{
  "repo": "endomorphosis/ipfs_germany_laws",
  "base_tip": "62477e216917df268f186972ef49581b02144156",
  "staged_at": "2026-10-02T17:22:15-0700",
  "uploaded": true,
  "method": "append-only: federal (gesetze-im-internet) rows first and byte-identical row values; DE-<Land> Landesrecht rows appended in Land order (BW..TH), then date_issued, then id",
  "subnational_laws_added": {
    "DE-BB": 962,
    "DE-NW": 1264,
    "DE-SN": 934
  },
  "subnational_articles_added": {
    "DE-BB": 20311,
    "DE-NW": 26603,
    "DE-SN": 17237
  },
  "never_thin": {
    "live_tip": "62477e216917df268f186972ef49581b02144156",
    "tip_unchanged": true,
    "snapshot_matches_live": true,
    "stage": "/workspace/legal-corpora/hf-staging/ipfs_germany_laws_subnational_noHB_20261002T172147",
    "source_stage": "/workspace/legal-corpora/hf-staging/ipfs_germany_laws_subnational_20261002T171728",
    "hb_dropped": {
      "laws": 1166,
      "articles": 18581
    },
    "laws": {
      "old_rows": 6127,
      "new_rows": 9287,
      "columns_arrow_equal": true,
      "mismatch_columns": [],
      "federal_rowset_sha256_old": "478e615aca8fc10e218648af2eed1a61766bad746cf91211184a164a00e42d8b",
      "federal_rowset_sha256_new": "478e615aca8fc10e218648af2eed1a61766bad746cf91211184a164a00e42d8b",
      "old_ids_missing": 0,
      "duplicate_ids_before": 0,
      "duplicate_ids_after": 0,
      "new_duplicate_ids": 0,
      "schema_equal_incl_metadata": true,
      "column_order_equal": true,
      "PASS": true
    },
    "articles": {
      "old_rows": 129983,
      "new_rows": 194134,
      "columns_arrow_equal": true,
      "mismatch_columns": [],
      "federal_rowset_sha256_old": "9e63dc3c3cd267eee2e392d94d1e6db333eedc402261d37c33546b530b57b554",
      "federal_rowset_sha256_new": "9e63dc3c3cd267eee2e392d94d1e6db333eedc402261d37c33546b530b57b554",
      "old_ids_missing": 0,
      "duplicate_ids_before": 4824,
      "duplicate_ids_after": 4824,
      "new_duplicate_ids": 0,
      "schema_equal_incl_metadata": true,
      "column_order_equal": true,
      "PASS": true
    },
    "post": {
      "per_jurisdiction": {
        "DE": {
          "laws": 6127,
          "articles": 129983
        },
        "DE-BB": {
          "laws": 962,
          "articles": 20311
        },
        "DE-NW": {
          "laws": 1264,
          "articles": 26603
        },
        "DE-SN": {
          "laws": 934,
          "articles": 17237
        }
      },
      "orphan_articles": 0,
      "article_count_mismatch_laws": 0,
      "hb_law_rows": 0,
      "hb_article_rows": 0
    },
    "expected_counts_match": true,
    "federal_first": true,
    "laws_sha256_staged": "4956a300ac1392196ecc633d89cb2305b41a57926889cd2b07872ae639213aa1",
    "articles_sha256_staged": "7f72155737bc43cf45783f5ef6dcb732d000f45ca8dcc774b9fa270cfa5f9d04",
    "PASS": true
  },
  "never_thin_independent": {
    "laws": {
      "old_rows": 6127,
      "new_rows": 9287,
      "columns_arrow_equal": true,
      "mismatch_columns": [],
      "federal_rowset_sha256_old": "478e615aca8fc10e218648af2eed1a61766bad746cf91211184a164a00e42d8b",
      "federal_rowset_sha256_new": "478e615aca8fc10e218648af2eed1a61766bad746cf91211184a164a00e42d8b",
      "old_ids_missing": 0,
      "duplicate_ids_before": 0,
      "duplicate_ids_after": 0,
      "new_duplicate_ids": 0,
      "schema_equal_incl_metadata": true,
      "column_order_equal": true,
      "PASS": true
    },
    "articles": {
      "old_rows": 129983,
      "new_rows": 194134,
      "columns_arrow_equal": true,
      "mismatch_columns": [],
      "federal_rowset_sha256_old": "9e63dc3c3cd267eee2e392d94d1e6db333eedc402261d37c33546b530b57b554",
      "federal_rowset_sha256_new": "9e63dc3c3cd267eee2e392d94d1e6db333eedc402261d37c33546b530b57b554",
      "old_ids_missing": 0,
      "duplicate_ids_before": 4824,
      "duplicate_ids_after": 4824,
      "new_duplicate_ids": 0,
      "schema_equal_incl_metadata": true,
      "column_order_equal": true,
      "PASS": true
    }
  },
  "schema_parity": {
    "laws": true,
    "articles": true,
    "PASS": true
  },
  "dedupe": {
    "method": {
      "normalized_title": "NFKC, lower-case, trailing \"vom <date>\" removed, punctuation collapsed",
      "text_hash": "sha1 of whitespace-collapsed NFKC law body (law text minus title); bodies <200 chars not hashed",
      "true_duplicate_rule": "SN: old REVOSax ids that redirect are resolved to the final vorschrift id (canonical page kept; alias re-keyed if canonical not cached). Same id with different text -> re-keyed (BB de-bb-vo-<slug>). within Land: same id (keep first) or same normalized title AND same body hash (keep first). vs federal: same id, or same body hash as a federal law (identical consolidated text) -> dropped. Title-only matches are reported, not dropped."
    },
    "per_land": {
      "DE-NW": {
        "vs_federal_by_abbreviation_info": 3,
        "vs_federal_by_normalized_title": 1,
        "laws_in": 1264,
        "laws_kept": 1264,
        "laws_dropped": 0,
        "articles_in": 26603,
        "articles_kept": 26603,
        "within_same_normalized_title_kept": 5,
        "within_same_body_hash_kept_diff_title": 0,
        "article_ids_colliding_with_federal": 0,
        "duplicate_article_ids_within": 0,
        "article_text_identical_to_a_federal_article": 47
      },
      "DE-SN": {
        "within_by_resolved_portal_id": 99,
        "within_by_resolved_portal_id_text_identical": 99,
        "rekeyed_redirect_alias": 4,
        "vs_federal_by_abbreviation_info": 1,
        "laws_in": 1033,
        "laws_kept": 934,
        "laws_dropped": 99,
        "articles_in": 19783,
        "articles_kept": 17237,
        "within_same_normalized_title_kept": 51,
        "within_same_body_hash_kept_diff_title": 0,
        "article_ids_colliding_with_federal": 0,
        "duplicate_article_ids_within": 0,
        "article_text_identical_to_a_federal_article": 5
      },
      "DE-HB": {
        "vs_federal_by_normalized_title": 3,
        "vs_federal_by_abbreviation_info": 2,
        "laws_in": 1166,
        "laws_kept": 1166,
        "laws_dropped": 0,
        "articles_in": 18581,
        "articles_kept": 18581,
        "within_same_normalized_title_kept": 2,
        "within_same_body_hash_kept_diff_title": 0,
        "article_ids_colliding_with_federal": 0,
        "duplicate_article_ids_within": 0,
        "article_text_identical_to_a_federal_article": 22
      },
      "DE-BB": {
        "rekeyed_id_collision": 1,
        "vs_federal_by_normalized_title": 3,
        "vs_federal_by_abbreviation_info": 6,
        "laws_in": 962,
        "laws_kept": 962,
        "laws_dropped": 0,
        "articles_in": 20311,
        "articles_kept": 20311,
        "within_same_normalized_title_kept": 1,
        "within_same_body_hash_kept_diff_title": 0,
        "article_ids_colliding_with_federal": 0,
        "duplicate_article_ids_within": 0,
        "article_text_identical_to_a_federal_article": 10
      }
    },
    "federal_title_overlaps_kept": {
      "DE-NW": [
        {
          "id": "de-nw-32418",
          "title": "Verordnung zur Überleitung in die im Zweiten Gesetz zur Vereinheitlichung und Neuregelung des Besoldungsrechts in Bund und Ländern geregelten Ämter und über die",
          "federal_id": "besvng2_lv"
        }
      ],
      "DE-HB": [
        {
          "id": "de-hb-nnlhb0000b280",
          "title": "Gesetz zur Ahndung nationalsozialistischer Straftaten",
          "federal_id": "nsahndgg_br"
        },
        {
          "id": "de-hb-nnlhb0000b27f",
          "title": "Gesetz zur Wiedergutmachung nationalsozialistischen Unrechts in der Strafrechtspflege",
          "federal_id": "nsunrg_br"
        },
        {
          "id": "de-hb-nnlhb0000aaac",
          "title": "Verordnung zur Ausführung des Personenstandsgesetzes",
          "federal_id": "pstv"
        }
      ],
      "DE-BB": [
        {
          "id": "de-bb-natpmschweizv",
          "title": "Verordnung über die Festsetzung von Naturschutzgebieten und einem Landschaftsschutzgebiet von zentraler Bedeutung als Naturpark „Märkische Schweiz“",
          "federal_id": "natpmschweizv"
        },
        {
          "id": "de-bb-natsgschorfhv",
          "title": "Verordnung über die Festsetzung von Naturschutzgebieten und einem Landschaftsschutzgebiet von zentraler Bedeutung mit der Gesamtbezeichnung „Biosphärenreservat ",
          "federal_id": "natsgschorfhv"
        },
        {
          "id": "de-bb-natsgspreewv",
          "title": "Verordnung über die Festsetzung von Naturschutzgebieten und einem Landschaftsschutzgebiet von zentraler Bedeutung mit der Gesamtbezeichnung „Biosphärenreservat ",
          "federal_id": "natsgspreewv"
        }
      ]
    },
    "federal_title_overlap_note": "Kept: same title as a GII federal row but different text. GII carries some pre-1990 GDR regulations (Naturpark/Biosphärenreservat VOs of 12.09.1990) and Bremen-origin laws (_br) as continuing federal law; the Land portals carry their own Landesrecht versions. Text similarity to the federal row: de-bb-natsgschorfhv 0.93, de-bb-natsgspreewv 0.91, de-bb-natpmschweizv 0.29, de-nw-32418 0.26, HB rows <=0.08 -> not byte-identical, so not dropped.",
    "dropped_total": 99,
    "dropped_vs_federal": 0,
    "rekeyed": [
      {
        "land": "SN",
        "old_id": "de-sn-13761",
        "new_id": "de-sn-18338",
        "source_url": "https://www.revosax.sachsen.de/vorschrift/18338",
        "why": "REVOSax id 13761 redirects to vorschrift/18338; canonical page not otherwise cached"
      },
      {
        "land": "SN",
        "old_id": "de-sn-18658",
        "new_id": "de-sn-19006",
        "source_url": "https://www.revosax.sachsen.de/vorschrift/19006",
        "why": "REVOSax id 18658 redirects to vorschrift/19006; canonical page not otherwise cached"
      },
      {
        "land": "SN",
        "old_id": "de-sn-18886",
        "new_id": "de-sn-19726",
        "source_url": "https://www.revosax.sachsen.de/vorschrift/19726",
        "why": "REVOSax id 18886 redirects to vorschrift/19726; canonical page not otherwise cached"
      },
      {
        "land": "SN",
        "old_id": "de-sn-17188",
        "new_id": "de-sn-21651",
        "source_url": "https://www.revosax.sachsen.de/vorschrift/21651",
        "why": "REVOSax id 17188 redirects to vorschrift/21651; canonical page not otherwise cached"
      },
      {
        "land": "BB",
        "old_id": "de-bb-mdf-2015",
        "new_id": "de-bb-vo-mdf-2015",
        "source_url": "https://bravors.brandenburg.de/verordnungen/mdf_2015",
        "why": "id collision with a different instrument of the same Land"
      }
    ],
    "federal_preexisting_duplicate_article_ids": 4824,
    "id_namespace": "Landesrecht ids are 'de-<land>-<portal id>' (nw, sn, hb, bb); 0 collide with the 6,127 federal law ids or 125,159 distinct federal article ids (one federal id, 'de-mail-g', also begins with 'de-' but is not in a Land namespace).",
    "note_noHB": "dedupe numbers cover all 4 collected Länder; HB had 0 drops"
  },
  "dedupe_dropped_ids": [
    "de-sn-1264",
    "de-sn-1924",
    "de-sn-4514",
    "de-sn-5448",
    "de-sn-1527",
    "de-sn-12541",
    "de-sn-10308",
    "de-sn-18323",
    "de-sn-4924",
    "de-sn-12110",
    "de-sn-9818",
    "de-sn-2939",
    "de-sn-14154",
    "de-sn-17977",
    "de-sn-15181",
    "de-sn-18325",
    "de-sn-12889",
    "de-sn-4434",
    "de-sn-18248",
    "de-sn-14106",
    "de-sn-14107",
    "de-sn-18326",
    "de-sn-2068",
    "de-sn-14182",
    "de-sn-12036",
    "de-sn-11440",
    "de-sn-2228",
    "de-sn-4425",
    "de-sn-1593",
    "de-sn-18739",
    "de-sn-18897",
    "de-sn-12387",
    "de-sn-9242",
    "de-sn-18929",
    "de-sn-19062",
    "de-sn-19034",
    "de-sn-19155",
    "de-sn-19190",
    "de-sn-19189",
    "de-sn-19298",
    "de-sn-19299",
    "de-sn-19327",
    "de-sn-19328",
    "de-sn-3673",
    "de-sn-11999",
    "de-sn-19403",
    "de-sn-19557",
    "de-sn-19564",
    "de-sn-19548",
    "de-sn-2948",
    "de-sn-12887",
    "de-sn-18610",
    "de-sn-19662",
    "de-sn-1596",
    "de-sn-18939",
    "de-sn-16904",
    "de-sn-13868",
    "de-sn-17812",
    "de-sn-10739",
    "de-sn-4286",
    "de-sn-10424",
    "de-sn-3733",
    "de-sn-10562",
    "de-sn-12517",
    "de-sn-4146",
    "de-sn-2674",
    "de-sn-3941",
    "de-sn-10289",
    "de-sn-13873",
    "de-sn-2876",
    "de-sn-17366",
    "de-sn-17730",
    "de-sn-16805",
    "de-sn-19379",
    "de-sn-9577",
    "de-sn-9801",
    "de-sn-9315",
    "de-sn-10462",
    "de-sn-17722",
    "de-sn-10461",
    "de-sn-3553",
    "de-sn-1856",
    "de-sn-3288",
    "de-sn-12206",
    "de-sn-10909",
    "de-sn-10636",
    "de-sn-1307",
    "de-sn-19750",
    "de-sn-4508",
    "de-sn-16264",
    "de-sn-12018",
    "de-sn-11438",
    "de-sn-13945",
    "de-sn-19795",
    "de-sn-20373",
    "de-sn-19977",
    "de-sn-17330",
    "de-sn-12147",
    "de-sn-17976"
  ],
  "handcheck_20": 20,
  "spotcheck": "48/48",
  "variant": "noHB",
  "source_stage": "/workspace/legal-corpora/hf-staging/ipfs_germany_laws_subnational_20261002T171728",
  "held_local_only": {
    "DE-HB": {
      "laws": 1166,
      "articles": 18581,
      "reason": "licence review pending: every HB document labelled CC BY-NC-ND while portal terms say 'für alle Zwecke' with attribution"
    }
  },
  "totals": {
    "laws": 9287,
    "articles": 194134
  },
  "uploaded_at": "2026-10-19T08:41:55-0700",
  "upload_parent_commit": "ea1b53b04c19b18d4810826d544c5414621596bb",
  "nw_delta_20261018": {
    "parent_tip": "ea1b53b04c19b18d4810826d544c5414621596bb",
    "new_laws": 19,
    "new_articles": 240,
    "new_law_ids": [
      "de-nw-26575",
      "de-nw-27299",
      "de-nw-28123",
      "de-nw-28174",
      "de-nw-28186",
      "de-nw-28249",
      "de-nw-28266",
      "de-nw-28401",
      "de-nw-28723",
      "de-nw-28766",
      "de-nw-28902",
      "de-nw-30179",
      "de-nw-30563",
      "de-nw-30610",
      "de-nw-31266",
      "de-nw-32954",
      "de-nw-33321",
      "de-nw-33702",
      "de-nw-34110"
    ],
    "source_stage": "/workspace/legal-corpora/hf-staging/de_nw_delta_20261018T182357",
    "appended_at": "2026-10-19T08:41:55-0700",
    "totals_after": {
      "laws": 12348,
      "articles": 213351
    },
    "DE-NW_laws_after": 1283,
    "DE-NW_articles_after": 26843
  },
  "update_20261025_nw_bb": {
    "commits": [
      "3ab08e388e230241cbb0b63b895ac9594f256886",
      "follow-up"
    ],
    "laws_added": {
      "DE-NW": 9,
      "DE-BB": 5
    },
    "articles_added": 428,
    "n_laws": 12362,
    "n_articles": 213779,
    "new_columns": [
      "version_date",
      "is_current",
      "supersedes",
      "superseded_by",
      "effective_from"
    ],
    "version_date_note": "NW: URL Fassung date; BB: issuance (vom) date",
    "future_versions": {
      "de-nw-b41909efdb3b47e0": "2027-01-01"
    },
    "method": "append-only",
    "source": "fresh_discovery_20261025T102144"
  }
}