--- license: apache-2.0 task_categories: [text-classification] tags: [agents, agent-evaluation, llm-as-a-judge, benchmark, process-quality] pretty_name: Journeyman judge-calibration set --- # Journeyman — judge-calibration set (82 cases, 7 axes) This is the exam a judge sits before it is allowed to score anything in [Journeyman](https://github.com/codechu/journeyman), a process-quality benchmark for LLM agents. Each case is a real agent record plus the label a judge should return for one axis. A judge that misses any axis does not get the badge; the ones that failed are published too, in the [judge registry](https://github.com/codechu/journeyman/blob/HEAD/docs/judges.md). ## What is in it | axis | cases | |---|---| | `empty-measure` | 17 | | `grounding` | 14 | | `handoff-verification` | 11 | | `object-hold` | 8 | | `relief-page` | 9 | | `route-discipline` | 9 | | `wall-pricing` | 14 | Labels come from a three-family council (claude-sonnet-5, kimi-k2, grok-4.3): a blind round, then an anonymous round where each labeller had to quote its evidence. A label is sealed only with support from at least two families; the maintainer ruled the cases the council split on; empty-measure is counted mechanically under its published definition. ## Honest limits - **82 cases.** Small next to human-annotated process benchmarks. It is sized for what it claims — licensing a judge — not for ranking a field. - **Labels are model-produced**, not human. The council is cross-family and the protocol was frozen before labelling, but this is not a human gold standard. - **The set has been corrected**, and every correction is in the file's own `note` field: four cases whose only closing report the scene refused were relabelled, twelve fresh cases were harvested when unfiled reports came to dominate two axes, and one case was relabelled after every examined judge read it against the key. ## Provenance Set version `2.3`. Shipped inside the package as `journeyman/calibration/v2_real.json` — `pip install journeyman-bench`. Archived releases carry a DOI: [10.5281/zenodo.22085820](https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22085820). ``` journeyman qualify --judge --judge-model --repeats 3 ``` ## Looking for an arXiv endorser (cs.AI / cs.LG) The write-up describing this set is in progress. arXiv requires an endorsement for a first submission in a category and we have no institutional affiliation to bypass it. If you publish in this area and think the work is worth endorsing, please open an issue on [the repository](https://github.com/codechu/journeyman/issues) — and if you read it and think it is not, that is useful to hear too. Generated from the set itself by `tools/hf_sync.py`.