#!/usr/bin/env python3 """Case 1 physical runs and nominal simulations: per-run MAE (Tables II-III) and per-run start metadata. Input: the folder TestingData of https://github.com/uwsbel/sbel-reproducibility/tree/master/2024/PathFollowingSim2real (sub-folders rd_path = Path 1, syn_path = Path 2, lot17 = Path 3; five physical runs per policy and path, and one nominal simulation log sim_.csv per policy and path) and the reference waypoints of the Docker image (path_iros_1.csv, path_iros_2.csv, lot17_sinsquare.csv; copied to data/waypoints/). Error definition (each logged sample): nearest reference waypoint (zero lookahead); lateral error = body-frame lateral component of the displacement to that waypoint; heading error = wrapped difference between waypoint heading and vehicle heading. Run MAE = mean of the absolute errors over all logged samples (no trimming or filtering). Pose columns: nine-column logs (0, 1, 2); fourteen-column logs (Path 3 NN-MPC and NN-HD physical runs) (2, 3, 10). The derived start quantities (initial pose, initial errors, motion onset, stale-pose fraction, pose outliers, stationary segments) are proxies computed from the logged samples; the logs carry no timestamps. Outputs (OUT_DIR): physical_runs.csv 60 physical runs (rounded as in the released table) nominal_sim_runs.csv 12 nominal simulation runs (full precision) tables_II_III.json per path and policy: mean and sample SD (ddof = 1) of the five run MAEs, nominal sim MAE tables_II_III.tex the rows of Tables II (lateral, m) and III (heading, rad) physical_pair_bootstrap.json per path and metric: mean MAE difference of each controller pair and its 95 % run bootstrap interval (20000 replicates, seed 20261019) physical_summary.json start spread of the physical runs (max start distance, max |initial lateral error|) Usage: python physical_runs.py TESTING_DATA_DIR WAYPOINTS_DIR OUT_DIR """ import csv import glob import hashlib import itertools import json import math import os import sys import numpy as np PATHS = {'rd_path': 'path_iros_1', 'syn_path': 'path_iros_2', 'lot17': 'lot17_sinsquare'} PATH_KEY = {'rd_path': 'P1', 'syn_path': 'P2', 'lot17': 'P3'} POLICY = {'mpc': 'MPC', 'nn_mpc': 'NN-MPC', 'pid': 'PID', 'nn_mc': 'NN-HD', 'mpc_bb': 'NN-MPC', 'mc_bb': 'NN-HD'} CTRL_ORDER = ['MPC', 'NN-MPC', 'PID', 'NN-HD'] N_BOOT, BOOT_SEED = 20000, 20261019 def sha(p): return hashlib.sha256(open(p, 'rb').read()).hexdigest() def wrap(a): return np.arctan2(np.sin(a), np.cos(a)) def errors(x, y, th, ref, lookahead=0.0): ax, ay = x + np.cos(th) * lookahead, y + np.sin(th) * lookahead idx = ((ax[:, None] - ref[None, :, 0]) ** 2 + (ay[:, None] - ref[None, :, 1]) ** 2).argmin(1) dx, dy = ref[idx, 0] - x, ref[idx, 1] - y return -np.sin(th) * dx + np.cos(th) * dy, wrap(ref[idx, 2] - th), idx def runs_of(mask): out, start = [], None for i, m in enumerate(mask): if m and start is None: start = i if not m and start is not None: out.append((start, i - 1)); start = None if start is not None: out.append((start, len(mask) - 1)) return out def analyse(f, ref, data): a = np.loadtxt(f, delimiter=',') cols = (0, 1, 2) if a.shape[1] == 9 else (2, 3, 10) x, y, th = a[:, cols[0]], a[:, cols[1]], a[:, cols[2]] lat, head, idx = errors(x, y, th, ref) step = np.r_[0.0, np.hypot(np.diff(x), np.diff(y))] moving = np.where(step > 0.01)[0] onset = int(moving[0]) if len(moving) else None # isolated outliers: sample far from both neighbours while neighbours are close to each other out_rows = [] for t in range(1, len(a) - 1): d_prev = np.hypot(x[t] - x[t - 1], y[t] - y[t - 1]); d_next = np.hypot(x[t + 1] - x[t], y[t + 1] - y[t]) d_skip = np.hypot(x[t + 1] - x[t - 1], y[t + 1] - y[t - 1]) if d_prev > 0.5 and d_next > 0.5 and d_skip < 0.5: out_rows.append(t) big_steps = [int(t) for t in np.where(step > 0.5)[0] if t not in out_rows and t - 1 not in out_rows] stationary = [(s, e) for s, e in runs_of(step < 0.01) if onset is not None and s > onset and e - s + 1 >= 20 and e < len(a) - 1] n_ref = len(ref) return dict( file=os.path.relpath(f, data), sha256=sha(f), columns=a.shape[1], rows=len(a), initial_pose=[float(x[0]), float(y[0]), float(th[0])], initial_zero_lookahead_lateral_m=float(lat[0]), initial_heading_error_rad=float(head[0]), initial_nearest_waypoint=int(idx[0]), motion_onset_row=onset, stale_pose_fraction=float(np.mean(step[1:] < 1e-9)), max_progress_waypoint_fraction=float(idx.max() / (n_ref - 1)), isolated_pose_outlier_rows=out_rows, other_pose_steps_gt_0p5m_rows=big_steps, stationary_segments_after_onset_ge_2s=[[int(s), int(e)] for s, e in stationary], max_abs_lateral_m=float(np.abs(lat).max()), mae=np.abs(np.column_stack((lat, head))).mean(axis=0).tolist()) def main(): data, wp, out = sys.argv[1:4] os.makedirs(out, exist_ok=True) runs = [] for folder, stem in PATHS.items(): ref = np.loadtxt(os.path.join(wp, stem + '.csv'), delimiter=',') for f in sorted(glob.glob(os.path.join(data, folder, '*.csv'))): name = os.path.basename(f)[:-4] pol = name[4:] if name.startswith('sim_') else name.rsplit('_', 1)[0] r = analyse(f, ref, data) r.update(path=folder, policy=POLICY[pol], kind='nominal_sim' if name.startswith('sim_') else 'physical') runs.append(r) phys = [r for r in runs if r['kind'] == 'physical'] assert len(phys) == 60 rows = [] for r in sorted(phys, key=lambda r: (PATH_KEY[r['path']], CTRL_ORDER.index(r['policy']), r['file'])): run_idx = int(os.path.splitext(os.path.basename(r['file']))[0].split('_')[-1]) rows.append({ 'path': PATH_KEY[r['path']], 'controller': r['policy'], 'run': run_idx, 'log_file': 'TestingData/' + r['file'], 'log_sha256': r['sha256'], 'log_columns': r['columns'], 'rows': r['rows'], 'start_distance_from_local_origin_m': round(math.hypot(*r['initial_pose'][:2]), 4), 'start_yaw_local_frame_rad': round(r['initial_pose'][2], 4), 'initial_lateral_error_m': round(r['initial_zero_lookahead_lateral_m'], 4), 'initial_heading_error_rad': round(r['initial_heading_error_rad'], 4), 'initial_nearest_waypoint': r['initial_nearest_waypoint'], 'motion_onset_row': r['motion_onset_row'], 'max_progress_waypoint_fraction': round(r['max_progress_waypoint_fraction'], 4), 'stale_pose_fraction': round(r['stale_pose_fraction'], 4), 'pose_steps_gt_0p5m': len(r['other_pose_steps_gt_0p5m_rows']), 'isolated_pose_outliers': len(r['isolated_pose_outlier_rows']), 'stationary_segments_ge_2s_after_onset': len(r['stationary_segments_after_onset_ge_2s']), 'run_mae_lateral_m': round(r['mae'][0], 5), 'run_mae_heading_rad': round(r['mae'][1], 5), 'max_abs_lateral_error_m': round(r['max_abs_lateral_m'], 3), }) with open(os.path.join(out, 'physical_runs.csv'), 'w', newline='') as f: w = csv.DictWriter(f, fieldnames=list(rows[0].keys())) w.writeheader() w.writerows(rows) nom = sorted([r for r in runs if r['kind'] == 'nominal_sim'], key=lambda r: (PATH_KEY[r['path']], CTRL_ORDER.index(r['policy']))) assert len(nom) == 12 with open(os.path.join(out, 'nominal_sim_runs.csv'), 'w', newline='') as f: w = csv.writer(f) w.writerow(['path', 'controller', 'log_file', 'log_sha256', 'log_columns', 'rows', 'run_mae_lateral_m', 'run_mae_heading_rad']) for r in nom: w.writerow([PATH_KEY[r['path']], r['policy'], 'TestingData/' + r['file'], r['sha256'], r['columns'], r['rows'], repr(r['mae'][0]), repr(r['mae'][1])]) # Tables II-III: mean and sample SD (ddof = 1) of the five run MAEs (full precision); one nominal simulation run tab = {} for folder in PATHS: p = PATH_KEY[folder] for c in CTRL_ORDER: v = np.array([r['mae'] for r in phys if r['path'] == folder and r['policy'] == c]) s = next(r for r in nom if r['path'] == folder and r['policy'] == c) tab[f'{p}|{c}'] = {'n_runs': len(v), 'real_mean': v.mean(axis=0).tolist(), 'real_sd': v.std(axis=0, ddof=1).tolist(), 'nominal_sim': s['mae']} json.dump({'metrics': ['lateral_m', 'heading_rad'], 'cells': tab}, open(os.path.join(out, 'tables_II_III.json'), 'w'), indent=1) lines = [] for mi, (name, unit) in enumerate((('Table II: lateral error', 'm'), ('Table III: heading error', 'rad'))): lines += [f'% {name} ({unit}); columns Path 1, Path 2, Path 3', r'Policy & Path 1 & Path 2 & Path 3 \\'] for c in CTRL_ORDER: cells = [tab[f'{p}|{c}'] for p in ('P1', 'P2', 'P3')] lines.append(f'{c}-Sim & ' + ' & '.join(f"${x['nominal_sim'][mi]:.3f}$" for x in cells) + r' \\') lines.append(f'{c}-Real & ' + ' & '.join(f"${x['real_mean'][mi]:.3f}\\pm{x['real_sd'][mi]:.3f}$" for x in cells) + r' \\') lines.append('') open(os.path.join(out, 'tables_II_III.tex'), 'w').write('\n'.join(lines)) # Run bootstrap of the mean-MAE difference of each controller pair: resample the five runs of each controller # independently (with replacement), 20000 replicates, seed 20261019; one draw array per path (Paths 1, 2, 3 in # this order), shared by both metrics. rng = np.random.default_rng(BOOT_SEED) pairs = {} for folder in PATHS: p = PATH_KEY[folder] run_mae = np.array([[r['mae'] for r in phys if r['path'] == folder and r['policy'] == c] for c in CTRL_ORDER]) draws = rng.integers(0, 5, size=(4, N_BOOT, 5)) for mi, m in enumerate(('lateral', 'heading')): v = run_mae[:, :, mi] boot = np.stack([v[k][draws[k]].mean(axis=1) for k in range(4)], axis=1) point = v.mean(axis=1) pairs[f'{p}_{m}'] = [{'pair': f'{CTRL_ORDER[a]} - {CTRL_ORDER[b]}', 'mean_difference': float(point[a] - point[b]), 'bootstrap_95': np.quantile(boot[:, a] - boot[:, b], [.025, .975]).tolist()} for a, b in itertools.combinations(range(4), 2)] json.dump({'replicates': N_BOOT, 'seed': BOOT_SEED, 'pairs': pairs}, open(os.path.join(out, 'physical_pair_bootstrap.json'), 'w'), indent=1) summ = {'n_physical_runs': len(phys), 'n_nominal_sim_runs': len(nom), 'max_start_distance_from_local_origin_m': round(max(math.hypot(*r['initial_pose'][:2]) for r in phys), 4), 'max_abs_initial_lateral_error_m': round(max(abs(r['initial_zero_lookahead_lateral_m']) for r in phys), 4)} json.dump(summ, open(os.path.join(out, 'physical_summary.json'), 'w'), indent=1) print(json.dumps(summ)) print('\n'.join(lines)) if __name__ == '__main__': main()