[ { "group": "g1_olmo1b", "base": "allenai/OLMo-2-0425-1B", "new": "allenai/OLMo-2-0425-1B-DPO", "revisions": [ "a1847dff35000b4271fa70afc5db10fd29fedbdf", "c4b0485961ab24c2433b090f3b922f0913a9290f" ], "T_new": 1.1949092149734497, "T_old": 1.0043145418167114, "T_new_top4k": 1.1949092149734497, "T_old_top4k": 1.0043145418167114, "jensen_ok": true, "Delta": 0.4185507648961213, "Delta_ci": [ 0.41313019781259347, 0.4240376949368989 ], "S_sym_aff": 0.16012318485343013, "S_sym_aff_ci": [ 0.15287248442099333, 0.16694215494252354 ], "S_card_aff": 0.16011954147232665, "S_card_aff_ci": [ 0.15286963810204937, 0.1669779527446439 ], "S_sym_cf_beta100000": 0.07835146462235221, "S_sym_cf_beta100000_ci": [ 0.07634619048538215, 0.08026267707100732 ], "S_sym_bias": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_bias_top4k": 0.06527161057675568, "S_sym_bias_top4k_ci": [ 0.06309050092610702, 0.06744767850643389 ], "S_sym_aff_top4k": 0.23399849379618753, "S_sym_aff_top4k_ci": [ 0.22983486177381277, 0.23793867627041834 ], "valid": true, "flag_bias": false, "flag_aff_above_floor": false }, { "group": "g1_olmo1b", "base": "allenai/OLMo-2-0425-1B", "new": "allenai/OLMo-2-0425-1B-Instruct", "revisions": [ "a1847dff35000b4271fa70afc5db10fd29fedbdf", "48d788eca847d4d7548f375ad03d3c9312f6139e" ], "T_new": 1.1988457441329956, "T_old": 1.0043145418167114, "T_new_top4k": 1.1988457441329956, "T_old_top4k": 1.0043145418167114, "jensen_ok": true, "Delta": 0.4231487361167017, "Delta_ci": [ 0.41772161873286384, 0.42877136036828556 ], "S_sym_aff": 0.15816555155741407, "S_sym_aff_ci": [ 0.15081662314148034, 0.1650820600037124 ], "S_card_aff": 0.15816194776560877, "S_card_aff_ci": [ 0.15079631051875936, 0.16508937167423646 ], "S_sym_cf_beta100000": 0.07383643665745132, "S_sym_cf_beta100000_ci": [ 0.07185936933106778, 0.07574547600257059 ], "S_sym_bias": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_bias_top4k": 0.059778396064337436, "S_sym_bias_top4k_ci": [ 0.05759155713319683, 0.06194250992729082 ], "S_sym_aff_top4k": 0.23385028320516055, "S_sym_aff_top4k_ci": [ 0.22963560597015972, 0.2377476761809702 ], "valid": true, "flag_bias": false, "flag_aff_above_floor": false }, { "group": "g1_olmo1b", "base": "allenai/OLMo-2-0425-1B", "new": "allenai/OLMo-2-0425-1B-SFT", "revisions": [ "a1847dff35000b4271fa70afc5db10fd29fedbdf", "0d85a3d037876ce6ac7d4311d994400fc66ac27f" ], "T_new": 1.0745843648910522, "T_old": 1.0043145418167114, "T_new_top4k": 1.089660406112671, "T_old_top4k": 1.0043145418167114, "jensen_ok": true, "Delta": 0.2284110083966402, "Delta_ci": [ 0.22420528392026398, 0.23275101925741817 ], "S_sym_aff": 0.059967823610939885, "S_sym_aff_ci": [ 0.058050039263162635, 0.06194179301346137 ], "S_card_aff": 0.05996114731298757, "S_card_aff_ci": [ 0.058009832448460225, 0.06197653346374726 ], "S_sym_cf_beta100000": 0.03633450406250438, "S_sym_cf_beta100000_ci": [ 0.03406993192006898, 0.03853931513302604 ], "S_sym_bias": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_bias_top4k": 0.017736728921653566, "S_sym_bias_top4k_ci": [ 0.01623808915187231, 0.019325711876835697 ], "S_sym_aff_top4k": 0.08860544773964218, "S_sym_aff_top4k_ci": [ 0.08518144330300771, 0.09204609665961445 ], "valid": true, "flag_bias": false, "flag_aff_above_floor": false }, { "group": "g2_olmo7b", "base": "allenai/OLMo-2-1124-7B", "new": "allenai/OLMo-2-1124-7B-DPO", "revisions": [ "7df9a82518afdecae4e8c026b27adccc8c1f0032", "e34ea60adff2e575f4fe7569eaffd1b28509b6fd" ], "T_new": 1.2012851238250732, "T_old": 1.0063581466674805, "T_new_top4k": 1.256685495376587, "T_old_top4k": 1.0063581466674805, "jensen_ok": true, "Delta": 0.32937609416625335, "Delta_ci": [ 0.32453808906442905, 0.3340626024740971 ], "S_sym_aff": 0.23491369607491075, "S_sym_aff_ci": [ 0.23107224444540556, 0.23891159267279166 ], "S_card_aff": 0.23508006706386267, "S_card_aff_ci": [ 0.2311740826897212, 0.23911200398203097 ], "S_sym_cf_beta100000": 0.05177416941698454, "S_sym_cf_beta100000_ci": [ 0.05051137949109771, 0.05309973715531023 ], "S_sym_bias": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_bias_top4k": 0.03771076521225081, "S_sym_bias_top4k_ci": [ 0.03619239920911191, 0.03916814882482527 ], "S_sym_aff_top4k": 0.3352596598309593, "S_sym_aff_top4k_ci": [ 0.3299508901978646, 0.34048443405148876 ], "valid": true, "flag_bias": false, "flag_aff_above_floor": false }, { "group": "g2_olmo7b", "base": "allenai/OLMo-2-1124-7B", "new": "allenai/OLMo-2-1124-7B-Instruct", "revisions": [ "7df9a82518afdecae4e8c026b27adccc8c1f0032", "470b1fba1ae01581f270116362ee4aa1b97f4c84" ], "T_new": 1.2196701765060425, "T_old": 1.0063581466674805, "T_new_top4k": 1.2759183645248413, "T_old_top4k": 1.0063581466674805, "jensen_ok": true, "Delta": 0.3539630246342731, "Delta_ci": [ 0.34882031975645333, 0.3590025080956555 ], "S_sym_aff": 0.25659014709824157, "S_sym_aff_ci": [ 0.25275536738528626, 0.2605863233670888 ], "S_card_aff": 0.2567449616486603, "S_card_aff_ci": [ 0.25283752342116395, 0.26080309722368794 ], "S_sym_cf_beta100000": 0.05185383425335888, "S_sym_cf_beta100000_ci": [ 0.05061230174343176, 0.05316466206283642 ], "S_sym_bias": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_bias_top4k": 0.038614487707227196, "S_sym_bias_top4k_ci": [ 0.03711942058834634, 0.04005681420830686 ], "S_sym_aff_top4k": 0.35885688266548277, "S_sym_aff_top4k_ci": [ 0.35370668924632315, 0.36400023536945997 ], "valid": true, "flag_bias": false, "flag_aff_above_floor": false }, { "group": "g2_olmo7b", "base": "allenai/OLMo-2-1124-7B", "new": "allenai/OLMo-2-1124-7B-SFT", "revisions": [ "7df9a82518afdecae4e8c026b27adccc8c1f0032", "1de02c0175118a9de5854aec80a1f970e701e928" ], "T_new": 1.1108440160751343, "T_old": 1.0063581466674805, "T_new_top4k": 1.1301395893096924, "T_old_top4k": 1.0063581466674805, "jensen_ok": true, "Delta": 0.1650833158937437, "Delta_ci": [ 0.1621969969104053, 0.16810884446084165 ], "S_sym_aff": 0.1394018983905312, "S_sym_aff_ci": [ 0.1350680743971902, 0.1437479520949934 ], "S_card_aff": 0.13973384366450942, "S_card_aff_ci": [ 0.13531646382873413, 0.14418655744335712 ], "S_sym_cf_beta100000": 0.039156465387399364, "S_sym_cf_beta100000_ci": [ 0.037312330353177506, 0.041032489395481424 ], "S_sym_bias": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_bias_top4k": 0.02037636725856662, "S_sym_bias_top4k_ci": [ 0.018918295356509265, 0.021873031347081674 ], "S_sym_aff_top4k": 0.17508902991291897, "S_sym_aff_top4k_ci": [ 0.16981712280302136, 0.18048574892264332 ], "valid": true, "flag_bias": false, "flag_aff_above_floor": false }, { "group": "g3_qwen7b", "base": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-7B", "new": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct", "revisions": [ "d149729398750b98c0af14eb82c78cfe92750796", "a09a35458c702b33eeacc393d103063234e8bc28" ], "T_new": 1.0825163125991821, "T_old": 1.0129996538162231, "T_new_top4k": 1.0803180932998657, "T_old_top4k": 1.0129996538162231, "jensen_ok": true, "Delta": 0.049644093618954166, "Delta_ci": [ 0.04823753450969246, 0.0511898176387201 ], "S_sym_aff": 0.23850534914212485, "S_sym_aff_ci": [ 0.23276452997725733, 0.24435291053167382 ], "S_card_aff": 0.24203513064817733, "S_card_aff_ci": [ 0.23545901889688906, 0.24861895018204863 ], "S_sym_cf_beta100000": 0.10550444898530476, "S_sym_cf_beta100000_ci": [ 0.09987111517830698, 0.11088233530189218 ], "S_sym_bias": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_bias_top4k": 0.09758927654652616, "S_sym_bias_top4k_ci": [ 0.09211262102479688, 0.1037596535755468 ], "S_sym_aff_top4k": 0.2875739269883355, "S_sym_aff_top4k_ci": [ 0.28072887613213426, 0.2951696185610573 ], "valid": true, "flag_bias": false, "flag_aff_above_floor": false }, { "group": "g3_qwen7b", "base": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-7B", "new": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-Coder-7B", "revisions": [ "d149729398750b98c0af14eb82c78cfe92750796", "0396a76181e127dfc13e5c5ec48a8cee09938b02" ], "T_new": 1.0184048414230347, "T_old": 1.0129996538162231, "T_new_top4k": 1.0184048414230347, "T_old_top4k": 1.0129996538162231, "jensen_ok": true, "Delta": 0.13518436628108255, "Delta_ci": [ 0.12875118924505652, 0.14150004111756231 ], "S_sym_aff": 0.0032806147048616285, "S_sym_aff_ci": [ 0.0028463265950080447, 0.0037003799505454125 ], "S_card_aff": 0.004576865213419501, "S_card_aff_ci": [ 0.003948990914721846, 0.005196444578637342 ], "S_sym_cf_beta100000": 0.005876917717800967, "S_sym_cf_beta100000_ci": [ 0.00415263119472592, 0.007754116676181255 ], "S_sym_bias": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_bias_top4k": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_top4k_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_aff_top4k": 0.0032806147048616285, "S_sym_aff_top4k_ci": [ 0.0028463265950080447, 0.0037003799505454125 ], "valid": true, "flag_bias": false, "flag_aff_above_floor": false }, { "group": "g3_qwen7b", "base": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-7B", "new": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-Math-7B", "revisions": [ "d149729398750b98c0af14eb82c78cfe92750796", "b101308fe89651ea5ce025f25317fea6fc07e96e" ], "T_new": 1.0416233539581299, "T_old": 1.0129996538162231, "T_new_top4k": 1.0562371015548706, "T_old_top4k": 1.0129996538162231, "jensen_ok": true, "Delta": 0.4845618239835763, "Delta_ci": [ 0.4711493116552698, 0.4980697847379199 ], "S_sym_aff": 0.00751285714403116, "S_sym_aff_ci": [ 0.007020436756186274, 0.008012353537394138 ], "S_card_aff": 0.007874488611612197, "S_card_aff_ci": [ 0.007329715657047295, 0.00842256648164824 ], "S_sym_cf_beta100000": 0.03018808182015731, "S_sym_cf_beta100000_ci": [ 0.02778784970855601, 0.03243741675249257 ], "S_sym_bias": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_bias_top4k": 0.0036703694164087475, "S_sym_bias_top4k_ci": [ 0.0032333526234939484, 0.004120727935387605 ], "S_sym_aff_top4k": 0.013030907760352761, "S_sym_aff_top4k_ci": [ 0.012126729113317147, 0.013989470524102163 ], "valid": true, "flag_bias": false, "flag_aff_above_floor": false }, { "group": "g4_qwen1p5b", "base": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-1.5B", "new": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-1.5B-Instruct", "revisions": [ "8faed761d45a263340a0528343f099c05c9a4323", "989aa7980e4cf806f80c7fef2b1adb7bc71aa306" ], "T_new": 1.0163367986679077, "T_old": 1.0096734762191772, "T_new_top4k": 1.0163367986679077, "T_old_top4k": 1.0096734762191772, "jensen_ok": true, "Delta": 0.02780842983650844, "Delta_ci": [ 0.027017735227700755, 0.028680108009362125 ], "S_sym_aff": 0.017661284614274964, "S_sym_aff_ci": [ 0.01612980782260861, 0.019229416820756753 ], "S_card_aff": 0.022201697990002052, "S_card_aff_ci": [ 0.019348300271113412, 0.025043502170322304 ], "S_sym_cf_beta100000": 0.08568553552609315, "S_sym_cf_beta100000_ci": [ 0.07952909206018151, 0.0920068233649752 ], "S_sym_bias": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_bias_top4k": 0.04177955391516097, "S_sym_bias_top4k_ci": [ 0.034574185657162256, 0.049644485523304686 ], "S_sym_aff_top4k": 0.05807389380372263, "S_sym_aff_top4k_ci": [ 0.050771675984914014, 0.06617693803846486 ], "valid": true, "flag_bias": false, "flag_aff_above_floor": false }, { "group": "g4_qwen1p5b", "base": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-1.5B", "new": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-Coder-1.5B", "revisions": [ "8faed761d45a263340a0528343f099c05c9a4323", "df3ce67c0e24480f20468b6ef2894622d69eb73b" ], "T_new": 1.0043145418167114, "T_old": 1.0096734762191772, "T_new_top4k": 1.0043145418167114, "T_old_top4k": 1.0096734762191772, "jensen_ok": true, "Delta": 0.12747431695535472, "Delta_ci": [ 0.12190996485038703, 0.13274458243016166 ], "S_sym_aff": -0.0011037657827221992, "S_sym_aff_ci": [ -0.0013221613828451272, -0.0008904386298371538 ], "S_card_aff": -0.00011327789619464126, "S_card_aff_ci": [ -0.00026605499280855336, 3.9878713440298274e-05 ], "S_sym_cf_beta100000": 0.00756706160399756, "S_sym_cf_beta100000_ci": [ 0.0056848570820573095, 0.009441023031267594 ], "S_sym_bias": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_bias_top4k": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_top4k_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_aff_top4k": -0.0011037657827221992, "S_sym_aff_top4k_ci": [ -0.0013221613828451272, -0.0008904386298371538 ], "valid": true, "flag_bias": false, "flag_aff_above_floor": false }, { "group": "g4_qwen1p5b", "base": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-1.5B", "new": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-Math-1.5B", "revisions": [ "8faed761d45a263340a0528343f099c05c9a4323", "4a83ca6e4526a4f2da3aa259ec36c259f66b2ab2" ], "T_new": 1.0382031202316284, "T_old": 1.0096734762191772, "T_new_top4k": 1.0382031202316284, "T_old_top4k": 1.0096734762191772, "jensen_ok": true, "Delta": 0.7958462717884367, "Delta_ci": [ 0.7774869308038029, 0.8142367296311875 ], "S_sym_aff": 0.004409794815457002, "S_sym_aff_ci": [ 0.003997602559951302, 0.004833866718259258 ], "S_card_aff": 0.004568445765098251, "S_card_aff_ci": [ 0.00414480214216047, 0.00500485812098149 ], "S_sym_cf_beta100000": 0.029044724414267642, "S_sym_cf_beta100000_ci": [ 0.027216881296904007, 0.03072405521498595 ], "S_sym_bias": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_bias_top4k": 0.008824946292003921, "S_sym_bias_top4k_ci": [ 0.008225717886774477, 0.009480685006718325 ], "S_sym_aff_top4k": 0.011829558965027909, "S_sym_aff_top4k_ci": [ 0.011176161614834673, 0.012519111239490583 ], "valid": true, "flag_bias": false, "flag_aff_above_floor": false }, { "group": "g5_smollm2", "base": "HuggingFaceTB/SmolLM2-1.7B", "new": "HuggingFaceTB/SmolLM2-1.7B-Instruct", "revisions": [ "effd688a12921b4cc83e3312b6feb579f70f9c71", "31b70e2e869a7173562077fd711b654946d38674" ], "T_new": 1.0326929092407227, "T_old": 1.0043145418167114, "T_new_top4k": 1.0450549125671387, "T_old_top4k": 1.0043145418167114, "jensen_ok": true, "Delta": 0.11356385989909024, "Delta_ci": [ 0.1106581118392278, 0.11644094385531048 ], "S_sym_aff": 0.020734834431685223, "S_sym_aff_ci": [ 0.01952290650329079, 0.02194663172145263 ], "S_card_aff": 0.020905675721500174, "S_card_aff_ci": [ 0.019546630649798998, 0.022239581251853678 ], "S_sym_cf_beta100000": 0.017143908503973848, "S_sym_cf_beta100000_ci": [ 0.014891413086598321, 0.019406577378308545 ], "S_sym_bias": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_bias_top4k": 0.006722423963456237, "S_sym_bias_top4k_ci": [ 0.00417856865300138, 0.009260132797410494 ], "S_sym_aff_top4k": 0.036176418581613023, "S_sym_aff_top4k_ci": [ 0.033065217082333884, 0.039277568184046666 ], "valid": true, "flag_bias": false, "flag_aff_above_floor": false }, { "group": "g6_olmo1b_anneal", "base": "allenai/OLMo-2-0425-1B", "new": "allenai/OLMo-2-0425-1B", "revisions": [ "9d3e43659f00c17e6da23cf32333afd1fc39fa1a", "a1847dff35000b4271fa70afc5db10fd29fedbdf" ], "T_new": 1.0043145418167114, "T_old": 0.995703935623169, "T_new_top4k": 1.0043145418167114, "T_old_top4k": 0.995703935623169, "jensen_ok": true, "Delta": 0.012435701150238287, "Delta_ci": [ 0.008149991561034886, 0.016684465118597572 ], "S_sym_aff": -0.004914376709013846, "S_sym_aff_ci": [ -0.009511867647414674, -0.001741233721410535 ], "S_card_aff": -0.00012262597253079042, "S_card_aff_ci": [ -0.001902857032283791, 0.0014126940395386865 ], "S_sym_cf_beta100000": -0.02625785634859734, "S_sym_cf_beta100000_ci": [ -0.04894989347512945, -0.0064702664921274956 ], "S_sym_bias": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_bias_top4k": 0.0, "S_sym_bias_top4k_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "S_sym_aff_top4k": -0.004914376709013846, "S_sym_aff_top4k_ci": [ -0.009511867647414674, -0.001741233721410535 ], "valid": true, "flag_bias": false, "flag_aff_above_floor": false } ]