# IP notes: what's in the open dataset and why **Short version:** the file holds only facts (names, measurements, identifiers). Facts aren't protected by copyright in the U.S. The things that are protected are creative expression: marketing descriptions, photos, and the brands' own spec-sheet layouts. We left all of those out. We also left out the two things that were a business risk rather than a legal one: prices and our finish-family mapping. ## Dave's rulings, 2026-11-08 - **No prices.** MAP agreements make a public price list a standing exposure (one MAP incident already happened via the Google feed), and a static snapshot would be quoted by models for years after the price changed. Live prices reach AI shopping surfaces through the Shopify agent feed, UCP, and Sienna, which is the right channel for them. - **No finish-family column.** The cross-brand finish mapping is the one piece of real Knobs.co work product in the data. It stays exclusive to the Finish Index page on knobs.co, so anyone who wants it comes to us and cites us. - **Authorized brands only.** Rocky Mountain Hardware is bought through a distributor, not as an authorized dealer, so it is excluded. Every brand in the file is one Knobs.co is an authorized dealer for. ## Why the remaining fields are safe to release - **Dimensions, hole spacing, projection, finish names, product types:** measurable facts about physical products. U.S. copyright protects original expression, not facts (*Feist v. Rural Telephone*, 1991). A list of measurements covering the whole catalog has no creative selection. - **GTIN / UPC and part numbers:** identifiers published so retailers and marketplaces can match products. Already in public product feeds. - **Brand and series names:** used only to name the product (nominative use), the way every retailer and marketplace refers to a product. No logos, no implied endorsement. - **Our compilation:** the selection and decimal-inch normalization is Knobs.co's work. CC BY 4.0 lets others reuse it with credit, and every reuse points back to knobs.co. ## What a competitor gets from this Nothing they can't already get. Any dealer of these brands receives the same spec data from the brand; anyone else can scrape knobs.co or the brand sites. What is not in the file: images, copy, prices, sales data, reviews, the finish-family mapping, Sienna, and the vendor relationships. ## What we deliberately excluded - Product descriptions and marketing copy (the brands' text and ours). - All images and image URLs (brand photography is licensed to us for selling, not redistribution). - Spec-sheet PDFs, care text, warranty text, "notes" fields. - Inventory, cost, vendor pricing, margins, lead times, order or customer data. - Brand configurator JSON (Emtek and Rocky Mountain pricing rules and option trees). - Archived and draft products. ## Before publishing 1. A quick read of the Emtek and Top Knobs dealer terms for any clause about third-party data channels (covers most rows). 2. Not legal advice. These notes are a reasoned summary for a decision, not a lawyer's sign-off.