{ "n_runs": 111, "n_outcomes": 39, "arms": [ "bon3_cap64", "cot_ladder", "direct_cap48", "sc3_cap64", "tool_cap128" ], "task_subset": [ "arithmetic-1-0000", "arithmetic-2-0003", "arithmetic-3-0006", "code_reasoning-1-0000", "code_reasoning-2-0003", "code_reasoning-3-0006", "logic-1-0000", "logic-2-0003", "logic-3-0006" ], "arm_table": [ { "config_id": "bon3_cap64", "strategy": "best_of_n", "n_outcomes": 9, "accuracy": 0.0, "acc_lo": 0.0, "acc_hi": 0.0, "mean_completion_tokens": 180.5556, "mean_latency_s": 7.4974, "tokens_per_correct": Infinity, "parse_error_rate": 0.0, "ece": 0.7486, "brier": 0.5671, "mean_confidence": 0.7486, "n_tool_calls": 0 }, { "config_id": "cot_ladder", "strategy": "cot", "n_outcomes": 9, "accuracy": 0.3333, "acc_lo": 0.0, "acc_hi": 0.6667, "mean_completion_tokens": 151.2222, "mean_latency_s": 32.809, "tokens_per_correct": 453.6667, "parse_error_rate": 0.3333, "ece": 0.4037, "brier": 0.3672, "mean_confidence": 0.737, "n_tool_calls": 0 }, { "config_id": "direct_cap48", "strategy": "direct", "n_outcomes": 9, "accuracy": 0.1111, "acc_lo": 0.0, "acc_hi": 0.3333, "mean_completion_tokens": 7.3333, "mean_latency_s": 2.6896, "tokens_per_correct": 66.0, "parse_error_rate": 0.3333, "ece": 0.5109, "brier": 0.3682, "mean_confidence": 0.622, "n_tool_calls": 0 }, { "config_id": "sc3_cap64", "strategy": "self_consistency", "n_outcomes": 9, "accuracy": 0.1111, "acc_lo": 0.0, "acc_hi": 0.3333, "mean_completion_tokens": 180.5556, "mean_latency_s": 7.4974, "tokens_per_correct": 1625.0, "parse_error_rate": 0.0, "ece": 0.4074, "brier": 0.284, "mean_confidence": 0.5185, "n_tool_calls": 0 }, { "config_id": "tool_cap128", "strategy": "tool_augmented", "n_outcomes": 3, "accuracy": 0.3333, "acc_lo": 0.0, "acc_hi": 1.0, "mean_completion_tokens": 128.0, "mean_latency_s": 26.8196, "tokens_per_correct": 384.0, "parse_error_rate": 0.6667, "ece": NaN, "brier": NaN, "mean_confidence": NaN, "n_tool_calls": 3 } ], "domain_table": [ { "config_id": "bon3_cap64", "domain": "arithmetic", "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 157.6667 }, { "config_id": "bon3_cap64", "domain": "code_reasoning", "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 192.0 }, { "config_id": "bon3_cap64", "domain": "logic", "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 192.0 }, { "config_id": "cot_ladder", "domain": "arithmetic", "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.6667, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 1.0, "mean_tokens": 137.3333 }, { "config_id": "cot_ladder", "domain": "code_reasoning", "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.3333, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 1.0, "mean_tokens": 156.3333 }, { "config_id": "cot_ladder", "domain": "logic", "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 160.0 }, { "config_id": "direct_cap48", "domain": "arithmetic", "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.3333, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 1.0, "mean_tokens": 2.6667 }, { "config_id": "direct_cap48", "domain": "code_reasoning", "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 3.3333 }, { "config_id": "direct_cap48", "domain": "logic", "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 16.0 }, { "config_id": "sc3_cap64", "domain": "arithmetic", "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.3333, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 1.0, "mean_tokens": 157.6667 }, { "config_id": "sc3_cap64", "domain": "code_reasoning", "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 192.0 }, { "config_id": "sc3_cap64", "domain": "logic", "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 192.0 }, { "config_id": "tool_cap128", "domain": "arithmetic", "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.3333, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 1.0, "mean_tokens": 128.0 } ], "difficulty_table": [ { "config_id": "bon3_cap64", "difficulty": 1, "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 157.6667 }, { "config_id": "bon3_cap64", "difficulty": 2, "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 192.0 }, { "config_id": "bon3_cap64", "difficulty": 3, "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 192.0 }, { "config_id": "cot_ladder", "difficulty": 1, "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.6667, "mean_tokens": 146.3333 }, { "config_id": "cot_ladder", "difficulty": 2, "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.3333, "mean_tokens": 147.3333 }, { "config_id": "cot_ladder", "difficulty": 3, "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 160.0 }, { "config_id": "direct_cap48", "difficulty": 1, "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.3333, "mean_tokens": 6.3333 }, { "config_id": "direct_cap48", "difficulty": 2, "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 6.6667 }, { "config_id": "direct_cap48", "difficulty": 3, "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 9.0 }, { "config_id": "sc3_cap64", "difficulty": 1, "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.3333, "mean_tokens": 157.6667 }, { "config_id": "sc3_cap64", "difficulty": 2, "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 192.0 }, { "config_id": "sc3_cap64", "difficulty": 3, "n": 3, "accuracy": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 192.0 }, { "config_id": "tool_cap128", "difficulty": 1, "n": 1, "accuracy": 1.0, "mean_tokens": 128.0 }, { "config_id": "tool_cap128", "difficulty": 2, "n": 1, "accuracy": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 128.0 }, { "config_id": "tool_cap128", "difficulty": 3, "n": 1, "accuracy": 0.0, "mean_tokens": 128.0 } ], "ladder_curves": { "cot_ladder": { "x": [ 48.0, 96.0, 151.22222222222223 ], "y": [ 0.0, 0.1111111111111111, 0.3333333333333333 ], "lo": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0 ], "hi": [ 0.0, 0.3333333333333333, 0.6666666666666666 ], "family": "all" }, "cot_ladder::arithmetic": { "x": [ 48.0, 96.0, 137.33333333333334 ], "y": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.6666666666666666 ], "lo": null, "hi": null, "family": "arithmetic" }, "cot_ladder::code_reasoning": { "x": [ 48.0, 96.0, 156.33333333333334 ], "y": [ 0.0, 0.3333333333333333, 0.3333333333333333 ], "lo": null, "hi": null, "family": "code_reasoning" }, "cot_ladder::logic": { "x": [ 48.0, 96.0, 160.0 ], "y": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0 ], "lo": null, "hi": null, "family": "logic" } }, "n_outcomes_all_budgets": 57, "total_completion_tokens": 6357.0, "marginal_gain": { "cot_ladder": [ { "from_tokens": 48.0, "to_tokens": 96.0, "delta_accuracy": 0.1111111111111111, "gain_per_1k_tokens": 2.3148148148148144 }, { "from_tokens": 96.0, "to_tokens": 151.22222222222223, "delta_accuracy": 0.2222222222222222, "gain_per_1k_tokens": 4.024144869215291 } ] }, "saturation": { "cot_ladder": 151.22222222222223 }, "sample_analysis": { "sc3_cap64": { "mean_sample_accuracy": 0.07407407407407407, "pass_at_k": { "1": 0.07407407407407408, "2": 0.1111111111111111, "3": 0.1111111111111111 }, "consistency": { "n_tasks": 9, "modal_agreement": 0.9629629629629629, "flip_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "stable_correct_rate": 0.0, "stable_wrong_rate": 0.8888888888888888, "unstable_rate": 0.1111111111111111 }, "answer_entropy": 0.0, "tokens_per_task": 180.55555555555554 }, "bon3_cap64": { "mean_sample_accuracy": 0.07407407407407407, "pass_at_k": { "1": 0.07407407407407408, "2": 0.1111111111111111, "3": 0.1111111111111111 }, "consistency": { "n_tasks": 9, "modal_agreement": 0.9629629629629629, "flip_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "stable_correct_rate": 0.0, "stable_wrong_rate": 0.8888888888888888, "unstable_rate": 0.1111111111111111 }, "answer_entropy": 0.0, "tokens_per_task": 180.55555555555554 } }, "paired": { "cot_ladder_vs_direct_cap48": { "diff": 0.2222222222222222, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 0.5555555555555556, "p": 0.5, "n_pairs": 9, "n_discordant": 2, "a_only": 2, "b_only": 0, "n_tasks": 9, "p_holm": 1.0 }, "sc3_cap64_vs_direct_cap48": { "diff": 0.0, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 0.0, "p": 1.0, "n_pairs": 9, "n_discordant": 0, "a_only": 0, "b_only": 0, "n_tasks": 9, "p_holm": 1.0 }, "bon3_cap64_vs_direct_cap48": { "diff": -0.1111111111111111, "lo": -0.3333333333333333, "hi": 0.0, "p": 1.0, "n_pairs": 9, "n_discordant": 1, "a_only": 0, "b_only": 1, "n_tasks": 9, "p_holm": 1.0 }, "tool_cap128_vs_direct_cap48": { "diff": 0.0, "lo": 0.0, "hi": 0.0, "p": 1.0, "n_pairs": 3, "n_discordant": 0, "a_only": 0, "b_only": 0, "n_tasks": 3, "p_holm": 1.0 } }, "budget_matched": { "direct_cap48": { "accuracy": 0.1111111111111111, "tokens": 7.333333333333333, "latency_s": 2.6895666666666664 }, "cot_ladder": { "accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, "tokens": 151.22222222222223, "latency_s": 32.80903333333334 }, "sc3_cap64": { "accuracy": 0.1111111111111111, "tokens": 180.55555555555554, "latency_s": 7.497444444444445 }, "bon3_cap64": { "accuracy": 0.0, "tokens": 180.55555555555554, "latency_s": 7.497444444444445 }, "tool_cap128": { "accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, "tokens": 128.0, "latency_s": 26.819633333333332 } }, "selective": { "direct_cap48": { "aurc": 0.7473985890652558 }, "cot_ladder": { "aurc": 0.5144179894179894 }, "sc3_cap64": { "aurc": 0.6918430335097002 }, "bon3_cap64": { "aurc": 0.8888888888888888 } } }