import OAI.Geometry.Nikodym.SmoothMetric noncomputable section namespace OAI.Geometry.Nikodym.SmoothCoordinateMetric open scoped RealInnerProductSpace variable {E : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup E] [InnerProductSpace ℝ E] [FiniteDimensional ℝ E] /-- Uniqueness of a torsion-free metric-compatible connection, proved directly from the coordinate Koszul formula. -/ theorem christoffel_eq_of_symmetric_compatible (g : SmoothCoordinateMetric E) {x : E} (hx : x ∈ g.domain) (Γ : E → E → E) (hsym : ∀ u v, Γ u v = Γ v u) (hcompat : ∀ u v w, g.inner x (Γ u v) w + g.inner x v (Γ u w) = ⟪fderiv ℝ g.coefficient x u v,w⟫) (u v : E) : g.christoffel x u v = Γ u v := by have hs : ∀ a b, g.inner x a b = g.inner x b a := by intro a b exact (g.symmetric x hx a b).trans (real_inner_comm _ _) have he : ∀ w, g.inner x (g.christoffel x u v) w = g.inner x (Γ u v) w := by intro w rw [g.christoffel_koszul hx, ← hcompat u v w, ← hcompat v u w, ← hcompat w u v] rw [hsym v u, hsym w u, hsym w v, hs v (Γ u w), hs u (Γ v w)] ring let d := g.christoffel x u v - Γ u v have hz : g.inner x d d = 0 := by simpa only [d,SmoothCoordinateMetric.inner,map_sub,inner_sub_left,sub_eq_zero] using he d have hd : d = 0 := by by_contra hn exact (ne_of_gt (g.positive x hx d hn)) hz exact sub_eq_zero.mp hd end OAI.Geometry.Nikodym.SmoothCoordinateMetric