessary for the determination of the case.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Article 255 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that the record of an administrative offence shall be signed by the person drafting it and the offender, and that if the offender refuses to sign, a relevant entry is made in the record.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Article 255 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that when drafting the record, the offender must be made aware of his rights and obligations under Article 267 of the Code and a relevant entry must be made in the record.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Article 256 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that the record of an administrative offence shall be transmitted to the authority (public official) authorised to examine the administrative case.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Article 259 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that in order to prevent administrative offences, if other measures of compulsion have been exhausted, and to ensure the timely and accurate examination of cases and the enforcement of decisions, a person may be subjected to an administrative arrest, search, inspection of belongings and confiscation of belongings and documents, for the purpose of verifying his identity and drawing up a record of an administrative offence, if this record cannot be drawn up on the spot and if such a record is required to be drawn up.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Article 260 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that an administrative arrest must be recorded, and the record must indicate the date and place, the post and the name of the person drawing up the record, information about the arrestee, and the time, place and grounds of the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Article 261 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that only authorities (officials) authorised by the laws of the USSR and Armenia can impose an administrative arrest on a person who has committed an administrative offence, including the internal affairs authorities in cases of minor hooliganism.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Article 267 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that the person against whom administrative proceedings are brought has the right to familiarise himself with the materials of the case, to make statements, to submit evidence, to lodge motions, and to have legal assistance during the examination of the case.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Article 271 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that any person who may be aware of any circumstance connected to the case which needs to be clarified may be called as a witness in an administrative case.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Article 277 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that cases concerning administrative offences envisaged under, inter alia, Article 172 of the Code shall be examined within one day.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Article 278 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that at the hearing the examining authority announces the case to be examined and the person against whom administrative proceedings are brought, explains to the persons participating in the case their rights and obligations, reads out the record of an administrative offence, hears the persons participating in the case, examines the evidence and rules on motions, and if a public prosecutor participates, hears his opinion.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Article 279 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that in examining the administrative case, the authority must clarify whether an administrative offence has been committed, whether the person in question is guilty of committing it, whether an administrative penalty should be imposed, whether there are mitigating and aggravating circumstances, and whether pecuniary damage has been caused.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Article 286 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that the court's (the judge's) decision to impose an administrative penalty is final and not subject to appeal in administrative proceedings, except for the cases prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Article 289 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that the prosecutor can lodge a protest against the decision taken on an administrative case.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Article 294 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 1985 provides that the judge's decision to impose an administrative penalty for an offence envisaged under, inter alia, Article 172 of the Code can be quashed or modified by the judge himself upon a protest of the prosecutor and, whether or not such a protest is lodged, by the chairman of the superior court.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Offences of 1985"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Article 5 of the Law on the Status of a Judge (Դատավորի կարգավիճակի մասին ՀՀ օրենք) provides that in administering justice, a judge is independent and obeys only the law, and is not accountable to any public authority or a public official.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. The Law on the Status of a Judge (Դատավորի կարգավիճակի մասին ՀՀ օրենք)"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Article 6 of the Law on the Status of a Judge provides that any interference by public authorities, bodies of local self-government and their officials, political parties, non-governmental associations and media with a judge's performance of his functions of administering justice is impermissible and leads to accountability prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. The Law on the Status of a Judge (Դատավորի կարգավիճակի մասին ՀՀ օրենք)"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Article 6 of the Law on the Status of a Judge provides that a judge is not obliged to give explanations concerning a case or the substance of materials under his consideration or to grant access to them other than in cases and according to a procedure prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. The Law on the Status of a Judge (Դատավորի կարգավիճակի մասին ՀՀ օրենք)"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Chapter 9 of the Ministry of Justice Regulations (ՀՀ արդարադատության նախարարության կանոնակարգ) adopted on 28 November 2002 prescribes the rules for organising and holding the proficiency test on the basis of which the annual lists of professional fitness and career development of judges are prepared by the Ministry of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. The Ministry of Justice Regulations (ՀՀ արդարադատության նախարարության կանոնակարգ) adopted on 28 November 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "On 16 April 2003 the Constitutional Court of Armenia adopted a decision on the basis of an application lodged by the main opposition candidate in the 2003 Armenian presidential election challenging the conduct and results of the election.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC DECISIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Armenia noted, inter alia, that a number of authorised election assistants had been subjected to administrative detention in the second round of the 2003 Armenian presidential election and had thus been deprived of the possibility of actively pursuing their duties any further.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC DECISIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Armenia stated that subjecting persons to administrative detention for having participated in unauthorised demonstrations and marches constituted an interference with the right to freedom of peaceful assembly guaranteed by Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC DECISIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Armenia stated that such application of the administrative detention procedure was in contradiction with European 'rule of law' standards.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC DECISIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Armenia stated that all decisions made by the courts imposing administrative detention for participation in unauthorised demonstrations and marches were to be a topic for discussion in the Council of Court Chairmen and the Council of Justice in terms of both their form and substance.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC DECISIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Resolution 1304 (2002) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe on honouring of obligations and commitments by Armenia invited the Armenian authorities to revise the Administrative Code without delay.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "A. Resolution 1304 (2002) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE): Honouring of obligations and commitments by Armenia"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Resolution 1304 (2002) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe urged the Armenian authorities to abolish the provisions of the Administrative Code concerning administrative detention and to refrain from applying them in the interim.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "A. Resolution 1304 (2002) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE): Honouring of obligations and commitments by Armenia"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Resolution 1304 (2002) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe warned the Armenian authorities of the abuses that the application of administrative detention provisions leads to, which are seriously at variance with the principles of the Council of Europe.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "A. Resolution 1304 (2002) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE): Honouring of obligations and commitments by Armenia"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "The Report by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe, Doc. 10027, dated 12 January 2004, states that the day after the first round of the presidential election held on 9 February 2003, several demonstrations and protest meetings took place in Yerevan and several towns at the prompting of opposition political parties.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "B. Report by the PACE Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe, Doc. 10027, 12 January 2004"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "The Report Doc. 10027 of 12 January 2004 states that between the two rounds of the 2003 Armenian presidential elections, and as from 22 February 2003, more than 200 people were arrested by the police at the behest of the authorities, among them some members of the political parties in opposition or of their campaign staff, and agents of these parties.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "B. Report by the PACE Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe, Doc. 10027, 12 January 2004"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "The Report Doc. 10027 of 12 January 2004 states that the arrested persons were taken into custody without notification of their families, then brought before the courts and sentenced to a fortnight's administrative internment in over 80 cases, or to fines in 65 other cases.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "B. Report by the PACE Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe, Doc. 10027, 12 January 2004"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The Report Doc. 10027 of 12 January 2004 states that the persons arrested between the two rounds of the 2003 Armenian presidential elections were tried in camera and with few exceptions did not receive the assistance of a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "B. Report by the PACE Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe, Doc. 10027, 12 January 2004"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The Report Doc. 10027 of 12 January 2004 states that many of the arrested persons were unable to participate in the second round of the 2003 Armenian presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "B. Report by the PACE Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe, Doc. 10027, 12 January 2004"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The Report Doc. 10027 of 12 January 2004 states that further arrests were made after the second round of the 2003 Armenian presidential election, with the Ministry of Justice acknowledging that 132 people were arrested between 17 and 25 March 2003, 69 of them being sentenced to an 'administrative' custodial penalty and 63 to a fine.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "B. Report by the PACE Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe, Doc. 10027, 12 January 2004"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The Report Doc. 10027 of 12 January 2004 states that according to the OSCE, 77 is the number sentenced to a term of imprisonment over the period of 17 to 25 March 2003.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "B. Report by the PACE Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe, Doc. 10027, 12 January 2004"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "The Report Doc. 10027 of 12 January 2004 describes the summary procedure prescribed by the Administrative Code of Armenia as an authentic remnant of the Communist style of justice inherited from the Soviet era, which denies the person charged the right to inform his/her family or to request the immediate assistance of a lawyer, and enables a judge, under an arrangement for immediate trial in camera, to have him/her held for a fortnight maximum.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "B. Report by the PACE Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe, Doc. 10027, 12 January 2004"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The Report Doc. 10027 of 12 January 2004 states that during an August 2003 visit, the Armenian authorities justified their decision to arrest and convict demonstrators by invoking the need to shield law and order from their misdeeds, claiming that the demonstrators were thugs, 'antisocial elements', alcoholics or drug addicts.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "B. Report by the PACE Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe, Doc. 10027, 12 January 2004"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "The Report Doc. 10027 of 12 January 2004 states that the freedom to demonstrate and the freedom to come and go must be reconciled with respect for law and order, and that preservation of law and order must not serve to condone wrongful deprivation or restriction of freedom to form assemblies and to demonstrate.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "B. Report by the PACE Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe, Doc. 10027, 12 January 2004"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "Resolution 1361 (2004) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe on honouring of obligations and commitments by Armenia states that the Assembly is shocked by the scandalous use that continues to be made of the arbitrary procedures concerning administrative detention provided for in the Administrative Code of Armenia, which is totally incompatible with Resolution 1304 (2002).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "C. Resolution 1361 (2004) of the PACE: Honouring of obligations and commitments by Armenia"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "Resolution 1361 (2004) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe firmly condemns the arrest and conviction of over 270 people — members of the opposition parties, sympathisers and office-holders — between the two rounds of the 2003 Armenian presidential election and at the end of the second round.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "C. Resolution 1361 (2004) of the PACE: Honouring of obligations and commitments by Armenia"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Resolution 1361 (2004) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expects the Armenian authorities to discuss by February 2004 the issue of administrative detention provided for in the Administrative Code in co-operation with Council of Europe experts and to send the draft amendments for the Council of Europe's expertise by April 2004.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "C. Resolution 1361 (2004) of the PACE: Honouring of obligations and commitments by Armenia"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "Resolution 1361 (2004) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe asks the Armenian authorities to immediately begin examining, in co-operation with the Council of Europe, the question of the balance to be struck between freedom of assembly and demonstration and respect for public order, and to adopt a law on demonstrations and public meetings in full compliance with Council of Europe principles and standards.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "C. Resolution 1361 (2004) of the PACE: Honouring of obligations and commitments by Armenia"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 titled 'An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election' states that in the period between the 19 February 2003 round and the 5 March 2003 runoff of the presidential election, the main opposition candidate's campaign staged several rallies in the centre of Yerevan, each of which attracted tens of thousands of supporters.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that after the 5 March 2003 runoff the main opposition candidate's campaign continued to stage rallies in the centre of Yerevan at intervals of several days or a week, to protest alleged election fraud.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that although rallies and protest demonstrations in support of the main opposition candidate were largely peaceful, the governing authorities portrayed them as a threat to public order and political stability, and used this as grounds for arrests.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that in a first wave of arrests between 21 and 27 February 2003, roughly 160 chiefs and staff of regional and district campaign headquarters of the main opposition candidate, authorised election assistants, and even drivers were taken to their local police stations.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that dozens of activists were arrested at their homes in different regions of the country the morning after police supposedly picked them out, among several tens of thousands, at an 'unauthorised' rally in Yerevan in the late afternoon of 21 February 2003.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that when police officers took opposition activists from their homes it was invariably on the pretext that the local police chief wanted to talk to them, and that some activists accompanied the officers willingly while some initially refused but met threats in response.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that in some cases where the police did not initially find the activist at home, they resorted to violent or extra-legal tactics, including taking family members as hostages to compel activists to give themselves up.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that following international pressure, about seventy-five of the eighty-six men serving election rally-related administrative detention sentences were released during the weekend of 1-2 March 2003.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that during the period 18-22 March 2003, as post-election protest rallies continued, the police arrested approximately ninety activists supporting the main opposition candidate in Yerevan, Abovian, Artashat district, Talin, and other areas, with most taken from their homes and dozens receiving administrative detention sentences.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that several men and women were arrested after the 7 April 2003 demonstration in central Yerevan and given administrative fines or terms of detention.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that on bringing opposition activists to the police station, officers kept them in incommunicado detention, depriving them of counsel, which allowed police wide scope to pressure the activists to admit guilt.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that in many cases the police refused to inform or acknowledge to relatives and lawyers of people who had gone missing that they were in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that a lawyer who took on the cases of more than thirty activists taken in the first wave of arrests said that simply finding the people he had been tasked to represent was his primary task, and providing legal assistance came a distant second.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that the wife of an activist arrested in Armavir said: 'For five days they gave no information. We did not know whether he was alive or dead.'", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that when lawyers, relatives, or human rights groups tried to find detainees in custody, police did not cooperate, with lawyer T. T.-Y. stating: 'When we go to police departments, we are told the detainee is in court. When we go to the court, they say he or she is in one of the police departments. Before the confusion is resolved, a court verdict for fifteen days of administrative detention has already been issued.'", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that in Armenia there is no system of obligatory, transparent registration of all detainees at police stations, and that in two cases documented by Human Rights Watch, police pretended detainees were not at a particular police station when they patently were.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that the police kept detainees for as long as they considered necessary, with little apparent reference to procedural rights guarantees.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that with some detained activists the police were initially at a loss as to what to charge them with, and with others the police manipulated the ambiguity, threatening both criminal and administrative charges.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that at Echmiadzin police station, officers threatened to press criminal charges against one defendant if he refused to confess that he resisted and swore at the policemen who had taken him from his home, and that he signed on the strength of their promise that he would only get two days of administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that from mid-March 2003 onward, the police extracted either written confessions or undertakings to take no further part in rallies from a number of activists by threatening to beat them.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that one defendant detained at the Yerevan City Police Department stated that her three interrogators pointed out the lockup in the courtyard, said it was full of women and that they would all be truncheoned that night, showed her black spots on the carpet said to be blood, and through this kind of pressure forced her to write that she took part in a rally and obstructed traffic.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that in several cases police did use violence, including one defendant allegedly being hit on the head with a plastic bottle of water and another recounting being hit with a pistol butt, then punched and kicked.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that in almost all cases, administrative court hearings against opposition activists were closed and cursory, with courts considering only police evidence and not giving the defendant the opportunity to summon defence counsel or defence witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that several factors indicate that the judges acted under the influence of political authorities, including that in many cases judges issued the harshest administrative sentence possible — fifteen days detention — to opposition activists.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that some judges at the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan were frank with defendants about their one-sentence-fits-all policy, with one judge telling a defendant 'Those who took part in the rally — we are giving them all fifteen days' and another stating that 'his instructions were to put us all away for fifteen days — no less.'", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that judges' questioning of several defendants was blatantly political, such as 'Why do you play at opposition?' and 'Why do you bad-mouth the government?', and that judges warned some not to participate in opposition rallies again.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that during the week of 22-28 February 2003, when the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan tried nearly one hundred supporters of the main opposition candidate, 'Red Berets' — police commandos — sealed off the building to the public, and the chairman of the court acknowledged that their deployment was an initiative of the police leadership on which the court was not consulted.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that some defendants demanded lawyers but court officials and police told them that lawyers were either 'not necessary' or 'not allowed' in administrative cases, and that lawyer N.B. was barred from entering the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan on 22 February 2003 to defend his client despite having a contract with the defendant.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that in most cases, hearings lasted from a few seconds to a few minutes and the written judgments were pre-prepared.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that one judge started a defendant's hearing by reading out his sentence — fifteen days detention for having participated in an unauthorised march — and when the defendant objected that he had not participated in the march, the judge said 'It is proven' and called a policeman to take him away.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that two opposition party activists from the Shengavit district of Yerevan were each given three days' detention without learning what they were charged with, and that a judge quelled another defendant's objection to the absence of stated information or grounds for his fifteen-day sentence with the comment 'Just say thank you that we didn't press a criminal charge.'", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper of 23 May 2003 states that on 22 February 2003 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan handed out some administrative detention sentences without conducting hearings in the presence of defendants, with at least one police van with several detained activists inside seen to drive up to the court where a court official emerged and reportedly handed prepared judgments to the escorting police officers, after which the van drove away without the defendants having set foot in court.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. RELEVANT RESOLUTIONS AND REPORTS ON THE APPLICATION OF THE PROCEDURE OF ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION BEFORE, DURING AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION OF FEBRUARY-MARCH 2003", "D. Human Rights Watch Briefing Paper, 23 May 2003, An Imitation of Law: the Use of Administrative Detention in the 2003 Armenian Presidential Election"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F024", "F037", "F061", "F062", "F071"], "interference": ["F023", "F024", "F037", "F061", "F062"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F038", "F108"], "legitimate_aim": ["F024", "F026", "F037"], "necessity": ["F012", "F013", "F014", "F016", "F017", "F025", "F055", "F056", "F057", "F058", "F059", "F061", "F062"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F012", "F013", "F017", "F024", "F062"], "interference": ["F061", "F062"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F038", "F108"], "legitimate_aim": ["F037"], "necessity": ["F016", "F017", "F025", "F061", "F062"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F012", "F017", "F061", "F062", "F016"]}} {"case_name": "case_276", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1948.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "In 2003 a presidential election was held in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The first round of the 2003 Armenian presidential election took place on 19 February 2003.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The second round of the 2003 Armenian presidential election took place on 5 March 2003.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant acted as an authorised election assistant (վստահված անձ) for the main opposition candidate in the 2003 Armenian presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Following the first and second rounds of the 2003 Armenian presidential election, a series of protest rallies were organised in Yerevan by the opposition parties.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "According to the materials of the case, the applicant attended one of the opposition protest rallies in Yerevan on 23 February 2003.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant denied attending the opposition protest rallies in Yerevan and alleged that he had not attended the rallies.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 26 February 2003 at 8 a.m. the applicant was visited at home by two police officers from the Shengavit District Police Department (ՀՀ ոստիկանության Շենգավիթի բաժին).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The two police officers from the Shengavit District Police Department informed the applicant that the chief of the police department wished to speak to him.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant was taken to the Shengavit District Police Department police station on 26 February 2003.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "At the Shengavit District Police Department police station an administrative case was initiated against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant was charged under Article 172 of the Code of Administrative Offences (Վարչական իրավախախտումների վերաբերյալ ՀՀ օրենսգիրք – the Code of Administrative Offences) with minor hooliganism.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The charge of minor hooliganism against the applicant was on the ground that he had participated in the unauthorised demonstration of 23 February 2003 and had violated public order.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 26 February 2003, several hours after being brought to the police station, the applicant was taken to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan (Երևան քաղաքի Կենտրոն և Նորք-Մարաշ համայնքների առաջին ատյանի դատարան).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "At the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan, the applicant was brought before Judge H.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Judge H. conducted a brief hearing concerning the applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Judge H. found the applicant guilty as charged under Article 172 of the Code of Administrative Offences with minor hooliganism.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Judge H. sentenced the applicant to ten days of administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Judge H. found that on 23 February 2003 on Mashtots Avenue in Yerevan the applicant participated together with a group of people in an unauthorised demonstration and march, and violated public order.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The decision of Judge H. of 26 February 2003 stated that it could be protested against by the prosecutor under Article 289 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant was taken to a detention facility to serve his ten-day sentence of administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant alleged that on 1 March 2003 he was taken from his cell to another room in the detention facility.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant alleged that on the table in the room there were two sample applications.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant alleged that one of the two sample applications was handed to him with the instruction to write and sign his name on it.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The content of the application handed to the applicant was a statement which declared: \"I regret what I have done and request a review of my case.\"", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The application handed to the applicant was addressed to the President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal (ՀՀ քրեական և զինվորական գործերով վերաքննիչ դատարանի նախագահ).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant alleged that he had to sign the application document even though he disagreed with its contents, in order to be released and to be able to perform his authorised election assistant duties in the second round of the 2003 Armenian presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 1 March 2003 the President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal reviewed the applicant's conviction.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal found, in reviewing the applicant's conviction, that the applicant had been subjected to administrative detention for attending an unauthorised demonstration in the Kentron District of Yerevan on 23 February 2003 and violating public order, according to the decision of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal found, having reviewed the applicant's appeal and the materials concerning the administrative offence, that the penalty imposed on the applicant must be changed.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal changed the applicant's penalty from ten days of administrative detention to an administrative fine of 2,000 Armenian drams (AMD), which was approximately 3 euros (EUR) at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal ordered the applicant's release from detention.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On the evening of 1 March 2003 the applicant was released from detention.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "At the time of his release on 1 March 2003, the applicant had served approximately three days of his ten-day sentence of administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 26 March 2003 the applicant sent an application to the Ministry of Justice (ՀՀ արդարադատության նախարարություն) arguing that he had never participated in any demonstrations, and in particular the one held on 23 February 2003, and seeking a review of his case.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 26 March 2003 the applicant sent an application to the Court of Cassation (ՀՀ վճռաբեկ դատարան) arguing that he had never participated in any demonstrations, and in particular the one held on 23 February 2003, and seeking a review of his case.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 26 March 2003 the applicant sent an application to the Presidential Human Rights Commission (ՀՀ նախագահին առընթեր մարդու իրավունքների հարցերի հանձնաժողով) arguing that he had never participated in any demonstrations, and in particular the one held on 23 February 2003, and seeking a review of his case.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "By a letter of 3 April 2003 the Court of Cassation forwarded the applicant's application to be dealt with by the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "By a letter of 11 April 2003 the Ministry of Justice informed the applicant that the rights of persons charged with an administrative offence were defined in Article 276 of the Code of Administrative Offences and should have been invoked by the applicant during the examination of his case.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Ministry of Justice's letter of 11 April 2003 further stated that the decision of 26 February 2003 could be protested against by the prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "By a letter of 16 April 2003 the President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal informed the applicant that his application of 26 March 2003 could not be examined, since the applicant had missed the prescribed 10-day time-limit for appeal.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "By a letter of 17 April 2003 the General Prosecutor's Office gave a reply to the applicant's application addressed to the Presidential Human Rights Commission similar to the reply given by the President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal on 16 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 27 April 2003 the applicant again complained to the Ministry of Justice that the decision of 26 February 2003 had been unlawful since he had not participated in any demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "By a letter of 6 May 2003 the Ministry of Justice gave the same reply as its letter of 11 April 2003 in response to the applicant's complaint of 27 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 10 June 2003 the Department for the Enforcement of Judicial Acts (Դատական ակտերի հարկադիր կատարման ծառայություն – the Department for the Enforcement of Judicial Acts) instituted enforcement proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The enforcement proceedings instituted by the Department for the Enforcement of Judicial Acts on 10 June 2003 were based on an execution writ issued by the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan on 15 May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicant alleged that around the period of June 2003 he was visited at home by an officer of the Department for the Enforcement of Judicial Acts.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The applicant alleged that the officer of the Department for the Enforcement of Judicial Acts informed him that the decision of 26 February 2003 had been reviewed on 1 March 2003 and a fine had been imposed.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The applicant alleged that only upon the visit of the officer of the Department for the Enforcement of Judicial Acts did he become aware of the existence of the decision of the President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal of 1 March 2003.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The applicant paid the administrative fine of 2,000 Armenian drams (AMD) imposed by the President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal on 1 March 2003.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 12 June 2003 the Department for the Enforcement of Judicial Acts decided to terminate the enforcement proceedings since the terms of the execution writ had been complied with.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic provisions and international documents and reports is contained in the judgment in the case of Galstyan v. Armenia (no. 26986/03, §§ 25-32, 15 November 2007).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F007", "F008", "F014", "F015", "F019", "F021", "F031", "F032", "F033"], "interference": ["F014", "F015", "F019", "F020", "F030", "F033", "F034", "F052"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F014", "F054"], "legitimate_aim": ["F015", "F021"], "necessity": ["F007", "F008", "F015", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F031", "F033", "F054"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F007", "F008", "F031"], "interference": ["F014", "F015", "F030", "F033"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F014", "F054"], "legitimate_aim": ["F015"], "necessity": ["F031", "F054"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F008", "F015", "F031", "F033", "F054"]}} {"case_name": "case_277", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1984.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1980.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1955.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The fourth applicant was born in 1979.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants live in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 17 October 2003 the applicants took part in an anti-war demonstration in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The anti-war demonstration in Istanbul on 17 October 2003 was dispersed by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicants were arrested by police officers during the dispersal of the anti-war demonstration in Istanbul on 17 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicants were taken into police custody following their arrest on 17 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicants remained in police custody until their release the day following their arrest on 17 October 2003, i.e. on 18 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicants allege that they were subjected to ill-treatment during their arrest on 17 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicants allege that they were subjected to ill-treatment during their detention in police custody following their arrest on 17 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "An incident report was drawn up by a number of police officers on 17 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the incident report drawn up on 17 October 2003, fifty to sixty persons, including the applicants, gathered in a square in Istanbul at 7.45 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the incident report drawn up on 17 October 2003, the persons gathered in the square in Istanbul chanted anti-war slogans.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the incident report drawn up on 17 October 2003, the persons gathered in the square were protesting against the Government's proposals to send soldiers to participate in the invasion of Iraq.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the incident report drawn up on 17 October 2003, the police warned the gathered persons using loudspeakers that they were disturbing the flow of traffic.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the incident report drawn up on 17 October 2003, the police asked the gathered persons to disperse but were unsuccessful.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the incident report drawn up on 17 October 2003, when the police attempted to arrest some of the demonstrators and put them into police vehicles, a number of the demonstrators displayed rowdy behaviour.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the incident report drawn up on 17 October 2003, the police had to use force against a number of the demonstrators who displayed rowdy behaviour.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the incident report drawn up on 17 October 2003, a total of six persons, including the applicants, were arrested and taken to a police station at 8.30 p.m. on 17 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The incident report of 17 October 2003 was signed by six police officers who were referred to in the report only by their identification numbers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 17 October 2003, the same day as their arrest, the applicants were examined by a doctor.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the medical reports drawn up on 17 October 2003, the second applicant had no signs of ill-treatment on his/her body.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the medical reports drawn up on 17 October 2003, the third applicant had no signs of ill-treatment on his/her body.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the medical reports drawn up on 17 October 2003, the first applicant had bruising on her lower lip.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the medical reports drawn up on 17 October 2003, the first applicant had bruising on her lower right leg.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the medical reports drawn up on 17 October 2003, the fourth applicant had bruising on the left side of his lower back.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the medical reports drawn up on 17 October 2003, the fourth applicant had bruising on the back of his right ear.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the medical reports drawn up on 17 October 2003, the fourth applicant's legs were sensitive.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the medical reports drawn up on 17 October 2003, the fourth applicant had redness in his left eye.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On the evening of 17 October 2003, the applicants were questioned by the police in the presence of a duty lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "During police questioning on the evening of 17 October 2003, the first applicant exercised his/her right to remain silent.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "During police questioning on the evening of 17 October 2003, the second applicant exercised his/her right to remain silent.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "During police questioning on the evening of 17 October 2003, the fourth applicant exercised his/her right to remain silent.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "During police questioning on the evening of 17 October 2003, the third applicant did not exercise his/her right to remain silent.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 18 October 2003, the day following their arrest, the applicants were examined by a doctor for a second time.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the medical reports drawn up on 18 October 2003, there were no signs of ill-treatment on the applicants' bodies other than those mentioned in the medical reports drawn up on 17 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "At around 2 p.m. on 18 October 2003, the applicants were brought before the Bakırköy prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicants told the Bakırköy prosecutor that by attending the demonstration on 17 October 2003 they had been exercising their democratic rights.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicants told the Bakırköy prosecutor that the police had arrested them without any previous warnings.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The fourth applicant complained to the Bakırköy prosecutor that he had been beaten up by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The first applicant complained to the Bakırköy prosecutor that police chief M. T. had sworn at him/her during his/her time in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The fourth applicant complained to the Bakırköy prosecutor that police chief M. T. had sworn at him during his time in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicants were released on 18 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 21 October 2003 the Bakırköy prosecutor asked for an investigation to be opened into the applicants' allegations of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicants submitted a formal complaint to the Bakırköy prosecutor on 5 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Hacı Badem, did not complain of ill-treatment in the formal complaint submitted to the Bakırköy prosecutor on 5 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The first applicant complained of ill-treatment in the formal complaint submitted to the Bakırköy prosecutor on 5 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The second applicant complained of ill-treatment in the formal complaint submitted to the Bakırköy prosecutor on 5 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The fourth applicant complained of ill-treatment in the formal complaint submitted to the Bakırköy prosecutor on 5 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In the formal complaint submitted to the Bakırköy prosecutor on 5 November 2003, the first, second, and fourth applicants stated, referring to Article 3 of the Convention, that police officers had punched and kicked them in the course of their arrests on 17 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "In the formal complaint submitted to the Bakırköy prosecutor on 5 November 2003, the first, second, and fourth applicants stated, referring to Article 3 of the Convention, that police officers had punched and kicked them during their detention at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Between 10 December 2003 and 13 April 2004, the Bakırköy prosecutor questioned eleven police officers.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Ten of the eleven police officers questioned by the Bakırköy prosecutor denied having been at the demonstration on 17 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Ten of the eleven police officers questioned by the Bakırköy prosecutor stated they had not seen any of the demonstrators because they had been working elsewhere at the time of the demonstration on 17 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Police chief M.T. told the Bakırköy prosecutor that he had not taken part in the dispersal of the demonstration on 17 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Police chief M.T. told the Bakırköy prosecutor that he had questioned the applicants in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Police chief M.T. denied having ill-treated any of the arrestees.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Police chief M.T. denied having sworn at any of the arrestees.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 14 April 2004 the Bakırköy prosecutor decided to close the investigation into the applicants' allegations of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "In deciding to close the investigation on 14 April 2004, the Bakırköy prosecutor considered, on the basis of the documents in the file, that when the applicants refused to disperse the police had had to use force against them.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Bakırköy prosecutor concluded that the applicants' simple injuries had been caused when the police were exercising their statutory powers on the use of force.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The applicants lodged an objection against the Bakırköy prosecutor's decision of 14 April 2004 to close the investigation into their allegations of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Eyüp Assize Court rejected the applicants' objection against the Bakırköy prosecutor's decision to close the investigation on 8 December 2004.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Eyüp Assize Court's decision of 8 December 2004 stated that it was to be served on the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "According to a hand-written note on the Eyüp Assize Court's decision of 8 December 2004, the decision was communicated to the applicants on 9 February 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 21 October 2003 criminal proceedings were instigated against the applicants for having taken part in an unlawful demonstration, in breach of sections 33, 36 and 40 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 28 January 2008 the Bakırköy Criminal Court of First Instance acquitted the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Bakırköy Criminal Court of First Instance held, in its judgment of 28 January 2008, that the applicants had exercised their democratic rights and had not committed any offences.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F070"], "interference": ["F007", "F008", "F017", "F018", "F020", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F068"], "legitimate_aim": ["F068"], "necessity": ["F006", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F007", "F008", "F020", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F068", "F069", "F070"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F014", "F070"], "interference": ["F008", "F020", "F026", "F028"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F068"], "legitimate_aim": ["F068"], "necessity": ["F014", "F017", "F018", "F008", "F020", "F026", "F028", "F068", "F069", "F070"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F006", "F014", "F017", "F008", "F020", "F026", "F028", "F069", "F070"]}} {"case_name": "case_278", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant, Genderdoc-M, is a non-governmental organisation based in Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant, Genderdoc-M, has as its object to provide information and to assist the LGBT community.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 7 April 2005, the applicant association applied to Chişinău Municipal Council for authorisation to hold a peaceful demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The peaceful demonstration for which the applicant association sought authorisation was to be held in front of the Parliament on 27 May 2005.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The purpose of the proposed demonstration was to encourage the adoption of laws to protect sexual minorities from discrimination.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 27 April 2005, the Chişinău Municipal Council rejected the applicant association's application to hold a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Chişinău Municipal Council rejected the application on the ground that the applicant association's demonstration was baseless.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Chişinău Municipal Council stated as justification that a law on the protection of national minorities had already been adopted.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 6 May 2005, the Chişinău Mayor's Office refused permission for the proposed demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Chişinău Mayor's Office refused permission on the ground that a law on the protection of national minorities was already in place.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Chişinău Mayor's Office also refused permission on the ground that there were legal provisions which dictated which individuals had the power of legislative initiative required to promote laws.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant association contested the decision of the Chişinău Mayor's Office of 6 May 2005.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant association argued that the ban on their demonstration was illegal.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant association argued that the ban on their demonstration was discriminatory.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 2 June 2005, the Chişinău Court of Appeal allowed the applicant association's action.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 2 June 2005, the Chişinău Court of Appeal declared the Chişinău Mayor's Office decision of 6 May 2005 void.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal found that the arguments relied on by the Chişinău Mayor's Office to justify its refusal to authorise the assembly were legally ungrounded, as the law does not provide such grounds for the non-authorisation of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal found that the decision as to whether to authorise or not to authorise an assembly should not be made conditional on the nature of the problems the participants intend to bring to society's attention.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal found that the decision as to whether to authorise or not to authorise an assembly should not be made conditional on the status of those problems.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal concluded that the Chişinău Mayor's Office decision of 6 May 2005 was issued contrary to the provisions of Article 26(1) of the Law regarding administrative complaints, and was thus illegal and void.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal declared ill-founded the applicant association's complaint regarding the Chişinău Mayor's Office's non-compliance with the time-limit of forty-eight hours for notification of the refusal of authorisation for the assembly required under section 14 of the Law regarding the organisation and conduct of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Chişinău Mayor's Office appealed against the decision of the Chişinău Court of Appeal of 2 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Chişinău Mayor's Office argued that they had received many requests from individuals and associations which were vehemently against the authorisation of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The individuals and associations who sent requests to the Chişinău Mayor's Office opposed the adoption of any law legalising homosexual partnerships.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The requests received by the Chişinău Mayor's Office laid emphasis on various legal provisions that concerned the protection of marriage and the family.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 7 September 2005, the Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova allowed the appeal lodged by the Chişinău Mayor's Office.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 7 September 2005, the Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova quashed the Chişinău Court of Appeal decision of 2 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 7 September 2005, the Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova decided to send the case to the Chişinău Court of Appeal for re-examination.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "In their submissions to the Chişinău Court of Appeal on re-examination, the Chişinău Mayor's Office argued that the holding of an assembly for the promotion of the rights of sexual minorities would endanger public order.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "In their submissions to the Chişinău Court of Appeal on re-examination, the Chişinău Mayor's Office argued that the holding of an assembly for the promotion of the rights of sexual minorities would endanger social morality.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "In their submissions to the Chişinău Court of Appeal on re-examination, the Chişinău Mayor's Office argued that the organisers of the demonstration had not assumed any responsibility as regards the demonstration's good management.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant association argued before the Chişinău Court of Appeal on re-examination that the ban on their demonstration was illegal.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant association argued before the Chişinău Court of Appeal on re-examination that the ban on their demonstration was discriminatory.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 14 June 2006, the Chişinău Court of Appeal found against the applicant association on re-examination.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant association appealed against the Chişinău Court of Appeal decision of 14 June 2006.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 18 October 2006, the Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova upheld the decision of the Chişinău Court of Appeal of 14 June 2006.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova found that the applicant association had failed to give undertakings to respect the law, as required by law in respect of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova found that the applicant association had failed to give undertakings to designate a person or persons in charge of the conduct of the demonstration, as required by law in respect of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova found that the applicant association had failed to give undertakings to create together with the police a group of people responsible for the maintenance of public order, as required by law in respect of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova found that the applicant association had failed to give undertakings to mark the site of the demonstration with special signs, as required by law in respect of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova found that the applicant association had failed to give undertakings to pay the Chişinău Municipal Council any fees related to the arrangement of the site of the demonstration, as required by law in respect of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova found that the applicant association had failed to give undertakings to establish the route to and from the site of the demonstration, as required by law in respect of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova found that the applicant association had failed to give undertakings to provide the police with unfettered access to the site of the demonstration, as required by law in respect of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova found that the applicant association had failed to give undertakings to forbid the participation of certain persons, as required by law in respect of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova considered that there was a risk that the demonstration would cause a breach of public order.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Law no. 560-XIII of 21 July 1995 regarding the organisation and conduct of assemblies provides under Section 5 that assemblies may be held only after the organisers have duly notified the urban mayor's (municipal) or rural offices.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Law no. 560-XIII of 21 July 1995 regarding the organisation and conduct of assemblies provides under Section 11(1) that the organiser of an assembly must lodge a notification with the mayor's office at least fifteen days before the chosen date, according to the model provided in the appendix to that law.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "Law no. 560-XIII of 21 July 1995 regarding the organisation and conduct of assemblies provides under Section 11(2) that the preliminary notification should indicate the name of the organiser and the aim of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Law no. 560-XIII of 21 July 1995 regarding the organisation and conduct of assemblies provides under Section 11(2) that the preliminary notification should indicate the date and time the assembly is to begin and end.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Law no. 560-XIII of 21 July 1995 regarding the organisation and conduct of assemblies provides under Section 11(2) that the preliminary notification should indicate where the assembly will take place and the routes to and from the place.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Law no. 560-XIII of 21 July 1995 regarding the organisation and conduct of assemblies provides under Section 11(2) that the preliminary notification should indicate the form the assembly will take.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Law no. 560-XIII of 21 July 1995 regarding the organisation and conduct of assemblies provides under Section 11(2) that the preliminary notification should indicate the approximate number of participants.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Law no. 560-XIII of 21 July 1995 regarding the organisation and conduct of assemblies provides under Section 11(2) that the preliminary notification should indicate those appointed to ensure the good conduct of the assembly and to be responsible for it.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Law no. 560-XIII of 21 July 1995 regarding the organisation and conduct of assemblies provides under Section 11(2) that the preliminary notification should indicate the services the organisers require from the mayor's office.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Law no. 560-XIII of 21 July 1995 regarding the organisation and conduct of assemblies provides under Section 11(3) that the Mayor's Office may in justified cases modify, with the organiser's consent, elements of the preliminary notification.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Law no. 560-XIII of 21 July 1995 regarding the organisation and conduct of assemblies provides under Section 13 that after examining the preliminary declaration, the Mayor's Office shall issue one of the following decisions and inform the organiser: grant permission, or refuse permission under section 12(6).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Law no. 560-XIII of 21 July 1995 regarding the organisation and conduct of assemblies provides under Section 15(1) that the organiser can contest the refusal to authorise an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Law no. 560-XIII of 21 July 1995 regarding the organisation and conduct of assemblies provides under Section 15(2) that the relevant judicial body shall decide upon the organiser's contestation within 5 days from its lodging.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Section 34 of Law no. 123 of 18 March 2003 regarding local public administration provides that the Mayor undertakes legal measures regarding the conduct of public assemblies over the administered territory.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Section 34 of Law no. 123 of 18 March 2003 regarding local public administration provides that the Mayor undertakes measures forbidding or suspending shows, presentations and other public demonstrations which contradict legal order and morals.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Article 54(1) of the Moldovan Constitution provides that the exercise of certain rights or freedoms may be restricted only under the law and only as required for: the defence of national security, of public order, health or morals, of citizens' rights and freedoms, the carrying out of investigations in criminal cases, the prevention of the consequences of a natural calamity or of a technological disaster.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Article 54(2) of the Moldovan Constitution provides that restrictions enforced must be in proportion to the situation that caused them, and may not affect the existence of that right or liberty.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Article 184 of the Moldovan Civil Code defines an association as a non-commercial organisation established voluntarily by associated individuals and legal entities under provisions of the law on the basis of community of interests, which are consistent with public order and good morals, for the purpose of meeting various non-material needs.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F009"], "interference": ["F006", "F009", "F036"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F005"], "interference": ["F006", "F009", "F036"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F005", "F009", "F036"]}} {"case_name": "case_279", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_281", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The case concerns the dispersal by the police of a demonstration organised by a political party.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The case concerns the injuries sustained by the second applicant during the dispersal of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complain of a violation of their rights under Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The second applicant alleges a further violation of Article 3 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants' details are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants were initially represented by Mr E. Cinmen, a lawyer practising in Muğla.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicants were subsequently also represented by Mr R. Demir, a lawyer practising in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicants were subsequently also represented by Ms Y. Kılıç, a lawyer practising in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr Hacı Ali Açıkgül.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Mr Hacı Ali Açıkgül held the position of Head of the Department of Human Rights of the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Türkiye.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "At the time of the events giving rise to the present application, the applicants were members of the Turkish Grand National Assembly.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "According to a number of police reports issued in May and June 2010, two websites were considered to have links with the PKK (Workers' Party of Kurdistan, an armed terrorist organisation).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "According to police reports issued in May and June 2010, the two websites considered to have links with the PKK mainly reported that various wings of the PKK would put an end, as of 1 June 2010, to the ceasefire which they had declared thirteen months previously.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The information on the two websites considered to have links with the PKK contained statements by the leader of the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The information on the two websites considered to have links with the PKK invited people to 'resist' and to 'join' the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 29 May 2010 the security forces received an intelligence report indicating that as of 1 June 2010 the PKK (Workers' Party of Kurdistan) would incite people to acts of civil disobedience across the country.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The intelligence report received on 29 May 2010 mentioned possible attacks against the security forces involving the use of stones, sticks and Molotov cocktails as well as the burning of vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The intelligence report received on 29 May 2010 mentioned possible attacks against public buildings involving the use of stones, sticks and Molotov cocktails as well as the burning of vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 31 May 2010 the General Security Directorate issued a report about possible attacks in the Silopi district of Şırnak province.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 2 June 2010 one of the two websites considered to have links with the PKK reported that the Silopi branch of the BDP (a political party) would organise a march the following day.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The march reported on 2 June 2010 was to take place with the participation of some members of parliament.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The march reported on 2 June 2010 was organised with a view to protesting against the increased military operations in the region.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The march was to begin at 4 p.m. in front of the BDP party office in Silopi.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The march was to continue from the BDP party office in Silopi towards the Habur border post between Türkiye and Iraq, situated approximately fifteen kilometres from Silopi.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "A police report of 2 June 2010 indicated that a crowd of people intended to block the main road leading to the Habur border post.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "A police report of 2 June 2010 indicated that a crowd of people intended to march towards the Habur border post, where a statement to the press would be read out.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The police report of 2 June 2010 mentioned that the group might, if provoked, attack the security forces and their vehicles with stones.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 3 June 2010 the Silopi Security Directorate issued an internal document outlining the measures to be taken and the instructions to be followed by the police before and during the forthcoming demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The internal document issued by the Silopi Security Directorate on 3 June 2010 instructed that police officers were to avoid provoking the demonstrators, follow the warning procedure at all times and comply with the chain of command.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The internal document issued by the Silopi Security Directorate on 3 June 2010 instructed that force might be used in a graduated manner only if necessary and subject to the instructions of the superior officer.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION AS SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 3 June 2010, at about 2 p.m., representatives of the BDP had a meeting with the District Governor of Silopi.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to police reports, at about 3 p.m. on 3 June 2010, people began gathering in front of the BDP party office in Silopi.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to police reports, the number of people gathered in front of the BDP party office in Silopi had reached approximately three thousand by around 4.30 p.m. on 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "At about 4.30 p.m. on 3 June 2010, a bus belonging to the BDP arrived on the right-hand side of the main road leading to the Habur border post.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "At about 4.30 p.m. on 3 June 2010, the demonstrators suddenly headed towards the BDP bus and gathered around it.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Both sides of the main road leading to the Habur border post were blocked by the police and by three water-cannon vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the statements of the police officers, the three water-cannon vehicles were initially stationed about 100 to 150 metres from the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Some demonstrators were holding banners displaying the slogan 'The only interlocutor is esteemed Öcalan' ('Tek muhatap sayın Öcalan').", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Some demonstrators were holding banners displaying the slogan 'The Republic of Türkiye needs you, esteemed Öcalan' ('T.C.'nin size ihtiyacı var sayın Öcalan').", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Some demonstrators were holding banners displaying the slogan 'Our leadership is looking for an interlocutor for a solution' ('Önderliğimiz çözüm için muhatap arıyor').", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "Some demonstrators were holding banners displaying the slogan 'Take the esteemed leader of the Kurdish people Abdullah Öcalan as an interlocutor for a democratic solution of the Kurdish issue' ('Kürt sorununun demokratik çözümü için Kürt önderi sayın Abdullah Öcalan muhatap alınsın').", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Some demonstrators were holding banners displaying the slogan 'End the operations' ('Operasyonlara son').", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Some demonstrators were holding banners displaying the slogan 'Keep your dirty hands off our free mountains' ('Kirli ellerinizi özgür dağlarımızdan çekin').", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "A number of demonstrators were carrying wooden sticks during the demonstration on 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "A number of demonstrators were carrying flags of the PKK (Workers' Party of Kurdistan) during the demonstration on 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "A number of demonstrators were carrying posters of the PKK leader or members during the demonstration on 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Some demonstrators' faces were covered during the demonstration on 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The police warned the participants several times that the demonstration on 3 June 2010 was unlawful and ordered them to disperse immediately.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The police warned the participants that if they failed to disperse, the police would use force.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "According to police reports, at about 4.40 p.m. on 3 June 2010, the applicants joined the front lines of demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Shortly after the applicants joined the front lines, the group of demonstrators, accompanied by the BDP bus, began marching on the main road towards the police.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "As the demonstrators continued to march despite another warning, the police dispersed them by using water cannon and tear gas.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "During the first moments of the police intervention on 3 June 2010, the second applicant fell to the ground and sustained injuries to her hip.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The second applicant was subsequently taken to the Silopi Public Hospital after sustaining injuries during the police intervention on 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "A medical report drawn up by the Silopi Public Hospital at 5.25 p.m. on 3 June 2010 mentioned that the second applicant had a fractured neck of femur (a type of hip fracture).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The fractured neck of femur sustained by the second applicant could not be treated by a simple medical procedure.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The 'history' section of a second report drawn up by the Silopi Public Hospital on 3 June 2010 noted that the second applicant had 'slipped and fallen when Panzers had sprayed water during the demonstration'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The second applicant was subsequently transported to a private hospital in Ankara, where she was operated on 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The second applicant was discharged from the private hospital in Ankara on 11 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "After being discharged from hospital on 11 June 2010, the second applicant received physiotherapy owing to her inability to walk.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The second applicant was prescribed several consecutive periods of sick leave lasting until 24 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "A medical report from 2014 indicated that the second applicant was able to walk with crutches.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In her submissions to the Court, the second applicant stated that she was still receiving treatment for her injury.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "A police officer (S.Y.) reported that he had sustained injuries to his left leg caused by a stone thrown by the demonstrators before the intervention of the security forces on 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The medical report issued on 3 June 2010 by the Silopi Public Hospital in respect of police officer S.Y. mentioned soft tissue damage rendering him unfit for work for ten days.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Another police officer (İ.K.) stated that he had been injured during the intervention of the security forces on 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Police officer İ.K. was prescribed seven days' sick leave following his injury during the security forces' intervention on 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The police records drawn up on 3 June 2010 noted that several vehicles belonging to the security forces had been damaged by stones.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The police records drawn up on 3 June 2010 did not mention whether the damage to security force vehicles had occurred before or during the police intervention.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. EVENTS OF 3 JUNE 2010 AND INJURIES OF THE SECOND APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 14 June 2010 the presidency of the Inspection Board of the Ministry of the Interior appointed two chief inspectors to investigate the incidents that had taken place during the demonstration of 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The chief inspectors collected documents and evidence, including video footage of the incidents of 3 June 2010 recorded by the police.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The chief inspectors took statements from the Şırnak Governor.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The chief inspectors took statements from the District Governor of Silopi.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The chief inspectors took statements from the officers in command of the security forces in Silopi.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The chief inspectors took statements from the chair of the Silopi branch of the BDP.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The chief inspectors took statements from the police officers driving the water-cannon vehicles during the events of 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The chief inspectors took statements from the police officers who had operated the water jets during the events of 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "According to the police officers, one of the water-cannon vehicles had been stationed on the right-hand side of the road leading to the Habur border post during the events of 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "According to the police officers, the other two water-cannon vehicles had been on the opposite side of the road leading to the Habur border post during the events of 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The police officers maintained that the initial distance between the crowd and the water-cannon vehicles had been about 100 to 150 metres.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The police officers explained that they had used water cannons because the demonstrators had begun advancing towards the vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Water-cannon operator S.T. stated that water had been sprayed in accordance with the instructions they received when the group had advanced about 50 metres towards the police.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Water-cannon driver H.S.Ş. stated that they had received an instruction to intervene once the initial distance between the crowd and the vehicles had been halved.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Water-cannon operator M.K. maintained that the demonstrators had started to throw stones from a distance of 50 metres.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Police officer S.Y. reported that he had been injured when some demonstrators had begun to throw stones from a distance of approximately 50 metres.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Some police officers stated that water had been sprayed only once by each water-cannon vehicle, for a duration of between eight and ten seconds.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The police officers maintained that they could not have, and had not, targeted a specific person when using the water cannon.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The police officers stated that visibility from within the water-cannon vehicles had been poor and that they had been watching the events from the monitors inside the vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Water-cannon driver D.A. maintained that it was a coincidence that the second applicant had been hit by water and been injured as a result of her fall.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Water-cannon operator S.T. stated that water had caused the second applicant to fall and be injured through an unfortunate coincidence.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The police officers maintained that if they had not intervened at that moment it would not have been possible to move the water-cannon vehicles because of the approaching crowd of demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The police officers maintained that a direct confrontation between the approaching crowd of demonstrators and the police officers positioned behind the water-cannon vehicles would have been inevitable had they not intervened.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "According to the police officers, a direct confrontation between the crowd and the police would have caused even more serious incidents.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "In their statements, the representatives of the BDP maintained that they had been informed by some members of parliament that the Şırnak Governor had given them permission to hold the march on one side of the main road.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Şırnak Governor denied the BDP representatives' claim that permission had been given to hold the march on one side of the main road.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The District Governor of Silopi denied the BDP representatives' claim that permission had been given to hold the march on one side of the main road.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "On 14 September 2010 the chief inspectors submitted their report to the presidency of the Inspection Board of the Ministry of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The chief inspectors' report stated that the Şırnak Governor had not given permission for the demonstration to be held on the main road.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The chief inspectors' report stated that the District Governor of Silopi had proposed alternative venues to the organisers of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "According to the chief inspectors' report, the police had taken the necessary preparatory measures by deploying three water-cannon vehicles stationed at a distance of about 100 to 150 metres from the gathering point.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The chief inspectors' report noted that officials had expressed concerns that if the police did not intervene, the number of participants might increase, rendering it impossible to intervene.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The chief inspectors' report referred to concerns about possible provocative acts and serious incidents targeting the military barracks situated further along the road taken by the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The chief inspectors' report mentioned that the police had warned the protestors many times that the demonstration was unlawful and had ordered them to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The chief inspectors' report stated that as the crowd had not stopped advancing towards the police, the police had used water cannon and tear gas, prompted by concerns that it would become impossible to intervene if the crowd reached the police barricade.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The chief inspectors' report stated that the police intervention had lasted eight to ten seconds and that pressurised water had been sprayed only once.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The chief inspectors' report stated that there was nothing to indicate that the members of parliament had been targeted by the police officers, and that it was pure coincidence that the second applicant had been hit by water (tamamen tesadüfen suya hedef olduğu).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The chief inspectors' report stated that the injury sustained by the second applicant had been the result of her falling awkwardly (biçimsiz bir şekilde) owing to physical weakness.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The chief inspectors' report noted that the other demonstrators who had been hit by the same pressurised water had not been injured.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The chief inspectors' report found that the police had intervened at the right moment, given that there had been more than three thousand demonstrators and that their number could have reached ten thousand at any moment.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The chief inspectors' report found that there had been no serious injuries apart from that of the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The chief inspectors' report concluded that the intervention had been carried out in such a manner as to cause the least possible damage.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The chief inspectors concluded that there were no grounds for instituting criminal proceedings against the Şırnak Governor and the law-enforcement personnel.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The chief inspectors concluded that there were no grounds for instituting administrative proceedings against the Şırnak Governor and the law-enforcement personnel.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "On 30 December 2010, on the basis of the chief inspectors' report of 14 September 2010 and pursuant to Law no. 4483 on the prosecution of civil servants, the Ministry of the Interior decided not to authorise the prosecution of the Şırnak Governor and the law-enforcement personnel in relation to the events of 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "On 28 January 2011 the applicants lodged an objection against the Ministry of the Interior's decision of 30 December 2010 not to authorise prosecution.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "On 6 July 2011 the Supreme Administrative Court dismissed the applicants' objection against the Ministry of the Interior's decision not to authorise prosecution.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Supreme Administrative Court dismissed the applicants' objection on the grounds that the intervention had been carried out in such a manner as to cause the least possible damage.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "On an unknown date the Silopi public prosecutor's office initiated, of its own motion, an investigation into the events of 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "On 8 June 2010 the Silopi public prosecutor's office requested information from the District Governor's Office of Silopi as to whether a preliminary investigation into the events of 3 June 2010 had been initiated pursuant to Law no. 4483.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "On 8 June 2010 the Silopi public prosecutor's office requested that a decision be taken on whether to authorise the prosecution of the law-enforcement personnel in Silopi for the offence of misconduct in office.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "On 28 June 2010 the applicants filed a complaint against the police officers and other officials involved in the incidents of 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "In their complaint of 28 June 2010, the applicants claimed that they had been ill-treated.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "In their complaint of 28 June 2010, the applicants claimed that their right to freedom of expression had been violated.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "In their complaint of 28 June 2010, the applicants claimed that their right to freedom of assembly had been violated.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "On 9 February 2012 the Silopi public prosecutor issued a decision not to bring a prosecution against the law-enforcement personnel and their superior officers in relation to the events of 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Silopi public prosecutor, referring to the Ministry of the Interior's decision of 30 December 2010, considered that no prosecution could be brought in respect of the offence of misconduct in office, since the latter fell within the scope of Law no. 4483 on the prosecution of civil servants.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Silopi public prosecutor reiterated the conclusions of the chief inspectors' report of 14 September 2010 and found that there was no indication that the officials had acted with an intention to directly or indirectly inflict bodily harm.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The Silopi public prosecutor found that no negligence was attributable to the law-enforcement personnel and their superior officers in relation to the events of 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Silopi public prosecutor held that freedom of expression and of assembly were subject to limitations and that the intervention of the security forces in an unlawful demonstration could not be regarded as preventing the exercise of the right to freedom of expression or other rights of the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "On 21 March 2012 the applicants objected to the Silopi public prosecutor's decision of 9 February 2012 not to bring a prosecution.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The Silopi public prosecutor's decision of 9 February 2012 was amenable to judicial review except in so far as it concerned the alleged offence of misconduct in office.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "On 8 May 2012 the Siirt Assize Court dismissed the applicants' objection to the Silopi public prosecutor's decision of 9 February 2012.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The Siirt Assize Court dismissed the applicants' objection on the grounds that the demonstration had not been duly notified to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The Siirt Assize Court dismissed the applicants' objection on the grounds that the demonstrators had been warned and ordered to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The Siirt Assize Court dismissed the applicants' objection on the grounds that the injuries complained of had occurred in a moment of panic during the police intervention.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The Siirt Assize Court dismissed the applicants' objection on the grounds that there had been no direct intervention by the police officers against the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The Government provided the Court with several video recordings made by the police during the events of 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. VIDEO FOOTAGE SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The video footage shows the second applicant in the front lines of demonstrators immediately before the spraying of pressurised water towards that area.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. VIDEO FOOTAGE SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Although it is impossible to see clearly the exact moment when the second applicant fell, the video footage shows that she was on the ground immediately after the first round of water spraying.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. VIDEO FOOTAGE SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The video footage shows that the second applicant attempted to stand up after her fall but was unable to do so.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. VIDEO FOOTAGE SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "The video footage shows that pressurised water was sprayed more than once during the police intervention on 3 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. VIDEO FOOTAGE SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "The video footage shows that the traffic on the road in question was not stopped until the demonstrators began heading towards the BDP bus.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. VIDEO FOOTAGE SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "The video footage shows that the police intervention began less than two minutes after the applicants joined the front lines of demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. VIDEO FOOTAGE SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "The video footage shows that at least three adolescents among the demonstrators threw stones at the security forces shortly after the group began heading towards the road.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. VIDEO FOOTAGE SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The video footage shows that some of the demonstrators reacted against the stone-throwing behaviour of the adolescents.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. VIDEO FOOTAGE SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The video footage shows that the vast majority of the participants were not involved in any violent act during the period before the intervention of the police.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. VIDEO FOOTAGE SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The video footage shows some demonstrators throwing stones at the police after the dispersal of the march.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. VIDEO FOOTAGE SUBMITTED BY THE GOVERNMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The relevant domestic law in respect of freedom of assembly is set out in Oya Ataman v. Turkey (no. 74552/01, §§ 13-15, ECHR 2006-XIV).", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "The relevant domestic law in respect of the prosecution of civil servants and public officials is set out in Eğitim ve Bilim Emekçileri Sendikası and Others v. Turkey (no. 20347/07, §§ 42-52, 5 July 2016).", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "At the material time, section 10 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) required that in order for a meeting to take place, the governor's office or authorities of the district in which the demonstration is planned must be informed, during opening hours and at least seventy-two hours prior to the meeting, by a notice containing the signature of all the members of the organising committee.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "Section 22 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911), as in force at the material time, prohibited demonstrations and processions on public streets and highways.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "Section 24 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) provided that demonstrations and processions which did not comply with the provisions of the Act would be dispersed by force on the order of the governor's office and after the demonstrators had been warned.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "Under section 16 of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police, when faced with resistance in the performance of their duties, the police may use force for the purpose of, and to the extent necessary for, breaking down such resistance.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Under section 16 of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police, the use of force means recourse to physical and material force and weaponry in order to immobilise those resisting the police, in a graduated manner depending on the nature and degree of resistance.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "Under section 16 of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police, the term 'material force' is defined as including handcuffs, truncheons, pressurised water and tear gas.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "Under section 16 of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police, a warning is required before using force; however, depending on the nature and degree of resistance, it may also be possible to use force without any warning.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "Under section 16 of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police, the police determine the equipment and the degree of force to be used, and where the action is taken against a group, that determination is made by the supervisor of the intervening unit.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "Article 25 of the Directive of 30 December 1982 on the rapid reaction forces (Polis Çevik Kuvvet Yönetmeliği) lays down the principles governing the supervision, control and intervention of those forces during demonstrations, as summarised in Abdullah Yaşa and Others v. Turkey (no. 44827/08, § 27, 16 July 2013).", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials were adopted on 7 September 1990 by the Eighth United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials provide that the development and deployment of non-lethal incapacitating weapons should be carefully evaluated in order to minimise the risk of endangering uninvolved persons, and the use of such weapons should be carefully controlled.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "On 6 July 2018 the Human Rights Council adopted Resolution 38/11 on the promotion and protection of human rights in the context of peaceful protests.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "Human Rights Council Resolution 38/11 calls upon States to investigate any death or significant injury, including those that lead to disability, incurred during protests, including those resulting from the discharge of firearms or the use of less-lethal weapons by officials exercising law enforcement duties or by private personnel acting on behalf of the State.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "Human Rights Council Resolution 38/11 encourages States to make appropriate protective equipment and less-lethal weapons available to their officials exercising law enforcement duties in order to decrease their need to use weapons of any kind, while pursuing efforts to regulate and establish protocols for the training and use of less-lethal weapons, bearing in mind that even less-lethal weapons can result in a risk to life.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "Human Rights Council Resolution 38/11 underlines the importance of thorough and independent testing of less-lethal weapons prior to procurement and deployment to establish their lethality and the extent of likely injury, and of monitoring appropriate training and use of such weapons.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The United Nations Human Rights Guidance on Less-Lethal Weapons in Law Enforcement was issued on 1 June 2020 by the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The United Nations Human Rights Guidance on Less-Lethal Weapons in Law Enforcement (paragraph 7.7.2) provides that in general, water cannon should only be used in situations of serious public disorder where there is a significant likelihood of loss of life, serious injury or the widespread destruction of property.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The United Nations Human Rights Guidance on Less-Lethal Weapons in Law Enforcement (paragraph 7.7.2) provides that the deployment of water cannon should be carefully planned and managed with rigorous command and control at a senior level in order to meet the requirements of necessity and proportionality.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The United Nations Human Rights Guidance on Less-Lethal Weapons in Law Enforcement (paragraph 7.7.3) provides that water cannon should not be used against persons in elevated positions, where there is a risk of significant secondary injury.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The United Nations Human Rights Guidance on Less-Lethal Weapons in Law Enforcement (paragraph 7.7.3) identifies risks of water cannon use including hypothermia and cold-water shock in cold weather, and the risk of persons slipping or being forced by the jet against walls or other hard objects.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The United Nations Human Rights Guidance on Less-Lethal Weapons in Law Enforcement (paragraph 7.7.3) notes that certain water cannon are indiscriminate in their effects, as they are unable to target individuals accurately.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The United Nations Human Rights Guidance on Less-Lethal Weapons in Law Enforcement (paragraph 7.7.4) provides that water cannon shall not target a jet of water at an individual or group of persons at short range owing to the risk of causing permanent blindness or secondary injuries if persons are propelled energetically by the water jet.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "The United Nations Human Rights Guidance on Less-Lethal Weapons in Law Enforcement (paragraph 7.7.4) provides that water cannon shall not be used against restrained persons or persons otherwise unable to move.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 2435 (2022) on fighting and preventing excessive and unjustified use of force by law-enforcement officers was adopted on 27 April 2022.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 2435 (2022) calls on member States of the Council of Europe and observer States to ensure that the use of weapons and other lethal or non-lethal tools by law-enforcement agencies is thoroughly regulated by their national legislation, which should lay down instructions and safeguards against abuse.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights published a Human Rights Comment on 25 February 2014 entitled 'Police abuse – a serious threat to the rule of law'.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Human Rights Comment of 25 February 2014 states that States should develop clear guidelines concerning the proportionate use of force by police, including the use of tear gas, pepper spray, water cannons and firearms in the context of demonstrations, in line with international standards.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (third edition, 2019) were prepared by the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe in consultation with the European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission) of the Council of Europe.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (third edition, 2019), paragraph 185, provide that the use of plastic/rubber bullets, baton rounds, attenuated energy projectiles, water cannons and other forceful methods of crowd control must be strictly regulated and recorded.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F050", "F143", "F064", "F144", "F145", "F146", "F068", "F069"], "interference": ["F052", "F048"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F150", "F151", "F152"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F016", "F019", "F027", "F020", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F102", "F032", "F034", "F035", "F050", "F052", "F142", "F143", "F048", "F049", "F103", "F053", "F055", "F138", "F139", "F150", "F151"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F050", "F143", "F064", "F144", "F145", "F146", "F068", "F069"], "interference": ["F052"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F150", "F151", "F152"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F027", "F020", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F102", "F032", "F034", "F035", "F050", "F052", "F142", "F143", "F048", "F049", "F053", "F055", "F138", "F139", "F150", "F151"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F027", "F020", "F146", "F144", "F145", "F069", "F142", "F032", "F050", "F143", "F052", "F048", "F053", "F055", "F151", "F150"]}} {"case_name": "case_282", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_284", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_285", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_286", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants or organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_288", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant complained of a violation of his right to freedom of expression on account of his conviction.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant complained of a violation of his right to freedom of assembly on account of his conviction.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant's conviction was based, inter alia, on his participation in several demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant's conviction was based, inter alia, on his participation in several press conferences.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The case concerns the alleged unfairness of the criminal proceedings against the applicant owing to his inability to question an anonymous witness at any stage of the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The case concerns the alleged unfairness of the criminal proceedings against the applicant owing to the domestic courts' rejection of his request to have the contents of his confiscated computer examined.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 29 December 2009 the Tunceli Security Directorate received an anonymous email.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The anonymous email received by the Tunceli Security Directorate on 29 December 2009 accused the applicant of being a member of the Patriotic Democratic Youth Assembly (Yurtsever Demokratik Gençlik Hareketi – the YDGM).", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Patriotic Democratic Youth Assembly (Yurtsever Demokratik Gençlik Hareketi – the YDGM) is considered by the Turkish national authorities to be the youth branch of the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan).", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 10 June 2010 the Malatya public prosecutor filed a bill of indictment against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The bill of indictment filed by the Malatya public prosecutor on 10 June 2010 charged the applicant, along with eight others, with being a member of an armed terrorist organisation, namely the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan), under Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The bill of indictment filed by the Malatya public prosecutor on 10 June 2010 also charged the applicant under section 5 of the Law on the Prevention of Terrorism.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Malatya public prosecutor noted that the applicant had participated in certain demonstrations in line with the PKK's instructions as published on certain websites and a TV channel.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Malatya public prosecutor noted that the applicant had participated in certain press conferences in line with the PKK's instructions as published on certain websites and a TV channel.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Malatya public prosecutor observed that the applicant had visited incarcerated members of the PKK to show moral support and undertake organisational activities.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Malatya public prosecutor observed that the applicant had visited family members of incarcerated members of the PKK to show moral support and undertake organisational activities.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Malatya public prosecutor observed that the applicant had been accused of being a member of the Patriotic Democratic Youth Assembly (YDGM) in an anonymous email.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Malatya public prosecutor observed that the anthem of the PKK had been found in the applicant's computer.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Malatya public prosecutor observed that symbols of the PKK had been found in the applicant's computer.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Malatya public prosecutor observed that texts composed by members of the PKK had been found in the applicant's computer.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "During the criminal proceedings the applicant denied the charges against him.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant submitted that he had merely visited one of his friends in prison, who had not been convicted of any crime at the time of the visits.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant submitted that his prison visits had not been related to any organisational activities.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant stated that he had not received any instructions from any illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant stated that there was no evidence to support the contention that he had received instructions from an illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant did not deny that he had taken part in the demonstrations referred to by the Malatya public prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant did not deny that he had taken part in the press conferences referred to by the Malatya public prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant argued that the demonstrations and press conferences in which he had participated had been legal activities permitted by the relevant authorities.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 23 June 2011 the Malatya Assize Court convicted the applicant under Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) of being a member of an armed terrorist organisation, namely the PKK (the Workers' Party of Kurdistan).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court's conviction of the applicant on 23 June 2011 was based, inter alia, on his participation in certain demonstrations on the calls published on websites and in media outlets controlled by or belonging to the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court's conviction of the applicant on 23 June 2011 was based, inter alia, on his participation in certain press conferences on the calls published on websites and in media outlets controlled by or belonging to the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court sentenced the applicant to nine years' imprisonment on 23 June 2011.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court took the view that the applicant had been a member of the Patriotic Democratic Youth Assembly (YDGM).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had participated in various events such as press conferences, panels, meetings, and demonstrations with a view to actively maintaining the organisational activities of the Patriotic Democratic Youth Assembly (YDGM) in accordance with instructions given by the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had taken part in talks with other people concerning the arrests of other Patriotic Democratic Youth Assembly (YDGM) members which had taken place on 16 June 2009.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had taken part in a press conference held on 11 September 2009.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "At the press conference held on 11 September 2009, the participants sent faxes containing opinions and recommendations of the PKK to the offices of the President and the Prime Minister from the Tunceli post office.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The document sent by fax at the press conference of 11 September 2009 had been known as 'the Roadmap' and had been drawn up by the PKK's leader.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had taken part in a press conference held on 12 October 2009 by a member of the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye from Tunceli in commemoration of the removal of the leader of the PKK from Syria in 1998.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had taken part in an illegal press conference held on 7 December 2009 in protest against the allegedly deteriorating conditions of detention of the leader of the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had taken part in a demonstration held on 7 December 2009 in protest against the allegedly deteriorating conditions of detention of the leader of the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "During the demonstration held on 7 December 2009, the applicant had covered his face with a mask in such a way as to show that he had been a participant in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had taken part in a march held in Tunceli on 27 February 2010 in support of the workers of a State-run company (Tekel).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had taken part in a press conference held in Tunceli on 27 February 2010 in support of the workers of a State-run company (Tekel).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had taken part in a press conference held in Tunceli on 7 March 2010 in the context of the centenary of International Women's Day.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had taken part in the Nawruz celebrations held on 21 March 2010.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "At the Nawruz celebrations on 21 March 2010, the applicant had been part of a group of Patriotic Democratic Youth Assembly (YDGM) members who had been committing crimes.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "At the Nawruz celebrations on 21 March 2010, the applicant had – under the guidance of his co-defendant N.Y. – shouted at police officers for conducting a body search of a person named E.F.D.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had taken part in a panel entitled 'The 15th February Conspiracy' with a view to ensuring the continuity of campaigns organised under the legal appearance and in the form of rebellion.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had taken part in a press conference named 'We condemn the 15th February Conspiracy' with a view to ensuring the continuity of campaigns organised under the legal appearance and in the form of rebellion.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had taken part in a march held on 1 May 2010 to celebrate International Workers' Day.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had taken part in a press conference held in Samsun to protest against an attack perpetrated against A.T., who had been the then co-president of the Party for a Democratic Society (the DTP).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court found that the applicant had taken part in talks with others about potential locations where Patriotic Democratic Youth Assembly (YDGM) members could meet and review its actions.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court grounded its decision to convict the applicant on the visits he had paid together with other Patriotic Democratic Youth Assembly (YDGM) members to imprisoned members of the PKK to provide them with moral support.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court grounded its decision to convict the applicant on the visits he had paid together with other Patriotic Democratic Youth Assembly (YDGM) members to the families and relatives of imprisoned members of the PKK to provide them with moral support.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court grounded its decision to convict the applicant on materials found on his computer which had been seized by the police, namely the anthem of the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court grounded its decision to convict the applicant on materials found on his computer which had been seized by the police, namely a symbol in the form of a star with the inscription 'Dersim'.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court grounded its decision to convict the applicant on materials found on his computer which had been seized by the police, namely pictures of members of the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Malatya Assize Court grounded its decision to convict the applicant on materials found on his computer which had been seized by the police, namely texts composed by members of the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Throughout the criminal proceedings the applicant maintained that the Patriotic Democratic Youth Assembly (YDGM) had been the legal youth wing of the Party for a Democratic Society (DTP).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Throughout the criminal proceedings the applicant maintained that all the acts imputed to him had been lawful.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicant appealed against his conviction by the Malatya Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 9 April 2012 the Court of Cassation upheld the Malatya Assize Court's first-instance judgment convicting the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F013", "F014", "F026", "F027", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F034", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F051"], "interference": ["F029", "F032", "F063"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F011", "F012", "F029"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F013", "F014", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F034", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F051", "F060", "F061"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F026", "F027", "F030", "F031", "F034"], "interference": ["F029", "F032", "F063"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F011", "F012"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F034", "F043", "F045", "F046", "F051", "F060"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F004", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F034", "F046", "F060", "F063"]}} {"case_name": "case_290", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_291", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_292", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention and Protocols to the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_293", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, was born in 1988.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, lives in Khimki in the Moscow Region.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, was born in 1985.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, lives in Zhukovskiy in the Moscow Region.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants were represented by Mr Rachkovskiy, a lawyer practising in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants were represented by Ms N. Dobreva, a lawyer practising in Sofia.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Government were represented initially by Mr G. Matyushkin, Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr M. Galperin, successor to Mr G. Matyushkin as Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 7-65, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 7-33, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 6 May 2012 a public demonstration entitled the 'March of Millions' was held in central Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration of 6 May 2012 was held to protest against the allegedly rigged presidential elections.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration of 6 May 2012 had been approved by the Moscow city authorities in the form of a march followed by a meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The approved meeting at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 was supposed to end at 7.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The march on 6 May 2012 was peaceful and held without any disruptions.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "When the marchers arrived at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, it transpired that barriers installed by the police had narrowed the entrance to the meeting venue, allegedly restricting the space allocated for the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "To control the crowd at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, a police cordon forced the protestors to remain within the barriers.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "There were numerous clashes between the police and protesters at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police ordered the organisers of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square to finish the meeting early.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police began to disperse the participants of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "It took the police about two hours to clear the protestors from Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the Moscow city department of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation opened a criminal investigation into suspected acts of mass disorder, an offence under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the Moscow city department of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation opened a criminal investigation into suspected violence against the police, an offence under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 18 May 2012 the criminal investigation file opened on 6 May 2012 was transferred to the headquarters of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation for further investigation.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 28 May 2012 another criminal investigation was launched into the offence of organising acts of mass disorder under Article 212 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 28 May 2012 the two criminal cases concerning the events at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 were joined.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 16 December 2013 the Investigative Committee disjoined the case against the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, and the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, and their two co-defendants from the main criminal case file concerning the mass disorder at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "At the time of the events of 6 May 2012, the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, was a student working part-time.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, took part in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, he did not take part in any disorder or clashes with the police at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, was arrested at the site of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, was taken to the Ivanoskoye District police station in Moscow following his arrest on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "At the Ivanoskoye District police station in Moscow, an on-duty officer drew up an administrative-offence record stating that the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, had disobeyed a lawful police order, an offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The administrative-offence record stated that the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, had broken the police cordon and thrown stones and glass bottles.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The administrative-offence record stated that when ordered to cease his actions, the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, had refused to do so.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 8 May 2012 the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, was brought before the justice of the peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, denied before the justice of the peace having broken the police cordon or having thrown bottles and stones at police officers.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The justice of the peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District in Moscow, relying on a police officer's report, found the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, guilty of disobeying a lawful police order under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The justice of the peace of Court Circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District in Moscow sentenced the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, to fifteen days' detention.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "After his release from administrative detention, the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, continued to live at his usual address and pursue his activities.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 6 February 2013 the first applicant's, Mr Gushchin's, flat was searched and his travel passport was seized.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 6 February 2013 the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, was arrested on suspicion of having participated in acts of mass disorder during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 6 February 2013 the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, was arrested on suspicion of having used violence against the police during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, was charged under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (participation in mass disorder).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, was charged under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (violence against a public official).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, was accused in particular of grabbing a police officer's uniform and pushing him to the ground.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 7 February 2013 the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, was placed in pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, remained in pre-trial detention for one year and six months.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The first applicant's, Mr Gushchin's, pre-trial detention was examined by the Court in a separate case and was found to be unjustified (see Kovyazin and Others v. Russia, nos. 13008/13 and 2 others, §§ 79-94, 17 September 2015).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 20 November 2013 final charges were brought against the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 20 November 2013 final charges were brought against the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "1. The first applicant's arrest and administrative conviction"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 14 April 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow began the trial in a criminal case against four participants in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square, including both the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, and the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The four defendants at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow trial beginning 14 April 2014 were charged with participation in acts of mass disorder and committing acts of violence against police officers.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 25 July 2014, during a court hearing, the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, requested that the court grant a stay of proceedings in respect of the charges under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation on the grounds that the acts with which he was charged were covered by the administrative offence of which he had been convicted on 8 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 25 July 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found no grounds to grant the first applicant's, Mr Gushchin's, request for a stay of proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On an unspecified date police officer A., the alleged victim of the first applicant's, Mr Gushchin's, assault, was questioned as a witness during the trial.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Police officer A. testified that when he had been arresting one of the active participants of the demonstration, someone had pulled his helmet and bullet-proof vest, blocking his access to air.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Police officer A. testified that he had fallen to the ground and when he had tried to get up, someone had pushed him again, causing him to fall.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Police officer A. testified that when he had managed to stand up, he had seen a young man whom he had later identified as the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, who had then disappeared in the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Police officer A. testified that he had felt pain as a result of the first applicant's, Mr Gushchin's, actions but had not asked for medical assistance.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Police officer D., questioned as a witness during the trial, testified that he had seen the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, holding on to police officer A.'s bullet-proof vest and trying to push him to the ground.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 18 August 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, guilty as charged.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that on 6 May 2012, at 5 p.m. at the latest, the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, arrived at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow to take part in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that between 5 p.m. and 10 p.m. on 6 May 2012, the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, took part in acts of mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, acting with intent, used violence against police officer A. which did not pose a threat to the life or health of that officer.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, acting with intent with the aim of using violence, tried to prevent police officers from arresting aggressive participants of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, standing behind police officer A., grabbed the latter's bullet-proof vest with his right hand and his anti-riot helmet with his left hand and, acting together with an unidentified person, dragged police officer A. away and then pushed him to the ground.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the first applicant's, Mr Gushchin's, actions caused police officer A. pain.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, pleaded not guilty to the crime under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation but partially confessed to the use of violence against a public official under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, testified at trial that when police officers had started using force, special means and truncheons against participants in the demonstration, he had heard a cry for help and had seen a man lying on the ground.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, testified at trial that a police officer, who had later turned out to be police officer A., had been bent over the man on the ground, beating him with a truncheon.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, testified at trial that he had grabbed police officer A.'s uniform and pulled it up, and had not hit or pushed anyone.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, testified at trial that police officer A. had not fallen to the ground as a result of the first applicant's actions.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, testified at trial that he was aware that by grabbing police officer A.'s uniform, he had committed a crime under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, testified at trial that he did not deny that afterwards he had been standing in a line with others impeding the police from arresting the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, testified at trial that on 6 May 2012 he had been arrested, taken to the police station and convicted by a justice of the peace under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that it had not established any facts showing unlawful behaviour on the part of the police during the demonstration on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the police officers acted lawfully during the demonstration on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow rejected the first applicant's, Mr Gushchin's, argument that the criminal proceedings and his prosecution should be terminated on the grounds that he had already been subjected to administrative liability for the same act.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that on 8 May 2012 the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, was convicted of failure to obey a lawful order of the police under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the first applicant's, Mr Gushchin's, participation in mass disorder and his use of violence against a public official were not covered by the scope of the offence provided for in Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation, as the administrative offence and the crimes had different objects and were committed at different times, albeit consecutively.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow relied on a video recording showing how the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, had grabbed police officer A.'s bullet-proof vest and helmet and had pushed him.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow relied on records of identification parades, according to which police officer A. had identified the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, as the man who had used violence against police officer A.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow relied on records of identification parades, according to which police officer D. had identified the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, as the man who had used violence against police officer A.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, was sentenced to two years and six months' imprisonment, calculated on the basis of a two-year prison term under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation running partly concurrently with a term of one year under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The first applicant's, Mr Gushchin's, pre-trial detention counted towards his prison sentence.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "On 27 November 2014 the Moscow City Court upheld the first-instance judgment convicting the first applicant, Mr Gushchin.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Moscow City Court dismissed the first applicant's, Mr Gushchin's, allegation that he had been tried and convicted twice for the same offence.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Gushchin, was released on 8 August 2015 having served his prison term.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Application of Mr Gushchin (no. 22581/15)", "2. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "At the time of his arrest, the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, was working as a financial consultant.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, was a member of the Opposition Coordination Council, a political movement.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, and his partner took part in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "When the police were dispersing the protestors at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, intervened in what he perceived as an arbitrary arrest of another protestor.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The police applied force against the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "According to the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, he was severely beaten up at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 and received medical assistance in an ambulance present at the venue.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "On 2 July 2012 the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, lodged a complaint with the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation, alleging police brutality.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, attached to his complaint a medical certificate confirming the injuries caused to him on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "On 28 April 2013 the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, was detained on suspicion of having participated in acts of mass disorder during the demonstration of 6 May 2012, an offence under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 28 April 2013 the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, was detained on suspicion of having used violence against the police during the demonstration of 6 May 2012, an offence under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, was accused in particular of pulling police officer I. by the leg and dragging him away from another protestor.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, was accused of pulling police officer I. down to the ground.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "Unidentified protestors had then allegedly hit police officer I. on the head following the second applicant's, Mr Gaskarov's, actions.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On 28 April 2013 the second applicant's, Mr Gaskarov's, pre-trial detention was ordered.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "On 26 August 2013 police officer B. identified the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, as the protestor who had pulled him by the left arm out of the chain of police officers during the clashes at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "On 20 November 2013 the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, was questioned by the investigators.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, confessed to having pulled police officer I. by the leg to prevent him from arresting another protestor.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "On 13 December 2013 the investigators referred the second applicant's, Mr Gaskarov's, complaint of ill-treatment to a competent authority.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, was not aware of any follow-up to his complaint of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "On 6 December 2013 the investigators questioned Ms L.A., who had participated in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Ms L.A. witnessed a police officer kicking the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, in the face during the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Ms L.A. provided the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, with first aid on the spot at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "1. The second applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "On 14 April 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow began the hearing of the criminal case against the first applicant, Mr Gushchin, the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, and two co-defendants.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "2. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The hearings of the criminal case at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow took place in hearing room no. 403 of the courthouse, which was equipped with metal cages in which the defendants were held during the hearings.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "2. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The hearings of the criminal case at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow took place in hearing room no. 410 of the courthouse, which was equipped with metal cages in which the defendants were held during the hearings.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "2. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "One hearing during the first-instance trial took place at the Moscow City Court in hearing room no. 338, which was equipped with a glass cabin (for the description of conditions of detention in that room, see Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia, nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 74-75, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "2. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "In its judgment of 18 August 2014, the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, guilty as charged.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that on 6 May 2012 at 5 p.m. at the latest, the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, arrived at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow to take part in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that between 5 p.m. and 8 p.m. on 6 May 2012, the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, took part in acts of mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, acting with intent, used violence against police officer I. which did not pose a threat to the life or health of that officer.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, tried to prevent police officers, including police officer I., from arresting another protestor.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, grabbed police officer I. by the leg and, using violence together with unidentified persons, dragged police officer I. away from the protestor and pulled him to the ground.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that unidentified persons hit police officer I. in the head at least twice following the second applicant's, Mr Gaskarov's, actions.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that as a result of the second applicant's, Mr Gaskarov's, and other persons' actions, the protestor was able to escape from the police.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, acting with intent, also used violence against police officer B. by pulling the latter by the left arm and abruptly pulling police officer B. out of the chain of police officers, thereby breaking the chain and making a passage in it for those participating in the mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the second applicant's, Mr Gaskarov's, actions caused police officer B. physical pain.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, pleaded not guilty at trial.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, testified at trial that he had been in front of the cordon when the clashes had begun and had pulled police officer B. by the arm but had not hit him.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, testified at trial that he had seen a group of police officers trying to arrest a young man, pushing him to the ground, grabbing him by his legs and, as the second applicant had thought, beating the man with truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, testified at trial that he had approached police officer I. and dragged him away to a metre's distance, without using violence.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, testified at trial that the young man had then stood up and run in the direction of the crowd, and police officer I. had followed him.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, testified at trial that he had seen a few protestors approach police officer I. and hit him at least twice.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, testified at trial that during the demonstration on 6 May 2012 he had been beaten up by the police without any reason.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, testified at trial that he had lodged a criminal complaint of ill-treatment with the law-enforcement authorities but they had refused to open a criminal investigation into his allegations.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that it had not established any facts showing unlawful behaviour on the part of the police during the demonstration on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the police officers acted lawfully during the demonstration on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, was sentenced to three years and six months' imprisonment, calculated on the basis of a three-year prison term under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, to run partly concurrently with a term of one year and six months under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The second applicant's, Mr Gaskarov's, pre-trial detention counted towards his prison sentence.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "On 27 November 2014 the Moscow City Court upheld the first-instance judgment convicting the second applicant, Mr Gaskarov.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Gaskarov, was released on 27 October 2016 having served his prison term.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "C. Application of Mr Gaskarov (no. 28251/15)", "3. The trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Article 212 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the organisation of mass disorder, accompanied by violence, riots, arson, destruction of property, the use of firearms, explosives and explosive devices, as well as armed resistance to a public official, shall be punishable by four to ten years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that participation in the types of mass disorder provided for by Article 212 § 1 shall be punishable by three to eight years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Article 212 § 3 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the instigation of mass disorder provided for by Article 212 § 1, or the instigation of participation in such acts, or the instigation of violence against citizens, shall be punishable by a restriction of liberty for up to two years, or community service for up to two years, or deprivation of liberty for the same term.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation of 30 December 2001, in force at the material time, provided that failure to obey a lawful order or demand of a police officer in connection with the performance of the officer's official duties relating to maintaining public order and security, or impeding the officer's performance of his or her official duties, shall be punishable by a fine of between RUB 500 and RUB 1,000 or by administrative detention for up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F012", "F014", "F016", "F019", "F021", "F047", "F066", "F067", "F071", "F072", "F078", "F079", "F094", "F095", "F096", "F101", "F102", "F120", "F121", "F135", "F136"], "interference": ["F021", "F047", "F063", "F086", "F101", "F102", "F117", "F125", "F137"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F023", "F024"], "necessity": ["F013", "F014", "F019", "F021", "F047", "F053", "F066", "F067", "F071", "F072", "F078", "F079", "F086", "F092", "F094", "F095", "F101", "F120", "F121", "F125", "F135", "F136", "F137", "F142"], "positive_obligation": ["F017", "F019", "F021", "F045", "F063"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F012", "F014", "F016", "F019", "F021", "F047", "F066", "F078", "F079", "F101", "F120", "F135", "F136"], "interference": ["F063", "F086", "F117", "F137"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F023", "F024"], "necessity": ["F013", "F014", "F019", "F021", "F047", "F053", "F066", "F067", "F071", "F072", "F078", "F079", "F086", "F094", "F095", "F101", "F120", "F121", "F125", "F135", "F136", "F137", "F142"], "positive_obligation": ["F017", "F019", "F021", "F045", "F063"]}, "list3": ["F014", "F019", "F021", "F047", "F066", "F086", "F101", "F120", "F125", "F137", "F078", "F079", "F135", "F136", "F094", "F071", "F013"]}} {"case_name": "case_296", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1992.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Diyarbakır.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 14 July 2008 a demonstration was held in Diyarbakır.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The demonstration of 14 July 2008 in Diyarbakır was held to protest about the conditions of detention of Abdullah Öcalan.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Abdullah Öcalan is the leader of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party) is an illegal armed organisation.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "A report was prepared by four police officers on 21 July 2008 following the examination of video footage of the demonstration of 14 July 2008 recorded by the police.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 11 July 2008 the Fırat News Agency, a website controlled by the PKK, published a declaration of the Democratic People's Initiative of Turkey and Kurdistan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The declaration of the Democratic People's Initiative of Turkey and Kurdistan contained instructions to hold meetings and marches in each town and city on 14 July 2008 to show support for Abdullah Öcalan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, on the website www.rojaciwan.com, which was controlled by the PKK, a news article containing a call for participation in the reading out of a press statement to be held by the Party for a Democratic Society (Demokratik Toplum Partisi, DTP) in Diyarbakır on 14 July 2008 had been published.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The police report of 21 July 2008 stated that the police had received information according to which the Diyarbakır branch of the Party for a Democratic Society (DTP) was the organiser of the press statement to be held on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, Members of Parliament, mayors and local politicians from the DTP as well as members of a number of non-governmental organisations were expected to gather in front of the DTP's Diyarbakır party office at around 5.30 p.m. on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, the group was expected to march from the DTP's Diyarbakır party office to Koşuyolu Park, where they would make a press statement.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The police took the necessary measures on 14 July 2008 as they suspected that there could be violent protests during the march, which could become a demonstration for the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, people started to assemble by 4.30 p.m. on 14 July 2008 in front of the DTP party office in Diyarbakır.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, mayors and Members of Parliament were among the demonstrators on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, by 5.50 p.m. on 14 July 2008 approximately 3,000 people had gathered in front of the DTP party office in Diyarbakır.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, demonstrators started to march and arrived at Koşuyolu Park at 6.30 p.m. on 14 July 2008, where the press statement was made.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, at 7 p.m. on 14 July 2008, while Emine Ayna, a Member of Parliament from the DTP, was giving a speech, a group of people started throwing stones at the police officers and the cars parked in the neighbourhood.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, both in front of the local branch of the DTP and during the march on 14 July 2008, demonstrators chanted slogans praising Abdullah Öcalan, including \"Every Kurd is Öcalan's fedai\" (\"Her Kürt Apo'nun Fedaisidir\"), \"We will drop the world without Öcalan on your head\" (\"Öcalansız dünyayı başınıza yıkarız\"), \"The Youth to Botan, to the free country\" (\"Gençlik Botan'a, Özgür Vatana\"), \"Salutations to İmralı\" (\"Selam Selam İmralı'ya Bin Selam\"), \"With our blood, with our life, we are with you, Öcalan\" (\"Canımızla, kanımızla, seninleyiz Öcalan\"), \"Long live President Öcalan\" (\"Biji Serok Apo\"), \"Martyrs are immortal\" (\"Şehîd Namirin\"), \"No life without the Leader, Mr./Esteemed Öcalan\" (\"Başkansız yaşam olmaz, Sayın Öcalan\").", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, demonstrators on 14 July 2008 carried banners containing slogans such as \"Stop the torture in İmralı\" (\"İmralı işkencesine son\") and \"We make war for life, we die for peace\" (\"Yaşamak için savaşırız; Barış için ölürüz\").", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, demonstrators on 14 July 2008 brandished photographs of Abdullah Öcalan and flags of the so-called \"Confederation\".", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, subsequent to the press statements on 14 July 2008, when the crowd dispersed, some people within the crowd knocked over waste containers and attacked the police and the shops in the neighbourhood with stones and bats while chanting slogans in support of the PKK and its leader.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, the police gave a warning to those people and asked them to disperse on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, the demonstrators refused to obey the warnings to disperse on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, the police intervened against the group on 14 July 2008 using truncheons, water and tear gas.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the police report of 21 July 2008, some people had taken down the Turkish flag in the schoolyard of the Diyarbakır nursery school on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "At the end of the police report of 21 July 2008, it was noted that, according to the video footage, the applicant had thrown stones at the police together with a number of other persons on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "At the end of the police report of 21 July 2008, it was noted that, according to the video footage, the applicant had acted with the group which had taken down the Turkish flag at the Diyarbakır nursery school on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The police report of 21 July 2008 contained twenty-four photographs extracted from the video footage recorded by the police.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "In four of the photographs from the police report of 21 July 2008, the applicant is seen in a group of young men while, according to the police, throwing stones at the security forces.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "In two of the photographs from the police report of 21 July 2008, the applicant is seen standing together with a group of people by a flag pole.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "A total of six photographs in the police report of 21 July 2008 concern the taking down of the Turkish flag.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "One photograph in the police report of 21 July 2008 contains an image of a knocked-over waste container.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "One photograph in the police report of 21 July 2008 shows a damaged passenger van.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The remaining photographs in the police report of 21 July 2008 contain images of demonstrators standing in front of a building or walking.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 14 July 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant was arrested on 21 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the arrest and transfer report, the video recording of the demonstration by the police showed that the applicant had thrown stones at the police officers on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the arrest and transfer report, the video recording of the demonstration by the police showed that the applicant had been in the crowd which had taken down the Turkish flag in a schoolyard on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The officers who drafted the arrest and transfer report stated therein that the applicant had been informed of his rights when arrested on 21 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicant was transferred to the children's branch of the Security Directorate after being found to be a minor subsequent to a medical check following his arrest on 21 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicant noted \"I am not signing\" and put his signature under that sentence on the arrest and transfer report.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 22 July 2008 the applicant made statements before the Diyarbakır public prosecutor in the presence of a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "In his statement of 22 July 2008, the applicant stated that he was a primary school graduate and a peddler.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "In his statement of 22 July 2008, the applicant stated that on 14 July 2008 he and his brother were selling watermelons in front of Koşuyolu Park in Diyarbakır.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In his statement of 22 July 2008, the applicant stated that a large group of demonstrators chanting the slogan \"Long live President Öcalan\" (\"Biji Serok Apo\") approached him on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In his statement of 22 July 2008, the applicant stated that the police intervened and took a number of persons into custody on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "In his statement of 22 July 2008, the applicant stated that he joined the demonstrators and chanted the slogan \"Long live President Öcalan\" (\"Biji Serok Apo\") on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In his statement of 22 July 2008, the applicant stated that he threw stones at the police officers on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In his statement of 22 July 2008, the applicant stated that some people went to a school and he went with them on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "In his statement of 22 July 2008, the applicant stated that some people climbed on the flagpole in the school garden, took down the Turkish flag and replaced it with a PKK flag on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In his statement of 22 July 2008, the applicant stated that he was not involved in taking down the Turkish flag on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "In his statement of 22 July 2008, the applicant stated that he did not have any particular purpose when he chanted the slogan and threw stones at the police, and that he only acted together with the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In his statement of 22 July 2008, the applicant stated that he did not know why there was a demonstration and that he had no connection with any illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In his statement of 22 July 2008, the applicant confirmed that the person in the photograph shown to him was himself.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 22 July 2008 the applicant was brought before a judge of the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Before the judge of the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court on 22 July 2008, the applicant maintained that his statements to the public prosecutor had reflected the truth.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicant's lawyer asked the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court on 22 July 2008 not to remand the applicant in custody, submitting that the applicant was a minor and therefore not capable of realising the meaning and consequences of his acts.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The judge of the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court remanded the applicant in custody on 22 July 2008 in view of the existence of a strong suspicion that he had committed the offence of \"committing an offence on behalf of an illegal organisation without being a member of the organisation\", in breach of Law no. 2911 (Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The judge of the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court remanded the applicant in custody on 22 July 2008 in view of the existence of a strong suspicion that he had committed the offence of \"dissemination of propaganda in support of a terrorist organisation\", and having regard to the evidence.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 22 July 2008 the Diyarbakır public prosecutor filed a bill of indictment against the applicant with the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court had special jurisdiction to try a number of aggravated crimes enumerated under Article 250 § 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The applicant was charged with membership of an illegal organisation as he was considered to have committed a crime on behalf of an illegal organisation under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) on the basis of Articles 220 § 6 and 314 § 3 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The applicant was charged with resisting the security forces by way of throwing stones under sections 23(b) and 33(c) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicant was charged with disseminating propaganda in support of the PKK under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The applicant was charged with denigration of the symbols of the sovereignty of the State under Article 300 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 21 October 2008 the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court held the first hearing in the case against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "During the hearing of 21 October 2008, the applicant reiterated his statements of 22 July 2008 and asked to be released.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "During the hearing of 21 October 2008, the applicant maintained that he had participated in the demonstration, chanted the slogan \"Long live President Öcalan\" (\"Biji Serok Apo\") and thrown stones at the police when they intervened.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "During the hearing of 21 October 2008, the applicant submitted that he had not been among those who had taken down the Turkish flag.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The public prosecutor asked the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court to convict the applicant under Articles 300 and 314 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) and sections 23(b) and 33(c) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The public prosecutor requested that the sentences be reduced taking into account the fact that the applicant had been aged between 15 and 18 years old at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 11 November 2008 the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court rendered its judgment in the case against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court noted in its judgment of 11 November 2008 a summary of the applicant's defence submissions and the public prosecutor's observations on the merits of the case.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court noted in its judgment of 11 November 2008 the following evidence in the case file: the applicant's statements before the public prosecutor and the judge on 22 July 2008; his identity documents and a document showing that he did not have a previous criminal record; the arrest and transfer report of 21 July 2008; an incident report dated 14 July 2008; printed versions of documents downloaded from the Internet; the police report of 21 July 2008 describing the events of 14 July 2008 and the applicant's participation in those events; photographs extracted from the video footage recorded by the police; and medical reports.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court found in its judgment of 11 November 2008 that on 11 July 2008 the Fırat News Agency, controlled by the PKK, published a declaration of the Democratic People's Initiative of Turkey and Kurdistan containing instructions to hold marches on 14 July 2008 to show respect for Abdullah Öcalan, with the nature of Serhildan (rebellion).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court found in its judgment of 11 November 2008 that on the website www.rojaciwan.com, also controlled by the PKK, a news article containing a call for participation in the reading out of a press statement was published, describing the treatment of Abdullah Öcalan as torture and calling people to participate.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court found in its judgment of 11 November 2008 that on 14 July 2008 at around 4.30 p.m. people began to gather in front of the local branch of the DTP in Diyarbakır, including Members of Parliament and mayors who were members of the DTP.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court found in its judgment of 11 November 2008 that at around 5.50 p.m. on 14 July 2008 there were 3,000 persons gathered, and the crowd started the march, arriving in Koşuyolu Park at around 6.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court found in its judgment of 11 November 2008 that both in front of the local branch of the DTP and during the march on 14 July 2008, demonstrators chanted slogans praising Abdullah Öcalan, the leader of the terrorist organisation, and carried banners, photographs of Abdullah Öcalan and flags of the so-called \"Confederation\".", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court found in its judgment of 11 November 2008 that at 7 p.m. on 14 July 2008, while Emine Ayna, a Member of Parliament from the DTP, was giving a speech, a group of people started throwing stones at the police officers and the cars parked in the neighbourhood.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court found in its judgment of 11 November 2008 that subsequent to the press statements on 14 July 2008, some people knocked over waste containers and attacked the police and shops with stones and bats while chanting slogans in support of the PKK and its leader, and that some within the crowd took down the Turkish flag in the schoolyard of the Diyarbakır nursery school.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court established in its judgment of 11 November 2008 that the applicant (Ferit Gülcü) actively took part in the illegal demonstrations held on 14 July 2008 in Diyarbakır in accordance with the instructions of the terrorist organisation PKK.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court established in its judgment of 11 November 2008 that the applicant chanted the slogan \"Long live President Öcalan\" (\"Biji Serok Apo\") together with the crowd on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court established in its judgment of 11 November 2008 that the applicant attacked the police with stones on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court established in its judgment of 11 November 2008 that the applicant acted together with the group who took down the Turkish flag in the schoolyard of the Diyarbakır nursery school on 14 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court established in its judgment of 11 November 2008 that the applicant incited the persons who took down the Turkish flag, thereby strengthening their will to commit that offence.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court noted in its judgment of 11 November 2008 that in his defence submissions the applicant accepted that he had taken part in the illegal demonstration, made propaganda in support of the terrorist organisation, and resisted the police by way of throwing stones, but denied participating in the taking down of the Turkish flag.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court concluded in its judgment of 11 November 2008 that the applicant's acts, committed within the knowledge and in line with the will of the PKK organisation, were perpetrated on behalf of the organisation, and that the applicant should be convicted under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) with reference to Articles 314 § 3 and 220 § 6 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court acquitted the applicant on the charge of denigration of the symbols of the sovereignty of the State under Article 300 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), noting that it was not established that the crime had been committed by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court convicted the applicant under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), on the basis of Articles 220 § 6 and 314 § 3 of the same Code; section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713); and sections 23(b) and 33(c) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court sentenced the applicant to a total of seven years and six months of imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court convicted the applicant of membership of an illegal organisation pursuant to Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) on the basis of Articles 220 § 6 and 314 § 3 of the same Code, finding it established that the applicant had taken part in the events of 14 July 2008 which had become propaganda in support of the illegal organisation, upon the call made by the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "For the membership of an illegal organisation conviction, the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court applied the minimum penalty of five years' imprisonment, then increased it by one and a half times by virtue of section 5 of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) to seven years and six months.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "For the membership of an illegal organisation conviction, the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court reduced the sentence by one third by virtue of Article 31 § 3 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), taking into account that the applicant had been aged between 15 and 18 at the material time, resulting in five years.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "For the membership of an illegal organisation conviction, the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court further reduced the sentence by one sixth under Article 62 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) taking into account the applicant's \"sincere confessions\" as well as his attitude and behaviour during the proceedings, resulting in a total of four years and two months of imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court convicted the applicant of disseminating propaganda in support of a terrorist organisation under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "For the propaganda conviction, the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court applied the minimum penalty of one year of imprisonment, then reduced it by one third by virtue of Article 31 § 3 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) taking into account the fact that the applicant had been aged between 15 and 18 at the material time, resulting in eight months.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "For the propaganda conviction, the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court further reduced the sentence by one sixth under Article 62 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), taking into account the applicant's \"sincere confessions\" as well as his attitude and behaviour during the proceedings, resulting in a total of six months and twenty days.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court decided not to commute the propaganda sentence to a fine under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713), or to defer it pursuant to section 13 of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court found Article 231 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) governing the suspension of the pronouncement of a judgment inapplicable in the circumstances of the applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court convicted the applicant of resistance to security forces pursuant to sections 23(b) and 33(c) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "For the resistance to security forces conviction, the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court applied the minimum penalty of five years' imprisonment, then reduced it by one third by virtue of Article 31 § 3 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), taking into account the fact that the applicant had been aged between 15 and 18 at the material time, resulting in three years and four months.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "For the resistance to security forces conviction, the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court further reduced the sentence by one sixth under Article 62 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), taking into account the applicant's \"sincere confessions\" as well as his attitude and behaviour during the proceedings, resulting in a total of two years, nine months and ten days' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court decided not to commute the resistance to security forces sentence to a fine, and not to defer it, having regard to the overall sentence and the fact that the applicant did not give the impression that he would refrain from committing a crime.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "On 6 October 2009 the Court of Cassation upheld the judgment of 11 November 2008 of the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "On 16 December 2009 the final decision of the Court of Cassation was deposited with the registry of the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "On 25 July 2010 Law no. 6008 entered into force.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "On 26 July 2010 the applicant's representative lodged a petition with the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The applicant's representative noted in the petition of 26 July 2010 that Law no. 6008 had amended certain provisions of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) and the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The applicant's representative requested in the petition of 26 July 2010 that the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court examine whether the amended versions of the provisions of Laws nos. 2911 and 3713 could be considered to be in favour of the applicant and, if so, whether the execution of the applicant's sentence could be suspended.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "On 26 July 2010 the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court decided to suspend the execution of the applicant's sentence in view of the fact that certain provisions of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) and the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) amended by Law no. 6008 were in favour of juvenile offenders.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Following the suspension of the execution of the applicant's sentence on 26 July 2010, the applicant was released from prison.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "A new procedure was initiated in accordance with Article 7 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), according to which in the case of a difference between the legal provisions in force on the date of commission of a crime and those in force after that date, the provision which is more favourable will be applied to the offender.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "On 3 December 2010 the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court held that it no longer had jurisdiction over the applicant's case in the light of a new paragraph added to Article 250 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) by Law no. 6008.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The new paragraph added to Article 250 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) by Law no. 6008 provided that minors could not be tried by assize courts which had special jurisdiction.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "On 20 January 2011 Diyarbakır Juvenile Assize Court decided that it was not competent to examine the applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "On 22 February 2011 Diyarbakır Juvenile Court decided that it was not competent to examine the applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Upon both Diyarbakır Juvenile Assize Court and Diyarbakır Juvenile Court declining jurisdiction, the applicant's case was transferred to the Court of Cassation to resolve the issue of jurisdiction.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "On 3 October 2012 the Court of Cassation decided that Diyarbakır Juvenile Court had jurisdiction over the applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Diyarbakır Juvenile Court started the re-assessment of the applicant's case with a view to determining the applicable legal provisions and the sentences in accordance with Article 7 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) and in the light of the amendments made to the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) and the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) by Law no. 6008 (uyarlama yargılaması).", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "On an unspecified date the applicant made statements before Diyarbakır Juvenile Court, contending that he had already served his prison sentence and that he contested the new procedure.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "On 20 December 2012 Diyarbakır Juvenile Court rendered its judgment regarding the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Diyarbakır Juvenile Court revoked the applicant's convictions contained in the judgment of 11 November 2008 of the Fifth Division of Diyarbakır Assize Court, holding that the amendments applied by Law no. 6008 were in favour of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Diyarbakır Juvenile Court acquitted the applicant of the charge of membership of a terrorist organisation under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), having regard to section 34/A of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911), which had entered into force on 25 July 2010 with Law no. 6008.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Diyarbakır Juvenile Court convicted the applicant of disseminating propaganda in support of a terrorist organisation under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "For the propaganda conviction, Diyarbakır Juvenile Court applied the minimum penalty of one year of imprisonment, then reduced it by one third by virtue of Article 31 § 3 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), taking into account the fact that the applicant had been aged between 15 and 18 at the material time, resulting in eight months.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "For the propaganda conviction, Diyarbakır Juvenile Court further reduced the sentence by one sixth under Article 62 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), taking into account the possible implications of the sentence for the minor, resulting in a total of six months and twenty days.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Diyarbakır Juvenile Court suspended the pronouncement of the propaganda judgment on condition that the applicant did not commit another wilful offence for a period of three years, in accordance with Article 231 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) and Article 23 of the Code of Juvenile Protection (Law no. 5395), having regard to the length of the sentence and to the fact that the applicant did not have a criminal record.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Diyarbakır Juvenile Court convicted the applicant of participation in a demonstration while in possession of prohibited materials pursuant to section 33(1) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "For the conviction of participation in a demonstration while in possession of prohibited materials, Diyarbakır Juvenile Court applied the minimum penalty of six months' imprisonment, then reduced it by one third by virtue of Article 31 § 3 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), taking into account the fact that the applicant had been aged between 15 and 18 at the material time, resulting in four months.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "For the conviction of participation in a demonstration while in possession of prohibited materials, Diyarbakır Juvenile Court further reduced the sentence by one sixth under Article 62 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), taking into account the possible implications of the sentence for the minor, resulting in a total of three months and ten days.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Diyarbakır Juvenile Court suspended the pronouncement of the judgment for participation in a demonstration while in possession of prohibited materials on condition that the applicant did not commit another wilful offence for a period of three years, in accordance with Article 231 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) and Article 23 of the Code of Juvenile Protection (Law no. 5395), having regard to the length of the sentence and to the fact that the applicant did not have a criminal record.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Diyarbakır Juvenile Court convicted the applicant of resistance to the security forces which had used force to disperse the demonstrators pursuant to section 32(1) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "For the conviction of resistance to the security forces under section 32(1) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911), Diyarbakır Juvenile Court applied the minimum penalty of six months' imprisonment, then reduced it by one third by virtue of Article 31 § 3 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), taking into account the fact that the applicant had been aged between 15 and 18 at the material time, resulting in four months.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "For the conviction of resistance to the security forces under section 32(1) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911), Diyarbakır Juvenile Court further reduced the sentence by one sixth under Article 62 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), taking into account the possible implications of the sentence for the minor, resulting in a total of three months and ten days.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Diyarbakır Juvenile Court suspended the pronouncement of the judgment for resistance to the security forces under section 32(1) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) on condition that the applicant did not commit another wilful offence for a period of three years, in accordance with Article 231 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) and Article 23 of the Code of Juvenile Protection (Law no. 5395), having regard to the length of the sentence and to the fact that the applicant did not have a criminal record.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Diyarbakır Juvenile Court convicted the applicant of obstructing the security forces in the execution of their duties by way of resistance together with other persons and using the influence of an organisation pursuant to section 32(2) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) and Article 265 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "For the conviction under section 32(2) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) and Article 265 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), Diyarbakır Juvenile Court applied the minimum penalty of six months' imprisonment, then increased it by one third as the crime had been committed collectively, resulting in eight months.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "For the conviction under section 32(2) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) and Article 265 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), Diyarbakır Juvenile Court further increased the sentence by one half pursuant to Article 265 § 4 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) as the crime had been committed using the influence of an organisation, resulting in twelve months.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "For the conviction under section 32(2) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) and Article 265 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), Diyarbakır Juvenile Court reduced the sentence by one third by virtue of Article 31 § 3 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), taking into account the fact that the applicant had been aged between 15 and 18 at the material time, resulting in eight months.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "For the conviction under section 32(2) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) and Article 265 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), Diyarbakır Juvenile Court further reduced the sentence by one sixth under Article 62 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), taking into account the possible implications of the sentence for a minor, resulting in a total of six months and twenty days.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Diyarbakır Juvenile Court suspended the pronouncement of the judgment for the conviction under section 32(2) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) and Article 265 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) on condition that the applicant did not commit another wilful offence for a period of three years, in accordance with Article 231 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) and Article 23 of the Code of Juvenile Protection (Law no. 5395), having regard to the length of the sentence and to the fact that the applicant did not have a criminal record.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "On 31 December 2012 the judgment of Diyarbakır Juvenile Court of 20 December 2012 became final in the absence of any objection.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Under Article 7 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), in case of a difference between the legal provisions in force at the date of commission of an offence and those in force after that date, the provision which is more favourable is applied to the offender.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who establishes or directs organisations for the purpose of criminal activity shall be liable to imprisonment of between two and six years, provided that the structure of the organisation, the number of members, and the quantity of equipment and supplies are sufficient to commit the intended crimes.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who becomes a member of an organisation established for the purpose of criminal activity shall be liable to imprisonment of between one and three years.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 3 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that if the organisation is armed, the sentences stated in paragraphs 1 and 2 shall be increased by a proportion of between one quarter and one half.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 4 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that any crime committed within the framework of the organisation's activities shall be punished separately.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 5 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that the heads of the organisations shall also be sentenced as the perpetrators of all crimes committed within the framework of the organisation's activities.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who commits a crime on behalf of the illegal organisation, even if they are not a member of that organisation, shall also be punished for being a member of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 7 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who aids and abets an illegal organisation knowingly and intentionally, even if they do not belong to the hierarchical structure of the organisation, shall be punished as a member of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 8 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who makes propaganda for the organisation or its objectives shall be punished by imprisonment of between one and three years, and if the said crime is committed through the media and press the sentence shall be increased by one half.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article 220 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) were amended by Law no. 6352, which entered into force on 2 July 2012, to provide that the penalty to be imposed for membership under paragraph 6 may be reduced by up to half, and the penalty under paragraph 7 may be reduced by up to two thirds depending on the nature of the assistance.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) was further amended by Law no. 6459, which entered into force on 11 April 2013, to provide that the paragraph shall be applicable only for armed organisations.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "Article 314 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who forms an armed organisation to commit the crimes listed in the fourth and fifth sections of that chapter, or commands such an organisation, shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between ten and fifteen years.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who becomes a member of an armed organisation mentioned in Article 314 § 1 shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between five and ten years.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "Article 314 § 3 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that other provisions relating to the crime of forming an organisation for the purpose of criminal activity are also applicable for the crime of membership of an armed organisation.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "Article 300 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who publicly tears, burns or otherwise denigrates the Turkish flag shall be sentenced to a term of imprisonment of between one and three years, and that this provision applies to all signs bearing the white crescent and star on a red ground described in the Constitution as a symbol of the sovereignty of the State of the Republic of Turkey.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "Article 265 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who uses methods of violence or threats against a public officer with a view to obstructing him or her in the execution of his or her duties shall be liable to imprisonment of between six months and three years.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "According to section 23(b) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911), in force at the material time, meetings or demonstration marches during which the demonstrators or the participants bear, inter alia, firearms, explosives, cutting and perforating tools, stones, bats, iron or rubber bars, wires, chains, poisons, gas or fog materials, were considered to be \"unlawful meetings and demonstration marches\".", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911)"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "Section 33(c) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911), before it was amended by Law no. 6008 on 25 July 2010, provided that persons who show resistance with weapons or materials listed in section 23(b) while being dispersed during meetings and demonstration marches shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between five and eight years.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911)"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "Following the amendments introduced by Law no. 6008, section 33 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) provided that persons who take part in meetings and demonstration marches while carrying weapons or materials listed in section 23(b) shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between six months and three years.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911)"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "Following the amendments introduced by Law no. 6008, section 32(1) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) provides that persons taking part in unlawful meetings or demonstration marches who continue not to disperse despite warnings or use of force shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between six months and three years, and that if the offender is one of the organisers the sentence shall be increased by half.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911)"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "Following the amendments introduced by Law no. 6008, section 32(2) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) provides that persons who resist the security forces by methods of violence or threats despite warnings or use of force shall also be punished for committing the crime proscribed by Article 265 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911)"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "By Law no. 6008 a new provision, section 34/A, was added to the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911), providing that section 2(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) shall not be applicable to children who commit the crime of resistance during unlawful meetings and demonstration marches or who commit the crime of propaganda during meetings and demonstration marches in which they take part.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911)"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "At the material time, section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) provided that any person who disseminates propaganda in support of a terrorist organisation shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between one and five years.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "Section 2(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713), referred to in section 34/A of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911), provides that persons who commit crimes on behalf of a terrorist organisation shall be considered as terror offenders even if they are not a member of that terrorist organisation.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "Suspension of the pronouncement of a judgment is governed by Article 231 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271).", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271)"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "Article 231 § 5 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) provides that if the accused has been convicted and ordered to pay a fine or sentenced to imprisonment for less than two years, the court may decide to suspend the pronouncement of the judgment, and that such suspension entails that the judgment shall not bear any legal consequences for the offender.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271)"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "Article 231 § 6 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) provides that suspension of the pronouncement of the judgment may be decided provided that: (a) the offender has never been found guilty of a wilful offence; (b) the court is convinced that there is little risk of any further offence being committed; and (c) the damage caused to the victim or to society is redressed by way of restitution or compensation.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271)"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "Article 231 § 8 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) provides that if the pronouncement of the judgment is suspended, the offender will be kept under supervision for the following five years.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271)"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "Article 231 § 10 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) provides that if the offender does not commit another wilful offence and abides by the obligations of the supervision order, the judgment whose pronouncement had been suspended will be cancelled and the case discontinued.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271)"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "Article 231 § 11 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) provides that if the offender commits another wilful offence or acts in violation of the obligations of the supervision order, the court shall impose the sentence, but may evaluate the offender's situation and decide that up to half of the total sentence will not be executed, and may also suspend the execution of any imprisonment or commute it to other optional measures.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271)"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "Article 231 § 12 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) provides that an objection to the decision to suspend the pronouncement of the judgment may be filed.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271)"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "At the material time, according to Article 250 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) and section 4 of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713), assize courts with special jurisdiction were competent to try a number of crimes, including the crimes proscribed by Article 314 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271)"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "By Law no. 6008 a new paragraph (paragraph 4) was inserted in Article 250 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271), according to which children could not be tried by assize courts which had special jurisdiction.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271)"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "On 5 July 2012 both Article 250 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271) and section 4 of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) were repealed and assize courts with special jurisdiction were abolished.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Code of Criminal Procedure (Law no. 5271)"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "Article 23 of the Code of Child Protection (Law no. 5395) provides that at the end of criminal proceedings brought against a child, the court may decide to suspend the pronouncement of the judgment if the conditions are fulfilled, and that the period of supervision for such persons is three years.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Code of Child Protection (Law no. 5395)"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "In criminal proceedings brought against a certain F.Ö., on 29 September 2006 Diyarbakır Assize Court convicted him under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) and section 32(1) and (3) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) on account of his participation in and conduct during three demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "On 21 February 2007 the Ninth Criminal Division of the Court of Cassation quashed the judgment of Diyarbakır Assize Court in the case of F.Ö., holding that F.Ö.'s acts constituted not only the offences proscribed in section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) and section 32(1) and (3) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911), but also membership of an illegal organisation under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) on the basis of Articles 220 § 6 and 314 § 3 of the same Code, as he had committed those offences on behalf of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "The Ninth Criminal Division of the Court of Cassation considered that F.Ö. should be punished for having committed the offence of membership of an illegal organisation and the other offences proscribed in section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) and section 32(1) and (3) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "On 31 May 2007 Diyarbakır Assize Court reiterated its previous judgment that F.Ö.'s acts did not constitute the offence proscribed in Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "Diyarbakır Assize Court stated in its judgment of 31 May 2007 in the case of F.Ö. that in cases where people participate in funerals of members of a terrorist organisation or in Newroz celebrations subsequent to abstract and generalised calls of that organisation, and where chanting slogans constitutes propaganda for that organisation, it is not possible to state that those crimes were committed on behalf of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "Diyarbakır Assize Court stated in its judgment of 31 May 2007 in the case of F.Ö. that in order for a court to conclude that a crime was committed on behalf of an organisation, the organisation must have called for action not to an undefined collective, but rather to an individual person who is capable of directly committing that act.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "As a result of the disagreement between Diyarbakır Assize Court and the Ninth Criminal Division of the Court of Cassation in the case of F.Ö., the case was transferred to the Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions).", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) decided to quash the judgment of Diyarbakır Assize Court in the case of F.Ö. (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44).", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) in its decision of 4 March 2008 described the PKK's aim as forming a Marxist–Leninist state by separation of a part of the territory under the sovereignty of the Republic of Turkey by means of an armed struggle.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) in its decision of 4 March 2008 described that following the arrest of Abdullah Öcalan, the PKK held its 7th Congress between 2 and 23 January 2000, at which a new action plan, the 'Democratisation and Peace Project', was adopted, and the Central Committee was replaced by the Party Assembly while the ARGK and the ERNK were replaced by the HPG (Kurdistan People's Defence Force) and the YDK (Kurdistan Democratic People's Union) respectively.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) in its decision of 4 March 2008 described that a conference named 'the 6th National Conference' by the PKK was held between 5 and 22 August 2000, at which an action plan of 'Civil Disobedience' was adopted, aimed at damaging the international reputation of the State of the Republic of Turkey and its security forces.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) in its decision of 4 March 2008 described various civil disobedience actions planned and implemented by the PKK, including submitting petitions for Kurdish language education, dressing in traditional Kurdish costumes, applying to courts to have 'Kurdish' written on identity cards, and filing applications stating support for the PKK's new strategy.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) in its decision of 4 March 2008 described that at the PKK's 8th Congress held between 4 and 10 April 2002, the name PKK was changed to KADEK (Kongra Azadi U Demokrasi A Kürdistane – Kurdistan Freedom and Democracy Congress).", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) in its decision of 4 March 2008 described that at the PKK's 9th Congress held between 26 October and 15 November 2003, the name KADEK was changed to KONGRA-GEL (Kurdish People's Congress).", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) in its decision of 4 March 2008 described that between 16 and 26 May 2004 the PKK held its 10th Congress on Mount Kandil in Northern Iraq, at which it decided to re-activate the militants of the HPG and to carry out armed actions, and also decided to bring forward various issues via sympathising individuals and NGOs to shape public opinion and apply pressure on the State.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) in its decision of 4 March 2008 described that the PKK reverted back to its original name of 'PKK' (Partiye Karkerani Kürdistan – Kurdistan Workers' Party) on 4 April 2005, the birthday of Abdullah Öcalan.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) in its decision of 4 March 2008 described events of 28 March 2006 in Diyarbakır, where around 1500-2000 people gathered at Şerif Efendi Mosque following the deaths of fourteen PKK militants, and the crowd chanted separatist slogans, waved posters of Abdullah Öcalan and banners of the organisation, and subsequently threw stones at police officers, injured a number of police officers and caused extensive material damage.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) in its decision of 4 March 2008 described that demonstrations continued on 29, 30 and 31 March 2006, during which protesters burned vehicles, looted businesses, hurled Molotov cocktails, blocked roads, attacked police officers and police vehicles, staged an arson attack on a bank building and took down and burned a Turkish flag.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) in its decision of 4 March 2008 described that prior to the March 2006 demonstrations, media organs controlled by the PKK, including Fırat News Agency and Roj TV, had called for mass protests.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) in its decision of 4 March 2008 described that throughout the nationwide protests of March 2006, above two hundred police officers were injured, several cars were burned, windows of an indeterminate number of shops were smashed, many State buildings were set on fire, 9 people died and 41 persons were injured.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) in its decision of 4 March 2008 described that F.Ö. participated in the funeral of E.E., a member of the PKK killed on 26 February 2006, carried the deceased's coffin, sang the PKK's anthem 'Hernepeş', chanted slogans praising the PKK and its leader, and directed the group.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) in its decision of 4 March 2008 described that F.Ö. participated in the Newroz celebrations held in Diyarbakır Fairground on 21 March 2006, was among a group of people who attacked police officers at control points, destroyed barriers, carried flags symbolising the PKK and posters of its leader, directed the group, and 10 police officers were injured.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) held in its decision of 4 March 2008 that the PKK's public call had been made concrete through broadcasts from media organs of the organisation and there is no need for such calls to target identified individual persons.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) held in its decision of 4 March 2008 that the acts carried out on behalf of the PKK were within the knowledge of the organisation and in line with its will, and that the acts of an accused who participates in such acts constitute a breach of Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) on the basis of Articles 220 § 6 and 314 § 3 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. The decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "The Convention on the Rights of the Child was adopted by the General Assembly of the United Nations on 20 November 1989 and has binding force under international law vis-à-vis the Contracting States, including all member States of the Council of Europe.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "1. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child"]}, {"fact_id": "F205", "text": "Article 1 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child states that a child means every human being below the age of eighteen years unless under the law applicable to the child, majority is attained earlier.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "1. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child"]}, {"fact_id": "F206", "text": "Article 3 § 1 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child provides that in all actions concerning children, whether undertaken by public or private social welfare institutions, courts of law, administrative authorities or legislative bodies, the best interests of the child shall be a primary consideration.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "1. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child"]}, {"fact_id": "F207", "text": "Article 37(b) of the Convention on the Rights of the Child provides that no child shall be deprived of his or her liberty unlawfully or arbitrarily, and that the arrest, detention or imprisonment of a child shall be in conformity with the law and shall be used only as a measure of last resort and for the shortest appropriate period of time.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "1. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child"]}, {"fact_id": "F208", "text": "Article 37(c) of the Convention on the Rights of the Child provides that every child deprived of liberty shall be treated with humanity and respect for the inherent dignity of the human person, and in a manner which takes into account the needs of persons of his or her age.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "1. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child"]}, {"fact_id": "F209", "text": "Article 40 § 1 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child provides that States Parties recognize the right of every child alleged as, accused of, or recognized as having infringed the penal law to be treated in a manner consistent with the promotion of the child's sense of dignity and worth, which reinforces the child's respect for the human rights and fundamental freedoms of others and which takes into account the child's age and the desirability of promoting the child's reintegration and the child's assuming a constructive role in society.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "1. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child"]}, {"fact_id": "F210", "text": "Article 40 § 3(b) of the Convention on the Rights of the Child provides that States Parties shall seek to promote measures for dealing with children in conflict with the law without resorting to judicial proceedings, providing that human rights and legal safeguards are fully respected.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "1. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child"]}, {"fact_id": "F211", "text": "Article 40 § 4 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child provides that a variety of dispositions, such as care, guidance and supervision orders, counselling, probation, foster care, education and vocational training programmes and other alternatives to institutional care shall be available to ensure that children are dealt with in a manner appropriate to their well-being and proportionate both to their circumstances and the offence.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "1. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child"]}, {"fact_id": "F212", "text": "General Comment No. 10 of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child, dated 25 April 2007, states that children in conflict with the law have the right to be treated in ways that promote their reintegration and the child's assuming a constructive role in society, and that the arrest, detention or imprisonment of a child may be used only as a measure of last resort.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "2. General Comment No. 10 (2007) of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (CRC/C/GC/10)"]}, {"fact_id": "F213", "text": "General Comment No. 10 of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child, dated 25 April 2007, states that when judicial proceedings are initiated, the juvenile justice system should provide for ample opportunities to deal with children in conflict with the law by using social and/or educational measures, and to strictly limit the use of deprivation of liberty, and in particular pre-trial detention, as a measure of last resort.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "2. General Comment No. 10 (2007) of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (CRC/C/GC/10)"]}, {"fact_id": "F214", "text": "General Comment No. 10 of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child, dated 25 April 2007, states that the reaction to an offence should always be in proportion not only to the circumstances and the gravity of the offence, but also to the age, lesser culpability, circumstances and needs of the child, as well as to the various and particularly long-term needs of the society, and that a strictly punitive approach is not in accordance with the leading principles for juvenile justice.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "2. General Comment No. 10 (2007) of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (CRC/C/GC/10)"]}, {"fact_id": "F215", "text": "The Concluding Observations of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child on Turkey (CRC/C/TUR/CO/2-3), dated 30 July 2012, recommended that Turkey continue its efforts to ensure full enjoyment of the freedoms of expression, association and peaceful assembly by children by amending its legislation to remove the remaining obstacles to these rights.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "3. Concluding Observations of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child: Turkey (CRC/C/TUR/CO/2-3)"]}, {"fact_id": "F216", "text": "The Concluding Observations of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child on Turkey (CRC/C/TUR/CO/2-3), dated 30 July 2012, commended Turkey for its extensive reforms in the area of juvenile justice, including new legislative changes resulting in the increase of the age of criminal liability from 11 to 12 years, requiring all persons under the age of 18, including those charged under the Counter-terrorism Law, to be considered in juvenile courts, and introducing reduced sentences for children and special measures for children who are pushed into crime.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "3. Concluding Observations of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child: Turkey (CRC/C/TUR/CO/2-3)"]}, {"fact_id": "F217", "text": "The Concluding Observations of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child on Turkey (CRC/C/TUR/CO/2-3), dated 30 July 2012, expressed concern about: insufficient number of professionals working in the juvenile justice system; poor quality of legal assistance provided to children; long duration of trials involving children resulting in large numbers of children in pre-trial detention; unduly heavy penalties against children and lack of alternative measures; reports that amendments to the Counter-terrorism Law are not upheld in practice; and long detention periods and poor conditions in some prisons.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "3. Concluding Observations of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child: Turkey (CRC/C/TUR/CO/2-3)"]}, {"fact_id": "F218", "text": "The Concluding Observations of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child on Turkey (CRC/C/TUR/CO/2-3), dated 30 July 2012, recommended that Turkey bring the juvenile justice system fully in line with the Convention on the Rights of the Child, in particular articles 37, 39 and 40, and with other relevant standards including the Beijing Rules, the Riyadh Guidelines, the Havana Rules, the Vienna Guidelines and the Committee's general comment No. 10 (2007).", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. United Nations Documents", "3. Concluding Observations of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child: Turkey (CRC/C/TUR/CO/2-3)"]}, {"fact_id": "F219", "text": "In its Resolution 2010 (2014), adopted on 27 June 2014 and entitled \"Child-friendly juvenile justice: from rhetoric to reality\", the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe called on member States to establish a specialised juvenile justice system, set the minimum age of criminal responsibility at at least 14 years of age, prohibit exceptions to the minimum age of criminal responsibility, and ensure that detention of juveniles is used as a measure of last resort and for the shortest possible period of time.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "1. Resolution 2010 (2014) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F220", "text": "In its Resolution 2010 (2014) of 27 June 2014, the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe called on member States to develop a broad range of alternative non-custodial measures and sanctions, abolish life imprisonment for children, establish a reasonable maximum period to which a child may be sentenced, and develop a broad range of diversion programmes based on principles of restorative justice.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "1. Resolution 2010 (2014) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F221", "text": "The Recommendation of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe on social reactions to juvenile delinquency (R (87)20), adopted on 17 September 1987 at the 410th meeting of the Ministers' Deputies, recommended that governments of member states review their legislation and practice with a view to excluding the remand in custody of minors, apart from exceptional cases of very serious offences committed by older minors, and in such cases restricting the length of remand in custody and keeping minors apart from adults.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "2. Recommendation R (87) 20 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F222", "text": "The Recommendation on the European Rules for juvenile offenders subject to sanctions or measures (CM/Rec(2008)11), adopted by the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe on 5 November 2008, provides that the imposition and implementation of sanctions or measures shall be based on the best interests of the juvenile offenders, limited by the gravity of the offences committed, and take account of their age, physical and mental well-being, development, capacities and personal circumstances.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "3. Recommendation CM/Rec(2008)11 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F223", "text": "The Recommendation CM/Rec(2008)11, adopted by the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe on 5 November 2008, provides that deprivation of liberty of a juvenile shall be a measure of last resort and imposed and implemented for the shortest period possible, and that special efforts must be undertaken to avoid pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "3. Recommendation CM/Rec(2008)11 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F224", "text": "In his report published on 1 October 2009 (CommDH(2009)30), following his visit to Turkey on 28 June to 3 July 2009, Mr Thomas Hammarberg, the former Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, stated that over the previous nine months approximately 250 children of Kurdish origin, more than 190 of them between 13 and 17 years of age, had been arrested and detained after having taken part in demonstrations organised by Kurdish groups and thrown stones at police forces.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "4. Reports of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F225", "text": "In his report published on 1 October 2009 (CommDH(2009)30), Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated that four children aged between 16 and 17 had been detained in the Diyarbakır prison since 14 July 2008, charged with membership of a terrorist organization as a result of participating in a protest in Diyarbakır.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "4. Reports of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F226", "text": "In his report published on 1 October 2009 (CommDH(2009)30), Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated that prosecution in such cases is often based on Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), and that the extensive use of this provision by courts against participants of Kurdish-related demonstrations follows a ruling of the General Criminal Board of the Court of Cassation in March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "4. Reports of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F227", "text": "In his report published on 1 October 2009 (CommDH(2009)30), Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated that it appears necessary to revisit certain over-restrictive provisions of the legislation, including Criminal Code Articles 301 and 220, which have been used in a manner that has unjustifiably suppressed freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "4. Reports of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F228", "text": "In his report published on 12 July 2011 (CommDH(2011)25), following his visit to Turkey on 27 to 29 April 2011, Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated that his deep concern about the application of Article 220 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), and in particular its paragraphs 6 and 8, expressed following his 2009 visit, remains valid in the context of freedom of expression and freedom of the media in Turkey.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "4. Reports of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F229", "text": "In his report published on 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2), following his visit to Turkey on 10 to 14 October 2011, Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated that he was particularly preoccupied by the wide interpretation of the courts concerning the definition of offences and their constitutive acts under the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) and Article 220 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "4. Reports of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F230", "text": "In his report published on 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2), Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated that persons participating in demonstrations following public calls by the PKK were brought into the ambit of Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), in accordance with a ruling of the Court of Cassation in March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "4. Reports of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F231", "text": "In his report published on 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2), Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated that the application of Article 220 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), as well as of Articles 6 and 7 of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713), continues to raise serious concerns.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "4. Reports of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F232", "text": "In his report published on 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2), Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated that violence or the threat to use violence is an essential component of an act of terrorism, and that restrictions of human rights in the fight against terrorism must be defined as precisely as possible and be necessary and proportionate to the aim pursued.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "4. Reports of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F233", "text": "In his report published on 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2), Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated that the provisions contained in the Turkish anti-terror legislation and Article 220 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) allow for a very wide margin of appreciation, in particular in cases where membership in a terrorist organisation has not been proven and when an act or statement may be deemed to coincide with the aims or instructions of a terrorist organisation.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "4. Reports of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F234", "text": "On 20 February 2012 Mr Thomas Hammarberg published his comments concerning a draft law presented to the Parliament of Turkey by the Government, which envisaged amendments to various legal provisions, including Article 220 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "4. Reports of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F235", "text": "The draft law commented on by Mr Thomas Hammarberg on 20 February 2012 was subsequently adopted on 2 July 2012 as Law no. 6352.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "4. Reports of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F236", "text": "In his comments of 20 February 2012, Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated that the proposed amendments to Article 220 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) concerning paragraphs 6 and 7 would reduce the penalty by half for paragraph 6 and by up to two thirds for paragraph 7, potentially allowing persons being tried for these offences to benefit from alternative measures to remand in custody.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "4. Reports of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F237", "text": "In his comments of 20 February 2012, Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated that while the proposed amendments to Article 220 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) could have short-term benefits, they do not offer a lasting solution to serious problems caused by Article 220, and that the main concern is the fact that Article 220 allows for a very wide margin of appreciation in cases where membership in a terrorist organisation has not been proven.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Council of Europe documents", "4. Reports of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe"]}, {"fact_id": "F238", "text": "On 1 November 2010 Human Rights Watch published a report entitled \"Protesting as a Terrorist Offence / The Arbitrary Use of Terrorism Laws to Prosecute and Incarcerate Demonstrators in Turkey\", which mainly concerned trials and convictions of demonstrators in Turkey under the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) and the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F239", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 stated that many hundreds of people in Turkey face prosecution or are serving substantial sentences for terrorism convictions for engaging in peaceful protest or throwing stones or burning a tire at a protest, and that legal amendments since 2005 and case law since 2008 have allowed courts to convict demonstrators under the harshest terrorism laws.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F240", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 stated that criminal justice officials have deemed Kurdish protestors to be 'committing crimes on behalf of the PKK without being a member of that organization' under Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), resulting in prosecution as if they were armed 'members' of the PKK under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F241", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 stated that the majority of adults convicted under these laws have received prison terms of between seven and 15 years, and that prior to a July 2010 legal amendment, child protestors typically received prison sentences of between four and five years.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F242", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 stated that in none of the cases examined by Human Rights Watch had prosecutors submitted evidence to establish that the individual defendant either heard the PKK's 'appeal' or had been directly instructed or motivated by the PKK to participate in the demonstration, or had any other specific link with the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F243", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 stated that on 22 July 2010 the Turkish parliament adopted Law no. 6008, published in the Official Gazette on 25 July 2010, which provides that all children will henceforth stand trial in juvenile courts; child demonstrators who commit propaganda crimes or resist dispersal by the police will not be charged with membership in a terrorist organisation; and children will not face aggravated penalties and may benefit from sentence postponements and similar measures for public order offences.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F244", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 stated that Law no. 6008 omits any provision to prevent children from being charged with 'making propaganda for a terrorist organization' under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) or Article 220 § 8 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F245", "text": "The Amnesty International report published on 17 June 2010, entitled \"All Children Have Rights / End Unfair Prosecutions of Children under Anti-terrorism Legislation in Turkey\", concerned the rights of children who are arrested, detained and tried under the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) and the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) on account of their participation in demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Reports of Amnesty International"]}, {"fact_id": "F246", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 17 June 2010 stated that official statistics show that prosecutions were initiated against 513 children under Article 314 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) in 2006-7 and against 737 children under the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) during the same period.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Reports of Amnesty International"]}, {"fact_id": "F247", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 17 June 2010 stated that the Justice Ministry stated in a written answer in December 2009 that from 2006-8 prosecutions were initiated against 1,308 children under the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) and 719 children under Article 314 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Reports of Amnesty International"]}, {"fact_id": "F248", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 17 June 2010 stated that children alleged to have participated in demonstrations are frequently prosecuted under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) and under Article 314 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) via Article 220 § 6 of the same Code, following a ruling of the Supreme Court of Appeals (case number 2007/9282).", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Reports of Amnesty International"]}, {"fact_id": "F249", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 17 June 2010 stated that children who have been prosecuted in connection with their participation in demonstrations have frequently faced multiple charges for the same act, including making propaganda for a terrorist organisation, membership of a terrorist organisation and violation of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Reports of Amnesty International"]}, {"fact_id": "F250", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 17 June 2010 stated that by law, children aged 15-17 are tried in Special Heavy Penal courts under the same procedures as adults for terrorism-related offences, pursuant to Article 9 of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713), with hearings closed to the public.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Reports of Amnesty International"]}, {"fact_id": "F251", "text": "On 27 March 2013 Amnesty International published a report entitled \"Turkey: Decriminalize Dissent / Time to deliver on the Right to Freedom of Expression\".", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Reports of Amnesty International"]}, {"fact_id": "F252", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 27 March 2013 stated that Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) allows the state to punish individuals who have not been proven in court to be members of a terrorist organisation as though they were, if deemed to have performed a criminal act 'in the name of an organization'.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Reports of Amnesty International"]}, {"fact_id": "F253", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 27 March 2013 stated that courts have used Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) as the basis for imposing increased sentences with little evidence of the commission of a recognizably criminal offence or any demonstrable link to a 'terrorist organization', and that the evidence frequently amounts to nothing more than participation in demonstrations or the writing of pro-Kurdish articles.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Reports of Amnesty International"]}, {"fact_id": "F254", "text": "The Amnesty International report of 27 March 2013 recommended that Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) be repealed and that legitimate prosecutions be brought instead under other existing Penal Code articles requiring proof of membership or intent to assist a terrorist organization.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Reports of Amnesty International"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F011", "F037", "F049", "F083", "F085", "F046", "F048", "F053", "F054", "F014", "F084", "F088", "F063", "F064", "F065"], "interference": ["F091", "F092", "F037", "F059", "F073", "F106", "F113", "F123", "F124", "F125", "F126", "F129", "F130", "F133", "F134", "F137", "F138", "F143"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F151", "F157", "F158", "F161", "F162", "F167", "F187", "F202", "F203", "F083", "F089", "F093", "F094", "F095", "F096"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F076", "F077", "F089", "F093", "F097", "F001", "F088", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F054", "F068", "F069", "F126", "F059", "F060", "F094", "F095", "F096", "F098", "F099", "F103", "F104", "F092", "F113", "F037", "F073", "F028", "F031", "F085", "F102"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F048", "F053", "F054", "F063"], "interference": ["F037", "F059", "F091", "F092", "F113", "F129"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F151", "F187", "F202", "F203", "F089"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F037", "F049", "F053", "F054", "F068", "F069", "F088", "F089", "F093", "F094", "F095", "F096", "F097", "F098", "F099", "F103", "F104", "F113", "F126"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F001", "F003", "F004", "F048", "F049", "F053", "F054", "F068", "F069", "F088", "F089", "F093", "F094", "F095", "F096", "F097", "F098", "F099", "F103", "F104", "F092", "F037", "F059", "F113", "F126", "F129"]}} {"case_name": "case_298", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' dates of birth and places of residence are given in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "At the material time many of the applicants were members of opposition political parties or groups.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held on 20 October 2012 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held on 17 November 2012 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 15 October 2012, prior to the assembly planned for 20 October 2012, the organisers, who were members of the opposition, gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 12 November 2012, prior to the assembly planned for 17 November 2012, the organisers, who were members of the opposition, gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority refused to authorise the demonstration of 20 October 2012 at the place indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority proposed an alternative location for the demonstration of 20 October 2012 on the outskirts of Baku, specifically the yard of a driving school situated in the 20th habitable area of the Sabail District.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority refused to authorise the demonstration of 17 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority noted in general terms that the assembly planned for 17 November 2012 would not be in accordance with the Law on Freedom of Assembly.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority noted that the square where the organisers proposed to hold the assembly planned for 17 November 2012 was a designated public leisure area.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority noted that the assembly planned for 17 November 2012 would be impractical.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The organisers decided to hold the demonstrations of 20 October 2012 and 17 November 2012 as originally planned, despite the Baku City Executive Authority's refusals.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the applicants, the demonstrations were intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the applicants, the demonstrations were conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The participants in the demonstrations were demanding democratic reforms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The participants in the demonstrations were protesting against impediments on freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Each applicant attended one of the two demonstrations held on 20 October 2012 or 17 November 2012 in Baku (as specified in the Appendix).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Shortly after the demonstrations had begun, the police started to disperse those who had gathered.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "All applicants were arrested during the dispersal operations.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "All applicants were taken to various police stations following their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to most of the applicants, they were arrested by people in plain clothes.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicants were questioned at the respective police stations.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On the day of each applicant's arrest, administrative offence reports (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) were issued on the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The administrative offence reports stated that by deliberately failing to comply with a lawful order of the police, the applicants had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicants in application nos. 8204/13, 8468/13, 31201/13 and 51930/13 were also charged under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences (violation of the rules on holding public assemblies).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "Some of the applicants refused to sign the administrative offence reports.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the applicants, they were never served with copies of the administrative offence reports.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the applicants, they were never served with other documents from their case files.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the applicants, they were not given access to a lawyer after their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the applicants, they were not given access to a lawyer while they were in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Each applicant was brought before a first-instance court on the day of their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to most of the applicants, the hearing before the court in each case was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "Members of the public were not allowed inside the courtroom during the respective hearings.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The courts had not taken a formal decision to close the hearings to the public.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to all applicants, they were not given an opportunity to appoint lawyers of their own choosing at the first-instance court hearings.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "State-funded lawyers were invited to represent most of the applicants at the first-instance court hearings.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicants in application nos. 8204/13, 31201/13 and 51930/13 were not represented by a lawyer at the first-instance court hearings.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the transcripts of the respective court hearings, the applicants in application nos. 8204/13 and 51930/13 refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and decided to defend themselves in person.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicants stated in the respective first-instance courts that they had participated or attempted to participate in the demonstrations of 20 October 2012 or 17 November 2012, exercising their right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicants stated in the respective first-instance courts that they were not guilty of failing to comply with a lawful order of the police.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to the transcripts of the hearings, in their oral submissions the State-funded lawyers stated in general terms that the applicants were not guilty.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the transcripts of the hearings, in their oral submissions the State-funded lawyers briefly asked the respective courts to adopt a fair decision.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "With respect to the applicants in application nos. 8468/13, 17569/13 and 45211/13, the State-funded lawyers did not make any oral or written submissions.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The only witnesses questioned during the respective court hearings were police officers who, according to official records, had arrested the applicants or issued administrative offence reports on them.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The police officer witnesses testified that the applicants had staged unauthorised demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The police officer witnesses testified that the applicants had been shouting loudly on the street.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "In application nos. 8204/13, 8468/13, 14226/13, 17569/13, 31201/13, 45211/13 and 51930/13, the respective courts did not question any witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In most of the cases, the respective first-instance courts found that the applicants had failed to stop participating in an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "With respect to the applicant in application no. 5231/13, the first-instance court found that he had attempted to make noise by shouting on a street.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "With respect to the applicant in application no. 17575/13, the first-instance court stated in general terms that he had deliberately failed to comply with a lawful order of the police.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The courts convicted the applicants under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The courts sentenced the applicants to a period of administrative detention varying from five to thirteen days (as specified in the Appendix).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The applicant in application no. 8468/13 was additionally convicted under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On various dates the applicants lodged appeals with the Baku Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "In their appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicants argued that their convictions were in violation of their rights because the demonstrations in which they had participated or attempted to participate had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In their appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicants complained that their arrests had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "In their appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicants complained that the hearings before the respective first-instance courts had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicants asked the Baku Court of Appeal to quash the first-instance courts' decisions in their respective cases.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The applicants were represented before the Baku Court of Appeal by lawyers of their own choosing.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On various dates the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants' appeals.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal upheld the decisions of the respective first-instance courts (as specified in the Appendix).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "A summary of the relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings in Azerbaijan can be found in the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, §§ 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "A summary of the relevant provisions concerning the organisation and holding of public assemblies in Azerbaijan can be found in the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, §§ 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Relevant extracts of international documents concerning the subject matter can be found in the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, §§ 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F040"], "interference": ["F019", "F020", "F024", "F025", "F052", "F053"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F063", "F064"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F005", "F006", "F014", "F015", "F019", "F024", "F025", "F040", "F049", "F052"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F018"], "interference": ["F019", "F020", "F052", "F053"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F007", "F009", "F064"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F005", "F006", "F014", "F015", "F019", "F025", "F052"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F014", "F015", "F018", "F019", "F025", "F052", "F053"]}} {"case_name": "case_299", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' dates of birth and places of residence are given in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held in Baku on 12 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held in Baku on 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held in Baku on 10 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "It appears that the organisers of the demonstrations gave no proper prior notice to the relevant authority, the Baku City Executive Authority.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "According to the applicants, the demonstrations were intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "According to the applicants, the demonstrations were conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The demonstration of 12 January 2013 was aimed at protesting about the deaths of soldiers in the army.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The demonstration of 10 March 2013 was aimed at protesting about the deaths of soldiers in the army.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The demonstration of 26 January 2013 condemned the use of force by the police against the participants of previous demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Each applicant attended one of the demonstrations (as specified in the Appendix).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Shortly after the demonstrations had begun, the police started to disperse those who had gathered.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "All three applicants were arrested during the dispersal operations.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "All three applicants were taken to police stations following their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the second applicant, during the demonstration she was giving an interview to the media.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the second applicant, the moment of her arrest was recorded.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicants were questioned at the police stations they had been taken to.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On the day of each applicant's arrest, administrative-offence reports (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) were issued.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The administrative-offence reports stated that the applicants had committed an administrative offence under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the first applicant, she or he was never served with copies of the administrative-offence reports.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the first applicant, she or he was never served with other documents from her or his case file.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the second applicant, she was never served with copies of the administrative-offence reports.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the second applicant, she was never served with other documents from her case file.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the first applicant, she or he was not given access to a lawyer after arrest or while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the third applicant, she or he was not given access to a lawyer after arrest or while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to a statement (ərizə) written by the second applicant at the police station on the day of her arrest, she refused the services of a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The first applicant was released after being kept in police custody for a few hours.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The first applicant's release was subject to an undertaking to reappear at the police station two days later.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The third applicant was taken to a trial court directly from the police station on the day following his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The first applicant was brought before a first-instance court on the date he returned to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The second applicant was brought before a court on the day of her arrest.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The hearing in the second applicant's case was postponed for two days to allow her to hire a lawyer of her own choosing.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "A State-funded lawyer was appointed to assist the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The second applicant was not represented by a lawyer during the court proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The third applicant was not represented by a lawyer during the court proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to documents from the case file of the second applicant, on the day the hearing recommenced, the lawyer she had hired failed to appear.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to documents from the case file of the second applicant, she decided to defend herself in person after her hired lawyer failed to appear.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "None of the material submitted to the Court contains any records showing that the State-funded lawyer, Mr V.M., made any oral submissions on behalf of the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "None of the material submitted to the Court contains any records showing that the State-funded lawyer, Mr V.M., made any written submissions on behalf of the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The only witnesses questioned during the court hearing with respect to the second applicant were the police officers who, according to the official records, had arrested her.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The only witnesses questioned during the court hearing with respect to the second applicant were the police officers who, according to the official records, had drawn up the administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The police officers testified that the second applicant had staged an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "No witnesses were questioned by the courts in the first applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "No witnesses were questioned by the courts in the third applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The first-instance courts found that the applicants had participated in unauthorised demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicants were convicted under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicants were sentenced to fines of 450, 500 and 600 Azerbaijani manats respectively (as specified in the Appendix).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On various dates the applicants lodged appeals with the Baku Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In their appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicants argued that their convictions had been in violation of their rights because the demonstrations in which they had participated had been spontaneous.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In their appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicants argued that their convictions had been in violation of their rights because the demonstrations in which they had participated had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "In their appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicants complained that their arrests had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In their appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicants complained that the hearings before the first-instance courts had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The applicants asked the Baku Court of Appeal to quash the first-instance courts' decisions in their cases.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The applicants were not represented before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal refused to grant the applicants' requests to hear evidence from particular witnesses in their favour.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal gave no reasons for refusing to hear evidence from particular witnesses in the applicants' favour.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In the case of the second applicant, the Baku Court of Appeal additionally refused to examine video recordings made by the media during her arrest.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal gave no reasons for refusing to examine the video recordings made by the media during the second applicant's arrest.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On various dates the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants' appeals and upheld the decisions of the first-instance courts (as specified in the Appendix).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 8 August 2014 Mr I. Aliyev, who represented all three applicants before the Court, was arrested on charges of large-scale tax evasion.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 8 August 2014 Mr I. Aliyev was arrested on charges of abuse of power.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 8 August 2014 Mr I. Aliyev was arrested on charges of illegal entrepreneurship.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 8 August 2014 Mr I. Aliyev was detained pending trial.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The circumstances relating to Mr I. Aliyev's arrest and detention are the subject of a separate application brought by him before the Court (application no. 68762/14).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 8 August 2014 the prosecuting authorities conducted a search of Mr I. Aliyev's home.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 9 August 2014 the prosecuting authorities conducted a search of Mr I. Aliyev's office.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "During the search, the domestic authorities seized a large number of documents, including all the case files relating to the pending applications before the Court, which were in Mr I. Aliyev's possession as a representative.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The files relating to the present cases, which it appears included copies of all the documents and correspondence between the Court and the parties, were seized in their entirety.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "No adequate inventory of the seized document files relating to the Court proceedings was made in the search and seizure records of 8 and 9 August 2014.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On an unspecified date Mr I. Aliyev lodged a complaint with the Nasimi District Court, claiming that the search of his home and office had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Mr I. Aliyev complained to the Nasimi District Court about the seizure of the documents and files relating to the pending court proceedings before the Court.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Mr I. Aliyev complained to the Nasimi District Court about the seizure of the documents and files relating to the pending proceedings before the domestic courts.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 12 September 2014 the Nasimi District Court dismissed Mr I. Aliyev's claim.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Nasimi District Court held that the searches of Mr I. Aliyev's home and office had been conducted in accordance with the relevant law.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Nasimi District Court found that the documents relating to the cases pending before the Court and the domestic courts could not be returned to the applicants at that stage of the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Following an appeal, on 23 September 2014 the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the Nasimi District Court's decision of 12 September 2014.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 25 October 2014 the investigating authorities returned a number of the case files concerning the applications lodged with the Court, including the files relating to the present cases, to Mr I. Aliyev's lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The investigator's decision of 25 October 2014 specified that it had been established that among the documents seized on 8 and 9 August 2014 there had been files concerning applications by a number of individuals and organisations lodged with the European Court of Human Rights, which had no relation to the substance of the criminal proceedings against Mr Intigam Aliyev.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The investigator's decision of 25 October 2014 specified that the files concerning applications lodged with the European Court of Human Rights had been delivered to Mr I. Aliyev's lawyer, Mr Javad Javadov.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicants' case files"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "At the time of the applicants' arrest, Article 5 § IV of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that no prior written notification was required for spontaneous assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Before amendments were introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, a breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies had been punishable under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 by a reprimand or a fine of between 7 and 13 Azerbaijani manats.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 entered into force on 1 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced new wording to Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 on breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Under the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, participation in an assembly organised in breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies became explicitly punishable under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Under the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, administrative detention of up to fifteen days was introduced as a punishment for participation in an assembly organised in breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Under the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, community service was introduced as a punishment for participation in an assembly organised in breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Under the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, the fine for a breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies was increased to between 300 and 600 Azerbaijani manats for participants of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Under the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, the fine for a breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies was set at between 1,500 and 3,000 Azerbaijani manats for individuals who organise an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Under the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, the fine for a breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies was set at between 3,000 and 6,000 Azerbaijani manats for persons in charge (vəzifəli şəxslər) who organise an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Under the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, the fine for a breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies was set at between 15,000 and 30,000 Azerbaijani manats for legal entities involved in the organisation of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Pursuant to Presidential Order (sərəncam) no. 1866 of 1 December 2011, which was in force until 1 September 2013, the minimum wage in Azerbaijan was 93.5 Azerbaijani manats.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, entitled 'The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan', noted that there is no political dialogue with the opposition parties outside parliament in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about the restrictive climate for the activities of the extra-parliamentary opposition in Azerbaijan, which complains about limitations imposed on freedom of expression and freedom of assembly and the lack of access to the public media.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the establishment of an inclusive political system and a truly competitive and unrestrictive political environment requires full implementation of basic freedoms, including freedom of expression, freedom of assembly and freedom of association.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed deep concern about the situation regarding basic freedoms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about recently adopted amendments to the Criminal Code and the Administrative Code of Azerbaijan, which increased penalties for the organisers of, and participants in, 'unauthorised' gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe noted that, considering the authorities' ongoing blanket ban on protests in the Baku city centre, the amendments to the Criminal Code and the Administrative Code were likely to have a further negative impact on freedom of assembly and freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about the restrictive use of certain articles of the Criminal Code of Azerbaijan, in particular Articles 221 and 233, against participants in peaceful, albeit unauthorised, demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 was produced by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, Nils Muižnieks, expressed deep concern in his Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 about recent amendments to the Law on Freedom of Assembly, the Criminal Code and the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan, which further erode the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, Nils Muižnieks, stated in his Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 that the sanctions which can now be imposed, coupled with the fact that local authorities have not authorised a single rally in Baku city centre in recent years, clearly have a chilling effect on the organisation of or participation in demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, Nils Muižnieks, stated in his Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 that participants in peaceful assemblies should not be sanctioned for the mere fact of being present at and actively participating in the demonstration in question, provided they do not do anything illegal, violent or obscene in the course of it.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, Nils Muižnieks, urged the Azerbaijani authorities in his Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 to ensure that no disproportionate sanction, which would undermine the fundamental right to peaceful assembly, is imposed.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "A summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, the relevant provisions concerning the organisation and holding of public assemblies, and the relevant extracts of international documents can be found in the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, paragraphs 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F011", "F046", "F047", "F084", "F085", "F087"], "interference": ["F012", "F013", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F059"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F005", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F080"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F006", "F007", "F012", "F013", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F084", "F085", "F087", "F097", "F101"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F011"], "interference": ["F012", "F013", "F046"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F005", "F008", "F010", "F080"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F006", "F007", "F012", "F046", "F047", "F084", "F087", "F097", "F101"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F005", "F006", "F007", "F012", "F046", "F047", "F084", "F087", "F097", "F101"]}} {"case_name": "case_302", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The circumstances relating to the applicants' arrest and custody, and the subsequent administrative proceedings against them are similar to those in Bayramov v. Azerbaijan (Committee application nos. 19150/13 and 52022/13, 6 April 2017).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. GENERAL INFORMATION PERTAINING TO ALL APPLICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The circumstances relating to the applicants' arrest and custody, and the subsequent administrative proceedings against them are similar to those in Huseynov and Others v. Azerbaijan (Committee application nos. 34262/14 and 5 others, 24 November 2016).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. GENERAL INFORMATION PERTAINING TO ALL APPLICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The circumstances relating to the applicants' arrest and custody, and the subsequent administrative proceedings against them are similar to those in Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (application nos. 67360/11 and 2 others, 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. GENERAL INFORMATION PERTAINING TO ALL APPLICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The circumstances relating to the applicants' arrest and custody, and the subsequent administrative proceedings against them are similar to those in Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (application no. 60259/11, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. GENERAL INFORMATION PERTAINING TO ALL APPLICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants were members of various opposition parties and movements at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. GENERAL INFORMATION PERTAINING TO ALL APPLICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants were arrested and convicted under different provisions of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. GENERAL INFORMATION PERTAINING TO ALL APPLICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicants were arrested and convicted under different provisions of the Code of Administrative Offences with a view to either punishing them for participating in peaceful demonstrations or preventing them from doing so.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. GENERAL INFORMATION PERTAINING TO ALL APPLICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Further information concerning the applications, including the applicants' personal details, is set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. GENERAL INFORMATION PERTAINING TO ALL APPLICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant, together with a number of other members of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan, was arrested during the dispersal of an unauthorised demonstration held on 23 November 2006.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 23 November 2006, the Sabail District Court convicted the applicant under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, relying on the related administrative offence report.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 23 November 2006, the Sabail District Court sentenced the applicant to ten days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Similar decisions to the Sabail District Court's decision of 23 November 2006 appear to have been given in respect of a number of others arrested in connection with the demonstration of 23 November 2006.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant was not represented during the pre-trial stage of the administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant was not represented during the trial stage of the administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the applicant, following the trial, the applicant was unaware of the decision taken by the Sabail District Court as it was not announced by the judge during the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicant was able to obtain a copy of the Sabail District Court's decision of 23 November 2006 several months after the trial.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 24 November 2006, E.Q., a lawyer, lodged an appeal against the Sabail District Court's decision of 23 November 2006 on behalf of several members of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan who had been detained, including the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the applicant, there had been no contact between the applicant and E.Q. prior to E.Q. lodging the appeal.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the applicant, the applicant was unaware of the appeal lodged by E.Q. on 24 November 2006.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 27 November 2006, the Baku Court of Appeal held a hearing in the applicant's absence.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 27 November 2006, the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the Sabail District Court's decision of 23 November 2006.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Following the applicant's release from detention, the applicant requested a copy of the Sabail District Court's decision of 23 November 2006, but to no avail.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 7 February 2007, the applicant managed to obtain a copy of the Sabail District Court's decision of 23 November 2006 by visiting the court's registry.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 12 February 2007, the applicant lodged an appeal against the Sabail District Court's decision of 23 November 2006, alleging a breach of his rights under Article 5 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 12 February 2007, the applicant lodged an appeal against the Sabail District Court's decision of 23 November 2006, alleging a breach of his rights under Article 6 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 12 February 2007, the applicant lodged an appeal against the Sabail District Court's decision of 23 November 2006, alleging a breach of his rights under Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 12 February 2007, the applicant lodged an appeal against the Sabail District Court's decision of 23 November 2006, alleging a breach of his rights under Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "In the appeal lodged on 12 February 2007, the applicant complained in particular that he had been denied legal assistance during the pre-trial stage of the administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "In the appeal lodged on 12 February 2007, the applicant complained in particular that he had been denied legal assistance during the trial stage of the administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 2 March 2007, the Baku Court of Appeal refused to admit the applicant's appeal of 12 February 2007 on the grounds that a similar appeal had already been lodged by E.Q. and examined on 27 November 2006.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "A. Application no. 39919/07"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 5 February 2007, the applicant instituted civil proceedings seeking compensation for his unlawful arrest on 23 November 2006 (the arrest that is the subject of application no. 39919/07).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "B. Application no. 56947/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 12 June 2008, the Sabail District Court dismissed the applicant's civil action seeking compensation for his unlawful arrest on 23 November 2006.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "B. Application no. 56947/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Sabail District Court's decision of 12 June 2008 dismissing the applicant's civil action was upheld on appeal on 21 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "B. Application no. 56947/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The applicant lodged a cassation appeal against the decision upholding the dismissal of his civil action, but it was left unexamined for procedural reasons.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PECULIARITIES OF INDIVIDUAL APPLICATIONS Nos. 39919/07 AND 56947/10", "B. Application no. 56947/10"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F007", "F009", "F005"], "interference": ["F006", "F007", "F009", "F010", "F011"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F007", "F006", "F009", "F010", "F011"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F007"], "interference": ["F006", "F007"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F007"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F007", "F006"]}} {"case_name": "case_304", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant organisation is a non-governmental human rights organisation.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant organisation is based in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 12 May 2007, a third person identified as L.G. died while at a police station.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "L.G. was apparently a witness in a murder investigation at the time of his/her death.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "According to the official version, L.G. died in an attempt to escape by jumping out of a second-floor window of the police station.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The death of L.G. on 12 May 2007 provoked an outcry among Armenian human rights groups and civil society.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 19 February 2008, a presidential election was held in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The presidential election of 19 February 2008 in Armenia was followed by mass post-election rallies and protests.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The post-election rallies and protests resulted in an intense standoff between the Armenian authorities and the supporters of the opposition.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The standoff between the Armenian authorities and opposition supporters resulted in clashes.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The clashes following the 19 February 2008 presidential election in Armenia resulted in at least ten persons being killed.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 1 March 2008, a state of emergency was declared by the President of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The state of emergency declared on 1 March 2008 by the President of Armenia was for a period of 20 days.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "During the state of emergency declared on 1 March 2008, all public assemblies in Armenia were banned.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 6 May 2008, the applicant organisation applied to the Mayor of Yerevan, notifying its intention to hold a mourning march on the first anniversary of L.G.'s death.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The mourning march notified by the applicant organisation was planned to take place on 12 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The mourning march notified by the applicant organisation was planned to take place from 8 p.m. to 9.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The mourning march notified by the applicant organisation was planned to start at Republic Square in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The mourning march notified by the applicant organisation was planned to continue through Nalbandyan Street in the direction of the police station.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 8 May 2008, the Mayor of Yerevan decided to ban the planned mourning march.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Mayor of Yerevan's decision to ban the planned mourning march was made with reference to Section 9 § 4 (3) of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Mayor of Yerevan's decision to ban the planned mourning march was made with reference to Section 13 § 1 (3) of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Mayor of Yerevan's ban decision cited an official opinion of the Police dated 8 May 2008, stating that the mass public event held on 1 March 2008 turned into mass disorder resulting in human casualties.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Mayor of Yerevan's ban decision cited the Police opinion stating that not all the circumstances of the crime and offenders from the 1 March 2008 event had been disclosed.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Mayor of Yerevan's ban decision cited the Police opinion stating that not all weapons and ammunition used at the 1 March 2008 event, whose circulation may pose danger to the lives and health of citizens, had been found in the course of the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The investigation into the 1 March 2008 events was instituted by the Special Investigative Service of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The Mayor of Yerevan's ban decision cited the Police opinion concluding that it would be impossible to prevent new crimes if the planned mass public event were held.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Mayor of Yerevan's ban decision cited an official opinion of the National Security Service of Armenia dated 7 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The National Security Service of Armenia's opinion of 7 May 2008 stated that the National Security Service had credible and verified data showing that the planned mass public event, if allowed, would result in undermining national security.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The National Security Service of Armenia's opinion of 7 May 2008 stated that the planned mass public event, if allowed, would result in undermining public order and the health and morality of society.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The National Security Service of Armenia's opinion of 7 May 2008 stated that the planned mass public event, if allowed, would result in encroachments on constitutional rights and freedoms.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The National Security Service of Armenia's opinion of 7 May 2008 stated that the planned mass public event, if allowed, would result in disorder and new crimes.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "By a letter dated 12 May 2008, the Mayor of Yerevan's ban decision of 8 May 2008 was posted to the applicant organisation.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 12 May 2008, the police prevented the organisers from holding the planned mourning march.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The police who prevented the organisers from holding the planned mourning march on 12 May 2008 had apparently been informed of the Mayor of Yerevan's ban decision of 8 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 13 May 2008, the applicant organisation received the letter dated 12 May 2008 containing the Mayor of Yerevan's ban decision.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to Section 9 § 4 (3) of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the competent authority may ban the holding of a public event if, according to credible data, it is aimed at forcibly overthrowing the constitutional order.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to Section 9 § 4 (3) of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the competent authority may ban the holding of a public event if, according to credible data, it is aimed at inflaming ethnic, racial or religious hatred.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to Section 9 § 4 (3) of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the competent authority may ban the holding of a public event if, according to credible data, it is aimed at campaigning for violence or war.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to Section 9 § 4 (3) of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the competent authority may ban the holding of a public event if, according to credible data, it may lead to mass disorder and crime.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to Section 9 § 4 (3) of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the competent authority may ban the holding of a public event if, according to credible data, it may lead to undermining national security, public order and the health and morality of society.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to Section 9 § 4 (3) of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the competent authority may ban the holding of a public event if, according to credible data, it may lead to encroachments on the constitutional rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to Section 9 § 4 (3) of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, data may be considered credible if the Police or the National Security Service under the Government of Armenia have issued an official opinion on the data.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to Section 9 § 4 (3) of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the Police or the National Security Service under the Government of Armenia shall also issue an opinion if the grounds for banning cease to exist.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to Section 9 § 4 (3) of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, an official opinion from the Police or the National Security Service under the Government of Armenia is also issued in cases envisaged by Section 9 § 6 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to Section 9 § 6 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, in cases where mass public events have turned into mass disorder resulting in human casualties, the competent authority may temporarily ban the holding of mass public events in order to prevent new crimes.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to Section 9 § 6 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the temporary ban on mass public events may be imposed only given that other means of prevention have been exhausted.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "According to Section 9 § 6 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the temporary ban on mass public events shall last until the circumstances of the crime and the identity of the offenders have been disclosed.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "According to Section 10 § 1 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, mass public events may be held only after notifying the competent authority in writing.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "According to Section 10 § 4 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the organisers shall send written notification of the intention to hold a mass public event to the head of the local authority where the event is to be organised.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "According to Section 10 § 4 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, if the public event is to be held in Yerevan, the written notification shall be sent to the Mayor of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "According to Section 10 § 4 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the written notification shall be sent not later than five working days before the planned date of the event.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "According to Section 10 § 4 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the written notification shall be sent not earlier than twenty days before the planned date of the event.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "According to Section 12 § 1 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the competent authority shall examine the notification within 72 hours of receipt.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "According to Section 12 § 1 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, notifications shall be examined in the order in which they have been received.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "According to Section 12 § 6 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, in the absence of the circumstances mentioned in Section 13 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the notification of the mass public event shall be taken into consideration and the event shall be held in the place and at the time indicated in the notification.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "According to Section 12 § 6 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, in the presence of the circumstances mentioned in Section 13 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, a decision shall be taken banning the mass public event.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "According to Section 12 § 7 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the competent authority shall immediately inform the organisers of its decision taken as a result of examination of the notification.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "According to Section 12 § 7 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the competent authority shall immediately inform the police of its decision taken as a result of examination of the notification.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "According to Section 12 § 7 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the competent authority shall post up its decision on its premises in a specially designated spot, accessible and visible to the public.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "According to Section 12 § 7 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the decision of the competent authority shall remain posted up until 6 p.m. on the planned date of the mass public event indicated in the notification.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "According to Section 12 § 8 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, should the competent authority not take a decision banning the mass public event, the organisers shall have the right to hold the mass public event on the terms and conditions set forth in the notification.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "According to Section 13 § 1 (3) of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, a mass public event may be banned only when, inter alia, there exist grounds stipulated by Section 9 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "According to Section 13 § 2 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, a decision banning a mass public event shall contain a reasoned and clear explanation of the grounds on which the mass public event is banned.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "According to Section 13 § 3 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, a decision banning a mass public event may be contested before the courts.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "According to Section 13 § 3 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the court shall adopt a judgment within 24 hours of a challenge to a ban decision.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "According to Section 13 § 3 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, a court judgment annulling a decision banning a mass public event shall enter into force from the moment of its delivery.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (as in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "According to Articles 66-69 of the Code of Administrative Procedure, four types of application may be lodged with the Administrative Court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "According to Article 66 of the Code of Administrative Procedure, an application to challenge may be lodged with the Administrative Court, seeking the annulment in part or in whole of the administrative act constituting an interference.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "According to Article 67 of the Code of Administrative Procedure, an application to oblige may be lodged with the Administrative Court, seeking the adoption of a favourable administrative act.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "According to Article 68 of the Code of Administrative Procedure, an application to perform an action may be lodged with the Administrative Court, seeking the performance of certain actions or refraining from certain actions.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "According to Article 69 of the Code of Administrative Procedure, an application to recognise may be lodged with the Administrative Court, seeking the recognition of existence or absence of a legal relationship.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "According to Article 69 of the Code of Administrative Procedure, an application to recognise may be lodged only if it is impossible to lodge an application under Articles 66-68 of the Code of Administrative Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "According to Article 69 of the Code of Administrative Procedure, an application to recognise may seek to recognise the invalidity of an administrative act.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "According to Article 69 of the Code of Administrative Procedure, an application to recognise may seek to recognise the unlawfulness of an interfering administrative act which is no longer in force, or of actions or inaction, if the applicant has a justified interest in doing so.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "According to Article 69 of the Code of Administrative Procedure, a justified interest in recognising the unlawfulness of an administrative act exists if there is a risk of adoption of a similar act or of performance of similar actions or inaction.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "According to Article 69 of the Code of Administrative Procedure, a justified interest in recognising the unlawfulness of an administrative act exists if the applicant intends to claim pecuniary damage.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "According to Article 69 of the Code of Administrative Procedure, a justified interest in recognising the unlawfulness of an administrative act exists if the applicant seeks to restore his honour, dignity or reputation.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Code of Administrative Procedure"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F006", "F015", "F016"], "interference": ["F020", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F021", "F022"], "legitimate_aim": ["F010", "F011", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F026"], "necessity": ["F001", "F003", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F010", "F012", "F013", "F015", "F016", "F028", "F029", "F043"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F015", "F016"], "interference": ["F020", "F034", "F035"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F021", "F022"], "legitimate_aim": ["F023", "F024", "F025"], "necessity": ["F001", "F003", "F012", "F013", "F015", "F016", "F028", "F029"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F001", "F003", "F012", "F013", "F016", "F020", "F028", "F029", "F034"]}} {"case_name": "case_308", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1961.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Vanadzor.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant had been granted legal aid.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr Tumanyan, a lawyer practising in Vanadzor.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr G. Kostanyan.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr Y. Kirakosyan, Representative of the Republic of Armenia to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 7 July 2006 the applicant began working as a leading specialist at the Lori Regional Administration.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant held the rank of Civil Servant of the First Category.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "From 1 February to 5 March 2008 the applicant took leave.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "According to the applicant, he took leave from 1 February to 5 March 2008 in order to be able to participate in the upcoming presidential election to be held in Armenia on 19 February 2008.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The presidential election in Armenia was held on 19 February 2008.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the then Prime Minister, Mr Serzh Sargsyan, representing the ruling party.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the main opposition candidate, Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On the day of the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election, the applicant acted as Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan's authorised election assistant (վստահված անձ).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Immediately after the announcement of the preliminary results of the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election, Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan called on his supporters to gather at Freedom Square in central Yerevan in order to protest against the irregularities which had allegedly occurred in the election process.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan announced that the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election had not been free and fair.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "From 20 February 2008 onwards, nationwide daily protest rallies were held by Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan's supporters.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The protest rallies held by Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan's supporters from 20 February 2008 onwards attracted at times tens of thousands of people.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The main meeting point of Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan's supporters during the protest rallies from 20 February 2008 onwards was Freedom Square in central Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 26 February 2008 the applicant took part in a protest rally at Freedom Square in central Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 28 February 2008 the applicant took part in a protest rally at Freedom Square in central Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 6 March 2008 the Chief of the Lori Regional Police sent a letter to the Lori Regional Governor.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The letter of 6 March 2008 from the Chief of the Lori Regional Police to the Lori Regional Governor stated that the applicant had participated in Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan's pre-election campaign.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The letter of 6 March 2008 from the Chief of the Lori Regional Police to the Lori Regional Governor stated that the applicant had participated in unauthorised demonstrations held at Freedom Square in central Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The letter of 6 March 2008 from the Chief of the Lori Regional Police to the Lori Regional Governor stated that several other employees of the Lori Regional Administration, who were members of the opposition party, had participated in Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan's pre-election campaign.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The letter of 6 March 2008 from the Chief of the Lori Regional Police to the Lori Regional Governor stated that several other employees of the Lori Regional Administration, who were members of the opposition party, had participated in unauthorised demonstrations held at Freedom Square in central Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 6 March 2008 the Head of Staff of the Lori Regional Administration asked the applicant to submit a written explanation of his conduct during his leave.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 6 March 2008 the applicant replied to the Head of Staff of the Lori Regional Administration that he had participated in the peaceful demonstrations held on 26 and 28 February 2008 at Freedom Square in central Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicant alleged that on 7 March 2008 his house had been searched.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant alleged that after the search of his house on 7 March 2008, he had been taken to a police station and questioned about the demonstrations organised by the opposition.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 11 March 2008 the applicant was dismissed from his post by an order of the Head of Staff of the Lori Regional Administration.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The order of dismissal of 11 March 2008 was issued with reference to section 33 § 1(j) of the Civil Service Act.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The stated reason for the applicant's dismissal on 11 March 2008 was a breach of the principle of political restraint of civil servants.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 14 March 2008 the applicant was deprived of the rank of Civil Servant of the First Category.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 18 April 2008 the applicant instituted proceedings against the Lori Regional Administration, seeking to annul the order of 11 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "In the proceedings against the Lori Regional Administration, the applicant submitted that from 1 February to 5 March 2008 he had been on leave, during which he had acted as one of Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan's authorised election assistants.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "In the proceedings against the Lori Regional Administration, the applicant submitted that he had participated on two occasions in the opposition demonstrations, which had become the reason for his dismissal.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "In the proceedings against the Lori Regional Administration, the applicant argued that he had not used his official position in the interests of any political party since he had been on leave during the relevant period.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "In the proceedings against the Lori Regional Administration, the applicant claimed that he was being persecuted for his political views.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 28 April 2008 the Administrative Court set the case against the Lori Regional Administration down for trial.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 12 May 2008 the Lori Regional Governor decreed to introduce staffing changes in the Lori Regional Administration by, inter alia, cutting the applicant's post.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 19 June 2009 the Administrative Court allowed the applicant's claim and annulled the order of 11 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 19 June 2009 the Administrative Court refused to reinstate the applicant in his post.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Administrative Court found that the conclusion of the Lori Regional Administration that the applicant had breached the principle of political restraint of civil servants by participating in the pre-election campaign and attending the demonstrations had been based on assumptions.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Administrative Court found that no evidence had been produced to demonstrate that the applicant had engaged in any behaviour that could be characterised as a breach of the principle of political restraint of civil servants.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Administrative Court found that none of the grounds for dismissal envisaged by section 24 §§ 1-3 of the Civil Service Act were present in the applicant's case and that the dismissal order was to be annulled.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Administrative Court took into account the fact that the applicant's position at the Lori Regional Administration had been cut on 12 May 2008, bringing to an end the employment relationship between the applicant and the Lori Regional Administration.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Administrative Court found that it was impossible to restore the employment relationship between the applicant and the Lori Regional Administration and to reinstate the applicant in his previous post.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Administrative Court awarded the applicant, of its own motion, the sum of his unpaid salary for the period of his involuntary absence, namely from 11 March to 12 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The applicant lodged an appeal on points of law against the Administrative Court's judgment of 19 June 2009.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 9 September 2009 the Court of Cassation declared the applicant's appeal on points of law inadmissible for lack of merit.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "At later dates the applicant addressed letters to various authorities inquiring about the reasons why his post had been cut.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "By a letter of 16 December 2010 the applicant was informed by the Lori Regional Governor that two posts, including that of the applicant, had been vacant and had been cut in order to create two other posts within the Lori Regional Administration.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "By a letter of 23 February 2011 the applicant was informed by the Deputy Minister of Regional Administration that two posts, including that of the applicant, had been vacant and had been cut in order to create two other posts within the Lori Regional Administration.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Section 24 § 1(d) of the Civil Service Act (in force 2002-2018) provides that a civil servant does not have the right to violate the principle of political restraint of civil servants, that is to use his official position in the interests of political parties or non-governmental organisations, including religious associations, campaign in their favour or carry out other political or religious activities while performing his service duties.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Section 33 § 1(j) of the Civil Service Act (in force 2002-2018) provides that grounds for dismissal of a civil servant from his position include, inter alia, failure to comply with the restrictions envisaged in section 24 §§ 1-3 of that Act.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F010", "F016", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F024", "F025", "F029", "F045", "F046"], "interference": ["F021", "F022", "F025", "F032", "F033", "F034"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F033", "F034", "F056", "F057"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F008", "F009", "F010", "F012", "F016", "F021", "F022", "F029", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F056", "F057"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F010", "F021", "F022"], "interference": ["F021", "F022", "F032", "F034"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F033", "F056", "F057"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F010", "F021", "F022", "F032", "F034", "F045", "F046", "F056"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F010", "F021", "F022", "F032", "F034", "F045", "F046", "F056"]}} {"case_name": "case_311", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1965.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The first applicant lives in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1984.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1975.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The second applicant lives in Sumgait.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The third applicant lives in Sumgait.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "At the material time the applicants were members of the main opposition parties or groups in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The year 2011 was marked by an increased number of opposition demonstrations in Azerbaijan, mainly in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Opposition demonstrations were held in Azerbaijan on 11 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Opposition demonstrations were held in Azerbaijan on 12 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Opposition demonstrations were held in Azerbaijan on 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Opposition demonstrations were held in Azerbaijan on 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Opposition demonstrations were held in Azerbaijan on 22 May 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Opposition demonstrations were held in Azerbaijan on 19 June 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the applicants, the relevant authorities were notified about the demonstrations but refused to authorise them.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Despite their peaceful character, demonstrations held without authorisation were dispersed by the police.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "All three applicants participated in a number of opposition demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In the course of many opposition demonstrations, all three applicants were arrested and convicted.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 12 April 2010 the second applicant was arrested and convicted of breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 12 April 2010 the second applicant was arrested and convicted of failure to obey a lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 30 April 2010 the second applicant was arrested and convicted of breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 30 April 2010 the second applicant was arrested and convicted of failure to obey a lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 12 March 2011 the second applicant was arrested and convicted of breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 12 March 2011 the second applicant was arrested and convicted of failure to obey a lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The third applicant was arrested during the demonstration of 12 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The third applicant was reprimanded for breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of public assemblies following his arrest during the demonstration of 12 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicants, they had intended to attend the demonstration scheduled for 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the applicants, the first applicant was involved in the organisation of the demonstration scheduled for 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Prior notice of the demonstration of 2 April 2011 had been given to the relevant authority, the Baku City Executive Authority.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The first applicant alleged that between approximately 10 a.m. and 11 a.m. on 31 March 2011, after he had taken his child to kindergarten, police officers stopped his car.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The first applicant alleged that police officers requested that he follow them to a police station after stopping his car on 31 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The first applicant did not oppose the police officers' demand and was taken to police station no. 20 of the Nasimi District Police Office.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "At an unspecified time on 31 March 2011, the first applicant was informed that he was being detained in connection with the upcoming demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "At around 2 p.m. on 31 March 2011, the first applicant learned that he would not be released from detention.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The first applicant was questioned at police station no. 20 of the Nasimi District Police Office on 31 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "During questioning on 31 March 2011, the first applicant was asked about his intention to participate in the demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "During questioning on 31 March 2011, the first applicant was asked generally about the politics in the country.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the official records, the first applicant was arrested for disobeying a lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Police officers F.P., S.A. and R.V. stated in a report submitted to a superior police officer that at around 10.30 a.m. on 31 March 2011 on 3rd Alatava street in Baku they stopped a person driving in his car and requested his identity document because he bore a resemblance to a person on a wanted list.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Police officers F.P., S.A. and R.V. stated in their report that the person ignored their lawful demand to produce his identity document.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "Police officers F.P., S.A. and R.V. stated in their report that they brought the person to the police station, where they found out he was the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "At around 1.20 p.m. on 31 March 2011, an administrative-offence report was issued by police officer T.A. in respect of the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The administrative-offence report issued by police officer T.A. stated that the first applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 (failure to comply with a lawful order of a police officer) of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The first applicant signed the part of the administrative-offence report acknowledging that he had been familiarised with the report.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The first applicant left without signature the part of the administrative-offence report with a pre-printed text stating that the rights and obligations under Articles 371, 372, 374, 377, 379 and 410.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Republic of Azerbaijan were explained.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The first applicant made a statement that he had not disobeyed any order given by the police, and this statement was included in the administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to the first applicant, he was never provided with a copy of the administrative-offence report or with other documents in his case file.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "According to the first applicant, he was not given access to a lawyer after his arrest or while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The first applicant was brought before the Nasimi District Court on the day of his arrest, 31 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "According to the first applicant, the hearing before the Nasimi District Court began at 3 p.m. and was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The first applicant refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and insisted on hiring a lawyer of his own choice, but the judge disregarded his request.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "According to the first applicant, his representation by the State-funded lawyer was ineffective and of a formalistic nature.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The first applicant stated before the Nasimi District Court that he had been stopped by the police and had been requested to follow them to a police station, and that he had complied with that request.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The first applicant stated before the Nasimi District Court that he was not guilty of disobeying a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The only witnesses questioned during the court hearing before the Nasimi District Court were police officers T.A., F.P. and S.A.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Police officer T.A. testified at the Nasimi District Court hearing that he had prepared the administrative-offence report in respect of the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Police officers F.P. and S.A. gave testimonies at the Nasimi District Court hearing that were virtually identical to the report they had submitted to a superior police officer.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "According to the record of the hearing before the Nasimi District Court, the State-funded lawyer stated that the first applicant was not guilty and asked the court to terminate the administrative proceedings against him.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Nasimi District Court found that the first applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Nasimi District Court sentenced the first applicant to seven days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The first applicant lodged an appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal, presenting his version of the facts surrounding the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "In his appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal, the first applicant argued that he had been arrested in connection with the demonstration scheduled for 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In his appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal, the first applicant complained that his arrest had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "In his appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal, the first applicant complained that the hearing before the Nasimi District Court had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The first applicant urged the Baku Court of Appeal to quash the Nasimi District Court's decision.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "It appears that the first applicant was not represented by a lawyer before the Baku Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 5 April 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the first applicant's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 5 April 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the Nasimi District Court, stating that its findings had been correct.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "1. The first applicant, Mr Ilham Huseynli"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The second applicant alleged that at around 10.30 a.m. on 31 March 2011, when he was still in bed, three police officers entered his apartment without an arrest warrant.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The second applicant's father let the police officers into the apartment on 31 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The police officers took the second applicant to police station no. 3 of the Sumgait City Police Office on 31 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "At an unspecified time on 31 March 2011, the second applicant was questioned about his political activities at police station no. 3 of the Sumgait City Police Office.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "According to the official records, the second applicant was arrested for minor hooliganism.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "According to the official records, the second applicant was arrested for disobeying a lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Police officer T.R. stated in a report submitted to a superior police officer that at around 12.30 p.m. on 31 March 2011 on the territory of the 9th micro-district of Sumgait, he noticed a person who was making noise.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Police officer T.R. stated in his report that although he invited the person to respect the discipline, the person continued his cursing and improper behaviour.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Police officer T.R. stated in his report that he brought the person to police station no. 3, where they found out the person was the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On the day of the arrest, an administrative-offence report was issued by police officer E.S. in respect of the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The administrative-offence report issued by police officer E.S. stated that the second applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 296 (minor hooliganism) of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The administrative-offence report issued by police officer E.S. stated that the second applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The second applicant refused to sign the administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "According to the second applicant, he was never provided with a copy of the administrative-offence report or with other documents in his case file.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "According to the second applicant, he was not given access to a lawyer after his arrest or while he was kept in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "According to a statement allegedly signed by the second applicant and submitted to the Court by the Government, the second applicant had refused legal assistance while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "According to the transcript of the hearing before the Sumgait Court of Appeal, the second applicant claimed that he had not signed the statement in which he allegedly refused legal assistance while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The second applicant was brought before the Sumgait City Court on the day of his arrest, 31 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "According to the second applicant, the hearing before the Sumgait City Court began at 3.30 p.m. and was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "According to the second applicant, he was not given an opportunity to hire a lawyer of his own choice at the hearing before the Sumgait City Court.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "According to the transcript of the first-instance court hearing before the Sumgait City Court, the second applicant refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and decided to defend himself in person.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The second applicant stated before the Sumgait City Court that he had been taken to a police station from his apartment and that it had been his father who had let the police officers in.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The second applicant stated before the Sumgait City Court that at the police station he had been questioned about his political activity.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The second applicant stated before the Sumgait City Court that he was not guilty of disobeying a police officer or of swearing at the location indicated by the police.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "According to the transcript of the Sumgait Court of Appeal hearing, the second applicant orally requested that the chief of police station no. 3, M.N., be questioned.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "There is no information whether the chief of police station no. 3, M.N., was questioned.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The only witness questioned during the court hearing before the Sumgait City Court was police officer T.R.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Police officer T.R. testified at the Sumgait City Court hearing that the second applicant had been swearing without addressing any particular person and had failed to obey his order to stop his illegal behaviour.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Sumgait City Court found that the second applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 296 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Sumgait City Court found that the second applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Sumgait City Court sentenced the second applicant to seven days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The second applicant lodged an appeal before the Sumgait Court of Appeal, presenting his version of the facts surrounding the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "In his appeal before the Sumgait Court of Appeal, the second applicant argued that his arrest had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "In his appeal before the Sumgait Court of Appeal, the second applicant argued that the hearing before the Sumgait City Court had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "In his appeal before the Sumgait Court of Appeal, the second applicant argued that his right to respect for home had been violated by the police.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The second applicant urged the Sumgait Court of Appeal to quash the Sumgait City Court's decision.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "It appears that the second applicant refused legal assistance at the hearing before the Sumgait Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "On 19 April 2011 the Sumgait Court of Appeal dismissed the second applicant's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "On 19 April 2011 the Sumgait Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the Sumgait City Court, stating that its findings had been correct.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "2. The second applicant, Mr Elchin Salimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "According to the third applicant, at around 11 a.m. on 31 March 2011 he went with his lawyer to the Sumgait City Police Office.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "According to the third applicant, after a conversation with the chief of police at the Sumgait City Police Office, the third applicant and his lawyer left.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The third applicant did not clearly explain the purpose of his visit to the Sumgait City Police Office on 31 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The third applicant alleged that when he had been outside the Sumgait City Police Office and no longer accompanied by his lawyer, police officers arrested him without explaining the reasons for doing so.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The third applicant alleged that police officers took him to police station no. 4 of the Sumgait City Police Office after arresting him on 31 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "According to the official records, the third applicant was arrested for minor hooliganism.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Police officer N.M. stated in a report submitted to a superior police officer that at around 12.30 p.m. on 31 March 2011 on Akhundov street in Sumgait, the police officers noticed a person who was swearing loudly without addressing anyone in particular.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Police officer N.M. stated in his report that the police officers approached the person and brought him to police station no. 4, where they found out the person was the third applicant.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Police officers R.S. and A.M. submitted explanatory reports to a superior police officer that were virtually identical to the report submitted by police officer N.M.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "On the day of the arrest, police officer V.J. issued an administrative-offence report in respect of the third applicant.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The administrative-offence report issued by police officer V.J. stated that the third applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 296 (minor hooliganism) of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The third applicant refused to sign the administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "According to the third applicant, he was never provided with a copy of the administrative-offence report or with other documents in his case file.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "According to the third applicant, he was not given access to a lawyer after his arrest or while he was kept in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "According to a decision dated 31 March 2011, police officer V.J. decided to invite a lawyer to represent the third applicant, without indicating at what stage the lawyer should join the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The third applicant was brought before the Sumgait City Court on the day of his arrest, 31 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "According to the third applicant, he was not given an opportunity to hire a lawyer of his own choice to represent him at the hearing before the Sumgait City Court, which began at 4 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The third applicant asked the judge to postpone the examination of the case for one hour so that his lawyer could arrive at the court.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The judge decided to adjourn the hearing for only thirty minutes and to recommence the hearing at 4.30 p.m., which was not enough time for the third applicant's lawyer to arrive.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "According to the transcript of the court hearing before the Sumgait City Court, the third applicant refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The third applicant stated before the Sumgait City Court that he was not guilty of breaching public order by swearing at the location indicated by the police.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The third applicant stated before the Sumgait City Court that he believed the motive for his arrest had been his participation in the demonstration of 12 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The only witnesses questioned during the court hearing before the Sumgait City Court in the third applicant's case were police officers M.N., R.S. and A.M.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Police officers M.N., R.S. and A.M. testified at the Sumgait City Court hearing that the third applicant had been swearing without addressing anyone in particular and that they had therefore taken him to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The Sumgait City Court found that the third applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 296 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The Sumgait City Court sentenced the third applicant to seven days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The third applicant lodged an appeal before the Sumgait Court of Appeal, presenting his version of the facts surrounding the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "In his appeal before the Sumgait Court of Appeal, the third applicant argued that his arrest had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "In his appeal before the Sumgait Court of Appeal, the third applicant argued that the hearing before the Sumgait City Court had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The third applicant urged the Sumgait Court of Appeal to quash the Sumgait City Court's decision.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "It appears that the third applicant prepared his written appeal before the Sumgait Court of Appeal with the assistance of a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The third applicant participated in the hearing before the Sumgait Court of Appeal without his lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "On 15 April 2011 the Sumgait Court of Appeal dismissed the third applicant's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "On 15 April 2011 the Sumgait Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the Sumgait City Court, stating that its findings had been correct.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrest, custody and administrative detention", "3. The third applicant, Mr Ibrahim Ahmadzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Article 49 of the 1995 Constitution of Azerbaijan provides that everyone has the right, having notified the respective governmental bodies in advance, to assemble with other people peacefully and without arms, to organise meetings, demonstrations, protests and marches, and to stage pickets.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. 1995 Constitution"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Under Article 5 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, advance written notification is required in order to agree on the place and time of an assembly and the route of a march, with the purpose of enabling the relevant local executive authority to take necessary measures.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Under Article 5 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, the notification has to be done in writing five days before the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Article 8 §§ IV and V of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides the relevant local executive authority with broad powers to issue relevant orders so as to prohibit a public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Article 8 § VI of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides the relevant local executive authority with broad powers to issue relevant orders so as to stop a public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Article 9 §§ II and VII of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides the relevant local executive authority with broad powers to restrict or change the place, route and/or time of a public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Article 9 § VI of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides the relevant local executive authority with broad powers to designate specific areas for public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "At the material time, Article 375.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that a defender and a representative shall be allowed to participate in administrative-offence proceedings from the time an administrative-offence report is drawn up.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "At the material time, Article 375.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that if an individual is subjected to an administrative arrest for committing an administrative offence, a defender shall be allowed to participate in the administrative-offence proceedings from the moment of the administrative arrest.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "At the material time, Article 376.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that if it is impossible for the lawyer chosen by the person against whom administrative-offence proceedings are being carried out to attend, a judge shall appoint a lawyer for that person in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "At the material time, Article 376.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that if a person subjected to an administrative arrest has no possibility to hire a lawyer due to his or her financial situation, his or her legal assistance shall be funded by the State, and in this case a lawyer may not refuse to carry out his or her duties.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "At the material time, Article 396.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that an authorised official may use administrative arrest as a measure to prevent administrative offences, to establish the identity of a person, to draw up an administrative-offence report if this cannot be done at the place of the administrative offence and if the drawing up of a report is important, to ensure the correct and timely examination of administrative-offence cases, and to ensure the implementation of decisions in administrative-offence cases.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "At the material time, Article 398.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that administrative arrest, that is the short-term restriction of an individual's liberty, may be applied in exceptional circumstances when deemed necessary for ensuring the correct and timely examination of an administrative-offence case or for the implementation of a decision in an administrative-offence case, except for instances set out in legislation.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "At the material time, Article 410.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that an individual who is subject to administrative-offence proceedings or a representative of a legal entity shall be given an opportunity to familiarise himself with the administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "At the material time, Article 410.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that an individual who is subject to the administrative-offence proceedings or a representative of a legal entity has the right to a copy of the administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "At the material time, Article 414.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that a report concerning an administrative offence punishable by administrative detention shall be sent to a judge for examination immediately after it has been drawn up.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "At the material time, Article 422.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that cases concerning an administrative offence punishable by administrative detention shall be examined on the day of receipt by the court of an administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "At the material time, Article 422.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that cases against persons subjected to administrative arrest shall be examined at the latest within 48 hours of their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "Under Article 368 of the Code of Administrative Offences, a public prosecutor has the right to participate in administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "Chapter 28 of the Code of Administrative Offences enumerates the participants of administrative proceedings and their rights and obligations.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "Chapter 28 of the Code of Administrative Offences does not mention the prosecution — a police officer, public prosecutor or any other public official representing the prosecution — as a participant of the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe continued to receive reports of threats, harassment, and violence against journalists or youth activists in Azerbaijan since the publication of his 2010 report.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "One of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe's recommendations to the Azerbaijani authorities was to end practices of unjustified or selective criminal prosecution of journalists or others who may express critical opinions.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The Ganja City Court sentenced youth activist and candidate in the 2010 parliamentary elections Bakhtiyar Hajiyev to two years in prison on 18 May 2011 for evading military service.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "According to the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe's document CommDH(2011)33 of 29 September 2011, the timing of Bakhtiyar Hajiyev's arrest and the charges against him appear to be indicative of an attempt to stop his activities, which were critical of the Government.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "Jabbar Savalan, a member of the youth group of the Azerbaijan Popular Front Party, was sentenced on 4 May 2011 to two and a half years imprisonment by the Sumgait City Court on drug possession charges, after marijuana was said to be found in his possession.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "Jabbar Savalan's sentencing occurred soon after he had posted several critical comments against the authorities and called for protests via social networks.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "Several international governmental and non-governmental organisations voiced their concerns about what they considered to be fabricated charges against Jabbar Savalan.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "According to the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe's document CommDH(2011)33 of 29 September 2011, in the past months several national and international NGOs had faced difficulties in carrying out their activities freely in Azerbaijan, and some of them had even been obliged to cease their activities.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "A building where several human rights organisations were located, including the Office of the Institute for Peace and Democracy, was demolished on 11 August 2011 in the framework of a reconstruction programme being implemented in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "The building's occupants were unable to retrieve any of their belongings, and their working materials — such as computers, documents, and books — were destroyed during the demolition on 11 August 2011.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "According to the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe's document CommDH(2011)33 of 29 September 2011, the circumstances of the demolition, which occurred in the evening, give reason to believe that it was carried out in retaliation against the activities of Leyla Yunus, the director of the Institute for Peace and Democracy and owner of the house, who was an outspoken critic of corruption and forced evictions in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "According to the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe's document CommDH(2011)33 of 29 September 2011, the Commissioner's attention was drawn to the wave of arrests of activists and political opponents in connection with protests held in Baku in March and April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "According to the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe's document CommDH(2011)33 of 29 September 2011, the protests in Baku in March and April 2011 were sometimes dispersed with excessive force, and the work of journalists was hindered.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "According to the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe's document CommDH(2011)33 of 29 September 2011, the organisers of protests in Baku in March and April 2011 were denied permission to demonstrate in a central square and other places in the city centre in Baku, and were instead authorised to hold a demonstration in the outskirts of the city.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe criticised on various occasions the method of curbing the impact of a demonstration by allowing it to take place only at another time and at a less central location, thereby diminishing significantly the visibility of the rally and its message to the general public.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "According to the report CommDH(2013)14 of 6 August 2013 by Nils Muižnieks, Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, in recent years the Azerbaijani authorities have arrested and prosecuted online media actors, notably bloggers or social media activists, in moves which have often been described as retaliation against their online activities.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "According to the report CommDH(2013)14 of 6 August 2013, bloggers Adnan Hajizadeh and Emin Milli were arrested in early September 2009 for hooliganism after having posted a video on YouTube which was critical of the government.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "According to the report CommDH(2013)14 of 6 August 2013, the issue of limitations imposed on freedom of assembly has regularly been raised by local and international observers in recent years, with the most frequent problems including the banning of demonstrations in central and easily accessible locations and the use of force to disperse demonstrations, leading to arrests and in some cases harsh sentences.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "According to the report CommDH(2013)14 of 6 August 2013, the Azerbaijani authorities confirmed that the legislation does not require permission for rallies, but the authorities appear to have interpreted it as requiring such permission, and a system of authorisation has in practice replaced the system of notification.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "According to the report CommDH(2013)14 of 6 August 2013, peaceful protesters have been effectively banned from demonstrating in central Baku since 2006, despite advanced notification of the assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "According to the report CommDH(2013)14 of 6 August 2013, several requests by the political opposition or civil society to hold demonstrations were allegedly denied or, when allowed, organisers were obliged to have them in areas very remote from the city centre.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, adopted on 23 January 2013, noted that there is no political dialogue with the opposition parties outside parliament in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "C. Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe: \"The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan\", 23 January 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about the restrictive climate for the activities of the extra-parliamentary opposition in Azerbaijan, which complains about limitations imposed on freedom of expression and freedom of assembly and the lack of access to the public media.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "C. Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe: \"The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan\", 23 January 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the establishment of an inclusive political system and a truly competitive and unrestrictive political environment requires full implementation of basic freedoms, including freedom of expression, freedom of assembly and freedom of association.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "C. Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe: \"The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan\", 23 January 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed deep concern about the situation regarding basic freedoms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "C. Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe: \"The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan\", 23 January 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed alarm at reports from human rights defenders and domestic and international non-governmental organisations about the alleged use of fabricated charges against activists and journalists in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "C. Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe: \"The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan\", 23 January 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the combination of the restrictive implementation of freedoms with unfair trials and the undue influence of the executive results in the systemic detention of people who may be considered prisoners of conscience in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "C. Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe: \"The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan\", 23 January 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "The European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan (P7_TA(2011)0243) noted that a wide-ranging clampdown on freedom of expression and assembly was being carried out in Azerbaijan following the peaceful protests against the government on 11 March and 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "D. European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan, P7_TA(2011)0243"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "The European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan noted that the clampdown included arrests, harassment and intimidation of civil society activists, media professionals and opposition politicians in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "D. European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan, P7_TA(2011)0243"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "The European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan noted that the cases of activists Jabbar Savalan and Bakhtiyar Hajiev were of particular concern.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "D. European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan, P7_TA(2011)0243"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "The European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan expressed deep concern at the increasing number of incidents of harassment, attacks and violence against civil society and social network activists and journalists in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "D. European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan, P7_TA(2011)0243"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "The European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan strongly deplored the practice of intimidating, arresting, prosecuting and convicting independent journalists and political activists on various criminal charges in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "D. European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan, P7_TA(2011)0243"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "The European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan deplored the arrest of around 200 people prior to, and during, the anti-government protests of 2 April 2011 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "D. European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan, P7_TA(2011)0243"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "The European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan called on the Azerbaijani authorities to allow peaceful protest as well as freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "D. European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan, P7_TA(2011)0243"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "The European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan deplored the physical violence used against protesters at the anti-government protests of 2 April 2011 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "D. European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan, P7_TA(2011)0243"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "The European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan called on the Azerbaijani authorities to maintain a dialogue with members of civil-society organisations and to allow individuals to freely engage in peaceful, democratic activities.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "D. European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan, P7_TA(2011)0243"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "The European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan encouraged the Azerbaijani authorities to allow peaceful demonstrations to take place in relevant locations and urged them to refrain from intimidating the organisers by detaining them and charging them with criminal and other offences.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "D. European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan, P7_TA(2011)0243"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "The European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan regretted that some youth activists had been expelled from Baku State University after missing examinations while in police custody linked to their political activities.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "D. European Parliament Resolution of 12 May 2011 on Azerbaijan, P7_TA(2011)0243"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "According to the Amnesty International public statement EUR55/003/2011 of 31 March 2011, ahead of the 2 April protest organised by opposition political parties through Facebook, the Azerbaijani authorities detained at least 11 prominent political activists on 31 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "E. Public Statement by Amnesty International: \"Clampdown on activists intensifies in Azerbaijan ahead of 2 April protests\", EUR55/003/2011, 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "According to the Amnesty International public statement EUR55/003/2011 of 31 March 2011, the wave of arrests began on 29 March when Nazim Abbasli from the Azerbaijan Democrat Party was arrested and given five days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "E. Public Statement by Amnesty International: \"Clampdown on activists intensifies in Azerbaijan ahead of 2 April protests\", EUR55/003/2011, 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "According to the Amnesty International public statement EUR55/003/2011 of 31 March 2011, Elchin Salimov, a member of the youth wing of opposition party Musavat, was arrested on 31 March 2011 by police and questioned about the 2 April rally, and was sentenced to seven days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "E. Public Statement by Amnesty International: \"Clampdown on activists intensifies in Azerbaijan ahead of 2 April protests\", EUR55/003/2011, 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "According to the Amnesty International public statement EUR55/003/2011 of 31 March 2011, Rauf Mammadov, a member of the youth wing of opposition party Musavat, was arrested on 31 March 2011 by police and questioned about the 2 April rally.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "E. Public Statement by Amnesty International: \"Clampdown on activists intensifies in Azerbaijan ahead of 2 April protests\", EUR55/003/2011, 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F205", "text": "According to the Amnesty International public statement EUR55/003/2011 of 31 March 2011, police questioned the family of Musavat member Idris Emiraslanli in an attempt to ascertain his whereabouts.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "E. Public Statement by Amnesty International: \"Clampdown on activists intensifies in Azerbaijan ahead of 2 April protests\", EUR55/003/2011, 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F206", "text": "According to the Amnesty International public statement EUR55/003/2011 of 31 March 2011, Deputy Chairman of the Azerbaijan Popular Front Party Ilham Huseynli was arrested on 31 March 2011 and remained in custody that evening.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "E. Public Statement by Amnesty International: \"Clampdown on activists intensifies in Azerbaijan ahead of 2 April protests\", EUR55/003/2011, 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F207", "text": "According to the Amnesty International public statement EUR55/003/2011 of 31 March 2011, Azerbaijan Popular Front Party members Karim Mehdiyev, Mehdi Mehdiyev and Nemat Aliyev were arrested on 31 March 2011 and remained in custody that evening.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "E. Public Statement by Amnesty International: \"Clampdown on activists intensifies in Azerbaijan ahead of 2 April protests\", EUR55/003/2011, 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F208", "text": "According to the Amnesty International public statement EUR55/003/2011 of 31 March 2011, Classical Popular Front Party member Yagub Babanli and youth activists Khalid Amanli, Rovshan Nasili, and Tabriz Qasimov were all arrested on 31 March 2011 and remained in custody that evening.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "E. Public Statement by Amnesty International: \"Clampdown on activists intensifies in Azerbaijan ahead of 2 April protests\", EUR55/003/2011, 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F209", "text": "According to the Amnesty International public statement EUR55/003/2011 of 31 March 2011, Ilham Huseynli, Nemat Aliyev, Tabriz Qasimov and Mehdi Mehdiyev were given sentences ranging between five and seven days' administrative detention, convicted of resisting police or disturbing the public order despite the fact that the protests had yet to take place.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "E. Public Statement by Amnesty International: \"Clampdown on activists intensifies in Azerbaijan ahead of 2 April protests\", EUR55/003/2011, 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F210", "text": "According to the Amnesty International public statement EUR55/003/2011 of 31 March 2011, Amnesty International was concerned that the trials of those arrested on 31 March 2011 were held behind closed doors.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "E. Public Statement by Amnesty International: \"Clampdown on activists intensifies in Azerbaijan ahead of 2 April protests\", EUR55/003/2011, 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F211", "text": "According to the Amnesty International public statement EUR55/003/2011 of 31 March 2011, several youth activists who posted the announcement of the protest on the internet were arrested on questionable charges and convicted in trials that reportedly failed to meet international standards in connection with the March 11 protest.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "E. Public Statement by Amnesty International: \"Clampdown on activists intensifies in Azerbaijan ahead of 2 April protests\", EUR55/003/2011, 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F212", "text": "According to the Amnesty International public statement EUR55/003/2011 of 31 March 2011, the call for protests on 2 April 2011 met with a new wave of violence and intimidation directed against activists and journalists.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "E. Public Statement by Amnesty International: \"Clampdown on activists intensifies in Azerbaijan ahead of 2 April protests\", EUR55/003/2011, 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F213", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 1 April 2011, Azerbaijani authorities detained at least 10 opposition activists in an effort to prevent a public rally planned for 2 April 2011 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "F. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Activists Jailed Ahead of Planned Protest. International Partners Should Condemn Crackdown\", 1 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F214", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 1 April 2011, police detained the activists on 31 March 2011 in Baku and various provinces.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "F. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Activists Jailed Ahead of Planned Protest. International Partners Should Condemn Crackdown\", 1 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F215", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 1 April 2011, the protests planned for 2 April 2011 were organised by Azerbaijan's opposition parties and young social network users.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "F. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Activists Jailed Ahead of Planned Protest. International Partners Should Condemn Crackdown\", 1 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F216", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 1 April 2011, the activists were quickly convicted in summary trials on charges of disobeying police orders and sentenced to administrative detention ranging from five to thirteen days, which would keep them locked up beyond the protest date.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "F. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Activists Jailed Ahead of Planned Protest. International Partners Should Condemn Crackdown\", 1 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F217", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 1 April 2011, police in Sumgait rounded up at least two activists: Ibrahim Mammedzade, a political activist who ran in the November 2010 parliamentary elections, and Elchin Salimov, an opposition Musavat party youth activist.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "F. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Activists Jailed Ahead of Planned Protest. International Partners Should Condemn Crackdown\", 1 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F218", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 1 April 2011, police went to Ibrahim Mammedzade's home on the morning of 31 March 2011 but did not find him there.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "F. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Activists Jailed Ahead of Planned Protest. International Partners Should Condemn Crackdown\", 1 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F219", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 1 April 2011, Ibrahim Mammedzade later went to the Sumgait Municipal Police Department on his own accord, together with his lawyer, Asabali Mustafayev.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "F. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Activists Jailed Ahead of Planned Protest. International Partners Should Condemn Crackdown\", 1 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F220", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 1 April 2011, after about an hour-long conversation with the deputy police chief, in which Ibrahim Mammedzade was asked about his educational background and political activities, the deputy police chief assured lawyer Asabali Mustafayev that Mammedzade would not be detained.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "F. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Activists Jailed Ahead of Planned Protest. International Partners Should Condemn Crackdown\", 1 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F221", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 1 April 2011, later in the day police detained Ibrahim Mammedzade, and a court sentenced him to seven days' administrative detention for allegedly disobeying a police order.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "F. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Activists Jailed Ahead of Planned Protest. International Partners Should Condemn Crackdown\", 1 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F222", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 1 April 2011, the trial of Ibrahim Mammedzade was closed, and the judge refused to wait for lawyer Asabali Mustafayev to arrive.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "F. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Activists Jailed Ahead of Planned Protest. International Partners Should Condemn Crackdown\", 1 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F223", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 1 April 2011, lawyer Asabali Mustafayev told Human Rights Watch that Elchin Salimov had been picked up at home in the early hours of 31 March 2011 and sentenced to seven days of administrative detention for disobeying a police order.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "F. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Activists Jailed Ahead of Planned Protest. International Partners Should Condemn Crackdown\", 1 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F224", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 1 April 2011, the Mobile Group of Lawyers reported that other activists detained in Baku on 31 March 2011 and convicted of disobeying police orders included: Rovshan Nasirli, blogger and active social network user, sentenced by the Yasamal District Court to nine days; Namat Aliyev, opposition Popular Front Party member, sentenced to seven days by the Nizami District Court; Khalid Amanli, an opposition Musavat party youth activist, sentenced to eight days by the Yasamal District Court; and Kerim Mehdiyev, the driver for the opposition Popular Front Party leader, sentenced to 13 days by the Binagadi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "F. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Activists Jailed Ahead of Planned Protest. International Partners Should Condemn Crackdown\", 1 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F225", "text": "According to the Amnesty International press release of 2 April 2011, according to local rights groups six more activists had been detained on 1 April 2011 in connection with the protest, bringing the total number of those arrested before the protest to 17.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "G. Press release by Amnesty International: \"Azerbaijan protests broken up as riot police move in\", 2 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F226", "text": "According to the Amnesty International press release of 2 April 2011, Vugar Hasanli, Teymur Abbasli, Ibrahim Ahmadzade and Tahir Abdullayev were arrested by police late on 1 April 2011, picked up by officers from their homes in and around Baku.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "G. Press release by Amnesty International: \"Azerbaijan protests broken up as riot police move in\", 2 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F227", "text": "According to the Amnesty International press release of 2 April 2011, Vugar Hasanli was sentenced to 10 days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "G. Press release by Amnesty International: \"Azerbaijan protests broken up as riot police move in\", 2 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F228", "text": "According to the Amnesty International press release of 2 April 2011, Ibrahim Ahmadzade was sentenced to 7 days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "G. Press release by Amnesty International: \"Azerbaijan protests broken up as riot police move in\", 2 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F229", "text": "According to the Amnesty International press release of 2 April 2011, at least seven individuals were sentenced to administrative detention, most under Article 310.1 of Azerbaijan's Code of Administrative Offences which bans wilful disobedience of a police official.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "G. Press release by Amnesty International: \"Azerbaijan protests broken up as riot police move in\", 2 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F230", "text": "According to the Amnesty International press release of 2 April 2011, the majority of the trials took place behind closed doors, without the defendants having access to legal representation.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "G. Press release by Amnesty International: \"Azerbaijan protests broken up as riot police move in\", 2 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F231", "text": "According to the Amnesty International press release of 2 April 2011, John Dalhuisen stated that the fact that key organisers were being arrested in advance and sentenced in closed trials of offences that had yet to take place was indicative of the length to which the authorities were prepared to go to silence dissenting voices.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "G. Press release by Amnesty International: \"Azerbaijan protests broken up as riot police move in\", 2 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F232", "text": "According to the Amnesty International press release of 2 April 2011, political activists Arzu Musayev and Kifayet Musayev said police had told them not to leave their home district of Gadabay to attend the rally in Baku, and that when they did they were followed by police officers all day.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "G. Press release by Amnesty International: \"Azerbaijan protests broken up as riot police move in\", 2 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F233", "text": "According to the Amnesty International press release of 2 April 2011, Azerbaijan state TV reported that the 2 April protest was an attempt by foreign powers to destabilise Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "G. Press release by Amnesty International: \"Azerbaijan protests broken up as riot police move in\", 2 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F234", "text": "According to the Amnesty International press release of 2 April 2011, state controlled television stations broadcast several programmes depicting Facebook users as mentally ill.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "G. Press release by Amnesty International: \"Azerbaijan protests broken up as riot police move in\", 2 April 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F235", "text": "According to the Amnesty International report EUR55/011/2011 of 2011, the Azerbaijani authorities brought questionable criminal charges against Vidadi Isgandarov, a human rights defender, and opposition leader Shahin Hasanli, with the timing of their arrests and the dubious nature of the charges strongly suggesting they were targeted for their political activities and the peaceful exercise of their rights to freedom of expression and assembly.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "H. Amnesty International Report: \"The Spring That Never Blossomed. Freedoms Suppressed In Azerbaijan\", EUR55/011/2011, 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F236", "text": "According to the Amnesty International report EUR55/011/2011 of 2011, Shahin Hasanli, managing board member of the Popular Front Party, was one of those arrested on 31 March 2011 prior to the 2 April opposition rally.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "H. Amnesty International Report: \"The Spring That Never Blossomed. Freedoms Suppressed In Azerbaijan\", EUR55/011/2011, 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F237", "text": "According to the Amnesty International report EUR55/011/2011 of 2011, Shahin Hasanli was convicted on 22 July 2011 and sentenced to two years' imprisonment for the possession of illegal arms.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "H. Amnesty International Report: \"The Spring That Never Blossomed. Freedoms Suppressed In Azerbaijan\", EUR55/011/2011, 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F238", "text": "According to the Amnesty International report EUR55/011/2011 of 2011, Shahin Hasanli, who was one of the main organisers behind the March and April 2011 protests, claimed that the bullets were planted on him by the police at the time of his arrest and maintained that he had been targeted because of his political activities.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "H. Amnesty International Report: \"The Spring That Never Blossomed. Freedoms Suppressed In Azerbaijan\", EUR55/011/2011, 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F239", "text": "According to the Amnesty International report EUR55/011/2011 of 2011, the timing of Shahin Hasanli's arrest a few days before the April 2011 protests, the nature of the charges and the paucity of supporting evidence all point strongly to the conclusion that his arrest was politically motivated.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "H. Amnesty International Report: \"The Spring That Never Blossomed. Freedoms Suppressed In Azerbaijan\", EUR55/011/2011, 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F240", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 12 March 2011, in at least three cases the Azerbaijani authorities held activists on administrative charges just long enough to prevent them from participating in the planned protests.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "I. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Azerbaijan: Government Cracks Down to Prevent Protests. Authorities Detain Dozens and Suspend a Human Rights Group\", 12 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F241", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 12 March 2011, on 8 March 2011 police detained Rashadat Akhundov, a 27-year-old social media activist who was one of the first to call for the 11 March protest.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "I. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Azerbaijan: Government Cracks Down to Prevent Protests. Authorities Detain Dozens and Suspend a Human Rights Group\", 12 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F242", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 12 March 2011, lawyer Elchin Namazov told Human Rights Watch that police in civilian clothes approached Rashadat Akhundov as he was running errands in Baku and demanded his documents, then grabbed him, twisted his arms, stuffed him into a car and drove away.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "I. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Azerbaijan: Government Cracks Down to Prevent Protests. Authorities Detain Dozens and Suspend a Human Rights Group\", 12 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F243", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 12 March 2011, the Khatai District Court convicted Rashadat Akhundov of disobeying police orders and sentenced him to five days of administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "I. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Azerbaijan: Government Cracks Down to Prevent Protests. Authorities Detain Dozens and Suspend a Human Rights Group\", 12 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F244", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 12 March 2011, on 8 March 2011 police arrested Sahavat Sultanov, deputy head of the opposition party Musavat's youth wing and an active social media user, who had actively promoted the 12 March opposition rally through his Facebook contacts and other outreach.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "I. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Azerbaijan: Government Cracks Down to Prevent Protests. Authorities Detain Dozens and Suspend a Human Rights Group\", 12 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F245", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 12 March 2011, police charged Sahavat Sultanov with auto hooliganism — violating traffic rules — and in a hearing that lasted only minutes a judge sentenced him to five days of administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "I. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Azerbaijan: Government Cracks Down to Prevent Protests. Authorities Detain Dozens and Suspend a Human Rights Group\", 12 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F246", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 12 March 2011, on 4 March 2011 police detained Dayanat Babayev, a member of the opposition Popular Front Party's Youth Committee and an active Facebook and social network user who was critical of the government but promoted peaceful public protests.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "I. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Azerbaijan: Government Cracks Down to Prevent Protests. Authorities Detain Dozens and Suspend a Human Rights Group\", 12 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F247", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 12 March 2011, Dayanat Babayev's family and friends heard nothing until 6 March 2011, when they learned that he had been convicted, allegedly for disobeying a police order, and sentenced to 10 days in detention.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "I. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Azerbaijan: Government Cracks Down to Prevent Protests. Authorities Detain Dozens and Suspend a Human Rights Group\", 12 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F248", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 12 March 2011, the court ruling stated that Dayanat Babayev had disobeyed police orders and insulted policemen who approached him to warn him not to use foul language while talking on the phone in public.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "I. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Azerbaijan: Government Cracks Down to Prevent Protests. Authorities Detain Dozens and Suspend a Human Rights Group\", 12 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F249", "text": "According to the Human Rights Watch news release of 12 March 2011, lawyer Asabali Mustafayev, who visited Dayanat Babayev in the detention centre on 7 March 2011, said that Babayev was rounded up in an internet café in downtown Baku, where fifteen minutes after he arrived, three plainclothes policemen came in, twisted his arms and took him away with no explanation.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "I. News release by Human Rights Watch: \"Azerbaijan: Government Cracks Down to Prevent Protests. Authorities Detain Dozens and Suspend a Human Rights Group\", 12 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F250", "text": "According to the Annual Freedom of Expression Report by the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety of 2012, freelance journalist Fuad Huseynov was arrested in October 2010 on charges of hooliganism after exposing illegal activities of public officials in the Ujar region, in particular involvement in drug trafficking and trafficking in persons.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "J. Annual Freedom of Expression Report by the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety: \"Azerbaijan's Critical Voices Struggling for Survival\", 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F251", "text": "According to the Annual Freedom of Expression Report by the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety of 2012, on 26 September 2011 Fuad Huseynov was sentenced to six and a half years in prison under Article 221.3 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "J. Annual Freedom of Expression Report by the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety: \"Azerbaijan's Critical Voices Struggling for Survival\", 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F252", "text": "According to the Annual Freedom of Expression Report by the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety of 2012, one of the victims who testified against Fuad Huseynov later stated that he had been pressured into giving false testimony by a local mafia group.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "J. Annual Freedom of Expression Report by the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety: \"Azerbaijan's Critical Voices Struggling for Survival\", 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F253", "text": "According to the Annual Freedom of Expression Report by the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety of 2012, Fuad Huseynov had previously served two years of a three and a half year prison sentence on hooliganism charges after he accused a former Ujar city police chief of drug-related crimes.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "J. Annual Freedom of Expression Report by the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety: \"Azerbaijan's Critical Voices Struggling for Survival\", 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F254", "text": "According to the Annual Freedom of Expression Report by the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety of 2012, blogger and human rights defender Taleh Khasmammadov was arrested on 12 November 2011 in the Ujar region and charged with hooliganism under Criminal Code Articles 221.2.2 and 221.3, as well as resisting arrest under Article 315.1.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "J. Annual Freedom of Expression Report by the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety: \"Azerbaijan's Critical Voices Struggling for Survival\", 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F255", "text": "According to the Annual Freedom of Expression Report by the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety of 2012, Taleh Khasmammadov was sentenced on 20 April 2012 to four years in prison and is thought to have been targeted for exposing the criminal activities of local officials, including by posting a series of videos to YouTube containing interviews with victims of human rights abuses.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "J. Annual Freedom of Expression Report by the Institute for Reporters' Freedom and Safety: \"Azerbaijan's Critical Voices Struggling for Survival\", 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F256", "text": "According to the Contact online news release of 31 March 2011, the chief of the press service department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Azerbaijan, Orkhan Mansurzade, informed the Turan news agency that attempts to breach public order and to hold a protest on 2 April 2011 at the central streets and squares of Baku without agreement of the Baku City Executive Authority would be vigorously prevented.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "K. News release by Contact online news: \"Ministry of Internal Affairs threatens participants of 2 April protest\", 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F257", "text": "According to the Contact online news release of 31 March 2011, the mayor's office refused to give permission to the Ictimai Palata to hold a demonstration on 2 April 2011 in front of Narimanov cinema and proposed to hold the protest in Bibiheybet settlement.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "K. News release by Contact online news: \"Ministry of Internal Affairs threatens participants of 2 April protest\", 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F258", "text": "According to the Contact online news release of 31 March 2011, the Ictimai Palata decided to hold the protest at 2 p.m. on 2 April 2011 at the Fountains Square.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "K. News release by Contact online news: \"Ministry of Internal Affairs threatens participants of 2 April protest\", 31 March 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F259", "text": "According to the Contact online news release of 31 March 2011, in connection with the Ictimai Palata's decision to hold the protest at the Fountains Square on 2 April 2011, arrests of potential activists began.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC DOCUMENTS AND PRESS RELEASES", "K. News release by Contact online news: \"Ministry of Internal Affairs threatens participants of 2 April protest\", 31 March 2011"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F029", "F256", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F007", "F017", "F027", "F028"], "interference": ["F008", "F007", "F017", "F029", "F256", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F043", "F059", "F060", "F073", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F077", "F079", "F097", "F098", "F099", "F113", "F114", "F115", "F118", "F132", "F133", "F050", "F055", "F056", "F057", "F087", "F095", "F096", "F130", "F131", "F174", "F175", "F190", "F191", "F194", "F195", "F201", "F202", "F203", "F204", "F205", "F206", "F207", "F208", "F209", "F210", "F211", "F212", "F213", "F214", "F215", "F216", "F217", "F218", "F219", "F220", "F221", "F222", "F223", "F224", "F225", "F226", "F227", "F228", "F229", "F230", "F231", "F240", "F241", "F242", "F243", "F244", "F245", "F246", "F247", "F248", "F249", "F033", "F036"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F043", "F079", "F080", "F118", "F033", "F036", "F038", "F059", "F060", "F073", "F074", "F097", "F098", "F099", "F113", "F132", "F133"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F029", "F011", "F007", "F017", "F027"], "interference": ["F008", "F007", "F017", "F029", "F256", "F033", "F036", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F043", "F059", "F060", "F073", "F075", "F079", "F097", "F099", "F113", "F114", "F118", "F132", "F133", "F050", "F055", "F057", "F087", "F095", "F130", "F174", "F194", "F195", "F201", "F209", "F213", "F216"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F043", "F079", "F118", "F033", "F036"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F007", "F017", "F029", "F256", "F033", "F036", "F038", "F039", "F043", "F059", "F060", "F073", "F075", "F079", "F097", "F099", "F113", "F114", "F118", "F132", "F133", "F195", "F201", "F209"]}} {"case_name": "case_312", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' dates of birth and places of residence are given in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "At the material time all the applicants were members of an opposition party called the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan (PFPA).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan (PFPA), together with some other parties, formed a political union called Milli Shura.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The first applicant was chairman of the Youth Committee of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan (PFPA).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The first applicant was a journalist for the Azadlig newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The fourth applicant was a member of the Youth Committee of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan (PFPA).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The fifth applicant was a member of the board of the Youth Committee of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan (PFPA).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The second applicant was chairman of the Jalilabad district branch of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan (PFPA).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The second applicant had been a candidate of the PFPA-Musavat political bloc in the parliamentary elections of 2010.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The third applicant was a bodyguard for a chairman of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan (PFPA), Mr A.K.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The sixth applicant was a bodyguard for a chairman of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan (PFPA), Mr A.K.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The period from 2011 to 2013 appears to have been marked by an increase in political sensitivity in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The increase in political sensitivity in Azerbaijan from 2011 to 2013 was generated, inter alia, by the presidential elections, which took place in October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "During the period from 2011 to 2013, all the applicants participated in a number of peaceful opposition demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "In the course of many of the peaceful opposition demonstrations, most of the applicants were arrested and subsequently convicted, as the assemblies had not been authorised.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The second applicant was arrested during a demonstration on 20 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The third applicant was arrested during a demonstration on 20 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The fourth applicant was arrested during a demonstration on 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The fifth applicant was arrested during a demonstration on 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The second applicant was arrested during a demonstration on 11 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The fourth applicant was arrested during a demonstration on 11 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the applicants, they had intended to participate in upcoming protests planned by Milli Shura, including a protest scheduled for 9 March 2014, which was eventually cancelled.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The fourth applicant was an organiser of a protest scheduled for 23 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the fourth applicant, he had created a Facebook group calling for the resignation of the Baku city mayor.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the fourth applicant, the Baku city mayor had allegedly insulted the Azeri nation in a speech by saying that the only man in the country was the President.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Facebook group created by the fourth applicant had invited the public to participate in a demonstration against the Baku city mayor.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "All the applicants were arrested in either February or March 2014.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The fourth applicant was arrested on 22 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The first applicant was arrested on 27 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The second applicant was arrested on 27 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The third applicant was arrested on 27 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The sixth applicant was arrested on 5 March 2014.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The fifth applicant claimed that he had been arrested on 5 March 2014.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the official records, the fifth applicant was arrested early in the morning (at around 7 a.m.) on 6 March 2014.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "According to the official records, the first applicant was arrested for disobeying a lawful order of a police officer to stop swearing loudly without addressing anyone in particular.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to the official records, the police approached the second applicant because he had been noticed behaving suspiciously.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the official records, the police approached the sixth applicant because he had been noticed behaving suspiciously.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the official records, the police approached the third applicant because he was suspected of committing a traffic accident.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the official records, the police approached the fifth applicant because there was a complaint against him by a certain Ms K.N.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the official records, the police approached the fourth applicant because there was information about him.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the official records, the second applicant was arrested because when police officers had approached him, he had deliberately failed to comply with an order to produce an identity document and/or had been rude or showed resistance.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to the official records, the sixth applicant was arrested because when police officers had approached him, he had deliberately failed to comply with an order to produce an identity document and/or had been rude or showed resistance.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the official records, the third applicant was arrested because when police officers had approached him, he had deliberately failed to comply with an order to produce an identity document and/or had been rude or showed resistance.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the official records, the fifth applicant was arrested because when police officers had approached him, he had deliberately failed to comply with an order to produce an identity document and/or had been rude or showed resistance.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the official records, the fourth applicant was arrested because when police officers had approached him, he had deliberately failed to comply with an order to produce an identity document and/or had been rude or showed resistance.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The first applicant contested the official version of his arrest, claiming that he had been approached by police officers and had been requested to follow them to a police station or office, and that he had obeyed that request.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The second applicant contested the official version of his arrest, claiming that he had been approached by police officers and had been requested to follow them to a police station or office, and that he had obeyed that request.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The third applicant contested the official version of his arrest, claiming that he had been approached by police officers and had been requested to follow them to a police station or office, and that he had obeyed that request.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The third applicant submitted that he had been requested to show his identity document and that he had obeyed that request.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The first applicant argued that the reasons given by the police officers for arresting him had been different from the official version, stating that the police had demanded that he follow them to a police station because there was a problem with a loan he had obtained from a bank.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The first applicant went to the police station together with his father.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Sometime after arriving at the police station, the first applicant's father was requested to leave the police station, while the first applicant remained in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The second applicant argued that the reasons given by the police officers for arresting him had been different from the official version, stating that the police had demanded that he follow them to a police office because the chief of police wanted to see him.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The fourth applicant submitted that he had been arrested by people in plain clothes, without any explanations, and that initially he had not known that those persons were police officers.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The fifth applicant submitted that he had been arrested by people in plain clothes, without any explanations, and that initially he had not known that those persons were police officers.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The sixth applicant submitted that he had been arrested by people in plain clothes, without any explanations, and that initially he had not known that those persons were police officers.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The fourth applicant claimed that he had been arrested at his flat and that the persons who had arrested him had also seized his computer and had taken him to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "After the fourth applicant's arrest, the police accessed his Facebook account through his seized computer and put a notice on it that the demonstration planned for 23 February 2014 had been cancelled.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The fifth applicant claimed that he had been arrested in the evening of the day before the officially recorded date of arrest and had spent the night in custody.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "At the respective police stations or offices, administrative offence reports (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) were issued against the applicants, setting out the charges against them.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "All the applicants were charged with an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (failure to comply with a lawful order of a police officer).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The first applicant was also charged under Article 296 of the Code of Administrative Offences (minor hooliganism).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "According to the applicants, they were never served with copies of the administrative offence reports or with other documents from their case files.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "According to the applicants, they were not given access to a lawyer after their arrest or while they were in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "According to a record (protokol) issued by a police officer who had arrested the fifth applicant and prepared an administrative offence report on him, a State-funded lawyer was proposed to the fifth applicant, but the fifth applicant refused his assistance.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The record (protokol) regarding the fifth applicant was signed by the police officer and the fifth applicant.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The lawyer's name and signature are missing from the record (protokol) regarding the fifth applicant.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "According to a statement (ərizə) written by the fourth applicant at a police office on the day of his arrest, the fourth applicant had refused the services of a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On various dates the applicants were brought before the respective first-instance courts, which adopted their decisions on the merits on the same dates as detailed in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "According to all the applicants, they were not given an opportunity to appoint lawyers of their own choosing during the court proceedings before the first-instance courts.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "State-funded lawyers were appointed to assist the applicants during the court proceedings before the first-instance courts.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "According to the documents in the respective case files, the first applicant refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and decided to defend himself in person before the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "According to the documents in the respective case files, the third applicant refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and decided to defend himself in person before the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "According to the documents in the respective case files, the fifth applicant refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and decided to defend himself in person before the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "According to the documents in the respective case files, the sixth applicant refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and decided to defend himself in person before the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "According to the transcripts of the respective hearings, the State-funded lawyer for the second applicant, Mr K.K., briefly asked the court to discontinue the administrative case against the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "According to the transcripts of the respective hearings, the State-funded lawyer for the fourth applicant, Ms S.H., briefly asked the court to consider the young age of the fourth applicant.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "In their statements before the courts, the first, second, third, fourth and sixth applicants contested the police officers' versions of the events surrounding their arrests.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The first applicant argued before the court that he had been arrested for his political activity.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The third applicant argued before the court that the police's allegation that they were investigating a car accident was a lie and that the police had wanted to frame him.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The fourth applicant argued before the court that he had been arrested for the comments he had posted on Facebook against the Baku city mayor.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The courts disregarded the applicants' statements contesting the police officers' versions of the events.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The fifth applicant gave a self-incriminatory statement before the court confirming the police officers' account of the events.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The fifth applicant subsequently claimed that he had given the self-incriminatory statement because the previous day he had been threatened with more serious charges and had still felt under the control of the police.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "During the hearings with regard to the first applicant, only the police officers who, according to the official records, had arrested the first applicant and/or issued administrative offence reports on him were questioned as witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "During the hearings with regard to the second applicant, only the police officers who, according to the official records, had arrested the second applicant and/or issued administrative offence reports on him were questioned as witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "During the hearings with regard to the fourth applicant, only the police officers who, according to the official records, had arrested the fourth applicant and/or issued administrative offence reports on him were questioned as witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "During the hearings with regard to the fifth applicant, only the police officers who, according to the official records, had arrested the fifth applicant and/or issued administrative offence reports on him were questioned as witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "In their statements, the police officers questioned as witnesses reiterated the official version of the reasons for the applicants' arrests.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "In the case of the third applicant, the court questioned three prosecution witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "All three prosecution witnesses in the case of the third applicant stated that the third applicant had argued with the police officers, resisted and insulted them, saying to a police major 'why have you brought these puppies here?'", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "In the case of the sixth applicant, the court did not question any witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The courts found that the applicants had committed the administrative offences attributed to them.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The courts convicted the applicants under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (failure to comply with a lawful order of a police officer).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The courts sentenced the applicants to periods of administrative detention varying from ten to twenty days, as detailed in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The first applicant was also convicted under Article 296 of the Code of Administrative Offences (minor hooliganism).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "On various dates the applicants lodged appeals with the Baku Court of Appeal, presenting their version of the facts surrounding their arrests.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The first, second, third, fifth and sixth applicants argued before the Baku Court of Appeal that they had been unlawfully arrested for their political activity, including their active participation in demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The fourth applicant argued before the Baku Court of Appeal that he had been unlawfully arrested for the comments he had posted on social media.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The applicants complained before the Baku Court of Appeal that the hearings before the respective first-instance courts had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The fifth applicant submitted to the Baku Court of Appeal that previously he had given self-incriminatory statements for fear of being framed for the offence of illegal possession of drugs.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The fifth applicant complained to the Baku Court of Appeal that he had been kept in the police station overnight from 5 to 6 March 2014 without any official decision or record of his detention.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "All the applicants were represented before the Baku Court of Appeal by lawyers of their own choosing.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On various dates the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants' appeals and upheld the decisions of the respective first-instance courts, stating that the conclusions reached by those courts were correct, as detailed in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Article 410.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 provided, at the material time, that a copy of the administrative-offence report shall be given to an individual who is subject to administrative-offence proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, titled 'The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan', expressed concern that recently adopted amendments to the Criminal Code and the Administrative Code had increased penalties for the organisers of, and participants in, unauthorised gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that, considering the authorities' ongoing blanket ban on protests in the Baku city centre, the amendments increasing penalties for organisers of and participants in unauthorised gatherings were likely to have a further negative impact on freedom of assembly and freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Resolution 2062 (2015) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, titled 'The functioning of democratic institutions in Azerbaijan', was adopted on 23 June 2015.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Resolution 2062 (2015) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the lack of independence of the judiciary remains a concern in Azerbaijan, where the executive branch is alleged to continue to exert undue influence.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Resolution 2062 (2015) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that dubiously motivated criminal prosecutions and disproportionate sentences remain a concern in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Resolution 2062 (2015) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that fairness of trials, equality of arms and respect for the presumption of innocence are major concerns in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Resolution 2062 (2015) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that it was alarmed by reports by human rights defenders and international NGOs, confirmed by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights, concerning the increase in criminal prosecutions against NGO leaders, journalists, lawyers and others who express critical opinions, based on alleged charges in relation to their work.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Resolution 2062 (2015) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe called on the Azerbaijani authorities to end the systemic harassment of those who are critical of the government and to release those wrongfully detained.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The European Parliament in its Resolution (2015/2840(RSP)) of 10 September 2015 emphasised that the overall human rights situation in Azerbaijan has deteriorated continuously over the last few years, with growing intimidation and repression and intensification of the practice of criminal prosecution of NGO leaders, human rights defenders, journalists and other civil society representatives.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The European Parliament in its Resolution (2015/2840(RSP)) of 10 September 2015 emphasised that peaceful protesters have been effectively banned from demonstrating in central Baku since 2006.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The European Parliament in its Resolution (2015/2840(RSP)) of 10 September 2015 emphasised that new, harsh fines and longer periods of administrative detention for those who organise or participate in unauthorised public gatherings have recently been introduced in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Amnesty International in its Report of May 2014, titled 'Behind Bars: Silencing Dissent in Azerbaijan', referred to a decrease of public protests in Azerbaijan due to the harshening from 1 January 2013 of penalties for breach of rules on organisation and holding of peaceful assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Amnesty International in its Report of May 2014, titled 'Behind Bars: Silencing Dissent in Azerbaijan', emphasised that those who have called for public protest in Azerbaijan have been dealt with harshly, with criminal proceedings initiated against them under fabricated charges.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "In a public statement of 7 March 2014, titled 'Azerbaijan: Opposition party loses HQ after explosion and sees seven members arrested within 2 weeks', Amnesty International reported on numerous detentions and arrests of activists of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan during late February and early March 2014.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Amnesty International's public statement of 7 March 2014 reported on an explosion which occurred on 3 March 2014 in the basement of a building housing the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Amnesty International's public statement of 7 March 2014 reported on allegations by the owner of the property housing the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan that prior to the explosion he had been pressured to evict the party.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "A summary of the relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, the relevant provisions concerning freedom of assembly, and the relevant extracts from international documents and press releases can be found in the judgment in the case of Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (nos. 67360/11, 67964/11 and 69379/11, paragraphs 67-77, 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F014", "F015", "F022", "F023"], "interference": ["F002", "F014", "F015", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F061", "F078", "F079", "F082", "F085", "F086", "F087", "F088", "F089", "F093", "F094", "F095", "F104", "F108", "F110", "F113", "F114", "F117", "F118", "F119"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F035", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F061", "F078", "F079", "F082", "F085", "F086", "F087", "F088", "F089", "F093", "F094", "F104"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F014", "F015"], "interference": ["F002", "F014", "F027", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F061", "F082", "F085", "F086", "F087", "F088", "F089", "F110", "F113", "F119"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F035", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F061", "F082", "F085", "F086", "F087", "F088", "F089"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F014", "F027", "F035", "F061", "F082", "F085", "F086", "F087", "F088", "F110", "F119"]}} {"case_name": "case_313", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "At the time of the events giving rise to the application, Hyde Park (the first applicant) was registered with the Moldovan Ministry of Justice as a non-governmental organisation.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) lobbied, among other things, for freedom of expression and the right to peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "In 2007, Hyde Park's members decided to discontinue the organisation's registration with the Moldovan Ministry of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Hyde Park's members decided to discontinue the organisation's registration on grounds of alleged pressure and intimidation by the State.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of the refusal of the Moldovan Ministry of Justice to register amendments to Hyde Park's articles of association.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of the repeated freezing of Hyde Park's bank account.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of the arbitrary arrest of Hyde Park's members.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of attempts to shut down Hyde Park's newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Several of Hyde Park's leaders requested political asylum in western countries.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "It was decided to continue Hyde Park's activity under the same name but without registering it with the State authorities.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "It was decided that the new unincorporated association would become the former registered organisation's successor.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Hyde Park was removed from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations on 2 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "After removal from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations on 2 June 2008, Hyde Park's activities continued as before on the basis of its new articles of association.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Hyde Park (the unincorporated association) continued editing its newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Hyde Park (the unincorporated association) continued editing its Internet page.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Hyde Park (the unincorporated association) continued staging protests and demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Gheorghe Lupuşoru is a member and supporter of Hyde Park.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Anatol Hristea-Stan is a member and supporter of Hyde Park.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Mariana Gălescu is a member and supporter of Hyde Park.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Alina Didilică is a member and supporter of Hyde Park.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Oleg Brega is a member and supporter of Hyde Park.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Gheorghe Lupuşoru was born in 1969.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Anatol Hristea-Stan was born in 1953.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Mariana Gălescu was born in 1982.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Alina Didilică was born in 1978.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Oleg Brega was born in 1973.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "Gheorghe Lupuşoru lives in Chişinău.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "Anatol Hristea-Stan lives in Chişinău.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Mariana Gălescu lives in Chişinău.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Alina Didilică lives in Cazangic.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Oleg Brega lives in Pepeni.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 26 September 2005, Hyde Park (the first applicant) applied to the Chişinău Municipal Council for authorisation to hold a peaceful rally in the Stefan cel Mare Park in Chişinău.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The peaceful rally for which Hyde Park sought authorisation was planned for 14 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The peaceful rally for which Hyde Park sought authorisation was in support of freedom of speech.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 7 October 2005, the Chişinău Municipal Council rejected Hyde Park's application to hold a rally in the Stefan cel Mare Park on 14 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Chişinău Municipal Council rejected Hyde Park's application on the ground that on 14 October 2005 a number of events were planned in the city centre, including in the Stefan cel Mare Park.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Chişinău Municipal Council rejected Hyde Park's application on the ground that 14 October 2005 was a day of public holiday.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Chişinău Municipal Council's decision rejecting Hyde Park's application was sent by mail to Hyde Park on 10 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Chişinău Municipal Council's decision rejecting Hyde Park's application was received by Hyde Park on 12 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 12 October 2005, Hyde Park (the first applicant) challenged the Chişinău Municipal Council's refusal to authorise the rally in court.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) argued, among other things, that the Chişinău Municipal Council's refusal was unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) argued that the Chişinău Municipal Council's refusal was contrary to Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) asked that the case be examined urgently.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 2 December 2005, the Chişinău Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants' action challenging the Chişinău Municipal Council's refusal to authorise the rally.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal found that the Chişinău Municipal Council had lawfully rejected Hyde Park's application to hold a rally.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal considered that since other events were scheduled to take place in the Stefan cel Mare Park on 14 October 2005, such as exhibitions, sports events, concerts and other demonstrations, Hyde Park's rally might hinder those events.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal considered that Hyde Park's rally might endanger public order.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal noted that the application to the Chişinău Municipal Council had been signed by the president of Hyde Park.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal noted that there was no evidence in the case file that the council of Hyde Park had approved the application to hold the rally.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Hyde Park appealed against the Chişinău Court of Appeal's judgment of 2 December 2005.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Hyde Park argued on appeal that the Chişinău Court of Appeal's judgment breached its members' right to freedom of assembly as guaranteed by Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Hyde Park argued on appeal that the Chişinău Court of Appeal's judgment was contrary to the provisions of the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Hyde Park argued on appeal that there was no evidence that the rally would endanger public order.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 3 May 2006, the Supreme Court of Justice dismissed Hyde Park's (the first applicant's) appeal on points of law against the Chişinău Court of Appeal's judgment.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice reiterated that authorising Hyde Park's rally at the same time as other cultural and sports demonstrations in the Stefan cel Mare Park ran the risk of resulting in violent clashes and thus endangered public order.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Section 6(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be conducted peacefully, without any sort of weapons, and shall ensure the protection of participants and the environment, without impeding the normal use of public highways, road traffic and the operation of economic undertakings and without degenerating into acts of violence capable of endangering the public order and the physical integrity and life of persons or their property.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Section 7 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be suspended in the following circumstances: denial and defamation of the State and of the people; incitement to war or aggression and incitement to hatred on ethnic, racial or religious grounds; incitement to discrimination, territorial separatism or public violence; acts that undermine the constitutional order.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Section 8(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies may be conducted in squares, streets, parks and other public places in cities, towns and villages, and also in public buildings.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Section 8(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct an assembly in the buildings of the public authorities, the local authorities, prosecutors' offices, the courts or companies with armed security.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Section 8(3)(a) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct assemblies within fifty metres of the parliament building, the residence of the president of Moldova, the seat of the government, the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Section 8(3)(b) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct assemblies within twenty-five metres of the buildings of the central administrative authority, the local public authorities, courts, prosecutors' offices, police stations, prisons and social rehabilitation institutions, military installations, railway stations, airports, hospitals, companies which use dangerous equipment and machines, and diplomatic institutions.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Section 8(4) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that free access to the premises of the institutions listed in Section 8(3) shall be guaranteed.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Section 8(5) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local public authorities may, if the organisers agree, establish places or buildings for permanent assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Section 11(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that not later than fifteen days prior to the date of the assembly, the organiser shall submit a notification to the Municipal Council, a specimen of which is set out in the annex which forms an integral part of the Act.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate: the name of the organiser and the aim of the assembly; the date, starting time and finishing time of the assembly; the location of the assembly and the access and return routes; the manner in which the assembly is to take place; the approximate number of participants; the persons who are to ensure and answer for the sound conduct of the assembly; and the services the organiser asks the Municipal Council to provide.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Section 11(3) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that if the situation so requires, the Municipal Council may alter certain aspects of the prior notification with the agreement of the organiser of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Section 12(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall be examined by the local government of the town or village at the latest five days before the date of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Section 12(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that when the prior notification is considered at an ordinary or extraordinary meeting of the Municipal Council, the discussion shall deal with the form, timetable, location and other conditions for the conduct of the assembly and the decision taken shall take account of the specific situation.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Section 12(6) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local authorities can reject an application to hold an assembly only if, after having consulted the police, they have obtained convincing evidence that the provisions of Sections 6 and 7 of the Assemblies Act will be breached with serious consequences for society.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Section 14(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that a decision rejecting the application for holding an assembly shall be reasoned and presented in writing, and shall contain reasons for refusing to issue the authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Section 15(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the organiser of the assembly can challenge in the administrative courts the refusal of the local government.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F032", "F033", "F034", "F056"], "interference": ["F033", "F035", "F036", "F037"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F033", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F044", "F054", "F056", "F057", "F064", "F067", "F069", "F070"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F032", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F044", "F046", "F047", "F054", "F055", "F056", "F057", "F069"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F032", "F034"], "interference": ["F035"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F033", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F044", "F054", "F069"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F032", "F033", "F034", "F036", "F044", "F054", "F056", "F057", "F069"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F032", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F044", "F054", "F056", "F057", "F069"]}} {"case_name": "case_314", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "At the time of the events giving rise to the application, Hyde Park (the first applicant) was registered with the Moldovan Ministry of Justice as a non-governmental organisation.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) lobbied, among other things, for freedom of expression and the right to peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "In 2007, the members of Hyde Park (the first applicant) decided to discontinue the organisation's registration.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The members of Hyde Park (the first applicant) decided to discontinue the organisation's registration on grounds of alleged pressure and intimidation by the State.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The members of Hyde Park (the first applicant) complained of the refusal of the Moldovan Ministry of Justice to register amendments to the organisation's articles of association.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The members of Hyde Park (the first applicant) complained of the repeated freezing of the organisation's bank account.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The members of Hyde Park (the first applicant) complained of the arbitrary arrest of its members.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The members of Hyde Park (the first applicant) complained of attempts to shut down its newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Several of the leaders of Hyde Park (the first applicant) requested political asylum in western countries.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "It was decided that Hyde Park (the first applicant) would continue its activity under the same name but without registering it with the State authorities.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "It was decided that the new unincorporated association of Hyde Park would become the former registered organisation's successor.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) was removed from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations on 2 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "After removal from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations on 2 June 2008, Hyde Park's activities continued as before on the basis of its new articles of association.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) continued editing its newspaper after removal from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) continued editing its Internet page after removal from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) continued staging protests and demonstrations after removal from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Gheorghe Lupuşoru is a member and supporter of Hyde Park (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Anatol Hristea-Stan is a member and supporter of Hyde Park (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Mariana Gălescu is a member and supporter of Hyde Park (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Alina Didilică is a member and supporter of Hyde Park (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Oleg Brega is a member and supporter of Hyde Park (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Gheorghe Lupuşoru was born in 1969 and lives in Chişinău.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Anatol Hristea-Stan was born in 1953 and lives in Chişinău.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Mariana Gălescu was born in 1982 and lives in Chişinău.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Alina Didilică was born in 1978 and lives in Cazangic.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Oleg Brega was born in 1973 and lives in Pepeni.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 10 February 2006, Hyde Park (the first applicant) applied to the Chişinău Municipal Council for authorisation to hold a peaceful demonstration in front of the Parliament building on 25 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The peaceful demonstration for which Hyde Park (the first applicant) sought authorisation was intended to protest against the 'non-transparent' manner of organising the Eurovision song contest in Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 21 February 2006, the Chişinău Municipal Council rejected Hyde Park's (the first applicant's) application to hold a demonstration in front of the Parliament building on 25 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Chişinău Municipal Council rejected Hyde Park's (the first applicant's) application on the ground that the Parliament was not responsible for organising the Eurovision song contest.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Chişinău Municipal Council rejected Hyde Park's (the first applicant's) application on the ground that the Eurovision song contest had taken place in Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Chişinău Municipal Council rejected Hyde Park's (the first applicant's) application on the ground that the protest was groundless because it concerned past events.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 22 February 2006, Hyde Park (the first applicant) challenged the Chişinău Municipal Council's refusal to authorise the demonstration in court.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) argued, among other things, that the Chişinău Municipal Council's refusal was unlawful and contrary to Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) asked that the case challenging the Chişinău Municipal Council's refusal be examined urgently.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "During the court proceedings, the Chişinău Municipal Council relied on two new reasons for rejecting Hyde Park's (the first applicant's) application to hold a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "During the court proceedings, the Chişinău Municipal Council argued that the members of Hyde Park (the first applicant) had not participated in the Eurovision song contest.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "During the court proceedings, the Chişinău Municipal Council argued that the problem concerning the Eurovision song contest had already been discussed in Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 24 February 2006, the Chişinău Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants' action challenging the Chişinău Municipal Council's refusal to authorise the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal found that the Chişinău Municipal Council had lawfully rejected Hyde Park's (the first applicant's) application to hold a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal upheld all the reasons relied upon by the Chişinău Municipal Council for rejecting Hyde Park's (the first applicant's) application.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal gave a new reason in favour of the Chişinău Municipal Council's decision not to authorise the demonstration, namely that Hyde Park (the first applicant) had failed to correctly indicate the aim of its protest in its request for authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "In its request for authorisation, Hyde Park (the first applicant) indicated that the protest was intended to be against the manner in which the Eurovision song contest was organised.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "During the court proceedings, Hyde Park (the first applicant) submitted that its intention was to protest against the non-transparent manner in which the televoting in Moldova had taken place.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) appealed against the Chişinău Court of Appeal's judgment of 24 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) argued in its appeal that the Chişinău Court of Appeal's judgment had breached the right of its members to hold peaceful meetings in public places, contrary to Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) argued in its appeal that the Chişinău Court of Appeal's judgment had breached the right of its members to hold peaceful meetings in public places, contrary to Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 28 June 2006, the Supreme Court of Justice dismissed the applicant's appeal on points of law against the Chişinău Court of Appeal's judgment of 24 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Section 6(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be conducted peacefully, without any sort of weapons, and shall ensure the protection of participants and the environment.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Section 6(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall not impede the normal use of public highways, road traffic and the operation of economic undertakings.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Section 6(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall not degenerate into acts of violence capable of endangering the public order and the physical integrity and life of persons or their property.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Section 7 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be suspended in circumstances including denial and defamation of the State and of the people.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Section 7 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be suspended in circumstances including incitement to war or aggression and incitement to hatred on ethnic, racial or religious grounds.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Section 7 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be suspended in circumstances including incitement to discrimination, territorial separatism or public violence.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Section 7 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be suspended in circumstances including acts that undermine the constitutional order.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Section 8(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies may be conducted in squares, streets, parks and other public places in cities, towns and villages, and also in public buildings.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Section 8(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it is forbidden to conduct an assembly in the buildings of the public authorities, the local authorities, prosecutors' offices, the courts or companies with armed security.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Section 8(3)(a) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it is forbidden to conduct assemblies within fifty metres of the parliament building, the residence of the president of Moldova, the seat of the government, the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Section 8(3)(b) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it is forbidden to conduct assemblies within twenty-five metres of the buildings of the central administrative authority, the local public authorities, courts, prosecutors' offices, police stations, prisons and social rehabilitation institutions, military installations, railway stations, airports, hospitals, companies which use dangerous equipment and machines, and diplomatic institutions.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Section 8(4) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that free access to the premises of the institutions listed in section 8(3) shall be guaranteed.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Section 8(5) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local public authorities may, if the organisers agree, establish places or buildings for permanent assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Section 11(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that not later than fifteen days prior to the date of the assembly, the organiser shall submit a notification to the Municipal Council.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the name of the organiser of the assembly and the aim of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the date, starting time and finishing time of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the location of the assembly and the access and return routes.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the manner in which the assembly is to take place.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the approximate number of participants.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the persons who are to ensure and answer for the sound conduct of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the services the organiser of the assembly asks the Municipal Council to provide.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Section 11(3) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that if the situation so requires, the Municipal Council may alter certain aspects of the prior notification with the agreement of the organiser of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Section 12(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall be examined by the local government of the town or village at the latest five days before the date of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Section 12(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that when the prior notification is considered at an ordinary or extraordinary meeting of the Municipal Council, the discussion shall deal with the form, timetable, location and other conditions for the conduct of the assembly, and the decision taken shall take account of the specific situation.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Section 12(6) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local authorities can reject an application to hold an assembly only if, after having consulted the police, they have obtained convincing evidence that the provisions of sections 6 and 7 of the Assemblies Act will be breached with serious consequences for society.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Section 14(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that a decision rejecting the application for holding an assembly shall be reasoned and presented in writing, and shall contain reasons for refusing to issue the authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Section 15(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the organiser of the assembly can challenge the refusal in the administrative courts.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F027", "F028", "F029", "F049"], "interference": ["F029", "F030", "F031", "F032"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F073", "F074"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F039", "F040", "F042", "F073", "F074"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F027", "F028"], "interference": ["F029"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F030", "F032", "F073"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F028", "F029", "F030", "F032", "F042", "F073"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F032", "F042", "F073"]}} {"case_name": "case_315", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "At the time of the events giving rise to the application, Hyde Park (the first applicant) was registered with the Moldovan Ministry of Justice as a non-governmental organisation.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) lobbied, inter alia, for freedom of expression and the right to peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "In 2007, Hyde Park's members decided to discontinue the organisation's registration with the Moldovan Ministry of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Hyde Park's members decided to discontinue the organisation's registration on grounds of alleged pressure and intimidation by the State.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of the refusal of the Moldovan Ministry of Justice to register amendments to Hyde Park's articles of association.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of the repeated freezing of Hyde Park's bank account.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of the arbitrary arrest of Hyde Park's members.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of attempts to shut down Hyde Park's newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Several of Hyde Park's leaders requested political asylum in western countries.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "It was decided to continue Hyde Park's activity under the same name but without registering it with the State authorities.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "It was decided that the new unincorporated association would become the former registered organisation's successor.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Hyde Park was removed from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations on 2 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "After removal from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations on 2 June 2008, Hyde Park's activities continued as before on the basis of its new articles of association.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Hyde Park continued editing its newspaper after removal from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Hyde Park continued maintaining its Internet page after removal from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Hyde Park continued staging protests and demonstrations after removal from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Oleg Brega is a member and supporter of Hyde Park (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Anatolie Juraveli is a member and supporter of Hyde Park (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Roman Cotelea is a member and supporter of Hyde Park (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Mariana Galescu is a member and supporter of Hyde Park (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Radu Vasilascu is a member and supporter of Hyde Park (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Vitalie Dragan is a member and supporter of Hyde Park (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Angela Lungu is a member and supporter of Hyde Park (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Anatol Hristea-Stan is a member and supporter of Hyde Park (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Oleg Brega was born in 1973.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Anatolie Juraveli was born in 1988.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "Roman Cotelea was born in 1987.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "Mariana Galescu was born in 1982.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Radu Vasilascu was born in 1983.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Vitalie Dragan was born in 1967.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Angela Lungu was born in 1988.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Anatol Hristea-Stan was born in 1953.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "Oleg Brega, Anatolie Juraveli, Roman Cotelea, Mariana Galescu, Radu Vasilascu, Vitalie Dragan, Angela Lungu and Anatol Hristea-Stan live in Pepeni, Durlesti and Chişinău.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 30 June 2006, Hyde Park (the first applicant) applied to the Chişinău Municipal Council for authorisation to hold a peaceful demonstration at the junction of Banulescu-Bodoni and Stefan cel Mare streets, not far from the Government building.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) requested authorisation to hold the demonstration between 1 and 31 August 2006.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The purpose of the demonstration was to protest against the refusal of the Moldovan Ministry of Culture to install a monument dedicated to the poet Liviu Rebreanu.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The monument dedicated to the poet Liviu Rebreanu had been donated by the Government of Romania.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 18 July 2006, the Chişinău Municipal Council authorised the holding of a demonstration in writing, but only on 1 August 2006.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Chişinău Municipal Council stated that it considered that one day of protest was sufficient in order to bring Hyde Park's concerns to the Government's attention.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 25 July 2006, Hyde Park challenged the Chişinău Municipal Council's decision of 18 July 2006 in court.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 29 August 2006, the Chişinău Court of Appeal found that the Chişinău Municipality's refusal to authorise the demonstration for the full requested period had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 29 August 2006, the Chişinău Court of Appeal quashed the Chişinău Municipal Council's decision of 18 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 29 August 2006, the Chişinău Court of Appeal ordered the Chişinău Municipal Council to authorise Hyde Park (the first applicant) to hold a demonstration in front of the Government building between 29 and 31 August 2006.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal ordered that its judgment of 29 August 2006 should come into force immediately.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 30 August 2006, the applicants requested authorisation from the Chişinău Municipality on the basis of the judgment of the Chişinău Court of Appeal of 29 August 2006.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Chişinău Municipality refused to comply with the judgment of 29 August 2006 on the ground that it was not final.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 30 August 2006 at 5 p.m., the applicants started their demonstration at the place indicated in the judgment of the Chişinău Court of Appeal of 29 August 2006.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 30 August 2006 at 5.15 p.m., the applicants were approached by a group of police officers who asked whether they had authorisation for the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicants showed the police officers the judgment of the Chişinău Court of Appeal of 29 August 2006 as authorisation for the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "A video was made by the police on 30 August 2006 and forms part of the domestic case file.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "In the police video, a police officer can be seen attempting to convince Mr Oleg Brega to stop the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In the police video, Mr Oleg Brega refuses to stop the demonstration and argues that Hyde Park has a court judgment authorising the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Mr Oleg Brega spoke through a megaphone declaring that Moldova is a totalitarian State where there is no freedom of speech.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Mr Oleg Brega declared through a megaphone that Moldova would have to answer for all its illegal behaviour before the Strasbourg Court.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Mr Oleg Brega accused the police and the State authorities of illegal behaviour.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "A person wearing a Special Forces uniform attacked one of the Hyde Park members from behind and violently threw him to the ground.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "After the attack by the person in Special Forces uniform, the other demonstration participants were immediately surrounded by a group of police officers and taken to a police van.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Nobody among the demonstration participants appeared to resist arrest.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "A female voice, apparently one of the demonstration participants, called on somebody not to resist arrest.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "According to the applicants, Mr Anatolie Juraveli was thrown to the ground by Special Forces officers during the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "According to the applicants, a person referred to as Mr D. was thrown to the ground by Special Forces officers during the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "At the police station, police officers took the applicants' belongings including their mobile telephones.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The minutes of arrest indicated, inter alia, that the applicants' belongings had been taken for storage.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The applicants were locked in different cells in groups of three or four persons at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The two female applicants were put in a separate cell at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "According to the applicants, they were not allowed to make any telephone calls while detained at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "According to the applicants, they were not allowed to consult a lawyer while detained at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "According to the applicants, the cells at the police station were small, humid and dirty.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "According to the applicants, the cells at the police station smelled of urine and faeces.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "According to the applicants, the cells at the police station did not have windows.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "According to the applicants, the electric light in the cells at the police station was always on.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "According to the applicants, there were only two wooden benches inside each cell at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The applicants were held in detention for approximately forty hours.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "During the approximately forty hours of detention, the applicants were not provided with any food.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "During detention, the applicants were only provided with water and occasionally taken to a toilet.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Only after the intervention of several human rights non-governmental organisations and after sixteen hours of detention were the applicants' relatives allowed to bring them food.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Government disputed the applicants' description of the conditions of detention at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 1 September 2006 at approximately 10 a.m., the applicants were taken to court.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "At court on 1 September 2006, the applicants' mobile telephones and cameras were returned to them.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "At court on 1 September 2006, the applicants learned about the charges against them for the first time.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The applicants were charged with holding an unauthorised demonstration contrary to Article 174 § 1 of the Moldovan Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The applicants were charged with resisting arrest contrary to Article 174 § 5 of the Moldovan Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The applicants were charged with insulting police officers contrary to Article 174 § 6 of the Moldovan Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "After receiving their belongings on 1 September 2006, the applicants alleged that all the video and audio files concerning the demonstration had been deleted from their mobile telephones by the police.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "During the proceedings on 1 September 2006, Mr Oleg Brega requested the court to order an expert evaluation of his mobile telephone records in order to determine whether the police had deleted files from it.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "During the proceedings on 1 September 2006, Ms Mariana Galescu requested the court to order an expert evaluation of her mobile telephone records in order to determine whether the police had deleted files from it.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The court rejected the request by Mr Oleg Brega and Ms Mariana Galescu for an expert evaluation of their mobile telephone records.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The proceedings on 1 September 2006 were adjourned.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The applicants were released at noon on 1 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 3 October 2006, the Buiucani District Court continued the administrative proceedings against the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "On 3 October 2006, the Buiucani District Court found all applicants except Hyde Park (the first applicant) guilty of holding and participating in an unauthorised demonstration contrary to Article 174 § 1 of the Moldovan Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Buiucani District Court found that after obtaining the favourable judgment from the Chişinău Court of Appeal of 29 August 2006, the applicants should have applied to the Chişinău Municipal Council for authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Buiucani District Court fined each applicant except Mr Oleg Brega 200 Moldovan lei (MDL).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Buiucani District Court fined Mr Oleg Brega, who was the president of Hyde Park at the time, MDL 500.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "All the applicants were acquitted by the Buiucani District Court of the charges concerning the insulting of police officers.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "All the applicants were acquitted by the Buiucani District Court of the charges concerning resisting arrest.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Buiucani District Court acquitted the applicants of the charges of insulting police officers and resisting arrest after viewing a video of the arrest made by the police officers and finding that there was no justification for bringing these accusations.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "All the applicants appealed against the Buiucani District Court's decision of 3 October 2006 in so far as it concerned their participation in an unlawful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "In their appeal, the applicants argued, inter alia, that Hyde Park had applied to the Chişinău Municipal Council for authorisation on 30 August 2006.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "In their appeal, the applicants argued that their request for authorisation on 30 August 2006 had been dismissed on the ground that the judgment of the Chişinău Court of Appeal of 29 August 2006 was not yet in force.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "In their appeal, the applicants repeated their request to have an expert evaluate their mobile telephone records.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "On 26 October 2006, the Chişinău Court of Appeal upheld the applicants' appeal.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "On 26 October 2006, the Chişinău Court of Appeal found that the applicants' demonstration was lawful by virtue of the judgment of the Chişinău Court of Appeal of 29 August 2006.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On 26 October 2006, the applicants were acquitted of the charges relating to their participation in an unlawful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "On 18 September 2006, the applicants lodged a criminal complaint against the police officers who had arrested them.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "In their criminal complaint of 18 September 2006, the applicants complained that they had been abused by the police officers who arrested them.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "In their criminal complaint of 18 September 2006, the applicants complained that they had been illegally detained.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "In their criminal complaint of 18 September 2006, the applicants complained that their right to privacy of correspondence had been violated.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "In their criminal complaint of 18 September 2006, the applicants complained that their right to freedom of assembly had been violated.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "In their criminal complaint of 18 September 2006, the applicants complained that they had suffered inhuman and degrading treatment.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "In their criminal complaint of 18 September 2006, the applicants complained of the refusal to execute court decisions.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Between September 2006 and September 2007, the criminal proceedings initiated at the applicants' request were dismissed and re-opened four times.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "On each occasion between September 2006 and September 2007, the Prosecutor's Office dismissed the applicants' criminal complaint.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "On each occasion between September 2006 and September 2007, the courts or the hierarchically superior prosecutor quashed the Prosecutor's Office's decision to dismiss and ordered a re-examination.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The reasons for the Prosecutor's Office's dismissals included the testimonies of police officers and police witnesses who confirmed the allegations that the applicants had insulted the police and resisted arrest.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Regarding the allegation concerning tampering with the applicants' mobile telephones and deleting files from them, the Prosecutor's Office accepted the testimony of a police officer who confirmed that two mobile telephones had been seized during the applicants' detention but denied the allegations that somebody had tampered with them.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Regarding the video of the event filmed by the police representatives, the Prosecutor's Office argued that it had been lost and that, therefore, it could not be examined.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "On 27 September 2007, the Rascani District Court quashed the last decision dismissing the applicants' complaints and ordered a re-examination.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "After 27 September 2007, the applicants did not hear any more from the Prosecutor's Office about the status of their complaint.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "On 10 January 2008, the applicants wrote to the Prosecutor General's Office to enquire as to the stage reached in their proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The applicants did not receive a reply from the Prosecutor General's Office to their letter of 10 January 2008.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "A copy of the applicants' letter of 10 January 2008 with a stamp of the Prosecutor General's Office on it was annexed to the applicants' observations.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "According to the applicants, it was only from the Government's observations that they learned that their complaint had been dismissed again on 12 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The Government disputed the applicants' submissions concerning the letter of 10 January 2008 which the applicants stated they had sent to the Prosecutor General's Office.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The Government did not dispute the authenticity of the Prosecutor General's stamp on the copy of the applicants' letter of 10 January 2008.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "On 1 November 2006, the Supreme Court of Justice examined the appeal on points of law lodged by the Chişinău Municipal Council against the judgment of the Chişinău Court of Appeal of 29 August 2006.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "On 1 November 2006, the Supreme Court of Justice quashed the judgment of the Chişinău Court of Appeal of 29 August 2006.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "On 1 November 2006, the Supreme Court of Justice dismissed the applicants' action, finding that the Chişinău Municipal Council's decision of 18 July 2006 was lawful.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice ruled that the ruling of the Chişinău Court of Appeal concerning the immediate enforcement of its judgment of 29 August 2006 had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Section 6(1) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be conducted peacefully, without any sort of weapons, and shall ensure the protection of participants and the environment, without impeding the normal use of public highways, road traffic and the operation of economic undertakings and without degenerating into acts of violence capable of endangering the public order and the physical integrity and life of persons or their property.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Section 7 of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be suspended in circumstances including: denial and defamation of the State and of the people; incitement to war or aggression and incitement to hatred on ethnic, racial or religious grounds; incitement to discrimination, territorial separatism or public violence; and acts that undermine the constitutional order.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Section 8(1) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies may be conducted in squares, streets, parks and other public places in cities, towns and villages, and also in public buildings.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Section 8(2) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct an assembly in the buildings of the public authorities, the local authorities, prosecutors' offices, the courts or companies with armed security.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Section 8(3)(a) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct assemblies within fifty metres of the parliament building, the residence of the President of Moldova, the seat of the government, the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Section 8(3)(b) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct assemblies within twenty-five metres of the buildings of the central administrative authority, the local public authorities, courts, prosecutors' offices, police stations, prisons and social rehabilitation institutions, military installations, railway stations, airports, hospitals, companies which use dangerous equipment and machines, and diplomatic institutions.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Section 8(4) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that free access to the premises of the institutions listed in Section 8(3) shall be guaranteed.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Section 8(5) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local public authorities may, if the organisers agree, establish places or buildings for permanent assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Section 11(1) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that not later than fifteen days prior to the date of the assembly, the organiser shall submit a notification to the Municipal Council.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate: the name of the organiser and the aim of the assembly; the date, starting time and finishing time; the location and access and return routes; the manner in which the assembly is to take place; the approximate number of participants; the persons who are to ensure and answer for the sound conduct of the assembly; and the services the organiser asks the Municipal Council to provide.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Section 11(3) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that if the situation so requires, the Municipal Council may alter certain aspects of the prior notification with the agreement of the organiser of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Section 12(1) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall be examined by the local government of the town or village at the latest 5 days before the date of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Section 12(2) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that when the prior notification is considered at an ordinary or extraordinary meeting of the Municipal Council, the discussion shall deal with the form, timetable, location and other conditions for the conduct of the assembly and the decision taken shall take account of the specific situation.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Section 12(6) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local authorities can reject an application to hold an assembly only if after having consulted the police, it has obtained convincing evidence that the provisions of sections 6 and 7 will be breached with serious consequences for society.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Section 14(1) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that a decision rejecting the application for holding an assembly shall be reasoned and presented in writing and shall contain reasons for refusing to issue the authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Section 15(1) of the Moldovan Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the organiser of the assembly can challenge the refusal in the administrative courts.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Article 166(1) of the Moldovan Criminal Code provides that illegal deprivation of liberty, if it is not a kidnapping, shall be punishable with community work of 120-240 hours or imprisonment of up to 2 years.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Article 166(2) of the Moldovan Criminal Code provides that illegal deprivation of liberty committed against two or more persons or by two or more persons shall be punishable with imprisonment of 3 to 8 years.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Article 184(1) of the Moldovan Criminal Code provides that violation of the right to freedom of assembly by way of illegal hindering of a demonstration, rally or action of protest or hindering of persons from taking part in them, when committed by an official, by two or more persons, or accompanied by acts of violence which are not dangerous to life or health, shall be punishable with a fine of four to eight thousand Moldovan lei or with community work of 180-240 hours, or with imprisonment of up to two years.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "Article 174 § 1(2) of the Moldovan Code of Administrative Offences, in force at the material time, provides that the organisation and holding of an assembly without prior notification to the Municipal Council or without authorisation from the Council, or in breach of the conditions concerning the conduct of meetings indicated in the authorisation, shall be punishable by a fine imposed on the organisers (leaders) of the assembly in an amount equal to between MDL 500 and 1,000.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "Article 174 § 1(4) of the Moldovan Code of Administrative Offences, in force at the material time, provides that active participation in an assembly referred to in paragraph 2 of Article 174 § 1 shall be punishable by a fine in an amount between MDL 200 and 300.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "Article 174 § 5 of the Moldovan Code of Administrative Offences, in force at the material time, provides that resisting a police officer in the exercise of his or her duties of ensuring public order and the fight against crime shall be punishable by a fine up to MDL 300 or detention of up to thirty days.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "Article 174 § 6 of the Moldovan Code of Administrative Offences, in force at the material time, provides that insulting police officers in the exercise of their duties shall be punishable by a fine of up to MDL 200 or imprisonment of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "Article 249 of the Moldovan Code of Administrative Offences, in force at the material time, provides that persons who breached the rules concerning the organisation and holding of assemblies, resisted a police officer or behaved offensively towards him, may be detained until the case is examined by a court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Section 12(3) of Moldovan Law No. 1226 on Pre-Trial Detention provides that detainees shall be subjected to body searches and shall not be allowed to have money, precious objects and objects forbidden in places of detention; money shall be transferred into their personal accounts, while precious objects and other objects shall be stored.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "More detailed rules concerning detainees' belongings and their storage by the authorities in charge of detention facilities are contained in the Government's Decision No. 583 of 26 May 2006.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "Section 29, paragraph 373 of Government's Decision No. 583 of 26 May 2006 provides that money, precious objects and forbidden objects must be taken away from detainees.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "Section 29, paragraph 375 of Government's Decision No. 583 of 26 May 2006 provides that during detention the goods mentioned in paragraph 373 shall be transmitted to the accounting department of the detention facility for storage.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "Section 29, paragraph 376 of Government's Decision No. 583 of 26 May 2006 provides that forbidden objects and substances shall be taken away from detainees when they are discovered.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "Section 29, paragraph 377 of Government's Decision No. 583 of 26 May 2006 provides that the right to take away forbidden objects is vested in the representatives of the administration, guardians and other employees of the penitentiary system.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "Section 29, paragraph 378 of Government's Decision No. 583 of 26 May 2006 provides that the taking away of goods shall be carried out by at least two representatives of the administration, in the presence of the detainee whose goods are taken away.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "Section 29, paragraph 379 of Government's Decision No. 583 of 26 May 2006 provides that minutes of the removal of possessions shall be drawn up and copied three times: one copy for the detainee whose goods are removed, another for the accounting department and the third copy for the detainee's personal file.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "Section 29, paragraph 380 of Government's Decision No. 583 of 26 May 2006 provides that the minutes shall contain: the name of the detention facility; date, time and place of the removal of goods; reason for the removal; first name, last name, position and grade of the persons who participated in the removal; first name and last name of the detainee; an exhaustive list of the goods removed indicating denominations, quantity, brand, series, number, registration number; and signatures of all the participants including that of the detainee.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "Section 29, paragraph 381 of Government's Decision No. 583 of 26 May 2006 provides that the minutes shall also contain details relating to the price of the object(s), their material, and any distinguishing features.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "Section 29, paragraph 382 of Government's Decision No. 583 of 26 May 2006 provides that if the detainee is not in agreement with the minutes, he has the right to write his objections in the minutes.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "Section 29, paragraph 383 of Government's Decision No. 583 of 26 May 2006 provides that money and other valuables shall be transmitted urgently (not later than one day) to the accounting department and that removed goods shall be registered in a special register for valuables.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "Section 29, paragraph 384 of Government's Decision No. 583 of 26 May 2006 provides that any money removed shall be transferred to the detainee's bank account.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "According to Annex No. 7 to Government's Decision No. 583 of 26 May 2006, it is forbidden for detained persons to have mobile telephones.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F034", "F035", "F038", "F039", "F130", "F131", "F143"], "interference": ["F034", "F035", "F038", "F039"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F038", "F039", "F130", "F131", "F143", "F144"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F038", "F039", "F130", "F131", "F143"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F034", "F035", "F039"], "interference": ["F034", "F035", "F038", "F039"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F039", "F130", "F131", "F143", "F144"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F038", "F039", "F130", "F131", "F143"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F034", "F035", "F038", "F039", "F130", "F131", "F143"]}} {"case_name": "case_316", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "At the time of the events in question, Hyde Park was registered with the Moldovan Ministry of Justice as a non-governmental organisation.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "Hyde Park lobbied, among other things, for freedom of expression and the right to free assembly.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "In 2007, Hyde Park's members decided to discontinue registration with the Moldovan Ministry of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Hyde Park's members decided to discontinue registration on grounds of alleged pressure and intimidation from the State.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of the refusal of the Moldovan Ministry of Justice to register amendments to Hyde Park's articles of association.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of the repeated freezing of Hyde Park's bank account.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of arbitrary arrest of Hyde Park's members.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of attempts to shut down Hyde Park's newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of other interferences by the State in addition to those specifically listed.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Several of Hyde Park's leaders requested political asylum in western countries.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "It was decided that Hyde Park would continue its activity under the same name but without being registered with the State authorities.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "It was decided that the new unincorporated association would become the former registered organisation's successor.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "After Hyde Park was struck off the Government's list of non-governmental organisations, on 2 June 2008, Hyde Park's activity continued on the basis of new articles of association.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "After 2 June 2008, all of Hyde Park's activities were carried on.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Hyde Park continued editing its newspaper after being struck off the Government's list of non-governmental organisations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Hyde Park continued editing its internet page after being struck off the Government's list of non-governmental organisations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Hyde Park continued staging protests and demonstrations after being struck off the Government's list of non-governmental organisations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "1. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 23 July 2007, Hyde Park applied to the Municipal Council of Chișinău for authorisation to stage a protest on 30 August 2007.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The planned protest of 30 August 2007 was to be staged in front of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Prosecutor General's Office.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The planned protest of 30 August 2007 was against alleged acts of harassment of Hyde Park by the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Prosecutor General's Office.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 20 August 2007, the Municipal Council of Chișinău authorised the protest planned for 30 August 2007.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Municipal Council of Chișinău authorised the protest to be staged in front of the building of the Ministry of Internal Affairs between 7.30 a.m. and 8.15 a.m. on 30 August 2007.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Municipal Council of Chișinău authorised the protest to be staged in front of the Prosecutor General's Office between 8.15 a.m. and 9 a.m. on 30 August 2007.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The authorisation required the protest to be held at a distance of at least fifty metres from the buildings of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Prosecutor General's Office.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 30 August 2007, at 7.30 a.m., the applicants started their protest in front of the Ministry of Internal Affairs.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Immediately after the applicants started their protest on 30 August 2007, a police officer approached them and ordered them to stop the protest.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The police officer ordered the applicants to stop the protest because the Municipal Council of Chișinău's authorisation of 20 August 2007 had been challenged by the Prosecutor General's Office in court on 29 August 2007.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The police officer argued that according to the Law on the Prosecutor's Office, the prosecutor's appeal against an administrative act suspended the latter's action until after a court examined it.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicants refused to comply with the police officer's order to stop the protest on 30 August 2007.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicants argued that the Municipal Council of Chișinău's authorisation of 20 August 2007 was valid and that their protest was peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicants relied on the provisions of the Constitution of Moldova and on the Convention in support of their argument that the protest was lawful.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Shortly after the applicants refused to comply, a police van arrived at the scene of the protest on 30 August 2007.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "Mr Ghenadie Brega was arrested on 30 August 2007 and taken to a police station where he was questioned.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "Mr Oleg Brega was arrested on 30 August 2007 and taken to a police station where he was questioned.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Mr Hristea-Stan was arrested on 30 August 2007 and taken to a police station where he was questioned.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Mr Juraveli was arrested on 30 August 2007 and taken to a police station where he was questioned.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "At approximately 9.30 a.m. on 30 August 2007, Mr Ghenadie Brega, Mr Oleg Brega, Mr Hristea-Stan and Mr Juraveli were released without explanation.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicants could not continue their protest on 30 August 2007 because the time indicated in the Municipal Council of Chișinău's authorisation had lapsed.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 30 August 2007, a criminal complaint was lodged against the police officers who carried out the arrests of Mr Ghenadie Brega, Mr Oleg Brega, Mr Hristea-Stan and Mr Juraveli.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The criminal complaint against the police officers who carried out the arrests on 30 August 2007 was dismissed by the head of the police station of the Centru District on 19 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The head of the police station of the Centru District dismissed the criminal complaint on the ground that the Municipal Council of Chișinău's authorisation of 20 August 2007 contained numerous flaws, including a failure to indicate the exact place of the protest.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The head of the police station of the Centru District dismissed the criminal complaint on the ground that the Municipal Council of Chișinău's authorisation of 20 August 2007 failed to indicate the number of participants.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Prosecutor General's Office's appeal against the Municipal Council of Chișinău's authorisation of 20 August 2007 appears never to have been examined by the courts.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "2. The demonstration of 30 August 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 30 August 2007, Mr Juraveli, the vice-president of Hyde Park, applied to the Municipal Council of Chișinău for an authorisation to stage a protest in front of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Prosecutor General's Office between 4 and 11 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The planned protest between 4 and 11 September 2007 was against the allegedly abusive suppression of Hyde Park's peaceful protest of 30 August 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In the application for authorisation for the protest between 4 and 11 September 2007, Mr Juraveli indicated that ten persons were to participate in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In the application for authorisation for the protest between 4 and 11 September 2007, Mr Juraveli gave his own name as one of those responsible for the conduct of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "In the application for authorisation for the protest between 4 and 11 September 2007, Mr Juraveli gave the name of Mr Oleg Brega as one of those responsible for the conduct of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In the application for authorisation for the protest between 4 and 11 September 2007, Mr Juraveli gave the name of Mr Hristea-Stan as one of those responsible for the conduct of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Municipal Council of Chișinău did not adopt a decision in respect of Mr Juraveli's application of 30 August 2007 before the first date of the planned demonstration, 4 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "At 9 a.m. on 4 September 2007, the applicants started their protest in front of the Ministry of Internal Affairs.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "At 9.25 a.m. on 4 September 2007, Mr Ghenadie Brega was arrested on the ground that the demonstration had not been authorised.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "At 9.25 a.m. on 4 September 2007, Mr Oleg Brega was arrested on the ground that the demonstration had not been authorised.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "At 9.25 a.m. on 4 September 2007, a Hyde Park member who is not an applicant in the present case was arrested on the ground that the demonstration had not been authorised.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Mr Ghenadie Brega, Mr Oleg Brega and the non-applicant Hyde Park member were taken to a police station on 4 September 2007 where they were body searched.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Mr Ghenadie Brega, Mr Oleg Brega and the non-applicant Hyde Park member were kept at the police station for approximately five hours on 4 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "According to the applicants, the police examined and made copies of the detained persons' documents, including personal letters, on 4 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Two of the persons detained on 4 September 2007 were placed in cages and later in cells at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The persons detained on 4 September 2007 were later taken to the Centru District Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Since the hearing at the Centru District Court was adjourned, the persons detained on 4 September 2007 were released at 3 p.m. that day.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 21 September 2007, the Centru District Court examined the charges against the applicants arising from the demonstration of 4 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicants argued before the Centru District Court that since the Municipal Council of Chișinău had failed to examine their application for authorisation before the date of the demonstration, they had the right to hold the demonstration in accordance with section 12(5) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The applicants submitted to the Centru District Court that they had been told by a representative of the local authorities that the Municipal Council of Chișinău did not have time to deal with their request and that they could hold their protest as planned.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Centru District Court dismissed the applicants' submissions regarding the demonstration of 4 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Centru District Court found that the applicants had breached section 11(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 by failing to submit the application within fifteen days in advance of the planned assembly.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "According to the Centru District Court, the protest should have been held on 14 September 2007 at the earliest.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Centru District Court found Mr Ghenadie Brega guilty of organising an unauthorised demonstration and fined him 800 Moldovan lei (approximately 48 euros).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Centru District Court found Mr Oleg Brega guilty of organising an unauthorised demonstration and fined him 800 Moldovan lei (approximately 48 euros).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Another Hyde Park member who is not an applicant in the present case was fined 200 Moldovan lei by the Centru District Court in connection with the demonstration of 4 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The applicants appealed against the Centru District Court's judgment regarding the demonstration of 4 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The applicants' appeal was dismissed by the Chișinău Court of Appeal on the same grounds on 23 October 2007.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 4 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 7 September 2007, the Municipal Council of Chișinău examined Mr Juraveli's application of 30 August 2007 for authorisation to stage a protest.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 10 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 7 September 2007, the Municipal Council of Chișinău issued an authorisation to Mr Juraveli to organise and stage a protest in front of the buildings of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Prosecutor General's Office between 8 and 11 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 10 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "In the morning of 10 September 2007, several members of Hyde Park started to protest in front of the buildings of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Prosecutor General's Office.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 10 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Several minutes after the Hyde Park members began protesting on 10 September 2007, the police arrived and arrested Mr Juraveli on the ground that the authorisation did not contain the names of all the persons involved in the protest.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 10 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Several minutes after the Hyde Park members began protesting on 10 September 2007, the police arrived and arrested Mr Oleg Brega on the ground that the authorisation did not contain the names of all the persons involved in the protest.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 10 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Several minutes after the Hyde Park members began protesting on 10 September 2007, the police arrived and arrested Mr Hristea-Stan on the ground that the authorisation did not contain the names of all the persons involved in the protest.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 10 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Government maintained that Mr Juraveli, Mr Oleg Brega and Mr Hristea-Stan had been detained on 10 September 2007 for breach of the peace and for having shouted insults about the Minister for Internal Affairs.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 10 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "At the police station on 10 September 2007, Mr Juraveli, Mr Oleg Brega and Mr Hristea-Stan were questioned and searched.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 10 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "Mr Juraveli, Mr Oleg Brega and Mr Hristea-Stan were released after five hours of detention on 10 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 10 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The applicants maintained that, while detained on 10 September 2007, they were not allowed to make any telephone calls or to contact a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 10 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The police filed administrative proceedings against Mr Juraveli, Mr Oleg Brega and Mr Hristea-Stan following their arrest on 10 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 10 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "On 21 September 2007, the Centru District Court decided to discontinue the administrative proceedings filed against Mr Juraveli, Mr Oleg Brega and Mr Hristea-Stan in connection with the events of 10 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "3. The demonstration of 10 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On 5 September 2007, Mr Oleg Brega wrote to the Prosecutor General making a criminal complaint in respect of the actions of the police at the demonstration of 30 August 2007.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "4. Letters to the Prosecutor General"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 5 September 2007, Mr Oleg Brega wrote to the Prosecutor General making a criminal complaint in respect of the actions of the police at the demonstration of 4 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "4. Letters to the Prosecutor General"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "A further letter to the Prosecutor General regarding the criminal complaint about police actions at the demonstrations of 30 August and 4 September 2007 was sent on 10 January 2008.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "4. Letters to the Prosecutor General"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The applicants maintain that they did not receive an official response to either letter sent to the Prosecutor General on 5 September 2007 and 10 January 2008.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASES", "4. Letters to the Prosecutor General"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Article 32(1) of the Constitution of the Republic of Moldova guarantees each citizen freedom of thought, of opinion, and freedom of expression in public through words, images or through other available means.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Article 32(2) of the Constitution of the Republic of Moldova provides that freedom of expression shall not harm the honour or dignity of others or the right of others to have their own opinion.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Article 32(3) of the Constitution of the Republic of Moldova provides that the law prohibits and punishes the contestation and defamation of the State and the nation, calls to war and aggression, national, racial or religious hatred, incitement to discrimination, territorial separatism, or public violence, as well as other expression which endangers the constitutional order.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Article 40 of the Constitution of the Republic of Moldova provides that all meetings, demonstrations, rallies, processions or any other assemblies are free, and they may be organised and take place only peacefully and without the use of weapons.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Section 6(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be conducted peacefully, without any sort of weapons, and shall ensure the protection of participants and the environment, without impeding the normal use of public highways, road traffic and the operation of economic undertakings and without degenerating into acts of violence capable of endangering the public order and the physical integrity and life of persons or their property.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Section 7 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be suspended in circumstances including denial and defamation of the State and of the people, incitement to war or aggression, incitement to hatred on ethnic, racial or religious grounds, incitement to discrimination, territorial separatism or public violence, and acts that undermine the constitutional order.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Section 8(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies may be conducted in squares, streets, parks and other public places in cities, towns and villages, and also in public buildings.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Section 8(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct an assembly in the buildings of the public authorities, the local authorities, prosecutors' offices, the courts or companies with armed security.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Section 8(3)(a) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct assemblies within fifty metres of the parliament building, the residence of the President of Moldova, the seat of the government, the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Section 8(3)(b) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct assemblies within twenty-five metres of the buildings of the central administrative authority, the local public authorities, courts, prosecutors' offices, police stations, prisons and social rehabilitation institutions, military installations, railway stations, airports, hospitals, companies which use dangerous equipment and machines, and diplomatic institutions.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Section 8(4) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that free access to the premises of the institutions listed in section 8(3) shall be guaranteed.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Section 8(5) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local public authorities may, if the organisers agree, establish places or buildings for permanent assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "Section 11(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that not later than fifteen days prior to the date of the assembly, the organiser shall submit a notification to the Municipal Council.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate the name of the organiser and the aim of the assembly, the date, starting time and finishing time, the location and access and return routes, the manner in which the assembly is to take place, the approximate number of participants, the persons responsible for the sound conduct of the assembly, and the services the organiser asks the Municipal Council to provide.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "Section 11(3) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that if the situation so requires, the Municipal Council may alter certain aspects of the prior notification with the agreement of the organiser of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "Section 12(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall be examined by the local government of the town or village at the latest five days before the date of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "Section 12(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that when the prior notification is considered at an ordinary or extraordinary meeting of the Municipal Council, the discussion shall deal with the form, timetable, location and other conditions for the conduct of the assembly and the decision taken shall take account of the specific situation.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Section 12(6) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local authorities can reject an application to hold an assembly only if, after having consulted the police, it has obtained convincing evidence that the provisions of sections 6 and 7 of the Assemblies Act will be breached with serious consequences for society.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Section 14(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that a decision rejecting the application for holding an assembly shall be reasoned and presented in writing, and shall contain reasons for refusing to issue the authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Section 15(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the organiser of the assembly can challenge the refusal in the administrative courts.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Section 19 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that participants at the assembly are required to respect the Act and other laws referred to therein, to respect the instructions of the organiser of the assembly and decisions of the municipality or police, and to leave the assembly if asked by the organiser, the municipality or the police.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Article 166(1) of the Criminal Code of Moldova provides that illegal deprivation of liberty, if it is not a kidnapping, shall be punishable with community work of 120-240 hours or imprisonment of up to 2 years.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Article 166(2) of the Criminal Code of Moldova provides that illegal deprivation of liberty committed against two or more persons or by two or more persons shall be punishable with imprisonment of 3 to 8 years.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Article 184(1) of the Criminal Code of Moldova provides that violation of the right to freedom of assembly by way of illegal hindering of a demonstration, rally or action of protest or hindering of persons from taking part in them, when committed by an official, by two or more persons, or accompanied by acts of violence which are not dangerous to life or health, shall be punishable with a fine of four to eight thousand Moldovan lei or with community work of 180-240 hours, or with imprisonment of up to two years.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Article 174 § 1(2) of the Code of Administrative Offences, in force at the material time, provided that the organisation and holding of an assembly without prior notification to the Municipal Council or without authorisation from the Council, or in breach of the conditions concerning the conduct of meetings indicated in the authorisation, shall be punishable by a fine on the organisers (leaders) of the assembly in an amount equal to between 500 and 1,000 Moldovan lei.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Article 174 § 1(4) of the Code of Administrative Offences, in force at the material time, provided that active participation in an assembly referred to in paragraph 2 of Article 174 § 1 shall be punishable by a fine in an amount between 200 and 300 Moldovan lei.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Article 174 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences, in force at the material time, provided that resisting a police officer in the exercise of his or her duties of ensuring public order and the fight against crime shall be punishable by a fine up to 300 Moldovan lei or detention of up to thirty days.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Article 174 § 6 of the Code of Administrative Offences, in force at the material time, provided that insulting police officers in the exercise of their duties shall be punishable by a fine of up to 200 Moldovan lei or imprisonment of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Article 14 of the Civil Code of Moldova provides that any person whose rights have been infringed may request full compensation in respect of the damage thus caused.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The relevant provisions of Law no. 1545 (1998) on compensation for damage caused by the illegal acts of the criminal investigation organs, prosecution and courts have been set out in the Court's judgment in Sarban v. Moldova, no. 3456/05, § 54, 4 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "In the case of Belicevecen v. the Ministry of Finance (no. 2ra-1171/07, 4 July 2007), the Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova found that a person could claim damages on the basis of Law no. 1545 (1998) only if he or she had been fully acquitted of all the charges against him or her.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "In the case of Belicevecen v. the Ministry of Finance (no. 2ra-1171/07, 4 July 2007), since Mr Belicevecen had been found guilty in respect of one of the charges brought against him, the Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova found he could not claim any damages under Law no. 1545 (1998).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F025", "F030", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F044", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F073", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F077"], "interference": ["F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F052", "F053", "F056", "F067", "F068", "F075", "F076", "F077", "F080"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F025", "F030", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F045", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F067", "F068", "F073", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F077", "F112"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F020", "F025", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F077"], "interference": ["F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F038", "F052", "F053", "F067", "F068", "F075", "F076", "F077"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F020", "F021", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F038", "F045", "F050", "F052", "F053", "F067", "F068", "F073", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F077", "F112"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F020", "F021", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F038", "F045", "F052", "F053", "F067", "F068", "F073", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F077", "F112"]}} {"case_name": "case_317", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "At the time of the events giving rise to the application, Hyde Park (the first applicant) was registered with the Moldovan Ministry of Justice as a non-governmental organisation.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) lobbied, among other things, for freedom of expression and the right to peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "In 2007, Hyde Park's members decided to discontinue the organisation's registration with the Moldovan Ministry of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Hyde Park's members decided to discontinue the organisation's registration on grounds of alleged pressure and intimidation by the State.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of the refusal of the Moldovan Ministry of Justice to register amendments to Hyde Park's articles of association.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of the repeated freezing of Hyde Park's bank account.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of the arbitrary arrest of Hyde Park's members.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Hyde Park's members complained of attempts to shut down Hyde Park's newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Several of Hyde Park's leaders requested political asylum in western countries.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "It was decided to continue Hyde Park's activity under the same name but without registering it with the State authorities.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "It was decided that the new unincorporated association would become the former registered organisation Hyde Park's successor.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Hyde Park was removed from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations on 2 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "After removal from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations on 2 June 2008, Hyde Park's activities continued as before on the basis of its new articles of association.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Hyde Park continued editing its newspaper after removal from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Hyde Park continued editing its Internet page after removal from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Hyde Park continued staging protests and demonstrations after removal from the Government's list of non-governmental organisations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Gheorghe Lupuşoru is a member and supporter of Hyde Park.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Anatol Hristea-Stan is a member and supporter of Hyde Park.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Mariana Gălescu is a member and supporter of Hyde Park.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Alina Didilică is a member and supporter of Hyde Park.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Oleg Brega is a member and supporter of Hyde Park.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Gheorghe Lupuşoru was born in 1969 and lives in Chişinău.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Anatol Hristea-Stan was born in 1953 and lives in Chişinău.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Mariana Gălescu was born in 1982 and lives in Chişinău.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Alina Didilică was born in 1978 and lives in Cazangic.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Oleg Brega was born in 1973 and lives in Pepeni.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 6 December 2004, Hyde Park applied to the Chişinău Municipal Council for authorisation to hold a peaceful meeting in front of the Romanian Embassy on 5 January 2005.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The purpose of the planned meeting on 5 January 2005 was to protest against the policy of Romania in respect of Moldovan students.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The application to the Chişinău Municipal Council was signed by Hyde Park's president.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Hyde Park's application to the Chişinău Municipal Council stated that members and supporters of Hyde Park who study in Romania or who have relatives studying there were not content with the manner in which they were treated by the Romanian authorities.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Hyde Park's application to the Chişinău Municipal Council stated that the intended protest would take place in front of the Romanian Embassy, between 11 a.m. and 2 p.m., in front of the entrance on Bucharest street.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Hyde Park's application to the Chişinău Municipal Council stated that Hyde Park undertook to respect public order and not to block traffic.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 30 December 2004, the Chişinău Municipal Council rejected Hyde Park's application to hold a protest meeting on 5 January 2005.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Chişinău Municipal Council rejected Hyde Park's application on the ground that the municipal police considered the applicants' protest to be unfounded and unwelcome.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Chişinău Municipal Council's rejection stated that it was the Government of Romania which financed the studies of Moldovan students in Romania and therefore the Romanian authorities were competent to take a decision in respect of the applicants' application of 6 December 2004.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 3 January 2005, Hyde Park (the first applicant) challenged the Chişinău Municipal Council's refusal in court.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) argued in court that the Chişinău Municipal Council's refusal was unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) argued that the Chişinău Municipal Council had protracted the examination of their application until the last day of the year so as not to leave it enough time to challenge the refusal in the courts.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) asked that the case be examined urgently.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) explained that many persons who had expressed their wish to participate in the demonstration were students in Romania and were at home, in Chişinău, only for the winter break.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 21 February 2005, the Chişinău Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants' action against the Chişinău Municipal Council's refusal to authorise the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal found on 21 February 2005 that the Chişinău Municipal Council had acted within its competence in refusing the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal observed that the police, the Prosecutor's Office and the Secret Service had obtained information that the applicants intended to breach the provisions of sections 6 and 7 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Hyde Park appealed against the Chişinău Court of Appeal's judgment of 21 February 2005.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Hyde Park argued on appeal that the Chişinău Court of Appeal's judgment of 21 February 2005 had breached the right of Hyde Park's members to hold peaceful meetings in public places.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Hyde Park argued on appeal that no evidence had been presented to support the view that the holding of the demonstration would have given rise to an infringement of sections 6 and 7 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 8 June 2005, the Supreme Court of Justice upheld Hyde Park's appeal against the Chişinău Court of Appeal's judgment of 21 February 2005.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 8 June 2005, the Supreme Court of Justice quashed the Chişinău Court of Appeal's judgment of 21 February 2005.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 8 June 2005, the Supreme Court of Justice ordered a re-examination of the case concerning Hyde Park's application to hold a demonstration in front of the Romanian Embassy.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice found on 8 June 2005 that there was no evidence that the applicants intended to breach sections 6 and 7 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 6 October 2005, the Chişinău Court of Appeal again dismissed the applicants' action concerning the refusal to authorise the demonstration in front of the Romanian Embassy.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal dismissed the action on 6 October 2005 on the basis that the holding of a protest meeting in front of the Romanian Embassy could have prejudiced the image of the Moldovan State and of the Moldovan people.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal found on 6 October 2005 that the decision to hold a protest meeting had not been adopted by the council of Hyde Park, as required by Hyde Park's statutes.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Chişinău Court of Appeal found on 6 October 2005 that Hyde Park's statutes did not contain, in its list of activities, provisions sanctioning actions such as holding protest meetings.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Hyde Park (the first applicant) appealed against the Chişinău Court of Appeal's judgment of 6 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 14 December 2005, the Supreme Court of Justice dismissed the applicants' appeal on points of law against the Chişinău Court of Appeal's judgment of 6 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice dismissed the applicants' appeal on 14 December 2005 on the ground that the holding of a demonstration in front of the Romanian Embassy could have prejudiced the image of the Moldovan State and of the Moldovan people.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Section 6(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be conducted peacefully, without any sort of weapons, and shall ensure the protection of participants and the environment, without impeding the normal use of public highways, road traffic and the operation of economic undertakings and without degenerating into acts of violence capable of endangering the public order and the physical integrity and life of persons or their property.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Section 7 of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies shall be suspended in the following circumstances: denial and defamation of the State and of the people; incitement to war or aggression and incitement to hatred on ethnic, racial or religious grounds; incitement to discrimination, territorial separatism or public violence; acts that undermine the constitutional order.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Section 8(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that assemblies may be conducted in squares, streets, parks and other public places in cities, towns and villages, and also in public buildings.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Section 8(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct an assembly in the buildings of the public authorities, the local authorities, prosecutors' offices, the courts or companies with armed security.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Section 8(3)(a) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct assemblies within fifty metres of the parliament building, the residence of the President of Moldova, the seat of the government, the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Section 8(3)(b) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that it shall be forbidden to conduct assemblies within twenty-five metres of the buildings of the central administrative authority, the local public authorities, courts, prosecutors' offices, police stations, prisons and social rehabilitation institutions, military installations, railway stations, airports, hospitals, companies which use dangerous equipment and machines, and diplomatic institutions.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Section 8(4) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that free access to the premises of the institutions listed in section 8(3) shall be guaranteed.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Section 8(5) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local public authorities may, if the organisers agree, establish places or buildings for permanent assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Section 11(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that not later than fifteen days prior to the date of the assembly, the organiser shall submit a notification to the Municipal Council, a specimen of which is set out in the annex which forms an integral part of the Act.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall indicate: the name of the organiser and the aim of the assembly; the date, starting time and finishing time; the location and the access and return routes; the manner in which the assembly is to take place; the approximate number of participants; the persons who are to ensure and answer for the sound conduct of the assembly; and the services the organiser asks the Municipal Council to provide.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Section 11(3) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that if the situation so requires, the Municipal Council may alter certain aspects of the prior notification with the agreement of the organiser of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Section 12(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the prior notification shall be examined by the local government of the town or village at the latest 5 days before the date of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Section 12(2) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that when the prior notification is considered at an ordinary or extraordinary meeting of the Municipal Council, the discussion shall deal with the form, timetable, location and other conditions for the conduct of the assembly and the decision taken shall take account of the specific situation.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Section 12(6) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the local authorities can reject an application to hold an assembly only if after having consulted the police, it has obtained convincing evidence that the provisions of sections 6 and 7 will be breached with serious consequences for society.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Section 14(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that a decision rejecting the application for holding an assembly shall be reasoned and presented in writing and shall contain reasons for refusing to issue the authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Section 15(1) of the Assemblies Act of 21 June 1995 provides that the organiser of the assembly can challenge the refusal in the administrative courts.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 22 February 2008, the Parliament of Moldova adopted a new Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The new Assemblies Act adopted on 22 February 2008 provides that no authorisation is needed for the holding of demonstrations with less than fifty participants.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F027", "F028", "F032", "F033", "F058"], "interference": ["F027", "F033", "F034"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F033", "F034", "F035", "F071", "F072"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F028", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F041", "F050", "F051", "F056", "F058", "F059", "F066", "F069", "F071"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F027", "F028", "F032"], "interference": ["F027", "F033"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F034", "F071"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F028", "F032", "F034", "F041", "F050", "F051", "F056", "F069", "F071"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F027", "F028", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F041", "F050", "F051", "F056", "F071"]}} {"case_name": "case_319", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1988.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1989.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1977.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The first applicant lives in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The third applicant lives in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The second applicant lives in Khirdalan.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The youth group Committee for Protection of Rights of Young Political Prisoners (Gənc Siyasi Məhbusların Hüquqlarını Müdafiə Komitəsi) decided to hold a demonstration at around 5.30 p.m. on 22 May 2011 at the Seaside Boulevard in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Committee for Protection of Rights of Young Political Prisoners did not notify their plan to hold a demonstration to the relevant authority, the Baku City Executive Authority.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "According to the applicants, the demonstration on 22 May 2011 was intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the applicants, the demonstration on 22 May 2011 was conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The participants of the demonstration on 22 May 2011 were a group of ten to twelve persons.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The participants of the demonstration on 22 May 2011 were demanding the release of young persons arrested during some previous demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicants attended the demonstration on 22 May 2011 at the Seaside Boulevard in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Shortly after the demonstration on 22 May 2011 had begun, the police started to disperse it.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the applicants, as soon as they noticed the police approaching they attempted to run away and leave the place of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the applicants, police officers followed and caught the applicants after they attempted to run away from the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "All three applicants were arrested by police officers V.I. and R.G. at around 5.30 p.m. on 22 May 2011.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "All three applicants were taken to police station No. 39 of the Sabail District Police Office after their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Police officers V.I. and R.G. submitted a report (raport) to a superior police officer stating that at around 5.30 p.m. at the Seaside Boulevard a group of young persons attempted to hold an unauthorised demonstration by shouting out loud and disturbed people.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Police officers V.I. and R.G. stated in their report that when they wanted to calm down those persons, the persons ignored them.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Police officers V.I. and R.G. stated in their report that they brought the persons to police station No. 39.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the applicants, they were questioned at police station No. 39 of the Sabail District Police Office.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Between 6.15 p.m. and 6.30 p.m. on 22 May 2011, administrative-offence reports (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) were issued by police officer T.R. in respect of all three applicants.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The administrative-offence reports stated that at 5.30 p.m. on 22 May 2011, by deliberately failing to comply with the lawful order of the police, the applicants had committed an administrative offence under Article 310 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "All three applicants refused to sign the respective administrative-offence reports.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The administrative-offence reports contained pre-printed texts declaring that the arrested person was familiarised with the report.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The administrative-offence reports contained pre-printed texts declaring that the rights and obligations under Articles 371, 372, 374, 377, 379 and 410.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Republic of Azerbaijan were explained to the arrested person.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "Subsequently, police officer T.R. prepared administrative-arrest reports (inzibati qaydada tutma haqqında protokol) with respect to the first and second applicants.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the administrative-arrest reports, copies of which were submitted to the Court by the Government, the first applicant had been subjected to administrative arrest at 7 p.m. on 22 May 2011.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the administrative-arrest reports, copies of which were submitted to the Court by the Government, the second applicant had been subjected to administrative arrest at 7 p.m. on 22 May 2011.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The administrative-arrest reports stated that the first applicant had been released on 22 May 2011, without specifying the time of the alleged release.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The administrative-arrest reports stated that the second applicant had been released on 22 May 2011, without specifying the time of the alleged release.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The administrative-arrest reports contained signatures of the first and second applicants.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "All three applicants maintained that they had been kept in police custody overnight following their arrest on 22 May 2011.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "According to the applicants, they were never served with copies of the administrative-offence reports.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to the applicants, they were never served with other documents in their case files.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the applicants, they were not given access to a lawyer after the arrest or while they were kept in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 22 May 2011 and the applicants' \"administrative\" arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 23 May 2011, the day after his arrest, the first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, was brought before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, the hearing before the Sabail District Court began at 12.40 p.m. and was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, members of the public, including human rights defenders and journalists, were not allowed to attend the hearing before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, the Sabail District Court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearing to the public.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, was not represented by any lawyer at the hearing before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, he was not given an opportunity to hire a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, stated before the Sabail District Court that he was not guilty of disobeying a lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The only witness questioned during the court hearing of the first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, before the Sabail District Court was police officer R.G.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Police officer R.G. testified at the hearing of the first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, that at around 5.30 p.m. on 22 May 2011 a group of persons attempted to hold an unauthorised demonstration by shouting out loud and disturbed people.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Police officer R.G. testified that when he and his colleague wanted to calm down those persons, among them the first applicant Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, they disobeyed a lawful police order.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "Police officer R.G. testified that he and his colleague brought the persons to police station No. 39 where administrative-offence reports were issued in their respect.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Sabail District Court found that the first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, had failed to stop participating in the unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Sabail District Court convicted the first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Sabail District Court sentenced the first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, to seven days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, lodged an appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal arguing that his conviction was in violation of his rights because the demonstration in which he had participated had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, complained in his appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal that his arrest had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, complained in his appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal that the hearing before the Sabail District Court had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, requested the Baku Court of Appeal to quash the Sabail District Court's decision.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, was represented before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 31 May 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the first applicant Mr Agasif Ibrahimov's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 31 May 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the Sabail District Court in the case of the first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, stating that its findings had been correct.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal noted that at the Sabail District Court hearing the first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, had refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and had decided to defend himself in person.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "1. The first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 23 May 2011, the day after his arrest, the second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, was brought before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "According to the second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, the hearing before the Sabail District Court began at 12.30 p.m. and was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "According to the second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, members of the public were not allowed to attend the hearing before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "According to the second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, the Sabail District Court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearing to the public.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, was not represented by any lawyer at the hearing before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "According to the second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, he was not given an opportunity to hire a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "According to the transcript of the court hearing, the second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and decided to defend himself in person.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, stated before the Sabail District Court that he was not guilty of disobeying a lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, stated before the Sabail District Court that he had participated in the demonstration as an observer.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The only witness questioned during the court hearing of the second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, before the Sabail District Court was police officer R.G.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The statement that police officer R.G. gave against the second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, was similar to his statement against the first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, at the Sabail District Court hearing.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Sabail District Court found that the second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, had failed to stop participating in the unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Sabail District Court convicted the second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Sabail District Court sentenced the second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, to eight days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, lodged an appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal arguing that his conviction was in violation of his rights because the demonstration in which he had participated had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, complained in his appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal that his arrest had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, complained in his appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal that the hearing before the Sabail District Court had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, requested the Baku Court of Appeal to quash the Sabail District Court's decision.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, was represented before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "On 31 May 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the second applicant Mr Emin Farhadi's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 31 May 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the Sabail District Court in the case of the second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi, stating that its findings had been correct.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "2. The second applicant, Mr Emin Farhadi"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 23 May 2011, the day after his arrest, the third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, was brought before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "According to the third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, the hearing before the Sabail District Court began at 12.30 p.m. and was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "According to the third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, members of the public were not allowed to attend the hearing before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "According to the third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, the Sabail District Court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearing to the public.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, was not represented by any lawyer at the hearing before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "According to the third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, he was not given an opportunity to hire a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer because he believed that such assistance would be of a formalistic nature.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, stated before the Sabail District Court that he was not guilty of disobeying a lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, stated before the Sabail District Court that he and other participants of the demonstration had protested peacefully.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, stated before the Sabail District Court that he and other participants had been holding photos of arrested young persons without uttering any slogans.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, stated before the Sabail District Court that he had run away as soon as he saw the police approaching and had boarded a taxi.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, stated before the Sabail District Court that police officers had stopped the taxi he had boarded and had forced him out.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The only witness questioned during the court hearing of the third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, before the Sabail District Court was police officer R.G.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The statement that police officer R.G. gave against the third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, was similar to his statement against the first applicant, Mr Agasif Ibrahimov, at the Sabail District Court hearing.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Police officer R.G. confirmed at the hearing of the third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, that Mr Jamil Hajiyev had tried to escape by taxi and that the police officers had stopped that taxi.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Sabail District Court found that the third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, had failed to stop participating in the unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Sabail District Court convicted the third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Sabail District Court sentenced the third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, to seven days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, lodged an appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal arguing that his conviction was in violation of his rights because the demonstration in which he had participated had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, complained in his appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal that his arrest had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, complained in his appeal before the Baku Court of Appeal that the hearing before the Sabail District Court had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, requested the Baku Court of Appeal to quash the Sabail District Court's decision.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, was represented before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On 31 May 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the third applicant Mr Jamil Hajiyev's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "On 31 May 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the Sabail District Court in the case of the third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev, stating that its findings had been correct.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants", "3. The third applicant, Mr Jamil Hajiyev"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Article 49 of the 1995 Constitution of Azerbaijan provides that everyone has the right, having notified respective governmental bodies in advance, to assemble with other people peacefully and without arms, to organise meetings, demonstrations, protests and marches, and to stage pickets.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. 1995 Constitution"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Under Article 5 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, advance written notification is required in order to agree upon the place and time of an assembly and upon the route of a march, with the purpose of enabling the relevant local executive authority to take necessary measures.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Under Article 5 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, the notification has to be done in writing five days before the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Under Article 5 § IV of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, no prior written notification was required for spontaneous assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Article 8 §§ IV and V of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides the relevant local executive authority with powers to prohibit a public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Article 8 § VI of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides the relevant local executive authority with powers to stop a public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Article 9 §§ II and VII of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides the relevant local executive authority with powers to restrict or change the place, route and/or time of a public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Article 9 § VI of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides the relevant local executive authority with powers to designate specific areas for public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "At the material time, Article 14 § I(2) of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that police authorities have the power, when necessary, to stop an assembly which has not been notified to the authorities beforehand, save for spontaneous assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "At the material time, Article 14 § I(4) of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that police authorities have the power to apprehend and remove from the place where an event is being held persons who came carrying weapons, rocks, pieces of wood and glass, clubs that may pose a threat to people's life and safety or damage property, explosives, flammables, or radioactive materials.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "At the material time, Article 14 § II(2) of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that police authorities have the power to order the organisers and participants of an assembly to use all available opportunities to stop the assembly and to disperse, in execution of orders specified under Article 8 paragraphs V and VI of that Law.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "At the material time, Article 14 § II(3) of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that police authorities have the power to warn organisers and participants that physical force or exceptional measures will be used against them if the order to stop the assembly and to disperse is not complied with.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "At the material time, Article 14 § II(4) of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that police authorities have the power to use physical force or exceptional measures in order to stop an assembly and disperse participants, in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "At the material time, Article 14 § II(5) of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that police authorities have the power to apprehend persons not complying with the order to stop an assembly and disperse.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "At the material time, Article 14 § VI of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the use of physical force or exceptional measures by police officers in all circumstances must be proportionate to an existing threat.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "At the material time, Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that any breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies, demonstrations, protests, marches and pickets shall be punishable by a reprimand or a fine of seven to thirteen Azerbaijani manats.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "At the material time, Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that deliberate failure by an individual to comply with the lawful order of a police officer or military serviceman carrying out their duties to protect public order shall be punishable by a fine of twenty to twenty-five Azerbaijani manats or, if that sanction is inadequate in the circumstances of the case and taking into account the character of the offender, by administrative detention for a term of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "At the material time, Article 376.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that if it is impossible for the lawyer chosen by the person against whom administrative-offence proceedings are being carried out to attend, a judge shall appoint a lawyer for that person in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "At the material time, Article 376.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that if a person subjected to an administrative arrest has no possibility to hire a lawyer due to his or her financial situation, his or her legal assistance shall be funded by the State, and in this case a lawyer may not refuse to carry out his or her duties.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "At the material time, Article 396.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that an authorised official may use measures including administrative arrest in order to prevent administrative offences, to establish the identity of a person, to draw up an administrative-offence report if this cannot be done at the place of the administrative offence and if the drawing up of a report is important, to ensure the correct and timely examination of administrative-offence cases, and to ensure the implementation of decisions in administrative-offence cases.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "At the material time, Article 398.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that administrative arrest, that is the short-term restriction of an individual's liberty, may be applied in exceptional circumstances when deemed necessary for ensuring the correct and timely examination of an administrative-offence case or for the implementation of a decision in an administrative-offence case, except for instances set out in legislation.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "At the material time, Article 410.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that an individual who is subject to administrative-offence proceedings or a representative of a legal entity shall be given an opportunity to familiarise with the administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "At the material time, Article 410.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that an individual who is subject to administrative-offence proceedings or a representative of a legal entity has the right to a copy of the administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "At the material time, Article 414.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that a report concerning an administrative offence punishable by administrative detention shall be sent to a judge for examination immediately after it has been drawn up.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "At the material time, Article 422.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that cases concerning an administrative offence punishable by administrative detention shall be examined on the day of receipt by the court of an administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "At the material time, Article 422.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that cases against persons subjected to administrative arrest shall be examined at the latest within 48 hours of their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Under Article 368 of the Code of Administrative Offences, a public prosecutor has a right to participate in administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Chapter 28 of the Code of Administrative Offences enumerates the participants of administrative proceedings and their rights and obligations.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Chapter 28 of the Code of Administrative Offences does not mention the prosecution — a police officer, public prosecutor or any other public official representing the prosecution — as a participant of the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 (\"the CAO\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, in document CommDH(2011)33 dated 29 September 2011, noted that his attention was drawn to the wave of arrests of activists and political opponents in connection with protests held in Baku in March and April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "According to information received by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, the protests held in Baku in March and April 2011 were sometimes dispersed with excessive force and the work of journalists was hindered.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe noted that the organisers of protests in Baku in March and April 2011 were denied permission to demonstrate in a central square and other places in the city centre in Baku, and were instead authorised to hold a demonstration in the outskirts of the city.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Several persons were detained on grounds of violating public order in connection with protests held in Baku in March and April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Six opposition activists were sentenced on 25 August 2011 for participating in actions causing disturbance of public order, following trials whose conformity with human rights standards has been called into question.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe criticised the method of curbing the impact of a demonstration by allowing it to take place only at another time and at a less central location, thereby diminishing significantly the visibility of the rally and its message to the general public.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe urged the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure that the right to freedom of peaceful assembly is fully guaranteed in Azerbaijan, in accordance with the Court's case-law.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "A. \"Observations on the human rights situation in Azerbaijan: Freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of peaceful assembly\", by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, CommDH(2011)33, 29 September 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "In the Report CommDH(2013)14 dated 6 August 2013, Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe Nils Muižnieks noted that the issue of limitations imposed on freedom of assembly had regularly been raised by local and international observers in recent years.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "The Report CommDH(2013)14 noted that the most frequent problems encountered included the banning of demonstrations in central and easily accessible locations and the use of force to disperse demonstrations, leading to arrests and in some cases harsh sentences.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Commissioner Nils Muižnieks called on the Azerbaijani authorities to adopt effective measures to prevent the use of force against peaceful protestors by law enforcement officials.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Commissioner Nils Muižnieks reiterated the recommendation of the 2010 Report inviting the Azerbaijani authorities to reform the existing system of internal disciplinary investigations of police ill-treatment and to introduce an independent police complaints body.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Azerbaijan amended its Law on Freedom of Assembly in 2008 following two opinions adopted by the Council of Europe Venice Commission.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Commissioner Nils Muižnieks noted that while the Law on Freedom of Assembly is in line with international standards, undue restrictions of the right to freedom of peaceful assembly are widely reported in practice.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The problems with freedom of assembly in Azerbaijan mainly stem from the interpretation of Article 5 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, which provides for a notification procedure before convening an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "In 2006, the Venice Commission welcomed the confirmation by representatives of the Government that the requirement in the Law on Freedom of Assembly was for notification and not for a prior permission to hold the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "In 2006, the Venice Commission noted that other provisions of the Law on Freedom of Assembly could, as they currently stood, encourage the competent authorities to issue a blanket prohibition as soon as the notification process proves incomplete.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "In 2007, the Venice Commission added that a system of notification is in itself admissible so long as it is only meant to help the authorities cope more easily with the practical problems involved with the holding of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "In 2007, the Venice Commission stressed that it is important that assemblies can be held with a presumption of legality so as to avoid any chilling effect on organisers and participants.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "Commissioner Nils Muižnieks noted that the Azerbaijani authorities confirmed that the legislation does not require permission for rallies, but the authorities appear to have interpreted it as requiring such permission, and a system of authorisation has in practice replaced the system of notification.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Peaceful protesters have been effectively banned from demonstrating in central Baku since 2006, despite advanced notification of the assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "Several requests by the political opposition or civil society to hold demonstrations in Baku were allegedly denied or, when allowed, organisers were obliged to have them in areas very remote from the city centre.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "Commissioner Nils Muižnieks called on the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure that no authorisation is required for the holding of public demonstrations and that the system of notification is applied in accordance with European standards.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "Commissioner Nils Muižnieks welcomed the announced publication by the Azerbaijani authorities of a list of locations where demonstrations will be made possible, and called for these to include adequate locations in the centre of Baku and other cities.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "Commissioner Nils Muižnieks stated that the authorities should seek to facilitate and protect public assemblies at the organisers' preferred location, given the need for tolerance in a democratic society.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "Commissioner Nils Muižnieks expressed concern relating to the reported non-implementation of due process standards in proceedings brought against participants in unauthorised demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "Commissioner Nils Muižnieks stated that participants in peaceful assemblies should not be sanctioned for the mere fact of being present at and actively participating in the demonstration in question, provided they do not do anything illegal, violent or obscene in the course of it.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "Commissioner Nils Muižnieks urged the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure that no disproportionate sanction, which would undermine the fundamental right to peaceful assembly, is imposed.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "Commissioner Nils Muižnieks called on the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure the full respect of fair trial guarantees for protesters.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "B. Report by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013, CommDH(2013)14, 6 August 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report 'Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent' (2013) stated that the Baku municipal authorities have implemented a blanket ban on all opposition demonstrations in the city center since early 2006.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (2013) stated that the Azerbaijani authorities have broken up unsanctioned demonstrations, often with violence, and have arrested and imprisoned peaceful protestors, organizers, and participants.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (2013) stated that the misdemeanor trials of those charged for involvement in unsanctioned protests in Azerbaijan are perfunctory.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (2013) stated that while the constitution of Azerbaijan stipulates that groups may peacefully assemble after simply notifying the relevant government body in advance, in practice authorities require that gatherings obtain a permit issued by local municipalities.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (2013) stated that municipal authorities have effectively banned all forms of peaceful protest from the center of Baku and instead force all demonstrations into designated zones on the outskirts of the city.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (2013) stated that such a blanket ban on freedom of assembly in the central areas of Baku violates Azerbaijan's international obligations to respect freedom of assembly and expression.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (2013) stated that for several years police have dispersed, at times violently, peaceful protests in Baku's center.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (2013) stated that in the days before and during the Eurovision Song Contest held in Baku in May 2012, police broke up several protests in the city's center and briefly detained dozens of peaceful demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (2013) stated that in 2011, when activists inspired by the uprisings in the Middle East and North Africa launched protests in Azerbaijan, the government responded by arresting hundreds of protesters, activists, and journalists.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (2013) stated that several protesters in Azerbaijan in 2011 were convicted of public order offences and imprisoned for up to three years.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (2013) stated that the Azerbaijani authorities regularly use administrative or misdemeanor charges to lock up people for organizing or participating in unsanctioned rallies, then prosecuting and convicting them in perfunctory trials.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS", "C. Report by Human Rights Watch, \"Tightening the Screws: Azerbaijan's Crackdown on Civil Society and Dissent\", 2013"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F013", "F014", "F017", "F049", "F050", "F071", "F072", "F089", "F090", "F096", "F097"], "interference": ["F014", "F017", "F049", "F050", "F071", "F072", "F096", "F097"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F008", "F009", "F024", "F049", "F071", "F096", "F109", "F121", "F122"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F009", "F010", "F011", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F019", "F020", "F023", "F024", "F049", "F051", "F071", "F073", "F089", "F090", "F091", "F092", "F096", "F098", "F121", "F122"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F007", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F013", "F049", "F071", "F096"], "interference": ["F014", "F017", "F049", "F071", "F096"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F008", "F024", "F049", "F071", "F096", "F109", "F121", "F122"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F009", "F010", "F011", "F014", "F015", "F019", "F049", "F051", "F071", "F073", "F096", "F098", "F121", "F122"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F009", "F010", "F011", "F015", "F049", "F051", "F071", "F073", "F096", "F098", "F121", "F122"]}} {"case_name": "case_320", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant is a legal entity registered under Georgian law on 8 November 2010.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "With the exception of the first applicant, the remaining fourteen applicants live in Tbilisi.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The dates of birth of the applicants are indicated in the attached annex to the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The first applicant is a Georgian non-governmental organisation set up to promote and protect the rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) people in Georgia.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "1. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The first applicant planned to organise a peaceful march on 17 May 2012 in the centre of Tbilisi.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "1. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The peaceful march planned by the first applicant was intended to mark the International Day Against Homophobia.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "1. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 8 May 2012, the first applicant gave the Tbilisi City Hall prior notice of its intention to hold a peaceful demonstration on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "1. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 8 May 2012, the first applicant gave the Ministry of the Interior prior notice of its intention to hold a peaceful demonstration on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "1. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The first applicant informed the authorities of the planned route of the march, which would start from the grounds of the Tbilisi Concert Hall and proceed to Orbeliani Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "1. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The first applicant informed the authorities of the approximate number of participants in the planned march.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "1. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "In light of a foreseeable protest from those opposed to the LGBT community in Georgia and the general background of hostility towards sexual minorities, the first applicant specifically requested that the authorities provide sufficient protection from possible violence.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "1. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 14 May 2012, the Tbilisi City Hall acknowledged receipt of the first applicant's request of 8 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "1. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 14 May 2012, the Tbilisi City Hall explained to the first applicant the rights and responsibilities of demonstrators as provided for by the relevant law.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "1. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 15 May 2012, the first applicant organisation was contacted by a senior officer of the Ministry of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "1. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The senior officer of the Ministry of the Interior clarified the details of the planned march of 17 May 2012 with the first applicant organisation.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "1. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The senior officer of the Ministry of the Interior confirmed to the first applicant organisation that police forces would be deployed to ensure that the procession of 17 May 2012 took place peacefully.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "1. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The second to fourteenth applicants submitted written statements describing the exact circumstances surrounding the incident of 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "At around 1 p.m. on 17 May 2012, members of the LGBT community, staff members of Identoba and other LGBT activists, including the second to fourteenth applicants, gathered at the Tbilisi Concert Hall area, totalling approximately thirty people.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Shortly before the beginning of the demonstration on 17 May 2012, members of the Orthodox Parents' Union arrived in the Tbilisi Concert Hall area.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Shortly before the beginning of the demonstration on 17 May 2012, members of the Saint King Vakhtang Gorgasali's Brotherhood arrived in the Tbilisi Concert Hall area.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Journalists were present at the Tbilisi Concert Hall area shortly before the demonstration on 17 May 2012, recording interviews with the LGBT marchers.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Approximately 200 metres from the starting point of the march on 17 May 2012, members of the Orthodox Parents' Union and the Saint King Vakhtang Gorgasali's Brotherhood confronted the LGBT marchers.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "When the LGBT marchers reached Rustaveli Avenue on 17 May 2012, they were met by a hundred or more counter-demonstrators who were particularly aggressive and verbally offensive.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The counter-demonstrators blocked the LGBT marchers' way on Rustaveli Avenue by making a human chain and encircling the marchers, making it impossible for them to pass.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The LGBT marchers were subjected to threats of physical assault and to insults by the counter-demonstrators on Rustaveli Avenue on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The LGBT marchers, feeling threatened on 17 May 2012, immediately telephoned the police to alert them to the danger and request the immediate dispatch of additional police forces.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "While waiting for additional police support on 17 May 2012, the LGBT marchers noticed a few police officers present at the scene on Rustaveli Avenue.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "When the LGBT marchers approached the police officers present at the scene on 17 May 2012 and asked for help, the officers replied that they were not part of the police patrol and it was not their duty to intervene.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "After approximately twenty to thirty minutes of escalating aggression on 17 May 2012, counter-demonstrators grabbed banners from the hands of several LGBT activists and tore them apart.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Counter-demonstrators resorted to physical attack by pushing and punching the LGBT marchers in the front row on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "As a result of the counter-demonstrators' assault on 17 May 2012, the sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili), who was in the front line of the march, was knocked down, beaten and kicked.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Shortly after the assault on the sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili), several police patrol cars arrived at the scene on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "Some law-enforcement officers intervened by stopping the beating of the sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili) on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "Police officers separated the opposing parties on 17 May 2012 by standing between the LGBT marchers and the counter-demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "At the time police officers separated the parties on 17 May 2012, the aggressive and agitated counter-demonstrators were still making particularly vitriolic threats against the marchers.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The third applicant (Mr L. Berianidze), who was standing on the pavement with other LGBT marchers on 17 May 2012, asked the police to take more active measures to protect the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The police responded to the third applicant (Mr L. Berianidze) by forcing him into a patrol car on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The police drove the third applicant (Mr L. Berianidze) to the Old Tbilisi Police Department of the Ministry of the Interior on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The third applicant (Mr L. Berianidze) was detained at the Old Tbilisi Police Department of the Ministry of the Interior for approximately twenty minutes on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The third applicant (Mr L. Berianidze) was given no official explanation for his arrest at the time of his detention on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "As subsequently explained by the Government, the police had sought to distance the third applicant (Mr L. Berianidze) from the scene on 17 May 2012 in order to protect him from the angry counter-demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili), the seventh applicant (Ms G. Dzerkorashvili) and the tenth applicant (Ms M. Kalandadze), all employees of Identoba, were arrested by the police on 17 May 2012 when they moved from the pavement to the road.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The sixth, seventh and tenth applicants (Mr G. Demetrashvili, Ms G. Dzerkorashvili and Ms M. Kalandadze) were forced into police patrol cars and driven around the city for approximately twenty minutes before being returned to Rustaveli Avenue on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "As subsequently explained by the Government, the aim of the short-term retention of the sixth, seventh and tenth applicants on 17 May 2012 was to prevent them from committing an administrative offence of impeding road traffic.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "As subsequently explained by the Government, the aim of the short-term retention of the sixth, seventh and tenth applicants on 17 May 2012 was also to protect them from the counter-demonstrators' assault.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Later on 17 May 2012, the third applicant (Mr L. Berianidze) sought medical help for his injuries.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Later on 17 May 2012, the sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili) sought medical help for his injuries.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The third applicant (Mr L. Berianidze) was found to have a bruised left knee, grazes on his left palm and fingers, a haemorrhagic forearm and a haematoma on the right eyebrow.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili) was found to have a closed head trauma, cerebral contusions, and bruises on the left side of his chest.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 19 May 2012, the fourteenth applicant (Ms M. Tsutskiridze) visited a doctor.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The fourteenth applicant (Ms M. Tsutskiridze) was diagnosed with a contusion of the left wrist.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The clashes between the LGBT marchers and counter-demonstrators on 17 May 2012 were recorded by journalists present at the scene.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The footage of the clashes between the LGBT marchers and counter-demonstrators on 17 May 2012 was broadcast in the evening of 17 May 2012 by a number of national television channels.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The faces of the applicants who had been attacked and the assailing counter-demonstrators were clearly recognisable in the broadcast footage of the clashes of 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Peaceful demonstration of 17 May 2012", "2. Clashes with counter-demonstrators"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 18 May 2012, members of the board of the first applicant organisation filed several complaints with the Ministry of the Interior concerning the violent acts committed during the march of 17 May 2012 by representatives of the Orthodox Parents' Union and the Saint King Vakhtang Gorgasali's Brotherhood.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 18 May 2012, members of the board of the first applicant organisation filed several complaints with the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office concerning the violent acts committed during the march of 17 May 2012 by representatives of the Orthodox Parents' Union and the Saint King Vakhtang Gorgasali's Brotherhood.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The complaints filed on 18 May 2012 were mostly based on the account of the circumstances as described in the thirteen individual applicants' written statements.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 19 May 2012, a criminal investigation was launched into the infliction of light bodily harm on the fourteenth applicant (Ms M. Tsutskiridze) by unidentified persons.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "When questioned as a witness on 19 May 2012, the fourteenth applicant (Ms M. Tsutskiridze) stated that unidentified men had grabbed her poster and hit her with the handle of the poster.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 23 May 2012, the eighth applicant (Ms E. Glakhashvili) was questioned about the fourteenth applicant's (Ms M. Tsutskiridze's) injury to her hand.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 21 June 2012, a forensic medical examination was commissioned by the investigation into the fourteenth applicant's (Ms M. Tsutskiridze's) injuries.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The forensic medical examination commissioned on 21 June 2012 found that the bruising and excoriation the fourteenth applicant (Ms M. Tsutskiridze) had sustained on her wrist represented light bodily injuries.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The fourteenth applicant (Ms M. Tsutskiridze) was not granted victim status within the framework of the criminal investigation opened on 19 May 2012 at that time.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 26 June 2012, the first applicant received a letter from the deputy director of the police patrol department of the Ministry of the Interior in response to the board members' complaints of 18 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The letter of 26 June 2012 from the deputy director of the police patrol department of the Ministry of the Interior stated that there were no signs of illegality in the actions of the police during the demonstration of 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The letter of 26 June 2012 from the deputy director of the police patrol department of the Ministry of the Interior stated that there was no need to launch an investigation against the police for abuse of power.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Two counter-demonstrators had been arrested for transgression under Article 166 of the Code of Administrative Offences (minor breach of public order) in connection with the events of 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The two counter-demonstrators arrested for minor breach of public order under Article 166 of the Code of Administrative Offences were each fined 100 Georgian laris (approximately 45 euros) in connection with the events of 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 3 July 2012, the first applicant and the second to fourteenth applicants filed additional criminal complaints with the Chief Public Prosecutor and the Minister of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 5 July 2012, the first applicant and the second to fourteenth applicants filed additional criminal complaints with the Chief Public Prosecutor and the Minister of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "In their criminal complaints of 3 and 5 July 2012, the applicants specifically requested that a criminal investigation be launched on account of the verbal and physical attacks perpetrated against them by the counter-demonstrators with clear discriminatory intent.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "In their criminal complaints of 3 and 5 July 2012, the applicants specifically requested that a criminal investigation be launched on account of the acts and/or omissions of the police officers who had failed to protect them from the assaults on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "In their criminal complaints of 3 and 5 July 2012, the applicants emphasised that criminal inquiries should be conducted with due regard to Article 53 of the Criminal Code of Georgia, which provided that the existence of homophobic intent was an aggravating circumstance in the commission of a criminal offence.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The criminal complaints of the third, sixth, seventh and tenth applicants focussed on the attacks against them by the counter-demonstrators and the lack of police protection during the incident of 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The third, sixth, seventh and tenth applicants did not request an inquiry into the alleged restriction of their liberty by the police during the incident of 17 May 2012 under Article 147 of the Criminal Code of Georgia.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "By a letter of 17 July 2012, the Ministry of the Interior replied to the first applicant and the second to fourteenth applicants that during the incident of 17 May 2012 the police had called upon both the LGBT marchers and the counter-demonstrators to exercise their right to demonstrate in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Ministry of the Interior's letter of 17 July 2012 reiterated the information concerning the imposition of administrative sanctions on two of the counter-demonstrators, namely their arrest and fine of 100 Georgian laris each under Article 166 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 24 October 2012, a criminal investigation was opened into the alleged beating of the sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili) by unidentified persons on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "On 24 October 2012, the sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili) was interviewed as a witness in the criminal investigation into his alleged beating.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili) stated when interviewed on 24 October 2012 that he had been encircled and insulted by five or six counter-demonstrators on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili) stated when interviewed on 24 October 2012 that the attackers had started kicking and hitting him on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili) stated when interviewed on 24 October 2012 that the ill-treatment on 17 May 2012 lasted for a few minutes until a police officer finally intervened and removed him from the scene.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "On 6 November 2012, a forensic medical expert issued an opinion confirming that the sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili) had sustained a contusion and closed head trauma.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili) was not granted victim status at the time of the criminal investigation opened on 24 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "In September 2014, the two counter-demonstrators who had previously been fined for administrative misconduct in connection with the events of 17 May 2012 were examined as witnesses in relation to the beating of the sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili).", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "In September 2014, the sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili) was questioned again about the incident of 17 May 2012 and stated that he could no longer remember certain circumstances due to the significant lapse of time.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "In September 2014, the sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili) confirmed that he would still be able to recognise the faces of those individuals who had assaulted him on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "According to the latest information available in the case file, the criminal investigation opened on 19 May 2012 into the light bodily injuries sustained by the fourteenth applicant (Ms M. Tsutskiridze) is still pending.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "According to the latest information available in the case file, the criminal investigation opened on 24 October 2012 into the light bodily injuries sustained by the sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili) is still pending.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The sixth applicant (Mr G. Demetrashvili) has never been granted victim status in the criminal investigation into his injuries.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The fourteenth applicant (Ms M. Tsutskiridze) has never been granted victim status in the criminal investigation into her injuries.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "On 27 March 2012, an amendment to Article 53 of the Criminal Code of Georgia was adopted pursuant to which discrimination on the grounds of sexual orientation and gender identity was recognised as a bias motive and an aggravating circumstance in the commission of a criminal offence.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Article 53 § 3(1) of the Criminal Code of Georgia provides that the commission of any offence listed in the Criminal Code on the grounds of any type of discrimination, including that linked to race, skin colour, language, sex, sexual orientation and gender identity, age, religion, political and other views, disabilities, citizenship, national, ethnic or social background, origin, economic status or societal position or place of residence, shall be an aggravating circumstance.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Article 117 of the Criminal Code of Georgia proscribed the offence of intentional infliction of severe physical injuries.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Article 118 of the Criminal Code of Georgia proscribed the offence of intentional infliction of less serious physical injuries.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Article 120 of the Criminal Code of Georgia proscribed the offence of intentional infliction of light physical injuries.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Article 125 of the Criminal Code of Georgia provided for punishment for the offence of battery or other physical assault entailing physical pain of a lower intensity, not amounting to the level of injury associated with the offence of intentional infliction of light physical injuries under Article 120 of the Criminal Code of Georgia.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Article 126 of the Criminal Code of Georgia proscribed the act of regular battery or any other violence entailing the victim's physical or mental suffering of a level not amounting to that associated with the offences of intentional infliction of severe or less serious physical injuries under Articles 117 and 118 of the Criminal Code of Georgia.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Article 147 of the Criminal Code of Georgia made the intentionally abusive restriction of a person's physical liberty by a State agent — 'premeditated false arrest' — a criminally punishable offence.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "Article 151 of the Criminal Code of Georgia provides that making threats of death or damage to health or destroying property is a criminally punishable offence.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "A qualifying condition for the offence under Article 151 of the Criminal Code of Georgia is that the victim, the addressee of the threat, must have perceived the threat as real from his or her subjective standpoint.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "Pursuant to Article 161 of the Criminal Code of Georgia, illicit obstruction, perpetrated with recourse to violence, threat of violence or abuse of official capacity, of the exercise of the right to peaceful demonstration was a criminally punishable offence.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 was adopted by the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe on 31 March 2010 on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "B. Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe to member States on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 provides that member states should ensure effective, prompt and impartial investigations into alleged cases of crimes and other incidents where the sexual orientation or gender identity of the victim is reasonably suspected to have constituted a motive for the perpetrator.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "B. Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe to member States on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 provides that member states should ensure that particular attention is paid to the investigation of crimes and incidents allegedly committed by law enforcement officials or by other persons acting in an official capacity, and that those responsible are effectively brought to justice and, where appropriate, punished in order to avoid impunity.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "B. Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe to member States on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 provides that member states should ensure that when determining sanctions, a bias motive related to sexual orientation or gender identity may be taken into account as an aggravating circumstance.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "B. Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe to member States on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 provides that member states should take appropriate measures to ensure that the right to freedom of expression can be effectively enjoyed without discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity, in accordance with Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "B. Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe to member States on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 provides that member states should take appropriate measures at national, regional and local levels to ensure that the right to freedom of peaceful assembly, as enshrined in Article 11 of the Convention, can be effectively enjoyed without discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "B. Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe to member States on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 provides that member states should ensure that law enforcement authorities take appropriate measures to protect participants in peaceful demonstrations in favour of the human rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender persons from any attempts to unlawfully disrupt or inhibit the effective enjoyment of their right to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "B. Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe to member States on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 provides that public authorities at all levels should be encouraged to publicly condemn, notably in the media, any unlawful interferences with the right of individuals and groups of individuals to exercise their freedom of expression and peaceful assembly, notably when related to the human rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender persons.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "B. Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe to member States on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "A study on Discrimination on Grounds of Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity in Europe was conducted under the auspices of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, with a second edition published in September 2011.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The study on Discrimination on Grounds of Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity in Europe found that in Georgia 84% of respondents expressed negative attitudes towards homosexuality.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "In 2010, before a debate in the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe on a report focusing on LGBT human rights, different religious communities in Georgia collaboratively protested about 'abnormalities, such as homosexuality, bisexuality and other sexual perversions'.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The study on Discrimination on Grounds of Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity in Europe found that in Georgia, NGO research demonstrates that 87% of lesbian, gay and bisexual persons conceal their sexual orientation from their families.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "On 12 September 2014, a report was published on the visit to Georgia by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights from 20 to 25 January 2014.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 12 September 2014 noted that due to prevailing negative attitudes, many Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Intersex (LGBTI) persons in Georgia conceal their sexual orientation or gender identity for fear of harassment and discrimination, including in the workplace and by public institutions.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 12 September 2014 noted that the Public Defender of Georgia had received over 30 complaints in 2013 about attacks against LGBTI persons.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 12 September 2014 noted that ILGA-Europe had collected information on seven hate crimes perpetrated against LGBTI persons during 2013, including various types of attacks such as rape, and threats of violence including death threats.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 12 September 2014 noted that the local NGO Identoba, in its report submitted to the UN Human Rights Committee in September 2013, referred to a murder with evidence of a possible hate motive which occurred in western Georgia in April 2013.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 12 September 2014 noted that the numbers of bias-motivated attacks against LGBTI persons cited are most certainly lower than the actual occurrence, due to the reluctance of victims to report violence to police, inter alia because of fears that their sexual orientation would be disclosed to family members.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 12 September 2014 noted that NGOs had expressed serious concerns regarding the lack of effective investigation and adequate punishment for perpetrators of attacks against LGBTI persons in Georgia.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 12 September 2014 encouraged increased efforts to enhance tolerance and non-discrimination among the majority population in Georgia, and emphasised the importance for authorities, public actors and community leaders to send an unambiguous message in favour of human rights and tolerance, and against violence, hate speech and discrimination.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 12 September 2014 welcomed the plans to develop comprehensive anti-discrimination legislation in Georgia and strongly encouraged the establishment of an equality body with the power to sanction instances of discrimination, including on actors from the private sector.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 12 September 2014 stated that hate crimes should be effectively investigated and qualified as such by law enforcement bodies in Georgia, that the bias motive should be taken into account as an aggravating circumstance as already provided for by national legislation, and that perpetrators should receive punishment commensurate to the gravity of the offence.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "C. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "In its 2013 Annual Review of the situation of the LGBT community in Georgia, the International Lesbian and Gay Association (ILGA) noted that in March 2012 an amendment to Article 53 of the Criminal Code of Georgia was adopted to tackle intolerance on the grounds of sexual orientation and gender identity, making homophobic or transphobic motivation an aggravating factor in sentencing perpetrators of crimes.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "D. The International Lesbian and Gay Association (ILGA) on the LGBT community's problems in Georgia"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The International Lesbian and Gay Association (ILGA) noted in its 2013 Annual Review that the legislative change to Article 53 of the Criminal Code of Georgia was adopted as a response to recommendations from the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "D. The International Lesbian and Gay Association (ILGA) on the LGBT community's problems in Georgia"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The International Lesbian and Gay Association (ILGA) noted in its 2013 Annual Review that the government of Georgia did not take measures to ensure effective implementation of the amended Article 53 of the Criminal Code, such as training the relevant police officers or taking actions to build confidence between law enforcement forces and the LGBT community.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "D. The International Lesbian and Gay Association (ILGA) on the LGBT community's problems in Georgia"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The International Lesbian and Gay Association (ILGA) collected information on seven hate crimes perpetrated against LGBT persons in Georgia during 2013, including various types of attacks such as rape, and various types of physical violence threats including death threats.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "D. The International Lesbian and Gay Association (ILGA) on the LGBT community's problems in Georgia"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Some of the hate crimes collected by the International Lesbian and Gay Association (ILGA) in its 2013 Annual Review targeted the organisers and participants of the International Day Against Homophobia (IDAHO) demonstration that took place in May 2012 in Georgia.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW. INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND OTHER MATERIALS", "D. The International Lesbian and Gay Association (ILGA) on the LGBT community's problems in Georgia"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F018", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F029", "F030"], "interference": ["F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F035"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": ["F005", "F007", "F008", "F011", "F023", "F024", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F112", "F113"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F005", "F006", "F018", "F022"], "interference": ["F024", "F027", "F028", "F032"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": ["F007", "F011", "F023", "F027", "F028", "F031", "F112"]}, "list3": ["F007", "F011", "F023", "F024", "F027", "F028", "F031", "F112"]}} {"case_name": "case_321", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_322", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The case mainly concerns the alleged violation of the applicant's rights under Article 11 of the Convention in respect of administrative offence proceedings against him related to his participation in a public protest on 20 April 2013 (the first episode).", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The case mainly concerns the alleged violation of the applicant's rights under Article 6 §§ 1 and 3 (d) of the Convention in respect of administrative offence proceedings against him related to his participation in a public protest on 20 April 2013 (the first episode).", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The case concerns the alleged breach of Article 2 of Protocol No. 7 to the Convention on account of the examination of the applicant's appeal against his administrative detention ordered on 16 August 2013 only after he had served it in full (the second episode).", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 20 April 2013 the applicant participated in a protest against a construction project in a public park in Kyiv.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "About an hour after the protest began on 20 April 2013, a police officer approached the applicant and ordered him to get into a police car, allegedly without explanations.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "After the applicant refused to comply with the police officer's order to get into a police car, he was handcuffed and brought to the local police station.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The police drew up a report stating that the applicant had maliciously disobeyed a lawful police order, which is an administrative offence under Article 185 of the Code of Administrative Offences, by refusing to go to a police car.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The police report stated that the applicant had grabbed hold of the officer's clothing and tried to throw himself to the ground.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant stated in the police report that he had not received any lawful orders from police officers.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicant stated in the police report that witnesses P. and Ch., who had witnessed his arrest, could confirm his version of the events.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant was released later on 20 April 2013.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 18 July 2013 the Obolonskyy Kyiv District Court found the applicant guilty as charged of maliciously disobeying a lawful police order under Article 185 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Obolonskyy Kyiv District Court fined the applicant 255 Ukrainian hryvnias.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "In addition to the police report, the Obolonskyy Kyiv District Court relied on the statements of several guards of the construction site who submitted that an aggressive looking group from among the protesters had approached the site, had damaged some equipment and had left.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant appealed against the Obolonskyy Kyiv District Court's judgment, arguing that he had not received any lawful police orders before his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicant appealed against the Obolonskyy Kyiv District Court's judgment, arguing that no violent behaviour had ever been attributed to him.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant complained in his appeal that the Obolonskyy Kyiv District Court had arbitrarily rejected his request for questioning witnesses P. and Ch.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 5 September 2013 the Kyiv City Court of Appeal rejected the applicant's appeal against the Obolonskyy Kyiv District Court's judgment, with reasoning similar to that of the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Kyiv City Court of Appeal neither commented on the applicant's request for questioning witnesses P. and Ch. nor indicated the reasons for its rejection of that request.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Obolonskyy Kyiv District Court neither commented on the applicant's request for questioning witnesses P. and Ch. nor indicated the reasons for its rejection of that request.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 16 August 2013 the applicant entered the Kyiv City Council premises, relying on his status as a journalist and an assistant to a council member.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Together with several other persons, the applicant stayed in the empty assembly hall of the Kyiv City Council premises, from which they were removed by the police.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 16 August 2013 the Kyiv Shevchenkivskyy District Court found the applicant guilty of maliciously disobeying a lawful police order in respect of the incident at the Kyiv City Council premises.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Kyiv Shevchenkivskyy District Court sentenced the applicant to five days' detention for maliciously disobeying a lawful police order on 16 August 2013.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant began serving the five-day detention sentence immediately on 16 August 2013.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 21 August 2013, once released from detention, the applicant lodged an appeal against the Kyiv Shevchenkivskyy District Court's judgment.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 26 September 2013 the Kyiv City Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal against the Kyiv Shevchenkivskyy District Court's judgment of 16 August 2013.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F016"], "interference": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F011", "F012", "F013"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F005", "F007", "F009", "F012", "F015", "F018"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F016"], "interference": ["F006", "F011", "F012"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F005", "F009", "F012", "F015"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F004", "F016", "F005", "F009", "F012", "F015"]}} {"case_name": "case_323", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_328", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_331", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1984.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Mardin.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "At the time of the events giving rise to the present application, the applicant was a student at the Philosophy Department of the Faculty of Arts and Science at Dicle University.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 28 March 2006 a funeral of four militants of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party), an illegal armed organisation, took place in Diyarbakır.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "An incident report regarding events that took place between 28 March and 1 April 2006 was prepared on 3 April 2006 by the police.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The incident report regarding events between 28 March and 1 April 2006 was signed by more than 220 police officers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The police incident report stated that on 24 March 2006 fourteen PKK militants had been killed by the security forces.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The police incident report stated that the remains of four of the PKK militants killed on 24 March 2006 were released to their families in order to be buried in Diyarbakır.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 28 March 2006 at around 7 a.m., the remains of the four PKK militants were taken to a mosque where around 1,500–2,000 people had gathered.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The crowd at the mosque on 28 March 2006 blocked traffic as they carried the coffins of the four PKK militants.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The crowd at the mosque on 28 March 2006 chanted separatist, hostile slogans in Turkish and Kurdish in support of the PKK and Abdullah Öcalan, the leader of the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The crowd at the mosque on 28 March 2006 waved PKK posters and banners.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The crowd on 28 March 2006 walked to a cemetery for the burial of the four deceased PKK militants.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The security forces did not intervene in the crowd on 28 March 2006 because there were relatives of the deceased, including children and old people, in the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The police incident report stated that after the burial ceremony had been completed on 28 March 2006, a group of about 1,000 people continued to march.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The police warned the marching group of about 1,000 people on 28 March 2006 that they were not allowed to chant illegal slogans, disseminate propaganda in support of the PKK, or wave illegal flags.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "After being warned by the police on 28 March 2006, the crowd became agitated and started throwing stones at the police officers on duty, injuring a number of them.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The crowd on 28 March 2006 caused extensive damage to State buildings and vehicles, banks, shops, and other vehicles belonging to private individuals.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the police incident report, more people later joined the illegal demonstration, which continued on 29, 30 and 31 March and 1 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The police incident report stated that prior to the events of 28 March 2006, some media organs controlled by the PKK had called for mass protests.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 5 March 2007 a demonstration was held on the campus of Dicle University to protest about the conditions of Abdullah Öcalan's detention.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The demonstration on 5 March 2007 at Dicle University protested in particular about the alleged poisoning of Abdullah Öcalan by the Turkish authorities.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 5 March 2007 a group of forty people entered the Dicle University building and asked the students to leave.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 5 March 2007 the group of forty people held a press conference on the premises of Dicle University.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 5 March 2007 the group of forty people chanted slogans in favour of the PKK and Abdullah Öcalan on the premises of Dicle University.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 28 March 2006 and 5 March 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 9 March 2007 the applicant was arrested.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 10 March 2007 the applicant was questioned at the anti-terror branch of the Diyarbakır police headquarters.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "During questioning on 10 March 2007 at the anti-terror branch of the Diyarbakır police headquarters, the applicant denied taking part in the demonstration of 5 March 2007 at Dicle University.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "During questioning on 10 March 2007 at the anti-terror branch of the Diyarbakır police headquarters, the applicant denied taking part in the funeral of 28 March 2006 and the subsequent events.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 10 March 2007 the applicant made a statement to the Diyarbakır public prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant was shown photographs taken of him on 28 March 2006 during the funeral of the PKK militants.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant was shown photographs taken of him on 5 March 2007 during the demonstration at Dicle University.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant accepted to the Diyarbakır public prosecutor that he had participated in the funeral of one of the PKK militants on 28 March 2006.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The applicant stated to the Diyarbakır public prosecutor that the PKK militant whose funeral he attended on 28 March 2006 had been a relative of a friend of his.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant stated to the Diyarbakır public prosecutor that he had attended the funeral on 28 March 2006 as a religious duty.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicant stated to the Diyarbakır public prosecutor that he had not attacked the police with stones during the events of 28 March 2006.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant stated to the Diyarbakır public prosecutor that on 5 March 2007 he had stood in front of the Dicle University building with other students for a short while.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant stated to the Diyarbakır public prosecutor that his photograph must have been taken while he stood in front of the Dicle University building on 5 March 2007.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicant stated to the Diyarbakır public prosecutor that he had not chanted slogans with the demonstrators on 5 March 2007.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicant was brought before a judge of the Diyarbakır Assize Court on 10 March 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "Before the judge of the Diyarbakır Assize Court on 10 March 2007, the applicant maintained that his statements to the Diyarbakır public prosecutor had reflected the truth.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The judge of the Diyarbakır Assize Court remanded the applicant in custody on the basis of a strong suspicion that he had committed the offence of disseminating propaganda in support of a terrorist organisation or its purposes.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 8 May 2007 the Diyarbakır public prosecutor filed a bill of indictment against the applicant with the Diyarbakır Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant was charged with disseminating propaganda in support of the PKK under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant was charged with membership of an illegal organisation under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), on the basis of Articles 220 § 6 and 314 § 3 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Diyarbakır public prosecutor noted in the indictment that on 28 March 2006 the applicant had participated in an illegal demonstration held under the pretext of a funeral.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Diyarbakır public prosecutor noted in the indictment that on 28 March 2006 the applicant had chanted a slogan during the illegal demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Diyarbakır public prosecutor noted in the indictment that on 28 March 2006 the applicant had covered his face with the hood of his coat during the illegal demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Diyarbakır public prosecutor noted in the indictment that on 5 March 2007 the applicant had supported the chanting of slogans in favour of the PKK by applauding during the demonstration at Dicle University.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Diyarbakır public prosecutor claimed in the indictment that the applicant had regularly, willingly and knowingly participated in illegal demonstrations organised by political parties, associations and persons who supported the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Diyarbakır public prosecutor claimed in the indictment that the applicant should be punished for membership of an illegal organisation on the basis of his regular participation in illegal demonstrations organised by supporters of the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In support of the indictment, the Diyarbakır public prosecutor submitted police video recordings of the funeral held on 28 March 2006 to the Diyarbakır Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "In support of the indictment, the Diyarbakır public prosecutor submitted police video recordings of the demonstration at Dicle University of 5 March 2007 to the Diyarbakır Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In the first police video recording, the applicant was seen in a crowd next to a coffin making a 'V' sign.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In the second police video recording, the applicant was seen in a crowd with the hood of his coat on his head.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "In the third police video recording, the applicant was seen applauding with other students.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 19 June 2007 the Diyarbakır Assize Court held the first hearing in the criminal proceedings against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "At the first hearing on 19 June 2007, the applicant made defence submissions stating that he had attended the funeral on 28 March 2006.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "At the first hearing on 19 June 2007, the applicant stated that he had briefly participated in the gathering at Dicle University on 5 March 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "At the first hearing on 19 June 2007, the applicant accepted that he was the person in the photographs submitted as evidence.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "At the first hearing on 19 June 2007, the applicant denied the accuracy of the allegation that he had chanted slogans during the funeral of 28 March 2006.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "At the first hearing on 19 June 2007, the applicant denied the accuracy of the allegation that he had chanted slogans during the demonstration of 5 March 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "At the first hearing on 19 June 2007, the applicant stated that he did not remember making a 'V' sign but that he might have done so along with the rest of the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "At the first hearing on 19 June 2007, a witness was heard by the Diyarbakır Assize Court and confirmed the applicant's version of events of 5 March 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "At the end of the first hearing on 19 June 2007, the Diyarbakır Assize Court ordered the applicant's continued detention on remand.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 30 November 2007, at the end of the fourth hearing, the Diyarbakır Assize Court convicted the applicant of membership of an illegal organisation, the PKK, pursuant to Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), on the basis of Articles 220 § 6 and 314 § 3 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court sentenced the applicant to six years and three months' imprisonment for membership of an illegal organisation, the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court convicted the applicant of two counts of disseminating propaganda in support of the PKK under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court sentenced the applicant to a total of one year and eight months' imprisonment for two counts of disseminating propaganda in support of the PKK under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court gave a summary of the applicant's defence submissions as part of its judgment of 30 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court gave a summary of the Diyarbakır public prosecutor's observations on the merits of the case as part of its judgment of 30 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The evidence in the case file included the applicant's statements to the police, the Diyarbakır public prosecutor and the judge, dated 10 March 2007.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The evidence in the case file included a photograph relating to the funeral of 28 March 2006.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The evidence in the case file included printed versions of news articles published by various media in support of the PKK which had been downloaded from the Internet.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The evidence in the case file included arrest and incident reports.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The evidence in the case file included reports on the video recordings.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The evidence in the case file included a copy of the leaflet distributed at Dicle University on 5 March 2007.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The evidence in the case file included reports by experts on the examination of the video recordings.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The evidence in the case file included the applicant's identity documents.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The evidence in the case file included a document showing that the applicant had no previous criminal record.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court observed, on the basis of the police video recordings and photographs extracted from those recordings, that the applicant had attended the funeral of four PKK militants on 28 March 2006.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court observed that the applicant had walked in front of one of the coffins during the funeral of 28 March 2006.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court observed that the applicant had made a 'V' sign during the funeral of 28 March 2006.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court noted that the funeral of 28 March 2006 had subsequently turned into propaganda for the PKK-KONGRA/GEL, thus becoming an illegal demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court considered that the applicant had played an active role in the illegal demonstration of 28 March 2006, noting that he had walked close to the coffins.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court noted that it was not established that the applicant had chanted slogans during the funeral of 28 March 2006.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court noted that during the demonstration held on 5 March 2007 at Dicle University, the applicant had applauded while other demonstrators chanted slogans in support of Abdullah Öcalan.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court noted that the funeral of the PKK militants on 28 March 2006 had been held in line with calls and instructions issued by the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court noted that the demonstration of 5 March 2007 at Dicle University had been held in line with calls and instructions issued by the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found that the funeral of 28 March 2006 and the demonstration of 5 March 2007 had subsequently turned into propaganda events in favour of the PKK and had become illegal demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found it established that the applicant had acted with the intention of supporting the deceased PKK militants on 28 March 2006, thereby committing the offence of disseminating propaganda in favour of the PKK and its leader.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found it established that the applicant had acted together with illegal demonstrators on 5 March 2007, thereby committing the offence of disseminating propaganda in favour of the PKK and its leader.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court referred to a decision dated 22 March 2007 (case no. 2006/9165, decision no. 2007/2432) of the Ninth Criminal Division of the Court of Cassation of Turkey.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "In its decision of 22 March 2007, the Ninth Criminal Division of the Court of Cassation of Turkey considered that acts of accused demonstrators including participation in the demonstration of 28 March 2006 after calls by the PKK, chanting slogans in support of the PKK and Abdullah Öcalan, singing the PKK's youth march song, burning tyres and blocking traffic, carrying PKK flags, banners and Öcalan posters, attacking public buildings and police and civilian vehicles with stones and Molotov cocktails, and carrying the bodies of PKK militants killed by the security forces, should be considered as offences committed on behalf of the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Ninth Criminal Division of the Court of Cassation of Turkey found in its decision of 22 March 2007 that the accused demonstrators should be punished for those offences and also be convicted of membership of an illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court noted that the applicant had acted together with the demonstrators referred to in the Ninth Criminal Division's decision of 22 March 2007 on 28 March 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court considered that the applicant's participation in the funeral and demonstration of 28 March 2006 and his conduct at that time had occurred as a result of instructions and calls by the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court considered that the applicant had acted on behalf of the PKK, in line with the goals and activities of the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court considered that the applicant should be punished not only for disseminating propaganda but also for membership of an illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "One of the three judges sitting on the bench of the Diyarbakır Assize Court dissented from the judgment of 30 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The dissenting judge stated that neither Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) nor the explanatory memorandum on Article 220 § 6 explained the concept of committing an offence on behalf of an illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The dissenting judge noted that an offence committed on behalf of an illegal organisation should be capable of producing a result for a terrorist organisation and its aims, such as the offences of aggravated injury, kidnapping, deprivation of liberty, murder or bombing.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The dissenting judge noted that an offence committed on behalf of an illegal organisation should have devastating repercussions for society when the way of committing the offence, the time of the offence and its effects were taken into consideration.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The dissenting judge opined that in order to conclude that non-members of an illegal organisation had committed an offence on behalf of that illegal organisation, there should be a decision to commit an offence on behalf of that organisation and an intention to join the organisation in question.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The dissenting judge concluded that the applicant should only have been convicted under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (the Prevention of Terrorism Act).", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The applicant appealed against the judgment of the Diyarbakır Assize Court of 30 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "On 29 January 2009 the Court of Cassation of Turkey upheld the judgment of 30 November 2007 in so far as it related to the applicant's conviction under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), on the basis of Articles 220 § 6 and 314 § 3 of the same Code, for membership of an illegal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "On 29 January 2009 the Court of Cassation of Turkey quashed the applicant's conviction under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (the Prevention of Terrorism Act) on procedural grounds.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "On 23 March 2009 the Court of Cassation's decision of 29 January 2009 was deposited with the registry of the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "On 28 April 2009 the Diyarbakır Assize Court once again convicted the applicant under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (the Prevention of Terrorism Act).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "On 17 October 2012 the Court of Cassation of Turkey quashed the applicant's conviction under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (the Prevention of Terrorism Act).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "On 14 December 2012 the Diyarbakır Assize Court decided to suspend the criminal proceedings against the applicant under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (the Prevention of Terrorism Act), pursuant to Law no. 6352.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Law no. 6352 had entered into force on 5 July 2012.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The suspension of criminal proceedings against the applicant under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 was for a period of three years.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The suspension of criminal proceedings against the applicant under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 was on the condition that he did not commit an offence when expressing ideas and opinions through the medium of the press or other media, or by any other method.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "On 25 October 2010 the applicant was expelled from Dicle University by the administrative board of the Faculty of Arts and Science.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The applicant was expelled from Dicle University because he had failed to complete his degree within the maximum period of seven years for an undergraduate programme.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The applicant lodged a case against the decision to expel him from Dicle University.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "On 5 June 2012 the Diyarbakır Administrative Court dismissed the applicant's case against the decision to expel him from Dicle University.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The Diyarbakır Administrative Court considered that the fact that the applicant had been serving a prison sentence did not justify his non-attendance at classes and examinations.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "After serving four years and eight months of his sentence, the applicant was released from prison on 15 November 2011.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "On 1 April 2005 Law no. 5237 (the Criminal Code of Turkey) entered into force.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who establishes or directs organisations for the purpose of criminal activity shall be liable to imprisonment of between two and six years, provided that the structure of the organisation, the number of the members, and the quantity of the equipment and supplies are sufficient to commit the intended crimes.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who becomes a member of an organisation established for the purpose of criminal activity shall be liable to imprisonment of between one and three years.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 3 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that if the organisation is armed, the sentences stated in Article 220 §§ 1 and 2 shall be increased by between one quarter and one half.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 4 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that any crime committed within the framework of the organisation's activities shall be punished separately.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 5 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that the heads of organisations shall also be sentenced as perpetrators of all crimes committed within the framework of such organisations' activities.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who commits a crime on behalf of an illegal organisation, even if they are not a member of that organisation, shall also be punished for being a member of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 7 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who aids and abets an illegal organisation knowingly and intentionally, even if they do not belong to the hierarchical structure of the organisation, shall be punished as a member of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 8 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who spreads propaganda for the organisation or its objectives shall be punished by imprisonment of between one and three years, and if the said crime is committed through the media and press the sentence shall be increased by one half.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article 220 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) were amended by Law no. 6352, which entered into force on 2 July 2012.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "As amended by Law no. 6352, Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who commits a crime on behalf of an illegal organisation, even if they are not a member of that organisation, shall also be punished for being a member of the organisation, and the penalty to be imposed for membership may be reduced by up to half.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "As amended by Law no. 6352, Article 220 § 7 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who aids and abets an illegal organisation knowingly and intentionally, even if they do not belong to the hierarchical structure of the organisation, shall be punished as a member of the organisation, and the penalty to be imposed for membership may be reduced by up to two thirds, depending on the nature of the assistance.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) was further amended by Law no. 6459, which entered into force on 11 April 2013.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "As amended by Law no. 6459, Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) currently provides that anyone who commits a crime on behalf of an illegal organisation, even if they are not a member of that organisation, shall also be punished for being a member of the organisation, the penalty to be imposed for membership may be reduced by up to half, and this paragraph shall be applicable only for armed organisations.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Article 314 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who forms an armed organisation to commit the crimes listed in the fourth and fifth sections of the relevant chapter, or commands such an organisation, shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between ten and fifteen years.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who becomes a member of an armed organisation mentioned in Article 314 § 1 shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between five and ten years.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Article 314 § 3 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that other provisions relating to the crime of forming an organisation for the purpose of criminal activity are also applicable for the crime of membership of an armed organisation.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "At the material time, section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) provided that any person who disseminates propaganda in support of a terrorist organisation shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between one and five years.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Law no. 6459 amended section 7 of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) by adding a new paragraph.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "According to the new paragraph added to section 7 of Law no. 3713 by Law no. 6459, people who have committed the offence under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (disseminating propaganda in favour of a terrorist organisation) shall not in addition be held criminally liable under Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "According to the new paragraph added to section 7 of Law no. 3713 by Law no. 6459, people who have committed the offence under section 6(2) of Law no. 3713 (printing and disseminating declarations made by terrorist organisations which provide legitimacy to or praise the methods of violence or threats used by terrorist organisations or which encourage the use of such methods) shall not in addition be held criminally liable under Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "According to the new paragraph added to section 7 of Law no. 3713 by Law no. 6459, people who have committed the offence under section 28(1) of the Marches and Demonstrations Act (Law no. 2911) (participating in an unlawful demonstration) shall not in addition be held criminally liable under Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "On 29 September 2006, the Diyarbakır Assize Court convicted a certain F.Ö. under section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 (the Prevention of Terrorism Act) and section 32(1) and (3) of Law no. 2911 (the Marches and Demonstrations Act) for participation in and his conduct during three demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "On 21 February 2007 the Ninth Criminal Division of the Court of Cassation of Turkey quashed the first-instance judgment against F.Ö., holding that F.Ö.'s acts had constituted not only the offences for which he had been found guilty, but also membership of an illegal organisation under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237), on the basis of Articles 220 § 6 and 314 § 3, as he had committed the offences on behalf of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The Ninth Criminal Division of the Court of Cassation of Turkey considered that F.Ö. should be punished for the offence of membership of an illegal organisation and the other offences proscribed by section 7(2) of Law no. 3713 and section 32(1) and (3) of Law no. 2911.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "On 31 May 2007 the Diyarbakır Assize Court reiterated its previous judgment that F.Ö.'s acts had not constituted the offence proscribed by Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court noted in its judgment of 31 May 2007 that in order for a court to conclude that a crime had been committed on behalf of an organisation, the latter must have issued a call for action to an individual who was capable of directly committing that act, rather than to an undefined collective group.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "As a result of the disagreement between the Diyarbakır Assize Court and the Ninth Criminal Division of the Court of Cassation of Turkey regarding F.Ö.'s case, the case was transferred to the Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) of Turkey.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) of Turkey decided to quash the Diyarbakır Assize Court judgment in F.Ö.'s case.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) of Turkey held on 4 March 2008 that participation in unauthorised demonstrations held after appeals by an illegal organisation and acts which constituted independent offences committed during those demonstrations could be considered as having been carried out on behalf of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) of Turkey held on 4 March 2008 that such acts should be sanctioned under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) on the basis of Articles 220 § 6 and 314 § 3, along with other criminal-law provisions.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The Plenary Court of Cassation (Criminal Divisions) of Turkey held on 4 March 2008 that appeals by an illegal organisation made in concrete terms through broadcasts by its media outlets did not need to target identified individuals.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 4 March 2008 (Case no. 2007/9-282, Decision no. 2008/44)"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "At its 106th plenary session, held on 11 and 12 March 2016, the Venice Commission (European Commission for Democracy through Law) adopted an Opinion on Articles 216, 299, 301 and 314 of the Penal Code of Turkey (CDL-AD(2016)002).", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 noted that the Penal Code of Turkey does not contain a definition of an armed organisation or an armed group.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 noted that in its judgment E. 2006/10-253 K. 2007/80 of 3 April 2007, the General Criminal Board of the Court of Cassation of Turkey listed the main criteria that a criminal organisation for the purposes of Article 220 of the Penal Code should display, including: at least three members; a tight or loose hierarchical connection between members; a common intention to commit crimes; continuity in time; and sufficient structure, number of members, tools and equipment for the commission of the envisaged crimes.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 noted that the Court of Cassation of Turkey developed the criterion of 'membership' in an armed organisation by examining different acts of the suspect, taking account of their 'continuity, diversity and intensity' in order to see whether those acts prove an 'organic relationship' with the organisation or whether the acts may be considered as committed knowingly and wilfully within the 'hierarchical structure' of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 noted that if an 'organic relationship' with the organisation cannot be proven on the basis of acts attributed to the defendant which do not present any 'continuity, diversity or intensity', the paragraphs on 'aiding and abetting an armed organisation' or 'committing crime on behalf of an armed organisation' under Article 220 of the Penal Code may be applied.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 noted that acts such as 'participating in a public demonstration following a general call from pro-PKK media outlets, making victory sign and shouting slogans to support and in favour of the leader of a terrorist organisation, clashing with the security forces and forming barricades' are considered crimes committed on behalf of an organisation and not as membership.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 recommended that the established criteria in the case law of the Court of Cassation of Turkey — that acts attributed to a defendant should show 'in their continuity, diversity and intensity' an 'organic relationship' to an organisation or prove that the defendant acted knowingly and willingly within the 'hierarchical structure' of the organisation — should be applied strictly.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 stated that the loose application of the criteria of 'continuity, diversity and intensity' and 'organic relationship' may give rise to issues concerning in particular the principle of legality within the meaning of Article 7 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 stated that the expression of an opinion in its different forms should not be the only evidence before domestic courts to decide on the membership of the defendant in an armed organisation.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 stated that where the only evidence consists of forms of expression, a conviction for being a member of an armed organisation would constitute an interference with the right of the defendants to freedom of expression, and that the necessity of this interference should be examined in the concrete circumstances of each case on the basis of the criteria set forth in the case-law of the ECtHR, in particular the criterion of 'incitement to violence'.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 noted that in a judgment of 4 March 2008 the General Criminal Board of the Court of Cassation of Turkey held that acts such as participating in a public demonstration following a general call from pro-PKK media outlets, making a victory sign and shouting slogans to support and in favour of the leader of a terrorist organisation, and clashing with the security forces, are considered crimes committed on behalf of the terrorist organisation.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 noted that in the judgment of 4 March 2008, although membership in an armed organisation was not established, the defendant was convicted as a member of a criminal organisation according to Article 220 § 6 of the Penal Code applied in conjunction with Article 314.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 noted that by the judgment of 4 March 2008, the Court of Cassation of Turkey annulled the decision of the Diyarbakır Assize Court which had considered that in order for a court to conclude that a crime was committed on behalf of an organisation, the latter must have called for action not to an undefined collective, but rather to an individual person who is capable of directly committing that act.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 noted that a new paragraph was added to Article 7 of the Anti-Terror Law no. 3713 by an amendment of 11 April 2013, providing that those who committed the crimes indicated in section 7(2) of Law no. 3713, section 6(2) of Law no. 3713, and section 28(1) of the Public Demonstrations Law no. 2911 shall not be sentenced separately under Article 220(6) of the Penal Code.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 welcomed the amendment introduced to Article 7 of the Anti-Terror Law no. 3713, which excluded the above-mentioned crimes from the scope of application of Article 220(6) of the Penal Code.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 considered that the scope of the amendment to Article 7 of the Anti-Terror Law no. 3713 is rather limited and does not provide for sufficient protection to the exercise of freedom of expression and assembly.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 noted that some forms of expression may also fall under the scope of Article 220(7) of the Penal Code (aiding and abetting an organisation), which could lead to abusive application in practice since a form of expression considered as being in support of an organisation may be sanctioned under Article 220(7) instead of Article 220(6) in order to sentence defendants as if they were members of an armed organisation under Article 314, although their organic relationship with an armed organisation is not established.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 noted that the new paragraph added to Article 7 of the Anti-Terror Law no. 3713 refers to section 28(1) of the Law on Public Demonstrations, which merely criminalises the organisation of or participation in unlawful public demonstrations, while the crime regulated under Article 32(1) of the Law on Public Demonstrations (refusing to obey the warnings of the security forces during a public demonstration to disperse) may still fall under the scope of Article 220(6) of the Penal Code in conjunction with Article 314.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 recommended that the sentence 'although he is not a member of that organisation, shall also be sentenced for the offence of being a member of that organisation' in paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article 220 of the Penal Code be repealed, so that those who commit the crimes indicated in paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article 220 would not be sanctioned as members of an armed organisation under Article 314, but by other, separate sanctions.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002 stated that should the sentence in paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article 220 be maintained, the Turkish authorities should consider limiting the application of Article 220 in conjunction with Article 314 to cases which do not involve the exercise of the rights to freedom of expression and assembly.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "In a report published on 1 October 2009 following a visit to Turkey between 28 June and 3 July 2009, Mr Thomas Hammarberg, the former Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, expressed concerns about the interpretation and application of, inter alia, Article 220 of the Criminal Code of Turkey.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "1. Reports of 1 October 2009 and 12 July 2011 (CommDH(2017)5) and (CommDH(2011)25)"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "In a report dated 12 July 2011, Mr Thomas Hammarberg, the former Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, stated that his concerns regarding Article 220 of the Criminal Code of Turkey remained valid.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "1. Reports of 1 October 2009 and 12 July 2011 (CommDH(2017)5) and (CommDH(2011)25)"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "In a report published on 10 January 2012 following a visit to Turkey between 10 and 14 October 2011, Mr Thomas Hammarberg, the former Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, stated that any allegation of terrorist activity must be established with convincing evidence and beyond any reasonable doubt.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "2. Report of 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2)"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated in his report of 10 January 2012 that violence or the threat to use violence is an essential component of an act of terrorism, and that restrictions of human rights in the fight against terrorism must be defined as precisely as possible and be necessary and proportionate to the aim pursued.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "2. Report of 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2)"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated in his report of 10 January 2012 that the provisions contained in the Turkish anti-terror legislation and Article 220 of the Criminal Code of Turkey allow for a very wide margin of appreciation, in particular in cases where membership in a terrorist organisation has not been proven and when an act or statement may be deemed to coincide with the aims or instructions of a terrorist organisation.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "2. Report of 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2)"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "Mr Thomas Hammarberg encouraged the Turkish authorities in his report of 10 January 2012 to reflect on and address concerns about the Turkish anti-terror legislation and Article 220 of the Criminal Code of Turkey through legislative measures and/or case-law.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "2. Report of 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2)"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "In a memorandum on freedom of expression and media freedom in Turkey (CommDH(2017)5), published on 15 February 2017 following a visit to Turkey between 6 and 14 April 2016, Mr Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, stressed the need for a complete overhaul of the Turkish Criminal Code, including Article 220 §§ 6 and 7 and Article 314.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "3. Memorandum of 15 February 2017 ((CommDH(2017)5))"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "Mr Nils Muižnieks considered in his memorandum (CommDH(2017)5) of 15 February 2017 that the overhaul of the Turkish Criminal Code should take full account of the Court's case-law and the Venice Commission's Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "3. Memorandum of 15 February 2017 ((CommDH(2017)5))"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F021", "F036", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F066", "F067", "F068", "F081", "F082", "F083", "F086", "F087", "F088", "F089", "F110"], "interference": ["F066", "F067", "F081", "F082", "F083", "F087", "F121"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F066", "F067", "F080", "F081", "F082", "F083", "F086", "F087", "F088", "F089", "F097", "F098", "F099", "F121", "F128", "F137", "F151", "F152", "F153", "F157"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F021", "F044", "F066", "F081", "F082", "F083", "F086", "F087"], "interference": ["F066", "F067", "F121"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F066", "F067", "F080", "F081", "F082", "F083", "F086", "F087", "F088", "F089", "F121", "F128", "F137", "F151", "F153", "F157"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F004", "F021", "F044", "F066", "F067", "F081", "F086", "F087", "F088", "F089", "F121", "F128", "F151", "F153", "F157"]}} {"case_name": "case_332", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants describe themselves as being of Macedonian ethnicity.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants are members of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden – PIRIN (\"UMO Ilinden – PIRIN\").", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "UMO Ilinden – PIRIN apparently has close links with the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden is an association based in south-west Bulgaria, in an area known as the Pirin region or the geographic region of Pirin Macedonia.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden makes yearly attempts to organise commemorative events on various sites in Pirin Macedonia.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "During the period 1994–2003, the rallies organised by the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden were, with minor exceptions, systematically banned by the Bulgarian authorities.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The systematic banning of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden's rallies during 1994–2003 was addressed in the case of Stankov and the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden v. Bulgaria, nos. 29221/95 and 29225/95, ECHR 2001-IX.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The systematic banning of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden's rallies during 1994–2003 was also addressed in the case of The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Ivanov v. Bulgaria, no. 44079/98, 20 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden was refused registration in 1990–91.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden was refused registration again in 1998–99.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The refusal of registration of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden was addressed in the case of The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Others v. Bulgaria (dec.), no. 59491/00, 9 September 2004.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "UMO Ilinden – PIRIN had in the meantime obtained registration as a political party prior to 29 February 2000.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 29 February 2000, UMO Ilinden – PIRIN was declared unconstitutional by the Bulgarian Constitutional Court.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "As a result of being declared unconstitutional, UMO Ilinden – PIRIN was dissolved on 29 February 2000.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The dissolution of UMO Ilinden – PIRIN was addressed in the case of The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden – PIRIN and Others v. Bulgaria, no. 59489/00, 20 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 3 August 1998, the second applicant, acting on behalf of the members and followers of UMO Ilinden – PIRIN, informed the mayor of Sofia that a rally had been planned for 10 August 1998.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The rally planned for 10 August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The rally planned for 10 August 1998 was to mark the anniversary of the 1913 Bucharest Treaty.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The rally planned for 10 August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The rally planned for 10 August 1998 was to be held in the public garden in front of the National Theatre in Sofia.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The rally planned for 10 August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Approximately one hundred people were expected to attend the rally planned for 10 August 1998.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The rally planned for 10 August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The second applicant assured the mayor of Sofia that no disturbances would occur during the rally planned for 10 August 1998.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The rally planned for 10 August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 3 August 1998, the mayor of Sofia issued an order prohibiting the rally planned for 10 August 1998.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The rally planned for 10 August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The mayor of Sofia's order prohibiting the rally planned for 10 August 1998 was issued pursuant to section 12(2)(2) of the Meetings and Marches Act.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The rally planned for 10 August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The mayor of Sofia opined, without giving further reasons, that the rally planned for 10 August 1998 would \"create conditions for breaches of the public order\".", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The rally planned for 10 August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "A copy of the mayor of Sofia's order prohibiting the rally planned for 10 August 1998 was sent to the Sofia police authorities for enforcement.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The rally planned for 10 August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Apparently no appeal was made against the mayor of Sofia's order prohibiting the rally planned for 10 August 1998.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The rally planned for 10 August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 1 September 1998, the first applicant, acting on behalf of the members and followers of UMO Ilinden – PIRIN, informed the mayor of Sofia that a rally had been planned for 12 September 1998.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The rally planned for 12 September 1998 was to be held between 12 noon and 2 p.m. in front of the National Theatre in Sofia.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The first applicant stated that the rally planned for 12 September 1998 would be in commemoration of the \"[d]ay of the genocide against the Macedonians\".", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Approximately one hundred and twenty persons were expected to take part in the rally planned for 12 September 1998.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The first applicant assured the mayor of Sofia that the rally planned for 12 September 1998 would be entirely peaceful and that no disturbances would occur.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 2 September 1998, the mayor of Sofia issued an order banning the rally planned for 12 September 1998.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The mayor of Sofia's order banning the rally planned for 12 September 1998 was issued pursuant to section 12(2)(2) of the Meetings and Marches Act.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The mayor of Sofia's order banning the rally planned for 12 September 1998 stated that the event would \"create conditions for breaches of the public order\", without giving further reasons.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "A copy of the mayor of Sofia's order banning the rally planned for 12 September 1998 was sent to the Sofia police authorities for enforcement.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 2 September 1998, the first applicant lodged an appeal against the mayor of Sofia's order banning the rally planned for 12 September 1998 with the Sofia District Court.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The first applicant argued before the Sofia District Court that the mayor of Sofia's order banning the rally planned for 12 September 1998 was not reasoned.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The first applicant argued before the Sofia District Court that there were no grounds to anticipate that the rally planned for 12 September 1998 would pose a threat to public order.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The first applicant argued before the Sofia District Court that allowing local authorities to prohibit public events without specifying reasons would render nugatory the legal guarantees of freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 8 September 1998, the Sofia District Court ruled in private that it had no jurisdiction to examine the first applicant's appeal against the mayor of Sofia's order banning the rally planned for 12 September 1998.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Sofia District Court held that the mayor of Sofia's order banning the rally planned for 12 September 1998 had to be appealed first before the Executive Committee of the People's Council, as provided in section 12(4) of the Meetings and Marches Act.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Sofia District Court held that the person concerned could resort to the court only if an appeal to the Executive Committee of the People's Council was unsuccessful.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Sofia District Court discontinued the judicial proceedings concerning the first applicant's appeal and sent the appeal to the Executive Committee of the People's Council.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Sofia District Court's ruling of 8 September 1998 was apparently not notified to the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Since on 12 September 1998 the mayor of Sofia's ban on the rally had not been overturned, the applicants informed the members and followers of UMO Ilinden – PIRIN that the rally would not take place.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 17 September 1998, the first applicant appealed against the Sofia District Court's ruling of 8 September 1998 to the Sofia City Court.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The first applicant had apparently learned about the Sofia District Court's ruling of 8 September 1998 in the meantime before lodging his appeal on 17 September 1998.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The first applicant argued before the Sofia City Court that the Sofia District Court had erred in referring the appeal to the Executive Committee of the People's Council.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The first applicant argued that the Executive Committee of the People's Council was mentioned in the Meetings and Marches Act, which had been enacted prior to the Constitution of 1991, when the municipal authorities had been structured differently.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The first applicant argued that under the Constitution of 1991, the Executive Committee of the People's Council, which had been part of the executive branch of the local authorities, had ceased to exist.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The first applicant argued that it was erroneous to hold that the Municipal Council – the municipal legislative body – was the successor to the Executive Committee of the People's Council and as such competent to examine appeals against orders of the mayor.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The first applicant argued that the Municipal Council convened at long intervals, which had prevented it from examining the appeal in time for the rally planned for 12 September 1998.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 19 March 2002, the Sofia City Court dismissed the first applicant's appeal against the Sofia District Court's ruling of 8 September 1998.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Sofia City Court held that by section 12(4) of the Meetings and Marches Act, the organiser of a rally could appeal against the mayoral ban to the Municipal Council, which had to rule on the appeal within twenty-four hours.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Sofia City Court held that only if the Municipal Council dismissed the appeal could the dispute be brought before the court.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Sofia City Court held that by section 35(2) of the Administrative Procedure Act, judicial review of administrative acts was only possible if the administrative remedies had been exhausted or the time-limit for doing so had expired.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Sofia City Court held that in the case at hand no administrative appeal had been lodged, whereas the appeal to the Sofia District Court had been lodged on 2 September 1998, i.e. before the expiry of the twenty-four hours' time-limit laid down in section 12(4) of the Meetings and Marches Act.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Sofia City Court held that the argument that the Municipal Council convened at long intervals and was hence not in a position to examine the appeal in time was unavailing, because an infelicitous legal rule still had to be complied with.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Sofia City Court held that if the administrative body failed to rule on the appeal within twenty-four hours, the planned event could take place, as provided by section 12(5) of the Meetings and Marches Act.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Sofia City Court held that the Municipal Council had the power to rule on an appeal against the mayoral ban, because by the terms of section 21(2) of the Local Self-Government and Local Administration Act it could decide on all questions of importance for the local community.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The first applicant appealed to the Supreme Court of Cassation against the Sofia City Court's decision of 19 March 2002, reiterating his arguments.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 11 March 2003, the Supreme Court of Cassation dismissed the first applicant's appeal in a final decision.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Supreme Court of Cassation held that the Sofia City Court's disposition of the case had been correct, although it did not support the reasoning given by the Sofia City Court.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Supreme Court of Cassation held that by the time the Sofia City Court had decided the case – more than three and a half years after the date of the rally planned for 12 September 1998 – the first applicant had no longer had any interest in appealing against the ban.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Supreme Court of Cassation held that the first applicant's interest in appealing against the ban had been lacking even at the time of the lodging of the appeal against the Sofia District Court's ruling.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The rally planned for 12 September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Article 43(1) of the Constitution of Bulgaria of 1991 provides that everyone shall have the right to peaceful and unarmed assembly at meetings and marches.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Article 43(2) of the Constitution of Bulgaria of 1991 provides that the procedure for organising and holding meetings and marches shall be provided for by Act of Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Article 43(3) of the Constitution of Bulgaria of 1991 provides that permission shall not be required for meetings to be held indoors.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Article 44(2) of the Constitution of Bulgaria of 1991 provides that organisations whose activities are directed against the sovereignty or the territorial integrity of the country or against the unity of the nation, or aim at stirring racial, national, ethnic or religious hatred, or at violating the rights and freedoms of others, as well as organisations creating secret or paramilitary structures, or which seek to achieve their aims through violence, shall be prohibited.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The legal requirements for the organisation of meetings are laid down in the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 (\"Закон за събранията, митингите и манифестациите\").", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Section 2 of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that meetings, rallies and marches may be organised by individuals, associations, political or other civic organisations.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Section 8(1) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that where a meeting or rally is to be held outdoors, the organisers shall notify the respective People's Council or mayor's office in writing at least forty-eight hours before its beginning and shall indicate the name of the organiser, the aim of the meeting or rally, and its venue and time.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Section 12(1) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that where the time or venue of the meeting or rally or the itinerary of the march would create a situation endangering public order or traffic safety, the President of the Executive Committee of the People's Council, or the mayor, respectively, shall propose their modification.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Section 12(2) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that the President of the Executive Committee of the People's Council or the mayor shall be competent to prohibit the holding of a meeting, rally or march where reliable information exists that: (1) it aims at the violent overturning of Constitutional public order or is directed against the territorial integrity of the country; (2) it would endanger public order in the local community; or (4) it would breach the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Section 12(3) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that the prohibition shall be imposed by a written reasoned act not later than twenty-four hours after the notification.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Section 12(4) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that the organiser of the meeting, rally or march may appeal to the Executive Committee of the People's Council against the prohibition, and the Executive Committee shall decide within twenty-four hours.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Section 12(5) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that where the Executive Committee of the People's Council has not decided within the twenty-four hour time-limit, the march, rally or meeting may proceed.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Section 12(6) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that if the appeal is dismissed, the dispute shall be referred to the respective district court which shall decide within five days, and that court's decision shall be final.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Meetings and Marches Act was enacted in 1990, when the Constitution of 1971 was still in force.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "Under the Constitution of 1971, the executive local state organs were the Executive Committees of the district People's Councils.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "Under the Constitution of 1971, the mayors referred to in some provisions of the Meetings and Marches Act were representatives of the Executive Committee acting in villages and towns under the jurisdiction of the respective People's Council.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Constitution of Bulgaria of 1991 abolished the Executive Committees of the People's Councils.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Constitution of Bulgaria of 1991 established the post of mayor, elected by direct universal suffrage, as the \"organ of the executive power in the municipality\" under Article 139(1).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The general rules of procedure for administrative appeals and judicial review of administrative acts are set out in the Administrative Procedure Act of 1979 (\"Закон за административното производство\").", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Section 19(1) of the Administrative Procedure Act of 1979 provides that administrative acts may be appealed hierarchically before the higher administrative body or official.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Section 27(1) of the Administrative Procedure Act of 1979 provides that the appeal must be examined by the administrative body or official which is immediately superior to the body or official which issued the act.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Section 27(3) of the Administrative Procedure Act of 1979 provides that the acts of the mayors may be appealed before the regional governors.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Section 33(1) of the Administrative Procedure Act of 1979 provides that administrative acts may also be appealed before the competent courts.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Section 35(2) of the Administrative Procedure Act of 1979 provides that the appeal to the courts must be lodged after the administrative remedies have been exhausted or the time-limit for doing so has expired.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Section 21(1) of the Local Self-Government and Local Administration Act of 1991 (\"Закон за местното самоуправление и местната администрация\") contains a list of the powers of the Municipal Council.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Section 21(1) of the Local Self-Government and Local Administration Act of 1991 makes no mention of a power of the Municipal Council to examine appeals against acts of the mayor.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Section 21(2) of the Local Self-Government and Local Administration Act of 1991 provides that the Municipal Council is generally competent to decide on matters of importance for the local community which do not fall within the competence of other bodies.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F020", "F030", "F002"], "interference": ["F021", "F024", "F031", "F034", "F044", "F079", "F081", "F082", "F040", "F042", "F075", "F076", "F090"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F022", "F032", "F023", "F033", "F073", "F074"], "legitimate_aim": ["F023", "F033"], "necessity": ["F023", "F033", "F074", "F013", "F003", "F004", "F006"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F020", "F030"], "interference": ["F021", "F031", "F081", "F082", "F044", "F090"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F022", "F032", "F073"], "legitimate_aim": ["F023", "F033"], "necessity": ["F023", "F033", "F013"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F021", "F031", "F023", "F033", "F022", "F032", "F073", "F081", "F082", "F044", "F013", "F020", "F030"]}} {"case_name": "case_333", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_334", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1958.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Batman.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "At the time of the events giving rise to the present application, the applicant was the head of the Batman branch of the People's Democratic Party (DEHAP).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Subsequently, the applicant was the head of the Batman branch of the Party for a Democratic Society (DTP).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On unspecified dates in 2005 and 2006, the Batman public prosecutor's office initiated at least four criminal investigations against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 18 October 2005, the applicant made a statement before the Batman public prosecutor in relation to his attendance at a number of public meetings.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 6 December 2005, the applicant made a statement before the Batman public prosecutor in relation to his attendance at a number of public meetings.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 1 February 2006, the applicant made a statement before the Batman public prosecutor in relation to his attendance at a number of public meetings.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 23 March 2006, the applicant made a statement before the Batman public prosecutor in relation to his attendance at a number of public meetings.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "When questioned on 18 October 2005, the applicant was asked about his participation in an event commemorating a number of deceased members of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party, an illegal armed organisation) held on 22 August 2005.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant responded that he had become aware of the event commemorating deceased PKK members when demonstrators had started to march to the cemetery where the deceased were buried.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant stated that, as he was the head of the Batman branch of DEHAP (People's Democratic Party), he had attended the march in order to keep the demonstrators under control and to prevent any possible disturbances in the town.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "When questioned on 6 December 2005, the applicant stated that on 17 August 2005 he had been the head of the DEHAP (People's Democratic Party) branch in Batman.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "When questioned on 6 December 2005, the applicant stated that he had not praised the leader of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party) in his speech.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant stated that although Abdullah Öcalan, the leader of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party), was in prison, he was regarded as a political actor by the local population.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicant stated that his intention had been to express the social fact that Abdullah Öcalan was regarded as a political actor by the local population, and that he was against any kind of violence.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "When the Batman public prosecutor reminded the applicant of the violent acts of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party), the applicant stated that he was against violence regardless of whom it emanated from.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 1 February 2006, the Batman public prosecutor asked the applicant why he had referred to the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party) leader as 'Esteemed/Mr (Sayın) Öcalan' during one of his speeches.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant responded that he had used the word 'Sayın' as a matter of courtesy.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant stated that he had not intended to disseminate propaganda in favour of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party) or to praise a criminal.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 23 March 2006, the applicant was questioned by the Batman public prosecutor in the context of a criminal investigation opened against him on suspicion of membership of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant stated that he had participated in several demonstrations and readings of press statements in his capacity as the head of the Batman branch of DEHAP (People's Democratic Party) and the DTP (Party for a Democratic Society).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant stated that he had not committed any offence during the demonstrations and readings of press statements he attended.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant denied the veracity of the allegation that the public meetings he attended had been organised in accordance with the instructions of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "When asked about a sentence condemning both the death of Turkish soldiers and PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party) members which he had uttered during a speech, the applicant stated that he would utter that sentence again without hesitation.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant stated that the petition campaign entitled 'I accept Abdullah Öcalan as a political actor' had not been started upon the instructions of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant accepted that he had demanded an end to the solitary confinement of Abdullah Öcalan.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant accepted that he had addressed Abdullah Öcalan as 'Esteemed/Mr (Sayın) Öcalan'.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant denied the allegation that he had had the intention of disseminating propaganda in favour of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicant contended that he had attended the demonstrations and meetings in question in order to control the crowds and to prevent any possible disturbances.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant claimed that his aim was to contribute to peace and democracy.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 23 March 2006, the applicant was brought before the Batman Magistrates' Court and questioned in respect of his involvement in a demonstration held on 16 February 2006 in Batman.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant submitted that he had attended the demonstration of 16 February 2006 with a view to preventing violence, since he was the head of the DTP (Party for a Democratic Society) at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Batman Magistrates' Court ordered the applicant's remand in custody.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 24 March 2006, the Batman public prosecutor decided to transfer the investigation to the Diyarbakır public prosecutor's office.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Batman public prosecutor held that the offence which the applicant had committed, namely membership of a terrorist organisation and carrying out membership activities, was not within the Batman public prosecutor's office's jurisdiction.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 26 April 2006, the Diyarbakır public prosecutor filed an indictment with the Diyarbakır Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Diyarbakır public prosecutor charged the applicant and a certain M.G. under Article 220 § 8 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) with disseminating propaganda in favour of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party) on ten occasions.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "In the indictment, the Diyarbakır public prosecutor listed a total of ten marches and demonstrations which the applicant had attended.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Diyarbakır public prosecutor noted that during those marches and demonstrations, demonstrators had chanted slogans and carried banners praising the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party) and its leader, Abdullah Öcalan.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Diyarbakır public prosecutor noted that the applicant had made speeches in Kurdish at nine of the ten assemblies listed in the indictment.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 30 May 2006, the Diyarbakır Assize Court held the first hearing on the merits of the case.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "During the first hearing on 30 May 2006, the applicant contended that he was the head of the Batman branch of the DTP (Party for a Democratic Society).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant stated that although he had participated in the public meetings indicated in the indictment, he had not chanted any slogans or carried banners containing illegal expressions.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant submitted that he had not directed demonstrators to commit any illegal acts.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicant stressed that in general he attended such public meetings at the request of the security forces, since the security forces asked him to be present in order to prevent any possible clashes between themselves and the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "During the second hearing held on 18 July 2006, the Diyarbakır public prosecutor submitted his observations on the merits of the case.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Diyarbakır public prosecutor contended that the applicant had attended various illegal public meetings between 19 February 2005 and 16 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Diyarbakır public prosecutor contended that the applicant had made speeches in which he had praised the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party) and its leader.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Diyarbakır public prosecutor alleged that the events attended by the applicant had been organised either in line with the policies of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party) or under its instructions with a view to supporting that organisation.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Taking into account the intensity, variety and continuity of the applicant's activities, the Diyarbakır public prosecutor considered that the applicant's acts constituted knowingly and willingly aiding the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Diyarbakır public prosecutor asked the Diyarbakır Assize Court to convict the applicant under Articles 220 § 7 and 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) of membership of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 26 September 2006, the Diyarbakır Assize Court held the fourth and last hearing in the case.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 26 September 2006, the Diyarbakır Assize Court convicted the applicant and his co-accused M.G. of membership of an illegal organisation under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) on the basis of Articles 220 § 7 and 314 § 3 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found it established that the applicant had knowingly and willingly aided the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to six years and three months' imprisonment by the Diyarbakır Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court's judgment recorded that the applicant was alleged to have attended the reading out of a press statement and an illegal march held on 19 February 2005 in the Mem-u Zin Park in Batman, during which demonstrators chanted slogans in favour of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party) and Abdullah Öcalan.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court's judgment recorded that the applicant was alleged to have attended an event commemorating a deceased PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party) member held in the Batman cemetery on 31 March 2005, making a speech in Kurdish and making participants say prayers in Kurdish.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court's judgment recorded that the applicant was alleged to have attended the reading out of a press statement at the Batman branch of DEHAP (People's Democratic Party) on 16 August 2005 regarding the petition campaign entitled 'I accept Abdullah Öcalan as a political actor'.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court's judgment recorded that the applicant was alleged to have attended the illegal demonstration held on 22 August 2005 to commemorate seven members of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party) killed by the security forces in an armed clash which had occurred in Batman.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court's judgment recorded that the applicant was alleged to have attended the demonstration organised by DEHAP (People's Democratic Party) and held on 9 November 2005, during which demonstrators chanted illegal slogans, and to have made a speech in Kurdish addressed to the press and the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court's judgment recorded that the applicant was alleged to have attended the demonstration held on 16 November 2005, during which demonstrators chanted slogans in favour of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party) and Abdullah Öcalan and carried banners, and to have made a speech in Kurdish addressed to the press and the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court's judgment recorded that the applicant was alleged to have attended the demonstration held on 30 November 2005 protesting against the attempts to close down ROJ TV, the alleged solitary confinement of Abdullah Öcalan, and the statement by Deniz Baykal, the leader of the CHP (People's Republican Party), regarding the events that had occurred in Yüksekova, during which demonstrators chanted slogans in favour of Abdullah Öcalan, and to have made a speech in Kurdish addressed to the press and the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court's judgment recorded that the applicant was alleged to have attended the reading out of a press statement and a march held on 21 December 2005 protesting against the solitary confinement of Abdullah Öcalan, during which demonstrators chanted illegal slogans and carried banners, and to have made a speech in Kurdish addressed to the press and the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court's judgment recorded that the applicant was alleged to have attended the march and the reading out of a press statement held on 8 February 2006 in Batman, during which illegal slogans were chanted, and to have made a speech in Kurdish.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court's judgment recorded that the applicant was alleged to have attended the illegal demonstration and the reading out of a press statement held on 16 February 2006 close to the DTP (Party for a Democratic Society) Batman branch, during which illegal slogans were chanted and banners were carried, and to have made a speech in Kurdish.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "In his defence submissions before the Diyarbakır Assize Court, the applicant stated that he had participated in the demonstrations and the reading out of press statements mentioned in the indictment but that he had neither chanted slogans nor carried banners.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Diyarbakır Assize Court that he had attended those meetings at the request of the security forces and that the security forces had asked him to warn the crowds not to resist them and to work with them with a view to preventing possible disturbances.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The case file before the Diyarbakır Assize Court contained police reports, photographs and video recordings of the events which the applicant attended and the speeches he made.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found that during all the demonstrations and marches held in Batman which the applicant attended, slogans in favour of Abdullah Öcalan were chanted and demonstrators carried banners.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found that the speeches made by the applicant praised Abdullah Öcalan.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found it established that the applicant attended the public meetings in question and organised them.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found the applicant's defence submissions — that his aim had been to prevent clashes between demonstrators and security forces and that he had not intended to disseminate propaganda in favour of the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party) — to be baseless.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found it established that the applicant worked as the head of the Batman branch of DEHAP (People's Democratic Party) and that subsequent to the closure of DEHAP he was the head of the Batman branch of the DTP (Party for a Democratic Society).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found that the applicant attended ten marches and demonstrations held between 19 February 2005 and 16 February 2006, organised by DEHAP (People's Democratic Party) and DTP (Party for a Democratic Society).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found that illegal slogans were chanted and illegal banners were carried during the ten marches and demonstrations attended by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found that in some of those meetings, the applicant read press statements containing expressions praising Abdullah Öcalan.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found that all of the marches and demonstrations in question were illegal within the meaning of section 23/b of the Marches and Demonstrations Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found that all of the marches and demonstrations were organised in line with the 'Democratic Political Struggle' strategy adopted by the PKK (Kurdish Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found that media broadcasts in line with the PKK's (Kurdish Workers' Party) strategies had announced those marches and demonstrations prior to them, and that the same media organs had used those demonstrations as propaganda materials after they had been held.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found that the applicant and M.G. organised several illegal demonstrations in line with the PKK's (Kurdish Workers' Party) instructions and that during those demonstrations they addressed demonstrators who chanted slogans and carried banners containing expressions in favour of the PKK and Abdullah Öcalan.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court found that in their speeches the applicant and M.G. praised the PKK's (Kurdish Workers' Party) leader.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court considered that, taking into account the continuity and nature of the applicant's and M.G.'s acts, those acts went beyond the offence of dissemination of propaganda in favour of a terrorist organisation and amounted to the offence of 'knowingly and willingly aiding an illegal organisation without being in the hierarchical structure' proscribed by Article 220 § 7 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court decided to convict the applicant and M.G. under Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 13 April 2010, the Court of Cassation upheld the first-instance judgment of the Diyarbakır Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "By Law no. 6352, which entered into force on 5 July 2012, paragraph 7 of Article 220 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) was amended.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The applicant applied to the Diyarbakır Assize Court requesting it to examine whether the amended version of paragraph 7 of Article 220 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) could be considered to be in his favour.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The applicant requested the Diyarbakır Assize Court to examine whether, if the amended version of paragraph 7 of Article 220 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) was in his favour, the execution of his sentence could be suspended.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The applicant stated that he was currently serving his prison sentence at the time of his application to the Diyarbakır Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 16 August 2012, the Diyarbakır Assize Court decided to reduce the applicant's sentence to five years, two months and fifteen days' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Diyarbakır Assize Court rejected the applicant's request to have the execution of his sentence suspended.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "On 1 April 2005, Law no. 5237 (the Criminal Code) entered into force.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who establishes or directs an organisation for the purpose of criminal activity shall be liable to imprisonment of between two and six years, provided that the structure of the organisation, the number of members and the quantity of equipment and supplies are sufficient to commit the intended crimes.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who becomes a member of an organisation established for the purpose of criminal activity shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between one and three years.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 3 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that if the organisation is armed, the sentences stated in paragraphs 1 and 2 shall be increased by between one quarter and one half.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 4 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that any crime committed within the framework of the organisation's activities shall be punished separately.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 5 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that the heads of such an organisation shall also be sentenced as perpetrators of all crimes committed within the framework of the organisation's activities.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who commits a crime on behalf of an illegal organisation, even if he is not a member of that organisation, shall also be punished for being a member of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 7 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who aids an illegal organisation knowingly and willingly, even if he does not belong to the hierarchical structure of the organisation, shall be punished as a member of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "At the material time, Article 220 § 8 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provided that anyone who spreads propaganda for the organisation or its objectives shall be punished by a term of imprisonment of between one and three years, and if the said crime is committed through the press or other media the sentence shall be increased by one half.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article 220 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) were amended by Law no. 6352, which entered into force on 2 July 2012.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "As amended by Law no. 6352, Article 220 § 6 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who commits a crime on behalf of an illegal organisation, even if he is not a member of that organisation, shall also be punished for being a member of the organisation, and the penalty to be imposed for membership may be reduced by up to half.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "As amended by Law no. 6352, Article 220 § 7 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who aids an illegal organisation knowingly and willingly, even if he does not belong to the hierarchical structure of the organisation, shall be punished as a member of the organisation, and the penalty to be imposed for membership may be reduced by up to two thirds, depending on the nature of the assistance.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "Article 314 § 1 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who forms an armed organisation to commit the crimes listed in the fourth and fifth sections of the relevant chapter, or commands such an organisation, shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between ten and fifteen years.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Article 314 § 2 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that anyone who becomes a member of an armed organisation mentioned in Article 314 § 1 shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between five and ten years.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Article 314 § 3 of the Criminal Code (Law no. 5237) provides that other provisions relating to the crime of establishing an organisation for the purpose of criminal activity are also applicable to the crime of membership of an armed organisation.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (Law no. 5237)"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Between 7 August 2003 and 18 July 2006, section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) provided that any person who assists members of terrorist organisations or who disseminates propaganda inciting violence or other methods of terrorism shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of one to five years and a judicial fine of five million liras to one billion liras.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The first sentence of section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) was amended by Law no. 5532, which entered into force on 18 July 2006, to provide that any person who disseminates propaganda in favour of a terrorist organisation shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of one to five years.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The first sentence of section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713), as amended on 30 April 2013 by Law no. 6459, currently provides that any person who disseminates propaganda in favour of a terrorist organisation by justifying, praising or encouraging the use of methods constituting coercion, violence or threats shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of one to five years.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "At its 106th plenary session, held on 11 and 12 March 2016, the Venice Commission (European Commission for Democracy through Law) adopted an Opinion on Articles 216, 299, 301 and 314 of the Penal Code of Turkey (CDL-AD(2016)002).", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that the Penal Code of Turkey does not contain a definition of an armed organisation or an armed group.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that in its judgment E. 2006/10-253 K. 2007/80 of 3 April 2007, the General Criminal Board of the Court of Cassation of Turkey listed the main criteria that a criminal organisation — for the purposes of Article 220 of the Penal Code — should display: the group must have at least three members; there should be a tight or loose hierarchical connection between the members; an 'abstract link' between the members is not sufficient; the members should have a common intention to commit crimes even though no crime has yet been committed; the group must present continuity in time; and the structure of the group, the number of its members, tools and equipment should be sufficient for the commission of the envisaged crimes.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that the Court of Cassation of Turkey developed the criterion of 'membership' in an armed organisation by examining different acts of the suspect, taking account of their 'continuity, diversity and intensity', in order to determine whether those acts prove an 'organic relationship' with the organisation or whether the acts may be considered as committed knowingly and wilfully within the 'hierarchical structure' of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that if the 'organic relationship' with the organisation cannot be proven on the basis of acts attributed to the defendant which do not present any 'continuity, diversity or intensity', the paragraphs on 'aiding and abetting an armed organisation' or 'committing crime on behalf of an armed organisation' under Article 220 of the Penal Code may be applied.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that, according to non-governmental sources, in the application of Article 314 of the Penal Code of Turkey, domestic courts in many cases decide on the membership of a person in an armed organisation on the basis of very weak evidence, raising questions as to the 'foreseeability' of the application of Article 314.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that Amnesty International, in its 2013 Report on Turkey, considered that conduct which is not in itself criminal — such as activity related to the exercise of the rights to freedom of assembly, association and expression — is considered as evidence of membership of defendants in an armed organisation, and that individuals have been prosecuted for membership of a terrorist organisation on charges relating solely to their engagement in peaceful and lawful pro-Kurdish activities.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that examples of concrete cases provided by Amnesty International in which evidence was considered to link defendants to a terrorist organisation included attendance at six different demonstrations allegedly organised by a terrorist organisation and a speech made at one of those demonstrations, or participation in the 'Political Academy' organised by the Peace and Democracy Party (BDP) and diverse activities in the framework of that Academy.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that in the case of Yılmaz and Kılıç v. Turkey (application no. 68514/01), the European Court of Human Rights considered that where the only evidence which led to the criminal conviction of the applicants under Article 169 of the former Penal Code was forms of expression, it should be concluded that there was an interference with the applicants' right to freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that the European Court of Human Rights applied the same principle in the case of Gül and others v. Turkey (application no. 4870/02) and held that the criminal conviction of the applicants on the basis of Article 169 of the former Penal Code constituted an interference with their right to freedom of expression, since the only evidence used against them was the content of the slogans they shouted during a public demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion stated that conviction on the basis of weak evidence in the application of Article 314 of the Penal Code of Turkey may create problems in the field of Article 7 of the Convention, since that provision embodies the principle that criminal law must not be extensively construed to an accused's detriment.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion stated that where the only evidence which led domestic courts to convict a defendant for being a member of an armed organisation consists of forms of expression, reliance on weak evidence may also give rise to problems concerning the 'foreseeability' of the interference with the right to freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion stated that any allegation of membership of an armed organisation must be established with convincing evidence and beyond any reasonable doubt.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Venice Commission recommended that the established criteria in the case law of the Court of Cassation of Turkey — that acts attributed to a defendant should show 'in their continuity, diversity and intensity' an 'organic relationship' to an organisation, or prove that the defendant acted knowingly and willingly within the 'hierarchical structure' of the organisation — should be applied strictly.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The Venice Commission stated that the loose application of the criteria of 'continuity, diversity and intensity' may give rise to issues concerning the principle of legality within the meaning of Article 7 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The Venice Commission recommended that the expression of an opinion in its different forms should not be the only evidence before domestic courts to decide on the membership of a defendant in an armed organisation.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Venice Commission stated that where the only evidence consists of forms of expression, a conviction for being a member of an armed organisation would constitute an interference with the right to freedom of expression, and that the necessity of this interference should be examined in the concrete circumstances of each case on the basis of the criteria set forth in the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights, in particular the criterion of 'incitement to violence'.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that paragraph 3 of Article 314 of the Penal Code of Turkey provides that all other provisions related to the crime of establishing an organization to commit a crime will be applied in conjunction with Article 314.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that in many recent judgments of the Court of Cassation of Turkey, Article 314 of the Penal Code was applied in conjunction with paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article 220, on the basis of the reference made in Article 314(3) to 'other provisions' related to forming a criminal organisation.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that in a judgment of 4 March 2008, the General Criminal Board of the Court of Cassation of Turkey held that acts such as participating in a public demonstration following a general call from pro-PKK media outlets, making a victory sign and shouting slogans to support the leader of a terrorist organisation, and clashing with the security forces, are considered crimes committed on behalf of the terrorist organisation, and that the defendant was convicted as a member of a criminal organisation under paragraph 6 of Article 220 applied in conjunction with Article 314, although membership in an armed organisation was not established.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that in the judgment of 4 March 2008, the Court of Cassation of Turkey annulled the decision of the Diyarbakır Assize Court, which had considered that in order for a court to conclude that a crime was committed on behalf of an organisation, the organisation must have called for action not to an undefined collective, but rather to an individual person capable of directly committing that act.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that in a judgment of 24 March 2011, the 9th Chamber of the Court of Cassation of Turkey held that participation in an illegal public demonstration following a general call of an armed organisation on its internet site, covering one's face during a demonstration to hide identity, and shouting slogans in support of the armed organisation were considered as committing crimes on behalf of an armed organisation, and the defendant was convicted as a member of an armed organisation under Article 220(6) in conjunction with Article 314, although his membership was not proven.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that Article 220(7) of the Penal Code of Turkey, concerning aiding and abetting an organisation knowingly and willingly, was also applied to cases involving freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that in the Nedim Şener case, the applicant was prosecuted under Article 314(3) in conjunction with Article 220(7) for having contributed, at the request of suspected members of a criminal organisation, to the preparation of books criticising the actions of the government.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that in a judgment of 4 June 2012, the Court of Cassation of Turkey found that defendants who, in the framework of a campaign instigated by a terrorist organisation on its internet sites, prepared a declaration stating 'If it is a crime to refer to Öcalan as Mr. Öcalan, I hereby commit this crime and I denounce myself to the authorities' and collected signatures for this declaration, were considered to have been 'knowingly and willingly aiding the criminal organisation'.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that defendants who are considered to have committed crimes on behalf of an armed organisation under paragraph 6 of Article 220 of the Penal Code, or to have aided and abetted an armed organisation knowingly and willingly under paragraph 7 of Article 220, are also sentenced for the offence of being a member of that organisation under Article 314, although their 'organic relationship' with the armed organisation cannot be proven.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The Venice Commission's Opinion noted that a new paragraph was added to Article 7 of the Anti-Terror Law no. 3713 by an amendment of 11 April 2013, providing that those who committed the crime of propaganda in support of a terrorist organisation under Article 7(2), the crime of printing and disseminating declarations by terrorist organisations under Article 6(2), or the crime of participating in an unlawful demonstration under Article 28(1) of the Public Demonstrations Law no. 2911, shall not be sentenced separately under Article 220(6) of the Penal Code.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The Venice Commission welcomed the amendment introduced to Article 7 of the Anti-Terror Law no. 3713, which excluded the above-mentioned crimes from the scope of application of Article 220(6) of the Penal Code, so that suspects accused of having committed such crimes shall not be punished separately as members of an armed organisation under Article 314.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The Venice Commission considered that the scope of the amendment to Article 7 of the Anti-Terror Law no. 3713 is rather limited and does not provide sufficient protection to the exercise of freedom of expression and assembly, because the amendment excluded the mentioned crimes only from the scope of Article 220(6) but not from Article 220(7), which may lead to abusive application in practice.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The Venice Commission recommended that the sentence 'although he is not a member of that organisation, shall also be sentenced for the offence of being a member of that organisation' in paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article 220 of the Penal Code of Turkey be repealed, so that those who commit the crimes indicated in those paragraphs would not be sanctioned as members of an armed organisation under Article 314.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The Venice Commission stated that should the sentence in paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article 220 be maintained, the Turkish authorities should consider limiting the application of Article 220 in conjunction with Article 314 to cases which do not involve the exercise of the rights to freedom of expression and assembly.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "In a report published on 10 January 2012, Mr Thomas Hammarberg, the former Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, reported on a visit to Turkey between 10 and 14 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "1. Report of 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2)"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated that any allegation of terrorist activity must be established with convincing evidence and beyond any reasonable doubt, and that any deviation from established human rights principles in the fight against terrorism ultimately serves the interests of terrorist organisations.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "1. Report of 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2)"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Mr Thomas Hammarberg stated that violence or the threat to use violence is an essential component of an act of terrorism, and that restrictions of human rights in the fight against terrorism must be defined as precisely as possible and be necessary and proportionate to the aim pursued.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "1. Report of 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2)"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Mr Thomas Hammarberg considered that the provisions contained in the Turkish anti-terror legislation and Article 220 of the Turkish Criminal Code allow for a very wide margin of appreciation, in particular in cases where membership in a terrorist organisation has not been proven and when an act or statement may be deemed to coincide with the aims or instructions of a terrorist organisation.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "1. Report of 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2)"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Mr Thomas Hammarberg encouraged the Turkish authorities to reflect on and address the concerns about the wide margin of appreciation allowed by Turkish anti-terror legislation and Article 220 of the Turkish Criminal Code through legislative measures and/or case-law.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "1. Report of 10 January 2012 (CommDH(2012)2)"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "In a memorandum on freedom of expression and media freedom in Turkey published on 15 February 2017 (CommDH(2017)5), Mr Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, reported on a visit to Turkey between 6 and 14 April 2016.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "2. Memorandum of 15 February 2017 ((CommDH(2017)5))"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Mr Nils Muižnieks stressed the need for a complete overhaul of the Turkish Criminal Code, including Article 220 §§ 6 and 7 and Article 314.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "2. Memorandum of 15 February 2017 ((CommDH(2017)5))"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Mr Nils Muižnieks considered that the overhaul of the Turkish Criminal Code should take full account of the European Court of Human Rights' case-law and the Venice Commission Opinion CDL-AD(2016)002.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe", "2. Memorandum of 15 February 2017 ((CommDH(2017)5))"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "On 1 November 2010, Human Rights Watch published a report entitled 'Protesting as a Terrorist Offence / The Arbitrary Use of Terrorism Laws to Prosecute and Incarcerate Demonstrators in Turkey'.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report of 1 November 2010 was seventy-five pages long and mainly concerned trials and convictions of demonstrators in Turkey under Laws nos. 5237 (Criminal Code), 2911 (Public Demonstrations Law) and 3713 (Prevention of Terrorism Act).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report stated that many hundreds of people in Turkey face prosecution or are serving substantial sentences for terrorism convictions for engaging in peaceful protest or throwing stones or burning a tire at a protest.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report stated that legal amendments since 2005, along with case law since 2008, have allowed courts in Turkey to convict demonstrators under the harshest terrorism laws by invoking Articles 220 and 314 of the Turkish Penal Code in combination with the Anti-Terror Law (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report stated that Article 220 of the Turkish Penal Code (Law no. 5237), entitled 'Forming Organized Groups with the Intention of Committing Crime', has been most commonly used to punish criminal gangs, but courts have also applied it to those deemed to be associated with armed political organizations.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report stated that Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code provides that a person who aids and abets an organisation knowingly and willingly, although not belonging to the hierarchical structure of the organisation, shall be punished as though a member of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report stated that Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code has in some cases been applied to leftist demonstrators who have been punished as 'members' of armed organizations for 'knowingly and willingly aiding' them without providing any material assistance.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The Human Rights Watch report stated that Turkish Penal Code Articles 220/6 and 220/7 are so vaguely worded and lacking in clarity about what is prohibited as to offer an individual no indication of how to regulate or limit conduct.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "Human Rights Watch recommended that the Turkish Government urgently amend Article 220 of the Turkish Penal Code and repeal Articles 220/6 and 220/7, which are vague, lack legal clarity and specificity, and are therefore subject to arbitrary application.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "Human Rights Watch recommended that the Turkish Government set up a review board to examine all cases concluded under Articles 220/6 and 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code for compliance with international human rights law obligations, with a view to quashing sentences under Articles 314/2 and 314/3 in connection with Articles 220/6 and 220/7.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "1. Report of Human Rights Watch of 1 November 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "On 27 March 2013, Amnesty International published a report entitled 'Turkey: Decriminalize Dissent / Time to deliver on the Right to Freedom of Expression'.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The Amnesty International report stated that Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code criminalises assisting a terrorist organisation and is a self-standing offence that does not require the commission of a further criminal act.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The Amnesty International report stated that Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code allows for the sentencing of those convicted under it as though they were members of the organisation they are found to have assisted.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The Amnesty International report stated that Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code is often used to prosecute conduct protected by the rights to freedom of expression, association and assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The Amnesty International report stated that the choice of prosecutors to prosecute under Article 220/6 or Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code often appears arbitrary, with similar behaviour sometimes prosecuted under one, sometimes under the other, and sometimes under Article 314 directly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The Amnesty International report stated that when prosecutors seek to convict a person under Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code, they often do not provide evidence demonstrating a link to a terrorist organisation, nor do they attempt to prove that the accused was engaged in any criminal offence or in aiding and abetting, other than supposedly assisting the proscribed organisation.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "Amnesty International stated that it is incumbent on the Turkish authorities to ensure that Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code is not used to bring prosecutions that violate the rights to freedom of expression, association and assembly or other human rights.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "Amnesty International stated that no inference should be drawn from someone undertaking a lawful act — such as participating in a peaceful demonstration — even if such acts benefit, through lawful means, goals shared by a terrorist organisation, and that anyone carrying out a lawful act which does not aid and abet the planning or commission of a crime should not be criminalised on the sole basis of their political convictions.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "Amnesty International urged the Turkish government to adopt guidelines for prosecutors on the application of Article 220/7 of the Turkish Penal Code that set out clear criteria for when assisting an armed group can be criminalised, including the requirement that such assistance must either in and of itself be a recognisable criminal offence, or be directly linked to the planning or commission of one.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Non-governmental Organisations' Reports", "2. Report of Amnesty International of 27 March 2013"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F039", "F053", "F054", "F075", "F079", "F072", "F077", "F082", "F003", "F004", "F074", "F083"], "interference": ["F054", "F039", "F075", "F056", "F090", "F089"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F099", "F092", "F057", "F058", "F098", "F129", "F131", "F085", "F075", "F079", "F071", "F083", "F113", "F104", "F105", "F003", "F004", "F074", "F056", "F090"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F039", "F075", "F003", "F074"], "interference": ["F054", "F056", "F090"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F099", "F098", "F129", "F085", "F083", "F075", "F079", "F113", "F105", "F056", "F092", "F057", "F058", "F003", "F074"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F039", "F075", "F003", "F074", "F083", "F054", "F099", "F129", "F085", "F105", "F056"]}} {"case_name": "case_335", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1974.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The facts of the case are in dispute between the applicant and the Government.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The facts as presented by the applicant are set out in Section B of the judgment (paragraphs 6-8).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Government's submissions concerning the facts are summarised in Section C of the judgment (paragraphs 9-13).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The documentary evidence submitted by the applicant and the Government is summarised in Section D of the judgment (paragraphs 14-26).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 6 March 2005 the applicant took part in a demonstration to mark the Women's Day celebrations in Beyazıt Square in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "During the demonstration on 6 March 2005 in Beyazıt Square, a large number of police officers formed a ring around the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "During the demonstration on 6 March 2005 in Beyazıt Square, police officers did not prevent people from entering the square.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "During the demonstration on 6 March 2005 in Beyazıt Square, police officers did not interfere with the demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Women's Day celebrations on 6 March 2005 ended with a press release issued by a number of women's organisations.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "When the crowds began to disperse after the Women's Day celebrations on 6 March 2005, police officers started hitting people, including the applicant, with their truncheons and the ends of their weapons.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "When the crowds began to disperse after the Women's Day celebrations on 6 March 2005, police officers sprayed people, including the applicant, with tear gas.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "As a result of blows to her head, face and other parts of her body, the applicant fell to the ground during the incident on 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Whilst the applicant was on the ground, police officers continued to kick and hit her with their sticks.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Police officers swore at the applicant and insulted her during the incident on 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant was seriously injured during the incident on 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant was left semi-conscious as a result of the incident on 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant had to be helped by a member of the public to leave the area after the incident on 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The incident on 6 March 2005 was widely publicised in the national and international media.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 18 February 2005 the office of the Governor of Istanbul was informed that a demonstration would be held in Beyazıt Square on 6 March 2005 to celebrate Women's Day.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The request to hold the Women's Day celebrations in Beyazıt Square on 6 March 2005 was rejected.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 23 February 2005 the organising committee was informed by letter that the Women's Day celebrations could be held in Çağlayan Square in the Şişli district of Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 23 February 2005 the organising committee was informed by letter that the Women's Day celebrations could be held in Beykoz Field in the Beykoz district of Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 6 March 2005 people began gathering at different locations in order to march towards Beyazıt Square.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Members of the security forces told people gathering on 6 March 2005 that they would not be allowed to march towards Beyazıt Square because it would obstruct the flow of traffic.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "Members of the security forces waited for 20-25 minutes for the demonstrators to disperse on 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "During the 20-25 minute waiting period on 6 March 2005, some of the demonstrators left the area.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Those demonstrators who remained on 6 March 2005 blocked the traffic and insisted on marching to Beyazıt Square.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Members of the security forces intervened on 6 March 2005 and reopened the road that had been blocked by demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "At around 11.30 a.m. on 6 March 2005 the dispersed groups gathered in Beyazıt Square and read out a press statement.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "At 1 p.m. on 6 March 2005, after the press statement had been read out, a group of approximately sixty persons refused to leave Beyazıt Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "When the police warned the group of approximately sixty persons who refused to leave Beyazıt Square, the demonstrators responded by throwing stones at the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "As a result of demonstrators throwing stones at police officers, the police officers arrested a number of the demonstrators and took them into custody by using force.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant was not arrested during the incident on 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "During the incident on 6 March 2005, seven police officers were injured by the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "During the incident on 6 March 2005, many police cars were damaged by the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Government submitted to the Court video footage of the events of 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The video footage submitted by the Government is a compilation of news aired by national television channels.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The video footage submitted by the Government includes the official video recording of the events of 6 March 2005 made by a police cameraman.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The video footage shows police officers wearing gas masks hitting with their truncheons a large number of demonstrators who try to run away from the area.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The video footage shows demonstrators who had fallen to the ground being kicked and hit with truncheons by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The video footage shows a male demonstrator who uses his body to protect a woman on the ground being kicked in the face by a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The video footage shows police officers spraying demonstrators hiding in bushes with tear gas before hitting them with their truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The video footage shows two women on the ground trying to protect themselves from attacks by police officers being sprayed with tear gas.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The video footage shows women who had taken refuge in nearby shops and cafes being dragged out by the police and beaten up.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The video footage shows a number of shoppers, shopkeepers and other persons who had not been demonstrating but who had been in the area and were affected by the intense tear gas, wandering around in a confused state.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "An expert was appointed by the domestic investigating authorities to examine the video footage of the events of 6 March 2005 and prepare a report.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "According to the report prepared by the expert appointed by the domestic investigating authorities, police officers had not issued any warnings to the demonstrators to disperse before attacking them on 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "According to the report prepared by the expert appointed by the domestic investigating authorities, the demonstrators had not resisted the police intervention on 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "According to the report prepared by the expert appointed by the domestic investigating authorities, the demonstrators had not attacked the police on 6 March 2005 but had simply tried to run away from the area.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "According to the report prepared by the expert appointed by the domestic investigating authorities, police had hit the demonstrators — including those who had fallen to the ground — with their truncheons, kicked them, punched them and sprayed them with tear gas on 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 8 March 2005 the applicant submitted a written request to the Bakırköy prosecutor requesting a medical examination.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The applicant alleged in her written request to the Bakırköy prosecutor that excessive force had been used by the police officers during the incident on 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The applicant alleged in her written request to the Bakırköy prosecutor that as a result of the excessive force used by police officers on 6 March 2005, various parts of her body had been injured.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Bakırköy prosecutor referred the applicant to the Forensic Medicine Institute for a medical examination.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "A medical examination of the applicant was carried out on 8 March 2005 at the Bakırköy branch of the Forensic Medicine Institute.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "According to the report of the medical examination carried out at the Bakırköy branch of the Forensic Medicine Institute on 8 March 2005, a large number of ecchymosed areas of various sizes were present on the applicant's body, including her left upper arm, right forearm, left femur, buttocks and knees.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The doctor who conducted the medical examination at the Bakırköy branch of the Forensic Medicine Institute on 8 March 2005 concluded that the applicant's injuries would prevent her from working for a period of five days.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 11 March 2005 the applicant lodged an official complaint with the Istanbul prosecutor against the Governor of Istanbul and the police officers responsible for her ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "In her complaint to the Istanbul prosecutor, the applicant pointed out that, according to the applicable legislation, no prior notice or permission was necessary to read out a press release.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "In her complaint to the Istanbul prosecutor, the applicant requested, inter alia, that the Governor of Istanbul and the police chiefs who abused their duties by not allowing her to enjoy her right to assembly be put on trial.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In her complaint to the Istanbul prosecutor, the applicant requested that the police officers who had ill-treated her be put on trial.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The applicant complained to the Istanbul prosecutor that excessive force and tear gas had been used by the police officers against her and against her fellow demonstrators when they were dispersing and leaving the area of their own accord on 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicant noted in her complaint to the Istanbul prosecutor that footage shown on television channels and photographs published in newspapers had showed the scale of the incident of 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 8 April 2005 the Chief Prosecutor at the Court of Cassation concluded that the applicant had not mentioned a specific incident that could be attributed to the Governor of Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 8 April 2005 a decision was made not to prosecute the Governor of Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 6 June 2005 the disciplinary board of the police considered that six police officers had kicked the demonstrators and had also hit them with their truncheons during the incident of 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The disciplinary board of the police held that the six police officers' actions during the incident of 6 March 2005 amounted to 'degrading behaviour'.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The disciplinary board of the police decided to 'condemn' the actions of three police chiefs for failing to train the six police officers properly.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The disciplinary board of the police imposed a fine equivalent to three days' salary on the six police officers who had kicked the demonstrators and hit them with their truncheons during the incident of 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 12 December 2005 the Istanbul prosecutor decided not to bring criminal proceedings against forty-four police officers for the offence of abuse of duty in respect of victims and complainants whose bodies did not bear any injuries.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "In the Istanbul prosecutor's decision of 12 December 2005, thirty-nine persons, including the applicant, were named as victims and complainants.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The applicant lodged an objection against the Istanbul prosecutor's decision of 12 December 2005 not to bring criminal proceedings against forty-four police officers, in which she repeated her complaints about the excessive use of force against her.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The applicant's objection against the Istanbul prosecutor's decision of 12 December 2005 was rejected on 28 September 2007 by the Beyoğlu Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 9 December 2005 the Istanbul prosecutor filed an indictment with the Istanbul Criminal Court of First Instance accusing a total of fifty-four police officers of the offence of causing injuries by exceeding the limits of their powers on the use of force.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "In the indictment filed on 9 December 2005, forty-nine persons, including the applicant, were listed as victims and complainants.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The indictment filed on 9 December 2005 made references to a report which had been forwarded to the Istanbul prosecutor on 28 April 2005 pertaining to an investigation conducted by four senior police inspectors in the immediate aftermath of the events of 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "According to the indictment filed on 9 December 2005, the inspectors' report concluded that seven of the fifty-four police officers named as suspects in the indictment had used excessive force against fifteen of the complainants and victims, including the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "According to the indictment filed on 9 December 2005, the four senior police inspectors considered that the seven officers had not used their truncheons in accordance with the applicable regulations.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "According to the indictment filed on 9 December 2005, the four senior police inspectors considered that the seven officers had kicked a number of female demonstrators who had already been neutralised.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The trial before the Fourth Division of the Istanbul Criminal Court of First Instance began in 2005.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The trial before the Fourth Division of the Istanbul Criminal Court of First Instance was concluded on 12 May 2011.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The trial court noted that the victims and complainants complained of having been injured when the defendant police officers kicked them, punched them and hit them with their truncheons and shields.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The trial court noted that the victims and complainants complained of having been excessively sprayed with tear gas by the defendant police officers.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The trial court noted that the victims and complainants stated that the defendant police officers had been wearing gas masks and hiding the identification numbers on their uniforms.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The trial court noted that the victims and complainants stated that the attacks had taken place very suddenly and when they had already been affected by tear gas, making it impossible to identify the police officers individually.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The defendant police officers submitted to the trial court that they had not committed the offence with which they were charged.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The defendant police officers maintained before the trial court that the demonstrators had been harming public order by insisting on continuing with the reading out of their press release and by attacking the police with iron bars.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The defendant police officers maintained before the trial court that the force used by them against the demonstrators had not been disproportionate.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Six of the defendant police officers accepted during the preliminary investigation stage that they had kicked the demonstrators from behind.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The lawyers defending the six defendant police officers submitted during the trial that the self-implicating statements had been taken from the police officers by the inspectors under duress and as a result of the press coverage of the incidents.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The lawyers defending the six defendant police officers submitted during the trial that the inspectors questioning the police officers had acted contrary to the applicable procedure.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The defendant police officers maintained before the trial court that the medical reports, while establishing that the incidents had taken place, were insufficient to establish the identities of the police officers, and that the victims should have been required to identify them first.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The defendant police officers maintained before the trial court that the offences in question were time-barred and the proceedings against them should have been discontinued.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "In his final submissions during the trial, the prosecutor agreed with the defendants and argued that the defendants should be acquitted because the victims had been unable to identify the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The trial court found that the defendants' objections based on the statute of limitations should be rejected, as proceedings against them would be time-barred five years after the last defence submissions were made by them on 8 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The trial court noted that the large numbers of defendants and victims, coupled with the fact that this was a large-scale incident, resulted in delays in obtaining all the evidence.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The trial court noted that the trial was also delayed as a result of the defendants' covering their faces with helmets and not displaying their identification numbers.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The trial court found, having examined the video footage of the events as well as the reports and witness statements, that it was not possible to expect the victims to identify the police officers who attacked them because it was not possible to recognise the police officers in the video footage.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The inspectors who had questioned the police officers were heard in the course of the trial proceedings and confirmed the authenticity and accuracy of the statements they had taken from the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The trial court found that the inspectors' statements were corroborated by the video footage which shows the punching, kicking, hitting with truncheons and shields, and using an excessive amount of tear gas.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The trial court found that in the Saraçhane area, the police did not interfere in the demonstration until the demonstrators started walking on the road where there was traffic circulation, and that intervention was made with a view to maintaining public order.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The trial court found that the video footage shows police intervention against people who had already surrendered themselves to the police or who had been hiding in bushes after having been sprayed with tear gas, occurring not on the road but off it.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The trial court found that in Beyazıt Square, the video footage shows a scuffle between the police and demonstrators carrying banners.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The trial court found that the video footage shows the police kicking and hitting with their truncheons and shields persons — mostly women — who try to run away from the scene and who are not carrying any banners, in Beyazıt Square.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The trial court found, based on statements taken from the police officers by the inspectors, that defendants M.C. and A.O.P. had kicked from behind two female demonstrators who had in their hands nothing to pose a danger to the two officers.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The trial court found, based on statements taken from the police officers by the inspectors, that defendant S.B. used excessive force against a woman who had taken refuge in a café.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The trial court found, based on statements taken from the police officers by the inspectors, that defendant C.U. hit a female demonstrator on her shoulder and broke one of her bones.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The trial court found, based on statements taken from the police officers by the inspectors, that defendant Y.K. kicked a demonstrator who had been trying to seek help from the police after having been sprayed with tear gas.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The trial court found, based on statements taken from the police officers by the inspectors, that defendant E.B. kicked a person who had already been arrested.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The trial court found that some of the defendant police officers exceeded the limits of their powers on the use of force and used excessive force.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The trial court concluded that police officers M.C., A.O.P., S.B., Y.K. and E.B. had used excessive force against the demonstrators and committed the offence of ill-treatment defined in section 245 of the Criminal Code then in force (Law No. 765).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The trial court sentenced police officers M.C., A.O.P., S.B., Y.K. and E.B. to terms of imprisonment ranging from five to ten months.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The trial court found police officer C.U. guilty of the offence of causing grievous bodily harm while using his powers as a public official, an offence defined in section 86 § 3 of the Criminal Code now in force (Law No. 5237), for having broken a bone of one of the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The trial court sentenced police officer C.U. to twenty-one months' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The remaining forty-eight defendant police officers were acquitted by the trial court for lack of evidence.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "According to information provided to the Court by the Government on 10 November 2011, the criminal proceedings against the police officers were discontinued on 8 September 2011 on account of the statute of limitations.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Section 245 of the Criminal Code in force at the material time (Law No. 765) provided that any law-enforcement officer who, in the course of duty and in circumstances other than those prescribed by law, ill-treats, injures or hits a person or inflicts on them bodily harm, shall be sentenced to between three months' and five years' imprisonment and temporarily barred from public service.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Section 86(1) of the Criminal Code now in force (Law No. 5237) provides that a person who intentionally causes physical suffering to another person, or harms that other person's physical or mental health, shall be sentenced to between one and three years' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Section 86(2)(c) of the Criminal Code now in force (Law No. 5237) provides that if the offence of intentionally causing bodily harm is committed by virtue of execution of public duties, the offender shall be prosecuted without waiting for an official complaint from the victim and sentenced to between two and five years' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Section 10 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law No. 2911) provides that in order for a meeting to take place, the governor's office or authorities of the district in which the demonstration is planned must be informed, during opening hours and at least seventy-two hours prior to the meeting, by a notice containing the signature of all the members of the organising board.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Section 22 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law No. 2911) prohibits demonstrations and processions on public streets, in parks, places of worship and buildings in which public services are based.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Section 22 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law No. 2911) provides that demonstrations organised in public squares must comply with security instructions and not disrupt individuals' movement or public transport.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Section 24 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law No. 2911) provides that demonstrations and processions which do not comply with the provisions of the Act will be dispersed by force on the order of the governor's office and after the demonstrators have been warned.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Section 32(1) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law No. 2911), as it read before it was amended in 2008 and 2010, provided that unarmed persons taking part in an unlawful meeting or procession who, instead of dispersing of their own motion after having been warned or ordered to do so and who thus have to be forcefully dispersed by government forces, are liable to be sentenced to a term of imprisonment of between one and three years.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Section 32(2) of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law No. 2911), as it read before it was amended in 2008 and 2010, provided that unless their action breaches another criminal law provision which stipulates a more severe punishment, persons who resort to violence or making threats while being dispersed, or who resist the attempts to disperse them, are liable to be sentenced to a term of imprisonment of between three and five years.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "On 15 February 2008 the Ministry of the Interior issued a directive to law enforcement personnel on the use of tear gases (Circular No. 19).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Ministry of the Interior's Circular No. 19 notes that, according to section 16 § 3(b) of the Law on the Duties and Powers of the Police (Law No. 2559), tear gases are listed among the weapons which law enforcement officials are permitted to use in the execution of their duties.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The Ministry of the Interior's Circular No. 19 sets out the circumstances in which tear gases may be used — both in open and confined spaces — and explains how best to obtain the maximum benefit from their use.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The Ministry of the Interior's Circular No. 19 stipulates that tear gases may not be used against persons who have stopped putting up resistance.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The Ministry of the Interior's Circular No. 19 recommends that law enforcement personnel be prepared to provide first aid to those affected by tear gas.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "According to an information note issued by the Turkish Medical Association (Türk Tabipleri Birliği) in June 2013, CS (chlorobenzylidenemalononitrile) and CN (chloroacetophenone) gases are used by law-enforcement officials in Turkey.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "According to the Turkish Medical Association's information note of June 2013, CS and CN gases damage the eyes, cause burns on the skin, severely affect the respiratory system and the lungs, restrict breathing, slow down the heart beat and cause fluctuations in blood pressure.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "According to the Turkish Medical Association's information note of June 2013, prolonged contact with CS and CN gases permanently damages the cornea of the eye, upsets the heart rhythm, and has caused damage to the lungs which has led to deaths.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "According to the Turkish Medical Association's information note of June 2013, the effects of CS and CN gases are more pronounced in children, pregnant women and persons with existing respiratory problems, heart problems, aneurysms, allergies and weak immune systems.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "According to the Turkish Medical Association's information note of June 2013, sudden allergic oedema caused in the upper respiratory systems by CS and CN gases, as well as use of gases on persons with asthma or bronchitis, may be fatal.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "According to expert reports referenced in the Turkish Medical Association's information note of June 2013, fatal doses of gases were used in operations conducted in 20 prisons in Turkey on 19 December 2000, during which 32 persons lost their lives and hundreds were injured.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "According to the Turkish Medical Association's information note of June 2013, on 1 May 2007 a seventy-five-year-old man who was sprayed with gas in Turkey lost his life.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "According to the Turkish Medical Association's information note of June 2013, such gases have been used extensively in two incidents in 2011 during which two persons lost their lives.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "On 3 June 2013 the Respiratory Society of Turkey (Türkiye Solunum Araştırmaları Derneği; TÜSAD) issued a press release to inform the public about the dangers of tear gas and about the steps to be taken after contact with tear gas.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "According to the Respiratory Society of Turkey's press release of 3 June 2013, tear gas affects primarily the mucus membranes, in particular the eyes, throat, respiratory system and the nose.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "According to the Respiratory Society of Turkey's press release of 3 June 2013, on contact tear gas immediately causes a general feeling of burning; discomfort and excessive watering of the eyes; pain and a feeling of burning of the skin and in the nose and throat; coughing; breathing difficulties; extreme restlessness and discomfort; and temporary blindness.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "According to the Respiratory Society of Turkey's press release of 3 June 2013, although tear gas does not cause permanent damage in the organs with which it comes into contact, its acute effects are extremely discomforting and lead to panic.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "According to the Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and on their Destruction of 13 January 1993 (the CWC), tear gas is not considered a chemical weapon and its use is authorised for the purpose of law enforcement, including domestic riot control, under Article II § 9(d).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and on their Destruction of 13 January 1993 (the CWC) entered into force with regard to Turkey on 11 June 1997.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Principle 3 of the Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials (Eighth United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders, Havana, 1990) provides that the development and deployment of non-lethal incapacitating weapons should be carefully evaluated in order to minimize the risk of endangering uninvolved persons, and the use of such weapons should be carefully controlled.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Principle 5 of the Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials (Eighth United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders, Havana, 1990) provides that whenever the lawful use of force and firearms is unavoidable, law enforcement officials shall exercise restraint in such use and act in proportion to the seriousness of the offence and the legitimate objective to be achieved.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "Principle 5 of the Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials (Eighth United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders, Havana, 1990) provides that whenever the lawful use of force and firearms is unavoidable, law enforcement officials shall minimize damage and injury, and respect and preserve human life.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "Principle 5 of the Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials (Eighth United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders, Havana, 1990) provides that whenever the lawful use of force and firearms is unavoidable, law enforcement officials shall ensure that assistance and medical aid are rendered to any injured or affected persons at the earliest possible moment.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "Principle 5 of the Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials (Eighth United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders, Havana, 1990) provides that whenever the lawful use of force and firearms is unavoidable, law enforcement officials shall ensure that relatives or close friends of the injured or affected person are notified at the earliest possible moment.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "Principle 9 of the Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials (Eighth United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders, Havana, 1990) provides that law enforcement officials shall not use firearms against persons except in self-defence or defence of others against the imminent threat of death or serious injury, to prevent the perpetration of a particularly serious crime involving grave threat to life, to arrest a person presenting such a danger and resisting their authority, or to prevent his or her escape, and only when less extreme means are insufficient to achieve these objectives, and that intentional lethal use of firearms may only be made when strictly unavoidable in order to protect life.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "Principle 12 of the Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials (Eighth United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders, Havana, 1990) provides that as everyone is allowed to participate in lawful and peaceful assemblies, Governments and law enforcement agencies and officials shall recognize that force and firearms may be used only in accordance with Principles 13 and 14.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Principle 13 of the Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials (Eighth United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders, Havana, 1990) provides that in the dispersal of assemblies that are unlawful but non-violent, law enforcement officials shall avoid the use of force or, where that is not practicable, shall restrict such force to the minimum extent necessary.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "Principle 14 of the Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials (Eighth United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders, Havana, 1990) provides that in the dispersal of violent assemblies, law enforcement officials may use firearms only when less dangerous means are not practicable and only to the minimum extent necessary, and shall not use firearms except under the conditions stipulated in Principle 9.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "Paragraph 35 of the Report of the Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association, Maina Kiai (UN Human Rights Council A/HRC/20/27, 21 May 2012) recalls that tear gas does not discriminate between demonstrators and non-demonstrators, healthy people and people with health conditions.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "Paragraph 35 of the Report of the Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association, Maina Kiai (UN Human Rights Council A/HRC/20/27, 21 May 2012) warns against any modification of the chemical composition of tear gas for the sole purpose of inflicting severe pain on protestors and, indirectly, bystanders.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "Paragraph 16 of the Concluding observations of the UN Committee against Torture on Denmark (CAT/C/DNK/CO/5, 16 July 2007) states that the Committee is concerned at reports of alleged excessive use of force, such as the use of physical violence and tear gas, by law enforcement officials during the 'Ungdomshus' Youth House riots in Copenhagen in March 2007.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "Paragraph 16 of the Concluding observations of the UN Committee against Torture on Denmark (CAT/C/DNK/CO/5, 16 July 2007) notes with concern reports suggesting that a number of persons had been killed by Danish law enforcement officials over the past two years.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "Paragraph 16 of the Concluding observations of the UN Committee against Torture on Denmark (CAT/C/DNK/CO/5, 16 July 2007) recommends that Denmark review the existing framework to handle allegations of excessive use of force by law enforcement officials to ensure its compliance with the Convention against Torture.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "Paragraph 16 of the Concluding observations of the UN Committee against Torture on Denmark (CAT/C/DNK/CO/5, 16 July 2007) recommends that Denmark ensure prompt and impartial investigations into all complaints or allegations of misconduct, in particular when a person dies or is seriously injured following contact with law enforcement officials.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "Paragraph 16 of the Concluding observations of the UN Committee against Torture on Denmark (CAT/C/DNK/CO/5, 16 July 2007) recommends that Denmark review and strengthen its education and training programmes relating to the use of force by law enforcement officials to ensure that the use of force is strictly limited to that required to perform their duties.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "Paragraph 13 of the Concluding observations of the UN Committee against Torture on Turkey (CAT/C/TUR/CO/3, 20 January 2011) notes the acknowledgement by the representative of Turkey of excessive use of force by law enforcement authorities and information on measures taken to eradicate such practice, including by inscribing identification numbers on the helmet of police officers during demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "Paragraph 13 of the Concluding observations of the UN Committee against Torture on Turkey (CAT/C/TUR/CO/3, 20 January 2011) states that the Committee remains concerned at reports indicating an increase in the excessive use of force and ill-treatment of demonstrators by police outside official detention places.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "Paragraph 13 of the Concluding observations of the UN Committee against Torture on Turkey (CAT/C/TUR/CO/3, 20 January 2011) recommends that Turkey promptly implement effective measures to put an end to excessive use of force and ill-treatment by law enforcement authorities.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "Paragraph 13(a) of the Concluding observations of the UN Committee against Torture on Turkey (CAT/C/TUR/CO/3, 20 January 2011) recommends that Turkey ensure that domestic laws, rules of engagement and standard operating procedures relating to public order and crowd control are fully in line with the Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials, in particular the provision that lethal use of firearms may only be made when strictly unavoidable in order to protect life.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (the CPT) has expressed its concerns over the use of pepper spray in law enforcement.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The CPT considers that pepper spray is a potentially dangerous substance and should not be used in confined spaces (CPT/Inf (2009) 25).", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The CPT considers that even when pepper spray is used in open spaces it has serious reservations, and that if exceptionally it needs to be used, there should be clearly defined safeguards in place, including that persons exposed to pepper spray should be granted immediate access to a medical doctor and be offered an antidote (CPT/Inf (2009) 25).", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The CPT considers that pepper spray should never be deployed against a prisoner who has already been brought under control (CPT/Inf (2009) 25).", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "In its reports pertaining to visits carried out in a number of Member States of the Council of Europe, the CPT has recommended that a clear directive governing the use of pepper spray be drawn up, which should include clear instructions as to when pepper spray may be used, stating explicitly that pepper spray should not be used in a confined area (CPT/Inf (2009) 8).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "In its reports pertaining to visits carried out in a number of Member States of the Council of Europe, the CPT has recommended that the directive on pepper spray include the right of prisoners exposed to pepper spray to be granted immediate access to a doctor and to be offered measures of relief (CPT/Inf (2009) 8).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "In its reports pertaining to visits carried out in a number of Member States of the Council of Europe, the CPT has recommended that the directive on pepper spray include information regarding the qualifications, training and skills of staff members authorised to use pepper spray (CPT/Inf (2009) 8).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "In its reports pertaining to visits carried out in a number of Member States of the Council of Europe, the CPT has recommended that the directive on pepper spray include an adequate reporting and inspection mechanism with respect to the use of pepper spray (CPT/Inf (2009) 8).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "In its 2005 Progress Report on Turkey (COM (2005) 561 final), the European Commission stated that while public demonstrations in Turkey are subject to fewer restrictions than in the past, a number of incidents have raised concerns, and that in several regions brutality by the security forces has been alleged in the context of demonstrations and outdoor NGO press statements.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "In its 2005 Progress Report on Turkey (COM (2005) 561 final), the European Commission stated that during the demonstration marking international Women's Day in Istanbul on 6 March 2005, police intervened with disproportionate force, using tear gas and truncheons and injuring a number of participants.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "In its 2005 Progress Report on Turkey (COM (2005) 561 final), the European Commission stated that the Turkish government quickly conveyed the message that such behaviour on the part of the police is unacceptable following the incident of 6 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "In its 2005 Progress Report on Turkey (COM (2005) 561 final), the European Commission stated that following the incident of 6 March 2005, the Ministry of Interior demoted and fined 6 policemen and reprimanded 3 senior officials.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "In its 2005 Progress Report on Turkey (COM (2005) 561 final), the European Commission stated that a judicial investigation launched by the Istanbul Public Prosecutor following the incident of 6 March 2005 was ongoing at the time of the report.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F007", "F011", "F041", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F072", "F035"], "interference": ["F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F017", "F018"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F122", "F123", "F124", "F125", "F022"], "legitimate_aim": ["F022", "F029", "F030"], "necessity": ["F035", "F072", "F073", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F091", "F112", "F113", "F104", "F106", "F017", "F020"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F007", "F051"], "interference": ["F012", "F013", "F017"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F122", "F125"], "legitimate_aim": ["F022"], "necessity": ["F051", "F091", "F112", "F035", "F041", "F104"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F007", "F051", "F091", "F112", "F035", "F041", "F122", "F022"]}} {"case_name": "case_337", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1977.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The opposition planned to hold a demonstration on 17 November 2012 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The opposition planned to hold a demonstration on 26 January 2013 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 12 November 2012, the organisers gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority about the demonstration planned for 17 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "No prior notice was given to the Baku City Executive Authority by the organisers of the demonstration of 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Information about the demonstration of 26 January 2013 was disseminated through Facebook or the press.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority refused to authorise the holding of the demonstration of 17 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority stated in general terms that the demonstration of 17 November 2012 was not in accordance with the Law on Freedom of Assembly.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority stated that the square where the organisers proposed to hold the assembly of 17 November 2012 was a designated public leisure area.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority stated that the assembly of 17 November 2012 was impractical.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Despite the Baku City Executive Authority's refusal, the organisers decided to hold the demonstrations in the centre of Baku.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstrations were intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstrations were conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The participants in the demonstration of 17 November 2012 were demanding democratic reforms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The participants in the demonstration of 17 November 2012 were protesting against impediments to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The participants in the demonstration of 26 January 2013 were condemning the use of force by the police against participants of previous demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant attended the demonstration of 17 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant attended the demonstration of 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Shortly after the demonstration of 17 November 2012 had begun, the police started to disperse it.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Shortly after the demonstration of 26 January 2013 had begun, the police started to disperse it.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant was arrested during the dispersal operation of the demonstration of 17 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant was arrested during the dispersal operation of the demonstration of 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "After his arrest on 17 November 2012, the applicant was taken to a police station where he was questioned.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "After his arrest on 26 January 2013, the applicant was taken to a police station where he was questioned.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the applicant, in the first case (17 November 2012) he was arrested by people in plain clothes.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 17 November 2012, the day of the applicant's arrest, an administrative-offence report (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) was issued in respect of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 26 January 2013, the day of the applicant's arrest, an administrative-offence report (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) was issued in respect of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The administrative-offence report issued on 17 November 2012 stated that by deliberately failing to comply with a lawful order from the police, the applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "In the second case (26 January 2013), the applicant was charged with an administrative offence under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences, which concerns participation in a public assembly that had not been organised in accordance with the law.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with copies of the administrative-offence reports from his case files.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with other documents from his case files.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to the applicant, in neither the first case (17 November 2012) nor the second case (26 January 2013) was he given access to a lawyer after his arrest or while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "In the first case, the applicant was brought before the Sabail District Court on the day of his arrest, 17 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "In the second case, the applicant was brought before the Sabail District Court on the day of his arrest, 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing before the Sabail District Court in the first case (17 November 2012) was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing before the Sabail District Court in the second case (26 January 2013) was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the applicant, members of the public were not allowed to attend the court hearings in either case, even though the court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearings to the public.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the applicant, in neither the first case (17 November 2012) nor the second case (26 January 2013) was he given an opportunity to hire a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The record of the court hearing in the first case (17 November 2012) before the Sabail District Court shows that the applicant declared that he did not need legal assistance and would defend himself in person.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "At the court hearing in the second case (26 January 2013) before the Sabail District Court, a State-funded lawyer was appointed to assist the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to documents submitted by the Government, the applicant refused the assistance of the State-funded lawyer appointed at the second case hearing and decided to defend himself in person.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "At the hearing in the first case (17 November 2012) before the Sabail District Court, the court did not question any witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "In the second case (26 January 2013) before the Sabail District Court, the court questioned two police officers.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The two police officers questioned in the second case testified that they had arrested the applicant because he had staged an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In the first case (17 November 2012), the Sabail District Court found that the applicant had participated in an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In the second case (26 January 2013), the Sabail District Court found that the applicant had participated in an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "By a decision of 17 November 2012, the Sabail District Court convicted the applicant under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "By a decision of 17 November 2012, the Sabail District Court sentenced the applicant to five days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "By a decision of 26 January 2013, the Sabail District Court convicted the applicant under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "By a decision of 26 January 2013, the Sabail District Court sentenced the applicant to a fine of 500 Azerbaijani manats (AZN).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On unspecified dates the applicant lodged appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal against his conviction in the first case (17 November 2012).", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On unspecified dates the applicant lodged appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal against his conviction in the second case (26 January 2013).", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In his appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant argued that his convictions were in violation of his rights because the demonstrations in which he had participated had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In his appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant complained that his arrests had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "In his appeals before the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant complained that the hearings before the respective first-instance courts had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In the first case (17 November 2012), the applicant was assisted before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "In the second case (26 January 2013), the applicant was not represented by a lawyer before the Baku Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 23 November 2012, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal in the first case and upheld the decision of the Sabail District Court of 17 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 5 February 2013, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal in the second case and upheld the decision of the Sabail District Court of 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "At the time of both of the applicant's arrests, under Article 5 § IV of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, no prior written notification was required for spontaneous assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 17 November 2012, Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 provided that any breach of the rules, set forth under the legislation, on the organisation and holding of assemblies, demonstrations, protests, marches and pickets shall be punishable by a reprimand or a fine of seven to thirteen Azerbaijani manats.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 17 November 2012, Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000 provided that deliberate failure by an individual to comply with a lawful order of a police officer or military serviceman carrying out their duties to protect public order shall be punishable by a fine of twenty to twenty-five Azerbaijani manats or, if that sanction is inadequate in the circumstances of the case and taking into account the character of the offender, by administrative detention for a term of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 entered into force on 1 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced new wording to Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences concerning breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Under the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, participation in an assembly organised in breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies became explicitly punishable under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced for the first time a punishment in the form of administrative detention of up to fifteen days for breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced community service as a new form of punishment for breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 increased the fine for breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies, fixing the amount at between AZN 300 and 600 for participants of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 fixed the fine for breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies at between AZN 1,500 and 3,000 for individuals who organise an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 fixed the fine for breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies at between AZN 3,000 and 6,000 for persons in charge (vəzifəli şəxslər) who organise an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 fixed the fine for breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies at between AZN 15,000 and 30,000 for legal entities involved in the organisation of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Law no. 457-IVQD of 2 November 2012 entered into force on 29 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Law no. 457-IVQD of 2 November 2012 increased the fine set out in Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences to AZN 200.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "According to presidential Order (sərəncam) no. 1866 of 1 December 2011, which was in force until 1 September 2013, the minimum wage in Azerbaijan was AZN 93.5.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, titled 'The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan', stated that there is no political dialogue with the opposition parties outside parliament in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about the restrictive climate for the activities of the extra-parliamentary opposition in Azerbaijan, which complains about limitations imposed on freedom of expression and freedom of assembly and the lack of access to the public media.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the establishment of an inclusive political system and a truly competitive and unrestrictive political environment in Azerbaijan requires full implementation of basic freedoms, including freedom of expression, freedom of assembly and freedom of association.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed deep concern about the situation regarding basic freedoms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe raised concern about recently adopted amendments to the Criminal Code and the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan, which increased penalties for the organisers of, and participants in, 'unauthorised' gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that, considering the Azerbaijani authorities' ongoing blanket ban on protests in the Baku city centre, the amendments increasing penalties for organisers of and participants in unauthorised gatherings are likely to have a further negative impact on freedom of assembly and freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about the restrictive use of certain articles of the Criminal Code of Azerbaijan, in particular Articles 221 and 233, against participants in peaceful, albeit unauthorised, demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 was authored by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 by Nils Muižnieks stated that the Commissioner is deeply concerned by the recent amendments to the Law on Freedom of Assembly, the Criminal Code and the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan, which further erode the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 by Nils Muižnieks stated that the sanctions which can now be imposed, coupled with the fact that local authorities have not authorised a single rally in Baku city centre in recent years, clearly have a chilling effect on the organisation of or participation in demonstrations in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 by Nils Muižnieks stated that participants in peaceful assemblies should not be sanctioned for the mere fact of being present at and actively participating in the demonstration in question, provided they do not do anything illegal, violent or obscene in the course of it.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 by Nils Muižnieks urged the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure that no disproportionate sanction, which would undermine the fundamental right to peaceful assembly, is imposed.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "A summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, relevant provisions concerning organisation and holding of public assemblies, and relevant extracts of international documents can be found in the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, paragraphs 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F013", "F014", "F018", "F019", "F022", "F023", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F051"], "interference": ["F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F075"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F005", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F029", "F061", "F063"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F005", "F008", "F009", "F013", "F014", "F020", "F021", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F069", "F075", "F080", "F081", "F085"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F013", "F014", "F018", "F019"], "interference": ["F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F049", "F051"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F005", "F006", "F008", "F009", "F061", "F063"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F005", "F013", "F014", "F020", "F021", "F049", "F051", "F075"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F004", "F013", "F014", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F005", "F049", "F051", "F075"]}} {"case_name": "case_339", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1955.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was represented by Ms L. Sahakyan, a lawyer practising in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr E. Varosyan, a lawyer practising in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr A. Ghazaryan, a non-practising lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr G. Kostanyan.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr Y. Kirakosyan, Representative of the Republic of Armenia to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant was at the material time the Deputy General Prosecutor of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicant had occupied the post of Deputy General Prosecutor of Armenia since 17 January 2006.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant held the rank of First Category State Justice Councillor.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "In the past, the applicant had occupied different high-level posts, including the post of Military Prosecutor of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 19 February 2008 a presidential election was held in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 presidential election was the then Prime Minister, Mr Sargsyan, representing the ruling party.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 presidential election was the main opposition candidate, Mr Ter-Petrosyan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Immediately after the announcement of the preliminary results of the 19 February 2008 presidential election, Mr Ter-Petrosyan called on his supporters to gather at Freedom Square in central Yerevan in order to protest against alleged irregularities in the election process.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Mr Ter-Petrosyan announced that the 19 February 2008 presidential election had not been free and fair.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "From 20 February 2008 onwards, nationwide daily protest rallies were held by Mr Ter-Petrosyan's supporters.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The main meeting place of Mr Ter-Petrosyan's supporters during the protest rallies was Freedom Square and the surrounding park in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The rallies at Freedom Square attracted at times tens of thousands of people.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Several hundred demonstrators stayed in the Freedom Square area around the clock, having set up a camp.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 22 February 2008 the applicant made a speech at the rally held at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "In his speech at Freedom Square on 22 February 2008, the applicant expressed his support for Mr Ter-Petrosyan.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "In his speech at Freedom Square on 22 February 2008, the applicant criticised the conduct of the presidential election, alleging various types of irregularities.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "In his speech at Freedom Square on 22 February 2008, the applicant called on those gathered not to give up and to stand by their votes.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "In his speech at Freedom Square on 22 February 2008, the applicant said that rule of law had to be finally established in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant alleged that, following his speech at Freedom Square on 22 February 2008, the authorities started persecuting him and his family members.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 22 February 2008, the same date as the applicant's speech at Freedom Square, the General Prosecutor applied to the President of Armenia seeking to have the applicant dismissed.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The General Prosecutor's application to the President of Armenia sought the applicant's dismissal on the ground that the applicant had participated in a rally and made a political speech, thereby violating the law which required prosecutors to maintain political neutrality and not to engage in political activities.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 23 February 2008 the President of Armenia issued a decree dismissing the applicant from the post of Deputy General Prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 23 February 2008 the President of Armenia issued a decree depriving the applicant of his rank of First Category State Justice Councillor.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the applicant, on 23 February 2008 at around 10 p.m. the applicant, his brother V.J., and four others had been travelling from Ejmiatsin to Yerevan in two cars.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to the applicant, after stopping at the intersection near Argavand village, the applicant and his companions had been attacked by a group of masked and armed persons.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the applicant, the masked and armed persons had crashed their unmarked vehicle into the front of the applicant's car.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "According to the applicant, the masked and armed persons had come out of their vehicle and, firing their guns, had surrounded the applicant's car.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to the applicant, the applicant had surrendered himself and his weapon to the masked and armed persons and had been taken into their car.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the applicant, the masked and armed persons had tried to take V.J., who suffered from spinal tuberculosis and had mobility problems, out of the car.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the applicant, the attackers had started to break the car window and, as V.J. opened the door, had hit him in the face with a pistol grip.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the applicant, the attackers had pulled V.J. out of the car and thrown him to the ground, ignoring warnings about V.J.'s spinal disease.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the applicant, the attackers had continued shooting and injured V.J.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the applicant, the applicant, his brother V.J. and two others, together with their cars, were taken into police custody.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to an announcement made on 23 February 2008 on the website of the Armenian police entitled 'Gagik Jhangiryan is in custody', operative information had been received at the Principal Department for the Fight against Organised Crime (PDFOC) that the persons driving two cars (with indication of licence plates) had been armed and intended to destabilise the situation in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the Armenian police announcement, at around 11 p.m. on 23 February 2008 the above-mentioned cars had been pulled over near Argavand intersection by PDFOC officers.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the Armenian police announcement, during an inspection near Argavand intersection, PDFOC officers encountered resistance from the persons in the cars.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the Armenian police announcement, as a result of the resistance encountered near Argavand intersection, one of the police officers had accidentally fired his service gun, inflicting light injuries on two other police officers and V.J., who had put up resistance.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to the Armenian police announcement, the persons in question, including the applicant, V.J. and two other persons accompanying them, had been taken to the PDFOC.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to the Armenian police announcement, a CZ-75-type pistol had been found in the applicant's possession.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "According to the Armenian police announcement, two other pistols had been found in the possession of V.J. and one of the other two persons accompanying the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "According to the record of bringing a person in, the applicant was brought in to the PDFOC on 23 February 2008 at around 11.30 p.m. from the intersection of Isakov Avenue and Argavand village by PDFOC officers G.G., A.M. and R.M.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "According to the record of bringing a person in, the applicant was brought in to the PDFOC on suspicion of illegal possession, carrying and transportation of arms and ammunition, and for showing resistance to police officers.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The applicant refused to sign the record of bringing a person in.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 23 February 2008 the car accompanying the applicant was searched at the PDFOC and a Browning-type pistol was found, which also belonged to the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 23 February 2008 a number of PDFOC officers filed reports with the chief of the PDFOC.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Several PDFOC officers who had participated in the police operation near Argavand village described the circumstances of that operation, including how V.J. had allegedly put up resistance and punched officer R.M. in the face.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "One PDFOC officer reported that during the police operation near Argavand village a CZ-75 B-type pistol had been retrieved, which had a serial number and had been issued to the applicant on 30 July 2003 for an indefinite period of time.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "PDFOC officers A.H. and T.A. reported that, while they were taking the applicant inside the PDFOC building, the applicant, in the courtyard of the PDFOC building, had disobeyed their lawful orders.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "PDFOC officers A.H. and T.A. reported that the applicant had punched officer A.H. in the courtyard of the PDFOC building.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "PDFOC officers A.H. and T.A. reported that the applicant had torn officer T.A.'s uniform in the courtyard of the PDFOC building.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "PDFOC officers A.H. and T.A. reported that the applicant had used swear words and made threats of retribution against them and their families in the courtyard of the PDFOC building.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Several PDFOC officers reported that, while in the lobby of the PDFOC building, the applicant and his brother V.J. had disobeyed the orders of police officers, used swear words and made threats.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The applicant contested the account of events provided by PDFOC officers and denied having assaulted the officers in question.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicant alleged that, at the time of his arrival at the PDFOC, several hundred police officers had been present in the courtyard of the building and any resistance would have been pointless.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The applicant alleged that it had been he and his brother V.J. who had been ill-treated by police officers in the lobby of the PDFOC.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The applicant alleged that police officers had thrown him and his brother V.J. to the ground and started kicking and punching them in the lobby of the PDFOC.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicant alleged that when he had pleaded with the police officers not to hit V.J. because of his spinal disease, they had started hitting V.J. even more vigorously, aiming at his spine.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 24 February 2008, at an unspecified time, a criminal case was instituted under Article 316 § 2 (life or health-threatening assault on a public official) of the Armenian Criminal Code on account of V.J.'s alleged use of violence against the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 24 February 2008 at 1.10 a.m. a PDFOC investigator drew up a record of the applicant's arrest within the framework of the instituted criminal case, indicating 1.10 a.m. as the time of the applicant's arrest.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The record of the applicant's arrest stated that the applicant was arrested on suspicion of illegal acquisition, possession and carrying of arms and ammunition, as provided for by Article 235 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The record of the applicant's arrest stated that on 23 February 2008 a CZ-75 B-type pistol had been found in the applicant's possession, together with 14 cartridges.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Later on 24 February 2008 another criminal case was instituted under Article 235 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (illegal acquisition, possession or carrying of arms and ammunition) in respect of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The second criminal case instituted under Article 235 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code was joined with the first criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The second criminal case alleged that the applicant, in unknown circumstances, had illegally acquired from an unidentified person a Browning-type pistol loaded with 9 mm cartridges.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The second criminal case alleged that the applicant had illegally kept the Browning-type pistol in the VAZ 21010 car accompanying him on 23 February 2008, which had later been found during the inspection of that car.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The investigator took statements from a number of police officers who confirmed the information provided earlier in their reports.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Officers A.H. and T.A. described how the applicant had refused to step out of the car and how they had had to apply force in order to take him inside the PDFOC building.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Officers A.H. and T.A. described how the applicant had punched officer A.H., torn officer T.A.'s uniform, used swear words and made threats during the process of being taken inside the PDFOC building.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "No questions were posed by the investigator when taking statements from the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Browning pistol was subjected to a forensic examination which concluded on 26 February 2008 that a digit had been added at the end of the serial number, engraved by hand.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The applicant alleged that the extra digit had been added to the Browning pistol's serial number by the police officers after the seizure of the pistol, which he had possessed and carried legally, in order to create the appearance of an illegal nature of that pistol.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 26 February 2008 the applicant was formally charged under Article 235 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (illegal acquisition, possession or carrying of arms and ammunition).", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 26 February 2008 the applicant was formally charged under Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (non-life or health-threatening assault on a public official).", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "As regards the charge under Article 235 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code, it was stated that the applicant, under circumstances yet to be disclosed, had illegally obtained a firearm, namely a 9 mm Browning pistol together with its cartridges, which he had illegally kept in the car accompanying him.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "As regards the charge under Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code, it was stated that, after being taken to the PDFOC on suspicion of illegally carrying a firearm, the applicant, while in the courtyard of the PDFOC building, had disobeyed the lawful orders of PDFOC officers to step out of the police car and to enter the building.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "As regards the charge under Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code, it was stated that the applicant had punched officer A.H. in the shoulder, as a result of which the officer had fallen down.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "As regards the charge under Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code, it was stated that the applicant had pulled and torn the uniform of officer T.A.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "As regards the charge under Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code, it was stated that the applicant had refused to enter the PDFOC building and threatened the officers with violence and retribution.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "On 27 February 2008 at 3.30 a.m. the applicant was brought before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan examined the investigator's application seeking to have the applicant detained for a period of two months on the ground that he might abscond, evade criminal responsibility, obstruct the proceedings and commit an offence.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that the charges against him were unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that the Browning pistol was a registered and licensed weapon legally owned by him.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that it was not his responsibility if there had been a mix-up with the Browning pistol's registration number.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that he had voluntarily surrendered his CZ-75 pistol to the police officers during the raid and that all the weapons found in his and others' possession were legal.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that after arriving at the PDFOC he had been met by a large crowd of police officers who forcibly took him inside the building, and therefore the allegations of resistance or violence on his part were nonsense.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that there was no reason to believe that he, a former Deputy Prosecutor General, would obstruct the investigation or abscond, and that the gravity of the charges alone could not justify his detention.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan decided to allow the investigator's application for the applicant's detention.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the circumstances of the case and the evidence obtained provided sufficient reasons to believe that, if the applicant remained at large, he could commit a new offence, abscond or obstruct the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "On 3 March 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal against the detention decision, arguing inter alia that his detention was not based on a reasonable suspicion since he had possessed and carried the Browning pistol legally.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "In his appeal of 3 March 2008, the applicant argued that he had never used violence against officers A.H. and T.A.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "In his appeal of 3 March 2008, the applicant argued that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan's decision was unreasoned since the risks of his absconding or obstructing the investigation had not been substantiated.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 7 March 2008 the Criminal Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal against the detention decision.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal found on 7 March 2008 that there was a reasonable suspicion, from the materials submitted, that the applicant had committed the imputed offences.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal found on 7 March 2008 that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan's decision to detain the applicant was well-reasoned.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. Charges against the applicant and his detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "On 1 March 2008 in the early morning a police operation was conducted on Freedom Square where several hundred demonstrators were camping.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "As a result of the police operation on Freedom Square on 1 March 2008, Freedom Square was cleared of all demonstrators, resulting in clashes between the demonstrators and the police.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "On 1 March 2008 criminal proceedings were instituted regarding the events at Freedom Square on the grounds that the leaders of the opposition and their supporters had organised unlawful demonstrations, incited disobedience and committed violence against the police.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Further details of the criminal proceedings instituted on 1 March 2008 regarding the events at Freedom Square are described in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia, no. 23086/08, § 15, 20 September 2018.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Later on 1 March 2008 the situation in Yerevan deteriorated and rallies continued in a number of streets until the early morning of 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The rallies continuing on 1-2 March 2008 involved clashes between protesters and law enforcement officers.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The clashes on 1-2 March 2008 resulted in ten deaths, including eight civilians.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The clashes on 1-2 March 2008 resulted in numerous injured persons.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Following the clashes on 1-2 March 2008, a state of emergency was declared by the President of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "On 2 March 2008 another set of criminal proceedings was instituted on the grounds that the leaders of the opposition and their supporters had organised mass disorder in the streets of Yerevan, including murders, violence and other reprehensible acts.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Further details of the criminal proceedings instituted on 2 March 2008 are described in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia, no. 23086/08, § 17.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "On 2 March 2008 both sets of criminal proceedings instituted on 1 March 2008 and 2 March 2008 were joined and examined under case number 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "On 7 March 2008 the investigator decided to join the applicant's criminal case to case number 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "On 18 April 2008 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan extended the applicant's detention by two months.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found on 18 April 2008 that, if the applicant remained at large, he could abscond or obstruct the investigation by exerting unlawful pressure on the persons involved in the proceedings, concealing or falsifying materials essential for the case or in some other way.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "On 23 April 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal against the extension of his detention, arguing inter alia that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan's decision was unreasoned and the risks of his absconding or obstructing the investigation were unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "On 8 May 2008 the Criminal Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal against the extension of his detention, finding that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan's decision to extend the applicant's detention was well-reasoned.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "On 6 June 2008 the investigator questioned the applicant, in the main asking him to explain the speech he had made at Freedom Square on 22 February 2008.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "On 13 June 2008 the charge of illegal possession of a weapon under Article 235 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code was dropped on the ground that the applicant had a licence to keep and carry the Browning pistol.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "On 13 June 2008 the charge of illegal possession of a weapon under Article 235 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code was dropped on the ground that it had not been possible to establish the circumstances under which the extra digit had been added to the Browning pistol's serial number.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "On 13 June 2008 a new charge was brought against the applicant under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (usurpation of power).", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The new charge under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code alleged that the applicant, following the 19 February 2008 presidential election, had joined Levon Ter-Petrosyan and his followers in masterminding and taking actions seeking to usurp power.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The new charge under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code alleged that the applicant, using his standing as Deputy General Prosecutor, had participated in discrediting the conduct of the election, casting doubt on its lawfulness among the international community, and instilling distrust towards the results among large segments of the population.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The new charge under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code alleged that the applicant had created illusions of public discontent and revolt, and organised and conducted unlawful mass rallies aimed at destabilising the political situation in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The new charge under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code alleged that the applicant had planned and taken actions seeking to isolate lawful public officials, force them to resign and exercise power in their stead.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The new charge under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code alleged that the applicant had made public speeches and calls of a provocative nature aimed at usurping state power.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "On 13 June 2008 the investigator requested that the applicant's detention be extended, taking into account inter alia the fact that it was a voluminous and complex criminal case which required further numerous investigative measures.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The investigator's request for extension of the applicant's detention on 13 June 2008 noted that, beside the applicant, a number of other individuals were accused under Article 300 of the Armenian Criminal Code, including some who were in hiding.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "On 19 June 2008 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan extended the applicant's detention by two more months.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan, in extending the applicant's detention on 19 June 2008, took into account the nature and gravity of the imputed offences.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found on 19 June 2008 that, if the applicant remained at large, he could abscond, obstruct the proceedings by exerting pressure on the persons involved in the proceedings and, by his actions, hinder the further disclosure of the circumstances of the case.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "On 23 June 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal arguing inter alia that his detention was not based on a reasonable suspicion.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "In his appeal of 23 June 2008, the applicant argued that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan had failed to provide any reasons in support of its finding that he might abscond or obstruct the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "On 2 July 2008 the Criminal Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal against the extension of his detention.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal found on 2 July 2008 that there was a reasonable suspicion from the materials submitted that the applicant had committed an offence.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal found on 2 July 2008 that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan's decision to extend the applicant's detention was well-reasoned.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "On 13 August 2008 the charge of usurpation of power under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code was dropped for lack of sufficient evidence.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "It was stated on 13 August 2008 that numerous investigative measures had been taken but no new evidence of the applicant's participation in usurpation of state power had been obtained.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "On 13 August 2008 the applicant's criminal case was disjoined from case number 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "On 22 August 2008 the investigation into the applicant's criminal case was completed and the case was referred to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan for trial.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "On 22 August 2008 Judge Z.V. of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan decided to take over the applicant's criminal case and to set the case down for trial.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "On 22 August 2008 Judge Z.V. ruled that the applicant's preventive measure was to remain unchanged.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "On 1 September 2008 Judge Z.V. examined a challenge lodged by the applicant seeking that the judge recuse himself from the examination of the case for lack of impartiality.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The applicant's challenge for recusal of Judge Z.V. was based on the fact that the judge's son, A.V., who worked as an investigator, was a member of the investigative team entrusted with the investigation of the applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Judge Z.V. noted that he was aware that his son A.V. had been a member of the relevant investigative team.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Judge Z.V. found that his son A.V. had not performed or taken part in any investigative measure carried out in respect of the applicant during the investigation of the case.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "Judge Z.V. found that he could still conduct an impartial examination since the fact that his son A.V. was a member of the investigative team did not in itself give rise to a reasonable doubt as regards his impartiality.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "Judge Z.V. found that domestic law did not envisage the fact of involvement of a family member in the investigation of a case as a ground for recusal of a judge.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "On 11 February 2009 Judge Z.V. examined and dismissed a request lodged by the applicant seeking to be released, finding that it was still necessary to keep the applicant in detention.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "During the trial the applicant pleaded not guilty and submitted that he had not put up any resistance during the police operation.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "During the trial the applicant submitted that, having arrived at the courtyard of the PDFOC building, he had seen around 200 to 300 people gathered there.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "During the trial the applicant submitted that he had got out of the car and, together with the persons accompanying him, entered the PDFOC building.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "During the trial the applicant submitted that his arrest had been effected by ten masked persons who had attacked him and his brother V.J. and subjected them to ill-treatment both at the time of arrest and in the lobby of the PDFOC building.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "Police officer A.H. testified that on 23 February 2008 at about 11.30 p.m., while at work, he had received an instruction to accompany an arrested person from the courtyard into the lobby of the PDFOC building and to hand him over to the officers of the criminal intelligence unit.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "Police officer A.H. testified that the same instruction had been given to his colleague, officer T.A.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "Police officer A.H. testified that as officer T.A. opened the van door, they had recognised the applicant and requested that he step out of the vehicle.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "Police officer A.H. testified that the applicant had disobeyed and tried to kick them but they had managed to take him out forcibly and, holding him by the arms, had walked towards the PDFOC building.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "Police officer A.H. testified that the applicant had managed to free his right hand and punch officer A.H. in the shoulder, as a result of which officer A.H. had lost his balance and fallen down.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "Police officer A.H. testified that as officer T.A. intervened, the applicant, while making threats and swearing at them and their family members, had pulled and torn a pocket on officer T.A.'s uniform.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "Police officer A.H. testified that they had then taken the applicant inside the PDFOC building by forcibly twisting his arms, and handed him over to the officers of the criminal intelligence unit.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "Police officer T.A. gave testimony similar to that of police officer A.H. regarding the events at the PDFOC on 23 February 2008.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "A number of other PDFOC officers testified in court during the applicant's trial.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "Seven PDFOC officers stated in court that the applicant had used swear words and made threats in the lobby of the PDFOC.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "Fourteen PDFOC officers who had overseen and/or participated in the police operation near Argavand village, including G.G., A.M. and R.M., described the circumstances of that operation in court.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The fourteen PDFOC officers who described the police operation near Argavand village stated inter alia that after arriving at the PDFOC they had been greeted by officers A.H. and T.A., and had immediately entered the building to report the incident.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The applicant requested that four Members of Parliament, Z.P., A.I., A.Sak. and A.D., be summoned as witnesses during the trial.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The applicant claimed that the four Members of Parliament Z.P., A.I., A.Sak. and A.D. had visited him in the remand prison on 27 February 2008 and witnessed his bodily injuries sustained as a result of ill-treatment in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The applicant requested that three opposition supporters, S.A., V.K. and A.Sis., be summoned as witnesses during the trial.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The applicant argued that S.A., V.K. and A.Sis. had also been taken and kept at the PDFOC on 24 February 2008 and allegedly possessed certain information regarding what had happened there the day before.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "The applicant argued that S.A., V.K. and A.Sis. had allegedly been told by police officers that the applicant and his brother V.J. had been beaten on 23 February 2008 and had overheard police officers discussing the case as being 'trumped up' against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan dismissed the applicant's requests to summon the witnesses Z.P., A.I., A.Sak., A.D., S.A., V.K. and A.Sis.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "On 23 March 2009 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan, sitting in a single judge formation composed of Judge Z.V., found the applicant guilty as charged.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "On 23 March 2009 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan sentenced the applicant to three years' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that on 23 February 2008 at around 11.30 p.m. the applicant, having been brought in to the courtyard of the PDFOC upon a suspicion of carrying illegal firearms and ammunition, disobeyed the lawful orders of police officers who were performing their official duties.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant punched and caused pain to police officer A.H.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant pulled and tore the uniform of officer T.A., refused to enter the PDFOC building and threatened the police officers and their families with physical retribution.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant had voluntarily given up his CZ-75 B-type pistol during the police operation near Argavand village.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that all the weapons retrieved during the police operation near Argavand village, including those belonging to the applicant, had been found, following an inspection, to have been possessed and carried legally.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "In reaching its findings, the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan relied on the statements of police officers A.H. and T.A. and other officers who had testified in court.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "As material evidence, the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan cited officer T.A.'s torn uniform.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found the applicant's submissions and arguments to be unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "On 16 April 2009 the applicant lodged an appeal against the District Court's judgment, arguing inter alia that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan had failed to assess properly the evidence, dismissed his submissions and refused his requests seeking to prove his innocence.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "In his appeal of 16 April 2009, the applicant argued that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan had based its findings solely on the testimony of the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "In his appeal of 16 April 2009, the applicant alleged that the true reason for his prosecution and conviction was to punish him for the speech he had made at the opposition rally on 22 February 2008, arguing that he had thereby been discriminated against on the basis of his political views.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "In his appeal of 16 April 2009, the applicant argued that Judge Z.V. had not been impartial because of the involvement of his son A.V. in the investigative team.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "On 20 May 2009 the Court of Appeal upheld the judgment of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan and dismissed the applicant's appeal, finding that the arguments contained therein were unfounded.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "On 19 June 2009 the applicant lodged an appeal on points of law to the Court of Cassation.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "On 14 July 2009 the Court of Cassation declared the applicant's appeal on points of law inadmissible for lack of merit.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "On 22 June 2009 the applicant was released under amnesty.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law and relevant international materials, see Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (no. 23086/08) and Ara Harutyunyan v. Armenia (no. 629/11, §§ 30-37, 20 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "A number of provisions of domestic law and extracts from international materials not quoted in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (no. 23086/08) or Ara Harutyunyan v. Armenia (no. 629/11) are set out in the relevant legal framework section of this judgment.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003), as in force at the material time, provided that usurpation of State power, namely actions aimed at violent seizure of State power or its violent retention in violation of the Constitution, as well as violent overthrow of the constitutional order of Armenia or violent breach of the territorial integrity of Armenia, was punishable by imprisonment for a period from ten to fifteen years.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Criminal Code (2003)"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "Article 90 § 1(3) of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999), as in force at the material time, provided that a judge is obliged to recuse himself if he is aware of facts or circumstances capable of raising a reasonable doubt as regards his impartiality in a particular case.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "Article 90 § 1(3) of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provided that grounds for recusal include cases where a judge or his spouse or a person having kinship with him of up to the third degree may reasonably become (or has reasons to believe that he will become) a participant in the proceedings or has participated in the proceedings at a lower instance as a judge or as a participant in the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "Article 90 § 1(3) of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provided that a person's children, parents, sisters and brothers are considered as having kinship of the first degree with him, within the meaning of that Article.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "On 15 April 2008 the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe produced the Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579).", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579), produced by the co-rapporteurs, stated that the opposition received a boost in support when a number of high-level state officials publicly denounced the 19 February 2008 presidential election as fraudulent and announced their support for Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579) stated that those high-level state officials who publicly denounced the election were subsequently dismissed from their positions.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579) stated that a number of those high-level state officials, as well as several opposition activists, were arrested on seemingly artificial charges, which left the impression that their prosecution was politically motivated.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579) stated that according to the Helsinki Association of Armenia, a total of 14 persons were arrested and placed under investigation in the period from 20 to 29 February 2008.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "Between April 2008 and June 2009 the OSCE/ODIHR (Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights) conducted a monitoring project of about a hundred trials of opposition leaders and supporters related to the events of 1-2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (OSCE/ODIHR)"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "The OSCE/ODIHR monitoring project of trials related to the events of 1-2 March 2008 included the applicant's case under number 94.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (OSCE/ODIHR)"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F013", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F009", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F120", "F123", "F124", "F125", "F126", "F127", "F128"], "interference": ["F198", "F199", "F200", "F201", "F202", "F009", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F042", "F043", "F066", "F070", "F055", "F179", "F180", "F052", "F071", "F072", "F073", "F120", "F123", "F124", "F125", "F126", "F127", "F128", "F129", "F130", "F131", "F139", "F080", "F082", "F121", "F122", "F081", "F156", "F157", "F158", "F159", "F160", "F161", "F162", "F163", "F174", "F175", "F181", "F183", "F114", "F115", "F203", "F204"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F081", "F174", "F175", "F022", "F030", "F042", "F121", "F123", "F139", "F115", "F181"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F013", "F018", "F019", "F022", "F023", "F024"], "interference": ["F022", "F028", "F030", "F042", "F055", "F120", "F121", "F123", "F139", "F115", "F174", "F181", "F183", "F201", "F203", "F204"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F022", "F030", "F042", "F121", "F123", "F139", "F174", "F181"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F022", "F028", "F030", "F042", "F121", "F120", "F123", "F139", "F115", "F174", "F181"]}} {"case_name": "case_340", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1976.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Syktyvkar.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 19 September 2015 the Federal Security Service (FSB) announced that criminal proceedings on suspicion of membership of a criminal gang and fraud had been opened against the Governor of the Komi Republic, Mr Gaizer.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 19 September 2015 the Investigations Committee of the Russian Federation announced that criminal proceedings on suspicion of membership of a criminal gang and fraud had been opened against the Governor of the Komi Republic, Mr Gaizer.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 19 September 2015 the Federal Security Service (FSB) and the Investigations Committee of the Russian Federation announced that criminal proceedings on suspicion of membership of a criminal gang and fraud had been opened against one of the deputies of the Governor of the Komi Republic.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 19 September 2015 the Federal Security Service (FSB) and the Investigations Committee of the Russian Federation announced that criminal proceedings on suspicion of membership of a criminal gang and fraud had been opened against several high-ranking officials in the Komi Republic government.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 19 September 2015 the Federal Security Service (FSB) and the Investigations Committee of the Russian Federation announced that criminal proceedings on suspicion of membership of a criminal gang and fraud had been opened against the speaker of the Komi Republic parliament.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 19 September 2015 the Federal Security Service (FSB) and the Investigations Committee of the Russian Federation announced that criminal proceedings on suspicion of membership of a criminal gang and fraud had been opened against a representative of the Komi Republic in the upper chamber of the Russian Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "All of the persons against whom criminal proceedings were announced on 19 September 2015 — including the Governor of the Komi Republic Mr Gaizer, one of his deputies, several high-ranking officials in the Komi Republic government, the speaker of the Komi Republic parliament, and a representative of the Komi Republic in the upper chamber of the Russian Parliament — were arrested on 19 September 2015.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 21 September 2015 the applicant, together with Ms S., notified the Syktyvkar Town Administration of their intention to hold a 'picket' (пикетирование) on 25 September 2015 from 5 to 6 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The 'picket' notified on 21 September 2015 was intended to be held at the crossroads of Lenin and Kommunisticheskaya streets behind the Lenin monument in Syktyvkar.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The 'picket' notified on 21 September 2015 was expected to be attended by fifty people.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The stated aim of the 'picket' notified on 21 September 2015 was to 'discuss the arrest of the Komi Republic government'.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 21 September 2015 the applicant published a copy of his notification of 21 September 2015 on his Internet blog.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 21 September 2015, the applicant stated that the aim of the 'picket' was to let people express their thoughts about the arrests of members of the Komi Republic government.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 21 September 2015, the applicant stated that any opinions — from approval to criticism of the arrests — were welcome at the 'picket'.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 21 September 2015, the applicant stated that he hoped the 'picket' would be approved.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 21 September 2015, the applicant stated that if the town administration proposed to hold the 'picket' on the outskirts of the town, a 'people's assembly' (народный сход), which did not require prior notification, would be held at the same location behind the Lenin monument.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 21 September 2015, the applicant criticised the fact that regional governors were appointed by the President of the Russian Federation and expressed the wish that governors be elected by the people.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 21 September 2015, the applicant asked why Mr Gaizer had been appointed governor of the Komi Republic in 2010 if, according to the investigators, he had been a member of a criminal gang since 2006.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 21 September 2015, the applicant stated that the accusations against Mr Gaizer and the others seemed to be based on a very slim evidentiary basis, which gave reasons to believe that the criminal proceedings against them were politically motivated.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 21 September 2015, the applicant stated his opinion that Mr Putin was trying to frighten other governors into submission.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 21 September 2015, the applicant stated that appointed governors always served the interests of those who had appointed them.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 21 September 2015, the applicant stated that he wanted to propose a discussion about the future of the Komi Republic and, in particular, about whether the people wanted the next governor to be appointed or elected.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 21 September 2015 the Syktyvkar Town Administration refused to approve the venue chosen by the applicant for the 'picket'.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Administration's refusal of 21 September 2015 pointed out that Komi Republic regional law no. 91-RZ of 20 November 2012 [sic] prohibited the holding of public events in Stefanovskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Administration proposed that the 'picket' be held at one of the special locations for public events designated by the Komi Republic government.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant received the Syktyvkar Town Administration's decision of 21 September 2015 on 22 September 2015.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 22 September 2015 the applicant published a new entry on his Internet blog informing his readers that the Syktyvkar Town Administration had refused to approve the venue behind the Lenin monument.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 22 September 2015, the applicant enclosed a copy of the Syktyvkar Town Administration's decision of 21 September 2015.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 22 September 2015, the applicant stated that a 'people's assembly' would be held instead at the same location and time as the originally planned 'picket'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 22 September 2015, the applicant explained that a 'people's assembly' was an assembly of people who gathered to discuss without there being any organisers.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 22 September 2015, the applicant explained that unlike a 'picket', it was not possible to use placards during a 'people's assembly'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 22 September 2015, the applicant stated that the official who had signed the refusal to approve the 'picket' was the same official who had been responsible for a 30% increase in the cost of heating in the previous two years.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 23 September 2015 the applicant published a post on VKontakte calling for participation in the public discussion on 25 September 2015.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 24 September 2015 the applicant's VKontakte account was blocked by the VKontakte administrator.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant's VKontakte account was blocked on 24 September 2015 following an order by the Federal Service for Supervision of Communications, Information Technology and Mass Media.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant's VKontakte account was blocked on 24 September 2015 following an order by a deputy Prosecutor General of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The deputy Prosecutor General found that the applicant's VKontakte post of 23 September 2015, which was publicly accessible, contained information about a 'picket' to be held on 25 September 2015 at the crossroads of Lenin and Kommunisticheskaya streets.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The deputy Prosecutor General found that the Syktyvkar Town Administration had refused to allow the 'picket' because it was prohibited to hold public events at the crossroads of Lenin and Kommunisticheskaya streets.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The deputy Prosecutor General found that the applicant's VKontakte post of 23 September 2015 amounted to campaigning for participation in an unlawful public event in breach of section 10 paragraph 1 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicant's VKontakte account was blocked pursuant to section 15.3(1) of Law no. 149-FZ of 27 July 2006 on Information, Information Technologies and Protection of Information (the Information Act).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 25 September 2015 the applicant published a third entry on his Internet blog.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 25 September 2015, the applicant asked what would happen if many people came to the 'people's assembly' later that day.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 25 September 2015, the applicant stated that he did not believe that a high turnout at the 'people's assembly' would make the Kremlin change its politics, appoint a responsible local person as the governor of the Komi Republic, or stop unsubstantiated accusations against Mr Gaizer.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 25 September 2015, the applicant stated that a high participation rate would show that there were many people who were not afraid to express their opinion.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 25 September 2015, the applicant stated that the FSB and the Prosecutor General's office were afraid of politically active people.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "In his Internet blog post of 25 September 2015, the applicant called on everyone to come to the 'people's assembly' to prevent similar situations in future.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 25 September 2015 the administrator of the Internet site that hosted the applicant's blog informed the applicant by email that access to the three blog entries (published on 21 September 2015, 22 September 2015, and 25 September 2015) had been restricted.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Access to the three blog entries was restricted on the order of the Prosecutor General's office.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Prosecutor General's office ordered the restriction of access to the three blog entries because they had been found to contain calls to participate in public events held in breach of the established procedure.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "At about 7 p.m. on 25 September 2015 about fifty people gathered near the Lenin monument in Syktyvkar.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The 'people's assembly' on 25 September 2015 near the Lenin monument went peacefully and without any disturbance.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Notification of a public event and the blocking of the applicant's social networking account and of three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 26 October 2015 the applicant challenged before the Syktyvkar Town Court the Syktyvkar Town Administration's decision of 21 September 2015 refusing to approve the location of the 'picket'.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Syktyvkar Town Court that the 'picket' had been intended to take place fifty metres from Stefanovskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Syktyvkar Town Court that the 'picket' would not have caused any disturbance or inconvenience.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Syktyvkar Town Court that the special designated locations proposed by the Syktyvkar Town Administration would have been unsuitable.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 18 November 2015 the Syktyvkar Town Court rejected the applicant's complaint against the Syktyvkar Town Administration's decision of 21 September 2015 refusing to approve the location of the 'picket'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "In its judgment of 18 November 2015, the Syktyvkar Town Court cited Article 11 of the Convention, the applicable domestic provisions, and the Constitutional Court's decision of 2 April 2009.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 18 November 2015 that the applicant's argument that the event would lose its purpose if held at the locations proposed by the Syktyvkar Town Administration was unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 18 November 2015 that the law requires organisers to make reasonable and sufficient efforts to reach a compromise on the basis of a balance of interests in order to enjoy the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 18 November 2015 that where there is no ban on holding a public event but rather an alternative location is proposed, the organisers may not reject without valid reasons the conditions proposed by the authorities for holding the event.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court noted in its judgment of 18 November 2015 that Decree no. 598 of 25 December 2012 by the Komi Republic Government designated special locations for holding public events in Syktyvkar, having ensured that they were in keeping with the aims of public events and accessible by public transport, permitted the organisers of and participants in public events to use public utility facilities, respected sanitary norms and rules, and guaranteed the safety of the organisers of and participants in public events.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court noted in its judgment of 18 November 2015 that the Syktyvkar Town Administration's decision of 21 September 2015 mentioned the special locations designated by Decree no. 598 of 25 December 2012, de facto proposing them as an alternative to the location chosen by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court noted in its judgment of 18 November 2015 that the Syktyvkar Town Administration's decree no. 9/3483 of 4 September 2013 amended its decree no. 10/4160 of 28 October 2008 on locations where public events were prohibited.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court noted in its judgment of 18 November 2015 that in accordance with the amended decree no. 10/4160 of 28 October 2008, it is prohibited to hold public events at the crossroads of Lenin and Kommunisticheskaya streets.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 18 November 2015 that the Syktyvkar Town Administration's proposal to change the location of the applicant's public event was well reasoned and lawful.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 18 November 2015 that the refusal to approve the location was lawful and acceptable.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 18 November 2015 that the Syktyvkar Town Administration's decision of 21 September 2015 was made within the time-limit established by law.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 18 November 2015 that the Syktyvkar Town Administration's decision of 21 September 2015 contained reasons justifying the impossibility of holding the public event at the chosen location, a well-reasoned proposal to change the location, and an explanation of the procedure for notifying public events.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 18 November 2015 that the applicant was not deprived of a possibility to enjoy his constitutional right to hold public events in accordance with the procedure established by the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 18 November 2015 that the applicant's rights and freedoms under Articles 10 and 11 of the Convention were not restricted by the Syktyvkar Town Administration's contested decision of 21 September 2015.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 18 November 2015 that there were no obstacles preventing the applicant from enjoying his constitutional rights.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The applicant appealed against the Syktyvkar Town Court's judgment of 18 November 2015.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant submitted that the crossroads of Lenin and Kommunisticheskaya streets was outside the area where public events were prohibited by Komi Republic regional law no. 91-RZ.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant submitted that the Syktyvkar Town Administration's decree no. 9/3483 of 4 September 2013, which allegedly prohibited public events at the crossroads of Lenin and Kommunisticheskaya streets, had never been published and was therefore not accessible to the public.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 28 January 2016 the Supreme Court of the Komi Republic upheld the Syktyvkar Town Court's judgment of 18 November 2015 on appeal, finding it lawful, well reasoned and justified.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the Syktyvkar Town Court rejected the complaint on the merits because the contested refusal to approve the chosen location of the picket had been made by the competent authority in accordance with the procedure prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the Syktyvkar Town Administration had given the applicant an objective possibility to enjoy his constitutional and Convention rights.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the Syktyvkar Town Court correctly applied the Public Events Act providing for the conditions for enjoying the right to peaceful assembly guaranteed by Article 31 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the Syktyvkar Town Administration's proposal to change the location of the public event chosen by the organisers had been substantiated, well reasoned and justified by the necessity to respect the balance of interests of the parties and to ensure public safety.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that it is prohibited to hold public events at the crossroads of Lenin and Kommunisticheskaya streets.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic noted in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that Decree no. 598 of 25 December 2012 by the Komi Republic Government designated special locations for holding political public events in Syktyvkar.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the choice of a location for an event and its approval by the municipal authorities does not restrict the participants' right to freedom of opinion and expression.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the applicant's argument that it was impossible to hold the event was hypothetical and did not refer to any valid reasons explaining why the locations proposed by the Syktyvkar Town Administration were incompatible with the public event's purposes.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that in accordance with Article 17 § 3 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, the enjoyment of one's rights and freedoms must not breach the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that there were objective and sufficient reasons for the proposal to change the location of the public event with the aim of ensuring a balance between the rights of the organisers and those of third persons.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the Syktyvkar Town Administration did not omit to examine the request for approval of the location of the public event and gave its reply to the applicant within the statutory time-limit.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the Syktyvkar Town Administration's reply contained reasons explaining why it was impossible to hold the public event at the chosen location and a well-reasoned proposal to change the location.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the applicant's constitutional rights and interests were respected and there was no violation of Article 11 of the Convention guaranteeing freedom of assembly, or of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the law does not guarantee the organiser of a public event an unconditional right to hold a public event at the location which he considers the most relevant to its political and social significance.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the Syktyvkar Town Administration fulfilled its statutory obligation to propose an alternative location for the public event that was compatible with its purposes.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the locations proposed by the Syktyvkar Town Administration were an adequate alternative to the chosen location and were in keeping with its purposes.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the arguments in the appeal submissions were based on an incorrect assessment of the facts of the case and an incorrect interpretation of the applicable legal provisions and did not therefore warrant the quashing of the Syktyvkar Town Court's judgment.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the Syktyvkar Town Administration's contested decision was in accordance with the Public Events Act, was made within the municipal authorities' powers and was in the interests of ensuring public order, with the aim of preventing disorder, protecting health and morality, and safeguarding the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held in its judgment of 28 January 2016 that the Syktyvkar Town Administration's contested decision did not breach the applicant's rights.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The applicant lodged a cassation appeal against the Supreme Court of the Komi Republic's judgment of 28 January 2016.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "In his cassation appeal, the applicant repeated his previous arguments from his earlier appeal.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "In his cassation appeal, the applicant added that public events were regularly held at the crossroads of Lenin and Kommunisticheskaya streets.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 19 July 2016 a judge of the Supreme Court of the Komi Republic refused to refer the applicant's cassation appeal to the Presidium of the Supreme Court of the Komi Republic for examination.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The judge of the Supreme Court of the Komi Republic refused to refer the cassation appeal on 19 July 2016 having found no significant violations of substantive or procedural law which had influenced the outcome of the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Judicial review of the refusal to approve the venue of the \"picket\""]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "On 25 December 2015 the applicant challenged before the Syktyvkar Town Court the decisions of the prosecutor's office to block his VKontakte account.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "On 25 December 2015 the applicant challenged before the Syktyvkar Town Court the decisions of the prosecutor's office to block three entries on his Internet blog.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The applicant argued before the Syktyvkar Town Court that the decisions to block his VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog had not been necessary in a democratic society and had therefore breached his right to freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The applicant claimed before the Syktyvkar Town Court that he had suffered non-pecuniary damage as a result of the decisions to block his VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "On 5 April 2016 the Syktyvkar Town Court dismissed the applicant's claim against the decisions of the prosecutor's office to block his VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "In its judgment of 5 April 2016, the Syktyvkar Town Court cited Article 10 of the Convention and section 15.3 of Law no. 149-FZ of 27 July 2006 on Information, Information Technologies and Protection of Information (the Information Act).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court noted in its judgment of 5 April 2016 that the Syktyvkar Town Administration had refused to approve the 'picket' at the location chosen by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 5 April 2016 that despite the lack of approval for the public event, the applicant described the preparations for holding it on his VKontakte page and on his blog, calling on an unrestricted audience to participate in an unauthorised public event.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 5 April 2016 that access to the information published by the applicant was restricted because he had breached information distribution rules by distributing information containing calls for participation in a public event to be held in breach of the established procedure.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 5 April 2016 that the restriction on access to the applicant's information had a basis in law and pursued the aim of preventing breaches of law in the sphere of distribution of information.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 5 April 2016 that the applicant's freedom of expression was not restricted, because access was blocked to information distributed in breach of the law, rather than in connection with the contents of the applicant's statements about the aims of the notified public event.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 5 April 2016 that restriction of access to the entire VKontakte account rather than to the specific post had a basis in law, which in substance provides for restriction of access to an entire account, taking into consideration the nature of real-time distribution of publicly accessible content on the Internet.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Syktyvkar Town Court held in its judgment of 5 April 2016 that given that it was possible for the applicant to create and distribute new Internet posts, the applicant's personal non-property rights were not breached, and the claim must therefore be dismissed.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "On 7 July 2016 the Supreme Court of the Komi Republic upheld the Syktyvkar Town Court's judgment of 5 April 2016 on appeal, finding that it had been lawful, well reasoned and justified.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "On 14 December 2016 a judge of the Supreme Court of the Komi Republic refused to refer a cassation appeal lodged by the applicant with the Presidium of the Supreme Court of the Komi Republic for examination.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held on 14 December 2016 that calls for participation in public events held in breach of the established procedure were incompatible with public order.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Komi Republic held on 14 December 2016 that the restriction on access to information containing calls for participation in public events held in breach of the established procedure pursued the aim of preventing more serious violations of public order.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "On 31 January 2017 a judge of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation refused to refer the applicant's cassation appeal for consideration by the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The judge of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation refused to refer the cassation appeal on 31 January 2017 finding that no significant violations of substantive or procedural law had influenced the outcome of the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Judicial review of the decisions to block the applicant's VKontakte account and three entries on his Internet blog"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "For a summary of the domestic provisions on the procedure for the notification and conduct of public events, on relevant judicial review procedures and on the liability for breaches committed in the course of public events, see Lashmankin and Others v. Russia, nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, §§ 216-312, 7 February 2017.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The applicable domestic provisions on the procedure for the notification and conduct of public events have since been interpreted by the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 deals with the application of legislation governing public events during judicial examination of administrative complaints and administrative-offence cases.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that a refusal to approve a public event, its location or time or the manner in which it is to be conducted may be challenged before a court either by the event organiser or by a person appointed by the organiser to fulfil certain organisational tasks (point 2).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that when examining administrative complaints about refusals to approve public events, courts have to examine whether the interference by a public authority with the right to freedom of public assembly was lawful, necessary and proportionate to a legitimate aim (point 9).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that courts must examine all the grounds advanced by the public authority and all the evidence submitted by it and assess whether the reasons for the interference were relevant and sufficient (point 9).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that courts must verify whether the proposal to change the location or time of a public event or the manner of conducting it was made within the three-day statutory time-limit (point 10).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that failure to comply with the three-day statutory time-limit for proposing a change of location or time means that the public event must be considered to be approved by default (point 10).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that courts must take into account that a proposal to change the location or time of a public event or the manner in which it is to be conducted must not be arbitrary or unreasoned (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that proposals to change the location or time of a public event must mention specific facts showing that public interest considerations make it manifestly impossible to hold the public event at the chosen location or time (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that public interests justifying a change of location or time may include: normal functioning of essential public utilities, social and transport infrastructure and communications; maintenance of public order and safety of citizens; disruption of pedestrians or traffic or of citizens' access to residential premises or to social or transport facilities; and other similar considerations (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that inconvenience caused to citizens by a public event or an assumption by the authorities that there might be a risk of such inconvenience may not in themselves be considered valid reasons for changing the location or time of a public event (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that a necessity to temporarily divert pedestrians or traffic may not be considered a valid reason for changing the location or time of a public event, provided that it is possible to ensure that the traffic and the conduct of everyone involved in the event will comply with the established rules and will not lead to traffic accidents (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that disruption of pedestrians or traffic or a risk of disruption of essential public utility services may be considered valid reasons for proposing to change the location or time of a public event, provided that holding the public event will breach traffic or public transport safety requirements or limit citizens' access to residential premises or public facilities, irrespective of measures taken by the public authority to ensure compliance with such requirements (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that the public authority must submit to the court evidence of specific facts making it impossible to hold the public event at the chosen location or time (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that courts may not take into account any circumstances which were not mentioned in the proposal to change the location or time of the public event (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that courts should take into account that the public authority must suggest a specific alternative location and time for the public event compatible with its purposes and its social and political significance (point 13).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that if approval was denied because it was prohibited to hold public events at the chosen location, the public authority may suggest an alternative location for that event (point 13).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that the organiser must reply in writing, stating whether he or she accepts the proposed alternative location and/or time, no later than three days before the planned date of the event (point 13).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that the organiser may also propose another location or time for approval (point 13).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that if the organiser wants to change the date of the event, he must submit a new notification (point 13).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that public events held at private premises with unrestricted public access (such as shopping malls) must be notified to the public authority, and the organiser must enclose with the notification the consent to the public event signed by the premises' owner (points 8 and 14).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that it is not necessary to notify a public event planned at a specially designated location for public events, provided that the number of participants does not exceed the number permitted for each such location by regional law (point 15).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that the organiser must ensure the safety of participants and must therefore make enquiries about any other events planned at the same location at the same time to make sure that the maximum capacity of the location will not be exceeded (point 15).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that the fact that the organiser informed the public authority about the intended public event will be taken into account if he or she is held liable for failure to ensure public order and safety (point 15).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that the public authority may propose a change of location or time of a public event to be held at a specially designated location and not requiring notification only if another public event has been scheduled to take place at the same location and time and either the number of participants of the two simultaneous events will exceed the maximum capacity of the location, or it will not be possible to ensure the peaceful character of the simultaneous events by applying security arrangements habitually used at public events with a comparable number of participants (point 15).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that a cultural event, a fair or some other mass event not falling under the Public Events Act, scheduled to take place at the same specially designated location at the same time, may not in itself serve as lawful grounds for proposing to change the location or time of a public event (point 16).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that a cultural event, a fair or some other mass event not falling under the Public Events Act may serve as lawful grounds for proposing to change the location or time of a public event only if information about that mass event was duly published and it will not be possible to ensure safety at the two events if they are held simultaneously (point 16).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that if a court allowed the administrative complaint before the planned date of the public event, it may require the public authority not to impede the public event at the location and time chosen by the organisers (point 20).", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that if the public authority has submitted evidence showing that new grounds objectively preventing holding the public event at the chosen location or time arose after the contested decision, the court may require that the public authority re-examine the issue of the event's location, time or the manner in which it is to be conducted within a certain time-limit (point 20).", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Procedure for the notification and conduct of public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "Section 5 of Komi Republic Law no. 91-RZ of 29 November 2012 on the Holding of Public Events in the Komi Republic prohibits the holding of public events in Stefanovskaya Square in the town of Syktyvkar.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Komi Republic legislation on public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "Section 5 of Komi Republic Law no. 91-RZ of 29 November 2012 on the Holding of Public Events in the Komi Republic prohibits the holding of public events at railway stations, bus stations, markets, airports, educational institutions, buildings of educational institutions, religious buildings and areas within a radius of fifty metres of the entrance to those facilities.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Komi Republic legislation on public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "Section 5 of Komi Republic Law no. 91-RZ of 29 November 2012 on the Holding of Public Events in the Komi Republic prohibits the holding of public events at children's playgrounds, locations designated by the municipal authorities for children's recreation and activities, pedestrian pavements, bus stops, and public parking areas.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Komi Republic legislation on public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Section 5 of Komi Republic Law no. 91-RZ of 29 November 2012 on the Holding of Public Events in the Komi Republic prohibits the holding of public events at buildings in a state of disrepair and areas within a radius of fifty metres of the entrance to such buildings.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Komi Republic legislation on public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "Section 5 of Komi Republic Law no. 91-RZ of 29 November 2012 on the Holding of Public Events in the Komi Republic prohibits the holding of public events at buildings under construction, reconstruction or repair and areas within a radius of fifty metres of the entrance to such buildings.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Komi Republic legislation on public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "Section 5 of Komi Republic Law no. 91-RZ of 29 November 2012 on the Holding of Public Events in the Komi Republic prohibits the holding of public events at buildings occupied by the regional authorities of the Komi Republic, Komi Republic branches of the federal authorities, the municipal authorities of the Komi Republic, state institutions in the Komi Republic and areas within a radius of fifty metres of the entrance to those buildings.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Komi Republic legislation on public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "Section 5 of Komi Republic Law no. 91-RZ of 29 November 2012 on the Holding of Public Events in the Komi Republic provides that the listed prohibitions apply in addition to the locations where the holding of public events is prohibited pursuant to section 8 paragraph 2 of the Federal Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Komi Republic legislation on public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "Syktyvkar Town Administration's decree no. 9/3483 of 4 September 2013 described the perimeter of the zone in the immediate vicinity of the Constitutional Court of the Komi Republic where the holding of public events was prohibited.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Komi Republic legislation on public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The perimeter described in Syktyvkar Town Administration's decree no. 9/3483 of 4 September 2013 comprised the entire Stefanovskaya Square and the adjacent streets, including the area at the crossroads of Lenin and Kommunisticheskaya streets.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Komi Republic legislation on public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "Section 15.3(1) of Law no. 149-FZ of 27 July 2006 on Information, Information Technologies and Protection of Information (the Information Act), as in force at the material time, provided that if information disseminated through telecommunication networks, including the Internet, containing calls for mass disorder, extremist activities or participation in mass (public) events held in breach of the established procedure has been discovered, the Prosecutor General of the Russian Federation or his deputies shall order the federal law-enforcement authority supervising the mass media, mass communications and information technologies to take measures to restrict access to information media distributing that information.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Information Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "Section 15.3(2) of the Information Act, as in force at the material time, provided that on the basis of the order mentioned in subsection 1, the federal law-enforcement authority supervising the mass media, mass communications and information technologies shall immediately order service providers to take measures to restrict access to the information medium or to the information published on it containing calls for mass disorder, extremist activities or participation in mass (public) events held in breach of the established procedure, mentioning the domain name, network address and URL of the webpage permitting identification of the information.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Information Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "Section 15.3(2) of the Information Act, as in force at the material time, provided that the federal law-enforcement authority supervising the mass media, mass communications and information technologies shall identify the host service provider or person hosting the information medium on a telecommunication network such as the Internet or providing services to the owner of the website containing calls for mass disorder, extremist activities or participation in mass (public) events held in breach of the established procedure.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Information Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "Section 15.3(2) of the Information Act, as in force at the material time, provided that the federal law-enforcement authority supervising the mass media, mass communications and information technologies shall send to the host service provider an electronic notification in Russian and English about a breach of the information distribution rules, mentioning the domain name, network address, and URL of the webpage permitting identification of the information, and an order to delete the information.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Information Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "Section 15.3(2) of the Information Act, as in force at the material time, provided that the federal law-enforcement authority supervising the mass media, mass communications and information technologies shall record in a special electronic register the date and time when the notification was sent to the host service provider.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Information Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "Section 15.3(3) of the Information Act, as in force at the material time, provided that upon receipt of the order to take measures to restrict access, the communications service provider permitting access to the Internet telecommunications network must immediately restrict access to the information medium or to information published thereon and containing calls for mass disorder, extremist activities or participation in mass (public) events held in breach of the established procedure.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Information Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "Section 15.3(4) of the Information Act, as in force at the material time, provided that within twenty-four hours of receiving the notification, the host service provider must inform the owner of the information resource about the notification and that it is necessary to immediately delete the information containing calls for mass disorder, extremist activities or participation in mass (public) events held in breach of the established procedure.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Information Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "Section 15.3(5) of the Information Act, as in force at the material time, provided that if the owner of the information medium has deleted the information containing calls for mass disorder, extremist activities or participation in mass (public) events held in breach of the established procedure, he must send a notification to the federal law-enforcement authority supervising the mass media, mass communications and information technologies, and such notification may be sent electronically.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Information Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "Section 15.3(6) of the Information Act, as in force at the material time, provided that upon receipt of the notification that the information has been deleted, and after verifying its authenticity, the federal law-enforcement authority supervising the mass media, mass communications and information technologies must immediately send a notification to the communications service provider that it may reopen access to the information medium.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Information Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "Section 15.3(7) of the Information Act, as in force at the material time, provided that upon receipt of the notification mentioned in subsection 6, the communications service provider shall immediately reopen access to the information medium.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Information Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015) entered into force on 15 September 2015.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "Article 226 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015) provides that complaints about decisions, acts or omissions of State and municipal authorities and officials are to be examined within a month of receipt, or within two months by the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, if not otherwise provided for by the Code for certain categories of cases.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. Administrative proceedings"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F010", "F012", "F013", "F052", "F053"], "interference": ["F025", "F027"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F026", "F065", "F066", "F151", "F158", "F159"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F025", "F026", "F151", "F158", "F159"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F010", "F052", "F053"], "interference": ["F025", "F027"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F151", "F158", "F159"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F025", "F026", "F151", "F158", "F159"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F010", "F025", "F053", "F151", "F158", "F159"]}} {"case_name": "case_341", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1969.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1980.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1985.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The fourth applicant was born in 1967.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The fifth applicant was born in 1984.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "All five applicants live in Tbilisi.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "All five applicants are members of the Equality Institute, a Georgian non-governmental organisation.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Equality Institute was established in February 2004.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "As part of its activities, the Equality Institute aimed at monitoring penal and law-enforcement authorities and promoting the independence of the judiciary.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Equality Institute held public press conferences denouncing various serious human-rights abuses allegedly committed by the Ministry of the Interior and in Georgian prisons.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Equality Institute held street demonstrations denouncing various serious human-rights abuses allegedly committed by the Ministry of the Interior and in Georgian prisons.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "At around 2.20 p.m. on 29 June 2006, the applicants began a demonstration outside the Tbilisi Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The purpose of the applicants' demonstration on 29 June 2006 was to express their support for Mr Shalva Ramishvili and Mr Davit Kokhreidze.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Mr Shalva Ramishvili and Mr Davit Kokhreidze were owners of the 202 private television channel.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Mr Shalva Ramishvili and Mr Davit Kokhreidze were on trial on 29 June 2006.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The case of Ramishvili and Kokhreidze received considerable public attention at the time of the demonstration on 29 June 2006.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Further details of the case of Ramishvili and Kokhreidze are described in Ramishvili and Kokhreidze v. Georgia, no. 1704/06, §§ 9-66, 27 January 2009.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicants drafted written statements on 4 and 5 July 2006 as a reminder of the exact circumstances surrounding the incident of 29 June 2006.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the applicants' written statements of 4 and 5 July 2006, the applicants entered the yard of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal through the main gates.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the applicants' written statements of 4 and 5 July 2006, the security guards noticed that one of the applicants was carrying a megaphone but did not object.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the applicants' written statements of 4 and 5 July 2006, the applicants stopped ten to twenty metres from the court-house.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the applicants' written statements of 4 and 5 July 2006, the first applicant used a megaphone to utter slogans.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The first applicant uttered the slogan: \"We should not have political prisoners in Georgia!\"", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The first applicant uttered the slogan: \"We urge you to obey justice and not the private interests of a number of high officials!\"", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The first applicant uttered the slogan: \"Give me justice or give me death!\"", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The first applicant took the view that the existing situation concerning human rights in Georgia was similar to the terror unleashed by the Soviet State in the late 1930s.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The first applicant disdainfully referred to the Minister of the Interior, Mr V.M., as \"Lavrentiy Beria's bastard\".", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the written statements of the fourth and fifth applicants, they called for the immediate release of Mr Ramishvili and Mr Kokhreidze as unlawfully detained.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the written statements of the fourth and fifth applicants, they urged the Tbilisi Court of Appeal \"not to become an accomplice of the criminal activities of the [Minister of the Interior]\".", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the applicants, nothing was displayed or addressed to the court which could be construed as contempt during the incident of 29 June 2006.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the applicants, the absence of contempt during the incident of 29 June 2006 could be confirmed by independent eyewitnesses to the incident.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the applicants, the absence of contempt during the incident of 29 June 2006 could be confirmed by images filmed by a cameraman from the 202 television channel.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The first applicant's speech had lasted some three minutes when several uniformed court bailiffs approached the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the applicants, the court bailiffs restrained the applicants by force allegedly without prior warning or explanation.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicants were taken into the court-house after being restrained by the bailiffs.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicants were locked in the bailiffs' duty room of the court-house.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the applicants' written statements of 4 and 5 July 2006, no record of the applicants' arrest was drawn up on the spot.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the applicants' written statements of 4 and 5 July 2006, the applicants were not shown any arrest record.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the applicants' written statements of 4 and 5 July 2006, the applicants were not asked to sign any arrest record.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The bailiffs reassured the applicants that they were not formally under arrest, that it was a simple misunderstanding, and that they would soon be released.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The case file contained five separate records of arrest, one for each applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The arrest records indicated the name of the drafting bailiff for each applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The arrest records indicated the name, date of birth, address, and full serial number of the identification card of each of the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The arrest records stated that the applicants had been arrested at around 2.20 p.m. on 29 June 2006.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The arrest records stated that the applicants had been arrested on the basis of section 76(3) § 1 (f) of the Courts of Common Jurisdiction Act of 13 June 1997.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The arrest records stated that the offenders had \"breached public order\" in the form of \"contempt of court, insults, disregard of the bailiffs' lawful orders to stop the wrongdoing, resistance to the bailiffs, attempts to influence the court by actions and verbal expressions, impeding the administration of justice, and so on\".", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "All arrest records contained an entry in the drafting bailiff's handwriting indicating that the applicants had \"refused to sign this record or to receive a copy thereof\".", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The President of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal was immediately informed of the offence and of the applicants' arrest.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The police were immediately informed of the offence and of the applicants' arrest.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "According to the applicants, the records of their arrest were drafted and added to the file concerning their case ex post factum.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The applicants were confined in the duty room of the court-house for some three hours in complete unawareness of the reasons for their detention.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "After being confined in the duty room, the applicants were transferred by the police to an Interior Ministry remand centre.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The case file contains an excerpt from the relevant prison log showing that the fourth applicant entered the Interior Ministry remand centre at 5.45 p.m. on 29 June 2006.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The case file contained explanatory memos from three court bailiffs who had participated in the applicants' arrest.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The explanatory memos from the three court bailiffs were half-page handwritten documents containing similar phrases.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The explanatory memos from the three court bailiffs were addressed to the Chief of the Bailiff Service of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "According to the bailiffs' explanatory memos, the applicants, \"standing near the public entrance of the court at around 2.20 p.m.\", had started \"demanding the release of political prisoners\".", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "According to the bailiffs' explanatory memos, the applicants had been \"insulting the court by their expressions and actions\".", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "One of the bailiffs stated in his memo that the applicants' actions had amounted to an encroachment upon the court's independence and impartiality.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Another bailiff stated in his memo that the wrongdoers had been trying to influence the court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "All three bailiffs stated in their memos that, prior to resorting to the measure of arrest, they had requested the applicants to stop the disturbance.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "When the applicants were transferred to the Interior Ministry remand centre, they learnt that they had been detained on the basis of a decision of 29 June 2006 issued by the President of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The decision of 29 June 2006 was a one-page document issued by the President of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal, Mrs E.T.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The decision of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The President of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal, Mrs E.T., sat privately and without holding an oral hearing when issuing the decision of 29 June 2006.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The decision of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The President of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal, Mrs E.T., decided to detain the applicants for thirty days on the basis of the bailiffs' written submissions alone.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The decision of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The detention of the applicants was ordered under Article 208 § 6(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The decision of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The decision of 29 June 2006 noted the bailiffs' version of the incident, namely that the applicants, \"who were inside the court building, in its central entrance, were breaching public order, obstructing the normal functioning of the court and seeking to influence the court with respect to proceedings in a particular case\".", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The decision of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The decision of 29 June 2006 noted that despite the bailiffs' request that they stop the disturbance, the applicants persisted with their conduct in the form of \"verbal expressions and actions\".", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The decision of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The President of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal, Mrs E.T., concluded in the decision of 29 June 2006 that the applicants had \"breached public order, shown manifest and gross contempt towards the court and endangered the administration of justice\".", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The decision of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The operative part of the decision of 29 June 2006 indicated that no appeal lay against it.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The decision of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The operative part of the decision of 29 June 2006 indicated that the applicants were to serve their sentence in remand centre no. 2 of the Ministry of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The decision of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The operative part of the decision of 29 June 2006 indicated that the Tbilisi police department was responsible for its execution.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The decision of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 21 July 2006, the applicants requested the Supreme Court of Georgia to examine their complaint against the decision of 29 June 2006 under Article 279 of the Code on Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The applicants' request to the Supreme Court of Georgia on 21 July 2006 referred to the suspension of the operation of Article 208 § 7 of the Code of Criminal Procedure by the Constitutional Court's decision of 20 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The applicants argued before the Supreme Court of Georgia that their detention was an administrative penalty.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The applicants complained before the Supreme Court of Georgia that the President of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal had committed a manifest miscarriage of justice by punishing them under Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which provision clearly envisaged liability only for acts committed inside court buildings.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The applicants submitted a video recording of their demonstration to the Supreme Court of Georgia to show that it had taken place in the yard of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The applicants argued before the Supreme Court of Georgia that Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure could not be considered a foreseeable and therefore legitimate basis for their conviction and detention.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The applicants complained before the Supreme Court of Georgia that the President of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal had violated the principles of a fair trial by delivering her decision entirely on the basis of the one-sided account provided by the bailiffs.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The applicants complained before the Supreme Court of Georgia that the President of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal had chosen the severest sanction of those available under Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 26 July 2006, Supreme Court judge Mr Z.M. examined the applicants' complaint of 21 July 2006 in absentia.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Supreme Court judge Mr Z.M. dismissed the applicants' complaint of 21 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The date of the examination of the applicants' complaint on 26 July 2006 was not communicated to the applicants in advance.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "In the decision of 26 July 2006, Judge Z.M. first noted that the suspension of Article 208 § 7 of the Code of Criminal Procedure did not automatically entitle the applicants to lodge an appeal against their detention.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Judge Z.M. acknowledged in the decision of 26 July 2006 that the applicants' detention was, by its nature, an administrative penalty.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Judge Z.M. ruled in the decision of 26 July 2006 that the complaint of 21 July 2006 against the penalty could be examined under Article 279 of the Code on Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Judge Z.M. criticised the applicants in the decision of 26 July 2006 for abusing their right to freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Judge Z.M. found in the decision of 26 July 2006 that it was established from the case materials that the applicants had truly exhibited \"manifest and gross contempt\" towards the Tbilisi Court of Appeal by committing those acts \"inside the court building, namely in its central entrance hall\".", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Judge Z.M. stated in the decision of 26 July 2006 that the aim of Article 208 § 6(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure was to protect public order not only inside court-houses but also outside them, in adjacent premises.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Judge Z.M. stated in the decision of 26 July 2006 that the President of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal had no other choice but to sanction the applicants under Article 208 § 6(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, since what was at stake was \"not the judge's own interests but the authority of the court and the proper administration of justice\".", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "In reply to the complaint that the President of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal had made her decision entirely on the basis of one-sided submissions, Judge Z.M. stated in the decision of 26 July 2006 that all the evidence — the records of the applicants' arrest and the explanatory notes — had been drafted and submitted by the bailiffs for consideration by the President in accordance with a procedure envisaged by law.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Judge Z.M. stated in the decision of 26 July 2006 that the thirty days' detention had been an appropriate punishment, given the gravity of the acts committed.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The period of the applicants' detention expired and they were released on 28 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The video recording submitted by the applicants showed excerpts from a television programme prepared by the 202 channel concerning the incident of 29 June 2006.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The video recording of the incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The first scene of the video recording briefly showed several uniformed bailiffs restraining some of the applicants in the yard of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The video recording of the incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "In the first scene of the video recording, the first applicant, holding a megaphone, was hustled by the bailiffs towards the central entrance of the court-house.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The video recording of the incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "At the end of the first scene of the video recording, a man's hand was placed over the lens of the camera.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The video recording of the incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "In a later episode of the television programme, the President of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal, Mrs E.T., was shown at a press conference concerning the applicants' arrest.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The video recording of the incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "At the press conference, the President of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal, Mrs E.T., stated: \"... five individuals, ... who have shown such direct and gross contempt towards the court and breached public order in the court... I will impose upon them, by my ruling, a form of detention for thirty days, and this will be another good example [of the fact] that respect towards courts and the maintenance of public order in court will be protected very strictly.\"", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The video recording of the incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The commentator of the television programme noted that, prior to taking office as President of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal, Mrs E.T. had served as deputy to Mr V.M., the Minister of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The video recording of the incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The remaining scenes in the television broadcast showed interviews with the applicants' advocates and supporters.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The video recording of the incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "Some of the applicants' advocates and supporters stated in the television broadcast that the applicants could not be held liable under Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, because their actions had taken place outside the court building.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The video recording of the incident of 29 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "Section 76(3) § 1 of the Courts of Common Jurisdiction Act of 13 June 1997 listed court bailiffs' rights and responsibilities, including: ensuring the safety of judges, parties to proceedings and witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Act of 13 June 1997 on Courts of Common Jurisdiction, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "Section 76(3) § 1 of the Courts of Common Jurisdiction Act of 13 June 1997 required bailiffs to maintain order inside the court-house and hearing rooms.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Act of 13 June 1997 on Courts of Common Jurisdiction, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Section 76(3) § 1 of the Courts of Common Jurisdiction Act of 13 June 1997 required bailiffs to enforce the instructions of the President of the court and of the hearing judge concerning the maintenance of order.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Act of 13 June 1997 on Courts of Common Jurisdiction, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Section 76(3) § 1 of the Courts of Common Jurisdiction Act of 13 June 1997 required bailiffs to protect the court-house.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Act of 13 June 1997 on Courts of Common Jurisdiction, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Section 76(3) § 1 of the Courts of Common Jurisdiction Act of 13 June 1997 required bailiffs to ensure that hearing rooms are well prepared for the conduct of proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Act of 13 June 1997 on Courts of Common Jurisdiction, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Section 76(3) § 1 (f) of the Courts of Common Jurisdiction Act of 13 June 1997 required bailiffs to prevent offences from being committed inside the court-house, identify offenders and, if necessary, arrest them for the purpose of handing them over to the police, and draft a written record on such arrests.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Act of 13 June 1997 on Courts of Common Jurisdiction, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Section 76(3) § 1 of the Courts of Common Jurisdiction Act of 13 June 1997 required bailiffs to exercise all other powers envisaged by law.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Act of 13 June 1997 on Courts of Common Jurisdiction, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Section 76(3) § 2 (a) of the Courts of Common Jurisdiction Act of 13 June 1997 gave bailiffs the right to resort to physical force, to \"special equipment\" and even to firearms in the exercise of their duties.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Act of 13 June 1997 on Courts of Common Jurisdiction, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Section 76(4) § 1 of the Courts of Common Jurisdiction Act of 13 June 1997 specified that the right to resort to physical force, special equipment and firearms could be exercised only if other less severe measures of constraint had been shown to be ineffective.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Act of 13 June 1997 on Courts of Common Jurisdiction, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Section 76(4) § 4 of the Courts of Common Jurisdiction Act of 13 June 1997 specified that bailiffs were obliged to issue a verbal warning to the persons concerned prior to resorting to force.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Act of 13 June 1997 on Courts of Common Jurisdiction, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, on the basis of which the applicants were sanctioned by the decision of 29 June 2006, was titled \"Liability for breach of public order in court\".", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCP\"), as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Article 208 § 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provided that the President of the court shall ensure the maintenance of public order in the court, whilst the presiding judge shall be responsible for maintaining order during the hearing of cases.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCP\"), as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Article 208 § 2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provided that a party to the proceedings, or any other person who has either breached public order during a hearing, or disregarded the presiding judge's ruling or is in contempt of court, shall be fined and/or expelled from the courtroom.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCP\"), as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Article 208 § 2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provided that if the person expelled from the courtroom continues to breach such an order, the detention envisaged by Article 208 may be imposed upon him or her.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCP\"), as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Article 208 § 6 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provided that if manifest and gross contempt of court has been shown, the judge presiding over the hearing may issue a decision to detain the offender for up to thirty days, and such a decision shall be enforced immediately.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCP\"), as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Article 208 § 6(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure provided that in the event of a breach of public order or contempt committed inside the court building, the President of the court shall be entitled to apply the measures envisaged by Article 208 against the offender.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCP\"), as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Article 208 § 7 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provided that decisions of the presiding judge and of the President of the court under Article 208 shall be delivered by on-the-spot deliberations and without an oral hearing, and no appeal shall lie against them.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCP\"), as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Subsequent to the Constitutional Court judgments of 15 December 2006, Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure was significantly revised on 29 December 2006.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCP\"), as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The newly added paragraph 8 of Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure explicitly gave court bailiffs the power to arrest a person who had either \"breached public order in the court, was in contempt, or had obstructed the normal functioning of the court\".", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCP\"), as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Under the revised Article 208 § 8 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, bailiffs were obliged to draw up a record of such arrests and to bring the offenders before the President of the relevant court within twenty-four hours.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCP\"), as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Under the revised Article 208 § 8 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the President had a further twenty-four hours to issue a decision on whether to punish the offender.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCP\"), as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Paragraphs 10 and 11 of the amended Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure stated that proceedings concerning the imposition of detention on an offender should always be adversarial and conducted at an oral hearing at which the offender would be given an opportunity to defend him or herself.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCP\"), as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Under the amended Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, should the President decide to detain the offender, the latter was entitled to lodge an appeal against that decision with the higher court within the next forty-eight hours.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCP\"), as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Code on Administrative Offences was adopted on 15 December 1984, when Georgia was part of the Soviet Union.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Numerous amendments were subsequently introduced to the Code on Administrative Offences after its adoption in 1984.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Article 10 of the Code on Administrative Offences defined an administrative offence as a wrongful action or omission, committed either deliberately or by negligence, which contravenes the State or public order, the rules on Governance, property or citizens' rights and freedoms, and which attracts administrative liability.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Article 10 of the Code on Administrative Offences provided that administrative liability shall be imposed only in those cases where the offences envisaged under the Code do not call for criminal liability in the light of the applicable legislation.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Article 24 § 1 of the Code on Administrative Offences listed the forms of administrative penalties, of which administrative detention was the severest.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Pursuant to Article 32 § 1 of the Code on Administrative Offences, administrative detention could be imposed by a district (city) court, only as an exception, for certain types of administrative offences and for a period not exceeding thirty days.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Article 244 of the Code on Administrative Offences provided for measures of restraint in administrative proceedings, such as administrative arrest, search of the person or of objects, seizure of objects and of documents.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Article 244 of the Code on Administrative Offences provided that measures of restraint, including arrest, could be used \"in order to prevent an administrative offence..., to ensure a timely and proper examination of an administrative case, and to enforce any decision or ruling delivered in such a case\".", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Article 246 of the Code on Administrative Offences contained an inclusive list of those authorities which were empowered to effectuate an administrative arrest.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Court bailiffs were not among the authorities empowered to effectuate an administrative arrest under Article 246 of the Code on Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Pursuant to Article 247 of the Code on Administrative Offences, administrative arrest must not exceed three hours, unless specific statutes provided for longer terms \"in cases of exceptional need\".", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Articles 252, 263 and 264 of the Code on Administrative Offences contained procedural and substantive rules on the conduct of administrative proceedings, similar to those normally applicable to criminal proceedings in court.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Under Articles 252, 263 and 264 of the Code on Administrative Offences, a person charged with an administrative offence had the right to examine the case materials.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Under Articles 252, 263 and 264 of the Code on Administrative Offences, a person charged with an administrative offence had the right to submit arguments, evidence and requests.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Under Articles 252, 263 and 264 of the Code on Administrative Offences, a person charged with an administrative offence had the right to benefit from legal assistance during the examination of the case.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Under Articles 252, 263 and 264 of the Code on Administrative Offences, a person charged with an administrative offence had the right to plead in his or her native language or to be assisted by an interpreter.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Under Articles 252, 263 and 264 of the Code on Administrative Offences, a person charged with an administrative offence had the right to appeal against procedural rulings.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Under Articles 252, 263 and 264 of the Code on Administrative Offences, an administrative case was always to be examined in the presence of the charged person during an oral hearing.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Under Articles 252, 263 and 264 of the Code on Administrative Offences, in absentia proceedings could take place only if the charged person had been duly summoned but had failed to appear.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Pursuant to Article 271 § 2 of the Code on Administrative Offences, no appeal lay, as a general rule, against a court decision convicting a person of an administrative offence and imposing a penalty.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Pursuant to Article 279 of the Code on Administrative Offences, a final decision could be quashed by means of an extraordinary review, at the request of a prosecutor or by the President of the superior court.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Article 271 § 2 of the Code on Administrative Offences provided: \"The city (district) court's decision to impose an administrative penalty is final and not subject to an appeal in administrative proceedings, except for those cases where a law holds otherwise.\"", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Article 279 of the Code on Administrative Offences provided: \"The administrative judge's (court's) decision concerning an administrative offence can be quashed or amended by the delivering judge (court) at a prosecutor's request and, whether or not such a request has been lodged, by the President of the superior court...\"", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Code on Administrative Offences, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "Article 413 § 1 of the Civil Code explained the notion of non-pecuniary damage, providing that non-pecuniary damage, the amount of which should be reasonable and equitable, can be claimed exclusively in the situations explicitly envisaged by law.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. The Civil Code and the Code of Civil Procedure, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "Article 413 § 2 of the Civil Code provided that an individual is entitled to request compensation for non-pecuniary damage caused in respect of damage to his or her health.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. The Civil Code and the Code of Civil Procedure, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "Article 1005 of the Civil Code specified that State agencies were jointly liable for damage caused to a private party by intentional or negligent actions on the part of their officials.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. The Civil Code and the Code of Civil Procedure, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "Article 1005 of the Civil Code specified that State liability included such particular instances as unlawful conviction for a criminal or administrative offence or imposition of unlawful detention, the existence of which should first be established by a court.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. The Civil Code and the Code of Civil Procedure, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "Pursuant to Article 423 § 1 (f) of the Code of Civil Procedure, a final judgment (decision) in a civil case could be reconsidered on the basis of newly discovered circumstances.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. The Civil Code and the Code of Civil Procedure, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Under Article 423 § 1 (f) of the Code of Civil Procedure, grounds for reconsideration included factual circumstances or evidence which, had they been submitted to the domestic courts pending the original examination of the case, would have led to a different outcome.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. The Civil Code and the Code of Civil Procedure, as worded at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The Constitutional Court case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\" originated in constitutional appeals by two advocates who had been detained under Article 208 § 6 of the Code of Criminal Procedure for breach of public order and contempt of court committed in courtrooms during the oral hearing of criminal cases.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. The Constitutional Court's judgment of 15 December 2006 in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\""]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "In a decision of 20 July 2006, the Constitutional Court declared the constitutional appeals in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\" admissible for an examination on the merits.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. The Constitutional Court's judgment of 15 December 2006 in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\""]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "In its decision of 20 July 2006, the Constitutional Court suspended the operation of Article 208 § 7 of the Code of Criminal Procedure pending the proceedings in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\".", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. The Constitutional Court's judgment of 15 December 2006 in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\""]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "In a judgment of 15 December 2006, the Constitutional Court abrogated Article 208 § 7 of the Code of Criminal Procedure as unconstitutional.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. The Constitutional Court's judgment of 15 December 2006 in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\""]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "In its judgment of 15 December 2006, the Constitutional Court, referring to the Court's case-law, found that Article 6 § 1 of the Convention applied under its \"criminal head\" to the proceedings under Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. The Constitutional Court's judgment of 15 December 2006 in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\""]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "In its judgment of 15 December 2006, the Constitutional Court reasoned that proceedings under Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which entitled the hearing judge to convict a person of a breach of public order/contempt of court by on-the-spot deliberations without holding an oral hearing, negated the most fundamental safeguards of a fair trial, such as the right to equality of arms and adversarial proceedings and the right to have adequate time and facilities for the preparation of the defence.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. The Constitutional Court's judgment of 15 December 2006 in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\""]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "In its judgment of 15 December 2006, the Constitutional Court stated that paragraph 7 of Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure violated Article 42 § 1 of the Constitution of Georgia by denying a person convicted under Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure the right to lodge an appeal.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. The Constitutional Court's judgment of 15 December 2006 in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\""]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "In its judgment of 15 December 2006, the Constitutional Court stated that paragraph 7 of Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure violated Article 2 of Protocol No. 7 to the Convention by denying a person convicted under Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure the right to lodge an appeal.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. The Constitutional Court's judgment of 15 December 2006 in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\""]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "In support of its finding regarding Article 2 of Protocol No. 7, the Constitutional Court referred to the Court's judgment in the case of Gurepka v. Ukraine (no. 61406/00, §§ 59-62, 6 September 2005).", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. The Constitutional Court's judgment of 15 December 2006 in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\""]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "In its judgment of 15 December 2006, the Constitutional Court criticised the definition of the offence of contempt of court as contained in paragraph 6 of Article 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure as vague.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. The Constitutional Court's judgment of 15 December 2006 in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\""]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The Constitutional Court stated in its judgment of 15 December 2006 that \"the offence prescribed by the disputed provision is not clearly formulated... and the interpretation may be ambiguous due to the lack of specificity and vagueness of the provision\".", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. The Constitutional Court's judgment of 15 December 2006 in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\""]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The Constitutional Court stated in its judgment of 15 December 2006 that where legislation introduces a sanction such as detention, an offender must clearly understand the nature of the offence for which he is subjected to detention, and the judge applying the law should be able to do so correctly and adequately.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. The Constitutional Court's judgment of 15 December 2006 in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\""]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The Constitutional Court stated in its judgment of 15 December 2006 that achieving and maintaining the protection of the authority of the courts and the smooth functioning of the justice system should not be carried out at the expense of the impairment of fundamental human rights.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. The Constitutional Court's judgment of 15 December 2006 in the case of \"Masurashvili and Mebonia v. the Parliament of Georgia\""]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F012", "F019", "F021", "F007", "F033", "F035", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F034", "F095", "F096"], "interference": ["F033", "F035", "F036", "F052", "F065", "F066", "F069"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F108", "F118", "F012", "F019", "F021", "F067", "F164", "F165"], "legitimate_aim": ["F016", "F099"], "necessity": ["F007", "F012", "F033", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F016", "F009", "F026", "F034", "F095", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F068", "F069", "F067", "F019", "F021", "F096", "F117", "F130", "F093"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F012", "F007", "F033", "F027", "F034"], "interference": ["F035", "F065", "F066"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F108", "F118", "F019", "F021", "F164"], "legitimate_aim": ["F016", "F099"], "necessity": ["F012", "F033", "F007", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F027", "F029", "F034", "F063", "F065", "F067", "F117"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F012", "F033", "F007", "F027", "F034", "F067", "F065", "F117", "F108", "F118", "F019"]}} {"case_name": "case_342", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_343", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F001", "F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_344", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_345", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_348", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of country-wide protests against a retirement age hike.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The country-wide protests against the retirement age hike were organised by Aleksey Navalnyy.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The country-wide protests against the retirement age hike organised by Aleksey Navalnyy took place on 9 September 2018.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_350", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant is a former World Chess Champion.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The first applicant is a political activist.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth, and seventh applicants are political activists.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 24 November 2007 a group of opposition politicians organised protest rallies in several Russian cities, including Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The protest rallies of 24 November 2007 were part of a public campaign \"[f]or the consolidation of democratic forces in order to defend the Constitution and the legal order\".", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The public campaign \"[f]or the consolidation of democratic forces in order to defend the Constitution and the legal order\" was initiated before the Presidential elections in March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 24 November 2007 the applicants attended a gathering on Academician Sakharov Prospekt.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The gathering on Academician Sakharov Prospekt on 24 November 2007 had been organised by the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The gathering on Academician Sakharov Prospekt on 24 November 2007 had been approved by the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the applicants, at 3 p.m. on 24 November 2007, at the end of the gathering on Academician Sakharov Prospekt, the applicants started walking to the location of another authorised gathering on Chistoprudnyy Boulevard.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The authorised gathering on Chistoprudnyy Boulevard took place between 2 p.m. and 4 p.m. on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Government alleged that some 1,500 people took part in the procession on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicants contested the Government's figure of 1,500 participants in the procession as grossly overestimated.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On their way from Academician Sakharov Prospekt, which ran past Myasnitskaya Street, the applicants also intended to take a petition to the Central Electoral Committee.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicants' route on 24 November 2007 was blocked by the riot police.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicants were arrested on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Excessive force was allegedly used against the applicants at the time of their arrest on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "At 3.45 p.m. on 24 November 2007 the first and second applicants were taken to the Basmannyy District police station.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "A duty officer at the Basmannyy District police station drew up an administrative offence statement (протокол об административном правонарушении) in respect of the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "A duty officer at the Basmannyy District police station drew up an administrative offence statement (протокол об административном правонарушении) in respect of the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The administrative offence statements in respect of the first and second applicants were drawn up on the basis of reports (рапорт) by police officers M. and U.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The first applicant was charged with breaching the established procedure for conducting public events, an offence under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The first applicant was charged with disobeying lawful police orders, an offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The second applicant was charged with breaching the established procedure for conducting public events, an offence under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The second applicant was charged with disobeying lawful police orders, an offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The administrative detention of the first and second applicants was ordered with reference to Article 27.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The first applicant was detained until 6.20 p.m. on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The second applicant was detained until an unspecified time on 26 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Immediately after his release from detention on 24 November 2007, the first applicant appeared before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the first applicant, members of the public who wanted to attend the hearing of his case were prevented from entering the court on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the first applicant, the court had been cordoned off by the riot police on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The first applicant claimed that even his lawyers had experienced difficulties getting into the court of the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The first applicant applied for the hearing before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow to be adjourned until 26 November 2007 to allow him time to study the case file with his lawyer and prepare his defence.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The hearing before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow was adjourned, but only until 7.15 p.m. on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The first applicant applied for six witnesses to be called and examined at the hearing before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The six witnesses the first applicant applied to have called included four police officers.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The six witnesses the first applicant applied to have called included two eyewitnesses waiting outside the courthouse.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The first applicant requested that certain video and photographic material be admitted as evidence at the hearing before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow examined police officers M. and U. at the hearing concerning the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Police officer M. stated that after the public gathering on 24 November 2007 the first applicant had participated in an unauthorised march down Myasnitskaya Street towards Chistoprudnyy Boulevard.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "Police officer U. stated that after the public gathering on 24 November 2007 the first applicant had participated in an unauthorised march down Myasnitskaya Street towards Chistoprudnyy Boulevard.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Police officers M. and U. stated that the first applicant had chanted \"Down with Putin!\" during the march on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The first applicant pleaded not guilty at the hearing before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The first applicant disputed the police officers' testimony and police reports at the hearing before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The first applicant testified that he had been arrested while walking alongside other people from one authorised gathering to another on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The first applicant testified that when he had seen that the path had been blocked by the police he had turned back as ordered, but as he had walked away he had been arrested.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The first applicant insisted that there had been no other way of complying with the police's order to disperse than to turn back.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The first applicant denied that there had been an organised march on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The first applicant denied that he had called out to anyone to follow him on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 24 November 2007 the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow found the first applicant guilty of both charges.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow established that the first applicant had marched among some 1,500 people in what had constituted an unauthorised public event on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow based her findings on police officers M. and U.'s witness statements and written reports.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow based her findings on the administrative offence statements in respect of two charges against the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow based her findings on the report on the administrative arrest of the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow dismissed the first applicant's testimony as false, finding that it contradicted the police officers' testimony and reports.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow found police officers M. and U.'s testimony and reports trustworthy because they had \"no vested interest\".", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow sentenced the first applicant to five days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow noted that the first applicant had a previous conviction for a similar administrative offence when sentencing him.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 26 November 2007 the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow considered the administrative charges against the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The second applicant applied for six witnesses to be called and examined at the hearing before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The six witnesses the second applicant applied to have called included five police officers.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The six witnesses the second applicant applied to have called included one defence witness.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow examined only police officer U. at the hearing concerning the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Police officer U. gave essentially the same testimony in the second applicant's case as in the first applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The second applicant pleaded not guilty at the hearing before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The second applicant alleged that he had been arrested while walking from the authorised meeting on Academician Sakharov Prospekt to the metro station on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow based her findings in the second applicant's case on police officer U.'s witness statements and the written police reports.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow dismissed the second applicant's testimony on the same grounds as in the first applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow found the second applicant guilty of both charges.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 382 of the Krasnoselskiy District of Moscow sentenced the second applicant to five days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 26 November 2007 the Meshchanskiy District Court of Moscow examined and dismissed the appeal lodged by the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 26 November 2007 the Meshchanskiy District Court of Moscow examined and dismissed the appeal lodged by the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The applicants served their sentences in detention centres for administrative offenders (спецприемник).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The other applicants (third, fourth, fifth, sixth, and seventh applicants) were arrested in the same circumstances as the first and second applicants on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The other applicants (third, fourth, fifth, sixth, and seventh applicants) were convicted of administrative offences.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic law is contained in Kasparov and Others v. Russia (no. 21613/07, § 35, 3 October 2013).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic law is contained in Navalnyy and Yashin v. Russia (no. 76204/11, §§ 43-44, 4 December 2014).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F005", "F007", "F009", "F010", "F012", "F015", "F016"], "interference": ["F015", "F016", "F018", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F057", "F070"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002", "F004", "F005", "F007", "F009", "F015", "F016", "F022", "F024", "F050", "F051", "F057", "F069", "F070", "F073"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F005", "F007", "F009", "F010", "F012", "F015", "F016"], "interference": ["F015", "F016", "F057", "F070"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002", "F004", "F022", "F024", "F051", "F057", "F070", "F073"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F007", "F010", "F015", "F016", "F051", "F022", "F057", "F070", "F073", "F001", "F002", "F004"]}} {"case_name": "case_351", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) was born in 1963.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Mr Tarasov (the second applicant) was born in 1968.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Mr Tarasov (the second applicant) lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Mr Kharlamov (the third applicant) was born in 1973.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Mr Kharlamov (the third applicant) lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Mr Kalashnikov (the fourth applicant) was born in 1971.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Mr Kalashnikov (the fourth applicant) lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Mr Toropov (the fifth applicant) was born in 1973.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Mr Toropov (the fifth applicant) lives in Orudyevo, in the Moscow Region.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Mr Stelmakh (the sixth applicant) was born in 1978.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Mr Stelmakh (the sixth applicant) lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Mr Orel (the seventh applicant) was born in 1968.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Mr Orel (the seventh applicant) lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Mr Melikhov (the eighth applicant) was born in 1972.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Mr Melikhov (the eighth applicant) lives in Korolev, in the Moscow Region.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Ms Chelysheva (the ninth applicant) was born in 1967.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Ms Chelysheva (the ninth applicant) lives in Nizhniy Novgorod.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "In 2007 Mr Kasparov (the first applicant), together with other individuals representing a coalition of opposition groups, intended to take part in an anti-government rally to campaign before the forthcoming parliamentary elections.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The demonstration became known as the March of Dissenters.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The March of Dissenters was organised by three individuals, none of whom are applicants in the present case.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 30 March 2007 the three organisers of the March of Dissenters submitted notice of a public demonstration to the mayor of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The notice indicated that a meeting would be held at 12 noon on 14 April 2007 in Novopushkinskiy Park.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The notice indicated that the meeting would last until 1.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The notice indicated that the meeting would be followed by a march via Tverskaya Street and Okhotnyy Ryad Street to Teatralnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The notice indicated that the march was to end at 2 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The organisers estimated that about 2,000 people would take part in the event.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The notice stated that the proposed demonstration was intended \"to express the demands of Russian citizens for the urgent reinstatement of the full scope of citizens' electoral rights, through the abolition of the legislative amendments of recent years\".", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 5 April 2007 the Department for Liaison with Security Authorities of the Moscow Government informed the organisers that the event was liable to disrupt the functioning of urban services and the movement of passers-by.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Department for Liaison with Security Authorities of the Moscow Government informed the organisers that authorisation could only be granted for a meeting at the foot of the Griboyedov monument on Chistoprudnyy Boulevard between 12 noon and 1.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The authorised meeting at the foot of the Griboyedov monument on Chistoprudnyy Boulevard was at a different location in central Moscow from the originally proposed venue.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Department for Liaison with Security Authorities of the Moscow Government informed the organisers that the number of participants at the authorised meeting could not exceed 1,000, the maximum capacity of the venue.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "No march was authorised by the Department for Liaison with Security Authorities of the Moscow Government.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 6 April 2007 the organisers resubmitted the notice, proposing four alternative routes for the march, all in central Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 6 April 2007 the organisers agreed to limit the number of participants to 1,000.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 10 April 2007 the Department for Liaison with Security Authorities of the Moscow Government informed the organisers that none of the four alternative routes could be accepted.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Department for Liaison with Security Authorities of the Moscow Government rejected the four alternative routes for the same reasons as the refusal of the original proposal.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Department for Liaison with Security Authorities of the Moscow Government suggested that the organisers hold the event at an aeronautical club in one of the Moscow suburbs.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Documents submitted by the Government reveal that on 14 April 2007 the Moscow police were reinforced by special units of the riot police (OMON).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The OMON units reinforcing the Moscow police on 14 April 2007 were brought in specially from twenty-nine regions of Russia.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The stated purpose of bringing in OMON units from twenty-nine regions of Russia on 14 April 2007 was \"to protect public order and security\" on that day.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the Government, on 14 April 2007 at about 11.40 a.m. groups of people started gathering near Pushkinskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the Government, a group of about twenty persons, including the first eight applicants, started marching down Tverskaya Street while shouting anti-government slogans on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the Government, the total number of people who took part in the unauthorised march on 14 April 2007 was about fifty.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to the Government, the first eight applicants were arrested as they tried to pass from Tverskaya Street onto Red Square on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Government originally alleged that the march down Tverskaya Street had begun at 1.30 p.m., as had been indicated in the police reports.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Government subsequently submitted that the first eight applicants had been arrested at 1 p.m. and brought to the police station at 1.30 p.m. on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicants claimed that they had not staged a demonstration in Tverskaya Street, but had happened to be there for different reasons.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Mr Kasparov (the first applicant), Mr Tarasov (the second applicant) and Mr Toropov (the fifth applicant) claimed that at 12 noon on 14 April 2007 they had been walking peacefully down Tverskaya Street towards the place of the authorised meeting at the Griboyedov monument.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The applicants did not specify the number of people walking alongside them on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The applicants claimed that their way had been barred by the riot police who were blocking off several streets in central Moscow on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The applicants claimed that all pedestrians, both aspiring protesters and unsuspecting passers-by, had been pushed back, surrounded and indiscriminately beaten up by the riot police before being arrested and taken in police vans to different police stations on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Mr Stelmakh (the sixth applicant) claimed that he had not been heading to a meeting but had been walking down Tverskaya Street with his friends on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Mr Stelmakh (the sixth applicant) claimed that when he saw the riot police dispersing a crowd and arresting people he had dropped into the \"Russkoye Bistro\" café on Tverskaya Street.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Mr Stelmakh (the sixth applicant) claimed that he was arrested at about 12 noon in the \"Russkoye Bistro\" café on Tverskaya Street on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Mr Kharlamov (the third applicant) claimed that he had had no intention of participating in a public event on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Mr Kharlamov (the third applicant) claimed that he had been arrested when he came out of a shop near Pushkinskaya Square after having collected his mobile phone, which was being repaired.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Mr Kalashnikov (the fourth applicant) claimed that he had been arrested when he was heading to a local McDonald's restaurant to meet a friend on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Mr Orel (the seventh applicant) submitted that he had been heading to McDonald's on 14 April 2007 but could not get there because the street was closed off by the riot police.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Mr Orel (the seventh applicant) claimed that he had dropped into the \"Russkoye Bistro\" café on Tverskaya Street, where he had been arrested on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Mr Melikhov (the eighth applicant) said that he had been heading to McDonald's on 14 April 2007 but could not get there and had been arrested in Tverskaya Street.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The applicants claimed that there had been at least thirty other people in the police van, all of whom had been arrested at the same time as the applicants on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "When the applicants arrived at the police station on 14 April 2007, reports on their administrative arrest were drawn up in accordance with Article 27.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The first to eighth applicants were charged with the administrative offence of breaching the regulations on holding demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 17 April 2007 Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) received a letter from the Federal Security Service summoning him for an interview.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Federal Security Service summoned Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) for an interview following a media appeal broadcast on 8 April 2007 by the radio station Ekho Moskvy, in which he had called on listeners to take part in the demonstration on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Federal Security Service suggested that Mr Kasparov's statements on Ekho Moskvy could constitute the criminal offence of incitement to extremist activities.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "There is no information on any follow-up to the Federal Security Service interview of Mr Kasparov (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Demonstration of 14 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "After his arrest on 14 April 2007 Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) was taken to the police station and was then brought before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) was charged with a breach of the established procedure for conducting public assemblies, an offence under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The hearing of the administrative case against Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) was fixed for 5.30 p.m. on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) filed two motions to have the hearing adjourned in order to have sufficient time to prepare his defence.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow noted the insignificant volume of the case file (five pages) and decided to hold the hearing on 14 April 2007, having postponed it first by forty-five minutes and then by an additional twenty minutes.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "At 6.30 p.m. on 14 April 2007 the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow examined the charges against Mr Kasparov (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "At the hearing on 14 April 2007 Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) was represented by a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The applicants alleged that no members of the public had been allowed in the courtroom during the hearing on 14 April 2007, as the building had been cordoned off by the police.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Mr Kasparov's (the first applicant's) counsel, Ms Moskalenko, filed a motion to have the hearing opened to the public.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow issued a decision stating that the hearing was open to the public.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "At the beginning of the hearing on 14 April 2007, Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) filed a motion to call and examine six eyewitnesses, four of whom had been arrested at the same time as him.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow rejected the motion to call eyewitnesses, holding that it was premature to call witnesses before the applicant and the police had been questioned.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow examined the police report, according to which Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) had been arrested at 1.30 p.m. while \"walking in a big group of people shouting anti-government slogans\".", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow questioned Mr I., the policeman who had arrested Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) and drawn up the report.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Mr I. testified that because of the public manifestations expected to take place between 12 noon and 4 p.m. on 14 April 2007 he had received an instruction to safeguard public order at 19 Tverskaya Street, in particular to stop any organised groups of people heading in the direction of Red Square.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Mr I. testified that Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) had been walking in a group of about fifty to sixty people on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Mr I. testified that, following instructions to disperse the unauthorised demonstration which was threatening to spill over into the security perimeter of Red Square, he had arrested Mr Kasparov (the first applicant).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) claimed that the policeman Mr I. had given the wrong place and time of the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) reiterated the request to question the eyewitnesses, stating that the persons in question were waiting outside the court and were ready to be called.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow rejected the motion to call eyewitnesses on the grounds that the persons concerned had not been mentioned in the police report and that the facts were sufficiently clear to determine the charges.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow accepted the version of events put forward by the police, finding that Mr I.'s testimony was credible because he was performing his professional duties, had not been acquainted with the applicant, had no reason to slander him, and was a party with no vested interest.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow referred to the Moscow authorities' decision of 5 April 2007 and concluded that on 14 April 2007 Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) had attempted to take part in an unauthorised demonstration at 19 Tverskaya Street, where he had been arrested.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) was found to have acted in breach of the regulations on holding demonstrations and was convicted of an administrative offence under Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) was ordered to pay a fine of 1,000 Russian roubles (about 25 euros).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) appealed to the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow against his conviction.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) contested the facts as established at first instance in his appeal to the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) claimed in his appeal that the hearing had not been held in public.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) alleged in his appeal that he had not been given a chance to prepare his defence or to present his case adequately.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 14 May 2007 the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow examined Mr Kasparov's (the first applicant's) appeal.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "On 14 May 2007 the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow upheld the first-instance judgment against Mr Kasparov (the first applicant), reiterating that he had participated in an unauthorised demonstration and had been marching in a group of people chanting anti-government slogans.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow noted that there had been no proof that the first-instance hearing had not been held in public.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow noted that there had been no proof that Mr Kasparov (the first applicant) had not been given sufficient time to prepare his defence, since he had had two hours to do so.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Administrative proceedings concerning the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants were conducted at first instance by the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The second to eighth applicants were each individually convicted of having breached the procedure for the conduct of public assemblies, an administrative offence under Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The second to eighth applicants were each ordered to pay a fine of 1,000 Russian roubles.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "During the trial, the second to eighth applicants all contested the police reports, in particular as regards the time and circumstances of their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "During the trial, the second to eighth applicants all requested the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow to call and examine eyewitnesses.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow found that the facts were sufficiently established in each of the second to eighth applicants' cases and rejected the requests to call eyewitnesses.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The decisions and reasons given by the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow in the second to eighth applicants' cases were essentially the same as in Mr Kasparov's (the first applicant's) case.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Mr Toropov's (the fifth applicant's) case was examined in his absence and in the absence of his lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow rejected a motion lodged by Mr Toropov (the fifth applicant) for the proceedings to be adjourned, finding that it was possible to proceed without the applicant and his lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The first-instance judgments in the second, third, fourth and sixth applicants' cases were given on 16 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The first-instance judgment in Mr Toropov's (the fifth applicant's) case was given on 22 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The first-instance judgments in the seventh and eighth applicants' cases were given on 25 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The second to eighth applicants subsequently appealed unsuccessfully to the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The reasons given by the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow on appeal in the second to eighth applicants' cases were essentially the same as in Mr Kasparov's (the first applicant's) case.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The appeal decisions in the second, third, fourth, sixth, seventh and eighth applicants' cases were given on 14 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The appeal decision in Mr Toropov's (the fifth applicant's) case was given on 11 July 2007.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Administrative proceedings concerning the second to eighth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Ms Chelysheva (the ninth applicant) alleged that on 14 April 2007 she had been heading to the meeting at the Griboyedov monument.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The complaint lodged by the ninth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Ms Chelysheva (the ninth applicant) alleged that at Sretenskiye Vorota Square she and other pedestrians had been attacked by a unit of the riot police on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The complaint lodged by the ninth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Ms Chelysheva (the ninth applicant) alleged that she had seen a policeman hitting a man with a truncheon and had intervened to try to stop the beating.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The complaint lodged by the ninth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Ms Chelysheva (the ninth applicant) alleged that a policeman had kicked her on her left leg.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The complaint lodged by the ninth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Ms Chelysheva (the ninth applicant) alleged that she had been badly hurt and therefore could not go to the meeting at the Griboyedov monument on 14 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The complaint lodged by the ninth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Later on 14 April 2007 Ms Chelysheva (the ninth applicant) sought medical help at Moscow City Clinic no. 137.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The complaint lodged by the ninth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Ms Chelysheva (the ninth applicant) was diagnosed with a haematoma of the left ankle at Moscow City Clinic no. 137.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The complaint lodged by the ninth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "On 16 April 2007 Ms Chelysheva (the ninth applicant) filed a complaint with the Moscow prosecutor's office requesting that criminal proceedings be brought against the policemen who had used force against her.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The complaint lodged by the ninth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "On 6 July 2007 the Meshchanskiy Inter-District Prosecutor's Office decided to dispense with a criminal investigation into the incident involving Ms Chelysheva (the ninth applicant).", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The complaint lodged by the ninth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "On 18 March 2011 the Meshchanskiy Inter-District Prosecutor's Office quashed its decision of 6 July 2007 to dispense with a criminal investigation and remitted the file for additional investigation.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The complaint lodged by the ninth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Instructions were given to question Ms Chelysheva (the ninth applicant) and three named eyewitnesses, to obtain the medical documents and to conduct a forensic examination.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The complaint lodged by the ninth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "There is no information as to the outcome of the additional investigation proceedings remitted by the Meshchanskiy Inter-District Prosecutor's Office on 18 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. The complaint lodged by the ninth applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Article 20.2 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that breaches of the established procedure for the organisation of public gatherings, meetings, demonstrations, marches or pickets shall be punishable by an administrative fine of between ten and twenty times the minimum wage, payable by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that breaches of the established procedure for the conduct of public gatherings, meetings, demonstrations, marches or pickets shall be punishable by an administrative fine of between 1,000 and 2,000 Russian roubles for the organisers, and between 500 and 1,000 Russian roubles for the participants.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Article 27.2 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the escorting or transfer by force of an individual for the purpose of drawing up an administrative offence report, if this cannot be done at the place where the offence was discovered and if the drawing-up of a report is mandatory, shall be carried out by the police.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Article 27.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the escort operation shall be carried out as quickly as possible.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Article 27.2 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the escort operation shall be recorded in an escort operation report, an administrative offence report or an administrative detention report, and that the escorted person shall be given a copy of the escort operation report if he or she so requests.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Article 27.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that administrative arrest or short-term restriction of an individual's liberty may be applied in exceptional cases if this is necessary for the prompt and proper examination of the alleged administrative offence or to secure the enforcement of any penalty imposed by a judgment concerning an administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Article 27.3 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that where the detained person so requests, his family, the administrative department at his place of work or study and his defence counsel shall be informed of his whereabouts.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Article 27.3 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the arrested person shall have his rights and obligations under the Code explained to him, and the corresponding entry shall be made in the administrative arrest report.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Article 27.4 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the administrative arrest shall be recorded in a report.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Article 27.4 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that if he or she so requests, the arrested person shall be given a copy of the administrative arrest report.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Article 27.5 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the duration of the administrative arrest shall not exceed three hours, except in the cases set out in paragraphs 2 and 3 of that Article.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Article 27.5 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that persons subject to administrative proceedings concerning offences involving unlawful crossing of the Russian border may be subject to administrative arrest for up to 48 hours.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Article 27.5 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that persons subject to administrative proceedings concerning offences punishable, among other administrative sanctions, by administrative detention may be subject to administrative arrest for up to 48 hours.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F050", "F044", "F046", "F082", "F085", "F091", "F099", "F057", "F058", "F059", "F054", "F060", "F062", "F045", "F086"], "interference": ["F064", "F065", "F070", "F092", "F093", "F103", "F104", "F046"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F082", "F087", "F105", "F107", "F089", "F090", "F047", "F048", "F050"], "legitimate_aim": ["F065", "F086", "F091", "F092"], "necessity": ["F082", "F091", "F092", "F099", "F103", "F030", "F034", "F037", "F086", "F084", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F085", "F044", "F045"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F050", "F082", "F085", "F044", "F045", "F091"], "interference": ["F064", "F065", "F092", "F103"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F082", "F087", "F105", "F089", "F047", "F048"], "legitimate_aim": ["F065", "F086"], "necessity": ["F082", "F091", "F092", "F099", "F034", "F084", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F085", "F086", "F044"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F034", "F082", "F091", "F092", "F084", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F085", "F044"]}} {"case_name": "case_352", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1963.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "An EU-Russia summit was scheduled for 17 and 18 May 2007 to take place in Samara.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 18 May 2007 the applicant was travelling to Samara to take part in the opposition rally called 'March of Dissent'.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The opposition rally 'March of Dissent' had been organised to coincide with the EU-Russia summit scheduled for 17 and 18 May 2007 in Samara.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant was accompanied by several activists who were also travelling to the 'March of Dissent' rally in Samara on 18 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "At 8.30 a.m. on 18 May 2007, the applicant and his fellow activists arrived at Terminal 1 of Sheremetyevo airport, Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant and his fellow activists attempted to check in for flight no. SU0697 to Samara at Terminal 1 of Sheremetyevo airport, Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The parties have submitted different versions of events as to what happened after the applicant and his fellow activists attempted to check in for flight no. SU0697 at Terminal 1 of Sheremetyevo airport on 18 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicant submits that, when he presented his passport for identity check, police officer A. seized the applicant's passport.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant submits that, when he presented his passport for identity check, police officer A. seized the applicant's ticket.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant submits that he was required to leave the check-in area and to follow police officer A.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant submits that he was taken to a police office on the second floor of Sheremetyevo airport.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant submits that five other persons from his group were escorted from the check-in hall in the same manner as the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "At 11.20 a.m. on 18 May 2007, the applicant and the five others from his group were ordered to remain on the second floor of Sheremetyevo airport.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "At 11.20 a.m. on 18 May 2007, the applicant and the five others from his group were informed that they would have to be questioned as to how they had purchased their allegedly forged tickets.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "At 12.20 p.m. on 18 May 2007, the operative duty police officer from the Department of the Interior (Criminal Division), Captain N., questioned the applicant as to where he had bought his ticket.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant replied to Captain N. that his ticket had been purchased lawfully.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant refused to give any further explanation to Captain N., relying on his constitutional right to remain silent.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant maintains that he was under orders not to leave the police office at Sheremetyevo airport.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant maintains that he was prevented from leaving the police office at Sheremetyevo airport by an armed policeman who was guarding the doorway.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant remained at the police station at Sheremetyevo airport until 1.30 p.m. on 18 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant has submitted three documents in support of his version of events.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The first document submitted by the applicant is a copy of the record (протокол) of search and confiscation completed by Captain N.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The record (протокол) of search and confiscation completed by Captain N. records that the applicant was searched.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The record (протокол) of search and confiscation completed by Captain N. records that the applicant's aeroplane ticket was confiscated in accordance with Articles 21.1, 27.7 and 27.10 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "At the bottom of the record (протокол) of search and confiscation, the applicant has written that it had been explained to him that the search and seizure could be appealed to a higher authority.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "At the bottom of the record (протокол) of search and confiscation, the applicant has written that the record had been handed to him at 1 p.m. on 18 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "At the bottom of the record (протокол) of search and confiscation, the applicant has written that the actual seizure of the ticket by police officer A. had taken place at 8.30 a.m. at the check-in desk.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The second document submitted by the applicant is a pro forma statement (объяснение) filled in by Captain N.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Captain N. recorded in the pro forma statement (объяснение) that he began filling out the statement at 12.40 p.m. on 18 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Captain N. recorded in the pro forma statement (объяснение) that he finished filling out the statement at 12.50 p.m. on 18 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "Captain N. recorded in the pro forma statement (объяснение) that, when asked, the applicant refused to give an explanation for the ticket.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On the pro forma statement (объяснение), the applicant has written that the ticket was obtained legally.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On the pro forma statement (объяснение), the applicant has written that, relying on Article 51 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation (the right against self-incrimination), he refused to give any further explanation because he had been detained illegally in the departure hall without explanation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On the pro forma statement (объяснение), the applicant has written that from 8.30 a.m. until 12.50 p.m. on 18 May 2007 he had been deprived of his freedom of movement.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On the pro forma statement (объяснение), the applicant has written that no documents had been provided to him until 12.50 p.m. on 18 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The third document submitted by the applicant is a handwritten declaration made by the applicant and five others while at Sheremetyevo airport on 18 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The handwritten declaration states that on 18 May 2007 at Sheremetyevo Airport Terminal 1, the applicant and five others were prevented from taking flight 813 to Samara because police officer A. seized their tickets at the check-in desk.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The handwritten declaration states that the applicant and five others were at the airport building under the surveillance of police officers, with their passports confiscated.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The handwritten declaration states that at 11.20 a.m. on 18 May 2007, police officers A., C. and S. categorically prohibited the applicant and five others from leaving the second floor of Sheremetyevo airport.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The handwritten declaration states that police officers A., C. and S. indicated that the applicant and five others had to provide an explanation to the police officers because some tickets were allegedly forged.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The handwritten declaration states that as of 12.20 p.m. on 18 May 2007, the applicant and five others were still detained in the hall of Sheremetyevo airport without any documents being provided to them.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Government submitted that on 17 May 2007, the Department of the Interior's Sheremetyevo airport branch received information on forged tickets being sold for the 18 May 2007 Moscow-Samara flight.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The respondent Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Government submitted that on 18 May 2007, officers from the Department of the Interior's Sheremetyevo airport branch, acting on information about forged tickets, were present at check-in and examined the tickets of all passengers on the Moscow-Samara flight.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The respondent Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Government submitted that in the course of the ticket checks on 18 May 2007, twenty tickets bearing signs of forgery were found, having worn spots and dubious printing forms.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The respondent Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Government submitted that the twenty tickets bearing signs of forgery were confiscated and the passengers who had presented them were prevented from boarding the Moscow-Samara flight.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The respondent Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Government submitted that the confiscated tickets were subsequently sent for forensic examination.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The respondent Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Government submitted that the forensic examination of the confiscated tickets showed thirteen tickets with signs of writing on top of the original text.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The respondent Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Government commented that their records indicated that the applicant's ticket for the Moscow-Samara flight had been seized.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The respondent Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Government commented that their records contained no record of the applicant's passport also being seized.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The respondent Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Government commented that if the applicant's passport had been seized, the applicant would have been able to make a written comment to that effect in the search record drawn up by the police, but he had not done so.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The respondent Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Government commented that under section 11 of the Police Act (no. 1026-1 of 18 April 1991), the police had the right to seek an explanation from the applicant regarding the ticket, and he had been invited to provide one.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The respondent Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Government commented that the applicant's allegation that he was questioned from 8.30 a.m. to 1.30 p.m. was not supported by the police records.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The respondent Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The applicant complained to the Moscow Transport Prosecutor's Office about having been unlawfully detained by the police.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The applicant requested that the Moscow Transport Prosecutor's Office prosecute those responsible for his alleged unlawful detention.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 28 June 2007, the prosecutor's office decided not to open criminal proceedings against the policemen involved in the events of 18 May 2007 at Sheremetyevo airport.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The prosecutor's office decision of 28 June 2007 stated that on 18 May 2007 the police, together with the Sheremetyevo airport security service, carried out a check of the passengers leaving on flight no. 813, Moscow–Samara.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The prosecutor's office decision of 28 June 2007 stated that during the check, thirteen plane tickets with traces of forgery were discovered and seized.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The prosecutor's office decision of 28 June 2007 stated that the police subsequently conducted an inquiry under Articles 144-145 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "When questioned, police officer A. stated that on 17 May 2007 at 6 p.m. he received operative information that some forged tickets had been sold for the Moscow-Samara flight leaving on 18 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Police officer A. stated that on 18 May 2007 he verified the information about forged tickets by checking all passengers' tickets for flight no. 813, Moscow–Samara.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Police officer A. stated that thirteen plane tickets were found to have traces of forgery, such as scuff marks, and that the ticket blanks used for printing the tickets were suspicious.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Police officer A. stated that the police seized the tickets and removed the passengers from flight no. 813, Moscow–Samara.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Police officer A. stated that he wrote a report concerning the facts of the ticket seizure, after which the materials were sent to the Sheremetyevo police unit.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "When questioned, the Head of the Operational-Search Unit of the Aviation Division of the Department of the Interior, officer S., stated that on 18 May 2007, on the occasion of the high-profile EU-Russia summit in Samara, policemen of the Aviation Division of the Moscow branch of the Department of the Interior, together with its subordinate units in the airports of the Moscow region, carried out operational search activities to identify persons of an extremist nature intending to organise mass riots.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Officer S. stated that in connection with the operational search activities, the police carried out checks on persons leaving for Samara on 18 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Officer S. stated that on 18 May 2007, he, together with operative officer A.B., arrived at Sheremetyevo airport, where at 7.30 a.m. check-in began for flight no. 813, Moscow–Samara.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Officer S. stated that together with the airport security screening service, they checked all passengers on flight no. 813, Moscow–Samara, which included screening their luggage with special equipment and checking their documents.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Officer S. stated that during the check, some officers noticed that tickets of certain passengers had additional non-standard notes, and when inspected, these tickets raised doubts as to their authenticity.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Officer S. stated that thirteen suspected forged tickets were seized and the passengers were questioned about the circumstances of their purchase.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Officer S. stated that several passengers decided not to fly on flight no. 813, Moscow–Samara, without explaining why.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Officer S. stated that on 18 May 2007, similar checks were conducted for other flights to Samara.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The sales director of the airline confirmed that the tickets for flight no. 813, Moscow–Samara were issued and sold in a normal manner.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "An expert examination of the twenty seized tickets from flight no. 813, Moscow–Samara revealed that seven tickets had no corrections of the original content.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "An expert examination of the twenty seized tickets from flight no. 813, Moscow–Samara revealed that for thirteen of the tickets, secondary text had been added on top of the original text in the fields 'flight number' and 'time'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The prosecutor's office inquiry established that the policemen had acted within their powers and with sufficient grounds when seizing the tickets of the passengers for flight no. 813, Moscow–Samara.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The prosecutor's office refused to institute criminal proceedings further to the complaint about the commission of criminal offences of abuse of powers and exceeding official powers by the eleven policemen involved, for absence of corpus delicti.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The applicant challenged the prosecutor's office decision of 28 June 2007 before a court under the procedure set out in Article 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The applicant requested that the prosecutor's office decision dispensing with criminal proceedings be declared unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The applicant requested that the prosecutor's office be ordered to remedy the shortcomings in the decision dispensing with criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 20 July 2007, the Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow examined and rejected the applicant's appeal against the prosecutor's office decision of 28 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow noted that the applicant had complained to the prosecutor's office about his five-hour detention at Sheremetyevo airport.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow noted that the applicant had complained to the prosecutor's office about the seizure of his ticket to Samara.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow observed that the applicant had challenged the prosecutor's refusal to open criminal proceedings claiming, inter alia, that the police had unlawfully restricted his liberty.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow observed that the applicant had challenged the prosecutor's refusal to open criminal proceedings claiming that the police had acted in violation of his right to freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow observed that the applicant had challenged the prosecutor's refusal to open criminal proceedings claiming that the police had acted in violation of his right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow noted that the applicant had claimed that he had been deprived of his constitutional rights by the prosecutor's office.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow considered that the prosecutor's office had taken its decision in accordance with the procedure provided for by law and remained within its competence while doing so.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow upheld the finding that no criminal offence could be imputed to the police officers in question.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow found the applicant's allegations about the unlawfulness of the ticket seizure to be unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow found that the seizure of the applicant's ticket had been carried out in accordance with Articles 27.7 and 27.10 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant had been taken to the airport police quarters to provide an explanation for the purchase of his ticket.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant had not been 'isolated' at the police station at Sheremetyevo airport.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow found that there had been no grounds for applying the three-hour time-limit for the application of preventative measures in administrative offences cases as provided for by the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow found that there had been no grounds for the drawing up of a detention report (протокол о задержании).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow concluded that the prosecutor's decision of 28 June 2007 was lawful and well-founded.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The applicant brought a cassation appeal against the Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow's decision of 20 July 2007.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "In his cassation appeal, the applicant claimed that the measures applied to him were contrary to the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "In his cassation appeal, the applicant claimed that there had been violations of his constitutional rights to liberty, freedom of expression and freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On 20 August 2007, the Moscow City Court examined and dismissed the applicant's cassation appeal.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Moscow City Court noted that the subject matter of the applicant's appeal to court had been the lawfulness of the prosecutor's refusal to institute criminal proceedings against the officers who had allegedly violated his constitutional rights.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Moscow City Court upheld the decision not to institute criminal proceedings as correct in substance and form.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Moscow City Court held that the alleged breach by the police officers of statutory detention limits were outside the scope of the Golovinskiy District Court of Moscow's power of review.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's complaint to the prosecutor and subsequent court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Section 11(4) of the Police Act (no. 1026-1 of 18 April 1991), as in force at the material time, provided that, for the performance of their duties, the police had the right to obtain from citizens and State officials necessary statements, information, certificates, documents and copies thereof.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Article 21.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides for liability of designated officials for a failure to submit information on persons to be drafted in the armed forces to the relevant military authority.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Article 27.7 of the Code of Administrative Offences allows personal searches and searches of luggage carried by a person to be conducted if it is necessary to find an object or an instrument of an administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Article 27.7 of the Code of Administrative Offences defines the search procedure and sets out the requirements of the search report.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Article 27.10 of the Code of Administrative Offences states that objects and instruments of an administrative offence, as well as documents that may serve as evidence in proceedings concerning an administrative offence, may be seized in accordance with the specified procedure.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Article 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation entered into force on 1 July 2002.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Article 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation provides that any decisions and actions (or failures to act) by investigators, investigating judges or prosecutors with regard to a criminal investigation may be challenged before a superior prosecutor or a court.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F005", "F007", "F008"], "interference": ["F004", "F010", "F011", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F026", "F039", "F041"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F020", "F021", "F026", "F095", "F096", "F106", "F107", "F109"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F005", "F008"], "interference": ["F004", "F022", "F026", "F039"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F026", "F095", "F096", "F106", "F020", "F021"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F004", "F026", "F022", "F039", "F106", "F095"]}} {"case_name": "case_355", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1955.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1954.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1958.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants live in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The first applicant and the second applicant are spouses.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 15 April 2007 in St Petersburg a coalition of opposition groups organised an anti-government rally to campaign before the forthcoming parliamentary elections.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The anti-government rally of 15 April 2007 was part of a series of protest demonstrations called a 'March of Dissenters'.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The St Petersburg city administration authorised the rally in the form of a meeting to be held between noon and 2 p.m. at Pionerskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The site of the rally at Pionerskaya Square was cordoned off by metal railings.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The site of the rally at Pionerskaya Square was cordoned off by several rows of police officers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Government submitted that 6,100 police officers were deployed at the rally on 15 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Government submitted that among the 6,100 police officers deployed, 400 were officers from the Special Purpose Squad (ОМОН), referred to as the riot police.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicants attended the rally on 15 April 2007 at Pionerskaya Square in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the applicants, when the rally ended the police directed all the protesters to the nearby Pushkinskaya metro station.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the applicants, the police closed all neighbouring quarters to traffic and pedestrians when directing protesters to Pushkinskaya metro station.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the applicants, the applicants saw the riot police (Special Purpose Squad, ОМОН) running towards them and indiscriminately hitting all those around them.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the applicants, Pushkinskaya metro station was closed at the time.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the applicants, the applicants tried to escape via Zagorodnyy Prospect but were blocked between police cordons.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the applicants, the police pushed civilians into a small park.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the applicants, some persons entered the small park via the gate while others had to climb over the fence.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the Government, at the end of the rally a group of approximately 60 persons under the flags of the National Bolshevik Party attempted to break through the police cordon.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the Government, the group of approximately 60 persons under the flags of the National Bolshevik Party attempted to lead an unauthorised march via Zagorodnyy Prospect towards Moskovskiy Prospect.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the Government, persons in the group of approximately 60 persons under the flags of the National Bolshevik Party shouted slogans at the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the Government, persons in the group of approximately 60 persons under the flags of the National Bolshevik Party threw bottles and other objects at the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the Government's version of events, the riot police (Special Purpose Squad, ОМОН) had to use force in order to disperse the particular group of protesters who attempted to break through the police cordon and restore public order.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "During the events of 15 April 2007, the first applicant was approached by a riot police officer.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "During the events of 15 April 2007, the first applicant was severely beaten by a riot police officer.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The riot police officer hit the first applicant on the chest, ribs and shoulders.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The riot police officer left the first applicant lying unconscious.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Other protesters and the second applicant carried the first applicant to an ambulance van.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The first applicant was later taken to the Mariinskiy Hospital.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "At the Mariinskiy Hospital the first applicant was diagnosed with a closed fracture of the seventh rib, traumatic pneumothorax, a closed craniocerebral injury, and brain concussion.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "During the events of 15 April 2007, the third applicant was hit by a riot police officer with a rubber truncheon to the face.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The third applicant started falling unconscious after being hit by the riot police officer.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The third applicant was helped by other protesters after starting to fall unconscious.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The third applicant was subsequently diagnosed with a craniocerebral injury sustained on 15 April 2007, concussion, closed fractures of the nose bones and the right cheek bone.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The first applicant remained in hospital for several days before being released for outpatient treatment.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The third applicant remained in hospital for several days before being released for outpatient treatment.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 15 April 2007 the emergency doctors informed the prosecution authorities that the first applicant had applied for medical assistance.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 15 April 2007 the emergency doctors informed the prosecution authorities that the third applicant had applied for medical assistance.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 15 April 2007 the hospital informed the prosecution authorities that the first applicant had applied for medical assistance.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 15 April 2007 the hospital informed the prosecution authorities that the third applicant had applied for medical assistance.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "In April 2007 the applicants submitted complaints to the St Petersburg prosecution authorities about police brutality.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "In May 2007 the applicants submitted additional complaints to the St Petersburg prosecution authorities about police brutality.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 21 June 2007 a criminal case was opened in relation to the events of 15 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 27 August 2007 the third applicant was granted the status of a victim in the criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 8 October 2007 the third applicant submitted, inter alia, that the police officer who had attacked her wore a helmet and had no identification markings.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 15 June 2007 a domestic court found that the prosecution authorities had failed to comply with the time-limits established for examination of individual complaints.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 15 June 2007 a domestic court found that the prosecution authorities had unlawfully denied the applicants access to the case-file of the enquiry.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 15 June 2007 a domestic court found that the prosecution authorities had failed to ensure the applicants' procedural rights during the criminal investigation.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 15 November 2007 a domestic court found that the prosecution authorities had failed to comply with the time-limits established for examination of individual complaints.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 15 November 2007 a domestic court found that the prosecution authorities had unlawfully denied the applicants access to the case-file of the enquiry.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 15 November 2007 a domestic court found that the prosecution authorities had failed to ensure the applicants' procedural rights during the criminal investigation.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 30 November 2007 the first applicant was granted the status of a victim in the criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 30 November 2007 the second applicant was granted the status of a victim in the criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 4 December 2007 the first applicant gave to the investigator photographs from newspapers depicting an officer who looked like the police officer who had attacked him.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The officer depicted in the photographs provided by the first applicant had a number indicated on his helmet.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "It was later established that the photograph provided by the first applicant was made in another city one day before the rally of 15 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The investigator attempted to identify the police officer by the number available on the helmet shown in the photographs.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The investigator received a reply from the police that the helmet with the number shown in the photographs had not been used on the day of the events of 15 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Between December 2007 and June 2009 the criminal investigation was suspended seven times due to failure to identify the police officers who had attacked the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 25 June 2009 the criminal proceedings were stayed because the perpetrators could not be identified.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The first applicant challenged the decision of 25 June 2009 to stay the criminal proceedings, arguing that the investigator had not taken all the necessary steps to identify the police officers involved in the attacks.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 29 April 2011 the Oktyabrskiy District Court of St Petersburg found the decision of 25 June 2009 to stay the criminal proceedings lawful.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of St Petersburg noted that during the investigation it was established that on 15 April 2007 some unidentified police officers had exceeded their official powers and beaten a number of protesters.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of St Petersburg noted that the victims and witnesses could not identify the police officers due to the fact that the officers were wearing helmets and had no identification markings.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of St Petersburg noted that photographs provided by one of the witnesses did not reveal any relevant information for the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of St Petersburg acknowledged that in the first applicant's case there had been an attempt to identify the police officer concerned by the number on his helmet seen on photos provided by the first applicant himself.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of St Petersburg observed that during the criminal investigation some police officers deployed during the rally of 15 April 2007 had been questioned.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of St Petersburg observed that during the criminal investigation video and photo materials had been analysed.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of St Petersburg found that none of the investigative measures taken allowed identification of the perpetrators.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Oktyabrskiy District Court of St Petersburg rejected the first applicant's complaint against the decision to stay the criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 21 June 2011 the St Petersburg City Court upheld the decision of the Oktyabrskiy District Court of St Petersburg of 29 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "It appears that the criminal proceedings relating to the events of 15 April 2007 are still pending.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The investigation into the events of 15 April 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic law provisions governing use of force by the police can be found in Annenkov and Others v. Russia (no. 31475/10, §§ 68 and 69, 25 July 2017).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F013", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024"], "interference": ["F026", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F036", "F065"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025"], "necessity": ["F026", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F036", "F065", "F013"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F013", "F021", "F022"], "interference": ["F027", "F033", "F065"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F027", "F032", "F033", "F036", "F065", "F013"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F006", "F013", "F021", "F027", "F032", "F033", "F036", "F065"]}} {"case_name": "case_356", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1974.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1994.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants live in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "At the material time, the first applicant was a member of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan, one of the main opposition parties in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "At the material time, the second applicant was a member of an opposition group called Nida.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants participated in an assembly on 6 May 2014.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "According to the applicants, they were among people who gathered near the Baku Assize Court on 6 May 2014 to support members of Nida (an opposition group) who were being tried on that day.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The courtroom of the Baku Assize Court was full on 6 May 2014, and therefore some people gathered outside the court to wait for the outcome of the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "When the Baku Assize Court announced its judgment on 6 May 2014, those who had gathered outside began to protest against the judgment, considering it unfair.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the applicants, the protest on 6 May 2014 near the Baku Assize Court was brief, spontaneous and peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Immediately after the protesters started chanting slogans on 6 May 2014, police officers and people in plain clothes began to forcibly disperse the demonstration near the Baku Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicants were arrested during the dispersal operation on 6 May 2014.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "After their arrest, the applicants were taken to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicants were kept overnight at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicants were questioned at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 6 May 2014, the day of the applicants' arrest, administrative-offence reports (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) were issued against the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The administrative-offence reports issued against the applicants stated that they had committed an administrative offence under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan: participation in a public assembly organised not in accordance with the law.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the applicants, they were never served with copies of the administrative-offence reports issued against them.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the applicants, they were never served with copies of other documents from their case files.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the applicants, they were not given access to a lawyer after their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the applicants, they were not given access to a lawyer while they were in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to a police officer's decision and an order dated 6 May 2014, a State-funded lawyer, Mr O.A., was invited to defend the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to a police officer's decision and an order dated 6 May 2014, a State-funded lawyer, Mr A.B., was invited to defend the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicants were brought before the Nasimi District Court on 7 May 2014, the day following their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the applicants, the hearing before the Nasimi District Court (first-instance court) was very brief in the case of the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the applicants, the hearing before the Nasimi District Court (first-instance court) was very brief in the case of the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicants, members of the public were not allowed inside the courtroom during the hearings before the Nasimi District Court, even though the court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearing to the public.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the applicants, they were not given an opportunity to appoint lawyers of their own choosing before the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "A State-funded lawyer, Mr O.A., was invited to defend the first applicant before the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The State-funded lawyer invited to defend the first applicant before the Nasimi District Court, Mr O.A., was the same lawyer who had been invited to defend her in accordance with the police officer's decision of 6 May 2014.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The second applicant was not represented by a lawyer before the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the transcript of the hearing before the Nasimi District Court in the second applicant's case, the second applicant refused the assistance of the State-funded lawyer and decided to defend himself in person.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to the transcript of the hearing before the Nasimi District Court concerning the first applicant, the State-funded lawyer Mr O.A. did not make any oral or written submissions.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The only witnesses questioned during the hearing before the Nasimi District Court concerning the first applicant were police officers who, according to official records, had arrested her or issued the administrative-offence report on her.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The police officers questioned as witnesses during the hearing before the Nasimi District Court concerning the first applicant testified that the first applicant had staged an unauthorised protest.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "With respect to the second applicant, the Nasimi District Court did not question any witness.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the transcript of the hearing before the Nasimi District Court concerning the first applicant, the first applicant stated that she had participated in the protest of 6 May 2014 and had rightfully used 'improper language' in the course of the protest.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the transcript of the hearing before the Nasimi District Court concerning the second applicant, the second applicant stated that he had simply protested against an unfair judgment against the Nida members and had not committed any unlawful action.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Nasimi District Court found that the first applicant had participated in an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Nasimi District Court found that the second applicant had participated in an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Nasimi District Court convicted the first applicant under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Nasimi District Court convicted the second applicant under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Nasimi District Court sentenced the first applicant to a period of administrative detention of thirty days.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Nasimi District Court sentenced the second applicant to a period of administrative detention of twenty days.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On unspecified dates, the applicants lodged appeals with the Baku Court of Appeal against their convictions by the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In their appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicants argued that their convictions had been in violation of their rights because the protest in which they had participated had been spontaneous and peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In their appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicants complained that their arrests had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "In their appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicants complained that the hearings before the Nasimi District Court had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicants asked the Baku Court of Appeal to quash the Nasimi District Court's decisions in their respective cases.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The first applicant was assisted by a lawyer of her own choosing before the Baku Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The second applicant was not represented by a lawyer before the Baku Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 16 May 2014, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the first applicant's appeal and upheld the decision of the Nasimi District Court in her case.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 22 May 2014, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the second applicant's appeal and upheld the decision of the Nasimi District Court in his case.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "At the time of the applicants' arrest, under Article 5 § IV of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of Azerbaijan of 13 November 1998, no prior written notification was required for spontaneous assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Before amendments introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, a breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies was punishable under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan of 2000 by a reprimand or a fine of seven to thirteen Azerbaijani manats (AZN).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 entered into force on 1 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced new wording to Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan on breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Following the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, participation in an assembly organised in breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies became explicitly punishable under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced, for the first time, punishments in the form of administrative detention of up to 15 days or community service for participation in an assembly organised in breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 increased the fine for a breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies, fixing the amounts as follows: between AZN 300 and AZN 600 for participants of an assembly; AZN 1,500 to AZN 3,000 for individuals who organise an assembly; AZN 3,000 to AZN 6,000 for persons in charge (vəzifəli şəxslər) who organise an assembly; and between AZN 15,000 and AZN 30,000 for legal entities involved in the organisation of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "By Law no. 651-IVQD of 14 May 2013, which entered into force on 5 June 2013, the administrative detention sentence provided for in Article 298.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan was increased to 'up to two months'.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "By Law no. 651-IVQD of 14 May 2013, which entered into force on 5 June 2013, the administrative detention sentence provided for in Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan was increased to 'up to two months'.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, titled 'The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan', stated that there is no political dialogue with the opposition parties outside parliament in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about the restrictive climate for the activities of the extra-parliamentary opposition in Azerbaijan, which complains about limitations imposed on freedom of expression and freedom of assembly and the lack of access to the public media.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the establishment of an inclusive political system and a truly competitive and unrestrictive political environment in Azerbaijan requires full implementation of basic freedoms, including freedom of expression, freedom of assembly and freedom of association.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed deep concern about the situation regarding basic freedoms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe raised concern about recently adopted amendments to the Criminal Code and the Administrative Code of Azerbaijan, which increased penalties for the organisers of, and participants in, 'unauthorised' gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that, considering the authorities' ongoing blanket ban on protests in the Baku city centre, the amendments increasing penalties for organisers of and participants in 'unauthorised' gatherings were likely to have a further negative impact on freedom of assembly and freedom of expression in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about the restrictive use of certain articles of the Criminal Code of Azerbaijan, in particular Articles 221 and 233, against participants in peaceful, albeit unauthorised, demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Report CommDH(2013)14 was issued on 6 August 2013 by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "In Report CommDH(2013)14, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe expressed deep concern about recent amendments to the Law on Freedom of Assembly, the Criminal Code and the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan, which further erode the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "In Report CommDH(2013)14, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe stated that the sanctions which can now be imposed under the amended laws, coupled with the fact that local authorities have not authorised a single rally in Baku city centre in recent years, clearly have a chilling effect on the organisation of or participation in demonstrations in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "In Report CommDH(2013)14, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe expressed the view that participants in peaceful assemblies should not be sanctioned for the mere fact of being present at and actively participating in a demonstration, provided they do not do anything illegal, violent or obscene in the course of it.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "In Report CommDH(2013)14, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe urged the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure that no disproportionate sanction, which would undermine the fundamental right to peaceful assembly, is imposed.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "A summary of other relevant domestic provisions concerning administrative proceedings and the organisation and holding of public assemblies in Azerbaijan, and relevant extracts from international documents, can be found in the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, paragraphs 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F037", "F012", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044"], "interference": ["F011", "F012", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F058", "F062"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F016", "F017", "F054"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F010", "F011", "F017", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F062", "F067", "F068", "F072"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F009", "F010", "F037"], "interference": ["F011", "F012", "F043", "F044"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F009", "F017", "F054"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F011", "F017", "F039", "F040", "F043", "F044", "F062"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F006", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F017", "F039", "F040", "F043", "F044", "F054", "F062"]}} {"case_name": "case_357", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies that took place in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_362", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_363", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1942.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The background to the banning of the two rallies at issue in the present case has been set out in detail in the judgment in Stankov and the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden v. Bulgaria, nos. 29221/95 and 29225/95, ECHR 2001-IX.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The background to the banning of the two rallies at issue in the present case has been set out in detail in the judgment in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Ivanov v. Bulgaria, no. 44079/98, 20 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The background to the banning of the two rallies at issue in the present case has been set out in detail in the judgment in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden-PIRIN and Others v. Bulgaria, no. 59489/00, 20 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The background to the banning of the two rallies at issue in the present case has been set out in detail in the judgment in Ivanov and Others v. Bulgaria, no. 46336/99, 24 November 2005.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The background to the banning of the two rallies at issue in the present case has been set out in detail in the judgment in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Others v. Bulgaria, no. 59491/00, 19 January 2006.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The background to the banning of the two rallies at issue in the present case has been set out in detail in the judgment in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Ivanov v. Bulgaria (no. 2), no. 37586/04, 18 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The background to the banning of the two rallies at issue in the present case has been set out in detail in the judgment in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Others v. Bulgaria (no. 2), no. 34960/04, 18 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The background to the banning of the two rallies at issue in the present case has been set out in detail in the judgment in Singartiyski and Others v. Bulgaria, no. 48284/07, 18 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The background to the banning of the two rallies at issue in the present case has been set out in detail in the judgment in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden-PIRIN and Others v. Bulgaria (no. 2), nos. 41561/07 and 20972/08, 18 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant was one of the applicants in Ivanov and Others v. Bulgaria, no. 46336/99, 24 November 2005.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant is the brother of Mr Yordan Kostadinov Ivanov.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Mr Yordan Kostadinov Ivanov was one of the applicants in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Ivanov v. Bulgaria, no. 44079/98, 20 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Mr Yordan Kostadinov Ivanov was one of the applicants in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Others v. Bulgaria, no. 59491/00, 19 January 2006.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Mr Yordan Kostadinov Ivanov was one of the applicants in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Ivanov v. Bulgaria (no. 2), no. 37586/04, 18 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Mr Yordan Kostadinov Ivanov was one of the applicants in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Others v. Bulgaria (no. 2), no. 34960/04, 18 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 15 September 2006, the applicant, acting on behalf of the unregistered organisation the Macedonian Initiative Committee, notified Blagoevgrad's mayor that the Macedonian Initiative Committee intended to stage a rally at 4 p.m. on 30 September 2006 in Macedonia Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The rally planned for 30 September 2006 in Macedonia Square was intended to commemorate the eighty-second anniversary of 'the day of the genocide of Macedonians in Bulgaria – 12 September 1924'.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The rally planned for 30 September 2006 in Macedonia Square would consist of the laying of wreaths and flowers and the reading of a short address.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 15 September 2006, Blagoevgrad's mayor replied to the applicant that the rally planned for 30 September 2006 in Macedonia Square could not proceed.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Blagoevgrad's mayor stated that the municipality had planned an event in Macedonia Square for 30 September 2006 — a concert marking the Day of Music.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Blagoevgrad's mayor stated that the parallel event of the concert marking the Day of Music made the staging of the rally on 30 September 2006 impossible.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 18 September 2006, the applicant, acting on behalf of the Macedonian Initiative Committee, sought judicial review of Blagoevgrad's mayor's decision refusing the rally planned for 30 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant argued that under applicable international-law agreements, the Macedonian Initiative Committee was entitled to stage peaceful rallies without being registered.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "In a final decision of 19 September 2006, the Blagoevgrad District Court held that the application for judicial review of the mayor's decision regarding the rally planned for 30 September 2006 was admissible.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "In a final decision of 19 September 2006, the Blagoevgrad District Court held that Blagoevgrad's mayor's decision refusing the rally planned for 30 September 2006 was amenable to judicial review.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "In a final decision of 19 September 2006, the Blagoevgrad District Court found that Blagoevgrad's mayor's decision refusing the rally planned for 30 September 2006 was lawful, because there was a risk that the rights and freedoms of others might be infringed.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court found it was not appropriate to hold the rally planned for 30 September 2006, which in view of its intended theme was political in character, alongside the municipality's concert event marking the Day of Music.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court found that the performance of musical works could not be reconciled with political addresses.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court found it was not proper to force music lovers to listen to political speeches and declarations, especially ones not accepted unequivocally by Bulgarian society.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court noted that Bulgarian society was particularly sensitive to assertions that a Macedonian minority existed in Bulgaria and that its rights were being infringed.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "As a result of the Blagoevgrad District Court's decision of 19 September 2006, the Macedonian Initiative Committee called off the rally planned for 30 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The applicant submitted that he was not aware of whether the municipality's concert event marking the Day of Music had in fact taken place on 30 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant had made a request for information under freedom-of-information laws regarding whether the municipality's event had taken place, but had not received a reply.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The municipality's cultural calendar for 2006 showed that the concert marking the Day of Music had been scheduled for 1 October 2006 rather than 30 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "1. Rally planned for 30 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden, an unregistered association based in south-western Bulgaria in an area known as the Pirin region or the geographic region of Pirin Macedonia, attempted to organise a rally on 11 or 12 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "2. Rally planned for 12 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The rally attempted by the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden on 11 or 12 September 2006 was a similar rally to the one planned by the Macedonian Initiative Committee for 30 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "2. Rally planned for 12 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The attempt by the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden to organise a rally on 11 or 12 September 2006 was fruitless.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "2. Rally planned for 12 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Blagoevgrad's mayor banned the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden's rally planned for 11 or 12 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "2. Rally planned for 12 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "A legal challenge to Blagoevgrad's mayor's decision banning the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden's rally planned for 11 or 12 September 2006 was dismissed by the Blagoevgrad District Court on 8 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "2. Rally planned for 12 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The circumstances relating to the dismissal of the legal challenge to the ban on the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden's rally planned for 11 or 12 September 2006 are set out in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Ivanov v. Bulgaria (no. 2), no. 37586/04, 18 October 2011, at paragraphs 58–63.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies in September 2006", "2. Rally planned for 12 September 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 28 August 2007, the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad of its intention to stage a rally on Macedonia Square, in front of Gotse Delchev's monument, at 4.30 p.m. on 12 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The rally planned by the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden for 12 September 2007 was to mark the anniversary of 'the genocide against the Macedonians'.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The rally planned by the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden for 12 September 2007 would consist of the laying of a wreath and flowers on Gotse Delchev's monument and a short speech, and would last one hour.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 29 August 2007, the Mayor of Blagoevgrad replied that the notification by the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden for the rally on 12 September 2007 could not be examined as the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden had not produced documents proving its official registration.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the lack of registration documents made it impossible to identify the managing bodies of the event planned by the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden for 12 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the municipality had planned an event on Macedonia Square for 12 September 2007 — a children's holiday under the name 'Hello, school' to mark the beginning of the school year — which made the holding of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden's rally impossible.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 30 August 2007, the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden sought judicial review by the newly created Blagoevgrad Administrative Court, reiterating the arguments raised in its previous applications.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In a decision of 30 August 2007, the Blagoevgrad Administrative Court found that under the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act, which was lex specialis in relation to the general rules of administrative procedure, the court competent to examine an application for judicial review of a Mayor's decision to ban a rally was the district court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Blagoevgrad Administrative Court sent the file regarding the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden's application for judicial review of the ban on the 12 September 2007 rally to the Blagoevgrad District Court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In a final decision of 5 September 2007, the Blagoevgrad District Court dismissed the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden's application for judicial review of the ban on the rally planned for 12 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court held that the lack of registration of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden did not amount to sufficient grounds to prohibit the rally planned for 12 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court held that the fact that another event likely to draw a number of people, many of whom were children, was due to take place on the same date in Macedonia Square was enough to justify the ban on the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden's rally planned for 12 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court found it was inopportune to allow two wholly different events to be staged at the same time and place on 12 September 2007 in Macedonia Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "According to the applicants in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Ivanov v. Bulgaria (no. 2), no school event took place at 4 p.m. on 12 September 2007 on Macedonia Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "When a number of members and supporters of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden gathered in front of the American University in Blagoevgrad at about 5 p.m. on 12 September 2007, they were stopped by the police.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "A number of members and supporters of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden were arrested by police on 12 September 2007 in Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The arrested members and supporters of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden were taken to a police station and held for about three hours on 12 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The arrested members and supporters of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden were charged with committing administrative offences for having tried to take part in a banned rally on 12 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 22 October 2007, the deputy Mayor of Blagoevgrad imposed administrative punishments — fines of 200 Bulgarian levs (102.26 euros) each — on Mr Yordan Kostadinov Ivanov and on a number of members of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden for having taken part in a banned rally on 12 September 2007, in breach of a public-order regulation issued by the Blagoevgrad Municipal Council.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Mr Yordan Kostadinov Ivanov and the members of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden who received administrative fines from the deputy Mayor of Blagoevgrad all sought judicial review of those fines.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In a series of judgments delivered on 18 and 19 February, 11 March, and 22 and 29 May 2008, the Blagoevgrad District Court annulled the fines imposed by the deputy Mayor of Blagoevgrad on Mr Yordan Kostadinov Ivanov and members of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "In some of the judgments annulling the fines, the Blagoevgrad District Court found that the fines were invalid because under the applicable rules the deputy Mayor of Blagoevgrad had no power to impose administrative punishments.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "In other judgments annulling the fines, the Blagoevgrad District Court found that the deputy Mayor of Blagoevgrad's decisions were defective because they did not specify which administrative offences had been committed.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "In other judgments annulling the fines, the Blagoevgrad District Court held that although the Mayor of Blagoevgrad's ban on the rally planned for 12 September 2007 was legally binding, the actions of the members of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden on that date had not amounted to the staging of a rally, as they had been too few and had not tried to wave banners and make speeches, but merely to lay flowers on Gotse Delchev's monument.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court stated that every person, regardless of their political convictions, had the right to honour the memory of national heroes in peace.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "It was the applicant who acted on behalf of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden in its dealings with Blagoevgrad's mayor and the courts in relation to the rally on 12 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Rally on 12 September 2007"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The relevant domestic law and practice have been set out in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Ivanov v. Bulgaria (no. 2), no. 37586/04, 18 October 2011, at paragraphs 107–112.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F018", "F024", "F019", "F020"], "interference": ["F021", "F023", "F033"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F022", "F023", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F003", "F004", "F008", "F010"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F018", "F024"], "interference": ["F021", "F033"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F022", "F028", "F031", "F032", "F003", "F004", "F008", "F010"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F018", "F021", "F022", "F028", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F003", "F004", "F008", "F010"]}} {"case_name": "case_364", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some of the applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_365", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_367", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_370", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention and Protocols to the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_371", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_372", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The case concerns the alleged lack of public access to a reasoned judgment in a civil case.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The case concerns the applicant's arrest and administrative offence proceedings for participating in an unlawful public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The case concerns the applicant's dismissal from the police for criticising her superiors.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant was born in 1967.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant had been granted legal aid.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant was represented by Ms V. Petrova, a lawyer practising in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Government were represented by Mr G. Matyushkin, Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Mr G. Matyushkin was succeeded in the office of Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights by Mr M. Galperin.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr M. Galperin, Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant was a police officer in the Administrative Department of the Special Police Force (ОМОН).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. SOLO DEMONSTRATION OF 25 FEBRUARY 2009 AND THE APPLICANT'S DISMISSAL FROM POLICE SERVICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 25 February 2009 the applicant held a solo demonstration in front of the Government of Russia building.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. SOLO DEMONSTRATION OF 25 FEBRUARY 2009 AND THE APPLICANT'S DISMISSAL FROM POLICE SERVICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant's solo demonstration of 25 February 2009 was covered by the press.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. SOLO DEMONSTRATION OF 25 FEBRUARY 2009 AND THE APPLICANT'S DISMISSAL FROM POLICE SERVICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant alleged that the in-house police medical practitioner had damaged her daughter's health on purpose.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. SOLO DEMONSTRATION OF 25 FEBRUARY 2009 AND THE APPLICANT'S DISMISSAL FROM POLICE SERVICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 13 March 2009 the applicant was dismissed from the police for a serious breach of disciplinary rules.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. SOLO DEMONSTRATION OF 25 FEBRUARY 2009 AND THE APPLICANT'S DISMISSAL FROM POLICE SERVICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 24 March 2009 the applicant challenged her dismissal before the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. SOLO DEMONSTRATION OF 25 FEBRUARY 2009 AND THE APPLICANT'S DISMISSAL FROM POLICE SERVICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 10 April 2009 the Tverskoy District Court found it established that by holding the solo demonstration the applicant had committed a serious breach of disciplinary rules.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. SOLO DEMONSTRATION OF 25 FEBRUARY 2009 AND THE APPLICANT'S DISMISSAL FROM POLICE SERVICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 10 April 2009 the Tverskoy District Court found that there had been statutory grounds for the applicant's dismissal.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. SOLO DEMONSTRATION OF 25 FEBRUARY 2009 AND THE APPLICANT'S DISMISSAL FROM POLICE SERVICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 10 April 2009 the Tverskoy District Court found that the applicant's dismissal had been lawful.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. SOLO DEMONSTRATION OF 25 FEBRUARY 2009 AND THE APPLICANT'S DISMISSAL FROM POLICE SERVICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 30 June 2010 the Moscow City Court upheld the Tverskoy District Court judgment of 10 April 2009 on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. SOLO DEMONSTRATION OF 25 FEBRUARY 2009 AND THE APPLICANT'S DISMISSAL FROM POLICE SERVICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 30 June 2010 the Moscow City Court found that the Tverskoy District Court judgment of 10 April 2009 had been lawful, sufficiently reasoned and justified.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. SOLO DEMONSTRATION OF 25 FEBRUARY 2009 AND THE APPLICANT'S DISMISSAL FROM POLICE SERVICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 20 September 2010 the applicant notified the Prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow of her intention to hold a picket from 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. on 23 September 2010.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The intended picket on 23 September 2010 was to be held in front of the Prosecutor General's office on Bolshaya Dmitrovka Street.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Ten people were expected to attend the intended picket on 23 September 2010.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The aim of the intended picket on 23 September 2010 was to draw the Prosecutor General's attention to corruption of prosecutors and to the absence of any effective remedy in that respect.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 20 September 2010 the Prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow refused to approve the public event planned for 23 September 2010.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow refused to approve the public event on the ground that the notification had been submitted outside the time-limit established by the Public Events Act (no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "At about 10.20 a.m. on 23 September 2010 four people started to picket on Bolshaya Dmitrovka Street in front of the Prosecutor General's office.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "As it was raining on 23 September 2010, the participants to the picket took shelter in the archway of one of the neighbouring buildings.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The participants to the picket on 23 September 2010 displayed placards protesting against corruption of prosecutors.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "At about 11 a.m. on 23 September 2010 the participants to the picket were arrested by the police and brought to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant was released at 2 p.m. on 23 September 2010.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 11 November 2010 the Justice of the Peace of the 369th Court Circuit of the Tverskoy District of Moscow found the applicant guilty of a breach of the established procedure for the conduct of public events, an offence under Article 20.2 § 1 of the Administrative Offences Code.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of the 369th Court Circuit of the Tverskoy District of Moscow found that the applicant had organised a public event which had not received an official approval.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of the 369th Court Circuit of the Tverskoy District of Moscow sentenced the applicant to a fine in the amount of 1,000 Russian roubles (about 23.5 euros).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant appealed against the judgment of 11 November 2010 of the Justice of the Peace of the 369th Court Circuit of the Tverskoy District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant argued on appeal that she had submitted a notification on 20 September 2010, that is three days before the intended event of 23 September 2010, as required by the Public Events Act (no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicant argued on appeal that the Prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow's refusal to approve the event had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 28 December 2010 the Tverskoy District Court upheld the judgment of 11 November 2010 of the Justice of the Peace of the 369th Court Circuit of the Tverskoy District of Moscow on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court found on appeal that the notification for the event had been submitted at 11.25 a.m. on 20 September 2010, that is less than three days before the intended event which had been scheduled to start at 10 a.m. on 23 September 2010.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court found on appeal that the applicant had not complied with the time-limit established by the Public Events Act (no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court found on appeal that the Prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow's refusal to approve the event had been lawful.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court found on appeal that by holding a public event which had not received an official approval, the applicant had violated the established procedure for the conduct of public events.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PUBLIC EVENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2010"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant sued the Moscow Interior Department for a long-service pension payable to police officers after twenty years of service.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PENSION DISPUTE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 6 August 2009 the Tverskoy District Court held a hearing in the pension dispute between the applicant and the Moscow Interior Department.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PENSION DISPUTE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "At the close of the hearing on 6 August 2009, the Tverskoy District Court read out the operative part of the judgment, stating that the applicant's claims were dismissed in full.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PENSION DISPUTE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "A copy of the reasoned judgment of 6 August 2009 was served on the applicant on 31 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PENSION DISPUTE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicant appealed against the Tverskoy District Court judgment of 6 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PENSION DISPUTE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The applicant complained on appeal that the Tverskoy District Court had not read out the full text of the judgment at the hearing of 6 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PENSION DISPUTE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 14 September 2010 the Moscow City Court held an appeal hearing in the pension dispute.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PENSION DISPUTE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "At the close of the appeal hearing on 14 September 2010, the Moscow City Court read out the operative part of the judgment, stating that the Tverskoy District Court judgment of 6 August 2009 was upheld.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PENSION DISPUTE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 26 January 2011 the applicant received a copy of the Moscow City Court appeal judgment of 14 September 2010.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PENSION DISPUTE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Moscow City Court appeal judgment of 14 September 2010 did not address the issue of public pronouncement of the first-instance and appeal judgments.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PENSION DISPUTE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Public Events Act (no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004) provides that a notification in respect of a picket involving several persons must be submitted no later than three days before the intended picket.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. NOTIFICATION OF PUBLIC EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Public Events Act (no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004) provides that if the end of the notification time-limit falls on a Sunday or a public holiday, the notification must be submitted no later than four days before the intended picket.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. NOTIFICATION OF PUBLIC EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Public Events Act (no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004) provides that no notification is required for gatherings or pickets involving one person (section 7 paragraphs 1 and 3).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. NOTIFICATION OF PUBLIC EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Article 191 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation provides that a time-limit starts to run on the next day after the date, or the occurrence of the event, which sets off its beginning.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. NOTIFICATION OF PUBLIC EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Ruling no. 28 by the Plenary Supreme Court of 26 June 2018 provides that the day when the notification is lodged and the day when the public event is scheduled to take place are not taken into account for the calculation of the notification time-limit (paragraph 6).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. NOTIFICATION OF PUBLIC EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "For a complete summary of the domestic provisions on the procedure for the notification and conduct of public events and liability for breaches committed in the course of public events, see Lashmankin and Others v. Russia (nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, §§ 216-312, 7 February 2017).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. NOTIFICATION OF PUBLIC EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Article 199 §§ 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (as in force at the material time) provided that a judgment was to be delivered immediately after the examination of a case.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Article 199 §§ 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (as in force at the material time) provided that the operative part of the judgment was to be pronounced at the last hearing.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Article 199 §§ 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (as in force at the material time) provided that the pronounced operative part of the judgment was to be signed by all judges and included in the case file.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Article 199 §§ 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (as in force at the material time) provided that the preparation of a reasoned judgment could be postponed for no more than five days.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Courts Administration Office's Instruction no. 36 of 29 April 2003 (in force at the material time) set out an exhaustive list of persons who were allowed to consult a case file in a court building, including the parties to the proceedings, their representatives, other participants to the proceedings, public prosecutors and other officials (paragraph 12.1).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Courts Administration Office's Instruction no. 36 of 29 April 2003 (in force at the material time) set out an exhaustive list of persons who could be given copies of documents from a case file, including the parties to the proceedings and their representatives (paragraph 12.6).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Federal Law no. 262-FZ of 22 December 2008 on Access to Information on the Functioning of Courts in the Russian Federation provided for the publication of domestic courts' judgments on the internet.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Federal Law no. 262-FZ of 22 December 2008 on Access to Information on the Functioning of Courts in the Russian Federation came into force on 1 July 2010.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "For a summary of other provisions concerning the public pronouncement of judgments, see Malmberg and Others v. Russia, nos. 23045/05 and 3 others, §§ 30-41, 15 January 2015.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F034", "F035", "F040", "F044"], "interference": ["F027", "F028", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F023", "F027", "F028", "F038", "F039", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F055", "F056", "F058"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F027", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F040", "F044"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F029", "F031", "F032"], "interference": ["F027", "F032", "F034", "F036"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F023", "F041", "F042", "F055"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F034", "F035", "F044"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F035", "F041", "F044"]}} {"case_name": "case_373", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' details are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The respondent state is the Russian Government.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 4 December 2011, general elections to the State Duma took place in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 5 December 2011, the applicants participated in a public event in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants participated in the public event in Moscow to protest against the elections.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicants considered the elections to the State Duma held on 4 December 2011 to be rigged.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The authorities had been duly notified about the assembly held on 5 December 2011 in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The circumstances relating to the public event of 5 December 2011 in Moscow have already been examined by the Court in Navalnyy and Yashin v. Russia, no. 76204/11, §§ 6-11, judgment of 4 December 2014.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "After the demonstration on 5 December 2011, the applicants were arrested.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "After being arrested, the applicants were transferred to various police stations in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "At the various police stations in Moscow, the relevant administrative records were drawn up in respect of the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The administrative offence records were based on the reports and explanations of the police officers who had arrested the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicants were detained at the relevant police stations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicants spent up to three nights at the relevant police stations before being brought before the Justices of the Peace.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicants submitted that they had had no place to sleep during their detention at the police stations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicants submitted that access to toilets had been restricted during their detention at the police stations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Some of the applicants submitted that during transport to the place of detention following their administrative conviction, they had been kept for several hours in an unheated bus.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On various dates, all the applicants were convicted under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, which concerns refusal to obey the lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicants were sentenced to either administrative fines or administrative imprisonment, as set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The domestic courts relied on the administrative offence records when convicting the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The domestic courts relied on the reports and explanations of the police officers when convicting the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The domestic courts considered it unlawful that some of the applicants had shouted slogans during a public assembly that followed the initial demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The domestic courts considered it unlawful that some of the applicants had refused to stop participating in a public assembly that followed the initial demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The public assembly that followed the initial demonstration was one in respect of which no advance notification had been submitted to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The relevant domestic law applicable at the material time is set out in Navalnyy and Yashin v. Russia, no. 76204/11, §§ 43-44, judgment of 4 December 2014.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F005", "F006", "F008", "F009", "F025"], "interference": ["F010", "F019", "F020"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F005", "F008", "F010", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F005", "F008", "F009"], "interference": ["F010", "F019"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F005", "F008", "F010", "F019", "F025"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F005", "F008", "F010", "F019", "F025"]}} {"case_name": "case_374", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "One of the main issues in the present case is whether the authorities failed to take protective measures to minimise or eliminate the effects of pollution allegedly caused by the continuing operation of a landfill site near the applicants' homes in the town of Klin, Moscow Region, in violation of the applicants' rights under Article 8 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "One of the main issues in the present case is whether the applicants had an effective domestic remedy in respect of the complaint about pollution caused by the continuing operation of a landfill site near their homes in the town of Klin, Moscow Region.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some of the applications raise an issue concerning the right to freedom of peaceful assembly in connection with the applicants' protests against the landfill site near the town of Klin, Moscow Region.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants' relevant personal details are set out in Appendix I of the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants were represented by Mr K. Koroteev, a lawyer practising in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Government were initially represented by Mr M. Galperin, former Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Government were latterly represented by Mr M. Vinogradov, successor to Mr M. Galperin as Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicants live in the town of Klin, Moscow Region.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The town of Klin, Moscow Region, is located approximately 7 km from Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The villages of Novotschapovo, Bol'shoye Tschapovo, Golikovo and Opritovo are located near each other in the Klin District.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The villages of Novotschapovo, Bol'shoye Tschapovo, Golikovo and Opritovo are located between 5.8 and 13 km from Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Since 1993 Aleksinskiy Quarry has been used as a landfill site for solid household waste collected in the Klin District.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Aleksinskiy Quarry is currently operated by the waste management company Kombinat LLC (OOO Комбинат).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Kombinat LLC (OOO Комбинат) operates Aleksinskiy Quarry pursuant to a lease agreement dated 12 November 2009 with the Klin municipal administration.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicants alleged that large amounts of solid waste had been taken to Aleksinskiy Quarry daily and deposited in the landfill site, in violation of the applicable environmental regulations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicants alleged that the unlawful operation of the landfill site at Aleksinskiy Quarry had caused a strong foul odour in Klin and the areas nearby.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicants alleged that the unlawful operation of the landfill site at Aleksinskiy Quarry had caused air pollution in Klin and the areas nearby.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicants alleged that the unlawful operation of the landfill site at Aleksinskiy Quarry had caused groundwater contamination in Klin and the areas nearby.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicants alleged that the unlawful operation of the landfill site at Aleksinskiy Quarry had caused the circulation of waste particles in the air in Klin and the areas nearby.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicants alleged that the large numbers of scavenging birds at the landfill site at Aleksinskiy Quarry had threatened air safety in the area.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "A military airbase known as Klin-5 was situated within 3 km of the landfill site at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The military airbase Klin-5 was situated in proximity to the applicants' houses.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "A large-scale multi-level solid waste recycling and processing plant (комбинат по переработке отходов (КПО) «Алексинский карьер» – the waste processing plant) was set up at the site of Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry started operations at the end of 2019.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The project for the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been discussed at a public hearing.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The project for the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry had received a positive conclusion from the authorities concerning the assessment of its impact on the environment.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. BACKGROUND TO THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 11 May 2017 the Klin Town Court of Moscow Region examined a claim for compensation of damage to health and non-pecuniary damage brought by Mr Kotov (the first applicant) against Kombinat LLC, the Moscow Regional Department of the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment, and the Klin municipal administration.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The claim brought by Mr Kotov (the first applicant) on 11 May 2017 was in connection with the use and operation of the landfill site at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Mr Kotov (the first applicant) requested the Klin Town Court of Moscow Region to order the defendants to abstain from acts or omissions interfering with his right to a safe environment or creating a risk of such interference.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The first applicant explained at the hearing that he owned and had been cultivating a plot of land in the village of Bol'shoye Tschapovo in the Klin District of Moscow Region.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The first applicant explained at the hearing that since 2015, every day, especially on hot days or in the evening, there had been a strong foul odour which had made him feel frustrated, physically and mentally unwell, had caused him to have mood swings and had made him lose the desire to work and unable to sleep.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The first applicant explained at the hearing that since 2015 he had experienced headaches and nausea so badly that he could not even eat.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The first applicant explained at the hearing that the landfill at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been the source of the foul waste odour, which had been confirmed by multiple complaints from local residents.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The first applicant explained at the hearing that the landfill at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been the source of the foul waste odour, which had been confirmed by the head of the regional administrative and technical supervisory body in a press release of 20 July 2016.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Witnesses A., Ch., Ey. and An., who lived in the villages close to Aleksinskiy Quarry, testified at the hearing that since 2015 there had regularly been a strong unpleasant odour emanating from the quarry.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Klin Town Court of Moscow Region found that the first applicant had not substantiated with documentary evidence the harm allegedly caused to his health owing to the operation of the landfill site at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Klin Town Court of Moscow Region found that the first applicant had not substantiated with documentary evidence the non-pecuniary damage he had allegedly sustained owing to the operation of the landfill site at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Klin Town Court of Moscow Region held that no documentary evidence such as medical certificates confirming disability or admission for treatment in outpatient facilities or hospital, prescriptions for medication, or pharmaceutical or medical receipts had been submitted proving harm to the first applicant's health.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Klin Town Court of Moscow Region held that the testimony of the four witnesses summoned on the first applicant's behalf regarding the foul odour emanating from the landfill site had been their subjective assessments of the odour and were not proof that the first applicant had actually endured any suffering personally.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Klin Town Court of Moscow Region held that the testimony of the four witnesses summoned on the first applicant's behalf was not proof that the first applicant had in fact sustained non-pecuniary damage caused by the smell from Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Klin Town Court of Moscow Region held that Kombinat LLC had been sanctioned in administrative proceedings on 7 April 2015 for failure to register as a waste management company in the State landfill register.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Klin Town Court of Moscow Region held that Kombinat LLC had been sanctioned in administrative proceedings on 15 July 2015 for failing to obtain a licence to emit harmful substances.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Klin Town Court of Moscow Region held that the administrative sanctions against Kombinat LLC of 7 April 2015 and 15 July 2015 were not legally binding in the first applicant's case, as he had not been a party to either of those sets of proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Klin Town Court of Moscow Region held that neither the administrative judgments against Kombinat LLC nor a judgment of the Commercial Court of Moscow Region finding Kombinat LLC liable for conducting business operations without a permit showed that the company had caused any air pollution.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to an inspection report dated 30 March 2017 by the Moscow Regional Department of the Ministry of Natural Resources and the Environment, the level of permitted air pollution during the operation of the landfill site by Kombinat LLC had not been exceeded.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The inspection report dated 30 March 2017 by the Moscow Regional Department of the Ministry of Natural Resources and the Environment was not provided to the Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 12 July 2017 the judgment of the Klin Town Court of Moscow Region in the first applicant's case was upheld on appeal by the Moscow Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 12 October 2017 the judgment of the Klin Town Court of Moscow Region in the first applicant's case was upheld by the Moscow Regional Court in cassation appeal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 27 November 2017 the judgment of the Klin Town Court of Moscow Region in the first applicant's case was upheld by the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation in cassation appeal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "A. Civil proceedings brought by the first applicant (Mr Kotov, application no. 6142/18)"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 7 April 2015 the Klin Town Court sanctioned Kombinat LLC in administrative proceedings for failing to register in the State landfill register.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 15 July 2015 the Klin Town Court sanctioned Kombinat LLC in administrative proceedings for failing to register in the State landfill register.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 15 July 2015 the Klin Town Court sanctioned Kombinat LLC in administrative proceedings for operating without a licence to emit certain harmful substances into the atmospheric air and without established emission limits, imposing a fine (amount left blank in the published copy of the judgment).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 3 March 2017 the Klin Town Court sanctioned Kombinat LLC in administrative proceedings for illegally depositing waste beyond the designated boundaries of Aleksinskiy Quarry, imposing a fine of RUB 150,000 (about EUR 1,700).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 4 August 2017 the Consumer Protection Authority sanctioned Kombinat LLC in administrative proceedings (details set out in paragraphs 18-22 and 25 of the judgment).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 13 October 2017 the Klin Town Court sanctioned Kombinat LLC in administrative proceedings (details set out in paragraphs 19-20 of the judgment).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 15 December 2017 the Klin Town Court sanctioned Kombinat LLC in administrative proceedings for emitting toxic elements above the maximum permitted levels (MPL) registered on 6 September 2017, specifically ammonia at 3 MPL, nitrogen oxide at 53 MPL, phenol at 93.8 MPL, soot at 1.3 MPL, and xylol at 2.3 MPL, imposing a fine of RUB 90,000 (about EUR 1,000).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 19 December 2017 the Klin Town Court sanctioned Kombinat LLC in administrative proceedings (details set out in paragraph 22 of the judgment).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 24 April 2018 the Commercial Court of Moscow Region sanctioned Kombinat LLC in administrative proceedings for failing to construct a protective barrier around Aleksinskiy Quarry to prevent the spread of fragments of waste, thus endangering people's lives and health and creating various environmental hazards, imposing a fine of RUB 100,000 (about EUR 1,000).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 7 May 2018 the Klin Town Court sanctioned Kombinat LLC in administrative proceedings for emitting toxic elements above the maximum permitted levels (MPL) registered on 8 February 2018, specifically nitrogen dioxide at 2.2-12.8 MPL, imposing a fine of RUB 100,000.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 7 May 2018 the Klin Town Court sanctioned Kombinat LLC in administrative proceedings for failing to mention in its report on emissions a degasification furnace that releases carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxide, imposing a fine (amount left blank in the published copy of the judgment).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 7 May 2018 the Klin Town Court sanctioned Kombinat LLC in administrative proceedings for failing to keep land adjacent to Aleksinskiy Quarry free of uncollected fragments of waste and for depositing unauthorised types of waste, imposing a fine of RUB 140,000 (about EUR 1,600).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 15 May 2018 the Ministry of Natural Resources and the Environment sanctioned Kombinat LLC for emitting ammonia 3.9-17 times above the maximum permitted level (MPL), as detected during an inspection on 27 April 2018 at air monitoring posts in the villages near Aleksinskiy Quarry, and ordered Kombinat LLC to ensure compliance with its emissions permit by 26 January 2019.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 17 May 2018 a State body issued an order to Kombinat LLC to comply with the relevant environmental regulations after finding that Kombinat LLC had deposited 833,186.20 tonnes of waste in 2017, above the authorised limit of 270,000 tonnes of waste per year.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 19 June 2018 the Klin Town Court sanctioned Kombinat LLC in administrative proceedings for depositing unauthorised waste of type II hazard, imposing a fine of RUB 120,000 (about EUR 1,400).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 13 December 2018 the Klin Town Court sanctioned Kombinat LLC in administrative proceedings for operating without a positive assessment of the environmental impact of its activities and in the absence of an established sanitary protection zone.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "At the hearing of 7 April 2015 (administrative proceedings no. 1), the representative of Kombinat LLC explained that the company had been taking steps to have itself listed in the State landfill register.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "At the hearing of 7 April 2015 (administrative proceedings no. 1), the representative of Kombinat LLC explained that the authorities had not yet taken a decision on registering Kombinat LLC in the State landfill register.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "At the hearing of 15 July 2015 (administrative proceedings no. 3), the representative of Kombinat LLC stated that no measurements of emissions from Aleksinskiy Quarry had been carried out.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "At the hearing of 15 July 2015 (administrative proceedings no. 3), the representative of Kombinat LLC stated that Aleksinskiy Quarry was the only place for household waste disposal in the Klin District.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "At the hearing of 15 July 2015 (administrative proceedings no. 3), the representative of Kombinat LLC stated that the suspension of Kombinat LLC's operations would be very damaging to the local environment.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "At the hearing of 15 July 2015 (administrative proceedings no. 3), the representative of Kombinat LLC explained that the authorities had not yet registered Kombinat LLC in the State landfill register.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 4 August 2017 the Consumer Protection Authority of Moscow Region (the regional CPA), acting upon complaints by an unidentified number of people allegedly affected by the activities of Kombinat LLC, carried out an inspection at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Consumer Protection Authority of Moscow Region (the regional CPA) concluded that in the course of its waste processing operations Kombinat LLC had breached sixteen environmental, sanitary and epidemiological regulations.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Consumer Protection Authority of Moscow Region (the regional CPA) ordered Kombinat LLC to suspend its operations and carry out remedial measures by 1 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 11 August 2017 the Klin Town Court terminated the administrative proceedings against Kombinat LLC, finding the results of the inspection of 4 August 2017 unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "An inspector of the Consumer Protection Authority of Moscow Region (the regional CPA) appealed against the Klin Town Court's decision of 11 August 2017 terminating the administrative proceedings against Kombinat LLC.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 7 September 2017 the Moscow Regional Court remitted the case against Kombinat LLC to the Klin Town Court for fresh examination.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 13 October 2017 the Klin Town Court confirmed the conclusions of the inspection of 4 August 2017 and found Kombinat LLC liable for breaching sixteen relevant sanitary, epidemiological and environmental regulations.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The sixteen violations found by the Klin Town Court on 13 October 2017 included Kombinat LLC's failure to obtain the approval of the chief environmental health officer (Главный санитарный врач) for the creation of a sanitary protection zone around Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The sixteen violations found by the Klin Town Court on 13 October 2017 included insufficient soil supply for the intermediary and final stages of waste separation at Aleksinskiy Quarry, resulting in uncovered and visible waste remains.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The sixteen violations found by the Klin Town Court on 13 October 2017 included leftover waste (mainly plastic rubbish bags) on the boundary of Aleksinskiy Quarry adjacent to the villages of Naprugovo and Novotschapovo.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The sixteen violations found by the Klin Town Court on 13 October 2017 included the absence of gas control systems at Aleksinskiy Quarry, which causes an increase in air pollution and has an adverse impact on nearby residential areas.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The sixteen violations found by the Klin Town Court on 13 October 2017 included the absence of a system for collecting leachates (liquid from rotten waste which endangers the quality of soil, groundwater and surface water) at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The sixteen violations found by the Klin Town Court on 13 October 2017 included the absence of regular monitoring (once every ten days) of uncollected fragments of waste such as plastic bags and scraps of paper at Aleksinskiy Quarry and failure to take the relevant clean-up measures.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The sixteen violations found by the Klin Town Court on 13 October 2017 included Kombinat LLC's failure to carry out regular cellular morphological and chemical testing of waste components at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The sixteen violations found by the Klin Town Court on 13 October 2017 included Kombinat LLC's failure to make water control facilities at Aleksinskiy Quarry accessible to inspectors' vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Klin Town Court ordered Kombinat LLC to immediately suspend its activities for ninety days following the judgment of 13 October 2017.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Klin Town Court explicitly stated in the operative part of its decision of 13 October 2017 that the lodging of an appeal complaint would not prevent execution of the administrative sanction imposed on Kombinat LLC.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "On 13 October 2017 the Klin Town Court granted a request by Kombinat LLC to suspend execution of the administrative sanction of ninety days' suspension of activities, pending the examination of Kombinat LLC's statement of appeal by the Moscow Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 19 December 2017 the Klin Town Court re-examined the case against Kombinat LLC, which had been remitted to it by the Moscow Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "On 19 December 2017 the Klin Town Court confirmed its earlier conclusions of 13 October 2017 regarding Kombinat LLC's violations.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "On 19 December 2017 the Klin Town Court imposed an administrative fine of RUB 250,000 (about EUR 3,000) on Kombinat LLC, which was paid in full.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "One of the applicants, Ms Kotova (application no. 106/19), brought a complaint against the Klin Town Court's decision to suspend execution of the administrative sanction against Kombinat LLC.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "On 8 February 2018 the Moscow Regional Court allowed Ms Kotova's complaint and quashed the Klin Town Court's decision to suspend execution of the administrative sanction against Kombinat LLC.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "No further information was provided to the Court in respect of the proceedings brought by Ms Kotova (application no. 106/19) against the decision to suspend execution of the administrative sanction against Kombinat LLC.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "On 15 May 2018 another notice of violation was issued to Kombinat LLC stating that the main source of air pollution at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been the body of the landfill itself.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The notice of violation issued to Kombinat LLC on 15 May 2018 stated that hydrogen sulphide, ammonia, methane, benzol, nitrogen dioxide, formaldehyde and other toxic substances had been released into the atmospheric air as a result of waste disposal at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 7 June 2018 the Consumer Protection Authority of Moscow Region (the regional CPA) carried out an unannounced inspection at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Consumer Protection Authority of Moscow Region (the regional CPA) established on 7 June 2018 that all the violations detected on 4 August 2017 had been corrected by Kombinat LLC, except the failure to obtain the approval of the chief environmental health officer for a sanitary protection zone around Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "B. Administrative proceedings in respect of Kombinat LLC brought by different State bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 8 November 2019 the Klin Town Court examined a complaint brought by a group of residents of Klin, including the applicants (except the first, fourth and seventh applicants), against Kombinat LLC.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The group of residents of Klin, including the applicants (except the first, fourth and seventh applicants), requested the Klin Town Court to stop Kombinat LLC's activities and close Aleksinskiy Quarry permanently.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Klin Town Court found that Kombinat LLC had obtained a State-issued licence to collect and process solid waste, issued in 2007.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Klin Town Court found that Kombinat LLC had obtained a licence to emit harmful substances within the applicable limits, issued in 2015.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Klin Town Court found that Kombinat LLC had obtained two positive assessments of the environmental impact of its activities, issued in 2014 and 2015 respectively.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Klin Town Court found that Kombinat LLC had obtained a positive assessment of its project for a sanitary protection zone, issued in 2016.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The Klin Town Court found that Kombinat LLC had obtained a certificate confirming registration of Aleksinskiy Quarry in the polluting entities register, issued in 2017.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Klin Town Court examined a report by Mr P., a court-appointed environmental expert, who testified that Kombinat LLC had committed irreversible environmental violations and that waste disposal at Aleksinskiy Quarry should be discontinued immediately.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "At the hearing before the Klin Town Court, Mr P. confirmed the conclusions reached in his expert report.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "At the hearing before the Klin Town Court, Mr P. explained that he had not tested air quality at Aleksinskiy Quarry, and that the relevant officials should do such tests regularly over a year.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "According to Mr P., it was not possible to establish a direct link between the environmental impact of Aleksinskiy Quarry and morbidity rates.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "According to Mr P., no technology existed to collect leachate that had already contaminated soil at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "In 1993 a protective plastic liner had been laid at Aleksinskiy Quarry against leachate contamination, but no data was available about its maintenance.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Klin Town Court found the expert's report by Mr P. unconvincing because Mr P. had not reviewed the relevant project documentation for Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Klin Town Court found the expert's report by Mr P. unconvincing because Mr P. had not tested air, water and soil quality at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Klin Town Court found the expert's report by Mr P. unconvincing because Mr P. had not noted any measurements of harmful substances for Aleksinskiy Quarry or Klin.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Klin Town Court found the expert's report by Mr P. unconvincing because Mr P. had not measured the quantity of waste that had been deposited at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Klin Town Court held that Kombinat LLC had provided reports on air, water and soil quality testing at Aleksinskiy Quarry and beyond its boundaries, carried out between March 2018 and June 2019 by a private laboratory (Promenergo LLC).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "According to the reports by Promenergo LLC covering March 2018 to June 2019, the maximum permitted levels (MPL) for nitrogen dioxide, ammonia, carbon monoxide, phenol, formaldehyde, hydrogen sulphide, benzol, methane, xylol and toluene had not been exceeded at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Excerpts from the reports by Promenergo LLC (at least eight of which from 2018 were provided to the Court) indicate, prima facie, that the maximum permitted levels (MPL) of some substances had been exceeded at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The Klin Town Court found that in June 2019 the director of Kombinat LLC had approved a programme for regular air, water and soil quality testing at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Reports on air, water and soil quality tests conducted in September 2019 pursuant to Kombinat LLC's programme were submitted to the Klin Town Court.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "On 22 August 2019 the Consumer Protection Authority (CPA) approved the project documentation for the creation of a sanitary protection zone around Aleksinskiy Quarry as being compliant with the relevant environmental standards, including those for air quality.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "On 23 September 2019 the project documentation for the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry was approved by the State authorities.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The commander-in-chief of the military base located in the Klin District informed Kombinat LLC that the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been approved as safe for flights.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The Klin Town Court concluded that the applicants had not submitted solid and convincing proof of a risk of Kombinat LLC causing harm in the future as a result of its activities at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Klin Town Court concluded that the applicants had not submitted solid and convincing proof that the risk of Kombinat LLC causing harm in the future could in fact materialise and that its operations should be shut down.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Klin Town Court did not take the reports on air quality testing submitted by the applicants into account on the grounds that they had been prepared by the applicants themselves.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The Klin Town Court found that Kombinat LLC had submitted proof of compliance of its operations with the applicable standards and regulations.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Klin Town Court held that the fact that courts and administrative bodies had sanctioned Kombinat LLC eight times in the past for different violations of sanitary and environmental regulations could not justify shutting down its operations because it had not been proven that those violations had caused irreversible damage to the environment.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "On 2 March 2020 the Moscow Regional Court dismissed an appeal by the applicants against the Klin Town Court's judgment of 8 November 2019.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The applicants did not provide the Court with a copy of the Moscow Regional Court's judgment of 2 March 2020.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The applicants submitted that they had tried to bring further cassation appeals before the higher courts, but that their appeals had been returned to them for what they described as 'contrived' procedural reasons.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "It appears from the relevant domestic decisions submitted by the applicants that they did not comply with the procedural requirements for filing cassation appeals.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "On 28 July 2021 the Klin Town Court refused a request by the applicants to re-examine the case anew because they had sought the reassessment of evidence that had already been examined at the hearing of 8 November 2019, which was not considered a valid reason for reopening the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "C. Civil proceedings against Kombinat LLC brought by residents of Klin"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Some of the applicants, together with other residents of Klin, brought administrative proceedings in connection with the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "D. Administrative proceedings concerning the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Some of the applicants alleged that the public hearing and procedure for approval of the project for the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been tainted with certain defects.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "D. Administrative proceedings concerning the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The domestic courts dismissed the applicants' complaints concerning the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "D. Administrative proceedings concerning the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The domestic courts established, on the basis of the evidence examined, that all procedural requirements had been observed by the respective authorities in relation to the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry, and that those authorities had acted within their powers.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "D. Administrative proceedings concerning the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The domestic courts found that there was nothing to indicate that the applicants' rights had been breached in the process of approving the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC PROCEEDINGS", "D. Administrative proceedings concerning the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "In March 2018 the applicants started organising protests against the landfill site at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANTS' PROTESTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "All the applicants except Ms Kotova (application no. 106/19) were charged with various administrative offences in connection with their protests against the landfill site.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANTS' PROTESTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "The details concerning the charges against the applicants, their arrest and the administrative sanctions imposed on them in connection with their protests are outlined in Appendix I of the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANTS' PROTESTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "In November 2017 Mr Kotov submitted three notices of a public event (meeting) to the Klin municipal administration.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANTS' PROTESTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "In May 2018 Mr Kotov submitted one notice of an environmental protest car rally to the Klin municipal administration.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANTS' PROTESTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Neither of Mr Kotov's applications to the Klin municipal administration for a public event or environmental protest car rally was approved.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANTS' PROTESTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Mr Kotov brought a complaint against the Klin municipal authorities before the courts in connection with the non-approval of his applications for public events.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANTS' PROTESTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The details of the proceedings brought by Mr Kotov against the Klin municipal authorities are outlined in Appendix I (application no. 56764/18) of the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANTS' PROTESTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "In a letter of 10 April 2013 addressed to the Russian President, the regional governor of Moscow Region highlighted the deteriorating environmental situation in Moscow Region and the need to implement modern waste processing technologies.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "In a letter of 10 April 2013 addressed to the Russian President, the regional governor of Moscow Region requested the President to order the closure of twenty-four landfills in Moscow Region owing to their excessive storage capacity and obsolete technical characteristics.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "In 2017 and 2018 State laboratories of the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment of Moscow Region and of the State Fire and Rescue Service and Federal Service for Hydrometeorology and Environmental Monitoring carried out air quality tests in the vicinity of Aleksinskiy Quarry and in Klin.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "From December 2018 to November 2019 a public interest group carried out measurements of air quality in the vicinity of Aleksinskiy Quarry and in Klin, using special testing equipment.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "Excerpts from air testing reports produced by State laboratories indicate a number of instances where the maximum permitted levels (MPL) in the atmospheric air of Klin and its districts had been exceeded.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "On other dates, air quality measurements in Klin and its districts indicated no excess of the maximum permitted levels (MPL).", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "A report of the state laboratory dated 15 March 2018 of air sampling in some of the villages near Aleksinskiy Quarry stated that a foul odour typical for landfills had been smelled in the village of Novotschapovo.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The state laboratory report dated 15 March 2018 stated that residents of the village of Novotschapovo should complain to the relevant authorities about the foul odour.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "A notice of violation issued to Kombinat LLC by the Moscow Regional Department of the Ministry of Natural Resources and the Environment on 17 May 2018 stated that Aleksinskiy Quarry had exceeded its storage capacity by three times, with 833,186.20 tonnes of waste deposited in 2017 instead of an anticipated 270,000 tonnes.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "According to a letter dated 16 July 2018 from the Federal Service for Hydrometeorology and Environmental Monitoring, the level of pollution in Klin had been classified as 'high', mostly owing to an overconcentration of formaldehyde in the atmospheric air.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The letter dated 16 July 2018 from the Federal Service for Hydrometeorology and Environmental Monitoring stated that the high concentration of formaldehyde in June 2018 in Klin could be explained by a certain type of repair works carried out at the time, solar radiation or certain chemical reactions.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "According to an expert report dated 22 August 2019 concerning the project for a sanitary protection zone around the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry, 1,662,625 tonnes of waste had been deposited at Aleksinskiy Quarry between mid-2017 and mid-2019.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The applicants submitted that the 1,662,625 tonnes of waste deposited at Aleksinskiy Quarry between mid-2017 and mid-2019 had been almost three times above the authorised limit for waste disposal.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "A forensic expert report dated 31 July 2019 submitted by Mr P. in reply to questions of the Klin Town Court concluded that the source of the 'foul landfill odour' could only have been the body of the landfill itself at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The forensic expert report dated 31 July 2019 by Mr P. concluded that the landfill at Aleksinskiy Quarry was the only place in the vicinity of Klin that attracted large numbers of birds.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The forensic expert report dated 31 July 2019 by Mr P. concluded that the violation by Kombinat LLC of sanitary, epidemiological and environmental regulations had resulted in detectable consequences for the environment and the health of the population.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The forensic expert report dated 31 July 2019 by Mr P. concluded that the massive uncontrolled leakage of toxic organic waste (leachate) from Aleksinskiy Quarry had been practically impossible to remediate and had posed a real danger to the life and health of the population.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The forensic expert report dated 31 July 2019 by Mr P. concluded that the leachate from Aleksinskiy Quarry had seriously endangered the environment, had impaired the quality of fresh water and groundwater, and could contaminate soil and water sources for decades.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The forensic expert report dated 31 July 2019 by Mr P. concluded that Kombinat LLC had deposited waste beyond the established boundaries of the landfill at Aleksinskiy Quarry and had exceeded the landfill's authorised capacity for waste disposal.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "In the opinion of forensic expert Mr P. in his report dated 31 July 2019, Kombinat LLC should have been ordered to take measures to prevent further breaches and to repair the damage caused at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE APPLICANTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The Government submitted that within the framework of the 2018 Russia-wide 'Ecology' project, plans had been drawn up for the construction of a large-scale multi-level solid waste recycling and processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "A. Project for the construction of a solid waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been planned to carry out the sorting and subsequent recycling of solid waste to help improve the environmental situation in the area.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "A. Project for the construction of a solid waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The processing capacity of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been estimated at between 150,000 and 300,000 tonnes of solid waste per year.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "A. Project for the construction of a solid waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been designed to use the best available national and international technologies aimed at reducing landfill, lowering the risks of gas formation and foul odours and creating recycled fuels.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "A. Project for the construction of a solid waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "Kombinat LLC's project for the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been examined at a public hearing.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "A. Project for the construction of a solid waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "Kombinat LLC's project for the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been submitted for a State environmental impact assessment.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "A. Project for the construction of a solid waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "On 23 September 2019 the project for the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been approved for implementation by the Ministry of Natural Resources and the Environment.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "A. Project for the construction of a solid waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "On 22 August 2019 the project for delimiting a 1.5 km sanitary protection zone around the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been studied by the relevant State expert commission.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "A. Project for the construction of a solid waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "On 23 October 2019 the project for delimiting a 1.5 km sanitary protection zone around the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been approved by the Russian Consumer Protection Authority (CPA) as being in compliance with the relevant regulations.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "A. Project for the construction of a solid waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "The Government submitted that in 2019 the regional authorities of Moscow Region had approved an investment programme for remediating and decontaminating Aleksinskiy Quarry for 2019-2027.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "B. Remediation and decontamination of Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "The investment programme for remediating and decontaminating Aleksinskiy Quarry had been in effect since 1 July 2019.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "B. Remediation and decontamination of Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "The investment programme for remediating and decontaminating Aleksinskiy Quarry stipulated the construction of systems for collecting and processing landfill gas, collecting leachates and purifying filters.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "B. Remediation and decontamination of Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "The investment programme for remediating and decontaminating Aleksinskiy Quarry stipulated the construction of a multi-level solid waste sorting and processing facility.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "B. Remediation and decontamination of Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "The investment programme for remediating and decontaminating Aleksinskiy Quarry stipulated sealing the body of the landfill and its borders to prevent leakage.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "B. Remediation and decontamination of Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "The investment programme for remediating and decontaminating Aleksinskiy Quarry stipulated collecting rainwater and diverting drainage.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "B. Remediation and decontamination of Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "Kombinat LLC implemented technologies for drainage and the treatment of rainwater at Aleksinskiy Quarry to reduce the negative impact of its activities on the environment.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "C. Measures taken by Kombinat LLC for improving the environmental impact"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "Kombinat LLC implemented technologies for acoustic protection from birds at Aleksinskiy Quarry to reduce the negative impact of its activities on the environment.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "C. Measures taken by Kombinat LLC for improving the environmental impact"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "Kombinat LLC implemented technologies for electronically controlling the amount of waste taken to Aleksinskiy Quarry by trucks to reduce the negative impact of its activities on the environment.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "C. Measures taken by Kombinat LLC for improving the environmental impact"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "Kombinat LLC implemented technologies for collecting, decontaminating and disposing of landfill gas at Aleksinskiy Quarry to reduce the negative impact of its activities on the environment.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "C. Measures taken by Kombinat LLC for improving the environmental impact"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "Kombinat LLC started constructing a reverse osmosis system for treating leachate at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "C. Measures taken by Kombinat LLC for improving the environmental impact"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "Kombinat LLC regularly (every three months) monitored emissions into the air, water and soil at Aleksinskiy Quarry and published the results of its inspections on the quarry's website.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "C. Measures taken by Kombinat LLC for improving the environmental impact"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "Kombinat LLC complied with the judgment of 13 October 2017 of the Klin Town Court by paying the fine imposed on it in full.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "C. Measures taken by Kombinat LLC for improving the environmental impact"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "Kombinat LLC carried out the relevant remedial measures for violations of the relevant sanitary regulations following the judgment of 13 October 2017 of the Klin Town Court, which had been confirmed by the supervisory State bodies.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "C. Measures taken by Kombinat LLC for improving the environmental impact"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "The Government submitted that according to reports on atmospheric air, wastewater and groundwater quality testing carried out between 21 March 2018 and 10 June 2019 within and outside the boundaries of Aleksinskiy Quarry, the maximum permitted levels (MPL) of nitrogen dioxide, ammonia, carbon monoxide, phenol, xylol and toluene had not been exceeded.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "D. Sanitary and epidemiological inspections at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "The Government submitted that in 2018-2019 weekly air quality monitoring had been carried out in the municipal districts adjacent to Aleksinskiy Quarry within 500 metres to 2 km.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "D. Sanitary and epidemiological inspections at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "Of the 1,206 air samples taken in 2018-2019 in the municipal districts adjacent to Aleksinskiy Quarry, 1,170 were tested.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "D. Sanitary and epidemiological inspections at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "The air quality testing in 2018-2019 in the municipal districts adjacent to Aleksinskiy Quarry indicated that the concentrations of hydrogen sulphide, ammonia, methane, methanethiol, sulphur dioxide and phenol had been within the relevant maximum permitted levels (MPL).", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "D. Sanitary and epidemiological inspections at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "Water quality monitoring in 2018-2019 in the municipal districts adjacent to Aleksinskiy Quarry had not revealed excessive concentrations of harmful substances.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "D. Sanitary and epidemiological inspections at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "Testing of groundwater from wells and boreholes and of soil in 2018-2019 in the municipal districts adjacent to Aleksinskiy Quarry showed no deviation from the relevant health standards.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "D. Sanitary and epidemiological inspections at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "On 31 January 2018, during an unannounced inspection by the authorities, concentrations of ammonia above the relevant maximum permitted level (MPL) had been detected at the air monitoring posts at Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "D. Sanitary and epidemiological inspections at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "As a result of the detection of ammonia above the relevant maximum permitted level (MPL) on 31 January 2018, Kombinat LLC had been ordered to take remedial measures in order to comply with the relevant MPL.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "D. Sanitary and epidemiological inspections at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "According to Kombinat LLC's letter of 31 January 2019 and supporting documents, Kombinat LLC had complied with the order to take remedial measures to bring ammonia levels within the relevant maximum permitted level (MPL).", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "D. Sanitary and epidemiological inspections at Aleksinskiy Quarry"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "The Government submitted that in 2018-2019 the authorities of Moscow Region had received seventy-three requests (обращения) concerning the operation of Aleksinskiy Quarry, including requests to have it closed.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "E. Examining public requests concerning Aleksinskiy Quarry and access to information concerning the environment"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "The Government submitted that no complaints (жалобы) had been received by the authorities or regional medical organisations about the negative impact of Aleksinskiy Quarry on people's health.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "E. Examining public requests concerning Aleksinskiy Quarry and access to information concerning the environment"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "Representatives of the Ministry of Defence had requested the regional government of Moscow Region to have Aleksinskiy Quarry closed because its use had endangered the safety of military planes from Klin-5 airbase during their flights, owing to the circulation of birds above the quarry.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "E. Examining public requests concerning Aleksinskiy Quarry and access to information concerning the environment"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "The authorities stated in reply to the Ministry of Defence's request that there were no grounds to close Aleksinskiy Quarry since the modern waste processing plant would be installed by 2021 and the quarry would no longer pose a danger to aircraft.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "E. Examining public requests concerning Aleksinskiy Quarry and access to information concerning the environment"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "Between 18 March 2016 and 29 April 2019 the regional and municipal authorities, including representatives of the Committee on the Environment of Moscow Region legislative authority, held eighteen public meetings in the form of hearings, assize legislative sessions and discussions in respect of operations at Aleksinskiy Quarry and its modernisation.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "E. Examining public requests concerning Aleksinskiy Quarry and access to information concerning the environment"]}, {"fact_id": "F205", "text": "On 29 April 2019 a public hearing was held on the project for the construction of a waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry in order to obtain the views of residents, including those of the applicants, who provided their observations and objections on the issue.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "E. Examining public requests concerning Aleksinskiy Quarry and access to information concerning the environment"]}, {"fact_id": "F206", "text": "Following the public hearing of 29 April 2019, the project documentation for the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry was sent for a State environmental impact assessment.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "E. Examining public requests concerning Aleksinskiy Quarry and access to information concerning the environment"]}, {"fact_id": "F207", "text": "Information on air and water pollution as well as radiation in the Russian regions had been regularly published on the website of the Federal Service for Hydrometeorology and Environmental Monitoring and had been available to the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "E. Examining public requests concerning Aleksinskiy Quarry and access to information concerning the environment"]}, {"fact_id": "F208", "text": "Information about the environmental conditions at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been published and updated by Kombinat LLC on its website.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE RELIED ON BY THE GOVERNMENT", "E. Examining public requests concerning Aleksinskiy Quarry and access to information concerning the environment"]}, {"fact_id": "F209", "text": "On 28 January 2016 the Regional Minister of Natural Resources and the Environment of Moscow Region, during a meeting with residents of Klin and official representatives of Kombinat LLC, stated that the main complaint by residents was the smell emanating from Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F210", "text": "On 28 January 2016 the Regional Minister of Natural Resources and the Environment of Moscow Region stated that waste disposal operations at Aleksinskiy Quarry had been carried out in violation of the applicable regulations.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F211", "text": "On 28 January 2016 the Regional Minister of Natural Resources and the Environment of Moscow Region stated that the construction of the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry appeared to be the only solution to the environmental problems caused by the quarry.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F212", "text": "According to a website dedicated to the national 'Ecology' project, the project includes nine environmental programmes, including a programme on waste management and waste processing infrastructure in Russia in 2019-2024.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F213", "text": "The national 'Ecology' project's programme on waste management and waste processing infrastructure in Russia in 2019-2024 has a budget of RUB 450 billion.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F214", "text": "The national 'Ecology' project's programme on waste management and waste processing infrastructure in Russia in 2019-2024 includes the introduction of recycling schemes and the construction of more than 200 waste processing plants in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F215", "text": "According to information published on the official website of the Moscow regional government, a recycling system was launched in 2019 in Moscow Region to increase the reuse of materials and decrease the waste deposited in landfill.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F216", "text": "Funds for the reclamation of landfill sites in Moscow Region were allocated for 2020-2022 in the regional budget.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F217", "text": "A large-scale multi-level solid waste recycling and processing plant opened at the end of 2019 at the site of Aleksinskiy Quarry.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F218", "text": "At the end of 2020 the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry started functioning at full processing capacity.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F219", "text": "In early 2021 half of the solid waste collected at the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry was recycled, with 20% of recyclable materials (glass, paper, steel and plastic) recovered and 30% of solid waste composted.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F220", "text": "In total, more than 100,000 tonnes of solid waste had been recycled at the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry, reducing the volume of waste disposal in the landfill by half.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F221", "text": "Aleksinskiy Quarry closed in 2020 and degasification (burning of landfill biogases in a special high-temperature furnace) was being actively pursued to prevent the spreading of foul odours in the Klin District.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F222", "text": "The construction of purification facilities at Aleksinskiy Quarry was underway following its closure in 2020.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F223", "text": "Three more boreholes for the extraction of landfill gas at Aleksinskiy Quarry would be created in the near future following its closure in 2020.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F224", "text": "A complex solid waste processing infrastructure has been under construction in Moscow Region since 2019.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F225", "text": "Thirty-nine landfill sites in Moscow Region closed in 2020.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F226", "text": "Ten modern waste processing plants have been launched in Moscow Region and 2.6 million tonnes of solid waste has been recycled by them.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F227", "text": "The construction of four more thermal solid waste disposal plants in Moscow Region is planned for 2022-2023, with an estimated target of only 7% of solid waste being deposited in landfill, which is well above the target of the national 'Ecology' project.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F228", "text": "In 2015 and 2016 the Klin District was named among the areas for which the highest proportion of unsatisfactory tests of water was reported.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F229", "text": "In 2016 and 2020 the proportion of unsatisfactory tests of water from non-centralised sources in the Klin District was reported as compared to the average regional indicator.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F230", "text": "Excessive concentrations of various chemical elements were detected in drinking water in the Klin District in 2015-2019.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F231", "text": "The excessive amounts of iron and manganese in water in the Klin District had resulted in an increased risk of developing blood and immunity-related diseases.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F232", "text": "According to the 2018 report, the higher proportion of unsatisfactory tests of atmospheric air in towns and villages in Moscow Region could be attributed to pollution from landfills where solid household waste was deposited.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F233", "text": "In 2018 air quality testing was regularly carried out at landfill sites in Moscow Region, including at Aleksinskiy Quarry, where the concentrations of harmful substances were within the applicable limits that year.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F234", "text": "In 2019 recycling schemes were being actively implemented in Moscow Region, which made it possible to deposit lower volumes of waste in the landfill sites.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F235", "text": "As projected, the waste processing plant at Aleksinskiy Quarry started operations in 2019, where regular air quality testing continued to be carried out in 2019 and 2020.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F236", "text": "In 2019 a technical station for removing iron from water was set up in Klin within the framework of the national 'Clean Water' project.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F237", "text": "The right to a safe environment in Russia is contained in Article 42 of the Russian Constitution.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F238", "text": "The right to bring civil or administrative proceedings by private persons or State bodies in respect of environmental damage in Russia is contained in Articles 1064 and 1065 of the Civil Code, Article 23.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, Articles 39 and 218 of the Code of Administrative Procedure, and Article 42 of the Land Code.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F239", "text": "The obligation of physical or legal persons to comply with relevant environmental regulations in Russia is contained in Articles 1064 and 1065 of the Civil Code, Article 23.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, Articles 39 and 218 of the Code of Administrative Procedure, and Article 42 of the Land Code.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F240", "text": "Articles 56 and 57 of the Russian Civil Procedure Code govern issues of presenting and collecting evidence in civil proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F241", "text": "Ruling of the Russian Supreme Court no. 1 of 26 January 2010 contains detailed provisions concerning compensation of harm to life or health of physical persons and compensation for environmental damage.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F242", "text": "Ruling of the Russian Supreme Court no. 49 of 30 November 2017 contains detailed provisions concerning compensation of harm to life or health of physical persons and compensation for environmental damage.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F243", "text": "Federal Law no. 174-FZ of 23 November 1995 regulates environmental impact assessments for various industrial projects made by State bodies or public interest organisations in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F244", "text": "Federal Law no. 89-FZ of 24 June 1998 regulates matters relating to industrial and household waste, including registration of landfills in the State landfill register, in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F245", "text": "Federal Law no. 52-FZ of 12 March 1999 regulates the sanitary and epidemiological well-being of the population in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F246", "text": "Federal Law no. 96-FZ of 4 May 1999 regulates air pollution, including the requirement of industrial self-monitoring, in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F247", "text": "Federal Law no. 7-FZ of 10 January 2002 regulates the protection of the environment in Russia, covering types of polluting entities, the requirement of industrial self-monitoring, the right to information, the right to protest, the right to compensation, and the right to bring complaints.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F248", "text": "Federal Law no. 99-FZ of 4 May 2011 regulates the licensing of activities of waste-processing operators in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F249", "text": "Decree no. 322 of 30 June 2004 and State Decree no. 476 of 5 June 2013 (as in force before 30 June 2021) regulate the Federal Consumer Protection Authority's supervisory and preventative functions in the environmental sphere, including dealing with complaints about unfavourable environmental conditions, in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F250", "text": "Sanitary Regulations 2.2.1/2.1.1.1200-03 of 25 September 2007 regulate environmental protection zones around polluting enterprises in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F140", "F141", "F143", "F144"], "interference": ["F141", "F143", "F144", "F145"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F140", "F141", "F143", "F144", "F145", "F146"], "positive_obligation": ["F141"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F140", "F141", "F143", "F144"], "interference": ["F141", "F145"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F141", "F143", "F144", "F145"], "positive_obligation": ["F141"]}, "list3": ["F141", "F143", "F144", "F145"]}} {"case_name": "case_375", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1965.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "At 4.07 p.m. on 7 October 2009, the applicant notified the police that he planned to organise a demonstration on 10 October 2009.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The demonstration planned by the applicant was scheduled to run from 2 p.m. to 7 p.m. on 10 October 2009.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The demonstration planned by the applicant was to take place in front of the Venyige Street prison in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The purpose of the demonstration planned by the applicant was to protest against the \"political persecution of national radicalism\".", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Venyige Street is a broad cul-de-sac.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Venyige Street has a service lane.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006"], "interference": ["F003", "F004", "F005"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F005", "F007", "F008"], "necessity": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F007", "F008"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F005", "F006"], "interference": ["F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F005"], "necessity": ["F003", "F005", "F007", "F008"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F005", "F007", "F008"]}} {"case_name": "case_376", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1965.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 14 April 2010 the applicant notified the police that he planned to organise a demonstration on 17 April 2010.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The demonstration was planned to take place from 2 to 7 p.m. on 17 April 2010.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The demonstration was planned to take place in front of the Venyige Street prison in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The purpose of the planned demonstration was to draw attention to the 'situation of political prisoners'.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Venyige Street is a broad cul-de-sac with a service lane.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 16 April 2010 the head of the Budapest Police Department banned the planned demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The head of the Budapest Police Department banned the demonstration on the grounds that traffic could not be diverted to alternative routes, pursuant to section 8(1) of the Assembly Act.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "In the decision banning the demonstration, the head of the Budapest Police Department referred to Article 21 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "In the decision banning the demonstration, the head of the Budapest Police Department referred to Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "In the decision banning the demonstration, the head of the Budapest Police Department referred to Decision no. 55/2001.AB of the Constitutional Court of Hungary.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 19 April 2010 the applicant sought a judicial review of the decision banning the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant's application for judicial review on 19 April 2010 was made within the statutory time-limit.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 22 April 2010 the Budapest Regional Court dismissed the applicant's case challenging the ban on the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court noted that in assessing whether traffic could be diverted to other routes, the Budapest Police Department had reckoned on the participation of some 200 demonstrators, as per the applicant's notification.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Budapest Police Department obtained the opinion of a traffic expert before making its decision to ban the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Budapest Police Department established that lawful parking and traffic circulation in the neighbourhood of Venyige Street prison would become impossible should the demonstration take place.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court agreed with the Budapest Police Department's decision that the right to assembly, although a constitutional fundamental right, is not absolute.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court held that the right to assembly must not give rise to a violation of the fundamental rights of others and could therefore be restricted.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court was satisfied that the Budapest Police Department's decision had been lawful because the police had adequately established the facts.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court was satisfied that the Budapest Police Department's decision had been lawful because the police had complied with the procedural rules.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court was satisfied that the Budapest Police Department's decision had been lawful because the police had applied clear assessment criteria.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court was satisfied that the Budapest Police Department's decision had been lawful because the assessment of the evidence had been logical.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006"], "interference": ["F008", "F009"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F009"], "legitimate_aim": ["F009", "F018"], "necessity": ["F005", "F007", "F009", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F006"], "interference": ["F008"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F009"], "legitimate_aim": ["F009"], "necessity": ["F005", "F007", "F009", "F016"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F005", "F007", "F008", "F009"]}} {"case_name": "case_377", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1965.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant intended to organise a demonstration protesting against \"the persecution of national radicalism\".", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The demonstration was planned to take place between 4 p.m. and 7 p.m. on 15 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The planned venue for the demonstration was Venyige Street in Budapest Xth District, in front of Budapest Penitentiary.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, Venyige Street is five metres wide.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "According to the applicant's submissions, Venyige Street is eight metres wide.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Parallel to the main driveway of Venyige Street, there is a service lane with a width equivalent to that of two cars.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The service lane parallel to the main driveway of Venyige Street is normally used as a car park.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the applicant's submissions, the service lane could have accommodated largely all the demonstration participants without them creating any major traffic incident.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant submitted a notification to Budapest Police Department under Act no. III of 1989 on the Right of Assembly.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "In the notification to Budapest Police Department, the applicant indicated that a maximum of 200 participants were to be expected at the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant's notification to Budapest Police Department was made at 5.40 p.m. on 12 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 14 August 2009, Budapest Police Department banned the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Budapest Police Department banned the demonstration in pursuit of its prerogatives under section 8(1) of Act no. III of 1989 on the Right of Assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Budapest Police Department was of the view that there was no alternative route for traffic in the neighbourhood of Venyige Street.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Budapest Police Department concluded that the demonstration would impede traffic inordinately because there was no alternative route for traffic in the neighbourhood.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant was reproached by Budapest Police Department with the fact that the notification did not contain the agenda for the gathering.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Because of the prohibition by Budapest Police Department, the demonstration did not take place.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 17 August 2009, the applicant requested judicial review of the Budapest Police Department's decision banning the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant explained that he had not specified the agenda in the notification because the meeting had been intended as a rather small one.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant explained that the actual course of events at the demonstration, such as speeches or discussion, was hard to predict because the meeting was intended as a small one.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 19 August 2009, the Budapest Regional Court rejected the applicant's complaint against the Budapest Police Department's decision banning the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court observed that the question of previous notification of the agenda was immaterial to the case.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court found that the only valid reason for banning the demonstration was the disproportionate difficulties which would be caused to traffic by the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court relied on an expert opinion provided by the Traffic Division of Budapest Police Department.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the Traffic Division of Budapest Police Department's expert opinion, the demonstration would have significantly impeded traffic heading to the shops located in Venyige Street, a dead end.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the Traffic Division of Budapest Police Department's expert opinion, the demonstration would have significantly impeded traffic heading to the local waste disposal site accessible via Venyige Street.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the Traffic Division of Budapest Police Department's expert opinion, the demonstration would have significantly impeded traffic heading to the suppliers' entrance of Budapest Prison via Venyige Street.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the Traffic Division of Budapest Police Department's expert opinion, the disruption caused by the crowd might have extended to Maglódi Road, a major thoroughfare in the vicinity of Venyige Street.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Maglódi Road has lines of city transport running along it.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Relying on the expert opinion of the Traffic Division of Budapest Police Department, the Budapest Regional Court endorsed the Budapest Police Department's decision banning the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F012"], "interference": ["F014", "F019"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F011", "F015"], "legitimate_aim": ["F014", "F017"], "necessity": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F012", "F025", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F012"], "interference": ["F014", "F019"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F015"], "legitimate_aim": ["F017"], "necessity": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F012", "F025", "F027", "F030"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F014", "F019", "F015", "F012", "F027", "F008", "F030", "F025"]}} {"case_name": "case_378", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants are members of the religious organization \"Bozhya Slava\" based in Syktyvkar.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the location of public religious events.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the time of public religious events.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Some applicants raised complaints about the lack of domestic remedies against the alleged violations of their freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F004"]}} {"case_name": "case_380", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius, was born in 1970.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius, lives in Vaitkūnai village, Utenos region.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Bronius Markauskas, was born in 1960.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Bronius Markauskas, lives in Triušeliai village, Klaipėda region.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Artūras Pilota, was born in 1973.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The third applicant, Mr Artūras Pilota, lives in Ožkasviliai village, Marijampolė region.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The fourth applicant, Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas, was born in 1959.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The fourth applicant, Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas, lives in Jungėnai village, Marijampolė region.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The fifth applicant, Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, was born in 1961.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The fifth applicant, Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, lives in Varakiškė village, Vilkaviškis region.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "In April 2003 a group of farmers held a demonstration in front of the Seimas (the Lithuanian Parliament) building.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The April 2003 demonstration was held to protest about the situation in the agricultural sector with regard to a fall in wholesale prices for various agricultural products.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The April 2003 demonstration was held to protest about the lack of subsidies for producing agricultural products.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The farmers demonstrating in April 2003 demanded that the State take action regarding the situation in the agricultural sector.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 16 May 2003 the Chamber of Agriculture (Žemės ūkio rūmai), an organisation established to represent the interests of farmers, met to discuss possible solutions to issues in the agricultural sector.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "At the 16 May 2003 meeting of the Chamber of Agriculture, one of the measures foreseen if no positive changes in legal regulation were forthcoming was addressing complaints to the administrative courts.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "At the 16 May 2003 meeting of the Chamber of Agriculture, it was decided to organise protests in three different locations next to trunk roads in Lithuania to draw attention to problems in the agricultural sector.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In May 2003 the Kalvarija municipality issued a permit to hold a peaceful assembly in Kalvarija town, 'near the marketplace'.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "In May 2003 the Pasvalys municipality issued a permit to hold a demonstration 'at the car park at the sixty-third kilometre of the Via Baltica highway and next to that highway'.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "In May 2003 the Klaipėda municipality issued a permit covering an 'area in Divupiai village next to, but not closer than twenty-five metres from, the Vilnius-Klaipėda highway'.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The permit issued by the Klaipėda municipality specified that Mr Bronius Markauskas was one of the organisers of the gathering.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Mr Bronius Markauskas was informed that he had to observe the law and to adhere to any orders from the authorities and the police in connection with the permitted gathering.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The demonstrations started on 19 May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The farmers gathered in the designated areas on 19 May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 21 May 2003 the farmers blocked and continued to demonstrate on the roads next to Dirvupiai village, on the Vilnius-Klaipėda highway.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 21 May 2003 the farmers blocked and continued to demonstrate at the sixty-third kilometre of the Panevėžys-Pasvalys-Riga highway.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 21 May 2003 the farmers blocked and continued to demonstrate at the ninety-fourth kilometre of the Kaunas-Marijampolė-Suvalkai highway.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 22 May 2003 the farmers continued negotiations with the Government.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 23 May 2003, following a successful outcome to negotiations with the Government, the farmers stopped blocking the roads.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Pre-trial investigations against the applicants and a number of other persons were started on suspicion of having caused a riot.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "In July 2003 Mr Bronius Markauskas, Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, Mr Artūras Pilota and Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas were ordered not to leave their place of residence.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The measure ordering Mr Bronius Markauskas, Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, Mr Artūras Pilota and Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas not to leave their place of residence was lifted in October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The police record of 22 May 2003 indicates that during the farmers' demonstration on the Kaunas-Marijampolė-Suvalkai highway the farmers and the lorry drivers had a few arguments, but more serious conflicts were avoided.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "Later in May 2003, four companies that transport goods informed the police and Linava, the Lithuanian National Road Carriers' Association, that they had sustained pecuniary damage in the sum of 25,235 Lithuanian litai (approximately 7,300 euros) due to the blockade of the roads during the farmers' demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The four transport companies stated that they would institute civil proceedings in respect of their claims for pecuniary damage caused by the blockade of the roads during the farmers' demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 1 September 2003 the Pasvalys police issued a certificate stating that on 19-23 May 2003 the farmers had held a demonstration at the car park at the sixty-third kilometre of the Panevėžys-Pasvalys-Riga highway.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the Pasvalys police certificate of 1 September 2003, on 21 May 2003 at around midday the farmers had gone on to the Panevėžys-Pasvalys-Riga highway and had stopped the traffic.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the Pasvalys police certificate of 1 September 2003, the farmers had only allowed through passenger vehicles and vehicles that carried dangerous substances.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the Pasvalys police certificate of 1 September 2003, vehicles that carried goods and cars had been allowed to go through once in an hour and ten at a time on each side of the road.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the Pasvalys police certificate of 1 September 2003, the police had attempted to let the traffic bypass the blockade through neighbouring villages in order to ameliorate the situation.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the Pasvalys police certificate of 1 September 2003, due to the poor condition of neighbouring roads, not all lorries that carried goods had been able to drive on them and they had had to remain on the highway until the farmers had left it.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to the Pasvalys police certificate of 1 September 2003, some lorries had become stuck in sand and special machinery had been necessary to pull them out.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the Pasvalys police certificate of 1 September 2003, the farmers had unblocked the Panevėžys-Pasvalys-Riga highway at 4 p.m. on 23 May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicants submitted that on 1 October 2003 the police had imposed a fine of 40 Lithuanian litai (approximately 12 euros) on farmer A.D.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the applicants, the police record relating to the fine on farmer A.D. established that on 21 May 2003 A.D. had taken the farmers to block the Kaunas-Marijampolė-Suvalkai highway in Kalvarija municipality.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to the applicants, the police record relating to the fine on farmer A.D. established that A.D. had walked in the middle of the road, pushing a cart in front of him, thus obstructing the traffic.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to the applicants, by his actions A.D. had breached paragraph 81 of the Road Traffic Rules and thus committed an administrative law violation as provided for in Article 131 of the Code of Administrative Law Offences.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 4 December 2003 an indictment was brought before the courts.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Mr Bronius Markauskas and Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius were accused of incitement to riot under Article 283 § 1 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The prosecutor noted that Mr Bronius Markauskas had taken part in the farmers' meeting of 16 May 2003, at which the farmers had decided to hold demonstrations near major highways on 19 May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The prosecutor noted that at the 16 May 2003 meeting, the farmers had decided that should the Government not grant their requirements by 11 a.m. on 21 May 2003, they would blockade those highways.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The prosecutor noted that on 19 May 2003 Mr Bronius Markauskas had told the farmers to blockade the roads on 21 May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The prosecutor noted that as a result of Mr Bronius Markauskas's incitement, at 12.09 p.m. on 21 May 2003 around 500 farmers had gone on to the Vilnius-Klaipėda highway.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The prosecutor noted that the farmers had refused to obey police requests not to stand on the Vilnius-Klaipėda road.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The prosecutor noted that as a consequence of the blockade of the Vilnius-Klaipėda highway, traffic had been blocked until 1 p.m. on 23 May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The prosecutor noted that traffic jams had occurred on neighbouring roads and road transport in the region had become impossible as a result of the blockade of the Vilnius-Klaipėda highway.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The prosecutor claimed that Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius had incited the farmers to blockade the Panevėžys-Pasvalys-Riga highway.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The prosecutor claimed that as a result of Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius's incitement, at midday on 21 May 2003 around 250 people had gone on to the Panevėžys-Pasvalys-Riga highway, refusing police orders not to block the highway.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The prosecutor claimed that the Panevėžys-Pasvalys-Riga road had remained blocked until 10.58 a.m. on 23 May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The prosecutor claimed that the roads in the vicinity of the Panevėžys-Pasvalys-Riga highway had become clogged as a result of the blockade.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The prosecutor claimed that the normal functioning of the Saločiai-Grenctale border control post had been interrupted as a result of the blockade of the Panevėžys-Pasvalys-Riga highway.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas and Mr Artūras Pilota were accused of a serious breach of public order during the riot, under Article 283 § 1 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The prosecutor established that on 21 May 2003, at around 11.50 a.m., around 1,500 people had gone on to the ninety-fourth kilometre of the Kaunas-Marijampolė-Suvalkai highway.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The prosecutor established that at about 3-4 p.m. on 21 May 2003, Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas and Mr Artūras Pilota had driven on to the Kaunas-Marijampolė-Suvalkai highway with three tractors and had left the tractors on the asphalt carriageway.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The prosecutor established that Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas and Mr Artūras Pilota had refused to obey police instructions not to breach public order and not to leave the tractors on the road.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The prosecutor established that the tractors had remained on the Kaunas-Marijampolė-Suvalkai road until 4.15 p.m. on 23 May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The prosecutor established that as a result of the blockade, the Kaunas-Marijampolė-Suvalkai highway had been blocked from the eighty-fourth to the ninety-fourth kilometre.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The prosecutor established that due to the resulting increase of traffic on neighbouring roads, congestion had built up and car transport in the region had come to a halt.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The prosecutor established that the normal functioning of the Kalvarija and Marijampolė State border control posts had been disrupted as a result of the blockade of the Kaunas-Marijampolė-Suvalkai highway.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Within the criminal proceedings, a logistics company brought a civil claim against Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius, as the person who had incited the farmers to block the Panevėžys-Pasvalys-Riga road, seeking damages of 1,100 Lithuanian litai (approximately 290 euros) for the loss allegedly incurred due to the blockade of that road.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 16 August 2004 the Kaunas City District Court suspended the examination of the case in respect of Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas, Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, Mr Bronius Markauskas and Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius, as they had failed to present themselves at the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius and Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis had been notified about the forthcoming hearing of 16 August 2004 by summons.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Mr Bronius Markauskas had also been informed about the hearing of 16 August 2004 in advance.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 16 August 2004 the case was examined only with regard to Mr Artūras Pilota.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 16 August 2004 the Kaunas City District Court questioned eight witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The applicants' lawyer was present at the hearing of 16 August 2004 and put questions to seven of the eight witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 17-20 August 2004 the Kaunas City District Court held hearings where several other witnesses testified about the demonstration at issue.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court examined the case on 17-20 August 2004 only with regard to Mr Artūras Pilota, who was present at those hearings.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "It transpires from the judgments of the Kaunas Regional Court and the Supreme Court that all the applicants were present at certain hearings before the Kaunas City District Court.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 29 September 2004 the Kaunas City District Court found the applicants guilty of having incited riots or having participated in them, under Article 283 § 1 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "In convicting Mr Bronius Markauskas, the Kaunas City District Court relied on video recordings of the events, documentary evidence and the testimony of one witness.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court concluded that Mr Bronius Markauskas had organised a gathering with the aim of seriously violating public order, that is to say a riot.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court found that Mr Bronius Markauskas had been one of the leaders of the farmers' meeting on 16 May 2003, at which the farmers had decided to attempt to achieve their goals by organising protests next to trunk roads.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court found that Mr Bronius Markauskas had coordinated the actions of the farmers and as a consequence on 21 May 2003 around 500 people had gone to the Vilnius-Klaipėda road and had blocked it.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court found that as a result of Mr Bronius Markauskas's actions, car traffic on the Vilnius-Klaipėda road had been blocked until 23 May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court found that the ensuing serious breach of public order had been deliberate and had to be qualified as rioting.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court dismissed Mr Bronius Markauskas's claim that he and other farmers had acted out of necessity because the roadblock had been their last opportunity to draw the Government's attention to their problems.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court found that the farmers had had another alternative, namely bringing complaints before the administrative courts, which the farmers had themselves mentioned during the meeting of 16 May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court noted that under Article 31 § 2 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code, a person who created a dangerous situation by his or her actions could only rely on the defence of necessity when a dangerous situation arose through negligence.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court found that the actions of Mr Bronius Markauskas had been deliberate and it was therefore appropriate to find him guilty of organising the riot.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court established, mainly on the basis of video recordings and documentary evidence, that Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius had organised a gathering with the aim of seriously breaching public order.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court established that Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius had taken part in the farmers' meeting of 16 May 2003 and had known about the decision to hold protests next to the roads.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court established that when a crowd of farmers had blocked the Panevėžys-Pasvalys-Riga road on 21 May 2003, public order had been seriously breached, car traffic had stopped at that part of the road, causing inconvenience to drivers and goods carriers.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court established that during the blockade of 21 and 22 May 2003, Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius coordinated the actions of the crowd by giving orders that some of the vehicles should be let through.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court established that during the blockade of 21 and 22 May 2003, Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius incited the farmers to hold on and not to move away from the highway.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court established that during the blockade of 21 and 22 May 2003, Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius was in contact with the participants in the protests in Kalvarija municipality and Klaipėda region.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court established that during the blockade of 21 and 22 May 2003, Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius was negotiating with the authorities by mobile phone in the name of the farmers.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court emphasised that the farmers who had gathered obeyed the actions of Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius and followed his orders.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court qualified the actions of Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius as organising riots under Article 283 § 1 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On the basis of written evidence submitted by Linava (the Lithuanian National Road Carriers' Association), the Kaunas City District Court found that by having organised the blockade of the Panevėžys-Pasvalys-Riga road, Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius had seriously breached public order and had caused pecuniary damage to three carrier companies.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "As one of the carriers had submitted a civil claim in the sum of 1,100 Lithuanian litai, the Kaunas City District Court deemed it proper to grant it.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "In finding Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas and Mr Artūras Pilota guilty of rioting, the Kaunas City District Court relied on documentary evidence, audiovisual materials and two witnesses' testimony.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court established that on 21 May 2003 between 11.50 a.m. and 4.15 p.m., Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas and Mr Artūras Pilota had driven tractors on to the Kaunas-Marijampolė-Suvalkai highway at its ninety-fourth kilometre.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court established that Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas and Mr Artūras Pilota had refused to obey lawful requirements by the police not to breach public order and not to park the tractors on the road.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court established that Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas and Mr Artūras Pilota had kept the tractors on the Kaunas-Marijampolė-Suvalkai highway until 4.15 p.m. on 22 May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court established that because about 1,500 people had gathered on the road, the traffic had been blocked between the eighty-fourth and ninety-fourth kilometres of the Kaunas-Marijampolė-Suvalkai road.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court established that traffic jams had occurred and the normal functioning of the Kalvarija and Lazdijai border control offices had been disrupted as a result of the blockade of the Kaunas-Marijampolė-Suvalkai highway.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The five applicants were each given a sixty-day custodial sentence (baudžiamasis areštas) by the Kaunas City District Court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court noted that all the applicants had positive characteristics and there were no circumstances aggravating their guilt.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court suspended the sentences of all five applicants for one year, finding there was reason to believe that the aim of the punishment could be achieved without actually depriving them of their liberty.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The applicants were ordered not to leave their places of residence for more than seven days without the authorities' prior agreement, for a period of one year whilst execution of the sentence was suspended.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Kaunas City District Court acquitted, for lack of evidence, two other individuals charged with organising the riots.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The applicants lodged an appeal with the Kaunas Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "In their appeal, the applicants noted that another farmer, A.D., had been punished under administrative law for an identical violation.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "All five applicants took part in a hearing before the Kaunas Regional Court and asked that they be acquitted.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "On 14 January 2005 the Kaunas Regional Court found that the trial court had thoroughly and impartially assessed all the circumstances of the case.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court observed that the crime of rioting placed in danger public order, society's safety, human health, dignity and the inviolability of property.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court observed that the objective aspect of the crime of rioting was organising gathered people for a common goal of breaching public order and carrying out that decision, which in the instant case had been to organise the roadblocks.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court observed that to constitute the crime of rioting, the actions also had to be committed on purpose, that is to say the persons charged had to understand the unlawfulness of their actions.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court observed that during the demonstrations Mr Bronius Markauskas and Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius had told others that it had been decided to block the roads.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court established that Mr Bronius Markauskas and Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius had understood that the roadblocks would be illegal and that they had been warned about their liability as organisers.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court found that despite being warned, Mr Bronius Markauskas and Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius had kept coordinating the farmers' actions and had insisted that farmers would maintain the roadblocks.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court found that as a direct result of the actions of Mr Bronius Markauskas and Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius, on 21 May 2003 a crowd had gone on to a highway and had blocked it, thereby stopping the traffic and breaching the constitutional rights and liberties of others to move freely and without restriction.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court found that the actions of Mr Bronius Markauskas and Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius had caused damage to goods carriers and had thus seriously breached public order.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court shared the trial court's conclusion as to the reasonableness of convicting Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas and Mr Artūras Pilota.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court found that by driving tractors on to the road, causing traffic congestion and disturbing the work of the State border control service, and by refusing to obey lawful requests by the police not to park their tractors on the road, Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas and Mr Artūras Pilota had seriously breached public order.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court found that the fact that after the roads had been blocked the police and the drivers had negotiated with the farmers with the result that some of the drivers had been let through did not diminish the danger of the offence and its unlawfulness.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court emphasised that the blockade of a major highway (magistralinis kelias) had had dangerous consequences and could not be considered to have been a mere administrative law offence such as a traffic violation.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "As to the applicants' argument that their offences were identical to that for which farmer A.D. had been given a merely administrative punishment for a traffic violation, the Kaunas Regional Court only briefly indicated that it was not an administrative court and thus could not comment on the administrative violation.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court noted that the applicants had the right to freedom of expression under Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court observed that the right to freedom of expression under Article 10 of the Convention was not without restrictions where the interests of public order and prevention of crime were at stake.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court observed that analogous limitations to freedom of expression were listed in Article 25 of the Lithuanian Constitution.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court emphasised that the behaviour of Mr Bronius Markauskas and Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius, in guiding the actions of the other individuals involved in the protest, could not be regarded as a non-punishable expression of their opinion, because they had breached public order by their actions, for which criminal liability was foreseen.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court stated that the criminal offence had not lost its element of public danger merely because the Government had refused to raise wholesale prices or because the Government had allegedly failed to take necessary action.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court dismissed the applicants' complaints that they had not had a fair trial, in that the video recordings proving their guilt had been forged.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court observed that when the video recordings had been shown as evidence before the Kaunas City District Court, the applicants had not alleged that they had been falsified, although they had each been asked if the events shown in the recording were true.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court observed that the applicants had not answered in the negative when asked about the video recordings, but had agreed with the recorded material.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court found that the mere fact that the film had been recorded with interruptions did not mean that it was illegitimate evidence.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court found that although the applicants had alleged that one of the tapes had been falsified, the judgment had not been based on that particular tape.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court found that the trial court's refusal to question some witnesses had been reasoned, the evidence in the case had been legitimate and not falsified, and no other procedural violations were found.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court observed that although Mr Kęstutis Miliauskas, Mr Virginijus Mykolaitis, Mr Bronius Markauskas and Mr Arūnas Kudrevičius had failed to attend the first hearing at the Kaunas City District Court on 16 August 2004, the court had suspended the examination of the case with regard to those applicants.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court noted that all the applicants were present at some point when the case was examined by the Kaunas City District Court and therefore could exercise their procedural rights unhindered.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court noted that witnesses had not been questioned in the absence of the applicants concerned.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court found that the rights of the applicants had not been infringed at any point.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court dismissed a complaint by Mr Bronius Markauskas that immunity from criminal liability should apply to him because of his status as a parliamentary candidate.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court noted that the crime at issue had been committed in May 2003, whilst the Central Electoral Commission had registered Mr Bronius Markauskas as a candidate in the Parliamentary elections only in September 2004.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court found that Mr Bronius Markauskas did not have immunity under domestic law with regard to the crime committed in May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court upheld the trial court's decision not to summon the Speaker of Parliament, the Prime Minister and other members of the Government and Parliament for questioning.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court deemed that the Speaker of Parliament, the Prime Minister and other members of the Government and Parliament could only have given evidence on economic matters which had no relation to the case.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The Kaunas Regional Court found that the aforementioned politicians had not participated in the gathering or seen the violations of public order and therefore could not have given any evidence as to the circumstances of the offence charged.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "On 4 October 2005 the Supreme Court, composed of an enlarged chamber of seven judges, dismissed an appeal on points of law brought by the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "In providing an explanation of the substance of the crime of rioting under Article 283 § 1 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code, the Supreme Court referred to the classification of the offence as an offence against public order.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The Supreme Court established that Article 283 § 1 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code stipulated the following features of the crime of rioting: the organisation of a gathering with the aim of causing public violence, damaging property or breaching public order in other ways, or the commission of those actions during a gathering.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "The Supreme Court found that a riot was to be characterised as a situation when a gathering of people deliberately seriously breached public order, caused public violence, or damaged property.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The Supreme Court found that the subjective aspect of the crime of rioting was that of the deliberate nature of the action, requiring the guilty person to be aware that he or she was performing an action listed as an offence in Article 283 § 1 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code and to wish to so act.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The Supreme Court found that the lower courts had been correct in qualifying the applicants' actions as falling under Article 283 § 1 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The Supreme Court found that the Kaunas City District Court had properly established all the prerequisites for the application of Article 283 § 1 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code, namely that there had been a crowd and that public order had been breached by blocking the roads, stopping traffic and disturbing the work of the State border control service.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The Supreme Court found that the applicants had been sentenced for their crimes under a law which had been valid at the time at which the crimes had been committed and their sentences had been imposed in accordance with the provisions of the Lithuanian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The Supreme Court found that the applicants' convictions had been in accordance with the law and not in breach of Article 7 § 1 of the European Convention on Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The Supreme Court stated that the applicants had not been sentenced for expressing their opinion or imparting ideas, actions protected by Article 10 § 1 of the Convention, but for actions by which they had seriously breached public order.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The Supreme Court noted that while part of the examination of the case at the trial stage had been carried out without some of the applicants being present, they had failed to submit any legitimate reasons for their absence, and thus the courts had had the right to examine the case without them.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The Supreme Court found there was no indication that the Kaunas City District Court would have deliberately obstructed any of the applicants from taking part in the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The Supreme Court noted that the trial court had to ensure that the case would be decided within a reasonable time.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The Supreme Court found that the convictions had been based solely on the evidence examined at the hearings at which all applicants had been present.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The Supreme Court found that the applicants' lawyer, who had defended the interests of all the co-accused, had had every opportunity to question every witness in the case, thus having assured the applicants' right to have witnesses against them examined under Article 6 § 3 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The Supreme Court found that the question of the immunity of the parliamentary candidate had been correctly settled, noting that a parliamentary candidate had immunity only for actions performed during the electoral campaign, whereas a member of Parliament had immunity irrespective of the date on which he or she had committed a crime.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The Supreme Court upheld the trial court's reasoning not to summon members of the Parliament and the Government for questioning, referring to the Court's case-law to the effect that the accused does not have the right to request that every witness be called to testify.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The Supreme Court shared the appellate court's view that the applicants could not be considered as having acted out of necessity.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The Supreme Court held that the fall in milk purchase prices and other problems with subsidies for agriculture had not constituted a clear or present danger to someone's property, because the property in question had not yet materialised.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The Supreme Court held that the law protects existing property and that the State had not deprived the applicants of their property.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The Supreme Court held that the applicants' dissatisfaction with the Government's agricultural policy had not justified the acts for which the five applicants had been convicted.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "The Supreme Court found that the materials in the case file did not allow the conclusion that the applicants' conviction under Article 283 § 1 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code had been in breach of Article 23 of the Lithuanian Constitution or Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the European Convention on Human Rights, because the property in question had not yet materialised.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "By court rulings of 17, 18, 20, 21 October and 7 November 2005, the courts discharged the five applicants from their suspended sentences.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "Article 23 of the Constitution of the Republic of Lithuania states that property is inviolable.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "Article 25 of the Constitution of the Republic of Lithuania provides that a natural person shall have the right to have his own convictions and to freely express them.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "Article 25 of the Constitution of the Republic of Lithuania provides that a natural person must not be hindered from seeking, receiving and imparting information and ideas.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "Article 25 of the Constitution of the Republic of Lithuania provides that freedom to express convictions, to receive and impart information may not be limited otherwise than by law, if this is necessary to protect the health, honour and dignity, private life, and morals of a natural person, or to defend the constitutional order.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "Article 25 of the Constitution of the Republic of Lithuania provides that freedom to express convictions and to impart information shall be incompatible with criminal actions – incitement of national, racial, religious, or social hatred, violence and discrimination, or slander and disinformation.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "On 25 October 2000 the Lithuanian Criminal Code was published in the Official Gazette (Valstybės žinios).", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "Article 283 § 1 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code establishes criminal liability for rioting, which is categorised as a public order offence.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "Article 283 § 1 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code provides that a person who has organised or provoked a gathering of persons to commit public acts of violence, damage property or seriously breach public order in other ways, or a person who, during a riot, has committed acts of violence, damaged property or seriously breached public order in other ways, may be sentenced to a custodial sentence (baudžiamasis areštas) or imprisonment for up to five years.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "Article 75 § 1 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code stipulates that if a person is sentenced to imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years for the commission of one or several minor or less serious premeditated crimes, a court may suspend the sentence imposed for a period ranging from one to three years.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "Article 75 § 2 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code stipulates that the sentence may be suspended when the court rules that there is a sufficient basis for believing that the purpose of the penalty will be achieved without the sentence actually being served.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "Article 75 § 2 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code provides that when suspending execution of the sentence, the court may order the convicted person not to leave his place of residence for a period of longer than seven days, without prior agreement of the authority which supervises execution of the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "Pursuant to Article 97 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code, individuals convicted of a crime and whose conviction has become effective are considered as people with a previous conviction.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "Pursuant to Article 97 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code, any person given a suspended sentence is considered as having a previous conviction during the period of suspension of the sentence.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "Article 31 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code defines the concept of necessity (būtinasis reikalingumas), stating that a person shall not be held liable under the criminal law for an act committed in an attempt to avert an immediate danger which threatens him, other persons or their rights, or public or State interests, where this danger could not have been averted by other means and where the damage caused is less than the damage which it is intended to avert.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "Article 31 of the Lithuanian Criminal Code provides that a person who creates a dangerous situation by his actions may only rely upon the defence of necessity when the dangerous situation arose through negligence (dėl neatsargumo).", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "Article 1241 of the Lithuanian Code of Administrative Law Offences at the relevant time provided for administrative liability for a breach of traffic rules by drivers, stipulating that a breach of the rules on how and when a driver could stop and park on highways carried a fine from 100 to 150 Lithuanian litai (approximately 30-45 euros).", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "Article 131 of the Lithuanian Code of Administrative Law Offences provided for administrative liability for non-observance by pedestrians of traffic signals, crossing of a carriageway or walking on it, punishable by a fine of 30-50 Lithuanian litai (approximately 8-15 euros).", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "Point 81 of the Lithuanian Road Traffic Rules provided that pedestrians must walk on the sidewalk and, if there is none, on the right side of the road in a single line.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "Article 62 (2) of the Constitution of the Republic of Lithuania states that a member of the Parliament may not be held criminally liable without the consent of the Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "Article 49 (1) of the Lithuanian Law on Parliamentary Elections provides that without the consent of the Central Electoral Commission, during an election campaign as well as until the first meeting of a newly-elected Parliament, a parliamentary candidate may not be charged with a crime or arrested and his or her freedom may not be restricted in any other way.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "Article 248 § 2 of the Lithuanian Code of Criminal Procedure stipulates that when there are many accused in the criminal case, the court may allow one or several accused or their counsels not to take part in the examination of the evidence that is not related to that or those accused.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "The Lithuanian Law on Courts at the material time provided that the Supreme Court forms uniform judicial practice in interpreting and applying laws and other legislation.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "To that end, the Supreme Court publishes the decisions of the plenary court as well as the most important decisions of its three or seven judges' chambers in the 'Courts' practice' bulletin.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "The Lithuanian Law on Courts provided that the Supreme Court also analyses courts' practice when they apply the laws and gives recommendations to be followed.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "Depending on the complexity of the case, the Supreme Court decides cases in chambers of three or seven judges or in plenary session under Articles 23, 27 and 36 of the Lithuanian Law on Courts.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "In Eugen Schmidberger, Internationale Transporte und Planzüge v. Republik Österreich, Case C-112/00 [2003], ECR I-05659, the European Court of Justice found that the fact that the Austrian authorities did not ban a demonstration by protesters which resulted in the complete closure of a single major transit route between Austria and Germany for almost thirty hours was not incompatible with Articles 28 and 29 of the Treaty Establishing the European Community, read together with Article 10 of that Treaty.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT EUROPEAN UNION LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "The European Court of Justice in Schmidberger found that the restriction of trade in goods between Member States was justified by the legitimate interest in the protection of fundamental rights, in that case the protesters' freedom of expression and freedom of assembly, which applied both to the Community and the Member States.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT EUROPEAN UNION LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "The European Court of Justice in Schmidberger acknowledged that the national authorities enjoyed a wide margin of discretion in balancing restrictions on intra-Community trade against the protection of fundamental rights, but held that it was for the European Court of Justice to determine whether the restrictions placed upon intra-Community trade were proportionate in the light of the legitimate objective pursued.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT EUROPEAN UNION LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "The European Court of Justice in Schmidberger acknowledged that whilst a demonstration on a public highway usually entailed inconvenience for non-participants, in particular as regards free movement, that inconvenience could in principle be tolerated provided that the objective pursued is the public and lawful demonstration of an opinion.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT EUROPEAN UNION LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F018", "F019", "F020", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F033", "F038", "F039", "F080", "F094", "F108", "F110"], "interference": ["F018", "F019", "F020", "F080", "F108", "F110", "F111"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F180", "F181"], "legitimate_aim": ["F025", "F026", "F027", "F034", "F061", "F069"], "necessity": ["F025", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F033", "F038", "F039", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F070", "F080", "F094", "F101", "F108", "F110", "F111", "F116", "F117", "F118", "F129", "F151"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F018", "F019", "F020", "F033", "F038", "F039", "F080"], "interference": ["F080", "F108", "F110", "F111"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F180", "F181"], "legitimate_aim": ["F025", "F026", "F027", "F034"], "necessity": ["F028", "F029", "F033", "F038", "F039", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F070", "F080", "F101", "F108", "F110", "F111", "F116", "F129", "F151"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F018", "F019", "F020", "F033", "F038", "F039", "F028", "F029", "F070", "F101", "F080", "F116", "F151", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F129", "F108", "F110", "F111"]}} {"case_name": "case_381", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_382", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_383", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_385", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_386", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_387", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_388", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_389", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1967.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Santovenia de Pisuerga.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr J.A. Blanco Rodríguez, a lawyer practising in Valladolid.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Mr J.A. Blanco Rodríguez was later replaced as the applicant's representative by Ms C. López Cedrón, a lawyer practising in Valladolid.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr R.A. León Cavero, State Attorney.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On Sunday 2 February 2014, the applicant took part in a demonstration in Valladolid.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The demonstration on 2 February 2014 in Valladolid was against budgetary cuts and high unemployment rates, among other social issues.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The protest on 2 February 2014 in Valladolid was organised by an association in favour of unemployed people's rights called Asociación parad@s en movimiento Valladolid.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The authorities had been notified in advance of the demonstration of 2 February 2014 as required by Spanish legislation.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The organisers of the demonstration of 2 February 2014 had themselves requested the public-security resources needed to regulate road traffic.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The organisers of the demonstration of 2 February 2014 had themselves requested the public-security resources needed to guarantee the proper progression of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The protest of 2 February 2014 proceeded without incident until its official end.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "After the official end of the demonstration on 2 February 2014, a group of around fifty to sixty protesters continued marching in the streets of Valladolid city centre.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "After the official end of the demonstration on 2 February 2014, the group of around fifty to sixty protesters marched mostly through pedestrian streets.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "After the official end of the demonstration on 2 February 2014, the group of around fifty to sixty protesters moved towards a square called Plaza de San Lorenzo in Valladolid.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The post-official-end protest on 2 February 2014 was spontaneous.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The authorities had not been informed of the post-official-end protest on 2 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 2 February 2014, a political party was holding a congress in Valladolid.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 2 February 2014, some politicians were having lunch in a restaurant located in Plaza de San Lorenzo when the group of protesters gathered in the square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The protesters stood in front of the restaurant in Plaza de San Lorenzo holding a placard which read 'stop the criminalisation of social protest' (paremos la criminalización de la protesta social).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo denounced cases of corruption.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Immediately after the protesters stopped their march and stood in Plaza de San Lorenzo, the police approached them.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The police asked the protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo to remove the placard they were displaying.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The police asked the protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo to peacefully dissolve the protest.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The police asked the protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo to allow traffic to pass as normal.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Several police vans were parked in the roadways adjacent to Plaza de San Lorenzo.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The police officers approached the protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo on foot.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The police officers who approached the protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo were not wearing body armour or protective helmets.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The police officers who approached the protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo carried truncheons and their service pistols.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The police officers tried to remove the placard held by the protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The police officers held some of the protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo and pushed them away from the group in an attempt to dissolve the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo did not approach the entrance to the restaurant.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo did not enter the restaurant's premises.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo refused to put down the placard.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The police forced the protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo to put down the placard.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo were forcefully separated by the police.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Some of the protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo tried to resist the police.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Tension escalated during the police intervention in Plaza de San Lorenzo on 2 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Some of the police officers' interventions in Plaza de San Lorenzo included pushing protesters to the ground.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Some of the police officers' interventions in Plaza de San Lorenzo included hitting protesters with truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "Some of the police officers' interventions in Plaza de San Lorenzo included kicking protesters, even when they were already lying on the ground.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "One of the protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo tried unsuccessfully to take an officer's gun out of its holster.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The protester who tried to take an officer's gun out of its holster was subdued by the officer and arrested.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Two other protesters in Plaza de San Lorenzo were arrested for violent conduct or threats.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "A fourth protester's arrest was ordered but the protester managed to escape from the police.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Two police officers were injured during the events in Plaza de San Lorenzo on 2 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant was not among the protesters who were arrested during the events in Plaza de San Lorenzo on 2 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant was holding the placard in the first line of the demonstration in Plaza de San Lorenzo when she was struck violently by a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicant suffered injuries to her mouth as a result of being struck by a police officer in Plaza de San Lorenzo.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The applicant suffered injuries to her hand as a result of being struck by a police officer in Plaza de San Lorenzo.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The applicant claimed that while protecting her head with her hand, her hand had been hit with a truncheon, which in turn had caused her to injure her mouth.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The applicant was taken to hospital for medical care following the events in Plaza de San Lorenzo on 2 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "According to the medical report, the applicant had suffered a direct trauma to her left hand.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "According to the medical report, the applicant had an open cut in her head.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "According to the medical report, the applicant had bruises in her head.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "According to the medical report, the applicant had a fracture in her head.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "According to the medical report, the applicant had inflammation in her head.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "According to a medical report issued on 3 June 2014 by the Institute of Legal Medicine of Valladolid, the applicant's injuries had taken ninety days to heal.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "According to the medical report issued on 3 June 2014 by the Institute of Legal Medicine of Valladolid, during the ninety days of healing the applicant was not able to perform her usual activities.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Another medical report, issued after 3 June 2014, stated that the applicant's injuries had completely impeded her return to her usual activities.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 15 February 2016, the applicant was given the status of 'permanently incapacitated to perform her usual activities' as a consequence of her injuries suffered on 2 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "According to the police report, the protesters repeatedly tried to enter the restaurant in Plaza de San Lorenzo.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "According to the police report, the protesters succeeded in interrupting the traffic in Plaza de San Lorenzo.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The police report noted that the applicant had been among the six protesters who had had to be taken to hospital for treatment of injuries.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 22 February 2014, criminal proceedings were brought before Valladolid investigating judge no. 4 against ten police officers for causing bodily harm.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 22 February 2014, criminal proceedings were brought before Valladolid investigating judge no. 4 against some of the protesters for disobedience, resisting police officers and assault.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The applicant appeared before Valladolid investigating judge no. 4 on 4 April 2014 to give a statement as a witness and victim.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 23 May 2016, Valladolid investigating judge no. 4 provisionally discharged (sobreseimiento provisional) the police officers under investigation.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 31 May 2016, Valladolid investigating judge no. 4 decided to continue the proceedings against four of the protesters (auto de continuación del procedimiento por los trámites del procedimiento abreviado).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 21 November 2016, after the charges had been presented by the public prosecutor, Valladolid investigating judge no. 4 decided to address proceedings against four protesters (other than the applicant) and send them to the competent criminal judge for them to be examined on the merits (auto de apertura del juicio oral).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The defendants lodged appeals against the decisions of 23 and 31 May 2016 of Valladolid investigating judge no. 4 with the Audiencia Provincial of Valladolid.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 17 October 2016, the Audiencia Provincial of Valladolid confirmed the dismissal of the proceedings against the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Audiencia Provincial of Valladolid stated that the police intervention had been justified not because the protesters had tried to enter the restaurant, for which there was no evidence, but because the protesters had been holding a placard with which they had occupied a public road, preventing the movement of vehicles and people.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Audiencia Provincial of Valladolid stated that everything had been due to a police response to a situation of violence and disorder generated by people who had refused to abide by police orders to dissolve the demonstration and remove the placard.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Audiencia Provincial of Valladolid stated that the individuals had refused to identify themselves properly, kicked, struggled, insulted and pushed the police officers, who had had to repel that action, resulting in injuries on both sides.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Audiencia Provincial of Valladolid stated that what differentiated one action from another was that the police had acted legitimately, while the demonstrators had opposed the actions of the police in an active and violent manner.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 15 November 2016, the applicant lodged an amparo appeal before the Constitutional Court of Spain.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "In the amparo appeal, the applicant argued that her right to a fair trial had been violated by the refusal of the investigating judge to further enquire into the alleged offences committed by the police officers against her and other protesters.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "In the amparo appeal, the applicant argued that her right to a fair trial had been violated by the refusal of the Audiencia Provincial of Valladolid to further enquire into the alleged offences committed by the police officers against her and other protesters.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "In the amparo appeal, the applicant claimed that her right to freedom of thought had been violated.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "In the amparo appeal, the applicant claimed that her right to freedom of expression had been violated.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "In the amparo appeal, the applicant claimed that her rights to freedom of assembly and association had been violated.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "On 22 February 2017, the Constitutional Court of Spain declared the applicant's amparo appeal inadmissible because the applicant had not duly complied with the obligation to prove that her appeal was one of 'special constitutional relevance'.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "Criminal proceedings against police officers – the present application"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On 19 April 2019, a hearing was held before Valladolid criminal judge no. 3 against three of the accused protesters.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "No information was submitted about why the case against the fourth protester was not heard on the same day as the hearing of 19 April 2019 before Valladolid criminal judge no. 3.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "By a judgment of 20 April 2018 given by Valladolid criminal judge no. 3, three protesters were acquitted.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Two of the three acquitted protesters were acquitted because the public prosecutor had withdrawn the charges against them.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The third acquitted protester was acquitted because no evidence had been found incriminating him.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The judgment of 20 April 2018 by Valladolid criminal judge no. 3 stated that the events had taken place when the police had tried to take the placard away from those holding it.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The judgment of 20 April 2018 by Valladolid criminal judge no. 3 stated that it could be seen in the footage that police officers were kicking people.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Valladolid criminal judge no. 3 found that the attitude and behaviour of the protesters had not justified the indiscriminate use of force by the police against them.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Valladolid criminal judge no. 3 found that the protesters had not impeded the movement of traffic.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Valladolid criminal judge no. 3 found that the protesters had not threatened anyone.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Valladolid criminal judge no. 3 found that the protesters had not tried to enter the restaurant in Plaza de San Lorenzo.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Valladolid criminal judge no. 3 found that the protesters had not attacked the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Valladolid criminal judge no. 3 stated that the right to freedom of assembly had been violated when the only response after the end of the official demonstration had been to use force even when there had been no danger to the physical integrity of the people inside the restaurant.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "In the view of Valladolid criminal judge no. 3, the protest had been violently dispersed without any prior warning to dissolve the demonstration or to put down the placard.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "No criminal proceedings were ever initiated against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "A. Criminal proceedings against protesters"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "On 16 January 2017, the applicant brought an administrative claim against the Spanish Ministry of the Interior for liability for the injuries suffered on 2 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "B. Administrative proceedings and judicial administrative proceedings for compensation for the injuries suffered."]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The applicant's administrative claim against the Spanish Ministry of the Interior was rejected in a decision of the Ministry of Interior dated 28 August 2017.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "B. Administrative proceedings and judicial administrative proceedings for compensation for the injuries suffered."]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The applicant appealed the Ministry of Interior's decision of 28 August 2017 to the Audiencia Nacional.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "B. Administrative proceedings and judicial administrative proceedings for compensation for the injuries suffered."]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "In a judgment of 27 March 2019, the Audiencia Nacional found that the State was liable for the conduct of the police agents who had intervened in the dispersal of the protest on 2 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "B. Administrative proceedings and judicial administrative proceedings for compensation for the injuries suffered."]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "In its judgment of 27 March 2019, the Audiencia Nacional found that the police intervention on 2 February 2014 had been disproportionate in its response to the group of protesters.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "B. Administrative proceedings and judicial administrative proceedings for compensation for the injuries suffered."]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "In its judgment of 27 March 2019, the Audiencia Nacional found that the police intervention on 2 February 2014 had been disproportionate in view of the force used against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "B. Administrative proceedings and judicial administrative proceedings for compensation for the injuries suffered."]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "In its judgment of 27 March 2019, the Audiencia Nacional found that the applicant had no legal duty to bear the damage caused to her purely because she had taken part in the protest.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "B. Administrative proceedings and judicial administrative proceedings for compensation for the injuries suffered."]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Among the evidence considered by the Audiencia Nacional in its judgment of 27 March 2019 were videos provided and the statements of two witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "B. Administrative proceedings and judicial administrative proceedings for compensation for the injuries suffered."]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Audiencia Nacional took into account the judgment of 20 April 2018 given by Valladolid criminal judge no. 3 and reproduced that text in full in its judgment of 27 March 2019.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "B. Administrative proceedings and judicial administrative proceedings for compensation for the injuries suffered."]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Audiencia Nacional ordered the Spanish administration to pay the applicant 10,000 euros in its judgment of 27 March 2019.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "B. Administrative proceedings and judicial administrative proceedings for compensation for the injuries suffered."]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The amount of 10,000 euros was fixed by the Audiencia Nacional taking into account the standard harmonised amounts for redress established as guidelines for cases such as the present one in domestic legislation.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "B. Administrative proceedings and judicial administrative proceedings for compensation for the injuries suffered."]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The amount of 10,000 euros was fixed by the Audiencia Nacional taking into account the seriousness of the applicant's injuries, the number of days needed to heal, the damage to her appearance and the sequelae.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OTHER RELEVANT FACTS THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LODGING OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION", "B. Administrative proceedings and judicial administrative proceedings for compensation for the injuries suffered."]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Section 21(1) of the Spanish Constitution recognises the right to peaceful unarmed assembly and provides that the exercise of this right shall not require prior authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Section 21(2) of the Spanish Constitution provides that in the event of meetings in public places and of demonstrations, prior notification shall be given to the authorities, who may ban them only when there are well-founded grounds to expect a breach of public order, involving danger to persons or property.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Section 3(1) of the Right of Assembly Act (Institutional Law 9/1983 of 15 July 1983) provides that meetings shall not be subject to prior authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Section 3(2) of the Right of Assembly Act (Institutional Law 9/1983 of 15 July 1983) provides that the governmental authority shall protect meetings and demonstrations against those who attempt to prevent, disturb or undermine the lawful exercise of this right.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Section 5(a) of the Right of Assembly Act (Institutional Law 9/1983 of 15 July 1983) provides that the government authority shall suspend and, if appropriate, dissolve meetings and demonstrations when they are considered unlawful under criminal law.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Section 5(b) of the Right of Assembly Act (Institutional Law 9/1983 of 15 July 1983) provides that the government authority shall suspend and, if appropriate, dissolve meetings and demonstrations when disturbances of public order occur, endangering persons or property.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Section 5(c) of the Right of Assembly Act (Institutional Law 9/1983 of 15 July 1983) provides that the government authority shall suspend and, if appropriate, dissolve meetings and demonstrations when paramilitary uniforms are worn by attendees.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Section 5 of the Right of Assembly Act (Institutional Law 9/1983 of 15 July 1983) provides that resolutions to suspend or dissolve meetings and demonstrations shall be communicated beforehand to the attendees in the manner provided by law.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Section 8 of the Right of Assembly Act (Institutional Law 9/1983 of 15 July 1983) provides that the holding of meetings in places of public transit and demonstrations must be communicated in writing to the corresponding governmental authority by their organisers or promoters.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Section 23(1) of the Protection of Public Safety Act (Institutional Law 4/2015 of 30 March 2015) provides that the relevant authorities shall adopt the necessary measures to protect the holding of assemblies and demonstrations, preventing the disruption of public safety.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Section 23(1) of the Protection of Public Safety Act (Institutional Law 4/2015 of 30 March 2015) provides that the authorities will order the dissolution of assemblies in places of public transit and of demonstrations in the cases established in section 5 of Institutional Law 9/1983 of 15 July 1983, regulating the right of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Section 23(1) of the Protection of Public Safety Act (Institutional Law 4/2015 of 30 March 2015) provides that the authorities will also disperse vehicles grouped together deliberately when these hamper, put in danger or hinder the traffic on those roads.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Section 23(2) of the Protection of Public Safety Act (Institutional Law 4/2015 of 30 March 2015) provides that intervention measures for the maintenance or reestablishment of public safety in assemblies and demonstrations shall be gradual and proportionate to the circumstances of the case.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Section 23(2) of the Protection of Public Safety Act (Institutional Law 4/2015 of 30 March 2015) provides that the dissolution of assemblies and demonstrations will constitute the last resort.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Section 23(3) of the Protection of Public Safety Act (Institutional Law 4/2015 of 30 March 2015) provides that before adopting dissolution measures, the acting units of the Security Forces and Corps shall warn the persons affected, even orally should the urgency of the situation make it unavoidable.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Section 23(3) of the Protection of Public Safety Act (Institutional Law 4/2015 of 30 March 2015) provides that in cases of public safety risk being posed by weapons, explosive devices or blunt objects, or any other objects dangerous in some way, the Security Forces and Corps shall be able to dissolve the assembly or demonstration or remove the vehicles and obstacles without the need for a prior warning.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F008", "F009", "F012", "F013", "F016", "F047", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F098", "F064", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F032", "F033", "F091", "F092", "F093", "F094", "F095", "F097"], "interference": ["F038", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F052", "F053", "F054", "F055", "F056", "F057", "F098"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F115", "F116", "F118", "F120", "F121", "F123", "F124", "F125"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F006", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F016", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F032", "F033", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F047", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F052", "F053", "F054", "F055", "F056", "F057", "F064", "F086", "F087", "F088", "F091", "F092", "F093", "F094", "F095", "F097", "F098"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F013", "F016", "F048", "F091", "F092", "F094", "F095", "F098"], "interference": ["F048", "F049", "F050"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F115", "F116", "F120", "F123", "F125"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F006", "F014", "F020", "F032", "F033", "F047", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F091", "F092", "F097", "F098"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F006", "F013", "F014", "F016", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F091", "F092", "F097", "F098"]}} {"case_name": "case_393", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The case concerns a protest against a preannounced eviction of a squatted building.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants argue that they had no violent intentions.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants argue that their arrest amounted to an unjustified interference with their right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants argue that their prosecution amounted to an unjustified interference with their right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants argue that their conviction amounted to an unjustified interference with their right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants argue that the interference with their right to freedom of peaceful assembly lacked a legal basis.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicants argue that the interference with their right to freedom of peaceful assembly was disproportionate.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "A list of the applicants and their personal details is set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicants were represented by Mr W.H. Jebbink, a lawyer practising in Amsterdam.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Ms B. Koopman, of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 10 May 2011 the public prosecutor notified the occupants of a building known as the Schijnheilig squat at Passeerdersgracht in Amsterdam that they were suspected of squatting.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 10 May 2011 the public prosecutor notified the occupants of the Schijnheilig squat at Passeerdersgracht in Amsterdam that they would be evicted on or before 5 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 1 July 2011 the provisional-measures judge (voorzieningenrechter) of the Regional Court (rechtbank) of Amsterdam ruled that the intended eviction of the Schijnheilig squat was lawful.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 1 July 2011 a message on the website of Independent Media Centre (www.indymedia.nl) called on sympathisers to gather outside the Schijnheilig squat on 5 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The message on www.indymedia.nl called on sympathisers to gather outside the Schijnheilig squat on 5 July 2011 \"to make a spectacular statement protesting against an empty city and call for 'free space', for places where creativity and not money rules\".", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The message on www.indymedia.nl stated: \"We expect that the Mobile Unit [Mobiele Eenheid; a special operations unit of the police] will arrive at 6 a.m.\"", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The message on www.indymedia.nl stated: \"The protest (manifestatie) will continue until the Mobile Unit come to their senses\".", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 2 July 2011 a call for protest in the form of \"poetry, singing, dancing, screaming, jumping [or] sending an angry letter\" appeared on another website.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 5 July 2011, at around 6 a.m., some 150 people gathered in front of and around the Schijnheilig squat at Passeerdersgracht in Amsterdam.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Seats and tables had been positioned to block the street in front of the Schijnheilig squat on 5 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Some participants in the gathering on 5 July 2011 had air mattresses with them.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Loud music was being played from the rooftop of a building opposite the Schijnheilig squat during the gathering on 5 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Banners had been placed on various nearby public buildings and bridges with texts such as \"Squatting's here to stay\" and \"Van der Laan is going down\" (\"Van der Laan gaat eraan\"), referring to Mr Eberhard van der Laan, then Mayor of Amsterdam.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "During the gathering on 5 July 2011 the participants danced, played instruments, stood close and talked to each other, and chanted slogans such as \"Squatting's here to stay\" and \"You Government puppets\".", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Most of the participants in the gathering on 5 July 2011 were recognisable and wore plain clothes.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Some of the participants in the gathering on 5 July 2011 were dressed up in costumes or wedding dresses.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "Some of the participants in the gathering on 5 July 2011 wore sunglasses, balaclavas or other masks or cloths to cover their faces.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "At 6.57 a.m. on 5 July 2011 the Police Commissioner ordered those present in front of the Schijnheilig squat to disperse and leave Passeerdersgracht in the direction of an adjacent street.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The participants in the gathering on 5 July 2011 failed to obey the Police Commissioner's order to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "After issuing two additional orders to disperse, the Police Commissioner instructed the Mobile Unit (Mobiele Eenheid, a special operations unit of the police) to carry out a charge.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Using protective shields and wielding truncheons, the Mobile Unit advanced and cleared the area in front of the Schijnheilig squat.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Items such as beer bottles and a beer crate were thrown at the police during the events on 5 July 2011 at Passeerdersgracht.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "Several smoke bombs were used during the events on 5 July 2011 at Passeerdersgracht.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "There was a small fire during the events on 5 July 2011 at Passeerdersgracht.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "At 8.37 a.m. on 5 July 2011 the Police Commissioner informed the participants that they were all under arrest.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "A total of 138 persons, including the applicants, were arrested on 5 July 2011 on suspicion of participating in an unlawful gathering or otherwise disturbing public order, prohibited and made punishable by the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (Algemene Plaatselijke Verordening; the APV).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The 138 arrested persons, including the applicants, were arraigned before the assistant public prosecutor on 5 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The 138 arrested persons, including the applicants, were released on the afternoon of 5 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Six other persons were arrested on 5 July 2011, placed in police custody and prosecuted on suspicion of publicly committing acts of violence in concert against persons or property under Article 141 of the Dutch Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The events on Passeerdersgracht and Prinsengracht on 5 July 2011 were recorded by the police in two videos.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The police video recordings of the events on Passeerdersgracht and Prinsengracht were viewed during the hearing in the appeal proceedings before the Amsterdam Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The police video recordings of the events on Passeerdersgracht and Prinsengracht were submitted by the applicants to the Court.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. EVENTS BEFORE AND DURING THE PROTEST"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On an unspecified date, the applicants were summonsed to appear before the limited jurisdiction judge (kantonrechter) of the Amsterdam Regional Court on suspicion of participating in an unlawful gathering or otherwise disturbing public order, contrary to section 2.2(1) of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On an unspecified date, the applicants were summonsed to appear before the limited jurisdiction judge (kantonrechter) of the Amsterdam Regional Court on suspicion of failing to comply with a police order to disperse, contrary to section 2.2(3) of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "By separate judgments of 14 June 2013 the limited jurisdiction judge (kantonrechter) of the Amsterdam Regional Court found proven that the applicants had failed to comply with police orders to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "By separate judgments of 14 June 2013 the limited jurisdiction judge (kantonrechter) of the Amsterdam Regional Court found not proven that the applicants had participated in an unlawful gathering as referred to in the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge reasoned that according to section 2.2(4) of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV), gatherings that have the character of a demonstration as referred to in the Public Assemblies Act (Wet openbare manifestaties) should be excluded from the scope of section 2.2 of the APV.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge reasoned that a demonstration is about expressing collectively experienced thoughts and wishes in the political or social field.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge was of the opinion that the gathering of the group of persons on 5 July 2011 was initially characterised more as a demonstration as referred to in the Public Assemblies Act than an unlawful gathering entailing disorder in the sense of section 2.2 of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge found that at the outset of the gathering on 5 July 2011 there was no threat of disorder.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge noted that a call had been made beforehand for all sympathisers of the Schijnheilig squat to make a statement against an empty city and in favour of free space.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge noted that the formal record of findings of the Police Commissioner indicated that the atmosphere was somewhat relaxed at the start of the gathering on 5 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge noted that the group of persons at the gathering on 5 July 2011 stayed together almost continuously, sang along with musical instruments, chanted slogans, and performed dances together.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge noted that the public prosecutor stated at the hearing that four demonstrators wore wedding dresses and that their photos were taken by or with the cooperation of the police.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge concluded that at the outset of the gathering on 5 July 2011 there was a demonstration within the meaning of the Public Assemblies Act (Wet openbare manifestaties).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge noted that according to the Public Assemblies Act, the decision on the permissibility of a demonstration lies with the Mayor.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge noted that pursuant to section 7 of the Public Assemblies Act, the Mayor has the power to end or disperse a demonstration in the interest of traffic and to combat and prevent disorder.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge noted that according to Supreme Court case-law (judgment of 17 October 2006), the authority conferred by section 7 of the Public Assemblies Act to end a demonstration cannot be exercised without an order from the Mayor.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge found that it did not appear that the Mayor gave the police commissioner an order to end the demonstration on 5 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge found that it was not possible to deduce from the documents and what was discussed at the hearing that the police order on 5 July 2011 was based on section 7 of the Public Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge concluded that it was not established that the demonstration on 5 July 2011, which had originally been permitted and covered by the Public Assemblies Act, was at a later point in time no longer permitted under that Act.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge concluded that the demonstration on 5 July 2011 must be deemed to have remained permissible under the Public Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The limited jurisdiction judge found that sections 2.2(1) and 2.2(3) of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV) had been inapplicable pursuant to section 2.2(4) of the APV.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The applicants were acquitted by the limited jurisdiction judge of the offence of participating in an unlawful gathering or otherwise disturbing public order.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicants were discharged from prosecution by the limited jurisdiction judge for the offence of failing to comply with police orders to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Public Prosecution Service appealed against the judgments of the limited jurisdiction judge of 14 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "By separate judgments of 31 August 2015 the Court of Appeal (gerechtshof) of Amsterdam quashed the judgments of the Amsterdam Regional Court of 14 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal held that the aim of the gathering on 5 July 2011 had been to seek confrontation with the Mobile Unit (Mobiele Eenheid) and to physically prevent the eviction of the Schijnheilig squat.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal held that the gathering on 5 July 2011 could not be regarded as a demonstration in the sense of the Public Assemblies Act because its aim had been to seek confrontation with the Mobile Unit and to physically prevent the eviction.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal held that the gathering on 5 July 2011 had fallen within the scope of section 2.2 of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal held that public order had been disturbed within the meaning of section 2.2(1) of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV) on 5 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that the gathering on 5 July 2011 was occasioned by the preannounced eviction of the Schijnheilig squat.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that after the police sent a letter announcing the eviction, a call was placed on the Internet on the website indymedia.nl stating that 'the protest will continue until the Mobile Unit come to their senses'.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that the organiser of the gathering on 5 July 2011 did not notify the Mayor in writing at least twenty-four hours before the start of the gathering, as required.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that video camera images of 5 July 2011 show that smoke bombs were used in front of the Schijnheilig squat.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that video camera images of 5 July 2011 show that barricades were raised in front of the Schijnheilig squat by putting tables and chairs on the road, blocking the public road and access to the buildings to be cleared.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that several people brought air mattresses to the gathering on 5 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that some persons at the gathering on 5 July 2011 were masked or clad in balaclavas.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal considered that bringing air mattresses to the gathering served the purpose of protecting oneself against truncheons in the event of a confrontation with the Mobile Unit.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal considered that wearing masks or balaclavas at the gathering served the purpose of protecting oneself against recognition in the event of a confrontation with the Mobile Unit.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that the Police Commissioner explained at the hearing that the gathering on Passeerdersgracht, the blocked public road and barricaded access to the premises made the eviction impossible.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal found that the acts as charged took place on 5 July 2011 at Passeerdersgracht in Amsterdam on the side of the Schijnheilig squat and also on the opposite side of the canal.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that camera images show that smoke bombs were also used on the opposite side of the canal from the Schijnheilig squat on 5 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that people dressed in dark clothing and wearing face coverings were found in the street and on the adjoining waterfront on the opposite side of the canal on 5 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that the Police Commissioner stated in his formal record of findings that on the other side of the premises to be vacated, a person was playing amplified music which made an infernal racket and was apparently intended to strengthen the group of persons in front of the premises.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal held that the facts on 5 July 2011 led to a disturbance of public order on the entire Passeerdersgracht within the meaning of section 2.2(1) of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that camera images show that a large group of people lingered at Passeerdersgracht on 5 July 2011 and that within this group the above-mentioned acts were taking place.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that the Police Commissioner stated in his formal record of findings that the group of people stayed connected with each other almost continuously on 5 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that the Police Commissioner described in his formal record that he ordered the group three times to remove themselves in the direction of Prinsengracht.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that the group reacted to the Police Commissioner's orders en masse by yelling and screaming, and that bottles were thrown in the direction of the Police Commissioner's vehicle.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that the people in the group did not comply with the Police Commissioner's orders to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that the Police Commissioner ordered the Mobile Unit to carry out a charge that drove the group of persons from Passeerdersgracht to Prinsengracht.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that when the police drove the group to Prinsengracht, a paint bomb was thrown from the group in the direction of the line formed by the Mobile Unit.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that various objects, such as sticks and bottles, were thrown at the police officers when the group was driven to Prinsengracht.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that several people in the group made kicking motions towards the police officers in the line formation when the group was driven to Prinsengracht.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that the Police Commissioner stated at the appeal hearing that it had been possible for persons from the group to leave the group but that it had been impossible for them to return to it afterwards.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that the persons in the group had plenty of time to leave the group before their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that the Police Commissioner stated that some persons had moved towards the Mobile Unit vehicles with the apparent intention of leaving, but that the majority of the group had stayed together.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal held that before the persons from the group were arrested there had been time and opportunity to leave the group that had been driven together.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal held that the group of persons was not created by the action of the police, but the group stayed together voluntarily.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal noted that the footage shows that at the moment of arrest, the group were sitting on the ground with their arms interlocked.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal found it proven that the applicants had participated in an unlawful gathering or otherwise disturbed public order in breach of section 2.2(1) of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal found it proven that the applicants had failed to comply with a police order to disperse in breach of section 2.2(3) of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Amsterdam Court of Appeal sentenced each applicant to two fines of 50 euros (EUR), each fine to be replaced by one day's detention in the event of non-payment.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The applicants lodged appeals on points of law with the Supreme Court (Hoge Raad) against the judgments of the Amsterdam Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "In their appeals on points of law to the Supreme Court, the applicants submitted that the Amsterdam Court of Appeal had failed to recognise that the protest had been a \"peaceful assembly\" within the meaning of Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "In their appeals on points of law to the Supreme Court, the applicants submitted that the protest had fallen within the scope of the Public Assemblies Act (Wet openbare manifestaties).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "In their appeals on points of law to the Supreme Court, the applicants referred to case-law of the Court, including Cisse v. France, no. 51346/99, 9 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "In their appeals on points of law to the Supreme Court, the applicants referred to the OSCE/Venice Commission Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Advocate General to the Supreme Court recommended in his advisory opinion that the applicants' appeals on points of law be dismissed.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Advocate General noted that the boundary between a gathering for the purpose of expression of opinion and a gathering as a coercive measure (dwangmaatregel) cannot always be drawn sharply.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Advocate General noted that a demonstration of a certain size can be accompanied by some coercion (dwang), while coercion can be partly a goal of a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Advocate General noted that freedom of assembly must be regarded as one of the foundations of a democratic society and may not be interpreted restrictively according to the Court.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Advocate General noted that the scope of Article 11 of the Convention includes all kinds of gatherings, including demonstrations and blockades.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Advocate General noted that the mere circumstance that there is a risk of disturbances during a demonstration does not mean that the protection of Article 11 of the Convention will lapse.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Advocate General noted that the protection of Article 11 of the Convention does not lapse if some participants in the demonstration have violent intentions or if marginal or sporadic violent or other criminal behaviour is displayed.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Advocate General noted that according to settled case-law of the Court, the notion of 'peaceful assembly' does not include 'a demonstration where the organizers and participants have violent intentions which result in public disorder'.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The Advocate General noted that the Explanatory Memorandum to the Bill which became the Public Assemblies Act states that actions not primarily intended for the expression of a common opinion but predominantly involving the application of de facto coercion are not demonstrations within the meaning of that Act.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The Advocate General considered that the Amsterdam Court of Appeal did not err in law with regard to the concept of 'demonstration' within the meaning of the Public Assemblies Act when it ruled that the purpose of the gathering had been to seek a confrontation with the Mobile Unit and to physically prevent the eviction.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The Advocate General considered that the Amsterdam Court of Appeal did not fail to acknowledge the treaty-based frame of reference (verdragsrechtelijk toetsingskader) in its ruling.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Advocate General noted that the call to gather had stated that the event would continue until the Mobile Unit came to their senses, and that the organisers had failed to send a timely notification pursuant to section 2.32 of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Advocate General noted that video footage showed that smoke bombs were being thrown, a fire was being lit and barricades in the form of tables and chairs had been erected in front of the Schijnheilig squat before the Mobile Unit proceeded to carrying out charges.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Advocate General noted that preparations had been made for a confrontation with the Mobile Unit, such as bringing air mattresses and wearing balaclavas and masks.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The Advocate General considered that the Amsterdam Court of Appeal's ruling that the primary purpose of the gathering had been to hinder the eviction of the Schijnheilig squat was not incomprehensible (niet onbegrijpelijk).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The Advocate General considered that the mere circumstance that the event also bore characteristics of a demonstration did not detract from the Amsterdam Court of Appeal's ruling.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Advocate General considered that the Amsterdam Court of Appeal's judgment was not incomprehensible and was sufficiently reasoned (toereikend gemotiveerd) and, being interwoven with assessments of a factual nature, could not be further reviewed in an appeal on points of law.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Advocate General noted that the explanatory note to section 2.2 of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV) clarifies that the prohibitions in section 2.2 of the APV do not apply to demonstrations within the meaning of the Public Assemblies Act, and that if the Public Assemblies Act is inapplicable, the prohibitions in section 2.2 of the APV do apply.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The Advocate General considered that given that the Amsterdam Court of Appeal's judgment that there had been no demonstration within the meaning of the Public Assemblies Act did not err in law and was not incomprehensible, the same could be said of the consideration that the exception in section 2.2(4) of the APV did not apply.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "By separate judgments of 11 April 2017 the Supreme Court (Hoge Raad) dismissed the applicants' appeals on points of law.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "By its judgments of 11 April 2017 the Supreme Court upheld the judgments of the Amsterdam Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The Supreme Court held that the Amsterdam Court of Appeal had ruled not incomprehensibly that the aim of the gathering was to seek a confrontation with the Mobile Unit and to physically prevent the eviction.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The Supreme Court held that the Amsterdam Court of Appeal's ruling implied that the gathering did not primarily have the character of common expression of opinion, but was aimed at preventing the police from proceeding with the announced eviction by means of de facto coercion.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The Supreme Court held that the Amsterdam Court of Appeal did not err in law and was not incomprehensible in ruling that there was no question of a demonstration within the meaning of the Public Assemblies Act and that the conduct of those present fell within the scope of section 2.2 of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The Supreme Court held that the applicants' argument concerning a broad interpretation of the right to freedom of assembly as protected by Article 11 of the Convention did not necessitate a different conclusion.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The Supreme Court noted that according to settled case-law of the Court, Article 11 of the Convention does not protect 'a demonstration where the organizers and participants have violent intentions', citing Schwabe and M.G. v. Germany, nos. 8080/08 and 8577/08, ECHR 2011 (extracts).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Article 9(1) of the Constitution of the Kingdom of the Netherlands (Grondwet) provides that the right of assembly (vergadering) and demonstration (betoging) shall be recognised, without prejudice to the responsibility of everyone under the law.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. CONSTITUTION OF THE KINGDOM OF THE NETHERLANDS"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Article 9(2) of the Constitution of the Kingdom of the Netherlands provides that rules to protect health, in the interest of traffic, and to combat or prevent disorder may be laid down by Act of Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. CONSTITUTION OF THE KINGDOM OF THE NETHERLANDS"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Article 9 of the Constitution of the Kingdom of the Netherlands does not define the scope of the right to assembly and demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. CONSTITUTION OF THE KINGDOM OF THE NETHERLANDS"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "At the time of the preparation of the 1983 constitutional amendment, the question was raised to what extent it would be acceptable that forms of expression in the context of a demonstration amount to coercion.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. CONSTITUTION OF THE KINGDOM OF THE NETHERLANDS"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The Memorandum in Reply (Memorie van Antwoord) to the Bill which amended Article 9 of the Constitution notes that the notion of a 'demonstration' within the meaning of Article 9 of the Constitution does not include 'actions of which the quality of common expression of opinion has faded into the background and which are in the nature of coercive measures (dwangmaatregelen) against the Government or against third parties, as may be the case with blockades of roads and waterways' (Parliamentary Documents, Lower House of Parliament 1976/77, 13 872, no. 7, p. 33).", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. CONSTITUTION OF THE KINGDOM OF THE NETHERLANDS"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Article 93 of the Constitution of the Kingdom of the Netherlands provides that the Convention forms part of domestic law.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. CONSTITUTION OF THE KINGDOM OF THE NETHERLANDS"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Pursuant to Article 94 of the Constitution of the Kingdom of the Netherlands, the provisions of the Convention take precedence over domestic statutory rules in the event of a conflict.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. CONSTITUTION OF THE KINGDOM OF THE NETHERLANDS"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Dutch courts are expected, as far as is possible, to interpret and apply domestic law in such a way that the State meets its treaty obligations (verdragsconforme uitleg), as established for example in the Supreme Court judgment of 16 November 1990, ECLI:NL:HR:1990:ZC0044.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. CONSTITUTION OF THE KINGDOM OF THE NETHERLANDS"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "The Public Assemblies Act (Wet openbare manifestaties) is an act laid down by Parliament that regulates the exercise of and restrictions on the freedom of religion under Article 6 of the Constitution of the Kingdom of the Netherlands.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The Public Assemblies Act (Wet openbare manifestaties) regulates the exercise of and restrictions on the right of assembly and demonstration under Article 9 of the Constitution of the Kingdom of the Netherlands.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Under section 2 of the Public Assemblies Act, the power to restrict the rights of freedom of religion and assembly and demonstration as conferred on public authorities may be used only to protect health, in the interest of traffic and to combat or prevent disorder.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Under section 6 of the Public Assemblies Act, the Mayor may issue instructions which organisers of or participants in an assembly or demonstration must observe.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Under section 7 of the Public Assemblies Act, the Mayor may order the organisers or participants to end the assembly or demonstration forthwith and disperse if one of the interests referred to in section 2 of the Public Assemblies Act so requires.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "Under section 11 of the Public Assemblies Act, the violation of the provisions of the Act is punishable by a term of detention not exceeding two months or a second-category fine.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the Bill which became the Public Assemblies Act (Parliamentary Documents, Lower House of Parliament 1985/86, 19 427, no. 3, p. 8) states that events within the meaning of the proposed Act include assemblies and demonstrations, which share the common feature of being intended for more or less collectively expressed thoughts, feelings or beliefs.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the Bill which became the Public Assemblies Act states that whereas the main aim of an assembly is internal opinion- and decision-making, a demonstration is about expressing thoughts or wishes on matters of a political or social nature which are shared by those taking part.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the Bill which became the Public Assemblies Act states that actions not primarily intended for the expression of a common opinion but predominantly involving the application of de facto coercion (feitelijke dwang) are not demonstrations within the meaning of the Act, as may be the case with blockades of roads and waterways, unlawful gatherings, riots and so forth.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The Supreme Court held in a judgment of 17 October 2006 (ECLI:NL:HR:2006:AU6741) that the power under section 7 of the Public Assemblies Act to end a demonstration could not be exercised by a police officer without a specific instruction to that effect given by the Mayor.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES ACT"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Section 2.2(1) of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV) of 2008 prohibits, on or near the public road or in a building or vessel accessible to the public, participating in an unlawful gathering (samenscholing), defined in section 2.1(4) as 'a gathering of people who assume a threatening attitude, have malicious intentions or appear threatening', or, either as a member of a group or individually, imposing oneself unnecessarily, harassing others, fighting or otherwise disturbing public order (de orde verstoren).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "III. AMSTERDAM GENERAL MUNICIPAL BY-LAW OF 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "Section 2.2(3) of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV) of 2008 requires a person who is present on or near the public road at an event that attracts members of the public or at any occurrence that causes or is likely to cause disturbances (ongeregeldheden), or who is moving towards that event or occurrence, to immediately obey an order given by a police officer to move away in a given direction.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "III. AMSTERDAM GENERAL MUNICIPAL BY-LAW OF 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "Section 2.2(4) of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV) of 2008 provides that the prohibitions in section 2.2 do not apply to demonstrations and assemblies within the meaning of the Public Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "III. AMSTERDAM GENERAL MUNICIPAL BY-LAW OF 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV) of 2008 was laid down by the local council (gemeenteraad).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "III. AMSTERDAM GENERAL MUNICIPAL BY-LAW OF 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "An explanatory note to section 2.2 of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV) provides that regulation of demonstrations does not fall within the competence of the municipal legislature and that gatherings to which the Public Assemblies Act applies are excluded by section 2.2(4) of the APV.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "III. AMSTERDAM GENERAL MUNICIPAL BY-LAW OF 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The explanatory note to section 2.2 of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV) provides that the Mayor must base any measures regarding demonstrations on the Public Assemblies Act, which grants the Mayor powers to take measures in the event of disturbances and contains penal provisions in this regard.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "III. AMSTERDAM GENERAL MUNICIPAL BY-LAW OF 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "A breach of section 2.2(1) of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV) is a minor offence under section 154 of the Municipality Act.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "III. AMSTERDAM GENERAL MUNICIPAL BY-LAW OF 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "A breach of section 2.2(3) of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV) is a minor offence under section 154 of the Municipality Act.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "III. AMSTERDAM GENERAL MUNICIPAL BY-LAW OF 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "A breach of section 2.2(1) or section 2.2(3) of the Amsterdam general municipal by-law (APV) is punishable by a term of imprisonment not exceeding three months or a second-category fine under section 6.1 of the APV.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "III. AMSTERDAM GENERAL MUNICIPAL BY-LAW OF 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017rev, 15 July 2020, 3rd edition) were prepared by the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) in consultation with the European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "IV. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "Section B, paragraph 86 of the OSCE/ODIHR Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (3rd edition) provides that all assemblies shall be presumed to be peaceful in the absence of convincing evidence that the organisers and/or a significant number of participants intend to use, advocate or incite imminent violence.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "IV. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "Section B, paragraph 87 of the OSCE/ODIHR Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (3rd edition) provides that law enforcement officials must differentiate between peaceful and non-peaceful participants since only those who themselves take part in violence forfeit the legal guarantee of their right to assemble.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "IV. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "Section B, paragraph 87 of the OSCE/ODIHR Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly (3rd edition) provides that state intervention should target individual wrongdoers, rather than all participants more generally, unless that is impossible due to the massive nature of the violence committed.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "IV. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "General Comment No. 37 on the right of peaceful assembly (Article 21) of the Human Rights Committee, adopted at its 129th session (29 June–24 July 2020, UN Doc. CCPR/C/GC/37), provides that the use of disguises should not in itself be deemed to signify violent intent (at point 60).", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "IV. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F021", "F023", "F024", "F027", "F032", "F033", "F036", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F068", "F069", "F167"], "interference": ["F036", "F037", "F043", "F044", "F102", "F103", "F104", "F129", "F130"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F032", "F033", "F034", "F071", "F086", "F090", "F094"], "necessity": ["F129", "F130", "F131", "F132", "F133", "F134", "F135"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F001", "F013", "F014", "F017", "F019", "F021", "F023", "F027", "F032", "F033", "F036", "F039", "F068"], "interference": ["F036", "F102", "F103", "F104", "F129", "F130"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F032", "F033", "F071"], "necessity": ["F129", "F131", "F133", "F134", "F135"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F017", "F019", "F036", "F039", "F068", "F102", "F103", "F104", "F129", "F134", "F135"]}} {"case_name": "case_395", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_396", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_397", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_399", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1978.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1958.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The first applicant lives in Kyiv.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The second applicant lives in Lviv.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants were represented by Ms Y. Zakrevska, a lawyer practising in Kyiv.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, most recently Mr I. Lishchyna, of the Ministry of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "At the material time, the first applicant, Mr I. Lutsenko, was a well-known journalist.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "At the material time, Mr I. Lutsenko was the leader of a civic organisation called Protect the Old Kyiv.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The aim of the civic organisation Protect the Old Kyiv was to preserve the historical architecture of Kyiv.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Mr I. Lutsenko took an active part in the Maidan protests.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 22 December 2013, the council of the Maidan People's Union gave Mr I. Lutsenko the position of deputy chief supervisor in charge of order within the protesters' camp on Maidan Nezalezhnosti.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "In his capacity as deputy chief supervisor in charge of order within the protesters' camp on Maidan Nezalezhnosti, Mr I. Lutsenko helped to take care of wounded protesters by transporting them to various medical facilities.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The second applicant's brother was Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Mr Y. Verbytskyy was originally from Lviv.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "At the material time, Mr Y. Verbytskyy worked as a seismologist at the Karpatske Department of the Institute of Geophysics in Lviv.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "In January 2014, Mr Y. Verbytskyy came to Kyiv and took part in the Maidan protests.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In the early hours of 21 January 2014, Mr Y. Verbytskyy's eye was injured during a clash between protesters and the police.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "At about 3.45 a.m. on 21 January 2014, Mr I. Lutsenko took Mr Y. Verbytskyy to a hospital.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to a copy of a police record submitted by the Government, at 4.33 a.m. on 21 January 2014 a doctor from the hospital informed the police that Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy had been abducted from the hospital by several persons in plain clothes.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the relevant investigation files, the abductors used force against Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The first applicant, Mr I. Lutsenko, was kicked in the face by the abductors, and consequently two of his teeth were broken.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy were placed in a vehicle by the abductors and taken to a remote area.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy were beaten and ill-treated by the abductors in a remote area.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 21 January 2014, the outside temperature in Kyiv was around -10°C.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to information provided by the first applicant and information contained in the investigation files, Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy were taken to a garage after being abducted.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "In the garage, Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy were questioned by unidentified Russian-speaking individuals about their involvement in the Maidan protests.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "During the questioning in the garage, Mr I. Lutsenko answered the questions in Russian.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "During the questioning in the garage, Mr Y. Verbytskyy answered the questions in Ukrainian.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "During the questioning in the garage, both Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy were subjected to repeated beatings and other forms of ill-treatment over the course of several hours.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The abductors put a plastic bag over Mr I. Lutsenko's head and tied it with duct tape.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "A small hole was made in the plastic bag placed over Mr I. Lutsenko's head so that he could breathe.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The abductors tied Mr I. Lutsenko's hands and legs with duct tape and put him on the floor.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "While Mr I. Lutsenko was lying on his left side, the abductors repeatedly kicked and punched him in the face, head, back, thighs, ankles and hands, particularly aiming to hit his joints.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Mr I. Lutsenko was beaten with wooden and metal sticks by the abductors.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "During the beating, Mr I. Lutsenko was threatened with death on a number of occasions.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to a forensic medical report dated 20 February 2014, established by an expert hired by the State, Mr I. Lutsenko had numerous haematomas and contusions on the trunk of his body, limbs, head and face.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The forensic medical report dated 20 February 2014 classified Mr I. Lutsenko's injuries as minor.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "At about 4.30 a.m. on 21 January 2014, a doctor from the hospital informed the police of the abduction of Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "At about 9.30 a.m. on 21 January 2014, Mr I. Lutsenko's partner lodged a complaint with the police regarding his disappearance.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "At about 6 p.m. on 21 January 2014, Mr I. Lutsenko was taken to a public road near a village in the Boryspil District, about 50 kilometres away from central Kyiv, and was left there.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "From the public road near a village in the Boryspil District, Mr I. Lutsenko managed to get help.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Subsequently after being left on the public road, Mr I. Lutsenko was questioned by a police officer concerning the events of his abduction and ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Mr Y. Verbytskyy's wife lodged a complaint with the police regarding his abduction.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 21 January 2014, a criminal investigation was launched into Mr Y. Verbytskyy's wife's complaint regarding his abduction.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 22 January 2014, Mr Y. Verbytskyy's body was found in a forest in the Boryspil District.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "A preliminary medical report recorded that Mr Y. Verbytskyy had died of hypothermia.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "Multiple injuries were found on the trunk of Mr Y. Verbytskyy's body, limbs, head and face.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "According to a forensic medical report of 12 March 2014, a copy of which was submitted to the Court, Mr Y. Verbytskyy's injuries included numerous haematomas all over the trunk of his body, limbs, head and face.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "According to the forensic medical report of 12 March 2014, Mr Y. Verbytskyy's injuries included fractured bones and ribs.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "According to the forensic medical report of 12 March 2014, Mr Y. Verbytskyy's injuries included internal bleeding.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "According to the forensic medical report of 12 March 2014, it was considered that Mr Y. Verbytskyy had been hit by blunt objects at least thirty times.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The forensic medical report of 12 March 2014 confirmed that Mr Y. Verbytskyy had died of hypothermia.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PRINCIPLE EVENTS AT ISSUE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 22 January 2014, the police started a criminal investigation into the death of Mr Y. Verbytskyy, which was classified as murder.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The criminal investigation into Mr Y. Verbytskyy's abduction was joined to the criminal investigation into his death.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The second applicant took part in the criminal proceedings into Mr Y. Verbytskyy's death as a victim.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The second applicant was questioned regarding the events surrounding Mr Y. Verbytskyy's abduction and death.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The second applicant took part in other investigative actions in the criminal proceedings into Mr Y. Verbytskyy's death.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 22 January 2014, the police started a criminal investigation into the first applicant Mr I. Lutsenko's abduction.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The criminal investigation into Mr I. Lutsenko's abduction was eventually merged with the investigation into the murder of Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 27 January 2014, Mr I. Lutsenko was questioned by the police about the events of his abduction and ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Mr I. Lutsenko stated that while he had been in the hands of his abductors, he had heard Mr Y. Verbytskyy being beaten more severely after the abductors had found out that he was originally from Lviv.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Mr I. Lutsenko stated that those beating Mr Y. Verbytskyy had repeatedly called him 'banderovets' (бандеровець).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Mr I. Lutsenko stated that he heard the abductors discussing the possibility of taking him and Mr Y. Verbytskyy to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "According to the case material, including letters from the Prosecutor General's Office and the Ministry of Internal Affairs dated 4 February, 19 May, 15 June and 29 November 2016, between February and April 2014 thirteen individuals were identified as suspects in the investigation into the abduction and killing of Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Two of the thirteen suspects, identified as T. and M., were suspected of having taken part in the abduction of Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "T. and M. were alleged to have been the drivers of the vehicles used in the abduction of Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "According to official notifications of suspicion issued by investigators from the Chief Investigative Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs on 24 July 2014 informing T. that he was under suspicion, Mr I. Lutsenko's and Mr Y. Verbytskyy's abduction and ill-treatment were part of the authorities' attempt to suppress the Maidan protests.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "According to official notifications of suspicion issued by investigators from the Chief Investigative Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs on 28 July 2014 informing M. that he was under suspicion, Mr I. Lutsenko's and Mr Y. Verbytskyy's abduction and ill-treatment were part of the authorities' attempt to suppress the Maidan protests.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "According to the official notifications of suspicion, different private individuals, including those with a criminal background, had been hired by unidentified law-enforcement officials to attack and intimidate the Maidan protesters.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "According to the official notifications of suspicion, the group of suspects who had allegedly abducted and tortured Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy had been organised and directed by N., Ch. and Z.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "According to the official notifications of suspicion, N., Ch. and Z. had acted on the instructions of unidentified representatives of State bodies.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "According to the official notifications of suspicion, a number of other unidentified individuals were said to have participated in the ill-treatment of Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "According to the official notifications of suspicion, having tortured Mr Y. Verbytskyy in the garage and discovered that he was from Lviv, the suspects and other unknown individuals took him to an isolated forest.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "According to the official notifications of suspicion, the suspects and other unknown individuals beat Mr Y. Verbytskyy in the isolated forest with the aim of killing him.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "According to the official notifications of suspicion, the suspects considered Mr Y. Verbytskyy to be 'a representative of the most radical part of Western Ukraine, rallying against the ruling party and senior government officials.'", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "According to the official notifications of suspicion, the suspects left Mr Y. Verbytskyy in the forest, exposed to freezing temperatures, without any outer clothing.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "According to the official notifications of suspicion, the suspects knew that Mr Y. Verbytskyy could not leave the forest area by himself because of his injuries.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "According to the official notifications of suspicion, it was concluded that the suspects had assumed that Mr Y. Verbytskyy would die in the conditions in which he was left and that they had wanted him to die in this way.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "According to the official notifications of suspicion, Mr Y. Verbytskyy's death was classified as murder.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "According to the official notifications of suspicion, a forensic medical report of 3 February 2014 found that, because of his injuries, Mr Y. Verbytskyy had not been able to move freely, which had increased the negative consequences of his exposure to freezing temperatures, ultimately resulting in his death.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "No copy of the forensic medical report of 3 February 2014 has been submitted to the Court.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The trial of M. has been ongoing before the Pecherskyy District Court in Kyiv since June 2015.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Proceedings concerning the remaining twelve suspects, including T., were suspended because their whereabouts were unknown.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The twelve suspects whose proceedings were suspended were put on a wanted list.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "According to the Ministry of Internal Affairs' letter of 29 November 2016, one of the suspects was located in Russia, but his extradition was refused by the Russian authorities.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The whereabouts of the other suspects who absconded were unknown.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "According to the Government, in the course of the investigations into Mr I. Lutsenko's and Mr Y. Verbytskyy's abduction and the latter's murder, over 100 witnesses, suspects and victims were questioned.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "According to the Government, in the course of the investigations into Mr I. Lutsenko's and Mr Y. Verbytskyy's abduction and the latter's murder, searches and forensic examinations were performed.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "According to the Government, the first applicant Mr I. Lutsenko took an active part in the investigations and made no complaints at domestic level regarding their effectiveness.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Government stated that no further details about the investigations could be provided because this could harm the investigations which were still ongoing, without giving any further information or explanation in that regard.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "In the course of the investigations into the abduction and ill-treatment of Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy and the latter's murder, it was established that between 12 and 28 January 2014 Mr I. Lutsenko's telephone conversations had been intercepted by the police as part of an investigation in another case relating to the Maidan protests.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "According to a copy of the extract from the official Ukrainian electronic database of criminal proceedings provided by the applicants, the investigators found evidence demonstrating that during the commission of the crimes against Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy the organisers of those crimes maintained permanent contact with the leadership of the Ministry of Internal Affairs.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "According to a copy of the extract from the official Ukrainian electronic database of criminal proceedings provided by the applicants, the investigators found evidence that unidentified police officers shared with the organisers of the abduction of the protesters information concerning Mr I. Lutsenko's telephone conversations and location, which had been obtained in the course of police surveillance operations.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "On 20 August 2014, the police launched a separate investigation into the possible involvement of agents of the police in the crimes committed against Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "According to a letter from the Prosecutor General's Office of 25 November 2016, on an unspecified date two police officers were charged with the unlawful interception of Mr I. Lutsenko's telephone conversations under Article 163 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "According to a letter from the Prosecutor General's Office of 25 November 2016, on an unspecified date two police officers were charged with falsification of official documents under Article 366 § 1 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The case against the two police officers charged with unlawful interception of Mr I. Lutsenko's telephone conversations and falsification of official documents was referred to the Shevchenkivskyy District Court for trial.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "According to information published on the Prosecutor General's Office's dedicated website, the proceedings before the Shevchenkivskyy District Court were not concluded at the time of the adoption of this judgment.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "According to information published on the Prosecutor General's Office's dedicated website, the relevant proceedings into the crimes against Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy were ongoing at the time of the adoption of this judgment.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. OFFICIAL INVESTIGATIONS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "In March 2014, under the Act on State Support for the Victim Participants in Mass Actions of Civil Protest and their Family Members of 21 February 2014, the State Treasury paid the relatives of Mr Y. Verbytskyy a sum forming part of a total of UAH 243,600 on account of his death.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PAYMENTS TO THE RELATIVES OF MR Y. VERBYTSKYY"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "In February 2015, under the Act on State Support for the Victim Participants in Mass Actions of Civil Protest and their Family Members of 21 February 2014, the State Treasury paid the relatives of Mr Y. Verbytskyy a sum forming part of a total of UAH 243,600 on account of his death.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PAYMENTS TO THE RELATIVES OF MR Y. VERBYTSKYY"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The total amount of UAH 243,600 paid by the State Treasury to the relatives of Mr Y. Verbytskyy was the equivalent of about EUR 13,300 at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PAYMENTS TO THE RELATIVES OF MR Y. VERBYTSKYY"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "Summaries of and extracts from the domestic legal framework and international reports of relevance for the examination of all applications lodged in relation to the Maidan protests and their aftermath, including the present two applications, are to be found in Shmorgunov and Others v. Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Some of the international reports summarised in Shmorgunov and Others v. Ukraine also contain information relating specifically to the events at issue in the present case concerning Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "In its 2015 report, the International Advisory Panel made observations concerning the investigations relating to Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "According to the International Advisory Panel's 2015 report, 13 suspects, most of them titushky, as well as individuals identified as Zubrytskyi and Chebotariov, were served with notices of suspicion on various charges related to the incidents involving Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "According to the International Advisory Panel's 2015 report, two suspects were arrested, notified of suspicion and detained in connection with the incidents involving Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "According to the International Advisory Panel's 2015 report, on 20 August 2014 the indictments against the two arrested suspects were submitted to the court.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "According to the International Advisory Panel's 2015 report, on 16 October 2014 the trial court returned the indictments against the two arrested suspects, citing certain shortcomings in them.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "According to the International Advisory Panel's 2015 report, the prosecutor's appeal against the return of the indictments was due to be heard on 12 December 2014, and the International Advisory Panel had not been informed of the outcome of the appeal.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "According to the International Advisory Panel's 2015 report, the proceedings concerning the remaining 11 suspects in the case involving Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy were suspended, with ten suspects on the wanted list and the eleventh being pursued through international co-operation arrangements.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine published a Briefing Note on Accountability for Killings and Violent Deaths During the Maidan Protest in February 2019.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, all victims from the Maidan protests died or sustained lethal injuries in January-February 2014, when the protests turned violent following the adoption by Parliament of a series of laws that limited freedom of peaceful assembly and expression, and introduced criminal responsibility for extremism and the seizure of administrative buildings.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, the internal troops of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Berkut special riot police units, who had been dispatched to restrain the protestors, were reinforced with civilian counter-protestors, so-called 'titushky', allegedly upon coordination with former senior police officials.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, the internal troops of the Ministry of Internal Affairs were disbanded and reformed into the National Guard.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, the Berkut special riot police units were disbanded shortly after the end of the Maidan protests and reformed into special units within regional police departments.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, five years after the end of the Maidan protests, accountability for the killings and violent deaths of 84 protestors, a man who did not participate in the protests, and 13 law enforcement officers had yet to be achieved.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, the investigation into the killing of 17 protestors and 13 law enforcement officers had still to identify individual perpetrators.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, only one person had been found guilty of unintentional killing of a protestor.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, two persons were found guilty of hooliganism in relation to an incident that resulted in the killing of another protestor.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, the Special Investigations Department identified 14 members of a 'titushky' group as being involved in the abduction, torture and killing of Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, as of February 2019, 12 of the 14 identified members of the 'titushky' group involved in the abduction, torture and killing of Mr Y. Verbytskyy had absconded.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, on 23 April 2014, police detained two male members of the 'titushky' group involved in the abduction, torture and killing of Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, the first of the two detained men owned a garage in the outskirts of Kyiv where both Mr I. Lutsenko and Mr Y. Verbytskyy were tortured and interrogated.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, the first detained man absconded shortly after being indicted on charges of abduction, torture and intentional killing.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, the second detained man, who acted as a lookout, was on trial facing abduction charges as of February 2019.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, on 17 July 2018, after almost three years of hearings on the merits of the case against the second detained man, the judge recused herself from the case.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, as of February 2019, a new judge in the case against the second detained man had still to be appointed.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, on 28 July 2017, Special Investigations Department investigators detained another member of the 'titushky' group on charges of the creation of a criminal organisation, interference with public assemblies, abduction, torture and intentional killing of Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, on 24 July 2018, the third detained member of the 'titushky' group was indicted and his case was sent for trial.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, as of February 2019, the third detained defendant remained in detention while the court heard testimonies of prosecution witnesses, including other members of 'titushky' groups.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, the Department for Organised Crime Investigation indicted two police officers for unlawful surveillance over Mr I. Lutsenko, who was abducted together with Mr Y. Verbytskyy during the Maidan protests.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, the criminal proceeding into the organisation of unlawful surveillance of Mr I. Lutsenko was merged with the case of abduction, torture and killing of Mr Y. Verbytskyy.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, the prosecution for the killing of Mr Y. Verbytskyy was marred by the failure of the Government to ensure the appearance at court of one of the key defendants.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "According to the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine's February 2019 Briefing Note, the failure to ensure the trial without undue delay of the second member of the 'titushky' group was also a concern.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F011", "F017", "F018"], "interference": ["F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F027", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F068", "F069", "F070", "F071", "F072", "F076", "F093", "F094"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": ["F018", "F114", "F115"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F011", "F017"], "interference": ["F020", "F027", "F046", "F068", "F069", "F072", "F093", "F094"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": ["F114", "F115"]}, "list3": ["F011", "F017", "F020", "F027", "F046", "F068", "F072", "F093"]}} {"case_name": "case_400", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_401", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1992.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Lobnya, Moscow Region.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 7-65, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 7-33, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The parties' submissions on the circumstances directly relevant to the present case are set out below.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 6 May 2012 a public demonstration entitled the 'March of Millions' was held in central Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration on 6 May 2012 was held to protest against the allegedly rigged presidential elections.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration on 6 May 2012 had been approved by the Moscow city authorities in the form of a march followed by a meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The approved meeting at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 was supposed to end at 7.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The march on 6 May 2012 was peaceful and held without any disruptions.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "When the marchers arrived at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, it transpired that barriers installed by the police had narrowed the entrance to the meeting venue.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The barriers installed by the police at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 allegedly restricted the space allocated for the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "To control the crowd at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, a police cordon forced the protestors to remain within the barriers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "There were numerous clashes between the police and protesters at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police ordered that the meeting at Bolotnaya Square finish early.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police began to disperse the participants of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "It took the police about two hours to clear the protestors from Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the Moscow city department of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation opened criminal proceedings to investigate suspected acts of mass disorder under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the Moscow city department of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation opened criminal proceedings to investigate suspected violence against the police under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 18 May 2012 the criminal case file was transferred from the Moscow city department of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation to the headquarters of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation for further investigation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 28 May 2012 an investigation was launched into the criminal offence of organising acts of mass disorder under Article 212 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 28 May 2012 the two criminal cases (investigation into mass disorder and violence against police, and investigation into organising acts of mass disorder) were joined.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "At the time of the events of 6 May 2012, the applicant was a first-year student at the faculty of culture studies of the State Academic University for the Humanities.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the applicant took part in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the applicant, he was beaten up by the police as they were dispersing the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "At 4 a.m. on 7 May 2012 the applicant was admitted to the emergency ward of Sklifosovskiy hospital.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "At Sklifosovskiy hospital on 7 May 2012 the applicant was examined by a trauma doctor.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "At Sklifosovskiy hospital on 7 May 2012 the applicant was examined by a neurosurgeon.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The examination at Sklifosovskiy hospital on 7 May 2012 revealed multiple bruises on the applicant's chest.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The examination at Sklifosovskiy hospital on 7 May 2012 revealed multiple bruises on the applicant's spine.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The examination at Sklifosovskiy hospital on 7 May 2012 revealed multiple bruises on the applicant's shoulders.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The examination at Sklifosovskiy hospital on 7 May 2012 revealed multiple bruises on the applicant's knees.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The examination at Sklifosovskiy hospital on 7 May 2012 revealed multiple bruises on the applicant's head.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "After the events of 6 May 2012 the applicant continued to live at his usual address.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "After the events of 6 May 2012 the applicant continued to pursue his studies.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 9 June 2012 the applicant was arrested on suspicion of having participated in acts of mass disorder during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 9 June 2012 the applicant was arrested on suspicion of having used violence against the police during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 9 June 2012 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow ordered the applicant's pre-trial detention until 9 August 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow's detention order of 9 June 2012 referred to the gravity of the charges against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow's detention order of 9 June 2012 referred to information about the applicant's personality.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow noted in its detention order of 9 June 2012 that the applicant's father was a Ukrainian national living in Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow noted in its detention order of 9 June 2012 that the applicant might flee to Ukraine to avoid the investigation and trial.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow concluded in its detention order of 9 June 2012 that the circumstances gave sufficient reasons to believe that the applicant, if at liberty, was likely to continue his criminal activity.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow concluded in its detention order of 9 June 2012 that the circumstances gave sufficient reasons to believe that the applicant, if at liberty, was likely to influence witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow concluded in its detention order of 9 June 2012 that the circumstances gave sufficient reasons to believe that the applicant, if at liberty, was likely to destroy evidence.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow concluded in its detention order of 9 June 2012 that the circumstances gave sufficient reasons to believe that the applicant, if at liberty, was likely to otherwise obstruct the investigation of the criminal case, which was at an initial stage.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 18 June 2012 charges were brought against the applicant under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (participation in acts of mass disorder accompanied by violence).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 18 June 2012 charges were brought against the applicant under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (use of violence against a public official).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicant was accused of having torn a protection helmet off a police officer's head during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 11 July 2012 the Moscow City Court upheld the detention order of 9 June 2012 issued by the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 7 August 2012 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow examined an investigator's request for an extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "At the hearing on 7 August 2012, the applicant requested that an alternative preventive measure be applied pending trial, such as house arrest.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "At the hearing on 7 August 2012, the applicant requested that an alternative preventive measure be applied pending trial, such as a written undertaking not to leave a specified place.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 7 August 2012 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow found that the circumstances that had justified the detention order had not changed and extended the applicant's detention until 6 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 5 September 2012 the Moscow City Court upheld the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow's decision of 7 August 2012 extending the applicant's pre-trial detention until 6 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 2 November 2012 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow authorised a further extension of the applicant's detention until 6 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In its decision of 2 November 2012, the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow reiterated the grounds given in the previous extension orders and stated that the circumstances justifying the detention order had not changed.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 3 December 2012 the Moscow City Court upheld the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow's decision of 2 November 2012 extending the applicant's pre-trial detention until 6 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 21 November 2012 the charges against the applicant were reformulated.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The reformulated charges of 21 November 2012 additionally stated that the applicant had shouted insulting slogans during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The reformulated charges of 21 November 2012 additionally stated that the applicant had used metal barriers to obstruct the police during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The reformulated charges of 21 November 2012 additionally stated that the applicant had at least three times thrown stones and pieces of tarmac at police officers during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The reformulated charges of 21 November 2012 additionally stated that the applicant had once punched a policeman during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The reformulated charges of 21 November 2012 additionally stated that the applicant had grabbed a police officer's uniform during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The reformulated charges of 21 November 2012 additionally stated that the applicant had snatched a protection helmet from a police officer's hands during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 29 November 2012 Police Officer P. identified the applicant during an identification parade as a participant in the mass disorder at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 29 November 2012 Police Officer P. identified the applicant during an identification parade as the person who had twice thrown pieces of tarmac at the police during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 29 November 2012 Police Officer P. identified the applicant during an identification parade as the person who had tried to snatch a protection helmet from a policeman's hands during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Police Officer P. specified during the identification parade on 29 November 2012 that he had not seen whether the applicant had in fact succeeded in snatching the helmet or not.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 7 December 2012 the investigator of the Zamoskvoretskiy Inter-district Investigation Committee of Moscow refused to open a criminal case into allegations made by the applicant that he had been subjected to ill-treatment by the police during his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The investigator of the Zamoskvoretskiy Inter-district Investigation Committee of Moscow considered on 7 December 2012 that the use of force by the police had been justified by the behaviour of the protesters, including the applicant, who had actively resisted their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The investigator of the Zamoskvoretskiy Inter-district Investigation Committee of Moscow considered on 7 December 2012 that the use of force by the police had been justified by the behaviour of the protesters, including the applicant, who had thrown various objects at the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 27 February 2013 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow granted an extension of the applicant's detention until 9 June 2013, essentially on the same grounds as earlier.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "In its decision of 27 February 2013, the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow noted that the applicant's state of health was satisfactory and did not warrant his release.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 27 March 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow's decision of 27 February 2013 extending the applicant's pre-trial detention until 9 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 22 April 2013 the Moscow City Court authorised a further extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention until 6 July 2013.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "In its decision of 22 April 2013, the Moscow City Court noted that even though the applicant and his lawyer had already finished reading the case file, other defendants had not.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "In its decision of 22 April 2013, the Moscow City Court reiterated the grounds given in the previous extension orders and stated that the circumstances justifying the detention order had not changed.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "On 24 May 2013 the applicant's criminal case was transferred to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow for the determination of criminal charges.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 6 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow granted another extension of the applicant's detention until 24 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The detention extension decision of 6 June 2013 by the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow concerned eleven defendants.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "In its decision of 6 June 2013, the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow based its decision on the gravity of the charges against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "In its decision of 6 June 2013, the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that 'the reasons which initially warranted the detention have not changed'.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "In its decision of 6 June 2013, the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that 'no other measures of restraint would secure the aims and goals of the judicial proceedings'.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 2 July 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow's extension order of 6 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On 19 November 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow examined an investigator's request for an extension of detention in respect of nine defendants, including the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "At the hearing on 19 November 2013, the applicant presented a personal guarantee from a member of the State Duma in support of an undertaking by him to appear before the investigating authorities and the courts for the examination of his case.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow did not consider the personal guarantee from a member of the State Duma presented by the applicant at the hearing on 19 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "On 19 November 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow ordered that the applicant and his co-defendants be detained until 24 February 2014 on the grounds of gravity of the charges and the nature of the offences imputable to them.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 17 December 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow's extension order of 19 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "From 20 June 2012 until his conviction the applicant was held in remand prison IZ-77/5 in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The applicant was detained in cell no. 403 of remand prison IZ-77/5 in Moscow until 20 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The applicant was detained in cell no. 403 of remand prison IZ-77/5 in Moscow from 27 May 2013 to 19 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The applicant was detained in cell no. 403 of remand prison IZ-77/5 in Moscow from 29 June 2013 to January 2014.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The applicant was detained in cell no. 12 of remand prison IZ-77/5 in Moscow until 25 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The applicant was detained in cell no. 317 of remand prison IZ-77/5 in Moscow until 27 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The applicant was detained in cell no. 4 of remand prison IZ-77/5 in Moscow until 29 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Cell no. 403 in remand prison IZ-77/5 in Moscow measured 40 sq. m. and had ten sleeping places.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Cell no. 12 in remand prison IZ-77/5 in Moscow measured 6.1 sq. m. and had one sleeping place.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "Cell no. 317 in remand prison IZ-77/5 in Moscow measured 32.9 sq. m. and had eight sleeping places.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Cell no. 4 in remand prison IZ-77/5 in Moscow measured 48 sq. m. and had twelve sleeping places.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The parties agreed that the number of inmates in the cells of remand prison IZ-77/5 had not exceeded the design capacity.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The parties agreed that the size of the cells and the number of detainees had allowed the applicant four square metres of personal space.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The parties agreed that the applicant had had an individual sleeping place in every cell of remand prison IZ-77/5.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "According to the applicant, prison cell no. 403 in remand prison IZ-77/5 measured approximately 7 by 5 metres and housed ten inmates, including himself.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "According to the applicant, cell no. 403 in remand prison IZ-77/5 was inadequately lit.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "According to the applicant, cell no. 403 in remand prison IZ-77/5 was inadequately ventilated.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "According to the applicant, cell no. 403 in remand prison IZ-77/5 was excessively hot in the summer.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "According to the applicant, cell no. 403 in remand prison IZ-77/5 was cold in the winter.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "According to the applicant, the windows in cell no. 403 in remand prison IZ-77/5 were too high to give sufficient light for reading or working with documents.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "According to the applicant, a shower was allowed once a week in remand prison IZ-77/5.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "According to the applicant, the lavatory pan in cell no. 403 in remand prison IZ-77/5 was separated from the living space only by a plastic partition.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "According to the applicant, the bed linen in remand prison IZ-77/5 was old.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "According to the applicant, the beds in remand prison IZ-77/5 were small for a man of his height.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "According to the applicant, outdoor exercise in remand prison IZ-77/5 was limited to one hour per day.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "According to the Government, all of the cells in remand prison IZ-77/5 had sanitary units with wash stands and the necessary furniture.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "According to the Government, the cells in remand prison IZ-77/5 were equipped with ventilation, heating and lighting.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "According to the Government, the state of the sanitary facilities in remand prison IZ-77/5 had been satisfactory.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "According to the Government, the bedding in remand prison IZ-77/5 had been changed once a week.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "According to the Government, the cells in remand prison IZ-77/5 had been disinfected and subjected to pest control regularly.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant had been able to shower once a week in remand prison IZ-77/5.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant had been entitled to one hour of outdoor exercise per day in remand prison IZ-77/5.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The applicant's description of the conditions of detention during his transfer from remand prison IZ-77/5 to court and back, and the Government's submissions in that regard, were identical to those in the case of Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 69-73, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the courthouse"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The applicant submitted that the holding room of the Moscow City Court had been poorly lit.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the courthouse"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The applicant submitted that access to a toilet in the holding room of the Moscow City Court had been limited to once an hour.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the courthouse"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The applicant submitted that he had been required to strip naked during the body search conducted in the holding room of the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the courthouse"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The applicant submitted that he had been required to perform sit-ups during the body search conducted in the holding room of the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the courthouse"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The court proceedings in the applicant's criminal case began on 6 June 2013 in hearing room no. 338 at the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "At the end of July 2013 the court proceedings in the applicant's criminal case moved to hearing room no. 635 at the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The defendants, including the applicant, were held in glass cabins in hearing room no. 338 at the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The defendants, including the applicant, were held in glass cabins in hearing room no. 635 at the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "From mid-September 2013 to the end of 2013 the hearings in the applicant's criminal case continued in hearing room no. 303 at the Nikulinskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "In January and February 2014 the hearings in the applicant's criminal case took place in hearing room no. 410 at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Hearing room no. 303 at the Nikulinskiy District Court of Moscow was equipped with metal cages in which nine defendants (eight from 19 December 2013), including the applicant, sat during the hearings.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Hearing room no. 410 at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow was equipped with metal cages in which nine defendants (eight from 19 December 2013), including the applicant, sat during the hearings.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "For a detailed description of the conditions in the hearing rooms used in the applicant's criminal case, see Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 74-77, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "On 6 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow began a preliminary hearing in a criminal case against ten participants in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The ten participants in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square were charged with participating in acts of mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The ten participants in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square were charged with committing acts of violence against police officers.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "On 18 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow began the trial on the merits in the criminal case against the ten participants in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "On an unspecified date Police Officer T., the alleged victim of the applicant's assault, was examined as a witness in the applicant's criminal trial.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Police Officer T. testified that at some point during the demonstration of 6 May 2012 he had been surrounded by the crowd and subjected to violence.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Police Officer T. stated that the applicant had tried to snatch the protection helmet from his hands during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Police Officer M. was questioned as a witness in the applicant's criminal trial.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Police Officer M. stated that the applicant had shouted something during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Police Officer M. stated that the applicant had thrown a stone or a piece of tarmac at a policeman during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "On 21 February 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found the applicant guilty as charged under Articles 212 § 2 and 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that between 4 p.m. and 8 p.m. on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square, unidentified persons called those present to move outside the agreed meeting venue and to defy the lawful orders of the police.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that unidentified persons called those present at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 to use violence, which led to mass disorder accompanied by the use of violence against public officials in connection with the performance of their duties and the destruction of property.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that on 6 May 2012 at 5 p.m. at the latest the defendants acquired the criminal intent to participate in mass disorder and to use violence against police officers.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that participants of the acts of mass disorder threw pieces of tarmac, stones, sticks and other objects at the police, which hit them on various parts of their body.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that between 5.05 p.m. and 10 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the applicant shouted insulting slogans and used metal barriers to block the police's movement, thus preventing the arrest of the participants in the acts of mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant, acting intentionally, at least three times threw stones and pieces of tarmac at police officers in a targeted manner during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant used violence against an unidentified police officer which did not endanger his life or health during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that unidentified participants in the acts of mass disorder tore a protection helmet off an unidentified police officer's head and punched and kicked him several times in the head and body, while the applicant punched this police officer at least once.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant used violence against Police Officer T. which did not endanger his life or health during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that unidentified participants of the acts of mass disorder intentionally tore off Police Officer T.'s protection helmet, which T. continued to hold in his hands, and punched him in the head and body, whereupon the applicant intentionally grabbed T.'s uniform and snatched the helmet from his hands.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The applicant pleaded not guilty at his criminal trial before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The applicant testified at his criminal trial that he had decided to attend the public gathering on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The applicant testified at his criminal trial that when leaving the Malyy Kamennyy Bridge he saw a lot of police officers equipped with bullet-proof vests, helmets and truncheons, which filled him with indignation.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The applicant testified at his criminal trial that as nothing was happening on the stage, he decided to return, and when leaving the venue he saw the police officers randomly arresting people while hitting them with truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The applicant testified at his criminal trial that he was hit in the back three times with a truncheon.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The applicant testified at his criminal trial that when he saw violent acts by the police, he approached the barriers where other protestors were standing and expressed his indignation.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The applicant testified at his criminal trial that when trying to leave the venue, somebody tore off his shirt.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The applicant testified at his criminal trial that at some point he came across Police Officer T., who was not wearing any helmet.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The applicant testified at his criminal trial that when he tried to leave, police officers ran up to him and started to beat him in the head and body, then arrested him and took him to a police vehicle.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The applicant insisted at his criminal trial that he had committed no acts in respect of Police Officer T., had not seen his helmet and had snatched nothing from his hands.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow considered the defendants' arguments that they were protecting somebody from police officers or happened to be victims of the police's use of force as farfetched and aimed at mitigating their responsibility.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to three years and six months' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The applicant's sentence of three years and six months' imprisonment was calculated on the basis of a three-year prison term under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, partly concurrent with a term of one year under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The applicant's pre-trial detention counted towards his prison sentence.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "The applicant appealed against the judgment of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow of 21 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant complained that he had not used metal barriers to block the police's movement and insisted that he had been standing close to those barriers before the protestors had started to be arrested.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant pointed out that the video records proved that he had not taken Police Officer T.'s helmet and had not used violence against him.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant argued that the first-instance court had not assessed his statements about ill-treatment by the police.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "On 20 June 2014 the Moscow City Court upheld the first-instance judgment of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow of 21 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "The applicant was represented by a lawyer, Mr D., throughout the criminal proceedings at domestic level.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Correspondence with the Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "On 11 January 2013 Mr D. sent the Court an introductory letter containing the outline of the applicant's complaints of ill-treatment by the police on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Correspondence with the Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "On 11 January 2013 Mr D. sent the Court an introductory letter containing the outline of the applicant's complaints of unjustified pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Correspondence with the Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "On 24 January 2013 the Registry of the Court acknowledged receipt of the introductory letter sent by Mr D. on 11 January 2013, registered under application no. 6312/13.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Correspondence with the Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "The applicant was invited to return the completed application form within eight weeks of receipt of the Court's letter of 24 January 2013, but no later than 21 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Correspondence with the Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "No further correspondence had been received from the applicant following the Court's letter of 24 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Correspondence with the Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "On 28 August 2013 the Registry of the Court asked the applicant whether he was still being represented by Mr D.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Correspondence with the Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "On 28 August 2013 the Registry of the Court reminded the applicant to return the completed application form.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Correspondence with the Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "On 18 September 2013 the Court received the completed application form, signed by a different lawyer, Mr Agranovskiy.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Correspondence with the Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "The completed application form received on 18 September 2013 contained complaints about the conditions of detention in the remand prison.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Correspondence with the Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "The completed application form received on 18 September 2013 contained complaints about the conditions of detention in the courtroom.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Correspondence with the Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "The completed application form received on 18 September 2013 contained complaints about the conditions of detention during transfers to and from the prison.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Correspondence with the Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "The completed application form received on 18 September 2013 contained complaints about unjustified pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "G. Correspondence with the Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "Article 212 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the organisation of mass disorder, accompanied by violence, riots, arson, destruction of property, the use of firearms, explosives and explosive devices, as well as armed resistance to a public official, shall be punishable by four to ten years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that participation in the types of mass disorder provided for by Article 212 § 1 shall be punishable by three to eight years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "Article 212 § 3 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the instigation of mass disorder provided for by Article 212 § 1, or the instigation of participation in such acts, or the instigation of violence against citizens, shall be punishable by a restriction of liberty for up to two years, or community service for up to two years, or deprivation of liberty for the same term.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the use of violence which does not endanger life or health, or the threat to use such violence against a public official or his relatives in connection with the performance of his or her duties, shall be punishable by a fine of up to 200,000 roubles or an equivalent of the convicted person's wages for 18 months, or community service for up to five years, or up to five years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law provisions governing pre-trial detention and for the practice of the domestic courts in that matter, see the case of Zherebin v. Russia (no. 51445/09, §§ 16-25, 24 March 2016).", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "For a summary of the applicable regulations and the European standards for prison conditions, see Ananyev and Others v. Russia (nos. 42525/07 and 60800/08, §§ 55 et seq., 10 January 2012).", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F008", "F010", "F024", "F148", "F149", "F150", "F158", "F159", "F014", "F025", "F161", "F162", "F152", "F153"], "interference": ["F036", "F037", "F147", "F169", "F016"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F190", "F191", "F193", "F047", "F048"], "legitimate_aim": ["F014", "F018", "F019", "F191", "F193"], "necessity": ["F147", "F169", "F170", "F152", "F153", "F154", "F155", "F157", "F143", "F144", "F146", "F151", "F173", "F158", "F163", "F168", "F175", "F025", "F026", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F162", "F070", "F071", "F159", "F150", "F148", "F149", "F161", "F166", "F137", "F138", "F139"], "positive_obligation": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F008", "F010", "F024", "F148", "F149", "F150", "F158", "F159"], "interference": ["F036", "F037", "F147", "F169"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F191", "F193"], "legitimate_aim": ["F014", "F018", "F019"], "necessity": ["F147", "F169", "F170", "F152", "F153", "F143", "F154", "F155", "F173", "F025", "F026", "F029", "F030", "F070", "F168", "F175", "F150", "F148", "F161", "F166", "F137"], "positive_obligation": ["F011", "F013", "F014", "F016"]}, "list3": ["F008", "F024", "F010", "F148", "F150", "F147", "F169", "F170", "F143", "F154", "F173", "F025", "F029", "F030", "F070", "F168", "F161", "F137"]}} {"case_name": "case_405", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' particulars are given in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "All applicants were members of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "All applicants were activists of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants attended unauthorised opposition demonstrations organised by the Ictimai Palata group, held in Baku on 14 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants attended unauthorised opposition demonstrations organised by the Ictimai Palata group, held in Baku on 21 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "According to the applicants, the participants in the demonstration of 14 May 2012 were demanding action against corruption.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "According to the applicants, the participants in the demonstration of 14 May 2012 were demanding action against violation of human rights.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "According to the applicants, on 21 May 2012 the demonstration participants were reportedly demanding the release of political prisoners detained in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicants submitted that the demonstrations had been intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicants submitted that the demonstrations had been conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Shortly after the applicants joined the demonstrations, the police started to disperse the protesters.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova), shortly after the police operation to disperse the demonstration of 14 May 2012 had started, around six or seven police officers pushed her so that she almost fell off a ladder.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "1. The first applicant, Ms Mahaddinova"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova), the fourth applicant (Ms Huseynova) held onto her and prevented her from falling off the ladder during the dispersal of the demonstration of 14 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "1. The first applicant, Ms Mahaddinova"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova), a police officer, whom she did not know, slapped her neck during the dispersal of the demonstration of 14 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "1. The first applicant, Ms Mahaddinova"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova), after being slapped on the neck she suddenly became unable to control her physical movements.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "1. The first applicant, Ms Mahaddinova"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova), after being slapped on the neck her vision had temporarily darkened.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "1. The first applicant, Ms Mahaddinova"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova), she felt pain in her right shoulder, right ear and eyes for a long time after the events of 14 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "1. The first applicant, Ms Mahaddinova"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova), she was forcibly put on a bus by the police, together with six or seven other female participants in the demonstration of 14 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "1. The first applicant, Ms Mahaddinova"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova), she was released after being driven around in the city for some time following the demonstration of 14 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "1. The first applicant, Ms Mahaddinova"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova), during the 21 May 2012 demonstration several police officers swore at her.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "1. The first applicant, Ms Mahaddinova"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova), during the 21 May 2012 demonstration several police officers applied physical force to her, as a result of which she had bruises for several months.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "1. The first applicant, Ms Mahaddinova"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova), police officers dragged her by both hands to a car during the 21 May 2012 demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "1. The first applicant, Ms Mahaddinova"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova), she was in pain and shouted during the 21 May 2012 demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "1. The first applicant, Ms Mahaddinova"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova), she was released by the police with the second applicant's (Ms Salimzade's) help during the 21 May 2012 demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "1. The first applicant, Ms Mahaddinova"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Salimzade), on 14 May 2012 the police pushed her and she fell to the ground, sustaining injuries and pain.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "2. The second applicant, Ms Salimzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Salimzade), police officers swore at her during the 14 May 2012 demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "2. The second applicant, Ms Salimzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Salimzade), police officers intentionally touched some parts of her body to humiliate her as a woman during the 14 May 2012 demonstration, including pressing her breasts.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "2. The second applicant, Ms Salimzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Salimzade), on 21 May 2012 police officers pushed her towards a ladder and she fell to the ground, sustaining a contusion.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "2. The second applicant, Ms Salimzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Salimzade), police officers dragged her through the street by her hands during the 21 May 2012 demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "2. The second applicant, Ms Salimzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Salimzade), she lost consciousness during the events of 21 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "2. The second applicant, Ms Salimzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Salimzade) submitted that she had to spend two hours in hospital on 21 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The alleged ill-treatment of the first and second applicants", "2. The second applicant, Ms Salimzade"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the third applicant (Ms Khalilova), during the dispersal of the demonstration of 14 May 2012 a police officer hit her in the knee hard.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The dispersal of the assemblies", "1. The third applicant, Ms Khalilova"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to the third applicant (Ms Khalilova), during the dispersal of the demonstration of 14 May 2012 a police officer swore at her.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The dispersal of the assemblies", "1. The third applicant, Ms Khalilova"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the third applicant (Ms Khalilova), the police forcibly put her on a bus which was being used to remove people from the demonstration venue of 14 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The dispersal of the assemblies", "1. The third applicant, Ms Khalilova"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "According to the third applicant (Ms Khalilova), at the demonstration of 21 May 2012 the same officer who had insulted her on 14 May 2012 insulted her again.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The dispersal of the assemblies", "1. The third applicant, Ms Khalilova"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to the third applicant (Ms Khalilova), she was taken by the police to the Sabail District Police Office following the 21 May 2012 demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The dispersal of the assemblies", "1. The third applicant, Ms Khalilova"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the third applicant (Ms Khalilova), at the Sabail District Police Office a police officer swore at her.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The dispersal of the assemblies", "1. The third applicant, Ms Khalilova"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the fourth applicant (Ms Huseynova), during the 14 May 2012 demonstration a police officer hit her from behind and pushed her aside.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The dispersal of the assemblies", "2. The fourth applicant, Ms Huseynova"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the fourth applicant (Ms Huseynova), as she tried to help the second applicant (Ms Salimzade) during the 14 May 2012 demonstration, police officers grabbed her and pushed her towards a car.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The dispersal of the assemblies", "2. The fourth applicant, Ms Huseynova"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the fourth applicant (Ms Huseynova), when she tried to escape from a police officer during the 14 May 2012 demonstration, the police officer stepped on her foot to stop her.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The dispersal of the assemblies", "2. The fourth applicant, Ms Huseynova"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the fourth applicant (Ms Huseynova), during the 21 May 2012 demonstration she was taken to the Sabail District Police Office in order to stop her participation in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The dispersal of the assemblies", "2. The fourth applicant, Ms Huseynova"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On various dates the applicants complained to the Sabail district prosecutor's office, requesting that a criminal investigation be instituted into their ill-treatment during the dispersal of the assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Sabail district prosecutor's office questioned police officers from the Sabail District Police Office, namely police officers A.R., M.B., and A.J., in respect of the complaints of all of the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Sabail district prosecutor's office questioned police officers S.G. and E.M. in respect of the fourth applicant's (Ms Huseynova's) complaint.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "All questioned police officers stated that they had not applied physical force to any of the participants at the demonstration, including the applicants, but had warned the participants to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicants were questioned by the Sabail district prosecutor's office and reiterated their complaints regarding ill-treatment by the police.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Apart from the third applicant (Ms Khalilova), all applicants submitted video footage and photographs taken during the demonstrations to the Sabail district prosecutor's office.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "A forensic expert was appointed following criminal complaints lodged by the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova) and the second applicant (Ms Salimzade) on 21 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The forensic expert examined the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova) on 25 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The forensic expert examined the second applicant (Ms Salimzade) on 31 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The forensic expert issued a forensic report on 29 May 2012 in respect of the first applicant (Ms Mahaddinova), according to which there were no traces of any injuries on her.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The forensic expert issued a forensic report on 31 May 2012 in respect of the second applicant (Ms Salimzade), according to which there were no traces of any injuries on her.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The third applicant (Ms Khalilova) refused to be examined by the forensic expert, claiming that the signs of ill-treatment had disappeared with the passage of time.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The fourth applicant (Ms Huseynova) refused to be examined by the forensic expert, claiming that the signs of ill-treatment had disappeared with the passage of time.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "By a decision of 1 June 2012, the Sabail district prosecutor's office refused to open a criminal case in respect of the first applicant's (Ms Mahaddinova's) complaint.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "By a decision of 1 June 2012, the Sabail district prosecutor's office refused to open a criminal case in respect of the second applicant's (Ms Salimzade's) complaint.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "By a decision of 30 June 2012, the Sabail district prosecutor's office refused to open a criminal case in respect of the fourth applicant's (Ms Huseynova's) complaint.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "By a decision of 6 July 2012, the Sabail district prosecutor's office refused to open a criminal case in respect of the third applicant's (Ms Khalilova's) complaint.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Sabail district prosecutor's office addressed the applicants' complaints with regard to the demonstration of 14 May 2012 only.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Sabail district prosecutor's office relied on the police officers' statements in refusing to open criminal cases.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Sabail district prosecutor's office relied on the lack of proof that the applicants had in fact been injured in refusing to open criminal cases.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On an unspecified date the applicants lodged a criminal complaint with the Sabail District Court against the refusals to open a criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The applicants complained to the Sabail District Court that the security camera recordings relating to the demonstrations in question had not been reviewed during the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The applicants complained to the Sabail District Court that the witnesses who had observed the police using force against them had not been called or examined during the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicants complained to the Sabail District Court that the investigation had not had regard to the video footage and photographs of the demonstrations they had submitted.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The applicants complained to the Sabail District Court that the police officers questioned by the Sabail district prosecutor's office had been selected randomly, without regard to the officers' personal involvement in the applicants' cases.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The applicants complained to the Sabail District Court that the Sabail district prosecutor's office had not conducted any investigation into the demonstration of 21 May 2012 despite the applicants' specific complaints in this connection.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 23 October 2012 the Sabail District Court, examining the case in the framework of the judicial supervision procedure, dismissed the applicants' complaints.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 23 October 2012 the Sabail District Court found the prosecuting authorities' refusals to open criminal proceedings lawful.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "According to the Sabail District Court's decision of 23 October 2012, the applicants participated in unauthorised assemblies on 14 and 21 May 2012 and were removed from the venue of the unlawful assembly, by being put on buses, for having violated public order and not obeying the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Sabail District Court held on 23 October 2012 that the applicants' claims of having been subjected to attacks and ill-treatment by the police officers concerned had not been proved.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Sabail District Court found on 23 October 2012 that there was no criminal offence in the police officers' actions.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The analysis section of the Sabail District Court's decision of 23 October 2012 addressed the parties' submissions concerning the assembly on 14 May 2012 only.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 5 November 2012 the applicants filed an appeal in which they reiterated their previous complaints.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 16 November 2012 the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the Sabail District Court's decision of 23 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 16 November 2012 the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants' appeal.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Remedies used by the applicants in respect of the alleged ill-treatment and the dispersal of the assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The relevant domestic law concerning the prohibition of ill-treatment is summarised in Mustafa Hajili v. Azerbaijan (no. 42119/12, §§ 26-28, 24 November 2016).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The relevant domestic law concerning freedom of assembly and the organisation and holding of public assemblies is summarised in Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, §§ 27-30, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F005", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F045"], "interference": ["F004", "F005", "F011", "F070"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F004", "F005", "F070"], "legitimate_aim": ["F004", "F005", "F070"], "necessity": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F045", "F060", "F070", "F071", "F072"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F005", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F045"], "interference": ["F004", "F005", "F011", "F070"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F004", "F005", "F070"], "legitimate_aim": ["F004", "F005", "F070"], "necessity": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F045", "F070", "F071", "F072"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F045", "F070"]}} {"case_name": "case_406", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1973.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held on 31 July 2010 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held on 10 March 2013 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 23 July 2010 the organisers, consisting of several members of opposition parties, gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) of the demonstration planned for 31 July 2010.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "It appears that no prior notice was given to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) by the organisers of the demonstration of 10 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Information about the demonstration of 10 March 2013 was disseminated via Facebook or the press.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) refused to authorise the demonstration of 31 July 2010 at the places indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) proposed three alternative locations on the outskirts of Baku for the demonstration of 31 July 2010: a stadium situated in the Binagadi District, a square near Zigh Road in the Khatai District, and the yard of a driving school situated in the 20th habitable area of the Sabail District.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) noted that of the locations proposed by the organisers at which to hold the assembly, the squares were all designated public leisure areas.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) noted that of the locations proposed by the organisers at which to hold the assembly, the other places (apart from the squares) were areas with heavy traffic.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The organisers decided to hold the demonstrations in the centre of Baku despite the Baku City Executive Authority's refusal to authorise the demonstration at the places indicated.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstrations of 31 July 2010 and 10 March 2013 were intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstrations of 31 July 2010 and 10 March 2013 were conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the applicant, the participants of the demonstration of 31 July 2010 were demanding free and fair elections and democratic reforms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the applicant, the participants of the demonstration of 10 March 2013 were protesting over the deaths of numerous soldiers in the army.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant attended the demonstration of 31 July 2010.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant attended the demonstration of 10 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Shortly after the demonstration of 31 July 2010 had begun, the police started to disperse those who had gathered.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Shortly after the demonstration of 10 March 2013 had begun, the police started to disperse those who had gathered.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant was arrested during the dispersal operation at the demonstration of 31 July 2010.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant was arrested during the dispersal operation at the demonstration of 10 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "After his arrest at the demonstration of 31 July 2010, the applicant was taken to a police station where he was questioned.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "After his arrest at the demonstration of 10 March 2013, the applicant was taken to a police station where he was questioned.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On the day of the applicant's arrest following the demonstration of 31 July 2010, an administrative offence report (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) was issued on the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On the day of the applicant's arrest following the demonstration of 10 March 2013, an administrative offence report (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) was issued on the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The administrative offence report issued following the applicant's arrest on 31 July 2010 stated that by deliberately failing to comply with a lawful order of the police, the applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "Following the applicant's arrest on 10 March 2013, the applicant was charged with an administrative offence under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) (participation in a public assembly organised not in accordance with the law).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with copies of the administrative offence reports from his case files in either the first case (31 July 2010) or the second case (10 March 2013).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with other material from his case files in either the first case (31 July 2010) or the second case (10 March 2013).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "In the first case (arrest on 31 July 2010), the applicant was not given access to a lawyer after the arrest or while he was in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "In the second case (arrest on 10 March 2013), the applicant was not given access to a lawyer after the arrest or while he was in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "In the first case, the applicant was brought before the Sabail District Court on 31 July 2010, the day of his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "In the second case, the applicant was held in police custody overnight following his arrest on 10 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "In the second case, the applicant was brought before the Sabail District Court on 11 March 2013, the day after his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing before the Sabail District Court in the first case (31 July 2010) was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing before the Sabail District Court in the second case (11 March 2013) was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the applicant, in the second case (11 March 2013), members of the public were not allowed inside the courtroom at the Sabail District Court hearing.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the applicant, in the second case (11 March 2013), the Sabail District Court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearing to the public.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the applicant, in the first case (31 July 2010), the applicant was not given an opportunity to appoint a lawyer of his own choosing at the court hearing before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the applicant, in the second case (11 March 2013), the applicant was not given an opportunity to appoint a lawyer of his own choosing at the court hearing before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "At the Sabail District Court hearing in the first case (31 July 2010), the applicant was not represented by a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the material submitted to the Court by the parties in the first case, the applicant refused legal assistance at the Sabail District Court hearing on 31 July 2010.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "It appears that at the Sabail District Court hearing in the second case (11 March 2013), a State-funded lawyer was invited to represent the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "None of the material submitted to the Court contains any records showing that the State-funded lawyer, Ms E.Z., made any oral submissions to the Sabail District Court (first-instance court) in the second case (11 March 2013).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "None of the material submitted to the Court contains any records showing that the State-funded lawyer, Ms E.Z., made any written submissions to the Sabail District Court (first-instance court) in the second case (11 March 2013).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "At the Sabail District Court hearings in both the first case (31 July 2010) and the second case (11 March 2013), the court did not question any witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "By a decision of 31 July 2010, the Sabail District Court (first-instance court) convicted the applicant under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "By a decision of 31 July 2010, the Sabail District Court (first-instance court) sentenced the applicant to seven days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "By a decision of 11 March 2013, the Sabail District Court (first-instance court) convicted the applicant under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "By a decision of 11 March 2013, the Sabail District Court (first-instance court) sentenced the applicant to seven days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On unspecified dates the applicant lodged appeals with the Baku Court of Appeal against his convictions in both the first case (31 July 2010) and the second case (11 March 2013).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "In his appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant argued that his convictions were in violation of his rights because the demonstrations in which he had participated had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In his appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant complained that his arrests had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In his appeals to the Baku Court of Appeal, the applicant complained that the hearings before the Sabail District Court (first-instance court) had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "In the first case (appeal against the conviction of 31 July 2010), the applicant was not represented by a lawyer before the Baku Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In the second case (appeal against the conviction of 11 March 2013), the applicant prepared his appeal with the assistance of a lawyer of his own choosing.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "In the second case (appeal against the conviction of 11 March 2013), the applicant's lawyer of his own choosing did not attend the hearing before the Baku Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 16 August 2010, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal in the first case and upheld the decision of the Sabail District Court (first-instance court) of 31 July 2010.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 27 March 2013, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal in the second case and upheld the decision of the Sabail District Court (first-instance court) of 11 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "According to the applicant, the decision of the Baku Court of Appeal of 16 August 2010 was sent to him on 23 December 2010.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "According to the applicant, the decision of the Baku Court of Appeal of 16 August 2010 was sent to him on 23 December 2010 only after he complained that the court had failed to serve him with that decision.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrests on 31 July 2010 and 10 March 2013, under Article 5 § IV of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, no prior written notification was required for spontaneous assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 31 July 2010, Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 (CAO) provided that any breach of the rules, set forth under the legislation, on the organisation and holding of assemblies, demonstrations, protests, marches and pickets shall be punishable by a reprimand or a fine of seven to thirteen manats (AZN).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 31 July 2010, Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 (CAO) provided that deliberate failure by an individual to comply with a lawful order of a police officer or military serviceman carrying out their duties to protect public order shall be punishable by a fine of twenty to twenty-five manats (AZN) or, if that sanction is inadequate in the circumstances of the case and taking into account the character of the offender, by up to fifteen days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 31 July 2010, Article 410.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 (CAO) provided that an individual who is subject to administrative offence proceedings or a representative of a legal entity shall be given an opportunity to familiarise himself with the administrative offence report.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 31 July 2010, Article 410.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 (CAO) provided that an individual who is subject to administrative offence proceedings or a representative of a legal entity has the right to a copy of the administrative offence report.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 31 July 2010, Article 437.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 (CAO) provided that a copy of a decision delivered on the basis of an appeal or a protest against a decision in an administrative offence case shall be given to the individual with respect to whom the decision in an administrative offence case was adopted within three days of its adoption.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "At the time of the applicant's arrest on 31 July 2010, Article 437.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 (CAO) provided that a copy of a decision delivered on the basis of an appeal or a protest against a decision sentencing an individual to administrative detention shall be given to that individual on the day of its adoption.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 entered into force on 1 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced new wording to Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) concerning breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Following the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, participation in an assembly organised in breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies became explicitly punishable under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced for the first time a punishment in the form of administrative detention of up to 15 days under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced community service as a new form of punishment under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 increased the fine for breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies to between AZN 300 and 600 for participants of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 increased the fine for breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies to between AZN 1,500 and 3,000 for individuals who organise an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 increased the fine for breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies to between AZN 3,000 and 6,000 for persons in charge (vəzifəli şəxslər) who organise an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 increased the fine for breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies to between AZN 15,000 and 30,000 for legal entities involved in the organisation of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "By Law no. 457-IVQD of 2 November 2012, which entered into force on 29 November 2012, the fine set out in Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO) was increased to AZN 200.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, titled 'The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan', stated that there is no political dialogue with the opposition parties outside parliament in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the Parliamentary Assembly is concerned by the restrictive climate for the activities of the extra-parliamentary opposition in Azerbaijan, which complains about limitations imposed on freedom of expression and freedom of assembly and the lack of access to the public media.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the establishment of an inclusive political system and a truly competitive and unrestrictive political environment in Azerbaijan requires full implementation of basic freedoms, including freedom of expression, freedom of assembly and freedom of association.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the situation in Azerbaijan regarding basic freedoms is preoccupying and the Parliamentary Assembly expressed its deep concern in this regard.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that recently adopted amendments to the Criminal Code and the Administrative Code of Azerbaijan, which increased penalties for the organisers of and participants in 'unauthorised' gatherings, raise concern.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that, considering the Azerbaijani authorities' ongoing blanket ban on protests in the Baku city centre, the amendments increasing penalties for organisers of and participants in 'unauthorised' gatherings are likely to have a further negative impact on freedom of assembly and freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the restrictive use of certain articles of the Criminal Code of Azerbaijan, in particular Articles 221 and 233, against participants in peaceful, albeit unauthorised, demonstrations, is a matter of concern.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 was authored by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 by Nils Muižnieks, Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, stated that the Commissioner is deeply concerned by the recent amendments to the Law on Freedom of Assembly, the Criminal Code and the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan, which further erode the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 by Nils Muižnieks, Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, stated that the sanctions which can now be imposed, coupled with the fact that local authorities have not authorised a single rally in Baku city centre in recent years, clearly have a chilling effect on the organisation of or participation in demonstrations in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 by Nils Muižnieks, Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, stated that participants in peaceful assemblies should not be sanctioned for the mere fact of being present at and actively participating in the demonstration in question, provided they do not do anything illegal, violent or obscene in the course of it.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 by Nils Muižnieks, Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, urged the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure that no disproportionate sanction, which would undermine the fundamental right to peaceful assembly, is imposed.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "For a summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, the relevant provisions concerning the organisation and holding of public assemblies, and the relevant extracts of international documents, the Court refers to the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, paragraphs 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F013", "F014", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022"], "interference": ["F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F051"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F005", "F006", "F007", "F027", "F063", "F065"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F005", "F013", "F014", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F073", "F075", "F079", "F080", "F081", "F083", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F089"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F013", "F014", "F017", "F018"], "interference": ["F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F051"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F005", "F006", "F027", "F063", "F065"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F005", "F013", "F014", "F019", "F020", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F073", "F075", "F079", "F085", "F089"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F013", "F014", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F063", "F073", "F075", "F079", "F085", "F089"]}} {"case_name": "case_408", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' personal details are set out in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants are opposition-oriented activists.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants are members of opposition parties.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Starting from 2010, a number of opposition parties or groups organised several demonstrations in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The demonstrations organised by opposition parties or groups in Baku starting from 2010 had not been authorised.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Many participants in the unauthorised demonstrations in Baku were arrested during the dispersal of those demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "One of the unauthorised demonstrations in Baku took place on 19 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "One of the unauthorised demonstrations in Baku took place on 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant in application no. 56317/11 was arrested during the dispersal of the demonstration of 19 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicant in application no. 56317/11 was taken to a police station following his arrest during the dispersal of the demonstration of 19 June 2010.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "An administrative-offence report (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) was drawn up at the police station in respect of the applicant in application no. 56317/11.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The administrative-offence report stated that the applicant in application no. 56317/11, by participating in an unauthorised demonstration, had deliberately failed to comply with a lawful order of the police.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The administrative-offence report stated that the applicant in application no. 56317/11 had committed an administrative offence under Article 310.1 (failure to comply with a lawful order of a police officer) of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 19 June 2010 the Sabail District Court convicted the applicant in application no. 56317/11 under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Sabail District Court sentenced the applicant in application no. 56317/11 to a fine of 20 Azerbaijani manats (approximately 20 euros).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "After the arrest of the applicant in application no. 56317/11, he was not represented by a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "During the first-instance court hearing, the applicant in application no. 56317/11 was not represented by a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Sabail District Court, as first-instance court, relied heavily on the administrative-offence report issued in respect of the applicant in application no. 56317/11.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant in application no. 56317/11 lodged an appeal against his conviction.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant in application no. 56317/11 complained in his appeal that his conviction had been in violation of his rights because the demonstration in which he had participated had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 23 July 2010 the Baku Court of Appeal held a hearing in the appeal of the applicant in application no. 56317/11 in the applicant's absence.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 23 July 2010 the Baku Court of Appeal held a hearing in the appeal of the applicant in application no. 56317/11 in the applicant's lawyer's absence.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 23 July 2010 the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the Sabail District Court convicting the applicant in application no. 56317/11 under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 28 February 2011 the Registry of the Sabail District Court sent the applicant in application no. 56317/11 a copy of the Baku Court of Appeal's decision of 23 July 2010.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 19 June 2010 (application no. 56317/11)"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The year 2011 was marked by an increased number of opposition demonstrations in Azerbaijan, mainly in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Opposition demonstrations in Azerbaijan were held on 11 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "Opposition demonstrations in Azerbaijan were held on 12 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "Opposition demonstrations in Azerbaijan were held on 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Opposition demonstrations in Azerbaijan were held on 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Opposition demonstrations in Azerbaijan were held on 22 May 2011.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Opposition demonstrations in Azerbaijan were held on 19 June 2011.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The organisers of the demonstration of 2 April 2011 gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority on 18 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The aim of the demonstration of 2 April 2011 was, in particular, to demand the Government guarantee the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The aim of the demonstration of 2 April 2011 was, in particular, to demand the Government carry out democratic reforms.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The aim of the demonstration of 2 April 2011 was, in particular, to demand the Government release political prisoners.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "By a letter of 31 March 2011, the Baku City Executive Authority refused to authorise the holding of the demonstration of 2 April 2011 at the place indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority proposed by its letter of 31 March 2011 that the demonstration of 2 April 2011 be held at a different location from the one indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The organisers of the demonstration of 2 April 2011 decided to hold the demonstration in the central squares of Baku despite the Baku City Executive Authority's refusal to authorise the originally proposed location.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Information about the demonstration of 2 April 2011 was disseminated through the press.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "A day before the demonstration of 2 April 2011 (i.e., on 1 April 2011), the Baku city prosecutor's office issued a notice addressed to the applicant in application no. 59661/12 and certain other individuals who were presumed organisers of the demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The notice issued by the Baku city prosecutor's office on 1 April 2011 stated that if there was an attempt to hold a public assembly in places not agreed upon with the Baku City Executive Authority, illegal actions consisting of breach of public order and insubordination to lawful demands of public officers, or causing inconvenience to the population, or causing disruption of the normal functioning of transport, enterprises, bodies and organisations, would be prevented in accordance with the law.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The notice issued by the Baku city prosecutor's office on 1 April 2011 stated that prescribed relevant measures would be taken against the applicant in application no. 59661/12 and the other addressees as organisers of the public assemblies if they attempted to hold a public assembly in places not agreed upon with the Baku City Executive Authority.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The notice issued by the Baku city prosecutor's office on 1 April 2011 contained a warning that the mentioned actions entailed criminal responsibility under Article 220 (mass disorder) of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The notice issued by the Baku city prosecutor's office on 1 April 2011 contained a warning that the mentioned actions entailed criminal responsibility under Article 233 (organisation or active participation in actions causing a breach of public order) of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicants decided to participate in the demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Video recordings submitted by some applicants show that on 2 April 2011, as soon as protesters began gathering in central streets of Baku, marching and chanting slogans calling for the government's resignation, the police started to disperse the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The police dispersed the demonstration of 2 April 2011 by arresting demonstrators and forcing them into police vehicles and buses.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The dispersal of the demonstration of 2 April 2011 resulted in isolated incidents of clashes between police officers and demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "It appears that several demonstrators at the demonstration of 2 April 2011 inflicted physical injuries on around twenty-five police officers.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "It appears that several demonstrators at the demonstration of 2 April 2011 damaged two private vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "It appears that several demonstrators at the demonstration of 2 April 2011 broke windows of some shops and offices located near the place where the demonstration was held.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "1. General information pertaining to all applications"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 were arrested during the dispersal of the demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 were brought to various police offices for questioning as witnesses following their arrest on 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Later on 2 April 2011, formal decisions were drawn up to detain the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 as suspects in criminal cases.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 4 April 2011 the prosecution formally charged the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 with a criminal offence under Article 233 of the Criminal Code (organisation of or active participation in actions causing a breach of public order).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11 and 27472/12 were detained pending trial.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Mr Fuad Gahramanli (applicant in application no. 59661/12) was placed under police supervision as a preventive pre-trial measure.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 29 July 2011 a bill of indictment was drawn up in respect of the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 and the case went to trial.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "During the trial, the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 pleaded not guilty.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "During the trial, the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 argued that the case against them was politically motivated.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 25 August 2011, while the trial against the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 was under way, the Sabail District Court delivered a judgment in another criminal case against six other participants in the demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Sabail District Court's judgment of 25 August 2011 in the case against six other participants in the demonstration of 2 April 2011 stated that those individuals had committed the criminal offences in question under the direction (təşkilatçılıq) of the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 and several other individuals.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "By a judgment of 3 October 2011, the Sabail District Court convicted the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 under Article 233 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Sabail District Court sentenced the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 to various terms of imprisonment ranging from two years to two years and six months (as set out in the Appendix).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Sabail District Court found in its judgment of 3 October 2011 that the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 had disobeyed the orders of the police.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Sabail District Court found in its judgment of 3 October 2011 that the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 had organised and actively participated in actions causing a breach of public order.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Sabail District Court found in its judgment of 3 October 2011 that the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 had organised and actively participated in actions causing traffic jams.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Sabail District Court found in its judgment of 3 October 2011 that the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 had organised and actively participated in actions causing destruction of private and public property.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Sabail District Court found in its judgment of 3 October 2011 that the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 had organised and actively participated in actions causing infliction of injuries to twenty-five civilians and police officers.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on statements of civil claimants who testified that some unidentified participants in the demonstration had inflicted on them either physical or material damage.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on statements of police officers who testified that the applicants had actively participated in the demonstration, behaved aggressively, led other participants, chanted slogans and refused to obey orders of the police.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on medical forensic reports concerning injuries sustained by a number of victims.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on forensic reports concerning the damage inflicted to various vehicles and shops.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on video footage which showed Mr Hajili speaking about the necessity to organise a demonstration against the Government's policies during a meeting of several opposition parties held on 27 February 2011.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on video footage containing an interview with Mr Gahramanli held on 1 April 2011 in which he spoke about the organisation of the demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on video footage which showed Mr Gahramanli marching together with others and chanting slogans during the demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on video footage which showed Mr Majidli chanting slogans and being arrested during the dispersal of the demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on a video recording which showed other participants in the demonstration of 2 April 2011 kicking and damaging a bus.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Sabail District Court rejected the civil claims lodged against the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 by legal and physical persons for procedural reasons.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 appealed against the Sabail District Court's judgment of 3 October 2011, complaining of the unfairness of the criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 appealed against the Sabail District Court's judgment of 3 October 2011, complaining of the breach of their right to presumption of innocence.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 appealed against the Sabail District Court's judgment of 3 October 2011, complaining that their arrest and conviction had been in violation of their right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "On 16 December 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the appeals of the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 against the Sabail District Court's judgment of 3 October 2011, finding their complaints unfounded.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On 24 April 2012 the Supreme Court dismissed appeals on points of law lodged by the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 and upheld the Baku Court of Appeal's judgment of 16 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 21 June 2012 the Supreme Court dismissed appeals on points of law lodged by the applicants in applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12 and upheld the Baku Court of Appeal's judgment of 16 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(i) Criminal proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "According to the applicant Mr Tural Abbasli (application no. 27472/12), on 2 April 2011 he was subjected to ill-treatment during his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(ii) Alleged ill-treatment of Mr. Tural Abbasli (application no. 27472/12)"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "According to the applicant Mr Tural Abbasli (application no. 27472/12), on 2 April 2011 he was subjected to ill-treatment while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(ii) Alleged ill-treatment of Mr. Tural Abbasli (application no. 27472/12)"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "On 4 April 2011 Mr Tural Abbasli (applicant in application no. 27472/12) complained of his ill-treatment to a judge deciding on his pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(ii) Alleged ill-treatment of Mr. Tural Abbasli (application no. 27472/12)"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The judge to whom Mr Tural Abbasli complained of ill-treatment on 4 April 2011 sent the complaint to the Baku city prosecutor's office for examination.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(ii) Alleged ill-treatment of Mr. Tural Abbasli (application no. 27472/12)"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 25 April 2011 the Baku city prosecutor's office refused to institute criminal proceedings in connection with Mr Tural Abbasli's (applicant in application no. 27472/12) allegations of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(ii) Alleged ill-treatment of Mr. Tural Abbasli (application no. 27472/12)"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Mr Tural Abbasli (applicant in application no. 27472/12) lodged a complaint with the Sabail District Court in respect of the Baku city prosecutor's office's decision of 25 April 2011 refusing to institute criminal proceedings regarding his allegations of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(ii) Alleged ill-treatment of Mr. Tural Abbasli (application no. 27472/12)"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "On 8 September 2011 the Sabail District Court dismissed Mr Tural Abbasli's (applicant in application no. 27472/12) complaint against the Baku city prosecutor's office's decision of 25 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(ii) Alleged ill-treatment of Mr. Tural Abbasli (application no. 27472/12)"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Mr Tural Abbasli (applicant in application no. 27472/12) appealed against the Sabail District Court's decision of 8 September 2011.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(ii) Alleged ill-treatment of Mr. Tural Abbasli (application no. 27472/12)"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "In a final decision of 23 September 2011, the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the Sabail District Court's decision of 8 September 2011 dismissing Mr Tural Abbasli's complaint regarding his allegations of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(ii) Alleged ill-treatment of Mr. Tural Abbasli (application no. 27472/12)"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "According to Mr Tural Abbasli (applicant in application no. 27472/12), he received the Baku Court of Appeal's decision of 23 September 2011 on 3 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(a) Applications nos. 56317/11, 67932/11, 27472/12 and 59661/12", "(ii) Alleged ill-treatment of Mr. Tural Abbasli (application no. 27472/12)"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Some of the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 were arrested during the dispersal of the demonstration on 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Some of the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 were arrested a few days after the demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 9 April 2011 the prosecution formally charged Mr Babak Hasanov with a criminal offence under Article 233 of the Criminal Code (active participation in actions causing a breach of public order).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "On 9 April 2011 the prosecution formally charged Mr Elshan Hasanov with a criminal offence under Article 233 of the Criminal Code (active participation in actions causing a breach of public order).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 9 April 2011 the prosecution formally charged Mr Sahib Karimov with a criminal offence under Article 233 of the Criminal Code (active participation in actions causing a breach of public order).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On 15 April 2011 the prosecution formally charged Mr Zulfugar Eyvazov with a criminal offence under Article 233 of the Criminal Code (active participation in actions causing a breach of public order).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "On 16 April 2011 the prosecution formally charged Mr Arif Alishli with a criminal offence under Article 233 of the Criminal Code (active participation in actions causing a breach of public order).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "Mr Arif Alishli was additionally charged under Article 186.1 of the Criminal Code (intentional destruction or damaging of property) for damaging a bus owned by S.M. which the police had been using to transport arrested demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "Mr Sahib Karimov was additionally charged under Article 186.1 of the Criminal Code (intentional destruction or damaging of property) for damaging a bus owned by S.M. which the police had been using to transport arrested demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Mr Zulfugar Eyvazov was additionally charged under Article 186.1 of the Criminal Code (intentional destruction or damaging of property) for damaging a bus owned by S.M. which the police had been using to transport arrested demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 were detained pending trial.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "On 28 June 2011 a bill of indictment was drawn up in respect of the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 and the case went to trial.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "During the trial, the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 pleaded not guilty, relying on their right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "By a judgment of 25 August 2011, the Sabail District Court convicted the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 under Article 233 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Sabail District Court's judgment of 25 August 2011 also convicted Mr Arif Alishli (application no. 28563/13) under Article 186.1 of the Criminal Code (intentional destruction or damaging of property).", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Sabail District Court's judgment of 25 August 2011 acquitted Mr Sahib Karimov (application no. 12717/13) under Article 186.1 of the Criminal Code for lack of evidence.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Sabail District Court's judgment of 25 August 2011 acquitted Mr Zulfugar Eyvazov (application no. 6903/13) under Article 186.1 of the Criminal Code for lack of evidence.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Sabail District Court sentenced the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 to various terms of imprisonment ranging from one year and six months to three years (as set out in the Appendix).", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Sabail District Court found in its judgment of 25 August 2011 that the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 had disobeyed the orders of the police.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Sabail District Court found in its judgment of 25 August 2011 that the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 had actively participated in actions causing a breach of public order.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Sabail District Court found in its judgment of 25 August 2011 that the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 had actively participated in actions causing traffic jams.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Sabail District Court found in its judgment of 25 August 2011 that the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 had actively participated in actions causing destruction of private and public property.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The Sabail District Court found in its judgment of 25 August 2011 that the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 had actively participated in actions causing infliction of injuries to twenty-five civilians and police officers.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The Sabail District Court found in its judgment of 25 August 2011 that the actions of Mr Arif Alishli (application no. 28563/13) had resulted in damage to other individuals' property.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on the testimony of S.M., according to whom some protesters had hit his bus and damaged it.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on statements of civil claimants concerning material loss suffered because of the traffic jams caused by the demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on statements of police officers who testified that unidentified participants had behaved aggressively, chanted slogans and refused to obey orders of the police to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on the testimony of one police officer who had participated in the arrest of demonstrators and was able to identify Mr Babak Hasanov.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on testimonies of bystanders, according to whom unidentified demonstrators chanted slogans and disobeyed the police.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on forensic and financial reports concerning the material damage sustained by various vehicles and businesses.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 guilty, the Sabail District Court relied on video recordings which showed Mr Arif Alishli, together with another demonstrator, kicking and punching various parts of a bus which had been used by the police to transport arrested demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Sabail District Court examined civil claims against the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 in its judgment of 25 August 2011.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The Sabail District Court allowed civil claims lodged by legal and physical persons who had allegedly suffered financial losses because of the traffic jams caused by the demonstration of 2 April 2011, awarding in total the sum of 5,265 Azerbaijani manats (approximately 4,659 euros) to be paid jointly by the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 and another defendant, E.I.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Sabail District Court granted S.M.'s civil claim in the amount of 1,325 Azerbaijani manats (approximately 1,172 euros) against Mr Arif Alishli (application no. 28563/13) and E.I.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 appealed against the Sabail District Court's judgment of 25 August 2011, complaining of the unfairness of the criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 appealed against the Sabail District Court's judgment of 25 August 2011, complaining of the breach of their right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "On 18 October 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal reduced the sentence of Mr Elshan Hasanov from two years' to one year's imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "On 18 October 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the remainder of the appeals of the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 against the Sabail District Court's judgment of 25 August 2011.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "On 5 June 2012 the Supreme Court dismissed appeals on points of law by the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 and upheld the Baku Court of Appeal's judgment of 18 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "On 17 October 2012 the Supreme Court dismissed appeals on points of law by the applicants in applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13 and upheld the Baku Court of Appeal's judgment of 18 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "On 22 June 2012 Mr Babak Hasanov was pardoned and released from serving the remainder of his sentence.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "On 22 June 2012 Mr Zulfugar Eyvazov was pardoned and released from serving the remainder of his sentence.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "On 22 June 2012 Mr Sahib Karimov was pardoned and released from serving the remainder of his sentence.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(b) Applications nos. 6814/13, 6903/13, 7990/13, 12717/13 and 28563/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Mr Ulvu Guliyev (applicant in application no. 23365/14) was arrested on 8 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Mr Rufat Hajibeyli (applicant in application no. 25680/14) was arrested on 22 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "On 9 April 2011 the prosecution formally charged Mr Ulvu Guliyev (applicant in application no. 23365/14) with a criminal offence under Article 233 of the Criminal Code (organisation or active participation in actions causing a breach of public order).", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "On 9 April 2011 the prosecution formally charged Mr Ulvu Guliyev (applicant in application no. 23365/14) with a criminal offence under Article 315.1 of the Criminal Code (resistance to or violence against a public officer).", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "On 23 April 2011 the prosecution formally charged Mr Rufat Hajibeyli (applicant in application no. 25680/14) with a criminal offence under Article 233 of the Criminal Code (organisation or active participation in actions causing a breach of public order).", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "The applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 were detained pending trial.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "On 13 July 2011 a bill of indictment was drawn up in respect of the applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 and the case went to trial.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "During the trial, the applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 pleaded not guilty, relying on their right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "By a judgment of 10 October 2011, the Nasimi District Court found that the applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 had actively participated in actions causing a breach of public order.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The Nasimi District Court found in its judgment of 10 October 2011 that Mr Ulvu Guliyev (application no. 23365/14) had violently resisted police officers.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "The Nasimi District Court convicted the applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 under Article 233 of the Criminal Code in its judgment of 10 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The Nasimi District Court additionally convicted Mr Ulvu Guliyev (application no. 23365/14) under Article 315.1 of the Criminal Code in its judgment of 10 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "The Nasimi District Court sentenced Mr Rufat Hajibeyli (application no. 25680/14) to a term of imprisonment of one year and six months.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The Nasimi District Court sentenced Mr Ulvu Guliyev (application no. 23365/14) to a term of imprisonment of three years.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 guilty, the Nasimi District Court relied on testimonies of four police officers, E.T., N.S., M.M. and R.H., who had participated in the arrest of Mr Ulvu Guliyev and who testified that Mr Ulvu Guliyev had violently resisted the arrest by elbowing one of them, N.S., as a result of which that police officer's cap had fallen off.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Police officer N.S. testified that he had not sustained any injuries as a result of Mr Ulvu Guliyev elbowing him during the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "Police officer N.S. testified that Mr Ulvu Guliyev had kicked and damaged a police car during the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 guilty, the Nasimi District Court relied on testimonies of other police officers, according to which other demonstrators behaved aggressively, chanted slogans and refused to obey orders of the police to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 guilty, the Nasimi District Court relied on statements of civil claimants and financial reports concerning the damage caused to their property and material loss suffered because of the traffic jams caused by the demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 guilty, the Nasimi District Court relied on testimonies of bystanders who witnessed unidentified demonstrators disobeying orders of the police, damaging a police car and breaking a pharmacy window.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "In finding the applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 guilty, the Nasimi District Court relied on video recordings of the demonstration of 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The Nasimi District Court dismissed the civil claims lodged against the applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 by legal and physical persons for procedural reasons.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 lodged appeals with the Baku Court of Appeal against the Nasimi District Court's judgment of 10 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 complained in their appeals that there had been various defects in the trial and that the hearings before the Nasimi District Court had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 complained in their appeals that their arrest and conviction had been in violation of their right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "On 1 December 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the appeals of the applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 against the Nasimi District Court's judgment of 10 October 2011.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "On 3 July 2012 the Supreme Court dismissed appeals on points of law by the applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 and upheld the Baku Court of Appeal's judgment of 1 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "On 17 September 2013 the Supreme Court dismissed appeals on points of law by the applicants in applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14 and upheld the Baku Court of Appeal's judgment of 1 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "On 22 June 2012 Mr Ulvu Guliyev (application no. 23365/14) was pardoned and released from serving the remainder of his sentence.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "On 22 June 2012 Mr Rufat Hajibeyli (application no. 25680/14) was pardoned and released from serving the remainder of his sentence.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration of 2 April 2011 (all applications)", "2. Peculiarities of individual applications", "(c) Applications nos. 23365/14 and 25680/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "Article 186.1 of the Criminal Code of Azerbaijan provides that deliberate destruction or damage of another's property which caused significant harm is punishable by a fine in the amount of 500 to 1,000 Azerbaijani manats, or deprivation of liberty for a period of up to two years.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "Article 233 of the Criminal Code of Azerbaijan provides that organisation by a group of individuals of actions which grossly breach public order, or are associated with insubordination in respect of lawful demands of a public officer, or cause disruption of the normal functioning of transport, companies, public bodies and organisations, as well as active participation in such actions, is punishable by a fine in the amount of 5,000 to 8,000 Azerbaijani manats, or correctional labour for a period of up to two years, or deprivation of liberty for a period of up to three years.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "Article 315.1 of the Criminal Code of Azerbaijan provides that use of violence against, or violent resistance to, a public officer in connection with the exercise of the latter's official duties, or use against the close relatives of such a public officer of violence which does not pose a danger to their life or health, or the threat of use of such violence, is punishable by deprivation of liberty for a period of up to three years.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "For a summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, the relevant provisions concerning the organisation and holding of public assemblies, and the relevant extracts of international documents, see the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, paragraphs 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F008", "F032", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F052", "F055", "F063", "F065", "F066", "F071", "F077", "F096", "F097", "F102", "F103", "F109", "F110", "F122", "F126", "F141", "F149", "F150", "F153", "F154"], "interference": ["F052", "F055", "F063", "F064", "F096", "F097", "F098", "F099", "F100", "F101", "F102", "F109", "F110", "F113", "F139", "F140", "F141", "F142", "F143", "F149", "F150", "F152"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F047", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F051"], "necessity": ["F032", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F054", "F055", "F056", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F066", "F070", "F071", "F072", "F073", "F077", "F078", "F103", "F109", "F110", "F113", "F119", "F126", "F142", "F150", "F152", "F153", "F154"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F008", "F032", "F036", "F038", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F126", "F153", "F154"], "interference": ["F052", "F055", "F063", "F064", "F096", "F097", "F109", "F113", "F139", "F149", "F150", "F152"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F032", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F056", "F064", "F065", "F070", "F071", "F103", "F110", "F113", "F126", "F142", "F150", "F152", "F153", "F154"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F032", "F036", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F056", "F064", "F070", "F071", "F113", "F126", "F152", "F153", "F154"]}} {"case_name": "case_410", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the application are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the location of public events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the time of conduct of public events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the manner of conduct of public events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003", "F004"]}} {"case_name": "case_411", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant (Ms Makarova) was born in 1989.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The first applicant (Ms Makarova) lived in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Astakhova) was born in 1985.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Astakhova) lives in Mytishchi, Moscow Region.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The third applicant (Ms Fokht-Babushkina) was born in 1994.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The third applicant (Ms Fokht-Babushkina) lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 14 December 2012 the State Duma, the lower house of the Federal Assembly of Russia, adopted at first reading a draft law.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The draft law adopted at first reading by the State Duma on 14 December 2012 prohibited, in particular, the adoption of children of Russian nationality by citizens of the United States of America.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 17 December 2012 the official daily newspaper Rossiyskaya Gazeta announced that the second reading of the draft law prohibiting adoption of Russian children by United States citizens was scheduled for 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Makarova), she had read on various online social networks that many people intended to stage solo demonstrations (одиночные пикеты) on 19 December 2012 in front of the State Duma.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Makarova), the intended solo demonstrations on 19 December 2012 were to express opposition to the draft law prohibiting adoption of Russian children by United States citizens.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The format of solo demonstrations was chosen because there was no longer time to observe the minimum statutory three-day notification period required for other types of group public events.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "All three applicants decided to hold solo demonstrations on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the applicants, at around 9 a.m. on 19 December 2012 they positioned themselves, holding banners, in the vicinity of the State Duma.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the applicants, at around 9 a.m. on 19 December 2012 they were positioned at some distance from other protesters in the vicinity of the State Duma.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Makarova), she was arrested by the police several minutes after positioning herself near the State Duma on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Makarova), after her arrest she was taken to a police van.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the first applicant (Ms Makarova), there were no orders from police officers to stop the demonstration and leave the area before her arrest.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Astakhova) and the third applicant (Ms Fokht-Babushkina), after their solo demonstrations they left the area, showing their posters to journalists at the journalists' request.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Astakhova) and the third applicant (Ms Fokht-Babushkina), at the point when they were showing their posters to journalists, they were arrested by the police.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Astakhova) and the third applicant (Ms Fokht-Babushkina), after their arrest they were taken to the Tverskoy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the Government, at 10 a.m. on 19 December 2012 all three applicants took part in a group picket (пикет) held without prior notification of the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the Government, the first applicant (Ms Makarova) held a poster reading 'I am looking for an American who will adopt me' during the group picket on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the Government, the second applicant (Ms Astakhova) held a poster reading 'Orphans are guilty for the death of Mr Magnitskiy? Do not disgrace yourself' during the group picket on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the Government, the third applicant (Ms Fokht-Babushkina) held a poster reading 'Orphans are guilty for the death of Mr Magnitskiy? Do not disgrace yourself' during the group picket on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the Government, the applicants did not react to the lawful demands of the police to stop participating in the group picket on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the Government, the applicants continued picketing and attracted the attention of passers-by on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the Government, at 10.30 a.m. on 19 December 2012 the applicants were arrested and taken to the Tverskoy district police station for the purpose of compiling an administrative-offence record.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the Government, at 1.20 p.m. on 19 December 2012 the applicants were released from the Tverskoy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "At the Tverskoy district police station the applicants were charged with participating in a group public event held without prior notification, in breach of Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The administrative-offence record in respect of the first applicant (Ms Makarova) indicated that the offence had been committed at 10 a.m. on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The police officers' reports in respect of all three applicants indicated that the offence had been committed at 10 a.m. on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The administrative-offence record and police officers' reports stated that the applicants had taken part in a non-notified group public event and had refused to end it when requested to do so by the police.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 15 January 2013 the justice of the peace of circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow found the first applicant (Ms Makarova) guilty under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The justice of the peace of circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow sentenced the first applicant (Ms Makarova) to a fine of 20,000 Russian roubles (about 495 euros at the time).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The justice of the peace found it established, on the basis of the administrative-offence record, the police officers' reports, and oral testimony by a police officer who had arrested the first applicant (Ms Makarova), that the first applicant had taken part in a public event (picket) which had involved fifty people and had been held without prior notification of the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 14 February 2013 the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow upheld the judgment of 15 January 2013 against the first applicant (Ms Makarova) on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The first applicant (Ms Makarova) did not attend the appeal hearing before the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow, even though she had been duly summoned to it.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 31 January 2013 the justice of the peace of circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow convicted the second applicant (Ms Astakhova) under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences in separate proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 31 January 2013 the justice of the peace of circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow convicted the third applicant (Ms Fokht-Babushkina) under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences in separate proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The justice of the peace sentenced the second applicant (Ms Astakhova) to a fine of 20,000 Russian roubles.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The justice of the peace sentenced the third applicant (Ms Fokht-Babushkina) to a fine of 20,000 Russian roubles.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The justice of the peace relied on the administrative offence records, the police officers' reports, and oral testimony by a police officer who had arrested the second applicant (Ms Astakhova) and the third applicant (Ms Fokht-Babushkina).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 21 February 2013 the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow upheld the judgment in respect of the third applicant (Ms Fokht-Babushkina) on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 21 March 2013 the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow upheld the judgment in respect of the second applicant (Ms Astakhova) on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Both the second applicant (Ms Astakhova) and the third applicant (Ms Fokht-Babushkina) were absent from their respective appeal hearings before the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The third applicant's (Ms Fokht-Babushkina's) lawyer participated in the appeal hearing before the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "In the third applicant's (Ms Fokht-Babushkina's) appeal case, the appellate court examined some documents and interviewed a police officer in a detailed manner before affording the defence counsel an opportunity to cross-examine him.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In the third applicant's (Ms Fokht-Babushkina's) appeal case, the appeal judge asked a number of follow-up questions after the defence counsel cross-examined the police officer.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In its appeal decision in the third applicant's (Ms Fokht-Babushkina's) case, the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow considered that the third applicant's guilt had been proved by adverse evidence, including the administrative-offence record, the escort procedure record, and testimonies.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 1 July 2013 the Moscow City Court examined a supervisory review complaint lodged by the second applicant (Ms Astakhova).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 5 July 2013 the Moscow City Court examined a supervisory review complaint lodged by the third applicant (Ms Fokht-Babushkina).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Moscow City Court reclassified the charges against the second applicant (Ms Astakhova) as falling under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences, namely breach of the established procedure for the conduct of public events committed by a participant.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Moscow City Court reclassified the charges against the third applicant (Ms Fokht-Babushkina) as falling under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences, namely breach of the established procedure for the conduct of public events committed by a participant.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Moscow City Court reduced the fine imposed on the second applicant (Ms Astakhova) to 10,000 Russian roubles (about 232 euros at the time).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Moscow City Court reduced the fine imposed on the third applicant (Ms Fokht-Babushkina) to 10,000 Russian roubles (about 232 euros at the time).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "A summary of domestic law and practice concerning regulations relating to the conduct of public events, liability for breaches committed in the course of such events, and administrative escorting and arrest can be found in Lashmankin and Others v. Russia, nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, §§ 216-312, 7 February 2017.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "A summary of domestic law and practice concerning regulations relating to the conduct of public events, liability for breaches committed in the course of such events, and administrative escorting and arrest can also be found in Novikova and Others v. Russia, nos. 25501/07 and 4 others, §§ 47-84, 26 April 2016.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Until 1 January 2013, charges under Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences were to be determined at first instance by a justice of the peace, pursuant to Article 23.1 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences as in force until 1 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Since 1 January 2013, charges under Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences are to be determined at first instance by a district court of general jurisdiction, pursuant to Article 23.1 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences as in force since 1 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Since 6 January 2013, Moscow City Law no. 10 of 4 April 2007 provides that the distance between solo demonstrations should be no less than fifty metres.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Moscow City Law no. 10 of 4 April 2007 specifies, in section 2.3, that simultaneous demonstrations should be treated as solo demonstrations, provided that they do not have a common goal and organisation.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F013", "F014", "F015", "F036", "F034", "F039", "F040", "F011", "F043", "F018", "F019"], "interference": ["F016", "F017", "F021", "F028", "F030", "F034", "F035", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F042"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F057", "F058", "F061"], "legitimate_aim": ["F033", "F034", "F036", "F039", "F040"], "necessity": ["F007", "F008", "F009", "F012", "F014", "F015", "F018", "F019", "F030", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F013", "F014", "F015", "F036", "F018", "F019"], "interference": ["F028", "F034", "F039", "F040", "F035", "F041", "F042"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F061"], "legitimate_aim": ["F033", "F036"], "necessity": ["F009", "F012", "F014", "F015", "F033", "F034", "F036", "F039", "F040"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F009", "F012", "F014", "F015", "F033", "F034", "F036", "F039", "F040"]}} {"case_name": "case_412", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1950.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "At the material time the applicant was a district councillor.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 21 August 2003 the non-governmental organisation \"City-wide public council for the protection of citizens' rights in town planning and for the protection of the environment\" decided to hold an assembly of Krylatskoye district residents at the Zashchitnikov Neba Square in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "One purpose of the planned assembly was to protest against the Moscow mayor's failure to respond to the resolution of the assembly held in May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "One purpose of the planned assembly was to protest against the planned construction of several luxurious blocks of flats in the place of facilities for sports and children.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "One purpose of the planned assembly was to cast a vote of no confidence in the city authorities and call for their resignation.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "One purpose of the planned assembly was to discuss matters of local self-governance.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 25 August 2003 the applicant, together with three other co-organisers of the assembly, informed the Prefecture of the Western Administrative District of Moscow of the date, time, place and purposes of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The residential district of Krylatskoye was within the jurisdiction of the Prefecture of the Western Administrative District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The assembly was scheduled to take place from 6.30 to 8.30 p.m. on Thursday, 4 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The assembly was expected to be attended by about a hundred persons.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 29 August 2003 the prefect of the Western Administrative District of Moscow issued a decision to accept the notice of the planned assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 29 August 2003 the prefect of the Western Administrative District of Moscow instructed the police to ensure public safety during the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant and co-organisers informed residents of the Krylatskoye district about the planned assembly by way of bill-posting.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 3 September 2003 the prefect of the Western Administrative District of Moscow cancelled his previous decision of 29 August 2003 accepting the notice of the planned assembly.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The prefect cancelled his decision of 29 August 2003 \"in connection with the operative information of law-enforcement authorities about an expected outbreak of terrorist activities in the Krylatskoye district and with a view to ensuring the safety of the district's residents\".", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 3 September 2003 the police were instructed \"to take measures to prevent the assembly planned for 4 September 2003 at the Zashchitnikov Neba Square from being held\".", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 4 September 2003 a few dozen residents gathered on the Zashchitnikov Neba Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant was among the residents who gathered on the Zashchitnikov Neba Square on 4 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "No loud speakers were deployed at the Zashchitnikov Neba Square on 4 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "No attempts were made to start a general discussion at the Zashchitnikov Neba Square on 4 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The police dispersed the crowd at the Zashchitnikov Neba Square on 4 September 2003 by force.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 5, 6 and 7 September 2003 (Friday to Sunday) the \"Day of the City\" was celebrated throughout Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The programme for the \"Day of the City\" festivities had been approved by the Moscow Government's resolution of 12 August 2003.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The programme for the \"Day of the City\" festivities included sixty-one events.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The \"Day of the City\" events included the \"World-wide Tea Festival\", the opening ceremony, \"Parade of the Festivals\", the European champions' road running cup, the Moscow cup of the automobile all-round competition, the children's artistic and sport performance, sound and light show, students' parade, and many others.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The \"Day of the City\" events took place in major public thoroughfares.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant submitted media reports showing that no scheduled \"Day of the City\" events had been cancelled.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicant submitted media reports showing that the \"Day of the City\" public festivities had been attended by thousands of people.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public assembly on 4 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant left the Zashchitnikov Neba Square in a private car at about 8 p.m. on 4 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's overnight detention at the police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "At a nearby crossing, the police blocked the applicant's car.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's overnight detention at the police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The police held the driver of the applicant's car at gun-point.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's overnight detention at the police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The police took the applicant out of the car by force.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's overnight detention at the police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The police escorted the applicant to Krylatskoye district police station (ОВД района «Крылатское»).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's overnight detention at the police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to the administrative-arrest record of 4 September 2003, the applicant was arrested for refusing to comply with a lawful order of the police.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's overnight detention at the police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Following the applicant's complaints about unlawful police actions, the Kuntsevskiy District Prosecutor interviewed the officers who had apprehended the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's overnight detention at the police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Captain F., Officer D. and the driver L. stated that they had been present at the assembly site since 6 p.m. on 4 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's overnight detention at the police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Captain F., Officer D. and the driver L. stated that at 8 p.m. on 4 September 2003, when people were beginning to leave, they had arrested the applicant and taken him to the police station \"for clarification of facts, namely the [legal] ground for holding a public assembly\".", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's overnight detention at the police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Mr N., who had been the duty officer at Krylatskoye district police station, testified that at 8 p.m. on 4 September 2003 the head of the police station had told him to prepare a report on an administrative offence of disobedience of police orders committed by Mr Makhmudov (the applicant), who had been \"detained for conducting an unauthorised meeting\".", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's overnight detention at the police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "At Krylatskoye district police station the applicant was placed in a cell.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's overnight detention at the police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicant remained in the cell at Krylatskoye district police station until he was brought before a judge on 5 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's overnight detention at the police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The cell at Krylatskoye district police station was dirty and covered with spittle.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's overnight detention at the police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant was not given any food or drink while detained at Krylatskoye district police station.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's overnight detention at the police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 5 September 2003 the applicant was brought before a judge of the Kuntsevskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicant was charged with disobeying lawful police orders, an administrative offence under Article 19.3 of the Code on Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant was charged with organising an unauthorised assembly, an administrative offence under Article 20.2 of the Code on Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The two charges against the applicant — disobeying lawful police orders and organising an unauthorised assembly — were examined separately by the Kuntsevskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Examining the charge of disobedience of lawful police orders, the judge of the Kuntsevskiy District Court found that a number of breaches of the Code of Administrative Offences had been revealed during the preparation and examination of the administrative case.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The judge found that it was not clear from the case material what the applicant's stance was with regard to the offence imputed to him, but that it appeared from his statement that he had not committed any offence.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The judge found that, in breach of Article 28.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences, the report did not list witnesses who could confirm the guilt of the applicant, nor did it refer to other evidence confirming the offending acts or disobedience of police orders.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The judge found that an administrative inquiry had been ordered on 5 September 2003 but no such inquiry had actually been carried out, as the file did not contain any depositions or other additional material obtained by such an inquiry.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The judge found that pursuant to Article 28.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences, a report on an administrative offence punishable by administrative arrest must be submitted for judicial examination immediately after its issuance.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The judge found that the administrative-arrest record concerning the applicant (Mr Makhmudov) had been prepared at 8 p.m. on 4 September 2003 but the material was submitted to the court only at 4.30 p.m. on 5 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The judge found that the report contained no information as to who disobeyed the order, which police officer gave the order, where the order was given, or what kind of lawful order it was.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The judge found that the administrative-arrest record did not refer to Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences, although the breach of that provision was the basis for the applicant's arrest, and did not refer to the grounds for arrest.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The judge found that the administrative-arrest record did not describe the detainee's clothing, the absence or presence of bodily injuries, or to whom the information about the arrest was communicated.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The judge found that the information on the identity of attesting witnesses was incomplete, that attesting witness no. 2 did not sign the record, and that witnesses for the defence had not been examined.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The judge of the Kuntsevskiy District Court returned the material to Krylatskoye police station for correction of the identified defects.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The judge of the Kuntsevskiy District Court ordered the applicant's release at 5.10 p.m. on 5 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 7 October 2003 the police resubmitted the file concerning the charge of disobeying lawful police orders to the Kuntsevskiy District Court.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 29 October 2003 the Kuntsevskiy District Court found that the police had not made good the defects identified in the decision of 5 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 29 October 2003 the Kuntsevskiy District Court noted that the applicant (Mr Makhmudov) had unambiguously declared himself not guilty of the imputed offence and had listed nine witnesses as being ready to testify that he had not committed any illegal actions against the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 29 October 2003 the Kuntsevskiy District Court discontinued the proceedings against the applicant on the charge of disobeying lawful police orders, finding that the available evidence was insufficient for a finding of guilt and that all measures for proving the applicant's guilt had been exhausted.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Following the applicant's complaint that the legal basis for discontinuance of the proceedings had not been set out explicitly, on 2 December 2003 the decision of 29 October 2003 was quashed by a higher court.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 2 December 2003 the higher court remitted the matter for a new examination.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 19 December 2003 the Kuntsevskiy District Court ordered the discontinuance of the proceedings on the charge of disobeying lawful police orders on the ground that the two-month prescription period had expired.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "1. The charge of disobeying lawful police orders"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The judge of the Kuntsevskiy District Court examined witnesses for the defence, who denied that the assembly had taken place, and police officers who testified for the prosecution, in relation to the charge of organising an unauthorised assembly.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charge of organising an unauthorised assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The judge of the Kuntsevskiy District Court found that the applicant had been in breach of the established procedure for organising public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charge of organising an unauthorised assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The judge of the Kuntsevskiy District Court found that the applicant had known that the prefect's decision of 29 August 2003 had been reversed but had proceeded nevertheless with organisation of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charge of organising an unauthorised assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The judge of the Kuntsevskiy District Court fined the applicant 1,000 Russian roubles (approximately 30 euros) on the charge of organising an unauthorised assembly.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charge of organising an unauthorised assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 6 July 2004 the Moscow City Court upheld the decision fining the applicant on an appeal by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charge of organising an unauthorised assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The applicant challenged the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003 before the Kuntsevskiy District Court.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The applicant claimed that the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003 had no legal basis, arguing that Russian law did not permit cancellation of an authorised assembly.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The applicant claimed that the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003 had been issued too late, on the eve of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The applicant claimed that the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003 could not be founded on \"operative information\".", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The applicant sought a declaration that the police had unlawfully dispersed the assembly by force on 4 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Kuntsevskiy District Court asked Krylatskoye police station to produce the operative information which had been the basis for cancelling the authorisation for the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Kuntsevskiy District Court asked the police command of the Western Administrative District of Moscow to produce the operative information which had been the basis for cancelling the authorisation for the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 16 December 2003 Krylatskoye police station replied that there had been no operative information in their possession.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 21 January 2004 the police command of the Western Administrative District of Moscow replied that the material requested was classified as secret and for that reason could not be made available to the judge.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The applicant asked the Kuntsevskiy District Court to relinquish jurisdiction to the Moscow City Court, which was competent under national law to hear cases involving confidential material.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "In an interim decision of 30 January 2004, the Kuntsevskiy District Court refused the applicant's request to relinquish jurisdiction to the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "In its interim decision of 30 January 2004, the Kuntsevskiy District Court held that the purpose of the proceedings was to establish whether or not the prefect's decision had been lawful rather than whether the prefect had or had not received information from the law-enforcement authorities.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "In a judgment of 30 January 2004, the Kuntsevskiy District Court rejected the applicant's complaint against the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Kuntsevskiy District Court established that the prefect had issued the contested decision of 3 September 2003 further to a letter from the head of the police command of the Western Administrative District of 2 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "In the letter of 2 September 2003, the head of the police command of the Western Administrative District asked the prefect to annul his decision of 29 August 2003 because the police command \"had received, from various sources, information about potential terrorist attacks in Moscow, in places of mass gatherings\".", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Kuntsevskiy District Court found that no evidence contradicting the information contained in the letter from the police command of the Western Administrative District to the prefect of the Western Administrative District had been produced before the court.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Kuntsevskiy District Court found that the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003 was issued not in connection with the notice filed by the assembly organisers but in connection with a threat of increasing terrorist activities in the areas of mass gatherings, with a view to ensuring the security of the Krylatskoye District's residents.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Kuntsevskiy District Court found that the prefect acted within the competence of the State body and that his actions were appropriate to the presumed threat and complied with the Russian Constitution.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Kuntsevskiy District Court found that the actions of the Krylatskoye district police, which were aimed at preventing the mass action from taking place in connection with a real threat to life, health and security of citizens, were compatible with the Moscow regulations on co-ordinated police action during mass assemblies and the requirements of Article 17 § 3 of the Russian Constitution.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The applicant lodged an appeal against the Kuntsevskiy District Court's judgment of 30 January 2004.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The applicant submitted on appeal that not a single public gathering organised by the Moscow mayor's office in the framework of the \"Day of the City\" had been cancelled as a result of a potential terrorist threat.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The applicant submitted on appeal that the Kuntsevskiy District Court had failed to supply a concrete legal basis for the prefect's decision to cancel the assembly permit.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "On 8 April 2004 the Moscow City Court, in summary fashion, rejected the applicant's appeal against the Kuntsevskiy District Court's judgment of 30 January 2004.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Judicial review of the prefect's decision of 3 September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "On 13 November 2003 the applicant lodged a civil claim for damages against Krylatskoye police station, the Moscow branch of the federal treasury and the Ministry of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "On 25 March 2004 the applicant lodged a further civil claim for damages against Krylatskoye police station, the Moscow branch of the federal treasury and the Ministry of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The applicant sought compensation for unlawful arrest and overnight detention in inhuman conditions, without sleep, food or drink.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "On 6 July 2004 the Kuntsevskiy District Court dismissed the applicant's civil claim for damages.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Kuntsevskiy District Court dismissed the applicant's civil claim on the ground that Article 1070 of the Civil Code did not provide for State officials' liability for non-pecuniary damage incurred through unlawful administrative arrest.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On 14 April 2005 the Presidium of the Moscow City Court quashed the Kuntsevskiy District Court's decision of 6 July 2004 dismissing the applicant's civil claim.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "On 14 April 2005 the Presidium of the Moscow City Court remitted the applicant's civil claim for a fresh examination.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "On 16 November 2005 the Kuntsevskiy District Court dismissed the applicant's civil claim for damages again.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Kuntsevskiy District Court noted that in cases of administrative arrest, State officials would be liable for non-pecuniary damage only if a fault on their part were proven.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Kuntsevskiy District Court found that the applicant had been detained for 21 hours and 10 minutes for his failure to comply with a lawful police order.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The Kuntsevskiy District Court found that the applicant's arrest had been lawful because the Russian Constitution only required a judicial decision if the relevant period of custody exceeded forty-eight hours.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Kuntsevskiy District Court found that the administrative case against the applicant had been discontinued on a formal ground — the expiry of the prescription period — rather than by a finding of his innocence.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Kuntsevskiy District Court found that State officials had acted within their competence and powers and therefore could not be held liable for non-pecuniary damage sustained by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "On 2 March 2006 the Moscow City Court, on an appeal by the applicant, upheld the judgment of 16 November 2005 of the Kuntsevskiy District Court.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Moscow City Court endorsed, in summary fashion, the Kuntsevskiy District Court's reasoning in its judgment of 16 November 2005.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Civil claim for damages on account of unlawful arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Russian Constitution guarantees the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and the right to hold meetings, demonstrations, marches and pickets under Article 31.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 was in force at the material time pursuant to Russian Presidential Decree no. 524 of 25 May 1992.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Under Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988, organisers of an assembly were required to serve written notice on the municipal authorities no later than ten days before the planned assembly (§ 2).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Under Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988, the municipal authority was required to give its response no later than five days before the assembly (§ 3).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Under Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988, an assembly could be banned if its purpose was contrary to the Constitution or threatened public order or the security of citizens.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The provisional regulations on the procedure for notification of the executive branch of the Moscow authorities about meetings, street marches, demonstrations and pickets in streets, squares and other public places were approved by Presidential Decree no. 765 of 24 May 1993.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Under the provisional regulations approved by Presidential Decree no. 765 of 24 May 1993, notice of an assembly was to be served by the assembly organisers on the executive body between the fifteenth and tenth day before the planned assembly (§ 2).", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Under the provisional regulations approved by Presidential Decree no. 765 of 24 May 1993, the executive body could refuse to accept the notice if the purpose of the assembly was contrary to the principles of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, generally accepted public morals, if there was no undertaking on the part of the organisers to ensure public safety, if the assembly coincided in time and place with another one, if it threatened normal functioning of companies or organisations, or if it required suspending public or rail transport (§ 4).", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Under the provisional regulations approved by Presidential Decree no. 765 of 24 May 1993, the executive body, in cooperation with the organisers, could suggest a different place, time or route of the assembly in order to ensure public safety (§ 5).", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Under the provisional regulations approved by Presidential Decree no. 765 of 24 May 1993, refusal to accept notice of an assembly was amenable to judicial review (§ 10).", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Suppression of Terrorism Act (Federal Law no. 130-FZ of 25 July 1998) was in force at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Suppression of Terrorism Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Under the Suppression of Terrorism Act (Federal Law no. 130-FZ of 25 July 1998), the Ministry of the Interior fought terrorism by way of preventing, detecting and putting an end to terrorist offences pursuing lucrative goals (section 7 § 3).", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Suppression of Terrorism Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Under the Suppression of Terrorism Act (Federal Law no. 130-FZ of 25 July 1998), regional executive bodies, municipal bodies, public associations and organisations and State officials were required to assist the authorities responsible for suppression of terrorism (section 9 § 1).", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Suppression of Terrorism Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Under Article 27.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001, administrative arrest — a temporary restriction of liberty of an individual — may be ordered in exceptional circumstances where it is necessary for a correct and prompt examination of the administrative case.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Under Article 27.5 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001, the duration of administrative arrest must not exceed three hours, except for situations described in paragraphs 2 and 3 of that Article.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Under Article 27.5 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001, anyone who is subject to administrative proceedings concerning an offence punishable by administrative detention may be placed under administrative arrest for a period not exceeding forty-eight hours.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001, disobedience of a lawful order or demand of a police officer is punishable by an administrative fine or by up to fifteen days' administrative detention (administrativnyi arest).", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Under Article 1070 § 1 of the Civil Code, the State or regional treasury is liable — irrespective of any fault by State officials — for damage sustained by an individual on account of unlawful criminal prosecution, unlawful application of a preventive measure in the form of placement in custody or an undertaking not to leave the place of residence, or an unlawful administrative penalty in the form of detention or community work.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Compensation for unlawful deprivation of liberty"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Under Articles 1069 and 1064 of the Civil Code, damage incurred by an individual through unlawful acts of the investigation or prosecution authorities in a form other than those listed in Article 1070 § 1 is compensated for on the condition that the fault of the person who inflicted the damage has been proven.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Compensation for unlawful deprivation of liberty"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Under Articles 150 and 151 of the Civil Code, a court may hold the tortfeasor liable for non-pecuniary damage incurred by an individual through actions impairing his or her personal non-property rights, such as the right to personal integrity and the right to liberty of movement.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Compensation for unlawful deprivation of liberty"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Under Article 1100 § 2 of the Civil Code, non-pecuniary damage must be compensated for irrespective of the tortfeasor's fault in the event of unlawful conviction or prosecution, unlawful application of a preventive measure in the form of placement in custody or an undertaking not to leave the place of residence, or an unlawful administrative penalty in the form of detention or community service.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Compensation for unlawful deprivation of liberty"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F009", "F011", "F012", "F020", "F071"], "interference": ["F016", "F017", "F018", "F023", "F071"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F017", "F087"], "necessity": ["F017", "F078", "F079", "F080", "F081", "F082", "F083", "F084", "F085", "F087", "F088", "F091", "F095", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F012"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F009", "F011", "F020"], "interference": ["F016", "F023", "F071"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F017"], "necessity": ["F017", "F080", "F081", "F083", "F088", "F091", "F095", "F024", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F012"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F016", "F017", "F080", "F081", "F088", "F091", "F095", "F024", "F029", "F030", "F023", "F071"]}} {"case_name": "case_413", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F001", "F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_415", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_416", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1953.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Irkutsk.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "In 2003 the applicant was charged with fraud relating to the alleged misappropriation of money in the private company she had worked for.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant's criminal case was brought before the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "In the course of the trial before the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk, the applicant dismissed several legal-aid lawyers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk appointed lawyer V. as defence counsel for the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "During the court proceedings before the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk, an issue arose as to the applicant's mental state and ability to stand trial.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 14 October 2003, after hearing the parties including the applicant and lawyer V., the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk decided that the applicant should undergo an out-patient psychiatric examination in the regional psychiatric hospital.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant refused to comply with the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk's order of 14 October 2003 to undergo an out-patient psychiatric examination.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "A trial hearing was scheduled for 27 November 2003, inter alia, to settle the issue of the applicant's psychiatric examination.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant did not appear at the trial hearing scheduled for 27 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 27 November 2003, the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk ordered the applicant's detention.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The prosecutor requested the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk to order the applicant's detention on the grounds that she had been obstructing the court proceedings by refusing to undergo a psychiatric examination and had failed to attend the hearing without a valid excuse.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Article 247 of the Code of Criminal Procedure authorises a court to order that a defaulting defendant be brought before the court or to order or vary a preventive measure.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Article 97 of the Code of Criminal Procedure authorises a court to order a preventive measure if there is a risk that the defendant would obstruct the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk observed that despite its court order of 14 October 2003 the applicant refused to undergo a psychiatric examination.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant, having been informed of the date and time of the hearing on 27 November 2003, failed to attend it and did not provide any valid excuse.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 27 November 2003, the applicant came to the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk's registry, submitted a request there, and left the court building.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk found that the applicant was obstructing the proceedings, which justified her placement in custody.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk took into account that the applicant was charged with a serious criminal offence when ordering her detention.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk ordered the applicant's arrest and detention in Irkutsk remand centre.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "By a separate decision issued on 27 November 2003, the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk ordered that the applicant should be placed in the regional psychiatric hospital for the purpose of an in-patient psychiatric examination.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On the evening of 27 November 2003, the applicant was arrested at her home.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "After being arrested at her home on 27 November 2003, the applicant was taken to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "An arrest record was compiled at the police station, stating that the grounds and reasons for the applicant's arrest were a court order.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The arrest record stated that the applicant had been informed of her rights under Article 46 § 4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, including the right to be informed of the nature of the accusation against her, to receive a copy of a decision to institute criminal proceedings, or a copy of the arrest record, or a copy of a detention order.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant wrote in the arrest record that her arrest was unlawful and that she had not had access to the document in which the grounds for her arrest were stated.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On the evening of 27 November 2003, the applicant was placed in Irkutsk remand centre.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 28 November 2003, the applicant appealed against the detention order of 27 November 2003 to the Irkutsk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the applicant, without a copy of the detention order of 27 November 2003 she could only make a preliminary statement of appeal.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant dispatched her appeal to the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk, which received it on 2 December 2003.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant dispatched her appeal to the Irkutsk Regional Court, which received it on 3 December 2003.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 2 December 2003, the applicant was served with a copy of the detention order of 27 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 4 December 2003, the applicant's next of kin retained lawyer Sh.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 4 December 2003, lawyer Sh. lodged an additional appeal against the detention order of 27 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicant was provided with a copy of lawyer Sh.'s appeal against the detention order.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 10 December 2003, the applicant lodged a request to be brought to the appeal hearing concerning the detention order of 27 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 10 December 2003, the Irkutsk Regional Court returned the appeal against the detention order to the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk to enable the latter to inform the other parties to the criminal proceedings of the appeal.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 19 December 2003, the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk informed the other parties to the criminal proceedings of the appeal against the detention order.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The psychiatric examination of the applicant took place from 10 to 15 December 2003 in the regional psychiatric hospital in Irkutsk.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 16 December 2003, the medical panel issued a psychiatric report indicating that it was not possible to draw a clear conclusion as to the applicant's mental state and ability to stand trial.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The medical panel recommended further examination of the applicant in Moscow psychiatric hospital.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 16 or 19 December 2003, the applicant submitted to the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk or the Irkutsk Regional Court a document dated 10 December 2003 by which Mr G., head officer of the medical unit of the remand centre, indicated that it would be opportune to examine whether the applicant could be released from detention.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 22 December 2003, the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk again submitted the applicant's and her lawyers' appeals to the Irkutsk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Irkutsk Regional Court received the applicant's and her lawyers' appeals on 23 December 2003.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 25 December 2003, the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk held a trial hearing during which it dismissed counsel's application for the applicant's release.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 25 December 2003, the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk ordered a new psychiatric examination of the applicant in Moscow psychiatric hospital.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On an unspecified date, lawyer Sh. submitted to the Irkutsk Regional Court a letter dated 25 December 2003 by which the Regional Department of Justice indicated that the relevant official registers contained no information about the applicant's court-appointed lawyer, advocate V.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 5 January 2004, the applicant withdrew her request to be brought to the appeal hearing concerning the detention order of 27 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 7 January 2004, the applicant was transferred to Moscow for a psychiatric examination.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "According to the Government, due to the winter holiday period the appeal hearing concerning the applicant's detention order of 27 November 2003 was listed in the Irkutsk Regional Court for 8 January 2004.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 8 January 2004, the Irkutsk Regional Court returned the detention appeal file to the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk for an internal inquiry.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The reason for the adjournment on 8 January 2004 was apparently the need to verify whether the applicant had legal assistance during the hearing on her pre-trial detention on 27 November 2003 and whether Ms V. was a professional advocate.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 19 January 2004, Ms V. submitted a written statement confirming that she was a professional advocate.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 19 January 2004, Ms V. submitted a written statement confirming that she had attended court hearings in the applicant's criminal case on 14 October and 17 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On an unspecified date, the President of the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk obtained a certificate from Mr G. indicating that the applicant was fit for detention and was receiving the necessary medical care in the remand centre.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "After the inquiry requested by the Irkutsk Regional Court, on 4 February 2004 the detention appeal file was returned to the Irkutsk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The appeal hearing concerning the detention order of 27 November 2003 was scheduled for 26 February 2004.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 26 February 2004, the Irkutsk Regional Court heard the prosecutor and counsel in the appeal concerning the detention order of 27 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 26 February 2004, the Irkutsk Regional Court upheld the detention order of 27 November 2003.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Irkutsk Regional Court held on 26 February 2004 that the certificate submitted by the defence was not sufficient to warrant the applicant's immediate release from detention because another certificate issued by the same detention centre confirmed that the applicant was fit for detention.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Irkutsk Regional Court noted on 26 February 2004 that the applicant needed a gynaecological consultation, which could be carried out at a later date.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In April 2004, the Irkutsk Regional Court examined and dismissed the applicant's request for a supervisory review in respect of the appeal decision of 26 February 2004.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "In April 2004, the Irkutsk Regional Court noted that advocate V. had been present at the first-instance hearing on the applicant's detention and that reference to the applicant's own presence had been a clerical error.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicant was released in May 2004.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "By judgment of 21 September 2007, the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of Irkutsk acquitted the applicant of the fraud charges.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 28 July 2008, the Irkutsk Regional Court upheld the judgment of 21 September 2007 acquitting the applicant of the fraud charges.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "In May 2005, after the applicant had been released from detention but while the criminal case against her was still pending, the applicant and two others, Ms I. and Ms B., decided to stage a static demonstration (пикетирование) in front of various public authorities in Moscow, including the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The purpose of the static demonstration planned by the applicant, Ms I. and Ms B. was to protest against the allegedly unlawful actions of public authorities and corruption.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstration related to persistent difficulties in relation to pending cases involving law enforcement agencies and courts, in particular in the Irkutsk Region, and the failure of the local authorities to deal with their grievances.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 30 May 2005, the applicant, Ms I. and Ms B. sent a telegram to the Moscow Mayor's Office informing the authorities of their intention to stage static demonstrations between 3 and 16 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 31 May 2005, the Moscow Mayor's Office acknowledged receipt of the telegram sent by the applicant, Ms I. and Ms B. on 30 May 2005.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 7 June 2005 at 9.30 a.m., the applicant and her friends Ms I. and Ms B. placed themselves on a pavement separated from the building of the Federal Judges Qualifications Board by a road.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 7 June 2005, Ms I. and Ms B. unfolded banners/posters containing their message during the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "At 9.45 a.m. on 7 June 2005, the applicant and her friends were approached by several police officers, one of whom asked them to show documents justifying their demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The applicant explained to the police officer that they needed no authorisation and produced the telegram message sent to the Moscow Mayor's Office and the certified copy of the telegram bearing the mayor's office stamp.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 7 June 2005, the police officer told the applicant and her friends to cease their demonstration and follow him to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The applicant and her friends refused to comply with the police officer's order to cease their demonstration and follow him to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The police officer compelled the applicant and her friends to follow him to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "An arrest record was drawn up at the police station stating that the applicant was brought to the police station at 9.45 a.m. on 7 June 2005 in relation to an administrative offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences for the purpose of compiling a record under Article 27.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The applicant wrote in the arrest record that she had not been informed of her rights and did not understand them.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "While in the police station on 7 June 2005, the applicant made a written statement indicating that she came to Moscow to protect her rights against various law enforcement agencies.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The applicant's written statement at the police station stated that she was holding a static demonstration at 9.45 a.m. on 7 June 2005 in conformity with the Public Gatherings Act, as notified to the authorities on 30 May 2005.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The applicant's written statement at the police station stated that she was arrested by a person wearing a police uniform who refused to introduce himself and to show his licence.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The applicant's written statement at the police station stated that the officers told her that their superior had ordered that the demonstrators be taken to the police station without explaining the actual reasons for the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The applicant's written statement at the police station stated that under section 18 of the Public Gatherings Act the police should not impede the exercise of the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The applicant's written statement at the police station stated that there were no reasons to stop and disperse the demonstration under section 15 of the Public Gatherings Act.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The applicant's written statement at the police station stated that the officer refused her request to call her next of kin and to inform them of her arrest.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The police compiled an administrative offence report stating that on 7 June 2005 the applicant held a non-authorised demonstration, thereby committing an administrative offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The applicant wrote in the administrative offence report that she had not been informed of her rights and did not understand them.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The applicant wrote in the administrative offence report that she had not been given a copy of the report despite her request.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "1. The demonstration in Moscow and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The police decided that the applicant and her friends should be brought before the Justice of the Peace in the 375th Circuit of the Arbatskiy District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Justice of the Peace in the 375th Circuit of the Arbatskiy District of Moscow was informed of the incoming cases and scheduled their examination for 5 p.m. on 7 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "A photocopy of a document dated 11 June 2004 and signed by the President of the Presnenskiy District Court indicates that under the regulations of that court the public had access to the premises until 6 p.m. during weekdays.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The office of the Justice of the Peace who dealt with the applicant's case was situated in the same building as the Presnenskiy District Court.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "According to the applicant, she and her friends were brought to the premises of the Presnenskiy District Court some time after 7 p.m. on 7 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Justice of the Peace first examined Ms I.'s case, in which the applicant acted as a lay defender.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The examination of the applicant's case before the Justice of the Peace started at or around 10 p.m. on 7 June 2005 and lasted some minutes.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Justice of the Peace granted the applicant's request to have access to the case file.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The applicant unsuccessfully sought an adjournment before the Justice of the Peace to have time to study the case file and to prepare her defence.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Justice of the Peace found the applicant guilty of non-compliance with a lawful order by a police officer, an offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Justice of the Peace sentenced the applicant to seven days of detention, to be counted from the moment of her arrest on the morning of 7 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The applicant wrote in the court record that she had lodged a request and challenged the judge but that these motions had not been examined.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Justice of the Peace established that on 7 June 2005 the applicant failed to comply with a lawful order by police officers and failed to end a non-authorised demonstration in front of the Supreme Court of Russia.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The applicant pleaded not guilty before the Justice of the Peace.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The Justice of the Peace granted the applicant's request to have her co-participants in the demonstration as lay defenders in the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Justice of the Peace dismissed the applicant's request to obtain external video recordings of the building of the Supreme Court of Russia, finding no reason to doubt the veracity of the administrative offence record.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Police officer Mr S. was heard as a witness before the Justice of the Peace and stated that he and his colleagues asked the demonstration participants to show documents relating to the authorisation of the public event.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Police officer Mr S. stated that the applicant handed over a telegram and that since there were doubts as to the authenticity of the document, the applicant and the other two were asked to show their identity documents.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Police officer Mr S. stated that since the applicant and the other two refused to show identity documents despite several warnings, the police took them to the police station to determine their identities and to determine the circumstances relating to the lawfulness of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Police officer Mr S. stated that since the applicant and the others refused to follow the police, they were compelled to do so.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Justice of the Peace found that the documents produced by the applicant had been amended and that the police officers had sufficient reasons to doubt their authenticity.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Justice of the Peace found that the police officers' order to the applicant and her companions to accompany them to the police station was lawful and justified, also in view of the defendants' refusals to show identity documents.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Justice of the Peace rejected the applicant's allegation that she was not asked to show her identity documents.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Ms I. was sentenced to five days of detention by the Justice of the Peace.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Ms B. was sentenced to six days of detention by the Justice of the Peace.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The applicant was released on 14 June 2005, having served the sentence imposed by the Justice of the Peace.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The applicant and her friends appealed against the judgments of 7 June 2005 to the Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "On 24 June 2005, the applicant was notified of the date and time of the appeal hearing before the Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "On 27 June 2005, the applicant asked that her lay defenders be informed of the date, time and place of the appeal hearing before the Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "On 27 June 2005, the Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow examined the applicant's appeal against the judgment of 7 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "On 27 June 2005, the Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow upheld the judgment of 7 June 2005 against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow found on 27 June 2005 that on 7 June 2005 the applicant held a non-authorised demonstration and held a banner containing a very negative assessment of the professional activity of the Prosecutor General, the President of the Supreme Court and the Minister of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow found on 27 June 2005 that the applicant refused to comply with lawful orders to end the violation of the public order and threatened police officers with prosecution, thereby resisting a lawful order by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow noted on 27 June 2005 that under sections 5 and 12 of the Public Gatherings Act one has a right to assemble at a venue and at an hour previously indicated in a notification to the competent authority.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow noted on 27 June 2005 that section 8 of the Public Gatherings Act prohibits public events in the immediate vicinity of court buildings.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow noted on 27 June 2005 that section 17 of the Public Gatherings Act provides that failure to comply with a lawful order of the police or resistance to the police entails the liability of the persons concerned.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "On 1 July 2005, the Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow examined Ms I.'s appeal and discontinued the administrative offence case against her.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow found on 1 July 2005 that the administrative offence record against Ms I. contained no indication of the content of the repeated orders of the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Police officer Mr P. explained to the Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow on appeal that the administrative case against Ms I. concerned unlawful demonstrating.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow found on 1 July 2005 that the administrative proceedings against Ms I. were initiated in relation to a fact falling within the scope of Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences rather than Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow found on 1 July 2005 that sufficient evidence was not adduced at first instance to find Ms I. guilty of the offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "On 6 July 2005, the Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow quashed the first-instance judgment in respect of Ms B. and discontinued the administrative offence case against her.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow found on 6 July 2005 that it followed from reports made by police officers that Ms B. was arrested after the group had attempted to carry out a non-authorised demonstration, that she failed to comply with repeated orders of police officers and shouted.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow found on 6 July 2005 that the administrative offence record against Ms B. referred to unlawful demonstrating falling within the scope of Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow found on 6 July 2005 that the administrative offence record against Ms B. was not signed by the head officer.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow found on 6 July 2005 that sufficient evidence was not adduced at first instance to find Ms B. guilty of the offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The applicant lodged numerous complaints against the Justice of the Peace who convicted her.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "By a letter of 5 September 2005, the Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow dismissed the applicant's complaint against the Justice of the Peace.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow's letter of 5 September 2005 indicated that, as explained by the Justice of the Peace, he had examined the cases against the applicant and her friends between 5 p.m. and 10 p.m. on 7 June 2005.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "2. Court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "According to the applicant, from 7 to 9 June 2005 she was kept in the police station without food or drink.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "3. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "According to the applicant, the cell in the police station where she was held from 7 to 9 June 2005 had no windows or system of ventilation.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "3. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "According to the applicant, she had no access to a toilet while held in the police station from 7 to 9 June 2005 and had to urinate in the presence of other detainees, including male detainees.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "3. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "According to the applicant, from 9 to 14 June 2005 she was kept in a detention facility where, despite her illnesses, she was forced to clean the premises.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Administrative offence proceedings against the applicant", "3. Conditions of detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Article 97 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provided at the relevant time that an investigator or a court could order a preventive measure, for instance detention, if there were sufficient grounds to consider that the defendant would flee investigation or trial, would continue his criminal activity or would threaten a witness or otherwise obstruct the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Detention pending criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Article 247 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provided that a court was empowered to order that the defaulting defendant be brought to the trial, or to order or vary a preventive measure.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Detention pending criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Section 7(1) of the Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) provided that a person organising a public gathering (except for a meeting or a static demonstration) should notify in writing the competent public authority not earlier than fifteen and not later than ten days before the date of the event.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Section 7(1) of the Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) provided that for a static demonstration by several people notification may be made no later than three days before the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "Section 7(3) of the Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) provided that a notification should contain a reference to the aim of the event, the type of the event, the venue(s) and itineraries, the date and time of the event, the expected number of participants, and the full name, contact address and telephone number of the event organiser.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "Section 12(1) of the Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) provided that the competent public authority should acknowledge in writing receipt of the notification and indicate the date and time of receipt.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "Section 12(1) of the Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) provided that the competent public authority should inform the event organiser on the same day — in the case of a notification received less than five days before a static demonstration by several people — of any alternative proposal concerning the event venue and/or time.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "Under the Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004), an organiser of a public gathering was obliged to submit a notification of the public event in conformity with the requirements of section 7 of the Act.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "Under the Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004), an organiser of a public gathering was obliged to inform the public authority in writing whether the alternative proposal concerning the event time and/or venue was accepted.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Under the Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004), an organiser of a public gathering was obliged to suspend the event or end it if the event participants committed unlawful actions.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "Section 5 of the Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) provided that the organiser of the event is not allowed to proceed with it if the notification was not submitted in conformity with the time-limit or if the authority's alternative proposal for another venue and/or time for the event was not settled with the public authority.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "Under the Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004), a public event could be held in any suitable venue.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "Section 8 of the Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004) provided that no public event could be held in the immediate vicinity of court buildings.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that non-compliance with a lawful order by a police officer, given within the scope of his or her professional duties, is punishable by a fine or administrative detention of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Code of Administrative Offences (CAO)", "1. Material law"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that violation of the rules or procedure for organising or participating in a public gathering (a meeting, demonstration or static demonstration) is punishable by a fine.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Code of Administrative Offences (CAO)", "1. Material law"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "Article 25.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that a person prosecuted in administrative offence proceedings has the right to have access to the case file, to make submissions, to adduce evidence, to lodge requests and to legal assistance.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Code of Administrative Offences (CAO)", "2. Procedural law"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "Article 25.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that the administrative case should be examined in the presence of the person prosecuted.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Code of Administrative Offences (CAO)", "2. Procedural law"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "Article 25.5 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that a defendant in an administrative case may be assisted by an advocate or another person chosen by the defendant.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Code of Administrative Offences (CAO)", "2. Procedural law"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "Article 27.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that in exceptional circumstances relating to the needs for a proper and expedient examination of the administrative case, the person concerned may be placed under administrative arrest.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Code of Administrative Offences (CAO)", "2. Procedural law"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "Article 27.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that the arrestee should be informed of his rights and obligations and that this notification should be mentioned in the arrest record.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Code of Administrative Offences (CAO)", "2. Procedural law"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "Article 28.8 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that the competent public authority should compile the administrative offence file and transmit it to the competent court for examination, with the file to be sent within one day, or immediately if administrative detention or deportation may be incurred.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Code of Administrative Offences (CAO)", "2. Procedural law"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "Article 29.6 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that a court should examine the administrative case within fifteen days, to which one month may be added if additional evidence is needed.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Code of Administrative Offences (CAO)", "2. Procedural law"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "Article 29.6 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that if the administrative charge concerns an offence punishable by administrative detention, the case should be examined on the day when the administrative record was submitted to the court or within forty-eight hours of the defendant's arrest.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Code of Administrative Offences (CAO)", "2. Procedural law"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "Article 24.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences provided that administrative cases should be examined at a public hearing, except in cases relating to State or other protected secrets or where it is necessary to protect the honour or reputation of the person(s) participating in the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Code of Administrative Offences (CAO)", "2. Procedural law"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "Chapter 25 of the Code of Administrative Offences, entitled 'Participants in administrative offence proceedings, their rights and obligations', lists the following participants: the defendant, the victim, legal representatives of a person or a legal entity, a witness, a defender or a representative, an attesting witness, an expert, a translator and a prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Code of Administrative Offences (CAO)", "2. Procedural law"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "Article 25.11 of the Code of Administrative Offences provides that a public prosecutor may institute administrative offence proceedings, take part in the examination of the case, make requests, deliver opinions, appeal against the court decision, and carry out other actions prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Code of Administrative Offences (CAO)", "2. Procedural law"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F068", "F069", "F073", "F077", "F078", "F089", "F104", "F123"], "interference": ["F077", "F078", "F079", "F080", "F089", "F101", "F102", "F104", "F109", "F110", "F113", "F122", "F123", "F124"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F101", "F104", "F122", "F123", "F124"], "necessity": ["F068", "F071", "F073", "F080", "F089", "F101", "F102", "F104", "F122", "F123", "F124", "F125", "F126", "F128", "F129", "F131", "F132", "F133", "F135", "F137", "F149", "F157", "F163"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F068", "F073", "F089", "F104"], "interference": ["F079", "F089", "F102", "F104"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": ["F123"], "necessity": ["F068", "F071", "F073", "F080", "F089", "F102", "F104", "F122", "F123", "F124", "F126", "F128", "F133", "F163"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F068", "F071", "F073", "F080", "F089", "F102", "F104", "F123", "F126", "F128", "F133", "F163"]}} {"case_name": "case_417", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of the lack of impartiality of the tribunal in view of the absence of the prosecuting party in administrative-offence proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention, in addition to their complaint about the lack of impartiality of the tribunal.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F003"], "interference": ["F001", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F001"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F001", "F003"], "interference": ["F001"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F001"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F001", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_418", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_419", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_424", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1960.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 19 February 2008 a presidential election was held in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the then Prime Minister, Mr Sargsyan, representing the ruling party.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the main opposition candidate, Mr Ter-Petrosyan.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "During the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election campaign, the applicant acted as an authorised election assistant for Mr Ter-Petrosyan.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "During the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election campaign, the applicant was a member of Mr Ter-Petrosyan's central election headquarters.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Immediately after the announcement of the preliminary results of the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election, Mr Ter-Petrosyan called on his supporters to gather at Freedom Square in central Yerevan in order to protest against alleged irregularities in the election process.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Mr Ter-Petrosyan announced that the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election had not been free and fair.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "From 20 February 2008 onwards, nationwide daily protest rallies were held by Mr Ter-Petrosyan's supporters.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The main meeting place of Mr Ter-Petrosyan's supporters during the daily protest rallies from 20 February 2008 onwards was Freedom Square and the surrounding park in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The rallies at Freedom Square attracted at times tens of thousands of people.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Several hundred demonstrators stayed at Freedom Square and the surrounding area around the clock, having set up a camp.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant was an active participant in the rallies at Freedom Square, regularly attending the ongoing demonstrations and sit-ins from 20 February 2008 onwards.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 1 March 2008, apparently at some point between 6 and 7 a.m., police forces arrived on Freedom Square in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Government alleged that the purpose of the 1 March 2008 police operation at Freedom Square was the verification of information obtained by the police a day earlier, according to which the demonstrators possessed arms and ammunition.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Government alleged that the members of the police force who arrived at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008 were not equipped with any protective gear.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Government alleged that hundreds of demonstrators armed with metal rods and wooden clubs had gathered at Freedom Square, waiting for the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators attacked the police officers at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008, hitting them and throwing stones, pointed metal objects and Molotov cocktails at them.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Government alleged that numerous police officers were injured as a result of the demonstrators' attack at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant was present at Freedom Square when the police operation was conducted on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant contested the Government's allegations and submitted that the assembly at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008 had been peaceful and none of the demonstrators had been armed.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant submitted that it was the police who had attacked the peaceful demonstrators at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008, using excessive force, in order to terminate the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "As a result of the police operation on 1 March 2008, all the demonstrators present at Freedom Square, including the applicant, fled from the square.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 1 March 2008 a criminal case was instituted in connection with the events at Freedom Square, which was later examined under case number 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The decision instituting criminal case no. 62202608 stated that Mr Ter-Petrosyan and a number of other opposition leaders and activists had organised and held unlawful demonstrations at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The decision instituting criminal case no. 62202608 stated that Mr Ter-Petrosyan and a number of other opposition leaders and activists had incited disobedience of the orders to end the unauthorised demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The decision instituting criminal case no. 62202608 stated that a number of demonstrators had illegally carried arms and ammunition and committed life- and health-threatening assault on police officers.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the record of the applicant's bringing-in drafted by arresting police officers H.K. and E.K., the applicant was brought in to Kanaker-Zeytun Police Station from Freedom Square at 8.50 a.m. on 1 March 2008 on suspicion of having put up resistance to a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Police officer H.K. reported in writing to the chief of Kanaker-Zeytun Police Station that the applicant had been brought in from Freedom Square for having put up resistance by disobeying their lawful orders, refusing to be taken to the police station, pushing them and trying to flee.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Police officer E.K. reported in writing to the chief of Kanaker-Zeytun Police Station that the applicant had been brought in from Freedom Square for having put up resistance by disobeying their lawful orders, refusing to be taken to the police station, pushing them and trying to flee.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant was questioned as a witness and stated that he had continuously participated in the demonstrations at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant stated that on 1 March 2008, early in the morning, police forces had arrived at Freedom Square and started violently dispersing the demonstrators gathered there.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The applicant stated that he had tried to persuade the police officers not to apply force at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008, but had been attacked with tear gas and batons and had been pushed to the ground.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant stated that after getting to his feet at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008, he had walked towards Northern Avenue.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicant stated that two other demonstrators, H.M. and A.O., whom he knew personally, had walked along with him towards Northern Avenue on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant stated that as he reached the intersection of Northern Avenue and Abovyan Street on 1 March 2008, police officers had approached them, taken them by the arms and ordered them to follow to a nearby location.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant stated that he, H.M. and A.O. had been handcuffed and taken by car to Kanaker-Zeytun Police Station on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the materials of the case, besides the applicant, several other opposition supporters were taken that morning of 1 March 2008 from Freedom Square to Kanaker-Zeytun Police Station, including H.M. and A.O.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 2 March 2008 the investigator drew up a record of the applicant's arrest, indicating that the applicant was suspected of having committed offences under Article 225.1 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code (inciting disobedience to an order to terminate an unlawful assembly).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 2 March 2008 the investigator drew up a record of the applicant's arrest, indicating that the applicant was suspected of having committed offences under Article 316 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code (life or health-threatening assault on a public official).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Police officer H.K. was questioned and stated that he had participated in the police operation at Freedom Square in the early morning of 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Police officer E.K. was questioned and stated that he had participated in the police operation at Freedom Square in the early morning of 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Police officer H.K. stated that the demonstrators at Freedom Square, when ordered to terminate the assembly on 1 March 2008, had put up resistance, assaulted the police officers and fled.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Police officer H.K. stated that, having been given the task of pursuing and finding persons who had fled Freedom Square, he had stopped one man who was walking with a few others for an identity check at the intersection of Northern Avenue and Abovyan Street on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Police officer H.K. stated that the man he stopped at the intersection of Northern Avenue and Abovyan Street had been calm at first, but after being asked to follow him to a police station to check whether he had been involved in the unlawful events at Freedom Square, the man had pushed him and tried to flee.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Police officer H.K. stated that police officer E.K. had approached at that moment, and the man had pushed police officer E.K. as well, but then the man had surrendered to the officers and had been taken to Kanaker-Zeytun Police Station where he had been identified as the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "Police officer H.K. stated that the two persons walking with the applicant had been taken away by other police officers before he had stopped the applicant at the intersection of Northern Avenue and Abovyan Street.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Police officer E.K. made submissions similar to those of police officer H.K. regarding the events at the intersection of Northern Avenue and Abovyan Street on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the applicant was formally charged under Article 225.1 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code (inciting disobedience to an order to terminate an unlawful assembly) within the scope of criminal case no. 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the applicant was formally charged under Article 316 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code (life or health-threatening assault on a public official) within the scope of criminal case no. 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The decision charging the applicant on 4 March 2008 stated that the applicant, having participated from 20 February 2008 in the unlawful assembly organised by Mr Ter-Petrosyan and his co-thinkers, incited disobedience of the orders to end the assembly, accompanied with public insults addressed at public officials.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The decision charging the applicant on 4 March 2008 stated that on 1 March 2008 at around 6 a.m., when police officers demanded participants in the demonstration at Freedom Square to allow verification of information that they possessed arms and ammunition and warned them to end the unlawful event, the applicant and other demonstrators disobeyed the police officers' lawful orders and committed life- and health-threatening assault on them, causing injuries of various nature and degree.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The applicant was questioned and denied having incited disobedience or inflicted any violence on the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the applicant was remanded in custody.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 27 March 2008 the investigator dropped the charges against the applicant under Article 225.1 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code (inciting disobedience to an order to terminate an unlawful assembly) for lack of evidence.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 27 March 2008 the investigator dropped the charges against the applicant under Article 316 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code (life or health-threatening assault on a public official) for lack of evidence.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 27 March 2008 the investigator brought a new charge against the applicant under Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (non-life or health-threatening assault on a public official) in respect of the same facts as in the initial charge.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 27 March 2008 the applicant was questioned and once again denied having done anything illegal at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 27 March 2008 the applicant stated that when he had been approached in the street by the two police officers, he had been agitated because of the effect of the tear gas and had behaved in a way which was later assessed as unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 27 March 2008 the applicant stated that he admitted his guilt for having assaulted the two police officers, H.K. and E.K., in a non-life and health-threatening way.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 3 April 2008 the bill of indictment was approved under Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (non-life or health-threatening assault on a public official) and the applicant's case was referred to a court.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 28 April 2008 the applicant's trial commenced in the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "During the trial before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan, the applicant retracted the admission of guilt he had made during the investigation and pleaded not guilty.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "During the trial before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan, the applicant stated that he had not assaulted the two police officers H.K. and E.K., who he alleged had made false statements.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Police officers H.K. and E.K. were questioned as witnesses before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan and maintained their statements against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "According to the applicant, he had been unable to question properly the police officers H.K. and E.K. in court as the trial judge disallowed some of the questions, namely those related to the lawfulness of the police actions at Freedom Square in the morning of 1 March 2008, as not related to the circumstances of the case under examination.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The applicant requested the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan to call H.M. and A.O. as witnesses, stating that they had been with him at the time of the alleged incident and had witnessed that he had not assaulted the two police officers H.K. and E.K.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "In support of his request to call H.M. and A.O. as witnesses, the applicant submitted written statements by H.M. and A.O. in which they corroborated his account of events.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan adjourned the examination of the applicant's request to call H.M. and A.O. as witnesses until the other evidence in the case file had been examined.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 15 May 2008 the applicant repeated his request to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan to call H.M. and A.O. as witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 15 May 2008 the applicant argued before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that the case against him, based solely on the statements of police officers H.K. and E.K., was trumped up and that he was basically prosecuted for having exercised his freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 2 June 2008 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan examined and dismissed the applicant's request to call H.M. and A.O. as witnesses, holding that it was unnecessary to call them on the ground that there was sufficient evidence in the case file.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 16 June 2008 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found the applicant guilty under Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (non-life or health-threatening assault on a public official).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 16 June 2008 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan sentenced the applicant to three years' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant had participated on a daily basis in mass public events, marches, around-the-clock demonstrations and sit-ins held continuously from 20 February 2008 in violation of the procedure prescribed by law and disrupting the capital's life, traffic, normal functioning of public institutions and peace and calm of the population.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that on 1 March 2008 at around 7 a.m., when police officers demanded the demonstrators gathered at Freedom Square to give them a possibility to verify the veracity of the information that the demonstrators possessed arms and ammunition and once again warned them to end the unlawful event, the applicant disobeyed the lawful orders of police officers H.K. and E.K. and assaulted them in a non-life or health-threatening way by pushing and pulling them.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "In reaching its findings, the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan relied on the statements of police officers H.K. and E.K.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "On 3 July 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal arguing that the trial court, by dismissing his request to call H.M. and A.O. as witnesses and relying solely on the witness statements of police officers H.K. and E.K., had violated his right to a fair trial as protected by Article 6 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 3 July 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal arguing that his prosecution and conviction had been in violation of Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 3 July 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal arguing that his prosecution and conviction had been in violation of Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 3 July 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal arguing that his prosecution and conviction had been in violation of Article 14 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "During the examination of the applicant's appeal by the Criminal Court of Appeal, the applicant lodged a request to call H.M. and A.O. as witnesses, similar to the one lodged before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On 24 September 2008 the Criminal Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal and upheld his conviction.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 24 September 2008 the Criminal Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's request to call H.M. and A.O. as witnesses, finding that the applicant's submissions were insufficient to conclude that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan's dismissal of that request had been unfounded.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal held that, as could be seen from the materials of the case, before police officers H.K. and E.K. had approached the applicant, both H.M. and A.O. had already been taken from the scene by other police officers and had therefore not witnessed the incident involving the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "On 17 December 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal on points of law before the Court of Cassation, raising arguments similar to those raised in his earlier appeal.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "On 22 January 2009 the Court of Cassation declared the applicant's appeal on points of law inadmissible for lack of merit.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic law and practice, as well as of the relevant international materials, can be found in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (application no. 23086/08, §§ 91-134, judgment of 20 September 2018).", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE AND RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F010", "F011", "F014", "F015", "F021", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F074", "F089"], "interference": ["F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F058", "F062", "F074", "F075"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F014", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F045", "F046", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F056", "F057", "F058", "F074", "F075", "F077", "F078"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F010", "F011", "F014", "F015", "F021", "F089"], "interference": ["F058", "F074", "F075"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F014", "F037", "F045", "F050", "F051", "F056", "F057", "F058", "F077", "F078"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F014", "F021", "F037", "F045", "F050", "F051", "F056", "F057", "F058", "F077", "F078", "F089"]}} {"case_name": "case_426", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_427", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' details are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The Government were represented by Mr G. Matyushkin, Representative of the Russian Federation at the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr A. Fedorov, Head of the Office of the Representative of the Russian Federation at the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr M. Galperin, Representative of the Russian Federation at the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 24 February 2014, the final hearing in the criminal case concerning the mass disorder at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow on 6 May 2012 took place at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Seven participants in the events at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow on 6 May 2012 were sentenced to prison terms of two and a half years and four years.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The criminal proceedings concerning the mass disorder at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow on 6 May 2012 were considered by many to be driven by political reasons.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The criminal proceedings concerning the mass disorder at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow on 6 May 2012 attracted a lot of public and media attention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "In the evening of 24 February 2014, a public gathering in support of the convicted activists took place at Tverskaya Street in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "In the evening of 24 February 2014, a public gathering in support of the convicted activists took place at Malaya Sadovaya Street in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The public meetings on 24 February 2014 at Tverskaya Street in Moscow and at Malaya Sadovaya Street in St Petersburg had been advertised on social media.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The authorities had not been notified of the public gatherings on 24 February 2014 at Tverskaya Street in Moscow and at Malaya Sadovaya Street in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicants took part in the public meetings on 24 February 2014 at Tverskaya Street in Moscow and at Malaya Sadovaya Street in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "There is no information that the public meetings on 24 February 2014 at Tverskaya Street in Moscow and at Malaya Sadovaya Street in St Petersburg turned violent.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The protesters at the public meetings on 24 February 2014 shouted political slogans.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The police warned the protesters at the public meetings on 24 February 2014 through megaphones that the gatherings had not been authorised.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The police instructed the protesters at the public meetings on 24 February 2014 to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicants were apprehended and transferred to various police stations following the public meetings on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On the dates stipulated in the appended table, the applicants were convicted under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences for breaching the procedure for the organisation or conduct of public gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicants were sentenced to fines ranging between 10,000 Russian roubles (RUB 10,000) and RUB 20,000, as set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant in application no. 3093/15 was convicted under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences for a refusal to obey a lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant in application no. 3093/15 was ordered to pay RUB 1,000.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The domestic courts in the case of the applicant in application no. 3093/15 relied on the administrative record, the reports and explanations of the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The domestic courts considered it unlawful that the applicant in application no. 3093/15 shouted slogans during a public assembly in respect of which no advance notification had been submitted to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The domestic courts considered it unlawful that the applicant in application no. 3093/15 refused to stop participating in a public assembly in respect of which no advance notification had been submitted to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law, see Navalnyy v. Russia [GC] (nos. 29580/12 and 4 others, §§ 46-47, 15 November 2018).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The domestic legal provisions governing administrative transfer (escorting) and detention are set out in the case of Butkevich v. Russia (no. 5865/07, §§ 33-36, 13 February 2018).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to Article 31.9 of the Code of Administrative Offences, if a decision imposing an administrative punishment is not enforced during two years from its entry into force, it can no longer be executed.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to Article 31.9 of the Code of Administrative Offences, the time when the enforcement of a decision imposing an administrative punishment is suspended or stayed is excluded from the two-year period after which the decision can no longer be executed.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F010", "F011", "F014", "F015", "F016"], "interference": ["F013", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F025", "F026"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F013", "F015", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F010", "F011", "F014", "F015"], "interference": ["F013", "F019", "F020"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F013", "F015", "F019", "F020"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F013", "F014", "F015", "F019", "F020"]}} {"case_name": "case_429", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some of the applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_431", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_433", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' dates of birth and places of residence are given in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held in Baku on 12 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held in Baku on 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held in Baku on 10 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held in Baku on 29 December 2013.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "It appears that the organisers of the demonstrations gave no proper prior notice to the relevant authority, the Baku City Executive Authority.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "According to the applicants, the demonstrations were intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "According to the applicants, the demonstrations were conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The demonstration of 12 January 2013 was aimed at protesting about the deaths of soldiers in the army.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The demonstration of 10 March 2013 was aimed at protesting about the deaths of soldiers in the army.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The demonstration of 26 January 2013 condemned the use of force by the police against the participants of previous demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Those taking part in the demonstration of 29 December 2013 were protesting against bureaucratic injustices which had allegedly caused a disabled war veteran to set himself on fire on 25 December 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Each applicant attended one of the demonstrations as specified in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Shortly after the demonstrations had begun, the police started to disperse those who had gathered.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "All the applicants were arrested during the dispersal operations.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "All the applicants were taken to various police stations following their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicants were questioned at the police stations they were taken to.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On the day of each applicant's arrest, administrative offence reports (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) were issued.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The administrative offence reports stated that the applicants had committed an administrative offence under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Some of the applicants in applications nos. 52270/13, 26424/14 and 26994/14 refused to sign the administrative offence reports.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to most of the applicants, they were never served with copies of the administrative offence reports.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to most of the applicants, they were never served with other documents from their case files.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to most of the applicants, they were not given access to a lawyer after their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to most of the applicants, they were not given access to a lawyer while they were in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to statements (ərizə) written by the applicant in application no. 20589/13 at the police station on the day of their arrest on 12 January 2013, the applicant refused the services of a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to statements (ərizə) written by the applicant in application no. 33164/13 at the police station on the day of their arrest on 10 March 2013, the applicant refused the services of a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant in application no. 20589/13 was released after being kept in police custody for a few hours, subject to an undertaking to reappear at the police station on various dates.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant in application no. 26424/14 was released after being kept in police custody for a few hours, subject to an undertaking to reappear at the police station on various dates.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrests"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Most of the applicants were taken to trial courts directly from the police stations.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Most of the applicants were taken to trial courts either on the day of their arrest or the following day.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant in application no. 20589/13 was brought before a first-instance court on the day they returned to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant in application no. 26424/14 was brought before a first-instance court on the day they returned to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to most of the applicants, the court hearing in each case was very brief.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to most of the applicants, members of the public were not allowed in the courtroom during the hearings.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "According to most of the applicants, the court had not taken a formal decision to close the hearing to the public.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to most of the applicants, they were not given an opportunity to appoint lawyers of their own choosing.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "State-funded lawyers were asked to assist some of the applicants during the court hearings.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant in application no. 21219/13 was not represented by a lawyer during the first-instance court hearing.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicant in application no. 33164/13 was not represented by a lawyer during the first-instance court hearing.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicant in application no. 33593/13 was not represented by a lawyer during the first-instance court hearing.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicant in application no. 26994/14 was not represented by a lawyer during the first-instance court hearing.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to documents from the case files, the applicant in application no. 21219/13 refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and decided to defend themselves in person.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to documents from the case files, the applicant in application no. 33164/13 refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and decided to defend themselves in person.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to documents from the case files, the applicant in application no. 26994/14 refused the assistance of a State-funded lawyer and decided to defend themselves in person.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the transcript of the hearing concerning the applicant in application no. 20589/13, the State-funded lawyer stated briefly in his oral submissions that the applicant was guilty and asked the court for lenience.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The State-funded lawyer for the applicant in application no. 26424/14 stated in general terms that the applicant was not guilty and asked the court to discontinue the case.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "None of the material submitted to the Court contains any record showing that the State-funded lawyer, Mr V.M., made any oral submissions on behalf of the applicant in application no. 52270/13.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "None of the material submitted to the Court contains any record showing that the State-funded lawyer, Mr V.M., made any written submissions on behalf of the applicant in application no. 52270/13.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The only witnesses questioned during the court hearings with respect to the applicant in application no. 20589/13 were the police officers who, according to the official records, had arrested the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The only witnesses questioned during the court hearings with respect to the applicant in application no. 26424/14 were the police officers who, according to the official records, had arrested the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The police officers testified that the applicants in applications nos. 20589/13 and 26424/14 had staged unauthorised demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "No witnesses were questioned by the courts in the other applicants' cases (other than applications nos. 20589/13 and 26424/14).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The first-instance courts found that the applicants had participated in unauthorised demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The applicants were convicted under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The applicants were sentenced to a period of administrative detention varying from thirteen to seventeen days, or to a fine of 400 or 500 Azerbaijani manats (AZN), as specified in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On various dates the applicants lodged appeals with the Baku Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicants argued before the Baku Court of Appeal that their convictions had been in violation of their rights because the demonstrations in which they had participated or attempted to participate had been peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicants complained before the Baku Court of Appeal that their arrests had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicants complained before the Baku Court of Appeal that the hearings before the first-instance courts had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The applicants asked the Baku Court of Appeal to quash the first-instance courts' decisions in their cases.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The applicant in application no. 21219/13 was assisted before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer of their own choosing.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicant in application no. 52270/13 was assisted before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer of their own choosing.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The applicant in application no. 26424/14 was assisted before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer of their own choosing.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The other applicants (other than those in applications nos. 21219/13, 52270/13 and 26424/14) were not represented by a lawyer before the Baku Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On various dates the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants' appeals and upheld the decisions of the first-instance courts, as specified in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "In its decision with regard to the applicant in application no. 33593/13, the Baku Court of Appeal noted, inter alia, that the applicant had voluntarily refused legal assistance at the pre-trial stage.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "At the time of the applicants' arrest, Article 5 § IV of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that no prior written notification was required for spontaneous assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Before amendments introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, a breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies was punishable under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 2000.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 entered into force on 1 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012 introduced new wording to Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences on breaching the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Following the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, participation in an assembly organised in breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies became explicitly punishable under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Following the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, punishments in the form of administrative detention of up to 15 days were introduced for the first time under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Following the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, punishments in the form of community service were introduced for the first time under Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Following the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, the fine for a breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies was increased to between AZN 300 and AZN 600 for participants of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Following the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, the fine for a breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies was increased to between AZN 1,500 and AZN 3,000 for individuals who organise an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Following the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, the fine for a breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies was increased to between AZN 3,000 and AZN 6,000 for persons in charge (vəzifəli şəxslər) who organise an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Following the amendment introduced by Law no. 462-IVQD of 2 November 2012, the fine for a breach of the rules on the organisation and holding of assemblies was increased to between AZN 15,000 and AZN 30,000 for legal entities involved in the organisation of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "By Law no. 651-IVQD of 14 May 2013, which entered into force on 5 June 2013, the administrative detention sentence foreseen in Article 298.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences was increased to 'up to two months'.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "By Law no. 651-IVQD of 14 May 2013, which entered into force on 5 June 2013, the administrative detention sentence foreseen in Article 298.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences was increased to 'up to two months'.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "According to Presidential Order (sərəncam) no. 1866 of 1 December 2011, which was in force until 1 September 2013, the minimum wage in Azerbaijan was AZN 93.5.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, titled 'The honouring of obligations and commitments by Azerbaijan', noted that there is no political dialogue with the opposition parties outside parliament in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about the restrictive climate for the activities of the extra-parliamentary opposition in Azerbaijan, which complains about limitations imposed on freedom of expression and freedom of assembly and the lack of access to the public media.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe stated that the establishment of an inclusive political system and a truly competitive and unrestrictive political environment requires full implementation of basic freedoms, including freedom of expression, freedom of assembly and freedom of association.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed deep concern about the situation regarding basic freedoms in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe noted that recently adopted amendments to the Criminal Code and the Administrative Code increased penalties for the organisers of, and participants in, 'unauthorised' gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe noted that, considering the authorities' ongoing blanket ban on protests in the Baku city centre, the amendments increasing penalties for organisers of and participants in 'unauthorised' gatherings are likely to have a further negative impact on freedom of assembly and freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Resolution 1917 (2013) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe expressed concern about the restrictive use of certain articles of the Criminal Code, in particular Articles 221 and 233, against participants in peaceful, albeit unauthorised, demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Report (CommDH(2013)14) of 6 August 2013 was produced by Nils Muižnieks, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Azerbaijan from 22 to 24 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "In Report (CommDH(2013)14), the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe expressed deep concern about recent amendments to the Law on Freedom of Assembly, the Criminal Code and the Code of Administrative Offences, which further erode the right to freedom of assembly in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "In Report (CommDH(2013)14), the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe stated that the sanctions which can now be imposed, coupled with the fact that local authorities have not authorised a single rally in Baku city centre in recent years, clearly have a chilling effect on the organisation of or participation in demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "In Report (CommDH(2013)14), the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe expressed the view that participants in peaceful assemblies should not be sanctioned for the mere fact of being present at and actively participating in the demonstration in question, provided they do not do anything illegal, violent or obscene in the course of it.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "In Report (CommDH(2013)14), the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe urged the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure that no disproportionate sanction, which would undermine the fundamental right to peaceful assembly, is imposed.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "A summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, the relevant provisions concerning the organisation and holding of public assemblies, and the relevant extracts of international documents can be found in the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, paragraphs 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["national_security", "public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F013"], "interference": ["F014", "F015", "F053", "F054", "F055"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F002", "F005", "F006", "F009", "F012", "F067"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F007", "F008", "F014", "F015", "F053", "F054", "F055", "F071", "F072", "F085", "F086", "F090"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004", "F005", "F007", "F008", "F013"], "interference": ["F014", "F015", "F054", "F055"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F002", "F005", "F006", "F009", "F012", "F067"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F007", "F008", "F014", "F054", "F055", "F071", "F072"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F007", "F008", "F014", "F054", "F055", "F071", "F072"]}} {"case_name": "case_436", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1957.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr V. Grigoryan of the European Human Rights Advocacy Centre (EHRAC) based in London.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr P. Leach of the European Human Rights Advocacy Centre (EHRAC) based in London.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant was represented by Ms J. Gavron of the European Human Rights Advocacy Centre (EHRAC) based in London.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant was represented by Ms J. Evans of the European Human Rights Advocacy Centre (EHRAC) based in London.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr M. Shushanyan, a lawyer practising in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr G. Kostanyan.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr Y. Kirakosyan, Representative of the Republic of Armenia to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 19 February 2008 a presidential election was held in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the then Prime Minister, Mr Serzh Sargsyan, representing the ruling party.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the main opposition candidate, Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Immediately after the announcement of the preliminary results of the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election, Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan called on his supporters to gather at Freedom Square in central Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan called on his supporters to gather at Freedom Square in central Yerevan in order to protest against alleged irregularities in the 19 February 2008 election process.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan announced that the 19 February 2008 presidential election had not been free and fair.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "From 20 February 2008 onwards, nationwide daily protest rallies were held by Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan's supporters.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The main meeting place of Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan's supporters during the protest rallies from 20 February 2008 onwards was Freedom Square and the surrounding park in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The rallies at Freedom Square attracted at times tens of thousands of people.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Several hundred demonstrators stayed at Freedom Square around the clock, having set up a camp.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "At the material time, the applicant was an opposition member of parliament.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "At the material time, the applicant was a supporter of Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant regularly attended the ongoing demonstrations at Freedom Square from 20 February 2008 onwards.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant occasionally gave speeches at the ongoing demonstrations at Freedom Square from 20 February 2008 onwards.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 24 February 2008 the Central Election Commission of Armenia announced that Mr Serzh Sargsyan had won the 19 February 2008 presidential election with around 52% of all votes cast.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 24 February 2008 the Central Election Commission of Armenia announced that Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan had received around 21% of votes in the 19 February 2008 presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 29 February 2008 the protest rallies at Freedom Square were still in full swing.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "A. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 1 March 2008, at approximately 6-7 a.m., a police operation was conducted at Freedom Square in Yerevan where several hundred demonstrators were camping.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant alleged that the police had violently attacked the demonstrators at Freedom Square with rubber batons during the 1 March 2008 police operation.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicant alleged that the police had violently attacked the demonstrators at Freedom Square with electric shock devices during the 1 March 2008 police operation.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant alleged that the police terminated the assembly at Freedom Square during the 1 March 2008 police operation.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Government contested the applicant's allegations regarding the nature of the 1 March 2008 police operation at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Government claimed that the reason for the 1 March 2008 police operation at Freedom Square was to verify information obtained on the previous day by the Armenian Police and National Security Service, according to which a large number of weapons were to be distributed to protesters to incite provocative actions and riots in Yerevan on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "As a result of the 1 March 2008 police operation at Freedom Square, clashes took place between the police and the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 1 March 2008 a criminal case was instituted under several Articles of the Armenian Criminal Code in connection with the events at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The criminal case instituted on 1 March 2008 in connection with the events at Freedom Square included charges of organising and holding an unlawful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The criminal case instituted on 1 March 2008 in connection with the events at Freedom Square included charges of incitement to disobedience of police orders to terminate the unlawful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The criminal case instituted on 1 March 2008 in connection with the events at Freedom Square included charges of illegal possession of arms and ammunition.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The criminal case instituted on 1 March 2008 in connection with the events at Freedom Square included charges of life-threatening assaults on police officers.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The decision to institute criminal proceedings on 1 March 2008 stated that, after the announcement of the preliminary results of the 19 February 2008 presidential election, Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan, members of parliament K.S. and S.M., and the chief editor of Haykakan Zhamanak daily newspaper N.P., and others organised and held mass public events at Yerevan's Freedom Square in violation of the procedure prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The decision to institute criminal proceedings on 1 March 2008 stated that Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan, members of parliament K.S. and S.M., the chief editor of Haykakan Zhamanak daily newspaper N.P., and others made calls inciting disobedience of decisions ordering an end to the events held in violation of the procedure prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The decision to institute criminal proceedings on 1 March 2008 stated that a number of participants in the mass events illegally possessed and carried illegally obtained arms and ammunition.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The decision to institute criminal proceedings on 1 March 2008 stated that on 1 March 2008 at around 6 a.m., when the police took measures to forcibly end the public events held in violation of the procedure prescribed by law in compliance with section 14 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the organisers and participants disobeyed the lawful orders of the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The decision to institute criminal proceedings on 1 March 2008 stated that the organisers and participants committed a life- and health-threatening assault on police officers with clubs, metal rods and other adapted objects, causing the police officers injuries of varied severity.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "After Freedom Square was cleared of demonstrators on 1 March 2008, some demonstrators relocated to the area near the French Embassy, the Yerevan Mayor's Office and the Myasnikyan monument, situated about 1.7-2 km from Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Thousands of other people poured into the streets of Yerevan and joined the demonstrators near the French Embassy, the Yerevan Mayor's Office and the Myasnikyan monument in response to the events of the early morning of 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant was present in the area near the French Embassy, the Yerevan Mayor's Office and the Myasnikyan monument on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "Rallies continued in the area near the French Embassy, the Yerevan Mayor's Office and the Myasnikyan monument, as well as in adjacent streets including Grigor Lusavorich, Mashtots, Leo and Paronyan streets, until the early morning of 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Tensions gradually escalated during the rallies on 1-2 March 2008, resulting in clashes between some protesters and law enforcement officers.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "As a result of the events of 1-2 March 2008 in Yerevan, ten persons died, including eight civilians.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "As a result of the events of 1-2 March 2008 in Yerevan, numerous persons were injured.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "As a result of the events of 1-2 March 2008 in Yerevan, public and private property was damaged.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "As a result of the events of 1-2 March 2008 in Yerevan, a state of emergency was declared by the outgoing President of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Government alleged that the disorder which took place in Yerevan on 1 and 2 March 2008 had been incited and organised by the applicant in conspiracy with several other active opposition supporters.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The applicant disputed the Government's allegation that the disorder which took place in Yerevan on 1 and 2 March 2008 had been incited and organised by him in conspiracy with several other active opposition supporters.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 2 March 2008 another criminal case was instituted under, inter alia, Article 225 § 3 of the Armenian Criminal Code (organising mass disorder involving murder) in connection with the events of 1 and 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The decision to institute the criminal case on 2 March 2008 stated that Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan, members of parliament K.S. and S.M., the chief editor of Haykakan Zhamanak daily newspaper N.P., and others, not willing to concede defeat at the 19 February 2008 presidential election, with the aim of casting doubt on the election and discrediting the election and the authorities, from 1 March 2008 in the area of the Yerevan Mayor's Office and central streets organised mass disorder involving murders, violence, massacre, arson, destruction of property and armed resistance to public officials, with the use of firearms, explosives and other adapted objects.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 2 March 2008 the two criminal cases instituted on 1 March 2008 and 2 March 2008 were joined and examined under case number 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS", "B. The events of 1-2 March 2008 and institution of criminal cases"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the General Prosecutor applied to the Armenian parliament with a request to have the applicant's parliamentary immunity lifted.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the General Prosecutor applied to the Armenian parliament for authorisation to bring charges against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the General Prosecutor applied to the Armenian parliament for authorisation to have the applicant detained.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the General Prosecutor applied to the Armenian parliament for authorisation to have three other members of parliament detained alongside the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The General Prosecutor's request of 4 March 2008 described the events which had taken place in Yerevan between 20 February and the early morning of 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The General Prosecutor's request of 4 March 2008 stated that the evidence obtained in the case provided sufficient grounds to believe that the applicant and three other members of parliament had taken an active part in inciting violence with public calls they had made.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The General Prosecutor's request of 4 March 2008 stated that the evidence obtained in the case provided sufficient grounds to believe that the applicant and three other members of parliament had organised mass disorder through direct participation, instigation and various types of support, including the recruitment and arming of attackers.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The General Prosecutor's request of 4 March 2008 stated that there were sufficient grounds to bring charges against the applicant and three other members of parliament under Article 225 § 3 of the Armenian Criminal Code for organising mass disorder which had taken place in Yerevan between 20 February and 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The General Prosecutor's request of 4 March 2008 stated that there were sufficient grounds to bring charges against the applicant and three other members of parliament under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (usurpation of State power) for organising mass disorder with the aim of a violent usurpation of State power in breach of the Constitution.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The General Prosecutor's request of 4 March 2008 stated that there was sufficient evidence justifying the applicant's detention, including the risk of absconding and obstructing justice.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the Armenian parliament adopted a resolution granting the General Prosecutor's request to lift the applicant's parliamentary immunity and authorise charges and detention.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 5 March 2008 the applicant was formally charged under Article 225 § 3 of the Armenian Criminal Code within the scope of criminal case no. 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 5 March 2008 the applicant was formally charged under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code within the scope of criminal case no. 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The charging decision of 5 March 2008 stated that after the opposition candidate lost at the 19 February 2008 presidential election, the applicant joined the opposition candidate's group of supporters and, having conspired with them to usurp State power in violation of the constitutional order, actively participated in carrying out activities for that purpose.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The charging decision of 5 March 2008 stated that the applicant's activities included discrediting the pre-election process and the conduct of the election, raising doubts among the international community regarding the legality of the election, instilling distrust towards the results among large segments of the population, creating illusions of public discontent and revolt, and organising and holding unlawful demonstrations aimed at destabilising the internal political situation.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The charging decision of 5 March 2008 stated that the applicant, three other members of parliament and a number of other opposition supporters incited and organised mass disorder which took place in Yerevan on 1 and 2 March 2008 and involved mass violence, massacre, arson, destruction and damage of public and private property, armed resistance to public officials and murder.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 12 March 2008 the applicant was arrested by officers of the National Security Service of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 12 March 2008 the applicant was placed in detention on the basis of a court order.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The applicant's detention order was extended throughout the investigation and the trial.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 13 March 2008 the applicant was questioned by the investigator.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "On 13 March 2008 the applicant denied the charges under Article 225 § 3 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 13 March 2008 the applicant denied the charges under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 13 March 2008 the applicant refused to testify.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 13 March 2008 a search was conducted in several premises belonging to the applicant, including a restaurant.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "During the search on 13 March 2008 of premises belonging to the applicant, various types of ammunition and explosives were found and seized at a restaurant belonging to the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On 12 June 2008 an additional charge was brought against the applicant under Article 235 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code for illegal possession of ammunition and explosives.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The additional charge under Article 235 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code brought against the applicant on 12 June 2008 was made with reference to the items seized during the search of the applicant's premises on 13 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On 1 December 2008 the prosecutor approved the bill of indictment against the applicant and six other opposition leaders, commonly known as the 'Case of Seven'.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The applicant's criminal case had been disjoined from criminal case no. 62202608 before being transferred for trial.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "On 1 December 2008 the applicant's criminal case (the 'Case of Seven') was transferred for trial.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "On 31 March 2009 the prosecutor replaced the charge against the applicant under Article 225 § 3 of the Armenian Criminal Code with a charge under Article 225 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 31 March 2009 the prosecutor dropped the charge against the applicant under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The prosecutor dropped the charge under Article 300 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code on the ground that, on 24 March 2009, Article 300 § 1 had been amended and could not be applied retroactively.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The prosecutor replaced the charge under Article 225 § 3 of the Armenian Criminal Code with a charge under Article 225 § 1 on the ground that, on 24 March 2009, Article 225 § 3 had been repealed.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "On 1 April 2009 the case against the applicant was disjoined into separate proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "During the trial, the Kotayk Regional Court called and heard at least thirteen prosecution witnesses, mostly demonstrators who had attended the assembly at Freedom Square, many from the applicant's region.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Five of the prosecution witnesses heard by the Kotayk Regional Court either fully or partially retracted the statements they had given against the applicant during the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The five prosecution witnesses who retracted their statements claimed that they had been either guided or dictated by the investigator, or that their statements had been extracted by ill-treatment or intimidation.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Two prosecution witnesses, T.K. and V.S., failed to appear before the Kotayk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The testimony of prosecution witness G.A. was interrupted at one of the hearings before the Kotayk Regional Court and never resumed.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court failed to secure the appearance of prosecution witnesses T.K. and V.S.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court decided to read out the pre-trial statements of prosecution witnesses T.K. and V.S. despite the applicant's objections.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Prosecution witness G.A. submitted that he had been intimidated by the applicant's relatives and did not wish to continue his testimony in court out of fear for his life.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court at first tried unsuccessfully to secure prosecution witness G.A.'s appearance before the court.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court decided to relieve prosecution witness G.A. from the obligation to appear and to rely on his pre-trial statement.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The applicant requested that the Head of the Special Investigative Service be summoned as a witness and examined in court in connection with the charge of illegal possession of ammunition and explosives.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court rejected the applicant's request to summon the Head of the Special Investigative Service as a witness.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "On 22 June 2009 the Kotayk Regional Court found the applicant guilty under Article 225 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "On 22 June 2009 the Kotayk Regional Court found the applicant guilty under Article 235 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "On 22 June 2009 the Kotayk Regional Court sentenced the applicant to a total of eight years in prison.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that after the preliminary results of the 19 February 2008 election were made public, the applicant, together with a group of people, starting from 20 February 2008 carried out organisational activities for the purpose of creating discontent in society and preparing the crowd gathered at Freedom Square for use of violence and disobedience.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that the applicant and his group bought household items and food for demonstrators and provided money to ensure the continuous presence of groups of people at the events at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that the applicant and his group distributed rods, clubs, armature, Molotov cocktails, metal structures considered projectile cold weapons, firearms and ammunition to some of those taking part in the demonstrations at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that the applicant, using his army commander's experience and his standing acquired during the fight for liberation of Artsakh and his influence among veterans of the Nagorno Karabakh war, declared during the demonstrations at Freedom Square that he would struggle until the end and demanded that demonstrators be ready to take decisive steps.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that the applicant incited those recruited in the town of Hrazdan and adjacent villages to participate in the demonstrations held in violation of the law, acting as their personal commander and leader.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that the applicant regularly circulated at Freedom Square accompanied by bodyguards and companions-in-arms as a show of strength to arouse the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that between 27 and 29 February 2008 the applicant organised the transportation of wooden and metal clubs, armature and Molotov cocktails to Freedom Square, where they were hidden in tents designated as 'Hrazdan', 'Kotchor' and 'Vanatur'.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that on 29 February 2008 operative information was received by the Armenian Police and the National Security Service that a group of persons intended to instigate mass disorder in Yerevan on 1 March 2008 through provocations and that a large quantity of clubs, metal rods, explosive substances, firearms and grenades were to be distributed among participants of the assembly at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that in the early morning of 1 March 2008 the police tried to discover illegal items at Freedom Square and to prevent their use, and as a result of the police operation part of the objects brought for the purpose of carrying out mass disorder, including firearms and ammunition, were discovered at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that thereafter participants of the assembly, led by the applicant's group, gathered in the area adjacent to the Myasnikyan monument, an important intersection of several streets of Yerevan situated in the vicinity of the French, Italian and Russian embassies.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that at around 11 a.m. on 1 March 2008 the participants of the mass disorder blocked Grigor Lusavorich street by placing trolleybuses along the carriageway and armed themselves with stones, rods, sticks, explosive substances, explosive devices, firearms and Molotov cocktails.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that Molotov cocktails were filled with flammable liquid immediately behind the platform at the Myasnikyan monument and in the nearby park.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that the applicant and others rejected the offer made by the authorities to hold the assembly in another location and, with their speeches and orders, gave instructions to the gathered crowd with the aim of keeping it there as long as possible.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that from 1 to 2 March 2008 mass disorder was perpetrated in the area of the Myasnikyan monument and the Yerevan Mayor's Office, as well as Grigor Lusavorich, Mashtots, Leo and Paronyan streets, with use of firearms, ammunition and explosive substances and devices, during which armed resistance was shown to the police and servicemen of the Police Troops.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court found it established that a total of 187 persons, including 32 civilians, sustained injuries as a result of the mass disorder of 1-2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court specified the number of persons injured and killed and vehicles damaged, as well as the pecuniary damage caused to the police, the city of Yerevan, the central district and private businesses as a result of the mass disorder of 1-2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The Kotayk Regional Court concluded that the mass disorder of 1-2 March 2008 had stopped only after the declaration of a state of emergency and its prevention by the actions of the police.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "As regards the charge of illegal possession of ammunition and explosives, the Kotayk Regional Court found that the applicant had obtained the items in question at an unidentified time and illegally kept them in his restaurant's storage room.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "In reaching its conclusions, the Kotayk Regional Court relied, inter alia, on the statements of the witnesses who had appeared in court and the pre-trial statements of witnesses T.K., V.S. and G.A.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "As regards the pre-trial statements retracted in court, the Kotayk Regional Court found that the witnesses in question, as the applicant's companions-in-arms, friends and residents of his area, had retracted their statements because of being familiar and close with the applicant, and decided to give preference to their pre-trial statements.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "On 22 July 2009 the applicant lodged an appeal against his conviction.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "On 31 July 2009 the Criminal Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal against his conviction.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "On 31 July 2009 the Criminal Court of Appeal upheld the judgment of the Kotayk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "On 30 August 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal on points of law.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "On 10 September 2009 the Court of Cassation of Armenia declared the applicant's appeal on points of law inadmissible for lack of merit.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "For Articles 225 and 300 of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003), see Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia (no. 49020/08, §§ 44-46, 15 October 2020).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code (2003)"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Article 235 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003) prescribes a penalty for illegal acquisition, sale, possession, trafficking or carrying of firearms (except smoothbore firearms and their bullets), ammunition, rifled firearms cartridges or explosive substances or devices.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code (2003)"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Article 235 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003) prescribes a penalty of two to six years' imprisonment for illegal acquisition, sale, possession, trafficking or carrying of firearms (except smoothbore firearms and their bullets), ammunition, rifled firearms cartridges or explosive substances or devices, if committed by a group of people acting in collusion.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code (2003)"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "For the relevant extracts of the Armenian Ombudsman's Ad Hoc Public Report regarding the 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events, see Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (no. 23086/08, § 124, 20 September 2018) and Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia (no. 49020/08, § 49, 15 October 2020).", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "B. Ad Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "In its Resolutions regarding the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election and the events that followed, the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) condemned the arrest and continuing detention of scores of persons, including more than 100 opposition supporters and three members of parliament, among them the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) condemned the arrest and continuing detention of the persons referred to in its Resolutions as being on seemingly artificial and politically motivated charges, especially those under Articles 225 and 300 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "For the relevant extracts of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolutions and other relevant international materials regarding the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election and subsequent events, see Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (no. 23086/08, §§ 125-34, 20 September 2018) and Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia (no. 49020/08, §§ 51-57, 15 October 2020).", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F027", "F028", "F033", "F034", "F049", "F109", "F112", "F113"], "interference": ["F023", "F024", "F106", "F108"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F028", "F033", "F034", "F045", "F046", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F054", "F055", "F083", "F084", "F107", "F108", "F109", "F111", "F112", "F113", "F115", "F116", "F117", "F118", "F119", "F121", "F122", "F126", "F127", "F128", "F138", "F139", "F140"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F023", "F024", "F028", "F033"], "interference": ["F023", "F024", "F106", "F108"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F028", "F033", "F045", "F046", "F049", "F083", "F107", "F109", "F112", "F113", "F115", "F116", "F117", "F118", "F121", "F126", "F138", "F139"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F017", "F018", "F021", "F023", "F024", "F028", "F033", "F045", "F049", "F106", "F108", "F109", "F138", "F139"]}} {"case_name": "case_438", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants or organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_439", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of country-wide protests against a retirement age hike.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of country-wide protests against a retirement age hike.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The country-wide protests against the retirement age hike were organised by Aleksey Navalnyy.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The country-wide protests against the retirement age hike organised by Aleksey Navalnyy took place on 9 September 2018.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_441", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' dates of birth and places of residence are given in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "At the material time, the second applicant was a member of an opposition group called Nida.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "At the material time, the third applicant was a member of an opposition group called İctimai Palata.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The third applicant was one of the organisers of several demonstrations held in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The first applicant participated in a demonstration organised by the opposition on 20 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The second applicant participated in a demonstration organised by the opposition on 20 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 15 October 2012, prior to the demonstration of 20 October 2012, the organisers gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) refused to authorise the holding of the demonstration at the place indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA) proposed a different location on the outskirts of Baku — the grounds of a driving school situated in the 20th residential area of the Sabail District — as an alternative venue for the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Despite the Baku City Executive Authority's refusal to authorise the original location, the organisers decided to hold the demonstration as originally planned.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The second applicant participated in a demonstration held on 12 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The second applicant participated in a demonstration held on 26 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The third applicant participated in a demonstration held on 30 April 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The organisers of the demonstrations held on 12 January 2013, 26 January 2013, and 30 April 2013 gave no proper prior notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (the BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Information about the demonstrations held on 12 January 2013, 26 January 2013, and 30 April 2013 was disseminated on the internet or in the press.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the applicants, the demonstrations were intended to be peaceful and were conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The participants of the demonstration of 20 October 2012 were demanding democratic reforms in Azerbaijan and free and fair elections.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The participants of the demonstration of 20 October 2012 were protesting against impediments on freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The demonstration of 12 January 2013 was aimed at protesting about the deaths of soldiers in the army.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The demonstration of 26 January 2013 condemned the use of force by the police against the participants of previous demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The participants of the demonstration of 30 April 2013 were commemorating the victims of a terrorist attack committed in 2009 at the Azerbaijan State Oil Academy.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The police began to disperse the demonstration of 20 October 2012 as soon as the protesters began to gather.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The police began to disperse the demonstration of 12 January 2013 as soon as the protesters began to gather.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The police began to disperse the demonstration of 26 January 2013 as soon as the protesters began to gather.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The police began to disperse the demonstration of 30 April 2013 as soon as the protesters began to gather.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The circumstances related to the dispersal of the demonstration of 20 October 2012, the first and second applicants' arrests and custody, and subsequent administrative proceedings against them are similar to those in Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, judgment of 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "Further details regarding the circumstances related to the dispersal of the demonstration of 20 October 2012, the first and second applicants' arrests and custody, and subsequent administrative proceedings against them are given in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The circumstances related to the dispersal of the demonstrations of 12 January 2013, 26 January 2013, and 30 April 2013, the second and third applicants' arrests and custody, and the subsequent administrative proceedings against them are similar to those in Bayramov v. Azerbaijan ([Committee] nos. 19150/13 and 52022/13, judgment of 6 April 2017).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Further details regarding the circumstances related to the dispersal of the demonstrations of 12 January 2013, 26 January 2013, and 30 April 2013, the second and third applicants' arrests and custody, and the subsequent administrative proceedings against them are given in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' arrests and subsequent administrative proceedings against them"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Law no. 135-IVQD of 31 May 2011 introduced amendments to the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 (the CAO), which entered into force on 1 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "After the amendments introduced by Law no. 135-IVQD of 31 May 2011, Article 410.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 provided that a copy of the administrative offence report shall be given to an individual who is subject to the administrative offence proceedings or to a representative of a legal entity.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "After the amendments introduced by Law no. 135-IVQD of 31 May 2011, Article 410.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 provided that an aggrieved person in administrative offence proceedings has the right to a copy of the administrative offence report.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "A summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, relevant provisions concerning freedom of assembly, the organisation and holding of public assemblies, and relevant extracts from international documents and press releases can be found in the judgment of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, 15 October 2015) at paragraphs 27–30, 33–35, and 37–42.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "A summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, relevant provisions concerning freedom of assembly, the organisation and holding of public assemblies, and relevant extracts from international documents and press releases can be found in the judgment of Abbasli v. Azerbaijan ([Committee] nos. 5417/13 and 73309/14, 16 February 2017) at paragraphs 23–25 and 28–29.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F005", "F006", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F016", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F028"], "interference": ["F005", "F006", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F028"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F026", "F028"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F005", "F006", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F016"], "interference": ["F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F028"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F026", "F028"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F005", "F006", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F016", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F028"]}} {"case_name": "case_442", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of nationwide protests.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The nationwide protests took place in various Russian cities on 5 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The nationwide protests on 5 May 2018 took place before Vladimir Putin's inauguration for the fourth presidential term.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_443", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1972.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "At the material time, the applicant was a member of the \"Republic\" Party (\"Հանրապետություն\" կուսակցություն).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 10 May 2002, the \"Republic\" Party applied to the Mayor of Yerevan for permission to hold a demonstration on Freedom Square in Yerevan on 14 May 2002.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 13 May 2002, the Mayor of Yerevan authorised the demonstration on Freedom Square as requested by the \"Republic\" Party.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The demonstration was held as planned on 14 May 2002 at around 15.00 on Freedom Square in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The demonstration on 14 May 2002 was jointly organised by the \"Republic\" Party and six other political parties.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant participated in the demonstration on 14 May 2002 on Freedom Square in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Following the demonstration, at around 16.00 on 14 May 2002, the applicant called on participants to hold a procession through Baghramyan Avenue towards the Parliament building.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "A crowd of people followed the applicant in a procession along Baghramyan Avenue towards the Parliament building on 14 May 2002.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 14 May 2002 at 23.10, the applicant was arrested.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "After being arrested on 14 May 2002, the applicant was brought to the Arabkir District Police Station of Yerevan (ՀՀ ոստիկանության Երևան քաղաքի Արաբկիրի բաժին).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Police officers prepared a record of an administrative offence (վարչական իրավախախտման արձանագրություն) stating that the applicant had \"organised an unlawful procession and violated the prescribed rules for holding demonstrations and street processions\".", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 15 May 2002, the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan (Երևան քաղաքի Կենտրոն և Նորք-Մարաշ համայնքների առաջին ատյանի դատարան) examined the applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the applicant, in violation of the prescribed rules for holding street processions and demonstrations, on 14 May 2002 at around 16.00, participated with a group of people in an unauthorised procession.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the applicant's participation in the unauthorised procession constituted an offence envisaged by Article 180.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (Վարչական իրավախախտումների վերաբերյալ ՀՀ օրենսգիրք).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it necessary, taking into consideration the circumstances of the case and the personality of the applicant, to impose an administrative penalty in the form of a fine.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan imposed a fine on the applicant in the amount of 500 Armenian drams (AMD), which was approximately EUR 1 at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The decision of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan imposing a fine on the applicant was final and not subject to appeal.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 24 May 2002, the applicant lodged an appeal with the Civil Court of Appeal (ՀՀ քաղաքացիական գործերով վերաքննիչ դատարան).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "In his appeal to the Civil Court of Appeal, the applicant argued that in accordance with the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia he had a right to contest the decision of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan before a higher court.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "In his appeal to the Civil Court of Appeal, the applicant argued that the interference with his right to freedom of assembly was not prescribed by law, as there did not exist any law which prescribed the rules that the applicant had allegedly violated.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "In his appeal to the Civil Court of Appeal, the applicant expressly requested the Civil Court of Appeal to name any law prescribing the rules he had allegedly violated, if such a law existed.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 14 June 2002, the Civil Court of Appeal examined the applicant's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Civil Court of Appeal found that on 14 May 2002 at around 15.00 the applicant participated in an authorised demonstration on Freedom Square in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Civil Court of Appeal found that on 14 May 2002 at around 16.00 the applicant, with a group of people, participated in an unauthorised procession through Baghramyan Avenue, during which he headed the procession.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The Civil Court of Appeal found that the applicant was brought to the police station as a result of heading the unauthorised procession through Baghramyan Avenue on 14 May 2002.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Civil Court of Appeal found that the applicant heading an unauthorised procession was characterised as an offence envisaged under Article 180.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, and therefore the applicant must be subjected to administrative liability.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 24 June 2002, the applicant lodged a cassation appeal with the Court of Cassation (ՀՀ վճռաբեկ դատարան).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "By a letter of 1 July 2002, the Court of Cassation informed the applicant that the domestic legislation did not provide for a right to lodge a cassation appeal against the decisions which the applicant sought to contest.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Article 180.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provides that violation of the prescribed rules for organising or holding assemblies, rallies, street processions and demonstrations shall be punishable by imposition of a penalty in the amount of fifty to one hundred per cent of the fixed minimum wage.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "A. Code of Administrative Offences (6 December 1985)"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Article 180.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provides that in exceptional cases, where in the circumstances of the case and taking into account the offender's personality the application of a financial penalty would be deemed insufficient, the violation may be punishable by imposition of administrative detention not exceeding fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "A. Code of Administrative Offences (6 December 1985)"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR on \"Rules for Organising and Holding of Assemblies, Rallies, Street Processions and Demonstrations in the USSR\" of 28 July 1988 defined the requirement of prior authorisation for holding mass events.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "B. The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR on \"Rules for Organising and Holding of Assemblies, Rallies, Street Processions and Demonstrations in the USSR\" (28 July 1988)"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 defined the authority deciding on requests for authorisation as the executive committee of the relevant local council of people's deputies.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "B. The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR on \"Rules for Organising and Holding of Assemblies, Rallies, Street Processions and Demonstrations in the USSR\" (28 July 1988)"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 defined the procedure for making a request for authorisation and its required content.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "B. The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR on \"Rules for Organising and Holding of Assemblies, Rallies, Street Processions and Demonstrations in the USSR\" (28 July 1988)"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 defined the decision to be taken following the examination of a request for authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "B. The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR on \"Rules for Organising and Holding of Assemblies, Rallies, Street Processions and Demonstrations in the USSR\" (28 July 1988)"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 provided for a possibility to appeal a decision on a request for authorisation to a superior authority.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "B. The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR on \"Rules for Organising and Holding of Assemblies, Rallies, Street Processions and Demonstrations in the USSR\" (28 July 1988)"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 set out requirements to be met when holding a mass event, including that the event must take place at the time and place specified in the request, that public order must be respected, and that no carrying of arms was permitted.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "B. The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR on \"Rules for Organising and Holding of Assemblies, Rallies, Street Processions and Demonstrations in the USSR\" (28 July 1988)"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 defined the reasons for refusal of an authorisation for a mass event.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "B. The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR on \"Rules for Organising and Holding of Assemblies, Rallies, Street Processions and Demonstrations in the USSR\" (28 July 1988)"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 defined the grounds on which a particular mass event could be dispersed, including absence of a request, refusal of an authorisation, and violation of public order.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "B. The Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR on \"Rules for Organising and Holding of Assemblies, Rallies, Street Processions and Demonstrations in the USSR\" (28 July 1988)"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "By adopting the USSR Law on \"Approving Decrees of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR on Making Amendments and Supplements to Certain USSR Legal Acts\" of 28 October 1988, the Supreme Soviet of the USSR approved a number of decrees of the Chairmanship, including the Decree of 28 July 1988 on \"Rules for Organising and Holding of Assemblies, Rallies, Street Processions and Demonstrations in the USSR\".", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "C. The USSR Law on \"Approving Decrees of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR on Making Amendments and Supplements to Certain USSR Legal Acts\" (28 October 1988)"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Armenia's Declaration of Independence of 23 August 1990 stated that the Supreme Soviet of the Armenian Soviet Socialist Republic, based on the principles enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the general norms of international law, and aiming to achieve the establishment of a democratic society ruled by law, declared that the Armenian Soviet Socialist Republic is renamed as the Republic of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "D. Armenia's Declaration of Independence (23 August 1990)"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Armenia's Declaration of Independence of 23 August 1990 declared that only the Constitution and laws of the Republic of Armenia are valid on the territory of the Republic of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "D. Armenia's Declaration of Independence (23 August 1990)"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Article 16 of the Constitutional Law on the Foundations of Independent Statehood of 25 September 1991 provided that until the adoption of a new constitution of the Republic of Armenia, the valid Constitution and laws are effective to the extent to which they do not contradict that Law and the legal acts adopted on the basis of the Declaration of Independence.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "E. Constitutional Law on the Foundations of Independent Statehood (25 September 1991)"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Article 11 of the Commonwealth of Independent States Convention of 8 December 1991 provided that from the moment of signing the Convention, norms of third states, including those of the former USSR, shall not be applied on the territories of the signatory states.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "F. The CIS Convention (8 December 1991) signed and ratified by Armenia on 21 December 1991 and 18 February 1992 respectively"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Armenia signed the Commonwealth of Independent States Convention on 21 December 1991.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "F. The CIS Convention (8 December 1991) signed and ratified by Armenia on 21 December 1991 and 18 February 1992 respectively"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Armenia ratified the Commonwealth of Independent States Convention on 18 February 1992.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "F. The CIS Convention (8 December 1991) signed and ratified by Armenia on 21 December 1991 and 18 February 1992 respectively"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Preamble of the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia of 5 July 1995 stated that the Armenian nation, taking as a basis the fundamental principles of the Armenian statehood enshrined in Armenia's Declaration of Independence, adopts the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "G. The Constitution of the Republic of Armenia (5 July 1995, in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Article 4 of the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia of 5 July 1995 provided that the State guarantees the protection of human rights and freedoms on the basis of the Constitution and laws, and in accordance with the principles and norms of international law.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "G. The Constitution of the Republic of Armenia (5 July 1995, in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Article 26 of the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia of 5 July 1995 provided that citizens have the right to hold peaceful assemblies, rallies, processions and demonstrations without carrying arms.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "G. The Constitution of the Republic of Armenia (5 July 1995, in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Article 44 of the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia of 5 July 1995 provided that no restrictions may be placed on the exercise of the rights and freedoms enshrined in Articles 23-27 of the Constitution other than such as are prescribed by law and are necessary in the interests of national security or public safety, for the protection of public order, health or morals, or for the protection of the rights, freedoms, honour and reputation of others.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "G. The Constitution of the Republic of Armenia (5 July 1995, in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Article 116 of the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia of 5 July 1995 provided that from the date of entry into force of the Constitution, the Constitution of 1978 with subsequent amendments and supplements, and constitutional laws lose their force.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "G. The Constitution of the Republic of Armenia (5 July 1995, in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Article 116 of the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia of 5 July 1995 provided that from the date of entry into force of the Constitution, the laws and other legal acts of the Republic of Armenia are effective to the extent to which they do not contradict the Constitution.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "G. The Constitution of the Republic of Armenia (5 July 1995, in force at the material time)"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Article 1.5 of the Presidential Decree on Public Administration of Yerevan of 6 May 1997 provided that the Mayor of Yerevan shall decide on the issue of holding assemblies, rallies, processions, demonstrations and other mass events in Yerevan in accordance with the rules prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "H. Presidential Decree on Public Administration of Yerevan (6 May 1997)"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 28 April 2004, the Armenian Parliament adopted a law regulating the procedure for holding assemblies, rallies, street processions and demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "I. The Law on Holding Assemblies, Rallies, Street Processions and Demonstrations adopted on 28 April 2004"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Article 16 of the Law on Holding Assemblies, Rallies, Street Processions and Demonstrations of 28 April 2004 stated that, from the date of its entry into force, the Decree of the Chairmanship of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR on \"Rules for Organising and Holding of Assemblies, Rallies, Street Processions and Demonstrations in the USSR\" of 28 July 1988 was not to be applied on the territory of the Republic of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW", "I. The Law on Holding Assemblies, Rallies, Street Processions and Demonstrations adopted on 28 April 2004"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018"], "interference": ["F011", "F013", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F031"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F015", "F016", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F031", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F052", "F053", "F055", "F056", "F006"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F008", "F009", "F010"], "interference": ["F016", "F018", "F031"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F016", "F028", "F031", "F033", "F041", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F055", "F056"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F009", "F010", "F016", "F018", "F031", "F028", "F041", "F044", "F045", "F055"]}} {"case_name": "case_444", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_445", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_446", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_448", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applications concern the administrative arrest of the applicants prior to a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applications concern the detention of the applicants prior to a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applications concern the subsequent conviction of the applicants on charges of minor hooliganism.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The arrests and detention of the applicants occurred prior to a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 17 April 2011, the applicant in application no. 13509/12 (the first applicant) was a reporter at the time of his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 17 April 2011, the first applicant was arrested before a demonstration of opposition to the government.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "A record of the first applicant's administrative arrest was drawn up following his arrest on 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "An administrative-offence report was drawn up following the first applicant's arrest on 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The administrative arrest record and administrative-offence report indicated that the first applicant had been arrested on 17 April 2011 for failure to comply with a lawful request of the police to stop swearing in the street.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The first applicant was charged with the administrative offence of minor hooliganism under Article 296 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The first applicant was kept in police custody overnight following his arrest on 17 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 18 April 2011, the first applicant was brought before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Sabail District Court found the first applicant guilty under Article 296 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Sabail District Court sentenced the first applicant to a fine in the amount of 50 Azerbaijani manats (approximately 50 euros at the material time).", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The domestic courts based their decision in the first applicant's case solely on the administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The domestic courts based their decision in the first applicant's case solely on two witness statements from the police officers who had carried out his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The first applicant appealed against his administrative conviction.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In his appeal, the first applicant claimed that his arrest had been unlawful and unjustified.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "In his appeal, the first applicant claimed that his detention had been unlawful and unjustified.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "In his appeal, the first applicant claimed that the Sabail District Court's decision had not been sufficiently reasoned.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "In his appeal, the first applicant claimed that he had not been provided with the administrative-offence report so that he could prepare his defence.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "In his appeal, the first applicant claimed that he had not been provided with any other document so that he could prepare his defence.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "By a final decision of 19 May 2011, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the first applicant's appeal as unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 13509/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant in application no. 64801/12 (the second applicant) was the chairman of the Central Executive Office of the Musavat Party at the time of the events.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 24 May 2012, opposition groups were planning to hold a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The second applicant was planning to participate in the demonstration planned for 24 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "At 9.55 a.m. on 24 May 2012, the second applicant was walking with his grandson when he was stopped by two plainclothes police officers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The two plainclothes police officers invited the second applicant to the police station at 9.55 a.m. on 24 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The second applicant went with the police officers to the police station on 24 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The second applicant was held at the police station for around seven hours on 24 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The second applicant was asked various questions while held at the police station on 24 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "At 5 p.m. on 24 May 2012, the second applicant was brought before the Binagadi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Binagadi District Court found the second applicant guilty of the administrative offence of failure to comply with a lawful request of a police officer under Article 310 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Binagadi District Court sentenced the second applicant to a fine of 20 Azerbaijani manats (approximately 20 euros at the material time).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The second applicant appealed against his administrative conviction.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "In his appeal, the second applicant claimed that he had been unlawfully deprived of his liberty.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "In his appeal, the second applicant claimed that the Binagadi District Court had not given reasons for its decision.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "In his appeal, the second applicant claimed that he had been arrested to prevent him from participating in the demonstration of 24 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "By a final decision of 21 June 2012, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the second applicant's appeal as unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 64801/12"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicants complained that their rights protected under Article 5 § 1 of the Convention had been breached by the domestic authorities.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. COMPLAINTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicants complained that their rights protected under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention had been breached by the domestic authorities.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. COMPLAINTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicants complained that their rights protected under Article 6 § 3 of the Convention had been breached by the domestic authorities.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. COMPLAINTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The second applicant complained under Article 11 of the Convention of a violation of his right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. COMPLAINTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F025", "F026", "F027", "F029", "F030", "F033"], "interference": ["F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F032", "F033", "F034"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F025", "F026"], "interference": ["F027", "F030", "F033"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F025", "F026", "F027", "F030", "F033"]}} {"case_name": "case_449", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1950.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 19 February 2008 a presidential election was held in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the then Prime Minister, Mr Sargsyan, representing the ruling party.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the main opposition candidate, Mr Ter-Petrosyan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Mr Ter-Petrosyan had served as President of Armenia between 1991 and 1998.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant had occupied the post of Head of the Penitentiary Department at the Ministry of the Interior during Mr Ter-Petrosyan's presidency.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant was an active supporter of Mr Ter-Petrosyan's candidacy in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Immediately after the announcement of the preliminary results of the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election, Mr Ter-Petrosyan called on his supporters to gather at Freedom Square (also known as Opera Square) in central Yerevan to protest against alleged irregularities in the election process.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Mr Ter-Petrosyan announced that the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election had not been free and fair.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "From 20 February 2008 onwards, nationwide daily protest rallies were held by Mr Ter-Petrosyan's supporters, with their main meeting place being Freedom Square and the surrounding park in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The rallies at Freedom Square, held during the daytime and late into the night, attracted at times tens of thousands of people.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Several hundred demonstrators stayed at Freedom Square around the clock, having set up a camp.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant was an active participant in the rallies at Freedom Square and was often on the podium.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant made a speech on the first day of the rallies at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 24 February 2008 the Central Election Commission of Armenia announced that Mr Sargsyan had won the 19 February 2008 presidential election with around 52% of all votes cast.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the Central Election Commission's announcement of 24 February 2008, Mr Ter-Petrosyan received around 21% of votes in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 29 February 2008 the rallies at Freedom Square were still in full swing.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On the night of 29 February 2008 the applicant camped at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "1. The presidential election and the demonstrations held between 20 February and 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant alleged that on 1 March 2008 at around 6 a.m. the police arrived at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant alleged that the several hundred demonstrators camping at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008 were mostly still asleep when the police arrived, although some were awake, having been informed in advance about the arrival of a large number of police officers.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant alleged that in total about 800 heavily armed police officers appeared at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant alleged that the police cordon started approaching the tents at Freedom Square and panic broke out among the demonstrators who started waking the others up.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant alleged that some of the demonstrators managed to switch on the microphones and the lights on Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant alleged that Mr Ter-Petrosyan was also at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008 and addressed the demonstrators, saying: \"We see that police forces have arrived at the square. Please, do not have any contact with them and do not touch them in any way. Please keep your distance from them. Let us wait and see what they want from us. If they have something to tell us, we are ready to listen. Please, be patient and peaceful\".", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant alleged that after Mr Ter-Petrosyan's address there was silence for about a minute, by which time the police forces had already encircled Freedom Square with a triple cordon.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant alleged that suddenly, without any prior warning or orders to disperse, the police forces, shouting loudly, attacked the demonstrators at Freedom Square, most of whom were still asleep in their tents, violently beating them with rubber batons and destroying the camp.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant alleged that Mr Ter-Petrosyan was immediately arrested and taken away from Freedom Square on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant alleged that within a few minutes no demonstrator remained at Freedom Square, since everybody, including the applicant, had tried to save themselves by fleeing.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicant alleged that he and other activists were then pursued by the police through the streets and arrested.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Government contested the applicant's allegations regarding the police operation of 1 March 2008 at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Government claimed that the reason for the police operation of 1 March 2008 at Freedom Square was information obtained on 29 February 2008 by the Armenian Police and National Security Service, according to which a large number of weapons, including metal rods, wooden clubs, firearms, grenades and explosives, were to be distributed to the protesters to incite provocative actions and mass disorder in Yerevan on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Government claimed that the police operation of 1 March 2008 aimed to verify the intelligence information about weapons being distributed to protesters.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Government claimed that members of the relevant police force, without being equipped with any protective gear, arrived at Freedom Square where about 800 to 900 demonstrators armed with metal rods and wooden clubs had gathered waiting for the police.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Government claimed that the demonstrators attacked the police officers on 1 March 2008, hitting them and throwing stones, pointed metal objects and Molotov cocktails at them, as a result of which numerous police officers were injured.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Government submitted a number of official documents in support of their allegations regarding the 1 March 2008 police operation, including six records of inspection of the scene drawn up by investigators of the Principal Department for Investigations of the Armenian Police.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the six records of inspection of the scene submitted by the Government, the inspections were carried out on 1 March 2008 at several locations in Freedom Square and the surrounding park at various times between 8.30 a.m. and 11.45 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the records of inspection of the scene, a number of different objects were found at Freedom Square and the surrounding park on 1 March 2008, including pistols, cartridges, grenades and other explosives, wooden and rubber clubs, metal rods and other metal objects having a spiky, hedgehog-like shape.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Government submitted a number of expert conclusions produced following the forensic examination of the objects found at Freedom Square and the surrounding park on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 1 March 2008 the Special Investigative Service of Armenia instituted criminal case no. 62202508 under Article 225.1 §§ 1 and 2, Article 235 §§ 1 and 2 and Article 316 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code in connection with the events at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The decision instituting criminal case no. 62202508 stated that after the announcement of the preliminary results of the 19 February 2008 presidential election, Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan, members of parliament K.S. and S.M., the chief editor of Haykakan Zhamanak daily newspaper N.P., and others organised and held mass public events at Yerevan's Freedom Square in violation of the procedure prescribed by law and incited disobedience to the decisions ordering an end to the events held in violation of the procedure prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The decision instituting criminal case no. 62202508 stated that a number of participants in the mass events at Freedom Square illegally possessed and carried illegally obtained arms and ammunition.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The decision instituting criminal case no. 62202508 stated that on 1 March 2008 at around 6 a.m., when the police took measures aimed at forcibly ending the public events held in violation of the procedure prescribed by law in compliance with the requirements of section 14 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act, the organisers and participants of the events, disobeying the lawful orders of the police officers who were performing their official duties, committed a life- and health-threatening assault on them with clubs, metal rods and other adapted objects, causing the police officers injuries of varied severity.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "2. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and institution of criminal case no. 62202508"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "After Freedom Square was cleared of demonstrators on 1 March 2008, some of them relocated to the area near the French Embassy, the Yerevan Mayor's Office and the Yerevan Press Building, situated at Grigor Lusavorich and Arshakunyats Streets about 1.7-2 km from Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The demonstrators who relocated near the French Embassy, the Yerevan Mayor's Office and the Yerevan Press Building were later joined by thousands of others who apparently poured into the streets of Yerevan in response to the events of the early morning of 1 March 2008 to voice their discontent.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The rallies on 1 March 2008 continued throughout the city of Yerevan until late at night, involving clashes between protesters and law enforcement officers.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The events of 1 March 2008 in Yerevan resulted in ten deaths, including eight civilians.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The events of 1 March 2008 in Yerevan resulted in numerous injured persons.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Following the events of 1 March 2008, a state of emergency was declared by the incumbent President Kocharyan.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The state of emergency declared by President Kocharyan prohibited, inter alia, the holding of any further rallies and other mass public events for a period of twenty days.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 2 March 2008 another criminal case was instituted, no. 62202608, under Article 225 § 3 and Article 235 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code, in connection with the events following the clearing of Freedom Square on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The decision instituting criminal case no. 62202608 stated that Mr Ter-Petrosyan, the candidate running for president at the 19 February 2008 presidential election, and his followers and supporters, members of parliament K.S. and S.M., the chief editor of Haykakan Zhamanak daily newspaper N.P., and others, not willing to concede defeat at the election, with the aim of casting doubt on the election and discrediting the election and the authorities, from 1 March 2008 in the area of the Yerevan Mayor's Office and central streets organised mass disorder involving murders, violence, pogroms, arson, destruction of property and armed resistance to public officials, with the use of firearms, explosives and other adapted objects.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 2 March 2008 a number of police officers who had been involved in the events of 1-2 March 2008, including officers A.Arsh. and A.Aru., were granted victim status within the scope of criminal case no. 62202508 and later gave testimony.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Police officer A.Arsh. underwent a forensic medical examination and, according to the relevant medical conclusion, was found to have suffered a bruise to the left side of his forehead, which had been inflicted by a blunt object and caused light damage to health.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "According to the testimony of police officer A.Arsh., dated 2 March 2008, on 1 March 2008 he had been on duty at Freedom Square as a member of the Patrol Guard Service deployed there for the purpose of preserving public order and assisting the police units entrusted with the task of verifying intelligence information concerning the possession of arms by the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "According to the testimony of police officer A.Arsh., dated 2 March 2008, the demonstrators started assaulting the police officers at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "According to the testimony of police officer A.Arsh., dated 2 March 2008, the Patrol Guard Service officers tried to calm the demonstrators but one of them, who was a slim man of around 55 with greying hair, a wide forehead and a sharp nose, hit police officer A.Arsh. twice on the head with a stick and fled in the direction of Northern Avenue.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "According to the testimony of police officer A.Arsh., dated 2 March 2008, another Patrol Guard Service officer, A.Aru., tried to assist police officer A.Arsh., after which A.Aru. left in the same direction as the assailant.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "According to the testimony of police officer A.Aru., dated 11 March 2008, after the demonstrators started assaulting and resisting the police officers at Freedom Square, while standing behind the Hovhannes Tumanyan statue, he had seen one demonstrator assault police officer A.Arsh. by hitting him twice on the head with a stick.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "According to the testimony of police officer A.Aru., dated 11 March 2008, he had continued to perform his duties in the area of Arshakunyats Street where, near the Yerevan Press Building, he had noticed the same person who had assaulted police officer A.Arsh., who was a slim man of around 50 with a wide forehead, of medium height and with short black hair.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "According to the testimony of police officer A.Aru., dated 11 March 2008, he had approached the man near the Yerevan Press Building and asked him to follow him to a police station but the man had refused to comply with his order and punched him a few times in the chest, kicked his shield and fled.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "By a letter of 10 March 2008 the Chief of the Special Investigative Service requested detailed information from the Deputy Chief of the Armenian Police concerning the police operation of 1 March 2008 at Freedom Square, including its aim, planning, the number of police officers involved and the weapons and other means of personal protection used.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "By a letter of 27 March 2008 the Deputy Chief of the Armenian Police replied to the Chief of the Special Investigative Service's request of 10 March 2008, stating that the organisers and participants in the unauthorised rallies held between 20 and 29 February 2008 had, on numerous occasions, been informed about the unlawful nature of those events.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Deputy Chief of the Armenian Police's letter of 27 March 2008 stated that the police operation of 1 March 2008 was based on intelligence information received the previous day by the police and the national security service, according to which a large quantity of metal rods, wooden clubs, firearms, grenades and explosives was to be distributed to the demonstrators in order to instigate mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Deputy Chief of the Armenian Police's letter of 27 March 2008 stated that the aim of the 1 March 2008 operation was to verify the intelligence information and to inspect the area.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Deputy Chief of the Armenian Police's letter of 27 March 2008 stated that a number of unarmed police officers had entered Opera Square (Freedom Square) where they were attacked by 800-900 demonstrators armed with metal rods and wooden clubs, who were expecting the arrival of the police.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Deputy Chief of the Armenian Police's letter of 27 March 2008 stated that the police officers were beaten and stones, pointed metal objects and Molotov cocktails were thrown at them.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Deputy Chief of the Armenian Police's letter of 27 March 2008 stated that in order to prevent the disorder, an on-the-spot decision had been taken to engage the auxiliary police forces, which had been deployed earlier on the approaches to Freedom Square and had been equipped with helmets, shields and rubber batons.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Deputy Chief of the Armenian Police's letter of 27 March 2008 stated that the engagement of the auxiliary police forces resulted in the demonstrators fleeing Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Deputy Chief of the Armenian Police's letter of 27 March 2008 stated that the operation was carried out between 7 and 7.30 a.m. and was followed by a search, as a result of which numerous specially adapted metal objects, arms, ammunition and Molotov cocktails were found.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Deputy Chief of the Armenian Police's letter of 27 March 2008 stated that dozens of the most active and aggressive participants in the mass disorder were taken to various police stations.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Many participants in the post-election rallies, including a number of opposition leaders, were charged and stood trial within the scope of criminal cases nos. 62202508 and 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The outcome of criminal cases nos. 62202508 and 62202608 is unclear.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election events", "3. The subsequent developments and institution of criminal case no. 62202608"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "According to a handwritten document entitled \"the record of bringing-in\", the applicant was \"brought in\" to Kentron Police Station on 1 March 2008 at around 6.30 a.m. by three police officers, E.R., H.S. and A.A., from 1 Grigor Lusavorich Street.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The record of bringing-in stated that the applicant was brought to Kentron Police Station \"for organising unauthorised demonstrations at Freedom Square in support of Mr Ter-Petrosyan, resisting police officers and disobeying their lawful orders\".", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The record of bringing-in was signed by the three police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. and an officer of Kentron Police Station who had drafted it.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "At the bottom of the record of bringing-in it was noted that the applicant had refused to sign it.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The applicant alleged that the record of bringing-in had never been presented to him.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The applicant alleged that in reality he had been taken into custody by about 10-15 persons who did not introduce themselves as police officers and were masked.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The applicant alleged that those persons had been pursuing him all the way from Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The applicant alleged that he had managed to catch a taxi, but the taxi had been blocked after about 1-2 km by a police car at the intersection of Arshakunyats and Grigor Lusavorich Streets near the Yerevan Press Building.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The applicant alleged that the above-mentioned persons had forced him out of the taxi and started kicking, punching and hitting him with rubber batons.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The applicant alleged that he had then lost consciousness and been transported to Kentron Police Station.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The applicant alleged that upon his arrival at Kentron Police Station the same persons had continued to beat and humiliate him.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The applicant alleged that different parts of his body had been hit at Kentron Police Station, including his head and legs, as a result of which he had fallen on the floor, bleeding and unable to get up.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The applicant alleged that he had been hit on the head again at Kentron Police Station, which had resulted in concussion and loss of consciousness.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The applicant alleged that twice an ambulance had been called to provide medical assistance at Kentron Police Station.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The applicant alleged that his ill-treatment at Kentron Police Station had been inflicted upon the instructions of the police chief.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Police officer E.R. reported to the Chief of Kentron Police Station that at around 7.30 a.m. on 1 March 2008, together with police officers H.S. and A.A., he brought the applicant in to Kentron Police Station from near Yerevan circus for having resisted police officers.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Police officer E.R.'s report to the Chief of Kentron Police Station stated that while showing resistance, the applicant dropped a knife, two mobile telephones and a bunch of keys.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Another report addressed by police officer E.R. to the Chief of Kentron Police Station, signed by all three officers E.R., H.S. and A.A., stated that following an alert received on 1 March 2008, they were in the area of the unauthorised demonstration held at Freedom Square where the demonstrators were ordered to terminate the unauthorised demonstration and to clear the square.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The report signed by police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. stated that the demonstrators disobeyed their lawful orders and, while showing resistance, swore at the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The report signed by police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. stated that police officer E.R. noticed one person near Yerevan circus who was showing overly active resistance to the police and who climbed into a random taxi.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The report signed by police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. stated that police officer E.R. approached the taxi, removed that person, who dropped a knife at that moment, and together with police officers H.S. and A.A. brought that person in to Kentron Police Station, where he was identified as the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. addressed several other reports to the Chief of Kentron Police Station with practically identical content, stating that following an alert received on 1 March 2008 they were in the area of the unauthorised demonstration held at Freedom Square where the demonstrators were ordered to terminate the unauthorised demonstration and to clear the square.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The reports by police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. stated that the demonstrators disobeyed their lawful orders and showed resistance to the police officers, while hitting and swearing at them and the authorities, and that the most active of these citizens were brought in to the police station from the streets adjacent to the square.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "A memorandum signed by the Chief of Kentron Police Station in Yerevan and the Chief of the Yerevan Police, entitled \"Assaults and insults of a public official; organisation of public events in violation of the procedure prescribed by law; mass disorder within the territory of Kentron Police Station\", stated that on 1 March 2008 at around 7 a.m. officers of the Armenian police, having received an order, demanded the persons gathered at Freedom Square to vacate the square and to terminate the mass event.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The memorandum signed by the Chief of Kentron Police Station and the Chief of the Yerevan Police stated that the persons gathered at Freedom Square did not obey the lawful orders of the police officers and, by committing health- and life-threatening assault, subjected them to mass beatings and did not obey their lawful orders.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The memorandum signed by the Chief of Kentron Police Station and the Chief of the Yerevan Police stated that the activists of the rally were brought in to Kentron Police Station in Yerevan, among them A.M., the applicant, D.A., M.A., V.H. and H.B.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The memorandum signed by the Chief of Kentron Police Station and the Chief of the Yerevan Police stated that a clasp knife was discovered in the applicant's possession during his personal inspection conducted at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The knife found in the applicant's possession was at a later date examined by a forensic expert who classified it as a \"bladed weapon\".", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The applicant alleged that he had never carried a knife and therefore no such object had ever been found in his possession.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "From 7.20 to 7.40 p.m. on 1 March 2008 the investigator questioned the applicant as a witness.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "According to the relevant record of the witness questioning, the applicant stated that he had been informed in connection with which criminal case he had been summoned to testify as a witness and that it had been explained to him that as a witness he was obliged to testify or risk criminal sanctions.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The applicant stated during the witness questioning on 1 March 2008 that he did not wish to testify because he had not committed any offence.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The applicant was kept in a cell at Kentron Police Station until around 10 p.m. on 1 March 2008, when the investigator came to question him again.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The applicant alleged that he had been unable to testify at around 10 p.m. on 1 March 2008 because of the ill-treatment he had endured earlier.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "At around 10.30 p.m. on 1 March 2008 the investigator drew up a record of the applicant's arrest by filling in the relevant template, indicating \"10.30 p.m.\" as the time of the applicant's arrest.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The arrest record indicated \"Articles 225.1 § 2 and 316 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code\" as the provisions under which the applicant was suspected of having committed offences.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The arrest record drawn up at around 10.30 p.m. on 1 March 2008 was signed by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "On 2 March 2008, in the early morning, the applicant was transferred to police holding cells.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Following a medical examination upon the applicant's transfer to police holding cells on 2 March 2008, a number of injuries were noted, including an open wound on the left side of his head and a bluish-red left eye.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The applicant complained of pain in his legs upon his transfer to police holding cells on 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The applicant alleged that the medical examination at the police holding cells on 2 March 2008 had not been carried out properly and only the obvious injuries had been recorded for purely formal reasons.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "At 3.10 p.m. on 2 March 2008 the applicant was questioned as a suspect by the investigator within the scope of criminal case no. 62202508 in the presence of his lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "During the questioning on 2 March 2008, the applicant submitted that he had not committed any offence and had been participating in a peaceful demonstration at Freedom Square when, at around 6.30 a.m., thousands of police officers had started beating peaceful demonstrators with rubber batons without prior warning or orders to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "During the questioning on 2 March 2008, the applicant submitted that he and others had fled Freedom Square but the police officers had pursued them armed with rubber batons, and he had been followed for about 2 km.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "During the questioning on 2 March 2008, the applicant submitted that being of an advanced age, he had not been able to continue running so he had sat in a random taxi, which the police officers had blocked with a police car, after which they had taken him out and brutally beaten him, constantly repeating his name and swearing.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "During the questioning on 2 March 2008, the applicant submitted that he had then been taken to Kentron Police Station where he had again been beaten by the same police officers, after which they had left, and that the injuries on his body had been sustained in those circumstances.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "During the questioning on 2 March 2008, the applicant submitted that he had not been ill-treated by any of the officers at the police station itself, that he did not know the identity of those who had ill-treated him but would be able to identify them.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "During the questioning on 2 March 2008, the investigator posed three questions to the applicant: (a) whether the applicant had participated in any demonstrations held after the 19 February 2008 presidential election and what his role had been; (b) which of the demonstrators had had weapons and ammunition, the types of such weapons and the place where they had been hidden; and (c) who were the persons who had ordered the demonstrators, on 1 March 2008 at 7 a.m., to resist the police.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "During the questioning on 2 March 2008, the applicant admitted his participation in the demonstrations and marches but stated that he had stayed at Freedom Square around the clock only on 29 February 2008.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "During the questioning on 2 March 2008, the applicant stated that he had been up on the podium on multiple occasions but that the podium had been accessible to anyone.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "During the questioning on 2 March 2008, the applicant stated that he had never seen the demonstrators with any weapons or ammunition, that the demonstrations had been peaceful and accompanied with song and dance, and that nobody had given any orders to resist the police.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "During the questioning on 2 March 2008, the applicant stated that orders to resist the police would have been pointless anyway, since the police had entered the square covertly and started assaulting the demonstrators with rubber batons.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "On 2 March 2008 the investigator ordered a forensic medical examination of the applicant within the scope of criminal case no. 62202508.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The investigator's decision ordering the forensic medical examination of the applicant stated that during the events of 1 March 2008 a number of persons had been injured, including the applicant, and it was therefore necessary to clarify the location, nature, sequence of infliction, age and severity of any injuries on the applicant's body and the method of their infliction.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The investigator's decision ordering the forensic medical examination of the applicant was transmitted to a forensic medical expert on 6 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Between 7.30 and 9.30 p.m. on 2 March 2008 the investigator questioned in turn police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. in connection with the early morning events of 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The statements of police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. made during questioning on 2 March 2008, including the questions and answers, were verbatim reproductions of each other.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. stated during questioning on 2 March 2008 that certain police officers, over a loudspeaker, ordered those gathered at Freedom Square to terminate the unlawful and unauthorised demonstration and to leave, but they did not leave and some of them incited disobedience to the orders of the police officers and to continue the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. stated during questioning on 2 March 2008 that the demonstrators who were disobeying the police officers, assaulting them and making calls, were being brought in to police stations, and a number of demonstrators were assaulting the police officers with stones.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. stated during questioning on 2 March 2008 that while trying to restore order, some of the police officers, including themselves, reached the area of Pushkin Street, and at around 7 a.m. at the intersection of Pushkin Street and Northern Avenue they noticed several persons demonstrating overly violent behaviour, pulling, punching and kicking a group of outnumbered and unfamiliar police officers in police uniforms.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. stated during questioning on 2 March 2008 that they intervened and managed to transport three of the attackers to the police car, who were later identified as D.A., M.A. and V.H., and brought them in to Kentron Police Station.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. stated during questioning on 2 March 2008 that after bringing in D.A., M.A. and V.H., they returned to Freedom Square where mass disorder was still continuing, and pursued overly active demonstrators running through Northern Avenue towards the Yerevan Press Building.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. stated during questioning on 2 March 2008 that having reached Yerevan circus, they noticed one person showing resistance to police officers, punching and kicking them, after which he tried to sit in a random taxi car, but they managed to capture him, during which a knife, two mobile telephones and a bunch of keys fell from his pockets, and they brought that person in to Kentron Police Station, where he was identified as the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. stated during questioning on 2 March 2008 that they did not sustain any injuries, and that while being brought in to the police station, the persons they apprehended just pulled on their uniforms trying to free themselves.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. stated during questioning on 2 March 2008 that they were not familiar with the police officers who were assaulted by the persons they brought in to the police station, and could not provide further information about them.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A. stated during questioning on 2 March 2008 that they did not notice the persons they brought in to the police station having any weapons or other objects when they assaulted the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "On an unspecified date two more police officers, A.P. and M.G., were questioned in connection with the events of 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Police officer A.P. submitted during questioning that on 1 March 2008 he had been at Kentron Police Station when the applicant was brought in and a clasp knife found in his possession was presented, and that the applicant had not claimed that the knife did not belong to him.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Police officer M.G., who was the driver of the police car that took the applicant to Kentron Police Station, submitted during questioning that a knife had been discovered in the applicant's possession when he was being brought in.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "1. The applicant's arrest and alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "On 3 March 2008 the applicant was formally charged under Articles 225.1 § 2 and 316 § 2, as well as Articles 301 and 318 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code, within the scope of criminal case no. 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "The charge against the applicant of 3 March 2008 stated that from 20 February 2008 onwards the applicant, together with Mr Ter-Petrosyan and others, organised and conducted unlawful public events, mass demonstrations, 24-hour long rallies, assemblies, pickets and sit-ins disrupting the normal life, traffic, functioning of public and private institutions and peace and quiet of the population in Yerevan and involving calls for a violent overthrow of the government and public insults addressed at public officials connected with the performance of their official duties.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The charge against the applicant of 3 March 2008 stated that on 1 March 2008 at around 6 a.m., when the police officers demanded the participants in the demonstration at Freedom Square to give a possibility to verify the veracity of the information that they possessed arms and ammunition, and once again warned them to end the unlawful event, the applicant and other demonstrators, disobeying the police officers' lawful orders, committed life- and health-threatening assault on them.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the applicant's lawyer filed a complaint with the Chief of the Special Investigative Service, alleging that the applicant had been unjustifiably taken to Kentron Police Station under the so-called procedure of \"bringing-in\", subjected to ill-treatment and then unlawfully kept there the whole day on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The applicant's lawyer's complaint of 4 March 2008 stated that the record of the applicant's \"bringing-in\" had never been presented to him.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The applicant's lawyer's complaint of 4 March 2008 stated that the applicant's 72-hour arrest permitted by law had already expired, in violation of Article 5 § 1 (c) of the Convention, and it was still unclear on what evidence the charge against him was based.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "The applicant's lawyer's complaint of 4 March 2008 also relied on Articles 3, 10 and 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "On 4 March 2008 at 7 p.m. the applicant was brought before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan which examined the investigator's application seeking to have him detained.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that he had been brutally beaten and humiliated in the street and had sustained numerous injuries.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that no police officer had approached him to ask about weapons or to say that the demonstration was unlawful and that the demonstrators were to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that he was not a member of any political party and had not organised any demonstrations, and the charges against him were politically motivated and lacked corpus delicti.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that as regards the charge of assault under Article 316 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code, a group of 20-25 persons, without presenting themselves as police officers or asking him to follow them to a police station, preemptively attacked him and beat him up in the street, thereby creating an appearance of resistance, and that no actual police officer to whom he had allegedly put up resistance had been identified.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that his rights guaranteed by Article 10 of the Convention had been violated because he was prosecuted for simply being one of the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that the charge under Article 301 of the Armenian Criminal Code was not based on any evidence and it was not even stated what calls for a violent overthrow of the government he had allegedly made.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan decided to allow the investigator's application and order the applicant's detention for a period of two months.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan concluded that the application for the applicant's detention was substantiated, taking into account that there was sufficient evidence in the case to impose a preventive measure, and in view of the nature and dangerousness of the imputed offence and the fact that, if he remained at large, the applicant could abscond, obstruct the proceedings, continue his criminal activities and evade criminal responsibility.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "On 5 March 2008 the applicant was transferred to Vardashen Remand Prison.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "At the time of the applicant's admission to Vardashen Remand Prison on 5 March 2008, a \"record of physical injuries\" was drawn up and signed by the applicant, which indicated the following injuries on his body: a bruise on the lower left eye socket, scratch wounds on the shins, a bruise measuring 10 x 12 cm on the external surface of the right shoulder blade and a scabbed wound measuring 2 x 3 cm on the rear part of the left temple.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The \"record of physical injuries\" drawn up at Vardashen Remand Prison on 5 March 2008 indicated that the injuries, according to the applicant, were four days old.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The applicant alleged that the medical examination at Vardashen Remand Prison on 5 March 2008 had not been carried out properly and not all the injuries had been recorded.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "On 10 March 2008 the forensic medical expert examined the applicant at Vardashen Remand Prison as ordered by the investigator's decision of 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The applicant reiterated before the forensic medical expert on 10 March 2008 the circumstances of his alleged ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The forensic medical expert's conclusion, produced on 3 April 2008, found the following injuries on the applicant: a wound measuring 0.9 x 0.2 cm covered with a grey crust on the left part of the back of the head; a bruise on the left side of the outer part of the upper and lower eyelids and the cheek area of a pale yellow-greenish colour; a bruise measuring 6.3 x 2.8 cm of pale greenish-yellow colour on the right part of the chest; a bruise measuring 1.8 x 1.5 cm on the front surface of the upper third part of the right leg of a pale greenish-blue colour; and small scratches covered with grey scabs on the inner surface of the joint between the leg and the foot.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The forensic medical expert's conclusion of 3 April 2008 stated that the injuries sustained by the applicant were caused by blunt objects, possibly within the period indicated in the circumstances of the case, and that both jointly and separately they did not qualify as mild bodily injuries.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The forensic medical expert's conclusion of 3 April 2008 stated that since the injuries were inflicted within a short period, it was impossible to determine the sequence of their infliction.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The applicant alleged that the forensic medical expert who examined him on 10 March 2008 had not been impartial and independent and had not fully recorded all of his injuries.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "On 10 March 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal against his detention order.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "In his appeal against the detention order, the applicant argued that the charge against him was unsubstantiated, lacked certainty and clarity, and was not based on sufficient evidence or any witness testimony.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "In his appeal against the detention order, the applicant argued that in violation of the guarantees of Article 5 § 1 (c) of the Convention, an artificial ground had been created to justify his detention, namely resisting a public official, which had never happened.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "In his appeal against the detention order, the applicant argued that there were not sufficient grounds justifying his detention: he was known to be of good character, had a permanent place of residence, did not try to hide from the investigation or refuse to appear before the investigating authority, and no real evidence of any attempt to obstruct the proceedings had been presented.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "In his appeal against the detention order, the applicant argued that if he were to remain at large, he could not engage in similar activities, given the state of emergency declared in the country.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "On 21 March 2008 the Criminal Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal against the detention order, finding that the applicant's detention was based on a reasonable suspicion and the grounds relied on by the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan in justification of detention were sufficient.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "On 28 March 2008 confrontations were held between the applicant and police officers E.R., H.S. and A.P., who reiterated their earlier statements.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "The applicant refused to have a confrontation with police officer A.A. on 28 March 2008, alleging that E.R., H.S. and A.A. were not the police officers who had apprehended him.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "On 25 April 2008 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan extended the applicant's detention by two months, finding that it was still necessary to carry out a number of investigative measures and that, if he remained at large, the applicant could abscond, obstruct the proceedings, commit another offence and evade criminal responsibility.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "On 26 June 2008 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan extended the applicant's detention by a further two months, finding that it was still necessary to carry out a number of investigative measures and that, if he remained at large, the applicant could abscond, obstruct the proceedings, commit another offence and evade criminal responsibility.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "The applicant's request for bail was refused by the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "On 2 May 2008 the applicant's lawyer wrote to the Chief of Kentron Police Station, enquiring about the circumstances in which the applicant had sustained his injuries; whether they had been inflicted at the police station or prior to his arrival there and, if it was the latter, whether any record had been made in the police registers.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "On 3 June 2008 the applicant applied to the General Prosecutor requesting that criminal proceedings be instituted and an investigation be carried out into the fact of his ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "In his application to the General Prosecutor of 3 June 2008, the applicant submitted that the circumstances of his arrest involved an offence against him since he had been beaten and tortured, but no assessment had been given to that circumstance in the context of the criminal case against him.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "No reply was provided to the applicant's lawyer's enquiry of 2 May 2008 to the Chief of Kentron Police Station.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "No decision was taken on the applicant's application of 3 June 2008 to the General Prosecutor requesting an investigation into his ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "On 18 June 2008 seven members of the Armenian parliament filed a request with the General Prosecutor, seeking to have the applicant's detention replaced with another preventive measure, namely their personal guarantee.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "The seven members of the Armenian parliament submitted in their request of 18 June 2008 that the detention of several hundred persons, including the applicant, following the presidential election was a disproportionate measure and was not based on reasonable suspicions.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "The seven members of the Armenian parliament submitted in their request of 18 June 2008 that they personally knew the applicant and guaranteed that, if he remained at large, he would not abscond, obstruct the proceedings, commit another offence or evade his penalty, if any.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "The outcome of the seven members of the Armenian parliament's request of 18 June 2008 to the General Prosecutor is unclear.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "On 28 June 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal against the extension order of 26 June 2008, arguing that his continued detention was not based on a reasonable suspicion and that he was being persecuted for his political views.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "In his appeal of 28 June 2008, the applicant argued that the courts provided no evidential or factual basis in support of the charges against him, that the case against him was trumped up with police officers being the only witnesses and with the identities of the allegedly injured police officers not being known.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "In his appeal of 28 June 2008, the applicant argued that the courts had extended his detention in order for the investigating authority to have sufficient time to fabricate charges, and that the courts provided abstract and stereotyped reasons when extending his detention.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "On 15 July 2008 the Criminal Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal of 28 June 2008 on the same grounds as previously.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "2. The charges against the applicant, his detention and further investigative measures"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "On 12 June 2008 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan under Article 290 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure, seeking to have the relevant police order which served as a basis for the police operation of 1 March 2008 declared unlawful and unfounded, and the ensuing police actions declared unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "In his complaint of 12 June 2008, the applicant submitted that he had participated in the demonstrations held from 20 February 2008 onwards, which had been held in compliance with the Constitution and Article 11 of the Convention and involved no criminal behaviour.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "In his complaint of 12 June 2008, the applicant submitted that in the morning of 1 March 2008 armed police forces had suddenly invaded Freedom Square and started beating peaceful demonstrators, and that the police attack had been unjustified and failed to meet the requirements of Article 11 § 2 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "In his complaint of 12 June 2008, the applicant submitted that the true purpose of the police operation was to launch political persecution of the supporters of Mr Ter-Petrosyan, including himself, by provoking the demonstrators to engage in clashes, creating artificial charges of resistance to police and punishing them for exercising their right to freedom of assembly and for their political opinion.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "In his complaint of 12 June 2008, the applicant requested that the decisions to institute criminal proceedings and to bring charges against him be quashed and the proceedings be discontinued.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "On 8 July 2008 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan dismissed the applicant's complaint of 12 June 2008, finding that the relevant police order was not a decision or action prescribed by the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure and therefore could not be contested under Article 290 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found on 8 July 2008 that the applicant's requests to quash the decisions in question and to discontinue the criminal proceedings could be lodged with a court only after they had been raised before a prosecutor, which the applicant had failed to do.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "On 21 July 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal against the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan's decision of 8 July 2008, arguing that the District Court had incorrectly interpreted Article 290 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "In his appeal of 21 July 2008, the applicant argued that the District Court had failed to make any assessment of the police actions and its conclusion that the police order did not fall within the scope of criminal procedure law had not been based on the circumstances of the case.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "In his appeal of 21 July 2008, the applicant argued that the police actions had been unlawful and disproportionate and the force used against peaceful demonstrators had been excessive, while the decision to institute criminal proceedings was artificial by its nature.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "On 19 August 2008 the Criminal Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan of 8 July 2008 and dismissed the applicant's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal found on 19 August 2008, relying on Article 290 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure, that the contested police order, the decision to institute criminal proceedings, as well as ordering the investigating authority to discontinue the criminal proceedings, were beyond the scope of judicial control over the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F205", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal found on 19 August 2008 that Article 290 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure presupposed judicial control over pre-trial proceedings and therefore applied only to the period after a decision to institute such proceedings was taken.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F206", "text": "On 3 November 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal on points of law against the Criminal Court of Appeal's decision of 19 August 2008.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F207", "text": "On 21 November 2008 the Court of Cassation of Armenia refused to examine the applicant's appeal on points of law on the grounds that it had been lodged out of time and that no proof was attached to the appeal certifying that its copy had been served on the respondent party.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "3. The applicant's complaint against the police actions of 1 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F208", "text": "On 28 July 2008 about twenty-five police officers, including police officers A.Arsh. and A.Aru., who had allegedly been assaulted during the events of 1-2 March 2008 and had provided a description of the alleged perpetrators, were invited to Vardashen Remand Prison to identify the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F209", "text": "The applicant refused to take part in the identification parade on 28 July 2008, stating that that investigative measure had no probative value, and as a result the parade did not take place.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F210", "text": "Instead of an identification parade, a photo identification of the applicant was carried out on 28 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F211", "text": "Police officer A.Arsh. identified the applicant, from among the photographs shown to him on 28 July 2008, as the person who had assaulted him at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008 at around 7 a.m. by hitting him twice with a stick, stating that he recognised the applicant by the general structure of his face, his wide forehead and his haircut and style.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F212", "text": "Police officer A.Aru. identified the applicant, through the same photo identification procedure on 28 July 2008, as the person who had assaulted police officer A.Arsh. at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008 at around 7 a.m. with a stick and later assaulted him on Arshakunyats Street, stating that he recognised the applicant by his facial features, the structure of his forehead and his hair.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F213", "text": "On 5 August 2008 the investigator decided to drop the charges against the applicant under Article 225.1 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code, finding that it had been established by the investigation that the order issued by the police officers to the demonstrators on 1 March 2008 at around 7 a.m. at Freedom Square was not to disperse but to allow them to inspect the area, and thus the applicant's actions did not contain elements of a crime prescribed by that Article.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F214", "text": "On 5 August 2008 the investigator decided to drop the charges against the applicant under Article 301 of the Armenian Criminal Code on the ground of insufficient evidence, since the applicant's involvement in an attempt to seize State power could not be established.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F215", "text": "On 5 August 2008 the investigator decided to drop the charges against the applicant under Article 318 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code since that Article had been repealed in the meantime.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F216", "text": "On 5 August 2008 the investigator decided to supplement the charge against the applicant under Article 316 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code with new charges under Article 235 § 4 and Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F217", "text": "The supplemented charge stated that the applicant, having regularly participated in the unauthorised demonstrations held following the presidential election, had been present at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008 at around 7 a.m. when some of the demonstrators, using makeshift clubs, rods and other dangerous objects, had assaulted the police officers after the latter had demanded to be allowed to verify the information concerning the possession of arms and ammunition by the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F218", "text": "The supplemented charge stated that the applicant had refused to comply with the lawful orders of the police officers, assaulted police officer A.Arsh., twice hitting him on the head with a stick and causing light damage to his health, after which he had disappeared in the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F219", "text": "The supplemented charge stated that police officer A.Aru. had witnessed the act committed by the applicant against police officer A.Arsh. but failed to bring him in.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F220", "text": "The supplemented charge stated that police officer A.Aru. had continued to perform his duties near the Yerevan Press Building situated on Arshakunyats Street, where he had once again noticed the applicant, tried to bring him in, but the applicant had resisted, pushed, pulled and kicked police officer A.Aru., thereby assaulting him in a non-health-threatening way, and tried to escape in a random taxi.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F221", "text": "The supplemented charge stated that police officers E.R., H.S. and A.A., who were on duty in the same area, had witnessed the applicant's assault on police officer A.Aru. and brought the applicant in to Kentron Police Station, at which time a weapon, namely a knife, was found in his possession.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F222", "text": "On 5 August 2008 the investigator invited the applicant for questioning and a confrontation with police officer A.Arsh.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F223", "text": "The applicant refused to testify or to take part in the confrontation with police officer A.Arsh. on 5 August 2008, stating that he did not trust the investigator and the investigative measures in question.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F224", "text": "The applicant's lawyer stated on 5 August 2008 that a confrontation with a police officer so many months after the event did not appear credible and was simply another attempt to create evidence against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F225", "text": "On 6 August 2008 the applicant's case was disjoined from criminal case no. 62202608 into a separate criminal case, no. 62215008.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F226", "text": "On 6 August 2008 the knife found in the applicant's possession was examined by the investigator and its description was recorded.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F227", "text": "On 13 August 2008 the General Prosecutor approved the bill of indictment against the applicant under Articles 235 § 4 and 316 §§ 1 and 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F228", "text": "The bill of indictment approved on 13 August 2008 contained an identical statement of facts to that in the supplemented charge against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F229", "text": "The bill of indictment relied on the statements of police officers A.Arsh. and A.Aru. made in their capacity as victims.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F230", "text": "The bill of indictment relied on the records of the applicant's photo identification by police officers A.Arsh. and A.Aru.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F231", "text": "The bill of indictment relied on the statements of police officers H.S., E.R., A.A., A.P. and M.G. made in their capacity as witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F232", "text": "The bill of indictment relied on the submissions of the police officers made during the confrontations with the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F233", "text": "The bill of indictment relied on two expert conclusions: one regarding the injury sustained by police officer A.Arsh. and the other classifying the knife in question as a \"bladed weapon\", as well as the record of inspection of the knife.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F234", "text": "The bill of indictment relied on the letter of 27 March 2008 of the Deputy Chief of the Armenian Police.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F235", "text": "The bill of indictment relied on the records of inspection of the scene at Freedom Square and the relevant expert conclusions.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F236", "text": "The indictment stated that injuries had been discovered on the applicant, which did not qualify even as light injuries and which had been caused during the clash between the police officers and \"the persons assaulting them\".", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F237", "text": "The indictment stated that the investigation into the injuries discovered on the applicant was still pending.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "4. The modified charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F238", "text": "On 13 August 2008 the applicant's case was sent to the Yerevan Criminal Court for trial.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F239", "text": "In the course of the proceedings before the Yerevan Criminal Court, the court summoned and heard police officers A.Arsh., A.Aru., H.S., E.R., A.A., A.P. and M.G.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F240", "text": "Police officer A.Arsh. submitted before the Yerevan Criminal Court that on 1 March 2008, when the police asked the demonstrators gathered at Freedom Square to allow them to carry out an inspection for weapons, the demonstrators had reacted violently, and that the applicant had attacked him and hit him twice on the head with a stick, after which he had fled.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F241", "text": "Police officer A.Aru. submitted before the Yerevan Criminal Court that he had seen the applicant attack police officer A.Arsh. and hit him on the head with a stick, and that he had thereafter continued to perform his duty in the area of Arshakunyats Street, where he had noticed the applicant, asked him to go with him to a police station, but the applicant had hit him several times on the chest, kicked his shield and fled.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F242", "text": "Police officer H.S. submitted before the Yerevan Criminal Court that in the morning of 1 March 2008 the applicant had assaulted police officers on Arshakunyats Street near the Yerevan Press Building, by hitting and pulling them, and that he and police officers E.R. and A.A. had brought the applicant in in a patrol car, and a knife, mobile telephones and a bunch of keys had fallen from his pockets.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F243", "text": "Police officer E.R. submitted before the Yerevan Criminal Court that when performing his duty on Arshakunyats Street in the morning of 1 March 2008, he had seen an individual punching and kicking police officers, that the person had tried to flee but he and police officers H.S. and A.A. had brought him in, whereupon he had been identified as the applicant, and that a knife, a mobile telephone and a bunch of keys had been found in his possession.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F244", "text": "Police officer A.A. submitted before the Yerevan Criminal Court similar evidence to police officers H.S. and E.R. but stated that two mobile telephones had fallen from the applicant's pockets and that this had happened at 7.30 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F245", "text": "Police officers A.P. and M.G. reiterated their earlier statements before the Yerevan Criminal Court.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F246", "text": "The applicant denied his guilt before the Yerevan Criminal Court and submitted that even if he had participated in the demonstrations held from 20 February 2008, he had done nothing illegal.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F247", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Yerevan Criminal Court that he and his co-thinkers at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008 had found out about the forthcoming arrival of the police several hours in advance, and that after the police had arrived, he had not hit anyone and had tried to escape.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F248", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Yerevan Criminal Court that having reached Arshakunyats Street, he had been brutally beaten by police officers and transported to Kentron Police Station where he had also been beaten, and that he had never carried a knife.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F249", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Yerevan Criminal Court that the alleged assault on police officers A.Arsh. and A.Aru. could not have happened at around 7.15 a.m. and 7.30 a.m. as alleged by the prosecution, because the police operation had happened at around 6 a.m. and at 6.30 a.m. he had already been at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F250", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Yerevan Criminal Court that according to the relevant medical expert conclusion, police officer A.Arsh. had sustained his injury at some point between 1 and 3 March 2008, casting doubt on the claim that the injury had been sustained specifically on the morning of 1 March 2008, especially given that police officer A.Arsh. had participated in clashes on both 1 and 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F251", "text": "The applicant lodged requests with the Yerevan Criminal Court seeking to have a number of persons called and examined as witnesses, including A.M., D.A., M.A., V.H., H.B., N.T., S.M., S.A. and H.T.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F252", "text": "The applicant argued before the Yerevan Criminal Court that the testimony of A.M., D.A., M.A., V.H. and H.B., who were also active demonstrators, would support his allegation that the police actions had been unlawful from the very outset, that on 1 March 2008 at around 6 a.m. he and they had been attacked by the police without prior warning and had been forcibly brought in, and that at 7 a.m. he had already been at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F253", "text": "The applicant argued before the Yerevan Criminal Court that N.T. and S.M., who were also opposition activists, had been by his side at Freedom Square when the demonstrators had been attacked by the police and their testimony would clarify circumstances related to the charge against him, including that as early as at 6.45 a.m. there had been nobody at Freedom Square apart from the police.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F254", "text": "The applicant argued before the Yerevan Criminal Court that testimony from S.A. and H.T., who were high-ranking police officials and had apparently given orders for the police operation, was important in order to assess the police actions of the morning of 1 March 2008, and that it was also necessary to call and examine other Patrol Guard Service officers who had taken part in the police operation.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F255", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court decided to dismiss the applicant's requests to call and examine witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F256", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court found that N.T. had already been questioned by the investigator during the investigation and it was sufficient to read out his statement in court.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F257", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court found that S.M., who was separately also standing trial, had in general refused to give testimony during the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F258", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court found that as regards V.H., D.A. and M.A., the argument that they were able to confirm the fact that at 6.30 a.m. the applicant had already been at the police station was not a sufficient reason to call and examine them in court.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F259", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court found that as regards S.A., H.T. and the unnamed Patrol Guard Service officers, it had been explained to the defence that the police actions could be contested before the courts through a different procedure, and in such circumstances the necessity of calling and examining those police officers was not well-founded.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F260", "text": "On 23 October 2008 the Yerevan Criminal Court found the applicant guilty under Article 235 § 4 and Article 316 §§ 1 and 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F261", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court sentenced the applicant under Article 235 § 4 of the Armenian Criminal Code to a fine in the amount of 400,000 Armenian drams.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F262", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court sentenced the applicant under Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code to a fine in the amount of 500,000 Armenian drams.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F263", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court sentenced the applicant under Article 316 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code to five years' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F264", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court found it established that in the period preceding 1 March 2008 intelligence information was received by the Armenian Police and the National Security Service that the demonstrators gathered at Yerevan's Freedom Square had in their possession firearms, ammunition, clubs, rods and other objects for the purpose of causing physical injuries and violence.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F265", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court found it established that on 1 March 2008 at around 7 a.m. police officers demanded the persons gathered at Yerevan's Freedom Square to allow them to verify the above information by inspecting the area, and that this demand was announced out loud several times.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F266", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court found it established that some of the people gathered at Freedom Square, including the applicant, had already been informed several hours in advance about the planned police operation.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F267", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court found it established that the applicant, in front of the statue of Hovhannes Tumanyan, hit police officer A.Arsh. twice on the head with a stick, causing light damage to his health accompanied by a brief deterioration of health, after which he disappeared in the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F268", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court found it established that police officer A.Aru. saw the act committed by the applicant against police officer A.Arsh. and continued his duty in the area near the Yerevan Press Building situated at Arshakunyats Street, where he once again noticed the applicant and tried to bring him in.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F269", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court found it established that the applicant, disobeying police officer A.Aru.'s lawful order to appear at the police station, assaulted him in a non-health-threatening way by pushing, pulling and kicking him, and tried to escape in a random taxi.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F270", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court found it established that police officers A.A., E.R. and H.S., who were on duty in the same area, noticed the incident and brought the applicant in to Kentron Police Station, during which a bladed weapon – a knife – fell from the applicant's pocket, as well as two mobile telephones and a bunch of keys.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F271", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court found it established that on 1 March 2008 at 9 p.m. the applicant was arrested and on 4 March 2008 he was detained.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F272", "text": "In establishing its findings, the Yerevan Criminal Court relied on the same evidence on which the indictment was based, plus the statements of the police officers made in court.", "source_paragraph": 85, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F273", "text": "The Yerevan Criminal Court found the applicant's submissions to be unreliable and an attempt to avoid criminal responsibility.", "source_paragraph": 85, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F274", "text": "On 10 November 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal against the Yerevan Criminal Court's judgment of 23 October 2008, arguing that the charge against him was trumped-up and politically motivated.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F275", "text": "In his appeal of 10 November 2008, the applicant argued that he had been ill-treated both at the time of his apprehension and at the police station and that no investigation had been carried out into his allegations of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F276", "text": "In his appeal of 10 November 2008, the applicant argued that the interference with his freedom of peaceful assembly had been unlawful, unjustified and accompanied with use of excessive force by the police.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F277", "text": "In his appeal of 10 November 2008, the applicant argued that the only witnesses in the case were police officers who, being interested in the outcome of the case because of the brutal and unlawful force used against the demonstrators, were not impartial and trustworthy witnesses and had made contradictory statements which were then coordinated towards the end of the investigation and which constituted the sole basis for his conviction.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F278", "text": "In his appeal of 10 November 2008, the applicant argued that the principle of equality of arms had not been respected since his request to call and examine witnesses on his behalf had been groundlessly dismissed, and that the entire case was based on police testimony while he was not allowed to defend himself effectively and to summon any impartial witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F279", "text": "In his appeal of 10 November 2008, the applicant contested the reliability of the evidence provided by police officers H.S., E.R. and A.A., pointing to the fact that their statements made in court differed while those made during the investigation had been identical in wording, and that it appeared from their statements that they had been arresting different demonstrators from different locations, all at the same time.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F280", "text": "In his appeal of 10 November 2008, the applicant argued that the statements of police officers A.Arsh. and A.Aru. concerned events which had taken place in a chaotic situation early in the morning when it was still dark, and that the police officers had effectively refused to answer any questions in court, limiting their answers to either \"I do not remember\" or \"I do not know\".", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F281", "text": "In his appeal of 10 November 2008, the applicant argued that the trial court had failed to make any assessment of the police actions at Freedom Square, including their lawfulness and proportionality, without which the charge against him could not receive a fair determination.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F282", "text": "In his appeal of 10 November 2008, the applicant alleged that he had been known to the authorities and was persecuted for being a supporter of Mr Ter-Petrosyan and because of a critical speech he had made on the first day of the demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F283", "text": "In his appeal of 10 November 2008, the applicant argued that he had initially been charged with resisting unidentified police officers, until about five months later when a new charge had emerged of him assaulting another police officer in a different location, namely at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F284", "text": "In his appeal of 10 November 2008, the applicant argued that there were multiple contradictions regarding the time of his apprehension, which in later police statements was alleged to have happened at around 7.30-8 a.m., whereas according to the relevant record, at around 6.30 a.m. he had already been at Kentron Police Station.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F285", "text": "In his appeal of 10 November 2008, the applicant argued that if he was suspected of assaulting police officer A.Arsh. on 1 March 2008, he should have been presented for identification as early as on 2 March 2008, but instead photo identification was performed only about five months later.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F286", "text": "In his appeal of 10 November 2008, the applicant relied on, inter alia, Articles 3, 5, 6, 10 and 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F287", "text": "On 10 December 2008 the Criminal Court of Appeal examined the applicant's appeal of 10 November 2008 through an expedited procedure and decided on the same day to dismiss it, relying on the same evidence as the Yerevan Criminal Court.", "source_paragraph": 87, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F288", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's argument that his conviction was based solely on the statements of police officers who were not impartial witnesses, finding that the fact that the victims and witnesses in the case were police officers did not diminish the probative value of their statements and it was unacceptable to view this as a predetermining or prejudicial circumstance.", "source_paragraph": 87, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F289", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal found that the criminal case was based also on a number of expert conclusions, the records of inspection of the scene and the records of the applicant's photo identification.", "source_paragraph": 87, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F290", "text": "As regards the applicant's claim that his allegations of ill-treatment had not been investigated, the Criminal Court of Appeal stated that, according to a decision of the investigating authority, it was still necessary to carry out a comprehensive investigation – within the scope of criminal case no. 62202608 – into the circumstances under which injuries had been sustained by persons, including the applicant, who had participated in the mass disorder of 1-2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 87, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F291", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal stated that since the investigation into the applicant's criminal case had been completed, his case was disjoined from criminal case no. 62202608, while the latter was still pending.", "source_paragraph": 87, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F292", "text": "On 27 January 2009 the applicant lodged an appeal on points of law, raising similar arguments to those in his appeal of 10 November 2008 and relying on, inter alia, Articles 3, 5, 6, 10 and 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 88, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F293", "text": "On 10 March 2009 the Court of Cassation of Armenia declared the applicant's appeal on points of law inadmissible for lack of merit.", "source_paragraph": 89, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F294", "text": "At the end of November 2010 the applicant was released from prison after having served more than half of his sentence.", "source_paragraph": 90, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The criminal proceedings against the applicant", "5. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F295", "text": "Article 225.1 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003) provides that inciting disobedience to an order to terminate a public event held in violation of the procedure prescribed by law is punishable by a fine of between 300 and 500 times the minimum wage or detention of up to three months.", "source_paragraph": 91, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (2003)", "1. Provisions related to the charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F296", "text": "Article 235 § 4 of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003) provides that illegal carrying of a gas, bladed or missile weapon is punishable by a fine of between 200 and 600 times the minimum wage or detention of between one and three months or imprisonment for a period not exceeding two years.", "source_paragraph": 92, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (2003)", "1. Provisions related to the charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F297", "text": "Article 301 of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003) provides that making public calls for a violent overthrow of the government and a violent change of the constitutional order of Armenia is punishable by a fine of between 300 and 500 times the minimum wage or by detention of between two and three months or by imprisonment for a period not exceeding three years.", "source_paragraph": 93, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (2003)", "1. Provisions related to the charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F298", "text": "Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003) provides that non-life-threatening or non-health-threatening assault or threat of such assault on a public official or his or her next-of-kin, connected with the performance of his or her official duties, is punishable by a fine of between 300 and 500 times the minimum wage or detention of up to one month or imprisonment for a period not exceeding five years.", "source_paragraph": 94, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (2003)", "1. Provisions related to the charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F299", "text": "Article 316 § 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003) provides that a life-threatening or a health-threatening assault on a public official or his or her next-of-kin, connected with the performance of their duties, is punishable by imprisonment for a period from five to ten years.", "source_paragraph": 94, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (2003)", "1. Provisions related to the charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F300", "text": "Article 318 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003) provides that publicly insulting a public official, in connection with the performance of his duties, is punishable by a fine of between 100 and 500 times the minimum wage or detention of up to one month.", "source_paragraph": 95, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (2003)", "1. Provisions related to the charges against the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F301", "text": "Article 225 § 3 of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003) prescribes a penalty for organising mass disorder involving violence, massacre, arson, destruction of or damage to property, or armed resistance to public officials and murder.", "source_paragraph": 96, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (2003)", "2. Other relevant provisions"]}, {"fact_id": "F302", "text": "Article 225.1 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003) prescribes a penalty for organising and holding a public event in violation of the procedure prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 97, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (2003)", "2. Other relevant provisions"]}, {"fact_id": "F303", "text": "Article 235 §§ 1 and 2 of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003) prescribes a penalty for illegal acquisition, sale, possession, trafficking or carrying of arms and ammunition by a group of people acting in collusion.", "source_paragraph": 98, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal Code (2003)", "2. Other relevant provisions"]}, {"fact_id": "F304", "text": "For a summary of the relevant provisions of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) concerning ill-treatment and investigation, see Zalyan and Others v. Armenia (nos. 36894/04 and 3521/07, §§ 148-154, 17 March 2016).", "source_paragraph": 99, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "1. Ill-treatment and investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F305", "text": "Article 34 § 1 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that a body of inquiry, an investigator and a prosecutor may arrest and question a person suspected of having committed an offence, as well as impose measures of compulsion and bring charges against such a person, on the grounds and in accordance with the procedure prescribed by the Code.", "source_paragraph": 100, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(a) Arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F306", "text": "Article 62 § 1 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999), entitled \"Suspect\", provides that a suspect is the person (a) who has been arrested upon a suspicion of having committed an offence; or (b) in whose respect, prior to bringing a charge, a decision has been adopted to impose a preventive measure.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(a) Arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F307", "text": "Article 63 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) enumerates the rights enjoyed by a suspect, including the right to be informed about the reasons for his arrest and his rights as a suspect, to have a lawyer and to be questioned in his or her presence, to remain silent and to inform his next-of-kin – immediately and, in any event, not later than 12 hours after being taken into custody – of the place where he is held in custody and the grounds for his custody.", "source_paragraph": 102, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(a) Arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F308", "text": "Article 128 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999), entitled \"The Notion of Arrest\", provides that arrest is the taking of a person into custody, bringing him before the body of inquiry or the authority conducting the criminal proceedings, drawing up the relevant record and informing that person about it, for the purpose of preventing him or her from committing an offence or from fleeing after having committed an offence and with the aim of keeping that person in short-term custody in places and conditions defined by law.", "source_paragraph": 103, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(a) Arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F309", "text": "Article 128 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that a person may be arrested (1) on an immediate suspicion of having committed an offence; or (2) on the basis of an arrest warrant issued by the prosecuting authority.", "source_paragraph": 103, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(a) Arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F310", "text": "Article 129 § 1 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999), entitled \"Arrest on an Immediate Suspicion of Having Committed an Offence\", provides that a person suspected of having committed an offence may be arrested if (a) he was caught while committing a criminal act or immediately thereafter; (b) an eyewitness directly points him out as the perpetrator of a criminal act; (c) obvious traces linking him to a criminal act have been discovered on him, his clothes or other objects used by him, or in his home or vehicle; or (d) there are other grounds to suspect a person, who has made an attempt to flee from the crime scene or from the authority conducting criminal proceedings or who has no permanent residence or resides elsewhere or whose identity is unknown, of having committed an offence.", "source_paragraph": 104, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(a) Arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F311", "text": "Article 129 § 2 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that an arrest on immediate suspicion of having committed an offence may not exceed 72 hours from the moment of taking into custody.", "source_paragraph": 104, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(a) Arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F312", "text": "Article 130 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999), entitled \"Arrest on the Basis of an Arrest Warrant Issued by the Prosecuting Authority\", prescribes the possibility of arresting a person on a suspicion of having committed an offence on the basis of an arrest warrant issued by the prosecuting authority.", "source_paragraph": 105, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(a) Arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F313", "text": "Article 131.1 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999), entitled \"The Procedure for a Suspect's Arrest\", provides that a record of a suspect's arrest must be drawn up within three hours of bringing him before the body of inquiry, the investigator or the prosecutor and a copy must be given to the arrested person upon his signature.", "source_paragraph": 106, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(a) Arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F314", "text": "Article 131.1 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that the record of a suspect's arrest must indicate the time when it was drawn up (date, hour and minute), the time, place, reason(s) and purpose of the arrest, the article of the Criminal Code under which a person is suspected of having committed an offence, the results of his personal search and other circumstances, including any declarations and requests by the arrested person.", "source_paragraph": 106, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(a) Arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F315", "text": "Article 132 § 1 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that an arrested person must be released upon a decision of the authority conducting the criminal proceedings if (1) the suspicion of having committed an offence has not been confirmed; (2) there is no need to keep the person in custody; or (3) the maximum time-limit for an arrest prescribed by the Code of Criminal Procedure has expired and the court has not adopted a decision to detain the accused.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(a) Arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F316", "text": "For a summary of the relevant provisions of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) concerning detention on remand, see Ara Harutyunyan v. Armenia (no. 629/11, §§ 30-37, 20 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 108, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(b) Detention on remand"]}, {"fact_id": "F317", "text": "Article 6 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) prescribes that \"taking into custody\" is the act which starts from the moment of a person's de facto and forcible deprivation of liberty when being arrested or detained or when enforcing a custodial sentence.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(c) Other provisions related to deprivation of liberty"]}, {"fact_id": "F318", "text": "Article 153 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999), entitled \"Bringing-In\", provides that bringing a person in is when a suspect, accused, defendant, convicted person, witness or victim, who fails to appear before the investigating authority without valid reasons, is forcibly taken to the body conducting the criminal proceedings in order to carry out procedural measures with his participation as prescribed by the Code of Criminal Procedure, which may lead to the temporary restriction of rights and freedoms of the brought-in person.", "source_paragraph": 110, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(c) Other provisions related to deprivation of liberty"]}, {"fact_id": "F319", "text": "Article 153 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that \"bringing-in\" is carried out upon a reasoned decision of the body of inquiry, the investigator, the prosecutor or the court.", "source_paragraph": 110, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(c) Other provisions related to deprivation of liberty"]}, {"fact_id": "F320", "text": "Article 180 § 1 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999), entitled \"Procedure for examination of crime reports\", provides that crime reports must be examined and decided upon immediately, while in cases where it is necessary to check whether there are lawful and sufficient grounds to institute a criminal case, within ten days following the receipt of such reports.", "source_paragraph": 111, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(c) Other provisions related to deprivation of liberty"]}, {"fact_id": "F321", "text": "Article 180 § 2 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that within the period for examination of crime reports, additional documents, statements or other materials may be obtained; the scene of the incident may be inspected; persons may be brought in and subjected to a personal search if there are sufficient grounds for a suspicion that they have committed an offence; samples may be taken for inspection; and examinations may be ordered.", "source_paragraph": 111, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "2. Deprivation of liberty", "(c) Other provisions related to deprivation of liberty"]}, {"fact_id": "F322", "text": "Article 103 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that actions and decisions of the authority conducting the criminal proceedings may be appealed against by the participants in the proceedings, in accordance with a procedure prescribed by the Code.", "source_paragraph": 112, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "3. Appeals against decisions and actions of the authority conducting the criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F323", "text": "Article 103 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that appeal against actions and decisions of an investigator or an officer of a body of inquiry lies to the respective prosecutor, against actions and decisions of a prosecutor to a superior prosecutor, and against actions and decisions of a court to a superior court.", "source_paragraph": 112, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "3. Appeals against decisions and actions of the authority conducting the criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F324", "text": "Article 103 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that in cases prescribed by the Code an appeal against actions and decisions of the prosecuting authority may be lodged with a court.", "source_paragraph": 112, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "3. Appeals against decisions and actions of the authority conducting the criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F325", "text": "Article 290 §§ 1, 4 and 5 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999), entitled \"Contesting before a court unlawful and unfounded decisions and actions of a body of inquiry, an investigator, a prosecutor or bodies carrying out operative and intelligence measures\", provides that such decisions and actions may be contested before a court by the suspect, the accused, the defence lawyer, the victim, the participants in the criminal proceedings and other persons whose rights and lawful interests were violated by those decisions and actions, if their complaints had not been granted by a prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "3. Appeals against decisions and actions of the authority conducting the criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F326", "text": "Article 290 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that the complaint shall be examined by a single judge within ten days from its receipt, and if the complaint is found to be substantiated, the court shall adopt a decision obliging the body conducting the criminal proceedings to put an end to the violation of a person's rights and freedoms.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "3. Appeals against decisions and actions of the authority conducting the criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F327", "text": "Article 86 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that a witness is a person, summoned by the party or the authority conducting the criminal proceedings for the purpose of providing testimony, who may be aware of any circumstance investigated within the scope of a criminal case, and that a witness is obliged to appear upon the summons of the authority conducting the criminal proceedings in order to provide testimony or participate in investigative and other procedural measures.", "source_paragraph": 114, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "4. Other relevant provisions"]}, {"fact_id": "F328", "text": "Article 221 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that a person undergoing identification is presented to the identifier together with at least three other persons of the same sex and as similar as possible in appearance and clothing to the person undergoing identification, and that if necessary, the identification may be performed using photos of different persons similar in appearance and clothing to the person undergoing identification.", "source_paragraph": 115, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "4. Other relevant provisions"]}, {"fact_id": "F329", "text": "Article 331 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that a party lodging a request seeking to adduce and include in the case file additional evidence must demonstrate the circumstances which such evidence may be necessary to clarify, and that the court is obliged to examine any such request and to hear the parties' opinions.", "source_paragraph": 116, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "4. Other relevant provisions"]}, {"fact_id": "F330", "text": "Article 331 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that the court must allow the request if the circumstances which it seeks to clarify may be of importance to the case or the material whose probative value is being contested has been obtained in substantial violation of the law, and that the court must reason its decision to dismiss the request.", "source_paragraph": 116, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "4. Other relevant provisions"]}, {"fact_id": "F331", "text": "Article 331 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) provides that the court is entitled to decide to call witnesses, order examinations or request other evidence of its own motion.", "source_paragraph": 116, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Criminal Procedure (1999)", "4. Other relevant provisions"]}, {"fact_id": "F332", "text": "Section 2 of the Armenian Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that the concept of a public event includes peaceful assemblies, rallies, marches (parades) and demonstrations (including sit-ins).", "source_paragraph": 117, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F333", "text": "Section 2 of the Armenian Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that mass public events are those public events which have a hundred or more participants, and non-mass public events are those which have fewer than a hundred participants.", "source_paragraph": 117, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F334", "text": "Section 7 §§ 1 and 4 of the Armenian Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that everyone has the right to participate in public events, and that participants in a public event are not allowed to carry, use or apply weapons, ammunition, explosives, poisonous, inflammable or any other objects or substances which may harm the life, health or property of others.", "source_paragraph": 118, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F335", "text": "Section 10 §§ 1, 2 and 4 of the Armenian Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that, except for cases when a non-mass public event spontaneously turns into a mass public event, mass public events may be held only after notifying the competent authority in writing.", "source_paragraph": 119, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F336", "text": "Section 10 of the Armenian Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that everyone has the right to hold non-mass public events without notifying the competent authority and without violating public order.", "source_paragraph": 119, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F337", "text": "Section 10 § 4 of the Armenian Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that the organisers shall submit a written notification of the intention to hold a mass public event to the head of the local authority where the event is to be held or to the Mayor of Yerevan, if the public event is to be held in Yerevan, not later than five working days and not earlier than twenty days before the planned date of the event.", "source_paragraph": 119, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F338", "text": "Section 12 § 8 of the Armenian Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that, should the competent authority not take a decision banning the mass public event, the organisers shall have the right to hold the mass public event on the terms and conditions set forth in the notification.", "source_paragraph": 120, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F339", "text": "Section 14 of the Armenian Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that the police are entitled to decide to terminate a public event and to order the organisers to terminate the event, by allowing them a reasonable time-limit to do so, if, inter alia, the mass public event is being held without notification, except for the cases in which a non-mass public event spontaneously turns into a mass public event.", "source_paragraph": 121, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F340", "text": "Section 14 of the Armenian Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that the organiser, having received the order to terminate the event, is obliged to announce immediately the termination of the event and to take measures aimed at terminating the event within the time-limit fixed by the police.", "source_paragraph": 121, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F341", "text": "Section 14 of the Armenian Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that the police are entitled to terminate forcibly a public event only if (a) the order to terminate an event is not immediately announced to the participants by the organiser; or (b) the order to terminate the public event has not been complied with within the fixed time-limit and its continuation poses a real threat to the life and health of others, State and public security, public order or public or private property.", "source_paragraph": 121, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F342", "text": "Section 14 of the Armenian Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that the police, before forcibly terminating an event, are obliged to inform the participants at least twice over a loudspeaker about the order to terminate the public event and to fix a reasonable time-limit for its termination, and that if the public event is not terminated within such a time-limit, the police are entitled to terminate the event forcibly, using lawful means.", "source_paragraph": 121, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F343", "text": "Section 14 of the Armenian Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that the procedure for forcible termination shall not be applied if an outbreak of mass disorder takes place in the location where the public event is held, requiring implementation of urgent measures.", "source_paragraph": 121, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F344", "text": "Section 29 of the Armenian Police Act (2001) provides that a police officer may use physical force, special means and firearms as an exceptional measure in cases and according to a procedure prescribed by the Act.", "source_paragraph": 122, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Police Act (2001)"]}, {"fact_id": "F345", "text": "Section 29 of the Armenian Police Act (2001) provides that a police officer is obliged to report to his superior within the shortest possible time about the injuries sustained by a person as a result of the use of force, and that the police authority is obliged to inform the close relatives of the victim and the prosecutor about the incident within a short time-limit.", "source_paragraph": 122, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Police Act (2001)"]}, {"fact_id": "F346", "text": "On 18 December 2009 the Court of Cassation of Armenia adopted a decision in an unrelated criminal case, examining questions concerning initial deprivation of liberty under the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999).", "source_paragraph": 123, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 18 December 2009 (case no. EADD/0085/06/09)"]}, {"fact_id": "F347", "text": "The Court of Cassation's decision of 18 December 2009 pointed out that there were two procedures for depriving a person of his liberty on suspicion of having committed an offence under the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999), namely \"arrest\" (Articles 128-133) and \"detention\" (Articles 137-142).", "source_paragraph": 123, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 18 December 2009 (case no. EADD/0085/06/09)"]}, {"fact_id": "F348", "text": "The Court of Cassation's decision of 18 December 2009 stated that the arrest procedure under Article 128 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure (1999) consisted of four consecutive actions: (a) the de facto deprivation of a person's liberty; (b) bringing him before the competent authority; (c) drawing up a record of his arrest; and (d) informing him about that record.", "source_paragraph": 123, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 18 December 2009 (case no. EADD/0085/06/09)"]}, {"fact_id": "F349", "text": "The Court of Cassation's decision of 18 December 2009 stated that a person could obtain the status of an \"arrestee\" only after the completion of the fourth and final action, namely after he was informed about the record of his arrest before the prosecuting authority.", "source_paragraph": 123, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 18 December 2009 (case no. EADD/0085/06/09)"]}, {"fact_id": "F350", "text": "The Court of Cassation's decision of 18 December 2009 stated that if the relevant authority continued and completed the arrest procedure in respect of a person brought before it, then the start of the arrest period would be calculated from the moment that person had been taken into custody, albeit retroactively.", "source_paragraph": 123, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 18 December 2009 (case no. EADD/0085/06/09)"]}, {"fact_id": "F351", "text": "The Court of Cassation's decision of 18 December 2009 concluded that the procedures for depriving a person of liberty on a suspicion of having committed an offence were not limited to \"arrest\" and \"detention\" but also included the procedure of taking into custody and bringing before the relevant authority, and that a person deprived of his liberty could also have an initial legal status which could be conditionally called the status of a \"brought-in person\".", "source_paragraph": 123, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 18 December 2009 (case no. EADD/0085/06/09)"]}, {"fact_id": "F352", "text": "The Court of Cassation's decision of 18 December 2009 stated that persons in such situations should enjoy the rights guaranteed by the Constitution and the Convention, including knowing the reasons for their deprivation of liberty, having access to a lawyer and maintaining silence.", "source_paragraph": 123, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Decision of the Court of Cassation of 18 December 2009 (case no. EADD/0085/06/09)"]}, {"fact_id": "F353", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman carried out a comprehensive and in-depth analysis of the post-election events in Armenia and produced an Ad-Hoc Public Report on the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F354", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report stated that the 1 March 2008 events started with the forcible termination of the peaceful sit-in at Freedom Square, when at 6.40 a.m. police officers wearing anti-riot gear and carrying shields and batons attacked the demonstrators who were at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F355", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report stated that from a formal point of view, the demonstration that lasted from 21 February to 1 March 2008 did not comply with the requirements of law because the Mayor of Yerevan had neither been notified nor taken note of a demonstration to be held.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F356", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report quoted the OSCE/ODIHR report as stating: \"From 21 February to early morning on 1 March protesters held a peaceful, though not formally authorised, assembly (and tent camp) in Freedom Square in Yerevan and conducted numerous peaceful processions. Speakers at the assembly announced that their aim was to annul and repeat the election. Until 1 March, the authorities overall tolerated the protests.\"", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F357", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report quoted President Robert Kocharyan as stating: \"The unauthorised demonstrations were not terminated by the police for nine consecutive days only for one reason: I prohibited them to do so. The reason was the post-election recount and the appeal process. I believed that a dispersal of demonstrations would be perceived as an attempt by the authorities to undermine the recount or the appeal process.\"", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F358", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report stated that the 1 March 2008 intervention was justified with the argument that on 29 February the police and the National Security Service had received intelligence information according to which arms were building up at Freedom Square, and that in order to render the situation harmless, in the morning of 1 March the police undertook an operation intended to seize those socially-dangerous materials.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F359", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report stated that the campaign headquarters of Mr Ter-Petrosyan and the opposition Heritage Party both insisted that the objective of the measures of the morning of 1 March 2008 was, under the disguise of an inspection of the area, to terminate by force the peaceful demonstrations that had been ongoing for ten days, to remove the persons participating in the sit-in and to ban further demonstrations at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F360", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report noted contradictions in the statements released by the Prosecutor General's Office, including that the request lodged by the Prosecutor General on 4 March 2008 stated \"the objective of the police was to carry out an operation aimed at seizing arms, which deteriorated into a clash\", while the press release issued by the Prosecutor General's Office on 1 March stated \"the objective of the police was to terminate forcibly the assembly at around 6 a.m. on 1 March\".", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F361", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report raised the question of how it happened that at around 6.30 a.m. on 1 March 2008, in a matter of just minutes, the police was able to mobilise numerous units wearing anti-riot gear and carrying shields and batons, if the only objective was to perform an inspection of the area.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F362", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report noted concerns over the confiscation of the videotapes of two media outlets and the smashing of the camcorder of a third media outlet, all of which were videotaping in the area of Freedom Square in the morning of 1 March 2008, and that a freelance photographer of Aravot daily was beaten and the photos he had taken were taken away.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F363", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report stated that in the morning of 1 March 2008 and later on the same day in the vicinity of the French Embassy, no shots were fired during the first half of the day and no firearms were used by the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F364", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report stated that on 29 February 2008 President Robert Kocharyan stated that among available solutions was the \"cleaning of the Square\" by the police.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F365", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report stated that while it is true that every day prior to 1 March the police announced over loudspeakers that the demonstration was unlawful and ordered the demonstrators to end it, no such order was made in the morning of 1 March 2008 and no time-limit was given to the demonstrators to end the demonstration as required by section 14 of the Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F366", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report stated that there were two police cordons at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008: one right on the square and the other one along the four adjacent streets, and that the purpose of those cordons was to keep everyone out so that the demonstration ended.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F367", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report stated that not all the persons gathered at Freedom Square were purported criminals, and that the police operation directly resulted in the forcible termination of the demonstration, with demonstrators being chased far beyond Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F368", "text": "The Armenian Ombudsman's Report stated that to date, not a single criminal case had been initiated against any police officer, even for excessive use of physical force and of special means.", "source_paragraph": 124, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Ad-Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F369", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 1609 (2008), adopted on 17 April 2008, stated that on 19 February 2008 a presidential election took place in Armenia and that the ad hoc committee which observed the election considered that it was \"administered mostly in line with Council of Europe standards\" but found a number of violations and shortcomings, including unequal campaign conditions for the candidates, the lack of transparency of the election administration and a complaints and appeals process that did not give complainants access to an effective legal remedy, as well as a number of cases of electoral fraud.", "source_paragraph": 125, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)", "(a) Resolution 1609 (2008): The functioning of democratic institutions in Armenia, 17 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F370", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 1609 (2008) stated that the violations and shortcomings observed in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election raised questions among a part of the Armenian public with regard to the credibility of the outcome of the election, and that this lack of public confidence was the basis for the peaceful protests – held without prior official notification – that ensued after the announcement of the preliminary results, and which were tolerated by the authorities for ten days.", "source_paragraph": 125, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)", "(a) Resolution 1609 (2008): The functioning of democratic institutions in Armenia, 17 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F371", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 1609 (2008) deplored the clashes between the police and the protesters and the escalation of violence on 1 March 2008 which resulted in 10 deaths and about 200 people being injured, and stated that the exact circumstances that led to the tragic events of 1 March, as well as the manner in which they were handled by the authorities, including the imposition of a state of emergency in Yerevan from 1 to 20 March 2008 and the alleged excessive use of force by the police, should be the subject of a credible independent investigation.", "source_paragraph": 125, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)", "(a) Resolution 1609 (2008): The functioning of democratic institutions in Armenia, 17 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F372", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 1609 (2008) condemned the arrest and continuing detention of scores of persons, including more than 100 opposition supporters and three members of parliament, some of them on seemingly artificial and politically motivated charges, characterising this as a de facto crackdown on the opposition by the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 125, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)", "(a) Resolution 1609 (2008): The functioning of democratic institutions in Armenia, 17 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F373", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 1609 (2008) stated that despite successful legislative reforms, the courts in Armenia still lacked the necessary independence to inspire the public's trust as impartial arbiters, and that the courts did not appear to question the necessity of keeping people in detention pending trial and generally responded favourably to requests by the prosecutors without properly weighing up the grounds for this, as required by Article 5, paragraph 3, of the European Convention on Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 125, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)", "(a) Resolution 1609 (2008): The functioning of democratic institutions in Armenia, 17 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F374", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 1609 (2008) urged the Armenian authorities to guarantee freedom of assembly in both law and practice, in compliance with Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights, and to stop arbitrary arrests and detentions, as well as the ill-treatment of detainees, in particular during police custody.", "source_paragraph": 125, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)", "(a) Resolution 1609 (2008): The functioning of democratic institutions in Armenia, 17 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F375", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 1609 (2008) called for an independent, transparent and credible inquiry into the events of 1 March 2008 and the circumstances that led to them, including the alleged excessive use of force by the police and violence by the protesters, and for the release of persons detained on seemingly artificial and politically motivated charges or who did not personally commit any violent acts or serious offences.", "source_paragraph": 125, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)", "(a) Resolution 1609 (2008): The functioning of democratic institutions in Armenia, 17 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F376", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 1620 (2008), adopted on 25 June 2008, welcomed the recent developments with regard to the release of persons seemingly detained on artificial and politically motivated charges who did not personally commit any violent acts or serious offences, but considered that progress on this issue was not sufficient.", "source_paragraph": 126, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)", "(b) Resolution 1620 (2008): Implementation by Armenia of Assembly Resolution 1609 (2008), 25 June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F377", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 1620 (2008) stated that the cases still under investigation should be closed or promptly brought before the courts to ensure the right to a fair trial within a reasonable time in compliance with the case law of the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 126, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)", "(b) Resolution 1620 (2008): Implementation by Armenia of Assembly Resolution 1609 (2008), 25 June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F378", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 1620 (2008) stated that the cases under Articles 300 and 225 of the Armenian Criminal Code should be dropped unless there is strong evidence that the accused have personally committed acts of violence or ordered, abetted or assisted the committing of such acts, and that a verdict based solely on a single police testimony without corroborating evidence is not acceptable.", "source_paragraph": 126, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)", "(b) Resolution 1620 (2008): Implementation by Armenia of Assembly Resolution 1609 (2008), 25 June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F379", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 1620 (2008) urged the Armenian authorities to consider all legal means available to them, including amnesty, pardons and dismissal of charges, with respect to all persons detained or sentenced in relation to the events of 1 and 2 March 2008, with the exception of those who personally committed acts of violence or other serious criminal offences.", "source_paragraph": 126, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)", "(b) Resolution 1620 (2008): Implementation by Armenia of Assembly Resolution 1609 (2008), 25 June 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F380", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 1643 (2009), adopted on 27 January 2009, stated that a significant number of prosecution cases and convictions in relation to the events of 1 and 2 March 2008 in Armenia was based solely on police testimony, without substantial corroborating evidence.", "source_paragraph": 127, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)", "(c) Resolution 1643 (2009): The implementation by Armenia of Assembly Resolutions 1609 (2008) and 1620 (2008), 27 January 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F381", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 1643 (2009) noted that doubts had been voiced, including by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights, regarding the nature of the charges brought under Articles 225 and 300 of the Armenian Criminal Code, as well as with regard to the legal proceedings against those convicted in relation to the events of 1 and 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 127, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)", "(c) Resolution 1643 (2009): The implementation by Armenia of Assembly Resolutions 1609 (2008) and 1620 (2008), 27 January 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F382", "text": "Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolution 1643 (2009) considered that the charges against a significant number of persons, especially those charged under Articles 225, paragraph 3, and 300 of the Armenian Criminal Code and those based solely on police evidence, could have been politically motivated.", "source_paragraph": 127, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)", "(c) Resolution 1643 (2009): The implementation by Armenia of Assembly Resolutions 1609 (2008) and 1620 (2008), 27 January 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F383", "text": "The European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment carried out a visit to Armenia from 15 to 17 March 2008 and produced a report (CPT/Inf(2010)7) to the Armenian Government.", "source_paragraph": 128, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT): Report to the Armenian Government on the visit to Armenia carried out by the CPT from 15 to 17 March 2008, CPT/Inf(2010)7"]}, {"fact_id": "F384", "text": "The European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment's delegation carried out individual interviews with most of the persons remanded in custody on charges related to the post-election events, who were being held at Nubarashen, Vardashen and Yerevan-Kentron prisons (some 70 people), as well as several persons detained at the Temporary holding facility of the National Security Service and the Holding Centre of Yerevan City Police Station.", "source_paragraph": 128, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT): Report to the Armenian Government on the visit to Armenia carried out by the CPT from 15 to 17 March 2008, CPT/Inf(2010)7"]}, {"fact_id": "F385", "text": "The European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment's report stated that practically all the persons who had been detained by law enforcement officers on 1 March 2008 alleged that they had been physically ill-treated at the time of their apprehension, even though they apparently had not offered resistance, with the ill-treatment consisting mainly of truncheon blows, kicks and punches to the body and head, and being pushed to the ground and dragged into a police vehicle.", "source_paragraph": 128, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT): Report to the Armenian Government on the visit to Armenia carried out by the CPT from 15 to 17 March 2008, CPT/Inf(2010)7"]}, {"fact_id": "F386", "text": "The European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment's report stated that in some cases the beating had apparently continued during transportation to police establishments and upon arrival there, and that according to several of the persons alleging ill-treatment, some of the law enforcement officials involved were wearing masks and did not have any form of identification on their clothing.", "source_paragraph": 128, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT): Report to the Armenian Government on the visit to Armenia carried out by the CPT from 15 to 17 March 2008, CPT/Inf(2010)7"]}, {"fact_id": "F387", "text": "The European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment's report stated that the delegation received a few allegations of physical ill-treatment at the time of questioning by the police, consisting essentially of slaps, punches, kicks and truncheon blows, apparently inflicted with the purpose of obtaining confessions or information implicating other persons.", "source_paragraph": 128, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT): Report to the Armenian Government on the visit to Armenia carried out by the CPT from 15 to 17 March 2008, CPT/Inf(2010)7"]}, {"fact_id": "F388", "text": "The European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment's report stated that certain of the persons who made allegations of ill-treatment were found on examination by a medical member of the delegation to display physical marks or conditions consistent with their allegations, and that the medical documentation at the penitentiary establishments visited also contained descriptions of various injuries observed by prison doctors during the initial examination of a number of persons admitted in the two weeks preceding the delegation's visit.", "source_paragraph": 128, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT): Report to the Armenian Government on the visit to Armenia carried out by the CPT from 15 to 17 March 2008, CPT/Inf(2010)7"]}, {"fact_id": "F389", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights conducted a Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008 and produced a report (CommDH(2008)11REV) dated 20 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 129, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(a) Report by the Commissioner on his Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F390", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 20 March 2008 stated that after nine days of peaceful demonstrations on Opera Square (Freedom Square), the national police and security forces tried to disperse the protesters on 1 March 2008, and that clashes occurred between the police and security forces and the demonstrators in front of Myasnikyan's monument and the French Embassy, which resulted in the death of eight persons.", "source_paragraph": 129, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(a) Report by the Commissioner on his Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F391", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 20 March 2008 stated that the Head of Police explained that the police had received information that the demonstrators were arming themselves with weapons and ammunition, and that the initial intent was also to move them to another location in the city to avoid problems of public transport and sanitation.", "source_paragraph": 129, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(a) Report by the Commissioner on his Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F392", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 20 March 2008 stated that the search operation reportedly started early Saturday morning at approximately 6.30 a.m., during which tents were taken down and people were beaten and injured, and that demonstrators started resisting and clashes broke out.", "source_paragraph": 129, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(a) Report by the Commissioner on his Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F393", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 20 March 2008 stated that it seemed clear that excessive use of force was used by police and the security forces, as confirmed by the sheer number of injured persons and passing civilians registered in the hospitals as well as found in places of detention, having beating marks, concussion and open scars on their skulls.", "source_paragraph": 129, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(a) Report by the Commissioner on his Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F394", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 20 March 2008 stated that on 13 March 2008 the Prosecutor General informed that over 95 persons had been arrested for having organized or participated in demonstrations and mass disturbances of public order, and that most of the arrested had been charged with disturbing public order, illegal possession of arms, incitement to violent acts, and resisting violently police arrest.", "source_paragraph": 129, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(a) Report by the Commissioner on his Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F395", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 20 March 2008 stated that detainees claimed that the police had used excessive force in connection with arrest, and that it seemed that beating took place in a number of cases at the time of arrest and during transportation of the apprehended to the different precincts.", "source_paragraph": 129, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(a) Report by the Commissioner on his Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F396", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 20 March 2008 stated that there had been delays in the registration of arrests, that access to defence lawyers had in some instances been delayed, that family members or relatives had not been informed of the detainee's whereabouts, and that persons apprehended had not been promptly informed of the charges against them.", "source_paragraph": 129, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(a) Report by the Commissioner on his Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F397", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 20 March 2008 stated that the prosecutors had consistently brought the same charges irrespective of the person's actual doing and involvement, regularly invoking Article 225 § 3, Article 316 and Article 300 of the Armenian Criminal Code, and had applied standardized language in the charges against those arrested.", "source_paragraph": 129, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(a) Report by the Commissioner on his Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F398", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 20 March 2008 stated that the judges seemed not to have entered into a serious test of the charges, the legality of the apprehension and the proportionality of deprivation of liberty, and that the courts seemed to have routinely granted pre-trial detention of two months to allow the prosecutor to investigate further and prepare the charges and the criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 129, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(a) Report by the Commissioner on his Special Mission to Armenia on 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F399", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights conducted a further Special Mission to Armenia on 13-15 July 2008 and produced a Summary of Findings (CommDH(2008)29) dated 29 September 2008.", "source_paragraph": 130, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(b) Summary of Findings by the Commissioner on his Special Mission to Armenia on 13-15 July 2008, CommDH(2008)29, 29 September 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F400", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Summary of Findings of 29 September 2008 stated that the preliminary investigation phase of all criminal cases relating to the events of 1-2 March 2008 had been completed, that most of the cases had been brought to court, and that a large majority of the persons concerned – virtually all of them opposition supporters – had been found guilty and sentenced.", "source_paragraph": 130, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(b) Summary of Findings by the Commissioner on his Special Mission to Armenia on 13-15 July 2008, CommDH(2008)29, 29 September 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F401", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Summary of Findings of 29 September 2008 stated that prosecution cases against 19 persons were based solely on police testimony, and that many interlocutors considered that the principle of equality of arms was not being applied in practice, and that the resort to fast trial proceedings in a number of cases – certain of which had lasted less than 30 minutes – gave rise to questions.", "source_paragraph": 130, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(b) Summary of Findings by the Commissioner on his Special Mission to Armenia on 13-15 July 2008, CommDH(2008)29, 29 September 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F402", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Summary of Findings of 29 September 2008 stated that to date, no law enforcement officials had been charged in connection with the 1 March 2008 events.", "source_paragraph": 130, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(b) Summary of Findings by the Commissioner on his Special Mission to Armenia on 13-15 July 2008, CommDH(2008)29, 29 September 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F403", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights produced a report (CommDH(2011)12) dated 9 May 2011 following his visit to Armenia from 18 to 21 January 2011.", "source_paragraph": 131, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(c) Report by the Commissioner following his visit to Armenia from 18 to 21 January 2011: CommDH(2011)12, 9 May 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F404", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 9 May 2011 stated that over a hundred people were arrested in the context of the March 2008 events, virtually all of them opposition supporters, and many of them were subjected to criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 131, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(c) Report by the Commissioner following his visit to Armenia from 18 to 21 January 2011: CommDH(2011)12, 9 May 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F405", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 9 May 2011 stated that as a result of the amendments to the Armenian Criminal Code and the implementation of the amnesty decision adopted by the National Assembly of Armenia in June 2009, the majority of those deprived of their liberty in connection to the events of March 2008 were released.", "source_paragraph": 131, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(c) Report by the Commissioner following his visit to Armenia from 18 to 21 January 2011: CommDH(2011)12, 9 May 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F406", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' report of 9 May 2011 stated that several detainees and opposition figures were released in November and December 2010 after serving half of their sentence or because they were eligible to be released on parole, including the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 131, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "3. Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights", "(c) Report by the Commissioner following his visit to Armenia from 18 to 21 January 2011: CommDH(2011)12, 9 May 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F407", "text": "The European Parliament passed a Resolution on the Situation in Armenia on 13 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 132, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Other international bodies", "1. European Parliament"]}, {"fact_id": "F408", "text": "The European Parliament's Resolution of 13 March 2008 stated that opposition supporters began peaceful rallies on 20 February 2008 in Yerevan to protest against the election result and demand a rerun, and that on the evening of 1 March 2008, after eleven days of protest by opposition supporters, violence erupted when police moved into Freedom Square in central Yerevan to disperse the protesters camped out in tents, leaving eight people dead, including one police officer, and dozens injured.", "source_paragraph": 132, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Other international bodies", "1. European Parliament"]}, {"fact_id": "F409", "text": "The European Parliament's Resolution of 13 March 2008 stated that a state of emergency was declared on 1 March 2008, which imposed restrictions on the freedom of the media, freedom of assembly and political parties.", "source_paragraph": 132, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Other international bodies", "1. European Parliament"]}, {"fact_id": "F410", "text": "The European Parliament's Resolution of 13 March 2008 expressed concern at the violent police crackdown on opposition demonstrations, leading to the death of eight citizens including one police officer, with over a hundred injured, and called for a prompt, thorough, transparent, independent and impartial investigation of the events of 1 March 2008, including an independent investigation of the police intervention during the dispersal of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 132, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Other international bodies", "1. European Parliament"]}, {"fact_id": "F411", "text": "The Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights produced a Final Report on the Trial Monitoring Project in Armenia (April 2008-June 2009).", "source_paragraph": 133, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Other international bodies", "2. Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F412", "text": "The Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights' Trial Monitoring Project monitored 93 criminal cases involving a total of 109 defendants between April 2008 and July 2009.", "source_paragraph": 133, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Other international bodies", "2. Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F413", "text": "The Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights' Final Report stated that many of the monitored cases revealed shortcomings with regard to a genuine procedural equality between prosecution and defence, with judges at times treating the parties unequally, displaying openly friendly attitudes towards the prosecution and openly hostile attitudes towards the defence.", "source_paragraph": 133, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Other international bodies", "2. Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F414", "text": "The Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights' Final Report stated that in numerous trials, judges did not allow the defence to reasonably present their case and/or confront the prosecution witnesses, and that there was an overreliance on incriminating police testimonies, which cast doubts over the existence of equality of arms.", "source_paragraph": 133, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Other international bodies", "2. Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F415", "text": "The Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights' Final Report stated that defence lawyers regularly motioned the courts to summon witnesses, order forensic expertise, and introduce other additional evidence, but courts were generally reluctant to grant motions, often without any reasoning, although national legislation obliges the courts to give reasoning for these rulings.", "source_paragraph": 133, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Other international bodies", "2. Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F416", "text": "The Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights' Final Report stated that in at least 44 monitored first instance cases the witness testimonies heard by the courts supported only the prosecution's version of events, and that the defence was effectively prevented from access to potentially exonerating evidence and the opportunity to refute the testimony of prosecution witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 133, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Other international bodies", "2. Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F417", "text": "The Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights' Final Report stated that of 234 witnesses called by the prosecution in the monitored cases, 125 witnesses were police officers, and that there were 19 separate cases where charges were based on incriminating statements given by police officers, with 17 cases where the testimony of police witnesses was the only witness testimony given in court and became the primary basis for court decisions.", "source_paragraph": 133, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Other international bodies", "2. Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F418", "text": "The Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights' Final Report stated that of the 19 cases featuring police witnesses, 13 defendants were charged with resistance to the police under Article 316 of the Armenian Criminal Code, and that at least six defendants made allegations of police misconduct or brutality against them at the time of apprehension, which were not investigated and no tainted evidence was excluded by the judges.", "source_paragraph": 133, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Other international bodies", "2. Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F419", "text": "The Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights' Final Report stated that monitoring data indicated that judges readily accepted the testimonies of police witnesses and did not ask for corroborating evidence, even when there were significant contradictions between the pre-trial testimonies of these witnesses and their statements at trial, and when there were clear inconsistencies between the testimonies of different officers in the same case.", "source_paragraph": 133, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Other international bodies", "2. Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights"]}, {"fact_id": "F420", "text": "Human Rights Watch produced a report entitled \"Democracy on Rocky Ground: Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability\" in February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky [Ground], Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F421", "text": "Human Rights Watch's report stated that statements taken from demonstrators and bystanders suggested that the first police action in the early morning of 1 March 2008 against the Freedom Square tent encampment entailed excessive use of force, without warning and in the absence, at the start, of resistance.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky [Ground], Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F422", "text": "Human Rights Watch's report stated that according to the first deputy police chief A.M., the police had arrived at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008 to conduct a search, acting on information that demonstrators had been arming themselves with metal rods, and possibly firearms, in preparation for committing acts of violent protest, and that initially a group of 25-30 police officers, including experts and investigators, were sent to do the search.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky [Ground], Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F423", "text": "Human Rights Watch's report stated that according to the first deputy police chief A.M., when the group tried to conduct the search, the protesters turned aggressive and resisted police with wooden sticks and iron bars, resulting in injuries to several policemen, and that more police had to be deployed and had to use force to disperse the crowd, with the operation lasting about 30 minutes and 10 policemen sustaining injuries.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky [Ground], Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F424", "text": "Human Rights Watch's report stated that several witnesses interviewed separately by Human Rights Watch consistently described that some time shortly after 6 a.m. on 1 March 2008, while it was still dark, hundreds of Special Forces police in riot armour, with helmets, plastic shields, and rubber truncheons, started approaching Freedom Square from Tumanyan Street and Mashtots Avenue, surrounded the square and stood there for a few minutes.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky [Ground], Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F425", "text": "Human Rights Watch's report stated that according to Mr Ter-Petrosyan's account, he addressed the protesters asking them to step back from the police line and then to stay where they were and wait for instructions from the police, and also warned the police that there were women and children among the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky [Ground], Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F426", "text": "Human Rights Watch's report stated that according to multiple witnesses, even before Mr Ter-Petrosyan finished his address, police advanced towards the demonstrators in several lines, beating their truncheons against their plastic shields, making no audible demand for anyone to disperse nor giving any indication of the purpose of their presence, and then without any warning, riot police attacked the demonstrators, using rubber truncheons, iron sticks, and electric shock batons.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky [Ground], Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F427", "text": "Human Rights Watch's report stated that as a result of the early morning police actions on Freedom Square on 1 March 2008, 31 people were officially reported to be injured, including six policemen.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky [Ground], Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F428", "text": "Human Rights Watch's report stated that the police claimed that after the demonstrators were dispersed they found a stock of real and makeshift weapons, including three guns, 15 grenades, two bullet cases and 138 bullets of various calibres, plastic explosives, a big number of makeshift weapons, syringes and drugs, but that all witnesses and victims interviewed by Human Rights Watch claimed that the alleged arms cache was planted after the demonstration was dispersed.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky [Ground], Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F429", "text": "Human Rights Watch's report stated that the chairman of the ad hoc parliamentary commission established to investigate the 1 March 2008 events told Human Rights Watch in January 2009 that he had not seen any evidence linking the arms cache to the demonstration's participants or organizers.", "source_paragraph": 134, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "C. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky [Ground], Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F018", "F019", "F022", "F034", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F066", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F070", "F074", "F075", "F090", "F094", "F097", "F098", "F099", "F100", "F101", "F102", "F136", "F144", "F226", "F260", "F264", "F265", "F267", "F272", "F273", "F354", "F356", "F360", "F363", "F365", "F366", "F367", "F370", "F371", "F390", "F393", "F406", "F421", "F424", "F426", "F428"], "interference": ["F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F074", "F075", "F089", "F097", "F098", "F099", "F143", "F144", "F145", "F157", "F216", "F217", "F218", "F219", "F220", "F221", "F260", "F261", "F262", "F263", "F354", "F366", "F367"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F018", "F019", "F022", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F053", "F055", "F056", "F057", "F058", "F059", "F060", "F061", "F062", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F074", "F075", "F089", "F090", "F093", "F094", "F097", "F098", "F099", "F100", "F101", "F108", "F109", "F143", "F144", "F145", "F208", "F209", "F210", "F211", "F212", "F213", "F214", "F215", "F216", "F226", "F229", "F231", "F232", "F249", "F260", "F263", "F264", "F265", "F267", "F268", "F269", "F270", "F272", "F273", "F284", "F294", "F354", "F357", "F360", "F361", "F364", "F365", "F368", "F369", "F370", "F371", "F372", "F378", "F380", "F381", "F382", "F393", "F394", "F401", "F402", "F406", "F417", "F421", "F424", "F426"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F038", "F043", "F064", "F099", "F102", "F354", "F356", "F363", "F365"], "interference": ["F143", "F157", "F260", "F263", "F354", "F366", "F367"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F011", "F013", "F018", "F043", "F064", "F074", "F075", "F097", "F099", "F108", "F144", "F213", "F214", "F216", "F229", "F249", "F267", "F272", "F354", "F360", "F365", "F368", "F371", "F372", "F380", "F393", "F421"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F011", "F013", "F014", "F043", "F074", "F075", "F099", "F144", "F213", "F249", "F272", "F354", "F360", "F365", "F368", "F372", "F380"]}} {"case_name": "case_450", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' details are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants were represented by Mr R. Mustafazade, a lawyer practising in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants were represented by Mr A. Mustafayev, a lawyer practising in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr Ç. Əsgərov.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The facts of the case may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants in all three applications (nos. 69483/13, 76319/13, and 30456/14) were members of a political group called the Public Chamber (İctimai Palata).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "As members of the Public Chamber (İctimai Palata), the applicants planned to hold several assemblies in 2012 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicants in application no. 69483/13 planned an assembly in the form of a picketing, to be held on 22 April 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "A. Application no. 69483/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicants in application no. 69483/13 gave a notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) in advance of the planned assembly.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "A. Application no. 69483/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the notice given to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 69483/13 was scheduled to take place from 12 p.m. to 1 p.m. on 22 April 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "A. Application no. 69483/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "According to the notice given to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 69483/13 was scheduled to take place in front of the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) building.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "A. Application no. 69483/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "According to the notice given to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), the expected participation in the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 69483/13 was fifty individuals.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "A. Application no. 69483/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The purpose of the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 69483/13 was to demand the removal of unwritten restrictions placed on the freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "A. Application no. 69483/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The purpose of the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 69483/13 was to demand political reforms.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "A. Application no. 69483/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The purpose of the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 69483/13 was to demand freedom for political prisoners.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "A. Application no. 69483/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "By a letter of 18 April 2012, the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) refused to authorise the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 69483/13.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "A. Application no. 69483/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) noted in its letter of 18 April 2012 that it had designated a location for another assembly with a similar cause on the same day (22 April 2012), namely the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 76319/13.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "A. Application no. 69483/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) stated in its letter of 18 April 2012 that the assembly proposed by the applicants in application no. 69483/13 was 'to no purpose' (keçirilməsi məqsədəuyğun hesab olunmur) because another assembly with a similar cause had already been designated a location on the same day.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "A. Application no. 69483/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 69483/13 was not eventually held.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "A. Application no. 69483/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicants in application no. 76319/13 planned an assembly in the form of a march followed by a meeting, to be held on 22 April 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicants in application no. 76319/13 gave a notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) in advance of the planned assembly.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the notice given to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 76319/13 was scheduled to take place from 4 p.m. to 6 p.m. on 22 April 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the notice given to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), the expected participation in the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 76319/13 was ten thousand people.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicants in application no. 76319/13 proposed a location in the Nizami district of Baku, namely a square in front of the Tabriz cinema, for the holding of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicants in application no. 76319/13 proposed a location in the Binagadi district of Baku for the holding of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicants in application no. 76319/13 proposed a location in the Narimanov district of Baku for the holding of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicants in application no. 76319/13 asked the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) to agree to one of the three proposed locations for the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the content of the slogans to be used, the purpose of the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 76319/13 included demanding new parliamentary elections.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the content of the slogans to be used, the purpose of the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 76319/13 included demanding political reforms.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the content of the slogans to be used, the purpose of the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 76319/13 included demanding freedom for political prisoners.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the content of the slogans to be used, the purpose of the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 76319/13 included demanding protection of the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the content of the slogans to be used, the purpose of the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 76319/13 included protesting against corruption.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to the content of the slogans to be used, the purpose of the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 76319/13 included protesting against violation of property rights.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "By a letter of 18 April 2012, the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) refused to authorise the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 76319/13 at any of the three locations proposed by the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), in its letter of 18 April 2012, proposed another location for the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 76319/13, namely the grounds of a driving school situated in the 20th residential area of the Sabail district, on the outskirts of Baku.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) noted in its letter of 18 April 2012 that the locations indicated by the applicants in application no. 76319/13 were 'areas with intense traffic, and therefore it was not possible to hold assemblies there'.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) noted in its letter of 18 April 2012 that 'it was not possible to ensure security in respect of the assembly planned by the applicants in application no. 76319/13, considering the serious problems that the assembly would cause to the free movement of citizens who did not want to participate in it, and to the smooth functioning of transport'.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Following the refusal of the authorisation, the applicants in application no. 76319/13 decided to hold the assembly at the place proposed by the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), namely the grounds of a driving school situated in the 20th residential area of the Sabail district.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "B. Application no. 76319/13"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicant in application no. 30456/14 planned an assembly in the form of a march, to be held on 13 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "C. Application no. 30456/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicant in application no. 30456/14 gave a notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) in advance of the planned assembly.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "C. Application no. 30456/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the notice given to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), the assembly planned by the applicant in application no. 30456/14 was scheduled to take place from 4 p.m. to 6 p.m. on 13 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "C. Application no. 30456/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to the notice given to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), the expected participation in the assembly planned by the applicant in application no. 30456/14 was ten thousand people.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "C. Application no. 30456/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the notice given to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), the march planned by the applicant in application no. 30456/14 was to start at a square adjacent to the Parliament Avenue in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "C. Application no. 30456/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the notice given to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), the march planned by the applicant in application no. 30456/14 was to follow Parliament Avenue in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "C. Application no. 30456/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the notice given to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), the march planned by the applicant in application no. 30456/14 was to finish in front of the Parliament building in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "C. Application no. 30456/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The purpose of the assembly planned by the applicant in application no. 30456/14 was to demand early elections to the Parliament of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "C. Application no. 30456/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "By a letter of 10 October 2012, the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) refused to authorise the assembly planned by the applicant in application no. 30456/14 at the location indicated by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "C. Application no. 30456/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), in its letter of 10 October 2012, proposed another location for the assembly planned by the applicant in application no. 30456/14, namely the grounds of a driving school situated in the 20th residential area of the Sabail district, on the outskirts of Baku — the same location proposed by the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) in application no. 76319/13.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "C. Application no. 30456/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) noted in its letter of 10 October 2012 that the location indicated by the applicant in application no. 30456/14 was an 'area with intense traffic, and therefore it was not possible to hold assemblies there'.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "C. Application no. 30456/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) noted in its letter of 10 October 2012 that 'it was not possible to ensure security in respect of the assembly planned by the applicant in application no. 30456/14, considering the serious problems that the assembly would cause to the free movement of citizens who did not want to participate in it, and to the smooth functioning of transport'.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "C. Application no. 30456/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The march planned by the applicant in application no. 30456/14 was not eventually held.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. REQUESTS TO AUTHORISE THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLIES", "C. Application no. 30456/14"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Having received the refusal letters from the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA), the applicants lodged complaints in the form of a civil action against the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) before the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "In their complaints before the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1, the applicants argued that their right to freedom of assembly had been violated.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In all three applications (nos. 69483/13, 76319/13, and 30456/14), the applicants asked the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1 to declare the Baku City Executive Authority's (BCEA's) decisions unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In application no. 30456/14, the applicant asked the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1 to order the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) to authorise the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "In applications nos. 69483/13 and 76319/13, the applicants asked the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1 to order the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) to pay non-pecuniary damages.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In each of the three cases, the applicants challenged the lawfulness of the Baku City Executive Authority's (BCEA's) decisions before the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "In each of the three cases, the applicants challenged the proportionality of the Baku City Executive Authority's (BCEA's) decisions before the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicants in application no. 69483/13 argued before the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1 that it had been unlawful to refuse the authorisation of their assembly simply because another assembly with similar slogans had been planned elsewhere in Baku on the same date.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The applicants in application no. 76319/13 argued before the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1 that one of the locations they had proposed — namely, a square in front of the Tabriz cinema in the Nizami district of Baku — was on the Baku City Executive Authority's (BCEA's) indicative list of places for the holding of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority's (BCEA's) indicative list of places for the holding of public assemblies had been prepared in accordance with Article 9 § VI of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority's (BCEA's) indicative list of places for the holding of public assemblies was published in the Official Gazette, Azerbaijan newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The applicants in application no. 76319/13 submitted a copy of the Baku City Executive Authority's (BCEA's) indicative list of places for the holding of public assemblies to the domestic courts, but not to the Court.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The applicant in application no. 30456/14 argued before the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1 that the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) had failed to present any evidence in support of its allegations.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicants in application no. 76319/13 argued before the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1 that the location on the outskirts of Baku proposed by the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) — namely, the grounds of a driving school situated in the 20th residential area of the Sabail district — was unfit for holding public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The applicant in application no. 30456/14 argued before the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1 that the planned location of the assembly (starting at a square adjacent to Parliament Avenue, following that avenue, and finishing in front of the Parliament building) was very important for the purpose of the assembly, since the demands that the participants intended to voice were related to and addressed to the Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 28 August 2012, the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1 dismissed the applicants' complaint in application no. 69483/13, accepting the Baku City Executive Authority's (BCEA's) findings as valid reasons for refusing to authorise the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 29 August 2012, the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1 dismissed the applicants' complaint in application no. 76319/13, accepting the Baku City Executive Authority's (BCEA's) findings as valid reasons for refusing to authorise the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 17 April 2013, the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1 dismissed the applicant's complaint in application no. 30456/14, accepting the Baku City Executive Authority's (BCEA's) findings as valid reasons for refusing to authorise the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The applicants in all three applications appealed against the judgments of the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1, reiterating their previous complaints and arguments.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 13 December 2012, the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the judgment of the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1 in application no. 69483/13, largely reiterating the first-instance court's findings.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 20 December 2012, the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the judgment of the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1 in application no. 76319/13, largely reiterating the first-instance court's findings.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 13 August 2013, the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the judgment of the Baku Administrative Economic Court No. 1 in application no. 30456/14, largely reiterating the first-instance court's findings.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 13 March 2013, the Supreme Court of Azerbaijan upheld the judgment of the Baku Court of Appeal in application no. 69483/13, largely reiterating the appellate court's findings.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 15 May 2013, the Supreme Court of Azerbaijan upheld the judgment of the Baku Court of Appeal in application no. 76319/13, largely reiterating the appellate court's findings.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 20 November 2013, the Supreme Court of Azerbaijan upheld the judgment of the Baku Court of Appeal in application no. 30456/14, largely reiterating the appellate court's findings.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "None of the domestic courts addressed the applicants' argument in application no. 76319/13 that the square in front of the Tabriz cinema in the Nizami district of Baku was on the Baku City Executive Authority's (BCEA's) indicative list of places for the holding of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "None of the domestic courts addressed the applicant's argument in application no. 30456/14 that the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) had failed to present any evidence in support of its allegations.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "None of the domestic courts addressed the applicants' argument in application no. 76319/13 that the location on the outskirts of Baku proposed by the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) was unfit for holding public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "None of the domestic courts addressed the applicant's argument in application no. 30456/14 that the planned location of the assembly was very important for the purpose of the assembly because the demands were related to and addressed to the Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. DOMESTIC COURT PROCEEDINGS"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "At the material time, Article 5 § I of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 required any person or persons organising an assembly listed in Article 3 of that Law to notify in advance the relevant body of the executive authority in written form, as a rule at least five days prior to the day of convening the intended assembly, for the purposes of authorising the assembly's time and place and the route of a march.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "At the material time, Article 5 § I of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that submission of a notification in less than five days prior to the intended assembly must be justified by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "At the material time, Article 5 § II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 required a written notification to include the form of the intended assembly.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "At the material time, Article 5 § II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 required a written notification to include the general purpose of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "At the material time, Article 5 § II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 required a written notification to include the place and time of convening of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "At the material time, Article 5 § II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 required a written notification to include the approximate number of participants.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "At the material time, Article 5 § II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 required a written notification to include, in respect of a march, its proposed route (the place where the march begins, its distance and an end location).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "At the material time, Article 5 § II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 required a written notification to include the name, surname, patronymic and address of the organisers of the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "At the material time, Article 5 § II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 required a written notification to include the date of submission of the written notification.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "At the material time, Article 5 § II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 required a written notification to include contact telephone numbers or, in the event of their absence, contact addresses.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "At the material time, Article 5 § II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that organisers may submit additional information before the relevant body of the executive authority makes a decision.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "At the material time, Article 5 § III of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 required all organisers of the assembly to sign the written notification.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "At the material time, Article 5 § IV of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that submission of a written notification for spontaneous assemblies is not required.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "At the material time, Article 5 § IV of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that spontaneous assemblies may be restricted or stopped in accordance with the requirements specified in Articles 7 and 8 of that Law.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "At the material time, Article 7 § I of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that no restrictions shall be placed on the right to freedom of assembly other than those that are prescribed by law and are necessary in a democratic society in the interests of national security or public safety, for the prevention of disorder or crime, for the protection of health or morals or for the protection of the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "At the material time, Article 7 § II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that restrictions on the freedom of assembly must be proportionate to the aim pursued and must not exceed necessary and sufficient limits.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "At the material time, Article 7 § III of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that measures taken to restrict the freedom of assembly must be strictly necessary for achieving the aim which served as the reason for imposing the restriction.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "At the material time, Article 7 § IV of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that freedom of assembly may be restricted in various ways including a change to the time and place of the assembly or a change to the route of a march, but only for the purposes prescribed under Article 7 § I of that Law.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "At the material time, Article 8 § I of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that assemblies accompanied by calls for discrimination, discord (hostility), or violence, or incitement to national, racial or religious discord shall be prohibited.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "At the material time, Article 8 § II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that assemblies which promote war shall be prohibited.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "At the material time, Article 8 § III of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the holding of a peaceful assembly with political goals shall be prohibited twenty-four hours prior to the day and until closure of constituencies on the day of elections of the President of the Republic of Azerbaijan (on the entire State territory).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "At the material time, Article 8 § III of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the holding of a peaceful assembly with political goals shall be prohibited twenty-four hours prior to the day and until closure of constituencies on the day of elections of deputies to the Milli Mejlis (the Parliament) of the Republic of Azerbaijan (on the entire State territory).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "At the material time, Article 8 § III of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the holding of a peaceful assembly with political goals shall be prohibited twenty-four hours prior to the day and until closure of constituencies on the day of elections of deputies to the Ali Mejlis (the Parliament) of the Nakhichevan Autonomous Republic (on the territory of the Nakhichevan Autonomous Republic).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "At the material time, Article 8 § III of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the holding of a peaceful assembly with political goals shall be prohibited twenty-four hours prior to the day and until closure of constituencies on the day of municipal elections (on the territory of the respective city and district).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "At the material time, Article 8 § III of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the holding of a peaceful assembly with political goals shall be prohibited twenty-four hours prior to the day and until closure of constituencies on the day of a referendum.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "At the material time, Article 8 § IV of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that on account of the need to implement security measures during international events of considerable State importance, the holding of peaceful assemblies with political goals on the eve of, and on the days of, those events may be prohibited by a decision of the relevant body of the executive authority, in accordance with the requirements prescribed under Article 7 of that Law.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "At the material time, Article 8 § V of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that if necessary in a democratic society, an assembly may be prohibited by an order of the relevant body of the executive authority, in accordance with the requirements prescribed under Article 7 of that Law.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "At the material time, Article 8 § VI of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that if necessary, an assembly may be stopped by an order of the relevant body of the executive authority, in accordance with the requirements prescribed under Article 7 of that Law.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "At the material time, Article 8 § VII of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that prohibition or stopping of an assembly under Article 8 §§ IV, V and VI shall be considered as a measure of last resort and shall be applied only when the restrictions provided for under Article 7 of that Law are not sufficient.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "At the material time, Article 8 § VIII of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that during a state of emergency, the holding of assemblies on the territory where that state of emergency is applied may be restricted or prohibited, in accordance with the requirements prescribed under the Law of the Republic of Azerbaijan on States of Emergency.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § I of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that any restriction on an intended place of a peaceful assembly shall be placed in accordance with the criteria determined under Article 7 of that Law.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that if another assembly has already been arranged at the place and time stipulated in a written notification submitted by the organisers of a counter-assembly and if there are sufficient grounds to conclude that a counter-assembly may cause a conflict between the parties, the relevant body of the executive authority shall propose to the organisers that they indicate a different place and time for the counter-assembly.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that a written notification of the amended time and place shall be submitted to the relevant body of the executive authority at least three days prior to the new date of an event.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that in the event that a counter-assembly is held, the police authorities shall take measures to ensure the security of the participants of both the assembly and the counter-assembly.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § III of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the holding of gatherings, meetings, demonstrations and marches may be prohibited within a radius of 200 metres around the buildings of the Milli Madjlis (the Parliament) of Azerbaijan, the Presidential Palace, the official residence of the President of Azerbaijan, the Cabinet of Ministers, the Ali Madjlis of the Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic, the Cabinet of Ministers of the Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic, central, district and city executive authority bodies (the list of which shall be defined by the relevant executive authority), and the Constitutional Court of Azerbaijan, the Supreme Court, the appellate courts and the Supreme Court of the Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § III of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the holding of gatherings, meetings, demonstrations and marches may be prohibited on bridges, in tunnels, at construction sites, at production sites which present a danger to human life and health, and other sites requiring compliance with special technical norms for safety, specially protected nature areas and sites, protection zones of trunk pipelines, electrical networks with tension exceeding 1000 volts, airports, underground railways, railway facilities, defence facilities, technical facilities for water supply and sewerage systems, oil wells and waters.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § III of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the holding of gatherings, meetings, demonstrations and marches may be prohibited in places allocated by the relevant body of the executive authority for holding special State events.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § III of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the holding of gatherings, meetings, demonstrations and marches may be prohibited in areas used for military purposes and in places located closer than 150 metres to the boundaries of those areas, or, if necessary, within the security distance between those areas and participants of an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § III of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the holding of gatherings, meetings, demonstrations and marches may be prohibited on the sites of penal facilities, pre-trial detention facilities, and psychiatric medical institutions, as well as in places located closer than 150 metres to the boundaries of those sites.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § IV of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the holding of assemblies with political content in places of pilgrimage and worship, and in cemeteries, may be restricted.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § V of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the number of picketers shall not exceed fifty persons, picketers shall not stand closer than ten metres to the entrance of a picketed location, shall not create obstacles for entry to and exit from the picketed location, and shall not use amplifiers above ten watts.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § VI of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the relevant body of the executive authority shall allocate in each city and district special areas for conducting gatherings, meetings and demonstrations, and shall publish a list of those proposed places in the local press and bring it to the attention of the population by other means.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § VI of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that organisers may choose one of the places proposed for gatherings, meetings and demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § VI of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that as a result of a petition, the relevant body of the executive authority may change the list of proposed places for gatherings, meetings and demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "At the material time, Article 9 § VII of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provided that the time for holding an assembly may be restricted by the relevant body of the executive authority, in accordance with the requirements of Article 7 of that Law.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F008", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F020", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F039", "F046"], "interference": ["F016", "F017", "F018", "F034", "F036", "F037", "F047", "F049", "F050"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F006", "F010", "F011", "F017", "F018", "F022", "F024", "F034", "F036", "F059", "F060", "F061", "F062", "F064", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F071", "F072", "F073", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F077", "F078", "F079", "F095", "F107", "F109"], "legitimate_aim": ["F018", "F036", "F037", "F049", "F050"], "necessity": ["F006", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F023", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F035", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F065", "F066", "F080"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F028", "F046"], "interference": ["F016", "F018", "F034", "F036", "F037", "F047", "F049", "F050"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F006", "F018", "F024", "F060", "F061", "F062", "F064", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F071", "F072", "F073", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F077", "F078"], "legitimate_aim": ["F018", "F036", "F037", "F049", "F050"], "necessity": ["F006", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F035", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F048", "F066", "F080"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F006", "F016", "F018", "F024", "F034", "F035", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F077", "F078", "F080"]}} {"case_name": "case_452", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The case concerns restrictions imposed by the authorities on the location of several public events.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The case concerns restrictions imposed by the authorities on the time of conduct of several public events.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The case concerns restrictions imposed by the authorities on the manner of conduct of several public events.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants complained about being unlawfully arrested.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants complained about being convicted of various administrative offences.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants' details are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Russian Government were represented by Mr G. Matyushkin, Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Mr G. Matyushkin was succeeded in the office of Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights by Mr M. Galperin.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Mr M. Galperin subsequently represented the Russian Government before the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The three applicants in the present case were involved in a number of public events in 2007-2008 in Rostov-na-Donu.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "All three applicants reside in Rostov-na-Donu.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Some of the applications lodged by the three applicants concern the same public events.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Some of the applications lodged by the three applicants are unrelated to each other but similar in substance.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The main details of the complaints under Articles 10 and 11 of the Convention are summarised in the text of the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Repetitive complaints under Articles 3, 5 and 6 of the Convention are detailed in the Appendix to the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant in application no. 9685/08 is Mr Nagibin.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 9685/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 22 June 2007 the Justice of the Peace of the 4th Circuit of the Pervomayskiy District of Rostov-na-Donu found Mr Nagibin guilty of a breach of public order, an administrative offence under Article 20.1 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 9685/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Justice of the Peace based her decision on the strength of evidence produced by the police, including reports by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 9685/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Justice of the Peace based her decision on statements by two witnesses who had signed their statements attesting that Mr Nagibin used foul language and verbally assaulted them.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 9685/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Mr Nagibin was sentenced to nine days' administrative imprisonment by the Justice of the Peace of the 4th Circuit of the Pervomayskiy District of Rostov-na-Donu on 22 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 9685/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Justice of the Peace rejected Mr Nagibin's request to question the prosecution witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 9685/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 27 June 2007 the Pervomayskiy District Court of Rostov-na-Donu rejected Mr Nagibin's appeal against his conviction in a summary fashion.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION No. 9685/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant in application no. 22572/08 is Mr Nagibin.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "At about 3 p.m. on 12 December 2006 Mr Nagibin was apprehended by police officers from the Organised Crime Unit of the Rostov Regional Police Directorate as he was leaving his home.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The police officers from the Organised Crime Unit of the Rostov Regional Police Directorate brought Mr Nagibin to the Pervomayskiy district police station on 12 December 2006.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the police, Mr Nagibin was stopped on 12 December 2006 for an identity check.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the police, Mr Nagibin resisted the identity check and attempted to flee.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "At the Pervomayskiy district police station, a report on an administrative offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences (failure to comply with lawful demands of a police officer) was drawn up against Mr Nagibin.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Mr Nagibin remained in custody on the premises of the Pervomayskiy district police station until 3 p.m. on 13 December 2006.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Mr Nagibin did not receive any food during his custody at the Pervomayskiy district police station from 12 to 13 December 2006.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Mr Nagibin was not taken outdoors during his custody at the Pervomayskiy district police station from 12 to 13 December 2006.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The cell at the Pervomayskiy district police station where Mr Nagibin was held measured approximately 2 square metres.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The cell at the Pervomayskiy district police station accommodated Mr Nagibin and one other person.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The cell at the Pervomayskiy district police station was not equipped with a bed.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 13 December 2006 Mr Nagibin was brought before the Justice of the Peace of the 5th Court Circuit of the Pervomayskiy District of Rostov-na-Donu.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of the 5th Court Circuit of the Pervomayskiy District of Rostov-na-Donu dismissed the administrative case against Mr Nagibin and returned the file to the police.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Justice of the Peace dismissed the case against Mr Nagibin because he was a member of the district electoral commission.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 13 February 2007 the police discontinued the administrative proceedings against Mr Nagibin upon expiry of the statutory prescription period.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Mr Nagibin complained to a court that he had been unlawfully deprived of his liberty.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "Mr Nagibin complained to a court about the poor conditions of his detention at the Pervomayskiy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "In the proceedings on Mr Nagibin's complaint, the court established that on 12 December 2006 police officers had stopped Mr Nagibin to check his identity and to conduct explanatory and preventive discussions.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The police officers testified that they had received operative information on the preparation by National-Bolsheviks of an unlawful march in Moscow, known as the 'Dissenters' March'.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The police officers testified that they were requested to conduct explanatory and preventive discussions with prospective participants in the 'Dissenters' March', including Mr Nagibin.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The police officers testified that they did not know Mr Nagibin and only had his verbal description.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The police officers testified that on 12 December 2006 they arrived at Mr Nagibin's residence and, as he was not at home, waited for him in the street.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The police officers testified that once they saw a man who matched the description of Mr Nagibin, they approached him, introduced themselves and asked him for identity documents.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The police officers testified that the man refused to show identity documents, pushed them away and attempted to flee, which aroused suspicions as to the lawfulness of his conduct.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The police officers testified that because Mr Nagibin had offered resistance, he was placed in a car and brought to the Pervomayskiy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 6 April 2007 the Pervomayskiy District Court of Rostov-na-Donu gave judgment rejecting Mr Nagibin's claims regarding his arrest and detention.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Pervomayskiy District Court of Rostov-na-Donu found that the police officers had acted within their competence because they had the right, under section 11 §§ 2 and 15 of the Police Act, to check the identity papers of individuals suspected of a criminal or administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Pervomayskiy District Court of Rostov-na-Donu found that Mr Nagibin's overnight detention had been lawful because the Code of Administrative Offences permitted detention for up to forty-eight hours.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 6 June 2007 the Rostov Regional Court upheld the Pervomayskiy District Court's judgment of 6 April 2007 on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Mr Nagibin attempted to complain about the decision to conduct 'preventive discussions' for the purpose of dissuading prospective participants from taking part in mass gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "By decision of 18 July 2007, the Pervomayskiy District Court refused to examine Mr Nagibin's complaint about the decision to conduct 'preventive discussions', finding that the issues raised had already been determined in the judgment of 6 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 17 November 2007 the Pervomayskiy District Court's decision of 18 July 2007 refusing to examine Mr Nagibin's complaint about 'preventive discussions' was upheld on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION No. 22572/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In November 2007 Mr Nagibin and Mr Ye. notified the Rostov-na-Donu town administration of their intention to hold a static demonstration (picket) to protest against the authorities' decision to exclude the 'Different Russia' (Drugaya Rossiya) party from participating in the parliamentary election.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Rostov-na-Donu town administration replied to Mr Nagibin and Mr Ye. stating that if they intended to campaign for candidates of the association not listed on the electoral ballots they would violate the law.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Rostov-na-Donu town administration requested Mr Nagibin and Mr Ye. to submit a notification in which the purpose of the picket event would be formulated in compliance with the law.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 24 November 2007 Mr Nagibin proceeded with the static demonstration (picket).", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 24 November 2007 Mr Nagibin was apprehended because his passport was found to be defiled with unauthorised pen writing and the police officers intended to draft the relevant record of the administrative offence at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Mr Nagibin refused to follow the police officers to the police station, explaining that he was a participant in the picket.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Mr Nagibin was brought to a police station and charged with non-compliance with a lawful order of a police officer under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 2 December 2007 Mr Nagibin was convicted of the administrative offence of non-compliance with a lawful order of a police officer on the basis of the police report and oral testimony of officer Mr Kh.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Mr Nagibin was sentenced to three days of administrative imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The court credited the period from 5.20 p.m. on 24 November 2007 until 10.45 a.m. on 26 November 2007 to the time to be served by Mr Nagibin.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Mr Nagibin appealed against his conviction of 2 December 2007.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 11 January 2008 the Pervomayskiy District Court upheld Mr Nagibin's conviction of 2 December 2007.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 18 February 2008 Mr Nagibin challenged the Rostov-na-Donu town administration's rejection of his picket notification before a court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 7 March 2008 the Pervomayskiy District Court found that there had been no breach of Mr Nagibin's right to hold a picket because the Rostov-na-Donu town administration had not prohibited the event.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Pervomayskiy District Court found on 7 March 2008 that Mr Nagibin had actually begun picketing but had been detained and brought to administrative liability for an unrelated offence.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 23 April 2008 the Rostov Regional Court upheld the Pervomayskiy District Court's judgment of 7 March 2008 on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. APPLICATION No. 37565/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The first applicant in application no. 37581/08 is Mr Nagibin.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. APPLICATION No. 37581/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The second applicant in application no. 37581/08 is Mr Batyy.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. APPLICATION No. 37581/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 19 June 2007 Mr Nagibin and Mr Ye. notified the Rostov-na-Donu town administration of their intention to hold a meeting of approximately three hundred participants on Sovetov Square from 5 p.m. to 6 p.m. on 30 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. APPLICATION No. 37581/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 19 June 2007 Mr Nagibin and Mr Ye. notified the Rostov-na-Donu town administration of their intention to hold the 'Dissenters' March' (Марш несогласных) along Sadovaya and Sovetskaya Streets following the meeting on Sovetov Square on 30 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. APPLICATION No. 37581/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 19 June 2007 Mr Nagibin and Mr Ye. notified the Rostov-na-Donu town administration of their intention to hold another meeting at Karl Marx Square until 7.30 p.m. on 30 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. APPLICATION No. 37581/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 20 June 2007 the Rostov-na-Donu town administration informed Mr Nagibin that the contemplated events had not been sufficiently prepared.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. APPLICATION No. 37581/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Rostov-na-Donu town administration noted that the notification did not indicate which side of Sadovaya and Sovetskaya Streets the march would take place.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. APPLICATION No. 37581/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Rostov-na-Donu town administration noted that the notification did not indicate where the participants would cross the streets.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. APPLICATION No. 37581/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 21 September 2007 Mr Nagibin, Mr Batyy and Mr Ye. complained to a court about the Rostov-na-Donu town administration's de facto refusal of their application to hold a march.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. APPLICATION No. 37581/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 8 October 2007 the Pervomayskiy District Court of Rostov-na-Donu found in favour of Mr Nagibin, Mr Batyy and Mr Ye. regarding the Rostov-na-Donu town administration's de facto refusal of their application to hold a march.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. APPLICATION No. 37581/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Following the Rostov-na-Donu town administration's appeal, on 21 November 2007 the Rostov-na-Donu Regional Court reversed the Pervomayskiy District Court's decision of 8 October 2007.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. APPLICATION No. 37581/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Rostov-na-Donu Regional Court held on 21 November 2007 that the administration's response had not prohibited the meeting or prevented the organisers from submitting more detailed information on its route and venue.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. APPLICATION No. 37581/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Rostov-na-Donu Regional Court held on 21 November 2007 that the organisers had not made use of the possibility to submit more detailed information on the route and venue.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. APPLICATION No. 37581/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Rostov-na-Donu Regional Court determined, without referring to specific dates, that Mr Nagibin, Mr Batyy and Mr Ye. had missed the three-month time-limit for appealing against the Rostov-na-Donu town administration's decision.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. APPLICATION No. 37581/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The applicant in application no. 42250/08 is Mr Nikolayev.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "A. Notification of the public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Mr Nikolayev on various dates notified the Rostov-na-Donu town administration of his intention to hold public events at different locations as set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "A. Notification of the public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Rostov-na-Donu town administration imposed restrictions as to the location of the public event on each occasion that Mr Nikolayev submitted a notification.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "A. Notification of the public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Mr Nikolayev contested the Rostov-na-Donu town administration's replies before the domestic courts, with details of those proceedings set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "A. Notification of the public events"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "On 24 November 2007 Mr Nikolayev and Mr S. intended to take part in the event organised by Mr Nagibin and Mr Ye. (the picket notified in November 2007 relating to application no. 37565/08).", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "At 3.15 p.m. on 24 November 2007 three police officers in uniform and two persons in civilian clothing approached Mr Nikolayev while he was standing near a kiosk.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Mr Nikolayev was told to follow the police officers to the district police station, with the stated reasons being that his driver's licence was a forgery, his cell phone had been stolen, and he looked like a wanted criminal.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Mr Nikolayev was brought to the Kirovskiy district police station on 24 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Mr Nikolayev was charged with a breach of public order, an offence under Article 20.1 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "According to the police report, on 24 November 2007 Mr Nikolayev had sworn obscenely, disobeyed police orders, pushed the policemen away and attempted to flee.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The arrest record noted that Mr Nikolayev had been arrested with a view to ensuring administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Mr Nikolayev was placed into a temporary detention cell at the Kirovskiy district police station where he remained until 10.35 a.m. on 26 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "According to Mr Nikolayev, the temporary detention cell at the Kirovskiy district police station measured 1.4 by 1.5 metres (2.1 square metres).", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "According to Mr Nikolayev, the temporary detention cell at the Kirovskiy district police station was equipped with two short and narrow benches.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Mr Nikolayev shared the temporary detention cell with three other persons.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "Access to drinking water or a toilet was only possible outside the temporary detention cell, at the discretion of police officers.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The temporary detention cell at the Kirovskiy district police station was not heated.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "In the morning of 26 November 2007 Mr Nikolayev was brought before the Justice of the Peace of the 2nd Circuit of the Kirovskiy District of Rostov-na-Donu.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Mr Nikolayev was found guilty of breach of public order under Article 20.1 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences and sentenced to ten days' administrative imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The Justice of the Peace based the decision on three identical reports by officers Mr G., Mr Sh. and Mr N. who claimed to have heard Mr Nikolayev saying obscenities.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Justice of the Peace based the decision on two identical typewritten statements by Mr S. and Mr A. who stated that they had seen two men swearing and ignoring police rebukes.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Justice of the Peace heard officers Mr G., Mr Sh. and Mr N. and also Mr A., who confirmed their pre-trial testimonies.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Mr S. appeared in court but was not allowed to testify because he had no identity documents on his person.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Mr Nikolayev appealed against his conviction.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "On 30 November 2007 the Kirovskiy District Court rejected Mr Nikolayev's appeal in a summary fashion.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Kirovskiy District Court reduced Mr Nikolayev's term of administrative imprisonment from ten days to eight days.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "V. APPLICATION No. 42250/08", "B. Demonstration on 24 November 2007, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The applicant in application no. 57374/08 is Mr Nagibin.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The facts of application no. 57374/08 are related to the facts in application no. 37565/08.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Mr Nagibin was apprehended on 24 November 2007 and brought to the Kirovskiy district police station in Rostov-na-Donu.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Mr Nagibin stayed at the Kirovskiy district police station in Rostov-na-Donu from 24 November 2007 until 26 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "On 26 November 2007 Mr Nagibin was brought before the Justice of the Peace of the Kirovskiy District.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "On 26 November 2007 the Justice of the Peace of the Kirovskiy District adjourned the hearing in Mr Nagibin's case.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Mr Nagibin was released on 26 November 2007 following the adjournment of the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "When convicting Mr Nagibin of an administrative offence, the judge sentenced him to three days' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The judge held that Mr Nagibin's detention from 5.20 p.m. on 24 November 2007 to 10.45 a.m. on 26 November 2007 should be credited to the time to be served.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "On an unspecified date Mr Nagibin brought a judicial complaint against the Kirovskiy district police station arguing that the period from 3.10 p.m. until 5.20 p.m. on 24 November 2007 (the time from his factual arrest until his transfer to the police station was completed) should be included in the period of his detention.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Mr Nagibin argued that the period from 10.45 a.m. until 5.20 p.m. on 26 November 2007 (the time when he was transferred to the judge and waited for the hearing) should also be included in the period of his detention.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "On 14 March 2008 the Pervomayskiy District Court of Rostov-na-Donu rejected Mr Nagibin's complaint against the Kirovskiy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The Pervomayskiy District Court noted that the Code of Administrative Offences distinguished between 'transfer' (Article 27.2 § 1, 'доставление') — the act of transfer by convoy of an individual to a police station to prepare a report on an administrative offence — and 'administrative detention' (Article 27.3 § 1, 'административное задержание') — a short-time restriction on the liberty of the offender for the purpose of correct and diligent examination of the administrative case.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Relying on the testimony of police officers, the Pervomayskiy District Court found that Mr Nagibin had been subjected to 'transfer' until 5.20 p.m. on 24 November 2007 and had been free to move around the police station and had not been held there by force.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Pervomayskiy District Court found that on 26 November 2007 Mr Nagibin had not been restricted in his liberty while on the premises of the Justice of the Peace and had been able to confer with his lawyer and other individuals.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "On 23 April 2008 the Rostov Regional Court upheld the Pervomayskiy District Court's judgment of 14 March 2008, reproducing its text verbatim.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VI. APPLICATION No. 57374/08"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "From 24 to 26 November 2007 Mr Nagibin (the applicant in application no. 10460/09) was held in the administrative-detention cell located on the premises of the Kirovskiy district police station in Rostov-na-Donu.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VII. APPLICATION No. 10460/09"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The administrative-detention cell at the Kirovskiy district police station measured 3.5 square metres.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VII. APPLICATION No. 10460/09"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Mr Nagibin shared the administrative-detention cell at the Kirovskiy district police station with three to five other detainees.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VII. APPLICATION No. 10460/09"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The administrative-detention cell at the Kirovskiy district police station was equipped with one bed, thirty centimetres wide and too short for an adult.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VII. APPLICATION No. 10460/09"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Detainees in the administrative-detention cell at the Kirovskiy district police station took turns to sleep on the floor.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VII. APPLICATION No. 10460/09"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "There was no natural light in the administrative-detention cell at the Kirovskiy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VII. APPLICATION No. 10460/09"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "There was no possibility for outdoor exercise for detainees held in the administrative-detention cell at the Kirovskiy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VII. APPLICATION No. 10460/09"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Mr Nagibin complained before the domestic courts about the poor conditions of his detention at the Kirovskiy district police station from 24 to 26 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VII. APPLICATION No. 10460/09"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "On 27 May 2010 the Rostov Regional Court found that Mr Nagibin was unlawfully deprived of proper meals during his detention at the Kirovskiy district police station from 24 to 26 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VII. APPLICATION No. 10460/09"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "On 27 May 2010 the Rostov Regional Court found that Mr Nagibin was unlawfully deprived of a sleeping place during his detention at the Kirovskiy district police station from 24 to 26 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VII. APPLICATION No. 10460/09"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The domestic courts established that Mr Nagibin was kept in a cell measuring 3.5 square metres with three other persons during his detention at the Kirovskiy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VII. APPLICATION No. 10460/09"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "On 8 December 2008 Mr Nagibin and Mr Ye. notified the Rostov-na-Donu town administration of their intention to hold a picket on Russian Constitution Day (12 December 2008).", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "A. Notification of the public event"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "The picket notified on 8 December 2008 was to take place in front of the building of the Presidential Envoy to the Southern Federal District on Bolshaya Sadovaya Street or across the road on Sovetov Square.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "A. Notification of the public event"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "On 8 December 2008 the Rostov-na-Donu town administration replied that Mr Nagibin had to hold the picket in another area, in front of the Sports Palace.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "A. Notification of the public event"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "On 10 December 2008 the Rostov-na-Donu town administration again replied that Mr Nagibin had to hold the picket in another area, in front of the Sports Palace.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "A. Notification of the public event"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "On 30 June 2010 the Supreme Court of Russia, following a request by the Ombudsman, held that the replies of the Rostov-na-Donu town administration of 8 and 10 December 2008 were unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "A. Notification of the public event"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "In his observations of 6 November 2011 Mr Nagibin withdrew his complaint under Article 11 of the Convention concerning the alleged restriction on the location of the public event in application no. 39189/09.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "A. Notification of the public event"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "At 5.20 p.m. on 12 December 2008 Mr Nagibin came to Voroshilovskiy Drive for a solitary demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Mr Nagibin carried a sandwich board during his solitary demonstration on 12 December 2008 at Voroshilovskiy Drive.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Mr Nagibin distributed leaflets to passers-by during his solitary demonstration on 12 December 2008 at Voroshilovskiy Drive.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "At approximately 5.40 p.m. on 12 December 2008 two police officers apprehended Mr Nagibin during his solitary demonstration at Voroshilovskiy Drive.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "Mr Nagibin was taken to the Kirovskiy district police station following his apprehension on 12 December 2008.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "Mr Nagibin was charged with a breach of public order and verbal assaults, an administrative offence under Article 20.1 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, following his apprehension on 12 December 2008.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The administrative arrest record stated that Mr Nagibin had been arrested to ensure administrative trial, identify the offender and to draft the administrative offence record.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "Mr Nagibin noted in the administrative arrest record that he had been in a solo demonstration when the police arrested him and contested the lawfulness of the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "On 13 December 2008 the Justice of the Peace of the 6th Court Circuit of the Kirovskiy District found Mr Nagibin guilty of breach of public order and verbal assaults under Article 20.1 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of the 6th Court Circuit of the Kirovskiy District based the conviction on submissions by several witnesses and two police officers, establishing in general terms that Mr Nagibin had used foul language in a public space.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The text of the judgment of 13 December 2008 did not specify which particular words Mr Nagibin had pronounced.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The Justice of the Peace did not address Mr Nagibin's arguments that he had not used foul language but rather had been making a solo demonstration when the police officers came and ordered him to stop the unlawful demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The Justice of the Peace sentenced Mr Nagibin to three days' administrative imprisonment, to be calculated from 7.35 p.m. on 12 December 2008.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "Mr Nagibin appealed against his conviction of 13 December 2008, arguing inter alia that the judge had not taken into account the fact that he had been picketing.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "On 12 January 2009 the Pervomayskiy District Court of Rostov-na-Donu upheld Mr Nagibin's conviction of 13 December 2008.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "On 25 March 2009 the Pervomayskiy District Court rejected Mr Nagibin's claim for inclusion of the time period from 5.48 p.m. to 7.35 p.m. on 12 December 2008 in the period of his detention.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The Pervomayskiy District Court held on 25 March 2009 that it was not reliably shown that Mr Nagibin had been detained at 5.48 p.m. on 12 December 2008.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "On 28 May 2009 the Rostov Regional Court upheld the Pervomayskiy District Court's decision of 25 March 2009 on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "VIII. APPLICATION No. 39189/09", "B. Solo demonstration on 12 December 2008, arrest and conviction of the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The applicant in application no. 1965/10 is Mr Nagibin.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IX. APPLICATION NO. 1965/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "Mr Nagibin complained to a court about poor conditions of his detention in the night from 12 to 13 December 2008 on the premises of the Kirovskiy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IX. APPLICATION NO. 1965/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "Mr Nagibin argued that he had no sleeping place during his detention at the Kirovskiy district police station in the night from 12 to 13 December 2008.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IX. APPLICATION NO. 1965/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "Mr Nagibin argued that on 13 December 2008 he was transported in an unheated minivan for more than two hours.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IX. APPLICATION NO. 1965/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "Mr Nagibin argued that he had not received any food on 13 December 2008.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IX. APPLICATION NO. 1965/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "On 25 March 2009 the Pervomayskiy District Court rejected Mr Nagibin's complaints about the conditions of his detention at the Kirovskiy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IX. APPLICATION NO. 1965/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The Pervomayskiy District Court found on 25 March 2009 that Mr Nagibin had been provided with a sleeping place on a bench and bed linen during his detention at the Kirovskiy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IX. APPLICATION NO. 1965/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The Pervomayskiy District Court found on 25 March 2009 that Mr Nagibin had been given packed food provisions on 12 and 13 December 2008.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IX. APPLICATION NO. 1965/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "The Pervomayskiy District Court accepted the police representative's submission that the car used to transport Mr Nagibin on 13 December 2008 had been 'specifically equipped' for transporting people.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IX. APPLICATION NO. 1965/10"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "On 28 May 2009 the Rostov Regional Court upheld the Pervomayskiy District Court's judgment of 25 March 2009 on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IX. APPLICATION NO. 1965/10"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002", "F003", "F004", "F011", "F057", "F060", "F075", "F076", "F088", "F091", "F092", "F093", "F094", "F095", "F096", "F110", "F111"], "interference": ["F001", "F002", "F003", "F004", "F057", "F058", "F059", "F060", "F061", "F062", "F063", "F075", "F076", "F077", "F078", "F079", "F080", "F088", "F089"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F058", "F059", "F078", "F079", "F080", "F089"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002", "F003", "F058", "F059", "F078", "F079", "F080", "F089"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F011", "F057", "F060", "F075", "F088", "F091", "F092"], "interference": ["F001", "F058", "F059", "F061", "F063", "F078", "F079", "F080", "F089"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F058", "F059", "F078", "F079", "F080", "F089"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F078", "F079", "F080", "F089"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F011", "F057", "F060", "F061", "F075", "F078", "F088", "F089"]}} {"case_name": "case_453", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "On 20 January 2012, Mr Nagibin and five other persons notified the Rostov-on-Don Town Administration of their intention to hold a public event in support of fair elections in the centre of Rostov-on-Don.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "Mr Nagibin and five other persons proposed several alternative locations for the public event, including Teatralnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The public event notified by Mr Nagibin and five other persons was scheduled for 4 February 2012.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 23 January 2012, the Rostov-on-Don Town Administration refused to approve the time of the public event proposed by Mr Nagibin and five other persons.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 23 January 2012, the Rostov-on-Don Town Administration refused to approve any of the proposed locations of the public event proposed by Mr Nagibin and five other persons.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "With regard to Teatralnaya Square in particular, Mr Nagibin and other event organisers were informed that another public event, namely 'For honest and clean democracy', was already scheduled to be held by the Liberal Democratic Party of Russia at the same time and location.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "At 2.30 p.m. on 4 February 2012, Mr Nagibin, together with an unspecified number of persons, arrived in Teatralnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "At 2.30 p.m. on 4 February 2012, Mr Nagibin and the persons accompanying him joined the public event organised by the Liberal Democratic Party of Russia at Teatralnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "At the Liberal Democratic Party of Russia's public event at Teatralnaya Square on 4 February 2012, Mr Nagibin spoke out on the alleged illegality of the State Duma elections.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "At the Liberal Democratic Party of Russia's public event at Teatralnaya Square on 4 February 2012, Mr Nagibin distributed leaflets in support of his position regarding the alleged illegality of the State Duma elections.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "A police officer present at Teatralnaya Square on 4 February 2012 ordered Mr Nagibin, and others who had arrived with him, to stop their unauthorised meeting and to leave the square.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Mr Nagibin refused to comply with the police officer's order to stop the unauthorised meeting and leave Teatralnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "At 3.30 p.m. on 4 February 2012, Mr Nagibin was arrested and taken to the police station for the purposes of compiling an administrative-offence record.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 11 April 2012, the justice of the peace of the 3rd Circuit of the Proletarskiy District of Rostov-on-Don found Mr Nagibin guilty under Article 20.2 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences for holding an unauthorised public event.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 3rd Circuit of the Proletarskiy District of Rostov-on-Don fined Mr Nagibin 1,000 Russian roubles, equivalent to about 26 euros at the time of the judgment on 11 April 2012.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 3rd Circuit of the Proletarskiy District of Rostov-on-Don dismissed Mr Nagibin's argument that he had simply joined the Liberal Democratic Party of Russia's public event, which was in line with the message he had wished to convey.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 3rd Circuit of the Proletarskiy District of Rostov-on-Don dismissed Mr Nagibin's argument that he had not staged a public event of his own.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 25 July 2012, the Proletarskiy District Court of Rostov-on-Don upheld the judgment of the justice of the peace of the 3rd Circuit of the Proletarskiy District of Rostov-on-Don dated 11 April 2012 on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicants were refused permission to hold a number of other public events on different dates in 2012.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Mr Nagibin was administratively prosecuted and fined for having organised and taken part in unauthorised public events in 2012.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Mr Nagibin was administratively prosecuted and fined for having organised and taken part in unauthorised public events in 2016.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The relevant facts and complaints concerning the applicants' refused public events and Mr Nagibin's administrative prosecutions are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F013"], "interference": ["F013", "F014", "F015", "F018"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F014"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F008", "F010"], "interference": ["F013", "F014"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F014"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F004", "F005", "F008", "F014", "F016", "F017"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F006", "F008", "F014", "F016", "F017"]}} {"case_name": "case_458", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "In the beginning of March 2017, Mr Aleksey Navalnyy, a political activist and popular blogger, released a film on YouTube.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The film released by Mr Aleksey Navalnyy on YouTube alleged that a high-ranking State official had used charities and shell companies to amass a collection of luxuries.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The YouTube film released by Mr Aleksey Navalnyy had been watched nearly twelve million times by the end of March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Following Mr Aleksey Navalnyy's call, on Sunday 26 March 2017, thousands of people took to the streets in more than eighty Russian cities protesting against corruption, lawlessness and inequality.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Hundreds of protesters were arrested at peaceful rallies on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Hundreds of protesters who were arrested at peaceful rallies on 26 March 2017 were later convicted of administrative offences for breach of rules on public events.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 14 March 2017, Mr Navalnyy notified the Moscow Government about his intention to hold a march in the centre of Moscow on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 14 March 2017, Mr Navalnyy notified the Moscow Government about his intention to hold a gathering in the centre of Moscow on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The purpose of the march and gathering notified by Mr Navalnyy on 14 March 2017 was to call for investigation of corruption by state officials.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 16 March 2017, the Regional Security and Anti-Corruption Department of Moscow informed Mr Navalnyy that the march was likely to disrupt traffic.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 16 March 2017, the Regional Security and Anti-Corruption Department of Moscow informed Mr Navalnyy that the march was likely to breach the rights of others.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 22 March 2017, the Regional Security and Anti-Corruption Department of Moscow suggested to Mr Navalnyy that he hold his public events in Sokolniki park, located quite far from the centre of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 22 March 2017, the Regional Security and Anti-Corruption Department of Moscow suggested to Mr Navalnyy that he hold his public events in Lublino district, located quite far from the centre of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Mr Navalnyy refused to accept the proposals made by the Regional Security and Anti-Corruption Department of Moscow to hold his public events in Sokolniki park or Lublino district.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On his YouTube channel, Mr Navalnyy called on people to join the march on 26 March 2017 in Tverskaya street by exiting any of the five metro stations located along that street and walking in any direction.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Mr Navalnyy promised on his YouTube channel to assist those who would be arrested at the march in preparing an application to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Regional Security and Anti-Corruption Department of Moscow, being aware of Mr Navalnyy's call on YouTube, asked the police to deploy additional forces to secure safety and public order in the city centre of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 26 March 2017, Mr Navalnyy arrived in Tverskaya street to take part in the march.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 26 March 2017, Mr Navalnyy was walking down Tverskaya street with other participants of the march.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "At 2.28 p.m. on 26 March 2017, Mr Navalnyy was apprehended by the police in Tverskaya street and placed in a police bus.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "At 3.31 p.m. on 26 March 2017, Mr Navalnyy was administratively arrested at the Konkovo police station of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Mr Navalnyy remained at the Konkovo police station of Moscow until 8.45 a.m. on 27 March 2017, when he was taken to court.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 27 March 2017, the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow found Mr Navalnyy guilty of organising and holding an unauthorised public event with about 4,000 participants.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The unauthorised public event for which Mr Navalnyy was found guilty caused disruption of movement of pedestrians and traffic.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The offence of organising and holding an unauthorised public event causing disruption of movement of pedestrians and traffic is punishable under Article 20.2 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offence.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow sentenced Mr Navalnyy to a fine of 20,000 Russian roubles for organising and holding an unauthorised public event on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "After announcing the judgment on the unauthorised public event charge, the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow informed Mr Navalnyy that he was also accused of failure to obey a lawful order of a police officer during his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow informed Mr Navalnyy that the case concerning failure to obey a lawful order of a police officer would be examined right away.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Mr Navalnyy's request to adjourn the hearing on the charge of failure to obey a lawful order of a police officer was dismissed by the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Mr Navalnyy's request to be provided with adequate time to prepare for the trial on the charge of failure to obey a lawful order of a police officer was dismissed by the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Mr Navalnyy's request to question eyewitnesses of his arrest was dismissed by the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Mr Navalnyy's request to question two police officers who had drawn up the reports depicting the events of 26 March 2017 was dismissed by the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow found Mr Navalnyy guilty of breach of Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offence (failure to obey a lawful order of a police officer).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow sentenced Mr Navalnyy to 15 days' administrative detention for breach of Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offence.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 30 March 2017, the Moscow City Court dismissed Mr Navalnyy's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Moscow City Court refused to question the eyewitnesses of Mr Navalnyy's arrest on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Moscow City Court disallowed Mr Navalnyy's questions to the police officers during their examination on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "I. APPLICATION NO. 25809/17"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicants in the other applications were administratively prosecuted for participation in the unauthorised march in Moscow on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "II. OTHER APPLICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicants in the other applications were sentenced to administrative detention or fined for participation in the unauthorised march in Moscow on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "II. OTHER APPLICATIONS"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The relevant facts and complaints concerning the other applicants are set out in the Appendix to the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE", "II. OTHER APPLICATIONS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F007", "F008", "F015", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F023"], "interference": ["F020", "F021", "F023", "F026", "F033", "F034"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F025"], "legitimate_aim": ["F010", "F011", "F024"], "necessity": ["F001", "F002", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F034", "F035"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F019", "F023"], "interference": ["F020", "F023"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F025"], "legitimate_aim": ["F010", "F011"], "necessity": ["F009", "F010", "F019", "F023", "F024"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F009", "F019", "F020", "F023", "F024"]}} {"case_name": "case_459", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1976.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1983.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Both applicants live in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Both applicants are political activists and opposition leaders.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The first applicant is a well-known anti-corruption campaigner.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The first applicant is a popular blogger.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The second applicant is a leader of the political movement \"Solidarnost\".", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 4 December 2011 general elections of the State Duma took place in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 5 December 2011 the applicants took part in a public demonstration (a meeting) at Chistyye Prudy, Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The public demonstration on 5 December 2011 was held to protest against the allegedly rigged State Duma elections.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The demonstration on 5 December 2011 had been duly authorised by the mayor of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The number of participants at the meeting on 5 December 2011 was estimated between 5,000 and 10,000.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The meeting on 5 December 2011 was conducted by the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "During the meeting on 5 December 2011, the first applicant addressed the participants with a speech calling for fresh, fair elections.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "During the meeting on 5 December 2011, the first applicant described United Russia, the election frontrunner, as \"a party of crooks and thieves\".", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "After the demonstration on 5 December 2011, the applicants were arrested.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The parties disagreed as to the circumstances of the applicants' arrest after the demonstration on 5 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicants claimed that at the end of the meeting they had headed, with other people, towards the Kuznetskiy Most metro station, where the first applicant had left his car.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicants claimed that they were walking along the pavement, leaving the road clear for traffic.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicants claimed that their way was suddenly blocked by the riot police (сотрудники внутренних войск и ОМОН).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicants claimed that without any introduction or demand, the police surrounded a group of about one hundred protesters, including the applicants, pressing them against a building.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicants claimed that the surrounded group chanted \"One for all, and all for one!\".", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicants claimed that the riot police then began to arrest the protesters.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the applicants, no one in the surrounded group put up any resistance.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicants claimed that they obeyed the police and followed them to the police bus.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the Government, at the end of the meeting the second applicant called on the participants to march down Myasnitskaya Street onto Lubyanskaya Square and then to the office of the Central Electoral Commission.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the Government, at 8.30 p.m. about sixty people, including the applicants, began walking down Chistoprudnyy Boulevard, Bolshaya Lubyanka Street and Rozhdestvenka Street.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the Government, the group of about sixty people walked along the road, obstructing the traffic and chanting slogans such as \"This is our city!\" and \"Down with the police state!\".", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the Government, at the crossroads of Pushechnaya and Rozhdestvenka Streets the police blocked the march and ordered the marchers to stop.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the Government, the marchers pushed through the police cordon at the crossroads of Pushechnaya and Rozhdestvenka Streets and went on.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the Government, the marchers were stopped by the police again at 2 Teatralnyy Proyezd.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the Government, the marchers ignored the repeated demands of the police to stop and thereby prevented the police from carrying out their mission of securing public order.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to the Government, confronted with the marchers' persistent behaviour, the police arrested the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "Both applicants were arrested at about 8.45 p.m. on 5 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Both applicants were taken to a police bus after their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 5 December 2011 and the applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "At about 9.40 p.m. on 5 December 2011 the applicants were taken to the Severnoye Izmaylovo District police station, Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "At 11.40 p.m. on 5 December 2011 the first applicant was subjected to a body search at the Severnoye Izmaylovo District police station, which lasted until 12.15 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The first applicant's personal affairs, including his mobile phone, barrister licence, watch, money, credit cards, driving licence and some items of clothing, were seized during the body search.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The second applicant was searched at the Severnoye Izmaylovo District police station, and his mobile phone, belt, watch, whistle and a badge reading \"Against the Party of Crooks and Thieves\" were seized.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The list of the seized objects from both applicants was recorded in the search report.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicants were unable to retrieve the seized objects, although those objects were not attached to the case file.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicants requested that their lawyers, who had arrived at the Severnoye Izmaylovo District police station and had presented their authority, be allowed to see them.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The applicants' request to see their lawyers at the Severnoye Izmaylovo District police station was refused.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicants were not allowed to make a phone call to their families at the Severnoye Izmaylovo District police station.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Both applicants lodged complaints at the Severnoye Izmaylovo District police station alleging that their rights had been violated during their arrest and detention.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "At about 12.45 a.m. on 6 December 2011 the applicants were transferred from the Severnoye Izmaylovo District police station to the Vostochnyy District police station, Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicants arrived at the Vostochnyy District police station at about 1.45 a.m. on 6 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "At the Vostochnyy District police station the applicants requested to see a lawyer and to make a phone call, but this was refused.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The first applicant lodged a complaint about the refusal to see a lawyer and make a phone call at the Vostochnyy District police station.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "At 2.30 a.m. on 6 December 2011 the applicants were transferred to the Kitay-Gorod District police station.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "At the Kitay-Gorod District police station, police reports were drawn up stating that the applicants had been escorted to the police station in accordance with Article 27.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "At 2.40 a.m. on 6 December 2011 further police reports were drawn up at the Kitay-Gorod District police station in which it was decided to remand the applicants in custody under Article 27.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The applicants were charged with an administrative offence for refusing to comply with a lawful order of the police, in breach of Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The charges against the applicants were based on the identical statements of two police officers, identified as I. and F., who alleged that they had ordered the applicants to follow them to the police bus to give statements on the administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Police officers I. and F. alleged in their statements that the applicants had pushed them away and had therefore been arrested.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "At the Kitay-Gorod District police station the applicants requested permission to see their lawyers and to telephone their families, but their requests were refused.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The first applicant remained in custody at the Kitay-Gorod District police station until 3 p.m. on 6 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The second applicant remained in custody at the Kitay-Gorod District police station until 10 a.m. on 6 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicants claimed that the conditions of detention during their transfer between the police stations were inhuman and degrading.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The applicants claimed that the conditions of detention in the cell at the Kitay-Gorod District police station were inhuman and degrading.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The applicants claimed that they had spent six hours being driven to different police stations without being given any food or drinking water.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicants claimed that at the Kitay-Gorod District police station they were placed together in a cell measuring about 6 sq. m with concrete walls, a metal grill, a concrete floor, no windows and no furniture except for two narrow wooden benches.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The applicants claimed that the cell at the Kitay-Gorod District police station was poorly lit and had no ventilation.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The applicants claimed that there was no sanitary equipment, beds or bedding in the cell at the Kitay-Gorod District police station.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicants claimed that they did not receive any food or water until later on 6 December 2011 when they were allowed to receive a parcel from their families containing drinking water and crackers.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The applicants claimed that no food other than drinking water and crackers was allowed in the parcels from their families.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Government submitted that the applicants had spent about one hour in transit to the Vostochnyy District police station.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Government submitted that the applicants had spent about forty-five minutes in transit to the Kitay-Gorod District police station.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Government submitted that the transit times were not long enough to require the provision of meals.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "According to the Government, the applicants were detained at the Kitay-Gorod District police station in an administrative-detention cell measuring 12.3 sq. m equipped with artificial lighting and mandatory ventilation.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Government claimed that the applicants had been provided with a sleeping place — a wooden bench — and bedding, which they had refused.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Government provided a photograph of the cell at the Kitay-Gorod District police station with a metal grill, a close-up photograph of the bench showing its width of 47 cm, and another photograph showing the same bench covered with a blanket and with a pillow placed on it.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Government contended that the cells at the Kitay-Gorod District police station had to be cleaned and disinfected twice a day and that pest control had to be carried out once every three months, in accordance with the cleaning service agreement between the Ministry of the Interior and a private company.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Government provided a copy of the cleaning service agreement between the Ministry of the Interior and a private company in support of their statement about cell cleaning and disinfection.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicants had not complained about the conditions of their detention at the Kitay-Gorod District police station.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "According to the Government, the applicants had been offered food at the Kitay-Gorod District police station but had refused to take it.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' transfer to police stations and their overnight detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 6 December 2011 the applicants were brought before the Justice of the Peace to have their charges examined in administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The applicants met their counsels for the first time shortly before the administrative hearing on 6 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The administrative case of the second applicant was examined first, and then the case of the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The administrative case against the second applicant was examined by the acting Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 370 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow, Ms B.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "At the beginning of the hearing, the second applicant challenged the Justice of the Peace Ms B. on the grounds that she had previously found him guilty of an administrative offence and sentenced him to five days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "After his previous conviction by Ms B., the second applicant had lodged numerous complaints about Ms B. and had campaigned against her in his online blogs.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Justice of the Peace Ms B. dismissed the challenge against her in the second applicant's administrative case.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The second applicant requested leave to call and examine five witnesses: police officers I. and F. who had drawn up the arrest reports; K., the on-duty police officer at the Kitay-Gorod District police station; Mr B., a fellow activist; and the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The request to call witnesses in the second applicant's administrative case was granted in respect of police officers I., F. and Mr B.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The second applicant complained of unlawful detention during the first six hours after his arrest in the administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The second applicant complained of poor conditions of detention at the Kitay-Gorod District police station in the administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The second applicant complained of the acts and omissions of the officials at the Severnoye Izmaylovo District police station in the administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The second applicant's complaints about unlawful detention, poor conditions of detention and acts and omissions of officials were not examined in the administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Justice of the Peace questioned witnesses I. and F. in the second applicant's administrative case.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Police officers I. and F. stated that after the public meeting the second applicant had participated, together with some sixty people, in an unauthorised march from Chistoprudnyy Boulevard, through Bolshaya Lubyanka Street, Kuznetskiy Most Street and down Rozhdestvenka Street.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Police officers I. and F. stated that the marchers had been obstructing the traffic, chanting slogans and ignoring police orders made on a loudspeaker to stop the march.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Police officers I. and F. stated that they had required the second applicant to follow them to the police bus in order to draw up a report on the administrative offence, but he had ignored them.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Police officers I. and F. stated that they had seized the second applicant by the arms; he had resisted, refusing to present his documents and calling out to the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The second applicant pleaded not guilty and contested the police officers' testimonies in the administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The second applicant testified that he had been arrested at the indicated address while walking alongside other people returning from the authorised meeting.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The second applicant insisted that he had been arrested without any warning or orders from the police.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Witness B. testified in the second applicant's administrative case that he had been present during the second applicant's arrest.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Witness B. testified that the policemen had not given the second applicant any orders before arresting him.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 6 December 2011 the Justice of the Peace found the second applicant guilty of having disobeyed a lawful order of the police.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Justice of the Peace based her findings against the second applicant on the witness statements of police officers I. and F., their written reports and the report on the administrative arrest.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Justice of the Peace dismissed the testimonies given by the second applicant and witness B. on the grounds that they had contradicted the police officers' testimonies and reports.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The second applicant was convicted under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences and sentenced to fifteen days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "1. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Yashin"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The first applicant's administrative case was examined after the second applicant's trial by the same Justice of the Peace, Ms B.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "In the interval between the two administrative hearings, the first applicant's counsel was able briefly to access the case file of the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "In the interval between the two administrative hearings, the first applicant's counsel met the first applicant for the first time.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "According to the applicants, the proceedings in the first applicant's administrative case began in the absence of members of the public, who were prevented from entering the hearing room.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "According to the applicants, many members of the public were barred from approaching the courthouse, which was cordoned off by the police.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "According to the applicants, later during the proceedings, eight journalists were allowed into the hearing room at the first applicant's insistent requests.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Government contended that the proceedings in the first applicant's administrative case had been open to the public.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "At the beginning of the first applicant's administrative trial, the first applicant requested that the case be transferred, in accordance with the statutory rules, to a court at his place of residence.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "At the beginning of the first applicant's administrative trial, the first applicant requested that the hearing be adjourned in order to give him time to prepare his defence.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "At the beginning of the first applicant's administrative trial, the first applicant requested that the verbatim records of the hearing be kept open.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "At the beginning of the first applicant's administrative trial, the first applicant requested that copies of the complaints that he had lodged at the police stations the previous night be made available to him.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "At the beginning of the first applicant's administrative trial, the first applicant requested that five eyewitnesses of his arrest, including the second applicant, be called and examined.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Justice of the Peace dismissed all of the first applicant's requests except the request that witnesses T. and A. be called.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The first applicant challenged the Justice of the Peace Ms B. in his administrative case, but the challenge was unsuccessful.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Police officers I. and F. gave testimonies in the first applicant's administrative case identical to those they had given in the second applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The Justice of the Peace disallowed the following questions put by the first applicant's defence counsel to police officers I. and F.: \"What orders did you personally give to Mr Navalnyy?\", \"Who gave the order to arrest Mr Navalnyy?\" and \"Why were two policemen's reports identical?\".", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The first applicant pleaded not guilty and contested the police officers' testimonies in the administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The first applicant testified that he had been returning from the authorised meeting, walking together with other people, not marching or chanting any slogans.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The first applicant testified that the police had repeatedly obstructed their way and had then arrested them.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The first applicant insisted that he had not received any orders from the police and had not resisted the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Witness T. testified that he had seen the first applicant's arrest.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Witness T. testified that it had been noisy and he had not heard the police officers giving the first applicant any orders before arresting him.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Witness T. testified that the police had announced through a loudspeaker \"Your actions are unlawful\" while surrounding a group of people, and had then begun arresting them.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Witness T. testified that he had not seen the first applicant resisting the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Witness A. testified that he had been walking down Teatralnyy Proyezd and had seen people in uniform arresting the first applicant on the pavement.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Witness A. testified that during the arrest the police had announced through a loudspeaker \"Your actions are unlawful\".", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "Witness A. testified that he had not seen the first applicant resisting the police during the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The first applicant requested that two video recordings of his arrest, shot by witnesses T. and A., be admitted as evidence in the administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The first applicant requested that the court obtain and examine the video footage which the police had at their disposal.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The requests to admit the video recordings were dismissed on the grounds that the court had no technical means of playing the recordings and that it would be unacceptable to use the devices provided by the defence.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The requests to admit the video recordings were not joined to the case file on the grounds that they had been submitted at the wrong stage of the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "According to the first applicant, most of the questions put by the defence to the witnesses were disallowed by the Justice of the Peace in his administrative case.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The Justice of the Peace refused to entertain the first applicant's complaints concerning the lack of access to a lawyer after his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The Justice of the Peace refused to entertain the first applicant's complaints concerning the refusal of a statutory phone call after the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The Justice of the Peace refused to entertain the first applicant's complaints concerning the allegedly unlawful detention during the first six hours after the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The Justice of the Peace refused to entertain the first applicant's complaints concerning the seizure of his possessions during the search.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The Justice of the Peace refused to entertain the first applicant's complaints concerning the inhuman and degrading conditions of transfer and of detention at the Kitay-Gorod District police station.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "On 6 December 2011 the Justice of the Peace found the first applicant guilty of having disobeyed the lawful order of the police.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "The Justice of the Peace based her findings against the first applicant on the witness statements of police officers I. and F., their written reports and the report on the administrative arrest.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "The Justice of the Peace dismissed the testimonies of the first applicant, witness A. and witness T. on the grounds that they had contradicted the police officers' testimonies and reports, and that no reasons for mistrusting the latter had been established.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "The first applicant was convicted under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences and sentenced to fifteen days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "2. Hearing of the administrative case against Mr Navalnyy"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "On 6 December 2011 both applicants lodged appeals against their arrest and conviction for the administrative offence, claiming that these had been in breach of domestic law and in violation of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "In their appeals, the applicants contested the findings of fact made by the first instance as regards the events following their departure from the authorised meeting.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "In their appeals, the applicants complained about the refusal of the Justice of the Peace to grant their requests, to admit the video materials as evidence and to call all the witnesses requested by the defence.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "In their appeals, the applicants challenged the grounds on which the court had dismissed the testimonies of the applicants and the defence witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "In their appeals, the applicants complained of unlawful detention during the first six hours after their arrest.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "In their appeals, the applicants complained of lack of access to a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "In their appeals, the applicants complained of the conditions in which they had been transferred between the police stations and remanded in custody at the Kitay-Gorod District police station.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "On 7 December 2011 the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow examined the applicants' appeals in separate proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow dismissed the complaints about the refusals to hear witnesses and to admit the evidence requested by the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow rejected the applicants' requests to have witnesses called in the appeal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow rejected the request to admit the video recordings in evidence because of their \"unknown provenance\".", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow refused to keep a verbatim record of the hearing because it considered it unnecessary.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow granted the request to join a photograph of the first applicant's arrest to the case file.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "On 7 December 2011 the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow dismissed the applicants' appeals and upheld the first-instance judgment in both cases, citing the same reasons.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held in the first applicant's case that the Justice of the Peace had correctly established that the first applicant had disobeyed a lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that at 8.45 p.m. on 5 December 2011 at 2 Teatralnyy Proyezd, Moscow (near Metropol hotel), after the authorised public meeting at Chistoprudnyy Boulevard, the first applicant participated with a group of about 60 people in a march that had not been notified to the executive authorities.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that the first applicant went out on the road and continued walking from Chistoprudnyy Boulevard, down the side streets to Bolshaya Lubyanka Street, Kuznetskiy Most Street, and Rozhdestvenka Street in the direction of Red Square.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that the first applicant obstructed the traffic and created a risk of accident while shouting out \"Shame!\", \"This is our city!\", \"Russia without Putin!\", \"Down with the police state!\".", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that a police cordon was set up at the crossroads of Pushechnaya and Rozhdestvenka Streets to intercept the march, and that repeated lawful orders to stop and end the march were given through a loudspeaker.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that despite the police orders, the first applicant with a group of people pushed through the cordon and came out onto Teatralnyy Proyezd while continuing to chant slogans, where they were met by another police cordon.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that the first applicant did not react to the repeated lawful orders to stop and disperse, continued his unlawful acts drawing the attention of citizens and the press.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that during his arrest the first applicant, in reply to an invitation to proceed to the police bus for the issuing of an administrative offence report, began to push away police officers I. and F., trying to cause panic among people, thereby manifesting his refusal to comply with the lawful orders of the police and preventing them from carrying out their duties, an offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that the first applicant's guilt was proven by the report on the administrative charges, the statements of police officers I. and F. and their testimonies given to the Justice of the Peace at the court hearing.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow found that no bias on the part of police officers I. and F. or grounds for them to slander the first applicant had been established, and therefore rejected the explanations of the first applicant and the witness testimonies of A. and T. for want of reliable corroboration.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that the police had sufficient grounds for arresting the first applicant and for escorting him to the Kitay-Gorod District police station, Moscow, in particular, the impossibility of drawing up an administrative offence report on the spot.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow dismissed the defence arguments concerning the unlawful deprivation of liberty during six hours as unsubstantiated, noting that after his arrest at Teatralnyy Proyezd, at 2.30 a.m. on 6 December 2011 the first applicant was taken to the Kitay-Gorod District police station where the administrative material against him was issued.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that the police officers had complied with the terms of administrative detention provided for by Article 27.5 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "During the appeal hearing in the first applicant's case, the second applicant was examined as a witness and testified that at the time of the first applicant's arrest he had been with him at Teatralnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "The second applicant testified as a witness in the appeal hearing that at the time of arrest they were on the pavement near the underpass and did not commit any unlawful acts, and that about 100 people were blocked by the riot police.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "The second applicant testified as a witness in the appeal hearing that both the first applicant and the second applicant were arrested virtually simultaneously, that the police officers did not give any orders, there was no disobedience on the part of the applicants, and that police officers I. and F. did not take part in their arrest and their court testimonies were false.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow found the second applicant's witness testimony unreliable and dismissed it because it contradicted the testimonies of police officers I. and F., which were described as logical, consistent, concordant and objectively corroborated by the written evidence.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "The judgment of the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow in the second applicant's case was essentially the same as in the first applicant's case, including the similar testimonies of the other applicant.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings", "3. Appeal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "The Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004) provided, at the material time, that a public event could be stopped if there was a real threat to life or the physical integrity of persons or property.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "The Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004) provided, at the material time, that a public event could be stopped if the participants had acted unlawfully or the event organiser had knowingly breached the requirements of the Act as regards the conduct of the event (section 16).", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "Under the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004), a representative of the public authority, who had to be present at the event, could order the event organiser to put an end to the event in circumstances justifying stopping the event.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "Under the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004), the representative of the public authority had to explain the reasons for the order to end the event and provide time for compliance with it.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "Under the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004), if the organiser did not comply with the order to end the event, the public official could issue the same order to the participants.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "Under the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004), if both the organiser and participants failed to comply with the order to end the event, the police were to take appropriate measures to stop the event (section 17).", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001, at the material time, provided that failure to obey a lawful order or demand of a police officer in connection with the performance of their official duties related to maintaining public order and security, or impeding the performance by them of their official duties, shall be punishable by a fine of between 500 and 1,000 Russian roubles or by administrative detention of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "Article 20.2(1) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001, at the material time, provided that breaches of the established procedure for the organisation of public gatherings, meetings, demonstrations, marches or pickets shall be punishable by an administrative fine of between ten and twenty times the minimum wage, payable by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "Article 20.2(2) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001, at the material time, provided that breaches of the established procedure for the conduct of public gatherings, meetings, demonstrations, marches or pickets shall be punishable by an administrative fine of between 1,000 and 2,000 Russian roubles for the organisers, and between 500 and 1,000 Russian roubles for the participants.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "Article 27.2(1) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that the escorting or the transfer by force of an individual for the purpose of drawing up an administrative offence report, if this cannot be done at the place where the offence was discovered and if the drawing up of a report is mandatory, shall be carried out by the police.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "Article 27.2(2) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that the escort operation shall be carried out as quickly as possible.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "Article 27.2(3) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that the escort operation shall be recorded in an escort operation report, an administrative offence report or an administrative detention report, and that the escorted person shall be given a copy of the escort operation report if he or she so requests.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "Article 27.3(1) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that administrative detention or short-term restriction of an individual's liberty may be applied in exceptional cases if this is necessary for the prompt and proper examination of the alleged administrative offence or to secure the enforcement of any penalty imposed by a judgment concerning an administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "Article 27.3(3) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that where the detained person so requests, his family, the administrative department at his place of work or study and his defence counsel shall be informed of his whereabouts.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "Article 27.3(5) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that the detained person shall have his rights and obligations under the Code explained to him, and the corresponding entry shall be made in the administrative arrest report.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "Article 27.4(1) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that administrative detention shall be recorded in a report.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "Article 27.4(2) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that if he or she so requests, the detained person shall be given a copy of the administrative detention report.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "Article 27.5(1) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that the duration of administrative detention shall not exceed three hours, except in the cases set out in paragraphs 2 and 3 of that Article.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "Article 27.5(2) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that persons subject to administrative proceedings concerning offences involving unlawful crossing of the Russian border may be subject to administrative detention for up to 48 hours.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "Article 27.5(3) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that persons subject to administrative proceedings concerning offences punishable, among other administrative sanctions, by administrative detention may be subject to administrative detention for up to 48 hours.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "Article 27.5(4) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that the term of the administrative detention is calculated from the time when a person escorted in accordance with Article 27.2 is taken to the police station, and in respect of a person in a state of alcoholic intoxication, from the time of his sobering up.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F009", "F011", "F027", "F034", "F091", "F160", "F161", "F028", "F019", "F021", "F024", "F162", "F100", "F141"], "interference": ["F016", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F053", "F103", "F144"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F054", "F055", "F093", "F094", "F095", "F097", "F099", "F102", "F120", "F123", "F125", "F143"], "legitimate_aim": ["F027", "F028", "F029", "F031", "F034", "F019"], "necessity": ["F034", "F027", "F021", "F024", "F011", "F160", "F158", "F159", "F168", "F186", "F051", "F169", "F170", "F035", "F036", "F103", "F144", "F183", "F185", "F028", "F162", "F100", "F141", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F007"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F009", "F011", "F027", "F021", "F024"], "interference": ["F016", "F053", "F103", "F144"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F054", "F097", "F123", "F102", "F143"], "legitimate_aim": ["F027", "F028"], "necessity": ["F024", "F027", "F021", "F160", "F186", "F035", "F051", "F103", "F144", "F183", "F004", "F158"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F009", "F011", "F027", "F024", "F160", "F016", "F186", "F035", "F051", "F103", "F144", "F183", "F004", "F158"]}} {"case_name": "case_460", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1976.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant is a political activist.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant is an opposition leader.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant is an anti-corruption campaigner.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant is a popular blogger.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Five applications before the Court concern the applicant's arrests on seven occasions at different public events.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 5 March 2012 the applicant took part in a meeting at Pushkinskaya Square, Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The meeting at Pushkinskaya Square on 5 March 2012 began at 7 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The meeting at Pushkinskaya Square on 5 March 2012 had been called to protest against the allegedly rigged presidential elections in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The meeting at Pushkinskaya Square on 5 March 2012 had been approved by the municipal authorities.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "At the end of the meeting at Pushkinskaya Square on 5 March 2012, at 9 p.m., State Duma deputy Mr P. addressed the participants.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "State Duma deputy Mr P. invited the public to stay after the meeting at Pushkinskaya Square on 5 March 2012 for informal consultations.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The informal consultations at Pushkinskaya Square on 5 March 2012 began at about 9.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The informal consultations at Pushkinskaya Square on 5 March 2012 were attended by some 500 people.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the applicant, he stayed among others at Pushkinskaya Square on 5 March 2012 for a meeting with State Duma deputy Mr P.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the applicant, those remaining at Pushkinskaya Square on 5 March 2012 remained peacefully within the pedestrian area of the square and did not obstruct the traffic or access.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant was holding an irregular gathering at Pushkinskaya Square on 5 March 2012 without prior notification and was shouting political slogans.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "At 10.45 p.m. on 5 March 2012 the police arrived at Pushkinskaya Square and arrested the applicant, among many others.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "After his arrest on 5 March 2012, the applicant was taken to the Tverskoy District police station.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On the evening of 5 March 2012 two policemen drew up a report on the administrative offence stating that the applicant had been arrested at 10.45 p.m. 'in a fountain' at Pushkinskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The administrative offence report drawn up on 5 March 2012 stated that the applicant had taken part in an irregular public gathering.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The administrative offence report drawn up on 5 March 2012 stated that the applicant had ignored police orders to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant was charged with a breach of the established procedure for conducting public events, an offence under Article 20 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation, in connection with the events of 5 March 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant was released at 12.15 a.m. on 6 March 2012 following his arrest on 5 March 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 15 March 2012 the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District examined the administrative charges against the applicant arising from the events of 5 March 2012.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant challenged the authenticity of the police reports and the witness statement of the two police officers on the grounds that he had been arrested by different police officers from those who drew up the reports.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant's objection challenging the authenticity of the police reports and witness statements was dismissed by the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On the basis of the written statements and testimony of two police officers, the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District found the applicant guilty of taking part in an irregular public gathering conducted without prior notification.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 369 of the Tverskoy District fined the applicant RUB 1,000 (equivalent at the material time to about EUR 25) under Article 20 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 10 April 2012 the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow examined the applicant's appeal against the judgment of 15 March 2012.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant was absent from the appeal hearing on 10 April 2012 before the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow, but was represented by a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "At the appeal hearing on 10 April 2012, the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow questioned one further eyewitness, a journalist.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The journalist eyewitness testified at the appeal hearing on 10 April 2012 that before being arrested the applicant was standing 'in a fountain, holding hands with others' and chanting political slogans.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The journalist eyewitness testified at the appeal hearing on 10 April 2012 that the police officers who had placed the applicant in the police bus were the same officers who had signed the report and who had appeared at the first-instance hearing.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow examined two video recordings submitted by the applicant at the appeal hearing on 10 April 2012.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow found at the appeal hearing on 10 April 2012 that State Duma deputy Mr P. had indeed called a public meeting.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow concluded at the appeal hearing on 10 April 2012 that at the time of his arrest the applicant was not meeting State Duma deputy Mr P. but was participating in a protest assembly.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow upheld the judgment of 15 March 2012 at the appeal hearing on 10 April 2012.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The applicant's arrest on 5 March 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 8 May 2012 the applicant took part in an overnight 'walkabout', an informal gathering whereby activists peacefully met at a public venue to discuss current affairs.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 8 May 2012 several dozen activists met up to discuss the inauguration of Mr Vladimir Putin as President of Russia on the previous day (7 May 2012).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 8 May 2012 some areas of central Moscow were restricted for traffic due to the presidential inauguration and the Victory Day celebrations.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 8 May 2012 some areas of central Moscow were partly restricted to pedestrians due to the presidential inauguration and the Victory Day celebrations.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "At 4.30 a.m. on 8 May 2012, according to the applicant, the applicant was walking down Lubyanskiy Proyezd accompanied by about 170 people.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "At 4 a.m. on 8 May 2012, according to the Government, the applicant was walking down Lubyanskiy Proyezd accompanied by about 170 people.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 8 May 2012 the group walking down Lubyanskiy Proyezd stopped on the stairs of a public building for a group photograph.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 8 May 2012, while the applicant was taking a group photograph on the stairs of a public building on Lubyanskiy Proyezd, he was arrested by riot police.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "At 8 a.m. on 8 May 2012 the applicant was taken to a police station following his first arrest that day, where an administrative offence report was drawn up.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The applicant was charged with a breach of the established procedure for conducting public events, an offence under Article 20 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation, in connection with the events at Lubyanskiy Proyezd on 8 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The applicant was released at 10.50 a.m. on 8 May 2012 following his first arrest that day.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "At 11.55 p.m. on 8 May 2012, according to the Government, the applicant was walking down Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street in a cluster of about fifty people.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "At 11 p.m. on 8 May 2012, according to the applicant, the applicant was walking down Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street in a cluster of about fifty people.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "According to the applicant, the group walking down Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street on 8 May 2012 stayed on the pavement, had no banners or sound equipment, and were causing no nuisance.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 8 May 2012 on Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street the group was surrounded by riot police and the applicant was arrested without any order or warning.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "At 11.58 p.m. on 8 May 2012 the applicant was taken to a police station following his second arrest that day, where an administrative offence report was drawn up.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicant was charged with a breach of the established procedure for conducting public events, an offence under Article 20 § 2 (2) of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation, in connection with the events at Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street on 8 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicant was released at 2.50 a.m. on 9 May 2012 following his second arrest on 8 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 30 May 2012 the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District examined the charges concerning the applicant's administrative offence at Lubyanskiy Proyezd on 8 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The applicant was absent from the proceedings on 30 May 2012 before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District, but was represented by his lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The applicant's lawyer disputed the applicant's participation in an irregular assembly at Lubyanskiy Proyezd and claimed that the applicant had not chanted any slogans.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicant's lawyer asked the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District to admit video evidence and to examine certain eyewitnesses, but she refused to do so.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On the basis of written statements by two police officers, the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District found the applicant guilty of taking part in a meeting conducted before 7 a.m., in breach of regulations.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District fined the applicant RUB 1,000 under Article 20 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation in connection with the events at Lubyanskiy Proyezd on 8 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The judgment of the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District concerning the Lubyanskiy Proyezd incident was delivered in full on 1 June 2012.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The judgment of the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District concerning the Lubyanskiy Proyezd incident was upheld on 6 July 2012 by the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 1 June 2012 the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 380 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow examined the administrative charges concerning the applicant's administrative offence at Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street on 8 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The applicant was absent from the proceedings on 1 June 2012 before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 380 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow, but was represented by his lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The applicant's lawyer disputed the applicant's participation in an irregular assembly at Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street and claimed that the applicant had not chanted any slogans.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 380 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow questioned three eyewitnesses and the police officer who had arrested the applicant at Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The police officer who arrested the applicant at Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street testified that he had arrested the applicant because the applicant was walking in a big group of people, obstructing traffic and chanting political slogans.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The eyewitnesses at the hearing on 1 June 2012 testified that the applicant had been walking down Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street with about fifty or sixty people.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The eyewitnesses at the hearing on 1 June 2012 testified that the police had blocked the group's way on Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street and had begun to arrest them without any warning.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The eyewitnesses at the hearing on 1 June 2012 denied hearing any slogans or amplified sound at Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 380 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow refused to admit video evidence in the proceedings concerning the Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street incident.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 380 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow dismissed the eyewitness statements on the grounds that the eyewitnesses were likely to be the applicant's supporters and were therefore biased.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The applicant was found guilty by the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 380 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow of taking part in a meeting conducted in breach of regulations at Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street on 8 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 380 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow fined the applicant RUB 1,000 under Article 20 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation in connection with the Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street incident.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The judgment of the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 380 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow concerning the Bolshaya Nikitskaya Street incident was upheld on 25 June 2012 by the Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's two arrests on 8 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 9 May 2012 the applicant arrived at 5 a.m. at Kudrinskaya Square in Moscow to take part in an informal meeting with a State Duma deputy.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 9 May 2012 the applicant arrived at Kudrinskaya Square in Moscow to attend the Victory Day celebrations.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 9 May 2012 at Kudrinskaya Square the applicant was among 50 to 100 people peacefully 'walking about' and discussing current affairs.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "According to the applicant, the gathering at Kudrinskaya Square on 9 May 2012 was not a demonstration: there had been no banners and no noise, and no one was chanting slogans or giving speeches.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "At 6 a.m. on 9 May 2012 riot police arrived at Kudrinskaya Square and arrested the applicant without issuing any orders or warning.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The applicant submitted a video recording of his arrest at Kudrinskaya Square on 9 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "At 8.50 a.m. on 9 May 2012 the applicant was taken to the Strogino District police station.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "At 11.50 a.m. on 9 May 2012 the applicant was searched at the Strogino District police station and an administrative offence report was drawn up.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "According to the applicant, he was detained at the Strogino District police station for more than three hours before being brought before a Justice of the Peace on 9 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Government confirmed that the applicant had been detained pending trial following his arrest on 9 May 2012, but did not specify the duration.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "At an unidentified time on 9 May 2012 the applicant was brought before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 375 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 375 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow refused the applicant's request that the police officers who had arrested him be called and examined.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 375 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow refused the applicant's request that video evidence be admitted.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 375 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow granted the applicant's request for examination of three eyewitnesses.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The three eyewitnesses at the hearing before the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 375 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow testified that there had been a public meeting with a State Duma deputy at Kudrinskaya Square on 9 May 2012 to discuss current political developments.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The three eyewitnesses testified that no one at Kudrinskaya Square on 9 May 2012 had chanted slogans or made noise or obstructed traffic.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The three eyewitnesses testified that the police had not issued any orders or warnings before arresting the applicant at Kudrinskaya Square on 9 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "On the basis of the written statements of two police officers, the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 375 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow established that the applicant had taken part in an irregular public meeting at Kudrinskaya Square on 9 May 2012 and had disobeyed a lawful order from the police to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 375 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow found that the applicant had chanted the slogans 'Russia without Putin!' and 'Putin is a thief!' at Kudrinskaya Square on 9 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 375 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow found that the applicant had refused to leave Kudrinskaya Square, which needed to be cleared for the Victory Day celebrations.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 375 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow rejected the statements of the three eyewitnesses on the grounds that they had given different estimates of the number of people present at Kudrinskaya Square, the number of police officers who arrested the applicant, and the time of his arrival at the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The applicant was found guilty by the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 375 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow of disobeying the lawful order of the police, in breach of Article 19 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation, in connection with the events at Kudrinskaya Square on 9 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to fifteen days' administrative imprisonment by the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 375 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow in connection with the events at Kudrinskaya Square on 9 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "On 10 May 2012 the applicant lodged an appeal against the judgment of the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 375 of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On 12 December 2012 the Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow examined the applicant's appeal against the judgment of 9 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "At the appeal hearing on 12 December 2012, the applicant asked for the police officers on whose reports and statements the Justice of the Peace had based the judgment of 9 May 2012 to be cross-examined.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "At the appeal hearing on 12 December 2012, the applicant asked for eight eyewitnesses to be examined.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "At the appeal hearing on 12 December 2012, the applicant asked for the video recording of his arrest at Kudrinskaya Square on 9 May 2012 to be admitted as evidence.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow dismissed the applicant's requests for cross-examination of police officers, examination of eight eyewitnesses, and admission of the video recording at the appeal hearing on 12 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow upheld the judgment of 9 May 2012 at the appeal hearing on 12 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The applicant's arrest on 9 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "On 27 October 2012 the applicant held a static demonstration ('picket', пикетирование) at Lubyanskaya Square in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The static demonstration at Lubyanskaya Square on 27 October 2012 was part of a series of peaceful pickets held in Moscow in front of the buildings housing the Federal Security Service and the Russian Investigation Committee to protest 'against repressions and torture'.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "According to the applicant, his demonstration at Lubyanskaya Square on 27 October 2012 was a solo picket (одиночное пикетирование) which was not subject to a prior notification to the competent public authority.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "In total, about thirty people consecutively took part in the picket event at Lubyanskaya Square on 27 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "At 3.30 p.m. on 27 October 2012 the police arrested the applicant at 9 Maroseyka Street when he was walking down the street accompanied by a group of people.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "According to the applicant, at the moment of his arrest on 27 October 2012 he had finished picketing and was peacefully walking along the pavement; he was not chanting or carrying any banners, but was being followed by a group of people, including journalists, whose number he estimated as 'two dozen'.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant had organised an irregular march on 27 October 2012 without prior notification.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The applicant was taken to the police station at 4.10 p.m. on 27 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The applicant was charged with a breach of the established procedure for conducting public events, an offence under Article 20 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation, in connection with the events of 27 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The applicant was released at 7.17 p.m. on 27 October 2012 following his arrest that day.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "On 30 October 2012 the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District examined the charges arising from the applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District examined three eyewitnesses called at the applicant's request in the proceedings concerning the events of 27 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District refused the applicant's request that the police officers who had arrested him on 27 October 2012 be called and examined.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The applicant's request that a video recording of the events of 27 October 2012 be admitted as evidence was refused by the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The applicant's request that a written report from an NGO which had observed the pickets on 27 October 2012 be admitted in evidence was refused by the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The three eyewitnesses examined at the applicant's request testified that after ending his picket on 27 October 2012, the applicant had walked down the street while speaking with a fellow activist, surrounded by journalists; he remained on the pavement, did not chant slogans, and carried no banners.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The three eyewitnesses testified that several other participants in the picket on 27 October 2012 remained standing with their banners, at a certain distance from each other.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The three eyewitnesses testified that the police arrested the applicant on 27 October 2012 without any warning or explanation.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "On the basis of written reports by two police officers, the Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District established that the applicant had organised and led a group of thirty people on 27 October 2012, thus holding a march without the approval of the local authorities.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District established that the group on 27 October 2012 was heading from Lubyanskaya Square to Lefortovo detention facility.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District established that at 9 Maroseyka Street on 27 October 2012 the group had obstructed the road, thus halting traffic.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District dismissed the witness statements in the applicant's favour on the grounds that they contradicted the evidence in the case file.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District found the applicant guilty of taking part in a march which had not been duly notified to the authorities on 27 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of Circuit no. 387 of the Basmannyy District fined the applicant RUB 30,000 (equivalent at the material time to about EUR 740) under Article 20 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation in connection with the events of 27 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "On 7 December 2012 the Basmannyy District Court upheld the judgment of 30 October 2012 concerning the applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. The applicant's arrest on 27 October 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "On 24 February 2014 at 12 noon the applicant went to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow to attend a hearing involving activists who were on trial for participation in mass disorders at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The judgment in the Bolotnaya Square mass disorders case was to be delivered at a public hearing on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "On 24 February 2014 the court-house of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow was cordoned off and obstructed by police vans, and the applicant was unable to enter.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "On 24 February 2014 the applicant remained outside the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow among other members of the public wishing to attend the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "According to the applicant, on 24 February 2014 he was standing silently outside the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow when the police suddenly rushed into the crowd and arrested him, without any order, warning or pretext.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "According to the official version, on 24 February 2014 outside the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow the applicant was holding an irregular gathering and chanting political slogans.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "At 12.50 p.m. on 24 February 2014 the applicant was taken to a police station following his first arrest that day.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "The applicant was charged with a breach of the established procedure for conducting public events, an offence under Article 20 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation, in connection with the events outside the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "The applicant was released at 3 p.m. on 24 February 2014 following his first arrest that day.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "At about 7.45 p.m. on 24 February 2014 the applicant took part in a peaceful public gathering following the delivery of the judgment in respect of mass disorders at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The judgment in the Bolotnaya Square mass disorders case resulted in several activists being sentenced to prison terms.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The gathering on 24 February 2014 at about 7.45 p.m. had about 150 participants and took place at Tverskaya Street.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "On 24 February 2014 at Tverskaya Street the applicant was arrested while he was standing on the pavement talking to a journalist.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "According to the applicant, he had received no order or warning before his second arrest on 24 February 2014 at Tverskaya Street, and he did not resist the police.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "According to the police report, when the applicant was being seated in the police vehicle on 24 February 2014 he was waving at the crowd and trying to attract media attention, thus demonstrating a refusal to comply with the police order and resisting the officers in the performance of their duties.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "At 8.20 p.m. on 24 February 2014 the applicant was taken to the Tverskoy District police station following his second arrest that day, where an administrative offence report was drawn up.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "The applicant was charged with disobeying a lawful order of the police, an offence under Article 19 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation, in connection with the events at Tverskaya Street on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The applicant was detained on remand following his second arrest on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "On 25 February 2014 at an unidentified time the applicant was brought before the judge of the Tverskoy District Court, who examined the charges under Article 19 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation arising from the events at Tverskaya Street on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "The applicant's request for two eyewitnesses to be examined at the hearing on 25 February 2014 before the Tverskoy District Court was granted.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The two eyewitnesses at the hearing on 25 February 2014 testified that the police had not given the applicant any orders or warnings before proceeding to arrest him at Tverskaya Street on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court admitted and examined the video recording of the contested events at Tverskaya Street on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court questioned the two police officers on whose reports the charges arising from the events at Tverskaya Street on 24 February 2014 were based.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court established that the applicant had taken part in an irregular meeting at Tverskaya Street on 24 February 2014 and had disobeyed the lawful order of the police to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The applicant was found guilty by the Tverskoy District Court of disobeying a lawful order of the police, in breach of Article 19 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation, in connection with the events at Tverskaya Street on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to seven days' administrative imprisonment by the Tverskoy District Court in connection with the events at Tverskaya Street on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "On 7 March 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court examined the charges relating to the applicant's alleged participation on 24 February 2014 in an unauthorised public gathering in front of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The applicant requested that two eyewitnesses present at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow on 24 February 2014 be examined at the hearing on 7 March 2014.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The applicant requested that the two policemen on whose reports the charges arising from the events outside the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow on 24 February 2014 were based be examined at the hearing on 7 March 2014.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court dismissed the applicant's requests for examination of two eyewitnesses and two policemen at the hearing on 7 March 2014.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court admitted a video recording of the contested events outside the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow on 24 February 2014, but decided not to take cognisance of its contents because it was undated and because it had not reproduced the full sequence of events.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "On the basis of the written reports by two police officers, the judge of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court found the applicant guilty of taking part in a meeting on 24 February 2014 which had not been notified to the competent authority in accordance with the procedure provided by law.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court fined the applicant RUB 10,000 (equivalent to about EUR 200) under Article 20 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation in connection with the events outside the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "On 24 March 2014 the Moscow City Court upheld the judgment of 25 February 2014 of the Tverskoy District Court concerning the events at Tverskaya Street on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "On 22 May 2014 the Moscow City Court upheld the judgment of 7 March 2014 of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court concerning the events outside the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The applicant's two arrests on 24 February 2014"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law, the Court refers to Kasparov and Others v. Russia (no. 21613/07, § 35, 3 October 2013).", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law, the Court refers to Navalnyy and Yashin v. Russia (no. 76204/11, §§ 43-44, 4 December 2014).", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law, the Court refers to Novikova and Others v. Russia (nos. 25501/07 and 4 others, §§ 67-69, 26 April 2016).", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law, the Court refers to Lashmankin and Others v. Russia (nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, §§ 216-312, 7 February 2017).", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "Article 55 § 3 of the Russian Constitution provides that the rights and freedoms of individuals and citizens may be limited by federal law only to the extent required for the protection of the fundamental principles of the constitutional system, morality, health, the rights and lawful interests of other people, and for ensuring the defence of the country and the security of the State.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "The Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets, no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), Section 2, defines a public event as an open, peaceful action accessible to all, held in the form of a gathering, a meeting, a demonstration, a march, or a picket or in various combinations of these forms, organised at the initiative of citizens of the Russian Federation, political parties, other public associations, or religious associations, including events held with the use of vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "The Public Events Act, Section 2, provides that the aim of a public event is the free expression and formation of opinions, and to put forward demands on issues of political, economic, social and cultural life in the country, as well as issues of foreign policy.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "The Public Events Act, Section 3, provides that a public event is based on the principle of legality, meaning compliance with the provisions of the Russian Constitution, the Public Events Act, and other legislative acts of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "The Public Events Act, Section 5 § 4, provides that the organiser of a public event must notify the executive or municipal authority of the public event in accordance with Section 7 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "The Public Events Act, Section 7, provides that notification of a public event (except for a gathering and a picket held by a solo participant) must be filed in writing by its organiser with the executive or municipal authority no earlier than fifteen days and no later than ten days before the date of the public event.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "The Public Events Act, Section 16, provides that the grounds for ending a public event include: the emergence of a genuine threat to citizens' lives or health, and to the possessions of physical or legal persons; commission by the participants of unlawful acts or a deliberate breach by the organiser of the requirements on the procedure for the conduct of public events; and (following legislative amendments of 8 June 2012) non-compliance by the organisers with the obligations set out in Section 5 § 4 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "The Public Events Act, Section 17 § 1, provides that if it is decided to end the public event, the representative of the executive or municipal authority shall give an order to the organiser to end the public event, having explained the reasons for its termination, and within twenty-four hours shall issue this order in writing and serve it on the organiser; shall set the time for compliance with the order; and if the organiser does not comply, shall directly address the participants and set an additional time for compliance.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "The Public Events Act, Section 17 § 2, provides that in the event of non-compliance with the order to end the public event, the police shall take the necessary measures to end the public event.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "The Public Events Act, Section 17 § 3, provides that the procedure for ending a public event set out in Section 17 § 1 shall not apply in the event of mass disorder, mob violence, arson, or other situations requiring urgent action.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "The Public Events Act, Section 17 § 4, provides that failure to obey lawful orders from police officers or resistance to them by certain participants of the public event may incur liability as provided for by law.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "The Public Events Act, Section 18 § 1, provides that the organiser of a public event, officials and other citizens shall not be entitled to prevent the participants in a public event from expressing their opinions in a manner that does not violate public order and the procedure for holding a public event.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "Prior to 8 June 2012, Article 19 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that failure to obey a lawful order or demand of a police officer in connection with the performance of their official duties related to maintaining public order and security, or impeding the performance by them of their official duties, shall be punishable by a fine of between RUB 500 and RUB 1,000 or by administrative imprisonment of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "Prior to 8 June 2012, Article 20 § 2 (1) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that breaches of the established procedure for the organisation of public gatherings, meetings, demonstrations, marches or pickets shall be punishable by an administrative fine of between ten and twenty times the minimum wage, payable by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "Prior to 8 June 2012, Article 20 § 2 (2) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provided that breaches of the established procedure for the conduct of public gatherings, meetings, demonstrations, marches or pickets shall be punishable by an administrative fine of between RUB 1,000 and RUB 2,000 for the organisers, and between RUB 500 and RUB 1,000 for the participants.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "Article 27 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the transfer of an individual to a police station for the purpose of drawing up an administrative offence report, if this cannot be done at the place where the offence was discovered and if the drawing up of a report is mandatory, shall be carried out by the police, and the transfer operation shall be carried out as quickly as possible.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "Article 27 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the transfer shall be recorded in a transfer operation report, an administrative offence report or an administrative detention report, and the transferred person shall be given a copy of the transfer operation report if he or she so requests.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "Article 27 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that administrative detention or short-term restriction of an individual's liberty may be applied in exceptional cases if this is necessary for the prompt and proper examination of the alleged administrative offence or to secure the enforcement of any penalty imposed by a judgment concerning an administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "Article 27 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that where the detained person so requests, his or her family, the administrative department at his or her place of work or study and his or her defence counsel shall be informed of his or her whereabouts.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "Article 27 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the detained person shall have his or her rights and obligations under the Code explained to him or her, and the corresponding entry shall be made in the administrative arrest report.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "Article 27 § 4 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that administrative detention shall be recorded in a report, and if he or she so requests, the detained person shall be given a copy of the administrative detention report.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "Article 27 § 5 (1) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the duration of administrative detention shall not exceed three hours, except in the cases set out in paragraphs 2 and 3 of that Article.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "Article 27 § 5 (2) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that persons subject to administrative proceedings concerning offences involving unlawful crossing of the Russian border may be subject to administrative detention for up to 48 hours.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "Article 27 § 5 (3) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that persons subject to administrative proceedings concerning offences which are punishable, among other administrative sanctions, by administrative imprisonment may be subject to administrative detention for up to 48 hours.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "Article 27 § 5 (4) of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the term of administrative detention is calculated from the time when a person transferred in accordance with Article 27 § 2 is taken to the police station, and in respect of a person in a state of alcoholic intoxication, from the time of his sobering up.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "On 8 June 2012 the Code of Administrative Offences was amended by Law no. 65-FZ.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "Following the amendments of 8 June 2012 (Law no. 65-FZ), a breach of the procedure for organising or running a public event by an organiser became punishable by a fine of between RUB 10,000 and RUB 20,000 or up to forty hours of community work under Article 20 § 2 (1) of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "Following the amendments of 8 June 2012 (Law no. 65-FZ), the organisation or running of a public event without notifying the competent public authority became punishable by a fine of between RUB 20,000 and RUB 30,000 or up to fifty hours of community work under Article 20 § 2 (2) of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "Following the amendments of 8 June 2012 (Law no. 65-FZ), stricter penalties were introduced under Article 20 § 2 (3 and 4) of the Code of Administrative Offences for the above actions or inaction where they obstructed pedestrians or traffic, or caused damage to health or property.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "Following the amendments of 8 June 2012 (Law no. 65-FZ), separate offences were introduced under Article 20 § 2 (5) and (6) of the Code of Administrative Offences concerning violations by an event participant of the procedure for running the event, and where such violations caused damage to health or property.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "Following the amendments of 8 June 2012 (Law no. 65-FZ), Article 4.5 of the Code of Administrative Offences was amended to increase the limitation period for the offence under Article 20 § 2 from two months to one year.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F205", "text": "On 26 June 2018 the Plenary of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation adopted the Resolution 'On certain questions arising during judicial examination of administrative cases and cases on administrative offences related to the application of the legislation on public events'.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F206", "text": "The Supreme Court Resolution of 26 June 2018 indicated that an organiser's failure to notify a public event was to be classified under Article 20 § 2 (2-4) of the Code of Administrative Offences, whereas the holding of a public event which had been refused by the authorities constituted an offence on the part of the organiser under Article 20 § 2 (1) of the Code (§§ 28-29 of the Supreme Court Resolution).", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F207", "text": "The Supreme Court Resolution of 26 June 2018 indicated that the failure by a participant in a public event to comply with lawful orders or instructions of the police was to be classified under Article 20 § 2 (5) of the Code of Administrative Offences, which was in these circumstances to be regarded as a lex specialis in relation to Article 19 § 3 (1) of the Code (§ 33 of the Resolution).", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F208", "text": "The Supreme Court Resolution of 26 June 2018 indicated that the concept of a non-authorised event included events conducted without notification as well as events in respect of which the competent authorities had rejected the notification.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F209", "text": "The Supreme Court Resolution of 26 June 2018 indicated that transfer to a police station for the purpose of drawing up an administrative offence report and/or administrative detention in exceptional cases would be justified only if it was otherwise impossible to identify the committed offence, to establish the identity of the offender, to examine the case concerning the administrative offence correctly and in a timely manner or to enforce the administrative sentence (§ 40 of the Resolution).", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F210", "text": "The Supreme Court Resolution of 26 June 2018 indicated that administrative detention could be justified by a demonstrated risk of the perpetrator resuming the unlawful acts or absconding, by the absence of a fixed residence, or by the need to carry out procedural acts or to secure the evidence (§ 40 of the Resolution).", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F211", "text": "At the date of adoption of the present judgment, the Council of Europe's Committee of Ministers is continuing its supervision of the pending execution of the judgment in Lashmankin and Others v. Russia (nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, 7 February 2017).", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F212", "text": "At the 1318th meeting of the Committee of Ministers (June 2018, DH), a decision was adopted (CM/Del/Dec(2018)1318/H46-21) regarding general measures in the execution of the judgment in Lashmankin and Others v. Russia.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F213", "text": "The decision adopted at the 1318th meeting of the Committee of Ministers (June 2018) recalled the Council of Europe's readiness, recently expressed by the Secretary General, to assist the Russian Federation in the work to improve its legislation in the field of freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F214", "text": "The decision adopted at the 1318th meeting of the Committee of Ministers (June 2018) noted, as regards judicial practice, a number of positive developments in the form of a series of decisions from the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation over the last years, including an overview of the practice of international bodies and the case-law of the Court concerning freedom of assembly prepared by the Supreme Court.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F215", "text": "The decision adopted at the 1318th meeting of the Committee of Ministers (June 2018) noted the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation's ongoing efforts to adopt further guidance to domestic courts on certain issues arising in administrative cases and administrative offences cases regarding the application of the legislation governing the procedure for the organisation and the holding of public events, and encouraged these developments.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F216", "text": "The decision adopted at the 1318th meeting of the Committee of Ministers (June 2018) stressed the need to rapidly adopt additional measures, whether in the form of regulations or training and awareness raising measures, to ensure that the practice of relevant municipal authorities and the police, including as regards the use of force, the dispersal of public events and the arrest of participants, is brought into line with the requirements of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F217", "text": "The decision adopted at the 1318th meeting of the Committee of Ministers (June 2018) highlighted the potential interest of the wide dissemination of the guidelines prepared by the Venice Commission and the OSCE (CDL-AD(2014)046, available also in Russian).", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F218", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights issued a Follow-up Memorandum on Freedom of Assembly in the Russian Federation, dated 5 September 2017.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F219", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Follow-up Memorandum of 5 September 2017 stated that ensuring the safety of participants and public order is a legitimate consideration, but this should not translate into a lack of tolerance towards peaceful public events which have not been agreed with the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F220", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Follow-up Memorandum of 5 September 2017 stated that the 2012 amendments to the Russian legislation on assemblies gave broad grounds for the dispersal of public events, including any irregularities in the organisation or the conduct of public events, some of which are not clearly defined in law.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F221", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Follow-up Memorandum of 5 September 2017 noted that one of the concerns about the 2012 amendments expressed by the Presidential Council was the lack of clarity in terms of which actions or omissions can trigger administrative liability.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F222", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Follow-up Memorandum of 5 September 2017 noted that earlier clarifications by the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation that there must be compelling public order considerations to make holding a public event impossible seem to have had little effect in practice.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F223", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Follow-up Memorandum of 5 September 2017 cited as a notable example the violent dispersal and arrests of hundreds of protesters during a spontaneous but peaceful gathering on the occasion of the verdict in the Bolotnaya case in February 2014, because of the absence of a prior authorisation from the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F224", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Follow-up Memorandum of 5 September 2017 reported a growing intolerance towards unauthorised public events involving relatively low numbers of peaceful participants, including even single-person pickets which are formally exempt from the agreement procedure.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F225", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Follow-up Memorandum of 5 September 2017 cited as an example the apprehension and escort to a police station of six activists for reading the Russian Constitution aloud in front of the State Duma on 12 September 2016.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F226", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Follow-up Memorandum of 5 September 2017 cited as an example the reportedly violent arrest in Beslan and imposition of community service upon five mothers of victims of the September 2004 terrorist attack, who wished to commemorate its 12th anniversary while wearing t-shirts with inscriptions critical of the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F227", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Follow-up Memorandum of 5 September 2017 cited as an example the apprehension of separate solo picketers, including minors, demonstrating with blank sheets of paper and duct-taped mouths in Moscow on 1 July 2017.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F228", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Follow-up Memorandum of 5 September 2017 cited as an example the apprehension of four animal rights activists picketing at a distance of 50 metres from one another in Ekaterinburg on 7 June 2017.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F229", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Follow-up Memorandum of 5 September 2017 stated that the need to maintain public order should not be interpreted in such a way as to strip the right to freedom of peaceful assembly of its meaning.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F230", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Follow-up Memorandum of 5 September 2017 stated that according to international standards, if the domestic legal framework foresees a notification procedure, its objective should be to allow State authorities the opportunity to facilitate the exercise of the right to freedom of assembly, and that failure to notify the authorities of an assembly does not render it unlawful and should not be used as a basis for dispersing it.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F231", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights' Follow-up Memorandum of 5 September 2017 welcomed the initiative of the Human Rights Council to prepare amendments to the legal framework governing public events in co-operation with the National Guard, and supported the statements made by the Federal Ombudsman and the Ombudsman of St Petersburg regarding the need to reinforce the right to freedom of assembly and safeguards against arbitrary application of restrictive measures.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F232", "text": "The preparatory work on Article 18 of the Convention (Collected edition of the 'Travaux Préparatoires' of the European Convention on Human Rights, Martinus Nijhoff, vol. IV, 1977, pp. 130, 179-181 and 955) states that the international collective guarantee has as its purpose to ensure that no State shall aim at suppressing the guaranteed freedom by means of minor measures which, while made with the pretext of organising the exercise of freedoms or safeguarding the letter of the law, have the opposite effect.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PREPARATORY WORKS"]}, {"fact_id": "F233", "text": "The preparatory work on Article 18 of the Convention states that it is legitimate and necessary to limit, sometimes even to restrain, individual freedoms to allow everyone the peaceful exercise of their freedom and to ensure the maintenance of morality, of the general well-being, of the common good and of public need.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PREPARATORY WORKS"]}, {"fact_id": "F234", "text": "The preparatory work on Article 18 of the Convention states that when the State defines, organises, regulates and limits freedoms in the interest of the general well-being, it is only fulfilling its duty and such action is permissible and legitimate.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PREPARATORY WORKS"]}, {"fact_id": "F235", "text": "The preparatory work on Article 18 of the Convention states that when the State intervenes to suppress, restrain and limit freedoms for reasons of state, to protect itself against an opposition it considers dangerous, or to destroy fundamental freedoms it ought to guarantee, then it acts against public interest and the laws it passes are contrary to the principle of international guarantee.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PREPARATORY WORKS"]}, {"fact_id": "F236", "text": "The preparatory work on Article 18 of the Convention states that every State which violates human rights and above all the rights of freedom will always have an excuse, such as morality, order, public security and democratic rights.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PREPARATORY WORKS"]}, {"fact_id": "F237", "text": "The preparatory work on Article 18 of the Convention states that in a democracy, the limitation imposed on individual freedom will be valid only if it has as its aim the public interest and the common good, and that the State may limit an individual freedom in the interests of the freedom of all, in the general interest of a superior freedom of right, in the public interest of the nation.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "IV. PREPARATORY WORKS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F015", "F016", "F018", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F052", "F053", "F054", "F080", "F081", "F082", "F083", "F110", "F111", "F112", "F113", "F114", "F115", "F116", "F128", "F129", "F135", "F136", "F137", "F138", "F139", "F144", "F145", "F146", "F147", "F175", "F176", "F179"], "interference": ["F020", "F021", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F030", "F031", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F055", "F056", "F057", "F084", "F086", "F087", "F101", "F102", "F114", "F117", "F118", "F133", "F141", "F142", "F143", "F147", "F150", "F151", "F152", "F159", "F160", "F167"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F020", "F021", "F048", "F049", "F055", "F056", "F084", "F086", "F087", "F110", "F114", "F115", "F116", "F135", "F136", "F137", "F138", "F175", "F176", "F178", "F179", "F180", "F181", "F182", "F186", "F187", "F188", "F199", "F200", "F201", "F202", "F203"], "legitimate_aim": ["F018", "F041", "F054", "F083", "F110", "F114", "F115", "F116", "F125", "F135", "F136", "F137", "F138", "F139", "F140", "F144", "F146", "F147"], "necessity": ["F015", "F016", "F018", "F020", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F030", "F031", "F041", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F050", "F052", "F053", "F054", "F055", "F057", "F063", "F064", "F078", "F080", "F082", "F083", "F084", "F097", "F101", "F102", "F133", "F144", "F145", "F146", "F147", "F151", "F158", "F159", "F160", "F167", "F170", "F171", "F172", "F173", "F175", "F179", "F180", "F181", "F182"], "positive_obligation": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F102", "F160", "F170", "F171", "F172", "F173", "F199", "F200", "F201", "F202", "F203"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F009", "F012", "F015", "F016", "F018", "F041", "F042", "F045", "F052", "F054", "F080", "F082", "F083", "F110", "F114", "F115", "F135", "F136", "F137", "F138", "F144", "F145", "F146", "F147"], "interference": ["F020", "F025", "F030", "F031", "F048", "F050", "F055", "F057", "F084", "F101", "F102", "F114", "F118", "F133", "F141", "F142", "F147", "F151", "F152", "F159", "F160", "F167"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F110", "F114", "F115", "F116", "F135", "F137", "F138", "F175", "F179", "F180", "F181", "F182", "F186", "F187", "F188", "F199", "F200", "F201"], "legitimate_aim": ["F110", "F114", "F115", "F125", "F135", "F136", "F137", "F138", "F139", "F018", "F041", "F054", "F083", "F144", "F146", "F147"], "necessity": ["F018", "F020", "F023", "F024", "F030", "F031", "F041", "F045", "F048", "F052", "F054", "F055", "F063", "F080", "F082", "F083", "F084", "F097", "F102", "F144", "F145", "F146", "F147", "F158", "F159", "F160", "F175", "F179", "F180"], "positive_obligation": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F102", "F160", "F199", "F200", "F201"]}, "list3": ["F018", "F020", "F023", "F030", "F041", "F048", "F054", "F055", "F083", "F084", "F102", "F110", "F114", "F115", "F135", "F136", "F137", "F138", "F144", "F145", "F147", "F158", "F159", "F160", "F175", "F179", "F180", "F003", "F004", "F005", "F006"]}} {"case_name": "case_461", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of nationwide protests against the Russian military attack on Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of nationwide protests against the Russian military attack on Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_462", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of country-wide protests against corruption.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The country-wide protests against corruption were organised by Aleksey Navalnyy.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The country-wide protests against corruption organised by Aleksey Navalnyy took place on 26 March 2017.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The complaints regarding disproportionate measures taken against organisers or participants of the protests are referenced in Navalnyy and Others v. Russia [Committee], application nos. 25809/17 and 14 others, § 2, judgment of 4 October 2022.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention and the Protocols thereto.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F004"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F004"]}} {"case_name": "case_463", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_464", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1959.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant is a professional politician.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant held in the past the post of Nizhniy Novgorod governor.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant held in the past the post of Deputy Prime Minister.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant held in the past the post of Minister for Energy.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant became one of the best-known opposition leaders in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant was a founder of the political party the Union of Right Forces.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant was subsequently a founder of the political movement Solidarnost.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 10 December 2010 eight individuals, none of whom are applicants in the present case, submitted notice of a public demonstration to the mayor of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The notice indicated that a meeting would be held from 6 p.m. to 7.30 p.m. on Triumfalnaya Square, Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The organisers estimated that about 1,500 people would take part in the event at Triumfalnaya Square on 31 December 2010.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The notice stated that the proposed demonstration was intended to demand respect for the constitutional right to peaceful demonstration and assembly guaranteed by Article 31 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The organisers indicated that it would not be necessary to divert the traffic for the proposed demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 22 December 2010 the Moscow Government's Department for Liaison with Security Authorities informed the organisers that the event had been approved by the deputy mayor of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The number of participants in the approved demonstration at Triumfalnaya Square was limited to 1,000.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "A particular sector of Triumfalnaya Square was designated for the approved event: in the area between the First and the Second Brestskaya Streets, opposite the Pekin Hotel and the adjacent road leading to the Tchaikovsky Concert Hall.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 16 December 2010 another group of three individuals, none of whom are applicants in the present case, submitted notice of an alternative public demonstration to the mayor of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The alternative public demonstration submitted on 16 December 2010 was planned at the same time and place as the authorised event and with the same title.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The second public demonstration submitted on 16 December 2010 was not authorised.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 22 December 2010 a number of alternatives as to the time and place were offered to the organisers of the second public demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "None of the organisers of the second public demonstration could go to the venue on 31 December 2010 because two of them had been arrested earlier on the same day.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The third organiser of the second public demonstration had been abroad on 31 December 2010 and could not attend the venue.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The authorised meeting began at 6 p.m. on 31 December 2010 at Triumfalnaya Square, as planned.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the applicant, the perimeter of Triumfalnaya Square was cordoned off and guarded by the riot police on 31 December 2010.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the applicant, the only access to the meeting venue at Triumfalnaya Square was at Tverskaya Street.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant claimed that he had arrived at the meeting at Triumfalnaya Square with his daughter.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant claimed that he had parked his car at Tverskaya Street.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant claimed that he and his daughter had entered Triumfalnaya Square from Tverskaya Street through the only opening in the cordon.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "During the meeting at Triumfalnaya Square on 31 December 2010, the applicant addressed the participants with a speech in which he criticised the criminal conviction of Mikhail Khodorkovskiy, the former owner of the Yukos oil company.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "During the meeting at Triumfalnaya Square on 31 December 2010, the applicant addressed the participants with a speech in which he criticised the criminal conviction of Platon Lebedev, associate of Mikhail Khodorkovskiy.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "During the meeting at Triumfalnaya Square on 31 December 2010, the applicant condemned the corruption in the State administration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "During the meeting at Triumfalnaya Square on 31 December 2010, the applicant chanted the slogan \"The authorities to resign!\".", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "During the meeting at Triumfalnaya Square on 31 December 2010, the applicant chanted the slogan \"Putin to resign!\".", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "During the meeting at Triumfalnaya Square on 31 December 2010, the applicant chanted the slogan \"Happy New Year without Putin!\".", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "At the end of the meeting at Triumfalnaya Square on 31 December 2010, the applicant, accompanied by his daughter, headed across Triumfalnaya Square towards Tverskaya Street.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "At the exit from Triumfalnaya Square, the applicant saw the riot police arresting one of the participants in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Shortly after seeing the riot police arrest a participant, the applicant was also arrested and put into a police vehicle.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The parties disagreed as to the circumstances of the applicant's arrest on 31 December 2010.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicant claimed that on the way to his car his passage had been obstructed by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicant claimed that he and his daughter had found themselves in a crowd when his passage was obstructed by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicant claimed that he heard a police instruction over a loudspeaker calling for people to stay calm and to pass through.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The applicant claimed that he saw two people being arrested and put in police vans before he was arrested.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant claimed that he was arrested without any warning or explanation.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant claimed that he had not disobeyed or resisted the police and had followed their instructions to pass through.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicant claimed that he had been arrested by an officer who had been wearing a fur hat, an indication of higher rank, as opposed to the crash helmets worn by the riot police troops guarding the cordon.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant alleged that there existed at least three video recordings of his arrest, including the events immediately leading up to it.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant alleged that two of the video recordings of his arrest had been produced by two media channels.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicant alleged that one of the video recordings of his arrest had been produced by an independent photographer, Mr T.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The applicant maintained that there existed an official video of the public demonstration and the ensuing arrests, which had allegedly been shot by the police and kept at the Moscow Department of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "According to the Government, at the end of the meeting at Triumfalnaya Square on 31 December 2010, the applicant had headed towards Tverskaya Street and had begun calling passers-by to take part in another, unauthorised, meeting while shouting out anti-government slogans.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Government alleged that two police officers, Sergeant X and Private Y, had warned the applicant and ordered him to stop agitating the crowd and to return to the authorised meeting.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Government contended that the applicant had ignored the warning from Sergeant X and Private Y and had continued shouting out slogans and disobeying the police.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Government contended that Sergeant X and Private Y arrested the applicant after he ignored their warning and continued shouting slogans and disobeying the police.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "At 7 p.m. on 31 December 2010 the applicant was taken to the police station of the Tverskoy District Department of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "At 7.10 p.m. on 31 December 2010, Private Y drew up a report stating that the applicant had been escorted to the Tverskoy District Department of the Interior police station in order to draw up the administrative material.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "At 7.10 p.m. on 31 December 2010, the on-duty police officer at the Tverskoy District Department of the Interior drew up a report on the applicant's administrative arrest under Article 27.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences, stating that the applicant had been arrested in order to draw up the administrative material.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicant signed both the escort report and the administrative arrest report, indicating his disagreement with their content.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Both Sergeant X and Private Y produced identical duty reports stating that on 31 December 2010 at 18.30 Boris Yefimovich Nemtsov was apprehended because he had disobeyed a lawful order of the police in connection with Sergeant X and Private Y performing their duty of maintaining public order and safeguarding the public.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The duty reports of Sergeant X and Private Y stated that the applicant stood at 31 Tverskaya Street and began to shout \"Down with Putin!\", \"Russia without Putin!\" as well as insults to President Medvedev, catching people's attention and calling them to come to the Mayakovskiy monument for a meeting.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The duty reports of Sergeant X and Private Y stated that Sergeant X and Private Y approached the applicant, introduced themselves and warned him that it was unacceptable to hold a meeting at Triumfalnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The duty reports of Sergeant X and Private Y stated that Sergeant X and Private Y invited the applicant to proceed to the authorised event taking place between the First and the Second Brestskaya Streets, opposite the Pekin Hotel.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The duty reports of Sergeant X and Private Y stated that the applicant did not react to their requests and continued to shout out slogans and call people to hold a meeting.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The duty reports of Sergeant X and Private Y stated that the applicant deliberately refused to comply with the lawful orders to cease his actions breaching public order and continued them ostentatiously.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The duty reports of Sergeant X and Private Y stated that the applicant was invited to enter a police van to prevent him from organising an unauthorised meeting at Triumfalnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The duty reports of Sergeant X and Private Y stated that in response to the lawful orders to enter the police van, the applicant began to break loose, pushed Sergeant X and Private Y away and shouted insults: \"Down with the police state!\", \"Free-for-all cops!\", attempting to cause mayhem among the surrounding citizens.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The duty reports of Sergeant X and Private Y stated that by his conduct the applicant demonstrated his refusal to carry out the lawful order of the police and prevented them from carrying out their duty, thus committing an offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "At 7.30 p.m. on 31 December 2010, Sergeant X and Private Y made witness statements essentially copying the text of their duty reports.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "At 7.30 p.m. on 31 December 2010, the district police inspector drew up a report on the administrative offence stating that the applicant had disobeyed a lawful order of the police in breach of Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The applicant signed the administrative offence report with the remark \"100% lies\".", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 31 December 2010 the head of the Tverskoy District Department of the Interior police station issued a decision to transfer the administrative case file to the Justice of the Peace.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 31 December 2010 at about 7.15 p.m. the NTV television channel reported on the series of arrests following the demonstration at Triumfalnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Police Colonel B. commented on the applicant's arrest on the NTV television channel on 31 December 2010, stating that the applicant had been arrested for instigating an unauthorised meeting.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Public demonstration on 31 December 2010 and the applicant's arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The applicant remained in detention at the Tverskoy District Department of the Interior police station until 2 January 2011, pending the determination of the charges against him.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The applicant described the conditions of his detention at the Tverskoy District Department of the Interior police station as extremely poor.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The applicant was detained in a solitary cell measuring 1.5 by 3 metres at the Tverskoy District Department of the Interior police station.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The cell in which the applicant was detained had a concrete floor, no windows, and very bleak artificial lighting insufficient for reading.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The cell in which the applicant was detained was not equipped with ventilation or furniture, except for a narrow wooden bench without a mattress or any bedding.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The walls in the cell in which the applicant was detained had been coated with \"shuba\", a sort of abrasive concrete lining.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The cell in which the applicant was detained was not equipped with a lavatory or wash basin.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The applicant had been obliged to call the wardens to take him to the lavatory when they were available.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The applicant was not provided with food or drink by the detention facility; he received only the food and drinking water that was passed to him by his family.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Government submitted that from 31 December 2010 to 10 a.m. on 2 January 2011 the applicant had been detained in an administrative-detention cell measuring 5.6 sq. m equipped with artificial lighting and mandatory ventilation.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Government claimed that the applicant had been provided with drinking water and food, as well as with a sleeping place and bedding, but had refused to take them because he had received everything necessary from his family and friends.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 1 January 2011 two members of a public commission for the monitoring of detention facilities visited the Tverskoy District Department of the Interior police station to check the conditions of the applicant's detention.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The report of the two members of the public commission for the monitoring of detention facilities stated that the applicant had been detained in a cell without a window, which was poorly lit, lacked ventilation and had no sanitary facilities, sleeping place, mattress or bedding.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The two members of the public commission for the monitoring of detention facilities found that the cell was not adequate for a two-day confinement.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The two members of the public commission for the monitoring of detention facilities noted that the applicant had not been receiving hot food.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "On 2 January 2011, following his conviction for an administrative offence, the applicant was transferred to another detention facility until 15 January 2011.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The applicant claimed that the poor conditions of detention had had a negative impact on his health.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The applicant submitted a medical certificate indicating that between 3 and 12 January 2011 he had sought medical assistance every day.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's detention at the Tverskoy District police station"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "On 2 January 2011 the Justice of the Peace of circuit no. 369 of Tverskoy District of Moscow scheduled the hearing of the applicant's administrative case to take place on the same day.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "At 11.30 a.m. on 2 January 2011 the applicant was brought before the Justice of the Peace of circuit no. 369 of Tverskoy District of Moscow, who examined the charges.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "In the courtroom on 2 January 2011 the applicant discovered that there was no seat for him and he remained standing during the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The hearing before the Justice of the Peace on 2 January 2011 lasted for over five hours.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "According to the applicant, the Justice of the Peace had ordered him to stand throughout the hearing on 2 January 2011.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Government contested the applicant's allegation that the Justice of the Peace had ordered him to stand, and claimed that the Justice of the Peace had repeatedly asked if anyone in the audience could give their seat to the applicant, but the applicant and his counsel had objected and insisted that he remain standing.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The applicant claimed that standing throughout the trial on 2 January 2011 had been humiliating and physically difficult, especially after having spent two days in detention in poor conditions.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The applicant alleged that standing throughout the trial had prevented him from participating effectively in the proceedings because he could only address the judge in writing and had been obliged to write his submissions while standing up.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The applicant alleged that being obliged to stand throughout the trial had further aggravated his fatigue and hampered the conduct of his defence.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The applicant pleaded not guilty at the hearing before the Justice of the Peace on 2 January 2011.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The applicant claimed at the hearing that he had been detained for no reason other than political oppression.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The applicant contested the content of the police reports, in particular the statement that the police had given him a warning or an order which he could have disobeyed.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "At the hearing before the Justice of the Peace on 2 January 2011, the applicant requested that the court admit as evidence the video footage of his arrest broadcast by two media channels.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "At the hearing before the Justice of the Peace on 2 January 2011, the applicant requested that the recording made by Mr T., an independent photographer, be admitted as evidence.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "At the hearing before the Justice of the Peace on 2 January 2011, the applicant requested that the court obtain from the prosecution the video recording made by the Moscow police at the scene of the public demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "At the hearing before the Justice of the Peace on 2 January 2011, the applicant requested that the court call and cross-examine Police Colonel B. about the circumstances of the applicant's arrest, which Police Colonel B. had commented on in the media.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Justice of the Peace dismissed the applicant's request to admit the video recordings on the grounds that the provenance of the recordings was not supported by evidence.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The Justice of the Peace refused to order that the video recording made by the police be admitted as evidence, stating that the applicant's request was not specific enough and that the applicant had failed to prove the existence of any such recordings.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Justice of the Peace refused to call and examine Police Colonel B. as a witness, having considered that request irrelevant.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "At the applicant's request, the Justice of the Peace called and examined thirteen witnesses who had been at the scene of the authorised demonstration at Triumfalnaya Square on 31 December 2010.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The thirteen witnesses testified that they had heard the applicant addressing the meeting at Triumfalnaya Square and that after his speech he had said farewell and left; he had not made any calls to go on to another meeting.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Six of the thirteen witnesses testified that they had left the meeting at the same time as the applicant and had witnessed his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Six witnesses testified that the exit from the meeting at Triumfalnaya Square had been blocked by the riot police and the crowd had begun to build up because those who wanted to leave could not do so.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Six witnesses testified that when the applicant arrived at the cordon the police surrounded him so as to separate him from others wanting to leave the meeting, and arrested him.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Eight witnesses stated that the applicant had not been shouting any slogans and had not been acting against the police orders before being surrounded and arrested.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Witness M.T. stated that she had heard the applicant asking the riot police why the exit had been blocked.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Witness M.T. stated that she had heard the applicant shouting that Article 31 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation guaranteed the freedom of assembly, but he had not shouted any calls or obscenities.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The remaining witnesses at the hearing before the Justice of the Peace had not seen the actual arrest of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The applicant's daughter and her friend testified that they had been walking back to the car with the applicant and talking about the plans for New Year's eve when they arrived at the police cordon.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The applicant's daughter and her friend testified that they had lost sight of the applicant in the crowd at the police cordon, and one or two minutes later had called him on his mobile phone and found out that he had been arrested.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Justice of the Peace called and examined two policemen, Sergeant X and Private Y, who had signed the reports stating that they had arrested the applicant because he had disobeyed their orders.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Sergeant X and Private Y testified that on 31 December 2010 they had been on duty maintaining public order at Triumfalnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Sergeant X and Private Y testified that they had seen the applicant at 31 Tverskaya Street shouting anti-government slogans and calling people around him to hold an unauthorised meeting.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Sergeant X and Private Y testified that they had approached the applicant and requested him to stop agitating outside the authorised meeting and to return to the place allocated for the meeting to speak there.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Sergeant X and Private Y testified that the applicant had not reacted to their requests, so they had asked him to proceed to the police van.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Sergeant X and Private Y testified that the applicant had disobeyed the order to proceed to the police van and had been arrested; he had put up resistance while being arrested.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "On 2 January 2011 the Justice of the Peace found that the applicant had disobeyed the police orders to stop chanting anti-government slogans and had resisted lawful arrest.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Justice of the Peace based her findings on the witness statements of Sergeant X and Private Y, their written reports of 31 December 2010, their written statements of the same date, the report on the administrative arrest of the same date, the notice of the public demonstration of 16 December 2010, and the reply of 22 December 2010 indicating that the second demonstration had not been authorised.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The Justice of the Peace dismissed the applicant's testimony on the grounds that as a defendant, he would have sought to exonerate himself from administrative liability.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The Justice of the Peace dismissed the testimonies of seven eyewitnesses on the grounds that they had contradicted the policemen's testimonies and because those witnesses had been acquainted with the applicant, had taken part in the same demonstration and therefore must have been biased towards the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The testimonies of the remaining six witnesses were dismissed by the Justice of the Peace as irrelevant.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The applicant was found guilty of having disobeyed a lawful order of the police, in breach of Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to fifteen days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "On 3 January 2011 the applicant wrote an appeal against the judgment of the Justice of the Peace and submitted it to the detention facility administration unit.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Despite the applicant's counsel's numerous attempts to lodge the appeal directly with the court, the appeal was not accepted before 9 January 2011.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "On 11 January 2011 the applicant's counsel submitted a supplement to the points of appeal against the judgment of the Justice of the Peace.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "In his appeal the applicant claimed that his arrest and conviction for the administrative offence had been in breach of domestic law and in violation of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "In his appeal the applicant alleged that his right to freedom of expression had been violated.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "In his appeal the applicant alleged that his right to freedom of assembly had been violated.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "In his appeal the applicant contested the findings of fact made by the Justice of the Peace as regards his conduct after he had left the meeting at Triumfalnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "In his appeal the applicant challenged the Justice of the Peace's refusal to admit the photographic and video materials as evidence or to obtain the footage of the demonstration shot by the police.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "In his appeal the applicant complained about the manner in which the first-instance hearing had been conducted, in particular alleging that the Justice of the Peace had ordered him to stand throughout the hearing, which had been humiliating and had made it difficult to participate in the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "In his appeal the applicant complained about the conditions of his detention at the Tverskoy District Department of the Interior police station from 31 December 2010 to 2 January 2011.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "On 12 January 2011 the Tverskoy District Court examined the applicant's appeal against the judgment of the Justice of the Peace.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "At the applicant's request, the Tverskoy District Court kept verbatim records of the appeal hearing on 12 January 2011.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "During the appeal hearing on 12 January 2011, the applicant complained of the alleged unlawfulness of his arrest and the poor conditions of his detention at the Tverskoy District Department of the Interior police station.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "During the appeal hearing on 12 January 2011, the applicant asked the Tverskoy District Court to declare the acts of the police who had detained him for over forty hours before bringing him before a court unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "At the appeal hearing on 12 January 2011, the applicant reiterated his requests that the court admit three video recordings of his arrest as evidence.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "At the appeal hearing on 12 January 2011, the applicant reiterated his request that the court obtain the video recording made by the Moscow police at the scene of the public demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "At the appeal hearing on 12 January 2011, the applicant requested that two photographs of his arrest be admitted as evidence.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "At the appeal hearing on 12 January 2011, the applicant asked the court to call and examine photographer T. as a witness.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "At the appeal hearing on 12 January 2011, the applicant asked the court to cross-examine police officers Sergeant X and Private Y again.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court granted the request to admit one video recording as evidence at the appeal hearing on 12 January 2011.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court granted the request to admit two photographs as evidence at the appeal hearing on 12 January 2011.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court decided to call and examine photographer T. as a witness at the appeal hearing on 12 January 2011.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court rejected all other requests made by the applicant at the appeal hearing on 12 January 2011, including the request to obtain the police video recording and to cross-examine Sergeant X and Private Y again.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "Photographer T. testified at the appeal hearing that he had gone to the meeting at Triumfalnaya Square to film it and had been waiting for the applicant at the exit because he had wanted to interview him.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "Photographer T. testified that when the applicant approached the exit from Triumfalnaya Square, a big group of policemen rushed over to block his way and there had been a minute's pause when a crowd began to build up against the cordon, blocking the passage.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "Photographer T. testified that one person was arrested, and about thirty seconds later someone else, and then the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "Photographer T. testified that he saw the applicant's arrest while filming it from a distance of about five or six metres, separated from the applicant by several rows of people, of which two rows consisted of policemen.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "Photographer T. testified that his recording began a few minutes before the arrest and continued without any interruption until the applicant had been put in the police van.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "Photographer T. testified that the applicant had not put up any resistance to the officers arresting him.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "Photographer T. identified on a photograph the officer wearing a fur hat who had arrested the applicant, and explained that that person had taken the applicant out of the crowd and then passed him on to another policeman in order to put the applicant into the police van.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "Photographer T. testified that the applicant had not shouted any slogans or insults and had repeated \"Easy, easy\" to the policemen while being escorted to the van.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "Photographer T. testified that the applicant had been standing throughout the first-instance hearing before the Justice of the Peace, while his counsel had been sitting on a chair.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court watched the video recording made by photographer T. at the appeal hearing on 12 January 2011.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court decided not to take cognisance of photographer T.'s testimonies, his recording or the photograph submitted at the appeal hearing.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court found that the footage showed a large number of people gathered at 31 Tverskaya Street in Moscow, with the applicant at the centre, and that a policeman addressed the citizens through a loudspeaker with a request to disperse and not to block the passage, but the applicant remained standing in one place addressing the gathered citizens.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court found that the video operator was at such a distance from the applicant that he was separated from him by several rows of people, including gathered citizens and riot police, making it impossible to understand what the citizens and the applicant were saying.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court found that the recording of the applicant was interrupted as the camera pointed away onto the policemen putting the first arrested person, and then another one, into the police vans, and only afterwards showed the applicant being led to a police van by policemen without putting up resistance.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court concluded that the submitted footage did not show the applicant's actions immediately before his placement in the police van and did not depict the applicant addressing the citizens before he was detained, and therefore did not refute the testimonies of Sergeant X and Private Y.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court found that photographer T.'s testimony could not refute the testimonies of Sergeant X and Private Y because T. had observed only those actions of the applicant that appeared on the footage.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court found that the photographs submitted during the appeal hearing depicting the applicant surrounded by policemen, one of whom was supporting his arm, could not be considered as refuting the event of the offence or the evidence, including the testimonies of Sergeant X and Private Y, because of the absence of information on the exact time of their taking or their connection with the place.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "On 12 January 2011 the Tverskoy District Court dismissed the applicant's appeal and upheld the first-instance judgment of the Justice of the Peace.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court found, on the basis of the testimonies and reports of Sergeant X and Private Y, that the applicant had indeed been guilty of having disobeyed a lawful order of the police.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court upheld the reasoning of the Justice of the Peace whereby it rejected the testimonies of thirteen witnesses called at the applicant's request.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court found no reason to mistrust the testimonies of Sergeant X and Private Y because they had had no personal interest in the outcome of the applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "In its appeal decision of 12 January 2011, the Tverskoy District Court addressed the lawfulness of the applicant's detention pending the first-instance trial and considered that there had been no breach.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court's appeal decision stated that after the report on the administrative offence had been drawn up, the information necessary for establishing the circumstances of the committed offence was collected, including the explanations of Sergeant X and Private Y, the notice of the place of the public demonstration of 31 December 2010, the mayor's reply to that notice, and the personal characteristics of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court's appeal decision referred to a ruling made by the Justice of the Peace of 2 September 2010 convicting the applicant of an offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court's appeal decision held that the applicant's detention during less than 48 hours was not in breach of Article 27.5 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court found that the applicant's complaints about the conditions of his detention between 31 December 2010 and 2 January 2011 were outside the scope of the appeal proceedings, holding that another type of legal action should have been brought by the applicant to challenge those acts.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court did not specify what procedure the applicant should have followed as an avenue for his complaints about the conditions of detention.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "On 31 March 2011 the applicant lodged before the Tverskoy District Court a complaint under Chapter 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure, challenging his initial arrest and complaining of the poor conditions of detention for over forty hours.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "On 4 April 2011 the Tverskoy District Court refused to accept the applicant's action under Chapter 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure, holding that the questions concerning the lawfulness of the police acts had to be examined in the relevant administrative proceedings and could not be dealt with in civil proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "On 14 April 2011 the applicant appealed against the Tverskoy District Court's refusal to accept his complaint under Chapter 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "The Moscow City Court dismissed the applicant's appeal on 22 July 2011.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "The Moscow City Court relied on Ruling no. 2 of 10 February 2009 by the Plenary Supreme Court of the Russian Federation in dismissing the applicant's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "The Moscow City Court held that courts may not examine complaints lodged under Chapter 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure against acts or inaction connected with the application of the Code of Administrative Offences, Chapter 30 of which provides for the procedure for challenging them.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "The Moscow City Court held that acts or inaction inseparable from an administrative case may not be subject to a separate challenge, and that arguments against the admissibility of evidence or the application of a precautionary measure may be put forward during the hearing of the administrative case or in points of appeal against the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "The Moscow City Court held that if administrative proceedings are terminated, acts committed in the course of those proceedings that entailed a breach of an individual's rights or freedoms, or hindered the exercise of their rights and freedoms, or imposed an obligation after the proceedings had been terminated, may be challenged under Chapter 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "The Moscow City Court held that acts of officials where no administrative file has been opened may be challenged under Chapter 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "The applicant attempted to challenge the acts of the judiciary involved in his case before the Judiciary Qualification Board of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "The applicant's attempts to challenge the acts of the judiciary before the Judiciary Qualification Board of Moscow were unsuccessful.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Administrative proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that failure to obey a lawful order or demand of a police officer in connection with the performance of their official duties related to maintaining public order and security, or impeding the performance by them of their official duties, shall be punishable by a fine of between five hundred and one thousand roubles or by administrative detention of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "Article 27.2 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the escorting or transfer by force of an individual for the purpose of drawing up an administrative offence report, if this cannot be done at the place where the offence was discovered and if the drawing up of a report is mandatory, shall be carried out by the police.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "Article 27.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the escort operation shall be carried out as quickly as possible.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "Article 27.2 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the escort operation shall be recorded in an escort operation report, an administrative offence report or an administrative detention report, and the escorted person shall be given a copy of the escort operation report if he or she so requests.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "Article 27.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that administrative detention or short-term restriction of an individual's liberty may be applied in exceptional cases if this is necessary for the prompt and proper examination of the alleged administrative offence or to secure the enforcement of any penalty imposed by a judgment concerning an administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "Article 27.3 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that where the detained person so requests, his family, the administrative department at his place of work or study and his defence counsel shall be informed of his whereabouts.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "Article 27.3 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the detained person shall have his rights and obligations under the Code explained to him, and the corresponding entry shall be made in the administrative arrest report.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "Article 27.4 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that administrative detention shall be recorded in a report.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "Article 27.4 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that if he or she so requests, the detained person shall be given a copy of the administrative detention report.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F205", "text": "Article 27.5 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that the duration of administrative detention shall not exceed three hours, except in the cases set out in paragraphs 2 and 3 of that Article.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F206", "text": "Article 27.5 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that persons subject to administrative proceedings concerning offences involving unlawful crossing of the Russian border may be subject to administrative detention for up to 48 hours.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F207", "text": "Article 27.5 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001 provides that persons subject to administrative proceedings concerning offences punishable, among other administrative sanctions, by administrative detention may be subject to administrative detention for up to 48 hours.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F024", "F011", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F025", "F026", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F114", "F117", "F118", "F163", "F165"], "interference": ["F038", "F036", "F055", "F074", "F133", "F134", "F163"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F196", "F069", "F133", "F134", "F103", "F112", "F116", "F117", "F118", "F162", "F163", "F165"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F114", "F117", "F118", "F163", "F165", "F112", "F116", "F162", "F060", "F128", "F175", "F074", "F133", "F134", "F003", "F007", "F072", "F073", "F038"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F024", "F015", "F030", "F036", "F117", "F118", "F163"], "interference": ["F038", "F074", "F133", "F134"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F196", "F117", "F118", "F163", "F165", "F133"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F117", "F118", "F112", "F163", "F165", "F074", "F134", "F003", "F007", "F072", "F073"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F024", "F015", "F030", "F038", "F133", "F134", "F196", "F117", "F118", "F163", "F165", "F003", "F007"]}} {"case_name": "case_465", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The case concerns the applicant's criminal conviction for acts of mass disorder and violence against the police during the suppression of a demonstration at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant was born in 1990.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant lives in San Rafael, California, the USA.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr D. Gaynutdinov, a lawyer practising in Sofia, Bulgaria.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Government were represented by Mr M. Galperin, Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 7-65, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. DEMONSTRATION OF 6 MAY 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 7-33, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. DEMONSTRATION OF 6 MAY 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The parties' submissions on the circumstances directly relevant to the present case are set out below.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. DEMONSTRATION OF 6 MAY 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "At the time of the events of 6 May 2012, the applicant was a political activist.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant had previously taken part in several public protests before 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "According to the applicant, on 6 May 2012 he arrived at Kaluzhskaya Square in Moscow to take part in the 'March of Millions'.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "According to the applicant, at around 6.50 p.m. on 6 May 2012 he found himself near Malyy Kamennyy Bridge in a crowd surrounded by police officers who were beating the protestors with truncheons and arresting them.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the applicant, a police officer attacked him using a truncheon on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the applicant, he was outraged and scared as a result of the police officer's attack.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the applicant, he tried to protect himself from the blows by extending his arms forward and distancing himself from the police.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the applicant, four police officers eventually grabbed him and escorted him to a police car, which took him to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 19 May 2012 the investigators questioned police officer Mr G., who had been present at Bolotnaya Square at the time of the events of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Police officer Mr G. testified on 19 May 2012 that the participants of the acts of mass disorder had thrown chunks of tarmac, stones and bottles at the police.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Police officer Mr G. testified on 19 May 2012 that the participants of the acts of mass disorder had shouted slogans.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Police officer Mr G. stated on 19 May 2012 that neither he nor his colleagues had sustained any injuries as a result of the actions of the participants of the acts of mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 22 October 2014 police officer Mr G. was questioned again, after having familiarised himself with a video recording of the events of 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Police officer Mr G. confirmed on 22 October 2014 that he was depicted in the video recording together with his colleague police officer Mr K.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "In the video recording, police officers Mr G. and Mr K. were facing a thirty-year-old man with short dark hair, dressed in a red t-shirt and hooded jacket, with an umbrella in his arms.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Police officer Mr G. stated on 22 October 2014 that the young man in the video recording provoked the police officers with his actions and words, which Mr G. could not remember.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "In response to police officers Mr G.'s and Mr K.'s attempts to apprehend the young man, the man pushed Mr K.'s hands away and tried to escape but was hampered by the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "When police officer Mr G. approached the young man, the latter hit Mr G. on the left wrist.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The video recording depicted the young man striking police officer Mr K.'s head with the umbrella.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Police officer Mr G. stated on 22 October 2014 that he had not seen the blow to police officer Mr K.'s head with the umbrella.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Police officer Mr G. stated on 22 October 2014 that police officer Mr K. had not told him about the blow to his head with the umbrella.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Police officer Mr G. tried to grab the young man's clothes to apprehend him but the latter was resisting.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The video recording showed police officers Mr G. and Mr K. apprehending the young man, with the assistance of other police officers.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "Police officer Mr G. stated on 22 October 2014 that he had felt pain when the young man had hit him on the wrist but that he had sustained no injuries.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 22 October 2014 the police questioned the applicant about the events of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant refused to make any self-incriminating statements on 22 October 2014, invoking Article 51 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "After being questioned on 22 October 2014, the applicant took part in an identification parade before police officer Mr A.K.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Police officer Mr A.K. identified the applicant in the identification parade as a person who had taken part in acts of mass disorder on 6 May 2012 in Bolotnaya Square, resisting police officers and hitting them with his hands.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 22 October 2014 the applicant was arrested.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 26 February 2015 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow ordered the applicant's house arrest until 6 April 2015.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 27 February 2015 charges were brought against the applicant under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (participation in acts of mass disorder accompanied by violence and destruction of property).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 27 February 2015 charges were brought against the applicant under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (use of violence against a public official).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 3 April 2015 charges were brought against the applicant under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (participation in acts of mass disorder accompanied by violence and destruction of property).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 3 April 2015 charges were brought against the applicant under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (use of violence against a public official).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The charges stated that the applicant had hit Police Officer K. at least once in the left hand.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The charges stated that the applicant had hit Police Officer G. twice in the left hand.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The charges stated that the applicant had hit Police Officer K. in the head with his umbrella at least once.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The charges stated that the applicant's actions had caused both Police Officer K. and Police Officer G. physical pain.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 6 August 2015 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow began a preliminary hearing in the criminal case against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 20 August 2015 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow began the trial on the merits in the criminal case against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 25 August 2015 Police Officer G. was examined as a witness at the trial.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Police Officer G. testified on 25 August 2015 that during the apprehension of aggressive participants of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square, a young man later identified as the applicant had hit him twice in the left hand.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Police Officer G. testified on 25 August 2015 that the applicant had hit Police Officer K. in the head with his umbrella.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Police Officer G. testified on 25 August 2015 that the applicant had hit Police Officer K. in the left hand.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Police Officer G. testified on 25 August 2015 that the applicant's actions caused Police Officer G. pain but that he sustained no injuries.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Police Officer K. was examined as a witness on 25 August 2015 and gave statements similar to those of Police Officer G.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 21 October 2015 Police Officer A.K. was questioned at the trial.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Police Officer A.K. stated on 21 October 2015 that he had seen the applicant at Bolotnaya Square resisting arrest and hitting police officers with his hands and an umbrella.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 1 December 2015 Ms N., who did not know the applicant before the events of 6 May 2012, was questioned as a defence witness at the trial.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Ms N. testified on 1 December 2015 that during the clashes between protestors and the police at Bolotnaya Square she had been knocked down at some point.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Ms N. testified on 1 December 2015 that the applicant and other persons had helped her to stand up after she had been knocked down.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Ms N. testified on 1 December 2015 that after helping her stand up, the applicant had joined a group of people within six metres from her.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Ms N. testified on 1 December 2015 that at some point the applicant had been pulled out of the crowd and arrested by the police.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Ms N. testified on 1 December 2015 that the applicant had neither acted aggressively nor resisted his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 22 December 2015 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found the applicant guilty as charged.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that on 6 May 2012 at 5 p.m. at the latest the applicant arrived at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow to take part in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that between 5 p.m. and 10 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the applicant took part in acts of mass disorder accompanied by violence against police officers and the destruction of property.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the applicant defied lawful orders of the police and military and tried to break through the police cordon on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that unidentified participants of acts of mass disorder threw chunks of tarmac, stones, sticks and other objects at the police, which hit them.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the applicant used violence against Police Officers K. and G. which did not endanger their life or health.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the applicant, acting with the intention of using violence, tried to prevent police officers from arresting aggressive participants of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the applicant, standing in front of Police Officers K. and G., hit Police Officer K. in his left hand at least once.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the applicant hit Police Officer G. in his left hand at least once.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the applicant hit Police Officer K. in the head with his umbrella.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the applicant hit Police Officer G. at least once in the left hand, causing both Police Officers K. and G. pain.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow noted that the applicant did not deny the facts shown in the video recording but pleaded not guilty and refused to testify in accordance with Article 51 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the applicant's guilt was established by the testimonies of victims including Police Officers K. and G. and witnesses, and other evidence.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that it had no doubts as to the reliability of the evidence against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the fact of mass disorder taking place at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 could be seen from the video recording.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow described the video recording as showing a young man moving in the crowd and a group of police officers in the crowd performing their duties and apprehending aggressive participants of acts of mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow described the video recording as showing the young man with a folded umbrella approaching police officers who were arresting Mr Lutskevich and standing still.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow described the video recording as showing police officers beginning to arrest the young man, who resisted arrest, hit one police officer in the helmet with his umbrella and in the hands, and hit another police officer at least twice in the hands.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow described the video recording as showing the police arresting the young man and taking him away.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that according to an expert opinion, the young man in the video recording was identified as the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow was critical of the testimony of defence witness Ms N., finding it rebutted by the testimony of victims and other witnesses which the court accepted as reliable.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to two years and six months' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The applicant's sentence of two years and six months' imprisonment was calculated on the basis of a two-year prison term under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, partly concurrent with a term of one year and six months under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The applicant appealed against the judgment of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow of 22 December 2015.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant indicated that the video recording did not show him hitting Police Officers G. and K.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant argued that the statements of Police Officer G. given in 2012, soon after the events at Bolotnaya Square, confirmed that Police Officer G. had sustained neither injuries nor pain.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant considered that the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow had unjustifiably dismissed the testimony of defence witnesses, which made the trial unfair.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "On 26 April 2016 the Moscow City Court upheld the first-instance judgment of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow of 22 December 2015.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The applicant was released on 24 August 2017, having served his prison term.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. THE APPLICANT'S TRIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The relevant provisions of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation can be found in Frumkin v. Russia, no. 74568/12, § 78, 5 January 2016.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F012", "F065", "F066", "F013", "F070", "F080", "F062", "F063", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F007", "F008"], "interference": ["F038", "F040", "F041", "F064", "F085", "F086"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F040", "F041", "F093"], "legitimate_aim": ["F040", "F041", "F064"], "necessity": ["F022", "F023", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F058", "F062", "F063", "F084", "F076", "F077", "F085", "F086", "F069", "F047", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F033", "F054", "F066", "F070", "F071", "F072", "F073", "F013", "F014", "F016", "F080", "F092", "F001", "F007", "F008"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F012", "F065", "F062", "F063", "F080"], "interference": ["F064", "F085", "F086"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F040", "F041", "F093"], "legitimate_aim": ["F040", "F041"], "necessity": ["F022", "F051", "F058", "F062", "F063", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F069", "F066", "F013", "F080", "F092"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F012", "F064", "F085", "F086", "F069", "F022", "F062", "F063", "F084", "F066", "F080", "F013"]}} {"case_name": "case_467", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under various provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_469", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants live in Vladikavkaz.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants are former policemen.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants were all involved in the conflict-resolution and peace-keeping operation in the zone of the armed Ossetian-Ingush conflict in October and November 1992.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "As a consequence of their involvement in the conflict-resolution and peace-keeping operation in the zone of the armed Ossetian-Ingush conflict, the applicants were entitled to certain social payments.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants sued the Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya Regional Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs (the regional internal-affairs department) for social-payments arrears.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings in respect of social-payments arrears"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On various dates in 2001 or 2002, the Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz allowed the applicants' claims against the Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya Regional Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs (the regional internal-affairs department) for social-payments arrears.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings in respect of social-payments arrears"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz ordered that the Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya Regional Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs (the regional internal-affairs department) pay the social-payments arrears to the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings in respect of social-payments arrears"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The dates of the judgments and the amounts of the awards in respect of the applicants' social-payments arrears claims are listed in the Annex to the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings in respect of social-payments arrears"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicants submitted the writs of execution to the Ministry of Finance.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings in respect of social-payments arrears"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Ministry of Finance returned the writs of execution to the applicants on the ground of lack of funds to pay the judgment debts.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings in respect of social-payments arrears"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The judgments in favour of all the applicants were eventually enforced between September 2004 and April 2005.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings in respect of social-payments arrears"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The dates of payment in respect of each applicant are listed in the Annex to the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings in respect of social-payments arrears"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "All the applicants except Mr Varziev sued the Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya Regional Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs (the regional internal-affairs department) for pecuniary damage incurred through the belated enforcement of the judgments in their favour.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings in respect of social-payments arrears"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On various dates in 2005, the Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz acknowledged that the delays in enforcement of the judgments had violated the applicants' rights.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings in respect of social-payments arrears"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On various dates in 2005, the Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz awarded each of the applicants (except Mr Varziev) a sum to cover inflation losses sustained as a result of the belated enforcement of the judgments.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings in respect of social-payments arrears"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The awards for inflation losses were paid to the applicants on various dates in 2005.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings in respect of social-payments arrears"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "One of the applicants, Mr Tsallagov, did not submit the writ of execution to the Ministry of Finance and did not therefore receive his award for inflation losses.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings in respect of social-payments arrears"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 15 September 2003, the applicants notified the Vladikavkaz Town Administration of their intention to hold a demonstration in Svoboda Square in Vladikavkaz.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The purpose of the planned demonstration in Svoboda Square was to protest against the Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya Regional Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs (the regional internal-affairs department)'s failure to settle the social-payments debt.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The demonstration was scheduled to start on 30 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The demonstration was announced as being of unlimited duration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 24 September 2003, the Vladikavkaz Town Administration refused to approve Svoboda Square as the venue for the applicants' demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 24 September 2003, the Vladikavkaz Town Administration suggested that the demonstration be held in front of the Tkhapsayev theatre.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 30 September 2003, the applicants began their demonstration in Svoboda Square in front of the Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya Regional Government building.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "About one hundred people participated in the demonstration in Svoboda Square on 30 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The demonstrators put up tents in Svoboda Square and remained in the square day and night.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The demonstrators displayed placards and banners stating their criticisms and demands.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 3 October 2003, the Vladikavkaz Town Legislature annulled the decision of 24 September 2003 at the request of the Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya Regional Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs (the regional internal-affairs department).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Vladikavkaz Town Legislature annulled the decision of 24 September 2003 'in connection with a risk of terrorist acts in the places of mass gatherings of people'.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Vladikavkaz Town Legislature asked the Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya Regional Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs (the regional internal-affairs department) to take measures to break up the demonstration in Svoboda Square.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Vladikavkaz Town Legislature asked the Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya Regional Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs (the regional internal-affairs department) to restore public order in Svoboda Square.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 11 October 2003, the Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz declared the demonstration in Svoboda Square unlawful because it violated the rights of others.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz found that the demonstration hampered citizens' access to public transport and to the cinema situated in Svoboda Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz found that the demonstration hampered officials' access to the administrative buildings situated in Svoboda Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz found that the chanting of slogans by the applicants disturbed the officials' work.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz noted that the Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya Regional Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs (the regional internal-affairs department) had information about an expected outbreak of terrorist activities in the region.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz found that the mass gathering of people in the vicinity of the administrative buildings in Svoboda Square increased the risk of terrorist acts and other offences being committed.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz found that the mass gathering of people in Svoboda Square impeded the conduct of preventive operations by the law-enforcement agencies.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz noted that the Vladikavkaz Town Administration had ordered that all meetings and assemblies be held in front of the Tkhapsayev theatre.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz found that the demonstration in Svoboda Square was in breach of the Vladikavkaz Town Administration's order that all meetings and assemblies be held in front of the Tkhapsayev theatre.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz found that public gatherings of unlimited duration were not authorised by Russian law.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "It appears from a videotape and press articles submitted by the applicants that on 11 October 2003 the police ordered the protesters in Svoboda Square to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "As the protesters refused to stop the demonstration, the police dismantled the tents the protesters had erected in Svoboda Square.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "After the police dismantled the tents, the protesters put the tents back up and continued their demonstration in Svoboda Square.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 18 November 2003, the Supreme Court of the Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya Republic upheld the judgment of 11 October 2003 of the Leninskiy District Court of Vladikavkaz on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 27 November 2003, the Parliament of the Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya Republic decreed that Svoboda Square in Vladikavkaz was reserved for meetings, assemblies and demonstrations organised at the initiative of the authorities of the Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya Republic and the town of Vladikavkaz.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Parliament of the Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya Republic decreed that public gatherings other than those organised at the initiative of the authorities were to be held at a venue to be determined by the Vladikavkaz Town Administration.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On an unspecified date in December 2003, the protesters ended the demonstration in Svoboda Square.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Demonstration organised by the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "For the relevant provisions of domestic law regarding the enforcement of final judgments, see Burdov v. Russia (no. 2) (application no. 33509/04, §§ 22 and 26-29, 15 January 2009).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Enforcement of judgments"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Federal Law № 68-ФЗ of 30 April 2010 (in force as of 4 May 2010) provides that in the event of a violation of the right to trial within a reasonable time, Russian citizens are entitled to seek compensation for non-pecuniary damage.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Enforcement of judgments"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Federal Law № 68-ФЗ of 30 April 2010 (in force as of 4 May 2010) provides that in the event of a violation of the right to enforcement of a final judgment, Russian citizens are entitled to seek compensation for non-pecuniary damage.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Enforcement of judgments"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Federal Law № 69-ФЗ, adopted on 30 April 2010, introduced pertinent changes in Russian legislation relating to compensation for violations of the right to trial within a reasonable time and the right to enforcement of a final judgment.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Enforcement of judgments"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Section 6.2 of Federal Law № 68-ФЗ provides that everyone who has an application pending with the European Court of Human Rights concerning a complaint of the nature described in Federal Law № 68-ФЗ has six months to bring the complaint to the domestic courts.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Enforcement of judgments"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Russian Constitution guarantees the right to freedom of peaceful assembly (Article 31).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Russian Constitution guarantees the right to hold meetings, demonstrations, marches and pickets (Article 31).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Presidential Decree no. 524 of 25 May 1992 (in force at the material time) provided that the exercise of the right to freedom of assembly should not violate the rights and freedoms of others (section 1).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Presidential Decree no. 524 of 25 May 1992 (in force at the material time) prohibited the use of the right to freedom of assembly for the purpose of violently overthrowing the Government (section 1).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Presidential Decree no. 524 of 25 May 1992 (in force at the material time) prohibited the use of the right to freedom of assembly for the purpose of inciting racial, ethnic or religious hatred (section 1).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Presidential Decree no. 524 of 25 May 1992 (in force at the material time) prohibited the use of the right to freedom of assembly for the purpose of advocating violence or war (section 1).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 (in force at the material time pursuant to Presidential Decree no. 524 of 25 May 1992) provided that organisers of an assembly were to serve a written notification on the municipal authorities no later than ten days before the planned assembly (section 2).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 provided that the notification was to mention the purposes, type, location or itinerary of the assembly, the time of its beginning and end, the expected number of participants, and the names and addresses of the organisers (section 2).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 provided that the municipal authority was to give its response no later than five days before the assembly (section 3).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 provided that the municipal authority could, if necessary, suggest another venue or time for the assembly (section 3).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 provided that an assembly could be banned if its purpose was contrary to the Constitution or threatened public order or the security of citizens (section 6).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 provided that an assembly was to be stopped at the request of the authorities if no prior notification of the assembly had been given (section 7, case 1).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 provided that an assembly was to be stopped at the request of the authorities if a decision banning the assembly had been issued (section 7, case 2).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 provided that an assembly was to be stopped at the request of the authorities if the established procedure for the conduct of public assemblies had been breached (section 7, case 3).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 provided that an assembly was to be stopped at the request of the authorities if there was a danger to citizens' life or health (section 7, case 4).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 provided that an assembly was to be stopped at the request of the authorities if the public order was breached (section 7, case 5).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Public assemblies"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Succession in Russian law is regulated by Part 3 of the Civil Code.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Succession"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Under Article 1112 of the Russian Civil Code, succession includes the deceased's property or pecuniary rights or claims.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Succession"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Under Article 1112 of the Russian Civil Code, succession does not include rights or obligations intrinsically linked to the deceased's person, such as alimony or a right to compensation for damage to health.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Succession"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Under Articles 1152 and 1162 of the Russian Civil Code, an heir should claim and accept succession and obtain a succession certificate from a public notary.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Succession"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Under Article 1183 § 1 of the Russian Civil Code, the right to receive salary payments and payments qualifying as such, pension payments and other sums of money payable to the deceased person as a means of subsistence which were not received in his lifetime belongs to the members of the deceased's family who had been residing with him.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Succession"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Under Article 1183 § 1 of the Russian Civil Code, the right to receive salary payments and payments qualifying as such, pension payments and other sums of money payable to the deceased person as a means of subsistence which were not received in his lifetime also belongs to any disabled dependants, irrespective of their having resided with the deceased or not.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Succession"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "In accordance with section 63 of the Federal Law on Pension Welfare of Military Service Personnel (1993), as in force at the material time, pension payments due to a pensioner but not received in his lifetime are payable to the members of the deceased's family if they were in charge of his or her funeral.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Succession"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "In accordance with section 63 of the Federal Law on Pension Welfare of Military Service Personnel (1993), as in force at the material time, pension payments due to a pensioner but not received in his lifetime shall not be included in the succession.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Succession"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": false, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F022", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F048"], "interference": ["F022", "F032", "F042", "F043"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F022", "F024", "F026", "F027", "F032", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F048"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F044"], "interference": ["F022", "F032", "F042", "F043"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F024", "F026", "F027", "F032", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F048"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F024", "F026", "F027", "F032", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F048"]}} {"case_name": "case_471", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants are members of EĞİTİM-SEN (Eğitim ve Bilim Emekçileri Sendikası – The Education Workers' Trade Union).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "EĞİTİM-SEN (Eğitim ve Bilim Emekçileri Sendikası – The Education Workers' Trade Union) is a trade union.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "EĞİTİM-SEN (Eğitim ve Bilim Emekçileri Sendikası – The Education Workers' Trade Union) is a member of KESK (Kamu Emekçileri Sendikaları Konfederasyonu – The Confederation of Public Employees' Trade Unions).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "In 2001 the Turkish Parliament prepared a draft bill to amend the Act on Trade Unions.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "While the draft bill to amend the Act on Trade Unions was being discussed in the Turkish Parliament, KESK (Kamu Emekçileri Sendikaları Konfederasyonu – The Confederation of Public Employees' Trade Unions) decided to organise meetings in Ankara to protest the bill.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The aim of the meetings organised by KESK (Kamu Emekçileri Sendikaları Konfederasyonu – The Confederation of Public Employees' Trade Unions) was to draw public attention to the draft bill to amend the Act on Trade Unions.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The aim of the meetings organised by KESK (Kamu Emekçileri Sendikaları Konfederasyonu – The Confederation of Public Employees' Trade Unions) was to achieve the withdrawal of the draft bill to amend the Act on Trade Unions.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "In the view of KESK (Kamu Emekçileri Sendikaları Konfederasyonu – The Confederation of Public Employees' Trade Unions), the draft bill to amend the Act on Trade Unions did not meet international standards.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 18 December 2000, the Governorship of Ankara issued a circular providing guidelines on meetings and demonstrations organised in the city of Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The circular issued by the Governorship of Ankara on 18 December 2000 was issued in accordance with the Law on Meetings and Demonstration Marches (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "According to the circular issued by the Governorship of Ankara on 18 December 2000, the meeting place chosen by KESK (Kamu Emekçileri Sendikaları Konfederasyonu – The Confederation of Public Employees' Trade Unions) was not among the permitted areas.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 7 June 2001, Nurettin Aldemir gathered in Kızılay together with other persons.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 7 June 2001, Şehrinaz Artar gathered in Kızılay together with other persons.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 7 June 2001, Ömer Buzludağ gathered in Kızılay together with other persons.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 7 June 2001, Sami Evren gathered in Kızılay together with other persons.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 7 June 2001, Ali Rıza Özer gathered in Kızılay together with other persons.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 25 June 2001, Arzu Doğan gathered in Kızılay together with other persons.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 25 June 2001, Tacettin Yağdıran gathered in Kızılay together with other persons.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 25 June 2001, Elif Akgül gathered in Kızılay together with other persons.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On both occasions (7 June 2001 and 25 June 2001), while the president of KESK (Kamu Emekçileri Sendikaları Konfederasyonu – The Confederation of Public Employees' Trade Unions) was reading out press statements, police officers warned the demonstrators that their action was contrary to the law.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On both occasions (7 June 2001 and 25 June 2001), while the president of KESK (Kamu Emekçileri Sendikaları Konfederasyonu – The Confederation of Public Employees' Trade Unions) was reading out press statements, police officers warned the demonstrators that they had to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On both occasions (7 June 2001 and 25 June 2001), the demonstrators blocked the main street of the Kızılay district (Atatürk Avenue).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On both occasions (7 June 2001 and 25 June 2001), the demonstrators attempted to march towards the Prime Minister's Office.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On both occasions (7 June 2001 and 25 June 2001), police officers intervened and used truncheons with a view to dispersing the crowds.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On both occasions (7 June 2001 and 25 June 2001), police officers intervened and used sticks with a view to dispersing the crowds.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On both occasions (7 June 2001 and 25 June 2001), police officers intervened and used tear gas with a view to dispersing the crowds.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On both occasions (7 June 2001 and 25 June 2001), some of the demonstrators attacked the security forces using pavement stones and sticks.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The attacks by demonstrators on security forces caused the injury of seven police officers.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The attacks by demonstrators on security forces caused the destruction of a police vehicle.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicants were wounded during the incidents on 7 June 2001 and 25 June 2001 in Kızılay.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 7 June 2001, Şehrinaz Artar was examined by a doctor from the Hacettepe University Hospital.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 7 June 2001, Ömer Buzludağ was examined by a doctor from the Hacettepe University Hospital.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The doctor from the Hacettepe University Hospital noted an ecchymosis of 2x2 cm on the left eyebrow of Şehrinaz Artar.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The doctor from the Hacettepe University Hospital noted an abrasion of 3 cm on the right eyebrow of Ömer Buzludağ.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Nurettin Aldemir did not submit any medical evidence to the Court in support of his subsequent allegations of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Sami Evren did not submit any medical evidence to the Court in support of his subsequent allegations of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Ali Rıza Özer did not submit any medical evidence to the Court in support of his subsequent allegations of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 25 June 2001, Arzu Doğan was examined by a forensic medical expert from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The forensic medical expert from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute observed an ecchymosis on the lip of Arzu Doğan.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The forensic medical expert from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute observed a hyperaemic graze on the left wrist of Arzu Doğan.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The forensic medical expert from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute observed superficial abrasions on the right wrist of Arzu Doğan.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The forensic medical expert from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute observed superficial abrasions on the right arm of Arzu Doğan.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The forensic medical expert from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute concluded that the injuries rendered Arzu Doğan unfit for work for one day.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 25 June 2001, Tacettin Yağdıran was examined by a forensic medical expert from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The forensic medical expert from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute observed a sutured injury on the occipital lobe of the head of Tacettin Yağdıran.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The forensic medical expert from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute observed a haematoma under the sutured injury on the occipital lobe of the head of Tacettin Yağdıran.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The forensic medical expert from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute considered that the injuries of Tacettin Yağdıran rendered him unfit for work for seven days.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 25 June 2001, Elif Akgül was examined by a doctor from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The doctor from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute observed abrasions on the skin on the left scapula of Elif Akgül.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The doctor from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute observed abrasions on the skin on the back of Elif Akgül.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The doctor from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute observed a haematoma of 2x2 cm on the right frontal lobe of Elif Akgül.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The doctor from the Ankara Forensic Medicine Institute concluded that the injuries rendered Elif Akgül unfit for work for five days.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On an unspecified date, the applicants filed a complaint with the Ankara public prosecutor's office against the Ankara Governor.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On an unspecified date, the applicants filed a complaint with the Ankara public prosecutor's office against the director of the Ankara Security Directorate.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On an unspecified date, the applicants filed a complaint with the Ankara public prosecutor's office against the director of the Rapid Intervention Force branch of the Ankara Security Directorate.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On an unspecified date, the applicants filed a complaint with the Ankara public prosecutor's office against the police officers who were involved in the incidents of 7 June 2001 and 25 June 2001 in Kızılay.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 26 June 2001, the Ankara public prosecutor brought charges against twenty-seven demonstrators, including Arzu Doğan and Sami Evren, for violation of the Law on Meetings and Demonstration Marches (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 23 July 2001, pursuant to Law no. 4483 on the prosecution of civil servants, the Ankara public prosecutor transferred the file to the Ministry of Interior seeking an authorisation to initiate criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 9 October 2001, the Ministry of the Interior decided not to take action against the officials and officers accused by the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Ministry of the Interior's decision of 9 October 2001 was based on Article 4 of Law no. 4483 on the prosecution of civil servants.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Ministry of the Interior found that the allegations made by the applicants against the officials and officers were of an 'abstract nature'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Ministry of the Interior considered that the force used by the police during the incidents of 7 June 2001 and 25 June 2001 was lawful and justified in the circumstances of the case.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Ministry of the Interior considered that the police officers had been under an obligation to disperse the demonstrators who had organised an illegal meeting.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Ministry of the Interior's decision of 9 October 2001 was sent to the Ankara public prosecutor's office on 19 December 2001.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "In a decision of 14 November 2001, the Ankara Criminal Court acquitted Arzu Doğan of the charges brought against her for violation of the Law on Meetings and Demonstration Marches (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "In a decision of 14 November 2001, the Ankara Criminal Court acquitted Sami Evren of the charges brought against him for violation of the Law on Meetings and Demonstration Marches (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "In a decision of 14 November 2001, the Ankara Criminal Court acquitted other demonstrators of the charges brought against them for violation of the Law on Meetings and Demonstration Marches (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Ankara Criminal Court decided in its decision of 14 November 2001 that the demonstrators enjoyed a right to hold unarmed and peaceful meetings and demonstrations without prior permission.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 29 January 2002, the Ankara public prosecutor issued a decision of non-prosecution as regards the applicants' complaints against the Ankara Governor, the director of the Ankara Security Directorate, the director of the Rapid Intervention Force branch of the Ankara Security Directorate, and the police officers involved in the incidents.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Article 34 of the Turkish Constitution provides that everyone has the right to hold unarmed and peaceful meetings and demonstration marches without prior permission.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitutional guarantees"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Article 34 of the Turkish Constitution provides that the formalities, conditions, and procedures governing the exercise of the right to hold meetings and demonstration marches shall be prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitutional guarantees"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "At the material time, section 10 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) required that, in order for a meeting to take place, the governor's office or authorities of the district in which the demonstration is planned must be informed during opening hours and at least seventy-two hours prior to the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "At the material time, section 10 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) required that the notification to the governor's office or district authorities must be by a notice containing the signature of all the members of the organising board.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Section 22 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) prohibited demonstrations and processions on public streets.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Section 22 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) prohibited demonstrations and processions in parks.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Section 22 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) prohibited demonstrations and processions in places of worship.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Section 22 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) prohibited demonstrations and processions in buildings in which public services were based.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Section 22 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) required that demonstrations organised in public squares comply with security instructions and not disrupt individuals' movement or public transport.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "Section 24 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) provided that demonstrations and processions which did not comply with the provisions of the Act would be dispersed by force on the order of the governor's office and after the demonstrators had been warned.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "According to the circular issued by the Governorship of Ankara on 18 December 2000, which provides guidelines on meetings and demonstrations, Kızılay avenue is not among the permitted areas for demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. The Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Article 16(a) of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that the police may use firearms in the event of self-defence.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Article 16(h) of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that the police may use firearms if a person or a group resists the police and prevents them from carrying out their duties or if there is an attack against the police.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Additional Article 6 (dated 16 June 1985) of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that in cases of resistance by persons whose arrest is necessary or by groups whose dispersal is necessary, or of their threatening to attack or carrying out an attack, the police may use violence to subdue these actions.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Additional Article 6 (dated 16 June 1985) of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that use of violence refers to the use of bodily force, physical force and all types of weapons specified in the law, and it gradually increases according to the nature and level of resistance and attack in such a way as to restore calm.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Additional Article 6 (dated 16 June 1985) of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that in cases of intervention by group forces, the extent of the use of force and the equipment and instruments to be used are determined by the commander of the intervening force.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "According to Article 165 of the now defunct Code on Criminal Procedure, a complainant may file an appeal against the decision of a public prosecutor not to institute criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Code on Criminal Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "According to Article 165 of the now defunct Code on Criminal Procedure, an appeal against a public prosecutor's decision not to institute criminal proceedings must be lodged within fifteen days from the day of notification of the decision to the complainant.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Code on Criminal Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "According to Article 165 of the now defunct Code on Criminal Procedure, an appeal against a public prosecutor's decision not to institute criminal proceedings must be lodged with the president of the assize court in whose jurisdiction the public prosecutor works.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Code on Criminal Procedure"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F023"], "interference": ["F011", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F030", "F057", "F080"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F010", "F074", "F078", "F079", "F080"], "legitimate_aim": ["F022", "F023", "F027"], "necessity": ["F006", "F007", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F070", "F072"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F005", "F006", "F012", "F017", "F020"], "interference": ["F024", "F026", "F030", "F057"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F074", "F079", "F080"], "legitimate_aim": ["F022"], "necessity": ["F020", "F022", "F024", "F026", "F027"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F005", "F020", "F022", "F024", "F026", "F027", "F030", "F057", "F074", "F080"]}} {"case_name": "case_472", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_473", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1986.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Mozhaysk, Moscow Region.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 31 January 2009, the applicant and six other people decided to hold a flash mob in front of the Office of the Russian Government in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant and six other people arrived at the Office of the Russian Government in Moscow at around 1 p.m. on 31 January 2009.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant and six other people positioned themselves at Gorbatyy Bridge on 31 January 2009.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Each participant in the flash mob held a blank sheet of paper.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Each participant in the flash mob had their mouth covered with adhesive tape.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "At 1.20 p.m. on 31 January 2009, the police ordered the group at Gorbatyy Bridge to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant asked to be informed of the grounds for the police order to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicant was taken to Presnenskiy police station.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant was charged under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences (breaches of the established procedure for the organisation or conduct of public gatherings, meetings, demonstrations, marches or pickets).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The charge against the applicant under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences related to his participation in a public gathering.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The basis for the charge against the applicant was that the requirement of prior notification under the Federal Law on Gatherings, Meetings, Demonstrations, Processions and Pickets, no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), had not been respected.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 11 March 2009, the justice of the peace of the 378th circuit of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow convicted the applicant of the administrative offence under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 378th circuit of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow sentenced the applicant to a fine of 1,000 Russian roubles (approximately 22 euros).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The judgment of 11 March 2009 stated that at 1.20 p.m. on 31 January 2009, the applicant, as a participant in the public event in the form of a static demonstration (пикетирование), breached the established procedure for the conduct of a public event.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant denied his guilt in respect of the administrative offence charged under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant stated that he had been aware of the need to comply with the notification procedure when organising a public event.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant stated that in this particular case compliance with the notification procedure had not been necessary because the act had not been political in character but had been a flash mob, that is to say a synchronised action of several people.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant told the police officers that the participants in the act had not been involved in a public event but had been taking photos on Gorbatyy Bridge while holding blank sheets of paper.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 378th circuit of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow declined the applicant's arguments because his guilt in the administrative offence had been proved by the bulk of evidence examined in the course of the court hearing.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The judgment of 11 March 2009 found that the applicant voluntarily and directly participated in the public event in the form of a static demonstration that had been taking place in breach of the procedure set out by the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The judgment of 11 March 2009 found that the applicant failed to comply with the lawful order by the police officers to stop the static demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 378th circuit of the Presnenskiy District of Moscow dismissed the applicant's argument that the act did not amount to a public event in the form of a static demonstration and that he did not participate in a public event, because the evidence collected in the case showed otherwise.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant appealed against the judgment of 11 March 2009, challenging the applicability of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004) to the circumstances of the case.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant appealed against the judgment of 11 March 2009, contesting the fine imposed on him.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 28 April 2009, the Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow upheld the judgment of 11 March 2009.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow dismissed the applicant's and his lawyer's arguments presented in the statement of appeal.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant appeared at around 2 p.m. on 31 January 2009 among a group of comrades with whom he had agreed to do so on the Internet, on the bridge in front of the building at 2 Krasnopresnenskaya Embankment in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant covered his mouth with adhesive tape during the event on 31 January 2009.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant carried sheets of A4 paper without any inscriptions or images during the event on 31 January 2009.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant was present for ten to fifteen minutes at the bridge in front of the building at 2 Krasnopresnenskaya Embankment in Moscow in the absence of any permission whatsoever.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Presnenskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant's actions fully met the criteria of the administrative offence set out in Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences in the form of a static demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in Kasparov and Others v. Russia (no. 21613/07, § 35, 3 October 2013).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in Navalnyy and Yashin v. Russia (no. 76204/11, §§ 43-44, 4 December 2014).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in Novikova and Others v. Russia (nos. 25501/07 and 4 others, §§ 67-69, 26 April 2016).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in Lashmankin and Others v. Russia (nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, §§ 216-312, 7 February 2017).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The provisions of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004) as in force at the material time directly relevant to the present case are set out in the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Section 2(1) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004) defined a 'public event' as an open, peaceful event accessible to all, organised at the initiative of citizens of the Russian Federation, political parties, other public associations, or religious associations.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Section 2(1) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004) provided that a public event must have the aims of expressing or developing opinions freely and voicing demands on issues related to political, economic, social or cultural life in the country, and issues related to foreign policy.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004) distinguished between five types of public event: a gathering (собрание); a meeting (митинг); a demonstration (демонстрация); a march (шествие); and a static demonstration (пикетирование).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Further details on the five types of public event under the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004) can be found in Lashmankin and Others v. Russia (nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, § 219, 7 February 2017).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Section 2(6) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004) defined a static demonstration as a form of public expression of opinion that does not involve movement or the use of loudspeaker equipment.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Section 2(6) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004) provided that in a static demonstration, one or more citizens with placards, banners and other means of visual expression station themselves near the target object of the static demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "In accordance with sections 5(4)(1) and 7(1)(3) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004), notification in respect of a static demonstration involving several persons must be submitted no later than three days before the intended static demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In accordance with sections 5(4)(1) and 7(1)(3) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004), if the end of the notification time-limit falls on a Sunday or a public holiday, notification must be submitted no later than four days before the intended static demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Under the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004), no notification was required for gatherings (собрание).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "Under the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004), no notification was required for static demonstrations involving one person.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In accordance with section 7(3) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004), notification must contain the purpose of a public event.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In accordance with section 7(3) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004), notification must contain the form of a public event.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "In accordance with section 7(3) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004), notification must contain the place of a public event.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In accordance with section 7(3) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004), notification must contain the date and the time of the beginning and ending of a public event.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "In accordance with section 7(3) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004), notification must contain the envisioned number of participants of a public event.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In accordance with section 7(3) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004), notification must contain the methods by employing which the organiser of a public event intends to ensure that public order be maintained and emergency medical aid be made available.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In accordance with section 7(3) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004), notification must contain the full name of the organiser of a public event, his or her address and phone number.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "In accordance with section 7(3) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004), notification must contain the full names of persons authorised by the organiser of a public event to represent him or her in the course of a public event.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In accordance with section 7(3) of the Public Events Act (Federal Law no. FZ-54 of 19 June 2004), notification must contain the date of submitting the notification.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F017", "F019", "F032"], "interference": ["F003", "F008", "F010", "F011", "F013", "F014", "F015"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F039", "F040", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F054", "F055", "F056", "F057"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F003", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F011", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F021", "F022", "F027", "F032", "F033"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F032"], "interference": ["F008", "F013", "F014", "F015"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F043", "F044", "F045", "F048", "F049"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F003", "F006", "F007", "F013", "F014", "F022", "F027", "F033"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F022", "F027"]}} {"case_name": "case_475", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention or Protocols to the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_476", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_479", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1970.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 22 April 2000, the applicant organised a demonstration in Sultanahmet Square in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant is a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant is a member of the administrative board of the Istanbul Human Rights Association.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The demonstration organised by the applicant on 22 April 2000 took the form of a march followed by a statement to the press.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The demonstration organised by the applicant on 22 April 2000 was held to protest against plans for 'F-type' prisons.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "At about 12 noon on 22 April 2000, a group of forty to fifty persons gathered in Sultanahmet Square brandishing placards and signs.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The group of forty to fifty persons gathered in Sultanahmet Square under the leadership of the applicant and Eren Keskin.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Eren Keskin is a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Eren Keskin is the President of the Istanbul Human Rights Association.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The police asked the group gathered in Sultanahmet Square to disperse and to end the gathering.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The police informed the group via a loudspeaker that the demonstration was unlawful because advance notice had not been submitted.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The police informed the group via a loudspeaker that the demonstration was likely to cause public-order problems at a busy time of day.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The demonstrators refused to obey the police order to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The demonstrators attempted to continue marching towards the police.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The police dispersed the group of demonstrators using a kind of tear gas known as 'pepper spray'.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The police arrested thirty-nine demonstrators, including the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The police took the thirty-nine arrested demonstrators, including the applicant, to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "After an identity check, the applicant was released at 12.45 p.m. on 22 April 2000.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant was released at 12.45 p.m. in view of her profession as a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 26 April 2000, the applicant lodged a criminal complaint with the Beyoğlu prosecutor's office against the head of the Istanbul security police and the police officers concerned.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "In her criminal complaint of 26 April 2000, the applicant alleged that she had been ill-treated through the use of pepper spray.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "In her criminal complaint of 26 April 2000, the applicant alleged that she had been unlawfully arrested.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "In her criminal complaint of 26 April 2000, the applicant alleged that she had been prevented from making the public statement scheduled for the end of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 29 June 2000, the public prosecutor's office discontinued the proceedings against the head of the Istanbul security police and the police officers concerned on the ground that no offence had been committed.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 25 July 2000, the applicant applied to the Beyoğlu Assize Court seeking to have the decision of 29 June 2000 to discontinue proceedings set aside.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 25 September 2000, the Beyoğlu Assize Court upheld the decision that there was no case to answer.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Article 34 of the Turkish Constitution provides that everyone has the right to hold unarmed and peaceful meetings and demonstration marches without prior permission.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Domestic legislation on freedom of assembly", "1. Constitutional guarantees"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Article 34 of the Turkish Constitution provides that the formalities, conditions, and procedures governing the exercise of the right to hold meetings and demonstration marches shall be prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Domestic legislation on freedom of assembly", "1. Constitutional guarantees"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "At the material time, section 10 of Law no. 2911 on assemblies and marches required that, in order for a meeting to take place, the governor's office or authorities of the district in which the demonstration is planned must be informed during opening hours and at least seventy-two hours prior to the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Domestic legislation on freedom of assembly", "2. The Demonstrations Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Under section 10 of Law no. 2911 on assemblies and marches, the required notice must contain the signature of all the members of the organising board.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Domestic legislation on freedom of assembly", "2. The Demonstrations Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "Section 22 of Law no. 2911 on assemblies and marches prohibits demonstrations and processions on public streets, in parks, places of worship, and buildings in which public services are based.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Domestic legislation on freedom of assembly", "2. The Demonstrations Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "Under section 22 of Law no. 2911 on assemblies and marches, demonstrations organised in public squares must comply with security instructions and not disrupt individuals' movement or public transport.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Domestic legislation on freedom of assembly", "2. The Demonstrations Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Section 24 of Law no. 2911 on assemblies and marches provides that demonstrations and processions which do not comply with the provisions of that Act will be dispersed by force on the order of the governor's office and after the demonstrators have been warned.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Domestic legislation on freedom of assembly", "2. The Demonstrations Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission) adopted an opinion interpreting the OSCE/ODHIR guidelines on drafting laws on freedom of assembly with regard to the regulation of public meetings at its 64th plenary session held on 21-22 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Opinion of the Venice Commission"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Venice Commission's opinion set out its approach particularly with regard to advance notice of demonstrations in public places.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Opinion of the Venice Commission"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Venice Commission stated in paragraph 29 of its opinion that establishing a regime of prior notification of peaceful assemblies does not necessarily extend to an infringement of the right to freedom of assembly, and that such regimes exist in several European countries.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Opinion of the Venice Commission"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Venice Commission stated in paragraph 29 of its opinion that the need for advance notice generally arises in respect of certain meetings or assemblies — for instance, when a procession is planned to take place on the highway, or a static assembly is planned to take place on a public square — which require the police and other authorities to enable it to occur and not to use powers that they may validly have (for instance, of regulating traffic) to obstruct the event.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Opinion of the Venice Commission"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Venice Commission emphasised in paragraph 30 of its opinion that the regime of prior notification must not in any circumstances indirectly restrict the right to hold peaceful meetings by, for instance, providing for too detailed and complicated requirements, or imposing too onerous procedural conditions.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Opinion of the Venice Commission"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "Under Article I § 5 of the Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and on their Destruction of 13 January 1993 (the CWC), each State Party undertakes not to use riot control agents as a method of warfare.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. International regulations on the use of \"tear gas\""]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Tear gas and so-called 'pepper spray' are not considered chemical weapons under the Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and on their Destruction of 13 January 1993 (the CWC), which contains an annex listing the names of prohibited chemical products.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. International regulations on the use of \"tear gas\""]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Under Article II § 9(d) of the Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and on their Destruction of 13 January 1993 (the CWC), the use of tear gas and pepper spray is authorised for the purpose of law enforcement, including domestic riot control.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. International regulations on the use of \"tear gas\""]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and on their Destruction of 13 January 1993 (the CWC) does not state which State bodies may be involved in maintaining public order, leaving this as a matter for the sovereign power of the State concerned.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. International regulations on the use of \"tear gas\""]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and on their Destruction of 13 January 1993 (the CWC) entered into force with regard to Turkey on 11 June 1997.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. International regulations on the use of \"tear gas\""]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "It is recognised that the use of 'pepper spray' can produce effects such as respiratory problems, nausea, vomiting, irritation of the respiratory tract, irritation of the tear ducts and eyes, spasms, chest pain, dermatitis, or allergies.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. International regulations on the use of \"tear gas\""]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "It is recognised that in strong doses, 'pepper spray' may cause necrosis of tissue in the respiratory or digestive tract.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. International regulations on the use of \"tear gas\""]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "It is recognised that in strong doses, 'pepper spray' may cause pulmonary oedema.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. International regulations on the use of \"tear gas\""]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "It is recognised that in strong doses, 'pepper spray' may cause internal haemorrhaging, specifically haemorrhaging of the suprarenal gland.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. International regulations on the use of \"tear gas\""]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F018", "F020"], "interference": ["F006", "F012", "F017", "F018"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F033", "F034"], "legitimate_aim": ["F013", "F014", "F031"], "necessity": ["F005", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F018", "F020"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F015", "F016"], "interference": ["F012", "F017", "F018"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F033"], "legitimate_aim": ["F014", "F031"], "necessity": ["F005", "F007", "F008", "F011", "F014", "F015", "F018", "F020"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F007", "F008", "F011", "F014", "F017", "F018", "F020", "F031", "F033"]}} {"case_name": "case_480", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The case concerns the criminal conviction of the applicant for organising and participating in an unlawful demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "On 25 March 2011 a group of about seventy people gathered in front of the Viranşehir (district of Şanlıurfa) branch of the Peace and Democracy Party (the BDP, a pro-Kurdish political party).", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 25 March 2011 the group of about seventy people held a march in Viranşehir (district of Şanlıurfa).", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant was the Vice-President of the Şanlıurfa branch of the Peace and Democracy Party (the BDP, a pro-Kurdish political party).", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant delivered a speech to the demonstrators at the end of the march on 25 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "In his speech at the end of the march on 25 March 2011, the applicant said: 'We request that the persecutions happening in this country be ended, that our friends arrested in relation to the KCK [Koma Civakên Kurdistan – Kurdistan Communities Union] incident be released, that the electoral thresholds be lowered and that the teaching of our mother tongue [and] education in our mother tongue be guaranteed under the Constitution. We will continue this protest until our requests are granted. We will never kneel down...'", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 6 April 2011 the Viranşehir Chief Public Prosecutor's Office indicted the applicant in the Viranşehir Criminal Court of First Instance (the Criminal Court).", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant was indicted under section 28(1) of the Meetings and Demonstrations Act (Law no. 2911) for organising and participating in an unlawful demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The bill of indictment referred, inter alia, to the applicant's speech delivered during the demonstration of 25 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The bill of indictment referred to slogans chanted by the demonstrators during the demonstration of 25 March 2011, including 'Biji Serok Apo' ('Long live President Apo') and 'Şehit namırın' ('Martyrs are immortal').", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "At the hearing of 11 October 2011, the applicant argued that the applicant had expressed his opinions in the speech at issue, which had not contained any criminal elements.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "At the hearing of 11 October 2011, the applicant's lawyer argued that the applicant had expressed his opinions in the speech at issue, which had not contained any criminal elements.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "At the hearing of 11 October 2011, the applicant maintained that he had not led the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "At the hearing of 11 October 2011, the applicant maintained that the police had neither ordered the demonstrators to disperse nor warned them that the demonstration had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "At the hearing of 17 November 2011, the applicant's lawyer argued that the demonstration in question had not been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 17 November 2011 the Viranşehir Criminal Court of First Instance (the Criminal Court) convicted the applicant as charged under section 28(1) of the Meetings and Demonstrations Act (Law no. 2911) for organising and participating in an unlawful demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Viranşehir Criminal Court of First Instance (the Criminal Court) sentenced the applicant to one year and three months' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Viranşehir Criminal Court of First Instance (the Criminal Court) suspended the pronouncement of the judgment for a probationary period of five years, pursuant to Article 231 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Viranşehir Criminal Court of First Instance (the Criminal Court) noted that the demonstration of 25 March 2011 had been held without the requisite prior notification.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Viranşehir Criminal Court of First Instance (the Criminal Court) noted that the demonstration of 25 March 2011 had been held in contravention of the conditions provided for by the law.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Viranşehir Criminal Court of First Instance (the Criminal Court) held that the applicant had taken part in the organisation of the demonstration of 25 March 2011, bearing in mind that he had been the Vice-President of the Şanlıurfa branch of the Peace and Democracy Party (the BDP).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Viranşehir Criminal Court of First Instance (the Criminal Court) held that the applicant had taken part in the organisation of the demonstration of 25 March 2011, bearing in mind that he had had influence over the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Viranşehir Criminal Court of First Instance (the Criminal Court) referred to the applicant's speech of 25 March 2011 in its reasoning for convicting the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 2 March 2012 the Şanlıurfa Assize Court dismissed an objection lodged by the applicant against the decision to suspend the pronouncement of the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant complained that his criminal conviction had breached Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant complained that his criminal conviction had breached Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002", "F003", "F005", "F006", "F010", "F016", "F023"], "interference": ["F016", "F017", "F018"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F008", "F016"], "legitimate_aim": ["F019", "F020"], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F005", "F006", "F010", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F005", "F006", "F010"], "interference": ["F016", "F017", "F018"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F008", "F016"], "legitimate_aim": ["F019"], "necessity": ["F006", "F010", "F017", "F018", "F019"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F005", "F006", "F010", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019"]}} {"case_name": "case_481", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1951.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Vienna.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 30 October 1998, the applicant notified the Salzburg Federal Police Authority (Bundespolizeidirektion) under section 2 of the Assembly Act (Versammlungsgesetz) of a planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant is a member of parliament for the Green Party.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant notified the Salzburg Federal Police Authority that on All Saints' Day, 1 November 1998, from 9 a.m. until 1 p.m., he would be holding a meeting at the Salzburg municipal cemetery in front of the war memorial.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant noted that the planned meeting would coincide with the gathering of Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant considered the gathering of Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) to be unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The purpose of the applicant's planned meeting was to commemorate the Salzburg Jews killed by the SS during the Second World War.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant expected about six participants at the planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The participants of the applicant's planned meeting would carry commemorative messages in their hands and attached to their clothes.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant stated that no other means of expression, such as chanting or banners, which might offend piety or undermine public order would be used at the planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 31 October 1998, the Salzburg Federal Police Authority prohibited the applicant's planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority relied on section 6 of the Assembly Act (Versammlungsgesetz) when prohibiting the applicant's planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority relied on Article 11 of the Convention when prohibiting the applicant's planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority prohibited the applicant's planned meeting on the ground that it would endanger public order and security.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "F.E. is also a member of parliament for the Green Party.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "F.E. had informed the Salzburg Federal Police Authority of the allegedly illegal assembly of Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) in memory of the SS soldiers killed in the Second World War.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The assembly of Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) was to be held at the same time and place as the applicant's planned meeting, namely on 1 November 1998 at the Salzburg municipal cemetery in front of the war memorial.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "F.E. refused to give an undertaking that the proposed meeting in memory of the murdered Salzburg Jews would not disrupt the Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) gathering.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority noted that Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) was a registered association.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV), like a number of other organisations, traditionally held a commemoration ceremony at the Salzburg municipal cemetery on All Saints' Day.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority noted that such commemorations by Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) qualified as popular ceremonies within the meaning of section 5 of the Assembly Act (Versammlungsgesetz) and thus did not require authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority found that disruption of the Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) commemoration ceremony and other commemoration ceremonies was likely to offend the religious feelings of members of the public visiting the cemetery.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority found that disruption of the commemoration ceremonies would indisputably be regarded as disrespectful towards the dead soldiers of both world wars and thus as an unbearable provocation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority found that there was a risk of protests by visitors to the cemetery which could degenerate into open conflict between them and those participating in the applicant's planned assembly.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Salzburg Federal Police Authority ordered that any remedies used against its decision to prohibit the applicant's planned meeting should not have suspensive effect.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "As a result of the Salzburg Federal Police Authority's order that remedies should not have suspensive effect, the applicant's planned demonstration could not take place.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 17 August 1999, the Salzburg Public Security Authority (Sicherheitsdirektion) dismissed an appeal by the applicant against the prohibition of his planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Salzburg Public Security Authority (Sicherheitsdirektion) noted that Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) was a registered association whose members were mainly former members of the SS.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "For more than forty years, members of Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) had commemorated SS soldiers killed in the Second World War by gathering on All Saints' Day and laying a wreath in front of the war memorial at the Salzburg municipal cemetery.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "In the years prior to 1999, a number of organisations had organised protest campaigns with the aim of disrupting the Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) commemoration ceremony.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The protest campaigns against the Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) commemoration ceremony had led to vehement discussions with members of Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) and other visitors to the cemetery.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The protest campaigns against the Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) commemoration ceremony had required intervention by the police.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Salzburg Public Security Authority (Sicherheitsdirektion), referring to the submissions of F.E., found that the assembly planned by the applicant was also aimed at a confrontation with Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Salzburg Public Security Authority (Sicherheitsdirektion) concluded that the prohibition of the applicant's planned assembly was necessary for the maintenance of public order.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Salzburg Public Security Authority (Sicherheitsdirektion) concluded that the prohibition of the applicant's planned assembly was necessary for the protection of the Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) commemoration ceremony.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 13 December 2000, the Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) dismissed a complaint by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant's complaint to the Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) alleged violations of his right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicant's complaint to the Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) alleged violations of his right to freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicant's complaint to the Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) alleged violations of his right to freedom of religion.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicant's complaint to the Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) alleged violations of his right to non-discrimination.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) observed that the authorities deciding on the prohibition of an assembly had to weigh the applicant's interest in holding the meeting against the public interests enumerated in Article 11 § 2 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) stated that the prohibition of the applicant's proposed meeting would not be justified if its sole purpose were to protect the Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) commemoration ceremony.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) expressed doubts as to the authorities' assessment that the Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) commemoration was a popular ceremony within the meaning of section 5 of the Assembly Act (Versammlungsgesetz) and therefore did not require authorisation.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) found that the prohibition of the applicant's planned meeting was justified for reasons other than the protection of the Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) commemoration ceremony.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) noted that the gathering of Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) had in previous years been the target of activities aimed at disrupting it.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) noted that the activities aimed at disrupting the Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) gathering had caused considerable nuisance to other visitors of the cemetery.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) noted that the activities aimed at disrupting the Comradeship IV (Kameradschaft IV) gathering had each time required police intervention.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) found that the authorities had correctly assumed that the prohibition of the assembly planned by the applicant was necessary to protect the general public against potential disturbances.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) observed that All Saints' Day is an important religious holiday on which the population traditionally visits cemeteries in order to commemorate the dead.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) observed that the commemoration of the dead as a religious tradition is protected by Article 9 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) observed that Article 9 of the Convention contains a positive obligation for the State to protect persons manifesting their religion against deliberate disturbance by others.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) found that the prohibition of the applicant's assembly was necessary under Article 11 § 2 of the Convention for the protection of the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof) found that the prohibition of the applicant's assembly did not violate any other Convention right relied on by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Constitutional Court's (Verfassungsgerichtshof) decision of 13 December 2000 was served on the applicant's counsel on 5 February 2001.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Assembly Act 1953 (Versammlungsgesetz) regulates the exercise of the right to freedom of assembly in Austria.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Section 2(1) of the Assembly Act 1953 (Versammlungsgesetz) provides that any person intending to organise a public assembly or any assembly which is generally open to persons other than invited guests must give the authorities notice in writing at least twenty-four hours in advance.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Section 2(1) of the Assembly Act 1953 (Versammlungsgesetz) requires that the written notice indicate the purpose, place and time of the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Pursuant to section 5 of the Assembly Act 1953 (Versammlungsgesetz), certain gatherings such as public entertainment, popular ceremonies or religious processions do not fall within the scope of the Assembly Act 1953 (Versammlungsgesetz).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Pursuant to section 6 of the Assembly Act 1953 (Versammlungsgesetz), the competent authority must prohibit any assembly which would contravene criminal law or endanger public order and security.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F005", "F008", "F006", "F018", "F029", "F004", "F010", "F011", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F009"], "interference": ["F012", "F026", "F027"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F013", "F060"], "legitimate_aim": ["F015", "F023", "F025", "F021", "F050", "F046", "F047", "F048"], "necessity": ["F004", "F006", "F008", "F018", "F029", "F005", "F010", "F011", "F009", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F012", "F027", "F015", "F035", "F036", "F043", "F026"], "positive_obligation": ["F045", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F012"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F005", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F029"], "interference": ["F012", "F026", "F027"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F013", "F060"], "legitimate_aim": ["F015", "F023", "F050"], "necessity": ["F004", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F018", "F029", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F035", "F036", "F043"], "positive_obligation": ["F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F031", "F032", "F033"]}, "list3": ["F004", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F027", "F029", "F032", "F033", "F043"]}} {"case_name": "case_482", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1973.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Mersin.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant is a teacher in primary school.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "At the material time, the applicant was a member of the local branch of the trade union of Education and Science Workers (Eğitim ve Bilim Emekçileri Sendikası).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "At the material time, the applicant was secretary of the local branch of the trade union of Education and Science Workers (Eğitim ve Bilim Emekçileri Sendikası).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 28 November 2008, the applicant participated in a demonstration organised by the trade union of Education and Science Workers (Eğitim ve Bilim Emekçileri Sendikası).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The demonstration of 28 November 2008 was held on the theme 'No to violence against women'.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 29 June 2009, the District Directorate of National Education imposed a disciplinary sanction on the applicant in the form of a reprimand.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The disciplinary sanction of reprimand imposed on the applicant on 29 June 2009 was imposed for her participation in the demonstration of 28 November 2008.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The disciplinary sanction of reprimand imposed on the applicant on 29 June 2009 was imposed under Article 125 of Law no. 657 on Civil Servants.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 10 July 2009, the applicant objected to the District Directorate of National Education's decision of 29 June 2009 imposing a reprimand.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 10 July 2009, the applicant requested the annulment of the District Directorate of National Education's decision of 29 June 2009 imposing a reprimand.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 29 July 2009, the Disciplinary Board of the Yenişehir district governor dismissed the applicant's objection to the reprimand decision of 29 June 2009.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Disciplinary Board of the Yenişehir district governor dismissed the applicant's objection on the ground that the contested decision was in accordance with law.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Disciplinary Board of the Yenişehir district governor dismissed the applicant's objection on the ground that there were no grounds for the annulment of the contested decision.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "A full description of relevant domestic law at the material time can be found in Karaçay v. Turkey (no. 6615/03, §§ 14-17, 27 March 2007).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "A full description of relevant domestic law at the material time can be found in İsmail Sezer v. Turkey (no. 36807/07, §§ 14-21, 24 March 2015).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F009"], "interference": ["F008", "F009", "F010"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F008", "F009", "F013", "F014"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F007"], "interference": ["F008", "F009"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F008", "F009"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F006", "F008", "F009"]}} {"case_name": "case_483", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_484", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of a public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The public assembly in which the applicants participated consisted of manifestations for fair elections to the Moscow City Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The manifestations for fair elections to the Moscow City Parliament took place in August 2019 in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention in addition to their complaint about disproportionate measures.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_485", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_486", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention and its Protocol.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_488", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_489", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_492", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1975.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr L. Gevorgyan, a lawyer practising in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Mr L. Gevorgyan later withdrew from the case.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr Y. Kirakosyan.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Mr Y. Kirakosyan holds the position of Representative of the Republic of Armenia to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The facts of the case were submitted by the applicant and were not contested by the Government.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 19 February 2008 a presidential election was held in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the then Prime Minister, Mr Sargsyan, representing the ruling party.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the main opposition candidate, Mr Ter-Petrosyan.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "At the material time, the applicant was the editor-in-chief of Haykakan Zhamanak (\"Armenian Times\"), a daily opposition newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant was an active supporter of Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan's pre-election campaign.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant was a member of Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan's pre-election campaign.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Immediately after the announcement of the preliminary results of the 19 February 2008 presidential election, Mr Ter-Petrosyan called on his supporters to gather at Freedom Square in central Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Mr Ter-Petrosyan called on his supporters to gather at Freedom Square in order to protest against alleged irregularities in the election process.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Mr Ter-Petrosyan announced that the 19 February 2008 presidential election had not been free and fair.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "From 20 February 2008 onwards, nationwide daily protest rallies were held by Mr Ter-Petrosyan's supporters.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The main meeting place of Mr Ter-Petrosyan's supporters during the protest rallies from 20 February 2008 onwards was Freedom Square and the surrounding park in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The rallies at Freedom Square attracted at times tens of thousands of people.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Several hundred demonstrators stayed at Freedom Square and the surrounding area around the clock, having set up a camp.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "A detailed description of the demonstrations at Freedom Square, including the police intervention breaking up the camp and sealing off the square in the early morning of 1 March 2008, can be found in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (no. 23086/08, §§ 7-17, 20 September 2018), Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia (no. 49020/08, §§ 5-15, 15 October 2020) and Dareskizb Ltd v. Armenia (no. 61737/08, §§ 5-12, 21 September 2021).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "A detailed description of the later gathering of several thousand people in the area of the French Embassy, the Yerevan Mayor's Office and the Myasnikyan monument can be found in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (no. 23086/08, §§ 7-17, 20 September 2018), Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia (no. 49020/08, §§ 5-15, 15 October 2020) and Dareskizb Ltd v. Armenia (no. 61737/08, §§ 5-12, 21 September 2021).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "A detailed description of the escalation of tensions between the protesters and the law-enforcement authorities and the resulting violence on 1 March 2008 can be found in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (no. 23086/08, §§ 7-17, 20 September 2018), Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia (no. 49020/08, §§ 5-15, 15 October 2020) and Dareskizb Ltd v. Armenia (no. 61737/08, §§ 5-12, 21 September 2021).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "A detailed description of the declaration of a state of emergency can be found in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (no. 23086/08, §§ 7-17, 20 September 2018), Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia (no. 49020/08, §§ 5-15, 15 October 2020) and Dareskizb Ltd v. Armenia (no. 61737/08, §§ 5-12, 21 September 2021).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "A detailed description of the institution of criminal cases against opposition leaders and activists on 1 and 2 March 2008 can be found in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (no. 23086/08, §§ 7-17, 20 September 2018), Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia (no. 49020/08, §§ 5-15, 15 October 2020) and Dareskizb Ltd v. Armenia (no. 61737/08, §§ 5-12, 21 September 2021).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant alleged that he had actively participated in the demonstrations at Freedom Square, attending them on a daily basis.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant alleged that he regularly gave speeches at the demonstrations at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant alleged that the demonstrations had been peaceful and had aimed at annulling the results of the rigged election and holding a new election.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant alleged that the authorities had responded to the demonstrations by carrying out unlawful persecution and harassment of opposition supporters and those who had given speeches at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicant alleged that on 23 and 24 February 2008 a number of high-ranking officials who had supported or had been suspected of supporting the opposition had been dismissed from office.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant alleged that on 23 and 24 February 2008 a number of opposition leaders and activists had been arrested.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant alleged that the police had attacked and brutally beaten the demonstrators camping at Freedom Square in the early morning of 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant alleged that after the demonstrators had fled to the area of the French Embassy and had been joined by thousands of others, the police and military forces and equipment had started to encircle that area.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The applicant alleged that another brutal attack had been launched on the demonstrators near the French Embassy area, and the demonstrators had had to defend themselves with random objects.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant alleged that the demonstrators had barricaded the area near the French Embassy with public and private vehicles and continued the demonstration peacefully.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicant alleged that he, together with a number of other opposition leaders, had called on the public to stay calm and tried to prevent new clashes by creating a human chain between the police forces and the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant alleged that the demonstrators had been waiting for Mr Ter-Petrosyan's arrival but Mr Ter-Petrosyan had been placed under house arrest in the meantime.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant alleged that several more attacks had been launched on the demonstrators, using not only crowd control weapons but also live ammunition, snipers and military equipment, resulting in up to ten deaths and numerous injured.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Around the same period when criminal cases were instituted against opposition leaders and activists on 1 and 2 March 2008, the applicant went into hiding.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the applicant was formally charged under Article 225 (organising mass disorder) of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the applicant was formally charged under Article 300 (usurpation of State power) of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The charging decision of 4 March 2008 stated that the applicant conspired with presidential candidate Levon Ter-Petrosyan and a number of his supporters to unconstitutionally usurp State power by destabilising the internal political situation in Armenia if Levon Ter-Petrosyan were to suffer a defeat at the presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The charging decision of 4 March 2008 stated that the applicant, together with Levon Ter-Petrosyan and a number of his supporters, starting from the day after the 19 February 2008 election, organised and held in Yerevan continuous mass public events, marches and round-the-clock demonstrations and sit-ins in violation of the procedure prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The charging decision of 4 March 2008 stated that the applicant publicly gave incendiary speeches and made public calls inciting to civil disobedience, disobedience against lawful orders of the law-enforcement authorities and assistance in disintegration of the State system and overthrow of the current government.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The charging decision of 4 March 2008 stated that on 1 March 2008, addressing the crowd gathered at the area adjacent to the Yerevan Mayor's Office as an official election assistant of Levon Ter-Petrosyan, the applicant instigated and organised mass disorder which involved mass violence, widespread massacre, arson, destruction and damage of public and private property, overt looting, armed resistance against public officials, mass assaults on public officials with the use of firearms and explosives, and murders.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 24 March 2009 the charge against the applicant under Article 300 of the Armenian Criminal Code (usurpation of State power) was dropped.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The charge under Article 300 of the Armenian Criminal Code was dropped because that provision had been amended and as a result was no longer applicable.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 1 July 2009 the applicant voluntarily turned himself in to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 3 July 2009 the applicant was brought before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 3 July 2009 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan decided to detain the applicant for a period of two months.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan ordered the applicant's detention on the ground that he was a flight risk and could obstruct the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan took into account the fact that a search had been launched in respect of the applicant when ordering his detention.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 16 July 2009 the Criminal Court of Appeal upheld the decision to detain the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal stated in its 16 July 2009 decision that a search for the applicant had been launched and he had appeared before the investigating authority only one year and four months later.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 27 August 2009 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan extended the applicant's detention by two months on the same grounds as the initial detention order.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 11 September 2009 the Criminal Court of Appeal upheld the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan's decision of 27 August 2009 extending the applicant's detention.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The charges against the applicant and his pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 12 October 2009, following the completion of the investigation, the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan took a decision setting the case down for trial.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "In its 12 October 2009 decision, the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan ruled that the applicant's detention should remain unchanged, reasoning that the applicant had been accused of, among others, a serious crime for which a penalty of from four to ten years' imprisonment is prescribed.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "In its 12 October 2009 decision, the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan stated that, taking into account the nature and dangerousness of the crimes imputed to the applicant and the fact that he had been in hiding and a search had been initiated in his respect, the probability of his absconding if he remained at large was high.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 19 January 2010 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found the applicant guilty under Article 225 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (organising mass disorder).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 19 January 2010 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan sentenced the applicant to seven years' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that Serzh Sargsyan won the presidential election held on 19 February 2008.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant, together with A.A., S.S., H.H., M.M. and S.M. (who had already been convicted under Article 225 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code in a separate set of proceedings) and a number of other persons, starting from 20 February 2008, carried out organisational activities for the purpose of creating discontent in society towards the conduct and results of the election and preparing the crowd gathered at Freedom Square for use of violence and disobedience.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant and others spread false information about the assembly being authorised by the authorities, about around 500,000 people attending it, about the election result being rigged, and about presidential candidate Levon Ter-Petrosyan winning about 60% of the votes cast.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant and others provided demonstrators at Freedom Square with household items and money to ensure their constant presence at the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that rods, clubs, armature, petrol bombs, metal constructions used as missile weapons, firearms and ammunition were distributed to a group of participants of the assembly at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that with the intention of inciting and carrying out mass disorder in Yerevan on 1 March 2008, the members of the group formed groups of people ready to use violence on a mass scale and organised distribution among those persons of illegally obtained firearms, ammunition, explosive substances, explosive devices, bladed weapons and various objects adapted to inflict violence.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan held that, having found out about the imminent arrival of the police forces in the early morning of 1 March 2008, the applicant, together with his co-thinkers, woke up those camping at Freedom Square and called on them to arm themselves and to give a 'proper welcome' to the police.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan held that as a result of the applicant's actions, the crowd attacked the police officers who had approached and asked to carry out an inspection for weapons.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan held that the police operation at Freedom Square eventually led to the discovery of various weapons and ammunition, which had been brought to Freedom Square to be used during the planned mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the participants of the assembly, led by the applicant, A.A. and others, moved to and gathered in the area adjacent to the Myasnikyan monument, an important intersection of several streets in Yerevan situated in the vicinity of the French, Italian and Russian embassies.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that at around 11 a.m. on 1 March 2008 the participants of the mass disorder blocked Grigor Lusavorich Street by placing trolleybuses across the driveway, after which they attacked the police officers who were preserving public order.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the applicant, together with A.A., S.M. and others, rejected the offer made by the authorities to move the assembly to another location for the purpose of preserving public order and ensuring the safety of participants.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the applicant, with his speeches and orders, organised and oversaw keeping the gathered crowd in the same location for as long as possible and derailing its relocation, as well as the process of arming themselves with objects adapted to inflict injuries and other objects at hand, assaulting the police officers and showing active disobedience to their lawful orders.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that, as organised and directly instructed by the applicant, S.S. and others, barricades were created by damaging transportation means and other property and by putting them out of order.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the applicant gave instructions to the demonstrators to arm themselves and to be ready to resist, as well as to recruit new people at any cost.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the applicant continuously circulated among the participants in the mass disorder and organised the formation and dislocation of their groups.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the applicant gave concrete instructions to participants to split into groups, build barricades, arm themselves with stones, sticks and other objects in order to injure the police officers, and grab batons and shields from the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the applicant publicly encouraged the participants in the mass disorder to grab shields and batons from the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the applicant called on soldiers and police officers involved in maintaining public order not to carry out their duties, to join the participants in the mass disorder and to turn their weapons towards the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the applicant gave concrete instructions on how to reinforce positions and to prepare for new acts of violence.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the applicant made public declarations about areas captured by the participants in the disorder and declared that all the soldiers had fled and the entire process was under their control, in order to keep the participants in the mass disorder around and to inspire them.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the applicant regularly invited other organisers of the mass disorder for consultations in order to organise and coordinate the activities of its participants.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found that the applicant regularly exchanged information with A.A. and S.S. about the massacre, arson, intentional destruction, damage and looting of property taking place on Grigor Lusavorich, Mashtots, Leo and Paronyan streets of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan concluded that the events in question amounted to 'mass disorder' within the meaning of Article 225 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan concluded that the applicant's actions fell within the scope of Article 225 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "On 19 February 2010 the applicant lodged an appeal against his conviction.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "In his appeal of 19 February 2010, the applicant argued that his conviction had violated the guarantees of Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "In his appeal of 19 February 2010, the applicant argued that his conviction had violated the guarantees of Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "In his appeal of 19 February 2010, the applicant alleged that the authorities had embarked on a campaign of political repression against the supporters of Mr Ter-Petrosyan before and during the peaceful demonstrations held at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "In his appeal of 19 February 2010, the applicant alleged that the authorities had initiated unlawful criminal prosecution of supporters of Mr Ter-Petrosyan following the dispersal of the assembly on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "In his appeal of 19 February 2010, the applicant argued that the speeches made at Freedom Square involved neither incitement to violence nor a violent overthrow of the government, and that Freedom Square had become an important platform for public debate on a topic of significant public concern.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "In his appeal of 19 February 2010, the applicant argued that the leaders of the opposition regularly stressed in their speeches the importance of adhering to the rule of law.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "In his appeal of 19 February 2010, the applicant denied that he had guided the demonstrators to the area of the Yerevan Mayor's Office and the Myasnikyan monument, submitting that the demonstrators had fled to that area on escaping from the police and being pursued by them after their brutal dispersal from Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "In his appeal of 19 February 2010, the applicant contested that the actions of the demonstrators could be characterised as 'mass disorder' and argued that, even assuming they could, the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan had failed to indicate any concrete actions taken by him towards the organisation of such mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "In his appeal of 19 February 2010, the applicant argued that there had been no preliminary agreement between the so-called organisers of the alleged mass disorder and that some of them had not even been familiar with each other before meeting for the first time in court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "In his appeal of 19 February 2010, the applicant argued that he had never incited to violence or any other actions which could be characterised as 'mass disorder'.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "In his appeal of 19 February 2010, the applicant argued that when he arrived at the vicinity of the Yerevan Mayor's Office, the demonstrators had already barricaded themselves and detached various objects from a nearby construction site for self-defence.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "On 9 March 2010 the Criminal Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal and upheld his conviction.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal held in its 9 March 2010 decision that the applicant had participated in the assembly held from 20 February to 1 March 2008, during which he had availed himself of his freedom of expression by freely imparting information and ideas without any interference by the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal held in its 9 March 2010 decision that during the demonstrations held in various parts of Yerevan the applicant had committed a criminal offence, namely organising mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal held in its 9 March 2010 decision that the applicant had been prosecuted for criminal conduct during the demonstrations, rather than for his participation in the demonstrations and expressing his opinion, and therefore there had not been an interference with the applicant's right to freedom of peaceful assembly under Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal held in its 9 March 2010 decision that, taking into account the weapons and ammunition found at Freedom Square, the assembly at Freedom Square had not been peaceful, and nor had the assembly in the area adjacent to the Yerevan Mayor's Office.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On 10 April 2010 the applicant lodged an appeal on points of law.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "On 30 April 2010 the Court of Cassation of Armenia declared the applicant's appeal on points of law inadmissible for lack of merit.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "A summary of the relevant provisions of the Armenian Criminal Code (2003) can be found in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (no. 23086/08, §§ 94, 96 and 97, 20 September 2018) and Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia (no. 49020/08, §§ 44-47, 15 October 2020).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "A. Criminal Code (2003)"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Relevant extracts of the Armenian Ombudsman's Ad Hoc Public Report on the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments regarding the presidential election and the post-election events can be found in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (no. 23086/08, § 124, 20 September 2018) and Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia (no. 49020/08, § 49, 15 October 2020).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND OTHER MATERIALS", "B. Ad Hoc Public Report of Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman): On the 2008 February 19 Presidential Election and the Post-Electoral Developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "In its Resolutions regarding the 19 February 2008 presidential election and the events that followed, the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe condemned the arrest and continuing detention of scores of persons, including more than 100 opposition supporters and three members of parliament.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe condemned the arrest and continuing detention of opposition supporters and members of parliament on seemingly artificial and politically motivated charges, especially those under Articles 225 and 300 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Relevant extracts of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Resolutions and a number of other relevant international materials regarding the 19 February 2008 presidential election and post-election events can be found in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia (no. 23086/08, §§ 125-34, 20 September 2018) and Myasnik Malkhasyan v. Armenia (no. 49020/08, §§ 50-57, 15 October 2020).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F008", "F012", "F013", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F066", "F067", "F068", "F069", "F070"], "interference": ["F040", "F060", "F061", "F063"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F025", "F040", "F041", "F060", "F061", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F066", "F067", "F070", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F077", "F078", "F079", "F081", "F082", "F083", "F084", "F108", "F109"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F012", "F017", "F018", "F021", "F023", "F068", "F070"], "interference": ["F040", "F060", "F061", "F063"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F060", "F061", "F063", "F066", "F074", "F078", "F081", "F108", "F109"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F012", "F017", "F018", "F060", "F061", "F063", "F066", "F074", "F078", "F108", "F109"]}} {"case_name": "case_493", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants are forty-eight Hungarian nationals.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants were creditors of an insolvent private company, together with 40,000 other individuals.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants were unable to obtain their outstanding claims from the insolvent private company.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants intended to hold a series of demonstrations between 7 July and 20 August 2004 in front of the Prime Minister's private residence in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant submitted photographs of the scene of the proposed demonstration events.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "According to photographs submitted by the applicant, the Prime Minister's house is situated on a two-lane road in a residential area composed of villas.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Across the street from the Prime Minister's property, between parked cars and the fence of another villa, there is a footpath parallel to which is a strip of grass which is over five metres wide.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant stated that the participants in the planned demonstrations intended only to occupy the pedestrian zone across the street from the Prime Minister's house.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The first applicant, István Patyi, was the main organiser of the planned demonstration events.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "István Patyi notified the Budapest Police Department of the planned demonstrations as prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 5 July 2004 the Budapest Police Department prohibited the planned demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant sought judicial review of the Budapest Police Department's decision of 5 July 2004 prohibiting the demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 8 July 2004 the Budapest Regional Court quashed the Budapest Police Department's decision of 5 July 2004 prohibiting the demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 8 July 2004 the Budapest Regional Court remitted the case to the Budapest Police Department.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "In the resumed proceedings following the Budapest Regional Court's decision of 8 July 2004, the Budapest Police Department again prohibited the demonstrations on 10 July 2004.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicant sought judicial review of the Budapest Police Department's decision of 10 July 2004 prohibiting the demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 15 July 2004 the Budapest Regional Court dismissed the applicant's action against the Budapest Police Department's decision of 10 July 2004.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In the meantime, the applicant and some fifteen other private individuals appeared before the Prime Minister's house.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the applicant's submissions, the applicant and the fifteen other private individuals appeared before the Prime Minister's house disguising themselves as tourists.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The police were present when the applicant and the fifteen other private individuals appeared before the Prime Minister's house.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant informed the police that he and the other individuals did not intend to demonstrate.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant and the fifteen other private individuals were not prevented from walking in front of the Prime Minister's house and they then left the scene undisturbed.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant and the fifteen other private individuals did not cause any hindrance or inconvenience to the traffic or other pedestrians.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Subsequently, the applicant notified the police of another demonstration planned for 1 November 2004, for the same reasons as the earlier demonstrations and at the same spot in front of the Prime Minister's house in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The planned number of demonstrators for the 1 November 2004 demonstration was twenty.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The head of the Budapest Police Department prohibited the 1 November 2004 demonstration on 28 October 2004, relying on section 8 of Act no. III of 1989 on the Right of Assembly.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The Budapest Police Department was of the view that the pavement in front of the Prime Minister's house was not wide enough to secure the necessary space for the demonstrators and other pedestrians at the same time.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Budapest Police Department determined that, in order to prevent possible accidents and confrontations between the demonstrators and passers-by, it would be necessary to close half the street in front of the Prime Minister's house.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Budapest Police Department pointed out that on the street in front of the Prime Minister's house three bus services operated on a regular basis.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Budapest Police Department noted that on 1 November 2004, All Saints' Day, the traffic was expected to be heavier since many people would visit cemeteries that day.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Budapest Police Department obtained the expert opinion of the Department of Traffic Administration regarding the 1 November 2004 demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Budapest Police Department held that the 1 November 2004 demonstration would cause a disproportionate hindrance to the traffic, which could not be secured by alternative means.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant sought judicial review of the Budapest Police Department's decision of 28 October 2004 prohibiting the 1 November 2004 demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 5 November 2004 the Budapest Regional Court dismissed the applicant's action against the Budapest Police Department's decision prohibiting the 1 November 2004 demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court established on 5 November 2004 that the Budapest Police Department's decision prohibiting the 1 November 2004 demonstration had been in compliance with the law and in particular with Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Subsequently, the applicants intended to organise other demonstrations limited to twenty persons.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 18 November 2004 the applicant notified the Budapest Police Department that demonstrations were to take place on 30 November, 1 December, 14 December and in the afternoon of 24 December 2004, again in front of the Prime Minister's house in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 19 November 2004 the head of the Budapest Police Department prohibited the demonstrations planned for 30 November, 1 December, 14 December and the afternoon of 24 December 2004.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Budapest Police Department reiterated that the pavement in front of the Prime Minister's house was not wide enough to secure the necessary space for the demonstrators and other pedestrians at the same time.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Budapest Police Department determined that, in order to prevent possible accidents and confrontations between the demonstrators and passers-by, half the street in front of the Prime Minister's house would need to be closed.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Budapest Police Department pointed out that on the street in front of the Prime Minister's house three bus services operated on a regular basis.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Budapest Police Department noted that in winter, the traffic on the street in front of the Prime Minister's house was expected to be heavier since many people left for the ski resorts around Budapest via that street.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Budapest Police Department noted that there was a possibility of heavy snowfalls and that it would be difficult to secure alternative routes.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Budapest Police Department obtained the expert opinion of the Department of Traffic Administration regarding the demonstrations planned for 30 November, 1 December, 14 December and 24 December 2004.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Budapest Police Department held that the demonstrations planned for 30 November, 1 December, 14 December and 24 December 2004 would cause a disproportionate hindrance to the traffic, in particular to the buses, which could not be secured by alternative means.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicant sought judicial review of the Budapest Police Department's decision of 19 November 2004 prohibiting the demonstrations planned for 30 November, 1 December, 14 December and 24 December 2004.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant stated that his aim was to hold peaceful, silent demonstrations lasting only twenty minutes.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant stated that the only action planned for the demonstrations was to stand in line in front of the Prime Minister's house, with twenty participants.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 26 November 2004 the Budapest Regional Court dismissed the applicant's motion seeking judicial review of the Budapest Police Department's decision of 19 November 2004.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court established on 26 November 2004 that the Budapest Police Department's decision prohibiting the demonstrations planned for 30 November, 1 December, 14 December and 24 December 2004 had been in compliance with the law and the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 12 December 2004 the Budapest Public Transportation Company officially informed the applicant that on 24 December 2004 no buses would be running after 4.19 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The circumstances of the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Constitution of the Republic of Hungary (Act no. 20 of 1949 as amended), Article 62, provides that the Republic of Hungary acknowledges the right to peaceful assembly and secures its free exercise.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Relevant domestic law", "1. Constitution of the Republic of Hungary"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Section 2(3) of Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly provides that the exercise of freedom of assembly shall not constitute a crime or an incitement to crime and should not result in the infringement of the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Relevant domestic law", "2. Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Section 6 of Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly provides that the organisation of an event held in the public domain shall be notified to the competent police headquarters according to the place of the event, and in Budapest to the Budapest Police Headquarters, three days prior to the planned date of the event, and that the obligation to notify the police lies with the organiser of the event.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Relevant domestic law", "2. Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Section 8(1) of Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly (as in force at the relevant time) provides that if the holding of an event subject to prior notification seriously endangers the proper functioning of the representative bodies or courts, or the circulation of traffic cannot be secured by another route, the police may ban the holding of the event at the place or time indicated in the notification, within forty-eight hours of receipt of the notification by the authority.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Relevant domestic law", "2. Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Section 9(1) of Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly provides that no appeal shall lie against the decision of the police, but the organiser may seek judicial review of the administrative decision within three days of its notification.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Relevant domestic law", "2. Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Section 14(1) of Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly (as in force at the relevant time) provides that the police shall disperse an event if the exercise of the right to freedom of assembly contravenes section 2(3), or if the participants appear at the event in possession of arms, or if an event subject to prior notification is held without notification or despite a decision banning the event.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Relevant domestic law", "2. Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Section 14(3) of Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly (as in force at the relevant time) provides that if an event is dispersed, the participants may seek judicial review within fifteen days with a view to the establishment of the illegality of the dispersal.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Relevant domestic law", "2. Act no. 3 of 1989 on Freedom of Assembly"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F009", "F010", "F024", "F037", "F002", "F003", "F025", "F036", "F047", "F048"], "interference": ["F026", "F038"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F054", "F055", "F057"], "legitimate_aim": ["F027", "F029", "F041"], "necessity": ["F005", "F007", "F008", "F023", "F025", "F026", "F034", "F036", "F038", "F039", "F047", "F048", "F049", "F051"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F009", "F010", "F002", "F025", "F047", "F048"], "interference": ["F026", "F038"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F055"], "legitimate_aim": ["F029"], "necessity": ["F007", "F025", "F047", "F048", "F051", "F038", "F039"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F007", "F025", "F047", "F048", "F051", "F039", "F026", "F038"]}} {"case_name": "case_494", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1965.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant intended to organise demonstrations in order to call attention to the situation of those having sustained damage originating in a major bankruptcy case which had attracted considerable media attention in Hungary.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 5 February 2007 the applicant applied to the Budapest Police Department for acquiescence in a demonstration on 10 March 2007 scheduled in Kossuth Square, in front of Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 5 February 2007 the applicant applied to the Budapest Police Department for acquiescence in a demonstration of ongoing nature, from 10 March until 31 October 2007, scheduled in Kossuth Square, in front of Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 7 February 2007 the Budapest Police Department refused to deal with the applicant's application for acquiescence in a demonstration on 10 March 2007.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 7 February 2007 the Budapest Police Department refused to deal with the applicant's application for acquiescence in an ongoing demonstration from 10 March until 31 October 2007.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 23 October 2006 the Budapest Police Department declared the area of Kossuth Square, in front of Parliament, a \"security operational zone\" (biztonsági műveleti terület) in view of the tumultuous events in Budapest in September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The \"security operational zone\" declaration was, after a prolongation, in place for an indefinite period of time.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Budapest Police Department observed that the \"security operational zone\" measure remained outside the Budapest Police Department's competence as regards the prohibition of, or acquiescence in, a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 5 March 2007 the National Police Commander upheld the Budapest Police Department's decision of 7 February 2007 refusing to deal with the applicant's applications.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 14 January 2008 the Budapest Regional Court dismissed the applicant's request for judicial review of the police authorities' decisions.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court's dismissal of the applicant's request for judicial review endorsed in essence the police authorities' reasoning.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court's decision of 14 January 2008 was served on the applicant on 26 January 2008.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 29 January 2007 a Mr K. challenged the Budapest Police Department's decision to declare Kossuth Square a \"security operational zone\".", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 14 March 2007 the Budapest Police Commander rejected Mr K.'s complaint challenging the declaration of Kossuth Square as a \"security operational zone\".", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Budapest Police Commander's decision of 14 March 2007 rejecting Mr K.'s complaint was quashed by the National Police Commander on 16 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In the resumed administrative proceedings, on 22 June 2007 the Budapest Police Commander again rejected Mr K.'s complaint challenging the declaration of Kossuth Square as a \"security operational zone\".", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 19 July 2007 the National Police Commander upheld the Budapest Police Commander's decision of 22 June 2007 rejecting Mr K.'s complaint.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Mr K. challenged the National Police Commander's ruling of 19 July 2007 in court.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Mr K.'s court action challenging the National Police Commander's ruling of 19 July 2007 was dismissed by the Budapest Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On appeal, the Supreme Court quashed the Budapest Regional Court's decision dismissing Mr K.'s action.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On appeal, the Supreme Court quashed the National Police Commander's decision of 19 July 2007.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "In the resumed second-instance administrative proceedings, on 23 December 2009 the National Police Commander again upheld the Budapest Police Commander's decision rejecting Mr K.'s complaint.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Mr K. requested judicial review of the National Police Commander's decision of 23 December 2009.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 11 November 2010 the Budapest Regional Court, in judgment no. 27.K.31.354/2010/9., quashed both the first-instance and the second-instance administrative decisions concerning Mr K.'s complaint about the \"security operational zone\" in Kossuth Square.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 11 November 2010 the Budapest Regional Court, in judgment no. 27.K.31.354/2010/9., remitted the case to the Budapest Police Commander.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court pointed out in judgment no. 27.K.31.354/2010/9. that the impugned administrative decisions did not contain any concrete elements establishing the necessity and proportionality of maintaining the \"security operational zone\" after the prolongation of 22 November 2006.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court pointed out in judgment no. 27.K.31.354/2010/9. that the impugned administrative decisions did not address Mr K.'s suggestion that the mere fencing-off of Parliament's immediate vicinity — rather than the global ban on Kossuth Square — would have been sufficient in the circumstances.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "In the resumed first-instance administrative proceedings, on 4 April 2011 the Budapest Police Commander partly sustained Mr K.'s complaint.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Budapest Police Commander, in partly sustaining Mr K.'s complaint on 4 April 2011, noted that, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, the proportionality of the \"security operational zone\" measure had successfully been challenged.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F005"], "interference": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F010"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F008", "F009", "F015", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F030", "F031"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F005"], "interference": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F010"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F008", "F009", "F015", "F026", "F028", "F030", "F031"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F004", "F006", "F008", "F026", "F031"]}} {"case_name": "case_495", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants or organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_496", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants raised complaints other than disproportionate measures under provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_497", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1961 and lives in Malatya.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1972 and lives in Malatya.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1985 and lives in Malatya.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The fourth applicant was born in 1956 and lives in Malatya.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The fifth applicant was born in 1962 and lives in Malatya.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The facts of the case are in dispute between the applicants and the Government.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The facts as presented by the applicants are set out in section B of the judgment (paragraphs 7-13).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Government's submissions concerning the facts are summarised in section C of the judgment (paragraphs 14-20).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The documentary evidence submitted by the applicants and the Government is summarised in section D of the judgment (paragraphs 21-41).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Introduction"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 8 March 2005 the applicants took part in International Women's Day celebrations in the city of Malatya.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "During the International Women's Day celebrations on 8 March 2005 in Malatya, a group comprising hundreds of police officers formed a cordon around the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "During the International Women's Day celebrations on 8 March 2005 in Malatya, the police chief warned the participants that no prior permission had been obtained for the gathering.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The first applicant, Ms Nihal Pekaslan, was a spokesperson for the Women's Democratic Platform.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The first applicant, Ms Nihal Pekaslan, told the police chief that the applicants were exercising their constitutional right.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The first applicant, Ms Nihal Pekaslan, told the police chief that the applicable legislation required no prior permission for the gathering.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Police officers dragged a number of persons, including four of the applicants, into waiting police vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "In the course of dragging persons into police vehicles, police officers sprayed the crowds with tear gas.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In the course of dragging persons into police vehicles, police officers hit some of the crowd, including four of the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir, was not arrested on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir, was not beaten up during the events of 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir, was sprayed with tear gas during the events of 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir, was accompanied by her eleven-year-old daughter during the events of 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir, was accompanied by her mother during the events of 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The eleven-year-old daughter of the second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir, was sprayed with tear gas during the events of 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The mother of the second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir, was sprayed with tear gas during the events of 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "Ill-treatment of the detained women continued in the police vehicles after their arrest on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "Male police officers started squeezing the arms and legs of the detained women inside the police vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The detained women told the police officers that the police officers had no right to behave as they were behaving.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The detained women asked for female police officers to accompany them in the police vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "When the detained women told the police officers they had no right to behave as they were and asked for female police officers, the detained women were sworn at by the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The episode of ill-treatment in the police vehicles lasted for approximately twenty minutes.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The four arrested applicants were taken to a police station on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "After being taken to a police station, the four arrested applicants were subsequently taken to the Forensic Medicine Institute for a medical examination on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to medical reports drawn up on 8 March 2005, the four applicants who had been hit by police officers had a number of injuries on their bodies.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "According to medical reports drawn up on 8 March 2005, the injuries sustained by the four applicants rendered them unable to work for periods of between one and three days.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Later on 8 March 2005, the four arrested applicants were released from police custody.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 8 March 2005 the applicants took part in International Women's Day celebrations in Malatya, according to the Government's submissions.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, three different groups of demonstrators were present at the International Women's Day celebrations in Malatya on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the demonstrators at the International Women's Day celebrations in Malatya on 8 March 2005 were carrying placards, flags and posters.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the demonstrations at the International Women's Day celebrations in Malatya on 8 March 2005 hindered the flow of traffic.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, a group of police officers tried to convince the demonstrators to disperse on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, police officers requested the demonstrators to hold their demonstrations without impeding the circulation of traffic on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, a police chief warned the participants on 8 March 2005 that no prior permission had been obtained for the gathering.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the police chief told the participants on 8 March 2005 that they could carry on with their demonstration on the pavement and walk in an orderly manner without violating public order.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the group of demonstrators, including the applicants, refused to disperse and continued with their demonstration on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the police chief made several unsuccessful attempts to tell the participants that the manner in which they were conducting their demonstration was unlawful because they were impeding the flow of traffic.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the police chief told the participants that they could leave their placards — which were too large — and walk on the pavement, and that the placards would be returned to them later.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the group of demonstrators insisted on blocking the street and continued with their demonstration on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the demonstrators shouted slogans and continued to protest despite police officers' warnings and efforts on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, ten to fifteen police officers formed a cordon around the participants who had been giving orders to the rest of the demonstrators on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the demonstrators inside the police cordon continued to protest, saying that they would not end the illegal demonstration even if they were arrested.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, police officers put a number of persons, including four of the applicants, into waiting police vehicles by force on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the force used to put the persons into the police vehicles could not be considered disproportionate.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the four arrested applicants and other persons were taken to the Malatya Court House on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, on the way to the Malatya Court House the applicants insulted the police officers present in the vehicle and tried to provoke them.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the police officers kept their calm despite the applicants' behaviour in the vehicle on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, female demonstrators were accompanied by female police officers in the vehicle on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the remaining members of the group who had not been arrested continued with their demonstration on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the remaining members of the group who had not been arrested read out their press release after having complied with the police officers' request to fold their placards and walk on the pavement.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Government submitted video footage of the incident on 8 March 2005 to the Court.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Government argued that the video footage of the incident supported their submissions about the events of 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The Government's submissions on the facts"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The following information emerges from the documents submitted by the parties.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "According to a report signed by eighteen police officers, at 2.00 p.m. on 8 March 2005, police received intelligence that a number of non-governmental organisations were planning to gather at the junction of Milli Egemenlik Street with a view to marching from there to the square outside the post office.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "According to a report signed by eighteen police officers, the police put in place all necessary security measures at the junction of Milli Egemenlik Street at 11.00 a.m. on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "According to a report signed by eighteen police officers, the demonstrators began arriving at the junction of Milli Egemenlik Street at midday on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "According to a report signed by eighteen police officers, police officers unsuccessfully urged the demonstrators not to march with their placards to the square, where a press release was scheduled to be read out.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "According to a report signed by eighteen police officers, when the demonstrators ignored the police and started marching, they blocked a main road.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "According to a report signed by eighteen police officers, police officers had to use force to arrest the applicants — with the exception of the second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir — and five other demonstrators because they resisted arrest and insulted the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "According to another police report drawn up on 8 March 2005, the arrested persons behaved in a rowdy manner while being transported to the Malatya Court House in a vehicle.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "According to another police report drawn up on 8 March 2005, the arrested persons insulted the police officers present in the vehicle by shouting things such as 'Who do you think you are? You have no right to behave like this. Shame on you, are you going to tell your children that you are torturers?'.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Government submitted to the Court video footage of the incidents recorded by police officers on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The part of the video footage where the police officers used force and arrested the applicants does not feature in the footage submitted to the Court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The video footage begins with police officers trying to persuade the demonstrators to leave their placards behind.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The video footage resumes with the demonstrators protesting against the use of force by the police officers and asking for their arrested friends to be released.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "It can be seen from the video footage that before they were arrested the applicants drew the police officers' attention to a circular issued by the Ministry of the Interior on 11 June 2004.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "A copy of the circular issued by the Ministry of the Interior on 11 June 2004 was made available to the Court by the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "In the circular issued by the Ministry of the Interior on 11 June 2004, the Ministry urges police officers to respect certain rights and freedoms, including freedom of expression and assembly.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "In the circular issued by the Ministry of the Interior on 11 June 2004, the Ministry reminds police officers that rights and freedoms including freedom of expression and assembly can only be restricted in limited circumstances.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "In the circular issued by the Ministry of the Interior on 11 June 2004, police officers are urged to show restraint when faced with demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "In the circular issued by the Ministry of the Interior on 11 June 2004, police officers are urged to use their powers to promote the rights of civil society.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 8 March 2005 the four arrested applicants were examined by doctors at the local branch of the Forensic Medicine Institute.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "According to the medical report of 8 March 2005, Ms Nihal Pekaslan had four ecchymosed areas measuring between one and five centimetres on both forearms and on the left hand, and grazes on both forearms and on the left hand.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "According to the medical report of 8 March 2005, Ms Nihal Pekaslan's injuries prevented her from working for three days.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "According to the medical report of 8 March 2005, Ms Kıvanç Pekaslan had an ecchymosed area measuring 2 x 2 centimetres on the inside of the right arm.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "According to the medical report of 8 March 2005, Ms Kıvanç Pekaslan's injury prevented her from working for one day.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "According to the medical report of 8 March 2005, Mr İbrahim Bozay had two ecchymosed areas each measuring 1 x 1 centimetre on the forehead.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "According to the medical report of 8 March 2005, Mr İbrahim Bozay had two ecchymosed grazes on one of the fingers of the right hand and on the right forearm, measuring 1 x 1 and 2 x 2 centimetres respectively.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "According to the medical report of 8 March 2005, Mr İbrahim Bozay's injuries prevented him from working for one day.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "According to the medical report of 8 March 2005, Ms Leyla Bozay told the doctor that she had been hit on the nape of the neck and that her hair had been pulled.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "According to the medical report of 8 March 2005, the doctor observed two ecchymosed areas measuring 1 x 1 and 2 x 1 centimetres on the insides of both arms of Ms Leyla Bozay.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "According to the medical report of 8 March 2005, Ms Leyla Bozay's injuries prevented her from working for one day.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "On 10 March 2005, at 2.40 p.m., the first applicant, Ms Nihal Pekaslan, was examined by a doctor at the Malatya State Hospital.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "On 10 March 2005, the doctor at the Malatya State Hospital observed two ecchymosed areas measuring 15 x 15 centimetres on the arms of the first applicant, Ms Nihal Pekaslan.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "On 10 March 2005, the doctor at the Malatya State Hospital observed various other ecchymosed areas on the knee and hand of the first applicant, Ms Nihal Pekaslan.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "According to the doctor at the Malatya State Hospital, the injuries observed on the first applicant, Ms Nihal Pekaslan, on 10 March 2005 had been caused some thirty-six to forty-eight hours previously.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "1. Documents pertaining to the incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "On 8 March 2005 the second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir, lodged an official complaint with the prosecutor against the police officers who, she alleged, had sprayed her and her daughter with tear gas.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "On 8 March 2005 the second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir, orally informed the prosecutor that she would recognise the police officer who had sprayed her and her daughter with tear gas.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Approximately thirty-five days after 8 March 2005, the second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir, was asked by the investigating police officer whether she would be able to identify the police officer responsible for spraying her and her daughter with tear gas.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "When asked approximately thirty-five days after the incident whether she could identify the police officer responsible, the second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir, stated that she had only seen him once and then only for a few seconds.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir, stated that had she been asked immediately after the incident she would have been able to recognise the police officer responsible.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On 11 March 2005 the remaining four applicants lodged an official complaint with the prosecutor against the police officers allegedly responsible for the ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "In their complaint of 11 March 2005, the four applicants complained that they had been beaten up and assaulted while exercising their right to freedom of expression and assembly.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "In their complaint of 11 March 2005, the four applicants referred to Articles 3 and 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On 16 March 2005 a police chief in Malatya sent a verbatim transcription of the video footage of the incidents to the Malatya prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Between 4 April 2005 and 3 May 2005 the Malatya prosecutor took statements from eighteen police officers who had been on duty on the day of the incidents on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "A police chief told the Malatya prosecutor that female demonstrators had attacked the police on 8 March 2005 and that the police had had to use force in response.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "A police chief told the Malatya prosecutor that the force used by the police on 8 March 2005 had been proportionate.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Four of the police officers told the Malatya prosecutor that the demonstrators had blocked the street on 8 March 2005 and that the police had had to arrest them.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Four of the police officers told the Malatya prosecutor that while they were arresting the demonstrators on 8 March 2005 there had been scuffles and the demonstrators had attacked the police officers with sticks.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Four of the police officers told the Malatya prosecutor that the police officers had had to use force on 8 March 2005, as a result of which the demonstrators might have suffered minor injuries.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The remaining thirteen police officers' statements to the Malatya prosecutor concerned solely the complaints made by the applicants regarding the alleged assaults by male police officers on the way to the Malatya Court House.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The remaining thirteen police officers denied that the demonstrators had been assaulted in the police vehicles on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The remaining thirteen police officers stated that the arrested persons had been accompanied by female officers in the vehicles on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "On 18 April 2005 the Malatya prosecutor examined the video footage submitted to his office by the police and recorded his findings in a report.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "In his report of 18 April 2005, the Malatya prosecutor expressed the opinion that the demonstrators had tried to break the police cordon and march on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "In his report of 18 April 2005, the Malatya prosecutor expressed the opinion that the police officers had not behaved in an arbitrary manner on 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "In his report of 18 April 2005, the Malatya prosecutor expressed the opinion that the use of force by the police officers on 8 March 2005 had not been excessive.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "On 12 May 2005 the Malatya prosecutor decided not to prosecute the police officers involved in the events of 8 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "In his decision of 12 May 2005, the Malatya prosecutor stated that the second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir, had been unable to recognise the police officer who had sprayed her with tear gas.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "In his decision of 12 May 2005, the Malatya prosecutor stated that the applicants had gathered in the area without having sought prior permission.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "In his decision of 12 May 2005, the Malatya prosecutor stated that in dispersing the unauthorised demonstration, the police officers had been impelled to resort to the use of force in order to apprehend the applicants because they had resisted arrest and insulted the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "In his decision of 12 May 2005, the Malatya prosecutor stated that other than the applicants' unsubstantiated allegations, there was no evidence justifying the prosecution of the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The applicants lodged an objection against the Malatya prosecutor's decision of 12 May 2005 not to prosecute the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "In their objection, the applicants argued that although they had not resisted arrest, the police officers had proceeded to arrest them by using force.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "In their objection, the applicants maintained that they had tried to exercise their right to freedom of expression, which was guaranteed by the Constitution as well as by Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "In their objection, the applicants pointed out that according to the applicable legislation, no prior permission was necessary to hold demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "In their objection, the applicants argued that the police officers had acted contrary to the circular issued by the Ministry of the Interior on 11 June 2004.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "In their objection, the applicants argued that the police officers' actions had been in breach of Article 3 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The objection filed by the applicants against the Malatya prosecutor's decision not to prosecute the police officers was rejected by the Elazığ Assize Court on 28 July 2005.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The Elazığ Assize Court's decision of 28 July 2005 rejecting the applicants' objection was communicated to the applicants in September 2005.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "2. Documents pertaining to the investigation into the allegations of ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "On 8 March 2005 four of the applicants — all the applicants with the exception of the second applicant, Ms Refika Meltem İspir — were questioned by the Malatya prosecutor as suspects.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "3. Documents pertaining to the applicants' trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The four applicants told the Malatya prosecutor on 8 March 2005 that before they could even begin their demonstration the police had arrested them without warning and, in the course of doing so, had hit them.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "3. Documents pertaining to the applicants' trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The four applicants denied to the Malatya prosecutor on 8 March 2005 that they had insulted the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "3. Documents pertaining to the applicants' trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Lawyers representing the applicants told the Malatya prosecutor on 8 March 2005 that the arrests had been arbitrary and in breach of their clients' fundamental rights and freedoms under the Convention, including the prohibition of torture.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "3. Documents pertaining to the applicants' trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Lawyers representing the applicants told the Malatya prosecutor on 8 March 2005 that their clients had been exercising their democratic rights and had not committed any offences.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "3. Documents pertaining to the applicants' trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "On 8 March 2005 the Malatya prosecutor filed an indictment with the Malatya Criminal Court of First Instance and brought criminal proceedings against the four applicants and the remaining five persons who had been arrested together with the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "3. Documents pertaining to the applicants' trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The criminal proceedings brought on 8 March 2005 against the four applicants and the five other arrested persons were for insulting the police officers and contravening the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "3. Documents pertaining to the applicants' trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "On 2 June 2005 the Malatya Criminal Court of First Instance acquitted the four applicants and the remaining defendants.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "3. Documents pertaining to the applicants' trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The Malatya Criminal Court of First Instance held on 2 June 2005 that there was no evidence to show that the four applicants had put up resistance against the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Documentary evidence submitted by the parties", "3. Documents pertaining to the applicants' trial"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F010", "F016", "F052", "F138", "F139"], "interference": ["F016", "F018", "F019", "F026", "F032", "F082", "F083", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F087", "F088", "F089", "F090", "F091", "F098", "F099", "F119"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F137"], "legitimate_aim": ["F040", "F041", "F043", "F045"], "necessity": ["F016", "F018", "F026", "F136", "F137", "F138", "F139"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F010", "F138", "F139"], "interference": ["F016", "F018", "F019", "F099"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F137"], "legitimate_aim": ["F040"], "necessity": ["F016", "F136", "F138", "F139"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F010", "F016", "F018", "F136", "F138", "F139"]}} {"case_name": "case_499", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_500", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1964.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant claimed that her home had been in Exo Metochi in northern Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The house in Exo Metochi had belonged to the applicant's mother.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The house in Exo Metochi was located on a large site with trees covering an area of 711 square metres.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The house in Exo Metochi was registered under plot no. 151, sheet/plan 22/20.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 17 April 2002 the applicant's mother transferred the house in Exo Metochi to Mr Georgios Sotiri Petrakides (the applicant's brother) by way of gift.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Since the 1974 Turkish intervention the applicant had been deprived of her home in Exo Metochi in northern Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant's home in Exo Metochi was located in the area under the occupation and control of the Turkish military authorities.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Turkish military authorities prevented the applicant from having access to and using her home in Exo Metochi.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE APPLICANT'S HOME"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 19 July 1989, the applicant joined an anti-Turkish demonstration in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicants in the Chrysostomos and Papachrysostomou v. Turkey cases also took part in the anti-Turkish demonstration on 19 July 1989 in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant in the Loizidou v. Turkey ((merits), 18 December 1996, Reports 1996-VI) case also took part in the anti-Turkish demonstration on 19 July 1989 in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was held on the fifteenth anniversary of the Turkish intervention in Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was held in support of the missing persons and to protest against human-rights violations.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the applicant, in the course of the demonstration of 19 July 1989 the applicant was seized by the hair by Turkish military personnel and/or other personnel acting under Turkish control.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the applicant, in the course of the demonstration of 19 July 1989 the applicant was violently beaten on the head, back and bottom by Turkish military personnel and/or other personnel acting under Turkish control.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the applicant, Turkish military personnel and/or other personnel acting under Turkish control continually grabbed hold of the applicant's breasts during the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the applicant, the applicant was dragged to a bus through a crowd that spat and swore at her during the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the applicant, the applicant was taken to the so-called 'Pavlides Garage' with other women following the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the applicant, on her arrival at the 'Pavlides Garage' the applicant was searched and forced to sit on the floor.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the applicant, the toilet facilities at the 'Pavlides Garage' were filthy and the applicant was refused water.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the applicant, two UN soldiers were present at the 'Pavlides Garage' but were not allowed to note down the names of the detainees.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the applicant, the crowd outside the 'Pavlides Garage' was swearing, shouting abuse and threats, and throwing stones at the garage, some of which came through the roof.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 20 July 1989 the applicant was interrogated in the 'Pavlides Garage' for more than an hour.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant refused to sign a statement that was written in Turkish during her interrogation on 20 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant and the other detainees were provided with food on 20 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant and the other detainees were photographed and filmed by a television crew on 20 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 20 July 1989 the applicant was taken to court and remanded in custody for two days.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant was transferred to Ortakeuy Prison following her court appearance on 20 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "At Ortakeuy Prison the applicant was kept in a cell with another woman.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to the applicant, the conditions of detention at Ortakeuy Prison were appalling and there were not enough beds for all the women detainees.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the applicant, during the night at Ortakeuy Prison the applicant and the other detainees were harassed by the guards.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 21 July 1989 the applicant was taken to court to stand trial.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to the applicant, the applicant had no legal representation at her trial on 21 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the applicant, the applicant had no proper interpretation at her trial on 21 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "According to the applicant, the applicant had not previously seen the exhibits which were produced at her trial on 21 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the applicant, outside the court on 21 July 1989 a crowd had gathered and was constantly shouting.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 22 July 1989 the court sentenced the applicant to three days' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 22 July 1989 the court imposed a fine of 50 Cyprus pounds (approximately 85 euros) on the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The court imposed five additional days in prison on the applicant in default of payment of the fine within 24 hours.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "After the trial on 22 July 1989 the applicant was taken back to Ortakeuy Prison.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the applicant, in the course of her detention the guards constantly made a lot of noise both during the day and at night.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the applicant, in the course of her detention the guards repeatedly entered the cells and turned on the lights.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to the applicant, on two occasions the applicant had to sign documents written in Turkish in order to get her personal effects back.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to the applicant, after an incident between the detainees and some Turkish photographers, the applicant was hit by one of her guards and put in an isolation cell.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "According to the applicant, the isolation cell was filthy, dark, very hot and had no ventilation.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "According to the applicant, while in the isolation cell the applicant was attacked and beaten by one of the guards, receiving severe blows to the face, head and arms.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "According to the applicant, the applicant's arm was badly injured and she lost consciousness while in the isolation cell.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "According to the applicant, the applicant was visited in the isolation cell by a person claiming to be a doctor who said that she needed treatment, but no treatment was given.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "According to the applicant, the applicant remained in the isolation cell until her release on 24 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "According to the applicant, the applicant was examined by a UN officer who bandaged her arm upon her release on 24 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "According to the applicant, after her release on 24 July 1989 the applicant was taken by bus to southern Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In support of her claim of ill-treatment, the applicant produced two medical certificates.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The first medical certificate was issued by Doctor Andreas Hadjiloizou, a pathologist practising in Ayios Dhometios, on 20 December 2002.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Doctor Andreas Hadjiloizou's certificate states that Mrs Petrakidou visited his clinic on 25 July 1989 after she was released by the Turks and complained of headaches, difficulty in moving her head and pain in the right lower part of the arm following violent twisting.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Doctor Andreas Hadjiloizou's certificate states that examination established that Mrs Petrakidou had mild concussion, difficulty in moving her head and pain in the right lower part of the arm due to violent twisting.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Doctor Andreas Hadjiloizou's certificate states that Mrs Petrakidou was advised to remain in bed for one week.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Doctor Andreas Hadjiloizou's certificate states that Mrs Petrakidou subsequently visited him several times complaining of dizziness and headaches.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The second medical certificate was a 'medical opinion' issued on an unspecified date by Doctor Simos Nissiotis, a specialist orthopaedic surgeon practising in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Doctor Simos Nissiotis's medical opinion states that the patient Alkiviadous Petrakidou Marianna had been followed by him from 26 July 1989 for various problems resulting from ill-treatment she was subjected to in the prisons of the Turkish-Cypriot pseudo-state in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Doctor Simos Nissiotis's medical opinion states that the patient participated in an anti-occupation demonstration on 19 July 1989 and was arrested by the authorities of the Turkish-Cypriot pseudo-state.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Doctor Simos Nissiotis's medical opinion states that during her arrest and detention the patient was beaten and ill-treated by the authorities of the Turkish-Cypriot pseudo-state.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Doctor Simos Nissiotis's medical opinion states that the patient was released on 27 July 1989 and was immediately taken to Nicosia General Hospital to be examined by doctors and to be administered medical treatment.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Doctor Simos Nissiotis's medical opinion states that on 26 July 1989 the patient visited his clinic for further examination and treatment.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Doctor Simos Nissiotis's medical opinion states that the patient presented with injury to the head and concussion, with diffuse haematomas to the head and mainly in her hair, and was complaining of headache and dizziness, and appeared to be in a very bad shape with a lot of phobias.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Doctor Simos Nissiotis's medical opinion states that the patient presented with contusion of the nape, complaining of pain and stiffness in the nape with contracted muscles, and that movements of the head were painful and limited and caused aggravation of headache and dizziness.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Doctor Simos Nissiotis's medical opinion states that the patient presented with contusion of the right forearm, wearing an elastic bandage on her right forearm and complaining mainly of pain with movements in the extensor and flexor, and that upon removal of the bandage she had a haematoma in the area of the round extensor.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Doctor Simos Nissiotis's medical opinion states that he recommended anti-inflammatory, muscle relaxant and analgesic medicines for the patient's orthopaedic problems, put her forearm in a special sock, and recommended that after the acute phase (approximately 10 days) she start doing exercise and swimming.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Doctor Simos Nissiotis's medical opinion states that for her concussion he recommended that the patient avoid gazing fixedly and exposure to the sun.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Doctor Simos Nissiotis's medical opinion states that the patient returned to work on 7 August 1989, though still having problems resulting from her contusions and concussion, which decreased in frequency with the passage of time.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Doctor Simos Nissiotis's medical opinion states that the patient has since suffered mainly from pain in the neck, particularly in the cold months, and that this is due to weakness of the muscles of the nape caused by her old injury.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Doctor Simos Nissiotis's medical opinion states that as regards problems resulting from the patient's concussion, phobias and psychological problems, she is being treated by a specialist colleague.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The applicant produced a photograph of herself with a bandage on her right arm.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The photograph of the applicant with a bandage on her right arm was allegedly taken on her return home after her release by the authorities of the 'Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus' (the 'TRNC').", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant had participated in a violent demonstration with the aim of inflaming anti-Turkish sentiment.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators, supported by the Greek-Cypriot administration, were demanding that the 'Green Line' in Nicosia should be dismantled.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Government alleged that some demonstrators carried Greek flags, clubs, knives and wire-cutters.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators were acting in a provocative manner and shouting abuse.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators were warned in Greek and English that unless they dispersed they would be arrested in accordance with the laws of the 'TRNC'.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was arrested by the Turkish-Cypriot police after crossing the UN buffer zone and entering the area under Turkish-Cypriot control.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Government alleged that the Turkish-Cypriot police intervened in the face of the manifest inability of the Greek-Cypriot authorities and the UN Force in Cyprus to contain the incursion and its possible consequences.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Government alleged that no force was used against demonstrators who did not intrude into the 'TRNC' border area.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Government alleged that in the case of demonstrators who were arrested for violating the border, no more force was used than was reasonably necessary in the circumstances in order to arrest and detain the persons concerned.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Government alleged that no one was ill-treated.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Government alleged that it was possible that some of the demonstrators had hurt themselves in the confusion or in attempting to scale barbed wire or other fencing.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Government alleged that had the Turkish police, or anyone else, assaulted or beaten any of the demonstrators, the UN Secretary General would no doubt have referred to this in his report to the Security Council.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was charged, tried, found guilty and sentenced to a short term of imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant pleaded not guilty but did not give evidence and declined to use the available judicial remedies.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was asked if she required assistance from a lawyer registered in the 'TRNC' but refused and did not ask for legal representation.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Government alleged that interpretation services were provided at the trial by qualified interpreters.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Government alleged that all the proceedings were translated into Greek.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989 on the UN operations in Cyprus, the UN Secretary General stated that in the evening of 19 July 1989, some 1,000 Greek Cypriot demonstrators, mostly women, forced their way into the UN buffer zone in the Ayios Kassianos area of Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that the demonstrators broke through a wire barrier maintained by the UN Force in Cyprus (UNFICYP) and destroyed a UNFICYP observation post.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that the demonstrators broke through the line formed by UNFICYP soldiers and entered a former school complex where UNFICYP reinforcements regrouped to prevent them from proceeding further.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that a short while later, Turkish-Cypriot police and security forces elements forced their way into the area and apprehended 111 persons, 101 of them women.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that the Ayios Kassianos school complex is situated in the UN buffer zone, but that the Turkish forces claim it to be on their side of the cease-fire line.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that under working arrangements with UNFICYP, the Turkish-Cypriot security forces had patrolled the Ayios Kassianos school grounds for several years within specific restrictions, and that this patrolling ceased altogether as part of the unmanning agreement implemented in May 1989.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that in the afternoon of 21 July 1989, some 300 Greek Cypriots gathered at the main entrance to the UN protected area in Nicosia to protest the continuing detention by the Turkish-Cypriot authorities of those apprehended at Ayios Kassianos.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that the demonstrators, whose number fluctuated between 200 and 2,000, blocked all UN traffic through the main entrance to the UN protected area in Nicosia until 30 July 1989, when the Turkish-Cypriot authorities released the last two detainees.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that the events of 19 July 1989 created considerable tension in the island and intensive efforts were made, both at the UN headquarters and at Nicosia, to contain and resolve the situation.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that on 21 July 1989 the UN Secretary General expressed his concern at the events and stressed that it was vital that all parties keep in mind the purpose of the UN buffer zone as well as their responsibility to ensure that that area was not violated.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that on 21 July 1989 the UN Secretary General urged the Turkish-Cypriot authorities to release without delay all those who had been detained.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that on 24 July 1989 the President of the Security Council announced that he had conveyed to the representatives of all the parties, on behalf of the members of the Council, the Council's deep concern at the tense situation created by the incidents of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that the President of the Security Council stressed the need strictly to respect the UN buffer zone and appealed for the immediate release of all persons still detained.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that the President of the Security Council asked all concerned to show maximum restraint and to take urgent steps to bring about a relaxation of tension and contribute to the creation of an atmosphere favourable to the negotiations.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The applicant produced 21 photographs taken at different times during the demonstration on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Photographs 1 to 7 produced by the applicant were intended to show that, notwithstanding the deployment of the Turkish-Cypriot police, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "In photographs 8 to 10 produced by the applicant, members of the Turkish-Cypriot police are seen breaking up the UNFICYP cordon.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The final set of photographs produced by the applicant show members of the Turkish-Cypriot police using force to arrest some of the women demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The English translation of the 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court judgment of 22 July 1989 indicates that the applicant, together with 24 other women, was charged with entering 'TRNC' territory without permission, contrary to sections 2, 8 and 9 of Law no. 5/72.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The English translation of the 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court judgment of 22 July 1989 indicates that the applicant, together with 24 other women, was charged with entering 'TRNC' territory other than through an approved port, contrary to subsections 12(1) and (5) of the Aliens and Immigration Law.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court judgment of 22 July 1989 was given in the presence of the accused and of an interpreter, who was reminded of his oath.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that the accused did not accept the charges against them and stated that they did not wish to use the services of a lawyer registered in the 'TRNC'.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that the public prosecutor called seven witnesses, whose statements were translated into Greek for the accused's benefit.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that the witnesses (mainly police officers on duty at the time of the demonstration) declared that the accused had illegally entered the 'TRNC' buffer zone, shouted abuse at the Turkish-Cypriot forces, and resisted arrest by pulling and pushing.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that knives and other cutting objects had been found in the bags of some of the demonstrators who had been arrested.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that the accused had been told that they could cross-examine witnesses in turn and, if they wished, choose one of their number to cross-examine the witnesses on behalf of all the accused, but that they did not do so.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that some of the accused, including the applicant, put questions to the prosecution witnesses, while most of the accused women did not make use of their right of cross-examination.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that the applicant made the following statement: 'I consider our arrest as illegal, because we were arrested while we were on a territory which, however you look at it, is Hellenic, by troops we do not recognise. We had come in peace, but were faced by violence, not by the Turkish army, but by the Turkish Cypriots, who until then we had considered as brothers.'", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that some of the other women accused gave statements declaring that the demonstration was peaceful, that they had not carried weapons and that they did not recognise the 'TRNC' as a valid State.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court concluded, relying on the statements of the prosecution witnesses, that the accused had crossed the borders of the 'TRNC' at an unapproved entry point and without permission and had resisted by various means the UN and Turkish forces which had tried to stop them.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court concluded that the statements made by some of the accused were mainly of a political nature and did not undermine the statements of the prosecution witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court concluded that the prosecution had proved its case beyond reasonable doubt and that the accused were guilty on both counts.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "In deciding on the sentence, the 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court took into account the seriousness of the offence and the fact that the accused had shown no remorse and continued to deny the validity of the 'TRNC'.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code defines an unlawful assembly as five or more persons assembled with intent to commit an offence, or assembled with intent to carry out some common purpose and conducting themselves in such a manner as to cause persons in the neighbourhood to fear that they will commit a breach of the peace or will needlessly and without any reasonable occasion provoke other persons to commit a breach of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that it is immaterial that the original assembling was lawful if, being assembled, the persons conduct themselves with a common purpose in such a manner as to constitute an unlawful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that when an unlawful assembly has begun to execute its purpose by a breach of the peace and to the terror of the public, the assembly is called a riot and the persons assembled are said to be riotously assembled.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "According to section 71 of the Cypriot Criminal Code, any person who takes part in an unlawful assembly is guilty of a misdemeanour and liable to imprisonment for one year.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "Section 80 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that any person who carries in public without lawful occasion any offensive arm or weapon in such a manner as to cause terror to any person is guilty of a misdemeanour and is liable to imprisonment for two years, and his arm or weapons shall be forfeited.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "According to section 82 of the Cypriot Criminal Code, it is an offence to carry a knife outside the home.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "Chapter 155, section 14(1)(b) of the Cypriot Criminal Procedure Law states that any officer may, without warrant, arrest any person who commits in his presence any offence punishable with imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Police officers' powers of arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Chapter 155, section 14(1)(c) of the Cypriot Criminal Procedure Law states that any officer may, without warrant, arrest any person who obstructs a police officer while in the execution of his duty.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Police officers' powers of arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Section 9 of Law No. 5/72 states that any person who enters a prohibited military area without authorization, or by stealth, or fraudulently, shall be tried by a military court in accordance with the Military Offences Act, and those found guilty shall be punished.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Subsection 12(1) of the Aliens and Immigration Law states that no person shall enter or leave the Colony except through an approved port.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Subsection 12(5) of the Aliens and Immigration Law states that any person who contravenes or fails to observe any of the provisions of subsections (1), (2), (3) or (4) of section 12 shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months or to a fine not exceeding one hundred pounds or to both such imprisonment and such a fine.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": false, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["national_security", "public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F011", "F082", "F094", "F095", "F096", "F117", "F123"], "interference": ["F011", "F082", "F097"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F112", "F113", "F127", "F130", "F133", "F135", "F136", "F137"], "legitimate_aim": ["F094", "F095", "F096", "F117", "F123"], "necessity": ["F094", "F095", "F096", "F112", "F113", "F117", "F123"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F011", "F094", "F095", "F096"], "interference": ["F011", "F082"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F112", "F113", "F127", "F130", "F133"], "legitimate_aim": ["F094", "F095", "F096"], "necessity": ["F094", "F095", "F096", "F117", "F123"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F011", "F082", "F094", "F095", "F096", "F117", "F127", "F130", "F133"]}} {"case_name": "case_501", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1980.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1986.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1986.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The fourth applicant was born in 1990.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The fifth applicant was born in 1989.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The sixth applicant was born in 1974.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The seventh applicant was born in 1988.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The second, third, fourth and seventh applicants live in Chișinău.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The first applicant lives in Baden-Baden.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The fifth applicant lives in Cahul.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The sixth applicant lives in Mereni.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicants were represented by Mr V. Vieru, a lawyer practising in Chișinău.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicants were represented by Ms N. Hriplivîi, a lawyer practising in Chișinău.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr O. Rotari.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicants are members and sympathisers of an extra-parliamentary opposition party called 'Casa noastră - Moldova' (Our home – Moldova).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The extra-parliamentary opposition party 'Casa noastră - Moldova' (Our home – Moldova) was led by the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "At the time of the events, the first applicant was a member of the Moldovan delegation to the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On Sunday 6 September 2015, another opposition political party organised a large anti-government rally in the central square of Chișinău.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicants participated in the large anti-government rally held on 6 September 2015 in the central square of Chișinău.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Other sympathisers of the party 'Casa noastră - Moldova' (Our home – Moldova) participated in the large anti-government rally held on 6 September 2015 in the central square of Chișinău.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "One of the resolutions of the rally of 6 September 2015 was the demand for the immediate dismissal of the Prosecutor General.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Prosecutor General was accused of being politically subordinated to Mr Vladimir Plahotniuc.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Mr Vladimir Plahotniuc was the leader of the main governing party at the time of the rally on 6 September 2015.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Immediately after the rally, a large group of persons led by the applicants marched towards the headquarters of the Prosecutor General's Office to demand the Prosecutor General's resignation.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "At approximately 2.15 p.m. on 6 September 2015, the group approached the building of the Prosecutor General's Office.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "A video of the event, which is part of the case-file, shows several members of the group wearing black t-shirts with the inscription ПЛХ-ПНХ (the abbreviation in Russian of the words meaning 'Fuck you Plahotniuc') rushing on the steps of the Prosecutor General's Office building towards its entrance.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "In the video of the event, the fifth applicant can be seen approaching one of the entrance doors of the Prosecutor General's Office building and sitting right next to it while leaning against the door.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "Several police officers immediately lifted the fifth applicant up and pushed him away from the entrance of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Many more members of the group climbed the steps of the Prosecutor General's Office building and rushed towards the entrance doors, being stopped and pushed back by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Within two to three minutes, the demonstrators were pushed away from the entrance doors of the Prosecutor General's Office building towards the lower part of the steps by a group of policemen who outnumbered them.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "No violence is seen on the video footage apart from the pushing of the demonstrators by the police officers away from the entrance of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The demonstrators were seen on the video footage shouting slogans including 'Rușine' (meaning 'Shame on you'), 'Plahotniuc la dubă' (meaning 'Plahotniuc in prison') and 'Jos mafia' ('Down with the mafia').", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The demonstrators were seen on the video footage whistling and drum beating.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The police officers, present in great numbers, formed a line in front of the demonstrators preventing them from climbing the steps toward the entrance of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The majority of the demonstrators stayed on the pavement, the lawn and the road in front of the Prosecutor General's Office building, with only several dozen being on the lower part of the steps.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "After being pushed to the lower part of the stairs, at approximately 2.18 p.m. on 6 September 2015, a group of approximately 15-20 demonstrators, including the applicants, sat on the steps at the feet of the police cordon.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The group of approximately 15-20 demonstrators, including the applicants, announced at approximately 2.18 p.m. that they intended to install tents and stay at the Prosecutor General's Office until the resignation of the Prosecutor General.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Later, the group of approximately 15-20 demonstrators, including the applicants, stood up from the steps.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "At approximately 2.23 p.m. on 6 September 2015, a special forces unit wearing helmets and special anti-riot gear approached the demonstration at the Prosecutor General's Office.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "At 2.27 p.m. on 6 September 2015, several demonstrators started installing tents on the pavement in front of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "At 2.28 p.m. on 6 September 2015, the police demanded the demonstrators to vacate the premises in front of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "At 2.28 p.m. on 6 September 2015, the police warned the demonstrators that they would be removed by force in case of non-compliance with the demand to vacate the premises.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The demonstrators refused to comply with the police demand to vacate the premises in front of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "At 2.29 p.m. on 6 September 2015, the police forces started pushing the demonstrators further away from the entrance of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "One of the demonstrators wearing a black t-shirt was seen being arrested by two police officers behind the police cordon at the Prosecutor General's Office.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Having been pushed to the pavement, the demonstrators again sat down at approximately 2.31 p.m. on 6 September 2015, this time on the pavement in front of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "Another video included in the case-file starts at 4.01 p.m. on 6 September 2015.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "At 4.01 p.m. on 6 September 2015, many demonstrators were scattered on the pavement, lawn and road in front of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "At 4.01 p.m. on 6 September 2015, the steps of the Prosecutor General's Office building were occupied by the police.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "At 4.01 p.m. on 6 September 2015, approximately ten tents were installed on the sidewalk in front of the steps of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "A group of demonstrators including some of the applicants were seen seated on the lower part of the steps of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The first applicant shouted through a megaphone that the demonstration at the Prosecutor General's Office was a peaceful demonstration and that they had the constitutional right to peacefully protest.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "At 4.20 p.m. on 6 September 2015, a representative of the Mayor's Office approached the persons sitting on the pavement in front of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The representative of the Mayor's Office told the persons sitting on the pavement that they were breaking the law by occupying the pavement and gave them five minutes to vacate it.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The protesters retorted that the pavement was public property and that they had the right to hold a peaceful protest on it.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "At 4.42 p.m. on 6 September 2015, members of the special forces and the police started taking away the tents from the pavement in front of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "In spite of some protesters' attempts to retain the tents, within two minutes all tents were taken away by the police from the pavement in front of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "At 4.47 p.m. on 6 September 2015, all the demonstrators were pushed away from both the steps, the pavement and the lawn in front of the Prosecutor General's Office building.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "At approximately 5 p.m. on 6 September 2015, the demonstration at the Prosecutor General's Office came to an end.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "A. The demonstration of 6 September 2015"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "All the applicants were arrested at approximately 4.39 p.m. on 6 September 2015.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "All the applicants were taken to a police station following their arrest on 6 September 2015.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The applicants were placed in detention for a period of seventy-two hours on suspicion of having committed the offence of participating in mass disorders provided for by Article 285 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 8 September 2015, the applicants were formally charged with the offence of participating in mass disorders under Article 285 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 8 September 2015, the Rîşcani District Court ordered the applicants' remand in custody for a period of thirty days.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Rîşcani District Court's decision ordering the applicants' remand in custody stated that there was evidence and witness statements confirming the applicants' active involvement in violence against the police, without indicating which evidence and which witness statements.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "In their appeal against the remand in custody decision, the applicants argued that the criminal prosecution and their detention were politically motivated.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "In their appeal against the remand in custody decision, the applicants argued that there was not one single piece of evidence confirming the alleged violence against the police during the demonstration of 6 September 2015.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "In their appeal against the remand in custody decision, the applicants indicated that there were no medical documents supporting the accusation about violence against the police during the demonstration of 6 September 2015.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants' appeal against the Rîşcani District Court's decision ordering their remand in custody.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The applicants' detention was prolonged several times after the initial thirty-day remand in custody.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 22 February 2016, the Rîşcani District Court ordered the applicants' house arrest.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Rîşcani District Court's decision to order house arrest on 22 February 2016 was a result of the involvement of numerous members of the Council of Europe's Parliamentary Assembly.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "While under house arrest, the applicants were obliged to wear electronic bracelets.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The fourth applicant's house arrest was changed to provisional release under judicial control on 4 April 2016.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The applicants other than the fourth applicant were released under judicial control on 26 April 2016.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 26 April 2016, the court ordered as one of many surety measures in respect of the applicants other than the fourth applicant the prohibition on participating in public gatherings, if there was a risk of the gathering degenerating into mass disorders.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The prohibition on participating in public gatherings imposed on 26 April 2016 was prolonged on many occasions by the Rîşcani District Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "All the applicants' appeals against the prohibition on participating in public gatherings were dismissed by the Court of Appeal by 12 March 2019.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 28 June 2017, the Rîşcani District Court found the applicants guilty as charged with the offence of participating in mass disorders under Article 285 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 28 June 2017, the Rîşcani District Court sentenced the applicants to suspended sentences of three and four years' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 29 September 2017, the first applicant, who was in Germany, applied for asylum in Germany.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "On 16 October 2017, the German authorities granted the first applicant refugee status on the grounds that in Moldova he was prosecuted for political reasons.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On 12 March 2019, a panel of three judges of the Chișinău Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants' appeals against the judgment of 28 June 2017 of the Rîşcani District Court.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "One of the members of the panel of three judges of the Chișinău Court of Appeal, Judge S.B., made a dissenting opinion in the judgment of 12 March 2019.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Judge S.B. stated in her dissenting opinion that after having viewed the video footage included in the case-file and having examined the other materials of the case, she did not find any evidence of violence against the police during the demonstration of 6 September 2015.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Judge S.B. stated in her dissenting opinion that she saw a peaceful gathering of persons protesting against the Government and expressing their discontent with the policy of the Government.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Judge S.B. stated in her dissenting opinion that the demonstration of 6 September 2015 had taken place on a Sunday and had not hindered in any way the work of the Prosecutor General's Office.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Judge S.B. expressed the opinion in her dissenting opinion that the applicants should have been acquitted.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "In June 2019, following a week of tensions between the authorities and the opposition, a peaceful overthrow of the Government took place in Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "In June 2019, the former leader of the ruling political party, Mr V. Plahotniuc, fled Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "On 11 February 2020, the Supreme Court of Justice of Moldova upheld the applicants' appeal against the judgment of the Chișinău Court of Appeal of 12 March 2019.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice found that the applicants' conviction had been based exclusively on the interpretation and description of the facts made by the prosecution without any attention having been paid to the position of the applicants and to the materials of the case-file.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice quashed the Chișinău Court of Appeal's judgment of 12 March 2019.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice sent the case back to the Chișinău Court of Appeal for a fresh examination.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "On 20 July 2020, the Chișinău Court of Appeal upheld the applicants' appeal against the judgment of 28 June 2017 of the Rîşcani District Court and quashed it.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "On 20 July 2020, the Chișinău Court of Appeal sent the case for a fresh examination by the Rîşcani District Court.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The criminal case against the applicants is pending before the Rîşcani District Court as the first instance court to date.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. The applicants' detention and their criminal prosecution"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Article 40 of the Constitution of the Republic of Moldova (on freedom of assembly) provides that all meetings, demonstrations, rallies, processions or any other assemblies are free, but they may be organised and take place only peacefully and without the use of weapons.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "Article 285(1) of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Moldova, entitled 'Mass disorders', as in force at the material time, provided that organizing or leading mass disorders involving violence against persons, pogroms, arson, damage to goods, the use of firearms or other objects used as weapons, and violent or armed resistance to representatives of authorities shall be punished by imprisonment for 4 to 8 years.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Article 285(2) of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Moldova, entitled 'Mass disorders', as in force at the material time, provided that active participation in the commission of actions set forth in Article 285(1) shall be punished by imprisonment for 3 to 7 years.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "Article 285(3) of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Moldova, entitled 'Mass disorders', as in force at the material time, provided that calls for active, violent insubordination to the legitimate requests of the authorities' representatives, and for participation in mass disorders and for the commission of acts of violence against persons shall be punished by a fine in the amount of 200 to 500 conventional units or by community service for 180 to 240 hours or by imprisonment for up to 2 years.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "Article 191(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Republic of Moldova, entitled 'Provisional release under judicial control', as in force at the material time, provided that the provisional release under judicial control of a person under preventive arrest, of a detainee or of a person in whose case an arrest request was filed, may be granted by the investigative judge or, as the case may be, the court and shall imply one or several of the obligations set forth in Article 191(3).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "Article 191(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Republic of Moldova, entitled 'Provisional release under judicial control', as in force at the material time, provided that provisional release under judicial control shall not be granted to a suspect/accused/defendant if he/she has convictions which remain in the criminal record for serious, especially serious or exceptionally serious crimes or if there are indications that he/she will commit another crime, will try to influence witnesses, will destroy sources of evidence or will evade justice.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Article 191(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Republic of Moldova, entitled 'Provisional release under judicial control', as in force at the material time, provided that the provisional release under judicial control of an arrestee shall imply one or several obligations, including: not to leave the place of domicile other than under the conditions set by the investigative judge or court; to notify the criminal investigative body or court about any change of domicile; not to appear in specifically determined places; to appear whenever summoned by the criminal investigative body or court; not to contact specific persons; not to commit any actions preventing the finding of the truth in criminal proceedings; not to drive vehicles or not to practise a profession used in the commission of the crime; and to leave the passport with the investigating judge or the court.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Article 191(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Republic of Moldova, entitled 'Provisional release under judicial control', as in force at the material time, provided that the police in the territorial jurisdiction in which a suspect/accused/defendant temporarily released lives shall exert control over him/her meeting the obligations set by the court.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Article 191(5) of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Republic of Moldova, entitled 'Provisional release under judicial control', as in force at the material time, provided that judicial control over a temporarily released person may be cancelled, wholly or partially, for justifiable reasons and in the manner set for this measure.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F077", "F076", "F020", "F019", "F099"], "interference": ["F077", "F076", "F078", "F079"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F103", "F104", "F105", "F106", "F107", "F077"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F077"], "interference": ["F077", "F076"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F105", "F077"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F077", "F105"]}} {"case_name": "case_503", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention and Protocols thereto.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_504", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_505", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of unlawful detention (deprivation of liberty).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F003"], "interference": ["F001", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003"], "interference": ["F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_508", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The present case concerns alleged restrictions imposed by the authorities on the exercise of the applicants' freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The present case concerns the alleged lack of domestic remedies in regard to restrictions on the applicants' freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants' names and other relevant details of the applications are set out in the Appendix to the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The Government were initially represented by Mr M. Galperin, former Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Government were later represented by Mr M. Vinogradov, successor to Mr M. Galperin as Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 5 October 2018 the applicant in Application No. 29356/19 notified the prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow of his intention to hold a picket (пикетирование) on 11 October 2018.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The picket notified by the applicant in Application No. 29356/19 was planned to run from 12 noon to 3 p.m. on 11 October 2018.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The picket notified by the applicant in Application No. 29356/19 was to take place in front of the State Duma (lower chamber of the Russian Parliament) building in central Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Twenty people were expected to attend the picket notified by the applicant in Application No. 29356/19.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The aim of the picket notified by the applicant in Application No. 29356/19 was to protest against the increase in the State pension age recently voted by the State Duma.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 5 October 2018 a deputy prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow refused to approve the location chosen by the applicant in Application No. 29356/19 for the picket.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The deputy prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow indicated that the venue chosen by the applicant in Application No. 29356/19 was unsuitable for public events because it would be impossible to meet safety requirements there.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The deputy prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow indicated that holding a picket at the chosen venue might result in disruption to the functioning of public utilities, transport, social or communications services.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The deputy prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow indicated that holding a picket at the chosen venue might result in obstruction of pedestrian traffic or a breach of the rights and interests of citizens not participating in the notified event.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The deputy prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow proposed that the picket be held in Moscow's Lermontov Park, some 3 km from the State Duma building.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant in Application No. 29356/19 challenged the deputy prefect's decision refusing to approve the location of the picket before the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant in Application No. 29356/19 submitted before the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow that the aim of the public event was to make the State Duma deputies aware of the inadmissibility of raising the State pension age.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant in Application No. 29356/19 submitted before the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow that it was crucial to hold the event in front of the State Duma building, as the deputies were there daily.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant in Application No. 29356/19 submitted before the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow that the pedestrian pavement in front of the State Duma building was large enough to allow the picket to take place without obstructing pedestrian traffic or access to the State Duma.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 10 October 2018 the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow dismissed the applicant's complaint in Application No. 29356/19.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Taganskiy District Court of Moscow held that pedestrian and vehicle traffic at Okhotnyy Ryad Street in Moscow, the location chosen by the applicant in Application No. 29356/19, is heavy.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Taganskiy District Court of Moscow held that the deputy prefect's finding that the location at Okhotnyy Ryad Street in Moscow was unsuitable for public events was justified, as holding public events there might endanger the safety of participants and non-participants.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Taganskiy District Court of Moscow held that the deputy prefect's decision met the requirements of section 8 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Taganskiy District Court of Moscow held that the applicant in Application No. 29356/19 had been given a written decision within the established time-limit indicating the reasons why it was impossible to hold the public event at the chosen location and time.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Taganskiy District Court of Moscow held that the applicant in Application No. 29356/19 had not been deprived of an opportunity to enjoy his constitutional right to hold a public event by choosing another location, including the location proposed by the deputy prefect.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The Taganskiy District Court of Moscow held that the participants' right to express opinions during public events and voice demands on issues related to political, economic, social or cultural life had not been restricted.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant in Application No. 29356/19 appealed against the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow's judgment of 10 October 2018.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant in Application No. 29356/19 submitted on appeal that the authorities had no legal grounds for refusing to approve the picket.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 11 October 2018 the Moscow City Court upheld the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow's judgment of 10 October 2018 on appeal in Application No. 29356/19.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Moscow City Court held that the Taganskiy District Court of Moscow's finding that the authorities' decision was lawful and well-reasoned was correct and sufficiently reasoned.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Moscow City Court noted that by a decision of 5 October 2018 the organiser of the public event in Application No. 29356/19 was informed of the reasons why it was not possible to hold the public event at the chosen location.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Moscow City Court held that a regional public authority has competence under section 12 of the Public Events Act to make to the organiser of a public event a well-reasoned proposal to change its location.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Moscow City Court held that the applicant in Application No. 29356/19 was not banned from holding a public event because he was offered an alternative location accessible to the public.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Moscow City Court concluded that the contested decision by the deputy prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow was within its statutory powers, the procedure for adopting it was complied with, there were reasons for adopting the decision, and its content met the applicable statutory requirements.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 25 January 2019 a judge of the Moscow City Court refused to refer a cassation appeal lodged by the applicant in Application No. 29356/19 with the Presidium of the Moscow City Court for examination.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The judge of the Moscow City Court who refused to refer the cassation appeal in Application No. 29356/19 referred to Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 when endorsing the reasoning of the lower courts.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 17 April 2019 a judge of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation refused to refer the applicant's cassation appeal in Application No. 29356/19 for consideration by the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The judge of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation found that no significant violations of substantive or procedural law had influenced the outcome of the proceedings in Application No. 29356/19.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. APPLICATION NO. 29356/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicants in Application No. 31119/19 are human rights activists.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 10 December 2018 the applicants in Application No. 31119/19 notified the Moscow government of their intention to hold a public gathering on 22 December 2018 in Pushkin Square in central Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The public gathering notified by the applicants in Application No. 31119/19 was planned to run from 2 to 5 p.m. on 22 December 2018.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "About 1,000 people were expected to attend the public gathering notified by the applicants in Application No. 31119/19.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The aim of the public gathering notified by the applicants in Application No. 31119/19 was to mark the anniversary of the first post-war political protest held in Pushkin Square on 5 December 1965.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The aim of the public gathering notified by the applicants in Application No. 31119/19 was to urge the authorities to respect rights to freedom of expression and assembly.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicants in Application No. 31119/19 promised not to disrupt traffic during the planned public gathering.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 12 December 2018 the Moscow Department of Regional Security informed the applicants in Application No. 31119/19 that another public event was scheduled to take place in Pushkin Square on 22 December 2018.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Moscow Department of Regional Security proposed that the applicants' gathering in Application No. 31119/19 be held at a special venue for public events in Sokolniki Park.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 13 December 2018 three applicants in Application No. 31119/19 submitted to the Moscow government a written proposal for an agreement over the location of the public event.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Three applicants in Application No. 31119/19 pointed out the importance of holding the event in Pushkin Square, stemming from the fact that the protest of 5 December 1965 had also been held there.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Three applicants in Application No. 31119/19 stated that the alternative location proposed by the Moscow Department of Regional Security (Sokolniki Park) was incompatible with the event's purposes as it was too far away from the headquarters of the public authorities targeted by its intended message.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Three applicants in Application No. 31119/19 requested further information about the event planned in Pushkin Square on 22 December 2018, in particular its time frame and the contact details of its organisers.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Three applicants in Application No. 31119/19 asked that the Moscow government propose a time slot that would not overlap with the other event planned in Pushkin Square on 22 December 2018 and assist in negotiations with its organisers.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The applicants in Application No. 31119/19 did not receive a reply to their written proposal for an agreement over the location of the public event submitted on 13 December 2018.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 13 December 2018 all applicants in Application No. 31119/19 challenged the refusal to approve the public gathering before the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow, on the grounds that it was not sufficiently reasoned.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The applicants in Application No. 31119/19 submitted before the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow that the Moscow government had not explained why it was not possible to hold the two events simultaneously in Pushkin Square.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicants in Application No. 31119/19 submitted before the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow that the Moscow government had not mentioned at what time the other event was planned and why it would be impossible to hold the applicants' event before or after it.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicants in Application No. 31119/19 stressed before the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow that Pushkin Square was the only venue that would allow the event's purposes to be achieved.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicants in Application No. 31119/19 relied before the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow on Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018, in particular its requirements that any interference by a public authority with the right to freedom of public assembly had to be lawful, necessary and proportionate to a legitimate aim.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The applicants in Application No. 31119/19 relied before the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow on Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018, in particular its requirement that interference be justified through the submission of evidence of specific facts making it impossible to hold the public event at the chosen location or time.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 20 December 2018 the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow dismissed the applicants' complaint in Application No. 31119/19.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow referred to Article 11 of the Convention, the applicable domestic provisions and Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 when dismissing the applicants' complaint in Application No. 31119/19.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that regional and local law-enforcement authorities have an obligation to ensure public order and safety during public events and should take these circumstances into account when proposing to change the location of a public event.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that the law-enforcement authorities complied with the statutory requirements when proposing to change the location of the applicants' public event in Application No. 31119/19.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that the Moscow government, when preparing its reply to the notification of the public event lodged on 11 December 2018, sent a request for information to the office of the prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow found that the office of the prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow replied that another event had already been planned to take place in Pushkin Square on 22 December 2018 from 7.30 a.m. to 8 p.m., namely the 'Moscow Traditions of New Year Celebrations'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow found that the holding of the 'Moscow Traditions of New Year Celebrations' event in Pushkin Square on 22 December 2018 had been approved on 21 November 2018.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that the Moscow government complied with its obligation to submit to the court evidence of specific facts making it impossible to hold the public event at the chosen location and/or time.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that the law does not provide for any obligation to submit evidence of specific facts making it impossible to hold the public event to the organisers of public events.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that there was no reason to believe that it would be impossible to achieve the event's purposes if it were to be held at another location.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that the law-enforcement authorities complied with the statutory prohibition on putting public order and safety of citizens at risk if holding a public event at the same venue where a popular cultural event has already been approved.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow held that non-compliance by the applicants in Application No. 31119/19 with the statutory prohibition could amount to an abuse of the right to freedom of assembly, which falls outside of the scope of judicial protection.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 20 December 2018 three applicants in Application No. 31119/19 appealed against the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow's judgment.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Three applicants in Application No. 31119/19 extensively relied on the European Court of Human Rights' findings in the case of Lashmankin and Others v. Russia (nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, 7 February 2017) in their appeal.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Three applicants in Application No. 31119/19 reiterated the arguments they had made before the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow in their appeal.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 21 December 2018 the Moscow City Court upheld the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow's judgment in Application No. 31119/19.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Moscow City Court endorsed the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow's reasoning in Application No. 31119/19, referring to Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Moscow City Court held that the appellants' arguments that the law-enforcement authorities had not considered the possibility of holding two events simultaneously did not warrant the quashing of the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow's judgment.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Moscow City Court found that before sending a reply to the event organisers in Application No. 31119/19, the Moscow government had received information from the office of the prefect of the Central Administrative District of Moscow, the Moscow Department of Cultural Heritage and the Moscow Department of Commerce.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Moscow City Court found that the celebrations in Pushkin Square on 22 December 2018 would occupy 3,000 sq. m, making it impossible to hold the applicants' public event in Application No. 31119/19.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Moscow City Court concluded that the contested decision by the Moscow government in Application No. 31119/19 was within its statutory powers, the procedure for its adoption was respected, there were reasons for adopting that decision, and its content met the applicable statutory requirements.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 25 December 2018 the other three applicants in Application No. 31119/19 lodged an appeal against the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow's judgment.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "On 6 June 2019 the Moscow City Court dismissed the appeal lodged on 25 December 2018 by the other three applicants in Application No. 31119/19.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The parties in Application No. 31119/19 did not provide a copy of the Moscow City Court's judgment of 6 June 2019.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The applicants in Application No. 31119/19 lodged two separate cassation appeals.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On 18 June 2019 a judge of the Moscow City Court refused to refer one of the cassation appeals in Application No. 31119/19 to the Presidium of the Moscow City Court for examination.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "On 29 August 2019 a judge of the Moscow City Court refused to refer the other cassation appeal in Application No. 31119/19 to the Presidium of the Moscow City Court for examination.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The parties in Application No. 31119/19 did not provide copies of the decisions refusing to refer the cassation appeals to the Presidium of the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "On 15 August 2019 applicants in Application No. 31119/19 lodged a cassation appeal with the Presidium of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 24 September 2019 applicants in Application No. 31119/19 lodged a cassation appeal with the Presidium of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The applicants in Application No. 31119/19 reiterated their previous arguments in their cassation appeals to the Presidium of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, stressing that the domestic courts had failed to apply Article 11 of the Convention interpreted in the light of the European Court of Human Rights' case-law.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "On 17 September 2019 a judge of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation refused to refer one of the applicants' cassation appeals in Application No. 31119/19 for consideration by the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "On 22 November 2019 a judge of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation refused to refer the other applicants' cassation appeal in Application No. 31119/19 for consideration by the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The judge of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation found no significant violations of substantive or procedural law which had influenced the outcome of the proceedings in Application No. 31119/19.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. APPLICATION NO. 31119/19"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015) entered into force on 15 September 2015.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015) replaced Chapter 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure governing the procedure for examining complaints about decisions, acts or omissions of State and municipal authorities and officials.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015) replaced the Judicial Review Act (Law no. 4966-1 of 27 April 1993 on judicial review of decisions and acts violating citizens' rights and freedoms).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Under Article 219 § 4 of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015), a complaint against the authorities' decisions concerning the change of location or time of a public event must be lodged with a court within ten days of the date on which the complainant learnt of the breach of his rights.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Under Article 226 § 4 of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015), complaints against authorities' decisions concerning the change of location or time of a public event must be examined by courts within ten days.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "Under Article 226 § 4 of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015), if a complaint is lodged before the planned date of the public event, it must be examined at the latest on the eve of that date.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Under Article 227 §§ 4 and 6 of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015), a reasoned judicial decision must be prepared as soon as possible on the same day and immediately served on the complainant.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "Under Article 227 § 8 of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015), the judicial decision is subject to immediate enforcement.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "Under Article 305 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015), if an appeal has been lodged against the first-instance decision before the planned date of the public event, it must be examined at the latest on the eve of that date.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "Under Article 226 § 8 of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015), when examining the case, the court must review the lawfulness of the contested decision.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Under Article 226 § 9 of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015), the court must examine whether the State or municipal authority had competence to make the contested decision, whether the procedure prescribed by law for its adoption was respected, whether the contested decision was taken on the grounds prescribed by law, and whether the contents of the contested decision met the requirements of law.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Under Article 226 § 11 of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015), the burden of proof as to the lawfulness of the contested decision lies with the authority concerned.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Under Article 226 § 11 of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015), the complainant has to prove that his rights and freedoms have been breached by the contested decision and that he has complied with the time-limit for lodging the complaint.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Under Article 227 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015), the court allows the complaint if it has been established that the contested decision is unlawful and breaches the complainant's rights or freedoms, and in that case requires the authority to remedy the breach of the citizen's rights or to stop hindering such rights.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Under Article 227 § 3 of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015), when necessary, the court determines specific steps to be taken to remedy the violation and sets out the time-limit.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Under Article 318 §§ 1 and 2 of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Law no. 21-FZ of 8 March 2015), after unsuccessful recourse to the appeal court, the complainant can lodge a cassation appeal within six months from the delivery of the appeal decision.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Under Article 319 § 2.1 of the Code of Administrative Procedure as revised by Law no. 103-FZ of 5 April 2016, a cassation appeal should have been lodged with the presidium of the regional supreme court.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Under Article 319 § 2.3 of the Code of Administrative Procedure as in force at the time, a cassation appeal could subsequently be lodged with the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Relevant legislation"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "On 26 June 2018 the Plenary of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation adopted Ruling no. 28 'On certain questions arising during judicial examination of administrative cases and cases on administrative offences related to the application of the legislation on public events'.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 was adopted with a view to ensuring consistency in judicial practice and provided the judiciary with guidelines on the application of the Public Events Act when examining administrative complaints.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 is summarised in Kablis v. Russia (nos. 48310/16 and 59663/17, §§ 29-33, 30 April 2019).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that a refusal to approve a public event, its location or time or the manner in which it is to be conducted may be challenged before a court either by the event organiser or by a person appointed by the organiser to fulfil certain organisational tasks (point 2).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that when examining administrative complaints about public events, courts have to examine whether the interference by a public authority with the right to freedom of public assembly was lawful, necessary and proportionate to a legitimate aim (point 9).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that courts must examine all the grounds advanced by the public authority and all the evidence submitted by it and assess whether the reasons for the interference were relevant and sufficient (point 9).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that a proposal to change the location or time of a public event or the manner in which it is to be conducted must not be arbitrary or unreasoned, and must mention specific facts showing that public interest considerations make it manifestly impossible to hold the public event at the chosen location or time (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that public interests justifying a change of location or time may include normal functioning of essential public utilities, social and transport infrastructure and communications; maintenance of public order and safety of citizens; disruption of pedestrians or traffic or of citizens' access to residential premises or to social or transport facilities; and other similar considerations (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that inconvenience caused to citizens by a public event or an assumption by the authorities that there might be a risk of such inconvenience may not in themselves be considered valid reasons for changing the location or time of a public event (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that the public authority must submit to the court evidence of specific facts making it impossible to hold the public event at the chosen location or time, and courts may not take into account any circumstances which were not mentioned in the proposal to change the location or time of the public event (point 12).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that the public authority must suggest a specific alternative location and time for the public event compatible with its purposes and its social and political significance (point 13).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that the organiser must reply in writing, stating whether he or she accepts the proposed alternative location and/or time, no later than three days before the planned date of the event, and may also propose another location or time for approval (point 13).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 provides that if the organiser wants to change the date of the event, he must submit a new notification (point 13).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Government submitted seventeen judgments delivered by domestic courts between July 2018 and November 2019, with references to Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018, and sometimes Article 11 of the Convention and the European Court of Human Rights' relevant case-law.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Domestic practice on the application of Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "In most of the seventeen judgments submitted by the Government, first-instance courts found local authorities' refusals to approve public events unjustified due to insufficient evidence regarding the unsuitability of the selected location or timing.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Domestic practice on the application of Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "In most of the seventeen judgments submitted by the Government, first-instance courts found local authorities' refusals to approve public events unjustified due to insufficient evidence regarding the inability to hold two events simultaneously for security reasons.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Domestic practice on the application of Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "In the seventeen judgments submitted by the Government, courts deemed any refusal unjustified where the authorities failed to propose an alternative location or time for the public event.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Domestic practice on the application of Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "In the seventeen judgments submitted by the Government, courts deemed any refusal unjustified where the authorities' suggestions for alternative locations did not align with the organisers' intended message of the event.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Domestic practice on the application of Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "In cases where the authorities' refusals to approve the location and time of the public event were found to be lawful and well-reasoned, first-instance courts scrutinized the reasons behind these decisions, including assessment of potential participant numbers making it impossible to host two events concurrently at one place.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Domestic practice on the application of Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "In cases where the authorities' refusals to approve the location and time of the public event were found to be lawful and well-reasoned, first-instance courts scrutinized the reasons behind these decisions, including consideration of construction works planned at the chosen location and time of the event.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Domestic practice on the application of Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "In some instances, appellate courts overturned lower courts' decisions, finding that local authorities' refusals to approve public events were not well-reasoned because they lacked reference to specific facts or evidence.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Domestic practice on the application of Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation ruled in several cases that local authorities' refusals to approve public events were unlawful or ill-founded, overturning lower courts' decisions and either ordering re-examination of the case or issuing a new decision.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Domestic practice on the application of Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The Venice Commission issued a document entitled 'The Compilation of Venice Commission Opinions Concerning Freedom of Assembly' on 1 July 2014 (CDL-PI(2014)0003).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "1. The European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The Venice Commission's Compilation of Opinions Concerning Freedom of Assembly (CDL-PI(2014)0003) states that location is one of the key aspects of freedom of assembly and that the privilege of the organiser to decide which location fits best for the purpose of the assembly is part of the very essence of freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "1. The European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The Venice Commission's Compilation of Opinions Concerning Freedom of Assembly (CDL-PI(2014)0003) states that assemblies in public spaces should not have to give way to more routine uses of the space, as use of public space for an assembly is just as much a legitimate use as any other.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "1. The European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The Venice Commission's Compilation of Opinions Concerning Freedom of Assembly (CDL-PI(2014)0003) states that the purpose of an assembly is often closely linked to a certain location and freedom of assembly includes the right of the assembly to take place within 'sight and sound' of its target object.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "1. The European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The Venice Commission's Compilation of Opinions Concerning Freedom of Assembly (CDL-PI(2014)0003) states that proper restrictions on the use of public places are based on whether the assembly will actually interfere with or disrupt the designated use of a location, and that the mere possibility of an assembly causing inconvenience does not provide a justification for prohibiting it.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "1. The European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The Venice Commission's Compilation of Opinions Concerning Freedom of Assembly (CDL-PI(2014)0003) stresses that it is the privilege of the organiser to decide which location fits best, as demonstrations often need to be conducted in certain specific areas in order to attract attention, and that respect for the autonomy of the organizer in deciding on the place of the event should be the norm.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "1. The European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "The Venice Commission's Compilation of Opinions Concerning Freedom of Assembly (CDL-PI(2014)0003) states that the State has a duty to facilitate and protect peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "1. The European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "The Venice Commission's Compilation of Opinions Concerning Freedom of Assembly (CDL-PI(2014)0003) recommends that a co-operative process between the organizer and the authority be established in order to give the organizer the possibility to improve the framework of the assembly, and that the decision-making and review process be fair and transparent.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "1. The European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "The Venice Commission's Compilation of Opinions Concerning Freedom of Assembly (CDL-PI(2014)0003) states that the organizer of an assembly should not be compelled or coerced either to accept whatever alternative(s) the authorities propose or to negotiate with the authorities about key aspects, particularly the time or place, of a planned assembly, as to require otherwise would undermine the very essence of the right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "1. The European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission)"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "The implementation of the judgment in Lashmankin and Others v. Russia and seventy-two other repetitive cases fell under the enhanced supervision procedure of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "2. The Committee of Ministers"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "At its 1377bis (Human Rights) meeting from 1 to 3 September 2020, the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe examined the status of execution in the Lashmankin group of cases and adopted decision CM/Del/Dec(2020)1377bis/H46-33.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "2. The Committee of Ministers"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe noted in decision CM/Del/Dec(2020)1377bis/H46-33 that although certain positive steps were taken in the Lashmankin group, these were insufficient to attest to tangible progress.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "2. The Committee of Ministers"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe welcomed Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 which provided important clarifications in respect of the relevant practice in the Lashmankin group.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "2. The Committee of Ministers"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe noted the positive examples provided by the Russian authorities in their action plan, consisting of twenty judicial decisions delivered by courts of all levels between July 2018 and February 2020 in various Russian regions.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "2. The Committee of Ministers"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe examined the Lashmankin group at its 1406th (Human Rights) meeting from 7 to 9 June 2021 and adopted decision CM/Del/Dec(2021)1406/H46-29.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "2. The Committee of Ministers"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe welcomed Plenary Supreme Court Ruling no. 28 of 26 June 2018 and other domestic measures in decision CM/Del/Dec(2021)1406/H46-29.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "2. The Committee of Ministers"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "According to the Russian authorities' action plan submitted in connection with the Lashmankin group, in 2020 the first-instance courts found the authorities' refusals to approve the location, time or manner of conducting public events unlawful in 312 cases out of 815 similar challenges.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "2. The Committee of Ministers"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe recalled in decision CM/Del/Dec(2021)1406/H46-29 the necessity of further changes to the Public Events Act with a view to introducing proper notification rules narrowing down the local authorities' discretion in authorising public events and obliging the authorities to assess thoroughly the proportionality of their decisions.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "2. The Committee of Ministers"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe exhorted the Russian authorities to complete the work of amending the Public Events Act without further delay.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "2. The Committee of Ministers"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "At the 1459th (Human Rights) meeting on 9 March 2023, the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe adopted decision CM/Del/Dec(2023)1459/H46-21.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "2. The Committee of Ministers"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "In decision CM/Del/Dec(2023)1459/H46-21, the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe emphasised that the Russian Federation, despite having ceased to be a member of the Council of Europe as of 16 March 2022, was still obliged to implement the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "2. The Committee of Ministers"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "In decision CM/Del/Dec(2023)1459/H46-21, the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe urged the Russian authorities to improve the notification rules on public events and to limit the discretion of local authorities in authorising public events.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "A. Council of Europe materials", "2. The Committee of Ministers"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "In his Report of 21 May 2012 (A/HRC/20/27), the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and freedom of association stressed that States have a negative obligation not to unduly interfere with the right to peaceful assembly (§ 39 of the Report).", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The United Nations Special Rapporteur on the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and freedom of association stated in his Report of 21 May 2012 (A/HRC/20/27) that any restrictions imposed on the right to peaceful assembly must be necessary and proportionate to the aim pursued.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The United Nations Special Rapporteur on the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and freedom of association stated in his Report of 21 May 2012 (A/HRC/20/27) that assemblies must be facilitated within 'sight and sound' of their object and target audience.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The United Nations Special Rapporteur on the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and freedom of association stated in his Report of 21 May 2012 (A/HRC/20/27) that organisers of peaceful assemblies should not be coerced to follow the authorities' suggestions if these would undermine the essence of their right to freedom of peaceful assembly (§ 40 of the Report).", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The United Nations Special Rapporteur on the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and freedom of association warned in his Report of 21 May 2012 (A/HRC/20/27) against the practice whereby authorities allow a demonstration to take place only in the outskirts of the city or in a specific square where its impact will be muted (§ 40 of the Report).", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "B. United Nations documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) were issued by the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) and the European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission) of the Council of Europe.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that any restrictions imposed on assemblies must have a formal basis in law and be based on one or more legitimate grounds: national security, public safety, public order, the protection of public health or morals, and the protection of the rights and freedoms of others (paragraph 28).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that the legitimate grounds for restricting assemblies should not be supplemented by additional grounds in domestic legislation and should be narrowly interpreted by the authorities (paragraph 28).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that any restrictions on the right to freedom of peaceful assembly must be both necessary in a democratic society to achieve a legitimate aim, and proportionate to such aim, and that the least intrusive means of achieving a legitimate aim should always be given preference (paragraph 29).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that the principle of proportionality requires that authorities do not routinely impose restrictions which would fundamentally alter the character of an event, such as relocating assemblies to less central areas of a city (paragraph 29).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that banning or prohibiting an assembly should always be a measure of last resort and should only be considered when a less restrictive response would not achieve the aim (paragraph 29).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that any restrictions on assemblies should not be based on the content of the message that they seek to communicate, and restrictions must not be justified simply on the basis of the authorities' own disagreement with the merits of a particular protest (paragraph 30).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that people have the right in principle to choose the location or route of an assembly in publicly accessible places, including public parks, squares, streets, roads, avenues, sidewalks, pavement, footpaths, and open areas near public buildings and facilities (paragraph 61).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that assemblies should be regarded as an equally legitimate use of public space as other, more routine uses of such space, such as commercial activity or pedestrian and vehicular traffic (paragraph 62).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that where prior notification is submitted for two or more assemblies at the same place and time, simultaneous events should be facilitated where possible (paragraph 78).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that where simultaneous assemblies cannot be facilitated, the organisers should be encouraged to explore alternative options that might yield a mutually satisfactory resolution, and where such a resolution cannot be found, the authorities should still seek to accommodate the different assemblies ensuring that any alternative locations remain within sight and sound of the target audiences (paragraph 78).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that a 'first come, first served' rule must not be implemented in a way that enables some assembly organisers to 'block-book' particular locations, and that simply prohibiting an assembly in the same place and at the same time as an already notified or planned public assembly in cases where both can reasonably be accommodated is likely to amount to a disproportionate and possibly discriminatory response (paragraph 78).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that assemblies should be facilitated within 'sight and sound' of their target audience unless compelling reasons necessitate a change of venue, and that in those cases alternative sites should be provided that are as close as possible to the initially proposed site (paragraph 82).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that involvement in prior negotiations on the part of the organizers should be entirely voluntary, and an unwillingness or refusal to engage in dialogue with the authorities should not have negative repercussions for the organizers or their assembly (paragraph 124).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that those seeking to exercise the right to freedom of peaceful assembly should have recourse to a prompt and effective remedy against decisions disproportionately, arbitrarily or illegally restricting or prohibiting assemblies, and that the relevant court decisions should be issued prior to the planned events (paragraph 125).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that in both administrative and court proceedings, the burden of proof should be on the relevant state authority to prove that the restrictions imposed are justified, and that courts or tribunals should have the authority to review all circumstances of the case (paragraph 125).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that restrictions to the right to freedom of peaceful assembly must be both necessary to achieve a legitimate aim and proportionate to such aim, and that the reasons provided by the authorities for any restriction should be relevant and sufficient, convincing and compelling, and based on a comprehensive assessment of the relevant facts (paragraph 131).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that the principle of proportionality requires that authorities should generally not impose restrictions which would fundamentally alter the character of an event, such as relocating assemblies to less central areas of a city (paragraph 131).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that the types of restriction imposed on an assembly should in principle relate only to its 'time, place, and manner', not to the message that is being communicated, and that States enjoy a certain discretion in relation to time, place and manner restrictions (paragraph 145).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that at the core of the right to freedom of assembly is the ability of the assembly participants to choose the place where they can best communicate their message to their desired audience, and that it would be disproportionate if authorities categorically excluded places suitable and open to the public as sites for peaceful assemblies (paragraph 147).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that the fact that a message could also be expressed in another place is by itself insufficient reason to require an assembly to be held elsewhere, even if that location is within sight and sound of the target audience, and that other means of conveying expression such as placement of video screens are not adequate substitutes for the physical presence of assembly participants within sight and sound of the intended audience (paragraph 147).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "The Joint Guidelines on freedom of peaceful assembly (CDL-AD(2019)017, third edition) state that the designated public authorities and law enforcement officials should make every effort to reach a mutual agreement with the organizers of an assembly on the time, place, and manner of the event (paragraph 169).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL", "C. Other international documents"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F007", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F041", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F048", "F051"], "interference": ["F012", "F016", "F047", "F048"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F095", "F098", "F099", "F100", "F104", "F105", "F113", "F114", "F117", "F118", "F119", "F122", "F123", "F152", "F153", "F156"], "legitimate_aim": ["F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F023"], "necessity": ["F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F016", "F018", "F019", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F030", "F031", "F034", "F044", "F045", "F047", "F048", "F050", "F051", "F053", "F054", "F061", "F062", "F063", "F064", "F066", "F067", "F071", "F076", "F077", "F078", "F080", "F119", "F122"], "positive_obligation": ["F016", "F034", "F053", "F054"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F007", "F009", "F011", "F041", "F044", "F045", "F046"], "interference": ["F012", "F047", "F048"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F113", "F119", "F152", "F156"], "legitimate_aim": ["F013", "F014", "F015", "F023"], "necessity": ["F010", "F012", "F013", "F016", "F019", "F022", "F034", "F044", "F045", "F048", "F051", "F053", "F054", "F066", "F078", "F080"], "positive_obligation": ["F016", "F034", "F053", "F054"]}, "list3": ["F009", "F011", "F013", "F016", "F022", "F034", "F044", "F045", "F048", "F051", "F053", "F054", "F080"]}} {"case_name": "case_509", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_510", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1990.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lived in Moscow until his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 7-65, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 7-33, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The parties' submissions on the circumstances directly relevant to the present case are set out below.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 6 May 2012 a public demonstration entitled the 'March of Millions' was held in central Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration on 6 May 2012 was held to protest against the allegedly rigged presidential elections.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration on 6 May 2012 had been approved by the Moscow city authorities in the form of a march followed by a meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The approved meeting at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 was supposed to end at 7.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The march on 6 May 2012 was peaceful and held without any disruptions.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "When the marchers arrived at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, it became apparent that barriers installed by the police had narrowed the entrance to the meeting venue.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The barriers installed by the police at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 allegedly restricted the space allocated for the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "To control the crowd at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, the police cordon forced the protestors to remain within the barriers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "There were numerous clashes between the police and protestors at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police ordered the meeting at Bolotnaya Square to finish early.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police began to disperse the participants of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "It took the police about two hours to clear Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the Moscow city department of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation opened criminal proceedings to investigate suspected acts of mass disorder under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the Moscow city department of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation opened criminal proceedings to investigate suspected violence against the police under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 18 May 2012 the criminal file opened on 6 May 2012 was transferred to the headquarters of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation for further investigation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 28 May 2012 an investigation was launched into the criminal offence of organising acts of mass disorder under Article 212 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 28 May 2012 the two criminal cases (mass disorder and organising mass disorder) were joined into a single case.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "At the time of his arrest the applicant was a second-year student at the Moscow University of Social Studies.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "At the time of his arrest the applicant worked part-time as a courier for an insurance company.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the applicant, on 6 May 2012 he arrived at Kaluzhskaya Square to take part in the 'March of Millions' demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the applicant, on 6 May 2012 he walked with other participants from Kaluzhskaya Square to Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicant, upon arrival at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 he discovered that the police cordon had blocked access to the square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the applicant, when passage to the stage of the rally taking place along the embankment was opened, the applicant went in that direction.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the applicant, the police started to disperse the protesters at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, using excessive force and beating them with truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the applicant, in response to the police dispersal, the protesters dragged metal barriers into place to protect themselves from the police.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the applicant, at one point he observed a protester in a green T-shirt who five or six police officers were holding and beating with truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the applicant, he grabbed the protester in the green T-shirt and pulled him back, trying to protect him from the truncheon blows.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant was arrested by the police on 6 May 2012 and taken to a police station before being released shortly after.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "After the events of 6 May 2012 the applicant continued to live at his usual address and pursue his studies.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 26 July 2012 the applicant was arrested on suspicion of having participated in acts of mass disorder on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 27 July 2012 the Basmannyy District Court ordered that the applicant be placed in pre-trial detention until 26 September 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court's detention order of 27 July 2012 referred to the gravity of the charges against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court's detention order of 27 July 2012 referred to information about the applicant's character, including a report by Moscow Police's chief of department at the Centre for Counter-Extremism.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the report by Moscow Police's chief of department at the Centre for Counter-Extremism, the applicant was an active member of organisations of a destructive character.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the report by Moscow Police's chief of department at the Centre for Counter-Extremism, if the applicant were to stay at liberty, he planned to threaten witnesses, abscond and obstruct the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court concluded on 27 July 2012 that the circumstances gave sufficient grounds to believe that the applicant was likely to flee to avoid the investigation and trial.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court concluded on 27 July 2012 that the circumstances gave sufficient grounds to believe that the applicant was likely to destroy evidence or otherwise obstruct the investigation of the criminal case, which was still at an initial stage.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 1 August 2012 charges were brought against the applicant under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (participation in acts of mass disorder accompanied by violence).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant was accused of resisting police officers by pushing them away when they were arresting other protestors.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant was accused of trying to liberate protestors who were being arrested by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 27 August 2012 the Moscow City Court upheld the detention order of 27 July 2012 issued by the Basmannyy District Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 24 September 2012 the Basmannyy District Court examined an application from the investigator for an extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "At the hearing on 24 September 2012 the applicant asked for the preventive measure to be changed to house arrest.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "At the hearing on 24 September 2012 the applicant asked for the preventive measure to be changed to a written undertaking not to leave a specified place.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "At the hearing on 24 September 2012 the applicant asked for the preventive measure to be changed to bail.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "At the hearing on 24 September 2012 the applicant asked for the preventive measure to be changed to personal guarantees.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 24 September 2012 the Basmannyy District Court granted the investigator's application and extended the applicant's pre-trial detention until 6 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court's extension order of 24 September 2012 was based on the finding that the circumstances justifying the original detention order had not changed.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 1 October 2012 Police Officer T. identified the applicant during an identification parade as a participant in mass disorder who had used violence against him.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Police Officer T. stated that when he and other officers had been arresting a protester, the applicant had grabbed T.'s hand and pulled it off the protestor, thereby causing Police Officer T. pain.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Police Officer L. identified the applicant during an identification parade as a participant in acts of mass disorder who had tried to prevent the police from arresting another protestor.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 22 October 2012 the Moscow City Court dismissed the applicant's appeal against the extension order of 24 September 2012 issued by the Basmannyy District Court.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 29 October 2012 the Basmannyy District Court granted an extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention until 6 March 2013, essentially on the same grounds as earlier.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court's extension order of 29 October 2012 noted that the circumstances justifying the detention order had not changed.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "In the extension order of 29 October 2012 the Basmannyy District Court dismissed an objection from the applicant to the use of the operational-search reports concerning his character.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "In the extension order of 29 October 2012 the Basmannyy District Court rejected the applicant's contesting of the alleged membership of any organisations of a destructive nature.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 15 November 2012 the charges against the applicant were reformulated.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 21 December 2012 the charges against the applicant were reformulated.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The reformulated charges stated that the applicant had been wearing a surgical mask to conceal his face during the events of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The reformulated charges stated that the applicant had used violence against the police while trying to liberate protestors who had been arrested.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The reformulated charges stated that the applicant had pushed police officers away.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The reformulated charges stated that the applicant had grabbed Police Officer T.'s hand and pulled it off a protester, thereby preventing his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The reformulated charges stated that the applicant had built a line of metal barriers to block the police and had tried to repel the police with them.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The applicant's alleged offences were additionally classified under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (use of violence against a public official).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 5 March 2013 the Basmannyy District Court granted a new extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention until 6 July 2013, essentially on the same grounds as before.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 17 April 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the extension order of 5 March 2013 issued by the Basmannyy District Court.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 24 May 2013 the applicant's criminal case was transferred to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow for the determination of criminal charges.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 6 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow granted another extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention until 24 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The extension order of 6 June 2013 by the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow concerned eleven defendants.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court's extension order of 6 June 2013 was based on the gravity of the charges and the finding that 'the reasons which initially warranted the detention have not changed'.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court's extension order of 6 June 2013 was based on the finding that 'no other measures of restraint would secure the aims and goals of the judicial proceedings'.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The applicant's request for an alternative preventive measure was dismissed by the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court on 6 June 2013 on the grounds that no other measure could secure the proper course of justice in the case.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 2 July 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the extension order of 6 June 2013 issued by the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "On 19 November 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow granted another extension of pre-trial detention in respect of nine defendants, including the applicant, until 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court's extension order of 19 November 2013 was based on the gravity of the charges and the nature of the offences imputable to the defendants.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 17 December 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the extension order of 19 November 2013 issued by the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The applicant was held in remand prison IZ-77/2 for the whole period of his pre-trial detention from 4 September 2012.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of the applicant's detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "According to the applicant, the conditions of his detention in remand prison IZ-77/2 had been poor.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of the applicant's detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The applicant referred to Lind v. Russia (no. 25664/05, §§ 42 and 58-63, 6 December 2007), in which the Court had previously found a breach of Article 3 of the Convention because of overcrowding in remand prison IZ-77/2 in 2004-2005.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of the applicant's detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The applicant referred to Zentsov and Others v. Russia (no. 35297/05, §§ 25-29 and 40-44, 23 October 2012), in which the Court had previously found a breach of Article 3 of the Convention because of overcrowding in remand prison IZ-77/2 in 2004-2005.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of the applicant's detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The applicant referred to Vyatkin v. Russia (no. 18813/06, §§ 26-27 and 38-43, 11 April 2013), in which the Court had previously found a breach of Article 3 of the Convention because of overcrowding in remand prison IZ-77/2 in 2004-2005.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of the applicant's detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The applicant submitted that his conditions of detention in remand prison IZ-77/2 had been similar to those found to breach Article 3 of the Convention in the cases of Lind v. Russia, Zentsov and Others v. Russia, and Vyatkin v. Russia.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of the applicant's detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The applicant's description of the conditions of detention during transfer from the remand prison to court and back was identical to those described in Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 69-73, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Government's submissions regarding the conditions of detention during transfer from the remand prison to court and back were identical to those in Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 69-73, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The applicant submitted that the convoy room of the Moscow City Court was poorly lit.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The applicant submitted that access to the toilet in the convoy room of the Moscow City Court was limited to once an hour.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The applicant submitted that he had been required to strip naked and to perform sit-ups during the body search conducted in the convoy room of the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "On 6 June 2013 court proceedings began in hearing room no. 338 at the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "At the end of July 2013 the court proceedings moved from hearing room no. 338 to hearing room no. 635 at the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The defendants, including the applicant, were held in glass cabins in hearing room no. 338 and hearing room no. 635 at the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "From mid-September 2013 to the end of 2013 the hearings continued at the Nikulinskiy District Court of Moscow in hearing room no. 303.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "In January and February 2014 the hearings took place at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow in hearing room no. 410.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Hearing room no. 303 at the Nikulinskiy District Court of Moscow and hearing room no. 410 at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow were equipped with metal cages in which nine defendants (seven from 19 December 2013), including the applicant, sat during the hearings.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "For a detailed description of the conditions in the hearing rooms used during the trial, see Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 74-77, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 6 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow began a preliminary hearing in a criminal case against ten participants in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The ten defendants in the criminal case before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow were charged with participation in acts of mass disorder and committing acts of violence against police officers.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "On 18 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow began the trial on the merits of the criminal case against the ten participants in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "On 5 September 2013 Police Officer T., the alleged victim of the applicant's assault, was examined as a witness at the trial.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "Police Officer T. testified that the applicant had impeded him and two other police officers from arresting a protester by grabbing T.'s hand and pushing the officers away.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Police Officer T. testified that the applicant had caused him pain but had not inflicted any injuries.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "During the hearing on 5 September 2013 the applicant and his lawyers applied to deprive Police Officer T. of victim status because no harm had been caused to him.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The court refused the applicant's request to deprive Police Officer T. of victim status as unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "On 21 February 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found the applicant guilty as charged.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that between 4 p.m. and 8 p.m. on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square, unidentified persons called those present to move outside the agreed meeting venue and to defy the lawful orders of the police.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that unidentified persons called those present at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 to use violence, which led to mass disorder accompanied by the use of violence against public officials in connection with the performance of their duties and the destruction of property.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that on 6 May 2012 at 5 p.m. at the latest the defendants acquired the criminal intent to participate in mass disorder and to use violence against police officers.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that participants of the acts of mass disorder threw chunks of tarmac, stones, sticks and other objects at the police, which hit them on various parts of their body.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the defendants, who participated in the acts of mass disorder, implemented their criminal intent to use violence against public officials by applying physical force which was not a danger to the life or health of those officials.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the applicant, who was wearing a surgical mask to hide his face, together with unidentified persons, tried to liberate those arrested by the police for a breach of public order and pushed the police officers away.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the applicant used violence against Police Officer T. which did not endanger his life or health.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that from 5 p.m. to 9.40 p.m. on 6 May 2012, when unidentified participants of acts of mass disorder tried to break the police cordon, the applicant acting intentionally grabbed Police Officer T.'s hand and pulled it off the person whom T. was arresting, thus impeding his apprehension, which caused T. pain.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow held that the applicant, together with unidentified persons, built a line of metal barriers blocking the police's movements and tried to repel the line of police officers with the help of those barriers.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The applicant pleaded not guilty at trial and testified that he had decided to attend the public gathering on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The applicant testified that for the purposes of personal security he wore a surgical mask at the demonstration on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The applicant testified that he was at the bridge when a blockage occurred and did not see what was happening, but at one point he had been able to proceed with the flow of people towards the stage.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The applicant testified that at the stage area he saw the mass beating of people by police officers and participants of the rally starting to bring forward metal barriers and to put them close to the police officers, trying to protect themselves from the latter.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The applicant testified that he was standing close to the barriers, taking his hands off when the police officers used their truncheons to hit over the barriers.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The applicant testified that he saw a group of five or six police officers who were trying to seize a young man in a green T-shirt and were hitting the man with their truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The applicant testified that, considering the young man in the green T-shirt was in danger because the police actions were unlawful, he tried to snatch him from the officers' hands by grasping the young man's waistband, pulling it and turning his back to protect him from the truncheon blows.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The applicant testified that he finds it conceivable that in the turmoil he might unintentionally have pushed someone and asked for attention to be paid to Police Officer T.'s statements that T. did not feel any pain.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The applicant testified that after the events at Bolotnaya Square he was arrested and taken to a police vehicle.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow considered the defendants' arguments that they were protecting somebody from police officers or happened to be victims of the police's use of force as farfetched and aimed at the mitigation of their responsibility.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to three years and six months' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The applicant's sentence of three years and six months' imprisonment was calculated on the basis of a three-year prison term under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, partly concurrent with a term of one year and three months under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The applicant's pre-trial detention counted towards his prison sentence.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The applicant appealed against the judgment of 21 February 2014 of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "In his appeal the applicant complained that the same acts imputed to him had been classified under both Article 212 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation and Article 318 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "In his appeal the applicant insisted that he had not used violence against Police Officer T. because T. had not suffered any pain or injuries.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "On 20 June 2014 the Moscow City Court upheld the first-instance judgment of 21 February 2014 of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "Article 212 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the organisation of mass disorder, accompanied by violence, riot, arson, destruction of property, the use of firearms, explosives and explosive devices, as well as armed resistance to a public official, shall be punishable by four to ten years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that participation in the types of mass disorder provided for by Article 212 § 1 shall be punishable by three to eight years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Article 212 § 3 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the instigation of the acts of mass disorder provided for by Article 212 § 1, or the instigation of participation in such acts, or the instigation of violence against citizens, shall be punishable by a restriction of liberty for up to two years, or community service for up to two years, or deprivation of liberty for the same term.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the use of violence which does not endanger life or health, or the threat to use such violence against a public official or his relatives in connection with the performance of his or her duties, shall be punishable by a fine of up to 200,000 roubles or an equivalent of the convicted person's wages for 18 months, or community service for up to five years, or up to five years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic law provisions governing pre-trial detention and the practice of the domestic courts in such matters is set out in Zherebin v. Russia (no. 51445/09, §§ 16-25, 24 March 2016).", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F003", "F004", "F025", "F026", "F010", "F108", "F114", "F116", "F117"], "interference": ["F035", "F043", "F069", "F108", "F128", "F134"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F135", "F136", "F138", "F036", "F043", "F069"], "legitimate_aim": ["F018", "F019", "F043", "F069", "F108"], "necessity": ["F008", "F108", "F115", "F116", "F117", "F128", "F129", "F029", "F031", "F032", "F127", "F054", "F055", "F103", "F104", "F105", "F030", "F121", "F122", "F025", "F026", "F118", "F034", "F074", "F100", "F101"], "positive_obligation": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F008", "F025", "F026", "F010", "F116", "F117"], "interference": ["F108", "F128"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F136", "F138"], "legitimate_aim": ["F018", "F019"], "necessity": ["F008", "F105", "F115", "F116", "F117", "F127", "F128", "F129", "F031", "F032", "F055", "F030", "F121"], "positive_obligation": ["F011", "F013", "F014", "F016"]}, "list3": ["F008", "F108", "F115", "F105", "F116", "F117", "F128", "F129", "F127", "F055"]}} {"case_name": "case_512", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant's details and information relevant to the application are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the location of a public event.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the time of conduct of a public event.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the manner of conduct of a public event.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003", "F004"]}} {"case_name": "case_513", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention and Protocols thereto.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_514", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1969.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Tököl.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr T. Hüttl, a lawyer practising in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Mr T. Hüttl was acting on behalf of the Hungarian Civil Liberties Union.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr Z. Tallódi, of the Ministry of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant planned a demonstration in order to draw attention to the plight of borrowers of foreign-currency loans.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 8 October 2013 the applicant applied to the Budapest Police Department for acquiescence in a demonstration lasting from 17 October until 1 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The demonstration applied for on 8 October 2013 was scheduled to be held in District II of Budapest, in the neighbourhood of the embassy of Israel.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The demonstration applied for on 8 October 2013 was also scheduled to be held in District XII of Budapest, in the neighbourhood of the permanent residence of the Prime Minister.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 10 October 2013 the Budapest Police Department dismissed the applicant's application for acquiescence in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Budapest Police Department observed that on 2 October 2013, closure of the District XII venue had been ordered by the Counter-Terrorism Centre.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The closure of the District XII venue was ordered by the Counter-Terrorism Centre in view of the impending visit of the ambassador of Israel and other protected persons.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The closure measure of the District XII venue was in place from 3 October until 31 December 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Budapest Police Department examined the applicant's application as covering a single demonstration to be held in two locations.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Because the Budapest Police Department examined the application as covering a single demonstration to be held in two locations, the District II location was not examined separately.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "In dismissing the applicant's case, the Budapest Police Department drew the applicant's attention to a venue adjacent to the District XII location where an assembly would have been permissible.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant sought judicial review of the Budapest Police Department's decision of 10 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 14 October 2013 the Budapest Administrative and Labour Court reviewed the entire case.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court noted that the locations selected by the applicant had no symbolic significance.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court noted that the locations selected by the applicant were part of residential zones with narrow streets.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court noted that a demonstration lasting for the period intended would potentially involve crowds, meaning that tents, food stands, loudspeakers and portable toilets would need to be set up.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court noted that a demonstration lasting for the period intended would generate much noise.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court noted that the demonstration would create a situation capable of affecting the private life of residents.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court further stated that the applicant's case was to be tested in relation to the necessity and the proportionality of the restriction complained of.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court observed that there were a number of competing rights at stake: the applicant's right to freedom of assembly, on the one hand; and the rights of others to respect for their private life and free movement, and an official dignitary's right to statutory protection, on the other.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "In the Budapest Administrative and Labour Court's view, the rights of others to respect for their private life and free movement, and an official dignitary's right to statutory protection, outweighed the applicant's interest in having the demonstration at the desired locations.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court held that the demonstration therefore had to be prohibited.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant lodged a constitutional complaint against the decision of the Budapest Administrative and Labour Court.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 9 June 2015 the Constitutional Court declared the applicant's constitutional complaint admissible.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Constitutional Court gave its decision no. 354/2019 (XII.16.) AB on 16 December 2019.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Constitutional Court observed that the Budapest Administrative and Labour Court had construed the rights to respect for private life and free movement, as well as an official dignitary's right to statutory protection, as grounds for restricting the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Constitutional Court found that the Budapest Administrative and Labour Court's reasoning amounted to an unlawful broadening of the scope of exhaustive reasons for the prohibition of a demonstration as contemplated in section 8(1) of the Assembly Act (Act no. III of 1989).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "New regulations had meanwhile been enacted extending the scope of potential reasons for the prohibition of a demonstration under the Assembly Act (Act no. III of 1989).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Constitutional Court was satisfied that the applicant's constitutional complaint had no further purpose and discontinued the case.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Section 8(1) of the Assembly Act (Act no. III of 1989) provides that if the holding of an event subject to prior notification seriously endangers the proper functioning of the representative bodies or courts, or the circulation of traffic cannot be secured by another route, the police may ban the holding of the event at the place or time indicated in the notification, within forty-eight hours of receipt of the notification by the authority.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Section 8(2) of the Assembly Act (Act no. III of 1989) provides that the decision of the police shall be communicated to the organiser in writing within 24 hours.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F007", "F008"], "interference": ["F011", "F028"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F036", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F032", "F033"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F007", "F008"], "interference": ["F011", "F028"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F036", "F032", "F033"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F007", "F008", "F011", "F028", "F036", "F032", "F033"]}} {"case_name": "case_517", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "On 10 April 2006 a group of seven people living in the Dokuzparinskiy District of Dagestan posted a written notice informing the district authorities that on 25 April 2006 they would hold a public demonstration in the village of Usukhchay.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The Dokuzparinskiy District of Dagestan is a mountainous region close to the border with Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants' names were not mentioned in the list of organisers of the demonstration planned for 25 April 2006 in the village of Usukhchay.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "One of the principal aims of the demonstration planned for 25 April 2006 in the village of Usukhchay was to criticise the work of the head of the local administration, Mr A.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "One of the principal aims of the demonstration planned for 25 April 2006 in the village of Usukhchay was to denounce corruption and the misuse of public funds by the local administration.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "One of the principal aims of the demonstration planned for 25 April 2006 in the village of Usukhchay was to draw attention to the inactivity of the law-enforcement agencies regarding abuses committed by Mr A. and his colleagues.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The demonstration planned for 25 April 2006 was supposed to be held in a recreational park in the village of Usukhchay from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The estimated number of participants in the demonstration planned for 25 April 2006 in the village of Usukhchay was 5,000.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The organisers of the demonstration planned for 25 April 2006 in the village of Usukhchay asked the police to dispatch officers for the protection of those participating in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Although the applicants' names were not in the notice of the demonstration planned for 25 April 2006 in the village of Usukhchay, the applicants claimed that they had played an active part in the organisation of the meeting in their respective communities.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The notice of the demonstration planned for 25 April 2006 in the village of Usukhchay was sent to the district administration with copies to the Dokuzparinskiy district prosecutor and the head of the district police department.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicants produced a copy of a payment slip from a post office in Makhachkala indicating that the notice of the demonstration had been posted by registered mail on 10 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "According to documents submitted by the Government, the notice of the demonstration planned for 25 April 2006 in the village of Usukhchay was received by the district administration on 17 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 17 April 2006 the head of the district administration, Mr A. — the same person who was the principal target of the criticism by the demonstrators — informed the organisers that the district administration was opposed to the demonstration planned for 25 April 2006 in the village of Usukhchay.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "In his letter of 17 April 2006, Mr A. stated that the notice of the demonstration had been lodged outside the time-limit fixed in the Public Gatherings Act (Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "In his letter of 17 April 2006, Mr A. stated that the park in Usukhchay was not supposed to admit more than 500 people, making it impossible to hold the planned demonstration there.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "In his letter of 17 April 2006, Mr A. stated that the purpose of the demonstration was to condemn the embezzlement of public funds and the deliberate destruction of financial records by the district administration.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In his letter of 17 April 2006, Mr A. stated that the competent law-enforcement authorities, in particular the prosecutor's office, and financial authorities such as the Ministry of Finance of Dagestan, had already inquired into the allegations of embezzlement and destruction of financial records and concluded that there had been no case to answer.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The letter of 17 April 2006 from Mr A. contained a warning addressed to the organisers that if they proceeded with the demonstration as planned, they would be held liable in accordance with the law.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The refusal by the district administration of 17 April 2006 to allow the demonstration in Usukhchay planned for 25 April 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "At about 4 p.m. on 19 April 2006, a group of men armed with iron rods and sticks attacked another group of individuals near the village of Khiv.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Two persons were injured in the attack near the village of Khiv on 19 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Having received information about the clash near the village of Khiv on 19 April 2006, the Derbent police dispatched a group of officers to the scene.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Derbent police set up an improvised roadblock near the \"Gereykhanov Sovkhoz\" (Kasumkent village) to check passing cars and prevent further clashes following the incident near the village of Khiv on 19 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "A few hours after the police set up the roadblock near the \"Gereykhanov Sovkhoz\" (Kasumkent village), a group of about 300 people armed with wooden sticks, iron rods and similar objects arrived at the roadblock in several cars without licence plates.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the authorities, the second applicant climbed onto the roof of his car at the roadblock near the \"Gereykhanov Sovkhoz\" (Kasumkent village) and started to incite his fellow villagers to resist the police and to run them over.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the authorities, the second applicant's followers started to abuse the police verbally, pushed them out of their way and tried to overturn a police vehicle and a truck which the police had used to block the road near the \"Gereykhanov Sovkhoz\" (Kasumkent village).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "One of the police officers at the roadblock near the \"Gereykhanov Sovkhoz\" (Kasumkent village) was injured and his uniform was ripped during the confrontation on 19 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "As a result of the confrontation at the roadblock near the \"Gereykhanov Sovkhoz\" (Kasumkent village) on 19 April 2006, the police gave up and let the cars pass.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The second applicant denied having participated in the scuffle near the village of Khiv on 19 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The second applicant maintained that on 19 April 2006 he had been taking part in a gathering in the Kurakhskiy District.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The second applicant claimed that at the episode near the police roadblock on 19 April 2006 he had argued with the police officers, asking them to let him and his car through, and that the windscreen of his car had been broken by the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The second applicant claimed that he had not committed any unlawful acts at the roadblock near the \"Gereykhanov Sovkhoz\" (Kasumkent village) on 19 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On an unspecified date the prosecutor's office opened a criminal investigation into the events of 19 April 2006 (case no. 6424).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 21 April 2006 the second applicant was arrested with reference to criminal case no. 6424, which concerned the riot on 19 April 2006 in the village of Khiv.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 22 April 2006 the Khiv District Court granted the police's request to detain the second applicant on remand.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The second applicant was suspected of having committed a crime under Article 212 § 3 (\"Mass riots\") of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation in connection with the events of 19 April 2006 in the village of Khiv.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The second applicant was suspected of having committed a crime under Article 318 § 1 (\"Use of violence against a public official\") of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation in connection with the events of 19 April 2006 in the village of Khiv.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Khiv District Court ruled on 22 April 2006 that the second applicant should be detained because otherwise he might obstruct the establishment of the truth, destroy evidence or abscond.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The second applicant appealed against the Khiv District Court's detention order of 22 April 2006, claiming that the court's decision was unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 28 April 2006 the Supreme Court of Dagestan dismissed the second applicant's appeal against the detention order in a summary fashion.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 20 June 2006 the Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala ordered the second applicant's release, indicating that he had a permanent place of residence, three children to take care of and an elderly father who was ill, and that the charges against him were not serious.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The second applicant was released following the order of the Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala on 20 June 2006.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Subsequently, the criminal case against the second applicant was closed by the trial court for \"active repentance\".", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 19 April 2006 in Kamsumkent and Khiv and the arrest of the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Despite the decision of the local administration of 17 April 2006 whereby the demonstration of 25 April 2006 had not been allowed, the organisers decided to hold it as planned.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The first applicant took part in the \"unauthorised\" demonstration of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The third applicant took part in the \"unauthorised\" demonstration of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The second applicant was not amongst the protesters at the demonstration of 25 April 2006 because at that time he had been detained on remand in connection with the episode of 19 April 2006 in the village of Khiv.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "At about 10 a.m. on 25 April 2006, a group of approximately 1,000 people gathered on the outskirts of Usukhchay.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Other demonstrators were unable to reach the assembly point on the outskirts of Usukhchay on 25 April 2006 because the roads had been blocked by the police.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The organisers of the demonstration on 25 April 2006 tried to meet representatives of the village administration in order to discuss the situation, but to no avail.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "When the demonstrators started moving towards the centre of Usukhchay on 25 April 2006, the police blocked their way.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 25 April 2006 another group of demonstrators from the neighbouring village of Miskindzha were stopped by the police on the way to Usukhchay.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The demonstrators from the village of Miskindzha were ordered by the police on 25 April 2006 to return to Miskindzha and hold their demonstration there separately, if they so wished.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In the afternoon of 25 April 2006, the demonstrators from Usukhchay started moving towards Miskindzha.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Because the police had blocked the road on 25 April 2006, the demonstrators moving from Usukhchay towards Miskindzha had to leave their cars and walk.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Because of bad weather and the long distance to walk, some demonstrators decided to give up on 25 April 2006 during the march from Usukhchay to Miskindzha.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "When the demonstration arrived at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, there were no more than 200 to 300 participants.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The demonstration at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 was peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "At about 3 p.m. on 25 April 2006, the demonstrators at Miskindzha were encircled by police officers from the Special Police Force Unit (OMON).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The police opened fire with automatic rifles above the demonstrators' heads at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The police used tear gas to disperse the demonstration at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The police used smoke bombs to disperse the demonstration at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The police used stun grenades to disperse the demonstration at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The demonstrators at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 started to run in the direction of the village after the police opened fire and used special equipment.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The police officers followed the demonstrators running towards the village of Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 and beat them with rubber truncheons and rifle butts.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "As a result of the dispersal of the demonstration at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, one person was shot dead.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "As a result of the dispersal of the demonstration at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, five people were severely injured.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "As a result of the dispersal of the demonstration at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, several dozen people were beaten up or were injured by the shells of tear-gas bombs which had exploded in the midst of the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Sixty-seven people were arrested following the dispersal of the demonstration at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The organisers of the meeting of 25 April 2006 were charged in connection with their participation in the organisation of an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "According to the first and third applicants' submissions, they were present at the scene of the confrontation in Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 up to a certain moment but left when the clash started at about 3 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Neither the first applicant nor the third applicant was hurt during the clash at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "One of the participants in the demonstration of 25 April 2006, referring to the words of witness Mr S.F., claimed that the gunshot wound received by a police officer had been self-inflicted: the officer concerned had shot himself in the leg by accident because his gun had not been locked.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "1. The first and the third applicants' account"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 24 April 2006 the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Dagestan issued Order No. 7 \"On measures to stabilise the situation in the Dokuzparinskiy District of Dagestan\".", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Order No. 7 of 24 April 2006 issued by the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Dagestan described the unauthorised demonstration of 25 April 2006, which supposedly would involve about two thousand people \"with an aggressive predisposition\".", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Order No. 7 of 24 April 2006 issued by the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Dagestan mentioned the risks of blocking the roads and disturbing the normal work of State institutions in connection with the planned demonstration of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Order No. 7 of 24 April 2006 issued by the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Dagestan provided for the formation of a \"mixed squad\" comprising thirty-five police officers from the Special Forces Unit of the Ministry (OMON) and 147 officers from eight local police stations.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Colonel Iz. was appointed as commander of the \"mixed squad\" formed pursuant to Order No. 7 of 24 April 2006 issued by the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Dagestan.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "Order No. 7 of 24 April 2006 issued by the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Dagestan provided for undercover observation of the leaders of the demonstrators, video-recording of the events, strengthening of identity checks at the roadblocks and other security measures.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The \"mixed squad\" formed pursuant to Order No. 7 of 24 April 2006 moved to Usukhchay and took position at several roadblocks controlling roads leading to the village and near certain buildings occupied by State bodies.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The aim of the police operation in Usukhchay on 25 April 2006 was to secure public order, guarantee the constitutional rights and freedoms of the population and prevent clashes between the supporters of Mr A. and his opponents.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "In their observations, the Government claimed that on the eve of the demonstration of 25 April 2006, someone had taken alcohol, foodstuff and illegal drugs to Usukhchay and distributed them amongst the residents of the village.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "In their observations, the Government claimed that there was information about individuals from other villages who had arrived in Usukhchay with the aim of inciting the local population to participate in the unlawful demonstration and to insubordination to the law-enforcement authorities.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "At about 11 a.m. on 25 April 2006, three groups of people gathered near the premises of the village administration in Usukhchay.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "One group of about 150 people who gathered near the premises of the village administration in Usukhchay on 25 April 2006 were supporters of Mr A., the head of the district administration.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Two other groups — counting about one thousand people in aggregate — who gathered near the premises of the village administration in Usukhchay on 25 April 2006 were opponents of Mr A.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Official documents in the case file refer to another group of about 450 to 500 people who arrived in Usukhchay on 25 April 2006 to take part in the demonstration; it is unclear whether that group was able to join the gathering in the centre or was stopped by the police on the outskirts of the village.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "In view of the risk of clashes between the opposing groups in Usukhchay on 25 April 2006, representatives of the protesters were invited to take part in negotiations in the local prosecutor's office.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The negotiations in the local prosecutor's office on 25 April 2006 involved Colonel Iz., the Deputy Minister of Internal Affairs of Dagestan, the prosecutor Ms Lg., and the head of the local police Mr Akb.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "During the negotiations on 25 April 2006, the authorities proposed to the organisers of the demonstration that they could hold the demonstration in a municipal garage.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The offer to hold the demonstration in a municipal garage was declined by the demonstrators on 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The demonstrators started to move from Usukhchay to Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, where they arrived at about 1 or 2 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Someone blocked the road connecting several villages near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 with objects including paving stones, timber beams and water pipes.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The blocked road near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 was a federal-level road connecting several villages, and its blockage caused a considerable traffic jam.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The authorities warned the organisers of the demonstration on 25 April 2006 that if the road near Miskindzha remained blocked, the organisers would be held liable and the law-enforcement authorities present on the spot would use force and \"special equipment\".", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The organisers of the demonstration on 25 April 2006 refused to follow the instructions to unblock the road near Miskindzha and told other demonstrators to disobey the police orders.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "When the police, following the orders of Deputy Minister Colonel Iz., started to remove the barricade from the road near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, unidentified men in the crowd started to throw stones at them.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Several shots were fired from a garden situated uphill on the left side of the road near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Some of the protesters at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 were armed with cold weapons such as iron rods, which they used as bats while attacking the police.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "Some of the protesters at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 tried to grab the service guns from the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "As a result of the confrontation at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, the police used two stun grenades.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "As a result of the confrontation at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, the police used twenty-three tear-gas grenades.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "As a result of the confrontation at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, the police used thirty-six rubber bullets.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "As a result of the confrontation at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, the police fired 747 shots from automatic rifles above the heads of the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Fifty-two of the most active protesters at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 were arrested and taken to the Dokuzparinskiy police station.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Unidentified police officers used pump-action shotguns loaded with 22 mm grenades filled with tear gas at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, and those shots were fired in the direction of the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Following the clash between the police and the demonstrators at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, eleven police officers had bruises on their arms and legs, scratches and concussion.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Following the clash between the police and the demonstrators at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, one police officer had a ruptured spleen.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Following the clash between the police and the demonstrators at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, police officer Mr Il. had a gunshot wound in the form of a perforated bullet hole in the right thigh.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Following the clash at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, Mr Akh. had a blunt gunshot wound to the right side of the thorax with fractured ribs.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Following the clash at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, Mr Nsr. had a gunshot wound to the left side of the thorax with broken shoulder bones.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Following the clash at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, Mr Al. was wounded by a shell fragment in the right shin and thigh.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Following the clash at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, Mr Gnd. had a gunshot wound to the right forearm with a fractured bone.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Following the clash at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, Mr Ng. received a mortal wound by a gas grenade to the thorax and died on the way to hospital.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "2. The Government's account"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "In support of their account of the events of 25 April 2006, the Government produced some documents apparently obtained in the course of the investigation (case no. 67610).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "It is unclear whether all the documents produced by the Government related to case no. 67610 and whether they constituted the entirety of the materials collected within that case.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Government produced medical certificates describing the injuries of several police officers following the clash at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, but not those of police officer Mr Il.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The Government produced several medical certificates describing the injuries sustained by the protesters at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, all of whom had bruises and scratches.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "According to the medical certificates, the protesters claimed that the police had kicked, beaten and battered them with rubber truncheons and gun butts during the events of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Some of the protesters at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 had been injured by the rubber bullets used by the police.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Some protesters claimed that they had been beaten up after having been arrested and taken to the Dokuzparinskiy police station following the events of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Mr Akb., the head of the Dokuzparinskiy police, gave testimony about the events of 25 April 2006 that was generally consonant with the Government's account.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Mr Akb. stated that he had been warned about the demonstration of 25 April 2006 in a telegram sent by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "On 17 April 2006 Mr Akb. met one of the organisers of the demonstration and discussed the event.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "At some time after 10 a.m. on 25 April 2006, Mr Akb.'s men stopped a large group of protesters who had been trying to enter Usukhchay.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Mr Akb. spoke with the leaders of the protesters on 25 April 2006 and explained to them that \"the demonstration had not been authorised, and that the actions [of the demonstrators] were unlawful\".", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "During negotiations on 25 April 2006, the deputy head of the district administration proposed to the protesters that they hold the demonstration in a municipal garage, explaining that if they stayed in the square near the district administration premises, they risked blocking the main road.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The leaders of the protesters visited the municipal garage on 25 April 2006 but were not satisfied with the offer to hold the demonstration there.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The leaders of the protesters informed the authorities on 25 April 2006 that they would send the protesters to Miskindzha and hold their demonstration there, in the village community centre.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "After the negotiations on 25 April 2006, a small group of protesters started to move towards the village centre of Usukhchay, whereas others marched to Miskindzha, accompanied by the police.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "At about 1 p.m. on 25 April 2006, Mr Akb. was informed that the federal road near Miskindzha had been blocked by two large heaps of stones.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Mr Akb. arrived at the scene near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 and started to negotiate with the leaders of the protesters, trying to persuade them to unblock the road, but they refused and insisted on meeting the leadership of the Dagestan Republic.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "New people arrived at the scene near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, armed with stones and sticks.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "Since the negotiations near Miskindzha had failed on 25 April 2006, Mr Akb. ordered the police to start clearing the road.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The men who had gathered on the sides of the road near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 started to throw stones at the police officers, several of whom were hit, so Mr Akb. authorised the use of shields and rubber truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "Once the first heap of stones had been removed near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 and traffic had started to move, the police discovered that 300 metres further down the road it had again been obstructed with pipes.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "Throughout the time the police were clearing the road near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, police officers had stones thrown at them.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Mr Akb. authorised the police to use firearms near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 but only above the heads of the protesters.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "By 6 p.m. on 25 April 2006 the road near Miskindzha had been unblocked.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "Witness Mr Yakh., one of the protesters, testified that when they had arrived in Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, the road had not yet been blocked.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "Witness Mr Yakh. testified that people had started to block the road near Miskindzha spontaneously with stones in order to draw the authorities' attention to their claims.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "Witness Mr Yakh. testified that the leaders of the demonstration at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, who spoke before the crowd, called everybody to order and asked them not to break the law.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Witness Mr Yakh. testified that a police colonel appeared at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 and asked the leaders of the protesters to unblock the road, but they refused.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "Witness Mr Yakh. testified that the police attacked the protesters from two sides at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 and started to shoot and throw gas grenades into the crowd, causing people to run in the direction of Miskindzha.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "Witness Mr Yakh. testified that he had not seen protesters throwing stones at the police at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006; by contrast, the police had thrown stones at the crowd in order to unblock the road.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Witness Mr Ag., a district administration official, testified that all the protesters at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, including women and elderly people, had been drunk, because earlier a mini-lorry had brought a cargo of vodka which had been distributed to the protesters.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Witness Mr Ag. testified that he joined the crowd and went with the protesters to Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, where he listened to the speeches of the leaders of the demonstration before a crowd of approximately 300 people.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Witness Mr Ag. testified that after the failure of the negotiations between the protesters and the authorities at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, the leaders started to incite the protesters to throw stones.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "Witness Mr Ag. testified that he heard the sound of shots coming from the side where the protesters had gathered at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, and that a police officer was wounded.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "Witness Mr Ag. testified that the police started to move towards the protesters at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 and fired two or three warning shots above their heads.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "Witness Mr Ag. testified that when the police started to remove the stones from the road and arrest the protesters at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, he left.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "Witness Mr Ag. testified that on the way back from Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 he overheard two women complaining that the organisers had not paid them and that they had been used as a human shield against the police.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "According to an undated report by the head of the Special Forces Unit, Major Kr., the police had started using gas grenades at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 only when a large group of about 1,000 men armed with iron rods, wooden sticks and knives had attacked them.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Major Kr. specified in his undated report that when his officers were moving from the first barricade to the second near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, someone had started to shoot at them from under the nearby trees with an automatic gun and a hunter's gun.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "Witness Mr Agb. testified that on 25 April 2006 he had been going on his business but had been stopped by the crowd near Miskindzha.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "Witness Mr Agb. testified that he heard the first applicant calling the protesters not to block the road but to gather in the community centre of Miskindzha on 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "Witness Mr Agb. testified that some of the demonstrators disobeyed the first applicant's call on 25 April 2006; two lorries arrived and dumped stones on the road near Miskindzha.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "Witness Mr Agb. testified that some of the protesters were throwing stones at the police near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "Witness Mr Chub. was the driver of the lorry that had brought stones for the first barricade near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "Witness Mr Chub. explained that he had loaded the stones near the river in order to build a shed in his garden, and that near the entry to Miskindzha he was stopped by a group of youngsters who ordered him, under the threat of violence, to dump the stones directly on the road.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The written testimonies of several other eyewitnesses of the events at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 were inconclusive.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "Some eyewitnesses of the events at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 testified that a group of adolescents had been throwing stones at the police.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "Some eyewitnesses of the events at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 testified that the police had used firearms by shooting in the air, whereas the demonstrators had no firearms.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "Some eyewitnesses of the events at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 heard shots from the side of the protesters.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Demonstration of 25 April 2006 in Usukhchay and Miskindzha and its dispersal", "3. Documents submitted by the Government"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "On 29 April 2006 the first applicant (Mr Primov) was arrested for participating in the organisation of an unauthorised demonstration on 25 April 2006 (criminal case no. 67610).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Primov) was suspected of having committed a crime under Article 213 § 2 (\"Hooliganism\") of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation in connection with the events of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Primov) was suspected of having committed a crime under Article 318 § 2 (\"Use of violence against a public official\") of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation in connection with the events of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "The police suspected that the first applicant (Mr Primov) had incited the demonstrators to block the road and to \"disobey the lawful orders of the police with the use of firearms\" during the events of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The police applied to the Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala for a detention order against the first applicant (Mr Primov).", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "According to the Government, the decision of the Prosecutor of the Dagestan Republic (the Regional Prosecutor's Office) to seek the first applicant's (Mr Primov's) detention was based on the witness statements of Mr Als., Mr Agsh., Mr Shk. and an anonymous witness.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The witnesses Mr Als., Mr Agsh., Mr Shk. and an anonymous witness identified the first applicant (Mr Primov) as one of the leaders of the demonstration who had incited the crowd to attack the police during the events of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "On 30 April 2006 the Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala placed the first applicant (Mr Primov) in pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "In its ruling of 30 April 2006, the Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala noted that the first applicant (Mr Primov) was suspected of having committed a serious crime and that he might continue his criminal activity, abscond or obstruct the course of justice.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "In its ruling of 30 April 2006, the Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala also referred to the first applicant's (Mr Primov's) \"personality\" as a reason for pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "The first applicant's (Mr Primov's) lawyer appealed against the pre-trial detention order of 30 April 2006, indicating that the first applicant worked as head of a municipal social-security office, had a permanent place of residence and four children, and had good references from his colleagues and neighbours.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "The first applicant's (Mr Primov's) lawyer stated in the appeal that the first applicant had not been contacted by the investigators before his arrest on 29 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "The first applicant's (Mr Primov's) lawyer noted in the appeal that a suspect could be held in pre-trial detention before being formally charged only in exceptional circumstances.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "The first applicant's (Mr Primov's) lawyer noted in the appeal that the court's ruling of 30 April 2006 did not refer to any specific facts showing that the first applicant indeed intended to continue his criminal activities, abscond or obstruct the course of justice.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "The first applicant's (Mr Primov's) lawyer pointed to various irregularities in the application by the police and in the court's ruling of 30 April 2006 imposing the detention order.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "On 6 May 2006 the Supreme Court of Dagestan dismissed the first applicant's (Mr Primov's) appeal against the pre-trial detention order in a summary fashion.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "The Supreme Court of Dagestan's reasoning in dismissing the first applicant's (Mr Primov's) appeal on 6 May 2006 was identical to that of the Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "On 8 May 2006 the first applicant (Mr Primov) was charged under Article 213 § 3 and Article 318 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "In the indictment of 8 May 2006, the first applicant (Mr Primov) was referred to as \"the organiser of the demonstration\".", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "The indictment of 8 May 2006 mentioned that, as one of the organisers of the demonstration, the first applicant (Mr Primov) had ordered the protesters to block the road, throw stones in the direction of the police and use firearms.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Primov) had a confrontation with the witnesses who had earlier identified him as one of the instigators of the riot, and according to the Government, they all denied their previous allegations concerning his role in the riot.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "On 27 June 2006 the Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala refused to extend the first applicant's (Mr Primov's) pre-trial detention, ruling that the police had not produced any evidence that he might abscond or obstruct the course of justice.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala on 27 June 2006 stated that the need to question other demonstrators who had used violence against the police was not a good reason for extending the first applicant's (Mr Primov's) detention.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala on 27 June 2006 stated that the first applicant (Mr Primov) had no previous convictions, was married, was in employment, had good references, had been awarded State decorations and had a permanent place of residence.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Primov) was released following the Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala's refusal on 27 June 2006 to extend his pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(a) Arrest and detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "On 25 December 2006 the criminal case against the first applicant (Mr Primov) was discontinued for lack of evidence.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "The investigator established that the road going to Miskindzha had been blocked by the protesters on 25 April 2006; when the police had tried to clear the road, the protesters had started to throw stones and sticks at them.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "The investigator established that several police officers had been injured during the events of 25 April 2006 near Miskindzha; police officer Mr Il. had been wounded by a bullet fired from a hunter's gun.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "The investigator's decision to discontinue the case against the first applicant (Mr Primov) referred to the protocol of examining the site of the clash, during which 139 5.45 mm cartridges (the type used in the police's automatic guns) were discovered.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "The investigator's decision to discontinue the case against the first applicant (Mr Primov) referred to the protocol of examining the site of the clash, during which one 7.45 mm cartridge (standard army Kalashnikov rifle) was discovered.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "The investigator's decision to discontinue the case against the first applicant (Mr Primov) referred to the protocol of examining the site of the clash, during which two cardboard cartridges (hunter's gun) were discovered.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "The investigator's decision to discontinue the case against the first applicant (Mr Primov) referred to the protocol of examining the site of the clash, during which one cartridge from a tear-gas grenade was discovered.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "The investigator referred to the testimony of several demonstrators who stated that when the police had approached the demonstrators at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, most of the people had remained calm.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "The investigator referred to the testimony of several demonstrators who stated that some time later, a group of young men identified as \"the people of Mr Kanberov\" had arrived at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 and started to throw stones and shout insults at the police.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "Two police officers questioned by the investigator were granted anonymity and testified that the leaders of the demonstration on 25 April 2006, including the first and third applicants, had ordered the protesters to disobey the police and throw stones at them.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "The testimony of the two anonymous police officers was confirmed by several other police officers who testified under their real names, including Mr Sch.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "During a face-to-face confrontation with the first applicant (Mr Primov), police officer Mr Sch. retracted his statement that the first applicant had ordered the protesters to disobey the police and throw stones at them.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "Police officer Mr Msl. testified that the first applicant (Mr Primov) had left the scene of the confrontation at Miskindzha between 12 noon and 1 p.m. on 25 April 2006, namely before the start of the clash, because of an emergency in his family.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "The fact that the first applicant (Mr Primov) had left the scene of the confrontation at Miskindzha before the start of the clash on 25 April 2006 was confirmed by witness Mr Dzhv.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "Witness Mr Um. testified that the first applicant (Mr Primov) had tried to persuade the protesters to follow the orders of the police and had designated thirty people to keep order during the demonstration of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F205", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Primov) and the third applicant (Mr Askerov) were questioned by the investigator and denied their guilt, claiming that they had been collaborating with the police and had tried to call the protesters to order during the events of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F206", "text": "The investigator referred to a video recording of the demonstration of 25 April 2006 which showed that the first applicant (Mr Primov) and the third applicant (Mr Askerov) had asked the protesters not to react to provocations and to remain calm.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F207", "text": "On 25 December 2006 the first applicant (Mr Primov) was informed of his right to claim damages in connection with the criminal prosecution against him.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "1. The first applicant (Mr Primov)", "(b) Findings of the domestic investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F208", "text": "The third applicant (Mr Askerov) was arrested on 29 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F209", "text": "It is undisputed that the third applicant (Mr Askerov) was present during the demonstration of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F210", "text": "The third applicant's (Mr Askerov's) arrest on 29 April 2006 was connected not to the demonstration of 25 April 2006 but to his role in the events of 19 April 2006 in the village of Khiv and was ordered within criminal case no. 6424.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F211", "text": "On 1 May 2006 the Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala ordered the third applicant's (Mr Askerov's) pre-trial detention, reasoning that as he might be given a prison sentence, he might abscond.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F212", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala noted on 1 May 2006 that although the arrest warrant had been issued by the police on 20 April 2006, the third applicant (Mr Askerov) had not been arrested until 29 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F213", "text": "The third applicant (Mr Askerov) appealed against the pre-trial detention order of 1 May 2006, stating that before 29 April 2006 the police had not taken any steps to enforce the arrest warrant of 20 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F214", "text": "The third applicant (Mr Askerov) stated in his appeal that he had been arrested on the premises of the Ministry of the Interior of Dagestan, where he had gone of his own motion.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F215", "text": "On 6 May 2006 the Supreme Court of Dagestan upheld the findings of the first-instance court regarding the third applicant's (Mr Askerov's) pre-trial detention in a summary fashion.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F216", "text": "On 6 May 2006 the third applicant (Mr Askerov) was charged under Articles 212 and 318 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation for participating in the events of 19 April 2006 in the village of Khiv.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F217", "text": "The charges against the third applicant (Mr Askerov) in connection with the events of 19 April 2006 in the village of Khiv were similar to those against the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F218", "text": "On 26 June 2006 the Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala refused to extend the third applicant's (Mr Askerov's) pre-trial detention, ruling that the police had not produced any evidence that he might abscond or obstruct the course of justice.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F219", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala on 26 June 2006 indicated that the need to conduct further investigative steps was not a legitimate reason for extending the third applicant's (Mr Askerov's) detention.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F220", "text": "The Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala on 26 June 2006 concluded that it was possible to apply a milder preventive measure than detention for the third applicant (Mr Askerov).", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F221", "text": "The third applicant (Mr Askerov) was released following the Sovetskiy District Court of Makhachkala's refusal on 26 June 2006 to extend his pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F222", "text": "According to the Government's submissions, the accusations against the third applicant (Mr Askerov) were based on the testimony of one witness.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F223", "text": "The prosecution authorities decided to drop the charges against the third applicant (Mr Askerov).", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Arrest of the participants and organisers of the demonstration", "2. The third applicant (Mr Askerov)"]}, {"fact_id": "F224", "text": "On 25 April 2006 the Regional Prosecutor's Office of the Dagestan Republic ordered a criminal investigation into the events in Usukhchay and Miskindzha (case no. 67611).", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F225", "text": "The facts investigated in criminal case no. 67611 were categorised under Article 105 § 2 (e) (\"Murder\") of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F226", "text": "The facts investigated in criminal case no. 67611 were categorised under Article 222 (\"Unlawful possession of or trafficking in firearms\") of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F227", "text": "On 7 May 2006 Colonel Mk., acting head of the Special Forces Unit (OMON) of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Dagestan, drew up a report on the events of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F228", "text": "Colonel Mk. explained in his report of 7 May 2006 that the tear-gas grenades had been used at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 when the protesters attacked the police with iron rods and tried to grab the service guns.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F229", "text": "On 10 May 2006 an internal inquiry carried out by the federal Ministry of the Interior concluded that the police's actions on 25 April 2006 had been appropriate.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F230", "text": "According to the final report of the internal inquiry of 10 May 2006, at 4.45 p.m. on 25 April 2006 Colonel Iz. had ordered his officers to unblock the road near Miskindzha, but the officers were attacked by a group of men armed with iron rods, stones and knives.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F231", "text": "According to the final report of the internal inquiry of 10 May 2006, some of the men who attacked the police near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 tried to grab the officers' service guns.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F232", "text": "According to the final report of the internal inquiry of 10 May 2006, when the police entered Miskindzha on 25 April 2006, they discovered a lorry loaded with alcohol, cigarettes and foodstuff.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F233", "text": "Lieutenant-Colonel Mr Og. testified that his men had been fired at from the nearby gardens located on the left side of the road near Miskindzha on 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F234", "text": "Police officer Mr Il. (who had sustained a bullet wound to his thigh) testified that a hooded man had shot at him with a hunter's gun during the events of 25 April 2006 near Miskindzha.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F235", "text": "An appendix to the internal inquiry of 10 May 2006 described restrictions on the use of gas grenades; in particular, it was prohibited to \"shoot gas grenades directly at humans\".", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F236", "text": "On an unspecified date in May 2006, the first applicant (Mr Primov) drafted and submitted to the investigator his account of the events of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F237", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Primov) claimed in his account that the demonstration of 25 April 2006 had started peacefully, despite information that a group of Mr A.'s supporters had occupied the park in Usukhchay.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F238", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Primov) claimed that during the negotiations with the authorities in the morning of 25 April 2006, the authorities' representatives warned the protesters that if they insisted on holding the demonstration in Usukhchay, there would be bloodshed.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F239", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Primov) claimed that in the afternoon of 25 April 2006, when the demonstrators refused to leave the road near Miskindzha, the police started to shoot and beat them with rubber truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F240", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Primov) submitted to the prosecutor a video recording of the start of the clash at Miskindzha on 25 April 2006 and requested the questioning of several participants of the events.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F241", "text": "On 19 October 2006 the Regional Prosecutor's Office of the Dagestan Republic opened a criminal investigation under Article 286 § 3 (b) and (c) of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (\"Abuse of office\") concerning the killing of Mr Ng. (case no. 668459).", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F242", "text": "On 4 December 2006 criminal cases nos. 668459 and 67611 were joined.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F243", "text": "According to the Government, within criminal cases nos. 668459 and 67611 the investigators questioned more than seventy witnesses and conducted ballistic and medical forensic examinations.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F244", "text": "The relatives of the victims or the victims themselves were granted the status of victims in the proceedings of criminal cases nos. 668459 and 67611.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F245", "text": "The prosecution was unable to establish the persons responsible for the facts at the heart of the investigation in criminal cases nos. 668459 and 67611.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F246", "text": "On 20 February 2007 the investigation in criminal cases nos. 668459 and 67611 was suspended.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F247", "text": "The investigator held that \"in breach of the instruction on the use of special equipment ... No. 865dsp, officers of the Special Forces Unit ... fired twenty-three 23mm gas grenades\" during the events of 25 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F248", "text": "It was impossible to identify the police officers who had fired the fatal shot during the events of 25 April 2006 near Miskindzha.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F249", "text": "On an unidentified date the investigation in criminal cases nos. 668459 and 67611 was reopened after being suspended on 20 February 2007.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F250", "text": "On 16 January 2010 the investigation in criminal cases nos. 668459 and 67611 was suspended again.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Criminal investigation into the events of 25 April 2006 and other inquiries"]}, {"fact_id": "F251", "text": "Article 30 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation provides that everyone has the right to freedom of association.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F252", "text": "Article 55 § 3 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation provides that rights and freedoms may be restricted by federal laws for the protection of constitutional principles, public morals, health and the rights and lawful interests of others, and to ensure the defence and security of the State.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F253", "text": "The Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004, \"the Public Gatherings Act\") provided for the rights and duties of the organisers of public events as in force at the relevant time.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F254", "text": "The relevant provisions of the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004) were summarised in detail in the case of Alekseyev v. Russia (nos. 4916/07, 25924/08 and 14599/09, § 50, 21 October 2010).", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F255", "text": "Section 5 of the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004) provided that the organiser of a public event had to submit to the municipal authority a written notice in accordance with section 7 of that law.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F256", "text": "Section 5 of the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004) provided that the organiser had the right to hold a demonstration at the venue and time specified in the notice or as altered by agreement with the municipal authority.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F257", "text": "Section 5 of the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004) provided that the organiser had the right to hold assemblies at a venue that had been specially allocated or adapted to ensure the safety of citizens while such assemblies were held.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F258", "text": "Section 5 of the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004) provided that the organiser had to require the participants in the public event to observe public order and comply with the lawful requirements of the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F259", "text": "Under section 5(5) of the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004), the organiser of the public event had no right to hold it if the notice on holding the public event had not been submitted in due time or no agreement had been reached with the municipal authorities on their reasoned proposal as to the alteration of the venue and/or time of the public event.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F260", "text": "Section 7 of the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004) provided that a written notice about a public event had to be lodged by the organiser with the municipal authority concerned not earlier than fifteen days and not later than ten days before the date of the event.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F261", "text": "Under Part 2 of the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004), the procedure for lodging notices of public events had to be defined in the regional legislation.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F262", "text": "Under section 8 of the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004), a public event could be held at any suitable venue provided that it did not threaten the safety of the participants.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F263", "text": "Under section 12 of the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004), the municipal authorities, upon receiving notice of the public event, had to propose an alternative venue and/or time for the public event if the original conditions set out in the notice did not correspond to the requirements of the law.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F264", "text": "Under section 12 of the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004), the municipal authorities also had to ensure, within their competence and jointly with the organisers and the authorised representative of the Ministry of the Interior, that public order and the safety of citizens while holding the event were respected.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F265", "text": "Under section 19 of the Federal Law on Assemblies, Meetings, Demonstrations, Marches and Picketing (no. 54-FZ of 18 August 2004), decisions, acts or omissions of municipal authorities could be contested in court in accordance with the law.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. The Public Gatherings Act"]}, {"fact_id": "F266", "text": "Under the Code of Civil Procedure of 2002, a person affected by an unlawful administrative act or omission by a State or municipal authority disposes of two types of remedy: a \"complaint\" or a \"claim\" (иск) against the State.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Judicial review of the actions of the municipal authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F267", "text": "Complaints under the Code of Civil Procedure of 2002 are governed by Chapter 25 of the Code (\"Challenging decisions, acts or omissions of State and municipal authorities and officials\").", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Judicial review of the actions of the municipal authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F268", "text": "The Code of Civil Procedure of 2002 provides for judicial review of decisions and other acts of State or municipal officials if those acts breached the rights and freedoms of the interested person.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Judicial review of the actions of the municipal authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F269", "text": "Article 258 § 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure of 2002 provides that a complaint must not be granted if the action challenged in court \"is in compliance with the law, has been taken within the jurisdiction of the State body or official and the rights and freedoms of the citizen have not been violated\".", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Judicial review of the actions of the municipal authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F270", "text": "As follows from Article 258 of the Code of Civil Procedure of 2002, a successful plaintiff under Chapter 25 may obtain an injunction against the State body or official concerned, by which the court must require \"full elimination of the breach of the rights and freedoms\".", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Judicial review of the actions of the municipal authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F271", "text": "The Code of Civil Procedure of 2002 is silent on whether Chapter 25 allows the plaintiff to seek reliefs other than an injunction, in particular damages.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Judicial review of the actions of the municipal authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F272", "text": "Article 257 of the Code of Civil Procedure of 2002 provides that complaints lodged under Chapter 25 of the Code must be examined within ten days from the date of their lodging.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Judicial review of the actions of the municipal authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F273", "text": "Under Article 338 of the Code of Civil Procedure of 2002, the parties have ten days to lodge an appeal following a decision on a complaint under Chapter 25.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Judicial review of the actions of the municipal authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F274", "text": "Under Article 348 of the Code of Civil Procedure of 2002, the Court of Appeal has one month from the date of its receipt to consider an appeal lodged under Article 338.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Judicial review of the actions of the municipal authorities"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F003", "F009", "F012", "F013", "F020", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F034", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F051", "F054", "F071", "F084", "F093", "F097", "F099", "F107", "F108", "F109", "F131", "F134", "F135", "F158", "F162", "F168", "F190", "F191", "F192", "F193", "F194", "F195", "F205", "F206", "F210", "F216", "F229", "F230"], "interference": ["F003", "F034", "F051", "F059", "F080", "F165", "F210"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F001", "F012", "F013", "F260", "F261"], "legitimate_aim": ["F020", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F077", "F080", "F081", "F168", "F170", "F171"], "necessity": ["F001", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F020", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F048", "F051", "F077", "F080", "F086", "F087", "F090", "F091", "F093", "F094", "F097", "F099", "F106", "F107", "F108", "F109", "F126", "F165", "F168", "F170", "F171", "F185", "F189", "F190", "F192", "F193", "F194", "F195", "F201", "F235", "F247"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F001", "F009", "F034", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F071", "F093", "F097", "F099", "F107", "F108", "F109", "F168", "F190", "F192", "F205", "F206", "F210"], "interference": ["F003", "F034", "F051", "F080", "F165", "F210"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F001", "F012", "F013", "F260", "F261"], "legitimate_aim": ["F020", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F168", "F170", "F171"], "necessity": ["F001", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F020", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F048", "F051", "F077", "F080", "F090", "F091", "F093", "F094", "F097", "F099", "F106", "F107", "F108", "F109", "F165", "F168", "F170", "F171", "F189", "F190", "F192", "F193", "F194", "F195", "F235", "F247"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F001", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F048", "F051", "F077", "F080", "F090", "F091", "F093", "F094", "F097", "F099", "F107", "F108", "F109", "F192", "F193", "F194", "F195", "F106", "F235", "F247"]}} {"case_name": "case_518", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of the disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants, except for Ms Kuzmina (application no. 49671/21), also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention and its Protocol.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_519", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "On 29 January 2009 the police arrested a person who was protesting peacefully in front of the Prosecutor General's Office.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "As a reaction to the arrest of a peaceful protester in front of the Prosecutor General's Office on 29 January 2009, the applicant organisations decided to hold a demonstration in front of the Prosecutor General's Office.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "As a reaction to the arrest of a peaceful protester in front of the Prosecutor General's Office on 29 January 2009, the applicant organisations decided to hold a march from the Prosecutor General's Office to the Ministry of Internal Affairs.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "As a reaction to the arrest of a peaceful protester in front of the Prosecutor General's Office on 29 January 2009, the applicant organisations decided to hold a demonstration in front of the Ministry of Internal Affairs.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 2 February 2009 the first and the second applicants lodged a notification with the municipal authorities stating their intention to conduct a demonstration in front of the Prosecutor General's Office, followed by a march to the Ministry of Internal Affairs and a demonstration in front of the Ministry of Internal Affairs.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "In the notification lodged on 2 February 2009, the first and the second applicants described the planned event as a spontaneous reaction to the events of 29 January 2009.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "In the notification lodged on 2 February 2009, the first and the second applicants relied on Section 12(1) of the Assemblies Act of 2008.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 3 February 2009 the first and the second applicants organised a protest demonstration in front of the Prosecutor General's Office.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "From the video submitted by the parties, it appears that approximately twenty individuals took part in the demonstration on 3 February 2009 in front of the Prosecutor General's Office.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The third applicant was among the participants in the demonstration on 3 February 2009 in front of the Prosecutor General's Office.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Several minutes after the beginning of the demonstration on 3 February 2009, the protesters were attacked by six men wearing masks.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The six masked attackers physically assaulted the protesters during the demonstration on 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The six masked attackers sprayed tear gas over the protesters during the demonstration on 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The six masked attackers sprayed paint over the protesters during the demonstration on 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "As a result of the attack on 3 February 2009, the third applicant sustained numerous injuries to his head and limbs.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "As a result of the attack on 3 February 2009, the third applicant needed medical treatment.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The protesters defended themselves and managed to chase away the attackers during the attack on 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The protesters managed to immobilise two of the six attackers during the attack on 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "One of the attackers admitted to having been paid 1,000 Moldovan lei (approximately 60 euros) by an unknown person for his participation in the attack on 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "From the very beginning of the gathering on 3 February 2009, four uniformed police officers observed the event from a patrol car parked close to the place of the event.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The event on 3 February 2009 was filmed by approximately six people in plain clothes.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the applicants, the approximately six people in plain clothes who filmed the event on 3 February 2009 were police officers.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Government denied that the approximately six people in plain clothes who filmed the event on 3 February 2009 were police officers.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "When the clash between the protesters and the attackers began on 3 February 2009, no police officer intervened.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The protesters called the police and requested assistance during the attack on 3 February 2009, but received no assistance.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "A police patrol appeared only one hour and a half after the attack began on 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The police patrol that arrived one hour and a half after the attack began on 3 February 2009 took the two immobilised attackers into custody.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The organisers of the demonstration lodged a criminal complaint with the Prosecutor General's Office following the attack on 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "In the criminal complaint lodged with the Prosecutor General's Office, the organisers of the demonstration complained inter alia about the failure of the police to intervene promptly during the attack on 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "A criminal investigation was initiated following the criminal complaint lodged by the organisers of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "All six attackers who attacked the demonstration on 3 February 2009 were identified in the course of the criminal investigation.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Only two of the six attackers were eventually given suspended sentences of four years for violation of the freedom of assembly of others and hooliganism.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "No action was taken in respect of the applicants' complaint about the inaction of the police during the attack on 3 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to Section 10 of the Assemblies Act of 2008, the organisers of a demonstration must notify the local authorities five days in advance about the planned demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Under Article 12(1) of the Assemblies Act of 2008, no obligation to notify local authorities five days in advance exists for spontaneous demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Under Article 12(5) of the Assemblies Act of 2008, no obligation to notify local authorities five days in advance exists for demonstrations with fewer than fifty participants.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to Article 67 of the Code of Administrative Offences, the failure by organisers of a demonstration to notify the local authorities in accordance with the provisions of the Assemblies Act of 2008 is punishable with a fine of up to 800 Moldovan Lei.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The fine of up to 800 Moldovan Lei under Article 67 of the Code of Administrative Offences was the equivalent of approximately 50 euros at the time of the events.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F015", "F016"], "interference": ["F020", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F036", "F037", "F009", "F011"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F015", "F016", "F020", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F036", "F009", "F019", "F021", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F008", "F009", "F010", "F011"], "interference": ["F020", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F036", "F009"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F015", "F016", "F020", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F036", "F009", "F019", "F021", "F031", "F032", "F033"]}, "list3": ["F008", "F009", "F011", "F020", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F036", "F032", "F019"]}} {"case_name": "case_520", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_521", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1937.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 19 July 1989 the applicant joined an anti-Turkish demonstration in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants in the Chrysostomos and Papachrysostomou v. Turkey case also took part in the anti-Turkish demonstration in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant in the Loizidou v. Turkey case also took part in the anti-Turkish demonstration in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant before the Nicosia District Court on 3 January 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant before the Nicosia District Court on 3 January 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was held on the fifteenth anniversary of the Turkish intervention in Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant before the Nicosia District Court on 3 January 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was held in support of missing persons and to protest against human rights violations.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The demonstrators gathered at the Ayios Kassianos school in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "United Nations soldiers shouted a warning to the demonstrators not to advance further.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "After United Nations soldiers had shouted a warning to the demonstrators not to advance further, the applicant was seized by the hair by Turkish military personnel and/or other personnel acting under Turkish control.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant was beaten and assaulted by Turkish military personnel and/or other personnel acting under Turkish control.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The beating of the applicant was inflicted with electrical batons by 3 or 4 policemen all over the applicant's body, in particular the head and back.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "One of the blows to the applicant caused a painful injury to the applicant's right arm and elbow, with loss of blood.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant was dragged to a small, stiflingly hot room in which other demonstrators were also being held.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "One of the prisoners in the small room where the applicant was held had been severely beaten and was unconscious.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant and the other detainees were led through a hostile crowd that spat and swore at them to a bus waiting to take them to the so-called 'Pavlides Garage'.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "As the applicant entered the Pavlides Garage, her handbag was seized.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant was forced to sit on the floor at the Pavlides Garage.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The toilet facilities at the Pavlides Garage were filthy.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "A crowd gathered outside the Pavlides Garage was swearing, shouting abuse and threats, and throwing stones, some of which came through the corrugated iron roof.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "One of the detainees at the Pavlides Garage, a doctor, treated the applicant's arm, which was still bleeding, with whatever he had to hand and bandaged it.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "One of the female prisoners, Mrs Vrahimi (application no. 16078/90), was beaten in front of the other detainees at the Pavlides Garage.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The other detainees at the Pavlides Garage remained silent while Mrs Vrahimi was beaten, fearing for their own fate.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "A woman at the Pavlides Garage shouted that she was an American citizen and was released shortly afterwards.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "While in the Pavlides Garage, the applicant was interrogated.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant refused to sign the statement produced during interrogation at the Pavlides Garage, which was written in Turkish.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The interrogation at the Pavlides Garage took place in Greek and touched mainly on political subjects.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 20 July 1989, the applicant and the other detainees were given food.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 20 July 1989, the applicant and the other detainees were photographed and filmed by a television crew.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Later on 20 July 1989, after being subjected to a body search, the applicant was taken to a court which remanded her in custody for two days.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant was transferred with other women who had been arrested at the same time to the Ortakeuy prison.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "At the Ortakeuy prison, the applicant was held in a cell with another woman.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The conditions of detention at the Ortakeuy prison were appalling and the cell was unbearably hot.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "During the night at the Ortakeuy prison, the applicant and the other detainees were constantly checked and counted by the guards and as a result were unable to sleep.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicant went on hunger strike while detained at the Ortakeuy prison.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "During the evening of 21 July 1989, the applicant was taken to the Nicosia District Court for trial.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The judge at the Nicosia District Court asked the applicant and the other accused whether they wanted legal representation.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicant and the other accused replied that they would only accept as defence counsel a lawyer registered with the bar association of the Republic of Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "As a result of the applicant and the other accused refusing to accept a lawyer not registered with the bar association of the Republic of Cyprus, they were not assisted by a lawyer at trial.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The interpretation into Greek at the Nicosia District Court trial was poor and did not cover all the words used by the witnesses and the parties.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Each time an accused tried to speak and give an explanation at the Nicosia District Court trial, she was interrupted.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Although the applicant had never previously seen some of the exhibits produced at the trial, notably a pair of scissors, gloves and a saw, one of the prosecution witnesses said that he had found a penknife in the applicant's handbag.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant alleged that she had taken the penknife with her to peel an apple and that the blade was not even two inches long.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant tried to explain her position regarding the penknife to the judge but was not allowed to.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicant showed her bandaged arm in order to complain about the beating she had suffered, but an officer replied that she could have injured herself by falling down.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "After the trial at the Nicosia District Court, the applicant was taken back to prison.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 22 July 1989, the Nicosia District Court ordered the applicant to enter into a recognizance of 1,000,000 Turkish liras as a guarantee that she would not commit further breaches of the peace for a period of one year.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The trial judge at the Nicosia District Court noted that it was the second time the applicant had illegally entered 'TRNC' territory.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Most of the accused, including the applicant, were sentenced to 2 days' imprisonment and a fine of 50 Cypriot pounds (approximately 85 euros), with five additional days in prison in default of payment within 24 hours.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "After the public delivery of the judgment on 22 July 1989, the accused, including the applicant, were returned to prison.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 24 July 1989, the applicant was released and taken by bus to southern Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "As a result of the beating described in the applicant's account, three of the applicant's vertebrae were damaged.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Doctors told the applicant that the condition of her central nerve was continuously deteriorating and that no surgery could be carried out.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant had participated in a violent demonstration with the aim of enflaming anti-Turkish sentiment.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators, supported by the Greek-Cypriot administration, were demanding that the 'Green Line' in Nicosia should be dismantled.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Government alleged that some demonstrators carried Greek flags, clubs, knives and wire-cutters.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators were acting in a provocative manner and shouting abuse.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators were warned in Greek and English that unless they dispersed they would be arrested in accordance with the laws of the 'TRNC'.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was arrested by the Turkish-Cypriot police after crossing the UN buffer zone and entering the area under Turkish-Cypriot control.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Government alleged that the Turkish-Cypriot police intervened in the face of the manifest inability of the Greek-Cypriot authorities and the UN Force in Cyprus to contain the incursion and its possible consequences.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Government alleged that no force was used against demonstrators who did not intrude into the 'TRNC' border area.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Government alleged that in the case of demonstrators who were arrested for violating the border, no more force was used than was reasonably necessary in the circumstances in order to arrest and detain the persons concerned.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Government alleged that no one was ill-treated.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Government alleged that it was possible that some of the demonstrators had hurt themselves in the confusion or in attempting to scale barbed wire or other fencing.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Government alleged that had the Turkish police, or anyone else, assaulted or beaten any of the demonstrators, the UN Secretary General would no doubt have referred to this in his report to the Security Council.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was charged, tried, found guilty and sentenced to a short term of imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant pleaded not guilty but did not give evidence and declined to use the available judicial remedies.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was asked if she required assistance from a lawyer registered in the 'TRNC', but refused and did not ask for legal representation.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Government alleged that interpretation services were provided at the trial by qualified interpreters and that all the proceedings were translated into Greek.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of the events"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989 on UN operations in Cyprus, the UN Secretary General stated that a serious situation arose in July 1989 as a result of a demonstration by Greek Cypriots in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The UN Secretary General stated that in the evening of 19 July 1989, some 1,000 Greek Cypriot demonstrators, mostly women, forced their way into the UN buffer zone in the Ayios Kassianos area of Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The UN Secretary General stated that the demonstrators broke through a wire barrier maintained by the United Nations Force in Cyprus (UNFICYP) and destroyed an UNFICYP observation post.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The UN Secretary General stated that the demonstrators broke through the line formed by UNFICYP soldiers and entered a former school complex where UNFICYP reinforcements regrouped to prevent them from proceeding further.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The UN Secretary General stated that a short while later, Turkish-Cypriot police and security forces elements forced their way into the area and apprehended 111 persons, 101 of them women.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The UN Secretary General stated that the Ayios Kassianos school complex is situated in the UN buffer zone, but that the Turkish forces claim it to be on their side of the cease-fire line.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The UN Secretary General stated that under working arrangements with UNFICYP, the Turkish-Cypriot security forces had patrolled the Ayios Kassianos school grounds for several years within specific restrictions, and that this patrolling had ceased altogether as part of an unmanning agreement implemented in May 1989.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The UN Secretary General stated that in the afternoon of 21 July 1989, some 300 Greek Cypriots gathered at the main entrance to the UN protected area in Nicosia, where the UN headquarters is located, to protest the continuing detention by the Turkish-Cypriot authorities of those apprehended at Ayios Kassianos.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The UN Secretary General stated that the number of demonstrators at the UN protected area entrance fluctuated between 200 and 2,000, and that they blocked all UN traffic through the entrance until 30 July 1989, when the Turkish-Cypriot authorities released the last two detainees.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The UN Secretary General stated that the events of 19 July 1989 created considerable tension in Cyprus and that intensive efforts were made, both at the UN headquarters and at Nicosia, to contain and resolve the situation.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The UN Secretary General stated that on 21 July 1989, he expressed his concern at the events that had taken place and stressed that it was vital that all parties keep in mind the purpose of the UN buffer zone as well as their responsibility to ensure that that area was not violated.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The UN Secretary General stated that on 21 July 1989, he urged the Turkish-Cypriot authorities to release without delay all those who had been detained.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The UN Secretary General stated that on 24 July 1989, the President of the Security Council announced that he had conveyed to the representatives of all the parties, on behalf of the members of the Council, the Council's deep concern at the tense situation created by the incidents of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The UN Secretary General stated that the President of the Security Council stressed the need strictly to respect the UN buffer zone and appealed for the immediate release of all persons still detained.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The UN Secretary General stated that the President of the Security Council asked all concerned to show maximum restraint and to take urgent steps that would bring about a relaxation of tension and contribute to the creation of an atmosphere favourable to the negotiations.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The applicant produced 21 photographs taken at different times during the demonstration on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Photographs 1 to 7 produced by the applicant were intended to show that, notwithstanding the deployment of the Turkish-Cypriot police, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "In photographs 8 to 10 produced by the applicant, members of the Turkish-Cypriot police are seen breaking up the UNFICYP cordon.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The final set of photographs produced by the applicant show members of the Turkish-Cypriot police using force to arrest some of the women demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The English translation of the Nicosia District Court judgment of 22 July 1989 indicates that the applicant, together with 23 other women, was charged with entering 'TRNC' territory without permission, contrary to sections 2, 8 and 9 of Law No. 5/72.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The English translation of the Nicosia District Court judgment of 22 July 1989 indicates that the applicant, together with 23 other women, was charged with entering 'TRNC' territory other than through an approved port, contrary to subsections 12(1) and (5) of the Aliens and Immigration Law.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The Nicosia District Court judgment of 22 July 1989 was given in the presence of the accused and of an interpreter.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The trial judge at the Nicosia District Court noted that the accused did not accept the charges against them and stated that they did not wish to use the services of a lawyer registered in the 'TRNC'.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The trial judge at the Nicosia District Court noted that some of the accused had fainted during the trial and had been taken to hospital and excused from attending the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The trial judge at the Nicosia District Court noted that the public prosecutor called 7 witnesses, whose statements were translated into Greek for the accused's benefit.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The trial judge at the Nicosia District Court noted that the witnesses, mainly police officers on duty at the time of the demonstration, declared that the accused had illegally entered the 'TRNC' buffer zone, shouted abuse at the Turkish-Cypriot forces, and resisted arrest by pulling and pushing.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The trial judge at the Nicosia District Court noted that knives and other cutting objects had been found in the bags of some of the demonstrators who had been arrested.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The trial judge at the Nicosia District Court noted that witnesses declared that the demonstrators had passed the barriers at the UN observation post, broken the wooden door of a church and moved toward a water reservoir.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The trial judge at the Nicosia District Court noted that according to a map shown at trial, the area where the accused had entered was 'TRNC' territory.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The trial judge at the Nicosia District Court noted that the accused did not call any defence witnesses and did not address the court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The trial judge at the Nicosia District Court noted that the accused had been told that they could cross-examine witnesses in turn and, if they so wished, choose one of their number to cross-examine the witnesses on behalf of all the accused, but that they had not done so.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "Relying on the statements of the prosecution witnesses, the Nicosia District Court concluded that the accused had crossed the borders of the 'TRNC' at an unapproved entry point and without permission and had resisted by various means the UN and Turkish forces which had tried to stop them.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Nicosia District Court found that the prosecution had proved its case beyond reasonable doubt and that the accused were guilty on both counts.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "In deciding on the sentence, the Nicosia District Court took into account the seriousness of the offence and the fact that the accused had shown no remorse and continued to deny the validity of the 'TRNC'.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code defines an unlawful assembly as five or more persons assembled with intent to commit an offence, or, being assembled with intent to carry out some common purpose, conducting themselves in such a manner as to cause persons in the neighbourhood to fear that the persons so assembled will commit a breach of the peace, or will by such assembly needlessly and without any reasonable occasion provoke other persons to commit a breach of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that it is immaterial that the original assembling was lawful if, being assembled, the persons conduct themselves with a common purpose in such a manner as to constitute an unlawful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that when an unlawful assembly has begun to execute the purpose for which it assembled by a breach of the peace and to the terror of the public, the assembly is called a riot and the persons assembled are said to be riotously assembled.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "According to section 71 of the Cypriot Criminal Code, any person who takes part in an unlawful assembly is guilty of a misdemeanour and liable to imprisonment for one year.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Section 80 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that any person who carries in public without lawful occasion any offensive arm or weapon in such a manner as to cause terror to any person is guilty of a misdemeanour and is liable to imprisonment for two years, and his arm or weapons shall be forfeited.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "According to section 82 of the Cypriot Criminal Code, it is an offence to carry a knife outside the home.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Chapter 155, section 14(1)(b) of the Cypriot Criminal Procedure Law states that any officer may, without warrant, arrest any person who commits in his presence any offence punishable with imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Police officers' powers of arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Chapter 155, section 14(1)(c) of the Cypriot Criminal Procedure Law states that any officer may, without warrant, arrest any person who obstructs a police officer while in the execution of his duty.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Police officers' powers of arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Section 9 of Law No. 5/72 states that any person who enters a prohibited military area without authorization, or by stealth, or fraudulently, shall be tried by a military court in accordance with the Military Offences Act, and those found guilty shall be punished.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Subsection 12(1) of the Aliens and Immigration Law states that no person shall enter or leave the Colony except through an approved port.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Subsection 12(5) of the Aliens and Immigration Law states that any person who contravenes or fails to observe any of the provisions of subsections (1), (2), (3) or (4) of section 12 shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months or to a fine not exceeding one hundred pounds or to both such imprisonment and fine.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": false, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["national_security", "public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F009", "F072", "F073", "F074", "F075", "F099"], "interference": ["F003", "F009", "F031", "F050", "F052", "F075"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F105", "F106", "F107", "F108", "F111", "F112"], "legitimate_aim": ["F072", "F073", "F074"], "necessity": ["F072", "F073", "F074", "F075", "F090", "F091", "F096", "F099", "F113", "F114", "F115"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F072", "F073", "F074"], "interference": ["F003", "F031", "F075"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F105", "F108", "F111"], "legitimate_aim": ["F072", "F073", "F074"], "necessity": ["F072", "F073", "F074", "F075", "F099"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F072", "F073", "F074", "F075", "F099", "F105", "F108", "F111"]}} {"case_name": "case_522", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_523", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_524", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_526", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_528", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "Mr A. Navalnyy launched a nationwide campaign called \"He is not our Tsar\".", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The campaign \"He is not our Tsar\" consisted of holding rallies on 5 May 2018 to protest against the forthcoming inauguration of Mr V. Putin as the President of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The election of Mr V. Putin as President of the Russian Federation took place on 18 March 2018.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Ms P. notified the Cheboksary town administration of her intention to hold a public event in the form of a march and a meeting.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Cheboksary town administration informed Ms P. that the itinerary for the march included areas where public events were not allowed under the regional legislation.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Cheboksary town administration invited Ms P. to hold a meeting instead of the planned march and meeting event.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Cheboksary town administration invited Ms P. to hold the meeting in one of the specially designated areas approved by the regional government in its Decree no. 598 of 26 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The specially designated area proposed by the Cheboksary town administration was specifically at Sosnovskaya Street, next to a church, a local police station and a children's park.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Ms P. replied to the Cheboksary town administration indicating her disagreement with the proposed alternative venue.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the applicants, the venue mentioned by the Cheboksary town administration remained within the town borders of Cheboksary.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "According to the applicants, the distance between the venue proposed by the Cheboksary town administration and the initially proposed venue amounted to some fifty kilometres.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "According to the applicants, the venue proposed by the Cheboksary town administration had poor transport and public infrastructure which would have been impracticable for the presence of hundreds of participants.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Cheboksary town administration's decision regarding Ms P.'s notice was subsequently upheld on judicial review.", "source_paragraph": null, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Mr A. Navalnyy launched a nationwide campaign called \"He is not our Tsar\".", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The campaign \"He is not our Tsar\" consisted of holding rallies on 5 May 2018 to protest against the forthcoming inauguration of Mr V. Putin as the President of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The election of Mr V. Putin as President of the Russian Federation took place on 18 March 2018.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Ms P. notified the Cheboksary town administration of her intention to hold a public event in the form of a march and a meeting.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Cheboksary town administration informed Ms P. that the itinerary for the march included areas where public events were not allowed under the regional legislation.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Cheboksary town administration invited Ms P. to hold a meeting instead of the planned march and meeting event.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Cheboksary town administration invited Ms P. to hold the meeting in one of the specially designated areas approved by the regional government in its Decree no. 598 of 26 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The specially designated area proposed by the Cheboksary town administration was specifically at Sosnovskaya Street, next to a church, a local police station and a children's park.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Ms P. replied to the Cheboksary town administration indicating her disagreement with the proposed alternative venue.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the applicants, the venue mentioned by the Cheboksary town administration remained within the town borders of Cheboksary.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the applicants, the distance between the venue proposed by the Cheboksary town administration and the initially proposed venue amounted to some fifty kilometres.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the applicants, the venue proposed by the Cheboksary town administration had poor transport and public infrastructure which would have been impracticable for the presence of hundreds of participants.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Cheboksary town administration's decision regarding Ms P.'s notice was subsequently upheld on judicial review.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 5 May 2018 people assembled into a non-approved rally in Cheboksary.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The non-approved rally on 5 May 2018 was held in a different manner as compared to the notice lodged by Ms P.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "At 2 p.m. on 5 May 2018 at Respublika Square in Cheboksary, according to the applicants, the police ordered the demonstrators to cease the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the applicants, the police threatened the demonstrators at Respublika Square with use of force when ordering them to cease the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "After the police order at Respublika Square, the demonstrators started to move through the main town streets of Cheboksary, walking on the pavements to avoid disruption of traffic.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The demonstrators moving through the main town streets of Cheboksary were followed by the police.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "At Chapayev Square in Cheboksary, the demonstrators were met by another police squad and dispersed.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the authorities, the applicants did not comply with the police order to cease participation in the meeting at Respublika Square on 5 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "According to the authorities, from 2.30 to 4 p.m. on 5 May 2018, the applicants participated in an event at Chapayev Square in Cheboksary.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The authorities and the courts classified the event at Chapayev Square on 5 May 2018 as a \"demonstration\" under the Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act).", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the authorities, the applicants did not comply with the police order to cease participation in the demonstration at Chapayev Square on 5 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "At Respublika Square, the police made several warnings informing the demonstrators of the unlawful nature of their presence in a public place and required them to cease their unlawful activities.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "At Chapayev Square, the police made several warnings informing the demonstrators of the unlawful nature of their presence in a public place and required them to cease their unlawful activities.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. \"HYBRID\" PUBLIC EVENT ON 5 MAY 2018"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 15 May 2018 the Leninskiy District Court of Cheboksary examined two separate cases concerning Mr Raymov's participation in the meeting and the demonstration on 5 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "A. Mr Raymov"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Cheboksary examined the two separate cases concerning Mr Raymov at two hearings on 15 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "A. Mr Raymov"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "In the case concerning Mr Raymov's participation in the meeting, the Leninskiy District Court of Cheboksary convicted him under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences and sentenced him to a fine of 10,000 Russian roubles (approximately 135 euros at the time).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "A. Mr Raymov"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "In the case concerning Mr Raymov's participation in the demonstration, the Leninskiy District Court of Cheboksary convicted him under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences and sentenced him to a fine of 20,000 Russian roubles (approximately 270 euros at the time).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "A. Mr Raymov"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Mr Raymov appealed against the convictions, arguing that he had exercised his freedom of peaceful assembly by taking part in one single event.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "A. Mr Raymov"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Mr Raymov argued on appeal that it had been unjustified to prosecute and punish him separately for two parts of the same event.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "A. Mr Raymov"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 5 June 2018 the Supreme Court of the Chuvashiya Republic held appeal hearings in each of the two cases concerning Mr Raymov.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "A. Mr Raymov"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Chuvashiya Republic upheld the trial judgments in both cases concerning Mr Raymov.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "A. Mr Raymov"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Chuvashiya Republic stated that Mr Raymov had violated section 6 § 3 of the Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act) because he had not complied with the orders to disperse given during the meeting and demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "A. Mr Raymov"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Chuvashiya Republic stated that Mr Raymov had been prosecuted for different facts in the two separate cases.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "A. Mr Raymov"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In a separate third set of proceedings, Mr Raymov was convicted under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences in relation to his non-compliance with the order to disperse during the meeting on 5 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "A. Mr Raymov"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The appeal court set aside the judgment convicting Mr Raymov under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences and discontinued the proceedings for lack of corpus delicti.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "A. Mr Raymov"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The appeal court discontinued the proceedings against Mr Raymov under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences pursuant to a recent resolution by the Plenary Supreme Court of the Russian Federation on the application of the lex specialis rule in cases concerning rallies.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "A. Mr Raymov"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The resolution by the Plenary Supreme Court of the Russian Federation on the application of the lex specialis rule in cases concerning rallies is referenced in Korneyeva v. Russia, no. 72051/17, §§ 25 and 60, 8 October 2019.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "A. Mr Raymov"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 9 June 2018 the Leninskiy District Court of Cheboksary examined charges against Mr Ryabenko under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences on account of his participation in the meeting on 5 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 9 June 2018 the Leninskiy District Court of Cheboksary examined charges against Mr Ryabenko under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences on account of his participation in the meeting on 5 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Mr Ryabenko was sentenced to a fine of 10,500 Russian roubles in the proceedings concerning his participation in the meeting on 5 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Cheboksary took note of the existence of a final decision by which the Cheboksary town administration's reply to Ms P.'s notice had been upheld on judicial review.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Cheboksary found that Mr Ryabenko had taken part in a non-notified public event consisting of a meeting, which had then transformed into a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Cheboksary found that Mr Ryabenko had not complied with the repeated orders from the police requiring the termination of the event on 5 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Cheboksary stated that the event's organisers had defined its topic as protection of citizens' rights, while the slogans and speeches during the event were in breach of that topic.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Cheboksary stated that the slogans and speeches during the event on 5 May 2018 amounted in substance to a negative assessment of the person who had been elected to the post of the President of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Leninskiy District Court of Cheboksary stated that the slogans and speeches during the event on 5 May 2018 did not contain an indication of any civic views or deficiencies in the functioning of the State or proposals for improvements.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In separate proceedings, on 9 June 2018 the Leninskiy District Court of Cheboksary convicted Mr Ryabenko under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences on account of his participation in the demonstration on 5 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Mr Ryabenko was sentenced to up to twenty hours of community work in the proceedings concerning his participation in the demonstration on 5 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 10 July 2018 the Supreme Court of the Chuvashiya Republic, reviewing the judgment of the Leninskiy District Court of Cheboksary described in paragraph 8 of the judgment, set aside the conviction of Mr Ryabenko under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 10 July 2018 the Supreme Court of the Chuvashiya Republic upheld Mr Ryabenko's conviction for the offence under Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences relating to the meeting and reduced the fine to 10,000 Russian roubles.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 10 July 2018 the same judge of the Supreme Court of the Chuvashiya Republic also examined Mr Ryabenko's appeal against the judgment relating to the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Chuvashiya Republic upheld Mr Ryabenko's conviction relating to the demonstration, considering that Mr Ryabenko had violated section 6 § 3 (1) of the Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Chuvashiya Republic found that Mr Ryabenko had committed a serious breach of public order and public safety in relation to the demonstration on 5 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Chuvashiya Republic found that Mr Ryabenko's actions had entailed consequences consisting of the presence of numerous people on the pavements in the town centre of Cheboksary and near buildings hosting public authorities.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Chuvashiya Republic found that Mr Ryabenko's actions had impeded the movement of pedestrians and had created a real threat of interfering with the authorities' functioning and other people's rights.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANTS", "B. Mr Ryabenko"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act) defines a \"public event\" as an open, peaceful action accessible to all.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Under the Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), a public event may be held in the form of a gathering, a meeting, a demonstration, a march, or a picket, or in various combinations of these forms, as defined in section 2 of that Act.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Pursuant to sections 5 and 7 of the Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), the organiser of a public event must notify the executive or municipal authority of the event.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Under the Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act), the procedure for notification of a public event is determined by a regional statute.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The notification procedure under the Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act) is described in Navalnyy v. Russia [GC], nos. 29580/12 and 4 others, § 45, 15 November 2018.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Under the Chuvashiya Republic's Statute no. 77 of 30 November 2012, public events were prohibited at all locations mentioned in section 8 of the Federal Law no. 54-FZ of 19 June 2004 (the Public Events Act).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Under the Chuvashiya Republic's Statute no. 77 of 30 November 2012, public events were prohibited at or near shopping malls or markets and within fifty metres of them.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "Under the Chuvashiya Republic's Statute no. 77 of 30 November 2012, public events were prohibited at buildings hosting educational, children-related, cultural, medical or sports institutions and, until 2020, within fifty metres of those buildings.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "Under the Chuvashiya Republic's Statute no. 77 of 30 November 2012, public events were prohibited at sports areas and children's playgrounds.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Under the Chuvashiya Republic's Statute no. 77 of 30 November 2012, public events were prohibited at religious buildings or objects and, until 2020, within fifty metres of them.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Under the Chuvashiya Republic's Statute no. 77 of 30 November 2012, public events were prohibited at buildings hosting municipal and public authorities and, until 2020, within thirty metres of them.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Under the Chuvashiya Republic's Statute no. 77 of 30 November 2012, public events were prohibited at entrances to residential buildings if the distance was less than five metres.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F027", "F028", "F031", "F033", "F036", "F040", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F055", "F063"], "interference": ["F034", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F042", "F043", "F048", "F055", "F063", "F068"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F027", "F028", "F036", "F040", "F041", "F044", "F049", "F055", "F063", "F073"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F027", "F028", "F031", "F033", "F034", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F042", "F043", "F047", "F048", "F055", "F063", "F066", "F068", "F069", "F070", "F071"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F027", "F031", "F042"], "interference": ["F034", "F037", "F042", "F063"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F036", "F040", "F073"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F027", "F031", "F038", "F039", "F042", "F043", "F048", "F063", "F068"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F027", "F031", "F038", "F039", "F042", "F048", "F063", "F068"]}} {"case_name": "case_530", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_532", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of country-wide protests against a retirement age hike organised by Aleksey Navalnyy on 9 September 2018.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of country-wide protests against a retirement age hike organised by Aleksey Navalnyy on 9 September 2018.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_537", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1951.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The first applicant lives in Erjovo.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The second applicant is a company incorporated in the Transdniestrian region of Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants were represented by Mr S.G. Popovschi, a lawyer practising in Tiraspol.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The background to the case, including the Transdniestrian armed conflict of 1991-1992 and the subsequent events, is set out in Ilaşcu and Others v. Moldova and Russia ([GC], no. 48787/99, §§ 28-185, ECHR 2004-VII).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The background to the case, including the Transdniestrian armed conflict of 1991-1992 and the subsequent events, is set out in Catan and Others v. the Republic of Moldova and Russia ([GC], nos. 43370/04, 8252/05 and 18454/06, §§ 8-42, ECHR 2012).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 6 November 2012, the former members of the kolkhoz Rodina from Erjovo and Sarateia villages created the second applicant (a company incorporated in the Transdniestrian region of Moldova).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The second applicant was created with a view to defending the interests of the former members of the kolkhoz Rodina in respect of plans by the Government of the Transdniestrian region of Moldova concerning their land.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 21 September 2013, the first applicant organised a public meeting for the former members of the kolkhoz Rodina.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The public meeting organised by the first applicant on 21 September 2013 was held with a view to discussing the matter about the land.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Sixty-five persons participated in the public meeting organised by the first applicant on 21 September 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 23 September 2013, the Rîbniţa District Court imposed a fine of 145 MRT roubles on the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Rîbniţa District Court imposed the fine on the first applicant for breach of the rules of conducting public manifestations.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Rîbniţa District Court found that the first applicant had not obtained a prior authorisation for holding the public manifestation on 21 September 2013.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The first applicant challenged the Rîbniţa District Court's decision of 23 September 2013 before the MRT (Moldovan Transdniestrian Republic) Supreme Court.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 31 October 2013, the MRT (Moldovan Transdniestrian Republic) Supreme Court dismissed the first applicant's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 31 October 2013, the MRT (Moldovan Transdniestrian Republic) Supreme Court upheld the decision of the Rîbniţa District Court imposing a fine of 145 MRT roubles on the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Reports by inter-governmental and non-governmental organisations, the relevant domestic law and practice of the Republic of Moldova, and other pertinent documents were summarised in Mozer v. the Republic of Moldova and Russia ([GC], no. 11138/10, §§ 61-77, 23 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015"], "interference": ["F010", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F019"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": ["F006", "F007", "F019"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F010", "F012"], "interference": ["F010", "F013", "F014"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F019"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": ["F019"]}, "list3": ["F010", "F013", "F014", "F019"]}} {"case_name": "case_538", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of nationwide protests.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of nationwide protests.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The nationwide protests took place in various Russian cities on 5 May 2018.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The nationwide protests on 5 May 2018 took place before Vladimir Putin's inauguration for the fourth presidential term.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention, in addition to their complaint about disproportionate measures.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003", "F004"]}} {"case_name": "case_539", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_540", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The case concerns the respondent State's alleged failure to protect the applicants, all of whom are members of the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex (LGBTI) community, from homophobic acts of violence by private individuals.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The case concerns the respondent State's alleged failure to conduct an effective investigation into incidents of homophobic acts of violence against the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants complained that they had been apprehended and detained unlawfully during peaceful demonstrations in support of LGBTI people.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The names of the applicants' representatives are listed in the appendix to the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Government were initially represented by Mr M. Galperin, Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Government were later represented by Mr M. Vinogradov, successor to Mr M. Galperin as Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 17 May 2012 Mr Romanov took part in the 'Rainbow flash mob' event in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The 'Rainbow flash mob' event in St Petersburg on 17 May 2012 had been authorised by the local authorities.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The 'Rainbow flash mob' event in St Petersburg on 17 May 2012 marked the International Day Against Homophobia and Transphobia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "A group of people protesting against the 'Rainbow flash mob' event gathered nearby during the event on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The police were deployed to maintain public order during the 'Rainbow flash mob' event on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The police did not intervene when counter-demonstrators started insulting the participants in the 'Rainbow flash mob' event on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The parties submitted no further information about any preliminary measures which had been put in place to protect the demonstrators at the 'Rainbow flash mob' event on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "During the 'Rainbow flash mob' event on 17 May 2012, Mr Romanov was holding a balloon with the inscription 'Jesus Christ loves men and women equally'.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "During the 'Rainbow flash mob' event on 17 May 2012, one of the counter-demonstrators, Mr L., fired five times towards Mr Romanov with a spray gun.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "While firing at Mr Romanov, Mr L. shouted 'sodomy is a mortal sin'.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "As a result of Mr L.'s attack, Mr Romanov suffered chemical burns to the conjunctivae and cornea.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "As a result of Mr L.'s attack, Mr Romanov suffered a contusion in the area of the right cheekbone.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The police apprehended Mr L. after the attack on Mr Romanov on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Mr L. was charged with hooliganism under Article 213 § 1 (a) of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "In his statement of 17 May 2012, Mr L. explained that he had come to the 'Rainbow flash mob' event to 'fight sexual minorities'.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 17 February 2013 an investigator questioned Mr L.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the record of the interview of 17 February 2013, Mr L. was the founder of the 'Sin-free City' movement.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "One of the aims of the 'Sin-free City' movement was to fight the 'propaganda of perversion', including homosexuality.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 17 July 2013 Mr Romanov requested the investigator to explore alleged motives of hate against LGBTI people in the case concerning the attack on him on 17 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "By a decision of 18 July 2012, the investigator dismissed Mr Romanov's request to explore hate motives against LGBTI people for 'lack of any evidence of hate motives'.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "In the decision of 18 July 2012, the investigator indicated that Mr L. had not insulted anyone, had come to the event by accident, and that his actions had been motivated by the blasphemous words on the balloon.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 11 November 2013 the Petrogradskiy District Court of St Petersburg convicted Mr L. of hooliganism under Article 213 § 1 (a) of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation as charged.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Petrogradskiy District Court of St Petersburg sentenced Mr L. to one year's imprisonment, conditional on one year's probation.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 18 December 2013 the State Duma of the Russian Federation amnestied Mr L.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 12 February 2014 the St Petersburg City Court quashed the Petrogradskiy District Court's decision convicting Mr L.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 12 February 2014 the St Petersburg City Court discontinued the case against Mr L. in accordance with the Amnesty Act.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Mr Romanov (application no. 58358/14)"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 11 January 2013 Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov notified the authorities in Voronezh of their intent to hold a demonstration involving about fifty participants on 20 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The planned demonstration on 20 January 2013 in Voronezh was against the enactment of the law banning 'propaganda of non-traditional sexual relations'.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The authorities in Voronezh authorised the demonstration planned for 20 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 15 January 2013 a far-right organisation called 'Separate Division' ('Отдельный Дивизион') published on its website a call to disrupt the demonstration planned for 20 January 2013 in Voronezh.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "In connection with the demonstration planned for 20 January 2013 in Voronezh, Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov began receiving death threats on the Russian social media platform Vkontakte.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 17 January 2013 Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov asked the police to open a criminal case under Article 119 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation and to grant them protection, enclosing printouts of the threatening messages.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 19 January 2013 Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov asked the police to open a criminal case under Article 119 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation and to grant them protection, enclosing printouts of the threatening messages.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The organisers of the demonstration planned for 20 January 2013 in Voronezh notified the police of a counter-demonstration which was to take place at the same venue with the aim of obstructing the event.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 30 January 2013 the police refused Mr Nasonov's application to have a criminal investigation opened.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 20 January 2013 more than one hundred counter-demonstrators came to the site of the LGBTI demonstration in Voronezh, where six participants were present.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 20 January 2013 counter-demonstrators at the site of the LGBTI demonstration in Voronezh unfolded banners with homophobic slogans and called for violence against the participants in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 20 January 2013 counter-demonstrators threw snowballs and paint balloons at the participants in the LGBTI demonstration in Voronezh and tore up the participants' posters.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "At around 2 p.m. on 20 January 2013 some of the counter-demonstrators beat Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov at the site of the LGBTI demonstration in Voronezh.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "About forty police officers were present at the site of the LGBTI demonstration in Voronezh on 20 January 2013 but did not intervene.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "All the participants in the LGBTI demonstration in Voronezh on 20 January 2013 had to stop the demonstration and leave.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov requested that the police institute criminal proceedings against the attackers under Article 116 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov requested that the police institute criminal proceedings against the attackers under Article 282 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The police opened two sets of criminal investigations following the attacks on Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov on 20 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 25 January 2013 Mr Z. confessed to having attacked Mr Lebedev during the LGBTI demonstration in Voronezh on 20 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Mr Z. was charged under Article 116 § 2 (a) of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation with battery (побои) committed for disorderly motives.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 2 August 2013 a magistrate in the Central District of Voronezh convicted Mr Z. of battery (побои) committed for disorderly motives under Article 116 § 2 (a) of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation as charged.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 21 January 2014 the Central District Court of Voronezh upheld the magistrate's decision convicting Mr Z.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Mr Z. was released from the obligation to serve his sentence on the grounds that the limitation period had expired.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The police suspended the criminal proceedings against other attackers of Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov owing to the impossibility of identifying the suspects.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Mr Lebedev and Mr Nasonov (application no. 7146/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 29 June 2013 Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov and Mr Prokopenko took part in a demonstration involving about eighty participants in St Petersburg aimed at drawing attention to violations of the rights of LGBTI people in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The local authorities had been notified in advance of the demonstration of 29 June 2013 in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The local authorities deployed 165 police officers to maintain public order at the site of the demonstration of 29 June 2013 in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "A group of counter-demonstrators gathered next to the participants in the demonstration of 29 June 2013 in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Counter-demonstrators at the demonstration of 29 June 2013 in St Petersburg shouted homophobic slogans, called for violence against the participants and threw stones and smoke bombs at them.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "At around 3 p.m. on 29 June 2013 one of the counter-demonstrators ran up to Mr Prokopenko and punched him in the face and hands.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The police present at the scene of the demonstration of 29 June 2013 in St Petersburg did not intervene when counter-demonstrators attacked the participants.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova and Mr Fedorov decided to leave the demonstration of 29 June 2013 in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "While Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova and Mr Fedorov were walking away from the demonstration of 29 June 2013 in St Petersburg, about thirty counter-demonstrators ran up to them and started beating them.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The police arrived about ten minutes after the beating of Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova and Mr Fedorov on 29 June 2013 and took the applicants to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The police called an ambulance three hours after taking the applicants to the police station following the attacks on 29 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "According to medical certificates of 29 June 2013, Mr Starov sustained contusion of the soft tissue on the head and face, contusion and haematoma of the thorax, and closed abdominal trauma.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "According to medical certificates of 29 June 2013, Ms Pitenova sustained bruises on the left chest and lower back.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "According to medical certificates of 29 June 2013, Mr Fedorov sustained abrasions on the back, shoulder and soft tissue of the head.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "No medical certificate was drawn up for Mr Prokopenko following the attacks on 29 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov and Mr Prokopenko sought to have a criminal investigation opened into the homophobic attacks on them on 29 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The police questioned some of the participants who had been assaulted during the demonstration of 29 June 2013 but never identified the perpetrators.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Between July 2013 and December 2015 the police repeatedly refused to open a criminal investigation into battery committed for hate motives under Article 116 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation in relation to the attacks of 29 June 2013, citing a 'hostile attitude of people of heterosexual orientation towards members of the LGBTI community'.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The prosecutor quashed the police's repeated decisions not to open a criminal investigation into the attacks of 29 June 2013 each time and ordered additional inquiries, emphasising the need to identify and question eyewitnesses of the attacks on the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Following the last decision by the police on 23 December 2015 not to initiate a criminal investigation into the attacks of 29 June 2013, the police did not carry out the measures ordered by the prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "1. Demonstration of 29 June 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 12 October 2013 Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina intended to take part in a demonstration in St Petersburg to mark Coming Out Day.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The facts relating to the demonstration of 12 October 2013 in St Petersburg were the subject of the Court's judgment in Berkman v. Russia (no. 46712/15, 1 December 2020).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "About 500 police officers were deployed to ensure public order during the demonstration of 12 October 2013 in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina arrived at the site of the demonstration of 12 October 2013 in St Petersburg in advance and saw a group of counter-demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Counter-demonstrators at the site of the demonstration of 12 October 2013 in St Petersburg shouted homophobic slogans, pushed Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina and prevented them from proceeding to the venue.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The police did not intervene when counter-demonstrators pushed Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina and prevented them from proceeding to the venue of the demonstration of 12 October 2013 in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "At 1.55 p.m. on 12 October 2013, five minutes before the demonstration started, the police began apprehending the participants, including Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina, on the grounds that they had used foul language.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "At 2.30 p.m. on 12 October 2013 the police escorted Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Administrative-offence reports were drawn up against Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina under Article 20.1 § 1 ('petty hooliganism' – мелкое хулиганство) of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation following their apprehension on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The administrative-offence report in respect of Mr Fedorov was drawn up at 7.50 p.m. on 12 October 2013 and he was released at 8 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The administrative-offence report in respect of Mr Prokopenko was drawn up at 4.05 p.m. on 12 October 2013 and he was released at 7.05 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The administrative-offence report in respect of Ms Levina was drawn up at 5.25 p.m. on 12 October 2013 and she was released at 6.50 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 13 November 2013 the Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg discontinued the administrative-offence proceedings against Mr Fedorov for lack of evidence.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "On 13 November 2013 the Dzerzhinskiy District Court of St Petersburg discontinued the administrative-offence proceedings against Ms Levina for lack of evidence.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Mr Fedorov and Ms Levina complained that they had been apprehended and detained unlawfully, before the start of the authorised demonstration of 12 October 2013 in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "On 26 February 2015 the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of St Petersburg dismissed the complaint by Mr Fedorov and Ms Levina that they had been apprehended and detained unlawfully on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "On 29 April 2016 the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation finally upheld the Kuybyshevskiy District Court of St Petersburg's decision dismissing the complaint by Mr Fedorov and Ms Levina.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "On 6 March 2014 the St Petersburg City Court discontinued the administrative-offence proceedings against Mr Prokopenko for lack of evidence.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Mr Prokopenko brought a civil action seeking compensation for non-pecuniary damage caused by his being unlawfully apprehended and detained before the start of the authorised demonstration of 12 October 2013 in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "On 10 February 2015 the Petrogradskiy District Court of St Petersburg awarded Mr Prokopenko 2,000 Russian roubles (RUB), equivalent to approximately 27 euros (EUR), in respect of non-pecuniary damage for his unlawful apprehension and detention on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 9 June 2015 the St Petersburg City Court dismissed an appeal by Mr Prokopenko against the Petrogradskiy District Court's award of 2,000 RUB in non-pecuniary damages.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "On 1 December 2015 a judge of the St Petersburg City Court refused to refer a cassation appeal lodged by Mr Prokopenko to the Presidium of that court for examination.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Mr Starov, Ms Pitenova, Mr Fedorov, Mr Prokopenko and Ms Levina (application no. 25887/15)", "2. Demonstration of 12 October 2013 and subsequent events"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 3 November 2013 Mr Chechetkin attended the 'Rainbow Tea Social', a weekly event held to support LGBTI people, at an HIV prevention centre in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "At around 7.15 p.m. on 3 November 2013 two young men in hoods armed with a baseball bat and an air gun entered the HIV prevention centre in St Petersburg where the 'Rainbow Tea Social' event was being held.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The two intruders were stopped in the corridor of the HIV prevention centre by Ms P., one of the organisers of the 'Rainbow Tea Social' event.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "Mr Chechetkin was nearby when the two intruders were stopped in the corridor of the HIV prevention centre on 3 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "As soon as Mr Chechetkin turned his head in the direction of the intruders, one of them shot him in the left eye with an air gun.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "After being shot in the left eye, Mr Chechetkin crouched down and tried to hide.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "One of the attackers shouted 'where are you going, faggot?' at Mr Chechetkin and then approached him and hit him in the shoulder and leg with a baseball bat.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "After attacking Mr Chechetkin, the two men left the HIV prevention centre.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The police arrived shortly after the attack on Mr Chechetkin on 3 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "An ambulance arrived shortly after the attack on Mr Chechetkin on 3 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The police found and collected evidence at the HIV prevention centre following the attack on 3 November 2013, including three metal bullets, several shoe prints, palm prints and fingerprints.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "After the attack on 3 November 2013, Mr Chechetkin underwent surgery on his eye.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The pellet was removed from Mr Chechetkin's eye following surgery, but he lost sight in his left eye.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "On 4 November 2013, at the request of Ms P., the police opened a criminal case in respect of the attack on Mr Chechetkin at the HIV prevention centre.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The attack on Mr Chechetkin on 3 November 2013 was classified under Article 213 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation as a disorderly act committed by a group.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Between November 2013 and February 2014 the police questioned Mr Chechetkin, Ms P. and more than fifteen other participants in the 'Rainbow Tea Social' event about the attack of 3 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "All persons questioned by the police between November 2013 and February 2014 about the attack of 3 November 2013 alleged that the attack had been motivated by hatred against LGBTI people.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Ms P. noted that on the day of the attack on 3 November 2013 a social network community called 'Wolf-Homophobe' ('Волк-Гомофоб') had published a post about the upcoming attack in St Petersburg on its webpage.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The investigator in the case of the attack on Mr Chechetkin identified and questioned several people who had participated in actions against the LGBTI community.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "None of the fingerprints of the people questioned by the investigator in the case of the attack on Mr Chechetkin matched those found at the scene of the attack on 3 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "On 24 December 2013 the investigator refused an application by Mr Chechetkin's lawyer for the perpetrators' actions to be classified under Article 111 § 3 (a) and (b) of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation as actions committed by a group of persons for motives of hatred or enmity towards LGBTI people.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "On 5 March 2014 the Leninskiy District Court of St Petersburg dismissed an appeal against the investigator's decision of 24 December 2013 refusing to classify the perpetrators' actions as motivated by hatred or enmity towards LGBTI people, holding that it was premature to decide on the legal classification of the offence at such an early stage of the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "On 21 April 2014 the St Petersburg City Court upheld the Leninskiy District Court of St Petersburg's decision of 5 March 2014 dismissing the appeal against the investigator's refusal to reclassify the offence.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "On 16 July 2014 the investigator suspended the investigation into the attack on Mr Chechetkin on the grounds that the attackers could not be identified.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "On 6 March 2015 the Leninskiy District Court of St Petersburg dismissed an appeal by Mr Chechetkin against the investigator's decision of 16 July 2014 to suspend the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "On 6 March 2015 the Leninskiy District Court of St Petersburg dismissed a further application by Mr Chechetkin to have the perpetrators' actions classified as motivated by hatred.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "On 7 May 2015 the St Petersburg City Court upheld the Leninskiy District Court of St Petersburg's decision of 6 March 2015.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The investigators suspended and resumed the investigation into the attack on Mr Chechetkin multiple times, most recently on 7 October 2017, without achieving any tangible results.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Mr Chechetkin has not received any further information about the progress of the investigation into the attack on him since 7 October 2017.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Mr Chechetkin (application no. 42395/15)"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "On 14 October 2017 Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin were in a bar in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "At around 5 p.m. on 14 October 2017 a man unknown to Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin noticed a rainbow bracelet on their friend's hand and approached them.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The man who approached Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin on 14 October 2017 insulted them while referring to their perceived homosexuality.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The man who approached Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin on 14 October 2017 beat them, inflicting several bruises which were recorded by a doctor later that day.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "On 15 October 2017 Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin reported the incident of 14 October 2017 to the police.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "On 23 October 2017 the police refused to institute criminal proceedings in relation to the attack on Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin, stating that 'the attack had amounted to an administrative offence under Article 6.1.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation' ('battery').", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "On 15 February 2018 a prosecutor quashed the police's decision of 23 October 2017 refusing to institute criminal proceedings and ordered the police to carry out additional inquiries, notably to obtain video-recordings from webcams, identify and question witnesses and obtain the opinion of a medical expert.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "On 3 March 2018 the police opened administrative-offence proceedings under Article 6.1.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation in relation to the attack on Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "On 19 March 2018 the police refused to institute criminal proceedings in relation to the attack on Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin, essentially reiterating the reasons given in their first refusal of 23 October 2017.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "On 12 July 2018 the police refused to institute criminal proceedings in relation to the attack on Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin, essentially reiterating the reasons given in their first refusal of 23 October 2017.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "On 29 May 2018 a prosecutor quashed the police's decision of 19 March 2018 refusing to institute criminal proceedings and ordered additional inquiries.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "On 28 December 2018 a prosecutor quashed the police's decision of 12 July 2018 refusing to institute criminal proceedings and ordered additional inquiries.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "No criminal investigation was ever instituted in relation to the attack on Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin on 14 October 2017.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "On 19 December 2018 the applicants' lawyer challenged the police's decision of 12 July 2018 refusing to institute criminal proceedings in relation to the attack on Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "On 15 January 2019 the Nevskiy District Court of St Petersburg discontinued the proceedings challenging the police's decision of 12 July 2018 on the basis that the impugned decision had already been quashed.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "On 24 April 2019 the St Petersburg City Court endorsed the Nevskiy District Court of St Petersburg's decision of 15 January 2019.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "On 14 October 2019 the police discontinued the administrative proceedings in relation to the attack on Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin on the grounds that the limitation period had expired.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Ms Gromadskaya and Mr Martin (applications nos. 56617/19 and 56637/19)"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "Article 63 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides a list of aggravated circumstances of a crime, which includes committing a crime on the grounds of political, ideological, racial, national, or religious hatred, or on the grounds of hostility or hatred towards any social group.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal law"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "Article 111 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the intentional infliction of severe harm to a person's health, the endangering of their life, or the causing of harm resulting in the loss of sight, speech, hearing or any organ or the loss of its functions, termination of a pregnancy, mental disorder, drug addiction or substance abuse, or harm resulting in the irreparable disfigurement of the face or causing a significant and persistent loss of general working capacity by at least one third or a complete loss of professional working capacity, shall be punishable by imprisonment for a term of up to eight years.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal law"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "Article 111 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the same acts as in Article 111 § 1, if committed against a person or their close relatives in connection with the performance of official duties, against a minor or person in a helpless state, in a generally dangerous manner, for hire, for disorderly motives, on the grounds of political, ideological, racial, national or religious hatred or enmity or on the grounds of hostility or hatred towards any social group, or for the purpose of using the organs or tissues of the victim, shall be punishable by imprisonment for a term of up to ten years, with or without a restriction of liberty for a term of up to two years.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal law"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "Article 111 § 3 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the acts provided for in the first or second part of Article 111, if committed by a group of persons, a group of persons upon prior conspiracy or an organised group, or against two or more persons, shall be punishable by imprisonment for a term of up to twelve years, with or without a restriction of liberty for a term of up to two years.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal law"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "Article 116 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the infliction of beatings or other violent actions causing physical pain but not resulting in the consequences specified in Article 115 of the Criminal Code shall be punishable by a fine of up to RUB 40,000, or by the seizure of the convicted person's wages or other income for a period of up to three months, or by community service for a period of up to 360 hours, or by corrective labour for a period of up to six months or by imprisonment for a term of up to three months.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal law"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "Article 116 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the same acts as in Article 116 § 1, if committed for disorderly motives or on grounds of political, ideological, racial, national or religious hatred or enmity or on grounds of hostility or hatred towards any social group, shall be punishable by community service for a period of up to 360 hours, or by corrective labour for a period of up to one year, or by restriction of liberty for a period of up to two years, or by compulsory labour for a period of up to two years, or by imprisonment for a term of up to six months or by deprivation of liberty for a period of up to two years.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal law"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "Article 282 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that actions aimed at inciting hatred or enmity and humiliating the dignity of an individual or a group of individuals on the grounds of gender, race, ethnic origin, language, background, religious beliefs or membership of a social group, committed publicly or in the mass media, shall be punishable by a fine of from RUB 100,000 to RUB 300,000 or an amount equivalent to the convicted person's wages or other income for a period of from one to two years, or by the withdrawal of the right to hold certain posts or carry out certain activities for a period of up to three years, or by community service for a period of up to 360 hours, or by corrective labour for a period of up to one year, or by compulsory labour for a period of up to two years or by deprivation of liberty of up to two years.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal law"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "Article 282 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the same actions as in Article 282 § 1, if committed with the use of violence or the threat of its use, by a person using his or her official position, or by an organised group, are punishable by a fine of RUB 100,000 to RUB 500,000 or an amount equivalent to the convicted person's wages or other income for a period of from one to three years, or by the withdrawal of the right to hold certain posts or carry out certain activities for a period of up to five years, or by community service for a period of up to 480 hours, or by corrective labour for a period of from one to two years, or by compulsory labour for a period of up to five years or by deprivation of liberty of up to five years.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Criminal law"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Until 3 July 2016 any form of 'battery' had constituted a criminal offence under Article 116 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Administrative law"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "On 3 July 2016 the 'non-aggravated' form of battery was decriminalised and reclassified as an administrative offence under Article 6.1.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Administrative law"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "Article 6.1.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation provides that the infliction of beatings or the commission of other violent actions that cause physical pain but do not result in the consequences specified in Article 115 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation shall, as long as these acts do not constitute a criminal offense, entail the imposition of an administrative fine of from RUB 5,000 to RUB 30,000, or administrative detention for a period of from ten to fifteen days or community service for a period of from sixty to 120 hours.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Administrative law"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "In accordance with the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation's ruling of 23 September 2014 on the constitutionality of Article 6.21 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Russia, the concept of 'a social group' may apply to a group of people on the basis of their sexual orientation.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "I. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Case-law of the Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "On 31 March 2010 the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe adopted Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 to member States on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe provides that member states should ensure effective, prompt and impartial investigations into alleged cases of crimes and other incidents where the sexual orientation or gender identity of the victim is reasonably suspected to have constituted a motive for the perpetrator.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe provides that member states should ensure that particular attention is paid to the investigation of crimes and incidents allegedly committed by law enforcement officials or by other persons acting in an official capacity, and that those responsible are effectively brought to justice and, where appropriate, punished in order to avoid impunity.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe provides that member states should ensure that when determining sanctions, a bias motive related to sexual orientation or gender identity may be taken into account as an aggravating circumstance.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "In its report on the Russian Federation adopted on 4 December 2018 (CRI(2019)2), the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance noted that sexual orientation and gender identity are not explicitly enumerated as prohibited grounds in the relevant provisions of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, such as Articles 282, 136 and 63.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The European Commission against Racism and Intolerance noted in its report CRI(2019)2 that Articles 282, 136 and 63 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation include a reference to 'any social group' in their list of grounds, and that the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation in 2014 found that this term can apply to a group of individuals with a specific sexual orientation.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The European Commission against Racism and Intolerance noted in its report CRI(2019)2 that the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation's 2014 interpretation that 'any social group' can apply to a group of individuals with a specific sexual orientation does not seem to be reflected in regular court practice.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "The European Commission against Racism and Intolerance noted in its report CRI(2019)2 that the United Nations expressed concern about the fact that Article 63 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation on aggravating circumstances does not appear to have ever been applied to cases involving violence against LGBTI persons, in spite of a high number of such incidents.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "The European Commission against Racism and Intolerance noted in its report CRI(2019)2 that the Russian authorities informed the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance that they do not see a need to name sexual orientation and gender identity expressly in the list of grounds of Articles 282, 136 and 63 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "In its report CRI(2019)2, the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance recommended that the Russian authorities amend all existing legislation in order to include explicitly the grounds of sexual orientation and gender identity in the list of protected grounds, in particular in Articles 282, 136 and 63 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "In its concluding observations on the seventh periodic report of the Russian Federation of 28 April 2015 (CCPR/C/RUS/7), the United Nations Human Rights Committee expressed concern that Article 63 § 1 (e) of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, recognising as aggravated circumstances the commission of an offence for reasons of 'hatred or enmity' or 'hate or hostility towards a given social group', does not appear to have ever been applied to cases involving violence against LGBTI individuals.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "In its concluding observations CCPR/C/RUS/7, the United Nations Human Rights Committee stated that the Russian Federation should clearly and officially state that it does not tolerate any form of social stigmatization of homosexuality, bisexuality or transsexuality, or hate speech, discrimination or violence against persons based on their sexual orientation or gender identity.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "In its concluding observations CCPR/C/RUS/7, the United Nations Human Rights Committee stated that the Russian Federation should take all the steps necessary to ensure the investigation, prosecution and punishment of any act of violence motivated by the victim's sexual orientation or gender identity and apply the provisions of Article 63 § 1 (e) of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation to such acts.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE", "II. INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F008", "F009", "F034", "F036", "F058", "F059", "F078", "F011", "F013", "F016", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F061", "F062", "F063", "F066", "F082"], "interference": ["F078", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F092", "F096", "F097"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": ["F008", "F009", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F016", "F034", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F039", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F058", "F059", "F060", "F061", "F062", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F066", "F078", "F080", "F081", "F082", "F083"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F008", "F009", "F034", "F036", "F058", "F059", "F078", "F013"], "interference": ["F084", "F085", "F097"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": ["F012", "F013", "F014", "F016", "F037", "F039", "F041", "F042", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F060", "F062", "F064", "F066", "F080", "F082", "F083"]}, "list3": ["F009", "F036", "F059", "F078", "F013", "F047", "F064", "F083", "F084", "F097", "F046", "F066", "F039", "F041"]}} {"case_name": "case_541", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants are members and/or sympathisers of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) is a parliamentary political party in the Republic of Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) was in opposition at the time of the events.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Towards the end of 2001, the Government of Moldova made public its intention to make the study of the Russian language compulsory in schools for children aged seven and over.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Government of Moldova's initiative to make the study of the Russian language compulsory in schools prompted vehement criticism from the opposition.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Government of Moldova's initiative to make the study of the Russian language compulsory in schools generated a heated public debate.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 26 December 2001, the parliamentary group of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) informed Chişinău Municipal Council of its intention to hold a meeting with its supporters on 9 January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The meeting intended by the parliamentary group of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) was to be held in the Square of the Great National Assembly, in front of the Government buildings.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The parliamentary group of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) stated that the meeting would relate to the introduction of the compulsory study of Russian in schools.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The parliamentary group of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) relied on section 22 of the Status of Members of Parliament Act, which according to the CDPP did not require members of Parliament to obtain prior authorisation for meetings with their supporters.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "1. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "By a decision of 3 January 2002, Chişinău Municipal Council classified the gathering to be held on 9 January 2002 as a 'demonstration' within the meaning of sections 4, 8, 12 and 13 of the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "By a decision of 3 January 2002, Chişinău Municipal Council authorised the parliamentary group of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) to hold the gathering in the Square of the National Opera rather than the Square of the Great National Assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Chişinău Municipal Council did not give any reasons for the change of location from the Square of the Great National Assembly to the Square of the National Opera.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 23 January 2002, Chişinău Municipal Council addressed a letter to the Ministry of Justice informing it that there was a discrepancy between the provisions of the Status of Members of Parliament Act and those of the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Chişinău Municipal Council informed the Ministry of Justice that it did not know which of the Status of Members of Parliament Act or the Assemblies Act to apply.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Chişinău Municipal Council stated that a number of reputable lawyers supported the idea that the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) members of Parliament had the right to hold meetings with their supporters in the Square of the Great National Assembly without obtaining prior authorisation, in accordance with sections 22 and 23 of the Status of Members of Parliament Act.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Chişinău Municipal Council cited the opinion of an Ombudsman who considered that, since section 23 of the Status of Members of Parliament Act proclaimed the right of Members of Parliament to raise demands on the spot for action to remedy a breach of the law, the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) members of Parliament were entitled to raise their demands for the cessation of the alleged breaches concerning the introduction of compulsory Russian lessons in front of the Government building.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Ombudsman considered that the Government building also housed the Ministry of Education, which was relevant to the CDPP members of Parliament raising their demands there.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Chişinău Municipal Council requested the Ministry of Justice to ask Parliament for an official interpretation of the legislation in question regarding the discrepancy between the Status of Members of Parliament Act and the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 26 January 2002, Chişinău Municipal Council issued a decision noting that the provisions of domestic legislation were contradictory in respect of the demonstrations organised by the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) and that the opinions of legal experts were contradictory.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "In its decision of 26 January 2002, Chişinău Municipal Council stated that it had formally requested the Ministry of Justice to ask Parliament for an official and urgent interpretation of the relevant legislation.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "In its decision of 26 January 2002, Chişinău Municipal Council suspended its decision of 3 January 2002 until Parliament had given its official interpretation of the relevant legislation.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "2. Decisions of the Municipal Council"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 9 January 2002, the parliamentary group of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) held a gathering in the Square of the Great National Assembly, in front of Government headquarters.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Gatherings held by the CDPP members of Parliament"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The parliamentary group of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) also held gatherings on 11, 13, 15, 16 and 17 January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Gatherings held by the CDPP members of Parliament"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) informed Chişinău Municipal Council in advance of each gathering.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Gatherings held by the CDPP members of Parliament"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) did not seek authorisation in accordance with the Assemblies Act for the gatherings it held.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "3. Gatherings held by the CDPP members of Parliament"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 14 January 2002, the Ministry of Justice issued an official warning to the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) in accordance with section 27 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Ministry of Justice stated that the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) had breached the provisions of section 6 of the Assemblies Act by organising demonstrations in the Great National Assembly Square on 9, 10, 11 and 13 January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Ministry of Justice stated that the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) had organised demonstrations notwithstanding the authorisation issued by Chişinău Municipal Council, which gave permission only for a demonstration on 9 January 2002 in the Square of the National Opera.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Ministry of Justice called for an immediate halt to the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s actions, which it considered to be illegal and unconstitutional.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Ministry of Justice claimed that the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s gatherings were not meetings with voters within the meaning of the Status of Members of Parliament Act, but demonstrations falling under the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Ministry of Justice asked the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) for a written explanation within three days.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Ministry of Justice warned the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) that if it failed to comply with the warning, the Ministry would impose a temporary ban (suspendarea activităţii) on the party's activities in accordance with section 29 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 17 January 2002, the President of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) wrote a letter to the Ministry of Justice stating that the gatherings had not been organised by the CDPP but by members of its parliamentary group.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The President of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) stated in his letter to the Ministry of Justice that it was the members of the parliamentary group who were liable for the gatherings, and not the Party.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The President of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) relied on section 22 of the Status of Members of Parliament Act, arguing that it was a very specific act applicable to meetings between members of Parliament and voters, while the Assemblies Act was general in nature.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The President of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) submitted that the threatened ban on the party's activities would amount to a political measure on the part of the Communist Party in order to repress the opposition.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "4. Warning letter from the Ministry of Justice and the CDPP's reply"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 18 January 2002, the Ministry of Justice issued a decision imposing a one-month ban on the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s activities, in accordance with section 29 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The one-month ban on the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s activities was imposed on the basis of the organisation by the CDPP of unauthorised demonstrations on 9, 10, 11, 13, 15, 16 and 17 January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Ministry of Justice dismissed the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) leader's argument that the party could not be held liable for the gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Ministry of Justice stated that the gatherings organised by the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) on 9, 10, 11, 13, 15, 16 and 17 January 2002 had in fact been demonstrations and marches and therefore fell within the scope of the Assemblies Act rather than the Status of Members of Parliament Act.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to the Ministry of Justice's decision of 18 January 2002, the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) had breached the provisions of sections 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 11 of the Assemblies Act by not obtaining prior authorisation from Chişinău Municipal Council to stage demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the Ministry of Justice's decision of 18 January 2002, the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) had breached the provisions of sections 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 11 of the Assemblies Act by blocking public roads.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The participation of minors in the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) demonstrations had been in breach of Article 15 of the International Convention on the Rights of the Child.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The participation of minors in the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) demonstrations had been in breach of section 13(3) of the Protection of Children Act.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The participation of minors in the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) demonstrations had been in breach of section 56(g) of the Education Act.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s actions disclosed a violation of sections 27 and 29 of the Parties and other Socio-Political Organisations Act.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s actions disclosed a violation of section 15(1) and (2) of the Status of Members of Parliament Act.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s actions disclosed a violation of Article 32 of the Constitution of the Republic of Moldova.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The use of the slogan 'I'd rather be dead than a Communist' (mai bine mort decât comunist) at the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) demonstrations could be interpreted as a call to public violence and an act undermining the legal and constitutional order.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "5. The temporary ban imposed on the CDPP's activities"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 24 January 2002, the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) challenged the decision of the Ministry of Justice of 18 January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) argued in its challenge that the gatherings had been meetings with voters within the meaning of the Status of Members of Parliament Act, and not assemblies falling within the scope of the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 8 February 2002, the Ministry of Justice issued a decision lifting the temporary ban imposed on the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s activities.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In its decision of 8 February 2002, the Ministry of Justice stressed that the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) had breached all the laws mentioned in the decision of 18 January 2002 and that the temporary ban had been necessary and justified.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Ministry of Justice lifted the temporary ban on the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s activities following an inquiry made by the Secretary General of the Council of Europe under Article 52 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Ministry of Justice lifted the temporary ban on the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s activities having regard to the forthcoming local elections.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The decision of the Ministry of Justice of 8 February 2002 did not set aside the decision of 18 January 2002 imposing the temporary ban on the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s activities.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 7 March 2002, the Court of Appeal found in favour of the Ministry of Justice and ruled that the decision of 18 January 2002 imposing a one-month ban on the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s activities had been lawful.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Court of Appeal dismissed the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s argument that the party could not be held liable for the actions of its members, namely its parliamentary group.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Court of Appeal found that the gatherings organised by the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) had in fact been demonstrations, meetings and marches which fell under the provisions of the Assemblies Act, and not meetings with voters.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Court of Appeal found that even assuming the gatherings had been intended as meetings with voters, they had gradually taken on the nature of demonstrations and accordingly the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) needed authorisation in order to organise them.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Court of Appeal stated that as a result of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) demonstrations, the public transport company had suffered losses of 12,133 Moldovan lei (MDL) (approximately 1,050 euros (EUR) at the time).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Court of Appeal stated that the participation of minors in the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) demonstrations had been in breach of the International Convention on the Rights of the Child, the Protection of Children Act and the Education Act.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) lodged an appeal against the Court of Appeal's decision of 7 March 2002 with the Supreme Court of Justice, relying inter alia on Articles 10 and 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 17 May 2002, a panel of the Supreme Court of Justice delivered its judgment dismissing the appeal lodged by the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) against the Court of Appeal's decision of 7 March 2002.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice endorsed the arguments of the Court of Appeal and found that since the demonstrations organised by the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) had been illegal, the sanction imposed on it had not been disproportionate.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice stated that in any event the decision of the Ministry of Justice of 18 January 2002 had not had any negative effects on the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) since it had not been enforced, the CDPP's accounts had not been frozen and the party could continue its activities unhindered.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "6. Proceedings challenging the ban on the Party's activities, and lifting of the ban"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Ministry of Justice did not reply to Chişinău Municipal Council's request of 23 January 2002 for interpretation of the law.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. Proceedings by the Government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Ministry of Justice did not address any request to Parliament regarding the interpretation of the law following Chişinău Municipal Council's request of 23 January 2002.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. Proceedings by the Government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 21 February 2002, the Government lodged an application with the Supreme Court of Justice asking it to declare the demonstrations organised by the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) illegal and to order their cessation.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. Proceedings by the Government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 25 February 2002, the Supreme Court of Justice ruled in favour of the Government and declared the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) gatherings illegal.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. Proceedings by the Government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice stated in its ruling of 25 February 2002 that even if the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) had the initial intention of holding meetings with its supporters, those meetings later took on the character of demonstrations, marches, processions and picketing, which fall under the provisions of the Organisation and Conduct of Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. Proceedings by the Government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice stated in its ruling of 25 February 2002 that the leaders of the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) were required to comply with the provisions of the Assemblies Act.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. Proceedings by the Government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) appealed against the Supreme Court of Justice's judgment of 25 February 2002.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. Proceedings by the Government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 15 March 2002, the Supreme Court of Justice dismissed the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP)'s appeal against the judgment of 25 February 2002.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. Proceedings by the Government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Supreme Court of Justice's judgment of 25 February 2002 declaring the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) gatherings illegal became final on 15 March 2002.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "7. Proceedings by the Government seeking to have the gatherings held by the CDPP declared illegal and requesting an order to discontinue them"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On unspecified dates, the district police compiled administrative case files in connection with the applicants' participation in unauthorised demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The administrative cases against the applicants were referred to the Buiucani District Court.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "By its decision of 21 February 2002, the Buiucani District Court found the first applicant, Mr Roşca, guilty of having organised and actively participated in the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) demonstrations between 9 and 31 January 2002, in breach of Article 174/1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "By its decision of 21 February 2002, the Buiucani District Court found the second applicant, Mr Secareanu, guilty of having organised and actively participated in the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) demonstrations between 9 and 31 January 2002, in breach of Article 174/1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "By its decision of 24 January 2002, the Buiucani District Court found the third applicant, Mr Buburuz, guilty of having participated in a Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) demonstration on 15 January 2002, in breach of Article 174/1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "By its decision of 29 January 2002, the Buiucani District Court found the fourth applicant, Mr Roşcovan, guilty of having participated in a demonstration on 20 January 2004, in breach of Article 174/1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "By its decision of 24 January 2002, the Buiucani District Court found the fifth applicant, Mr Eremia, guilty of having participated in a demonstration on 13 January 2004, in breach of Article 174/1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Buiucani District Court imposed an administrative fine of MDL 450 (EUR 40) on the first applicant, Mr Roşca.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Buiucani District Court imposed an administrative fine of MDL 450 (EUR 40) on the second applicant, Mr Secareanu.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The Buiucani District Court imposed an administrative fine of MDL 90 (EUR 8) on the third applicant, Mr Buburuz.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Buiucani District Court imposed an administrative fine of MDL 90 (EUR 8) on the fourth applicant, Mr Roşcovan.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Buiucani District Court imposed an administrative fine of MDL 90 (EUR 8) on the fifth applicant, Mr Eremia.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The applicants appealed against the Buiucani District Court judgments, claiming inter alia a breach of their right to freedom of expression under Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The applicants appealed against the Buiucani District Court judgments, claiming inter alia a breach of their right to freedom of assembly under Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "By its decision of 30 April 2002, the Chişinău Regional Court dismissed the appeal of the first applicant, Mr Roşca, against the Buiucani District Court judgment.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "By its decision of 30 April 2002, the Chişinău Regional Court dismissed the appeal of the second applicant, Mr Secareanu, against the Buiucani District Court judgment.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "By its decision of 13 February 2002, the Chişinău Regional Court dismissed the appeal of the third applicant, Mr Buburuz, against the Buiucani District Court judgment.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "By its decision of 28 February 2002, the Chişinău Regional Court dismissed the appeal of the fourth applicant, Mr Roşcovan, against the Buiucani District Court judgment.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "By its decision of 13 February 2002, the Chişinău Regional Court dismissed the appeal of the fifth applicant, Mr Eremia, against the Buiucani District Court judgment.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Chişinău Regional Court gave no reasons for dismissing the applicants' appeals against the Buiucani District Court judgments.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "8. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The relevant domestic law applicable to this case was set out in Christian Democratic People's Party v. Moldova, no. 28793/02, §§ 34-41, ECHR 2006-.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F009", "F023", "F024", "F026", "F050", "F077", "F078", "F079", "F080", "F081", "F082", "F083", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F087", "F088"], "interference": ["F026", "F077", "F078", "F079", "F080", "F081", "F082", "F083", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F087", "F088"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F014", "F015", "F016", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F009", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F026", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F050", "F063", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F087", "F088"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F001", "F023", "F024", "F050", "F079", "F080", "F081", "F082", "F083"], "interference": ["F026", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F087", "F088"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F015", "F020", "F022"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F004", "F006", "F015", "F020", "F022", "F026", "F044", "F050", "F063"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F001", "F002", "F003", "F004", "F006", "F020", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F026", "F050", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F087", "F088"]}} {"case_name": "case_542", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the location of public events.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the time of conduct of public events.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the manner of conduct of public events.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Some applicants alleged the lack of an effective remedy in respect of restrictions imposed on public events.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Some applicants alleged unlawful arrest.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003", "F004"]}} {"case_name": "case_543", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_545", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants raised complaints other than disproportionate measures under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_547", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1962.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "At the material time, the applicant was a civil servant in the Metropolitan Municipality of Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "At the material time, the applicant was a member of the local branch of the Tümbel-Sen trade union.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Tümbel-Sen trade union is affiliated to the KESK (Kamu Emekçileri Sendikaları Konfederasyonu – the Confederation of Public Employees' Trade Unions).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "In April 2008, the DİSK (Devrimci İşçi Sendikaları Konfederasyonu – Confederation of Revolutionary Workers' Trade Unions) announced that it was planning a large-scale demonstration in Istanbul for 1 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "In April 2008, the KESK (Kamu Emekçileri Sendikaları Konfederasyonu – Confederation of Public Employees' Trade Unions) announced that it was planning a large-scale demonstration in Istanbul for 1 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The DİSK and the KESK announced that their members would be gathering on 1 May 2008 to celebrate Labour Day.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The DİSK and the KESK announced that their members would be gathering on 1 May 2008 to commemorate friends who had lost their lives during the demonstrations of 1 May 1977.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "In May 2008, the applicant was informed that a disciplinary investigation had been initiated against him for being absent without leave on 1 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant was asked to submit his defence submissions in connection with the disciplinary investigation initiated against him for being absent without leave on 1 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant explained that he had participated in a demonstration organised by his trade union on 1 May 2008 to celebrate International Labour Day.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant was given a warning as a disciplinary sanction owing to his being absent without leave on 1 May 2008.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The disciplinary sanction of a warning was imposed on the applicant pursuant to section 125 of the Civil Servants Act (Law no. 657).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 13 May 2008, the applicant objected to the disciplinary warning decision and requested its annulment.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 16 May 2008, the Disciplinary Board of the Istanbul Municipality dismissed the applicant's objection to the disciplinary warning decision.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Disciplinary Board of the Istanbul Municipality found that the contested disciplinary warning decision was in accordance with the law.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Disciplinary Board of the Istanbul Municipality found that there were no grounds to annul the disciplinary warning decision.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "A full description of the relevant domestic law at the material time can be found in Karaçay v. Turkey (no. 6615/03, §§ 14-17, 27 March 2007).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "A full description of the relevant domestic law at the material time can be found in İsmail Sezer v. Turkey (no. 36807/07, §§ 14-21, 24 March 2015).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "By Law no. 5892, amending the Law on General and National Holidays, adopted on 22 April 2009, 1 May (Labour Day) was designated as a public holiday.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F021"], "interference": ["F013", "F014"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F014"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F016", "F017", "F018"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F012"], "interference": ["F013", "F014"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F014"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F012", "F013", "F014", "F016", "F017"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F005", "F007", "F012", "F013", "F017"]}} {"case_name": "case_548", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants or organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_550", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1964.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Istanbul.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant is a member of the Human Rights Association in Turkey.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "According to official police documents drafted on 8 April 2002 at 9.15 p.m., the security forces received information that the Human Rights Association would hold an unauthorised demonstration and press release concerning Israel's operations against Palestine at Tünel Square on 8 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "According to official police documents drafted on 8 April 2002 at 9.30 p.m., the security forces received information that the Human Rights Association would hold an unauthorised demonstration and press release concerning Israel's operations against Palestine at Tünel Square on 8 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The police took the necessary precautions at Tünel Square as of 7 p.m. on 8 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "At 8 p.m. on 8 April 2002, around 30-35 persons gathered at Tünel Square holding candles, photos and banners.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The banners held by the demonstrators at Tünel Square on 8 April 2002 stated, inter alia, \"All the world is Palestine, all of us are Palestinians\".", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The banners held by the demonstrators at Tünel Square on 8 April 2002 stated, inter alia, \"an end to the occupation, freedom to Palestine\".", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The banners held by the demonstrators at Tünel Square on 8 April 2002 stated, inter alia, \"Wanted Ariel Sharon war-criminal\".", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The demonstrators at Tünel Square on 8 April 2002 sat down on the street.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The police chief warned the demonstrators many times to disperse on 8 April 2002 at Tünel Square.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The police opened a passage for the demonstrators to leave Tünel Square on 8 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The group of demonstrators at Tünel Square on 8 April 2002 started to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Two persons, including the applicant, continued to sit and shout slogans at Tünel Square on 8 April 2002 despite warnings from the police.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The police used force to arrest the two persons, including the applicant, who continued to sit and shout slogans at Tünel Square on 8 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant submitted in the application form that on 8 April 2002 he had arrived at Tünel Square in order to participate in the Human Rights Association's press release on Israel's invasion of Palestine.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant submitted that the police intercepted the group at Tünel Square on 8 April 2002 and told them that they would not permit such a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant submitted that as a result of the police interception, the organisers decided to disperse and told the group to disband.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant submitted that while the group was dispersing, he saw that the police were trying to arrest Ms M.A., a fellow demonstrator.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant submitted that when he intervened and asked why the police were arresting Ms M.A., the police chief got angry.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant submitted that the police chief and 5 or 6 other police officers beat him up.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant submitted that the police then arrested him and Ms M.A.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant claimed to have received punches and kicks during his arrest on 8 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant claimed to have been hit by a truncheon on various parts of his body, including his head and his back, during his arrest on 8 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant and Ms M.A. were brought to the Beyoğlu police station following their arrest on 8 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant and Ms M.A. were released from the Beyoğlu police station 1.5 hours after their arrest on 8 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant was asked to give a statement to the prosecutor's office the next day, i.e. on 9 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The police took the applicant for a medical examination to Taksim Hospital following his arrest on 8 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The doctor who examined the applicant at Taksim Hospital noted a swelling and ecchymosis of 2 cm on the applicant's head in the frontal region.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The medical report from Taksim Hospital mentioned that the applicant had complained of a headache.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The medical report from Taksim Hospital mentioned that the applicant had complained of difficulty in breathing.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 9 April 2002 the applicant was heard by Mr Y.A., a prosecutor at the Beyoğlu public prosecutor's office.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "In his deposition on 9 April 2002, the applicant complained, inter alia, about the manner in which he had been arrested.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "In his deposition on 9 April 2002, the applicant requested that those who had committed offences against him be punished.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 9 April 2002 the applicant was examined by a doctor at the Beyoğlu Forensic Medicine Department.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The doctor at the Beyoğlu Forensic Medicine Department noted a swelling of 2 cm on the applicant's head in the frontal region on 9 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The doctor at the Beyoğlu Forensic Medicine Department noted that the applicant had sensitivity to the right of his chest on 9 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 10 June 2002 an Istanbul deputy police chief was appointed to carry out a preliminary investigation on behalf of the governor of Istanbul into the allegations of ill-treatment made by the applicant and Ms M.A.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On an unspecified date the Istanbul deputy police chief prepared his report and submitted it to the Istanbul governor's office.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Istanbul deputy police chief's report recommended that authorisation for the prosecution of Mr Ş.P., the police chief on duty on 8 April 2002, should be declined on the ground that the complaints were ill-founded.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 4 July 2002 the Istanbul Deputy Governor refused authorisation for the prosecution of Mr Ş.P., the police chief on duty on 8 April 2002, on the basis of the information contained in the Istanbul deputy police chief's report and statements.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 12 August 2002 the applicant lodged an objection to the Istanbul Deputy Governor's decision of 4 July 2002 with the Istanbul Regional Administrative Court.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "In his objection of 12 August 2002, the applicant submitted that his complaint of ill-treatment concerned not only the police chief Mr Ş.P. but also all those officers who had carried out his order to beat him.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 26 November 2002 the Istanbul Regional Administrative Court upheld the applicant's objection on account of an insufficient investigation, notably regarding the other police officers involved.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On an unspecified date the same Istanbul deputy police chief prepared a second report in which he reiterated his previous findings and submitted it to the Istanbul governor's office.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 7 March 2003 the Istanbul Governor declined authorisation for the prosecution of the police officers on the basis of the information contained in the second report and statements prepared by the Istanbul deputy police chief.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 4 July 2003 the Istanbul Regional Administrative Court, upon the objection of Ms M.A., transferred the case to the Beyoğlu public prosecutor's office.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Istanbul Regional Administrative Court transferred the case to the Beyoğlu public prosecutor's office on the ground that the complainant's accusations concerned allegations of ill-treatment under Article 245 of the relevant criminal law.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Istanbul Regional Administrative Court transferred the case to the Beyoğlu public prosecutor's office on the ground that, pursuant to amendments to the criminal law and code on criminal procedure, authorisation was no longer a prerequisite to prosecute the accused police officers.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 7 August 2003 the Beyoğlu public prosecutor decided not to prosecute the accused police officers.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In his decision of 7 August 2003, the Beyoğlu public prosecutor noted that about 30-35 persons had gathered with candles and banners at Tünel in Beyoğlu on 8 April 2002 in order to protest Israel's invasion of Palestine.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "In his decision of 7 August 2003, the Beyoğlu public prosecutor noted that following warnings from the police, the demonstrators had started to disperse on 8 April 2002.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In his decision of 7 August 2003, the Beyoğlu public prosecutor noted that the complainants had continued to sit down and shout slogans after warnings to disperse on 8 April 2002, and as a result the police had had to use force and arrest them.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Beyoğlu public prosecutor considered in his decision of 7 August 2003 that the force used by the security forces was in line with Article 24 of the Assemblies and Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 26 August 2003 the applicant filed an objection with the Beyoğlu public prosecutor's office, to be referred to the assize court, against the Beyoğlu public prosecutor's decision of 7 August 2003.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In his petition of 26 August 2003, the applicant complained that his right to freedom of expression had been infringed by his unlawful arrest and ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "In his petition of 26 August 2003, the applicant complained that his right to peaceful assembly had been infringed by his unlawful arrest and ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 9 September 2003 the Istanbul Assize Court dismissed the applicant's objection against the Beyoğlu public prosecutor's decision of 7 August 2003.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Istanbul Assize Court's decision of 9 September 2003 was notified to the applicant's legal representative on 27 October 2003.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "A description of the relevant domestic law at the material time can be found in Mehmet Ümit Erdem v. Turkey, no. 42234/02, § 19, 17 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F004", "F005", "F012", "F014", "F017", "F016"], "interference": ["F016", "F012", "F013"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F055", "F004", "F005"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F004", "F005", "F018", "F026", "F012", "F014", "F016"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F007", "F017", "F012", "F014"], "interference": ["F016", "F012"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F055", "F004"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F007", "F018", "F004", "F012", "F014"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F007", "F018", "F004", "F012", "F014", "F016"]}} {"case_name": "case_551", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1954.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Ashtarak, Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant is the chairman of a regional branch of the Republic Party («Հանրապետություն» կուսակցություն).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "In 2003 a presidential election was held in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The first round of the 2003 Armenian presidential election took place on 19 February 2003.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The second round of the 2003 Armenian presidential election took place on 5 March 2003.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Following the first and second rounds of the 2003 Armenian presidential election, a series of protest rallies were organised in Yerevan by the opposition parties.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 20 February 2003 the applicant participated in a demonstration held in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The demonstration held in Yerevan on 20 February 2003 was apparently followed by a march.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 26 February 2003 another demonstration was apparently supposed to take place in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 26 February 2003 the applicant and two other members of the Republic Party set off by car from Ashnak village to Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant alleged that on the road to Yerevan their car was stopped by several individuals in civilian clothes.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant alleged that the individuals who stopped their car introduced themselves as officers of the Aragatsotn Regional Police Department.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant and his colleagues were taken to the Aragatsotn Regional Police Department.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "From the Aragatsotn Regional Police Department, the applicant was transferred to the Central District Police Department of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "At the Central District Police Department of Yerevan, an administrative case was initiated against the applicant on account of his participation in the demonstration of 20 February 2003.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 26 February 2003, several hours after being brought to the Central District Police Department of Yerevan, the applicant was taken to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan (Երևան քաղաքի Կենտրոն և Նորք-Մարաշ համայնքներկ առաջին ատյանի դատարան).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "At the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan, the applicant was brought before Judge A.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Judge A. heard the applicant and his lawyer before delivering the sentence.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "After a brief hearing, Judge A. sentenced the applicant under Article 180.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (Վարչական իրավախախտումների վերաբերյալ ՀՀ օրենսգիրք – \"the CAO\") to ten days of administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Judge A. found that on 20 February 2003 the applicant participated in an unauthorised march, thus violating the prescribed rules for organising and holding street marches and demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Judge A. found that for the act of participating in an unauthorised march, the applicant was brought to the Central District Police Department on 26 February 2003.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Judge A. found that the fact of the applicant's participation in an unauthorised march was confirmed by the explanation given by the applicant in court and the examination of the materials of the administrative case file.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The decision of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan stated that it was not subject to appeal.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The decision of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan stated that it could be protested against only by the prosecutor.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 27 February 2003 the applicant's lawyer lodged an appeal with the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal (ՀՀ քրեական և զինվորական գործերով վերաքննիչ դատարան) against the decision of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 27 February 2003 the applicant's lawyer lodged an application with the General Prosecutor (ՀՀ գլխավոր դատախազ) requesting him to initiate an appeal against the decision of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant's lawyer argued, relying on various domestic provisions, that he was entitled to lodge an appeal against the decision of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant's lawyer submitted that the interference with the applicant's right to freedom of peaceful assembly was in violation of the Constitution of Armenia and was not prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicant's lawyer submitted that the penalty imposed on the applicant was excessive.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant's lawyer attached a copy of the contested decision of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan to the appeal.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 2 March 2003 the President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal (ՀՀ քրեական և զինվորական գործերով վերաքննիչ դատարանի նախագահ) reviewed the applicant's conviction.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal found that the applicant, according to the decision of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan, was subjected to administrative detention for violating the prescribed rules for organising and holding assemblies, demonstrations, street marches and rallies, by participating in an unauthorised demonstration and street march on 20 February 2003.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal found, having familiarised himself with the applicant's appeal and the materials concerning the administrative offence, that the penalty imposed on the applicant must be changed.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal changed the penalty imposed on the applicant to an administrative fine of 1,000 Armenian drams (AMD), approximately 1.5 euros (EUR) at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The President of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal ordered the applicant's release from detention.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 2 March 2003 the applicant was released from detention after having served approximately four days of his ten-day sentence.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "By a letter of 4 March 2003, the applicant's lawyer was informed by the General Prosecutor's Office (ՀՀ գլխավոր դատախազություն) that, on the basis of the applicant's appeal, the penalty had been changed by decision of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "By a letter of 4 March 2003, the applicant's lawyer was informed by the General Prosecutor's Office (ՀՀ գլխավոր դատախազություն) that the applicant had been released by decision of the Criminal and Military Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The demonstration of 20 February 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 3 December 2003 the applicant supplemented his initial application to the Court with complaints about additional events.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 14 May 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 14 May 2003 the applicant participated in a demonstration held in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 14 May 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 21 May 2003 the applicant was taken to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 14 May 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 21 May 2003 the applicant was transported from a police station to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 14 May 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "At the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan, an administrative fine of 1,000 Armenian drams (AMD) was imposed on the applicant for having organised the participation of a group of people from his region in an unauthorised demonstration on 14 May 2003.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The demonstration of 14 May 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "A summary of the relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings is contained in the judgment in the case of Galstyan v. Armenia (no. 26986/03, § 26, 15 November 2007).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "A summary of the relevant legislation invoked by the parties in connection with Article 180.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO) is contained in the judgment in the case of Mkrtchyan v. Armenia (no. 6562/03, §§ 20-28, 11 January 2007).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F008", "F009", "F020", "F021"], "interference": ["F020", "F021", "F035"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F008", "F020", "F021", "F046"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F008", "F009", "F021"], "interference": ["F020", "F021"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F008", "F020", "F021", "F046"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F008", "F020", "F021", "F046"]}} {"case_name": "case_552", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_553", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_554", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1968.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Kazan.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr I.N. Sholokhov, a lawyer practising in Kazan.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The Government were represented by Mr G. Matyushkin, Representative of the Russian Government before the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr M. Galperin, successor to Mr G. Matyushkin as Representative of the Russian Government before the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 10 October 2007 the applicant notified the Kazan Town Hall of the intention of a group of dormitory residents to organise a static demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 12 October 2007 the Kazan Town Hall refused to approve the demonstration at the proposed location.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Kazan Town Hall stated that heavy road traffic and a car park for government vehicles would put the participants' security in danger, as the reason for refusing to approve the demonstration at the proposed location.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Kazan Town Hall proposed that the demonstration be held inside the park at Svoboda Square.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Kazan Town Hall proposed that the demonstration be held on the other side of Svoboda Square opposite a theatre.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On an unspecified date the applicant notified the authorities that he disagreed with the proposal to change the location of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Between 9 a.m. and 11.30 a.m. on 18 October 2007 a demonstration was held on the pavement close to Svoboda Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The demonstration on 18 October 2007 was held on the pavement close to the building of the Cabinet of Ministers opposite the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Tatarstan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "At 3.45 p.m. on 18 October 2007 the applicant was forcibly arrested at a bus stop.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "After being forcibly arrested, the applicant was taken to the Yapeyeva police department in the Vakhitovskiy District of Kazan.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant was charged with an administrative offence under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences on account of holding the demonstration in the vicinity of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Tatarstan.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant was charged with an administrative offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 20 October 2007 the applicant lodged a criminal complaint about the use of force by the police.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Kazan investigative committee at the prosecutor's office of the Republic of Tatarstan refused to institute criminal proceedings against the police officers, concluding that the use of force had been lawful and not excessive.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Kazan investigative committee at the prosecutor's office of the Republic of Tatarstan refused to institute criminal proceedings against the police officers in accordance with Article 24 § 1 (2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, citing lack of the constituent elements of a crime.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Kazan investigative committee at the prosecutor's office of the Republic of Tatarstan issued its last refusal to institute criminal proceedings against the police officers on 2 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Vakhitovskiy District Court upheld the refusal to institute criminal proceedings against the police officers in a judgment of 8 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan upheld the Vakhitovskiy District Court's judgment of 8 April 2008 in a judgment of 29 April 2008, following appeals lodged by the applicant and the assistant prosecutor of Kazan.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation rejected a request by the applicant for supervisory review of the judgments of 8 April 2008 and 29 April 2008 in a decision of 18 August 2008.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 12 November 2007 the Justice of the Peace of the 4th Court Circuit of the Vakhitovskiy District of Kazan convicted the applicant of breaching the established procedure for conducting public assemblies under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The conviction under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences was on the grounds that the applicant had held the demonstration opposite the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Tatarstan, which was prohibited by law.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to a fine of 1,000 roubles (RUB) for the offence under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 16 November 2007 the Justice of the Peace of the 5th Court Circuit of the Vakhitovskiy District of Kazan convicted the applicant of disobeying a lawful order of the police under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to a fine of RUB 800 for the offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant appealed against the judgments of 12 and 16 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 23 November 2007 the Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan upheld the judgment of 12 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 30 November 2007 the Vakhitovskiy District Court of Kazan upheld the judgment of 16 November 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 11 January 2008 the Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan granted the applicant's request for supervisory review of the judgments in the proceedings which had ended with his conviction under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan held that the record of the applicant's administrative offence had not contained specific reasons for his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan held that the reasons for the applicant's arrest had not been established in the course of the administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan held that the record of the applicant's administrative arrest had not been in the case file.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan concluded that there had been no lawful grounds for arresting the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan stressed that an administrative arrest was a measure of restraint which could be applied only in the exceptional circumstances provided for by law and that those circumstances had not been present in the applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan found that there were no grounds for finding the applicant guilty of committing the administrative offence of disobeying a lawful order of the police under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan quashed the judgment of 16 November 2007 convicting the applicant under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan quashed the judgment of 30 November 2007 upholding the conviction under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan discontinued the administrative proceedings against the applicant under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant lodged a civil claim in respect of non-pecuniary damage.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 26 June 2008 the Novo-Savinovskiy District Court of Kazan, relying on the judgment of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan of 11 January 2008, established that in forcibly arresting the applicant, the police officers from the Kazan Town Police Department had acted unlawfully, in the absence of legitimate grounds.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 26 June 2008 the Novo-Savinovskiy District Court of Kazan established that in escorting the applicant to the police station, the police officers from the Kazan Town Police Department had acted unlawfully, in the absence of legitimate grounds.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 26 June 2008 the Novo-Savinovskiy District Court of Kazan established that in bringing administrative proceedings against the applicant under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, the police officers from the Kazan Town Police Department had acted unlawfully, in the absence of legitimate grounds.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Novo-Savinovskiy District Court of Kazan relied on the Constitutional Court's judgment no. 1-P of 25 January 2001.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Novo-Savinovskiy District Court of Kazan relied on the Constitutional Court's decision no. 440-O of 4 December 2003.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Novo-Savinovskiy District Court of Kazan held that Article 1070 § 1 of the Civil Code, which provided for the State's strict liability in certain cases, also applied to situations in which harm had resulted from other equivalent measures of restraint such as escorting and administrative arrest.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Novo-Savinovskiy District Court of Kazan held that administrative arrest was equivalent to the measure of administrative detention expressly included in Article 1070 § 1 of the Civil Code because the duration of the administrative detention included the duration of the administrative arrest by virtue of Article 32.8 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Novo-Savinovskiy District Court of Kazan awarded the applicant RUB 10,000 in respect of non-pecuniary damage sustained as a result of the police officers' unlawful actions.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The RUB 10,000 award in respect of non-pecuniary damage was to be paid by the Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 31 July 2008 the Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan upheld the Novo-Savinovskiy District Court's judgment of 26 June 2008 on appeal lodged by the respondent.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "A summary of domestic law concerning the conduct of public events, liability for breaches committed during such events, and administrative escorting and arrest can be found in Lashmankin and Others v. Russia, nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, §§ 216-42, 298-300 and 308-10, 7 February 2017.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F007", "F008", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F026"], "interference": ["F008", "F010", "F011", "F015", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F032"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F026", "F027", "F055"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F026", "F027", "F032", "F055"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F007", "F012", "F013", "F014"], "interference": ["F008", "F015", "F026"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F027", "F055"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F026", "F027", "F055"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F007", "F008", "F014", "F026", "F027", "F055"]}} {"case_name": "case_555", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of nationwide protests in support of the jailed opposition leader, Aleksey Navalnyy.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of nationwide protests in support of the jailed opposition leader, Aleksey Navalnyy.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_556", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them on account of their arrest following their participation in public demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them on account of their conviction for an administrative offence following their participation in public demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_558", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1964 and lives in Adıyaman.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1969 and lives in Adıyaman.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1964 and lives in Adıyaman.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The fourth applicant was born in 1971 and lives in Adıyaman.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The fifth applicant was born in 1961 and lives in Adıyaman.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The sixth applicant was born in 1965 and lives in Adıyaman.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The seventh applicant was born in 1971 and lives in Adıyaman.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The eighth applicant was born in 1975 and lives in Adıyaman.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The ninth applicant was born in 1964 and lives in Adıyaman.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The tenth applicant was born in 1971 and lives in Adıyaman.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The eleventh applicant was born in 1965 and lives in Adıyaman.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 30 April 1999, the Adıyaman Governor authorised the holding of May Day celebrations in the Adıyaman Amphitheatre, located in the Hasancık District.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 1 May 1999, a group of people, including the applicants, gathered in the building of the Health Workers' Trade Union.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 1 May 1999, the group that had gathered in the building of the Health Workers' Trade Union started to walk towards the Adıyaman Amphitheatre for the May Day celebrations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The group walking towards the Adıyaman Amphitheatre was stopped by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The group stated that they had obtained prior authorisation from the Adıyaman Governor and attempted to continue their march towards the Adıyaman Amphitheatre.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The police intervened to disperse the group that was attempting to continue its march towards the Adıyaman Amphitheatre.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicants were allegedly injured during the police intervention to disperse the group as a result of the force used by the police.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the incident report, thirty-eight people, including the applicants, were arrested during the incident on 1 May 1999.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Following their arrest, the applicants were taken to the Adıyaman State Hospital, where they were examined by a doctor.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The medical report in respect of Ms Zeynep Saya stated that there were no signs of ill-treatment on her body.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The medical report in respect of Mr Hasan Ölgün stated that there were no signs of ill-treatment on his body.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The medical report in respect of Mr Müslüm Atasoy stated that there were no signs of ill-treatment on his body.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The medical report in respect of Ms Zöhre Taş stated that there were no signs of ill-treatment on her body.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The medical report in respect of Mr Nedim Çifçi stated that there were no signs of ill-treatment on his body.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The medical report in respect of Ms Hediye Kilinç stated that there were no signs of ill-treatment on her body.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The medical report in respect of Şeyho Saya indicated tenderness on the back of the right leg and on the back.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The medical report in respect of Çetin Taş indicated tenderness on the lower left side of the chest and pain while breathing.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The medical report in respect of Çetin Taş indicated tenderness and pain on the right side of the forehead.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The medical report in respect of Çetin Taş indicated a possible fracture of the ribs on the left side of the chest.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The medical report in respect of Akın Doğan indicated scratches on the back.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The medical report in respect of Ali Murat Bilgiç indicated tenderness and bruises on the left shoulder and the left arm.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The medical report in respect of Bahattin Barış Bilgiç indicated scratches on the right elbow and the right knee, and hyperaemia on the left side of the chest.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "Following their examination at the Adıyaman State Hospital, the applicants were taken into custody.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicants were released from custody the day after they were taken into custody, on 2 May 1999.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On different dates in May 1999, the applicants filed criminal complaints with the Adıyaman Public Prosecutor against those police officers who had allegedly used excessive force during the applicants' arrest on 1 May 1999.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 17 June 1999, the Adıyaman Public Prosecutor transferred the case file to the Adıyaman Provincial Administrative Council.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Adıyaman Public Prosecutor sought authorisation from the Adıyaman Provincial Administrative Council to bring criminal proceedings against the accused police officers, pursuant to the provisions of the Law on the Prosecution of Civil Servants.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 16 February 2000, the Adıyaman Provincial Administrative Council found that there was not enough evidence to initiate criminal proceedings against the accused police officers.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 16 February 2000, the Adıyaman Provincial Administrative Council refused to initiate criminal proceedings against the accused police officers.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 1 September 2000, the applicants appealed against the decision of the Adıyaman Provincial Administrative Council of 16 February 2000.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "In their appeal petition, the applicants invoked a breach of Article 11 of the Convention, arguing that the police interference had breached their freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 14 June 2001, the Supreme Administrative Council upheld the decision of the Adıyaman Provincial Administrative Council of 16 February 2000 refusing to initiate criminal proceedings against the accused police officers.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 1 June 1999, the Adıyaman Public Prosecutor examined a video recording of the incident of 1 May 1999.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 1 June 1999, the Adıyaman Public Prosecutor delivered a decision not to prosecute with regard to seventy demonstrators, including the applicants, who had been involved in the incident on 1 May 1999.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In his decision of 1 June 1999, the Adıyaman Public Prosecutor stated that the demonstrators had been stopped by the police, although they had been walking silently along the pavement, without presenting a danger to the public or engaging in any violent activities.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In his decision of 1 June 1999, the Adıyaman Public Prosecutor indicated that, pursuant to section 24 of the Assemblies and Marches Act (Law no. 2911), the police were under an obligation to warn the group out loud to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "In his decision of 1 June 1999, the Adıyaman Public Prosecutor observed from the video recording of the incident that the police had failed to warn the group out loud to disperse as required by section 24 of the Assemblies and Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In his decision of 1 June 1999, the Adıyaman Public Prosecutor held that the accused demonstrators had not violated the Assemblies and Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F012", "F016", "F014", "F015", "F017", "F046"], "interference": ["F017", "F019", "F015", "F048", "F035"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F012", "F016", "F014", "F015", "F017", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F019", "F035"], "positive_obligation": ["F012"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F012", "F014", "F046"], "interference": ["F017", "F019"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F012", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F017"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F012", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F017", "F019"]}} {"case_name": "case_559", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant lives in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "On 13 October 2008, the applicant applied to the Budapest Police Department for authorisation for a political demonstration in front of Parliament, in Kossuth Square.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Kossuth Square is a vast open area traditionally used for political demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "One of the declared objectives of the planned demonstration was commemoration of the revolution of 1956.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "One of the declared objectives of the planned demonstration was commemoration of the tumultuous events in Budapest in 2006.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "One of the declared objectives of the planned demonstration was to call attention to the perceived absence of legal certainty in Hungary.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The planned demonstration was scheduled for Friday, 17 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "According to Parliament's official and public activity log available on the Internet, the only event taking place on 17 October 2008 in Parliament's building was a conference and open day organised by the Hungarian Alliance for Enhancing Female Careers under the title 'Employment – Equality of Chances – Competitiveness'.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "According to Parliament's official and public activity log available on the Internet, no parliamentary session was scheduled for 17 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 14 October 2008, the Budapest Police Department proposed to the applicant that the planned demonstration be held in a secluded part of Kossuth Square, rather than its entirety.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant refused the Budapest Police Department's suggestion to hold the demonstration in a secluded part of Kossuth Square.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 15 October 2008, the Budapest Police Department forbade the applicant's planned demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Budapest Police Department was of the view that the planned demonstration would 'gravely endanger' the functioning of Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Budapest Police Department considered that 'gravely endangering' the functioning of Parliament was a legitimate ground for prohibiting the demonstration under section 8(1) of the Assembly Act.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Budapest Police Department considered that amplified speeches and music belonging to the programme of the planned demonstration might disturb the Members of Parliament's work.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Budapest Police Department estimated the number of participants in the planned demonstration at 150 to 200 persons.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Budapest Police Department considered that participants in the planned demonstration might physically impede Members of Parliament from driving in and out of Parliament's car park.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Budapest Police Department considered that participants physically impeding Members of Parliament from driving in and out of Parliament's car park would amount to restricting the Members of Parliament's freedom of movement.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Budapest Police Department considered that participants physically impeding Members of Parliament from driving in and out of Parliament's car park would amount to inhibiting the functioning of the organ of the people's representation.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant applied for judicial review of the Budapest Police Department's decision forbidding the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant submitted that another demonstration with an agenda identical to his, scheduled for Wednesday, 15 October 2008, had not been forbidden on exactly the same location as his planned demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant submitted that the fact that the other demonstration on 15 October 2008 had not been forbidden showed discrimination against him and his planned event.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to Parliament's official and public activity log available on the Internet, on 15 October 2008 five parliamentary commissions were in session.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 22 October 2008, the Budapest Regional Court dismissed the applicant's complaint against the Budapest Police Department's decision forbidding the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court endorsed in essence the Budapest Police Department's reasoning for forbidding the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F007", "F012"], "interference": ["F012"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F014"], "legitimate_aim": ["F013", "F015", "F017", "F018", "F019"], "necessity": ["F010", "F011", "F013", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F021", "F023", "F008", "F009"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F012"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F014"], "legitimate_aim": ["F013"], "necessity": ["F010", "F021", "F023", "F009"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F012", "F009", "F021", "F023"]}} {"case_name": "case_561", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1985.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1985.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The first applicant lives in Bad Bevensen.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The second applicant lives in Berlin.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "A G8 summit of Heads of State and Government was held from 6 to 8 June 2007 in Heiligendamm, in the vicinity of Rostock.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The police considered that there was a threat of terrorist attacks during the G8 summit in Heiligendamm.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The police considered that the threat of terrorist attacks during the G8 summit came in particular from Islamist terrorists.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Having regard to the experience of previous G8 summits, the police considered that there was a risk of property damage by left-wing extremists during the G8 summit in Heiligendamm.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Left-wing extremists were found to have planned to protest against the G8 summit in Heiligendamm.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Left-wing extremists were found to have planned to block the G8 summit in Heiligendamm.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Left-wing extremists were found to have planned to sabotage the G8 summit in Heiligendamm.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The police estimated that there would be around 25,000 participants at an international demonstration in Rostock on 2 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The police estimated that approximately 2,500 of the 25,000 participants at the international demonstration in Rostock on 2 June 2007 were ready to use violence.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The police estimated that there would be around 15,000 demonstrators present during the G8 summit in Heiligendamm.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The police estimated that approximately 1,500 of the 15,000 demonstrators present during the G8 summit would be ready to use violence.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 2 June 2007 serious riots broke out in Rostock city centre.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The riots in Rostock city centre on 2 June 2007 involved well-organised violent demonstrators forming what has been termed a 'black block'.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The violent demonstrators forming the 'black block' attacked the police with stones and baseball bats during the riots in Rostock city centre on 2 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "400 policemen were injured during the riots in Rostock city centre on 2 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to a press release of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Ministry of the Interior dated 28 June 2007, some 17,000 police officers had been involved in ensuring that the G8 summit could be held without disruption.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to a press release of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Ministry of the Interior dated 28 June 2007, some 17,000 police officers had been involved in protecting the G8 summit participants from attacks by terrorists or anti-globalisation demonstrators prepared to use violence.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "During the G8 summit, 1,112 people had been detained in holding pens for prisoners (Gefangenensammelstellen).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The courts had been asked to confirm the detention of 628 detainees held during the G8 summit.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The courts confirmed the detention of 113 individuals out of the 628 cases submitted for judicial confirmation during the G8 summit.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "1. The authorities' assessment of the security situation and the security measures taken during the G8 summit"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "In June 2007 the applicants drove to Rostock in order to participate in demonstrations against the G8 summit in Heiligendamm.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "2. The applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 3 June 2007 at around 10.15 p.m. the applicants' identity was checked and established by the police in a car park in front of Waldeck prison.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "2. The applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "At the time of the identity check on 3 June 2007, the applicants were standing next to a van in the company of seven other people in the car park in front of Waldeck prison.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "2. The applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "No other people were present in the car park in front of Waldeck prison at the time of the identity check on 3 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "2. The applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The police submitted that the first applicant had physically resisted the identity check on 3 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "2. The applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The police submitted that the first applicant had hit the arms of a policeman who had attempted to determine the second applicant's identity during the identity check on 3 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "2. The applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The police submitted that the first applicant had kicked another policeman's shin in order to prevent his own identity from being determined during the identity check on 3 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "2. The applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicants submitted that the second applicant had been hit by the police during the identity check on 3 June 2007, although he had already been holding his identity card in his hand ready for inspection.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "2. The applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The police searched the van in the car park in front of Waldeck prison on 3 June 2007 and found folded-up banners bearing the inscription 'Freedom for all prisoners'.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "2. The applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The police searched the van in the car park in front of Waldeck prison on 3 June 2007 and found folded-up banners bearing the inscription 'Free all now'.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "2. The applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicants were arrested on 3 June 2007 following the identity check and search of the van in front of Waldeck prison.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "2. The applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The banners found in the van in front of Waldeck prison on 3 June 2007 appear to have been seized by the police.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case", "2. The applicants' arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 4 June 2007 at 4.20 a.m. the Rostock District Court, having examined the first applicant in person, ordered the first applicant's detention (amtlicher Gewahrsam) until 9 June 2007, 12 noon at the latest.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "1. The proceedings before the District Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 4 June 2007 at 4 a.m. the Rostock District Court, having examined the second applicant in person, ordered the second applicant's detention (amtlicher Gewahrsam) until 9 June 2007, 12 noon at the latest.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "1. The proceedings before the District Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Rostock District Court relied on section 55(1), paragraph 2(a), of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA) in ordering the applicants' detention.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "1. The proceedings before the District Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Rostock District Court relied on section 56(5) of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA) in ordering the applicants' detention.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "1. The proceedings before the District Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Rostock District Court found that the applicants' detention had been lawful in order to prevent the imminent commission or continuation of a criminal offence.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "1. The proceedings before the District Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Rostock District Court found that, as the applicants had been found in front of Waldeck prison in a van in which objects calling for the liberation of prisoners had been discovered, it had to be assumed that they had been about to commit or aid and abet a criminal offence.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "1. The proceedings before the District Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Rostock District Court found that the applicants' continued detention was indispensable and proportionate.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "1. The proceedings before the District Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "At the hearing before the Rostock District Court, both applicants had given the impression that they had intended to proceed with committing an offence.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "1. The proceedings before the District Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "At the hearing before the Rostock District Court, the applicants had not made any statements or submissions on the merits and had therefore been unable to justify their conduct.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "1. The proceedings before the District Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 4 June 2007 the Rostock Regional Court dismissed the appeal (sofortige Beschwerde) lodged by the first applicant against the Rostock District Court's detention order.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "2. The proceedings before the Regional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 4 June 2007 the Rostock Regional Court dismissed the appeal (sofortige Beschwerde) lodged by the second applicant against the Rostock District Court's detention order.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "2. The proceedings before the Regional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Rostock Regional Court confirmed the Rostock District Court's finding that the applicants' arrest had been lawful under section 55(1), paragraph 2(a), of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "2. The proceedings before the Regional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Rostock Regional Court found that, as the applicants had been found in the vicinity of Waldeck prison in possession of banners with an imperative wording ('free'), they had intended to incite others to free prisoners, which constituted an offence.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "2. The proceedings before the Regional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Rostock Regional Court found, having regard to the material in the case file, that the first applicant had obstructed police officers in the exercise of their duties.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "2. The proceedings before the Regional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Rostock Regional Court noted that the second applicant had been charged with dangerous interference with rail traffic in 2002 in connection with the transport of 'castor' containers.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "2. The proceedings before the Regional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Rostock Regional Court agreed with the Rostock District Court's reasoning that the continuation of the applicants' detention was indispensable and proportionate.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "2. The proceedings before the Regional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 7 June 2007 the Rostock Court of Appeal dismissed further appeals (sofortige weitere Beschwerde) brought by the applicants against the Rostock Regional Court's decisions.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In their further appeals before the Rostock Court of Appeal, the applicants, represented by counsel, submitted that the slogans on the banners had been addressed to the police and the authorities, urging them to end the numerous arrests and detentions of demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In their further appeals before the Rostock Court of Appeal, the applicants submitted that the slogans on the banners had not been meant to call upon others to attack prisons and to free prisoners by force.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "In their further appeals before the Rostock Court of Appeal, the applicants submitted that the interpretation that the banners called for attacking prisons and freeing prisoners by force had to be considered far-fetched, given that there had not been any violent liberation of detainees from German prisons in recent decades.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal upheld the lower courts' finding that the requirements of section 55(1), paragraph 2(a), of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA) had been met.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal found that the applicants' arrest and continued detention was indispensable in order to avert a danger to public security and order.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal found that the banner 'Free all now', together with the banner 'Freedom for all prisoners', could be understood as an incitement to liberate prisoners, an offence under Article 120 of the German Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal found that the police had been entitled to assume that the applicants had intended to drive to Rostock and display the banners at the partly violent demonstrations there.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal found that displaying the banners at the partly violent demonstrations in Rostock might have incited a crowd ready to use violence to liberate people who had been arrested and detained.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal found that the requirements of section 55(1), paragraph 2(c), of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA) had also been met in respect of the second applicant.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal noted that the second applicant had been arrested in 2002 in comparable circumstances on suspicion of dangerous interference with rail traffic in connection with the transport of castor containers.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal found it irrelevant whether the second applicant had subsequently been convicted following his 2002 arrest.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal noted that the applicants had not contested the courts' conclusions and had not made any statements or submissions on the merits.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal noted that the police had been obliged to take into consideration the general security situation in Rostock on 2 and 3 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal noted that on 2 and 3 June 2007 very violent clashes between demonstrators and the police had taken place in Rostock city centre.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal found that the applicants had proved to be prone to violence themselves by attacking police officers.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal considered that the applicants' right to freedom of expression under the German Basic Law did not warrant a different conclusion regarding the lawfulness of their detention.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal accepted that the slogans on the banners could be understood in different ways.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal found that in the tense situation in and around Rostock the police had been authorised to prevent ambiguous declarations which could have led to a risk to public security and order.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal found that the duration of the applicants' detention was proportionate.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "According to a report by the Rostock police of 6 June 2007, between 6,000 and 10,000 anti-globalisation activists, some of whom were very violent, were moving towards Heiligendamm and were calling for an 'attack on the embankment'.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Rostock Court of Appeal found that it could not be ruled out that the applicants would have participated in the demonstrations moving towards Heiligendamm with the banners and would thus have incited other demonstrators to liberate prisoners.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "3. The proceedings before the Court of Appeal"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 6 June 2007 the first applicant lodged a constitutional complaint with the Federal Constitutional Court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 6 June 2007 the second applicant lodged a constitutional complaint with the Federal Constitutional Court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 6 June 2007 both applicants applied to the Federal Constitutional Court for an interim injunction ordering their immediate release.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The applicants complained before the Federal Constitutional Court that their detention had violated their right to liberty.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The applicants complained before the Federal Constitutional Court that their detention had violated their right to freedom of expression.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The second applicant submitted before the Federal Constitutional Court that his detention had been in breach of his right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Both applicants argued before the Federal Constitutional Court that it had been far-fetched to interpret the slogans on the banners as inciting other demonstrators to attack prisons and to liberate prisoners.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The applicants submitted before the Federal Constitutional Court that the banners had been addressed to the police, who had already arrested many anti-globalisation activists, to the participants in the G8 summit and to the public in general, and had not advocated acts of violence.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The applicants submitted before the Federal Constitutional Court that they did not have any previous convictions.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The second applicant submitted before the Federal Constitutional Court that the criminal proceedings against him for dangerous interference with rail traffic had been discontinued.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The first applicant's constitutional complaint was initially registered at the Federal Constitutional Court under file no. 2 BvR 1195/07.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The second applicant's constitutional complaint was initially registered at the Federal Constitutional Court under file no. 2 BvR 1196/07.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "On 8 June 2007 the reporting judge at the Federal Constitutional Court informed the applicants' representatives by telephone that the Federal Constitutional Court would not take a decision on the applicants' request for interim measures.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "On 9 June 2007 at 12 noon the applicants were released from prison.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Following the applicants' release from prison on 9 June 2007, their constitutional complaints of 6 June 2007 were considered to have become devoid of purpose.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 6 July 2007 the applicants asked the Federal Constitutional Court to find that their detention had been unconstitutional, despite the fact that they had been released in the meantime.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Following the applicants' request of 6 July 2007, the first applicant's constitutional complaint was registered anew at the Federal Constitutional Court under file no. 2 BvR 1521/07.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Following the applicants' request of 6 July 2007, the second applicant's constitutional complaint was registered anew at the Federal Constitutional Court under file no. 2 BvR 1520/07.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "On 6 August 2007 the Federal Constitutional Court, in two separate decisions, declined to consider the first applicant's constitutional complaint (file no. 2 BvR 1521/07) without giving reasons.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "On 6 August 2007 the Federal Constitutional Court, in two separate decisions, declined to consider the second applicant's constitutional complaint (file no. 2 BvR 1520/07) without giving reasons.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The Federal Constitutional Court's decision of 6 August 2007 was served on the first applicant's counsel on 14 August 2007.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The Federal Constitutional Court's decision of 6 August 2007 was served on the second applicant's counsel on 13 August 2007.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings at issue", "4. The proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The criminal proceedings instituted against the first applicant for having obstructed public officers in the exercise of their duties (Widerstand gegen Vollstreckungsbeamte) in the course of the identity check on 3 June 2007 were discontinued in exchange for the first applicant paying 200 euros (EUR).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The criminal proceedings against the second applicant for having obstructed public officers in the exercise of their duties (Widerstand gegen Vollstreckungsbeamte) in the course of the identity check on 3 June 2007 were discontinued on grounds of insignificance.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The applicants submitted that one of the police officers involved in their arrest had later been convicted of causing bodily harm while discharging public duties in relation to a different matter.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The applicants submitted that the proceedings against the police officer convicted of causing bodily harm while discharging public duties were still pending before the appellate court.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Government did not comment on the applicants' submission regarding the police officer convicted of causing bodily harm while discharging public duties.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "No criminal proceedings were brought against the applicants for having incited others to free prisoners.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "On 20 December 2007 the Rostock Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants' complaints of a violation of their right to be heard.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On 1 May 2008 the Federal Constitutional Court declined to consider the first applicant's fresh constitutional complaint (file no. 2 BvR 538/08).", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "On 3 May 2008 the Federal Constitutional Court declined to consider the second applicant's fresh constitutional complaint (file no. 2 BvR 164/08).", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "In their fresh constitutional complaints, the applicants had relied in particular on their rights to liberty, to freedom of expression and to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Section 55(1), paragraph 2, of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA) provides that a person may be detained if this is indispensable in order to prevent the imminent commission or continuation of a criminal offence.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (\"the PSOA\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Under section 55(1), paragraph 2(a), of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA), the assumption that a person will commit or aid and abet a criminal offence may be based on the fact that he or she has announced or incited the commission of the offence or carries banners or other items containing such incitement.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (\"the PSOA\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Under section 55(1), paragraph 2(c), of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA), the assumption that a person will commit or aid and abet a criminal offence may be based on the fact that he or she has been apprehended in the past on comparable grounds as a person involved in the commission of offences, and if facts warrant the conclusion that a repetition of this conduct is to be expected.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (\"the PSOA\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Section 56(5) of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA) provides that if the police take a person into custody, they must immediately obtain a judicial decision on the lawfulness and continuation of the detention.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (\"the PSOA\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Section 56(5) of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA) provides that the judicial decision must set a maximum duration of detention, which may not exceed ten days in cases governed by section 55(1), paragraph 2.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (\"the PSOA\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Section 56(5) of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA) provides that the District Court in the district in which the person concerned was arrested has jurisdiction to take the decision on the lawfulness and continuation of detention.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (\"the PSOA\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Under section 52 of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA), the authorities may order a person to leave a place or prohibit a person from going to a specific place (Platzverweisung) in order to avert a real danger.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (\"the PSOA\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Under section 52 of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA), if the facts warrant the conclusion that a person will commit an offence in a specific area, the person may be prohibited from entering that area for up to ten weeks.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (\"the PSOA\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Under section 61(1), paragraph 1, of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA), an item may only be seized in order to avert an imminent danger to public security or order.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (\"the PSOA\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Under section 61(1), paragraph 4, of the Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (the PSOA), an item may only be seized if the facts warrant the conclusion that it might be used in order to commit a criminal or regulatory offence.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Mecklenburg-West Pomerania Public Security and Order Act (\"the PSOA\")"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Section 120(1) of the German Criminal Code provides that anyone who frees a prisoner or incites or helps him to escape is to be punished by imprisonment of up to three years or a fine.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Section 120(3) of the German Criminal Code provides that an attempt to commit the offence of freeing a prisoner or inciting or helping him to escape is also punishable.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. The Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Sections 112 et seq. of the German Code of Criminal Procedure concern pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. The Code of Criminal Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Pursuant to section 112(1) of the German Code of Criminal Procedure, a defendant may be remanded in custody if there is a strong suspicion that he has committed a criminal offence and if there are grounds for arresting him.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. The Code of Criminal Procedure"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Pursuant to section 112(1) of the German Code of Criminal Procedure, pre-trial detention may not be ordered if it is disproportionate to the importance of the case and to the penalty or measure of correction and prevention expected to be imposed.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. The Code of Criminal Procedure"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_crime", "public_safety"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F005", "F012", "F013", "F015", "F016", "F022", "F025", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F037", "F038", "F054", "F055", "F067", "F070", "F083", "F088", "F097", "F098", "F102"], "interference": ["F037", "F038", "F088"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F039", "F107", "F108"], "legitimate_aim": ["F039", "F041", "F049", "F059", "F107", "F108", "F117"], "necessity": ["F012", "F013", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F022", "F025", "F033", "F034", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F054", "F055", "F059", "F061", "F067", "F070", "F074", "F088", "F102", "F113", "F115", "F116"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F005", "F012", "F013", "F016", "F025", "F035", "F037", "F038", "F054", "F055", "F070", "F083", "F088", "F102"], "interference": ["F037", "F038", "F088"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F039", "F107", "F108"], "legitimate_aim": ["F039", "F059", "F107", "F108", "F117"], "necessity": ["F022", "F025", "F033", "F034", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F054", "F055", "F070", "F088", "F102"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F025", "F033", "F034", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F070", "F088", "F102", "F022"]}} {"case_name": "case_563", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_566", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1957.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Yekaterinburg.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 18 March 2003, the applicant, Mr Sh., and Ms M. sent a notice to the head of Yekaterinburg town administration of their intention to stage a picket in front of the Sverdlovsk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The picket was planned to take place between 25 and 28 March 2003 between 9 and 11 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The declared purpose of the picket was 'to attract public attention to violations of the human right of access to a court'.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 19 March 2003, the head of the Committee for Public Relations and Mass Media of the Yekaterinburg town administration acknowledged receipt of the picket notice.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The head of the Committee for Public Relations and Mass Media of the Yekaterinburg town administration noted that, should the picket cause any inconvenience, such as blocking access to the court-house or impairing its normal functioning, the administration would have to intervene.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 20 March 2003, the head of the Yekaterinburg public security police ordered that the police should maintain public order and traffic safety during the picket.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 25 March 2003, the applicant and others held the picket in front of the Sverdlovsk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "During the picket on 25 March 2003, the applicant and others distributed press clippings and leaflets about Mr Ovcharuk, the President of the Sverdlovsk Regional Court, who had allegedly been involved in corruption scandals.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "During the picket on 25 March 2003, the applicant and others collected signatures for the dismissal of Mr Ovcharuk, the President of the Sverdlovsk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 27 March 2003, Mr Dementyev, the first deputy president of the Sverdlovsk Regional Court, sent a letter to the head of the Verkh-Issetskiy police department of Yekaterinburg.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "In his letter of 27 March 2003, Mr Dementyev stated that, with the consent of the Yekaterinburg town administration, a group of citizens comprising Mr Sh., Mr Kuznetsov (the applicant), and Ms M. held a picket in front of the building of the Sverdlovsk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "In his letter of 27 March 2003, Mr Dementyev stated that the picket notice indicated that the purpose of the picket was 'to attract public attention to violations of the human right of access to a court'.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "In his letter of 27 March 2003, Mr Dementyev stated that the picket organisers misled the officials of the Yekaterinburg town administration as to the real purposes of their action.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "In his letter of 27 March 2003, Mr Dementyev stated that instead of drawing public attention to the problems of judicial protection and violations of human rights as indicated in the picket notice, for three days the picket participants distributed printed leaflets and materials of a slanderous and insulting nature which targeted the president of the Sverdlovsk Regional Court personally.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "In his letter of 27 March 2003, Mr Dementyev stated that the information contained in the extract from the Novaya Gazeta newspaper was more than two years old.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In his letter of 27 March 2003, Mr Dementyev stated that the information in the Novaya Gazeta newspaper extract had been checked by the Supreme Qualification Panel of Judges and the Prosecutor General's Office and found to be slanderous.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "In his letter of 27 March 2003, Mr Dementyev stated that the picket participants, in particular Mr Sh. and Mr Kuznetsov (the applicant), were perfectly aware that the information in the Novaya Gazeta newspaper extract had been found to be slanderous.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "In his letter of 27 March 2003, Mr Dementyev stated that the picket organisers deliberately and maliciously changed the nature of the action and thereby misled the public.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "In his letter of 27 March 2003, Mr Dementyev stated that the picket organisers committed an administrative offence by violating section 4 of the Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council of 28 July 1988, as amended by the Presidential Decree of 25 May 1992.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "In his letter of 27 March 2003, Mr Dementyev stated that pursuant to section 8 of the Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council of 28 July 1988, Mr Sh., Mr Kuznetsov (the applicant), and Ms M. were administratively liable under Article 20.2 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "In his letter of 27 March 2003, Mr Dementyev asked the head of the Verkh-Issetskiy police department of Yekaterinburg to institute administrative proceedings against Mr Sh., Mr Kuznetsov (the applicant), and Ms M. in accordance with Article 28.3 § 2 (1) of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "In his letter of 27 March 2003, Mr Dementyev asked the head of the Verkh-Issetskiy police department of Yekaterinburg to prepare a report on an administrative offence and decide on the issue of the legal responsibility of Mr Sh., Mr Kuznetsov (the applicant), and Ms M. for the breach of law.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "In his letter of 27 March 2003, Mr Dementyev requested to be informed of the decision taken by the Verkh-Issetskiy police department of Yekaterinburg.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 17 April 2003, an official of the Verkh-Issetskiy police department of Yekaterinburg compiled a report on administrative offences committed by the applicant under Article 20.2 §§ 1 and 2 of the Code on Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the report of 17 April 2003, the applicant had given notice of the picket too late.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the report of 17 April 2003, the applicant had distributed leaflets of a slanderous and insulting nature against the president of the Sverdlovsk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the report of 17 April 2003, the applicant had obstructed the passage of citizens into the court-house of the Sverdlovsk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "Court bailiffs Mr R. and Mr M. were listed as eyewitnesses in the report of 17 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 21 April 2003, the head of the Verkh-Issetskiy police department forwarded the report on administrative offences and supplementary materials to the Verkh-Issetskiy District Court of Yekaterinburg.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The administrative offence matter was assigned to the justice of the peace of the 3rd Court Circuit of the Verkh-Issetskiy district of Yekaterinburg.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 15 May 2003, the applicant challenged the judicial formation and requested that the matter be examined in a neighbouring region.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The applicant claimed that objective examination of the matter in Yekaterinburg was impossible because it had been initiated at the instigation of high-ranking officials of the Sverdlovsk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The justice of the peace dismissed the applicant's challenge, holding that under the Code on Administrative Offences there were no legal grounds to change the venue.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 19 May 2003, the justice of the peace issued a ruling on an administrative offence (постановление по делу об административном правонарушении) in which she found the applicant guilty on three counts.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The justice of the peace held that the applicant had breached the established procedure for organising a picket by sending the picket notice eight days before the picket date.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The justice of the peace held that both the 1988 USSR Supreme Council's Decree and the local Yekaterinburg regulation on public assemblies established a ten-day notification period for pickets.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The justice of the peace found the applicant guilty of breaching public order during the picket, relying on the report on an administrative offence dated 17 April 2003.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Witnesses Mr M. and Mr R. testified in court that they worked as court bailiffs in the Sverdlovsk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "Witnesses Mr M. and Mr R. testified that at about 9.10 a.m. on 25 March 2003 they had gone onto the porch of the Sverdlovsk Regional Court and seen some people with banners, among them Mr Kuznetsov (the applicant) holding the banner 'Ovcharuk – resign'.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Witnesses Mr M. and Mr R. testified that the picket participants were standing on the porch right in front of the entrance on the top floor, blocking the passage and distributing leaflets.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Witnesses Mr M. and Mr R. testified that when they asked the picket participants to show their identity documents and go down the stairs, the participants refused, but went down after a police officer approached them.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Witnesses Mr M. and Mr R. testified that judges coming to work had told them that the picket participants had blocked access to the Sverdlovsk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The justice of the peace relied on the report by court bailiff Mr R. of 25 March 2003 as evidence of the applicant's guilt.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The justice of the peace relied on the report by police officer Mr G. from the Verkh-Issetskiy police station, which indicated that between 25 and 28 March 2003 he had been responsible for public order during the picket in front of the Sverdlovsk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Police officer Mr G.'s report stated that the picket had been organised by Mr Kuznetsov (the applicant), Mr Sh., and Ms M., who at 9 a.m. on the day of the picket were standing on the staircase at the entrance to the Sverdlovsk Regional Court and thus obstructing access to the building.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "Police officer Mr G.'s report stated that following his intervention and that of the court bailiffs, the picket participants went down to the pavement in front of the court-house and did not subsequently interfere with the normal functioning of the Sverdlovsk Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The justice of the peace did not accept the arguments by the applicant's representative that the applicant did not block access to the Sverdlovsk Regional Court, because those arguments contradicted the evidence already examined in court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The justice of the peace noted that the defence witnesses were present at the picket from 9.30 a.m., by which time the picket participants had already descended the staircase on orders of the police officer and were no longer blocking access.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The justice of the peace held that photographs produced by the defence and examined in court could not prove that the applicant did not block access to the court-house, because they depicted solely the moment when they were taken rather than the entire time during which the picket had been held, and because the court did not know when the photographs were taken.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The justice of the peace found that the picket had been conducted at variance with the aims listed in the notice.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "According to the notice dated 18 March 2003, the initiative group of citizens comprising Mr Sh., Mr Kuznetsov (the applicant), and Ms M. held a protest action against violations of citizens' right to judicial protection.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The applicant's representative explained in court that the picket aimed at attracting public attention to the problems of judicial protection, such as refusals to accept a claim or unfair judgments.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Witness Mr M. stated that he had brought and distributed a newspaper describing certain instances in which citizens' rights to judicial protection had been breached.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The picket participants distributed extracts from the Novaya Gazeta newspaper containing A. Politkovskaya's article 'Ovcharuk and his team', which in its contents did not correspond to the aims of the picket as stated in the notice.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The distribution of the Novaya Gazeta newspaper extracts was not contested by the applicant's representative in court and was also confirmed by witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The justice of the peace declared the applicant guilty under Article 20.2 §§ 1 and 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The justice of the peace fined the applicant 1,000 Russian roubles (approximately 35 euros).", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 11 July 2003, the Verkh-Issetskiy District Court of Yekaterinburg, on an appeal by the applicant, upheld the ruling of the justice of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Verkh-Issetskiy District Court of Yekaterinburg endorsed the reasons given by the justice of the peace in upholding the ruling.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The judgment of the Verkh-Issetskiy District Court of Yekaterinburg of 11 July 2003 was final as no further ordinary appeal lay against it.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Russian Constitution guarantees the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and the right to hold meetings, demonstrations, marches and pickets under Article 31.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988 was in force at the material time pursuant to Presidential Decree no. 524 of 25 May 1992.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Under section 2 of the Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988, organisers of an assembly were required to give written notice to the municipal authorities no later than ten days before the planned assembly.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Under section 3 of the Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988, the municipal authority was required to give its response no later than five days before the assembly.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Under section 4 of the Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988, assemblies were to be conducted in accordance with the aims listed in the notice and with respect for Soviet laws and public order.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Under section 8 of the Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Council no. 9306-XI of 28 July 1988, individuals who breached the established procedure for organising and holding assemblies incurred liability under the laws of the USSR and Soviet republics.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Article 20.2 § 1 of the Code on Administrative Offences provides that a breach of the established procedure for organising a demonstration, meeting, procession or picket shall be punishable by a fine of ten to twenty times the minimum monthly wage, which was 1,000 to 2,000 Russian roubles at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code on Administrative Offences stipulates that a breach of the established procedure for holding a demonstration, meeting or picket shall be punishable by a fine of ten to twenty times the minimum wage for organisers, or five to ten times the minimum wage for participants.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F006", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F037", "F043", "F048", "F050", "F056"], "interference": ["F009", "F026", "F058", "F059", "F060"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F058", "F069", "F070"], "legitimate_aim": ["F026", "F058"], "necessity": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F008", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F026", "F037", "F038", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F047", "F048", "F050", "F052", "F056", "F060", "F061", "F065"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F009", "F010", "F043", "F048"], "interference": ["F058", "F059", "F060"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F069", "F070"], "legitimate_aim": ["F026"], "necessity": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F008", "F010", "F012", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F026", "F043", "F048", "F050", "F052", "F060", "F061", "F065"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F012", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F026", "F043", "F048", "F050", "F052", "F058", "F059", "F060", "F061", "F065"]}} {"case_name": "case_568", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_569", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "On different dates, the applicants were taken to police stations.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants were taken to police stations as administrative suspects of offences related to public events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants were subsequently administratively convicted for participation in different public events in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants complained of unlawful detention (deprivation of liberty).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F003", "F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004"], "interference": ["F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F004"]}} {"case_name": "case_571", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1979.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Odessa.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant is a vice-president of Zelyonka (Зелёнка), a non-governmental youth organisation.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant is a member of the Odessa City Council.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 17 March 2009 the applicant, acting on behalf of Zelyonka, notified the Odessa City Mayor of the organisation's intention to hold a peaceful assembly (picket) in front of the Odessa City Council building on 19 March 2009 from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 17 March 2009 the applicant, acting on behalf of Zelyonka, notified the Head of the Prymorsky District Police Department of Odessa of the organisation's intention to hold a peaceful assembly (picket) in front of the Odessa City Council building on 19 March 2009 from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The declared purpose of the planned assembly on 19 March 2009 was to demand the completion of the construction of residential buildings contracted by the Odessa City Council's Department of Construction.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "By a letter dated 17 March 2009, the Odessa City Council informed the applicant that holding a picket with such short notice was liable to be considered unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Odessa City Council's letter of 17 March 2009 indicated that, pursuant to the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organisation and holding of meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR (the 1988 Decree), notification had to be given no later than ten days prior to the meeting in question.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Odessa City Council's letter of 17 March 2009 indicated that the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, in its decision of 19 April 2001, had held that the organisers of peaceful assemblies must inform the authorities in advance of their intention to hold a meeting.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Odessa City Council's letter of 17 March 2009 mentioned that no implementing law in respect of the right to peaceful assembly had yet been enacted in Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Odessa City Council's letter of 17 March 2009 mentioned that the 1988 Decree (Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organisation and holding of meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR) was still in force.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Odessa City Council's letter of 17 March 2009 informed the applicant that untimely notification about the picket could be considered a violation of the procedure for holding meetings under paragraph 2 of the 1988 Decree (Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Odessa City Council's letter of 17 March 2009 informed the applicant that the person responsible for untimely notification could be held administratively liable under Article 185-1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The picket took place as planned between 11 a.m. and 1 p.m. on 19 March 2009.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the applicant, the picket on 19 March 2009 was peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the applicant, only a few people took part in the picket on 19 March 2009.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The police report of 19 March 2009 noted that about 250 persons had taken part in the picket.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The police report of 19 March 2009 noted that there had been no violation of public order during the picket.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 4 April 2009 a police officer of the Prymorsky District Police Department of Odessa drew up an administrative offence report in the applicant's presence.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The administrative offence report of 4 April 2009 indicated that on 19 March 2009 the applicant had organised and held a picket in violation of Article 185-1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The administrative offence report of 4 April 2009 indicated that on 19 March 2009 the applicant had organised and held a picket in violation of the decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant signed the administrative offence report of 4 April 2009, adding a note to the effect that he considered his actions lawful.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The administrative offence report of 4 April 2009 was referred to a court.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 15 May 2009 the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa examined the applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the record of the hearing provided by the Government, the questioning at the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa on 15 May 2009 took place between 1.24 and 1.34 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "After the questioning on 15 May 2009, the judge of the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa retired to the deliberations chamber.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "At 2.27 p.m. on 15 May 2009 the judge of the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa publicly pronounced judgment.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The hearing at the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa on 15 May 2009 closed at 2.32 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the Government, the full text of the judgment of the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa of 15 May 2009 was pronounced publicly.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the Government, three hours after the judgment of 15 May 2009 was pronounced, the court clerk of the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa handed a hard copy of the judgment to the applicant's representative.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the applicant, the judgment of the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa of 15 May 2009 was not pronounced in public but given to his representative in writing three hours after the end of the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "In its judgment of 15 May 2009, the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa found that the applicant had violated public order by failing to give the Odessa City Council sufficient advance notification of the picket he had organised.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "In its judgment of 15 May 2009, the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa found the applicant guilty of having violated the procedure for organising and holding meetings and demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "In its judgment of 15 May 2009, the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa fined the applicant 170 Ukrainian hryvnias (UAH) (approximately 17 euros (EUR)).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Prymorsky District Court of Odessa held that the applicant was in breach of Article 185-1 of the Code of Administrative Offences because he had not complied with the ten-day notification requirement.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Prymorsky District Court of Odessa based its findings on the 1988 Decree (Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988), which provided that an application to hold an assembly had to be lodged with the relevant authority at least ten days in advance.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Prymorsky District Court of Odessa referred to the decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001 and noted that the exact time-limits for notification were to be regulated by law.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Prymorsky District Court of Odessa indicated that the 1988 Decree (Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988) was valid in Ukraine under the Resolution of the Ukrainian Parliament (Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine) on temporary application of certain legislative acts of the Soviet Union.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Prymorsky District Court of Odessa pointed to the fact that the applicant had been informed by the Odessa City Council that the notification he had given was liable to be regarded as contrary to the requirements of the legislation and had been warned that he could incur administrative liability.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 25 May 2009 the applicant appealed against the judgment of the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa of 15 May 2009.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "In his appeal of 25 May 2009, the applicant argued that the 1988 Decree (Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988), on which the first-instance court had based its decision, was invalid and contrary to the Constitution of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "In his appeal of 25 May 2009, the applicant noted that the 1988 Decree provided that persons wishing to hold a peaceful assembly had to seek permission, whereas the Constitution of Ukraine provided only that the authorities had to be notified of an intention to hold such an assembly.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "In his appeal of 25 May 2009, the applicant noted that Article 92 of the Constitution of Ukraine provided that human rights guarantees had to be regulated exclusively by laws.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "In his appeal of 25 May 2009, the applicant noted that Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine provided that restrictions on the right to peaceful assembly could be established only by law, whereas the 1988 Decree was not a law of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In his appeal of 25 May 2009, the applicant noted that at the time of the picket there had been no judicial decision restricting the picket as required by Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In his appeal of 25 May 2009, the applicant contended that his punishment violated Article 11 of the Convention and was not necessary as the picket had been peaceful and had not violated public order.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "In his appeal of 25 May 2009, the applicant complained that the judgment of the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa had not been pronounced publicly, which was contrary to Article 285 of the Code of Administrative Offences and to Article 6 § 1 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 16 July 2009 the Odessa Regional Court of Appeal ruled in the presence of the applicant and his representative.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 16 July 2009 the Odessa Regional Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa of 15 May 2009.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The ruling of the Odessa Regional Court of Appeal of 16 July 2009 contained a summary of the facts of the case, outlined the applicant's arguments, and included an analysis of the pertinent legislation in line with that of the first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Odessa Regional Court of Appeal pointed out that the applicant had been punished not for breaching the procedure for holding an assembly but for violating the established procedure for organising it.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Odessa Regional Court of Appeal did not address the applicant's complaint that the judgment of the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa had not been pronounced publicly.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The applicant has not paid the fine of 170 Ukrainian hryvnias (UAH) imposed by the Prymorsky District Court of Odessa.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Article 22 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that human and citizens' rights and freedoms affirmed by the Constitution are not exhaustive.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Article 22 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that constitutional rights and freedoms are guaranteed and shall not be abolished.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Article 22 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that the content and scope of existing rights and freedoms shall not be diminished by the enactment of new laws or the amendment of laws that are in force.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that citizens have the right to assemble peacefully without arms and to hold meetings, rallies, marches and demonstrations, after notifying the executive authorities and bodies of local self-government beforehand.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that restrictions on the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly may be established by a court in accordance with the law, in the interests of national security and public order only, for the purpose of preventing disturbances or crimes, protecting the health of the population, or protecting the rights and freedoms of other persons.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Article 92(1) of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that human and citizens' rights and freedoms, the guarantees of these rights and freedoms, and the main duties of the citizen are determined exclusively by the laws of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Chapter XV (Transitional Provisions) of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that laws and other normative acts enacted prior to the entry into force of the Constitution shall apply in so far as they do not conflict with the Constitution of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Article 185-1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provides that a breach of the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations shall be punishable by a reprimand or by a fine of between ten and twenty-five times the minimum monthly wage.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO)"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Article 185-1 of the Code of Administrative Offences provides that the same actions committed within a year of the application of administrative penalties or by the organiser of the meeting, rally, street procession or demonstration shall be punishable by a fine of between twenty and one hundred times the minimum monthly wage, or by correctional labour of one to two months with a deduction of 20% of earnings, or by administrative detention of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO)"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Article 285 of the Code of Administrative Offences provides that a decision regarding an administrative offence shall be pronounced immediately after the examination of the case.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO)"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Article 285 of the Code of Administrative Offences provides that within three days a copy of the decision regarding an administrative offence shall be given or sent to the person concerned.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code of Administrative Offences (the CAO)"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR (the 1988 Decree) lays down the procedure for seeking and granting permission to organise and hold meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR (the 1988 Decree)"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The 1988 Decree provides that an application to hold a meeting, rally, street procession or demonstration shall be submitted to the executive committee of the appropriate local Soviet of people's deputies.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR (the 1988 Decree)"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The 1988 Decree provides that an application to hold a meeting, rally, street procession or demonstration shall be submitted in writing no later than ten days before the planned date of the event in question.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR (the 1988 Decree)"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The 1988 Decree provides that the executive committee of the Soviet of people's deputies shall examine the application and notify the representatives (organisers) of its decision no later than five days prior to the date of the event mentioned in the application.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR (the 1988 Decree)"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The 1988 Decree provides that the executive committee of the Soviet of people's deputies shall ban a meeting, rally, street procession or demonstration if the goal of the event is contrary to the Constitution of the USSR, the constitutions of the Republics of the Union or of the autonomous republics, or poses a threat to public order and the safety of citizens.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR (the 1988 Decree)"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Resolution of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine of 12 September 1991 on temporary application of certain legislative acts of the Soviet Union provides that, before the relevant legislation of Ukraine is enacted, the legislation of the USSR is applicable within the territory of Ukraine in respect of issues that have not been regulated by the legislation of Ukraine and in so far as they do not contravene the Constitution and legislation of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. The Resolution of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine of 12 September 1991 on temporary application of certain legislative acts of the Soviet Union"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "In its decision of 19 April 2001, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine considered an application by the Ministry of the Interior of Ukraine for an official interpretation of the provisions of Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine regarding timely notification to executive authorities or bodies of local self-government of planned meetings, rallies, marches or demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "1. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001 in a case regarding timely notification of a peaceful assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Ukraine's decision of 19 April 2001 noted that the current legislation of Ukraine does not provide for a specific time-limit within which the executive authorities or bodies of local self-government are to be notified about planned meetings, rallies, marches or demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "1. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001 in a case regarding timely notification of a peaceful assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "In its decision of 19 April 2001, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine held that the provisions of Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine on timely notification to executive authorities or bodies of local self-government about planned meetings, rallies, marches or demonstrations shall be understood to mean that organisers must inform the above-mentioned authorities in advance, that is, within a reasonable time prior to the date of the planned event.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "1. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001 in a case regarding timely notification of a peaceful assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Ukraine's decision of 19 April 2001 held that the notification time-limits should not restrict the right of citizens under Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine, but should serve as a guarantee of this right and at the same time provide the relevant executive authorities or bodies of local self-government with an opportunity to take measures to ensure that citizens may freely hold meetings, rallies, marches and demonstrations and to protect public order and the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "1. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001 in a case regarding timely notification of a peaceful assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Ukraine's decision of 19 April 2001 held that specifying the exact deadlines for timely notification with regard to the particularities of different forms of peaceful assembly, the number of participants, the venue, and the time of the event is a matter for legislative regulation.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "1. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001 in a case regarding timely notification of a peaceful assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 21 May 2012 the Plenary of the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine, by its Decree No. 6, decided to send the Information Note of April 2012 on a study and summary of the jurisprudence of administrative courts applying the relevant legislation and deciding cases concerning the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly in 2010 and 2011 for information to the judges of lower administrative courts.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "2. Information note of April 2012 by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine on a study and summary of the jurisprudence of administrative courts applying the relevant legislation and deciding cases concerning the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly (meetings, rallies, marches, demonstrations, etc.) in 2010 and 2011."]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Information Note of April 2012 of the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine stated that judicial practice contained instances of cases restricting the right to peaceful assembly being decided on the basis of the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations laid down by the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 No. 9306-XI, and that this approach is incorrect.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "2. Information note of April 2012 by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine on a study and summary of the jurisprudence of administrative courts applying the relevant legislation and deciding cases concerning the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly (meetings, rallies, marches, demonstrations, etc.) in 2010 and 2011."]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Information Note of April 2012 of the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine stated that the norms of the 1988 Decree establish the procedure for authorising (registering) peaceful assembly and empower the authorities and bodies of local self-government to ban such events, whereas the norms of the Constitution of Ukraine provide for a procedure whereby the authorities are notified that a gathering is to be held and provide that only the courts have power to ban a peaceful gathering.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "2. Information note of April 2012 by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine on a study and summary of the jurisprudence of administrative courts applying the relevant legislation and deciding cases concerning the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly (meetings, rallies, marches, demonstrations, etc.) in 2010 and 2011."]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Information Note of April 2012 of the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine stated that the 1988 Decree (Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988) should not be applied by courts when deciding cases concerning the right to peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "2. Information note of April 2012 by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine on a study and summary of the jurisprudence of administrative courts applying the relevant legislation and deciding cases concerning the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly (meetings, rallies, marches, demonstrations, etc.) in 2010 and 2011."]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "In a judgment of 30 March 2007 in the case of S. v. the Executive Committee of the Dnipropetrovs'k City Council, the Babushkinsky District Court of Dnipropetrovs'k held that the procedures for exercising the right to freedom of assembly and the procedures and grounds for restricting the right were not regulated by Ukrainian legislation.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "In its judgment of 30 March 2007 in the case of S. v. the Executive Committee of the Dnipropetrovs'k City Council, the Babushkinsky District Court of Dnipropetrovs'k held that the Dnipropetrovs'k City Council had no grounds for adopting the impugned regulation on holding mass events in the city of Dnipropetrovs'k, which would interfere with the rights of citizens.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "In a judgment of 29 November 2011, the Kyiv Administrative Court restricted the right of several non-governmental organisations and private persons to hold a demonstration on account, in particular, of their failure to notify the Kyiv City State Administration of their intention ten days in advance.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "In its judgment of 29 November 2011, the Kyiv Administrative Court referred to the 1988 Decree (Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The participants in the demonstration appealed against the Kyiv Administrative Court's judgment of 29 November 2011.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On 16 May 2012 the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal quashed the judgment of the Kyiv Administrative Court of 29 November 2011.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "In its decision of 16 May 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal noted that the 1988 Decree conflicted with the Constitution of Ukraine as it required the organisers to seek permission to hold a demonstration and authorised the executive authorities to ban such an event, whereas Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine provided that the authorities should be notified that a demonstration was being planned and empowered only the judicial authorities to place restrictions on the organisation thereof.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "In its decision of 16 May 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal noted that in its decision of 19 April 2001 the Constitutional Court of Ukraine had not referred to the 1988 Decree as a normative act which should apply in Ukraine to the legal relations under consideration.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "In its decision of 16 May 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal noted that the file contained no documents proving that notification about the demonstration less than 10 days in advance had not allowed the police to ensure public order during the demonstration and that the holding of such an event could create a real risk of riots or crimes or endanger the health of the population and imperil the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "In its decision of 16 May 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal concluded that the judgment of the Kyiv Administrative Court of 29 November 2011 was incompatible with Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine and Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "In a decision of 11 October 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal quashed a judgment of the Kyiv Administrative Court which had restricted the freedom of peaceful assembly in respect of a number of political and non-governmental organisations upon an application by the Kyiv City State Administration.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "In its decision of 11 October 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal noted that in deciding the case the first-instance court (Kyiv Administrative Court) had had regard to the provisions of the 1988 Decree (Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988), whereas since 1996 the question of holding peaceful gatherings had been regulated by the Constitution of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "In its decision of 11 October 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal stated that the 1988 Decree conflicted with the Constitution of Ukraine as it provided for a procedure for seeking permission to hold a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "In its decision of 11 October 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal stated that the 1988 Decree concerned the holding of demonstrations in a non-existent country (the USSR), regulated relations between the citizens of the USSR and the executive committees of the Soviets of People's Deputies, and considered demonstrations on the basis of their compatibility with the Constitution of the USSR and the constitutions of the union and autonomous republics, that is, non-existent constitutions of non-existent subjects.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "In its decision of 11 October 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal noted that under the Constitution of Ukraine human rights and freedoms, and the relevant safeguards, could be defined only by the laws of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. Domestic case-law", "3. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Other relevant domestic law and practice and relevant international documents concerning the right to peaceful assembly can be found in the case of Vyerentsov v. Ukraine (application no. 20372/11, paragraphs 26, 32, 33 and 38 to 43, judgment of 11 April 2013).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL AND DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Other relevant international and domestic law and practice"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F005", "F015", "F016", "F019", "F034"], "interference": ["F034", "F035", "F050"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F011", "F036", "F037", "F050", "F058", "F059", "F060", "F062", "F066", "F067", "F068", "F070", "F071", "F073", "F076", "F078", "F079", "F081", "F083", "F086", "F087", "F094"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F005", "F015", "F016", "F019"], "interference": ["F034", "F035"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F058", "F060", "F062", "F066", "F068", "F070", "F071", "F073", "F076", "F078", "F094"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F015", "F034", "F035", "F058", "F060", "F062", "F068", "F070", "F071", "F073", "F076", "F078"]}} {"case_name": "case_572", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' details are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The Government were represented by Mr G. Matyushkin, Representative of the Russian Federation at the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr A. Fedorov, Head of the Office of the Representative of the Russian Federation at the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr M. Galperin, Representative of the Russian Federation at the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On the dates indicated in the appended table, the applicants participated in various political demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicants were apprehended at the venue of the demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicants were transferred to various police stations in Moscow or St Petersburg after being apprehended.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Administrative records were drawn up at the police stations in Moscow or St Petersburg to which the applicants were transferred.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The records of the administrative offence were based on the reports and explanations of the police officers who had arrested the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Some of the applicants were released several hours after being taken to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Some of the applicants spent the night at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On the dates stipulated in the appended table, the applicants were convicted under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, which concerns a refusal to obey the lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Some of the applicants were ordered to pay fines ranging between 500 Russian roubles (RUB) and RUB 1,000.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Some of the applicants were sentenced to administrative imprisonment for three to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The specific sentences imposed on each applicant are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The domestic courts relied on the administrative records, the reports and explanations of the police officers when convicting the applicants under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The domestic courts considered it unlawful that some of the applicants shouted slogans during a public assembly in respect of which no advance notification had been submitted to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The domestic courts considered it unlawful that some of the applicants refused to stop participating in a public assembly in respect of which no advance notification had been submitted to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law, see Navalnyy v. Russia [GC] (application nos. 29580/12 and 4 others, §§ 46-47, judgment of 15 November 2018).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The domestic legal provisions governing administrative transfer (escorting) and detention are set out in the case of Butkevich v. Russia (application no. 5865/07, §§ 33-36, judgment of 13 February 2018).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F018", "F019"], "interference": ["F007", "F008", "F013", "F014", "F015"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F006", "F007", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F018", "F019"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F018", "F019"], "interference": ["F007", "F013", "F015"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F006", "F013", "F015", "F018", "F019"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F006", "F007", "F013", "F015", "F018", "F019"]}} {"case_name": "case_577", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1953.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1964.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1951.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The fourth applicant was born in 1960.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The fifth applicant was born in 1956.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants live in Musomishta, Koprivlen, Sandanski and Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "All five applicants are members of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden – Party for Economic Development and Integration of the Population (UMO Ilinden – PIRIN).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "All five applicants are followers of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden – Party for Economic Development and Integration of the Population (UMO Ilinden – PIRIN).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "UMO Ilinden – PIRIN is a political party founded in 1998.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "UMO Ilinden – PIRIN is based in south-western Bulgaria, in an area known as the Pirin region or the geographic region of Pirin Macedonia.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "UMO Ilinden – PIRIN was declared unconstitutional by the Bulgarian Constitutional Court on 29 February 2000.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "As a result of being declared unconstitutional by the Bulgarian Constitutional Court, UMO Ilinden – PIRIN was dissolved.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "In a judgment of 20 October 2005, the Court (European Court of Human Rights) found that the dissolution of UMO Ilinden – PIRIN had been in breach of the party's right to freedom of association.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "In a judgment of 20 October 2005, the Court (European Court of Human Rights) found that the dissolution of UMO Ilinden – PIRIN had been in breach of its members' right to freedom of association.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The judgment of 20 October 2005 concerning UMO Ilinden – PIRIN is reported as United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden – PIRIN and Others v. Bulgaria, no. 59489/00, 20 October 2005.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "UMO Ilinden – PIRIN apparently has links with the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden (UMO Ilinden), an association also based in south-western Bulgaria.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "UMO Ilinden advocates similar ideas to UMO Ilinden – PIRIN.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The links between UMO Ilinden – PIRIN and UMO Ilinden are referenced in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden – PIRIN and Others v. Bulgaria, no. 59489/00, §§ 9-12, and in Ivanov and Others v. Bulgaria, no. 46336/99, § 10, 24 November 2005.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F007", "F008", "F009", "F010"], "interference": ["F007", "F009"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F011", "F012"], "legitimate_aim": ["F011", "F012"], "necessity": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F016", "F017"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F007"], "interference": ["F007"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F011", "F012"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F016"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F007", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F016"]}} {"case_name": "case_578", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of the lack of impartiality of the tribunal in view of the absence of the prosecuting party in administrative-offence proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention, in addition to their complaint about the lack of impartiality of the tribunal.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": [], "interference": [], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": [], "interference": [], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": []}} {"case_name": "case_579", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_580", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_581", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_582", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_583", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1959.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant died in 2014.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "At the time of his death in 2014, the applicant was living in Paris.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant was represented by Ms L. Sahakyan, a lawyer practising in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr G. Kostanyan.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr Y. Kirakosyan, Representative of the Republic of Armenia to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 19 February 2008 a presidential election was held in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the then Prime Minister, Mr Sargsyan, representing the ruling party.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "One of the main contenders in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the main opposition candidate, Mr Ter-Petrosyan.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Immediately after the announcement of the preliminary results of the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election, Mr Ter-Petrosyan called on his supporters to gather at Freedom Square in central Yerevan to protest against alleged irregularities in the election process.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Mr Ter-Petrosyan announced that the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election had not been free and fair.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "From 20 February 2008 onwards, nationwide daily protest rallies were held by Mr Ter-Petrosyan's supporters.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The main meeting place of Mr Ter-Petrosyan's supporters during the protest rallies from 20 February 2008 onwards was Freedom Square and the surrounding park in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The rallies at Freedom Square attracted at times tens of thousands of people.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Several hundred demonstrators stayed at Freedom Square around the clock, having set up a camp.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant was a former member of the Armenian Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant had in the past occupied different posts in the Government of Armenia, including a ministerial post.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant was a member of the political council of an opposition party.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant was a supporter of Mr Ter-Petrosyan's candidacy at the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant was an active participant in the protest rallies, regularly attending the ongoing demonstrations and sit-ins at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant spent the night of 23 to 24 February 2008 at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE 19 FEBRUARY 2008 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND THE POST-ELECTION EVENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the applicant, on 24 February 2008 at around 10 a.m. he and two of his friends, A.Sis. and V.K., were driving home from the rally at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the applicant, on 24 February 2008 at around 10 a.m. the car in which the applicant, A.Sis. and V.K. were travelling was blocked on Teryan Street in Yerevan by another car.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the applicant, masked gunmen emerged from the blocking car and demanded that the applicant and his friends get out of their car.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the applicant, he was thrown to the ground and searched but nothing was found.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicant, he and his companions A.Sis. and V.K. were forced into the blocking car and taken to the Principal Department for the Fight against Organised Crime of the Armenian Police (PDFOC).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the record of bringing a person in, the applicant was brought in to the Principal Department for the Fight against Organised Crime of the Armenian Police (PDFOC) on 24 February 2008 at around 11.30 a.m. by operative police officers of the PDFOC.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the record of bringing a person in, the applicant was brought in to the PDFOC on suspicion of carrying illegal arms and ammunition.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "At 11.45 a.m. on 24 February 2008 the applicant was subjected to a search at the PDFOC by police officers in the presence of two attesting witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The record of the applicant's search at the PDFOC indicated that a spring baton had been found in the applicant's coat pocket.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The record of the applicant's search at the PDFOC indicated that the applicant had stated that the baton belonged to him and that he carried it for self-defence.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant, in his application to the Court, contested the circumstances of his being searched at the PDFOC and alleged that no arms or other prohibited items had been found as a result of that search.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The applicant alleged that after the search at the PDFOC he was taken to another room where a police officer produced a baton, saying that it had been found in his car.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant alleged that he denied that the baton belonged to him or that it had ever been in his car.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicant alleged that police officers persuaded him to admit that the baton had been found during his personal search, saying that he, as a member of the Hunters' Union, was allowed to own it.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant alleged that police officers threatened that if he refused to confess, they would record that the baton had been found during the personal search of A.Sis. and V.K., who, not being members of the Hunters' Union, would be prosecuted.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant alleged that under such circumstances he was compelled to confess that the baton belonged to him.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicant alleged that only after his compelled confession were the two attesting witnesses called in and a record of his personal search drawn up.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "At an unspecified hour on 24 February 2008 the applicant's car was searched at the PDFOC and a Makarov-type pistol was found.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 24 February 2008 one of the PDFOC officers addressed a report to the Head of the PDFOC.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to the PDFOC officer's report, on 24 February 2008 at 11 a.m. an anonymous call had been made to the PDFOC stating that a Lexus-model black car was parked at the crossroads of Teryan and Koryun Streets in Yerevan and that its passengers were armed.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the PDFOC officer's report, an operative group of police officers of the PDFOC had immediately set off to the scene and taken into custody the Lexus-model black car and its passengers: the applicant, A.Sis. and V.K.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the PDFOC officer's report, a spring baton had been found when the applicant was searched.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the PDFOC officer's report, a Makarov-type pistol was found on searching the applicant's car.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "A statement was taken from the applicant in which he submitted that he had spent the previous night at Freedom Square at a rally in support of Mr Ter-Petrosyan.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant submitted in his statement that in the morning on his way home his car had been stopped on Teryan Street by police officers who had taken him and the other passengers to the PDFOC.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant submitted in his statement that the Makarov pistol belonged to him and was a registered weapon granted to him in 1994 by the Minister of Defence of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicant submitted in his statement that he had the necessary documents showing that he carried the Makarov pistol legally.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The applicant submitted in his statement that the baton found during his search also belonged to him and he carried it for self-defence.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 24 February 2008 the applicant and the materials concerning his case were transferred from the PDFOC to Kentron Police Station of Yerevan for further inquiry.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "An investigator at Kentron Police Station decided to order that the applicant undergo a forensic toxicological-chemical examination to detect use of drugs, reasoning the need for such examination by the fact that a baton had been found in the applicant's possession.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The investigator at Kentron Police Station ordered a forensic examination of the Makarov pistol found in the applicant's car.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The forensic expert examining the Makarov pistol found that it lacked a hammer, rendering it ineffective and therefore not to be considered a firearm.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "At 11 p.m. on 24 February 2008 the applicant was taken by police officers K.H., E.P. and A.S. of Kentron Police Station to the National Bureau of Examinations.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "At the National Bureau of Examinations the applicant underwent the assigned forensic toxicological-chemical examination, which revealed no traces of drugs in his body.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Upon return from the National Bureau of Examinations, police officers K.H., E.P. and A.S. reported to the Chief of Kentron Police Station that on the way back the applicant had started complaining of being treated unlawfully and threatened them with violence.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "According to police officers K.H., E.P. and A.S., upon reaching Kentron Police Station the applicant had disobeyed their order to step out of the car.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "According to police officers K.H., E.P. and A.S., the applicant pushed police officer K.H. when leaving the car and started a scuffle with him.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "According to police officers K.H., E.P. and A.S., the applicant refused to enter the police building and punched police officer K.H. several times in the chest.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "According to police officers K.H., E.P. and A.S., the applicant was forcibly pushed into Kentron Police Station by the three officers, where he continued threatening them with violence.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicant alleged that no incident involving resistance or assault on police officers had ever happened upon his return to Kentron Police Station.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "According to the applicant, as the car pulled up at Kentron Police Station, he got out of the car upon an order from one of the police officers and they accompanied him into the building.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "According to the applicant, the only thing he said when he got out of the car was to tell the police officers that his arrest was unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicant alleged that a number of his relatives and friends, one of his future defence lawyers and a journalist had been standing near Kentron Police Station at the time he was brought back from the forensic examination, having gathered there expecting his release.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 25 February 2008 the investigator took statements from police officers K.H., E.P. and A.S., who confirmed their earlier reports.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 25 February 2008 the investigator decided to institute a criminal case under Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code (non-life or health-threatening assault on a public official).", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The decision to institute a criminal case stated that on 24 February 2008 around 11 p.m. the applicant, who had been brought in from the crossroads of Koryun and Teryan Streets of Yerevan on suspicion of using drugs and illegal possession of arms, was transported to the National Bureau of Examination to give samples.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The decision to institute a criminal case stated that on the way back from the National Bureau of Examination, the applicant, first in the car and then in the front yard of Kentron Police Station, disobeyed the lawful orders of the police officers, insulted them and assaulted them in a non-life-threatening way by punching one of the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 25 February 2008 at 1.35 a.m. a record of the applicant's arrest was drawn up stating that the applicant was arrested on suspicion of having committed an offence under Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 25 February 2008 police officers K.H., E.P. and A.S. were questioned as witnesses and confirmed their earlier statements.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The applicant was questioned as a suspect but refused to testify or answer any questions.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The applicant declared that he was a victim of political persecution and that the charge against him was trumped up.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 25 February 2008 police officer K.H. underwent a forensic medical examination which did not reveal any injuries on his body.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "A. The applicant's arrest and institution of a criminal case"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 27 February 2008 the applicant was formally charged under Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The charge against the applicant and his placement in detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The decision formally charging the applicant stated that on 24 February 2008 at around 11.30 p.m. in front of Kentron Police Station the applicant had threatened the police officers and, in defiance of their lawful orders, inflicted non-life-threatening violence on police officer K.H. by punching him in the chest.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The charge against the applicant and his placement in detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 27 February 2008 the applicant was brought before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan (the District Court).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The charge against the applicant and his placement in detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan examined the investigator's application seeking to have the applicant detained for a period of two months on the ground that, if he remained at large, he could commit a new offence, abscond or obstruct the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The charge against the applicant and his placement in detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that the application for his detention was unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The charge against the applicant and his placement in detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that he had not resisted or punched the police officers and would not have been able to do so since he had been handcuffed.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The charge against the applicant and his placement in detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The applicant submitted before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that he was a war veteran with many military awards, no criminal record and a permanent place of residence.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The charge against the applicant and his placement in detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The applicant declared before the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan that the case against him was politically motivated.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The charge against the applicant and his placement in detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan decided to allow the investigator's application for the applicant's detention, finding that, if the applicant remained at large, he could commit a new offence, abscond or obstruct the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The charge against the applicant and his placement in detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On 29 February 2008 the investigator decided to order a forensic examination of the spring baton found in the applicant's possession.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The charge against the applicant and his placement in detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The forensic expert concluded that the spring baton was a factory-produced mace which could be characterised as a striking-crushing cold weapon (սառը զենք), based on its overall appearance, measurements, structure and relevant literature.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The charge against the applicant and his placement in detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On 29 February 2008 the results of the toxicological-chemical examination were produced and no traces of drugs were found in the applicant's body.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "B. The charge against the applicant and his placement in detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "On 1 March 2008 in the early morning a police operation was conducted on Freedom Square where several hundred demonstrators were camping.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "As a result of the police operation on 1 March 2008, Freedom Square was cleared of all demonstrators, resulting in clashes between the demonstrators and the police.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "On 1 March 2008 criminal proceedings were instituted regarding the events at Freedom Square on the grounds that the leaders of the opposition and their supporters had organised unlawful demonstrations, incited disobedience and committed violence against the police.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Further details regarding the criminal proceedings instituted on 1 March 2008 are set out in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia, no. 23086/08, § 15, 20 September 2018.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Later on 1 March 2008 the situation in Yerevan deteriorated and rallies continued in a number of streets until early in the morning of 2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The rallies on 1-2 March 2008 involved clashes between protesters and law enforcement officers.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The events of 1-2 March 2008 in Yerevan resulted in ten deaths, including eight civilians.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The events of 1-2 March 2008 in Yerevan resulted in numerous injured persons.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Following the events of 1-2 March 2008, a state of emergency was declared by the President of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "On 2 March 2008 another set of criminal proceedings was instituted on the grounds that the leaders of the opposition and their supporters had organised mass disorder in the streets of Yerevan, including murders, violence and other reprehensible acts.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Further details regarding the criminal proceedings instituted on 2 March 2008 are set out in Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia, no. 23086/08, § 17.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 2 March 2008 both sets of criminal proceedings instituted on 1 March 2008 and 2 March 2008 were joined and examined under case number 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "On 11 March 2008 the investigator decided to join the applicant's criminal case to case no. 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The decision to join the applicant's criminal case to case no. 62202608 stated that the applicant had also taken part in organising and conducting the unlawful demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On 12 March 2008 the investigator, referring to case no. 62202608, prohibited the applicant's contact with the outside world, including close relatives, the media and any other person, on the ground that such contact might obstruct the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "On 2 April 2008 the applicant went on a hunger strike, demanding that the authorities stop his political persecution and release him from detention.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "C. The events of 1-2 March 2008, institution of criminal proceedings and joinder of the applicant's case to those proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "On 15 April 2008 the investigator applied to the court to have the applicant's detention extended.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "In the application to extend the applicant's detention, the investigator referred to the materials of criminal case no. 62202608 and the progress made in the investigation of that case.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The investigator's application to extend detention stated that sufficient information had been obtained suggesting that the applicant, after the defeat of Mr Ter-Petrosyan in the presidential election, having joined a group of Mr Ter-Petrosyan's like-minded followers and conspired with them to usurp State power in violation of Armenia's Constitution, had actively participated in the implementation of the mentioned criminal plan.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The investigator's application to extend detention stated that it was necessary to carry out further investigative measures to clarify the circumstances of the applicant's involvement in the criminal act in question.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "On 21 April 2008 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan allowed the investigator's application and extended the applicant's detention by two months.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan extended the applicant's detention on 21 April 2008 taking into account the nature and dangerousness of the imputed offence and the fact that the applicant, if he remained at large, could abscond, obstruct the investigation or avoid criminal responsibility and punishment.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "In extending the applicant's detention on 21 April 2008, the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan made a reference to the investigation conducted into criminal case no. 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "On 26 April 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal against the detention extension decision, arguing inter alia that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan's decision was unreasoned and the risks of his absconding or obstructing the investigation were unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "On 8 May 2008 the Criminal Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal against the detention extension, finding that the circumstances on which the applicant's detention was based persisted, since there was still a high risk that the applicant could obstruct the investigation and abscond.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "On 23 May 2008 the investigator questioned police officer S.H., who was said to be on guard duty at Kentron Police Station on the night of 24 February 2008.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "On 3 June 2008 the investigator questioned police officer A.H., who was said to be on guard duty at Kentron Police Station on the night of 24 February 2008.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Police officer S.H. stated that he had heard loud noises from outside Kentron Police Station, stepped outside and seen police officers K.H., E.P. and A.S. holding the applicant by his arms, trying to push him into the police station.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Police officer S.H. stated that the applicant was disobeying, showing resistance to the officers and trying to free himself, while shouting and making threats, and had eventually been pushed inside the station where he continued making threats.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Police officer A.H. stated that he had been inside Kentron Police Station and seen a person, whom he later recognised as a former minister, held by his arms by police officers K.H., E.P. and A.S., brought inside the station where he briefly threatened to have the officers' heads smashed and then calmed down and sat down.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Both police officers S.H. and A.H. stated that police officer K.H. had sat down when inside Kentron Police Station, holding his hand to his chest and saying that the applicant had punched him.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "On 15 June 2008 the investigator applied to the court to have the applicant's detention extended once more, again making reference to the materials of criminal case no. 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "In the application to extend the applicant's detention on 15 June 2008, the investigator added that, following a number of investigative measures, no sufficient evidence had been obtained directly implicating the applicant in the commission of the criminal act investigated in case no. 62202608.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "On 18 June 2008 the applicant's criminal case was disjoined from case no. 62202608 as it was apparently ready for trial.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "On 19 June 2008 the General Prosecutor's Office wrote to the investigator dealing with the applicant's case, drawing his attention to the fact that the applicant had been charged only under Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The General Prosecutor's Office noted that the applicant's actions had also contained elements of an offence envisaged by Article 235 § 4 of the Armenian Criminal Code (illegal carrying of a cold weapon) and instructed the investigator to bring new charges.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "On 20 June 2008 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan extended the applicant's detention by 20 days, namely until 15 July 2008, on the same grounds as previously.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "On 24 June 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal against the detention extension decision of 20 June 2008, raising the same arguments as previously.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "On 26 June 2008 the investigator decided to bring a new charge against the applicant under Article 235 § 4 of the Armenian Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The decision to bring a new charge under Article 235 § 4 of the Armenian Criminal Code stated that a spring baton had been found in the applicant's coat pocket as a result of the personal search conducted upon bringing him to the police station on 24 February 2008.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "On 7 July 2008 the investigation into the applicant's criminal case was completed and the case was referred to the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan for trial.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "On 9 July 2008 the Criminal Court of Appeal decided to leave the applicant's appeal of 24 June 2008 without examination on the ground that the investigation had been completed and the case had been referred for trial.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "D. Extension of the applicant's detention and a new charge against him"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "On 14 July 2008 a judge of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan who had taken over the applicant's criminal case decided to set the case down for trial.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "On 22 July 2008, during the first hearing, the applicant requested to be released from detention.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The applicant argued at the hearing on 22 July 2008 that his detention authorised by a court had expired on 15 July 2008.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The applicant argued at the hearing on 22 July 2008 that the judge had failed to address the issue of his detention when deciding to set the case down for trial on 14 July 2008, in violation of Articles 293 and 300 of the Armenian Code of Criminal Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "On 22 July 2008 the judge took a decision stating that the question of the applicant's continued detention had been examined on 14 July 2008 when adopting the decision to set the case down for trial and it had been decided to leave the applicant's detention unchanged.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The judge stated on 22 July 2008 that as a result of a typographical error, the paragraph concerning the applicant's detention had not been reflected in the operative part of the decision of 14 July 2008, which was to be read as containing the phrase 'to leave the applicant's detention unchanged'.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "At the next hearing on 28 July 2008 the judge presented the parties with the decision of 22 July 2008 and dismissed the applicant's request for release.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "On 17 September 2008 another judge of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan who had taken over the applicant's case decided to set the case down for trial and also ruled to leave the applicant's detention unchanged.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "In the course of the trial the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan summoned for questioning police officers K.H., E.P., A.S., S.H. and A.H., who maintained their statements against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "After police officers S.H. and A.H. gave their testimony, the applicant requested additional time to prepare for their questioning.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan dismissed the applicant's request for additional time to prepare for questioning of police officers S.H. and A.H. on the ground that the applicant and his defence lawyers had had enough time to prepare themselves.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan stated that it was ready to allow a request for additional preparation time in the future if it were substantiated.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "At the next court hearing the applicant lodged a similar request, seeking to summon and question police officers S.H. and A.H.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan announced that it would examine the applicant's request to summon police officers S.H. and A.H. after the applicant's questioning but it appears that it never revisited that question.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "The applicant pleaded not guilty and contested the factual allegations against him at trial.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "The applicant lodged several requests with the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan seeking to call witnesses on his behalf.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The applicant requested that a number of persons be summoned as witnesses, including S.A., V.A., L.S., P.K., K.G. and A.Y., who were his relatives, political supporters and one journalist.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The applicant submitted that S.A., V.A., L.S., P.K., K.G. and A.Y. had gathered at Kentron Police Station and had been standing at the entrance when he was brought back by police officers from the forensic examination and could confirm that no incident had taken place as he left the car and entered the police building.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The applicant requested that A.Sis. and V.K., who had been kept at Kentron Police Station on the night from 24 to 25 February 2008, be summoned as witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The applicant submitted that A.Sis. and V.K. had witnessed from their cell window how he had been escorted into the police building and later had heard no shouts or sounds of protest when he had been escorted through the lobby inside the building.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "In support of the requests to call witnesses, the applicant's lawyer submitted records of statements which the lawyer had taken from those persons containing their relevant submissions.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan dismissed the applicant's request to summon S.A., V.A., L.S., P.K., K.G. and A.Y. on the ground that the case file contained no information about those persons.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan dismissed the applicant's request to summon A.Sis. and V.K. on the ground that it was not necessary to call those persons since the materials of the case contained sufficient information to draw appropriate conclusions.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The applicant's lawyer requested the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan to admit as evidence the records of the statements taken from the persons the applicant had sought to call as witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan granted the applicant's lawyer's request and the statements were included in the case file.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "On 19 November 2008 the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found the applicant guilty as charged.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan sentenced the applicant under Article 316 § 1 of the Armenian Criminal Code to two years' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan sentenced the applicant under Article 235 § 4 of the Armenian Criminal Code to a fine in the amount of 300,000 Armenian drams (AMD).", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant had illegally carried a spring baton (mace) characterised as a striking-crushing cold weapon, which was found in his coat pocket and seized during his personal search on 24 February 2008.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant, having found out about the need to take samples from him, became agitated, started complaining and, on the way back to Kentron Police Station, made threats of retribution against the accompanying police officers who were performing their official duties.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that near the entrance to Kentron Police Station, police officer K.H. and witnesses E.P. and A.S. ordered the applicant to step out of the car and to enter the police building, and the applicant disobeyed their lawful order.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that after police officer K.H. repeated the order, the applicant first pushed and then, using non-life and health-threatening violence, pulled and punched police officer K.H. several times in the chest, causing him physical pain.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found it established that the applicant was thereafter forcibly taken inside the lobby of Kentron Police Station, while he continued his threats addressed at the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "In reaching its findings, the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan relied on the statements of the police officers, the record of the applicant's bringing-in, the record of the applicant's search, the conclusions of the forensic expert characterising the baton as a striking-crushing cold weapon, and the applicant's statement of 24 February 2008 in which he had admitted that the baton belonged to him.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan found the applicant's arguments and the materials submitted by him to be unreliable, in conflict with the circumstances of the case and provided by persons who had close relations with the applicant, were not impartial and aimed to protect him.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "On 9 December 2008 the applicant lodged an appeal against the judgment of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "In his appeal of 9 December 2008, the applicant argued that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan had failed to assess properly the evidence and ignored his submissions in support of his innocence.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "In his appeal of 9 December 2008, the applicant argued that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan had based its findings solely on the statements of police officers.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "In his appeal of 9 December 2008, the applicant argued that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan had refused to hear the persons whom he had sought to call as witnesses on his behalf.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "In his appeal of 9 December 2008, the applicant argued that the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan had deprived him of the opportunity to question witnesses against him, namely police officers S.H. and A.H.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "In his appeal of 9 December 2008, the applicant alleged that the true reason for his prosecution and conviction was his being an opposition activist and to prevent his participation in the opposition demonstrations, arguing that he had been discriminated against on the basis of his political views.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "On 27 January 2009 the Criminal Court of Appeal upheld the judgment of the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan and dismissed the applicant's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal found that the arguments relied on in the applicant's appeal, including the impossibility to question in court police officers S.H. and A.H., could not serve as a valid ground for quashing the judgment as they were not indicative of a substantial violation of the criminal process.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal found that the indictment and the conviction were based on sufficient evidence proving the applicant's guilt.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "The Criminal Court of Appeal found that the applicant's allegations that the true reason for his prosecution was his political activism and participation in the opposition demonstrations were unsubstantiated, as the Kentron and Nork-Marash District Court of Yerevan had been guided by the law, legal awareness, inner conviction and the evidence obtained and examined in court.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "On 27 April 2009 the applicant lodged an appeal on points of law, raising similar arguments as in his appeal of 9 December 2008.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "On 15 June 2009 the Court of Cassation of Armenia declared the applicant's appeal on points of law inadmissible for lack of merit.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "Later in June 2009 the applicant was granted amnesty and released from prison after having served more than half of his sentence.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE APPLICANT", "E. The court proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law and relevant international materials, see Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia, no. 23086/08, §§ 91-134, 20 September 2018.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law and relevant international materials, see Ara Harutyunyan v. Armenia, no. 629/11, §§ 30-37, 20 October 2016.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law and relevant international materials, see Poghosyan v. Armenia, no. 44068/07, §§ 26-41, 20 December 2011.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "A number of relevant international materials not quoted in the judgments of Mushegh Saghatelyan v. Armenia, Ara Harutyunyan v. Armenia and Poghosyan v. Armenia are set out in the relevant legal framework section of the present judgment.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "On 15 April 2008 the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe produced the Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579).", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. PARLIAMENTARY ASSEMBLY OF THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE (PACE)"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the PACE Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579) stated that the opposition received a boost in support when a number of high-level state officials publicly denounced the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election as fraudulent and announced their support for Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. PARLIAMENTARY ASSEMBLY OF THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE (PACE)"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the PACE Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579) stated that those officials who denounced the election were subsequently dismissed from their positions.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. PARLIAMENTARY ASSEMBLY OF THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE (PACE)"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the PACE Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579) stated that a number of those officials, as well as several opposition activists, were arrested on seemingly artificial charges, which left the impression that their prosecution was politically motivated.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. PARLIAMENTARY ASSEMBLY OF THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE (PACE)"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "The Explanatory Memorandum to the PACE Report on the Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia (Doc. 11579) stated that according to the Helsinki Association of Armenia, a total of 14 persons were arrested and placed under investigation in the period from 20 to 29 February 2008.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "I. PARLIAMENTARY ASSEMBLY OF THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE (PACE)"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "Between April 2008 and June 2009 the OSCE/ODIHR (Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights) conducted a monitoring project of about a hundred trials of opposition leaders and supporters related to the events of 1-2 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. ORGANISATION FOR SECURITY AND COOPERATION IN EUROPE/OFFICE FOR DEMOCRATIC INSTITUTIONS AND HUMAN RIGHTS (OSCE/ODIHR)"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "The OSCE/ODIHR monitoring project of trials related to the events of 1-2 March 2008 included the applicant's case under number 88.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK", "II. ORGANISATION FOR SECURITY AND COOPERATION IN EUROPE/OFFICE FOR DEMOCRATIC INSTITUTIONS AND HUMAN RIGHTS (OSCE/ODIHR)"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F008", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F028", "F029"], "interference": ["F008", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F015", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F028", "F029", "F031", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F052", "F057", "F058", "F059", "F060", "F061", "F067", "F068", "F075", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F099", "F100", "F101", "F103", "F104", "F105", "F107", "F109", "F119", "F120", "F121", "F122", "F125", "F126", "F137", "F154", "F155", "F156", "F162", "F163", "F181", "F182", "F183", "F184", "F185", "F186", "F187"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F067", "F075", "F099", "F100", "F119", "F120", "F121", "F122", "F125", "F154", "F155", "F156", "F157", "F158", "F159", "F160", "F161", "F162"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F013", "F019", "F021", "F022", "F023"], "interference": ["F019", "F021", "F022", "F042", "F052", "F068", "F086", "F099", "F100", "F101", "F104", "F105", "F119", "F120", "F121", "F122", "F125", "F154", "F162", "F184", "F186", "F187"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F075", "F100", "F119", "F125", "F154"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F013", "F021", "F022", "F042", "F052", "F086", "F099", "F100", "F105", "F119", "F122", "F125", "F154", "F162", "F184", "F187"]}} {"case_name": "case_585", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants' personal details appear in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "On 12 October 2006, Mr M., a leader of a human rights association called 'Mashr' based in Nazran, the Republic of Ingushetia, submitted a notification of a planned stationary demonstration (picket) to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The notification submitted by Mr M. on 12 October 2006 was submitted in accordance with the Law on Assemblies, Gatherings, Demonstrations and Pickets of 19 June 2004 (the Public Assemblies Act).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The planned picket was to be held on 16 October 2006 from 4 p.m. to 6 p.m. near the monument to the heroes of the Second World War on Bazorkina Avenue in Nazran, the Republic of Ingushetia.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The purpose of the planned picket was to commemorate the journalist Anna Politkovskaya, who was murdered on 7 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "From 12 October 2006, the human rights association Mashr began to circulate information on the planned picket to prospective participants, including the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "On 15 October 2006, the director of the human rights association Mashr received a handwritten letter from the Head of Nazran City Administration banning the planned picket.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Head of Nazran City Administration banned the planned picket on the grounds that Mashr, being a non-commercial organisation, had no right to organise it.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Considering the decision of the Nazran City Administration to be in breach of the law, Mr M. went ahead with the organisation of the picket.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Mr M. intended to challenge the decision of the Nazran City Administration banning the picket at a later stage.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 16 October 2006, before 4 p.m., the applicants arrived at the site of the planned picket near the monument to the heroes of the Second World War on Bazorkina Avenue in Nazran.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 16 October 2006, some policemen and men in civilian clothes were present at the site of the planned picket before 4 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 16 October 2006, Mr M. and others had also gathered at the site of the planned picket with the view to participating in it.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 16 October 2006, the police and the men in civilian clothes allegedly insulted the picketers, including the applicants, at the site of the planned picket.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 16 October 2006, the police and the men in civilian clothes ordered the picketers, including the applicants, to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "When the applicants realised that it would be impossible for them to proceed with the picket on 16 October 2006, they decided to leave the site.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 16 October 2006, the third, fourth and fifth applicants were apprehended on their way to their car after leaving the site of the planned picket.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 16 October 2006, the sixth applicant was arrested at the site of the planned picket.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "At approximately 4 p.m. on 16 October 2006, the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants were transferred to the Nazran police department.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the applicants, they were driven to the Nazran police department in cars that had no police markings.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the applicants, they were not promptly informed about the reasons for their arrest on 16 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the applicants, their lawyer was not allowed to see them when he arrived at the Nazran police department on 16 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "As submitted by the applicants, at midnight on 16–17 October 2006, the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants were brought before the Justice of the Peace of the 8th Court Circuit of Nazran.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of the 8th Court Circuit of Nazran read out to the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants the records of their arrest drawn by the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The arrest records stated that the applicants had taken part in the picket and had refused to obey the police order to leave the place of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The arrest records stated that the applicants' conduct constituted an administrative offence under Article 20.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants contested the arrest records before the Justice of the Peace of the 8th Court Circuit of Nazran.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of the 8th Court Circuit of Nazran postponed the hearing to 17 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants were released between 12.30 a.m. and 1.30 a.m. on 17 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The hearing before the Justice of the Peace of the 8th Court Circuit of Nazran was subsequently postponed from 17 October 2006 to 31 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 31 October 2006, the Justice of the Peace of the 8th Court Circuit of Nazran discontinued the administrative proceedings against the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants on the ground that no offence had taken place.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "1. Dispersal of the picket, arrest and detention of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "As submitted by the applicants, when leaving the site of the planned picket on 16 October 2006, the second applicant was attacked from behind by two men.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "2. Attacks on the first and the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "During the fight that followed the attack on the second applicant, a man in civilian clothes named Mr T. hit the first applicant in her face.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "2. Attacks on the first and the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "After being hit in the face by Mr T., the first applicant started bleeding from the nose.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "2. Attacks on the first and the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The second applicant took the first applicant to the hospital after she was hit in the face by Mr T. on 16 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "2. Attacks on the first and the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The first applicant was diagnosed with an open nasal bone fracture.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "2. Attacks on the first and the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The first applicant was diagnosed with a concussion.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "2. Attacks on the first and the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The first applicant was diagnosed with a closed craniocerebral trauma.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Events of 16 October 2006", "2. Attacks on the first and the second applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 18 October 2006, the applicants complained to the Nazran Prosecutor's Office about the events of 16 October 2006, including the dispersal of the picket, the arrests, the detention, and the attacks on the first and second applicants.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 7 November 2006, the Nazran Prosecutor's Office refused to institute a criminal investigation concerning the attack on the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Nazran Prosecutor's Office refused to institute a criminal investigation on 7 November 2006 on the grounds that the injuries had been sustained two weeks prior to 16 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 23 November 2006, the Nazran Prosecutor's Office reversed its decision of 7 November 2006 refusing to institute a criminal investigation concerning the attack on the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Nazran Prosecutor's Office, in reversing the decision of 7 November 2006, stated that the decision did not contain an assessment of the behaviour of the police during the events of 16 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Nazran Prosecutor's Office stated that the investigator had not addressed the applicants' allegations that the police officers were rude, unlawfully arrested and detained them for more than three hours.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 27 December 2006, the Nazran Prosecutor's Office refused to institute a criminal investigation into the actions of the police officers during the events of 16 October 2006 for a lack of corpus delicti.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In its decision of 27 December 2006, the Nazran Prosecutor's Office stated that the first applicant's injuries had been allegedly inflicted on 16 October 2006 by Mr T.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In its decision of 27 December 2006, the Nazran Prosecutor's Office ordered the file concerning the attack on the first applicant by Mr T. to be sent for a further review.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 2 February 2007, an investigation officer instituted criminal proceedings in respect of Mr T. as regards the attack on the first applicant on 16 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 26 February 2007, the applicants challenged the decision of 27 December 2006 of the Nazran Prosecutor's Office before the Nazran Town Court.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In their challenge before the Nazran Town Court on 26 February 2007, the applicants complained about the ban of the peaceful assembly and its dispersal on 16 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "In their challenge before the Nazran Town Court on 26 February 2007, the applicants complained about their arrest and detention for more than three hours on 16 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In their challenge before the Nazran Town Court on 26 February 2007, the applicants submitted that the attacks on the first and the second applicant had taken place in the presence of some high-ranking police officers who tolerated the assaults.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 24 April 2007, the Nazran Town Court dismissed the applicants' complaint against the decision of 27 December 2006 of the Nazran Prosecutor's Office.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Nazran Town Court dismissed the complaint on 24 April 2007 on the ground that the first applicant had not been beaten by the police officers, but by a man in civilian clothes.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 5 June 2007, the Supreme Court of Ingushetia dismissed the applicants' appeal against the Nazran Town Court's decision of 24 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Neither the applicants nor their counsel was present at the hearing before the Supreme Court of Ingushetia on 5 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 3 July 2007, the applicants' legal counsel received a copy of the decision of the Supreme Court of Ingushetia of 5 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 10 June 2007, the Justice of the Peace of the 9th Court Circuit of the Nasyr-Kortskiy District of Nazran found Mr T. guilty of the blows inflicted on the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of the 9th Court Circuit of the Nasyr-Kortskiy District of Nazran ordered Mr T. to pay a fine of 30,000 Russian roubles (RUB).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of the 9th Court Circuit of the Nasyr-Kortskiy District of Nazran examined a video recording which confirmed that Mr T. had punched the first applicant in the face.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The description of the video recording provided in the sentence of the Justice of the Peace of the 9th Court Circuit of the Nasyr-Kortskiy District of Nazran further stated that Mr T. had been prevented from hitting the first applicant for the second time by the policemen and the persons dressed in plain clothes present at the site.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The first applicant did not appeal against the sentence of the Justice of the Peace of the 9th Court Circuit of the Nasyr-Kortskiy District of Nazran of 10 June 2007.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The first applicant did not lodge any civil claims in connection with the events of 16 October 2006.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Investigation into the events of 16 October 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "A summary of the domestic provisions on the procedure for the notification of public events, on the liability for breaches committed in the course of public events, and on the administrative transfer (escorting) and detention can be found in Lashmankin and Others v. Russia (application nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, paragraphs 216–312, judgment of 7 February 2017).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F011", "F013", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018"], "interference": ["F007", "F008", "F015", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F029"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F007", "F008", "F015", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F029", "F031"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F011", "F013", "F016"], "interference": ["F007", "F015", "F017", "F018"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F008", "F015", "F017", "F018", "F031"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F004", "F007", "F008", "F015", "F017", "F018", "F031"]}} {"case_name": "case_586", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_588", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_590", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_591", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden (also referred to as 'the applicant association' or 'Ilinden') is an association based in south-western Bulgaria.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The area where the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden is based is known as the Pirin region or the geographic region of Pirin Macedonia.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Mr Boris Stankov is a Bulgarian citizen.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Mr Boris Stankov was born in 1926.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Mr Boris Stankov lives in Petrich.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "At the relevant time Mr Boris Stankov was the chairman of a branch of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden was founded on 14 April 1990.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "According to its statute and programme, the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden aimed to 'unite all Macedonians in Bulgaria on a regional and cultural basis'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "According to its statute and programme, the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden aimed to achieve 'the recognition of the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Section 8 of the statute of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden stated that the organisation would not infringe the territorial integrity of Bulgaria.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Section 9 of the statute of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden stated that the organisation 'would not use violent, brutal, inhuman or unlawful means'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "According to the applicants' submissions before the Court, the main activity of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden was the organisation of celebrations to commemorate historical events of importance for Macedonians in Bulgaria.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Over an unspecified period the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden published a newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "In 1990 the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden applied for registration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "In 1990 the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden was refused registration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "In the proceedings for registration of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden, the Blagoevgrad Regional Court examined the statute of the association, its programme and other written evidence.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "In the proceedings for registration of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden, the Supreme Court examined the statute of the association, its programme and other written evidence.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In decisions of July and November 1990 and March 1991, the courts found that the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden's aims were directed against the unity of the nation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "In decisions of July and November 1990 and March 1991, the courts found that the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden advocated national and ethnic hatred.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "In decisions of July and November 1990 and March 1991, the courts found that the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden was dangerous for the territorial integrity of Bulgaria.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The courts found that registration of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden would be contrary to Articles 3, 8 and 52 § 3 of the Bulgarian Constitution of 1971, as in force at the time.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The aims of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden included, inter alia, the 'political development of Macedonia'.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The aims of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden included the establishment of a 'united, independent Macedonian State'.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "In its appeal to the Supreme Court, the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden stated that 'the Macedonian people would not accept Bulgarian, Greek or Serbian rule'.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The courts found that the formal declaration in the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden's statute that it would not infringe the territorial integrity of Bulgaria appeared inconsistent with the remaining material.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The judgment of the Supreme Court of 11 March 1991 stated that the lower courts correctly established that the aims of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden under its statute and programme were directed against the unity of the nation.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The judgment of the Supreme Court of 11 March 1991 stated that the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden sought to disseminate the ideas of Macedonianism among the Bulgarian population, especially in a particular geographical area.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The judgment of the Supreme Court of 11 March 1991 stated that the ideas of Macedonianism presupposed the 'denationalisation' of the Bulgarian population and its conversion into a Macedonian population.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The judgment of the Supreme Court of 11 March 1991 stated that the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden was directed against the unity of the nation and was therefore prohibited under Article 35 § 3 of the Bulgarian Constitution of 1971.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The parties do not appear to dispute that during the relevant period the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden underwent changes of leadership.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The parties do not appear to dispute that during the relevant period there was internal conflict within the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The local branches or separate factions of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden differed in their views and activities.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "1. The founding and the dissolution of the applicant association"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden held a meeting for the first time on 22 April 1990 at the Rozhen Monastery, at the grave of Yane Sandanski.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 20 April 1991 the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden organised a commemoration meeting at the Rozhen Monastery.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "At the commemoration meeting of 20 April 1991 at the Rozhen Monastery, the participants adopted a declaration addressed to the President and Parliament of Bulgaria.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The declaration adopted at the meeting of 20 April 1991 demanded that minority rights, of which the participants stated they had been deprived, should be guaranteed in accordance with international agreements on minorities.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The declaration adopted at the meeting of 20 April 1991 demanded the introduction of the study of the Macedonian language, history and culture in all educational institutions in Pirin Macedonia.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The declaration adopted at the meeting of 20 April 1991 demanded the right to radio and television broadcasts in the Macedonian language.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The declaration adopted at the meeting of 20 April 1991 demanded that an end be put to the assimilation process and the destruction of the Macedonian culture.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The declaration adopted at the meeting of 20 April 1991 demanded the right to publish in the Macedonian language.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The declaration adopted at the meeting of 20 April 1991 demanded that the Macedonian Church should be independent.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The declaration adopted at the meeting of 20 April 1991 demanded that all Bulgarian political parties on the territory of Pirin Macedonia should be dissolved or renamed Macedonian and should defend the national rights of the Macedonian people.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The declaration adopted at the meeting of 20 April 1991 demanded the complete cultural, economic and political autonomy of Pirin Macedonia and the withdrawal of the Bulgarian occupation armies from Pirin Macedonia.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The declaration adopted at the meeting of 20 April 1991 stated that should the Bulgarian government not respond positively to the demands, Ilinden would appeal to the United Nations Organisation, the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe, the European Parliament and the Great Powers, demanding annulment of the separatist military union of 20 February 1912 between Bulgaria, Serbia and Greece, withdrawal of the invaders from the occupied territories, and unification of Macedonia under the auspices of the United Nations and with the protection of the Great Powers.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "A police report was drawn up in 1998 by the director of the police in the region and submitted to the Court by the Government.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to the 1998 police report, 'fierce anti-Bulgarian declarations' had been made at the meetings of 22 April 1990 and 20 April 1991.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to the 1998 police report, on 22 April 1990 a declaration requesting the recognition of a Macedonian minority and cultural autonomy had been read out.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The 1998 police report did not mention any incident at the meeting of 22 April 1990.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "According to the 1998 police report, on 20 April 1991 about 300 to 350 Ilinden supporters had gathered during the official commemoration of the death of Yane Sandanski.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "According to the 1998 police report, the official commemoration of the death of Yane Sandanski on 20 April 1991 had been attended by 4,000 participants.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "According to the 1998 police report, members of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden, standing on a separate platform on 20 April 1991, had allegedly hissed and booed the police, labelled the Bulgarians 'barbarians', 'conquerors' and 'enslavers' and called on them to leave and 'free' the region from their presence.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "According to the 1998 police report, a 'shocking' incident had occurred on 20 April 1991 in which Mr B., a prominent politician, had been splashed with beer on his face.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "According to the 1998 police report, the police had allegedly prevented any further clashes at the meeting of 20 April 1991.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The 1998 police report concluded that the events organised by the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden were provocative and that there was a real risk of incidents.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The 1998 police report stated that since 1992 the municipalities in the region had normally refused to allow events organised by the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden to proceed.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The 1998 police report stated that with a view to protecting the law, the assistance of the prosecuting authorities and of the police was normally sought in relation to events organised by the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicants submitted copies of photographs, written testimonies and statements of persons who claimed that on several occasions between 1990 and 1994 there had been police actions obstructing the activities of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicants submitted copies of photographs, written testimonies and statements of persons who claimed that on several occasions between 1990 and 1994 there had been acts of private individuals obstructing the activities of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicants submitted copies of newspaper articles accusing the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden of misappropriating Bulgarian national symbols.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The applicants submitted copies of newspaper articles describing the leaders of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden as uneducated, mentally ill or traitors.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The applicants submitted copies of newspaper articles denying the existence of a Macedonian minority in Bulgaria.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicants alleged that the newspaper articles reflected public opinion in Bulgaria as manipulated by the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background of the case", "2. Public meetings prior to the period under consideration"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In July 1994 Mr Stankov, as chairman of the Petrich branch of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden, requested the mayor of Petrich to authorise a meeting to be held on 31 July 1994 in the area of Samuilova krepost in commemoration of a historical event.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "1. The events of July 1994"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 13 July 1994 the mayor of Petrich refused permission for the meeting requested by Mr Stankov, without giving any reasons.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "1. The events of July 1994"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden appealed to the Petrich District Court against the mayor of Petrich's refusal of 13 July 1994.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "1. The events of July 1994"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Petrich District Court dismissed the appeal on 16 July 1994.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "1. The events of July 1994"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Petrich District Court found that since the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden had been banned, there were well-founded fears that the demonstration would endanger public order and the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "1. The events of July 1994"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 28 July 1994 Mr Ivanov, the representative of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden, was issued with a written warning by the police to stay away from the official traditional fair at Samuilova krepost.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "1. The events of July 1994"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 28 July 1994 another person (in addition to Mr Ivanov) was issued with a written warning by the police to stay away from the official traditional fair at Samuilova krepost.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "1. The events of July 1994"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The written warnings issued on 28 July 1994 stated that they were based on the applicable law.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "1. The events of July 1994"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Despite the refusal of the authorities, on 31 July 1994 some members of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden attempted to approach the historical site of Samuilova krepost.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "1. The events of July 1994"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "According to the applicants' assessment, approximately 120 to 150 members of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden attempted to approach Samuilova krepost on 31 July 1994.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "1. The events of July 1994"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 31 July 1994 the police blocked the way of members of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden attempting to approach Samuilova krepost; according to the applicants, the police were heavily armed.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "1. The events of July 1994"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Government submitted that the allegation that the area of Samuilova krepost had been sealed off on 31 July 1994 was 'manifestly ill-founded'.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "1. The events of July 1994"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 10 April 1995 the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden requested the mayor of Sandanski to authorise a meeting to be held on 22 April 1995 at the grave of Yane Sandanski at the Rozhen Monastery, on the occasion of the eightieth anniversary of his death.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "2. The events of April 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 14 April 1995 the mayor of Sandanski refused the request for a meeting on 22 April 1995, on the ground that the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden was not duly registered by the courts.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "2. The events of April 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 15 April 1995 the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden appealed to the Sandanski District Court against the mayor of Sandanski's refusal, stating inter alia that the Macedonian people had been deprived of their right to their own cultural life in violation of international law.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "2. The events of April 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Sandanski District Court never examined the appeal lodged by the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden on 15 April 1995.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "2. The events of April 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "On 22 April 1995 the municipality of Sandanski held an official ceremony to mark the anniversary of Yane Sandanski's death at his grave at the Rozhen Monastery.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "2. The events of April 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The official ceremony at the Rozhen Monastery on 22 April 1995 commenced at about 10 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "2. The events of April 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The applicants submitted that a group of their supporters who had travelled to the Rozhen Monastery on 22 April 1995 had been ordered by the police to leave their cars in the nearby town of Melnik and had been transported to the monastery by local buses.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "2. The events of April 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The applicants submitted that on 22 April 1995 their supporters had been allowed to visit the grave of Yane Sandanski at the Rozhen Monastery, to lay a wreath and to light candles.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "2. The events of April 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The applicants submitted that on 22 April 1995 their supporters had not been allowed to bring placards, banners and musical instruments to the site of the grave of Yane Sandanski at the Rozhen Monastery.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "2. The events of April 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The applicants submitted that on 22 April 1995 their supporters had not been allowed to make speeches at the grave of Yane Sandanski at the Rozhen Monastery.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "2. The events of April 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The applicants submitted that the police had taken away the ribbon attached to the wreath laid by their supporters at the Rozhen Monastery on 22 April 1995.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "2. The events of April 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The applicants submitted that on 22 April 1995 the participants celebrated the event without music, near the Rozhen Monastery but away from the grave.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "2. The events of April 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "In July 1995 the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden again requested authorisation to hold a commemorative meeting on 30 July 1995 at Samuilova krepost, the historical site in the vicinity of Petrich.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "3. The events of July 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "On 14 July 1995 the mayor of Petrich refused the request for a meeting on 30 July 1995 at Samuilova krepost without giving any reason.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "3. The events of July 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden appealed against the mayor of Petrich's refusal of 14 July 1995.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "3. The events of July 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "By judgment of 18 July 1995 the Petrich District Court upheld the mayor of Petrich's refusal to authorise the meeting on 30 July 1995 at Samuilova krepost.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "3. The events of July 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Petrich District Court found that 'the holding of a commemorative meeting of Ilinden on 30 July 1995 at Samuilova krepost would endanger public order'.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "3. The events of July 1995"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "On 8 April 1997 the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden informed the mayor of Sandanski and the local police that they were organising a meeting to be held on 20 April 1997 at the Rozhen Monastery to commemorate the death of Yane Sandanski.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "In a letter to the mayor of Sandanski, the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden stated that Yane Sandanski, who is considered in Bulgaria as a Bulgarian national hero, was in fact a 'Macedonian fighter for the national independence of Macedonia from Turkish rule and against the Bulgarian oppressors'.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "On 11 April 1997 the mayor of Sandanski refused to grant permission for the meeting planned for 20 April 1997 at the Rozhen Monastery.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The mayor of Sandanski stated that permission for the commemoration of the same historical event had been requested on 4 April 1997 by the director of the local high school.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The mayor of Sandanski explained that the commemoration on 20 April 1997 would be organised jointly by the local high school and the municipality and that 'every [person], individually, could come'.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "On 15 April 1997 the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden appealed to the Sandanski District Court against the mayor of Sandanski's refusal of 11 April 1997, stating inter alia that the mayor had not allowed them, 'as a separate ethnic community', to organise a meeting at the tomb of their national hero.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 17 April 1997 the President of the Sandanski District Court issued an order refusing to examine the appeal on the merits on the ground that it had been submitted on behalf of an unregistered organisation.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The date on which the order of 17 April 1997 was notified to the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden is unclear.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The applicants initially denied having received a response to their appeal of 15 April 1997.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "In later submissions to the Commission, the applicants stated that on 5 May 1997 they had become aware of the order of 17 April 1997 issued by the President of the Sandanski District Court.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "As the defects in the appeal of 15 April 1997 were not remedied within the statutory seven-day time-limit, on 5 May 1997 the President of the Sandanski District Court ordered the discontinuance of the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The order of 5 May 1997 discontinuing the proceedings was notified to the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden on 13 August 1997.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The applicants claimed that on 20 April 1997 the police had prevented a group of their supporters from approaching the Rozhen Monastery.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The applicants claimed that on 20 April 1997 two persons had been ill-treated by the police.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The applicants submitted that on 20 April 1997 only thirteen students and two teachers from the local high school had arrived at the Rozhen Monastery.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The applicants submitted that on 20 April 1997 the students had laid a wreath at the Rozhen Monastery in the presence of the police and had left two minutes later.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "4. The events of April 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "On 14 July 1997 Mr Stankov, as chairman of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden's branch in Petrich, requested authorisation for a commemorative meeting to be held on 2 August 1997 at Samuilova krepost, in the outskirts of Petrich.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "5. The events of July and August 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "On 17 July 1997 the mayor of Petrich refused the request for a meeting on 2 August 1997 at Samuilova krepost, stating that the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden was not 'a legitimate organisation'.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "5. The events of July and August 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "On 20 July 1997 the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden appealed to the Petrich District Court against the mayor of Petrich's refusal of 17 July 1997, stating inter alia that there was no legal provision prohibiting meetings of organisations which were not 'legitimate' and that the planned public event would be peaceful and would not endanger public order.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "5. The events of July and August 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "By decision of 1 August 1997 the Petrich District Court dismissed the appeal on the merits.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "5. The events of July and August 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Petrich District Court found that the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden was not duly registered 'in accordance with the laws of the country'.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "5. The events of July and August 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Petrich District Court found that it had not been shown that the persons who had acted on behalf of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden actually represented it.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "5. The events of July and August 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Petrich District Court found that it had been unclear who had organised the event and who would be responsible for order during the meeting under the terms of sections 9 and 10 of the Meetings and Marches Act.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "5. The events of July and August 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Petrich District Court concluded that the lack of clarity as regards the organisers of a public event endangered public order and the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "5. The events of July and August 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The applicants submitted that on 2 August 1997 the police had not allowed a group of supporters of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden to reach the historical site of Samuilova krepost in the vicinity of Petrich.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period under consideration", "5. The events of July and August 1997"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The parties made submissions and presented copies of documents concerning the activities of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Some of the documents relied upon by the Government appear to concern statements of persons adhering to a faction or a branch of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden, which groups apparently differed in their views and activities.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The Government relied on the declaration of 20 April 1991 adopted at the Rozhen Monastery meeting and on the 1998 police report concerning the meetings of 1990 and 1991.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The Government submitted that during meetings, in letters to institutions or in statements to the media, persons associated with the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and its supporters had made declarations to the effect that they wanted the Bulgarians to leave the region of Pirin Macedonia.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Government submitted that persons associated with the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and its supporters had stated that there could be 'no peace in the Balkans unless the Bulgarians, the Greeks and all others recognise the national rights of the Macedonian people and no democracy in any Balkan country without such recognition'.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Government submitted copies of several issues of Vestnik za Makedonzite v Balgaria i Po Sveta and Makedonska poshta, pamphlets published by one of the factions linked to the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Government submitted copies of press material relating to the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and factions linked to it.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The submitted material contained information about a 'secret' private meeting of a faction of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden held on 28 September 1997.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The meeting of 28 September 1997 allegedly declared that on 10 August 1998 the region of Pirin Macedonia would become 'politically, economically and culturally autonomous' or independent, on the basis that eighty-five years after the Bucharest Treaty of 1913 the States Parties to it were allegedly under obligation to withdraw from the 'enslaved' Macedonian territories.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Makedonska poshta invited all Macedonians to a march in Sofia on 3 August 1998, stressing that the participants should not carry arms.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "A handwritten poster, allegedly issued by followers of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden in Petrich, called for a boycott of the 1994 parliamentary election 'to prevent the establishment of legitimate Bulgarian authorities in the region' of Pirin Macedonia.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The handwritten poster allegedly issued by followers of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden in Petrich called for a united Macedonian State.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The handwritten poster allegedly issued by followers of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden in Petrich called for 'an international invasion' by the Security Council of the United Nations 'according to the model of Grenada, Kuwait and Haiti'.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "An appeal for a boycott of the 1997 election stated that the Macedonians should abstain from voting in protest against the lack of recognition of their rights as a minority.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "In a declaration published in the press in the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, the leaders of a faction linked to the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden criticised the Bulgarian authorities for their refusal to recognise the Macedonian language and the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "In a declaration published in the press in the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, the leaders of a faction linked to the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden appealed to various international organisations to exert pressure on the Bulgarian authorities to recognise the Macedonian language and the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The Government submitted a copy of a 'memorandum' addressed to the United Nations, signed by activists of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden or a faction of it, dated 1 July 1997.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The memorandum of 1 July 1997 contained a short overview of historical events and complaints about the attitude of the Bulgarian authorities.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The memorandum of 1 July 1997 demanded collective minority rights, access to Bulgarian State archives, the return of confiscated material, the revision of the way Bulgarian history is seen, the revision of international treaties of 1912 and 1913, the dissolution of the 'political police', the dissolution of nationalistic and violent parties and organisations, the registration of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden as the legitimate organisation of the Macedonians in Bulgaria, radio broadcasts in Macedonian, an investigation into violations committed against Macedonians and economic assistance.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The memorandum of 1 July 1997 stated that the signatories were not acting through confrontation, tension or violence, and that their way to achieve enjoyment of their rights as a Macedonian ethnic minority in Bulgaria and in Pirin Macedonia was through peaceful means and negotiations.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The memorandum of 1 July 1997 stated that the signatories' peaceful and lawful means were to the advantage of the authorities who denied the existence of a Macedonian minority, and that the authorities could afford political, economic and psychological pressure, and arms.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "Before the Court the Government relied on a judgment of the Bulgarian Constitutional Court of 29 February 2000 in a case concerning the constitutionality of a political party called the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden-PIRIN: Party for Economic Development and Integration of the Population (UMOIPIRIN), which had been registered by the competent courts in 1999.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The Bulgarian Constitutional Court found in its judgment of 29 February 2000 that the aims of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden-PIRIN: Party for Economic Development and Integration of the Population (UMOIPIRIN) were directed against the territorial integrity of the country and that therefore it was unconstitutional.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The Bulgarian Constitutional Court noted that the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden-PIRIN: Party for Economic Development and Integration of the Population (UMOIPIRIN) could be regarded as a successor to or a continuation of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "On that basis the Bulgarian Constitutional Court relied extensively on submissions about the history and the activities of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden in the assessment of the question whether UMOIPIRIN was constitutional.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "The Bulgarian Constitutional Court took note of the demands made in the declaration of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden of 20 April 1991 adopted at the Rozhen Monastery.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "The Bulgarian Constitutional Court observed that maps of the region depicting parts of Bulgarian and Greek territory as Macedonian had been published by the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "The Bulgarian Constitutional Court observed that there had been repeated calls by the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden for autonomy and even secession.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The Bulgarian Constitutional Court noted that representatives of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden had made offensive remarks about the Bulgarian nation.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The Bulgarian Constitutional Court found that the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and UMOIPIRIN considered the region of Pirin as a territory which was only temporarily under Bulgarian control and would soon become independent.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The Bulgarian Constitutional Court found that the activities of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and UMOIPIRIN were directed against the territorial integrity of the country and were prohibited under Article 44 § 2 of the Bulgarian Constitution of 1991.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The Bulgarian Constitutional Court found that the prohibition was in conformity with Article 11 § 2 of the Convention, there being no doubt that an activity against the territorial integrity of the country endangered its national security.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "The Bulgarian Constitutional Court's judgment of 29 February 2000 was adopted by nine votes to three.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The dissenting judges in the Bulgarian Constitutional Court's judgment of 29 February 2000 gave separate opinions which have not been published.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Other evidence concerning the aims and the activities of the applicant association and its supporters"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "In support of the allegation that some members of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden were in possession of arms, the Government submitted copies of two documents.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Evidence submitted by the Government in support of their allegation that some of the members of the applicant association were in possession of arms"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The first document submitted by the Government was a copy of an article from the Kontinent daily newspaper, dated 1/2 March 1997.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Evidence submitted by the Government in support of their allegation that some of the members of the applicant association were in possession of arms"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The Kontinent daily newspaper article of 1/2 March 1997 stated that a Mr D.P.K. had been arrested in Petrich for having threatened police officers with blowing up their homes, as they had impeded his business.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Evidence submitted by the Government in support of their allegation that some of the members of the applicant association were in possession of arms"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "According to the Kontinent daily newspaper article of 1/2 March 1997, during the arrest of Mr D.P.K. the police had allegedly discovered explosives in his home.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Evidence submitted by the Government in support of their allegation that some of the members of the applicant association were in possession of arms"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The Kontinent daily newspaper article of 1/2 March 1997 recalled that Mr D.P.K. was allegedly a leader of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and a 'Macedonian activist'.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Evidence submitted by the Government in support of their allegation that some of the members of the applicant association were in possession of arms"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The second document submitted by the Government appears to be a photocopy of a flyer announcing the founding of an organisation and inviting those interested to join.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Evidence submitted by the Government in support of their allegation that some of the members of the applicant association were in possession of arms"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The flyer bears no signature, dates allegedly from 1995 and appears to have been typed on a typewriter.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Evidence submitted by the Government in support of their allegation that some of the members of the applicant association were in possession of arms"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The flyer explained that the newly created United Macedonian Organisation Nova did not wish to replace the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Evidence submitted by the Government in support of their allegation that some of the members of the applicant association were in possession of arms"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "The flyer criticised certain leaders of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Evidence submitted by the Government in support of their allegation that some of the members of the applicant association were in possession of arms"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "The flyer stated that the United Macedonian Organisation Nova would form armed groups with the aim of 'helping the Republic of Macedonia to survive'.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Evidence submitted by the Government in support of their allegation that some of the members of the applicant association were in possession of arms"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The Government did not provide any comment or additional information on the contents of the two documents submitted by them in support of the allegation that some members of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden were in possession of arms.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Evidence submitted by the Government in support of their allegation that some of the members of the applicant association were in possession of arms"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "During the hearing before the Court, the Government's Agent declared that no criminal proceedings relevant to the present case had ever been brought against members of the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Evidence submitted by the Government in support of their allegation that some of the members of the applicant association were in possession of arms"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The Government stressed that knowledge of the historical context and of the current situation in Bulgaria and in the Balkans was essential for the understanding of the issues in the present case.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The Government's summary of the historical context"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "According to the Government's historical summary, the Bulgarian nation consolidated within several geographical regions, one of them being the geographical region of Macedonia.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The Government's summary of the historical context"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "According to the Government's historical summary, in 1878, when Bulgaria was partially liberated from Turkish dominance, the Berlin Peace Treaty left the region of Macedonia within the borders of Turkey.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The Government's summary of the historical context"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "According to the Government's historical summary, between 1878 and 1913 the Bulgarian population of Macedonia organised five unsuccessful uprisings seeking liberation from Turkish rule and union with Bulgaria, followed by massive refugee migrations from the region to Bulgaria, with hundreds of thousands of Macedonian Bulgarians settling in Bulgaria.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The Government's summary of the historical context"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "According to the Government's historical summary, in 1934 the so-called 'Macedonian nation' was proclaimed for the first time by a resolution of the Communist International, and before that no reliable historical source had ever mentioned any Slavic population in the region other than the Bulgarian population.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The Government's summary of the historical context"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "According to the Government's historical summary, after the Second World War the Communist power in Yugoslavia proclaimed the concept of a separate Macedonian nation, and a separate language and alphabet were created and imposed by decree of 2 August 1944.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The Government's summary of the historical context"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "According to the Government's historical summary, a massive assimilation campaign accompanied by brutalities was launched in Yugoslavia following the proclamation of a separate Macedonian nation.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The Government's summary of the historical context"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "According to the Government's historical summary, for a short period the Bulgarian Communist Party, inspired by the idea of creating a Bulgarian-Yugoslav federation, initiated a campaign of forcible imposition of a 'Macedonian' identity on the population in the region of Pirin Macedonia, and in the 1946 and 1956 censuses individuals living in that region were forced to declare themselves 'Macedonians'; the campaign was abandoned in 1963, partly due to the refusal of the population to change their identity.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The Government's summary of the historical context"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "According to the Government's historical summary, even if a process of formation of a new nation took place, it was limited to the territory of the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The Government's summary of the historical context"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "According to the Government's historical summary, in the 1992 census only 3,019 Bulgarian citizens identified themselves as Macedonians and indicated Macedonian as their mother tongue.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The Government's summary of the historical context"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "According to the Government's historical summary, in the 1992 census another 7,784 Bulgarian citizens declared themselves Macedonians in the geographical sense, while allegedly indicating their Bulgarian national conscience and mother tongue.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The Government's summary of the historical context"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "According to the Government's historical summary, individuals considering themselves Macedonians are not discriminated against in Bulgaria, have their own cultural and educational organisation called Svetlina, and there are books and newspapers in the 'Macedonian language'.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. The Government's summary of the historical context"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "Article 43 § 1 of the Bulgarian Constitution of July 1991 provides that everyone shall have the right to peaceful and unarmed assembly at meetings and marches.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "Article 43 § 2 of the Bulgarian Constitution of July 1991 provides that the procedure for organising and holding meetings and marches shall be provided for by act of Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "Article 43 § 3 of the Bulgarian Constitution of July 1991 provides that permission shall not be required for meetings to be held indoors.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "Article 44 § 2 of the Bulgarian Constitution of July 1991 prohibits organisations whose activities are directed against the sovereignty or the territorial integrity of the country or against the unity of the nation, or aim at stirring up racial, national, ethnic or religious hatred, or at violating the rights and freedoms of others, as well as organisations creating secret or paramilitary structures, or which seek to achieve their aims through violence.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "The legal requirements for the organisation of meetings are set out in the Bulgarian Meetings and Marches Act of 1990.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "Section 2 of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that meetings and marches may be organised by individuals, associations, political or other public organisations.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "Section 6(2) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that every organiser of or participant in a march or a meeting shall be responsible for damage caused through his or her fault during the event.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "Section 8(1) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that where a meeting is to be held outdoors the organisers shall notify in writing the respective People's Council or mayor's office not later than forty-eight hours before the beginning of the meeting, indicating the name of the organiser, the aim of the meeting, and the place and time of the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "Section 9(1) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that the organisers of the meeting shall take the measures necessary to ensure order during the event.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "Section 10 of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that the meeting shall be presided over by a president and that the participants shall abide by the instructions of the president concerning the preservation of public order.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "Section 12(1) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that where the time or place of the meeting, or the itinerary of the march, would create a situation endangering public order or traffic safety, the President of the Executive Committee of the People's Council or the mayor shall propose their modification.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "Section 12(2) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that the President of the Executive Committee of the People's Council or the mayor shall be competent to prohibit the holding of a meeting, demonstration or march where reliable information exists that it aims at the violent overturning of constitutional public order or is directed against the territorial integrity of the country, would endanger public order in the local community, or would breach the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "Section 12(3) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that the prohibition shall be imposed by a written reasoned act not later than twenty-four hours following the notification.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "Section 12(4) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that the organiser of the meeting, demonstration or march may appeal to the Executive Committee of the People's Council against the prohibition, and the Executive Committee shall decide within twenty-four hours.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "Section 12(5) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that where the Executive Committee of the People's Council has not decided within the twenty-four hour time-limit, the march, demonstration or meeting may proceed.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "Section 12(6) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that if the appeal is dismissed the dispute shall be referred to the relevant district court which shall decide within five days, and that court's decision shall be final.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "The Meetings and Marches Act was adopted in 1990 when the Bulgarian Constitution of 1971 was in force, under which the executive local State organs were the executive committees of the people's councils in each district.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "Under the Bulgarian Constitution of 1971, the mayors referred to in some provisions of the Meetings and Marches Act were representatives of the executive committee acting in villages and towns under the jurisdiction of the respective people's councils.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "The Bulgarian Constitution of 1991 abolished the executive committees and established the post of mayor, elected by direct universal suffrage, as the 'organ of the executive power in the municipality' under Article 139.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["national_security", "public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F063", "F075", "F087", "F092", "F108", "F055", "F082", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F136", "F162", "F156", "F157", "F158", "F159", "F160", "F161", "F152", "F153", "F154", "F155", "F046", "F048", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F139", "F147", "F126", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F118"], "interference": ["F055", "F064", "F076", "F088", "F094", "F109", "F068", "F069", "F082", "F083", "F084", "F085", "F086", "F096"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F064", "F076", "F088", "F109", "F112", "F066", "F067", "F090", "F091", "F186", "F179", "F185", "F187", "F188", "F190"], "legitimate_aim": ["F022", "F023", "F043", "F044", "F120", "F125", "F144"], "necessity": ["F015", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F055", "F139", "F147", "F156", "F157", "F158", "F159", "F160", "F161", "F046", "F048", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F054", "F067", "F091", "F115", "F162", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F043", "F044", "F120", "F125", "F144", "F010", "F011", "F126", "F136", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F118", "F027", "F028", "F059", "F060", "F061", "F093", "F064", "F076", "F088", "F094", "F109", "F083", "F084", "F033", "F063", "F075", "F079", "F092", "F095", "F096", "F172"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F063", "F075", "F087", "F092", "F108", "F011", "F162", "F157", "F161", "F048", "F032"], "interference": ["F055", "F064", "F076", "F088", "F094", "F109", "F083", "F084"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F186", "F067", "F091", "F064", "F076", "F190"], "legitimate_aim": ["F022", "F023", "F043", "F044", "F120", "F125", "F144"], "necessity": ["F055", "F162", "F011", "F136", "F032", "F118", "F043", "F044", "F144", "F018", "F020", "F139", "F147", "F157", "F161", "F048", "F052", "F172", "F083", "F084", "F079", "F075"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F055", "F162", "F011", "F136", "F032", "F018", "F020", "F043", "F044", "F144", "F157", "F161", "F083", "F084", "F172"]}} {"case_name": "case_595", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1992.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in town Uzlovaya, Tula region.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 7-65, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 7-33, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The parties' submissions on the circumstances directly relevant to the present case are set out below.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 6 May 2012 a public demonstration entitled the 'March of Millions' was held in central Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration of 6 May 2012 was held to protest against the allegedly rigged presidential elections.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration of 6 May 2012 had been approved by the Moscow city authorities in the form of a march followed by a meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The approved meeting at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 was supposed to end at 7.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The march on 6 May 2012 was peaceful and held without any disruptions.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "When the marchers arrived at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, it became apparent that barriers installed by the police had narrowed the entrance to the meeting venue.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The barriers installed by the police at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 allegedly restricted the space allocated for the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "To control the crowd at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, the police cordon forced the protestors to remain within the barriers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "There were numerous clashes between the police and protestors at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police ordered the meeting at Bolotnaya Square to finish early.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police began to disperse the participants of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "It took the police about two hours to clear Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the Moscow city department of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation opened criminal proceedings to investigate suspected acts of mass disorder under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the Moscow city department of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation opened criminal proceedings to investigate suspected violence against the police under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 18 May 2012 the criminal case file was transferred from the Moscow city department to the headquarters of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation for further investigation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 28 May 2012 an investigation was launched into the criminal offence of organising acts of mass disorder under Article 212 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 28 May 2012 the two criminal cases (mass disorder/violence against police, and organising mass disorder) were joined into a single criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "At the time of his arrest the applicant was a fourth-year student at the Russian State Humanities University.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the applicant took part in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "After the events of 6 May 2012 the applicant continued to live at his usual address.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "After the events of 6 May 2012 the applicant continued to pursue his studies at the Russian State Humanities University.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 8 June 2012 the applicant was arrested on suspicion of having participated in acts of mass disorder during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 8 June 2012 the applicant was arrested on suspicion of having used violence against the police during the demonstration of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 9 June 2012 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow ordered that the applicant be placed in pre-trial detention until 8 August 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its detention order of 9 June 2012, referred to the gravity of the charges against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its detention order of 9 June 2012, stated that if at liberty the applicant could co-ordinate his position with accomplices who had yet to be discovered and whose identities were still being established by the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its detention order of 9 June 2012, concluded that there were sufficient reasons to believe that the applicant was likely to flee to avoid the investigation and trial.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its detention order of 9 June 2012, concluded that there were sufficient reasons to believe that the applicant was likely to continue his criminal activity if at liberty.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its detention order of 9 June 2012, concluded that there were sufficient reasons to believe that the applicant was likely to destroy evidence or otherwise obstruct the investigation if at liberty.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its detention order of 9 June 2012, noted that the criminal case was still at an initial stage.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 15 June 2012 charges were brought against the applicant under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (participation in acts of mass disorder accompanied by violence).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 15 June 2012 charges were brought against the applicant under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (use of violence against a public official).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant was accused of attempting to break through the police cordon at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicant was accused of throwing pieces of tarmac and stones at Police Officer K. at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicant's alleged throwing of pieces of tarmac and stones at Police Officer K. was accused of having caused Police Officer K. a broken finger.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 16 July 2012 the Moscow City Court upheld the detention order of 9 June 2012 issued by the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 6 August 2012 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow examined an application from the investigator for an extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 6 August 2012 the applicant asked the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow for the preventive measure to be changed to house arrest.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 6 August 2012 the applicant asked the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow for the preventive measure to be changed to a written undertaking not to leave a specified place.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 6 August 2012 the applicant asked the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow for the preventive measure to be changed to personal guarantees.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 6 August 2012 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow granted the investigator's application and extended the applicant's pre-trial detention until 6 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its extension order of 6 August 2012, considered that the circumstances justifying the detention order had not changed.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 12 September 2012 the Moscow City Court upheld the extension order of 6 August 2012 issued by the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 30 October 2012 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow granted an extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention until 6 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its extension order of 30 October 2012, noted that the circumstances justifying the detention order had not changed, essentially on the same grounds as earlier.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 20 November 2012 the charges against the applicant were reformulated to state that he had gone to the venue of the public event on 6 May 2012 with a mask.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The reformulated charges of 20 November 2012 stated that the applicant had put on the mask to conceal his face.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The reformulated charges of 20 November 2012 stated that the applicant had shouted anti-government slogans at the demonstration on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The reformulated charges of 20 November 2012 stated that the applicant had thrown at least three pieces of tarmac at police officers during the demonstration on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The reformulated charges of 20 November 2012 stated that one chunk of tarmac thrown by the applicant had hit Police Officer K. on the right hand, causing him pain but no lasting harm.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Following the reformulation of charges on 20 November 2012, the classification of the offences against the applicant remained unchanged.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 1 March 2013 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow granted an application from the investigator for an extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention until 8 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 22 April 2013 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow granted an application from the investigator for an extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention until 6 July 2013.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its extension orders of 1 March 2013 and 22 April 2013, considered that the circumstances justifying the detention order had not changed.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 10 April 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the extension order of 1 March 2013 issued by the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 30 May 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the extension order of 22 April 2013 issued by the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 24 May 2013 the applicant's criminal case was transferred to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow for the determination of criminal charges.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 6 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow granted an extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention until 24 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The extension order of 6 June 2013 by the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow concerned eleven defendants.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow, in its extension order of 6 June 2013, based its decision on the gravity of the charges and its finding that the reasons which initially warranted the detention had not changed.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow, in its extension order of 6 June 2013, found that no other measures of restraint would secure the aims and goals of the judicial proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The applicant's request for an alternative preventive measure was dismissed by the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow on 6 June 2013 on the grounds that no other measure could secure the proper course of justice in the case.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 2 July 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the extension order of 6 June 2013 issued by the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 19 November 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow granted an extension of detention in respect of nine defendants, including the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow, in its extension order of 19 November 2013, ordered the detention of the nine defendants, including the applicant, until 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow, in its extension order of 19 November 2013, based its decision on the gravity of the charges and the nature of the offences imputable to the defendants.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 17 December 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the extension order of 19 November 2013 issued by the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The applicant was held in remand prison IZ-77/5 for the whole period of his pre-trial detention from 20 June 2012.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of the applicant's detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The applicant was held in four different cells in remand prison IZ-77/5 during his pre-trial detention.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of the applicant's detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The applicant did not provide any description of the conditions of his detention in remand prison IZ-77/5.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of the applicant's detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The applicant's description of the conditions of detention during transfer from the remand prison to court and back was identical to those described in Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 69-73, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Government's submissions regarding the conditions of detention during transfer from the remand prison to court and back were identical to those in Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 69-73, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The applicant submitted that the convoy room of the Moscow City Court was poorly lit.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The applicant submitted that access to the toilet in the convoy room of the Moscow City Court was limited to once an hour.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The applicant submitted that he had been required to strip naked and to perform sit-ups during the body search conducted in the convoy room of the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 6 June 2013 court proceedings began in hearing room no. 338 at the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "At the end of July 2013 court proceedings moved from hearing room no. 338 to hearing room no. 635 at the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The defendants, including the applicant, were held in glass cabins in hearing room no. 338 and hearing room no. 635 at the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "From mid-September 2013 to the end of 2013 the hearings continued at the Nikulinskiy District Court of Moscow in hearing room no. 303.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "In January and February 2014 the hearings took place at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow in hearing room no. 410.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Hearing room no. 303 at the Nikulinskiy District Court of Moscow and hearing room no. 410 at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow were equipped with metal cages in which nine defendants (eight from 19 December 2013), including the applicant, sat during the hearings.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "For a detailed description of the conditions in the hearing rooms used during the trial, see Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 74-77, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "On 6 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow began a preliminary hearing in a criminal case against ten participants in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The ten defendants in the criminal case before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow were charged with participation in acts of mass disorder and committing acts of violence against police officers.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 18 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow began the trial on the merits of the criminal case against the ten participants in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Police Officer K., the alleged victim of the applicant's assault, was examined as a witness at the trial before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow on an unidentified date.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Police Officer K. testified that he had noticed the applicant in the crowd wearing a black mask with eye holes.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Police Officer K. testified that the applicant had acted aggressively and had thrown pieces of tarmac, bottles and stones at police officers along with other participants.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Police Officer K. testified that one piece of tarmac had hit him on the right hand, which had caused a broken finger.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Police Officer K. testified that he had arrested the applicant, who had tried to escape and had resisted the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Police Officer K.K. was also questioned as a witness at the trial before the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Police Officer K.K. testified that the applicant had thrown stones at the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 21 February 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found the applicant guilty as charged under Articles 212 § 2 and 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that between 4 p.m. and 8 p.m. on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square, unidentified persons called those present to move outside the agreed meeting venue and to defy the lawful orders of the police.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that the unidentified persons' calls led to mass disorder accompanied by the use of violence against public officials in connection with the performance of their duties and the destruction of property.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that at 5 p.m. at the latest on 6 May 2012 the defendants acquired the criminal intent to participate in mass disorder and to use violence against police officers.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant put on a mask to conceal his face so that he could not be recognised and brought to responsibility for committing unlawful acts.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that between 5 p.m. and 6.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the applicant repeatedly shouted anti-government slogans.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that participants of the acts of mass disorder threw chunks of tarmac, stones, sticks and other objects at the police, hitting them on various parts of their body.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that the applicant used violence against Police Officer K. which did not endanger his life or health.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that from 5 p.m. to 6.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the applicant threw at least three pieces of tarmac at police officers in a targeted manner.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that one piece of tarmac measuring 15 cm by 15 cm hit Police Officer K. on the right hand, causing him pain.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The applicant pleaded not guilty at trial and testified that he had decided to attend the public gathering on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The applicant testified at trial that after the security check he put on a mask with eye holes because he wanted to avoid being recognised by members of the opposition.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The applicant testified at trial that when a stampede occurred he tried to leave the venue but could not get out of the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The applicant testified at trial that he saw three police officers with truncheons heading in his direction, got scared and tried to hide from them in the crowd, but they ran him down and twisted his arms behind his back.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The applicant testified at trial that one of the police officers asked him why he was wearing a mask and then said that it was prohibited.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The applicant testified at trial that he took the mask off and the police officers conveyed him to a police vehicle, and then returned the mask to him.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The applicant testified at trial that he did not pick up any objects or throw them at the police, did not engage in any acts against Police Officer K., and did not resist arrest.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found that a medical expert opinion stated that Police Officer K. had a broken finger which could have been caused on 6 May 2012 and that the recovery process would take more than 21 days.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow considered the defendants' arguments that they were protecting somebody from police officers or happened to be victims of the police's use of force as farfetched and aimed at the mitigation of their responsibility.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to three years and six months' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The applicant's sentence of three years and six months' imprisonment was calculated on the basis of a three-year prison term under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, partly concurrent with a term of one year and four months under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The applicant's pre-trial detention counted towards his prison sentence.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The applicant appealed against the judgment of 21 February 2014 of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "In his appeal the applicant contested his involvement in the acts of mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "In his appeal the applicant insisted that he had caused no injuries to Police Officer K.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "In his appeal the applicant complained that the trial court had refused to question Officer Sh., who could have confirmed his account of events.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "On 20 June 2014 the Moscow City Court upheld the first-instance judgment of 21 February 2014 of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Article 212 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the organisation of mass disorder, accompanied by violence, riots, arson, destruction of property, the use of firearms, explosives and explosive devices, as well as armed resistance to a public official, shall be punishable by four to ten years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that participation in the types of mass disorder provided for by Article 212 § 1 shall be punishable by three to eight years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Article 212 § 3 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the instigation of the acts of mass disorder provided for by Article 212 § 1, or the instigation of participation in such acts, or the instigation of violence against citizens, shall be punishable by a restriction of liberty for up to two years, or community service for up to two years, or deprivation of liberty for the same term.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the use of violence which does not endanger life or health, or the threat to use such violence against a public official or his relatives in connection with the performance of his or her duties, shall be punishable by a fine of up to 200,000 roubles or an equivalent of the convicted person's wages for 18 months, or community service for up to five years, or up to five years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic law provisions governing pre-trial detention and the practice of the domestic courts in such matters is set out in Zherebin v. Russia (no. 51445/09, §§ 16-25, 24 March 2016).", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F008", "F099", "F100", "F101", "F039", "F054", "F106", "F016"], "interference": ["F027", "F028", "F036", "F037", "F098", "F117", "F118"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F029", "F036", "F037", "F126", "F128", "F114", "F123", "F120", "F124"], "legitimate_aim": ["F014", "F018", "F019", "F006", "F007"], "necessity": ["F098", "F103", "F105", "F106", "F107", "F115", "F008", "F114", "F123", "F120", "F124", "F117", "F118", "F016", "F054", "F099", "F100", "F108", "F025", "F026", "F024", "F007", "F088", "F089", "F064"], "positive_obligation": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F008", "F099", "F100", "F016", "F106"], "interference": ["F098", "F117", "F118"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F036", "F037", "F126", "F128", "F114", "F123", "F124"], "legitimate_aim": ["F014", "F018", "F019"], "necessity": ["F117", "F118", "F103", "F008", "F105", "F107", "F115", "F108", "F099", "F100", "F016", "F106", "F114", "F123", "F124", "F088"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F008", "F098", "F117", "F118", "F103", "F105", "F107", "F115", "F099", "F100", "F016", "F106", "F123", "F124", "F088"]}} {"case_name": "case_596", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_598", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1964.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Larnaca.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant claimed that his home had been in the village of Marathovounos in the District of Famagusta, northern Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant's family had owned considerable immovable property in northern Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant's family was one of the wealthiest families in the village of Marathovounos.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant's parents had intended to transfer to the applicant a quarter share in their immovable properties when the applicant reached the age of 18.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Because of the 1974 Turkish intervention, the transfer of a quarter share in the applicant's parents' immovable properties to the applicant did not happen.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant considered that, even though the formal registration process was not completed, he had been the 'beneficial owner' of a quarter share in his parents' properties from the age of 18.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The properties listed in paragraph 3 were all transferred to the applicant by way of gift from his parents on 6 August 1996 under declarations of transfer nos. D-1534, D-1535, D-1537 and D-1538.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Rashies, plot no. 149, sheet/plan 22/24, described as a house (area approximately 250 square metres) and yard (ground floor), used as a residence, with a total area of 2,339 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, plot no. 223, sheet/plan 22/24, described as a field, with an area of 2,161 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, plot no. 170, sheet/plan 22/24, described as a field, with an area of 1,339 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Rashies, plot no. 188, sheet/plan 22/24, described as a field, with an area of 2,190 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, plot no. 303/1/1, sheet/plan 22/24.V.1, described as a field, with an area of 276 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Xylogefyro, plot no. 130, sheet/plan 23/26, described as a field, with an area of 26,127 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Landes, plot no. 406, sheet/plan 22/32, described as a field, with an area of 4,925 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Paneloporta, plot no. 274, sheet/plan 22/32, described as a field, with an area of 4,076 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Paneloporta, plot no. 275, sheet/plan 22/32, described as a field, with an area of 4,413 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Pallourokampos, plot no. 403, sheet/plan 22/31, described as a field, with an area of 9,382 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Angastina, plot no. 439/1, sheet/plan 22/31, described as a field, with an area of 7,055 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Angastina, plot no. 439/2, sheet/plan 22/31, described as a field, with an area of 974 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Parraka, plot nos. 330/2/1, 330/3 and 335/1, sheet/plan 22/7, described as a field, with an area of 8,758 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Tzaetika, plot no. 135, sheet/plan 22/16, described as a field, with an area of 3,145 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Hepipis, plot no. 236, sheet/plan 22/16, described as a field, with an area of 2,703 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Vitsada Road, plot no. 269, sheet/plan 22/16, described as a field, with an area of 2,325 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Tzaetika, plot no. 246/1, sheet/plan 22/16, described as a field, with an area of 1,994 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 6 August 1996 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Tzaetika, plot no. 246/2, sheet/plan 22/16, described as a field, with an area of 1,918 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The properties listed in paragraph 4 were all transferred to the applicant by way of gift from his parents on 12 January 2000 under declaration of transfer no. D-36.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 12 January 2000 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, plot no. 321, sheet/plan 22/24.V.1, described as a house and yard (ground floor), with an area of 1,238 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 12 January 2000 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Limni, plot no. 147, sheet/plan 22/32, described as a field, with an area of 1,370 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 12 January 2000 a quarter share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Limni, plot no. 140/1, sheet/plan 22/32, described as a field, with an area of 11,050 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 12 January 2000 a one-eighth share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Mazeri, plot no. 180/1, sheet/plan 23/17, described as a field, with an area of 13,500 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 12 January 2000 a one-thirty-second share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Toumpa, plot no. 34, sheet/plan 23/17, described as a field, with an area of 17,827 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The properties listed in paragraph 5 were all transferred to the applicant by way of gift from his parents on 13 January 2000 under declarations of transfer nos. D-45 and D-46.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 13 January 2000 a one-eighth share in property at Famagusta, Marathovounos, Trachonas, plot no. 805, sheet/plan 22/24, described as a field, with an area of 11,542 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 13 January 2000 a one-sixteenth share in property at Famagusta, Angastina, Angoulos, plot no. 267, sheet/plan 22/30, described as a field, with an area of 13,925 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant received by gift on 13 January 2000 a one-sixteenth share in property at Famagusta, Angastina, Angoulos, plot no. 152, sheet/plan 22/38, described as a field, with an area of 3,295 sq. m.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "In order to substantiate his claim to ownership, the applicant produced the relevant certificates of ownership of Turkish-occupied immovable property issued by the Republic of Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicant alleged that since the 1974 Turkish intervention he had been deprived of his property rights, as his property was located in the area under the occupation and control of the Turkish military authorities.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicant alleged that the Turkish military authorities had prevented him from having access to and from using his properties in northern Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. HOME AND PROPERTY ISSUES"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 19 July 1989, the applicant joined an anti-Turkish demonstration in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicants in the Chrysostomos and Papachrysostomou v. Turkey and Loizidou v. Turkey cases also took part in the anti-Turkish demonstration in the Ayios Kassianos area in Nicosia on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant before the 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court on 7 August 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant before the 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court on 7 August 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was held on the fifteenth anniversary of the Turkish intervention in Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to an affidavit sworn by the applicant before the 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court on 7 August 2000, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was held in support of the missing persons and to protest against human-rights violations.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicant heard about the demonstration of 19 July 1989 from the local radio and press.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "During the afternoon of 19 July 1989, the radio announced that Turkish soldiers and policemen had started to cruelly beat the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant was a nursing officer.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicant decided to go to the area where the events of 19 July 1989 were taking place.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The applicant took with him a special bag containing first-aid equipment when he went to the demonstration area on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The applicant wore an armband marked with the Red Cross sign when he went to the demonstration area on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The applicant told UN officers that he was a nurse on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "UN officers informed the applicant that they needed his help for a woman who had received an injury to the head and was lying on the ground.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "While the applicant was trying to attend to the injured woman, he was beaten with clubs about the head and body by Turkish military personnel and/or other personnel acting under Turkish control.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Despite the applicant's attempts to explain that he was a nurse, Turkish military personnel and/or other personnel acting under Turkish control continued to hit him.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The applicant felt a powerful blow to the head and started bleeding during the events of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicant was led away at gunpoint through an angry crowd that shouted abuse and threats on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicant was taken by bus to the so-called 'Pavlides Garage' on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The crowd had encircled the bus transporting the applicant and was hitting it with sticks and throwing stones at the arrested persons.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "At the 'Pavlides Garage', a body search was carried out and all the applicant's personal effects were taken.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "At the 'Pavlides Garage', the crowd was shouting and throwing stones at the garage, some of which came through the roof.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Some hours after arriving at the 'Pavlides Garage', the applicant was taken to hospital where he had stitches to his head.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "After receiving stitches at hospital, the applicant was taken back to the 'Pavlides Garage'.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The applicant was still bleeding and his clothes were soaked with blood when he was taken back to the 'Pavlides Garage'.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "Sometime after midnight on 19-20 July 1989, the applicant was interrogated by a Greek-speaking officer at the 'Pavlides Garage'.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The applicant declared during interrogation that he had joined the demonstration voluntarily for humanitarian reasons.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The applicant was told to sign a statement in Turkish but refused, as he did not understand Turkish.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The applicant refused to sign the statement in Turkish because signing would have been tantamount to recognising the 'Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus' (the 'TRNC').", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "In the morning of 20 July 1989, the applicant was taken to Seray Police Station and put in a cell that was dark, damp and dirty.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "While at Seray Police Station, the applicant was beaten and threatened.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 20 July 1989, the applicant was given back his personal effects and taken to court.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "At court on 20 July 1989, an interpreter explained the charges to the accused.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The applicant understood that he was accused of having violated the borders of the 'TRNC'.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The applicant informed the judge on 20 July 1989 that he had attended the demonstration only in order to offer humanitarian aid as a member of the Red Cross.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The court remained completely indifferent to what the applicant said on 20 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The applicant was remanded in custody for two days after the court appearance on 20 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The applicant was taken to Ortakeuy Prison after being remanded in custody.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "At Ortakeuy Prison, all the applicant's personal effects were taken away again.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "At Ortakeuy Prison, the applicant was blindfolded and led to another area of the prison where he was interrogated and punched.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The interrogation at Ortakeuy Prison was aimed solely at eliciting military information and the applicant lied about certain details.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The applicant was forced to wash the blood from his clothes before appearing in court the next day.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "After the interrogation at Ortakeuy Prison, the applicant was taken to the central prison.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "On 21 July 1989, the applicant was taken to court.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Foreign journalists and UN officers were present in the courtroom on 21 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The accused had no legal representation at the court hearing on 21 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The quality of the interpretation at the court hearing on 21 July 1989 was poor; the applicant felt that the interpreter was not translating all of what was being said.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "At the court hearing on 21 July 1989, the Bishop of Kitium spoke on behalf of the other accused and said that they would agree to be defended only by a Greek-Cypriot or UN lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The judge at the court hearing on 21 July 1989 replied that she could only appoint a lawyer registered with the 'TRNC' bar association.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The accused pleaded not guilty at the court hearing on 21 July 1989 and stated that they did not recognise the legitimacy of the 'TRNC' or its tribunals.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Four witnesses were called by the prosecution at the court hearing on 21 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Bishop of Kitium put some questions to the first prosecution witness at the court hearing on 21 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The judge refused to allow some of the questions put by the Bishop of Kitium to the first prosecution witness, and the Bishop accordingly declined to cross-examine any other witness.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The prosecution witnesses lied about basic facts surrounding the demonstration and the arrest of the accused at the court hearing on 21 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "One of the persons present in the courtroom on 21 July 1989 spoke briefly to the Bishop of Kitium, who became frightened as a result.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "After the trial on 21 July 1989, the applicant and his co-accused were taken back to prison and their pictures were taken.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "On 22 July 1989, the applicant was again taken to court.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "A hostile crowd gathered outside the courtroom on 22 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 22 July 1989, the applicant was sentenced to three days' imprisonment and a fine of 50 Cyprus pounds (approximately 85 euros), with five additional days in prison in default of payment within 24 hours.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The sentence of 22 July 1989 was translated into Greek and the accused stated that they would not pay the fine.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "An angry crowd had assembled within the precinct of the court on 22 July 1989 and was shouting, swearing and making obscene gestures at the accused.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The applicant had the impression that the crowd's presence and actions on 22 July 1989 were being orchestrated and controlled by the police.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "From 24 until 28 July 1989, the applicant went on a hunger strike to protest about the prison director's refusal to give the Bishop of Kitium church vestments and holy vessels with which to celebrate mass.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The applicant was put in an isolation cell as punishment for going on hunger strike.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The applicant continued his hunger strike notwithstanding the pressure exerted by the prison staff.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "On 28 July 1989, the applicant was released and taken back to southern Cyprus.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "On 29 July 1989, the applicant went to the police headquarters in Nicosia and made a complaint about his arrest and ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The applicant was referred to Nicosia General Hospital, where he was examined by a doctor, following his complaint on 29 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "In support of his claim of ill-treatment, the applicant produced a medical certificate issued on 29 July 1989 by Dr A. Hadjihannas, a medical officer at Nicosia Hospital.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 29 July 1989 by Dr A. Hadjihannas states that Dr Hadjihannas examined the applicant (Costas Stratis) on 29 July 1989 and found a head injury to the left frontal bone with four stitches.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 29 July 1989 by Dr A. Hadjihannas states that the applicant's blood pressure was 120/80.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 29 July 1989 by Dr A. Hadjihannas states that removal of stitches and cleaning of the wound was recommended.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The medical certificate issued on 29 July 1989 by Dr A. Hadjihannas states that the applicant complained of mild pain in the epigastrium and nausea, treatment was provided, and a urine culture was recommended for old nephritis.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "A. The applicant's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant had participated in a violent demonstration with the aim of inflaming anti-Turkish sentiment on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators, supported by the Greek-Cypriot administration, were demanding that the 'Green Line' in Nicosia should be dismantled.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Government alleged that some demonstrators carried Greek flags, clubs, knives and wire-cutters and were acting in a provocative manner and shouting abuse.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Government alleged that the demonstrators were warned in Greek and English that unless they dispersed they would be arrested in accordance with the laws of the 'TRNC'.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was arrested by the Turkish-Cypriot police after crossing the UN buffer zone and entering the area under Turkish-Cypriot control.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The Government alleged that the Turkish-Cypriot police intervened in the face of the manifest inability of the Greek-Cypriot authorities and the UN Force in Cyprus to contain the incursion and its possible consequences.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The Government alleged that no force was used against demonstrators who did not intrude into the 'TRNC' border area on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The Government alleged that in the case of demonstrators who were arrested for violating the border, no more force was used than was reasonably necessary in the circumstances in order to arrest and detain the persons concerned.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Government alleged that no one was ill-treated during the events of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Government alleged that it was possible that some of the demonstrators had hurt themselves in the confusion or in attempting to scale barbed wire or other fencing.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Government alleged that had the Turkish police, or anyone else, assaulted or beaten any of the demonstrators, the UN Secretary General would no doubt have referred to this in his report to the Security Council.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was charged, tried, found guilty and sentenced to a short term of imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant pleaded not guilty but did not give evidence and declined to use the available judicial remedies.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was asked if he required assistance from a lawyer registered in the 'TRNC', but refused and did not ask for legal representation.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Government alleged that interpretation services were provided at the trial by qualified interpreters and all the proceedings were translated into Greek.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "B. The Government's version of events"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "In his report of 7 December 1989 on UN operations in Cyprus, the UN Secretary General stated that a serious situation arose in July 1989 as a result of a demonstration by Greek Cypriots in Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that in the evening of 19 July 1989, some 1,000 Greek Cypriot demonstrators, mostly women, forced their way into the UN buffer zone in the Ayios Kassianos area of Nicosia.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that the demonstrators broke through a wire barrier maintained by UNFICYP and destroyed an UNFICYP observation post.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that the demonstrators broke through the line formed by UNFICYP soldiers and entered a former school complex where UNFICYP reinforcements regrouped to prevent them from proceeding further.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that a short while later, Turkish-Cypriot police and security forces elements forced their way into the area and apprehended 111 persons, 101 of them women.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that the Ayios Kassianos school complex is situated in the UN buffer zone, but the Turkish forces claim it to be on their side of the cease-fire line.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that under working arrangements with UNFICYP, the Turkish-Cypriot security forces had patrolled the Ayios Kassianos school grounds for several years within specific restrictions, and that this patrolling ceased altogether as part of the unmanning agreement implemented in May 1989.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that in the afternoon of 21 July 1989, some 300 Greek Cypriots gathered at the main entrance to the UN protected area in Nicosia to protest the continuing detention by the Turkish-Cypriot authorities of those apprehended at Ayios Kassianos.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that the demonstrators, whose number fluctuated between 200 and 2,000, blocked all UN traffic through the main entrance to the UN protected area in Nicosia until 30 July 1989, when the Turkish-Cypriot authorities released the last two detainees.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that the events of 19 July 1989 created considerable tension in the island and intensive efforts were made, both at the UN headquarters and at Nicosia, to contain and resolve the situation.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that on 21 July 1989, the UN Secretary General expressed his concern at the events and stressed that it was vital that all parties keep in mind the purpose of the UN buffer zone and their responsibility to ensure that the area was not violated.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that the UN Secretary General urged the Turkish-Cypriot authorities to release without delay all those who had been detained.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that on 24 July 1989, the President of the Security Council announced that he had conveyed to the representatives of all the parties the Security Council's deep concern at the tense situation created by the incidents of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "The UN Secretary General's report of 7 December 1989 states that the President of the Security Council stressed the need strictly to respect the UN buffer zone and appealed for the immediate release of all persons still detained, asking all concerned to show maximum restraint and to take urgent steps to bring about a relaxation of tension.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "C. The UN Secretary General's report"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "The applicant produced 21 photographs taken at different times during the demonstration on 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "Photographs 1 to 7 produced by the applicant were intended to show that, notwithstanding the deployment of the Turkish-Cypriot police, the demonstration of 19 July 1989 was peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "In photographs 8 to 10 produced by the applicant, members of the Turkish-Cypriot police are seen breaking up the UNFICYP cordon during the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The final set of photographs produced by the applicant show members of the Turkish-Cypriot police using force to arrest some of the demonstrators during the demonstration of 19 July 1989.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "D. Photographs of the demonstration"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The English translation of the 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court's judgment of 22 July 1989 indicates that the applicant, together with 9 other men, was charged with entering 'TRNC' territory without permission, contrary to sections 2, 8 and 9 of Law no. 5/72.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The English translation of the 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court's judgment of 22 July 1989 indicates that the applicant, together with 9 other men, was charged with entering 'TRNC' territory other than through an approved port, contrary to subsections 12(1) and (5) of the Aliens and Immigration Law.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court's judgment of 22 July 1989 was given in the presence of the accused and of an interpreter.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that the accused did not accept the charges against them and stated that they did not wish to use the services of a lawyer registered in the 'TRNC'.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that the public prosecutor called five witnesses, whose statements were translated into Greek for the accused's benefit.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that the prosecution witnesses (mainly police officers on duty at the time of the demonstration) declared that the accused had illegally crossed the 'TRNC' border, shouted abuse at the Turkish-Cypriot forces and resisted arrest by pulling and pushing.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that knives and other cutting objects had been found in the bags of some of the demonstrators who had been arrested.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that the accused had been told that they could cross-examine witnesses in turn and, if they so wished, choose one of their number to cross-examine the witnesses on behalf of all the accused.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that during the hearing of evidence, one of the accused put a few questions to one of the prosecution witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that the applicant had stated that he considered the Cypriot coast to be the border and for that reason did not accept that he had violated the border.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court noted that before the District Court gave its sentence, the Bishop of Kitium, speaking on behalf of all the accused, made a statement saying that their struggle had been peaceful, that their aim was to have Greek-Cypriots and Turkish-Cypriots living together in peace, that they had not been carrying weapons and that they had asked for UN protection.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court concluded, relying on statements by the prosecution witnesses, that the accused had crossed the borders of the 'TRNC' at an unapproved entry point and without permission and had resisted by various means the UN and Turkish forces which had tried to stop them.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court found that the prosecution had proved its case beyond reasonable doubt and that the accused were guilty on both counts.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "In deciding on the sentence, the 'TRNC' Nicosia District Court took into account the seriousness of the offence and the fact that the accused had shown no remorse and continued to deny the validity of the 'TRNC'.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. THE DEMONSTRATION OF 19 JULY 1989", "E. Documents pertaining to the applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code defines an unlawful assembly as occurring where five or more persons assemble with intent to commit an offence, or, being assembled with intent to carry out some common purpose, conduct themselves in such a manner as to cause persons in the neighbourhood to fear that the persons so assembled will commit a breach of the peace or will needlessly and without any reasonable occasion provoke other persons to commit a breach of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that it is immaterial that the original assembly was lawful if, being assembled, the persons conduct themselves with a common purpose in such a manner as to cause fear of a breach of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "Section 70 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that when an unlawful assembly has begun to execute its purpose by a breach of the peace and to the terror of the public, the assembly is called a riot and the persons assembled are said to be riotously assembled.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "According to section 71 of the Cypriot Criminal Code, any person who takes part in an unlawful assembly is guilty of a misdemeanour and liable to imprisonment for one year.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "Section 80 of the Cypriot Criminal Code provides that any person who carries in public without lawful occasion any offensive arm or weapon in such a manner as to cause terror to any person is guilty of a misdemeanour, liable to imprisonment for two years, and his arms or weapons shall be forfeited.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "According to section 82 of the Cypriot Criminal Code, it is an offence to carry a knife outside the home.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Cypriot Criminal Code"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "Chapter 155, section 14(1)(b) of the Cypriot Criminal Procedure Law states that any police officer may, without warrant, arrest any person who commits in his presence any offence punishable with imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Police officers' powers of arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "Chapter 155, section 14(1)(c) of the Cypriot Criminal Procedure Law states that any police officer may, without warrant, arrest any person who obstructs a police officer while in the execution of his duty.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Police officers' powers of arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "Section 9 of Law No. 5/72 states that any person who enters a prohibited military area without authorization, or by stealth, or fraudulently, shall be tried by a military court in accordance with the Military Offences Act and those found guilty shall be punished.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "Subsection 12(1) of the Aliens and Immigration Law states that no person shall enter or leave the Colony except through an approved port.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "Subsection 12(5) of the Aliens and Immigration Law states that any person who contravenes or fails to observe any of the provisions of subsections (1), (2), (3) or (4) of section 12 shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months or to a fine not exceeding one hundred pounds or to both such imprisonment and fine.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Offence of illegal entry into \"TRNC\" territory"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": false, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["national_security", "public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F041", "F129", "F130", "F131"], "interference": ["F041", "F129", "F132"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F160", "F163", "F166", "F167", "F146", "F147", "F168", "F169", "F170"], "legitimate_aim": ["F129", "F130", "F131", "F151", "F157"], "necessity": ["F129", "F130", "F131", "F146", "F147", "F151", "F157"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F041", "F129", "F130", "F131"], "interference": ["F041", "F132"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F160", "F163", "F166", "F146"], "legitimate_aim": ["F129", "F130", "F131", "F151"], "necessity": ["F129", "F130", "F131", "F151"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F041", "F129", "F130", "F131", "F151"]}} {"case_name": "case_600", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants in a protest on 6 March 2022 in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The protest on 6 March 2022 in Moscow was against the Russian military attack on Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention in addition to their complaint about disproportionate measures.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_601", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention and the Protocols thereto.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_602", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of the ban on holding lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) public assemblies imposed by the domestic authorities.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of the discriminatory manner in which the domestic authorities treated their applications for holding lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) public events.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "In application no. 13518/10, Mr Sutyagin raised a complaint about the lack of domestic remedies against the alleged violation of his right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_603", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "On 24 February 2014 the applicants participated in a spontaneous gathering in front of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants came to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow to attend a public hearing involving activists who were on trial in relation to mass disorders at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants were arrested during the gathering in front of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants were convicted of administrative offences following their arrest during the gathering on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants' details are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant in application no. 47800/14 was represented before the Court by Mr A. Savelyev, a lawyer practising in Domodedovo.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicants in application no. 67936/14 were represented before the Court by the lawyers of the Memorial Human Rights Centre and the European Human Rights Advocacy Centre (EHRAC).", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant in application no. 68196/14 was represented before the Court by Mr N. Zboroshenko, a lawyer practising in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Russian Government were initially represented before the Court by Mr G. Matyushkin, Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Russian Government were subsequently represented before the Court by Mr M. Galperin, who succeeded Mr G. Matyushkin as Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On the morning of 24 February 2014 the applicants were among some 150 people who came to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicants came to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow to attend the public delivery of the judgment in the criminal case concerning mass disorders at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The court-house of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow was cordoned off by the police on the morning of 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicants could not enter the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow because it was cordoned off by the police.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicants remained outside the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow among other members of the public who were also aspiring to attend the hearing, thus forming a gathering.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Further details about the gathering outside the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow on 24 February 2014 are described in Navalnyy v. Russia [GC], nos. 29580/12 and 4 others, §§ 35-42, 15 November 2018.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "At different times the applicants were arrested and transferred to a police station following the gathering outside the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow on 24 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Details regarding the administrative proceedings against each applicant are outlined in the Appendix.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences provides that violation by a participant in a public event of the established procedure for conducting a public event is punishable with a fine of 10,000 to 20,000 roubles.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences provides that violation by a participant in a public event of the established procedure for conducting a public event is punishable with up to forty hours of community work.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "A summary of other relevant domestic provisions is set out in Navalnyy v. Russia [GC], nos. 29580/12 and 4 others, §§ 46-47, 15 November 2018.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "A summary of other relevant domestic provisions is set out in Lashmankin and Others v. Russia, nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, §§ 223 and 226, 7 February 2017.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "A summary of other relevant domestic provisions is set out in Korneyeva v. Russia, no. 72051/17, §§ 22-26, 8 October 2019.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The domestic legal provisions governing administrative transfer (escorting) and detention are set out in Butkevich v. Russia, no. 5865/07, §§ 33-36, 13 February 2018.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to Article 31.9 of the Code of Administrative Offences, if a decision imposing an administrative punishment is not enforced during two years from its entry into force, it can no longer be executed.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to Article 31.9 of the Code of Administrative Offences, the time when enforcement of a decision imposing an administrative punishment is suspended or stayed is excluded from the two-year period after which the decision can no longer be executed.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F012", "F016", "F017", "F013"], "interference": ["F003", "F018", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F003", "F018", "F004", "F016", "F013"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F016", "F013"], "interference": ["F018", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F016", "F013", "F018", "F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F016", "F013", "F018", "F004"]}} {"case_name": "case_604", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_606", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1943.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lived in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 24 November 2006, the applicant announced to the Budapest Police Department his intention to organise a demonstration on 9 December 2006 on Kossuth Square in Budapest, in front of Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The announcement of 24 November 2006 was made as required by the Assembly Act 1989.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 26 November 2006, the Budapest Police Department refused to deal with the applicant's application to organise a demonstration on Kossuth Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 23 October 2006, the Budapest Police Department declared the area of Kossuth Square a 'security operational zone' (biztonsági műveleti terület) for an indefinite period of time.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Budapest Police Department declared Kossuth Square a 'security operational zone' in view of the tumultuous events in Budapest in September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The Budapest Police Department observed that the designation of Kossuth Square as a 'security operational zone' placed it outside the Budapest Police Department's jurisdiction as regards the prohibition of, or acquiescence in, a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 6 December 2006, the Budapest Regional Court dismissed the applicant's request for judicial review of the Budapest Police Department's refusal to deal with the application.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court, in dismissing the applicant's request for judicial review on 6 December 2006, observed that no decision on the merits of the case had ever been adopted by the administrative authorities, which excluded such a review.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 11 December 2006, the Deputy Head of the National Police Department dismissed the applicant's further complaint.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 19 December 2006, the applicant filed an action with the Budapest Regional Court challenging the decision of 23 October 2006 declaring Kossuth Square a 'security operational zone'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 19 December 2006, the applicant filed an action with the Budapest Regional Court challenging the decision of 11 December 2006 by the Deputy Head of the National Police Department.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 11 January 2007, the Head of Budapest Police dismissed the applicant's renewed complaint.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 12 February 2007, the Deputy Head of the National Police Department partly reversed the Head of Budapest Police's decision of 11 January 2007.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 12 February 2007, the Deputy Head of the National Police Department instructed the Budapest Police Department to substitute the indefinite 'security operational zone' measure with one of definite duration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 5 March 2007, the Budapest Regional Court dismissed the applicant's action arising from the decisions of 11 January 2007 and 12 February 2007.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "In dismissing the applicant's action on 5 March 2007, the Budapest Regional Court essentially endorsed the police authorities' earlier reasoning.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court pointed out on 5 March 2007 that the proceedings only concerned the police's decision on non-competence and did not constitute a review of the police's original decision declaring Kossuth Square a 'security operational zone'.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Upon a further complaint by the applicant, on 18 March 2008 the Budapest Regional Court quashed the decisions of 11 January 2007 and 12 February 2007.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 18 March 2008, the Budapest Regional Court remitted the case to the National Police Department.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "In reaction to the applicant's petition for review, on 29 April 2009 the Supreme Court quashed the Budapest Regional Court's decision of 18 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 29 April 2009, the Supreme Court remitted the case to the Budapest Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court's procedure was interrupted on 1 October 2009 on account of the applicant's death.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant's son and heir joined the proceedings before the Budapest Regional Court as successor on 25 August 2011.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Government submitted that the subject matter of the litigation pending before the Budapest Regional Court was the police's original decision declaring Kossuth Square a 'security operational zone'.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Proceedings initiated by the applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "In a case concerning the same area (Kossuth Square), on 29 January 2007 a Mr K. challenged the police's decision to declare Kossuth Square a 'security operational zone'.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 14 March 2007, the Budapest Police Commander rejected Mr K.'s complaint challenging the declaration of Kossuth Square as a 'security operational zone'.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Budapest Police Commander's decision of 14 March 2007 rejecting Mr K.'s complaint was quashed by the National Commander on 16 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "In the resumed administrative proceedings, on 22 June 2007 the Budapest Police Commander again rejected Mr K.'s complaint challenging the declaration of Kossuth Square as a 'security operational zone'.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 19 July 2007, the National Commander upheld the Budapest Police Commander's decision of 22 June 2007 rejecting Mr K.'s complaint.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Mr K. challenged the National Commander's ruling of 19 July 2007 in court.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "Mr K.'s action challenging the National Commander's ruling of 19 July 2007 was dismissed by the Budapest Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On appeal, the Supreme Court quashed the Budapest Regional Court's decision dismissing Mr K.'s action.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On appeal, the Supreme Court quashed the National Commander's decision of 19 July 2007.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "In the resumed second-instance administrative proceedings, on 23 December 2009 the National Commander again upheld the Budapest Police Commander's decision rejecting Mr K.'s complaint about the declaration of Kossuth Square as a 'security operational zone'.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Mr K. requested judicial review of the National Commander's decision of 23 December 2009.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 11 November 2010, the Budapest Regional Court issued judgment no. 27.K.31.354/2010/9., quashing both the first-instance and the second-instance administrative decisions concerning the declaration of Kossuth Square as a 'security operational zone'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 11 November 2010, the Budapest Regional Court remitted the case to the Budapest Police Commander.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court in judgment no. 27.K.31.354/2010/9. pointed out that the impugned administrative decisions did not contain any concrete elements establishing the necessity and proportionality of maintaining the 'security operational zone' after the prolongation of 22 November 2006.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Budapest Regional Court in judgment no. 27.K.31.354/2010/9. pointed out that the impugned administrative decisions did not address Mr K.'s suggestion that the mere fencing-off of Parliament's immediate vicinity, rather than the global ban on Kossuth Square, would have been sufficient in the circumstances.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "In the resumed first-instance administrative proceedings, on 4 April 2011 the Budapest Police Commander partly sustained Mr K.'s complaint concerning the declaration of Kossuth Square as a 'security operational zone'.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 4 April 2011, the Budapest Police Commander noted that, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, the proportionality of the 'security operational zone' measure had successfully been challenged by Mr K.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Proceedings initiated by Mr K."]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F005", "F006", "F008"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F006", "F027", "F038", "F040", "F042", "F043"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003"], "interference": ["F005", "F006", "F008"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F006", "F038", "F040", "F043"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F006", "F038", "F040", "F043"]}} {"case_name": "case_609", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1953.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Sumgayit.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant is a person with a Category 2 disability.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant receives a disability pension.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 6 November 2005 parliamentary elections were held in Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Following the announcement of the results of the parliamentary elections of 6 November 2005, the opposition electoral coalition Azadliq decided to hold demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The demonstrations organised by Azadliq were intended to protest against alleged irregularities during the parliamentary elections of 6 November 2005.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 26 November 2005 Azadliq held a demonstration at Galaba Square in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The demonstration on 26 November 2005 at Galaba Square was scheduled from 3 p.m. to 5 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The demonstration on 26 November 2005 at Galaba Square was held to protest against alleged election irregularities.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Shortly after 5 p.m. on 26 November 2005, police began an operation to forcibly disperse the demonstrators at Galaba Square in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The police began the dispersal operation because the demonstration had continued beyond the authorised time-limit.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The dispersal operation on 26 November 2005 was conducted by riot police units.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The riot police units conducting the dispersal operation on 26 November 2005 were fully equipped with helmets, shields and truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant and her family participated in the demonstration on 26 November 2005 at Galaba Square in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the applicant, at around 4.45 p.m. on 26 November 2005 she was walking slowly to the edge of Galaba Square to wait for her husband to join her so that they could go home.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the applicant, she suddenly saw demonstrators beginning to run away from Galaba Square in a chaotic manner.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the applicant, at the same moment she saw demonstrators running away, she was hit on the head and back several times from behind.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the applicant, when she turned round after being hit, she was kicked in the chest and abdomen area.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the applicant, she managed to see that the persons who had kicked her were police officers in uniform equipped with a shield and truncheon.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the applicant, she lost consciousness and fell to the ground after being kicked by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Several news agencies managed to take photographs of the applicant lying unconscious on the ground surrounded by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Some of the photographs of the applicant lying unconscious on the ground were published in various newspapers and other news outlets.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant lay in the same spot at Galaba Square for an unspecified period of time.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant lost and regained consciousness several times while lying on the ground at Galaba Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the applicant, when she was conscious she saw several civilians trying to help her.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicant, the attempts by civilians to help her were actively prevented by the riot police and their police dogs.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the applicant, for a long time the riot police did not allow the ambulance units stationed at Galaba Square to provide her with any assistance.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the applicant, she was finally taken to hospital only after a number of civilians had urged the riot police to allow this.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The applicant was admitted to hospital at 6.30 p.m. on 26 November 2005.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The medical record concerning the applicant identifies her as Tahirova Surayya Musa gizi, born in 1953, living in Sumgayit, not working.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The medical record states that the applicant was admitted to hospital at 6.30–6.35 p.m. on 26 November 2005.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The medical record states that the applicant left the hospital on 27 November 2005.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The medical record records the applicant's full diagnosis as blunt trauma of the abdomen and diabetes.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The medical record states that the applicant was admitted to hospital with pain under the left ribs and general weakness.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "According to the medical record, the applicant stated that she had been beaten up by police officers at Galaba Square on 26 November 2005 at around 5 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The medical record states that the applicant was taken to hospital from the scene of the incident by an ambulance.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The medical record states that on objective examination, on palpation the abdomen was not hard and was involved in respiration.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The medical record states that there was a little sharp pain under the applicant's left ribs on palpation.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The medical record states that ultrasound examination did not reveal free liquid or traumatic changes in the applicant's abdomen.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The medical record states that no fracture was apparent in the left part of the applicant's rib cage during X-ray examination.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The medical record states that the applicant was transferred for further examination and dynamic observation to the Reanimation and Intensive Therapy Department.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The medical record states that on 27 November 2005, at the request of the applicant and her relatives, she left the hospital in a stable condition.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant spent the night of 26–27 November 2005 in hospital and received in-patient treatment.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant's condition was stabilised and she was discharged from hospital the morning of 27 November 2005.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Events of 26 November 2005"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On an unspecified date the applicant lodged a civil action against the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant's civil action against the Ministry of Internal Affairs sought compensation for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage caused by ill-treatment and breach of her right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant argued that the riot police units of the Ministry of Internal Affairs had used unlawful, unjustified and excessive force against her.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicant argued that the riot police units of the Ministry of Internal Affairs had failed to comply with their duty to provide urgent medical assistance to persons injured as a result of the use of force.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In support of her civil claims, the applicant submitted copies of the relevant medical documents and photographs of the incident.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "In the course of the civil proceedings, the representative of the Ministry of Internal Affairs rejected the applicant's claim.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The representative of the Ministry of Internal Affairs submitted that the duration of the demonstration on 26 November 2005 had been determined in advance, scheduled to begin at 3 p.m. and end at 5 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The representative of the Ministry of Internal Affairs submitted that the demonstrators stayed at Galaba Square beyond 5 p.m. with the intention of continuing the demonstration unlawfully.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The representative of the Ministry of Internal Affairs submitted that soldiers of Internal Troops were not present at Galaba Square and that only police officers and the Riot Police Regiment were at the square.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The representative of the Ministry of Internal Affairs submitted that police officers asked demonstrators with loudspeakers to leave Galaba Square after the end of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The representative of the Ministry of Internal Affairs submitted that the police officers did not infringe the requirements of the legislation.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The representative of the Ministry of Internal Affairs was silent as to the applicant's particular complaint about her ill-treatment by the police.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 31 March 2006 the Sabayil District Court dismissed the applicant's civil claim.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Sabayil District Court found that the applicant had failed to prove her allegations, in particular that she had been beaten or had otherwise sustained physical or psychological damage as a result of the police actions.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Sabayil District Court held, without further explanation, that the medical record and photographs submitted to the court did not constitute proof of the applicant's allegations.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Sabayil District Court held that the forcible dispersal of the demonstration on 26 November 2005 was lawful because the demonstrators had stayed at Galaba Square beyond 5 p.m., the time-limit permitted by the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Sabayil District Court's judgment cited Article 7 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of the Republic of Azerbaijan, which provides the possibility to place restrictions on freedom of assembly for the prevention of disorder or crimes, for the protection of public interests and state security, and for the protection of other interests necessary in a democratic society.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Sabayil District Court's judgment cited Article 14 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of the Republic of Azerbaijan, which entitles police authorities to warn organisers and participants that force will be used if an order to suspend the assembly and for its participants to disperse is not executed, and to use appropriate force to ensure the suspension of the assembly and the dispersal of its participants.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Sabayil District Court found that the applicant had failed to submit any evidence proving that the police dispersed the gathering of 26 November 2005 before 5 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Sabayil District Court found that police officers did not intervene in the demonstration until 5 p.m. and, only after the end of the determined period and following numerous warnings, the demonstrators were dispersed.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Sabayil District Court found that the applicant had failed to submit reliable evidence proving that she was injured because she had been beaten by the police and as a result lost consciousness and fell to the ground.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 5 June 2006 the applicant appealed against the Sabayil District Court's judgment of 31 March 2006, reiterating her complaints.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "In her appeal, the applicant noted that the Sabayil District Court had not examined in detail copies of the relevant medical documents and photographs, which showed that she had been ill-treated by the police.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 11 August 2006 the Court of Appeal upheld the Sabayil District Court's judgment of 31 March 2006.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Court of Appeal's judgment of 11 August 2006 is almost identical in its wording to the Sabayil District Court's judgment and reiterates the same reasons for the dismissal of the applicant's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 12 December 2006 the Supreme Court of Azerbaijan upheld the judgments of the Sabayil District Court and the Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The proceedings before the domestic courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Article 46(III) of the Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan provides that no one shall be subjected to torture or ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Article 46(III) of the Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan provides that no one shall be subjected to degrading treatment or punishment.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Article 49(I) of the Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan provides that everyone has the right to freely assemble together with others.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Article 49(II) of the Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan provides that everyone has the right, upon notification to relevant Government bodies in advance, to assemble peacefully with others, without arms, and to hold rallies, meetings, demonstrations, street marches and pickets.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. The Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Article 1 of the Law on Police of 28 October 1999 defines special equipments as truncheons, arm-restraining instruments, tear gas, rubber bullets, water cannons, special devices for forcible stopping of vehicles and other special equipments provided by the legislation of the Republic of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Police of 28 October 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Article 26(VI) of the Law on Police of 28 October 1999 provides that use of physical force, special equipments or firearms in cases of extreme necessity shall be proportionate to the danger posed.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Police of 28 October 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Article 26(VII) of the Law on Police of 28 October 1999 provides that the relevant police authorities must carry out an inquiry into every incident involving the use of physical force, special equipments or firearms by a police officer and must issue a pertinent opinion on its lawfulness.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Police of 28 October 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "Article 26(IX) of the Law on Police of 28 October 1999 provides that unlawful use of physical force, special equipments or firearms by a police officer entails the officer's responsibility under the relevant legislation.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Police of 28 October 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "Article 27(I)(1) of the Law on Police of 28 October 1999 provides that a police officer should use physical force, special equipments or firearms against a person only in the event of absolute necessity or necessary self-defence, after all other means of coercion have failed to produce the required result, and in proportion to the gravity of the offence and the personality of the offender.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Police of 28 October 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Article 27(I)(5) of the Law on Police of 28 October 1999 provides that a police officer must provide the necessary medical aid to anyone injured as a result of the use of physical force, special equipments or firearms.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Police of 28 October 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Article 27(I)(7) of the Law on Police of 28 October 1999 provides that a police officer must report in writing to the police office where he or she serves or to the police office of the area where firearms have been used, on the occasions he or she used physical force, special equipments or firearms.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Police of 28 October 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Article 27(I)(8) of the Law on Police of 28 October 1999 provides that a police officer must inform the relevant prosecutor in writing of any use of physical force, special equipments or firearms within twenty-four hours.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Law on Police of 28 October 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Article 37.1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of Azerbaijan provides that, depending on the nature and severity of the offence, criminal prosecution shall be carried out in the form of private, public-private or public charges.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCrP\"), as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Article 37.2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of Azerbaijan provides that a private criminal prosecution shall take place only upon a complaint by the victim concerning offences under Articles 147 (defamation), 148 (insult), 165.1 (infringement of copyrights and related rights) and 166.1 (infringement of patent and invention rights) of the Criminal Code, and shall be discontinued in the event of reconciliation between the victim and the accused before the court deliberates.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCrP\"), as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Article 37.3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of Azerbaijan provides that a public-private criminal prosecution shall take place upon a complaint by the victim or, in the circumstances provided for in Article 37.5, on the initiative of the prosecutor for offences including Articles 127 (deliberate infliction of less serious injury to health), 128 (deliberate infliction of minor injury to health), 131.1 (infliction of less serious injury to health by negligence), 132–134 (beating; ill-treatment; death threat or threat of infliction of serious injury to health) and other specified articles of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCrP\"), as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Article 37.5.2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of Azerbaijan provides that where no complaint is made by the victim, a public-private criminal prosecution may be initiated by the prosecutor if the offence was committed by or against a representative of the authority or other officials of State authorities.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCrP\"), as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Article 37.6 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of Azerbaijan provides that in respect of offences not provided for in Articles 37.2 and 37.3, criminal prosecution shall be carried out in the form of public charges.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCrP\"), as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Article 39.1.8 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of Azerbaijan provides that a criminal prosecution may not be launched or, if already launched, shall be discontinued if the victim has not lodged a complaint in the case of a private prosecution or if the prosecutor does not take the initiative in launching the criminal prosecution in the case of public-private charges.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCrP\"), as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Article 46.1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of Azerbaijan provides that there shall be proper reason and grounds for the institution of criminal proceedings relating to a public or semi-public prosecution.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCrP\"), as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Article 46.2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of Azerbaijan provides that the reason for instituting criminal proceedings may be an application from an individual, information from a legal entity (official) or the media, or information directly obtained by the investigator or the prosecutor, concerning an offence committed or in preparation.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. The Code of Criminal Procedure (\"the CCrP\"), as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Article 7 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides that any restriction on freedom of assembly may be placed only by law and for the purposes of protection of interests necessary in a democratic society, including: protection of the interests of public and state security; prevention of disturbance of public order; prevention of disorder or crime; protection of the health of the population; protection of morals; and protection of the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Article 14.I.3 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides that the police have the right to suspend an assembly, if the need arises, when the conduct of the assembly does not meet the conditions provided in the prior written notification.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Article 14.II of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides that the police have the right to inform organisers of and participants in an assembly of its suspension and dispersal, to order organisers and participants to use all available means for suspension of the assembly and dispersal of participants, to warn organisers and participants that force will be used if an order to suspend the assembly and for its participants to disperse is not executed, and to use appropriate force to ensure the suspension of the assembly and the dispersal of its participants.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Article 14.6 of the Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998 provides that use of physical force or special equipments by the police should in any case be proportional to the danger in question.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "D. Law on Freedom of Assembly of 13 November 1998, as in force at the material time"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Article 3 of the Code of Conduct for Law Enforcement Officials (adopted by the UN General Assembly Resolution 34/169 of 17 November 1979) provides that law enforcement officials may use force only when strictly necessary and to the extent required for the performance of their duty.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND REPORTS", "A. Basic principles on the use of force adopted by the United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Article 5 of the Code of Conduct for Law Enforcement Officials (adopted by the UN General Assembly Resolution 34/169 of 17 November 1979) provides that no law enforcement official may inflict, instigate or tolerate any act of torture or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, nor may any law enforcement official invoke superior orders or exceptional circumstances as a justification of torture or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND REPORTS", "A. Basic principles on the use of force adopted by the United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Principle 13 of the Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials (adopted by the Eighth UN Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders, Havana, Cuba, 27 August to 7 September 1990) provides that in the dispersal of assemblies that are unlawful but non-violent, law enforcement officials shall avoid the use of force or, where that is not practicable, shall restrict such force to the minimum extent necessary.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND REPORTS", "A. Basic principles on the use of force adopted by the United Nations"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The OSCE/ODIHR Election Observation Mission Final Report on the parliamentary elections of 6 November 2005 (dated 1 February 2006) states that on 9, 13 and 19 November 2005 Azadliq organised and received permission to hold rallies at Galaba Square to protest election irregularities, and that no serious incidents were reported.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND REPORTS", "B. Reports by international bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The OSCE/ODIHR Election Observation Mission Final Report on the parliamentary elections of 6 November 2005 (dated 1 February 2006) states that Azadliq and other opposition parties organised another protest meeting on 26 November 2005 at Galaba Square.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND REPORTS", "B. Reports by international bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The OSCE/ODIHR Election Observation Mission Final Report on the parliamentary elections of 6 November 2005 (dated 1 February 2006) states that the 26 November 2005 protest meeting at Galaba Square took place after the departure of the Election Observation Mission from Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND REPORTS", "B. Reports by international bodies"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The OSCE/ODIHR Election Observation Mission Final Report on the parliamentary elections of 6 November 2005 (dated 1 February 2006) states that police dispersed the participants of the 26 November 2005 meeting at Galaba Square using considerable force, immediately after expiration of the allotted time for the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS AND REPORTS", "B. Reports by international bodies"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F008", "F009", "F010", "F012", "F015"], "interference": ["F011", "F015"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F092", "F093", "F094"], "legitimate_aim": ["F012"], "necessity": ["F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F016"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F008", "F009", "F012", "F015"], "interference": ["F011", "F015"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F092", "F094"], "legitimate_aim": ["F012"], "necessity": ["F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F016"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F008", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016"]}} {"case_name": "case_611", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_614", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants attempted to participate in a public event in support of LGBTI people.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The public event in support of LGBTI people was authorised to take place on 12 October 2013 in St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The facts related to the public event on 12 October 2013 in St Petersburg were examined by the Court in Berkman v. Russia (no. 46712/15, 1 December 2020).", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The public event on 12 October 2013 in St Petersburg was disrupted by violent counter-demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The police present at the public event on 12 October 2013 arrested a group of participants in the event.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants were among the group of participants arrested by the police at the public event on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicants were transferred to a police station following their arrest at the public event on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicants were charged with disorderly misconduct (use of foul language), an offence under Article 20.1 of the Federal Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 21 November 2013, the court terminated the administrative proceedings against the second applicant for the lack of elements of an administrative offence in her acts.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 18 December 2013, the court terminated the administrative proceedings against the first applicant for the lack of elements of an administrative offence in her acts.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 24 February 2014, the first applicant lodged a civil claim against police and other authorities with the Primorskiy District Court of St Petersburg.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The first applicant's civil claim challenged the lawfulness of her arrest and detention at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The first applicant's civil claim alleged that her arrest and detention infringed, among others, her right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The first applicant's civil claim alleged that her arrest and detention infringed, among others, her right not to be discriminated against.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 24 April 2014, the Primorskiy District Court of St Petersburg dismissed the first applicant's civil claim.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Primorskiy District Court of St Petersburg considered that the first applicant's arrest and transfer to the police station had been lawful because she had refused to show her ID documents to the police.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 6 October 2014, the St Petersburg City Court upheld the Primorskiy District Court's judgment of 24 April 2014 on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court stressed that there had been tension between the participants of the gathering and counter-demonstrators during the event on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court stressed that there had been a breach of public order during the event on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court held that the first applicant's arrest and transfer to the police station had been justified for the purposes of facilitating subsequent administrative proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The St Petersburg City Court held that the fact that the administrative proceedings against the first applicant had later been terminated had not invalidated the lawfulness of the first applicant's arrest.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 6 February 2015, the St Petersburg City Court dismissed the first applicant's cassation appeal against the Primorskiy District Court judgment of 24 April 2014 and the St Petersburg City Court appeal decision of 6 October 2014.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On an unspecified date in 2014, the second applicant brought civil proceedings against the State.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The second applicant claimed that her arrest at the venue of the gathering on 12 October 2013 had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The second applicant claimed that her transfer to the police station following her arrest had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The second applicant claimed that the police had failed to ensure public order during the gathering on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The second applicant claimed that the police had failed to ensure the safety of participants in the gathering on 12 October 2013.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The second applicant claimed non-pecuniary damage in the amount of 225,000 Russian roubles (approximately 3,100 euros at the time).", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 16 December 2014, the Petrogradskiy District Court of St Petersburg partly granted the second applicant's civil claim.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Petrogradskiy District Court of St Petersburg found that the second applicant's arrest and transfer to the police station had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Petrogradskiy District Court of St Petersburg awarded the second applicant 2,000 Russian roubles (about 28 euros at the time) in compensation.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Petrogradskiy District Court of St Petersburg dismissed the remainder of the second applicant's claims concerning police inaction for the lack of evidence.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The second applicant's subsequent appeals against the Petrogradskiy District Court judgment of 16 December 2014 were dismissed.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The final decision dismissing the second applicant's appeals against the Petrogradskiy District Court judgment of 16 December 2014 was delivered by the Supreme Court of Russia on 22 January 2016.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicants complained under Article 5 of the Convention that their arrest had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicants complained under Article 5 of the Convention that their transfer to the police station had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicants complained under Article 5 of the Convention that their subsequent detention at the police station for several hours had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicants complained under Article 11 of the Convention, taken alone, that the authorities had failed to enable the public gathering on 12 October 2013 to proceed peacefully.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicants complained under Article 11 of the Convention, taken alone, that the authorities' interference with the applicants' freedom of peaceful assembly had been arbitrary.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicants complained under Article 11 of the Convention in conjunction with Article 14 of the Convention that the authorities had failed to enable the public gathering on 12 October 2013 to proceed peacefully.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicants complained under Article 11 of the Convention in conjunction with Article 14 of the Convention that the authorities' interference with the applicants' freedom of peaceful assembly had been arbitrary.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicants complained under Article 11 of the Convention in conjunction with Article 14 of the Convention that the police arrested only the participants in the LGBTI public event and disregarded the breaches of public order by their opponents.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002", "F004", "F005", "F006"], "interference": ["F005", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F039"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F005", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F016", "F020", "F021", "F039", "F042"], "positive_obligation": ["F004", "F005", "F026", "F027", "F038", "F040", "F042"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F001", "F002", "F004"], "interference": ["F005", "F006", "F007"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F009", "F010", "F042"], "positive_obligation": ["F004", "F005", "F042"]}, "list3": ["F001", "F002", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F009", "F010", "F042"]}} {"case_name": "case_615", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1945.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was the President of Armenia between 1991 and 1998.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 19 February 2008 a presidential election was held in Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant was running as the main opposition candidate in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant's main opponent in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election was the then Prime Minister, Mr Sargsyan.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Mr Sargsyan represented the ruling party in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Mr Sargsyan was a close ally of the outgoing President, Mr Kocharyan.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Immediately after the announcement of the preliminary results of the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election, the applicant called on his supporters to gather at Freedom Square in central Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicant called on his supporters to gather at Freedom Square in central Yerevan in order to protest against irregularities which had allegedly occurred in the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election process.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant announced that the 19 February 2008 Armenian presidential election had not been free and fair.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "From 20 February 2008 onwards, nationwide daily protest rallies were held by the applicant's supporters.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The main meeting place of the applicant's supporters during the post-election protest rallies from 20 February 2008 onwards was Freedom Square and the surrounding park in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The rallies at Freedom Square were held during the daytime and late into the night, and attracted at times tens of thousands of people.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Several hundred demonstrators stayed at Freedom Square around the clock, having set up a camp.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicant participated in the post-election rallies in his capacity as opposition leader and presidential candidate.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant gave speeches two to three times a day on issues of political and public interest during the post-election rallies.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant regularly called on his supporters to continue the mass protests during the post-election rallies.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant stayed at Freedom Square around the clock during the post-election rallies, leaving only for two to three hours a day.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 23 February 2008 the outgoing President Mr Kocharyan held individual meetings with the chief of police, chief of the army and chief of national security.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 23 February 2008 the outgoing President Mr Kocharyan announced that he would not allow anybody to destabilise the situation in Armenia and gave instructions to that effect.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant alleged that, following the outgoing President Mr Kocharyan's meetings on 23 February 2008, persecution had begun against many of the applicant's supporters.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant alleged that various political and public figures who had expressed their support for his candidacy were arrested and charged on various grounds.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The applicant alleged that members of his election campaign were arrested and charged on various grounds.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The applicant alleged that many of his supporters in the regions were subjected to ill-treatment and psychological pressure at police stations.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicant alleged that many of his supporters in the regions were dismissed from work or deprived of social benefits.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant alleged that his telephone conversations and those of his supporters were tapped.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant alleged that various party premises were searched.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 24 February 2008 the Central Election Commission of Armenia announced that Mr Sargsyan had won the 19 February 2008 presidential election with around 52% of all votes cast.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 24 February 2008 the Central Election Commission of Armenia announced that the applicant had received around 21% of votes in the 19 February 2008 presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 29 February 2008 the post-election rallies were still in full swing.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "By 29 February 2008 all international election observers had left Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicant alleged that the Armenian authorities had deliberately waited for the departure of the international election observers before starting their unlawful dispersal of the assembly at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 29 February 2008 the applicant applied to the Constitutional Court of Armenia, contesting the results of the 19 February 2008 presidential election and seeking to annul them.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The 19 February 2008 presidential election and the post-election demonstrations"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant alleged that on 1 March 2008 at around 6 a.m. the police arrived at Freedom Square in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicant alleged that at the time the police arrived at Freedom Square on 1 March 2008 at around 6 a.m., he had been asleep in his car parked at the square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicant alleged that most of the demonstrators camping at Freedom Square were also asleep when the police arrived on 1 March 2008 at around 6 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant alleged that news spread that the police were in the vicinity of Freedom Square and the demonstrators began to waken.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The applicant alleged that he was woken by his bodyguard and walked to one of the statues situated in the centre of Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The applicant alleged that by the time he walked to one of the statues in the centre of Freedom Square, the police forces had already encircled the several hundred demonstrators based on the square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicant alleged that the police forces started making a loud noise by banging their rubber batons against their shields, which spread panic among the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicant alleged that some demonstrators managed to switch on the microphones and the lights on Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The applicant alleged that he addressed the demonstrators from a platform at Freedom Square, saying: \"We see that police forces have arrived on the square. Please, do not have any contact with them and do not touch them. Please, keep your distance from them. Let us wait and see what they want from us. If they have something to tell us, we are ready to listen. Please, be patient and peaceful\".", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant alleged that the demonstrators followed his request and kept their distance from the police forces.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant alleged that the police forces had surrounded the demonstrators with a triple cordon.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicant alleged that suddenly, without any prior warning or orders to disperse, the police forces, shouting loudly, attacked the demonstrators at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant alleged that the police forces violently beat the demonstrators with rubber batons and destroyed the camp at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant alleged that in a matter of minutes the demonstrators were pushed out of Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicant alleged that the demonstrators tried to save themselves by fleeing from the police officers who chased, beat and kicked them brutally, regardless of their age and gender.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The applicant alleged that while he was on the platform at Freedom Square, he was approached by the Head of the State Protection Department (SPD) of the National Security Service, who was also the chief of the Armenian President's bodyguard team, and other SPD officers.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The applicant alleged that the Head of the SPD and other SPD officers surrounded the applicant and his bodyguards and then forcibly took them to one of the central statues on Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The applicant alleged that at one of the central statues on Freedom Square, he was ordered to sit on a bench surrounded only by SPD officers.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The applicant alleged that after Freedom Square was cleared of all demonstrators, the Head of the SPD approached the applicant and ordered him to leave the square.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The applicant alleged that he refused to comply with the order to leave Freedom Square, saying that he would not leave the square voluntarily and that they could make him do so only by arresting him.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The applicant alleged that after further attempts to make him leave Freedom Square failed, the Head of the SPD forced the applicant into a car and took him to his house in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The applicant alleged that once at his house in Yerevan, he was not allowed to leave the territory of his house and garden.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicant alleged that the roads to his house were blocked by special police forces, SPD officers, the road traffic police and other police units.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicant alleged that block posts were set up and all vehicles heading to and from his house were checked and searched.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicant alleged that no one could reach him or go in or out of his home without the permission of the special forces.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The applicant alleged that the special forces, after carrying out a search of visitors and their vehicles, reported their identity and the purpose of their visit to an unidentified superior and allowed visitors to go in and out only after receiving instructions from that person.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "After Freedom Square was cleared of demonstrators, some of them relocated to the area near the French Embassy in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The demonstrators who relocated near the French Embassy were later joined by thousands of others who apparently poured into the streets of Yerevan in response to the events of the early morning of 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The rallies on 1 March 2008 continued throughout Yerevan until late at night, involving clashes between protesters and law enforcement officers.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The clashes between protesters and law enforcement officers on 1 March 2008 in Yerevan resulted in ten deaths, including eight civilians.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The clashes between protesters and law enforcement officers on 1 March 2008 in Yerevan resulted in numerous injured persons.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Following the events of 1 March 2008, the outgoing President Mr Kocharyan declared a state of emergency.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The state of emergency declared by the outgoing President Mr Kocharyan prohibited the holding of any further rallies and other mass public events for a period of twenty days.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Government alleged that the reason for the police operation of 1 March 2008 at Freedom Square was information obtained the day before by the law enforcement authorities, according to which a large number of weapons were to be distributed to the protesters to incite provocative actions and mass disorder in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Government alleged that members of the relevant police force arrived on Freedom Square at around 7 a.m. on 1 March 2008 to verify information about weapons being distributed to protesters.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Government alleged that the police met with resistance from the demonstrators at Freedom Square, who attacked the police officers with wooden bats, metal rods and stones.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Government alleged that once violence had erupted on Freedom Square, the applicant was surrounded on the platform by the Head of the SPD and other SPD officers because his security was in danger.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was taken to the edge of Freedom Square, about 20 to 30 metres away from the platform, where he sat on a bench surrounded by SPD officers.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Government alleged that after the assembly at Freedom Square was terminated, the applicant, who was still sitting on the bench, was advised by the Head of the SPD to go home, but he refused.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Government alleged that during the time the applicant was sitting on the bench at Freedom Square, a journalist freely approached the applicant, interviewed him and left.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was again advised by the Head of the SPD to go home but did not respond.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Government alleged that an SPD car then approached and the applicant got into the car voluntarily and was taken by SPD officers to his home in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Government alleged that while being taken home, the applicant did not express any wish to go elsewhere.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The Government alleged that later in the afternoon of 1 March 2008, additional SPD and police forces were stationed near the applicant's house as part of special security measures employed in respect of all persons under State protection, because of the escalating violence in Yerevan.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The Government alleged that for security reasons SPD officers were instructed to search everyone entering the applicant's house, but were never instructed to prohibit anyone from entering the house or to prevent the applicant from leaving.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant expressed the wish to leave his house and to join the demonstrators near the French Embassy only once, on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant was told by the Head of the SPD that he was free to leave and go wherever he wanted, but the SPD would not be able to ensure his security in the area near the French Embassy and would not accompany him there.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant did not wish to leave his house without State protection.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "On 1 March 2008 the Secretary General of the Council of Europe issued a press release expressing concern about reports of injuries during the security forces' operation to disperse protesters in Yerevan that morning.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "In the press release of 1 March 2008, the Secretary General of the Council of Europe stated that if reports of injuries during the security forces' operation were confirmed, all allegations of excessive force should be properly investigated.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "In the press release of 1 March 2008, the Secretary General of the Council of Europe stated that it was vital to prevent any further violence.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "In the press release of 1 March 2008, the Secretary General of the Council of Europe stated that he was alarmed by reports that the runner-up in the recent presidential elections, former President Levon Ter-Petrosyan (the applicant), had been put under house arrest.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "In the press release of 1 March 2008, the Secretary General of the Council of Europe stated that if the applicant was under house arrest, he should be immediately released.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "In the press release of 1 March 2008, the Secretary General of the Council of Europe stated that if the applicant was accused of committing a crime, he should be properly charged and prosecuted in a court of law like anyone else.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "In the press release of 1 March 2008, the Secretary General of the Council of Europe stated that in a democracy you cannot arbitrarily detain political opponents.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 1 March 2008 the State Protection Department (SPD) of the National Security Service issued a statement that was broadcast on the public television channel of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The SPD statement broadcast on 1 March 2008 stated that SPD officers had decided to remove the applicant from Freedom Square pursuant to Section 6 § 3 of the Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection, in order to ensure his safety as a former President of Armenia subject to State protection.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The SPD statement broadcast on 1 March 2008 stated that the applicant had been removed from Freedom Square and taken to his house, which was similarly to be protected by the SPD pursuant to Section 12 (2) of the Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The SPD statement broadcast on 1 March 2008 stated that the SPD had warned the applicant that he must categorically refrain from attempting to leave his house, indicating that otherwise the SPD could not bear responsibility for his safety, since they could not accompany him to an unlawful demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the applicant's representative filed a request at the hearing before the Constitutional Court of Armenia, submitting that the applicant was under de facto house arrest and unable to attend the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the applicant's representative requested that the Constitutional Court of Armenia take measures to ensure the applicant's attendance at the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The President of the Constitutional Court of Armenia replied on 4 March 2008 that the applicant had three representatives at the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The President of the Constitutional Court of Armenia stated on 4 March 2008 that if the applicant also wished to attend but was unable for whatever reason, the request would be examined and an appropriate decision would be taken.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the Constitutional Court of Armenia took a decision ordering the General Prosecutor's Office to clarify the fact of the applicant's alleged de facto deprivation of liberty, as claimed by his representatives.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the Constitutional Court of Armenia ordered the General Prosecutor's Office to ensure the applicant's attendance at the hearing before the Constitutional Court if he so wished.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the General Prosecutor's Office replied that the applicant was not deprived of his liberty.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the General Prosecutor's Office replied that there were no restrictions on the applicant's freedom of movement.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the General Prosecutor's Office replied that there was no such concept as \"house arrest\" under Armenian law.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the General Prosecutor's Office replied that the applicant was free to attend the hearing before the Constitutional Court of Armenia if he so wished.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On 4 March 2008 the General Prosecutor's Office replied that it was not the duty of the General Prosecutor's Office to ensure the applicant's attendance at the Constitutional Court hearing.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The applicant alleged that, following the decision of the Constitutional Court of Armenia, he was allowed to attend the Constitutional Court hearing on 5 March 2008 for one hour.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The applicant alleged that his house arrest lasted without interruption until at least 20 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The Government alleged that the applicant attended the hearing before the Constitutional Court of Armenia after he had expressed the wish to do so and had been accompanied by SPD officers.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Government alleged that after the Constitutional Court hearing was over, the applicant himself asked to return home.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "The Government alleged that after returning home from the Constitutional Court hearing, the applicant did not express any wish to leave his house until the state of emergency was lifted on 20 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The Government alleged that the special SPD reinforcements were removed from the applicant's house on 16 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Government alleged that throughout the period of the state of emergency, the applicant had numerous visitors at his house, including journalists, diplomats and other persons, none of whom was prohibited from entering.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "On 8 March 2008 the Constitutional Court of Armenia dismissed the applicant's application of 29 February 2008 contesting the results of the 19 February 2008 presidential election.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The early morning police operation on 1 March 2008 and the applicant's alleged house arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Article 65 of the Armenian Code of Administrative Procedure (2008-2014) provides that an applicant, by lodging a challenging claim, may demand partial or full annulment or modification of an interfering administrative act.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Code of Administrative Procedure (2008-2014)"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Article 66 of the Armenian Code of Administrative Procedure (2008-2014) provides that an applicant, by lodging an obligating claim, may demand the enactment of a favourable administrative act which an administrative authority refused to – or did not – enact.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Code of Administrative Procedure (2008-2014)"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "Article 67 of the Armenian Code of Administrative Procedure (2008-2014) provides that an applicant, by lodging a claim for performance of an action, may demand the performance of certain actions or refraining from such actions which are not aimed at the enactment of an administrative act.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Code of Administrative Procedure (2008-2014)"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "Article 68 of the Armenian Code of Administrative Procedure (2008-2014) provides that an applicant, by lodging an acknowledgement claim, may demand an acknowledgement of existence or absence of any legal relationship, if he cannot lodge a claim under Articles 65-67 of the Code.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Code of Administrative Procedure (2008-2014)"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Article 68 of the Armenian Code of Administrative Procedure (2008-2014) provides that an applicant, by lodging an acknowledgement claim, may demand an acknowledgement of invalidity of an administrative act.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Code of Administrative Procedure (2008-2014)"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Article 68 of the Armenian Code of Administrative Procedure (2008-2014) provides that an applicant, by lodging an acknowledgement claim, may demand an acknowledgement of unlawfulness of an interfering administrative act or action which no longer has legal force, if the applicant has a legitimate interest in having the act or action acknowledged as unlawful, that is if: (a) there is a risk of once again enacting a similar interfering administrative act or performing a similar action in a similar situation; (b) the applicant intends to claim pecuniary damages; or (c) the applicant pursues the aim of rehabilitating his honour, dignity or business reputation.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "A. Code of Administrative Procedure (2008-2014)"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "Section 1 of the Armenian Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection (2004) lists the main concepts used in the Act, including \"protected objects\", defined as buildings, constructions, structures, adjacent territories and transportation means where persons subject to State protection are permanently or temporarily located and which require protection in order to ensure the security of persons subject to State protection.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection (2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "Section 6 § 3 of the Armenian Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection (2004) provides that a former President of Armenia is provided with personal lifetime State protection, except in cases prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection (2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "Section 10 of the Armenian Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection (2004) provides that the authority carrying out State protection is the State Protection Department of Armenia.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection (2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "Section 11(2) of the Armenian Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection (2004) lists as a main task of the State Protection Department of Armenia ensuring the security of persons subject to State protection at their permanent or temporary location, including during travel.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection (2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "Section 11(7) of the Armenian Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection (2004) lists as a main task of the State Protection Department of Armenia ensuring the regime of access control established at a protected object.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection (2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "Section 12(2) of the Armenian Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection (2004) provides that the State Protection Department of Armenia is obliged to organise and implement protective, regime, technical and other measures aimed at ensuring the security of persons subject to State protection.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection (2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "Section 13(4) of the Armenian Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection (2004) provides that the State Protection Department of Armenia has the right to check the identity documents of public officials and other persons during their entry and exit to and from a protected object, to carry out their inspection and an inspection of objects which they have on them, their transportation means and objects transported in them, including by applying technical measures.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "B. Act on Ensuring the Security of Persons Subject to Special State Protection (2004)"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "Section 14 § 1(4) of the Armenian Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011) provides that the police are entitled to decide to terminate a public event and to order the organisers to terminate the event, by allowing them a reasonable time-limit to do so, if, after a warning by the police, public order and requirements of the law continue to be violated and this poses a real risk to the life and health of others, State and public security and public order, and may cause substantial pecuniary damage to the State, the community, natural or legal persons.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW", "C. Assemblies, Rallies, Marches and Demonstrations Act (2004-2011)"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The Report of the Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe (Monitoring Committee), Doc. 11579, dated 15 April 2008, stated that the exact circumstances that led to the tragic events of 1 March 2008, as well as the manner in which they were handled by the authorities, including the declaration of the state of emergency, must be subject to an official independent investigation.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. The Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia: Report by the Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe (Monitoring Committee), Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The Report of the Council of Europe Monitoring Committee (Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008) stated that according to the official version, in the early morning of 1 March 2008, the police attempted a search of the tent camp on Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. The Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia: Report by the Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe (Monitoring Committee), Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Report of the Council of Europe Monitoring Committee (Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008) stated that after the police met with resistance from the protesters, the police took the decision to clear the tent camp on Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. The Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia: Report by the Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe (Monitoring Committee), Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The Report of the Council of Europe Monitoring Committee (Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008) stated that during the police action to clear the tent camp on Freedom Square, 31 persons were injured according to official information.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. The Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia: Report by the Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe (Monitoring Committee), Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The Report of the Council of Europe Monitoring Committee (Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008) stated that Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan (the applicant) was placed under de facto house arrest during the police action on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. The Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia: Report by the Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe (Monitoring Committee), Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The Report of the Council of Europe Monitoring Committee (Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008) noted in a footnote that the authorities said the applicant was free to travel if he rescinded his security detail, but that the clearly existing threats to his personal safety and life made it impossible for him to do so, as was obviously known by the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "1. The Functioning of Democratic Institutions in Armenia: Report by the Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe (Monitoring Committee), Doc. 11579, 15 April 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights conducted a special mission to Armenia from 12 to 15 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. Report by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia, 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "During his visit to Armenia from 12 to 15 March 2008, the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights had a separate meeting with the former President and Presidential candidate, Levon Ter-Petrosyan (the applicant).", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. Report by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia, 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The Report of the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia (CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008) stated that the search operation at Freedom Square reportedly started early Saturday morning at approximately 6.30, according to several interlocutors.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. Report by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia, 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The Report of the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia (CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008) stated that during the search operation at Freedom Square, tents were taken down and people were beaten and injured.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. Report by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia, 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The Report of the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia (CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008) stated that demonstrators started resisting and clashes broke out between the police and security forces and the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. Report by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia, 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The Report of the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia (CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008) stated that according to both parties, a tentative agreement seems to have been reached later on the morning of 1 March 2008 to relocate the demonstration and allow it to continue, either in front of the Myasnikyan monument near the French Embassy or close to the main train station.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. Report by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia, 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The Report of the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia (CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008) stated that the tentative agreement to relocate the demonstration appears never to have been properly communicated to the demonstrators by their leaders, notably Mr Ter-Petrosyan (the applicant), who at that stage was prevented from leaving his residence.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. Report by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia, 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The Report of the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia (CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008) stated that former President Mr Levon Ter-Petrosyan (the applicant) was held in what must be qualified as de facto house arrest.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. Report by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia, 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "The Report of the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia (CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008) stated that the applicant was provided close protection by the authorities in charge of the State of Emergency, notably the National Security Services.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. Report by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia, 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "The Report of the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia (CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008) stated that according to the Head of Police, the applicant was free to leave his house, however the close protection service would only accompany him to safe places.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Council of Europe bodies", "2. Report by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights on his Special Mission to Armenia, 12-15 March 2008, CommDH(2008)11REV, 20 March 2008"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (Democracy on Rocky Ground: Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009) stated that the applicant (Levon Ter-Petrosyan), who had been sleeping in his car parked at Freedom Square, was woken up during the police operation on 1 March 2008.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky Ground: Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (February 2009) stated that according to the account the applicant gave Human Rights Watch, he addressed the protesters asking them to step back from the police line, and then to stay where they were and wait for instructions from the police.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky Ground: Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (February 2009) stated that according to the account the applicant gave Human Rights Watch, he warned the police that there were women and children among the demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky Ground: Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (February 2009) stated that even before the applicant finished his address, police advanced towards the demonstrators in several lines, beating their truncheons against their plastic shields.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky Ground: Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (February 2009) stated that according to multiple witnesses, the police made no audible demand for anyone to disperse nor gave any indication of the purpose of their presence at Freedom Square.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky Ground: Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (February 2009) stated that the police started pushing demonstrators from Freedom Square with their shields, causing some to panic and scream and others to run.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky Ground: Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (February 2009) stated that some demonstrators appeared ready to fight the police, which was why, according to the applicant, he urged the crowd not to resist the police.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky Ground: Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (February 2009) stated that immediately afterwards, without any warning, riot police attacked the demonstrators at Freedom Square, using rubber truncheons, iron sticks, and electric shock batons.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky Ground: Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (February 2009) stated that according to the applicant, a group of about 30 policemen under the command of the Head of the SPD approached him and forcibly took him aside.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky Ground: Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (February 2009) stated that when asked if he was arrested, the applicant was told that police were there to guarantee his safety and that he was requested to cooperate.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky Ground: Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The Human Rights Watch Report (February 2009) stated that the applicant (Levon Ter-Petrosyan) was subsequently taken home and effectively put under house arrest.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Human Rights Watch Report: Democracy on Rocky Ground: Armenia's Disputed 2008 Presidential Election, Post-Election Violence, and the One-Sided Pursuit of Accountability, February 2009"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F009", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F039", "F043", "F044", "F046", "F147"], "interference": ["F016", "F019", "F035", "F039", "F046", "F047", "F048"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F043", "F044", "F046", "F047", "F147", "F148", "F150"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F012", "F013", "F016", "F019", "F039", "F043", "F044"], "interference": ["F016", "F039", "F046", "F047"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F043", "F044", "F046", "F047", "F147"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F012", "F016", "F039", "F043", "F044", "F046", "F047"]}} {"case_name": "case_623", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The background to the case is described in detail in the European Court of Human Rights' judgment in Stankov and the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden v. Bulgaria (nos. 29221/95 and 29225/95, ECHR 2001-IX).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The background to the case is described in detail in the European Court of Human Rights' judgment in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Ivanov v. Bulgaria (no. 44079/98, 20 October 2005).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background to the case"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 30 March 2004 the second applicant and two other members of Ilinden notified the Mayor of Sandanski that the organisation intended to stage a rally on 18 April 2004.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The rally notified on 30 March 2004 was planned to take place between 10 a.m. and 4 p.m. on 18 April 2004 at the grave of Yane Sandanski near the Rozhen Monastery.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The purpose of the rally notified on 30 March 2004 was to commemorate the anniversary of Yane Sandanski's \"dastardly murder\".", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The planned rally notified on 30 March 2004 would include laying flowers at the grave of Yane Sandanski.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The planned rally notified on 30 March 2004 would include making speeches about the life and activity of Yane Sandanski.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The planned rally notified on 30 March 2004 would include a \"cultural programme\".", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 13 April 2004 the Mayor of Sandanski advised the organisers of the Ilinden rally that Ilinden could hold a rally between 10 a.m. and 12 noon on 18 April 2004.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Mayor of Sandanski's letter of 13 April 2004 did not give reasons for his decision restricting the rally.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Mayor of Sandanski's letter of 13 April 2004 stated that the rally could include laying flowers on the grave of Yane Sandanski.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Mayor of Sandanski's letter of 13 April 2004 stated that the rally could include making speeches about Yane Sandanski.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On the morning of 18 April 2004 the organisers of the Ilinden rally built a stage near the grave of Yane Sandanski and started decorating it.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the applicants, at about 10.30 a.m. on 18 April 2004 a plain-clothes police officer, accompanied by two uniformed police officers, approached the organisers and told them to stop decorating the stage.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "According to the applicants, the plain-clothes police officer told the organisers on 18 April 2004 that the Mayor's permission was valid only until 12 noon and that after that they were to leave the area.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "According to the applicants, the police officer's statement on 18 April 2004 led to tension, with some of the participants reacting forcefully.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "After the tension on 18 April 2004, the rally was allowed to proceed.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Government disputed the applicants' assertion that a police officer told the organisers to stop decorating the stage and that this led to tension on 18 April 2004.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "According to the Government, the rally on 18 April 2004 took place without incident.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "According to the Government, the rally on 18 April 2004 was attended by more than two hundred foreign guests, including representatives of the embassy of \"the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia\" and a number of Bulgarian and Macedonian journalists.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "According to the applicants, no other organisations held events at Yane Sandanski's grave between 8 a.m. and 4 p.m. on 18 April 2004.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the applicants, in the days before the rally on 18 April 2004 the local radio and cable television stations reported that the rally had been banned and was not to be attended.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Government disputed the applicants' assertion that local radio and cable television stations reported that the rally on 18 April 2004 had been banned.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "1. The events of March and April 2004 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 19 April 2004 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad of its intention to stage a rally at 3 p.m. on 4 May 2004 in front of the monument to Gotse Delchev in Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The purpose of the rally notified on 19 April 2004 was to commemorate the anniversary of Gotse Delchev's assassination by laying flowers.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The rally notified on 19 April 2004 was described as being in front of the monument to \"the great Macedonian revolutionary\" Gotse Delchev in Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The rally notified on 19 April 2004 would start in front of the American University in Blagoevgrad and make its way to Macedonia Square, where the monument to Gotse Delchev was located.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "In a letter dated 20 April 2004 and received by Ilinden on 24 April 2004, the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that every citizen of the Republic of Bulgaria had the right to pay his respect to the memory of national heroes and lay flowers at their monuments.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "In the letter of 20 April 2004, the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that in the way it had been planned, the rally was in fact a procession.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "In the letter of 20 April 2004, the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that to proclaim Gotse Delchev a \"Macedonian revolutionary\" was \"unconstitutional and provocative\".", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "In the letter of 20 April 2004, the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the rally was likely to stir unrest and breaches of public order, as had happened in the past.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "In the letter of 20 April 2004, the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the holding of rallies presupposed registration, proof of which Ilinden had not presented.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "In the letter of 20 April 2004, the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the municipality had planned an event on Macedonia Square for 4 May 2004 to mark the \"May holidays\", which made the holding of Ilinden's rally impossible.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 26 April 2004 Ilinden sought judicial review of the Mayor of Blagoevgrad's decision by the Blagoevgrad District Court.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court instructed Ilinden to provide proof of registration in connection with its application for judicial review filed on 26 April 2004.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Ilinden did not produce proof of registration as instructed by the Blagoevgrad District Court.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "In a decision of 4 May 2004 the Blagoevgrad District Court declared Ilinden's application for judicial review inadmissible.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court noted in its decision of 4 May 2004 that on 18 November 2002 Ilinden had been refused registration as a non-profit association (as described in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Others v. Bulgaria (no. 2), no. 34960/04, §§ 12-16, 18 October 2011).", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court noted in its decision of 4 May 2004 that the application concerned a rally due to take place on the day of the court's decision, making compliance with the court's instructions impossible.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court held in its decision of 4 May 2004 that the application was defective and could not be examined.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "On 3 May 2004 the police, relying on section 62 of the 1997 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act, ordered the head of Ilinden's Blagoevgrad chapter not to organise rallies by members of Ilinden without permission by the Mayor of Blagoevgrad and in breach of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The police order of 3 May 2004 admonished the head of Ilinden's Blagoevgrad chapter to coordinate the members of Ilinden to prevent demonstrations with foreign flags and other symbols, or the display of placards with anti-Bulgarian slogans, which was likely to incite unrest and breaches of public order.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 3 May 2004 the police ordered another member of Ilinden not to commemorate the anniversary of the death of Gotse Delchev or use propaganda materials against the Republic of Bulgaria and the Constitution of the Republic of Bulgaria.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 4 May 2004 members of Ilinden were able to lay flowers on the monument to Gotse Delchev in Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 4 May 2004 members of Ilinden were not allowed to carry flags or placards at the monument to Gotse Delchev in Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to the applicants, the municipality of Blagoevgrad did not hold any event on 4 May 2004.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to the Government, the municipality of Blagoevgrad held the traditional celebration on 4 May 2004, which was open to all comers, including members of Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "2. The events of April and May 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 19 July 2004 the head of Ilinden's chapter in Petrich notified the Mayor of Petrich that the organisation intended to stage a rally in the area of Samuilova Krepost between 10.30 a.m. and 4 p.m. on 1 August 2004, to mark the anniversary of the Ilinden uprising.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "3. The events of July and August 2004 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In a letter of 22 July 2004 the Mayor of Petrich advised Ilinden that it did not have permission to hold the rally on 1 August 2004 at Samuilova Krepost.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "3. The events of July and August 2004 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Mayor of Petrich's letter of 22 July 2004 stated that another organisation, VMRO, had already applied for and been granted permission to hold an event at Samuilova Krepost at the same place and at the same time as Ilinden's planned rally.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "3. The events of July and August 2004 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 29 July 2004 Ilinden sought judicial review of the Mayor of Petrich's decision by the Petrich District Court.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "3. The events of July and August 2004 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In a decision of 30 July 2004 the Petrich District Court discontinued the proceedings on Ilinden's application for judicial review.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "3. The events of July and August 2004 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Petrich District Court held in its decision of 30 July 2004 that under the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act the holding of rallies was not subject to permission by the Mayor.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "3. The events of July and August 2004 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Petrich District Court held in its decision of 30 July 2004 that in certain limited cases the Mayor could ban a rally.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "3. The events of July and August 2004 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Petrich District Court held in its decision of 30 July 2004 that the Mayor of Petrich's letter did not amount to a ban but could be regarded as a mere proposal to alter the time and place of the rally.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "3. The events of July and August 2004 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Petrich District Court held in its decision of 30 July 2004 that there was no valid administrative decision to be reviewed and the application for judicial review was pointless.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "3. The events of July and August 2004 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 1 August 2004 Ilinden held its rally in Samuilova Krepost, apparently without disturbance by the authorities or by hostile counter-demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "3. The events of July and August 2004 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "According to the Government, the authorities asked VMRO to reschedule its event at Samuilova Krepost to ensure the smooth unfolding of Ilinden's rally on 1 August 2004.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "3. The events of July and August 2004 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "According to the Government, the authorities instructed the management of the Samuilova Krepost site not to collect the usual fees for visiting it on 1 August 2004.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "3. The events of July and August 2004 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "According to the applicants, VMRO did not have any real intention to hold an event at Samuilova Krepost on 1 August 2004 and had coordinated their request with the police.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "3. The events of July and August 2004 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 23 August 2004 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad of its intention to hold a rally at 3 p.m. on 12 September 2004 in front of Gotse Delchev's monument on Macedonia Square in Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The purpose of the rally notified on 23 August 2004 was to commemorate the Macedonians who fell victim to State terrorism and genocide in Bulgaria, by laying wreaths and making a short speech.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In a letter dated 24 August 2004 and received by Ilinden on 3 September 2004, the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the phrase \"to commemorate the Macedonians who fell victim to State terrorism in Bulgaria\" showed that the event Ilinden sought to organise would lead to breaches of public order and conflicts, as had happened in the past.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "In the letter of 24 August 2004, the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the holding of rallies presupposed registration, which had not been proved by Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "In the letter of 24 August 2004, the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the municipality had planned an event on Macedonia Square for 12 September 2004 to mark the beginning of the school year, which made the holding of Ilinden's rally impossible.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Ilinden sought judicial review of the Mayor of Blagoevgrad's ban on the rally planned for 12 September 2004 by the Blagoevgrad District Court.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "In a decision of 8 September 2004, notified to Ilinden on 10 September 2004, the Blagoevgrad District Court instructed Ilinden to provide evidence of, inter alia, its registration.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "At about 2.30 p.m. on 12 September 2004 members and supporters of Ilinden gathered in front of the American University in Blagoevgrad, with a view to marching to Macedonia Square.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 12 September 2004 the members and supporters of Ilinden gathered in front of the American University in Blagoevgrad were surrounded by about twenty-five uniformed police officers.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 12 September 2004 two plain-clothes police officers approached the leaders of the Ilinden rally and asked them to leave the placards and banners they were carrying.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "At about 3 p.m. on 12 September 2004 the participants in the Ilinden rally marched to Macedonia Square, holding up one flag and three placards.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 12 September 2004 the participants in the Ilinden rally were surrounded by police, who apparently told them several times to put the flag and the placards down.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 12 September 2004 about eighty metres from the monument to Gotse Delchev, a group of some forty police officers stopped the participants in the Ilinden rally.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 12 September 2004 a group of about fifteen counter-demonstrators from VMRO were assembled at the base of Gotse Delchev's monument on Macedonia Square, waving flags and shouting insults at the participants in the Ilinden rally.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "According to the applicants, the VMRO counter-demonstrators on 12 September 2004 had not notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad of their intention to hold an event.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "According to the applicants, on 12 September 2004 the police told the participants in Ilinden's rally that, to be allowed to approach the monument to Gotse Delchev, they had to put down their flags and placards, remove the ribbon from the wreath they were carrying, and proceed one by one.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "According to the applicants, on 12 September 2004 the participants in Ilinden's rally refused to comply with the police conditions and were not allowed to approach the monument to Gotse Delchev.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "According to the Government, Ilinden's failure to take into account the reasons given by the Mayor of Blagoevgrad sparked an angry reaction on the part of citizens around the monument to Gotse Delchev on 12 September 2004.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "According to the Government, the police protected the participants in Ilinden's rally from the angry bystanders on 12 September 2004 and allowed them to approach the monument to Gotse Delchev.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "4. The events of August and September 2004 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "On 4 April 2005 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Sandanski that it intended to organise a rally at the grave of Yane Sandanski near the Rozhen Monastery, to take place between 10.30 a.m. and 3 p.m. on 23 April 2005.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "In a letter of 5 April 2005 the Mayor of Sandanski stated that an event had been planned for 23 April 2005 by a vocational training school, which had given notice of it on an earlier date – 10 March 2005.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "In the letter of 5 April 2005 the Mayor of Sandanski told Ilinden that it would have to change the date, time and place of its rally planned for 23 April 2005.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "On 8 April 2005 Ilinden objected to the Mayor of Sandanski's request to change the date and time of the rally, stating that according to Macedonian cultural tradition the dead had to be commemorated either on the day of their death or on the closest Saturday.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On 8 April 2005 Ilinden stated that the grave of Yane Sandanski had to be accessible to everyone.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 8 April 2005 Ilinden said that it could change the place of its rally from the front of a church located near the grave of Yane Sandanski to the back of the church.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On 11 April 2005 Ilinden sought judicial review by the Sandanski District Court, arguing that the Mayor of Sandanski's refusal to allow its rally because of another event was unfounded, as there was enough room near the Rozhen Monastery for both events to proceed.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "In a decision of 13 April 2005 the Sandanski District Court found that Ilinden's application for judicial review was inadmissible.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Sandanski District Court held in its decision of 13 April 2005 that only bans on rallies were subject to judicial review, whereas the Mayor of Sandanski's letter did not amount to such a ban.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Sandanski District Court held in its decision of 13 April 2005 that even assuming the Mayor's letter could be regarded as a ban, it had not been previously appealed before the municipal council, as required under section 12(4) of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Sandanski District Court's decision of 13 April 2005 was served on the second applicant on 13 April 2005.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "At 10.30 a.m. on 23 April 2005 members and supporters of Ilinden assembled near Rozhen Monastery, building a stage with posters about three hundred metres from the grave of Yane Sandanski.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "According to the applicants, at approximately 10.30 a.m. on 23 April 2005 several police officers told the Ilinden participants to remove the posters because at 11 a.m. a group of pupils would be coming to lay wreaths at the grave and on the posters they would see that Yane Sandanski was being proclaimed not as a Bulgarian, but as a Macedonian revolutionary.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "According to the applicants, after the pupils left the scene on 23 April 2005, the participants in the Ilinden rally were allowed to put the posters back up.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "According to the Government, Ilinden reneged on a previous undertaking to move its rally on 23 April 2005 two hundred metres to the west.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "According to the Government, despite Ilinden's numerous breaches of the Mayor of Sandanski's order on 23 April 2005, the police intervened only to allow the pupils of the vocational training school to commemorate Yane Sandanski.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "According to the Government, after the pupils of the vocational training school commemorated Yane Sandanski on 23 April 2005, the pupils were asked to leave the area to avoid \"physical and other\" conflicts with Ilinden's members and supporters.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "According to the applicants, no \"physical conflicts\" had been likely on 23 April 2005 because the participants in the rally had withdrawn to about two hundred metres from the grave and knew and respected the teachers.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "According to the applicants, during the rally on 23 April 2005 several plain-clothes police officers threatened participants with arrest.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "5. The events of April 2005 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "On 18 April 2005 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad of its intention to hold a rally at 3 p.m. on 4 May 2005 on Macedonia Square, where it would lay wreaths on the monument to Gotse Delchev and make a short speech.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The rally notified on 18 April 2005 would start in front of the American University in Blagoevgrad and make its way to Macedonia Square, where the monument to Gotse Delchev was located.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "In a letter of 19 April 2005 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad informed Ilinden that every citizen of the Republic of Bulgaria had the right to pay his respects to the memory of national heroes and lay flowers at their monuments.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "In the letter of 19 April 2005 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that in the way it had been planned, the rally was in fact a procession.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "In the letter of 19 April 2005 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the rally was likely to cause breaches of public order and unrest, as had happened in the past.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "In the letter of 19 April 2005 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the holding of rallies presupposed registration, proof of which Ilinden had not presented.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "In the letter of 19 April 2005 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the municipality had planned a children's holiday on Macedonia Square for 4 May 2005, which made the holding of Ilinden's rally impossible.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "On 21 April 2005 Ilinden sought judicial review of the Mayor of Blagoevgrad's ban on the rally planned for 4 May 2005 by the Blagoevgrad District Court.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "On 21 April 2005 Ilinden appealed against the Mayor of Blagoevgrad's ban on the rally planned for 4 May 2005 to the Blagoevgrad Municipal Council.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "In a letter of 22 April 2005 the chairman of the Blagoevgrad Municipal Council rejected Ilinden's appeal against the Mayor's ban, on the ground that the Mayor's decision was lawful.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "On 3 May 2005 the Blagoevgrad District Court instructed Ilinden to rectify its application for judicial review by specifying which decision it sought review of and exactly what form of relief it was requesting.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "On 3 May 2005 the police, relying on section 62 of the 1997 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act, ordered the head of Ilinden's Blagoevgrad chapter not to organise a rally on 4 May 2005.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "According to the applicants, on 4 May 2005 the second applicant was arrested and taken to a police station in the town of Simitli.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "On 5 May 2005 the police drew up a report accusing the second applicant of having unlawfully organised a prohibited rally.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The rally took place on 4 May 2005.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "According to the applicants, the participants in the rally on 4 May 2005 were not allowed to approach Gotse Delchev's monument.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "6. The events of April and May 2005 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "On 4 July 2005 the head of Ilinden's chapter in Petrich notified the Mayor of Petrich that the organisation intended to stage a rally in the area of Samuilova Krepost at 10 a.m. on 2 August 2005, to mark the anniversary of the Ilinden uprising.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "7. The events of July 2005 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "In a letter of 11 July 2005 the Mayor of Petrich advised Ilinden that he could not allow the rally on 2 August 2005 at Samuilova Krepost, as VMRO had already, on 20 June 2005, applied for and been granted permission to hold an event at the same place and at the same time.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "7. The events of July 2005 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "On 18 July 2005 Ilinden sought judicial review of the Mayor of Petrich's decision by the Petrich District Court.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "7. The events of July 2005 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "Ilinden did not receive a reply from the Petrich District Court following its application for judicial review filed on 18 July 2005.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "7. The events of July 2005 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "On 2 August 2005 Ilinden held its rally in Samuilova Krepost, allegedly accompanied by a heavy police presence.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "7. The events of July 2005 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The police filmed the Ilinden rally on 2 August 2005 at Samuilova Krepost with a video camera.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "7. The events of July 2005 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "According to the applicants, the police filmed the rally on 2 August 2005 to identify new participants and bring pressure on them to make them refrain from taking part in similar rallies in the future.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "7. The events of July 2005 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "According to the Government, the police officers present at the rally on 2 August 2005 were no more than the usual number dispatched to such events.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "7. The events of July 2005 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "According to the Government, the police at the rally on 2 August 2005 did not allow any breaches of public order, save for the consumption of alcohol by members of Ilinden and their foreign guests.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "7. The events of July 2005 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "According to the Government, VMRO's decision, at the authorities' request, to reschedule their event for another time had served to prevent breaches of public order at the rally on 2 August 2005.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "7. The events of July 2005 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "On 23 August 2005 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad of its intention to hold a rally in front of the monument to Gotse Delchev on Macedonia Square at 3 p.m. on 12 September 2005.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Mayor of Blagoevgrad banned Ilinden's rally planned for 12 September 2005, because it coincided with a children's celebration marking the opening of the school year.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "Ilinden apparently did not receive a copy of the Mayor of Blagoevgrad's decision banning the rally planned for 12 September 2005.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "On 12 September 2005 the Blagoevgrad police, relying on section 62 of the 1997 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act, ordered the head of Ilinden's Blagoevgrad chapter not to organise or take part in rallies involving the laying of wreaths and flowers in front of Gotse Delchev's monument.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "On 12 September 2005 the Blagoevgrad police, relying on section 62 of the 1997 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act, ordered another of Ilinden's leaders not to organise or take part in rallies involving the laying of wreaths and flowers in front of Gotse Delchev's monument.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "At about 1 p.m. on 12 September 2005 members and supporters of Ilinden started gathering in front of the American University in Blagoevgrad with a view to marching to Macedonia Square.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "On 12 September 2005 approximately thirty uniformed and plain-clothes police officers surrounded the Ilinden members and supporters gathered in front of the American University in Blagoevgrad, blocked their way, seized the flags and placards they were carrying, and destroyed a wreath.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "According to the Government, the actions of the police on 12 September 2005 were monitored by a public prosecutor, who did not note any abuse of their powers.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "After the police intervention on 12 September 2005, the participants in the Ilinden rally decided not to go to Macedonia Square.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "On their way back from the American University on 12 September 2005, a group of participants from Sandanski laid flowers at a roadside monument near the village of Cherniche.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "A few days after 12 September 2005, a Member of Parliament from VMRO, Mr B. Yachev, was reported by the press to have commented that the police had acted properly on 12 September 2005, doing the job done in previous years by VMRO itself.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "A few days after 12 September 2005, the Mayor of Blagoevgrad was reported by the press to have said that he \"would not allow the staging of anti-Bulgarian demonstrations by separatist associations\".", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "On 30 October 2005 three of Ilinden's leaders filed a complaint about the actions of the police on 12 September 2005 with the Sofia Regional Military Prosecutor's Office.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "In a decision of 1 December 2005 the Sofia Regional Military Prosecutor's Office refused to open a criminal investigation into the police actions on 12 September 2005, reasoning that there was no indication that the police officers had acted unlawfully in preventing the rally or in impounding the objects carried by the participants.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "Ilinden's appeal against the Sofia Regional Military Prosecutor's Office decision of 1 December 2005 was rejected by the Military Appellate Prosecutor's Office on 16 January 2006.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "8. The events of August and September 2005 (Blagoevgrad) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "On 30 March 2006 the second applicant and two other members of Ilinden notified the Mayor of Sandanski that the organisation intended to stage a rally between 10 a.m. and 3 p.m. on 23 April 2006 at the grave of Yane Sandanski near the Rozhen Monastery, to commemorate the anniversary of his \"dastardly murder\".", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "9. The events of March and April 2006 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "The planned rally notified on 30 March 2006 would include laying flowers at the grave of Yane Sandanski, a speech about his life and activity, and a \"cultural programme\".", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "9. The events of March and April 2006 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "In a letter of 18 April 2006 the Mayor of Sandanski informed Ilinden that it could lay flowers at the grave of Yane Sandanski and organise a cultural programme between 10 a.m. and 12 noon on 23 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "9. The events of March and April 2006 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "On 23 April 2006 members and supporters of Ilinden gathered in front of Yane Sandanski's grave near the Rozhen Monastery.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "9. The events of March and April 2006 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "At about 12 noon on 23 April 2006 the police interrupted the Ilinden gathering, telling the participants that the time allowed by the Mayor of Sandanski had expired and they should disperse.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "9. The events of March and April 2006 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The participants in the Ilinden gathering on 23 April 2006 complied with the police instruction and left the area.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "9. The events of March and April 2006 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "According to the Government, the interruption of the Ilinden gathering on 23 April 2006 was necessary following the insistence of other organisations.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "9. The events of March and April 2006 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "According to the applicants, no other organisations held commemorative events near Rozhen Monastery on 23 April 2006.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "9. The events of March and April 2006 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "According to the applicants, the real reason for the interruption of the Ilinden gathering on 23 April 2006 was the desire of the police to prevent visitors to the Rozhen Monastery from seeing Ilinden's event.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "9. The events of March and April 2006 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "On 25 April 2006 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad of its intention to hold a rally at 4 p.m. on 4 May 2006 on Macedonia Square, laying wreaths on the monument to Gotse Delchev and making a short speech, to mark the anniversary of the death of Gotse Delchev described as a \"Macedonian apostle revolutionary\".", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "10. The events of April and May 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The rally notified on 25 April 2006 would start in front of the American University in Blagoevgrad and then make its way to Macedonia Square, where the monument to Gotse Delchev was located.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "10. The events of April and May 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "In a letter of 25 April 2006 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad informed Ilinden that every citizen of the Republic of Bulgaria had the right to pay his respects to the memory of national heroes and lay flowers at their monuments.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "10. The events of April and May 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "In the letter of 25 April 2006 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that in the way it had been planned, the rally was in fact a procession.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "10. The events of April and May 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "In the letter of 25 April 2006 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the rally was likely to cause breaches of public order and unrest, as had happened in the past.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "10. The events of April and May 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "In the letter of 25 April 2006 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the holding of rallies presupposed registration, proof of which Ilinden had not presented.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "10. The events of April and May 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "In the letter of 25 April 2006 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the municipality had planned a children's holiday on Macedonia Square for 4 May 2006, which made the holding of Ilinden's rally impossible.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "10. The events of April and May 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "On 4 May 2006 the police prevented the participants in the Ilinden rally from moving towards Macedonia Square.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "10. The events of April and May 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "On 4 May 2006 the police, relying on section 55 of the 2006 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act, ordered the Ilinden participants in writing to refrain from participating in assemblies without permission from the Mayor of Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "10. The events of April and May 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "On 4 May 2006 the police, relying on section 55 of the 2006 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act, ordered the Ilinden participants in writing not to use placards, banners and other visual materials featuring texts with anti-Bulgarian content.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "10. The events of April and May 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "According to the Government, the restrictions imposed on 4 May 2006 were necessary because of the simultaneous staging of a children's celebration.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "10. The events of April and May 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "On 6 July 2006 the head of Ilinden's chapter in Petrich notified the Mayor of Petrich that the organisation intended to hold a rally in the area of Samuilova Krepost at 10 a.m. on 30 July 2006, to mark the anniversary of the Ilinden uprising.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "11. The events of July 2006 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "In a letter of 14 July 2006 the Mayor of Petrich advised Ilinden that he authorised the rally planned for 30 July 2006 at Samuilova Krepost.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "11. The events of July 2006 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The Ilinden rally proceeded on 30 July 2006 at Samuilova Krepost and was attended by about two hundred and fifteen people.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "11. The events of July 2006 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "According to the Government, the only incident at the rally on 30 July 2006 was an attempt by a member of Ilinden to damage the film camera of a local television station.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "11. The events of July 2006 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "According to the applicants, the same member of Ilinden was kicked three times in the legs by a police officer on 30 July 2006 while trying to prevent the officer from entering a restaurant where the participants in the rally were dining.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "11. The events of July 2006 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "On 30 August 2006 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad of its intention to hold a rally on Macedonia Square at 4 p.m. on 12 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "On 30 August 2006 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad replied that the event planned for 12 September 2006 could not proceed, as it might breach public order and infringe the rights of others.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "On 4 September 2006 a member of Ilinden's managing council notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad again of the organisation's intention to hold a rally on 12 September 2006, to commemorate \"the victims of the Macedonian nation following the Bulgarian governments' acts of State terrorism and genocide\".", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "In the notification of 4 September 2006, the member of Ilinden's managing council stated that for years on end the Mayor of Blagoevgrad had prevented Ilinden from staging rallies, relying on bogus arguments.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "In a letter of 5 September 2006 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad replied that the notification could not be examined, as no documents proving that Ilinden had been registered had been produced.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "In the letter of 5 September 2006 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that it was impossible to identify the \"members of the managing bodies of [the] event\" due to the lack of registration documents.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "In the letter of 5 September 2006 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the municipality had organised a school holiday at Macedonia Square on 12 September 2006, which made the holding of Ilinden's rally impossible.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "On 7 September 2006 Ilinden sought judicial review of the Mayor of Blagoevgrad's ban on the rally planned for 12 September 2006 by the Blagoevgrad District Court.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "In a final decision of 8 September 2006 the Blagoevgrad District Court rejected Ilinden's application for judicial review of the ban on the rally planned for 12 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court held in its decision of 8 September 2006 that the risk of breaches of public order had not been made out by the Mayor of Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court held in its decision of 8 September 2006 that, in the light of the European Court of Human Rights' judgments in a series of cases against Bulgaria, the lack of registration was not a sufficient ground to ban a rally.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court held in its decision of 8 September 2006 that the holding of a school holiday prevented the parallel holding of Ilinden's rally on 12 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court stated in its decision of 8 September 2006 that it was inopportune to allow adults and children to gather at the same time and place, to concurrently stage a school event and a political one, as \"the children's fragile minds should not be subjected to the political interventions and influences which would inevitably occur if the two events [were] allowed to proceed together\".", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "On 8 September 2006 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad that it was willing to reschedule its rally for 4 p.m. on 11 September 2006.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "On 8 September 2006 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad replied to Ilinden's rescheduling notification that it could not be examined, as no documents proving that Ilinden had been registered had been produced.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "According to the applicants, as a result of the Mayor of Blagoevgrad's refusals, Ilinden decided not to hold an event on 12 September 2006; only one member laid flowers at the monument to Gotse Delchev.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "According to the Government, the rally on 12 September 2006 did take place without hindrance from the police.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "12. The events of September 2006 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "On 12 September 2006 Ilinden sought permission from the Mayor of Sandanski to rent a municipal hall on 15 October 2006, to hold a founding meeting needed for the organisation's registration as a political party.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "13. Ilinden's request to use a municipal hall in October 2006 (Sandanski)"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "On 26 September 2006 the Mayor of Sandanski replied that Ilinden's request to rent the municipal hall on 15 October 2006 could not be accommodated, as on 15 and 16 October 2006 the hall was due to host an international wrestling tournament.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "13. Ilinden's request to use a municipal hall in October 2006 (Sandanski)"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "The Mayor of Sandanski also stated on 26 September 2006 that the hall was very often used for cultural events and was due to undergo repairs.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "13. Ilinden's request to use a municipal hall in October 2006 (Sandanski)"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "On 27 September 2006 Ilinden informed the Mayor of Sandanski that it had learned that the wrestling tournament would not take place and asked him to reconsider his decision.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "13. Ilinden's request to use a municipal hall in October 2006 (Sandanski)"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "On 27 September 2006 Ilinden stated that there were no other suitable halls in the region and asked the Mayor of Sandanski to allow the founding meeting to be held in a square in front of the hall.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "13. Ilinden's request to use a municipal hall in October 2006 (Sandanski)"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "On 29 September 2006 the Mayor of Sandanski replied that according to the information available to him, the wrestling tournament would take place as planned.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "13. Ilinden's request to use a municipal hall in October 2006 (Sandanski)"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "On 29 September 2006 the Mayor of Sandanski stated that for the staging of the meeting in the square, Ilinden had to submit an official notification specifying the organiser of the event, its aim and its exact time and place.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "13. Ilinden's request to use a municipal hall in October 2006 (Sandanski)"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "On 2 October 2006 Ilinden reiterated its request to use the municipal hall in Sandanski and alternatively asked the Mayor to indicate another venue which could take up to five hundred people and allow its use.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "13. Ilinden's request to use a municipal hall in October 2006 (Sandanski)"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "On 5 October 2006 the Mayor of Sandanski confirmed that the hall would be in use on the requested date and stated that no other venue of such a size existed.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "13. Ilinden's request to use a municipal hall in October 2006 (Sandanski)"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "Ilinden complained about the Mayor of Sandanski's refusal to let it use the hall to the Commission for Protection against Discrimination, but to no avail.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "13. Ilinden's request to use a municipal hall in October 2006 (Sandanski)"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "Ilinden complained about the Mayor of Sandanski's refusal to let it use the hall to the Blagoevgrad Regional Governor, but to no avail.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "13. Ilinden's request to use a municipal hall in October 2006 (Sandanski)"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "As a result of the refusal to let it use the municipal hall, Ilinden apparently did not hold the founding meeting as planned.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "13. Ilinden's request to use a municipal hall in October 2006 (Sandanski)"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "According to the applicants, on 15 October 2006 the municipal hall in Sandanski was not hosting a sports event, but was empty.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "13. Ilinden's request to use a municipal hall in October 2006 (Sandanski)"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "According to the applicants, on 19 December 2006 three members of Ilinden were collecting declarations by persons who wished to become members of the political party at a stall in the centre of Sandanski.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "14. The incident of 19 December 2006 (Sandanski) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "According to the applicants, on 19 December 2006 two men approached the three Ilinden members at the stall in Sandanski, one of whom was the head of the Petrich chapter of the political party Attack, who shouted insults at them.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "14. The incident of 19 December 2006 (Sandanski) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "According to the applicants, on 19 December 2006 the head of the Petrich chapter of the political party Attack threw the materials on the stall to the ground, hit one of the members of Ilinden in the face, and tore apart an Ilinden poster.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "14. The incident of 19 December 2006 (Sandanski) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "According to the applicants, on 19 December 2006 the head of the Petrich chapter of the political party Attack called the police after the assault.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "14. The incident of 19 December 2006 (Sandanski) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "According to the applicants, the police arrived on 19 December 2006 and arrested the attacker.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "14. The incident of 19 December 2006 (Sandanski) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "According to the applicants, the attacker was warned not to engage in violent actions and released on 19 December 2006.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "14. The incident of 19 December 2006 (Sandanski) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "On 19 December 2006 the three members of Ilinden complained about the assault to the prosecuting authorities.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "14. The incident of 19 December 2006 (Sandanski) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "In a decision of 25 January 2007 the Sandanski District Prosecutor's Office refused to open a criminal investigation into the assault of 19 December 2006, as the acts alleged in the complaint did not constitute publicly prosecutable offences.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "14. The incident of 19 December 2006 (Sandanski) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "The Sandanski District Prosecutor's Office stated in its decision of 25 January 2007 that the bodily injuries suffered by the first Ilinden member were minor and therefore gave cause for a private prosecution only.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "14. The incident of 19 December 2006 (Sandanski) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "The Sandanski District Prosecutor's Office stated in its decision of 25 January 2007 that the destroyed property was not of great value, making its destruction a trivial occurrence which should not be criminally prosecuted.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "14. The incident of 19 December 2006 (Sandanski) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F205", "text": "The Sandanski District Prosecutor's Office stated in its decision of 25 January 2007 that the proffering of insults also gave cause for a private prosecution only.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "14. The incident of 19 December 2006 (Sandanski) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F206", "text": "On appeal by the three Ilinden members, on 5 February 2007 the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office upheld the Sandanski District Prosecutor's Office decision of 25 January 2007, fully endorsing its reasoning.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "14. The incident of 19 December 2006 (Sandanski) and the ensuing complaints to the prosecuting authorities"]}, {"fact_id": "F207", "text": "On 16 March 2007 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Sandanski that it intended to stage a rally between 10.30 a.m. and 2 p.m. on 22 April 2007 at the grave of Yane Sandanski near the Rozhen Monastery, to commemorate the anniversary of his \"dastardly murder\".", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F208", "text": "The planned rally notified on 16 March 2007 would include laying flowers at the grave of Yane Sandanski, a speech about his life and activity, and a \"cultural programme\".", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F209", "text": "On 16 March 2007 the Mayor of Sandanski informed Ilinden that he could not agree to the rally planned for 22 April 2007, as he had already allowed a sister organisation, UMO Ilinden – PIRIN, to stage an event at the grave of Yane Sandanski between 10 a.m. and 4 p.m. on 22 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F210", "text": "On 26 March 2007 Ilinden informed the Mayor of Sandanski that UMO Ilinden – PIRIN would in fact be holding their event in the town of Melnik, in front of Yane Sandanski's monument, between 10 a.m. and 4 p.m., and that only a small delegation would go to the grave near the Rozhen Monastery to lay flowers between 10 and 11 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F211", "text": "On 26 March 2007 Ilinden proposed to the Mayor of Sandanski to stage their rally at the grave of Yane Sandanski after 11 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F212", "text": "On 26 March 2007 the Mayor of Sandanski informed Ilinden that the rally could take place between 11 a.m. and 12 noon, as the police did not have the means of protecting a longer event.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F213", "text": "As a result of the Mayor of Sandanski's restriction, Ilinden decided to change the date of its rally to 21 April 2007 and notified the Mayor accordingly.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F214", "text": "On 27 March 2007 the Mayor of Sandanski replied that he could not accommodate Ilinden's wish to hold the rally on 21 April 2007, as a vocational training school had already applied for, and been given, permission to stage an event at that time.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F215", "text": "On 28 March 2007 Ilinden filed an application for judicial review with the Sandanski District Court, arguing that the Mayor of Sandanski's refusals to allow the rally as planned were unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F216", "text": "In its application of 28 March 2007, Ilinden argued that it was willing to shift the timing of the event but could not shrink it into the short timeframe allowed by the Mayor of Sandanski.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F217", "text": "In its application of 28 March 2007, Ilinden asked the Sandanski District Court to set aside the Mayor's decisions and allow the rally to be staged between 11 a.m. and 3 p.m. on 22 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F218", "text": "In a decision of 2 April 2007 the Sandanski District Court declared Ilinden's application for judicial review inadmissible.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F219", "text": "The Sandanski District Court held in its decision of 2 April 2007 that the Mayor of Sandanski had not banned the rally but merely proposed a change in its timing, as was his duty under section 12(1) of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F220", "text": "The Sandanski District Court held in its decision of 2 April 2007 that only bans on rallies were reviewable by the courts, and only after such bans had been appealed against to the municipal council.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F221", "text": "The Sandanski District Court held in its decision of 2 April 2007 that the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act did not give the courts jurisdiction to allow the holding of rallies.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F222", "text": "On 6 April 2007 Ilinden appealed to the Blagoevgrad Regional Court against the Sandanski District Court's decision of 2 April 2007, relying inter alia on the European Court of Human Rights' judgment in Ivanov and Others v. Bulgaria (no. 46336/99, 24 November 2005).", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F223", "text": "The outcome of Ilinden's appeal to the Blagoevgrad Regional Court filed on 6 April 2007 is unclear.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F224", "text": "On 18 April 2007 the Regional Governor of Blagoevgrad, acting of his own motion, annulled the Mayor of Sandanski's letter of 26 March 2007 allowing the Ilinden rally.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F225", "text": "The Regional Governor of Blagoevgrad reasoned in his decision of 18 April 2007 that the Mayor of Sandanski's letter of 26 March 2007 amounted to an administrative decision creating legal rights for Ilinden and that it was unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F226", "text": "The Regional Governor of Blagoevgrad stated in his decision of 18 April 2007 that Ilinden was not registered and that in February 2007 the Supreme Court of Cassation had upheld the Sofia City Court's judgment turning down a request by UMO Ilinden – PIRIN to be registered as a political party (as described in UMO Ilinden – PIRIN and Others v. Bulgaria (no. 2), no. 41561/07, §§ 8-19, 18 October 2011).", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F227", "text": "The Regional Governor of Blagoevgrad stated in his decision of 18 April 2007 that since Ilinden was unlawful under Bulgarian law, it had no standing to give notice of its intention to hold a rally.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F228", "text": "The Regional Governor of Blagoevgrad stated in his decision of 18 April 2007 that the proposed rally would put public order at risk, as the Rozhen Monastery was visited by many tourists, especially at weekends.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F229", "text": "The Regional Governor of Blagoevgrad stated in his decision of 18 April 2007 that rallies and meetings were being organised at the Rozhen Monastery location at the same time by local authorities and non-governmental organisations.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F230", "text": "The Regional Governor of Blagoevgrad stated in his decision of 18 April 2007 that as clashes between supporters of Ilinden and others had taken place in the past, it was necessary to ban Ilinden's rally.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F231", "text": "The Regional Governor of Blagoevgrad stated in his decision of 18 April 2007 that the activities of Ilinden were contrary to Bulgarian law, as they consisted in propaganda against the country's sovereignty and territorial integrity and aroused national and ethnic hatred.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F232", "text": "According to the applicants, on 22 April 2007 many bus companies hired to transport participants in the Ilinden rally to the Rozhen Monastery desisted, under pressure from the police.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F233", "text": "According to the applicants, on 22 April 2007 two cars carrying materials for a stage to be erected at the site of the rally were stopped by the police and not allowed to continue.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F234", "text": "According to the applicants, on 22 April 2007 a bus transporting a group of singers was diverted by the police.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F235", "text": "According to the applicants, on 22 April 2007 a number of other cars with participants were stopped and searched by the police while en route to Rozhen Monastery.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F236", "text": "According to the applicants, on 22 April 2007 the grave of Yane Sandanski was surrounded by about a hundred uniformed police officers and a number of plain-clothes ones, who did not allow the participants in the rally to approach it.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F237", "text": "According to the applicants, no other organisations were present at the grave of Yane Sandanski on 22 April 2007.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F238", "text": "According to the Government, Ilinden was able to hold the rally on 22 April 2007, in the presence of many Macedonian journalists and representatives of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the \"former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia\".", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F239", "text": "According to the Government, the alleged difficulties with the transportation of the participants on 22 April 2007 were overblown and the police had done nothing more than to ensure the smooth commemoration by various organisations of the anniversary of Yane Sandanski's death.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F240", "text": "According to the Government, it was not true that participants in the rally on 22 April 2007 had been stopped and searched.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "15. The events of March and April 2007 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F241", "text": "On 26 April 2007 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad of its intention to stage a rally on Macedonia Square, in front of Gotse Delchev's monument, at 4 p.m. on 4 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "16. The events of April and May 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F242", "text": "The rally notified on 26 April 2007 was to mark the anniversary of the assassination of Gotse Delchev, described as a \"Macedonian revolutionary\", and would consist of the laying of a wreath and flowers on the monument and a short speech, lasting one hour.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "16. The events of April and May 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F243", "text": "On 26 April 2007 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad replied that the notification could not be examined as Ilinden had not produced documents proving its official registration.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "16. The events of April and May 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F244", "text": "On 26 April 2007 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that it was impossible to identify the \"managing bodies of [the] event\" due to the lack of registration documents.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "16. The events of April and May 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F245", "text": "On 26 April 2007 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that on 4 May 2007 the municipality was organising children's games on Macedonia Square, so that the staging of Ilinden's event could not be allowed.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "16. The events of April and May 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F246", "text": "Ilinden filed an application for judicial review of the Mayor of Blagoevgrad's decision with the Blagoevgrad District Court, arguing that there was no risk that breaches of public order or traffic disturbances would occur.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "16. The events of April and May 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F247", "text": "In its application for judicial review, Ilinden argued that Macedonia Square was very large and Ilinden was planning to use only a small part of it for its rally.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "16. The events of April and May 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F248", "text": "In its application for judicial review, Ilinden argued that the ban was not justified under section 12(2) of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act or Article 11 § 2 of the Convention and was in breach of Ilinden's right to express its opinion under Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "16. The events of April and May 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F249", "text": "In a final decision of 27 April 2007 the Blagoevgrad District Court dismissed Ilinden's application for judicial review of the ban on the rally planned for 4 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "16. The events of April and May 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F250", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court held in its decision of 27 April 2007 that while the lack of registration did not amount to sufficient grounds to prohibit the rally, the risk that it could infringe the rights of others was enough to justify the ban.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "16. The events of April and May 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F251", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court stated in its decision of 27 April 2007 that it was inopportune to allow adults and children to gather at the same time and place, to concurrently stage a school event and a political one, as \"the children should not be subjected to the political interventions and influences which would inevitably occur if the two events [were] allowed to proceed together\".", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "16. The events of April and May 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F252", "text": "On 3 May 2007 the police, relying on section 55 of the 2006 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act, ordered in writing a member of Ilinden's leadership not to organise or take part in a rally on 4 May 2007.", "source_paragraph": 85, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "16. The events of April and May 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F253", "text": "According to the Government, on 4 May 2007 members of Ilinden laid flowers at the monument to Gotse Delchev without being stopped by the police.", "source_paragraph": 85, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "16. The events of April and May 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F254", "text": "On 16 July 2007 the head of Ilinden's chapter in Petrich notified the Mayor of Petrich that the organisation intended to stage a rally in the area of Samuilova Krepost at 10 a.m. on 29 July 2007, to mark the anniversary of the Ilinden uprising.", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "17. The events of July 2007 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F255", "text": "In a letter of 22 July 2004 the Mayor of Petrich advised Ilinden that VMRO had already applied for and been granted permission to hold an event at Samuilova Krepost at the same place and at the same time as Ilinden's planned rally on 29 July 2007.", "source_paragraph": 87, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "17. The events of July 2007 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F256", "text": "On 20 July 2007 Ilinden sought judicial review of the Mayor of Petrich's decision by the Petrich District Court, arguing that both events could proceed simultaneously.", "source_paragraph": 88, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "17. The events of July 2007 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F257", "text": "In a decision of 25 July 2007 the Petrich District Court declared Ilinden's application for judicial review inadmissible.", "source_paragraph": 88, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "17. The events of July 2007 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F258", "text": "The Petrich District Court held in its decision of 25 July 2007 that the Mayor of Petrich's letter did not amount to a ban, but merely to information that another rally had been planned for the same time and place.", "source_paragraph": 88, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "17. The events of July 2007 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F259", "text": "The Petrich District Court held in its decision of 25 July 2007 that under the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act, if a rally had not been banned within twenty-four hours of notice being given to the Mayor, it could proceed.", "source_paragraph": 88, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "17. The events of July 2007 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F260", "text": "The Petrich District Court held in its decision of 25 July 2007 that even if the Mayor did ban a rally, that decision first had to be appealed against to the municipal council and only then challenged by way of judicial review.", "source_paragraph": 88, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "17. The events of July 2007 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F261", "text": "On 29 July 2007 about three hundred and fifty members and supporters of Ilinden approached Samuilova Krepost, carrying placards and banners.", "source_paragraph": 89, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "17. The events of July 2007 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F262", "text": "According to the applicants, on 29 July 2007 the Ilinden participants were stopped by the police before reaching Samuilova Krepost and were ordered to put the placards and banners down.", "source_paragraph": 89, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "17. The events of July 2007 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F263", "text": "According to the applicants, the Ilinden participants obeyed the police order on 29 July 2007 and were allowed access to Samuilova Krepost without the materials.", "source_paragraph": 89, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "17. The events of July 2007 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F264", "text": "On 29 July 2007 the participants in the Ilinden rally laid wreaths and flowers at Samuilova Krepost.", "source_paragraph": 89, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "17. The events of July 2007 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F265", "text": "On 29 July 2007 a plain-clothes police officer removed the ribbons from the wreaths laid by the Ilinden participants at Samuilova Krepost.", "source_paragraph": 89, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "17. The events of July 2007 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F266", "text": "On 29 July 2007 the Ilinden participants tried to erect a stage at their chosen place at Samuilova Krepost but were stopped by the police and so erected it on the other side of a small river crossing the site.", "source_paragraph": 89, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "17. The events of July 2007 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F267", "text": "According to the Government, the police did not impose restrictions on the manner of commemorating the anniversary at Samuilova Krepost on 29 July 2007.", "source_paragraph": 89, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "17. The events of July 2007 (Samuilova Krepost)"]}, {"fact_id": "F268", "text": "On 28 August 2007 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad of its intention to stage a rally on Macedonia Square, in front of Gotse Delchev's monument, at 4.30 p.m. on 12 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 90, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F269", "text": "The rally notified on 28 August 2007 was to mark the anniversary of \"the genocide against the Macedonians\" and would consist of the laying of a wreath and flowers on the monument and a short speech, lasting one hour.", "source_paragraph": 90, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F270", "text": "On 29 August 2007 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad replied that the notification could not be examined as Ilinden had not produced documents proving its official registration.", "source_paragraph": 91, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F271", "text": "On 29 August 2007 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the municipality had planned a children's holiday under the name \"Hello, school\" on Macedonia Square for 12 September 2007, to mark the beginning of the school year, which made the holding of Ilinden's rally impossible.", "source_paragraph": 91, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F272", "text": "On 30 August 2007 Ilinden sought judicial review of the Mayor of Blagoevgrad's decision by the newly created Blagoevgrad Administrative Court.", "source_paragraph": 92, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F273", "text": "In a decision of 30 August 2007 the Blagoevgrad Administrative Court found that under the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act, which was lex specialis in relation to the general rules of administrative procedure, the court competent to examine an application for judicial review of a Mayor's decision to ban a rally was the district court.", "source_paragraph": 92, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F274", "text": "The Blagoevgrad Administrative Court sent the file to the Blagoevgrad District Court in its decision of 30 August 2007.", "source_paragraph": 92, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F275", "text": "In a final decision of 5 September 2007 the Blagoevgrad District Court dismissed Ilinden's application for judicial review of the ban on the rally planned for 12 September 2007.", "source_paragraph": 93, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F276", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court held in its decision of 5 September 2007 that while the lack of registration did not amount to sufficient grounds to prohibit the rally, the fact that another event likely to draw a number of people, many of whom were children, was due to take place on the same date in Macedonia Square was enough to justify the ban.", "source_paragraph": 93, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F277", "text": "According to the applicants, no school event took place at 4 p.m. on 12 September 2007 on Macedonia Square in Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 94, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F278", "text": "According to the applicants, when a number of members and supporters of Ilinden gathered in front of the American University in Blagoevgrad at about 5 p.m. on 12 September 2007, they were stopped by the police and a number of them were arrested.", "source_paragraph": 94, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F279", "text": "According to the applicants, the arrested Ilinden members on 12 September 2007 were taken to a police station, held for about three hours, and charged with committing administrative offences for having tried to take part in a banned rally.", "source_paragraph": 94, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F280", "text": "On 22 October 2007 the deputy Mayor of Blagoevgrad imposed administrative fines of 200 Bulgarian levs (102.26 euros) each on the second applicant and on a number of members of Ilinden for having taken part in a banned rally, in breach of a public-order regulation issued by the Blagoevgrad Municipal Council.", "source_paragraph": 95, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F281", "text": "The second applicant and the members of Ilinden fined on 22 October 2007 all sought judicial review of the fines.", "source_paragraph": 95, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F282", "text": "In a series of judgments delivered on 18 and 19 February, 11 March, and 22 and 29 May 2008 the Blagoevgrad District Court annulled the fines imposed on 22 October 2007.", "source_paragraph": 95, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F283", "text": "In some of the judgments annulling the fines, the Blagoevgrad District Court found that the fines were invalid as under the applicable rules the deputy Mayor of Blagoevgrad had no power to impose administrative punishments.", "source_paragraph": 95, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F284", "text": "In other judgments annulling the fines, the Blagoevgrad District Court found that the deputy Mayor's decisions were defective because they did not specify which administrative offences had been committed.", "source_paragraph": 95, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F285", "text": "In other judgments annulling the fines, the Blagoevgrad District Court held that although the Mayor's ban on the rally planned for 12 September 2007 was legally binding, the actions of the members of Ilinden on that date had not amounted to the staging of a rally, as they had been too few and had not tried to wave banners and make speeches, but merely to lay flowers on Gotse Delchev's monument.", "source_paragraph": 95, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F286", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court stated in those judgments that every person, regardless of their political convictions, had the right to honour the memory of national heroes in peace.", "source_paragraph": 95, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "18. The events of August and September 2007 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F287", "text": "On 4 March 2008 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Sandanski that it intended to stage a rally between 10.30 a.m. and 3 p.m. on 20 April 2008 at the grave of Yane Sandanski near the Rozhen Monastery, to commemorate the anniversary of his murder.", "source_paragraph": 96, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "19. The events of March and April 2008 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F288", "text": "The planned rally notified on 4 March 2008 would include laying flowers at the grave of Yane Sandanski, a speech about his life and work, and a \"literary and musical programme\".", "source_paragraph": 96, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "19. The events of March and April 2008 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F289", "text": "On 17 March 2008 the Mayor of Sandanski advised Ilinden that its members could lay flowers on the grave of Yane Sandanski between 10.30 and 11 a.m. on 20 April 2008, but not carry out the remainder of their programme, as an event had been planned for that date by a vocational training school.", "source_paragraph": 96, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "19. The events of March and April 2008 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F290", "text": "On 26 March 2008 Ilinden sought judicial review by the Sandanski District Court, arguing that there was enough room for both its and the school's events and that the limitations imposed by the Mayor of Sandanski hindered the exercise of its right of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 97, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "19. The events of March and April 2008 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F291", "text": "In a decision of 17 April 2008 the Sandanski District Court found that Ilinden's application for judicial review was inadmissible.", "source_paragraph": 97, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "19. The events of March and April 2008 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F292", "text": "The Sandanski District Court held in its decision of 17 April 2008 that the Mayor of Sandanski had not banned the rally but merely proposed a change in its timing, as was his duty under section 12(1) of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act.", "source_paragraph": 97, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "19. The events of March and April 2008 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F293", "text": "The Sandanski District Court held in its decision of 17 April 2008 that only bans on rallies were reviewable by the courts, and only after such bans had been appealed against to the municipal council, and that the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act did not give the courts jurisdiction to allow the holding of rallies.", "source_paragraph": 97, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "19. The events of March and April 2008 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F294", "text": "On 17 April 2008 the police, relying on section 55 of the 2006 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act, ordered the second applicant to abide by the limitations imposed by the Mayor of Sandanski, to ensure public order during the event, not to urge a violent change of the constitutional order, and not to incite the commission of offences through public speeches.", "source_paragraph": 98, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "19. The events of March and April 2008 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F295", "text": "According to the applicants, on 20 April 2008 the police stopped a number of cars travelling to Rozhen to take part in the Ilinden rally.", "source_paragraph": 99, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "19. The events of March and April 2008 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F296", "text": "According to the applicants, the grave of Yane Sandanski was surrounded by about thirty police officers on 20 April 2008.", "source_paragraph": 99, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "19. The events of March and April 2008 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F297", "text": "According to the applicants, on 20 April 2008 one police officer wanted to remove the ribbons from a wreath which members of Ilinden wished to lay on the grave of Yane Sandanski, which sparked off a forceful verbal exchange.", "source_paragraph": 99, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "19. The events of March and April 2008 (Rozhen)"]}, {"fact_id": "F298", "text": "On 1 September 2008 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad of its intention to stage a rally on Macedonia Square, in front of Gotse Delchev's monument, from 5 p.m. to 6 p.m. on 12 September 2008, to commemorate \"the genocide against the Macedonians perpetrated by Bulgarian State terrorism\".", "source_paragraph": 100, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "20. The events of September 2008 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F299", "text": "The rally notified on 1 September 2008 would consist of the laying of a wreath and flowers in front of Gotse Delchev's monument, the making of a short speech, and the lighting of candles.", "source_paragraph": 100, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "20. The events of September 2008 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F300", "text": "The Mayor of Blagoevgrad did not reply to Ilinden's notification of 1 September 2008.", "source_paragraph": 100, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "20. The events of September 2008 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F301", "text": "A number of members and supporters of Ilinden gathered in front of the American University in Blagoevgrad at about 4.40 p.m. on 12 September 2008.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "20. The events of September 2008 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F302", "text": "The Ilinden members and supporters gathered on 12 September 2008 carried two posters saying \"UMO Ilinden\" and \"12 September – Day of the Genocide of the Macedonians of Bulgaria\".", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "20. The events of September 2008 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F303", "text": "Several uniformed and plain-clothes police officers appeared at the scene in front of the American University in Blagoevgrad ten minutes after the Ilinden members gathered on 12 September 2008.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "20. The events of September 2008 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F304", "text": "On 12 September 2008 one police officer told the Ilinden participants that if they carried posters \"which are against Bulgaria\" the posters would be taken away.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "20. The events of September 2008 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F305", "text": "On 12 September 2008 the police seized the poster bearing the inscription \"12 September – Day of the Genocide of the Macedonians of Bulgaria\" from the Ilinden participants.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "20. The events of September 2008 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F306", "text": "On 12 September 2008 the participants in the Ilinden rally headed towards Macedonia Square in Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "20. The events of September 2008 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F307", "text": "On the way to Macedonia Square on 12 September 2008, two men threatened one of the Ilinden participants, saying \"we will now fine you 200 [Bulgarian] levs each, I know your sons, we will fire them from work ...\".", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "20. The events of September 2008 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F308", "text": "On 12 September 2008 the members of Ilinden stood in front of Gotse Delchev's monument on Macedonia Square, laid a wreath and flowers, and lit candles.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "20. The events of September 2008 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F309", "text": "On 12 September 2008 one member of Ilinden made a short speech at Gotse Delchev's monument on Macedonia Square.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "20. The events of September 2008 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F310", "text": "The police did not interfere with the Ilinden event at Macedonia Square on 12 September 2008.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "20. The events of September 2008 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F311", "text": "After the Ilinden event on 12 September 2008, the police arrested a member of Ilinden who was taking photographs, took his camera by force, and exposed the film in it.", "source_paragraph": 101, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "20. The events of September 2008 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F312", "text": "On 24 April 2009 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad of its intention to stage a rally on Macedonia Square, in front of Gotse Delchev's monument, at 5 p.m. on 4 May 2009, to mark the anniversary of Gotse Delchev's death.", "source_paragraph": 102, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "21. The events of April and May 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F313", "text": "In a letter delivered to Ilinden's chairman at 4.30 p.m. on 30 April 2009 the Mayor of Blagoevgrad informed the organisation that they could join the laying of flowers in front of Gotse Delchev's monument at 10 a.m. on 4 May 2009, together with representatives of other political and civic organisations.", "source_paragraph": 103, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "21. The events of April and May 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F314", "text": "In view of the short time until the date of the planned event, Ilinden did not seek judicial review of the Mayor of Blagoevgrad's decision communicated on 30 April 2009.", "source_paragraph": 103, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "21. The events of April and May 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F315", "text": "The second applicant and two other members of Ilinden tried to approach Gotse Delchev's monument at 2.40 p.m. on 4 May 2009.", "source_paragraph": 104, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "21. The events of April and May 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F316", "text": "The second applicant and two other members of Ilinden were arrested and taken to a police station on 4 May 2009.", "source_paragraph": 104, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "21. The events of April and May 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F317", "text": "At the police station on 4 May 2009, the second applicant and two other members of Ilinden were issued orders under section 55 of the 2006 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act not to take part in the rally prohibited by the Mayor of Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 104, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "21. The events of April and May 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F318", "text": "On 4 May 2009 the police seized a wreath with a ribbon saying \"To Gotse from UMO Ilinden\" from the Ilinden members.", "source_paragraph": 104, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "21. The events of April and May 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F319", "text": "On 31 August 2009 Ilinden notified the Mayor of Blagoevgrad of its intention to stage a rally in Macedonia Square, in front of Gotse Delchev's monument, between 12 noon and 1 p.m. on 12 September 2009, to mark the \"day of the genocide against the Macedonian people\".", "source_paragraph": 105, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "22. The events of August and September 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F320", "text": "The Mayor of Blagoevgrad did not reply to Ilinden's notification of 31 August 2009.", "source_paragraph": 105, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "22. The events of August and September 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F321", "text": "On 12 September 2009 members and supporters of Ilinden gathered in front of Gotse Delchev's monument on Macedonia Square in Blagoevgrad but were arrested and taken to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 106, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "22. The events of August and September 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F322", "text": "At the police station on 12 September 2009, the police, relying on section 55 of the 2006 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act, ordered the second applicant and six other members of Ilinden's leadership not to take part in rallies not authorised by the Mayor of Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 106, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "22. The events of August and September 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F323", "text": "On 12 September 2009 the police seized from the Ilinden members a ribbon bearing the inscription \"12.IX. Day of the genocide against the Macedonian people\".", "source_paragraph": 106, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "22. The events of August and September 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F324", "text": "On 12 September 2009 the police seized from the Ilinden members a poster bearing the inscription \"12.IX. Day of the genocide against the Macedonian people\".", "source_paragraph": 106, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "22. The events of August and September 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F325", "text": "On 12 September 2009 the police seized from the Ilinden members a red flag bearing the inscription \"Macedonia\" and depicting the \"Star of Vergina\".", "source_paragraph": 106, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "22. The events of August and September 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F326", "text": "On 14 September 2009 Ilinden requested the return of the items seized on 12 September 2009.", "source_paragraph": 106, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "22. The events of August and September 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F327", "text": "The police returned the seized items to Ilinden on 15 September 2009.", "source_paragraph": 106, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Rallies organised by Ilinden between 2004 and 2009", "22. The events of August and September 2009 (Blagoevgrad)"]}, {"fact_id": "F328", "text": "The relevant provisions of the 1991 Constitution and of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act are set out in paragraphs 48-51 of the European Court of Human Rights' judgment in Stankov and the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden v. Bulgaria (nos. 29221/95 and 29225/95, ECHR 2001-IX).", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F329", "text": "The relevant provisions of the 1991 Constitution and of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act are set out in paragraphs 72-76 of the European Court of Human Rights' judgment in United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Ivanov v. Bulgaria (no. 44079/98, 20 October 2005).", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F330", "text": "The relevant provisions of the 1991 Constitution and of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act are set out in paragraphs 24-28 of the European Court of Human Rights' judgment in Ivanov and Others v. Bulgaria (no. 46336/99, 24 November 2005).", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F331", "text": "Section 12(1) of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act provided that where the time or the place of the meeting, or the itinerary of the march, would create a situation endangering public order or traffic safety, the President of the Executive Committee of the People's Council, or the mayor, respectively, shall propose their modification.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F332", "text": "Section 12(2) of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act provided that the President of the Executive Committee of the People's Council, or the mayor, shall be competent to prohibit the holding of a meeting, demonstration or march where reliable information exists that it aims at the violent overturning of constitutional public order or is directed against the territorial integrity of the country.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F333", "text": "Section 12(2) of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act provided that the President of the Executive Committee of the People's Council, or the mayor, shall be competent to prohibit the holding of a meeting, demonstration or march where reliable information exists that it would endanger public order in the local community.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F334", "text": "Section 12(2) of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act provided that the President of the Executive Committee of the People's Council, or the mayor, shall be competent to prohibit the holding of a meeting, demonstration or march where reliable information exists that it would breach the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F335", "text": "Section 12(3) of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act provided that the prohibition shall be imposed by a written reasoned act not later than twenty-four hours following the notification.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F336", "text": "Section 12(4) of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act provided that the organiser of the meeting, demonstration or march may appeal to the Executive Committee of the People's Council against the prohibition, and the Executive Committee shall decide within twenty-four hours.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F337", "text": "Section 12(5) of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act provided that where the Executive Committee of the People's Council has not decided within the time-limit, the march, demonstration or meeting may proceed.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F338", "text": "Section 12(6) of the 1990 Meetings and Marches Act provided that if the appeal is dismissed the dispute shall be referred to the relevant district court which shall decide within five days, and that court's decision shall be final.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F339", "text": "The 1990 Meetings and Marches Act was adopted when the 1971 Constitution was in force, under which the executive local State authorities were the executive committees of the people's councils in each district.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F340", "text": "The 1991 Constitution abolished the executive committees of the people's councils and established the post of mayor, elected by direct universal suffrage, as the \"organ of the executive power in the municipality\" under Article 139.", "source_paragraph": 107, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F341", "text": "Under section 62(1) of the 1997 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act, the police could, if necessary for the performance of their duties, issue orders to individuals or organisations.", "source_paragraph": 108, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F342", "text": "Under section 62(4) of the 1997 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act, orders issued by the police were binding unless they obviously imposed the commission of an offence.", "source_paragraph": 108, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F343", "text": "Section 62(5) of the 1997 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act provided that police orders, when issued in writing, were subject to judicial review.", "source_paragraph": 108, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F344", "text": "Section 55(1), (4) and (5) of the 2006 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act, which superseded section 62 of the 1997 Ministry of Internal Affairs Act on 1 May 2006, has almost identical wording and is currently in force.", "source_paragraph": 108, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F345", "text": "Under section 31(1)(a) of the 1998 Administration Act, regional governors carry out governmental policy and coordinate the operations of the branches of central government in their respective regions.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F346", "text": "Under section 31(1)(b) of the 1998 Administration Act, regional governors seek to achieve a balance between national and local interests and interact with the local authorities.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F347", "text": "Under section 31(1)(c) of the 1998 Administration Act, regional governors are responsible for safeguarding State property in their respective regions.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F348", "text": "Under section 31(1)(d) of the 1998 Administration Act, regional governors uphold legality in their regions and supervise the enforcement of administrative decisions.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F349", "text": "Under section 31(1)(e) of the 1998 Administration Act, regional governors control the lawfulness of the decisions and the actions of local authorities.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F350", "text": "Under section 31(1)(f) of the 1998 Administration Act, regional governors coordinate and control the operations of the territorial branches of ministries and other central authorities, as well as the enforcement of their decisions.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F351", "text": "Under section 31(1)(g) of the 1998 Administration Act, regional governors organise civil defence.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F352", "text": "Under section 31(1)(h) of the 1998 Administration Act, regional governors preside over the regional security councils.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F353", "text": "Under section 31(1)(i) of the 1998 Administration Act, regional governors carry out the region's international contacts.", "source_paragraph": 109, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F354", "text": "Under Article 93 § 4 of the 2006 Code of Administrative Procedure, all mayoral decisions may be challenged before regional governors.", "source_paragraph": 110, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F355", "text": "Under section 32(2) of the 1998 Administration Act, regional governors may annul unlawful mayoral decisions.", "source_paragraph": 110, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F356", "text": "Under section 32(3) of the 1998 Administration Act, regional governors' decisions to annul unlawful mayoral decisions are subject to judicial review.", "source_paragraph": 110, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F357", "text": "Section 1(1) of the 1988 State Responsibility for Damage Caused to Citizens Act (renamed \"State and Municipalities Responsibility for Damage Act\" on 12 July 2006) provides that the State is liable for damage suffered by private persons as a result of unlawful decisions, actions or omissions by civil servants committed in the course of or in connection with the performance of their duties.", "source_paragraph": 111, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F358", "text": "Since 1 January 2006, municipalities are also liable under section 1(1) of the 1988 State and Municipalities Responsibility for Damage Act for damage suffered by private persons as a result of unlawful decisions, actions or omissions by civil servants committed in the course of or in connection with the performance of their duties.", "source_paragraph": 111, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F359", "text": "Article 169b of the 1968 Criminal Code makes it an offence to prevent someone, through violence, threats or other unlawful means, from exercising their \"constitutional political rights\".", "source_paragraph": 112, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F360", "text": "Article 169c of the 1968 Criminal Code provides that the offence under Article 169b is aggravated if committed by officials during or in connection with the performance of their duties.", "source_paragraph": 112, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F361", "text": "The Committee of Ministers concluded the examination of application no. 44079/98 (United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Ivanov v. Bulgaria) on 8 June 2011 by adopting Resolution CM/ResDH(2011)46.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOCUMENTS OF THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS"]}, {"fact_id": "F362", "text": "The Committee of Ministers concluded the examination of application no. 46336/99 (Ivanov and Others v. Bulgaria) on 8 June 2011 by adopting Resolution CM/ResDH(2011)46.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOCUMENTS OF THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS"]}, {"fact_id": "F363", "text": "Resolution CM/ResDH(2011)46 recalled that the violations of the Convention found by the European Court of Human Rights in applications nos. 44079/98 and 46336/99 concerned the infringement of the freedom of assembly of organisations aiming to achieve \"the recognition of the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria\" due to prohibitions of their meetings between 1998 and 2003, in violation of Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOCUMENTS OF THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS"]}, {"fact_id": "F364", "text": "Resolution CM/ResDH(2011)46 recalled that the violations of the Convention found by the European Court of Human Rights in applications nos. 44079/98 and 46336/99 included the lack of effective remedies to complain against the prohibitions of meetings, in violation of Article 13 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOCUMENTS OF THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS"]}, {"fact_id": "F365", "text": "Resolution CM/ResDH(2011)46 noted that two other applications were pending before the European Court of Human Rights concerning allegations relating to bans or to the holding of certain meetings of the applicants initially scheduled between March 2004 and September 2009.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOCUMENTS OF THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS"]}, {"fact_id": "F366", "text": "Resolution CM/ResDH(2011)46 stated that, in view of the positive trend observed concerning the holding of the applicants' meetings particularly since 2008 and the absence of complaints from them as regards 2010, no further individual measure seemed required in applications nos. 44079/98 and 46336/99.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOCUMENTS OF THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS"]}, {"fact_id": "F367", "text": "Resolution CM/ResDH(2011)46 noted that the Bulgarian authorities had taken awareness-raising measures to ensure that applicable domestic law is interpreted in conformity with the Convention and to prevent violations similar to those found by the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOCUMENTS OF THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS"]}, {"fact_id": "F368", "text": "Resolution CM/ResDH(2011)46 noted that the respondent state paid the applicants the just satisfaction provided in the judgments in applications nos. 44079/98 and 46336/99 within the time-limit set.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOCUMENTS OF THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS"]}, {"fact_id": "F369", "text": "By Resolution CM/ResDH(2011)46, the Committee of Ministers declared that it had exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in applications nos. 44079/98 and 46336/99 and decided to close the examination of those cases.", "source_paragraph": 113, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. RELEVANT DOCUMENTS OF THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F048", "F049", "F057", "F061", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F068", "F074", "F080", "F081", "F082", "F099", "F101", "F102", "F103", "F104", "F105", "F110", "F111", "F115", "F116", "F125", "F126", "F128", "F129", "F131", "F140", "F141", "F142", "F149", "F151", "F152", "F153", "F154", "F155", "F157", "F158", "F165", "F166", "F169", "F170", "F171", "F207", "F208", "F209", "F212", "F241", "F243", "F244", "F245", "F252", "F254", "F255", "F268", "F270", "F271", "F278", "F279", "F280", "F287", "F288", "F289", "F294", "F305", "F311", "F316", "F317", "F318", "F321", "F322", "F323", "F324", "F325"], "interference": ["F003", "F004", "F009", "F010", "F024", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F048", "F049", "F061", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F080", "F082", "F099", "F101", "F102", "F103", "F104", "F105", "F110", "F111", "F115", "F116", "F125", "F126", "F128", "F129", "F131", "F140", "F142", "F149", "F151", "F152", "F153", "F154", "F155", "F157", "F158", "F165", "F166", "F169", "F170", "F171", "F207", "F212", "F224", "F225", "F226", "F227", "F228", "F229", "F230", "F231", "F241", "F243", "F244", "F245", "F252", "F254", "F255", "F268", "F270", "F271", "F278", "F279", "F280", "F287", "F289", "F294", "F305", "F311", "F316", "F317", "F318", "F321", "F322", "F323", "F324", "F325"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F032", "F041", "F064", "F104", "F128", "F129", "F131", "F154", "F157", "F158", "F169", "F170", "F224", "F225", "F226", "F227", "F243", "F244", "F252", "F270", "F278", "F279", "F280", "F281", "F282", "F283", "F284", "F285", "F294", "F305", "F311", "F316", "F317", "F318", "F321", "F322", "F323", "F324", "F325", "F331", "F332", "F333", "F334", "F335", "F336", "F337", "F338", "F341", "F342", "F343", "F344"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F009", "F010", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F041", "F042", "F043", "F049", "F050", "F057", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F074", "F081", "F082", "F103", "F104", "F105", "F110", "F116", "F119", "F126", "F128", "F129", "F142", "F153", "F154", "F155", "F157", "F158", "F162", "F166", "F169", "F170", "F171", "F174", "F175", "F176", "F177", "F212", "F243", "F244", "F245", "F250", "F251", "F252", "F270", "F271", "F276", "F278", "F279", "F280", "F281", "F282", "F289", "F294", "F317", "F322"], "positive_obligation": ["F057", "F074", "F119", "F162"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F048", "F057", "F068", "F074"], "interference": ["F009", "F033", "F041", "F049", "F131", "F224", "F280", "F316"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F032", "F131", "F224", "F280", "F281", "F282", "F341", "F344"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F010", "F032", "F033", "F041", "F049", "F057", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F074", "F104", "F105", "F116", "F128", "F154", "F155", "F169", "F170", "F171", "F175", "F176", "F177", "F243", "F244", "F245", "F250", "F251", "F270", "F271", "F276", "F278", "F280", "F282"], "positive_obligation": ["F057", "F074"]}, "list3": ["F009", "F010", "F032", "F033", "F041", "F049", "F057", "F063", "F064", "F065", "F074", "F104", "F105", "F116", "F128", "F131", "F154", "F155", "F169", "F170", "F171", "F175", "F176", "F177", "F224", "F243", "F244", "F245", "F250", "F251", "F270", "F271", "F276", "F278", "F280", "F282", "F316"]}} {"case_name": "case_624", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "Ilinden is an association based in south-west Bulgaria, in an area known as the Pirin region or the geographic region of Pirin Macedonia.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "Ilinden has chapters in, inter alia, the towns of Sandanski, Petrich and Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Ilinden was founded on 14 April 1990.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "In 1990 Ilinden applied for registration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The courts refused Ilinden's 1990 registration application, holding that its statute and programme were directed against the unity of the nation (see Stankov and the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden v. Bulgaria, nos. 29221/95 and 29225/95, §§ 10-14, ECHR 2001-IX).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Ilinden's second attempt to register in 1998-99 likewise failed (see The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Others v. Bulgaria (dec.), no. 59491/00, 9 September 2004).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Ilinden's third attempt to register in 2002-04 likewise failed (see The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Others v. Bulgaria (dec.), no. 59491/00, 9 September 2004).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "During the period 1990-97 Ilinden each year tried to organise meetings at sites in Pirin Macedonia to commemorate certain historical events.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "All of Ilinden's commemorations during the period 1990-97 were banned by the Bulgarian authorities (see Stankov and the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden v. Bulgaria, nos. 29221/95 and 29225/95, §§ 15-31, ECHR 2001-IX).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 25 March 1998 the second applicant and three other members of Ilinden informed the mayor of Sandanski that Ilinden intended to organise a meeting on 19 April 1998 at the Rozhen monastery to commemorate the anniversary of the death of Yane Sandanski, a historical figure buried there.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 3 April 1998 the mayor of Sandanski informed the second applicant and the other members of Ilinden that he prohibited the meeting planned for 19 April 1998 at the Rozhen monastery, as the municipality was preparing a commemoration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 3 April 1998 the mayor of Sandanski informed the second applicant and the other members of Ilinden that he prohibited the meeting planned for 19 April 1998 at the Rozhen monastery because another association, which according to the Government was hostile towards Ilinden, had already notified the mayor of its intention to hold a meeting at the same time and place.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "Following the mayor of Sandanski's prohibition, the second applicant and the other members of Ilinden informed the mayor that in view of the scheduling conflict they decided to move the event to an earlier date, 18 April 1998.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 14 April 1998 the mayor of Sandanski replied that he could not assent to the meeting being held on 18 April 1998, as in the meantime the other association had informed him that their commemoration would last from 18 until 22 April.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 14 April 1998 Ilinden lodged an application for judicial review of the mayor of Sandanski's refusals with the Sandanski District Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 16 April 1998 Ilinden lodged an application for judicial review of the mayor of Sandanski's refusals with the Sandanski District Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 10 April 1998 Ilinden advised the head of the local police station of its intention to hold the meeting on 18 April 1998.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 16 April 1998 the police conducted a search at the home of a member of Ilinden, which served as a club of the organisation.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 16 April 1998 the police conducted a search at the home of another member of Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 16 April 1998 the police seized a copy machine, newspapers, books, leaflets, and some other items during searches at the homes of members of Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 17 April 1998 the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office issued a decree ordering the police to take measures to prevent Ilinden from holding a meeting.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office decree of 17 April 1998 was based on Article 185 § 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office decree of 17 April 1998 stated that the holding of the meeting by Ilinden would constitute an offence under Article 174a of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 17 April 1998 the police summoned the second applicant and several other members of Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 17 April 1998 the second applicant and several other members of Ilinden were issued written warnings informing them that the planned meeting had been banned by the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 18 April 1998 a number of members and followers of Ilinden from towns and villages in Pirin Macedonia tried to approach the Rozhen monastery by cars and by buses.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 18 April 1998 all members and followers of Ilinden trying to approach the Rozhen monastery were turned back by the police who were placed at checkpoints on the roads leading to the monastery.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 18 April 1998 the passengers of one bus travelling to the Rozhen monastery were forced off and the driver was fined for allegedly driving a vehicle in a state of disrepair.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 18 April 1998 one person coming by car to the Rozhen monastery was apparently taken into custody by the Sandanski police for ten hours for allegedly failing to produce an identification document, and was ill-treated.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 24 April 1998 the Sandanski District Court informed Ilinden of its refusal to examine the applications for judicial review on the merits, as they had been submitted on behalf of an unregistered organisation and were vague.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 24 April 1998 the Sandanski District Court invited Ilinden to rectify the deficiencies in its applications for judicial review within seven days.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 29 April 1998 the second applicant and several other members of Ilinden filed complaints against the 16 April 1998 search and seizure with the Regional Police Directorate and requested the return of the seized items.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "It appears that no reply was received by Ilinden from the Regional Police Directorate in response to the complaints filed on 29 April 1998 about the 16 April 1998 search and seizure.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 13 May 1998 the second applicant complained to the Sofia Military Prosecutor's Office about the coercive actions of the police before and during the planned commemoration of 18 April 1998.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "It appears that the second applicant did not receive an answer from the Sofia Military Prosecutor's Office in response to his complaint of 13 May 1998.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "1. The events of March, April and May 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 10 July 1998 Ilinden notified the mayor of Petrich that it planned to hold a meeting in the area of Samuilova krepost on 2 August 1998.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 15 July 1998 the mayor of Petrich replied that he could not allow the holding of a meeting at Samuilova krepost on 2 August 1998, as another meeting had been planned for the same date and place by a municipal child centre.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 16 July 1998 Ilinden lodged an application for judicial review with the Petrich District Court, arguing that for years in a row its meetings had been banned.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "In its application for judicial review of 16 July 1998, Ilinden stated that the area of Samuilova krepost where it planned to hold the meeting was large enough for two parallel events.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "In its application for judicial review of 16 July 1998, Ilinden stated that if holding two parallel events at Samuilova krepost was deemed impracticable, it was prepared to reschedule the meeting for another date.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "In a judgment of 20 July 1998 the Petrich District Court dismissed Ilinden's application for judicial review.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "In its judgment of 20 July 1998 the Petrich District Court held that Ilinden was not duly registered in accordance with the laws of Bulgaria.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "In its judgment of 20 July 1998 the Petrich District Court held that as a result of Ilinden's lack of registration, it was unclear who would be the organiser of the event and who would be responsible for order during the meeting, in accordance with sections 9 and 10 of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "In its judgment of 20 July 1998 the Petrich District Court concluded that the lack of clarity as to the organisers of a public event endangered public order and the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 28 July 1998 the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office issued a decree under Article 185 § 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, ordering the police to take measures to prevent Ilinden from holding a meeting.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office decree of 28 July 1998 reasoned that Ilinden was not registered and hence had no right to organisational or political activities, and that the holding of a meeting would therefore constitute an offence under Article 174a of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office decree of 28 July 1998 reasoned that Ilinden was advocating changes in the constitutional order in Bulgaria and that the holding of a meeting would therefore also constitute an offence under Chapter 1 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 2 August 1998 a number of members and followers of Ilinden travelled by car to Samuilova krepost, but all roads leading to the site were blocked by the police who were stopping the cars and turning them back.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Earlier in the morning of 2 August 1998 members of Ilinden from Petrich gathered at a bus station in order to go to Samuilova krepost.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 2 August 1998 several police officers approached members of Ilinden at the bus station in Petrich, informed them that the meeting had been banned by the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office, and warned them not to try to reach Samuilova krepost.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "On 2 August 1998, the plans of Ilinden to have the meeting at Samuilova krepost having failed, its members decided to hold it at the organisation's club in Petrich.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 2 August 1998, on the way to the organisation's club in Petrich, members of Ilinden tried to lay flowers and wreaths at the memorial of a poet, but the police blocked their way.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 2 August 1998 apparently one person was arrested and held for six hours in custody in connection with the events at Petrich.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "2. The events of July and August 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "On 7 September 1998 Ilinden notified the mayor of Blagoevgrad that it planned to lay wreaths on 12 September 1998 at the memorial of Gotze Delchev, situated in the centre of Blagoevgrad, to observe the seventy-fourth anniversary of the alleged killing of certain Macedonian activists by agents of the Bulgarian government.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "3. The events of September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "After no reply was forthcoming from the mayor of Blagoevgrad, the head of the local chapter of Ilinden telephoned the secretary of the municipality to enquire about the matter.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "3. The events of September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The secretary of the municipality of Blagoevgrad informed the head of the local chapter of Ilinden that Ilinden would not receive a written answer and that the municipality would advise the police so that it could prevent the event planned for 12 September 1998.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "3. The events of September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The applicants submitted that on 10 September 1998 Ilinden lodged an application for judicial review with the Blagoevgrad District Court, but that it was not examined within the statutory time-limit.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "3. The events of September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Government submitted that the records of the Blagoevgrad District Court did not indicate that an application for judicial review had indeed been lodged by Ilinden on 10 September 1998.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "3. The events of September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 11 September 1998 the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office issued a decree under Article 185 § 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, ordering the police to take measures to prevent Ilinden from holding a meeting.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "3. The events of September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office decree of 11 September 1998 reasoned that Ilinden was not registered and hence had no right to organisational or political activities.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "3. The events of September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office decree of 11 September 1998 reasoned that Ilinden was advocating changes in the constitutional order of Bulgaria and expressed anti-Bulgarian views.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "3. The events of September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office decree of 11 September 1998 stated that the holding of a meeting by Ilinden would lead to the commission of offences under Article 174a § 2 and Chapter 1 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "3. The events of September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In the evening of 11 September 1998 the police visited the house of the head of the local chapter of Ilinden in Blagoevgrad and warned him that if he tried to organise the event planned for 12 September 1998 he would be criminally prosecuted.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "3. The events of September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 12 September 1998 members and followers of Ilinden tried to approach the memorial of Gotze Delchev in Blagoevgrad, but the police blocked their way.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "3. The events of September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 12 September 1998 the police informed members and followers of Ilinden that the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office had banned the event and read them the decree, but refused to give them a copy.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "3. The events of September 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 7 April 1999 Ilinden notified the mayor of Sandanski that it planned a commemoration at Rozhen monastery on 25 April 1999.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "4. The events of April 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 9 April 1999 the mayor of Sandanski informed Ilinden that it would receive a reply after presenting a document establishing that it was a registered organisation.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "4. The events of April 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The applicants submitted that on 16 April 1999 Ilinden lodged an application for judicial review with the Sandanski District Court, but that the court did not reply.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "4. The events of April 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On an unspecified later date several members of Ilinden were warned by the police not to organise a meeting on 25 April 1999.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "4. The events of April 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 25 April 1999 members and followers of Ilinden tried to approach the Rozhen monastery by cars.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "4. The events of April 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 25 April 1999 the police, who had dispatched patrols at all roads leading to the Rozhen monastery, blocked the way of members and followers of Ilinden and turned them back.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "4. The events of April 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 25 April 1999 some drivers travelling to the Rozhen monastery were fined, allegedly for driving vehicles in a state of disrepair.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "4. The events of April 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 25 April 1999, on the way back from the Rozhen monastery, members of the Sandanski chapter of Ilinden tried to lay flowers at the bust of Yane Sandanski, but the police seized the flowers and allegedly arrested one person.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "4. The events of April 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 27 April 1999 Ilinden notified the mayor of Blagoevgrad that it planned to lay wreaths at the memorial of Gotze Delchev on 4 May 1999.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "5. The events of the end of April and May 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 29 April 1999 the mayor of Blagoevgrad invited Ilinden to present a document establishing that it was a registered organisation.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "5. The events of the end of April and May 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 29 April 1999 the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office issued a decree under Article 185 § 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, ordering the police to take measures to prevent Ilinden from holding a meeting.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "5. The events of the end of April and May 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office decree of 29 April 1999 reasoned that the holding of a meeting by Ilinden would constitute offences under Article 174a and Chapter 1 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "5. The events of the end of April and May 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 3 May 1999 a member of Ilinden lodged an application for judicial review with the Blagoevgrad District Court.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "5. The events of the end of April and May 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "By an order of 4 May 1999 the Blagoevgrad District Court refused to examine the application for judicial review, as it was unclear who was the organiser of the planned event.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "5. The events of the end of April and May 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "In its order of 4 May 1999 the Blagoevgrad District Court stated that it was competent to deal with applications against orders banning meetings and that no such order had been issued.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "5. The events of the end of April and May 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 4 May 1999 members and followers of Ilinden who tried to approach the memorial of Gotze Delchev in Blagoevgrad were stopped by the police, who informed them that the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office had issued a decree prohibiting the event.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "5. The events of the end of April and May 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 4 May 1999 the police read out the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office decree prohibiting the event to members and followers of Ilinden, but refused to give them a copy.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "5. The events of the end of April and May 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "On 25 May 1999 Ilinden complained to the Sofia Military Prosecutor's Office about the coercive actions of the police and the authorities in connection with the events of 4 May 1999.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "5. The events of the end of April and May 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On 25 May 1999 the Sofia Military Prosecutor's Office refused to open criminal proceedings in response to Ilinden's complaint, reasoning that since Ilinden had not been registered, the ban of its meeting had been lawful and that the police had acted in pursuance of their duty to preserve public order.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "5. The events of the end of April and May 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 12 July 1999 Ilinden notified the mayor of Petrich that it planned to hold a meeting at Samuilova krepost on 1 August 1999.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "6. The events of July and August 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On 20 July 1999 the mayor of Petrich replied that he could not allow the holding of a meeting at Samuilova krepost on 1 August 1999, as another meeting had been planned for the same date and place by another organisation.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "6. The events of July and August 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "On 21 July 1999 Ilinden lodged an application for judicial review with the Petrich District Court, stating that it was prepared to move its meeting to another hour of the day or to hold it on some of the hills adjacent to Samuilova krepost, so as to avoid interfering with the other meeting.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "6. The events of July and August 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "In a judgment of 26 July 1999 the Petrich District Court dismissed Ilinden's application for judicial review.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "6. The events of July and August 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "In its judgment of 26 July 1999 the Petrich District Court held that Ilinden was non-existent as it was not registered.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "6. The events of July and August 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "In its judgment of 26 July 1999 the Petrich District Court held that as a result of Ilinden's lack of registration, it could not be considered as the organiser of, and be responsible for order during the meeting, as required by sections 9 and 10 of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "6. The events of July and August 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "In its judgment of 26 July 1999 the Petrich District Court held that the lack of clarity as to the organisers of the event endangered public order.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "6. The events of July and August 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "In its judgment of 26 July 1999 the Petrich District Court held that another meeting had been scheduled for the same date and place as Ilinden's planned meeting.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "6. The events of July and August 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "On 27 July 1999 the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office issued a decree under Article 185 § 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, ordering the police to take measures to prevent Ilinden from holding a meeting.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "6. The events of July and August 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office decree of 27 July 1999 considered that the holding of a meeting by Ilinden would constitute offences under Article 174a and Chapter 1 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "6. The events of July and August 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "It appears that no meeting was held on 1 August 1999 at Samuilova krepost by any other organisation.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "6. The events of July and August 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "On 1 August 1999 members and followers of Ilinden tried to approach Samuilova krepost by cars, but were stopped by police stationed at the roads leading to the site.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "6. The events of July and August 1999"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "On 11 April 2000 Ilinden notified the mayor of Sandanski that it intended to organise a commemorative meeting on 22 April 2000 at Rozhen monastery.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "7. The events of April 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 18 April 2000 the mayor of Sandanski made an order prohibiting the meeting planned for 22 April 2000 at Rozhen monastery, apparently on the ground it would endanger public order.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "7. The events of April 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Ilinden did not seek judicial review of the mayor of Sandanski's order of 18 April 2000 prohibiting the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "7. The events of April 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 22 April 2000 members and followers of Ilinden tried to approach the Rozhen monastery by cars and were stopped at police checkpoints, where some of the drivers were fined, allegedly for traffic violations.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "7. The events of April 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On 22 April 2000 the police seized material intended for the decoration of a stage which members of Ilinden planned to set up at the Rozhen monastery site.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "7. The events of April 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "On 22 April 2000 a vehicle transporting musicians and their instruments to the Rozhen monastery was not allowed to continue by the police.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "7. The events of April 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "On 22 April 2000 the cars of members and followers of Ilinden were stopped again at a second police post near the Rozhen monastery and some written materials were impounded.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "7. The events of April 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "On 22 April 2000 some members and followers of Ilinden were allowed to approach the Rozhen monastery site, which was heavily guarded by police.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "7. The events of April 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The applicants alleged that on 22 April 2000 a plain-clothes police officer was filming the participants at the Rozhen monastery despite their objections.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "7. The events of April 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "On 22 April 2000 members and followers of Ilinden who reached the Rozhen monastery site laid flowers and made a short speech, apparently denouncing the 'assimilation policy' led by the Bulgarian Government, after which they left the site.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "7. The events of April 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "On 10 July 2000 Ilinden notified the mayor of Petrich of its intention to hold a commemorative meeting on 30 July 2000 at Samuilova krepost.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "8. The events of July 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "By a letter of 18 July 2000 the mayor of Petrich replied that he could not allow the event planned for 30 July 2000 at Samuilova krepost, as another association had already applied for authorisation to organise a meeting on the same date.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "8. The events of July 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Ilinden lodged an application for judicial review with the Petrich District Court, arguing that the Samuilova krepost site was large enough for two events to take place simultaneously.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "8. The events of July 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "In a judgment of 24 July 2000 the Petrich District Court dismissed Ilinden's application for judicial review.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "8. The events of July 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "In its judgment of 24 July 2000 the Petrich District Court found that Ilinden had not been registered and apparently had links with a political party, UMO Ilinden – PIRIN, which had been declared unconstitutional by the Bulgarian Constitutional Court on 29 February 2000 for acting against the territorial integrity of the country (see The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden – PIRIN and Others v. Bulgaria, no. 59489/00, §§ 21-27, 20 October 2005).", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "8. The events of July 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "In its judgment of 24 July 2000 the Petrich District Court found that the holding of a meeting by Ilinden could therefore pose a threat to the territorial integrity of Bulgaria.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "8. The events of July 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "In its judgment of 24 July 2000 the Petrich District Court found that another, duly registered, association intended to organise a meeting on the same date as Ilinden's planned meeting, and that the parallel holding of two events could endanger public order.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "8. The events of July 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "On 30 July 2000 certain members and followers of Ilinden were able to hold a meeting at Samuilova krepost, and it appears that the police did not interfere.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "8. The events of July 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "On 1 September 2000 Ilinden informed the mayor of Blagoevgrad that it wanted to hold a commemoration at the memorial of Gotze Delchev on 12 September 2000.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "9. The events of September 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The mayor of Blagoevgrad did not reply to Ilinden's notification of 1 September 2000.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "9. The events of September 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "Ilinden lodged an application for judicial review with the Blagoevgrad District Court regarding the planned commemoration of 12 September 2000, but did not get an answer.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "9. The events of September 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "On 8 September 2000 the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office issued a decree under Article 185 § 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, ordering the police to take measures to prevent Ilinden from holding a meeting.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "9. The events of September 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office decree of 8 September 2000 reasoned that the holding of a meeting by Ilinden would constitute an offence under Chapter 1 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "9. The events of September 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "On 12 September 2000 members and followers of Ilinden tried to approach the memorial of Gotze Delchev in Blagoevgrad, but were stopped by the police.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "9. The events of September 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "On 12 September 2000 a police officer read out the decree prohibiting the commemoration to members and followers of Ilinden, but refused to furnish a copy of it.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "9. The events of September 2000"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "On 4 April 2001 Ilinden notified the mayor of Sandanski that it would organise a meeting on 22 April 2001 at Rozhen monastery.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "10. The events of April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The mayor of Sandanski did not reply to Ilinden's notification of 4 April 2001.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "10. The events of April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "On 22 April 2001 members and followers of Ilinden assembled at the Rozhen monastery site.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "10. The events of April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "On 22 April 2001 approximately fifty police officers were present at the Rozhen monastery site during the Ilinden meeting.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "10. The events of April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The applicants averred that on 22 April 2001 two members of Ilinden tried to place a wreath covered with a band with an inscription on the grave of Yane Sandanski, and that four policemen moved towards them and ordered that the band be removed.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "10. The events of April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "The applicants averred that on 22 April 2001, when the persons carrying the wreath refused to remove the band, the police seized the wreath and arrested one of them, taking him to a nearby village, releasing him and warning him not to try to return to the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "10. The events of April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The applicants alleged that on 22 April 2001 a poster brought by members of Ilinden to the Rozhen monastery was taken away by a plainclothes police officer.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "10. The events of April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The applicants alleged that on 22 April 2001 the police prevented the placing on the podium of loudspeakers that members of Ilinden had brought to the Rozhen monastery.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "10. The events of April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The applicants alleged that on 22 April 2001 local catering companies were prohibited by the municipal authorities from sending staff and facilities to the Rozhen monastery site during the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "10. The events of April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The Government submitted that during the meeting of 22 April 2001 at Rozhen monastery a member of Ilinden stated that 'there have been and will be Macedonians. Death to the enemies! Not a single Bulgarian will remain living...'.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "10. The events of April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "According to the Government, on 22 April 2001 at Rozhen monastery one person who was drunk was taken out of the area where the meeting was taking place.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "10. The events of April 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "On 27 April 2001 Ilinden notified the mayor of Blagoevgrad that it intended to lay flowers at the memorial of Gotze Delchev on 4 May 2001.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "11. The events of the end of April and May 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The mayor of Blagoevgrad did not reply to Ilinden's notification of 27 April 2001.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "11. The events of the end of April and May 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "On 4 May 2001 a group of members and followers of Ilinden attempted to approach the memorial of Gotze Delchev in Blagoevgrad to lay a wreath covered with a band with an inscription.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "11. The events of the end of April and May 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The applicants alleged that on 4 May 2001 the police intervened and ordered members and followers of Ilinden to remove the band with the inscription from the wreath, citing a decree made by the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "11. The events of the end of April and May 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "On 4 May 2001 members and followers of Ilinden apparently refused to remove the band with the inscription, and several plainclothes police officers diverted them from the memorial of Gotze Delchev.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "11. The events of the end of April and May 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "On 4 May 2001 the members and followers of Ilinden headed for a nearby church, followed by the police who were allegedly shouting insulting words at them.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "11. The events of the end of April and May 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The applicants averred that on 4 May 2001 two police officers seized a camera held by one of the members of Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "11. The events of the end of April and May 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "On 4 May 2001 members and followers of Ilinden laid the wreath at a grave in the churchyard of a nearby church, and later in the day three unknown persons took it away.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "11. The events of the end of April and May 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "According to the Government, on 4 May 2001 the police had to disrupt the ceremony and direct the members and followers of Ilinden to the nearby church because other persons who were standing nearby became agitated upon the arrival of news that members of UMO Ilinden – PIRIN had tried to assault the Bulgarian ambassador in Skopje.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "11. The events of the end of April and May 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "On 12 July 2001 Ilinden notified the mayor of Petrich of its intention to hold a meeting on 29 July 2001 at Samuilova krepost.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "12. The events of July 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "By a letter of 20 July 2001, which was allegedly delivered at the home of a member of Ilinden on 28 July 2001 – a Saturday – the mayor of Petrich prohibited the meeting planned for 29 July 2001 because another meeting had been planned for the same date by a municipal child centre.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "12. The events of July 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "On 25 July 2001 the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office issued a decree under Article 185 § 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, ordering the police to take measures to prevent Ilinden from holding a meeting.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "12. The events of July 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office decree of 25 July 2001 reasoned that the holding of a meeting by Ilinden would constitute offences under Article 174a and Chapter 1 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "12. The events of July 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "On 29 July 2001 a group of approximately two hundred and fifty people tried to approach Samuilova krepost by buses and cars, but were turned back by the police two kilometres before the site.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "12. The events of July 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The applicants allege that on 29 July 2001 the police told members and followers of Ilinden that military exercises were to take place and that they could not continue to Samuilova krepost.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "12. The events of July 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "According to the Government, on 29 July 2001 members and followers of Ilinden were informed of the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office decree prohibiting the event at Samuilova krepost.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "12. The events of July 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "On 29 July 2001, after being stopped from reaching Samuilova krepost, the members and followers of Ilinden decided to lay flowers at the memorial of a poet in Petrich, but several dozen police officers blocked their way.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "12. The events of July 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "On 29 July 2001 the second applicant, Mr Ivanov, and another person were apparently arrested and kept several hours in custody in connection with the events in Petrich.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "12. The events of July 2001"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "On 23 August 2002 Ilinden notified the mayor of Blagoevgrad that it wanted to hold a commemoration at the memorial of Gotze Delchev in the centre of Blagoevgrad on 12 September 2002.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The mayor of Blagoevgrad did not reply to Ilinden's notification of 23 August 2002.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "At approximately 3.30 p.m. on 12 September 2002 members and followers of Ilinden, who had gathered at a meeting point situated at a little less than a kilometre from the memorial of Gotze Delchev in Blagoevgrad, started marching toward it.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "On 12 September 2002 the memorial of Gotze Delchev in Blagoevgrad was surrounded by a group of about twenty persons who were shouting insults, preventing members and followers of Ilinden from initially approaching it.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "On 12 September 2002 several persons from the hostile group attacked individual members and followers of Ilinden, broke the flagstaff one of them was carrying, tried to take another flag, tore a poster and took the ribbon from a wreath carried by one of the members of Ilinden.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "On 12 September 2002 a member of Ilinden was filming with a camera when one person from the hostile group attacked him from behind and tore the electrical cables of the camera.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "On 12 September 2002 the police were present at the memorial of Gotze Delchev in Blagoevgrad and had formed a cordon between the members and followers of Ilinden and the hostile group, but apparently failed to prevent the above incidents.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "On 12 September 2002 the police secured members and followers of Ilinden access to the memorial of Gotze Delchev in Blagoevgrad, where they laid a wreath.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "On 12 September 2002 the president of Ilinden tried to make a short speech at the memorial of Gotze Delchev in Blagoevgrad, which was constantly interrupted by the shouting of the hostile group.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "On 12 September 2002 the members and followers of Ilinden retreated from the memorial of Gotze Delchev in Blagoevgrad under police escort.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "On 23 September 2002 Ilinden complained to the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office about the actions of the hostile group during the events of 12 September 2002.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office ordered a preliminary verification in response to Ilinden's complaint of 23 September 2002, but apparently nothing ensued.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "On 15 October 2002 Ilinden complained to the Sofia Military Prosecutor's Office about the inactivity of the police officers present during the 12 September 2002 meeting and about their failure to secure the peaceful holding of the event.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The Sofia Military Prosecutor's Office carried out a preliminary verification in response to Ilinden's complaint of 15 October 2002 and on 10 December 2002 refused to open criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "On appeal by Ilinden, the Sofia Military Prosecutor's Office decree of 10 December 2002 refusing to open criminal proceedings was upheld by the Sofia Military Appellate Prosecutor's Office on 20 February 2003.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "Ilinden further appealed to the Chief Prosecutor's Office, which upheld the refusal to open criminal proceedings in a decree of 6 October 2003, reasoning that Ilinden's allegations were not supported by the facts established during the preliminary verification.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "The Chief Prosecutor's Office decree of 6 October 2003 stated that the police had strictly complied with the relevant legal provisions, that although certain members of Ilinden had acted provocatively, the officers had showed restraint and had performed their duties.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "13. The events of August and September 2002"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "On an unspecified date in July 2003 Ilinden notified the mayor of Petrich that it planned to hold a meeting at Samuilova krepost on 2 August 2003, to commemorate the one-hundred anniversary of the Ilinden uprising.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "14. The events of August 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "The mayor of Petrich apparently assented to Ilinden's planned meeting at Samuilova krepost on 2 August 2003.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "14. The events of August 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "On 2 August 2003 members and followers of Ilinden gathered at Samuilova krepost for a four-hour programme.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "14. The events of August 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "During the entire event at Samuilova krepost on 2 August 2003 a plainclothes police officer was filming.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "14. The events of August 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "On 2 August 2003 when the chairperson of Ilinden tried to remove the camera of the plainclothes police officer at Samuilova krepost, there ensued a scuffle and the police attempted to arrest him.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "14. The events of August 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "On 28 August 2003 Ilinden notified the mayor of Blagoevgrad that on 12 September 2003 it intended to organise a commemoration at the memorial of Gotze Delchev in Blagoevgrad.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "In its notification of 28 August 2003 Ilinden stated that the purpose of the event was to honour the memory of the 'victims of the genocide ... inflicted by the Bulgarian Government on the Macedonian nation'.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "In a letter of 1 September 2003, which was posted on 5 September and arrived on 9 September, the mayor of Blagoevgrad informed Ilinden that in principle every citizen of Bulgaria had the right to commemorate national heroes such as Gotze Delchev.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "In the letter of 1 September 2003 the mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that the remarks contained in Ilinden's notification were unconstitutional and provocative, and were indicative of actions which would infringe the rights of others and would lead to conflicts, as had already happened in the past.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "In the letter of 1 September 2003 the mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that in order to organise events, Ilinden had to be registered.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "In the letter of 1 September 2003 the mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that there was no need for the planned event to take place in front of the memorial of Gotze Delchev and that its timing was inopportune because another event had been planned for the same time and date.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "In the letter of 1 September 2003 the mayor of Blagoevgrad stated that if Ilinden chose another place for holding its commemoration, he would reconsider the matter.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "On 10 September 2003 Ilinden objected to the mayor of Blagoevgrad's decision, stating that it was willing to shift the time of its commemoration to one hour later, but that the place was closely bound to a specific occasion and could not be changed.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "On 10 September 2003 Ilinden filed an application for judicial review with the Blagoevgrad District Court regarding the planned commemoration of 12 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "On 11 September 2003 the police summoned two members of Ilinden and cautioned them in writing to refrain from organising the event planned for 12 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "On 12 September 2003 the mayor of Blagoevgrad informed Ilinden that he prohibited the planned event, because it would create conditions for the disruption of the public order and would endanger the rights of others.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "On 12 September 2003 members and followers of Ilinden gathered in the centre of Blagoevgrad with a view to marching to the memorial of Gotze Delchev.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "On 12 September 2003 approximately fifty police officers were present in the centre of Blagoevgrad where members and followers of Ilinden had gathered.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "On 12 September 2003 several police officers approached the members and followers of Ilinden in the centre of Blagoevgrad and read out a decree of the Blagoevgrad Regional Prosecutor's Office prohibiting the commemoration.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "In a decision of 16 September 2003 the Blagoevgrad District Court declared Ilinden's application for judicial review inadmissible.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court found that Ilinden's application for judicial review had been filed with the court on 10 September 2003 and had been brought to the attention of a judge-rapporteur at 4.37 p.m. on 11 September 2003.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court noted that by section 12(6) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990, the time-limit for ruling on the application was five days.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "The Blagoevgrad District Court held in its decision of 16 September 2003 that as of that date the issue whether to allow the event planned for 12 September 2003 had become moot and there was no need for the court to rule on it.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Prohibitions against the holding of meetings during the period 1998-2003", "15. The events of the end of August and September 2003"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "Article 43 § 1 of the Bulgarian Constitution of 1991 provides that everyone shall have the right to peaceful and unarmed assembly at meetings and marches.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "Article 43 § 2 of the Bulgarian Constitution of 1991 provides that the procedure for organising and holding meetings and marches shall be provided for by act of Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "Article 43 § 3 of the Bulgarian Constitution of 1991 provides that permission shall not be required for meetings to be held indoors.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "Article 44 § 2 of the Bulgarian Constitution of 1991 prohibits organisations whose activities are directed against the sovereignty or the territorial integrity of the country or against the unity of the nation, or aim at stirring racial, national, ethnic or religious hatred, or at violating the rights and freedoms of others, as well as organisations creating secret or paramilitary structures, or which seek to achieve their aims through violence.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "The legal requirements for the organisation of meetings in Bulgaria are laid down in the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "Section 2 of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that meetings, rallies and marches may be organised by individuals, associations, political or other civic organisations.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "Section 6(2) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that every organiser of or participant in a march or a meeting shall be responsible for damage caused through his or her fault during the event.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "Section 8(1) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that where a meeting or rally is to be held outdoors, the organisers shall notify the respective People's Council or mayor's office in writing at least forty-eight hours before its beginning and shall indicate the name of the organiser, the aim of the meeting or rally, and its venue and time.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "Section 9(1) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that the organisers of the meeting shall take the measures necessary to ensure order during the event.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "Section 10(1) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that the meeting shall be presided over by a president.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "Section 10(2) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that the participants shall abide by the instructions of the president concerning the preservation of public order.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "Section 12(1) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that where the time or venue of the meeting or rally or the itinerary of the march would create a situation endangering public order or traffic safety, the President of the Executive Committee of the People's Council, or the mayor, respectively, shall propose their modification.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "Section 12(2) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that the President of the Executive Committee of the People's Council or the mayor shall be competent to prohibit the holding of a meeting, rally or march where reliable information exists that it aims at the violent overturning of constitutional public order or is directed against the territorial integrity of the country, would endanger public order in the local community, or would breach the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "Section 12(3) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that the prohibition shall be imposed by a written reasoned act not later than twenty-four hours after the notification.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F205", "text": "Section 12(4) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that the organiser of the meeting, rally or march may appeal to the Executive Committee of the People's Council against the prohibition, and the Executive Committee shall decide within twenty-four hours.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F206", "text": "Section 12(5) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that where the Executive Committee of the People's Council has not decided within the applicable time-limit, the march, rally or meeting may proceed.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F207", "text": "Section 12(6) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990 provides that if the appeal is dismissed, the dispute shall be referred to the respective district court which shall decide within five days, and that court's decision shall be final.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F208", "text": "The Meetings and Marches Act was enacted in 1990, when the Constitution of 1971 was still in force.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F209", "text": "Under the Constitution of 1971 the executive local state organs were the Executive Committees of the district People's Councils.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F210", "text": "Under the Constitution of 1971 the mayors, referred to in some provisions of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990, were representatives of the Executive Committee acting in villages and towns which were under the jurisdiction of the respective People's Council.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F211", "text": "The Bulgarian Constitution of 1991 abolished the Executive Committees of the district People's Councils.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F212", "text": "The Bulgarian Constitution of 1991 established the post of mayor, elected by direct universal suffrage, as the organ of the executive power in the municipality (Article 139 § 1 of the Constitution of 1991).", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F213", "text": "Former Article 185 § 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, as in force at the material time and repealed in 2003, provided that the prosecutor was bound to take the necessary measures to prevent a crime for which there was reason to believe that it would be committed, including the temporary impounding of the means which could be used for committing the crime.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F214", "text": "Article 174a § 2 of the Bulgarian Criminal Code makes it an offence for the organiser of a public meeting to, inter alia, hold a prohibited meeting in violation of section 12(3) of the Meetings and Marches Act of 1990.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F215", "text": "Chapter 1 of the special part of the Bulgarian Criminal Code regulates offences against the Republic, including attempted coup d'état, terrorist offences, mutiny, espionage, sabotage, advocating a fascist or other antidemocratic ideology, and similar offences.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["national_security", "public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F008", "F009", "F026", "F048", "F064", "F070", "F096", "F100", "F106", "F114", "F124", "F135", "F146", "F153", "F170"], "interference": ["F027", "F048", "F064", "F071", "F081", "F096", "F098", "F100", "F101", "F103", "F108", "F110", "F114", "F118", "F120", "F135", "F136", "F137", "F138", "F143", "F144", "F146", "F153", "F154", "F155", "F156", "F157", "F158", "F159", "F160", "F169", "F170", "F183", "F186"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F021", "F042", "F043", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F059", "F067", "F075", "F076", "F086", "F089", "F090", "F091", "F092", "F093", "F098", "F108", "F111", "F112", "F113", "F118", "F119", "F143", "F144", "F183", "F195", "F202", "F203", "F213"], "legitimate_aim": ["F023", "F044", "F046", "F047", "F061", "F062", "F077", "F094", "F112", "F119", "F145", "F183"], "necessity": ["F008", "F009", "F021", "F023", "F027", "F044", "F045", "F046", "F047", "F048", "F059", "F061", "F062", "F064", "F071", "F076", "F077", "F081", "F086", "F093", "F094", "F096", "F098", "F100", "F108", "F112", "F118", "F119", "F120", "F143", "F144", "F145", "F146", "F173", "F174", "F175", "F176", "F177", "F178", "F179", "F183", "F186"], "positive_obligation": ["F154", "F155", "F156", "F157", "F158", "F159", "F160", "F162", "F164", "F165", "F166", "F167"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F008", "F009", "F026", "F106", "F124", "F153", "F170"], "interference": ["F027", "F048", "F064", "F071", "F081", "F096", "F098", "F101", "F108", "F120", "F137", "F146", "F154", "F157", "F186"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F042", "F098", "F195", "F203", "F213"], "legitimate_aim": ["F044", "F047", "F112", "F183"], "necessity": ["F009", "F021", "F045", "F059", "F076", "F093", "F118", "F143", "F183", "F186"], "positive_obligation": ["F154", "F155", "F157", "F162", "F164"]}, "list3": ["F009", "F027", "F048", "F081", "F096", "F098", "F101", "F108", "F120", "F137", "F146", "F154", "F155", "F157", "F183", "F186", "F213"]}} {"case_name": "case_629", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1979.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr D.A. Karsai, a lawyer practising in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr Z. Tallódi, of the Ministry of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 11 March 2013, Parliament adopted the Fourth Amendment to the Basic Law of Hungary.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Fourth Amendment to the Basic Law pertains to numerous, often controversial, issues of fundamental rights.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Under Hungarian law, the President of Hungary had five days to assent to the Fourth Amendment to the Basic Law.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant and other individuals intended to hold a demonstration in front of the President of Hungary's residence.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The purpose of the intended demonstration was to call on the President of Hungary not to assent to the Fourth Amendment to the Basic Law but to refer it to the Constitutional Court.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant informed the Budapest Police Department of his intention to hold a demonstration, in the form of a notification, on 11 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On the evening of 11 March 2013, the Budapest Police Department dismissed the applicant's notification without examining it on the merits.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Budapest Police Department pointed out that the Anti-Terror Centre had closed down the area in front of the President of Hungary's residence from 8 to 16 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Because the Anti-Terror Centre had closed down the area in front of the President of Hungary's residence from 8 to 16 March 2013, the Budapest Police Department stated that the area was no longer a public area available for demonstrations during that period.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 13 March 2013, the President of Hungary announced that he was to assent to the Fourth Amendment to the Basic Law.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 14 March 2013, the applicant challenged the Budapest Police Department's decision in court.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 18 March 2013, the Budapest Administrative and Labour Court quashed the Budapest Police Department's decision dismissing the applicant's notification.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court held that the Budapest Police Department had failed to provide in its decision the precise reasons why the Anti-Terror Centre had closed down the area in question.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court held that the Budapest Police Department had erroneously characterised the applicant's intended demonstration as one outside the scope of the law on peaceful demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The applicant submitted that he had subsequently filed an official liability action against the Budapest Police Department.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Government submitted that on 8 April 2013 the applicant had brought a claim for damages against the Budapest Police Department.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Government submitted that the applicant's claim for damages against the Budapest Police Department had subsequently been dismissed on 14 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F009", "F010", "F011", "F012"], "interference": ["F008", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F017", "F020", "F021", "F022"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F013", "F014", "F017", "F018", "F019"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F009", "F010", "F011"], "interference": ["F008", "F012", "F013", "F017", "F022"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F013", "F014", "F017", "F018"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F008", "F013", "F017", "F018", "F022"]}} {"case_name": "case_631", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1944.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Rivne.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "In 1980 the applicant began working as a boiler engine operator at Rivneteplokomunenergo.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Rivneteplokomunenergo was a municipal enterprise responsible for maintaining central heating in Rivne.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "In December 1998 a number of employees of Rivneteplokomunenergo, including the applicant, were transferred to Komunenergiya.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "Komunenergiya was a new municipal heating provider founded by the Rivne Town Administration.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Subsequently after December 1998, Rivneteplokomunenergo ceased its activities.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "Rivneteplokomunenergo was declared bankrupt.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Rivneteplokomunenergo was liquidated.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Before March 1999 the applicant's work performance was generally positive.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 12 February 1999 the applicant successfully passed tests on work safety when operating boilers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "According to the applicant, she and many of her colleagues had not received the salary due to them for the period of August–December 1998 during which they had worked at Rivneteplokomunenergo.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "In February 1999 a number of Komunenergiya employees met to discuss possible solutions to the problem of unpaid salary for the period August–December 1998.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The Komunenergiya employees who met in February 1999 agreed to form a trade union at Komunenergiya.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Komunenergiya employees who met in February 1999 agreed to organise a picket.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Subsequently, the applicant discontinued her membership of a trade union which had existed at Komunenergiya since 1998.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The applicant informed the management of Komunenergiya that a new trade union had been established by thirty-four employees of Komunenergiya.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the Government, the employees of Komunenergiya did not form a new trade union.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 22 February 1999 the applicant and two other persons, allegedly acting on behalf of the Komunenergiya staff, gave a written notice to the Mayor of Rivne.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The written notice of 22 February 1999 to the Mayor of Rivne stated that employees of Komunenergiya would picket the management of Komunenergiya at 7.30 a.m. on 3 March 1999.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The written notice of 22 February 1999 to the Mayor of Rivne stated that the reason for the picket was non-payment of salary from August 1998 to February 1999.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On an unspecified date the Rivne Town Administration included the information about the planned picket on 3 March 1999 in its register.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 27 February 1999 an inspection party comprising several colleagues of the applicant, including her direct supervisor and the deputy director of Komunenergiya, visited various boiler rooms, one of which the applicant worked in, in order to check compliance with safety instructions.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "In relation to the applicant's boiler room, the inspectors on 27 February 1999 noted that certain pieces of the boiler equipment were broken or otherwise not functioning.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "In relation to the applicant's boiler room, the inspectors on 27 February 1999 noted that the malfunctioning of boiler equipment had not been recorded in a special log kept by boiler operators.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "In relation to the applicant's boiler room, the inspectors on 27 February 1999 noted that certain parts of boiler equipment were not in place.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "In relation to the applicant's boiler room, the inspectors on 27 February 1999 noted that there were unauthorised objects on the boiler and in the room.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The inspectors on 27 February 1999 concluded that the applicant did not comply with the relevant safety instructions.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 2 March 1999 the management of Komunenergiya issued a reprimand to the applicant on the grounds of the safety-related findings of the 27 February 1999 inspection.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 3 March 1999 the applicant and some seventy other persons took part in a picket in front of Komunenergiya's main office.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "At the picket on 3 March 1999, participants expressed concerns that the management of Komunenergiya did not ensure timely payment of salaries.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "At the picket on 3 March 1999, participants expressed concerns that the director of Komunenergiya had misappropriated company funds.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On 3 March 1999 the applicant was required to be at work at 8 a.m. but came to work at 10 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The applicant's direct supervisor drew up a report concerning the applicant's two-hour absence from work on 3 March 1999.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The report drawn up by the applicant's direct supervisor noted that because of the applicant's two-hour absence on 3 March 1999, the applicant's colleague had had to work for two more hours after the latter's night shift.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 9 March 1999 Komunenergiya lodged a claim against the applicant and K. with the Rivne Court, asking the court to rule that the picket on 3 March 1999, which Komunenergiya termed a strike, had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Komunenergiya submitted to the Rivne Court that the strike on 3 March 1999 had lasted for three hours.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Komunenergiya submitted to the Rivne Court that about seventy persons had taken part in the strike on 3 March 1999.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Komunenergiya submitted to the Rivne Court that only three persons, including the applicant, had informed it of their participation in the strike by way of a written notice dated 22 February 1999.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "Komunenergiya alleged to the Rivne Court that the persons taking part in the strike on 3 March 1999 had not been authorised to represent the interests of staff.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "Komunenergiya alleged to the Rivne Court that the demands of the strikers on 3 March 1999 had not been approved by the staff or provided to the management in advance.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "A copy of the written notice of 22 February 1999 was joined to Komunenergiya's claim lodged with the Rivne Court on 9 March 1999.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The parties did not provide information concerning the outcome of Komunenergiya's claim lodged with the Rivne Court on 9 March 1999.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On 10 March 1999 the applicant was dismissed from work for systematic breach of her duties of employment pursuant to Article 40 § 3 of the Labour Code of 1971.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "On 29 March 1999 the applicant instituted proceedings in the Rivne Court seeking reinstatement in her position at Komunenergiya.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 29 March 1999 the applicant instituted proceedings in the Rivne Court seeking recovery of salary arrears.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant argued in the Rivne Court proceedings that her dismissal had been unlawful and unfounded.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant argued in the Rivne Court proceedings that the real reason for her dismissal had been the labour dispute between Komunenergiya's management and staff concerning non-payment of salary arrears.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In the course of the court hearings, the applicant stated that she had not been responsible for the safety-related issues discovered at her workplace on 27 February 1999.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In the course of the court hearings, the applicant stated that she had been absent from work on 3 March 1999 because she had participated in the picket, of which the local authorities had been duly informed.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "In the course of the court hearings, the applicant stated that prior to the picket on 3 March 1999 she had arranged with her colleague O. that he would replace her on that day.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The applicant acknowledged in the court hearings that she had not informed her direct supervisor of her absence on 3 March 1999 in advance.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The representatives of Komunenergiya denied in the court hearings that there had been a dispute between the applicant and Komunenergiya's management.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The representatives of Komunenergiya reiterated in the court hearings that the applicant had been dismissed for systematic breach of her duties of employment, in particular because of her failure to ensure safe working conditions in the boiler room on 27 February 1999.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The representatives of Komunenergiya reiterated in the court hearings that the applicant had been dismissed for systematic breach of her duties of employment, in particular because of her unauthorised absence from work on 3 March 1999.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 21 June 2000 the Rivne Court rejected the applicant's claim, finding that she had committed serious violations of work regulations during the short period of time she had worked at Komunenergiya.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In its judgment of 21 June 2000, the Rivne Court noted that, according to statements of the applicant's colleagues obtained during the court hearings and documents submitted by Komunenergiya, the applicant had been responsible for the safety-related issues discovered on 27 February 1999.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "In its judgment of 21 June 2000, the Rivne Court noted that the applicant had been absent from work for two hours on 3 March 1999 without informing management and her direct supervisor in advance.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "In its judgment of 21 June 2000, the Rivne Court concluded that the applicant had been lawfully dismissed pursuant to Article 40 § 3 of the Labour Code of 1971.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "In its judgment of 21 June 2000, the Rivne Court held that the applicant's submissions concerning a labour dispute between the management and staff were unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "In its judgment of 21 June 2000, the Rivne Court held that Komunenergiya was not responsible for the non-payment of salary arrears due to the applicant for the period before she left Rivneteplokomunenergo in December 1998.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The applicant appealed against the judgment of the Rivne Court of 21 June 2000 and contested its findings of fact.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In her appeal, the applicant stated that the management had been informed in advance of her participation in the picket on 3 March 1999, as on 22 February 1999 she had submitted a written notice to the local authorities.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 11 September 2000 the Rivne Regional Court quashed the judgment of the Rivne Court of 21 June 2000 and remitted the case for fresh consideration.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Rivne Regional Court disagreed that the applicant's case concerned systematic breaches of her employment duties.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 10 July 2001 the Rivne Court dismissed the applicant's claim on the same grounds as those given in its judgment of 21 June 2000.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "By a decision of 3 January 2002, the Rivne Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal as unsubstantiated and upheld the findings of the Rivne Court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "By a decision of 13 August 2002, the Supreme Court of Ukraine dismissed the applicant's appeal as unsubstantiated and upheld the findings of the Rivne Court.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "In its decision of 3 January 2002, the Rivne Court of Appeal noted that the applicant's allegation that she had been dismissed as a result of her participation in the picket on 3 March 1999 was unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Article 44 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that employees have the right to strike in order to protect their economic and social interests.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Article 44 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that the procedure for exercising the right to strike shall be established by law, taking into account the need to ensure national security, the protection of health, and the rights and freedoms of other persons.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Article 44 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that no one shall be forced to participate or to not participate in a strike.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Article 44 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that a strike may only be prohibited on the basis of law.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Article 40 § 3 of the Labour Code of 1971 provides that a labour contract of indefinite duration may be discontinued by an employer in cases of systematic and unjustified failure by an employee to fulfil his duties under the labour contract or staff regulations, if there were earlier disciplinary or public sanctions imposed on him.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Labour Code of 1971"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Article 151 of the Labour Code of 1971 provides that if no new disciplinary sanction is imposed on an employee within a year of the imposition of a previous disciplinary sanction, he is considered to have not been subjected to a disciplinary sanction.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Labour Code of 1971"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Section 3 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that parties to a collective labour dispute at an occupational level include employees or a trade union or another organisation authorised by employees to represent their interests, and the owner of an enterprise or the employer's representative.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Section 3 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that a body authorised by employees to represent their interests shall be the only authorised representative of employees during the time such a dispute exists.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Section 17 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 defines a strike as a temporary, collective and voluntary cessation of work by employees with the aim of resolution of a collective labour dispute.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "Section 17 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that striking shall be an extreme means of resolution of a collective labour dispute when all other possibilities of such resolution have been exhausted and the employer refuses to allow the claims of employees or of a body authorised by them, or of a trade union, or of an association of trade unions or of a body authorised by them.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "Section 18 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that pursuant to Article 44 of the Constitution of Ukraine employees have the right to strike in order to protect their economic and social interests.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Section 18 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that a strike may be commenced if conciliatory procedures have not led to the settlement of a collective labour dispute, or if the employer avoids conciliatory procedures, or does not comply with an agreement reached in the course of the resolution of a collective labour dispute.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Section 19 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that a decision to announce a strike at an enterprise shall be taken by the majority of employees at a general assembly or conference of employees, or by two-thirds of delegates to the conference, upon a request of a trade union or another association of employees authorised to represent the interests of employees, and that minutes must be drawn up reflecting such a decision.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Section 19 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that no one shall be forced to participate or to not participate in a strike.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Section 19 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that a body or person leading a strike shall inform the employer no later than seven days before the commencement of a strike, or no later than fifteen days if the decision to strike concerns a non-stop work process.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Section 19 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that the owner or his representative shall inform, as soon as possible, suppliers, consumers, transport organisations, and other interested enterprises about the employees' decision to announce a strike.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Section 19 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that a body or person leading a strike shall determine the place of the strike in agreement with the owner or his representative.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Section 19 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that if an assembly, meeting, or a picket takes place outside the enterprise, the body or person leading the strike shall inform the local authority no later than three days before it takes place.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Section 23 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that an application by the employer seeking to have a strike declared unlawful shall be considered by a court within seven days.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Section 23 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that a court's judgment declaring a strike unlawful obliges persons taking part in the strike to adopt a decision discontinuing or cancelling the announced strike, and obliges employees to return to work no later than the next day after the body or person leading the strike is served with a copy of the court's judgment.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Section 27 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that employees' participation in a strike, with the exception of strikes declared unlawful by a court, shall not be considered as a violation of work discipline and may not serve as a ground for disciplinary action.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "Section 28 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that organisation of, or participation in, a strike declared unlawful by a court shall constitute a violation of work discipline.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Section 28 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that employees shall not be remunerated for the time during which they take part in a strike.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Section 28 of the Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998 provides that the time during which an employee takes part in a strike declared unlawful by a court shall not be included in the period of his general and uninterrupted length of service.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. Resolution of Labour Disputes (Procedure) Act of 3 March 1998"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "Resolution No. 9 of the Plenary Supreme Court of Ukraine of 6 November 1992 concerning courts' practice of consideration of labour disputes provides that an employee may be dismissed pursuant to Article 40 § 3 of the Labour Code of 1971 for an offence committed at work only after disciplinary or public sanctions for unjustified breach of his duties under the labour contract or staff regulations have been imposed on him.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Resolution no. 9 of the Plenary Supreme Court of 6 November 1992 concerning courts' practice of consideration of labour disputes"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Resolution No. 9 of the Plenary Supreme Court of Ukraine of 6 November 1992 provides that in cases of dismissal under Article 40 § 3 of the Labour Code of 1971, only the disciplinary sanctions which are envisaged by law and are still in force pursuant to Article 151 of the Labour Code of 1971 shall be taken into account.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. Resolution no. 9 of the Plenary Supreme Court of 6 November 1992 concerning courts' practice of consideration of labour disputes"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": false, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F044", "F055"], "interference": ["F030", "F031", "F033", "F034", "F044", "F055"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F056", "F059", "F066", "F067", "F068", "F070", "F071", "F074", "F078", "F082", "F084", "F087", "F090"], "legitimate_aim": ["F044", "F059", "F074"], "necessity": ["F019", "F020", "F021", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F051", "F052", "F082", "F084", "F087"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F019", "F020", "F030", "F031"], "interference": ["F030", "F033", "F044", "F055"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F059", "F074", "F082", "F084", "F090"], "legitimate_aim": ["F044", "F074"], "necessity": ["F019", "F020", "F033", "F035", "F051", "F052", "F082", "F084"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F030", "F033", "F035", "F044", "F052", "F059", "F074", "F082", "F090"]}} {"case_name": "case_635", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1984.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1979.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Both applicants live in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 14 December 2012 the State Duma adopted at first reading a draft law that prohibited adoption of children of Russian nationality by US citizens.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 17 December 2012 the official daily newspaper Rossiyskaya Gazeta announced that the second reading of the draft law was scheduled for 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "According to the applicants, they read on various online social networks that many people intended to stage solo pickets (одиночные пикеты) on 19 December 2012 in front of the State Duma to express their opposition to the draft law prohibiting adoption of children of Russian nationality by US citizens.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "According to the applicants, the format of solo pickets was chosen because there was no longer time to observe the minimum statutory three-day notification period required for other types of group public events.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicants decided to hold their own solo pickets on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "At around 9 a.m. on 19 December 2012 the applicants positioned themselves, holding banners, in the vicinity of the State Duma at some distance from other protesters.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The circumstances of the applicants holding solo pickets near the State Duma are also addressed in Lashmankin and Others v. Russia, nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, §§ 206-15, 7 February 2017.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "According to the applicants, they were arrested by the police several minutes after positioning themselves near the State Duma on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "According to the applicants, they were brought to a police station after their arrest on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "At 10.30 a.m. on 19 December 2012 the police drew up a record of administrative escorting (протокол административного доставления) in respect of each applicant.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "A record of administrative arrest (протокол административного задержания) drawn up at 10.30 a.m. on 19 December 2012 stated that the applicants had arrived at the police station at 10.30 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Tsukanov, made a handwritten note on his arrest record stating that he had been actually apprehended at 9.20 a.m. on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Torchinskiy, made a handwritten note on his escorting record stating that he had been actually apprehended at 9.30 a.m. on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "At the police station both applicants were accused of organising and holding a group public event without prior notification, in breach of Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The administrative offence records indicate that the offences were committed at 10 a.m. on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Tsukanov, made a handwritten note on his administrative offence record stating that he came to the event venue at 9 a.m. and was arrested at 9.20 a.m. on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Tsukanov, was released from the police station at 1.20 p.m. on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Torchinskiy, was released from the police station at 1.10 p.m. on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 15 January 2013 the justice of the peace of the 369th Court Circuit of the Tverskoy District of Moscow found the second applicant, Mr Torchinskiy, guilty under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 369th Court Circuit of the Tverskoy District of Moscow sentenced the second applicant, Mr Torchinskiy, to a fine of 20,000 Russian roubles (about 495 euros at the time of the judgment on 15 January 2013).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The justice of the peace found it established, on the basis of administrative records and testimony of police officers, that the second applicant, Mr Torchinskiy, had taken part in a picket involving fifty people on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The justice of the peace found that the picket on 19 December 2012 was unlawful because no notification had been submitted by the organisers as required by the Public Events Act (PEA).", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The justice of the peace found that the second applicant, Mr Torchinskiy, had waved a banner during the picket on 19 December 2012, thereby attracting the attention of passers-by and journalists assembled for the occasion.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The justice of the peace found that the second applicant, Mr Torchinskiy, had not complied with the police order to stop picketing on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 6 February 2013 the justice of the peace of the 369th Court Circuit of the Tverskoy District of Moscow found the first applicant, Mr Tsukanov, guilty under Article 20.2 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The justice of the peace of the 369th Court Circuit of the Tverskoy District of Moscow sentenced the first applicant, Mr Tsukanov, to a fine of 20,000 Russian roubles (about 495 euros at the time of the judgment on 6 February 2013).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The reasoning in the judgment of 6 February 2013 concerning the first applicant, Mr Tsukanov, was identical to that in the judgment of 15 January 2013 concerning the second applicant, Mr Torchinskiy.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The justice of the peace in the judgment of 6 February 2013 also relied on police reports and testimony of a police officer who had apprehended the first applicant, Mr Tsukanov, at the venue of the public event on 19 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Both applicants appealed against their respective convictions, insisting that each of them had held a solo demonstration which did not require prior notification of the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Tsukanov, also pointed out in his appeal that he had been arrested earlier than indicated in the arrest record.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "On 13 February 2013 the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow upheld the judgment concerning the second applicant, Mr Torchinskiy.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 11 March 2013 the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow upheld the judgment concerning the first applicant, Mr Tsukanov.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The second applicant, Mr Torchinskiy, applied for review of the court decisions under Article 30.12 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 28 June 2013 the Deputy President of the Moscow City Court partly allowed the second applicant Mr Torchinskiy's complaint and changed the classification of the administrative charge against him.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 28 June 2013 the Deputy President of the Moscow City Court found the second applicant, Mr Torchinskiy, guilty of breach of the established procedure for the conduct of public events committed by a participant, an offence punishable under Article 20.2 § 5 of the Code of Administrative Offences (CAO).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 28 June 2013 the Deputy President of the Moscow City Court reduced the second applicant Mr Torchinskiy's fine to 10,000 Russian roubles (about 233 euros at the time).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "A summary of domestic law and practice concerning regulations relating to the conduct of public events, liability for breaches committed in their course, and administrative escorting and arrest can be found in Lashmankin and Others v. Russia, nos. 57818/09 and 14 others, §§ 216-312, 7 February 2017.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "A summary of domestic law and practice concerning regulations relating to the conduct of public events, liability for breaches committed in their course, and administrative escorting and arrest can also be found in Novikova and Others v. Russia, nos. 25501/07 and 4 others, §§ 47-85, 26 April 2016.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Since 6 January 2013 Moscow City Law no. 10 of 4 April 2007 provides that the distance between solo demonstrations should be no less than fifty meters.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "Moscow City Law no. 10 of 4 April 2007 (as applicable since 6 January 2013) specifies in section 2.3 that simultaneous demonstrations should be treated as solo demonstrations provided that they do not have a common goal and organisation.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F008", "F009", "F024", "F025", "F030", "F022", "F028", "F004", "F006"], "interference": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F028", "F029"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F017", "F040", "F041", "F042", "F043"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F009", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F030", "F017", "F005", "F007", "F022", "F034", "F035"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F008", "F009", "F024", "F025"], "interference": ["F011", "F013", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F028"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F017", "F042"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F005", "F007", "F009", "F025", "F030"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F005", "F007", "F009", "F025", "F022", "F028"]}} {"case_name": "case_637", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1992.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "A demonstration was planned to be held on 12 March 2011 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 7 March 2011, prior to the assembly, the organisers of the demonstration gave notice to the Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The organisers of the demonstration were members of the opposition.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) refused to authorise the demonstration at the place indicated by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Baku City Executive Authority (BCEA) proposed a different location for the demonstration on the outskirts of Baku — the grounds of a driving school situated in the 20th habitable area of the Sabail District.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The organisers decided to hold the demonstration in the centre of Baku despite the Baku City Executive Authority's refusal to authorise the originally indicated location.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstration was intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "According to the applicant, the demonstration was conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The participants of the demonstration were protesting against, inter alia, corruption.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The participants of the demonstration were demanding the resignation of the President of the State.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant attended the demonstration on 12 March 2011 in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Shortly after the demonstration had begun, the police started to disperse those who had gathered.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The applicant was arrested during the police dispersal operation.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "After his arrest, the applicant was taken to three different police stations consecutively.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "According to the applicant, he was arrested at around 2 p.m. on 12 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant's arrest and custody in the police stations were video recorded on a mobile phone by one of the protesters, Mr A.H.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On the day of the applicant's arrest, an administrative-offence report (inzibati xəta haqqında protokol) was drawn up in respect of the applicant by police officer E.G.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The administrative-offence report stated that at around 2.55 p.m. on 12 March 2011, at Fountains Square in Baku, the applicant had attempted to hold an unlawful demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The administrative-offence report stated that the applicant had disobeyed a lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant was charged with an administrative offence under Article 298 of the Code of Administrative Offences (violation of the rules on holding public assemblies).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant was charged with an administrative offence under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (failure to comply with a lawful order of a police officer).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 12 March 2011, two police officers, M.A. and H.A., prepared a report (raport) for a superior.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The report prepared by police officers M.A. and H.A. stated that at around 4 p.m. during the demonstration they had arrested ten individuals.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The report prepared by police officers M.A. and H.A. contained a list of the arrested protesters.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicant, his name — the eleventh on the list in the report prepared by police officers M.A. and H.A. — was added to the report later in different handwriting.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the official records, the administrative-offence report in the applicant's respect was prepared on the basis of the report drawn up by police officers M.A. and H.A.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with a copy of the administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the applicant, he was never served with other documents from his case file.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the applicant, he was not given access to a lawyer after his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the applicant, he was not given access to a lawyer while he was in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Administrative arrest"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "On the day of his arrest, 12 March 2011, the applicant was brought before the Sabail District Court, a first-instance court.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "A State-funded lawyer was appointed to assist the applicant before the Sabail District Court.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "None of the material submitted to the Court contains any record showing that the State-funded lawyer, Mr E.N., made any oral submissions on behalf of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "None of the material submitted to the Court contains any record showing that the State-funded lawyer, Mr E.N., made any written submissions on behalf of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "No witnesses were questioned during the court hearing before the Sabail District Court on 12 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "By a decision of 12 March 2011, the Sabail District Court convicted the applicant under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (failure to comply with a lawful order of a police officer).", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Sabail District Court sentenced the applicant to eight days' administrative detention by its decision of 12 March 2011.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On an unspecified date the applicant lodged an appeal with the Baku Court of Appeal against his arrest and conviction.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The applicant argued before the Baku Court of Appeal that his arrest and conviction were in violation of his right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicant argued before the Baku Court of Appeal that the hearing before the Sabail District Court had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The applicant argued before the Baku Court of Appeal that he had participated in the demonstration because he had had a constitutional right to do so.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The applicant argued before the Baku Court of Appeal that he had not disobeyed any order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant asked the Baku Court of Appeal to summon and examine witness Mr A.H., who, according to the applicant, had witnessed his arrest and time in custody.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The applicant asked the Baku Court of Appeal to summon and examine witness Mr A.M., who, according to the applicant, had witnessed his arrest and time in custody.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicant asked the Baku Court of Appeal to summon and examine witness Mr R.M., who, according to the applicant, had witnessed his arrest and time in custody.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicant asked the Baku Court of Appeal to examine the video recordings made by Mr A.H., which, according to the applicant, showed his arrest and custody in the police stations.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicant asked the Baku Court of Appeal to order a handwriting examination of the report prepared by police officers M.A. and H.A., in order to establish whether his name had been added to it by one of those two police officers.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The applicant alleged before the Baku Court of Appeal that his name had been added to the report prepared by police officers M.A. and H.A. as the eleventh person on the list, later and in different handwriting.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The applicant was represented before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer of his own choosing during the first set of appeal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "On 18 March 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal partially granted the applicant's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 18 March 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal remitted the case to the Sabail District Court for re-examination.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal found that the Sabail District Court had failed to examine the report prepared by police officers M.A. and H.A.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal held that the case file contained only a photocopy and not the original of the report prepared by police officers M.A. and H.A., and therefore it had not been possible to order its expert examination.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal did not address the applicant's requests to summon and examine witnesses Mr A.H., Mr A.M. and Mr R.M. on his behalf.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal did not address the applicant's request to examine the video recordings made by Mr A.H.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "1. First set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 12 April 2011 the Sabail District Court re-examined the case.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "According to the applicant, during the re-examination of the case he was not given an opportunity to appoint a lawyer of his own choosing.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "A State-funded lawyer was appointed to assist the applicant during the re-examination of the case before the Sabail District Court on 12 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The only witnesses questioned during the re-examination hearing before the Sabail District Court on 12 April 2011 were police officers M.A. and E.G.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Police officer M.A. testified at the re-examination hearing that the applicant had been detained for having participated in an unlawful assembly, making noise and disobeying the lawful orders of the police.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Police officer E.G. testified at the re-examination hearing that he had prepared the administrative-offence report in respect of the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "By a decision of 12 April 2011, the Sabail District Court convicted the applicant under Article 310.1 of the Code of Administrative Offences (failure to comply with a lawful order of a police officer).", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Sabail District Court sentenced the applicant to seven days' administrative detention by its decision of 12 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On an unspecified date the applicant appealed against the Sabail District Court's decision of 12 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The applicant argued before the Baku Court of Appeal that his arrest and conviction had been in violation of his right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The applicant argued before the Baku Court of Appeal that his arrest had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The applicant argued before the Baku Court of Appeal that the rehearing before the Sabail District Court had not been fair.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The applicant requested that witness Mr A.H. be summoned and heard before the Baku Court of Appeal during the second set of appeal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The applicant requested that witness Mr A.M. be summoned and heard before the Baku Court of Appeal during the second set of appeal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The applicant requested that witness Mr R.M. be summoned and heard before the Baku Court of Appeal during the second set of appeal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The applicant requested that witness Mr R.B. be summoned and heard before the Baku Court of Appeal during the second set of appeal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The applicant challenged the reliability of the official records related to his arrest and police custody before the Baku Court of Appeal during the second set of appeal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The applicant pointed out a discrepancy between the time of arrest indicated in the administrative-offence report (around 2.55 p.m.) and the time indicated in the report prepared by police officers M.A. and H.A. (around 4 p.m.).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The applicant repeated his allegation before the Baku Court of Appeal that his name had been added as the eleventh person on the list in the report prepared by police officers M.A. and H.A. later and in different handwriting.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The applicant asked the Baku Court of Appeal to hear at least three individuals listed along with him in the report prepared by police officers M.A. and H.A.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The applicant asked the Baku Court of Appeal to examine certain photographs made during his arrest and time in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "The applicant asked the Baku Court of Appeal to examine video recordings made during his arrest and time in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The applicant was not represented before the Baku Court of Appeal by a lawyer during the second set of appeal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "On 28 April 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal against the Sabail District Court's decision of 12 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 28 April 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the Sabail District Court's decision of 12 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal did not address the applicant's requests to summon and hear witnesses Mr A.H., Mr A.M., Mr R.M. and Mr R.B. during the second set of appeal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal did not address the applicant's request to examine photographs during the second set of appeal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal did not address the applicant's request to examine video recordings during the second set of appeal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Court proceedings against the applicant", "2. Second set of proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On 8 August 2014 Mr I. Aliyev, who represented the applicant before the Court, was arrested on charges of large-scale tax evasion, abuse of power and illegal entrepreneurship.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "On 8 August 2014 Mr I. Aliyev was detained pending trial.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The circumstances relating to Mr I. Aliyev's arrest and detention are the subject of a separate application brought by him before the Court (application no. 68762/14).", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "On 8 August 2014 the prosecuting authorities conducted a search of Mr I. Aliyev's home.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 9 August 2014 the prosecuting authorities conducted a search of Mr I. Aliyev's office.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "During the searches of Mr I. Aliyev's home and office on 8 and 9 August 2014, the domestic authorities seized a large number of documents, including all the case files relating to the pending applications before the Court which were in Mr I. Aliyev's possession as a representative.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The file relating to the present case, which included copies of all the documents and correspondence between the Court and the parties, was seized in its entirety during the searches of 8 and 9 August 2014.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "No adequate inventory of the seized files relating to the Court proceedings was made in the search and seizure records of 8 and 9 August 2014.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "On an unspecified date Mr I. Aliyev lodged a complaint with the Nasimi District Court, claiming that the search of his home and office had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Mr I. Aliyev complained to the Nasimi District Court about the seizure of the documents and files relating to the pending court proceedings before the Court and the domestic courts.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "On 12 September 2014 the Nasimi District Court dismissed Mr I. Aliyev's claim.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The Nasimi District Court held that the searches of Mr I. Aliyev's home and office had been conducted in accordance with the relevant law.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Nasimi District Court found that the documents relating to the cases pending before the Court and the domestic courts could not be returned to the applicants at that stage of the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Following an appeal by Mr I. Aliyev, on 23 September 2014 the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the Nasimi District Court's decision of 12 September 2014.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "On 25 October 2014 the investigating authorities returned a number of the case files concerning the applications lodged with the Court, including the file relating to the present case, to Mr I. Aliyev's lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The investigator's decision of 25 October 2014 specified that among the documents seized on 8 and 9 August 2014 there were files concerning applications by a number of individuals and organisations lodged with the European Court of Human Rights, which had no relation to the substance of the criminal proceedings against Mr I. Aliyev.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "The investigator's decision of 25 October 2014 specified that the files concerning applications lodged with the European Court of Human Rights were delivered to Mr I. Aliyev's lawyer, Mr Javad Javadov.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "At the material time, Article 410.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 provided that an individual who is subject to administrative-offence proceedings or a representative of a legal entity shall be given an opportunity to familiarise himself with the administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "At the material time, Article 410.4 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 provided that an individual who is subject to administrative-offence proceedings or a representative of a legal entity has the right to a copy of the administrative-offence report.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "At the material time, Article 437.2 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 provided that a copy of a decision delivered on the basis of an appeal or a protest against a decision in an administrative-offence case shall be given to the individual with respect to whom the decision was adopted within three days of its adoption.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "At the material time, Article 437.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences 2000 provided that a copy of a decision delivered on the basis of an appeal or a protest against a decision sentencing an individual to administrative detention shall be given to that individual on the day of its adoption.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "A summary of other relevant provisions concerning administrative proceedings, the relevant provisions concerning the organisation and holding of public assemblies, and the relevant extracts of international documents can be found in the judgment in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, paragraphs 27-42, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["national_security", "prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F013", "F014"], "interference": ["F014", "F015", "F020", "F021", "F023", "F027", "F038", "F039", "F064", "F065", "F075"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F023", "F027", "F038", "F064", "F075", "F107"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F004", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F013", "F014", "F038", "F064"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F013"], "interference": ["F014", "F015", "F064", "F065"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F006", "F008", "F023", "F027", "F075"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F004", "F009", "F010", "F014", "F064"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F003", "F004", "F006", "F009", "F010", "F013", "F014", "F015", "F027", "F064", "F075"]}} {"case_name": "case_638", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants listed in the appendix were all professors at Tbilisi State University at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants opposed reforms initiated by the new Tbilisi State University administration as part of the nation-wide higher education reform in 2004-2005.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants had initiated several court proceedings against Tbilisi State University regarding the higher education reforms.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants held numerous public meetings at Tbilisi State University as part of their activities opposing the reforms.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants made public statements denouncing what they called the 'destruction' of Tbilisi State University.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants wrote to various public officials denouncing what they called the 'destruction' of Tbilisi State University.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The first applicant, Mr Tuskia, was not a member of the Grand Academic Council of Tbilisi State University at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The sixth applicant, Ms Sikharulidze, was not a member of the Grand Academic Council of Tbilisi State University at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The ninth applicant, Mr D. Bakhtadze, was not a member of the Grand Academic Council of Tbilisi State University at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "All applicants except the first, sixth and ninth applicants were at the material time members of the Grand Academic Council of Tbilisi State University.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The Grand Academic Council was the highest representative body of Tbilisi State University, composed of seventy-eight members.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The Grand Academic Council operated under the Tbilisi State University charter approved by the President of Georgia on 13 July 2001.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Grand Academic Council led the protests against the changes at Tbilisi State University.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 8 June 2005 the President of Georgia issued Presidential Decree no. 473.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Presidential Decree no. 473 repealed the Tbilisi State University charter, thereby abolishing the Grand Academic Council.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "Representatives of the Grand Academic Council challenged before the Constitutional Court of Georgia the constitutionality and legality of Presidential Decree no. 473.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Representatives of the Grand Academic Council challenged before the Constitutional Court of Georgia the constitutionality and legality of several newly amended provisions of the Law on Higher Education.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 25 July 2005 the Constitutional Court of Georgia rejected the challenge to Presidential Decree no. 473 and the amended provisions of the Law on Higher Education as inadmissible.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 5 April 2006 the President of Georgia appointed Mr G.Kh. as acting Rector of Tbilisi State University.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 19 June 2006 the already-dissolved Grand Academic Council organised a meeting of Tbilisi State University staff.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 19-20 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "After the meeting of 19 June 2006, several former members of the Grand Academic Council met the acting Rector of Tbilisi State University, Mr G.Kh., to express their concerns regarding the changes at the University.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 19-20 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The meeting between former members of the Grand Academic Council and acting Rector Mr G.Kh. on 19 June 2006 ended without any results.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 19-20 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "After the meeting with Mr G.Kh. ended without results, Tbilisi State University employees — including all of the applicants — decided to stay at the University in one of the lecture halls and hold a further meeting among themselves.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 19-20 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the applicants, at around 1 a.m. on 20 June 2006 the police arrived at Tbilisi State University.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 19-20 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the applicants, the police forced everyone out of the Tbilisi State University building without giving any explanations or prior warning.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 19-20 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the applicants, despite the applicants' repeated requests, the police officers did not show them any order authorising the removal of the people gathered at Tbilisi State University.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 19-20 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 20 June 2006 the applicants, along with other employees of Tbilisi State University, gathered again in one of the lecture halls of the University.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 19-20 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "Towards the evening of 20 June 2006 the police allegedly again dispersed the applicants' meeting at Tbilisi State University.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The events of 19-20 June 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 3 July 2006, in response to a request by the fourth applicant, Mr Sanadze, the acting Rector of Tbilisi State University, Mr G.Kh., authorised a meeting of University employees in the Grand Hall of the main University building between 3.30 p.m. and 7 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "In the letter authorising the gathering on 3 July 2006, acting Rector Mr G.Kh. stressed that participants were asked to maintain order and to conclude the meeting before 7 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "At the meeting of 3 July 2006, the already-dissolved Grand Academic Council 'elected' the second applicant as the new Rector of Tbilisi State University.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "After the 'election' of the second applicant as new Rector, a group of about twenty people, including all of the applicants, headed to the office of acting Rector Mr G.Kh. to inform him of the Grand Academic Council's decision and to demand his resignation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to the applicants, they entered acting Rector Mr G.Kh.'s office on 3 July 2006 without using any force and informed him of the Grand Academic Council's decision.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the applicants, they asked Mr G.Kh. to leave his office, but he refused to do so.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "While the meeting at acting Rector Mr G.Kh.'s office continued, the police entered the Tbilisi State University grounds.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The police officers went directly to the office of acting Rector Mr G.Kh., who immediately left the room upon their arrival.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "According to the applicants, after the police asked the applicants and others present to leave the acting Rector's office, they left without any resistance and moved to a lecture hall.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Government disputed the applicants' version of events regarding the entry into acting Rector Mr G.Kh.'s office on 3 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "According to the Government's official version of events, at least twenty people forced their way into Mr G.Kh.'s office on 3 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "According to the Government's official version of events, dozens of other protesters stayed in the reception area and the corridor chanting slogans against Mr G.Kh.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "According to the Government's official version of events, the second applicant informed acting Rector Mr G.Kh. of the former Grand Academic Council's decision and demanded that he leave his office within ten minutes.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "According to the Government's official version of events, the Tbilisi State University security service was no longer in control of the situation and the functioning of the University administration was disrupted.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the Government's official version of events, the police were called to restore order because the applicants and other protesters were refusing to leave.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the Government's official version of events, Mr G.Kh. left his office as soon as the police arrived.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the Government's official version of events, it took more than one hour for the police to negotiate the applicants' removal from the acting Rector's office.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to the case file, after their removal from the acting Rector's office, the applicants together with other protesters — totalling approximately 400 people — gathered in one of the lecture halls of the main Tbilisi State University building and continued their protest.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The applicants alleged that at around 11 p.m. on 3 July 2006 the police closed the doors of the lecture hall and prevented the people inside from leaving.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The applicants alleged that they had been locked in the lecture hall without access to water, food or toilet facilities until approximately 8-10 a.m. on 4 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. The events of 3-4 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "On 3 July 2006 criminal proceedings were initiated under Article 226 of the Criminal Code of Georgia against unidentified perpetrators in respect of the organisation and participation in group actions violating public order.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "According to the applicants, on 4 July 2006 the Minister of Education of Georgia held a press briefing denouncing the events that had taken place at Tbilisi State University on 3 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "According to the applicants, at the press briefing on 4 July 2006 the Minister of Education referred to those involved in the 3 July 2006 events as 'hooligans'.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "According to the applicants, at the press briefing on 4 July 2006 the Minister of Education gave an assurance that all those involved in the 3 July 2006 events would bear responsibility for their actions.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Over the several days following 3 July 2006, twenty witnesses were questioned in connection with the events of 3 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Among the twenty witnesses questioned in connection with the events of 3 July 2006 were six police patrol officers, three members of the Tbilisi State University security service, and eleven administrative staff members including acting Rector Mr G.Kh. and his deputy.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Tbilisi State University staff members who were eyewitnesses to the events of 3 July 2006 all identified the applicants as being among those who had forced their way into acting Rector Mr G.Kh.'s office, insulted him and demanded his resignation.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Tbilisi State University staff members who were eyewitnesses noted that while there had been no physical confrontation, the group of 'protesting professors' had been acting in a highly disrespectful manner, chanting insulting expressions against Mr G.Kh.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Tbilisi State University staff members who were eyewitnesses claimed that the University had remained paralysed during the incident, with several meetings being disrupted and acting Rector Mr G.Kh. and several members of the University administration being prevented from carrying out their duties.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Acting Rector Mr G.Kh. testified that around twenty people, including all the applicants, had burst into his office in disregard of the orders of the security staff.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Acting Rector Mr G.Kh. testified that the second applicant had informed him of the former Grand Academic Council's decision and had 'categorically' demanded that he leave his office, 'bag and baggage', within ten minutes.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Acting Rector Mr G.Kh. testified that their meeting had continued against a background of noise and chanting, with protesters chanting 'leave, leave'.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Acting Rector Mr G.Kh. testified that he had not been personally insulted, although his colleagues had told him that protesters in the corridor adjacent to his office had been chanting insulting slogans.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "In reply to a direct question, acting Rector Mr G.Kh. explained that no foul language had been used by protesters in his office, either in respect of him or of his colleagues.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Acting Rector Mr G.Kh. testified that he remembered Mr Dolidze inciting via cell phone other protesters to join them in the acting Rector's office.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Acting Rector Mr G.Kh. testified that the incident in his office had lasted for about an hour and a half, paralysing not only his work but the functioning of the whole administration of Tbilisi State University.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Tbilisi State University security service members questioned during the pre-trial investigation claimed that they had been unable to identify the professors involved in the events of 3 July 2006 by name.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Tbilisi State University security service members confirmed that a large group of about fifty people, in disobedience of orders given by the security service, had entered the reception area of the acting Rector's office by force.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Tbilisi State University security service members confirmed that around fifteen or twenty people had forced their way into acting Rector Mr G.Kh.'s office, where they stayed for about two hours until the police secured their removal.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 5 July 2006 the second, fourth, fifth, seventh and eighth applicants were questioned as witnesses in the course of the criminal proceedings initiated on 3 July 2006 under Article 226 of the Criminal Code of Georgia.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 24 July 2006 several members of the former Grand Academic Council, including the second, third, fourth, fifth and seventh applicants, sent a letter to the President of Georgia complaining about the events of 19-20 June and 3-4 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "In the letter of 24 July 2006 to the President of Georgia, the applicants made a particular complaint that they, along with several hundred other people, had been locked in the Tbilisi State University lecture hall for the whole night of 3-4 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "In the letter of 24 July 2006 to the President of Georgia, the applicants alleged that being locked in the lecture hall had amounted to inhuman and degrading treatment, as they had been denied access to drinking water and a toilet and had been left without fresh air.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "In the letter of 24 July 2006 to the President of Georgia, the applicants requested the initiation of criminal proceedings regarding the events of 3-4 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "A copy of the letter of 24 July 2006 was sent to the Prosecutor General of Georgia.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "In support of their request, the applicants submitted statements given by fifteen people accounting in detail for the events of 19-20 June and 3-4 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 29 July 2006 the relevant prosecutor issued a ruling terminating the criminal proceedings concerning the alleged organisation and participation in group actions violating public order.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The prosecutor concluded in the ruling of 29 July 2006 that the actions of the applicants had not comprised elements of a crime.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "The prosecutor's ruling of 29 July 2006 stated that the applicants had committed administrative offences — namely arbitrary behaviour under Article 174 of the Code of Administrative Offences, a minor violation of public order under Article 166 of the Code of Administrative Offences, and disobeying the lawful instructions of law-enforcement personnel under Article 173 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "In the operative part of the prosecutor's ruling of 29 July 2006, the prosecutor stated that the ruling, along with the case file, was to be sent to the Tbilisi City Court in order for administrative proceedings to be conducted against the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "In the ruling of 29 July 2006, the prosecutor also decided to terminate proceedings that had apparently been opened against police officers in respect of their alleged unlawful use of force on 3-4 July 2006, finding the complaint lodged by the applicants in that connection unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The prosecutor's ruling of 29 July 2006 provided in its operative part a fifteen-day time-limit for an appeal against the decision to discontinue the criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The prosecutor's ruling of 29 July 2006 did not mention the applicants' complaint concerning the events of 19-20 June 2006.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The applicants were served with a copy of the prosecutor's ruling of 29 July 2006 late in the evening of 29 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "At the same time as being served with the ruling, the applicants were told that a hearing in the administrative proceedings initiated against them had been scheduled for the next day, 30 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "1. Criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On 30 July 2006 a hearing took place at the Tbilisi City Court in the administrative proceedings against the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "At the hearing of 30 July 2006, the applicants objected that owing to the initiation of the administrative proceedings they could not avail themselves of the opportunity to challenge the prosecutorial ruling of 29 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "At the hearing of 30 July 2006, the applicants complained that they had not had sufficient time to acquaint themselves with the relevant material in the case file and to hire a lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "At the hearing of 30 July 2006, the applicants requested that acting Rector Mr G.Kh. and the security staff of Tbilisi State University be questioned.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "At the hearing of 30 July 2006, the prosecutor requested the questioning of three of the police officers involved in the events that had developed in acting Rector Mr G.Kh.'s office on 3 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "At the hearing of 30 July 2006, the judge allowed the prosecutor's request for three police officers to be examined in court and postponed the hearing until 3 August 2006.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "At the hearing on 3 August 2006, the applicants reiterated their request for acting Rector Mr G.Kh. to be examined in court.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "At the hearing on 3 August 2006, the applicants requested that the court hear the deputy Rector of Tbilisi State University and four other eyewitnesses to the events of 3 July 2006, including two journalists who had not been questioned at the pre-trial stage of the discontinued criminal proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "At the hearing on 3 August 2006, the judge granted the applicants leave to question the four new witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "At the hearing on 3 August 2006, the judge refused the applicants' request for the questioning of acting Rector Mr G.Kh. and his deputy, reasoning that those two individuals had already been questioned at the pre-trial stage and that their statements had been included in the case file.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "According to the minutes of the 3 August 2006 hearing, the applicants challenged the factual circumstances of the events of 3 July 2006 as presented by the prosecutor, maintaining that they had not broken into the acting Rector's office but had entered it and sat there calmly without using any force.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "According to the minutes of the 3 August 2006 hearing, the applicants maintained that they had not insulted or threatened acting Rector Mr G.Kh. but had simply presented him with the decision of the Grand Academic Council.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "According to the minutes of the 3 August 2006 hearing, the applicants maintained that they had not disobeyed the instructions of the police but had left the acting Rector's office within ten or fifteen minutes of being ordered to do so by the police.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "At the 3 August 2006 hearing, the second applicant stated that he had been taken out of the acting Rector's office sitting on a chair because he had apparently looked very tired.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "At the 3 August 2006 hearing, the applicants' lawyers argued that the acting Rector's office did not constitute a public space for the purposes of Article 166 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "At the 3 August 2006 hearing, the applicants' lawyers argued that the applicants had simply been exercising their right to freedom of assembly and freedom of expression as provided for in the Constitution of Georgia.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "At the 3 August 2006 hearing, the applicants' lawyers alleged that the prosecutor had presented the case in a manner suggesting the collective administrative liability of the applicants, as the individual role of each applicant in the events of 3 July 2006 had not been identified.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "At the 3 August 2006 hearing, the applicants reiterated their complaint that they had been locked in the Tbilisi State University lecture hall for the night of 3-4 July 2006 without access to water or toilets.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "At the 3 August 2006 hearing, the applicants tried to put several questions to the prosecutor regarding the alleged locking in the lecture hall, but the presiding judge dismissed the questions as irrelevant and having no bearing on the case.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "At the hearing of 3 August 2006, V.J., a member of the Tbilisi State University security service, claimed that about fifty people — disregarding his orders and pushing him away — had forced their way to the reception area of the acting Rector's office.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "At the hearing of 3 August 2006, V.J. stated in reply to the judge's question that he could not recall exactly who had pushed him.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "At the hearing of 3 August 2006, V.J. stated that various protesters had been making insulting statements and noise and that as a result the work in the main building of Tbilisi State University had been disrupted.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "At the hearing of 3 August 2006, police patrol officer G.Ch. stated that at the moment of his arrival at Tbilisi State University there had been around 200 people protesting outside.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "At the hearing of 3 August 2006, police patrol officer G.Ch. stated that he had entered the University building and tried to enter the acting Rector's office, which had been blocked by protesters.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "At the hearing of 3 August 2006, police patrol officer G.Ch. stated that after making his way through protesters and entering acting Rector Mr G.Kh.'s office, he had seen around twenty people inside.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "At the hearing of 3 August 2006, police patrol officer G.Ch. stated that it had taken him and the other officers about one hour to persuade the protesters to leave the acting Rector's office.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "At the hearing of 3 August 2006, police patrol officer G.Ch. clarified in reply to a question that no one had physically resisted the police, but that the protesters had simply refused to leave the acting Rector's office.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "At the hearing of 3 August 2006, police patrol officer G.Ch. specified that insulting statements had been made by protesters in the corridor and not in the acting Rector's office.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "At the hearing of 3 August 2006, police officer Z.S. confirmed that while no force had been used, the police had spent an hour persuading a group of about twenty people to leave the acting Rector's office.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "At the hearing of 3 August 2006, police officer Z.S. stated that the second applicant, Mr Mebonia, had been taken out of the acting Rector's office still sitting on a chair as he had refused to stand up and leave by himself.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "At the hearing of 3 August 2006, police officer Z.S. stated that he recalled all of the applicants, except for the sixth applicant, Ms Sikharulidze, being inside the acting Rector's office.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "At the hearing of 3 August 2006, the third police officer, K.B., similarly maintained that there had been no physical confrontation inside the acting Rector's office, but that it had taken a while before those inside had agreed to leave.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "On 3 August 2006 the Tbilisi City Court examined two members of Tbilisi State University staff, who gave evidence similar to their pre-trial statements.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "On 3 August 2006 the Tbilisi City Court questioned two journalists and two professors, all of whom had been among the group of protesters on 3 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "The two journalists and two professors questioned on 3 August 2006 all claimed that there had been no confrontation — either physical or verbal — in the office of acting Rector Mr G.Kh. on 3 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The two journalists and two professors questioned on 3 August 2006 claimed that the group had been simply demanding the resignation of Mr G.Kh. and that they had left the office at the request of the police.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "By a decision of 4 August 2006, the Tbilisi City Court found the first, second, third, fourth, fifth, seventh and eighth applicants guilty of administrative offences under Articles 166, 173 and 174 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court imposed a fine of 100 Georgian laris (approximately 45 euros) on each of the first, second, third, fourth, fifth, seventh and eighth applicants.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court terminated the proceedings concerning the alleged disobeying of a lawful order given by the police under Article 173 of the Code of Administrative Offences with respect to the sixth applicant, Ms Sikharulidze, and the ninth applicant, Mr D. Bakhtadze, finding that they had left the acting Rector's office before the arrival of the police.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court found the sixth applicant, Ms Sikharulidze, and the ninth applicant, Mr D. Bakhtadze, guilty of administrative offences under Articles 166 and 174 of the Code of Administrative Offences only, imposing a fine of 100 Georgian laris on each of them.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "In reaching its decision, the Tbilisi City Court concluded that the Grand Academic Council had begun acting unlawfully from 8 June 2005, when the old Tbilisi State University charter had been repealed by Presidential Decree no. 473.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court found that the restoration of the dissolved Grand Academic Council and the election of the new University Rector on 3 July 2006 had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court found that the subsequent demand for the resignation of acting Rector Mr G.Kh. in view of the election had been unlawful and constituted the administrative offence of arbitrary behaviour within the meaning of Article 174 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "In connection with the charge of a minor breach of public order (minor hooliganism), the Tbilisi City Court established that the applicants had burst into the office of acting Rector Mr G.Kh., calling for his resignation.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court established that the applicants had demanded, in an insulting manner, that acting Rector Mr G.Kh. immediately leave his office and take all his belongings with him.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court concluded that the applicants had occupied the office of acting Rector Mr G.Kh. against his will for about two hours and had disregarded his repeated requests for them to leave.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court concluded that the applicants' behaviour had amounted to insulting harassment with respect to Mr G.Kh. and other staff present, and to 'other similar action' that had violated public order and peace.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court dismissed the applicants' argument that the acting Rector's office was merely a private working space, reasoning that the presence of the public rendered it a public space for the purposes of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court concluded that although persons are entitled to exercise the rights and freedoms enshrined in Articles 19, 24 and 25 of the Constitution of Georgia, they are obliged in the process of exercising those rights to abstain from violating others' rights and interests, from encroaching upon others' honour and dignity, and from violating public order.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court concluded that the applicants had, in exercising their constitutional rights, committed acts prohibited by law on 3 July 2006 in the office of the acting Rector.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court concluded that the sixth applicant, Ms Sikharulidze, and the ninth applicant, Mr D. Bakhtadze, had left the office of acting Rector Mr G.Kh. before the arrival of the police and were thus acquitted of the charge of disobeying a lawful order given by the police under Article 173 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court established that the remaining applicants had refused to leave the office of acting Rector Mr G.Kh. despite the repeated requests of the police.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court concluded that the applicants' refusal for more than an hour to obey the orders of the police, notwithstanding the fact that no physical force had been used, had amounted to a breach of Article 173 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The applicants appealed against the Tbilisi City Court's decision of 4 August 2006 to the chairwoman of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "In their appeal, the applicants complained that there had been no record of an administrative offence having been made individually in respect of each of them and that their individual roles in the commission of the impugned administrative offences had not been established.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "In their appeal, the applicants complained that the proceedings had been brought in a manner suggesting their collective liability.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "In their appeal, the applicants referred to witness statements noting that there had been two hundred people outside and twenty people inside the acting Rector's office during the events of 3 July 2006 and that it was impossible to identify the individuals who had allegedly insulted the acting Rector and forced their way into his office.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "In their appeal, the applicants complained of the failure of the Tbilisi City Court to examine acting Rector Mr G.Kh. and his deputy in the course of the trial.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "In their appeal, the applicants challenged the categorisation of their actions as administrative offences by the Tbilisi City Court, submitting that they had simply been exercising their freedom of expression and freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "On 4 September 2006, the chairwoman of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal, sitting privately and without holding an oral hearing, dismissed the applicants' appeal as unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "The chairwoman of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal concluded that the decision of the Tbilisi City Court had been lawful and properly reasoned.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The operative part of the Tbilisi Court of Appeal's decision of 4 September 2006 indicated that no further appeal was possible.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Subsequent developments", "2. Administrative proceedings against the applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The case file contains a copy of a television report by the Imedi broadcasting company about the events of 3 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Television report by the Imedi broadcasting company about the events of 3 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "As shown in Imedi's recording of the events of 3 July 2006, at least twenty people had entered the reception area of acting Rector Mr G.Kh.'s office by force, in disregard of the protests of the security staff and reception staff.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Television report by the Imedi broadcasting company about the events of 3 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "As shown in Imedi's recording of the events of 3 July 2006, some of those who entered the reception area had walked into the acting Rector's office itself, notifying Mr G.Kh. of the decision of the Grand Academic Council and demanding his resignation.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Television report by the Imedi broadcasting company about the events of 3 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "According to the Imedi video recording of 3 July 2006, dozens of protesters had simultaneously gathered in the corridor adjacent to the acting Rector's office and had chanted 'step down!'", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Television report by the Imedi broadcasting company about the events of 3 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "Imedi broadcasting company ran an extract from the press briefing held by the Minister of Education of Georgia on 4 July 2006.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Television report by the Imedi broadcasting company about the events of 3 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "At the press briefing on 4 July 2006, the Minister of Education of Georgia stated: 'Those people, who went beyond all the limits of academia and ethics yesterday, will of course, face responsibility for that.'", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Television report by the Imedi broadcasting company about the events of 3 July 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "Article 24(1) of the Constitution of Georgia provides that everyone shall be free to receive and impart information, to express and disseminate his or her opinion orally, in writing, or otherwise.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "Article 24(4) of the Constitution of Georgia provides that the exercise of the rights listed in Article 24(1) and (2) may be subject only to such limitations as are prescribed by law and are necessary in a democratic society in the interests of state security, territorial integrity or public safety, to prevent crime, to safeguard rights and dignity of others, to prevent disclosure of information acknowledged as confidential, or to ensure the independence and impartiality of justice.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "Article 25(1) of the Constitution of Georgia provides that everyone, except those serving in the military forces and the Ministry of Internal Affairs, shall have the right to gather publicly, unarmed, both indoors and outdoors, without prior permission.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "Article 25(3) of the Constitution of Georgia provides that authorities may terminate a public assembly or a manifestation only if it assumes an unlawful character.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "Article 1(1) of the Law of Georgia on Assembly and Demonstrations, as worded at the material time, provided that the law regulates the exercise of the right guaranteed by the Constitution of Georgia to gather publicly, unarmed, both indoors and outdoors, without prior permission.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "Article 1(3) of the Law of Georgia on Assembly and Demonstrations, as worded at the material time, provided that the law sets out the requirement that the authorities be notified if an assembly or a demonstration is due to be held in a public place or a place through which transport passes.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "Article 9(1) of the Law of Georgia on Assembly and Demonstrations, as worded at the material time, prohibited holding an assembly or a demonstration inside the building of the Parliament of Georgia, the residency of the President of Georgia, the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court of Georgia, on the premises of courts, prosecutor's offices or of police, penitentiary or military units and sites, in railway stations, airports, hospitals or diplomatic missions (or within a 20-metre radius thereof), on the premises of governmental institutions or local self-government bodies, or in the buildings of companies, institutions and organisations that operate under special labour security rules or are under armed guard.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "Article 9(1) of the Law of Georgia on Assembly and Demonstrations, as worded at the material time, also prohibited fully blocking the entrance to those sites.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "Under Article 9 of the Law on the Police, as in force at the material time, the police were responsible inter alia for dispersing unlawful rallies, demonstrations, pickets and other assemblies that posed a threat to public safety, the lives and health of people, property, and other rights guaranteed by law.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "The Law on the Police was replaced by a new Act in 2013.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The Code of Administrative Offences of Georgia was adopted on 15 December 1984, when Georgia was part of the Soviet Union, and subsequently numerous amendments were introduced.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "Article 166 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Georgia, as in force at the material time, defined minor hooliganism (a minor breach of public order) as swearing and cursing in a public place, causing insulting harassment to a person, or other similar actions which disturb public order and peace, punishable by a fine of 100 Georgian laris or, if that measure was not deemed sufficient, up to thirty days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "Article 173 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Georgia, as in force at the material time, provided that maliciously disobeying a lawful instruction or order issued by a law enforcement officer shall be punishable by a fine amounting to ten times the minimum monthly wage, or by one to six months' correctional labour compounded by the withholding of 20% of the offender's wages, or, if those measures were not deemed sufficient, by up to thirty days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "Article 174 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Georgia, as in force at the material time, defined arbitrary behaviour as the exercise of a right in violation of a law which does not cause any significant damage to people, the State or to public bodies, punishable by a warning or a fine of half the minimum monthly wage, or in the case of public officials, a warning or a fine of one minimum monthly wage.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": false, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F042", "F057", "F064", "F129", "F110", "F115", "F118", "F061", "F062"], "interference": ["F035", "F036", "F037", "F045", "F120", "F121", "F122", "F123"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F160", "F158", "F043", "F045", "F109", "F163", "F131", "F129", "F057", "F064", "F164", "F165"], "legitimate_aim": ["F031", "F032", "F039", "F040", "F149", "F146", "F147", "F148", "F057", "F105", "F064", "F129"], "necessity": ["F029", "F004", "F045", "F109", "F110", "F112", "F046", "F075", "F076", "F121", "F123", "F037", "F119", "F002", "F003", "F005", "F006", "F039", "F042", "F057", "F135", "F136"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F029", "F031", "F032", "F062", "F110", "F129"], "interference": ["F045", "F120", "F121", "F035", "F036"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F160", "F158", "F163", "F164", "F131", "F129"], "legitimate_aim": ["F039", "F040", "F149", "F057", "F064", "F147", "F148"], "necessity": ["F029", "F004", "F045", "F109", "F110", "F112", "F046", "F075", "F076", "F121", "F123", "F135", "F136", "F039"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F029", "F032", "F039", "F057", "F062", "F110", "F045", "F046", "F075", "F121", "F135", "F004"]}} {"case_name": "case_642", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The United Civil Aviation Trade Union is a trade union registered in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "Mr A. Csorba is a Hungarian national.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Mr A. Csorba was born in 1970.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Mr A. Csorba lives in Vecsés.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Mr A. Csorba is the President of the United Civil Aviation Trade Union.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 12 October 2012, Mr A. Csorba (the second applicant) applied to the Budapest police department for authorisation to hold a demonstration on the road leading to Budapest Ferenc Liszt International Airport.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "Mr A. Csorba (the second applicant) stated that the demonstration would be held on the hard shoulder of the road leading to Budapest Ferenc Liszt International Airport, which was not ordinarily used for traffic.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "One of the declared objectives of the demonstration was to draw the public's attention to the precarious financial situation in which the employees of Budapest Ferenc Liszt International Airport would find themselves if salary cuts envisaged by the company managing the airport were carried out.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The demonstration was scheduled to be held between 3 p.m. and 5 p.m. on 17 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Mr A. Csorba (the second applicant) specified that it was expected that about fifty to 100 persons would participate in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Mr A. Csorba (the second applicant) specified that it was intended that speeches would be given at the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Mr A. Csorba (the second applicant) specified that it was intended that an open letter would be read out at the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 14 October 2012, the Budapest police department registered the application to hold a demonstration on the road leading to Budapest Ferenc Liszt International Airport.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 14 October 2012, the Budapest police department informed Mr A. Csorba (the second applicant) that it was necessary to schedule a meeting with the organisers in order to clarify details regarding the programme of the demonstration and the number of police officers that would be required to secure the event.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "Mr A. Csorba (the second applicant) and the Vice-President of the United Civil Aviation Trade Union met with the representatives of the Monor police department on 14 October 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The representative of the Monor police department suggested that the demonstration be held at another location, since the planned venue on the road leading to Budapest Ferenc Liszt International Airport would endanger traffic.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "Mr A. Csorba (the second applicant) assured the police that the demonstrators would respect traffic rules.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Mr A. Csorba (the second applicant) assured the police that the demonstrators would only occupy the part of the road not used for traffic.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Mr A. Csorba (the second applicant) assured the police that the demonstrators would distribute flyers to car passengers.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Mr A. Csorba (the second applicant) assured the police that the organisers would call off or halt the demonstration if it was not in compliance with the relevant legal provisions.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 14 October 2012, the Monor police department forbade the demonstration planned for 17 October 2012 on the road leading to Budapest Ferenc Liszt International Airport.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Monor police department was of the view that the planned demonstration would endanger traffic.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Monor police department was of the view that the planned demonstration would render Budapest Ferenc Liszt International Airport inaccessible, infringing passengers' right to leave the country.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Monor police department was of the view that the demonstration would breach the traffic code, since those parts of the road not used for traffic were not supposed to be accessed by pedestrians or be used for parking.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 17 October 2012, the United Civil Aviation Trade Union (the first applicant) and Mr A. Csorba (the second applicant) requested judicial review of the Monor police department's decision forbidding the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The applicants relied on their right to freedom of expression in requesting judicial review of the Monor police department's decision forbidding the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicants relied on their right to freedom of assembly in requesting judicial review of the Monor police department's decision forbidding the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicants argued that a demonstration could only be forbidden on the grounds of a need to ensure traffic safety if there were no alternative means of access to Budapest Ferenc Liszt International Airport.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicants argued that the demonstration would not constitute any greater hindrance to traffic than would roadworks.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "By a decision of 19 October 2012, the Budapest Surroundings High Court (Budapest Környéki Törvényszék) dismissed the applicants' complaint requesting judicial review of the Monor police department's decision forbidding the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Budapest Surroundings High Court (Budapest Környéki Törvényszék) endorsed in essence the Monor police department's reasoning for forbidding the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "Section 8(1) of Act no. III of 1989 on the Right to Assembly provides that if the holding of an event subject to prior notification seriously endangers the proper functioning of the representative bodies or courts, or results in a disproportionate hindrance of the circulation of traffic, the police may ban the holding of the event at the place or time indicated in the notification, within 48 hours from the receipt of the notification by the authority.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F005", "F006", "F007", "F009", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F017", "F018", "F020"], "interference": ["F021", "F030"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F032", "F021"], "legitimate_aim": ["F022", "F023", "F032"], "necessity": ["F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F030", "F031"], "positive_obligation": ["F006", "F008", "F016", "F021", "F030", "F031"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F009", "F010", "F017", "F020"], "interference": ["F021"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F032", "F021"], "legitimate_aim": ["F022", "F023"], "necessity": ["F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F016", "F020", "F021", "F031"], "positive_obligation": ["F008", "F016", "F021"]}, "list3": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F016", "F020", "F021", "F031"]}} {"case_name": "case_644", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_645", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_646", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_647", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "On different dates, the applicants were taken to police stations.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants were taken to police stations as administrative suspects of offences related to public events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants were subsequently administratively convicted for participation in different public events in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants complained of unlawful detention (deprivation of liberty).", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004"], "interference": ["F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F004"]}} {"case_name": "case_648", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1975 and lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1964 and lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1982 and lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The fourth applicant was born in 1976 and lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The fifth applicant was born in 1983 and lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The sixth applicant was born in 1978 and lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The seventh applicant was born in 1961 and lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The eighth applicant was born in 1947 and lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The ninth applicant was born in 1955 and lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The tenth applicant was born in 1975 and lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The eleventh applicant was born in 1979 and lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The twelfth applicant was born in 1953 and lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The thirteenth applicant was born in 1952 and lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The fourteenth applicant was born in 1976 and lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 31 July 2000, the applicants, together with several other persons, gathered in a public park in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The gathering on 31 July 2000 was held in protest against F-type prisons.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The gathering on 31 July 2000 was held in protest against the events which had occurred in Bergama Prison.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "Violent clashes had taken place between detainees and security forces at Bergama Prison on 27 July 2000.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The participants at the 31 July 2000 gathering wanted to read out a press statement to express their concerns about F-type prisons.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The participants at the 31 July 2000 gathering wanted to read out a press statement to express their concerns about the events in Bergama Prison.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Police officers warned the crowd over a megaphone that the demonstration was illegal under Law no. 2911 on Meetings and Demonstration Marches.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The group ignored the police warning that the demonstration was illegal under Law no. 2911 on Meetings and Demonstration Marches.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "Police officers arrested twenty-four persons, including the applicants, and took them into custody.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to newspaper articles submitted by the applicants, police officers used force in order to disperse the protesters.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "As a result of the police use of force, some of the protesters were injured.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "As a result of the police use of force, a number of protesters were arrested by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the arrest report drawn up and signed by police officers, the applicants were demonstrating with protest banners in their hands.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the arrest report, after having warned the applicants to desist, the police arrested the protesters who continued demonstrating.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The arrest report noted that three police officers had been injured during the clash with the demonstrators at the time of the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The three injured police officers had to be taken to hospital following the clash with the demonstrators at the time of the arrest.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "Medical reports stated that the three police officers who were injured during the clash with the demonstrators were unfit for work for two days.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 31 August 2000, the Ankara Public Prosecutor filed an indictment with the Ankara Criminal Court of First Instance against the applicants and nine others.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The applicants and nine others were charged with having taken part in a demonstration in a public place without the permission of the authorities, contrary to Law no. 2911 on Meetings and Demonstration Marches.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The applicants alleged that police officers had been armed during the hearings before the trial court.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicants alleged that police officers had verbally harassed the defence lawyers during the hearings before the trial court.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicants alleged that police officers had obtained a copy of the reports and statements in the case file even though the police officers were not a party to the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicants' request to include the facts about armed police officers, verbal harassment of defence lawyers, and police officers obtaining case file documents in the record of the hearings was dismissed.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 5 July 2001, the Ankara Criminal Court of First Instance acquitted some of the accused.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 5 July 2001, the Ankara Criminal Court of First Instance convicted the applicants on the basis of evidence given by the applicants and by witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Ankara Criminal Court of First Instance found that the applicants had ignored the police warning that their meeting was illegal and that they had to disperse.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Ankara Criminal Court of First Instance found that the police had had to use force in order to arrest the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "Having examined the applicants' defence submissions, the Ankara Criminal Court of First Instance considered that the applicants had indirectly confessed to the crime (tevil yollu ikrar) by admitting that they had gathered in the park in order to protest against F-type prisons and the events in Bergama Prison.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Ankara Criminal Court of First Instance sentenced Rıza Altuntov to a fine, taking into account the fact that he was a minor at the time of the incident (seventeen and a half years old).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Ankara Criminal Court of First Instance sentenced the other applicants (excluding Rıza Altuntov) to one year and three months' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Ankara Criminal Court of First Instance decided to suspend enforcement of the applicants' sentence under section 6 of Law no. 667, with the exception of Alaattin Uğraş, Sinan Cem Uzunget and İsmail Temizyürek.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "On 7 March 2002, the applicants appealed to the Court of Cassation against the judgment of the Ankara Criminal Court of First Instance.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The written opinion of the Chief Public Prosecutor at the Court of Cassation was not transmitted to the applicants.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 19 December 2002, the Court of Cassation upheld the decision of the Ankara Criminal Court of First Instance.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Section 6 of Law no. 647 on the Execution of Sentences provides that anyone who has never been sentenced to a penalty other than a fine and is sentenced to a fine and/or a maximum term of one year's imprisonment may have his or her sentence suspended if the court is satisfied that the offender, having regard to his or her criminal record and criminal tendencies, will not reoffend if the sentence is thus suspended.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "Section 6 of Law no. 2253 on the Establishment and Rules of Procedure of the Juvenile Courts, as amended by Law no. 4963 of 30 July 2003, provides that criminal cases which concern crimes that normally fall under the jurisdiction of the regular courts and are committed by minors who are not yet eighteen years of age shall be examined by the juvenile courts.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "Article 34 of the Turkish Constitution provides that everyone has the right to hold unarmed and peaceful meetings and demonstration marches without prior permission.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "Article 34 of the Turkish Constitution provides that the formalities, conditions, and procedures governing the exercise of the right to hold meetings and demonstration marches shall be prescribed by law.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "At the material time, section 10 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911) required that, in order for a meeting to take place, the governor's office or authorities of the district in which the demonstration was planned must be informed, during opening hours and at least seventy-two hours prior to the meeting, by a notice containing the signature of all the members of the organising board.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Section 22 of Law no. 2911 (the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act) prohibited demonstrations and processions on public streets, in parks, places of worship, and buildings in which public services were based.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "Section 22 of Law no. 2911 (the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act) required that demonstrations organised in public squares comply with security instructions and not obstruct individual movement or public transport.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "Section 24 of Law no. 2911 (the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act) provided that demonstrations and processions which did not comply with the provisions of that law would be dispersed by force on the order of the governor's office and after the demonstrators had been warned.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "Section 16 of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that the police may use firearms in self-defence.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "Section 16 of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that the police may use firearms if a person or a group resists the police and prevents them from carrying out their duties or if there is an attack against the police.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Additional section 6 of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that in cases of resistance by persons whose arrest is necessary or by groups whose dispersal is necessary, or of an attack or threat of an attack, the police may use violence to subdue these actions.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "Additional section 6 of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that use of violence refers to the use of bodily force, physical force and all types of weapons specified in the law, and gradually increases according to the nature and level of resistance and attack in such a way as to restore calm.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Additional section 6 of Law no. 2559 on the Duties and Powers of the Police provides that in cases of intervention by group forces, the extent of the use of force and the equipment and instruments to be used shall be determined by the commander of the intervening force.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F015", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F027", "F039", "F044"], "interference": ["F023", "F024", "F039", "F044"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F051", "F053", "F054", "F055"], "legitimate_aim": ["F021", "F022", "F033"], "necessity": ["F015", "F016", "F017", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F027", "F029", "F044", "F045"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F015", "F016", "F017", "F019", "F027"], "interference": ["F023", "F024", "F039", "F044"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F054"], "legitimate_aim": ["F022", "F033"], "necessity": ["F015", "F019", "F024", "F025", "F027", "F029", "F044", "F045"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F015", "F019", "F024", "F025", "F027", "F039", "F044", "F054"]}} {"case_name": "case_649", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_650", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_653", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention and its Protocol.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_659", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1976.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was represented by Mr T. Hüttl, a lawyer practising in Budapest.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent at the Ministry of Justice, Mr Z. Tallódi.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant, together with another person, intended to organise demonstrations to draw attention to the situation of those having foreign currency loans.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant, together with another person, intended to organise demonstrations to draw attention to alleged fraudulent banking policies.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant, together with another person, intended to organise demonstrations to put pressure on decision-makers so that respect for the rule of law gains primacy over the interests of oligarchs.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 8 December 2014 the applicant notified the Budapest police department of his intention to organise a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The demonstration was scheduled for 19 December 2014 between 9 a.m. and 8 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The demonstration was planned to take place at nine venues: the headquarters of different banks, the Israeli embassy, the Kúria, the home of the chief executive officer (CEO) of the biggest commercial bank in Hungary, the home of the prime minister, and the Offices of the National Assembly.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The demonstration was planned to include a march between the different locations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The organisers specified that it was expected that about thirty to one hundred persons would participate in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The organisers specified that it was expected that about twenty to fifty cars would participate in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 8 December 2014 the organisers met with representatives of the Budapest police department for a conciliation meeting with the aim of amending the programme of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The representative of the Budapest police department informed the organisers that the demonstration should not disturb the proper functioning of and entry into the buildings in question.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The representative of the Budapest police department informed the organisers that the demonstration should not put pressure on the judiciary.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The representative of the Budapest police department reminded the organisers that the home of the prime minister was under special protection.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The organisers amended the agenda of the demonstration, reducing the time spent outside the Kúria building to ten minutes.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The organisers amended the agenda of the demonstration, reducing the time spent at the prime minister's home to ten minutes.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The organisers agreed to use megaphones only at the Kúria building and the prime minister's home.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The organisers agreed to approach the Kúria building and the prime minister's home only on foot.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The organisers agreed to change the aim of the demonstration from 'putting pressure on decision-makers' to 'raising public awareness'.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 9 December 2014 the Budapest police department banned the holding of the demonstration outside the Kúria building.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 9 December 2014 the Budapest police department banned the holding of the demonstration outside the home of the prime minister.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 9 December 2014 the Budapest police department banned the holding of the demonstration outside the home of the CEO of the biggest commercial bank in Hungary.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The reasoning of the Budapest police department's decision stated that according to information received from the vice-president of the Kúria, the aim of the demonstration, namely 'putting pressure on decision-makers', was unconstitutional.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The reasoning of the Budapest police department's decision stated that the aim of the demonstration, namely 'putting pressure on decision-makers', was likely to endanger the independence and proper functioning of the judiciary.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Budapest police department's decision held that the demonstration outside the Kúria was prohibited under section 8(1) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Budapest police department's decision held that the demonstration at the home of the prime minister would constitute a direct threat to the inhabitants' right to private and family life.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The Budapest police department's decision held that the demonstration at the home of the CEO of the biggest commercial bank in Hungary would constitute a direct threat to the inhabitants' right to private and family life.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Budapest police department's decision held that the demonstration at the homes of the prime minister and the CEO of the biggest commercial bank in Hungary would constitute a direct threat to the inhabitants' right to property.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Budapest police department's decision held that the demonstration at the homes of the prime minister and the CEO of the biggest commercial bank in Hungary would constitute a direct threat to the inhabitants' right to move around freely.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Budapest police department's decision held that the demonstration at the homes of the prime minister and the CEO of the biggest commercial bank in Hungary would be likely to frighten the children attending the nearby school.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The Budapest police department's decision held that the demonstration at the homes of the prime minister and the CEO of the biggest commercial bank in Hungary would endanger the safety of the protected persons living in the premises.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Budapest police department's decision held that the demonstration at the homes of the prime minister and the CEO of the biggest commercial bank in Hungary was prohibited under section 2(3) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 16 December 2014 the Budapest Administrative and Labour Court dismissed the organisers' request for a judicial review of the Budapest police department's decision banning the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court endorsed in essence the police authorities' reasoning for banning the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court explained that even the amended aim of the demonstration, 'raising awareness', was likely to exert influence on and thereby infringe the independence of the judiciary, irrespective of the peaceful nature of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court noted that the organisers had not submitted any evidence to the contrary regarding the demonstration's impact on judicial independence.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court relied on section 8(1) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act) in respect of the demonstration outside the Kúria building.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court found that the homes of the prime minister and the CEO of the biggest commercial bank in Hungary were not 'symbolic public places with a communication function', but residential areas.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court found that the protection of the residents' private life and civil rights was a relevant reason to restrict the right to assembly under section 2(3) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court found that as a 'captive audience' the residents at the homes of the prime minister and the CEO of the biggest commercial bank in Hungary would not be able to avoid having to listen to statements they potentially disagreed with or found offensive.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court found that the expression of the opinions of the demonstrators was likely to cause fear and distress in the children attending the school nearby the homes of the prime minister and the CEO of the biggest commercial bank in Hungary.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Budapest Administrative and Labour Court found that the restriction on the demonstration was necessary and proportionate.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The organisers lodged a complaint with the Constitutional Court of Hungary.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "In decision no. 13/2016 (VII.16) AB of 12 July 2016, the Constitutional Court of Hungary dismissed the organisers' complaint.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In decision no. 13/2016 (VII.16) AB of 12 July 2016, the Constitutional Court of Hungary found, examining the issue of its own motion, that there existed an unconstitutional legal lacuna since the law did not set out guidance for those applying the legislation in cases of conflict between the right to private life and the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary observed that the trial court did not take into consideration that the conduct of the police vacated their power to assess and decide.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary observed that the conciliation procedure, of primordial importance in guaranteeing fundamental rights, became only formal in the present case.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary reiterated that the role of the conciliation procedure is to remove the legal obstacles from holding a planned demonstration and, in the event it is successful, to pave the way for the exercise of the right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary emphasised that it has no power to reassess the evidence, and that it is up to the police and the trial court to decide whether the present circumstances constituted 'seriously endangering' the functioning of the judiciary.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary stated that there is a reinforced obligation of those applying the law to provide reasons for their decisions regarding the functioning of the judiciary.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary emphasised that the right to freedom of assembly can have an impact on the fundamental rights of others.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary pointed out that 'the infringement of the rights of others' as regulated in Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act) is not a ground to prohibit a demonstration but, in accordance with sections 2(3) and 14(1) of the Assembly Act, a reason to disperse a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary noted that the police relied on section 2(3) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act) to ban the demonstration outside the homes of the prime minister and the CEO of the biggest commercial bank in Hungary.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary noted that the court carrying out the judicial review reasoned that under section 2(3) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act), even a presumably peaceful demonstration can be banned.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary found it questionable how a peaceful demonstration can infringe the rights of others.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary found that the Budapest Administrative and Labour Court paid no heed to the organisers' intention to reduce the length of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary found that the Budapest Administrative and Labour Court's decision did not consider the length of the demonstration and the fact that it had been reduced in the course of the reconciliation procedure.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary found that the Budapest Administrative and Labour Court's decision gave the impression that it did not assess the circumstances of the present case, as it referred to 'continuous', 'lifestyle' and repeated demonstrations, which were irrelevant in the present case.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary reiterated that in accordance with Article I § 3 of the Fundamental Law of Hungary, the grounds for restricting the fundamental right to freedom of assembly should be defined by Parliament in a legislative act and in accordance with the principles of necessity and proportionality.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary stated that the exhaustive list of grounds for restricting the fundamental right to freedom of assembly is currently set out in section 8(1) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary took note of the fact that the current legislative environment does not provide any means for those applying the law in cases of a conflict with fundamental rights and constitutional values other than those listed in section 8(1) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary found that both the police and the Budapest Administrative and Labour Court relied on section 2(3) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act) because they recognised the conflict with fundamental rights.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary found that since the petitioner had the possibility to express his opinion at a number of stages of the demonstration, his right to freedom of assembly had not been disproportionally restricted.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary rejected the constitutional complaint challenging the constitutionality of the judicial decision.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary observed that the legal system does not define the standards and procedures the police have to take into account when reconciling the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and other fundamental rights in cases of conflict.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary found that the underlying reason for the restrictive judicial practice manifested in the present case is the lack of legal guarantees foreseeing less restrictive measures and conditions other than banning demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary stated that in exceptional circumstances the conflict between fundamental rights could result in the most severe restriction, namely banning a demonstration, but that the mere fact that there is a conflict between fundamental rights is not a sufficient ground for banning a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary stated that in cases of a conflict between fundamental rights, with the exception of when there is good reason to ban a demonstration, there should be a way for the police to negotiate with the organisers of a demonstration in order to strike a balance that enables the holding of a demonstration and the exercise of other concurring fundamental rights protected by the Fundamental Law of Hungary.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary stated that those applying the law should have the possibility to assess the circumstances of the demonstration without emptying the fundamental right of its basic content.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary stated that it is the obligation of the legislature to provide guidance for those applying the legislation to effectively fulfil their obligations under Article I of the Fundamental Law of Hungary in cases of conflicting fundamental rights.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary found, acting of its own motion, that there is an unconstitutional legislative lacuna in violation of Articles I and IV of the Fundamental Law of Hungary in that the legislature has not regulated the standards and procedures applicable for reconciling the fundamental right to private life with the fundamental right to freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Constitutional Court of Hungary called on Parliament to fulfil its legislative obligation to regulate the standards and procedures for reconciling the fundamental right to private life with the fundamental right to freedom of assembly by 31 December 2016.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Section 2(1) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act), as in force at the material time, provided that exercising the right to assembly covers holding peaceful assembly events, marches and demonstrations, where the participants may freely express their opinions.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Section 2(2) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act), as in force at the material time, provided that the participants of the event are entitled to convey their opinion to those interested.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "Section 2(3) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act), as in force at the material time, provided that exercising the right to assembly shall not result in committing a criminal offence or incitement to committing a criminal offence and shall not result in the violation of the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "Section 6 of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act), as in force at the material time, provided that events organised in public areas shall be notified to the police, or to the Budapest police department if the event is planned to be held in Budapest, at least three days before the intended date of the event.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Section 6 of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act), as in force at the material time, provided that the organiser of the event shall comply with the notification obligation.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Section 8(1) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act), as in force at the material time, provided that if the holding of an event subject to prior notification seriously endangers the proper functioning of the representative bodies or courts, or results in a disproportionate hindrance of the circulation of traffic, the police may prohibit the holding of the event at the place or time indicated in the notification, within forty-eight hours of receipt of the notification by the authority.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Section 8(2) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act), as in force at the material time, provided that the decision of the police shall be announced to the organiser within twenty-four hours in written form.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Section 8(3) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act), as in force at the material time, provided that the general rules of administrative proceedings are applicable to the proceedings of the police.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Section 14(1) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act), as in force at the material time, provided that the police shall disperse the event if the exercise of the right to assembly violates the provisions of section 2(3) of the Assembly Act, if the participants of the event are armed with firearms or explosives or any other object that could be used to endanger life, or an event is held despite a decision prohibiting it.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Section 14(2) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act), as in force at the material time, provided that the dispersal of the event shall be preceded by a warning.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "Section 14(3) of Act no. III of 1989 on the right to assembly (the Assembly Act), as in force at the material time, provided that if the event is dispersed, any participant of the event may initiate proceedings requesting the court to establish that the disbanding of the event was unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["rights_of_others", "prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F011", "F019", "F021", "F023"], "interference": ["F011", "F024", "F025", "F026"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F036", "F039", "F040", "F043", "F056", "F057", "F058", "F064", "F065", "F069", "F075", "F079", "F080", "F082", "F085"], "legitimate_aim": ["F024", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F082"], "necessity": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F011", "F012", "F019", "F021", "F023", "F027", "F028", "F039", "F040"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F009", "F019", "F023"], "interference": ["F011", "F024", "F025", "F026"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F029", "F036", "F043", "F056", "F064", "F079", "F082", "F085"], "legitimate_aim": ["F024", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F082"], "necessity": ["F006", "F008", "F011", "F019", "F023", "F027", "F039"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F006", "F011", "F019", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F036", "F056", "F082", "F085"]}} {"case_name": "case_664", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the location of public events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the time of conduct of public events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions imposed by the authorities on the manner of conduct of public events.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "In application no. 75642/12, the applicants also raised complaints about the lack of domestic remedies against the alleged violations of their freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "In application no. 27036/14, the applicants also raised complaints about the lack of domestic remedies against the alleged violations of their freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F002"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003", "F004"]}} {"case_name": "case_667", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1973.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Lviv.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 17 August 2010 the applicant notified the Lviv City Mayor on behalf of a local human-rights NGO called 'Vartovi zakonu' of its intention to hold a demonstration every Tuesday from 10.30 a.m. to 1 p.m. near the building of the Lviv Regional Prosecutor's Office.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The planned demonstration period announced on 17 August 2010 was between 17 August 2010 and 1 January 2011.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The aim of the demonstration announced on 17 August 2010 was to draw attention to the issue of corruption in the prosecution service.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The number of possible participants in the announced demonstration was declared as up to fifty persons.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "There is no information as to whether any demonstration was held prior to 12 October 2010 pursuant to the announcement of 17 August 2010.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 5 October 2010 the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council lodged a claim with the Lviv Administrative Court seeking to restrict the demonstration announced by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "On 6 October 2010 the Lviv Administrative Court left the claim of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council without consideration on the ground that it had been submitted too late.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 11 October 2010 the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council resubmitted its claim to the Lviv Administrative Court with a request for renewal of the time-limit for lodging the claim.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "On 11 October 2010 the Lviv Administrative Court allowed the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council's request for renewal of the time-limit and accepted the claim for examination.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On Tuesday 12 October 2010, further to his previous announcement of 17 August 2010, the applicant informed the Lviv City Council about the demonstration to be held on that particular day.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 12 October 2010 the applicant organised a peaceful demonstration near the Lviv Regional Prosecutor's Office between 11.30 a.m. and 12.40 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "About twenty-five persons took part in the demonstration on 12 October 2010 near the Lviv Regional Prosecutor's Office.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "During the demonstration on 12 October 2010, the demonstrators were standing on the pavement in front of the building of the Lviv Regional Prosecutor's Office when the police told them that they should remain at a distance of five metres from the building.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The police's instruction to remain five metres from the building of the Lviv Regional Prosecutor's Office would have forced the demonstrators to stand in the road and obstruct the traffic.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "After some discussion with the police during the demonstration on 12 October 2010, the demonstrators crossed the road and stood on a lawn on the opposite side of the street from the Lviv Regional Prosecutor's Office.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The police told the demonstrators that they could not stand on the lawn and should move away, which would have meant standing in the road again and obstructing the traffic, causing temporary traffic-jams.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "Immediately after the events at the demonstration on 12 October 2010, the applicant was called aside by two police officers.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The two police officers grabbed the applicant's arms and took him in the direction of the nearby police station.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "Some of the demonstrators requested the police officers to show them their identification and started filming the incident involving the applicant being taken by the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "After the demonstrators requested identification and started filming, the police officers let the applicant go.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 13 October 2010 the Lviv Regional Administrative Court granted a request by the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council to prohibit the holding of the pre-announced demonstrations by the applicant's NGO 'Vartovi zakonu' as from 19 October 2010.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The decision of the Lviv Regional Administrative Court of 13 October 2010 prohibiting the demonstrations was appealed against.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the applicant, on 13 October 2010 he was invited to the police station on the pretext that he had failed to appear at a court hearing to which he had been summoned.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the applicant, upon his arrival at the Galytskyy District Police Station at about 5 p.m. on 13 October 2010, the police accused the applicant of having committed the administrative offence of malicious disobedience to a lawful order by the police on 12 October 2010.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicant, upon his arrival at the Galytskyy District Police Station at about 5 p.m. on 13 October 2010, the police accused the applicant of having committed the administrative offence of breaching the procedure for organising and holding a demonstration on 12 October 2010.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the applicant, between 10 p.m. and 11 p.m. on 13 October 2010 the police drew up reports on the administrative offences of malicious disobedience to a lawful order by the police and of breaching the procedure for organising and holding a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the applicant, the applicant telephoned his lawyer on 13 October 2010 while at the Galytskyy District Police Station, but the lawyer was not allowed onto the premises of the police station.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the applicant, at 11 p.m. on 13 October 2010 the applicant was placed in a cell at the Galytskyy District Police Station.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the applicant, the applicant remained in the cell without food from 11 p.m. on 13 October 2010 until 3 p.m. on 14 October 2010.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 14 October 2010, before taking the applicant to court, the police drew up anew the reports on the administrative offences of malicious disobedience to a lawful order by the police and of breaching the procedure for organising and holding a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "In the reports drawn up on 14 October 2010, the police referred to provisions of the Code on Administrative Offences and to the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Lviv.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The reports drawn up on 14 October 2010 were signed by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "At 3 p.m. on 14 October 2010 the applicant was taken to the Galytskyy District Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The applicant had no opportunity to study the case-file materials before the court hearing at the Galytskyy District Court on 14 October 2010.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "During the hearing at the Galytskyy District Court on 14 October 2010, the court rejected the applicant's request to be represented by the lawyer of his choosing on the ground that the applicant was a human-rights defender and could defend himself.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "During the hearing at the Galytskyy District Court on 14 October 2010, the court rejected the applicant's request to summon and question witnesses.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "During the hearing at the Galytskyy District Court on 14 October 2010, the court rejected the applicant's request to examine a video made during the events of 12 October 2010.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "By a decision of 14 October 2010, the Galytskyy District Court found the applicant guilty of committing the administrative offence of malicious disobedience to a lawful order by the police.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "By a decision of 14 October 2010, the Galytskyy District Court found the applicant guilty of committing the administrative offence of breaching the procedure for organising and holding a demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Galytskyy District Court noted in its decision of 14 October 2010 that the applicant had held a street march without the permission of the Lviv City Council.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Galytskyy District Court noted in its decision of 14 October 2010 that the applicant had ignored the lawful demands of the police to stop breaching the peace.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Galytskyy District Court noted in its decision of 14 October 2010 that the applicant had refused to follow the police to their station but instead called the participants in the demonstration, who shouted and threatened the officers.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The applicant denied all accusations before the Galytskyy District Court on 14 October 2010.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Having heard the applicant and examined the case-file materials, the Galytskyy District Court concluded that the applicant's testimony was refuted by the written reports of the police officers and the traffic police officers.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Galytskyy District Court noted in its decision of 14 October 2010 that the police reports had been drawn up correctly and therefore had to be taken into account.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Galytskyy District Court sentenced the applicant to three days of administrative detention starting from 6 p.m. on 14 October 2010, with reference to the relevant provisions of the Code on Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "At around 6 p.m. on 17 October 2010 the applicant was released from administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 18 October 2010 the applicant appealed against the Galytskyy District Court's decision of 14 October 2010.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "In his appeal of 18 October 2010, the applicant complained that he had been found guilty even though he had not committed the alleged offences.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "In his appeal of 18 October 2010, the applicant noted that under Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine a demonstration could be held subject to notifying the authorities and any restrictions on holding one could be imposed only by a court, so no permission was required.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "In his appeal of 18 October 2010, the applicant noted that he had notified the Lviv City Council twice about the gathering of 12 October 2010 and that at the time it was held there had been no court decision prohibiting it.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In his appeal of 18 October 2010, the applicant argued that he had organised the gathering of 12 October 2010 lawfully and that the first-instance court's conclusion that he had 'held a meeting without permission of the City Council' had not been based on law as no such permission was required by domestic law.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In his appeal of 18 October 2010, the applicant challenged the police's conclusion that he had notified the authorities about the event of 12 October 2010 only a few hours in advance, claiming that he had already done so on 17 August 2010.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "In his appeal of 18 October 2010, the applicant argued that the requirement of notification two days in advance established by the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Lviv, to which the police referred in their reports on administrative offences, was not based on law.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In his appeal of 18 October 2010, the applicant argued that the Constitutional Court of Ukraine in its decision of 19 April 2001 had decided that the procedure for notification of peaceful assembly had to be a matter for legislative regulation.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "In his appeal of 18 October 2010, the applicant maintained that, in the absence of any lawful restrictions on holding a demonstration, demands by the police to stop such an event could not be considered lawful.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "In his appeal of 18 October 2010, the applicant maintained that the law did not provide for liability for disobeying unlawful demands of police officers.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "In his appeal of 18 October 2010, the applicant complained that the first-instance Galytskyy District Court had violated his right to defend himself by refusing to allow his lawyer to appear in the case on the ground that the applicant was a human-rights defender and therefore able to defend his rights himself.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "In a supplement to his appeal dated 27 October 2010, the applicant complained that his punishment violated Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "In a supplement to his appeal dated 27 October 2010, the applicant complained, referring to Article 6 §§ 1 and 3 (b-d) of the Convention, that his right to defend himself had been violated.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "In a supplement to his appeal dated 27 October 2010, the applicant complained that the first-instance Galytskyy District Court had refused to question the witnesses and to examine a video record of the peaceful demonstration of 12 October 2010.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 27 October 2010 the Lviv Regional Court of Appeal examined the applicant's appeal in the presence of the applicant and his lawyer.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "On 27 October 2010 the Lviv Regional Court of Appeal rejected the applicant's appeal against the Galytskyy District Court's decision of 14 October 2010.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Lviv Regional Court of Appeal summarised the findings of the first-instance Galytskyy District Court and the arguments of the applicant's appeal in its decision of 27 October 2010.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Lviv Regional Court of Appeal noted in its decision of 27 October 2010 that the findings of the Galytskyy District Court as to the applicant's guilt were well-founded and corresponded to the factual circumstances of the case.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The Lviv Regional Court of Appeal noted in its decision of 27 October 2010 that the findings of the Galytskyy District Court were confirmed by the police reports and other explanations and evidence.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "In reply to the applicant's arguments that there had been no corpus delicti in his actions, the Lviv Regional Court of Appeal noted in its decision of 27 October 2010 that those arguments should be disregarded because they were refuted by the body of evidence in the case, without elaborating further on that point.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Lviv Regional Court of Appeal referred in its decision of 27 October 2010 to the relevant provisions of the Code on Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Article 22 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that human and citizens' rights and freedoms affirmed by the Constitution are not exhaustive.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Article 22 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that constitutional rights and freedoms are guaranteed and shall not be abolished.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Article 22 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that the content and scope of existing rights and freedoms shall not be diminished by the enactment of new laws or the amendment of laws that are in force.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that citizens have the right to assemble peacefully without arms and to hold meetings, rallies, marches and demonstrations, after notifying the executive authorities and bodies of local self-government beforehand.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that restrictions on the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly may be established by a court in accordance with the law, in the interests of national security and public order only, for the purpose of preventing disturbances or crimes, protecting the health of the population, or protecting the rights and freedoms of other persons.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "Article 92 of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that human and citizens' rights and freedoms, the guarantees of these rights and freedoms, and the main duties of the citizen are determined exclusively by the laws of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Chapter XV (Transitional Provisions) of the Constitution of Ukraine provides that laws and other normative acts enacted prior to the entry into force of the Constitution of Ukraine shall apply in so far as they do not conflict with the Constitution of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "A. Constitution of Ukraine"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Article 185 of the Code on Administrative Offences provides that malicious disobedience to a lawful order or demand by a police officer who is carrying out his official duties shall be punishable by a fine of between eight and fifteen times the minimum monthly wage, or by correctional labour of between one and two months with a deduction of 20% of earnings, or, in the event that in the particular circumstances of the case and with regard to the offender's character these measures are found to be insufficient, by administrative detention of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code on Administrative Offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "Article 185-1 of the Code on Administrative Offences provides that a breach of the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations shall be punishable by a reprimand or by a fine of between ten and twenty-five times the minimum monthly wage.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code on Administrative Offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "Article 185-1 of the Code on Administrative Offences provides that the same actions committed within a year of the application of administrative penalties or by the organiser of the meeting, rally, street procession or demonstration shall be punishable by a fine of between twenty and one hundred times the minimum monthly wage, or by correctional labour of one to two months with a deduction of 20% of earnings, or by administrative detention of up to fifteen days.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code on Administrative Offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "Article 185-2 of the Code on Administrative Offences provides that the provision by officials of premises, transport, or technical means, or the creating of other conditions for the organisation and holding of meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in violation of the established procedure shall be punishable by a fine of between twenty and one hundred times the minimum monthly wage.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code on Administrative Offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Paragraph 1 of Article 268 of the Code on Administrative Offences provides that a person whose administrative liability is engaged shall be entitled to study the case materials, to give explanations, to present evidence, to make requests, and to have the assistance of a lawyer during the examination of the case.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code on Administrative Offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The right to a lawyer in administrative offence proceedings is guaranteed by Article 271 of the Code on Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code on Administrative Offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "According to Article 294 of the Code on Administrative Offences, a court resolution concerning an administrative offence could be appealed against.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code on Administrative Offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Article 294 of the Code on Administrative Offences provides that a court of appeal shall review the case within the scope of the appeal and is not limited to arguments of the appeal if incorrect application of substantive law or violation of procedural norms has been established during the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code on Administrative Offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Article 294 of the Code on Administrative Offences provides that the court of appeal can examine new pieces of evidence which have not been examined before, if it finds that the failure to present them to the local court was justified or that the local court rejected them without good reason.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "B. Code on Administrative Offences"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR lays down the procedure for seeking and granting permission to organise and hold meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR (the 1988 Decree)"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 provides that an application to hold a meeting, rally, street procession or demonstration shall be submitted to the executive committee of the appropriate local Soviet of people's deputies.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR (the 1988 Decree)"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 provides that an application to hold a meeting, rally, street procession or demonstration shall be submitted in writing no later than ten days before the planned date of the event.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR (the 1988 Decree)"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 provides that the executive committee of the Soviet of people's deputies shall examine the application and notify the representatives (organisers) of its decision no later than five days prior to the date of the event mentioned in the application.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR (the 1988 Decree)"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 provides that the executive committee of the Soviet of people's deputies shall ban a meeting, rally, street procession or demonstration if the goal of the event is contrary to the Constitution of the USSR, the Constitutions of the Republics of the Union or of the autonomous republics, or poses a threat to the public order and safety of citizens.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "C. The Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR (the 1988 Decree)"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "By enacting the USSR Law on approving Decrees of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR amending or supplementing certain USSR legal acts of 28 October 1988, the Supreme Soviet of the USSR approved a number of Decrees of the Presidium, including the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "D. The USSR Law on approving Decrees of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR amending or supplementing certain USSR legal acts (28 October 1988)"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Resolution of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine of 12 September 1991 on temporary application of certain legislative acts of the Soviet Union provides that, before the relevant legislation of Ukraine is enacted, the legislation of the USSR shall be applicable within the territory of Ukraine in respect of issues that have not been regulated by the legislation of Ukraine and in so far as they do not contravene the Constitution and legislation of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "E. The Resolution of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine of 12 September 1991 on temporary application of certain legislative acts of the Soviet Union"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Lviv introduced the procedure for organising peaceful gatherings in the city of Lviv.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Lviv"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "According to the Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004, the freedom of assembly was guaranteed but could be restricted by a court for considerations of public health, prevention of crime and disorder, and protection of the rights of others.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Lviv"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "According to the Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004, to restrict a gathering the Executive Committee could apply to a court.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Lviv"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "Item 7 of the procedure introduced by the Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 provided that notification about a planned gathering had to be given at least two working days prior to the date on which it was to be held.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Lviv"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "Item 14 of the procedure introduced by the Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 specified that gatherings could not be held in the road (except street marches and demonstrations), on lawns and flower beds, or in front of the central entrance (not closer than seven metres) and other entrances of administrative buildings, nor in case of non-compliance with sanitary norms.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Lviv"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Item 16 of the procedure introduced by the Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 specified that holding a gathering in breach of any of the restrictions imposed by item 14 should be considered a breach of the peace and should engage liability under the law.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Lviv"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "Item 15 of the procedure introduced by the Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 provided that the organisers should be responsible for ensuring public order during a gathering.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Lviv"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "Item 20 of the procedure introduced by the Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 provided that the authorities could apply to a court for the purpose of establishing the liability of persons responsible for breaching the procedure.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Lviv"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "On 1 June 2011 the Lviv City Council annulled the decision of 16 April 2004 of its Executive Committee on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Lviv.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Lviv"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "On 1 June 2011 the Lviv City Council ordered a new procedure on the holding of gatherings in the city of Lviv to be drawn up.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "F. Decision of the Executive Committee of the Lviv City Council of 16 April 2004 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the city of Lviv"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "In its decision of 19 April 2001, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine held that the Ministry of the Interior of Ukraine had applied to the Constitutional Court of Ukraine for an official interpretation of the provisions of Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine regarding timely notification to executive authorities or bodies of local self-government of planned meetings, rallies, marches or demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "1. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001 in a case regarding timely notification of peaceful assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "In its decision of 19 April 2001, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine noted that the current legislation of Ukraine did not provide for a specific time-limit within which the executive authorities or bodies of local self-government were to be notified about planned meetings, rallies, marches or demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "1. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001 in a case regarding timely notification of peaceful assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "In its decision of 19 April 2001, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine held that the provisions of the first part of Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine on timely notification to the executive authorities or bodies of local self-government about planned meetings, rallies, marches or demonstrations shall be understood to mean that organisers must inform the authorities in advance, that is, within a reasonable time prior to the date of the planned event.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "1. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001 in a case regarding timely notification of peaceful assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "In its decision of 19 April 2001, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine held that the time-limits for notification should not restrict the right of citizens under Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine, but should serve as a guarantee of this right and provide the relevant executive authorities or bodies of local self-government with an opportunity to take measures to ensure that citizens may freely hold meetings, rallies, marches and demonstrations and to protect public order and the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "1. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001 in a case regarding timely notification of peaceful assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "In its decision of 19 April 2001, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine held that specifying the exact deadlines for timely notification with regard to the particularities of different forms of peaceful assembly, the number of participants, the venue, and the time of the event is a matter for legislative regulation.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "1. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of 19 April 2001 in a case regarding timely notification of peaceful assembly"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "In its review of 1 March 2006 on the practice of the Supreme Court of Ukraine in cases concerning administrative offences under Articles 185 to 185-2 of the Code on Administrative Offences, the Supreme Court noted that no legislation had been enacted in Ukraine establishing a mechanism for fulfilling the right to freedom of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "2. Review of the practice of the Supreme Court in cases concerning administrative offences (Articles 185-185-2 of the Code on Administrative Offences) of 1 March 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "In its review of 1 March 2006, the Supreme Court of Ukraine noted that according to the Resolution of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine of 12 September 1991 No. 1545-XII on temporary application of certain legislative acts of the Soviet Union, the normative acts of the USSR remain in force, including the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "2. Review of the practice of the Supreme Court in cases concerning administrative offences (Articles 185-185-2 of the Code on Administrative Offences) of 1 March 2006"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Information note of April 2012 by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine on a study and summary of the jurisprudence of administrative courts applying the relevant legislation and deciding cases concerning the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly in 2010 and 2011 noted that the legislation of Ukraine does not currently have a special law regulating public relations in the sphere of peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "3. Information note of April 2012 by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine on a study and summary of the jurisprudence of administrative courts applying the relevant legislation and deciding cases concerning the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly (meetings, rallies, marches, demonstrations, etc.) in 2010 and 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Information note of April 2012 by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine noted that Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine, while providing that the executive authorities or bodies of local self-government must be notified in a timely manner that a peaceful gathering is to be held, does not establish specific deadlines for such notification, resulting in inconsistent application of the constitutional norm.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "3. Information note of April 2012 by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine on a study and summary of the jurisprudence of administrative courts applying the relevant legislation and deciding cases concerning the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly (meetings, rallies, marches, demonstrations, etc.) in 2010 and 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Information note of April 2012 by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine noted that judicial practice contained instances of cases restricting the right to peaceful assembly being decided on the basis of the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 No. 9306-XI on the procedure for organisation and holding of meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR, and that this approach was incorrect.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "3. Information note of April 2012 by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine on a study and summary of the jurisprudence of administrative courts applying the relevant legislation and deciding cases concerning the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly (meetings, rallies, marches, demonstrations, etc.) in 2010 and 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Information note of April 2012 by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine noted that the norms of the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 establish the procedure for authorising (registering) peaceful assembly and empower the authorities and bodies of local self-governments to ban such events, whereas the norms of the Constitution of Ukraine provide for a procedure whereby the authorities are notified that a gathering is to be held and provide that only the courts have power to ban a peaceful gathering.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "3. Information note of April 2012 by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine on a study and summary of the jurisprudence of administrative courts applying the relevant legislation and deciding cases concerning the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly (meetings, rallies, marches, demonstrations, etc.) in 2010 and 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Information note of April 2012 by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine concluded that the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 should not be applied by courts when deciding cases concerning the right to peaceful assembly.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "3. Information note of April 2012 by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine on a study and summary of the jurisprudence of administrative courts applying the relevant legislation and deciding cases concerning the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly (meetings, rallies, marches, demonstrations, etc.) in 2010 and 2011"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "In the judgment of the Babushkinsky District Court of Dnipropetrovsk of 30 March 2007 in the case of S. v. the Executive Committee of the Dnipropetrovsk City Council concerning the adoption of regulations on holding mass events in the city of Dnipropetrovsk, the court held that the procedures for exercising the right to freedom of assembly and the procedures and grounds for restricting the right were not regulated by Ukrainian legislation.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "In the judgment of the Babushkinsky District Court of Dnipropetrovsk of 30 March 2007 in the case of S. v. the Executive Committee of the Dnipropetrovsk City Council, the court held that the Dnipropetrovsk City Council had no grounds for adopting the impugned regulation on holding mass events, which would interfere with the rights of citizens.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "In a judgment of 29 November 2011, the Kyiv Administrative Court restricted the right of several NGOs and private persons to hold a demonstration on account, in particular, of their failure to notify the Kyiv City State Administration of their intention ten days in advance.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "In its judgment of 29 November 2011, the Kyiv Administrative Court referred to the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 on the procedure for organising and holding meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The participants in the case before the Kyiv Administrative Court appealed against the judgment of 29 November 2011.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "On 16 May 2012 the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal quashed the judgment of the Kyiv Administrative Court of 29 November 2011.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "In its decision of 16 May 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal noted that the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 conflicted with the Constitution of Ukraine as it required the organisers to seek permission to hold a demonstration and authorised the executive authorities to ban such an event, whereas Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine provided that the authorities should be notified that a demonstration was being planned and empowered only the judicial authorities to place restrictions on the organisation thereof.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "In its decision of 16 May 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal noted that in its decision of 19 April 2001 the Constitutional Court of Ukraine had not referred to the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 as a normative act which should apply in Ukraine to the legal relations under consideration.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "In its decision of 16 May 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal noted that the file contained no documents proving that notification about the demonstration less than 10 days in advance had not allowed the police to ensure public order during the demonstration and that the holding of such an event could create a real risk of riots or crimes or endanger the health of the population and imperil the rights and freedoms of others.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "In its decision of 16 May 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal concluded that the judgment of the Kyiv Administrative Court of 29 November 2011 was incompatible with Article 39 of the Constitution of Ukraine and Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "In a decision of 11 October 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal quashed the judgment of the Kyiv Administrative Court which had restricted the freedom of peaceful assembly in respect of a number of political and non-governmental organisations upon an application by the Kyiv City State Administration.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "In its decision of 11 October 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal noted that the first-instance Kyiv Administrative Court had had regard to the provisions of the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988, whereas since 1996 the question of holding peaceful gatherings had been regulated by the Constitution of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "In its decision of 11 October 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal stated that the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 conflicted with the Constitution of Ukraine as it provided for a procedure for seeking permission to hold a demonstration and concerned the holding of such events in a non-existent country (the USSR), regulated relations between the citizens of the USSR and the executive committees of the Soviets of People's Deputies, and considered demonstrations on the basis of their compatibility with the Constitution of the USSR and the constitutions of the union and the autonomous republics.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "In its decision of 11 October 2012, the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal noted that under the Constitution of Ukraine human rights and freedoms, and the relevant safeguards, could be defined only by the laws of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "According to the Ukrainian Helsinki Human Rights Union, in 2012 the Ukrainian authorities sought to restrict peaceful gatherings in 358 cases.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "According to the Ukrainian Helsinki Human Rights Union, in 2012 the Ukrainian authorities succeeded in restricting peaceful gatherings in approximately 90% of the cases in which they sought to do so.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "G. Domestic case-law", "4. Decisions of administrative courts"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "At the request of a Ukrainian Member of Parliament, the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine sent an information letter dated 26 November 2009 to an NGO in Kyiv.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "H. Information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The text of the information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009 can be found on the official website of the Ukrainian Parliament.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "H. Information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009 noted that the current legislation on the organisation and holding of peaceful demonstrations is not perfect.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "H. Information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009 noted that the organisation and conduct of peaceful demonstrations is regulated by the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR of 28 July 1988 No. 9306 on the organisation and holding of meetings, rallies, street marches and demonstrations in the USSR, which is effective in so far as it does not contradict the Constitution of Ukraine pursuant to paragraph 1 of Chapter XV (Transitional Provisions) of the Constitution of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "H. Information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009 noted that the requirements as to the organisation and holding of peaceful demonstrations, the time-limit for notification to be given to executive or local government bodies, and the documents to be attached to the application for holding the event are currently not regulated by law.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "H. Information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009 stated that only legislative regulation of the procedure for organising and holding peaceful demonstrations would eliminate the negative practices that had arisen due to the inadequacy of the current state of legal regulation.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "H. Information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009 stated that the Ministry of Justice had drafted the Law of Ukraine on the organisation and conduct of peaceful demonstrations, which was submitted by the Government of Ukraine to the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine (registration No. 2450 from 6 May 2008).", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "H. Information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009 stated that the draft Law of Ukraine on the organisation and conduct of peaceful demonstrations was approved by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine on its first reading on 3 June 2009.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "H. Information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "The draft Law of Ukraine on the organisation and conduct of peaceful demonstrations mentioned in the information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009 is currently awaiting its second reading in the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE", "H. Information letter of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 26 November 2009"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007), Section A, provide that legal provisions concerning advance notice should require a notice of intent rather than a request for permission.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007)"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007), Section A, provide that the notification process should not be onerous or bureaucratic.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007)"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007), Section A, provide that the period of notice should not be unnecessarily lengthy but should allow adequate time for the relevant state authorities to plan and prepare for the event and for the completion of an expeditious appeal to a tribunal or court should the legality of any restrictions imposed be challenged.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007)"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007), Section A, provide that if the authorities do not promptly present any objections to a notification, the organizers of a public assembly should be able to proceed with the planned activity in accordance with the terms notified and without restriction.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007)"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007), Section B, paragraph 7, provide that freedom of peaceful assembly should be accorded constitutional protection containing at a minimum a positive statement of both the right and the obligation to safeguard it, and that general constitutional provisions can be abused and afford unduly wide discretion to the authorities.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007)"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007), Section B, paragraph 9, provide that domestic laws regulating freedom of assembly must be consistent with the international instruments ratified by that state and must be interpreted and implemented in conformity with the relevant international and regional jurisprudence.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007)"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007), Section B, paragraph 30, provide that any restrictions imposed must have a formal basis in primary law and that the law itself must be sufficiently precise to enable an individual to assess whether or not his or her conduct would be in breach of the law and to foresee the consequences of such breaches.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007)"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007), Section B, paragraph 91, note that it is common for the regulatory authority to require advance written notice of public assemblies, and that the UN Human Rights Committee has held that a requirement to give notice, while a de facto restriction on freedom of assembly, is compatible with the permitted limitations laid down in Article 21 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007)"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007), Section B, paragraph 91, note that the European Commission on Human Rights in Rassemblement Jurassien (1979) stated that a prior notification procedure is in keeping with the requirements of Article 11(1) of the Convention, if only in order that the authorities may be in a position to ensure the peaceful nature of the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007)"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007), Section B, paragraph 92, provide that the notification process should not be onerous or bureaucratic, and that individual demonstrators should not be required to provide advance notification to the authorities of their intention to demonstrate.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007)"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007), Section B, paragraph 93, provide that the period of notice should not be unnecessarily lengthy (normally no more than a few days) but should allow adequate time for the relevant state authorities to plan and prepare for the event, for the regulatory body to give a prompt official response, and for the completion of an expeditious appeal to a tribunal or court.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007)"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007), Section B, paragraph 94, provide that the official receiving the notice should issue a receipt explicitly confirming that the organizers of the assembly are in compliance with the applicable notice requirements, and that the notice should be communicated immediately to all state organs involved in the regulatory process.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007)"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007), Section B, paragraph 95, provide that legal provisions concerning advance notice should require a notice of intent rather than a request for permission, and that countries where a permit is required are encouraged to amend domestic legislation so as to require notification only.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007)"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "The Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007), Section B, paragraph 96, provide that if the authorities do not respond promptly to a notification, the organizers of a public assembly may proceed with the activities according to the terms notified without restriction, and that even where authorization is required, authorization should be presumed granted if a response is not given within a reasonable time.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "A. Guidelines on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2007)"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "At its 64th plenary session on 21-22 October 2005, the European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission) adopted an opinion interpreting the OSCE/ODIHR guidelines on drafting laws on freedom of assembly with regard to the regulation of public meetings, including the requirement of advance notice of demonstrations in public places.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Opinion of the Venice Commission"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "In its opinion adopted at its 64th plenary session, the Venice Commission stated that establishing a regime of prior notification of peaceful assemblies does not necessarily extend to an infringement of the right, and that such regimes exist in several European countries.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Opinion of the Venice Commission"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "In its opinion adopted at its 64th plenary session, the Venice Commission stated that the need for advance notice generally arises in respect of certain meetings or assemblies, such as when a procession is planned to take place on the highway or a static assembly is planned to take place on a public square, which require the police and other authorities to enable it to occur and not to use powers they may validly have to obstruct the event.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Opinion of the Venice Commission"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "The Venice Commission emphasised that the regime of prior notification must not be such as to frustrate the intention of the organisers to hold a peaceful demonstration, and thus indirectly restrict their rights.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS", "B. Opinion of the Venice Commission"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F012", "F013", "F014"], "interference": ["F040", "F041", "F048", "F065"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F074", "F075", "F076", "F079", "F080", "F087", "F088", "F091", "F093", "F094", "F102", "F109", "F111", "F113", "F114", "F115", "F116", "F117", "F118", "F121", "F122", "F128", "F136"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F013"], "interference": ["F041", "F048"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F074", "F075", "F076", "F079", "F087", "F091", "F093", "F094", "F109", "F111", "F113", "F116", "F128"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F013", "F048", "F041", "F079", "F074", "F075", "F076", "F087", "F091", "F093", "F109", "F113", "F128", "F116"]}} {"case_name": "case_669", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The two cases concern the respondent State's alleged failure to protect the applicants' public rally from homophobic and/or transphobic acts of violence by counter-demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The two cases concern the respondent State's alleged failure to conduct an effective investigation into the incident involving the applicants' public rally.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants relied on Article 3 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants relied on Article 10 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants relied on Article 11 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicants relied on Article 14 of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The names of the applicants and their dates of birth/registration as legal entities are set out in the appendix to the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The thirty-five individual applicants are all Georgian nationals.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The two applicant associations are registered under Georgian law.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The applicant associations (applicants nos. 1 and 17) are Georgian non-governmental organisations set up to promote and protect the rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) people in Georgia.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The individual applicants are either staff members of the applicant associations or members and supporters of the LGBT community.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The sixteen applicants in application no. 73204/13 were represented by three Georgian lawyers: Ms T. Abazadze, Ms N. Jomarjidze and Ms Ts. Ratiani.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The sixteen applicants in application no. 73204/13 were represented by three British lawyers: Mr Ph. Leach, Ms J. Evans and Ms J. Gavron.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The twenty-one applicants in application no. 74959/13 were represented by four Georgian lawyers: Mr L. Asatiani, Ms N. Bolkvadze, Ms T. Abazadze and Ms N. Jomarjidze.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Government were represented by their Agent, Mr L. Meskhoradze, of the Ministry of Justice.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 24 April 2013 the two applicant associations informed the Ministry of the Interior of their intention to hold a peaceful public rally on 17 May 2013 in the centre of Tbilisi to mark the International Day Against Homophobia.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 1 May 2013 the two applicant associations informed the Ministry of the Interior of their intention to hold a peaceful public rally on 17 May 2013 in the centre of Tbilisi to mark the International Day Against Homophobia.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The planned event (the IDAHO event) would take the form of a silent twenty-minute flash mob.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The organisers of the IDAHO event indicated that the event would take place on Rustaveli Avenue, on the grounds of the former Parliament building in Tbilisi.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The organisers of the IDAHO event indicated that some fifty people would be taking part in the event.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "In view of the violence committed by radical groups during a similar event held the previous year (as documented in Identoba and Others v. Georgia, no. 73235/12, §§ 10-19, 12 May 2015), the applicant associations asked the Ministry of the Interior to invest more time and energy in devising an efficient plan to protect the public rally from possible violence.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 9 May 2013 the applicant associations informed the Ministry of the Interior of serious threats posted on the Internet by various identifiable individuals.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The threats posted on the Internet targeted the lives and health of staff members of the two applicant associations.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The threats posted on the Internet were aimed at dissuading the organisers from staging the IDAHO event.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 13 May 2013 reports were published by various media sources that a number of ultra-conservative NGOs and clergymen were planning to hold a counter-demonstration on 17 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The planned counter-demonstration on 17 May 2013 was intended to demand a ban on the 'popularisation and promotion of sexual minorities'.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The counter-demonstration was mainly being organised by G.G., a member of the NGO Former Prisoners for Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The counter-demonstration was mainly being organised by E.M., the President of the Georgian National Front.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The counter-demonstration was mainly being organised by Father J., a prominent clergyman of the Georgian Orthodox Church.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 13 May 2013 G.G. gave official notice to Tbilisi City Hall of the organising committee's intention to hold 'a prayer rally' on Rustaveli Avenue, on the grounds of the former Parliament building.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The location chosen for the 'prayer rally' (Rustaveli Avenue, on the grounds of the former Parliament building) was the same location previously chosen by the applicant associations for holding the IDAHO event.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The notice given to Tbilisi City Hall stated that priests and parishes from various churches in Tbilisi would be participating in the prayer rally.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "A number of interviews with priests were published in various national newspapers in which several clergymen, including Father J., openly and repeatedly stated that the aim of the 'prayer rally' was to prevent the IDAHO event from taking place.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "A number of clearly identifiable individual participants in the forthcoming counter-demonstration intensified a hate speech campaign on social media directed at the two applicant associations' staff members.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Various national newspapers and social media reported at the time that 'thousands of people' were expected to join the 'prayer rally'.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 13 May 2013 senior officials from the Ministry of the Interior held meetings with the two applicant associations organising the IDAHO event.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 15 May 2013 senior officials from the Ministry of the Interior held meetings with the two applicant associations organising the IDAHO event.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "During the meetings, Ministry of the Interior officials made formal assurances that no efforts would be spared to guarantee the safety of all the participants in the IDAHO event.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "It was specified during the meetings that Old Tbilisi police unit no. 7 would be in charge of the security arrangements associated with the IDAHO event.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Ministry of the Interior stated during the meetings that, according to the latest intelligence information, more than 10,000 people were planning to take part in the counter-demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Ministry of the Interior proposed that the applicant associations move the IDAHO event from the grounds of the former Parliament building to Pushkin Square, a few hundred metres away, in order to avoid a direct confrontation with the counter-demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Ministry of the Interior promised to deploy sufficient manpower to create strong police cordons between the two opposing groups at the IDAHO event.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The two applicant associations accepted the Ministry of the Interior's proposal to move the IDAHO event to Pushkin Square.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "On the day of the IDAHO event (17 May 2013), the Ministry of the Interior deployed some 2,000 police officers.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The 2,000 police officers deployed on 17 May 2013 were tasked with creating cordons separating Pushkin Square, where the applicants were to gather, from all the streets leading to the adjacent Rustaveli Avenue, where the 'prayer rally' was to be held.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "A. Prior arrangements"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Clergymen, their parishes and other participants in the 'prayer rally' started gathering outside the former Parliament building on the evening of 16 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "By the early afternoon of 17 May 2013, some 35,000 to 40,000 counter-demonstrators were already gathered outside the former Parliament building.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 17 May 2013, at around 12 noon, participants in the IDAHO event started gathering at Pushkin Square.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The arriving LGBT demonstrators at Pushkin Square could see an enormous and aggressive crowd of counter-demonstrators only a few hundred metres away.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The LGBT demonstrators at Pushkin Square were separated from the counter-demonstrators only by removable metal fences and a thin cordon of unarmed and unequipped police patrol officers.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The arriving LGBT demonstrators started having serious doubts about their safety at Pushkin Square.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The counter-demonstrators were chanting homophobic insults and physical threats at Pushkin Square.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "No riot squads could be seen at Pushkin Square on 17 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Applicants nos. 15, 19, 21-23, 25, 29, 31-33, 35 and 37 (the group of twelve individual applicants) were the first to arrive at Pushkin Square at 12 noon on 17 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The group of twelve individual applicants decided to wait until 12.45 p.m. for all the other participants to join them before starting the flash mob.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The remaining twenty-three individual applicants were, at the time of the group of twelve's arrival at Pushkin Square, outside Pushkin Square — either on the other side of the police cordons, amongst the counter-demonstrators, or elsewhere.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "At some point between 12.30 and 12.40 p.m. on 17 May 2013, a group of clergymen went through the police cordons to meet with senior officials from the Ministry of the Interior, including Deputy Minister G.Z.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The meeting between the clergymen and Ministry of the Interior senior officials took place in Pushkin Square, near the group of twelve individual applicants.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "Video footage recorded by independent journalists captured the negotiations between Ministry of the Interior officials and priests at Pushkin Square.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "During the negotiations, the priests urged, on behalf of the participants in the 'prayer rally', the police not to let the IDAHO event take place, arguing it would cause a clash with the counter-demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "Some of the priests can be heard on video footage repeating that 'people might get killed' during the negotiations with Ministry of the Interior officials.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "A priest identified by the applicants as Father E. can be heard on video footage telling Deputy Minister G.Z. that if the police attempted to protect the participants in the IDAHO event, the clergymen would start civil disobedience and ask the Georgian army to join their side.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Video footage filmed by independent journalists shows the clergymen returning from the meeting with the Ministry of the Interior's senior officials to the counter-demonstrators' side of the police cordon.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Video footage filmed by independent journalists shows the same clergymen leading the crowd to break through the police cordon with no resistance from the police.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "It appears from video footage that the participants in the IDAHO event were still in Pushkin Square when the clergymen and counter-demonstrators started passing through the police cordons.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "A video-recording filmed by journalists shows a number of police officers disassembling cordons and removing metal fences that had been installed to protect the LGBT demonstrators from the counter-demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "A journalist can be heard on video footage asking the police officers 'why are you letting them go through?' as the metal fences were being removed.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Video footage contains scenes of police patrol officers discussing an order from the deputy head of the State Security Agency — a structural unit of the Ministry of the Interior under Deputy Minister G.Z.'s direct supervision at the material time — to remove metal fences separating Pushkin Square from Rustaveli Avenue.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "Video footage shows certain police patrol officers, who were supposed to block the counter-demonstrators by standing in cordons, opening up gaps for the counter-demonstrators and saying things such as 'go!' and 'pass one by one!' as they passed through.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "A video-recording shows a journalist standing in an area adjacent to Pushkin Square asking police patrol officers whether the counter-demonstrators had run over the cordon or whether it had been opened by the police, to which one of the officers replied 'it has been opened.'", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Video footage shows that eventually hundreds of counter-demonstrators, led by clergymen, got through the police cordons and headed towards the group of twelve individual applicants and other participants in the IDAHO event gathered at Pushkin Square.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "As the counter-demonstrators approached the scene of the IDAHO event, their behaviour became increasingly aggressive: their initial marching pace turned into a run, they yelled insults and curses, and shook wooden sticks and iron batons in their hands.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Some of the counter-demonstrators grabbed heavy stones on their way towards the group of twelve individual applicants at Pushkin Square.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Faced with the approaching mob, the group of twelve individual applicants at Pushkin Square retreated by boarding two buses that had apparently been provided by the police in advance for dispersal purposes.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "None of the applicants knew anything about the dispersal plan involving the two buses.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The applicants' efforts to reach the buses were chaotic despite some guidance being offered by the police.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "Some of the applicants heard some of the police officers, who were supposed to be coordinating their removal from the scene, making homophobic jokes and insults during the commotion.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "Video footage filmed by independent journalists captures images of several clergymen running through Pushkin Square in the direction of the two buses and proffering insults, with one of them shaking a footstool in a menacing manner and threatening to kill the participants in the IDAHO event.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "Frenzied counter-demonstrators surrounded and blocked the buses containing the group of twelve individual applicants and other LGBT demonstrators, rocking the vehicles and throwing stones, wooden sticks and footstools at the windscreens.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "After the buses had made their way through the crowd, some of the counter-demonstrators got into their cars and chased the applicants across the city.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "According to the relevant individual applicants who were on the buses, for much of the journey the buses were not accompanied by the police, and the applicants were not aware where the drivers were taking them.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Images of the terrified applicants' faces were filmed by journalists on the buses and broadcast a few hours later on a number of national television channels.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "B. Pushkin Square incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "At around 12.30 p.m. on 17 May 2013, applicants nos. 2-14, 16 and 36 (the group of fifteen individual applicants) were trying to reach the site of the IDAHO event at Pushkin Square via the narrow Vachnadze Street.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "C. Vachnadze Street incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The group of fifteen individual applicants (applicants nos. 2-14, 16 and 36) were suddenly encircled by a large number of participants in the 'prayer rally' on Vachnadze Street.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "C. Vachnadze Street incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "The counter-demonstrators on Vachnadze Street, having identified the applicants as members of the LGBT community, started proffering homophobic insults and threats.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "C. Vachnadze Street incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "The number of unarmed and unequipped police officers at the scene on Vachnadze Street was insignificant in comparison to the mob and, according to the applicants, they were initially reluctant to help.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "C. Vachnadze Street incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "It was only after active intervention by a staff member of the local United Nations office in Tbilisi that the police patrol officers near Vachnadze Street were eventually deployed.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "C. Vachnadze Street incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "Police patrol officers near Vachnadze Street managed to remove the group of fifteen individual applicants from the mob by sneaking them into a house situated on the street and guarding its doors until a police minibus arrived.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "C. Vachnadze Street incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Once the trapped activists boarded the police minibus, the counter-demonstrators, yelling 'stone them all!' and 'kill them all!', surrounded it and broke almost all the windows and the front windscreen with iron batons and stones in an attempt to pull the passengers out.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "C. Vachnadze Street incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "After a few minutes of commotion, the driver of the police minibus managed to get through the mob on Vachnadze Street.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "C. Vachnadze Street incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "As later documented in medical records, all fifteen individual applicants (applicants nos. 2-14, 16 and 36) suffered severe stress on account of the assault on them on Vachnadze Street.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "C. Vachnadze Street incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "Applicant no. 12 also had concussion from a stone thrown by the mob which had hit her in the head during the Vachnadze Street incident.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "C. Vachnadze Street incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "Several of the police officers who took part in the dispersal of the relevant individual applicants on Vachnadze Street also received physical injuries as a result of the counter-demonstrators' aggressive actions.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "C. Vachnadze Street incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "In the late afternoon of 17 May 2013, applicant no. 23, one of the twelve individual applicants who had been assaulted at Pushkin Square and removed from the scene by the police, returned to the city centre in an attempt to find out the whereabouts of some of his missing friends and colleagues.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "Applicant no. 23 hoped that he would not be identified as an LGBT activist when he returned to the city centre in the late afternoon of 17 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "Images of applicant no. 23 fleeing Pushkin Square on a bus had already been broadcast by journalists on various television channels before he returned to the city centre.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "A group of counter-demonstrators, a dozen or so people still on Rustaveli Avenue near Pushkin Square, recognised applicant no. 23 on the street in the late afternoon of 17 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The counter-demonstrators encircled applicant no. 23 in the middle of Rustaveli Avenue and started punching and kicking him.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "Applicant no. 23 managed to run away from the attackers and found shelter in a supermarket on Rustaveli Avenue.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The attackers followed applicant no. 23 inside the supermarket but failed to find him.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "The attackers decided to block all the exits of the supermarket, hoping to eventually capture applicant no. 23.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "After some time and apparently a telephone call made by the supermarket staff, approximately ten police officers arrived at the supermarket.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "After finding applicant no. 23 in the basement of the supermarket, the police officers told him that, given that aggressive people were besieging the store, they could not ensure his safety.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The police officers suggested to applicant no. 23 that he shave off his beard and dress in a police uniform so that he could escape in disguise, and he agreed.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The police officers started shaving applicant no. 23's beard, but the process took more than an hour.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The beard-shaving process was filmed by the police officers on a mobile telephone.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "During the beard-shaving process, the police officers made homophobic remarks and asked applicant no. 23 questions such as 'whether or not he was gay' and 'whether he had ever had sex with a woman'.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "After his beard had been shaved off and he had dressed as a police patrol officer, applicant no. 23 was finally able to leave the supermarket.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "D. Rustaveli Avenue incident"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Applicants nos. 18, 20, 24, 26-28, 30 and 34 (the group of eight individual applicants) had remained on the counter-demonstrators' side of the police cordon before the commotion erupted at Pushkin Square.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "E. As regards the remaining applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "The group of eight individual applicants (applicants nos. 18, 20, 24, 26-28, 30 and 34) managed to mingle with the counter-demonstrators and flee the scene on their own.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "E. As regards the remaining applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The group of eight individual applicants were not identified by the counter-demonstrators as participants in the IDAHO event.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "E. As regards the remaining applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "No description of any type of alleged ill-treatment against the group of eight individual applicants was reported.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATION OF 17 MAY 2013", "E. As regards the remaining applicants"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "On 17 May 2013 the Ministry of the Interior launched of its own motion a general inquiry into the acts of violence committed during the clash between the participants in the IDAHO event and those in the 'prayer rally'.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "Old Tbilisi Police unit no. 7 was placed in charge of the general inquiry into the acts of violence committed during the clash on 17 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The general inquiry was conducted under Article 161 § 1 of the Criminal Code of Georgia — interference with the exercise of the right to freedom of assembly using violence.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "On 9 July 2013 the general inquiry launched on 17 May 2013 was split into two separate criminal investigations.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "One of the two separate criminal investigations culminated on 23 October 2015 with the Tbilisi City Court's acquittal of the accused.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "On 25 July 2013 the two applicant associations and thirty-three of the individual applicants (not applicants nos. 20 and 24) asked the Ministry of the Interior to identify and prosecute the individuals responsible for the violence committed against them during the IDAHO event.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "On 20 September 2013 the two applicant associations and thirty-three of the individual applicants (not applicants nos. 20 and 24) asked the Ministry of the Interior to identify and prosecute the individuals responsible for the violence committed against them during the IDAHO event.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The complainants enclosed a copy of the video footage concerning the incidents at Pushkin Square with their requests to the Ministry of the Interior.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "The complainants requested the opening of a separate criminal investigation against the officials of the Ministry of the Interior who had been responsible for letting the counter-demonstrators pass through the police cordons and otherwise conniving in the latter's illegal actions.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "No response was given by the Ministry of the Interior to the complainants' requests of 25 July and 20 September 2013.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "On unspecified dates in October 2013, applicant no. 23 was interviewed by investigators from Old Tbilisi police unit no. 7 in relation to the incident on Rustaveli Avenue.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "On unspecified dates in October 2013, applicant no. 36 was interviewed by investigators from Old Tbilisi police unit no. 7 in relation to the incident on Vachnadze Street.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "On 6 November 2013 applicants nos. 23 and 36 enquired with the Ministry of the Interior whether any progress had been made in the investigation and whether they had been granted victim status.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "On 6 November 2013 applicant no. 23 filed a criminal complaint with Old Tbilisi police unit no. 7 in which he specified the name of one of the alleged assailants of the attack on him on Rustaveli Avenue, providing the investigators with photographs and other contact details.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "In his criminal complaint of 6 November 2013, applicant no. 23 asked investigators to identify the police officers whom he had accused of degrading treatment during the beard-shaving incident, providing all the details of the insults to which he was allegedly subjected.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "It appears from subsequent developments in the criminal proceedings that the police never followed up on the details provided by applicant no. 23 in his criminal complaint of 6 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "On 6 November 2013 both applicant associations and all the individual applicants enquired with the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office about the progress of the investigation and whether they had been granted victim status.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "On 27 December 2013 the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office responded that there were no signs of illegality in the actions of the police, who had duly discharged their duties during the demonstration by preventing grave consequences which could otherwise have occurred given the disproportionately high number of counter-demonstrators.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "On 27 December 2013 the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office updated the applicants on the developments of the general inquiry launched by the Ministry of the Interior on 17 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "Following the opening of the general inquiry by the Ministry of the Interior, four counter-demonstrators were sanctioned for disorderly conduct under Article 166 of the Code of Administrative Offences of Georgia — a minor breach of public order — and fined 100 Georgian laris (approximately 45 euros) each.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "By December 2013, criminal proceedings under Article 161 of the Criminal Code of Georgia — unlawful interference with the exercise of the right to freedom of assembly using violence, threat of violence or abusing official capacity — were pending before a trial court against four other counter-demonstrators, including a clergyman.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "In April 2014, all the applicants, with the exception of applicants nos. 23 and 36, were questioned as witnesses by investigators of Old Tbilisi police unit no. 7 in relation to the incident of 17 May 2013 for the first time.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "In October 2015, investigators of Old Tbilisi police unit no. 7 questioned, as witnesses, nine of its officers who had been personally involved in the security arrangements during the IDAHO event on 17 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "On 23 October 2015 the Tbilisi City Court acquitted the four accused against whom charges had been pending under Article 161 of the Criminal Code of Georgia.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court stated that the investigation had failed to secure any evidence that would reliably prove the link between the violent dispersal of the IDAHO event and the actions of the accused on 17 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court identified a shortcoming in the investigation consisting of the investigators' failure to properly examine the relevant pieces of video footage of the dispersal, which the court considered crucial evidence that could have allowed for the proper identification of at least some of the perpetrators of the violent attacks.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "The Tbilisi City Court identified a further shortcoming in the investigation consisting of the failure to commission a forensic examination of the buses that had been damaged by the mob during the dispersal process.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "According to the material available in the case file before the Court, the second set of criminal proceedings conducted in relation to the violent clashes during the IDAHO event is still pending.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "None of the applicants, except applicant no. 23, were granted victim status in the criminal proceedings related to the IDAHO event.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "It is unknown whether there have been any other developments in the second set of criminal proceedings related to the IDAHO event.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "According to applicant no. 17, one of the two applicant associations, there were twelve documented cases of physical aggression in the immediate aftermath of 17 May 2013 against people unrelated to the IDAHO event solely on the grounds of actual or perceived sexual orientation and gender identity.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PROLIFERATION OF HATE CRIMES AFTER 17 MAY 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "According to applicant no. 17, one of the two applicant associations, there were seventeen documented cases of hate speech in the immediate aftermath of 17 May 2013 against people unrelated to the IDAHO event solely on the grounds of actual or perceived sexual orientation and gender identity.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PROLIFERATION OF HATE CRIMES AFTER 17 MAY 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "The relevant victims of the post-17 May 2013 incidents decided not to file criminal complaints with the law-enforcement authorities for lack of trust in the system and for fear of publicity and reprisal.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. PROLIFERATION OF HATE CRIMES AFTER 17 MAY 2013"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "The relevant domestic law and international material concerning the situation of the LGBT community in Georgia is comprehensively summarised in paragraphs 29-39 of the Court's judgment in the case of Identoba and Others v. Georgia, no. 73235/12, 12 May 2015.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F048", "F071", "F072", "F074", "F084", "F064", "F066"], "interference": ["F001", "F064", "F066", "F071", "F074", "F084"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F040", "F047", "F050", "F053", "F074", "F075", "F021", "F022", "F038", "F064", "F066", "F068", "F069", "F070", "F077", "F107"], "positive_obligation": ["F040", "F047", "F050", "F053", "F064", "F066", "F068", "F069", "F070", "F074", "F075", "F077", "F107"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F016", "F018", "F048", "F071"], "interference": ["F001", "F064", "F071"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F040", "F047", "F050", "F053", "F074", "F075"], "positive_obligation": ["F040", "F047", "F050", "F053", "F064", "F066", "F068", "F074", "F075"]}, "list3": ["F016", "F018", "F040", "F047", "F050", "F053", "F064", "F066", "F074", "F075"]}} {"case_name": "case_670", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1961.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1954.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Both applicants live in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 2 April 2011 the first applicant attended an unauthorised opposition demonstration held at Fountains Square in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 2 April 2011 the second applicant attended an unauthorised opposition demonstration held at Fountains Square in Baku.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The demonstration held at Fountains Square on 2 April 2011 was intended to be peaceful.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The demonstration held at Fountains Square on 2 April 2011 was conducted in a peaceful manner.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The participants of the demonstration held at Fountains Square on 2 April 2011 were demanding free and fair elections.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The participants of the demonstration held at Fountains Square on 2 April 2011 were demanding democratic reforms.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The participants of the demonstration held at Fountains Square on 2 April 2011 were demanding freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The participants of the demonstration held at Fountains Square on 2 April 2011 were demanding the release of people arrested during some previous demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Background information"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The first applicant was the Deputy Chairman of the Musavat Party.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The first applicant worked as a columnist for the Yeni Musavat newspaper.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "Upon arriving at Fountains Square at around 3 p.m. on 2 April 2011, the first applicant was arrested by police officers.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "After his arrest, the first applicant was taken to the Nasimi district police office.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The first applicant was taken to the Nasimi district police office together with other participants in the demonstration, including M.H. and N.S.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "After his arrival at the Nasimi district police office, the first applicant was placed in the exercise yard of the temporary detention centre of the Nasimi district police office.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The first applicant was placed in the exercise yard of the temporary detention centre of the Nasimi district police office together with other people who had been arrested, including M.H. and N.S.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The first applicant was allegedly beaten by S.N., who was the Deputy Head of the Nasimi district police office.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The first applicant was allegedly beaten by a police officer called J.A.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The first applicant was allegedly beaten by a person wearing plain clothes whom the first applicant did not know.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "According to the first applicant, S.N. (Deputy Head of the Nasimi district police office) swore at the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the first applicant, S.N. (Deputy Head of the Nasimi district police office) kicked the first applicant in his abdominal area.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "According to the first applicant, S.N. (Deputy Head of the Nasimi district police office) punched the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the first applicant, after S.N. (Deputy Head of the Nasimi district police office) kicked him in his testicles, the first applicant lost consciousness owing to the severe pain.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the first applicant, despite his requests, he was not provided with the requisite medical assistance while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The Government maintained that the first applicant had not been subjected to torture or inhuman or degrading treatment in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(a) The first applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the first applicant, at around midnight on the day of his arrest (2 April 2011) he was taken to the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the Government, the first applicant was taken to the Nasimi District Court at around 5 p.m. on 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The first applicant stated before the Nasimi District Court that he was not guilty of disobeying the lawful order of a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The first applicant did not have any lawyer at the court hearing before the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The first applicant insisted on being allowed to have a lawyer of his own choice at the court hearing before the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The first applicant requested to invite witnesses to testify on his behalf at the court hearing before the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The judge of the Nasimi District Court disregarded the first applicant's requests to have a lawyer of his own choice and to invite witnesses to testify on his behalf.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The hearing before the Nasimi District Court was brief.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The Nasimi District Court found that the first applicant had failed to stop participating in an unauthorised demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The Nasimi District Court convicted the first applicant under Article 310.1 (failure to comply with a lawful order of a police officer) of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The Nasimi District Court sentenced the first applicant to eight days' administrative detention.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The Nasimi District Court relied on the testimony of police officer A.E., who testified that the first applicant had been attempting to hold an unauthorised demonstration and had continued his actions, disobeying a request to stop participating in the unlawful demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Nasimi District Court relied on the testimony of police officer E.S., who testified that the first applicant had been attempting to hold an unauthorised demonstration and had continued his actions, disobeying a request to stop participating in the unlawful demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "During the court hearing on 2 April 2011 before the Nasimi District Court, the first applicant complained that on that day he had been beaten at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "During the court hearing on 2 April 2011 before the Nasimi District Court, the first applicant asked the court to facilitate the provision of the requisite medical assistance, but his request was ignored.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 4 April 2011 the first applicant lodged an appeal with the Baku Court of Appeal.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "In his appeal to the Baku Court of Appeal, the first applicant argued that his arrest had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "In his appeal to the Baku Court of Appeal, the first applicant argued that his conviction had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "In his appeal to the Baku Court of Appeal, the first applicant argued that the hearing before the Nasimi District Court had not been fair, in particular that he had not been allowed to have a lawyer of his own choice.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "In his appeal to the Baku Court of Appeal, the first applicant argued that his procedural application to call witnesses to testify on his behalf had been dismissed by the Nasimi District Court.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "In his appeal to the Baku Court of Appeal, the first applicant complained of ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In his appeal to the Baku Court of Appeal, the first applicant stated that he still felt unwell and had not received the requisite medical assistance.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "On 8 April 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the first applicant's appeal.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal held that the first applicant had had a State-appointed lawyer at the first-instance court (Nasimi District Court).", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Baku Court of Appeal held that the first applicant's ill-treatment claims had not been proved.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(b) Administrative court proceedings against the first applicant"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "On 6 April 2011 the first applicant lodged a complaint with the Nasimi District Court under the procedure for judicial review of prosecuting authorities' actions or decisions.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "In his complaint to the Nasimi District Court, the first applicant relied on Articles 3, 5, 6, 11, 13 and 14 of the Convention and complained regarding his ill-treatment on 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In his complaint to the Nasimi District Court, the first applicant complained regarding the unfairness of his conviction.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "In his complaint to the Nasimi District Court, the first applicant complained regarding the violation of his freedom of assembly.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "In his complaint to the Nasimi District Court, the first applicant complained regarding discrimination against him on the basis of his political views.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "By a decision of 12 April 2011, the Nasimi District Court refused to admit the first applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "By a decision of 12 April 2011, the Nasimi District Court sent the first applicant's complaint to the Nasimi district prosecutor's office, claiming that the latter had the authority to consider it.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On an unspecified date in April 2011 the first applicant applied to the Baku prosecutor's office, requesting that a criminal investigation into the matter of his alleged ill-treatment be instituted.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "According to a forensic report dated 15 April 2011, there was an abrasion on the first applicant's left calf caused by a blunt object.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "According to the forensic report dated 15 April 2011, the abrasion on the first applicant's left calf could have been inflicted on 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "By a decision of 28 April 2011, the Nasimi district prosecutor's office refused to open a criminal case regarding the first applicant's alleged ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Nasimi district prosecutor's office refused to open a criminal case on the grounds that the first applicant's beating by S.N. (Deputy Head of the Nasimi district police office) had not been proved.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Nasimi district prosecutor's office mainly relied on the findings of an inquiry conducted by the Nasimi district prosecutor's office into a similar complaint of ill-treatment from M.H., who had been detained with the first applicant on 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "Within the framework of the investigation into M.H.'s complaint, the first applicant, when questioned as a witness, gave testimony about being ill-treated by S.N. and other officers while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Within the framework of the investigation into M.H.'s complaint, M.H. gave testimony about being ill-treated by S.N. and other officers while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "Within the framework of the investigation into M.H.'s complaint, N.S., who had been detained with the first applicant on 2 April 2011, gave testimony about being ill-treated by S.N. and other officers while in police custody.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "S.N. (Deputy Head of the Nasimi district police office) denied any involvement in the first applicant's case, stating that he had not been at the Nasimi district police office at the material time.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "Police officer V.M. stated that the first applicant had not been detained in the temporary detention facility and had not been beaten.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "Police officer M.R. stated that the first applicant had not been detained in the temporary detention facility and had not been beaten.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "Police officer E.S. stated that the first applicant had not been detained in the temporary detention facility and had not been beaten.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Police officer A.E. stated that the first applicant had not been detained in the temporary detention facility and had not been beaten.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Police officer E.S. added that the injury on the first applicant's leg might have been caused during his arrest, when he had resisted being put in the police car.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "In an appeal of 31 May 2011 filed with the Nasimi District Court against the decision to refuse to open a criminal case, the first applicant reiterated his previous complaints.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "In his appeal of 31 May 2011, the first applicant pointed out that his forensic examination had taken place so long after the event that most of the injuries on his body had disappeared.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "In his appeal of 31 May 2011, the first applicant pointed out that the Nasimi district prosecutor's office had not identified the precise circumstances leading to his injury, in particular the place and time that his injuries had been inflicted.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "In his appeal of 31 May 2011, the first applicant pointed out that he had not been called to testify, but his witness statement in M.H.'s case had been used instead, and no separate investigation into his complaint had been conducted.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "On 21 June 2011 the Nasimi District Court held that the Nasimi district prosecutor's office's decision of 28 April 2011 to refuse to open a criminal case had been lawful.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The Nasimi District Court stated that the first applicant's complaint had been added to the investigation into M.H.'s similar complaint stemming from the same facts.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The Nasimi District Court stated that the relevant investigative actions had also been carried out in respect of the first applicant.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "By a judgment of 14 July 2011, the Baku Court of Appeal dismissed the first applicant's appeal of 30 June 2011.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "By a judgment of 14 July 2011, the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the Nasimi District Court's decision of 21 June 2011.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "1. The first applicant", "(c) Remedies used by the first applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "The second applicant was a member of the Popular Front Party of Azerbaijan.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(a) The second applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "At around 2 p.m. on 2 April 2011, while the second applicant was chanting during the demonstration at Fountains Square, four police officers approached him and twisted his arms behind his back in order to put him in a police car.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(a) The second applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "S.N. (Deputy Head of the Nasimi district police office) allegedly knew the second applicant from previous demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(a) The second applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "S.N. (Deputy Head of the Nasimi district police office) insulted the second applicant and twisted his arm even more, saying to the police officers, \"You should not twist [his arms], but break them, like this\".", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(a) The second applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "In response to S.N.'s twisting of his arm, the second applicant shouted out because of the pain.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(a) The second applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "Under S.N.'s orders, police officers beat the second applicant with truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(a) The second applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "The second applicant lost consciousness and lay on the ground for several minutes after being beaten with truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(a) The second applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "After the second applicant regained consciousness, the officers dragged him to a police car and took him to the Sabail district police office.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(a) The second applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "While in police custody at the Sabail district police office, the second applicant requested a medical examination and assistance, but his request was refused.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(a) The second applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The second applicant was reprimanded for participating in a public assembly under Article 298 (violation of the rules on holding public assemblies) of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(a) The second applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "The second applicant was released at around 5 p.m. on 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(a) The second applicant's alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "On 2 April 2011 the second applicant complained to the Sabail district prosecutor's office that he had been beaten and insulted during his arrest as a result of being an opposition member.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "On 2 April 2011 the second applicant requested that criminal proceedings be instituted by the Sabail district prosecutor's office.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "A forensic report dated 4 April 2011 stated that the second applicant had a bruise on his left arm.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The forensic report dated 4 April 2011 stated that the bruise on the second applicant's left arm could have been caused on 2 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The second applicant sought medical assistance at a medical centre, which provided him with outpatient treatment.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "According to the second applicant's medical records of 5 April 2011, issued by the medical centre, the second applicant had contusion of the soft tissues of his left upper arm and thorax.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "According to the second applicant's medical records of 5 April 2011, the second applicant had thoracic bruising.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "According to the second applicant's medical records of 5 April 2011, the second applicant had haemarthrosis of his right elbow joint.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "The second applicant was prescribed outpatient treatment, including a sling for his left upper arm and medicine.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The medical records of 5 April 2011 stated that the second applicant was experiencing chest pain while breathing.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "The medical records of 5 April 2011 stated that the second applicant had a haematoma and bruising on his upper arm, and that his upper arm's functions were limited.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "The second applicant submitted the medical records of 5 April 2011 to the Sabail district prosecutor's office.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The second applicant submitted to the Sabail district prosecutor's office photos of him taken during the demonstration, which had been published in the 24-25 April 2011 issue of the Azadlig newspaper, and in which S.N. (Deputy Head of the Nasimi district police office) and other police officers could be seen twisting his arm.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "The Sabail district prosecutor's office questioned four police officers who had taken part in the second applicant's arrest.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "S.N. (Deputy Head of the Nasimi district police office) denied the ill-treatment allegations against the second applicant, stating that he had not twisted the second applicant's arms.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Police officer A.R. claimed that he had not used physical force against the second applicant during his arrest, and that S.N. had not twisted the second applicant's arms.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Police officer V.S. claimed that he had not used physical force against the second applicant during his arrest, and that S.N. had not twisted the second applicant's arms.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Police officer A.A. claimed that he had not used physical force against the second applicant during his arrest, and that S.N. had not twisted the second applicant's arms.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "Police officer A.A. mentioned that the injury to the second applicant could have been inflicted when the second applicant had resisted the police by pushing them and hitting a police car with his hands.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "By a decision of 5 May 2011, the Sabail district prosecutor's office refused to open a criminal case regarding the second applicant's alleged ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Sabail district prosecutor's office found that there was no evidence that the second applicant had been beaten by police during his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "The Sabail district prosecutor's office relied mainly on the statements of the police officers in refusing to open a criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "The Sabail district prosecutor's office held that the bruise on the second applicant's arm mentioned in the forensic report had been caused when the second applicant had demonstrated resistance to the police.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "On 3 June 2016 the second applicant lodged a criminal complaint with the Sabail District Court against the Sabail district prosecutor's office's refusal to open a criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "In his complaint to the Sabail District Court, the second applicant complained that the Sabail district prosecutor's office had failed to conduct an effective investigation into his ill-treatment complaints.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "In his complaint to the Sabail District Court, the second applicant pointed out that the Sabail district prosecutor's office had relied on the testimonies of witnesses who had denied that S.N. had twisted his arms, while the photos he had submitted proved the contrary.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "In his complaint to the Sabail District Court, the second applicant pointed out that the decision to refuse to open a criminal case was silent as to his other injuries confirmed by the medical records of 5 April 2011.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "On 13 June 2011 the Nasimi District Court dismissed the second applicant's complaint, finding the investigator's decision to refuse to open a criminal case lawful.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The Nasimi District Court's decision of 13 June 2011 was silent as to the second applicant's specific complaints.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "In an appeal of 16 June 2011, the second applicant reiterated his previous complaints regarding his alleged ill-treatment.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "On 24 June 2011 the Baku Court of Appeal upheld the Nasimi District Court's decision of 13 June 2011 as lawful.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicants' alleged ill-treatment and subsequent proceedings", "2. The second applicant", "(b) Remedies used by the second applicant in relation to the alleged ill-treatment"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "On 8 August 2014 criminal proceedings were instituted against Mr I. Aliyev, who represented the second applicant before the Court.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the second applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "On 8 August 2014 the investigating authorities seized a large number of documents from Mr I. Aliyev's office, including all the case files relating to the ongoing proceedings before the Court.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the second applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "On 9 August 2014 the investigating authorities seized a large number of documents from Mr I. Aliyev's office, including all the case files relating to the ongoing proceedings before the Court.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the second applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "The seizure of documents from Mr I. Aliyev's office is referenced in the case of Aliyev v. Azerbaijan (nos. 68762/14 and 71200/14, 20 September 2018).", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the second applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The case file relating to the present application was seized in its entirety from Mr I. Aliyev's office on 8 and 9 August 2014.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the second applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "On 25 October 2014 the investigating authorities returned to Mr I. Aliyev's lawyer a number of the case files concerning the applications lodged before the Court, including the file relating to the present application.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Seizure of the second applicant's case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "The relevant domestic law concerning the prohibition of ill-treatment is summarised in the case of Mustafa Hajili v. Azerbaijan (no. 42119/12, paragraphs 26-28, 24 November 2016).", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "The relevant domestic law concerning administrative proceedings and freedom of assembly is summarised in the case of Gafgaz Mammadov v. Azerbaijan (no. 60259/11, paragraphs 27-39, 15 October 2015).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The relevant domestic law concerning administrative proceedings and freedom of assembly is summarised in the case of Huseynli and Others v. Azerbaijan (nos. 67360/11 and 2 others, paragraphs 56-66, 11 February 2016).", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F006", "F007", "F036", "F037", "F044", "F045"], "interference": ["F014", "F036", "F037", "F038", "F050"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F014", "F037", "F038", "F050"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F006", "F007", "F036", "F037"], "interference": ["F014", "F037", "F038", "F050"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F014", "F037", "F038"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F004", "F006", "F007", "F014", "F037", "F038", "F050"]}} {"case_name": "case_671", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "All applicants except the fourth applicant raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_674", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1991.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the applicant was arrested during the dispersal of a political rally at Bolotnaya Square in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant was found guilty of failure to obey lawful police orders, an offence under Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant was subsequently charged with participation in mass disorder, a criminal offence provided for by Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The applicant was subsequently charged with having committed violent acts against police officers, a criminal offence provided for by Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant was detained and tried on the charges of participation in mass disorder and violent acts against police officers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant was convicted to a prison term of two years and three months.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the assembly at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 are set out in more detail in the judgment Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 7-65, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "On 23 April 2012 five individuals (Mr I. Bakirov, Mr S. Davidis, Ms Y. Lukyanova, Ms N. Mityushkina and Mr S. Udaltsov) submitted notice of a public demonstration to the mayor of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The aim of the demonstration notified on 23 April 2012 was to protest against abuses and falsifications in the course of the elections to the State Duma and of the President of the Russian Federation, and to demand fair elections, respect for human rights, the rule of law and the international obligations of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 3 May 2012 the Moscow Department of Regional Security approved the route of the demonstration from Kaluzhskaya Square, down Bolshaya Yakimanka Street and Bolshaya Polyanka Street, followed by a meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The Moscow Department of Regional Security noted on 3 May 2012 that the organisers had provided a detailed plan of the proposed events.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The march approved on 3 May 2012 was to begin at 4 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The meeting approved on 3 May 2012 had to finish by 7.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The number of participants for the demonstration approved on 3 May 2012 was indicated as 5,000.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "On 4 May 2012 the First Deputy Head of the Moscow Department of Regional Security held a working meeting with the organisers of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square to discuss security issues.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "At the working meeting on 4 May 2012, the organisers and the authorities agreed that the assembly layout and the security arrangements would be identical to the previous public event organised by the same group of opposition activists on 4 February 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "At the public event on 4 February 2012, the venue of the meeting had included the park at Bolotnaya Square and the Bolotnaya embankment.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 5 May 2012 the Tsentralnyy District Prosecutor's Office of Moscow issued a warning to Mr S. Davidis against exceeding the notified number of participants and against erecting camping tents at the meeting venue.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 5 May 2012 the Tsentralnyy District Prosecutor's Office of Moscow issued a warning to Mr S. Udaltsov against exceeding the notified number of participants and against erecting camping tents at the meeting venue.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The intention to erect camping tents at the meeting venue was allegedly expressed by the organisers at the working meeting on 4 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 5 May 2012 the Moscow Department of the Interior published on its website official information about the forthcoming demonstration on 6 May 2012, including a map.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The map published by the Moscow Department of the Interior on 5 May 2012 indicated the route of the march, the traffic restrictions and an access plan to Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The map published by the Moscow Department of the Interior on 5 May 2012 delineated the area allotted to the meeting, which included the park at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The map published by the Moscow Department of the Interior on 5 May 2012 marked access to the meeting through the park at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "On 5 May 2012 the Police Chief of the Moscow Department of the Interior adopted a plan for safeguarding public order in Moscow on 6 May 2012 (the security plan).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The security plan provided for security measures in Moscow city centre in view of the forthcoming authorised demonstration at Bolotnaya Square and anticipated attempts by other opposition groups to hold unauthorised public gatherings.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The security plan set up operational headquarters to implement the security measures.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The police units assigned to police the march and the meeting on 6 May 2012 counted 2,400 riot police officers, of which 1,158 were on duty at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The police officers assigned to the demonstration on 6 May 2012 were instructed to search the demonstrators to prevent them from taking tents to the site of the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The police officers assigned to the demonstration on 6 May 2012 were instructed to obstruct access to Bolshoy Kamenyy bridge, diverting the marchers to Bolotnaya embankment, the place of the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The security plan required that the adjacent park at Bolotnaya Square be cordoned off.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "At about 1.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the organisers were allowed access to the meeting venue to set up their stage and sound equipment.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the police searched the vehicles delivering the stage and sound equipment and seized three tents found amid the gear.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the police arrested several people for bringing tents to the meeting venue.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "At the beginning of the march on 6 May 2012, the organisers signed an undertaking to ensure public order during the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "At the beginning of the march on 6 May 2012, the organisers gave assurances to the police that the limits on the place and time allocated for the assembly would be respected and that no tents would be placed on Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The march on 6 May 2012 began at 4.30 p.m. at Kaluzhskaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The march on 6 May 2012 went down Yakimanka Street peacefully and without disruption.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The turnout at the march on 6 May 2012 exceeded expectations, but there is no consensus as to the exact numbers.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The official estimate of participants at the march on 6 May 2012 was 8,000.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The organisers considered that there were about 25,000 participants at the march on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The media reported different numbers of participants at the march on 6 May 2012, some significantly exceeding the official and organisers' estimates.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "At about 5 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the march approached Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The leaders of the march found that the layout of the meeting and the placement of the police cordon at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 did not correspond to what they had anticipated.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "Unlike on 4 February 2012, the park at Bolotnaya Square was excluded from the meeting venue on 6 May 2012, which was limited to Bolotnaya embankment.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "Faced with the police cordon and unable to access the park at Bolotnaya Square, the leaders of the march — Mr S. Udaltsov, Mr A. Navalnyy, Mr B. Nemtsov and Mr I. Yashin — stopped and demanded that the police open access to the park.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The cordon officers at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 did not enter into any discussion with the protest leaders.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "No senior police officer was delegated to negotiate with the protest leaders at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "At 5.16 p.m. on 6 May 2012, after about fifteen minutes of attempting to engage with the cordon officers, Mr S. Udaltsov, Mr A. Navalnyy, Mr B. Nemtsov and Mr I. Yashin announced that they were going on a sit-down strike and sat on the ground.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "After the four leaders sat down at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, the people behind them stopped, although some people continued to go past them towards the stage.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "Between 5.20 p.m. and 5.45 p.m. on 6 May 2012 two State Duma deputies tried to negotiate the enlargement of the restricted area at Bolotnaya Square by moving the police cordon behind the park along the lines expected by the organisers.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "Between 5.20 p.m. and 5.45 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the Ombudsman of the Russian Federation, at the request of police, attempted to persuade the leaders of the sit-in to resume the procession and to head towards the meeting venue at Bolotnaya embankment where the stage had been set up.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "During the period between 5.20 p.m. and 5.45 p.m. on 6 May 2012, no senior police officer or municipal official came to the site of the sit-down protest at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "During the period between 5.20 p.m. and 5.45 p.m. on 6 May 2012, there was no direct communication between the authorities and the leaders of the sit-in at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "At 5.50 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the crowd around the sit-down protest at Bolotnaya Square built up, causing some congestion.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "At 5.50 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the leaders abandoned the sit-down protest and headed towards the stage, followed by the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "At 5.55 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the media reported that the police authorities were regarding the sit-down strike at Bolotnaya Square as a provocation of mass disorder and were considering prosecuting those responsible for it.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "At approximately 5.55 p.m. on 6 May 2012 a commotion near the police cordon occurred at the place vacated by the sit-down protest at Bolotnaya Square, and the police cordon was broken in several places.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "A crowd of about 100 people spilled over into the empty space beyond the police cordon at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "Within seconds of the cordon being broken at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, the police restored the cordon, which was reinforced by an additional riot police force.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "Those who found themselves outside the police cordon at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 wandered around, uncertain what to do next.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "Several people were apprehended at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 after the cordon was broken, others were pushed back inside the cordon, and some continued to loiter outside or walked towards the park.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The police cordon at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 began to push the crowd into the restricted area and advanced by several metres, pressing it inwards.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "At 6 p.m. on 6 May 2012 Ms Mityushkina, on police instructions, announced from the stage that the meeting was now over.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "Ms Mityushkina's announcement at 6 p.m. on 6 May 2012 that the meeting was over was apparently not heard by most of the demonstrators or the media reporters broadcasting from the spot.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The live television footage provided by the parties at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 contained no mention of Ms Mityushkina's announcement that the meeting was over.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "At approximately 6 p.m. on 6 May 2012 a Molotov cocktail was launched from the crowd at the corner of Malyy Kamennyy bridge over the restored police cordon at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The Molotov cocktail launched at the corner of Malyy Kamennyy bridge on 6 May 2012 landed outside the cordon and a passer-by's trousers caught fire.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The fire caused by the Molotov cocktail at Malyy Kamennyy bridge on 6 May 2012 was promptly extinguished by the police.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "At 6.15 p.m. on 6 May 2012 at the corner of Malyy Kamennyy bridge the riot police began breaking into the demonstration to split up the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "Running in tight formations at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, the riot police pushed the crowd apart, arrested some people, confronted others, and formed new cordons to isolate sections of the crowd.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "Some protesters at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 held up metal barriers and aligned them so as to resist the police, threw various objects at the police, shouted and chanted 'Shame!' and other slogans.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "Whenever the police apprehended someone from among the protesters at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, other protesters attempted to pull them back.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The police at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 applied combat techniques and used truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "At 6.20 p.m. on 6 May 2012 Mr S. Udaltsov climbed onto the stage at the opposite end of Bolotnaya Square to address the meeting and was arrested.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "At approximately 6.20 p.m. on 6 May 2012 Mr A. Navalnyy attempted to go up onto the stage at Bolotnaya Square but was arrested.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "At approximately 6.25 p.m. on 6 May 2012 Mr B. Nemtsov was arrested at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "At Malyy Kamennyy bridge on 6 May 2012 the police continued dividing the crowd and began pushing some sections away from the venue, asking participants through loudspeakers to leave for the metro station.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 continued for at least another hour after 6.20 p.m. until the venue was fully cleared of all protesters.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation opened a criminal investigation into the suspected mass disorder and violent acts against the police under Articles 212 § 2 and 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "On 28 May 2012 an investigation was launched into the criminal offence of organising mass disorder under Article 212 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On 28 May 2012 the two criminal cases — into mass disorder and violent acts against the police, and into organising mass disorder — were joined.", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "On 24 May 2013 the first criminal case against twelve individuals suspected of participation in mass disorder, including the applicant, was transferred to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow for the determination of criminal charges (the first 'Bolotnaya' case).", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "On 21 February 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow pronounced a judgment in the first Bolotnaya case.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow found eight individuals, including the applicant, guilty of participation in mass disorder and of violent acts against police officers during the public assembly on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "The eight individuals found guilty in the first Bolotnaya case received prison sentences of between two and a half and four years; one of them was released on parole.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to two years and six months' imprisonment by the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow in the first Bolotnaya case judgment of 21 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "Three co-defendants in the first Bolotnaya case had previously been pardoned under the Amnesty Act.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "A fourth co-defendant in the first Bolotnaya case had his case disjoined from the main proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "The first Bolotnaya case judgment of 21 February 2014 was upheld by the Moscow City Court on 20 June 2014.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "The Moscow City Court on 20 June 2014 reduced the applicant's prison sentence from two years and six months to two years and three months.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "On 24 July 2014 the Moscow City Court found Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev guilty of organising mass disorder on 6 May 2012 and sentenced them to four and a half years' imprisonment.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "On 18 March 2015 the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation upheld the Moscow City Court judgment of 24 July 2014 against Mr S. Udaltsov and Mr Razvozzhayev, with amendments.", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "On 18 August 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow examined another Bolotnaya case and found four persons guilty of participating in the mass disorder and of committing violent acts against police officers during the demonstration on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The four persons found guilty in the second Bolotnaya case on 18 August 2014 received prison sentences of between two and a half and three and a half years; one of them was released on parole.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow judgment of 18 August 2014 in the second Bolotnaya case was upheld by the Moscow City Court on 27 November 2014.", "source_paragraph": 33, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. The public assembly of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "At the time of his arrest on 6 May 2012, the applicant was a student at the political science faculty of the Moscow State University.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "At the time of his arrest on 6 May 2012, the applicant lived with his wife and their child born in 2011.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On 6 May 2012 the applicant arrived at Bolotnaya Square to take part in the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "According to the applicant, he did not take part in any disorder or clashes with the police on 6 May 2012, although he was in the area where clashes occurred.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "At one point during the dispersal of the demonstration on 6 May 2012, the applicant picked up from the ground a small round yellow object and threw it over the heads of the protesters in the direction of the police.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "The applicant was arrested shortly after throwing the small round yellow object on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "There is no information as to whether the applicant was detained on 6 May 2012 following his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 34, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "On 17 May 2012 the applicant was charged with non-compliance with a lawful order by a police officer on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "The applicant was found guilty of the offence provided by Article 19.3 of the Code of Administrative Offences and was sentenced to 24-hours' detention.", "source_paragraph": 35, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Until 9 June 2012 the applicant continued to study at the Moscow State University while living with his family at his usual address.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "On 9 June 2012 the applicant was detained on suspicion of having participated in mass disorders on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 36, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "On 11 June 2012 the Basmannyy District Court examined and granted the request to detain the applicant pending criminal investigation.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court on 11 June 2012 reasoned that the applicant was suspected of having committed criminal offences one of which is characterised as grave and the other of medium gravity, punishable by up to two years of deprivation of liberty, giving sufficient reasons to believe that the applicant was likely to abscond, to continue his criminal activity, to destroy evidence, or to otherwise obstruct the investigation.", "source_paragraph": 37, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court on 11 June 2012 dismissed the applicant's request for an alternative preventive measure, including bail of 500,000 Russian roubles (RUB).", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court on 11 June 2012 dismissed the applicant's request for personal guarantees of several state officials as an alternative preventive measure.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F114", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court on 11 June 2012 found that the applicant's release was not required on health grounds.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F115", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court on 11 June 2012 ordered the applicant's detention until 6 July 2012.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F116", "text": "On 2 July 2012 the Moscow City Court upheld the detention order of 11 June 2012.", "source_paragraph": 38, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F117", "text": "On 18 June 2012 charges were brought against the applicant under Article 212 § 2 (participation in mass disorder) of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F118", "text": "On 18 June 2012 charges were brought against the applicant under Article 318 § 1 (violence against a public official) of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F119", "text": "The applicant was accused of shouting slogans during the events of 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F120", "text": "The applicant was accused of throwing an unidentified small round yellow object that hit police officer F.'s shoulder during the events of 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 39, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F121", "text": "On 3 July 2012 the Basmannyy District Court examined the investigator's request to extend the term of the applicant's detention by four months.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F122", "text": "On 3 July 2012 the applicant asked for another preventive measure pending trial, offering bail of RUB 500,000 or the personal guarantees of a State Duma deputy, two Moscow municipal deputies and one academic.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F123", "text": "The applicant's request for an alternative preventive measure on 3 July 2012 was supported by petitions signed by six Moscow municipal deputies and three personal references from his place of residence and the Moscow State University.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F124", "text": "On 3 July 2012 the applicant made a plea for release on health grounds, providing medical certificates confirming that he was suffering from high-degree myopia and asthma.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F125", "text": "On 3 July 2012 the Basmannyy District Court found that the circumstances that had justified the detention order had not changed and, referring to the gravity of the charges and the complexity of the investigation, extended the applicant's detention until 6 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F126", "text": "The extension order of 3 July 2012 was upheld by the Moscow City Court on 6 August 2012.", "source_paragraph": 40, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F127", "text": "On 29 October 2012 the Basmannyy District Court granted another extension of the applicant's detention until 6 March 2013, essentially on the same grounds as before and noting that the circumstances that had justified the detention order had not changed.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F128", "text": "The extension order of 29 October 2012 was upheld by the Moscow City Court on 26 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 41, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F129", "text": "On 7 November 2012 the charges against the applicant were updated with a statement that the applicant's and others' acts had cumulatively caused police officer F. a haematoma on the head, leg and shoulder.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F130", "text": "The classification of the offences against the applicant remained unchanged following the update of charges on 7 November 2012.", "source_paragraph": 42, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F131", "text": "On 1 March 2013 the Basmannyy District Court granted a new extension of the applicant's detention until 9 June 2013, essentially on the same grounds as before and noting that the circumstances that had justified the detention order had not changed.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F132", "text": "On 10 April 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the extension order of 1 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 43, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F133", "text": "On 23 April 2013 the Moscow City Court examined a fresh request for the extension of the applicant's detention and granted it until 6 July 2013.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F134", "text": "The Moscow City Court on 23 April 2013 reasoned that the grounds for choosing the preventive measure in respect of the applicant were not only the gravity of the charges but also information about the applicant's personality indicating he could abscond from the investigation and trial, threaten witnesses, or otherwise obstruct the proceedings if released.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F135", "text": "The Moscow City Court on 23 April 2013 held that the aforementioned grounds had not changed and had not lost their relevance, and that the need for pre-trial detention had not ceased to exist.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F136", "text": "The Moscow City Court on 23 April 2013 held that the extension term was reasonable and justified by objective circumstances, and was not in conflict with the term of the pre-trial investigation.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F137", "text": "The Moscow City Court on 23 April 2013 held that the proportionality of the preventive measure to the gravity of the charges showed that the public interests related to the criminal investigation overrode the importance of the principle of respect of individual liberty.", "source_paragraph": 44, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F138", "text": "On 24 May 2013 the applicant's criminal case was transferred to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow for the determination of criminal charges.", "source_paragraph": 45, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F139", "text": "On 30 May 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the extension order of 23 April 2013.", "source_paragraph": 46, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F140", "text": "On 6 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow granted another extension of the applicant's detention until 24 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F141", "text": "The extension order of 6 June 2013 concerned eleven defendants and was based on the finding that the reasons taken into account when the preventive measures were chosen had not ceased to exist and had not changed.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F142", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court on 6 June 2013 held that the defendants, if at liberty, may flee the trial or otherwise obstruct the course of justice, motivated by the gravity of the charges.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F143", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court on 6 June 2013 held that no other measures of restraint would secure the aims and goals of the judicial proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F144", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court on 6 June 2013 took into account the arguments of Mr Akimenkov, Mr Belousov and Mr Barabanov and their counsel concerning health problems which occurred in custody, but noted that no documentary evidence had been provided that these defendants had diseases threatening their life or health and incompatible with detention in custody.", "source_paragraph": 47, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F145", "text": "On 2 July 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the extension order of 6 June 2013.", "source_paragraph": 48, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F146", "text": "On 6 August 2013, during a court hearing, the applicant made an application for release which was dismissed by the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court on the same day.", "source_paragraph": 49, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F147", "text": "On 11 September 2013 the Ombudsman of the Russian Federation applied to the Presidium of the Moscow City Court with a complaint about the extension of the applicant's pre-trial detention and requested an alternative preventive measure for him.", "source_paragraph": 50, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F148", "text": "On 22 October 2013 the applicant applied for release on the grounds of his child's medical condition and the deterioration of the applicant's own health.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F149", "text": "The applicant's application for release on 22 October 2013 was supported by several prominent public personages, including university professors, the dean of the faculty of political science and a State Duma deputy, all of whom provided personal guarantees.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F150", "text": "On 2 October 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court rejected the applicant's application for release.", "source_paragraph": 51, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F151", "text": "On 1 November 2013 the Moscow City Court refused the Ombudsman of the Russian Federation's request of 11 September 2013 for an alternative preventive measure for the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 52, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F152", "text": "On 19 November 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow granted another extension of detention in respect of nine defendants, including the applicant, ordering their detention until 24 February 2014 on the grounds of the gravity of the charges.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F153", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court on 19 November 2013 held that the defendants were charged with a criminal offence under Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, which belongs to the category of grave crimes punishable by a prison sentence of over three years.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F154", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court on 19 November 2013 held that some defendants were also charged with a criminal offence under Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, also punishable by a prison sentence of over three years.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F155", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court on 19 November 2013 held that despite the defendants being registered as having permanent addresses in the Russian Federation, the analysis of the overall information about the defendants' personalities and the nature of the offences gave the court sufficient grounds to consider that the defendants, if the preventive measure were changed to one not involving deprivation of liberty, may flee the trial or otherwise obstruct the course of justice.", "source_paragraph": 53, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F156", "text": "On 17 December 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the extension order of 19 November 2013.", "source_paragraph": 54, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest and pre-trial detention"]}, {"fact_id": "F157", "text": "The applicant has high-degree myopia.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F158", "text": "According to a 2009 medical certificate, the applicant's eyesight in the right eye was minus 10 dioptres and in the left eye minus 6 dioptres.", "source_paragraph": 55, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F159", "text": "From 19 June 2012 to 29 June 2013 the applicant was detained in remand prison IZ-77/5.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F160", "text": "From 29 June 2013 the applicant was held in remand prison IZ-77/2.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F161", "text": "Upon the applicant's arrival at the remand prisons, he was subjected to medical checks which did not reveal any health issues.", "source_paragraph": 56, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F162", "text": "The parties agree that on most days the number of inmates in the cell did not exceed the design capacity of the remand prisons.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F163", "text": "The parties agree that the size of the cells and the number of detainees allowed the applicant four square metres of personal space.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F164", "text": "The parties agree that the applicant had an individual sleeping place in every cell.", "source_paragraph": 57, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F165", "text": "According to the applicant, the cells in the remand prisons were inadequately lit and ventilated, excessively hot in summer and cold in winter.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F166", "text": "According to the applicant, all cells in the remand prisons had a lavatory pan separated from the living space by a chin-high plastic partition providing insufficient privacy.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F167", "text": "According to the applicant, he had been constantly exposed to cigarette smoke in the cells, and although the window in the cell could be opened it gave onto a courtyard used for incinerating rubbish, letting in fumes.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F168", "text": "According to the applicant, the cell constantly lacked fresh air and the forced ventilation could not compensate for it.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F169", "text": "According to the applicant, outdoor exercise was limited to one hour per day in the remand prisons.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F170", "text": "According to the applicant, the window in the cell was too high to give sufficient light for reading or working with documents.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F171", "text": "According to the applicant, access to drinking water in the remand prisons was conditional on the purchase of an electric kettle.", "source_paragraph": 58, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F172", "text": "According to the Government, the artificial light in the cells of the remand prisons was maintained at 100 watts round the clock except at night, from 10 p.m. to 6 a.m., when it was 75 watts.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F173", "text": "The Government provided measurement tables for the detention centre created in August 2013, which stated that the brightness in the cells was between 149 and 454 lux.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F174", "text": "The Government's measurement tables for August 2013 stated that the temperature in the cells was between 26°C and 29°C.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F175", "text": "The Government's measurement tables for August 2013 stated that the humidity in the cells was between 36% and 45%.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F176", "text": "According to the Government, in remand prison IZ-77/5 the detainees had access to a gym upon their written request.", "source_paragraph": 59, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F177", "text": "On 11 July 2012 the applicant applied in writing to the head of the remand prison facility for a medical examination, alleging that he had been suffering from asthma and high-degree myopia.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F178", "text": "On 20 September 2012 the applicant made a similar application for a medical examination to the investigator of the criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 60, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F179", "text": "On 3 October 2012 the investigator granted the applicant's request for a medical examination.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F180", "text": "The investigator's decision of 3 October 2012 noted that the performance of a medical examination fell outside the competence of the investigating bodies, but that given the importance of the applicant's state of health to the criminal case, the investigating bodies had sent a request to the administration of remand prison IZ-77/5 stating the need to carry out, in the shortest possible time, a medical examination of the applicant, the results of which were to be submitted to the investigating bodies for inclusion in the criminal case file.", "source_paragraph": 61, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F181", "text": "It appears that the medical examination of the applicant ordered on 3 October 2012 was not carried out.", "source_paragraph": 62, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F182", "text": "On 28 November 2012 the public commission for the monitoring of detention facilities visited remand prison IZ-77/5.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F183", "text": "On 11 January 2013 the public commission for the monitoring of detention facilities visited remand prison IZ-77/5.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F184", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant made no complaints about the conditions of detention or the lack of medical assistance during either visit by the public commission for the monitoring of detention facilities on 28 November 2012 and 11 January 2013.", "source_paragraph": 63, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F185", "text": "On 3 September 2013 the applicant had a hypertension crisis during a court hearing.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F186", "text": "An ambulance was called on 3 September 2013 and provided the applicant with the necessary assistance following his hypertension crisis.", "source_paragraph": 64, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F187", "text": "Following the applicant's complaints of headaches, on 6 September 2013 the applicant was placed in the medical ward of remand prison IZ-77/2.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F188", "text": "Upon admission to the medical ward of remand prison IZ-77/2 on 6 September 2013, the applicant was diagnosed with hypertension.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F189", "text": "The applicant remained in the medical ward of remand prison IZ-77/2 for a period of at least two months for his blood pressure to be monitored.", "source_paragraph": 65, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F190", "text": "The applicant alleged that the conditions in remand prison IZ-77/2 were poor, in particular on account of the lack of outdoor exercise and inadequate sanitary arrangements.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F191", "text": "The applicant specified that the lavatory pan in remand prison IZ-77/2 was separated from the living space by a chest-high partition providing insufficient privacy.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F192", "text": "According to the applicant's letter of 30 July 2013, he had not been able to have a shower since his transfer to remand prison IZ-77/2.", "source_paragraph": 66, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F193", "text": "According to the Government, in remand prison IZ-77/2 the toilet was separated by a solid partition from the rest of the cell and ensured the necessary privacy.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F194", "text": "According to the Government, the state of the sanitary facilities in remand prison IZ-77/2 was satisfactory.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F195", "text": "According to the Government, the cells in remand prison IZ-77/2 were treated for disinfection and pest-control once every three months and whenever necessary.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F196", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant was entitled to one hour's outdoor exercise per day in remand prison IZ-77/2.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F197", "text": "According to the Government, the cell in remand prison IZ-77/2 was cleaned and the bedding changed once a week.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F198", "text": "According to the Government, the cells in remand prison IZ-77/2 were equipped with forced ventilation and could be aired through a hinged window pane.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F199", "text": "According to the Government, artificial light in remand prison IZ-77/2 was provided at 100 watts by day and 75 watts by night.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F200", "text": "According to the Government, the glazed windows in remand prison IZ-77/2 let in sufficient daylight.", "source_paragraph": 67, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F201", "text": "Pursuant to the request of the applicant's counsel filed on an unidentified date, on 31 January 2014 the applicant was examined by an ophthalmologist.", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F202", "text": "On 31 January 2014 the applicant was diagnosed with high-degree myopia (minus 13 dioptres on both eyes).", "source_paragraph": 68, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Conditions of detention and medical assistance"]}, {"fact_id": "F203", "text": "During the hearing of the applicant's criminal case, which began in July 2013, the applicant and his co-defendants were regularly transferred from the remand prisons to the court-house and back.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F204", "text": "All the defendants in the applicant's criminal case attended the hearings on three or four consecutive days every week.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F205", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant's trial involved ninety-one court hearings, and it appears that the applicant was transferred to attend all of them.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F206", "text": "A typical schedule on a hearing day during the applicant's trial showed wake-up times between 5 a.m. and 7 a.m., boarding the van at 9.30 a.m., arrival at the court-house at 10 a.m., end of hearing between 3 p.m. and 7 p.m., boarding the van back between 5 p.m. and 9 p.m., arrival at remand prison IZ-77/2 between 7 p.m. and 10.30 p.m., and being brought to the cell between 7.40 p.m. and 00.10 a.m.", "source_paragraph": 69, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F207", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing schedule left him insufficient time for sleep between the court hearings.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F208", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing schedule gave him no time to prepare for the next day's hearing.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F209", "text": "According to the applicant, the hearing schedule deprived him of hot meals.", "source_paragraph": 70, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F210", "text": "The applicant alleged that the conditions in the prison assembly rooms and in the transfer vans were appalling, in particular owing to overcrowding.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F211", "text": "The applicant claimed that he was cramped together with other detainees and their belongings in a small tin cabin without windows, ventilated only through a roof hatch, with benches spaced at 30 cm.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F212", "text": "The applicant claimed that smoking was allowed in the transfer vans, which caused further discomfort, especially to non-smokers.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F213", "text": "The applicant claimed that occasionally detainees were transferred in vans divided into tight individual metal cubicles.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F214", "text": "The applicant claimed that in both types of transfer vans the cabin overheated in the summer and froze in cold weather.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F215", "text": "The applicant claimed that the transfer lasted for two to six hours depending on the number of pick-up points and traffic conditions.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F216", "text": "The applicant claimed that there was no opportunity to use a toilet during the transfer, even at other pick-up points where the van could wait for hours.", "source_paragraph": 71, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F217", "text": "At the Moscow City Court before and after the hearings the applicant and his co-defendants were held in convoy cells.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F218", "text": "According to the applicant, the convoy cells at the Moscow City Court were poorly lit and often overcrowded, and access to a toilet was subject to the availability of a convoy officer.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F219", "text": "According to the applicant, some of the convoy cells on the ground floor of the Moscow City Court were as small as two square metres, and each could be shared by two detainees.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F220", "text": "The applicant's account of the convoy cells and prison transfers was supported by witness statements submitted by his co-defendant Mr Kavkazskiy and those given by three fellow inmates unrelated to the present case, whose detailed accounts were consistent with the applicant's submissions.", "source_paragraph": 72, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F221", "text": "According to the Government, the morning transfer to the court-house did not exceed 1.5 hours, and the transfer back lasted for up to three hours because of the evening traffic.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F222", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant's schedule allowed for eight hours of uninterrupted sleep, with wake-up time at 6 a.m., pickup at 8 a.m., and drop-off after the hearing at 9.30 p.m., with assembly before and after the transfer not exceeding 30 minutes.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F223", "text": "According to the Government, all the detainees were provided with packed meals for the whole day out at the court-house and were given hot water at lunchtime.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F224", "text": "According to the Government, the vans used for the transfer were 2009-2011 models of KAMAZ-4308-AZ and KAMAZ-OTS-577489-AZ (both designed for 32 detainees), GAZ-326041-AZ (designed for seven detainees), and GAZ-3309-AZ (designed for 19 detainees).", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F225", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant and his co-defendants were detained in the convoy area of the Moscow City Court, which included four cells measuring 12 square metres each and toilets, including a wheelchair-accessible one, which the detainees could use on demand accompanied by the convoy.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F226", "text": "According to the Government, the convoy cells at the Moscow City Court had adequate light and ventilation, were furnished with tables and benches, and during intervals in the hearing the defendants could use an electric kettle to boil water.", "source_paragraph": 73, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Transfer between the detention centre and the court-house"]}, {"fact_id": "F227", "text": "On 6 June 2013 the court proceedings in the applicant's criminal case began in hearing room no. 338 of the Moscow City Court, which lent its premises to the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court to accommodate all participants, the public and the press.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F228", "text": "In hearing room no. 338 of the Moscow City Court, ten defendants were held in a glass cabin measuring 3.2 m x 1.7 m x 2.3 m (height).", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F229", "text": "The Government submitted that the glass cabin in hearing room no. 338 was a permanent courtroom installation consisting of a steel frame and sheets of bulletproof glass, with a partition inside, a steel mesh ceiling and a secure door, equipped with benches.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F230", "text": "The walls of the glass cabin in hearing room no. 338 had slots allowing documents to be passed between the defendants and their counsel; ventilation outlets were at floor level, and near the dock was an air conditioner.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F231", "text": "The glass cabin in hearing room no. 338 was equipped with microphones allowing for consultations with counsel and facilitating the defendants' participation in the proceedings.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F232", "text": "The Government specified that a convoy officer guarded the glass cabin in hearing room no. 338 on both sides, supervised the defendants and intercepted any attempts of contact with outsiders, but the defendants could communicate with their counsel with the court's permission.", "source_paragraph": 74, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F233", "text": "The applicant submitted that the glass cabin in hearing room no. 338 lacked space and ventilation and was virtually soundproof, hampering the defendants' participation in the proceedings and their communication with counsel.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F234", "text": "The applicant submitted that the benches in the glass cabin had no backrests, and the lack of space made it impossible to have documents or to consult counsel or the case file during the hearing.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F235", "text": "The applicant submitted that the video evidence examined at the hearing could not be seen by him from the glass cabin because of the distance between the cabin and the screen and his poor eyesight.", "source_paragraph": 75, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F236", "text": "In August 2013 the proceedings in the applicant's criminal case moved to hearing room no. 635 of the Moscow City Court.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F237", "text": "Hearing room no. 635 of the Moscow City Court was equipped with two glass cabins similar to the one in hearing room no. 338, except that there were no slots in them; each cabin measured 4 m x 1.2 m x 2.3 m (height).", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F238", "text": "From 2 August 2013 one of the defendants was no longer placed in the glass cabin owing to a change in the measure of restraint for him, and the nine remaining defendants were divided between the two cabins in hearing room no. 635.", "source_paragraph": 76, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F239", "text": "From mid-September 2013 to the end of 2013 the hearings in the applicant's criminal case continued on the premises of the Nikulinskiy District Court of Moscow in hearing room no. 303.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F240", "text": "In January and February 2014 the hearings in the applicant's criminal case took place at the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court in hearing room no. 410.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F241", "text": "Hearing rooms no. 303 of the Nikulinskiy District Court of Moscow and no. 410 of the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court were equipped with metal cages in which the nine defendants (from 19 December 2013 eight), including the applicant, sat during the hearings.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F242", "text": "According to photographs submitted by the applicant, the dimensions of the metal cages in hearing rooms no. 303 and no. 410 were similar to the glass cabins described above and were not equipped with any furniture other than benches.", "source_paragraph": 77, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "E. Conditions in the courtroom"]}, {"fact_id": "F243", "text": "On 6 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow began a preliminary hearing of the criminal case against ten participants in the public assembly at Bolotnaya Square charged with participation in mass disorders and violent acts against police officers.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F244", "text": "On 18 June 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow began the hearing on the merits of the criminal case against the participants in the public assembly at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 78, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F245", "text": "On 13 November 2013 police officer F., the victim of the applicant's alleged assault, was examined as a witness at the trial.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F246", "text": "Police officer F. testified on 13 November 2013 that the applicant had thrown an unidentified yellow object which had hit him on the shoulder and caused him pain.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F247", "text": "The applicant asked for police officer F.'s statements made during the investigation, which contained no mention of the yellow object or the applicant, to be read out in court.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F248", "text": "The applicant pointed out that no identification parade had been held during the investigation to enable police officer F. to identify the person who had assaulted him; instead, the applicant and police officer F. had been questioned in confrontation, whereby the applicant had been the only person introduced to police officer F. as the likely perpetrator.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F249", "text": "The court refused the applicant's request for police officer F.'s statements made during the investigation to be read out.", "source_paragraph": 79, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F250", "text": "On 21 February 2014 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow pronounced judgment in the applicant's criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F251", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court found that between 4 p.m. and 8 p.m. on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square, unidentified persons called those present to move outside the agreed meeting venue, to defy the lawful orders of the police, and to use violence, which led to mass disorder accompanied by the use of violence against public officials and the destruction of property.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F252", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court found that at 5 p.m. at the latest on 6 May 2012 the defendants acquired the criminal intent to participate in mass disorder and to use violence.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F253", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court found that the applicant (Mr Belousov) acquired an unidentified solid yellow round object at an unidentified time and place with the intention of using it to cause violence against officials.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F254", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court found that the applicant (Mr Belousov) repeatedly chanted anti-government slogans together with other participants in the mass disorder.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F255", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court found that participants in the mass disorder threw chunks of tarmac, stones, sticks and other objects at the police, hitting them on various body parts.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F256", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court found that the applicant (Mr Belousov) used violence not endangering the life or health of police officer F.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F257", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court found that between 5 p.m. and 8.10 p.m. on 6 May 2012 unidentified participants in the mass disorder deliberately administered at least three blows and kicks to police officer F.'s head, body and limbs, after which the applicant (Mr Belousov) deliberately threw an unidentified solid yellow round object which hit police officer F. on the upper right side of the chest, causing him physical pain.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F258", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court found that as a result of the applicant's (Mr Belousov's) and other unidentified persons' actions, police officer F. sustained physical pain and injuries in the form of bruising and abrasion of the soft tissues of the parietal region, bruising of the left forearm, and abrasion on the right shin, which constituted injuries not endangering life or health and not entailing short-term health impairment or minor durable professional incapacitation.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F259", "text": "The applicant (Mr Belousov) pleaded not guilty at trial and testified that he went to Malyy Kamennyy Bridge to see why the meeting was not starting, saw the riot police cordon and officers arresting some participants, was looking to leave, went to the middle of Bolotnaya Square, saw a girl who tripped on something and nearly fell, picked up an object from the ground that felt soft and slimy, threw it away without aiming it at anyone, joined hands with other protesters chanting slogans, and was then grabbed by three police officers and carried to the police vehicle.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F260", "text": "Police officer F. testified at trial that after the cordon was restored he was heading into the crowd to arrest offenders, somebody hit him three times on the head, then he felt a blow from a heavy object on his shoulder, and from the corner of his eye he saw the applicant (Mr Belousov) take a swing and toss something like a billiard ball.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F261", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court found that the applicant (Mr Belousov) was filmed at the moment he threw a yellow object at the police.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F262", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court rejected the defendants' argument that no mass disorder took place, finding that premeditated actions of a group of individuals who organised obstruction to the demonstrators' march caused discontent among the protesters towards the police, and that those leading the march changed their tactics and called for a sit-in, hoping to secure a change in the placement of the cordon; as a result, protesters forced their way through the police cordon and public order was disrupted.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F263", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court took into account the nature and degree of the applicant's involvement in the mass disorder and considered it possible to give him a sentence below the minimum punishment provided for by Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 80, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F264", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to two years and six months' imprisonment by the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow on 21 February 2014, calculated on the basis of a two-year prison term under Article 212 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation partly concurrent with a one-year prison term under Article 318 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F265", "text": "The applicant's pre-trial detention counted towards his prison sentence.", "source_paragraph": 81, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F266", "text": "The applicant appealed against the first-instance judgment of 21 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F267", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant contested the first-instance court's finding that mass disorder had taken place, alleging that there had only been isolated clashes between the protesters and the police, caused by the authorities' last-minute decision to alter the layout of the meeting venue and aggravated by their excessive crowd-control measures.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F268", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant denied that the object he threw hit anybody.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F269", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant alleged a breach of procedure for questioning in confrontation with the victim, police officer F., and complained that the court had refused to have the records of police officer F.'s interrogation conducted during the investigation read out.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F270", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant complained about the conditions in which he was escorted to the courtroom, the intensity of the hearing schedule, and that he had been placed in a glass cabin during the trial, claiming that it hindered his communication with counsel.", "source_paragraph": 82, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F271", "text": "On 20 June 2014 the Moscow City Court upheld the first-instance judgment of 21 February 2014.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F272", "text": "On 20 June 2014 the Moscow City Court reduced the applicant's prison sentence to two years and three months, comprising a one-year-and-nine-month term under Article 212 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation and a nine-month term under Article 318 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, to run partly concurrently.", "source_paragraph": 83, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F273", "text": "On 8 September 2014 the applicant was released after serving his prison term.", "source_paragraph": 84, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "F. The applicant's trial"]}, {"fact_id": "F274", "text": "Article 212 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the organisation of mass disorder accompanied by violence, riots, arson, destruction of property, use of firearms, explosives and explosive devices, as well as armed resistance to a public official, shall be punishable by four to ten years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 85, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F275", "text": "Article 212 § 2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that participation in the types of mass disorder provided for by Article 212 § 1 shall be punishable by three to eight years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 85, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F276", "text": "Article 212 § 3 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the instigation of mass disorder provided for by Article 212 § 1, or the instigation of participation in it, or the instigation of violence against citizens, shall be punishable by restriction of liberty for up to two years, or community works for up to two years, or deprivation of liberty for the same term.", "source_paragraph": 85, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F277", "text": "Article 318 § 1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation provides that the use of violence not endangering life or health, or the threat to use such violence against a public official or his relatives in connection with the performance of his or her duties, shall be punishable by a fine of up to 200,000 roubles or an equivalent of the convicted person's wages for 18 months, or community works for up to five years, or up to five years' deprivation of liberty.", "source_paragraph": 85, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F278", "text": "A summary of the relevant domestic law provisions governing the conditions and length of pre-trial detention is set out in Dolgova v. Russia (no. 11886/05, §§ 26-31, 2 March 2006) and Lind v. Russia (no. 25664/05, §§ 47-52, 6 December 2007).", "source_paragraph": 86, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F279", "text": "A summary of the applicable regulations and the European standards for prison conditions is set out in Ananyev and Others v. Russia (nos. 42525/07 and 60800/08, §§ 55 et seq., 10 January 2012).", "source_paragraph": 87, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F012", "F039", "F101", "F008", "F093", "F046", "F047", "F051", "F037", "F038", "F040", "F031", "F035", "F036", "F048", "F049", "F050", "F053", "F055", "F056", "F103", "F120", "F119", "F254", "F060", "F061", "F246"], "interference": ["F005", "F006", "F007", "F008", "F093", "F087", "F119", "F120", "F246"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F274", "F275", "F060", "F061", "F074", "F251", "F250", "F262"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F005", "F006", "F008", "F093", "F119", "F120", "F246", "F272", "F254", "F263", "F103", "F259", "F260", "F256", "F258", "F275", "F264", "F273", "F085", "F086", "F087"], "positive_obligation": ["F046", "F047", "F049", "F050", "F055", "F056", "F048", "F053"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F012", "F037", "F038", "F040", "F046", "F047", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F035", "F036", "F103", "F119", "F120", "F246", "F254"], "interference": ["F005", "F006", "F008", "F093", "F087"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F275", "F060", "F061", "F262"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F093", "F272", "F275", "F119", "F254", "F120", "F246", "F256", "F258", "F263", "F273", "F085", "F087"], "positive_obligation": ["F046", "F047", "F049", "F050", "F055", "F056"]}, "list3": ["F093", "F272", "F119", "F254", "F120", "F246", "F256", "F258", "F263", "F275", "F273", "F047", "F040"]}} {"case_name": "case_678", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_680", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1967.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Kalinkovichi.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 29 March 2008 the applicant was stopped by a Russian customs officer at the border crossing into Belarus.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "After checking the applicant's documents, the Russian customs officer informed the applicant that he had failed to declare his Opel car when entering Russia.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The Russian customs officer informed the applicant that by failing to declare his Opel car when entering Russia, the applicant had infringed Russian customs regulations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The Russian customs officer instituted administrative proceedings against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The Russian customs officer impounded the applicant's Opel car.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "On 11 June 2008 Colonel B., Head of the Novozybkov Customs Post of the Bryansk Customs Office, examined the applicant's case.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "Colonel B., Head of the Novozybkov Customs Post of the Bryansk Customs Office, found the applicant liable for having failed to declare his Opel car.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Colonel B., Head of the Novozybkov Customs Post of the Bryansk Customs Office, ordered the applicant to pay a fine in the amount of 35,509.50 Russian roubles (RUB).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Colonel B., Head of the Novozybkov Customs Post of the Bryansk Customs Office, ruled that the applicant's Opel car, which had been impounded by customs, should be returned to the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant appealed against the decision of 11 June 2008 issued by Colonel B., Head of the Novozybkov Customs Post of the Bryansk Customs Office.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On an unspecified date the Novozybkov Town Court of the Bryansk Region fixed the hearing for 8 August 2008.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 8 August 2008 the Novozybkov Town Court of the Bryansk Region examined the applicant's appeal against the decision of 11 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 8 August 2008 the Novozybkov Town Court of the Bryansk Region upheld the decision of 11 June 2008 issued by Colonel B., Head of the Novozybkov Customs Post of the Bryansk Customs Office.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Novozybkov Town Court of the Bryansk Region heard the case of 8 August 2008 in the applicant's absence.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "In the operative part of the judgment of 8 August 2008, the Novozybkov Town Court of the Bryansk Region advised the applicant of his right to appeal against that judgment.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "According to the applicant, the letter from the Novozybkov Town Court of the Bryansk Region notifying him of the date and time of the court hearing reached him on 9 August 2008.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 26 September 2008 the applicant received a copy of the Novozybkov Town Court of the Bryansk Region's judgment of 8 August 2008 by post.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On an unspecified date the applicant lodged an appeal with the Bryansk Regional Court against the judgment of 8 August 2008.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 13 November 2008 the Bryansk Regional Court sent a letter to the applicant informing him that his appeal was dismissed.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant submitted a request for supervisory review of the judgment of 8 August 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 26 January 2009 the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation dismissed the applicant's request for supervisory review.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 20 August 2009 the Acting Head of the Novozybkov Customs Post of the Bryansk Customs Office discontinued the enforcement proceedings in respect of the decision of 11 June 2008.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Acting Head of the Novozybkov Customs Post of the Bryansk Customs Office noted that the applicant was a foreign national.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Acting Head of the Novozybkov Customs Post of the Bryansk Customs Office noted that the applicant had no assets in the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The Acting Head of the Novozybkov Customs Post of the Bryansk Customs Office noted that the applicant had no known place of residence in the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Acting Head of the Novozybkov Customs Post of the Bryansk Customs Office noted that it was impossible to enforce the decision of 11 June 2008 on account of the expiry of the relevant time-limit.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "On 24 August 2009 the Bryansk Customs certified that the decision concerning the applicant's administrative liability had come into force on 15 July 2009.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "On 24 August 2009 the Bryansk Customs certified that the applicant had failed to reclaim his Opel car within a month of 15 July 2009.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On an unspecified date the regional agency in charge of the federal property applied to the Novozybkov Town Court of the Bryansk Region seeking to reclaim the applicant's Opel car as bona vacantia.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "On 12 November 2009 the Novozybkov Town Court of the Bryansk Region granted the regional agency in charge of the federal property's claims in full regarding the applicant's Opel car.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Novozybkov Town Court of the Bryansk Region took into account that, as claimed by the regional agency in charge of the federal property, the applicant had been repeatedly summoned to the regional customs office to pick up his Opel car.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the documents submitted by the Government, the Novozybkov Town Court of the Bryansk Region decided to hear the case of 12 November 2009 in the applicant's absence given that the applicant had been duly notified of the hearing and chose not to attend.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The applicant did not appeal against the judgment of 12 November 2009 of the Novozybkov Town Court of the Bryansk Region.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 2 June 2010 the judgment of 12 November 2009 of the Novozybkov Town Court of the Bryansk Region was enforced.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Impounding of the applicant's car"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 19 March 2012 the leaders of the Strategy-31 movement notified the Mayor of Moscow of their intention to organise a rally at Triumfalnaya Square in the centre of Moscow on 31 March 2012 (Saturday), scheduled from 6 to 8 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 19 March 2012 the leaders of the Strategy-31 movement notified the Mayor of Moscow of their intention to organise a march from Triumfalnaya Square down Tverskaya Street to Manezh Square on 31 March 2012 (Saturday), scheduled from 8 to 8.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "Approximately 1,500 people were expected to attend the rally and march planned for 31 March 2012 by the leaders of the Strategy-31 movement.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The rally and march planned for 31 March 2012 were organised to promote the right to peaceful assembly as set forth in Article 31 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The rally and march planned for 31 March 2012 were organised to promote the freedom of Parliamentary elections in Russia.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 20 March 2012 the Government of Moscow refused to agree on the venues for the rally and the march planned for 31 March 2012.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "According to the Moscow authorities, there was archaeological and construction work going on in Triumfalnaya Square at the time of the planned rally.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "According to the Moscow authorities, the march along the indicated route from Triumfalnaya Square down Tverskaya Street to Manezh Square would disrupt the normal functioning of the city's infrastructure and traffic.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "According to the Moscow authorities, the march along the indicated route from Triumfalnaya Square down Tverskaya Street to Manezh Square would infringe the rights and interests of people who would not take part in the rally and the march.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Moscow authorities suggested two alternative venues for the planned rally and march of 31 March 2012, both located in the centre of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "On 29 March 2012 the leaders of the Strategy-31 movement informed the Mayor of Moscow that the rally would take place at Triumfalnaya Square as indicated in their notification of 19 March 2012.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "On 31 March 2012 the rally was held as planned by its organisers at Triumfalnaya Square in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The applicant took part in the rally held on 31 March 2012 at Triumfalnaya Square in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "At 6.30 p.m. on 31 March 2012 the applicant was arrested and brought to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "According to the arrest record, the applicant had taken part in an unauthorised gathering on 31 March 2012.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "According to the arrest record, the applicant chanted the slogan \"Down with Putin\" at the gathering on 31 March 2012.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "According to the arrest record, the applicant chanted the slogan \"Let us stop the dictatorship\" at the gathering on 31 March 2012.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "According to the arrest record, the applicant chanted the slogan \"Fascism shall not pass\" at the gathering on 31 March 2012.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "On 17 April 2012 the Justice of the Peace of Precinct no. 367 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow found that the rally held on 31 March 2012 had been organised in contravention of the existing procedure.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "On 17 April 2012 the Justice of the Peace of Precinct no. 367 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow found that the applicant had taken part in the rally of 31 March 2012 without having verified whether it had been legitimate.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "On 17 April 2012 the Justice of the Peace of Precinct no. 367 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow found the applicant administratively liable for violation of the established procedure for organising a public assembly.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "On 17 April 2012 the Justice of the Peace of Precinct no. 367 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow fined the applicant RUB 500.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The applicant appealed against the decision of 17 April 2012 of the Justice of the Peace of Precinct no. 367 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 21 May 2012 the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow upheld the decision of 17 April 2012 of the Justice of the Peace of Precinct no. 367 of the Tverskoy District of Moscow on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Strategy-31 rally"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F048", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F054", "F055", "F056", "F057"], "interference": ["F049", "F050", "F051", "F057", "F058"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F049", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F054", "F055", "F056", "F057", "F058"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F048", "F049", "F052", "F053", "F054", "F057"], "interference": ["F050", "F057", "F058"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F054", "F057", "F058"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F048", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F052", "F053", "F054", "F057", "F058"]}} {"case_name": "case_681", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_682", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_683", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_684", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicants are Turkish nationals.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The first applicant was born in 1972.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The second applicant was born in 1965.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The third applicant was born in 1961.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "Mr Yılmaz Yıldız lives in Niğde.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The second and third applicants live in Mardin.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The first applicant, Yılmaz Yıldız, is a health officer.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The first applicant, Yılmaz Yıldız, is the branch chairman of the Health and Social Services Workers' Union (Sağlık ve Sosyal Hizmet Emekçileri Sendikası – 'the SES') in Niğde.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The second applicant, Kamiran Yıldırım, is a doctor.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The second applicant, Kamiran Yıldırım, is the branch chairman of the Health and Social Services Workers' Union (SES) in Mardin.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The third applicant, Mehmet Metin Çılgın, is a doctor.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The third applicant, Mehmet Metin Çılgın, is a member of the Health and Social Services Workers' Union (SES) in Mardin.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "On 4 February 2005, several members of the Health and Social Services Workers' Union (SES) gathered in front of the Niğde Social Security Institution (Sosyal Sigortalar Kurumu – 'the SSK') Hospital.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The first applicant, Yılmaz Yıldız, read out the Health and Social Services Workers' Union (SES)'s press statement drawing attention to the problems that could arise as a consequence of the transfer of hospitals incorporated in the Social Security Institution (SSK) to the Ministry of Health.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The Health and Social Services Workers' Union (SES) press statement was addressed to the press and the public.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The SES press statement stated that hospitals incorporated in the Social Security Institution (SSK) had been transferred to the Ministry of Health pursuant to Law no. 5283.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The SES press statement stated that following the transfer of SSK hospitals to the Ministry of Health, patients were unable to take their medication for a long time.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The SES press statement stated that following the transfer of SSK hospitals to the Ministry of Health, hospital staff had been working in a tense atmosphere.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The SES press statement stated that before the structural changes, the Health and Social Services Workers' Union (SES) had warned the Government and the public.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The SES press statement stated that the probable administrative and bureaucratic problems had been pointed out, including that the Social Security Institution (SSK) was going to be under a huge economic burden.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The SES press statement stated that the probable administrative and bureaucratic problems had been pointed out, including that people would have to pay for health care services.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The SES press statement stated that the probable administrative and bureaucratic problems had been pointed out, including that an additional tax was going to be imposed on workers.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The SES press statement stated that the Health and Social Services Workers' Union (SES) maintains that the Government should allocate more funds from the budget to health care services to redress the structural problems.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The SES press statement stated that the Health and Social Services Workers' Union (SES) states that all citizens should be provided with equal, accessible, sufficient and free health care services.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "On 25 February 2005, the second applicant, Kamiran Yıldırım, and the third applicant, Mehmet Metin Çılgın, together with another thirty persons gathered in the Mardin Yenişehir Social Security Institution (SSK) Hospital yard.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The second applicant, Kamiran Yıldırım, read out the press statement in his capacity as chairman of the Mardin branch of the Health and Social Services Workers' Union (SES).", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "During the gathering on 4 February 2005 in Niğde, the police did not prevent anyone from entering the yard.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "During the gathering on 25 February 2005 in Mardin, the police did not prevent anyone from entering the yard.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The police did not interfere with the demonstration on 4 February 2005 in Niğde or the reading out of the press statement.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The police did not interfere with the demonstration on 25 February 2005 in Mardin or the reading out of the press statement.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the police report of 4 February 2005 in Niğde, the group of demonstrators had been warned verbally that their gathering was illegal and ordered to disband for the protection of public order and safety.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the police report of 25 February 2005 in Mardin, the group of demonstrators had been warned verbally that their gathering was illegal and ordered to disband for the protection of public order and safety.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The Niğde public prosecutor filed an indictment charging the applicants with intentionally disobeying orders issued by the authorities aimed at protecting public order and safety, pursuant to section 32 of the Misdemeanours Act, Law No. 5326.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The Mardin public prosecutor filed an indictment charging the applicants with intentionally disobeying orders issued by the authorities aimed at protecting public order and safety, pursuant to section 32 of the Misdemeanours Act, Law No. 5326.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "On 8 June 2005, the Mardin Magistrates' Court convicted the applicants as charged and imposed on them administrative fines of 100 Turkish liras (TRY) (approximately 62 euros (EUR)).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "On 14 July 2005, the Niğde Magistrates' Court convicted the applicants as charged and imposed on them administrative fines of 100 Turkish liras (TRY) (approximately 62 euros (EUR)).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The applicants appealed against the decisions of the Mardin Magistrates' Court and the Niğde Magistrates' Court.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 20 June 2005, the Mardin Assize Court dismissed the applicants' appeals against the Mardin Magistrates' Court decision.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 26 July 2005, the Niğde Assize Court dismissed the applicants' appeals against the Niğde Magistrates' Court decision.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The Mardin Assize Court's decision dismissing the applicants' appeals was notified to the applicants on 15 July 2005.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Niğde Assize Court's decision dismissing the applicants' appeals was notified to the applicants on 3 August 2005.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 23 August 2005, the applicants paid the fines to the relevant tax departments.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 11 October 2005, the applicants paid the fines to the relevant tax departments.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "Section 32 of the Misdemeanours Act (Law No. 5326) provides that persons acting contrary to orders given by the competent authorities for the protection of public safety, public order and public health shall receive an administrative fine of 100 Turkish liras.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "Section 9/ç of the Provincial Administration Act (Law No. 5442) provides that governors may issue and announce general orders to exercise the authority conferred on them by, and perform duties in connection with, laws, by-laws, regulations and government decrees.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "Section 11/C of the Provincial Administration Act (Law No. 5442) provides that governors shall have the duty, inter alia, to secure peace and security, physical integrity, safety of private property and public well-being, and the authority to exercise preventive law enforcement.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to Ministry of the Interior Circular no. 2004/100, authorised governors, having assessed safety needs, may prohibit the making of press statements close to critical institutions.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "Under section 66 of the Provincial Administration Act (Law No. 5442), the local civil administration and local governors may impose penalties under section 32 of the Misdemeanours Act (Law No. 5326) on those who do not comply with decisions and measures taken in accordance with the applicable rules.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "Section 6 of the Meetings and Demonstrations Act (Law No. 2911) empowers the most senior local governors to make and announce necessary regulations regarding demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Press Bulletin of the Governorship of Mardin dated 20 July 2004 declared unlawful the making of press statements within 100 metres of hospitals.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Press Bulletin of the Niğde Governorship dated 5 August 2004 declared a prohibition on public statements made in front of any State institution or organisations and their outbuildings.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "explicit"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["public_safety", "prevention_of_disorder", "protection_of_health"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F013", "F025", "F014", "F026", "F016", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F050", "F051"], "interference": ["F033", "F034", "F035", "F036"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F044", "F035", "F036"], "legitimate_aim": ["F031", "F032", "F044"], "necessity": ["F013", "F025", "F014", "F016", "F026", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F034", "F035", "F036", "F038", "F039", "F050", "F051"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F013", "F025", "F014", "F026", "F016", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F030"], "interference": ["F035", "F036"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F044"], "legitimate_aim": ["F031", "F032"], "necessity": ["F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F035", "F036", "F038", "F039"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F013", "F025", "F027", "F028", "F029", "F030", "F031", "F032", "F035", "F036", "F038", "F039"]}} {"case_name": "case_685", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1961.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Adana.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 16 February 2006 a gathering was held in Adana on the anniversary of the arrest of Abdullah Öcalan.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Abdullah Öcalan is the leader of the PKK (Kurdistan Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The PKK (Kurdistan Workers' Party) is an illegal armed organisation.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The protesters gathered in front of the building of the Adana branch of the Democratic Society Party (Demokratik Toplum Partisi) (DTP).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "A press statement was read out in front of the Adana branch of the Democratic Society Party (DTP) building during the gathering on 16 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant was a member of the Democratic Society Party (DTP).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The applicant participated in the gathering held on 16 February 2006 in Adana.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "Clashes occurred between police officers and some demonstrators who were attempting to block the traffic.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "According to police reports, two police officers were injured as a result of objects thrown from the Democratic Society Party (DTP) building.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The police entered the Democratic Society Party (DTP) building following the clashes.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The police arrested 223 people, including the applicant, after entering the Democratic Society Party (DTP) building.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The day after the arrest, the applicant was detained on remand.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 10 March 2006 the Adana public prosecutor charged the applicant and sixteen other people with membership of the PKK (Kurdistan Workers' Party) under Articles 220 § 6 and 314 of the Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The Adana public prosecutor alleged that the accused had participated in the public gathering on 16 February 2006 in response to calls made by the PKK (Kurdistan Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Adana public prosecutor alleged that the accused had resisted the police officers during the gathering on 16 February 2006.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Adana public prosecutor alleged that the accused had therefore acted on behalf of the PKK (Kurdistan Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 5 May 2006 the applicant was released pending trial.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 10 September 2008 the Adana Assize Court convicted the applicant under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The Adana Assize Court did not find it established that the applicant had attended the reading out of the press statement in response to calls made by the PKK (Kurdistan Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The Adana Assize Court did not find it established that the applicant had injured any police officers.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The Adana Assize Court concluded that the applicant could not be convicted of membership of the PKK (Kurdistan Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "The Adana Assize Court concluded that the applicant could not be convicted of resistance to the police.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The Adana Assize Court considered that on 16 February 2006 the applicant had gone to the Democratic Society Party (DTP) building with a view to disseminating propaganda in support of the PKK (Kurdistan Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The Adana Assize Court convicted the applicant under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) on the basis that she had gone to the Democratic Society Party (DTP) building to disseminate propaganda in support of the PKK (Kurdistan Workers' Party).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The applicant was sentenced to ten months' imprisonment by the Adana Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The Adana Assize Court took into account the applicant's good behaviour during the trial when deciding to suspend the pronouncement of her conviction.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The Adana Assize Court took into account the absence of any previous criminal record on the applicant's part when deciding to suspend the pronouncement of her conviction.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Adana Assize Court suspended the pronouncement of the applicant's conviction on condition that she did not commit another intentional offence for a period of five years, under Article 231 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (hükmün açıklanmasının geri bırakılması).", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "On 20 November 2008 the Adana Assize Court dismissed an objection lodged by the applicant against the decision to suspend the pronouncement of her conviction.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The final decision of 20 November 2008 was served on the applicant on 9 January 2009.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The relevant domestic law applicable at the material time can be found in Belge v. Turkey (no. 50171/09, § 19, 6 December 2016).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "Between 7 August 2003 and 18 July 2006, section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) provided that any person who assists members of terrorist organisations or who disseminates propaganda inciting others to violence or other methods of terrorism shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between one and five years and a judicial fine of between five million liras and one billion liras.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["national_security", "prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F003", "F007", "F009", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F024", "F026"], "interference": ["F007", "F009", "F020", "F026", "F027", "F030"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F020", "F034"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F003", "F007", "F009", "F010", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F023", "F024", "F025", "F026"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F003", "F009", "F022", "F024"], "interference": ["F020", "F030"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F020", "F034"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F003", "F007", "F009", "F020", "F021", "F022", "F024", "F025", "F026"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F009", "F020", "F030", "F021", "F022", "F024", "F025", "F026"]}} {"case_name": "case_690", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1961.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Surgut, Khanty-Mansiyskiy Region, Russia.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant was the leader of a trade union in a private company.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant's co-workers expressed a wish to hold a public assembly on Constitution Day on 12 December 2009.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicant, in his capacity as trade union leader, decided to help his co-workers hold a public assembly on Constitution Day on 12 December 2009.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "According to the applicant, his help to his co-workers was 'an indirect expression of his own opinion'.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The applicant distributed banners to his co-workers.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The applicant explained to his co-workers that it would be more practicable to stage solo demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "To avoid prosecution for holding a public assembly without notifying the authorities in advance, the applicant suggested that his co-workers position themselves at some distance from each other, for instance on different streets.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "At the time of the events on 12 December 2009, there was no federal or regional statutory requirement concerning the minimum distance between simultaneous solo demonstrations.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The applicant was arrested.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The applicant was taken to the police station after his arrest.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant was held at the police station for three hours.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "On 18 December 2009, a justice of the peace found the applicant guilty under Article 20.2 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The justice of the peace fined the applicant 1,500 Russian roubles (approximately 35 euros at the time).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The justice of the peace considered that the applicant and his co-workers had met in one place.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The justice of the peace considered that the applicant had given instructions to his co-workers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The justice of the peace considered that the applicant had distributed banners to his co-workers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The justice of the peace considered that the applicant had taken his co-workers to the place of the demonstration.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The justice of the peace found that the above circumstances disclosed the presence of a group event in the form of a static demonstration (a 'picket').", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The justice of the peace found that the above circumstances confirmed the applicant's role as organiser of the group event.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The justice of the peace found that it was incumbent on the applicant to lodge a prior notification about the event to the competent authority as required by section 7 of the Public Events Act.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant appealed against the judgment of the justice of the peace of 18 December 2009.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant noted that the Public Events Act defined a 'picket' as a form of public expression of opinion where one or more citizens with placards, banners and other means of visual expression stationed themselves near the target object of the 'picket'.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant argued that there had been a separate 'target object' for each solo demonstrator.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant argued that the demonstrators had been positioned at a considerable distance from each other, for instance thirty metres apart for two of them.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "In his appeal, the applicant argued that he could not be lawfully considered as an organiser of a group event.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "On 22 January 2010, the Surgut Town Court upheld the judgment of the justice of the peace of 18 December 2009.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "A summary of domestic law and practice concerning regulations relating to public events in Russia is contained in Novikova and Others v. Russia, application nos. 25501/07, 57569/11, 80153/12, 5790/13 and 35015/13, §§ 47-85, judgment of 26 April 2016.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F005", "F007", "F008", "F009", "F010", "F014", "F020", "F021", "F026"], "interference": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F010", "F014", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F026", "F029"], "legitimate_aim": ["F009", "F010", "F014", "F015", "F022", "F026"], "necessity": ["F009", "F010", "F014", "F016", "F017", "F018", "F019", "F020", "F021", "F026", "F028"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F007", "F009", "F026"], "interference": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F014", "F015"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F010", "F020", "F026"], "legitimate_aim": ["F010", "F014", "F026"], "necessity": ["F010", "F014", "F020", "F026", "F028"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F010", "F014", "F020", "F026", "F028"]}} {"case_name": "case_691", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The case concerns police ill-treatment of the applicants during a political rally on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants were neither convicted of mass disorder nor accused of any other offence in connection with the relevant events at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 1, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) was born in 1966.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) was born in 1945.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) was represented by Mr S.A. Minenkov, a lawyer practising in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) was represented by Mr A.N. Laptev, a lawyer practising in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 2, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The Government were initially represented by Mr G. Matyushkin, the Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The Government were subsequently represented by Mr M. Galperin, the successor to Mr G. Matyushkin as Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the assembly at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in the judgment of Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 7-65, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "Both applicants participated in the political rally on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) was one of the organisers of the political rally on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "According to the applicants, they neither violated public order nor resisted the police who were present at the assembly on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "During the dispersal of the meeting on 6 May 2012, the police allegedly hit the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) on the head with a rubber truncheon.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "During the dispersal of the meeting on 6 May 2012, the police allegedly hit the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) on the head with a rubber truncheon.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) submitted photographs in support of his account of events at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "One of the photographs submitted by the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) shows some police officers aiming blows at the crowd with their rubber truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) can be seen in the crowd in the photograph showing police officers aiming blows with rubber truncheons.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "Another photograph submitted by the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) shows him being pulled by two police officers.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The photographs submitted by the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) do not show the actual moment when he was allegedly attacked with a rubber truncheon.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "Two photographs submitted by the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) show him at the site of the events at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 with his face bleeding.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "According to the first applicant (Mr Zakharov), having received a blow to the head, he lost consciousness.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "Other participants in the rally helped the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) obtain first aid treatment after he received a blow to the head.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) was taken to a hospital following the events at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) was discharged from hospital on 6 May 2012, the same day he was admitted.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) submitted a medical certificate dated 6 May 2012 stating that he had been diagnosed with a contused wound of the frontal lobe.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) provided links to YouTube videos showing the clashes between the police and the protesters at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The YouTube videos provided by the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) indicate that she was surrounded by police officers when she fell and started screaming.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The YouTube videos provided by the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) show other participants in the assembly carrying her and shouting at the police officers, accusing them of hitting an elderly woman, referring to the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan).", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) submitted a medical certificate stating that on 6 May 2012 an ambulance had been called for her to Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The medical certificate submitted by the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) attested that she had sustained a head injury on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The medical certificate submitted by the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) attested that she had soft tissue bruises on the right side of her head on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "The medical certificate submitted by the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) attested that she had soft tissue bruises in the perineal region on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "A medical certificate dated 7 May 2012 stated that the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) had had health problems as a result of the trauma she had experienced on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "A medical certificate dated 8 June 2012 stated that the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) had had health problems as a result of the trauma she had experienced on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Neither of the applicants was arrested in connection with the events of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Neither of the applicants was charged with any offence in connection with the events of 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY ON 6 MAY 2012 AND THE APPLICANTS' ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 23 June 2012 the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) asked the Investigation Committee to institute criminal proceedings on account of his alleged ill-treatment during the dispersal of the public assembly on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) enclosed photographs and a medical certificate dated 6 May 2012 with his application to the Investigation Committee.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The first applicant's (Mr Zakharov's) request to the Investigation Committee was joined to other requests concerning the alleged abuse of powers by the police officers on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "On 20 March 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy branch of the Investigation Committee dismissed several individual complaints concerning the allegedly unlawful acts of the police in dispersing the rally on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "On 20 March 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy branch of the Investigation Committee dismissed two official enquiries concerning the allegedly unlawful acts of the police in dispersing the rally on 6 May 2012, including the excessive use of force and arbitrary arrests.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "In his decision of 20 March 2013, the investigator at the Zamoskvoretskiy branch of the Investigation Committee referred to the first applicant's (Mr Zakharov's) description of the incident.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "In his decision of 20 March 2013, the investigator at the Zamoskvoretskiy branch of the Investigation Committee referred to statements by other persons, including some of the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "According to an internal inquiry conducted in the aftermath of the events at Bolotnaya Square, a police officer had called the first applicant (Mr Zakharov), inviting him to come to the police station to give further information and identify the police officer responsible for the attack.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The report on the internal inquiry conducted in the aftermath of the events at Bolotnaya Square was dated 8 June 2012.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The report on the internal inquiry dated 8 June 2012 stated that the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) had refused to attend the meeting at the police station, stating that he could not identify the police officer concerned.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "In his decision of 20 March 2013, the investigator at the Zamoskvoretskiy branch of the Investigation Committee found that on 6 May 2012, in response to the breaking of a police cordon by some protesters, the police had started arresting persons who had been most actively involved in those acts.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "In his decision of 20 March 2013, the investigator at the Zamoskvoretskiy branch of the Investigation Committee concluded that the work of the officers who had been in charge of apprehending offenders had involved the use of force and special means of restraint, in so far as necessary, against persons who had been putting up resistance.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "In his decision of 20 March 2013, the investigator at the Zamoskvoretskiy branch of the Investigation Committee found that there were no elements of a crime in the acts of the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The investigator at the Zamoskvoretskiy branch of the Investigation Committee did not examine the incident in respect of the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) in his decision of 20 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The investigator's decision of 20 March 2013 did not indicate that the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) had acted aggressively towards the police or shown any disobedience.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The investigator's decision of 20 March 2013 confirmed that the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) was not listed among the persons who had been apprehended on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusal of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) complained about the decision of 20 March 2013 to the prosecutor's office.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) challenged the decision of 20 March 2013 before the courts.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) argued that the investigator had not addressed his allegations in the decision of 20 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) argued that the investigator had made no attempt to identify the police officer responsible for the attack on him.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) claimed that by joining his application to those of others, the investigator had avoided assessing the particular incident of which he had complained.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) disputed what had allegedly been said during the telephone call in June 2012 in which a police officer had invited him to come to the police station to identify the officer responsible for the attack.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 17 May 2013 the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) was sent a reply from the prosecutor's office which briefly stated that there were no grounds for setting aside the decision not to open a criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 16 August 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow dismissed the first applicant's (Mr Zakharov's) complaint in respect of the decision of 20 March 2013 not to open a criminal case.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow, in its decision of 16 August 2013, considered that the investigator had made a thorough evaluation of the acts of the police that had safeguarded public order during the mass event.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow, in its decision of 16 August 2013, noted that the fact that the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) had been admitted to hospital on 6 May 2012 had been reported on the same day and had triggered an internal inquiry.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow, in its decision of 16 August 2013, found that the allegations regarding unlawful acts by the police in respect of the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) had not been confirmed during the internal inquiry.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 20 August 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow dismissed a judicial complaint by the first applicant (Mr Zakharov) concerning the prosecutor's reply of 17 May 2013.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow, in its decision of 20 August 2013, considered that the first applicant's (Mr Zakharov's) constitutional rights had not been violated, as he had had the opportunity to lodge a judicial complaint in respect of the decision of 20 March 2013.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) appealed against the decision of 16 August 2013, arguing that the investigator had not provided a thorough assessment of his arguments.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "The first applicant (Mr Zakharov) appealed against the decision of 16 August 2013, arguing that the investigator's conclusions were not based on the material of the pre-investigation inquiry.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 1 November 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow's decision of 16 August 2013.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The Moscow City Court, in its decision of 1 November 2013, stated that at the pre-trial stage, a court had no jurisdiction to rule on the credibility of information which an investigator had to check in accordance with Article 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "On 11 November 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow's decision of 20 August 2013.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE FIRST APPLICANT", "B. Complaints about the refusal to institute a criminal investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 29 October 2012 the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) asked for criminal proceedings to be instigated on account of her alleged ill-treatment by the police officers on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusals in respect of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "The second applicant's (Ms Varzhabetyan's) request for criminal proceedings was joined to other requests concerning the alleged abuse of powers by the police officers on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusals in respect of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 7 December 2012 the investigator refused to open a criminal investigation into the second applicant's (Ms Varzhabetyan's) alleged ill-treatment, on the grounds that the acts of the police did not constitute a criminal offence.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusals in respect of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 25 October 2013 the investigator refused to open a criminal investigation into the second applicant's (Ms Varzhabetyan's) alleged ill-treatment, on the grounds that the acts of the police did not constitute a criminal offence.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusals in respect of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 22 May 2014 the investigator refused to open a criminal investigation into the second applicant's (Ms Varzhabetyan's) alleged ill-treatment, on the grounds that the acts of the police did not constitute a criminal offence.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusals in respect of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 21 January 2016 the investigator refused to open a criminal investigation into the second applicant's (Ms Varzhabetyan's) alleged ill-treatment, on the grounds that the acts of the police did not constitute a criminal offence.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusals in respect of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "In his decisions refusing to open a criminal investigation into the second applicant's (Ms Varzhabetyan's) alleged ill-treatment, the investigator set out the second applicant's arguments concerning the incident but, without analysing the particular circumstances of her case, came to literally the same conclusions as those made in the first applicant's (Mr Zakharov's) case, namely that there were no elements of a crime in the acts of the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusals in respect of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "The prosecutor overruled the investigator's decision of 7 December 2012 as premature and ill-founded on 23 October 2013, and the material in the case file was subjected to a further inquiry.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusals in respect of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "The prosecutor overruled the investigator's decision of 25 October 2013 as premature and ill-founded on 25 April 2014, and the material in the case file was subjected to a further inquiry.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusals in respect of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "The prosecutor overruled the investigator's decision of 22 May 2014 as premature and ill-founded on 27 November 2015, and the material in the case file was subjected to a further inquiry.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusals in respect of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "The prosecutor overruled the investigator's decision of 21 January 2016 as premature and ill-founded on 2 November 2016, and the material in the case file was subjected to a further inquiry.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusals in respect of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "On the last occasion the prosecutor overruled the investigator's decision (2 November 2016), the prosecutor noted in particular that during the next additional inquiry the investigator had to examine the DVD that the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) had previously submitted.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusals in respect of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan), she was informed about the decisions not to open a criminal investigation following substantial delays.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusals in respect of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "According to the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan), on at least two occasions she learnt about the prosecutor's decisions overruling the investigator's refusals during court proceedings, after she had challenged those decisions.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "A. Request for a criminal investigation and refusals in respect of that request"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "On an unspecified date in 2013, the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) challenged a decision not to open a criminal investigation before the courts.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "B. Judicial complaints about the refusals to institute criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "On 23 September 2015 the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) challenged a decision not to open a criminal investigation before the courts.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "B. Judicial complaints about the refusals to institute criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "On 23 September 2016 the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) challenged a decision not to open a criminal investigation before the courts.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "B. Judicial complaints about the refusals to institute criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "On 25 October 2013 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow dismissed the second applicant's (Ms Varzhabetyan's) claim, finding that the decision not to institute a criminal investigation dated 7 December 2012 was lawful.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "B. Judicial complaints about the refusals to institute criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F091", "text": "On 30 November 2015 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow dismissed the second applicant's (Ms Varzhabetyan's) claim, as the investigator's decision of 22 May 2014 had been overruled by the prosecutor before the court hearing had taken place.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "B. Judicial complaints about the refusals to institute criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F092", "text": "On 10 November 2016 the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow dismissed the second applicant's (Ms Varzhabetyan's) claim, as the investigator's decision of 21 January 2016 had been overruled by the prosecutor before the court hearing had taken place.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "B. Judicial complaints about the refusals to institute criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F093", "text": "It does not follow from the materials available before the Court that the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) appealed against the Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow's decisions of 30 November 2015 and 10 November 2016.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "B. Judicial complaints about the refusals to institute criminal proceedings"]}, {"fact_id": "F094", "text": "On 21 June 2016 the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) claimed compensation for non-pecuniary damage allegedly caused by the investigating bodies that had dealt with her application and refused to institute a criminal investigation.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "C. Claim in respect of non-pecuniary damage on account of allegedly ineffective investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F095", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) argued that considering her request jointly with those of others had been unlawful.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "C. Claim in respect of non-pecuniary damage on account of allegedly ineffective investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F096", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) argued that the numerous remittals of the case for further inquiries revealed the deficiency of the work of the investigators.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "C. Claim in respect of non-pecuniary damage on account of allegedly ineffective investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F097", "text": "The second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) claimed that the failure to take the necessary measures to establish the circumstances of the incident had violated her rights and caused her psychological and physical suffering.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "C. Claim in respect of non-pecuniary damage on account of allegedly ineffective investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F098", "text": "On 28 November 2016 the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow rejected the second applicant's (Ms Varzhabetyan's) claim for compensation for non-pecuniary damage.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "C. Claim in respect of non-pecuniary damage on account of allegedly ineffective investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F099", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its decision of 28 November 2016, found that the alleged defects in the work of the investigators had been remedied by the overruling of their decisions.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "C. Claim in respect of non-pecuniary damage on account of allegedly ineffective investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F100", "text": "The Basmannyy District Court of Moscow, in its decision of 28 November 2016, found that the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan) had provided no evidence indicating that the defendants' acts had caused her any suffering and that they were at fault for the alleged negative consequences.", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "C. Claim in respect of non-pecuniary damage on account of allegedly ineffective investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F101", "text": "On 30 March 2017 the Moscow City Court upheld the Basmannyy District Court of Moscow's decision of 28 November 2016 on appeal.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "C. Claim in respect of non-pecuniary damage on account of allegedly ineffective investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F102", "text": "On 10 October 2017 a judge of the Moscow City Court dismissed a cassation appeal by the second applicant (Ms Varzhabetyan).", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "III. INVESTIGATION INTO THE ALLEGED ILL-TREATMENT OF THE SECOND APPLICANT", "C. Claim in respect of non-pecuniary damage on account of allegedly ineffective investigation"]}, {"fact_id": "F103", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law provisions governing pre-investigation inquiries and judicial review of the decisions of investigating authorities not to open a criminal case, see Lyapin v. Russia (no. 46956/09, §§ 99-100, 24 July 2014).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F104", "text": "Section 20 of the Police Act (no. 3 of 7 February 2011, as in force at the material time) provided that police officers might use physical force, including combat methods, to prevent criminal and administrative offences.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F105", "text": "Section 20 of the Police Act (no. 3 of 7 February 2011, as in force at the material time) provided that police officers might use physical force, including combat methods, to arrest individuals who had committed criminal or administrative offences.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F106", "text": "Section 20 of the Police Act (no. 3 of 7 February 2011, as in force at the material time) provided that police officers might use physical force, including combat methods, to overcome resistance to lawful orders if non-violent methods did not ensure compliance with responsibilities entrusted to the police.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F107", "text": "Section 21 of the Police Act (no. 3 of 7 February 2011) laid down an exhaustive list of circumstances in which special means, including rubber truncheons, might be used.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F108", "text": "Section 21 of the Police Act (no. 3 of 7 February 2011) permitted rubber truncheons to be used to repel an attack on civilians or police officers.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F109", "text": "Section 21 of the Police Act (no. 3 of 7 February 2011) permitted rubber truncheons to be used to overcome resistance shown to a police officer.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F110", "text": "Section 21 of the Police Act (no. 3 of 7 February 2011) permitted rubber truncheons to be used to repress mass disorder and put an end to collective actions disrupting the operation of transport, means of communication and legal entities.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F111", "text": "Section 21 of the Police Act (no. 3 of 7 February 2011) prohibited hitting a person on the head with a rubber truncheon.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F112", "text": "Section 22 of the Police Act (no. 3 of 7 February 2011) stated that the use of special means to suppress an unlawful, but peaceful manifestation that did not disrupt the operation of transport, means of communication and legal entities was prohibited.", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}, {"fact_id": "F113", "text": "For relevant international material on freedom of peaceful assembly, including guidelines on policing public assemblies, see Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, § 80, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 32, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "RELEVANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F011", "F012", "F002", "F014", "F037", "F038", "F053", "F054"], "interference": ["F015", "F016", "F022", "F027", "F029", "F031", "F032", "F033", "F037"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F104", "F105", "F106", "F107", "F108", "F109", "F110"], "legitimate_aim": ["F104", "F105", "F106", "F107", "F109", "F110"], "necessity": ["F037", "F038", "F002", "F053", "F054", "F015", "F016", "F027", "F032", "F033", "F111", "F112"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F001", "F012", "F002", "F037", "F053", "F054"], "interference": ["F015", "F016", "F027", "F032"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F104", "F106", "F109"], "legitimate_aim": ["F104", "F110"], "necessity": ["F037", "F002", "F053", "F054", "F111", "F015", "F016"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F012", "F002", "F037", "F015", "F016", "F111", "F053", "F054"]}} {"case_name": "case_694", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_697", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "On an unspecified date the Plovdiv Municipality started clearing the banks and the riverbed of the river \"Maritza\", which runs through the city of Plovdiv.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The clearing procedure carried out by the Plovdiv Municipality involved the uprooting and eradication of trees and plant life that were blocking the flow of the river \"Maritza\".", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicant organisation believed that the actions of the Plovdiv Municipality in clearing the banks and riverbed of the river \"Maritza\" were in violation of domestic environmental protection legislation.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicant organisation believed that the disorderly uprooting and eradication of the trees and plant life along the river \"Maritza\" would disrupt the biological balance of the river.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "On 18 April 2000 the applicant organisation informed the Plovdiv Municipality of its intention to hold a public rally on 19 April 2000 in front of the municipality.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "The aim of the public rally planned for 19 April 2000 was to protest against the Plovdiv Municipality's actions of uprooting and eradicating the river \"Maritza\"'s plant life.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The aim of the public rally planned for 19 April 2000 included a demand that the disorderly uprooting and eradication of the river \"Maritza\"'s plant life be stopped because it was destroying important alluvial trees and the habitat of rare, endangered birds.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "In a letter dated 19 April 2000 the Plovdiv Municipality informed the applicant organisation that it would not permit the planned public rally to go ahead.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The letter of 19 April 2000 from the Plovdiv Municipality prohibiting the public rally was signed by the secretary of the municipality.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The full text of the Plovdiv Municipality's letter of 19 April 2000 read: \"We inform you that the Plovdiv Municipality does not permit the conducting of the [planned] public rally.\"", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "Later on 19 April 2000, police officers visited the offices of the applicant organisation.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "On 19 April 2000, police officers obtained signed declarations from the leaders of the applicant organisation stating that they were aware of the prohibition on the planned public rally and would not organise the rally as planned.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "The applicant organisation did not hold a rally on 19 April 2000.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "After 19 April 2000, the clearing of the banks and the riverbed of the river \"Maritza\" by the Plovdiv Municipality continued unabated.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "On 26 April 2000 the applicant organisation appealed against the Plovdiv Municipality's prohibition of its public rally.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "The applicant organisation's appeal of 26 April 2000 was filed with the Plovdiv Municipality.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Plovdiv Municipality did not forward the applicant organisation's appeal of 26 April 2000 to the domestic courts together with all relevant documents, as required under the applicable legislation.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "On 7 June 2000 the applicant organisation re-filed its appeal against the Plovdiv Municipality's prohibition of the public rally directly with the Plovdiv Regional Court.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "On 21 June 2000 the Plovdiv Regional Court requested the Plovdiv Municipality to provide it with its file and all other relevant documents regarding the public rally planned by the applicant organisation.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "On 22 June 2000 the Plovdiv Municipality sent the documents requested by the Plovdiv Regional Court, with the exception of the applicant organisation's appeal of 26 April 2000.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "On 5 July 2000 the Plovdiv Regional Court requested that the Plovdiv Municipality provide it with the applicant organisation's appeal of 26 April 2000.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "On 5 July 2000 the Plovdiv Regional Court instructed the applicant organisation to deposit the required court fee.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant organisation deposited the required court fee on 9 October 2000.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 25 October 2000 the Plovdiv Municipality provided the Plovdiv Regional Court with the applicant organisation's appeal of 26 April 2000.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "At a hearing on 24 January 2001 the Plovdiv Regional Court examined the applicant organisation's appeal against the Plovdiv Municipality's prohibition of the public rally.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "In a judgment of 28 March 2001 the Plovdiv Regional Court declared null and void the Plovdiv Municipality's prohibition of the public rally planned by the applicant organisation for 19 April 2000.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "In its judgment of 28 March 2001 the Plovdiv Regional Court established that the prohibition of the public rally had been issued in violation of the provisions of the Meetings and Marches Act (1990), as it had been decided not by the mayor but by the secretary of the Plovdiv Municipality.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "In its judgment of 28 March 2001 the Plovdiv Regional Court established that the prohibition of the public rally lacked reference to any of the statutory grounds for issuing such prohibitions under the Meetings and Marches Act (1990).", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant organisation claimed that it was informed of the judgment of the Plovdiv Regional Court of 28 March 2001 on 10 July 2001.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "The Government did not challenge the applicant organisation's claim that it was informed of the judgment of the Plovdiv Regional Court of 28 March 2001 on 10 July 2001.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "No appeal was filed against the Plovdiv Regional Court's judgment of 28 March 2001.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "The Plovdiv Regional Court's judgment of 28 March 2001 became final on an unspecified date.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "The relevant provisions of the Constitution of Bulgaria (1991) and the Meetings and Marches Act (1990) have been summarised in the Court's judgment in the case of The United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Ivanov v. Bulgaria (application no. 44079/98, §§ 72-79, 20 October 2005).", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law and practice", "1. The Constitution (1991) and the Meetings and Marches Act (1990)"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "Section 39(1) of the Administrative Procedures Act (1979) provided, at the relevant time, that the administrative authority whose act was being appealed had an obligation to forward the appeal filed with it to the competent court within three days together with its full file on the matter.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law and practice", "2. The Administrative Procedures Act (1979)"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "Section 39(2) of the Administrative Procedures Act (1979) provided that if the appeal and file were not forwarded to the courts by the administrative authority, then the appellant had the right to re-file his appeal directly with the courts.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law and practice", "2. The Administrative Procedures Act (1979)"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "Before 1 January 2006, the State Responsibility for Damage Act of 1988 provided that the State was liable for damage caused only to private persons by the illegal acts, actions or omissions of its bodies and officials acting within the scope of, or in connection with, their administrative duties (section 1 of the State Responsibility for Damage Act of 1988).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law and practice", "3. The State Responsibility for Damage Act (1988)"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "Before 1 January 2006, the State Responsibility for Damage Act of 1988 provided that the State was liable for damage caused only to private persons by the organs of the investigation, the prosecution and the courts (section 2 of the State Responsibility for Damage Act of 1988).", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law and practice", "3. The State Responsibility for Damage Act (1988)"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "Currently, the State and local municipalities are also liable under section 1 of the State Responsibility for Damage Act of 1988 (as amended) for damage caused to juridical entities by the illegal acts, actions or omissions of their bodies and officials acting within the scope of, or in connection with, their administrative duties.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law and practice", "3. The State Responsibility for Damage Act (1988)"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "The amendment to the State Responsibility for Damage Act of 1988 extending liability to damage caused to juridical entities does not have retroactive effect in respect of damage caused prior to its date of introduction.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "B. Relevant domestic law and practice", "3. The State Responsibility for Damage Act (1988)"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F005", "F006", "F007", "F013"], "interference": ["F008", "F010", "F011", "F012", "F013"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F009", "F026", "F027", "F028"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F005", "F006"], "interference": ["F008", "F013"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F009", "F027"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F005", "F008", "F013", "F009", "F027"]}} {"case_name": "case_698", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F001", "F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_701", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The public assemblies in question were manifestations for fair elections to Mosgorduma (Moscow City Duma).", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003", "F004"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003", "F004"]}} {"case_name": "case_702", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers or participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002"], "interference": ["F002"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002"]}} {"case_name": "case_705", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The applicants, except for the applicant in application no. 46493/21, raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_706", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1988.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 7-65, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "The background facts relating to the planning, conduct and dispersal of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square are set out in more detail in Yaroslav Belousov v. Russia (nos. 2653/13 and 60980/14, §§ 7-33, 4 October 2016).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "The parties' submissions on the circumstances directly relevant to the present case are set out below in the judgment.", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "On 6 May 2012 a public demonstration entitled the 'March of Millions' was held in central Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration on 6 May 2012 was held to protest against the allegedly rigged presidential elections.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "The 'March of Millions' demonstration on 6 May 2012 had been approved by the Moscow city authorities in the form of a march followed by a meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "The approved meeting at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 was supposed to end at 7.30 p.m.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "The march on 6 May 2012 was peaceful and held without any disruptions.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "When the marchers arrived at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, it transpired that barriers installed by the police had narrowed the entrance to the meeting venue.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The barriers installed by the police at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012 allegedly restricted the space allocated for the meeting.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "To control the crowd at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012, a police cordon forced the protesters to remain within the barriers.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "There were numerous clashes between the police and protesters at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police ordered that the meeting at Bolotnaya Square finish early.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "At 5.30 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the police began to disperse the participants of the meeting at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "It took the police about two hours to clear the protesters from Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The applicant took part in the demonstration on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The applicant was arrested at the venue of the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "After her arrest at Bolotnaya Square, the applicant was taken to a police station.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "At the police station, the applicant was charged with an administrative offence.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "After a night in detention, the applicant was released.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "On 8 May 2012 the applicant was convicted of the administrative offence with which she had been charged.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 8 May 2012 the applicant was exempted from administrative liability.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Demonstration of 6 May 2012"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "According to the applicant, on 6 May 2012 she participated in the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "According to the applicant, she conducted herself peacefully at the demonstration at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "According to the applicant, she did not take part in any acts of violence prior to her arrest at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "According to the applicant, at 6 p.m. on 6 May 2012 she was arrested by the police at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "According to the applicant, at around 9 p.m. on 6 May 2012 she was taken to Taganskiy district police station of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant was arrested at 6 p.m. on 6 May 2012 at Bolotnaya Square.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant was arrested because she had been participating in breaking the police cordon at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "According to the Government, at 7.20 p.m. on 6 May 2012 the applicant was taken to Taganskiy district police station.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "According to the Government, the time of 7.20 p.m. on 6 May 2012 as the time the applicant was taken to Taganskiy district police station was also indicated in the record of her transfer to the police station for the purpose of compiling an administrative file.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "According to the Government, the applicant was released on 7 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "The record of administrative arrest indicated that the applicant had been arrested at 8.45 p.m. at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "The record of administrative arrest contained no mention of the date or time of the applicant's release.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "The record of administrative arrest indicated that the applicant had not asked to notify anyone of her arrest.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "The applicant signed an undertaking that she would attend court if ordered by the judge to do so.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "After the applicant's arrest, an on-duty officer drew up an administrative-offence record on the basis of the reports and explanatory notes of police officers G.S. and M.S., who had arrested the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "The reports and explanatory notes of police officers G.S. and M.S. were drawn up using an identical template.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The reports and explanatory notes of police officers G.S. and M.S. contained no individualised information except the police officers' personal information and the applicant's name.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The applicant was accused of disobeying lawful orders of the police, an offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The administrative-offence record reiterated the reports and notes of police officers G.S. and M.S.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The administrative-offence record stated that the applicant, acting as part of a group of 1,500 citizens, took part in an authorised meeting.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The administrative-offence record stated that during the event the applicant committed a breach of the rules on holding public events by breaking the police cordon.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The administrative-offence record stated that by breaking the police cordon the applicant prevented police officers from carrying out their service duties, in breach of Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "According to the applicant, at the police station she was not allowed to make a phone call, despite making insistent requests.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "According to the applicant, she told the police at the police station that she was the mother of a fifteen-month-old child left at home with a babysitter.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "According to the applicant, she requested that her family be notified of her arrest, but this was refused by the police.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "According to the applicant, her passport contained no information about her baby.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "According to the applicant, at the police station she was detained in a small overcrowded cell with no sanitary facilities, sleeping place or bedding.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "According to the applicant, she had no access to drinking water at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "According to the applicant, she was given no food at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The administrative case file contained an explanatory note by the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "In her explanatory note, the applicant stated that during the demonstration she had happened to be in the middle of the crowd, which had pulled her towards the police officers.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "In her explanatory note, the applicant stated that at some point she had been arrested and taken to the police station, even though she had not chanted any slogans.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "At around 6 p.m. on 7 May 2012 the applicant appeared before a justice of the peace.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The applicant's administrative case could not be examined on 7 May 2012 and she was taken back to the police station.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "According to the applicant, she was released from the police station at about 10 p.m. on 7 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "The applicant signed an undertaking that she would attend the court hearing of the administrative case.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 8 May 2012 the Justice of the Peace of circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District examined the charges against the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On the basis of the police officers' reports and explanations and the records of administrative transfer and arrest, the Justice of the Peace of circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District established that the applicant had committed an administrative offence under Article 19.3 § 1 of the Code of Administrative Offences, as described in the administrative-offence record.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "At the hearing on 8 May 2012, the applicant repeated the statements she had given in her explanatory note.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "The applicant's statements at the hearing on 8 May 2012 were dismissed by the Justice of the Peace of circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District decided to absolve the applicant from administrative liability on the grounds that her offence had not entailed serious consequences.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District decided to absolve the applicant from administrative liability on the grounds that she had a baby born in 2011.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "The Justice of the Peace of circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District issued the applicant a warning.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "The applicant did not appeal against the judgment of the Justice of the Peace of circuit no. 100 of the Yakimanka District of 8 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 26 July 2012 the applicant lodged a complaint under Chapter 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure with the Dorogomilovskiy District Court of Moscow.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "The applicant's complaint of 26 July 2012 concerned her allegedly arbitrary arrest on 6 May 2012 and detention until 7 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "The applicant's complaint of 26 July 2012 concerned the termination of the rally at Bolotnaya Square on 6 May 2012.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "The applicant's complaint of 26 July 2012 concerned the conditions of her detention at the police station.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 3 September 2012 the Dorogomilovskiy District Court of Moscow refused to examine the applicant's complaint on the grounds that the contested acts of the police had been the matter of the administrative proceedings and could not be challenged separately.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 3 September 2012 the Dorogomilovskiy District Court of Moscow did not examine the applicant's complaint about the conditions of detention.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 20 May 2013 the Moscow City Court quashed the part of the Dorogomilovskiy District Court's decision of 3 September 2012 concerning the refusal to examine the complaint about the conditions of detention.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "On 20 May 2013 the Moscow City Court upheld the remaining part of the Dorogomilovskiy District Court's decision of 3 September 2012.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 23 October 2013 the Dorogomilovskiy District Court dismissed the applicant's complaint about the conditions of her detention at the police station as unsubstantiated.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "On 28 February 2014 the Moscow City Court upheld the Dorogomilovskiy District Court's judgment of 23 October 2013 dismissing the applicant's complaint about the conditions of her detention.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. The applicant's arrest, detention and conviction for an administrative offence"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "For a summary of the relevant domestic law, see Frumkin v. Russia (no. 74568/12, §§ 77 and 79, 5 January 2016).", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "Article 3.9 § 2 of the Code of Administrative Offences provides that administrative detention may not be applied to women with children under fourteen years old.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "According to Article 2.9 of the Code of Administrative Offences, a judge examining an administrative case may exempt an offender from administrative liability and issue a warning if the offence was minor.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "Paragraph 1.1 (2) of Article 29.9 of the Code of Administrative Offences stipulates that if a warning is issued, the administrative proceedings must be discontinued.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "Chapter 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure (in force until 15 September 2015) described the procedure for examining complaints about decisions, acts or omissions of State and municipal authorities and officials.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F084", "text": "Article 254 of the Code of Civil Procedure (Chapter 25, in force until 15 September 2015) provided that a person could lodge a complaint with a court about an act or decision by any State or municipal authority or official if he or she considered that the act or decision had violated his or her rights and freedoms.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F085", "text": "Article 255 of the Code of Civil Procedure (Chapter 25, in force until 15 September 2015) provided that the complaint could concern any decision, act or omission which had violated the person's rights or freedoms, had impeded their exercise, or had imposed a duty or liability on that person.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F086", "text": "Article 256 of the Code of Civil Procedure (Chapter 25, in force until 15 September 2015) provided that the complaint had to be lodged with a court of general jurisdiction within three months of the date on which the complainant had learnt of the breach of his rights.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F087", "text": "In Ruling no. 2 of 10 February 2009, the Plenary Supreme Court of Russia stated that the procedure under Chapter 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure was not applicable to challenges against actions, omissions or decisions for which the Code of Administrative Offences did not establish a review procedure and which, being intrinsically linked to a given case of administrative offence charges, were not amenable to a separate review (paragraph 7 of the Ruling).", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F088", "text": "In Ruling no. 2 of 10 February 2009, the Plenary Supreme Court of Russia stated that the above statement was relevant for evidence in cases where certain measures were recorded, for instance in a record of transfer to a police station or a record of administrative arrest.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F089", "text": "In Ruling no. 2 of 10 February 2009, the Plenary Supreme Court of Russia stated that in circumstances where measures were recorded in a record of transfer to a police station or a record of administrative arrest, arguments relating to the inadmissibility of a piece of evidence or measure could be presented during examination of the administrative offence case or on appeal against a decision in such a case.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}, {"fact_id": "F090", "text": "In Ruling no. 2 of 10 February 2009, the Plenary Supreme Court of Russia stated that where administrative proceedings were discontinued, any actions taken during the proceedings could then be challenged under Chapter 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure, if they impinged upon the person's rights or freedoms, created obstacles to their being exercised, or imposed liability unlawfully.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": ["prevention_of_disorder", "prevention_of_crime", "rights_of_others"]}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F006", "F007", "F008", "F003", "F004", "F018", "F025", "F026", "F027", "F014", "F031", "F045", "F055", "F056", "F011", "F012", "F013"], "interference": ["F011", "F012", "F013", "F015", "F016", "F019", "F061", "F062", "F065"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F073", "F076", "F055", "F015", "F016", "F019"], "positive_obligation": ["F003", "F011", "F012", "F013", "F014"]}, "list2": {"scope": ["F006", "F008", "F018", "F026", "F055", "F011"], "interference": ["F015", "F016", "F019"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F073", "F076", "F016", "F019"], "positive_obligation": ["F011", "F013", "F014"]}, "list3": ["F006", "F008", "F018", "F026", "F011", "F015", "F016", "F019", "F073", "F076"]}} {"case_name": "case_707", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}} {"case_name": "case_708", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The applicant was born in 1984.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicant lives in Ankara.", "source_paragraph": 5, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "On 26 October 2008 a press conference was held in Gaziantep to protest about the conditions of detention and alleged ill-treatment of Abdullah Öcalan, the leader of the PKK (an illegal armed organisation).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "On 26 October 2008 a demonstration was held in Gaziantep to protest about the conditions of detention and alleged ill-treatment of Abdullah Öcalan, the leader of the PKK (an illegal armed organisation).", "source_paragraph": 6, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F005", "text": "According to a police report dated 31 December 2008, on 26 October 2008 clashes occurred between demonstrators and the police in three neighbourhoods in Gaziantep.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F006", "text": "According to a police report dated 20 January 2009, on 26 October 2008 clashes occurred between demonstrators and the police in three neighbourhoods in Gaziantep.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F007", "text": "As a result of the clashes on 26 October 2008 in Gaziantep, eleven police officers were injured.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F008", "text": "As a result of the clashes on 26 October 2008 in Gaziantep, police vehicles were damaged by some demonstrators who threw stones.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F009", "text": "As a result of the clashes on 26 October 2008 in Gaziantep, public buildings were damaged by some demonstrators who threw stones.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F010", "text": "In the police reports dated 31 December 2008 and 20 January 2009, it was noted that four photographs of a crowd had been taken by DIHA (Dicle News Agency) correspondents.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F011", "text": "The four photographs taken by DIHA (Dicle News Agency) correspondents were published in the local media.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F012", "text": "The four photographs taken by DIHA (Dicle News Agency) correspondents were published in media controlled by the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F013", "text": "In the photographs, a person who had covered his head with a hood and his face with a puşi was seen.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F014", "text": "The police officers who had prepared the reports dated 31 December 2008 and 20 January 2009 had found out that the person seen in the photographs with a covered head and face was the applicant.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F015", "text": "The police officers who had prepared the reports dated 31 December 2008 and 20 January 2009 had found out that the applicant had been active in the Patriotic Democratic Youth Assembly (Yurtsever Demokratik Gençlik Meclisi), a youth organisation which was, according to the police reports, linked to the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 7, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F016", "text": "On 18 February 2009 the Adana public prosecutor filed a bill of indictment against the applicant and one other person with the Adana Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F017", "text": "The Adana public prosecutor noted in the bill of indictment that the applicant had participated in the gathering which had started in front of one of the offices of the Party for a Democratic Society (Demokratik Toplum Partisi – DTP) in Gaziantep.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F018", "text": "The Adana public prosecutor noted in the bill of indictment that the applicant had covered his face during the gathering in front of one of the offices of the Party for a Democratic Society (Demokratik Toplum Partisi – DTP) in Gaziantep.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F019", "text": "The Adana public prosecutor noted in the bill of indictment that the applicant had chanted slogans during the gathering in front of one of the offices of the Party for a Democratic Society (Demokratik Toplum Partisi – DTP) in Gaziantep.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F020", "text": "The Adana public prosecutor relied on the photographs referred to by the police in the reports dated 31 December 2008 and 20 January 2009.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F021", "text": "The applicant was charged with membership of an illegal organisation under Article 220 § 6 of the Turkish Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F022", "text": "The applicant was charged with membership of an illegal organisation under Article 314 of the Turkish Criminal Code.", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F023", "text": "The applicant was charged with disseminating propaganda in favour of the PKK under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 8, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F024", "text": "On 12 March 2009 the applicant was arrested in relation to the charges brought against him in the bill of indictment of 18 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F025", "text": "Following his arrest on 12 March 2009, the applicant was subsequently detained on remand in relation to the charges brought against him in the bill of indictment of 18 February 2009.", "source_paragraph": 9, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F026", "text": "On 20 March 2009 the Adana Assize Court held the first hearing in the case.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F027", "text": "During the first hearing on 20 March 2009, the applicant made his defence statements.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F028", "text": "The applicant contended during the first hearing that he had never participated in meetings or demonstrations organised by the Party for a Democratic Society (Demokratik Toplum Partisi – DTP).", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F029", "text": "The applicant contended during the first hearing that he had not participated in the gathering in front of the Party for a Democratic Society (Demokratik Toplum Partisi – DTP) office on 26 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F030", "text": "When shown the photographs in the case file during the first hearing, the applicant denied the allegation that the person in the photographs was him.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F031", "text": "At the end of the first hearing on 20 March 2009, the Adana Assize Court ordered the applicant's release pending trial.", "source_paragraph": 10, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F032", "text": "At the second hearing held on 3 April 2009, the Adana public prosecutor submitted his observations on the merits of the case to the Adana Assize Court.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F033", "text": "At the second hearing held on 3 April 2009, the Adana public prosecutor asked the Adana Assize Court to convict the applicant as charged.", "source_paragraph": 11, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F034", "text": "At the fourth hearing held on 9 June 2009, the applicant made his final defence submissions.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F035", "text": "At the fourth hearing held on 9 June 2009, the applicant's co-accused made their final defence submissions.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F036", "text": "At the fourth hearing held on 9 June 2009, the applicant once again denied that he had participated in the gathering of 26 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 12, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F037", "text": "On 9 June 2009 the Adana Assize Court convicted the applicant of membership of an illegal organisation, the PKK, under Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code, on the basis of Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 § 3 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F038", "text": "On 9 June 2009 the Adana Assize Court sentenced the applicant to six years and three months' imprisonment for membership of an illegal organisation, the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F039", "text": "On 9 June 2009 the Adana Assize Court convicted the applicant of disseminating propaganda in support of the PKK under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F040", "text": "On 9 June 2009 the Adana Assize Court sentenced the applicant to ten months' imprisonment for disseminating propaganda in support of the PKK under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 13, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F041", "text": "The Adana Assize Court noted that the evidence available as regards the applicant included photographs of him among demonstrators with his face partially covered with a puşi.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F042", "text": "The Adana Assize Court noted that the evidence available as regards the applicant included the police report of 20 January 2009, according to which the applicant was one of the people who had participated in the illegal demonstration at around 1 p.m. on 26 October 2008 and chanted slogans and thrown stones at the police.", "source_paragraph": 14, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F043", "text": "The Adana Assize Court found it established that a press conference had been held in front of the Party for a Democratic Society (Demokratik Toplum Partisi – DTP) building on 26 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F044", "text": "The Adana Assize Court found it established that a press statement had been made at the press conference held in front of the Party for a Democratic Society (Demokratik Toplum Partisi – DTP) building on 26 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F045", "text": "The Adana Assize Court noted that during the press conference on 26 October 2008, demonstrators had chanted slogans in support of the PKK and its leader.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F046", "text": "The Adana Assize Court noted that the security forces had intervened after having heard the slogans chanted during the press conference on 26 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F047", "text": "The Adana Assize Court noted that clashes had occurred between the police and the demonstrators on 26 October 2008, which had resulted in the wounding of some police officers.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F048", "text": "The Adana Assize Court noted that clashes had occurred between the police and the demonstrators on 26 October 2008, which had resulted in damage to private and public vehicles.", "source_paragraph": 15, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F049", "text": "The Adana Assize Court found it established that the applicant had participated in the demonstration of 26 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F050", "text": "The Adana Assize Court found it established that the applicant had covered his face during the illegal demonstration of 26 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F051", "text": "The Adana Assize Court found it established that the applicant had disseminated propaganda in favour of the PKK by chanting slogans supporting the PKK and its leader during the demonstration of 26 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F052", "text": "The Adana Assize Court considered it established that the person in the photographs was the applicant, although he had his face partially covered.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F053", "text": "The Adana Assize Court decided to convict the applicant of disseminating propaganda in support of the PKK under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713).", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F054", "text": "The Adana Assize Court noted that the applicant had participated in the demonstration of 26 October 2008 as a result of the call put out by the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F055", "text": "The Adana Assize Court found that there was insufficient evidence to show that the applicant was a member of the PKK.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F056", "text": "The Adana Assize Court found that the applicant's participation in the demonstration of 26 October 2008 showed that he had committed criminal offences on behalf of the PKK, and therefore convicted him of membership of the PKK under Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code, on the basis of Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 § 3 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F057", "text": "The Adana Assize Court noted that there was no evidence showing that the applicant had been involved in acts of violence during the demonstration of 26 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F058", "text": "The Adana Assize Court acquitted the applicant of any charges relating to causing injury or damage in connection with the demonstration of 26 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 16, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F059", "text": "On 10 June 2009 the applicant appealed against the judgment of the Adana Assize Court of 9 June 2009.", "source_paragraph": 17, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F060", "text": "On 18 August 2009 the applicant started to serve his prison sentence.", "source_paragraph": 18, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F061", "text": "On 8 July 2010 the Court of Cassation dismissed the applicant's appeal against the judgment of 9 June 2009.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F062", "text": "On 8 July 2010 the Court of Cassation upheld the judgment of the Adana Assize Court of 9 June 2009.", "source_paragraph": 19, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "A. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 of the Criminal Code, and section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713)"]}, {"fact_id": "F063", "text": "On 5 July 2012 Law no. 6352, amending various laws with a view to suspending proceedings and sentences given in cases concerning crimes committed through the press and media and similar expressions of opinions, entered into force.", "source_paragraph": 20, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F064", "text": "On 12 July 2012 the Adana Assize Court decided to defer the execution of the sentences the applicant had been given in the judgment of 9 June 2009, pending its examination of the applicant's application for revision, reduction or suspension of the sentences in the light of the provisions of Law no. 6352 of 5 July 2012.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F065", "text": "The applicant was released from prison on 12 July 2012.", "source_paragraph": 21, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F066", "text": "On 20 December 2012 the Adana Assize Court rejected the applicant's application for revision, reduction or suspension of the sentence imposed under Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code, on the basis of Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 § 3 of the same Code, which had been given in the judgment of 9 June 2009.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F067", "text": "On 20 December 2012 the Adana Assize Court rejected the applicant's application for revision, reduction or suspension of the sentence imposed under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713), which had been given in the judgment of 9 June 2009.", "source_paragraph": 22, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F068", "text": "On 11 April 2013 Law no. 6459 amending Article 220 § 6 of the Turkish Criminal Code entered into force.", "source_paragraph": 23, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F069", "text": "On 20 June 2013, in the light of the amendment made to Article 220 § 6 of the Turkish Criminal Code by Law no. 6459, the Adana Assize Court decided to suspend the execution of the prison sentence given to the applicant under Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code, on the basis of Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 § 3 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 24, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F070", "text": "On 5 November 2013 the Adana Assize Court quashed the applicant's criminal conviction under Article 314 § 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code, on the basis of Article 220 § 6 and Article 314 § 3 of the same Code.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F071", "text": "On 5 November 2013 the Adana Assize Court rejected the applicant's application for the conviction under section 7(2) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (Law no. 3713) to be quashed, in the light of its considerations in its judgment of 9 June 2009 and, in particular, in the light of the fact that the applicant had participated in the demonstration of 26 October 2008 while he had his face partially covered.", "source_paragraph": 25, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "B. Subsequent developments"]}, {"fact_id": "F072", "text": "In 2009 the applicant was charged with obstructing the security forces in the execution of their duties during the demonstration of 26 October 2008, under sections 32 and 33 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 26, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911)"]}, {"fact_id": "F073", "text": "On 13 December 2012 the Gaziantep Criminal Court convicted the applicant of obstructing the security forces in the execution of their duties during the demonstration of 26 October 2008, under sections 32 and 33 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911)"]}, {"fact_id": "F074", "text": "On 13 December 2012 the Gaziantep Criminal Court sentenced the applicant to two years' imprisonment for obstructing the security forces in the execution of their duties during the demonstration of 26 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 27, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911)"]}, {"fact_id": "F075", "text": "On 30 December 2013 the Court of Cassation quashed the judgment of the Gaziantep Criminal Court of 13 December 2012.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911)"]}, {"fact_id": "F076", "text": "The Court of Cassation held on 30 December 2013 that there was no evidence in the case file in support of the allegation that the applicant had obstructed the security forces in the execution of their duties during the demonstration of 26 October 2008.", "source_paragraph": 28, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911)"]}, {"fact_id": "F077", "text": "On 15 May 2014 the Gaziantep Criminal Court acquitted the applicant of the charges brought against him under sections 32 and 33 of the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911).", "source_paragraph": 29, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "C. Criminal proceedings brought against the applicant under the Meetings and Demonstration Marches Act (Law no. 2911)"]}, {"fact_id": "F078", "text": "The applicant submitted four photographs to the Court which served as the basis for his convictions.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Photographs in the case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F079", "text": "All four photographs show a group of people consisting of men, women and children, standing in front of a building.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Photographs in the case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F080", "text": "In the photographs, a man is seen with a loudhailer.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Photographs in the case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F081", "text": "In the photographs, women and children hold banners.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Photographs in the case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F082", "text": "In all four photographs, a young man who has his head covered with the hood of his jacket and his face covered with a puşi is seen standing.", "source_paragraph": 30, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE", "D. Photographs in the case file"]}, {"fact_id": "F083", "text": "A description of the relevant domestic law applicable at the material time, the domestic practice and the relevant international materials can be found in Işıkırık v. Turkey (no. 41226/09, §§ 30-37, 14 November 2017).", "source_paragraph": 31, "section_path": ["THE FACTS", "II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND INTERNATIONAL MATERIALS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "implied"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F004", "F037", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F055", "F056", "F057", "F058"], "interference": ["F004", "F037", "F038", "F049", "F056", "F060", "F065"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F004", "F037", "F038", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F055", "F056", "F057", "F058"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F004", "F049", "F055", "F057", "F058"], "interference": ["F037", "F038", "F049", "F060", "F065"], "prescribed_by_law": ["F038", "F049", "F050", "F051", "F055", "F056", "F057", "F058"], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": [], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F004", "F037", "F038", "F049", "F051", "F055", "F056", "F057", "F058"]}} {"case_name": "case_709", "atomic_facts": [{"fact_id": "F001", "text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.", "source_paragraph": 3, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F002", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as organisers of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F003", "text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures taken against them as participants of public assemblies.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}, {"fact_id": "F004", "text": "Some applicants also raised other complaints under the provisions of the Convention and its Protocols.", "source_paragraph": 4, "section_path": ["THE FACTS"]}], "conclusion": {"violated": true, "elements": {"scope": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_assembly_exists": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_participation": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "scope_peaceful": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implied"}, "interference": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "explicit"}, "prescribed_by_law": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit"}, "prescribed_by_law_foreseeable": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_accessible": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "prescribed_by_law_safeguards": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}, "legitimate_aim": {"conclusion": "yes", "discussed": "implicit", "aims": []}, "necessity": {"conclusion": "no", "discussed": "explicit"}, "positive_obligation": {"conclusion": null, "discussed": "not_discussed"}}}, "fact_mapping": {"list1": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F001", "F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list2": {"scope": ["F002", "F003"], "interference": ["F002", "F003"], "prescribed_by_law": [], "legitimate_aim": [], "necessity": ["F002", "F003"], "positive_obligation": []}, "list3": ["F002", "F003"]}}