"""Every number the pages show about the two text-to-SQL exams, computed from the saved answers. python scripts/text2sql/exam_numbers.py # write web/src/data/exams.json and docs-site/src/data/exams.json python scripts/text2sql/exam_numbers.py --check # exit 1 if either file differs from what the answers give Strict scoring only (scripts/measure_adapter.py): an answer is right when running it returns the same rows as the reference query on the same database. Standard library plus measure_adapter; no GPU and no network. """ # ruff: noqa: E501 (the exam descriptions below are page text, kept as written) import argparse import importlib.util import json import math import sys from pathlib import Path ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[2] _spec = importlib.util.spec_from_file_location("measure_adapter", ROOT / "scripts" / "measure_adapter.py") m = importlib.util.module_from_spec(_spec) sys.modules["measure_adapter"] = m _spec.loader.exec_module(m) R1 = ROOT / "evidence" / "text2sql-round1" R2 = ROOT / "evidence" / "text2sql-round2" X2 = ROOT / "evidence" / "text2sql-exam2" OUTPUTS = [ROOT / "web" / "src" / "data" / "exams.json", ROOT / "docs-site" / "src" / "data" / "exams.json"] DIFFICULTIES = ["simple", "join", "aggregate", "hard"] MODELS = [ {"id": "base", "label": "Base model, no training", "short": "Base model"}, {"id": "teacher", "label": "Teacher (Nemotron 3 Ultra), same prompts", "short": "Teacher"}, {"id": "r1", "label": "Adapter, round 1 (821 rows)", "short": "Adapter, round 1"}, {"id": "r2", "label": "Adapter, round 2 (4,322 rows)", "short": "Adapter, round 2"}, ] EXAMS = [ { "id": "exam1", "name": "Exam 1", "rows": 172, "built": "22 Oct 2026", "writer": "Nemotron 3 Ultra, the teacher (open model, OpenMDW-1.1)", "writer_note": "The same model that wrote the training labels, so it favours the teacher and anything trained to copy it.", "industries": "14 industries; 57 of the 172 questions come from five industries that were never in training.", "checked": "Every reference query was run in the sandbox and kept only if it was one read-only SELECT returning 1 to 100 rows.", "fingerprint": "6b9c1db49bbe2aecf4157ed27845fe024d1b4fcb540f93d81b6987b982b22864", "evidence": "evidence/text2sql-round1", }, { "id": "exam2", "name": "Exam 2", "rows": 200, "built": "23 Oct 2026", "writer": "Claude Sonnet 5.5, a different lab's model, used for evaluation only", "writer_note": "Written after training by a different author, so it does not depend on the teacher's style. No closed model's output is training data anywhere in this project.", "industries": "10 industries in neither the training data nor exam 1: museum collections, veterinary clinic, wine distribution, film production, wind farm maintenance, court cases, recycling plant, podcast network, cinema chain, fishing fleet.", "checked": "The same sandbox check, with the same mix as exam 1 (60 simple, 60 join, 40 aggregate, 40 hard). No row shares a question, a query or a set of table names with the training data.", "fingerprint": "b7634971cf6b0d79e64e30e4c16d1253fad65ab9a501a06edc6c9f8e70d69058", "evidence": "evidence/text2sql-exam2", }, ] def load(path): return m.load_jsonl(path) def wilson(k, n): lo, hi = m.wilson(k, n) return round(lo, 4), round(hi, 4) def score(gold, dbs, answers): """Per-question right/wrong for each answers file; answers = {model: (rows, key or None)}.""" conns = {} out = {} for model, (rows, key) in answers.items(): flags = [False] * len(gold) for r in rows: g = gold[r["i"]] db = g["meta"]["db"] if db not in conns: conns[db] = m.sql_connect(dbs[db]) text = r[key]["text"] if key else r["text"] flags[r["i"]] = bool(m.sql_same(conns[db], g["completion"][0]["content"], text)) out[model] = flags return out, conns def shape(gold, rows, conns): """How the teacher's misses look: same rows with another column count, same count other values, other row count.""" c = {"exact": 0, "same_rows_other_columns": 0, "same_count_other_values": 0, "other_row_count": 0, "does_not_run": 0} for r in rows: g = gold[r["i"]] conn = conns[g["meta"]["db"]] ref, ans = m.sql_rows(conn, g["completion"][0]["content"]), m.sql_rows(conn, r["text"]) if ans is None: c["does_not_run"] += 1 elif m.sql_same(conn, g["completion"][0]["content"], r["text"]): c["exact"] += 1 elif len(ref[0]) != len(ans[0]): c["other_row_count"] += 1 elif ref[0] and ans[0] and len(ref[0][0]) != len(ans[0][0]): c["same_rows_other_columns"] += 1 else: c["same_count_other_values"] += 1 return c def exact_two_sided(up, down): n, k = up + down, min(up, down) return round(min(1.0, 2 * sum(math.comb(n, i) for i in range(k + 1)) / 2**n), 3) def build() -> dict: data = {"scores": {}, "difficulty": {}, "r1_to_r2": {}, "teacher_shape": {}} # exam 1: round 1 answers hold the base model and adapter 1, round 2's file holds adapter 2, the teacher's second answers its own file g1 = load(R1 / "data" / "golden.jsonl") d1 = json.loads((R1 / "data" / "dbs.json").read_text(encoding="utf-8")) r1_raw, r2_raw, t1 = ( load(R1 / "answers" / "raw.jsonl"), load(R2 / "answers" / "raw_r2.jsonl"), load(R1 / "answers" / "teacher2.jsonl"), ) s1, c1 = score( g1, d1, {"base": (r1_raw, "base"), "r1": (r1_raw, "adapter"), "r2": (r2_raw, "adapter"), "teacher": (t1, None)} ) g2 = load(X2 / "data" / "golden.jsonl") d2 = json.loads((X2 / "data" / "dbs.json").read_text(encoding="utf-8")) v1, v2, t2 = ( load(X2 / "answers" / "raw_v1.jsonl"), load(X2 / "answers" / "raw_v2.jsonl"), load(X2 / "answers" / "teacher2.jsonl"), ) s2, c2 = score(g2, d2, {"base": (v1, "base"), "r1": (v1, "adapter"), "r2": (v2, "adapter"), "teacher": (t2, None)}) for exam, gold, s, conns, teacher_rows in (("exam1", g1, s1, c1, t1), ("exam2", g2, s2, c2, t2)): n = len(gold) data["scores"][exam] = {} for model in ("base", "teacher", "r1", "r2"): k = sum(s[model]) lo, hi = wilson(k, n) data["scores"][exam][model] = {"agree": k, "n": n, "rate": round(k / n, 4), "lo": lo, "hi": hi} diff = {} for d in DIFFICULTIES: idx = [i for i, g in enumerate(gold) if g["meta"]["difficulty"] == d] diff[d] = {"n": len(idx), **{model: sum(s[model][i] for i in idx) for model in ("base", "teacher", "r1", "r2")}} data["difficulty"][exam] = diff up = sum(1 for a, b in zip(s["r1"], s["r2"], strict=True) if not a and b) down = sum(1 for a, b in zip(s["r1"], s["r2"], strict=True) if a and not b) both = sum(1 for a, b in zip(s["r1"], s["r2"], strict=True) if a and b) data["r1_to_r2"][exam] = { "wrong_to_right": up, "right_to_wrong": down, "both_right": both, "both_wrong": n - up - down - both, "p": exact_two_sided(up, down), } data["teacher_shape"][exam] = shape(gold, teacher_rows, conns) return {"updated": "2026-10-24", "models": MODELS, "exams": EXAMS, **data} def main() -> int: ap = argparse.ArgumentParser() ap.add_argument("--check", action="store_true") a = ap.parse_args() text = json.dumps(build(), indent=1, ensure_ascii=False) + "\n" bad = 0 for path in OUTPUTS: if a.check: if not path.exists() or path.read_text(encoding="utf-8") != text: print(f"STALE: {path.relative_to(ROOT)} differs from the saved answers; run scripts/text2sql/exam_numbers.py") bad += 1 else: path.parent.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) path.write_text(text, encoding="utf-8", newline="\n") print("wrote", path.relative_to(ROOT)) if a.check and not bad: print("OK: both exams.json files match the saved answers") return 1 if bad else 0 if __name__ == "__main__": sys.exit(main())