import Mathlib /-! Concrete two-by-two quaternionic Hermitian matrices and the Schur energy inequality, as used in Section 4 of `sections/energy.tex`. This is the first noncommutative block size; no abstract determinant properties are postulated. -/ namespace OAI.LinearAlgebra.Quaternion /-- The Hermitian matrix `[[a,b],[star b,d]]`, with its real diagonal explicit. -/ structure Hermitian where a : ℝ b : Quaternion ℝ d : ℝ /-- The real quaternionic Hermitian quadratic form. -/ def quadratic (A : Hermitian) (x y : Quaternion ℝ) : ℝ := A.a * Quaternion.normSq x + 2 * (star x * A.b * y).re + A.d * Quaternion.normSq y def PositiveSemidefinite (A : Hermitian) : Prop := ∀ x y, 0 ≤ quadratic A x y /-- In size two the Moore determinant is this explicit real polynomial. -/ def determinant (A : Hermitian) : ℝ := A.a * A.d - Quaternion.normSq A.b /-- The real trace pairing of two quaternionic Hermitian matrices. -/ def pairing (A B : Hermitian) : ℝ := A.a * B.a + 2 * (star A.b * B.b).re + A.d * B.d /-- The rank-one positive matrix `v v*` for the quaternionic column `(x,y)`. -/ def rankOne (x y : Quaternion ℝ) : Hermitian where a := Quaternion.normSq x b := x * star y d := Quaternion.normSq y def segment (D B : Hermitian) (t : ℝ) : Hermitian where a := t * D.a + (1 - t) * B.a b := t • D.b + (1 - t) • B.b d := t * D.d + (1 - t) * B.d /-- The mixed coefficient of the two-dimensional Moore determinant. -/ def mixedDeterminant (D B : Hermitian) : ℝ := D.a * B.d + D.d * B.a - 2 * (star D.b * B.b).re theorem re_star_mul_comm (x y : Quaternion ℝ) : (star x * y).re = (star y * x).re := by simp only [Quaternion.re_mul, Quaternion.re_star, Quaternion.imI_star, Quaternion.imJ_star, Quaternion.imK_star] ring theorem re_mul_comm (x y : Quaternion ℝ) : (x * y).re = (y * x).re := by simp only [Quaternion.re_mul] ring private theorem cross_identity (b x y : Quaternion ℝ) : (star b * x * star y).re = (star x * b * y).re := by calc _ = (star (star b * x * star y)).re := (Quaternion.re_star _).symm _ = (y * (star x * b)).re := by simp only [star_mul, star_star] _ = _ := re_mul_comm _ _ theorem rankOne_determinant (x y : Quaternion ℝ) : determinant (rankOne x y) = 0 := by simp [determinant, rankOne, map_mul] theorem rankOne_positiveSemidefinite (u v : Quaternion ℝ) : PositiveSemidefinite (rankOne u v) := by intro x y have hc : (star u * x * star (star v * y)).re = (star x * (u * star v) * y).re := by calc _ = ((star y * v) * (star u * x)).re := by rw [star_mul, star_star, re_mul_comm] _ = (star ((star y * v) * (star u * x))).re := (Quaternion.re_star _).symm _ = _ := by simp only [star_mul, star_star, mul_assoc] have hid : quadratic (rankOne u v) x y = Quaternion.normSq (star u * x + star v * y) := by simp only [quadratic, rankOne, Quaternion.normSq_add, map_mul, Quaternion.normSq_star, hc] ring rw [hid] exact Quaternion.normSq_nonneg /-- Polynomial expansion of the actual quaternionic determinant along a segment. -/ theorem determinant_segment (D B : Hermitian) (t : ℝ) : determinant (segment D B t) = t ^ 2 * determinant D + t * (1 - t) * mixedDeterminant D B + (1 - t) ^ 2 * determinant B := by simp only [determinant, segment, mixedDeterminant, Quaternion.normSq_def', Quaternion.re_add, Quaternion.re_smul, Quaternion.imI_add, Quaternion.imI_smul, Quaternion.imJ_add, Quaternion.imJ_smul, Quaternion.imK_add, Quaternion.imK_smul, Quaternion.re_mul, Quaternion.re_star, Quaternion.imI_star, Quaternion.imJ_star, Quaternion.imK_star, smul_eq_mul] ring /-- Quaternionic rank-one determinant segment formula, with no positivity assumption on `D` and no commutativity assumption on the quaternion entries. -/ theorem determinant_rankOne_segment (D : Hermitian) (u v : Quaternion ℝ) (t : ℝ) : determinant (segment D (rankOne u v) t) = t ^ 2 * determinant D + t * (1 - t) * mixedDeterminant D (rankOne u v) := by rw [determinant_segment, rankOne_determinant, mul_zero, add_zero] /-- Completing the square gives the quaternionic Schur complement directly. -/ theorem quadratic_complete_square (Q : Hermitian) (hd : Q.d ≠ 0) (x y : Quaternion ℝ) : quadratic Q x y = (Q.a - Quaternion.normSq Q.b / Q.d) * Quaternion.normSq x + Q.d * Quaternion.normSq ((Q.d⁻¹ • star Q.b) * x + y) := by simp only [quadratic, Quaternion.normSq_add, map_mul, Quaternion.normSq_smul, Quaternion.normSq_star, smul_mul_assoc, Quaternion.re_smul, smul_eq_mul, cross_identity] field_simp ring /-- Positivity immediately controls the time component of the current. -/ theorem time_nonneg {A : Hermitian} (hA : PositiveSemidefinite A) : 0 ≤ A.a := by simpa [quadratic] using hA 1 0 /-- Quaternionic Schur pairing inequality without assuming positivity of the full Hessian `Q`; only the spatial entry `Q.d` must be positive. -/ theorem schur_pairing_lower_bound {A : Hermitian} (hA : PositiveSemidefinite A) (Q : Hermitian) (hQ : 0 < Q.d) : A.a * (Q.a - Quaternion.normSq Q.b / Q.d) ≤ pairing A Q := by have h := mul_nonneg hQ.le (hA (Q.d⁻¹ • Q.b) 1) have hstar : star (Q.d⁻¹ • Q.b) = Q.d⁻¹ • star Q.b := by exact Quaternion.star_smul _ _ have hid : Q.d * quadratic A (Q.d⁻¹ • Q.b) 1 = pairing A Q - A.a * (Q.a - Quaternion.normSq Q.b / Q.d) := by simp only [quadratic, pairing, Quaternion.normSq_smul, hstar, smul_mul_assoc, mul_one, Quaternion.re_smul, map_one, smul_eq_mul, re_star_mul_comm Q.b A.b] field_simp ring rw [hid] at h exact sub_nonneg.mp h /-- Exact determinant identity underlying the preceding Schur estimate. -/ theorem determinant_eq_schur (Q : Hermitian) (hQ : Q.d ≠ 0) : determinant Q = Q.d * (Q.a - Quaternion.normSq Q.b / Q.d) := by unfold determinant field_simp /-- The usual Schur positivity criterion, proved for actual quaternionic quadratic forms and the explicit two-dimensional Moore determinant. -/ theorem positiveSemidefinite_iff_determinant_nonneg (Q : Hermitian) (hd : 0 < Q.d) : PositiveSemidefinite Q ↔ 0 ≤ determinant Q := by constructor · intro h have hc := h 1 (-(Q.d⁻¹ • star Q.b)) rw [quadratic_complete_square Q hd.ne'] at hc simp only [map_one, mul_one, add_neg_cancel, map_zero, mul_zero, add_zero] at hc rw [determinant_eq_schur Q hd.ne'] exact mul_nonneg hd.le hc · intro h x y have hc : 0 ≤ Q.a - Quaternion.normSq Q.b / Q.d := by rw [determinant_eq_schur Q hd.ne'] at h exact (mul_nonneg_iff_of_pos_left hd).mp h rw [quadratic_complete_square Q hd.ne'] exact add_nonneg (mul_nonneg hc Quaternion.normSq_nonneg) (mul_nonneg hd.le Quaternion.normSq_nonneg) /-- The determinant-normalized quaternionic energy inequality in size two. -/ theorem schur_energy_inequality {A : Hermitian} (hA : PositiveSemidefinite A) (Q : Hermitian) (hQ : 0 < Q.d) {lam : ℝ} (hlam : lam ≠ 0) (hfiber : Q.d = lam * A.a) : determinant Q / lam ≤ pairing A Q := by rw [determinant_eq_schur Q hQ.ne'] nth_rw 1 [hfiber] convert schur_pairing_lower_bound hA Q hQ using 1 field_simp end OAI.LinearAlgebra.Quaternion