{ "@context": { "@language": "en", "@vocab": "https://schema.org/", "arrayShape": "cr:arrayShape", "citeAs": "cr:citeAs", "column": "cr:column", "conformsTo": "dct:conformsTo", "containedIn": "cr:containedIn", "cr": "http://mlcommons.org/croissant/", "rai": "http://mlcommons.org/croissant/RAI/", "prov": "http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#", "rdfs": "http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#", "data": { "@id": "cr:data", "@type": "@json" }, "dataType": { "@id": "cr:dataType", "@type": "@vocab" }, "dct": "http://purl.org/dc/terms/", "equivalentProperty": "cr:equivalentProperty", "examples": { "@id": "cr:examples", "@type": "@json" }, "samplingRate": "cr:samplingRate", "extract": "cr:extract", "field": "cr:field", "fileProperty": "cr:fileProperty", "fileObject": "cr:fileObject", "fileSet": "cr:fileSet", "format": "cr:format", "includes": "cr:includes", "isArray": "cr:isArray", "isLiveDataset": "cr:isLiveDataset", "jsonPath": "cr:jsonPath", "key": "cr:key", "md5": "cr:md5", "parentField": "cr:parentField", "path": "cr:path", "recordSet": "cr:recordSet", "references": "cr:references", "regex": "cr:regex", "repeated": "cr:repeated", "replace": "cr:replace", "sc": "https://schema.org/", "separator": "cr:separator", "source": "cr:source", "subField": "cr:subField", "transform": "cr:transform" }, "@type": "sc:Dataset", "distribution": [ { "@type": "cr:FileObject", "@id": "repo", "name": "repo", "description": "The Hugging Face git repository.", "contentUrl": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/taoist/TRACE/tree/refs%2Fconvert%2Fparquet", "encodingFormat": "git+https", "sha256": "https://github.com/mlcommons/croissant/issues/80" }, { "@type": "cr:FileSet", "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default", "containedIn": { "@id": "repo" }, "encodingFormat": "application/x-parquet", "includes": "default/*/*.parquet" } ], "recordSet": [ { "@type": "cr:RecordSet", "dataType": "cr:Split", "key": { "@id": "default_splits/split_name" }, "@id": "default_splits", "name": "default_splits", "description": "Splits for the default config.", "field": [ { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default_splits/split_name", "dataType": "sc:Text" } ], "data": [ { "default_splits/split_name": "train" }, { "default_splits/split_name": "validation" }, { "default_splits/split_name": "test" } ] }, { "@type": "cr:RecordSet", "@id": "default", "description": "taoist/TRACE - 'default' subset\n\nAdditional information:\n- 3 splits: train, validation, test\n- 1 skipped column: turns", "field": [ { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/split", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "fileProperty": "fullpath" }, "transform": { "regex": "default/(?:partial-)?(train|validation|test)/.+parquet$" } }, "references": { "field": { "@id": "default_splits/split_name" } } }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/dialogue_id", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "dialogue_id" } } }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/city", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "city" } } }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/scenario", "subField": [ { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/scenario/persona_type", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "scenario" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "persona_type" } } }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/scenario/persona_description", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "scenario" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "persona_description" } } }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/scenario/primary_poi_type", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "scenario" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "primary_poi_type" } } }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/scenario/travel_context", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "scenario" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "travel_context" } } } ] }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/referenced_pois", "subField": [ { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/referenced_pois/business_id", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "referenced_pois" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "business_id" } } }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/referenced_pois/name", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "referenced_pois" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "name" } } }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/referenced_pois/poi_type", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "referenced_pois" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "poi_type" } } }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/referenced_pois/stars", "dataType": "cr:Float64", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "referenced_pois" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "stars" } } }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/referenced_pois/categories", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "referenced_pois" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "categories" } }, "isArray": true, "arrayShape": "-1" }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/referenced_pois/address", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "referenced_pois" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "address" } } }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/referenced_pois/price_range", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "referenced_pois" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "price_range" } } } ], "isArray": true, "arrayShape": "-1" }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/metadata", "subField": [ { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/metadata/model", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "metadata" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "model" } } }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/metadata/generated_at", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "metadata" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "generated_at" } } }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/metadata/n_candidate_pois", "dataType": "cr:Int64", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "metadata" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "n_candidate_pois" } } }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/metadata/candidate_poi_ids", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "metadata" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "candidate_poi_ids" } }, "isArray": true, "arrayShape": "-1" }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/metadata/open_set_pool_ids", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "metadata" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "open_set_pool_ids" } }, "isArray": true, "arrayShape": "-1" }, { "@type": "cr:Field", "@id": "default/metadata/difficulty", "dataType": "sc:Text", "source": { "fileSet": { "@id": "parquet-files-for-config-default" }, "extract": { "column": "metadata" }, "transform": { "jsonPath": "difficulty" } } } ] } ] } ], "conformsTo": "http://mlcommons.org/croissant/1.0", "name": "TRACE", "description": "TRACE is a 10,000-dialogue benchmark for conversational tourism recommendation that jointly tests three competencies: (1) recommendation accuracy, (2) review-grounded citation evidence, and (3) rejection recovery. Each multi-turn dialogue between a persona-driven user and an assistant recommender carries verbatim review-span citation pointers (review_id + character offsets) into a shared knowledge base of 2,400 Yelp points of interest (restaurants, attractions, hotels) across 8 U.S. cities and 34,208 reviews. 29.4% of dialogues contain explicit reject_and_refine turns that probe recovery. The release contains 8,001 train / 999 validation / 1,000 test dialogues (stratified by city x POI-type, seed 42), 47 persona archetypes, four difficulty tiers, and an open-set candidate pool (~50-100 POIs per dialogue) alongside the closed 8-POI protocol. Companion artifacts: 14 baseline implementations and a 25-metric evaluation toolkit.", "alternateName": [ "Tourism Recommendation with Accountable Citation Evidence", "TRACE Benchmark" ], "creator": [ { "@type": "Person", "name": "Zixu Zhao", "affiliation": { "@type": "Organization", "name": "UNSW Sydney" } }, { "@type": "Person", "name": "Sijin Wang", "affiliation": { "@type": "Organization", "name": "University of Adelaide" } }, { "@type": "Person", "name": "Yu Hou", "affiliation": { "@type": "Organization", "name": "Yonsei University" } }, { "@type": "Person", "name": "Yuanyuan Xu", "affiliation": { "@type": "Organization", "name": "UNSW Sydney" } }, { "@type": "Person", "name": "Yufan Sheng", "affiliation": { "@type": "Organization", "name": "UNSW Sydney" } }, { "@type": "Person", "name": "Xike Xie", "affiliation": { "@type": "Organization", "name": "University of Science and Technology of China" } }, { "@type": "Person", "name": "Wenjie Zhang", "affiliation": { "@type": "Organization", "name": "UNSW Sydney" } }, { "@type": "Person", "name": "Won-Yong Shin", "affiliation": { "@type": "Organization", "name": "Yonsei University" } }, { "@type": "Person", "name": "Xin Cao", "affiliation": { "@type": "Organization", "name": "UNSW Sydney" } } ], "keywords": [ "conversational recommendation", "tourism recommendation", "point of interest", "citation grounding", "review-grounded recommendation", "rejection recovery", "multi-turn dialogue", "open-set evaluation", "Yelp", "benchmark", "datasets", "natural language processing" ], "license": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/", "url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/taoist/TRACE", "sameAs": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/taoist/TRACE", "version": "1.0.0", "datePublished": "2026-05-02", "inLanguage": "en", "isAccessibleForFree": true, "usageInfo": "Synthetic content authored by us (dialogue structure, non-quote turn text, grounding annotations, quote_spans positional metadata, code) is released under CC BY 4.0. Verbatim Yelp review text is NOT redistributed: in released dialogue text it appears as [Q:N] placeholders backed by positional metadata (review ID + character offsets), and is hydrated locally from a user-obtained Yelp Open Dataset bundle under the Yelp Dataset User Agreement (non-commercial, non-sublicensable, revocable; https://www.yelp.com/dataset). Yelp-derived POI metadata (name, address, lat/lon, categories, stars, price) is included under the Yelp ToU 4.E academic-publication carve-out. business_id and review_id values appear as bare factual identifiers. See NOTICE.md for the full clause-by-clause split.", "citeAs": "@inproceedings{zhao2026trace,\n title = {TRACE: Tourism Recommendation with Accountable Citation Evidence},\n author = {Zhao, Zixu},\n year = {2026},\n url = {https://huggingface.co/datasets/taoist/TRACE}\n}", "rai:hasSyntheticData": true, "prov:wasGeneratedBy": { "@type": "prov:Activity", "rdfs:label": "TRACE synthetic-dialogue generation pipeline", "description": "Five-stage pipeline orchestrated by DSPy and executed by gpt-5.4-mini: (1) scenario construction conditioned on a persona archetype, (2) candidate POI selection (8 POIs sampled by stratified rating/category from the Yelp Open Dataset), (3) multi-turn dialogue generation with tier-specific reject_and_refine turns and verbatim review-span citations, (4) automated quality validation (turn structure, action coverage, POI/review references, per-quote fuzzy match >= 0.80 partial ratio), and (5) difficulty annotation (Easy/Medium/Hard/Expert) and stratified train/validation/test split (seed 42).", "prov:used": [ { "@type": "prov:Entity", "rdfs:label": "gpt-5.4-mini", "description": "Large language model used as both the dialogue generator and the structured-output engine via DSPy signatures. Single-LLM dependence is documented in the dataset's known limitations." }, { "@type": "prov:Entity", "rdfs:label": "DSPy", "description": "Programmatic-prompting framework providing typed signatures for action transitions, citation pointers, and grounding annotations during generation.", "url": "https://github.com/stanfordnlp/dspy" }, { "@type": "prov:Entity", "rdfs:label": "Yelp Open Dataset", "description": "Source of business metadata, review IDs, and review text (used only at generation time; review text is NOT redistributed in the released dataset).", "url": "https://www.yelp.com/dataset" } ], "prov:startedAtTime": "2026-04-23T00:00:00Z", "prov:endedAtTime": "2026-04-24T23:59:59Z" }, "rai:dataCollection": "Synthetic dialogues were generated with DSPy and gpt-5.4-mini conditioned on (a) one of 47 persona archetypes, (b) 8 candidate POIs sampled from the Yelp Open Dataset by stratified rating/category, and (c) tier-specific dialogue scenario prompts. The five-stage pipeline is: scenario construction, candidate POI selection, dialogue generation, automated quality validation (turn structure, action coverage, POI/review references, per-quote fuzzy match >= 0.80 partial ratio), and difficulty annotation (Easy/Medium/Hard/Expert).", "rai:dataAnnotationProtocol": "Per-turn annotations (action label, referenced_poi_ids, referenced_review_ids, acceptable_alternative_poi_ids, citation pointers, discovered_review_ids) are produced jointly with dialogue generation by the LLM under structured DSPy signatures and validated by automated checks. A secondary ALCE-style human evaluation pilot used five trained annotators rating 90 items (30 dialogues x 3 baselines: TF-IDF, RAG-Citation, LLM Zero-Shot) for citation precision, informativeness, and naturalness; Krippendorff's alpha is 0.31-0.58 across labels. Twenty additional dialogues received blind-written expert-author recommendations (POI Jaccard = 0.437, n=215).", "rai:dataPreprocessingProtocol": "POIs were drawn from the Yelp Open Dataset business and review files (yelp_academic_dataset_business.json, yelp_academic_dataset_review.json), filtered to 8 U.S. cities x 3 POI types x 100 POIs (= 2,400 POIs) with up to 15 reviews per POI (>= 5 minimum). Verbatim review spans cited by the LLM during dialogue generation were detected via fuzzy substring matching (>= 0.90 partial ratio) against the source review and replaced with [Q:N] placeholders. Quote-span metadata stores only (review_id, [start, end]) for exact quotes (~86% of cases) and (review_id, [start, end], edits) for near-verbatim quotes (~11%) where edits use whitelisted punctuation only (no Yelp word content). Splits are stratified by (city, difficulty) with seed 42.", "rai:dataReleaseMaintenancePlan": "The dataset is hosted on Hugging Face at https://huggingface.co/datasets/taoist/TRACE under CC BY 4.0 for our authored content. Versions follow semver (current: 1.0.0). Issues, bug reports, and dataset corrections are tracked via the HF dataset Discussions page. Maintenance commitment: active corrections for at least 24 months post-publication, with deprecated versions kept available via git revisions. Yelp-content reconstruction is guaranteed against any Yelp Open Dataset snapshot listed in the README compatibility matrix; new snapshots will be tested and added as Yelp publishes them.", "rai:dataUseCases": "Intended uses: (1) benchmarking conversational recommender systems on the joint axes of accuracy, citation grounding, and recovery; (2) studying the trade-off between LLM-style fluency and verbatim-evidence faithfulness in recommendation; (3) developing rejection-handling and aspect-synthesis techniques for multi-turn dialogue; (4) calibrating automated grounding metrics (CGS, NLI-entailment) against human judgments. Out-of-scope uses: production deployment for tourism advice without independent verification of POI accuracy, freshness, and licensing; commercial use of any Yelp-derived component without separate authorization from Yelp.", "rai:dataBiases": "Known biases: (1) Geographic - 8 mid-sized U.S. cities only (Indianapolis, Nashville, New Orleans, Philadelphia, Reno, Saint Louis, Tampa, Tucson); not representative of major metros, rural areas, or non-U.S. tourism. (2) Linguistic - U.S. English only; review style and user-preference expression follow Yelp/U.S. conventions. (3) Source - Yelp reviews skew toward businesses with strong online presence and active reviewer communities; long-tail or recently-opened venues are under-represented. (4) Persona - 47 hand-curated personas tilt toward common traveler archetypes; less coverage for accessibility-focused, elderly, or non-leisure travelers. (5) Generator - all dialogues come from a single LLM family (gpt-5.4-mini); stylistic patterns and reasoning biases of that model are inherited. (6) Visibility amplification - selecting top-rated POIs as candidates may reinforce attention to already popular venues.", "rai:dataLimitations": "Synthetic-dialogue artifact: dialogues are LLM-generated, not transcripts of real users, and may not capture full pragmatic complexity (multi-constraint negotiation, temporal availability, accessibility needs). Single-generator dependence: model-family-sensitive findings (notably rejection recovery) need cross-model replication. Open-set heterogeneity: baselines expose different candidate-access mechanisms; open-set comparisons are system-level rather than pure model quality. Human-eval scale: 90 items with five annotators is a calibration pilot, not a leaderboard. Grounding metric: composite CGS uses a hand-tuned CD/0.05 gate; baseline rankings should be cross-checked under alternative gates. Yelp dependency: the full knowledge base requires user-side reconstruction from a Yelp Open Dataset bundle; review text is not redistributed.", "rai:dataSocialImpact": "Positive: pushes CRS evaluation toward verifiable, audited recommendations rather than opaque scoring, which is particularly important in high-stakes consumer decisions like travel and hospitality. Risks: (1) over-optimization toward citation-density proxies may encourage excessive verbatim quoting rather than semantically supported reasoning; (2) deployments on Yelp-style data may concentrate attention on already popular venues, contributing to overtourism and neighborhood-level visibility inequities; (3) Yelp reviews encode social, geographic, and demographic biases that propagate to systems trained or evaluated on TRACE; (4) tourism recommendation can be misused to surface or hide specific businesses for commercial gain. Users deploying TRACE-trained systems should audit recommendation distributions for fairness across neighborhoods, price tiers, and minority-owned businesses.", "rai:personalSensitiveInformation": "The dataset does not contain personal data of real individuals. User personas are synthetic archetypes (e.g., 'budget-conscious solo traveler') and do not correspond to any real user. Yelp reviewer identifiers, user names, and account data are NOT included. POI references identify businesses (Yelp business_id) and review IDs (Yelp review_id) as bare factual identifiers; no reviewer-attributable text is redistributed. Content moderation: dialogues were generated under DSPy structured signatures with a system prompt that excludes personal-identifier fabrication; no manual safety review was performed beyond automated validation." }