{ "label": "exploratory", "sim2sim": true, "goal_set": "A", "pool": "explore", "policies": [ "rel1", "rel2", "rel3", "rel4", "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1002", "nonoise_s1003", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1001", "release_s1002", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1003", "robust_s1004" ], "goals": 100, "horizon_s": 40.0, "bootstrap": { "replicates": 2000, "seed": 20261104, "unit": "goal, stratified by goal range, paired across methods" }, "chrono": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 11.99, "rel2": 10.18, "rel3": 9.035, "rel4": 8.45, "nonoise_s1001": 6.64, "nonoise_s1002": 11.185, "nonoise_s1003": 10.765, "nonoise_s1004": 7.38, "release_s1001": 9.655, "release_s1002": 6.38, "release_s1003": 9.675, "release_s1004": 10.075, "robust_s1001": 6.99, "robust_s1002": 5.21, "robust_s1003": 6.08, "robust_s1004": 6.31 }, "order": [ "robust_s1002", "robust_s1003", "robust_s1004", "release_s1002", "nonoise_s1001", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "rel4", "rel3", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "rel2", "nonoise_s1003", "nonoise_s1002", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.48, "rel2": 0.84, "rel3": 0.94, "rel4": 0.96, "nonoise_s1001": 0.46, "nonoise_s1002": 0.28, "nonoise_s1003": 0.3, "nonoise_s1004": 0.46, "release_s1001": 0.46, "release_s1002": 0.46, "release_s1003": 0.34, "release_s1004": 0.32, "robust_s1001": 0.46, "robust_s1002": 0.46, "robust_s1003": 0.5, "robust_s1004": 0.46 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.58, "rel2": 0.96, "rel3": 0.96, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 0.98, "nonoise_s1002": 0.34, "nonoise_s1003": 0.52, "nonoise_s1004": 0.92, "release_s1001": 0.42, "release_s1002": 0.98, "release_s1003": 0.58, "release_s1004": 0.58, "robust_s1001": 0.94, "robust_s1002": 0.98, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 0.98 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.53, "rel2": 0.9, "rel3": 0.95, "rel4": 0.98, "nonoise_s1001": 0.72, "nonoise_s1002": 0.31, "nonoise_s1003": 0.41, "nonoise_s1004": 0.69, "release_s1001": 0.44, "release_s1002": 0.72, "release_s1003": 0.46, "release_s1004": 0.45, "robust_s1001": 0.7, "robust_s1002": 0.72, "robust_s1003": 0.75, "robust_s1004": 0.72 } }, "common_success_units": 7, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 23.5, "rel2": 15.928571428571429, "rel3": 12.557142857142859, "rel4": 12.614285714285712, "nonoise_s1001": 7.571428571428571, "nonoise_s1002": 7.428571428571429, "nonoise_s1003": 8.985714285714286, "nonoise_s1004": 7.5857142857142845, "release_s1001": 7.242857142857145, "release_s1002": 7.428571428571429, "release_s1003": 9.014285714285714, "release_s1004": 9.928571428571429, "robust_s1001": 7.557142857142858, "robust_s1002": 7.371428571428572, "robust_s1003": 7.614285714285715, "robust_s1004": 7.428571428571429 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.12, "ci95": [ 0.07, 0.17 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.065, "ci95": [ 0.03, 0.105 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.05, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.09 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.205, "ci95": [ 0.145, 0.265 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.515, "ci95": [ 0.435, 0.595 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.475, "ci95": [ 0.385, 0.5551249999999993 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.22, "ci95": [ 0.16, 0.285 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.405, "ci95": [ 0.33, 0.485 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.205, "ci95": [ 0.145, 0.265 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.45, "ci95": [ 0.365, 0.535 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5, "ci95": [ 0.41, 0.59 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.215, "ci95": [ 0.155, 0.28 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.205, "ci95": [ 0.145, 0.265 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.175, "ci95": [ 0.12, 0.23 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.205, "ci95": [ 0.145, 0.265 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.14, "ci95": [ 0.09, 0.19 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.13, "ci95": [ 0.085, 0.185 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.25, "ci95": [ 0.18, 0.32 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.655, "ci95": [ 0.565, 0.745 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.59, "ci95": [ 0.494875, 0.685 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.28, "ci95": [ 0.205, 0.355 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.54, "ci95": [ 0.45, 0.6301249999999993 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.25, "ci95": [ 0.18, 0.32 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.53, "ci95": [ 0.435, 0.625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.575, "ci95": [ 0.48, 0.6651249999999993 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.27, "ci95": [ 0.195, 0.345 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.25, "ci95": [ 0.18, 0.32 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.23, "ci95": [ 0.16, 0.3 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.25, "ci95": [ 0.18, 0.32 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.265, "ci95": [ 0.21, 0.32 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.27, "ci95": [ 0.195, 0.34 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.67, "ci95": [ 0.58, 0.76 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.61, "ci95": [ 0.514875, 0.7 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.295, "ci95": [ 0.22, 0.37 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.55, "ci95": [ 0.455, 0.6451249999999993 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.27, "ci95": [ 0.195, 0.34 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.56, "ci95": [ 0.465, 0.655 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6, "ci95": [ 0.5, 0.6901249999999992 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.29, "ci95": [ 0.215, 0.365 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.27, "ci95": [ 0.195, 0.34 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.25, "ci95": [ 0.175, 0.325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.27, "ci95": [ 0.195, 0.34 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.275, "ci95": [ 0.2, 0.35 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.685, "ci95": [ 0.595, 0.775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.62, "ci95": [ 0.52, 0.71 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.315, "ci95": [ 0.235, 0.395 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.565, "ci95": [ 0.47, 0.66 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.275, "ci95": [ 0.2, 0.35 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.56, "ci95": [ 0.46, 0.655 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6, "ci95": [ 0.504875, 0.69 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.295, "ci95": [ 0.21987500000000001, 0.375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.275, "ci95": [ 0.2, 0.35 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.255, "ci95": [ 0.18, 0.32512499999999933 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.275, "ci95": [ 0.2, 0.35 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.77, "ci95": [ 0.72, 0.82 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.77, "ci95": [ 0.7198749999999999, 0.82 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.6, "ci95": [ 0.555, 0.645 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.675, "ci95": [ 0.62, 0.73 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.455, "ci95": [ 0.415, 0.5 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.64, "ci95": [ 0.57, 0.705 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.68, "ci95": [ 0.615, 0.745 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.555, "ci95": [ 0.514875, 0.595 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.325, "ci95": [ 0.29, 0.36 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.435, "ci95": [ 0.375, 0.5 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.455, "ci95": [ 0.405, 0.51 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.475, "ci95": [ 0.42, 0.53 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.25, "ci95": [ 0.2, 0.305 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.4, "ci95": [ 0.349875, 0.455 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.22, "ci95": [ 0.174875, 0.27 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.43, "ci95": [ 0.37, 0.495 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.455, "ci95": [ 0.39, 0.515 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.235, "ci95": [ 0.185, 0.29 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.21, "ci95": [ 0.165, 0.255 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.21, "ci95": [ 0.16, 0.265 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.225, "ci95": [ 0.175, 0.275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.275, "ci95": [ 0.225, 0.325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.435, "ci95": [ 0.375, 0.5 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.215, "ci95": [ 0.17, 0.26 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.435, "ci95": [ 0.37, 0.495 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5, "ci95": [ 0.43, 0.56 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.26, "ci95": [ 0.21, 0.315 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.2, "ci95": [ 0.16, 0.24 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.235, "ci95": [ 0.179875, 0.295 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.22, "ci95": [ 0.175, 0.27 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.645, "ci95": [ 0.5898749999999999, 0.705 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.385, "ci95": [ 0.34, 0.43 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.605, "ci95": [ 0.53, 0.68 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.635, "ci95": [ 0.5648749999999999, 0.7 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.46, "ci95": [ 0.415, 0.5 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.295, "ci95": [ 0.26, 0.335 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.41, "ci95": [ 0.355, 0.47 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.42, "ci95": [ 0.37, 0.47 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.315, "ci95": [ 0.255, 0.375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.49, "ci95": [ 0.42, 0.56 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.515, "ci95": [ 0.445, 0.585 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.325, "ci95": [ 0.27, 0.38 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.28, "ci95": [ 0.235, 0.325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.31, "ci95": [ 0.255, 0.37 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.325, "ci95": [ 0.26, 0.385 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.685, "ci95": [ 0.63, 0.74 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.685, "ci95": [ 0.625, 0.745 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.575, "ci95": [ 0.53, 0.62 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.33, "ci95": [ 0.295, 0.365 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.46, "ci95": [ 0.405, 0.52 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.475, "ci95": [ 0.429875, 0.525 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.525, "ci95": [ 0.465, 0.59 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.37, "ci95": [ 0.3, 0.44 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.24, "ci95": [ 0.195, 0.29 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.29, "ci95": [ 0.23, 0.35 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.285, "ci95": [ 0.235, 0.345 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.34, "ci95": [ 0.275, 0.41 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.24, "ci95": [ 0.195, 0.285 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.335, "ci95": [ 0.27, 0.405 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.28, "ci95": [ 0.23, 0.335 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.315, "ci95": [ 0.28, 0.35 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.44, "ci95": [ 0.38, 0.5 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.445, "ci95": [ 0.39, 0.5 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.595, "ci95": [ 0.535, 0.655 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.63, "ci95": [ 0.59, 0.67 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.55, "ci95": [ 0.49, 0.61 ], "resolved": false } ], "resolved_pairs": 91, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 11.339875, 12.645 ], "rel2": [ 9.429875, 10.92 ], "rel3": [ 8.264875, 9.795124999999999 ], "rel4": [ 7.65, 9.26 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 6.145, 7.13 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 10.56975, 11.800499999999998 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 10.175, 11.33 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 6.854875000000001, 7.92 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.89, 10.41 ], "release_s1002": [ 5.899875000000001, 6.855 ], "release_s1003": [ 8.889875, 10.475 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.244874999999999, 10.885 ], "robust_s1001": [ 6.459875, 7.525 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.729875000000001, 5.695 ], "robust_s1003": [ 5.465, 6.675 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.789875, 6.825 ] } }, "conditions": { "act_0.1": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 15.134999999999996, "rel2": 13.7445, "rel3": 12.955499999999999, "rel4": 12.563750000000002, "nonoise_s1001": 3.7827500000000005, "nonoise_s1002": 13.738750000000005, "nonoise_s1003": 7.724999999999999, "nonoise_s1004": 3.8199999999999994, "release_s1001": 9.226499999999994, "release_s1002": 3.984249999999999, "release_s1003": 9.673250000000001, "release_s1004": 9.739500000000001, "robust_s1001": 4.395250000000002, "robust_s1002": 4.258999999999999, "robust_s1003": 6.022, "robust_s1004": 5.234999999999998 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "rel4", "rel3", "nonoise_s1002", "rel2", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.895, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.9475, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1895, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 5.746701854514573, "rel2": 5.261794198848956, "rel3": 5.140844337418086, "rel4": 5.096042220888163, "nonoise_s1001": 4.641530354230574, "nonoise_s1002": 5.228126651064387, "nonoise_s1003": 4.762163594656066, "nonoise_s1004": 4.642480222656733, "release_s1001": 4.8109762556634665, "release_s1002": 4.647704495981061, "release_s1003": 4.832717670425576, "release_s1004": 4.872506605289228, "robust_s1001": 4.66131927470104, "robust_s1002": 4.65335093437839, "robust_s1003": 4.723693943652754, "robust_s1004": 4.682902382294547 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.09824999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.069, 0.13049999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.087, "ci95": [ 0.05948750000000001, 0.11725000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.08424999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.056743749999999996, 0.11400000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.349, "ci95": [ 0.28449375, 0.40876874999999985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.01275, "ci95": [ 0.006, 0.020749999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.01925, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.030249999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.052250000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.0315, 0.07650624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.153, "ci95": [ 0.10398750000000002, 0.20500000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.00925, "ci95": [ 0.0030000000000000005, 0.017249999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.22675, "ci95": [ 0.18800000000000006, 0.26600000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.21900000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.18125, 0.2577499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.45324999999999993, "ci95": [ 0.40649374999999993, 0.49675624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.036000000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.023999999999999994, 0.04924999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0475, "ci95": [ 0.0325, 0.064 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.111, "ci95": [ 0.08100000000000002, 0.14225000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.23324999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.17599374999999998, 0.29350624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.02675, "ci95": [ 0.012249999999999999, 0.04374999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.33699999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.30249375000000006, 0.37299999999999983 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.51675, "ci95": [ 0.47825, 0.55675 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.044, "ci95": [ 0.029993749999999993, 0.058756249999999975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.056749999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.04025, 0.07400624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.12625, "ci95": [ 0.09424375000000004, 0.15899999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.24600000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.18750000000000008, 0.30451249999999985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.03125, "ci95": [ 0.014500000000000004, 0.0495 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.54175, "ci95": [ 0.5002375000000001, 0.5847562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.04724999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.03275, 0.06324999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.06225000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.04525000000000001, 0.08025624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.13575, "ci95": [ 0.10325000000000005, 0.16850624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.251, "ci95": [ 0.19149999999999998, 0.3107624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.03825, "ci95": [ 0.02025, 0.059 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8752500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8597499999999998, 0.8905 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5045000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.4997499999999999, 0.5084999999999996 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9632499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.9522499999999999, 0.9735000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.52, "ci95": [ 0.5084999999999997, 0.5362499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.941, "ci95": [ 0.9244999999999999, 0.9567562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.88575, "ci95": [ 0.8654999999999999, 0.9052562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5727499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5569999999999998, 0.5904999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5554999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5437499999999996, 0.5699999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7055000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6702499999999998, 0.7402562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.69375, "ci95": [ 0.6694937500000002, 0.7177562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0034999999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.00125, 0.00625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.03825, "ci95": [ 0.01675, 0.06649999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.003, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.00425, 0.016999999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.08400000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.009, "ci95": [ 0.00225, 0.017756249999999967 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0022500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.006750000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.12675, "ci95": [ 0.11125000000000006, 0.14200000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.67625, "ci95": [ 0.65424375, 0.7010000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.144, "ci95": [ 0.12300000000000004, 0.16899999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7827500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7644937499999992, 0.8032562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.72125, "ci95": [ 0.6912437500000002, 0.7517562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.1595, "ci95": [ 0.139, 0.18324999999999989 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.15849999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.13950000000000004, 0.18025625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.342, "ci95": [ 0.29224374999999986, 0.39574999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.18275000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.1649937499999999, 0.20374999999999982 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9627500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.95149375, 0.9732562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.5145000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5029999999999999, 0.5302562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.94, "ci95": [ 0.9232437499999999, 0.95625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.885, "ci95": [ 0.8644999999999999, 0.9047499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.56825, "ci95": [ 0.5534937499999993, 0.5847562499999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5504999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.53925, 0.56450625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7014999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6662375, 0.7369999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.68875, "ci95": [ 0.6654999999999999, 0.7125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.04075, "ci95": [ 0.029749999999999995, 0.05299999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6065, "ci95": [ 0.5820000000000001, 0.6299999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.581, "ci95": [ 0.5327374999999999, 0.629 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.06125, "ci95": [ 0.041493749999999996, 0.08700000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.05325, "ci95": [ 0.0395, 0.06774999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.19125, "ci95": [ 0.14873750000000002, 0.23550625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.06574999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.052743749999999985, 0.07950000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9279999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.9067500000000002, 0.9470062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8647499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.83375, 0.8915 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5529999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5307499999999997, 0.5739999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5325, "ci95": [ 0.5174937499999996, 0.5459999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6859999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6512437499999999, 0.72225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.67375, "ci95": [ 0.6474937499999999, 0.69875 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5515000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.49673124999999996, 0.6027625000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.08324999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.06, 0.11075624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.07999999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.06024375, 0.10025625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.15649999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.12124374999999998, 0.19575624999999988 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.08899999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.06949375, 0.10924999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.1425, "ci95": [ 0.11950000000000002, 0.16899999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.1475, "ci95": [ 0.12200000000000005, 0.17575000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.22899999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.18274375000000004, 0.27825625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.15900000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.13350000000000004, 0.18600000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.48200000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.46175000000000005, 0.5015000000000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6525, "ci95": [ 0.6097500000000003, 0.6952625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6207499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5965000000000003, 0.6437562499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.66125, "ci95": [ 0.6210000000000001, 0.7017562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6405, "ci95": [ 0.6167500000000001, 0.66475625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.418, "ci95": [ 0.36598749999999997, 0.4680187499999997 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 116, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 14.935243750000005, 15.324499999999986 ], "rel2": [ 13.562493750000002, 13.926018750000003 ], "rel3": [ 12.8265, 13.083018749999994 ], "rel4": [ 12.410475, 12.716518750000002 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.693493749999998, 3.8712687500000014 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 13.552487500000002, 13.915043750000004 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.559712499999999, 7.870762499999998 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.7319999999999993, 3.907574999999998 ], "release_s1001": [ 9.082993749999996, 9.3643 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.850731249999998, 4.145512499999997 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.478175000000004, 9.865262499999998 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.332750000000004, 10.143250000000002 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.23621875, 4.5975375 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.136499999999999, 4.39650625 ], "robust_s1003": [ 5.628456250000002, 6.429525000000001 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.097231249999999, 5.388775 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5333333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.45, 0.6166666666666667 ], "spearman": 0.7617647058823529, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6911764705882353, 0.8205882352941176 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.0, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.0272711490245533, 0.04999999999999999 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.323 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.2761530448893886, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.059076463079880556, 0.5823251360731083 ], "spearman": 0.3370126004362615, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.09597311910318672, 0.7799854944594699 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.007245481864178505, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.031929056798151875, 0.02489668867819256 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.4415 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.55, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5166666666666667, 0.6833333333333333 ], "spearman": 0.788235294117647, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.75, 0.8588235294117647 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.022798732483894524, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.04407757870811557, 0.05641311913459522 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.228 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 92, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 2, "discordant_method_correct": 1, "discordant_base_correct": 1 } }, "act_0.2": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 15.315750000000003, "rel2": 13.874000000000006, "rel3": 12.968250000000001, "rel4": 12.551749999999993, "nonoise_s1001": 3.8514999999999997, "nonoise_s1002": 13.646249999999998, "nonoise_s1003": 8.049999999999999, "nonoise_s1004": 3.855, "release_s1001": 8.987499999999999, "release_s1002": 4.014749999999999, "release_s1003": 9.539999999999997, "release_s1004": 9.79025, "robust_s1001": 4.426500000000002, "robust_s1002": 4.302499999999999, "robust_s1003": 5.787749999999999, "robust_s1004": 5.03825 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "rel4", "rel3", "nonoise_s1002", "rel2", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.944, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.997, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.9705, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1941, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 6.408191660272283, "rel2": 5.298969609414346, "rel3": 5.1622359671585345, "rel4": 5.10850077557355, "nonoise_s1001": 4.586965485616544, "nonoise_s1002": 5.176197842922732, "nonoise_s1003": 4.721792885595103, "nonoise_s1004": 4.587017005402547, "release_s1001": 4.751262233037423, "release_s1002": 4.592529628769385, "release_s1003": 4.780680052095439, "release_s1004": 4.831375586624185, "robust_s1001": 4.60587326317089, "robust_s1002": 4.598454408950255, "robust_s1003": 4.65914477778734, "robust_s1004": 4.621638331690871 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.07525, "ci95": [ 0.052743749999999985, 0.09975624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.05775, "ci95": [ 0.038743749999999993, 0.07899999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.05525, "ci95": [ 0.037487499999999986, 0.07524999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.31749999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.25649374999999996, 0.3750124999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.015499999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.008250000000000002, 0.024006249999999965 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.009250000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.005000000000000001, 0.014249999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.036, "ci95": [ 0.022000000000000002, 0.051256249999999975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.1155, "ci95": [ 0.07975, 0.15325624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.00225, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0055000000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.20149999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.16749999999999995, 0.23650625000000008 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.18525, "ci95": [ 0.15199374999999996, 0.22001249999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.43500000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.38725000000000004, 0.48025000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.049, "ci95": [ 0.03549375, 0.06300624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.034, "ci95": [ 0.024250000000000004, 0.043500000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.09025, "ci95": [ 0.06675000000000002, 0.11375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.19375, "ci95": [ 0.14899374999999998, 0.24050624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.011749999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.00525, 0.01925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.00125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.3339999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.3010000000000001, 0.36900000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.49725, "ci95": [ 0.4555000000000002, 0.5370062500000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.06325000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.04775, 0.07975000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.04875, "ci95": [ 0.03699374999999998, 0.06125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.11324999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.08850000000000001, 0.13950624999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.2145, "ci95": [ 0.16774999999999998, 0.26324999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0007500000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.018250000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.009500000000000001, 0.028499999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.5239999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4827500000000002, 0.5645062500000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.06775, "ci95": [ 0.05224374999999999, 0.08449999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.055999999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.043993749999999984, 0.06899999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0015000000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.1255, "ci95": [ 0.10175000000000001, 0.15174999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.22349999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.17700000000000002, 0.27225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.00125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.024, "ci95": [ 0.01225, 0.03775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.9990000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.99725, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8782499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8612500000000002, 0.8942500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.49975, "ci95": [ 0.4924999999999999, 0.5057499999999996 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9522499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.9422499999999998, 0.9620000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.5165000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5059999999999999, 0.5307499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9315000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.91475, 0.9472499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8932499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.87275, 0.9129999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.56825, "ci95": [ 0.5539999999999997, 0.58475625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.55475, "ci95": [ 0.5447499999999998, 0.5654999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.69375, "ci95": [ 0.6635000000000001, 0.7240000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.66125, "ci95": [ 0.6397499999999999, 0.68400625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0034999999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.006750000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0027500000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.03625, "ci95": [ 0.0165, 0.061256249999999964 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.00425, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.011000000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0105, "ci95": [ 0.0055000000000000005, 0.016749999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.0475, "ci95": [ 0.01825, 0.08501249999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.01075, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.039 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0017500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.00425 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.007250000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.00125, 0.015006249999999966 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.00375, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.01125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.12024999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.10549375000000001, 0.13650000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.586, "ci95": [ 0.5622500000000002, 0.6120062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.13649999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.11474375000000002, 0.1605 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7345, "ci95": [ 0.7192437499999998, 0.7517500000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7289999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7017437499999999, 0.7577562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.14850000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.127, 0.17349999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.14849999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.13149375, 0.16699999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.27, "ci95": [ 0.23125000000000004, 0.31500625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.154, "ci95": [ 0.13574374999999997, 0.1757562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9532499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.9427500000000002, 0.9632499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.514, "ci95": [ 0.5025000000000003, 0.52875 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9322499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.9152500000000002, 0.9477500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8952500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8752437499999999, 0.91400625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5685000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5554999999999999, 0.5834999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.552, "ci95": [ 0.5419937499999995, 0.5634999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6917500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6609999999999999, 0.7220125000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.659, "ci95": [ 0.6377437499999997, 0.6807562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.05375, "ci95": [ 0.043, 0.06499999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6337499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6102500000000002, 0.6557500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6255, "ci95": [ 0.5850000000000003, 0.6660062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.07200000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.05124999999999999, 0.09850624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.063, "ci95": [ 0.05050000000000001, 0.07525000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.17650000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.14200000000000002, 0.21375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.06375, "ci95": [ 0.05274999999999999, 0.07425625000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9207499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.8985000000000001, 0.9407562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8742500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8460000000000001, 0.8992500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.55375, "ci95": [ 0.5332437499999999, 0.57375625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.53525, "ci95": [ 0.5212437499999997, 0.5472499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.679, "ci95": [ 0.6472500000000001, 0.7117499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6477499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6247437500000002, 0.6707562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.58125, "ci95": [ 0.5365000000000003, 0.6260000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.08975000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.06749375, 0.11725000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.087, "ci95": [ 0.06849375, 0.10674999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.14200000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.11099375000000004, 0.17800000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.08825000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.06949374999999998, 0.10899999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.126, "ci95": [ 0.10324375000000001, 0.15175000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.13625, "ci95": [ 0.11175, 0.16300624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.20199999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.16225000000000006, 0.2460124999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.13874999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.11350000000000002, 0.16650624999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.48424999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.4654999999999998, 0.5015062499999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6379999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6015000000000001, 0.6755 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.59025, "ci95": [ 0.5667500000000002, 0.61425 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6495000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6149937499999999, 0.6852562500000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.61075, "ci95": [ 0.5877499999999998, 0.6329999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.4182500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.37498750000000014, 0.46050625 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 116, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 15.1624875, 15.462512500000003 ], "rel2": [ 13.710743750000004, 14.032499999999997 ], "rel3": [ 12.844750000000007, 13.090999999999994 ], "rel4": [ 12.421206250000001, 12.678524999999997 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.76899375, 3.9362624999999998 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 13.4449875, 13.833287499999996 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.9007375000000035, 8.195768750000006 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.7767312499999988, 3.9380062499999995 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.873718750000004, 9.11000625 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.879249999999999, 4.163749999999997 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.36475, 9.719293749999999 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.445693750000004, 10.141806250000004 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.271468750000001, 4.629518750000001 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.194225, 4.416249999999999 ], "robust_s1003": [ 5.480737500000003, 6.123024999999999 ], "robust_s1004": [ 4.888750000000002, 5.195006249999999 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5333333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.43333333333333335, 0.6166666666666667 ], "spearman": 0.7617647058823529, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.685785955597139, 0.8206617647058819 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.0, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.04379805267432435, 0.03347309635022899 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.5615 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.25941649671427414, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.06724369169070142, 0.5774109120414489 ], "spearman": 0.32671090522641943, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.10225244453463223, 0.7755765847928267 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.009491066310935936, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.04404052900276604, 0.02546172936339792 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.6915 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.6, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5166666666666667, 0.7 ], "spearman": 0.8, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.75, 0.8705882352941177 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.07279873248389446, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.044357104741906794, 0.08953528065900895 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.193 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 92, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 2, "discordant_method_correct": 1, "discordant_base_correct": 1 } }, "act_0.3": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 15.492000000000004, "rel2": 14.00275, "rel3": 12.985250000000002, "rel4": 12.476999999999999, "nonoise_s1001": 3.8340000000000005, "nonoise_s1002": 13.469999999999997, "nonoise_s1003": 8.957749999999999, "nonoise_s1004": 3.9042499999999993, "release_s1001": 8.690250000000002, "release_s1002": 3.9822499999999987, "release_s1003": 9.61225, "release_s1004": 9.72325, "robust_s1001": 4.378499999999999, "robust_s1002": 4.192249999999999, "robust_s1003": 5.5965000000000025, "robust_s1004": 4.701750000000001 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "release_s1001", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "rel4", "rel3", "nonoise_s1002", "rel2", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.99, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.988, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.989, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1978, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 7.60687564176303, "rel2": 5.52886754907178, "rel3": 5.270222450291062, "rel4": 5.209706776906313, "nonoise_s1001": 4.570475232010543, "nonoise_s1002": 5.2143579429755675, "nonoise_s1003": 4.781648134076318, "nonoise_s1004": 4.57254803144534, "release_s1001": 4.748837209567503, "release_s1002": 4.577401420585548, "release_s1003": 4.812588475350784, "release_s1004": 4.8548533881518185, "robust_s1001": 4.5882709821868835, "robust_s1002": 4.579726998196092, "robust_s1003": 4.6412537958552065, "robust_s1004": 4.596208292022875 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.052750000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.03599999999999999, 0.07124999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.0355, "ci95": [ 0.021999999999999992, 0.05050000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.030499999999999992, "ci95": [ 0.018499999999999996, 0.04400624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.25925000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.21400000000000002, 0.3037625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.026750000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.01775, 0.037000000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0024999999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.00875, "ci95": [ 0.0055000000000000005, 0.01275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.030500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.02075, 0.04099999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.05949999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.040999999999999995, 0.07949999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0007500000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0017500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.00375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.17300000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.14449375000000003, 0.20250624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.14825, "ci95": [ 0.12299374999999999, 0.17574999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.00125, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.00275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.40850000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.36474375, 0.45150625000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.06475, "ci95": [ 0.049493749999999996, 0.08125624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0025, "ci95": [ 0.0007500000000000001, 0.004749999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0255, "ci95": [ 0.018750000000000003, 0.03249999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0022500000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0825, "ci95": [ 0.06425000000000003, 0.10099999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.13324999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.10375000000000004, 0.16450625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.002, "ci95": [ 0.0005, 0.004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0015000000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.006249999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.0025, 0.0105 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0007500000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.3115, "ci95": [ 0.2827375, 0.3402562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.002, "ci95": [ 0.0005, 0.0037500000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.48475000000000007, "ci95": [ 0.4457500000000001, 0.5239999999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.08675, "ci95": [ 0.06999375000000001, 0.10425000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0027500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.04125, "ci95": [ 0.03274999999999999, 0.05000624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0017499999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.0035000000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.11124999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.09225000000000003, 0.13124999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.16425, "ci95": [ 0.13275, 0.19799999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0025, "ci95": [ 0.0007500000000000001, 0.0045000000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0024999999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.012249999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.006000000000000001, 0.01975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.00125, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.0027500000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.002, "ci95": [ 0.0007500000000000001, 0.00375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.5150000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.4785000000000002, 0.5527500000000003 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.102, "ci95": [ 0.085, 0.12000624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0027500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.05125000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.041749999999999995, 0.06124999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0015, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.1315, "ci95": [ 0.11250000000000002, 0.15150625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.1815, "ci95": [ 0.15073750000000002, 0.21474999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0030000000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.00125, 0.00525 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.00125, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.00275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.010249999999999999, 0.03225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0015000000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.9960000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9895, 0.9997499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.92425, "ci95": [ 0.91125, 0.9372499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5082499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5004999999999998, 0.5149999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9472499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.9374937499999997, 0.9577500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.51625, "ci95": [ 0.50675, 0.5284999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9457499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.9317500000000001, 0.9585000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.9235, "ci95": [ 0.90849375, 0.9380000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.565, "ci95": [ 0.5519999999999997, 0.5792562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5399999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5294999999999997, 0.5507499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.68525, "ci95": [ 0.6622500000000002, 0.7085000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6200000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6027500000000005, 0.6372500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.034, "ci95": [ 0.02574999999999998, 0.043749999999999976 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0035000000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.009256249999999968 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0285, "ci95": [ 0.010249999999999999, 0.05325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.00525, "ci95": [ 0.00075, 0.012 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.02725, "ci95": [ 0.020499999999999994, 0.034999999999999976 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.06825, "ci95": [ 0.03925, 0.10525625000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0115, "ci95": [ 0.0005, 0.0325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0027500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.0005, 0.005750000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0075, "ci95": [ 0.0034999999999999996, 0.012500000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.014256249999999967 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.075, "ci95": [ 0.06225000000000004, 0.08800000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.41674999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.38998750000000015, 0.44599999999999956 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.08650000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.07050000000000002, 0.10475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.608, "ci95": [ 0.5897500000000003, 0.6265125000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.627, "ci95": [ 0.5977437499999999, 0.6592562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0995, "ci95": [ 0.08, 0.12325000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.1, "ci95": [ 0.08375000000000002, 0.11675000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.17475, "ci95": [ 0.1407500000000001, 0.21276249999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.09325, "ci95": [ 0.07700000000000004, 0.11149999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9472499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.9369999999999998, 0.9577500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.5055000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.4945000000000004, 0.5192500000000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9440000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9302499999999999, 0.9567562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.9227500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9082500000000002, 0.9365000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.55625, "ci95": [ 0.5440000000000002, 0.5702499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.53075, "ci95": [ 0.5185000000000002, 0.5435062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.67525, "ci95": [ 0.6527437500000002, 0.6990062500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.60975, "ci95": [ 0.59249375, 0.6272500000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0565, "ci95": [ 0.0455, 0.06725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6737499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.6479937499999998, 0.6969999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6600000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6237500000000002, 0.6965000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0745, "ci95": [ 0.05449375000000002, 0.09875000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.06974999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.05674375000000002, 0.08225000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.17299999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.14325000000000002, 0.20526249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.06875, "ci95": [ 0.05749375, 0.08075000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.939, "ci95": [ 0.9195000000000002, 0.95550625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.9057499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.88149375, 0.92775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.54925, "ci95": [ 0.5302500000000001, 0.5672499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.522, "ci95": [ 0.5080000000000002, 0.5352500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6732500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6492500000000001, 0.6992562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.603, "ci95": [ 0.5847500000000003, 0.6197499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.55175, "ci95": [ 0.5124937500000001, 0.5932624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.07700000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.057500000000000016, 0.10124999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.07225000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.05749999999999999, 0.088 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.11475000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.08775000000000005, 0.14425625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0655, "ci95": [ 0.05125, 0.08150000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0955, "ci95": [ 0.07724999999999999, 0.1170125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.10725, "ci95": [ 0.08625000000000002, 0.12975625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.16774999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.13224375000000002, 0.20675625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.10375, "ci95": [ 0.081, 0.12925624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.4755000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.45649375, 0.49375000000000013 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6305000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6027500000000001, 0.65825625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.55225, "ci95": [ 0.53324375, 0.5725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.65075, "ci95": [ 0.6229999999999999, 0.6787499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.58025, "ci95": [ 0.5614999999999997, 0.5990062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.39649999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.36725, 0.42550624999999986 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 117, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 15.385987499999999, 15.595012500000013 ], "rel2": [ 13.869962500000005, 14.138512499999997 ], "rel3": [ 12.884750000000004, 13.0820125 ], "rel4": [ 12.374500000000006, 12.57900625000001 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.770500000000002, 3.8960249999999985 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 13.275725, 13.652256250000002 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 8.813981249999998, 9.101256250000002 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.8415, 3.9687499999999982 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.574243749999999, 8.81275 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.8725, 4.104006250000002 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.446224999999998, 9.769012500000002 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.4565, 10.003793750000002 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.243462500000001, 4.563006249999998 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.085243749999999, 4.29979375 ], "robust_s1003": [ 5.350487500000001, 5.861006250000002 ], "robust_s1004": [ 4.582993750000001, 4.833775 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.55, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.4665063768703912, 0.6333333333333333 ], "spearman": 0.7735294117647059, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6970588235294117, 0.8352941176470589 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.01666666666666672, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.015446146621713841, 0.06666666666666665 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.153 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.32636268941473195, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.033903175181040524, 0.6276205565667923 ], "spearman": 0.3546726493674193, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.0723689879203362, 0.7953101951097693 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.05745512638952188, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.026833322656606283, 0.07531932561202272 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.132 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.65, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5498484453922805, 0.7447763937925935 ], "spearman": 0.8294117647058824, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7647058823529411, 0.8970588235294118 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.1227987324838945, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.027410912041448854, 0.13960516216745672 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.0675 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 93, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 3, "discordant_method_correct": 2, "discordant_base_correct": 1 } }, "act_rate_delay": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 5.557, "rel2": 4.986000000000003, "rel3": 5.70775, "rel4": 6.699250000000001, "nonoise_s1001": 8.784, "nonoise_s1002": 12.68925, "nonoise_s1003": 12.741250000000004, "nonoise_s1004": 9.610749999999998, "release_s1001": 10.888499999999997, "release_s1002": 8.00525, "release_s1003": 11.881250000000005, "release_s1004": 11.731750000000003, "robust_s1001": 8.530749999999998, "robust_s1002": 5.2535, "robust_s1003": 5.026, "robust_s1004": 7.907750000000004 }, "order": [ "rel2", "robust_s1003", "robust_s1002", "rel1", "rel3", "rel4", "robust_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1001", "release_s1004", "release_s1003", "nonoise_s1002", "nonoise_s1003" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.95, "rel2": 0.995, "rel3": 0.947, "rel4": 0.896, "nonoise_s1001": 0.619, "nonoise_s1002": 0.521, "nonoise_s1003": 0.471, "nonoise_s1004": 0.582, "release_s1001": 0.579, "release_s1002": 0.645, "release_s1003": 0.546, "release_s1004": 0.511, "robust_s1001": 0.618, "robust_s1002": 0.727, "robust_s1003": 0.776, "robust_s1004": 0.627 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.995, "rel2": 0.897, "rel3": 0.801, "rel4": 0.757, "nonoise_s1001": 0.584, "nonoise_s1002": 0.52, "nonoise_s1003": 0.457, "nonoise_s1004": 0.547, "release_s1001": 0.544, "release_s1002": 0.605, "release_s1003": 0.525, "release_s1004": 0.517, "robust_s1001": 0.585, "robust_s1002": 0.715, "robust_s1003": 0.773, "robust_s1004": 0.632 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.9725, "rel2": 0.946, "rel3": 0.874, "rel4": 0.8265, "nonoise_s1001": 0.6015, "nonoise_s1002": 0.5205, "nonoise_s1003": 0.464, "nonoise_s1004": 0.5645, "release_s1001": 0.5615, "release_s1002": 0.625, "release_s1003": 0.5355, "release_s1004": 0.514, "robust_s1001": 0.6015, "robust_s1002": 0.721, "robust_s1003": 0.7745, "robust_s1004": 0.6295 } }, "common_success_units": 881, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 5.9349602911447965, "rel2": 5.497389334690557, "rel3": 5.5594778713113735, "rel4": 5.755845635757273, "nonoise_s1001": 6.874120312029333, "nonoise_s1002": 9.473666278241577, "nonoise_s1003": 10.009534628247836, "nonoise_s1004": 7.267309901392284, "release_s1001": 7.825766187520628, "release_s1002": 6.618274700086856, "release_s1003": 8.467082869316473, "release_s1004": 8.420544841368, "robust_s1001": 6.7569807146789, "robust_s1002": 5.5846765014289055, "robust_s1003": 5.520317834568348, "robust_s1004": 6.5341657236404505 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.39824999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.35675000000000007, 0.44099999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.526, "ci95": [ 0.4887499999999999, 0.56375625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.613, "ci95": [ 0.5792500000000003, 0.6467625000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.72875, "ci95": [ 0.6977437499999997, 0.7592562500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.8829999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.8595, 0.9062499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8755, "ci95": [ 0.8532500000000003, 0.8957562500000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.74575, "ci95": [ 0.7099937500000003, 0.7785000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.79825, "ci95": [ 0.7692437500000002, 0.8247562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.708, "ci95": [ 0.6735000000000001, 0.7405062500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8517500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8282437499999997, 0.8757562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.85225, "ci95": [ 0.8297499999999998, 0.8752499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.7219999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6875000000000001, 0.7535062500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.52125, "ci95": [ 0.4834999999999998, 0.5564999999999997 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.532, "ci95": [ 0.4905, 0.5702499999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6872499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6579937499999999, 0.7164999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.60625, "ci95": [ 0.5727499999999999, 0.6425062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.687, "ci95": [ 0.6560000000000001, 0.71825625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.74925, "ci95": [ 0.7157500000000002, 0.7802499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.90275, "ci95": [ 0.8820000000000001, 0.9220062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.88875, "ci95": [ 0.8720000000000006, 0.9039999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.76375, "ci95": [ 0.7260000000000005, 0.7985062500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.8275, "ci95": [ 0.8009999999999999, 0.8520062500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.72575, "ci95": [ 0.6894875, 0.7597562500000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8752499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.8575000000000004, 0.8920000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8740000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8562500000000002, 0.8907562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.7425, "ci95": [ 0.7052500000000004, 0.7757562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.53525, "ci95": [ 0.4929999999999999, 0.5729999999999996 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5275, "ci95": [ 0.4847437500000002, 0.56750625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7067500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6760000000000003, 0.7354999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.7092499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6829937499999997, 0.73525625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.7219999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6897500000000001, 0.7520062500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.8779999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.8590000000000002, 0.8962562500000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.86625, "ci95": [ 0.8522500000000004, 0.8795062500000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.7314999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6947437500000001, 0.76550625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.801, "ci95": [ 0.7757500000000002, 0.8247562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.6964999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6609999999999999, 0.7302500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8547499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8389937499999996, 0.8702500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.84925, "ci95": [ 0.8329937499999999, 0.86525 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.7134999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.677, 0.74725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.48025, "ci95": [ 0.43850000000000044, 0.5185125 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.45349999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.4145000000000001, 0.4920000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.66875, "ci95": [ 0.639, 0.6977499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.6922499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.6614874999999997, 0.7224999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.85075, "ci95": [ 0.8302500000000004, 0.8712499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8457499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8317500000000001, 0.8592562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.7027499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6684937500000003, 0.736 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.777, "ci95": [ 0.75275, 0.8007499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.6680000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6342375000000002, 0.70125625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8327499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.81725, 0.8482499999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.82325, "ci95": [ 0.8062500000000005, 0.8402499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.68175, "ci95": [ 0.6482437499999999, 0.7142562500000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.42125000000000007, "ci95": [ 0.38199999999999995, 0.4582499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.38075, "ci95": [ 0.3425, 0.41725625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6337499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.60575, 0.662 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.7789999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.7610000000000001, 0.7962500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.7962499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.78374375, 0.8092499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.6427499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6242500000000001, 0.6602499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.7497499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.7329937500000001, 0.76625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.36425, "ci95": [ 0.3510000000000001, 0.3765062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7805, "ci95": [ 0.7635, 0.7965000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7619999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7447437500000001, 0.77975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.43825000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.41974999999999996, 0.45750625000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.20474999999999993, "ci95": [ 0.19200000000000003, 0.21724999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.20250000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.18625, 0.21874999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.38825000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.36650000000000005, 0.41 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.4985, "ci95": [ 0.4744875, 0.5222625000000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.25175, "ci95": [ 0.23250000000000004, 0.2707499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.26225, "ci95": [ 0.2444875, 0.27949999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.20799999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.19074374999999993, 0.2262499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.3555, "ci95": [ 0.3287500000000002, 0.38300624999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.34650000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.32175, 0.37324999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.21849999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.20225000000000004, 0.23424999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.14225000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.1287500000000001, 0.15475000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1195, "ci95": [ 0.10475, 0.13424999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.2015, "ci95": [ 0.1852499999999999, 0.21824999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.22575, "ci95": [ 0.21125000000000005, 0.23900625000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.2612500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.2462437499999999, 0.27625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.19274999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.17924999999999994, 0.20549999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.33399999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.3167500000000001, 0.35200625000000013 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.34600000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.32799375, 0.3637500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.20825, "ci95": [ 0.19375, 0.2217562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.14375000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.13000000000000003, 0.15600000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.12675, "ci95": [ 0.11249374999999999, 0.1405 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.19125, "ci95": [ 0.17799999999999996, 0.20325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.6395, "ci95": [ 0.6167499999999999, 0.6642562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.31325, "ci95": [ 0.29574374999999997, 0.3307500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.72375, "ci95": [ 0.6984999999999998, 0.74575625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7065, "ci95": [ 0.6819937499999997, 0.7305062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.34525, "ci95": [ 0.3245000000000001, 0.3665000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.2035, "ci95": [ 0.18924999999999995, 0.21849999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.207, "ci95": [ 0.18899999999999997, 0.22349999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.3145, "ci95": [ 0.29073750000000004, 0.33949999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.21525, "ci95": [ 0.20074999999999993, 0.2297499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.643, "ci95": [ 0.6134937500000001, 0.6699999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.618, "ci95": [ 0.58824375, 0.6482562500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.23450000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.21875, 0.24974999999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.15200000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.1400000000000001, 0.16325000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1375, "ci95": [ 0.12250000000000004, 0.15175000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.22775, "ci95": [ 0.20975000000000002, 0.2460062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8022499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7882437499999995, 0.8167499999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7872499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.77125, 0.8034999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.58675, "ci95": [ 0.5669999999999998, 0.6059999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.21174999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.1987437499999999, 0.22524999999999987 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.20825000000000007, "ci95": [ 0.19223749999999995, 0.22474999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.4902500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.4675000000000004, 0.5112562500000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.48324999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.4625, 0.5047500000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.22149999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.20425000000000007, 0.24025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.14500000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.13099375000000005, 0.15825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.12300000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.10974999999999997, 0.13550000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.19949999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.184, 0.21600624999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.236, "ci95": [ 0.21848749999999997, 0.25375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.14925, "ci95": [ 0.13575, 0.16250000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.12625, "ci95": [ 0.11249374999999996, 0.13950625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.205, "ci95": [ 0.1905, 0.21924999999999983 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.20274999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.18999999999999992, 0.2165062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.20450000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.18799374999999993, 0.22149999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.41074999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.3847437499999999, 0.43825000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.46224999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.42174999999999996, 0.5077562500000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7972500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7839999999999999, 0.8097500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.78525, "ci95": [ 0.7679937499999998, 0.8010062500000003 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 110, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 5.213431249999998, 5.9055124999999995 ], "rel2": [ 4.6794937500000024, 5.313025000000003 ], "rel3": [ 5.412493749999999, 5.997506249999995 ], "rel4": [ 6.432993750000001, 6.956506250000002 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 8.58175, 8.972499999999998 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 12.482987499999995, 12.900281249999995 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 12.61423125, 12.8722625 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 9.31870625, 9.884024999999996 ], "release_s1001": [ 10.706075000000002, 11.070499999999996 ], "release_s1002": [ 7.802243749999998, 8.198518750000005 ], "release_s1003": [ 11.703481249999998, 12.057275000000002 ], "release_s1004": [ 11.566481249999997, 11.912525 ], "robust_s1001": [ 8.30243125, 8.747512499999997 ], "robust_s1002": [ 5.0151875, 5.476756250000001 ], "robust_s1003": [ 4.770237500000001, 5.27400625 ], "robust_s1004": [ 7.736500000000003, 8.071025 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.35, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.25, 0.43333333333333335 ], "spearman": 0.3941176470588235, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.25882352941176473, 0.538235294117647 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.18333333333333335, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.35, -0.016666666666666663 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.9865 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.41004543029030427, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.22229530961845007, 0.649841093878686 ], "spearman": 0.4974247115609449, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.2562368028612093, 0.7971103622626301 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.1411378672650942, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.35526949516577916, 0.6754606575259582 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.2465 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.2, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.08333333333333333, 0.31666666666666665 ], "spearman": 0.16176470588235295, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.02067654095330965, 0.3235294117647059 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.3272012675161055, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.5500534166634138, -0.22706150449920992 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 81, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 67, "discordant_method_correct": 28, "discordant_base_correct": 39 } }, "act_rate_delay_paper": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 5.67775, "rel2": 5.0334999999999965, "rel3": 5.77, "rel4": 6.78675, "nonoise_s1001": 8.721500000000002, "nonoise_s1002": 12.778249999999996, "nonoise_s1003": 12.784500000000003, "nonoise_s1004": 9.67675, "release_s1001": 10.89375, "release_s1002": 7.930500000000003, "release_s1003": 11.903499999999994, "release_s1004": 11.715499999999997, "robust_s1001": 8.424750000000001, "robust_s1002": 5.082750000000002, "robust_s1003": 4.975749999999999, "robust_s1004": 7.844500000000002 }, "order": [ "robust_s1003", "rel2", "robust_s1002", "rel1", "rel3", "rel4", "robust_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1001", "release_s1004", "release_s1003", "nonoise_s1002", "nonoise_s1003" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.945, "rel2": 0.988, "rel3": 0.941, "rel4": 0.887, "nonoise_s1001": 0.644, "nonoise_s1002": 0.559, "nonoise_s1003": 0.515, "nonoise_s1004": 0.602, "release_s1001": 0.608, "release_s1002": 0.666, "release_s1003": 0.585, "release_s1004": 0.556, "robust_s1001": 0.639, "robust_s1002": 0.738, "robust_s1003": 0.792, "robust_s1004": 0.661 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.994, "rel2": 0.907, "rel3": 0.81, "rel4": 0.753, "nonoise_s1001": 0.595, "nonoise_s1002": 0.505, "nonoise_s1003": 0.468, "nonoise_s1004": 0.551, "release_s1001": 0.547, "release_s1002": 0.609, "release_s1003": 0.532, "release_s1004": 0.534, "robust_s1001": 0.591, "robust_s1002": 0.739, "robust_s1003": 0.779, "robust_s1004": 0.64 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.9695, "rel2": 0.9475, "rel3": 0.8755, "rel4": 0.82, "nonoise_s1001": 0.6195, "nonoise_s1002": 0.532, "nonoise_s1003": 0.4915, "nonoise_s1004": 0.5765, "release_s1001": 0.5775, "release_s1002": 0.6375, "release_s1003": 0.5585, "release_s1004": 0.545, "robust_s1001": 0.615, "robust_s1002": 0.7385, "robust_s1003": 0.7855, "robust_s1004": 0.6505 } }, "common_success_units": 930, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 5.9330107599176385, "rel2": 5.388172048394398, "rel3": 5.438387100414563, "rel4": 5.622365588782936, "nonoise_s1001": 6.727526878285151, "nonoise_s1002": 9.205376366389695, "nonoise_s1003": 10.054516151387205, "nonoise_s1004": 7.1284946331413845, "release_s1001": 7.6122580623113985, "release_s1002": 6.453548393454603, "release_s1003": 8.426451614851592, "release_s1004": 8.44602151404145, "robust_s1001": 6.5801075461090255, "robust_s1002": 5.417634413062885, "robust_s1003": 5.43204301095778, "robust_s1004": 6.373010754585266 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.39525000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.3572500000000002, 0.4337499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.5152500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.48024999999999984, 0.5515 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.6072500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5755000000000001, 0.6402500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.7194999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6867437499999999, 0.75125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.8779999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.8534999999999999, 0.9024999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8672500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8430000000000005, 0.8895062500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.7387499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7057500000000003, 0.77225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.7954999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7692437499999999, 0.8207562500000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.6974999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6625000000000003, 0.7304999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.84175, "ci95": [ 0.8150000000000006, 0.8674999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8377499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8115000000000002, 0.8642562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.7142499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6807437500000001, 0.7462625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.513, "ci95": [ 0.47297500000000003, 0.5495125000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5217499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4787375, 0.5645 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6795, "ci95": [ 0.6439937499999998, 0.7134999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.612, "ci95": [ 0.5802437499999998, 0.6437562499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.6820000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.6537499999999998, 0.7110062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.745, "ci95": [ 0.7124999999999997, 0.7755062499999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.90825, "ci95": [ 0.8882500000000002, 0.9259999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.889, "ci95": [ 0.8715000000000004, 0.9052500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.76275, "ci95": [ 0.7289875000000001, 0.79475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.8212499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.7970000000000002, 0.8447562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.72375, "ci95": [ 0.6887499999999995, 0.75725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.872, "ci95": [ 0.8515000000000001, 0.8909999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8625, "ci95": [ 0.8417499999999998, 0.8817499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.7370000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.7025000000000001, 0.7697499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.52, "ci95": [ 0.4750000000000001, 0.5615062499999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.52375, "ci95": [ 0.4792500000000004, 0.5667500000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7025, "ci95": [ 0.66849375, 0.7360062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.701, "ci95": [ 0.6757500000000001, 0.7262500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.716, "ci95": [ 0.68525, 0.7460062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.88, "ci95": [ 0.8604937499999998, 0.89775625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8630000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8454999999999999, 0.8795000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.7342500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7022437499999999, 0.7662562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.7977500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7735000000000002, 0.8207562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.6940000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6609937499999999, 0.7265062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8482500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8292499999999999, 0.8657562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8392499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8207499999999999, 0.8570062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.709, "ci95": [ 0.6764874999999998, 0.7412499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.45899999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.41799375000000005, 0.49900625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.4495, "ci95": [ 0.40725, 0.4897499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.66625, "ci95": [ 0.6342499999999999, 0.6977562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.6830000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.6517500000000003, 0.7132562500000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.8514999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8304999999999997, 0.87025625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.83725, "ci95": [ 0.8187437499999999, 0.85375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.7035000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6727437500000001, 0.7352562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.7712499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7465000000000004, 0.79450625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.661, "ci95": [ 0.6270000000000002, 0.6935000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.825, "ci95": [ 0.80674375, 0.8422562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8104999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.7937499999999997, 0.8270000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.67325, "ci95": [ 0.6425000000000002, 0.7050062500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.391, "ci95": [ 0.3527437499999999, 0.4284999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.3762500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.3392500000000001, 0.4132562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.62, "ci95": [ 0.5884937500000001, 0.6520125000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.7957500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7795000000000003, 0.8115062500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8025000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7897500000000002, 0.81575 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.662, "ci95": [ 0.6445000000000001, 0.6785125000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.7632499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7462500000000002, 0.7805000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.35050000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.33624374999999973, 0.36525624999999984 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7897500000000002, "ci95": [ 0.7732500000000004, 0.8062500000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.76625, "ci95": [ 0.7467500000000007, 0.7852562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.42725, "ci95": [ 0.4105000000000001, 0.44450000000000023 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.1955, "ci95": [ 0.18375000000000002, 0.20774999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.20074999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.18624999999999997, 0.21549999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.38850000000000007, "ci95": [ 0.3660000000000002, 0.4102562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.5002500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.47725000000000006, 0.5225000000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.24950000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.22849375000000002, 0.2702500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.25350000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.23549999999999993, 0.27124999999999977 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.19325, "ci95": [ 0.17825, 0.2079999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.349, "ci95": [ 0.32150000000000006, 0.3754999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.347, "ci95": [ 0.32125, 0.3740125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.20424999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.1885, 0.21975000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.13275, "ci95": [ 0.11950000000000002, 0.14550000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.11375, "ci95": [ 0.1004937499999999, 0.12649999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.192, "ci95": [ 0.17574375000000003, 0.20799999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.22175, "ci95": [ 0.20725000000000002, 0.23575000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.2615, "ci95": [ 0.2457499999999999, 0.278 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.18849999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.17599374999999995, 0.20025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.322, "ci95": [ 0.3087500000000002, 0.33475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.3375000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.3207500000000001, 0.35550000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.20375000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.18974375000000002, 0.21800000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.13674999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.124, 0.14924999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1185, "ci95": [ 0.10674999999999997, 0.13 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.18450000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.1722500000000001, 0.19625000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.64475, "ci95": [ 0.6210000000000003, 0.6690000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.29474999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.27925, 0.3105 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.72925, "ci95": [ 0.7072437499999998, 0.7512562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.71325, "ci95": [ 0.69025, 0.7360062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.32675000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.3092499999999999, 0.3452624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.19024999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.17624374999999998, 0.20399999999999988 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.19849999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.18275, 0.2135062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.29825, "ci95": [ 0.2767499999999999, 0.31975624999999985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.20525, "ci95": [ 0.19150000000000003, 0.21925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.664, "ci95": [ 0.6359999999999999, 0.6897499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.62925, "ci95": [ 0.6000000000000001, 0.6579999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.22375, "ci95": [ 0.20750000000000018, 0.24050000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.13799999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.12574375, 0.15000000000000008 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.131, "ci95": [ 0.11799374999999994, 0.14375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.22375000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.2037500000000001, 0.24349999999999983 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.80925, "ci95": [ 0.7957500000000001, 0.8239999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7855000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7692499999999997, 0.802 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5802499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5620000000000003, 0.5977625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.20575, "ci95": [ 0.19349999999999987, 0.21899999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.20800000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.19325000000000003, 0.2230062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.48925, "ci95": [ 0.468, 0.5107562500000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.48575, "ci95": [ 0.46499375000000004, 0.5069999999999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.21575, "ci95": [ 0.19775, 0.23574999999999985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.13649999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.12225, 0.15 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1195, "ci95": [ 0.1075, 0.13174999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.18924999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.17325, 0.20500625000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.23725000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.21875000000000003, 0.25700000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.1405, "ci95": [ 0.12674375000000002, 0.15350000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1235, "ci95": [ 0.11049999999999997, 0.13599999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.19774999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.18224374999999993, 0.21324999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.19624999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.18349999999999994, 0.20900624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.20600000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.19049999999999997, 0.22150625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.4255, "ci95": [ 0.4005, 0.4497500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.47025000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.42699374999999995, 0.51650625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.8022499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7885000000000002, 0.8157499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.78525, "ci95": [ 0.7639937499999997, 0.8039999999999999 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 111, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 5.315237500000003, 6.0477874999999965 ], "rel2": [ 4.722443749999997, 5.357074999999995 ], "rel3": [ 5.47124375, 6.0546625 ], "rel4": [ 6.521193749999997, 7.050281249999997 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 8.529487500000004, 8.908543750000002 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 12.58125, 12.976256250000008 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 12.640743750000007, 12.92600625000001 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 9.405737500000003, 9.927024999999997 ], "release_s1001": [ 10.739475000000002, 11.045781250000003 ], "release_s1002": [ 7.736250000000001, 8.115268749999998 ], "release_s1003": [ 11.733737499999995, 12.071506249999999 ], "release_s1004": [ 11.529999999999998, 11.904256250000005 ], "robust_s1001": [ 8.203250000000002, 8.636781249999999 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.8294500000000005, 5.320043750000002 ], "robust_s1003": [ 4.732249999999998, 5.2137499999999966 ], "robust_s1004": [ 7.640956250000004, 8.03725625 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.36666666666666664, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.26666666666666666, 0.45 ], "spearman": 0.4264705882352941, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.27941176470588236, 0.5558823529411765 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.16666666666666669, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.3333333333333333, 0.0 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.9765 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.42678197846541877, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.24267994853915967, 0.6441603284397699 ], "spearman": 0.5356881509117868, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.2869757951313144, 0.7941163687309808 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.1578744154402087, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.3317175238551799, 0.6671128094882209 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.226 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.21666666666666667, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.08333333333333333, 0.31666666666666665 ], "spearman": 0.16470588235294117, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.02060339041968411, 0.31938344359982884 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.31053460084943885, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.5445667492672501, -0.2271313860076577 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 82, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 66, "discordant_method_correct": 28, "discordant_base_correct": 38 } }, "agn_c2": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 14.455749999999998, "rel2": 12.979250000000004, "rel3": 12.144500000000003, "rel4": 11.854750000000001, "nonoise_s1001": 4.1835, "nonoise_s1002": 13.794500000000003, "nonoise_s1003": 8.043249999999995, "nonoise_s1004": 4.315250000000001, "release_s1001": 9.357499999999998, "release_s1002": 4.170750000000001, "release_s1003": 9.991999999999999, "release_s1004": 10.695249999999998, "robust_s1001": 4.586499999999999, "robust_s1002": 4.0569999999999995, "robust_s1003": 5.977249999999999, "robust_s1004": 5.393000000000001 }, "order": [ "robust_s1002", "release_s1002", "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "rel4", "rel3", "rel2", "nonoise_s1002", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.842, "rel2": 0.986, "rel3": 0.999, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.993, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.9175, "rel2": 0.993, "rel3": 0.9995, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1835, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 6.2576566817000385, "rel2": 5.728283383411023, "rel3": 5.593242510527941, "rel4": 5.560490462240796, "nonoise_s1001": 5.096948226141345, "nonoise_s1002": 5.820817442161186, "nonoise_s1003": 5.237765668588374, "nonoise_s1004": 5.101035420511334, "release_s1001": 5.278147139276406, "release_s1002": 5.0978746572047555, "release_s1003": 5.317057225294919, "release_s1004": 5.438038143929734, "robust_s1001": 5.111553130747512, "robust_s1002": 5.069700267594257, "robust_s1003": 5.191444144456848, "robust_s1004": 5.128555856088852 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.11374999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.08399375, 0.14700625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.11125, "ci95": [ 0.08050000000000003, 0.14575625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.1235, "ci95": [ 0.09349375, 0.15775000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.027999999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.020500000000000004, 0.03624999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.40475, "ci95": [ 0.35348750000000007, 0.45526250000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.10400000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.08074374999999999, 0.13075624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.030250000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.022499999999999992, 0.038999999999999986 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.09925, "ci95": [ 0.0755, 0.127 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.02475, "ci95": [ 0.017750000000000002, 0.032249999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.13875, "ci95": [ 0.10924375000000001, 0.17250625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.2225, "ci95": [ 0.18174374999999993, 0.26325624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.022249999999999995, 0.03825624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.011000000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.006250000000000001, 0.016250000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.069, "ci95": [ 0.04450000000000001, 0.09400000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.033499999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.02275, 0.04675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.24275000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.20525, 0.28125625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.254, "ci95": [ 0.21450000000000005, 0.2937687500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.035500000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.027499999999999986, 0.044500000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.5067499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.46399374999999987, 0.5480062500000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.1535, "ci95": [ 0.12675, 0.18224999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.038250000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.029749999999999995, 0.04775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.154, "ci95": [ 0.12650000000000003, 0.18275624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.032249999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.024499999999999997, 0.04074999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.20775, "ci95": [ 0.17424999999999996, 0.24126249999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.29750000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.25899374999999997, 0.33549999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.03875000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.030250000000000003, 0.04775624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0165, "ci95": [ 0.0105, 0.023499999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.09475, "ci95": [ 0.06849999999999999, 0.12175625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.06225, "ci95": [ 0.046999999999999986, 0.079 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.3715, "ci95": [ 0.33724374999999995, 0.40649999999999986 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.034749999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.027249999999999993, 0.04299999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.56375, "ci95": [ 0.52275, 0.6040125000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.172, "ci95": [ 0.14500000000000002, 0.20075625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.038000000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.029750000000000002, 0.047000000000000014 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.17950000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.15200000000000002, 0.20775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.030750000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.0235, 0.038499999999999986 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.24050000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.20875000000000007, 0.2730062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.33399999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.29550000000000004, 0.37250000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0395, "ci95": [ 0.03149999999999999, 0.04849999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.018250000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.012, 0.025499999999999988 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.11699999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.09000000000000002, 0.14550625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.07, "ci95": [ 0.05425000000000001, 0.08675000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.02875, "ci95": [ 0.023, 0.03500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.5952500000000002, "ci95": [ 0.5549937500000002, 0.6340062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.17525, "ci95": [ 0.14800000000000002, 0.2032562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.03225, "ci95": [ 0.02575, 0.039256249999999965 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.19325000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.1660000000000001, 0.21976249999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.024000000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.018250000000000006, 0.030250000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.254, "ci95": [ 0.22324999999999995, 0.28475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.35, "ci95": [ 0.31299374999999996, 0.3857562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.033, "ci95": [ 0.026500000000000003, 0.03975000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0165, "ci95": [ 0.011000000000000003, 0.0225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.12225, "ci95": [ 0.09424374999999997, 0.15275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.06975, "ci95": [ 0.05424374999999998, 0.086 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.9919999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.98775, 0.9955000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8614999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.8482499999999997, 0.8744999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5165, "ci95": [ 0.5074999999999998, 0.5247499999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.948, "ci95": [ 0.9369999999999997, 0.9584999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.4912499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4787500000000001, 0.5077500000000003 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.945, "ci95": [ 0.9332499999999997, 0.9564999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.9265000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9125000000000001, 0.9405062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5485000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5322499999999999, 0.5667500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.49375, "ci95": [ 0.47549375, 0.512 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5975, "ci95": [ 0.5637499999999999, 0.6297499999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.623, "ci95": [ 0.6057499999999999, 0.6397562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.020749999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.01425, 0.02774999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0095, "ci95": [ 0.005500000000000001, 0.014256249999999969 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.049249999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.03275, 0.07175000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.01125, "ci95": [ 0.005993750000000002, 0.018249999999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0395, "ci95": [ 0.03199999999999999, 0.04725000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.077, "ci95": [ 0.04573749999999999, 0.11600000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.01875, "ci95": [ 0.0067500000000000025, 0.043256249999999975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.009750000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.005750000000000002, 0.014499999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.022000000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.01275, 0.033 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.010249999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.006000000000000001, 0.015499999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.14975000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.13750000000000012, 0.1622562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.634, "ci95": [ 0.6109937499999998, 0.659 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.145, "ci95": [ 0.12699375000000007, 0.16574999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.78125, "ci95": [ 0.7647437500000003, 0.7985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7995, "ci95": [ 0.7785, 0.8222562500000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.16374999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.14449375000000003, 0.1864999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.16724999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.14900000000000005, 0.18575000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.35474999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.31175, 0.3957562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.24849999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.23199999999999998, 0.2675062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9377499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.9272437499999993, 0.9484999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.47674999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.4624999999999999, 0.4940000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9390000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9272499999999998, 0.9507499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.9214999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.9084874999999994, 0.9349999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5315, "ci95": [ 0.5174999999999998, 0.5482499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.49000000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.47125000000000017, 0.5085000000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.59075, "ci95": [ 0.5584937499999998, 0.6232562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.612, "ci95": [ 0.59525, 0.6287499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.048499999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.038499999999999986, 0.05900000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6240000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6012437499999999, 0.6457499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6905, "ci95": [ 0.6527500000000004, 0.7274999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.067, "ci95": [ 0.048750000000000016, 0.09100000000000008 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.054000000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.04224374999999999, 0.06650000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.24600000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.20748124999999998, 0.2852562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.10750000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.09300000000000003, 0.12250000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9382499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.9222499999999999, 0.9524999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.9195, "ci95": [ 0.8965000000000001, 0.9390062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.55675, "ci95": [ 0.5344937499999998, 0.5780000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.4829999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4642500000000001, 0.5012500000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5942500000000002, "ci95": [ 0.5619999999999999, 0.6255062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.622, "ci95": [ 0.6017437499999997, 0.6392500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.62975, "ci95": [ 0.5942500000000002, 0.6665125000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.07275000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.05350000000000005, 0.09800000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.07225, "ci95": [ 0.05775, 0.08725000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.245, "ci95": [ 0.20950000000000008, 0.28150625000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.09624999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.08050000000000004, 0.11400625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.08700000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.06925000000000002, 0.11100625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.08700000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.06875000000000002, 0.10775625000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1985, "ci95": [ 0.15974375, 0.24026874999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.10049999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.08100000000000002, 0.12375624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.449, "ci95": [ 0.4259937499999999, 0.4724999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5685, "ci95": [ 0.5317437500000001, 0.60525625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.58325, "ci95": [ 0.5595000000000001, 0.6042500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6295000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5879937500000001, 0.66975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6817499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6640000000000004, 0.699 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.4725, "ci95": [ 0.4287499999999998, 0.5170062499999999 ], "resolved": false } ], "resolved_pairs": 114, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 14.161987500000008, 14.727 ], "rel2": [ 12.736750000000006, 13.227525000000005 ], "rel3": [ 11.962218750000002, 12.33175 ], "rel4": [ 11.675987500000003, 12.046275000000003 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 4.090749999999999, 4.278000000000001 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 13.582187500000003, 13.998256249999995 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.857987499999998, 8.234812499999997 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 4.218, 4.417262500000001 ], "release_s1001": [ 9.209243749999999, 9.5165125 ], "release_s1002": [ 4.047500000000002, 4.320025000000004 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.809474999999997, 10.179756249999999 ], "release_s1004": [ 10.40625, 10.985281249999996 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.420731249999998, 4.7977687499999995 ], "robust_s1002": [ 3.9139812499999995, 4.197025000000001 ], "robust_s1003": [ 5.5754937500000015, 6.389312499999999 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.254749999999999, 5.528518749999999 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.6333333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5272012675161055, 0.7113032974423645 ], "spearman": 0.8176470588235294, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.75, 0.8736029411764702 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.09999999999999998, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.050000000000000044, 0.1338923854009157 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.0 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.2761530448893886, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.05857791861290061, 0.6272190362421881 ], "spearman": 0.3502576371346299, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.09442902658851658, 0.8035322263676803 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.007245481864178505, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.026304895495407165, 0.0755376214789197 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.193 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5666666666666667, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5333333333333333, 0.7166666666666667 ], "spearman": 0.8058823529411765, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7735294117647059, 0.888235294117647 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.03946539915056113, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.010884008391677802, 0.10578440531270007 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.05 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 98, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 6, "discordant_method_correct": 6, "discordant_base_correct": 0 } }, "agn_c4": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 12.70375, "rel2": 11.216, "rel3": 10.40425, "rel4": 10.06, "nonoise_s1001": 4.995250000000001, "nonoise_s1002": 13.348249999999998, "nonoise_s1003": 8.45075, "nonoise_s1004": 4.997749999999999, "release_s1001": 9.489499999999994, "release_s1002": 4.7865, "release_s1003": 9.849750000000002, "release_s1004": 11.127749999999999, "robust_s1001": 5.1205, "robust_s1002": 5.343749999999999, "robust_s1003": 7.17775, "robust_s1004": 6.9285000000000005 }, "order": [ "release_s1002", "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "rel4", "rel3", "release_s1004", "rel2", "rel1", "nonoise_s1002" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.776, "rel2": 0.937, "rel3": 0.978, "rel4": 0.989, "nonoise_s1001": 0.959, "nonoise_s1002": 0.957, "nonoise_s1003": 0.959, "nonoise_s1004": 0.959, "release_s1001": 0.958, "release_s1002": 0.96, "release_s1003": 0.959, "release_s1004": 0.958, "robust_s1001": 0.959, "robust_s1002": 0.96, "robust_s1003": 0.96, "robust_s1004": 0.958 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.936, "rel2": 0.98, "rel3": 0.972, "rel4": 0.968, "nonoise_s1001": 0.956, "nonoise_s1002": 0.954, "nonoise_s1003": 0.955, "nonoise_s1004": 0.955, "release_s1001": 0.955, "release_s1002": 0.955, "release_s1003": 0.955, "release_s1004": 0.955, "robust_s1001": 0.955, "robust_s1002": 0.957, "robust_s1003": 0.95, "robust_s1004": 0.955 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.856, "rel2": 0.9585, "rel3": 0.975, "rel4": 0.9785, "nonoise_s1001": 0.9575, "nonoise_s1002": 0.9555, "nonoise_s1003": 0.957, "nonoise_s1004": 0.957, "release_s1001": 0.9565, "release_s1002": 0.9575, "release_s1003": 0.957, "release_s1004": 0.9565, "robust_s1001": 0.957, "robust_s1002": 0.9585, "robust_s1003": 0.955, "robust_s1004": 0.9565 } }, "common_success_units": 1625, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 8.683938463504498, "rel2": 7.773538469461294, "rel3": 7.615015387021578, "rel4": 7.5656615384175225, "nonoise_s1001": 7.198030778298011, "nonoise_s1002": 8.417107693818899, "nonoise_s1003": 7.449538461245023, "nonoise_s1004": 7.208184617409339, "release_s1001": 7.475569230373089, "release_s1002": 7.203200004577637, "release_s1003": 7.5022153811821575, "release_s1004": 7.886523088968717, "robust_s1001": 7.19870769750155, "robust_s1002": 7.136000001980708, "robust_s1003": 7.536492312357976, "robust_s1004": 7.29261538710961 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.15175, "ci95": [ 0.12624375, 0.18000624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.15750000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.13124374999999996, 0.1865125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.17674999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.1505, 0.2055124999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.16075000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.14575000000000002, 0.17624999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.45899999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.4207375000000001, 0.49926250000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.262, "ci95": [ 0.23549374999999992, 0.2900062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.16200000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.14725000000000002, 0.17750624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.2535, "ci95": [ 0.22949374999999994, 0.2804999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.15675, "ci95": [ 0.14200000000000002, 0.1722499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.28025, "ci95": [ 0.25199375, 0.3102500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.36075, "ci95": [ 0.326, 0.39625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.15899999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.14474374999999995, 0.17425000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.13950000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.12225000000000003, 0.15725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.20775000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.17949374999999992, 0.23775624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.20900000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.18074374999999993, 0.23575000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.27599999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.24524375000000004, 0.3084999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.28075000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.24750000000000003, 0.3145000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.18575, "ci95": [ 0.16975000000000004, 0.20175000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.5435, "ci95": [ 0.5084937500000001, 0.5790000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.32, "ci95": [ 0.29025, 0.3492499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.18350000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.16750000000000007, 0.1990000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.319, "ci95": [ 0.2895000000000001, 0.34950625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.17475, "ci95": [ 0.15925, 0.1905 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.349, "ci95": [ 0.31749999999999995, 0.38175000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.4397499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.407, 0.47275625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.1795, "ci95": [ 0.16424375, 0.19524999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.16875000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.14800000000000002, 0.19025625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.2545, "ci95": [ 0.22575000000000006, 0.28425625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.26099999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.23074375, 0.29225625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.38000000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.349, 0.41200625000000013 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.193, "ci95": [ 0.17675000000000002, 0.20875625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.59075, "ci95": [ 0.5547437500000002, 0.6247562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.3479999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.3184875, 0.3772562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.1865, "ci95": [ 0.1707500000000001, 0.20200000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.35174999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.3205000000000001, 0.38300625000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.17950000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.1635, 0.195 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.38800000000000007, "ci95": [ 0.35574375, 0.42125000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.4745000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.44149375, 0.50700625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.1855, "ci95": [ 0.17049375, 0.20100624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.18899999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.1669937499999999, 0.21200000000000008 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.28324999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.25398125, 0.3139999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.27949999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.24950000000000006, 0.30850625000000015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.19175, "ci95": [ 0.17525000000000002, 0.2077500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.61825, "ci95": [ 0.5817500000000004, 0.6527562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.36, "ci95": [ 0.3294937499999999, 0.38949999999999974 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.18525000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.16975, 0.20049999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.37999999999999984, "ci95": [ 0.34849375000000005, 0.4105062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.17625, "ci95": [ 0.16124999999999998, 0.19150625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.409, "ci95": [ 0.37675000000000003, 0.4405000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.4945000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.46274374999999995, 0.5257562499999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.18425, "ci95": [ 0.16925, 0.19900000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.203, "ci95": [ 0.18024374999999998, 0.22625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.29350000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.26298125, 0.32526249999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.28175, "ci95": [ 0.2534937500000001, 0.31000625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.9522499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.9447500000000001, 0.9590062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.815, "ci95": [ 0.8014999999999999, 0.8275000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.49150000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.47850000000000004, 0.5044999999999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.90375, "ci95": [ 0.89274375, 0.914 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.45875, "ci95": [ 0.44550000000000006, 0.4742499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.893, "ci95": [ 0.8822437499999995, 0.9034999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8954999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.884, 0.9067500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.50175, "ci95": [ 0.48449999999999993, 0.5212499999999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.55425, "ci95": [ 0.53675, 0.5729999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6025, "ci95": [ 0.5727437500000001, 0.6310000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6677500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6527437499999997, 0.6837625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.07525, "ci95": [ 0.06625000000000003, 0.08524999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.05200000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.044750000000000005, 0.05975625000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.10449999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.08749374999999998, 0.12625625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.04950000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.04224999999999999, 0.05750000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.091, "ci95": [ 0.08024375, 0.10250625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.13775, "ci95": [ 0.10924374999999999, 0.17225000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.05600000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.043500000000000004, 0.07425000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.04975, "ci95": [ 0.041249999999999974, 0.058256250000000016 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.14350000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.11974375000000007, 0.16800000000000012 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.05625000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.048249999999999994, 0.06450000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.19124999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.17900000000000005, 0.20375625000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.5797499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5572499999999998, 0.6039999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.19075, "ci95": [ 0.17375000000000004, 0.20974999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.68175, "ci95": [ 0.666, 0.6987500000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.78925, "ci95": [ 0.7727500000000004, 0.8074999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.20875, "ci95": [ 0.18849999999999995, 0.23274999999999987 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.2695, "ci95": [ 0.24749999999999986, 0.2924999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.42375, "ci95": [ 0.3825000000000001, 0.46325625000000065 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.3947500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.37475, 0.41575000000000023 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.8935, "ci95": [ 0.8812500000000004, 0.9052500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.47, "ci95": [ 0.45574374999999984, 0.4862499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8855, "ci95": [ 0.8742499999999999, 0.8964999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8900000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8787500000000001, 0.9015000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.51225, "ci95": [ 0.49749374999999985, 0.5292500000000003 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5557500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.53825, 0.57450625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5984999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5687499999999999, 0.6255062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6487499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.6342437499999998, 0.6645062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0915, "ci95": [ 0.08100000000000003, 0.10200000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.5975, "ci95": [ 0.5745000000000003, 0.6187562500000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.71525, "ci95": [ 0.684, 0.7437562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.11299999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.09425000000000003, 0.13699999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.154, "ci95": [ 0.13524999999999998, 0.17425000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.35074999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.30800000000000016, 0.3922562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.27425, "ci95": [ 0.25150000000000006, 0.2977499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.892, "ci95": [ 0.8762499999999999, 0.90475625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.893, "ci95": [ 0.8750000000000001, 0.9075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.54425, "ci95": [ 0.5237437500000001, 0.5650000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5525000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5349999999999999, 0.5702562499999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.61125, "ci95": [ 0.5830000000000004, 0.6379999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.66825, "ci95": [ 0.6492499999999999, 0.6855062499999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7005000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6747437499999999, 0.7262562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.12575, "ci95": [ 0.10699375, 0.14975000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.16249999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.14400000000000004, 0.1834999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.3612499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.3185000000000001, 0.40126249999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.26725, "ci95": [ 0.2454875, 0.29075625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.1165, "ci95": [ 0.10125000000000002, 0.13600624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.1275, "ci95": [ 0.10950000000000003, 0.1464999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.2895, "ci95": [ 0.24925, 0.33000624999999983 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.12950000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.11249999999999995, 0.1502562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5327500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5087500000000001, 0.5557562499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.595, "ci95": [ 0.5622500000000001, 0.62550625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.63825, "ci95": [ 0.6144999999999996, 0.6604999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.62575, "ci95": [ 0.5807500000000002, 0.6690125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6892499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.6652500000000003, 0.71225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.46299999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.41950000000000015, 0.5069999999999998 ], "resolved": false } ], "resolved_pairs": 114, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 12.389243749999995, 13.017006250000005 ], "rel2": [ 10.927468750000005, 11.4972625 ], "rel3": [ 10.172487499999995, 10.635531250000001 ], "rel4": [ 9.838674999999997, 10.299262499999998 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 4.894231249999999, 5.0987687500000005 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 13.13125, 13.564262500000002 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 8.242250000000002, 8.657031249999996 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 4.868987499999997, 5.127024999999998 ], "release_s1001": [ 9.312499999999998, 9.669812499999995 ], "release_s1002": [ 4.66874375, 4.917756249999999 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.65648125, 10.042268750000005 ], "release_s1004": [ 10.8994875, 11.360768750000002 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.950000000000001, 5.33326875 ], "robust_s1002": [ 5.149993749999998, 5.550249999999997 ], "robust_s1003": [ 6.7372250000000005, 7.604806249999999 ], "robust_s1004": [ 6.724487499999998, 7.138506250000002 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5833333333333334, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.4937281711658766, 0.65 ], "spearman": 0.7823529411764706, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7235192520409663, 0.8353462810430254 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.050000000000000044, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.015234216625575045, 0.10627357587183459 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.062 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.39330888211518983, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.016807316136320357, 0.7004780622328695 ], "spearman": 0.459161272210103, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.020738241515079338, 0.855051208583943 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.12440131908997976, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.0244714342207789, 0.14452241869096089 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.0015 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.55, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.45, 0.65 ], "spearman": 0.7705882352941177, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6941176470588235, 0.8470744116585658 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.022798732483894524, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.16088400839167777, 0.08946539915056118 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.657 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 95, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 7, "discordant_method_correct": 5, "discordant_base_correct": 2 } }, "agn_c4_loop": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 7.155000000000005, "rel2": 5.936, "rel3": 6.044749999999997, "rel4": 6.534749999999999, "nonoise_s1001": 8.001250000000002, "nonoise_s1002": 12.165499999999998, "nonoise_s1003": 12.285499999999997, "nonoise_s1004": 8.362249999999998, "release_s1001": 10.710250000000004, "release_s1002": 7.748499999999998, "release_s1003": 11.560250000000002, "release_s1004": 11.839499999999997, "robust_s1001": 7.864749999999998, "robust_s1002": 5.334250000000001, "robust_s1003": 6.759249999999998, "robust_s1004": 7.698249999999996 }, "order": [ "robust_s1002", "rel2", "rel3", "rel4", "robust_s1003", "rel1", "robust_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "nonoise_s1002", "nonoise_s1003" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.796, "rel2": 0.935, "rel3": 0.941, "rel4": 0.911, "nonoise_s1001": 0.657, "nonoise_s1002": 0.534, "nonoise_s1003": 0.417, "nonoise_s1004": 0.632, "release_s1001": 0.569, "release_s1002": 0.669, "release_s1003": 0.512, "release_s1004": 0.495, "robust_s1001": 0.668, "robust_s1002": 0.808, "robust_s1003": 0.781, "robust_s1004": 0.713 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.93, "rel2": 0.975, "rel3": 0.916, "rel4": 0.846, "nonoise_s1001": 0.609, "nonoise_s1002": 0.486, "nonoise_s1003": 0.383, "nonoise_s1004": 0.586, "release_s1001": 0.488, "release_s1002": 0.584, "release_s1003": 0.44, "release_s1004": 0.463, "robust_s1001": 0.573, "robust_s1002": 0.788, "robust_s1003": 0.796, "robust_s1004": 0.713 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.863, "rel2": 0.955, "rel3": 0.9285, "rel4": 0.8785, "nonoise_s1001": 0.633, "nonoise_s1002": 0.51, "nonoise_s1003": 0.4, "nonoise_s1004": 0.609, "release_s1001": 0.5285, "release_s1002": 0.6265, "release_s1003": 0.476, "release_s1004": 0.479, "robust_s1001": 0.6205, "robust_s1002": 0.798, "robust_s1003": 0.7885, "robust_s1004": 0.713 } }, "common_success_units": 581, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 12.820654079548873, "rel2": 11.548192793654083, "rel3": 11.232013784464378, "rel4": 11.150946640106568, "nonoise_s1001": 10.893287444484008, "nonoise_s1002": 13.610499129648257, "nonoise_s1003": 15.147848534707153, "nonoise_s1004": 11.014285725283335, "release_s1001": 11.894492278616113, "release_s1002": 10.82650605167251, "release_s1003": 13.017039588724685, "release_s1004": 12.788640276700413, "robust_s1001": 10.846987968057446, "robust_s1002": 10.600860566157277, "robust_s1003": 11.270395866975111, "robust_s1004": 10.899483647486019 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.322, "ci95": [ 0.29, 0.35574999999999973 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.39224999999999993, "ci95": [ 0.35674999999999996, 0.4280125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.44425, "ci95": [ 0.40825000000000017, 0.4805000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.6004999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5675000000000001, 0.6342562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.7605, "ci95": [ 0.7312500000000003, 0.7897500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.7759999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.7497500000000002, 0.8027625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.612, "ci95": [ 0.5792500000000002, 0.6445124999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.6829999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6539937499999999, 0.71300625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.5887499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.556, 0.62125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.73675, "ci95": [ 0.70625, 0.7660000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7547499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7250000000000004, 0.7860062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.588, "ci95": [ 0.5537249999999998, 0.6214999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.46525000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.43425, 0.4979999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5285000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.4880000000000001, 0.5705062500000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.5925, "ci95": [ 0.5562437499999998, 0.6297562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.48400000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.4532500000000003, 0.5142500000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.54, "ci95": [ 0.5090000000000005, 0.5720000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.6457499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.61224375, 0.67900625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.84725, "ci95": [ 0.82225, 0.8717562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8375, "ci95": [ 0.8149937499999996, 0.8584999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.6557499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.6209937499999997, 0.6892499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.7509999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7242499999999995, 0.7775062499999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.6317499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5985, 0.6639999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8055, "ci95": [ 0.7787499999999998, 0.8294999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8360000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8102437499999996, 0.86175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.63375, "ci95": [ 0.59975, 0.6675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.49125, "ci95": [ 0.4569999999999999, 0.5270062500000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5740000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5377499999999998, 0.6115062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6525, "ci95": [ 0.6167437499999998, 0.6882562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.5489999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5217437500000005, 0.5764999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.6345000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6015, 0.66625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.8632499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8394999999999997, 0.8857562499999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8412499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.8207499999999998, 0.8609999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.64875, "ci95": [ 0.6147375, 0.6825000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.7614999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.7340000000000007, 0.7882562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.6202500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5874875, 0.652 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8124999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7864937499999997, 0.8367499999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8432499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.8179999999999998, 0.8675062499999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.6245, "ci95": [ 0.5915000000000002, 0.65700625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.4435, "ci95": [ 0.40624999999999994, 0.48100624999999986 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5515, "ci95": [ 0.5157375, 0.5862562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.63775, "ci95": [ 0.6022500000000001, 0.6727500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.60625, "ci95": [ 0.57325, 0.6372562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.85225, "ci95": [ 0.8255000000000001, 0.8762500000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.838, "ci95": [ 0.8187437499999998, 0.8559999999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.6235, "ci95": [ 0.58974375, 0.6559999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.7607500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7335000000000003, 0.7859999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.5972500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5657437499999999, 0.6277562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.80775, "ci95": [ 0.78174375, 0.83225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8347500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8090000000000004, 0.8582562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5997499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.56649375, 0.6317625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.38425000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.34999374999999994, 0.4204999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.49149999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.45548749999999993, 0.5252499999999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6024999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5684937500000001, 0.63725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.7635, "ci95": [ 0.7354999999999999, 0.7890062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8039999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7890000000000004, 0.8182562500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5464999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5304999999999999, 0.5622500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.7707500000000002, "ci95": [ 0.7559999999999998, 0.7852499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.4574999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.44325000000000003, 0.4722499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.785, "ci95": [ 0.7699937499999999, 0.80125625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7787499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.7605000000000001, 0.7975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.4734999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4579999999999999, 0.4894999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.28625, "ci95": [ 0.26875000000000016, 0.3055000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.37475, "ci95": [ 0.35625000000000007, 0.39500000000000013 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.44525000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.42424999999999996, 0.4662562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.5252500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5045000000000003, 0.5472499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.2555, "ci95": [ 0.22974999999999998, 0.2842499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.32575, "ci95": [ 0.2992437499999999, 0.35350000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.235, "ci95": [ 0.21125000000000005, 0.26050625000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.414, "ci95": [ 0.38475000000000015, 0.4445000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.4079999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.3775, 0.44074999999999986 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.24525, "ci95": [ 0.2210000000000001, 0.27125000000000016 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.1215, "ci95": [ 0.10774999999999998, 0.13550624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.195, "ci95": [ 0.16999375000000003, 0.22149999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.19599999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.17074374999999997, 0.22375624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.2085, "ci95": [ 0.19375000000000006, 0.22325625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.32199999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.30349374999999995, 0.34025625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.20350000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.18824999999999992, 0.21975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.38175, "ci95": [ 0.36549375, 0.3972562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.435, "ci95": [ 0.4204999999999999, 0.45099999999999985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.209, "ci95": [ 0.1935, 0.22550000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.1555, "ci95": [ 0.13925000000000007, 0.1722500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.21400000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.1935000000000001, 0.23526249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.20725000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.19074374999999996, 0.22400625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.7465, "ci95": [ 0.7289937499999999, 0.7639999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.42475, "ci95": [ 0.40699375, 0.4405125000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7635, "ci95": [ 0.7460000000000002, 0.7810000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7515, "ci95": [ 0.731, 0.7717500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.44475000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.4272500000000001, 0.46150000000000013 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.27875000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.25975000000000004, 0.2982499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.36524999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.34575, 0.3850062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.41325, "ci95": [ 0.3919937499999999, 0.4340062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.22550000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.21049374999999992, 0.24075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6345, "ci95": [ 0.6079937500000002, 0.6614999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6267499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6005, 0.6537562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.2395, "ci95": [ 0.22349999999999998, 0.25600000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.165, "ci95": [ 0.14949374999999998, 0.18075000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.2637500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.24650000000000002, 0.28174999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.256, "ci95": [ 0.23800000000000002, 0.2749999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.78625, "ci95": [ 0.7712437499999999, 0.8015000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.78175, "ci95": [ 0.7642500000000002, 0.7997499999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5174999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.50275, 0.5317500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.29450000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.2774937499999999, 0.31175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.39125, "ci95": [ 0.37249375, 0.41201250000000017 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.4645, "ci95": [ 0.44399374999999974, 0.4854999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.52475, "ci95": [ 0.5062499999999998, 0.5459999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.22699999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.21000000000000005, 0.24474999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.15175, "ci95": [ 0.13424999999999995, 0.16925000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.23700000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.21500000000000002, 0.2594999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.22674999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.20899375000000006, 0.24525624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.22625000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.20775000000000013, 0.24400624999999987 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.12675, "ci95": [ 0.11224999999999996, 0.141 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.217, "ci95": [ 0.19475, 0.23925625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.16574999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.15150000000000002, 0.17925000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.29900000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.2812437499999999, 0.31750000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.39549999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.37425000000000014, 0.41875 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.4695000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.4492499999999999, 0.48999999999999966 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.56825, "ci95": [ 0.5385000000000002, 0.5995124999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7607499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7417500000000002, 0.78 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.608, "ci95": [ 0.5854937499999998, 0.6302499999999999 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 116, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 6.7744875, 7.517500000000001 ], "rel2": [ 5.64298125, 6.233749999999998 ], "rel3": [ 5.782743749999998, 6.3077687499999975 ], "rel4": [ 6.275743749999998, 6.803249999999996 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 7.771712500000002, 8.221049999999998 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 11.845375, 12.453743750000005 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 12.09075, 12.467106249999999 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 8.103993749999995, 8.617775000000002 ], "release_s1001": [ 10.545000000000002, 10.876762500000007 ], "release_s1002": [ 7.520481249999995, 7.966756250000001 ], "release_s1003": [ 11.34271875, 11.773268750000003 ], "release_s1004": [ 11.616700000000002, 12.071018750000002 ], "robust_s1001": [ 7.625493750000003, 8.096281249999997 ], "robust_s1002": [ 5.114743749999998, 5.558012499999999 ], "robust_s1003": [ 6.536249999999998, 6.988031250000003 ], "robust_s1004": [ 7.4849687499999975, 7.916499999999997 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.4, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.2833333333333333, 0.45 ], "spearman": 0.4411764705882353, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.29411764705882354, 0.5588235294117647 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.1333333333333333, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.32173004757419954, 0.016666666666666663 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.9705 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5606743638663344, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.37657233394007533, 0.7395219099980958 ], "spearman": 0.7417220551086279, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.5125189652538963, 0.8754627141924796 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.29176680084112433, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.1801493188890302, 0.7483166834275761 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.1055 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.23333333333333334, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.1008227993974741, 0.32636268941473195 ], "spearman": 0.17647058823529413, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.029411764705882353, 0.35 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.2938679341827722, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.5276904380752401, -0.21053460084943887 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 84, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 64, "discordant_method_correct": 28, "discordant_base_correct": 36 } }, "agn_c8": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 11.594750000000003, "rel2": 10.453249999999999, "rel3": 9.744999999999997, "rel4": 9.4875, "nonoise_s1001": 5.7522499999999965, "nonoise_s1002": 12.514249999999999, "nonoise_s1003": 8.447750000000001, "nonoise_s1004": 5.474999999999997, "release_s1001": 9.283000000000001, "release_s1002": 5.434499999999999, "release_s1003": 9.420999999999998, "release_s1004": 10.78925, "robust_s1001": 5.684500000000002, "robust_s1002": 6.331749999999999, "robust_s1003": 8.084750000000001, "robust_s1004": 7.501500000000002 }, "order": [ "release_s1002", "nonoise_s1004", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1001", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "rel4", "rel3", "rel2", "release_s1004", "rel1", "nonoise_s1002" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.771, "rel2": 0.86, "rel3": 0.894, "rel4": 0.912, "nonoise_s1001": 0.903, "nonoise_s1002": 0.885, "nonoise_s1003": 0.897, "nonoise_s1004": 0.901, "release_s1001": 0.901, "release_s1002": 0.903, "release_s1003": 0.9, "release_s1004": 0.892, "robust_s1001": 0.903, "robust_s1002": 0.904, "robust_s1003": 0.87, "robust_s1004": 0.902 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.786, "rel2": 0.857, "rel3": 0.87, "rel4": 0.864, "nonoise_s1001": 0.86, "nonoise_s1002": 0.803, "nonoise_s1003": 0.852, "nonoise_s1004": 0.862, "release_s1001": 0.845, "release_s1002": 0.86, "release_s1003": 0.853, "release_s1004": 0.816, "robust_s1001": 0.858, "robust_s1002": 0.86, "robust_s1003": 0.783, "robust_s1004": 0.855 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.7785, "rel2": 0.8585, "rel3": 0.882, "rel4": 0.888, "nonoise_s1001": 0.8815, "nonoise_s1002": 0.844, "nonoise_s1003": 0.8745, "nonoise_s1004": 0.8815, "release_s1001": 0.873, "release_s1002": 0.8815, "release_s1003": 0.8765, "release_s1004": 0.854, "robust_s1001": 0.8805, "robust_s1002": 0.882, "robust_s1003": 0.8265, "robust_s1004": 0.8785 } }, "common_success_units": 1325, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 10.009886790221593, "rel2": 8.818943407490568, "rel3": 8.611094351714511, "rel4": 8.60641509946787, "nonoise_s1001": 8.144377353461284, "nonoise_s1002": 9.692150952816009, "nonoise_s1003": 8.497735860887563, "nonoise_s1004": 8.169132074410062, "release_s1001": 8.473207551353383, "release_s1002": 8.13154717265435, "release_s1003": 8.51471698351626, "release_s1004": 8.989735828885493, "robust_s1001": 8.151622636138269, "robust_s1002": 8.019999987719194, "robust_s1003": 8.47773585386996, "robust_s1004": 8.195622632728433 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.2075, "ci95": [ 0.18499999999999997, 0.23149999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.21175, "ci95": [ 0.18924374999999988, 0.23549999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.23099999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.20824374999999995, 0.25550625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.24849999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.23049374999999986, 0.2667499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.48699999999999993, "ci95": [ 0.45275000000000015, 0.52250625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.342, "ci95": [ 0.317, 0.36699999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.2415, "ci95": [ 0.22449999999999995, 0.25850625000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.33325000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.3089999999999999, 0.35850624999999986 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.23774999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.22150000000000006, 0.25475000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.34650000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.3194999999999999, 0.3735125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.4255, "ci95": [ 0.39524999999999993, 0.45600624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.24050000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.22375000000000003, 0.2579999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.23624999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.21425000000000005, 0.25925000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.32125, "ci95": [ 0.29674375, 0.34574999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.295, "ci95": [ 0.2695, 0.32100625000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.3035, "ci95": [ 0.27749375, 0.33074999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.3125, "ci95": [ 0.2854937499999999, 0.34099999999999986 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.25975000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.24149375000000003, 0.27899999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.5495000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.517, 0.5807500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.376, "ci95": [ 0.349, 0.4029999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.24325, "ci95": [ 0.2257500000000001, 0.2612499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.3814999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.3557500000000001, 0.41 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.24125000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.22475, 0.25850000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.387, "ci95": [ 0.35874375000000014, 0.41575625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.4902499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4594937500000001, 0.5205000000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.24600000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.22924374999999994, 0.26349999999999985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.262, "ci95": [ 0.2375, 0.28751250000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.3655, "ci95": [ 0.33975, 0.3917499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.33625, "ci95": [ 0.3082499999999999, 0.36476249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.40324999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.3787250000000001, 0.4292500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.27149999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.25225, 0.2917562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.5825, "ci95": [ 0.5512437500000001, 0.61150625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.3955, "ci95": [ 0.36750000000000016, 0.424 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.25125, "ci95": [ 0.23350000000000018, 0.2695000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.41175000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.3844999999999999, 0.44100625000000016 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.24949999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.2325000000000001, 0.26700000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.41225, "ci95": [ 0.3829937500000001, 0.44175000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5184999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.48800000000000004, 0.5487562499999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.25325, "ci95": [ 0.23599375000000003, 0.27075625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.28175, "ci95": [ 0.25499999999999995, 0.3084999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.3847499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.35999999999999993, 0.41050000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.3545, "ci95": [ 0.32724999999999993, 0.38324999999999987 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.27449999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.25350000000000006, 0.2952499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.591, "ci95": [ 0.5597500000000002, 0.6195062500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.4072500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.37950000000000017, 0.43475625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.24775000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.22949375000000002, 0.26650000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.4327500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.405, 0.4612624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.24599999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.22874999999999993, 0.2637499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.43174999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.40373125, 0.4614999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5272500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.4987437499999999, 0.5565 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.25125, "ci95": [ 0.23449374999999986, 0.26875000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.29325, "ci95": [ 0.2669937500000001, 0.3195 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.3905000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.36424375, 0.4177500000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.366, "ci95": [ 0.3397499999999999, 0.39375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.8825, "ci95": [ 0.8704999999999998, 0.8939999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.7482500000000002, "ci95": [ 0.7337500000000002, 0.7635000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.45199999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.4385, 0.4655062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.8369999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8207437499999998, 0.8522625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.43675000000000014, "ci95": [ 0.4197500000000002, 0.4555 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8227500000000002, "ci95": [ 0.8092499999999998, 0.8375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8274999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8134999999999999, 0.8415062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.47100000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.45225000000000015, 0.49200000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.572, "ci95": [ 0.5527437499999999, 0.5902499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6107500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5837499999999999, 0.6390062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6415000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6262500000000001, 0.6579999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.135, "ci95": [ 0.12300000000000004, 0.14725000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.11975, "ci95": [ 0.10799375000000003, 0.13200000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.17925000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.1617500000000001, 0.20024999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.12099999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.10899999999999994, 0.13374999999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.15750000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.14500000000000005, 0.17075625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.21474999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.18699999999999994, 0.24724999999999983 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.13274999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.11650000000000006, 0.1537562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.13075, "ci95": [ 0.11750000000000003, 0.14525625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.2565, "ci95": [ 0.22899374999999997, 0.28525625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.131, "ci95": [ 0.11749374999999995, 0.14650000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.2535, "ci95": [ 0.2375000000000001, 0.26875625000000025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.5295, "ci95": [ 0.5059999999999999, 0.5539999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.2587500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.24025000000000002, 0.2780062500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.59675, "ci95": [ 0.5765000000000001, 0.6175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.752, "ci95": [ 0.736, 0.7677499999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.27075, "ci95": [ 0.25025000000000025, 0.29125625000000016 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.35325, "ci95": [ 0.3295, 0.3760062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.48975, "ci95": [ 0.4539937499999998, 0.5262499999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.452, "ci95": [ 0.43225000000000013, 0.47275000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.8327500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8179937499999999, 0.8472562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.4977500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.4829937499999998, 0.5135 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8207499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8067437499999995, 0.8352500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8224999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8089937499999995, 0.8367499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.52525, "ci95": [ 0.5102499999999999, 0.5414999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.581, "ci95": [ 0.5635000000000001, 0.5985062500000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.615, "ci95": [ 0.5879999999999999, 0.6429999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6389999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.622, 0.65625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.16224999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.1474999999999999, 0.17699999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.5985, "ci95": [ 0.5762437499999996, 0.6197499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6725, "ci95": [ 0.64375, 0.6999999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.17800000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.15824999999999997, 0.20275625000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.27074999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.24674999999999997, 0.29425625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.41674999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.37699374999999985, 0.45699999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.3559999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.33124999999999993, 0.38125625000000013 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8172499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7994999999999999, 0.8340000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8184999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7997499999999996, 0.8365062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.529, "ci95": [ 0.5092437499999999, 0.5480000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.584, "ci95": [ 0.5664937499999997, 0.60175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.62025, "ci95": [ 0.595, 0.6452500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6475, "ci95": [ 0.62875, 0.6659999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6752499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6477499999999999, 0.7017562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.2025, "ci95": [ 0.18299374999999998, 0.22375000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.27925000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.25399999999999984, 0.30399999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.4457500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.4092312500000001, 0.4842500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.36725, "ci95": [ 0.343, 0.3925000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.18725000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.17075000000000007, 0.205 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.2035, "ci95": [ 0.18324374999999993, 0.22399999999999984 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.3705, "ci95": [ 0.33524374999999984, 0.4077499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.19400000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.17724375, 0.21400000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5705, "ci95": [ 0.5480000000000002, 0.59125625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6085, "ci95": [ 0.5804937500000001, 0.6370062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6240000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6034999999999999, 0.6437499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.627, "ci95": [ 0.58749375, 0.6655187499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6595, "ci95": [ 0.6369937499999996, 0.6810062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.43799999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.4012437499999999, 0.4747499999999999 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 114, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 11.285243750000003, 11.896249999999998 ], "rel2": [ 10.178249999999998, 10.72875625 ], "rel3": [ 9.501187499999991, 9.985287499999995 ], "rel4": [ 9.25725, 9.724037499999998 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 5.620999999999999, 5.8805124999999965 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 12.276975, 12.732625000000004 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 8.229456249999997, 8.664000000000001 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 5.323243749999998, 5.625518749999999 ], "release_s1001": [ 9.092487499999999, 9.481024999999999 ], "release_s1002": [ 5.2905000000000015, 5.591756250000001 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.23046875, 9.599268749999998 ], "release_s1004": [ 10.555468749999996, 11.029081249999997 ], "robust_s1001": [ 5.5109875, 5.882256249999998 ], "robust_s1002": [ 6.124718750000001, 6.555256250000001 ], "robust_s1003": [ 7.698468750000001, 8.487293750000003 ], "robust_s1004": [ 7.321431249999997, 7.679781250000004 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5333333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.4666666666666667, 0.6166666666666667 ], "spearman": 0.7705882352941177, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7, 0.8235445668902722 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.0, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.04421734172501113, 0.08967504367590451 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.2545 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.37657233394007533, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.0, 0.683599072781475 ], "spearman": 0.47240630890847135, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.025001334777381132, 0.8496035070583748 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.10766477091486526, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.007594432121020382, 0.14453747030212794 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.015 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.48333333333333334, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.4166666666666667, 0.6 ], "spearman": 0.7235294117647059, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6352941176470588, 0.8117647058823529 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.043867934182772184, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.17812540769416363, 0.02294024253850132 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.9205 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 92, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 8, "discordant_method_correct": 4, "discordant_base_correct": 4 } }, "agn_c8_loop": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 8.168999999999997, "rel2": 7.360250000000002, "rel3": 7.368, "rel4": 7.638749999999999, "nonoise_s1001": 7.460750000000002, "nonoise_s1002": 11.788749999999995, "nonoise_s1003": 10.981249999999998, "nonoise_s1004": 7.403749999999999, "release_s1001": 9.74475, "release_s1002": 7.093250000000003, "release_s1003": 10.571000000000002, "release_s1004": 11.406749999999997, "robust_s1001": 7.166500000000001, "robust_s1002": 6.339750000000001, "robust_s1003": 7.598999999999995, "robust_s1004": 7.908500000000001 }, "order": [ "robust_s1002", "release_s1002", "robust_s1001", "rel2", "rel3", "nonoise_s1004", "nonoise_s1001", "robust_s1003", "rel4", "robust_s1004", "rel1", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1004", "nonoise_s1002" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.726, "rel2": 0.822, "rel3": 0.829, "rel4": 0.828, "nonoise_s1001": 0.707, "nonoise_s1002": 0.559, "nonoise_s1003": 0.514, "nonoise_s1004": 0.693, "release_s1001": 0.629, "release_s1002": 0.731, "release_s1003": 0.575, "release_s1004": 0.566, "robust_s1001": 0.718, "robust_s1002": 0.809, "robust_s1003": 0.747, "robust_s1004": 0.766 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.797, "rel2": 0.845, "rel3": 0.79, "rel4": 0.751, "nonoise_s1001": 0.596, "nonoise_s1002": 0.47, "nonoise_s1003": 0.427, "nonoise_s1004": 0.595, "release_s1001": 0.521, "release_s1002": 0.583, "release_s1003": 0.472, "release_s1004": 0.463, "robust_s1001": 0.589, "robust_s1002": 0.717, "robust_s1003": 0.684, "robust_s1004": 0.666 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.7615, "rel2": 0.8335, "rel3": 0.8095, "rel4": 0.7895, "nonoise_s1001": 0.6515, "nonoise_s1002": 0.5145, "nonoise_s1003": 0.4705, "nonoise_s1004": 0.644, "release_s1001": 0.575, "release_s1002": 0.657, "release_s1003": 0.5235, "release_s1004": 0.5145, "robust_s1001": 0.6535, "robust_s1002": 0.763, "robust_s1003": 0.7155, "robust_s1004": 0.716 } }, "common_success_units": 508, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 16.996259875654236, "rel2": 14.909645665348984, "rel3": 14.365551168993703, "rel4": 14.26555119114598, "nonoise_s1001": 13.815354332679838, "nonoise_s1002": 16.534645683652773, "nonoise_s1003": 16.852362196276506, "nonoise_s1004": 13.910433096679176, "release_s1001": 14.484448810262004, "release_s1002": 13.756889799917777, "release_s1003": 15.249606318830505, "release_s1004": 15.88956692462831, "robust_s1001": 13.71771656434367, "robust_s1002": 13.69192911555448, "robust_s1003": 14.635433083913458, "robust_s1004": 14.014566925566966 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.34600000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.3235, 0.36750624999999987 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.38975000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.36624375000000003, 0.4112562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.418, "ci95": [ 0.3937437499999999, 0.43975000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.5032499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.47525000000000006, 0.5287499999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.6837499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6537437499999998, 0.7155000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.65825, "ci95": [ 0.6322437500000003, 0.6832500000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5102499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4819999999999999, 0.5362499999999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.57725, "ci95": [ 0.554, 0.5997625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.4902499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.46175000000000016, 0.5159999999999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.63175, "ci95": [ 0.6057437499999998, 0.6577625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6692499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.6377437499999999, 0.7004999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.4815, "ci95": [ 0.45525000000000004, 0.50625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.43449999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.4099937499999999, 0.45925624999999987 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.50825, "ci95": [ 0.4807499999999999, 0.5350062499999997 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.529, "ci95": [ 0.5037499999999997, 0.5545125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.44150000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.41899999999999993, 0.4629999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.48225, "ci95": [ 0.45775, 0.5060062499999997 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.5260000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.49824999999999997, 0.55250625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.7397499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7125000000000001, 0.7669999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.69625, "ci95": [ 0.6714937500000002, 0.72125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5262499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4977437500000001, 0.5529999999999997 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.62275, "ci95": [ 0.5979937499999999, 0.6477499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.504, "ci95": [ 0.4747500000000002, 0.5317624999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6732499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6447499999999999, 0.7022562499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7275, "ci95": [ 0.6997437499999998, 0.7560062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.49725, "ci95": [ 0.4692500000000001, 0.5239999999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.4535, "ci95": [ 0.4294937500000001, 0.4770000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5365, "ci95": [ 0.5077375000000001, 0.5635000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.5589999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5327500000000001, 0.586 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.49674999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.4742437499999999, 0.5197499999999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.5149999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.48924374999999976, 0.53975625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.75725, "ci95": [ 0.7297374999999999, 0.7842562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.6995000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.67449375, 0.7252499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.51275, "ci95": [ 0.48549374999999984, 0.5385062500000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.625, "ci95": [ 0.6015000000000001, 0.6480062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.48950000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.46224999999999966, 0.5162562499999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6789999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6524937499999998, 0.7065124999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7297499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7029937499999998, 0.7577499999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.48474999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.46024375, 0.5082562500000003 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.41850000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.39599375, 0.44050625000000015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.50675, "ci95": [ 0.47875, 0.53325 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.54875, "ci95": [ 0.5237499999999998, 0.5747562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.4980000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.47225000000000006, 0.5225 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.758, "ci95": [ 0.7315000000000002, 0.7852625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.69325, "ci95": [ 0.6685, 0.7184999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.493, "ci95": [ 0.46649375000000015, 0.51800625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.62075, "ci95": [ 0.5984937499999999, 0.64475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.46974999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.4427499999999999, 0.49575625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6742499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.6469937499999999, 0.70125625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.718, "ci95": [ 0.6904937500000002, 0.7454999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.4684999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.44299999999999995, 0.49274999999999985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.376, "ci95": [ 0.3545, 0.3967499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.46775000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.4405000000000001, 0.49375625000000023 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.5209999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4952500000000002, 0.5480000000000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.7630000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.745, 0.7817499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.7629999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.7469937499999999, 0.7805000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.4765, "ci95": [ 0.4590000000000001, 0.49400000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.74075, "ci95": [ 0.7247500000000002, 0.7574999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.42999999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.41525, 0.4442499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7627499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7464999999999999, 0.7794999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7622500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7452500000000001, 0.7792500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.45549999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.4370000000000002, 0.47375625000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.42550000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.4069999999999998, 0.44399999999999973 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.469, "ci95": [ 0.4484937500000003, 0.4877562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.53325, "ci95": [ 0.5152500000000001, 0.5499999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.43799999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.41824999999999996, 0.45925000000000016 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.24975000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.23125000000000004, 0.2680000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.30875, "ci95": [ 0.2880000000000001, 0.3287562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.2385, "ci95": [ 0.21999375000000004, 0.25700000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.37300000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.34924999999999984, 0.39749999999999985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.40725, "ci95": [ 0.38249374999999997, 0.435 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.24349999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.22425, 0.26425 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.17625, "ci95": [ 0.15999999999999998, 0.19250625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.26425, "ci95": [ 0.23975, 0.28924999999999984 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.21375000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.19624374999999994, 0.23174999999999982 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.23774999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.22175, 0.25375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.35949999999999993, "ci95": [ 0.33875, 0.38 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.23724999999999993, "ci95": [ 0.21824999999999994, 0.25450624999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.43499999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.41700000000000015, 0.45299999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.545, "ci95": [ 0.5277500000000002, 0.56125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.24974999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.22949374999999997, 0.2702625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.2655, "ci95": [ 0.24424374999999993, 0.2862499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.325, "ci95": [ 0.29525000000000007, 0.35450625000000024 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.31225, "ci95": [ 0.2887500000000001, 0.33475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.73225, "ci95": [ 0.7167500000000001, 0.7477499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.47225, "ci95": [ 0.4572437500000001, 0.48699999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.758, "ci95": [ 0.7427437499999998, 0.7740062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.74775, "ci95": [ 0.7310000000000002, 0.7649999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.4842500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.46774374999999985, 0.5005000000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.42950000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.4119999999999998, 0.4467499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.46725, "ci95": [ 0.44950000000000023, 0.48550000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.51125, "ci95": [ 0.4924875, 0.52825 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.26125, "ci95": [ 0.2445000000000001, 0.2785 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.62375, "ci95": [ 0.6022437499999999, 0.647 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6594999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.63725, 0.6825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.26825000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.24974999999999986, 0.28799999999999987 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.29525, "ci95": [ 0.273, 0.31775625000000013 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.37050000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.3440000000000002, 0.39625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.3637500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.3447437499999999, 0.3824999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7637499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.7472500000000005, 0.7815062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7625, "ci95": [ 0.7459937500000001, 0.78 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.508, "ci95": [ 0.4912437499999998, 0.5230062500000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.43875, "ci95": [ 0.41950000000000004, 0.45724999999999966 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.48124999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.4614999999999999, 0.5012500000000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.54525, "ci95": [ 0.52775, 0.5632499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.60625, "ci95": [ 0.58599375, 0.62650625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.253, "ci95": [ 0.23325000000000004, 0.2742499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.26150000000000007, "ci95": [ 0.24050000000000016, 0.28300000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.35050000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.32249375000000013, 0.3787499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.33225, "ci95": [ 0.3077500000000001, 0.35700000000000015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.2395, "ci95": [ 0.22074999999999995, 0.2584999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.18450000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.1674937499999999, 0.20174999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.31225, "ci95": [ 0.28225000000000006, 0.34075625000000015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.192, "ci95": [ 0.17699374999999998, 0.20625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.44175, "ci95": [ 0.4239999999999998, 0.4600000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.48524999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.4677437499999999, 0.503 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.5402500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.52424375, 0.5562562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5784999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5557437499999999, 0.6009999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6827500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6650000000000003, 0.7007499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.524, "ci95": [ 0.4995000000000001, 0.5465 ], "resolved": false } ], "resolved_pairs": 95, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 7.893968749999996, 8.449062499999995 ], "rel2": [ 7.098250000000002, 7.613018749999998 ], "rel3": [ 7.144468749999996, 7.594262499999999 ], "rel4": [ 7.424456249999995, 7.863768749999997 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 7.26346875, 7.647787500000002 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 11.537499999999998, 12.038518750000001 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 10.753237500000003, 11.217287500000001 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 7.191993749999999, 7.611756250000001 ], "release_s1001": [ 9.5841375, 9.912331250000001 ], "release_s1002": [ 6.889000000000005, 7.294506250000003 ], "release_s1003": [ 10.352243750000001, 10.789518750000001 ], "release_s1004": [ 11.185718750000003, 11.639512499999999 ], "robust_s1001": [ 6.966974999999997, 7.36554375 ], "robust_s1002": [ 6.186993750000003, 6.499581249999999 ], "robust_s1003": [ 7.334725000000002, 7.8665375000000015 ], "robust_s1004": [ 7.763456250000003, 8.060793750000002 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.48333333333333334, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.3333333333333333, 0.6333333333333333 ], "spearman": 0.6411764705882353, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.4998529411764706, 0.7941176470588235 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.04999999999999999, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.21666666666666662, 0.14999999999999997 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.588 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.4937281711658766, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.3024168928365613, 0.7004780622328695 ], "spearman": 0.693156920547944, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.4542559253336979, 0.8643154706199015 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.2248206081406665, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.04021583070129005, 0.4370500769031214 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.0105 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.1, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.0, 0.25 ], "spearman": 0.1323529411764706, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.03235294117647059, 0.35 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.42720126751610554, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.6160884230455154, -0.31074249833707107 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 89, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 39, "discordant_method_correct": 18, "discordant_base_correct": 21 } }, "calib_wb_loop": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 14.575, "rel2": 12.675, "rel3": 11.14, "rel4": 10.44, "nonoise_s1001": 4.06, "nonoise_s1002": 13.27, "nonoise_s1003": 11.975, "nonoise_s1004": 4.63, "release_s1001": 8.885, "release_s1002": 3.705, "release_s1003": 11.175, "release_s1004": 10.405, "robust_s1001": 4.01, "robust_s1002": 3.475, "robust_s1003": 7.375, "robust_s1004": 4.205 }, "order": [ "robust_s1002", "release_s1002", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1001", "robust_s1004", "nonoise_s1004", "robust_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1004", "rel4", "rel3", "release_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "rel2", "nonoise_s1002", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.42, "rel2": 0.64, "rel3": 0.92, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 0.98, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 0.9, "release_s1004": 0.92, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.78, "rel2": 0.98, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 0.92, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.6, "rel2": 0.81, "rel3": 0.96, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 0.95, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 0.95, "release_s1004": 0.96, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 52, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 10.8692307472229, "rel2": 8.103846210699816, "rel3": 7.813461523789626, "rel4": 7.7115384707084065, "nonoise_s1001": 7.1615384587874775, "nonoise_s1002": 8.346153882833628, "nonoise_s1003": 7.938461560469407, "nonoise_s1004": 7.159615337848663, "release_s1001": 7.561538421190702, "release_s1002": 7.198076940499819, "release_s1003": 8.001923088844006, "release_s1004": 7.911538463372451, "robust_s1001": 7.1615384221076965, "robust_s1002": 7.136538500969227, "robust_s1003": 7.423076927661896, "robust_s1004": 7.186538489965292 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.13, "ci95": [ 0.095, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.055, "ci95": [ 0.025, 0.085 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.06, "ci95": [ 0.03, 0.095 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.32, "ci95": [ 0.24, 0.41 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.275, "ci95": [ 0.195, 0.36 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.265, "ci95": [ 0.185, 0.355 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.24, "ci95": [ 0.16, 0.33 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.07 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.16, "ci95": [ 0.115, 0.205 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.15, "ci95": [ 0.105, 0.2 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.49, "ci95": [ 0.41, 0.56 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.48, "ci95": [ 0.39, 0.56 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.21, "ci95": [ 0.145, 0.275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.48, "ci95": [ 0.39, 0.57 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.405, "ci95": [ 0.319875, 0.5 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.08, "ci95": [ 0.035, 0.13 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.26, "ci95": [ 0.205, 0.32 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.67, "ci95": [ 0.59, 0.755 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.59, "ci95": [ 0.5, 0.68 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.28, "ci95": [ 0.21, 0.355 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.605, "ci95": [ 0.515, 0.69 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.545, "ci95": [ 0.455, 0.64 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.125, "ci95": [ 0.07, 0.18 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.75, "ci95": [ 0.67, 0.83 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.615, "ci95": [ 0.53, 0.695 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.33, "ci95": [ 0.26, 0.4 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.03 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.65, "ci95": [ 0.57, 0.725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.565, "ci95": [ 0.475, 0.66 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.11, "ci95": [ 0.06, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.995, "ci95": [ 0.985, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.58, "ci95": [ 0.525, 0.63 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.89, "ci95": [ 0.845, 0.93 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.435, "ci95": [ 0.395, 0.475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.905, "ci95": [ 0.865, 0.945 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.89, "ci95": [ 0.85, 0.925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.485, "ci95": [ 0.44, 0.53 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.39, "ci95": [ 0.335, 0.44 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.855, "ci95": [ 0.81, 0.895 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.515, "ci95": [ 0.465, 0.565 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.305, "ci95": [ 0.22, 0.39 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.295, "ci95": [ 0.215, 0.3801249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.28, "ci95": [ 0.2, 0.365 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.03 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.23, "ci95": [ 0.165, 0.3 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.43, "ci95": [ 0.34, 0.52 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.43, "ci95": [ 0.345, 0.515 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04512499999999932 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.035 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.135, "ci95": [ 0.075, 0.2 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.87, "ci95": [ 0.82, 0.915 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.36, "ci95": [ 0.3, 0.42 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.865, "ci95": [ 0.81, 0.92 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.845, "ci95": [ 0.79, 0.895 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.415, "ci95": [ 0.37, 0.46012499999999934 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.32, "ci95": [ 0.26, 0.38 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.835, "ci95": [ 0.785, 0.88 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.445, "ci95": [ 0.385, 0.51 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.105, "ci95": [ 0.07, 0.14 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.695, "ci95": [ 0.62, 0.775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.56, "ci95": [ 0.47, 0.655 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.11, "ci95": [ 0.075, 0.15 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.155, "ci95": [ 0.1, 0.215 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.23, "ci95": [ 0.165, 0.3 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.135, "ci95": [ 0.08987500000000001, 0.185 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9, "ci95": [ 0.86, 0.94 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.905, "ci95": [ 0.865, 0.94 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.545, "ci95": [ 0.495, 0.595 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.44, "ci95": [ 0.385, 0.495 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.86, "ci95": [ 0.815, 0.905 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.575, "ci95": [ 0.534875, 0.62 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.37, "ci95": [ 0.295, 0.45 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.11, "ci95": [ 0.065, 0.16 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.1, "ci95": [ 0.06, 0.14 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.245, "ci95": [ 0.17, 0.325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.09, "ci95": [ 0.055, 0.13 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.115, "ci95": [ 0.075, 0.155 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.085, "ci95": [ 0.05487500000000001, 0.12 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.34, "ci95": [ 0.25, 0.435 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.09, "ci95": [ 0.06, 0.125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.405, "ci95": [ 0.34, 0.465 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.85, "ci95": [ 0.805, 0.895 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.535, "ci95": [ 0.48, 0.595 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.825, "ci95": [ 0.77, 0.875 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.625, "ci95": [ 0.58, 0.67 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.19, "ci95": [ 0.14, 0.245 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 105, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 14.19, 14.935 ], "rel2": [ 12.275, 13.065 ], "rel3": [ 10.819875, 11.475 ], "rel4": [ 10.185, 10.73 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.8598749999999997, 4.26 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 12.875, 13.665 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 11.534875, 12.385 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 4.34, 4.92 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.335, 9.425125 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.46, 3.9751249999999994 ], "release_s1003": [ 10.445, 11.895124999999998 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.689874999999999, 11.190124999999998 ], "robust_s1001": [ 3.74, 4.305124999999999 ], "robust_s1002": [ 3.164875, 3.765 ], "robust_s1003": [ 6.875, 7.88 ], "robust_s1004": [ 3.955, 4.445 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.75, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.65, 0.85 ], "spearman": 0.9, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.8388368984771871, 0.95 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.21666666666666667, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.16734801137403268, 0.2845644695175224 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.0 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.4937281711658766, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.10168788482499157, 0.7783310680153018 ], "spearman": 0.48123633337405025, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.07658329365862818, 0.9050775077218377 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.2248206081406665, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.09141546830221221, 0.2434006837071303 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.001 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.7, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5833333333333334, 0.7833333333333333 ], "spearman": 0.8764705882352941, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7823529411764706, 0.9139075321874166 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.17279873248389443, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.04415863470666746, 0.23967504367590453 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.072 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 105, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 17, "discordant_method_correct": 15, "discordant_base_correct": 2 } }, "delay_1": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 13.355, "rel2": 11.66, "rel3": 10.9, "rel4": 11.365, "nonoise_s1001": 5.365, "nonoise_s1002": 14.615, "nonoise_s1003": 10.17, "nonoise_s1004": 7.11, "release_s1001": 10.205, "release_s1002": 4.35, "release_s1003": 11.73, "release_s1004": 11.78, "robust_s1001": 4.815, "robust_s1002": 2.235, "robust_s1003": 2.92, "robust_s1004": 3.425 }, "order": [ "robust_s1002", "robust_s1003", "robust_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "rel3", "rel4", "rel2", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "rel1", "nonoise_s1002" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.9, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.95, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 95, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 5.7831579082890565, "rel2": 5.394736859672948, "rel3": 5.282105257636623, "rel4": 5.277894735336304, "nonoise_s1001": 4.921052629069278, "nonoise_s1002": 5.717894704718339, "nonoise_s1003": 5.128421033056159, "nonoise_s1004": 4.9736842205649925, "release_s1001": 5.141052630073146, "release_s1002": 4.890526312275937, "release_s1003": 5.22105262404994, "release_s1004": 5.299999982432316, "robust_s1001": 4.910526330847489, "robust_s1002": 4.757894724293759, "robust_s1003": 4.810526303241128, "robust_s1004": 4.827368445145456 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.12, "ci95": [ 0.08, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.14, "ci95": [ 0.095, 0.19 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.23, "ci95": [ 0.165, 0.3 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.075, "ci95": [ 0.045, 0.115 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.555, "ci95": [ 0.485, 0.6251249999999993 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.29, "ci95": [ 0.22, 0.355 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.135, "ci95": [ 0.085, 0.185 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.28, "ci95": [ 0.21, 0.345 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.07 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.34, "ci95": [ 0.27, 0.405 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.34, "ci95": [ 0.275, 0.4 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.075, "ci95": [ 0.04, 0.115 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.025, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.045 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.27, "ci95": [ 0.215, 0.325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.37, "ci95": [ 0.305, 0.43 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.14, "ci95": [ 0.09, 0.19 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.66, "ci95": [ 0.585, 0.735 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.355, "ci95": [ 0.295, 0.415 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.205, "ci95": [ 0.145, 0.26 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.355, "ci95": [ 0.295, 0.415 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.09, "ci95": [ 0.05, 0.135 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.43, "ci95": [ 0.37, 0.485 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.42, "ci95": [ 0.359875, 0.48 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.125, "ci95": [ 0.075, 0.175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.07 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.49, "ci95": [ 0.434875, 0.545 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.125, "ci95": [ 0.085, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.73, "ci95": [ 0.66, 0.795 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.395, "ci95": [ 0.34, 0.445 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.22, "ci95": [ 0.165, 0.275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.39, "ci95": [ 0.335, 0.4401249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.07, "ci95": [ 0.04, 0.1 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.49, "ci95": [ 0.43, 0.545 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.465, "ci95": [ 0.405, 0.525 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.105, "ci95": [ 0.065, 0.15 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.055 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.06 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.75, "ci95": [ 0.68, 0.82 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.4, "ci95": [ 0.345, 0.455 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.125, "ci95": [ 0.085, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.4, "ci95": [ 0.345, 0.45 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.51, "ci95": [ 0.455, 0.57 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.48, "ci95": [ 0.425, 0.535 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.025, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.04512499999999932 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.985, "ci95": [ 0.965, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.76, "ci95": [ 0.715, 0.81 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.975, "ci95": [ 0.95, 0.995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.34, "ci95": [ 0.29, 0.38512499999999933 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.995, "ci95": [ 0.985, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.99, "ci95": [ 0.975, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.405, "ci95": [ 0.355, 0.455 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.13, "ci95": [ 0.09, 0.175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.195, "ci95": [ 0.14, 0.25 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.235, "ci95": [ 0.19, 0.285 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.03 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.08, "ci95": [ 0.05, 0.115 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.495, "ci95": [ 0.435, 0.555 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.82, "ci95": [ 0.78, 0.865 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.785, "ci95": [ 0.745, 0.825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.06 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.945, "ci95": [ 0.915, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.095, "ci95": [ 0.055, 0.135 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.98, "ci95": [ 0.96, 0.995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.96, "ci95": [ 0.935, 0.985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.155, "ci95": [ 0.11, 0.205 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.075, "ci95": [ 0.035, 0.115 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.09, "ci95": [ 0.05, 0.13512499999999933 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.115, "ci95": [ 0.075, 0.16 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.795, "ci95": [ 0.744875, 0.845 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.775, "ci95": [ 0.725, 0.825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.045 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.99, "ci95": [ 0.97, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.98, "ci95": [ 0.95, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.57, "ci95": [ 0.53, 0.61 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.18, "ci95": [ 0.14, 0.22 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.27, "ci95": [ 0.215, 0.325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.325, "ci95": [ 0.275, 0.375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.595, "ci95": [ 0.535, 0.655 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.18, "ci95": [ 0.135, 0.225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.23, "ci95": [ 0.175, 0.29 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.3, "ci95": [ 0.25, 0.355 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.585, "ci95": [ 0.535, 0.64 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.77, "ci95": [ 0.725, 0.815 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.595, "ci95": [ 0.52, 0.665 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 113, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 12.859874999999999, 13.850249999999999 ], "rel2": [ 11.194875, 12.145124999999998 ], "rel3": [ 10.565, 11.245 ], "rel4": [ 11.105, 11.62 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 5.11, 5.63 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 14.344875, 14.885 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 9.865, 10.445 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 6.82, 7.405125 ], "release_s1001": [ 9.939874999999999, 10.47 ], "release_s1002": [ 4.125, 4.595 ], "release_s1003": [ 11.46, 12.005 ], "release_s1004": [ 11.444875, 12.11 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.51, 5.145 ], "robust_s1002": [ 2.034875, 2.445 ], "robust_s1003": [ 2.615, 3.2501249999999993 ], "robust_s1004": [ 3.164875, 3.715124999999999 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.7833333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.6945667492672501, 0.8333333333333334 ], "spearman": 0.9117647058823529, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.8558823529411764, 0.9382352941176471 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.25, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.10625280915204795, 0.3396750436759045 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.0 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.33613445378151263, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.051298917604257706, 0.6276205565667923 ], "spearman": 0.43151693667157587, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.03621673721338326, 0.8159290973141666 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.06722689075630256, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.09403933110535191, 0.2760346161872871 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.285 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.65, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.55, 0.75 ], "spearman": 0.8, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7269919786802289, 0.8903811920369318 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.1227987324838945, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.061233415933916846, 0.20627182883412337 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.1465 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 107, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 25, "discordant_method_correct": 20, "discordant_base_correct": 5 } }, "delay_2": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 9.22, "rel2": 7.27, "rel3": 6.97, "rel4": 7.175, "nonoise_s1001": 7.31, "nonoise_s1002": 15.275, "nonoise_s1003": 11.475, "nonoise_s1004": 7.945, "release_s1001": 11.86, "release_s1002": 6.55, "release_s1003": 12.88, "release_s1004": 13.1, "robust_s1001": 7.71, "robust_s1002": 2.1, "robust_s1003": 1.87, "robust_s1004": 7.29 }, "order": [ "robust_s1003", "robust_s1002", "release_s1002", "rel3", "rel4", "rel2", "robust_s1004", "nonoise_s1001", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "rel1", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "nonoise_s1002" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 100, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 6.5690000224113465, "rel2": 5.468999991416931, "rel3": 5.444000005722046, "rel4": 5.525000009536743, "nonoise_s1001": 5.487999997138977, "nonoise_s1002": 6.423000016212463, "nonoise_s1003": 5.727000029087066, "nonoise_s1004": 5.50799998998642, "release_s1001": 5.759999992847443, "release_s1002": 5.46, "release_s1003": 5.828999981880188, "release_s1004": 5.8990000009536745, "robust_s1001": 5.515999991893768, "robust_s1002": 4.976000010967255, "robust_s1003": 4.954000012874603, "robust_s1004": 5.483000025749207 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.18, "ci95": [ 0.13, 0.235 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.335, "ci95": [ 0.26, 0.41 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.415, "ci95": [ 0.345, 0.48 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.47, "ci95": [ 0.395, 0.545 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.69, "ci95": [ 0.61, 0.77 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.615, "ci95": [ 0.53, 0.7 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.495, "ci95": [ 0.42, 0.57 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.605, "ci95": [ 0.52, 0.69 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.455, "ci95": [ 0.38, 0.53 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.63, "ci95": [ 0.54, 0.715 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.64, "ci95": [ 0.55, 0.72 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.48, "ci95": [ 0.405, 0.55 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.17, "ci95": [ 0.105, 0.235 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.145, "ci95": [ 0.085, 0.21 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.455, "ci95": [ 0.38, 0.53 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.45, "ci95": [ 0.385, 0.51 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.515, "ci95": [ 0.46, 0.57 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.565, "ci95": [ 0.49, 0.64 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.86, "ci95": [ 0.79, 0.92 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.695, "ci95": [ 0.615, 0.775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.59, "ci95": [ 0.51, 0.665 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.7, "ci95": [ 0.624875, 0.775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.555, "ci95": [ 0.479875, 0.63 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.755, "ci95": [ 0.68, 0.825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.74, "ci95": [ 0.66, 0.815 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.57, "ci95": [ 0.49, 0.645 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.195, "ci95": [ 0.13, 0.26 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.17, "ci95": [ 0.11, 0.235 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.55, "ci95": [ 0.475, 0.625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.625, "ci95": [ 0.575, 0.6751249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.61, "ci95": [ 0.53, 0.685 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.89, "ci95": [ 0.83, 0.94 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.76, "ci95": [ 0.685, 0.8301249999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.65, "ci95": [ 0.575, 0.725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.785, "ci95": [ 0.705, 0.855 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.6, "ci95": [ 0.52, 0.675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.825, "ci95": [ 0.75, 0.89 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.82, "ci95": [ 0.75, 0.885 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.61, "ci95": [ 0.53, 0.685 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6, "ci95": [ 0.52, 0.68 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.63, "ci95": [ 0.549875, 0.71 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.915, "ci95": [ 0.855, 0.965 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.76, "ci95": [ 0.68, 0.8351249999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.665, "ci95": [ 0.585, 0.745 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.82, "ci95": [ 0.75, 0.885 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.625, "ci95": [ 0.545, 0.705 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.845, "ci95": [ 0.77, 0.91 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.86, "ci95": [ 0.794875, 0.92 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.64, "ci95": [ 0.56, 0.72 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.62, "ci95": [ 0.54, 0.705 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.965, "ci95": [ 0.94, 0.985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.605, "ci95": [ 0.55, 0.66 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.99, "ci95": [ 0.975, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.355, "ci95": [ 0.299875, 0.41 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.985, "ci95": [ 0.965, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.98, "ci95": [ 0.955, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.555, "ci95": [ 0.505, 0.6 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.49, "ci95": [ 0.43, 0.55 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.03 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.045 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.03 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.06, "ci95": [ 0.03, 0.09 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.53, "ci95": [ 0.445, 0.61 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.77, "ci95": [ 0.7098749999999999, 0.83 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.825, "ci95": [ 0.765, 0.88 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.06, "ci95": [ 0.025, 0.105 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.965, "ci95": [ 0.94, 0.985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.27, "ci95": [ 0.215, 0.33 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.985, "ci95": [ 0.965, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.98, "ci95": [ 0.96, 0.995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.48, "ci95": [ 0.425, 0.54 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.025, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.395, "ci95": [ 0.33, 0.46 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.745, "ci95": [ 0.675, 0.815 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.73, "ci95": [ 0.66, 0.795 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.065 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.055 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.975, "ci95": [ 0.9448749999999999, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.97, "ci95": [ 0.935, 0.995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.71, "ci95": [ 0.655, 0.765 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.065 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.02, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.64, "ci95": [ 0.58, 0.695 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.585, "ci95": [ 0.515, 0.655 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.06 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.045 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.045 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.03 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.045 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.025, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.44, "ci95": [ 0.379875, 0.5 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.41, "ci95": [ 0.34, 0.49 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.995, "ci95": [ 0.985, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.98, "ci95": [ 0.9548749999999999, 1.0 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 105, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 8.334875, 10.070124999999999 ], "rel2": [ 6.515, 8.02525 ], "rel3": [ 6.354875000000001, 7.600124999999999 ], "rel4": [ 6.59, 7.775125 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 6.97, 7.655 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 14.985, 15.51 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 11.055, 11.88 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 7.535, 8.340124999999999 ], "release_s1001": [ 11.519874999999999, 12.175 ], "release_s1002": [ 6.175, 6.915125 ], "release_s1003": [ 12.48, 13.235 ], "release_s1004": [ 12.71, 13.46 ], "robust_s1001": [ 7.325, 8.095 ], "robust_s1002": [ 1.91, 2.29 ], "robust_s1003": [ 1.685, 2.0601249999999993 ], "robust_s1004": [ 6.92, 7.67 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5666666666666667, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.4166666666666667, 0.75 ], "spearman": 0.7264705882352941, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.5636027653235259, 0.9058823529411765 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.033333333333333326, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.17186857511045836, 0.3 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.324 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.47699162299076214, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.2615934737666694, 0.6778302010921357 ], "spearman": 0.7019869450135229, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.39700645573647836, 0.8442907264244685 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.20808405996555207, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.00019560834131511918, 0.4644211324493551 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.025 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.25, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.15, 0.36666666666666664 ], "spearman": 0.31176470588235294, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.15294117647058825, 0.4765441176470584 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.2772012675161055, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.4612334159339168, -0.19357421406386544 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 94, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 46, "discordant_method_correct": 24, "discordant_base_correct": 22 } }, "delay_3": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 5.435, "rel2": 3.725, "rel3": 4.1, "rel4": 5.1, "nonoise_s1001": 8.705, "nonoise_s1002": 15.315, "nonoise_s1003": 12.23, "nonoise_s1004": 8.955, "release_s1001": 12.08, "release_s1002": 8.43, "release_s1003": 12.765, "release_s1004": 13.06, "robust_s1001": 9.115, "robust_s1002": 4.425, "robust_s1003": 4.995, "robust_s1004": 7.565 }, "order": [ "rel2", "rel3", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1003", "rel4", "rel1", "robust_s1004", "release_s1002", "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "robust_s1001", "release_s1001", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "nonoise_s1002" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 100, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 6.209000020027161, "rel2": 5.896000027656555, "rel3": 6.1650000047683715, "rel4": 6.429999997615814, "nonoise_s1001": 6.8550000524520875, "nonoise_s1002": 8.046000010967255, "nonoise_s1003": 7.184999985694885, "nonoise_s1004": 6.866000015735626, "release_s1001": 7.178000025749206, "release_s1002": 6.831000034809112, "release_s1003": 7.2730000209808345, "release_s1004": 7.3910000085830685, "robust_s1001": 6.888000032901764, "robust_s1002": 6.377999999523163, "robust_s1003": 6.440999987125397, "robust_s1004": 6.787000019550323 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.4, "ci95": [ 0.33, 0.47 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.515, "ci95": [ 0.455, 0.575 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.615, "ci95": [ 0.555, 0.675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.755, "ci95": [ 0.675, 0.83 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.84, "ci95": [ 0.77, 0.91 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8, "ci95": [ 0.725, 0.87 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.73, "ci95": [ 0.655, 0.81 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.8, "ci95": [ 0.725, 0.87 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.735, "ci95": [ 0.655, 0.815 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.81, "ci95": [ 0.73, 0.88 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.81, "ci95": [ 0.735, 0.88 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.735, "ci95": [ 0.655, 0.815 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.615, "ci95": [ 0.53, 0.695 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.65, "ci95": [ 0.57, 0.725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.755, "ci95": [ 0.675, 0.83 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.675, "ci95": [ 0.62, 0.73 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.765, "ci95": [ 0.7, 0.825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.865, "ci95": [ 0.799875, 0.925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.92, "ci95": [ 0.86, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.885, "ci95": [ 0.82, 0.94 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.85, "ci95": [ 0.78, 0.915 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.89, "ci95": [ 0.825, 0.945 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.84, "ci95": [ 0.77, 0.905 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.885, "ci95": [ 0.82, 0.94 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.9, "ci95": [ 0.84, 0.95 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.855, "ci95": [ 0.79, 0.9151249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.745, "ci95": [ 0.665, 0.825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.745, "ci95": [ 0.665, 0.82 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.855, "ci95": [ 0.785, 0.915 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.83, "ci95": [ 0.775, 0.88 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.87, "ci95": [ 0.805, 0.93 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.94, "ci95": [ 0.89, 0.98 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.895, "ci95": [ 0.83, 0.95 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.85, "ci95": [ 0.78, 0.91 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.92, "ci95": [ 0.86, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.835, "ci95": [ 0.765, 0.9 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.895, "ci95": [ 0.83, 0.95 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.91, "ci95": [ 0.85, 0.96 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.855, "ci95": [ 0.785, 0.92 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.71, "ci95": [ 0.624875, 0.795 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.73, "ci95": [ 0.645, 0.81 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.85, "ci95": [ 0.78, 0.915 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.845, "ci95": [ 0.77, 0.91 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.93, "ci95": [ 0.88, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.89, "ci95": [ 0.825, 0.945 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.83, "ci95": [ 0.755, 0.9 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.91, "ci95": [ 0.85, 0.96 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.83, "ci95": [ 0.755, 0.9 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.895, "ci95": [ 0.83, 0.95 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.915, "ci95": [ 0.855, 0.965 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.85, "ci95": [ 0.78, 0.915 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.67, "ci95": [ 0.58, 0.76 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.71, "ci95": [ 0.625, 0.79 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.835, "ci95": [ 0.76, 0.9 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.99, "ci95": [ 0.97, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.9, "ci95": [ 0.855, 0.945 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.535, "ci95": [ 0.465, 0.61 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.905, "ci95": [ 0.85, 0.95 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.465, "ci95": [ 0.39, 0.545 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9, "ci95": [ 0.845, 0.95 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.895, "ci95": [ 0.84, 0.95 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.595, "ci95": [ 0.525, 0.66 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.06 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1, "ci95": [ 0.055, 0.155 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.315, "ci95": [ 0.245, 0.385 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.05, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.095 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.05, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.095 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.055, "ci95": [ 0.02, 0.095 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.065, "ci95": [ 0.025, 0.12 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.03 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.135, "ci95": [ 0.08, 0.195 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.465, "ci95": [ 0.375, 0.555 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.095, "ci95": [ 0.04987500000000001, 0.145 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.625, "ci95": [ 0.54, 0.71 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.665, "ci95": [ 0.585, 0.745 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.15, "ci95": [ 0.09, 0.215 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.065 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.865, "ci95": [ 0.81, 0.915 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.42, "ci95": [ 0.35, 0.49 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.885, "ci95": [ 0.83, 0.935 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.895, "ci95": [ 0.84, 0.945 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.505, "ci95": [ 0.42, 0.58 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.07 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.085, "ci95": [ 0.04, 0.135 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.3, "ci95": [ 0.235, 0.37 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.13, "ci95": [ 0.075, 0.19 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.66, "ci95": [ 0.57, 0.74 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7, "ci95": [ 0.615, 0.78 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.1, "ci95": [ 0.055, 0.15 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.03 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.085 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.075, "ci95": [ 0.035, 0.125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.945, "ci95": [ 0.905, 0.975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.925, "ci95": [ 0.885, 0.96 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.61, "ci95": [ 0.52, 0.69 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.065 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.065, "ci95": [ 0.025, 0.11 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.355, "ci95": [ 0.29, 0.42 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.585, "ci95": [ 0.509875, 0.66 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.135, "ci95": [ 0.08, 0.195 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.045 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.03 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.12, "ci95": [ 0.065, 0.18 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.025, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.105, "ci95": [ 0.055, 0.16 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.26, "ci95": [ 0.19, 0.34 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.625, "ci95": [ 0.545, 0.71 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.91, "ci95": [ 0.865, 0.945 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.915, "ci95": [ 0.865, 0.96 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 115, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 4.54, 6.360125 ], "rel2": [ 3.01, 4.51 ], "rel3": [ 3.479875, 4.785 ], "rel4": [ 4.4898750000000005, 5.765 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 8.32, 9.075 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 14.975, 15.595 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 11.76, 12.68 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 8.47475, 9.390125 ], "release_s1001": [ 11.649875, 12.49 ], "release_s1002": [ 8.025, 8.850124999999998 ], "release_s1003": [ 12.275, 13.235 ], "release_s1004": [ 12.609874999999999, 13.52 ], "robust_s1001": [ 8.62, 9.6 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.06, 4.79 ], "robust_s1003": [ 4.555, 5.46 ], "robust_s1004": [ 7.155, 7.955 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.36666666666666664, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.2, 0.42694576233711573 ], "spearman": 0.38823529411764707, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.18522058823529414, 0.5352941176470588 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.16666666666666669, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.39009928096988555, -0.016736548175114496 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.985 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.46025507481564765, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.16035039978824722, 0.6666737882702884 ], "spearman": 0.6136867003577339, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.253797824359613, 0.8326154355790736 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.19134751179043757, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.41573447383448603, 0.695564849540929 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.2385 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.11666666666666667, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.0, 0.22594340036404523 ], "spearman": 0.05, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.1323529411764706, 0.24430184589520834 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.4105346008494388, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.6215999468147698, -0.3272012675161055 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 82, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 60, "discordant_method_correct": 25, "discordant_base_correct": 35 } }, "delay_rand03": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 10.720249999999998, "rel2": 9.066000000000004, "rel3": 8.706749999999998, "rel4": 9.025500000000001, "nonoise_s1001": 6.277750000000001, "nonoise_s1002": 14.72425, "nonoise_s1003": 10.387499999999998, "nonoise_s1004": 6.931250000000003, "release_s1001": 10.826500000000003, "release_s1002": 5.798750000000001, "release_s1003": 11.84025, "release_s1004": 12.017999999999997, "robust_s1001": 6.499, "robust_s1002": 3.281999999999999, "robust_s1003": 4.015750000000001, "robust_s1004": 5.880500000000001 }, "order": [ "robust_s1002", "robust_s1003", "release_s1002", "robust_s1004", "nonoise_s1001", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "rel3", "rel4", "rel2", "nonoise_s1003", "rel1", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "nonoise_s1002" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.945, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.9725, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1945, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 6.0194344627213665, "rel2": 5.49516710021502, "rel3": 5.503804628401611, "rel4": 5.583496142291778, "nonoise_s1001": 5.485244228416972, "nonoise_s1002": 6.378200521934921, "nonoise_s1003": 5.7108483278965885, "nonoise_s1004": 5.506015432034176, "release_s1001": 5.733624678344531, "release_s1002": 5.466478158637, "release_s1003": 5.804575830743981, "release_s1004": 5.885861186564428, "robust_s1001": 5.5052956440148435, "robust_s1002": 5.195475584804859, "robust_s1003": 5.236298206226378, "robust_s1004": 5.454447317368573 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.2005, "ci95": [ 0.15673124999999993, 0.2487499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.27725, "ci95": [ 0.22848125, 0.32775624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.33925, "ci95": [ 0.29399374999999994, 0.38925625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.33299999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.2924937499999999, 0.3735 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.605, "ci95": [ 0.54725, 0.65925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.429, "ci95": [ 0.37924374999999994, 0.47899999999999976 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.347, "ci95": [ 0.30324375, 0.3897625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.415, "ci95": [ 0.36949999999999994, 0.46100624999999984 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.318, "ci95": [ 0.27774374999999996, 0.35675624999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.4679999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4159937499999999, 0.52075625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.506, "ci95": [ 0.4532374999999999, 0.5595 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.3314999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.29, 0.37149999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.19449999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.16174375, 0.22750625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.204, "ci95": [ 0.1732375, 0.23526874999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.31175, "ci95": [ 0.27373749999999997, 0.3492562499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.406, "ci95": [ 0.36048749999999996, 0.4517499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.46974999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.42550000000000004, 0.5152499999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.39149999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.35300000000000004, 0.431 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.7215, "ci95": [ 0.67374375, 0.7672499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.49699999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.4512375000000001, 0.5402499999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.40850000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.36823749999999994, 0.4494999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.49624999999999986, "ci95": [ 0.45299999999999996, 0.5364999999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.373, "ci95": [ 0.33499375000000003, 0.41076250000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.56025, "ci95": [ 0.5107499999999999, 0.6072562499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5865, "ci95": [ 0.5364937499999999, 0.6342687499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.39, "ci95": [ 0.35224374999999997, 0.42950625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.2345, "ci95": [ 0.20175000000000004, 0.26475625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.24499999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.21100000000000005, 0.2797499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.35475, "ci95": [ 0.3189937499999999, 0.3902499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.5782499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5375, 0.6195062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.4022500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.3629937499999999, 0.4420062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.76375, "ci95": [ 0.72124375, 0.8040062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.5289999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.48224374999999986, 0.5719999999999997 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.4292499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.38500000000000006, 0.4709999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.5335, "ci95": [ 0.48974375000000003, 0.5740062500000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.3795, "ci95": [ 0.3404937499999998, 0.4200062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.59775, "ci95": [ 0.54825, 0.6445000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.621, "ci95": [ 0.5730000000000001, 0.66500625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.39575000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.35574999999999996, 0.436 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.18075, "ci95": [ 0.15549999999999994, 0.20700625000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.19975, "ci95": [ 0.17324375, 0.22575 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.366, "ci95": [ 0.32724374999999994, 0.40299999999999975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.3867499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.3447437499999999, 0.4264999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.7747499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.728, 0.8162499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.5277499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4784937499999997, 0.5742499999999997 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.41225000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.36800000000000005, 0.4547499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.54125, "ci95": [ 0.49823749999999983, 0.58175625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.37249999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.33174374999999984, 0.4132499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6039999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5517437499999999, 0.6542499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.63525, "ci95": [ 0.5880000000000001, 0.6777499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.38775, "ci95": [ 0.3482499999999999, 0.42725625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.16474999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.13975, 0.19100624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1845, "ci95": [ 0.15825, 0.21075000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.37024999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.3292437499999999, 0.4110062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.997, "ci95": [ 0.991, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.93175, "ci95": [ 0.91125, 0.9509999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.6014999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5689937499999997, 0.6342562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.96, "ci95": [ 0.9405, 0.97650625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.41800000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.38500000000000006, 0.4524999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9557499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.9372437499999999, 0.97175625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.93875, "ci95": [ 0.9144937499999999, 0.9604999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.53175, "ci95": [ 0.49399375, 0.5657625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.1925, "ci95": [ 0.17149374999999997, 0.21475625000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.26975, "ci95": [ 0.23975000000000002, 0.30301874999999984 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.439, "ci95": [ 0.40524374999999985, 0.47375624999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.011000000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.003, 0.021 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0034999999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.01 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.03275, "ci95": [ 0.01075, 0.06300624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.009, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.024 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.01525, "ci95": [ 0.006500000000000001, 0.025256249999999963 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.040249999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.01399375, 0.07550624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0115, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0045 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.003, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.027999999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.10074999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.0745, 0.12924999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.54675, "ci95": [ 0.4902499999999997, 0.6042499999999996 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.07425000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.046, 0.10951874999999991 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7595000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7239937499999998, 0.7944999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7567500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7194999999999997, 0.79325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.08800000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.06075000000000002, 0.11950000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0405, "ci95": [ 0.02850000000000001, 0.05325624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.09824999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.07575000000000001, 0.12425000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.07325, "ci95": [ 0.052000000000000005, 0.09975624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9405000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.919, 0.96075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.32300000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.29174374999999997, 0.357 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.94975, "ci95": [ 0.9307499999999999, 0.96625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.93375, "ci95": [ 0.9127437500000001, 0.95375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.4285, "ci95": [ 0.39149999999999996, 0.4652562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.17900000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.15675, 0.20450624999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.23975000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.21099375000000004, 0.2727562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.3772499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.34599374999999993, 0.41124999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.044, "ci95": [ 0.025993750000000003, 0.06425624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7094999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6627500000000001, 0.7522500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7105000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6619874999999996, 0.7539999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.04874999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.026500000000000003, 0.0772687499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.01925, "ci95": [ 0.00899375, 0.03100624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.06225, "ci95": [ 0.041499999999999995, 0.08474999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.045250000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.029493750000000003, 0.06275624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9615, "ci95": [ 0.9377437499999998, 0.98 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.9380000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.90675, 0.9630062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.6165, "ci95": [ 0.5767500000000003, 0.6542499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.20950000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.18724375000000004, 0.23375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.28400000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.2549937500000001, 0.31675000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.503, "ci95": [ 0.47149999999999964, 0.5320062499999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5815, "ci95": [ 0.52699375, 0.6362499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.059750000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.038, 0.08825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.02375, "ci95": [ 0.013493749999999999, 0.035 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.024249999999999997, 0.05775624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.036000000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.019000000000000003, 0.058506249999999954 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.07150000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.04675, 0.09925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.046, "ci95": [ 0.031000000000000007, 0.06499999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.05800000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.041750000000000016, 0.07699999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.05474999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.03574375, 0.08075000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.18775000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.16374999999999995, 0.21526249999999986 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.2655, "ci95": [ 0.23475000000000004, 0.2987499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.409, "ci95": [ 0.37249374999999996, 0.4457562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5710000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5315000000000003, 0.6140062500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.82125, "ci95": [ 0.7974937499999998, 0.84425 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7090000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6717437499999999, 0.74250625 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 108, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 10.124962499999995, 11.295818749999997 ], "rel2": [ 8.585056250000001, 9.5522875 ], "rel3": [ 8.320731249999996, 9.104293749999995 ], "rel4": [ 8.668356250000002, 9.399256250000002 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 6.056487500000002, 6.4998000000000005 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 14.487975000000004, 14.940512500000002 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 10.05574374999999, 10.708393749999997 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 6.6701812500000015, 7.184312500000003 ], "release_s1001": [ 10.604493750000005, 11.042625000000003 ], "release_s1002": [ 5.581743750000003, 6.028287500000001 ], "release_s1003": [ 11.553418749999997, 12.11476875 ], "release_s1004": [ 11.669481250000002, 12.333349999999998 ], "robust_s1001": [ 6.212718750000002, 6.785300000000001 ], "robust_s1002": [ 3.11798125, 3.452012500000002 ], "robust_s1003": [ 3.791462500000001, 4.258281250000001 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.677224999999997, 6.102756249999999 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.8, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.6775511127314989, 0.85 ], "spearman": 0.9029411764705882, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.8241204616617979, 0.9470588235294117 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.2666666666666667, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.07298672029286662, 0.4 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.0045 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.4435185266405332, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.15253182723748737, 0.6836087351633573 ], "spearman": 0.6166300418462601, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.18960677956643965, 0.8502060518983756 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.17461096361532313, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.017891179869551358, 0.3926773114895393 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.0405 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.6333333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.48333333333333334, 0.7333333333333333 ], "spearman": 0.7735294117647059, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6205882352941177, 0.861764705882353 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.10613206581722778, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.12762230360450347, 0.17279873248389443 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.3355 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 108, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 32, "discordant_method_correct": 24, "discordant_base_correct": 8 } }, "goal_far": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 13.434749999999994, "rel2": 11.986499999999996, "rel3": 11.36775, "rel4": 11.315499999999997, "nonoise_s1001": 3.4025000000000007, "nonoise_s1002": 15.043499999999996, "nonoise_s1003": 9.1415, "nonoise_s1004": 3.548, "release_s1001": 9.651250000000001, "release_s1002": 3.542, "release_s1003": 11.216750000000001, "release_s1004": 11.901, "robust_s1001": 4.142249999999999, "robust_s1002": 3.4565, "robust_s1003": 7.2027500000000035, "robust_s1004": 5.647499999999996 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1001", "robust_s1002", "release_s1002", "nonoise_s1004", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "rel4", "rel3", "release_s1004", "rel2", "rel1", "nonoise_s1002" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.98, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.99, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1980, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 7.523080805214969, "rel2": 7.295252530863791, "rel3": 7.222676774227258, "rel4": 7.195959599331172, "nonoise_s1001": 6.831818183985623, "nonoise_s1002": 8.043686878440356, "nonoise_s1003": 7.069090907621866, "nonoise_s1004": 6.836919197650871, "release_s1001": 7.074747473302514, "release_s1002": 6.836868695899693, "release_s1003": 7.175404034359286, "release_s1004": 7.4333838335191365, "robust_s1001": 6.860252531489941, "robust_s1002": 6.829595961956063, "robust_s1003": 7.0842424227733805, "robust_s1004": 6.910454544876561 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.15799999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.12524999999999997, 0.19325625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.14800000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.11725000000000003, 0.18075624999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.18100000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.14275000000000004, 0.22149999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.6722499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6182437500000001, 0.7252562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.23475000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.1864875, 0.2802562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.18825000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.1417375, 0.23375000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.31875, "ci95": [ 0.26975, 0.36500000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.4285000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.3807500000000001, 0.473 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.00075, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.00225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.19325, "ci95": [ 0.14698750000000002, 0.24300000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0415, "ci95": [ 0.026493749999999996, 0.05825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.31799999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.28350000000000014, 0.35175625000000027 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.35125, "ci95": [ 0.31248750000000003, 0.3912500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0030000000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.76725, "ci95": [ 0.7182374999999999, 0.8134999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.29075, "ci95": [ 0.24124375000000006, 0.33700625000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0022500000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.25049999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.20325000000000004, 0.29750624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.3995, "ci95": [ 0.34899375, 0.44775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5015, "ci95": [ 0.45849375000000014, 0.54475 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0017500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.0037500000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.23199999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.18472500000000003, 0.28425624999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.056749999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.038500000000000006, 0.07625624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.4485, "ci95": [ 0.41399375000000005, 0.48225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0034999999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.0005, 0.0075000000000000015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.8107499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.76624375, 0.8525062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.30175, "ci95": [ 0.25300000000000006, 0.349 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.004, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.009000000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.26549999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.22, 0.31250624999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0017499999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.00425 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.4287500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.37898750000000003, 0.47525000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.53, "ci95": [ 0.48674375, 0.575 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0055000000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.0007500000000000001, 0.01175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.23875, "ci95": [ 0.19049375, 0.29174999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.05925, "ci95": [ 0.039749999999999994, 0.08049999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.8340000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7919937499999999, 0.8720249999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.3055, "ci95": [ 0.25775, 0.3527500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.267, "ci95": [ 0.22224375, 0.31324999999999986 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.4432500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.39624374999999995, 0.4882500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.54075, "ci95": [ 0.49624999999999986, 0.5857625000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.25049999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.19999374999999997, 0.3025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.024, "ci95": [ 0.01575, 0.032749999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.9607499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.95025, 0.9707499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.52525, "ci95": [ 0.5017437500000002, 0.54775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9919999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.9875000000000003, 0.99575 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.52025, "ci95": [ 0.5032500000000001, 0.5387500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.991, "ci95": [ 0.9867500000000001, 0.9947500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.961, "ci95": [ 0.9495000000000001, 0.9715 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.612, "ci95": [ 0.5879937499999996, 0.6357562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.49949999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.47849999999999965, 0.52175625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7462499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7027374999999998, 0.7887499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.79425, "ci95": [ 0.7769999999999997, 0.8122499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.00875, "ci95": [ 0.0025000000000000005, 0.017750000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.0215, "ci95": [ 0.002, 0.04825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.006999999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.027999999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.002, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.006000000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.030243749999999986, 0.05049999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.5655, "ci95": [ 0.5144999999999998, 0.6142562499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.04800000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.03599374999999999, 0.06174999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8645, "ci95": [ 0.8362437500000001, 0.8909999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8407499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.81124375, 0.8692625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.05575000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.038743749999999993, 0.08125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.051, "ci95": [ 0.04024374999999999, 0.06250000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.39350000000000007, "ci95": [ 0.33424375, 0.45900624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.09325000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.07500000000000001, 0.11325000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9932500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9902500000000001, 0.996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.4935, "ci95": [ 0.47225000000000006, 0.5165 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9907500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9865, 0.9945000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.96175, "ci95": [ 0.95075, 0.9720000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5875, "ci95": [ 0.5707374999999997, 0.6054999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.46974999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.4442500000000001, 0.49550625000000026 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7342499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.6837374999999998, 0.7832499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.79175, "ci95": [ 0.77475, 0.8089999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.007250000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0045000000000000005, 0.010256249999999972 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7449999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6992499999999998, 0.785 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7652499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7257437500000001, 0.8032562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.01825, "ci95": [ 0.006000000000000001, 0.045749999999999985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.009000000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.005993750000000001, 0.0125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.30975, "ci95": [ 0.25700000000000006, 0.36575 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.025, "ci95": [ 0.01775, 0.03325000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9890000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9842500000000001, 0.9930000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.95175, "ci95": [ 0.93374375, 0.9665062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5977500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5739937500000001, 0.6197499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.4724999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.45274375000000006, 0.49026250000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7294999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6832437499999997, 0.7742499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7885, "ci95": [ 0.7677500000000002, 0.8077562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.665, "ci95": [ 0.6215, 0.7125000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.02025, "ci95": [ 0.007250000000000002, 0.047 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0115, "ci95": [ 0.0072499999999999995, 0.016499999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.23525000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.18798125000000002, 0.28575625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.022750000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.013500000000000003, 0.03499999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.05, "ci95": [ 0.03324374999999999, 0.07275624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.04724999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.033243749999999996, 0.0645 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.113, "ci95": [ 0.07374375000000001, 0.15875625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0565, "ci95": [ 0.0395, 0.07750625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.38150000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.35774375, 0.4050062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6927499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.6370000000000001, 0.74925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7400000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7147437500000002, 0.7622500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7127499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6622500000000001, 0.7622625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7730000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7565, 0.7900062500000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.37900000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.3174874999999999, 0.43800625000000004 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 115, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 13.136743749999996, 13.741787499999994 ], "rel2": [ 11.747993750000001, 12.247024999999999 ], "rel3": [ 11.155474999999996, 11.580518749999998 ], "rel4": [ 11.137718749999994, 11.50955 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.302250000000002, 3.5037624999999992 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 14.842993750000002, 15.22700625 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 8.88495625, 9.393281249999996 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.438731249999999, 3.6582624999999998 ], "release_s1001": [ 9.437700000000001, 9.867256250000008 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.453993749999999, 3.6482562500000015 ], "release_s1003": [ 10.971975000000002, 11.444512500000005 ], "release_s1004": [ 11.577218749999998, 12.2290125 ], "robust_s1001": [ 3.9852125, 4.3452562499999985 ], "robust_s1002": [ 3.3414750000000004, 3.5707562499999996 ], "robust_s1003": [ 6.606481249999999, 7.811543749999999 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.50073125, 5.804024999999997 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.6166666666666667, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5272012675161055, 0.6833333333333333 ], "spearman": 0.8205882352941176, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7558823529411764, 0.8705882352941177 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.08333333333333337, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.02265722242928777, 0.14999999999999997 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.0075 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.34309923758984645, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.008370054603510731, 0.6610936529170212 ], "spearman": 0.4385578817904189, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.023528497401051014, 0.8315307622772865 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.07419167456463638, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.01466939734987464, 0.10815526926855577 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.009 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.55, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.4666666666666667, 0.6833333333333333 ], "spearman": 0.7588235294117647, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6675735294117646, 0.861764705882353 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.022798732483894524, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.12776031958368783, 0.0983418890773864 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.609 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 97, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 7, "discordant_method_correct": 6, "discordant_base_correct": 1 } }, "goal_rot": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 14.965, "rel2": 13.557499999999996, "rel3": 12.793250000000002, "rel4": 12.43175, "nonoise_s1001": 3.787750000000001, "nonoise_s1002": 13.792749999999996, "nonoise_s1003": 7.984000000000001, "nonoise_s1004": 3.8415, "release_s1001": 9.177749999999996, "release_s1002": 3.97225, "release_s1003": 9.964500000000003, "release_s1004": 9.963750000000001, "robust_s1001": 4.414749999999999, "robust_s1002": 4.202000000000002, "robust_s1003": 5.904249999999999, "robust_s1004": 5.247250000000001 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1004", "release_s1003", "rel4", "rel3", "rel2", "nonoise_s1002", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.882, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.941, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1882, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 5.599787459490023, "rel2": 5.258076515005195, "rel3": 5.1480871444047445, "rel4": 5.10504782630584, "nonoise_s1001": 4.655419766332847, "nonoise_s1002": 5.291764087935436, "nonoise_s1003": 4.791285859410999, "nonoise_s1004": 4.65706694962241, "release_s1001": 4.8283740698847835, "release_s1002": 4.661583421080829, "release_s1003": 4.864346436942422, "release_s1004": 4.914187037982799, "robust_s1001": 4.674814027756864, "robust_s1002": 4.666684376572701, "robust_s1003": 4.737194472621022, "robust_s1004": 4.697555788265151 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.09849999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.07150000000000001, 0.129 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.09274999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.06649999999999999, 0.12275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.09049999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.06524374999999999, 0.1185 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.37849999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.3214812499999999, 0.42950625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.029750000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.0475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.018750000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.008, 0.03275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.10175, "ci95": [ 0.06675, 0.13999999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.217, "ci95": [ 0.15574375000000001, 0.2785 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.007499999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.00225, 0.014500000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.23975, "ci95": [ 0.20475000000000004, 0.27575625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.23074999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.1965, 0.26499999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.46225, "ci95": [ 0.4225, 0.49824999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.06775, "ci95": [ 0.04424375, 0.09299999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.055250000000000014, "ci95": [ 0.03574999999999999, 0.07625000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.17875000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.13474375, 0.22301249999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.27475, "ci95": [ 0.21424375, 0.33451874999999986 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.03175, "ci95": [ 0.014000000000000002, 0.05225624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.35525, "ci95": [ 0.32849999999999985, 0.38275625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.51625, "ci95": [ 0.4807500000000001, 0.5522499999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.07624999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.051493749999999984, 0.10225624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.06325000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.04300000000000001, 0.08500624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.19524999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.15100000000000005, 0.23925624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.29025, "ci95": [ 0.23074375000000003, 0.34900625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.04275, "ci95": [ 0.0225, 0.06575 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.546, "ci95": [ 0.5094937499999999, 0.5837500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.07925, "ci95": [ 0.05349375, 0.10625624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.07024999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.04949374999999998, 0.09250000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.20400000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.16075, 0.24700625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.296, "ci95": [ 0.23699375000000006, 0.3535062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.049249999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.027993749999999994, 0.07200625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.88275, "ci95": [ 0.8645000000000002, 0.9014999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.50775, "ci95": [ 0.5039999999999999, 0.5122499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.96175, "ci95": [ 0.9475, 0.9747499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.52, "ci95": [ 0.5139937499999997, 0.5264999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.94075, "ci95": [ 0.9217500000000001, 0.9580062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.887, "ci95": [ 0.8679999999999999, 0.90625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.57625, "ci95": [ 0.56375, 0.5902500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5512499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5425, 0.5605 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6894999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6582437499999998, 0.7209999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.69525, "ci95": [ 0.6720000000000002, 0.7184999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.002, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0045000000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.03325, "ci95": [ 0.02125, 0.04574999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.002, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.00475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.008, "ci95": [ 0.0035000000000000005, 0.013500000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.034, "ci95": [ 0.0175, 0.05275624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.009000000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0025, 0.017 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0007500000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.030500000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.00125, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0032500000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.11875, "ci95": [ 0.10000000000000007, 0.13675625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.63725, "ci95": [ 0.6132499999999999, 0.6607625000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.13274999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.11250000000000007, 0.1522500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.77975, "ci95": [ 0.7614937499999997, 0.7972500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7125, "ci95": [ 0.6875, 0.73850625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.15, "ci95": [ 0.12724375000000002, 0.17275624999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.14175000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.12250000000000004, 0.16075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.30524999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.2667500000000002, 0.3445062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.17574999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.15724375000000002, 0.19374999999999987 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9605000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.94624375, 0.9732499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.51275, "ci95": [ 0.5054999999999998, 0.5202499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9405000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9217437499999999, 0.9580000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8867499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.86775, 0.9057562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.56825, "ci95": [ 0.55675, 0.58125625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.54375, "ci95": [ 0.53474375, 0.5535 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6844999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6529937499999997, 0.7170062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6880000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.6657500000000001, 0.7102562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.04025, "ci95": [ 0.026993750000000004, 0.05475000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6170000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5945, 0.63975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.594, "ci95": [ 0.5567499999999999, 0.6329999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0665, "ci95": [ 0.04875, 0.08675000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.05074999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.035993750000000005, 0.06625624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.18475000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.14999374999999995, 0.22125624999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.06925, "ci95": [ 0.053243749999999986, 0.08725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9330000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.9134937499999998, 0.9514999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8717500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8524999999999998, 0.89125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5545, "ci95": [ 0.5419999999999999, 0.5687499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.52975, "ci95": [ 0.5217499999999997, 0.5384999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.67175, "ci95": [ 0.6417437499999998, 0.7020125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6747500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6499999999999999, 0.6994999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5385, "ci95": [ 0.49371874999999993, 0.5850125000000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.084, "ci95": [ 0.06299374999999999, 0.10675625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.07225, "ci95": [ 0.053, 0.09274999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.15250000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.12599374999999993, 0.18000000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.087, "ci95": [ 0.06674999999999999, 0.10851249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.13574999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.11649999999999999, 0.15525000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.136, "ci95": [ 0.11675000000000005, 0.15525 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.2125, "ci95": [ 0.18449999999999997, 0.24175624999999987 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.1545, "ci95": [ 0.1355, 0.17299999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.47550000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.46399999999999975, 0.48649999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6335000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5972500000000002, 0.6700000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6204999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5992437499999996, 0.6414999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6517499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.61624375, 0.6865000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.648, "ci95": [ 0.624, 0.67175625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.43300000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.38475000000000004, 0.4825062499999999 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 118, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 14.751731249999997, 15.163262499999998 ], "rel2": [ 13.346237499999992, 13.764512499999993 ], "rel3": [ 12.639237500000004, 12.948000000000002 ], "rel4": [ 12.276487499999998, 12.583287499999997 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.700231250000001, 3.8755312500000008 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 13.6295, 13.94800625 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.808500000000002, 8.16375 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.7575, 3.9272562499999983 ], "release_s1001": [ 9.05199375, 9.295506249999997 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.882737500000001, 4.062749999999999 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.743250000000003, 10.186999999999998 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.609487499999997, 10.340749999999998 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.29621875, 4.545262499999997 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.102750000000004, 4.303506250000001 ], "robust_s1003": [ 5.576737500000001, 6.23675625 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.107468750000002, 5.398250000000001 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5333333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.45, 0.627763375985955 ], "spearman": 0.7647058823529411, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.702880528915555, 0.8235294117647058 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.0, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.019016620420124034, 0.05020964452534338 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.24 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.25941649671427414, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.06029087865561773, 0.5774109120414489 ], "spearman": 0.33259758820347207, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.09868010421411776, 0.7793572091548884 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.009491066310935936, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.04311059450304636, 0.0254617969802301 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.5985 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5333333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5, 0.6666666666666666 ], "spearman": 0.7735294117647059, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7441176470588236, 0.8558823529411764 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.006132065817227805, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.032967412496909834, 0.03967679071361576 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.396 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 92, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 2, "discordant_method_correct": 1, "discordant_base_correct": 1 } }, "hold_1s": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 14.955, "rel2": 13.67, "rel3": 12.775, "rel4": 12.505, "nonoise_s1001": 3.73, "nonoise_s1002": 13.71, "nonoise_s1003": 7.855, "nonoise_s1004": 3.71, "release_s1001": 9.17, "release_s1002": 3.845, "release_s1003": 10.045, "release_s1004": 10.075, "robust_s1001": 4.33, "robust_s1002": 4.295, "robust_s1003": 6.125, "robust_s1004": 5.205 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1004", "nonoise_s1001", "release_s1002", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "rel4", "rel3", "rel2", "nonoise_s1002", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.88, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.94, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 94, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 6.623404272059177, "rel2": 6.263829756290354, "rel3": 6.145744704185648, "rel4": 6.111702122586839, "nonoise_s1001": 5.660638345048783, "nonoise_s1002": 6.297872353107371, "nonoise_s1003": 5.793617002507474, "nonoise_s1004": 5.660638339976047, "release_s1001": 5.838297889587727, "release_s1002": 5.663829833903211, "release_s1003": 5.880851101368032, "release_s1004": 5.932978718838793, "robust_s1001": 5.680851112020776, "robust_s1002": 5.675531965620975, "robust_s1003": 5.748936196590992, "robust_s1004": 5.703191518783569 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.12, "ci95": [ 0.08, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.105, "ci95": [ 0.07, 0.145 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.105, "ci95": [ 0.07, 0.145 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.35, "ci95": [ 0.285, 0.41 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.065 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.095, "ci95": [ 0.055, 0.145 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.22, "ci95": [ 0.16, 0.285 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.21, "ci95": [ 0.165, 0.26 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.225, "ci95": [ 0.18, 0.275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.445, "ci95": [ 0.395, 0.485 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.065, "ci95": [ 0.03, 0.105 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.06 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.17, "ci95": [ 0.115, 0.23 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.27, "ci95": [ 0.205, 0.335 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.06 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.375, "ci95": [ 0.33, 0.42 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.5, "ci95": [ 0.46, 0.5351249999999993 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.09, "ci95": [ 0.04987500000000001, 0.14 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.06, "ci95": [ 0.03, 0.09 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.195, "ci95": [ 0.135, 0.2551249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.285, "ci95": [ 0.22, 0.35 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.065 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.52, "ci95": [ 0.47, 0.565 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.09, "ci95": [ 0.04987500000000001, 0.14 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.06, "ci95": [ 0.03, 0.09 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.2, "ci95": [ 0.14, 0.26 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.295, "ci95": [ 0.235, 0.355 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.065 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.885, "ci95": [ 0.845, 0.925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5, "ci95": [ 0.485, 0.515 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.97, "ci95": [ 0.95, 0.99 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.51, "ci95": [ 0.5, 0.525 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.945, "ci95": [ 0.915, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.895, "ci95": [ 0.86, 0.93 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.575, "ci95": [ 0.54, 0.615 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.57, "ci95": [ 0.539875, 0.61 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.725, "ci95": [ 0.68, 0.775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.695, "ci95": [ 0.655, 0.74 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.07 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.085 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.11, "ci95": [ 0.075, 0.145 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.67, "ci95": [ 0.61, 0.73 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.13, "ci95": [ 0.09, 0.175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.825, "ci95": [ 0.785, 0.865 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.74, "ci95": [ 0.705, 0.775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.14, "ci95": [ 0.1, 0.18 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.155, "ci95": [ 0.115, 0.195 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.34, "ci95": [ 0.28, 0.405 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.2, "ci95": [ 0.15987500000000002, 0.24512499999999932 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.97, "ci95": [ 0.95, 0.99 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.51, "ci95": [ 0.495, 0.53 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.945, "ci95": [ 0.915, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.9, "ci95": [ 0.865, 0.93 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.575, "ci95": [ 0.54, 0.61 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.57, "ci95": [ 0.54, 0.605 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.73, "ci95": [ 0.685, 0.78 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7, "ci95": [ 0.66, 0.745 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.65, "ci95": [ 0.595, 0.705 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.62, "ci95": [ 0.56, 0.675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.05, "ci95": [ 0.024875000000000008, 0.085 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.02, 0.07012499999999933 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.185, "ci95": [ 0.12987500000000002, 0.245 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.06, "ci95": [ 0.035, 0.09 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.94, "ci95": [ 0.91, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.88, "ci95": [ 0.84, 0.92 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.565, "ci95": [ 0.525, 0.605 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.555, "ci95": [ 0.525, 0.59 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.715, "ci95": [ 0.67, 0.765 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.68, "ci95": [ 0.635, 0.725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.56, "ci95": [ 0.49, 0.62 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.07, "ci95": [ 0.04, 0.105 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.07, "ci95": [ 0.04, 0.1 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.15, "ci95": [ 0.1, 0.205 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.08, "ci95": [ 0.05, 0.11 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.13, "ci95": [ 0.095, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.14, "ci95": [ 0.105, 0.18 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.22, "ci95": [ 0.165, 0.28 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.145, "ci95": [ 0.10987500000000001, 0.185 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.495, "ci95": [ 0.465, 0.525 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.67, "ci95": [ 0.615, 0.7251249999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.62, "ci95": [ 0.58, 0.665 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.675, "ci95": [ 0.62, 0.73 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.63, "ci95": [ 0.59, 0.675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.395, "ci95": [ 0.33487500000000003, 0.455 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 113, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 14.695, 15.19 ], "rel2": [ 13.444875, 13.9 ], "rel3": [ 12.57, 12.975 ], "rel4": [ 12.28, 12.725124999999998 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.54, 3.915 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 13.535, 13.870124999999998 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.49, 8.215124999999999 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.52, 3.88 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.915, 9.415 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.635, 4.06 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.684875, 10.41 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.57, 10.54 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.08, 4.6 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.07, 4.535 ], "robust_s1003": [ 5.679875, 6.6 ], "robust_s1004": [ 4.955, 5.480125 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5333333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.4303234246969298, 0.6166666666666667 ], "spearman": 0.7617647058823529, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6818733069388118, 0.8176470588235294 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.0, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.2689075630252101, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.06038545898555877, 0.5883604528199821 ], "spearman": 0.3321060382916053, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.09823836282331362, 0.7813063958363201 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.0, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5272012675161055, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.4937281711658766, 0.6778302010921357 ], "spearman": 0.7696837992496278, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7402503843643647, 0.8535690316726274 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.0, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 92, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 0, "discordant_method_correct": 0, "discordant_base_correct": 0 } }, "loop_rate_hold": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 4.685, "rel2": 3.275, "rel3": 3.715, "rel4": 4.85, "nonoise_s1001": 9.41, "nonoise_s1002": 13.34, "nonoise_s1003": 13.955, "nonoise_s1004": 12.385, "release_s1001": 12.155, "release_s1002": 7.97, "release_s1003": 13.06, "release_s1004": 13.39, "robust_s1001": 8.86, "robust_s1002": 3.975, "robust_s1003": 3.645, "robust_s1004": 7.33 }, "order": [ "rel2", "robust_s1003", "rel3", "robust_s1002", "rel1", "rel4", "robust_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1001", "release_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1003", "nonoise_s1002", "release_s1004", "nonoise_s1003" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.88, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 0.96, "nonoise_s1002": 0.08, "nonoise_s1003": 0.0, "nonoise_s1004": 0.16, "release_s1001": 0.66, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 0.56, "release_s1004": 0.04, "robust_s1001": 0.96, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 0.8, "nonoise_s1002": 0.08, "nonoise_s1003": 0.0, "nonoise_s1004": 0.32, "release_s1001": 0.22, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 0.04, "release_s1004": 0.2, "robust_s1001": 0.9, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.94, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 0.88, "nonoise_s1002": 0.08, "nonoise_s1003": 0.0, "nonoise_s1004": 0.24, "release_s1001": 0.44, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 0.3, "release_s1004": 0.12, "robust_s1001": 0.93, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 0, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": null, "rel2": null, "rel3": null, "rel4": null, "nonoise_s1001": null, "nonoise_s1002": null, "nonoise_s1003": null, "nonoise_s1004": null, "release_s1001": null, "release_s1002": null, "release_s1003": null, "release_s1004": null, "robust_s1001": null, "robust_s1002": null, "robust_s1003": null, "robust_s1004": null }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.315, "ci95": [ 0.25, 0.38 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.43, "ci95": [ 0.355, 0.5 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.53, "ci95": [ 0.455, 0.6 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.87, "ci95": [ 0.81, 0.93 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.945, "ci95": [ 0.91, 0.98 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.97, "ci95": [ 0.945, 0.99 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.9, "ci95": [ 0.85, 0.945 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.91, "ci95": [ 0.86, 0.955 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.85, "ci95": [ 0.78, 0.91 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.935, "ci95": [ 0.885, 0.975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.96, "ci95": [ 0.929875, 0.985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.86, "ci95": [ 0.8, 0.92 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.54, "ci95": [ 0.45, 0.63 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.475, "ci95": [ 0.38, 0.565 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.825, "ci95": [ 0.75, 0.895 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.58, "ci95": [ 0.515, 0.65 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.7, "ci95": [ 0.63, 0.77 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.93, "ci95": [ 0.88, 0.98 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.975, "ci95": [ 0.945, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.93, "ci95": [ 0.88, 0.98 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.955, "ci95": [ 0.91, 0.99 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.93, "ci95": [ 0.88, 0.98 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.99, "ci95": [ 0.97, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.99, "ci95": [ 0.97, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.93, "ci95": [ 0.88, 0.98 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.66, "ci95": [ 0.57, 0.7501249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.58, "ci95": [ 0.489875, 0.675 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.89, "ci95": [ 0.8298749999999999, 0.945 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.745, "ci95": [ 0.685, 0.805 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.93, "ci95": [ 0.88, 0.98 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.975, "ci95": [ 0.945, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.93, "ci95": [ 0.88, 0.98 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.955, "ci95": [ 0.91, 0.99 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.925, "ci95": [ 0.87, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.99, "ci95": [ 0.97, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.99, "ci95": [ 0.97, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.92, "ci95": [ 0.86, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.545, "ci95": [ 0.45487500000000003, 0.635 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.53, "ci95": [ 0.439875, 0.625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.86, "ci95": [ 0.79, 0.925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.91, "ci95": [ 0.85, 0.96 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.96, "ci95": [ 0.92, 0.99 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.92, "ci95": [ 0.86, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.955, "ci95": [ 0.91, 0.99 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.9, "ci95": [ 0.84, 0.96 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.99, "ci95": [ 0.97, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.99, "ci95": [ 0.97, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.92, "ci95": [ 0.86, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.425, "ci95": [ 0.335, 0.52 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.385, "ci95": [ 0.295, 0.475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.77, "ci95": [ 0.69, 0.85 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.885, "ci95": [ 0.83, 0.935 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.94, "ci95": [ 0.905, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.825, "ci95": [ 0.765, 0.88 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.845, "ci95": [ 0.78, 0.905 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.225, "ci95": [ 0.16, 0.29 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.92, "ci95": [ 0.875, 0.955 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.88, "ci95": [ 0.825, 0.935 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.415, "ci95": [ 0.33487500000000003, 0.495 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.055 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.22, "ci95": [ 0.155, 0.29 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.54, "ci95": [ 0.515, 0.57 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.415, "ci95": [ 0.365, 0.465 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.32, "ci95": [ 0.265, 0.375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.06, "ci95": [ 0.02, 0.11 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.405, "ci95": [ 0.355, 0.455 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.48, "ci95": [ 0.44, 0.52 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.08, "ci95": [ 0.035, 0.13 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.06, "ci95": [ 0.02, 0.11 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.38, "ci95": [ 0.34, 0.42 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.28, "ci95": [ 0.24, 0.325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.36, "ci95": [ 0.325, 0.4 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.44, "ci95": [ 0.41, 0.47 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.06 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.44, "ci95": [ 0.37, 0.51 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.11, "ci95": [ 0.06, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.5, "ci95": [ 0.435, 0.56 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.585, "ci95": [ 0.535, 0.635 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.15, "ci95": [ 0.1, 0.205 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.025, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.06, "ci95": [ 0.025, 0.10012499999999933 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.61, "ci95": [ 0.545, 0.675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.645, "ci95": [ 0.5898749999999999, 0.7 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.15, "ci95": [ 0.09, 0.215 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.05, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.09 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.94, "ci95": [ 0.89, 0.98 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.65, "ci95": [ 0.565, 0.73 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.07 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.39, "ci95": [ 0.32, 0.46 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.575, "ci95": [ 0.525, 0.625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.075, "ci95": [ 0.035, 0.12 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.03 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.07 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.285, "ci95": [ 0.215, 0.36 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.39, "ci95": [ 0.3, 0.485 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.945, "ci95": [ 0.9, 0.98 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.945, "ci95": [ 0.9, 0.98 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 109, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 4.184875, 5.230125 ], "rel2": [ 2.88, 3.7152499999999984 ], "rel3": [ 3.315, 4.150125 ], "rel4": [ 4.43, 5.280125 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 8.985, 9.825 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 12.844875, 13.755 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 13.855, 14.045 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 11.795, 12.93 ], "release_s1001": [ 11.789874999999999, 12.52 ], "release_s1002": [ 7.66475, 8.255125 ], "release_s1003": [ 12.815, 13.3 ], "release_s1004": [ 13.054875, 13.695 ], "robust_s1001": [ 8.434875, 9.27 ], "robust_s1002": [ 3.62, 4.320125 ], "robust_s1003": [ 3.25, 4.06 ], "robust_s1004": [ 6.94, 7.73 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.3333333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.21666666666666667, 0.41004543029030427 ], "spearman": 0.3764705882352941, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.2235294117647059, 0.5176470588235295 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.2, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.38333333333333336, -0.033333333333333326 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.9915 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.42678197846541877, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.1924703040138163, 0.6722926454528143 ], "spearman": 0.5342164801675237, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.2339220648006278, 0.8226726581505253 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.1578744154402087, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.38988316276876767, 0.7115155753470971 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.257 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.2, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.04184137043778615, 0.2761530448893886 ], "spearman": 0.15, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.07945001786159712, 0.2911764705882353 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.3272012675161055, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.5946460922865887, -0.2603930907948321 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 80, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 68, "discordant_method_correct": 28, "discordant_base_correct": 40 } }, "nominal": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 14.955, "rel2": 13.67, "rel3": 12.775, "rel4": 12.505, "nonoise_s1001": 3.73, "nonoise_s1002": 13.71, "nonoise_s1003": 7.855, "nonoise_s1004": 3.71, "release_s1001": 9.17, "release_s1002": 3.845, "release_s1003": 10.045, "release_s1004": 10.075, "robust_s1001": 4.33, "robust_s1002": 4.295, "robust_s1003": 6.125, "robust_s1004": 5.205 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1004", "nonoise_s1001", "release_s1002", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "rel4", "rel3", "rel2", "nonoise_s1002", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.88, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.94, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 94, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 5.623404284741016, "rel2": 5.263829776581297, "rel3": 5.145744694040177, "rel4": 5.111702130195942, "nonoise_s1001": 4.660638314612369, "nonoise_s1002": 5.297872373398314, "nonoise_s1003": 4.793617015189313, "nonoise_s1004": 4.660638314612369, "release_s1001": 4.838297869296784, "release_s1002": 4.663829803466797, "release_s1003": 4.880851065858882, "release_s1004": 4.93297874673884, "robust_s1001": 4.680851081584362, "robust_s1002": 4.675531930111824, "robust_s1003": 4.748936188981888, "robust_s1004": 4.703191498492626 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.12, "ci95": [ 0.08, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.105, "ci95": [ 0.07, 0.145 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.105, "ci95": [ 0.07, 0.145 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.35, "ci95": [ 0.285, 0.41 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.065 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.095, "ci95": [ 0.055, 0.145 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.22, "ci95": [ 0.16, 0.285 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.21, "ci95": [ 0.165, 0.26 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.225, "ci95": [ 0.18, 0.275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.445, "ci95": [ 0.395, 0.485 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.065, "ci95": [ 0.03, 0.105 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.06 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.17, "ci95": [ 0.115, 0.23 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.27, "ci95": [ 0.205, 0.335 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.06 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.375, "ci95": [ 0.33, 0.42 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.5, "ci95": [ 0.46, 0.5351249999999993 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.09, "ci95": [ 0.04987500000000001, 0.14 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.06, "ci95": [ 0.03, 0.09 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.195, "ci95": [ 0.135, 0.2551249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.285, "ci95": [ 0.22, 0.35 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.065 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.52, "ci95": [ 0.47, 0.565 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.09, "ci95": [ 0.04987500000000001, 0.14 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.06, "ci95": [ 0.03, 0.09 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.2, "ci95": [ 0.14, 0.26 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.295, "ci95": [ 0.235, 0.355 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.065 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.885, "ci95": [ 0.845, 0.925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5, "ci95": [ 0.485, 0.515 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.97, "ci95": [ 0.95, 0.99 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.51, "ci95": [ 0.5, 0.525 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.945, "ci95": [ 0.915, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.895, "ci95": [ 0.86, 0.93 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.575, "ci95": [ 0.54, 0.615 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.57, "ci95": [ 0.539875, 0.61 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.725, "ci95": [ 0.68, 0.775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.695, "ci95": [ 0.655, 0.74 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.07 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.085 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.11, "ci95": [ 0.075, 0.145 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.67, "ci95": [ 0.61, 0.73 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.13, "ci95": [ 0.09, 0.175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.825, "ci95": [ 0.785, 0.865 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.74, "ci95": [ 0.705, 0.775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.14, "ci95": [ 0.1, 0.18 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.155, "ci95": [ 0.115, 0.195 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.34, "ci95": [ 0.28, 0.405 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.2, "ci95": [ 0.15987500000000002, 0.24512499999999932 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.97, "ci95": [ 0.95, 0.99 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.51, "ci95": [ 0.495, 0.53 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.945, "ci95": [ 0.915, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.9, "ci95": [ 0.865, 0.93 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.575, "ci95": [ 0.54, 0.61 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.57, "ci95": [ 0.54, 0.605 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.73, "ci95": [ 0.685, 0.78 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7, "ci95": [ 0.66, 0.745 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.65, "ci95": [ 0.595, 0.705 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.62, "ci95": [ 0.56, 0.675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.05, "ci95": [ 0.024875000000000008, 0.085 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.02, 0.07012499999999933 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.185, "ci95": [ 0.12987500000000002, 0.245 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.06, "ci95": [ 0.035, 0.09 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.94, "ci95": [ 0.91, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.88, "ci95": [ 0.84, 0.92 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.565, "ci95": [ 0.525, 0.605 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.555, "ci95": [ 0.525, 0.59 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.715, "ci95": [ 0.67, 0.765 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.68, "ci95": [ 0.635, 0.725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.56, "ci95": [ 0.49, 0.62 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.07, "ci95": [ 0.04, 0.105 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.07, "ci95": [ 0.04, 0.1 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.15, "ci95": [ 0.1, 0.205 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.08, "ci95": [ 0.05, 0.11 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.13, "ci95": [ 0.095, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.14, "ci95": [ 0.105, 0.18 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.22, "ci95": [ 0.165, 0.28 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.145, "ci95": [ 0.10987500000000001, 0.185 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.495, "ci95": [ 0.465, 0.525 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.67, "ci95": [ 0.615, 0.7251249999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.62, "ci95": [ 0.58, 0.665 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.675, "ci95": [ 0.62, 0.73 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.63, "ci95": [ 0.59, 0.675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.395, "ci95": [ 0.33487500000000003, 0.455 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 113, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 14.695, 15.19 ], "rel2": [ 13.444875, 13.9 ], "rel3": [ 12.57, 12.975 ], "rel4": [ 12.28, 12.725124999999998 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.54, 3.915 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 13.535, 13.870124999999998 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.49, 8.215124999999999 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.52, 3.88 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.915, 9.415 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.635, 4.06 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.684875, 10.41 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.57, 10.54 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.08, 4.6 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.07, 4.535 ], "robust_s1003": [ 5.679875, 6.6 ], "robust_s1004": [ 4.955, 5.480125 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5333333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.4303234246969298, 0.6166666666666667 ], "spearman": 0.7617647058823529, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6818733069388118, 0.8176470588235294 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.0, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.2689075630252101, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.06038545898555877, 0.5883604528199821 ], "spearman": 0.3321060382916053, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.09823836282331362, 0.7813063958363201 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.0, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5272012675161055, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.4937281711658766, 0.6778302010921357 ], "spearman": 0.7696837992496278, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7402503843643647, 0.8535690316726274 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.0, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 92, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 0, "discordant_method_correct": 0, "discordant_base_correct": 0 } }, "obs_0.5": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 14.93775, "rel2": 13.647499999999996, "rel3": 12.796999999999993, "rel4": 12.477249999999996, "nonoise_s1001": 3.675750000000001, "nonoise_s1002": 13.913999999999998, "nonoise_s1003": 7.727749999999999, "nonoise_s1004": 3.767750000000001, "release_s1001": 8.901250000000003, "release_s1002": 3.89975, "release_s1003": 10.136500000000002, "release_s1004": 10.404249999999998, "robust_s1001": 4.3012500000000005, "robust_s1002": 4.232000000000001, "robust_s1003": 5.99625, "robust_s1004": 5.184000000000001 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "rel4", "rel3", "rel2", "nonoise_s1002", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.88, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.94, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1880, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 5.624202151628251, "rel2": 5.2632978680286, "rel3": 5.148138303959623, "rel4": 5.107925534882444, "nonoise_s1001": 4.664521292549498, "nonoise_s1002": 5.324361719856871, "nonoise_s1003": 4.7952659662733685, "nonoise_s1004": 4.667127676213041, "release_s1001": 4.836276596530955, "release_s1002": 4.671223418890162, "release_s1003": 4.883404242611946, "release_s1004": 4.938244699417276, "robust_s1001": 4.684787251721037, "robust_s1002": 4.678989374003512, "robust_s1003": 4.751702146200423, "robust_s1004": 4.706861710802038 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.11899999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.08, 0.16027499999999983 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.11125, "ci95": [ 0.07275000000000001, 0.15150624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.10825, "ci95": [ 0.07049375000000001, 0.14875624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.38025, "ci95": [ 0.3137375, 0.44325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.02125, "ci95": [ 0.006, 0.039756249999999965 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0075, "ci95": [ 0.0005, 0.020256249999999965 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.09000000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.05074374999999999, 0.13475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.21725000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.15499374999999999, 0.2790249999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0075, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.019500000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.22, "ci95": [ 0.17671875, 0.26775625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.22474999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.17999375000000004, 0.2725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.49024999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.44274375, 0.5325 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.049, "ci95": [ 0.022243749999999996, 0.07875 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.03175, "ci95": [ 0.012500000000000002, 0.05274999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.15375, "ci95": [ 0.10499375000000002, 0.2064999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.2705, "ci95": [ 0.20398124999999998, 0.33625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0315, "ci95": [ 0.009, 0.059000000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.36200000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.31849375, 0.40474999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.563, "ci95": [ 0.5175, 0.61025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.06225, "ci95": [ 0.03225, 0.09501249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.04825, "ci95": [ 0.023750000000000004, 0.07300624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.17825, "ci95": [ 0.124, 0.23325625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.2865, "ci95": [ 0.22149375000000002, 0.35074999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.034, "ci95": [ 0.01149375, 0.06150624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.58075, "ci95": [ 0.5287500000000002, 0.63175625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.06574999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.03549375, 0.09999999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.05175, "ci95": [ 0.026243749999999996, 0.07900624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.18950000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.13524375, 0.24624999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.29275, "ci95": [ 0.23000000000000007, 0.3552624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.03725, "ci95": [ 0.01324375, 0.06600624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8832499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8492500000000001, 0.91625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.51225, "ci95": [ 0.49924999999999997, 0.52575625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.96075, "ci95": [ 0.93974375, 0.97875 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.52125, "ci95": [ 0.5080000000000001, 0.5375062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.96675, "ci95": [ 0.946, 0.98500625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.9272499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8997499999999999, 0.95375625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5760000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5452437500000001, 0.6092562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.56575, "ci95": [ 0.53724375, 0.5975000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7155, "ci95": [ 0.6692500000000001, 0.7617562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6955, "ci95": [ 0.6562375000000001, 0.73425625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.002, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.00425 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.021750000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.00724375, 0.04125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.003, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.009750000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.0037500000000000007, 0.0175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.048249999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.01624375, 0.09000624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037000000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0030000000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.00375, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.00825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.00075, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.00225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.12274999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.09050000000000001, 0.15575 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.64375, "ci95": [ 0.6037437499999997, 0.6852562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.13849999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.10424375, 0.17575624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8337499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8009875000000001, 0.8650000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7800000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7507437499999997, 0.8107562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.14900000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.11473750000000002, 0.1865 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.15475000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.12200000000000001, 0.18725000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.3335, "ci95": [ 0.27625000000000005, 0.39451249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.19975000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.16650000000000006, 0.23500000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9555000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9345, 0.9740000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.509, "ci95": [ 0.49375, 0.5275062500000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9620000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.94125, 0.9807499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.9239999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.89625, 0.9510000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.565, "ci95": [ 0.5402437499999999, 0.5927562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5535, "ci95": [ 0.5289812500000002, 0.5800000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.711, "ci95": [ 0.66449375, 0.75725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6872499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6499937500000001, 0.7252500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.04925000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.030493749999999993, 0.07075624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6920000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6557437499999998, 0.72700625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6672499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6219875, 0.7112499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.06549999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.039493749999999994, 0.09549999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.064, "ci95": [ 0.04250000000000001, 0.08850000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.20099999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.14900000000000005, 0.25575 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.08074999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.056749999999999995, 0.10675000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.95075, "ci95": [ 0.9257312499999999, 0.97225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.909, "ci95": [ 0.8729937500000001, 0.94 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.55475, "ci95": [ 0.52324375, 0.5874999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.54125, "ci95": [ 0.51774375, 0.56875625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6927500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6467375, 0.73775625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6727500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6345000000000002, 0.7107499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5815, "ci95": [ 0.5247375000000001, 0.63675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.057249999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.030999999999999996, 0.08775624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.05825, "ci95": [ 0.035750000000000004, 0.08224999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.12425000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.08424374999999999, 0.16950624999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.06875, "ci95": [ 0.04425000000000002, 0.094 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.09375, "ci95": [ 0.06524375, 0.12399999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.106, "ci95": [ 0.07624375000000001, 0.13900624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.18525, "ci95": [ 0.13399375, 0.24075624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.115, "ci95": [ 0.08549375000000001, 0.146 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.488, "ci95": [ 0.45824374999999995, 0.516 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.66175, "ci95": [ 0.6047500000000001, 0.7177562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.62025, "ci95": [ 0.58375, 0.6587499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6652499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6087375, 0.7179999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6352500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.60075, 0.6712500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.408, "ci95": [ 0.34824374999999996, 0.46776249999999997 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 116, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 14.689649999999995, 15.171762499999998 ], "rel2": [ 13.42496249999999, 13.866031250000008 ], "rel3": [ 12.619237499999999, 12.968799999999998 ], "rel4": [ 12.276231249999993, 12.671768749999995 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.5129625, 3.8385375000000024 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 13.721731249999994, 14.097093749999997 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.429968749999994, 8.020024999999997 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.6177500000000005, 3.9127562499999997 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.700987500000004, 9.092249999999998 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.731743749999999, 4.096249999999999 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.861000000000004, 10.409543750000001 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.984381249999998, 10.8317875 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.089206250000001, 4.552812499999999 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.036668750000001, 4.443518750000001 ], "robust_s1003": [ 5.547725, 6.453268750000002 ], "robust_s1004": [ 4.96299375, 5.415581250000002 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.55, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.45, 0.6333333333333333 ], "spearman": 0.7676470588235295, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6970588235294117, 0.8205882352941176 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.01666666666666672, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.01666666666666672, 0.050000000000000044 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.221 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.2928895930645031, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.05043276876802607, 0.5941474602165634 ], "spearman": 0.3428992834133141, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.08546146844737754, 0.7846943808111649 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.023982030039293, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.026929781498363715, 0.04156772892513653 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.2025 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.55, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5, 0.6833333333333333 ], "spearman": 0.7823529411764706, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7470588235294118, 0.8588235294117647 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.022798732483894524, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.02720126751610552, 0.0450772685621208 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.2965 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 93, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 1, "discordant_method_correct": 1, "discordant_base_correct": 0 } }, "paper_tr": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 15.094250000000002, "rel2": 13.699750000000002, "rel3": 12.930750000000003, "rel4": 12.558250000000005, "nonoise_s1001": 3.7757499999999995, "nonoise_s1002": 13.745249999999999, "nonoise_s1003": 7.742999999999999, "nonoise_s1004": 3.7827499999999996, "release_s1001": 9.2065, "release_s1002": 4.0125, "release_s1003": 9.77875, "release_s1004": 9.835999999999999, "robust_s1001": 4.336499999999999, "robust_s1002": 4.25075, "robust_s1003": 6.035749999999999, "robust_s1004": 5.2135 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "rel4", "rel3", "rel2", "nonoise_s1002", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.883, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.9415, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1883, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 5.6370685239833405, "rel2": 5.268932557144003, "rel3": 5.149283061176934, "rel4": 5.109134363988835, "nonoise_s1001": 4.660223060381013, "nonoise_s1002": 5.262719081553511, "nonoise_s1003": 4.784864590133813, "nonoise_s1004": 4.660435488169584, "release_s1001": 4.833722786136086, "release_s1002": 4.666967615825473, "release_s1003": 4.8609134249401045, "release_s1004": 4.902442911743675, "robust_s1001": 4.67875731529483, "robust_s1002": 4.672172079172403, "robust_s1003": 4.74445035960278, "robust_s1004": 4.70127456870664 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.10225, "ci95": [ 0.07125, 0.13749999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.09075, "ci95": [ 0.061243750000000007, 0.12300624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.08825, "ci95": [ 0.06000000000000001, 0.12024999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.35424999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.28974374999999997, 0.41550000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.013000000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.005000000000000001, 0.023 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.014250000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.006000000000000001, 0.024249999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.05975, "ci95": [ 0.03475, 0.08925624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.17475, "ci95": [ 0.11949375, 0.2325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0085, "ci95": [ 0.00225, 0.0165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.23075000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.19150000000000003, 0.2710062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.22525000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.18724375000000001, 0.2645 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.45425, "ci95": [ 0.41125, 0.49500625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.037000000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.022499999999999996, 0.05275624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.04375000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0265, 0.06225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.1285, "ci95": [ 0.09174374999999999, 0.16674999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.2545, "ci95": [ 0.1932375, 0.318 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0285, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.05050624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.344, "ci95": [ 0.3087500000000001, 0.38175000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.51525, "ci95": [ 0.47800000000000004, 0.55225 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.04274999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.026493749999999996, 0.06075624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.05050000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.03275, 0.07000624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.142, "ci95": [ 0.10400000000000001, 0.18124999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.266, "ci95": [ 0.20275, 0.32775625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.03025, "ci95": [ 0.011000000000000001, 0.05275624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.5385000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.49624374999999993, 0.58125 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.046999999999999986, "ci95": [ 0.029750000000000002, 0.06600624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.05575000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.03774999999999999, 0.07525625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.15100000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.11299374999999998, 0.19025625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.27125, "ci95": [ 0.20774374999999998, 0.33299999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.035750000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.01575, 0.059006249999999975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8782499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8585000000000003, 0.89775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.50075, "ci95": [ 0.49574999999999997, 0.5047499999999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9627500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9484999999999999, 0.9755000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.525, "ci95": [ 0.5122499999999998, 0.5417499999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9415, "ci95": [ 0.9222499999999999, 0.9594999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.88575, "ci95": [ 0.8624937499999998, 0.9092499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5695, "ci95": [ 0.5507499999999999, 0.5905000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5585, "ci95": [ 0.54375, 0.5752562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7097500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6714937500000001, 0.74875625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6925, "ci95": [ 0.6667500000000001, 0.7180062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0027500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.041749999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.01974375, 0.06950624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.002, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.006999999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.002, 0.013000000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.01399375, 0.0855 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0007500000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0055, "ci95": [ 0.0012437500000000003, 0.011000000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.00225, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.006250000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.1225, "ci95": [ 0.10275000000000008, 0.14175000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.6769999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6484937499999999, 0.7065062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.1425, "ci95": [ 0.11599375000000005, 0.17275624999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.792, "ci95": [ 0.76899375, 0.8159999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7197500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6864999999999999, 0.7529999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.14875, "ci95": [ 0.12399375000000011, 0.17425624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.15075000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.12674375, 0.17449999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.3435, "ci95": [ 0.29125, 0.3990124999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.18100000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.15849375000000002, 0.20549999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9627500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9482437499999999, 0.97575 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.52375, "ci95": [ 0.5097437499999998, 0.5420062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9415, "ci95": [ 0.922, 0.9595062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.88625, "ci95": [ 0.8629875, 0.90925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.56875, "ci95": [ 0.5509937499999997, 0.5887499999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5572499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5417499999999997, 0.5752499999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7087500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6704999999999999, 0.7474999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6915, "ci95": [ 0.6652437499999999, 0.7177500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.042249999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.028249999999999997, 0.05750624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.617, "ci95": [ 0.5887437500000002, 0.6432500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5844999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5319999999999999, 0.6355124999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.056749999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.03499374999999999, 0.08499999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.05025, "ci95": [ 0.03449374999999999, 0.06699999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.18675, "ci95": [ 0.14049999999999999, 0.23625624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0645, "ci95": [ 0.04825, 0.08174999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.92925, "ci95": [ 0.9062500000000001, 0.9504999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8640000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.83, 0.89375625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.54425, "ci95": [ 0.5187437499999998, 0.56975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5302500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5139999999999997, 0.5452499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6875, "ci95": [ 0.6509999999999998, 0.7262499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6677500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6399999999999999, 0.694 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.54325, "ci95": [ 0.48575000000000046, 0.5967500000000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.07550000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.05, 0.10450624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.07550000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.053993750000000014, 0.09825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.15100000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.11300000000000003, 0.1922562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0855, "ci95": [ 0.06375000000000001, 0.10899999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.135, "ci95": [ 0.10925000000000001, 0.16324999999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.14150000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.11449999999999999, 0.17175000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.22524999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.1794875, 0.27574999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.15725, "ci95": [ 0.13049999999999995, 0.187 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.488, "ci95": [ 0.466, 0.5097499999999997 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6597500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.61474375, 0.70525 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6242499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5979937499999999, 0.6502562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.66375, "ci95": [ 0.6202500000000001, 0.7084999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6382499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6142500000000001, 0.66275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.40875, "ci95": [ 0.35325, 0.46350625000000023 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 115, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 14.885231249999999, 15.29351250000001 ], "rel2": [ 13.505487499999997, 13.889781250000002 ], "rel3": [ 12.787725000000005, 13.070287500000004 ], "rel4": [ 12.396737499999999, 12.722268749999996 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.67424375, 3.8778 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 13.569993750000002, 13.909550000000001 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.542743750000001, 7.9330187500000005 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.6799937499999995, 3.890249999999998 ], "release_s1001": [ 9.035475, 9.376749999999998 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.8692312500000017, 4.18250625 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.551199999999998, 10.007531249999994 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.401206250000001, 10.280268750000001 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.16274375, 4.53961875 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.120243749999999, 4.396274999999999 ], "robust_s1003": [ 5.63245, 6.457506250000002 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.0577375, 5.377768750000002 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.55, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.43333333333333335, 0.6166666666666667 ], "spearman": 0.7676470588235295, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6881617647058823, 0.8205882352941176 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.01666666666666672, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.027410912041448854, 0.03333333333333338 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.496 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.2761530448893886, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.07533049143159656, 0.5775337676422397 ], "spearman": 0.3370126004362615, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.09816611024821363, 0.7770627260083212 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.007245481864178505, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.042687767085402964, 0.02439856701072614 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.608 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.55, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5, 0.6666666666666666 ], "spearman": 0.788235294117647, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7441176470588236, 0.8558823529411764 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.022798732483894524, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.044357104741906794, 0.0448024307276763 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.422 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 93, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 1, "discordant_method_correct": 1, "discordant_base_correct": 0 } }, "paper_tr_x2": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 15.1095, "rel2": 13.751499999999995, "rel3": 12.959000000000003, "rel4": 12.595000000000002, "nonoise_s1001": 3.827500000000001, "nonoise_s1002": 13.717250000000002, "nonoise_s1003": 7.712500000000002, "nonoise_s1004": 3.8445000000000005, "release_s1001": 9.2985, "release_s1002": 3.983, "release_s1003": 9.653000000000002, "release_s1004": 9.72, "robust_s1001": 4.399, "robust_s1002": 4.265250000000001, "robust_s1003": 5.961749999999999, "robust_s1004": 5.20275 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "rel4", "rel3", "nonoise_s1002", "rel2", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.892, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.946, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1892, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 5.74513742838047, "rel2": 5.27684989325844, "rel3": 5.151849896660819, "rel4": 5.105285410523162, "nonoise_s1001": 4.646300221472411, "nonoise_s1002": 5.229704025935925, "nonoise_s1003": 4.765909098797571, "nonoise_s1004": 4.646828762320585, "release_s1001": 4.815327698660199, "release_s1002": 4.651691341374944, "release_s1003": 4.83699787645965, "release_s1004": 4.877272733926269, "robust_s1001": 4.666279079294104, "robust_s1002": 4.657875273998898, "robust_s1003": 4.7247885949515895, "robust_s1004": 4.686680764022892 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.10550000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.07524375, 0.14000624999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.09050000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0625, 0.12275624999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.09025, "ci95": [ 0.06299375, 0.12125624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.35450000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.28924375, 0.41575 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0165, "ci95": [ 0.007243749999999999, 0.028506249999999966 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0215, "ci95": [ 0.01175, 0.032999999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.054000000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.03299375, 0.07775624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.14725, "ci95": [ 0.09999374999999996, 0.19600624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.010249999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.0027500000000000003, 0.01975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.22724999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.18875, 0.2662562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.22399999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.1855, 0.26326249999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.45125, "ci95": [ 0.4047500000000001, 0.4935 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.038500000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.0245, 0.055006249999999965 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.051, "ci95": [ 0.034243749999999996, 0.06849999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.11025, "ci95": [ 0.07999374999999999, 0.14075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.22574999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.17074374999999997, 0.28150625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.025249999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.011000000000000001, 0.04075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0007500000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.34550000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.3102500000000001, 0.38250625000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.51025, "ci95": [ 0.47100000000000003, 0.5492624999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.04550000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.030493749999999993, 0.06225624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.059750000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.042249999999999996, 0.07774999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.12775, "ci95": [ 0.09699374999999998, 0.16026249999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.23974999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.1839875, 0.295 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.029500000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.01425, 0.04625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0007500000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.53425, "ci95": [ 0.4904937499999999, 0.5782499999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.04800000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.03275, 0.06525 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.064, "ci95": [ 0.04675, 0.08199999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0015000000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.13374999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.10300000000000002, 0.1657562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.24674999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.19123125, 0.3032499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.03625, "ci95": [ 0.019500000000000003, 0.05375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.00125, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.00275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.9995, "ci95": [ 0.9984999999999999, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.86775, "ci95": [ 0.85175, 0.8837499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5025, "ci95": [ 0.4979999999999998, 0.5062499999999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9634999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.95149375, 0.9745062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.5155, "ci95": [ 0.5052437499999998, 0.5292499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9345, "ci95": [ 0.9159999999999999, 0.9522499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8795000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8580000000000001, 0.9002562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.569, "ci95": [ 0.55475, 0.5855062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.55425, "ci95": [ 0.5445, 0.5654999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.70075, "ci95": [ 0.6659937499999997, 0.7367499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6857500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6635000000000002, 0.7082500000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.004, "ci95": [ 0.0012437500000000003, 0.0075000000000000015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0015000000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.04675, "ci95": [ 0.02375, 0.07401249999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.00375, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.008268749999999898 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.009750000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.00475, 0.01575 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.044250000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.014000000000000004, 0.08325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.010249999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.039 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.006749999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.00224375, 0.01225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0055, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.13125, "ci95": [ 0.1155, 0.14725000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.6875000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6670000000000003, 0.7090000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.14625, "ci95": [ 0.12549375000000002, 0.1695062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7865000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7682499999999998, 0.8052499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.723, "ci95": [ 0.6927500000000003, 0.7542500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.16075, "ci95": [ 0.13950000000000004, 0.18500625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.15725, "ci95": [ 0.14075000000000001, 0.17400624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.336, "ci95": [ 0.28899375, 0.3867625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.17924999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.16025000000000006, 0.20099999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.96375, "ci95": [ 0.9519999999999998, 0.9745062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.51225, "ci95": [ 0.5012500000000001, 0.5267562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.93525, "ci95": [ 0.91675, 0.95250625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8802500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.85925, 0.9005062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5665, "ci95": [ 0.5524999999999999, 0.5827499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.55075, "ci95": [ 0.5407499999999998, 0.5624999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6987499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6637499999999998, 0.7349999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6822499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6607500000000001, 0.7045 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.040249999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.028750000000000005, 0.052749999999999984 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.5987500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.57525, 0.6215062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5780000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5295000000000002, 0.6267499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.056749999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.036750000000000005, 0.08325624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.048499999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.03575, 0.06175624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.179, "ci95": [ 0.13825000000000004, 0.22325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.05800000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.04549375, 0.07100000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9245, "ci95": [ 0.9022437500000002, 0.94475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8632499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8335000000000001, 0.8887562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.55375, "ci95": [ 0.5339999999999998, 0.5727499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5365, "ci95": [ 0.5224937499999994, 0.5482499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6854999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.6504937499999996, 0.7222500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.672, "ci95": [ 0.6482437499999999, 0.69475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.55775, "ci95": [ 0.5057437499999999, 0.6077562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.08474999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.060993750000000006, 0.11275624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0805, "ci95": [ 0.06149374999999999, 0.10075625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1495, "ci95": [ 0.11450000000000003, 0.18575625000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0895, "ci95": [ 0.06825, 0.11300624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.14175000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.11900000000000001, 0.16899999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.145, "ci95": [ 0.12175000000000004, 0.16975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.222, "ci95": [ 0.17825000000000002, 0.2702562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.15675, "ci95": [ 0.13150000000000003, 0.18400000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.4832500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.46523749999999986, 0.4987499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6457499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.60473125, 0.68825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6155, "ci95": [ 0.5920000000000002, 0.6387562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6562500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6164937500000001, 0.6977624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6355, "ci95": [ 0.6137499999999999, 0.6574999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.41975, "ci95": [ 0.36774999999999997, 0.47050624999999996 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 117, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 14.90645, 15.305287499999993 ], "rel2": [ 13.570237499999998, 13.932275 ], "rel3": [ 12.82498125000001, 13.0972625 ], "rel4": [ 12.4479875, 12.748537500000001 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.7352500000000024, 3.919756250000001 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 13.528237500000003, 13.900006250000002 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.566474999999999, 7.852262500000002 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.7517250000000026, 3.936793750000001 ], "release_s1001": [ 9.1574875, 9.438749999999999 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.856975, 4.128025 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.454250000000004, 9.843512500000005 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.333237499999997, 10.125781250000001 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.239999999999999, 4.600574999999999 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.159487499999999, 4.374756250000001 ], "robust_s1003": [ 5.580481250000001, 6.3562625 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.0565, 5.367756250000005 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5333333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.43333333333333335, 0.6166666666666667 ], "spearman": 0.7617647058823529, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6911651187879028, 0.8205882352941176 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.0, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.027480793549896743, 0.04999999999999993 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.388 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.25941649671427414, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.08403658068160179, 0.5655962116720425 ], "spearman": 0.32671090522641943, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.10376876400020298, 0.7719835688366588 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.009491066310935936, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.047282720087190026, 0.008578853644578967 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.872 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5666666666666667, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5166666666666667, 0.6945667492672501 ], "spearman": 0.7970588235294118, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7528676470588235, 0.8647058823529412 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.03946539915056113, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.04407757870811557, 0.07286861399234235 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.188 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 92, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 2, "discordant_method_correct": 1, "discordant_base_correct": 1 } }, "paper_tr_x4": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 15.308250000000001, "rel2": 13.882499999999995, "rel3": 13.024250000000002, "rel4": 12.607999999999997, "nonoise_s1001": 3.871250000000001, "nonoise_s1002": 13.657749999999995, "nonoise_s1003": 8.03775, "nonoise_s1004": 3.8689999999999998, "release_s1001": 9.021, "release_s1002": 4.001750000000002, "release_s1003": 9.483249999999996, "release_s1004": 9.753250000000003, "robust_s1001": 4.412749999999997, "robust_s1002": 4.2490000000000006, "robust_s1003": 5.794499999999999, "robust_s1004": 5.02575 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1004", "nonoise_s1001", "release_s1002", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "rel4", "rel3", "nonoise_s1002", "rel2", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.959, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.997, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.978, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1956, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 6.4562372198377895, "rel2": 5.314621679743862, "rel3": 5.178629864944271, "rel4": 5.123261764736995, "nonoise_s1001": 4.58859918588022, "nonoise_s1002": 5.175000006313948, "nonoise_s1003": 4.721983636571342, "nonoise_s1004": 4.5882924374627185, "release_s1001": 4.752862981004461, "release_s1002": 4.593865033673363, "release_s1003": 4.779856846498322, "release_s1004": 4.826533752106938, "robust_s1001": 4.605572599087268, "robust_s1002": 4.5985173832907025, "robust_s1003": 4.6579243353051885, "robust_s1004": 4.622239264242488 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.07800000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.05399999999999999, 0.10500624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.06525, "ci95": [ 0.044749999999999984, 0.08925000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.06199999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.041493749999999996, 0.08574999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.32025, "ci95": [ 0.2604874999999999, 0.37849999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.014750000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.00825, 0.022999999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0105, "ci95": [ 0.0055000000000000005, 0.016499999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.03375, "ci95": [ 0.0215, 0.048499999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.10525000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.07149375, 0.14226249999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.002, "ci95": [ 0.0005, 0.004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.21425, "ci95": [ 0.17949999999999997, 0.24999999999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.19925000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.16374375000000002, 0.23400624999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.43825, "ci95": [ 0.39274999999999993, 0.48176249999999987 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0435, "ci95": [ 0.030750000000000003, 0.05749999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.03375, "ci95": [ 0.02374374999999999, 0.044750000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.07975, "ci95": [ 0.057743749999999996, 0.10300000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.1725, "ci95": [ 0.13049375000000002, 0.21825624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.012750000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.006250000000000001, 0.020499999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0015000000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.0005, 0.00275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.33725, "ci95": [ 0.30249374999999995, 0.37225625000000023 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.49725, "ci95": [ 0.4570000000000001, 0.5380000000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.05325000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0395, 0.06825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.047, "ci95": [ 0.036243749999999984, 0.05875624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.10099999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.0785, 0.12375624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.19925, "ci95": [ 0.15649374999999996, 0.24425624999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.018250000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.010000000000000002, 0.0275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0017500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.0007500000000000001, 0.003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.5325, "ci95": [ 0.4927500000000001, 0.5727562500000003 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.05825, "ci95": [ 0.04375000000000001, 0.07349999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.05525, "ci95": [ 0.044, 0.06700625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.11200000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.08925000000000001, 0.13574999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.20775, "ci95": [ 0.16547500000000004, 0.25325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.023000000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.013000000000000001, 0.034249999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0017500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.0007500000000000001, 0.003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.99725, "ci95": [ 0.992, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8782499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.86, 0.8955062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.49875, "ci95": [ 0.4897437499999998, 0.5057499999999997 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9534999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.94124375, 0.96525 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.51325, "ci95": [ 0.5047499999999999, 0.5242499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9305, "ci95": [ 0.9124999999999999, 0.948 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8959999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8759937499999999, 0.91525625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5645, "ci95": [ 0.5502499999999999, 0.5802499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.54625, "ci95": [ 0.53775, 0.5552499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.69175, "ci95": [ 0.6629937499999997, 0.7235 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.65875, "ci95": [ 0.6362500000000003, 0.6817562499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.005750000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0017499999999999998, 0.011500000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0072499999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.038, "ci95": [ 0.01625, 0.06575624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.004750000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.0115 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.00975, "ci95": [ 0.0045, 0.01625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.0455, "ci95": [ 0.018743749999999997, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.009750000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.028999999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.00125, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0032499999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.00625, "ci95": [ 0.002, 0.01175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.00425, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.11875, "ci95": [ 0.10149375000000004, 0.13699999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.5867499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.56399375, 0.6127499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.13449999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.11400000000000005, 0.15775000000000008 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7275, "ci95": [ 0.7109999999999999, 0.7447499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7282499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.7034999999999999, 0.7542499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.14825, "ci95": [ 0.1257500000000001, 0.17399999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.14525, "ci95": [ 0.12674375000000004, 0.16375000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.273, "ci95": [ 0.23349374999999986, 0.31699999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.15375, "ci95": [ 0.13400000000000006, 0.17575 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.95525, "ci95": [ 0.94325, 0.96675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.511, "ci95": [ 0.5020000000000003, 0.5222500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.93125, "ci95": [ 0.9134937499999998, 0.9485062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.89775, "ci95": [ 0.8780000000000001, 0.91675625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5655, "ci95": [ 0.5532437499999996, 0.5794999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5439999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5349999999999998, 0.5537562499999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.691, "ci95": [ 0.6619937500000005, 0.7225062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6552500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6335000000000003, 0.67775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.049, "ci95": [ 0.03774999999999999, 0.06075000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6255, "ci95": [ 0.5994999999999999, 0.6502499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.622, "ci95": [ 0.5827437500000001, 0.6620062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0695, "ci95": [ 0.04925000000000001, 0.09475000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.05675000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.043500000000000004, 0.07025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.17325, "ci95": [ 0.14175000000000001, 0.20800000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.063, "ci95": [ 0.05075, 0.07600000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9217500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8992500000000001, 0.9417500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8802500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8539875000000001, 0.9047562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.55275, "ci95": [ 0.5347499999999997, 0.5704999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5307499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5184999999999998, 0.5412562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.68, "ci95": [ 0.6492437499999999, 0.7127500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6452499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6220000000000002, 0.66875 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5855000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5432375, 0.6300125000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.09175000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.06824374999999999, 0.11800000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.083, "ci95": [ 0.06374999999999999, 0.10350624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.14225, "ci95": [ 0.11249375000000006, 0.17450624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.087, "ci95": [ 0.06749999999999999, 0.10800624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.1225, "ci95": [ 0.10000000000000002, 0.1485 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.1285, "ci95": [ 0.10650000000000003, 0.15150624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.20225, "ci95": [ 0.16349375000000002, 0.24250625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.1335, "ci95": [ 0.10925000000000001, 0.16000625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.4800000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.4635000000000001, 0.49599999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6397499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.60524375, 0.6759999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.59225, "ci95": [ 0.5702437499999998, 0.6142499999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.65325, "ci95": [ 0.6187500000000001, 0.6887562500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6135, "ci95": [ 0.5904999999999999, 0.6364999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.41425000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.37025000000000013, 0.45575625000000025 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 117, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 15.1445, 15.457256250000002 ], "rel2": [ 13.722500000000007, 14.03676875 ], "rel3": [ 12.911731249999997, 13.13726875 ], "rel4": [ 12.479250000000002, 12.73775 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.7830000000000017, 3.9632499999999977 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 13.462993749999992, 13.848999999999998 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.881487500000004, 8.185268750000002 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.783731249999999, 3.9495062500000016 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.892725, 9.150275 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.883500000000002, 4.139012500000003 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.297243749999998, 9.6675125 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.441718750000003, 10.089999999999998 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.269712499999998, 4.602012499999998 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.14549375, 4.3565062500000025 ], "robust_s1003": [ 5.497950000000001, 6.113750000000001 ], "robust_s1004": [ 4.878, 5.186531250000001 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5166666666666667, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.43333333333333335, 0.6166666666666667 ], "spearman": 0.7558823529411764, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6852941176470588, 0.8235294117647058 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.016666666666666607, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.043661783732851185, 0.039325636133665576 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.5665 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.25941649671427414, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.075955452531275, 0.5774109120414489 ], "spearman": 0.32671090522641943, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.10372802646657872, 0.7756072739952867 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.009491066310935936, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.045465991963362457, 0.022629646420241255 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.8215 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.6166666666666667, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5166666666666667, 0.7166666666666667 ], "spearman": 0.8088235294117647, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7529411764705882, 0.8735294117647059 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.08946539915056118, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.044298969084314056, 0.10634171034257123 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.1535 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 91, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 1, "discordant_method_correct": 0, "discordant_base_correct": 1 } }, "pose_release": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 14.853249999999996, "rel2": 13.515500000000005, "rel3": 12.801499999999992, "rel4": 12.455999999999992, "nonoise_s1001": 3.8617499999999993, "nonoise_s1002": 13.875000000000007, "nonoise_s1003": 7.941000000000002, "nonoise_s1004": 3.9127500000000004, "release_s1001": 9.283, "release_s1002": 3.996749999999999, "release_s1003": 9.865, "release_s1004": 9.86125, "robust_s1001": 4.392250000000001, "robust_s1002": 4.281999999999999, "robust_s1003": 5.8537500000000025, "robust_s1004": 5.249250000000001 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1004", "release_s1003", "rel4", "rel3", "rel2", "nonoise_s1002", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.89, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.945, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1890, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 5.526560851884267, "rel2": 5.205396827818856, "rel3": 5.101269839806531, "rel4": 5.055026454521865, "nonoise_s1001": 4.624656083911815, "nonoise_s1002": 5.259682540981858, "nonoise_s1003": 4.758465607582576, "nonoise_s1004": 4.626084655491764, "release_s1001": 4.797566138436554, "release_s1002": 4.6288359790252, "release_s1003": 4.829894181786391, "release_s1004": 4.875132275321496, "robust_s1001": 4.640529100037126, "robust_s1002": 4.636296296182763, "robust_s1003": 4.704497351974407, "robust_s1004": 4.665132273883416 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.12200000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.11075000000000004, 0.13325000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.11574999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.10525000000000004, 0.12675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.113, "ci95": [ 0.10250000000000002, 0.12375624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.41050000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.37799374999999996, 0.44300624999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.03125, "ci95": [ 0.019249999999999996, 0.045500000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.02475, "ci95": [ 0.01525, 0.0355 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.10550000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.07625000000000001, 0.13600624999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.21224999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.15925000000000003, 0.2652562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.011749999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.006000000000000001, 0.01875 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.25425000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.2395, 0.26775625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.25, "ci95": [ 0.23474374999999995, 0.26525000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.49575, "ci95": [ 0.47, 0.52175625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.064, "ci95": [ 0.044000000000000004, 0.086 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.059500000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.04074375000000001, 0.07925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.17475000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.1362375, 0.21224999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.26975, "ci95": [ 0.21425000000000005, 0.32226249999999984 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0385, "ci95": [ 0.024249999999999994, 0.05424999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.36075, "ci95": [ 0.3484999999999999, 0.3735000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.54225, "ci95": [ 0.5145000000000002, 0.5725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.06925, "ci95": [ 0.04825, 0.09225625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.06724999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.04724999999999999, 0.0885 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.19174999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.15199374999999998, 0.23024999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.28725, "ci95": [ 0.23174375, 0.33974999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.05, "ci95": [ 0.03399374999999999, 0.06699999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.5617500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.52824375, 0.5977625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.07300000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.051, 0.0965 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.07624999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.05500000000000001, 0.09800624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.20174999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.16199374999999996, 0.23926249999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.2965, "ci95": [ 0.24100000000000002, 0.3500062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.05850000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.041749999999999995, 0.07599999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.9992500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.998, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8725, "ci95": [ 0.8579999999999999, 0.8862499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5065000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5019999999999999, 0.5109999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.964, "ci95": [ 0.95375, 0.9734999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.51475, "ci95": [ 0.5095000000000001, 0.5202499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.92875, "ci95": [ 0.9095000000000002, 0.9462562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.87625, "ci95": [ 0.861, 0.8910062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5657500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5559999999999998, 0.575 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5502499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.5429999999999999, 0.5577499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.67425, "ci95": [ 0.66125, 0.6870000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6859999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6632437500000001, 0.7085000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.006499999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.0027500000000000003, 0.011 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0024999999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0455, "ci95": [ 0.031493749999999994, 0.061500000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0030000000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.0007500000000000001, 0.006000000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.00825, "ci95": [ 0.00375, 0.01375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.03625, "ci95": [ 0.0275, 0.04500624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.00825, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.01225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.00375, "ci95": [ 0.00125, 0.007000000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.01875, "ci95": [ 0.012750000000000001, 0.02574999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0032500000000000007, "ci95": [ 0.0015, 0.0055000000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.12975, "ci95": [ 0.11625000000000005, 0.14425000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.6485, "ci95": [ 0.6330000000000001, 0.66375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.13949999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.12625000000000006, 0.15375000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.76975, "ci95": [ 0.7517499999999999, 0.7870000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7065, "ci95": [ 0.6849937500000001, 0.727 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.153, "ci95": [ 0.13850000000000007, 0.168 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.15325, "ci95": [ 0.13975000000000004, 0.16699999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.2975, "ci95": [ 0.27849999999999997, 0.31749999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.17775, "ci95": [ 0.16450000000000006, 0.1909999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9617500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9515, 0.97125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.508, "ci95": [ 0.5017500000000003, 0.5139999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9275, "ci95": [ 0.9082437499999999, 0.94525 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8747500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8592437499999999, 0.8899999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.559, "ci95": [ 0.5499999999999998, 0.5675000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.54375, "ci95": [ 0.5362499999999999, 0.55125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6702499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6572499999999998, 0.6827562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6794999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6572500000000001, 0.7012562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.038500000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.028749999999999994, 0.048756249999999966 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.603, "ci95": [ 0.58249375, 0.6225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5784999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5492499999999999, 0.6070000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.05675000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0455, 0.06875624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.049, "ci95": [ 0.03849999999999999, 0.06025000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.17799999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.15599375000000001, 0.2005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.06074999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.049243749999999975, 0.0725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9215000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9005000000000001, 0.94075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.86375, "ci95": [ 0.8490000000000001, 0.8782499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.55125, "ci95": [ 0.5395000000000001, 0.5619999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5362499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5302499999999997, 0.5427499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.66025, "ci95": [ 0.6469937499999998, 0.6732500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6739999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6507437500000001, 0.69750625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5347500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.49273750000000005, 0.57475 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.09, "ci95": [ 0.0705, 0.11150000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0855, "ci95": [ 0.066, 0.10675000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1635, "ci95": [ 0.14249375, 0.1875 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.09375, "ci95": [ 0.07375, 0.11500624999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.14200000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.12700000000000006, 0.15700624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.14775, "ci95": [ 0.13349375000000002, 0.16275625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.22525000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.20975, 0.24124999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.16024999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.14575000000000002, 0.17450000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.48450000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.4752500000000002, 0.49400000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6265000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6122437499999999, 0.6402499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.62275, "ci95": [ 0.6040000000000003, 0.6412500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6317499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6177499999999999, 0.6459999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6402500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.61699375, 0.6630000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.45099999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.4359937499999999, 0.4662562500000002 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 118, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 14.692743749999988, 15.00252499999999 ], "rel2": [ 13.348737500000011, 13.680750000000003 ], "rel3": [ 12.664243749999995, 12.937512499999995 ], "rel4": [ 12.320249999999998, 12.592024999999998 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.786493750000001, 3.9377499999999994 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 13.749981250000005, 14.007512500000002 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.834212500000001, 8.052756250000002 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.839500000000001, 3.9902687499999994 ], "release_s1001": [ 9.20099375, 9.364262499999999 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.920487499999998, 4.076762499999997 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.655712500000002, 10.073525000000005 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.545743750000002, 10.177287499999998 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.309737500000002, 4.477249999999999 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.200749999999998, 4.364262499999998 ], "robust_s1003": [ 5.70573125, 6.002024999999999 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.1249875, 5.370512500000003 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5333333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.4600932357603825, 0.6333333333333333 ], "spearman": 0.7647058823529411, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7, 0.8235294117647058 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.0, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.021861586959613554, 0.05020964452534338 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.221 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.2761530448893886, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.05910237578601138, 0.5823251360731083 ], "spearman": 0.3370126004362615, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.09435363876709092, 0.7805604930590949 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.007245481864178505, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.03817389740605963, 0.025598942112504557 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.4465 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.55, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5166666666666667, 0.6833333333333333 ], "spearman": 0.7823529411764706, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7499770102207486, 0.8594925064182863 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.022798732483894524, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.027760319583687854, 0.05641159185101907 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.2835 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 92, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 2, "discordant_method_correct": 1, "discordant_base_correct": 1 } }, "powertrain_speed": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 15.612999999999998, "rel2": 14.560000000000004, "rel3": 13.950750000000003, "rel4": 13.642500000000005, "nonoise_s1001": 4.312499999999999, "nonoise_s1002": 11.691749999999997, "nonoise_s1003": 7.990500000000001, "nonoise_s1004": 4.418749999999999, "release_s1001": 8.485000000000005, "release_s1002": 4.039250000000001, "release_s1003": 9.117, "release_s1004": 9.158499999999998, "robust_s1001": 4.794, "robust_s1002": 3.821749999999997, "robust_s1003": 5.108250000000001, "robust_s1004": 5.2965 }, "order": [ "robust_s1002", "release_s1002", "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1003", "robust_s1004", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "nonoise_s1002", "rel4", "rel3", "rel2", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.894, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.947, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1894, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 6.596990501112772, "rel2": 6.105279838270975, "rel3": 6.011562831298603, "rel4": 5.963569173465435, "nonoise_s1001": 4.105702215854822, "nonoise_s1002": 4.513146776584033, "nonoise_s1003": 4.221383315771661, "nonoise_s1004": 4.108922913308632, "release_s1001": 4.246251319882233, "release_s1002": 4.094931360471841, "release_s1003": 4.275395984697493, "release_s1004": 4.30095036914759, "robust_s1001": 4.123653642542133, "robust_s1002": 4.074392816396046, "robust_s1003": 4.114149946975104, "robust_s1004": 4.129514254448658 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.1235, "ci95": [ 0.09175000000000001, 0.15899999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.1115, "ci95": [ 0.08025000000000002, 0.14550624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.10825000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.07774375000000003, 0.14150624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.03825, "ci95": [ 0.02625, 0.05125624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0022500000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.0045000000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.0017499999999999998, 0.00775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.2577499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.22174999999999997, 0.29524999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.245, "ci95": [ 0.20973750000000002, 0.282 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.0475, "ci95": [ 0.034, 0.06124999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0032500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.00125, 0.005500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.009750000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.005000000000000001, 0.0155 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.3549999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.32150000000000006, 0.39025625000000014 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.049249999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.036499999999999984, 0.06225000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0035000000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.0015, 0.005750000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.0105, "ci95": [ 0.00575, 0.0165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.0515, "ci95": [ 0.03874999999999999, 0.065 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0035000000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.0015, 0.005750000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.0105, "ci95": [ 0.00575, 0.0165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.98425, "ci95": [ 0.9784999999999999, 0.99 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.87025, "ci95": [ 0.8547500000000002, 0.8852500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.51575, "ci95": [ 0.5082499999999999, 0.5229999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.89425, "ci95": [ 0.8799999999999999, 0.9084999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.4540000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.43975000000000014, 0.46874999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.90975, "ci95": [ 0.8929999999999998, 0.9257499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8965, "ci95": [ 0.8785000000000001, 0.9142562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.56575, "ci95": [ 0.5479999999999999, 0.5845000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.42550000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.4094937499999998, 0.44199999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5539999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5199812499999995, 0.5882562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6175, "ci95": [ 0.5979999999999998, 0.6379999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.062, "ci95": [ 0.049749999999999996, 0.07450624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.01625, "ci95": [ 0.0105, 0.022249999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.08574999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.06400000000000002, 0.11324999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.015499999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.008743750000000002, 0.023999999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.09274999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.08025000000000006, 0.10500000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.099, "ci95": [ 0.069, 0.13575624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.024999999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.01125, 0.04975624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.01825, "ci95": [ 0.01125, 0.026249999999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0385, "ci95": [ 0.0255, 0.05424999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.026000000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.016249999999999997, 0.03799999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.13874999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.12375000000000008, 0.15499999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.5782500000000002, "ci95": [ 0.55449375, 0.6042562499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.12599999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.10924374999999997, 0.1447562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.71, "ci95": [ 0.6920000000000005, 0.7307562500000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7105, "ci95": [ 0.6805000000000001, 0.7425 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.15425, "ci95": [ 0.1330000000000001, 0.18100624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.12325000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.10550000000000008, 0.14175625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.218, "ci95": [ 0.18324999999999975, 0.25375624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.18275, "ci95": [ 0.16599374999999997, 0.2022499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.8877499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.8734999999999998, 0.90150625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.43925, "ci95": [ 0.42550000000000004, 0.4537562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9079999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8912499999999998, 0.9237499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8939999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8755, 0.9115000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.54925, "ci95": [ 0.5315, 0.56875 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.4202499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4040000000000001, 0.4362499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5472499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5127437499999996, 0.5810062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.60625, "ci95": [ 0.5875000000000002, 0.6259999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.10125, "ci95": [ 0.08699375, 0.11550000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.62275, "ci95": [ 0.5972437500000001, 0.6465000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6459999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6062500000000002, 0.68450625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.12225000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.10250000000000008, 0.14650624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.1185, "ci95": [ 0.10000000000000007, 0.137 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.20199999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.17500000000000004, 0.23 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.149, "ci95": [ 0.13049999999999998, 0.16624999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9072499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8884999999999998, 0.9240062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.89375, "ci95": [ 0.8724937500000001, 0.9130062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5972500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.57525, 0.6197500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.45299999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.43799999999999994, 0.46749999999999964 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5902499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5539999999999999, 0.6245062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6552499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.63925, 0.6714999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.56275, "ci95": [ 0.5159999999999997, 0.6090125000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.10399999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.08275000000000002, 0.13000000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.10325000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.08499375, 0.12275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.154, "ci95": [ 0.12975000000000006, 0.18099999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.12075000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.10150000000000006, 0.14225000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.11774999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.09699375000000005, 0.14300000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.12075, "ci95": [ 0.09975000000000002, 0.14175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.191, "ci95": [ 0.1585, 0.2249999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.14975000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.12825000000000003, 0.17199999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.3872500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.3634999999999999, 0.4100062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5105, "ci95": [ 0.47150000000000003, 0.55025 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.54375, "ci95": [ 0.5152500000000001, 0.57300625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.65125, "ci95": [ 0.6132437500000001, 0.6900000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6970000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6807437499999999, 0.71475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.5485, "ci95": [ 0.5090000000000001, 0.58725625 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 119, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 15.505499999999993, 15.710774999999995 ], "rel2": [ 14.505993750000002, 14.61676250000001 ], "rel3": [ 13.897993749999998, 14.005499999999998 ], "rel4": [ 13.556493749999998, 13.731000000000003 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 4.2244562499999985, 4.404006249999999 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 11.572993750000002, 11.803025000000005 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.863250000000002, 8.114768749999998 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 4.337481249999996, 4.503006249999999 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.336737500000005, 8.640506250000001 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.932987500000001, 4.1607875000000005 ], "release_s1003": [ 8.95524375, 9.27801875 ], "release_s1004": [ 8.925250000000002, 9.3967625 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.610424999999999, 5.0175125000000005 ], "robust_s1002": [ 3.6792124999999976, 3.9720062499999975 ], "robust_s1003": [ 4.80493125, 5.409499999999996 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.176243749999997, 5.423774999999997 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.6, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5, 0.6666666666666666 ], "spearman": 0.7764705882352941, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7058823529411765, 0.8470588235294118 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.06666666666666665, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.005712776766541028, 0.10041928905068676 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.0215 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.32636268941473195, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.017605533560107817, 0.6443571047419068 ], "spearman": 0.3679176860657877, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.06333791679918624, 0.8108986398111007 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.05745512638952188, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.009210460980846748, 0.09092822273975082 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.037 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.6666666666666666, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.6, 0.8166666666666667 ], "spearman": 0.8352941176470589, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7822794117647058, 0.9352941176470588 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.1394653991505611, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.022436722049673768, 0.2224493249416556 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.0065 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 96, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 10, "discordant_method_correct": 7, "discordant_base_correct": 3 } }, "rate_0.1": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 5.935, "rel2": 4.905, "rel3": 5.58, "rel4": 6.75, "nonoise_s1001": 9.085, "nonoise_s1002": 13.11, "nonoise_s1003": 13.925, "nonoise_s1004": 11.01, "release_s1001": 11.96, "release_s1002": 7.495, "release_s1003": 12.755, "release_s1004": 12.27, "robust_s1001": 8.575, "robust_s1002": 3.12, "robust_s1003": 3.17, "robust_s1004": 6.355 }, "order": [ "robust_s1002", "robust_s1003", "rel2", "rel3", "rel1", "robust_s1004", "rel4", "release_s1002", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1001", "release_s1004", "release_s1003", "nonoise_s1002", "nonoise_s1003" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.88, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 0.96, "nonoise_s1002": 0.38, "nonoise_s1003": 0.18, "nonoise_s1004": 0.4, "release_s1001": 0.76, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 0.76, "release_s1004": 0.44, "robust_s1001": 0.98, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 0.84, "nonoise_s1002": 0.26, "nonoise_s1003": 0.04, "nonoise_s1004": 0.6, "release_s1001": 0.48, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 0.32, "release_s1004": 0.44, "robust_s1001": 0.94, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.94, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 0.9, "nonoise_s1002": 0.32, "nonoise_s1003": 0.11, "nonoise_s1004": 0.5, "release_s1001": 0.62, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 0.54, "release_s1004": 0.44, "robust_s1001": 0.96, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 7, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 2.7000000136239186, "rel2": 2.7000000136239186, "rel3": 2.7000000136239186, "rel4": 2.7000000136239186, "nonoise_s1001": 2.385714258466448, "nonoise_s1002": 2.8142857210976735, "nonoise_s1003": 2.6000000408717563, "nonoise_s1004": 2.385714258466448, "release_s1001": 2.4571427958352223, "release_s1002": 2.385714258466448, "release_s1003": 2.6571429116385326, "release_s1004": 2.6857143129621233, "robust_s1001": 2.3714285578046526, "robust_s1002": 2.3714285578046526, "robust_s1003": 2.3714285578046526, "robust_s1004": 2.3999999591282437 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.355, "ci95": [ 0.29, 0.42 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.475, "ci95": [ 0.40487500000000004, 0.545 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.605, "ci95": [ 0.535, 0.675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.74, "ci95": [ 0.655, 0.815 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.9, "ci95": [ 0.845, 0.95 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.895, "ci95": [ 0.84, 0.945 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.795, "ci95": [ 0.72, 0.86 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.835, "ci95": [ 0.77, 0.9 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.71, "ci95": [ 0.625, 0.79 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.875, "ci95": [ 0.815, 0.93 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.85, "ci95": [ 0.785, 0.91 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.765, "ci95": [ 0.6898749999999999, 0.835 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.285, "ci95": [ 0.2, 0.375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.355, "ci95": [ 0.27, 0.445 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.625, "ci95": [ 0.53, 0.715 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.65, "ci95": [ 0.585, 0.72 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.71, "ci95": [ 0.645, 0.78 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.805, "ci95": [ 0.725, 0.88 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.935, "ci95": [ 0.885, 0.98 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.92, "ci95": [ 0.87, 0.965 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.805, "ci95": [ 0.725, 0.875 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.89, "ci95": [ 0.83, 0.945 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.765, "ci95": [ 0.684875, 0.84 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.905, "ci95": [ 0.8548749999999999, 0.955 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.88, "ci95": [ 0.82, 0.935 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.82, "ci95": [ 0.744875, 0.89 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.37, "ci95": [ 0.28, 0.465 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.355, "ci95": [ 0.265, 0.445 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.64, "ci95": [ 0.55, 0.725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.74, "ci95": [ 0.68, 0.8 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.795, "ci95": [ 0.71, 0.865 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.915, "ci95": [ 0.86, 0.965 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.925, "ci95": [ 0.875, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.78, "ci95": [ 0.69, 0.855 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.885, "ci95": [ 0.82, 0.9401249999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.74, "ci95": [ 0.65, 0.815 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.915, "ci95": [ 0.864875, 0.965 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.895, "ci95": [ 0.84, 0.945 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.805, "ci95": [ 0.725, 0.875 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.31, "ci95": [ 0.225, 0.4 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.26, "ci95": [ 0.175, 0.345 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.58, "ci95": [ 0.48, 0.67 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.74, "ci95": [ 0.649875, 0.82 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.875, "ci95": [ 0.81, 0.935 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.925, "ci95": [ 0.875, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.745, "ci95": [ 0.65, 0.83 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.875, "ci95": [ 0.81, 0.935 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.67, "ci95": [ 0.575, 0.755 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.92, "ci95": [ 0.87, 0.965 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.865, "ci95": [ 0.805, 0.92 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.76, "ci95": [ 0.67, 0.84 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.255, "ci95": [ 0.18, 0.33 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.18, "ci95": [ 0.11, 0.25 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.495, "ci95": [ 0.4, 0.59 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.845, "ci95": [ 0.78, 0.91 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.935, "ci95": [ 0.9, 0.965 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.74, "ci95": [ 0.68, 0.795 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.795, "ci95": [ 0.72, 0.865 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.235, "ci95": [ 0.175, 0.295 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.895, "ci95": [ 0.845, 0.945 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.77, "ci95": [ 0.695, 0.845 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.425, "ci95": [ 0.35, 0.505 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.055, "ci95": [ 0.025, 0.085 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.09, "ci95": [ 0.045, 0.14 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.21, "ci95": [ 0.15, 0.275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.59, "ci95": [ 0.535, 0.645 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.33, "ci95": [ 0.265, 0.395 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.33, "ci95": [ 0.265, 0.4 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.095, "ci95": [ 0.045, 0.155 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.425, "ci95": [ 0.35, 0.505 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.435, "ci95": [ 0.36, 0.51 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.085, "ci95": [ 0.035, 0.14 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.05, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.095 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.27, "ci95": [ 0.22, 0.32 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.25, "ci95": [ 0.195, 0.305 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.31, "ci95": [ 0.255, 0.365 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.35, "ci95": [ 0.295, 0.405 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.02, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.035 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.54, "ci95": [ 0.46, 0.62 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.2, "ci95": [ 0.14, 0.26 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.625, "ci95": [ 0.55, 0.7 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.59, "ci95": [ 0.52, 0.6651249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.24, "ci95": [ 0.175, 0.305 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.06512499999999932 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.095, "ci95": [ 0.05, 0.145 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.125, "ci95": [ 0.075, 0.18 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.065, "ci95": [ 0.025, 0.11 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.585, "ci95": [ 0.505, 0.665 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.565, "ci95": [ 0.49, 0.645 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.11, "ci95": [ 0.06, 0.175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.035 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.06 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.07, "ci95": [ 0.03, 0.115 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.965, "ci95": [ 0.93, 0.995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.86, "ci95": [ 0.795, 0.925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.615, "ci95": [ 0.53, 0.695 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.065, "ci95": [ 0.035, 0.1 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1, "ci95": [ 0.055, 0.15 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.39, "ci95": [ 0.325, 0.455 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.515, "ci95": [ 0.445, 0.585 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.09, "ci95": [ 0.045, 0.145 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.035 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.07 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.215, "ci95": [ 0.14, 0.29 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.035 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.065, "ci95": [ 0.025, 0.11 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.055, "ci95": [ 0.025, 0.09 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.07, "ci95": [ 0.035, 0.11 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.275, "ci95": [ 0.205, 0.35 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.455, "ci95": [ 0.365, 0.55 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.915, "ci95": [ 0.875, 0.95 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.87, "ci95": [ 0.81, 0.92 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 110, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 5.25, 6.665 ], "rel2": [ 4.284875, 5.590125 ], "rel3": [ 4.955, 6.25 ], "rel4": [ 6.124875, 7.425 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 8.51, 9.61 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 12.549750000000001, 13.620124999999998 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 13.529874999999999, 14.285 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 10.249875, 11.735 ], "release_s1001": [ 11.439874999999999, 12.440124999999998 ], "release_s1002": [ 7.055, 7.875 ], "release_s1003": [ 12.344875, 13.14025 ], "release_s1004": [ 11.68975, 12.880125 ], "robust_s1001": [ 8.099874999999999, 9.05 ], "robust_s1002": [ 2.78, 3.4601249999999992 ], "robust_s1003": [ 2.81, 3.54 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.894875, 6.790125 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.43333333333333335, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.3093854877086271, 0.48333333333333334 ], "spearman": 0.5, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.3588235294117647, 0.6088235294117647 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.09999999999999998, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.2833333333333334, 0.04999999999999999 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.9425 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.4937281711658766, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.2857241221023671, 0.6443571047419068 ], "spearman": 0.6328184200331548, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.39820980312775756, 0.8023930556430089 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.2248206081406665, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.27412108025276083, 0.6696899828396904 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.1915 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.3, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.15, 0.4 ], "spearman": 0.35, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.15588235294117647, 0.48823529411764705 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.22720126751610553, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.49456674926725014, -0.12712963896994647 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 86, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 62, "discordant_method_correct": 28, "discordant_base_correct": 34 } }, "rate_rand": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 9.8895, "rel2": 8.485499999999998, "rel3": 8.427999999999999, "rel4": 8.91375, "nonoise_s1001": 6.848500000000001, "nonoise_s1002": 13.119750000000003, "nonoise_s1003": 12.987000000000007, "nonoise_s1004": 7.495500000000001, "release_s1001": 10.685, "release_s1002": 6.318749999999998, "release_s1003": 11.988999999999997, "release_s1004": 11.086000000000002, "robust_s1001": 6.938250000000002, "robust_s1002": 3.1515, "robust_s1003": 4.062750000000001, "robust_s1004": 5.6012499999999985 }, "order": [ "robust_s1002", "robust_s1003", "robust_s1004", "release_s1002", "nonoise_s1001", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "rel3", "rel2", "rel4", "rel1", "release_s1001", "release_s1004", "release_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "nonoise_s1002" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.88, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 0.834, "nonoise_s1002": 0.78, "nonoise_s1003": 0.714, "nonoise_s1004": 0.798, "release_s1001": 0.801, "release_s1002": 0.862, "release_s1003": 0.796, "release_s1004": 0.804, "robust_s1001": 0.836, "robust_s1002": 0.983, "robust_s1003": 0.997, "robust_s1004": 0.877 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 0.991, "nonoise_s1001": 0.854, "nonoise_s1002": 0.759, "nonoise_s1003": 0.636, "nonoise_s1004": 0.815, "release_s1001": 0.768, "release_s1002": 0.878, "release_s1003": 0.723, "release_s1004": 0.773, "robust_s1001": 0.852, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 0.96 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.94, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 0.9955, "nonoise_s1001": 0.844, "nonoise_s1002": 0.7695, "nonoise_s1003": 0.675, "nonoise_s1004": 0.8065, "release_s1001": 0.7845, "release_s1002": 0.87, "release_s1003": 0.7595, "release_s1004": 0.7885, "robust_s1001": 0.844, "robust_s1002": 0.9915, "robust_s1003": 0.9985, "robust_s1004": 0.9185 } }, "common_success_units": 1256, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 5.5242834691029445, "rel2": 5.1846337447500535, "rel3": 5.097372618450481, "rel4": 5.092515923035372, "nonoise_s1001": 4.8972930023624635, "nonoise_s1002": 6.223885361366211, "nonoise_s1003": 6.792595545767219, "nonoise_s1004": 4.995143314455725, "release_s1001": 5.436624206365294, "release_s1002": 4.848248411515716, "release_s1003": 5.9445860029026205, "release_s1004": 5.5305732598729955, "robust_s1001": 4.882324844219123, "robust_s1002": 4.672054146505465, "robust_s1003": 4.747929946821966, "robust_s1004": 4.791162418901541 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.25049999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.20874999999999996, 0.2935124999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.3307499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.28724375, 0.3752562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.3847500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.34275, 0.42724999999999974 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.36924999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.33124999999999993, 0.40425000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.6827500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6397437499999999, 0.72625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.6405, "ci95": [ 0.60425, 0.6780062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.38925000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.3517500000000002, 0.42425625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.513, "ci95": [ 0.47374374999999996, 0.54975 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.34975, "ci95": [ 0.31224374999999993, 0.385 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6030000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5635, 0.6435062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.563, "ci95": [ 0.51999375, 0.6054999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.3712499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.33649999999999997, 0.4042687499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.168, "ci95": [ 0.13399999999999995, 0.20151874999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.20375, "ci95": [ 0.16299375, 0.2475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.291, "ci95": [ 0.24974375000000007, 0.33100625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.45075, "ci95": [ 0.4137500000000001, 0.48924999999999974 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.506, "ci95": [ 0.46699375000000004, 0.5455000000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.4170000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.37549374999999996, 0.4542499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.77625, "ci95": [ 0.7389937499999999, 0.8127562499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.7214999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6897500000000002, 0.75275625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.4385, "ci95": [ 0.3959874999999998, 0.47649999999999987 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.5802499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5405000000000001, 0.61725625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.39725, "ci95": [ 0.3582500000000002, 0.4332562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.67875, "ci95": [ 0.6434937500000001, 0.7120125000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.64425, "ci95": [ 0.5997500000000001, 0.6870000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.42125, "ci95": [ 0.3839999999999999, 0.4562499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.19725, "ci95": [ 0.15975000000000006, 0.2352499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.21425, "ci95": [ 0.17498749999999993, 0.2532624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.32175000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.2797437500000002, 0.3617562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.5785, "ci95": [ 0.54324375, 0.6160062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.41250000000000014, "ci95": [ 0.369, 0.4512499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.80675, "ci95": [ 0.7650000000000001, 0.846 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.74525, "ci95": [ 0.7132500000000002, 0.7757562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.43699999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.39323125000000003, 0.4767499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.59625, "ci95": [ 0.5559874999999999, 0.6357562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.39199999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.34974375, 0.4302499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.70475, "ci95": [ 0.6679937499999998, 0.7387499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6652499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6202312500000001, 0.7065062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.42, "ci95": [ 0.37949374999999996, 0.45601249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.15324999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.12, 0.18675625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1545, "ci95": [ 0.11975000000000008, 0.18725000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.2875, "ci95": [ 0.24599375000000004, 0.32975000000000015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.39350000000000007, "ci95": [ 0.35049375, 0.43250000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.7975, "ci95": [ 0.7502437500000002, 0.8400124999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.7544999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.72025, 0.7865000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.41775000000000007, "ci95": [ 0.37349375, 0.45850000000000024 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.59075, "ci95": [ 0.5484937499999999, 0.63200625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.3652500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.3232437499999999, 0.4027500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7127500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6759999999999998, 0.7474999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.66425, "ci95": [ 0.6182437500000002, 0.7070000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.40025000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.3587437500000001, 0.43751249999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.10825000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.07925, 0.13749999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.10225, "ci95": [ 0.07649375000000001, 0.12975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.24849999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.2074999999999999, 0.2892562499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.879, "ci95": [ 0.8597499999999996, 0.8987562499999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.90775, "ci95": [ 0.8944937500000001, 0.9212562500000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5775, "ci95": [ 0.5627437499999999, 0.5930062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.8377500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8165000000000002, 0.85775625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.4275, "ci95": [ 0.41200000000000003, 0.44325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.87775, "ci95": [ 0.8564937499999992, 0.8969999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8167500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7842500000000002, 0.84750625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.50325, "ci95": [ 0.48474999999999985, 0.5225 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.19924999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.1757500000000001, 0.22350624999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.31549999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.2829937499999999, 0.35100625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.40175, "ci95": [ 0.3762500000000001, 0.4277562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.48625, "ci95": [ 0.44874374999999994, 0.5272562499999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.15825, "ci95": [ 0.13575, 0.18025625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.22375000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.19599374999999997, 0.25249999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.1025, "ci95": [ 0.08450000000000003, 0.11975625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.36125, "ci95": [ 0.31725, 0.40600625000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.29300000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.24874999999999997, 0.34051249999999983 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.11425, "ci95": [ 0.09725000000000003, 0.13200625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.006499999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.003, 0.0105 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.01325, "ci95": [ 0.006000000000000001, 0.021999999999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0635, "ci95": [ 0.04824375000000001, 0.07925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.11925000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.10249375, 0.13524999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.24, "ci95": [ 0.21399999999999994, 0.26700625000000017 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.081, "ci95": [ 0.06775000000000005, 0.09425000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.32175, "ci95": [ 0.2965000000000001, 0.34550000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.276, "ci95": [ 0.24674374999999993, 0.30650625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.09899999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.08549374999999995, 0.11275000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.02075, "ci95": [ 0.014249999999999999, 0.02775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.04575, "ci95": [ 0.033499999999999995, 0.059250000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.06525, "ci95": [ 0.053250000000000026, 0.07775000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.7789999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7529937499999997, 0.8032562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.38825000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.3682499999999998, 0.40750625000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8242499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.7975000000000004, 0.851 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7595000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.72299375, 0.7952562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.44724999999999987, "ci95": [ 0.4239999999999998, 0.4709999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.1825, "ci95": [ 0.15850000000000003, 0.20950625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.30624999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.273, 0.34050624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.355, "ci95": [ 0.3262437499999999, 0.38500625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.12375, "ci95": [ 0.10500000000000004, 0.14325624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.655, "ci95": [ 0.6144937500000003, 0.6944999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.55025, "ci95": [ 0.499, 0.6027562500000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.1365, "ci95": [ 0.11675000000000002, 0.15774999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.028000000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.01424375, 0.04475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.06975, "ci95": [ 0.05075000000000002, 0.08975625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.11249999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.08950000000000001, 0.13600624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9060000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.8899999999999999, 0.9212499999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8487500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8219999999999997, 0.8757499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5722499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5509999999999998, 0.5942562499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.20975000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.18650000000000005, 0.23301249999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.32900000000000007, "ci95": [ 0.29399375000000016, 0.3667562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.44275, "ci95": [ 0.41874375, 0.4679999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.3872499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.35825, 0.4167562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.12599999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.10575000000000002, 0.14949999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.02475, "ci95": [ 0.016243749999999998, 0.03424999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.04475, "ci95": [ 0.03049999999999999, 0.05901249999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0735, "ci95": [ 0.058000000000000024, 0.09000000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.19675000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.16349999999999998, 0.23149999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.03475, "ci95": [ 0.023493749999999994, 0.047749999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.05225, "ci95": [ 0.034999999999999996, 0.0715 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.09849999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.07975000000000002, 0.11925625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.18225000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.16175, 0.20450000000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.3045, "ci95": [ 0.2740000000000001, 0.3350125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.38299999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.3544937499999999, 0.40925000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5645000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.508225, 0.6240062500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7992500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7704937500000001, 0.8257562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6575, "ci95": [ 0.6172500000000002, 0.6947687499999999 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 115, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 9.482643750000005, 10.293787500000002 ], "rel2": [ 8.1304375, 8.85659375 ], "rel3": [ 8.08499375, 8.804018750000001 ], "rel4": [ 8.563468749999998, 9.296268750000003 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 6.557962499999997, 7.11078125 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 12.810474999999999, 13.417275000000005 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 12.753718750000004, 13.21801250000001 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 7.14474375, 7.821075000000001 ], "release_s1001": [ 10.399231249999994, 10.960774999999996 ], "release_s1002": [ 6.070750000000001, 6.553281250000003 ], "release_s1003": [ 11.7075, 12.2625125 ], "release_s1004": [ 10.718724999999996, 11.464006249999997 ], "robust_s1001": [ 6.690737500000001, 7.193512499999999 ], "robust_s1002": [ 2.95493125, 3.3480249999999994 ], "robust_s1003": [ 3.787700000000001, 4.347556250000001 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.3597375000000005, 5.824287500000001 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.8166666666666667, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.6833333333333333, 0.85 ], "spearman": 0.9088235294117647, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.8294117647058824, 0.9441176470588235 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.2833333333333333, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.08333333333333326, 0.4 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.004 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5606743638663344, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.35590759688747053, 0.7458698539828915 ], "spearman": 0.7284770184102596, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.49779143479460625, 0.8889259213035494 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.29176680084112433, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.06420496918617553, 0.5488060078181282 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.0095 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.6166666666666667, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.47699162299076214, 0.7166666666666667 ], "spearman": 0.7558823529411764, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.5916116391937866, 0.8382352941176471 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.08946539915056118, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.16102377140857344, 0.17287036103005352 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.395 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 109, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 39, "discordant_method_correct": 28, "discordant_base_correct": 11 } }, "rate_rand_paper": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 9.719, "rel2": 8.2615, "rel3": 8.246250000000002, "rel4": 8.814250000000005, "nonoise_s1001": 6.96475, "nonoise_s1002": 13.135249999999994, "nonoise_s1003": 13.054249999999998, "nonoise_s1004": 7.666249999999998, "release_s1001": 10.627000000000002, "release_s1002": 6.423499999999999, "release_s1003": 11.984000000000005, "release_s1004": 11.169999999999998, "robust_s1001": 7.064499999999998, "robust_s1002": 3.163749999999999, "robust_s1003": 4.0097499999999995, "robust_s1004": 5.696000000000001 }, "order": [ "robust_s1002", "robust_s1003", "robust_s1004", "release_s1002", "nonoise_s1001", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "rel3", "rel2", "rel4", "rel1", "release_s1001", "release_s1004", "release_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "nonoise_s1002" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.881, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 0.825, "nonoise_s1002": 0.766, "nonoise_s1003": 0.704, "nonoise_s1004": 0.784, "release_s1001": 0.783, "release_s1002": 0.859, "release_s1003": 0.78, "release_s1004": 0.779, "robust_s1001": 0.837, "robust_s1002": 0.99, "robust_s1003": 0.996, "robust_s1004": 0.869 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 0.982, "nonoise_s1001": 0.847, "nonoise_s1002": 0.745, "nonoise_s1003": 0.631, "nonoise_s1004": 0.81, "release_s1001": 0.749, "release_s1002": 0.878, "release_s1003": 0.699, "release_s1004": 0.749, "robust_s1001": 0.846, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 0.95 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.9405, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 0.991, "nonoise_s1001": 0.836, "nonoise_s1002": 0.7555, "nonoise_s1003": 0.6675, "nonoise_s1004": 0.797, "release_s1001": 0.766, "release_s1002": 0.8685, "release_s1003": 0.7395, "release_s1004": 0.764, "robust_s1001": 0.8415, "robust_s1002": 0.995, "robust_s1003": 0.998, "robust_s1004": 0.9095 } }, "common_success_units": 1239, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 5.4679580431392445, "rel2": 5.1457627098631535, "rel3": 5.06505246485694, "rel4": 5.067312347398254, "nonoise_s1001": 4.9162227639851785, "nonoise_s1002": 6.34301856624397, "nonoise_s1003": 7.166182411592559, "nonoise_s1004": 5.057949966341377, "release_s1001": 5.513397901648951, "release_s1002": 4.8645682038560425, "release_s1003": 6.075544791225467, "release_s1004": 5.670702178022186, "robust_s1001": 4.897336568439844, "robust_s1002": 4.674899120885004, "robust_s1003": 4.7380952484863625, "robust_s1004": 4.808958836771771 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.24974999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.21325000000000002, 0.287 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.3225, "ci95": [ 0.28624374999999996, 0.3595000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.38599999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.3527374999999999, 0.4207499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.38599999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.34923750000000003, 0.4210062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.6965, "ci95": [ 0.65424375, 0.73725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.6594999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6267437499999998, 0.6932499999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.40924999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.37174375000000015, 0.44625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.51175, "ci95": [ 0.47449375000000005, 0.5475125000000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.36924999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.33372500000000005, 0.40375625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.60775, "ci95": [ 0.5717437500000002, 0.6452500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.5645, "ci95": [ 0.5237499999999999, 0.6079999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.396, "ci95": [ 0.36125, 0.4290125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.179, "ci95": [ 0.14499999999999996, 0.21499999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.22274999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.18050000000000005, 0.26649999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.32050000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.28123750000000003, 0.35999999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.46199999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.4292437499999999, 0.4967499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.5177499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4840000000000002, 0.55025 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.436, "ci95": [ 0.39575000000000005, 0.4735125000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.79475, "ci95": [ 0.7582500000000002, 0.8310000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.7377499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7070000000000002, 0.7665062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.458, "ci95": [ 0.4169937500000001, 0.4987499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.5845, "ci95": [ 0.5449937500000003, 0.6225000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.41924999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.38099375, 0.4560125000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6837500000000002, "ci95": [ 0.6524937499999998, 0.7162500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.653, "ci95": [ 0.6099812500000003, 0.6940000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.4435, "ci95": [ 0.40500000000000014, 0.4797625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.21425000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.17550000000000002, 0.2540125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.23274999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.19224375000000002, 0.2747562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.3509999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.30974375, 0.3904999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.58075, "ci95": [ 0.5524937500000001, 0.6112500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.43900000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.3952437499999998, 0.47875624999999983 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.813, "ci95": [ 0.7745000000000002, 0.85075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.7615000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7304999999999998, 0.7902499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.45925000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.4155000000000001, 0.5012562500000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.5960000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5532375000000002, 0.6347562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.41625, "ci95": [ 0.37449999999999983, 0.4540124999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7130000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6807500000000002, 0.7449999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.682, "ci95": [ 0.6394937499999999, 0.72175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.44825000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.40775000000000006, 0.4874999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.15774999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.1235, 0.19175625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.15425, "ci95": [ 0.12099374999999998, 0.18750000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.31725000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.274, 0.3595062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.4054999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.36323749999999994, 0.44626249999999973 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.8019999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7594937499999996, 0.8432687499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.7674999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.7344999999999999, 0.7979999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.435, "ci95": [ 0.3904999999999999, 0.47899999999999987 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.59125, "ci95": [ 0.5465000000000002, 0.6325000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.37699999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.33525, 0.4169999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7175000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6830000000000002, 0.7512562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6755, "ci95": [ 0.6315000000000002, 0.7165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.41875, "ci95": [ 0.37749374999999985, 0.45851249999999977 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.10850000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.08099374999999998, 0.13650625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1075, "ci95": [ 0.08099375, 0.13525000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.26425, "ci95": [ 0.22323749999999984, 0.30625624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.8820000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8634937500000003, 0.9000000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.89875, "ci95": [ 0.885, 0.9129999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5840000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5665000000000002, 0.6019999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.83375, "ci95": [ 0.8127375000000001, 0.8545000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.4195000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.40625, 0.4329999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8785000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8584999999999998, 0.8975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8199999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.7897500000000004, 0.8477562500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.504, "ci95": [ 0.48349374999999983, 0.52475 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.19099999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.17149374999999992, 0.21149999999999985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.3005, "ci95": [ 0.27073749999999996, 0.332 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.3897500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.3712500000000001, 0.4075062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.4915, "ci95": [ 0.45474374999999984, 0.5295062500000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.158, "ci95": [ 0.136, 0.1797499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.21025000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.1852437499999999, 0.2350125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.09949999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.08275000000000005, 0.1165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.3670000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.32299374999999997, 0.41149999999999987 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.31175, "ci95": [ 0.26625000000000004, 0.36075624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.11899999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.10049375000000002, 0.13850000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.006500000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.002, 0.012249999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.018000000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.0085, 0.029256249999999963 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.07150000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.05450000000000003, 0.09075625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.127, "ci95": [ 0.11000000000000006, 0.14375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.23149999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.20725000000000005, 0.2562499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.08500000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.07100000000000006, 0.09950625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.31400000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.29000000000000015, 0.3380125000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.27599999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.24750000000000014, 0.30650625000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.10525000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.08949375000000002, 0.1220000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.019500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.01399374999999999, 0.02600624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0375, "ci95": [ 0.02799999999999998, 0.04850000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.06650000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.05399375000000002, 0.07975625000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.7752499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7512500000000005, 0.7990062500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.37725000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.3559937500000001, 0.3979999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8182499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7912500000000001, 0.8450000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7602500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7230000000000003, 0.7980000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.43475, "ci95": [ 0.4119937499999999, 0.4572499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.17475000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.15375000000000003, 0.19674999999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.28900000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.25899374999999997, 0.32075624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.3347500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.31025000000000014, 0.35824999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.13049999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.10924375000000001, 0.15250624999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6489999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6074875, 0.6877562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.565, "ci95": [ 0.5147437499999999, 0.6175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.1475, "ci95": [ 0.12875000000000003, 0.16900625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.027000000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.015243749999999995, 0.04150624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0745, "ci95": [ 0.055249999999999994, 0.09424999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.11375, "ci95": [ 0.09150000000000005, 0.13700625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9057499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.8892499999999995, 0.9212499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8487499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8227499999999996, 0.8745062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5695, "ci95": [ 0.5494937499999997, 0.5899999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.20024999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.1807375, 0.21976249999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.31375, "ci95": [ 0.28400000000000003, 0.34450625000000007 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.43200000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.41249999999999987, 0.45051874999999986 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.39875, "ci95": [ 0.37124374999999993, 0.42700625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.132, "ci95": [ 0.111, 0.1555 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0225, "ci95": [ 0.014999999999999996, 0.032 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.04125, "ci95": [ 0.028493749999999998, 0.055999999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.07600000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.06075000000000004, 0.09375000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.19699999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.16249375000000008, 0.23324999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.024, 0.047006249999999986 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.05075, "ci95": [ 0.03474999999999999, 0.06775625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.10275000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.08300000000000006, 0.12325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.17850000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.15925, 0.19800625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.29174999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.26375000000000004, 0.3204999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.38075000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.3559937500000001, 0.4030062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5472499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.49200000000000005, 0.6042562500000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.8035, "ci95": [ 0.7794937500000002, 0.8264999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.67175, "ci95": [ 0.6345000000000001, 0.7067625000000004 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 114, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 9.348693749999997, 10.076856250000004 ], "rel2": [ 7.899487499999995, 8.6110625 ], "rel3": [ 7.891468750000002, 8.604800000000003 ], "rel4": [ 8.460437500000006, 9.191025000000007 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 6.702693749999997, 7.216006250000001 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 12.821225000000002, 13.445550000000006 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 12.823487500000002, 13.269556250000003 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 7.330468749999996, 8.000549999999999 ], "release_s1001": [ 10.33574375, 10.916756249999997 ], "release_s1002": [ 6.197456249999999, 6.6419999999999995 ], "release_s1003": [ 11.705237500000003, 12.244543750000002 ], "release_s1004": [ 10.811743750000002, 11.549756249999993 ], "robust_s1001": [ 6.81371875, 7.324274999999998 ], "robust_s1002": [ 2.9952375000000004, 3.333999999999998 ], "robust_s1003": [ 3.75246875, 4.278037500000002 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.460618749999999, 5.93675625 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.8166666666666667, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.6833333333333333, 0.85 ], "spearman": 0.9088235294117647, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.8264705882352941, 0.9441176470588235 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.2833333333333333, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.08333333333333326, 0.4 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.0045 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5606743638663344, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.35598333940092547, 0.7563292261344161 ], "spearman": 0.7284770184102596, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.500754479049336, 0.8903608002792062 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.29176680084112433, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.06420932769052348, 0.5461408764805349 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.01 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5666666666666667, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.4, 0.6666666666666666 ], "spearman": 0.7029411764705882, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.4885857022709231, 0.8029411764705883 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.03946539915056113, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.2277603195836878, 0.139535280659009 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.622 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 109, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 39, "discordant_method_correct": 28, "discordant_base_correct": 11 } }, "tau0_logu": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 15.507749999999996, "rel2": 14.374250000000004, "rel3": 13.706749999999994, "rel4": 13.32875, "nonoise_s1001": 3.7680000000000007, "nonoise_s1002": 12.611500000000005, "nonoise_s1003": 7.641500000000002, "nonoise_s1004": 3.77, "release_s1001": 8.810500000000001, "release_s1002": 3.9200000000000004, "release_s1003": 9.097499999999997, "release_s1004": 9.20375, "robust_s1001": 4.19625, "robust_s1002": 4.3425, "robust_s1003": 6.4637499999999966, "robust_s1004": 5.257250000000002 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "nonoise_s1002", "rel4", "rel3", "rel2", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.875, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.9375, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1875, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 7.20101334063212, "rel2": 6.822293348185221, "rel3": 6.691893343734741, "rel4": 6.630506672286987, "nonoise_s1001": 5.269706668217977, "nonoise_s1002": 5.905440003840129, "nonoise_s1003": 5.4070399960835775, "nonoise_s1004": 5.2697600026448566, "release_s1001": 5.439786672083537, "release_s1002": 5.273600003814697, "release_s1003": 5.477173334376017, "release_s1004": 5.5310933400472, "robust_s1001": 5.284746670277913, "robust_s1002": 5.284320009485881, "robust_s1003": 5.368213331985474, "robust_s1004": 5.314026669311524 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.10525000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.07325000000000001, 0.14050624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.09650000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.066, 0.13 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.09125, "ci95": [ 0.061500000000000006, 0.12350624999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.15099999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.11499374999999996, 0.18575624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0017500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.00375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0017500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.0005, 0.0034999999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.008, "ci95": [ 0.0045000000000000005, 0.011999999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.035750000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.02275, 0.04975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0027500000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.23550000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.19499999999999995, 0.27675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.22125, "ci95": [ 0.18223749999999994, 0.26100625000000016 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.18750000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.15549375000000001, 0.21900000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0045000000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.00225, 0.007250000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0032500000000000007, "ci95": [ 0.0015, 0.0055000000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0195, "ci95": [ 0.012750000000000001, 0.026500000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.057, "ci95": [ 0.039743749999999994, 0.07600000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0025, "ci95": [ 0.0005, 0.005000000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.325, "ci95": [ 0.29149375000000016, 0.3630062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.20400000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.17550000000000002, 0.23275624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0055000000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.00275, 0.00875 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.004750000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.002, 0.00825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.022499999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.014250000000000002, 0.03125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.061, "ci95": [ 0.04299374999999999, 0.08124999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0025, "ci95": [ 0.0005, 0.005000000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.20975000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.18075, 0.23850000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.00575, "ci95": [ 0.0027500000000000003, 0.009000000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.004750000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.002, 0.00825 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.023499999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.015249999999999996, 0.032249999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.06225, "ci95": [ 0.04400000000000001, 0.08224999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0027500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.0005, 0.00525 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 1.0, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.8707499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8547500000000001, 0.8865000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5002500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.49399999999999983, 0.5052499999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.96025, "ci95": [ 0.9492437500000002, 0.97075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.5177499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.50725, 0.5322499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.92, "ci95": [ 0.90225, 0.9367562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.893, "ci95": [ 0.8732437499999999, 0.9122562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.55075, "ci95": [ 0.537, 0.5672499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5705, "ci95": [ 0.5587437499999995, 0.5834999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7474999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.7077500000000001, 0.7879999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7012500000000002, "ci95": [ 0.6794937499999998, 0.7234999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0035000000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.0007500000000000001, 0.006750000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.042249999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.01974375, 0.07200000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.00825, "ci95": [ 0.0032500000000000007, 0.014249999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.05025, "ci95": [ 0.01674375, 0.092 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.01975, "ci95": [ 0.008000000000000002, 0.034 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.00425, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.01275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.1275, "ci95": [ 0.11225000000000002, 0.14300000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.6070000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5800000000000004, 0.6337500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.1425, "ci95": [ 0.1215, 0.16725624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7517499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.7317500000000006, 0.7735 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.733, "ci95": [ 0.7025, 0.7645062500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.14900000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.12900000000000006, 0.17275624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.16274999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.14425000000000007, 0.18099999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.39349999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.34074374999999985, 0.4495062499999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.18325, "ci95": [ 0.16549374999999994, 0.20474999999999988 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.96025, "ci95": [ 0.9489937500000001, 0.97125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.516, "ci95": [ 0.504, 0.5322499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.92175, "ci95": [ 0.904, 0.9397500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8942500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.875, 0.9130062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5507500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.53775, 0.5664999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.57025, "ci95": [ 0.5567499999999996, 0.5857499999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7460000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.7059875, 0.78675625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6985000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6762500000000002, 0.72025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.04175000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.030749999999999993, 0.053000000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6310000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6049999999999999, 0.6579999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.62075, "ci95": [ 0.5749875, 0.66625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.059000000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.04049374999999998, 0.08375000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.06225, "ci95": [ 0.04825, 0.07675624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.28575, "ci95": [ 0.2324875, 0.34425000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.07325, "ci95": [ 0.06074374999999996, 0.08574999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9122499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.89, 0.93175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8805000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8534937499999999, 0.90400625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5345, "ci95": [ 0.5130000000000002, 0.5547687499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5517500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5374999999999998, 0.5657562499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7354999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6934937499999999, 0.7772562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.686, "ci95": [ 0.6637499999999998, 0.7079999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.58675, "ci95": [ 0.5325000000000002, 0.63950625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.09525, "ci95": [ 0.07249375, 0.12324999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.10325, "ci95": [ 0.08325000000000005, 0.12474999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.2245, "ci95": [ 0.18749374999999996, 0.26675624999999986 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.11125, "ci95": [ 0.08925000000000001, 0.13650000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.12525, "ci95": [ 0.10325000000000002, 0.15124999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.13875, "ci95": [ 0.11450000000000003, 0.16274999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.25925, "ci95": [ 0.2097499999999999, 0.31125625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.1475, "ci95": [ 0.12499999999999996, 0.17324999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.51875, "ci95": [ 0.49674374999999993, 0.5382562500000003 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7104999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.664, 0.7547625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.649, "ci95": [ 0.6222499999999996, 0.6755062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6964999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6469687500000001, 0.7455124999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6392500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6142500000000001, 0.66375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.3637500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.3049937499999999, 0.42324999999999996 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 118, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 15.371993749999989, 15.630249999999997 ], "rel2": [ 14.284743749999999, 14.46725 ], "rel3": [ 13.638243749999996, 13.77480624999999 ], "rel4": [ 13.234724999999996, 13.431268749999996 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.682250000000002, 3.8515062500000026 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 12.46694375, 12.747262500000007 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.507700000000003, 7.772499999999997 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.670987499999999, 3.8640000000000017 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.669925000000001, 8.9565 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.80374375, 4.064506249999999 ], "release_s1003": [ 8.924462500000002, 9.272756249999993 ], "release_s1004": [ 8.917237499999993, 9.506531249999998 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.034700000000001, 4.410806250000001 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.209212499999997, 4.4822625 ], "robust_s1003": [ 6.028737499999999, 6.888768749999998 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.11099375, 5.4225375 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.48333333333333334, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.38333333333333336, 0.5666666666666667 ], "spearman": 0.7088235294117647, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6294117647058823, 0.7764705882352941 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.04999999999999999, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.08335091451704008, -0.016666666666666663 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.999 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.25941649671427414, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.068429369445092, 0.5714487486348921 ], "spearman": 0.32671090522641943, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.10676833345658586, 0.7717465387144756 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.009491066310935936, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.05560696414099956, 0.02440220260531325 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.805 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5666666666666667, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.48333333333333334, 0.7 ], "spearman": 0.7823529411764706, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7264705882352941, 0.8558823529411764 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.03946539915056113, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.07784223262336629, 0.08953528065900895 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.4 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 89, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 5, "discordant_method_correct": 1, "discordant_base_correct": 4 } }, "vmax_u": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 15.27075000000001, "rel2": 14.143500000000003, "rel3": 13.544500000000003, "rel4": 13.493250000000005, "nonoise_s1001": 4.974499999999999, "nonoise_s1002": 12.3775, "nonoise_s1003": 7.7745, "nonoise_s1004": 5.261250000000001, "release_s1001": 8.73125, "release_s1002": 4.480999999999999, "release_s1003": 9.629999999999997, "release_s1004": 9.609000000000002, "robust_s1001": 5.074250000000001, "robust_s1002": 2.9789999999999988, "robust_s1003": 3.533, "robust_s1004": 5.122750000000001 }, "order": [ "robust_s1002", "robust_s1003", "release_s1002", "nonoise_s1001", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "nonoise_s1004", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1004", "release_s1003", "nonoise_s1002", "rel4", "rel3", "rel2", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.91, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.955, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1910, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 4.094921459577471, "rel2": 3.713821985334626, "rel3": 3.647591620340397, "rel4": 3.6352356009458373, "nonoise_s1001": 3.060052353611791, "nonoise_s1002": 3.420157066627323, "nonoise_s1003": 3.13963350232359, "nonoise_s1004": 3.0681675366082115, "release_s1001": 3.1812565396593504, "release_s1002": 3.0476963320951813, "release_s1003": 3.2099999932094394, "release_s1004": 3.2272251245239016, "robust_s1001": 3.068376957995729, "robust_s1002": 2.9878534004326265, "robust_s1003": 3.0032460702027324, "robust_s1004": 3.0563874327075418 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.13849999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.10450000000000002, 0.17624999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.13225, "ci95": [ 0.09949374999999999, 0.16850624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.1595, "ci95": [ 0.12125000000000002, 0.19925624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.21225000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.16224375, 0.2642562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0027500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.0005, 0.00575 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0015000000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0035000000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.027250000000000007, "ci95": [ 0.013749999999999998, 0.04500624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.055, "ci95": [ 0.034249999999999996, 0.07774999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.28274999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.24625000000000002, 0.3212499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.30975, "ci95": [ 0.26524999999999993, 0.35400625000000013 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.25825, "ci95": [ 0.20949375, 0.30775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0055000000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.0022500000000000003, 0.009250000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0075000000000000015, "ci95": [ 0.0032500000000000007, 0.011999999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.04825, "ci95": [ 0.029000000000000005, 0.06899999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.08224999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.05748749999999998, 0.109 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0007500000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0017499999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.4415000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.40575000000000017, 0.4772500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.27475, "ci95": [ 0.23098749999999998, 0.32175000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.006500000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.003, 0.01075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.009000000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.004, 0.01475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0515, "ci95": [ 0.03224375, 0.07275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.08649999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.06124374999999999, 0.11424999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0007500000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0017499999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.26849999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.22824374999999997, 0.31074999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.00625, "ci95": [ 0.0027500000000000003, 0.010499999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.00825, "ci95": [ 0.003993750000000001, 0.012750000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.05, "ci95": [ 0.032, 0.06949999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.08375, "ci95": [ 0.05925, 0.11000624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.0007500000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0017499999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.97125, "ci95": [ 0.9590000000000001, 0.9815 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.80325, "ci95": [ 0.77775, 0.8267500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5405000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5224937499999996, 0.5579999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.8697499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.8445, 0.8952499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.43900000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.42073749999999965, 0.45750624999999984 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.90925, "ci95": [ 0.8882500000000002, 0.9290062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8910000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8667500000000002, 0.9150062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5225, "ci95": [ 0.49949374999999974, 0.5457562499999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.25999999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.23924374999999987, 0.28124999999999983 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.32449999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.2917437500000001, 0.35926250000000015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.49449999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.4687500000000002, 0.5197625000000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.081, "ci95": [ 0.05999375000000001, 0.10150000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.029249999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.01799375, 0.042749999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.11675, "ci95": [ 0.09450000000000001, 0.14075625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0165, "ci95": [ 0.00849375, 0.026750000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.13949999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.11649999999999996, 0.16175625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.14750000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.1085, 0.19425624999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0235, "ci95": [ 0.00875, 0.049006249999999967 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.00625, "ci95": [ 0.0017499999999999998, 0.011500000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.00825, "ci95": [ 0.0034999999999999996, 0.013500000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.03900000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.028243749999999995, 0.05099999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.2275, "ci95": [ 0.20174374999999992, 0.2525187499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.63325, "ci95": [ 0.5960000000000002, 0.66975625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.16225, "ci95": [ 0.13550000000000006, 0.19 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7625, "ci95": [ 0.735, 0.7914999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7389999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7090000000000002, 0.7695000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.20275, "ci95": [ 0.17149374999999994, 0.2360125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.06575, "ci95": [ 0.05075000000000003, 0.08225625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.11200000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.08300000000000006, 0.14450625000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.22574999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.2035, 0.2477562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.84675, "ci95": [ 0.8199999999999997, 0.8742499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.40275000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.3800000000000001, 0.4265062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8994999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8767437500000002, 0.9217500000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.883, "ci95": [ 0.8577437499999997, 0.9067499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.48125, "ci95": [ 0.4572437500000001, 0.5057562500000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.24875000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.22549999999999998, 0.2725062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.304, "ci95": [ 0.27175, 0.3382562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.4699999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4409999999999999, 0.4989999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.10175000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.07974999999999999, 0.12399999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.6164999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5717499999999999, 0.6617499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6100000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5594937499999999, 0.6577562500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.13449999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.10349999999999998, 0.16826249999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.05925, "ci95": [ 0.04449999999999999, 0.07525 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.08149999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.0605, 0.10624999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.158, "ci95": [ 0.13199375000000002, 0.18450624999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.92925, "ci95": [ 0.91125, 0.9462499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.9085, "ci95": [ 0.88, 0.9322562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5807500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.55425, 0.6087500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.30624999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.28150000000000003, 0.3317499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.3662500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.33049375, 0.4037562499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.55025, "ci95": [ 0.5202437499999999, 0.5809999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.51275, "ci95": [ 0.46175000000000016, 0.5620000000000003 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.09024999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.06324374999999999, 0.1215187499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.036, "ci95": [ 0.02474999999999999, 0.04800000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.051750000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.033749999999999995, 0.07299999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.11275000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.09075000000000005, 0.13450625000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.11, "ci95": [ 0.08475000000000003, 0.13876250000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.05050000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.035993749999999984, 0.06750625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.08925000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.06274999999999999, 0.11900625000000008 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.14049999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.11700000000000003, 0.16525000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.264, "ci95": [ 0.24024999999999988, 0.2879999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.32925000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.29473750000000004, 0.36400625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.478, "ci95": [ 0.4467500000000001, 0.5070000000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.56075, "ci95": [ 0.5272437499999996, 0.5959999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.757, "ci95": [ 0.7379937500000001, 0.7760000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6970000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6627500000000001, 0.7285 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 115, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 15.09348750000001, 15.437000000000003 ], "rel2": [ 14.01874375, 14.276006250000002 ], "rel3": [ 13.447500000000002, 13.640249999999996 ], "rel4": [ 13.389237500000009, 13.597256250000004 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 4.851749999999999, 5.100256249999998 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 12.135993750000006, 12.616025000000006 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.594474999999998, 7.947049999999997 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 5.113750000000004, 5.415506250000004 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.507481249999996, 8.957275000000003 ], "release_s1002": [ 4.3205, 4.650506249999999 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.405999999999999, 9.85575625 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.3147, 9.904524999999998 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.8745, 5.301774999999999 ], "robust_s1002": [ 2.8367312500000006, 3.1290187500000006 ], "robust_s1003": [ 3.2889250000000003, 3.808506250000001 ], "robust_s1004": [ 4.96575, 5.28478125 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.6833333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5941474602165634, 0.75 ], "spearman": 0.8294117647058824, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7647058823529411, 0.8794117647058823 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.15000000000000002, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.04480134390208217, 0.21666666666666662 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.004 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.2761530448893886, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.008439494725697222, 0.5654461466217139 ], "spearman": 0.3340692589477352, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.043001179746766205, 0.7629156177470673 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.007245481864178505, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.11070136221825871, 0.19204929773012033 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.531 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.8, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.7, 0.8833333333333333 ], "spearman": 0.9176470588235294, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.8529411764705882, 0.9705882352941176 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.2727987324838945, "delta_tau_ci95": [ 0.11160336013826076, 0.3059224212918844 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.0005 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 101, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 17, "discordant_method_correct": 13, "discordant_base_correct": 4 } }, "wb_2": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 15.445, "rel2": 14.105, "rel3": 13.22, "rel4": 12.64, "nonoise_s1001": 3.92, "nonoise_s1002": 13.27, "nonoise_s1003": 5.725, "nonoise_s1004": 3.84, "release_s1001": 9.065, "release_s1002": 4.175, "release_s1003": 8.565, "release_s1004": 9.445, "robust_s1001": 4.465, "robust_s1002": 4.7, "robust_s1003": 7.82, "robust_s1004": 5.6 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1004", "nonoise_s1001", "release_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1004", "nonoise_s1003", "robust_s1003", "release_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1004", "rel4", "rel3", "nonoise_s1002", "rel2", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.58, "rel2": 0.9, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.9, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.74, "rel2": 0.95, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 74, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 7.718918951782021, "rel2": 6.025675702739406, "rel3": 5.824324333989942, "rel4": 5.7540540727409155, "nonoise_s1001": 5.244594583640227, "nonoise_s1002": 5.843243286416337, "nonoise_s1003": 5.3094594220857365, "nonoise_s1004": 5.243243236799498, "release_s1001": 5.431081072704212, "release_s1002": 5.272972967173602, "release_s1003": 5.40675675868988, "release_s1004": 5.481081079792332, "robust_s1001": 5.270270257382779, "robust_s1002": 5.268918916985795, "robust_s1003": 5.413513512224765, "robust_s1004": 5.3013513249319955 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.085, "ci95": [ 0.05, 0.12 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.055, "ci95": [ 0.025, 0.09 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.055, "ci95": [ 0.025, 0.09 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.265, "ci95": [ 0.195, 0.33 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.075, "ci95": [ 0.035, 0.125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.185, "ci95": [ 0.14, 0.23 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.175, "ci95": [ 0.13, 0.22 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.355, "ci95": [ 0.289875, 0.4151249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.19, "ci95": [ 0.135, 0.25 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.075, "ci95": [ 0.035, 0.12 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.265, "ci95": [ 0.22, 0.315 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.445, "ci95": [ 0.39, 0.495 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.205, "ci95": [ 0.145, 0.27 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1, "ci95": [ 0.055, 0.15 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.485, "ci95": [ 0.435, 0.535 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.03 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.035 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.22, "ci95": [ 0.155, 0.285 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.125, "ci95": [ 0.075, 0.18 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.995, "ci95": [ 0.985, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.715, "ci95": [ 0.68, 0.75 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.49, "ci95": [ 0.47, 0.51 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.94, "ci95": [ 0.91, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.525, "ci95": [ 0.505, 0.55 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.915, "ci95": [ 0.88, 0.95 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.855, "ci95": [ 0.82, 0.89 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.555, "ci95": [ 0.529875, 0.59 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.595, "ci95": [ 0.56, 0.635 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.79, "ci95": [ 0.74, 0.84 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.705, "ci95": [ 0.665, 0.745 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.05, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.095 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.045 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.085, "ci95": [ 0.04, 0.145 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.015, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.015 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.07, "ci95": [ 0.03, 0.115 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.275, "ci95": [ 0.24, 0.31 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.885, "ci95": [ 0.845, 0.925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.3, "ci95": [ 0.265, 0.34 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.865, "ci95": [ 0.825, 0.905 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.835, "ci95": [ 0.8, 0.8701249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.335, "ci95": [ 0.295, 0.375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.355, "ci95": [ 0.31, 0.405 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.675, "ci95": [ 0.6, 0.75 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.47, "ci95": [ 0.44, 0.5 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.945, "ci95": [ 0.915, 0.97 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.53, "ci95": [ 0.51, 0.555 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.92, "ci95": [ 0.89, 0.955 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.865, "ci95": [ 0.83, 0.9 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.565, "ci95": [ 0.535, 0.6 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.6, "ci95": [ 0.5648749999999999, 0.64 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.795, "ci95": [ 0.745, 0.845 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.71, "ci95": [ 0.67, 0.75 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.075, "ci95": [ 0.045, 0.11 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.44, "ci95": [ 0.39, 0.49 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.555, "ci95": [ 0.49, 0.6201249999999993 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.095, "ci95": [ 0.055, 0.135 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.095, "ci95": [ 0.065, 0.12512499999999932 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.4, "ci95": [ 0.32, 0.48 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.095, "ci95": [ 0.06, 0.135 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.89, "ci95": [ 0.85, 0.93 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.84, "ci95": [ 0.805, 0.88 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.535, "ci95": [ 0.5, 0.57 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.56, "ci95": [ 0.525, 0.6 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.77, "ci95": [ 0.725, 0.82 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.69, "ci95": [ 0.65, 0.73 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.625, "ci95": [ 0.57, 0.68 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.125, "ci95": [ 0.085, 0.17 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.13, "ci95": [ 0.095, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.47, "ci95": [ 0.395, 0.545 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.145, "ci95": [ 0.105, 0.185 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.17, "ci95": [ 0.135, 0.21 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.185, "ci95": [ 0.145, 0.225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.375, "ci95": [ 0.31, 0.44 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.175, "ci95": [ 0.135, 0.215 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.535, "ci95": [ 0.5, 0.57 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.745, "ci95": [ 0.685, 0.8 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.65, "ci95": [ 0.61, 0.69 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.73, "ci95": [ 0.665, 0.795 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.63, "ci95": [ 0.585, 0.675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.32, "ci95": [ 0.25, 0.395 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 113, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 15.265, 15.605125 ], "rel2": [ 13.935, 14.285 ], "rel3": [ 13.09, 13.34 ], "rel4": [ 12.485, 12.8 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.739875, 4.095 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 12.994874999999999, 13.515 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 5.454875, 5.98 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.6348749999999996, 4.030125 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.75, 9.38 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.945, 4.425 ], "release_s1003": [ 8.284875, 8.865 ], "release_s1004": [ 8.995, 9.94 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.205, 4.775 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.43, 4.995 ], "robust_s1003": [ 7.204875, 8.475 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.34, 5.865 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.4666666666666667, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.38333333333333336, 0.5666666666666667 ], "spearman": 0.7029411764705882, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6088235294117647, 0.7676611855655753 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.06666666666666665, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.10000000000000003, 0.0 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.989 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.17573375583870182, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.15903075197298883, 0.5085421332599229 ], "spearman": 0.19573220898699903, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.23429619553127268, 0.6637197018871476 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.09317380718650825, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.1446072969987649, -0.039769844356441944 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5774109120414489, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.47699162299076214, 0.6666666666666666 ], "spearman": 0.762325445528312, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6937158805071114, 0.8323529411764706 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.05020964452534338, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.09421908876272225, 0.06694619270045782 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.5005 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 88, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 4, "discordant_method_correct": 0, "discordant_base_correct": 4 } }, "wb_3.4": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 15.5, "rel2": 14.26, "rel3": 13.18, "rel4": 12.52, "nonoise_s1001": 3.725, "nonoise_s1002": 12.77, "nonoise_s1003": 4.63, "nonoise_s1004": 3.81, "release_s1001": 9.315, "release_s1002": 4.085, "release_s1003": 8.2, "release_s1004": 9.15, "robust_s1001": 4.235, "robust_s1002": 6.0, "robust_s1003": 8.96, "robust_s1004": 5.66 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1003", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1002", "release_s1003", "robust_s1003", "release_s1004", "release_s1001", "rel4", "nonoise_s1002", "rel3", "rel2", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.42, "rel2": 0.64, "rel3": 0.92, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.78, "rel2": 0.98, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.6, "rel2": 0.81, "rel3": 0.96, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 60, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 10.0049999554952, "rel2": 7.056666731834412, "rel3": 6.6000000158945715, "rel4": 6.488333344459534, "nonoise_s1001": 5.903333306312561, "nonoise_s1002": 6.613333344459534, "nonoise_s1003": 5.939999961853028, "nonoise_s1004": 5.9083333015441895, "release_s1001": 6.211666691303253, "release_s1002": 5.929999987284343, "release_s1003": 6.098333358764648, "release_s1004": 6.148333346843719, "robust_s1001": 5.921666634082794, "robust_s1002": 5.9633333285649615, "robust_s1003": 6.218333359559377, "robust_s1004": 5.968333295981089 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.13, "ci95": [ 0.095, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.055, "ci95": [ 0.025, 0.085 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.07 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.205, "ci95": [ 0.14, 0.275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.06 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.035, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.07 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.15, "ci95": [ 0.105, 0.195 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.12, "ci95": [ 0.08, 0.16 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.34, "ci95": [ 0.265, 0.41 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.03 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.14, "ci95": [ 0.09, 0.2 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.11, "ci95": [ 0.055, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.245, "ci95": [ 0.195, 0.295 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.425, "ci95": [ 0.36, 0.485 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.03 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.175, "ci95": [ 0.12, 0.24 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.17, "ci95": [ 0.105, 0.235 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.475, "ci95": [ 0.415, 0.535 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.05 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.195, "ci95": [ 0.135, 0.26 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.195, "ci95": [ 0.13, 0.26 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.98, "ci95": [ 0.96, 0.995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.625, "ci95": [ 0.585, 0.665 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.51, "ci95": [ 0.49, 0.53 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.965, "ci95": [ 0.94, 0.985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.54, "ci95": [ 0.515, 0.57 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.92, "ci95": [ 0.885, 0.95 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.885, "ci95": [ 0.85, 0.92 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.55, "ci95": [ 0.525, 0.58 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.745, "ci95": [ 0.7, 0.795 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.825, "ci95": [ 0.78, 0.87 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.73, "ci95": [ 0.685, 0.775 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.04 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.085, "ci95": [ 0.045, 0.13 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.04, "ci95": [ 0.015, 0.07 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.02, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.11, "ci95": [ 0.06, 0.17 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.009875000000000007, 0.06 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.05, "ci95": [ 0.025, 0.08 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.225, "ci95": [ 0.155, 0.295 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.01, 0.055 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.385, "ci95": [ 0.345, 0.425 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.97, "ci95": [ 0.945, 0.99 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.41, "ci95": [ 0.37, 0.45 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.92, "ci95": [ 0.885, 0.95 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.88, "ci95": [ 0.845, 0.915 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.43, "ci95": [ 0.385, 0.475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.62, "ci95": [ 0.565, 0.67 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.78, "ci95": [ 0.715, 0.84 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.62, "ci95": [ 0.575, 0.6651249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.965, "ci95": [ 0.94, 0.985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.53, "ci95": [ 0.505, 0.56 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.915, "ci95": [ 0.88, 0.945 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.88, "ci95": [ 0.845, 0.915 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.54, "ci95": [ 0.515, 0.57 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.735, "ci95": [ 0.685, 0.785 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.815, "ci95": [ 0.77, 0.86 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.725, "ci95": [ 0.68, 0.77 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.045, "ci95": [ 0.02, 0.075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.32, "ci95": [ 0.27, 0.37 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.515, "ci95": [ 0.445, 0.585 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.07, "ci95": [ 0.035, 0.11 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.13, "ci95": [ 0.09, 0.17 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.565, "ci95": [ 0.47, 0.66 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.065, "ci95": [ 0.035, 0.1 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.895, "ci95": [ 0.855, 0.93 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.86, "ci95": [ 0.82, 0.9 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.51, "ci95": [ 0.475, 0.545 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.705, "ci95": [ 0.655, 0.755 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.81, "ci95": [ 0.76, 0.86 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7, "ci95": [ 0.655, 0.745 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.635, "ci95": [ 0.575, 0.69 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.12, "ci95": [ 0.08, 0.16 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.235, "ci95": [ 0.19, 0.285 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.645, "ci95": [ 0.56, 0.73 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.18, "ci95": [ 0.135, 0.225 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.14, "ci95": [ 0.105, 0.18 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.265, "ci95": [ 0.215, 0.315 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.575, "ci95": [ 0.485, 0.66 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.18, "ci95": [ 0.14, 0.22 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.695, "ci95": [ 0.645, 0.745 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.78, "ci95": [ 0.725, 0.83 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.68, "ci95": [ 0.63, 0.725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.685, "ci95": [ 0.605, 0.7601249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.495, "ci95": [ 0.44, 0.555 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.255, "ci95": [ 0.185, 0.325 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 113, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 15.365, 15.625 ], "rel2": [ 14.07, 14.455 ], "rel3": [ 13.024875, 13.330124999999999 ], "rel4": [ 12.354875, 12.685 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.54, 3.91 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 12.415, 13.115 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 4.374875, 4.885 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.625, 4.005 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.999875, 9.605 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.845, 4.34 ], "release_s1003": [ 7.92, 8.47 ], "release_s1004": [ 8.7, 9.63 ], "robust_s1001": [ 3.96, 4.530125 ], "robust_s1002": [ 5.604875000000001, 6.39 ], "robust_s1003": [ 8.23, 9.74 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.3648750000000005, 5.9701249999999995 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.38333333333333336, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.3, 0.48333333333333334 ], "spearman": 0.5823529411764706, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.4793837953853734, 0.6676470588235294 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.14999999999999997, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.19400944423737895, -0.06666666666666665 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.15899720766358738, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.19761839226456343, 0.4641722099133472 ], "spearman": 0.17660048931157807, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.28346936064798345, 0.585764960837582 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.10991035536162269, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.19474843483028967, -0.06808336471130218 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.9995 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5333333333333333, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.45, 0.6276205565667923 ], "spearman": 0.6882352941176471, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6342416620373943, 0.788249799737832 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.006132065817227805, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.1274825405876079, 0.039325636133665576 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.8335 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 83, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 11, "discordant_method_correct": 1, "discordant_base_correct": 10 } }, "wb_logu1_8": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 15.343000000000002, "rel2": 14.125250000000001, "rel3": 13.13125, "rel4": 12.477, "nonoise_s1001": 3.920499999999998, "nonoise_s1002": 12.702, "nonoise_s1003": 5.266749999999999, "nonoise_s1004": 3.835999999999999, "release_s1001": 9.000000000000002, "release_s1002": 4.260249999999998, "release_s1003": 8.381500000000003, "release_s1004": 9.175250000000004, "robust_s1001": 4.481999999999998, "robust_s1002": 5.851499999999998, "robust_s1003": 8.473249999999998, "robust_s1004": 5.574500000000001 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1004", "nonoise_s1001", "release_s1002", "robust_s1001", "nonoise_s1003", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1002", "release_s1003", "robust_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1004", "rel4", "nonoise_s1002", "rel3", "rel2", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.505, "rel2": 0.733, "rel3": 0.86, "rel4": 0.947, "nonoise_s1001": 0.982, "nonoise_s1002": 0.982, "nonoise_s1003": 0.982, "nonoise_s1004": 0.982, "release_s1001": 0.982, "release_s1002": 0.982, "release_s1003": 0.982, "release_s1004": 0.987, "robust_s1001": 0.982, "robust_s1002": 0.982, "robust_s1003": 0.955, "robust_s1004": 0.982 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.749, "rel2": 0.94, "rel3": 0.973, "rel4": 0.997, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 0.98, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.627, "rel2": 0.8365, "rel3": 0.9165, "rel4": 0.972, "nonoise_s1001": 0.991, "nonoise_s1002": 0.991, "nonoise_s1003": 0.991, "nonoise_s1004": 0.991, "release_s1001": 0.991, "release_s1002": 0.991, "release_s1003": 0.991, "release_s1004": 0.9935, "robust_s1001": 0.991, "robust_s1002": 0.991, "robust_s1003": 0.9675, "robust_s1004": 0.991 } }, "common_success_units": 1248, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 9.397756402500164, "rel2": 6.885176281516369, "rel3": 6.224358977797704, "rel4": 6.075480765448167, "nonoise_s1001": 5.487499998166011, "nonoise_s1002": 6.160016035040219, "nonoise_s1003": 5.548477557225105, "nonoise_s1004": 5.48701922614605, "release_s1001": 5.730929496387641, "release_s1002": 5.508012816309929, "release_s1003": 5.674519234169752, "release_s1004": 5.713862179181515, "robust_s1001": 5.508974348696379, "robust_s1002": 5.539583325959169, "robust_s1003": 5.763701910582872, "robust_s1004": 5.53830127341625 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.13799999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.11200000000000002, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.09024999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.06799374999999998, 0.11350000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.0655, "ci95": [ 0.04349999999999999, 0.09000624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0045, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.213, "ci95": [ 0.15924375000000002, 0.2670124999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0052499999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.0015, 0.010249999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0045, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.00475, "ci95": [ 0.00125, 0.009499999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0045, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.012000000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.006000000000000002, 0.018999999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.0635, "ci95": [ 0.0365, 0.09475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0045, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0045, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.03775, "ci95": [ 0.019249999999999993, 0.061 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0045, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.17750000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.14624999999999996, 0.20900624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.14824999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.11600000000000003, 0.1815 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0045, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.34374999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.28649375, 0.39975625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.007749999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.0034999999999999996, 0.012999999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0045, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0075000000000000015, "ci95": [ 0.0034999999999999996, 0.012499999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0045, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.021249999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.013249999999999998, 0.03024999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.15925, "ci95": [ 0.11100000000000003, 0.21226249999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0045, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0045, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1205, "ci95": [ 0.07599375000000001, 0.1675 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0045, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.009 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.26375, "ci95": [ 0.22749375000000002, 0.30000000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.00125, 0.009756249999999968 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.4275, "ci95": [ 0.3787375, 0.4727624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0085, "ci95": [ 0.004, 0.014006249999999968 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.00125, 0.009756249999999968 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.01575, "ci95": [ 0.00825, 0.025249999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.00125, 0.009756249999999968 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.026000000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.017249999999999998, 0.03599999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.20374999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.14599375, 0.2635124999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.00125, 0.009756249999999968 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.00125, 0.009756249999999968 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.16125, "ci95": [ 0.11049375, 0.2110062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.00125, 0.009756249999999968 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.00575, "ci95": [ 0.0015, 0.0115 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.46974999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.42149374999999994, 0.5167499999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.009750000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.0045000000000000005, 0.016249999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.00575, "ci95": [ 0.0015, 0.0115 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.03724999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.018493749999999996, 0.06025624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.00575, "ci95": [ 0.0015, 0.0115 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0315, "ci95": [ 0.020999999999999998, 0.042506249999999975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.21974999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.1599875, 0.28250625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.00575, "ci95": [ 0.0015, 0.0115 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.007000000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0025, 0.012506249999999967 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.19675000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.14524374999999998, 0.2497562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.00575, "ci95": [ 0.0015, 0.0115 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.9714999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.95825, 0.983 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.6607499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.6407500000000002, 0.6797562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.4885, "ci95": [ 0.4769937499999999, 0.4977499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9315000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.91175, 0.95 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.5367500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5212499999999999, 0.5552499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.89375, "ci95": [ 0.87224375, 0.91425 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8532500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8272499999999999, 0.8787625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.557, "ci95": [ 0.5372499999999997, 0.5780062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.7085000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6879937499999997, 0.7302499999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.79425, "ci95": [ 0.75074375, 0.8350000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7034999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6782500000000001, 0.73025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.025249999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.014750000000000001, 0.0375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0255, "ci95": [ 0.015000000000000003, 0.0375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.077, "ci95": [ 0.04449999999999999, 0.11275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.044250000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.027750000000000004, 0.061500000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.055999999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.03674374999999999, 0.07725 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.11775000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.07249375000000001, 0.17175624999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.03975, "ci95": [ 0.02099375, 0.06624999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.06375, "ci95": [ 0.04449374999999999, 0.08500624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.23450000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.18774999999999997, 0.2827499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.03975000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.024750000000000005, 0.05624999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.33225, "ci95": [ 0.3134937500000001, 0.3507500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.8852500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8647499999999998, 0.90475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.37225, "ci95": [ 0.3492499999999998, 0.39724999999999966 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8727499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8537499999999999, 0.8919999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8334999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.8065000000000001, 0.8595062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.39425, "ci95": [ 0.36700000000000005, 0.4225062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.52825, "ci95": [ 0.5000000000000002, 0.5559999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.70025, "ci95": [ 0.6432437499999999, 0.7565124999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.5317500000000002, "ci95": [ 0.5115000000000001, 0.5542499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9390000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9205000000000001, 0.9562500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.5435, "ci95": [ 0.5257437499999998, 0.5644999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9015000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8809999999999999, 0.9222499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8625, "ci95": [ 0.8380000000000001, 0.8867625000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5682500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.5517499999999997, 0.5862499999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.7114999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6907437499999997, 0.7325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.79425, "ci95": [ 0.7510000000000001, 0.836 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7094999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.68324375, 0.7360062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.08375, "ci95": [ 0.06149374999999998, 0.10675000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.40975, "ci95": [ 0.3795000000000001, 0.4397500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.54725, "ci95": [ 0.49, 0.60475 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.10074999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.0715, 0.13450625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.17675000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.14474375, 0.2080062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.47474999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.40025000000000005, 0.5490062500000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.105, "ci95": [ 0.08150000000000002, 0.12900625000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8652500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.8394937499999999, 0.89050625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8275, "ci95": [ 0.79424375, 0.8587499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.52425, "ci95": [ 0.49549374999999984, 0.5507499999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.6699999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.6452500000000001, 0.69375625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7809999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7382500000000001, 0.82375625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6719999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6442500000000001, 0.6992562500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6147499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5632499999999999, 0.6649999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.146, "ci95": [ 0.11474999999999999, 0.18124999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.235, "ci95": [ 0.20100000000000004, 0.26900625000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5429999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4774937500000002, 0.6077500000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.16949999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.14699375000000003, 0.19274999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.1765, "ci95": [ 0.14775, 0.2070062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.2675, "ci95": [ 0.22749374999999997, 0.3070062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.49024999999999996, "ci95": [ 0.42346875, 0.5545 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.19325, "ci95": [ 0.16249375000000002, 0.22574999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.6545000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6242437499999995, 0.6835062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7472499999999997, "ci95": [ 0.6959937500000001, 0.7959999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.64275, "ci95": [ 0.6087437500000002, 0.67525625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.68025, "ci95": [ 0.6117499999999999, 0.7475062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.505, "ci95": [ 0.4670000000000002, 0.5447500000000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.28275, "ci95": [ 0.2259937499999999, 0.3400124999999997 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 113, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 15.198700000000002, 15.478256249999998 ], "rel2": [ 13.961500000000008, 14.291775000000003 ], "rel3": [ 12.996750000000004, 13.270524999999994 ], "rel4": [ 12.314218750000002, 12.63830000000001 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.801737499999999, 4.037756249999999 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 12.419493749999997, 12.9935125 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 5.117981250000001, 5.415812499999998 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.7075000000000005, 3.9515124999999993 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.746962500000002, 9.240568750000003 ], "release_s1002": [ 4.099462499999999, 4.439806249999999 ], "release_s1003": [ 8.21395, 8.549531250000003 ], "release_s1004": [ 8.747731250000001, 9.617506250000005 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.269993749999999, 4.7337750000000005 ], "robust_s1002": [ 5.603712499999998, 6.104056249999998 ], "robust_s1003": [ 7.825231249999997, 9.140862500000003 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.403250000000002, 5.749750000000002 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.38333333333333336, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.3096261412396175, 0.48333333333333334 ], "spearman": 0.5823529411764706, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.4974155643601566, 0.6764705882352942 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.14999999999999997, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.18333333333333335, -0.06666666666666665 ], "p_delta_le_0": 1.0 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.15899720766358738, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.18492015214942892, 0.47060485181697004 ], "spearman": 0.18395884303289384, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.27012941201109636, 0.6049270655047121 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.10991035536162269, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.17800891944711014, -0.07538542379816156 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.999 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5833333333333334, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.4666666666666667, 0.65 ], "spearman": 0.7647058823529411, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6529411764705882, 0.8205882352941176 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.05613206581722785, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.10520403037718651, 0.05613206581722785 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.653 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 83, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 9, "discordant_method_correct": 0, "discordant_base_correct": 9 } }, "wb_u1_4": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 15.419250000000003, "rel2": 14.131750000000004, "rel3": 13.159500000000001, "rel4": 12.595250000000004, "nonoise_s1001": 3.8212499999999996, "nonoise_s1002": 13.152250000000004, "nonoise_s1003": 5.428, "nonoise_s1004": 3.814499999999998, "release_s1001": 9.160500000000006, "release_s1002": 4.134499999999998, "release_s1003": 8.456999999999997, "release_s1004": 9.35825, "robust_s1001": 4.371250000000001, "robust_s1002": 5.252000000000001, "robust_s1003": 8.13125, "robust_s1004": 5.613500000000003 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1004", "nonoise_s1001", "release_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1002", "nonoise_s1003", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "release_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1004", "rel4", "nonoise_s1002", "rel3", "rel2", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.536, "rel2": 0.799, "rel3": 0.956, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 0.857, "rel2": 0.992, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.6965, "rel2": 0.8955, "rel3": 0.978, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1393, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 8.269633872681869, "rel2": 6.242928944640423, "rel3": 5.972720762849796, "rel4": 5.893682713142335, "nonoise_s1001": 5.367623826538327, "nonoise_s1002": 6.011414241893465, "nonoise_s1003": 5.429504651776853, "nonoise_s1004": 5.368485273428298, "release_s1001": 5.595333819413305, "release_s1002": 5.386934665836025, "release_s1003": 5.546877242983115, "release_s1004": 5.6060301572918805, "robust_s1001": 5.3893754343633935, "robust_s1002": 5.403230424930274, "robust_s1003": 5.578033015955633, "robust_s1004": 5.425053824645875 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.11025, "ci95": [ 0.0825, 0.14025624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.06375000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.03975, 0.08975624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.05525, "ci95": [ 0.03149999999999999, 0.08124999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.24775000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.18374375, 0.3095 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0007500000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0017499999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.006500000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0032500000000000003, 0.010249999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.07125, "ci95": [ 0.0375, 0.10975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.024249999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.005, 0.04975 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.17225000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.13674374999999997, 0.20799999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.156, "ci95": [ 0.11950000000000001, 0.19374999999999992 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.35875, "ci95": [ 0.29675, 0.41950000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0025, "ci95": [ 0.0007500000000000001, 0.0045000000000000005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0027500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.005 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.017, "ci95": [ 0.0105, 0.0235 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.18375, "ci95": [ 0.12949375, 0.2432687499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.08549999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.04300000000000001, 0.12950624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.26975, "ci95": [ 0.23024374999999994, 0.3115 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.44150000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.391, 0.48774999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0032500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.00125, 0.0055 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0105, "ci95": [ 0.00225, 0.02275624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.02025, "ci95": [ 0.012999999999999998, 0.027999999999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.21099999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.14975000000000002, 0.27425625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.12025000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.07275000000000001, 0.16876249999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.48375, "ci95": [ 0.43549375000000007, 0.53075 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.004, "ci95": [ 0.0017499999999999998, 0.0065000000000000014 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.0165, "ci95": [ 0.0037500000000000007, 0.03600624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.022250000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.014000000000000002, 0.030749999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.22000000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.15799375000000002, 0.2847624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.13925, "ci95": [ 0.09049375000000001, 0.19000624999999988 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.9944999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.9882499999999999, 0.99875 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.6945, "ci95": [ 0.67125, 0.7165000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.498, "ci95": [ 0.48724999999999985, 0.5062562500000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9492500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9299937499999998, 0.9672562500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.53275, "ci95": [ 0.5182499999999999, 0.5514999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.90675, "ci95": [ 0.8857500000000001, 0.9277562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.87, "ci95": [ 0.84524375, 0.8932499999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5567499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5372499999999998, 0.5782499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.6617500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6422499999999998, 0.6832499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.795, "ci95": [ 0.7499812499999999, 0.8377562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7195, "ci95": [ 0.6927500000000002, 0.7485062500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.005250000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.011756249999999966 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.005, "ci95": [ 0.001, 0.010756249999999965 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.057, "ci95": [ 0.02775, 0.09250624999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.02, "ci95": [ 0.00525, 0.04075 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.0225, "ci95": [ 0.00924375, 0.03874999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.08775000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.04300000000000001, 0.14301249999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.016, "ci95": [ 0.0024999999999999996, 0.041762499999999925 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.019500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.0095, 0.03175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.1295, "ci95": [ 0.08425000000000002, 0.17475 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.011500000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.0029937500000000003, 0.022506249999999964 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.30649999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.28525, 0.32824999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9057499999999998, "ci95": [ 0.8852500000000002, 0.9259999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.3345, "ci95": [ 0.30949999999999994, 0.36251249999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8784999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.8595, 0.8989999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8389999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.81375, 0.8637625000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.3605, "ci95": [ 0.3317437499999999, 0.3905124999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.45524999999999993, "ci95": [ 0.42724999999999996, 0.48375624999999955 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.69175, "ci95": [ 0.6297437499999999, 0.75325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.5105, "ci95": [ 0.49324999999999997, 0.5292499999999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.953, "ci95": [ 0.9335000000000001, 0.9707499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.5319999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5152437499999999, 0.554 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.90925, "ci95": [ 0.8897437499999999, 0.9295 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.87225, "ci95": [ 0.8492499999999998, 0.8945062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.55875, "ci95": [ 0.5424937499999997, 0.5779999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.66025, "ci95": [ 0.6399999999999999, 0.68200625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.79175, "ci95": [ 0.7459875, 0.83500625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.7177500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6907437500000002, 0.7464999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.06449999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.041749999999999995, 0.08900625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.402, "ci95": [ 0.37322499999999986, 0.42975625000000023 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.541, "ci95": [ 0.4819999999999999, 0.6007562499999998 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.08324999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.05274374999999999, 0.11775624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.10825, "ci95": [ 0.0825, 0.13425000000000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.4545, "ci95": [ 0.3799937500000001, 0.5302562500000001 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.08175, "ci95": [ 0.05975000000000001, 0.10325 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.8832499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.85574375, 0.91000625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8469999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.81375, 0.8779999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5257499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.4989999999999998, 0.5517499999999994 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.6240000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6007437499999996, 0.6462499999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.77625, "ci95": [ 0.7304999999999999, 0.82225625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6930000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.66425, 0.7217562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.6214999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5705000000000002, 0.6695062500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.127, "ci95": [ 0.09625, 0.16150624999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.17525, "ci95": [ 0.14674375000000003, 0.20300625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.5277499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.45675000000000004, 0.5965124999999999 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.15975, "ci95": [ 0.1362500000000001, 0.18325624999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.155, "ci95": [ 0.1295, 0.18425 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.21925000000000006, "ci95": [ 0.184, 0.25499999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.44775000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.3782500000000002, 0.5132562500000002 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.18424999999999997, "ci95": [ 0.15600000000000003, 0.21551249999999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.60125, "ci95": [ 0.572, 0.6285062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7502499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6985000000000002, 0.7997562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6602499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6260000000000003, 0.6940062500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.7020000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6395000000000001, 0.7630687499999994 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.57075, "ci95": [ 0.5399999999999999, 0.6022562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.30449999999999994, "ci95": [ 0.23974375, 0.36725625 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 112, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 15.260956250000008, 15.561762500000004 ], "rel2": [ 13.963000000000006, 14.306999999999999 ], "rel3": [ 13.034993749999995, 13.282256249999998 ], "rel4": [ 12.44824375, 12.739756250000008 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.7119874999999993, 3.92976875 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 12.894731249999998, 13.407056250000005 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 5.269499999999999, 5.584249999999998 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.702468749999998, 3.924512499999999 ], "release_s1001": [ 8.912737500000006, 9.414768750000002 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.9689812499999992, 4.337274999999998 ], "release_s1003": [ 8.2859875, 8.630999999999997 ], "release_s1004": [ 8.920743750000003, 9.803318749999997 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.1619375000000005, 4.626575 ], "robust_s1002": [ 5.047493749999998, 5.453506249999997 ], "robust_s1003": [ 7.501637499999996, 8.785543750000002 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.426243750000003, 5.809025 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.43333333333333335, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.35, 0.55 ], "spearman": 0.6529411764705882, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.5676470588235294, 0.7411764705882353 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.09999999999999998, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.1272012675161055, -0.016666666666666607 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.9985 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.1924703040138163, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.16807316136320358, 0.4979301888161361 ], "spearman": 0.22810896536078834, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.2506330394728968, 0.6627598485037589 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.07643725901139378, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.15942624771326455, -0.042405804250536555 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.999 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.5833333333333334, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.4666666666666667, 0.6666666666666666 ], "spearman": 0.7647058823529411, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.6852941176470588, 0.8264705882352941 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.05613206581722785, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.0944269862503545, 0.05634171034257118 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.506 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 86, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 6, "discordant_method_correct": 0, "discordant_base_correct": 6 } }, "yaw_45": { "rom": { "mean_rank": { "rel1": 14.980249999999995, "rel2": 13.578500000000005, "rel3": 12.83125, "rel4": 12.45525, "nonoise_s1001": 3.810999999999999, "nonoise_s1002": 13.777249999999997, "nonoise_s1003": 8.015499999999998, "nonoise_s1004": 3.8455, "release_s1001": 9.18125, "release_s1002": 3.9467500000000006, "release_s1003": 9.8905, "release_s1004": 9.958000000000002, "robust_s1001": 4.3795, "robust_s1002": 4.229000000000001, "robust_s1003": 5.919250000000001, "robust_s1004": 5.201250000000003 }, "order": [ "nonoise_s1001", "nonoise_s1004", "release_s1002", "robust_s1002", "robust_s1001", "robust_s1004", "robust_s1003", "nonoise_s1003", "release_s1001", "release_s1003", "release_s1004", "rel4", "rel3", "rel2", "nonoise_s1002", "rel1" ], "success_rate": { "id": { "rel1": 0.886, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "ood": { "rel1": 1.0, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 }, "all": { "rel1": 0.943, "rel2": 1.0, "rel3": 1.0, "rel4": 1.0, "nonoise_s1001": 1.0, "nonoise_s1002": 1.0, "nonoise_s1003": 1.0, "nonoise_s1004": 1.0, "release_s1001": 1.0, "release_s1002": 1.0, "release_s1003": 1.0, "release_s1004": 1.0, "robust_s1001": 1.0, "robust_s1002": 1.0, "robust_s1003": 1.0, "robust_s1004": 1.0 } }, "common_success_units": 1886, "mean_time_common_success": { "rel1": 5.593584316027126, "rel2": 5.253446449024933, "rel3": 5.145334042268998, "rel4": 5.105355247080895, "nonoise_s1001": 4.653340406281319, "nonoise_s1002": 5.290349959821489, "nonoise_s1003": 4.788865326191689, "nonoise_s1004": 4.654612940164285, "release_s1001": 4.826139980004676, "release_s1002": 4.657794273923589, "release_s1003": 4.8608165375121954, "release_s1004": 4.909331923577843, "robust_s1001": 4.670837755926341, "robust_s1002": 4.664262990051464, "robust_s1003": 4.736214209841772, "robust_s1004": 4.693478262689941 }, "pairs": [ { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel2", "win_a": 0.10024999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.07524375000000003, 0.12900000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.0935, "ci95": [ 0.06874375, 0.12075000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.09325, "ci95": [ 0.07024374999999998, 0.11900624999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.37599999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.32124374999999994, 0.42724999999999985 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.0255, "ci95": [ 0.013000000000000001, 0.040756249999999966 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.018500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.007250000000000001, 0.03275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.09700000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.06450000000000002, 0.13126249999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.20875, "ci95": [ 0.15050000000000002, 0.26899999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.006999999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.0029937500000000003, 0.01175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel1", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel3", "win_a": 0.23925000000000002, "ci95": [ 0.20650000000000002, 0.2735062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.23125, "ci95": [ 0.20124375000000003, 0.26126249999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.4675, "ci95": [ 0.42925, 0.50375625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.05950000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.04024375, 0.08025624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.05125, "ci95": [ 0.03324375, 0.07175000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.17125000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.12873750000000003, 0.21174999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.27175000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.21100000000000002, 0.33075625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.015000000000000003, 0.04724999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel2", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "rel4", "win_a": 0.349, "ci95": [ 0.32425, 0.3737562500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.5155, "ci95": [ 0.4817375000000001, 0.551 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.066, "ci95": [ 0.045, 0.08825624999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.05725, "ci95": [ 0.03825, 0.0785 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.18625000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.14499374999999998, 0.226 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.28775, "ci95": [ 0.2297375, 0.34325000000000006 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.03975000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.022750000000000003, 0.05975000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel3", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.54, "ci95": [ 0.5054750000000001, 0.5782500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.07075000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.04924999999999999, 0.09326249999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.06725, "ci95": [ 0.04724375000000001, 0.08900625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.196, "ci95": [ 0.15525000000000003, 0.23475625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.29525, "ci95": [ 0.23775000000000002, 0.35050000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.048999999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.029750000000000006, 0.07050000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "rel4", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1002", "win_a": 0.9997499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.99925, 1.0 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.885, "ci95": [ 0.8685, 0.9015062500000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.5057499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.5017499999999998, 0.5094999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9625, "ci95": [ 0.9507499999999999, 0.97375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.516, "ci95": [ 0.5097499999999998, 0.5227499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.9365000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9192500000000001, 0.9530062499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8885, "ci95": [ 0.87125, 0.9057500000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5705, "ci95": [ 0.5587437499999998, 0.5837499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.5515, "ci95": [ 0.5422437499999997, 0.5615000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6892499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6597375000000004, 0.7185000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.68375, "ci95": [ 0.6620000000000004, 0.7065062500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1003", "win_a": 0.00575, "ci95": [ 0.0017500000000000003, 0.010506249999999969 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.00025, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0007500000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.037000000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.024, 0.05125000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.00125, "ci95": [ 0.00025, 0.0025 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.008, "ci95": [ 0.003, 0.014749999999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.03775, "ci95": [ 0.022499999999999996, 0.054506249999999964 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.007000000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.00274375, 0.012499999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.0005, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.00125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.02175, "ci95": [ 0.013000000000000003, 0.03125 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.0022500000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.0007500000000000001, 0.00425 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "nonoise_s1004", "win_a": 0.115, "ci95": [ 0.09875000000000002, 0.13100624999999996 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.6335000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6142500000000003, 0.6525062500000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.1255, "ci95": [ 0.10949374999999999, 0.14225625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.7647499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.7469999999999999, 0.7834999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.7085000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6830000000000002, 0.7347562499999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.14375, "ci95": [ 0.1255, 0.165 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.14024999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.1245, 0.157 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.29825, "ci95": [ 0.2612500000000001, 0.33325625000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.16749999999999995, "ci95": [ 0.15100000000000008, 0.18575624999999982 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1001", "win_a": 0.9622499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.95049375, 0.9734999999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.51025, "ci95": [ 0.5052500000000001, 0.5159999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.937, "ci95": [ 0.92, 0.95375 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.88875, "ci95": [ 0.8717437499999998, 0.9057562500000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.565, "ci95": [ 0.5537499999999997, 0.5779999999999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.54575, "ci95": [ 0.5359999999999999, 0.5560000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6862500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6565000000000002, 0.7147500000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "nonoise_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6802499999999999, "ci95": [ 0.6587500000000004, 0.7035000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1002", "win_a": 0.04075, "ci95": [ 0.028999999999999995, 0.053 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.61075, "ci95": [ 0.5892499999999999, 0.6314999999999995 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.59475, "ci95": [ 0.56, 0.6292499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.05949999999999999, "ci95": [ 0.04500000000000001, 0.07475000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.052250000000000005, "ci95": [ 0.03975, 0.06500625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.18325, "ci95": [ 0.14974374999999998, 0.2175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.067, "ci95": [ 0.053, 0.0815 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1003", "win_a": 0.93125, "ci95": [ 0.91374375, 0.949 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.8775, "ci95": [ 0.8602500000000001, 0.8945062499999998 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.5545, "ci95": [ 0.5425, 0.5682499999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.534, "ci95": [ 0.5247437500000001, 0.5437500000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6785, "ci95": [ 0.6482499999999999, 0.7070000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6712500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6485000000000001, 0.6950000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "release_s1004", "win_a": 0.53725, "ci95": [ 0.4932500000000003, 0.5817625 ], "resolved": false }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.084, "ci95": [ 0.064, 0.10575000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.07725, "ci95": [ 0.05925000000000002, 0.09674999999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.15925000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.13174375, 0.18600000000000003 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.09050000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.07050000000000002, 0.11200624999999999 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1001", "win_a": 0.13274999999999998, "ci95": [ 0.11400000000000005, 0.15225000000000002 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.1355, "ci95": [ 0.11824374999999995, 0.15275 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.21700000000000003, "ci95": [ 0.18975000000000006, 0.24425000000000008 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "release_s1004", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.15325, "ci95": [ 0.13525000000000004, 0.17124999999999993 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1002", "win_a": 0.48125, "ci95": [ 0.4697500000000001, 0.49175 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.63975, "ci95": [ 0.6049937500000001, 0.6732562500000004 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1001", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.6165, "ci95": [ 0.5987500000000001, 0.63400625 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1003", "win_a": 0.6502500000000001, "ci95": [ 0.6147437499999998, 0.6837499999999997 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1002", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.639, "ci95": [ 0.6175, 0.6605000000000001 ], "resolved": true }, { "a": "robust_s1003", "b": "robust_s1004", "win_a": 0.43, "ci95": [ 0.38449374999999986, 0.4774999999999999 ], "resolved": true } ], "resolved_pairs": 117, "mean_rank_ci95": { "rel1": [ 14.774987499999998, 15.184768750000002 ], "rel2": [ 13.382962500000003, 13.76875 ], "rel3": [ 12.692981249999992, 12.971000000000002 ], "rel4": [ 12.317993750000007, 12.595037500000004 ], "nonoise_s1001": [ 3.7327500000000002, 3.89150625 ], "nonoise_s1002": [ 13.615493749999999, 13.938756250000003 ], "nonoise_s1003": [ 7.871699999999999, 8.162249999999997 ], "nonoise_s1004": [ 3.772250000000001, 3.9185062499999983 ], "release_s1001": [ 9.075743749999999, 9.290006250000003 ], "release_s1002": [ 3.864974999999999, 4.029268750000003 ], "release_s1003": [ 9.683931249999995, 10.095824999999998 ], "release_s1004": [ 9.606993750000003, 10.316006250000004 ], "robust_s1001": [ 4.281725, 4.49328125 ], "robust_s1002": [ 4.136750000000001, 4.325012499999999 ], "robust_s1003": [ 5.604187500000002, 6.227499999999997 ], "robust_s1004": [ 5.069487500000002, 5.3382625000000035 ] } }, "vs_chrono": { "all": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.55, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.45, 0.6333333333333333 ], "spearman": 0.7676470588235295, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7028676470588234, 0.8235294117647058 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.01666666666666672, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.027131386007657687, 0.05627532290954583 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.2135 }, "id": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.24267994853915967, "kendall_ci95": [ -0.06780635036208105, 0.5715978027200552 ], "spearman": 0.32229589299363, "spearman_ci95": [ -0.10080223942703513, 0.7728647195308118 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": -0.026227614486050405, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.044961110647032544, 0.024824944281026218 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.6995 }, "ood": { "kendall_tau_b": 0.55, "kendall_ci95": [ 0.5, 0.6779677793981649 ], "spearman": 0.788235294117647, "spearman_ci95": [ 0.7441176470588236, 0.8588235294117647 ], "delta_tau_vs_baseline": 0.022798732483894524, "delta_tau_ci95": [ -0.03783763259899277, 0.055922421291884405 ], "p_delta_le_0": 0.3525 } }, "pair_agreement_vs_baseline": { "pairs": 120, "method_correct": 93, "base_correct": 92, "discordant": 1, "discordant_method_correct": 1, "discordant_base_correct": 0 } } } }