import OAI.AlgebraicGeometry.GroupSchemes.Verschiebung import OAI.AlgebraicGeometry.GroupSchemes.DualMaps /-! # Local Obstruction -/ namespace OAI.AlgebraicGeometry.GroupSchemes.LocalObstruction.FiniteEtale noncomputable section /-! # FiniteEtale: the local algebra obstruction at the second level Finite-dimensional nilpotence gives the first-level Frobenius calculation. Nakayama then rules out a nonzero proper kernel ideal generated by pth powers of elements already in that ideal. These are algebraic steps of the connected height-one argument; the geometric classification is not assumed. -/ open OAI.AlgebraicGeometry.GroupSchemes.Verschiebung.FiniteEtale universe u v variable (k : Type u) [Field k] variable (A : Type v) [CommRing A] [Algebra k A] [Module.Finite k A] /-- A nilpotent in a finite-dimensional algebra vanishes by the dimension-th power. -/ theorem nilpotent_pow_finrank (x : A) (hx : IsNilpotent x) : x ^ Module.finrank k A = 0 := by have hφ : IsNilpotent (Algebra.lmul k A x) := hx.map (Algebra.lmul k A) have hz : (Algebra.lmul k A x) ^ Module.finrank k A = 0 := by have h := (Algebra.lmul k A x).aeval_self_charpoly rw [hφ.charpoly_eq_X_pow_finrank] at h simpa using h apply Algebra.lmul_injective (R := k) (A := A) rw [map_pow, map_zero] exact hz /-- In a local finite-dimensional algebra, the kernel of an augmentation is nilpotent. -/ theorem nilpotent_of_augmentation_zero [IsLocalRing A] (ε : A →ₐ[k] k) (x : A) (hx : ε x = 0) : IsNilpotent x := by have : IsArtinianRing A := isArtinian_of_tower k inferInstance rw [← mem_nilradical, nilradical, ← IsArtinianRing.jacobson_eq_radical, Ideal.zero_eq_bot, IsLocalRing.jacobson_eq_maximalIdeal _ bot_ne_top] rw [IsLocalRing.mem_maximalIdeal] intro hu have h := hu.map ε simp only [hx, not_isUnit_zero] at h variable (p : ℕ) [Fact p.Prime] [CharP k p] /-- Frobenius on a local algebra of dimension p factors through its augmentation. -/ theorem frobenius_of_local_rank_prime [IsLocalRing A] (hdim : Module.finrank k A = p) (ε : A →ₐ[k] k) (x : A) : x ^ p = algebraMap k A ((ε x) ^ p) := by have hn : (x - algebraMap k A (ε x)) ^ p = 0 := by rw [← hdim] apply nilpotent_pow_finrank k A apply nilpotent_of_augmentation_zero k A ε simp calc x ^ p = ((x - algebraMap k A (ε x)) + algebraMap k A (ε x)) ^ p := by rw [sub_add_cancel] _ = (x - algebraMap k A (ε x)) ^ p + (algebraMap k A (ε x)) ^ p := Verschiebung.FiniteEtale.algebra_pow_add p k A _ _ _ = (algebraMap k A (ε x)) ^ p := by rw [hn, zero_add] _ = algebraMap k A ((ε x) ^ p) := (map_pow _ _ _).symm section IdealObstruction variable {R : Type*} [CommRing R] [IsNoetherianRing R] [IsLocalRing R] /-- Nakayama's obstruction: a proper ideal cannot be generated by pth powers of images lying in the same ideal, unless the ideal is zero. -/ theorem kernel_ideal_eq_bot (p : ℕ) (hp : 2 ≤ p) (m I : Ideal R) (V : R →+* R) (hproper : I ≠ ⊤) (hV : ∀ x ∈ m, V x ∈ I) (hgen : I = Ideal.span ((fun x => V x ^ p) '' (m : Set R))) : I = ⊥ := by have hpow : I ≤ I ^ p := by conv_lhs => rw [hgen] apply Ideal.span_le.mpr rintro _ ⟨x, hx, rfl⟩ exact Ideal.pow_mem_pow (hV x hx) p have hsq : I ≤ I * I := by simpa only [pow_two] using hpow.trans (Ideal.pow_le_pow_right hp) have hid : IsIdempotentElem I := le_antisymm Ideal.mul_le_left hsq exact ((Ideal.isIdempotentElem_iff_eq_bot_or_top_of_isLocalRing I).mp hid).resolve_right hproper end IdealObstruction section DualLocal variable (C : Type*) [CommRing C] [HopfAlgebra k C] [Coalgebra.IsCocomm k C] [Module.Finite k C] [PerfectRing k p] local instance : CommRing (AbelianScheme.CartierDuality.DualAlgebra.Construction.DualCoordinate k C) := LinearMap.convCommRing local instance : Algebra k (AbelianScheme.CartierDuality.DualAlgebra.Construction.DualCoordinate k C) := LinearMap.convAlgebra variable [IsLocalRing (AbelianScheme.CartierDuality.DualAlgebra.Construction.DualCoordinate k C)] /-- If the Cartier dual has local coordinate algebra of dimension p, Verschiebung kills the augmentation ideal of the original group. -/ theorem verschiebung_kills_augmentation (hdim : Module.finrank k C = p) (x : C) (hx : Coalgebra.counit (R := k) x = 0) : Verschiebung.FiniteEtale.verschiebungFun p k C x = 0 := by apply (AbelianScheme.CartierDuality.DualAlgebra.Construction.dualCoordinateBidualLinearEquiv k C).injective ext f simp only [AbelianScheme.CartierDuality.DualAlgebra.Construction.dualCoordinateBidualLinearEquiv_apply, map_zero] apply (frobeniusEquiv k p).injective change f (Verschiebung.FiniteEtale.verschiebungFun p k C x) ^ p = (0 : k) ^ p rw [Verschiebung.FiniteEtale.eval_verschiebung_pow, zero_pow (Fact.out : p.Prime).ne_zero] have hdimD : Module.finrank k (AbelianScheme.CartierDuality.DualAlgebra.Construction.DualCoordinate k C) = p := by rw [(AbelianScheme.CartierDuality.DualAlgebra.Construction.dualCoordinateLinearEquiv k C).finrank_eq, Subspace.dual_finrank_eq, hdim] rw [frobenius_of_local_rank_prime k (AbelianScheme.CartierDuality.DualAlgebra.Construction.DualCoordinate k C) p hdimD (Bialgebra.counitAlgHom k (AbelianScheme.CartierDuality.DualAlgebra.Construction.DualCoordinate k C)) f] simp only [LinearMap.convAlgebraMap_apply, hx, map_zero, smul_zero] end DualLocal variable (R S : Type*) [CommRing R] [CommRing S] [HopfAlgebra k R] [HopfAlgebra k S] [Coalgebra.IsCocomm k R] [Coalgebra.IsCocomm k S] [Module.Finite k R] [Module.Finite k S] [PerfectRing k p] /-- The augmentation ideal of the coordinate Hopf algebra. -/ def augmentationIdeal : Ideal R := RingHom.ker (Bialgebra.counitAlgHom k R).toRingHom /-- The ideal defining the kernel of multiplication by p in affine coordinates. -/ def multiplicationKernelIdeal : Ideal R := Ideal.span ((fun x => ((WithConv.toConv (LinearMap.id : R →ₗ[k] R)) ^ p) x) '' (augmentationIdeal k R : Set R)) local instance : CommRing (AbelianScheme.CartierDuality.DualAlgebra.Construction.DualCoordinate k S) := LinearMap.convCommRing local instance : Algebra k (AbelianScheme.CartierDuality.DualAlgebra.Construction.DualCoordinate k S) := LinearMap.convAlgebra /-- The connected/connected obstruction for a prime-order first level: a larger local coordinate Hopf algebra cannot have this multiplication kernel when the quotient's Cartier dual is local. -/ theorem no_local_local_prime_step [IsLocalRing R] [IsLocalRing (AbelianScheme.CartierDuality.DualAlgebra.Construction.DualCoordinate k S)] (hdimR : p < Module.finrank k R) (hdimS : Module.finrank k S = p) (q : R →ₐc[k] S) (hker : RingHom.ker q.toAlgHom.toRingHom = multiplicationKernelIdeal k p R) : False := by have : Nontrivial S := (Bialgebra.counitAlgHom k S).toRingHom.domain_nontrivial have : IsNoetherianRing R := IsNoetherianRing.of_finite k R have hzero : RingHom.ker q.toAlgHom.toRingHom = ⊥ := by apply kernel_ideal_eq_bot p (Fact.out : p.Prime).two_le (augmentationIdeal k R) _ (Verschiebung.FiniteEtale.verschiebungRingHom p k R) · exact RingHom.ker_ne_top _ · intro x hx change q.toCoalgHom (Verschiebung.FiniteEtale.verschiebungFun p k R x) = 0 rw [DualMaps.FiniteEtale.verschiebung_natural k p q.toCoalgHom x] apply verschiebung_kills_augmentation k p S hdimS exact (CoalgHomClass.counit_comp_apply q x).trans hx · change RingHom.ker q.toAlgHom.toRingHom = Ideal.span ((fun x => Verschiebung.FiniteEtale.verschiebungFun p k R x ^ p) '' (augmentationIdeal k R : Set R)) simpa only [multiplicationKernelIdeal, Verschiebung.FiniteEtale.frobenius_verschiebung] using hker have hinj : Function.Injective q.toLinearMap := (RingHom.injective_iff_ker_eq_bot q.toAlgHom.toRingHom).mpr hzero have hle := LinearMap.finrank_le_finrank_of_injective hinj omega end end OAI.AlgebraicGeometry.GroupSchemes.LocalObstruction.FiniteEtale