Title stringlengths 15 159 | Body stringlengths 56 7.25k | Comments listlengths 0 27 | Answers listlengths 0 10 |
|---|---|---|---|
Psychology of the Enormous Complexity of Life | Are there any psychologists or a branch of psychology which deals directly with life as a complex reality? Life is enormously complex. By life I mean life as we experience it and the things we need to do in order to maintain even a basic and healthy life. Every day is loaded with micro-level decisions which nevertheles... | [
"One modern field that deals with this area is wisdom: \"... the ability to apply knowledge, experience, and good judgment to navigate life’s complexities.\"",
"Not enough for an answer, but way back 100 or so years ago, Gestalt Psychology was arising. Anything more modern would seem to specialize and differentia... | [
{
"body": "A psychology that doesn’t recognise the complexity of life would, IMO, be fairly unhelpful.\nAny of the following might meet your criterion, and I can think of others.\nHere’s a short selection – I’m sure you can find more by searching online.\n\nSweller’s Cognitive Load Theory\nFrankl’s Existential ... |
Validity of CliftonStrengths | Trying to find information about the validity of CliftonStrengths.
For a commercial, restricted test (which perhaps is not classified as test by the owner) it can be hard to find independent verification/opinions, and even this question might attract some interest from the owner company :)
There's an older question abo... | [] | [
{
"body": "I shudder at the thought of using it.\nReid, J. R., & Short, L. (2024). A critical analysis of strengths-based assessment and development: The case of the CliftonStrengths assessment. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research.\nhttps://www.researchgate.net/publication/384935651_Cautionary_... |
Can an atheist ever feel mass hysteria or mass psychogenic illness? | Like in this question, I have seen only videos related to spirituality. Are there any instances where atheist people (or person) have been subject to mass hysteria? Do these experiences only happen to religious people? | [
"en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_psychogenic_illness has some non-religious examples.",
"Has anyone thought that mass hysteria could be an example of strong emergence?"
] | [
{
"body": "Yes, definitely.\nI had anorexia nervosa for 15 years and I would consider it as a psychogenic mass illness.\nAlso the atheism is a point worth to discuss, thus anorexia is known as a \"religious\" practice of e.g. nuns, but in our time it is more a mixture between societal pressure, genetics, and p... |
Are there any studies that have examined the narcissism levels of scientists in philosophy, mathematics and physics? | I would be interested in studies on this topic. I think that obviously false theories are defended for too long due to high narcissism scores. | [
"Not an answer, but one thing worth noting is that scientists in these fields start out as students in these fields, and students in these fields are quite often convenience samples for human studies. Thus, even if there are no studies of narcissism in scientists, there are very likely to be studies of narcissism i... | [] |
Why do certain individuals struggle to memorize song lyrics? | Some people have a hard time memorizing song lyrics, even after repeated listening.
What individual factors contribute to the difficulty in remembering song lyrics? | [] | [
{
"body": "Music is a specific form of memory assistance called a mnemonic device. For some it creates connections. Those connections may not be articulable but the brain finds them.\nHow often one hears a song, the context, and any emotional attachments to the meaning can affect how well lyrics are retained. A... |
Dealing with regression assumption Issues | In our master's thesis, our goal was to model several (partially multiple) linear regressions. However, some of the assumptions were not met, such as the linearity of the variables. Additionally, some of the variables do not correlate significantly with each other. A possible reason for the violation of the assumptions... | [
"You are absolutely not alone in these misunderstandings of statistics, you'll find them in many many published papers. But it sounds like where you are at in your understanding right now is not at a place where you're really ready to assess regression assumptions, you need to take a few steps back and understand w... | [
{
"body": "I think you are mixing up a few things.\n\nCorrelation is not a prerequisite for regression; in fact, regression can be used to investigate whether there is a correlation between parameters, and by how much, and whether it is significant or not.\nSufficient power is also not an assumption for regress... |
What are your thoughts on Accelerated Resolution Therapy? | Recently I came into contact with my aunt, and it seems she has been doing very well. She has been developing a therapy technique that, she claims, helps resolves psychological problems from trauma, child abuse, domestic abuse, et cetera. She calls it Accelerated Resolution Therapy.
The essential thesis of her techniqu... | [
"My concern, other than lack of research, is simply that it requires a denial of the absolute truth, consequently instilling a lie. For this reason, I will stick with EMDR and other research-support therapies that are based in the reality and not denial of past events.",
"ART appears to be strongly based on EMDR,... | [
{
"body": "My concern is that there are many therapies being broadly promoted without sufficient evidence of effectiveness and this one is calling itself 'evidence-based\". I worry that time and resources are being invested and that clients are being promised amazing, if not unbelievable, benefits. Clients may ... |
Where can I find all the items on the SCTi-MAP? | I want to conduct the test with my friends and gain some insight into psychological analysis, but I can’t find the full list anywhere. | [] | [] |
Is there a mental disorder in which one is unable to determine personal preferences, and as a result, is a cause of great distress? | I know that our preferences and tastes help shape our behaviors and what activities we willingly engage in, but I also know that being faced with indecision is a common feature of the human experience. However, I wanted to know if there is a mental disorder classified in the DSM or elsewhere, where an individual's inde... | [
"Welcome to Psychology.SE. We work differently to most SE sites, where we have a strict policy that all questions should show evidence of prior research. Please help us to help you and edit your question to provide more information on what you have read on this subject, what made you ask this question, and any prob... | [
{
"body": "There is no specific symptom criteria in DSM that matches your description. It’s a very general problem that can be conceptualized in a variety of ways. \nThe closest thing I can think of that resembles your description would be generalized anxiety disorder (GAD). Dugas and Ladoceur claims in their r... |
What really is 'Consciousness'? | I'm more concerned about the biological aspect of this question than the psychological one (although both are equally bewildering). But what makes our brain conscious of one thing and unconscious of another? | [] | [
{
"body": "...what makes our brain conscious of one thing and unconscious of another?\n\nUnder normal conditions, our brain itself regulates what we are conscious of and what we suppress (or don't perceive). By conscious, I'll assume you mean aware. Why are we aware of the news on the television, but not consci... |
Would you classify confusion as an emotion? | I'm writing a short essay on emotions and I stumbled upon a few references of confusion being an emotion but no solid exclusive research results focusing on confusion as an emotion. If it isn't, what classification would it fit?
Few references: https://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/114/38/E7900.full.pdf (page E7901) which ... | [
"Confusion only happens when your with dangerous people and or someone or something involving the paranormal. Everything can be explained logically the things that cant are either because a person is in the process of being manipulated or entities/spirits are involved. Yes supernatural activity is real its not slee... | [
{
"body": "Cambridge Dictionary defines confusion as \"a situation in which people do not understand what is happening, what they should do or who someone or something is.\" This means that confusion occurs in one's thoughts, in the brain. \nI define emotion as \"an irritation of the heart\" or simply \"a heart... |
Is there such a thing as "emotional impedance"? | More specifically, what I would call emotional reactance. What this is would be the emotional equivalent of electrical reactance(which is the opposition to changes in voltage and current flow). So a person who experiences something that upsets them will be able to modulate those unpleasant emotions such that they decay... | [
"Often it is helpful for others if the asker provides some previous research they have done. For instance, your hunch tells you that emotions are negated over time, yet PTSD sufferers will tell you otherwise. Refining your question by specifying exactly what you are referring to helps to make the question more answ... | [] |
Is there a specific name for a delusional belief that you're your own duplicate? | I was watching a film where something like this was the twist ending and it got me thinking, "If somebody believes that they're an impostor of themself is there a name for that and if there is then what is it?"
The name of Impostor Syndrome makes it sound like a perfect fit, but it's not. Impostor syndrome is where one... | [] | [] |
What happens to someone missing teenage years of development? | Hypothetically, let's say a person were to fall into a coma as an adolescent for several years, until they were a physical adult.
Would that person, assuming the brain was still fully functional upon awakening, still maintain the immaturity and impulsiveness of a teenager, and if so, could it be corrected by just tryin... | [
"@Chris wonderful to have you around here. I'm looking forward to this upcoming contribution.",
"This post has been flagged for closure due to the posibility of it being primarily opinion-based however I am going to try and construct an answer for this as I feel it can be answered from a psychotherapy/psychology ... | [
{
"body": "Whilst typing this answer, I upvoted this question as it points to very interesting theories of drive, motivation, and personal development.\nShort Answer\nIf you take on board the theories surrounding life-span human development, there is an element of truth in your hypothesis. Elements of immaturi... |
Does the autistic child have a “theory of mind”? | Theory of Mind involves understanding another person's knowledge, beliefs, emotions, and intentions and applying that knowledge to navigate the social world. | [] | [
{
"body": "note: See comment by Arnon Weinberg; though this answer refers to theory of mind deficits in autism, it appears this is outdated thinking (note the age of some of the references).\nTheory of mind refers to an ability to recognize that others have a mind, and that others may have knowledge/beliefs/mot... |
Is there any study in the science about these true stories of babies? | For babies from several-month old to 4-year old, most of them get their parents frustrated(e.g. most babies often cry). But I heard of true stories of several babies. These true stories have the following common or similar parts about such babies:
After being left alone, such babies usually don't cry. He/She can play ... | [
"@yo-yos This isn't a good site to collect anecdotes on, and we ask that questions be based on something more than anecdote/personal observation. I know that can be frustrating when you're trying to look for evidence that a phenomenon exists, but it helps us keep the site clear of people asking about all their pers... | [] |
Can the items of UCLA Loneliness Scale not be called symptoms? | When did the question raise?
I am working on the data of 8 itemed UCLA Loneliness (ULS-8) [1] and 9 itemed PHQ [2] (PHQ-9) scales. I found that in the study of PHQ-9 [2], the authors mentioned the 9 items as symptoms. However, in the study on the ULS-8 scale [1], the authors did not mention the 8 items as the symptom. ... | [
"If anyone is interested in getting insights regarding this question, please check this researchgate.net/post/…"
] | [] |
Is there a link between Imposter Phenomenon and dreams of unfulfilled ambitions? | Imposter Syndrome is a popular topic in both scientific studies and pop-psychology articles. Less common is Imposter Phenomenon, wherein an attempt is made to be more conscientious about the subject. I have not done any extensive searches, but will accept this review article's conclusion that better research methodolog... | [] | [] |
How to prepare yours for daily risky routine like flying planes? | Obviously you need certain personal traits to be a pilot or a surgeon. But if you make a mistake someone dies, you might be included. So I think there have to be studies on how to prepare before you fly a plain or attempt a surgery or go into a gunfight etc.
What would a psychologist recommend to prepare for a day like... | [
"@BoppityBop asks \"BTW are you a pilot?\". Actually I do have a pilot's licence, but that's irrelevant. Any commercial flight where the pilot has to mentally prepare for the risk is not a flight you want to take. Every pilot I've known was extremely calm and took everything in stride, no preparation necessary. Bu... | [] |
Term for someone that makes themselves sad to pass it onto others? | Is there a term for somebody that will purposely make themselves feel sad, and perhaps other negative feelings, with the intention of making another person feel them too?
This would be a way of emotionally hurting someone, without having to physically touch them.
I am not looking for strictly academic literature, rathe... | [] | [] |
Why is it so hard to forget an information represented in a procedural memory | It is relatively easy to forget an information in declarative memory but its hard to forget behavioural habits such as driving car, cycling etc. These memories are both long-term memory but why is it so hard to forget behavioural habits? | [] | [] |
Alternative metrics to assess test validity/reliability | I have two versions of calculating a score for a test (which assesses how well they perform a task). One takes into account the difficulty of the items, the other does not. These tests are administered at different times. Each test is independent from the other. I expect some subjects to learn the task fairly quickly a... | [
"It's not about whether we believe it's necessary or not. Of course you can calculate test-retest reliability on any two samples, and that's just saying that you can calculate correlations between any two samples. But I don't know of any example of this and I suspect it's for a very good reason, namely: if each ind... | [] |
What work has been done studying methodological reforms in psychology after the replication crisis? | Can anyone point me to academic work that systematically studies how standards and methods have changed in psychology as a response to the replication crisis? Thanks. | [
"@information_parasite Research isn't monolithic, and there is no one-size-fits-all strategy to reforms.",
"@ARogueAnt. I've spent an hour or so on Google Scholar looking for context, and I haven't found anything. I found plenty of papers arguing for this or that reform, but so far none that systematically docume... | [
{
"body": "Ok, I came across \"Open science and reform practices in organizational behavior research over time (2011 to 2019)\" (Tenney et al. 2021), a paper which studies some Organization Behaviour journals over the last decade and concludes that there hasn't been widespread adoption of research practice refo... |
Can people learn without examples? | When learning various topics (math comes to mind as a good example), to what extent is information retained/understood affected by whether or not examples of the concept or process are provided?
For example, I was learning about encryption and absorbed quite a few whitepapers, but nothing stuck until I came across an i... | [
"Welcome to psych.SE. Much of the first half of the twentieth century was dedicated to research on learning without examples (conditioning). The example provided in the question is a \"worked example\", so maybe you are asking about the worked example effect?"
] | [] |
Is there a reason I cannot find those that specialize in psychiatry and psychology? | Any time I look this up, I only seem to find the differences between the two. I'm aware of the difference enough to know that one is generally someone you consult with to work out problems, while the other actually deals with the medical side of things.
What I want to know - and cannot find out - is why I cannot find ... | [] | [
{
"body": "Largely because in most (if not all) jurisdictions:\npsychiatrist = medical doctor + psychologist\nSo psychiatrists believe that they are, in fact, \"someone you consult with to work out problems\" and \"deals with the medical side of things.\"\nHowever, in practice, having many years of medical trai... |
Term for this Manipulation tactic -- saying "we" instead of "i" | The term is for when a manipulator keeps saying "we" this, "we" that, when really they should be saying "I". It's a form of manipulation I believe is called "forced" something.
Youtubers do it a lot.
The term is not "royal we" or "majestic plural".
I cannot remember what this term was called.
EDIT: What I'm referring t... | [] | [
{
"body": "Fake/false consensus effect.\nAs the authors of the associated article in effectivology.com put it:\n\nThe false-consensus effect is a cognitive bias that causes people to\noverestimate how much others are like them, in terms of sharing things\nsuch as their beliefs, values, characteristics, experien... |
Dialectical Behavior Therapy's Biosocial Theory - Social Environment Validates Patients' Maladaptive Behavior - As Defined By Who/What? | In Wikipedia's article about DBT, in the overview section it says:
In DBT's biosocial theory of BPD, clients have a biological predisposition for emotional dysregulation, and their social environment validates maladaptive behavior.
According to the theory, "maladaptive behavior" - as defined by who/what - the patient... | [] | [
{
"body": "Just as a point of note, you said you are quoting from Wikipedia, but it is actually WikiWand you are linking to.\nThe article cited Little, et al. (2018) which states that (emphasis mine):\n\nDBT is based on a biosocial theory of BPD, which posits that the core difficulties seen in this diagnosis st... |
Are there any movies or series involving someone with ADHD? | Aside from How I Met Your Mother, The Simpsons (or Finding Nemo, if that counts, which i don't think it does), are there any movies or series involving someone explicitly stated or highly believed to have ADHD? I can't seem to find any on Google.
There are movies or series about schizophrenia such as A Beautiful Mind, ... | [
"Hands down parks and rec. I don’t think it was intentional but Leslie Knope is the perfect portrayal of adhd/ocd in w WOMAN which has only been more recently discovered to present differently than in men. Even a bit of anxiety sometimes ( I have all of these diagnoses) . Plus Chris is a classic example of high fun... | [
{
"body": "The problem with ADHD is that it doesn't really have its own trademark indicator, the way that schizophrenia or Asperger's might. There are several different subtypes of ADHD, and they tend to look different from each other, particularly in the instance of ADHD with hyperactivity and ADHD-PI (primari... |
How do I counter the argument that since each person is different, there can't ever be a general scientific theory to blanket the minds? | I am interested in psychology and psychiatry but often a counter argument given by others when I bring up this topic is that since each person is different mentally, there can't be a general all encompassing theory. In response, I agree to what they say and say that it is the same case with medicine. All our physiologi... | [
"Every snowflake is different. Therefore it is impossible to have general theories about snowflakes.",
"What also do you mean by \"in defense of psychology and psychiatry\"? The argument that everyone is different and theories are untestable in the traditional scientific sense is in defense. Especially against t... | [
{
"body": "From a neuroscientific point of view, our brains are really quite similar. Two mechanisms come into play during the brain's development: nature and nurture (the extent of each giving birth to a major debate over the years).\nThe \"nature\" part is our genome, which sets the ground rules. The genome m... |
What is the inverse of anthropomorphism? | Anthropomorphism is the attribution of human traits, emotions, or intentions to non-human entities. However, one often can observe the inverse happening as well. Namely the attribution of non-human entities’ traits, emotions, or intentions to human entities. For example the biography book about Winston Churchill is cal... | [
"@BryanKrause I believe there is a sense of anthropomorphism which is definitely linked to neuroscience and psychology. Perhaps OP should edit their question to fit this sense more. See my other comment for elaboration on the neuroscientific sense of anthropomorphism.",
"I think this depends on the context behind... | [
{
"body": "Wikipedia explains zoomorphism,\n\nContrary to anthropomorphism, which views animal or non-animal\nbehavior in human terms, zoomorphism is the tendency of viewing human\nbehavior in terms of the behavior of animals.",
"comments": []
}
] |
Gender stereotypes | Guys i am new in gender studies, but somethings is really puzzeling to me. In Gender, nature, and Nurture from Richard A. Lippa there are comment about role of gender stereotypes in making "typical male or female work in home at so on": in our culture - typical women should take care about children and man should make ... | [
"@Chris Rogers Thank you for your comments to my question. I really appreciated it.",
"\"What is gender\" is another big subject in its own right which has a bearing on gender stereotypes. As the YouTube video you linked to in your question discusses, there is more awareness of gender fluidity and non-binary gend... | [
{
"body": "To answer your question, (from a social constructivist approach to gender stereotypes, and gender roles) both from \"gender roles\" and \"culture\". However, there are other approaches to conceptualizing gender in development that differ.\nFor example, a main feature of Liben and Bigler’s (2002) soc... |
Making a risk assessment type scale using existing scales | I am trying to make a risk assessment type scale that measures the likelihood/risk of someone experiencing a psychological disorder in a setting. There are about 10 factors (e.g., gender, sleep quality, self-esteem, resilience, loneliness) that increase the likelihood and I would like to include these in the new scale.... | [] | [] |
Recent Peer Review Studies on How Many Have Narcissistic Personality Disorder | Are there any peer-reviewed studies that show what percent of the population are believed to have Narcissistic Personality Disorder that have been published within the past ten years? I have read about studies that list the percent of people with NPD, but all of them came out on or before two thousand ten and may no lo... | [
"@Ooker No problem. Glad it helped",
"thank you so much",
"@Ooker Sure. I answered the question to the best of my abilities. Hope it helps!",
"If possible, can you help me on this question? Many thanks How widespread is learned-helplessness in society?"
] | [
{
"body": "While not a peer-reviewed study per se, but the DSM-5 says that the prevalence of Narcissistic Personality Disorder in the population is 6.2%, or approximately one out of sixteen members of the population (6.25%). The DSM-V was published in 2013 and is a peer-reviewed text, so it is within the 10 yea... |
At what point do dopamine/serotonin receptors become downregulated/upregulated? | It's well known that behaviors like pornography viewing lead to dopamine receptor downregulation to compensate for the extreme stimulation. Obviously, drugs like methamphetamine would lead to an even more profound downregulation if used.
When are receptors in this context downregulated or not? If pornography downregula... | [] | [] |
Correlation between sexual repression in adolescents and sexual deviancy later in life? | Is there a correlation between sexual repression and sexual deviancy?
Now we all have heard stories of people growing up in incredibly strict households that become some of the most exploratory and sexually deviant persons as soon as they get a 'taste of freedom' in college, or kids that went to Catholic schools that s... | [
"Hi Joseph, I agree with Arnon that it would be helpful to define \"sexual repression\" and \"sexual deviancy\". For example, for \"sexual repression\", could this be defined by teaching abstinence in health class in public school? Or could this be something that occurs in the household? Or, as in your example, ... | [
{
"body": "I think this question is not really about strict religious upbringings or sexuality at all, this is really about the broader issue of rebellious attitudes and anti-authoritarianism.\nNo matter what controlled environment with particular sets of rules that groups of people find themselves in, there wi... |
The "Triune brain" model is obsolete, what is the name of the model that replaces it? | The Triune brain model suggests our brains evolved adding more layers, a lizard brain, then a mammal brain, then a new human brain. As that's false, and the same structures have become modified in different ways in different lineages, what is the name of this current model? | [
"@Fizz Thank you, that's actually very helpful.",
"If you just want to read on some more recent theories, see \"mosaic brain hypothesis\" vs \"concerted bran theory\" royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rspb.2016.0433",
"\"replaces\" assumes the [evolutionary] triune model (and the replacement) were/are wide... | [
{
"body": "There isn’t a new model, exactly, since as the poster stated, the brain doesn’t operate as a model and earlier versions of brain structures simply modify themselves to evolve— it’s one brain. Meaning, one’s “lizard brain” is actually just a mammalian brain now. The new model perhaps is The Human Brai... |
what are some careers in psychology where you dont have to interact with people | I am a psychology student, just finished my BA. I like the subject psychology, but i just don't like interacting with people. I would prefer to work alone. I wouldn't mind once in a while interactions such as once a month but being around people everyday is too draining. | [
"What interests you? See if you can combine your passion in a manner that incorporates your psychology training."
] | [] |
How to make phrases in experimental conditions as similar as possible? | In behavioral economics and psychology, there are many experiments where participants receive variations of a piece of text depending on the experimental condition they are assigned to. For example, Beenen et al. [1] "used different messages in [an] invitation email to vary [an online community users'] perceptions of t... | [] | [] |
Are we different or same? | I don't know if this is the right site to ask this, if not sorry for that I am new here......
I am wondering if two childs from different parents from different regions are kept in a completely empty room, do they behave same or different and for why(for the genes? and they are just children, like pure children without... | [] | [
{
"body": "Welcome to Psychology.SE.\nWhen you ask\n\nif two childs from different parents from different regions are kept in a completely empty room, do they behave same or different\n\nthat is a question which is heavily debated in Psychology. It all boils down to the nature vs nurture or nature vs environmen... |
Where can I find open data for psychology research on meditation? | I would like to know how I can get free access to data obtained from psychological experiments conducted to study the effects of meditation on the brain. Ex : FMRI data and the like | [
"Contact the researchers that performed the studies that are found by web-search ‘fmri meditation’."
] | [
{
"body": "Kaggle has a dataset of an EEG conducted on a meditation group versus a control.\nOther than that, if you are looking for the raw datasets of fmri meditation studies, that may be a little more difficult. If you are fine with summary statistics, and some inferential tests (data that has already been a... |
Are the personality tests (specifically, the big five test) in open source psychometric project reliable? | Are the personality tests (specifically, the big five test) in open source psychometric project reliable?
Link : https://openpsychometrics.org/ | [] | [] |
Where can i find old archived patient records from 19th century psychiatric hospitals? | I do not have university access and do not want to spend money on protected documents. I am looking for free access. (Possibly I would spend money for original documents which should then be sent to me. ;) ) | [
"Perhaps a better place to ask this would be here - academia.stackexchange.com"
] | [
{
"body": "A Google search for patient records from 19th century psychiatric hospitals (no quotes) turns up relevant results, though not for free access.\nFor example, here's a service from The National Archives (UK) that looks like exactly what you're talking about. And another one from New Zealand. I'm sure t... |
Should I define each and every term while writing an article for a psychology journal? | I am writing a review article on dialectical behavioral therapy. If in the article, there are technical terms related to behavioral therapy, so, should I define each of the terms while writing the article or should I assume that the readers/editor/reviewers of the psychology journal know all these terms. For example: A... | [
"Welcome to psych.SE. This may be more of an opinion-based question that wouldn't be a good fit for this forum. I believe it's common practice to define terms that are important to the main content (like CBT), and for other terms (like conditioning), link to their definitions elsewhere."
] | [
{
"body": "This question may be better directed to academia.se.\nIn the first instance, you should check the editorial requirements of the journal you are targeting. Most journals prescribe that it is mandatory to spell out acronyms with first usage. It is possible that some very specific technical journals w... |
Are psychologists more immune to psychological problems? | Does knowledge of a psychological problem prevent (or enable one to better defend) the development of psychological issues? For example, if a person has studied about depression and is familiar with the causes and cures of it, is that person more able to prevent himself/herself from going into depression?
Are there sta... | [
"I would break this into two subsets: 1) bias based issues 2) genuine mental health issues The first group: Like a dietician knowing what foodgroups to cook, psychologists should generally be aware of the many bias that their personal schema produce. That said, perhaps it's like doctors who smoke? The second group:... | [
{
"body": "Barriers to Psychologists Seeking Mental Health Care by Jennifer L. Bearse, Mark R. McMinn, Winston Seegobin, and Kurt Free of George Fox University asks a similar question.\n\nProfessional psychologists provide help to people in need, but how freely do psychologists seek psychotherapy themselves whe... |
Short form of the Psychopathic Personality Inventory questionnaire | Recently I have been reviewing several articles related to psychopathy outside the forensic area and I have observed that a very popular questionnaire in a college setting is the Psychopathic Personality Inventory(PPI). So far I have not been able to find this questionnaire explicitly.
As far as I understand, the quest... | [] | [
{
"body": "An open version of the PPI is available here: https://openpsychometrics.org/tests/LSRP.php",
"comments": [
"Thanks Chris. The original question cited a 2001 reference. Prior to answering the question, I edited the question to include the 1996 reference. But you are correct, the 1995 refe... |
Why do some individuals enjoy watching scary videos? | Does watching scary videos affect mental health?
Are some individuals more/less prone to feeling scared than others? | [] | [
{
"body": "Below are some reasons why some people enjoy and what happens when watching a scary movie:\n\nHorror entertainment can trigger the fight-or-flight response, which comes with a boost in adrenaline, endorphins, and dopamine. The brain can then process surroundings and conclude that the experience is no... |
Why does Jung suggest that we need to defend our psyche from original religious experience? | I am reading "Psychology and Religion" which is a transcribed lecture by Carl Jung. In this lecture he mentions several times how the psyche uses dogma and ritual to defend again original religious experience or as a substitute. I understand why we might want to substitute for original religious experience, but I don'... | [
"This question is not about Jungian Analysis. I won't even touch whether or not Jung is a scientist. But if you think there is a better forum for a Jung question than Psychology, then please let me know, I will post there instead.",
"@ Arnon Weinberg - the question is about the validity of a statement. No matte... | [
{
"body": "For a really quick and clear understanding of why sometimes it is better to stay in the container of dogma read Edward Edinger's Moby Dick.\nJung's position is that religious energy must only sometimes be defended against. The entire process of Jungian Analysis does, in fact, consist of a process of ... |
Excitement level in OCEAN model | So, I would like to know what facet regulates these behaviours / cahracteristics of a person:
How loud and fast-talking they are (on average).
Their excitement level (on average).
Excitement seeking (1) (2) (3) (4) is defined as facet that tells how much a person seeks excitement, but does it tells how much a person ... | [] | [
{
"body": "It sounds like an aspect of extraversion. I.e., loud and fast talking sounds like gregariousness and assertiveness. In general, extraverts are also more active and expressive.\nFor example, the NEO-PI-R has facets of extraversion as follows:\n(E1) Warmth (E2)\nGregariousness (E3) Assertiveness (E4) ... |
Do children really show brand preference at age 2? | As I was reading a marketing textbook, I came across a paragraph that stated research has shown children as young as two can show brand preference (although I haven't yet searched for the source in the back of the book to check what research it's referring to.)
Research shows that children evidence brand preferences a... | [
"Makes sense. I believe that just about everything in ads in any medium targeting any demographic is manipulating whoever is paying attention to it. I tell my girls that pretty much every commercial is a scam and they seem to get it. I was also raised on generics and I can't say I have any real brand allegiance per... | [
{
"body": "Is it really the case that children are showing brand preference, preferring one brand over others when presented options, because of a specific affinity for that brand?\nAccording to research, it does seem that way.\nA longitudinal study of 20 years (Guest, 1964) found that brand preferences origina... |
Sublimation & Cathexis | I was aware about a term called Sublimation. Recently, I came along a word called Cathexis. After looking for its meaning in the dictionary, I realised, that it is not the synonym of Sublimation despite the meaning being quite similar. How do I differentiate between Sublimation and Cathexis? Are there any similarities... | [] | [
{
"body": "I would say subliminal is more cognitive, while cathexis is more emotional, though can be triggered/catalysed cognitive or subliminal.\nSubliminal is hard to define though, and cathexis from the field of psychoanalysis is kind of speculative. However there is obviously some kind of mechanism occuring... |
Does a positive response to antidepressants confirm the patient was in fact depressed? | Or, here is another way of phrasing this question… What might happen if you gave antidepressants to a neurotypical patient? Would the patient experience mania or giddiness, or would they simply not experience a change in mood at all?
Depression, like other mood disorders, is diagnosed based on symptoms experienced by t... | [] | [
{
"body": "So full disclosure, my background isn't in clinical psych so this is based largely on what i remember from undergrad and some very surface level literature searching but i'll provide sources for any specific claims :) Also, obligatory disclaimer: No part of this response is intended as any kind of me... |
Bibliotherapy in the treatment of depersonalization | Sometimes very strange things happen to people's psyches. Depersonalization is one such phenomenon.
Depersonalization is a painful experience of one’s own change, change in one’s own mental processes, one’s own “I”: patients complain that they have become “something different from before”, “lost emotions, feelings”, “... | [] | [] |
How does cognitive therapy work? | A depressed person has a negative self-conception. Cognitive therapists believe that the negative self-conception is the cause of the depression. This doesn't make sense to me.
Suppose a person with depression is unemployed, uneducated, idle, regarded by others as having little worth, and therefore they're socially iso... | [] | [] |
Do psychiatrists take into account affects on the different serotonin receptor types and subtypes when cycling anti-depressants in patients? | If someone is going through SSRIs to find one that works, doesn't it make sense to target each receptor in turn rather than the same one with different drugs (like prozac and zoloft, for example)? Is this considered when prescribing anti-depressants?
Is it even possible? | [
"What do you mean by \"each receptor in turn\"? Which receptors?"
] | [
{
"body": "Short answer, no.\nAfter lifestyle changes (optimising diet, exercise and social engagement) and psychotherapy (e.g. cognitive-behavioural therapy) have been trialled, most psychiatrists will commence a patient on selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI), like Prozac or Zoloft. If this is triall... |
Can Depression be a Psychosomatic Disorder in some people? | I was reading about Thomas Szasz's critique of psychiatry for my Psychology class and studies on Contagion Depression, such as those involving rats and John Calhoun's Universe 25 experiment, as well as research like Rosenhan's 'On Being Sane in Insane Places' and Solomon Asch's experiments, now I am drawn to investigat... | [] | [] |
Are a lot of highly logical people (such as mathematicians) prone to depression? | In my mathematics and physics classes, half the students are seeing, or have seen, psychologists because of depression. Based on my experience, I feel that there is a huge correlation between logical people doing mathematics, physics, informatics, programming, making computer games and depression. Is this just a person... | [
"@n0tis: \"Our work shows that the price of higher intelligence and more complex behaviours is more mental illness.\" cogsci.stackexchange.com/questions/5333/…",
"Only it it were shown that \"more logic-based employees\" actually are depressed.",
"Because this question is based off your personal experie... | [
{
"body": "Overall, based on my limited research it appears there is no evidence that people who are more logical are more likely to experience depression. There is a theory that people who see the world more accurately (of which rationality would be a component) are more likely to become depressed. It is calle... |
Having issue in functional connectivity of difference matrix between patient group and control group | I am following a paper to calculate functional connectivity of difference between MDD (major depressive disorder group) and Control group. I am getting more connectivity in MDD as compared to control group in certain frequency bands. The paper after calculating binary matrix and plotting it in 3D is getting region spec... | [
"For a large enough sample, I would be more surprised about connections that do not appear different between populations than surprised about connections that do show some significant difference.",
"@BryanKrause Right, thanks. Also, according to you, should subtracting average of MDD patients with average of cont... | [] |
Medical treatment for depression | Should depression be treated with excitatory or inhibitory medications?
Normally I have seen inhibitory drugs being prescribed for depression, hence my question. | [
"...Addressing these items greatly clarifies the question and brings focus to your post. This, in turn, facilitates better answers.",
"Welcome. We generally encourage that questions are accompanied by evidence of prior research. Evidently, you have done so, given your 2nd line in the question body. What did you f... | [
{
"body": "Indeed most medication types of Antidepressants are inhibitory such as Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, Serotonin–norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors, Norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors, and Norepinephrine–dopamine reuptake inhibitors, etc.\nHowever, surprisingly some research shows deprivatio... |
The relationship between sunlight and depression | Background information:
I recently had a discussion with my friend about a disagreement when renting an apartment and whether or not he should rent a house that faces the sun. My friend has a diagnosis of depression, and he was concerned that a room facing west would cause him to not receive enough sunlight and back ag... | [] | [
{
"body": "According to (my personal experience and) Wikipedia, your friend is right in that the amount of sun exposure might affect their mood: \"The incidence of melancholic depression has been found to increase when the temperature and/or sunlight are low.\" [Melancholia@Wikipedia]\nNevertheless, there are o... |
What happens to your body when overcoming side effects of SSRIs? | When you start taking SSRIs your body experiences side effects like vomiting, headaches, diarrhea etc.
Apparently these side effects go away after regular consumption.
What happens inside your body to make the side effects disappear?
My hypothesis is that your body adjusts to the extra stimuli in the environment via th... | [] | [
{
"body": "Well, I think that's a good question!\nThe resolution of side effects following the initiation of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) can be attributed to the capacity of the human body to adapt to alterations in its internal chemical milieu.\nFirst, let's have a quick review of the mecha... |
What can happen if a human takes SB-243213? | SB-243213 acts as a selective inverse agonist for the 5-HT2C receptor.
The 5-HT2C receptor is one of many 5-HT receptors which are receptors that bind serotonin, and seems to play a major role in both suicide (some suicide victims have an abnormally high number of 5-HT2C receptors in the prefrontal cortex) and schizoph... | [
"Incredibly high selectivity might not be the best thing in a medication due to potential dosing errors. See fentanyl and its \"super\" derivatives... There is such a thing as serotonin syndrome (e.g. overdosing with SSRI).",
"Welcome to Psychology & Neuroscience SE! \"I'll continue to update this post as I find ... | [
{
"body": "SB 243213 is an active, selective and high-affinity 5-HT2C receptor antagonist. It has improved anxiolytic profile and has the potential for schizophrenia and motor disorders.",
"comments": [
"Welcome and thanks for including your source of information. We encourage answers with some more b... |
Why the concept of "nervous breakdown" has been discarded by psychologists? | Why the concept of "nervous breakdown" (in French crise de nerfs) has been discarded in the field of psychology (although some medicine and psychology researchers argue for its usefulness)?
This situation has been well described in the Wikipedia article.
I understand that "nervous breakdown" has been basically replaced... | [
"@ChrisRogers I moved my personal analysis into an answer. My question was downvoted, I don't know the reason why. Anyway, the personal analysis being moved out renders the question clearer.",
"@ChrisRogers \"To me, there can be cases of stress, anxiety and depression among those who score low on neuroticism.\" T... | [
{
"body": "Definition of \"nervous breakdown\"\nThe \"nervous breakdown\" could be defined as:\nthe onset of the first symptoms of anxiety/depression caused by a no further capacity to cope with stressful life events\n\nUse of the concept for research and treatment\nTo me, the term \"nervous breakdown\" is very... |
Can hallucinogens treat depressive states? | Given the serotonin hypothesis of depression, increasing synaptic serotonin level may cause anti-depressive effects.
Hallucinogens seems to have such advantages:
They improve mood at once, but not after a while as SSRI. So hallucinogens may actually act faster.
There are more types of hallucinogens, then there are... | [
"Apparently, this is currently being investigated."
] | [
{
"body": "Most of the 'true' hallucinogens are classified as 5HT2A agonists. 5HT2A is a postsynaptic serotonin receptor. Serotonin-specific reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) on the other hand act by increasing serotonin (5HT) levels in the brain, which in turn activates presynaptic 5HT1A receptors. Due to a continuo... |
Understanding ketamine, the role of synatptic placitity in Major Depression | I am having a bit of an issue with my intuitive understanding of Ketamine's newfound role in treating depression. It is my understanding that Ketamine works by allowing synaptogenesis. The evidence for this mechanism seems to be quite robust. However, it leaves me with a nagging question. Why would excessive pruning of... | [] | [] |
Why could too much BDNF be detrimental in terms of depression and memory? | I am interested in looking at the effects of too much BDNF and other proteins such as repressor element one silencing transcription factor (REST). Most research suggest that elevated levels are protective, however there is a small amount of research suggesting that too much (over expression) may actually be detrimental... | [
"Here are two more papers on BDNF-overexpressing transgenic mice: Mice over-expressing BDNF in forebrain neurons develop an altered behavioral phenotype with age doi.org/10.1016/j.bbr.2014.04.025 Working memory deficits, increased anxiety-like traits, and seizure susceptibility in BDNF overexpressing mice doi.org... | [
{
"body": "This is a fairly open-ended question... One example of the potentially negative consequences of overexpressed BDNF is its effect on the likelihood and frequency of epileptic seizures.\nI guess the short version of this effect is that BDNF appears to promote neuronal growth, including neurogenesis, a... |
Can the effectiveness of antidepressants be explained by a placebo effect? | A friend of mine showed me a paper (Kirsch, 2014) where the author claims that antidepressants work mostly through a placebo effect (backed up with relevant citations). Antidepressants are generally serotonin enhancers and their mechanism of action hinges on the premise that there is a chemical imbalance of serotonin i... | [] | [
{
"body": "Short answer\nDon't believe everything you read.\nBackground\n\nThe article cited (Kirsch, 2014) appears in a German journal with a mediocre impact factor. Not the most convincing platform.\nI'll cite parts of the abstract, starting with\n\n\nBut analyses of the published data and the unpublished dat... |
Can the items of UCLA Loneliness Scale not be called symptoms? | When did the question raise?
I am working on the data of 8 itemed UCLA Loneliness (ULS-8) [1] and 9 itemed PHQ [2] (PHQ-9) scales. I found that in the study of PHQ-9 [2], the authors mentioned the 9 items as symptoms. However, in the study on the ULS-8 scale [1], the authors did not mention the 8 items as the symptom. ... | [
"If anyone is interested in getting insights regarding this question, please check this researchgate.net/post/…"
] | [] |
Are self-reported depression scores from inpatient facilities used to measure the efficacy of different pharmaceuticals? | In the United States, patients with clinical depression are somtimes hospitalized for sucidal ideation or attempted suicide. It is common practice to prevent patients from discharging themselves from the behavioral health center (or other facility). The outer doors are kept locked. Only.staff with a key may enter or le... | [
"\"it is standard practice to ask patients each day on a scale of 1 to 10 how depressed they are feeling\" - can you link to a reliable source backing this claim? Are they purely asking for just a 1-10 rating from the patient or are they assessing the scale from a series of questions?",
"I'm not sure what sort of... | [] |
Does belief in an afterlife play a role in suicide rates? | Religious beliefs, in particular views on the afterlife, could plausibly influence suicide.
Is there some study which tries to look at how belief systems play a role in the number of suicides in some country or in the world? | [] | [
{
"body": "I think, from a statistical point of view, this question will be impossible to answer, because belief in an afterlife is almost always tied to powerful confounding factors, such as participation in a community of fellow believers, marital status, age, etc. I imagine that religious affiliation probabl... |
Is there a term for grief triggered from merely seeing, or remembering, places that a griever enjoyed with loved ones? | The loved ones don't have to be dead. The may simply be too ill or senile. The griever may be anticipating grief. I am not asking about nostalgia or wistfulness — the bleakness, forlornness are much gloomier here.
Consider an adult who — whenever he happens upon, or remembers, a venue that he as a child used to freq... | [] | [
{
"body": "Desiderium, saudade.\nDesiderium being dragged into English by Thomas Aquinas from the works of Aristotle: an intense desire or longing for that which is lost (such as a time) which may never be regained.\nSaudade being adopted from Portuguese, first usage uncertain: a profound melancholic longing fo... |
Is depression linked to having difficulty into doing activities that are intensive (be it physically or mentally)? | Practicing exercise is recommended to treat depression for example.
But I think people, in general, if they are with depression tend to deal with it by doing activities that don't suppose much effort and give some reward in the least costly way (be it from playing videogames to consuming certain drugs, as long as they ... | [
"To be clear, I agree that depression results in decreased physical activity overall, but I believe the primary cause is lack of motivation. Your hypothesis appears to be that depressed persons select activities mainly based on cost. I hypothesise that the selection is based more on total stimulation, regardless of... | [] |
Do cognitive distortions not exist at all in non-depressed people? | Cognitive distortions like All-or-nothing thinking, Fortune Teller Error; do they exist in non-depressed people with a low intensity as well or they do not have these things at all? In other way, having cognitive distortions is the root cause of depression or having those distortions with high intensity is actually the... | [
"Elaborating on Michael's first point - a good idea would be to research 'depressive realism' and concerned experiments. It holds that in some cases, depressed persons can make more accurate inferences then their non-depressed counterparts. However, these rose-tinted glass that non-depressed people see through are ... | [
{
"body": "The short answer is yes.\nWhile research has indicated that anxiety, stress or depression can lead to cognitive distortions (Panourgia & Comoretto, 2017), they can exist without it (Gilbert, 1998).\n\nIt is suggested that cognitive distortions are natural consequences of using fast track defensive al... |
Do you think depressed people relate to dark and depressive internet memes, almost like a coping mechanism? | For example, this study found that they could be usefull | [
"That doesn't seem to be what the study's suggesting, more that dark subjects injected with humour may lift depression. Please take our tour and refer to the help center for guidance as to our ways. What's your question here, could you edit to clarify?"
] | [
{
"body": "In a similar vein, research shows a link between self-identification with \"darkness\" and depression, however a causal link in this relationship has not be supported.\nMore specifically, Bowes et al. (2015) found that teens that identified as \"goth\" were more likely to self-report depression, as c... |
Does replacing social media use with solitary activities alleviate loneliness? | Many studies about problematic social media use have suggested that social media increases loneliness. The typical hypothesis given is that social media displaces time spent in face-to-face social interactions. I cannot help but wonder:
Would engaging in solitary constructive activities (e.g. reading, art) provide a de... | [
"\"some studies suggest meaning can alleviate loneliness\". That's interesting if they say meaning alone without social context. Could you please provide examples of this for context and question clarity?",
"Well, one example is that some studies suggest meaning can alleviate loneliness. So, from this point of vi... | [] |
How to offer support to an American acquaintance with depression? | So, an online acquaintance of mine has mentioned that they're suffering from severe depression recently, and my natural response is to want to offer them support and encouragement - maybe suggest that they should see a psychologist and get some medication for the condition. However, I'm uncertain of how to do so, since... | [
"Rebecca's answer here is possibly relevant: meta.stackexchange.com/a/340597/401068",
"@Ooker I'm sure that professional help would doubtlessly be of assistance to them, but I'm uncertain if they'd be able to afford it or not.",
"I wonder if this question should be classified as seeking for professional help? B... | [
{
"body": "How untrained people should approach interactions with depressed people or any other mental health problem?\nThe main point to make is that you must not try to counsel them.\nI believe you may have worked this out for yourself, and I don't want to sound patronising and \"tell you how to suck eggs\", ... |
Using Vagus Nerve Stimulation to treat Depression | I came across an article written recently concerning the use of Vagus Nerve Stimulation (VNS) to treat difficult-to-treat depression (DTD) and other mood disorders (Sackeim, et al. 2020). However, there is a conflict of interest with all the authors, as reported by PubMed:
Professor Sackeim serves as a scientific advi... | [] | [] |
Are some latitudes or climates more conducive to human happiness than others? | Background
The 19th century Chinese political philosopher and dissident Kang Youwei wrote that among the more severe miseries of this life are: premature death, mutilation, slavery, and living outside of China. And Kang was hardly an innovator in this respect; indeed, he seems to have drawn on a long tradition in Chine... | [
"@Fizz I'm aware of SAD, but that - on its own - is a bit too narrow for what I'm trying to get at here. SAD, as I understand it, describes the unconscious, physiological effect of a lack of sunlight on a person's mood. But, in addition to that, I want to understand the psychological effects of summer and winter, a... | [] |
Any studies that assess effects of treatment to individual depression symptoms | As an study/research idea, I have been going through articles about treatment response (mostly SSRI and other antidepressants) related to treating depression, but many studies seem to be mostly reporting changes in total scores (eg BDI or PHQ) whereas I haven't really seen much research analyzing the effect of treatmen... | [] | [
{
"body": "To my mind, there are several reasons why this isn't the standard procedure. One reason is that Likert-type items are ordinal data, which means that standard statistical methods such as linear regression and t-tests shouldn't be used. Instead, non-parametric tests need to be used, and those generally... |
Can people fake mental illness to gain sympathy? | In the last decade, a lot of famous personalities and celebrities have opened up about suffering from mental disorders, largely depression. This has caused the younger generation to accept and seek help more easily than before, which is good, but my question deals with the authenticity of such claims on social media.
A... | [
"yes ,the phenomenon is called sadfishing ,acting hurt or vulnerable to gather attention. dictionary.com/e/slang/sadfishing There are psychological assessments in order to ascertain if criminals are really mentally ill or just faking.( many try to d... | [
{
"body": "Yes,many celebrities have talked about mental illness they have ,or have recovered.\nMost common is depression,bulimia,anorexia,OCD and sometimes bipolar,PTSD.\n[Not shocking since showbiz is majorly concerned about perfection and beauty to the the narrow standards prevalent].\nSometimes these claims... |
Can CBT cure any kind of depression? | CBT: Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, no doubt is far better than medications while having long terms goals in mind, but the question is: can it cure any kind of depression, like Seasonal Affective Disorder, Melancholic Depression etc? Or there are a few kinds of depression that can be cured only through medications? | [] | [
{
"body": "\"Cure\" is a very risky word here. If I stick to it, the answer is no, because no treatment is 100% successful; not in all cases. Let's talk about significant outcomes.\nCBT is not the only therapy that science has proven to have aceptable outcomes in depression treatment. Also Interpersonal Therapy... |
Are psychologists more immune to psychological problems? | Does knowledge of a psychological problem prevent (or enable one to better defend) the development of psychological issues? For example, if a person has studied about depression and is familiar with the causes and cures of it, is that person more able to prevent himself/herself from going into depression?
Are there sta... | [
"I would break this into two subsets: 1) bias based issues 2) genuine mental health issues The first group: Like a dietician knowing what foodgroups to cook, psychologists should generally be aware of the many bias that their personal schema produce. That said, perhaps it's like doctors who smoke? The second group:... | [
{
"body": "Barriers to Psychologists Seeking Mental Health Care by Jennifer L. Bearse, Mark R. McMinn, Winston Seegobin, and Kurt Free of George Fox University asks a similar question.\n\nProfessional psychologists provide help to people in need, but how freely do psychologists seek psychotherapy themselves whe... |
What has changed in your brain after electroconvulsive "therapy" (ECT)? | From this Wikipedia article:
Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), formerly known as electroshock therapy, is a psychiatric treatment in which seizures in the brain (without muscular convulsions) are electrically induced in patients to provide relief from mental disorders.1 Typically, 70 to 120 volts are applied externally... | [] | [
{
"body": "There is actually quite some information on this. After a cursory Google Scholar search using the keywords \"long-term neuronal effect of ECT\" I found the following effects on the brain:\n\nA week or two after the ECT, gray matter of depressed patients seemed to be increased in volume throughout the... |
Is serotonin conclusively linked to depression? | Some highlights from the article "The Depressing News about Anti-Depressants":
ever since a seminal study in 1998, whose findings were reinforced by landmark research in The Journal of the American Medical Association last month, that evidence has come with a big asterisk. Yes, the drugs are effective, in that they li... | [
"Related question about tianeptine cogsci.stackexchange.com/questions/18685/…"
] | [
{
"body": "It's all about the receptors, really. There are 7 families of serotonin receptors that perform different functions within the brain, and according to Wikipedia 14 different subtypes have been discovered. \nThe article assumes that a blanket level of serotonin would be sufficient to \"perk\" up the b... |
Asking "What's wrong in you life?" → Person sees more problems | I think if you ask a person "What's wrong in your life?" several times (for example monthly) the person starts to focus on negative things.
Maybe questions like this can have a negative outcome. The person will focus on (maybe even search) things which are negative. These questions might influence his attention. And fi... | [
"These are questions to answer which you need to analyze negative things in your life. Isn't it obvious and inevitable that they force you to think about negative things? The only case where you wouldn't do it is if you either don't understand the question or don't care to answer it."
] | [
{
"body": "Q: Would sparsely repeated negative prompts have negative long-term outcomes?\nA: Probably not, but more research would be needed to provide a definitive answer.\nNorem & Chang (2002) argue that how negative (or positive) cognitions affect individuals depends on their predisposition. For example, a ... |
Probiotics and Mental Health | While trying to find research articles within the realm of Psychosynthesis, I have been looking at the "collective unconscious"
Image Source: Wikipedia Commons - (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Lower Unconscious
Middle Unconscious
Higher Unconscious
Field of Consciousness
Conscious Self or "I"
Higher Self
Collective Unconscious
Cond... | [
"The diet I am on now for Hashimoto thyroiditis using Steven Gundry's The Plant Paradox basically takes the view you have presented here giving priority to the gut microbiome or more generally holobiome. It would not just be for mental health.",
"Very interesting. Thanks @ArnonWeinberg",
"Check out youtu.be/2y... | [
{
"body": "The following, and more, is available at my blog article Microbiome and Probiotics: Gut bacteria can affect your mental health?\nAnswer to Question 1:\n\nCan poor mental health affect the bidirectional communication between gut microbes and the brain?\n\nEven though there is cross talk between your e... |
Explanation of anti-depressive effect of newer antipsychotics | In my understanding, many newer antipsychotics (e.g. olanzapine and quetiapine) are considered to have an anti-depressive effect.
Olanzapine:
For olanzapine I found this on wikipedia: "it [olanzapine] is superior [to haloperidol] for the treatment of negative and depressive symptoms." 1
Quetiapine:
Is approaved by the ... | [
"I think it's a good question but probably not known; the claims are made (as you've cited) based on clinical data, not mechanistic understanding. Antidepressant mechanisms remain quite a mystery, with a lot of suggestive data for different hypotheses but no firm conclusions; likely the answer involves some complex... | [] |
Why does suicide risk increase just after starting an antidepressant? | There are many ways of treating depression, one of which is administering antidepressants. From this site, and several others, I read that risk of suicide increases after starting an antidepressant.
A few people do become more agitated, depressed, and anxious shortly
after an antidepressant is started or after the d... | [] | [
{
"body": "This comes from talking to a psychiatrist about the issue:\nOne of the effects of depression is a loss of motivation. In some suicidal individuals, this has the result that they want to die, but can't work up the motivation to do anything about it. Once they start taking antidepressants, however, t... |
What's the opposite of major depressive disorder? | Bipolar disorder, BD, involves manic episodes and depressive episodes.
If someone has a depressive episode, that person may have major depressive disorder, MDD or BD.
If someone has a manic episode, that person may have ___________ or BD.
So, what is the opposite of MDD?
It seems that "mania" is a term that describes a... | [
"Someone needs to seriously study \"major manic disorder\" because the only time I experience depression is when I drink alcohol.",
"I did not mean to say that it would be easy or pleasant to stay awake for a week without sleeping but merely that it would not kill or cause significant lasting harm to the average ... | [
{
"body": "There are two ways to interpret/answer this question. First, is there a recognized disorder that is characterized by mania in the absence of depression? Second, are there people who experience mania in the absence of depression?\nThe answer to the first interpretation is no. There is currently no \"m... |
What is the approximate average duration of a SCID-5 interview for diagnosing winter depression? | What is the approximate average duration of a DSM-V structured clinical interview for diagnosing winter depression? I would be very grateful for the answer! | [] | [] |
Causality regarding neurotransmitter imbalance and depression | Neurotransmitter imbalances are blamed for various psychiatric conditions (depression, ADHD, etc). Clearly plasma levels of neurotransmitters are confirmed to be abnormal in some people with such conditions. BUT, has causality ever been proven?
That is; for example, does a serotonin deficiency cause depression or doe... | [] | [
{
"body": "I have what is mostly a frame-challenge to your question as an answer: the simple \"neurotransmitter imbalance\" hypothesis is a bit outdated, and it hasn't been strongly influential in a research context for a very long time.\nRather, it is an extremely oversimplified way to try to explain that ther... |
Reducing smoking and mental health benefits | Recently I noticed improved mental health (better mood, better cognition? more energy) after reducing smoking.Is it backed up by research?
I know stopping smoking is, but reducing?
http://www.pulsetoday.co.uk/clinical/clinical-specialties/mental-health/stopping-smoking-as-effective-as-antidepressants-at-improving-mood... | [] | [] |
Why do people commit suicide? | I don't understand why people commit suicide.
If I imagine myself in a really bad situation and make a list of what kind of things I would do in that situation, I don't have suicide even in my top-100 things to do in my list! In the worst situation I would abandon everything and go on a trip!
So why do people not just... | [
"There are some close votes due to the question being primarily opinion based. While there is some personalization in the question, the topic itself is the subject of extensive research and seems to have plenty of solid empirical ground to stand on."
] | [
{
"body": "People who kill themselves usually believe that they are in an unbearable situation from which they cannot escape and that things won't ever get better.\nThe problem with research into the reasons for suicide is that those that successfuly killed themselves can no longer explain their motives, and th... |
why we failed to convince our own mind by reasoning and rational arguments over mental illness like depression, anxiety, phobia? | For example, one of my friend has fear of heights, even if there is a strong glass window and no reason for him to fall off. He is even aware and admits his fear is irrational.
Many may say it’s in subconscious mind or neurologically left brain, in that case, can you let me know experiments(better if I can do it myself... | [
"Good advice, removed question on ‘placebo effect’ and added one reference. Will add more.",
"\"If not, then how placebo effect works?\" How is this related to your question? Regardless, I recommend against asking follow-up questions which presume an answer to your original question. Therefore, this is best edite... | [
{
"body": "Some scientists will say that a fear of heights (and spiders, snakes, and the dark) are innate, i.e. that we are born with them because they confer an evolutionary advantage. In other words, a fear of heights tends to prevent falls, and a fear of snakes tends to prevent snake bites. We tend to have l... |
How does psychiatry judge suicide by military and political leaders? | Peru's ex-president Garcia's suicide to avoid arrest reminded me of general officers and politicians who, although wicked, were foxy but rational. They ought've been punished, but they cunningly escaped punishment through suicide.
I'm assuming that some of the jumpers in the Sep 11 2001 attacks on the WTC weren't judge... | [
"With Japanese, there is the history of the Kamikaze. There is also the practice of Seppuku/Harakiri"
] | [
{
"body": "Suicide is not a psychiatric disorder. Suicidal ideation or attempts are considered a symptom of certain psychiatric disorders (e.g. depression), and these disorders are treated by psychiatrists, but in and of itself suicide can be a rational choice and is in some legislations even legally facilitate... |
Triptans and SSRIs | When talking about triptans used for migraines such as Zolimitriptan, such drugs are selective serotonin receptor agonists.
SSRIs, as their function states, are Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors.
The British National Formulary doesn't say so, but I am wondering if triptans can affect the efficacy of SSRIs. If so,... | [] | [
{
"body": "triptans could help boost the efficacy of SSRIs \n\nThere is minimal evidence for this Chris. One of the reasons for that is that there is a limit to how much serotonin is released for the nerve cell. So more of the same isn't going to make much difference. \nedit: So in terms of reuptake inhibitors,... |
How much ashwagandha to relieve depression? | I've read this article, where is the herb ashwagandha which could treat depression.
Particularly:
In one controlled 60-day study in 64 stressed adults, those who took
600 mg of high-concentration ashwagandha extract per day reported a
79% reduction in severe depression, while the placebo group reported a
10% inc... | [
"I can't find better study, that confirms or disconfirms if ashwagandha helps for depression. Should I delete the question and rather ask for \"if it helps at all\"?",
"@xralf - your other study you linked in comments tested on rats, not humans. Although the results indicate a possible benefit in rats, it doesn'... | [] |
Is depression part of who a person is? | I have been diagnosed with major depressive disorder, commonly known as depression.
Some days ago I had a discussion with my therapist about whether or not depression is part of the person I am. She says that indeed it is and that I should accept it as a part of my being. I should not fight it, but rather accept it. I ... | [
"Welcome to psych.SE. If I am diagnosed with type 1 diabetes (currently incurable), then should I accept the illness as part of me (I am diabetic), or view it as something I have (I have diabetes)? It is both and either to different people and at different times - at times it is something to fight and at others i... | [
{
"body": "Depression can be defined as \"a state of feeling sad\" (Merriam-Webster), which is an emotion or a feeling in the heart. \nDepression can develop as a reaction to a thought, demand, event or word someone said to you.\nYou may have a certain \"character\" or \"temper\" that makes you vulnerable for t... |
Neuralink in depression treatment | In this article there is a statement that
Neuralink can help people with Parkinson’s disease, epilepsy, and
depression by promptly sending electric pulses into the areas
responsible for their specific symptoms.
Could you refer me to the detailed information about depression treatment via
Neuralink? | [
"@BryanKrause I agree with xralf. That would provide a suitable answer. As to the specific system, pointing out there are no studies can be part of that answer. If studies ever show up, a new answer can be posted.",
"@BryanKrause If the mechanism will be the same or similar as Neuralink it may be the answer. I'm ... | [] |
Can SSRI make things worse in the long term or cause delayed depression? | I found two articles that mention that taking SSRI for depression can actually make the depression worse.
"Now Antidepressant-Induced Chronic Depression Has a Name: Tardive Dysphoria" on Psychology Today.
"Antidepressants Make Things Worse in the Long Term" on the Behaviorism and Mental Health blog.
Is this true? Can... | [
"Just an assumption, it seems if a neurotransmitter removal mechanism is inhibited, probably there will be a product inhibition in the upstream processes such as release and biosynthesis. imo a better strategy could be using a stimulator that enhance biosynthesis as well as release process. The reuptake process wil... | [
{
"body": "Contrary to another post here, in my opinion and also that of an increasing majority of researchers studying this field, SSRIs and the so called 'antidepressant' drugs cause great harm.\nFirstly here is a list of common side effects: Insomnia (which is common in depression anyway), increased anxiousn... |
Recovery of memory especially working memory after depression | The impact of depression on memory and working memory has been discussed extensively in the thread below.
I can't seem to find information about rehabilitation and recovery of memory after depression.
Has there been any studies looking at memory improvement after depression?
What effect can depression have on memory... | [
"Thanks Bryan. I have not seen any evidence or links between recalled memory in any rehabilitation literature. At a push, maybe recalled memory is a marker for general recovery of memory but I can't see any evidence of that. Happy to be corrected of course. But now instead of focusing on the various aspects of memo... | [] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.