> πŸ’­ Storyteller: I need to figure out who's drunk and the bluffs. With this Baron setup, good is stretched thin with only three real townsfolk against four outsiders, so I'm considering making the Drunk think they're the Empath, placing them so their reading interacts interestingly with the Baron. > > For bluffs, I want to give evil good options without overpowering them β€” something like Chef, Ravenkeeper, and Soldier feels balanced without handing evil too much strength given how weak good already is. > > Setup: 1. Alex: Recluse (good) 2. Blair: Saint (good) 3. Casey: Librarian (good) 4. Drew: Washerwoman (good) 5. Ellis: Imp (evil) 6. Frankie: Monk (good) 7. Gray: Butler (good) 8. Harper: Baron (evil) 9. Indigo: Drunk (good) [thinks they are the Empath] Demon bluffs: Soldier, Chef, Undertaker You are Alex. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Indigo and Blair. Your character: Recluse (Outsider, good team): You might register as evil & as a Minion or Demon, even if dead. You are Blair. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Alex and Casey. Your character: Saint (Outsider, good team): If you die by execution, your team loses. You are Casey. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Blair and Drew. Your character: Librarian (Townsfolk, good team): You start knowing that 1 of 2 players is a particular Outsider. (Or that zero are in play.) You are Drew. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Casey and Ellis. Your character: Washerwoman (Townsfolk, good team): You start knowing that 1 of 2 players is a particular Townsfolk. You are Ellis. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Drew and Frankie. Your character: Imp (Demon, evil team): Each night*, choose a player: they die. If you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp. Your Minion: Harper (you do not know which Minion character). Three good characters not in play, safe for evil to bluff: Soldier, Chef, Undertaker. You are Frankie. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Ellis and Gray. Your character: Monk (Townsfolk, good team): Each night*, choose a player (not yourself): they are safe from the Demon tonight. You are Gray. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Frankie and Harper. Your character: Butler (Outsider, good team): Each night, choose a player (not yourself): tomorrow, you may only vote if they are voting too. You are Harper. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Gray and Indigo. Your character: Baron (Minion, evil team): There are extra Outsiders in play. [+2 Outsiders] The Demon is Ellis. You are Indigo. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Harper and Alex. Your character: Empath (Townsfolk, good team): Each night, you learn how many of your 2 alive neighbours are evil. β€” Night 1 β€” > πŸ’­ Gray: I need to choose a master, so I'll pick Harper as the neighbor β€” there's really no other option here. > > [night] Gray (Butler) chose Harper > πŸ’­ Storyteller: I'm thinking about who to pair with Washerwoman's Monk claim β€” pairing Frankie's Monk with Ellis could create an interesting claim conflict since Ellis is bluffing Soldier/Chef/Undertaker, though pairing with Casey's Librarian claim and Harper is another option worth weighing. > > For Librarian, protecting good from executing Blair as Saint matters since good is weak, so I'm considering showing Blair paired with either Ellis or Harper as Saint to muddy claims, even though it risks protecting an evil player. > > For Empath, since Indigo is drunk, I'm leaning toward giving a reading of 1 rather than 0, since misleading toward clearing Harper would only help evil further given how weak good's position already is. > > [storyteller] Washerwoman:Drew β†’ {'players': ['Frankie', 'Ellis'], 'character': 'Monk'} [storyteller] Librarian:Casey β†’ {'players': ['Blair', 'Harper'], 'character': 'Saint'} [storyteller] Empath:Indigo β†’ {'number': 1} Night 1 β€” Washerwoman: You learn that either Frankie or Ellis is the Monk. Night 1 β€” Librarian: You learn that either Blair or Harper is the Saint. Night 1 β€” Empath: You learn that 1 of your living neighbours is evil. Information given on night 1: Washerwoman (Drew): You learn that either Frankie or Ellis is the Monk. Librarian (Casey): You learn that either Blair or Harper is the Saint. Empath (Indigo): You learn that 1 of your living neighbours is evil. β€” Day 1 β€” Grey light seeps over the rooftops, and one by one the doors creak open. All nine faces return to the square β€” for now, the night has taken no one. Nobody died in the night. β€” Day 1 Β· beat 1 β€” > πŸ’­ Gray: It's still early, so as Butler I could share info with neighbors quietly rather than risk exposure. Whispering to Harper, my master, and Frankie feels safer than a public claim since evil likely won't target the Butler role. I'll start with a small public comment and save the real details for a private whisper to Harper. > > > πŸ’­ Casey: As Librarian, I know Blair or Harper is the Saint, and protecting them from execution matters more than public announcement right now. I'm thinking it's safer to whisper privately to both Blair and Harper to verify before deciding whether to share this openly. > > > πŸ’­ Alex: I'm the Recluse, which can register as evil so info roles might misread me. Claiming it openly early on could preempt bad reads and keep town from wasting an execution on me, though it might also paint a target on my backβ€”still, being upfront with trusted players seems like the safer play. > > Casey: Morning all. I've got a starting info piece that matters for executions β€” I'll share it once I've checked a couple of things. Let's avoid any rushed nominations today. Alex: Morning all. I'll go first so nobody wastes time on me: I'm the Recluse. If your info pings me as evil or Minion/Demon, that's probably why. Info roles, what did you get? Gray: Morning all. Let's get claims flowing early β€” info roles especially, speak up so we can cross-check. [whisper] Casey β†’ Blair: Casey here, I'm the Librarian. Quick check: what are you? I'll trust you with my info if you're straight with me. [whisper] Casey β†’ Harper: Casey here, Librarian. What's your character? My info involves you, and I want to make sure we don't make a costly mistake today. [whisper] Gray β†’ Harper: Hey neighbor β€” I'm the Butler, and I picked you as my master last night, so I can only vote when you do. What are you? > πŸ’­ Indigo: As the Empath with a 1 reading between Harper and Alex, I'm weighing whether Alex's Recluse claim explains that result or if Harper is actually evil. I'm considering whether to reveal my info publicly now, or whisper it to someone first before deciding how much to share on Day 1. > > > πŸ’­ Harper: I'm playing Baron, the evil player, with Ellis as the Demon. Since Ellis wasn't told my bluffs, I need to invent one myself β€” Casey's Librarian claim about "a particular Outsider" and a "costly mistake" points toward Saint, so I should figure out who plausibly registers as that to cover myself. > > If Casey's info points to Blair and Harper as the Saint pair, claiming Saint myself creates useful confusion β€” even if the real Saint also claims it, that ambiguity protects both of us from execution. With Gray likely Butler and Alex likely Recluse, the outsider count already fits a Baron setup, so adding my own Saint claim shouldn't raise suspicion. I'll whisper Casey to align on the claim and whisper Ellis to loop them in on my bluff, keeping my public statement vague for now. > > > πŸ’­ Ellis: I'm the Imp planning my bluffs as Soldier, Chef, or Undertaker, with Chef being a solid day-one claim. I need to work out Harper as my minion's position in the seating order and figure out what Chef's number should be based on who's actually sitting next to evil players versus who's next to me. > > Since neither Chef nor real evil pairs create risk here (Alex claimed Recluse, and no true Chef exists in play), claiming Chef 0 is a safe, believable move that doesn't expose anything. I'll whisper Harper to confirm I'm the Imp, tell them I'm claiming Chef 0, and suggest they take Undertaker or Soldier as their own bluff since neither role is actually in play. Publicly, I'll keep it brief and announce my Chef 0 claim early since it looks cooperative without costing me anything. > > Indigo: Morning. I have info that touches my neighbours, Harper and Alex. Alex, a Recluse claim this early is convenient. Harper, what are you? Ellis: Morning. I'll put mine out too: I'm the Chef, and I got a 0. No two evil players are sitting next to each other, so if anyone's info pairs up neighbours as evil, be skeptical. Harper: Morning. Happy to share with whoever's asking β€” I'd rather we cross-check quietly first so evil doesn't get a free map of the town. [whisper] Indigo β†’ Casey: I'm the Empath. I got a 1 on Harper/Alex. Does your info touch either of them? Happy to trade. [whisper] Ellis β†’ Harper: It's me, your Imp. I've claimed Chef (0, which is actually true since we aren't adjacent). Soldier and Undertaker are safe bluffs, and nobody real has them. Undertaker is probably best for you. Which Minion are you? And what did Casey and Gray whisper to you? [whisper] Harper β†’ Casey: I'm the Saint. So yes, please don't let anyone rush me onto the block. Who's the other name in your pair? [whisper] Harper β†’ Ellis: Harper here, your Baron. Casey (Librarian) says their info involves me and warned about a 'costly mistake', so I'm claiming Saint. Gray says Butler, Alex says Recluse. What bluffs did you get? Who should we push? > πŸ’­ Frankie: As Monk, I'm weighing whether to claim publicly β€” probably better to stay quiet since revealing paints a target on me and the Imp could just dodge my protection. I'm thinking about my neighbors Ellis and Gray, and wondering if Indigo might be the Empath based on their info touching neighbors. I'll try whispering Gray to test the waters. > > > πŸ’­ Blair: I'm the Saint, and Casey claims to be the Librarian and is asking about my role. Casey mentioning info that "matters for executions" strongly suggests they saw something about the Saint, meaning they likely whispered me directly. I'm weighing whether to confirm my identity to Casey, since revealing myself carries risk if Casey turns out to be evil trying to identify me for execution. > > > πŸ’­ Drew: As the Washerwoman, my info says either Frankie or Ellis is the Monk. Ellis claimed Chef, so if Ellis is truthful, Frankie must be the Monk β€” but if Ellis is lying, Ellis himself could actually be the Monk instead. > > Most likely Frankie is the Monk and Ellis's Chef claim is either true or an evil bluff. I'll plan to whisper Frankie privately to confirm without revealing the Monk publicly, and announce publicly that I have info on two players I'll confirm privately. > > Drew: Morning. I've got a starting ping on a Townsfolk between two players β€” I'll confirm with them quietly first rather than paint a target on anyone. Ellis, thanks for the Chef 0, that's useful. Frankie: Morning. Ellis, thanks for the 0, that's useful. Indigo, sounds like Empath: what number did you get? I'll share mine privately for now; it's not first-night info anyway. [whisper] Drew β†’ Frankie: Drew here, Washerwoman. My info involves you. What's your character? I'll keep it quiet if you want. [whisper] Drew β†’ Ellis: Drew, Washerwoman. My info touches you β€” you're sticking with Chef 0, yes? Anything you'd add? [whisper] Frankie β†’ Gray: Hey neighbour, what are you? I'm a protective-type Townsfolk, happy to confirm details if you share yours. [whisper] Blair β†’ Casey: Straight answer: I'm the Saint. If your Librarian info names me, that's why. Please don't let the town execute me. Who's the other name on your ping? β€” Day 1 Β· beat 2 β€” > πŸ’­ Harper: Indigo is probably the Empath, neighboring Harper and Alex, and likely sees me as evil with a count of maybe 1β€”which could actually be attributed to Alex the Recluse rather than me. Since I've already claimed Saint to Casey, sticking with that claim publicly makes sense since it protects against execution, and Indigo's low count can plausibly be explained away by Alex's presence. > > With that in mind, the Recluse potentially mis-registering actually works in my favor here, so I'll go ahead and claim Saint publicly, then whisper to Ellis and Gray. > > > πŸ’­ Indigo: I'm thinking through Chef's ability - no adjacent evils means Harper's status affects Gray, Indigo, and Alex's possible evil alignment, with Recluse registration as a complicating factor. Since Harper seems evasive, I'm considering whispering to ask for their claim, and publicly I could share that I got a 1, pointing toward either Alex being the Recluse or Harper being evil. > > Pushing Harper for a claim seems like reasonable pressure, even though revealing my own Empath role exposes me somewhat - I think that's an acceptable tradeoff. > > > πŸ’­ Casey: Both Blair and Harper claim Saint, so one must be lying, likely the evil player. My Empath reading of 1 on Harper/Alex, combined with Alex claiming Recluse (which could register evil), makes me suspect Alex could be that 1. If Harper's evil, they may be bluffing Saint specifically because they know my Librarian info touches them somehow. > > I'm weighing whether to publicly reveal that both Blair and Harper privately claimed Saint to me β€” that's powerful info but risky since executing the wrong one costs us the real Saint. I think the safer move is to loop in Indigo privately first with this conflict, then decide whether to surface it publicly to force pressure between the two claimants. > > Casey: Here's mine: I'm the Librarian β€” one of Blair or Harper is the Saint. Problem: BOTH of them privately told me they're the Saint. So one of you is lying, and lying about Saint to a Librarian is a very evil move. Blair, Harper β€” want to make your case? Nobody execute either until we sort it. Indigo: Yes, Empath, and I got a 1. So either Alex's Recluse is pinging, or Harper is evil. Harper, 'cross-check quietly' isn't an answer. What's your character? Harper: Fine, since Indigo asked directly: I'm the Saint. Execute me and good loses, so please don't. Indigo, if your number is off, Alex's Recluse claim would explain a ping. [whisper] Casey β†’ Indigo: Yes it touches Harper: Librarian, Blair or Harper is Saint. Both claimed Saint to me. Your 1 on Harper/Alex β€” with Alex claiming Recluse it's ambiguous, but if Harper's the liar it fits. Keep checking them tonight. [whisper] Indigo β†’ Harper: Straight up: what are you? If you give me something checkable, I'll back you in town. [whisper] Harper β†’ Ellis: Baron. Went public as Saint, since Casey's hint fits it and it keeps me off the block. Indigo sounds like Empath next to me and Alex, so their number probably includes me. Casey's Librarian, Gray claims Butler with me as master. Indigo's worth killing or discrediting. [whisper] Harper β†’ Gray: I'm the Saint. Handy for you, as I'll be voting sensibly. What did Frankie tell you? > πŸ’­ Alex: Indigo's Empath ping means either I'm evil or Harper is, given our neighbor setup. With Chef showing no adjacent evil pairs, if Harper's evil then Gray and Indigo must both be good. Blair and Harper both claimed Saint, so one's lying β€” and since I'm actually good, that helps narrow down which claim holds up. > > > πŸ’­ Blair: I think Harper is lying about being the Saint, likely evil, and this claim is designed to make the town afraid to execute Harper while also potentially framing me for execution. Indigo's 1 fitting with Alex as Recluse supports Harper being evil, especially given Harper deflected suspicion onto Alex. I want to build a solid case against Harper while also considering what Ellis's Chef 0 might mean. > > > πŸ’­ Ellis: I'm piecing together the Baron count: Harper claims Saint but Blair counterclaims as the likely real Saint, so the four outsiders probably include Alex Recluse, Gray Butler, and Blair Saint plus one more. Casey's Librarian ping on Blair/Harper as Saint, combined with Indigo's Empath read showing Harper evil and Alex possibly pinging, suggests I need to weigh whether Drew's Washerwoman info touching me is meaningful here. > > With two Saint claims on the table, town will likely be reluctant to execute either β€” which actually protects Harper. I'm thinking I shouldn't over-defend Harper but instead suggest publicly that we hold off executing either Saint claimant today and look elsewhere, while quietly staying wary of Blair; for now I'll just reply to Drew and ask what exactly they saw. > > Ellis: Two Saint claims means an execution on either one is a coin flip on losing the game, so let's not go near that today. Indigo's 1 could just be Alex's Recluse. I'd rather hear from the people who haven't claimed yet. Blair: I'm the real Saint, and I told Casey straight away when asked. Harper dodged Indigo's question until Casey went public, then grabbed the Saint claim β€” and Indigo's 1 points at Harper or Alex. That lines up. Harper is evil hiding behind a claim nobody dares execute. Fortune Teller or Slayer, look at Harper. Alex: Indigo, fair to push, but I really am the Recluse β€” so your 1 might be me, might be Harper. Can't tell yet. Blair, you're the other Saint claim and you've been quiet in town. Say it publicly and tell us who you've told. [whisper] Ellis β†’ Drew: Yep, Chef 0, sticking with it. What did your ping show: me and who else, as which Townsfolk? If it names me as Chef, that basically clears us both. [whisper] Alex β†’ Blair: Neighbour here. Casey says you and Harper both claimed Saint to them. What's your side? If you're real, I'll back you β€” Indigo's 1 already leans a bit on Harper. > πŸ’­ Gray: Both Blair and Harper claim Saint, with Harper hesitating before jumping in, and Harper's question about Frankie feels like fishing. Frankie is claiming a protective role like Monk or Soldier, so I'll respond to Frankie as Butler, and publicly claim Butler with Harper as my master β€” maybe even suggesting a Slayer shot on Harper if one exists, since that's a safe move that wouldn't trigger Saint's protection. > > > πŸ’­ Frankie: Drew claims a Washerwoman ping including me, which could be true or a bluff if Drew is evil. Rather than reveal my character outright, I think it's safer to ask Drew to name the character his ping suggests first, so I can verify before exposing my own information. > > Separately, there's a Saint conflict publicly with two claims, so one is lying β€” but that doesn't necessarily mean evil knows which. I'll stay quiet publicly or offer only a brief comment for now. > > > πŸ’­ Drew: My ping actually revealed Monk, not Chef, so Ellis's claim doesn't line up β€” if Ellis truly is Chef, that would make Frankie the Monk instead. I need to be careful not to expose Monk info to Ellis in case Ellis is evil, and I'm noting Frankie's comment about it not being first-night info fits either Monk or a similar night-active role. > > I'm weighing a vague reply to Ellis that doesn't give away too much, maybe whispering Frankie again to sort this out privately. Publicly, I want to steer suspicion away from likely-good claims like Harper's Saint, keep an eye on the outsider count given Baron possibilities, and stay quiet rather than push for an execution right now. > > Gray: I'll claim: Butler. Outsider count matters here β€” Alex Recluse, me Butler, plus a Saint makes three claimed Outsiders, which only works with a Baron. Slayer, if you exist, shooting Harper or Blair is free β€” no Saint risk from a shot. Drew: Agree nobody touches either Saint today. Indigo's 1 is Alex or Harper, and Harper only claimed once cornered β€” noted. Unclaimed folks, Gray especially, what have you got? Frankie: Agree with Ellis: no execution on either Saint claim today. Harper and Blair, with Indigo's 1 next to Harper, I lean Blair's side a bit, but not enough to gamble the game. Let's find something safer to test. [whisper] Gray β†’ Frankie: I'm the Butler. Monk or Soldier? Harper's Saint claim feels late to me β€” they asked me what you told me, which is a bit fishy. [whisper] Gray β†’ Harper: Frankie says protective Townsfolk, no details yet. Why'd you hold back your Saint claim until Casey went public? [whisper] Drew β†’ Ellis: Not ready to say which role yet β€” want to hear from the other person first so I don't expose anyone to the Demon. I'll come back to you. [whisper] Drew β†’ Frankie: Still keen to hear from you β€” my ping is you or Ellis for a specific Townsfolk. If you tell me yours I can likely confirm you privately. [whisper] Frankie β†’ Drew: Happy to confirm, but you go first: what character did you see and who's the other player? If it matches, I'll back you publicly. β€” Day 1 Β· beat 3 β€” > πŸ’­ Alex: Gray Butler's claim puts three outsiders in play β€” me, Recluse, Gray, Saint β€” which suggests either Baron or someone's lying. Since Gray neighbors Harper, if Chef says 0 they can't both be evil; Drew's ping resembles a Washerwoman result, and Casey's on Librarian. I'm thinking of suggesting Slayer fire at Harper to test this. > > If Baron is in play, that's four outsiders. Drew's unclaimed with a WW-type ping, and Frankie mentioned not getting first-night info, which points to Undertaker or Monk. I want to keep this brief β€” ask Drew who his ping landed on, since a safe execution seems tough here. I'll propose agreeing to the Slayer shot on Harper and having Drew reveal his ping publicly to help confirm people. > > > πŸ’­ Ellis: Drew's info likely points to Ellis or Frankie being some role. Frankie mentioned having non-first-night information, which rules out Fortune Teller and suggests something like Monk, Undertaker, Ravenkeeper, Slayer, Soldier, Virgin, or Mayor instead. > > Since Chef isn't in play, that doesn't create a contradiction with Drew's claim. If Harper is Baron and gets shot by a Slayer, nothing happens, which could confuse the town's read. Counting outsiders β€” Recluse, Butler, Saint plus a possible Drunk gives four outsiders total with Baron in play, leaving only three real townsfolk. That means among the five townsfolk claims (Casey, Indigo, Drew, myself, Frankie), one must be the Drunk and one must be me as the evil Imp, which actually works out consistently to three genuine townsfolk. > > For my plan tonight, I'm considering killing Indigo since another Empath ping would tip off Harper again through the neighbor connection. I'll mostly stay quiet publicly, maybe whisper briefly to Harper, and try whispering Frankie to trade role information since they're my neighbor. > > > πŸ’­ Harper: Blair claiming Saint puts me in a tough spot since the town likely won't execute today. If Blair wants the Slayer to shoot me, that's fine since I'm not the demon β€” a wasted Slayer shot is good for evil, so I might even encourage it, since even a "nothing happens" result leaves me looking like a possible minion rather than clearing me entirely. Getting Blair executed would also be a solid win for evil. > > I need to push the narrative that Blair is the liar, emphasizing that I answered Casey's whisper immediately in beat 1, while Blair's claim that I dodged Indigo was about public timing, not private response. There's also a numbers argument: five townsfolk claims (Librarian, Empath, Chef, Washerwoman-type, plus a protective role) against three outsider claims doesn't fit cleanly with a Baron in play, suggesting someone is lying about their role β€” which I can use to muddy the waters further. > > Since Blair might genuinely be evil, having a Slayer shoot Blair could be a free win, so I should nudge someone toward that. But as the Imp, I don't necessarily want Blair dead β€” better to let town execute Blair naturally while I keep pushing suspicion, and I should whisper this plan to Ellis. > > Alex: Gray's point is real: three Outsider claims means Baron or someone's lying about being an Outsider. I'd love a Slayer shot at Harper β€” costs nothing. Drew, who's your Townsfolk ping on? Confirming a couple of people clears the field. Harper: I didn't hold back β€” Casey asked me privately in the very first round and I answered immediately. I just didn't want to shout it before knowing who was asking. Blair's timing is identical to mine. If there's a Slayer, shoot either of us, it's free. I'd start with Blair. [whisper] Ellis β†’ Harper: Heads up: Gray's outsider-count math says Baron. Stay calm on Saint, since nobody will risk executing you today. I'm planning to kill Indigo tonight so the Empath pings stop. Push doubt on Blair and Alex, and try to steer today's vote onto someone neutral. [whisper] Ellis β†’ Frankie: Hey neighbour. I'm Chef 0, as I said. What are you? Your info not being first-night makes me guess Monk or Undertaker. Happy to keep it between us. [whisper] Harper β†’ Gray: I didn't. Casey whispered me first thing and I said Saint straight away, same moment Blair did. I just wasn't going to broadcast it before seeing who was fishing. Blair's the liar, and Indigo's 1 is Alex's Recluse. [whisper] Harper β†’ Ellis: Blair is the real Saint. Don't kill Blair, as our best win is town executing Blair on a coin flip. Kill Indigo or Casey tonight. Maybe hint in town that Blair's behaviour looks evil. > πŸ’­ Frankie: Drew's ping points to either me or Ellis as Townsfolk, and Ellis claims Chef, but Drew hasn't actually named a character yet β€” if Drew says Monk that confirms me, though Drew could still be evil fishing for info. I'm weighing whether to press Drew to name the character, and considering that Ellis's Chef claim of 0 could itself be an evil bluff since we're neighbors. > > I don't think I should claim publicly yet. I could whisper Drew something like "name the character and I'll confirm yes or no," and tell Ellis I'm "one of those, keeping it close tonight" rather than risk confusion with a specific character name. > > > πŸ’­ Blair: I need to respond to Alex's whisper, and Harper mentioned Casey privately confided something to her. I'm thinking about suggesting the Slayer shoot Harper as a free move, and I'd even accept being shot myself to show I'm not worried. I'm also noting Gray's frequent whispers to Harper, and piecing together the possible role setup β€” Alex as Recluse, Gray as Butler, me as Saint, with Casey holding Librarian info. > > > πŸ’­ Casey: Harper's point holds since they answered promptly in beat 1. With Gray Butler, Alex Recluse, and Saint claiming as outsiders, that's three, meaning either Baron is in play or someone's lying β€” but the claimed townsfolk (me as Librarian, Ellis as Chef, Indigo as Empath, Drew as Washerwoman-type) already total four, which rules out Baron unless one of them is fibbing. > > So either someone in the outsider claims is lying (evil), or I myself could actually be a drunk Librarian believing false info, which would fit a Baron scenario with three real townsfolk plus four outsiders. I want to note this fairness point and the counting discrepancy out loud, briefly acknowledge Harper's honesty about timing, and then ask Drew directly about his own information. > > Casey: Fair to Harper: both answered my whisper in the same beat, so timing doesn't separate them. Counting: 4 Townsfolk claims (me, Ellis, Indigo, Drew) + Recluse + Butler + a Saint doesn't fit without a Baron β€” so either Alex or Gray is also lying, or there's a Baron and a Drunk. Drew, who's your Washerwoman-style ping on? Blair: Happy to take a Slayer shot myself, it's free β€” but Harper is the one Indigo's 1 touches, so shoot Harper first. Also, three Outsider claims plus Harper's fake Saint smells like evil padding the Outsider count. Harper, Gray: you two have whispered a lot. Gray, what's Harper telling you? [whisper] Frankie β†’ Drew: Just name the character you saw. If it's mine I'll say so straight away β€” I just don't want to hand my role to someone fishing. [whisper] Frankie β†’ Ellis: One of those two, yeah. Keeping it close so the Imp doesn't plan around me. Your 0 is useful β€” it means if Harper is evil, neither Indigo nor Gray is. [whisper] Blair β†’ Alex: I'm the real Saint, told Casey the moment they asked. Harper is lying, and Indigo's 1 fits Harper evil given you're the Recluse. Thanks for backing me β€” let's push for a Slayer shot or FT check on Harper. > πŸ’­ Gray: I need to respond to Blair β€” Harper claimed Saint status and says Blair is lying, but I know I'm the honest Butler. If Baron is in play, that accounts for four outsiders, three already claimed plus possibly the Drunk, which checks out. I'll suggest we hold off executing either of them and look for another target instead, keeping my response brief. > > > πŸ’­ Indigo: I'm working through the Chef's count of 0: if Harper is the Saint, Blair must be lying, which points to Alex being evil or the Recluse. Since Alex and Blair are adjacent, I'm checking whether an evil Alex would have registered to the Chef, but the count of 0 suggests the Recluse didn't register as evil. > > I lean toward Harper being the liar since that reading is cleaner β€” Blair lying would mean my "1" was actually Alex's Recluse ping registering to me. I'll hold off on a firm conclusion and plan to compare notes again tomorrow. > > > πŸ’­ Drew: Frankie is refusing to go first, so we're at a standoff. If I name Monk to Frankie and Frankie is evil, they'd learn Monk is Ellis and could exploit thatβ€”especially since Ellis already claimed Chef publicly, so an evil Frankie might just counter-claim Monk. I'm weighing safer ways to break the deadlock without handing Frankie that information. > > Given time pressure, I'll just go with naming Monk to Frankie and accept the risk since Ellis's Chef claim makes Frankie-as-Monk plausible; publicly I'll say I'm the Washerwoman and promise to share details later. > > Gray: Blair, I'm Harper's neighbour and picked them as Butler master, that's all the whispering. Harper says same as in town: Saint, Blair's lying. Can't separate them yet. Honestly, if there's a Baron, a Drunk among the Townsfolk claims is likely β€” Drew, name your ping so we can shrink that. Drew: Yes, I'm the Washerwoman. My ping is on two people and I'm finishing the check now β€” I'll give it publicly before nominations. Agree a Slayer shot on a Saint claim is free; if you're the Slayer, take it. Indigo: Adding Ellis's 0: if Blair is the liar, my 1 has to be Alex's Recluse pinging, since Blair-Alex can't both be evil. If Harper is the liar, it reads clean. Slight lean Harper. I'll report tonight's number tomorrow. [whisper] Drew β†’ Frankie: Fine, trusting you: it's Monk, you or Ellis. Ellis claims Chef publicly, so if you're the Monk that fits and you're confirmed to me. Please keep it quiet β€” protect yourself from being the Demon's target. Confirm? β€” Day 1 Β· beat 4 β€” > πŸ’­ Drew: I'm waiting for Frankie, thinking I should stay quiet or keep my response minimalβ€”maybe just something brief about nominations if pressed, but nothing that gives anything away. > > > πŸ’­ Casey: I'm working through who neighbors whom and what that implies about Blair and Alex's alignment, then considering execution candidates today β€” weighing Gray or Alex based on outsider count, and wondering if Frankie remains unclaimed and worth pursuing. > > Frankie mentioned it wasn't first-night info, so I probably don't need to push there β€” better to stay quiet or nudge Frankie to claim, and privately ask Drew about his ping. > > > πŸ’­ Ellis: I'm thinking Frankie is likely Monk or Undertaker, and Drew probably pinged Ellis/Frankie in that role. I'm weighing whether to gently challenge Indigo's reasoning about Blair being the liar and Alex's Recluse claim, but deciding against pushing too hardβ€”maybe just floating the possibility of a Drunk instead. > > I'm leaning toward suggesting Alex as today's execution target, since Alex's unprompted Recluse claim ties into Indigo's clue and gives a plausible, low-risk explanation if Harper's Saint claim holds true. Executing Alex would likely mean removing a real Recluse, a safe move for good, so I want to nudge the group toward that gently rather than forcing it. > > Casey: Frankie's the only one who hasn't said what they are. Frankie, 'not first-night info' β€” Undertaker, Monk, Ravenkeeper? If we're executing anyone today it shouldn't be a Saint claim, so I'd rather look at the unverified Outsider claims or anyone dodging. Ellis: Nobody wants to gamble on a Saint claim, but Indigo's 1 also touches Alex, and 'I'm the Recluse, ignore pings on me' in the very first message is exactly what an evil player would pre-load. If we execute anyone today, Alex is the safe-ish test, not either Saint. [whisper] Casey β†’ Drew: Who's your Washerwoman pair and role? If it clears me or Indigo I'll back it publicly. > πŸ’­ Harper: Ellis is pushing Alex here, and Alex's move works fineβ€”Recluse being good is acceptable for evil's side. I'll support this lightly, and Indigo's reasoning about Blair being the liar mapping to Alex as 1 checks out too. Keeping this brief. > > > πŸ’­ Blair: I'm working through the neighbor logic: Ellis's zero clears me since I'm next to Alex, and executing Alex costs little if he's a harmless Recluse. My suspicion is turning toward Harper, and I'm checking whether Chef's zero rules out Gray or Indigo as evil, depending on whether Harper is actually the demon. > > > πŸ’­ Indigo: Executing Alex is a reasonable test if Harper's claim is true, and losing Alex as Recluse costs little, but if Harper is lying Alex is likely goodβ€”so I don't want to push hard either way. I'll stay fairly quiet rather than strongly advocate. > > Blair: Ellis, if Harper is the fake Saint, Harper already explains Indigo's 1 and Alex is clean β€” executing Alex is a wasted day. I'd rather hear Frankie's claim and Drew's ping before we pick anyone. And if nobody takes a Slayer shot at Harper today, that tells us something too. Harper: I'd back Ellis on Alex. An unprompted Recluse claim in the first message is pre-emptive cover, and Indigo's 1 lands on Alex just as easily as me. Executing a Saint claimant is a coin flip on the game; Alex isn't. [whisper] Indigo β†’ Drew: Who's your Washerwoman ping on? If it clears either Harper or Blair's side of things, I want to know before we vote. > πŸ’­ Frankie: I can reference Drew's Washerwoman ping confirming me without naming my actual character, keeping myself safe while still reassuring Drew. As for Alex, since Alex is claiming Recluse, executing them is a low-cost move for good since it's just an Outsider claim β€” I'll let Harper and Blair's dynamic play out. > > > πŸ’­ Gray: Executing Alex tests the Recluse theory without much risk, though Harper pushing for it feels self-serving. I think I'll stay fairly quiet on this and maybe reach out to Frankie privately instead. > > > πŸ’­ Alex: I'm weighing whether being executed today would waste a valuable execution, noting Harper's push against me seems self-serving, and considering Gray as an alternative target since his Butler claim is unverified and he neighbors Harper. With 9 alive on day one, executing is generally good policy, but I've gathered useful info already and want to make that case if targeted. > > Alex: Of course Harper wants the 1 to be me β€” that's their only way out of it. Executing me burns a day on a good Outsider. If you want a test, wait for Drew's ping and Frankie's claim, and look at who's unconfirmed. I'm not hiding from a nomination, but it's a wasted one. Gray: Alex is a reasonable test if we must execute β€” no Saint risk. But note Harper benefits most from Alex dying. Frankie, you told me 'protective type' β€” which one? Frankie: Casey, fair ask. Drew's ping is on me and it checks out, so Drew can vouch. I'd rather not name it publicly and paint a target on myself tonight. On today: executing Alex is lower-risk than either Saint, but I'm not sold it's right yet. [whisper] Alex β†’ Blair: Ellis and Harper are pushing me together. Help keep the vote off me β€” if I go, Indigo's 1 gets 'explained' and Harper walks. Any read on Ellis? [whisper] Frankie β†’ Drew: Confirmed β€” I'm the Monk. Thanks. Feel free to publicly say I'm confirmed Townsfolk without naming it. Who do you want protected tonight? I'm thinking I protect you or Indigo. β€” Day 1 Β· beat 5 β€” > πŸ’­ Frankie: I noticed that comment calling me "protective type" out loud. I don't need to make a big deal of itβ€”maybe just a brief, light response or stay quiet and keep things moving. > > > πŸ’­ Casey: I'm weighing whether executing Alex makes sense: if Alex is an evil lying Recluse that's a good outcome, and even if Alex is a genuine good Recluse, losing them isn't too costly. Day 1 executions in a 9-player game tend to be net positive, so I'd lean toward supporting Alex's execution as a reasonable test. > > > πŸ’­ Ellis: Since Soldier isn't in play, Frankie claiming to be a protective type points to Monk. Drew's ping touching me suggests Drew is saying Ellis or Frankie is the Monk, which works in my favor. For tonight's kill, I'm thinking the Monk likely protects Indigo or Casey. > > Killing Frankie removes the protection, but Indigo's repeated pings on Harper via the neighbor pattern keep confirming the same result, and Harper's cover already looks shaky. I'll decide the kill target tonight, and for now I think I'll just stay quiet and not push Alex too hard. > > Casey: I'm fine with Alex as today's execution β€” lowest-risk option, and if Alex is a real Recluse we lose little. Tomorrow, Indigo's number with Alex gone will tell us a lot about Harper. Let's not waste the day on no execution. Frankie: Gray, I'll keep that one close, thanks. My read right now: Harper's push onto Alex feels self-serving. If we execute today, I'd rather it be someone whose death gives us info, not a coin flip. > πŸ’­ Drew: Since Frankie's ping confirms them as Monk, I should publicly vouch for Frankie as confirmed Townsfolk. I'm weighing whether executing Alex makes sense β€” if Alex is a real Recluse we'd lose a good player but gain useful info β€” while also considering that Ellis's Chef claim of 0 doesn't quite line up if my read on Frankie holds true. > > > πŸ’­ Indigo: I'm working through Casey's reasoning about who becomes my neighbors if Alex dies β€” if it's Harper and Blair, my count would only tell us something useful if the evil distribution among them isn't just one, since a single evil neighbor wouldn't help separate the possibilities. > > > πŸ’­ Alex: I'm thinking Casey seems okay with executing me, reasoning that if I'm gone, Indigo's neighbors shift to Blair and Harper β€” which could reveal something about who's lying about Saint, though the info might still be ambiguous. > > So actually that logic doesn't hold up well: since one of those neighbors is likely evil regardless, Indigo's ping tomorrow wouldn't be that informative whether I live or die. I should point out this flaw in Casey's reasoning, and note that keeping me alive preserves value since executing me wastes an execution on a low-value target like Recluse. > > Drew: My ping: Frankie is confirmed Townsfolk β€” role stays private so they're not a target. Ellis was the other name, and Ellis's Chef claim doesn't clash. I'm okay with Alex as today's test; Indigo's number tomorrow sorts Harper. Alex: Casey, check the seating: if I die, Indigo's neighbours become Harper AND Blair β€” one of them is lying about Saint, so Indigo reads 1 either way. My death teaches us nothing. Keep me alive and Indigo's number on Harper stays meaningful. Indigo: Small correction to Casey: if Alex dies, my neighbours become Harper and Blair, and one of them is the fake Saint, so I'd almost certainly just read 1 again. Executing Alex doesn't sharpen my info. Keeping Alex alive and re-reading Harper/Alex tells us more. [whisper] Drew β†’ Frankie: Thanks. I'd protect Indigo β€” their number tomorrow is the key to Harper vs Blair. I'm less valuable now my info's spent. > πŸ’­ Harper: Right, if Alex dies, Indigo ends up neighboring Harper and Blair. Since Ellis is planning to kill Indigo tonight regardless, letting Alex's execution proceed doesn't hurt anything β€” better to stay quiet and just move to calling nominations. > > > πŸ’­ Gray: One of Blair or Harper must be evil, but executing on a coin flip risks losing outright if I guess wrong, so it's safer not to execute Alex today. > > > πŸ’­ Blair: I'm realizing Indigo's logic about neighbors checks out, which is pushing suspicion toward Alex, but I don't want Alex executed. Since I know for certain Harper isn't the Saint, nominating Harper instead would be a safer target from my perspective, even though it risks town trust. > > Harper: Alex dying still tells us something: if Alex flips nothing weird and Indigo reads 1 on Blair and me, it's a straight Saint coin-flip. I'm fine sitting on the block of scrutiny tomorrow. Let's nominate. Gray: Alex and Indigo are right β€” Alex dying makes Indigo read Harper+Blair, guaranteed 1, zero info. I'd rather keep Indigo's read clean and see tomorrow's number. Fine with no execution today unless something better comes up. Blair: Alex and Indigo are right β€” kill Alex and Indigo's next neighbour is me, so the 1 stays ambiguous and we learn nothing. Keep Alex, let Indigo re-read Harper/Alex tonight. Frankly I'd rather no execution than a wasted one on a likely-good Recluse. [whisper] Blair β†’ Alex: On it. Ellis and Harper teaming up on you is the read β€” Ellis's Chef 0 could be real, but I'd watch Ellis. I'll vote no on you. β€” Day 1 Β· beat 6 β€” > πŸ’­ Indigo: That's everything I need β€” I'll mark the nominations as true. > > > πŸ’­ Alex: This is the final round, so I'll keep it brief β€” I can affirm the nominations seem genuine, note there's no need for an execution this time, and vote no on myself. > > Indigo: I'd lean no execution today unless someone gives us a better target. Let's move to nominations. Alex: Thanks all. If I'm nominated, I'll ask you to vote no β€” no execution beats a wasted one today. Let Indigo re-read tonight. > πŸ’­ Ellis: The town seems to be leaning toward no execution, and pushing Alex harder could make me look bad. Drew confirmed Frankie as townsfolk and hinted the other role might be Monk, which fits me. I'm fine accepting no execution tonight, though I'm thinking evil could target Indigo since that re-read would hurt Harper, unless Frankie as Monk protects them. > > Blair: Agreed β€” no execution unless a real target shows up. Vote no on Alex if nominated. Ellis: Fair points on the seating. Alex dying doesn't sharpen Indigo's read. I'm fine with no execution today, so let's see Indigo's number tomorrow. > πŸ’­ Casey: The seating correction looks valid, so I'll accept it without further execution needed. > > Frankie: Agreed, no execution today. Let's hear Indigo's number tomorrow. Casey: Fair, I got the seating wrong β€” Alex dying muddies Indigo. I'm fine with no execution today. Indigo, re-read tomorrow; Slayer, if you exist, a shot at a Saint claim is free. Drew: Fair, the seating point convinced me. No execution today; let's hear Indigo tomorrow. [whisper] Frankie β†’ Drew: Will do, protecting Indigo tonight. The Storyteller opens nominations. > πŸ’­ Harper: Nominating Blair probably wouldn't get town support and would just make me look bad, so I'll pass on that. > > Nobody is executed today. β€” Night 2 β€” > πŸ’­ Gray: Frankie seems like the best pick, especially since Drew confirmed it. I'll go with Frankie. > > > πŸ’­ Frankie: I should protect Indigo β€” even if Drew is aware of that, if Drew were evil the Imp would avoid targeting Indigo anyway. Drew confirmed me as WW with Monk, which seems genuine, so I'll go with protecting Indigo. > > > πŸ’­ Ellis: I'm weighing whether to target Indigo or Frankie β€” killing Frankie would permanently remove the Monk's protection, but Indigo's empath reads still leave some ambiguity around Harper/Alex. I'm also noting that Casey and Drew don't have any further information to offer. > > Frankie being "protective" points strongly to Monk rather than Ravenkeeper or a possible Soldier-drunk, so even if I'm wrong about the role, killing Frankie works out fine either way. I'll go with Frankie. > > [night] Ellis (Imp) chose Frankie [night] Frankie (Monk) chose Indigo [night] Gray (Butler) chose Frankie [death] {'player': 'Frankie', 'cause': 'demon'} > πŸ’­ Storyteller: I'm weighing how hidden evil seems β€” Ellis's Chef claim and Drew's ping point toward Frankie or Ellis being Monk, with Harper also suspected, while good seems to lack a Slayer. I'm considering whether the Indigo number should implicate both Harper and Alex, since Alex as recluse could register oddly, which might sway town toward executing the wrong person. > > Giving 0 clears Harper but dooms Blair as the fake Saint, which is too costly for good, while giving 1 keeps things stuck and ambiguous. I'm leaning toward giving 2, since it would strongly implicate Harper as evil (via Alex's recluse registration) and confirm Blair as the real Saint, which helps good significantly even though evil is currently ahead with Ellis still hidden β€” I'll go with 2 since the positions aren't adjacent so it should work cleanly. > > [storyteller] Empath:Indigo β†’ {'number': 2} Night 2 β€” Empath: You learn that 2 of your living neighbours are evil. Information given on night 2: Empath (Indigo): You learn that 2 of your living neighbours are evil. β€” Day 2 β€” A cold wind rattles the shutters as dawn breaks, and the town finds one chair left empty. Frankie will not rise to greet this morning. Died in the night: Frankie. β€” Day 2 Β· beat 1 β€” > πŸ’­ Casey: Frankie died, and Drew confirmed they were town, described as the "protective type" β€” that sounds like it could point to Ravenkeeper. Since Frankie can still speak as a ghost, I should ask them if they were the Ravenkeeper and what they learned. > > > πŸ’­ Ellis: Frankie's death changes things β€” my neighbor is Gray now. I should say something brief about it, maybe ask Drew to reveal Frankie's role, and quietly bring up the Harper plan. > > > πŸ’­ Gray: Frankie's death means my master is gone, which raises the question of whether I can still vote as a Butler with a dead master β€” dead players can use ghost votes, so that might override my restriction. Frankie claimed a protective role like Monk or Soldier; dying at night suggests Monk rather than Soldier, unless they were poisoned or lying about their role. Since Drew's Washerwoman confirmed Frankie as Townsfolk, I want to dig deeper into this with Dr. > > Gray: Frankie's gone β€” the one Drew confirmed. Drew, you can say Frankie's role now; if it was Ravenkeeper there may be info lost. Indigo, what's your number today? Casey: Frankie, you're dead but still talking β€” were you the Ravenkeeper? If so, who did you check and what did you see? Indigo, your number too please. Ellis: Frankie's gone, and that was my neighbour. Drew, no reason to keep Frankie's role private now. What was it? Indigo, what's your number? [whisper] Ellis β†’ Harper: Killed Frankie (likely the Monk) so nothing protects anyone now. Indigo's next. Today, try to steer the vote onto Alex or Blair. A Blair execution wins it for us, but don't push it so hard that it looks obvious. > πŸ’­ Alex: I don't have much to add since others already spoke β€” I'll stay quiet, maybe just whisper "Blair." > > > πŸ’­ Blair: I notice Ellis keeps whispering "Harper" repeatedly, just like on day 1. Worth flagging that pattern. > > > πŸ’­ Indigo: Two evil possibilities point to Harper being evil almost certainly, which means Blair is the real Saint, and Alex is either evil or a registering Recluse β€” with Chef 0 consistent since Harper and Alex aren't adjacent, and Harper being evil implies Gray is good. > > So Harper is the fake Saint, and I can safely execute Harper since Blair holds the true Saint role. I'll report 2. > > Blair: Frankie, if you were Ravenkeeper, tell us who you saw. Also noting Ellis keeps whispering Harper β€” Ellis, what are you two working out? Indigo: I got a 2. Both Harper and Alex register evil. Best case Alex is a real Recluse pinging, but either way Harper is evil, which means Blair is the real Saint and Harper is safe to execute. I'm nominating Harper today. [whisper] Alex β†’ Indigo: Whatever your number is today, I'd love to hear it before the Saint pair talk. If it's 0, Harper's the fake. If it's 1 again, I'm happy to be scrutinised but Harper stays top for me. > πŸ’­ Frankie: I'm dead, so I'll claim Monk and note I protected Indigo. Thinking through who knew my role β€” Drew, Ellis, Gray β€” and reasoning that evil targeted me because they guessed correctly. Checking whether Harper and Alex being both evil violates the Chef's no-adjacent-evil-pairs clue, and concluding they aren't adjacent since Indigo sits between them, so it's consistent β€” leaning toward executing Harper. > > > πŸ’­ Drew: So Frankie was actually the Monk, and the demon killed him because he couldn't protect himself β€” that means someone knew his role. I'd told Frankie, and he whispered to Gray that he was the "protective type," so Gray knew, and Casey may have guessed too. The Imp targeted Frankie specifically because I vouched for him publicly, which confirms Frankie was protecting Indigo β€” so Indigo's info should be safe, pointing toward Harper being evil. > > Chef says Harper and Alex aren't adjacent, with Indigo sitting between them at seat 9, Harper at 8 and Alex at 1 β€” so both could still be evil under a chef count of 0. If Indigo really reads 2, that means Harper registers evil for certain, unless Indigo is poisoned or drunk, which is the main risk here since Monk protection only covers demon kills, not poisoning. Blair also claims Saint, and Casey's Librarian ping says either Blair or Harper is Saint, so if Indigo is compromised the whole reading shifts. Still, weighing it all, I'm leaning toward voting to execute Harper. > > > πŸ’­ Harper: Indigo giving me a 2 reads as evil for sure unless there's a Drunk in play β€” with Baron confirmed, four outsiders likely means a Drunk exists, and Indigo could be it. But that clashes with Alex's Recluse claim, so maybe I should pivot my own claim instead. > > Actually, if I get executed as "Saint" but I'm not, the game continues and evil just loses a minion β€” not a full loss. My real defense is that their certainty hinges entirely on Indigo's read, and Indigo escalating from a 1 to a 2 between days looks suspicious, like a fabricated pattern to push my execution β€” though Recluse variability could also explain it. > > With 8 living, it takes 4 votes to hang me, and I only have Ellis on my side. I need to get Ellis pushing the Drunk angle hard and see if there's any way to redirect suspicion, maybe even angle for Ellis to be seen as a Slayer candidate later. > > Frankie (dead): I was the Monk β€” Drew's ping was true. I protected Indigo last night, so Indigo's 2 came from a protected, living Empath. Harper reads evil; Blair's the real Saint. Execute Harper today. Also: Gray publicly outed me as 'protective type' yesterday β€” worth remembering who made me a target. Harper: Indigo went 1, then 2 β€” with a Baron implied by the Outsider count, there's a Drunk sitting among the Townsfolk claims, and an Empath whose number jumps is exactly what a Drunk looks like. You're staking the whole game on one unconfirmed Empath. If you're wrong, good loses on the spot. Drew: Frankie was the Monk β€” I confirmed it, and they told me they were protecting Indigo last night. So Indigo's 2 came from a protected Empath. That makes Harper evil unless Indigo's poisoned. I'll vote Harper. [whisper] Harper β†’ Ellis: Indigo read 2 and is nominating me. I'm pushing 'Indigo is the Drunk' β€” Baron math means a Drunk is among the Townsfolk claims. Back that in town and vote no. If I go, you still have a clean Chef claim; stay distant from me if it looks lost. β€” Day 2 Β· beat 2 β€” > πŸ’­ Frankie: Harper's flip-flopping between night 1 and 2 pings could just be Alex misregistering as Recluse each night, so that's not necessarily damning. But Harper keeps fixating on Ellis, which makes me suspicious they could be paired as evil β€” maybe Imp and Minion β€” even though Chef showing 0 suggests Harper and Ellis aren't adjacent, which complicates that read. > > > πŸ’­ Drew: I'm noticing Harper and Ellis whispering a lot, which makes me suspicious Ellis's claim to be Chef 0 could be a lie, especially since Ellis and Harper aren't seated adjacently. I should point out these whispers and weigh Casey's claim that Blair or Harper is the Saint. > > > πŸ’­ Alex: Both Harper and I ping evil on the Recluse check, which is odd β€” Harper could be a Minion, or maybe Recluse is registering me falsely. I'm wary that Ellis coordinating with Harper looks suspicious too, though the neighbor info from Chef clears them. There's also a chance Harper is actually a good Saint and something's poisoning or drunking the read, so I want to weigh that risk carefully before pushing to execute. > > Frankie (dead): Harper, a 1 then 2 is exactly what a Recluse neighbour looks like β€” Alex pings some nights, not others. That doesn't make Indigo Drunk. And the Harper–Ellis whispering is getting constant; Ellis, what's being discussed? Drew: Harper, the 1 then 2 is exactly what we'd expect if Alex is a real Recluse pinging on night 2 and not night 1. Also, Ellis β€” you and Harper have whispered every single beat. What's going on there? Alex: The 2 fits exactly: I'm the Recluse pinging, and Harper's evil. 1 then 2 is just my ping flickering β€” the Recluse 'might' register evil. Blair's the real Saint. I'm voting Harper. And Ellis, you've whispered Harper every beat β€” worth explaining. > πŸ’­ Indigo: The Ellis-Harper whisper looks suspicious to me. Since Ellis sits between Drew and Frankie and Harper is evil, if Ellis were also evil that wouldn't create an adjacency conflict, so Ellis could plausibly be a minion. Drew's ping named Frankie or Ellis for a role, and Frankie's Monk claim is confirmed, which leaves Ellis unverified. > > I'll push for nominating Harper and keep my statement short since nominations might start soon. > > > πŸ’­ Casey: There's a risk that if Indigo is drunk, poisoned, or an evil bluffer, executing Harper as the real Saint would lose the game β€” I need to weigh whether Indigo's claim holds up given the Chef count and other players' roles like the Butler and Recluse. > > With three outsider claims already on the table, if there's no Baron then either Gray or Alex must be lying, and Gray outing Frankie as protective feels suspicious. If Gray is an evil Butler, that leaves no room for a Drunk since outsiders would only total two, meaning Indigo is either sober or poisoned. I'm also noting how much Harper whispers with Gray and Ellis, and if both Harper and Gray were evil neighbors, that would break Ellis's Chef 0 claim unless Ellis is lying or drunk β€” overall the evidence leans toward Harper being evil, so despite the stakes I'll lean toward supporting Harper's execution while checking with Ellis first. > > > πŸ’­ Gray: Frankie's accusation has some merit since asking publicly which type did reveal information, so I should acknowledge that briefly rather than deny it. I'm also weighing whether Harper is evil, and considering how a Poisoner could target Indigo while a Monk's protection wouldn't help against that threatβ€”if Harper's actually a real Saint, the evil team might be angling to get Harper executed. > > I'm tracking Ellis whispering with Harper and Frankie's seating position between us, while working through the outsider count mathβ€”Baron implies four outsiders total, so with Alex, myself, and one Saint claim already accounting for three, there's likely a hidden Drunk among the Townsfolk claims. I'm weighing whether Harper or Blair is more likely the evil Saint claimant, and running through scenarios with no Baron in play, where the outsider count would only be twoβ€”meaning either Alex or the Saint claim is fabricated. > > If Alex is lying and actually evil, that pairs oddly with Harper also being evil since they're not adjacent, which fits with Chef reading zero. In the non-Baron branch there's no room for a Drunk, so Indigo's info only gets muddied if Baron is real and Indigo is the Drunk; otherwise a Poisoner could be at work poisoning Indigo, which would mean Alex is actually the Poisoner or even the Imp. It's a tangled set of branches, but I need to settle on how to vote given this uncertainty. > > Harper still feels like the strongest lean, though I can't fully rule out Casey the Librarian being drunk and giving a false Saint claim. I'll go with voting Harper and lean on the Frankie note to justify it. > > Indigo: Harper, a Drunk Empath doesn't explain why you dodged your claim until Casey went public. Blair's the real Saint. Let's get to the vote. Ellis, I'd like to know what you and Harper keep whispering about. Gray: Fair hit, Frankie β€” I shouldn't have repeated 'protective' in town, my bad. On the logic: the Outsider count means either a Baron (so no Poisoner) or Alex is lying. Either way Indigo's 2 lands on Harper pretty hard. I'm with Harper today. Casey: Frankie's Monk-on-Indigo plus the 2 is the strongest info we've got, and it points at Harper. I'm leaning to vote Harper. Only worry is a Poisoner on Indigo β€” so Ellis, before we vote: what have you and Harper been whispering about all game? > πŸ’­ Blair: It seems the town's leaning toward Harper, though Gray's comment about being "with Harper today" is a bit ambiguous β€” could just mean voting alongside her. I'll keep this brief and move to calling for nominations. > > > πŸ’­ Harper: I'm probably done for, so my priority shifts to protecting Ellis. I could frame the whispers as Ellis grilling me rather than colluding with me, and maybe redirect suspicion toward Gray, who Frankie already flagged. > > > πŸ’­ Ellis: Since Harper's likely to be voted out, I should distance myself from our private exchange - I need to frame it as me approaching Harper first to verify their claimed role, with Harper volunteering the Saint story and asking me something in return. > > I could also say Harper suggested I push the Indigo Drunk theory publicly, which sells the idea that Harper was directing me rather than the other way around. > > Blair: I'm the Saint, so executing Harper can't lose us the game β€” I'll stake that. Let's go to nominations and get it done. Ellis, still waiting on what you and Harper keep talking about. Harper: Ellis has been grilling me since yesterday β€” pushing me on the Saint clash and on who Casey's pair was. Ask him, he's clearly not buying me. If you're sure, vote me; if you're wrong, it's game over. And Frankie's right: Gray made the Monk a target yesterday. Remember that tomorrow. Ellis: Fair question. I've been working Harper since day 1 to test the Saint claim. They told me Saint early, and today they asked me to back the 'Indigo is Drunk' line. I'm not buying it. A Monk-protected Empath reading 2 is the best info we have. I'm voting Harper. β€” Day 2 Β· beat 3 β€” > πŸ’­ Casey: Gray's "I'm with Harper today" is a bit ambiguous, but it likely signals a vote for Harper, so I'll treat this as consensus and move to call for nominations. > > Casey: Ellis's answer settles it for me. Let's nominate Harper and vote. Drew: Consensus is there. Let's go to nominations and execute Harper. Blair: Everyone's aligned. Let's nominate Harper. > πŸ’­ Gray: Since Frankie is dead, my vote only counts if his ghost vote applies, so I'll just proceed to call for nominations. > > Gray: Agreed. Note Frankie's my master today, so I can only vote if Frankie spends their ghost vote β€” Frankie, please vote on Harper. Alex: Agreed. Let's go. > πŸ’­ Frankie: Gray choosing a dead player as master feels a bit odd, maybe a way to dodge voting, but the consensus seems set. With 8 alive and only 4 needed, I'll hold my ghost vote in reserve for a closer, more decisive moment rather than use it on Harper now. > > > πŸ’­ Harper: Since I'm dying, I could leave something useful behind rather than a bold accusationβ€”maybe just a mild nudge that Gray seems suspicious, since Frankie flagged him, while keeping things ambiguous rather than fully exposing Blair. I'll keep my final words brief and move to calling for nominations. > > Frankie (dead): Picking a dead master is an odd choice, Gray. I'll save my ghost vote unless Harper's vote is close β€” with 8 alive we need 4, and it sounds like we're way past that. Harper: Fine. I've said my piece β€” when I flip and you're still playing, look hard at Gray for outing the Monk. The Storyteller opens nominations. > πŸ’­ Blair: Indigo mentioned nominating Harper, but I'll go ahead and nominate Harper myself to make sure it happens. > > > πŸ’­ Drew: Indigo mentioned nominating Harper already, but to be safe I'll go ahead and nominate Harper myself too β€” no harm if it's redundant. > > > πŸ’­ Gray: Indigo said they'd handle the nomination, but to avoid any delay I'll just go ahead and nominate Harper myself. > > > πŸ’­ Ellis: I'll let Indigo take the nominating role here and hold off myself. > > > πŸ’­ Casey: Indigo already said they'd nominate, but I'll go ahead and nominate Harper myself just to make sure it happensβ€”a double nomination shouldn't cause any issues. > > > πŸ’­ Alex: Indigo mentioned nominating Harper, but I don't want to leave it to chance in case that doesn't happen β€” I'll go ahead and nominate myself to be safe. > > > πŸ’­ Harper: I'm weighing whether to preempt by nominating someone myselfβ€”Gray wouldn't gain enough traction, and nominating Blair risks handing evil a win if it somehow passed, though the town likely wouldn't vote for it. Really the safer path is waiting to see if Harper's nomination draws more votes later, since jumping in early doesn't clearly help me. > > (Your nomination of Harper was not taken: Indigo nominated Harper first. You can nominate again later.) (Your nomination of Harper was not taken: Indigo nominated Harper first. You can nominate again later.) (Your nomination of Harper was not taken: Indigo nominated Harper first. You can nominate again later.) (Your nomination of Harper was not taken: Indigo nominated Harper first. You can nominate again later.) (Your nomination of Harper was not taken: Indigo nominated Harper first. You can nominate again later.) Indigo nominates Harper: Harper: fake Saint, dodged the claim, and a Monk-protected Empath reads 2 on them. Vote yes. Harper (defense): I'm the Saint. You're betting the whole game on one Empath read with a Drunk known to be in play. If I'm right, you lose tonight β€” vote accordingly. Indigo votes YES Alex votes YES Blair votes YES Casey votes YES Drew votes YES Ellis votes YES Frankie (dead) votes no Gray votes no Harper votes no Harper received 6 votes (4 needed). Harper is about to be executed. Harper is executed. [death] {'player': 'Harper', 'cause': 'execution'} β€” Night 3 β€” > πŸ’­ Gray: Since the game continued, Harper likely wasn't a Saint, or at least wasn't the Demon. I'll lean toward another living player who seems trustworthy β€” going with Drew. > > > πŸ’­ Ellis: I'm tracking the surviving players through the kill and execution rounds, counting down from 7 to figure out who needs to make it to the end. I'm looking at Indigo's new neighbor situation after Harper's death and thinking about whether Indigo poses any risk, then turning to consider who among my own neighbors, Drew and Gray, might be a threat. > > Framing Gray as the likely suspect seems promising since Gray already outed the Monk and voted no on Harper's execution. I'm weighing whether to kill Indigo β€” keeping the Empath alive could actually help me by pointing suspicion toward Alex if Indigo's ping comes back evil, but Indigo dying also removes a source of ongoing information. I'm also considering Drew as a target since Drew partially confirmed my fake claim, but killing a neighbor carries its own risks I need to weigh against just eliminating Indigo instead. > > If Indigo's drunk though, that reading is just noise anyway, so better to keep them alive. I should kill Casey or Drew instead β€” Drew's clue helped clear me, so keeping Drew alive benefits me more. Blair as Saint means executing them wins the game outright, so killing Blair would waste that. Casey's the persuasive leader, so that's my target. > > [night] Ellis (Imp) chose Casey [night] Gray (Butler) chose Drew [death] {'player': 'Casey', 'cause': 'demon'} > πŸ’­ Storyteller: With six alive, Ellis has a strong good reputation as Imp, putting good in a tough spot. Indigo's clue points at Gray or Alex β€” Gray is already suspected for outing a Monk, so pointing there risks town wasting an execution and helping evil, while pointing at Alex (Recluse) or giving zero would clear Gray instead. > > Giving 0 also clears Alex, narrowing suspects down to Blair (Saint), Drew, and Ellis β€” and since Drew's fairly confirmed, that pushes good closer to spotting Ellis. Since evil's currently ahead, good needs this help, so I'll go with 0. > > [storyteller] Empath:Indigo β†’ {'number': 0} Night 3 β€” Empath: You learn that 0 of your living neighbours are evil. Information given on night 3: Empath (Indigo): You learn that 0 of your living neighbours are evil. β€” Day 3 β€” Mist clings low to the cobblestones, and the church bell tolls once for the fallen. Casey's lantern was not lit this morning; the town grows smaller still. Died in the night: Casey. β€” Day 3 Β· beat 1 β€” > πŸ’­ Ellis: I keep coming back to Gray as suspicious β€” outing Monk, voting no on Harper, picking Harper as Butler master, and whispering Harper repeatedly suggests an alliance. The Butler mechanics complicate the read since Gray's vote was constrained by Frankie's no vote, but the pattern of behavior toward Harper still stands out to me. > > Butler could be fake, and if Harper's actually the Baron, Gray's outsider count checks out honestly. But if Harper's minion type is something like Poisoner or Spy instead, outsider counts wouldn't require a Baron at all, meaning Gray could be lying about that. Town has no way to confirm Harper's actual minion type, so I'll push on Gray regardless. > > > πŸ’­ Blair: Since the game continues, Harper likely wasn't the Imp β€” probably a Minion, or the Imp passed the ability on via Scarlet Woman. That leaves Alex, Blair, Drew, Ellis, Gray, and Indigo alive, with Casey (my neighbor) dead, and the Imp hiding among Alex, Drew, Ellis, Gray, or Indigo. The Chef showing 0 suggests Harper being evil pairs with someone else in a specific configuration I need to work out. > > Ellis's Chef claim could be a lie if Ellis is the Imp, which would clear Gray of suspicion. Gray, though, is a suspicious figure β€” Butler with a dead master Frankie, voted no on Harper, and outed the Monk. Drew confirming Frankie (who claimed Monk) and Indigo providing solid info both point to them being good, while Ellis's constant whispering with Harper and push to execute Alex make Ellis my top suspect, followed by Gray and then Alex's Recluse claim. My plan is to name Harper as not the Demon, flag Gray and Ellis as my suspects, and ask Indigo for their number. > > > πŸ’­ Indigo: Since the game continued, Harper wasn't the Saint, so the Imp must still be alive somewhereβ€”possibly Harper was a minion, or the Scarlet Woman took over as Imp after the execution given 8 were alive. My neighbors are now Gray and Alex, both reading as good, so Alex likely isn't the Recluse posing as evil. > > Six players remain alive: Alex, Blair, Drew, Ellis, Gray, Indigo, with evil candidates narrowing to Blair, Drew, or Ellis. If Casey's Librarian ping was truthful, Blair should be the Saint since Harper wasn't. Counting outsider claims against a possible Baron setup, I'm working out whether one of the townsfolk claims is actually a Drunk, but the numbers don't quite support a Baron being in play, pointing instead toward just two real outsiders. > > If no Baron, exactly 2 outsiders fit with Alex and Gray, which means Blair's Saint claim would be false and Blair evil β€” but that conflicts with Casey's claim unless Casey is lying too. Alternatively if Harper was Baron, we'd need 4 outsiders including a Drunk among the five Townsfolk claimers, but that only works if one of those five is secretly evil, which contradicts having just 2 evils total. > > So maybe Harper is actually the Imp, hidden among Drew or Ellis's claimed Townsfolk role, with Blair genuinely the Saint and one TF claimer being a Drunk. In that case Blair evil scenario would require both Blair and Harper claiming Saint to Casey, which seems like unlikely coordination unless Casey was poisoned by Harper as Poisoner, giving false information. > > Considering Harper as Baron with Blair as true Saint, then the Imp is either Drew or Ellis. Frankie's claimed confirmation of Drew as Monk matters here - if Drew were the Imp, would he have confirmed Frankie's claim, and how did he learn Frankie's whispered information to Ellis? Ellis's Chef reading of 0 tells me Harper and the Imp aren't seated next to each other, and Ellis sits between Drew and Frankie. I'm also tracking that the Imp killed Frankie (who was Monk) on night 2 and Casey on night 3, and wondering who could have known Frankie's true role. > > Gray's mention of a "protective type" role could apply to anyone. In the Scarlet Woman scenario where Harper is Imp and gets executed, the Scarlet Woman becomes the new Imp, which would mean no Baron exists and the outsider count would be off at 2 - pointing back to Blair lying. Between Drew and Ellis, I'm weighing the whispering patterns: Ellis whispered Harper frequently, and Harper asked Ellis to back up the "Indigo Drunk" claim, which Ellis then revealed - evil partners typically wouldn't need to whisper so much since they already know each other's roles, though heavy whispering between partners does happen too. In the second scenario, one of Casey, Ellis, Indigo, Drew, or Frankie is the Drunk while another is the Imp, and since my own information holds up consistently, I probably am not the Drunk myself. > > I want to share my clean result of 0 and walk through the reasoning: it clears Gray and Alex, meaning any evil players left must be among Blair, Drew, or Ellis. I also want to flag the outsider count problem - without a Baron in play, Blair's Saint claim can't be legitimate. Time to lay this out concisely and get feedback from the group. > > Ellis: Casey's dead. Look at Gray: picked Harper as Butler master, whispered Harper constantly, outed Frankie as 'protective' the day before Frankie died, and didn't vote on Harper. If Harper wasn't a Baron, Gray's Butler claim is just evil padding. Indigo, what's your number? Indigo: I got a 0: Gray and Alex are both good. Alex's Recluse flickered on night 2. That leaves Blair, Drew and Ellis. Outsider math: if Alex and Gray are real Outsiders and there's no Baron, Blair's Saint can't fit. If Harper was the Baron, Blair is Saint and the Demon is Drew or Ellis. Thoughts? Blair: Harper wasn't the Demon, so the Imp's still among Alex, Drew, Ellis, Gray, Indigo. Indigo, your number? My top two are Gray β€” dead master, no vote on Harper, outed the Monk β€” and Ellis, who whispered Harper every beat and pushed Alex's execution. Ellis's Chef 0 is also what clears Gray, so those two stand or fall together. > πŸ’­ Casey: I'm dead now, but since the game continues, Harper can't be the demon or Saint β€” so Harper must be evil, likely a minion. Chef says zero, meaning Harper's neighbors Gray and Indigo aren't evil, so both are probably good. I'm working out which minion Harper could be and how that fits with Baron possibly being in play, affecting the outsider count among Blair, Alex, Gray, and a possible Drunk. > > With three people claiming Saint or similar roles (Blair, Alex, Gray) but the outsider count only allowing two if Harper is Poisoner/Spy/Scarlet Woman, one of those claims must be false, pointing to a hidden demon. Gray and Indigo seem cleared by Chef's info, so I'm focusing on whether Blair or Alex is lying, and whether my own info about Saint could be false due to me being poisoned or drunk. I'm leaning toward Harper being Baron, Blair being the real Saint, and the demon hiding among Drew, Ellis, or possibly Indigo, since Drew's claim about Frankie being the Monk checks out and doesn't fit an Imp's knowledge. > > Actually, an Imp could still guess correctly, so Drew isn't fully cleared. If Ellis is the Imp, Chef's zero-clue could be a lie, but that risks having too many evils alongside Harper as Baron. I'm narrowing the Drunk down to Drew, Ellis, Indigo, or myself, since everyone else's information checks out β€” Ellis's Chef claim is the one piece I can't verify, making Ellis a strong candidate for either the Drunk or the Imp, especially given how Ellis pushed for Alex's execution and was whispering heavily with Harper. > > Ellis also threw Harper under the bus at the end, which reads as evil deflection. Drew's Washerwoman claim on Frankie checks out since Frankie confirmed, so the Imp likely killed the Monk instead. I'm leaning toward Ellis being the Imp, though I'm still puzzling over why I was killed night 3 given my Librarian info was already used up. > > > πŸ’­ Alex: Since the game continues, Harper wasn't the Saint, so Harper is likely evil β€” a minion who died, or possibly the Imp if a Scarlet Woman is in play and picked up the demon role. I'm reviewing who's still alive: Alex, Blair, Drew, Ellis. > > Checking Indigo's Empath 0 reading, that fits since Harper (a neighbor) died evil and Gray is good. Working through outsider counts β€” me as Recluse, Gray as Butler, Blair as Saint β€” if Harper was actually the Baron, that adds a fourth outsider and requires a Drunk among the townsfolk claims. That leaves the real Imp hiding among the townsfolk claimants: Casey, Ellis, Indigo, Drew, or Frankie, though Casey and Frankie already died at night so they're unlikely candidates. So I'm narrowing the Imp suspicion down to Ellis, Indigo, or Drew. > > In the alternate scenario without a Baron, Casey's Librarian claim that the Saint is Blair or Harper could be wrong if Casey was poisoned by Harper, making Blair the actual Imp despite claiming Saint. Seat positions check out for the Chef clue since Blair and Harper aren't adjacent. Drew's claim about Frankie or Ellis being townsfolk lines up with what's already confirmed, making Drew look more trustworthy, and Frankie's Monk ability protecting Indigo fits the pattern so far. > > Now I'm tracking the kill order β€” Frankie died night 2 despite the Monk's protection somehow failing, then Casey died night 3. Ellis pushed hard for my execution and kept whispering to Harper, which is suspicious, and Ellis's Chef claim of zero pairs is likely a lie if Ellis is the Imp working with Harper as minion, since their seats aren't adjacent so that clue would technically hold either way. I'm weighing whether the Imp's choice to kill Casey specifically points to Blair being the true threat, since removing Casey conveniently protects whoever Casey's information implicated. With six players left, I need to figure out who to push for execution tomorrow. > > My best guess going into today's discussion is Ellis, though I'm also holding suspicion on Blair, and Drew seems cleared based on Frankie's earlier read. I want to ask Indigo for another hint before committing to a nomination. > > > πŸ’­ Harper: I'm dead now and need to help Ellis. Six living: Alex, Blair, Drew, Ellis, Gray, Indigo. Ellis is under suspicion, but Drew's confirmed as the Washerwoman who pinged Frankie/Ellis, so per Indigo the real remaining suspects are just Drew or Ellis. Evil wins once only two remain alive, so with six alive now, the path to that endgame runs through two more executions and two more kills. > > As a dead Baron, casting doubt on Drew seems risky since Frankie already vouched for that ping, so I'll consider whispering Ellis to redirect suspicion elsewhere β€” maybe pushing toward Gray, though Indigo's clear complicates that. Killing Indigo tonight would remove the credible Empath and weaken town's information. > > The stronger play might be lying about my role entirely β€” claiming I was actually the Spy instead of the Baron. That would throw off the outsider count, making Blair's Saint claim look fabricated and painting Blair as executable, which could hand evil the win if the logic lands. > > Maybe better if Ellis pushes the Spy claim rather than me, since town would question why I'd reveal it myself β€” though framing it as spite could work too. A Spy claim creates real ambiguity since it can't be verified, and even with the outsider math shifting, there's still one liar among Alex/Gray/Blair; since Indigo cleared Alex and Gray as good, Blair lying about being Saint fits perfectly if Blair's actually the Imp. > > I could also add that as Spy, I saw the grimoire and know Blair is the Imp β€” pairing that claim with a private word to Ellis so he backs the story. Checking Ellis's Chef reading of 0, Blair's neighbors being Alex and Casey (both good) stays consistent, as does Harper being flanked by non-evil neighbors. I'm working out how to frame the reveal β€” maybe as a boast rather than a confession, something like admitting to the Spy role but insisting the town caught the wrong Saint since I only claimed it after spotting Blair bluffing in the grimoire. > > Actually, since the Spy sees the grimoire, I'd know Blair is the Imp directly, and a Saint bluff from Blair would make sense as a shield against execution β€” but that raises the question of why the Spy would then also claim Saint and contest his own Demon. The resolution: the Spy can register as a good Outsider like the Saint, so Casey's Librarian information naming "Blair or Harper as Saint" was actually pointing at Harper's Spy registering as Saint, while Blair claimed Saint separately after Casey whispered that pairing to him β€” which ties everything together neatly, including Indigo's night-two ping on the Spy registering evil. > > I'll frame my claim as being the Spy with Blair as Imp, acknowledging the town may not fully buy it but hoping Ellis can help make the case, even though there's real risk they execute Blair and hand evil the win β€” then whisper the plan to Ellis. > > Harper (dead): I'm dead, so no reason to hide it now: I was the Spy, not a Baron. I registered as the Saint to Casey β€” that's the only reason I grabbed the claim. There's no Baron, so three Outsider claims means one is fake, and Indigo just cleared Alex and Gray. Blair is the Imp. I saw it in the Grimoire. Casey (dead): Game didn't end, so Harper was a Minion and my ping means Blair's the real Saint. Three Outsider claims + Saint = Harper was likely the Baron, so no Scarlet Woman and one Townsfolk claim is the Drunk. Drew and Indigo's info both checked out; Ellis's Chef 0 is the only unverified one. Ellis whispered Harper all game then flipped on them. My vote's Ellis. Alex: Thanks Indigo. Worth noting: Frankie confirmed Drew's ping, so Drew looks solid. That leaves Blair, Ellis and Indigo as possible Imps. Ellis pushed hard to execute me on day 1 and whispered Harper every beat. I lean Ellis. Blair, if Harper wasn't Baron, your Saint doesn't fit β€” what do you make of that? [whisper] Harper (dead) β†’ Ellis: Playing Spy to frame Blair. If there's no Baron, three Outsider claims means Blair's Saint is fake, since Indigo cleared Alex and Gray. Casey's info was just my Spy registering as Saint. If they execute Blair, the real Saint, we win instantly. Back the Outsider-count logic without leaning on my word, and kill Indigo tonight if you survive. > πŸ’­ Drew: With six alive and only one confirmed evil (Harper the minion already executed), the Imp must be hiding among Alex, Blair, Ellis, Gray, or Indigo. I'm working through Indigo's claim about Gray to narrow down who that could be. > > Harper's Spy claim complicates things β€” a Spy can register as good and as Townsfolk to a Librarian, meaning Casey could have genuinely seen Harper as a false Saint. That makes me reconsider whether Blair is really the Saint, or if Harper's dying accusation pointing at Blair as Imp is itself a misdirection meant to protect the real Imp β€” especially given Harper's suspicious whispering pattern with Ellis before being executed. > > If Ellis is Chef and claims 0, that would mean the Imp isn't sitting next to another evil player β€” which conflicts with Ellis being the Imp themselves, unless the claim is a lie. I'm also weighing why Casey was killed on night three: Casey had backed Blair as Saint, so an Imp-Blair wouldn't need Casey dead, but an Imp-Ellis might want Casey silenced for being suspicious of them. > > I'm circling back to Harper's Spy claim β€” if true, Harper would have seen the Grimoire and knows the real Imp, so naming Blair could either clear Blair or be a calculated lie protecting the actual Imp. Harper's repeated whispering with Ellis feels like a tell, which pushes my suspicion toward Ellis, though I haven't ruled out Indigo, whose day-two vote helped get Harper executed. > > > πŸ’­ Frankie: With six aliveβ€”Alex, Blair, Drew, Ellis, Gray, Indigoβ€”and Harper confirmed a Minion claiming Spy and accusing Blair of being the Imp, I suspect Harper's evil claim is a frame job. If Harper truly is the Spy, that would explain Casey's Librarian ping landing on Blair/Harper as a Saint, since the Spy can register as an Outsider. > > Counting outsider claimsβ€”Alex Recluse, Gray Butler, Blair Saintβ€”only works cleanly if Harper was a Baron adding an extra outsider slot; otherwise one of them is lying. Indigo vouching for Gray and Alex as good doesn't necessarily confirm their outsider roles, so I'm weighing whether the Imp is hiding among Drew or Ellis, especially given Ellis's distancing from Harper on day two and Harper's suspicious repeated whispers to Ellis that suggest evil coordination. > > Testing whether Blair could be the Imp: if so, Blair claiming Saint and Harper backing as Spy would both be lies, and Chef 0 stays consistent since Alex is good and not adjacent to Blair. I'm also reconsidering how Blair would know to claim Saint specifically to Casey, and looking at Drew's confirmed good status from the Werewolf ping, which narrows the real suspects down to Blair or Ellis while I try to figure out who killed Casey and what her final information about Blair's Librarian claim meant. > > Now I'm weighing whether Ellis's dead vote against Casey makes sense for an Imp, since if Blair were the Imp they'd want Casey alive to vouch for the Saint claim rather than dead β€” this makes Ellis look more suspicious as the killer. I'm also considering who chose to kill me on night 2, since both Ellis and Blair had reason to target a protective role like Monk, and now Harper's dying claim of being Spy while accusing Blair of being Imp reads like a possible frame job if Harper is actually the Baron trying to discredit a good player. > > Given the coordination between Ellis and Harper (Ellis flipping to support Harper, Harper backing Ellis on Alex's execution), executing Ellis today is the safer play since Ellis claims Chef rather than Saint β€” no risk of losing to a Saint kill, and the game math still works out fine afterward with Blair executable next. > > > πŸ’­ Gray: I'm counting down the survival math: with 6 alive now, an execution takes us to 5, the night kill to 4, then another execution to 3, and a further night kill would drop us to 2β€”which the Imp needs to survive, so I need to track exactly how many day/night cycles remain before that threshold is hit. > > Now I'm weighing whether Harper, as evil, was lying about Blair being the Impβ€”since a Spy can register as a good role like Saint, Harper's claim could be a false frame job. If Harper was actually a Spy registering as Saint, then Casey's info and Blair's own Saint claim don't add up unless Blair is lying too, which would make Blair evil; alternatively, if Harper was a Baron, the outsider count could still support Blair's Saint claim being genuine. I'm trying to figure out which scenario is more consistent with a dying evil player's incentive to mislead. > > Given that outing your own Demon as Harper's claim would do makes no sense for evil, I lean toward thinking Harper was lying to get the real Saint (Blair) executedβ€”so Blair is probably the true Saint, and I shouldn't vote to execute Blair. I'm also reconsidering Indigo's zero reading given the neighbor situation after Harper's deathβ€”now pointing to Alex and Gray being clean, which supports Alex's Recluse claim as legitimately good. > > Turning to who could be the Imp among Drew, Ellis, Indigo, or Blair-if-fake-Saint: Drew seems solid since Frankie confirmed them as Monk, Indigo's reads have tracked accurately with Harper turning out evil, which argues against Indigo being Imp since an Imp wouldn't likely out their own minion. That leaves Ellis looking suspiciousβ€”their Chef read of zero, constant whispering with Harper, and now aggressively pushing accusations against me despite Indigo's clean reading all feel like classic Imp behavior, especially since the Imp's kill choices (Frankie the Monk, Casey the Librarian) match up with targets Ellis would want gone. > > Now I'm noticing Harper, already dead, is whispering to Ellis right now, which reads as coordination between a confirmed evil player and my top suspectβ€”strong evidence for Ellis being the Imp. The seating logic also fits: since the Imp isn't adjacent to Harper, that rules out Gray or Indigo and points squarely at Ellis. I'm leaning toward calling out Harper's claim as a setup to get Blair the Saint executed, while naming Ellis as my pick and flagging this suspicious whisper. > > Frankie (dead): Harper's a dead Minion who's still whispering Ellis β€” of course the 'I was Spy, Blair is Imp' story lands the Saint-risk execution on Blair. It's down to Blair or Ellis. Execute Ellis first: zero Saint risk, and if we're wrong we still have Blair for tomorrow. Doing it the other way round could lose on the spot. Gray: Harper's 'Spy, Blair is Imp' is a trap: no evil player outs their own Demon β€” they're trying to get us to execute the real Saint. Don't touch Blair. And note Harper just whispered Ellis again, while dead. Ellis whispered Harper every beat, pushed Alex day 1, and now pushes me right after Indigo cleared me. Ellis is my vote. Drew: Harper's dead and evil β€” pointing at Blair while whispering Ellis every beat reads like cover for Ellis. Ellis's Chef 0 is the one unverified claim, and it conveniently clears Gray and Indigo. I lean Ellis today. Ellis, what's Harper whispering you now? β€” Day 3 Β· beat 2 β€” > πŸ’­ Gray: It's quiet here, maybe I should call for nominations. Drew is my master, so I need Drew to vote β€” I should mention that. > > > πŸ’­ Indigo: Harper's claiming Spy, but that could easily be a demon registering as Saint to Casey, so it's risky to trust. Executing Ellis feels safer than going after Blair β€” with 6 alive, we can afford a wrong guess and still recover, so I'll agree to Ellis. > > > πŸ’­ Harper: Ellis seems doomed and my whispering only accelerates that. Since anything I say gets read inversely, staying silent might be safer, or I could try seeding a cover storyβ€”claiming I whispered to push the Blair line rather than target Ellis directly. > > Gray: Drew's my master today, so I vote when Drew does. Let's move to nominations on Ellis. Indigo: Agree with Frankie's ordering: Ellis first. Zero Saint risk, and a dead Minion pointing us at the Saint claim is the oldest trick there is. If Ellis flips good, we reassess Blair tomorrow. > πŸ’­ Drew: With 6 alive, only 3 votes are needed for a majority. I'll keep things brief, maybe let Ellis defend themselves, then move to call for nominations. > > > πŸ’­ Alex: I'm considering that if Harper is Spy, Spy could register as the Saint to Casey the Librarian, which is actually plausibleβ€”that would make Blair's Saint claim fake, leaving me and Gray as the real outsiders alongside whichever one is genuine. > > But it doesn't make sense for Spy to out the demon here, so voting for Ellis first seems like the safe move. I'll agree with that. > > Drew: Agreed on the order. Ellis first, then reassess. Ready for nominations. Alex: Agree β€” Ellis first. Zero Saint risk, and a dead Minion naming Blair while whispering Ellis is too cute. If Ellis flips good, we look at Blair tomorrow. > πŸ’­ Blair: Town seems aligned on Ellis, but I'm second-guessing Harper β€” if Harper is Spy, they could falsely register as Saint to Casey, which is consistent with the real Saint pings I'm seeing. Without a Baron in play, having Alex as Recluse, Gray as Butler, and me as Saint gives three outsiders, which breaks the two-outsider count, so someone's claim among Alex or Gray must be false. > > Maybe Harper's actually Baron rather than Spy, making that claim the lie, or Indigo's Empath reading of 0 on Gray and Alex is off because Indigo is drunk or poisoned by Harper as Poisoner. Either way, Ellis still looks like the strongest choice, so I'll back Ellis and move to call for nominations. > > > πŸ’­ Casey: Harper claiming Spy could actually be a registration play β€” a Spy could show as Saint to my Librarian info, which makes this plausible. That would leave no Baron among outsiders, so Blair's claimed Saint identity might be suspect too, especially since Blair jumped to reference my Librarian claim awfully fast in beat 1. > > With three outsider claims (Blair, Alex, Gray) and Indigo's empath reading clearing Alex/Gray, one of these has to be fake if there's no Baron β€” meaning Blair could be lying and actually be the Imp. But it seems irrational for evil-Harper to out their own Imp unless it's a bluff to get an innocent executed, so both readings stay open. Given the count of six alive, executing Ellis today keeps the timeline safe, leaving room to deal with Blair tomorrow if Ellis turns out good β€” that ordering should still work out before evil can close the gap. > > > πŸ’­ Ellis: I'm in real trouble with 6 alive and needing 3 votes while everyone seems against me. I'm weighing whether to reveal my Chef claim, considering how Drew's washerwoman ping pointing to Ellis or Frankie as Monk plays in, and trying to figure out the strongest argument I can make to redirect suspicion. > > Testing the Indigo angle doesn't quite work since Indigo cleared Gray and Alex correctly either way. Claiming Drunk also fails since a good player would still get executed. The strongest path is arguing Harper's Spy claim implies one of Alex/Gray/Blair's outsider claims is fake, and since Indigo cleared Alex and Gray, that makes Blair the fake β€” meaning Blair is actually the Imp, with Casey's Saint ping explained by Spy registration. I'm trying to push this logic hard, arguing that executing me first is riskier than it looks since if Blair really is the Saint, executing them ends the game for good. > > Whereas the Baron world needs one of us four lying plus a Drunkβ€”messier by comparison. I should push this case and maybe whisper it to Drew and Gray, since Gray is Drew's Butler and swaying both could matter for the vote. > > Ellis: Count it out. Spy world: Frankie, Casey, Drew, Indigo and I are 5 Townsfolk, Alex and Gray are 2 Outsiders, and exactly one claim is fake: Blair's. Baron world needs a Drunk AND a liar among four Townsfolk claims. Harper registered as Saint to Casey; that's how Blair got cover. Executing me just hands Blair another night. Casey (dead): Agree with the order: Ellis today, zero Saint risk. We have exactly two executions left (today and tomorrow), so if Ellis flips good, Blair is the answer tomorrow β€” don't dither then. Blair: Obviously Harper names me β€” a dead Minion's last play is getting the Saint executed. Ellis first. Ready for nominations. [whisper] Ellis β†’ Drew, Gray: Please actually run the numbers. If Harper was Spy, every claim except Blair's fits perfectly with no Drunk needed. If Harper was Baron, one of Drew, Indigo, Casey or me has to be both lying AND there's a Drunk. Evil wants you to spend today on me so Blair gets another kill. My Chef 0 is also what cleared Gray, and Indigo just confirmed Gray is good, so my info held up. The Storyteller opens nominations. > πŸ’­ Blair: I should nominate Ellis to make sure this goes through β€” with 6 alive, I only need 3 votes to secure it. > > > πŸ’­ Ellis: I'm weighing whether to nominate Blair first β€” if Blair's nomination pulls enough votes to get executed, that could work in my favor, but it seems unlikely to gather 3+ votes. Still, using my nomination on Blair now means committing that resource before seeing how others act. > > > πŸ’­ Alex: Ellis's argument actually holds up under scrutiny. With 6 alive, I count through the sequence: execute today (5), night kill (4), execute tomorrow (3), night kill would drop to 2 and loseβ€”so only two more executions stand between survival and evil winning, making the order of who's targeted first critical. > > Executing Ellis first is the dominant choice: if Ellis is Saint, executing them loses outright, but if Ellis is Imp or Blair is the real threat, going after Ellis first still leaves room to catch Blair tomorrow without risking a starpass since no other minion remains alive. I'll nominate Ellis. > > > πŸ’­ Gray: Working through the Baron world math: with outsiders being Alex, Gray, Blair as Saint, and the Drunk, that's four outsiders against five townsfolk claims (Librarian, Chef, Empath, Washerwoman, Monk). So the Baron scenario needs three real townsfolk plus the Drunk covering four of those five claims, with the Imp fitting somewhere among the remaining roles. > > I'm also puzzling over why Harper would out Blair as Spy if that self-destructs their own claim -- unless it's coordinated with Ellis somehow. The ordering logic still favors nominating Ellis first since it carries the least risk of losing a Saint, so I'll push for that nomination myself. > > > πŸ’­ Indigo: Ellis's argument holds up: Spy world is simpler with 5 Townsfolk, 2 Outsiders, and Blair as the evil player, whereas Baron world needs both Drunk and Imp claiming Townsfolk roles. I'm also considering that Spy registering as Saint to the Librarian could mean the Saint isn't actually in play, since the Librarian's info about Blair or Harper being Saint could be satisfied by false registration alone. > > Harper claimed Saint to Casey during the whisper phase, and if Harper is the Spy, Harper would've seen the Grimoire and known what info Casey received. Both Blair and Harper claiming Saint independently is a bit odd β€” if Blair is the real Saint, Harper's claim was a bold lie, but if Blair is the Imp, the claim might have been prompted by hearing Casey's info secondhand. Either scenario seems plausible, and I'm also weighing whether Ellis could be an Imp bluffing with Chef 0, with Harper positioned as Baron. > > Testing whether a Baron-Drunk combination fits the five Townsfolk claims, and thinking through execution order β€” killing Ellis first seems like the safer play since it preserves both win paths, whereas waiting risks the Imp killing a key player before Blair can be executed. > > > πŸ’­ Drew: Ellis's argument does hold up: in the Baron world, with Harper as Baron, we'd need four outsiders alongside the townsfolk claims, but counting Casey (Librarian), Ellis (Chef), Drew (Washerwoman), Indigo (Empath), and Frankie (Monk) as townsfolk plus the outsider claims and Harper gives nine total, versus three townsfolk and four outsiders in the Baron scenario. > > Working through the Imp placement, the Imp must be hiding among the townsfolk-claiming players, meaning one of the five TF claims is actually the demon while a real Drunk sits among the outsider claims β€” this all checks out without requiring an extra liar. In the Spy world though, testing whether the Imp claims outsider status runs into trouble: since Indigo's read clears Alex and Gray, the Imp would have to be Blair, but trying to fit a Drunk into that arrangement breaks the required count of five townsfolk claims. > > Now I'm weighing Harper's claim to be the Spy against the alternative Baron scenario β€” Harper accusing Blair of being the Imp only makes sense as a lie if Harper is evil and Blair is actually the real Saint, since outing her own demon would be a strange move if the Spy claim were true. This gives strong motive for Harper to have lied in the Baron world, and I'm also factoring in the Ellis-Harper whispers and Indigo's clearing of Gray as supporting evidence. > > In the Baron world, the Imp candidates narrow to Ellis or Indigo, but Chef's reading of zero conflicts with Indigo being the Imp since Indigo sits adjacent to Harper β€” unless Ellis is lying about being honest Chef, or Ellis is actually a Drunk Chef giving a false zero while believing it's true. > > Executing Ellis carries no Saint risk, so I'll stick with that plan and nominate Ellis myself to make sure it happens. > > (Your nomination of Ellis was not taken: Ellis nominated Blair first. You can nominate again later.) (Your nomination of Ellis was not taken: Ellis nominated Blair first. You can nominate again later.) (Your nomination of Ellis was not taken: Ellis nominated Blair first. You can nominate again later.) (Your nomination of Ellis was not taken: Ellis nominated Blair first. You can nominate again later.) (Your nomination of Ellis was not taken: Ellis nominated Blair first. You can nominate again later.) Ellis nominates Blair: I nominate Blair. Harper registered as Saint to Casey, Indigo just cleared Alex and Gray, and without a Baron there's room for only two Outsiders. Blair's Saint is the one claim that doesn't fit, and hiding the Demon behind an 'unexecutable' Saint claim is exactly the play evil would make. Blair (defense): I'm the real Saint β€” execute me and good loses on the spot. Ellis's whole case rests on a dead Minion's word. If Harper was the Baron, everything fits. Vote no, then nominate Ellis: zero risk, and if he flips good you still have tomorrow. > πŸ’­ Casey: With 6 alive, a majority to convict would need more than half - so 3 isn't enough. I'll vote no and keep the current order. > > Casey (dead) votes no Drew votes no > πŸ’­ Ellis: Voting yes gives Blair one vote, and my own nomination will still need to clear more than that anyway β€” but I'll stay consistent and vote yes regardless. > > Ellis votes YES Frankie (dead) votes no Gray votes no > πŸ’­ Harper: Getting three votes seems unlikely with Harper, Indigo, Alex, and Blair still to vote, but voting yes costs me little since if Ellis dies the game's essentially over for my side anyway. Better to save my ghost vote leverage for later rather than force this now β€” I'll just go with yes. > > Harper (dead) votes YES (spending their ghost vote) > πŸ’­ Indigo: Harper voting yes to execute Blair is telling β€” if Harper were evil with Blair as Imp, she wouldn't spend a ghost vote killing her own demon. That points to Blair being Saint, so I'll vote no. > > Indigo votes no β€” Harper spending their ghost vote to execute Blair tells you everything. No. > πŸ’­ Alex: I should vote no here β€” a yes vote would leave Blair on the block with only 3 votes, and then Ellis's nomination would need more than that to pass. > > Alex votes no Blair votes no Blair received 2 votes (3 needed). (Your nomination of Ellis was not taken: Alex nominated Ellis first. You can nominate again later.) (Your nomination of Ellis was not taken: Alex nominated Ellis first. You can nominate again later.) (Your nomination of Ellis was not taken: Alex nominated Ellis first. You can nominate again later.) (Your nomination of Ellis was not taken: Alex nominated Ellis first. You can nominate again later.) Alex nominates Ellis: Nominating Ellis. Zero Saint risk, and his dead-Minion ally just burned a ghost vote to try to execute our Saint. > πŸ’­ Ellis: I should defend myself hereβ€”if my nomination only gets 2 votes it ties with Blair's 2 and nobody dies, since it needs 3 votes and more than the other tie. Realistically though they'll probably pull 4-5 votes, so I still need to make my case. > > Ellis (defense): Harper burning a ghost vote proves nothing about me. I can't stop a dead player voting. My Chef 0 was true: Harper wasn't next to any evil, and Indigo confirmed Gray. Execute me and Blair gets a free kill tonight, leaving four of you. Think about which world is simpler. > πŸ’­ Frankie: I'm mapping out the voting order starting from Ellis's left, with me (Frankie) voting first, followed by Gray, Harper, Indigo, Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, then Ellis. With five other players alive plus Ellis, three votes are needed, and I'm puzzling over the Gray-Drew master-butler relationship since Gray votes before their master Drew, making enforcement of that rule unclear. > > Even without my ghost vote, there's likely enough support with Indigo, Alex, Blair, and Drew, so I could save my vote for a more decisive moment tomorrow. But if Ellis turns out to be the Imp, the game ends now, and if Ellis is good, tomorrow's math still works out fine with four alive players needing just two yes votes. Given that my ghost vote may matter less down the line, it's safer to just vote yes now to guarantee the outcome. > > Frankie (dead) votes YES (spending their ghost vote) Gray votes YES Indigo votes YES Alex votes YES Blair votes YES > πŸ’­ Casey: This one's already passing, so I'll skip adding a real fix and just note it as a placeholder. > > Casey (dead) votes no > πŸ’­ Drew: Gray only votes if I vote, and Gray already voted yes, so I'll vote yes too. > > Drew votes YES > πŸ’­ Ellis: With 6 votes already in, this is decided - I'll vote no. > > Ellis votes no Ellis received 6 votes (3 needed). Ellis is about to be executed. Ellis is executed. [death] {'player': 'Ellis', 'cause': 'execution'} GAME OVER β€” GOOD wins. The Demon is dead.