{
  "study_id": "causal-relational-knockout-24law-v1",
  "scales": [
    {
      "scale": "4b",
      "model": "google/gemma-4-E4B-it",
      "probe_layer": 34,
      "n_laws": 24,
      "n_prompts": 192,
      "baseline_answer_margin_accuracy": 0.953125,
      "necessity_margin_drop": {
        "estimate_ci95": [
          4.326822916666667,
          3.6708984375,
          4.892903645833333
        ],
        "activation_control_estimate_ci95": [
          -0.09129503038194446,
          -0.11046040852864585,
          -0.0726318359375
        ],
        "specific_estimate_ci95": [
          4.418117947048611,
          3.76536627875434,
          4.996524047851562
        ],
        "specific_permutation_p": 9.99990000099999e-06
      },
      "counterfactual_coordinate": {
        "estimate_ci95": [
          9.4951171875,
          8.011360677083333,
          10.830086263020833
        ],
        "activation_control_estimate_ci95": [
          -0.2530619303385417,
          -0.3072681003146701,
          -0.1994424608018663
        ],
        "specific_estimate_ci95": [
          9.748179117838541,
          8.22444101969401,
          11.11812981499566
        ],
        "specific_permutation_p": 9.99990000099999e-06
      },
      "full_counterfactual": {
        "estimate_ci95": [
          17.962565104166668,
          14.91827392578125,
          20.5211669921875
        ],
        "direction_restored_estimate_ci95": [
          8.197265625,
          6.613606770833333,
          9.5514404296875
        ],
        "restoration_reduction_estimate_ci95": [
          9.765299479166666,
          8.213212076822916,
          11.159834798177082
        ],
        "restoration_permutation_p": 9.99990000099999e-06
      },
      "causal_mediation_fraction": {
        "coordinate_over_full_estimate_ci95": [
          0.5286058607129265,
          0.5007903662320922,
          0.5585188215670325
        ],
        "restoration_over_full_estimate_ci95": [
          0.5436472698936228,
          0.5161442408320372,
          0.5726049762569513
        ]
      },
      "law_level_breadth": {
        "neutralization_positive": 23,
        "neutralization_specific_positive": 23,
        "counterfactual_coordinate_positive": 23,
        "counterfactual_specific_positive": 23,
        "restoration_reduction_positive": 23,
        "denominator_laws": 24,
        "neutralization_specific_one_sided_sign_p": 1.4901161193847656e-06,
        "counterfactual_specific_one_sided_sign_p": 1.4901161193847656e-06,
        "restoration_one_sided_sign_p": 1.4901161193847656e-06
      },
      "next_token_kl": {
        "neutralize_estimate_ci95": [
          0.12564799683460912,
          0.09612246389158789,
          0.15837211263756143
        ],
        "neutralize_control_estimate_ci95": [
          0.0008095244219635101,
          0.00039002800259177586,
          0.0013809340085534517
        ],
        "counterfactual_coordinate_estimate_ci95": [
          1.3825703688918718,
          1.1239652162278426,
          1.6453840967222386
        ],
        "counterfactual_control_estimate_ci95": [
          0.00444981699733743,
          0.002519775203181597,
          0.006847416449345659
        ],
        "full_counterfactual_estimate_ci95": [
          8.691391470842063,
          7.49562340095484,
          9.794079802829462
        ]
      },
      "error_repair": {
        "initially_wrong_prompts": 8,
        "repaired_prompts": 4,
        "repair_fraction": 0.5,
        "mean_margin_before": -3.078125,
        "mean_margin_after": -0.1875,
        "mean_margin_change": 2.890625
      },
      "answer_margin_accuracy_by_intervention": {
        "clean": 0.953125,
        "correct_centroid": 0.9791666666666666,
        "counterfactual_control_0_minus": 0.953125,
        "counterfactual_control_0_plus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "counterfactual_control_1_minus": 0.953125,
        "counterfactual_control_1_plus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "counterfactual_control_2_minus": 0.953125,
        "counterfactual_control_2_plus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "counterfactual_coordinate": 0.4739583333333333,
        "full_counterfactual": 0.041666666666666664,
        "full_counterfactual_direction_restored": 0.6302083333333334,
        "neutralize": 0.8854166666666666,
        "neutralize_control_0_minus": 0.953125,
        "neutralize_control_0_plus": 0.9635416666666666,
        "neutralize_control_1_minus": 0.953125,
        "neutralize_control_1_plus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "neutralize_control_2_minus": 0.953125,
        "neutralize_control_2_plus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "wrong_centroid": 0.640625
      },
      "accuracy_transitions": {
        "neutralize": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 15,
          "wrong_to_correct": 2,
          "unchanged_correct": 168,
          "unchanged_wrong": 7,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.002349853515625
        },
        "counterfactual_coordinate": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 93,
          "wrong_to_correct": 1,
          "unchanged_correct": 90,
          "unchanged_wrong": 8,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 9.592548607487504e-27
        },
        "wrong_centroid": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 60,
          "wrong_to_correct": 0,
          "unchanged_correct": 123,
          "unchanged_wrong": 9,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.734723475976807e-18
        },
        "correct_centroid": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 0,
          "wrong_to_correct": 5,
          "unchanged_correct": 183,
          "unchanged_wrong": 4,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.0625
        },
        "full_counterfactual": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 182,
          "wrong_to_correct": 7,
          "unchanged_correct": 1,
          "unchanged_wrong": 2,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 4.047468372268292e-45
        },
        "full_counterfactual_direction_restored": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 68,
          "wrong_to_correct": 6,
          "unchanged_correct": 115,
          "unchanged_wrong": 3,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 2.1448756331687684e-14
        }
      },
      "counterfactual_restoration_decisions": {
        "full_swap_not_original_answer": 184,
        "original_answer_recovered_after_coordinate_restoration": 114,
        "recovery_fraction": 0.6195652173913043
      },
      "stratified_specific_effects": {
        "category": {
          "direct": {
            "n_laws": 12,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              5.353407118055556,
              4.949001736111111,
              5.732584635416667
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              11.740519205729166,
              10.683479817708335,
              12.790365600585936
            ]
          },
          "inverse": {
            "n_laws": 12,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              3.4828287760416665,
              2.506561957465278,
              4.319554985894096
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              7.755839029947918,
              5.52538079155816,
              9.831373765733504
            ]
          }
        },
        "answer_vocabulary": {
          "greater-smaller": {
            "n_laws": 24,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              4.098958333333333,
              3.5525689019097224,
              4.573353407118055
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              8.538330078125,
              7.341440836588542,
              9.60023939344618
            ]
          },
          "higher-lower": {
            "n_laws": 24,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              4.737277560763888,
              3.962990993923611,
              5.410374620225695
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              10.958028157552084,
              9.095079888237846,
              12.646533033582898
            ]
          }
        },
        "answer_order": {
          "reversed": {
            "n_laws": 24,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              4.012641059027778,
              3.3926852756076387,
              4.55072767469618
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              8.86907958984375,
              7.425578477647569,
              10.17007039388021
            ]
          },
          "standard": {
            "n_laws": 24,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              4.823594835069444,
              4.122064887152778,
              5.442493353949653
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              10.627278645833334,
              9.025752427842882,
              12.076268513997395
            ]
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "scale": "12b",
      "model": "google/gemma-4-12B-it",
      "probe_layer": 39,
      "n_laws": 24,
      "n_prompts": 192,
      "baseline_answer_margin_accuracy": 0.9583333333333334,
      "necessity_margin_drop": {
        "estimate_ci95": [
          3.049170176188151,
          2.5763143857320148,
          3.4853548685709637
        ],
        "activation_control_estimate_ci95": [
          -0.052968341443273746,
          -0.07903986771901449,
          -0.025901852092809152
        ],
        "specific_estimate_ci95": [
          3.1021385176314253,
          2.6351800388760034,
          3.5337335182974736
        ],
        "specific_permutation_p": 9.99990000099999e-06
      },
      "counterfactual_coordinate": {
        "estimate_ci95": [
          7.022085825602214,
          5.932338905334472,
          8.017909717559814
        ],
        "activation_control_estimate_ci95": [
          -0.06123714976840549,
          -0.09877733124627008,
          -0.024934854110082005
        ],
        "specific_estimate_ci95": [
          7.083322975370618,
          5.973378149668376,
          8.083865276310178
        ],
        "specific_permutation_p": 9.99990000099999e-06
      },
      "full_counterfactual": {
        "estimate_ci95": [
          21.93874740600586,
          19.159971300760905,
          24.42089436848958
        ],
        "direction_restored_estimate_ci95": [
          10.240282694498697,
          8.942734813690185,
          11.516595109303793
        ],
        "restoration_reduction_estimate_ci95": [
          11.698464711507162,
          10.013709163665771,
          13.108655230204265
        ],
        "restoration_permutation_p": 9.99990000099999e-06
      },
      "causal_mediation_fraction": {
        "coordinate_over_full_estimate_ci95": [
          0.3200768802178686,
          0.2905349576720793,
          0.3479699265418605
        ],
        "restoration_over_full_estimate_ci95": [
          0.5332330280763723,
          0.5077407193566771,
          0.5563298612079105
        ]
      },
      "law_level_breadth": {
        "neutralization_positive": 24,
        "neutralization_specific_positive": 24,
        "counterfactual_coordinate_positive": 24,
        "counterfactual_specific_positive": 24,
        "restoration_reduction_positive": 24,
        "denominator_laws": 24,
        "neutralization_specific_one_sided_sign_p": 5.960464477539063e-08,
        "counterfactual_specific_one_sided_sign_p": 5.960464477539063e-08,
        "restoration_one_sided_sign_p": 5.960464477539063e-08
      },
      "next_token_kl": {
        "neutralize_estimate_ci95": [
          0.017193929544430917,
          0.0026666023959230315,
          0.0388019242426084
        ],
        "neutralize_control_estimate_ci95": [
          1.9182399652908685e-05,
          2.6114496111350295e-06,
          4.283227650735521e-05
        ],
        "counterfactual_coordinate_estimate_ci95": [
          0.39695642288884736,
          0.23311370827296654,
          0.5904121578484368
        ],
        "counterfactual_control_estimate_ci95": [
          2.692684677240018e-05,
          1.2004993610180624e-05,
          4.599365756095271e-05
        ],
        "full_counterfactual_estimate_ci95": [
          7.921978739499839,
          6.665503093044629,
          9.02019121913496
        ]
      },
      "error_repair": {
        "initially_wrong_prompts": 8,
        "repaired_prompts": 2,
        "repair_fraction": 0.25,
        "mean_margin_before": -5.640625,
        "mean_margin_after": -1.1015625,
        "mean_margin_change": 4.5390625
      },
      "answer_margin_accuracy_by_intervention": {
        "clean": 0.9583333333333334,
        "correct_centroid": 0.96875,
        "counterfactual_control_0_minus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "counterfactual_control_0_plus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "counterfactual_control_1_minus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "counterfactual_control_1_plus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "counterfactual_control_2_minus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "counterfactual_control_2_plus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "counterfactual_coordinate": 0.8229166666666666,
        "full_counterfactual": 0.052083333333333336,
        "full_counterfactual_direction_restored": 0.6197916666666666,
        "neutralize": 0.9635416666666666,
        "neutralize_control_0_minus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "neutralize_control_0_plus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "neutralize_control_1_minus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "neutralize_control_1_plus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "neutralize_control_2_minus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "neutralize_control_2_plus": 0.9583333333333334,
        "wrong_centroid": 0.734375
      },
      "accuracy_transitions": {
        "neutralize": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 0,
          "wrong_to_correct": 1,
          "unchanged_correct": 184,
          "unchanged_wrong": 7,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.0
        },
        "counterfactual_coordinate": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 26,
          "wrong_to_correct": 0,
          "unchanged_correct": 158,
          "unchanged_wrong": 8,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 2.9802322387695312e-08
        },
        "wrong_centroid": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 43,
          "wrong_to_correct": 0,
          "unchanged_correct": 141,
          "unchanged_wrong": 8,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 2.2737367544323206e-13
        },
        "correct_centroid": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 0,
          "wrong_to_correct": 2,
          "unchanged_correct": 184,
          "unchanged_wrong": 6,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.5
        },
        "full_counterfactual": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 174,
          "wrong_to_correct": 0,
          "unchanged_correct": 10,
          "unchanged_wrong": 8,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 8.352389719038111e-53
        },
        "full_counterfactual_direction_restored": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 65,
          "wrong_to_correct": 0,
          "unchanged_correct": 119,
          "unchanged_wrong": 8,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 5.421010862427522e-20
        }
      },
      "counterfactual_restoration_decisions": {
        "full_swap_not_original_answer": 182,
        "original_answer_recovered_after_coordinate_restoration": 109,
        "recovery_fraction": 0.5989010989010989
      },
      "stratified_specific_effects": {
        "category": {
          "direct": {
            "n_laws": 12,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              3.7444557580682964,
              3.1208072205384574,
              4.191613370925188
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              8.47928285598755,
              6.869921025964948,
              9.57024059295654
            ]
          },
          "inverse": {
            "n_laws": 12,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              2.459821277194553,
              1.9377835856543646,
              2.902770879533555
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              5.687363094753689,
              4.494570710923937,
              6.6571951230367015
            ]
          }
        },
        "answer_vocabulary": {
          "greater-smaller": {
            "n_laws": 24,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              1.7776612142721813,
              1.5288225650787353,
              2.0113558183113733
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              3.1401740180121522,
              2.701593335469564,
              3.525528441535102
            ]
          },
          "higher-lower": {
            "n_laws": 24,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              4.426615820990668,
              3.7371979607476127,
              5.074875121646457
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              11.026471932729086,
              9.230026286178166,
              12.659910465611352
            ]
          }
        },
        "answer_order": {
          "reversed": {
            "n_laws": 24,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              2.3412108951144748,
              1.962038940853543,
              2.7024536132812504
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              5.4987670050727,
              4.602537430657281,
              6.337315654754638
            ]
          },
          "standard": {
            "n_laws": 24,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              3.863066140148375,
              3.294354703691271,
              4.3826629540158635
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              8.667878945668539,
              7.314549966653188,
              9.861916449334887
            ]
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "scale": "31b",
      "model": "google/gemma-4-31B-it",
      "probe_layer": 49,
      "n_laws": 24,
      "n_prompts": 192,
      "baseline_answer_margin_accuracy": 1.0,
      "necessity_margin_drop": {
        "estimate_ci95": [
          2.7307262420654297,
          2.6445648511250814,
          2.8192007223765057
        ],
        "activation_control_estimate_ci95": [
          0.019598219129774306,
          0.004327074686686197,
          0.03567689259847004
        ],
        "specific_estimate_ci95": [
          2.7111280229356556,
          2.6331515100267198,
          2.790174622005886
        ],
        "specific_permutation_p": 9.99990000099999e-06
      },
      "counterfactual_coordinate": {
        "estimate_ci95": [
          6.472181955973308,
          6.246534824371338,
          6.703958002726237
        ],
        "activation_control_estimate_ci95": [
          0.10815217759874134,
          0.09148009618123372,
          0.12642357084486217
        ],
        "specific_estimate_ci95": [
          6.364029778374565,
          6.146116744147407,
          6.587814394632975
        ],
        "specific_permutation_p": 9.99990000099999e-06
      },
      "full_counterfactual": {
        "estimate_ci95": [
          34.79676183064779,
          33.903386720021565,
          35.631842041015624
        ],
        "direction_restored_estimate_ci95": [
          17.54513422648112,
          16.838604990641276,
          18.222946421305338
        ],
        "restoration_reduction_estimate_ci95": [
          17.251627604166668,
          16.790118408203124,
          17.699137369791668
        ],
        "restoration_permutation_p": 9.99990000099999e-06
      },
      "causal_mediation_fraction": {
        "coordinate_over_full_estimate_ci95": [
          0.1859995475289552,
          0.1793678167340542,
          0.19285283181262727
        ],
        "restoration_over_full_estimate_ci95": [
          0.4957825583923165,
          0.48403683413379284,
          0.5072899419820645
        ]
      },
      "law_level_breadth": {
        "neutralization_positive": 24,
        "neutralization_specific_positive": 24,
        "counterfactual_coordinate_positive": 24,
        "counterfactual_specific_positive": 24,
        "restoration_reduction_positive": 24,
        "denominator_laws": 24,
        "neutralization_specific_one_sided_sign_p": 5.960464477539063e-08,
        "counterfactual_specific_one_sided_sign_p": 5.960464477539063e-08,
        "restoration_one_sided_sign_p": 5.960464477539063e-08
      },
      "next_token_kl": {
        "neutralize_estimate_ci95": [
          1.5116601740203876e-07,
          -7.956452669070856e-09,
          4.645366521194262e-07
        ],
        "neutralize_control_estimate_ci95": [
          1.3745578514960428e-09,
          -2.7006523041239545e-09,
          5.5920883207183785e-09
        ],
        "counterfactual_coordinate_estimate_ci95": [
          1.7809138351352505e-05,
          6.686200600955707e-06,
          3.122706601913455e-05
        ],
        "counterfactual_control_estimate_ci95": [
          7.615191696571304e-09,
          1.3152515032076526e-09,
          1.4450070170399877e-08
        ],
        "full_counterfactual_estimate_ci95": [
          9.821323543166121,
          9.231986925719927,
          10.376124817629654
        ]
      },
      "error_repair": {
        "initially_wrong_prompts": 0,
        "repaired_prompts": 0,
        "repair_fraction": null,
        "mean_margin_before": null,
        "mean_margin_after": null,
        "mean_margin_change": null
      },
      "answer_margin_accuracy_by_intervention": {
        "clean": 1.0,
        "correct_centroid": 1.0,
        "counterfactual_control_0_minus": 1.0,
        "counterfactual_control_0_plus": 1.0,
        "counterfactual_control_1_minus": 1.0,
        "counterfactual_control_1_plus": 1.0,
        "counterfactual_control_2_minus": 1.0,
        "counterfactual_control_2_plus": 1.0,
        "counterfactual_coordinate": 1.0,
        "full_counterfactual": 0.0,
        "full_counterfactual_direction_restored": 0.7916666666666666,
        "neutralize": 1.0,
        "neutralize_control_0_minus": 1.0,
        "neutralize_control_0_plus": 1.0,
        "neutralize_control_1_minus": 1.0,
        "neutralize_control_1_plus": 1.0,
        "neutralize_control_2_minus": 1.0,
        "neutralize_control_2_plus": 1.0,
        "wrong_centroid": 0.96875
      },
      "accuracy_transitions": {
        "neutralize": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 0,
          "wrong_to_correct": 0,
          "unchanged_correct": 192,
          "unchanged_wrong": 0,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.0
        },
        "counterfactual_coordinate": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 0,
          "wrong_to_correct": 0,
          "unchanged_correct": 192,
          "unchanged_wrong": 0,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.0
        },
        "wrong_centroid": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 6,
          "wrong_to_correct": 0,
          "unchanged_correct": 186,
          "unchanged_wrong": 0,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.03125
        },
        "correct_centroid": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 0,
          "wrong_to_correct": 0,
          "unchanged_correct": 192,
          "unchanged_wrong": 0,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.0
        },
        "full_counterfactual": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 192,
          "wrong_to_correct": 0,
          "unchanged_correct": 0,
          "unchanged_wrong": 0,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 3.1861838222649046e-58
        },
        "full_counterfactual_direction_restored": {
          "correct_to_wrong": 40,
          "wrong_to_correct": 0,
          "unchanged_correct": 152,
          "unchanged_wrong": 0,
          "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.8189894035458565e-12
        }
      },
      "counterfactual_restoration_decisions": {
        "full_swap_not_original_answer": 192,
        "original_answer_recovered_after_coordinate_restoration": 152,
        "recovery_fraction": 0.7916666666666666
      },
      "stratified_specific_effects": {
        "category": {
          "direct": {
            "n_laws": 12,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              2.8076536390516496,
              2.7016358905368376,
              2.9134031719631617
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              6.658977932400172,
              6.351785956488715,
              6.963634745279947
            ]
          },
          "inverse": {
            "n_laws": 12,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              2.6146024068196616,
              2.5225807083977596,
              2.695723692576091
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              6.069081624348957,
              5.848576482137044,
              6.265432824028863
            ]
          }
        },
        "answer_vocabulary": {
          "greater-smaller": {
            "n_laws": 24,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              1.6684519449869792,
              1.597330305311415,
              1.7446322547064885
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              3.812260945638021,
              3.659687678019206,
              3.967014100816515
            ]
          },
          "higher-lower": {
            "n_laws": 24,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              3.753804100884332,
              3.653686131371392,
              3.8551483896043566
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              8.91579861111111,
              8.589399804009332,
              9.263592190212673
            ]
          }
        },
        "answer_order": {
          "reversed": {
            "n_laws": 24,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              2.1019058227539062,
              2.021393415662977,
              2.1833878835042317
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              4.796902126736112,
              4.609622149997287,
              4.9718435499403215
            ]
          },
          "standard": {
            "n_laws": 24,
            "necessity_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              3.3203502231174045,
              3.23121985329522,
              3.4128231684366863
            ],
            "counterfactual_specific_estimate_ci95": [
              7.9311574300130205,
              7.649350357055665,
              8.232495752970376
            ]
          }
        }
      }
    }
  ]
}