{ "theorem1_phase_transition": { "parameters": { "p0": 0.78, "p_inf": 0.08, "lambda": 0.55, "mu_rate": 0.45 }, "analytical_population_mean_error_p_bar": 0.395, "analytical_critical_quorum_ratio_phi_crit": 0.69731, "analytical_cov_latency_accuracy": 0.385, "n_sweep": [ { "N": 7, "sync_full_majority_error": 0.28395, "quorum_curve": [ { "k": 3, "phi_eff": 0.4286, "analytical_elem_error": 0.60306, "mc_elem_error": 0.57859, "abs_formula_diff": 0.02447, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.61428, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.1307, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.3775 }, { "k": 3, "phi_eff": 0.4286, "analytical_elem_error": 0.60306, "mc_elem_error": 0.57859, "abs_formula_diff": 0.02447, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.61428, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.1307, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.3775 }, { "k": 3, "phi_eff": 0.4286, "analytical_elem_error": 0.60306, "mc_elem_error": 0.57859, "abs_formula_diff": 0.02447, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.61428, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.1307, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.3775 }, { "k": 5, "phi_eff": 0.7143, "analytical_elem_error": 0.49375, "mc_elem_error": 0.48359, "abs_formula_diff": 0.01015, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.46992, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.4211, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 4.5412 }, { "k": 5, "phi_eff": 0.7143, "analytical_elem_error": 0.49375, "mc_elem_error": 0.48359, "abs_formula_diff": 0.01015, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.46992, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.4211, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 4.5412 }, { "k": 5, "phi_eff": 0.7143, "analytical_elem_error": 0.49375, "mc_elem_error": 0.48359, "abs_formula_diff": 0.01015, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.46992, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.4211, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 4.5412 }, { "k": 7, "phi_eff": 1.0, "analytical_elem_error": 0.395, "mc_elem_error": 0.3966, "abs_formula_diff": 0.0016, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.28395, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 5.7684, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 10.9435 }, { "k": 7, "phi_eff": 1.0, "analytical_elem_error": 0.395, "mc_elem_error": 0.3966, "abs_formula_diff": 0.0016, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.28395, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 5.7684, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 10.9435 } ] }, { "N": 15, "sync_full_majority_error": 0.2015, "quorum_curve": [ { "k": 5, "phi_eff": 0.3333, "analytical_elem_error": 0.64119, "mc_elem_error": 0.62596, "abs_formula_diff": 0.01523, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.7237, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 0.8642, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 1.5892 }, { "k": 5, "phi_eff": 0.3333, "analytical_elem_error": 0.64119, "mc_elem_error": 0.62596, "abs_formula_diff": 0.01523, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.7237, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 0.8642, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 1.5892 }, { "k": 7, "phi_eff": 0.4667, "analytical_elem_error": 0.58803, "mc_elem_error": 0.5756, "abs_formula_diff": 0.01243, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.65817, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.3376, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.2831 }, { "k": 9, "phi_eff": 0.6, "analytical_elem_error": 0.53648, "mc_elem_error": 0.52769, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00878, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.56775, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.929, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 3.1401 }, { "k": 11, "phi_eff": 0.7333, "analytical_elem_error": 0.48677, "mc_elem_error": 0.48141, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00537, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.45198, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.7431, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 4.3359 }, { "k": 11, "phi_eff": 0.7333, "analytical_elem_error": 0.48677, "mc_elem_error": 0.48141, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00537, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.45198, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.7431, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 4.3359 }, { "k": 13, "phi_eff": 0.8667, "analytical_elem_error": 0.43933, "mc_elem_error": 0.43694, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00239, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.32312, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 4.039, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 6.3733 }, { "k": 15, "phi_eff": 1.0, "analytical_elem_error": 0.395, "mc_elem_error": 0.39488, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00012, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.2015, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 7.3748, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 12.6157 } ] }, { "N": 31, "sync_full_majority_error": 0.11607, "quorum_curve": [ { "k": 9, "phi_eff": 0.2903, "analytical_elem_error": 0.65865, "mc_elem_error": 0.64984, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00881, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.82542, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 0.7483, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 1.203 }, { "k": 11, "phi_eff": 0.3548, "analytical_elem_error": 0.63251, "mc_elem_error": 0.62458, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00793, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.80075, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 0.9549, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 1.4753 }, { "k": 15, "phi_eff": 0.4839, "analytical_elem_error": 0.58128, "mc_elem_error": 0.57458, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00671, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.7175, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.4394, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.1136 }, { "k": 17, "phi_eff": 0.5484, "analytical_elem_error": 0.55623, "mc_elem_error": 0.55044, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00578, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.6566, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.7259, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.4863 }, { "k": 21, "phi_eff": 0.6774, "analytical_elem_error": 0.50737, "mc_elem_error": 0.50313, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00424, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.51085, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.4459, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 3.4361 }, { "k": 23, "phi_eff": 0.7419, "analytical_elem_error": 0.48364, "mc_elem_error": 0.4802, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00344, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.42535, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.916, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 4.0732 }, { "k": 27, "phi_eff": 0.871, "analytical_elem_error": 0.43785, "mc_elem_error": 0.43592, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00193, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.25205, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 4.3193, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 6.0464 }, { "k": 31, "phi_eff": 1.0, "analytical_elem_error": 0.395, "mc_elem_error": 0.39445, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00055, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.11607, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 8.9323, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 14.2274 } ] }, { "N": 63, "sync_full_majority_error": 0.04537, "quorum_curve": [ { "k": 17, "phi_eff": 0.2698, "analytical_elem_error": 0.66701, "mc_elem_error": 0.66234, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00467, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.91615, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 0.6917, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 0.9889 }, { "k": 23, "phi_eff": 0.3651, "analytical_elem_error": 0.6284, "mc_elem_error": 0.62487, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00353, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.88302, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 0.9989, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 1.3671 }, { "k": 29, "phi_eff": 0.4603, "analytical_elem_error": 0.59053, "mc_elem_error": 0.58742, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00311, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.82437, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.3554, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 1.8028 }, { "k": 35, "phi_eff": 0.5556, "analytical_elem_error": 0.55347, "mc_elem_error": 0.55101, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00246, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.7205, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.7786, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.3147 }, { "k": 41, "phi_eff": 0.6508, "analytical_elem_error": 0.51731, "mc_elem_error": 0.51575, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00156, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.57637, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.305, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.9616 }, { "k": 47, "phi_eff": 0.746, "analytical_elem_error": 0.48215, "mc_elem_error": 0.48118, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00097, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.40163, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.9925, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 3.8045 }, { "k": 55, "phi_eff": 0.873, "analytical_elem_error": 0.43714, "mc_elem_error": 0.43694, "abs_formula_diff": 0.0002, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.1785, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 4.4678, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 5.7056 }, { "k": 63, "phi_eff": 1.0, "analytical_elem_error": 0.395, "mc_elem_error": 0.39525, "abs_formula_diff": 0.00025, "mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.04537, "mean_quorum_latency_s": 10.5123, "p95_quorum_latency_s": 15.85 } ] } ], "multi_option_plurality_verification": [ { "num_options": 4, "trap_concentration_theta": 0.8, "plurality_error_threshold_1_over_1plus_theta": 0.5556, "phi_crit_theta": 0.55013, "N": 63, "k": 21, "sync_plurality_error_mc": 0.006, "fast_plurality_false_consensus_mc": 0.72488 }, { "num_options": 4, "trap_concentration_theta": 0.65, "plurality_error_threshold_1_over_1plus_theta": 0.6061, "phi_crit_theta": 0.42102, "N": 63, "k": 21, "sync_plurality_error_mc": 0.00076, "fast_plurality_false_consensus_mc": 0.55196 } ] }, "theorem2_cascade_amplification": { "fast_k_of_n": { "per_stage_error": 0.56, "beta_herd": 0.72, "amplification_factor_rho": 0.3168, "asymptotic_error_floor": 0.81967, "stages": [ { "stage": 1, "analytical_cascade_error": 0.56, "mc_cascade_error": 0.55745, "abs_diff": 0.00255, "stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.44255, "analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.44, "mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.44255 }, { "stage": 2, "analytical_cascade_error": 0.73741, "mc_cascade_error": 0.7367, "abs_diff": 0.00071, "stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.2633, "analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.1936, "mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.19423 }, { "stage": 3, "analytical_cascade_error": 0.79361, "mc_cascade_error": 0.79297, "abs_diff": 0.00064, "stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.20703, "analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.08518, "mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.08585 }, { "stage": 4, "analytical_cascade_error": 0.81142, "mc_cascade_error": 0.80805, "abs_diff": 0.00337, "stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.19195, "analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.03748, "mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.03818 }, { "stage": 5, "analytical_cascade_error": 0.81706, "mc_cascade_error": 0.8154, "abs_diff": 0.00166, "stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.1846, "analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.01649, "mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.01715 }, { "stage": 6, "analytical_cascade_error": 0.81884, "mc_cascade_error": 0.8185, "abs_diff": 0.00034, "stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.1815, "analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.00726, "mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.0078 } ] }, "quorumguard": { "per_stage_error": 0.055, "beta_herd": 0.72, "amplification_factor_rho": 0.6804, "asymptotic_error_floor": 0.17209, "stages": [ { "stage": 1, "analytical_cascade_error": 0.055, "mc_cascade_error": 0.05362, "abs_diff": 0.00138, "stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.94637, "analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.945, "mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.94637 }, { "stage": 2, "analytical_cascade_error": 0.09242, "mc_cascade_error": 0.0931, "abs_diff": 0.00068, "stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.9069, "analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.89302, "mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.89302 }, { "stage": 3, "analytical_cascade_error": 0.11788, "mc_cascade_error": 0.11845, "abs_diff": 0.00057, "stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.88155, "analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.84391, "mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.8432 }, { "stage": 4, "analytical_cascade_error": 0.13521, "mc_cascade_error": 0.1329, "abs_diff": 0.00231, "stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.8671, "analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.79749, "mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.79837 }, { "stage": 5, "analytical_cascade_error": 0.147, "mc_cascade_error": 0.14583, "abs_diff": 0.00117, "stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.85418, "analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.75363, "mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.75438 }, { "stage": 6, "analytical_cascade_error": 0.15502, "mc_cascade_error": 0.1529, "abs_diff": 0.00212, "stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.8471, "analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.71218, "mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.71257 } ] } }, "theorem3_cvar_optimality": { "three_path_risk_verification": { "num_options": 4, "k_min": 3, "zeta_blind": 0.04, "eta_clean": 0.14, "eta_hedge": 0.07, "eta_sync": 0.11, "path_probs": { "clean": 0.42, "hedge": 0.48, "fallback": 0.1 }, "mc_empirical_stage_error": 0.06456, "mc_standard_error": 0.00025, "theorem3_1_upper_bound": 0.06486, "bound_holds_within_mc_se": true }, "preemptive_resume_mg1_verification": [ { "rho": 0.58, "rho_hi": 0.2729, "w_fcfs_analytical_s": 4.0213, "w_fcfs_sim_s": 3.8897, "w_hi_quantum_analytical_s": 1.948, "w_hi_quantum_sim_s": 1.8843, "w_norm_pr_analytical_s": 6.2968, "w_norm_pr_sim_s": 5.8556 }, { "rho": 0.72, "rho_hi": 0.3387, "w_fcfs_analytical_s": 7.4879, "w_fcfs_sim_s": 7.4643, "w_hi_quantum_analytical_s": 2.6591, "w_hi_quantum_sim_s": 2.7365, "w_norm_pr_analytical_s": 12.3697, "w_norm_pr_sim_s": 12.07 }, { "rho": 0.85, "rho_hi": 0.3999, "w_fcfs_analytical_s": 16.5011, "w_fcfs_sim_s": 15.995, "w_hi_quantum_analytical_s": 3.4592, "w_hi_quantum_sim_s": 3.4152, "w_norm_pr_analytical_s": 28.8577, "w_norm_pr_sim_s": 27.5526 }, { "rho": 0.93, "rho_hi": 0.4375, "w_fcfs_analytical_s": 38.6874, "w_fcfs_sim_s": 43.6709, "w_hi_quantum_analytical_s": 4.038, "w_hi_quantum_sim_s": 4.0453, "w_norm_pr_analytical_s": 70.3695, "w_norm_pr_sim_s": 79.6165 } ], "policy_monte_carlo": { "Fast_3_of_7": { "accuracy": 0.503, "false_consensus_risk": 0.497, "mean_latency_s": 0.9904, "p95_latency_s": 1.2614, "cvar95_latency_s": 1.2917 }, "Sync_7_of_7": { "accuracy": 0.7088, "false_consensus_risk": 0.2912, "mean_latency_s": 7.4281, "p95_latency_s": 15.3483, "cvar95_latency_s": 19.6111 }, "Genealogy_Sync_HPR": { "accuracy": 0.929, "false_consensus_risk": 0.071, "mean_latency_s": 7.4281, "p95_latency_s": 15.3483, "cvar95_latency_s": 19.6111 } } } }