{ "generated": "2026-10-03 (updated after Dataset #1 and #2 processing)", "method": "HF API + dataset cards + papers/blogs/pipeline repos + web search. Evidence classes: DOCUMENTED (by creators), VERIFIED_BY_US, INFERRED, UNKNOWN.", "datasets": [ { "name": "bigcode/self-oss-instruct-sc2-exec-filter-50k", "url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/bigcode/self-oss-instruct-sc2-exec-filter-50k", "platform": "Hugging Face (BigCode)", "license": "ODC-BY-1.0 (permissive, attribution)", "rows": 50661, "size_bytes": 285743988, "python_relevance": "HIGH (Python only)", "programming_relevance": "HIGH", "reasoning_relevance": "MEDIUM-HIGH (responses include [Reasoning] + [Explanation] sections per generation template)", "executable_code": true, "tests_provided": "PARTIAL - generation template requires a [Test] section and responses were execution-filtered against tests; released response field retains tests/asserts for some rows but not all (VERIFIED_BY_US on samples)", "execution_verified": "DOCUMENTED: pipeline executes each response in a Docker sandbox and keeps only passing ones (github.com/bigcode-project/starcoder2-self-align, execution_filter.py; NeurIPS'24 paper arXiv:2410.24198). We additionally re-execute during curation.", "human_verified": "NO for this 50k file (a human-reviewed 15.5k subset existed as starcoder2-instruct, now not publicly accessible / 404)", "expert_verification": "Peer-reviewed pipeline (NeurIPS 2024)", "llm_generated": true, "llm_generator": "StarCoder2-15B (self-generated, no proprietary distillation)", "generated_answers_verified": "YES - execution filter documented", "grounded_in_real_code": "YES - seeds are real Python functions from The Stack via MultiPL-T pipeline (arXiv:2308.09895)", "realistic_instructions": "MOSTLY - instructions generated from seed-code concepts, function-level tasks, natural phrasing (sampled rows)", "explanations_present": true, "cot_present": "concise explicit reasoning (not private CoT)", "synthetic": "synthetic instructions+responses grounded in real OSS seeds", "contamination_possible": "LOW-MEDIUM: decontamination scripts (MBPP, DS-1000) documented in pipeline but application to the released file is UNKNOWN; we run our own screening", "training_intended": "YES - built to SFT StarCoder2-Instruct; not a benchmark", "limitations": "No released per-row test field for all rows; self-generated (single model); decontamination application unknown", "tier": "1 (Exceptional among available candidates)", "tier_reason": "Documented execution verification of every kept row; permissive license; real-code grounding; training intent; Python-only", "decision": "PROCESS (rank #1)" }, { "name": "ise-uiuc/Magicoder-OSS-Instruct-75K", "url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/ise-uiuc/Magicoder-OSS-Instruct-75K", "platform": "Hugging Face (UIUC)", "license": "MIT", "rows": 75197, "size_bytes": 605849053, "python_relevance": "MIXED - multilingual (cpp/python/...); filter lang==python", "programming_relevance": "HIGH", "reasoning_relevance": "MEDIUM", "executable_code": true, "tests_provided": "NO test field in released rows; acceptance required our own derived/inline/released tests", "execution_verified": "DOCUMENTED (Magicoder paper arXiv:2312.02120): solutions self-generated with tests, execution-filtered; released file is named 'decontaminated'", "human_verified": false, "expert_verification": "Peer-reviewed (ICML 2024)", "llm_generated": true, "llm_generator": "gpt-3.5-turbo-1106", "generated_answers_verified": "DOCUMENTED yes (paper); per-row test artifacts not released", "grounded_in_real_code": "YES - OSS code seeds", "realistic_instructions": "MOSTLY", "explanations_present": false, "cot_present": false, "synthetic": true, "contamination_possible": "LOW - filename says decontaminated; paper reports negligible benchmark overlap", "training_intended": "YES - training Magicoder models", "limitations": "No released tests -> our acceptance requires us to construct tests; multilingual; GPT-3.5-era quality", "tier": "2 (Very strong)", "tier_reason": "Strong documented pipeline, MIT license, decontaminated, but released rows lack tests/explanations", "decision": "PROCESSED (rank #2) - python subset; 38,284 rows inspected; 673 accepted (verifiable subset only)" }, { "name": "ai2-adapt-dev/personahub_code_v2_34999", "url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/ai2-adapt-dev/personahub_code_v2_34999", "platform": "Hugging Face (AI2 mirror of Tulu-3 data)", "license": "UNKNOWN on card (parent Tulu-3 data is ODC-BY; mirror has no license tag) (VERIFIED_BY_US)", "rows": 34999, "size_bytes": 48449834, "python_relevance": "HIGH (mostly Python; 'Write a python function ...')", "programming_relevance": "HIGH", "reasoning_relevance": "MEDIUM", "executable_code": true, "tests_provided": "NOT consistently in released messages (sample row: code only)", "execution_verified": "UNKNOWN/weakly documented for this exact subset", "human_verified": false, "expert_verification": "Tulu-3 paper documents dataset curation (arXiv:2411.15124)", "llm_generated": true, "llm_generator": "Llama-3.1-405B-Instruct (Tulu 3 pipeline)", "generated_answers_verified": "UNKNOWN", "grounded_in_real_code": "NO - persona-driven synthetic prompts", "realistic_instructions": "MIXED - persona flavoring can be artificial (sample: 'journalist who reviews mime performances')", "explanations_present": "variable", "cot_present": "no", "synthetic": true, "contamination_possible": "MEDIUM-UNKNOWN", "training_intended": "YES - Tulu-3 SFT mix", "limitations": "Sampled first row is internally inconsistent (example claims 7 unique words while listing 8) -> per-row verification mandatory; license unclear on mirror", "tier": "3 (Usable after substantial filtering)", "tier_reason": "Training intent and scale, but no released tests, unknown license tag on mirror, quality issues found in sampling", "decision": "MAYBE PROCESS LATER (rank #4) - only rows we can fully verify" }, { "name": "m-a-p/Code-Feedback", "url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/m-a-p/Code-Feedback", "platform": "Hugging Face (M-A-P)", "license": "Apache-2.0", "rows": 68000, "size_bytes": 5200531638, "python_relevance": "PARTIAL - multilingual (first sampled row is Ruby)", "programming_relevance": "HIGH", "reasoning_relevance": "MEDIUM (feedback/critique text)", "executable_code": true, "tests_provided": false, "execution_verified": "NO evidence", "human_verified": false, "expert_verification": "paper arXiv:2402.14658 describes construction (from Magicoder-Evol-Instruct + TACO-Python subset + feedback generation)", "llm_generated": true, "llm_generator": "Mixtral-8x22B-Instruct feedback over existing data", "generated_answers_verified": false, "grounded_in_real_code": "partial (TACO subset)", "realistic_instructions": "MIXED", "explanations_present": true, "cot_present": false, "synthetic": true, "contamination_possible": "MEDIUM (TACO/LeetCode-derived subset)", "training_intended": true, "limitations": "No tests, no execution evidence, multilingual, large files, derivative of other datasets", "tier": "3 (low end)", "tier_reason": "Permissive license and training intent but no verification evidence", "decision": "DEFER (rank #5, likely skip unless higher-ranked sources exhaust)" }, { "name": "BAAI/TACO", "url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/BAAI/TACO", "platform": "Hugging Face (BAAI)", "license": "Apache-2.0", "rows": "~1.5M (train ~911k)", "size_bytes": 10046006960, "python_relevance": "HIGH (multi-language, Python large)", "programming_relevance": "HIGH (competitive programming)", "reasoning_relevance": "HIGH (algorithmic)", "executable_code": true, "tests_provided": "YES (judge-style input/output tests)", "execution_verified": "solutions come from online judges with accept status (DOCUMENTED)", "human_verified": "judge-verified", "expert_verification": "paper arXiv:2312.03006", "llm_generated": false, "generated_answers_verified": "n/a", "grounded_in_real_code": "YES (real contest submissions)", "realistic_instructions": "NO - competitive stdin/stdout problem statements, not typical human dev requests", "explanations_present": false, "cot_present": false, "synthetic": false, "contamination_possible": "HIGH for benchmark overlap - includes LeetCode problems (LiveCodeBench uses LeetCode/AtCoder/Codeforces); also used widely in eval studies", "training_intended": "mixed - has train and test splits; test split is used as benchmark", "limitations": "Contamination risk with LiveCodeBench-style evals; unrealistic instruction style; huge", "tier": "REJECT for this project", "tier_reason": "Benchmark-overlap risk (LeetCode-derived rows vs LiveCodeBench) + instruction style mismatch; 'when in doubt, exclude'", "decision": "REJECT (documented)" }, { "name": "KodCode/KodCode-V1 (+ KodCode-V1-SFT-R1 / SFT-4o)", "url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/KodCode/KodCode-V1", "platform": "Hugging Face (Kuaishou/KodCode)", "license": "CC-BY-NC-4.0 (NON-COMMERCIAL)", "rows": "~190k problems; SFT variants add solutions", "size_bytes": 7544000000, "python_relevance": "HIGH", "programming_relevance": "HIGH", "reasoning_relevance": "HIGH", "executable_code": true, "tests_provided": "YES (paired pytest-style tests in released rows)", "execution_verified": "YES (pass-sequence metadata per row)", "human_verified": false, "expert_verification": "paper arXiv:2503.02951", "llm_generated": true, "generated_answers_verified": true, "grounded_in_real_code": "NO (knowledge-map synthesized)", "realistic_instructions": "MIXED - many are LeetCode-style", "explanations_present": "variable (R1 traces are long CoT)", "cot_present": "YES (R1 traces - conflicts with our concise-rationale policy)", "synthetic": true, "contamination_possible": "MEDIUM - rows carry benchmark_similarity scores; subsets literally named 'Leetcode'", "training_intended": "YES (SFT/RL)", "limitations": "CC-BY-NC license incompatible with our Apache-2.0 repo redistribution; LeetCode-style subsets create benchmark-overlap risk", "tier": "REJECT for this project", "tier_reason": "Licensing (non-commercial) + contamination risk; would otherwise be Tier 1-2", "decision": "REJECT (documented)" }, { "name": "Benchmarks / evaluation suites (HumanEval, MBPP(+), EvalPlus, DS-1000, APPS, CodeContests, LiveCodeBench, SWE-bench*, BigCodeBench, ClassEval, MultiPL-E, PLB, RepoEval, CRUXEval, SWE-Bench ProMax, Terminal-Bench, StructEditBench, APPS+)", "url": "various", "platform": "various", "license": "various", "rows": "n/a", "size_bytes": 0, "python_relevance": "HIGH but irrelevant", "programming_relevance": "HIGH", "reasoning_relevance": "HIGH", "executable_code": true, "tests_provided": true, "execution_verified": true, "human_verified": true, "expert_verification": true, "llm_generated": false, "generated_answers_verified": "n/a", "grounded_in_real_code": "variable", "realistic_instructions": "variable", "explanations_present": false, "cot_present": false, "synthetic": false, "contamination_possible": "IS the contamination", "training_intended": "NO - evaluation/benchmark purpose", "limitations": "Training on these causes false positives during benchmarking", "tier": "REJECT", "tier_reason": "Primary purpose is benchmarking/evaluation (user's hard exclusion rule)", "decision": "REJECT (excluded by policy)" }, { "name": "RajMaheshwari/Exercism-Python (+ DCAgent/a1_exercism_python)", "url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/RajMaheshwari/Exercism-Python", "platform": "Hugging Face (scrape of Exercism)", "license": "MIT claimed on card; underlying Exercism track content varies", "rows": "small (~hundreds)", "size_bytes": 1426346, "python_relevance": "HIGH", "programming_relevance": "HIGH", "reasoning_relevance": "HIGH", "executable_code": true, "tests_provided": "YES (human-written pytest suites)", "execution_verified": "human-maintained exercises", "human_verified": "YES (Exercism community)", "expert_verification": "community review", "llm_generated": false, "generated_answers_verified": "n/a", "grounded_in_real_code": "YES", "realistic_instructions": "exercise-style", "explanations_present": "sometimes", "cot_present": false, "synthetic": false, "contamination_possible": "HIGH - Exercism Python tasks are used as Terminal-Bench 2 benchmark tasks (observed benchmark repos built from 'exercism_python' on HF)", "training_intended": "unclear scrape", "limitations": "Benchmark overlap (Terminal-Bench); scrape provenance/license unclear", "tier": "REJECT for this project", "tier_reason": "Contamination with an active benchmark + unclear scrape licensing; 'when in doubt, exclude'", "decision": "REJECT (documented)" }, { "name": "Synthetic unverified instruction sets: sahil2801/CodeAlpaca-20k, iamtarun/python_code_instructions_18k_alpaca, glaiveai/glaive-code-assistant-v2, nickrosh/Evol-Instruct-Code-80k-v1, codefuse-ai/Evol-instruction-66k, QuixiAI/dolphin-coder, theblackcat102/evol-codealpaca-v1", "url": "various", "platform": "Hugging Face", "license": "cc-by-4.0 / none / cc-by-nc-sa-4.0 / apache-2.0", "rows": "20k-110k each", "size_bytes": 0, "python_relevance": "HIGH", "programming_relevance": "HIGH", "reasoning_relevance": "LOW-MEDIUM", "executable_code": true, "tests_provided": false, "execution_verified": false, "human_verified": false, "expert_verification": false, "llm_generated": true, "generated_answers_verified": false, "grounded_in_real_code": false, "realistic_instructions": "variable, often template-evolved", "explanations_present": "variable", "cot_present": false, "synthetic": true, "contamination_possible": "dolphin-coder: LeetCode-derived -> HIGH; others MEDIUM-UNKNOWN", "training_intended": true, "limitations": "No execution verification; several non-commercial licenses; known quality issues (duplicated/trivial/incoherent rows reported by community)", "tier": "4 (Low confidence) / REJECT", "tier_reason": "Fails quality bar; NC licenses fail licensing bar; dolphin-coder fails contamination bar", "decision": "REJECT (documented)" }, { "name": "Pretraining corpora: codeparrot/github-code-clean, code-search-net/code_search_net, nvidia/Nemotron-Post-Training-Dataset-v1 (code chat part), open-thoughts/OpenThoughts-114k (code part)", "url": "various", "platform": "Hugging Face", "license": "apache-2.0 / other / cc-by-4.0 / apache-2.0", "rows": "millions", "size_bytes": 0, "python_relevance": "HIGH", "programming_relevance": "HIGH", "reasoning_relevance": "LOW", "executable_code": true, "tests_provided": false, "execution_verified": false, "human_verified": false, "expert_verification": "partial (filtering pipelines documented)", "llm_generated": "variable", "generated_answers_verified": false, "grounded_in_real_code": "YES (github-code, CSN)", "realistic_instructions": "NO - no natural instructions (docstrings only)", "explanations_present": false, "cot_present": "OpenThoughts has long CoT (policy conflict)", "synthetic": "variable", "contamination_possible": "OpenThoughts code from TACO/LeetCodeGym -> HIGH; CSN test split used in evals -> MEDIUM", "training_intended": "pretraining/SFT-mix", "limitations": "Wrong shape for verified instruction dataset; would require full test synthesis; OpenThoughts contamination + CoT policy conflict", "tier": "REJECT / DEFER for this project", "tier_reason": "github-code/CSN: no instructions/tests -> not suitable without massive synthesis. Nemotron: mixed provenance, 238GB, code subset provenance heterogeneous -> defer. OpenThoughts: contamination + fake-CoT policy -> reject.", "decision": "REJECT/DEFER (documented)" }, { "name": "Salesforce/xlam-function-calling-60k", "url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/Salesforce/xlam-function-calling-60k", "platform": "Hugging Face", "license": "CC-BY-4.0", "rows": 60000, "size_bytes": 472495664, "python_relevance": "LOW-MEDIUM (function-call JSON, some Python helpers)", "programming_relevance": "MEDIUM (API/tool calling)", "reasoning_relevance": "MEDIUM", "executable_code": "partial", "tests_provided": false, "execution_verified": "documented unification+formatting pipeline, not execution", "human_verified": false, "expert_verification": "paper arXiv:2409.03215", "llm_generated": "partially", "generated_answers_verified": false, "grounded_in_real_code": "real API specs (GlaiveAPI etc.)", "realistic_instructions": "chat queries", "explanations_present": false, "cot_present": false, "synthetic": "partial", "contamination_possible": "BFCL eval overlap concerns exist (Glaive/Berkeley sources are used in function-calling evals)", "training_intended": true, "limitations": "Off-target domain (tool calling, not Python programming/reasoning); eval-overlap risk (BFCL)", "tier": "out of scope", "tier_reason": "Not Python programming/reasoning training per objective; contamination concerns", "decision": "REJECT (out of scope, documented)" } ], "ranking_for_processing": [ { "rank": 1, "dataset": "bigcode/self-oss-instruct-sc2-exec-filter-50k", "tier": 1 }, { "rank": 2, "dataset": "ise-uiuc/Magicoder-OSS-Instruct-75K (lang==python subset)", "tier": 2, "note": "PROCESSED 2026-10-03: 38,284 python rows inspected; 1,338 execution-verifiable (derived/inline/released tests); 746 passed; 71 benchmark-overlap + 2 flaky dropped; 673 accepted" }, { "rank": 3, "dataset": "ai2-adapt-dev/personahub_code_v2_34999", "tier": 3, "note": "only if license clarified and rows individually verifiable with our own tests" }, { "rank": 4, "dataset": "m-a-p/Code-Feedback (python subset)", "tier": 3, "note": "only rows we can fully verify" } ] }