{ "benchmark": "MESI-KV Multi-Agent Disaggregated Coherence & Fine-Grained AST/SQLite Benchmark", "concurrency_levels": [ 1, 2, 4, 8 ], "operations_per_level": 500, "wire_header_memory_overhead": { "Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct (L=36, H_kv=2, D=128)": { "header_wire_bytes": 32, "block_tokens": 128, "per_layer_fp16_kv_bytes": 131072, "full_block_fp16_kv_bytes": 4718592, "overhead_vs_per_layer_pct": 0.0244140625, "overhead_vs_full_block_pct": 0.0006781684027777778 }, "Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct (L=28, H_kv=4, D=128)": { "header_wire_bytes": 32, "block_tokens": 128, "per_layer_fp16_kv_bytes": 262144, "full_block_fp16_kv_bytes": 7340032, "overhead_vs_per_layer_pct": 0.01220703125, "overhead_vs_full_block_pct": 0.0004359654017857143 }, "Qwen2.5-Coder-14B-Instruct (L=48, H_kv=8, D=128)": { "header_wire_bytes": 32, "block_tokens": 128, "per_layer_fp16_kv_bytes": 524288, "full_block_fp16_kv_bytes": 25165824, "overhead_vs_per_layer_pct": 0.006103515625, "overhead_vs_full_block_pct": 0.00012715657552083334 } }, "aggregate_by_mode": { "No-Coherence": { "mean_stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 49.0, "mean_stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 88.14, "mean_silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 100.0, "mean_false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0, "mean_false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "mean_read_lease_p50_us": 1.79, "mean_read_lease_p99_us": 3.33, "mean_write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0, "mean_write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0 }, "Coarse-File-Table": { "mean_stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "mean_stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "mean_silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "mean_false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 100.0, "mean_false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 100.0, "mean_read_lease_p50_us": 0.73, "mean_read_lease_p99_us": 2.87, "mean_write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0, "mean_write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0 }, "MESI-KV": { "mean_stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "mean_stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "mean_silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "mean_false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0, "mean_false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "mean_read_lease_p50_us": 0.81, "mean_read_lease_p99_us": 2.54, "mean_write_invalidate_p50_us": 5.68, "mean_write_invalidate_p99_us": 20.04 } }, "tau_act_sensitivity_p8": [ { "tau_act": 0.005, "satisfies_theorem2_tau_kv_le_tau_act": false, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 100.0, "commit_validate_p99_us": 6.46 }, { "tau_act": 0.015, "satisfies_theorem2_tau_kv_le_tau_act": false, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 38.3, "commit_validate_p99_us": 6.42 }, { "tau_act": 0.08, "satisfies_theorem2_tau_kv_le_tau_act": false, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "commit_validate_p99_us": 5.67 }, { "tau_act": 0.12, "satisfies_theorem2_tau_kv_le_tau_act": true, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "commit_validate_p99_us": 5.42 }, { "tau_act": 0.2, "satisfies_theorem2_tau_kv_le_tau_act": true, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 2.13, "commit_validate_p99_us": 7.0 }, { "tau_act": 0.4, "satisfies_theorem2_tau_kv_le_tau_act": true, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 100.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "commit_validate_p99_us": 6.04 } ], "results_by_concurrency": { "P=1": { "No-Coherence": { "mode": "No-Coherence", "concurrency_agents": 1, "num_operations": 500, "wall_time_ms": 311.53, "throughput_ops_per_sec": 1605.0, "stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 46.12, "stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 87.93, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 100.0, "false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "raw_counters": { "tool_reads_total": 232, "tool_cache_hits": 169, "stale_tool_cache_hits": 107, "kv_lookups_total": 232, "stale_kv_hits": 204, "collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 464, "collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0, "tainted_commit_attempts": 34, "silent_tainted_commits": 34, "clean_commit_attempts": 43, "false_blocked_clean_commits": 0 }, "directory_latency_us": { "read_lease_p50_us": 1.25, "read_lease_p99_us": 2.46, "write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0, "write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0, "python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0, "sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1946.12 } }, "Coarse-File-Table": { "mode": "Coarse-File-Table", "concurrency_agents": 1, "num_operations": 500, "wall_time_ms": 326.91, "throughput_ops_per_sec": 1529.5, "stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 100.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 100.0, "raw_counters": { "tool_reads_total": 232, "tool_cache_hits": 27, "stale_tool_cache_hits": 0, "kv_lookups_total": 232, "stale_kv_hits": 0, "collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 109, "collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 109, "tainted_commit_attempts": 34, "silent_tainted_commits": 0, "clean_commit_attempts": 43, "false_blocked_clean_commits": 43 }, "directory_latency_us": { "read_lease_p50_us": 0.71, "read_lease_p99_us": 2.71, "write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0, "write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0, "python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0, "sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1896.58 } }, "MESI-KV": { "mode": "MESI-KV", "concurrency_agents": 1, "num_operations": 500, "wall_time_ms": 392.68, "throughput_ops_per_sec": 1273.3, "stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "raw_counters": { "tool_reads_total": 232, "tool_cache_hits": 113, "stale_tool_cache_hits": 0, "kv_lookups_total": 232, "stale_kv_hits": 0, "collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 305, "collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0, "tainted_commit_attempts": 34, "silent_tainted_commits": 0, "clean_commit_attempts": 43, "false_blocked_clean_commits": 0 }, "directory_latency_us": { "read_lease_p50_us": 0.75, "read_lease_p99_us": 1.83, "write_invalidate_p50_us": 5.21, "write_invalidate_p99_us": 17.21, "commit_validate_p50_us": 3.25, "commit_validate_p99_us": 6.33, "python_ast_scan_p50_us": 165.08, "sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1893.67 } } }, "P=2": { "No-Coherence": { "mode": "No-Coherence", "concurrency_agents": 2, "num_operations": 500, "wall_time_ms": 317.2, "throughput_ops_per_sec": 1576.3, "stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 43.26, "stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 89.3, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 100.0, "false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "raw_counters": { "tool_reads_total": 215, "tool_cache_hits": 157, "stale_tool_cache_hits": 93, "kv_lookups_total": 215, "stale_kv_hits": 192, "collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 411, "collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0, "tainted_commit_attempts": 37, "silent_tainted_commits": 37, "clean_commit_attempts": 52, "false_blocked_clean_commits": 0 }, "directory_latency_us": { "read_lease_p50_us": 2.04, "read_lease_p99_us": 3.25, "write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0, "write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0, "python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0, "sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1978.0 } }, "Coarse-File-Table": { "mode": "Coarse-File-Table", "concurrency_agents": 2, "num_operations": 500, "wall_time_ms": 308.5, "throughput_ops_per_sec": 1620.7, "stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 100.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 100.0, "raw_counters": { "tool_reads_total": 215, "tool_cache_hits": 29, "stale_tool_cache_hits": 0, "kv_lookups_total": 215, "stale_kv_hits": 0, "collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 79, "collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 79, "tainted_commit_attempts": 37, "silent_tainted_commits": 0, "clean_commit_attempts": 52, "false_blocked_clean_commits": 52 }, "directory_latency_us": { "read_lease_p50_us": 0.75, "read_lease_p99_us": 2.83, "write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0, "write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0, "python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0, "sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1878.33 } }, "MESI-KV": { "mode": "MESI-KV", "concurrency_agents": 2, "num_operations": 500, "wall_time_ms": 315.43, "throughput_ops_per_sec": 1585.1, "stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "raw_counters": { "tool_reads_total": 215, "tool_cache_hits": 97, "stale_tool_cache_hits": 0, "kv_lookups_total": 215, "stale_kv_hits": 0, "collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 251, "collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0, "tainted_commit_attempts": 37, "silent_tainted_commits": 0, "clean_commit_attempts": 52, "false_blocked_clean_commits": 0 }, "directory_latency_us": { "read_lease_p50_us": 0.83, "read_lease_p99_us": 2.79, "write_invalidate_p50_us": 5.88, "write_invalidate_p99_us": 19.46, "commit_validate_p50_us": 3.25, "commit_validate_p99_us": 6.5, "python_ast_scan_p50_us": 161.92, "sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1914.12 } } }, "P=4": { "No-Coherence": { "mode": "No-Coherence", "concurrency_agents": 4, "num_operations": 500, "wall_time_ms": 399.8, "throughput_ops_per_sec": 1250.6, "stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 42.73, "stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 84.14, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 100.0, "false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "raw_counters": { "tool_reads_total": 227, "tool_cache_hits": 159, "stale_tool_cache_hits": 97, "kv_lookups_total": 227, "stale_kv_hits": 191, "collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 433, "collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0, "tainted_commit_attempts": 38, "silent_tainted_commits": 38, "clean_commit_attempts": 34, "false_blocked_clean_commits": 0 }, "directory_latency_us": { "read_lease_p50_us": 2.08, "read_lease_p99_us": 3.88, "write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0, "write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0, "python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0, "sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 2064.88 } }, "Coarse-File-Table": { "mode": "Coarse-File-Table", "concurrency_agents": 4, "num_operations": 500, "wall_time_ms": 346.35, "throughput_ops_per_sec": 1443.6, "stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 100.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 100.0, "raw_counters": { "tool_reads_total": 227, "tool_cache_hits": 35, "stale_tool_cache_hits": 0, "kv_lookups_total": 227, "stale_kv_hits": 0, "collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 100, "collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 100, "tainted_commit_attempts": 38, "silent_tainted_commits": 0, "clean_commit_attempts": 34, "false_blocked_clean_commits": 34 }, "directory_latency_us": { "read_lease_p50_us": 0.75, "read_lease_p99_us": 2.92, "write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0, "write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0, "python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0, "sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 2011.92 } }, "MESI-KV": { "mode": "MESI-KV", "concurrency_agents": 4, "num_operations": 500, "wall_time_ms": 385.9, "throughput_ops_per_sec": 1295.7, "stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "raw_counters": { "tool_reads_total": 227, "tool_cache_hits": 100, "stale_tool_cache_hits": 0, "kv_lookups_total": 227, "stale_kv_hits": 0, "collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 258, "collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0, "tainted_commit_attempts": 38, "silent_tainted_commits": 0, "clean_commit_attempts": 34, "false_blocked_clean_commits": 0 }, "directory_latency_us": { "read_lease_p50_us": 0.92, "read_lease_p99_us": 3.0, "write_invalidate_p50_us": 6.5, "write_invalidate_p99_us": 24.46, "commit_validate_p50_us": 4.08, "commit_validate_p99_us": 7.0, "python_ast_scan_p50_us": 168.71, "sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1989.42 } } }, "P=8": { "No-Coherence": { "mode": "No-Coherence", "concurrency_agents": 8, "num_operations": 500, "wall_time_ms": 440.91, "throughput_ops_per_sec": 1134.0, "stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 63.89, "stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 91.2, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 100.0, "false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "raw_counters": { "tool_reads_total": 216, "tool_cache_hits": 174, "stale_tool_cache_hits": 138, "kv_lookups_total": 216, "stale_kv_hits": 197, "collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 474, "collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0, "tainted_commit_attempts": 36, "silent_tainted_commits": 36, "clean_commit_attempts": 47, "false_blocked_clean_commits": 0 }, "directory_latency_us": { "read_lease_p50_us": 1.79, "read_lease_p99_us": 3.71, "write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0, "write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0, "python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0, "sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 2004.08 } }, "Coarse-File-Table": { "mode": "Coarse-File-Table", "concurrency_agents": 8, "num_operations": 500, "wall_time_ms": 323.03, "throughput_ops_per_sec": 1547.8, "stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 100.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 100.0, "raw_counters": { "tool_reads_total": 216, "tool_cache_hits": 27, "stale_tool_cache_hits": 0, "kv_lookups_total": 216, "stale_kv_hits": 0, "collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 104, "collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 104, "tainted_commit_attempts": 36, "silent_tainted_commits": 0, "clean_commit_attempts": 47, "false_blocked_clean_commits": 47 }, "directory_latency_us": { "read_lease_p50_us": 0.71, "read_lease_p99_us": 3.0, "write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0, "write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0, "commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0, "python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0, "sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1834.83 } }, "MESI-KV": { "mode": "MESI-KV", "concurrency_agents": 8, "num_operations": 500, "wall_time_ms": 408.07, "throughput_ops_per_sec": 1225.3, "stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0, "silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0, "false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0, "raw_counters": { "tool_reads_total": 216, "tool_cache_hits": 110, "stale_tool_cache_hits": 0, "kv_lookups_total": 216, "stale_kv_hits": 0, "collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 315, "collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0, "tainted_commit_attempts": 36, "silent_tainted_commits": 0, "clean_commit_attempts": 47, "false_blocked_clean_commits": 0 }, "directory_latency_us": { "read_lease_p50_us": 0.75, "read_lease_p99_us": 2.54, "write_invalidate_p50_us": 5.12, "write_invalidate_p99_us": 19.04, "commit_validate_p50_us": 3.29, "commit_validate_p99_us": 5.75, "python_ast_scan_p50_us": 159.21, "sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 2022.08 } } } } }